Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warnings:
Categories:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Collections:
Crown Jewels, Fics I have read 10+ times, LOTR fanfic time, Good Readings (ymmv), Creative Chaos Discord Recs, Too Legit to Quit (Reading), long fic to binge-read, AmazingLOTR, Bagginshield Classics, Def_Read_Again, Best Across Fandoms, Grade A Works, Masterpieces, sA's Tears Hall of Fame, International Fanworks Day 2022 - Classic Fic Recs, Dantalion's Library, Works So Good Id Physically Buy the Hard Cover Version in Stores, I Don'T KnoW WhaT a CollEctioN Is BuT I WanT To Keep ThiS StorY SomeWherE, This is a messy collection but I’m the mess the fics are great, They just have SO many words, Fics LunaK does not want to lose track of, Best Stories, quality writing just makes you cry sometimes yknow, Novel-Length Bagginshield Gems, My heart is full, What happens in (or out of) Arda..., I love you so, fics that completely altered the fabric of my reality, Favorites from Middle-Earth, B is for Brilliant, Aki's Enchanted forest
Stats:
Published:
2013-06-24
Completed:
2021-06-30
Words:
577,879
Chapters:
51/51
Kudos:
25,640
Hits:
0

Sansûkh

Chapter 34: Chapter Thirty-Four

Notes:

Hi All! Thank you SO MUCH for all your amazing support. You are all gems. Especial thanks to Jeza-Red and sutoribenda. *huuuugs*

I am currently editing the entirety of this monster to insert hover-text for translations. I have already done this chapter. Enjoy!

I am calling this The Chapter Of POVs Other Than Thorin's. :D

Art and Artiness
The Mighty Mighty Sansukh Masterpost
THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH. I can NEVER express how much it means to me.

Chess-ka: Ori and Bifur
Flukeoffate: Bomfris and Gimris
Flukeoffate: The Confession (chapter 33)
mintehz: Gimli and Legolas, Chapter 33
Aviva0017: Jeri child of Beri
gamcrackers: FINALLY! Chapter 33
nonbinaryschminary: Jeri child of Beri
valveillen: Legolas, the kiss
evil-bones-mccoy: Film poster for Sansukh

AGAIN THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH. If I have missed anything, pleasepleaseplease let me know!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo blinked awake. Surely he had only nodded off for a second? Damnation. Where was his book? It had been on his lap only moments ago.

"If you've taken it again, Erestor," he said crossly, and then he blinked as he registered his voice; no longer cracked and halting, he sounded clear and quick and exceedingly annoyed.

So. It was the dream again, the one he could never quite remember when he was awake. He looked down at his young, unlined hands, and then ran them over his face. Supple skin greeted his fingertips, without the dry looseness of age. It was not terribly bright, wherever he was, and he peered around. He was sitting on some description of dresser, and the air felt close and warm and comforting.

There was a groan from his left.

Bilbo whipped his head around, his tawny curls bouncing along the edge of his vision. There was a pallet tucked against the side of the room, piled with a couple of well-worn, handmade blankets and a thick black fur at the end. He could barely make out the figure buried beneath all those coverings.

He frowned as a pair of large, square hands poked out from beneath the blankets, curling into the air as whomever it was stretched rather extensively. The person (persons?) gave another, rather appreciative groan, and then there was the sound of fingers rasping against hair-covered skin. Scratching? Most likely.

And then Bilbo's eyebrows shot up as Thorin Oakenshield, naked to his waist and with the messiest hair that Bilbo had ever seen, sat up in the pallet and wiped down his face. He yawned, and Bilbo could have counted every tooth in his head. "Should have said something sooner, foolish star of mine," he mumbled in a rather gravelly, satisfied sort of voice, still scratching at his stomach absently. He looked tremendously pleased about something.

Oh, hells. Bilbo did not know where to put his face. Not this, not now, not him! Thorin was swinging his legs out from under his blankets, still half-asleep, and obviously getting ready to rise. Bilbo could feel his ears beginning to burn, and he knew his whole face was red as a beet.

It all came flooding back: standing in the sunlit glades of Rivendell and staring at his own face, wizened nearly beyond recognition. Learning that these little daydreams of his were rather more than just daydreams. Finding out that ghosts, as improbable as that sounded, were much, much more than the superstitious fancies of frightened children and the credulous.

Discovering that this pompous regal intolerably rude fool had been stalking him for eighty years!

The moment Thorin noticed him was obvious, as he froze so thoroughly he might as well have been made of stone after all.

"Must you continually parade around half naked?" Bilbo snapped, and he folded his arms and pointedly looked away. Confounded, confounded attractive Dwarf.

Thorin's eyes darted down to his lap, where the blanket was still curled. "I have a blanket."


Thorin and Bilbo, by lacefedora


"Is that really all you can say?" Bilbo's ears twitched in irritation, and he turned his eyes to the ceiling. It looked oddly unfamiliar, though he couldn't put his finger on why. "Get out. I have nothing to say to you."

"Bilbo," said Thorin slowly, and Bilbo's nostrils flared. "Master Baggins," he hastily corrected himself.

"Didn't you hear me?" Bilbo said, glaring up some more. He wasn't about to look at that ridiculous Dwarf and hear his ridiculous excuses. No thank you! "I said that I had nothing – less than nothing! – to say to you, so if you please, good morning and get! out!"

"I hear you, Master Baggins. I will leave you, then," Thorin said, low and deferent. "If I may dress, I will be on my way. I would not stay to cause you grief."

"Cause me – oh you, you confounded-" Bilbo spluttered, and his hands fisted upon his upper arms. "Would you kindly just remove yourself? I was perfectly fine until you saw fit to intrude upon me, lying there unwrapped like a peeled orange, asleep and in my bedroom no less! I shall-"

"Bilbo," Thorin said slowly, and then he seemed to hesitate, as though annoyed with himself for interrupting. "I am sorry, I am sorry for speaking out of turn, but – you are in my rooms. Did you not realise?"

That caused Bilbo's eyes to snap back to Thorin, wide with surprise. "Your rooms? Wait, but how is that possible?"

Bilbo's eyes were level with his, at this angle, and he was actually looking straight into Thorin's face. The Dwarf appeared much as he had before, nigh-precisely the same in fact. As though all those years had never happened. "I do not know," he told him, and Bilbo flushed again and looked away.

Now that he actually paid a little more attention, it was obvious that this was nothing like Rivendell. The angles were those starkly geometric shapes he associated with Dwarvish art, and there wasn't a skerrick of greenery to be seen. It wasn't nearly as grand as he had assumed, either: small and cramped and rather bare of decoration. The walls were of some sort of greyish stone, shot through with black shiny flecks, like certain marbles he remembered from a distant hazy childhood.

"Well then," Bilbo said, and he cleared his throat. "It would appear that I am the presumptuous one - for once."

"Presume away," Thorin said, and he leaned his elbows upon his knees and looked down at his bare feet. "I will not stop you. I welcome you."

Oh for - ! "That was not a prompt for some silly invitation to visit, you great galumphing idiot," Bilbo said, rather coldly. "That was the perfect opportunity for you to apologise for all your spying and sneaking. One which you missed, naturally."

"Ah." Thorin's madly snarled hair fell over his face, which was touched with the faintest hint of red. "My sincerest apologies, Master Baggins. I have intruded upon you in a most grievous fashion, and I am most heartily sorry."

"Goodness, you do apologise prettily when you put your mind to it, don't you?" Bilbo sniped, and Thorin looked up.

"I am sorry," he said, plainly and without any artifice or guardedness.

Bilbo pursed his lips. "Don't think I'm forgiving you!" he said, and wagged a finger threateningly. At all that - that Dwarvishness, and muscles, and shoulders, and soft-looking, grippable hair - stop it. "Because I am very, very angry. Very angry, and about lots of things, not just being spied upon, and – oh, please put a shirt on, I can't talk to you like this!"

Thorin blinked, and then fisted his blanket around his hips and stood. "Very well, I will…"

Acres of skin lightly dusted with hair, and tattooed arms and no, no, oh nonononono. Bilbo gritted his teeth and his eyes snapped back up to the ceiling. "Oh, drat it all."

Thorin evidently decided not to inquire after the matter, showing some discretion at last. Bilbo glared up at the ceiling as he heard the other moving around the room, evidently dressing as quickly as possible.

Though to be fair, perhaps Bilbo should watch Thorin dress in turn? Who knew what the bloody arrogant nuisance had gotten up to, sneaking and poking his overlarge Dwarvish nose into Bilbo's business without so much as a by-your-leave? Was there a single thing about Bilbo's life that was not an open book to Thorin? Was he permitted no secrets at all?

He fumed silently for a moment, and then another groan caused his eyes to flick back to see Thorin struggling with a blue tunic. His sleep-crazed hair had become half-caught in the neck of the tunic, half-all over his face. It was such a departure from the Thorin Oakenshield that Bilbo had known that he couldn't help staring.

And then the Dwarf, evidently rather embarrassed by his recalcitrant mop, grabbed the brush from the dresser. The dresser that Bilbo was seated upon. His hand passed straight through the Hobbit's leg!

Bilbo's eyebrows shot back up to his hairline, and he could feel his face falling into its most Baggins expression as Thorin slowly turned back to look at him. "Again, my apologies," he managed.

"You are not making a terribly good fist of this, are you," Bilbo said, and it was not a question. Thorin winced, making no effort to hide it, and he sat back upon his pallet and fiddled with the brush in his hands.

"Apparently not," he said ruefully.

"Dwarves," Bilbo sighed.

Thorin made no effort to move, seated upon his bed with a hastily-donned tunic sitting crookedly upon his shoulders, his hair a riot and his face full of chagrin. Bilbo briefly debated simply leaving the stubborn rude thing to his glowering and brooding, but something stopped him.

Thorin was different. Something about him… was different.

Bilbo had clung to his memories as hard as he could even as they slipped away, and those of Thorin had been the dearest and most painful of all. He had kept them squirrelled away as though pressed between fine paper. He had guarded them as closely as a dragon does his treasure. He had held them secret and private for all these years, more precious and more perilous than any ring.

