Chapter Text
The trouble with preparing for a journey, Bilbo Baggins had discovered, was that his husband considered every possible inconvenience a personal enemy that ought to be defeated before they ever left the front door.
This was particularly unfortunate when the journey in question involved travelling to Erebor in winter.
“I am not packing a third cloak, Thorin.”
“You will be grateful for it when we reach the mountains.”
“I shall be grateful for many things when we reach the mountains. A warm fire, a comfortable bed, and the opportunity to inform your nephews that you have spent the better part of a morning attempting to bury me beneath wool.”
Thorin looked up from the travelling chest he had been inspecting.
“Two cloaks are insufficient.”
“I already possess two cloaks, three waistcoats, four cardigans, and enough stockings to keep half of Hobbiton warm.”
“Your stockings will be of little use if the wind gets beneath your cloak.”
“Then I shall simply have to avoid allowing it to do so.”
“Bilbo.”
“Thorin.”
They regarded one another across the bedroom with the familiar determination of two people who had been married long enough to know that neither was likely to surrender.
Outside, a fine autumn rain pattered against the round windows of Bag End. The garden had grown increasingly bare over the past fortnight, its flowerbeds resting beneath damp leaves while the last stubborn roses bowed beneath the cold. Beyond the Hill, smoke rose from neighbouring chimneys, and the lanes of Hobbiton shone darkly beneath the morning drizzle.
Inside, however, the house was wonderfully warm.
A fire crackled in the sitting room, breakfast had been finished nearly an hour earlier, and the kitchen still carried the comforting scent of cinnamon from the apple cakes Bilbo had baked the previous evening.
It ought to have been a perfectly peaceful morning.
Unfortunately, Thorin had discovered that Bilbo intended to pack only one pair of winter gloves.
“Your hands will freeze,” the dwarf declared.
“My hands have survived winters before.”
“Not in the mountains.”
“I have been to Erebor, darling. You may recall that I accompanied you there on a rather memorable occasion.”
“That was different.”
“How?”
“We were travelling under considerably less comfortable circumstances.”
Bilbo folded his arms.
“Precisely. And somehow, despite goblins, orcs, wargs, and a dragon, I managed not to perish from insufficient gloves.”
Thorin opened his mouth.
Then closed it.
Bilbo smiled triumphantly.
“Wonderful. Now, if we've settled that matter, would you kindly help me decide whether Bombur would prefer blackberry preserves or the spiced plum jam Mrs. Goodbody brought us?”
Thorin stared at him.
“We are travelling across half of Middle-earth, and you intend to carry jars of jam?”
“Of course.”
“Bilbo.”
“Bombur likes my preserves.”
“Bombur likes anything that can be eaten.”
“Then he shall be delighted.”
Thorin rubbed a hand over his face.
Bilbo, who knew that gesture intimately, stepped closer and slipped his arms around his husband's waist.
“Oh, don't look so troubled, my love. We'll manage perfectly well.”
Thorin's hands settled automatically upon his hips.
“I would prefer that we manage without you catching your death in the cold.”
“And I would prefer that you remember I am not made of spun sugar.”
“No,” Thorin agreed, lowering his head until their foreheads touched. “You are considerably more troublesome.”
Bilbo laughed softly.
“And yet you married me.”
“A decision I am reminded of daily.”
“Regretting it?”
Thorin's expression warmed.
“Never.”
He kissed Bilbo gently, lingering just long enough that the hobbit forgot his argument about winter gloves.
Then, while Bilbo was still smiling, Thorin reached past him and placed a third cloak into the travelling chest.
Bilbo stared.
“Thorin Oakenshield!”
The dwarf looked entirely unrepentant.
“What?”
“You impossible creature!”
“I love you too, ghivashel.”
Bilbo was considering whether throwing a pillow at his husband would constitute a reasonable response when the front bell rang.
Both turned toward the sound.
“At this hour?” Bilbo murmured.
Thorin glanced toward the window.
“Perhaps one of the children.”
“Perhaps. Though I hope they haven't come to ask you to repair another toy. You still haven't finished the little horse for Daisy.”
“I have nearly finished it.”
“You said that yesterday.”
“It requires painting.”
“And the day before?”
“It required sanding.”
________________
Bilbo shook his head affectionately and left the bedroom.
He made his way down the passage, straightening his waistcoat as he went. The bell rang again before he reached the door, followed by a hurried knock.
“Coming!” he called.
When he opened the green door, he found a young messenger standing beneath the porch, rain dripping from the brim of his cap.
“Morning, Mr. Baggins. Letter for you.”
Bilbo smiled and accepted the envelope.
“Thank you, Tom. Would you like something warm before you go?”
“That's kind of you, sir, but I've several more deliveries.”
