Actions

Work Header

The Road Back to You — The Life They Dreamed Of

Summary:

Five years after leaving the crown behind, Thorin Oakenshield has found something he never expected: a peaceful life in the Shire, a workshop full of curious little hobbits, and a husband who never misses an opportunity to tease him.

With Yule approaching, Thorin and Bilbo decide it's time to visit their family in Erebor. But as winter draws near, an ordinary holiday journey may bring a few unexpected surprises.

After all, the best adventures aren't always the ones you plan

Notes:

Okay, I admit it… I just couldn't say goodbye to these two yet

After everything Thorin and Bilbo have been through, I think they (and we!) deserve a little peace, happiness, and some good old domestic fluff. No battles, no heartbreaking drama, no world-ending problems. Just two husbands enjoying the life they fought so hard to have, surrounded by family, love, and a little bit of chaos.

So here we are, back with our favourite dwarven king and his beloved hobbit. I hope you're not tired of them yet, because I'm certainly not!

Enjoy this little Yule special!

Chapter 1: Chapter One — The Teddy Bear of Hobbiton

Chapter Text

The first frost of autumn had arrived in Hobbiton three mornings earlier, settling over the gardens and fields like a fine dusting of silver. It clung to the hedgerows until well after sunrise, turned the fallen leaves beneath the trees brittle beneath passing feet, and left the round windows of Bag End misted along their edges. Beyond the Hill, the countryside stretched away beneath a pale blue sky, its rolling fields dressed in shades of amber, russet, and fading green. Smoke rose lazily from the chimneys of neighbouring hobbit-holes, carrying the familiar scents of burning oak, freshly baked bread, and the comforting promise of a warm breakfast.

Inside Bag End, Bilbo Baggins was beginning to suspect that his husband had forgotten the meaning of the word breakfast.

He stood in the kitchen with a wooden spoon in one hand and a dishcloth draped over his shoulder, surveying the table he had laid nearly half an hour earlier. There were eggs, mushrooms fried in butter, thick slices of toasted bread, and a small dish of blackberry preserves. The tea had been brewed, poured, and subsequently abandoned long enough to require warming again.

There was, however, no Thorin.

Bilbo glanced toward the open kitchen window, through which came the distant sound of hammering.

He sighed.

Five years.

Five peaceful, wonderful years since Thorin Oakenshield had surrendered the crown of Erebor to his nephew and settled permanently in the Shire. Five years of shared breakfasts, quiet evenings, walks beneath the stars, and the occasional disagreement over matters of absolutely no importance.

And somehow, despite having once commanded armies and governed a kingdom, Thorin remained entirely incapable of arriving at the breakfast table when summoned.

"Thorin!" Bilbo called through the window.

The hammering stopped.

"Yes?"

"Your breakfast!"

"One moment!"

Bilbo looked at the clock.

That was precisely what Thorin had said fifteen minutes earlier.

He considered shouting again, decided that doing so would only encourage his husband to insist he was nearly finished, and instead set down his spoon.

A moment later, he stepped outside.

The air was sharp enough to make him draw his cardigan more tightly around himself. He followed the little stone path around the side of Bag End, passing the herb garden and the low fence that separated their property from the neighbouring meadow.

There, beside the garden gate, he found Thorin kneeling on the grass.

The former King under the Mountain had a hammer in one hand, a collection of iron hinges beside his knee, and the expression of a dwarf engaged in work of tremendous importance.

The gate itself lay on the ground.

Bilbo stopped.

"Darling."

Thorin glanced over his shoulder, dark hair slipping across one cheek. Silver had begun to thread more noticeably through his temples over the years, although Bilbo privately thought it suited him rather splendidly.

"Good morning."

"Good morning," Bilbo repeated. "Might I ask what happened to our gate?"

"The lower hinge was loose."

"Was it?"

"Yes."

Bilbo regarded the dismantled gate.

"And naturally, the only possible solution was to remove the entire thing."

"The frame had begun to warp."

"Thorin, that gate has been standing perfectly well since before I was born."

"Which explains why it requires maintenance."

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

He had married a very stubborn dwarf.

Of course, this was hardly a recent discovery.

"Well, I do hope the gate appreciates your dedication," he said, "because your eggs certainly do not."

Thorin glanced toward the house, then at the unfinished work.

"I shall be there shortly."

"You shall be there now."

"Bilbo—"

"Thorin."

The dwarf considered him for a moment.

Then, with a sigh of long-suffering resignation, he placed his hammer in the toolbox and rose.

Bilbo smiled triumphantly.

"Wonderful. And do wash your hands. I have no intention of finding sawdust in the butter again."

"That happened once."

"Twice."

"The second occasion was not sawdust."

"It was wood shavings."

"A distinction worth making."

"Not at the breakfast table."

Thorin's mouth twitched.

As they walked toward Bag End, Bilbo slipped his hand into his husband's. Thorin's fingers closed around his automatically, warm and roughened from years of working with metal and wood.

It was such a familiar gesture now that neither of them gave it much thought.

There had been a time when Bilbo would have considered it impossible to imagine Thorin Oakenshield living peacefully beneath the Hill. Back then, the dwarf had seemed carved from the same stone as the mountains he loved: proud, unyielding, and burdened by responsibilities that left little room for anything else.

Yet here he was, complaining about a garden gate.

Bilbo squeezed his hand.

Thorin looked down at him.

"What?"

"Nothing, darling."

"You're smiling."

"Am I not permitted?"

"Not when it usually means you're thinking something troublesome."

Bilbo laughed and leaned up to kiss his cheek.

"Come and eat your breakfast, Your Majesty."

Thorin groaned.

"Do not start."

Unfortunately for him, Bilbo had no intention of stopping.

______________

 

Bag End had changed considerably since Thorin first came to live there.

Not in any way that would have offended Bilbo's fondness for his ancestral home, of course. The round green door remained exactly as it had always been, the polished brass knob still shone in the morning sunlight, and the familiar rooms retained their comfortable abundance of books, cushions, rugs, and well-loved furniture.

But there were signs of Thorin everywhere.

The shelves in the study had been strengthened and extended to accommodate Bilbo's ever-growing collection of books. The kitchen cupboards now possessed beautifully carved wooden handles, each decorated with a different leaf or flower. A small table beside the sitting-room hearth bore a pattern of interlocking dwarven knots along its edges, while the bedroom wardrobe had been rebuilt after Thorin declared its original hinges an insult to competent craftsmanship.

Bilbo had objected to that last improvement until he discovered that his husband had secretly carved their initials into the inside of one of its doors.

He had not objected afterward.

There were other changes, too.

A second coat hung beside Bilbo's near the entrance, considerably broader through the shoulders. Heavy boots stood beneath the bench, and a collection of dwarven books occupied a shelf in the sitting room. A silver-framed portrait of Fíli and Kíli, sent from Erebor two winters earlier, stood upon the mantelpiece beside a small wooden box containing their wedding beads.

And behind Bag End, where an old storage shed had once stood, there was now a workshop.

It had begun modestly enough.

Thorin had merely wanted somewhere to keep his tools.

Then he had required a larger workbench.

Then additional shelves.

Then a proper ventilation system for the little forge he intended to install.

By the end of their first year in the Shire, the storage shed had become a sturdy, handsome building with stone foundations, broad windows, and a chimney of its own.

Bilbo had watched the transformation with increasing amusement.

He had also insisted upon a comfortable armchair beside the window.

Thorin had questioned the necessity of placing upholstered furniture in a workshop.

Bilbo had informed him that if his husband intended to spend entire afternoons there, he should at least provide somewhere pleasant for his husband to sit.

The chair remained.

Indeed, it had become one of Thorin's favourite features, though he would never have admitted it.

Sometimes Bilbo spent hours there with a book, listening to the steady rhythm of hammering or the gentle scrape of a carving knife against wood. Sometimes they talked. Sometimes they shared a companionable silence, broken only when Thorin asked him to pass a tool or Bilbo reminded him that luncheon was approaching.

And sometimes, neither of them managed much work at all.

For Thorin's workshop had acquired a rather unexpected reputation throughout Hobbiton.

It had become the place where things were fixed.

And, perhaps more importantly, where little hobbits went when they wanted to see something wonderful.

_______________

 

By the time Thorin finished breakfast that morning, a small collection of visitors had already begun gathering outside.

He discovered them when he returned to the workshop carrying his toolbox.

Three little faces were peering through the nearest window.

The moment he looked in their direction, all three disappeared.

Thorin stopped.

He waited.

Slowly, a head covered in unruly brown curls rose above the windowsill.

Then another.

Then a third.

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

The heads vanished again.

He opened the workshop door.

"If you intend to spend the morning inspecting my windows, I ought to charge you for the privilege."

A burst of giggles came from the other side of the wall.

A little boy emerged first, followed by two girls wrapped in thick autumn coats.

"Good morning, Master Thorin!" the boy announced.

"Good morning, Pippin."

This was Peregrin Took, a freckled lad of seven who had appointed himself the unofficial inspector of Thorin's woodworking projects.

"Are you making another dragon?"

"Perhaps."

"Does it breathe fire?"

"Not unless something has gone terribly wrong."

The children laughed.

One of the girls, Daisy Cotton, pointed toward the small wooden step beneath the window.

"Can we watch?"

Thorin glanced at the step.

He had built it the previous spring after discovering muddy footprints on the outside wall. The younger children had been attempting to climb high enough to see over the windowsill, and one particularly determined little girl had nearly toppled into the flowerbed.

The step had solved the problem.

Naturally, Thorin maintained that it existed solely to protect Bilbo's flowers.

"You may come inside," he said. "Provided you remember the rules."

"No touching sharp things!" Pippin recited immediately.

"No running near the forge," Daisy added.

"And we mustn't bother you when you're holding hot metal," supplied the youngest girl, Rosie.

"Very good."

"Can we have the blankets?"

Thorin looked at her.

"Are you cold?"

Rosie nodded.

"Then you needn't ask."

He stepped aside, allowing the children to hurry into the workshop.

____________

 

The room smelled pleasantly of wood shavings, beeswax, and the faint metallic tang of the forge, which had not yet been lit that morning. Sunlight streamed through the broad windows, illuminating rows of neatly arranged tools and shelves crowded with half-finished projects.

There were wooden horses awaiting painted saddles, tiny foxes with curling tails, rabbits, birds, and several dragons in varying stages of completion.

One particularly ambitious dragon occupied the highest shelf, its wings spread wide and its long tail curling around a miniature mountain.

Thorin had been working on it for nearly a fortnight.

Pippin considered it the finest thing ever made.

Beside the little stove stood a wooden chest filled with thick woollen blankets. Thorin opened it and handed one to each child before settling onto his stool.

The children arranged themselves upon the cushioned bench he had built along the wall.

Rosie wrapped her blanket around her shoulders until only her nose remained visible.

Pippin leaned forward.

"What are you making today?"

Thorin selected a piece of pale wood from his workbench.

"A bird."

"What kind?"

"You shall have to wait and see."

"An eagle?"

"Perhaps."

"A chicken?"

"Possibly."

"A dragon?"

"Dragons are not birds."

"They have wings."

"So do bats."

Pippin considered this with great seriousness.

"Could you make a bat?"

Thorin sighed.

"I suspect I shall never finish anything at this rate."

Yet he was smiling as he picked up his carving knife.

By late morning, the workshop had acquired three more children, an elderly hobbit gentleman with a broken cupboard door, and Mrs. Goodbody, who had come to collect the rocking chair Thorin had repaired the previous week.

Bilbo discovered the gathering when he stepped outside carrying a tray.

He had known perfectly well what would happen.

Indeed, he had prepared accordingly.

The tray held a large pot of hot chocolate, several small mugs, and a plate piled high with freshly baked biscuits. A second pot contained tea for the adults, along with a little jug of milk and a bowl of sugar.

Bilbo nudged the workshop door open with his elbow.

"Good heavens. I see we've opened a public establishment."

Six little faces turned toward him.

"Master Bilbo!"

"Hot chocolate!"

"Biscuits!"

"Now, now," Bilbo laughed, carefully setting down the tray. "One at a time, please. There is quite enough for everyone."

Thorin looked up from his workbench.

"You spoil them."

Bilbo gave him a pointed look.

"Says the dwarf who has built an entire chest of toys for them."

"Those are practice pieces."

"Of course they are, darling."

"And the children happen to enjoy them."

"Pure coincidence, I'm sure."

Mrs. Goodbody chuckled from her chair near the stove.

"Oh, leave him be, Bilbo. The dear fellow is entitled to his little hobbies."

Thorin gave her a grateful nod.

"Thank you, madam."

"Such a sweetheart, isn't he?" she continued, turning toward Mrs. Proudfoot, who had arrived moments earlier. "Just look at him, surrounded by the little ones. Like a great big teddy bear."

Thorin's gratitude vanished.

Bilbo nearly spilled the hot chocolate.

"Mrs. Goodbody," Thorin began carefully, "I hardly think—"

"Oh, don't be modest, dear."

"I am not being modest."

"Such lovely thick hair, too," Mrs. Proudfoot observed. "And that handsome beard. He looks quite cuddly."

Bilbo turned away.

His shoulders began to shake.

Thorin stared at his husband.

"Bilbo."

"Yes, darling?"

"Do something."

Bilbo cleared his throat with tremendous difficulty.

"I'm afraid I don't see the problem."

"I was once King under the Mountain."

"Yes, dear," Mrs. Goodbody replied cheerfully. "And now you're our Thorin."

That silenced him.

Only briefly, but enough for Bilbo to notice.

The elderly hobbit woman seemed entirely unaware that she had said anything remarkable. She merely accepted her cup of tea and settled more comfortably in her chair.

Thorin looked down at the little wooden bird in his hands.

Then he resumed carving.

______________

 

Bilbo watched him for a moment, his amusement softening into something warmer.

He had seen Thorin receive honours from kings, accept the loyalty of armies, and stand beneath the great banners of Erebor while thousands bowed before him.

Yet somehow, being claimed so casually by an elderly hobbit woman appeared to have left him more thoroughly speechless than any royal ceremony.

Bilbo loved him rather desperately.

"Master Thorin?"

Rosie had approached his workbench, clutching her mug in both hands.

"Yes, little one?"

"Can I sit with you?"

Thorin set down his knife.

"Have you finished your chocolate?"

"Nearly."

"Then finish it first. I won't have you spilling it on yourself."

Rosie obeyed with considerable determination.

A minute later, she handed Bilbo her empty mug and climbed carefully onto Thorin's knee.

The dwarf steadied her automatically, settling one broad arm around her waist before returning his attention to the wooden bird.

"Now," he said, "where were we?"

"The wings!"

"Ah, yes. The wings."

Mrs. Goodbody watched them with a fond smile.

"See?" she whispered to Mrs. Proudfoot. "A teddy bear."

Thorin pretended not to hear.

Unfortunately, he heard everything.

______________

 

The trouble began shortly before luncheon.

Bilbo had just finished discussing the merits of replacing the pantry shelves with Mr. Burrows when a familiar, rather sharp voice sounded from the path.

"Well! I must say, this is quite a sight."

Bilbo closed his eyes.

He knew that voice.

He had known it for far too many years.

Lobelia Sackville-Baggins stood just beyond the workshop door, her expression suggesting that she had discovered something deeply improper.

She wore a dark green travelling cloak and carried a small handbag, which she held with the air of a weapon that might be deployed at any moment.

Her gaze moved across the workshop.

The children.

The blankets.

The biscuits.

The elderly women.

And finally Thorin, who still had Rosie sitting comfortably upon his knee.

Lobelia's mouth tightened.

"Bilbo," she said, "I had hoped to find you at home."

"You have found me at home, Lobelia."

"In your husband's workshop."

"Which happens to be part of our property."

"Yes, well." She sniffed. "I wished to speak with you about the boundary hedge."

Bilbo sighed inwardly.

The boundary hedge had been a subject of disagreement between various branches of the Baggins family for longer than he cared to remember.

"I'm afraid this is hardly the time."

Lobelia appeared not to hear him.

Her attention had returned to Thorin.

"Goodness gracious. Are those children actually allowed in here?"

Thorin looked up.

"Good afternoon, Mrs. Sackville-Baggins."

Lobelia acknowledged him with a stiff nod.

"Master Oakenshield."

Bilbo recognised the tone immediately.

It was the tone Lobelia used when she intended to be unpleasant while maintaining the appearance of perfect respectability.

"Yes," Bilbo answered, "the children are allowed here. They visit quite often."

"Extraordinary."

"Is it?"

"Well, surely you must understand my concern."

Bilbo's smile faded.

"And what concern would that be?"

Lobelia gestured vaguely toward Thorin.

"He's a dwarf, Bilbo."

There was a pause.

Thorin glanced down at himself.

"So I have been informed."

Pippin giggled.

Lobelia frowned.

"A very large dwarf, at that. All that hair, those great heavy boots, and goodness knows what sort of dreadful tools he keeps lying about."

"The tools are put away when the children visit," Thorin replied evenly.

"That hardly addresses the matter."

"What matter?" Bilbo asked.

Lobelia drew herself up.

"I have heard stories."

Bilbo felt his patience begin to fray.

"Have you?"

"Indeed. Stories about battles and axes and all manner of dreadful violence. Why, I've been told your husband was once a warrior!"

"I was," Thorin said.

Lobelia looked almost triumphant.

"There! You see?"

Bilbo stared at her.

"See what, precisely?"

"Well, surely a man who has spent so much of his life fighting cannot be expected to have a particularly gentle disposition."

The workshop grew quiet.

Even the children seemed to sense the change in atmosphere.

Lobelia continued, apparently encouraged by the silence.

"I have heard he fought orcs, and goblins, and even a dragon! And now he sits here surrounded by perfectly innocent little hobbits. I cannot imagine what their parents are thinking."

Thorin placed his carving knife carefully upon the workbench.

Rosie shifted on his knee.

He rested a reassuring hand against her back.

"Mrs. Sackville-Baggins," Bilbo began, his voice dangerously calm, "I suggest you consider your next words very carefully."

But Lobelia had never been particularly skilled at recognising warnings.

"Honestly, Bilbo, you cannot expect everyone to overlook his nature simply because you've married him. He may behave pleasantly enough in company, but who knows what he's like when no one is watching? I shouldn't be surprised if the poor children were frightened half to death of him."

Bilbo went very still.

Across the room, Thorin's expression changed.

Not dramatically.

He did not rise, raise his voice, or reach for any of the tools upon his workbench.

But the warmth that had softened his features throughout the morning disappeared.

For a moment, Bilbo saw something of the king who had once stood before hostile armies, his face composed into that familiar, unreadable mask.

"That," Bilbo said quietly, "is quite enough."

"Oh, don't be so sensitive—"

"Lobelia."

The sharpness in his voice made her blink.

"You are speaking about my husband. In his own home. In front of children who adore him. And I will not have you suggesting that he might harm them."

Lobelia opened her mouth.

She never got the chance to answer.

"Lobelia Sackville-Baggins!"

Mrs. Goodbody's voice rang through the workshop with such authority that even Thorin turned toward her.

The elderly hobbit woman had risen from her chair.

She was not particularly tall, even by hobbit standards, and her silver hair was arranged in a neat bun beneath a little blue bonnet.

Nevertheless, she looked formidable.

"I have listened to quite enough of that nonsense."

Lobelia stared.

"Mrs. Goodbody, surely you—"

"Don't you surely me, young lady."

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

He had not expected this.

Neither, judging by his expression, had Thorin.

Mrs. Proudfoot rose beside her friend.

"Honestly, Lobelia. You ought to be ashamed."

"Ashamed?" Lobelia repeated indignantly. "For expressing concern?"

"For insulting a perfectly respectable gentleman," Mrs. Proudfoot answered.

Lobelia gave a disbelieving laugh.

"Respectable? He's a dwarf!"

"And you're a hobbit," Mrs. Goodbody replied. "Yet I don't see anyone accusing all hobbits of having your manners."

Bilbo made a small choking sound.

Thorin lowered his head.

It was difficult to tell whether he was embarrassed or attempting not to smile.

Possibly both.

"I merely meant," Lobelia continued, her cheeks colouring, "that someone with such a violent history—"

"Has spent the past five years helping half this village," Mrs. Proudfoot interrupted. "He repaired my cupboards when the hinges broke, made me a new walking stick when my old one cracked, and carried a sack of flour all the way home for me when my back was troubling me."

"And he fixed my rocking chair," Mrs. Goodbody added.

"He built my grandson a little wooden horse."

"And my granddaughter a doll's cradle."

"He repaired the bridge railing near the mill!"

"And refused to accept payment for it!"

"Well, that hardly—"

"Furthermore," Mrs. Goodbody continued, raising her voice, "I have never once heard Master Thorin speak unkindly to a child. Not once. Even when they ask him the same question twenty times in a row."

Pippin looked vaguely guilty.

Thorin glanced at him.

The boy smiled sheepishly.

Lobelia's expression had become increasingly strained.

"That does not change the fact that he has killed things!"

Mrs. Goodbody folded her arms.

"And what of it?"

The question caught Lobelia entirely off guard.

"What?"

"Did you imagine those orcs he fought were coming to invite everyone to tea?"

Bilbo's shoulders began to shake.

Mrs. Proudfoot nodded firmly.

"I've heard the stories too, Lobelia. About that terrible dragon and the battle beneath the Mountain. From what I understand, Master Thorin fought to protect his people."

"He did," Bilbo said softly.

Mrs. Goodbody looked toward Thorin.

"Being capable of fighting doesn't make someone cruel. Sometimes it means they know exactly what they're protecting."

The words settled over the room.

Thorin's expression changed again.

This time, the severity left his face.

He looked at the elderly hobbit woman for a long moment, as though uncertain what to say.

Mrs. Goodbody seemed to mistake his silence for embarrassment.

"Oh, don't look so solemn, dear. We're defending you."

Thorin blinked.

"Madam, I—"

"And you needn't worry yourself about it."

"I wasn't—"

"Now, now."

She patted his shoulder.

Thorin Oakenshield, who had once negotiated with kings and stood against armies, fell silent beneath the gentle authority of a hobbit grandmother.

Bilbo was going to remember this for the rest of his life.

Lobelia, however, had not finished.

"Well, I still wouldn't trust him with children."

At that, Rosie lifted her head.

She had been listening quietly from Thorin's knee, her small brow furrowed in confusion.

"Why?"

Lobelia looked at her.

"Because, dear, he might frighten you."

Rosie considered this.

Then she turned toward Thorin, who was watching her with a rather troubled expression.

"Master Thorin?"

"Yes, little one?"

"Are you frightening?"

For a moment, Thorin seemed unable to answer.

Bilbo felt something tighten painfully in his chest.

Then Thorin brushed a stray curl away from Rosie's eyes.

"That depends," he said gently. "Have I frightened you?"

Rosie shook her head.

"No."

"Then I suppose we have our answer."

She smiled and settled against his chest again.

"You're warm."

Mrs. Goodbody made a delighted little noise.

"Just like a teddy bear!"

Thorin closed his eyes.

"Please, madam."

"Well, you are."

Lobelia looked as though she might explode.

Bilbo, meanwhile, had reached the limits of his restraint.

"Lobelia," he said pleasantly, "I believe you came to discuss the hedge."

"Yes, and—"

"Wonderful. You may write to me about it."

"But—"

"Good afternoon."

She stared at him.

Then at the elderly women.

Then at Thorin, who had returned to helping Rosie examine the little wooden bird.

With an offended sniff, Lobelia turned on her heel and marched down the garden path.

Nobody moved until she had disappeared around the corner.

Then Mrs. Proudfoot sighed.

"That woman could sour a whole barrel of cider simply by looking at it."

Bilbo burst out laughing.

Even Thorin could not quite suppress his smile.

Mrs. Goodbody returned to her chair, looking thoroughly satisfied.

"Honestly. Coming here and insulting our Thorin."

"Our Thorin?" the dwarf repeated.

"Of course, dear."

He looked helplessly toward Bilbo.

Bilbo smiled sweetly.

"I'm afraid you've been claimed, darling."

Thorin sighed.

And Rosie, still sitting on his knee, patted his beard.

"Don't worry, Master Thorin. I think you're a very nice teddy bear."

The former King under the Mountain stared at the ceiling.

"Someone," he muttered, "please fetch my crown. I appear to have misplaced all authority."

______________

 

By late afternoon, the visitors had gradually returned to their own homes.

The children departed with their blankets neatly folded, their pockets full of biscuits, and two new wooden animals between them. Mrs. Proudfoot left carrying her repaired walking stick, while Mrs. Goodbody insisted upon giving Thorin a small jar of plum preserves in gratitude for his work.

Thorin protested.

Mrs. Goodbody ignored him.

Bilbo accepted the preserves on his behalf.

Once the workshop had fallen quiet, Bilbo returned with a fresh pot of tea.

He found Thorin standing beside the workbench, carefully placing the unfinished bird upon a shelf.

For a moment, Bilbo simply watched him.

The late afternoon sunlight caught the silver in his hair and softened the strong lines of his face. His sleeves were still rolled up, and a little sawdust clung to his waistcoat.

There had been a time when Bilbo feared he might never see Thorin look so peaceful.

He crossed the room and slipped his arms around his husband's waist from behind.

Thorin's hands settled over his.

"Hello, ghivashel."

"Hello, my love."

Bilbo rested his cheek against Thorin's back.

They stood together in comfortable silence.

Eventually, Bilbo spoke.

"I'm sorry about Lobelia."

Thorin exhaled.

"You needn't apologise for her."

"She had no right to say those things."

"No."

Bilbo tightened his embrace.

"Did she upset you?"

Thorin considered the question.

"I've been called worse."

"That isn't what I asked."

A faint smile touched the dwarf's mouth.

"No," he admitted. "It isn't."

He turned carefully within Bilbo's arms, resting his hands upon his husband's shoulders.

"I am not troubled by her opinion of me. There have always been those who see a dwarf and decide they know everything worth knowing."

Bilbo frowned.

"That doesn't make it acceptable."

"I know."

Thorin glanced toward the empty bench where the children had spent the morning.

"But I would be lying if I said her words meant nothing. I do not like the thought of anyone believing those children unsafe in my company."

Bilbo's expression softened.

"Oh, Thorin."

"They trust me."

"Of course they do."

"And I would never—"

"I know."

Bilbo reached up and cupped his cheek.

"I know, darling."

Thorin covered his hand with his own.

For a little while, neither spoke.

Then Bilbo smiled.

"Besides, I believe Mrs. Goodbody made her opinion perfectly clear."

Thorin groaned.

"That woman is terrifying."

Bilbo laughed.

"More terrifying than Smaug?"

"Considerably. Smaug could at least be reasoned with."

"Thorin!"

"Very briefly."

Bilbo laughed harder.

Thorin drew him closer, pressing a kiss into his curls.

"I never expected this," he admitted after a moment.

Bilbo tilted his head.

"What?"

"Any of it."

His gaze travelled around the workshop, lingering upon the little wooden animals, the blankets beside the stove, and the comfortable chair by the window.

"When I first came here, I thought I would always be a stranger in your Shire. A dwarf among hobbits. An old king with no kingdom left to govern."

Bilbo opened his mouth to protest, but Thorin shook his head gently.

"I do not mean that I regret leaving Erebor. I never have."

He looked down at his husband.

"But I never imagined your people would welcome me as they have. That they would come to me with their broken furniture and their troublesome gates. That their children would sit in my workshop and ask me to carve them dragons."

His voice grew quieter.

"That they would call me one of their own."

Bilbo felt his throat tighten.

"Well," he said, attempting a smile, "you are rather difficult not to love."

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

"I recall you finding it quite easy to dislike me when we first met."

"Oh, you were insufferable."

"I was?"

"Utterly."

"And yet you married me."

"A momentary lapse in judgement."

Thorin laughed softly and kissed him.

It was a slow, familiar kiss, full of the comfortable affection of two people who had spent years learning the shape of one another's lives.

When they parted, Bilbo rested his forehead against Thorin's.

"You know," he murmured, "I rather like our life."

"So do I."

"Even with the broken gates?"

"Especially with the gates."

"And the children peering through your windows?"

Thorin smiled.

"Especially them."

Bilbo kissed him once more.

"Come along, my great big teddy bear. Supper won't cook itself."

Thorin stared at him.

"Bilbo."

"Yes, darling?"

"If you call me that again—"

"What will you do?"

Thorin considered him for a moment.

Then he swept Bilbo into his arms.

Bilbo gave a startled laugh as his feet left the floor.

"Thorin!"

"I believe," the dwarf announced, carrying him toward the door, "that I shall demonstrate precisely how frightening I can be."