He had thought he had understood everything there was of Thorin Oakenshield; noble, determined, arrogant, obsessive, stately and imposing Thorin Oakenshield, who could make Laketown rags seem like silks and velvets. Thorin Oakenshield, who had changed before Bilbo's eyes once before and not for the better.

But this Thorin just sat there, without any pretence at stateliness. He was not in the slightest bit imposing. Just a Dwarf after all. He simply sat there and waited, with hair asunder, legs bare beneath his crinkled tunic and beard mussed from the pillow. Calm contrition was written into every line of his face.

Bilbo had never associated patience with Thorin before - nor humility.

It piqued his interest. It intrigued him.

"Oh, fine," he muttered to himself, and slid down from the dresser.

Thorin looked up as Bilbo came to a halt before him. He swallowed at the flicker of hope in Thorin's eyes, so at odds with his resigned expression. "So," he said, and stifled the urge to fidget and the sudden surge of self-consciousness. Goodness, how absurd this all was! "These are your rooms? Where, exactly?"

"I am dead, Bil-Master Baggins," said Thorin gently, and Bilbo huffed.

"Yes, I know that. I'm not an imbecile, just a bit forgetful. It isn't my fault I can never remember these silly dreams when I wake. So. Where am I? I feel it's only polite to let me know where it is I keep ending up."

"These are the Halls of Mahal," Thorin told him, and he kept his eyes on the brush between his hands, leaning his elbows upon his knees. Bilbo frowned, scraping at his unreliable memory.

"Mahal, I've heard you lot say that name before," he said, and he tapped at his lip with a finger.

Thorin's face did not move, but his eyes smiled and Bilbo squashed the little leap in his belly at the sight. Stop it! "No doubt you have," he said. "Mahal is the one you call Aulë. He is our Maker, the father of all Dwarves."

"Oh." Bilbo fell silent. "Your room?"

"Aye."

"It's… plainer than I would have expected," Bilbo said, and he took the opportunity to look around himself more thoroughly. It was bare indeed, nothing like the rooms of a king. Thorin apparently lived plainly in his afterlife. A pallet, heaped high with rushes, that mountain of blankets, the fur for his feet. A chest, wooden and plain, for clothes perhaps. A desk with a few papers stacked upon it in a small pile. A dresser, the brass mirror embossed around the edges with primroses and honeysuckle. How… undwarven. A wooden tray filled with beads and cuffs, all gleaming with the dull grey sheen of steel. Boots by the door – urgh, why would any folk wear such things – and clothes scattered by a roughly-woven basket where they had fallen. A heavy rasp, sitting over upon the desk where it should not be. What was a tool such as that doing in a sleeproom? Tsk. "I should think my little corner of Rivendell is a palace compared to this."

Thorin's back straightened slightly, and there was a noticeable stiffness in his voice as he said, "I have found I care little for riches now. I will not have them near me. Never again. Not ever."

"Yes, I suppose so," Bilbo said distractedly, and then the words sunk in and he turned to Thorin with a frown. "Oh, surely you're not still afraid of-"

Thorin sat as still as stone.

"Oh." Bilbo shrank a little, shoulders falling. "Oh."

"I am sorry," Thorin said again, and the words sounded hard and stubborn in his mouth this time. "I will go."

Oh. Well, wasn't that what Bilbo wanted? For this snooping, sneaking little spy to leave him alone?

The Tookish part of Bilbo whispered, "liar."

Hush, Bilbo told it firmly. If it weren't for you, we wouldn't be in this pickle in the first place.

You want to know why he's so different. Why he has watched you, above all creatures. Why he has been so deplorably rude.

Bilbo was no better at resisting temptation than he had been at fifty. He sighed and sat down beside Thorin. "No – no, don't," he said, and he laced his fingers together to stop their twitching and looked down at them and decidedly not at Thorin. "Come now, I wouldn't chase you out of your own room!"

"But you would chase me from yours, and so I will leave you in peace, Master Burglar," Thorin said, and he made to stand.

"Well, if I did everything you did to me back to you in return, we would have another eighty years on our hands and we would have to find some battlements," Bilbo snapped. "Sit down."

Blast. His tongue had always been a little too sharp. He braced himself for Thorin's anger, but it never came. Instead, acceptance and remorse shone in Thorin's face, and he remained calm as he sagged back down.

So changed! How had he changed so thoroughly? Why wouldn't he roar at Bilbo? Where was that simmering undercurrent of resentment that had always lurked beneath his dignified demeanour; that air of terrible tragedy and vengeance unanswered?

The Dwarf's eyes flicked to Bilbo, and then refocused straight ahead. "I…"

"If you say you are sorry once more, I will leave and not come back." Bilbo emphatically thrust a finger into the air. "Not until I've had some answers, and given you a piece or two of my mind! Then I'll hear your pretty apologies, and not before."

Thorin opened his mouth, and at Bilbo's furious look, he shut it again.

"Also, you look like a shaggy pony, put that brush to good use." Bilbo sniffed and folded his arms. "Go on."

Thorin sent him a sidelong glance, and several expressions flew over his face, ranging from the angry to the bitter to the mildly amused. But he did not say a word. Instead, he lifted his brush to drag it through the thick, tangled mess of his hair, wincing as it snagged.

"Right, now that you're usefully occupied," Bilbo muttered, slightly taken aback. His prodding had yielded a result, but not the explosion he had expected. So Thorin was not entirely different then: there had been annoyance and anger there. He still had plenty of his vaunted pride, but it did not seem to overcome his reason any more.

The Hobbit resettled himself more comfortably and turned slightly towards Thorin. "I have questions. No, don't talk yet!"

Thorin bit down hard upon his lower lip.

"I want answers, not excuses. Do you understand me?"

"Aye."

"Good." Bilbo harrumphed a little and kicked his furry heels for a moment, his stomach full of butterflies all of a sudden. Now that the answers were here at long last, he did not know if he wanted them.

Stalling, Bilbo cast about for something to say, anything at all. His roving gaze fell upon a hairy, naked Dwarven leg and he blushed reflexively, before he blinked at the sight of those squat, hairless, stub-toed feet. He couldn't help but blurt, "your feet are ridiculous. Not a curl at all. I've known tiny babies with more hair on their toes."

"Is this a question?" Thorin's mouth was twitching. Confounded, dratted Dwarf.

"Just an observation," Bilbo said loftily, and he snorted when Thorin looked askance at him. "First question: why have you been spying on me? And I use the word spying advisedly. Mostly because I am trying very hard not to use the word haunting, as appropriate as it might seem. Well?"

Thorin was quiet as he mulled that over for a moment. "Master Baggins," he began, and then took a breath. "Because I hurt you, and I left you alone. Because I love you, and I think you – forgive me – I think you cared for me. Because I must make my amends, for all the wickedness and pain and peril I brought upon you. And because… because I enjoyed it. Because I wanted to be near you."

His eyes slid shut. "It made me happy."

Bilbo felt as though he had been struck by lightning. A churning feeling had begun in his belly, stirring the butterflies about in quite an unpleasant manner. He licked his lips, and then licked them again.

Well.

Made him happy, he growled to himself, even as a small voice in the back of his head began to gabble, because I love you, because love, I love you, loveyou, becauseiloveyou; Oh, it made him happy, did it, to pry into Bilbo's life as though he had the right to it! It made him happy to call Bilbo his, like a pet?

How dare –

- I think – forgive me – I think you cared for me.

As though that mattered a jot! Didn't even ask! Didn't even – of all the arrogance!

Thorin looked up, and worry flashed in those pale eyes. "Bilbo?"

"Don't," Bilbo hissed.

Thorin swallowed his words, and bent his head.

"Do you…" Bilbo's voice cracked, and he worked furiously to clear his suspiciously blurry eyes for a moment, "do you know, I had forgotten what you could be like when you thought you knew best?"

Thorin remained silent.

Bilbo took a deep, shuddering breath, and tipped back his head. "You stupid Dwarf," he said. "Well, at least this time you're not throwing yourself headlong into certain danger. Just headlong into my privacy."

Thorin quietly put his brush aside, and slowly stood once more. "I will leave you to your peace," he said, and he could not meet Bilbo's gaze.

"Sit," Bilbo said, as sharp as the crack of a whip.

Thorin sat.

"I am furious with you," Bilbo said, and he turned to skewer Thorin with his glare. The mess in his stomach had caught fire. "Let's put aside your presumption and your snooping and your arrogance for one second, shall we? I was not alone because of pining after you, you great daft dead fool. I was alone because I wished to be. I thoroughly dislike prying visitors. And yes, I care – cared for you," and he skipped as quickly as he could over those words. They felt unstable, like quicksand, and he rushed on: "but I like to know when I have company, no matter who they might be! Surely the night of our meeting proved that? I had no way of saying yes, come in and welcome, oh no, I didn't even get a choice: you just barged on ahead like Dwarves always do. I thought I was alone, Thorin! And now I find that I have never truly been alone at all. My whole life long, my privacy has been of no consequence to you. My wishes have meant nothing to you. You had no right!"

Thorin looked rather pale, but he sat and listened, breath coming faster. "Bilbo, I-"

"But you thought best, of course!" Bilbo threw up his hands. "And to top it off, you call me yours – as though you own me, as though you carried the deed to my life in your pocket!"

Thorin made a distressed sound of disagreement, deep in his throat, but Bilbo plowed ahead without allowing him the chance to interrupt:

"Oh, and let's examine that earlier little gem of an argument, shall we? That you must make your amends. Amends how? By turning me into a spectacle for your amusement?"

"No!" Thorin half-roared, "never that!"

"Then how, pray tell?" Bilbo scowled at him, though there was a small part of him that was rather relieved that Thorin could still lose his composure somewhat.

"I-I was given a gift," he said, and Bilbo watched as he shuddered and took a breath, calming himself down rather more rapidly than he had ever seen before. "I may reach the subconscious mind of my listener in the living world. I have tried to speak to you many times. Sometimes this young self – your subconscious self – listens. Your older self barely senses me at all."

"And you never thought to tell this me," Bilbo tipped his head, and raised his eyebrows in challenge. "I do not recall anything like that happening."

"I thought you were my loneliness, given shape and speech." Thorin sighed. "I am not well-versed in matters such as these, and my mind has proved a traitor to me before."