“Then at least take a biscuit.”
The boy grinned.
Bilbo disappeared into the kitchen and returned with two, wrapped neatly in a scrap of paper.
“There. One for the road and one for later.”
“Thank you, Mr. Baggins!”
The messenger hurried away through the rain.
Bilbo closed the door, still smiling.
Then he looked at the envelope.
The smile faded.
He recognised the handwriting.
It belonged to one of his Brandybuck relations in Buckland.
That alone was not unusual. Bilbo received letters from his mother's side of the family several times a year, although the correspondence tended to concern births, weddings, family gatherings, and occasionally some disagreement about inheritance that Bilbo had no particular desire to involve himself in.
But something about this envelope troubled him.
Perhaps it was the haste of the handwriting.
Perhaps it was the absence of the usual cheerful greeting upon the outside.
He broke the seal.
By the time Thorin entered the sitting room several minutes later, Bilbo had not moved from where he stood beside the little table near the door.
The letter trembled slightly in his hands.
“Bilbo?”
There was no answer.
Thorin stopped.
He knew his husband well enough to recognise the difference between ordinary distraction and genuine distress.
“Bilbo,” he repeated, more softly.
The hobbit looked up.
His face had gone terribly pale.
For one dreadful instant, Thorin felt the old, familiar coldness of fear settle beneath his ribs.
“What has happened?”
Bilbo swallowed.
“It's Drogo.”
Thorin frowned.
“Your cousin?”
Bilbo nodded.
“And Primula.”
He looked down at the letter again, as though the words might somehow have changed.
“There was an accident.”
Thorin crossed the room.
Bilbo's voice shook.
“They were boating on the Brandywine. Something happened. The boat overturned, and…”
He stopped.
Thorin gently took the letter from his trembling fingers.
He read it quickly.
The words were brief, written with the awkward restraint of someone attempting to deliver unbearable news without making it worse.
Drogo Baggins and his wife, Primula Brandybuck, had drowned.
Their son, Frodo, had been left behind.
Thorin lowered the letter.
“Oh, Bilbo.”
“He's only eleven.”
Bilbo said it so quietly that Thorin almost failed to hear him.
“He's only a little boy.”
Thorin set the parchment aside and gathered his husband into his arms.
Bilbo went willingly, pressing his face against the dwarf's shoulder.
For several moments, he said nothing.
Thorin held him, one broad hand resting between his shoulder blades while the other cradled the back of his head.
He did not tell Bilbo that everything would be all right.
Some things were not all right.
Some things could not be made right by kind words, however sincerely they were spoken.
Instead, he remained there until Bilbo was ready to speak.
“I knew Drogo when he was hardly older than Frodo,” the hobbit murmured at last. “He used to follow me about at family gatherings, asking questions about everything. And Primula…”
His voice faltered.
“She was always so full of life.”
Thorin pressed a kiss into his curls.
“I am sorry, my love.”
Bilbo drew a shaky breath.
“The letter says Frodo is staying at Brandy Hall. They are looking after him, of course. There are plenty of relatives there, and they're good people, but…”
He pulled back slightly.
“Thorin, he's lost both his parents.”
“I know.”
“He must be frightened.”
“Very likely.”
“And everyone will be fussing over him, and asking how he is, and expecting him to answer when he probably doesn't even know himself.”
Thorin brushed a tear from Bilbo's cheek.
“Then perhaps we ought to go to him.”
Bilbo looked up.
“You wouldn't mind?”
“Bilbo.”
“We were meant to be preparing for Erebor, and it's a fair journey to Buckland, and—”
“Erebor can wait a few days.”
Thorin spoke with such simple certainty that Bilbo's eyes filled again.
“We'll go together,” the dwarf continued. “Your family has suffered a terrible loss. You should be with them.”
Bilbo leaned into him once more.
“Thank you.”
Thorin held him a little tighter.
There was nothing to thank him for.
Not really.
________________
They left the following morning.
The rain had passed during the night, leaving the countryside washed clean beneath a pale, uncertain sun. Mist lingered over the fields, and the road east was scattered with damp leaves that clung to the wheels of passing carts.
Bilbo had packed only what they needed for several days.
Thorin, to his credit, had refrained from commenting upon the number of cloaks.
Their journey was quieter than most.
Bilbo sat beside his husband in the small hired carriage, watching the familiar Shire countryside pass beyond the window. Occasionally he spoke about Drogo or Primula, recalling some little incident from years before, and Thorin listened without interruption.
He learned that Drogo had possessed an astonishing appetite even by hobbit standards, that Primula had been quick to laugh and quicker still to speak her mind, and that Frodo had inherited his mother's dark curls and his father's fondness for sweet things.
