Chapter Text
The trouble began, as many troubles in Bag End did, with a perfectly reasonable question asked over breakfast.
“Frodo, my dear,” Bilbo began, setting down his teacup, “how would you feel about going on an adventure?”
Frodo, who had been carefully spreading strawberry preserves over a piece of toast, stopped with his knife halfway across the bread.
He looked up.
“An adventure?”
“A small one,” Bilbo said.
Thorin made a sound suspiciously like a snort from behind his newspaper.
Bilbo ignored him.
“Well, perhaps not particularly small. There would be quite a bit of travelling involved, and we would be away from home for some time, but I thought—”
“Bilbo,” Thorin interrupted gently.
His husband turned.
“What?”
“You're making it sound as though we're inviting the lad to march into Mordor.”
“I am doing no such thing!”
“You've been explaining the question for nearly a minute without actually asking it.”
Bilbo gave him a thoroughly offended look.
Frodo, meanwhile, was watching them with growing curiosity.
“Where would we go?”
Thorin folded his newspaper and placed it beside his plate.
“To Erebor.”
Frodo's eyes widened.
“The Lonely Mountain?”
“The very same.”
“Where you used to be king?”
“Yes.”
“And where Fíli is king now?”
Thorin smiled.
“Yes, lad.”
Frodo looked between his uncles, his forgotten toast resting upon his plate.
“Really?”
Bilbo's expression softened at the excitement in his voice.
“Really. We were actually planning to visit before you came to live with us. We thought we might spend Yule with Thorin's family.”
“Only,” Thorin added, “we decided there was something rather more important to attend to first.”
Frodo looked puzzled.
“What?”
Bilbo reached across the table and gently squeezed his hand.
“You, sweetheart.”
The boy lowered his eyes, but the small smile that appeared upon his face did not escape either of them.
_____________
For the past six weeks, Bag End had gradually become accustomed to having a third inhabitant. Frodo's little shoes stood beside the front door, his books had begun appearing among Bilbo's, and Thorin's workshop now contained a chair made especially for a young hobbit who had developed a remarkable interest in woodcarving.
It had not been an entirely easy six weeks. There were still mornings when Frodo woke unusually quiet, and evenings when the memory of his parents weighed upon him more heavily than he knew how to explain. But there were good days, too. Days filled with biscuits, laughter, stories, and the pleasant scrape of sandpaper against wood.
Bilbo and Thorin had no intention of disturbing that newfound security without first asking whether Frodo wanted to go.
“We would be travelling for several weeks,” Bilbo explained. “And because winter is approaching, we'd probably remain in Erebor for three or four months, until the roads were safe enough for the journey home.”
Frodo considered this.
“That's a very long time.”
“It is,” Thorin agreed. “Which is why you must tell us what you think. We can postpone the visit if you'd rather remain here.”
Frodo looked down at his toast.
Then he asked, “Would we go the same way you went on your adventure?”
Bilbo blinked.
“Well, more or less.”
“Past the places you've told me about?”
“Some of them,” Thorin said. “The roads have changed in places, and we'll take safer routes where we can.”
Frodo's eyes brightened.
“Would we see Rivendell?”
“If Lord Elrond is willing to receive us,” Bilbo answered.
“And the mountains?”
“Those will be rather difficult to miss,” Thorin said.
“And the forest where the elves captured you?”
Bilbo winced.
“Perhaps we needn't describe it quite like that.”
“But they did capture you.”
“They did,” Thorin admitted, looking entirely too amused by his husband's discomfort.
Frodo leaned forward.
“And the trolls?”
Bilbo nearly dropped his teacup.
“Absolutely not.”
Frodo blinked.
“But—”
“We are not visiting any trolls.”
“I only meant the place where you met them!”
“That is scarcely better.”
Thorin chuckled.
“The lad asked whether we might pass the place, ghivashel. Not whether we'd stop to have supper with its former inhabitants.”
Bilbo turned toward him.
“I distinctly remember you being considerably less amused by those trolls when they were threatening to eat us.”
“A fair point.”
Frodo giggled.
Then another thought occurred to him.
“Will I meet Fíli and Kíli?”
Thorin's expression warmed.
“You certainly will.”
“The ones who tried to teach a goat to climb stairs?”
Bilbo burst out laughing.
Thorin closed his eyes.
“I am beginning to regret some of the stories I've told you.”
“Did they really do it?”
“They tried,” Thorin admitted.
“Did the goat climb the stairs?”
“No. It chased Kíli into a laundry room and ate half of Fíli's scarf.”
Frodo laughed so hard that he nearly knocked over his milk.
Thorin caught the cup before disaster struck.