"By carrying me into the kitchen?"

"By refusing to put you down."

"Well, that's hardly a punishment."

Thorin's smile widened.

"Then perhaps I shall have to think of something else."

Bilbo wrapped his arms around his neck.

"Promises, promises."

Their laughter followed them all the way back to Bag End.

_______________

 

The letters arrived the following morning.

Bilbo was sorting through the post when he discovered a thick envelope bearing the familiar seal of Erebor.

He smiled immediately.

"Thorin! There's a letter from Fíli!"

His husband appeared from the sitting room carrying a cup of tea.

"Only one?"

"One envelope."

Bilbo turned it over.

"A rather heavy envelope."

Thorin stopped.

His expression became suspicious.

"How heavy?"

Bilbo weighed it in his hand.

"Enough that I suspect Kíli has something to do with it."

Thorin sighed.

"Naturally."

They settled at the kitchen table, where Bilbo had already prepared breakfast.

Thorin broke the seal and unfolded the first sheet of parchment.

His expression softened as he recognised his eldest nephew's handwriting.

"Well?" Bilbo prompted.

Thorin cleared his throat.

"'Dear Uncle Thorin and Bilbo. I hope this letter finds you both in good health and that the autumn weather has been kind to the Shire. Mother sends her love and wishes to remind you that neither of you has visited nearly often enough.'"

Bilbo smiled.

"That sounds like Dís."

"'Balin remains well, although he continues to insist upon correcting my historical references during council meetings. Dwalin has recently expanded the training programme for the younger guards, and Glóin reports that trade with Dale has improved considerably since the summer.'"

"Wonderful."

Thorin continued.

"'The western mines have exceeded their expected output, and the new agreements with the Iron Hills have been received favourably. I am pleased to report that the kingdom continues to prosper.'"

He paused.

A small, unmistakably proud smile appeared upon his face.

Bilbo noticed.

He always noticed.

"He's doing well," Bilbo said softly.

"Very well."

Thorin looked at the letter for another moment before continuing.

"'Unfortunately, I cannot say the same for my brother's understanding of administrative responsibility.'"

Bilbo's eyebrows rose.

"Oh, here we go."

Thorin sighed.

"'Kíli has once again rearranged the guard rotations without consulting the captain of the watch. While I acknowledge that his proposed changes may improve efficiency, I would appreciate it if he remembered that there is a proper procedure for such matters.'"

Bilbo reached for his tea.

"That doesn't sound entirely unreasonable."

"'Furthermore, he has taken to arriving at council meetings with breakfast.'"

Bilbo blinked.

"Breakfast?"

Thorin continued grimly.

"'Not a piece of bread or a cup of tea, which I might have overlooked. An entire tray. Yesterday he brought sausages, eggs, and a pot of honey, which he proceeded to spill upon a trade agreement awaiting my signature.'"

Bilbo began to laugh.

Thorin closed his eyes.

"That boy."

"Keep reading!"

"'When informed that the council chamber was not a dining hall, he replied that perhaps our meetings would be more productive if everyone were properly fed.'"

Bilbo nearly choked on his tea.

"Well, he has a point!"

"Bilbo."

"He does!"

Thorin shook his head and returned to the letter.

"'I would also be grateful if you could remind him that the royal stables are not an appropriate place to conduct archery competitions, regardless of how impressive he believes his aim to be.'"

Bilbo was laughing openly now.

"And here I thought Kíli might have grown sensible with age."

"He has not."

"'I love my brother dearly,'" Thorin read, "'but there are days when I begin to understand why you occasionally looked as though you wished to throw us both into the nearest river.'"

Thorin lowered the parchment.

Bilbo grinned.

"Did you?"

"Frequently."

"How dreadful."

"Particularly when they were young."

"Poor boys."

"They once filled my boots with river stones."

Bilbo stared at him.

Then he burst out laughing again.

Thorin continued with the expression of a dwarf who had suffered greatly.

"Kíli claimed it was Fíli's idea. Fíli claimed he had merely been supervising."

"And which was telling the truth?"

"Neither."

Bilbo wiped his eyes.

"Oh, I do miss them."

Thorin looked down at the letter.

"So do I."

He turned the page.

"'Despite these difficulties, I assure you that Kíli remains invaluable to Erebor. His work with the guards has been excellent, and his suggestions regarding the northern trade routes have already proven useful. I only wish he would occasionally remember that I am his king as well as his brother.'"

Bilbo smiled.

"There. He does appreciate him."

"Of course he does."

Thorin's voice carried the quiet certainty of someone who had raised both young dwarves and knew exactly how deeply they loved one another.

He continued.

"'The first snow has fallen upon the higher slopes, and preparations for Yule will soon begin. Mother has already begun arguing with Bombur over the feast arrangements. I suspect neither will emerge victorious.'"

Bilbo chuckled.

"'Give our regards to your neighbours, and please do not allow Uncle to spend the entire winter working outside without a proper coat. I remember his habits well enough.'"

Thorin frowned.

"Impertinent boy."

Bilbo looked delighted.

"'With love, Fíli.'"

Thorin folded the letter carefully.

For a moment, he simply sat smiling at the parchment.

Then he noticed another sheet tucked inside the envelope.

And another.

And another.

His smile vanished.

Bilbo leaned forward.

"Oh?"

Thorin stared at the pages.

"No."

"What is it?"

"Three pages."

Bilbo's grin widened.

"From Kíli?"

Thorin examined the first page.

"'Dear Uncle Thorin, before you believe a single word my dear brother has written, I feel obligated to provide a more accurate account of recent events.'"

Bilbo clapped a hand over his mouth.

Thorin sighed so deeply that it seemed to come from somewhere near his boots.

"'Firstly, Fíli has become an insufferable old man. Yesterday, he scheduled three council meetings before luncheon. Three. I am beginning to suspect that wearing the crown has damaged his brain.'"

Bilbo dissolved into laughter.

"'Secondly, I did not spill honey upon an important trade agreement. The honey was spilled by Lord Nárin when he attempted to reach across my breakfast tray. I consider this an unfortunate accident caused by poor spatial awareness.'"

Thorin looked at Bilbo.

Bilbo looked back.

Neither spoke.

Then Bilbo whispered, "Poor spatial awareness."

Thorin rubbed his forehead.

"'Thirdly, the archery competition in the royal stables was a perfectly reasonable exercise designed to improve the guards' accuracy under unusual conditions.'"

"Unusual conditions?" Bilbo repeated.

Thorin continued.

"'The fact that one of those conditions involved a goat was entirely incidental.'"

Silence.

Bilbo stared.

"A goat?"

Thorin slowly lowered the letter.

"I am not asking."

"Oh, you must!"

"I absolutely must not."

Bilbo reached across the table and tugged at the parchment.

"Thorin, please."

The dwarf sighed and continued.

"'As for the guard rotations, my changes reduced unnecessary patrol overlaps and allowed the men an additional hour of rest. Fíli eventually agreed with my assessment, although he neglected to mention this in his letter, presumably because admitting I was right would cause him physical discomfort.'"

Bilbo smiled.

"That sounds rather more reasonable."

"It does."

"'I would also like to report that Fíli has taken to reading official documents during supper, answering questions with distracted grunts, and occasionally forgetting that he has already poured himself a cup of tea.'"

Thorin's expression softened slightly.

"'He works too hard, Uncle. I know the kingdom matters to him, and I know he wants to make you proud. But I wish he'd remember that he is allowed to rest occasionally.'"

Bilbo stopped laughing.

For a moment, the kitchen was quiet.

Thorin looked at the words for a long time.

Then he continued more softly.

"'I try to help, even if he thinks I only make matters worse. I hope you know that. I would never let him carry everything alone.'"

Bilbo reached across the table and laid a hand over Thorin's.

The dwarf turned his hand beneath Bilbo's, threading their fingers together.

"They've grown into good men," Bilbo said.

Thorin nodded.

"They have."

He cleared his throat and resumed reading.

"'That said, I maintain that Fíli is an unbearable tyrant who has forgotten how to enjoy himself. If you could write and remind him that laughter is not prohibited by royal decree, I would be most grateful.'"

Bilbo laughed again.

"'Please visit soon. The halls are considerably less entertaining without you, and I miss Bilbo's cooking. Bombur makes excellent food, of course, but he refuses to prepare six separate breakfasts simply because I ask nicely.'"

"Six?" Bilbo exclaimed.

Thorin shook his head.

"'With love, your favourite nephew, Kíli.'"

He paused.

Then read the final line.

"'P.S. If Fíli claims to be your favourite nephew, remember that I am the one who actually writes entertaining letters.'"

Bilbo laughed until his cheeks hurt.

Thorin placed the pages upon the table and stared at them.

For several moments, he said nothing.

Then he muttered, "I cannot imagine where that boy inherited such a dreadful temper."

Bilbo slowly lowered his teacup.

He looked at his husband.

Thorin looked back.

"What?"

"Nothing, darling."

"Bilbo."

"Absolutely nothing."

Thorin narrowed his eyes.

Bilbo smiled serenely.

"I was merely considering the remarkable mysteries of heredity."

"Bilbo."

"Yes?"

"Eat your breakfast."

Bilbo laughed.

_____________

 

The morning passed pleasantly after that.

Thorin returned to his workshop, taking the letters with him to read again during his break, while Bilbo attended to the household accounts and began planning the winter stores.

By late afternoon, the sky had clouded over, and a cold wind stirred the fallen leaves along the garden path.

Bilbo found Thorin sitting in the workshop armchair, Fíli's letter resting open upon his knee.

The forge was cold.

His tools lay untouched.

Bilbo paused in the doorway.

"Darling?"

Thorin looked up.

"Bilbo."

"Are you quite all right?"

"Of course."

Bilbo entered and settled upon the arm of the chair.

He glanced at the letter.

"Thinking about the boys?"

Thorin nodded.

"A little."

Bilbo brushed a loose strand of dark hair away from his husband's face.

"You miss them."

It was not a question.

Thorin looked toward the window.

Outside, the autumn garden lay quiet beneath the fading light.

"I do."

Bilbo waited.

After a moment, Thorin continued.

"Fíli mentioned the snow upon the mountain. I had almost forgotten how early winter comes to Erebor."

Bilbo smiled.

"Hardly surprising. The Shire is rather kinder to us."

"Yes."

Thorin's thumb moved slowly across the edge of the parchment.

"Yule will be upon us before long."

"It will."

"I wonder how Dís is managing the preparations."

"Probably by ordering everyone about."

Thorin chuckled.

"Undoubtedly."

"And Kíli is probably making them twice as difficult."

"Without question."

Bilbo watched him for a moment.

Then Thorin looked up.

"Bilbo?"

"Yes, my love?"

"Would you mind terribly if we spent Yule in Erebor this year?"

Bilbo blinked.

For some reason, he had expected Thorin to take considerably longer to ask.

"Mind?"

Thorin shifted slightly.

"I know we have grown accustomed to celebrating here. And I know the journey is long, particularly in winter. I would not wish to trouble you with—"

"Thorin."

The dwarf stopped.

Bilbo smiled.

"Of course we can go."

Thorin studied him.

"You are certain?"

"Darling, I love our home. I love our quiet winters, our little celebrations, and the fact that I no longer have to worry about you disappearing into a mountain full of dragons."

"That happened once."

"Once was quite sufficient."

Thorin smiled faintly.

"But," Bilbo continued, "I also love your family. Our family. And I rather miss them myself."

Thorin's expression softened.

"Truly?"

"Of course. I haven't had anyone steal food from my plate in months."

"Kíli."

"Naturally."

"Fíli has been known to do it as well."

"Only when he thinks nobody is watching."

They shared a quiet laugh.

Then Bilbo slipped from the arm of the chair and settled into Thorin's lap, resting his hands upon his husband's shoulders.

"Besides," he said, "I think it would be lovely to spend Yule beneath the Mountain again. To see Dís and Balin, and all the others. And I should very much like to see how Fíli is managing his kingdom."

Thorin's gaze warmed with pride.

"He's managing it well."

"I know."

"He has accomplished more in five years than I dared hope."

"And he had a rather excellent teacher."

Thorin shook his head.

"Fíli has become a better king than I ever was."

Bilbo's expression softened.

"Thorin."

"It is not a sorrowful thought," the dwarf assured him. "Quite the opposite."

He glanced toward the letters.

"I spent so many years believing I had to carry everything myself. That the crown, the mountain, the future of our people—all of it depended upon me."

Bilbo rested his forehead against his.

"And now?"

Thorin smiled.

"Now I know I left Erebor in good hands."

Bilbo kissed him gently.

"Then I think we ought to go and remind those good hands that they are allowed to put down their paperwork occasionally."

Thorin laughed.

"Fíli may not appreciate the interference."

"Oh, I don't intend to interfere."

"Bilbo."

"I intend to spoil him."

"That may be worse."

"And Kíli."

"That will certainly be worse."

Bilbo grinned.

"Then it's settled."

Thorin drew him closer.

"Settled."

______________

 

Outside, the wind rustled through the last leaves of autumn.

Inside the workshop, the former King under the Mountain held his husband close and allowed himself to look forward to going home.

Not because Bag End was any less his home.

But because, after everything they had endured, he had been fortunate enough to find that he belonged to more than one place.

They wrote the letter that evening.

Bilbo insisted upon using his best stationery, while Thorin insisted that a perfectly ordinary sheet of parchment would suffice.

Bilbo won.

Naturally.

They sat together at the kitchen table, the fire crackling in the neighbouring sitting room and the smell of freshly baked apple tart lingering in the air.

Bilbo dipped his pen into the ink.

"How shall we begin?"

"'Dear Fíli,'" Thorin suggested.

Bilbo looked at him.

"How imaginative."

"It is his name."

"Yes, darling, I am aware."

Thorin leaned back in his chair.

"Then write whatever you please."

Bilbo smiled and began.

My dear Fíli,

Your latest letter brought us both tremendous pleasure, although I fear your brother's contribution may have caused your uncle to develop a headache.

Thorin frowned.

"I did not develop a headache."

"You rubbed your temples three times."

"That was exasperation."

"An important distinction."

Bilbo continued writing.

We are delighted to hear that Erebor continues to prosper, and we hope you are taking proper care of yourself. Kíli's observations regarding your tendency to overwork have not gone unnoticed.

Thorin nodded approvingly.

"Good."

As Yule is approaching, Thorin and I have decided that it is high time we visited our family. We intend to arrive several days before the celebrations, provided the roads remain passable.

Bilbo paused.

"Anything you'd like to add?"

Thorin considered.

"Tell Fíli I am proud of him."

Bilbo looked up.

There was no hesitation in his husband's expression.

He smiled and wrote the words.

Then Thorin added, "And tell Kíli that if I discover a goat in the royal council chamber, I shall personally assign him to stable duty for a month."

Bilbo laughed.

"That seems rather harsh."

"Not nearly harsh enough."

He finished the letter with a warm message for Dís, Balin, and the rest of the Company, then handed the parchment to Thorin.

The dwarf read it carefully.

At the bottom, beneath Bilbo's signature, he added a few lines in his own strong, angular handwriting.

Fíli,

Your brother is occasionally an idiot, but his concerns regarding your health are not without merit. Remember that a king who never rests eventually becomes a burden to those who must keep him standing.

I look forward to seeing what you have accomplished. You have made me very proud.

And Kíli—leave the goats alone.

With love,

Thorin.

Bilbo read the addition over his shoulder.

Then he wrapped his arms around his husband and kissed his cheek.

"Perfect."

Thorin looked mildly embarrassed.

"It is only a letter."

"Yes," Bilbo said softly. "A very lovely one."

They sealed it together.

______________

 

The following morning, Bilbo entrusted the envelope to a travelling messenger heading east, along with several other pieces of correspondence.

He watched the messenger disappear down the road before returning to Bag End, where Thorin was already making a list of supplies for their journey.

Neither of them knew that a violent storm would strike the eastern roads several days later.

Neither knew that the messenger's satchel would be damaged during a difficult crossing, scattering several letters into the swollen waters of a roadside stream.

And neither knew that their carefully written announcement would never reach Erebor.

For now, there was only the pleasant anticipation of seeing their family again.

That evening, Bilbo found Thorin in the workshop, studying a small piece of polished walnut.

"What are you making?" he asked.

"A gift."

"For whom?"

Thorin glanced at him.

"Fíli."

Bilbo smiled.

"And Kíli?"

Thorin gestured toward another piece of wood upon the workbench.

Bilbo laughed.

"Of course."

He crossed the room and settled into his familiar chair beside the window, opening the book he had brought with him.

Outside, the autumn wind whispered through the garden.

Inside, the workshop was warm and quiet, filled with the gentle scrape of Thorin's carving knife and the occasional rustle of a turning page.

After a while, Bilbo looked up.

"Thorin?"

"Hm?"

"Are you happy?"

The dwarf paused.

He looked around the workshop, at the tools he had collected, the little wooden toys awaiting their owners, and the thick blankets folded beside the stove.

Then he looked at Bilbo.

At the familiar face he had loved through danger and hardship, through years of marriage and countless ordinary mornings.

His expression softened.

"More than I ever believed I could be."

Bilbo smiled.

"Good."

Thorin set down his work, crossed the little room, and bent to kiss him.

And beyond the windows of Bag End, the Shire settled peacefully into another autumn evening, entirely unaware that before winter was over, the household beneath the Hill would be changed forever.

For the moment, there were only two inhabitants of Bag End.

Two husbands, a warm hearth, a workshop full of wooden animals, and a journey to Erebor waiting just beyond the coming frost.

Neither yet knew that, by the time they reached the Lonely Mountain, there would be three.

Chapter 2: Chapter Two — A Little Hobbit Left Behind

Chapter Text

The trouble with preparing for a journey, Bilbo Baggins had discovered, was that his husband considered every possible inconvenience a personal enemy that ought to be defeated before they ever left the front door.

This was particularly unfortunate when the journey in question involved travelling to Erebor in winter.

“I am not packing a third cloak, Thorin.”

“You will be grateful for it when we reach the mountains.”

“I shall be grateful for many things when we reach the mountains. A warm fire, a comfortable bed, and the opportunity to inform your nephews that you have spent the better part of a morning attempting to bury me beneath wool.”

Thorin looked up from the travelling chest he had been inspecting.

“Two cloaks are insufficient.”

“I already possess two cloaks, three waistcoats, four cardigans, and enough stockings to keep half of Hobbiton warm.”

“Your stockings will be of little use if the wind gets beneath your cloak.”

“Then I shall simply have to avoid allowing it to do so.”

“Bilbo.”

“Thorin.”

They regarded one another across the bedroom with the familiar determination of two people who had been married long enough to know that neither was likely to surrender.

Outside, a fine autumn rain pattered against the round windows of Bag End. The garden had grown increasingly bare over the past fortnight, its flowerbeds resting beneath damp leaves while the last stubborn roses bowed beneath the cold. Beyond the Hill, smoke rose from neighbouring chimneys, and the lanes of Hobbiton shone darkly beneath the morning drizzle.

Inside, however, the house was wonderfully warm.

A fire crackled in the sitting room, breakfast had been finished nearly an hour earlier, and the kitchen still carried the comforting scent of cinnamon from the apple cakes Bilbo had baked the previous evening.

It ought to have been a perfectly peaceful morning.

Unfortunately, Thorin had discovered that Bilbo intended to pack only one pair of winter gloves.

“Your hands will freeze,” the dwarf declared.

“My hands have survived winters before.”

“Not in the mountains.”

“I have been to Erebor, darling. You may recall that I accompanied you there on a rather memorable occasion.”

“That was different.”

“How?”

“We were travelling under considerably less comfortable circumstances.”

Bilbo folded his arms.

“Precisely. And somehow, despite goblins, orcs, wargs, and a dragon, I managed not to perish from insufficient gloves.”

Thorin opened his mouth.

Then closed it.

Bilbo smiled triumphantly.

“Wonderful. Now, if we've settled that matter, would you kindly help me decide whether Bombur would prefer blackberry preserves or the spiced plum jam Mrs. Goodbody brought us?”

Thorin stared at him.

“We are travelling across half of Middle-earth, and you intend to carry jars of jam?”

“Of course.”

“Bilbo.”

“Bombur likes my preserves.”

“Bombur likes anything that can be eaten.”

“Then he shall be delighted.”

Thorin rubbed a hand over his face.

Bilbo, who knew that gesture intimately, stepped closer and slipped his arms around his husband's waist.

“Oh, don't look so troubled, my love. We'll manage perfectly well.”

Thorin's hands settled automatically upon his hips.

“I would prefer that we manage without you catching your death in the cold.”

“And I would prefer that you remember I am not made of spun sugar.”

“No,” Thorin agreed, lowering his head until their foreheads touched. “You are considerably more troublesome.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

“And yet you married me.”

“A decision I am reminded of daily.”

“Regretting it?”

Thorin's expression warmed.

“Never.”

He kissed Bilbo gently, lingering just long enough that the hobbit forgot his argument about winter gloves.

Then, while Bilbo was still smiling, Thorin reached past him and placed a third cloak into the travelling chest.

Bilbo stared.

“Thorin Oakenshield!”

The dwarf looked entirely unrepentant.

“What?”

“You impossible creature!”

“I love you too, ghivashel.”

Bilbo was considering whether throwing a pillow at his husband would constitute a reasonable response when the front bell rang.

Both turned toward the sound.

“At this hour?” Bilbo murmured.

Thorin glanced toward the window.

“Perhaps one of the children.”

“Perhaps. Though I hope they haven't come to ask you to repair another toy. You still haven't finished the little horse for Daisy.”

“I have nearly finished it.”

“You said that yesterday.”

“It requires painting.”

“And the day before?”

“It required sanding.”

________________

 

Bilbo shook his head affectionately and left the bedroom.

He made his way down the passage, straightening his waistcoat as he went. The bell rang again before he reached the door, followed by a hurried knock.

“Coming!” he called.

When he opened the green door, he found a young messenger standing beneath the porch, rain dripping from the brim of his cap.

“Morning, Mr. Baggins. Letter for you.”

Bilbo smiled and accepted the envelope.

“Thank you, Tom. Would you like something warm before you go?”

“That's kind of you, sir, but I've several more deliveries.”

“Then at least take a biscuit.”

The boy grinned.

Bilbo disappeared into the kitchen and returned with two, wrapped neatly in a scrap of paper.

“There. One for the road and one for later.”

“Thank you, Mr. Baggins!”

The messenger hurried away through the rain.

Bilbo closed the door, still smiling.

Then he looked at the envelope.

The smile faded.

He recognised the handwriting.

It belonged to one of his Brandybuck relations in Buckland.

That alone was not unusual. Bilbo received letters from his mother's side of the family several times a year, although the correspondence tended to concern births, weddings, family gatherings, and occasionally some disagreement about inheritance that Bilbo had no particular desire to involve himself in.

But something about this envelope troubled him.

Perhaps it was the haste of the handwriting.

Perhaps it was the absence of the usual cheerful greeting upon the outside.

He broke the seal.

By the time Thorin entered the sitting room several minutes later, Bilbo had not moved from where he stood beside the little table near the door.

The letter trembled slightly in his hands.

“Bilbo?”

There was no answer.

Thorin stopped.

He knew his husband well enough to recognise the difference between ordinary distraction and genuine distress.

“Bilbo,” he repeated, more softly.

The hobbit looked up.

His face had gone terribly pale.

For one dreadful instant, Thorin felt the old, familiar coldness of fear settle beneath his ribs.

“What has happened?”

Bilbo swallowed.

“It's Drogo.”

Thorin frowned.

“Your cousin?”

Bilbo nodded.

“And Primula.”

He looked down at the letter again, as though the words might somehow have changed.

“There was an accident.”

Thorin crossed the room.

Bilbo's voice shook.

“They were boating on the Brandywine. Something happened. The boat overturned, and…”

He stopped.

Thorin gently took the letter from his trembling fingers.

He read it quickly.

The words were brief, written with the awkward restraint of someone attempting to deliver unbearable news without making it worse.

Drogo Baggins and his wife, Primula Brandybuck, had drowned.

Their son, Frodo, had been left behind.

Thorin lowered the letter.

“Oh, Bilbo.”

“He's only eleven.”

Bilbo said it so quietly that Thorin almost failed to hear him.

“He's only a little boy.”

Thorin set the parchment aside and gathered his husband into his arms.

Bilbo went willingly, pressing his face against the dwarf's shoulder.

For several moments, he said nothing.

Thorin held him, one broad hand resting between his shoulder blades while the other cradled the back of his head.

He did not tell Bilbo that everything would be all right.

Some things were not all right.

Some things could not be made right by kind words, however sincerely they were spoken.

Instead, he remained there until Bilbo was ready to speak.

“I knew Drogo when he was hardly older than Frodo,” the hobbit murmured at last. “He used to follow me about at family gatherings, asking questions about everything. And Primula…”

His voice faltered.

“She was always so full of life.”

Thorin pressed a kiss into his curls.

“I am sorry, my love.”

Bilbo drew a shaky breath.

“The letter says Frodo is staying at Brandy Hall. They are looking after him, of course. There are plenty of relatives there, and they're good people, but…”

He pulled back slightly.

“Thorin, he's lost both his parents.”

“I know.”

“He must be frightened.”

“Very likely.”

“And everyone will be fussing over him, and asking how he is, and expecting him to answer when he probably doesn't even know himself.”

Thorin brushed a tear from Bilbo's cheek.

“Then perhaps we ought to go to him.”

Bilbo looked up.

“You wouldn't mind?”

“Bilbo.”

“We were meant to be preparing for Erebor, and it's a fair journey to Buckland, and—”

“Erebor can wait a few days.”

Thorin spoke with such simple certainty that Bilbo's eyes filled again.

“We'll go together,” the dwarf continued. “Your family has suffered a terrible loss. You should be with them.”

Bilbo leaned into him once more.

“Thank you.”

Thorin held him a little tighter.

There was nothing to thank him for.

Not really.

________________

 

They left the following morning.

The rain had passed during the night, leaving the countryside washed clean beneath a pale, uncertain sun. Mist lingered over the fields, and the road east was scattered with damp leaves that clung to the wheels of passing carts.

Bilbo had packed only what they needed for several days.

Thorin, to his credit, had refrained from commenting upon the number of cloaks.

Their journey was quieter than most.

Bilbo sat beside his husband in the small hired carriage, watching the familiar Shire countryside pass beyond the window. Occasionally he spoke about Drogo or Primula, recalling some little incident from years before, and Thorin listened without interruption.

He learned that Drogo had possessed an astonishing appetite even by hobbit standards, that Primula had been quick to laugh and quicker still to speak her mind, and that Frodo had inherited his mother's dark curls and his father's fondness for sweet things.

“He visited us once,” Bilbo said as they travelled beneath a stand of yellowing trees. “With his parents. Do you remember?”

Thorin considered.

“Was that the summer when Dwalin came to stay?”

“No, the following spring. You were repairing the garden fence.”

Thorin's expression brightened with recognition.

“Ah. The little boy who asked whether my beard was heavy.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“Yes.”

“He also asked whether I slept wearing my boots.”

“You told him dwarves slept standing upright.”

“I did not.”

“You most certainly did.”

Thorin looked mildly offended.

“I told him that some dwarves could sleep standing upright.”

“Which was entirely untrue.”

“Not entirely.”

Bilbo shook his head.

For a moment, his smile lingered.

Then it faded.

“He was such a cheerful little thing.”

Thorin reached across the seat and took his hand.

“He may be again,” he said gently. “In time.”

Bilbo looked at their joined hands.

“I hope so.”

The carriage continued east.

They crossed the familiar lands of the Shire, passing farms, orchards, and little villages where hobbits hurried about their ordinary business. The world seemed almost painfully unchanged.

Children still played beside garden gates.

Farmers still complained about the weather.

Smoke still rose from chimneys as evening approached.

Somewhere, families were sitting down to supper together.

And in Buckland, an eleven-year-old boy would never again hear his mother call him to the table.

Bilbo turned his face toward the window.

Thorin kept hold of his hand.

________________

 

Brandy Hall was as busy as Bilbo remembered.

The great ancestral home of the Brandybucks sprawled through the hillside in a maze of passages, rooms, stairways, and interconnected halls. Its windows glowed warmly against the grey afternoon, and the familiar sounds of a large household drifted through the corridors: footsteps, distant conversation, the clatter of dishes, and the occasional shriek of children being chased by their siblings.

Yet beneath the ordinary bustle lay a subdued atmosphere.

Voices lowered when Bilbo and Thorin entered.

Relatives greeted them with tired smiles and embraces that lasted a little longer than usual.

Bilbo spoke quietly with the head of the household, offering condolences and asking after Frodo.