“He visited us once,” Bilbo said as they travelled beneath a stand of yellowing trees. “With his parents. Do you remember?”
Thorin considered.
“Was that the summer when Dwalin came to stay?”
“No, the following spring. You were repairing the garden fence.”
Thorin's expression brightened with recognition.
“Ah. The little boy who asked whether my beard was heavy.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“Yes.”
“He also asked whether I slept wearing my boots.”
“You told him dwarves slept standing upright.”
“I did not.”
“You most certainly did.”
Thorin looked mildly offended.
“I told him that some dwarves could sleep standing upright.”
“Which was entirely untrue.”
“Not entirely.”
Bilbo shook his head.
For a moment, his smile lingered.
Then it faded.
“He was such a cheerful little thing.”
Thorin reached across the seat and took his hand.
“He may be again,” he said gently. “In time.”
Bilbo looked at their joined hands.
“I hope so.”
The carriage continued east.
They crossed the familiar lands of the Shire, passing farms, orchards, and little villages where hobbits hurried about their ordinary business. The world seemed almost painfully unchanged.
Children still played beside garden gates.
Farmers still complained about the weather.
Smoke still rose from chimneys as evening approached.
Somewhere, families were sitting down to supper together.
And in Buckland, an eleven-year-old boy would never again hear his mother call him to the table.
Bilbo turned his face toward the window.
Thorin kept hold of his hand.
________________
Brandy Hall was as busy as Bilbo remembered.
The great ancestral home of the Brandybucks sprawled through the hillside in a maze of passages, rooms, stairways, and interconnected halls. Its windows glowed warmly against the grey afternoon, and the familiar sounds of a large household drifted through the corridors: footsteps, distant conversation, the clatter of dishes, and the occasional shriek of children being chased by their siblings.
Yet beneath the ordinary bustle lay a subdued atmosphere.
Voices lowered when Bilbo and Thorin entered.
Relatives greeted them with tired smiles and embraces that lasted a little longer than usual.
Bilbo spoke quietly with the head of the household, offering condolences and asking after Frodo.
“He's being looked after,” came the weary reply. “We've made certain he has everything he needs. But he's hardly himself, poor lad.”
Bilbo nodded.
“May we see him?”
“Of course.”
They were led through several familiar corridors toward a smaller sitting room overlooking the gardens.
The door stood partly open.
Inside, a little hobbit boy sat upon the rug near the hearth.
He had dark curls, pale cheeks, and large blue eyes that seemed far too solemn for someone his age. A small wooden cart lay in his lap, and he was attempting to fit one of its wheels back onto the axle.
Beside him sat a little box containing several other toys.
He did not look up when the door opened.
“Frodo, dear,” their relative said softly. “You have visitors.”
The boy raised his head.
His gaze moved first to Bilbo.
For a moment, he simply stared.
Then he rose.
“Cousin Bilbo?”
Bilbo felt his heart ache.
“Hello, Frodo.”
The boy hesitated.
Bilbo did not rush toward him.
Instead, he crouched slightly and opened his arms.
“If you'd like a hug, my dear, I have one available.”
Frodo stood very still.
Then, slowly, he crossed the room.
Bilbo gathered him close.
The boy's arms went around his neck, not tightly at first, but enough that Bilbo could feel how carefully he was holding himself together.
“Oh, Frodo,” he whispered.
He stroked the child's curls.
“I am so very sorry.”
Frodo said nothing.
Bilbo did not ask him to.
After a while, the boy stepped back.
His eyes moved toward Thorin.
The dwarf had remained near the doorway, giving them space.
Frodo studied him with quiet curiosity.
“You're Thorin.”
Thorin inclined his head.
“I am.”
“You live with Cousin Bilbo.”
“I do.”
Frodo considered this.
Then he said, “You made me a fox.”
Thorin blinked.
“A fox?”
“A wooden one.”
The dwarf searched his memory.
Gradually, a smile appeared.
“Ah. Yes. I remember.”
Frodo's expression softened almost imperceptibly.
“It had a little curled tail.”
“It did.”
“And you painted its nose black.”
Thorin nodded.
“I believe I did.”
Frodo looked down at his hands.
“I still have it.”
Something warm and painful moved through Thorin's chest.
“I'm glad,” he said.
Frodo glanced up again.
“You told stories, too.”
“Did I?”
“About mountains. And a dragon.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“Thorin does rather enjoy telling stories.”
The dwarf raised an eyebrow.
“I recall someone else who has been known to tell a tale or two.”
“Yes, but mine are considerably more sensible.”
“Of course.”
Frodo watched them exchange a familiar look.
For the first time since they had entered the room, the corners of his mouth moved slightly.
Not quite a smile.
But close.