“Careful, lad.”
Frodo wiped his mouth with his sleeve, earning a disapproving glance from Bilbo, and settled back into his chair.
For a moment, he looked thoughtful.
Then he asked, more quietly, “Would they like me?”
The question caught Thorin by surprise.
He studied the boy across the breakfast table.
Frodo was still learning how to believe that he was wanted. Sometimes that uncertainty appeared in the smallest of questions, asked so casually that another person might not have noticed the worry beneath them.
Thorin did.
“They'll be delighted to meet you,” he said.
“Even though they don't know me?”
“Especially because they don't know you yet.”
Bilbo smiled.
“And they'll have plenty of stories to tell you about Uncle Thorin.”
Thorin gave him a warning look.
“Bilbo.”
“Oh, I'm certain Fíli will be very responsible about it.”
“Bilbo.”
“And Kíli will undoubtedly remember every embarrassing thing you've ever done.”
Frodo's eyes widened with delight.
“Really?”
Thorin sighed.
“I fear this journey may be a dreadful mistake.”
That settled the matter.
Frodo announced that he very much wanted to go.
And before breakfast was finished, he had already asked whether dragons could be seen from the road, whether the elves would allow him to look at their books, and whether dwarves truly lived inside the Mountain or merely beneath it.
Bilbo answered what he could.
Thorin answered the rest.
By the time Frodo hurried away to fetch his journal, both husbands were smiling.
“Well,” Bilbo said, watching the empty doorway, “I think he's excited.”
Thorin reached for his tea.
“An astonishing deduction.”
Bilbo kicked him gently beneath the table.
______________
Preparing for the journey took considerably longer than Thorin had anticipated.
This was largely because Bilbo approached the business of packing as though the survival of Middle-earth depended upon the precise number of spare handkerchiefs they carried.
“Three,” Thorin said firmly.
Bilbo looked up from the open travelling chest.
“Three what?”
“Three winter cloaks for Frodo. Not five.”
“I'm packing four.”
“You have five laid out.”
“One is a travelling cloak.”
“That still makes it a cloak.”
Bilbo frowned.
“And what if one becomes wet?”
“We dry it.”
“And if another is torn?”
“I mend it.”
“And if—”
“Bilbo.”
His husband looked at him.
Thorin gestured toward the enormous pile of clothing.
“We are travelling to Erebor. There are tailors in Erebor. There are seamstresses in Erebor. There are enough blankets in Erebor to bury an entire company of dwarves.”
Bilbo folded his arms.
“And yet I distinctly remember a certain dwarf insisting that I pack extra gloves.”
“That is different.”
“How?”
“Gloves are important.”
“So are cloaks.”
Thorin opened his mouth.
Then closed it.
Bilbo smiled triumphantly.
From the doorway, Frodo watched them with considerable amusement.
“Uncle Bilbo?”
“Yes, sweetheart?”
“Why is Uncle Thorin packing three blankets in his own bag?”
Silence.
Bilbo slowly turned toward his husband.
Thorin stared at Frodo.
The boy looked entirely innocent.
“Three blankets?” Bilbo repeated.
Thorin cleared his throat.
“The nights may be cold.”
“Indeed.”
“And Frodo may need an extra.”
“Of course.”
Bilbo approached the dwarf's travelling bag, lifted the flap, and discovered not three blankets but four.
He looked up.
Thorin looked away.
Frodo dissolved into giggles.
In the end, Bilbo packed four cloaks, Thorin packed three blankets, and neither admitted that the other had made a reasonable point.
Frodo, meanwhile, was given a much smaller travelling case.
Thorin presented it to him one evening in the workshop.
It was made of dark polished wood, with sturdy brass fittings and a leather handle. Inside were carefully arranged compartments containing pencils, measuring tools, sanding blocks, a small wooden mallet, and several pieces of soft wood.
The sharper carving tools would remain safely at Bag End.
Frodo ran his fingers over the little case.
“Is this for the journey?”
Thorin nodded.
“I thought you might like to continue practising.”
Frodo opened one of the compartments.
“Even while we're travelling?”
“Provided we're somewhere suitable. I don't intend to have you carving while riding in a wagon.”
Frodo smiled.
“Thank you, Uncle Thorin.”
“You're welcome, lad.”
The boy examined the case again.
Then he looked up.
“Can I bring my fox?”
“Of course.”
“And my bird?”
“Certainly.”
Frodo hesitated.
“And the picture of Mama and Papa?”
Thorin's expression softened.
“If you wish.”
The boy nodded.
“I think I do.”
“Then we'll find somewhere safe for it.”