“He's being looked after,” came the weary reply. “We've made certain he has everything he needs. But he's hardly himself, poor lad.”

Bilbo nodded.

“May we see him?”

“Of course.”

They were led through several familiar corridors toward a smaller sitting room overlooking the gardens.

The door stood partly open.

Inside, a little hobbit boy sat upon the rug near the hearth.

He had dark curls, pale cheeks, and large blue eyes that seemed far too solemn for someone his age. A small wooden cart lay in his lap, and he was attempting to fit one of its wheels back onto the axle.

Beside him sat a little box containing several other toys.

He did not look up when the door opened.

“Frodo, dear,” their relative said softly. “You have visitors.”

The boy raised his head.

His gaze moved first to Bilbo.

For a moment, he simply stared.

Then he rose.

“Cousin Bilbo?”

Bilbo felt his heart ache.

“Hello, Frodo.”

The boy hesitated.

Bilbo did not rush toward him.

Instead, he crouched slightly and opened his arms.

“If you'd like a hug, my dear, I have one available.”

Frodo stood very still.

Then, slowly, he crossed the room.

Bilbo gathered him close.

The boy's arms went around his neck, not tightly at first, but enough that Bilbo could feel how carefully he was holding himself together.

“Oh, Frodo,” he whispered.

He stroked the child's curls.

“I am so very sorry.”

Frodo said nothing.

Bilbo did not ask him to.

After a while, the boy stepped back.

His eyes moved toward Thorin.

The dwarf had remained near the doorway, giving them space.

Frodo studied him with quiet curiosity.

“You're Thorin.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“I am.”

“You live with Cousin Bilbo.”

“I do.”

Frodo considered this.

Then he said, “You made me a fox.”

Thorin blinked.

“A fox?”

“A wooden one.”

The dwarf searched his memory.

Gradually, a smile appeared.

“Ah. Yes. I remember.”

Frodo's expression softened almost imperceptibly.

“It had a little curled tail.”

“It did.”

“And you painted its nose black.”

Thorin nodded.

“I believe I did.”

Frodo looked down at his hands.

“I still have it.”

Something warm and painful moved through Thorin's chest.

“I'm glad,” he said.

Frodo glanced up again.

“You told stories, too.”

“Did I?”

“About mountains. And a dragon.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“Thorin does rather enjoy telling stories.”

The dwarf raised an eyebrow.

“I recall someone else who has been known to tell a tale or two.”

“Yes, but mine are considerably more sensible.”

“Of course.”

Frodo watched them exchange a familiar look.

For the first time since they had entered the room, the corners of his mouth moved slightly.

Not quite a smile.

But close.

_______________

 

They spent the afternoon with him.

At first, Frodo seemed uncertain what was expected of him.

He answered Bilbo's questions politely, accepted a cup of warm milk when it was offered, and sat quietly beside the hearth while the adults spoke.

Bilbo quickly realised that the boy had grown weary of being asked how he felt.

So he stopped asking.

Instead, he talked.

About the journey from Hobbiton.

About the first frost in their garden.

About the unfortunate discovery that a family of mice had decided to make a home beneath the pantry shelves.

“Thorin was quite convinced that they were attempting to undermine the foundations of Bag End,” Bilbo explained from his armchair.

“I was not.”

“You spent an entire afternoon inspecting the floorboards.”

“Because I found evidence of damage.”

“You found three crumbs.”

“Which had been carried beneath the cupboard.”

Frodo looked between them.

“Did you catch the mice?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Oh, yes. Though I insisted they be taken somewhere safe.”

“They were relocated,” Thorin said.

“To the far end of the garden.”

“Beyond the vegetable beds.”

“Whereupon one of them promptly returned.”

Thorin sighed.

“A remarkably determined creature.”

Frodo looked down at his lap.

A tiny smile appeared.

Bilbo noticed.

He said nothing about it.

Instead, he continued describing the garden.

He told Frodo about the pumpkins that had grown so large that Thorin required a wheelbarrow to move them, the apple tree that had produced an unusually generous harvest, and the stubborn patch of carrots that refused to grow properly.

“Thorin planted them too close together,” Bilbo explained.

“I followed your instructions.”

“You followed half my instructions.”

“The other half were unnecessary.”

“They were the half concerning the distance between the seeds.”

Frodo looked toward Thorin.

“Did they grow?”

“Some of them,” the dwarf admitted.

“Very small carrots,” Bilbo added.

“They were perfectly edible.”

“Darling, one was scarcely longer than my thumb.”

Thorin folded his arms.

“It was an exceptionally flavourful carrot.”

Frodo gave a soft little laugh.

It lasted only a moment.

But Bilbo felt it like a shaft of sunlight breaking through cloud.

The boy's expression grew solemn again almost immediately, as though he had remembered that laughter was something he was no longer certain he ought to enjoy.

Bilbo simply continued speaking.

He did not tell Frodo to smile.

He did not praise him for laughing.

He allowed the moment to pass without making it into something the child might feel obliged to repeat.

Meanwhile, Thorin had noticed something else.

The wooden cart remained in Frodo's lap.

Every few minutes, the boy attempted to push its loose wheel back into place.

Each time, it slipped off again.

Frodo frowned at it.

He tried turning the little peg.

Then pressing harder.

Then examining the axle with increasing frustration.

Thorin watched for a while.

Finally, he shifted from his chair.

“Troublesome wheel?”

Frodo looked up.

He nodded.

“It keeps falling off.”

“May I see?”

The boy hesitated.

His fingers tightened around the cart.

Thorin waited.

He did not reach for it.

After a moment, Frodo held it out.

Thorin accepted it carefully.

The little cart was well made, though years of use had worn the edges smooth. Its wheels were carved from dark wood, and someone had painted a narrow red stripe along the sides.

The broken axle had been repaired before, judging by the tiny marks around the peg.

Thorin turned it over in his hands.

“Ah,” he murmured. “I see the difficulty.”

Frodo leaned forward.

“What is it?”

“The peg holding the wheel has worn down. It no longer fits tightly enough.”

“Can you fix it?”

“I believe so.”

Frodo watched him anxiously.

Thorin glanced toward the little sewing basket resting on a nearby table.

“Though I may require some assistance.”

Frodo blinked.

“Assistance?”

“Yes. My fingers are rather large for delicate work.”

The boy looked at Thorin's broad hands.

Then at his own.

“Mine are small.”

“So they are.”

Thorin smiled.

“Would you care to help?”

Frodo nodded.

________________

 

Bilbo watched from his armchair as Thorin settled upon the rug beside the boy.

He had seen his husband do this countless times in the workshop at Bag End: lowering himself to a child's level, treating some broken toy or difficult little project with the same seriousness he might once have given a piece of royal armour.

Thorin examined the cart again.

“I shall need a little piece of wood,” he said. “Something thin and strong.”

Bilbo rose.

“I believe I saw a box of spare buttons and odds and ends in the cabinet.”

“Would you mind?”

“Not at all.”

He returned a moment later with a small wooden box.

Thorin sorted through its contents until he found a short, narrow piece of hardwood.

“This should do.”

Frodo watched with growing interest.

“Will you make a new peg?”

“Yes. Though first we must make certain the wheel itself isn't damaged.”

He handed the wheel to Frodo.

“Can you turn it over for me?”

The boy obeyed.

“Now, do you see that little crack?”

Frodo leaned closer.

“Yes.”

“It isn't serious. But if we force the peg too tightly, the wood may split.”

“So we have to be careful?”

“Precisely.”

Frodo nodded solemnly.

Thorin smiled.

“A good craftsman knows when to use strength and when to use patience.”

Bilbo raised his eyebrows.

“A lesson you might occasionally remember yourself, darling.”

Thorin glanced up.

“I am perfectly patient.”

Bilbo looked at him.

Thorin looked back.

Frodo, watching them, smiled again.

This time, the smile lasted a little longer.

Thorin borrowed a small knife from the household and carefully shaped the new peg. He explained what he was doing as he worked, occasionally allowing Frodo to examine the wood or hold the wheel steady.

He did not rush.

He did not take over the task completely.

And when the new peg was ready, he guided Frodo through fitting the wheel back into place.

“There,” he said at last.

Frodo turned the wheel.

It spun smoothly.

His eyes widened.

“It works!”

Thorin smiled.

“So it does.”

Frodo rolled the cart across the rug.

The wheel remained firmly attached.

He tried again.

Then a third time.

A little of the tension left his shoulders.

Bilbo leaned forward.

“Splendid! We shall have to recruit you both to repair my garden wheelbarrow.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Your wheelbarrow does not require repairing.”

“It squeaks.”

“That is because you insist upon leaving it outside in the rain.”

“Such accusations.”

Frodo looked down at the cart.

Then he said quietly, “Papa gave it to me.”

The room grew still.

Thorin's hands rested upon his knees.

Bilbo did not move from his chair.

Frodo traced the faded red stripe along the cart's side.

“He made it when I was little.”

Thorin looked at the toy again.

The worn wheels.

The carefully fitted joints.

The little marks left by years of use.

“I thought it looked like something made with love,” he said gently.

Frodo swallowed.

“Papa said it was the fastest cart in Buckland.”

Thorin considered this with appropriate seriousness.

“Did he?”

Frodo nodded.

“He said no other cart could beat it.”

“Well,” Thorin replied, “then we must make certain it remains worthy of its reputation.”

The boy looked up.

“Do you think it will?”

“I believe so. Though I would advise against racing it down any particularly steep hills.”

Frodo stared at him.

Then, very softly, he said, “Papa said that too.”

Thorin's expression warmed.

“Then your father and I were in agreement.”

Frodo looked at the cart for a long moment.

His lower lip trembled.

He did not cry.

Not then.

Instead, he drew the little toy close against his chest.

“Thank you,” he whispered.

Thorin inclined his head.

“You're very welcome, Frodo.”

Bilbo looked away briefly, blinking hard.

Then he cleared his throat.

“Now, speaking of things that require great care, I really must tell you about the biscuits I make for the children who visit Thorin's workshop.”

Frodo glanced toward him.

“Children visit?”

“Oh, constantly.”

Thorin sighed.

“Not constantly.”

“Nearly constantly.”

“They come a few afternoons each week.”

“And several mornings.”

“Bilbo.”

“And occasionally before breakfast.”

Thorin considered this.

“That has happened.”

Bilbo smiled.

“You see, Frodo, your cousin Thorin has somehow become the most popular dwarf in Hobbiton.”

Frodo looked interested.

“Are there many dwarves in Hobbiton?”

“Only one,” Bilbo admitted.

Thorin gave him a long-suffering look.

“An unfair competition.”

“Nevertheless, you are winning splendidly.”

Frodo smiled.

Bilbo continued.

“The children come to watch him carve little animals. Foxes, rabbits, horses, dragons, whatever catches their fancy. In winter, Thorin keeps blankets ready for them, and I bring hot chocolate and biscuits.”

“Chocolate?” Frodo repeated.

“Oh, yes. Proper hot chocolate, with warm milk and a little cinnamon.”

“And biscuits?”

“Of course. It would hardly be a respectable gathering without biscuits.”

Thorin shook his head.

“He spoils them.”

Bilbo smiled serenely.

“And Thorin makes them toys.”

“Practice pieces.”

“Entirely accidental toys, naturally.”

Frodo looked toward the dwarf.

“Do you still make foxes?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“I do.”

Frodo looked down at his cart.

“I like foxes.”

“I remember.”

For a little while, the three of them remained together in the warm sitting room, speaking of gardens, wooden animals, biscuits, and the strange habits of Hobbiton's children.

Frodo did not become cheerful.

He did not forget his parents.

But he listened.

Sometimes he asked questions.

And once, when Bilbo described Mrs. Goodbody calling Thorin a great big teddy bear, he laughed so unexpectedly that even Thorin could not bring himself to object.

_______________

 

They remained at Brandy Hall for several days.

Bilbo spent much of that time with his relatives, sharing memories of Drogo and Primula and helping where he could. There were practical matters to discuss, belongings to sort through, and countless little arrangements that seemed cruelly ordinary beside the enormity of what had happened.

Thorin accompanied him whenever he was wanted.

When he was not, he found useful things to do.

A loose hinge in one of the guest rooms was repaired. A broken chair received a new joint. An elderly Brandybuck gentleman discovered that the dwarf was quite willing to examine the troublesome lock on his study door.

And occasionally, Thorin found himself in the little sitting room with Frodo.

They did not always talk.

Sometimes the boy read while Thorin worked on some small repair.

Sometimes Thorin told him stories.

Not grand tales of battles or the reclaiming of Erebor, though Frodo occasionally asked about the dragon.

More often, Thorin spoke of the Blue Mountains.

He told Frodo about winters when the snow rose higher than the youngest dwarflings, about the enormous kitchens where his nephews had once attempted to steal an entire tray of honey cakes, and about the time Kíli had become convinced that a particularly ill-tempered goat was secretly plotting against him.

Frodo listened with increasing fascination.

“Did the goat really chase him?”

“Across three courtyards.”

“Why?”

“Because Kíli had attempted to feed it a piece of his brother's cloak.”

Frodo stared.

Then he laughed.

Thorin smiled.

“Fíli was considerably less amused.”

“Did he get angry?”

“Very.”

“What happened?”

“He chased Kíli across the same three courtyards.”

Frodo laughed again.

It was a small sound, but a lovely one.

Thorin allowed himself to enjoy it.

He had learned long ago that laughter and grief could live beside one another.

Sometimes they had to.

On the third evening, Bilbo found Frodo sitting beside Thorin near the hearth, listening to a story about a young Fíli attempting to convince his uncle that he was old enough to accompany the warriors on patrol.

Frodo looked up when Bilbo entered.

“Cousin Bilbo?”

“Yes, my dear?”

“Did Thorin really have to carry Fíli home because he fell asleep?”

Bilbo glanced at his husband.

Thorin looked faintly embarrassed.

“Fíli was very young.”

“And very stubborn,” Bilbo added.

“Indeed.”

Frodo smiled.

“Like you?”

Bilbo burst out laughing.

Thorin stared at the boy.

Then, slowly, he smiled.

“I'm beginning to suspect you've been spending too much time with my husband.”

Frodo ducked his head.

But he was still smiling.

That night, long after the household had settled into silence, Bilbo sat upon the edge of the bed in their guest room.

A single lamp burned upon the bedside table.

Outside, the wind stirred the bare branches of the trees, brushing them softly against the window.

Thorin had removed his boots and was folding his travelling clothes when he noticed that Bilbo had been unusually quiet for some time.

He set the clothes aside.

“Bilbo?”

His husband looked up.

“Hm?”

“Something troubles you.”

Bilbo gave a faint smile.

“You always say that.”

“Because I am usually correct.”

“Insufferably so.”

Thorin crossed the room and sat beside him.

For a moment, Bilbo said nothing.

Then he asked, “Do you think Frodo is happy here?”

Thorin considered.

“I think his family is doing everything they can to care for him.”

“Yes.”

“They love him.”

“I know.”

Bilbo looked down at his hands.

“Brandy Hall is a good home.”

“It is.”

“And there are so many people here.”

Thorin waited.

Bilbo twisted his wedding ring gently around his finger.

“Do you think that helps? Having so many people around?”

“For some children, perhaps.”

“And for others?”

Thorin studied his husband.

“For others, it may be overwhelming.”

Bilbo nodded.

He was quiet again.

Then he asked, “Do you remember what Fíli and Kíli were like after their father died?”

Thorin's expression changed.

He had not expected the question, though perhaps he should have.

For a long moment, he looked toward the lamp.

“Yes,” he said softly. “I remember.”

Bilbo turned toward him.

“They were very young, weren't they?”

“Fíli was old enough to understand what death meant. Kíli was younger.”

Thorin's hands rested loosely upon his knees.

“He did not understand why his father had gone away and would not return.”

Bilbo's heart ached.

“What did you do?”

Thorin was silent for a while.

“I tried to help Dís as best I could.”

He gave a faint, humourless smile.

“At first, I thought I ought to have answers. That there must be something I could say to make the boys feel safe again.”

“And was there?”

“No.”

Thorin looked down.

“There was nothing I could say that would give them back their father.”

Bilbo reached for his hand.

Thorin took it.

“Fíli became very serious,” he continued. “Almost overnight. He stopped asking for things. Stopped complaining when he was tired. He tried to help his mother with everything, even tasks he was far too young to manage.”

Bilbo listened quietly.

“He believed he had to be strong for Kíli,” Thorin said. “And for Dís. He thought that if he behaved well enough, worked hard enough, and never caused trouble, perhaps it would make things easier for everyone.”

“That sounds like Fíli.”

“It does.”

Thorin smiled sadly.

“But he was still a little boy. Some nights I would find him awake long after everyone else had gone to bed, trying not to cry because he thought someone might hear.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

“What did you do?”

“I sat with him.”

“Did he talk?”

“Sometimes. Often he didn't.”

Thorin looked toward the window.

“I learned that he did not always need me to say anything. He only needed to know that I would remain until he fell asleep.”

Bilbo squeezed his hand.

“And Kíli?”

A different sort of tenderness entered Thorin's expression.

“Kíli followed me everywhere.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“That sounds like him too.”

“Everywhere,” Thorin repeated. “If I went to the forge, he followed. If I went to speak with Balin, he followed. If I left the room without telling him where I was going, he would come looking.”

“Poor little thing.”

“He was afraid.”

Thorin's voice grew quieter.

“He had lost his father. He did not understand why. And I think some part of him believed that anyone he loved might disappear just as suddenly.”

Bilbo leaned closer.

“What did you do?”

“I let him follow.”

A small smile touched Thorin's mouth.

“Sometimes he sat beside me in the forge for hours, asking questions. Sometimes he fell asleep against my shoulder while I worked. I would carry him back to his bed, and the next morning he would appear at my door again.”

Bilbo wiped at his eyes.

“You must have been very patient.”

Thorin chuckled softly.

“Not always. There were days when both boys tested every scrap of patience I possessed.”

“I can imagine.”

“But I loved them.”

The words were simple.

They carried the weight of years.

“I loved them,” Thorin repeated, “and I wanted them to know that whatever had happened, they were not alone.”

Bilbo looked at him for a long moment.

“You never tried to replace their father.”

“No.”

Thorin shook his head.

“I could not have done so, even if I had wished it. They had a father. They loved him. Losing him did not change that.”

He turned toward Bilbo.

“I only wanted to give them somewhere safe to grow.”

Bilbo lowered his gaze.

The room fell quiet.

Thorin watched him.

He knew that expression.

He knew the way Bilbo worried the edge of his sleeve between his fingers, the way his thoughts seemed to move ahead of his words, the way he asked questions whose answers he had already begun to understand.

Five years of marriage had taught him much about his husband.

But he had known Bilbo's heart long before their wedding.

He had seen it in the wilderness, when the hobbit had offered kindness to strangers and loyalty to those who scarcely deserved it.

He had seen it beneath the Mountain, when Bilbo had risked everything for people who were not his own.

And he saw it now.

Thorin lifted Bilbo's hand and pressed a kiss to his knuckles.

“We could bring him home, you know.”

Bilbo went very still.

He looked up.

“Thorin?”

“Frodo.”

The dwarf spoke gently.

“If he wishes it, and if his family agrees, we could offer him a home at Bag End.”

Bilbo stared at him.

For several moments, he seemed unable to speak.

Then he whispered, “I hadn't even asked.”

Thorin smiled.

“You didn't need to.”

“Darling…”

“I know you, Bilbo.”

His thumb moved slowly across the back of Bilbo's hand.

“I have watched you with him these past few days. And I have listened to the questions you've been asking.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

“I didn't want you to think…”

He stopped.

Thorin waited.

“I didn't want you to think I was deciding something so important without you.”

“You weren't.”

“Or that I expected you to…”

Bilbo swallowed.

“To become his father.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Oh, ghivashel.”

He drew Bilbo closer.

“I do not expect Frodo to look upon me as his father. Nor would I ask him to.”

Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.

“He had a father,” Thorin continued. “One who loved him enough to make him a little wooden cart. One whose words he still remembers.”

Bilbo nodded.

“I know.”

“And nothing we do should ever make him feel that loving his parents is something he must leave behind.”

A tear slipped down Bilbo's cheek.

Thorin brushed it away.

“But I remember what it was to lose family,” he said quietly. “I remember what it was to wake and discover that the world had changed, and that no amount of wishing could make it as it had been.”

His gaze drifted toward the darkened window.

“I remember Fíli and Kíli after their father's death. I remember how frightened they were, even when they tried to hide it.”

He looked back at Bilbo.

“And I remember how much it mattered that they still had people who loved them.”

Bilbo's lips trembled.

“Thorin…”

“I cannot give Frodo back what he has lost,” the dwarf said. “I cannot take away his grief, and I would never presume to take his father's place.”

He smiled faintly.

“But I can give him a warm hearth. A place at our table. Someone to help him mend his toys when they break.”

Bilbo let out a small, shaky laugh.

“And biscuits?”

“An unreasonable number of biscuits, knowing you.”

Bilbo laughed through his tears.

Thorin kissed his forehead.

“I can give him a home where laughter is welcome, even on the days when he feels sad. Where he needn't pretend to be brave all the time.”

He paused.

“And where he will never have to wonder whether someone will come looking for him if he is missing.”

Bilbo pressed his face against Thorin's shoulder.

The dwarf wrapped both arms around him.

For a long while, they simply held one another.

Eventually, Bilbo drew back.

“Are you certain?”

Thorin looked at him.

“Of course.”

“It would change things.”

“Yes.”

“Our routines. Our travels. Everything.”

“Some things.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“We might not have quite so many quiet mornings.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Bilbo, we currently have six children peering through our workshop windows before breakfast.”

“That is true.”

“And you feed half of Hobbiton every other afternoon.”

“Only the hungry half.”

Thorin chuckled.

“I suspect we shall manage.”

Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.

“Do you think he'd want to come?”

“I don't know.”

The honesty of the answer seemed to comfort Bilbo more than any easy reassurance might have done.

“Then we must ask him,” Thorin continued. “When the time is right.”

“And speak with the Brandybucks first.”

“Of course.”

Bilbo nodded slowly.

“I don't want him to feel as though we're taking him away from everyone he knows.”

“Then we won't.”

“We could still visit Buckland.”

“As often as he wishes.”

“And he could write to his relatives.”

“Certainly.”

Bilbo smiled.

“And we could tell him about Erebor.”

Thorin's expression warmed.

“I imagine Kíli would be delighted to have someone new to tell his dreadful jokes to.”

“Oh, goodness.”

“And Fíli would undoubtedly attempt to teach him proper manners.”

“While Kíli undid all his hard work.”

“Precisely.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

Then his expression grew thoughtful.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“What about Yule?”

The dwarf considered.

Their planned journey to Erebor suddenly seemed much less important than it had a week earlier.

“We can postpone it,” he said. “Fíli and Kíli will understand.”

Bilbo nodded.

“Perhaps.”

He was quiet for a moment.

“Though if Frodo did wish to come with us…”

Thorin smiled.

“Then we could ask whether he'd like to see the Mountain.”

Bilbo looked up.

“You wouldn't mind?”

“Bilbo, I spent thirteen months travelling with a hobbit who insisted upon stopping to examine every interesting tree and flower along the road.”

Bilbo gasped.

“I did not insist!”

“You did.”

“I merely appreciated the scenery.”

“You once delayed us because you wished to identify a particularly unusual mushroom.”

“It was a very unusual mushroom.”

Thorin laughed.

“I think I can manage travelling with another curious hobbit.”

Bilbo leaned forward and kissed him.

Then he rested against his chest, listening to the steady beat of his heart.

______________

 

For the first time since the letter had arrived at Bag End, something within him felt a little less helpless.

He still grieved for Drogo and Primula.

He still worried for their son.

And he knew that no amount of kindness could make the coming months easy.

But perhaps there was something they could do.

Something small and ordinary and immeasurably important.

They could open their door.

They could offer Frodo a place beside the fire.

They could let him bring his memories, his sadness, and his father's little wooden cart into a home already full of love.

And perhaps, in time, the sound of a child's laughter would become as familiar in Bag End as the scrape of Thorin's carving knife or the gentle rustle of Bilbo turning a page.

“Thorin?” Bilbo whispered.

“Hm?”

“Thank you.”

The dwarf tightened his arms around him.

“For what?”

“For knowing what I was trying to ask.”

Thorin kissed his hair.

“I shall always try to listen, ghivashel. Even when you haven't found the words.”

Bilbo smiled against his chest.

Outside, the wind moved softly through the trees surrounding Brandy Hall.

Somewhere farther along the corridor, a door opened and closed. A child laughed briefly before being hushed, and the great household settled once more into its nightly quiet.

In another room, Frodo Baggins slept with a little wooden cart resting upon the table beside his bed.

Its wheel no longer wobbled.

And though the boy did not know it yet, two people were lying awake nearby, thinking about how they might offer him something no broken toy could ever fully represent.

Not a replacement for what he had lost.

Not a promise that he would never be sad again.

Only a place where he could be loved.

A place where he could be a child.

A place where, when he was ready, he might begin to feel at home.

Chapter 3: Chapter Three — A Place at Our Table

Chapter Text

The first thing Bilbo Baggins discovered about offering a child a home was that the matter required considerably more courage than facing a dragon.

A dragon, at least, could be reasoned with—or distracted, or robbed, or, in particularly unfortunate circumstances, fled from at considerable speed. Bilbo had some experience with all three possibilities.

But sitting across from Saradoc Brandybuck in a comfortable parlour at Brandy Hall, with a cup of tea growing cold between his hands and Thorin seated beside him, Bilbo found himself struggling to arrange even the simplest words.

Fortunately, his husband had never been particularly troubled by difficult conversations.

“We would like to offer Frodo a home,” Thorin said.

Bilbo turned toward him, simultaneously grateful and mildly offended that the dwarf had managed in one sentence what he had spent the better part of ten minutes attempting to explain.

Saradoc looked between them.

“You mean to take him to Hobbiton?”

“If he wishes it,” Bilbo answered quickly. “Only if he wishes it. We wouldn't dream of making such a decision without asking him.”

“And you mean permanently?”

Bilbo glanced at Thorin.

The dwarf gave his hand a reassuring squeeze beneath the table.

“Yes,” Bilbo said. “If that's what Frodo wants.”

Saradoc leaned back in his chair.

Beyond the window, the gardens of Brandy Hall lay beneath a thin veil of morning mist. Somewhere in the corridors, a young hobbit was being scolded for running indoors, and the smell of fresh bread drifted faintly from the kitchens.

For several moments, Saradoc said nothing.

Then he sighed.

“I won't pretend the thought hasn't crossed our minds.”

Bilbo blinked.

“It has?”

“Frodo has always been fond of you, Bilbo. More than some of his other relations, I think. He's spoken about visiting Bag End before, and these past few days…” Saradoc paused, looking toward the door. “Well, he's been talking more since you arrived.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“He's a dear little boy.”

“He is. And we love him very much.”

“We know that,” Thorin said.

Saradoc regarded the dwarf thoughtfully.

“I hope you understand that this isn't a matter of whether we're willing to care for him.”

“Of course,” Thorin replied. “He has a family here. A large one, and one that clearly loves him.”

“Then why?”

Thorin considered the question.

“Because perhaps there is room for him to have another home as well.”

Saradoc's expression changed slightly.

Thorin continued, his voice quiet but certain.

“We have no intention of separating Frodo from the people he knows. He should be free to visit, write letters, and remain part of this household. Nor would we ever ask him to forget his parents.”

Bilbo nodded.

“We only thought that Bag End might be somewhere a little quieter for him. Somewhere he could settle without quite so much happening around him.”

Saradoc gave a weary smile.

“Brandy Hall has never been particularly good at quiet.”

From somewhere beyond the door came a tremendous crash, followed by a child's indignant declaration that it had not been his fault.

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

Saradoc sighed.

“An excellent demonstration.”

The three of them shared a small smile.

Then Saradoc grew serious again.

“Have you thought about what it means? Raising a child?”

Bilbo straightened.

“We have.”

“It's a considerable responsibility.”

“I know.”

“And Frodo isn't simply a child who needs feeding and clothing. He's grieving. There will be difficult days.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“I helped my sister raise her sons after their father died.”

Saradoc looked at him.

“Fíli and Kíli?”

“Yes.”

“I've heard Bilbo speak of them.”

“Then you have likely heard far too many stories about their mischief.”

“Not nearly enough, according to Bilbo.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“They were young when they lost their father. I remember what that grief looked like. I remember how differently they carried it.”

He glanced toward Bilbo.