_______________
They spent the afternoon with him.
At first, Frodo seemed uncertain what was expected of him.
He answered Bilbo's questions politely, accepted a cup of warm milk when it was offered, and sat quietly beside the hearth while the adults spoke.
Bilbo quickly realised that the boy had grown weary of being asked how he felt.
So he stopped asking.
Instead, he talked.
About the journey from Hobbiton.
About the first frost in their garden.
About the unfortunate discovery that a family of mice had decided to make a home beneath the pantry shelves.
“Thorin was quite convinced that they were attempting to undermine the foundations of Bag End,” Bilbo explained from his armchair.
“I was not.”
“You spent an entire afternoon inspecting the floorboards.”
“Because I found evidence of damage.”
“You found three crumbs.”
“Which had been carried beneath the cupboard.”
Frodo looked between them.
“Did you catch the mice?”
Bilbo smiled.
“Oh, yes. Though I insisted they be taken somewhere safe.”
“They were relocated,” Thorin said.
“To the far end of the garden.”
“Beyond the vegetable beds.”
“Whereupon one of them promptly returned.”
Thorin sighed.
“A remarkably determined creature.”
Frodo looked down at his lap.
A tiny smile appeared.
Bilbo noticed.
He said nothing about it.
Instead, he continued describing the garden.
He told Frodo about the pumpkins that had grown so large that Thorin required a wheelbarrow to move them, the apple tree that had produced an unusually generous harvest, and the stubborn patch of carrots that refused to grow properly.
“Thorin planted them too close together,” Bilbo explained.
“I followed your instructions.”
“You followed half my instructions.”
“The other half were unnecessary.”
“They were the half concerning the distance between the seeds.”
Frodo looked toward Thorin.
“Did they grow?”
“Some of them,” the dwarf admitted.
“Very small carrots,” Bilbo added.
“They were perfectly edible.”
“Darling, one was scarcely longer than my thumb.”
Thorin folded his arms.
“It was an exceptionally flavourful carrot.”
Frodo gave a soft little laugh.
It lasted only a moment.
But Bilbo felt it like a shaft of sunlight breaking through cloud.
The boy's expression grew solemn again almost immediately, as though he had remembered that laughter was something he was no longer certain he ought to enjoy.
Bilbo simply continued speaking.
He did not tell Frodo to smile.
He did not praise him for laughing.
He allowed the moment to pass without making it into something the child might feel obliged to repeat.
Meanwhile, Thorin had noticed something else.
The wooden cart remained in Frodo's lap.
Every few minutes, the boy attempted to push its loose wheel back into place.
Each time, it slipped off again.
Frodo frowned at it.
He tried turning the little peg.
Then pressing harder.
Then examining the axle with increasing frustration.
Thorin watched for a while.
Finally, he shifted from his chair.
“Troublesome wheel?”
Frodo looked up.
He nodded.
“It keeps falling off.”
“May I see?”
The boy hesitated.
His fingers tightened around the cart.
Thorin waited.
He did not reach for it.
After a moment, Frodo held it out.
Thorin accepted it carefully.
The little cart was well made, though years of use had worn the edges smooth. Its wheels were carved from dark wood, and someone had painted a narrow red stripe along the sides.
The broken axle had been repaired before, judging by the tiny marks around the peg.
Thorin turned it over in his hands.
“Ah,” he murmured. “I see the difficulty.”
Frodo leaned forward.
“What is it?”
“The peg holding the wheel has worn down. It no longer fits tightly enough.”
“Can you fix it?”
“I believe so.”
Frodo watched him anxiously.
Thorin glanced toward the little sewing basket resting on a nearby table.
“Though I may require some assistance.”
Frodo blinked.
“Assistance?”
“Yes. My fingers are rather large for delicate work.”
The boy looked at Thorin's broad hands.
Then at his own.
“Mine are small.”
“So they are.”
Thorin smiled.
“Would you care to help?”
Frodo nodded.
________________
Bilbo watched from his armchair as Thorin settled upon the rug beside the boy.
He had seen his husband do this countless times in the workshop at Bag End: lowering himself to a child's level, treating some broken toy or difficult little project with the same seriousness he might once have given a piece of royal armour.
Thorin examined the cart again.
“I shall need a little piece of wood,” he said. “Something thin and strong.”
Bilbo rose.
“I believe I saw a box of spare buttons and odds and ends in the cabinet.”
“Would you mind?”
“Not at all.”
He returned a moment later with a small wooden box.
Thorin sorted through its contents until he found a short, narrow piece of hardwood.
“This should do.”
Frodo watched with growing interest.
“Will you make a new peg?”
“Yes. Though first we must make certain the wheel itself isn't damaged.”
He handed the wheel to Frodo.