Ohhhhhh. A small sprout of pity began to uncurl in Bilbo's chest, and he cleared his throat. That… explains quite a bit. "Oh. Oh, I see. Well, that makes some sort of sense, I suppose." Bilbo worried at his lower lip.

He'd be damned if he apologised, however! Insolent dwarf. Just because he was lonely didn't give him the right to fossick through other people's privacy without permission. "These amends, then…"

"For how I treated you," Thorin clarified. "For causing you such terror, for drawing you into the spiral of my ever-widening madness and paranoia. For my cruelty. For-"

"Yes, yes, I remember, I was there," Bilbo said crossly. Would Thorin kindly stop prodding at all his long-nursed and bottled-up feelings? Oh, why had he asked for answers! Bother, bother, bother. "And we will talk about that, mark my words:-" over my dead body, "- but what do you mean by amends?"

"I swore to protect you." Thorin gave a half-shrug, and then let his shoulder fall. "And when you appeared to be safe beyond my aid, living in Elrond's house, I watched over Frodo and the Fellowship in your stead. I have guarded their steps. Every Dwarf in my family and of the Company is working day and night, reporting upon the War."

Ice slid down his spine. Bilbo's eyes widened. "What? Is Frodo alive? Is he all right? Is he eating?"

"He lives," Thorin nodded, and turned more fully towards Bilbo. "He lives. The burden grows heavier, but he moves ever-closer to the fire every day. My last report had them upon something called the 'stairs of Cirith Ungol', upon the borders of Mordor."

Bilbo's hand flew to his mouth. "Oh my lad," he whispered, horror-struck.

Thorin appeared to be steeling himself to say something unpleasant. More unpleasant. "He has conscripted a guide."

"A guide?"

"Gollum."

Bilbo could feel his entire face crumpling, and a low whine escaped his mouth. "Oh no," he breathed.

"I am so sorry," Thorin said, low.

"Frodo, oh my Frodo-lad," Bilbo mourned. "How can you protect him in Mordor? How can you protect him from that slimy vile little beast? How can you protect him from the creeping horror that is that damned, cursed Ring? How can any?"

"Be comforted," Thorin said, and then grimaced at the uselessness of the words. "Frodo hears me now and then, as does Sam. It is more difficult now that Gimli is not with him, of course."

Why, what had happened? He vaguely remembered the short-tempered, red-headed Dwarf from the Council, so very like Glóin. Was he not with the Fellowship? "What happened to him?" Bilbo sniffed and wiped at his nose. "Did he…?"

"Nay, he lives." Thorin's head lowered, and he seemed to be oddly grieved. "All the Fellowship is sundered, but they all still live save one. Boromir."

Oh gracious, he scared me then. Bilbo sagged in relief, and then winced. "Oh, I am sorry…"

"No, it is understandable. I grew to know them all well, where you only know your kin." He gave Bilbo a small smile. "Your cousin Pippin is like you in many ways."

"Balderdash. Wash out your mouth. He's a Took," Bilbo scoffed.

"So are you." Thorin raised his brows.

Was there a single, solitary thing about his life that Thorin had not sifted his way through? He probably knew the names of each and every of Bilbo's various neighbours and relations, and which of his tomato plants was the best producer, the appalling busybody. "Disrespectful, invasive, egotistical, stone-headed, nosy dwarves," Bilbo muttered, and he wiped at his nose again. "I should hover here all day, give you a taste of your own medicine."

"As I said, I welcome you." Thorin inclined his head. "You have my permission to come and go as you please, without reservation. I am truly sorry that I never sought the same from you. For my presumption, Master Baggins, I will happily suffer any punishment you see fit to mete out."

"Punishment!" Bilbo blinked, and then he frowned in thought. "Wait, you think I wish to punish you?"

"Why not?" Thorin said, surprised.

"Oh for…" Bilbo shook his head. "Really? I am angry, but I don't want to hurt you, you stubborn idiot creature."

"I betrayed your trust," Thorin objected, and Bilbo snorted again.

"Ah, but not before I betrayed yours, and so we are even. No punishment required."

"Even," said Thorin, flatly. "Bilbo, I isolated you from my Company, I poured my venom into your ears, I held my hands around your neck and tried to throttle you. I have tried to throw you from the walls of Erebor. I led you into a hopeless battle and took away any joy you felt in your own home. Erebor stands in Dwarven hands thanks to you: my dearest, fondest dream in life. Now I understand that I have also taken your privacy from you and assumed a level of care that – no, Bilbo we will never be even. I owe you too much for that!"

Bilbo ignored the laundry list of deeds and wrongdoings: it was no more than he'd said to himself for nearly eighty years after all. His own wrongdoings were worse, and with less cause. Frodo, ah, Frodo.

But – assumed a level of care? Hadn't Bilbo proven himself, proven that he cared, over and over? Hadn't he?

So much for his buried emotions, for his long-nursed resentments and affections. Bilbo's ears flashed red-hot, and he could feel his anger rising up in his belly to crowd into his mouth. "Assumed a level of," he spluttered, and he hopped down from the pallet to stand over Thorin. Part of him stood back and shook its head at his audacity, but the rest of him was riding the crest of a building wave of outrage. "Excuse me, Thorin so-called-bloody Oakenshield, are you doubting me? Doubting me?"

"I would never doubt you, not ever again. I-"

"Who got your miserable hairy arse out of Mirkwood, hm?" Bilbo snapped. The same foolhardy impulse that had once pushed him into squaring up to dragons and pickpocketing trolls and stealing priceless royal heirlooms now loosened his tongue. "Who stopped that orc from chopping your rock-filled head off? Who stayed by you and tried to get you to eat, down in that filthy pile of lizard-infected gold? Who was it that threw away all hope of your good opinion for the chance to save your sorry hide? Me, that's who, and I'll thank you not to doubt my 'level of care' ever again. The cheek of it!"

"I know – Bilbo, I know you did, and I can never…" Thorin rubbed his eyes with his fists and groaned. "I cannot repay you. Never. I owe you all, and I would not dare doubt you. But. I hurt you."

"Yes, you hurt me, and yes, I am angry about it," Bilbo fumed. "But are you honestly suggesting that I never hurt you?"

"I…"

"Because I remember tears in your eyes, Thorin Oakenshield, and they haunted me more than your ghost ever did," Bilbo hissed.

"You never raised your hand in anger to me, even when I lay under the spell of the gold," Thorin said hotly, and he shook his head. "No. Bilbo, no: that is not the same - and you know it!"

The stone walls rang with his last words.

Still rather good at getting to the point. Still rather good at speeches, too. Bilbo tried to get himself under control, but it was a dismal failure. He had repressed everything for so long. Of course, Thorin bloody Oakenshield only had to speak, and his careful dam was breached. Now? Now it had broken its bonds and was all bubbling up in great welling floods. Everything he had kept locked away for seventy-eight long years had come spilling out: anger, hurt and resentment keened in his ears. The private, unspoken little warmth and the bone-deep decades-old yearning hammered in his heart.

He closed his eyes and tried valiantly to master himself.

"No, it is not the same," he eventually said, and his voice was even and controlled. He was rather proud of that. "And you went and died before I got the chance to be angry with you, good and properly. You died, Thorin, and I was never able to see you change, to learn how to forgive you, how to trust again. Instead, I got old and kept it all buttoned tight inside my chest and snapped and snarled at any who prodded at it. I've been a suspicious old sod for longer than I care to imagine, and I don't even know if I can change anymore."

"I am so sorry." Thorin repeated. "I am so, so sorry."

"I said it back then, and I'll say it now: I was glad to share in your perils," Bilbo said, and he looked away. Out with it, Mad Baggins. You're old enough now to offer honesty for honesty, truth for truth. "But I'm less thrilled about having all of this dredged up. I thought it all beautifully tucked away in my memories, never to be touched ever again. My own little secrets," he added, and sighed. "My secrets are just as destructive as yours in the end, it appears."

"The Ring," Thorin said softly.

"The Ring," Bilbo agreed. "Ah, what a useful and cunning little thing it is! And so light, far too light when you consider all the wickedness it holds. Smaug said it first, you know. I have very pretty manners for a thief and a liar. You were hardly a postscript to that little bauble, in the end."

He stared at his young, unwrinkled, unspotted hands. "No wonder I became such a paranoid old duffer."

"I do not doubt you, Bilbo, nor do I underestimate the influence of the One Ring," Thorin said, and he looked up at the Hobbit. "I have heard its coaxing voice, and I know the creeping tendrils of obsession and mistrust better than most. But you speak of care, and of hurting, and you dance around your meaning with your words. You start arguments and do not meet my eyes. You wished for answers, and now you evade them."

Bilbo's mouth clamped shut.

My word, Thorin has changed indeed.

"I do not press you for anything," Thorin said, and he looked up to face Bilbo fully. His face was grave and beautiful underneath his riotous, silver-streaked hair. "I do not expect anything - I do not deserve explanations from you. But I must say this: Bilbo Baggins, I love you. I loved you when I did not know what it was I felt. All unknowing you stole your way into my affections, Master Burglar."

"Gracious, the dramatics again," Bilbo said, rather faintly. All these declarations! His heart couldn't take it; it was all too much.

But Thorin was still talking. "Surrounded by treachery, cursed by the dragon's greed and full of rage, I could not understand when I lived why it was I turned to you, over and over. Why, when my mind was overthrown, I reached for you and not for my kin. Why I felt at peace at last there upon the ice, with your hand upon my hair and your voice in my ears." Thorin's sharp, clear eyes flicked to the floor, to his preposterously charming baby-feet. "I acted violently, and foolishly. And I have not acted well in death either, it appears."

"Not… not exactly, no," Bilbo said, and his face felt rather hot. This was too much, far too quickly. He was feeling positively overwhelmed. Was there such a thing as spectral tea? He could do with a cup. "Why? Not… not love." The word skittered out from under his tongue, unsteady and slippery. "Tell me why you guard Frodo for me, why you've made a penance of it all."

Thorin was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "I will not be surprised if you cannot believe me, but I speak truth when I say that my guilt has poisoned me. I have been locked in shame and self-hatred. I have torn at my every good part in my haste to condemn my faults. I have allowed myself no peace, no healing, no understanding. I have driven myself to the edges of my endurance and punished myself in ways that I would call cruel if they were visited upon those I care for. If I have been unkind to others, I have been monstrous to myself."