“We cannot promise Frodo that he will never be unhappy. But we can promise that he will not have to face his unhappiness alone.”

Saradoc was quiet for a long while.

At last, he nodded.

“Then I think we ought to ask him.”

_______________

 

Frodo was in the small sitting room when Bilbo found him.

The little wooden cart rested beside his knee, its repaired wheel turning smoothly whenever he pushed it across the rug. He had a book open in his lap, although he appeared to have been reading the same page for some time.

He looked up when Bilbo entered.

“Cousin Bilbo?”

“Hello, my dear.”

Frodo closed the book.

“Where's Thorin?”

“Speaking with Saradoc. He'll join us shortly.”

“Oh.”

Bilbo settled into the armchair beside the hearth.

For a moment, he watched the boy carefully turn the cart over in his hands.

“Frodo,” he began, “may I ask you something?”

The boy nodded.

“You remember Bag End, don't you?”

“Yes.”

“Do you remember the garden?”

“A little.”

“And the kitchen?”

Frodo thought about it.

“You made seed cakes.”

Bilbo smiled.

“I did indeed.”

“And there was a yellow teapot.”

“There still is.”

Frodo looked pleased by this information.

Bilbo folded his hands in his lap.

“Well, Thorin and I have been talking, and we wondered whether you might like to come and stay with us.”

Frodo looked up.

“For a visit?”

“If you'd like.”

“How long?”

Bilbo hesitated.

Then he leaned forward.

“As long as you wish, my dear.”

Frodo frowned slightly.

“I don't understand.”

Bilbo's heart tightened.

“You could live with us, Frodo. At Bag End. We would very much like that, if it's something you would want too.”

The boy went very still.

His fingers closed around the little cart.

“Live there?”

“Yes.”

“With you and Thorin?”

“Yes.”

Frodo looked toward the window.

For several moments, he said nothing.

Then he asked, very quietly, “Would I have to leave Mama's and Papa's things here?”

“Oh, no.”

Bilbo moved from the armchair to sit beside him on the rug.

“Of course not. You could bring anything you wished. Your clothes, your books, your toys, anything that reminds you of them.”

“Even the big picture?”

Bilbo blinked.

“The picture?”

“The one of Mama and Papa. In the silver frame.”

“Especially that.”

Frodo looked down.

“And my cart?”

“Certainly.”

“And my fox?”

Bilbo smiled.

“I think Thorin would be rather disappointed if you left his fox behind.”

Frodo considered this.

“Could I still visit Brandy Hall?”

“As often as we can arrange it.”

“And write letters?”

“Of course.”

The boy rubbed his thumb against the cart's worn wooden side.

“Would everyone be angry if I went?”

Bilbo felt something painful twist inside his chest.

“Oh, Frodo.”

He reached out, then stopped, allowing the child to decide whether he wanted to be touched.

Frodo moved closer.

Bilbo gently put an arm around him.

“No one would be angry, my dear. Everyone here loves you. That won't change because you live somewhere else.”

Frodo rested against him.

“Would I have to call Thorin something different?”

Bilbo looked down in surprise.

“What do you mean?”

“Like… Father.”

For a moment, Bilbo could scarcely speak.

Then he shook his head.

“No, sweetheart. You may call Thorin whatever feels comfortable to you. And me, too. We aren't asking you to forget your mama and papa.”

Frodo swallowed.

“Could I call you Uncle Bilbo?”

Bilbo's expression softened so suddenly that he had to blink away tears.

“Of course you may, my dear.”

“And Thorin… Uncle Thorin?”

Bilbo smiled.

“I think he would like that very much.”

Frodo nodded thoughtfully.

“Good.”

Bilbo stroked his curls.

They sat together for a while.

Eventually, Frodo whispered, “Can I think about it?”

Bilbo kissed the top of his head.

“As long as you need.”

______________

 

Frodo gave them his answer the following afternoon.

He found Thorin in the garden, examining a loose latch on one of the smaller gates. Bilbo was nearby, speaking with a Brandybuck aunt about the journey back to Hobbiton.

The boy stood watching the dwarf for several moments before clearing his throat.

“Thorin?”

Thorin looked up.

“Yes, lad?”

“Could I… could I come live with you?”

Thorin set down his tools.

He turned fully toward Frodo.

“Of course you may.”

Frodo looked uncertain.

“Would you mind?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Not in the slightest.”

“But I might be troublesome.”

The dwarf raised an eyebrow.

“Frodo, I have lived with your cousin Bilbo for five years. I assure you, I am well acquainted with troublesome hobbits.”

“Thorin!” Bilbo exclaimed from across the garden.

Frodo giggled.

Thorin smiled.

Then he crouched before the boy.

“We would be very glad to have you with us, Frodo. But only if you're certain it's what you want.”

Frodo thought for a moment.

Then he nodded.

“I think I'd like to.”

Thorin offered him his hand.

“Then we shall be very happy to welcome you.”

Frodo took it.

For a moment, he looked down at their joined hands.

Then he glanced up.

“May I call you Uncle Thorin?”

The dwarf blinked.

It was such a small question, asked so quietly, and yet something about it caught him entirely unprepared.

He remembered two little dwarflings in the Blue Mountains, their small hands clutching his sleeves, their voices calling for their uncle whenever they needed help or comfort.

Thorin's expression warmed.

“I would be honoured, lad.”

Frodo smiled.

“Thank you, Uncle Thorin.”

Thorin gave his hand a gentle squeeze.

And when Bilbo came hurrying over, the boy allowed himself to be gathered into a warm embrace.

______________

 

The arrangements took several more days. Saradoc and the family discussed Frodo's guardianship with Bilbo and Thorin, making certain that his inheritance, belongings, and ties to Buckland would be protected. There were papers to sign, relatives to inform, and practical matters to settle before the adoption could be formally recognised.

Frodo was consulted throughout, although he found most of the discussions rather dull.

When at last everything was arranged, he was given time to choose what he wished to bring.

He packed the wooden cart.

The fox.

His favourite books.

Several pieces of clothing.

And the silver-framed picture of his parents.

Bilbo helped him wrap it carefully.

Thorin carried the heavier belongings.

And on a clear morning, beneath a sky washed pale blue by the autumn wind, the three of them departed Brandy Hall together.

_____________

 

Bag End had never seemed quite so large to Frodo.

He remembered it from his earlier visits, of course. He remembered the round green door, the garden, the comfortable sitting room, and the smell of something delicious that always seemed to drift from Bilbo's kitchen.

But visiting a place was different from arriving with the knowledge that one might remain there.

Frodo stood just inside the entrance hall, holding his little wooden fox.

Thorin carried the last of the luggage inside.

Bilbo removed his coat and hung it beside the door.

“Well,” he said brightly, “here we are.”

Frodo looked around.

The polished wooden floors gleamed in the afternoon light. A fire crackled in the sitting room, and the familiar scent of tea, old books, and beeswax filled the air.

From somewhere beyond the kitchen window came the cheerful chirping of birds.

Bilbo crouched beside him.

“Would you like to see your room?”

Frodo nodded.

They followed the passage to a smaller bedroom overlooking the garden.

It had a comfortable bed, a sturdy wardrobe, a little writing desk, and a round window through which Frodo could see the branches of an apple tree.

A soft green quilt covered the bed.

There was a bookshelf beside the desk, though most of its shelves remained empty.

Bilbo watched Frodo's expression anxiously.

“We thought you might like to arrange things yourself. And if there's anything you don't care for, we can change it.”

Frodo walked slowly toward the window.

“That's the garden?”

“Yes.”

“Can I go outside whenever I want?”

“Provided you tell us where you're going.”

Frodo nodded.

He turned toward the bed.

“Is this really mine?”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Yes, my dear.”

Frodo set his fox carefully upon the pillow.

Then he looked toward Thorin.

“Can I put my cart here too, Uncle Thorin?”

Thorin smiled.

“Wherever you like.”

Frodo placed the cart beside the fox.

For a while, he simply stood looking at them.

Bilbo resisted the urge to fill the silence.

Eventually, Frodo turned.

“Could we have tea, Uncle Bilbo?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Of course we can.”

And so their first afternoon as a household of three began with tea, apple cake, and Frodo sitting quietly between them while Thorin told an entirely unnecessary story about Kíli attempting to teach a goat to obey commands.

________________

 

The first week was not easy.

Frodo was polite, helpful, and terribly careful.

He asked permission before taking a book from the sitting-room shelves. He apologised when he accidentally knocked over a cushion. He folded his clothes neatly every morning and seemed almost distressed whenever Bilbo offered to help him with something.

At supper, he sometimes ate very little.

At other times, he ate enough to surprise even Bilbo.

He rarely complained.

And that, more than anything, troubled Thorin.

He remembered another little boy who had once tried very hard to be good.

One evening, after Frodo had gone to bed, Bilbo found his husband standing in the doorway of the child's room, watching the closed door thoughtfully.

“He's settling,” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin nodded.

“He is.”

“But?”

The dwarf sighed.

“He still behaves as though he's afraid of being a burden.”

Bilbo's expression saddened.

“I know.”

Thorin slipped an arm around his waist.

“We must give him time.”

Bilbo leaned against him.

“We will.”

And they did.

They did not demand that Frodo become cheerful.

They did not insist that he join every activity.

They allowed him to have quiet mornings, difficult afternoons, and evenings when he preferred to sit with a book rather than speak.

Sometimes he asked Bilbo questions about his parents.

Sometimes he cried.

Sometimes he laughed, then grew quiet again.

Bilbo and Thorin treated each of those moments as something perfectly ordinary.

Because grief, they understood, was not a thing that disappeared simply because a child had found somewhere safe.

By the second week, Frodo had discovered that Bilbo's kitchen was an excellent place to hide.

This was not because anything frightening happened in Thorin's workshop.

Quite the opposite.

The workshop was often filled with cheerful voices, the smell of fresh wood, and the sound of children arguing over which animal Thorin ought to carve next.

But there were sometimes too many children.

They crowded around the workbench, asked questions over one another, and laughed loudly whenever Thorin pretended to be offended by their suggestions.

Frodo liked watching them from the doorway.

He simply wasn't ready to join them.

______________

 

One afternoon, after three children arrived carrying a broken toy wagon and another two appeared demanding to see Thorin's latest dragon, Frodo quietly retreated into the kitchen.

Bilbo was preparing biscuit dough.

He looked up.

“Hello, my dear.”

Frodo hesitated.

“Can I stay here, Uncle Bilbo?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Of course. Though I warn you, I may put you to work.”

Frodo glanced at the flour-covered table.

“What are you making?”

“Biscuits.”

“For the children?”

“Some of them.”

Frodo considered this.

“Can I help?”

Bilbo's face brightened.

“I should be delighted.”

He fetched a small apron and tied it around Frodo's waist.

Then he showed him how to roll the dough and cut it into little shapes.

Frodo chose stars.

Bilbo chose leaves.

By the time the first tray was ready for the oven, both of them had flour on their sleeves, and Frodo had somehow managed to get a white streak across his nose.

Bilbo noticed.

He did not mention it.

Instead, he asked whether Frodo would like to taste a little of the dough.

Frodo looked scandalised.

“Before it's baked?”

Bilbo leaned closer.

“Don't tell Uncle Thorin.”

From the passage came a familiar voice.

“Don't tell Uncle Thorin what?”

Bilbo froze.

Frodo burst into laughter.

Thorin appeared in the doorway, saw the flour, the dough, and his husband's suspicious expression, and sighed.

“I see.”

Bilbo smiled sweetly.

“Would you like a biscuit, darling?”

“They are not baked.”

“Then you shall have to wait.”

Thorin looked toward Frodo.

“Is he always like this?”

Frodo nodded solemnly.

“I'm beginning to think so.”

“Traitor,” Bilbo murmured.

The boy giggled.

And when Thorin returned to his workshop, Frodo remained in the kitchen, helping Bilbo arrange the biscuits upon a tray.

He did not feel guilty for staying there.

Bilbo had made it clear that he was welcome.

___________

 

The quieter days belonged to Thorin.

At first, Frodo only visited the workshop when there were no other children.

He would appear in the doorway, holding a book or his little wooden fox, and stand watching the dwarf work.

Thorin never demanded an explanation.

He simply glanced up.

“Afternoon, lad.”

“Afternoon, Uncle Thorin.”

Then he returned to his carving.

Sometimes Frodo remained by the door.

Sometimes he sat upon one of the little stools.

And sometimes, after several minutes of silence, he began asking questions.

“What are you making?”

“A horse.”

“Why hasn't it got a tail?”

“Because I haven't carved one yet.”

“Oh.”

A pause.

“Will it have a long tail?”

“That depends.”

“On what?”

“Whether its owner wants a long tail.”

Frodo considered this.

“Who is it for?”

“Daisy Proudfoot.”

“Oh.”

Another pause.

“Does Daisy like horses?”

“Very much.”

Frodo watched the carving knife move carefully through the wood.

“Uncle Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Have you ever ridden a really big horse?”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“I have ridden horses larger than you would believe.”

“Bigger than the ones in the Shire?”

“Considerably.”

Frodo's eyes widened.

And so the questions began.

Sometimes they concerned the workshop.

Sometimes they concerned the mountains.

And sometimes they concerned the adventures Thorin and Bilbo had shared long before Frodo came to live with them.

“Did you really fight a dragon?”

Thorin paused.

“Yes.”

“Was it enormous?”

“Very.”

“Bigger than Bag End?”

Thorin chuckled.

“Much bigger.”

Frodo stared.

“Were you frightened?”

The dwarf set down his knife.

He looked at the boy thoughtfully.

“Of course.”

Frodo blinked.

“But you're brave.”

Thorin smiled.

“Being brave doesn't mean you aren't afraid, lad. It means doing what must be done despite your fear.”

Frodo considered that for a long while.

Then he nodded.

“I think I understand.”

Thorin picked up his carving again.

And Frodo remained beside him, watching.

________________

 

By the third week, Bilbo had discovered that his young cousin possessed an astonishing talent for asking questions at inconvenient moments.

“Uncle Bilbo?”

“Yes, my dear?”

“Did you really steal something from a dragon?”

Bilbo nearly dropped the wooden spoon he was holding.

He turned.

Frodo stood beside the kitchen table, carefully peeling an apple.

“Who told you that?”

“Uncle Thorin.”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Did he, now?”

“He said you were the bravest burglar in Middle-earth.”

Bilbo's cheeks grew pink.

“Well, I wouldn't go quite that far.”

From the passage came Thorin's voice.

“I would.”

Bilbo turned sharply.

“Thorin Oakenshield!”

The dwarf appeared in the doorway looking entirely innocent.

“What?”

“You are filling the boy's head with nonsense.”

“I am telling him the truth.”

“You are exaggerating.”

“Am I?”

“Yes!”

Thorin folded his arms.

“Did you not enter Smaug's hall?”

Bilbo sighed.

“Yes.”

“Did you not speak to him?”

“Yes.”

“Did you not steal from him?”

Bilbo looked deeply offended.

“I prefer to think of it as retrieving property that did not belong to him.”

Frodo giggled.

Thorin smiled.

“An excellent distinction, ghivashel.”

Bilbo pointed his spoon at him.

“You may peel the rest of these apples.”

Thorin looked at the basket.

There were at least twelve.

He sighed.

Frodo laughed.

And Bilbo, thoroughly pleased with himself, returned to preparing the filling.

The chair appeared during the fourth week.

Thorin had noticed that Frodo struggled to see what was happening upon the workbench.

The boy often stood on his toes, leaning forward whenever Thorin worked on something particularly interesting.

He never complained.

But Thorin noticed.

______________

 

So one afternoon, while Frodo helped Bilbo bake, the dwarf began making something new.

He selected sturdy oak from his collection of timber, measured the pieces carefully, and worked until the light outside had begun to fade.

The following morning, Frodo entered the workshop and stopped.

Beside Thorin's workbench stood a chair.

It was taller than the little stools used by the village children, with a comfortable backrest, a broad seat, and a small footrest beneath it.

Carved into the backrest was a fox.

Frodo stared.

“What's that?”

Thorin glanced up.

“A chair.”

Frodo gave him a mildly exasperated look.

“I know it's a chair.”

“Then why did you ask?”

The boy frowned.

“It's very tall.”

“So it is.”

“And it has a fox.”

“An observant lad.”

Frodo looked at him.

“Is it… for me?”

Thorin set down his tools.

“Well, I seem to have acquired an apprentice who cannot see over my workbench. I thought we ought to remedy that.”

Frodo stared at the chair again.

“An apprentice?”

“If you wish.”

The boy approached slowly.

He touched the carved fox.

Then he climbed onto the seat.

His feet rested comfortably upon the little footrest.

And for the first time, he could see the entire workbench without stretching.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Thorin smiled.

“Better?”

Frodo nodded.

“Much better.”

He ran his fingers over the fox.

“Did you make this?”

“I did.”

“For me?”

“Yes, lad.”

Frodo looked up.

Then, rather unexpectedly, he leaned forward and hugged Thorin around the shoulders.

The dwarf went still for half a heartbeat.

Then he gently returned the embrace.

“Thank you, Uncle Thorin,” Frodo whispered.

Thorin closed his eyes briefly.

“You're very welcome.”

______________

 

The tools came a little later.

Thorin had purchased some of them from a travelling merchant and made others himself.

A small wooden mallet.

Several sanding blocks.

A little ruler.

Pencils.

Pieces of soft wood suitable for practice.

And a carefully selected collection of beginner's tools designed for small hands, with anything sharp to be used only under his supervision.

He arranged them inside a sturdy wooden box.

Upon the lid, he carved two words.

FRODO BAGGINS

When Frodo discovered it, he stared for so long that Thorin began to wonder whether he had made some mistake.

“Is something wrong?”

Frodo shook his head.

“Are these mine?”

“Yes.”

“All of them?”

“Unless another Frodo Baggins has taken up residence in my workshop without informing me.”

Frodo smiled.

He touched the carved letters.

“Even the box?”

“Especially the box.”

The boy opened it again.

He examined each little tool with enormous care.

Then he looked up.

“Can you teach me, Uncle Thorin?”

Thorin smiled.

“Of course.”

___________

 

And so their lessons began.

At first, Frodo learned how to measure wood, smooth rough edges, and recognise different kinds of timber.

Thorin taught him how to hold tools properly, how to work patiently, and why rushing was often the quickest way to ruin a good piece of wood.

Frodo listened with serious attention.

Occasionally, he became frustrated.

Once, after sanding the same piece of wood for nearly half an hour, he dropped it upon the table.

“It still isn't smooth!”

Thorin examined it.

“No. Not quite.”

Frodo sighed.

“I'll never finish.”

The dwarf smiled.

“Would you like to know how many times I ruined my first carving?”

Frodo looked up.

“How many?”

“Seven.”

The boy blinked.

“Really?”

“Seven attempts before I managed something that even vaguely resembled the animal I intended.”

“What was it?”

“A bear.”

“What did it look like?”

Thorin considered.

“A very unfortunate potato.”

Frodo burst out laughing.

Thorin smiled.

“Shall we try again?”

Frodo picked up the wood.

“Yes.”

_________________

 

Not every night was peaceful.

One evening, near the end of the fifth week, Bilbo woke to the faint sound of crying.

At first, he thought he had dreamed it.

Then he heard it again.

He slipped carefully from beneath the blankets, leaving Thorin sleeping, and made his way down the passage.

Frodo's door was closed.

Bilbo knocked softly.

“Frodo?”

There was no answer.

He waited.

Then came a small voice.

“Uncle Bilbo?”

“May I come in?”

A pause.

“Yes.”

Bilbo opened the door.

Frodo sat curled beneath his blankets, his face wet with tears.

The little wooden fox rested beside his pillow.

Bilbo's heart ached.

“Oh, my dear.”

He sat on the edge of the bed.

“Bad dream?”

Frodo nodded.

Bilbo gently brushed the curls from his forehead.

“Would you like to tell me about it?”

The boy hesitated.

Then whispered, “I dreamed about Mama and Papa.”

Bilbo said nothing.

Frodo looked down at his hands.

“They were there. And then they weren't.”

His voice trembled.

“I tried to find them.”

Bilbo gathered him close.

Frodo began to cry properly then, pressing his face against Bilbo's waistcoat.

Bilbo held him.

He did not tell him to stop.

He did not promise that the dreams would disappear.

He simply stroked the child's hair and remained beside him until the sobs grew quieter.

Eventually, Frodo whispered, “Is it wrong?”

Bilbo looked down.

“What is, sweetheart?”

“To be happy here.”

Bilbo felt tears sting his own eyes.

“Why would it be wrong?”

“Because sometimes I forget to be sad.”

The words were so small that Bilbo almost missed them.

He tightened his embrace.

“Oh, Frodo.”

The boy looked up.

“Does that mean I'm forgetting them?”

“No.”

Bilbo's answer was immediate.

“Never.”

Frodo sniffled.

“But I laugh sometimes.”

“Of course you do.”

“And I like being here.”

Bilbo kissed his curls.

“My dear, loving your mama and papa doesn't mean you must be unhappy forever.”

Frodo listened.

“You can miss them every day,” Bilbo continued. “You can remember them, talk about them, and love them just as much as you always have. And you can still enjoy a sunny morning, or a good story, or a biscuit fresh from the oven.”

Frodo wiped his eyes.

“Really?”

“Really.”

A quiet knock sounded at the door.

Thorin stood in the doorway, carrying a small tray.

He had brought warm milk and a fresh blanket.

“May I come in?”

Frodo nodded.

Thorin entered and set the tray beside the bed.

He did not ask what had happened.

He simply settled into the nearby chair while Bilbo helped Frodo drink the milk.

After a while, the boy looked toward him.

“Uncle Thorin?”

“Yes, lad?”

“Did Fíli and Kíli miss their papa?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Very much.”

“Do they still?”

“I believe they do.”

Frodo looked down.

“Even though they're grown up?”

“Yes.”

The boy considered this.

“Does it get easier?”

Thorin was quiet for a moment.

“Some days.”

Frodo looked up.

“And other days?”

“Other days, you miss them terribly.”

The dwarf leaned forward.

“But that doesn't mean you've done anything wrong. It only means you loved them.”

Frodo nodded slowly.

Then he reached toward the silver-framed picture resting upon his bedside table.

Bilbo helped him lift it.

For a while, the three of them looked at the smiling faces of Drogo and Primula Baggins.

Frodo told them about the day the picture had been made.

About how his mother had complained that his father wouldn't sit still.

About how Drogo had made her laugh just before the artist began.

Bilbo smiled through his tears.

“That sounds very much like them.”

Eventually, Frodo grew sleepy.

Bilbo tucked the blankets around him.

Thorin adjusted the little fox beside his pillow.

And when they left the room, they kept the door slightly open.

Just in case.

________________

 

By the sixth week, Bag End had begun to change.

Not dramatically.

There were no grand announcements or sudden transformations.

The changes were small.

A third coat hung beside the front door.

A pair of little shoes rested beneath the bench in the entrance hall.

The kitchen table now had three places set for supper.

Frodo's books had begun appearing among Bilbo's, and his little wooden cart occasionally found its way into the sitting room.

His chair stood beside Thorin's workbench.

His tools remained neatly arranged inside their box.

And on quiet afternoons, he no longer hesitated in the workshop doorway.

He simply entered, climbed into his chair, and asked what Thorin was making.

Sometimes he worked on his own carvings.

Sometimes he watched.

Sometimes he asked questions about the adventures Thorin and Bilbo had shared.

And occasionally, he asked the same question of both husbands separately, only to discover that their answers were rather different.

“Uncle Bilbo says you were very stubborn during the journey,” Frodo announced one afternoon.

Thorin looked up from his work.

“Did he?”

“Yes.”

“An interesting accusation.”

“He said you argued with everyone.”

“Not everyone.”

“Did you argue with Uncle Bilbo?”

Thorin considered.

“Occasionally.”

Frodo smiled.

“Uncle Bilbo says you argued with him constantly.”

The dwarf sighed.

“Your uncle has a remarkable talent for exaggeration.”

Frodo giggled.

Then he leaned closer.

“Uncle Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Can you tell me about Erebor again?”

Thorin smiled.

“Which part?”

“The great hall.”

And so Thorin told him.

He described the enormous pillars rising into the darkness, the golden light of the great lamps, the sound of hammers echoing through the mountain, and the magnificent halls where his people had lived for generations.

He spoke of Fíli, now King under the Mountain, and Kíli, who still seemed determined to cause his older brother as much trouble as possible.

Frodo listened with shining eyes.

“Do you miss them?”

Thorin paused.

“Yes,” he admitted. “Very much.”

“Will we see them?”

The dwarf smiled.

“I hope so.”

That evening, Bilbo and Thorin discussed their journey once more.

The weather reports from the eastern roads had become increasingly uncertain. Snow had already begun gathering in the higher passes, and the safest opportunity for travelling would have to be chosen carefully.

Their original plan had been to leave well before Yule.

But the weeks spent helping Frodo settle had changed everything.

Neither regretted it.

“We could postpone the journey until spring,” Bilbo suggested.

Thorin considered.

“We could.”

“Though Fíli and Kíli would be disappointed.”

“They would understand.”

Bilbo nodded.

Then he looked toward the sitting room, where Frodo sat reading beside the fire.

“Perhaps we could still go, if the roads permit.”

Thorin followed his gaze.

“And remain through the winter?”

“Why not?”

The dwarf smiled.

“We might be there three or four months.”

Bilbo looked pleased.

“Then Frodo would have plenty of time to become accustomed to everyone.”

“And Kíli would have plenty of time to teach him dreadful habits.”

Bilbo laughed.

“I'm afraid that's unavoidable.”

Thorin reached for his hand.

“We'll wait for a suitable opportunity. If the roads are safe, we'll go. If not, we'll remain here.”

Bilbo squeezed his fingers.

“Agreed.”

Neither of them knew that the letter announcing their intended visit had never reached Erebor.

And neither suspected just how thoroughly their arrival would surprise the two young dwarves waiting beneath the Mountain.

The following afternoon was cold and bright.

A thin layer of frost clung to the garden, and the last leaves had fallen from the apple tree outside Frodo's bedroom.

Inside Thorin's workshop, a small fire burned steadily in the hearth.

Frodo sat upon his special chair, carefully smoothing the wings of a little wooden bird.

Thorin worked beside him.

For several minutes, the only sounds were the scrape of sandpaper and the occasional crackle of the fire.

Then Frodo frowned.

“Uncle Thorin?”

“Yes, lad?”

“I think the wings are too big.”

Thorin glanced over.

“Do you?”

Frodo nodded.

“Birds don't have wings that big.”

“Some do.”

“Not little ones.”

Thorin examined the carving.

“Perhaps you're right.”

Frodo looked pleased.

“Can you help me make them smaller?”

“Of course.”

Thorin moved his work aside and leaned closer.

Together, they examined the little bird.

Frodo listened carefully as Thorin explained how to adjust the shape without damaging the wood.

Then, with the dwarf guiding him, he began smoothing the wings again.

A few minutes later, the workshop door opened.

Bilbo entered carrying a tray.

“Hot chocolate!”

Frodo looked up immediately.

“With cinnamon, Uncle Bilbo?”

“Of course.”

“And biscuits?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Would I dare arrive without them?”

Thorin chuckled.

Bilbo set the tray upon a clear corner of the workbench.

Three mugs.

A plate of biscuits.

And a little bowl of apple slices, because Bilbo insisted that growing children required something besides sweets.

Frodo accepted his mug with both hands.

“Thank you, Uncle Bilbo.”

“You're very welcome, my dear.”

Bilbo settled into his familiar armchair near the hearth.

He watched as Frodo returned his attention to the little bird.

“Nearly finished?”

“Almost.”

“May I see?”

Frodo held it up.

Bilbo smiled.

“Oh, that's lovely.”

Frodo looked toward Thorin.

“Do you think it's good, Uncle Thorin?”

The dwarf examined the carving carefully.

The wings were not perfectly even.

One side was slightly thicker than the other, and the little beak had turned out rather more rounded than Frodo had intended.

But the shape was recognisable.

And, more importantly, Frodo had made it himself.

“I think you've done very well, lad.”

Frodo beamed.

Thorin felt something warm settle in his chest.

For a moment, he remembered two little dwarflings in the Blue Mountains.

Fíli, solemnly attempting to carve a sword from a piece of wood far too hard for his little hands.

Kíli, impatiently demanding that his own sword be bigger, sharper, and considerably more impressive.

He remembered their laughter.

Their arguments.

The way they had crowded around his workbench, asking questions and insisting upon helping.

He missed them terribly.

But when Frodo leaned closer to ask whether they might carve a rabbit next, Thorin found himself smiling.