______________
That evening, Bilbo helped Frodo wrap the silver-framed picture in a soft cloth. They placed it carefully among his belongings, together with the wooden fox, the little bird he had carved himself, and the journal in which he had begun recording his uncles' stories.
By the time everything was ready, Frodo's excitement had become almost impossible to contain.
He asked how many days remained until departure every morning.
Sometimes twice.
On the final evening, Bilbo found him sitting upon his bed, examining the little wooden fox.
“Nervous?” Bilbo asked.
Frodo considered.
“A little.”
Bilbo sat beside him.
“That's quite all right.”
“Were you nervous when you went on your adventure?”
Bilbo laughed softly.
“My dear boy, I was absolutely terrified.”
Frodo looked astonished.
“Really?”
“Oh, yes. I had no proper handkerchiefs, no idea where we were going, and thirteen dwarves who seemed determined to get themselves into trouble.”
“Fourteen,” Frodo corrected.
Bilbo smiled.
“Fourteen, if you count Gandalf as an honorary dwarf.”
Frodo giggled.
Then he grew thoughtful.
“Did you want to go home?”
“Very often.”
“But you stayed.”
Bilbo nodded.
“I did.”
“Why?”
Bilbo considered the question.
“Because somewhere along the way, the people I was travelling with became very important to me.”
Frodo looked toward the doorway, where Thorin's voice could be heard discussing the final arrangements with a neighbour.
“Especially Uncle Thorin?”
Bilbo smiled.
“Especially Uncle Thorin.”
Frodo leaned against him.
After a while, he whispered, “I'm glad you're both coming with me.”
Bilbo kissed his curls.
“So am I, sweetheart.”
____________
They departed Bag End beneath a pale autumn sky.
The morning was crisp enough that Frodo's breath appeared in little clouds, and the grass glittered with frost along the edges of the lane.
Several neighbours had come to see them off.
Mrs. Goodbody pressed a parcel of biscuits into Frodo's hands, insisting that growing boys required proper food while travelling. Rosie gave him a small ribbon to tie around his journal, and two of the children who regularly visited Thorin's workshop made him promise to tell them everything about the Mountain when he returned.
Thorin received several enthusiastic embraces from elderly hobbit women who reminded him to wear warm clothing and not to forget his meals.
Bilbo watched with unconcealed delight.
“I see you're very popular, darling.”
Thorin adjusted the strap of his travelling bag.
“I am beginning to suspect these women believe I am incapable of looking after myself.”
“An understandable concern.”
“Bilbo.”
His husband smiled.
Frodo giggled.
Then, with the last farewells exchanged, they set off along the road.
For Frodo, the first few days were a revelation.
He had travelled before, of course. Buckland and Hobbiton were not entirely unfamiliar to him, and he knew the roads between several neighbouring settlements.
But travelling with his uncles was different.
There was no hurried schedule, no expectation that he must behave as though he were older than eleven, and no one who grew impatient when he stopped to examine something interesting.
Thorin had arranged for comfortable transport where the roads allowed, and they travelled at a pace that suited all three of them. Sometimes Frodo walked beside the wagon, sometimes he rode, and occasionally Thorin lifted him onto a sturdy pony for short stretches under careful supervision.
Bilbo insisted upon proper meals.
Thorin insisted upon proper rest.
Frodo insisted upon asking approximately a hundred questions before luncheon.
By the fourth day, he had already filled several pages of his journal.
He drew trees, bridges, distant hills, and a particularly stubborn pony that had refused to cross a shallow stream until Thorin bribed it with an apple.
He also attempted to sketch his uncles.
Bilbo's portrait was recognisable.
Thorin's was considerably less flattering.
The dwarf examined it one evening beside the fire.
“Why is my nose so large?”
Frodo looked concerned.
“Is it too big?”
Bilbo leaned over.
“Oh, no. I think it's remarkably accurate.”
Thorin turned toward him.
“Do you?”
“Quite.”
Frodo giggled.
Thorin handed back the journal.
“Perhaps tomorrow we shall practise drawing mountains.”
______________
As the days passed, the Shire gradually fell behind them.
The roads became less familiar. The fields stretched farther between settlements, and the hills grew taller beneath the changing sky.
They stayed at inns whenever possible, choosing warm rooms and generous suppers over unnecessary hardship. Thorin knew too well what difficult journeys could become when pride persuaded travellers to ignore comfort.
There were evenings when Frodo fell asleep before finishing his supper, his head resting against Bilbo's shoulder.
Other nights, he remained awake long enough to demand another story.
“Uncle Thorin?”
The dwarf looked up from the fire.
“Yes, lad?”
“Did Uncle Bilbo really save you from spiders?”
Bilbo, who had been quietly reading, lowered his book.