“Can you turn it over for me?”
The boy obeyed.
“Now, do you see that little crack?”
Frodo leaned closer.
“Yes.”
“It isn't serious. But if we force the peg too tightly, the wood may split.”
“So we have to be careful?”
“Precisely.”
Frodo nodded solemnly.
Thorin smiled.
“A good craftsman knows when to use strength and when to use patience.”
Bilbo raised his eyebrows.
“A lesson you might occasionally remember yourself, darling.”
Thorin glanced up.
“I am perfectly patient.”
Bilbo looked at him.
Thorin looked back.
Frodo, watching them, smiled again.
This time, the smile lasted a little longer.
Thorin borrowed a small knife from the household and carefully shaped the new peg. He explained what he was doing as he worked, occasionally allowing Frodo to examine the wood or hold the wheel steady.
He did not rush.
He did not take over the task completely.
And when the new peg was ready, he guided Frodo through fitting the wheel back into place.
“There,” he said at last.
Frodo turned the wheel.
It spun smoothly.
His eyes widened.
“It works!”
Thorin smiled.
“So it does.”
Frodo rolled the cart across the rug.
The wheel remained firmly attached.
He tried again.
Then a third time.
A little of the tension left his shoulders.
Bilbo leaned forward.
“Splendid! We shall have to recruit you both to repair my garden wheelbarrow.”
Thorin raised an eyebrow.
“Your wheelbarrow does not require repairing.”
“It squeaks.”
“That is because you insist upon leaving it outside in the rain.”
“Such accusations.”
Frodo looked down at the cart.
Then he said quietly, “Papa gave it to me.”
The room grew still.
Thorin's hands rested upon his knees.
Bilbo did not move from his chair.
Frodo traced the faded red stripe along the cart's side.
“He made it when I was little.”
Thorin looked at the toy again.
The worn wheels.
The carefully fitted joints.
The little marks left by years of use.
“I thought it looked like something made with love,” he said gently.
Frodo swallowed.
“Papa said it was the fastest cart in Buckland.”
Thorin considered this with appropriate seriousness.
“Did he?”
Frodo nodded.
“He said no other cart could beat it.”
“Well,” Thorin replied, “then we must make certain it remains worthy of its reputation.”
The boy looked up.
“Do you think it will?”
“I believe so. Though I would advise against racing it down any particularly steep hills.”
Frodo stared at him.
Then, very softly, he said, “Papa said that too.”
Thorin's expression warmed.
“Then your father and I were in agreement.”
Frodo looked at the cart for a long moment.
His lower lip trembled.
He did not cry.
Not then.
Instead, he drew the little toy close against his chest.
“Thank you,” he whispered.
Thorin inclined his head.
“You're very welcome, Frodo.”
Bilbo looked away briefly, blinking hard.
Then he cleared his throat.
“Now, speaking of things that require great care, I really must tell you about the biscuits I make for the children who visit Thorin's workshop.”
Frodo glanced toward him.
“Children visit?”
“Oh, constantly.”
Thorin sighed.
“Not constantly.”
“Nearly constantly.”
“They come a few afternoons each week.”
“And several mornings.”
“Bilbo.”
“And occasionally before breakfast.”
Thorin considered this.
“That has happened.”
Bilbo smiled.
“You see, Frodo, your cousin Thorin has somehow become the most popular dwarf in Hobbiton.”
Frodo looked interested.
“Are there many dwarves in Hobbiton?”
“Only one,” Bilbo admitted.
Thorin gave him a long-suffering look.
“An unfair competition.”
“Nevertheless, you are winning splendidly.”
Frodo smiled.
Bilbo continued.
“The children come to watch him carve little animals. Foxes, rabbits, horses, dragons, whatever catches their fancy. In winter, Thorin keeps blankets ready for them, and I bring hot chocolate and biscuits.”
“Chocolate?” Frodo repeated.
“Oh, yes. Proper hot chocolate, with warm milk and a little cinnamon.”
“And biscuits?”
“Of course. It would hardly be a respectable gathering without biscuits.”
Thorin shook his head.
“He spoils them.”
Bilbo smiled serenely.
“And Thorin makes them toys.”
“Practice pieces.”
“Entirely accidental toys, naturally.”
Frodo looked toward the dwarf.
“Do you still make foxes?”
Thorin's expression softened.
“I do.”
Frodo looked down at his cart.
“I like foxes.”
“I remember.”
For a little while, the three of them remained together in the warm sitting room, speaking of gardens, wooden animals, biscuits, and the strange habits of Hobbiton's children.
Frodo did not become cheerful.
He did not forget his parents.
But he listened.
Sometimes he asked questions.