“I believe we could manage a rabbit.”

“With long ears?”

“Very long ears.”

“And a little tail?”

“Naturally.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

“Careful, darling. At this rate, you'll have an entire forest of wooden animals before spring.”

Thorin looked toward him.

“I seem to recall someone encouraging this.”

“I encourage many things.”

“Trouble, mostly.”

Bilbo smiled sweetly.

“And yet you married me.”

Thorin's expression warmed.

“So I did.”

Frodo looked between them.

Then he giggled.

Outside, the afternoon light began to fade.

The workshop windows glowed warmly against the cold garden, and the scent of fresh wood mingled with chocolate and cinnamon.

Frodo returned to smoothing his little bird.

Thorin continued carving.

Bilbo settled more comfortably into his chair, opening the book he had brought with him.

And for a while, the three of them simply enjoyed the quiet.

There were still difficult days.

There would be more.

Frodo still missed his parents, and sometimes the grief returned so suddenly that it seemed to take his breath away.

But he was learning that he did not have to face those moments alone.

He was learning that Uncle Bilbo would listen whenever he needed to speak.

That Uncle Thorin would make room beside him whenever he wished to sit.

That laughter was allowed.

That sadness was allowed.

And that neither would make the other disappear.

At Bag End, there was now a third place at the table.

A third mug beside the fire.

A little chair in the workshop.

And a boy who was beginning, slowly and carefully, to understand that he belonged.

Chapter 4: Chapter Four — The Road to the Mountain

Chapter Text

The trouble began, as many troubles in Bag End did, with a perfectly reasonable question asked over breakfast.

“Frodo, my dear,” Bilbo began, setting down his teacup, “how would you feel about going on an adventure?”

Frodo, who had been carefully spreading strawberry preserves over a piece of toast, stopped with his knife halfway across the bread.

He looked up.

“An adventure?”

“A small one,” Bilbo said.

Thorin made a sound suspiciously like a snort from behind his newspaper.

Bilbo ignored him.

“Well, perhaps not particularly small. There would be quite a bit of travelling involved, and we would be away from home for some time, but I thought—”

“Bilbo,” Thorin interrupted gently.

His husband turned.

“What?”

“You're making it sound as though we're inviting the lad to march into Mordor.”

“I am doing no such thing!”

“You've been explaining the question for nearly a minute without actually asking it.”

Bilbo gave him a thoroughly offended look.

Frodo, meanwhile, was watching them with growing curiosity.

“Where would we go?”

Thorin folded his newspaper and placed it beside his plate.

“To Erebor.”

Frodo's eyes widened.

“The Lonely Mountain?”

“The very same.”

“Where you used to be king?”

“Yes.”

“And where Fíli is king now?”

Thorin smiled.

“Yes, lad.”

Frodo looked between his uncles, his forgotten toast resting upon his plate.

“Really?”

Bilbo's expression softened at the excitement in his voice.

“Really. We were actually planning to visit before you came to live with us. We thought we might spend Yule with Thorin's family.”

“Only,” Thorin added, “we decided there was something rather more important to attend to first.”

Frodo looked puzzled.

“What?”

Bilbo reached across the table and gently squeezed his hand.

“You, sweetheart.”

The boy lowered his eyes, but the small smile that appeared upon his face did not escape either of them.

_____________

 

For the past six weeks, Bag End had gradually become accustomed to having a third inhabitant. Frodo's little shoes stood beside the front door, his books had begun appearing among Bilbo's, and Thorin's workshop now contained a chair made especially for a young hobbit who had developed a remarkable interest in woodcarving.

It had not been an entirely easy six weeks. There were still mornings when Frodo woke unusually quiet, and evenings when the memory of his parents weighed upon him more heavily than he knew how to explain. But there were good days, too. Days filled with biscuits, laughter, stories, and the pleasant scrape of sandpaper against wood.

Bilbo and Thorin had no intention of disturbing that newfound security without first asking whether Frodo wanted to go.

“We would be travelling for several weeks,” Bilbo explained. “And because winter is approaching, we'd probably remain in Erebor for three or four months, until the roads were safe enough for the journey home.”

Frodo considered this.

“That's a very long time.”

“It is,” Thorin agreed. “Which is why you must tell us what you think. We can postpone the visit if you'd rather remain here.”

Frodo looked down at his toast.

Then he asked, “Would we go the same way you went on your adventure?”

Bilbo blinked.

“Well, more or less.”

“Past the places you've told me about?”

“Some of them,” Thorin said. “The roads have changed in places, and we'll take safer routes where we can.”

Frodo's eyes brightened.

“Would we see Rivendell?”

“If Lord Elrond is willing to receive us,” Bilbo answered.

“And the mountains?”

“Those will be rather difficult to miss,” Thorin said.

“And the forest where the elves captured you?”

Bilbo winced.

“Perhaps we needn't describe it quite like that.”

“But they did capture you.”

“They did,” Thorin admitted, looking entirely too amused by his husband's discomfort.

Frodo leaned forward.

“And the trolls?”

Bilbo nearly dropped his teacup.

“Absolutely not.”

Frodo blinked.

“But—”

“We are not visiting any trolls.”

“I only meant the place where you met them!”

“That is scarcely better.”

Thorin chuckled.

“The lad asked whether we might pass the place, ghivashel. Not whether we'd stop to have supper with its former inhabitants.”

Bilbo turned toward him.

“I distinctly remember you being considerably less amused by those trolls when they were threatening to eat us.”

“A fair point.”

Frodo giggled.

Then another thought occurred to him.

“Will I meet Fíli and Kíli?”

Thorin's expression warmed.

“You certainly will.”

“The ones who tried to teach a goat to climb stairs?”

Bilbo burst out laughing.

Thorin closed his eyes.

“I am beginning to regret some of the stories I've told you.”

“Did they really do it?”

“They tried,” Thorin admitted.

“Did the goat climb the stairs?”

“No. It chased Kíli into a laundry room and ate half of Fíli's scarf.”

Frodo laughed so hard that he nearly knocked over his milk.

Thorin caught the cup before disaster struck.

“Careful, lad.”

Frodo wiped his mouth with his sleeve, earning a disapproving glance from Bilbo, and settled back into his chair.

For a moment, he looked thoughtful.

Then he asked, more quietly, “Would they like me?”

The question caught Thorin by surprise.

He studied the boy across the breakfast table.

Frodo was still learning how to believe that he was wanted. Sometimes that uncertainty appeared in the smallest of questions, asked so casually that another person might not have noticed the worry beneath them.

Thorin did.

“They'll be delighted to meet you,” he said.

“Even though they don't know me?”

“Especially because they don't know you yet.”

Bilbo smiled.

“And they'll have plenty of stories to tell you about Uncle Thorin.”

Thorin gave him a warning look.

“Bilbo.”

“Oh, I'm certain Fíli will be very responsible about it.”

“Bilbo.”

“And Kíli will undoubtedly remember every embarrassing thing you've ever done.”

Frodo's eyes widened with delight.

“Really?”

Thorin sighed.

“I fear this journey may be a dreadful mistake.”

That settled the matter.

Frodo announced that he very much wanted to go.

And before breakfast was finished, he had already asked whether dragons could be seen from the road, whether the elves would allow him to look at their books, and whether dwarves truly lived inside the Mountain or merely beneath it.

Bilbo answered what he could.

Thorin answered the rest.

By the time Frodo hurried away to fetch his journal, both husbands were smiling.

“Well,” Bilbo said, watching the empty doorway, “I think he's excited.”

Thorin reached for his tea.

“An astonishing deduction.”

Bilbo kicked him gently beneath the table.

______________

 

Preparing for the journey took considerably longer than Thorin had anticipated.

This was largely because Bilbo approached the business of packing as though the survival of Middle-earth depended upon the precise number of spare handkerchiefs they carried.

“Three,” Thorin said firmly.

Bilbo looked up from the open travelling chest.

“Three what?”

“Three winter cloaks for Frodo. Not five.”

“I'm packing four.”

“You have five laid out.”

“One is a travelling cloak.”

“That still makes it a cloak.”

Bilbo frowned.

“And what if one becomes wet?”

“We dry it.”

“And if another is torn?”

“I mend it.”

“And if—”

“Bilbo.”

His husband looked at him.

Thorin gestured toward the enormous pile of clothing.

“We are travelling to Erebor. There are tailors in Erebor. There are seamstresses in Erebor. There are enough blankets in Erebor to bury an entire company of dwarves.”

Bilbo folded his arms.

“And yet I distinctly remember a certain dwarf insisting that I pack extra gloves.”

“That is different.”

“How?”

“Gloves are important.”

“So are cloaks.”

Thorin opened his mouth.

Then closed it.

Bilbo smiled triumphantly.

From the doorway, Frodo watched them with considerable amusement.

“Uncle Bilbo?”

“Yes, sweetheart?”

“Why is Uncle Thorin packing three blankets in his own bag?”

Silence.

Bilbo slowly turned toward his husband.

Thorin stared at Frodo.

The boy looked entirely innocent.

“Three blankets?” Bilbo repeated.

Thorin cleared his throat.

“The nights may be cold.”

“Indeed.”

“And Frodo may need an extra.”

“Of course.”

Bilbo approached the dwarf's travelling bag, lifted the flap, and discovered not three blankets but four.

He looked up.

Thorin looked away.

Frodo dissolved into giggles.

In the end, Bilbo packed four cloaks, Thorin packed three blankets, and neither admitted that the other had made a reasonable point.

Frodo, meanwhile, was given a much smaller travelling case.

Thorin presented it to him one evening in the workshop.

It was made of dark polished wood, with sturdy brass fittings and a leather handle. Inside were carefully arranged compartments containing pencils, measuring tools, sanding blocks, a small wooden mallet, and several pieces of soft wood.

The sharper carving tools would remain safely at Bag End.

Frodo ran his fingers over the little case.

“Is this for the journey?”

Thorin nodded.

“I thought you might like to continue practising.”

Frodo opened one of the compartments.

“Even while we're travelling?”

“Provided we're somewhere suitable. I don't intend to have you carving while riding in a wagon.”

Frodo smiled.

“Thank you, Uncle Thorin.”

“You're welcome, lad.”

The boy examined the case again.

Then he looked up.

“Can I bring my fox?”

“Of course.”

“And my bird?”

“Certainly.”

Frodo hesitated.

“And the picture of Mama and Papa?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“If you wish.”

The boy nodded.

“I think I do.”

“Then we'll find somewhere safe for it.”

______________

 

That evening, Bilbo helped Frodo wrap the silver-framed picture in a soft cloth. They placed it carefully among his belongings, together with the wooden fox, the little bird he had carved himself, and the journal in which he had begun recording his uncles' stories.

By the time everything was ready, Frodo's excitement had become almost impossible to contain.

He asked how many days remained until departure every morning.

Sometimes twice.

On the final evening, Bilbo found him sitting upon his bed, examining the little wooden fox.

“Nervous?” Bilbo asked.

Frodo considered.

“A little.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

“That's quite all right.”

“Were you nervous when you went on your adventure?”

Bilbo laughed softly.

“My dear boy, I was absolutely terrified.”

Frodo looked astonished.

“Really?”

“Oh, yes. I had no proper handkerchiefs, no idea where we were going, and thirteen dwarves who seemed determined to get themselves into trouble.”

“Fourteen,” Frodo corrected.

Bilbo smiled.

“Fourteen, if you count Gandalf as an honorary dwarf.”

Frodo giggled.

Then he grew thoughtful.

“Did you want to go home?”

“Very often.”

“But you stayed.”

Bilbo nodded.

“I did.”

“Why?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“Because somewhere along the way, the people I was travelling with became very important to me.”

Frodo looked toward the doorway, where Thorin's voice could be heard discussing the final arrangements with a neighbour.

“Especially Uncle Thorin?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Especially Uncle Thorin.”

Frodo leaned against him.

After a while, he whispered, “I'm glad you're both coming with me.”

Bilbo kissed his curls.

“So am I, sweetheart.”

____________

 

They departed Bag End beneath a pale autumn sky.

The morning was crisp enough that Frodo's breath appeared in little clouds, and the grass glittered with frost along the edges of the lane.

Several neighbours had come to see them off.

Mrs. Goodbody pressed a parcel of biscuits into Frodo's hands, insisting that growing boys required proper food while travelling. Rosie gave him a small ribbon to tie around his journal, and two of the children who regularly visited Thorin's workshop made him promise to tell them everything about the Mountain when he returned.

Thorin received several enthusiastic embraces from elderly hobbit women who reminded him to wear warm clothing and not to forget his meals.

Bilbo watched with unconcealed delight.

“I see you're very popular, darling.”

Thorin adjusted the strap of his travelling bag.

“I am beginning to suspect these women believe I am incapable of looking after myself.”

“An understandable concern.”

“Bilbo.”

His husband smiled.

Frodo giggled.

Then, with the last farewells exchanged, they set off along the road.

For Frodo, the first few days were a revelation.

He had travelled before, of course. Buckland and Hobbiton were not entirely unfamiliar to him, and he knew the roads between several neighbouring settlements.

But travelling with his uncles was different.

There was no hurried schedule, no expectation that he must behave as though he were older than eleven, and no one who grew impatient when he stopped to examine something interesting.

Thorin had arranged for comfortable transport where the roads allowed, and they travelled at a pace that suited all three of them. Sometimes Frodo walked beside the wagon, sometimes he rode, and occasionally Thorin lifted him onto a sturdy pony for short stretches under careful supervision.

Bilbo insisted upon proper meals.

Thorin insisted upon proper rest.

Frodo insisted upon asking approximately a hundred questions before luncheon.

By the fourth day, he had already filled several pages of his journal.

He drew trees, bridges, distant hills, and a particularly stubborn pony that had refused to cross a shallow stream until Thorin bribed it with an apple.

He also attempted to sketch his uncles.

Bilbo's portrait was recognisable.

Thorin's was considerably less flattering.

The dwarf examined it one evening beside the fire.

“Why is my nose so large?”

Frodo looked concerned.

“Is it too big?”

Bilbo leaned over.

“Oh, no. I think it's remarkably accurate.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“Do you?”

“Quite.”

Frodo giggled.

Thorin handed back the journal.

“Perhaps tomorrow we shall practise drawing mountains.”

______________

 

As the days passed, the Shire gradually fell behind them.

The roads became less familiar. The fields stretched farther between settlements, and the hills grew taller beneath the changing sky.

They stayed at inns whenever possible, choosing warm rooms and generous suppers over unnecessary hardship. Thorin knew too well what difficult journeys could become when pride persuaded travellers to ignore comfort.

There were evenings when Frodo fell asleep before finishing his supper, his head resting against Bilbo's shoulder.

Other nights, he remained awake long enough to demand another story.

“Uncle Thorin?”

The dwarf looked up from the fire.

“Yes, lad?”

“Did Uncle Bilbo really save you from spiders?”

Bilbo, who had been quietly reading, lowered his book.

“Oh, dear.”

Thorin smiled.

“He did.”

“All of you?”

“Every one of us.”

Frodo turned toward Bilbo.

“By himself?”

Bilbo cleared his throat.

“Well, there were certain advantages to being rather small.”

“And rather brave,” Thorin added.

Bilbo's cheeks warmed.

“And rather fortunate.”

“Fortune had little to do with it.”

Frodo considered this.

“Were the spiders enormous?”

“Terribly,” Bilbo said.

“Bigger than dogs?”

“Much bigger.”

Frodo shuddered.

“I don't think I'd like that forest.”

“Neither did I,” Bilbo admitted.

Thorin reached across the space between their chairs and took his husband's hand.

“But you brought us through it.”

Bilbo smiled at him.

Frodo watched them for a moment, then returned to his journal and carefully wrote down that Uncle Bilbo had fought giant spiders.

Underneath, he added that Uncle Thorin said Bilbo was very brave.

He underlined the sentence twice.

_____________

 

Not every evening was quite so cheerful.

One night, after they had been travelling for nearly two weeks, Frodo became unusually quiet.

They had stopped at a comfortable inn, where a cheerful fire burned in the common room and the innkeeper's children were playing a game near the hearth.

Frodo watched them for a while.

Then he asked to go upstairs.

Bilbo followed a few minutes later.

He found the boy sitting upon the edge of his bed, holding the little silver-framed picture of his parents.

“Hello, sweetheart.”

Frodo looked up.

“Hello, Uncle Bilbo.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

“Missing them?”

Frodo nodded.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then the boy whispered, “Papa always said he'd take me travelling when I was older.”

Bilbo felt his chest tighten.

“Did he?”

“He said we'd go somewhere far away. Maybe even see the mountains.”

Frodo looked down at the picture.

“I wish he could come.”

Bilbo gently put an arm around him.

“I know, my dear.”

“I'm having fun,” Frodo said, sounding almost apologetic.

“I'm glad.”

“But sometimes I think about how they aren't here.”

Bilbo kissed his curls.

“Then you can think about them. You don't have to stop enjoying the journey.”

Frodo leaned against him.

A little later, Thorin joined them carrying three mugs of warm milk.

He listened while Frodo told him about Drogo's promise.

Then the dwarf settled into the chair beside the bed.

“Your father sounds like a hobbit who appreciated a good adventure.”

Frodo smiled faintly.

“He did.”

“Then perhaps he'd have enjoyed hearing about yours.”

The boy looked toward his journal.

“Do you think so?”

“I do.”

Frodo considered this.

Then he opened the journal and began writing about the places they had seen.

Bilbo remained beside him.

Thorin stayed until the fire had burned low.

And when Frodo finally fell asleep, the little silver picture rested safely upon the bedside table.

______________

 

Rivendell appeared before them in a wash of autumn gold and silver.

Frodo had imagined it many times.

He had pictured towers and bridges, enormous trees, and elves wearing shining robes. He had imagined waterfalls tumbling down mountainsides and songs drifting through the air.

Yet none of those imaginings quite prepared him for the sight of the valley opening beneath them.

The Last Homely House stood among trees whose leaves shimmered in the afternoon light. Waterfalls spilled down the cliffs, their distant thunder mingling with birdsong and the gentle murmur of the river.

Frodo stared.

“Oh.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Rather beautiful, isn't it?”

Frodo nodded without taking his eyes from the view.

“It's like a story.”

Thorin glanced toward the valley.

“It is a fine place.”

Bilbo turned toward him with exaggerated surprise.

“Was that a compliment?”

The dwarf raised an eyebrow.

“I am capable of appreciating elven architecture.”

“Of course you are, darling.”

Frodo giggled.

They descended into the valley as the sun began to sink behind the mountains.

Their arrival caused considerably less confusion than their eventual arrival at Erebor would.

The elves recognised Bilbo and Thorin, and word was quickly sent to Lord Elrond.

Before long, they were welcomed into a beautiful hall where warm lamps glowed beneath carved wooden beams.

Elrond greeted them with the composed warmth of someone who had witnessed many extraordinary things and was therefore not easily surprised.

“Bilbo Baggins,” he said, smiling. “And Thorin Oakenshield. It is a pleasure to welcome you both again.”

Bilbo bowed.

“Lord Elrond. You're very kind to receive us.”

Thorin inclined his head respectfully.

“We are grateful for your hospitality.”

Elrond's gaze moved between them.

Then he noticed the small hobbit standing beside Bilbo, staring up at him with enormous blue eyes.

“And who is this young traveller?”

Bilbo smiled proudly.

“This is Frodo, our nephew. He's recently come to live with us.”

Frodo immediately remembered his manners.

He stepped forward and gave a very serious little bow.

“Good evening, my lord.”

Elrond's expression softened.

“Good evening, Frodo. Welcome to Rivendell.”

“Thank you.”

“Have you travelled far?”

Frodo nodded.

“From Hobbiton.”

“A considerable journey for one so young.”

Frodo hesitated.

Then he asked, “Are you really thousands of years old?”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

Thorin looked toward the ceiling.

Elrond blinked.

Then, to Frodo's enormous relief, he laughed.

“I am indeed rather older than most people you will meet.”

Frodo stared.

“Do you remember dragons?”

“Some.”

“Real ones?”

“Very real.”

Frodo looked as though he might faint from excitement.

Bilbo sighed.

“I do apologise. He's been asking questions since we left Bag End.”

Elrond smiled.

“Then I suspect we shall get along very well.”

_____________

 

They were given comfortable rooms overlooking the gardens, and after supper Frodo was invited to listen to the evening music.

He sat between his uncles in a beautiful hall filled with soft golden light.

Elven voices rose and fell around them, weaving melodies that seemed to carry the memory of distant forests, ancient kingdoms, and stars reflected upon quiet water.

Frodo listened in complete fascination.

Occasionally, he leaned toward Bilbo to whisper a question.

Sometimes Bilbo answered.

Sometimes Thorin did.

And sometimes Elrond, seated nearby, offered an explanation that made the boy's eyes grow even wider.

Later, when the music had ended, Frodo was shown a collection of beautifully illustrated books.

He examined drawings of mountains, rivers, and ancient cities with such reverence that one of the elves quietly brought him a stool so he could see the higher shelves.

Bilbo watched him with a smile.

“He reminds me of someone,” Elrond remarked.

Bilbo glanced toward him.

“Does he?”

“A certain hobbit who once arrived here rather unwillingly, yet proved himself capable of remarkable courage.”

Bilbo blushed.

Thorin smiled.

“That hobbit is still rather remarkable.”

Elrond's eyes warmed.

“So I have observed.”

_____________

 

Before they retired for the night, Elrond presented Frodo with a small notebook bound in deep blue leather.

Its pages were thick and smooth, suitable for both writing and drawing.

“For your travels,” he explained.

Frodo accepted it with both hands.

“Thank you, Lord Elrond.”

“You may find that the world contains more wonders than even your uncles have managed to describe.”

Frodo looked toward Bilbo and Thorin.

“I think it does.”

That night, before going to bed, Frodo stood upon a balcony overlooking the valley.

The air was cool, and the stars shone brightly above the distant mountains.

Bilbo joined him, wrapping a warm cloak around his shoulders.

“Beautiful, isn't it?”

Frodo nodded.

After a moment, he whispered, “I wish Mama and Papa could have seen this.”

Bilbo rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“I think they would have loved it.”

Frodo looked down at the notebook Elrond had given him.

“Maybe I can draw it.”

“A wonderful idea.”

“Then I'll remember.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Yes, sweetheart. You will.”

Thorin appeared a little later, carrying an extra blanket and looking mildly displeased to discover that both hobbits were standing outside in the cold.

“Are you two planning to spend the entire night admiring the stars?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Only until you came to rescue us.”

Thorin sighed.

Frodo giggled.

And together, they returned to the warmth of their rooms.

______________

 

They departed Rivendell the following morning.

Elrond provided fresh provisions and advice concerning the roads ahead. Winter was approaching quickly, and several higher routes had already become difficult.

Thorin listened carefully.

He had no intention of taking unnecessary risks, particularly with Frodo accompanying them.

They adjusted their route accordingly, choosing safer roads and stopping whenever the weather demanded it.

The weeks that followed were filled with changing landscapes.

Frodo saw mountains rising against the sky, rivers winding through broad valleys, and forests whose trees seemed older than anything he had ever known.

He filled pages of his new notebook with drawings.

Some were remarkably good.

Others were less successful.

His first attempt at drawing a mountain looked suspiciously like a large potato.

Thorin examined it.

“An improvement upon my first bear.”

Frodo laughed.

Bilbo insisted upon keeping the drawing.

______________

 

As they travelled farther east, Frodo began asking more questions about Erebor.

He wanted to know whether the halls were truly filled with gold, whether dwarves slept underground, and whether Fíli wore a crown every day.

“No,” Thorin answered.

“Why not?”

“Because crowns are uncomfortable.”

Frodo considered this.

“Did you wear one?”

“When necessary.”

“Did you like it?”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“Not particularly.”

Bilbo glanced toward him.

“Your uncle was always much happier with a hammer in his hand than a crown upon his head.”

Thorin looked at his husband.

“Some things are more useful than others.”

Bilbo smiled.

Frodo wrote that down.

_______________

 

By the time they approached the lands surrounding the Lonely Mountain, the air had grown noticeably colder.

Snow lay upon the distant peaks, and the wind carried the sharp scent of approaching winter.

They were fortunate.

The roads remained passable, and the final stages of their journey passed without serious difficulty.

Then, one clear afternoon, Frodo saw it.

At first, he thought it was another mountain.

A particularly enormous one.

But Thorin slowed beside him and pointed toward the horizon.

“There, lad.”

Frodo followed his gaze.

The Lonely Mountain rose above the surrounding lands, its vast slopes stretching toward the clouds.

For several moments, the boy said nothing.

Then he whispered, “That's Erebor?”

Thorin nodded.

“Yes.”

Frodo stared.

“It's enormous.”

Bilbo smiled.

“It certainly is.”

“People live inside that?”

“Thousands of them,” Thorin answered.

Frodo looked up at his uncle.

“Did you really grow up there?”

Thorin's expression changed.

For a moment, he seemed to be looking not merely at the Mountain before them, but at something much farther away.

“Yes,” he said quietly. “I did.”

Bilbo reached for his hand.

Thorin squeezed it.

Frodo continued staring at the distant peaks.

Then he opened his notebook.

He tried to draw the Mountain.

After several minutes, he frowned.

“It won't fit.”

Bilbo looked over his shoulder.

“What won't?”

“The Mountain.”

Thorin chuckled.

“Then perhaps you'll need a larger page.”

Frodo considered this seriously.

“I think I need a much larger book.”

______________

 

The gates of Erebor were busy when they arrived.

Merchants were unloading wagons, guards were inspecting supplies, and dwarves moved through the broad entrance carrying crates, tools, and bundles of winter provisions.

Frodo watched everything with enormous curiosity.

Then Thorin approached the guards.

The first dwarf looked up.

For a moment, his expression remained perfectly ordinary.

Then his eyes widened.

He straightened so abruptly that the spear in his hand nearly struck the guard beside him.

“Your Majesty!”

Several nearby dwarves turned.

Thorin inclined his head.

“Good afternoon.”

The guard stared.

Bilbo smiled pleasantly.

Frodo looked between them.

“Is something wrong?” Thorin asked.

“N-no, Your Majesty! Of course not! We simply—”

The guard looked toward his companion.

His companion looked equally astonished.

“We weren't informed of your arrival.”

Thorin frowned.

“I sent a letter weeks ago.”

The guards exchanged another glance.

Bilbo's smile faltered slightly.

He leaned toward his husband.

“Darling,” he murmured, “I don't think they received our letter.”

Thorin looked at him.

Then back at the guards.

“I see.”

The first guard looked increasingly distressed.

“Please forgive us, Your Majesty. Had we known—”

“There is nothing to forgive,” Thorin interrupted. “Though I would appreciate knowing whether my nephews are presently in the Mountain.”

“Both of them, Your Majesty.”

“Excellent.”

The guard straightened.

“We shall escort you inside immediately.”

Thorin nodded.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo took Frodo's hand as they passed through the enormous gates.

The boy looked up at the towering stone walls, the vast pillars, and the golden light spilling from the halls beyond.

His mouth fell open.

“Uncle Thorin…”

The dwarf glanced down.

“Yes, lad?”

“It's even bigger inside.”

Thorin smiled.

“You haven't seen half of it yet.”

______________

 

The guards led them through the magnificent halls, past startled dwarves who stopped in their tracks upon recognising their former king.

Whispers followed them.

Some bowed.

Others simply stared.

Thorin grew increasingly puzzled.

Bilbo, meanwhile, was beginning to suspect that their missing letter had caused rather more confusion than either of them had anticipated.

At last, they reached the corridors leading toward the royal study.

One of the guards hurried ahead.

“His Majesty is occupied with Lord Kíli,” he explained. “But I shall inform him immediately.”

Thorin nodded.

“Very well.”

Frodo tightened his grip upon Bilbo's hand.

“Uncle Bilbo?”

“Yes, sweetheart?”

“Are they going to be angry?”

Bilbo looked down in surprise.

“Whatever for?”

“Because we came without telling them.”

Bilbo smiled gently.

“Oh, my dear. We did tell them. It seems our letter simply never arrived.”

Thorin rested a reassuring hand upon the boy's shoulder.

“My nephews will be pleased to see us.”

Frodo nodded.

Then he looked toward the enormous doors at the end of the corridor.

He could hear voices beyond them.

Rather loud voices.

He glanced up at Thorin.

“Are they always that noisy?”

The dwarf listened for a moment.

Then he sighed.

“Unfortunately, yes.”

________________

 

More than an hour earlier, King Fíli had begun to suspect that his younger brother was deliberately attempting to shorten his life.

This was not an entirely new suspicion.