Bilbo's eyes narrowed. That… sounded more like the Thorin Oakenshield he remembered, somehow: implacable in everything he did, both the good and bad. Or was it a plea for sympathy? No, it had been factually and regretfully said. This Thorin wanted pity no more than the old one had. "Oh, really?"

Thorin smiled. "I'm afraid so. I grow wiser now, I hope, though evidently I have further to grow. I am fortunate in the unconditional love of my kin."

"Your nephews."

Gratitude shone for a moment in Thorin's eyes, and he nodded once. "They stay close, as do my brother and mother."

"You have a brother?" Bilbo was exceedingly cross now. Here Thorin sat, knowing absolutely everything there was to know about Bilbo – and he knew next to nothing about Thorin in return!

"I do." Thorin's chin dipped, and his mouth twitched. Fondness, perhaps. "I owe them much for how you see me today. If it were not for their devotion I would yet be mired in guilt, unable to clamber out. But you should not discount love as an incentive, Master Baggins. Dwarves have a particularly single-minded devotion, as it so happens."

A flash of memory (oh, unreliable!), and Bilbo remembered a campfire in the little woods beyond the Shire, and a cheerful round face that spoke longingly of home, and Alrís. "Bombur told me," Bilbo said stiffly.

"Then you know I will love you unending and never care for another." Thorin spoke so simply of loving Bilbo, as though it was as easy as that. Bilbo's shire-bred disapproval clucked in his mind, and he bit down on his tongue. He, at least, had some proper discretion, even if he had long ago shredded his good reputation (and good riddance to it).

Thorin continued, ducking his head until his chin touched his chest. "I have no right to your affection, and I make no claim. I hold no deed in my pocket, Bilbo – I cannot own you, nor do I wish to. I have learned the folly of clutching too tightly. This love needs no answer from you. It is no obligation you must meet. That is the way of our people."

Then Thorin's eyes flicked up, and there was a new spark dancing in their depths, something brighter and wiser and clear as river water. "You speak of care, and I am content. It gives me hope that someday perhaps you will forgive me, and learn to trust me once more."

Oh, honestly! Bilbo's face flamed. He couldn't be doing with all this – thisness! He firmly squashed the Tookish part of him, which was quite ready to go on another adventure so long as those eyes were doing the asking. "You can't even touch me, I think I'm safe enough," he said, rather tartly. "And Hobbits don't really speak of such things, not openly. It's not… proper."

The look Thorin sent him was sympathetic. "I know."

Bilbo scowled reflexively at that. "Oh naturally, of course you know, nosy parker. You're worse than any of my bothersome relations. And I don't know if I ever will forgive you. You hurt me, you scared the living marrow out of me, and insulted me and goodness knows what else, and then you got yourself killed, if you please, and then even after you were dead you managed to show a deplorable lack of consideration. I'm beginning to see why you felt it necessary to do this, but don't think I like a single bit of it, dramatic Dwarvish declarations of affection aside. But I won't be doubted by you ever again, I won't."

Thorin seemed to be confused once more, and he frowned. A familiar expression at last! "I would take back my words and deeds once more…"

"You say that, and yet they remain said and done nevertheless." Thorin looked so terribly bleak at that, and the newly-released warmth in Bilbo's heart prompted him to add, "I'm not saying it's completely hopeless."

Thorin's head lifted and he unleashed the full slow devastating effect of that smile, and oh drat, blast, botheration and confustication! "Then you meant what you said. On the ice."

"Yes, well, you were dying at the time, weren't you? I had to say something," Bilbo threw out, and then he closed his eyes and grimaced, regretting his words immediately. "Yes I meant it. Stop doubting me."

"I do not doubt you, and never shall again," Thorin said earnestly, and he looked upon Bilbo as he had once before, deep in the belly of a mountain with an acorn sitting innocently upon his palm, even as a stolen stone burned a hole in his jerkin and a Ring plotted in his pocket. "I will do nothing without your permission. Never again will I assume or presume. I wait upon your pleasure, Master Baggins."

Bilbo reddened rather drastically. "Heavens," he faltered.

"What would you have me do?"

"I don't want – I haven't a clue. I'll think on it." Bilbo's eyes dropped down, and then he deliberately looked back up at the ceiling. "But as it so happens there is something you can do for me now."

"Yes? Anything, sabannimi."

"Please," Bilbo said again, and then he swallowed quite hard, "would you kindly put some pants on?"


Fíli peered into the tunnel mouth, and everything in him rose up and shrieked against it. "I don't like it."

Behind them, Sam sniffed. "Ugh! That smell!" he said. "It's getting stronger and stronger."

"Is this the only way, Sméagol?" said Frodo. The Hobbit's face was drawn and his cheeks were hollowed. His eyes were awful to see: huge and red-rimmed and full of pain.

"Oh, trust his word," Nori snorted.

Gollum simpered. "Yes, yes! Yes, we must go this way now."

"D'you mean to say you've been through this hole?" said Sam. "Phew! But perhaps you don't mind bad smells."

Gollum's eyes glinted. "He doesn't know what we minds, does he precious? No, he doesn't. But Sméagol can bear things. Yes. He's been through. O yes, right through. It's the only way."

Kíli glanced between the tunnel and his brother. "Are we sure about this?"

Fíli shook his head. "No. But let's go anyway."

Kíli's lips twitched into a resigned grin. "You are not sending me anywhere, let's make that plain."

"Now's when we need our little uncle," Fíli said, and held out his hands helplessly. "You're the fastest, you're the runner."

"Only because my legs are longer," Kíli objected. "And the little golden puffball is asleep, and you know what a surly grump he is when he wakes."

"You'll go if and when I tell you to," Fíli grumbled, and shoved Kíli's shoulder. "Get a move on."

"How'd I get stuck with you two," Nori muttered, and tugged at the middle braid of his beard in annoyance.

Drawing a deep breath they passed inside, following the near-noiseless padding of Hobbit feet. In a few steps they were in utter and impenetrable dark.

"It's even darker than Moria," whispered Kíli.

"Not as dark as the Paths of the Dead though," Nori replied. "Hold tight, lads, we got through both of those."

Fíli reached out and laid a hand against the wall. "Smooth," he said in surprise. "The walls are smooth. That tunnel-mouth didn't seem to be the work of hands, though."

"The three of us aren't stone-talkers," Nori's voice floated out of the darkness. "Bifur'd know."

"I'm not bothering Bifur," Kíli commented. "Not if it means bothering Ori."

"Don't remind me," Nori said, rather sourly. "Dori's goin' to have kittens."

"If you promise to let us know when the fireworks begin, we'll pay admission?" Kíli said, and Nori huffed in amusement.

"Never thought o' that. Thanks, lads."

"Don't mention it."

"Hang on, where's Gollum gone?" said Fíli abruptly.

For the soft dry susurration of his scampering had disappeared, and all that could be heard was the stumbling of Sam and Frodo, and their nervous breaths. The two Hobbits kept moving as though dazed by the awful stench. A cold thrill gripped Fíli's throat: what was this? What was this place?

"Mister Frodo," Sam's voice said, hoarse and harsh in the darkness, "here, hold my hand. There, got you!"

Frodo's breath could be heard the loudest: he was nearly panting, the intake of air laborious and painful to hear. It was almost as though he was forcing himself to keep moving through the reek.

Then they heard Frodo cry out, and the sound of limbs hitting the floor. And then he said, "here, Sam! Up, up – it all comes from here, the stench and the peril. Now for it! Quick!"

"On your feet, Mister Frodo," Sam said, staunch even in stark terror.

"What," Kíli began, but then a dreadful chittering sounded through the tunnels, bouncing from the smooth stone walls and sending mocking, fading echoes skittering up Fíli's neck.

"I don't like the sound of that," whispered Nori.

"Come on!" Fíli barked, and he leapt after the whispering of Sam and Frodo's feet. The chittering seemed to follow them, nibbling horribly in their ears.

"Ah!" said Sam, and then: "noodles and ninnyhammers!"

"The tunnel forks here," Frodo said, resigned. "Are you all right?"

"Banged my pride rather more than my head, Mister Frodo sir," Sam panted, and Fíli could just about picture his brave expression, putting the best face he could upon his terror for the sake of his beloved Master. ""Which way has Gollum gone? And why didn't he wait?"

"Perhaps we should get Bifur," whispered Kíli. "Ori might stay sleeping, you never know."

"He won't be able to tell much from stone he can't properly touch," said Nori. And then his voice lowered and he said, "an' I really don't need to see that."

"Sméagol!" said Frodo, trying to call. "Sméagol!" But his voice croaked, and the name fell dead almost as it left his lips.

"He's really gone this time, I fancy," muttered Sam. "I guess this is just exactly where he meant to bring us. Gollum! If ever I lay hands on you again, you'll be sorry for it."

"Samwise Gamgee, honorary Dwarf, I tell you," Fíli said. The creeping feeling on the back of his neck was getting worse, and he shifted uneasily.

There was a moment of fumbling, and then Frodo said, "the left way is blocked: some great stone has been rolled in front of it. Right or wrong, we must take the other."

"And quick!" Sam panted. "There's something worse than Gollum about. I can feel something looking at us."

"Not just me then," Fíli murmured.

"Can you see anything? You've got the best eyes," said Nori, and Fíli snorted.

"Ask the archer here, he's younger."

"Can't see my hand before my face, let alone anything to shoot at," Kíli said. "Let's get going: they're off again down the right passage."

"Stay close," Fíli ordered, and he felt rather than saw Kíli's eye-roll.

They had not gone more than a few yards when from behind them came a sound, startling and horrible in the heavy padded silence: a gurgling, bubbling noise, and a long venomous hiss. They wheeled round, but nothing could be seen. Still as stones they stood, staring, waiting for they did not know what.

"It's a trap!" shouted Sam.

"Are you bleedin' kiddin' me, I could have told him that three weeks ago!" Nori bellowed, and the three Dwarves all huddled close, eyes straining into the suffocating murk.

"That foul reek!" Frodo gasped, and he retched and reeled. The bubbling hiss drew nearer, and there was a creaking as of some great jointed thing that moved with slow purpose in the dark.