“Oh, dear.”
Thorin smiled.
“He did.”
“All of you?”
“Every one of us.”
Frodo turned toward Bilbo.
“By himself?”
Bilbo cleared his throat.
“Well, there were certain advantages to being rather small.”
“And rather brave,” Thorin added.
Bilbo's cheeks warmed.
“And rather fortunate.”
“Fortune had little to do with it.”
Frodo considered this.
“Were the spiders enormous?”
“Terribly,” Bilbo said.
“Bigger than dogs?”
“Much bigger.”
Frodo shuddered.
“I don't think I'd like that forest.”
“Neither did I,” Bilbo admitted.
Thorin reached across the space between their chairs and took his husband's hand.
“But you brought us through it.”
Bilbo smiled at him.
Frodo watched them for a moment, then returned to his journal and carefully wrote down that Uncle Bilbo had fought giant spiders.
Underneath, he added that Uncle Thorin said Bilbo was very brave.
He underlined the sentence twice.
_____________
Not every evening was quite so cheerful.
One night, after they had been travelling for nearly two weeks, Frodo became unusually quiet.
They had stopped at a comfortable inn, where a cheerful fire burned in the common room and the innkeeper's children were playing a game near the hearth.
Frodo watched them for a while.
Then he asked to go upstairs.
Bilbo followed a few minutes later.
He found the boy sitting upon the edge of his bed, holding the little silver-framed picture of his parents.
“Hello, sweetheart.”
Frodo looked up.
“Hello, Uncle Bilbo.”
Bilbo sat beside him.
“Missing them?”
Frodo nodded.
For a while, neither spoke.
Then the boy whispered, “Papa always said he'd take me travelling when I was older.”
Bilbo felt his chest tighten.
“Did he?”
“He said we'd go somewhere far away. Maybe even see the mountains.”
Frodo looked down at the picture.
“I wish he could come.”
Bilbo gently put an arm around him.
“I know, my dear.”
“I'm having fun,” Frodo said, sounding almost apologetic.
“I'm glad.”
“But sometimes I think about how they aren't here.”
Bilbo kissed his curls.
“Then you can think about them. You don't have to stop enjoying the journey.”
Frodo leaned against him.
A little later, Thorin joined them carrying three mugs of warm milk.
He listened while Frodo told him about Drogo's promise.
Then the dwarf settled into the chair beside the bed.
“Your father sounds like a hobbit who appreciated a good adventure.”
Frodo smiled faintly.
“He did.”
“Then perhaps he'd have enjoyed hearing about yours.”
The boy looked toward his journal.
“Do you think so?”
“I do.”
Frodo considered this.
Then he opened the journal and began writing about the places they had seen.
Bilbo remained beside him.
Thorin stayed until the fire had burned low.
And when Frodo finally fell asleep, the little silver picture rested safely upon the bedside table.
______________
Rivendell appeared before them in a wash of autumn gold and silver.
Frodo had imagined it many times.
He had pictured towers and bridges, enormous trees, and elves wearing shining robes. He had imagined waterfalls tumbling down mountainsides and songs drifting through the air.
Yet none of those imaginings quite prepared him for the sight of the valley opening beneath them.
The Last Homely House stood among trees whose leaves shimmered in the afternoon light. Waterfalls spilled down the cliffs, their distant thunder mingling with birdsong and the gentle murmur of the river.
Frodo stared.
“Oh.”
Bilbo smiled.
“Rather beautiful, isn't it?”
Frodo nodded without taking his eyes from the view.
“It's like a story.”
Thorin glanced toward the valley.
“It is a fine place.”
Bilbo turned toward him with exaggerated surprise.
“Was that a compliment?”
The dwarf raised an eyebrow.
“I am capable of appreciating elven architecture.”
“Of course you are, darling.”
Frodo giggled.
They descended into the valley as the sun began to sink behind the mountains.
Their arrival caused considerably less confusion than their eventual arrival at Erebor would.
The elves recognised Bilbo and Thorin, and word was quickly sent to Lord Elrond.
Before long, they were welcomed into a beautiful hall where warm lamps glowed beneath carved wooden beams.
Elrond greeted them with the composed warmth of someone who had witnessed many extraordinary things and was therefore not easily surprised.
“Bilbo Baggins,” he said, smiling. “And Thorin Oakenshield. It is a pleasure to welcome you both again.”
Bilbo bowed.
“Lord Elrond. You're very kind to receive us.”
Thorin inclined his head respectfully.
“We are grateful for your hospitality.”
Elrond's gaze moved between them.
Then he noticed the small hobbit standing beside Bilbo, staring up at him with enormous blue eyes.