And once, when Bilbo described Mrs. Goodbody calling Thorin a great big teddy bear, he laughed so unexpectedly that even Thorin could not bring himself to object.
_______________
They remained at Brandy Hall for several days.
Bilbo spent much of that time with his relatives, sharing memories of Drogo and Primula and helping where he could. There were practical matters to discuss, belongings to sort through, and countless little arrangements that seemed cruelly ordinary beside the enormity of what had happened.
Thorin accompanied him whenever he was wanted.
When he was not, he found useful things to do.
A loose hinge in one of the guest rooms was repaired. A broken chair received a new joint. An elderly Brandybuck gentleman discovered that the dwarf was quite willing to examine the troublesome lock on his study door.
And occasionally, Thorin found himself in the little sitting room with Frodo.
They did not always talk.
Sometimes the boy read while Thorin worked on some small repair.
Sometimes Thorin told him stories.
Not grand tales of battles or the reclaiming of Erebor, though Frodo occasionally asked about the dragon.
More often, Thorin spoke of the Blue Mountains.
He told Frodo about winters when the snow rose higher than the youngest dwarflings, about the enormous kitchens where his nephews had once attempted to steal an entire tray of honey cakes, and about the time Kíli had become convinced that a particularly ill-tempered goat was secretly plotting against him.
Frodo listened with increasing fascination.
“Did the goat really chase him?”
“Across three courtyards.”
“Why?”
“Because Kíli had attempted to feed it a piece of his brother's cloak.”
Frodo stared.
Then he laughed.
Thorin smiled.
“Fíli was considerably less amused.”
“Did he get angry?”
“Very.”
“What happened?”
“He chased Kíli across the same three courtyards.”
Frodo laughed again.
It was a small sound, but a lovely one.
Thorin allowed himself to enjoy it.
He had learned long ago that laughter and grief could live beside one another.
Sometimes they had to.
On the third evening, Bilbo found Frodo sitting beside Thorin near the hearth, listening to a story about a young Fíli attempting to convince his uncle that he was old enough to accompany the warriors on patrol.
Frodo looked up when Bilbo entered.
“Cousin Bilbo?”
“Yes, my dear?”
“Did Thorin really have to carry Fíli home because he fell asleep?”
Bilbo glanced at his husband.
Thorin looked faintly embarrassed.
“Fíli was very young.”
“And very stubborn,” Bilbo added.
“Indeed.”
Frodo smiled.
“Like you?”
Bilbo burst out laughing.
Thorin stared at the boy.
Then, slowly, he smiled.
“I'm beginning to suspect you've been spending too much time with my husband.”
Frodo ducked his head.
But he was still smiling.
That night, long after the household had settled into silence, Bilbo sat upon the edge of the bed in their guest room.
A single lamp burned upon the bedside table.
Outside, the wind stirred the bare branches of the trees, brushing them softly against the window.
Thorin had removed his boots and was folding his travelling clothes when he noticed that Bilbo had been unusually quiet for some time.
He set the clothes aside.
“Bilbo?”
His husband looked up.
“Hm?”
“Something troubles you.”
Bilbo gave a faint smile.
“You always say that.”
“Because I am usually correct.”
“Insufferably so.”
Thorin crossed the room and sat beside him.
For a moment, Bilbo said nothing.
Then he asked, “Do you think Frodo is happy here?”
Thorin considered.
“I think his family is doing everything they can to care for him.”
“Yes.”
“They love him.”
“I know.”
Bilbo looked down at his hands.
“Brandy Hall is a good home.”
“It is.”
“And there are so many people here.”
Thorin waited.
Bilbo twisted his wedding ring gently around his finger.
“Do you think that helps? Having so many people around?”
“For some children, perhaps.”
“And for others?”
Thorin studied his husband.
“For others, it may be overwhelming.”
Bilbo nodded.
He was quiet again.
Then he asked, “Do you remember what Fíli and Kíli were like after their father died?”
Thorin's expression changed.
He had not expected the question, though perhaps he should have.
For a long moment, he looked toward the lamp.
“Yes,” he said softly. “I remember.”
Bilbo turned toward him.
“They were very young, weren't they?”
“Fíli was old enough to understand what death meant. Kíli was younger.”
Thorin's hands rested loosely upon his knees.
“He did not understand why his father had gone away and would not return.”
Bilbo's heart ached.
“What did you do?”
Thorin was silent for a while.
“I tried to help Dís as best I could.”
He gave a faint, humourless smile.
“At first, I thought I ought to have answers. That there must be something I could say to make the boys feel safe again.”
“And was there?”
“No.”
Thorin looked down.
“There was nothing I could say that would give them back their father.”
Bilbo reached for his hand.
Thorin took it.