"Mister Frodo!" cried Sam, life and urgency lending his voice unexpected power. "The Lady's gift! The star-glass! A light to you in dark places, she said it was to be. The star-glass!"

"The star-glass?" muttered Frodo, as though he was half-asleep and barely hearing Sam at all. "Why yes! Why had I forgotten it? A light when all other lights go out!"

Then there was a flickering, faint light – weak against the clinging blackness, struggling out from between thin fingers. It seemed feeble at first, and then like a rising star its power waxed and burned, until it glowed like a minute heart of dazzling light.

The darkness receded from it until it seemed to shine in the centre of a globe of airy crystal, and the hand that held it sparkled with white fire.

"Maker preserve us," Fíli whispered, and he heard Nori gasp in astonishment behind him.

"Now there's a pretty thing," he said admiringly.

Frodo's face was traced in bluish white by the sudden fierce starlight, and he was staring at his uplifted hand in awe. There was an ugly bruise on Sam's forehead.

"Aiya Eärendil Elenion Ancalima!" Frodo cried, as though caught in a dream.

"What whation whatima?" said Kíli, under his breath.

"Elvish, I'll guess," Fíli answered, staring up at the tiny glass that shone like hope itself.

"Lads," Nori rasped, and he cleared his throat. "Lads. Lads."

"What?"

Nori only pointed, back down the way they had come. His finger was slightly trembling, something nobody of the Company had ever seen. Even when faced with an entire Goblin city, Nori had kept his composure.

Fíli frowned and peered down the gloomy passage. "What is it?"

And then Kíli's hand shot out and clamped onto his bicep, the fingers like steel bands. For revealed by the glimmering star-phial was two great clusters of many-windowed eyes. They gleamed with menace: bestial and yet filled with purpose and with hideous delight, gloating over their prey trapped beyond all hope of escape.

Frodo and Sam, horror-stricken, began slowly to back away. And then all at once their nerve broke, and away they ran like frightened hares. The light bobbed and flickered madly like a candle-flame in a stiff breeze, throwing crazed swinging shadows all over the smooth tunnel walls.

"Quick!" Fíli said, and ushered his brother and Nori ahead of him. "Move!"

Kíli made no attempt to reply. He was already reaching over his shoulder as though for an arrow, and cursed as his hand groped at empty air. "Just run!" Fíli told him curtly.

Kíli swore again and tore off after the fleeing shape of Nori, Fíli hot on his heels. He risked a look behind, and wished immediately that he had not.

"The eyes are following!" he called ahead.

"Which way?" Sam gasped, and his little knife was lifted high. In Frodo's hand Sting began to glow with a faint blue sheen.

"I don't know!" Frodo said, and he whirled in a circle, his eyes desperate and the glass held aloft in one hand. "I don't know! Sméagol! Sméagol!"

"No use calling him," Nori snapped, and his elaborate hair had begun to fray from his running. "Can you two feel the passage at all?"

"A little," Kíli said dubiously.

Fíli concentrated, pushing his heels as firmly against the smooth, sleek rock as he could. "Left…?" he said.

"It's almost on us!" Sam said.

"Stand! stand!" Frodo said, and he swiped at his filthy face with his sleeve and turned to face the oncoming horror. "Running is no use."

Slowly the eyes crept nearer.

Frodo drew himself tall, and lifted the Phial higher. "Galadriel!" he breathed, and he turned to face the approaching monster, his bare little chin set and determined. Then he took a short, sharp breath and slowly set off back along the passage towards the shining malevolence of those myriad eyes.

Fíli stared in dismay. "What's he doing?"

"I can't watch," Kíli moaned. Fíli gripped his wrist and drew him near.

"They've stopped," said Nori in surprise.

"What?"

"All them eyes! They stopped, as though the light coming near hurt them. Then they disappeared!"

"Mister Frodo!" Sam exclaimed, and he put a hand to his chest in sheer relief. "Stars and glory! But the Elves would make a song of that, if ever they heard of it!"

"Elves?" Fíli snorted, made loud and crude in relief. "I'll sing you a song, better than any tra-la-la-lallying."

"Ahem," said Kíli pointedly.

"Tra-la-la-lally was a bit daft, you have to admit," Nori murmured.

Kíli harrumphed and folded his arms.

Sam pulled Frodo back, and then brushed down his threadbare, dust-stained jacket. "Now let's get out of this foul hole!"

"Yes," Frodo said distantly, looking along the passage after the vast, many-eyed thing that had fled. "Yes; to Mordor."

"Left!" Fíli repeated, and by some miracle, the Hobbits chose that path.

On they trudged once more, stumbling and pitching with fatigue, drained beyond words by the ordeal. "Is it my imagination," whispered Kíli, "Or is this tunnel sloping upwards now?"

"I can feel air on my face!" said Sam suddenly. "The way out is ahead, surely!"

"Ah!"

Sam nearly ran his little sword through his master's back. For Frodo had been trapped in some dense shadow that the star-glass could not illuminate; it seemed to absorb the light cast rather than reflect it. "What in tarnation…?" he said, and stepped back a little to view it.

Across the width and height of the tunnel a vast web was spun, orderly as the web of some huge spider, but denser-woven and far greater, and each thread was as thick as rope.

Sam laughed grimly. "Cobwebs!" he said. "Is that all? Cobwebs! But what a spider! Have at 'em, down with 'em!"

"Oh no," said Nori, and he bit down on one of his braids.

"Oh not again," Fíli groaned. "I hate these things."

"No elves around these parts, I'm thinking," said Kíli without much hope. Fíli glanced to his brother, and upon seeing the longing in his eyes he nudged his shoulder.

"Cheer up, gravel-for-brains, we've a job to do," he said as briskly as he could manage in this horrible place.

Kíli dredged up a grin from somewhere. "Said the pebble to the rock."

"You're both twits an' I'll brave seein' Ori lying beside Bifur if it means another rotation next time," Nori muttered, twisting his beard in his hands. "Spiders? Anybody remember? Hello?"

"Sam's on it," Kíli said, and shrugged.

But it appeared that Sam's little knife could not break the spider-strands. Three times Sam tried with all his might, and three times the cords bounced and jiggled and shook Frodo, caught in their midst, and did not part.

"Let me try Sting. Here, take the star-glass. Do not be afraid. Hold it up and watch!" Frodo said, and wrestled with the sticky stuff until he could move his sword-arm. Then he brought down his arm with all his weight behind it. The blue-gleaming blade shore through the web-cords like a scythe through grass, and they leaped and writhed and then hung loose. A great rent was made, and Frodo cut his feet free and was soon standing again.

Stroke after stroke he dealt, until at last all the web within his reach was shattered, and the upper portion blew and swayed like a loose veil in the incoming wind. The trap was broken.

"Let's go!" he cried, and sped on and on up the sloping tunnel. "We're almost there! Can't you feel it? Fresh air!"

"If you can call any air o' Mordor fresh," Sam grumbled, but he hitched up his pack and kept pace with Frodo as best he could.

"I can see the sky!" said Kíli joyfully. "They're going to make it!"

"They've slipped that little creep's nets, ha!" Fíli crowed. "Melekûnîth belkul!"

"I don't trust it," said Nori.

"You barely trust your eyes before your own nose, you old crook," laughed Kíli, and he stamped a half-measure of a drum-dance as he ran. "They made it!"

"They're not out yet," Nori said ominously.

"Look, Sam! The pass!" Frodo said, and he pointed ahead. A fey mood was on him, and he raced as fast as his furry feet could carry him towards the great horned tops of the cliffs. Just peering over them was the reddish light of a fire: the tower of Cirith Ungol.

"Master, your sword, there's orcs about and worse than orcs!" Sam said, lurching forward with a warning hand extended. Sting was glowing brighter than ever – an unwavering beacon in the smoky haze of Mordor. Frodo, however, was too far ahead: relief and joy at escaping the trap had made him careless, and he was at least 20 feet away. Sam cursed and shoved the star-phial – which he still held – into his jerkin, before clattering after Frodo with a warning still caught on his lips.

Hardly had Sam hidden the light of the star-glass when she came.

From beneath a crack in the cliff issued the most loathly shape Fíli had ever seen: horrible beyond the eyes of Smaug, more dreadful than Azog's blade. Like a spider she was, but huger than any great hunting beast, and more terrible than they because of the evil purpose in her many-faceted, malevolent eyes. Great horns she had, and behind her short stalk-like neck was her huge swollen body, a vast bloated bag, swaying and sagging between her legs; its great bulk was black, blotched with livid marks, but the belly underneath was pale and luminous and gave forth a stench. Her legs were bent, with great knobbed joints high above her back, and hairs that stuck out like steel spines, and at each leg's end there was a claw.

"The spiders of Mirkwood suddenly seem sort of tame," Nori choked, and he shoved both of his side-braids into his mouth and bit down as hard as he could.

"Get Thorin!" Fíli ordered, and Kíli nodded rapidly and flashed away in a burst of starlight as Gimlîn-zâram stole him away.

The squelching, clacking, bubbling noise now made a terrible sort of sense. Nori and Fíli crowded close as the vast spider closed in behind Frodo, cutting Sam off from his master. Either she did not see the gardener, or she was avoiding the bearer of that painful pure light.

Sam gasped and gathered all his remaining breath to shout. "Look out behind!" he yelled. "Look out master! I'm" – but suddenly his cry was stifled.

A long-fingered hand had gripped him from behind, clasping over his mouth and nose and making it hard to breathe. It yanked him back with awful soft strength, wiry and fueled by a burning resentment that could have torn mountains apart.

"Mahumb," Nori breathed. "I hate being right."

"Got him!" hissed Gollum. "At last, my precious, we've got him, yes, the nassty Hobbit, the suspicious Hobbit, the stupid fat one. We takes this one. She'll get the other. O yes, Shelob will get him, not Sméagol: he promised; he won't hurt Master at all. But he's got you, you nassty filthy little sneak!" He spat on Sam's neck.

Sam's cheerful brown face, which had drained in fury at this treachery, suddenly flushed red. Rage and panic for Frodo's safety gave him a sudden violence and strength, and he took Gollum completely by surprise.

