Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 8: Bilbo Baggins, Guardian of the Trees

Summary:

Bilbo sneaks off to retrieve his sword, then finds himself racing to rescue his dwarves.

Notes:

So, please forgive me for the long wait. I had every intention of updating last week, or at the very latest, the beginning of this week. Then life hit me like a freight train. Needless to say, I will no longer be making predictions about my updates. Please accept this (somewhat) longer chapter as thanks for all of your patience and wonderful comments <3

(5/11/25)
Edit: I've gone through and fixed some of the grammar, as well as added a couple of paragraphs. No major changes were made to the story, there's just some extra details about Bilbo's current relationship with the dwarves

Chapter Text

Creeping through the shadowy depths of the Trollshaws, Bilbo began to wonder just how good of an idea this plan really was. He was tired, and hungry, and his shoulder still ached from falling off his pony earlier that evening. Granted, that had been a necessary sacrifice. If he hadn’t done something, the Company would have traveled straight on past the farmhouse and kept moving several miles beyond, and that would have been no good. There was no way he could have found his way to the troll hoard if they had continued on.

Still, he was starting to doubt his ability to find the hoard even with their camp being in the same spot.

He had snuck out of camp somewhere around an hour ago, managing to slip away without gaining the notice of Thorin, who was watching the woods like a hawk ever since they stopped for the night.

It wouldn’t be any good if Thorin caught him leaving because being caught would lead to a lot of questions that Bilbo didn't have an answer to. At least, no answer that wouldn’t make him sound completely mad.

No, nobody could know what he was going out to do that night.

When he returned to camp later, he would figure out some way to explain his absence, and how he had just happened to come across three elvish blades out in the woods. If he was lucky, maybe Gandalf would be back by then and he could help him form some sort of excuse.

Much to Bilbo’s dismay, the wizard left soon after they stopped to make camp, and no amount of begging could convince him to stay. When he tried to warn him of the danger they might meet there, Gandalf cut him off immediately.

“Don’t tell me anything! I fear that by knowing what will happen, I will somehow make things worse,” the wizard had said, refusing to hear another word of protest. Before he left, he patted Bilbo on the shoulder and gave him what was likely meant to be a reassuring smile. “If it makes you feel any better, I will keep an eye out for whatever danger it is that you fear.”

It didn’t make Bilbo feel better in the slightest.

Especially not now, when he was wandering through the woods, lost and alone.

Because he was indeed very lost.

At some point, he had gotten himself turned around, and now had no idea which way the troll hoard may be. Worse than that, he didn’t know which way to go to get back to camp. He could very well be stuck out there all night, never find his way back, and get left behind when the Company moved on in the morning.

The dwarves were pleasant enough to travel with—when they weren't busy mocking him for his bouts of hay-fever, that is—but he wasn't truly friends with any of them, yet.

Bombur welcomed his help cooking supper in the evenings and they could chat about spices and such easily enough, but they weren't quite at the point of trading recipes. Ori was fascinated by hobbit record keeping traditions in the Shire, and he'd sidle up to Bilbo to hear more about it sometimes when Dori's back was turned. Fili and Kili liked to pester him with ridiculous questions about hobbits when they got bored enough. (Mister Baggins, is it true hobbits can eat anything? Mister Baggins, are hobbit feet so big because they're like paddles to help you swim faster? Mister Baggins, do hobbits live in burrows because you're descended from rabbits? Mister Baggins—) Yesterday, he'd made the unfortunate mistake of giving a rather inappropriate response to that last question relating to rabbits and how quickly they reproduce. He regretted it immediately, but at least it had the benefit of drawing Bofur into the conversation, who was in stitches from laughing so hard.

The rest of the Company remained suspicious and distant. He was making progress and had high hopes they might warm up to him soon, but for now he was still an outsider. And he didn't doubt they would leave him behind.

The thought did nothing but make him feel panicked, and his pace quickened until he was nearly jogging, dodging around trees and hopping over roots as best he could. The longer he went on, though, the more he felt that he was just going in circles. Still, he didn’t stop moving. Not until his foot caught on uneven ground and he stumbled, falling to his knees on the forest floor.

He stayed there for a few moments, muttering some colorful curses under his breath and bemoaning his scuffed toes, but his complaints were cut short when he heard a strange sound.

At first, he thought it had to have been a breeze rustling in the treetops—or, that was his hope—but then he heard it again, and the sound was unmistakable.