“Fíli became very serious,” he continued. “Almost overnight. He stopped asking for things. Stopped complaining when he was tired. He tried to help his mother with everything, even tasks he was far too young to manage.”
Bilbo listened quietly.
“He believed he had to be strong for Kíli,” Thorin said. “And for Dís. He thought that if he behaved well enough, worked hard enough, and never caused trouble, perhaps it would make things easier for everyone.”
“That sounds like Fíli.”
“It does.”
Thorin smiled sadly.
“But he was still a little boy. Some nights I would find him awake long after everyone else had gone to bed, trying not to cry because he thought someone might hear.”
Bilbo's eyes filled.
“What did you do?”
“I sat with him.”
“Did he talk?”
“Sometimes. Often he didn't.”
Thorin looked toward the window.
“I learned that he did not always need me to say anything. He only needed to know that I would remain until he fell asleep.”
Bilbo squeezed his hand.
“And Kíli?”
A different sort of tenderness entered Thorin's expression.
“Kíli followed me everywhere.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“That sounds like him too.”
“Everywhere,” Thorin repeated. “If I went to the forge, he followed. If I went to speak with Balin, he followed. If I left the room without telling him where I was going, he would come looking.”
“Poor little thing.”
“He was afraid.”
Thorin's voice grew quieter.
“He had lost his father. He did not understand why. And I think some part of him believed that anyone he loved might disappear just as suddenly.”
Bilbo leaned closer.
“What did you do?”
“I let him follow.”
A small smile touched Thorin's mouth.
“Sometimes he sat beside me in the forge for hours, asking questions. Sometimes he fell asleep against my shoulder while I worked. I would carry him back to his bed, and the next morning he would appear at my door again.”
Bilbo wiped at his eyes.
“You must have been very patient.”
Thorin chuckled softly.
“Not always. There were days when both boys tested every scrap of patience I possessed.”
“I can imagine.”
“But I loved them.”
The words were simple.
They carried the weight of years.
“I loved them,” Thorin repeated, “and I wanted them to know that whatever had happened, they were not alone.”
Bilbo looked at him for a long moment.
“You never tried to replace their father.”
“No.”
Thorin shook his head.
“I could not have done so, even if I had wished it. They had a father. They loved him. Losing him did not change that.”
He turned toward Bilbo.
“I only wanted to give them somewhere safe to grow.”
Bilbo lowered his gaze.
The room fell quiet.
Thorin watched him.
He knew that expression.
He knew the way Bilbo worried the edge of his sleeve between his fingers, the way his thoughts seemed to move ahead of his words, the way he asked questions whose answers he had already begun to understand.
Five years of marriage had taught him much about his husband.
But he had known Bilbo's heart long before their wedding.
He had seen it in the wilderness, when the hobbit had offered kindness to strangers and loyalty to those who scarcely deserved it.
He had seen it beneath the Mountain, when Bilbo had risked everything for people who were not his own.
And he saw it now.
Thorin lifted Bilbo's hand and pressed a kiss to his knuckles.
“We could bring him home, you know.”
Bilbo went very still.
He looked up.
“Thorin?”
“Frodo.”
The dwarf spoke gently.
“If he wishes it, and if his family agrees, we could offer him a home at Bag End.”
Bilbo stared at him.
For several moments, he seemed unable to speak.
Then he whispered, “I hadn't even asked.”
Thorin smiled.
“You didn't need to.”
“Darling…”
“I know you, Bilbo.”
His thumb moved slowly across the back of Bilbo's hand.
“I have watched you with him these past few days. And I have listened to the questions you've been asking.”
Bilbo's eyes filled.
“I didn't want you to think…”
He stopped.
Thorin waited.
“I didn't want you to think I was deciding something so important without you.”
“You weren't.”
“Or that I expected you to…”
Bilbo swallowed.
“To become his father.”
Thorin's expression softened.
“Oh, ghivashel.”
He drew Bilbo closer.
“I do not expect Frodo to look upon me as his father. Nor would I ask him to.”
Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.
“He had a father,” Thorin continued. “One who loved him enough to make him a little wooden cart. One whose words he still remembers.”
Bilbo nodded.
“I know.”
“And nothing we do should ever make him feel that loving his parents is something he must leave behind.”
A tear slipped down Bilbo's cheek.
Thorin brushed it away.
“But I remember what it was to lose family,” he said quietly. “I remember what it was to wake and discover that the world had changed, and that no amount of wishing could make it as it had been.”
His gaze drifted toward the darkened window.
“I remember Fíli and Kíli after their father's death. I remember how frightened they were, even when they tried to hide it.”
He looked back at Bilbo.
“And I remember how much it mattered that they still had people who loved them.”
Bilbo's lips trembled.