“And who is this young traveller?”
Bilbo smiled proudly.
“This is Frodo, our nephew. He's recently come to live with us.”
Frodo immediately remembered his manners.
He stepped forward and gave a very serious little bow.
“Good evening, my lord.”
Elrond's expression softened.
“Good evening, Frodo. Welcome to Rivendell.”
“Thank you.”
“Have you travelled far?”
Frodo nodded.
“From Hobbiton.”
“A considerable journey for one so young.”
Frodo hesitated.
Then he asked, “Are you really thousands of years old?”
Bilbo closed his eyes.
Thorin looked toward the ceiling.
Elrond blinked.
Then, to Frodo's enormous relief, he laughed.
“I am indeed rather older than most people you will meet.”
Frodo stared.
“Do you remember dragons?”
“Some.”
“Real ones?”
“Very real.”
Frodo looked as though he might faint from excitement.
Bilbo sighed.
“I do apologise. He's been asking questions since we left Bag End.”
Elrond smiled.
“Then I suspect we shall get along very well.”
_____________
They were given comfortable rooms overlooking the gardens, and after supper Frodo was invited to listen to the evening music.
He sat between his uncles in a beautiful hall filled with soft golden light.
Elven voices rose and fell around them, weaving melodies that seemed to carry the memory of distant forests, ancient kingdoms, and stars reflected upon quiet water.
Frodo listened in complete fascination.
Occasionally, he leaned toward Bilbo to whisper a question.
Sometimes Bilbo answered.
Sometimes Thorin did.
And sometimes Elrond, seated nearby, offered an explanation that made the boy's eyes grow even wider.
Later, when the music had ended, Frodo was shown a collection of beautifully illustrated books.
He examined drawings of mountains, rivers, and ancient cities with such reverence that one of the elves quietly brought him a stool so he could see the higher shelves.
Bilbo watched him with a smile.
“He reminds me of someone,” Elrond remarked.
Bilbo glanced toward him.
“Does he?”
“A certain hobbit who once arrived here rather unwillingly, yet proved himself capable of remarkable courage.”
Bilbo blushed.
Thorin smiled.
“That hobbit is still rather remarkable.”
Elrond's eyes warmed.
“So I have observed.”
_____________
Before they retired for the night, Elrond presented Frodo with a small notebook bound in deep blue leather.
Its pages were thick and smooth, suitable for both writing and drawing.
“For your travels,” he explained.
Frodo accepted it with both hands.
“Thank you, Lord Elrond.”
“You may find that the world contains more wonders than even your uncles have managed to describe.”
Frodo looked toward Bilbo and Thorin.
“I think it does.”
That night, before going to bed, Frodo stood upon a balcony overlooking the valley.
The air was cool, and the stars shone brightly above the distant mountains.
Bilbo joined him, wrapping a warm cloak around his shoulders.
“Beautiful, isn't it?”
Frodo nodded.
After a moment, he whispered, “I wish Mama and Papa could have seen this.”
Bilbo rested a hand upon his shoulder.
“I think they would have loved it.”
Frodo looked down at the notebook Elrond had given him.
“Maybe I can draw it.”
“A wonderful idea.”
“Then I'll remember.”
Bilbo smiled.
“Yes, sweetheart. You will.”
Thorin appeared a little later, carrying an extra blanket and looking mildly displeased to discover that both hobbits were standing outside in the cold.
“Are you two planning to spend the entire night admiring the stars?”
Bilbo smiled.
“Only until you came to rescue us.”
Thorin sighed.
Frodo giggled.
And together, they returned to the warmth of their rooms.
______________
They departed Rivendell the following morning.
Elrond provided fresh provisions and advice concerning the roads ahead. Winter was approaching quickly, and several higher routes had already become difficult.
Thorin listened carefully.
He had no intention of taking unnecessary risks, particularly with Frodo accompanying them.
They adjusted their route accordingly, choosing safer roads and stopping whenever the weather demanded it.
The weeks that followed were filled with changing landscapes.
Frodo saw mountains rising against the sky, rivers winding through broad valleys, and forests whose trees seemed older than anything he had ever known.
He filled pages of his new notebook with drawings.
Some were remarkably good.
Others were less successful.
His first attempt at drawing a mountain looked suspiciously like a large potato.
Thorin examined it.
“An improvement upon my first bear.”
Frodo laughed.
Bilbo insisted upon keeping the drawing.
______________
As they travelled farther east, Frodo began asking more questions about Erebor.
He wanted to know whether the halls were truly filled with gold, whether dwarves slept underground, and whether Fíli wore a crown every day.
“No,” Thorin answered.
“Why not?”