Somebody, or something, was singing.

“Bilbo, you are a damn fool,” he whispered to himself, and his fear of being abandoned by the Company was replaced by a fear of something different.

He ventured into the woods earlier under the impression that as long as he avoided the trolls, he would be fine. He didn't consider there might be more dangers to find hiding in the dark shadows of the trees. What other monsters could be lurking about, just waiting for him to wander into their grasp?

How could he be so stupid?

During the day, this forest was unfamiliar to him at best—he had only traveled through a handful of times in his life, after all—and at night, it was ten times so.

The singing grew slightly louder, and as a chill began to creep down his spine, Bilbo remembered some of the stories of men—tales told with lowered voices on dark nights in quiet taverns. The ones of fairies that lured unknowing victims into their forest homes just to eat them.

Back in the Shire, people would scoff at the idea of fairies. They would say that there was no such thing, especially not in their peaceful corner of the world, and that would be the end of that.

But, well, Bilbo wasn’t in the Shire anymore, was he? Who was to say what was and wasn’t possible? He himself had gone back in time, for Yavanna’s sake! Was the existence of fairies, or any other nasty creature, really so unlikely?

Time travel aside, he had seen plenty of extraordinary and terrible things in his lifetime, so he had no place in ignoring such tales as purely fiction. Over the years, he had learned that most stories had at least some truth to them.

Yet even with the thoughts of fairies swirling about in his head, Bilbo found himself slowly relaxing. Because that melody—those words—he had heard them before. So long ago that he had practically forgotten them until now.

It sounded like home.

Like his mother washing dishes in the kitchen, swaying along to the music falling from her lips. Like his father’s voice drifting in through the open window from where he worked out in the garden.

The memory was so vivid and hit him so suddenly, he began stumbling off through the trees before he even consciously made the decision to do so.

He couldn’t bring himself to care that he was probably about to become the next meal of some malevolent creature.

The voice—soft and lilting—belonged to neither Belladonna nor Bungo, but it was familiar to him all the same. He had to know where it was coming from.

Besides, the singing was slowly but surely driving off his fear, and anything that comforting couldn’t be too terrible. Could it?

He was nearly desperate, hurtling through the woods with as much speed as he dared, and almost falling flat more than a few times. Still, no matter how quickly he went, the voice remained a steady distance ahead of him.

Just as he thought he would never catch up, the singer seemed to come to a standstill, and he propelled himself forward with a last burst of energy in a final attempt to reach them.

He flew out of the undergrowth and straight into the middle of a small clearing, and as soon as he skidded to a stop, the woods went silent. Nothing, not even a single cricket, made a sound.

There was only Bilbo, breathing heavily and whirling around in search of whoever’s voice he had been following, but there was no one. He was alone.

When the tears came, Bilbo did nothing to stop them from streaming down his cheeks and dripping onto his jacket front.

For a moment, he had been given a glimpse of his home. His true home. The one that had been full of his parents’ laughter and songs. The home that he hadn’t seen in over a century—and would never see again. And now that glimpse was gone, ripped away just as abruptly as the real thing was taken from him all those years ago.

He stood there for a long time, wallowing in his grief, and he would have stayed there for a great deal longer if he hadn’t realized that the clearing he was in the middle of looked rather familiar.

Wiping at his face and blinking away the bleariness in his eyes, Bilbo glanced around with confusion, then froze as his gaze landed on the gaping mouth of a cave.

He stared, and stared some more, hardly able to believe what he was seeing.

The voice—and whoever it belonged to—had lead him straight to his destination.

He was standing not more than a dozen feet away from the troll hoard.

Staring into the gaping mouth of the cave, Bilbo swallowed nervously.

Of course, when he first decided to head into the woods that night to retrieve their swords, he hadn’t taken into account just how dark it would be.

That was exactly the sort of thing he would forget.

Now here he was, ready to venture into a pitch black troll hoard with nothing to light his path. He almost thought about turning back, but shook his head immediately. He'd gotten this far, and there was no point in turning back now.

They needed those swords, and this was his only chance to get them. The Company would be moving on at dawn the next morning, and even if he did find a way to postpone their departure again, it wouldn’t matter because the trolls would be back in their cave come sun up anyways.

No, he had to get the swords now.

He’d just have to find them by feel rather than sight. How difficult could it be?

With that thought, he straightened up and—feigning confidence that he didn’t have—he strode into the dark.