“Thorin…”
“I cannot give Frodo back what he has lost,” the dwarf said. “I cannot take away his grief, and I would never presume to take his father's place.”
He smiled faintly.
“But I can give him a warm hearth. A place at our table. Someone to help him mend his toys when they break.”
Bilbo let out a small, shaky laugh.
“And biscuits?”
“An unreasonable number of biscuits, knowing you.”
Bilbo laughed through his tears.
Thorin kissed his forehead.
“I can give him a home where laughter is welcome, even on the days when he feels sad. Where he needn't pretend to be brave all the time.”
He paused.
“And where he will never have to wonder whether someone will come looking for him if he is missing.”
Bilbo pressed his face against Thorin's shoulder.
The dwarf wrapped both arms around him.
For a long while, they simply held one another.
Eventually, Bilbo drew back.
“Are you certain?”
Thorin looked at him.
“Of course.”
“It would change things.”
“Yes.”
“Our routines. Our travels. Everything.”
“Some things.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“We might not have quite so many quiet mornings.”
Thorin raised an eyebrow.
“Bilbo, we currently have six children peering through our workshop windows before breakfast.”
“That is true.”
“And you feed half of Hobbiton every other afternoon.”
“Only the hungry half.”
Thorin chuckled.
“I suspect we shall manage.”
Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.
“Do you think he'd want to come?”
“I don't know.”
The honesty of the answer seemed to comfort Bilbo more than any easy reassurance might have done.
“Then we must ask him,” Thorin continued. “When the time is right.”
“And speak with the Brandybucks first.”
“Of course.”
Bilbo nodded slowly.
“I don't want him to feel as though we're taking him away from everyone he knows.”
“Then we won't.”
“We could still visit Buckland.”
“As often as he wishes.”
“And he could write to his relatives.”
“Certainly.”
Bilbo smiled.
“And we could tell him about Erebor.”
Thorin's expression warmed.
“I imagine Kíli would be delighted to have someone new to tell his dreadful jokes to.”
“Oh, goodness.”
“And Fíli would undoubtedly attempt to teach him proper manners.”
“While Kíli undid all his hard work.”
“Precisely.”
Bilbo laughed softly.
Then his expression grew thoughtful.
“Thorin?”
“Yes?”
“What about Yule?”
The dwarf considered.
Their planned journey to Erebor suddenly seemed much less important than it had a week earlier.
“We can postpone it,” he said. “Fíli and Kíli will understand.”
Bilbo nodded.
“Perhaps.”
He was quiet for a moment.
“Though if Frodo did wish to come with us…”
Thorin smiled.
“Then we could ask whether he'd like to see the Mountain.”
Bilbo looked up.
“You wouldn't mind?”
“Bilbo, I spent thirteen months travelling with a hobbit who insisted upon stopping to examine every interesting tree and flower along the road.”
Bilbo gasped.
“I did not insist!”
“You did.”
“I merely appreciated the scenery.”
“You once delayed us because you wished to identify a particularly unusual mushroom.”
“It was a very unusual mushroom.”
Thorin laughed.
“I think I can manage travelling with another curious hobbit.”
Bilbo leaned forward and kissed him.
Then he rested against his chest, listening to the steady beat of his heart.
______________
For the first time since the letter had arrived at Bag End, something within him felt a little less helpless.
He still grieved for Drogo and Primula.
He still worried for their son.
And he knew that no amount of kindness could make the coming months easy.
But perhaps there was something they could do.
Something small and ordinary and immeasurably important.
They could open their door.
They could offer Frodo a place beside the fire.
They could let him bring his memories, his sadness, and his father's little wooden cart into a home already full of love.
And perhaps, in time, the sound of a child's laughter would become as familiar in Bag End as the scrape of Thorin's carving knife or the gentle rustle of Bilbo turning a page.
“Thorin?” Bilbo whispered.
“Hm?”
“Thank you.”
The dwarf tightened his arms around him.
“For what?”
“For knowing what I was trying to ask.”
Thorin kissed his hair.
“I shall always try to listen, ghivashel. Even when you haven't found the words.”
Bilbo smiled against his chest.
Outside, the wind moved softly through the trees surrounding Brandy Hall.
Somewhere farther along the corridor, a door opened and closed. A child laughed briefly before being hushed, and the great household settled once more into its nightly quiet.
In another room, Frodo Baggins slept with a little wooden cart resting upon the table beside his bed.
Its wheel no longer wobbled.
And though the boy did not know it yet, two people were lying awake nearby, thinking about how they might offer him something no broken toy could ever fully represent.
Not a replacement for what he had lost.
Not a promise that he would never be sad again.
Only a place where he could be loved.
A place where he could be a child.
A place where, when he was ready, he might begin to feel at home.