“Because crowns are uncomfortable.”
Frodo considered this.
“Did you wear one?”
“When necessary.”
“Did you like it?”
Thorin smiled faintly.
“Not particularly.”
Bilbo glanced toward him.
“Your uncle was always much happier with a hammer in his hand than a crown upon his head.”
Thorin looked at his husband.
“Some things are more useful than others.”
Bilbo smiled.
Frodo wrote that down.
_______________
By the time they approached the lands surrounding the Lonely Mountain, the air had grown noticeably colder.
Snow lay upon the distant peaks, and the wind carried the sharp scent of approaching winter.
They were fortunate.
The roads remained passable, and the final stages of their journey passed without serious difficulty.
Then, one clear afternoon, Frodo saw it.
At first, he thought it was another mountain.
A particularly enormous one.
But Thorin slowed beside him and pointed toward the horizon.
“There, lad.”
Frodo followed his gaze.
The Lonely Mountain rose above the surrounding lands, its vast slopes stretching toward the clouds.
For several moments, the boy said nothing.
Then he whispered, “That's Erebor?”
Thorin nodded.
“Yes.”
Frodo stared.
“It's enormous.”
Bilbo smiled.
“It certainly is.”
“People live inside that?”
“Thousands of them,” Thorin answered.
Frodo looked up at his uncle.
“Did you really grow up there?”
Thorin's expression changed.
For a moment, he seemed to be looking not merely at the Mountain before them, but at something much farther away.
“Yes,” he said quietly. “I did.”
Bilbo reached for his hand.
Thorin squeezed it.
Frodo continued staring at the distant peaks.
Then he opened his notebook.
He tried to draw the Mountain.
After several minutes, he frowned.
“It won't fit.”
Bilbo looked over his shoulder.
“What won't?”
“The Mountain.”
Thorin chuckled.
“Then perhaps you'll need a larger page.”
Frodo considered this seriously.
“I think I need a much larger book.”
______________
The gates of Erebor were busy when they arrived.
Merchants were unloading wagons, guards were inspecting supplies, and dwarves moved through the broad entrance carrying crates, tools, and bundles of winter provisions.
Frodo watched everything with enormous curiosity.
Then Thorin approached the guards.
The first dwarf looked up.
For a moment, his expression remained perfectly ordinary.
Then his eyes widened.
He straightened so abruptly that the spear in his hand nearly struck the guard beside him.
“Your Majesty!”
Several nearby dwarves turned.
Thorin inclined his head.
“Good afternoon.”
The guard stared.
Bilbo smiled pleasantly.
Frodo looked between them.
“Is something wrong?” Thorin asked.
“N-no, Your Majesty! Of course not! We simply—”
The guard looked toward his companion.
His companion looked equally astonished.
“We weren't informed of your arrival.”
Thorin frowned.
“I sent a letter weeks ago.”
The guards exchanged another glance.
Bilbo's smile faltered slightly.
He leaned toward his husband.
“Darling,” he murmured, “I don't think they received our letter.”
Thorin looked at him.
Then back at the guards.
“I see.”
The first guard looked increasingly distressed.
“Please forgive us, Your Majesty. Had we known—”
“There is nothing to forgive,” Thorin interrupted. “Though I would appreciate knowing whether my nephews are presently in the Mountain.”
“Both of them, Your Majesty.”
“Excellent.”
The guard straightened.
“We shall escort you inside immediately.”
Thorin nodded.
“Thank you.”
Bilbo took Frodo's hand as they passed through the enormous gates.
The boy looked up at the towering stone walls, the vast pillars, and the golden light spilling from the halls beyond.
His mouth fell open.
“Uncle Thorin…”
The dwarf glanced down.
“Yes, lad?”
“It's even bigger inside.”
Thorin smiled.
“You haven't seen half of it yet.”
______________
The guards led them through the magnificent halls, past startled dwarves who stopped in their tracks upon recognising their former king.
Whispers followed them.
Some bowed.
Others simply stared.
Thorin grew increasingly puzzled.
Bilbo, meanwhile, was beginning to suspect that their missing letter had caused rather more confusion than either of them had anticipated.
At last, they reached the corridors leading toward the royal study.
One of the guards hurried ahead.
“His Majesty is occupied with Lord Kíli,” he explained. “But I shall inform him immediately.”
Thorin nodded.
“Very well.”
Frodo tightened his grip upon Bilbo's hand.
“Uncle Bilbo?”
“Yes, sweetheart?”
“Are they going to be angry?”
Bilbo looked down in surprise.
“Whatever for?”
“Because we came without telling them.”
Bilbo smiled gently.