The vile stench of troll hit him like a wall the moment he stepped inside and Bilbo stopped, unable to stop himself from gagging.

Digging around in his pocket for a moment, he found his handkerchief. If he held it over his face and breathed through his mouth it helped, but only just a bit.

He forced himself to take a couple of steps. Then a few more.

He could barely see his hand in front of him, let alone anything else in the cave, and Bilbo struggled to remember where the swords had been the first time around.

They’d been in some kind of barrel, he was pretty sure. Gandalf and Thorin had been looking at them. Now the only question was where that barrel was.

Unfortunately, his memory only went so far and he had no idea where to find it. Really, he only peeked in through the entrance the last time, not wanting to enter the reeking cave. His short look hadn’t truly been enough to memorize the layout of it all. For all he knew, the swords could be anywhere.

He would just have to search until he found them.

It was easier said than done.

The floor of the cave was uneven and Bilbo found himself stumbling every couple of steps he took. For the first few minutes he managed to stay on his feet, but then something was in front of him and he tripped over it, tumbling to the ground.

Whatever it was, it fell over and a tinkling sound of metal on metal rang in the silence.

Curiously, Bilbo reached out, searching until his hand eventually landed on something cool and round. The image of a small chest full of gold flashed into his mind and he remembered Bofur, Nori, and Gloin taking the time to bury it. A “long term deposit” they had called it.

On their way back to the Shire after everything was said and done, he and Gandalf stopped so Bilbo could dig up the chest and take it home with him.

Shaking his head, Bilbo shoved the coin into his pocket then slowly got to his feet again. Going more carefully this time, he continued walking, blindly holding his hands out in front of him so he wouldn’t run into anything.

The cave was dark enough that he could have been stuck in there for hours.

It reminded him of when he was a fauntling and he and his cousins would dare each other to venture into old Gerontius Took’s cellar. Down a small set of steps, the chilly-aired cellar was pitch black when the door closed. As one of the more adventurous children in the group, Bilbo inevitably found himself in there whenever he went to visit his grandparents. Once, the cellar door had gotten jammed and he was stuck in there for what felt like hours until his cousins finally found his mother and she came to rescue him.

That one experience had been the major cause of his longtime fear of the dark. It was a fear that he eventually grew out of, of course, but even now he couldn’t deny the small bit of apprehension that he felt in his current situation.

Luckily, his trip into the troll cave didn't last nearly as long as that long ago trip into his grandparents' cellar.

Only a couple steps away from where he tripped over the chest of gold, his foot touched something smooth on the ground. He slowly crouched down, reaching out until his fingers found what he was looking for. Standing straight again he held his breath as he ran his hand over the object. He didn’t need to see it to know that it was Sting.

The hilt of the blade was familiar in his hands, as though the last time he held it hadn’t been over decade ago. Even blind, he easily strapped Sting to his belt, then started forward again. It took only a few moments for his outstretched hands to find the side of a wooden barrel.

With Orcrist and Glamdring awkwardly clutched to his chest, Bilbo turned and made his way out of the cave, doing his best not to trip again.

Emerging into the fresh air again was a relief, and once he was far enough that he could no longer smell the stench of the cave, he stopped for a moment to just breathe. He leaned against a tree and closed his eyes with a sigh.

Somehow, he had managed to get in and out of the cave without any problems. He almost couldn’t believe it. Now if he could just get back to camp without something going wrong, he thought he might be setting some sort of record for himself.

“Bilbo?”

The squawk that the hobbit let out may have been the most undignified sound he’d ever made, but he was too startled to care.

Jerking away from the tree, his eyes flew open and Sting was halfway out of its sheath before he realized who it was that had spoken.

Bilbo stared at the grey-cloaked wizard for a few moments, then slowly let go of his sword, glaring.

“You nearly scared the life out of me,” he accused. “Where have you been?”

The old man simply shrugged. “Looking ahead. I believe I have discovered the source of your worries.”

Bilbo couldn’t help but give an unamused snort. “Have you really?”

As glad as he was to not be alone in the creepy woods anymore, he wasn’t about to show it. When the wizard wandered off earlier that evening, Bilbo nearly went into a panic. The only thing that made him feel at all better was the thought that Gandalf would surely be back to help if anything terrible happened—he always came back. But Bilbo had still been on edge ever since.

“It is a mountain troll, is it not?”