Not Gollum himself could have twisted more quickly or more fiercely. Sam wriggled away from the foul little beast and desperately he tried to turn and stab his enemy. But Gollum was wily and had long years to practice his vicious arts. He recovered quickly. His arm shot out and he grabbed Sam's wrist: his fingers were like a vice; slowly and relentlessly he bent the hand down and forward, till with a cry of pain Sam released the sword and it fell to the ground; and all the while Gollum's other hand was tightening on Sam's throat.

"No, no, no," Nori groaned.

"Hurry up, Kee," Fíli whispered. "Hurry up!"

Then Sam played his last trick. With all his strength he pulled away and got his feet firmly planted; then suddenly he drove his legs against the ground and with his whole force hurled himself backwards. Gollum fell over with the sturdy Hobbit on top, all his breath driven out of him in a rush. He lay dazed, his twiglike limbs thrown asunder.

"Yes!" Fíli whooped, and he turned and headbutted Nori in his exuberance. Then he realised what exactly he had done, and drew back. Nori's face was sardonic.

"Next time wait until your brother's here, awright?"

Sam wasn't done. He laid in with his fists, one-two, one-two, in the simplest fashion possible. Fíli's hard-learned knowledge, gained from thousands of lessons from Thorin and Dwalin alike, despaired at the crude country technique. But the rest of him was cheering loudly as Gollum hissed and spat like a scalded cat. Apparently he was off his game when he could not grab and strangle his prey unawares, and a furious and stout Hobbit such as Sam Gamgee was far too difficult a meal – particularly once Sam swept up his dropped sword and raised it.

With a squeal, Gollum sprang aside on to all fours and he jumped away in one big bound like a frog. Before Sam could reach him, he was off, running with amazing speed back towards the tunnel.

"Damn you, Stinker!" Sam roared after him, and a fell light was in his honest eyes. "I'll find you and I'll stick you like one o' Old Proudfoot's pigs, so I shall!"

"Sam Gamgee, look to your master!" came a deep, commanding voice from behind Fili. All the tension in his belly unknotted all at once, and he turned to see Kíli hovering behind Thorin. His brother was wringing his hands anxiously.

But there was a power and a strength and a life in Thorin that Fíli had not seen since –

No, he had never seen Thorin thus.

It was as though all his warring, troubled facets had finally met in peace at last. His uncle was dishevelled, with plain trousers and the tunic he wore was creased and his hair half-mussed, but he wore his disarray with easy grace. He looked more alive than he had looked in - well, ever.

"Mahal wept," said Nori, echoing Fíli's own thoughts. "Has he? After struggling all these decades?"

Sam nearly dropped his sword, pausing at the dark hole of the tunnel. "Frodo," he said, and then he turned and raced as fast as any Hobbit had ever done. "Mister Frodo!"

The Dwarves all tore after him, but none of them were fleet enough to catch up with a Hobbit even upon their best day. The huge black stinking bag that was Shelob's abdomen rose before them, and Fíli could see a small shape beneath those clacking legs, spinning round and around and around.

"I have come too late," Thorin said, eyes ablaze and his mouth tight and worried.

"I hate webs," Nori muttered. "They take forever to get out of the eyebrows."

The monster was so intent upon her prize that she did not even notice Sam and his shouting until he was upon her. Nearby lay Sting, dropped where it had fallen. Sam did not even hesitate, but scooped up the little Elven letter-opener and sprang forward with it. "Now come, you filth!" he yelled. "You've hurt my master, you brute, and you'll pay for it!"

The gargantuan spider seemed to be shaken out her gloating dreams by Sam's little yell, and slowly she turned as though bending her malice upon him.

"What can we do?" Kíli said desperately, and Fíli's hand was groping into his coat for an absent blade.

"Wait," Thorin said, and though his voice was quiet it nevertheless quieted their small group. "This foul carrion-carcass does not yet know that this one is a lion beneath his Hobbit-skin. She will know it ere long."

Sam's eyes were lit with blazing fury, and he sprang beneath the arches of those clacking, stinking legs to slide directly underneath that grizzled ancient head with its clustered eyes. With a quick upthrust, one great eye went dark, and the mammoth spider screeched in outrage and agony.

"None have set blade to that foul flesh before now, I'll wager," Thorin said with some satisfaction. "I hope it enjoyed the taste."

Sam was hollering at the top of his lungs, his whole face red with rage. He was still beneath the monstrous spider, ducking and rolling and weaving to avoid her stabbing pincer-legs. Her vast belly was above him with its putrid light, and Fíli could see him gagging upon the stench. Still his wrath sustained him for one more blow, and he stabbed wildly upwards.

"Got her!" Fíli shouted.

But this beast was not as dragons are, no softer spot had she save only her eyes. Knobbed and pitted with corruption was her age-old hide, but ever thickened from within with layer on layer of evil growth. The blade scored it with a dreadful gash, but those hideous folds could not be pierced by Sam's wild swing. She yielded to the stroke, and then heaved up the great bag of her belly high above Sam's head.

Poison frothed and bubbled from the wound. Now splaying her legs she drove her huge bulk down on him again. Too soon. For Sam still stood upon his feet, and dropping his own sword, with both hands he held the elven-blade point upwards, fending off that ghastly roof; and so Shelob, with the driving force of her own cruel will, with strength greater than any warrior's hand, thrust herself upon a bitter spike.

Deep, deep it pricked, as Sam was crushed slowly to the ground.

A scream, unheard of in all the world since the very dawn of time, was let loose deep within the spider's body. A shudder went through her. Heaving up again, wrenching away from the pain, she bent her writhing limbs and keened in agony.

"The star-glass! From Lothlórien!" Fíli urged, and Thorin whipped around and repeated, "the phial of Galadriel!"

Sam fumbled in his tattered waistcoat and drew it forth again, and the colossal spider writhed in agony as it smashed into her damaged eye. Her limbs spasmed, gross and ungainly and rubbery, as she slunk away into her tunnels and away from the prey that had cost her more dearly than any other had ever done. Her clacking limbs and reeking stench were the last of her that could be seen, and then she was gone.

"Durin's blood, beard and bones," Kíli said, stunned.

"Frodo, Mister Frodo!" Sam gasped and, and he fell to his knees by Frodo's head. "Wake up, Mister Frodo me dear!"

Frodo did not speak.

Sam ripped with all his might at the sticky cords that wrapped around Frodo, enveloping him in a shroudlike cocoon. He was only able to pull open the area over Frodo's face. The older Hobbit was ashen and as still as carven marble.

"Master, dear master," Sam said, and through a long silence waited, listening in vain. Then seized by a panic, he pressed his ear against Frodo's chest and held his breath, and then held a hand over Frodo's mouth. He patted at Frodo's cheeks, rubbed at his hands, and felt at his brow.

"It cannot be," Fíli heard Thorin say, low and pained. "Not Frodo…!"

Sam lifted Frodo's spider-silk wrapped head into his lap and pressed it against his chest. Tears were beginning to well in his honest eyes, and Fíli could barely look at the pain in his face. "Frodo, Mister Frodo!" he sobbed. "Don't leave me here alone! It's your Sam calling. Don't go where I can't follow! Wake up, Mister Frodo! O wake up, Frodo, me dear, me dear. Wake up!"

Fíli could not have said how long they stood there, watching Sam bowed to the ground beneath his black despair. Thorin's hand upon his shoulder made him startle, and he realised he was weeping. He tried to swallow his tears, but they ran into his beard nevertheless. "Namadul, here," Thorin said, and wiped beneath his eyes with a thumb. "It is no shame to feel sorrow," he said, his own eyes glimmering suspiciously and his own voice full of grief. He cupped Fíli's jaw momentarily, and then drew him against his side. Kíli was pressed against his other shoulder, his face hidden amidst Thorin's wild hair. His back trembled, as though with sobs.

"All that watching, all that, that," Nori burst out, and he clenched his fists. "Bilbo will be shattered. To come so far, to get so close!"

"So close," Kíli said, muffled by Thorin's hair. "The pass is right there! Oh, curse Gollum, why did Frodo ever trust him?"

"Because he had to believe that he could be saved," Thorin said thickly, and he tucked Fíli's head under his chin. The familiar warm scent of him reminded Fíli of his childhood, and he took a shuddering breath, and then another. "Because the dark temptation of the Ring is what created Gollum, and even Hobbits may feel greed. Because we are all worthy of pity now and then, even the very meanest of us."

"Oh what shall I do now, Mister Frodo?" Sam said tenderly, and he stroked Frodo's motionless face. "Did I come all this way with you for nothing?"

"Frodo Baggins," Thorin said, and he bowed his head, his chin pressing against the crown of Fíli's head. "Ah, nekhushel. Gaubdûkhimâ gagin yâkùlib Mahal."

Kíli softly began to hum the mourning-song, and Nori and Fíli joined in.

"What can I do?" Sam managed through hitching breath and swimming eyes. "What can I do? Not leave you here unburied on top of the mountains, and go home. Or go on? Go on?" he repeated, and for a moment doubt and fear crossed his ravaged round face. "Go on? Is that what I've got to do? And leave him?"

"Aye, azaghîth," said Thorin, low.

"What? Me, alone, go to the Crack of Doom and all?" Sam quailed. "What? Me take the Ring from him? The Council gave it to him."

"The quest must continue, little tender of the soil, lion of the Shire," Thorin said, and his normally smooth deep voice cracked. "No one person is bigger than this task. The Council gave this burden to Frodo, but Frodo was given companions so that the task might not fail. And you are the last one left."

"I wish I wasn't the last," Sam groaned. "I wish old Gandalf was here or somebody."

"Even wizards fear this deed, Samwise Gamgee," Thorin said, and Fíli felt the bob of his throat as he swallowed. "You must go on. There is no other way."

"I'm sure to go wrong. And it's not for me to go taking the Ring, putting myself forward." Sam's fingers traced over Frodo's cold brow, and then he sighed heavily. "But you haven't put yourself forward; you've been put forward. And as for not being the right and proper person, why, Mister Frodo wasn't as you might say, nor Mister Bilbo. They didn't choose themselves."

"If Frodo is found with that thing on him, assuming Gollum doesn't rob him, well – the Enemy will get it. And even if Gollum gets his desire, the Dark Tower will see him. And that will be the end of everything," Thorin said, even as he wept for Frodo. The tears trickled down his face unheeded, but his voice was implacable now. "You have no time, and the days grow short and bloody. War beckons on every horizon, and you are the last hope left."