“Oh, my dear. We did tell them. It seems our letter simply never arrived.”
Thorin rested a reassuring hand upon the boy's shoulder.
“My nephews will be pleased to see us.”
Frodo nodded.
Then he looked toward the enormous doors at the end of the corridor.
He could hear voices beyond them.
Rather loud voices.
He glanced up at Thorin.
“Are they always that noisy?”
The dwarf listened for a moment.
Then he sighed.
“Unfortunately, yes.”
________________
More than an hour earlier, King Fíli had begun to suspect that his younger brother was deliberately attempting to shorten his life.
This was not an entirely new suspicion.
Kíli had been testing the limits of his patience since the day he learned to walk, and Fíli had long since accepted that being an older brother involved a certain amount of suffering.
Being King under the Mountain, however, had added several entirely new varieties of suffering to the arrangement.
At present, most of them were spread across his desk.
Maps.
Supply reports.
Letters from merchants.
Requests from settlements.
Military patrol schedules.
And one particularly unpleasant account of a caravan that had been attacked near the northern pass.
Fíli sat behind his desk, rubbing the bridge of his nose.
Kíli stood opposite him, leaning over a large map.
They had been discussing the matter for more than an hour.
At first, the conversation had been perfectly civil.
Kíli had arrived with reports from his captains, and Fíli had listened carefully while his brother explained the difficulties facing the northern patrols.
The first snowfall had arrived earlier than expected in several higher regions. Merchants were attempting to move goods before the roads became impassable, while smaller settlements depended upon regular deliveries of grain, tools, medicine, and winter clothing.
The problem was not simply that the roads were dangerous.
It was that there were too many roads, too many caravans, and not enough soldiers to protect all of them.
Fíli studied the map.
“How many men are currently stationed along the northern pass?”
“Forty-eight,” Kíli answered.
“And how many are available to reinforce them?”
“Another twenty, provided we pull them from the western patrols.”
Fíli frowned.
“That would leave the western road exposed.”
“Less exposed than the northern pass.”
“The western road supplies three settlements.”
“And the northern pass carries twice as many merchants.”
Fíli leaned back in his chair.
“Merchants who have been warned repeatedly not to travel without escorts.”
Kíli folded his arms.
“Warnings don't stop desperate people from taking risks.”
“I am aware.”
“Then you understand why we need more soldiers.”
Fíli looked toward the map again.
“I understand why you want them. That does not mean I can produce them out of thin air.”
Kíli sighed.
For a while, they continued discussing alternatives.
They considered shortening patrol routes, moving soldiers between outposts, and requesting assistance from neighbouring settlements.
Fíli rejected the idea of withdrawing guards from the eastern storehouses.
Kíli rejected the suggestion that merchants simply wait until spring.
Neither decision was unreasonable.
Both brothers knew it.
That was what made the matter so frustrating.
Fíli was responsible for the entire kingdom. He had to consider food reserves, trade agreements, the safety of settlements, and the number of soldiers available should a greater threat appear.
Kíli, meanwhile, had spent enough time travelling those roads to know precisely how dangerous they could become.
He had seen overturned wagons.
He had spoken with wounded merchants.
He had stood beside soldiers who had returned from patrols with fewer companions than they had taken out.
He was not willing to dismiss those dangers as an unfortunate inconvenience.
Eventually, Fíli reached for his tea.
It had gone cold.
He drank it anyway.
“Kíli,” he said, attempting patience, “I cannot assign an entire company to escort every merchant who wishes to cross the northern pass.”
“I haven't asked you to.”
“You've asked for thirty additional soldiers.”
“Because thirty would be sufficient to reinforce the road.”
“For how long?”
“Until the final caravans have passed.”
“And what happens when another settlement requests assistance?”
Kíli leaned forward.
“Then we deal with it.”
Fíli stared at him.
“That is not a plan.”
“It is better than leaving the caravans undefended.”
“They are not undefended!”
“Forty-eight soldiers spread across that entire route might as well be!”
Fíli set down his cup.
The sound was sharper than he intended.
For a moment, the brothers glared at one another.
Then Kíli sighed and straightened.
“Look, Fíli. I'm not trying to make your life difficult.”
His older brother gave him a long look.
“An astonishing claim.”
Kíli ignored that.
“I know what you're worried about. But if we lose another caravan, the merchants will stop using the road entirely. Then the settlements won't receive anything.”
Fíli looked down at the map.
He knew his brother was right about that.
But there were other dangers.
“If I move those soldiers north,” he said, “I risk leaving the western settlements without protection. And if the weather worsens, we may not be able to move them back quickly enough.”
Kíli frowned.
“Then we need another approach.”