Kíli had been testing the limits of his patience since the day he learned to walk, and Fíli had long since accepted that being an older brother involved a certain amount of suffering.

Being King under the Mountain, however, had added several entirely new varieties of suffering to the arrangement.

At present, most of them were spread across his desk.

Maps.

Supply reports.

Letters from merchants.

Requests from settlements.

Military patrol schedules.

And one particularly unpleasant account of a caravan that had been attacked near the northern pass.

Fíli sat behind his desk, rubbing the bridge of his nose.

Kíli stood opposite him, leaning over a large map.

They had been discussing the matter for more than an hour.

At first, the conversation had been perfectly civil.

Kíli had arrived with reports from his captains, and Fíli had listened carefully while his brother explained the difficulties facing the northern patrols.

The first snowfall had arrived earlier than expected in several higher regions. Merchants were attempting to move goods before the roads became impassable, while smaller settlements depended upon regular deliveries of grain, tools, medicine, and winter clothing.

The problem was not simply that the roads were dangerous.

It was that there were too many roads, too many caravans, and not enough soldiers to protect all of them.

Fíli studied the map.

“How many men are currently stationed along the northern pass?”

“Forty-eight,” Kíli answered.

“And how many are available to reinforce them?”

“Another twenty, provided we pull them from the western patrols.”

Fíli frowned.

“That would leave the western road exposed.”

“Less exposed than the northern pass.”

“The western road supplies three settlements.”

“And the northern pass carries twice as many merchants.”

Fíli leaned back in his chair.

“Merchants who have been warned repeatedly not to travel without escorts.”

Kíli folded his arms.

“Warnings don't stop desperate people from taking risks.”

“I am aware.”

“Then you understand why we need more soldiers.”

Fíli looked toward the map again.

“I understand why you want them. That does not mean I can produce them out of thin air.”

Kíli sighed.

For a while, they continued discussing alternatives.

They considered shortening patrol routes, moving soldiers between outposts, and requesting assistance from neighbouring settlements.

Fíli rejected the idea of withdrawing guards from the eastern storehouses.

Kíli rejected the suggestion that merchants simply wait until spring.

Neither decision was unreasonable.

Both brothers knew it.

That was what made the matter so frustrating.

Fíli was responsible for the entire kingdom. He had to consider food reserves, trade agreements, the safety of settlements, and the number of soldiers available should a greater threat appear.

Kíli, meanwhile, had spent enough time travelling those roads to know precisely how dangerous they could become.

He had seen overturned wagons.

He had spoken with wounded merchants.

He had stood beside soldiers who had returned from patrols with fewer companions than they had taken out.

He was not willing to dismiss those dangers as an unfortunate inconvenience.

Eventually, Fíli reached for his tea.

It had gone cold.

He drank it anyway.

“Kíli,” he said, attempting patience, “I cannot assign an entire company to escort every merchant who wishes to cross the northern pass.”

“I haven't asked you to.”

“You've asked for thirty additional soldiers.”

“Because thirty would be sufficient to reinforce the road.”

“For how long?”

“Until the final caravans have passed.”

“And what happens when another settlement requests assistance?”

Kíli leaned forward.

“Then we deal with it.”

Fíli stared at him.

“That is not a plan.”

“It is better than leaving the caravans undefended.”

“They are not undefended!”

“Forty-eight soldiers spread across that entire route might as well be!”

Fíli set down his cup.

The sound was sharper than he intended.

For a moment, the brothers glared at one another.

Then Kíli sighed and straightened.

“Look, Fíli. I'm not trying to make your life difficult.”

His older brother gave him a long look.

“An astonishing claim.”

Kíli ignored that.

“I know what you're worried about. But if we lose another caravan, the merchants will stop using the road entirely. Then the settlements won't receive anything.”

Fíli looked down at the map.

He knew his brother was right about that.

But there were other dangers.

“If I move those soldiers north,” he said, “I risk leaving the western settlements without protection. And if the weather worsens, we may not be able to move them back quickly enough.”

Kíli frowned.

“Then we need another approach.”

“We have been searching for another approach for over an hour.”

“And we haven't found one.”

“Thank you for the observation.”

“You're welcome.”

Fíli closed his eyes.

For one brief, unreasonable moment, he missed being a prince.

Not because he regretted becoming king.

He loved Erebor. He loved his people. He took his responsibilities seriously, perhaps more seriously than anyone except his uncle had expected.

But there were days when he missed being able to bring an impossible problem to Thorin and ask what he thought.

Thorin had always possessed an infuriating talent for seeing possibilities that others overlooked.

He had also possessed an equally infuriating talent for making those possibilities sound obvious.

Fíli sighed.

Kíli noticed.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“You're making that face.”

“What face?”

“The one you make when you're thinking about throwing me out of a window.”

Fíli looked at him.

“Kíli, we're underground.”

“Then I suppose I'm safe.”

“Regrettably.”

Kíli grinned.

For a moment, the tension eased.

Then Fíli looked at the map again.

“We still need a solution.”

His brother's smile faded.

“I know.”

They returned to the reports.

_______________

 

Another quarter of an hour passed.

Then someone knocked upon the study door.

Fíli barely looked up.

“Enter.”

A guard stepped inside.

“Your Majesty, forgive the interruption, but there are visitors—”

“Not now.”

The guard hesitated.

“Your Majesty, I really think you should—”

“Kíli, if we move the western patrols, how quickly can they reach the northern pass?”

“Two days. Three if the weather worsens.”

The guard cleared his throat.

“Your Majesty?”

Fíli looked up, irritation flashing across his face.

“What?”

“There are visitors who—”

“Unless the Mountain is collapsing, the treasury is burning, or Smaug has somehow returned from the dead, I do not have time for visitors!”

The guard froze.

Kíli glanced toward him.

Then back at his brother.

“You could at least hear him out.”

Fíli stared at him.

“We are in the middle of a rather important discussion!”

“And perhaps the visitors have something important to say.”

“Then they can wait!”

The guard looked increasingly miserable.

He opened his mouth.

Closed it.

Then glanced desperately toward the corridor.

Because standing just beyond the doorway was Thorin Oakenshield.

_____________

 

The former King under the Mountain had heard enough of the conversation to understand precisely what his nephews were arguing about.

And judging by the expression upon his face, he was not particularly impressed that they had spent over an hour circling a problem whose solution was now beginning to seem rather obvious.

Bilbo stood behind him.

His lips were pressed together in a determined attempt not to smile.

Thorin stepped forward.

“You're both overlooking the obvious.”

Kíli frowned.

He had been holding a rolled military report, one end resting against the map.

“Who—”

Thorin continued before he could finish.

“Keep the northern pass open for supply caravans. Send the merchants through in smaller, guarded groups rather than allowing them to travel independently. Station your scouts above the ravine, where they can observe the approaches, instead of spreading your soldiers along the entire road.”

He glanced at the map.

“Use the existing patrols to escort each group through the most dangerous section, then send them back for the next. You'll protect the settlements, keep the merchants moving, and avoid stripping the western road of its defences.”

For a moment, nobody spoke.

Kíli stared at the map.

It was a good solution.

A remarkably good solution.

It addressed the concerns both brothers had spent the past hour arguing about.

And it had been delivered in a voice that Kíli knew better than almost any other.

He slowly raised his head.

The report slipped halfway from his fingers.

He caught it at the last moment.

His mouth fell open.

Fíli, meanwhile, had chosen precisely the wrong moment to take another sip of tea.

He looked toward the doorway.

Saw the dwarf standing there.

And promptly nearly choked.

He coughed violently, nearly spilling the cup across his desk.

Kíli remained frozen.

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Do try not to drown yourself, Fíli. I would hate to discover that the King under the Mountain was defeated by a cup of tea.”

Bilbo, standing just behind his husband, covered his mouth.

His shoulders were shaking.

Fíli set down the cup with considerable difficulty.

He stared.

Kíli finally managed to speak.

“U-Uncle?”

Thorin folded his arms.

“Hello, lads.”

Bilbo stepped into view beside him, smiling broadly.

“Hello, boys. I see we're interrupting something.”

Fíli looked from Thorin to Bilbo.

Then back again.

His expression suggested that his mind had temporarily abandoned all useful functions.

Thorin glanced once more at the map.

“Of course, that is merely my suggestion. The decision is yours, Fíli. You're the king.”

Fíli blinked.

Kíli looked as though he might drop his report again.

Thorin waited.

Neither brother moved.

At last, the dwarf sighed.

“Well? Are neither of you going to greet your uncle?”

Chapter 5: Chapter Five — An Unexpected Little Brother

Chapter Text

For several moments, the royal study remained perfectly silent.

It was an extraordinary achievement, considering that scarcely a minute earlier, the room had been filled with the increasingly heated voices of two brothers arguing over military patrols, winter provisions, and the proper distribution of Erebor's soldiers.

Now, however, King Fíli sat behind his desk with a teacup clutched in one hand, staring at the doorway as though he had just witnessed the resurrection of Durin himself.

Kíli stood beside the map table, his mouth hanging open.

And Thorin Oakenshield, former King under the Mountain, regarded both his nephews with the mildly impatient expression of a dwarf who had expected a rather warmer welcome.

“Well?” he repeated. “Have you both forgotten how to speak?”

The rolled report finally slipped from Kíli's fingers.

It struck the floor with a hollow thump.

“UNCLE!”

Thorin barely had time to brace himself.

Kíli crossed the room in three enormous strides and collided with him hard enough to make Bilbo, standing just behind his husband, take a precautionary step backward.

Thorin grunted.

“By Mahal, lad! Have you mistaken me for a training dummy?”

Kíli ignored him completely.

His arms were wrapped around his uncle, his face buried against Thorin's shoulder, and for all his considerable height and broad shoulders, there was something unmistakably boyish about the way he clung to him.

“You're here!”

“So it would seem.”

“You're actually here!”

“An excellent observation.”

“You didn't tell us!”

Thorin drew back enough to look at him.

“I most certainly did.”

“No, you didn't!”

“I wrote a letter.”

“What letter?”

Thorin frowned.

Before he could answer, Fíli finally recovered from his astonishment.

He set his teacup down, pushed his chair backward, and rose so abruptly that the heavy wooden legs scraped across the floor.

For one brief moment, he looked every inch the King under the Mountain: tall, broad-shouldered, his golden hair neatly braided, his dark blue tunic embroidered with silver, and a circlet resting upon his brow.

Then he abandoned the dignity of his office entirely.

“Uncle!”

Thorin barely managed to release Kíli before Fíli reached him.

The embrace was different from his younger brother's. Fíli did not throw himself forward quite so recklessly, but the strength with which he wrapped his arms around Thorin spoke of years spent missing someone who had once been the centre of his childhood.

Thorin's expression softened.

He held his eldest nephew close, one hand settling against the back of his head.

“There you are, lad,” he murmured.

Fíli let out a breath that sounded suspiciously unsteady.

“You could have warned us.”

“I did warn you.”

“We received nothing.”

Thorin sighed.

“So I am beginning to understand.”

Bilbo, who had been watching with a smile, cleared his throat.

“I hate to interrupt this touching reunion, but I believe I deserve a greeting as well.”

Kíli turned so quickly that he nearly struck the map table.

“UNCLE BILBO!”

“Oh, heavens—”

Bilbo disappeared into an enthusiastic embrace.

Kíli lifted him clean off the floor.

“Kíli!” Bilbo protested, laughing despite himself. “Put me down! I'm not a sack of potatoes!”

“It's been ages!”

“It has been considerably less than an age!”

Fíli released Thorin and approached them, grinning.

“Kíli, put him down before you break him.”

“I am not going to break him!”

“You said that about Mother's favourite chair.”

“That chair was old!”

“It was three months old.”

Bilbo was finally returned to the floor, whereupon Fíli embraced him more carefully.

“It's wonderful to see you, Uncle Bilbo.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“And you, my dear boy.”

For a moment, he held Fíli close.

He remembered the young dwarf who had travelled beside them so many years ago, full of courage and determination, his golden hair frequently tangled by the wind. The dwarf before him was older now, carrying responsibilities that had once belonged to Thorin, but the affection in his eyes remained unchanged.

When they separated, Bilbo reached up to straighten Fíli's slightly crooked circlet.

“There,” he said. “Much better.”

Fíli laughed.

“You haven't changed.”

“Oh, I assure you, I have. My knees complain far more than they used to.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Your knees complained before we reached Rivendell on our first journey.”

“And whose fault was that?”

Kíli grinned.

“Uncle Thorin's, probably.”

“Precisely,” Bilbo declared.

Thorin shook his head.

He had been home for less than ten minutes, and already the entire family had united against him.

Some things, apparently, never changed.

It took another quarter of an hour before anyone remembered that the original purpose of the meeting had been to discuss military arrangements.

Fíli finally cleared a space on his desk and ordered fresh tea, along with something to eat. Bilbo accepted immediately. Thorin declined until Bilbo reminded him that they had travelled since morning, at which point he reconsidered.

Kíli remained standing close to his uncle, occasionally looking at him as though afraid he might disappear if left unattended.

“So,” Fíli said, settling into his chair again, “about this letter.”

Thorin explained when it had been sent.

Bilbo described the messenger who had collected it.

Neither could account for its disappearance.

“We assumed it had arrived,” Bilbo said. “When no answer came, we thought perhaps you were too busy preparing for winter.”

Fíli gave him a rueful smile.

“I have been busy, but I would have found time to answer that letter.”

“Of course you would, sweetheart.”

Kíli leaned against the desk.

“Well, at least we know why nobody told us.”

Fíli looked at him.

“Know what?”

“That Uncle Thorin was coming.”

“Yes, Kíli. We have established that.”

“I only mean that you nearly died because of a missing letter.”

Bilbo choked on his tea.

Thorin looked thoroughly amused.

Fíli slowly closed his eyes.

“I did not nearly die.”

“You nearly drowned in your own teacup.”

“I was surprised.”

“Very surprised.”

“Kíli.”

“I thought I might have to explain to Mother that her eldest son had been defeated by breakfast.”

“It was afternoon tea!”

“Even worse.”

Thorin chuckled.

Fíli pointed a warning finger at his brother.

“Not another word.”

Kíli opened his mouth.

Fíli raised his finger higher.

Kíli closed it again.

For approximately three seconds.

Then he grinned.

“Imagine what the historians would write.”

Fíli reached for the nearest cushion.

Thorin intercepted it before it could become a projectile.

“Enough, both of you.”

The brothers fell silent.

Bilbo smiled into his cup.

Thorin looked between them, and something in his expression softened.

There had been a time when these two had barely reached his waist, when Kíli had followed Fíli everywhere and Fíli had considered himself responsible for preventing his younger brother from getting into trouble.

Now one ruled a kingdom, and the other commanded soldiers.

Yet beneath the years and responsibilities, they remained unmistakably themselves.

He was proud of them.

More than either would ever fully understand.

_____________

 

“There is something else,” Thorin said after a moment.

Both brothers looked up.

Bilbo placed his cup down.

“We didn't come alone.”

Kíli blinked.

“Who else is here?”

“A young hobbit,” Thorin answered. “His name is Frodo.”

Fíli smiled curiously.

“A friend of yours?”

Thorin exchanged a glance with Bilbo.

“Family,” he said.

That single word changed the atmosphere.

Kíli straightened.

Fíli waited.

Thorin took a moment to gather his thoughts before explaining.

“Frodo is Bilbo's young cousin. He's eleven years old. A few months ago, he lost both his parents in an accident on the Brandywine.”

The brothers' expressions changed immediately.

Kíli's smile faded.

Fíli sat a little straighter.

Neither interrupted.

“He was staying with relatives in Buckland,” Bilbo continued quietly. “They cared for him, of course, but there were so many people, and he was terribly overwhelmed. We went to see him, and…”

He looked toward Thorin.

His husband reached across the table and took his hand.

“We brought him home,” Thorin finished. “We've adopted him.”

For a moment, neither nephew spoke.

Then Fíli asked gently, “How is he?”

“Better than he was,” Bilbo answered. “Some days are easier than others.”

Kíli looked down at his hands.

He remembered being small enough that his father's absence had seemed impossible to understand. He remembered waking in the night and asking his mother questions she could not answer. He remembered Fíli trying to be brave for both of them, even though he had been little more than a child himself.

And he remembered Thorin.

His uncle had not made the grief disappear.

He had simply remained.

He had repaired broken toys, listened to frightened questions, and carried two exhausted little dwarves to bed when they had cried themselves to sleep.

Kíli looked up.

“Does he know about us?”

Thorin nodded.

“Quite a lot, actually.”

Fíli smiled faintly.

“Should we be concerned?”

“Very,” Bilbo said.

Kíli groaned.

“You've told him stories.”

“Several.”

“Which ones?”

Thorin's expression became suspiciously innocent.

“Oh, a little of everything.”

Kíli stared.

“Uncle.”

But Thorin's amusement faded into something gentler.

“I wanted to speak with you before bringing him in. He's a good lad. Curious, clever, and rather shy when meeting new people. I don't want him to feel overwhelmed.”

Fíli nodded immediately.

“Of course.”

“He's still grieving,” Bilbo added. “And he's only just begun feeling truly settled with us.”

Kíli's expression softened.

“We understand.”

Thorin looked at them both.

He knew they did.

Perhaps better than anyone else in the Mountain.

Fíli rose.

“Then we'd better make sure his first visit to Erebor is a pleasant one.”

Kíli nodded eagerly.

“Absolutely.”

Thorin regarded his younger nephew.

“And that means no frightening him with stories about goblins, no dragging him through the armoury, and no teaching him anything that would cause Bilbo to develop a headache.”

Kíli looked offended.

“Why are you looking at me?”

“Experience.”

Fíli laughed.

Bilbo sighed.

“I am already beginning to regret bringing him.”

_______________

 

Frodo was sitting upon a cushioned bench in the corridor when Bilbo came to fetch him.

One of the guards had been telling him about the enormous stone pillars supporting the halls, and Frodo had listened with such fascination that the dwarf seemed almost disappointed when their conversation ended.

“Ready, sweetheart?” Bilbo asked.

Frodo looked toward the study doors.

“Are they nice?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Very.”

“Even Kíli?”

Bilbo paused.

“Well…”

“Bilbo,” Thorin called from behind him.

“Perfectly lovely,” Bilbo corrected.

Frodo smiled nervously.

Then he stood, clutching his little travelling bag.

The wooden bird he had carved at Bag End was tucked carefully into one of its outer pockets, its rounded head peeking above the fabric.

Bilbo offered his hand.

Frodo took it.

Together, they entered the study.

Fíli had removed his circlet.

It rested upon the desk beside the maps, and without it he looked rather less like the imposing King under the Mountain and considerably more like the friendly dwarf Frodo had imagined from his uncles' stories.

Kíli stood beside him.

Both brothers smiled.

“Hello, Frodo,” Fíli said warmly.

The boy stopped just inside the doorway.

“Hello.”

“I'm Fíli.”

Fíli crouched so they could speak at a more comfortable height.

“And this is my brother, Kíli.”

Kíli bent slightly.

“Hello, little one.”

Frodo looked between them.

He had expected dwarves.

He had not expected quite so much dwarf.

Both brothers were considerably taller and broader than he had imagined, with thick hair, braided beards, and clothes that looked much grander than anything worn in Hobbiton.

Kíli, in particular, seemed fascinated by him.

He had known hobbits before, of course. Bilbo had been part of his life for years.

But Frodo was so small.

Even compared with dwarven children of a similar age, he was tiny, with soft brown curls, round cheeks, and bare little feet peeking beneath his travelling trousers.

Kíli had the sudden, rather absurd urge to wrap him in a blanket and make certain nobody ever spoke sharply to him.

Instead, he smiled.

“Did you enjoy the journey?”

Frodo nodded.

“We went to Rivendell.”

Fíli's eyes brightened.

“Did you? What did you think of it?”

“It was beautiful. Lord Elrond gave me a notebook.”

“That's very kind of him.”

“He's very old.”

Kíli laughed.

“That he is.”

“Older than Uncle Thorin.”

Bilbo made a strangled noise.

Fíli pressed his lips together.

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Most people are younger than Lord Elrond, lad.”

Frodo considered that.

Then he looked at Kíli.

“Uncle Bilbo says you once tried to teach a goat to climb stairs.”

Kíli's smile vanished.

Fíli burst out laughing.

Thorin looked delighted.

Bilbo suddenly became interested in examining a nearby tapestry.

Kíli stared at the little hobbit.

“He told you that?”

Frodo nodded.

“And the goat ate Fíli's scarf.”

Fíli laughed harder.

“It did!”

Kíli turned toward Thorin.

“You promised never to tell anyone!”

“I recall making no such promise.”

“You said we'd never speak of it again!”

“An entirely different matter.”

Frodo giggled.

Kíli looked back at him.

For a moment, he tried to appear offended.

Then he smiled.

“Well, I suppose you've already heard the worst of me.”

Frodo shook his head.

“Uncle Thorin said you were very brave.”

Kíli blinked.

The words were so unexpected, and delivered with such innocent certainty, that he found himself momentarily speechless.

Thorin's expression softened.

Fíli watched his brother with a quiet smile.

Then Kíli cleared his throat.

“Well,” he said, “your uncle is a very wise dwarf.”

Bilbo snorted.

Thorin gave him a look.

Frodo smiled.

And just like that, some of his nervousness disappeared.

They spoke for a while about the journey, the places Frodo had seen, and his first impressions of Erebor.

Fíli asked thoughtful questions.

Kíli occasionally interrupted with enthusiastic suggestions about things Frodo ought to see.

Neither pressed him when he grew quiet.

Then Kíli noticed something sticking out of the boy's travelling bag.

“What's that?”

Frodo looked down.

“My carving.”

“You carve?”

Frodo brightened.

“Uncle Thorin teaches me.”

Kíli's eyes widened.

“Does he?”

Frodo carefully retrieved the little wooden figure.

It was small and rounded, carved from a piece of soft wood and polished with considerable care. Its proportions were not entirely correct, and one wing was noticeably thicker than the other, but Frodo had worked very hard on it.

Kíli leaned closer.

“Did you make that little cow yourself?”

Silence.

Frodo looked up.

His eyebrows drew together.

“It's a bird.”

Kíli blinked.

He looked at the carving.

Then at Frodo.

Then back at the carving.

“Oh.”

Frodo held it up.

“It has wings.”

“Yes,” Kíli said quickly. “Of course.”

“And a beak.”

“Right.”

“Cows don't have beaks.”

Fíli made a peculiar sound.

Bilbo covered his mouth.

Thorin looked away, his shoulders beginning to shake.

Kíli felt a dreadful sinking sensation.

He had somehow managed to offend the smallest, sweetest creature he had ever met.

And he had done it by calling a bird a cow.

“Of course they don't,” he agreed hastily. “I can see that now. It's a very fine bird.”

Frodo narrowed his eyes.

“You thought it was a cow.”

Kíli looked helplessly toward his brother.

Fíli offered absolutely no assistance.

“It's a very impressive first carving,” Kíli tried again.

Frodo continued looking at him.

Kíli panicked.

“Would you like to see the markets tomorrow?”

Frodo blinked.

“The markets?”

“Yes! In Dale. There are all sorts of wonderful things there.”

Frodo's expression softened slightly.

“Really?”

“Absolutely. And I'll show you the workshops here in Erebor, too.”

Frodo considered this.

“Can we see where they make swords?”

Bilbo immediately looked up.

“Kíli—”

“Of course!”

“Kíli!”

“And you can choose something from the market,” Kíli added hurriedly. “A present. Anything you like.”

Frodo stared.

“Anything?”

Kíli nodded.

“Anything.”

Frodo looked down at his bird.

Then back at Kíli.

After a moment, he smiled.

“All right. I forgive you.”

Kíli nearly sagged with relief.

Fíli finally lost his battle with laughter.

“You've known him for ten minutes,” he told his brother.

Kíli shrugged.

“And?”

“You've already promised him a shopping trip.”

“He deserves one.”

“You called his bird a cow.”

“Must you keep mentioning that?”

Frodo looked up.

“It is a bird.”

“Yes,” Kíli said solemnly. “A magnificent bird.”

Thorin chuckled.

Bilbo sighed.

He was beginning to suspect that his son had discovered a remarkably effective way of acquiring presents.

________________

 

Dís received the news of her brother's arrival while supervising arrangements for the winter stores.

The messenger barely finished speaking before she abandoned her work.

By the time Thorin and Bilbo reached her chambers, she was already waiting in the doorway.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

Thorin stopped.

Bilbo smiled nervously.

Kíli whispered, “Oh, you're in trouble.”

Thorin gave him a warning glance.

Dís folded her arms.

“Would you care to explain why I have just been informed that my brother is wandering around Erebor without having sent so much as a letter?”

“I sent a letter.”

“So everyone keeps telling me.”

“It appears to have been lost.”

Dís regarded him for another moment.

Then she crossed the space between them and embraced him fiercely.

Thorin held his sister close.

For a while, neither spoke.

When she finally drew back, her eyes were suspiciously bright.

“You ridiculous dwarf,” she murmured.

Thorin smiled.

“It's good to see you too.”

She embraced Bilbo next.

Then her gaze fell upon Frodo.

Thorin quietly explained who he was.

Dís listened without interrupting.

When she understood, her expression softened.

She crouched before the boy.

“Hello, Frodo. I'm Dís.”

Frodo bowed politely.

“Hello, Lady Dís.”

“Oh, none of that,” she said warmly. “Dís will do perfectly well.”

Frodo smiled shyly.

“I've heard about you.”

“Have you?”

He nodded.

“Uncle Thorin says you were very brave when Fíli and Kíli were little.”

Dís looked toward her brother.

Thorin merely smiled.

“Well,” she said, returning her attention to Frodo, “I had two rather troublesome sons. Someone had to be brave.”

“Mother!” Kíli protested.

Frodo giggled.

Dís offered him her hand.

“Come along, sweetheart. Let's find you somewhere comfortable to sit. You've had a very long journey.”

She did not overwhelm him with questions or insist upon an embrace.

Instead, she showed him the sitting room, offered him something warm to drink, and asked whether he would prefer biscuits or a little cake.

Frodo considered the question seriously.

“Could I have both?”

Dís laughed.

“Of course you may.”

Bilbo smiled.

Thorin watched his sister lead the boy toward the hearth.

For a moment, he remembered her as a young mother, exhausted and grieving, trying to remain strong for two little boys who had lost their father.

Now those boys were grown.

And here she was, welcoming another child with the same gentle patience she had once shown her own.

He felt a quiet warmth settle in his chest.

Dís glanced back at him.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

She narrowed her eyes.

“You're smiling.”

“Am I not allowed?”

“Not like that. It usually means you've done something troublesome.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Then I fear you've missed rather a lot."

________________

 

By evening, Frodo had been shown the beautiful chambers prepared for their stay.

He had a bedroom of his own adjoining Bilbo and Thorin's, with a comfortable bed, thick blankets, and a window overlooking part of the city.

His parents' picture stood upon the bedside table.

His wooden fox rested beside it.

And his little bird, having survived its unfortunate encounter with Kíli's artistic judgement, occupied a place of honour near the window.

Frodo had also met Balin, who greeted him with immediate warmth and offered to show him Erebor's library.

Bombur, upon discovering that Bilbo had brought a young hobbit, insisted that the kitchens prepare something especially suitable for a growing lad.

Bofur promised stories.

Dwalin looked at Frodo, looked at Thorin, and said only, “Another one, eh?”

Thorin smiled.

“Apparently.”

Dwalin grunted.

Then, after a moment, he offered Frodo a small honey biscuit from a plate.

Frodo accepted.

Bilbo decided that this was probably the dwarven equivalent of a heartfelt declaration of affection.

By the time supper arrived, Frodo was tired but happy.

The family gathered in a smaller dining room rather than the enormous royal hall.

There were no elaborate ceremonies, no long tables filled with unfamiliar nobles, and no expectation that Frodo must sit quietly while important people discussed important matters.

Instead, there was warm food, candlelight, laughter, and the familiar comfort of people who loved one another.

Frodo sat between Bilbo and Thorin at first.

Across from him were Fíli and Kíli.

Dís sat near the head of the table, watching her sons with the expression of a mother who had long since accepted that peaceful meals were an unreasonable expectation.

For a while, conversation centred upon Bag End.

Fíli asked about Thorin's workshop.

Kíli was astonished to discover that children regularly visited.

“You let them use your tools?”

“Under supervision,” Thorin answered.

“And you made Frodo a chair?”

“A raised chair so he can reach the workbench.”

Kíli looked delighted.

“Did you carve anything on it?”

“A fox,” Frodo answered proudly.