Bilbo thought the wizard sounded much calmer about the situation than he should have. “It’s three mountain trolls, actually. Three giant, smelly trolls that would be perfectly happy to eat the entire Company if so given the chance. Now, I suggest we get back before—”

He was cut off by a monstrous howl that that went echoing through the forest, sounding like a mix between a wounded cat and a furious orc, just ten times louder.

A cold flash of dread went through him, and Bilbo looked towards where the sound was coming from.

Towards the troll camp.

For a moment, he and Gandalf just stood there, until the next howl was let out and it jolted them from their stupors.

“Come on!” Thrusting Glamdring towards Gandalf, he turned on his heel and ran.

Streaking through the woods as fast as his feet could carry him, Bilbo couldn’t help but assume the worst.

The horrendous racket the troll was putting up didn’t necessarily mean that the Company was involved, of course, he knew that. But he could feel it—that tightening grip of dread—and he knew in his heart that his dwarves were in trouble.

He wasn’t wrong.

As he and Gandalf drew near enough to the troll’s camp that they could see the burning firelight through the trees, their run turned to a tiptoe and they crept as near to the clearing as they dared.

Peeking out from between the branches of a thick bush, Bilbo found himself looking at a sickeningly familiar scene.

Tied up in sacks and tossed in a haphazard pile was half of the Company. The other half was above the fire, slowly going through the process of being cooked alive. The ponies had all been herded into a makeshift corral and were stamping their hooves nervously.

One troll stood beside the fire, turning the spit and grumbling to himself.

The other two were off to the side, one of them sitting on the ground and wailing as the other leaned over him, poking and prodding none too gently at his horribly swollen eye.

Turning back to look at Gandalf, Bilbo hissed, “we have to do something.”

“Indeed,” the wizard mused, studying the scene before them with far less concern than the situation called for. “How did you manage to escape the last time? Assuming this happened before, of course.”

Bilbo couldn’t help the annoyance that shot through him at the question. “Oh, now, I can tell you about the future?”

Deeming not to respond, Gandalf just raised a single bushy brow and waited.

Bilbo glowered at him, but relented. “We distracted them long enough for the sun to rise and—”

“And turn the trolls to stone. Not the best plan, but I suppose it will have to do, given the circumstances. Dawn isn't too far off.”

He wanted to mention to the wizard that the plan had, in fact, been in at least part his idea, but he went on before Bilbo even had the chance to open his mouth.

“You be the distraction, and I’ll see what I can do about setting our friends free,” Gandalf said.

“How am I supposed to distract them?” Bilbo sputtered, but it was too late. Gandalf was already gone. “Ooh, damn that confusticating wizard!”

As much as he hated to do it, Bilbo would have to be the distraction whether he wanted to or not. He’d done it before and he would do it again, lest the Company be eaten and their journey end right then and there.

Shifting Orcrist in his arms—the sword was really quite heavy, but he couldn’t very well leave it there—Bilbo began his search for a good climbing tree.

 

***

 

He wasn’t sure how much time it took him to finally get perched up in the high branches of an oak tree overhanging the camp, but by the time he was settled, the troll with the hurt eye was still wailing as loudly as before, so he figured it couldn’t have taken too long.

It seemed his timing was perfect because it was only a couple moments later that the troll standing by the fire turned to his brothers and shouted.

“Shuddup, Tom! Your blubbering’s giving me a headache!”

“You take a burning stick to the eye and see how you like it!” Tom retorted, trying to scramble to his feet while clutching at one side of his face.

“Keep talking like that and you’ll see how you like a stick in both eyes!”

The third troll piped up then, pointing a log sized finger at the dwarves above the fire. “When’ll they be done, Bert? I’m starved.”

“Maybe it wouldn’t take so long if you lazy slugs ever bothered to help, Bill. Or maybe, I should just eat ‘em all myself and let you starve.”

Bill spat on the ground and shook his head. “You know I can’t cook.”

At the same time, Tom said, “I already called the one that stuck me! You can’t have it!”

And as though he feared Bert really would take his share of the meal, Tom lunged for pile of dwarves, his hands grasping at the burlap bags until he caught one and hauled it into the air and hung it over his gaping mouth.

It was Thorin.

An involuntary squeak found its way out of Bilbo’s throat, and he nearly leapt to his feet, only to remember he was in a tree and spent a moment scrabbling to keep his balance so he didn’t go plunging to the ground far below. Orcrist nearly slid from his lap.