“We have been searching for another approach for over an hour.”
“And we haven't found one.”
“Thank you for the observation.”
“You're welcome.”
Fíli closed his eyes.
For one brief, unreasonable moment, he missed being a prince.
Not because he regretted becoming king.
He loved Erebor. He loved his people. He took his responsibilities seriously, perhaps more seriously than anyone except his uncle had expected.
But there were days when he missed being able to bring an impossible problem to Thorin and ask what he thought.
Thorin had always possessed an infuriating talent for seeing possibilities that others overlooked.
He had also possessed an equally infuriating talent for making those possibilities sound obvious.
Fíli sighed.
Kíli noticed.
“What?”
“Nothing.”
“You're making that face.”
“What face?”
“The one you make when you're thinking about throwing me out of a window.”
Fíli looked at him.
“Kíli, we're underground.”
“Then I suppose I'm safe.”
“Regrettably.”
Kíli grinned.
For a moment, the tension eased.
Then Fíli looked at the map again.
“We still need a solution.”
His brother's smile faded.
“I know.”
They returned to the reports.
_______________
Another quarter of an hour passed.
Then someone knocked upon the study door.
Fíli barely looked up.
“Enter.”
A guard stepped inside.
“Your Majesty, forgive the interruption, but there are visitors—”
“Not now.”
The guard hesitated.
“Your Majesty, I really think you should—”
“Kíli, if we move the western patrols, how quickly can they reach the northern pass?”
“Two days. Three if the weather worsens.”
The guard cleared his throat.
“Your Majesty?”
Fíli looked up, irritation flashing across his face.
“What?”
“There are visitors who—”
“Unless the Mountain is collapsing, the treasury is burning, or Smaug has somehow returned from the dead, I do not have time for visitors!”
The guard froze.
Kíli glanced toward him.
Then back at his brother.
“You could at least hear him out.”
Fíli stared at him.
“We are in the middle of a rather important discussion!”
“And perhaps the visitors have something important to say.”
“Then they can wait!”
The guard looked increasingly miserable.
He opened his mouth.
Closed it.
Then glanced desperately toward the corridor.
Because standing just beyond the doorway was Thorin Oakenshield.
_____________
The former King under the Mountain had heard enough of the conversation to understand precisely what his nephews were arguing about.
And judging by the expression upon his face, he was not particularly impressed that they had spent over an hour circling a problem whose solution was now beginning to seem rather obvious.
Bilbo stood behind him.
His lips were pressed together in a determined attempt not to smile.
Thorin stepped forward.
“You're both overlooking the obvious.”
Kíli frowned.
He had been holding a rolled military report, one end resting against the map.
“Who—”
Thorin continued before he could finish.
“Keep the northern pass open for supply caravans. Send the merchants through in smaller, guarded groups rather than allowing them to travel independently. Station your scouts above the ravine, where they can observe the approaches, instead of spreading your soldiers along the entire road.”
He glanced at the map.
“Use the existing patrols to escort each group through the most dangerous section, then send them back for the next. You'll protect the settlements, keep the merchants moving, and avoid stripping the western road of its defences.”
For a moment, nobody spoke.
Kíli stared at the map.
It was a good solution.
A remarkably good solution.
It addressed the concerns both brothers had spent the past hour arguing about.
And it had been delivered in a voice that Kíli knew better than almost any other.
He slowly raised his head.
The report slipped halfway from his fingers.
He caught it at the last moment.
His mouth fell open.
Fíli, meanwhile, had chosen precisely the wrong moment to take another sip of tea.
He looked toward the doorway.
Saw the dwarf standing there.
And promptly nearly choked.
He coughed violently, nearly spilling the cup across his desk.
Kíli remained frozen.
Thorin raised an eyebrow.
“Do try not to drown yourself, Fíli. I would hate to discover that the King under the Mountain was defeated by a cup of tea.”
Bilbo, standing just behind his husband, covered his mouth.
His shoulders were shaking.
Fíli set down the cup with considerable difficulty.
He stared.
Kíli finally managed to speak.
“U-Uncle?”
Thorin folded his arms.
“Hello, lads.”
Bilbo stepped into view beside him, smiling broadly.
“Hello, boys. I see we're interrupting something.”
Fíli looked from Thorin to Bilbo.
Then back again.
His expression suggested that his mind had temporarily abandoned all useful functions.
Thorin glanced once more at the map.
“Of course, that is merely my suggestion. The decision is yours, Fíli. You're the king.”
Fíli blinked.
Kíli looked as though he might drop his report again.
Thorin waited.
Neither brother moved.
At last, the dwarf sighed.
“Well? Are neither of you going to greet your uncle?”