Sam sat, still as stone, for a long, long moment. Then he shook himself as though coming out of a dark dream.

"If I'm to go on," he said, "then I must take your sword, by your leave, Mr. Frodo, but I'll put this one to lie by you; and you've got your beautiful mithril coat from old Mister Bilbo. And your star-glass, Mister Frodo, you did lend it to me and I'll need it, for I'll be always in the dark now. It's too good for me, and the Lady gave it to you, but maybe she'd understand. Do you understand, Mister Frodo? I've got to go on."

Then Sam steeled himself as though he were about to plunge his hand into fire. Very gently he undid the clasp at Frodo's neck and slipped his hand inside his tunic; then with his other hand raising the head, he kissed the cold forehead, and softly drew the chain over it.

Not a flicker passed over Frodo's face – and that, more than anything, convinced Fíli that Frodo was truly dead. He would not suffer the Ring to be removed thus if –

Golden Heart, heir to Durin's Throne

Fíli cried out, and clapped his hands over his ears.

Crown Prince, Lion prince, gold be your name and gold can be your dominion, power and rule can be yours

"Namadul!" Thorin shouted, and he whirled Fíli to stare into his face. Fíli stared back at Thorin's eyes, his breath coming in jerky shallow gulps. "On me, focus on me, on my voice! It cannot harm you!"

Kidhuzurkurdu, the voice whispered, seductive and sinuous. Fíli clawed for air, and desperately pleaded without words for it to stop, stop!

"On me, Namadul!" Thorin commanded, and he pressed their heads together tightly. "Eyes on me!"

"Fee!" Kíli shouted, and he could vaguely feel his brother's arms wrapping tightly around him. "Don't listen to it!"

And then Sam put the chain into his waistcoat pocket, and Fíli sagged like a puppet whose strings had been cut. Kíli had to struggle beneath his weight for a moment, before Nori slung his arm over his shoulders and hauled him up.

"Well, that was tense," was all he said. The whites of his eyes were showing, and he was visibly trembling again. Fíli wondered for a second what Nori had heard, and then shuddered.

"It's tried it on us before," Kíli said, worriedly looking into Fíli's face. "It didn't get anywhere then, so I'll bet it's calling harder now. I didn't hear it this time. Must be attempting to strike a new vein."

"It can only lie and destroy," Thorin said darkly, and he smoothed back Fíli's braids. "You did well. All of you. Are you all right, Fili? Nori?"

Fíli nodded, and tried to compose himself. The voice had been like a vice, squeezing all thought from his head. How had Frodo even borne the thing a single day? "So, you can't hear it any more?" he managed, and Kíli shook his head.

"It calls, but I will not answer," Thorin said with firm finality. "Do you need to go?"

Fíli hesitated, and Nori bit his lip.

"Then we will go," said Thorin, and he glanced back at the scene. "Sam is the Ringbearer now. We can do no more here."

Sam was standing, oh-so slowly, as though he staggered beneath a great weight. Then he dashed away his new tears and looked longingly at Frodo's still, calm face. "Good-bye, master, my dear!" he murmured. "Forgive your Sam. He'll come back to this spot when the job's done – if he manages it. And then he'll not leave you again. Rest you quiet till I come; and may no foul creature come anigh you! And if the Lady could hear me and give me one wish, I would wish to come back and find you again. Good-bye!"

"Forgive me, Bilbo," Fíli heard Thorin whisper as the starlight reached around him and bore him gently away.


"They've pulled us out o' position," Dáin growled, and he sent Värc the raven back into the sky with a bounce of his forearm. "The Dale-Men's warriors are trapped in the tunnel, and we are still pinned in this bloody pile o' rock. Hammer and tongs! Imagine, throwing away a whole army just to make a diversion! And now Dale lies defenceless, bare as a babe, while they bring up this second force to rout her!"

Bomfrís panted, her hand clamped to her side. Upon her shoulder, the raven Tuäc croaked anxiously.

"Where is Thorin?" she said once she had her breath again. "I thought he was to man the walls?"

"There was a change o' plans, lass," Dáin said, and he held his hand high and brought it down with a flick of gnarled fingers. Shouts came as the signal was relayed along the wall, and great steaming kettles of hot liquid metal were poured from the battlements into the teeming, stinking horde below. The screaming and the stench was awful, and Bomfrís clamped a forearm over her mouth. "The tunnel has been breached."

Bomfrís stared at the King. "And he is down there?"

"Aye." Dáin watched the shrieking Orcs below, his wrinkled face hard as granite. "He has the best of our sappers with him, an' that Elf prince whose company you like so much."

Bomfrís scowled automatically at the mention of Laerophen, and then Dáin's words sank in and she paled, her freckles standing out starkly against her skin. "How long now?"

"Hours," Dáin said, and he reached out and patted her arm absently. "He's a strong lad, my son. He'll come back to you."

"How do you know?" she demanded.

Dáin turned to her, and she could see the incredible age in his faded blue eyes, the weariness. "Because he must," he said, and squeezed her forearm. "Now, go to the sconces, m'girl. Keep yourself safe. We need your bow to cover our assault."

"Our assault?" she said in alarm, but the King was striding along the wall to where Dwalin stood like an immovable boulder, gesturing for the old general to bend his head to talk.

"What d'you think he means, our assault?" Tuäc whispered.

"I don't know," she said, and wrung her hands. "But we have to go to the tunnel."

"No fear, you're not getting me down there!" Tuäc squawked, her wings rustling in indignation. "And the King said to go above!"

"Stay behind then, featherhead," she hissed, and span on her heel so quickly that the raven was forced to backwing away.

Tuäc hovered a moment, flapping and watching the Dwarrowdam race away, clad in her leather jerkin and pants and a hastily-donned brigandine. "Oh, I shall regret this," she said to herself, her beak clacking. "Bomfrís! Wait!"

Dáin glanced back as Bomfrís darted into the Mountain, and sighed. "Well, bugger."

"She didn't go back to the archery-posts, did she," Dwalin said, and it was not a question. He grunted. "I can send one o' mine to go get her."

"We've bigger matters," Dáin said, and he pulled off his helm and rubbed his forehead for a moment or two. "So. You agree?"

Dwalin gave him a crooked grin. "Done it before, haven't I?"

"Aye, but it weren't me doing the asking." Dáin stared out over the battlements for a moment. A great white Orc sneered at him from amidst the seething mass before the Mountain, her lips pulled back from bloody teeth. In her hand she held a great flail and scars were carved into her face in horribly familiar patterns. Dwalin glanced at the King, and then followed his gaze.

"Dâgalûr," said Dáin, and he shook his head. "Bolg's daughter. That family is worse than flies on a carcass."

"Aye, and we're the carcass," growled Dwalin. "Well, I'll go kill her then."

Dáin grinned. "Aye, but let me have my go first. Royal prerogative."

"Royal ass, more like," Dwalin muttered, and scowled like a thundercloud at the huge Orc-chiefess.

Dáin pulled the boar-helm back on and squared his shoulders. "Where's Dís?"

Dwalin nodded to behind Dáin, and he turned to see the First Advisor, standing like the figurehead upon a prow. She wore an ancient mail-shirt and faulds that bore the sigils of her ancestor, Thorin I, and in a blue surcoat and trousers she had never looked more like her brother. Her grey hair flapped in the wind as she lifted her sword and cut down the Orc that was crawling up the Mountainside like some elongated cockroach. "Need a hand there?"

"In a – moment!" she grunted, and pinned the Orc through with her sword like an insect upon a board. Then she leaned against it heavily and mopped at her brow. "I am too old for this."

Dwalin barked out a laugh. "Aye, you and all of us. And here we are."

"Why are you two bothering me now," she grumbled, and blew her hair out of her face with a puff. Sweat had washed dust and grime into the deep lines of sorrow and bitterness at mouth, eyes and brow. "I'm busy."

"As we feared," Dáin said simply, and she froze for a fraction of a second. Then her shoulders slumped.

"Ah."

"You don't seem surprised, either of you, if you don't mind me sayin'," said Dwalin, and he casually kicked an Orc in the face to send it screaming down off the battlements.

"I'm not," Dáin said, and he turned to headbutt another, sending it howling after Dwalin's. "Just sort o' resigned, to be honest."

"Dáin, please don't," said Dís, and she yanked her sword free of the Orc she had felled and took two halting steps towards her cousin. "Don't…"

"Brand is left surrounded," he said, and her face twisted in anger.

"They would not send help for us!"

"They did eventually," Dwalin murmured, and Dáin nodded. Dís scoffed, waving a hand jerkily.

"Eventually! Months later, months into this stinking siege. A token force only, trapped underground. We had to send Bofur to beg!"

"And no shame in that," said Dáin, and he grabbed the confused-looking Orc that had made it to the tops of the wall, blinking in surprise, and butted it sharply. It went limp in his grip. "Just remindin' them of their agreements. Bein' neighbourly, you might say."

"You and your agreements!" she snarled. "Always with your bloody agreements!"

"Well, that's why we make 'em," Dáin said peaceably, and he used his handful as a shield against the spear that came hurtling towards him. It made a schlock! sound as it entered the Orc's body. "We make 'em to honour 'em."

"Ignore it!" Dís cried, and she whirled and decapitated another Orc, kicking its head away with more than usual vehemence. "We are still surrounded, you mad old fool, it is suicide! We have enough to deal with as it is!"

Dáin shared a glance with Dwalin. "I can't, Dís."

"Your damned honour!" she spat, and then roused herself again to smash the face of an Orc with her mailed fist. It clutched its head and keeled over the wall, and she flicked the blood from her blade with a twist of her wrist. "Dáin, curse it all - honour will get you killed!"

"As you've said often enough," Dáin said, and he hauled himself around to send Barazanthual, his famous red axe, into the skull of another climber.

"Dwalin you cannot possibly agree," she implored him, Dwalin shifted slightly, uncomfortable. "You are our General. You must agree: this makes no military sense! It's lunacy!"

"Well, there's a strain o' that in our family, they do say," Dwalin said after a moment, and Dís' face drained of all colour.