Fíli smiled.

“Uncle used to make things for us too.”

Frodo looked up.

“Really?”

“Oh, yes,” Fíli said. “He repaired half our toys when we were little.”

“And made the other half,” Kíli added.

Thorin shook his head.

“You broke most of them.”

“Only because we played with them.”

“You attempted to use a wooden horse as a battering ram.”

Kíli grinned.

“It was a very sturdy horse.”

“Until you broke its head off.”

Frodo giggled.

Fíli leaned forward.

“And did Uncle Thorin teach you to carve that bird?”

Frodo nodded.

“He showed me how to sand it and make the shape. I did most of it myself.”

Fíli examined the little carving, which Frodo had brought along to show Dís.

He turned it carefully in his hands.

“You've done very well,” he said sincerely. “The wings must have taken patience.”

Frodo beamed.

“They did!”

Kíli leaned closer.

“It really is a lovely bird.”

Frodo looked at him suspiciously.

“You still think it's a cow.”

Fíli nearly dropped the carving.

Bilbo burst out laughing.

Kíli groaned.

“I am never going to escape this, am I?”

“No,” Thorin answered.

Dís looked between them.

“What have you done?”

“Nothing,” Kíli said quickly.

“He called my bird a cow,” Frodo explained.

Dís stared at her son.

Then she laughed so hard that she had to put down her fork.

Kíli buried his face in his hands.

Fíli looked delighted.

It was, Thorin decided, a very pleasant supper.

______________

 

The question came after the main meal, when the servants had cleared away the dishes and brought out small cakes, fruit preserves, and a magnificent pudding that had immediately captured Frodo's attention.

The boy had been unusually thoughtful for several minutes.

He watched Fíli pass Kíli a plate.

He watched Thorin speak quietly with Dís.

Then he looked toward Bilbo.

“Uncle Bilbo?”

“Yes, sweetheart?”

“Can I ask something?”

“Of course.”

Frodo hesitated.

He looked across the table at Fíli and Kíli.

“If Uncle Thorin is your uncle…”

Kíli nodded.

“He is.”

“And Uncle Bilbo is your uncle too?”

“Certainly,” Fíli answered.

Frodo frowned slightly, concentrating.

“And they're my uncles, but they've adopted me…”

Bilbo waited patiently.

Thorin set down his cup.

Frodo looked between the brothers.

“Does that mean you could be my brothers?”

The room grew quiet.

Not uncomfortably so.

But enough that Frodo suddenly wondered whether he had asked something foolish.

He lowered his eyes.

“I only meant…”

Fíli's expression softened.

He remembered being a child and trying to understand how families could change after someone was lost.

He remembered how frightened he had been of losing anyone else.

And he understood, perhaps better than Frodo realised, how much courage it had taken to ask.

“Frodo,” he said gently, “if you'd like us to be your brothers, we'd be very happy about that.”

Frodo looked up.

“Really?”

Kíli smiled.

“Very happy.”

The boy considered this.

Then his face brightened.

“I think I'd like that.”

Thorin felt Bilbo's hand find his beneath the table.

He squeezed it.

Kíli was smiling so broadly that Fíli suspected his cheeks might begin hurting.

“Well, then,” Kíli declared, “I suppose that makes you our little brother.”

Frodo giggled.

Fíli smiled.

“Welcome to the family, Frodo.”

“Thank you.”

For a while, the conversation returned to other things.

But Kíli had begun looking at Frodo with an expression that suggested he had just been entrusted with the most wonderful responsibility imaginable.

And naturally, he decided that responsibility involved education.

“Now,” he said, leaning toward the boy, “there's something very important I need to teach you.”

Frodo looked interested.

“What?”

Kíli grinned.

“How to annoy your older brothers.”

Fíli slowly lowered his fork.

“Kíli.”

“It's essential knowledge.”

“Kíli, don't.”

Frodo's eyes widened.

“How?”

“Well, first, you must learn to ask questions at inconvenient moments.”

Bilbo stared.

“Kíli!”

“And you should occasionally borrow things without asking.”

Fíli folded his arms.

“I am warning you.”

“Then there's the art of making very innocent faces when you've done something wrong.”

Frodo listened with enormous concentration.

Thorin watched him.

Then he looked at Kíli.

A slow smile appeared beneath his beard.

Bilbo noticed immediately.

“Thorin, do not encourage this.”

“I haven't said a word.”

“You're smiling.”

“Am I not allowed to smile at supper?”

Fíli studied his younger brother for a moment.

Then his own expression changed.

He appeared to have realised something.

Something rather important.

But instead of interrupting, he merely reached for his wine.

Kíli continued explaining his techniques.

Frodo nodded solemnly.

He did not attempt any of them.

Not yet.

And Kíli remained blissfully unaware that he had just provided his newest little brother with a remarkably useful education.

_______________

 

The second question arrived halfway through dessert.

Frodo had been carefully eating his pudding when he suddenly looked up.

“Fíli?”

“Yes, Frodo?”

“You're the king, aren't you?”

Fíli nodded.

“I am.”

“And Kíli is a prince?”

“Yes.”

Frodo considered this.

Then he asked, with complete innocence, “Does that mean I'm a prince too?”

Kíli answered immediately.

“Of course!”

Bilbo nearly dropped his spoon.

“I BEG YOUR PARDON?”

Frodo jumped slightly.

Bilbo immediately softened his voice.

“Sorry, sweetheart. I didn't mean to shout.”

Then he turned toward Kíli.

“What do you mean, of course?”

Kíli looked puzzled.

“Well, he's our little brother.”

“Yes?”

“And I'm a prince.”

“Yes?”

“And Fíli's the king.”

“I am aware of that!”

Kíli spread his hands.

“So it makes sense.”

Bilbo stared at him.

“It most certainly does not!”

Thorin calmly took another bite of his supper.

Bilbo turned toward him.

“Thorin?”

His husband looked up.

“Yes, ghivashel?”

“Say something.”

Thorin considered the matter.

“Well, technically, Frodo is my adopted son.”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Thorin, do not encourage this.”

“And I am still a member of the royal house.”

“Thorin.”

“Therefore—”

“THORIN!”

Frodo looked between them, fascinated.

Fíli, meanwhile, had grown unusually quiet.

Bilbo noticed.

His stomach sank.

“Fíli?”

The young king was looking thoughtfully at Frodo.

“Actually…”

Bilbo went pale.

“No.”

Fíli looked up.

“What?”

“No, no, no. Absolutely not.”

“Uncle Bilbo, I haven't said anything yet.”

“You were about to!”

Kíli grinned.

“See? Fíli agrees with me.”

“I have not agreed to anything,” Fíli said.

Then he paused.

“Although…”

Bilbo stared at him in horror.

Fíli leaned back in his chair.

“Frodo is Uncle Thorin's adopted son. That makes him part of our family, and Uncle Thorin remains a member of the House of Durin.”

“Precisely,” Kíli said.

Fíli continued thoughtfully.

“It would be rather unusual for him to be the only member of our immediate family without royal recognition.”

Bilbo looked as though someone had struck him over the head with a frying pan.

“He's a hobbit!”

Kíli blinked.

“We noticed.”

“KÍLI!”

Frodo giggled.

Fíli raised a hand.

“Uncle Bilbo, I understand your concern.”

“Do you?”

“Yes.”

“Because I am beginning to suspect nobody at this table understands my concern!”

Thorin looked amused.

Dís had quietly set down her wine and was watching the conversation with growing interest.

Fíli spoke gently.

“I'm not suggesting that Frodo should suddenly inherit responsibilities he doesn't understand. Nor would I make him an heir to the throne simply because he's part of our family.”

Bilbo looked slightly less alarmed.

“But an honorary princely title,” Fíli continued, “could be a meaningful way of formally recognising him as part of the House of Durin.”

Bilbo's relief vanished.

“Oh, heavens.”

Kíli looked delighted.

“Prince Frodo!”

Frodo's eyes widened.

“Really?”

Bilbo turned toward him.

“Sweetheart, being a prince is a very serious matter.”

Frodo considered this.

“Would I have to wear a crown?”

“Not necessarily,” Fíli answered.

“Would I have to sit in meetings?”

“No.”

“Would I have to learn to fight?”

Kíli opened his mouth.

Bilbo pointed at him.

“Don't.”

Kíli closed it again.

Frodo thought for another moment.

Then he asked, with genuine concern, “Would I still be allowed second breakfast?”

The table fell silent.

Thorin set down his fork.

“Frodo,” he said gravely, “any kingdom that denies its prince second breakfast is not worth ruling.”

Kíli burst out laughing.

Fíli covered his face.

Dís shook her head, smiling.

Bilbo stared at his husband.

“You are not helping.”

“I answered the lad's question.”

“You are actively encouraging this!”

Thorin looked entirely unrepentant.

Fíli cleared his throat.

“Uncle Bilbo, nothing will happen without discussing it properly with you and Uncle Thorin. And Frodo, of course.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“Promise?”

“I promise.”

Kíli leaned toward Frodo.

“But I still think you'd make an excellent prince.”

Frodo smiled.

Bilbo groaned.

Then Fíli added, rather thoughtfully, “We could perhaps discuss the matter before Yule.”

Bilbo slowly turned his head.

“Before what?”

Fíli smiled.

“Yule.”

Bilbo looked toward the ceiling.

He had survived trolls.

He had survived goblins.

He had survived giant spiders, a dragon, and the Battle of Five Armies.

He had even survived marrying Thorin Oakenshield.

Yet somehow, none of those experiences had prepared him for the possibility that his eleven-year-old hobbit son might become a prince of Erebor.

And the truly dreadful part was that everyone else seemed to think it was a perfectly reasonable idea.

The remainder of supper did little to improve Bilbo's peace of mind.

Kíli had apparently decided that becoming an older brother required him to take a personal interest in Frodo's education.

This would have been a lovely sentiment had his ideas not included archery, swordsmanship, riding, climbing, and the exploration of Erebor's lesser-known passages.

“I could teach him to shoot a bow,” Kíli suggested.

Frodo brightened.

“Really?”

“Of course!”

Bilbo looked horrified.

“He's eleven!”

“So was I when I began learning.”

Fíli sighed.

“That is not the reassuring argument you think it is.”

“And he could learn to ride.”

“Perhaps,” Thorin said.

“And we could visit the training grounds.”

“Under supervision,” Fíli added.

“And the armoury!”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Why must everything involve weapons?”

Kíli looked genuinely confused.

“Because they're interesting?”

Dís laughed.

Bilbo turned toward her.

“Surely you understand my concern.”

“Oh, I do,” she answered.

Bilbo looked relieved.

Then she continued, “I had exactly the same concerns when those two were small.”

Bilbo glanced toward Fíli and Kíli.

“And how did you manage?”

Dís smiled sweetly.

“I threatened to lock the armoury.”

Kíli groaned.

“Mother!”

“It worked for almost three days.”

Fíli laughed.

Thorin leaned back in his chair, watching the conversation unfold.

Across the table, Frodo was listening with wide-eyed fascination.

_______________

 

He had grown more comfortable throughout the evening. His shoulders were no longer drawn up with nervousness, and he had begun speaking without first glancing toward Bilbo for reassurance.

Kíli was making him laugh.

Fíli was answering his questions seriously.

Dís had quietly ensured that his plate remained full.

And whenever Frodo looked toward Thorin, the dwarf offered him a reassuring smile.

For a moment, Thorin was struck by a memory.

Two little dwarven boys sitting at a kitchen table.

Fíli trying very hard not to cry.

Kíli clinging to his brother's sleeve.

Dís standing near the hearth, exhausted and pale, doing everything she could to hold her family together.

Thorin had been younger then, carrying grief of his own, uncertain whether he possessed the wisdom required to help raise two children who had lost their father.

He had made mistakes.

Many of them.

But he had loved those boys fiercely.

And now they were grown.

One wore a crown.

The other commanded soldiers.

Both had become good, honourable dwarves.

And here they were, welcoming another grieving child into their lives without hesitation.

Thorin felt something warm and almost painfully tender settle beneath his ribs.

Bilbo noticed.

He followed his husband's gaze.

Across the table, Kíli was attempting to convince Frodo that learning to identify gemstones was an essential part of being a prince.

Fíli was explaining that not every royal responsibility involved treasure.

Frodo was asking whether emeralds were more valuable than rubies.

And Dís was trying to persuade everyone to finish their pudding before discussing the entire future of the kingdom.

Bilbo smiled.

He slipped his hand into Thorin's beneath the table.

“They're wonderful with him,” he murmured.

Thorin nodded.

“They are.”

For a moment, Bilbo forgot about the proposed princely title.

Then Kíli announced that Frodo ought to have his own practice sword.

Bilbo's expression changed immediately.

“Oh, absolutely not!”

Thorin chuckled.

And the argument began again.

______________

 

By the time supper ended, Frodo was struggling to keep his eyes open.

He had attempted to hide this fact by sitting very straight in his chair, but the effort had only made his exhaustion more obvious.

Bilbo noticed first.

“Come along, sweetheart. I think it's time for bed.”

Frodo blinked.

“Already?”

“You've had a very long day.”

“But Kíli was going to tell me about the secret passages.”

Kíli opened his mouth.

Fíli caught his sleeve.

“Tomorrow.”

Kíli sighed.

“Tomorrow.”

Frodo considered protesting.

Then he yawned so widely that his eyes watered.

Bilbo smiled.

“Exactly.”

Thorin rose and approached him.

“Come here, lad.”

Frodo lifted his arms without hesitation.

Thorin gathered him up, settling the small hobbit comfortably against his chest.

Frodo rested his head upon his uncle's shoulder.

Kíli watched with an expression of complete adoration.

“He's so small,” he whispered.

Fíli smiled.

“He is.”

“Look at his curls.”

“Kíli.”

“What?”

“Try not to stare.”

“I'm not staring.”

“You've been staring all evening.”

Kíli looked offended.

Then Frodo lifted his head.

“Goodnight, Fíli.”

Fíli's expression softened immediately.

“Goodnight, Frodo.”

“Goodnight, Kíli.”

Kíli smiled so broadly that Fíli wondered whether his brother's face might split in two.

“Goodnight, little brother.”

Frodo smiled sleepily.

Then he settled against Thorin again.

Dís approached and gently brushed a curl from his forehead.

“Sleep well, sweetheart.”

“Goodnight, Dís.”

Bilbo kissed her cheek.

“We'll see you in the morning.”

“Of course.”

Thorin carried Frodo from the dining room, with Bilbo walking beside him.

Behind them, Kíli watched until they disappeared around the corner.

Then he turned toward Fíli.

“We have a little brother.”

Fíli smiled.

“We do.”

Kíli looked delighted.

“A tiny little brother.”

“Yes.”

“With curls.”

“Kíli.”

“And he's adorable.”

Fíli laughed.

“I noticed.”

Kíli folded his arms.

“I think we should take him to Dale tomorrow.”

“You promised him that already.”

“And buy him something.”

“You promised that too.”

“And show him the workshops.”

“Kíli.”

“What?”

Fíli placed a hand upon his brother's shoulder.

“Perhaps we should let him sleep first.”

Kíli considered this.

Then nodded.

“Right.”

A moment passed.

“Do you think he'd like a pony?”

Fíli closed his eyes.

______________

 

Frodo was asleep before Thorin finished carrying him to his room.

Bilbo helped remove his travelling clothes and tucked him beneath the thick blankets.

The boy stirred only once, mumbling something about birds and cows.

Thorin looked toward Bilbo.

His husband pressed his lips together.

Neither managed to remain serious for long.

When Frodo was settled, Bilbo placed the wooden fox beside his pillow and checked that his parents' picture remained safely upon the bedside table.

Then he kissed the boy's forehead.

“Goodnight, sweetheart.”

Thorin brushed a hand over Frodo's curls.

“Sleep well, lad.”

They left the door slightly open.

In the adjoining sitting room, a fire burned quietly.

Bilbo sank into a chair with a sigh.

Thorin poured him a cup of tea.

“Well,” Bilbo said.

Thorin smiled.

“Well?”

“Our son has been in Erebor for less than a day.”

“Yes.”

“And already your nephew has promised him a shopping trip, an archery lesson, and a tour of the armoury.”

“An ambitious schedule.”

“Thorin.”

“And Fíli is considering making him a prince.”

Bilbo stared at him.

“Why are you smiling?”

Thorin sat beside him.

“Because they're happy.”

Bilbo's expression softened despite himself.

Thorin looked toward the fire.

“I wasn't certain how they would react. Not because I doubted their kindness, but because I knew what memories Frodo's circumstances might bring back.”

Bilbo reached for his hand.

“They understood.”

“Aye.”

“And they love him already.”

Thorin smiled.

“I believe they do.”

Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.

For a while, they sat together in comfortable silence.

Then Bilbo sighed.

“I'm still not convinced about the prince business.”

Thorin chuckled.

“I know.”

“He's a hobbit.”

“Yes.”

“A perfectly ordinary little hobbit.”

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo considered his words.

Then sighed again.

“Oh, very well. Perhaps not entirely ordinary.”

Thorin kissed his forehead.

“Whatever happens, he'll still be our Frodo.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Yes,” he murmured. “He will.”

________________

 

A gentle knock sounded at the door.

Thorin looked up.

“Come in.”

Fíli and Kíli entered.

Neither wore formal clothing now. Fíli had exchanged his royal tunic for something simpler, and Kíli had abandoned his weapons belt.

They looked, for a moment, remarkably like the two young dwarves Thorin remembered from years ago.

“Is Frodo asleep?” Fíli asked quietly.

Bilbo nodded.

“Out like a candle.”

Kíli smiled.

“He's had quite a day.”

“He certainly has,” Bilbo said pointedly.

Kíli looked innocent.

Fíli ignored him and approached Thorin.

“Uncle, may we speak with you?”

Thorin gestured toward the chairs.

“Of course.”

The brothers sat.

For a moment, Fíli seemed uncertain how to begin.

Then he looked toward the adjoining room.

“About Frodo…”

Thorin waited.

Fíli folded his hands.

“I know we haven't known him long. And I understand that he may need time to become comfortable with us.”

Thorin nodded.

“But I want you to know that we're very glad he's here.”

Kíli leaned forward.

“Very glad.”

Fíli smiled faintly.

“And if there's anything we can do to help him feel at home, we will.”

Thorin looked at his nephews.

For a moment, he could not find the words.

Then he said quietly, “Thank you.”

Kíli shrugged.

“He's family.”

Fíli nodded.

“And we remember what it was like.”

The room grew still.

Thorin looked at them both.

Fíli's expression was thoughtful.

Kíli's unusually serious.

Their father's death was not something they spoke about often, but it had never truly left them.

Fíli looked down at his hands.

“When Father died, I remember thinking that everything was going to change.”

Thorin listened.

“And it did,” Fíli continued. “But you were there. You helped Mother. You helped us.”

Kíli nodded.

“You made things feel safe again.”

Thorin swallowed.

Bilbo's hand tightened around his.

Fíli looked up.

“I know Frodo's circumstances are different. And I know we can't make him stop missing his parents.”

“No,” Thorin said softly. “You can't.”

“But we can make sure he never feels unwelcome here.”

Kíli nodded firmly.

“And we can make sure he knows he has people who care about him.”

Thorin looked between them.

He remembered carrying them to bed.

Teaching them to hold a hammer.

Watching them grow into warriors.

And later, watching Fíli become the king Thorin had always hoped he would be.

He had never been prouder of them than he was at that moment.

“You're good lads,” he said quietly.

Kíli smiled.

Fíli's eyes softened.

Thorin reached forward and rested a hand upon each of their shoulders.

“Better than I deserve.”

Fíli shook his head.

“No, Uncle.”

Kíli leaned closer.

“You taught us.”

Thorin looked at them for a long moment.

Then he pulled them both into an embrace.

Bilbo watched with a smile, his eyes bright.

For a little while, there were no kings, princes, military reports, or royal responsibilities.

Only a family, reunited beneath the Mountain.

Eventually, Kíli drew back.

“So,” he said, clearing his throat, “about Frodo's education…”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Oh, heavens.”

Fíli groaned.

“Kíli.”

“What?”

“We were having a moment.”

“We can have another moment later.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo shook his head.

And somewhere in the adjoining room, Frodo slept peacefully, entirely unaware that his arrival had already caused more excitement in the royal household than anything since Kíli's last attempt to reorganise the training grounds.

Later that night, Fíli and Kíli walked together through the quiet halls of Erebor.

Most of the Mountain had settled into sleep.

The torches burned low, and their footsteps echoed softly against the polished stone.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then Kíli smiled.

“I still can't believe it.”

Fíli glanced toward him.

“What?”

“That we have a little brother.”

Fíli smiled.

“I know.”

“He's so small.”

“You've mentioned that.”

“And his curls—”

“Kíli.”

“What?”

Fíli laughed.

“Nothing.”

They continued walking.

After a while, Kíli grew thoughtful.

“Do you think he'll like living here?”

Fíli considered.

“I think he'll enjoy visiting. But Bag End is his home now.”

Kíli nodded.

“Right.”

“And we should remember that.”

“I know.”

Fíli looked toward his brother.

Kíli's expression was unusually gentle.

“He's had a difficult time,” Kíli said quietly.

“Yes.”

“I just want him to be happy.”

Fíli smiled.

“So do I.”

They reached the corridor leading toward their separate chambers.

Kíli stopped.

Then he looked at his brother.

“Fíli?”

“Yes?”

“Do you think we could really make him a prince?”

Fíli sighed.

“I knew you were going to ask.”

“Well?”

Fíli considered the question.

It was not entirely simple.

There were traditions to consider, questions of inheritance, and the opinions of certain members of the court who would undoubtedly have something to say about a hobbit receiving a title within the House of Durin.

But there were also more important things.

Frodo was Thorin's son.

He was family.

And Fíli had no intention of allowing anyone to suggest otherwise.

“Perhaps,” he said at last.

Kíli grinned.

“Really?”

“Provided Uncle Bilbo agrees.”

Kíli's smile faltered.

“Oh.”

Fíli laughed.

“Yes. Oh.”

They both knew that persuading Bilbo Baggins would be considerably more difficult than persuading half the royal council.

Kíli considered this.

Then his grin returned.

“We could ask Frodo to help.”

Fíli stopped walking.

“Kíli.”

“What?”

“Do not involve an eleven-year-old in a political negotiation against his own father.”

Kíli looked thoughtful.

“Even if he's very persuasive?”

“Especially then.”

Kíli sighed dramatically.

“Fine.”

Fíli shook his head and continued toward his chambers.

Behind him, Kíli was still smiling.

Because whatever happened with the title, whatever arguments awaited them in the coming days, one thing was certain.

Somewhere in the royal guest chambers, a little hobbit was sleeping beneath warm blankets, with a wooden fox beside his pillow and a badly misunderstood bird upon his windowsill.

And for the first time in their lives, Fíli and Kíli had a younger brother.

Neither could quite believe their good fortune.

Chapter 6: Chapter Six — A Yule Beneath the Mountain

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

By the third morning of their visit to Erebor, Frodo Baggins had discovered three things about the Mountain.

The first was that dwarves considered a staircase of eighty-seven steps a perfectly reasonable shortcut.

The second was that the kitchens possessed at least six different entrances, although Bombur insisted there were only five and became suspiciously evasive whenever Frodo mentioned the sixth.

The third was that Kíli Oakenshield was an extraordinarily patient older brother.

Frodo had decided to investigate the limits of that patience.

It was, after all, Kíli's own fault.

________________

 

Three evenings earlier, the prince had spent a considerable amount of time explaining the finer points of annoying one's elder siblings. Frodo had listened attentively, asked several questions, and committed the most promising methods to memory.

Unfortunately for Kíli, he had neglected one rather important detail.

He was now somebody's elder brother.

"Kíli?"

"Yes, little brother?"

"How old are you?"

Kíli glanced down at the hobbit walking beside him. "Old enough."

"How old is that?"

"Older than you."

"Fíli's older than you."

"Thank you, Frodo. I'd forgotten."

"Does that mean he's better at being an older brother?"

Kíli stumbled.

Behind them, Fíli made a peculiar choking noise.

"No," Kíli said firmly. "It means he's had longer to practise being insufferable."

Frodo considered this.

"Kíli?"

"Yes?"

"What's insufferable?"

"Your eldest brother."

Fíli laughed outright.

They were crossing one of Erebor's upper galleries, where enormous pillars supported a ceiling lost in shadow and the morning light fell through high windows in long, pale ribbons. Far below, the great halls were already busy with merchants, craftsmen, and servants preparing for the coming Yule festivities.

Frodo had insisted upon walking between his brothers, one small hand occasionally catching Kíli's sleeve whenever the galleries grew particularly crowded.

"Kíli?"

"Yes?"

"Can I borrow your knife?"

"No."

"Why?"

"Because Uncle Bilbo would murder me."

"Would he?"

"Without hesitation."

"Would Uncle Thorin let him?"

"He'd help."

Frodo nodded solemnly.

A few moments passed.

"Kíli?"

The prince inhaled slowly.

Fíli, who had been enjoying himself enormously, leaned closer to Frodo.

"Ask him what happened to his first bow."

Kíli rounded on him. "Don't you dare."

Frodo's eyes brightened.

"What happened to your first bow?"

"Nothing."

"He shot Mother's favourite curtain."

"It was an accident!"

"He was aiming at an apple."

"The apple moved!"

Fíli stopped walking.

"The apple," he repeated.

"It was hanging from a branch!"

"Inside the house?"

Kíli pointed at him. "You promised never to mention that again."

"I promised not to mention it to Mother."

Frodo giggled.

By the time they reached the doors of the royal study, Kíli had begun to suspect that the morning was not proceeding entirely in his favour.

Fíli opened the door, stepped aside to let Frodo enter, and murmured to his brother, "He learns quickly."

Kíli frowned.

Then understanding dawned.

"Oh, you little—"

Frodo looked up with the most innocent expression imaginable.

"Yes, Kíli?"

Fíli had to brace himself against the doorframe.

____________

 

The royal study became Frodo's favourite room in Erebor almost by accident.

It was not the grandest chamber in the Mountain. The throne room possessed greater splendour, the treasury considerably more gold, and the libraries more books than Frodo could reasonably hope to read in a lifetime.

But Fíli's study had a large fireplace, a comfortable armchair, and two brothers who never seemed to mind when he wandered in.

At first, Frodo came only when invited.

Then he began appearing after luncheon, usually carrying a book or a collection of drawings. By the end of the first week, Fíli had instructed a servant to bring in a small table, a footstool, and a chair better suited to hobbit proportions.

Kíli contributed a thick blue blanket and a rather battered wooden box filled with pencils.

Fíli eyed the box.

"Where did you find those?"

"My room."

"They look familiar."

"They're pencils."

"They're my pencils."

Kíli inspected one. "Are they?"

"There's an F carved into the side."

"Perhaps it stands for Frodo."

"It stood for Fíli yesterday."

"Well, things change."

From his new chair, Frodo looked between them.

"Can I use them?"

Fíli sighed.

"Of course you can."

Kíli grinned triumphantly.

And that was how Frodo acquired his own little corner of the royal study.

He liked the sound of the fire, the scratch of Fíli's pen, and the familiar rhythm of Kíli moving restlessly between the maps and the desk. Sometimes the brothers discussed matters Frodo did not understand. Sometimes they argued about matters he understood even less.

Mostly, he was content simply to be there.

One afternoon, Kíli arrived carrying three reports and an expression that promised trouble.

"I'm going to have Hárin reassigned."

Fíli did not look up. "Good afternoon to you too."

"The southern watchtower needs a new roof."

"Yes, I know."

"Hárin has requested twelve additional soldiers."

"To repair it?"

"To stand beneath the holes, apparently. I can think of no other reason."

Fíli reached for the report. "Perhaps he means to rotate the men while the repairs are carried out."

"Then he ought to have written that instead of sending me six pages about declining morale."

"Did you speak to him?"

"Of course."

"And?"

"I explained the situation."

Fíli looked over the top of the parchment.

"Politely?"

Kíli hesitated.

From beside the fireplace, Frodo asked, "What does politely mean?"

"Something your brother occasionally remembers to be," Fíli replied.

Kíli dropped into a chair. "I was perfectly diplomatic."

"The last time you said that, Balin received a formal complaint."

"From a merchant who deserved it."

"You threatened to introduce him to the river."

"I said he might benefit from a refreshing swim."

"In November."

"He was wearing a very thick coat."

Frodo quietly wrote something in his notebook.

Fíli noticed.

"What are you writing, little brother?"

"'Diplomatic,'" Frodo answered. "Kíli says it's when you tell somebody they're being foolish without saying it properly."