He didn’t have time to come up with a plan, and he hadn’t spotted Gandalf anywhere since he disappeared. It was up to him to do something.

“Tom!” It took a moment for Bilbo to realize that the shout had come from him and he froze, sure that he had just given himself away.

The trolls didn’t see him, though, and Tom let out a shriek, dropping Thorin back onto the pile.

“What was that?!” Tom asked, spinning around to find whoever had said his name.

Bill looked as confused as his brother, but Bert turned a glare on the dwarves. “Oh, calm down, you lump. One of them’s messing with you.”

“I say we eat ‘em now to shut ‘em up,” Bill suggested, sliding a slimy tongue over his lips hungrily.

Cursing himself for his own stupidity, Bilbo cleared his throat and shouted again. “Bill!”

“Who’s that?”

“Bert!”

Whipping his head toward the dwarves again, Bert held up a knife threateningly. “Make another sound and I’ll cut out your tongues.”

This is a terrible idea, Bilbo thought.

“You will not touch them,” he said, and his voice boomed throughout the clearing, amplified louder than it should have been and sounding as though it came from every direction. It startled him so badly he nearly fell again.

Gandalf must have done something. Used some kind of magic to manipulate his voice.

Bert spun around, brandishing his knife and ended up facing slightly away from where Bilbo was actually perched. “Show yourself now and maybe I’ll let you live,” he spat.

“You better hope I let you live, after everything you three have done.”

“And who’re you to think you could kill three trolls?”

Bilbo had no idea what he was doing, and with his thoughts spinning so quickly he couldn’t process any of them, he grabbed the first one he could catch and held on. He pitched his voice lower and spoke in a dramatic tone, much as he used to do when Frodo was still young enough to ask for bedtime stories. “I am the guardian of trees. You have come into my home and ripped up the roots of this forest, and I do not take trespassers lightly. Begone, or you will feel my wrath.”

It was quite possibly the stupidest idea he'd had to date, but it was too late to go back now. And as though the very words had summoned it, a harsh wind picked up and blew through the woods, making the very trees tremble.

Bilbo made a mental note to thank Gandalf later.

Tom let out a frightened noise and stumbled into Bill, who growled and shoved him away, though he too looked unnerved. Only Bert was unmoved by the performance, if anything, he looked even more angry than before.

He swung his knife threateningly at Tom and snapped, “stop it, you! You’ll squash our supper.”

Indeed, he had barely missed stepping on poor Bombur who only just managed to roll out of the way.

Looking down at all the dwarves, Bilbo bit his lip. The ones in the sacks were all struggling to get free, but were no nearer to doing so. He was more worried about those still tied to the spit above the fire, though. They had stopped turning for at least a couple of minutes now, and those few unfortunate enough to be stuck on the bottom of the turn were being roasted by the flames licking at them from below. It was lucky that dwarves tended to have a certain amount of resistance to fire, or they'd likely be dead already.

So, he tried again.

“I said begone!”

The trees shook harder, but Bert stood firm. The damn troll was nearly as stubborn as Lobelia.

The other two, at least, were not.

Nudging at his brother’s arm, Tom was looking frantically at the woods around them. “Can we fight a ghost?” he asked, his voice somewhat shrill.

Bilbo didn’t know where ‘ghost’ had come from, but he wasn’t about to correct them.

“Quiet! It’s only a trick,” Bert hissed. Then, louder, he said, “Come on, then, oh Guardian!”

Another glance at the dwarves, and he saw that they were getting restless. They had started squirming about on the ground like a bunch of lumpy looking worms, and the sight would have been rather comical if not for the danger they were currently in.
They were beginning to grow restless as well, and Bilbo could hear them grumbling.

The only dwarf not moving around was Thorin. He was laying still on the ground, staring directly at the old oak where Bilbo sat. How he had pinpointed his location, Bilbo had no idea. He was quite positive he was hidden from view by all the branches and leaves. Still, Thorin was looking. And there almost seemed to be a hint of a smile on his face, though surely that was just his own imagination.

Drawing in a steadying breath, Bilbo turned his attention back to the trolls. Then, like a miracle sent from the Valar, he spotted a flash of grey on the other side of the clearing, and a moment later, there was the first hint of sunrise on the horizon.

“So be it,” he said.

Then Gandalf split the boulder and the golden sunlight of dawn spilled into the camp and the trolls were no more.