"This is about Thorin," she said, biting the words off in her fury. "Dáin, damn you…"

"No, it ain't about him," Dwalin said curtly. "This is about Dale. We have all three of us known Brand since he was in swaddling cloths. You dandled him on your knee, an' Dáin gifted him with one o' Bofur's toy soldiers. He is our friend. We promised to defend his home, cousin. You promised to personally defend it with your own blade."

She stared at them.

Then she closed her eyes. "Yes, I did," she said, nearly to herself. "I promised."

And then, even quieter: "Must I bury you too?"

Dáin stumped forward to lay a hand upon her shoulder and look earnestly into her face. "Stop that, now," he said. "Stop it, there ain't no guarantees, an' who knows? I might not cark it."

"Our track record of retaining our Kings in battle is not encouraging," she said tartly, her eyes still closed. "You have been preparing us: Thira, myself, your son, Bomfrís. You have been planning. Why do you have to be so…"

"So pigheaded?" Dáin finished for her, grinning broadly. She opened her eyes to pin him with her glare.

"Droll," she said, her marvellous voice cracking.

He tightened his fingers upon her shoulder. "I've not left you yet," he said. "And you're older than I am."

"Not that any can tell," she grated back. "I've been ice for longer than you can ever imagine. You still let the world change you: you let the world move you. I cannot."

"I know, namaduh kurdulu," he said, stepping closer. "I have eyes and a mind, and I make use of 'em. But come with me anyway."

She stared at him some more, her chest heaving.

Dwalin began to sing softly under his breath in a rusty but pleasant voice:

[The Iron Hills soldiers' song (choral), performed and arranged by the author]

[The Iron Hills soldiers' song (solo), performed and arranged by notanightlight]

"My home is no great hall of stone:
No golden treasures greet me.
Nor an ancient place of great renown
No grandeur in its history.

My home may not seem much to you
And pretty poor you think her
But gold and gems will turn on you
Where iron will not falter…"

Dáin smiled. "Trying to make an old man nostalgic now?"

"Is it working?" Dwalin retorted.

"I hate you both," Dís breathed. "Open the damned gates then. Let's save Dale."

"Get Thira, tell her to get to the outer bailey," Dáin said, hauling a nearby warrior by the arm and hissing in his ear. "Don't dawdle now!"

Dwalin lifted his Warhammer, and brought it down upon the nearby drum with a resounding and thunderous boom that seemed to shatter the very air, before following it with two faster beats, and then four slow.

The silence that followed was hushed and astonished.

"Are you sure, Majesty?" asked a soldier.

Dáin ignored that, and began to stump his way from the battlements to the Great Gates.

"O but take me where the falcons scream," sang Dwalin softly, following behind him. Dáin snorted, and joined in with his old and cracking voice:

"And the wind rips round the mountains,
Where the waters run as red as blood
And cascade in crashing fountains."

"Sentimental old men!" Dís spat, and when the following verses began to rise from all the throats around them, she closed her eyes and yet still a tear managed to escape from beneath her eyelid.

"My home is hard and poor and free
And untamed as any lion.
No gold nor gems does she have for me,
Her proud hard heart is iron.

My home is far away from here
My hearth it calls me sadly
My forge it lies so cold and drear
When it used to echo gladly."

By the Gate General Orla stood, along with Glóin, Dori, Gimrís and the combat healers. Her long-handled axe was held loosely in her hand and her eyes were confused as she took in the contingent of warriors from the battlements, all singing softly and led by the King.

"What's this?" she hissed to Dís, who sent her friend a hard look full of bitterness.

Glóin pulled at his vast snowy beard and sighed, his eyes distant. "It's an old Iron Hills soldiers' song."

"This is Dáin being a noble fool off to die for glory and honour and Erebor, like all the rest," Dís growled. "It will not be content until we are all spent!"

Orla was silent for a second, her usually stern mien cracking to show a swift and suddenly-concealed sadness. "Ah," was all she said.

Queen Thira was by the door, and she took the King's old, white-braided head in her hands and kissed him lingeringly. No-one was close enough to hear them speak, but she was weeping when she drew away and her thin face was anguished.



Dain and Thira, by kazimakuwabara

"You always knew I wouldn't die in a bed, my love, and you always knew I'd go before ye," Orla could hear Dáin say, and she tried to stopper her ears. "Why you married such an old Dwarrow, Mahal only knows. Watch our boy, won't you?"

"You're not planning to come back to me, not this time," she said, and he smiled.

"I think I'm done. This bloody pile o' rock that Oakenshield dumped on us has wrung me dry, but I can give her one last thing, eh?"

"Dáin," she half-gasped, and he smoothed back her black beard upon her cheeks with a thumb.

"Love you," was all he said.

"Come back," she moaned, and gripped at his hand. He pressed his forehead against hers, and ran her black braids through his hands once, letting them swing freely. "You always have before. Come back again, prove them all wrong one last time!"

"I'll try," he said, but he didn't sound optimistic. "I'll try."



Dáin and Thira, one last time, by fishfingersandscarves

Soldiers poured in from the battlements to gather behind the King, Orla, Dwalin, and Dís. The song rose in volume as the King kissed the Queen again, and her lips lingered upon his and her thin clever hands gripped his wrinkled, wise, wearied face.

"O I long for where the sun beats down
And the rivers roar with fierceness
Where the earth is painted red not brown
And the weather scares me beardless.

For gems and gold and mighty halls
The great will bid us roam.
And every time we obey their call
We pray that we come home."

Dáin nodded to Orla, who lifted her axe. Above the door, Dori winded the great battle-horn and the massive gears behind the Gates began to creak as the mechanism was turned for the first time in months. Dáin kissed Thira once more, and then he accepted Dwalin's knife and held it to his own wild white head. A braid came loose, and he pressed it into her hands, and then he caught Dís' eyes.



Dis, by renvsner

Her face was so contorted it appeared that she was growling, and her dark eyes were swimming in tears as around them every throat opened in thunderous, triumphant song:

"Soon the drums will sound again
And out we'll trot like cattle
The lordly need that iron blood
For watering their battle.

O I'll turn my feet towards the north
Like a compass ever true!
I'll never roam again henceforth
From my land of red and blue!"

"Come on then," said Dáin, and he shouldered Barazanthual. "Let's go face that scum all over again."

"You always knew," she accused him fiercely, "you always…"

"Dís," Dáin said, and his voice was nearly swallowed by the singing around them. "That blood-feud is centuries old, and we have never escaped it, never. Her great-grandfather beheaded my father, and I slaughtered him in return. Her grandfather killed Thrór and Fíli and Thorin, and Thorin killed him in return. Her father killed Kíli! Can we ever escape it? I'm next, and I know it. The target's on my head now. I've outrun it for a hell of a long time – but you can only run so fast when you've a dud leg like me."

"You bastard!" she cried, and he tipped his head.

"Aye," he said gently, and squeezed Thira's hand. "But practical. We have to save Dale, cousin. If Dale falls, we're good an' lost. We can't eat gold and we cannot stand alone, we learned that long ago. So, Dâgalûr is the risk we must face, an' I've known ever since I learned her name that she held my ticket in her filthy hands. But I tell you this, Dís: when this scum gets me, I'm countin' on you to get her in return."

"You'll kill her yourself, you damned fool," Dís snarled, and he laughed.

"Perhaps. It feels like a lucky sort o' day!"

The voices rose to a shattering wall of sound, and he turned to look at the Gates with determination glinting in those pale and faded blue eyes.

"O! I dream of jagged rusty skies,
And her savage wild beauty.
I see her when I close my eyes;
The Iron Hills for me!"

"The Iron Hills for me," Dáin sang to himself, quiet and rasping, and the boar-helm stooped for a second.

Then he lifted his axe into the sky and called in a great and dreadful voice:

"BARUK KHAZÂD! KHAZÂD AI-MÊNU!"

The Gates crashed open and the answering roar shook the air around them as Dáin led the Dwarves through and out into the killing field. Dís gritted her teeth and lifted her sword and followed through the haze of her angry tears.



Dis, by kazimakuwabara


TBC.

Notes:

Khuzdul
Azaghîth – Little warrior
Gimlîn-zâram – Star-pool
Nekhushel – sorrow of all sorrows
Gaubdûkhimâ gagin yâkùlib Mahal - May we meet again with the grace of Mahal (formal goodbye)
BARUK KHAZÂD! KHAZÂD AI-MÊNU! - (War-cry) "The Axes of the Dwarves! The Dwarves are upon you!"
Mahumb - droppings
sabannimi - Beautiful
Melekûnîth belkul - mighty little hobbits
namadul - son of sister
Kidhuzurkurdu - golden heart
namaduh kurdulu - sister of my heart

Black Speech
Dâgalûr - Demon

Quenya
Aiya Eärendil Elenion Ancalima - Hail Eärendil, brightest of stars!

...

A reference is made here to 'The Hobbit' in which Thorin says: "Dori is the strongest, but Fili is the youngest and still has the best sight."

Dialogue and description taken from 'Shelob's Lair' and 'The Choices of Master Samwise'.

The reason behind the Iron Hills' relative stability was their lack of Dwarven Ring. The rings attracted great treasure hoards, which in turn attracted dragons.

Under Dain's rule, the Dwarves of the Lonely Mountain gained a reputation for being trustworthy.

The soldiers' song is my own work and not Tolkien's. *hides* I hope you enjoy it.

The Dwarves of the Iron Hills were the last to make it to the Battle of Azanulbizar. There, upon the steps of Khazad-dum, Dain's father Nain was beheaded by Azog before his eyes. Then Dain (who was a lad of only 32 at the time) slew Azog in return. In this story I have reconciled this book canon with the new movie!canon by implying that book-Azog is in fact movie-Azog's father. (This, for those who find this as funny as I do, means that movie-Azog would have been called Junior).

 

ALSO: please find on my tumblr the fab DAIN IRONFOOT IS AWESOME fic rec list, for fans of Dain who want to avoid the floods of villain!Dain fics!
(and to those people who write villain!Dain - coolies! But pretty please tag it, it would be much appreciated.)

ALSO ALSO: I am a bit pressed for time these days what with my beautiful little dwarfling, and I often find it very difficult to answer, but I appreciate and read EVERY SINGLE COMMENT. They mean the world to me. Thank you SO MUCH.