Fíli closed his eyes.

Kíli looked delighted.

"An excellent definition."

"It is a dreadful definition."

"Then you explain it."

Fíli opened his mouth, considered the considerable complexity of diplomacy, and glanced at the small hobbit waiting expectantly.

"Being diplomatic," he said at last, "means choosing your words carefully so that people will listen to you."

Frodo thought about this.

"Then Kíli isn't very diplomatic."

There was a moment of silence.

Kíli stared.

Fíli lowered his face into his hands.

And Frodo, having reached a satisfactory conclusion, returned to his drawing.

______________

 

Balin and Dwalin discovered the change three days later.

They were approaching the royal study with a collection of documents when Dwalin suddenly stopped.

Balin nearly walked into him.

"What is it?"

Dwalin held up a hand.

They listened.

Nothing.

No raised voices. No furniture scraping across the floor. No exasperated declaration from Fíli that his brother was impossible, followed by Kíli explaining why that was an unreasonable accusation.

Balin frowned.

"Perhaps they're out."

"Both guards are at the door."

"Perhaps they're reading."

Dwalin gave him a look.

Together, they entered.

Fíli was seated behind his desk, examining correspondence. Kíli stood beside a map, discussing the placement of winter patrols in a voice scarcely louder than ordinary conversation.

Frodo was curled up near the fireplace, his blanket over his knees and a cup of chocolate balanced carefully on the table.

Dwalin surveyed the scene.

Then he turned to Balin.

"They've been replaced."

Kíli looked up. "What?"

"Who are you, and what have you done with my nephews?"

Fíli set down his pen. "Good afternoon, Dwalin."

Balin stared at the untouched furniture.

"Remarkable."

"What is?" Fíli asked.

"You've been discussing the northern patrols for twenty minutes," Balin observed, "and nobody has threatened to resign."

"I've never threatened to resign," Kíli protested.

Dwalin snorted.

"Last month you told your brother you were leaving the army and becoming a fisherman."

"That was different."

"You don't know how to fish."

"I could learn."

Frodo looked up.

"Would you take me fishing?"

Kíli's entire expression changed.

"Of course I would, little brother."

Fíli leaned back in his chair, smiling.

Balin slowly turned toward Dwalin.

"Well," he murmured, "I believe we've found the secret."

Dwalin looked at Frodo, then at the remarkably peaceful study.

"Hmph."

It was the sound of a dwarf confronted with a miracle he had no intention of admitting impressed him.

_______________

 

Later that afternoon, Thorin came to see his nephews and reacted much the same way.

He stood in the doorway for several moments, listening to Fíli explain a caravan schedule while Kíli marked a map.

Then he looked at Frodo.

Then back at his nephews.

"Is somebody ill?"

Fíli sighed. "Not you as well."

Thorin's mouth twitched.

"I raised you both. I know what a discussion about caravan schedules usually sounds like."

"We're capable of behaving ourselves," Kíli said.

"Since when?"

Frodo glanced up from his book.

Kíli immediately lowered his voice.

Thorin saw it.

A deep laugh escaped him, and he shook his head.

"All those years," he murmured. "All those years I tried to teach you patience."

"Uncle," Fíli warned.

"And all I required was a hobbit with a cup of chocolate."

Kíli threw a crumpled piece of parchment at him.

Thorin caught it without difficulty.

_______________

 

Erebor grew less intimidating with every passing day.

Kíli took Frodo through the armouries, where swords and axes gleamed beneath the lamps, and showed him the training grounds where dwarven warriors practised beneath the watchful eyes of their captains.

Dwalin, who had initially declared that children had no business wandering through an armoury, spent nearly an hour explaining the difference between ceremonial and practical weapons.

Balin discovered them there.

Frodo was seated on a bench, listening intently while Dwalin demonstrated how a shield's metal rim protected its wooden body.

"I thought you were busy," Balin remarked.

"I am busy."

"Of course."

"The lad asked a question."

"And you've been answering it for forty minutes?"

"It was a complicated question."

Frodo smiled.

"Dwalin says Kíli sometimes holds his sword wrong."

Dwalin went still.

Balin's eyebrows rose.

"Oh, does he?"

"Only when he's showing off," Frodo added helpfully.

Dwalin looked toward the ceiling.

He had made a terrible mistake.

The treasury was another matter entirely.

Frodo had never imagined so much gold could exist in one place.

It glittered beneath the lamps in great heaps, surrounded by jewels, ancient treasures, and objects of craftsmanship so delicate that even Bilbo might have forgotten to complain about the extravagance.

Frodo stood with his mouth open.

"All of this belongs to Fíli?"

"To Erebor," Fíli corrected gently. "I merely have the responsibility of looking after it."

"That sounds difficult."

"It can be."

Frodo studied a particularly enormous golden vessel.

"Does Uncle Thorin still like gold very much?"

Kíli's smile faded slightly.

Fíli glanced toward his brother.

There were memories attached to the treasury that neither wished to revisit casually.

But Kíli crouched beside Frodo and said, "Not nearly as much as he likes Uncle Bilbo."

Frodo considered this.

"Well, Uncle Bilbo does make very good cakes."

Fíli laughed, and even Kíli couldn't help joining him.

"That he does, little brother."

______________

 

Yet it was not the treasury or the armoury that made Frodo feel most at home.

It was knowing where to go when he wanted company.

Sometimes he visited Bombur in the kitchens, where he was invariably fed. Sometimes he found Dís, who had an endless supply of stories about Fíli and Kíli's childhood.

Once, she told him about the time Kíli had tried to hide a frog in Fíli's bed.

"It escaped," she explained.

"Where did it go?"

"Into your Uncle Thorin's boot."

Frodo laughed so hard he nearly spilled his tea.

"And what happened?"

"Your uncle discovered it during a council meeting."

"Did he shout?"

"My dear, I believe they heard him in Dale."

When Kíli later discovered what his mother had been telling Frodo, he accused her of betraying him.

Dís kissed his cheek.

"I have waited years for a sufficiently interested audience."

_______________

 

By the second week, Kíli had developed a habit of glancing at the clock shortly before two.

Fíli noticed it on a particularly cold afternoon.

"You're going to wear a hole through the face of that clock."

Kíli looked away.

"I'm checking the time."

"For the fourth time in ten minutes?"

"I have responsibilities."

"Indeed. And do those responsibilities happen to be approximately three feet tall?"

Kíli gave him a wounded look.

"You're becoming very unpleasant in your old age."

Fíli smiled into his correspondence.

"He's with Uncle Thorin this afternoon. They're working on something."

"What?"

"He wouldn't tell me."

"Suspicious."

"He's eleven, Kíli."

"Exactly. An age at which secrets become dangerous."

Fíli finally looked up.

"You hid a goat in my bedroom when you were eleven."

"And you still haven't forgiven me."

"It ate my boots."

"It was a hungry goat."

Before Fíli could respond, the door opened.

Frodo entered carrying a book almost as large as his chest.

"Sorry I'm late! Bombur gave me biscuits."

Kíli immediately pushed the smaller cup of chocolate toward Frodo's chair.

"Did he give you enough?"

Frodo nodded.

"Six."

"Only six?"

"Kíli," Fíli said.

"What?"

"Bilbo has to feed him supper."

Frodo climbed into his chair, apparently unconcerned by the discussion of his appetite.

Within minutes, the familiar sounds of the study returned.

A pen scratching.

A fire crackling.

Two brothers discussing their work.

And a little hobbit turning pages beside the hearth.

_____________

 

The problem with the winter supply caravans began with a narrow mountain pass.

Three villages beyond Dale were expecting provisions before the heaviest snows arrived. Twelve wagons had been prepared, but recent storms had made the upper road dangerous.

Kíli wanted to divide the caravan into smaller groups.

Fíli pointed out that they did not have enough soldiers to escort every group safely.

"Then we send six wagons at a time."

"And leave the other six waiting another week?"

"Better than losing all twelve."

"You're assuming the pass remains open."

"And you're assuming it closes."

Balin, seated near the desk, watched the exchange with weary familiarity.

Frodo was drawing a picture of a particularly round pony.

He listened for a while before looking up.

"Why do the wagons have to go all the way?"

Kíli glanced toward him.

"What do you mean?"

Frodo set down his pencil.

"Well, when Uncle Bilbo buys too many things in Hobbiton, sometimes he leaves the heavy ones at the shop. Then Uncle Thorin collects them later with a cart."

Fíli went still.

Kíli looked at the map.

Balin leaned forward.

"The old waystation," Fíli murmured.

Kíli straightened.

"Before the narrow pass."

"We could secure it as a supply depot," Balin said thoughtfully.

"Send the larger wagons only that far," Fíli continued. "Then arrange smaller deliveries from there whenever the weather permits."

"With the village headmen organising collections," Kíli added. "We'd need fewer escorts."

For several moments, all three dwarves studied the map.

Frodo returned to his pony.

Eventually Fíli looked up.

"Frodo?"

"Yes?"

"That was a very clever question."

Frodo smiled shyly.

"Thank you."

Kíli grinned.

"Our little brother has just saved us three days of arguing."

"More like six," Balin observed.

"Can I have another hot chocolate?" Frodo asked.

"Two!" Kíli declared.

"One," Fíli corrected.

Balin chuckled.

"Perhaps we ought to appoint him royal adviser."

That was precisely the moment Bilbo entered.

"Appoint whom to what?"

Kíli's expression brightened with terrible enthusiasm.

"Uncle Bilbo! Excellent news. Frodo has solved a royal supply problem."

Bilbo looked at Frodo.

Then at the maps.

Then at Balin.

"He's done what?"

"Quite a sensible suggestion," Balin assured him.

"Naturally," Kíli added, "we're considering a position for him at court."

Bilbo stared.

Fíli pressed his lips together.

"A position?"

"Royal Adviser on Wagons," Kíli suggested.

"And hot chocolate," Frodo contributed.

"An essential responsibility."

Bilbo slowly turned toward Thorin, who had followed him into the room.

"Your nephew is attempting to recruit our son into the royal government."

Thorin looked at the map.

Then at Frodo, who was happily eating a biscuit.

"Is he?"

"THORIN."

Thorin began laughing.

Bilbo threw up his hands.

"We have been here barely a fortnight! First he's to be a prince, now he's advising the king. By spring he'll be commanding the army!"

Dwalin, arriving behind them, considered this.

"He'd probably listen better than Kíli."

"DWALIN!"

Frodo looked rather pleased.

Fíli eventually managed to reassure Bilbo that nobody was appointing an eleven-year-old hobbit to an official position.

Kíli, unfortunately, continued addressing Frodo as "Your Advisership" for the rest of the afternoon.

_______________

 

The trip to Dale took place three days before Yule.

Snow had fallen during the night, covering the rooftops in white and leaving the streets sparkling beneath the winter sun. Evergreen garlands hung above the market stalls, and the air smelled of roasted chestnuts, spiced cakes, and woodsmoke.

Frodo was enchanted.

Kíli was determined to buy him everything.

Fíli was determined to prevent it.

"No."

"I haven't asked anything yet."

"You're looking at that stall."

"It's a perfectly respectable stall."

"It sells wooden swords."

"Precisely."

"He already has a wooden sword."

"Then he could have two."

"Kíli."

"What if he needs a spare?"

Frodo, who had been examining a little carved fox, looked up.

"I don't need another sword."

Fíli smiled triumphantly.

Kíli looked betrayed.

They wandered through the market for hours.

Frodo chose a small book of illustrated stories, a bundle of fine carving wood, and a little tin of coloured pencils. Kíli insisted upon buying him a warm winter cloak after discovering that the hobbit's ears had turned pink from the cold.

Fíli bought him a beautifully made leather satchel to carry his treasures.

At a stall near the eastern square, Frodo stopped.

Among the wooden toys was a small painted boat.

Its hull was blue, its sail white, and a tiny red flag fluttered from the mast.

Frodo reached toward it.

Then withdrew his hand.

Fíli noticed immediately.

"Something wrong?"

Frodo shook his head.

But his smile had disappeared.

Kíli followed his gaze.

"Do you like the boat?"

Frodo nodded.

"My papa used to make them."

The words were barely louder than the market around them.

Fíli crouched beside him.

"Did he?"

Frodo touched the edge of the stall.

"He made one with a blue sail once. We used to race them in the Brandywine. Mama said he cheated because he always gave his boats bigger sails."

A faint smile appeared.

Then it faded.

"I haven't thought about that for a while."

Neither brother hurried him.

After a moment, Kíli rested a hand on his shoulder.

"Come on, little brother. There's an inn nearby that makes excellent chocolate."

Frodo looked uncertainly at the boat.

"We can come back," Fíli promised.

________________

 

The inn was warm and quiet, with a broad hearth and windows clouded by steam. They found a table near the fire, and Kíli ordered three cups of hot chocolate and a plate of honey cakes.

For a while, they spoke about ordinary things.

The market.

The snow.

Whether Kíli had truly needed to purchase an entire bag of sugared almonds.

Then Frodo, staring into his cup, asked, "Does it ever stop hurting?"

Fíli's hand stilled around his mug.

Kíli looked toward the fire.

Neither asked what he meant.

"Not entirely," Fíli answered after a moment. "But it changes."

Frodo looked up.

"When Father died, I thought there would never be a day when I didn't miss him," Fíli continued. "There still are days when I do. But I can remember him now without every memory being painful."

Kíli gave a small, crooked smile.

"I remember his laugh better than his face sometimes. He used to carry me on his shoulders, and Mother would complain that I'd knock my head against the doorframes."

"You did knock your head against a doorframe," Fíli reminded him.

"Once."

"Twice."

"The second time was your fault."

Frodo smiled faintly.

Then he looked down again.

"Sometimes I feel bad when I'm happy."

Fíli waited.

"Because I like Bag End. And Uncle Thorin. And being here with you." Frodo swallowed. "Sometimes I forget to be sad for a little while. Then I remember Mama and Papa, and it feels like I've done something wrong."

Kíli's expression changed.

He reached across the table and gently covered Frodo's hand with his own.

"When Uncle Thorin took care of us after Father died, I loved him terribly," Kíli said. "Still do, though don't tell him. His head's large enough."

Frodo gave a watery laugh.

"But loving Uncle Thorin didn't mean I loved Father any less."

"Nor did laughing again," Fíli added. "Or growing older. Or having good days."

Frodo rubbed his eyes.

"I wish they could meet you."

Kíli's smile softened.

"I wish we could have met them."

"Papa would have liked you," Frodo said after some consideration. "He liked jokes."

"Then he'd have liked me best," Kíli declared.

"Don't start," Fíli warned.

"Mama would have liked Fíli," Frodo continued.

Kíli looked offended.

"Why?"

"Because he's sensible."

Fíli nearly spilled his chocolate.

For the first time that afternoon, Frodo laughed properly.

They stayed at the inn until the candles were lit and the market began to glow beneath the falling snow.

Frodo told them about his parents.

About Primula's singing.

About Drogo's terrible attempts at making pancakes.

About the boat races and summer afternoons beside the river.

Sometimes his voice trembled. Sometimes he laughed.

His brothers listened to all of it.

Before returning to Erebor, they visited the toy stall again.

Frodo bought the little blue boat.

That evening, he placed it beside the portrait of his parents in his chamber.

And when he went to bed, he felt sad.

But not quite so alone.

_______________

 

The following days were filled with preparations.

Evergreen branches appeared along the galleries. Lanterns were hung above the great halls, and the kitchens became so busy that Bombur threatened to ban anyone who entered merely to sample the food.

Frodo was, naturally, exempt.

Thorin spent several afternoons with him in the workshops.

Together, they constructed a small wooden recipe box, carefully fitting the hinged lid and dividing the inside into compartments.

Frodo carved little flowers around the edges.

Thorin helped him smooth the corners and showed him how to polish the wood until it gleamed.

"Who's this for, then?" Thorin asked one afternoon.

Frodo concentrated on a particularly difficult petal.

"It's a secret."

"Ah."

"You mustn't ask."

"I wouldn't dream of it."

Thorin examined the delicate carving.

"Whoever receives it will be very fortunate."

Frodo smiled to himself.

When Thorin stepped away to fetch another tool, Frodo carefully added the inscription inside the lid.

For all the wonderful things you make for us. Love, Frodo.

Meanwhile, Fíli and Kíli were helping with a considerably more complicated secret.

An experienced smith had forged a small ceremonial dagger, beautifully balanced and suitable for display or opening letters rather than combat.

Frodo helped polish the dark wooden handle and decorate the sheath, always under careful supervision.

The most important part was the engraving.

Three names.

Fíli. Kíli. Frodo.

Kíli stared at the finished blade for a long moment.

"He's going to cry."

Fíli glanced at him.

"Uncle Thorin?"

"Obviously."

"You cried when Frodo gave you that drawing of the three of us."

"I had dust in my eye."

"We were in the library."

"Very dusty place."

Frodo giggled.

He was also making two more wooden birds.

They were imperfect little creatures, with uneven wings and rather round bodies, but Thorin had helped him carve them, and Frodo was very proud.

One afternoon, Kíli nearly discovered them.

"What are you hiding?"

"Nothing."

"That looked suspiciously like something."

"It's a secret."

"From me?"

Frodo nodded.

Kíli placed a hand over his heart.

"After everything I've done for you?"

"You taught me how to annoy older brothers."

Fíli, passing the doorway, stopped.

Then he laughed so hard that Kíli threatened to lock him outside.

___________

 

It was during one of those afternoons in the study that Frodo asked a question neither brother expected.

"Fíli?"

"Yes, little brother?"

"How do you say father in Dwarvish?"

Fíli looked up from his correspondence.

Kíli, who had been sharpening a pencil with entirely unnecessary enthusiasm, paused.

"Adad," Fíli answered.

Frodo repeated it softly.

"Adad."

"Why?" Kíli asked.

"Just wondering."

Fíli smiled and returned to his work.

Frodo carefully wrote the word in his notebook.

He did not mention it again.

_______________

 

The evening before Yule, Bilbo found Dís sitting beside a window overlooking the snow-covered valley.

He joined her with a cup of tea and the expression of a hobbit who had been thoroughly defeated by his relatives.

Dís looked amused.

"Long day?"

"Your younger son has informed Frodo that a prince ought to know how to escape through the royal kitchens."

"Useful knowledge."

"Your elder son has apparently considered giving him a ceremonial title."

"Also useful."

"And Balin thinks he should advise the council."

Dís sipped her tea.

"Well, he does seem clever."

Bilbo stared at her.

"You're supposed to be on my side."

"I am."

"You have a peculiar way of showing it."

She laughed.

For a while, they watched the snow falling beyond the glass.

Then Dís said, more quietly, "The boys are very fond of him."

Bilbo's expression softened.

"I know."

"I haven't seen Kíli this excited about anything that didn't involve a weapon in years."

"That is not especially reassuring."

"And Fíli has been keeping biscuits in his study."

Bilbo smiled despite himself.

Dís set down her cup.

"Thorin did much the same for them, you know. After their father died."

Bilbo looked toward her.

"He never tried to take their father's place," she continued. "He simply stayed. Through the difficult days, the dreadful tempers, the nights when they couldn't sleep."

Bilbo lowered his gaze.

"Sometimes I wonder whether we're doing enough."

Dís reached across and squeezed his hand.

"You're there when he needs you. That matters more than you know."

Bilbo was quiet for a moment.

Then he sighed.

"I only wish being there didn't apparently require allowing him to join the royal government."

Dís laughed so loudly that a passing servant glanced through the doorway.

Yule arrived beneath a sky filled with snow.

________________

 

By evening, Erebor was radiant.

Lanterns shone along the galleries, evergreen garlands hung from the pillars, and the great hall rang with music and laughter.

The surviving members of the Company had gathered with their families and loved ones.

Bombur commanded the kitchens with the authority of a general. Bofur had somehow persuaded several children to help decorate a small tree, although half the ornaments had ended up hanging from his hat.

Balin was telling stories near the hearth while Dwalin interrupted whenever he believed a detail had been exaggerated.

Óin and Glóin argued cheerfully over an old expedition. Little Gimli listened with shining eyes, occasionally demanding to know whether his father had truly fought that many orcs.

Dori fussed over whether everyone had enough to eat. Nori quietly stole sweets from a passing tray. Ori caught him and promptly accepted one.

Bifur was helping a group of children fashion decorations from scraps of coloured cloth.

And in the middle of it all stood Thorin Oakenshield, watching the family he had once feared he would never see gathered together again.

Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's.

"You're looking terribly solemn for someone who's supposed to be enjoying himself."

Thorin smiled.

"Am I?"

"Very."

"Then perhaps you ought to do something about it."

Bilbo rose onto his toes and kissed him.

"There. Better?"

"Considerably."

Across the hall, Kíli made an exaggerated gagging noise.

Fíli elbowed him.

"Behave."

"I am behaving."

"Then try doing it less loudly."

_____________

 

Soon the family gathered near the great fireplace to exchange their presents.

Frodo was almost trembling with excitement.

He gave Fíli and Kíli their wooden birds first.

Fíli unwrapped his carefully.

For a moment, he said nothing.

Then he smiled. "Frodo, this is wonderful."

Frodo beamed.

Kíli unwrapped his own.

He tilted his head.

Turned the carving slightly.

Examined the wings.

Frodo folded his arms. "It's a bird."

Kíli looked up.

"I KNOW IT'S A BIRD!"

Fíli's shoulders began shaking.

Frodo narrowed his eyes.

"You were looking at it like it was a cow."

"I was admiring the craftsmanship!"

"Cows don't have wings, Kíli."

Dwalin barked a laugh.

Balin covered his mouth.

Kíli looked helplessly toward Thorin.

"Uncle, say something."

Thorin examined the carving.

"A very fine bird."

"Thank you!"

"Though the horns are unusual."

The entire room erupted.

Frodo laughed so hard that Kíli eventually scooped him up and hugged him.

"You're a menace," he informed him affectionately.

"You taught me."

"Yes," Kíli sighed. "That was my first mistake."

_____________

 

Then Frodo turned toward Bilbo.

He carried a small parcel wrapped in green cloth.

"This one's for you."

Bilbo accepted it with a smile.

"Oh, sweetheart, you didn't have to—"

He stopped when he saw the box.

The little flowers.

The carefully fitted lid.

The compartments inside.

And the inscription.

For several moments, Bilbo simply stared.

"Frodo..."

"Uncle Thorin helped me," Frodo explained quickly. "But he didn't know it was for you."

Thorin looked startled.

Bilbo traced the carved flowers with one finger.

"It's beautiful."

Frodo shifted nervously.

"Do you really like it?"

Bilbo pulled him close.

"More than I can possibly tell you."

Frodo hugged him back.

Then, very quietly, he whispered, "Happy Yule, Da."

Bilbo went still.

He drew back just enough to look at him.

"What was that, darling?"

Frodo's cheeks reddened.

"Da."

Bilbo's eyes widened.

"I thought..." Frodo hesitated. "Papa will always be my papa. But you're my Da. If that's all right."

Bilbo made a small, helpless sound.

"Oh, my darling boy."

He gathered Frodo into his arms again, holding him tightly.

"Of course it is."

Frodo buried his face against Bilbo's shoulder.

"And you don't have to call me that all the time," Bilbo added softly. "You can call me whatever feels right."

Frodo nodded.

Bilbo kissed his curls.

______________

 

Across the room, Thorin watched them with a tenderness that made his chest ache.

Then Frodo turned toward him.

"And this one's for you, Adad."

Thorin stopped breathing.

For a moment, the room seemed very far away.

He looked at Frodo.

"What did you call me, lad?"

Frodo held out the dark blue parcel.

"Adad. Fíli told me what it means."

Thorin glanced toward his nephews.

Fíli smiled faintly.

Kíli suddenly found the floor fascinating.

Frodo looked uncertain.

"Is it all right?"

Thorin knelt before him.

"My boy," he said, his voice rough, "you may call me that whenever you wish."

Frodo smiled.

"Even if I still call you Uncle Thorin sometimes?"

"Even then."

Thorin drew him into his arms.

And for a moment, the former King under the Mountain held his son so tightly that Frodo could feel his heartbeat.

When Thorin finally opened the parcel, he found the dagger.

He admired the blade, the dark handle, and the decorated sheath.

Then he saw the names.

Fíli. Kíli. Frodo.

His fingers stilled.

Kíli stepped closer. "We thought you ought to have something from all three of us."

Fíli rested a hand on his uncle's shoulder. "You've given us more than we could ever repay."

Thorin looked at the three of them.

His nephews, whom he had helped raise through exile and hardship.

And Frodo, the little hobbit who had found his way into their family.

He tried to speak.

Failed.

Then laughed quietly through the tears gathering in his eyes.

"You troublesome lot."

Kíli grinned.

"That's gratitude for you."

Thorin reached for him.

Then Fíli.

Then Frodo.

And somehow all three ended up in an embrace that made Bilbo laugh and cry at the same time.

Dís turned away to wipe her eyes.

Balin looked suspiciously interested in his handkerchief.

Dwalin stared fiercely into the fire.

Nobody commented.

_____________

 

Later, when the feast had ended and the younger children had begun falling asleep, Fíli found Kíli standing outside his chamber.

The prince was carefully placing Frodo's wooden bird upon a shelf.

Fíli leaned against the doorway.

"That's a very fine cow."

Kíli closed his eyes.

"Get out."

"Excellent horns."

"Fíli."

"Remarkable attention to detail."

"GET OUT OF MY ROOM!"

Fíli departed laughing.

His own bird stood proudly on the desk in his study, beside the inkstand and the little box of pencils.

He would never move it.

____________

 

The great hall had grown quieter by the time Frodo began to fall asleep.

He was curled beneath a blanket between Thorin and Bilbo, his head resting against Thorin's arm.

Fíli and Kíli sat nearby, arguing softly over whether Kíli had truly purchased an unreasonable number of presents in Dale.

Dís was laughing with Balin.

Dwalin had surrendered to a second cup of ale.

Somewhere across the hall, Bofur had begun another song.

Thorin looked around at them.

There had been Yules when the Company possessed little more than a fire, a shared meal, and the stubborn hope that someday they might return home.

There had been years of exile, hunger, grief, and uncertainty.

And there had been a time when Thorin believed the Mountain itself was the answer to every sorrow he carried.

Now he sat beside his husband, with their son asleep against him, his nephews nearby, his sister laughing, and the friends who had followed him through impossible dangers gathered beneath the roof of Erebor.

Bilbo noticed his expression.

"What are you thinking?"

Thorin looked at him.

"That I am a fortunate dwarf."

Bilbo smiled.

"You are."

Frodo stirred.

"Uncle Thorin?"

"Aye, lad?"

"Can we come back next Yule?"

Bilbo opened his mouth.

"We'll have to see, sweetheart—"

"OF COURSE YOU CAN!" Kíli announced from across the hearth.

Frodo giggled sleepily.

Bilbo gave Kíli a look of profound suffering.

Fíli sighed.

"Kíli, you cannot invite people on behalf of the king."

"I'm the king's brother."

"And I'm the king."

"Then invite them."

Fíli looked at Frodo.

"You're always welcome here, little brother."

Frodo smiled.

"Good."

He settled back against Thorin.

A moment later, he was asleep.

Thorin drew the blanket more securely around him, and Bilbo rested his head against his husband's shoulder.

Beyond the windows, snow fell softly over the Lonely Mountain.

Inside, the fire burned warm, the music continued, and the people Thorin loved remained close enough to touch.

For Thorin Oakenshield, who had once spent a lifetime searching for a home, there was no greater treasure than the family gathered around him.

Notes:

I just had to write this little story. After everything they've been through, I felt this overwhelming urge to give them something they rarely had before: peace.

No more battles, no more running from danger, no more wondering whether they'll all make it home alive. Just Thorin, Bilbo, Fíli, Kíli, and the family they love, finally getting to enjoy the life they fought so hard for.

Of course, they still have one adventure ahead of them… perhaps the most unpredictable one yet: raising a child.

I wanted them to have ordinary days filled with laughter, silly arguments, warm meals, and moments that might seem insignificant to others but mean everything to them.

 

And finally, thank you to everyone who walked this road alongside them, through every adventure, every heartbreak, every laugh, and every moment of love.

This is where "The Road Back to You" comes to an end. And perhaps, in the end, the road was never just about finding their way back to each other, but about finding their way back to family, to love, and to a place they could finally call home.

Will they stay in Erebor? Return to the Shire? Or perhaps, one day, set off on another unexpected adventure? Well, I'll leave that for all of you to imagine.

Because their story doesn't truly end here. Only our journey alongside them does.

And this time, the road led them exactly where they belonged.

Series this work belongs to: