Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Summary:

When Mahal himself offers to send Thorin back to the start of the quest to save the line of Durin, he is determined to make amends for all of the mistakes he made the first time around.

When Bilbo wakes up in Bag End eighty years in the past, all he knows is that he has somehow been given the chance to see his beloved dwarves again and he'll be damned if he doesn't take it.

Both dwarf and hobbit are desperate to prevent the quest from ending in tragedy, but neither will be able to do it on their own. They'll need to work together if they want to keep the entire Company alive and whole --but first they need to realize that they are not alone in their efforts, and they have to stop getting in each other's way at every turn they make.

Hopefully, they'll learn some things this time that they failed to learn before. And maybe, just maybe, they'll find their happy ending that both have been yearning for.

Notes:

This idea has been bouncing around in my head for over a year now, and I keep coming back to it every few months to add a bit more and edit things, but I've never gotten around to turning it into a coherent story. I've started working on it yet again, and I finally decided to actually publish it here in the hopes that it will motivate me to finish it.

This is the first fanfiction I've gotten up the courage to actually share with people, though it definitely isn't the first that I've written. I have thousands of words saved in dozens of documents stowed away where nobody will ever read them. If this goes well, maybe I'll start to share those stories as well.

For now, I hope you enjoy this first chapter --the next one is already written and I'll post it soon.

I'm the only one who has ever read/edited this, so any mistake is my own. If you happen to notice any errors, I'd appreciate it if you'd point it out so I can fix it.

Thank you!

Chapter 1: A Second Chance

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

He was so beautiful, with his large hazel eyes, and his curly mop of hair, and his face framed by a halo of golden sunlight. It didn’t matter that he was covered in grime or that there was blood on his bruised temple. The only thing that could make the hobbit more breathtaking in that moment was if his look of despair turned to a smile and the tears running down his cheeks were to cease. If Thorin had strength enough to do so, he would reach up and dry them himself, but he could hardly keep his eyes open, let alone lift his entire arm. But oh, how he wished he could cup those round cheeks in his palms or feel those soft lashes flutter against his fingertips at least once. As he was unable to do so, he had to settle with just staring up into the hobbit’s devastated face, which was steadily growing blurrier and blurrier as time went by.

Despite how muddled his thoughts were becoming, Thorin found himself thinking that if this was the last thing he ever saw, at least he would die happy knowing that Bilbo was alive—that he hadn’t been the cause of yet another pointless death.

Releasing a shuddering sigh, Thorin finally let his eyes fall shut, too exhausted to keep up the effort of holding them open. The hobbit spoke then, but he was already too far gone to understand the words. All he could make out was the anguish with which he said them. It sent a twinge of pain through Thorin’s chest—or maybe that was just the stab wound. Either way, it was accompanied with a wave of guilt and the urge to comfort his burglar, though he knew there was nothing he could do now. At the very least, he had gotten the chance to apologize for his actions on the wall.

It wasn’t ideal—a dying plea for forgiveness was not nearly enough to make up for the enormity of what he had done—but it would have to suffice. He hadn’t the time to do any better than that. Already, he could feel himself fading.

Soon he would be laid to rest in stone.

 

***

 

Thorin was alone in a cold, dark abyss. He had no sense of how much time was passing by, and as far as he knew it could have been only moments that he was there or centuries. The lack of sensations in the place was both terrifying and maddening. He could feel nothing—couldn’t even tell if his eyes were open or shut. It seemed possible that he didn’t even have a body at all. Maybe he was just a thought floating there in the darkness. All he had was the icy cold and the fear that he would be stuck there forever.

As he had lay dying on the frozen waterfall above the battle, he’d thought that he would finally get to see the Halls of Waiting and be reunited with his family after so long of being separated from them. He longed to feel his mother’s arms around him and to see Frerin once again. He needed to find Vili and apologize for leading his sons into such peril. And Fili and Kili, his two precious boys, he had to tell them how much he loved them. Before the battle, he’d said nothing about it, thinking that it was unnecessary. Surely they knew how much he cared—how much they meant to him.

Now he realized he how much of a fool he had been. He had to make things right, but he couldn’t do that. Not while he was trapped there in that place of nothingness.

At some point, he began to wonder if he would ever see the Halls at all. Maybe he would be stuck there for eternity as punishment for his crimes. After all, hadn’t he succumbed to greed and locked himself inside a mountain full of gold, leaving his kin to die in his name? Even worse, he had turned on the one he owed his very life to—had tried to throw him from the wall and kill him, and for what? A silly, glittering stone? Not only had he betrayed the trust of a member of his Company, but of his friend. His One.

Yes, after everything was said and done, Thorin could finally admit to himself that it was true. The fussy, homebody hobbit—who was too concerned about handkerchiefs and armchairs and had never wielded a blade before their meeting that fateful day in the Shire—was his One. He had wasted so much time trying to deny it, and now it was too late. He would probably never see Bilbo again. He knew nothing of the afterlife of hobbits, but he did know that one would likely not be allowed to join him in his. What did that matter, though, when he himself might not be allowed in?

It was painful to think, but he knew that he didn’t deserve to await the remaking of the world in the Halls of his Maker. Not after everything he had done—all the mistakes he had made.

At least, that was what Thorin had managed to convince himself by the time he suddenly realized that he could feel stone against his back and that the cold was gone, replaced by a comforting warmth that reminded him of home. Slowly, he opened his eyes to see columns of carven stone towering above him and he stared up at them in confusion for a moment. It didn’t take long for him to understand, and when he did, he closed his eyes again.

This cannot be right, he thought as he took a shuddering breath, I shouldn’t be here.

Yet the warmth didn’t go away, and he became acutely aware of the fact that he was laying on the floor, and eventually it became too uncomfortable for him to take anymore.

Opening his eyes again, he sat up and then climbed to his feet. It was strange. After being fatally injured, he should have been in some of pain, but he wasn’t even stiff. He felt as healthy as he had ever been. Looking down at himself, he found that he no longer had any of the armor that he had donned for the battle. Now, he wore only a simple tunic, trousers, and his boots. There was no blood or grime on any of the clothing, and when he lifted the tunic to peek at his chest, he found no evidence of the stab wound Azog had given him. Actually, there was no sign that he had ever been in any battle. All of the many scars that he’d gained over the years were nowhere to be seen, and besides the ink of his tattoo, his torso was otherwise left unmarked.

Somewhat unnerved by the sight, Thorin let the tunic fall back into place and turned his attention to his surroundings instead. He stood in the middle of a large, empty hall lined lengthwise with two rows of stone columns that rose to a ceiling far above. Below his boots, the floor was polished smooth as glass and he could nearly see his reflection looking back at him. On one end of the hall, a throne stood empty on a raised dais. He stared at it for a moment then tore his gaze away and walked over to the column nearest to him. As far up as he could see, there were intricate images carved into stone. Reaching out, he ran his hand over the lines curiously.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

He jerked away form the column like he’d been burned and spun around to face whoever had spoken. A few feet away stood a dwarf who had thick auburn hair and beard, both long with many beads and braids. He looked middle-aged, but his eyes held the wisdom of a being far older than any that Thorin had ever met before. Older, even, than Gandalf. It took only a moment for him to realize whose presence he stood in, and a moment more him to drop to one knee and bow his head respectfully.

“Mahal,” he breathed.

“I thank you, my son, but there is no need for it. Please, on your feet. I would have us speak on equal ground, not with you beneath me.” His voice fell silent after the words and the only sound was his footsteps as he walked closer.

Thorin looked up, eyes landing on the hand held out to him. He hesitantly took it and allowed the dwarf to help him to his feet. Up close, he was surprised to find that he stood an inch or two taller than him.

Once he was standing, the dwarf spoke again. “I have wanted to meet you for quite some time, though I admit it was not meant to be like this.”

Blinking, Thorin somehow found his voice. “I am sorry, but I am not sure what you mean.”

“You are an honorable dwarf, Thorin son of Thráin."

Thorin may have thought he was joking, but there was no hint of humor in his deep voice. The words were completely serious, and that confused him more than anything. He didn’t deserve to be titled as such, especially not by the Maker himself. “I thank you for your words, but—”

“But you do not believe them. Why?”

“I...I failed. I failed them. Dwalin and Balin and the others. Fili and Kili.”

“You have been through much, Thorin. You served your people well, even when many others would have turned their backs. You provided for them. You retook the mountain.”

Mahal spoke with no judgement in his voice, just kind curiosity. He acted as though he were just another dwarf—looked and sounded like one, too. Had Thorin met him under other circumstances, he never would have recognized the being for who he truly was. Maybe it was for that reason that he was able to answer the question. “I allowed dwarf blood to be spilled for the sake of my pride and greed. I fell to the madness.” 

“Ah, the sickness. It is a terrible thing. I would not wish it on anyone, yet even I am powerless to end it.” There was a hint of sadness in his voice, and he fell silent for a moment, studying Thorin with wise eyes. “Still, you overcame it in the end—something that even your grandfather hadn’t the strength to do. You returned to your own mind and went to aid in the fight, even when it seemed that all hope was lost. I do not see that as failure.”

Maybe it was not the best idea to argue with a literal god—especially when that god was complimenting him—but Thorin had always been somewhat hard-headed. “I may have reclaimed the mountain, but what of my sister’s sons? It was my foolishness that lost them their lives.”

Mahal didn’t seem at all surprised by his arguing, or offended by it. He simply considered him appraisingly for a moment. His stare was one that Thorin could not hold for long, and he looked away, dropping his gaze to the floor. The Maker thought him honorable, and Thorin himself wasn’t even sure why he was trying to convince him otherwise. Maybe it was his lingering guilt of all that had happened. If he had only just…

As if reading his thoughts, the dwarf spoke up once again. “Tell me, given the chance to go back and change things, what would you do differently?”

The question was not one that Thorin had to search out an answer for. “I would ensure that Erebor was better protected—better prepared for a dragon attack. I would prevent the mountain from ever being taken.”

“Really? And what of your hobbit? Were it not for the quest to reclaim Erebor, you would not have met him. Would you change things, even while knowing that it would result in you never meeting your One?”

Caught off guard, Thorin’s eyes snapped back up from the floor. He wasn’t sure why Bilbo was being brought into the conversation, but he still did not have to think long to come up with an answer. When he spoke, his voice was surprisingly hoarse. “Without the quest, I may not have met him, but he also never would have left the Shire. He would have stayed in his home with his books and his armchair and would never have known fear, or what it is like to starve. Yes, I would still change things. I may be left without my One, but at least he would be happy.”

“You say that as if you had forced him to join you and your Company. I wonder, what would his thoughts on the matter be?” Mahal mused.

“Why do you ask me these things?”

“I cannot send you back to before the dragon came, Thorin. The past is in the past, and it is too late to fix any of it.” He paused, as if waiting for some kind of interruption, but Thorin said nothing. “The present, however, is a different matter. What happened on Ravenhill was a mistake. The line of Durin was not meant to be broken. Whether through you or one of your heirs, it should have carried on. Durin’s sons were meant to rule under the mountain for generations to come.”

It was possible the words were meant to serve as some comfort to him, but they only succeeded in reminding Thorin once again all that he had lost. Wincing, he forced out a response. “Dáin is a good dwarf, and he will make a fine king.”

“There were many ways that the future might have played out, but Dáin becoming king was not meant to be one of them.”

Silence so quiet they could have heard a grain of sand hit the floor stretched between them, and Thorin struggled to make sense of it all. Maybe his words were true, but what did that matter now? Meant to be or not, Azog had killed the line of Durin. The only one who remained was Dís, and the line could not carry on through her. She could not have another child if she wanted to, and as soon as she was gone that would be the end of it.

After a while, he gave up on understanding and just shrugged helplessly. “What is it that you are trying to say?”

“This is your choice, Thorin. You may walk through that door and reunite with your kin right now. Your grandparents, mother, brother...they await the day that you will finally join them. If that is what you wish, then I will not stop you.” Mahal paused, but it was obvious something was being left unsaid.

Impatient, Thorin prompted him to go on. “Or?”

“Or, I can send you back to the beginning of the quest, and you can fix what was broken.”

“You said that the past cannot be changed.”

“Time is a strange thing, my son, and I will not attempt to explain it fully. Just know that what may be the past for you is still my present. In a way, the events of your past year have all happened in the same instant, and are still happening now. The start of your journey has not yet left my reach.”

“Then why return me to the start?” Thorin asked. “Would it not be simpler to send me back to the battle, before I sent Fili and Kili into the Defiler’s trap?”

“While that may be the simpler option, I do not believe it would be the most beneficial. There are things you must yet learn, and they are lessons that the battle alone cannot teach you. In time, you will understand why it must be so. For now, should you choose to do this, I must ask you to trust my judgement."

Pursing his lips, Thorin glanced over Mahal’s shoulder and looked to the door that he had mentioned earlier. It resided on the wall behind the throne, and looked simple in comparison to the rest of the grand room, but if what the god said was true—and Thorin had no doubt that it was—then it would lead him to his family. He had the urge to run to it and not look back. It would be such an easy thing to do. He could be done, finally be free from the hardships that life had wrought him. Erebor was in good hands.

Still, something stopped him.

“If I were to go back, what would I remember?”

Mahal's smile was wide enough to be seen even behind his thick beard. “Everything. Up to the very last moment at Ravenhill.”

“And this conversation?”

“Yes.”

Looking down at his hands, Thorin let out a long, slow breath.

This was a terrible idea.

With his luck, he would only succeed in making things worse. Still, it was a chance not to be passed up lightly. He had a feeling that there were not many others who were given such an opportunity, and he would be a fool to waste it. Had he not spent his time in the darkness yearning to right all of his wrongs?

He threw one last glance to the door before straightening up and meeting Mahal’s gaze. A time would come when he would see his family once again, but today was not that day.

“I will do it.”

Nodding, Mahal stepped forward and gently pressed his brow to Thorin’s. “Mizùl, Inùdoyê. Mahzirikhi zu gang ghukhil.”

The last thing Thorin saw was mithril eyes staring into his before there was a flash of light and everything went dark once again.

Notes:

Mizùl, Inùdoyê. Mahzirikhi zu gang ghukhil - Good luck, my son. I wish you a safe journey.
It's been a long time since I wrote this first chapter, so I don't remember exactly where found the khuzdul in it, but I am reasonably certain that it came from The Dwarrow Scholar.
I'd like to note that I did not come up with the name for Fili's and Kili's father. Vili is a name that I have seen used in numerous other fics, and I've found that I like it, so any credit for that goes to whoever decided to use that name first.

Chapter 2: A Rude Awakening

Summary:

Bilbo finds himself somewhere he expected to never see again, then proceeds to panic.

Notes:

I got a handful of lovely comments yesterday on the first chapter, and it seems that the general consensus is that people want to read more of my story. I am so grateful for all of the feedback, and I hope that you like this next part just as much as you liked the last. As promised, here's chapter two :D

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It was a nice morning, by all accounts. The early spring air was cool, but not cold, and the nearly cloudless blue sky promised a warm day. Already, hobbits were awake and eating their first breakfast or sitting outside having an early smoke. Fauntlings ran out their doors, excited for the new day and the good weather that would be perfect for playing conkers or flying a kite at the top of The Hill. Birds sang, and people milled about Hobbiton, getting ready for the market to open.

Yes, it was a nice morning indeed, but there was a slight problem.

At the end of Bagshot Row, inside a particularly nice smial with plenty of windows and a well-stocked pantry, there was a hobbit who was not enjoying the morning at all. In fact, he was in a bit of a panic.

Bilbo Baggins was a respectable hobbit—or at least he used to be—and being respectable, he liked to think that he was very level-headed. He’d had to go up against a plethora of nasty situations in his lifetime including (but certainly not limited to) negotiating with trolls, sharing in a game of riddles with a very unsavory creature, and facing a real live fire-breathing dragon—all of which had wanted to eat him at the time. Not to mention the thirteen dwarves that showed up in his home one evening unannounced and raided his pantry.

In any case, he thought he was rather accustomed to unexpected things happening by now, and it wasn’t often that anything truly surprised him anymore.

Still, when he opened his eyes and found himself staring up not at the sheer canopy of his bed in Valinor, but the ceiling of the master bedroom of Bag End, he very nearly screamed.

He was sitting up and halfway out of the bed before he realized that he was actually moving.

That wouldn’t have been so shocking if not for the fact that he had lost basically all mobility when he was one hundred thirty-three and had been unable to walk two years before that.

Slowly lowering himself back onto the edge of the bed, Bilbo looked down at his hands and blinked.

No longer knobbed and wrinkled with blue veins and liver spots, his hands looked young again. They were soft and smooth except for the calluses formed from many days spent writing and working out in the garden, but were otherwise unaffected by age.

He gazed around the room in confusion before his eyes locked onto the mirror that stood in the corner.

Forgetting his concerns about walking, Bilbo was on his feet and in front of the mirror in a second. He stared into the reflection and familiar hazel eyes stared right back at him. A mop of brown curls sat atop his head, mussed and tangled from sleep, and he wore a rumpled nightshirt that he hadn’t seen in ages. Briefly, he wondered if he was dreaming. If he was, it was far more realistic than any dream he had ever had before.

His next thought was that he had finally died and passed on to the afterlife.

He hoped not.

Although it had been—and always would be—his true home, Bag End was not what he imagined whenever he pictured the place that he would spend the rest of his blessed eternity.

That had him moving again, and he hurried out of the bedroom. Heading through the smial, he passed through several rooms before he reached the entrance hall, where he opened the front door and flung it open wide before striding out into the bright morning sunlight.

Under normal circumstances, Bilbo would have taken a moment to appreciate the good weather. He would sit on his bench with a pipe of Old Toby in hand, or maybe go for a walk around the village. But this situation was far from normal. As things were, he hardly even noticed the nice breeze. Instead, he scanned his surroundings until his eyes landed on Hamfast Gamgee and he walked towards him quickly.

The hobbit knelt in the front garden, tending to the tulips that were just beginning to bloom. It took him a moment to notice Bilbo standing over him and when he did, he gave a friendly greeting, went back to the flowers, then did a double take.

Bilbo probably made for a strange sight, standing out there in broad daylight wearing only his nightclothes and a wild look in his eyes.

Completely unrespectable.

If any of his other neighbors walked by at that particular moment and seen him like that, they may have fainted, but not Hamfast. The gardener always had a way of taking Bilbo’s odd quirks in stride, even when he was young, and this was no different. So, rather than make a big deal out of his state of undress, Hamfast simply looked up at him with concern.

“Whatever is the matter, Mister Bilbo?”

Bilbo waved the question away impatiently. “Quick, what’s the date?”

“The date?”

“Yes, the date.” He hadn’t meant to snap, really, but at the moment he couldn’t care enough to apologize.

To Hamfast’s credit, he made a valiant effort at hiding his bewilderment at the strange manner of the question and answered him. “Why, it’s the twenty-fourth of April, I believe.”

“And the year?” Bilbo pressed. “What’s the year?”

This did stump him, and the gardener started up at him with a furrowed brow, looking as if he was contemplating asking Bilbo if he felt ill. He must have decided against it, though, because he spoke after a few moments. “It’s 2941.”

With a hurried mixture of thanks and good mornings, Bilbo turned and scurried back inside, slamming the door behind him and leaning back against it heavily. With his heart pounding and his breath coming in quick gasps as it was, one would have thought he had just run all the way to Michel Delving and back. Bilbo shuddered and sank to the floor, burying his face in his hands.

Things were definitely awry.

He had sailed to the Undying Lands nearly four years ago in the company of Frodo, Gandalf, Lord Elrond, and Lady Galadriel. He was supposed to be there now, at the venerable age of one hundred thirty-five and living out the remainder of his days in peace, not back in the Shire at the age of—he paused, taking a moment to do the math—fifty years old.

For some reason, the thought stirred up a memory in him and he pondered on it for a few seconds, then he froze and his eyes snapped open.

“Surely not,” he whispered, hardly willing to believe the idea that had just come into his head, but clambering to his feet anyways.

He made it halfway across the entry hall before he spun on his heel and paced back to the door, then repeated the action for a few minutes as he struggled to work through his spinning thoughts.

If Hamfast was correct about the date, then a certain wizard was due to appear at his gate tomorrow morning, inviting him to go on an adventure.

The sensible parts of him said there was no power in Middle Earth capable of turning back time, but once he had reached old age it was a well known fact that not every part of him was sensible.

Also, he knew first hand there was power outside of Arda, didn’t he? The whole fiasco with the Ring should be proof enough of that.

If its creator had managed to return to the world and cause all of that destruction, who could say what else was out there? He wouldn’t be surprised if the Valar themselves could send a hobbit through time if they really had a mind to do it, though he could hardly fathom why they would.

It was either that, or he'd finally lost what little was left of his dwindling wits.

Bilbo stopped his pacing and headed for the kitchen, meaning to fix himself up a calming cup of tea. All those thoughts of time travel and gods were making his head hurt, and obsessing over it wasn’t going to change the fact that he was there. Really, there was only one way to prove if his suspicions were true or not, and that chance wouldn’t come until late morning the next day.

In the meantime, all he could do was wait and get used to having his younger body back—that is, if he didn’t wake up by then.

 

***

 

By the time he went to bed that night, Bilbo was still not completely convinced he wasn’t dreaming. A small part of him believed he would wake in the morning just to find himself back in Valinor, old and half blind once again. He would call Frodo in to share breakfast with him and tell him of the strange dream that he’d had as he slept. Maybe after that, he would ask his nephew to read to him from a book of poetry for a while until he got tired.

It was a nice idea, but at the same time, he thought he might be disappointed. If he really had been sent back to the past, he had no doubt it was going to get him into endless amounts of trouble, but at the same time, it was nice to finally be able to hear the birds again.

 

***

 

He didn’t have the chance to find out if he would be disappointed or not because when he woke up the next morning, he was still in Bag End. He laid in bed for a long while, just staring up at the ceiling and thinking, but the longer he thought, the more nervous he became.

If he was indeed back in time, the proof he needed would be arriving in only a few hours time. He wasn’t even sure yet if he wanted to know, not because he was afraid he would find out that it was true, but because he was afraid he’d find out it wasn’t.

What if this day passed him by like any other peaceful day in the Shire, and Gandalf never showed up? What would he do then?

It wasn’t until the sun rose enough for its rays to shine in through the window and blind him where his head rested on the pillow that Bilbo finally forced himself to get up. He wouldn’t find any answers if he wasted the day away in bed. He had already missed breakfast, so he got dressed and shuffled to the kitchen to find something to eat, but by the time he was finished making his food, he had worked himself into such a state that he couldn’t even eat it.

So he sat there at the table, nibbling the corners of his toast and sipping his tea, but hardly tasting either. Eventually, his stomach got tied into such a knot he began to feel sick, and he gave up on eating all together.

Restless and with nothing better to do, he fetched his old pipe and went outside to sit on the bench and wait.

Bilbo knew he was out there a bit early, but he found himself fearing that if he wasn’t, he might somehow miss Gandalf when he passed by. If the wizard showed up at all. But no, he didn’t want to think about that. Gandalf would come. He had to. He was the only person Bilbo knew who might be able to give him some answers.

Still, as more time passed and elevensies grew closer and closer, he couldn’t help but worry. Surely Gandalf had come earlier than this the last time, hadn’t he?

Bilbo couldn’t remember.

It was so long ago, and he hadn’t exactly been paying much attention to the time back then. He was far more concerned with avoiding getting dragged into any kind of adventure by some firecracker-making loon, no matter how well that loon had once known his mother. It seemed somewhat ironic that now when he actually wanted an adventure to find him, it was taking forever to arrive.

After a while, Bilbo found that his hands were shaking so much he couldn’t even hold his pipe steady anymore. Muttering under his breath, he gave up on smoking and got to his feet.

“Blasted wizard is always late,” he grumbled, heading towards the gate.

If Gandalf was going to take his sweet time getting there, then he would just have to go and find the old man himself. A small voice in the back of his mind told him Gandalf wasn’t coming and he was being ridiculous, but he ignored it.

Gandalf had to be coming, because Bilbo didn’t know what he would do if he wasn’t.

With that thought, he stepped out of his yard and turned left, starting down the lane.

He paid no mind to the neighbors who called out greetings as he passed by, too distracted by his current purpose to respond to them.

For all his searching, Bilbo almost missed the old man entirely. He’d gotten so caught up in his worrying that when the wizard came around the bend ahead of him, he completely passed him up and nearly tripped over his own two feet in his haste to turn back around and catch up with him.

“Gandalf!”

At some other time, Bilbo may have gotten some satisfaction from making his old friend jump in surprise, but at the moment he didn’t care. He hurried up to Gandalf’s side and started speaking before he could even fit in a word of greeting.

“You have no idea how relieved I am to see you.”

“Bilbo Baggins, is that you? You are just the hobbit I was on my way to find.”

Gandalf looked delighted, and seemed ready to go on talking, but Bilbo cut him off before he had the chance. “Yes, yes, I know. You were taking too long, so I came to fetch you myself."

As happy as he was to see him, Bilbo was too wound up to participate in simple pleasantries. He wanted answers.

“You were expecting me?”

Noticing that there was a slowly growing group of fauntlings nearby all whispering excitedly and staring at the wizard with wide eyes, Bilbo felt suddenly that the middle of the road was not the best place to have this conversation. He glanced at Gandalf nervously, then motioned back in the direction of Bag End. “Let’s take this somewhere else, shall we? We have much we need to talk about.”

“That we do,” Gandalf said slowly, looking bemused. Then he shook his head and waved a hand. “By all means, Master Baggins, lead on.”

It took just a few minutes to reach the round, green door of Bag End, and they spent it walking in silence. By the time they got there, Bilbo had somehow managed to ignore his urge to blurt everything out, but he was practically vibrating with the effort of it, and when he opened the door he pushed it so hard it nearly slammed into the wall.

Gandalf asked if he was alright, to which Bilbo only gave a nervous chuckle before scurrying inside. The hobbit headed straight for the kitchen, but paused to look back at the wizard.

“Don’t hit your head on the light.” He gave the warning just at the right moment and Gandalf stopped, eyes wandering up to the light fixture hanging only inches in front of his head. Bilbo waved off his grateful look then turned away again. “You go ahead and make yourself at home. I’ll just make us a pot of tea, then we can talk.”

Just because his good sensibilities were long lost to him didn't mean he'd completely forgotten his manners.

Bilbo soon returned to the parlor, carrying a tray laden with tea and seed cakes. He set it on the table and passed a very large mug to Gandalf before settling into his armchair.

The wizard sipped the tea with an appreciative hum, then set the mug down on the table and turned his gaze onto Bilbo. “Thank you, my dear boy, this is quite nice. Now, I’m sure you are curious as to why I am here and—”

Too impatient to listen to the whole explanation, Bilbo cut in quickly. “Gandalf, forgive me for the interruption, but I know exactly why you’re here and before we get into that, I think you should hear what I have to say.”

Well, perhaps he'd forgotten some of his manners.

“Oh you do, do you?” Gandalf asked, amused. He folded his hands in his lap and sat back in his seat, watching Bilbo expectantly. “Alright, then. Why am I here?”

“You’re here to convince me to be the fourteenth member in a company of dwarves traveling to the Lonely Mountain to take Erebor back from the dragon Smaug.”

The wizard's amusement disappeared, and he regarded Bilbo with furrowed brows and narrowed eyes.

Bilbo couldn't blame him.

“What I’m about to tell you is going to sound utterly mad, but I swear to you, Gandalf, I am completely serious."

 

***

 

About fifteen minutes later, he sat stiffly in his armchair, watching as Gandalf paced back and forth across the room. The wizard had listened quietly as Bilbo gave his explanation, then stood up as soon as he finished speaking and began to pace, grumbling under his breath as he went. The fact that he hadn’t actually said a word in response to what Bilbo had told him was beginning to make him nervous—or at least even more nervous than he had already been before.

When he couldn’t take the silence any longer, he spoke up. “You do believe me, don’t you?”

The wizard finally stopped, an unreadable look in his old eyes. Then he returned to his chair, letting out a deep sigh as he sat. “Yes, Bilbo, I believe you.”

He paused and reached into his robe with one hand, digging around a bit before pulling out a silver flask. Unscrewing the lid, he tossed back a swallow of whatever the container held, then offered it to Bilbo.

Having some experience with the wizard's strange spirits, he politely declined.

Huffing slightly, Gandalf closed the flask and shoved it back into his pocket before speaking again. “I believe you, though I do not pretend to understand it. You said before yesterday, you were living in Valinor?”

“Yes, I traveled there with you, Lord Elrond, and Frodo after—”

The wizard interrupted him quickly, holding up a hand. “Don’t tell me. The less I know about it, the better. Time is a dangerous thing to mess with, Bilbo, and having knowledge of the future will be a heavy burden.”

Bilbo couldn't help his small scowl and he wanted to point out that he'd never had any intentions of 'messing with time' and he didn't do it on purpose. But he ignored the urge, knowing it wouldn't help anything. “Alright, I won’t tell you, but what do you suggest I do?”

“The way I see it, you can either set off once again on the quest to Erebor, or you could stay here in the Shire and try to start over—live out a quiet life with your books and maps.”

The second suggestion had Bilbo letting out a sound of protest before Gandalf had even finished speaking. He’d be lying if he said he hadn’t considered it, however briefly, but decided against it rather quickly. How could he stay in Bag End, even knowing all of the dangers that the Company had ahead of them? The idea was positively absurd. Even more absurd than a hobbit traveling back in time.

Bilbo was not so self-absorbed as to think that he was vital to the quest—surely they could make do without him—but there had to be some reason he was living through all of this again, and he refused to believe that it was so he could just spend the rest of his (second) life living in the Shire like some sort of normal gentle-hobbit.

There had once been a point in his life where that idea would have been very appealing indeed, but that time was long gone. Frodo asked him on occasion if he ever regretted his choice of running out his door to go on an adventure and if he would ever change it, given the chance. Bilbo’s answer to those questions had always been a decisive no, and that wasn’t about to change now.

Those dwarves had become something like a family to him over that year he had spent traveling with them, and they continued to be just that throughout the rest of his days. He wasn’t going to abandon them now, even if they weren’t yet aware of just how much they meant to him.

If Gandalf understood any of that from his long silence, Bilbo didn’t know, but he stood from his seat and reached for his staff and hat. “It seems you have made your decision, so I will bid you farewell, for now.”

“You’re leaving already?” The question came out as a bit of a squeak, but Bilbo was too alarmed to care, and he scrambled to his feet to follow the wizard back into the entrance hall.

“I am afraid that I must. I've already sent word to the dwarves to meet here, but there are other arrangements for our journey that still need to be made.” Gandalf stopped at the door and turned a reassuring smile down at Bilbo. “Do not fret, my friend. I will return tomorrow evening.”

“I know,” Bilbo grumbled, rolling his eyes at the old man's presumption. Inviting a gaggle of total strangers to gather at Bag End without so much as a by your leave, honestly. The nerve. He watched as Gandalf stepped outside then, remembering something, he hurried forward and called after him. “Gandalf!”

The wizard stopped and glanced over his shoulder at him.

“I know you plan on scratching some silly symbol onto my door, and I would appreciate it if you put it on the gate instead. The door was just repainted a week ago.”

Gandalf laughed and shook his head. “If I did not know any better, I would think you a mind reader. Yes, my boy, I will put it on the gate.”

Bilbo stayed in the doorway and watched the wizard as he left the yard then paused and used his staff to scratch the symbol onto the gate. It wasn’t until Gandalf had gone down the lane and disappeared from sight that Bilbo turned to go back inside. Something flashed in the corner of his vision—a figure clad in green—but when he turned to look at the garden where the person had been standing, there was nobody there.

Notes:

Chapter three might take a little bit longer to come out because there are a few parts I need to either rewrite or finish, but I promise it will be published within the next two days.

Also, for some reason the notes from last chapter seem to be at the bottom of this one as well, but I can't get rid of it. If anybody had any idea of how to fix it, I'd be grateful for the help :)

Chapter 3: The Start of a Long Road

Summary:

Thorin makes his way to the Shire and joins up with some of his Company on the way.

Notes:

Sorry if this chapter seems a bit filler-y. I tried to make it interesting, but... forgive me if it's boring. I swear the next chapter will be better.

(5/10/25)
Edit: I went through this chapter and made a few changes to make the timeline make a little more sense. As it is now, Thorin and Bilbo wake up on the same morning. Two nights pass, and the third evening is when the Company arrives at Bag End. I didn't change too much, but a few paragraphs were rearranged / rewritten.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When Thorin awoke, it was to a painful migraine and an insistent pounding in his head. It reminded him of the feeling he would get the morning after a night of downing far too much ale, but he couldn’t remember drinking. Actually, he couldn’t remember much about anything at the moment. Judging by the soft surface underneath him, he was laying in a bed, though he had no clue as to how he could have gotten there.

The last time he slept in a real bed was the Company's final night in Lake-town, and that was a couple of weeks ago, now. There currently weren’t any beds available in Erebor—at least, none that weren’t rotted and buried beneath nearly two centuries worth of dust—and they had all been sleeping on the stone floor of a balcony above the treasury ever since entering the mountain.

Or, most of them had been.

Thorin wasn’t sure when he'd slept last. Resting hadn’t seemed all that important compared to his search for the—

The Arkenstone. Smaug. A sea of golden treasure. An acorn. Bilbo in a shirt of mithril. Bard and Thranduil. Arkenstone. Bilbo dangling over the side of the rampart. Gandalf. Orcs. Dead Fili. Azog. Bilbo with tears rolling freely down his cheeks. Darkness. Ancient silver eyes.

The images whirled through Thorin’s mind so quickly he couldn’t even process one before the next took its place.

Eyes flying open, he shot up in bed, clutching at his chest and breathing hard. A bright beam of sunshine blinded him, and for a moment all he could see were flashes of color. When his spotty vision cleared, he looked down at his chest and was relieved to find no wound there. Or no fresh wounds, anyway—the scars he'd become accustomed to seeing when he looked at himself had returned. He was comforted somewhat by the sight and looked away from his torso to glance around at his surroundings, finding that he was in vaguely familiar room.

Before he could figure out exactly where he was, it came to his attention that the pounding wasn’t just in his head and somebody was actually knocking on the door—very impatiently, by the sound of it.

Grumbling, Thorin struggled to untangle himself from the mess of blankets wrapped around his legs then rolled off the bed and crossed the room. He turned the lock on the knob and pulled the door open to glare at whoever was out there.

It was a middle-aged man with a balding head and stubble on his chin that was a poor attempt at growing a beard. His fist was raised, poised to continue his insistent knocking, but it dropped back to the man’s side as soon as his eyes landed on Thorin. He, too, looked familiar.

“What do you want?”

The man huffed at his tone, but didn’t sound too bothered when he spoke. “I apologize, Master Dwarf, but you did request that I tell you the moment a message arrived for you.”

Thorin stared at him, then glanced down at the paper he held in his hand. Nodding, he accepted the paper and muttered a quiet ‘thank you’. He closed the door before the man could get out a response.

Alone again, Thorin stood frozen as he worked through what was happening. He remembered now—facing Azog atop Ravenhill, dying, speaking with Mahal. The Maker had promised to send him back in time to the beginning of the quest. If it was true, then that would mean he was in a room at the inn in Bree, just outside the Shire. And the paper…

Hurrying to unfold it, he nearly tore the note in half in his haste. He stared at the long, slanted handwriting for a moment, slowly processing the words. It took him a second or two, then he let out a sigh of relief.

I have found your burglar. We are meeting on the 26th of April at Bag End, the end of Bagshot Row, Hobbiton, the Shire.
Gandalf

It was short and hardly contained even the bare minimum of information he would need to get to their meeting place, as per the wizard’s usual cryptic form of communication. It was no wonder he’d had such a difficult time finding the place last time.

Thorin would have been irritated if it weren’t for the fact that the note served as proof that everything he remembered wasn't just some elaborate hallucination. He truly was back in time, which meant he had another chance. He could right his past wrongs. He could reclaim Erebor again. He could save his sister-sons from their fates and prevent the line of Durin from ending.

Swallowing hard, Thorin pushed the thought from his mind and slipped the note into his pocket then went about gathering his things and getting dressed. Their deaths were not something he wanted to dwell on at the moment. Or ever. He had things he needed to to and places he needed to be. First thing first, he needed to recruit their burglar—preferably without getting lost again.

He ate a quick breakfast at the inn, then was out of Bree and on the road to the Shire before the town of men had even fully awoken. He had about three days before he would be expected at Bag End, and the sooner he started on his way, the sooner he would get there. If he was lucky, maybe he wouldn’t be late this time around.

 

***

 

Throughout the day, Thorin didn’t stop once to take a break, choosing instead to keep up a maintainable pace the entire time. When it grew close to noon and he became hungry, he dug food out of his pack and ate as he walked. It was probably for the best, anyway. At least walking, he could count his steps to distract himself. If he spent too much time sitting idle, he would start thinking about everything that had happened, and what was going to happen next, and he wasn’t sure he was ready to do that just yet. He didn’t want to contemplate what the gold sickness had done to him, or the battle, or his death.

So he walked. And he counted. And this time he actually looked at the lands on either side of the road that he traveled.

The first time he went through there he had been unconcerned about his surroundings, too focused on his destination to care about the places he passed to reach it. Now he paid attention, if only to keep his mind off of other, more unpleasant things.

For much of that first day, the road was lined with trees that stood tall overhead and grew close together so that he could not see far into the forest’s depths. Shadows dwelled beneath the trees, dark and unwelcoming, and he felt there could be somebody watching him and he would never even know it.

It reminded him of walking the paths of Mirkwood.

His only comfort was that the road seemed to take him around the perimeter of the forest rather than straight through.

It was nearly night when the trees finally began to spread out, getting far enough apart that the last rays of sunset could stream through their branches and reach the grassy ground below. The forest lost its threatening atmosphere, and he felt like he could breathe easily again. Thorin thought that at some point, he must have crossed into the Shire, though the border had not been marked. He began spotting signs of the land's inhabitants—low fences that ran parallel to the road, flocks of sheep with young lambs skipping among them, and well-tended fields of growing wheat—and decided it was as good a place as any to stop for the night.

He made his camp off the side of the road, though he decided not to bother with a fire. He would be warm enough with his cloak, and he didn’t feel like searching for wood to burn out in the grassy fields. He doubted there was any to be found there, anyways.

The first time he spent the night camped on the side of the road in the Shire, he’d had difficulty finding any rest. Alone in an unfamiliar territory, he spent the majority of those dark hours watching his surroundings with suspicion, unwilling to be caught off his guard in this strange place. Now, though, he had no trouble getting comfortable in a soft patch of grass. He kept his sword close, but had no real fear that he would be in danger here. Bilbo always spoke of his homeland as a place of peace and comfort, free of all the conflict of the world outside its borders.

And if his One believed the Shire to be safe, then Thorin would trust him.

It didn’t take long for sleep to take him.

 

***

 

After crossing the bridge over the Baranduin River—which, according to Bilbo, was actually called the Brandywine River—the presence of hobbits became far more obvious. Houses started cropping up every so often, and though they weren’t built into the sides of hills, their size was far too small to be home to any men and their doors and windows were mostly round in shape. The hobbits themselves must have been there as well, though most he saw only from a distance, and he had to wonder if they were avoiding the road—and him—on purpose. He passed a couple of carts as he walked, but he didn’t interact with their drivers, nor they him except to side-eye him warily as he went by.

Their attention made him nervous, but he supposed he had the same effect on them. He must make an uncomfortable sight—a lone dwarf with sword and shield by his side, a traveling cloak around his shoulders, and a rucksack on his back.

To them, he probably looked like trouble.

He couldn't blame them for thinking so.

 

***

 

His second night in the Shire was just as restful as the first, and Thorin woke before dawn, eager to finally reach his destination.

The day passed by at a steady pace and the hills in the distance grew ever closer. Thorin was certain he was making better time than when he last passed through—probably because he wasn’t pausing at every little settlement along the way thinking it was Hobbiton. This time, at least, he knew where he was going. He could hardly be blamed for getting lost before, though. From what he had seen so far, there were no road signs to be found, nor any signs to give a name to the villages he passed by.

He could only assume it was because the Shire rarely had visitors, and if you were there, then you should already know where you were and where you were going. Which was all well and good when you lived here, but for him, it only made things more difficult. He really should mention the wizard’s horrible directions as soon as he saw him later that day. Though the complaint would likely fall on deaf ears.

It was late evening and the light was fading from the sky when he spotted three familiar figures sitting beside the road up ahead.

Picking up his pace, it didn't take long to reach the place where his friends were resting. None of them noticed his approach until he called out to them, but after that it was only a matter of moments before they were on their feet and greeting him enthusiastically.

Bifur was speaking quickly in khuzdul and signing so fast in iglishmêk that Thorin could hardly understand what he was saying, Bombur was asking about his journey, and Bofur removed his hat and swept into a low bow—then promptly stood back up and gave him a wide grin.

Thorin was surprised to find how relieved he was to see them, then realized for the first time that he had never learned what had become of the rest of his Company after the battle. He knew of his own fate, and the fates of his sister-sons, but he had no idea if any of the others had perished. He supposed it didn’t matter now, anyways. He wasn’t going to let any of them die this time around. Still, it was comforting to see these three now and know that they were alright.

“I hope you do not mind if I join you,” he said, nodding to the three of them in turn.

Bofur’s grin only grew at his words, and he stuffed his hat back atop his head. “'Course we don’t mind, as long as you don’t mind our gabbling.”

Thorin found himself returning the smile easily. “Not at all. I have been on my own for quite a while, now. Conversation while we travel would be a welcome change.”

They took a couple of minutes for the three to gather their things from the side of the road, then they were walking again, and Thorin felt a great deal happier than he had since waking up in his room in Bree—longer, even. He couldn’t actually remember the last time he had been truly happy. Long before they entered the Lonely Mountain, no doubt—

Shaking his head to rid himself of the thought, he spoke up quickly, wanting to think about anything other than the madness that had taken hold of his mind upon reaching Erebor.

“How has your journey been so far?” he asked Bofur. “Not too difficult, I hope.”

He listened as the three recounted their travels, glad to have friends there to distract him.

 

***

 

When their troop of four crossed the bridge into Hobbiton, the sky was a dark shade of indigo and the stars were just beginning to appear. The night was calm, the only sounds being that of the laughter coming from the tavern a short ways back down the path, the musical chirping of night-bugs, and the turn of the water wheel in the river. And, of course, the quiet chatter of the Ur family.

Thorin walked a few strides ahead of the others and led the way through the quiet village. He was too deep in his thoughts to concentrate on the words of his companions, or to contribute any of his own.

Much of his travel through the Shire over the past days felt only vaguely familiar, and it hadn’t been until very recently that he started to recognize where they were with more certainty. The last time he was there, he spent more time wandering around Hobbiton looking for the place in Gandalf’s note than he liked to admit. He was sure he had walked every path of the village at least twice before he finally found his way. It was more than a little frustrating back then, but now it meant he was reasonably confident in his ability to reach Bag End without too much backtracking.

He hoped.

Making their way up the paths that wound around and between the hills, Thorin distractedly noticed many of the hobbit holes they passed still had light streaming out from their windows. Before, most of the village had been dark and quiet. With any luck he wouldn’t be so late in arriving at their meeting place.

Maybe he would actually make it in time to take part in the meal that he missed out on at the beginning of their journey to Erebor. More importantly, maybe he could make a better first impression on their host and prospective burglar. Tired, hungry, and eager to begin his quest, he hadn’t made the most gracious of guests.

Actually, in retrospect, he had been more than a little rude to the hobbit who was so kind as to provide all thirteen of them with food and shelter for the night.

Distracted as he was, Thorin nearly didn’t notice when a large group of dwarves and one wizard came into sight on the path up ahead. If it wasn’t for Bofur’s cry of greeting to them, he may have passed them all up entirely. As it was, his attention fell to the dwarves and he counted them as he approached, glad to find that all but five of his Company were present.

Once they reached the rest of their group, they all took a moment to greet each other. After receiving a rather firm slap on the back from Glóin and an inquiry of his health from Óin, Thorin found himself approaching Gandalf, who stood a bit separated from them, silently watching the exchange. The wizard nodded to him kindly, but it wasn’t until they all started up the path again that they spoke.

“Your message was rather vague in giving directions to this place,” Thorin said, ignoring the talking from the rest of the dwarves behind them.

Gandalf let out something that could either be a cough or a huff of laughter. “And yet you found your way here all the same. Tell me, how did your meeting with the council go?”

“I would rather wait until we are all gathered to speak of it.” Thorin did his best to keep his tone cool, but he couldn’t stop the slight grimace from showing on his face. The disappointment from that meeting was still rather fresh, despite it having taken place over a year ago for him.

Gandalf hummed with understanding but said nothing else, which Thorin was grateful for. They were nearing the top of the hill, and he wanted to watch for Bag End rather than engage in conversation. The moment he caught sight of the short wooden fence and the green door beyond that, his heartbeat and pace both quickened. He was the first to reach the gate, where the wizard's mark was etched into the wood, a clear sign that this was their destination.

Thorin paused to squint at the faintly glowing symbol, confusion stirring in the back corner of his mind. Hadn't it been on the door last time? After all, that had been part of the reason he struggled to find Bag End before. The door was set far enough back from the path that he'd been unable to see the mark until he entered the yard, and he was sure he'd passed their meeting place by at least once while he wandered lost through the village.

He cast a glance over his shoulder at the wizard who raised a fuzzy brow when their eyes met.

"Is something the matter?"

Pursing his lips, Thorin shook his head once, then opened the gate and stepped into the garden. Circles of yellow light shone on the grass, cast from the round windows on either side of the door. He stopped again, his feet suddenly heavy as boulders.

On the other side of that door resided his sister-sons, his best friend and shield brother, his most trusted advisor, and his One—two of which had recently lost their lives in a battle against an army of orcs, and all of which he had both wronged and betrayed in his madness. They, of course, would have no knowledge of any of that, but his guilt still weighed heavily on his heart nonetheless.

How could he face them after everything he had done? After doubting their loyalty, valuing a shimmering stone over their worth, and threatening their lives?

The simple answer to that question was that he couldn’t.

Still, no matter what shame he carried with him, he had to suck it up and walk through that door. If he didn’t, he couldn’t fix his mistakes, and that was the whole point of him being there.

He heard rather than saw his companions gathering behind him. Knowing he couldn’t just stand there forever without raising any questions from them, Thorin drew in a deep breath. Then, doing what he could to smother his anxious thoughts, he took the last couple of steps and went to knock on the door.

Notes:

I realize that it would take more than two days for Thorin to walk all the way from Bree to Hobbiton, but let's just pretend for the sake of this fic that they're closer to each other than they actually are. Or maybe dwarves are just capable of traveling large distances in short amounts of time...

Chapter 4: Familiar Faces

Summary:

As the Company begins to arrive at Bag End, Bilbo does his best to be a good host while trying to keep calm in the face of re-meeting all of his dearest friends —many of which are meant to be dead.

Notes:

This chapter is a bit shorter than the others, but I hope it will be just as good :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Early in the afternoon on the twenty-sixth of April, Bilbo headed for his kitchen.

It was a bit soon to start preparing for supper, as the first dwarf wouldn’t even arrive until after dark, if his memory served him correctly, but he could at least start on making extra seed cakes and maybe a few batches of biscuits. He seemed to remember that it hadn’t taken very long to run out of both the last time around. Besides, working in the warm kitchen, mixing cake batter, and being surrounded by the smell of baking things gave him something to keep his mind off of what was to come later. If he thought about it too much, he feared he was prone to dissolving into another panic.

So he baked and cooked until every available surface in the kitchen was taken up with food. It was nearing the evening when Bilbo finally forced himself to stop and clean up. He decided to take a quick bath—both to get the flour out of his hair and because he knew he wouldn’t have another chance to bathe properly until they reached Rivendell.

Unfortunately, bathing didn’t hold the same kind of distraction as working in the kitchen did. His mind started to wander, and before long he found himself thinking about the past. Or maybe now it was the future?

The last time he had seen any members of the Company was after the War of the Ring finally ended. He was still living in Rivendell then, Gloin had visited to attend a meeting that would recount everything that had happened, in a way ending the journey at the place it began; in Lord Elrond’s council. Bilbo particularly remembered the dwarf’s reaction to his son’s relationship with the elf prince, Legolas. The old dwarf had thrown a rather impressive fit—which involved many despairing words recalling the Company’s imprisonment in the dungeons of Mirkwood—and it served as a great source of amusement for Bilbo.

Before that, he'd seen the other dwarves only a handful of times each. One of the most memorable of them had been when Bifur, Bofur, and Nori came to escort him from the Shire when he left on his one hundred and eleventieth birthday.

It was with great sorrow that he later learned of Balin, Ori, and Oin’s demise at Moria—he mourned them for a long while after Frodo had told him of that.

Now, in just a short time, his friends would be arriving at his front door, alive and well.

But they won’t be your friends, Bilbo reminded himself glumly.

The dwarves coming later that day were the same ones that he had met during that first unexpected party, but they weren’t his dwarves. They weren’t the dwarves that he'd called his family for so long. Not really. None of them had yet shared in the perils of a long journey with him, and none would share his memories of their adventures.

To them, he would simply be Master Baggins, the strange halfling who had agreed to be their burglar.

It was with that unpleasant thought rolling around in his mind that Bilbo finally climbed out of the now tepid bath water and dressed in some fresh clothing. Outside, he could see the sun was beginning to set and the sky had taken on a pinkish hue. He estimated that he had maybe an hour left until people started showing up, meaning that he only had an hour left to prepare himself for what would likely be the strangest Wednesday in living memory.

Once he finished buttoning up his waistcoat and brushing the hair on his feet, he wasted no time in hurrying back to the dining room where he began to set the table. When he first hosted the troop of thirteen dwarves in his home, he'd been caught by surprise and there was nothing more laid out on the table than a baked fish and a couple of biscuits. He'd spent the entire event in a state of shock, and the quality of his hosting suffered for it. This time around, he was determined to do better. By the time his guests arrived, there would be a full meal ready and waiting for them, and there would certainly be enough seating ready to accommodate the entire Company or his name wasn’t Baggins.

 

***

 

When the first knock of the evening echoed through Bag End, Bilbo dropped the biscuit he was nibbling on and practically ran to the entry hall. Bursting out of the parlor, he skidded to a halt—somehow managing not to trip over his own two feet in the process—then took a deep breath. Smoothing his face into what he hoped was a pleasant smile, he reached out to the door with a shaking hand and pulled it open.

Considering the circumstances, meeting Gandalf in the past hadn’t been all that strange. The wizard was a constant in Bilbo’s life for several decades and could be counted on to never really change. As such, Bilbo hadn’t noticed anything different about him except for the fact that he was once again donning his grey robes and hat rather than the lighter ones he had worn ever since becoming Gandalf the White. He expected—or at the very least hoped—that seeing the dwarves again would turn out much the same. That he wouldn’t be shocked or too caught off guard with their appearances.

As it turned out, that had been a fool’s hope, and finding the dwarf currently standing on his front mat was a much different experience.

The last Bilbo had heard of Dwalin before setting off for Valinor was that the old dwarf was still very much alive and kicking—retired from his role as Captain of the Royal Guard of Erebor, but still protecting the home the Company had fought so hard to reclaim. While on their journey, it took a long while for him and the tattooed dwarf to begin trusting one another. It wasn’t until after they spent a few comfortable days under Beorn’s roof that Dwalin finally began to warm up to him. Still, Bilbo liked to think that the two of them were good friends before the end. It was for that reason that the sight of the warrior in front of him took his breath away and left him at a loss for words.

Whatever greeting he had planned promptly slipped from his mind and he was left utterly speechless. For a few moments, he could do nothing but stare, his smile slowly shrinking.

“What? Am I late, or something?” the dwarf asked gruffly, a slight scowl on his face.

The question brought Bilbo back to his senses somewhat and he shook his head quickly. “No, not at all. You’re the first to arrive, actually.” He gave a hasty bow then stepped out of the way and motioned the dwarf inside. “Bilbo Baggins, at your service. Please do come in. I’ve just put supper on the table.”

Seeming hesitant to accept the invitation inside, the dwarf inspected Bilbo cautiously for a moment. In the end, the mention of food must have been enough to convince him because he stepped through the door and introduced himself. He allowed Bilbo to take his cloak, then followed behind him as he lead the way to the dining room. At the sight of the meal on the table, Dwalin relaxed somewhat and sank into the nearest chair, beginning to pile food up onto a plate.

Figuring that the dwarf was well enough to be left alone, Bilbo returned to the kitchen. He checked on the raspberry tart in the oven then pulled out the pan, placing it on the counter to cool.

When he heard the next knock a few minutes later, Bilbo left some mince pies on the table on his way through the dining room.

Seeing Balin was no easier than seeing his brother was—harder, even, since the old dwarf was meant to be dead—but he somehow managed not to stare for too long and gave a cheerful greeting. He lead Balin to the dining room where they found Dwalin with his hand wedged inside a jar of biscuits. Noticing them, the warrior abandoned his plunder and approached his brother.

Bilbo hung back in the doorway and watched as the two teased one another and cracked their heads together.

A long time ago, the violent form of greeting was startling, but now he just turned away in order to hide his fond smile at the display of affection, then headed back to front door to wait for his next guests.

Another few minutes passed, then the bell rang once, then a second time, then went silent. Knowing who would be on the other side, Bilbo had to brace himself before opening it. The two young dwarves standing there both bowed at the same time, politely introducing themselves and then standing straight again to grin at him.

The Defiler had Fili in his grasp, dangling the young dwarf prince over the edge of the crumbling tower. Even from so far away, the terror—and even worse, the resignation—could easily be seen in his wide eyes. Beside him, Dwalin cursed softly and Thorin let out a broken gasp, but Bilbo could make no move to comfort them. All they could do was watch with horror as Fili screamed for them to run and Azog’s blade pierced him through the back. Then he fell, his limp body plummeting to the icy ground far below...

“You must be Master Boggins!” Kili said cheerfully.

Drawn out of the terrible memory by the comment, Bilbo swallowed the lump that had formed in his throat and did his very best to smile. “It’s Baggins, actually.”

“Well, Master Baggins,” Fili said, making sure to put emphasis on his name. “I hope we came in time for food.”

“You came at the perfect time,” Bilbo assured them and moved out of the way so they could both go inside.

They did so, and after closing the door and taking their cloaks and weapons, Bilbo stayed back. He watched them head in the direction of the dining room, and listened as they greeted Balin and Dwalin. Letting out a long breath, he leaned back against the wall and closed his eyes tightly. Those boys...the image of their bodies lying still and lifeless before him during the funeral would forever be ingrained in his memory.

Bilbo always heard people say that the dead looked like they were only sleeping, but he'd never seen it that way. At his father’s funeral, his mother’s, the Durins', and every other funeral he'd had the sorrow of attending in his long life, he hadn’t thought any of them looked asleep. They were too still and too pale, their chests didn’t rise and fall with their breath, and their eyes didn’t flutter with their dreams. No, their bodies were nothing more than empty shells, once so full of love and life.

Death had stolen that from them, and it was something that could never be returned again.

At least, that was what he always believed.

Now, standing there and listening to the happy chatter of the dwarves in his dining room, Bilbo wasn’t quite sure what to believe anymore.

He stayed in that spot for several minutes, trying and only somewhat succeeding to bring his nerves back under control. It wasn’t until he heard the sound of multiple people entering his yard that he opened his eyes and straightened up once again. After a moment of hesitation, he moved to answer the door before everyone could begin crowding around—he wanted to avoid another pile up of dwarves in his doorway, if he could.

Bilbo was expecting to see many familiar faces before him. He was prepared to find eight more dwarves and Gandalf. What he did see, however, was certainly not what he had expected.

They were all there, coming up the path through the yard, with Gandalf at the back of them all, just barely closing the gate. At the front of the group, standing there with his fist poised to knock, was none other than Thorin Oakenshield himself.

Despite all the fretting Bilbo had done over the past two days about not mucking up first impressions, his mind immediately went blank and he could do nothing but gape dumbly up at the dwarf before him.

The dwarf who Bilbo had chased after on an adventure eight decades ago.

Who had, in the short span of a year, become one of his dearest friends.

Who was supposed to be dead.

And who was supposed to be late, for Yavanna’s sake.

Evidently, he was neither of those things—dead or late—because there he stood, just as majestic and blue-eyed as Bilbo remembered him being. Also, just as inconsiderate as ever.

He wasn’t supposed to be there! At least, not yet!

Bilbo had thought he’d have close to another hour to prepare for facing him again. He wasn’t ready. Granted, he wasn’t sure he could ever be completely ready for something like this, but still—

“You are Master Baggins, I presume?”

Jolted out of his inner monologue of panic, Bilbo gasped like a fish out of water and nodded so quickly it made him dizzy. Clutching onto the door to keep himself standing, he attempted to speak, but what came out was a spill of words that were nearly unintelligible. “Yes! At your service, Bilbo Baggins, and all that.” It ended in a bit of a squeak and he winced.

So much for a good first impression.

In the yard, the dwarves failed to stifle their amused snickering, but Thorin just stared at him silently for a moment, an unreadable expression on his face. He was probably already beginning to question the wisdom in Gandalf’s choice in burglar, and maybe contemplating whether he should just turn around again and go back the way he had come—find someone more suitable for their quest. Surprisingly, he didn’t do that.

Instead, he asked, “may we come in?”

Bilbo didn’t have it in him to give a coherent answer, so he just pulled the door open wider and stepped back to grant them all entrance.

So it was that he spent the next handful of seconds desperately trying to compose himself as the large group of dwarves all filed into his home, each introducing themselves as they passed him by.

Gandalf came in last and he paused to give Bilbo a sympathetic pat on the shoulder before moving to hang his hat on the wall.

It was enough to bring Bilbo back to himself and he hurriedly closed the door before squeezing his way through the Company to lead them to the dining room. He paused when he reached the front of the group, though, finding himself once again face to face with his long dead friend. Or, face to chest as it were.

It surprised him, though it shouldn't have. Somehow, in all those long years separating them, he'd forgotten just how tall Thorin was.

He took a few quick steps back to put the space between the two of them, then stood still as the dwarf looked him up and down appraisingly.

Bilbo had to force himself not to fidget under that heavy gaze, and did his best to hold his head high. At the very least, he could be glad that he wasn’t wearing his dressing robe this time around. Instead, he wore a powder blue vest that he had found in the back of his closet and a darker blue tie around his neck.

Still, he couldn’t help but feel suddenly very self conscious. Not that there was anything he could do about it now.

Finally, Thorin met his eyes and looked at him yet again with a strange expression on his face before opening his mouth to speak.

Bracing himself for whatever harsh comment was about to come his way, Bilbo did his best to hold the dwarf’s stare.

“You look more like a grocer than a burglar.”

The words were not said in the disapproving tone that Bilbo expected, but rather came out softly, as though the one who spoke them had just had some great revelation. It took him by surprise for a moment, but he somehow managed to recover quickly.

This, at least, was a situation he was prepared for.

Not that he would ever admit it to anyone else, but Bilbo spent a great amount of time during the quest—and after it, for that matter—imagining how he could have responded to what was probably meant to be an insult. He had always been told that he had a silver tongue, but on that very first night of his adventure, with a troop of dwarves crowded into his smial, his words failed him. He wasn’t about to let that happen again, good impressions be damned.

“And you look more like a blacksmith than a king. I suppose that means you and I have something in common.” Bilbo looked Thorin up and down once, just as the dwarf had done to him moments before, then addressed the rest of the Company. “If you’ll just follow me, I’ll show you all to supper.”

Stepping around the stunned dwarf, Bilbo headed for the dining room and did his best to ignore his pounding heart.

Notes:

Thank you so much for all the wonderful comments and feedback you've given me so far! I treasure every word of it <3

Up until this point, every chapter was already written and only needed minimal editing before I could post it. Now, though, I've reached the part where everything is incomplete and disorganized and will need a lot more rewriting. So it's going to take a bit longer for chapters to be posted. I anticipate Chapter 5 will be finished by Wednesday, so please be patient!

Chapter 5: Unexpected Changes

Summary:

Before the quest has even begun, things are already changing and Thorin suspects Gandalf has something to do with it.

Notes:

Ok, so I lied. I finished the chapter earlier than I thought I would. You're welcome, I guess... ;)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Stunned, Thorin stood rooted to the spot as Bilbo stepped past him and headed for the dining room. He was speechless, and not just because the hobbit had responded to his grocer comment without so much as a stutter.

He had forgotten what Bilbo looked like at the beginning of the quest, before falling victim to bad weather and orcs and all the hardships that came with being on the road. Had forgotten what the hobbit looked like beneath all the dirt and dried blood, when exhaustion had not yet hung dark bags under his eyes.

Now there he was, golden-brown curls and all, not a trace of weariness to be seen. His patchwork robe and dismayed frown that he wore the last time Thorin showed up on his doorstep were nowhere to be seen, replaced with a blue waistcoat and rosy cheeks, and there was a sense of ease that Thorin couldn’t remember seeing in ages. Not since their time at Beorn’s, at least.

And that wasn’t even the most jarring part of his change in the hobbit's appearance.

No, what shocked him the most was the fact that Bilbo’s clothing no longer hung loosely on his frame, but instead hugged his curves—especially around the middle—and his face was rounder than he remembered. Less gaunt looking.

How had he never noticed just how much weight Bilbo lost from beginning to end of their quest? The change was so obvious now, it was painful. The fact that he could have ever allowed one of his Company to deteriorate so drastically was a disgrace. Was he really so blind?

More than that, how had he ever thought to bring such a soft creature along on their quest in the first place? Dwalin was right all those months ago when he said that gentle-folk had no place in the wild, yet Thorin had still agreed to let the hobbit join them without any argument at all. He had even gone so far as to refuse any responsibility should their burglar fall. He had expected him to fall, but did nothing to prevent Bilbo from leaving the comfort of his home.

He knew from experience that Bilbo was far more capable than he looked, but seeing him as he was now felt like a punch to the gut. How could he take someone as innocent as this out into the world in good conscience again? Was he really so selfish as to—

“Uncle!”

The sound of Fili’s voice broke him from his thoughts and he whirled around, suddenly feeling like his heart was in his throat. Both of his sister-sons were there, sending him familiar, large grins.

His boys.

He had helped raised them as though they were his own sons. Had watched them grow into two strong dwarves. And sent them both to their deaths when he was too much of a fool to recognize the trap on Ravenhill for what it was.

Of the many mistakes he had made throughout the quest—throughout his life—that was the one that he regretted most of all. It was something he would never forgive himself for, and he would keep the memory of it with him until the day he drew his final breath and beyond, however long that may be.

Still, despite his regrets, there they stood with no injury to be seen and the glimmer of mischief in their eyes that had disappeared sometime during their long trek through Mirkwood. He hadn’t realized how much he missed the sight of it, until now.

Kili spoke then, as cheerful as ever. “I’m surprised you got here so early. We were sure you’d get lost somewhere, and we’d have to come and find—”

Cutting him off before he could finish the comment, Thorin stepped forward and tugged them both into a tight embrace. With Kili pulled against his side and Fili’s head tucked beneath his chin, he closed his eyes and took a deep breath, fighting off the wave of emotion that threatened to drown him.

Watching Azog hold his golden-haired heir high and stab him through the back before dropping him to the foot of the tower far below had been the worst moment of Thorin’s life—worse than the day Smaug took Erebor. Worse than Azanulbizar. And later, as he lay bleeding out on the ice, he felt it in his heart when Kili fell. Thorin didn't need to see the body to know that he, too, had perished.

With both of them gone, it had been all the easier to stop fighting his approaching death and allow the darkness to take him. For he had no desire to live in a world without them in it. Of all the stars in his life, those two had always shone the brightest.

Now, to hold them both in his arms once again was a gift beyond value, and he silently thanked Mahal for giving it to him. Though he knew he didn’t deserve it.

“You do not know how glad I am to see you,” Thorin said, the words no louder than a breath.

He held onto them for another second or two longer, then finally released them and took a small step back. Their wide-eyed shock was enough to send another twinge of guilt through him.

Thinking back, he tried to remember the last time he held them in such a way, but realized he couldn’t. Not once over their journey had he offered either of them more comfort than a squeeze to the shoulder, and before that…it could well have been years since he’d shown so much affection. He had been so busy taking care of his people and then the Company that he hadn’t even thought to do more for his sister-sons.

That was yet another thing he swore to fix.

Their shock didn’t last long, and soon enough their wide grins were once again on their faces.

“We missed you, too,” Kili said brightly.

Thorin’s eyes traveled away from his nephews then, trailing over the rest of the Company and coming to a stop on Balin and Dwalin. Both were looking at him questioningly, but he just shook his head, not wanting to even attempt explaining himself.

Balin stared at him for a moment, then seemed to let it go and shrugged. “Why don’t we go and eat before all of the food gets cold.”

The suggestion was met with agreement all around, and Thorin allowed Fili and Kili to usher him into the dining room—the rest of the Company following right behind them.

For all the complaining Bilbo had done during the first journey about dwarves pilfering his pantry, Thorin was more than surprised to find that there was already a feast’s worth of food prepared and laid out and waiting to be eaten. Not only that, but there was even enough seating for them all—fifteen mismatched chairs all placed neatly around the dining room table.

As they took their seats and began to dish their food, Thorin noticed the empty chair beside Gandalf and glanced around the room in time to spot Bilbo moving toward the kitchen.

Before he so much as thought about it, Thorin called out to him. “Will you not dine with us, Master Baggins? It would be a shame for you to prepare all of this food just to end up not eating any of it.”

Pausing, Bilbo turned slightly to look back at him and blinked a couple of times. Then he seemed to shake off whatever thought made him look so quizzical and dipped his head in a slight nod. “Thank you, but I’ve been snacking all day, and had quite enough of it. If you all somehow manage to eat the entire table before I return, I won’t be too disappointed.”

With that, the hobbit disappeared into the kitchen.

Thorin ignored the urge to go after him and turned his attention back to the table, surveying the spread before him once again.

It was as though their host had been forewarned of the Company’s arrival, down to how many would be coming, and with enough time for him to properly prepare for his guests. Though, Thorin had no idea how that was possible.

He had started this journey again with the intent of changing things for the better, but he hadn’t expected their night at Bag End to be much different than what it was before. He couldn’t have warned Bilbo if he had wanted to. Yet, somehow, the hobbit was more than prepared.

Actually, Bilbo didn’t act at all dismayed to find his home being overrun by a troop of thirteen dwarves. If anything, he seemed almost happy—albeit somewhat nerve-wracked and restless.

Thorin could think of no possible way for Bilbo to have known that they were coming, unless…

Between spoonfuls of the hearty stew that he filled his bowl with, Thorin looked at Gandalf suspiciously.

On the last journey, Gandalf hadn’t so much as told Bilbo a single thing about the quest before he sent for all the dwarves to gather at their unwilling host’s home. This time, Bilbo somehow knew in advance they were coming, and hadn’t balked at the size of their group. He knew Thorin was a king without anyone making an introduction.

And how else would Bilbo know, unless Gandalf had already told him?

But why would he give Bilbo more warning this time? He had to have known the hobbit would raise less of a fuss if he had more information. And if he knew that, what else might the old wizard know?

While the rest of his Company ate and talked, Thorin stayed mostly silent and kept to his own racing thoughts—though that didn’t stop him from noticing Bilbo slip back into the room and take his seat beside Gandalf about halfway through the meal.

Eventually—when it got to the point that everybody had eaten their fill—plates and food started flying through the air, and the Company burst into song about blunting knives and bending forks, and Thorin almost jumped up from his seat, ready to put a stop to it all.

Though he hadn’t been present for that particular part of the meal during the first quest, he remembered how Bilbo griped about the scene for days afterward, bemoaning the treatment that his mother’s beloved pottery and silverware had received. Thorin knew the Company wouldn’t break a single dish, but he also knew just how important all of these things were to their burglar, and he had every intention of starting their friendship with Bilbo out on the right foot. It was for that reason that he nearly called a halt to all of the merrymaking.

Nearly.

But just as he was about to shout, he spotted Bilbo.

To his surprise, the hobbit wasn’t running about trying to protect his precious tableware. Actually, he wasn’t doing anything. He simply stood there, watching it all go down with a sense of calm. More than that, he seemed to be content—almost amused, even.

So after a moment, Thorin sank back down into his seat and let the Company have their fun. With everything they would soon be facing on the road to Erebor, Mahal knows they deserved to enjoy themselves a bit.

Especially seeing as Thorin would soon have to rain on their good cheer with his news that they would have no army at their back when they took down the dragon.

Yes, he could let them enjoy their time here for a little while longer.

 

***

 

Telling the Company about Dain’s refusal to aid them went just as Thorin had known it would. The news put a damper on everyone’s spirits and, looking around at them all, he could see the dismay and discouragement on all of their faces—they looked exactly as they had the first time he told them. The solemn expressions on the faces of both his sister-sons was too much for him to bear, and he immediately called their attention again.

“It does not matter if we are fourteen or fourteen hundred, I would take every single one of you over an army from the Iron Hills any day.” He cast his gaze around the table, looking each of them in the eye as he spoke. “Loyalty, honor, and willing hearts—that is all we need to see this task done. We have everything we need right here in this room.”

For a short moment, they were silent. Then the dwarves all let out a cheer. After that, they were all much more optimistic in their planning—a fact that Thorin was grateful for. Gandalf produced the map and key from somewhere inside his robes, a couple of small arguments broke out before being quickly halted again, and they made the decision to enter the mountain via the secret door.

All in all, it went well.

Still, Thorin had the sense that something was off, but it wasn't until the Company began to migrate into the parlor that he realized what it was.

With all the talk of quests and dragons, Bilbo took it all much better than Thorin remembered. He accepted the contract from Balin without argument, and wasn't nearly as alarmed as he should have been when he reached the section on funeral arrangements. He seemed quietly resigned to the idea of being burned to death by dragon fire, and didn't so much as sway on his feet when Bofur started teasing about furnaces with wings. When he finished reading, he refolded the parchment and tucked it into his jacket, then followed them all into the parlor.

He only stayed for a few minutes—just long enough to explain everyone’s sleeping arrangements for the night—and then he slipped away, saying that he needed a quiet place to think.

Thorin watched him go, then glanced at Gandalf once Bilbo was out of sight.

Just how much had the wizard told him? The hobbit hadn’t once protested at being called a burglar and hadn’t balked at mention of all the danger they could face on the road. Gandalf must have told him something, and that something must have been a much more detailed explanation than he gave the last time around.

When the old man noticed him watching, Thorin pursed his lips tightly and looked away, turning his gaze to the low fire burning in the hearth.

He would have to keep a close eye on the wizard. Something told him that Gandalf knew more than he was letting on.

Notes:

Fear not, Bilbo and Thorin will have a lot more interaction with each other in the next chapter!

Chapter 6: Going on an Adventure...Again

Summary:

Bilbo finds himself setting out on a journey to the Lonely Mountain for the second time in his life.

Notes:

Again, thank you all so much for your feedback! I really appreciate it <3

(5/11/25)
Edit: Fixed a timeline error

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

With supper finally finished, all talk of dragons diminished, and sleeping arrangements decided on, Bilbo finally had the chance to take a free moment to himself. Leaving the parlor, he quietly opened the front door and stepped outside into the cool night air, then headed to the bench and sat down. Staring blankly into the darkness beyond the garden, he did his best to keep his breath even and wind down.

Unsurprisingly, the evening had thrown him into an inner turmoil that proved to be exhausting to control. He'd constantly been on the verge of either crying or laughing, but he was never quite sure which. Either way, he didn’t want to draw any questions by suddenly having an emotional breakdown in front of the whole Company. After so long of not seeing any of his old friends, having them all there was nearly overwhelming. Not to mention the fact that several of them were supposed to be dead.

Out of everything, the hardest part so far had been pretending that he didn’t know any of them. He didn’t think they’d take kindly to the fact that he could repeat some of Bombur’s secret recipes by heart, or that he remembered stories of Gloin’s son and wife, or that he knew of young Ori’s talents when it came to drawing and writing.

He knew things about every member of the Company that no stranger could possibly know.

Like how Fili and Kili always ended up wrapped around each other as they slept, and how Dwalin hated anything looking even remotely like a mushroom getting anywhere near his food. And Thorin, well...

Bilbo knew things about their king that not even his best friend knew.

They were things that he himself wouldn’t even know if it weren’t for the weeks spent trapped in Thranduil’s dungeons, and the confessions they made there in the dark.

And Bilbo had to act as if none of it ever happened because if the Company found out just how much he knew they would surely leave him behind. For gaining a dwarf’s trust was a difficult process and revealing that you knew some of their deepest secrets and fears was not the best way to go about it. Even if they had been one of your dearest friends in another life.

The thoughts were doing nothing to calm him and Bilbo felt his eyes start to sting.

Sniffling, he buried his face in his hands and drew a shaky breath. How ridiculous, he thought, for someone as old as him to cry about things that happened so long ago. He’d gone through so much in his life from spending the first fifty years of it mostly alone, to going on an adventure, finding friends, and then losing those friends, just to end up alone once more—and it hardly seemed fair that he had to go through it all over again. Not to mention all of that business with that damned Ring. He never wanted to see that thing again after everything poor Frodo was put through because of it.

But he would do it, if he meant having even just a little bit more time with his friends.

With Thorin.

The dwarf was being unusually...pleasant, Bilbo thought. So far, there was no sign of the cold, unwelcoming behavior that he had been subject to the last time. There was no scorn in his eyes when Thorin looked at him, no questions about his ability to act as the Company’s burglar, and no demeaning comments—aside from the one about looking like a grocer, but even that had been more of an observation than an insult. He hadn’t said much to Bilbo, but what he did say was nothing but respectful.

It was surprising, to say the least.

Bilbo was prepared for the blatant insults and less than grateful behavior. What he wasn't prepared for was Thorin Oakenshield being polite.

He had no idea what to make of any of it. He knew his mind had become fuzzy and confused in his old age, but surely his memories weren't that unreliable. Which meant that something, somehow, had changed. The only explanation he could come up with was his own behavior. He hadn’t complained, cried, whined, or fainted at all that night, and it seemed that just that small change had made all the difference.

Who could have known that the only thing he needed to do to gain their leader’s respect was to not swoon at the slightest mention of dragons?

Bilbo didn’t know how long he sat there like that, but it didn’t seem like a lot of time passed before someone nearby cleared their throat and broke him from his thoughts. He jolted, sitting up straighter and turning to find Thorin himself standing there—as though just thinking about him could summon the dwarf.

Bilbo sucked in a sharp breath and stared up at him with wide eyes. He had spent the evening avoiding looking at Thorin, afraid that it would ruin his careful control of his emotions. One wrong word, one stray glance, and he would break down.

And after all that effort, there he was. There was no way that Bilbo could avoid him now. Not when it was just the two of them.

“Master Oakenshield,” Bilbo managed to say, bracing himself against his fraying nerves and putting on what he hoped was a welcoming smile. “Can I help you? If there’s something you need, I can—” As he spoke, he began to stand from his seat, but the dwarf raised a hand to stop him.

Thorin watched him, an unreadable look on his face. In the dark, the blue of his eyes looked nearly black. One side of his face was lit up by the light emanating from the window, and the other half was hidden in shadow.

“Something troubles you,” he said eventually.

After a short moment of hesitation, Bilbo sighed and sank back down onto the bench, rubbing his face wearily. He didn’t look at Thorin when he spoke.

“Yes, well, you’ve just asked me to join you on a dangerous quest that I may not come back from. I can't be blamed if I'm a bit apprehensive.”

“You do not have to come.”

The words were said so softly that Bilbo nearly didn’t hear them. But hear them he did, and he shot Thorin a surprised look, just to find that the dwarf had his gaze directed fixedly at the sky above them.

“You can stay here where it is safe. I would not force someone to come with us. Especially someone with so much to lose.”

Bilbo let out a startled laugh, but it was only half amused. It was interesting that Thorin would say such a thing, seeing as all that the hobbit cared about losing would be leaving in the morning to retake Erebor. He couldn’t care less about leaving Bag End and the Shire. This place would always be his home, of course, but he’d left it behind him over twenty years ago and he’d long since made his peace with that decision.

As long as Lobelia didn't get her sticky paws on the place, he was content to leave his cozy smial once again, and he'd already taken the necessary steps to ensure she never would.

“I appreciate your concern, but I am coming with you.”

“Why?”

Bilbo thought back on all those days spent lying in his bed in Valinor, staring out the window and wishing for something more. Truthfully, old age wasn't enjoyable for him. The Undying Lands were truly beautiful, but that mattered little when he hadn't the strength to explore them. And what use were the extensive libraries to him when his clouded vision made it impossible to read words on a page? What did it matter that the food was exquisite when his hands were too unsteady to feed himself? What enjoyment could he find from the song-halls when his ears were all but deaf?

To put it simply, he'd been bored, and yearning for a life that was far behind him.

It was several moments later when he finally found the words to answer Thorin's question. “I have spent quite some time waiting for an adventure.”

 

***

 

They stayed there in silence for a while, both staring up at the stars. Then Thorin eventually excused himself and went back inside Bag End, leaving Bilbo to his thoughts.

It wasn’t long after that quiet singing drifted out the cracked open window of the parlor, and it grew louder and louder until Bilbo could make out the words.

The song was one he had heard only once before, long ago on a night much like this one. It was a deep, eerie tune created by the voices of the Company mixing together. Among the words of burning trees and forgotten gold, he could easily pick out the sound of Thorin’s voice.

There had been many occasions after the quest was over that Bilbo tried to write down the words, but had found that no matter how hard he tried to remember, he could never get the lyrics quite right.

Listening to the song again now, the words carried a sense of rightness with them that Bilbo hadn’t felt in a long time. And when the tears that he had suppressed all evening began to form rivers down his cheeks, he did nothing to stop them.

He stayed outside on the bench until he could no longer hear the timbre of the song drifting into the night and the voices faded away. Then he slowly stood up and went back inside, peeking into the parlor quickly as he passed by.

The room was empty except for the three that would be spending the night there. Bofur was humming quietly to himself and turning his hat in his hands, Bifur sat near the fireplace staring silently into the slowly dying embers, and Bombur was sprawled out in the middle of the floor, already asleep and snoring.

Bilbo walked through the smial once to make sure that none of the Company needed anything—stopping briefly near the guest room to listen to Fili and Kili’s quiet laughter—then shut himself in the spare room where he took off his vest and climbed into bed.

Despite how tired he was, sleep didn’t find him until much later, and he spent what felt like hours staring up at the ceiling above him, the echoes of a song replaying over and over in his head.

 

***

 

Bilbo sneezed for what felt like the hundredth time that day and had to stifle his irritated groan. Quiet snickering from up ahead drifted back to him, and he glared at the two young princes who rode near the middle of the group, imagining that he could burn holes straight through the back of their coats with just his eyes. Of course, he couldn’t actually do that, so when he sneezed yet again, it was met with Fili and Kili bursting into a fit of laughter that was so loud it momentarily startled some of the ponies.

Grumbling to himself about nettlesome dwarves and horsehair, Bilbo had to hold onto the pommel of his saddle to stop himself from rubbing at his nose.

It just didn’t make any sense. He’d had two whole days to prepare for this journey, and he’d used the time to plan all that he needed to bring with him and packed accordingly. He’d brought a warm travel cloak, a thicker jacket, a spare shirt, and had even managed to leave all of his nice waistcoats behind. He had extra provisions—which included a bag of dried jerky, two water flasks, and several seed cakes that had evaded being eaten by dwarves three nights ago at Bag End. Still, despite all the extra preparations he had done in order to be ready for this adventure, he’d somehow forgotten to bring a single handkerchief.

Again.

For the first few days, he'd been too caught up in everything to even notice it was missing. He supposed the rains had been helping to keep the air clean of dust and hair and whatever else might be triggering his allergies. But the storm had finally cleared during the night, and ever since he woke up that morning, Bilbo's eyes watered relentlessly and he had a constant sniffle.

By the time they finally stopped to make camp for the night, he was almost certain some of the dwarves were keeping a tally of how many times he sneezed. Furthermore, he thought they were actually betting on it, though he had been more focused on staying in his saddle than he was on the Company’s mischief so he couldn’t be sure.

As far away as he could get from the ponies without leaving camp entirely, Bilbo sat on a log and snuffled, leaving the dwarves to gather wood for the fire, start supper, and refill their water supply from a nearby stream.

He was in no mood to help them with any of it. Not after a whole day of being mocked for—

Another sneeze exploded from him without warning, nearly sending him toppling backwards off of the log. Cursing, he threw out his arms to keep his balance, and did his best to ignore the laughter that came from the other side of the camp and the surrounding woods.

If this kept up he was going to strangle somebody with their own beard.

It was with that thought that a large hand fell to his shoulder and he tensed, getting ready for yet another teasing remark. But when he turned to kindly tell whoever was about to bother him to sod off, he stopped himself.

Thorin hadn’t approached him again since that night outside of Bag End, and Bilbo had yet to decide if he was grateful for it or disappointed. With Thorin usually travelling at the front of the group, and he himself normally closer to the back, he supposed that there wasn’t much chance for them to talk anyways. Though, for all that they hadn’t spoken to each other, there was no lack of staring between them since setting out on their journey.

While they rode, Bilbo always found his gaze being drawn to the front of the line, and he would sometimes just stare for hours at a time. His only excuse was that he still was getting used to the fact that the dwarf was alive and well—he ignored the voice in the back of his head telling him that he didn’t stare at Fili or Kili near as much, or Balin, Oin, or Ori either, for that matter.

So, Bilbo had his reasons for staring, but no matter how much he thought about it, he couldn’t fathom what reason Thorin could have to stare at him. It seemed that whenever they were stopped for a break or to make camp, he turned and there would be Thorin. He always looked away whenever their gazes met.

Maybe he stared because he was watching their burglar to judge if it was worth it to bring some gentle-hobbit along on the journey.

Whatever the reason was, Thorin was there now, standing over him and watching him with the same unreadable look in his eyes.

As soon as Bilbo met his gaze, Thorin quickly let his hand drop from his shoulder and took half a step away from him.

“Er...hello?” Bilbo managed to get out after a moment or two of struggling to find his voice.

Thorin merely grunted in response and thrust his hand forward, dangling something in front of the hobbit’s face. “I found this. I assume it is yours.”

Bilbo’s eyes nearly went cross-eyed as he looked at the item, then a quiet gasp escaped him and he took it quickly. “Oh! Thank you! But how did…” He stopped, realizing that the dwarf was already gone, across the camp starting a conversation with Dwalin.

Blinking, he looked back down to the cloth in his hands. It was one of his handkerchiefs—a white one with his initials embroidered in the corner with blue thread. How Thorin had managed it, he had no idea, but he was grateful all the same. He smiled slightly and wiped his nose before tucking the cloth into his pocket.

When he looked up again, it was to catch Fili and Kili both grinning at him smugly and an amused twinkle in Bofur’s eyes.

As he had done throughout the entire day thus far, Bilbo decided to ignore them.

 

***

 

Nearly a month into their journey and the Company finally reached the Trollshaws. The closer they came to the place they made camp the first time he’d gone through this, the more anxious Bilbo became. If he didn’t think of something soon, they’d be facing three mountain trolls before they knew what hit them. Of course, avoiding the trolls would get rid of one problem and only bring up another.

Unless they faced the foul creatures, there would be no way for them to get to the troll hoard and and retrieve the three elvish blades that had gone to Thorin, Gandalf, and himself.

They had weapons now, of course—even Bilbo had a dagger that once belonged to his mother strapped to his belt—and though they could make do with what they had, he had no desire to do so. The elvish blades had proven to be a valuable resource, sharper than anything they currently had and able to glow blue whenever there were orcs nearby. Plus—though he hadn’t used it in Eru only knew how long—Bilbo was beginning to find that he itched to have Sting in his hands once again.

A letter opener it may be but it served both him and Frodo well on their adventures and he would feel safer with it back at his side.

With all his worrying keeping him distracted, it didn’t take long for them to reach the meadow where they were meant to make camp.

Then something odd happened.

Thorin lead the Company on a path that gave a wide berth around the charred remains of the farmhouse that rested near to the tree line, and they continued to move on without any sign of stopping.

And Bilbo started to panic.

He hadn’t even thought about what would happen if they just passed by the trolls entirely, but the idea of leaving his sword behind made him feel ill.

He had to find some way to stop the Company, and fast, before they got too far away from where he needed them to be.

Notes:

I'm starting college next monday, meaning that these next three days are going to be taken up by my freshmen orientation. I'll do what I can to post the next chapter as soon as possible, but I can't make any promises because my life is about to get a bit crazy.

Chapter 7: An Evening of Misfortune

Summary:

Thorin finds that making changes to a timeline might be more difficult than he originally anticipated, and maybe there are some things that just can't be avoided.

Notes:

I'd like to apologize in advance for my horrible writing skills when it comes to writing any kind of battle. I swear I did my best.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The first few weeks of the journey passed by rather uneventfully, their only adversary thus far coming in the form of an occasional rainstorm that left them soaked and cold, but otherwise unharmed. Yet despite the ongoing peace that accompanied them all the way from the Shire, Thorin worried more and more the closer they came to the Trollshaws. By the time they were following the road into the shadow of the woods, he was so tense he felt as though he was one of those wind up toys that Bifur was so fond of making.

If he didn’t make a decision quick, the peace might come to an end much sooner than he would like it to.

His main concern at the moment were the three trolls of which they grew closer to with every moment that they traveled.

He could still remember the coarse fabric of the sack that he had been shoved into all those months ago, and remembered his fear that their quest was going to end then and there before it had even really begun. More than that, he remembered watching half of his Company as they were turned round and round on a spit over a giant fire and thinking that he was the one to lead them to such a terrible fate.

He had no desire to confront the trolls again. And they wouldn’t. Not if he could help it.

They would soon reach the place they had camped last time—the meadow with the burned farmhouse—and Thorin had every intention of leading the Company straight through the meadow and onwards. He wanted to put several miles between them and the trolls before night fell.

Still, he felt sharp tug of regret at the idea of leaving Orcrist behind.

The blade was the best he had ever wielded in his lifetime—even if it was forged by elves—and Thorin had grown rather fond of it. It was as though the sword was made specifically made for him. Sharp and perfectly balanced. After losing it in Mirkwood, he felt as though he had lost an arm, he was so attached to it.

That regret alone was almost enough to make him camp in the same place as last time, if only so he could go find the troll hoard and reclaim his sword.

If he was traveling on his own, he may have done just that, stinking trolls be damned.

But he wasn’t on his own, and it wasn’t just his safety that he had to worry about.

He would not put his Company in such danger unless it was absolutely necessary, and as it was, a single sword was not worth the risk—much as he wished it was.

No, they had to press on.

A glance back at his sister-sons was enough to solidify his resolve on that. His love for them was stronger than his love for any blade.

He had lived this long without Orcrist by his side, and he was willing to go without it again if it meant the Company remained safe for at least a while longer. The last time they faced the trolls, they barely escaped with their lives, and that was only thanks to Bilbo and Gandalf’s quick thinking. He didn’t want to try their luck again.

Yet, as in so many other things, the world seemed to be against him in this.

They barely made it past the farmhouse, and Thorin's eyes were glued to the road ahead where it disappeared back into the trees, when a shout came from somewhere behind him. He turned quickly to see what all the commotion was, one hand already reaching for his sword, then paused when he spotted no sign of any danger.

It took him a couple moments to realize what everybody was looking at, and when he did, Thorin swung himself out of the saddle and was heading towards the tail end of the Company.

He was the first one to reach Bilbo’s side, despite having been the farthest person away.

The hobbit was on the ground in the middle of the road, and his pony was off standing in the grass several feet away, stamping its hooves and looking restless.

“What happened?” Thorin asked quickly, crouching down and looking the hobbit head to toe with concern. “Are you hurt?”

“Poor Myrtle spooked and I fell. Not to worry, I think I just had the breath knocked out of me.” Bilbo wheezed and pushed himself into a sitting position, only to wince at the movement.

He hardly finished speaking before Thorin shouted for Oin, then turned back to Bilbo. “Stay there until we are sure that you are not injured.”

The hobbit pursed his lips at the command, but offered up no argument, and did as he was told. Thorin glanced up for a moment to see that Gandalf had come down from his own horse and was standing over them, leaning on his staff and looking down at Bilbo with a strange look in his eyes. Before he could even think to ask what the wizard was thinking, Oin showed up and Thorin turned his attention to the healer instead.

 

***

 

Half an hour later, Thorin stood on the edge of their camp, glowering at the trees on the opposite side of the meadow as though the forest were somehow to blame for their most recent misfortune. Behind him, he could hear the rest of the Company unloading the ponies and building up a pit so they could start a fire for Bombur to cook their supper on.

Every sharp echo of laughter or clang of pots hitting against each other made Thorin wince and curse the noise they were making, though he knew the trolls would not emerge from their cave for the night until darkness fell, and they would at least be safe until then. After that, though…

Thorin had a feeling he wasn’t going to get even a minute of sleep until they were far from this place. How could he, when he was worried that every sound they made would call three hungry trolls upon them all?

He wanted nothing more than to keep traveling further up the road until the sun set behind them, but that was no longer an option.

After giving their hobbit a once over, Oin decided that Bilbo should get some rest before they moved on, and Thorin couldn’t argue the matter lest people start asking questions. Explaining to them that he wanted to put as much distance as possible between them and the trolls living in the woods would only raise more issues—such as how he knew there were trolls nearby in the first place, and why he hadn't mentioned them earlier.

No, all he could do was set up camp in the farthest corner of the meadow and pray that they would make it through the night without incident.

Gandalf disappeared soon after they stopped, and Thorin let himself be bothered by it for only a few moments before pushing it from his mind. The wizard and his coming and goings were none of his concern. All he needed to do was make sure that the Company kept close.

So that was exactly what he did.

Rather than have his sister-sons do it, Thorin assigned Nori to watch over the ponies, with Bofur quickly volunteering to help him. As for Fili and Kili, he made them help Bombur with supper.

The two weren’t very happy with the arrangement, but Thorin ignored their complaints. If it kept them in camp where he could keep an eye on them, he could withstand their grumbling. As long as he could see them, they had no chance to go off and get into trouble. And avoiding trouble was his top priority at the moment.

Hopefully, it would be enough.

 

***

 

Just as it was beginning to get dark, Kili brought him a bowl of stew and sat down on the ground beside the rock that Thorin claimed the moment they made camp, his brother not far behind him.

Thorin wasn't even finished with three bites of his supper before he felt both of his sister-son’s grins fixed on him. He did his best to ignore it for as long as possible, but he eventually relented and looked at the two of them warily.

“Is there something the two of you need, or is your staring purely intended to make me uncomfortable?”

Fili’s grin grew and he gave a small shrug that was probably meant to come across as casual but was anything but.

“It’s nothing, really. We just noticed how quick you were to rush to Bilbo’s side when he fell from his pony,” Fili said, nodding in the direction of the hobbit in question.

Thorin avoided the urge to look over at Bilbo where he sat near the fire and fought to keep his face neutral. “I was concerned that Master Baggins might be hurt. If I was fast to reach him, I can hardly be blamed. Nobody has yet come to injury on this quest, and if it is at all in my power, I intend to keep it that way.”

That was the truth, really, if not all of it. And it wasn’t as though his nosy sister-sons needed the whole truth anyways. He wasn’t about to tell them that their Company’s burglar was his One—not because he didn’t want anybody to know, but because he didn’t want to subject Bilbo to the consequences of that admission. Thorin could handle Fili and Kili’s persistent teasing, but the hobbit was still warming up to them all, and he didn’t want to do anything to hinder that process.

At the very least, Bilbo seemed to be much more comfortable with the Company now than he had been before, which Thorin was grateful for.

Still, he tried to keep his distance from the hobbit for the most part—the main reason behind it being that he was worried if he did get close to him, Thorin would immediately fall to his knees and beg for forgiveness for something that he technically hadn’t even done yet. And something that he would never do again.

Bilbo wouldn’t understand any of that, though, so Thorin stayed away, as much as it pained him to do so.

Of course, whatever he told them, neither Fili nor Kili would be completely convinced of his answer, so the two just snickered and went back to their stew.

Exasperated, Thorin turned his eyes up to the darkening sky, but he smiled, unable to be upset by their mischief. After what happened on Ravenhill, he wasn’t sure he could truly be angry with them ever again.

It was a sobering thought, and his smile dropped.

 

***

 

Late that night, after nearly everyone had gone to sleep, Thorin was still seated on his rock, staring diligently at the tree line. He didn’t so much as twitch when Dwalin came to stand beside him, and a few moments passed by before either of them spoke.

“You should get some sleep,” Dwalin said eventually, his voice a harsh contrast to the soft sounds of the night. “I’ll take up the watch.”

Thorin shook his head, letting his fingers tap restlessly against the hilt of his sheathed sword and wishing—not for the first time—that it was Orcrist at his side. “I will not rest until we have left this place far behind us.”

“Why?”

“I do not like it here.”

It was the only answer he could give. He had no way to explain why he didn’t like it without sounding mad, so he didn’t try.

Dwalin didn’t ask any more questions though, trusting his shield-brother’s judgement just as he always did, and sat down next him. “Then we’ll watch together.”

Glancing over at his best friend, it hit Thorin just how much he owed him. This ever loyal dwarf had been by his side for as long as he could remember, never leaving him to fight on his own and never wavering in his support of him. Even amidst the gold-sickness, Dwalin’s faith in him had remained, and Thorin had returned that faith with nothing but mistrust and threats.

Dwalin didn’t remember any of that, of course, but Thorin did and he would never let himself forget it.

The Maker hadn’t just granted him with another chance to save the line of Durin. Thorin had been given more than a dozen second chances—one with each member of his Company—to make things right after how he had treated them all.

With that in mind, Thorin turned to the dwarf beside him and opened his mouth to say...something. He wasn’t sure what he planned to say, and he never got the chance to find out because just as he was about to speak, a crack echoed into the night and movement in the woods across the meadow caught his eye.

In less than a second, Thorin was on his feet and drawing his sword.

“What is it?” Dwalin asked, one of his axes already in hand.

Thorin didn’t have to see the huge lumbering shape in the darkness of the woods to know what made trees all shake and groan as it moved through them, and he didn’t need to see the trees to know that there were two more of those shapes close behind the first.

He didn’t know what had alerted the trolls to their presence, but it didn’t matter now. All that mattered was that they were heading straight towards their camp, and they only had a matter of seconds before the creatures were upon them.

“Wake the Company! Get them on their feet and make sure they have their weapons in hand! Now!”

Dwalin asked for no explanation and just turned on his heel to carry out Thorin’s orders.

Thorin listened as the quiet behind him quickly became a bout of commotion, but he didn’t take his eyes from the trees, and he watched as three familiar figures appeared from the shadows and didn’t so much as pause before they came barreling across the meadow.

He didn’t have to look to know that the Company had fallen into line behind him within moments, but there was no time for him to be proud. Dwalin had barely returned to his side when the first troll reached them. There was no time to do anything but let out a battle cry that the rest of the dwarves echoed before he threw himself into the fight.

Thorin and Dwalin stuck together, guarding each other’s back and fighting in tandem, just as they had always done.

One caused a distraction and the other went in to slice at a troll’s shins and ankles, then they traded off, falling back and advancing, weaving and lunging, and spinning around each other as though performing some intricate, dangerous dance. A dance they’d been performing all their lives.

Too soon, though, things took a turn for the worse.

After dodging away from a huge hand seeking to grab him, Thorin glanced around, making sure that nobody needed help. He was glad to see that everyone seemed to be holding their own. But something was wrong.

He took a quick count of the Company, and his heart stopped.

He counted twelve dwarves, which was all well and good, but there was no sign of a hobbit anywhere in the fray.

Where was Bilbo? Had he gotten the chance to flee from the fighting?

Thorin hoped so.

He was so distracted that he didn’t hear Dwalin’s warning shout telling him to move.

One of the trolls backhanded him, sending him flying through the air and crashing to the ground just a foot shy of the fire.

With the breath knocked out of him, Thorin struggled to sit up, searching the ground around him for the sword he had lost after being hit, but didn’t find it.

Already, the troll was coming for him again, its great ugly face screwed up into an ugly snarl. It would be on him in moments.

Weaponless, Thorin scrabbled for anything to defend himself with, and his hand curled around the end of a broken branch that stuck out of the fire. He surged to his feet just as the troll reached him, swinging the branch so its flaming end raked across the the monster’s face.

It let out a high pitched shriek, loud enough to make Thorin’s ears ring.

Still, he heard Fili well enough when he called out to him, and he dropped the branch in favor of catching the sword that his oldest heir tossed to him as he went hurtling by.

With sword in hand once again, Thorin turned on the troll that had since doubled over, clutching at its face and wailing deafeningly as it batted at the several dwarves swarming around it like stinging bugs.

Bifur, Bombur, Bofur, and Nori were all battering at its legs and torso, doing their best to trip it up and send it falling to the ground.

Thorin didn’t hesitate to join them, ducking the sweep of a giant arm and slicing his sword across the troll’s ribs.

It howled, but the sound was drowned out by the roar of one of the other trolls, which was quickly followed by a horrified scream that sounded like it came from Dori.

All at once, the fighting stopped and everyone froze.

Feeling sick, Thorin turned to see that the largest of the trolls was staring directly at him with fury in its hateful eyes, and trapped beneath its foot was Ori.

Beside him, Dwalin growled a particularly nasty curse and surged forward, but he stopped in his tracks as the troll pressed down harder, eliciting a pained yelp from the young dwarf under its heel.

“Lay down your arms, or I’ll squash this one into jelly,” the troll snarled.

The memory of the trolls threatening to tear Bilbo limb from limb flashed through Thorin’s mind, and with a glance at poor Ori whose eyes were wide and wild with fear, he relented.

Letting his blade fall to the ground at his feet, Thorin gave the troll a fierce glare of his own and hoped that, wherever he may be, a certain burglar would somehow manage to save them all once again.

Notes:

Thank you so much for being patient with me! Freshman orientation was exhausting, and I didn't have any free time at all over the past few days to get any writing done. With classes having started, I'll do my best to write as often as possible. I'm hoping to have at least one more chapter posted before this coming weekend, so keep an eye out for that.

Chapter 8: Bilbo Baggins, Guardian of the Trees

Summary:

Bilbo sneaks off to retrieve his sword, then finds himself racing to rescue his dwarves.

Notes:

So, please forgive me for the long wait. I had every intention of updating last week, or at the very latest, the beginning of this week. Then life hit me like a freight train. Needless to say, I will no longer be making predictions about my updates. Please accept this (somewhat) longer chapter as thanks for all of your patience and wonderful comments <3

(5/11/25)
Edit: I've gone through and fixed some of the grammar, as well as added a couple of paragraphs. No major changes were made to the story, there's just some extra details about Bilbo's current relationship with the dwarves

Chapter Text

Creeping through the shadowy depths of the Trollshaws, Bilbo began to wonder just how good of an idea this plan really was. He was tired, and hungry, and his shoulder still ached from falling off his pony earlier that evening. Granted, that had been a necessary sacrifice. If he hadn’t done something, the Company would have traveled straight on past the farmhouse and kept moving several miles beyond, and that would have been no good. There was no way he could have found his way to the troll hoard if they had continued on.

Still, he was starting to doubt his ability to find the hoard even with their camp being in the same spot.

He had snuck out of camp somewhere around an hour ago, managing to slip away without gaining the notice of Thorin, who was watching the woods like a hawk ever since they stopped for the night.

It wouldn’t be any good if Thorin caught him leaving because being caught would lead to a lot of questions that Bilbo didn't have an answer to. At least, no answer that wouldn’t make him sound completely mad.

No, nobody could know what he was going out to do that night.

When he returned to camp later, he would figure out some way to explain his absence, and how he had just happened to come across three elvish blades out in the woods. If he was lucky, maybe Gandalf would be back by then and he could help him form some sort of excuse.

Much to Bilbo’s dismay, the wizard left soon after they stopped to make camp, and no amount of begging could convince him to stay. When he tried to warn him of the danger they might meet there, Gandalf cut him off immediately.

“Don’t tell me anything! I fear that by knowing what will happen, I will somehow make things worse,” the wizard had said, refusing to hear another word of protest. Before he left, he patted Bilbo on the shoulder and gave him what was likely meant to be a reassuring smile. “If it makes you feel any better, I will keep an eye out for whatever danger it is that you fear.”

It didn’t make Bilbo feel better in the slightest.

Especially not now, when he was wandering through the woods, lost and alone.

Because he was indeed very lost.

At some point, he had gotten himself turned around, and now had no idea which way the troll hoard may be. Worse than that, he didn’t know which way to go to get back to camp. He could very well be stuck out there all night, never find his way back, and get left behind when the Company moved on in the morning.

The dwarves were pleasant enough to travel with—when they weren't busy mocking him for his bouts of hay-fever, that is—but he wasn't truly friends with any of them, yet.

Bombur welcomed his help cooking supper in the evenings and they could chat about spices and such easily enough, but they weren't quite at the point of trading recipes. Ori was fascinated by hobbit record keeping traditions in the Shire, and he'd sidle up to Bilbo to hear more about it sometimes when Dori's back was turned. Fili and Kili liked to pester him with ridiculous questions about hobbits when they got bored enough. (Mister Baggins, is it true hobbits can eat anything? Mister Baggins, are hobbit feet so big because they're like paddles to help you swim faster? Mister Baggins, do hobbits live in burrows because you're descended from rabbits? Mister Baggins—) Yesterday, he'd made the unfortunate mistake of giving a rather inappropriate response to that last question relating to rabbits and how quickly they reproduce. He regretted it immediately, but at least it had the benefit of drawing Bofur into the conversation, who was in stitches from laughing so hard.

The rest of the Company remained suspicious and distant. He was making progress and had high hopes they might warm up to him soon, but for now he was still an outsider. And he didn't doubt they would leave him behind.

The thought did nothing but make him feel panicked, and his pace quickened until he was nearly jogging, dodging around trees and hopping over roots as best he could. The longer he went on, though, the more he felt that he was just going in circles. Still, he didn’t stop moving. Not until his foot caught on uneven ground and he stumbled, falling to his knees on the forest floor.

He stayed there for a few moments, muttering some colorful curses under his breath and bemoaning his scuffed toes, but his complaints were cut short when he heard a strange sound.

At first, he thought it had to have been a breeze rustling in the treetops—or, that was his hope—but then he heard it again, and the sound was unmistakable.

Somebody, or something, was singing.

“Bilbo, you are a damn fool,” he whispered to himself, and his fear of being abandoned by the Company was replaced by a fear of something different.

He ventured into the woods earlier under the impression that as long as he avoided the trolls, he would be fine. He didn't consider there might be more dangers to find hiding in the dark shadows of the trees. What other monsters could be lurking about, just waiting for him to wander into their grasp?

How could he be so stupid?

During the day, this forest was unfamiliar to him at best—he had only traveled through a handful of times in his life, after all—and at night, it was ten times so.

The singing grew slightly louder, and as a chill began to creep down his spine, Bilbo remembered some of the stories of men—tales told with lowered voices on dark nights in quiet taverns. The ones of fairies that lured unknowing victims into their forest homes just to eat them.

Back in the Shire, people would scoff at the idea of fairies. They would say that there was no such thing, especially not in their peaceful corner of the world, and that would be the end of that.

But, well, Bilbo wasn’t in the Shire anymore, was he? Who was to say what was and wasn’t possible? He himself had gone back in time, for Yavanna’s sake! Was the existence of fairies, or any other nasty creature, really so unlikely?

Time travel aside, he had seen plenty of extraordinary and terrible things in his lifetime, so he had no place in ignoring such tales as purely fiction. Over the years, he had learned that most stories had at least some truth to them.

Yet even with the thoughts of fairies swirling about in his head, Bilbo found himself slowly relaxing. Because that melody—those words—he had heard them before. So long ago that he had practically forgotten them until now.

It sounded like home.

Like his mother washing dishes in the kitchen, swaying along to the music falling from her lips. Like his father’s voice drifting in through the open window from where he worked out in the garden.

The memory was so vivid and hit him so suddenly, he began stumbling off through the trees before he even consciously made the decision to do so.

He couldn’t bring himself to care that he was probably about to become the next meal of some malevolent creature.

The voice—soft and lilting—belonged to neither Belladonna nor Bungo, but it was familiar to him all the same. He had to know where it was coming from.

Besides, the singing was slowly but surely driving off his fear, and anything that comforting couldn’t be too terrible. Could it?

He was nearly desperate, hurtling through the woods with as much speed as he dared, and almost falling flat more than a few times. Still, no matter how quickly he went, the voice remained a steady distance ahead of him.

Just as he thought he would never catch up, the singer seemed to come to a standstill, and he propelled himself forward with a last burst of energy in a final attempt to reach them.

He flew out of the undergrowth and straight into the middle of a small clearing, and as soon as he skidded to a stop, the woods went silent. Nothing, not even a single cricket, made a sound.

There was only Bilbo, breathing heavily and whirling around in search of whoever’s voice he had been following, but there was no one. He was alone.

When the tears came, Bilbo did nothing to stop them from streaming down his cheeks and dripping onto his jacket front.

For a moment, he had been given a glimpse of his home. His true home. The one that had been full of his parents’ laughter and songs. The home that he hadn’t seen in over a century—and would never see again. And now that glimpse was gone, ripped away just as abruptly as the real thing was taken from him all those years ago.

He stood there for a long time, wallowing in his grief, and he would have stayed there for a great deal longer if he hadn’t realized that the clearing he was in the middle of looked rather familiar.

Wiping at his face and blinking away the bleariness in his eyes, Bilbo glanced around with confusion, then froze as his gaze landed on the gaping mouth of a cave.

He stared, and stared some more, hardly able to believe what he was seeing.

The voice—and whoever it belonged to—had lead him straight to his destination.

He was standing not more than a dozen feet away from the troll hoard.

Staring into the gaping mouth of the cave, Bilbo swallowed nervously.

Of course, when he first decided to head into the woods that night to retrieve their swords, he hadn’t taken into account just how dark it would be.

That was exactly the sort of thing he would forget.

Now here he was, ready to venture into a pitch black troll hoard with nothing to light his path. He almost thought about turning back, but shook his head immediately. He'd gotten this far, and there was no point in turning back now.

They needed those swords, and this was his only chance to get them. The Company would be moving on at dawn the next morning, and even if he did find a way to postpone their departure again, it wouldn’t matter because the trolls would be back in their cave come sun up anyways.

No, he had to get the swords now.

He’d just have to find them by feel rather than sight. How difficult could it be?

With that thought, he straightened up and—feigning confidence that he didn’t have—he strode into the dark.

The vile stench of troll hit him like a wall the moment he stepped inside and Bilbo stopped, unable to stop himself from gagging.

Digging around in his pocket for a moment, he found his handkerchief. If he held it over his face and breathed through his mouth it helped, but only just a bit.

He forced himself to take a couple of steps. Then a few more.

He could barely see his hand in front of him, let alone anything else in the cave, and Bilbo struggled to remember where the swords had been the first time around.

They’d been in some kind of barrel, he was pretty sure. Gandalf and Thorin had been looking at them. Now the only question was where that barrel was.

Unfortunately, his memory only went so far and he had no idea where to find it. Really, he only peeked in through the entrance the last time, not wanting to enter the reeking cave. His short look hadn’t truly been enough to memorize the layout of it all. For all he knew, the swords could be anywhere.

He would just have to search until he found them.

It was easier said than done.

The floor of the cave was uneven and Bilbo found himself stumbling every couple of steps he took. For the first few minutes he managed to stay on his feet, but then something was in front of him and he tripped over it, tumbling to the ground.

Whatever it was, it fell over and a tinkling sound of metal on metal rang in the silence.

Curiously, Bilbo reached out, searching until his hand eventually landed on something cool and round. The image of a small chest full of gold flashed into his mind and he remembered Bofur, Nori, and Gloin taking the time to bury it. A “long term deposit” they had called it.

On their way back to the Shire after everything was said and done, he and Gandalf stopped so Bilbo could dig up the chest and take it home with him.

Shaking his head, Bilbo shoved the coin into his pocket then slowly got to his feet again. Going more carefully this time, he continued walking, blindly holding his hands out in front of him so he wouldn’t run into anything.

The cave was dark enough that he could have been stuck in there for hours.

It reminded him of when he was a fauntling and he and his cousins would dare each other to venture into old Gerontius Took’s cellar. Down a small set of steps, the chilly-aired cellar was pitch black when the door closed. As one of the more adventurous children in the group, Bilbo inevitably found himself in there whenever he went to visit his grandparents. Once, the cellar door had gotten jammed and he was stuck in there for what felt like hours until his cousins finally found his mother and she came to rescue him.

That one experience had been the major cause of his longtime fear of the dark. It was a fear that he eventually grew out of, of course, but even now he couldn’t deny the small bit of apprehension that he felt in his current situation.

Luckily, his trip into the troll cave didn't last nearly as long as that long ago trip into his grandparents' cellar.

Only a couple steps away from where he tripped over the chest of gold, his foot touched something smooth on the ground. He slowly crouched down, reaching out until his fingers found what he was looking for. Standing straight again he held his breath as he ran his hand over the object. He didn’t need to see it to know that it was Sting.

The hilt of the blade was familiar in his hands, as though the last time he held it hadn’t been over decade ago. Even blind, he easily strapped Sting to his belt, then started forward again. It took only a few moments for his outstretched hands to find the side of a wooden barrel.

With Orcrist and Glamdring awkwardly clutched to his chest, Bilbo turned and made his way out of the cave, doing his best not to trip again.

Emerging into the fresh air again was a relief, and once he was far enough that he could no longer smell the stench of the cave, he stopped for a moment to just breathe. He leaned against a tree and closed his eyes with a sigh.

Somehow, he had managed to get in and out of the cave without any problems. He almost couldn’t believe it. Now if he could just get back to camp without something going wrong, he thought he might be setting some sort of record for himself.

“Bilbo?”

The squawk that the hobbit let out may have been the most undignified sound he’d ever made, but he was too startled to care.

Jerking away from the tree, his eyes flew open and Sting was halfway out of its sheath before he realized who it was that had spoken.

Bilbo stared at the grey-cloaked wizard for a few moments, then slowly let go of his sword, glaring.

“You nearly scared the life out of me,” he accused. “Where have you been?”

The old man simply shrugged. “Looking ahead. I believe I have discovered the source of your worries.”

Bilbo couldn’t help but give an unamused snort. “Have you really?”

As glad as he was to not be alone in the creepy woods anymore, he wasn’t about to show it. When the wizard wandered off earlier that evening, Bilbo nearly went into a panic. The only thing that made him feel at all better was the thought that Gandalf would surely be back to help if anything terrible happened—he always came back. But Bilbo had still been on edge ever since.

“It is a mountain troll, is it not?”

Bilbo thought the wizard sounded much calmer about the situation than he should have. “It’s three mountain trolls, actually. Three giant, smelly trolls that would be perfectly happy to eat the entire Company if so given the chance. Now, I suggest we get back before—”

He was cut off by a monstrous howl that that went echoing through the forest, sounding like a mix between a wounded cat and a furious orc, just ten times louder.

A cold flash of dread went through him, and Bilbo looked towards where the sound was coming from.

Towards the troll camp.

For a moment, he and Gandalf just stood there, until the next howl was let out and it jolted them from their stupors.

“Come on!” Thrusting Glamdring towards Gandalf, he turned on his heel and ran.

Streaking through the woods as fast as his feet could carry him, Bilbo couldn’t help but assume the worst.

The horrendous racket the troll was putting up didn’t necessarily mean that the Company was involved, of course, he knew that. But he could feel it—that tightening grip of dread—and he knew in his heart that his dwarves were in trouble.

He wasn’t wrong.

As he and Gandalf drew near enough to the troll’s camp that they could see the burning firelight through the trees, their run turned to a tiptoe and they crept as near to the clearing as they dared.

Peeking out from between the branches of a thick bush, Bilbo found himself looking at a sickeningly familiar scene.

Tied up in sacks and tossed in a haphazard pile was half of the Company. The other half was above the fire, slowly going through the process of being cooked alive. The ponies had all been herded into a makeshift corral and were stamping their hooves nervously.

One troll stood beside the fire, turning the spit and grumbling to himself.

The other two were off to the side, one of them sitting on the ground and wailing as the other leaned over him, poking and prodding none too gently at his horribly swollen eye.

Turning back to look at Gandalf, Bilbo hissed, “we have to do something.”

“Indeed,” the wizard mused, studying the scene before them with far less concern than the situation called for. “How did you manage to escape the last time? Assuming this happened before, of course.”

Bilbo couldn’t help the annoyance that shot through him at the question. “Oh, now, I can tell you about the future?”

Deeming not to respond, Gandalf just raised a single bushy brow and waited.

Bilbo glowered at him, but relented. “We distracted them long enough for the sun to rise and—”

“And turn the trolls to stone. Not the best plan, but I suppose it will have to do, given the circumstances. Dawn isn't too far off.”

He wanted to mention to the wizard that the plan had, in fact, been in at least part his idea, but he went on before Bilbo even had the chance to open his mouth.

“You be the distraction, and I’ll see what I can do about setting our friends free,” Gandalf said.

“How am I supposed to distract them?” Bilbo sputtered, but it was too late. Gandalf was already gone. “Ooh, damn that confusticating wizard!”

As much as he hated to do it, Bilbo would have to be the distraction whether he wanted to or not. He’d done it before and he would do it again, lest the Company be eaten and their journey end right then and there.

Shifting Orcrist in his arms—the sword was really quite heavy, but he couldn’t very well leave it there—Bilbo began his search for a good climbing tree.

 

***

 

He wasn’t sure how much time it took him to finally get perched up in the high branches of an oak tree overhanging the camp, but by the time he was settled, the troll with the hurt eye was still wailing as loudly as before, so he figured it couldn’t have taken too long.

It seemed his timing was perfect because it was only a couple moments later that the troll standing by the fire turned to his brothers and shouted.

“Shuddup, Tom! Your blubbering’s giving me a headache!”

“You take a burning stick to the eye and see how you like it!” Tom retorted, trying to scramble to his feet while clutching at one side of his face.

“Keep talking like that and you’ll see how you like a stick in both eyes!”

The third troll piped up then, pointing a log sized finger at the dwarves above the fire. “When’ll they be done, Bert? I’m starved.”

“Maybe it wouldn’t take so long if you lazy slugs ever bothered to help, Bill. Or maybe, I should just eat ‘em all myself and let you starve.”

Bill spat on the ground and shook his head. “You know I can’t cook.”

At the same time, Tom said, “I already called the one that stuck me! You can’t have it!”

And as though he feared Bert really would take his share of the meal, Tom lunged for pile of dwarves, his hands grasping at the burlap bags until he caught one and hauled it into the air and hung it over his gaping mouth.

It was Thorin.

An involuntary squeak found its way out of Bilbo’s throat, and he nearly leapt to his feet, only to remember he was in a tree and spent a moment scrabbling to keep his balance so he didn’t go plunging to the ground far below. Orcrist nearly slid from his lap.

He didn’t have time to come up with a plan, and he hadn’t spotted Gandalf anywhere since he disappeared. It was up to him to do something.

“Tom!” It took a moment for Bilbo to realize that the shout had come from him and he froze, sure that he had just given himself away.

The trolls didn’t see him, though, and Tom let out a shriek, dropping Thorin back onto the pile.

“What was that?!” Tom asked, spinning around to find whoever had said his name.

Bill looked as confused as his brother, but Bert turned a glare on the dwarves. “Oh, calm down, you lump. One of them’s messing with you.”

“I say we eat ‘em now to shut ‘em up,” Bill suggested, sliding a slimy tongue over his lips hungrily.

Cursing himself for his own stupidity, Bilbo cleared his throat and shouted again. “Bill!”

“Who’s that?”

“Bert!”

Whipping his head toward the dwarves again, Bert held up a knife threateningly. “Make another sound and I’ll cut out your tongues.”

This is a terrible idea, Bilbo thought.

“You will not touch them,” he said, and his voice boomed throughout the clearing, amplified louder than it should have been and sounding as though it came from every direction. It startled him so badly he nearly fell again.

Gandalf must have done something. Used some kind of magic to manipulate his voice.

Bert spun around, brandishing his knife and ended up facing slightly away from where Bilbo was actually perched. “Show yourself now and maybe I’ll let you live,” he spat.

“You better hope I let you live, after everything you three have done.”

“And who’re you to think you could kill three trolls?”

Bilbo had no idea what he was doing, and with his thoughts spinning so quickly he couldn’t process any of them, he grabbed the first one he could catch and held on. He pitched his voice lower and spoke in a dramatic tone, much as he used to do when Frodo was still young enough to ask for bedtime stories. “I am the guardian of trees. You have come into my home and ripped up the roots of this forest, and I do not take trespassers lightly. Begone, or you will feel my wrath.”

It was quite possibly the stupidest idea he'd had to date, but it was too late to go back now. And as though the very words had summoned it, a harsh wind picked up and blew through the woods, making the very trees tremble.

Bilbo made a mental note to thank Gandalf later.

Tom let out a frightened noise and stumbled into Bill, who growled and shoved him away, though he too looked unnerved. Only Bert was unmoved by the performance, if anything, he looked even more angry than before.

He swung his knife threateningly at Tom and snapped, “stop it, you! You’ll squash our supper.”

Indeed, he had barely missed stepping on poor Bombur who only just managed to roll out of the way.

Looking down at all the dwarves, Bilbo bit his lip. The ones in the sacks were all struggling to get free, but were no nearer to doing so. He was more worried about those still tied to the spit above the fire, though. They had stopped turning for at least a couple of minutes now, and those few unfortunate enough to be stuck on the bottom of the turn were being roasted by the flames licking at them from below. It was lucky that dwarves tended to have a certain amount of resistance to fire, or they'd likely be dead already.

So, he tried again.

“I said begone!”

The trees shook harder, but Bert stood firm. The damn troll was nearly as stubborn as Lobelia.

The other two, at least, were not.

Nudging at his brother’s arm, Tom was looking frantically at the woods around them. “Can we fight a ghost?” he asked, his voice somewhat shrill.

Bilbo didn’t know where ‘ghost’ had come from, but he wasn’t about to correct them.

“Quiet! It’s only a trick,” Bert hissed. Then, louder, he said, “Come on, then, oh Guardian!”

Another glance at the dwarves, and he saw that they were getting restless. They had started squirming about on the ground like a bunch of lumpy looking worms, and the sight would have been rather comical if not for the danger they were currently in.
They were beginning to grow restless as well, and Bilbo could hear them grumbling.

The only dwarf not moving around was Thorin. He was laying still on the ground, staring directly at the old oak where Bilbo sat. How he had pinpointed his location, Bilbo had no idea. He was quite positive he was hidden from view by all the branches and leaves. Still, Thorin was looking. And there almost seemed to be a hint of a smile on his face, though surely that was just his own imagination.

Drawing in a steadying breath, Bilbo turned his attention back to the trolls. Then, like a miracle sent from the Valar, he spotted a flash of grey on the other side of the clearing, and a moment later, there was the first hint of sunrise on the horizon.

“So be it,” he said.

Then Gandalf split the boulder and the golden sunlight of dawn spilled into the camp and the trolls were no more.

Chapter 9: Sneaking Suspicions

Summary:

As the Company continues their travel, Thorin begins to notice that Bilbo is acting a little odd.

Notes:

Wow, I can't believe it's been nearly a month since I last updated. Between classes and my job and homework, I have had absolutely no time to get any writing done. Sorry for the long wait, and thank you all for your patience!

(5/11/25)
Edit: Lol can you imagine a time where a month was a long time between updates? (I'm so sorry, I promise I'm getting there. The last few chapters are coming.)
I fixed a timeline error and made a few minor grammar edits

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Getting shoved into a stinking sack by a troll was an experience that Thorin had never wanted to go through—let alone go through it twice. Yet there he was, kicking the burlap off his feet among the rest of his Company for the second time. If it never happened again, it would be too soon. Still, he couldn’t truly complain. They had all made it through the ordeal without any serious injuries and none of them had actually been eaten, thanks to Bilbo.

It was with that thought that he turned towards the large oak overhanging the troll camp, just in time to see the hobbit fall out of the lowest branch and stumble a few feet before catching his balance.

Thorin wasn’t at all surprised that Bilbo had saved them. Really, he had been expecting it. The hobbit always had been rather resourceful in getting them out of sticky situations one way or another, and he was quite used to it at this point.

He started the walk over to Bilbo, ducking between two of the troll statues, and reached him as he was bending to pick something up from the ground.

Thorin didn’t quite know what he was going to say—up until now, he hadn’t spoken to Bilbo much at all over the last couple of weeks—but he had to say something. As soon as he opened his mouth to speak, though, he was distracted by a glint of silver. His eyes fell to the object in Bilbo’s hands, and he was speechless.

Bilbo turned towards him and jumped, apparently not having noticed his approach, then blew out a small huff of air. “You startled me.”

“Where did you get that?” Thorin asked, in place of an apology. There was no need to ask, of course. He knew exactly where the sword had come from. The real question was how.

They both stared at Orcrist for a moment, then Bilbo started to stammer. He looked more nervous now than he had ever since leaving Bag End.

“Oh, well, you see, I—”

He could have gone on like that forever if Gandalf hadn’t strode over right then. Bilbo gave the wizard a look that almost seemed pleading, and for a split second Gandalf looked confused. Before Thorin could be sure, though, the old man’s face smoothed over and he shrugged.

“We found it in the trolls’ hoard not far from here.”

Glancing between the two of them, Thorin asked, “and just what were you doing in their hoard?”

Again, Bilbo looked lost for words and again, Gandalf came to his rescue.

“I happened to come across it while I was on my walk. I went back to camp earlier to fetch Bilbo because I thought it might be good for him to practice his burglaring.”

Bilbo nodded meekly and held Orcrist out to Thorin. “We thought you might like this, so I grabbed it.”

Thorin took the sword after some hesitation, the weight of it familiar in his hands. It was a relief to hold it once again, but something about the story seemed wrong. He looked up again in time to see the grateful look that Bilbo shot at the wizard, which only made him more sure that there was something they weren’t telling him.

Still, he forced himself to nod. “Thank you, then. Both for the blade, and for saving us all. Our journey would have ended here, if not for you.”

He said the words to Bilbo in particular, and the hobbit smiled a bit, some of his nerves fading and being replaced with an almost surprised look. “Well, we couldn’t have that, could we? You’re quite welcome.”

The three of them stood in silence for a second or two, and Thorin studied them both, looking for some hint of what he was missing. He didn’t find it, though, and after another moment, Bilbo mumbled something about freeing the ponies.

Both the hobbit and Gandalf wandered off, then, and Thorin watched them go. When their backs were turned to him, he finally let his smile fall and his brows furrow.

“I did not see him,” he whispered to himself.

Ever since stopping in the meadow for the night, Thorin had been keeping watch, and he never saw Gandalf come back. There was no way the wizard could have returned to fetch Bilbo as he claimed. Thorin would have noticed. The hobbit he could understand being able to sneak away—he was small and capable of complete silence when he wanted to be. But Gandalf...the wizard was far too tall for him to not see. Thorin would have spotted him from a mile away.

Why they would lie about such a thing, Thorin had no idea, but he had every intention of finding out.

That would have to wait until later, though. Right now, he had to check on his sister-sons then get the Company back on the road.

The sooner they left this accursed place, the better.

 

***

 

They managed to pack up camp and leave the farmhouse behind them before it reached midday.

That was something Thorin could be grateful for, at least.

He was able to get away with keeping the Company moving at a quick pace without earning any complaints. It seemed everybody was eager to get away from the forest, and he was glad that nobody requested to rest for the day instead of move on.

He just hoped that their early departure and possession of their ponies would give them enough of a head start to avoid the warg scouts that he knew had to be on their trail.

It was early evening when the road started to veer out of the forest and run parallel to the tree line instead, and by sunset that night they had reached the edge of forest altogether. Before them stretched miles of rocky plains, and beyond that stood the Misty Mountains—looking bigger than ever as the Company grew closer and closer to them each day.

Deciding they didn’t want to camp out in the open plains that night, they kept within the edges of the forest. As the rest of the Company made camp, Thorin found a place to sit and took out his sword and a whetstone.

The mountains marked the halfway point on their journey to Erebor—in terms of distance, at least. He knew that they were nowhere near being halfway finished with the quest. Not by a long shot. There were still dozens of obstacles lying in wait on the road ahead of them, every single one of them potentially perilous.

On the first trip, Thorin hadn’t been nearly as anxious about it all as he was now. He supposed that came with actually knowing what was in store. The last time, he’d only had a vague clue of what dangers they might face in their travels. Now, he knew those dangers in painfully intimate detail, and they were about to plunge headfirst into it all. The trolls were only the beginning.

That wasn’t even mentioning the perils that might come their way due to any changes he made this time around. Already, things were turning out differently, and some of them weren’t even changes he had intended to make. What kind of dangers were ahead that he didn’t know about? And how would he protect his Company when he couldn’t see those dangers coming?

All of the worry those thoughts brought him were enough to make his head spin.

The familiar motions of sharpening the blade was a welcome distraction. Not that it needed to be sharpened. No, it was as perfectly lethal as ever—sharp enough to slice the skin on his thumb with the smallest touch.

Still, he diligently continued on with the routine, watching the last light of day catch in the spotless metal and listening to the laughter of his friends.

It was a sound he had yet to grow tired of, and he supposed it something to do with all those miserable weeks they spent wandering lost and starving in the Mirkwood, and then trapped in the dungeons of the elves after that. Even after their escape from their captors, all of their moods were rather dull. There was that final night in Lake-town before they made the final trek of their journey to the mountain when they drank and ate and sang, but underneath all that cheer had been a tense apprehension that none of them managed to shake. And once Erebor was retaken, they were all so busy searching for the Arkenstone—

Thorin’s hand slipped and he hissed, dropping the whetstone on the ground by his boots. He ignored it and looked at his hand, grimacing at the blood that was already welling in the cut across his palm.

“Oh!”

Thorin twisted around to see Bilbo standing behind him, holding a steaming bowl in each hand. Before he could say a word, the hobbit set the stew down and grabbed Thorin’s wrist, pulling it closer so he could inspect his palm.

“I am fine,” Thorin said, attempting to reclaim his hand, only to find that Bilbo’s grip was surprisingly strong.

Bilbo snorted and shook his head. “Obviously not. You’re bleeding all over the place.”

He wasn’t wrong.

The blood from Thorin’s cut had already run down his hand and was seeping over Bilbo’s fingers. They both stared at it—or more, Bilbo stared at the blood and Thorin stared at Bilbo.

He watched as the hobbit’s eyes widened and his face turned pale, lips pressing into a thin line. For a moment, he looked fearful. Then just as soon as the look was there, it was gone again and his face smoothed over into mild concern.

“I’ll see if I can get something from Oin.”

Then Bilbo let go of him and disappeared across the camp. Thorin thought he heard him grumble something about clumsy dwarves before he got too far.

It was only a minute later that he came back, taking a seat beside Thorin on the log with a one of Oin’s jars of ointment and a water flask in hand.

“Here, let me look.”

Thorin didn’t complain as Bilbo reclaimed his hand once again and began cleaning it off. He was more focused on the fact that they hadn’t been this close to each other since the very beginning of this (second) journey. And the only other time Bilbo ever actually held his hand was after the battle, when he lay dying on the ice.

As though he had suddenly been transported back to that instant, Thorin was fairly sure he wasn’t breathing.

When Bilbo first slathered the ointment onto his palm, he winced and the hobbit shot him an almost amused look.

Feeling his face get a bit warm, Thorin cleared his throat and looked away. “I could have done this myself.”

“Really? I’m not entirely sure you wouldn’t have just sat here and stared at it until you bled out.”

“It is not that bad,” Thorin said defensively.

The corner of Bilbo’s mouth quirked up slightly, but he didn’t respond.

He finished applying the salve and Thorin tried to take his hand back, but Bilbo still didn’t let go. He dug around in his pocket for a moment, then pulled out a familiar square of white cloth and looked at it scrutinizingly for a moment before nodding. “That will have to do, I suppose.”

Then he wrapped the handkerchief around Thorin’s palm and tied it into a makeshift bandage. He did it so smoothly one would think he’d done it before.

After Bilbo finally released him, they sat there for a few moments and stared at each other.

“Thank you,” Thorin eventually managed to get out.

Bilbo coughed slightly and glanced away from him, shrugging. “The stew’s going to get cold.”

With that, he reached over to grab take his bowl and stood up.

Before he could really think it through, Thorin caught the hobbit’s jacket. “You can sit. With me. If you would like.”

Blinking, Bilbo slowly nodded after a moment and sat down again. “Alright.”

For several minutes they sat in silence, not a word passing between them as they ate their supper. Thorin took the time to watch the hobbit from the corner of his eye.

He spent much of the last journey struggling to understand the strange creature Gandalf brought into their Company. Bilbo was small, and fussy, and completely ill-suited for life outside of his peaceful Shire. He had no idea how to defend himself—wielding a blade as though it was a butter knife rather than a weapon—and up until that moment on the flaming cliff, Thorin had been sure that he was frail and fragile, and more of a burden than a help. And up to a certain point, he hadn’t been completely wrong in his thinking.

Bilbo was a bit of burden in the beginning, with his constant complaining about everything. Yet, despite the rough start, Bilbo proved to be just as brave as any of them—maybe even more so.

In any case, Thorin had been convinced he had the hobbit completely figured out by the time they reached Erebor. Now, though, he wasn’t quite so sure.

By his reckoning, Bilbo should still be in that in-between stage of cowardice and courage, willing to have a debate about the proper way to cook dwarves with a trio of mountain trolls, but still daunted at the idea of carrying a sword. Yet, sitting beside him now, the hobbit didn’t seem the least bit shaken by the ordeal they’d gone through the night before. Not only that, he had his tiny sword strapped to his belt like it belonged there. He didn’t seem at all uncomfortable with its presence.

Though every thought in his mind was telling him to leave the matter be, Thorin couldn’t help his curiosity.

He wanted to know what had changed to help the hobbit find his courage so early.

“How are you fairing, Master Baggins?”

Bilbo looked slightly startled at the question. “Pardon me?”

Thorin went on before he could change his mind. “Last night was the first real danger we have faced on this journey. Are you regretting your choice to join us?”

It took several moments for the hobbit to answer, but when he did, there was no hesitation in his voice.

“I appreciate your concern, Master Oakenshield, but there’s no need to worry about losing your burglar. I won’t be turning my back on this Company on account of a few nasty trolls. I made a promise to help you get your home back, and that’s exactly what I intend to do.” Bilbo shrugged at that, as though he hadn’t just said the complete opposite of what Thorin was expecting, and he turned his gaze back towards the Misty Mountains. “Besides, if I let myself be cowed by what happened last night, how can I expect to face the worse dangers that still lie ahead?”

Thorin was nearly stunned speechless, until he caught the last part of what the hobbit had said. Looking at Bilbo dubiously, he asked, “And what kind of worse dangers are you expecting us to run into?”

Having taken another bite of stew when he finished talking, Bilbo choked on it now. After several moments of coughing into his sleeve, he shot Thorin a glance, his face a bit red and said nervously, “Well, er...the dragon, I suppose?”

He studied Bilbo for a moment or two, then hummed and looked away.

They sat together for a little while longer before Bilbo left him to go have a smoke with Gandalf and Balin.

Thorin waved off the invitation to join them and stayed where he was, staring down at the BB embroidered onto the makeshift bandage on his hand. He was still puzzling over the hobbit’s words later that night when he laid out his bedroll to get some sleep.

 

***

 

With no trees above them to provide shade from the sun, the next few days of travel were nothing short of hot and miserable. There was no denying that summer was finally upon them, and by that time the entire Company was likely wishing for a bit of that rain they were complaining about so much after they first left the Shire.

As the morning wore on, it got hotter and hotter, and everybody began removing whatever extra layers they could stand to be without.

Not even Gandalf was spared by the heat—going so far as to shed his outer robe before the sun had reached its highest peak in the sky.

Thorin removed his own fur jacket and jerkin and now wore nothing over his scale armor. That was something he wouldn’t take off, no matter how hot it might get. By the time noon had come and gone, he was beginning to decide that he much preferred the scorching heat of a forge over that of the sun, and was grateful that he had been born into a race that lived their lives in the cool depths of their mountains.

The ponies, too, seemed rather put out by the uncomfortable temperatures and were slogging along a bit slower than usual.

Of course, as soon as the first cry of a warg echoed over the plains, their pace increased considerably.

Cursing, Thorin urged his mount to go faster until he was riding alongside Dwalin. “Get Bifur and Gloin and guard the back end of the group. Make sure Kili has his bow ready. Keep the hobbit close to the middle.”

“We going to make a stand?” Dwalin asked tersely, one axe already in hand.

“Not yet. We only stop when we have to. We must get as close as we can.”

“Close to what?”

Thorin grimaced at the question, but didn’t answer it. Instead, he just jerked his head and Dwalin fell back, yelling in khuzdul to repeat Thorin’s orders to the rest of the Company.

As soon as his best friend was gone, Gandalf immediately took his place, his horse towering over Thorin’s own pony and casting him into shade for the first time that day. There was no time for him to be relieved for it, though. Not with an orc scout party very nearly nipping at their heels.

“The Hidden Valley is—”

Thorin had no patience to listen to the wizard’s persuasions. “I am well aware of where we are and what lies ahead.”

“We should not try and face our pursuers alone. It might be wise to—”

Gritting his teeth, it took no small effort for Thorin to repress his snarl. “Do what you will, Tharkûn, I will not alter our current course.”

He could practically feel the look of surprise Gandalf gave him, but he refused to acknowledge it. And as the wizard galloped off ahead of them, he tried to tell himself that there was no other way to handle the situation. Their ponies couldn’t outrun the wargs for long, and without the brown wizard and his team of sled-pulling rabbits, there was no hope of diverting the pack’s attention long enough for them to escape. Still, it didn’t stop the bile from burning in the back of his throat.

He let the disgust consume him for all of two seconds before focusing on their run once again. There were more important things to worry about at the moment.

A glance over his shoulder told him that Dwalin had followed his orders exactly. Bilbo was in the very of the middle of the group, and he was relieved to see that Fili and Kili had somehow been herded into the middle with him. Bofur, Bombur, and the Ri brothers formed a circle around them, and Balin and Oin had ridden ahead to flank Thorin on either side.

Despite the circumstances, he couldn’t help the burst of pride he felt at the sight.

Every single one of them had their weapons drawn and wore a look of grim determinations on their faces—even Bilbo had his little blade in hand.

Thorin had told them he would take them all over an army from the Iron Hills, and he meant every word of it.

So he turned to face ahead again, and they ran.

They pushed their mounts to ride faster than they had traveled thus far on their journey, and the ponies seemed perfectly happy to comply. Especially when they started spotting flashes of wargs and their riders in their peripheral vision.

The pack was trying to surround them, and Thorin knew that sooner or later they would succeed.

Unfortunately, it turned out to be sooner.

As the Company went to pass by a large outcrop of boulders, someone let out a cry of warning just before a warg leaped in front of them from above. It landed on the ground half a dozen yards ahead of them and made a terrible howling noise.

The ponies came to a clumsy stop, skidding into each other and whinnying with fear.

In moments, Balin and Oin had both placed themselves in front of Thorin and the warg leaped again, this time straight at them.

Just as Thorin lifted his shield and blade, an arrow screamed past his head and buried itself in the warg’s eye. At the same time, another arrow pierced its rider straight through the neck.

Both the orc and the warg slumped dead to the ground, and Thorin didn’t have time to be confused about where the second arrow had come from before a high, clear war horn echoed over the plains, accompanied by the sound of thundering hooves.

Cresting the hill a little ways ahead of them were a couple dozen riders, with a grey-robed wizard and a figure in golden armor at their head.

The elves had come.

Notes:

I'd like to note that this chapter is completely unedited, so there may be some mistakes. If anybody happens to notice any, I would appreciate it if you pointed it out, and I'll do my best to fix it as soon as I can :D

Chapter 10: A Spark of Hope

Summary:

Bilbo runs into someone he never expected to see, then meets with the White Council.

Notes:

So, I finished this a week later than I intended, but it's finally done. Sorry it's a bit shorter than the other chapters, but I figured that I had gotten to a good stopping point. Thank you all for being so patient and for all of your comments!

 

(5/11/25)
Edit: I added the paragraph mentioning Merry and Pippin and fixed some grammar issues.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Rivendell was as beautiful as always. More beautiful, even, considering that the last time Bilbo was there it had been nearly empty due to all the elves sailing West. The Hidden Valley was more lively than he had seen it in several decades. It was safe and warm and full of music and Bilbo should have been comforted by it. Instead, he spent the next couple of weeks on edge, unnerved by the knowledge that it wouldn’t be long before the darkness swept across Middle Earth and all the life in this place would disappear once again.

While he wasn’t with the dwarves, he was wandering the valley, trying to soak in every detail and commit it all to memory before he inevitably had to leave again. It was on one such occasion—on what would be one of their final days with the elves—that he came across what was perhaps one of the strongest reminders of just how much change the future held in store.

Bilbo was on his way to one of his favorite places in Rivendell—a small, out of the way garden where he used to go to think or write—when he ran into somebody he never expected to see.

Although, “ran into” probably wasn't quite the right way to describe it.

Halfway to the garden, Bilbo was following a path through a stand of pines when he heard a series of cracks and snaps coming from up above him.

Had he been in a clearer state of mind, he would have moved out of the way like any sensible person with the threat of something heavy falling down on their head, but Bilbo had spent the entire day worrying over the meeting he was supposed to go to that evening and was rather distracted. So, instead of move, he stopped walking and looked up just in time to see the mass of grey and green right before it crashed into him.

If he was his true age at the time, the impact very well could have killed him. As it was, Bilbo only felt like he was dead during the several moments that he lay on the ground, wheezing to catch the breath that had been knocked out of him.

He was still lying there when an unfamiliar face moved into his line of sight—leaning over him and looking concerned. The person was no elf. He was too small and lacked the pointed ears. Human, then, and a child at that.

“Hey, are you alright—” the boy stopped suddenly, his eyes growing wide, then… “You’re the halfling!”

Shaking his head in an attempt to clear his muddled thoughts, Bilbo pushed himself into a sitting position. “I’m a hobbit, actually.”

With his tangled dark hair and pale eyes, the boy looked almost...familiar. Though Bilbo hadn’t met many human children before, and he could say with near certainty that he’d never met this particular one.

“You’re with the company of dwarves that have been staying here!”

“I am,” Bilbo said. Climbing to his feet, he brushed himself off and bowed to the boy. “Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

The boy stood as well, and at his full height he was an inch or two taller than Bilbo. “My name is Estel. I’m sorry I fell on you, Mister Baggins.”

Bilbo hardly heard the apology, he was too caught up by the boy’s name. He knew that name, somehow. Didn't he?

“Have we met?” He asked after a few moments of trying and failing to dig up any memory of the boy.

Estel shook his head. “No, I’ve never met a half— I mean, a hobbit before. Or dwarves. I wanted to, but Lord Elrond said I wasn’t allowed to bother the guests.”

Bilbo furrowed his brows and chewed on his lip thoughtfully.

What was a child doing in Rivendell, anyway? A child who—apparently—knew Elrond. There were never any children when Bilbo had been there, elvish or otherwise.

As he thought, he studied the boy carefully, his eyes falling to the scrapes on his cheeks and hands, then he glanced up at the trees above them. “You aren’t hurt, are you? That was a rather long fall.”

Looking offended at that, Estel folded his arms and stood up straighter. “It would take more than that to hurt me. I wouldn’t have fallen out of the tree at all if the branch I was on hadn’t broken.”

Despite his words, Bilbo could easily see that the boy was putting most of his weight on his right leg. Amused, he shook his head. It was nice to know that the childish stubbornness was a trait shared across races. “Come on, then. There should be a steam nearby. Let’s get those scrapes cleaned up.”

His memory served him well, and it took less than a minute of walking before they came across the stream that Bilbo had mentioned. He made the boy sit down on a rock by the bank and dug around in his pocket for a handkerchief. He had gotten one from some of the elves about a week ago, as he had used his own handkerchief as a bandage for Thorin’s hand and had yet to get it back.

Estel didn’t complain too much as Bilbo cleaned his scrapes, and before long he was chattering on as children are wont to do.

Listening to him talk about the last time one of the elves had taken him hunting, Bilbo wasn’t quite sure of what tipped him off to the boy’s identity, but the realization came so suddenly that he felt as though he’d been hit over the head with a frying pan.

“Aragorn,” he whispered with amazement.

He didn’t know how he hadn’t seen it before, it was so obvious. It shouldn’t have taken him so long to figure it out. Some aspects of his old age were definitely still sticking with him. How annoying.

The boy stopped in the middle of a sentence and gave him a curious look. “What did you say?”

Bilbo just shook his head bemusedly, lost for words.

Aragorn. Strider. Thorongil. Longshanks. Estel was just the first of a long line of names this boy would go by in his lifetime to come. It was a name that meant ‘hope’ and it was quite fitting.

A light from the shadows shall spring, indeed.

That was just one line from the song he had written for his friend so long ago—or would write in the future to come, he supposed—and never before had he realized just how accurate it was.

This boy was just the spark of a flame that would someday save Middle Earth from the darkness, and he didn’t even know it.

“Found him!”

The familiar voice echoing through the trees interrupted Bilbo's musing and he winced. Turning to look back over his shoulder, he saw a wizard and two dwarf princes walking up the path towards them.

“It is time.”

That was all Gandalf had to say to make Bilbo’s heart sink. He knew this was a good thing, really, but he couldn’t help but be a bit apprehensive of the situation.

Still, he nodded once and got to his feet. Looking at Estel to see that the was looking up at Fili and Kili with barely restrained excitement, Bilbo smiled. “It was nice to meet you, Estel.”

“You too, Mister Baggins,” the boy responded, not taking his eyes off of the dwarves even for a second.

Bilbo glanced at Fili and Kili. “Maybe you two wouldn’t mind keeping my friend company for a while?”

Kili shot him a wide grin. “I think we could do that. Right, Fi?”

“Aye,” his older brother said, nodding in agreement.

Elrond wouldn't thank him for introducing his young charge to the Durin princes, but Bilbo couldn't help himself. As an adult, Aragorn had often been a bit too solemn. Perhaps such mischievous influence at a young age would do him some good. At the very least, it might prepare him for the chaos that was Meriadoc Brandybuck and Peregrin Took, should he eventually meet them in this timeline.

The last thing Bilbo saw before turning to follow Gandalf back through the trees was Estel’s eyes lighting up as he scrambled to his feet to introduce himself.

The two walked together in silence for several minutes, steadily climbing their way higher up the valley, and it was clear they were headed to a lone pavilion up on a ledge overlooking the rest of Rivendell. The closer they came, the more anxious Bilbo got, and the slower he found himself walking until he came to a complete stop in the middle of the path.

For a moment Gandalf kept walking, then realized that his companion was no longer beside him and he turned back to see where Bilbo had gone.

“Is something the matter?”

“Exactly how much do they know about me?” Bilbo asked, daunted by the idea of having to tell more people of his plight.

“They are aware of your situation, so you will not have to explain it to them completely. All you will need to do is answer some questions and elaborate on a few things that I have already told them.” The wizard gave him a comforting smile and gestured to the top of the path. “You have naught but friends here, Bilbo. We all want to help you.”

Taking a deep breath, Bilbo nodded and forced himself to continue walking. Gandalf was right. There was nothing for him to worry about.

That thought lasted all of half a minute.

As soon as they set foot in the pavilion, Bilbo glanced around to take count of who was there. The first two, he expected. Lady Galadriel stood with her back to them, her long hair shining golden in the evening sun, staring out at the valley below. Elrond sat quietly at the stone table in the middle.

The brown-clad figure beside him was a surprise, though not an unwelcome one. During their weeks in Rivendell, Bilbo had wondered what became of the peculiar wizard, seeing as they didn't run into him on their way to the valley.

It was the last person in the pavilion that had Bilbo stopping in his tracks and his stomach plummeting all the way down to his toes.

Sitting at the opposite side of the table from Elrond and Radagast was an old man with long white hair, beard, and robes. Though he’d never met him in person before, it wasn’t hard for Bilbo to guess who this was. It was Saruman, the White Wizard. The same White Wizard who turned to the darkness during the War of the Ring.

“Master Baggins, welcome.”

Elrond’s greeting both stopped Radagast’s chattering and broke Bilbo from his stupor. Tearing his gaze away from Saruman, he did his best to smile and gave a half bow.

“Thank you. I appreciate you taking the time to speak with me.”

He hoped his voice didn’t shake too much when he spoke, but if it did, nobody mentioned it.

The elf’s head dipped in acknowledgement and he gestured to the seat beside him. “Please, sit. We have much to discuss.”

After a nod of encouragement from Gandalf, Bilbo approached the table and climbed into the chair.

When he was settled, Elrond spoke again. “I suppose some introductions are in order—”

“Forgive my interruption, but I am in no need of introductions. I know who you all are,” Bilbo said.

“Perhaps you would not mind introducing yourself, then, for those of us here who have not met you yet.”

Nodding, Bilbo cleared his throat and glanced around. Galadriel had yet to move since their arrival, and he had no desire to look at Saruman, so after a few seconds his gaze fell to Radagast. “I am Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, and I’m here seeking your guidance and advice. Gandalf said you are already aware of my circumstances.”

“We are.” Elrond nodded. “And I think we should start with when you first realized you were in your past, to the best of your memory.”

So the next hour was spent recounting that morning nearly two months ago when he awoke to find himself in Bag End, then the events up until that day. He avoided saying much about the Company and their quest, and he said nothing about the future—keeping in mind Gandalf’s warnings and the fact that there was a potential traitor among them. He didn’t know if Saruman was already in the service of the Dark Lord or not, but he wasn’t going to take any chances.

“And you have no idea how any of this may have happened?” Elrond asked.

Bilbo shook his head.

“Who else have you spoken of this to?”

“Nobody outside of this council,” he answered.

“We decided it would be best to keep this quiet,” Gandalf piped up. “At least until we had the chance to discuss it here and hopefully come up with a solution. Or figure out how this could be possible.”

The pavilion fell silent for several long moments as everyone seemed to think over that last point. It came as a surprise when a new voice joined the conversation and Bilbo looked up to see that Galadriel had finally turned towards them.

Her voice floated over them all like a summer breeze—soft, yet easy to hear all the same.

“Only a great power could send someone back in time in such a way. Power greater than any here possess.”

At that, Saruman spoke up for the first time, and Bilbo jumped at the boom of his voice. “My Lady, surely you are not suggesting that the Valar had anything to do with this? We do not know if he speaks the truth, and even if he does, what reason could a god have to send a simple halfling back in time?”

Galadriel said nothing in response, and simply stared the White Wizard down with cool blue eyes.

Beside him, Bilbo noticed Gandalf’s hands clench, and his friend spoke up in his defense. “I have known Bilbo since his birth, and have been friends with his family for centuries. I assure you, he speaks the truth, no matter how bizarre his story might seem.”

Under Saruman’s dark glare, Gandalf pursed his lips tightly, though there was an angry storm brewing in his eyes. Radagast was mumbling to himself under his breath and glancing back and forth between his fellow wizards, anxiously turning his ragged hat in his hands.

“Peace!” Elrond said, slicing through the thick tension that had suddenly grown between them all. “Arguing amongst ourselves will solve nothing. There is no reason for Master Baggins to lie over something such as this, so until we have reason to think otherwise, we should believe his story to be true. In that case, the Lady is right. There is only one power great enough to perform such an act.”

“I’ve never heard of such a thing. Why would the Valar send somebody through time?” Radagast asked, looking to Bilbo as though staring at him hard enough would reveal some kind of answer.

Elrond grimaced like he had just tasted something sour. “I do not know.”

Just like that, the council dissolved into discussion that went so fast Bilbo could hardly keep up with what was being said. Really, it was all beginning to make his head pound and his stomach turn nauseous.

Bilbo was just thinking that he might actually be sick when through the din of loud voices came a soft caress at his mind that made him shiver, and his eyes were inexplicably drawn to Lady Galadriel just to find that she was already watching him.

“I sense darkness brewing on the horizon. When the time comes, you will be at the center of it.”

Hearing her voice in his thoughts was slightly unnerving, but Bilbo nodded all the same. There was no point in trying to deny it. Not when she already seemed to know.

For a split second, her eyes drifted to the end of the table before settling back on him.

“You fear him.”

Another nod. He didn’t need to ask who she meant.

For a few moments, Galadriel said nothing else, and Bilbo almost thought she was finished speaking with him. Then…

“You have been sent back for a reason, Bilbo Baggins. You are meant to be here.”

But I don’t know what to do, he thought somewhat desperately.

“When the time comes, you will. Speak with Oakenshield. You need not carry this burden alone.”

Bilbo blinked and shook his head. I don’t understand. What—

A hand on his shoulder dragged Bilbo from his thoughts and he glanced around to find that everyone had gone silent and were now staring at him.

“I’m sorry. I was distracted. What did you say?”

It was Elrond who answered him. “We will continue to look into your situation, but in the meantime it would be best for you to remain here in Rivendell. When we find any information that may be of use, we will speak of this again.”

That wasn’t going to happen.

Bilbo knew full well that the Company would be setting off again soon, and he had every intention of going with them when they did. Still, he nodded to Elrond in agreement anyways then glanced at Gandalf. “Thank you for your help. I suppose I’ll leave you to the rest of your meeting then, unless you need me here for awhile longer.”

Even as he said it, Bilbo was already slipping out of his seat.

Gandalf nodded and gave him a weary smile. It seemed that Bilbo hadn’t been the only one drained by the events of the past hour. “Yes, you can go. I will come find you later and we can talk some more.”

Glancing nervously in Saruman’s direction, Bilbo met his eyes for a short moment before promptly looking away again. He didn’t like the way the wizard was looking at him.

After giving another quick word of thanks, he turned on his heel and hurried towards the path that would take him back down into the valley. Before he could even leave the pavilion, though, Galadriel’s voice appeared in his head once again.

“Remember what I have told you, Bilbo. You are not alone.”

Notes:

I didn't really have time to do much editing, so if you find any mistakes please don't hesitate to point it out and I'll do my best to get it fixed!

Chapter 11: A Hobbit's Promise

Summary:

On the night before the Company is set to depart from Rivendell, Thorin's brooding is interrupted by a certain hobbit.

Notes:

Alright, guys, here it is! Chapter 11 is finally finished, although it is a little short. I hope you can all forgive me for taking two months to update. Things with school got so busy that I didn't have any time to write, but the semester is over now, and I'm hoping I'll be able to get at least a couple of chapters done before I have to go back.

(5/11/25)
Edit: Added a paragraph or two

Chapter Text

After aimlessly wandering the halls of Rivendell for what felt like forever, Thorin eventually found himself sitting alone in a small courtyard, lit only by the swarm of twinkling fireflies hovering in the air and the light of the crescent moon overhead. He knew he should be with his Company, but he needed to think. And he couldn’t do that surrounded by a dozen singing dwarves.

They were leaving the Hidden Valley bright and early to resume their long journey to the Lonely Mountain. Elrond read the map for them last night, and there was no reason to stay with their elvish hosts any longer—a fact that Thorin was glad for.

He was sick and tired of elves.

Granted, the ones they had spent the past couple of weeks with weren’t nearly as bad as Thranduil and his ilk, but they were still unpleasant in their own way.

Just the memory of the elf woman he ran into earlier that day was enough to make him shudder.

With long hair of pale gold and a silent grace about her, she was just like every other elf he ever had the displeasure of meeting, yet at the same time she wasn’t. She’d practically radiated an aura of otherness so strong it raised the hairs on the back of his neck. They hadn’t said a single word to each other, but when her eyes met his it was like she could see straight through him and down to his very core. What she saw there, he had no way of knowing, but by the time he managed to unstick his boots from the floor and hurry away, there was a slight smile curling at the corner of her lips, like she knew something he didn’t.

Yes, he was glad to leave Rivendell behind them.

And yet…

Thorin sighed and buried his face in his hands, rubbing at his burning eyes. He had hardly slept the past couple of days, and come tomorrow he knew his chances at getting any real rest would decrease exponentially. The road ahead held danger and peril at every turn, and the moment the Company set foot outside Rivendell there would be no safety for them. A slight reprieve at Beorn’s home was all he could hope for before they were well and truly in the thick of it all.

There were so many things he had to be careful of if he wanted to keep his Company alive throughout the next few months, it made his head hurt. Goblins, wargs, spiders, elves, a dragon. There was no end to troubles they would face of their way to the mountain. Not to mention the Pale Orc hadn’t even shown his gruesome face yet—and that was a reunion he was not looking forward to.

He had hoped that knowing the dangers they would face would make him more confident in their journey, but he was finding that the knowledge only made him more stressed than ever.

How could he lead his family and friends on, knowing what horrors lay in wait ahead of them? He had known the risks since the beginning of the first quest, of course, but that was before everything went wrong.

Before he and his sister-sons all perished in battle on the doorstep of what should have been their home.

Before—

He wasn’t sure what alerted him to the fact that he was no longer alone, but within moments he was sitting up straight once again and looking around for whoever had come to interrupt his thoughts.

After a moment, he found who he was looking for.

A familiar figure stood at the edge of the courtyard, seeming ready to bolt the moment their eyes met.

“Master Baggins. Do you need something?”

Bilbo froze in the middle of taking a step backwards and he seemed to struggle to say anything before he shook his head quickly. “No, no, I was just passing by. I’m sorry to disturb you.”

He took another step.

“No, wait.”

Thorin winced at the harsh tone and softened his voice a bit. “You can stay, if you would like. I would...appreciate the company.”

“Oh.” The hobbit halted his retreat and hesitated for a moment, seeming conflicted. “If you don’t mind, I suppose.”

“Sit with me.”

Bilbo nodded and slowly walked back into the courtyard. And he kept walking until he was standing a few feet away. Thorin gave him a tight smile and patted space on the bench beside him.

Once Bilbo sat down, crossing his hairy feet one over the other and folding his fidgety hands in his lap, the two of them said nothing for a while.

It wasn’t until the silence became too much for him to handle that Thorin said the first thing that came to mind. “Where did you go earlier?”

“Pardon?”

“Fili and Kili said you went somewhere with Gandalf.”

“Oh. That.” Bilbo shrugged slightly, and Thorin glanced at him from the corner of his eye. “We went and spoke with Lord Elrond. I...had some questions I hoped he might be able to answer.”

There was a time not too long ago that Thorin would have bristled at the thought of Bilbo going to have private meetings with elves, but he pushed the annoyance away and forced himself not to sound upset. “And did you get the answers you were looking for?”

“No. He was entirely unhelpful.”

Bilbo's voice was surprisingly bitter and Thorin looked at him with surprise.

“I am sorry,” he said after a moment.

The hobbit shrugged again, and the bitter tone turned more chipper in an instant, though there was weariness on his face. “What are you doing out here, anyway? Shouldn’t you be resting?”

“I could say the same of you,” Thorin pointed out. After a few moments without any response, he sighed and laced his fingers together tightly. “We are leaving in the morning.”

“We are.”

The fireflies had drifted closer and a few were flying lazily around the hobbit's head, flickering lights reflecting in his eyes and giving them a greenish-gold glow. Their stay in Rivendell had done Bilbo good. His hair was clean and curly, the bags under his eyes were nearly gone thanks to the extra rest, and his face had a healthy roundness to it again that had started to slim down over the course of their travels. Other than the tan and extra freckles on his nose and cheeks from being out in the sun, he looked as he did that night in Bag End. He looked soft.

And finally, after several days of keeping his silence on the matter, Thorin finally voiced one of the thoughts that had been plaguing him since their arrival to the valley. “You should stay here.”

“What.”

“It is safe here, and comfortable. There are books and food and beds.” Thorin swallowed and looked away, fixing his gaze on the empty space before them. “Where we are headed is no place for a hobbit.”

He could barely stand it, comparing Bilbo now to how he looked in the final days of that first journey, exhausted and scared and far too thin. Wearing thread-bare clothing and covered in various scrapes and bruises and burns from all the danger they faced. The memory of it hurt, knowing he had been at fault for the hobbit's state. He didn't want to leave Bilbo, but the pain of seeing him that way again would be far worse than the pain of separating. His One would be well-cared for, here in this valley of warmth and growing things.

Several seconds passed in silence, then…

“I beg your pardon, Mister Thorin Oakenshield, but I have no intention of staying here while you lot go off risking your lives,” Bilbo hissed, batting one of the fireflies away from his face angrily.

“But—”

Bilbo kept going, sounding more upset with every word. “I don’t need you coddling me like some helpless fauntling. I am perfectly aware of the dangers ahead, thank you very much.”

“I do not think you are,” the dwarf grumbled, more to himself than anything.

The hobbit’s eyes flashed and he snapped. “I know more about it than you might think.”

The words caught his attention and Thorin paused. Furrowing his brows, he turned and looked at Bilbo curiously.

He spoke after a moment, choosing his words carefully. “You know of the danger, and yet you will still come. Why?”

There was no sign of the timid creature Thorin had first met all those months ago on the doorstep of Bag End when Bilbo responded. His hazel eyes were hard, and his voice sure. “Because I gave my word, and I intend to keep it.”

“The contract—”

“I’m not talking about the contract,” the hobbit cut him off quickly, shaking his head. “Your home was taken from you and I will help you take it back, even if it kills me.”

Thorin stared in disbelief.

Bilbo blinked then cringed slightly, like he hadn’t meant to say what he did. Wringing his hands, he started stuttering. “Er, well, that is to say…”

Gaze falling to the sword still strapped to the hobbit’s belt, Thorin stopped breathing.

Oh.

Oh.

He was a gods-damned idiot.

“Bilbo?”

Chapter 12: To See Mountains Again

Summary:

The Company is making their way through the Misty Mountains and run into some trouble with the stone giants.

Notes:

Well, here's the next chapter. I wanted to get it up sooner, but about two days after I published the last chapter I ended up getting the flu, and with the holidays going on I didn't have much time to write. But this chapter is slightly longer than the last and it didn't take two months to finish, so I'm going to count it as a success :)

(5/11/25)
Edit: Added a few sentences to the first paragraph and fixed some grammar.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo remembered that once, all those many years ago when he finally left Bag End and the Shire behind for good, he told Gandalf he wanted to see mountains again. He only made it as far as Rivendell before he reluctantly admitted to himself he was far too old to go climbing up such steep paths. He'd had to say goodbye to Bofur, Nori, and Bifur there in the valley, and watching his dwarves go on without him tore at old wounds on his heart he had believed long healed. He'd yearned to chase after them, but while his mind was willing, his aching bones were not.

He never saw them again.

Now, trudging along the pass through the Misty Mountains—in the middle of a violent storm, soaked to the bone and caked with mud, and those very paths he had once looked at with such longing practically crumbling beneath his feet—he wondered how he could have ever actually wanted to venture into such a dreadful place.

His only guess was that time made the memories taste sweeter.

In any case, he suspected it would be a very, very long while before time managed to sugar-coat this particular experience.

He had a feeling that the same would prove true for the rest of his companions as well, if the current state of them was anything to go by. They were all a rather miserable bunch.

All except for their leader.

If the Company was discouraged by the raging storm threatening to blow them off the mountain, Thorin was the opposite. Amidst the exhaustion that hung over them all like a cloud as tangible as the ones that rained down on them, he was the only one who seemed able to conjure any amount of energy. His voice rose above the thunder and wind, calling out encouragement and urging them to stay together, and never faltered.

When Balin slipped and fell, Thorin hauled his friend back to his feet then shouldered the older dwarf’s pack along with his own and kept moving.

There was a look in his eyes that Bilbo wasn’t sure he'd ever seen before—a cold determination he thought might surpass anything the dwarf had shown throughout their original journey.

It was one of two expressions Bilbo had seen Thorin wear since they left Rivendell behind them just over a week ago. Whenever they were travelling, it was the determination, but in the rare moments that they stopped to rest—whenever he stopped to look at Bilbo—it became entirely different. He couldn’t quite place it, but reminded him of the shock that one feels after realizing something monumental, mixed with something much more raw.

It was the same look Thorin had in his eyes when he said his name—not just “Master Baggins”, but his actual name—right before Dwalin appeared, out of breath and urgent, relaying Gandalf’s message that they needed to leave Rivendell immediately.

Bilbo still hadn’t gotten the chance to ask Thorin about it, but for some reason he had the feeling it had something to do with why the dwarf had been so determined to keep him close ever since they had set foot in the mountains. Why, even now in the middle of the storm when there were arguably much more important things for their leader to be worrying about, he kept glancing back every few minutes to make sure Bilbo was still right behind him.

 

***

 

The mountains were fighting.

Boulders flew through the sky above them, hurled by the two massive stone giants in the middle of an all out brawl. The echoing booms of rock against rock joined with the sounds of thunder and howling wind to create a terrible symphony, nearly loud enough to burst eardrums.

The storm had only worsened in the past hours and once the stone giants made their appearance, the Company completely gave up on traveling any further and instead focused on clinging to the mountainside for dear life and praying they would survive.

Completely numb from head to toe, it took all Bilbo had to keep himself rooted to the wall of solid rock at his back as the mountain beneath them shook and quaked. The weather and constant movement had him feeling nauseous, and he probably would have been sick several times by now if he had anything in his stomach. As it was, none of them had gotten the chance to eat anything, being too preoccupied with trying not to go plummeting off the cliff a mere few feet away from where they huddled in a shallow alcove to the side of the path.

Bilbo longed for more substantial shelter from the stinging rains and shards of rock that pelted him relentlessly. He may even be willing to venture into a cave should they find one, goblins or no goblins, but they couldn’t see any sign of one nearby. And there was no way they were sending anyone to scout up ahead. Not when the chances of them never returning was so great.

So they stuck together, and though the storm became too loud for Thorin be heard, he continued to keep an eye on the entire Company, his entire body tense as though he was ready to lunge for anyone he thought was about to go down. And all the while, he had a hand wrapped around Bilbo’s arm, his steely grip just tight enough that Bilbo thought he might find a bruise there later.

He didn’t complain, though, not when that hand kept him on his feet as another tremor shook the mountain and rattled him to his bones.

He nearly thanked the dwarf, until he saw something in the corner of his eye and the words died on his tongue.

One of the giants swung its huge fist so hard that when it made contact, its opponent’s head went flying—and crashed into a spot on the mountain far above them.

The shaking resumed with the impact, and rocks began tumbling down onto all their heads like the beginnings of an avalanche.

The Company’s shouts could barely be heard over the din and they all drew each other nearer, desperately trying to avoid being hit by the falling debris.

It was then that Thorin finally released Bilbo and lunged for his nephews, practically throwing himself on top of them to shield them both from the shower of rocks.

Bilbo’s knees hit the ground and he threw his arms over his head, making no effort to try and rise again. After a few moments, he glanced around to see how the rest of the Company faired.

Dori, Nori, and Dwalin seemed to have all converged on Ori at once. Pushed up against the rock wall, the young dwarf looked like he might suffocate beneath the weight of them. Gloin and Balin each had a hold of one of Oin’s arms and were holding him up as the healer struggled to keep on his feet. Like Bilbo, Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur had all given up on standing and were huddled together on the ground.

For a single moment, it seemed they would all be fine.

Then the body of the now headless giant slammed into the mountain.

The earth itself lurched at the impact, and Bilbo was thrown by the force of it, skidding towards the edge of the cliff.

A high pitched shriek—which may or may not have come from him—was lost beneath a boom of thunder. He thought he heard someone shout his name, Bofur maybe, but there was too much mud and water in his eyes for him to see anything.

By some kind of miracle, Bilbo stopped just before reaching the edge. He knew he needed to get up, to move to a safer spot, but the fall knocked the wind out of him so he just laid there, disoriented and gasping for breath.

Then he was being hauled off the ground again and as soon as he was on his feet he clutched onto the fur coat of whoever had come to his rescue. Looking up, Bilbo came nose to nose with the dwarf.

Familiar blue eyes stared at him and he stared back, frozen.

Thorin was speaking, he was sure of it, but he couldn’t hear a word of what he was saying.

“What?!” Bilbo yelled, but he couldn’t even hear his own voice over storm.

Whether or not Thorin would try to repeat himself, Bilbo never got to find out. Because between one second and the next, the ground beneath his feet was gone and he was falling. Stumbling, Thorin held onto him, and for an impossibly long moment Bilbo was dangling in open air. Then the edge crumbled more and the earth under the dwarf’s boots gave way.

Bilbo only saw a brief flash of the Company’s horrified faces before he and Thorin were both sent tumbling down the cliff.

Notes:

Thank you to everybody who has commented since I posted chapter 11. I normally make it a point to reply to every comment, but with the spring semester starting up I have a feeling I'm not going to have any time to respond. Please just know that I see every single comment you guys send me and I cherish them all <3

I'd like to warn you that it may take a while for chapter 13 to get done because a lot is going to happen and unless I decide to change my outline, it's supposed to be considerably longer than the last few updates have been. That being said, please be patient and don't worry —I am not giving up on this story.

Chapter 13: Deep Dark Places

Summary:

After being separated from the rest of the Company, Thorin and Bilbo must find a different path out of the Misty Mountains. Thorin plans to take advantage of the occasion and use it as an opportunity to finally talk to the hobbit, but it proves to be a more difficult endeavor than he hoped.

Notes:

I feel like every chapter I write is going to start off with an apology for taking so long to update. Still, I am truly sorry. Unfortunately, school and mental health issues got in the way and I haven't had the motivation to write these past few months. The semester is finally over, though, and I'm feeling better. Yesterday I ended up reading through all of the comments you've made on this story and it gave me enough motivation to finally write the rest of this chapter. Thank you all so much for your love and support for my writing, it helps me more than you know <3

(5/11/25)
Edit: Added the detail about Balin's pack because I forgot Thorin was supposed to have it

Chapter Text

Thorin woke to a pounding head and something hard jabbing him in the back. His entire body ached, like he had lost a fight with Dwalin in the training ring ten times over, and he wanted nothing more than to fall back unconscious for several more hours. Unfortunately, as the moments went by, he became more and more aware of his discomfort.

Groaning, Thorin forced his eyes to open and he blinked a few times, trying to clear the blur. It took him a moment to realize that there was nothing wrong with his eyes and it was just dark. Still, there was enough light for him to see a shape move in the corner of his vision.

Thorin instinctively reached for his sword, just to find that it was no longer on his belt. So he struggled to sit up, readying himself to fight off whatever creature was stumbling towards him.

“Thorin?”

He paused, and squinted at the figure, then relaxed. “Bilbo."

“Yes, it’s me.” The hobbit staggered, then dropped to his knees at Thorin’s side, looking down at him worriedly. “Are you alright?”

For a moment, he was taken back to Ravenhill. The two of them had been in a similar position then—freezing and covered in grime. This time though, thankfully, it seemed that neither of them were fatally injured

Pushing the thought out of his mind, he ignored the question and looked around again. They were in a ravine of some sort, stone walls rising up on either side of them and dark, cloudy skies far, far above.

“We fell?” he asked, a vague memory of stone giants and a storm stirring in the back of his mind. His voice came out scratchy and rough and he winced.

Bilbo nodded, not even seeming to really notice when he reached out to brushed some hair from Thorin’s face. “We did, though I haven’t the faintest idea of how we survived it.”

“Dwarves have thick skulls.”

Letting out a short laugh, Bilbo shot him a quick grin. “Believe me, I’m well aware of that.”

Thorin huffed, but the response reminded him of the question he had yet to ask and he sobered. They hadn’t had a moment alone together since Rivendell, and he didn’t think time travel was a topic that should be brought up around the rest of the Company. They were alone now, though, unsavory as the situation may be.

With that thought, he started to sit up. “Bilbo—”

The hobbit’s smile fell and he pushed him back down, the hand on Thorin’s shoulder surprisingly firm. “Maybe you should stay still for a while longer. It looks like you took a rather nasty knock to the head. What if you have a concussion?”

Thorin brushed his fingertips over his temple, feeling the sticky, half-dried blood caked there. That explained the headache.

“Relax, Bilbo. I am fine,” he said, brushing the hobbit’s hand away gently.

His spine popped several times as he sat up and he let out a low groan, ignoring the warning look that Bilbo gave him. Once Thorin was on his feet, Bilbo moved away from him, assumingly to find whatever belongings he had lost during their fall.

Thorin didn’t miss the way the hobbit limped, and he immediately stopped taking stock of his own injuries. “Are you hurt?”

The hobbit waved the question off with hardly a glance and bent down to pick up his pack, wincing when he stood straight again. Thorin almost thought he wouldn’t answer at all, but then Bilbo turned to him.

“I just fell off a gods-damned cliff and somehow managed to survive with nothing more than some bruises and a sore ankle. I’m not about to push my luck by complaining,” he said.

Shaking his head from a mix of amazement and disbelief, Thorin wondered how he could have gone so long without realizing how out of the ordinary Bilbo’s behavior had been. From the very beginning, Bilbo was too willing and too confident when it came to the quest, and no amount of meddling from any wizard could have ever been enough to turn a gentle-hobbit into an adventurer before he even set foot out his door. Thorin had just been too blind to see it.

“Bilbo, there is something we should—”

But the hobbit wasn’t listening. Instead, he was staring at something on the ground by his feet and he was standing very, very still. Then he bent down to scoop whatever it was off the ground and tossed it towards Thorin, hissing. “We need to move.”

Catching Orcrist clumsily in his arms, he glanced down to see that the blade had come slightly unsheathed from its scabbard.

It was glowing.

In the short moment it took Thorin to put the blade back on his belt, Bilbo had already started walking at a brisk pace, despite what he had said about his ankle.

Cursing under his breath, Thorin hoisted Balin's pack onto his shoulder. His own pack was nowhere to be seen, and there was no time to search for it. He resigned himself to giving it up as lost, then hurried to catch up with Bilbo, silently vowing to kill every goblin in the Misty Mountains if that was what it would take to get even a few quiet moments to actually talk to his hobbit.

 

***

 

Though they didn't run into any trouble over the next hour, that unnerving glow of their swords never dimmed. Thorin tried multiple times to start a conversation with Bilbo, but the hobbit seemed too preoccupied with his own thoughts to talk. For the most part he was quiet, but every once in a while he started grumbling to himself, too quietly for Thorin to understand anything he was saying. So they walked in a tense almost-silence, and the sky far above them slowly grew lighter as dawn approached.

Just as Thorin was beginning to wonder how far the ravine would take them—and if they might be able to follow it all the way out of the Misty Mountains—they turned a sharp corner and came to a stop at the sight of a dark cave-mouth gaping at them from within the cliff face.

Up until now, they hadn’t come across any diverging paths. With two walls of stone on either side of them, both too steep to even consider climbing, there was nowhere to go but forward.

Thorin took one look at the cave and immediately decided this was one mountain he didn’t want to enter. He had every intention of passing the cave by and continuing to follow the ravine, wherever it may take them, but he only made it about ten steps before he noticed that there was no longer a hobbit at his side.

Stopping, Thorin turned around to see his companion staring into the dark, gripping the hilt of his small sword so tightly that his knuckles were white and a look on his face like he had just taken a bite out of a rotten apple.

“Bilbo?” After a moment of getting no response, Thorin sighed and went back. “What is it?”

“I have to go in there,” he said glumly.

“What? Why?”

“I just have to.”

“Bilbo, there are goblins in these mountains. Going in there would be like poking at a hornets’ nest. Not to mention that there is no way of knowing if there is a way out once we go in there.”

“There’s a way out.”

“But—”

Bilbo rounded on him, a determined glint in his eyes. “If we go in there, could you lead us through the tunnels? Don’t argue. It’s a yes or no question.”

“Of course I could, I am a dwarf. But I will not—”

“Master Oakenshield!”

Thorin shut up.

As soon as his voice stopped echoing through the ravine, Bilbo spoke again, though more quietly now. “Do you mean to tell me that a hobbit will go underground when a dwarf dare not?”

Spluttering, Thorin tried and failed to come up with a rebuttal, only managing to give the impression of a gaping fish. Bilbo, damn him, had the hint of a smirk tugging at the corner of his mouth.

For several moments, the two of them just stared at each other. Then Bilbo turned on his heel and strode toward the cave. “Come on, then. If we’re lucky, maybe we’ll make it out by supper.”

Grinding his teeth angrily, Thorin huffed and stomped after him.

 

***

 

Underground, there was no way of knowing exactly what time it was, but Thorin didn’t need a clock or the sun to know that they were not, in fact, lucky enough to make it out by supper. They walked for hours, making their way through what felt like miles of tunnels that snaked through the belly of the mountain.

As he said he could, Thorin was able to lead them on their way easily enough, but he hated every second of it. Normally, he would take comfort in being surrounded by stone on all sides. He spent almost his entire life living under mountains, after all. Navigating them was second-nature to him. But there was nothing comforting about this place. The stone here did not welcome him like that of Ered Luin or Erebor. Rather, it felt evil, as though it had been tainted by the shadows and the dark things that lived within them. It felt sick. Almost like Mirkwood.

That was all the more reason for them to move quickly.

Exhausted as they were, not once did they stop to rest, both too anxious to leave the darkness behind them.

Thorin, at least, could see well enough to guide them on their way, but he knew Bilbo had been traveling completely blind ever since they entered the cave. The hobbit stumbled over uneven ground and his own two feet dozens of times before Thorin suggested he hold onto his coat.

With Bilbo holding onto his sleeve, the going was a bit easier. Thorin was able to guide him around potential obstacles, so they could move faster, but it still wasn’t fast enough for his tastes.

The slower pace mixed with the dead quiet of the tunnels made hours feel like an eternity. Neither of them dared speak, even if their swords had gone dark a long time ago. There were fouler things than goblins lurking in the dark, and they didn’t want to risk alerting those things of their presence.

So they kept their silence and Thorin was left to agonize over his thoughts.

Thoughts that he was abruptly dragged out of when his boot scuffed against the ground and rather than rocks crunching under his foot he heard the unmistakable clink of metal on stone.

He stopped walking, and a moment later Bilbo ran into from behind.

“What is it?” the hobbit whispered.

Thorin ignored the question and stooped down, where he saw a glint of gold in the dark.

Without thinking, he reached out and picked up the small object.

It was a Ring, smooth and cold in the palm of his hand.

Under closer inspection, he found that it bore no markings on its surface. He briefly had the thought that something of dwarven make—intricately shaped and detailed—would be much nicer.

Still, there was something enticing about the simplicity of it.

He would keep it; just another precious trinket to add to the wealth of Erebor.

And for a moment he was no longer looking down at a little Ring, but staring out across a sea of treasure, the weight of his grandfather’s crown sitting upon his head. He basked in the golden light that surrounded him and reveled in what was easily the most beautiful sight he had ever laid eyes on—

He blinked and the vision was gone, along with the Ring he had been holding. Confused, he looked up in time to see a glint of gold as Bilbo shoved it into his pocket. He scowled and nearly told the hobbit to give it back, but stopped at the last second.

There was fear in Bilbo’s eyes, and the sight brought up another memory. One where he wore a crown upon his head and held a thieving hobbit in his hands.

Gasping, Thorin shook his head, trying to rid himself of the horrid memory. He felt sick, suddenly. Was he really so weak that just one look at a tiny trinket could send him back to madness? Maybe it was a good thing Bilbo took it from him. Maybe that was why he had taken it. If the hobbit had also been sent back to fix things, then surely he remembered everything—including all that took place in Erebor.

Not for the first time, Thorin felt the urge to drop to his knees and beg for forgiveness for all the terrible things he had done under the influence of dragon sickness.

“Bilbo—”

He wasn’t able to get another word out before a hand was unceremoniously slapped over his mouth, effectively muffling him. With his free hand, Bilbo pointed at Orcrist. It took all the strength Thorin had not to scream in frustration at the light that radiated from the blade.

Slowly, Bilbo stepped back and gestured in the direction they had been walking. Not far ahead, there was a bend in the tunnel, blocking their view of whatever struggle was taking place no more than twenty feet away from them.

The sickening sound of rock against flesh made a dull echo over and over again, backed by some horrid creature that was hissing and retching and shrieking all the while. A few moments later, there was a thud that sounded like a body hitting the ground, and the creature let out a victorious cackle. Apparently, whatever it was bludgeoning had finally either passed out or died.

Neither of them made a sound while they listened to the creature begin dragging its opponent away, presumably to eat it. It wasn’t until its raspy breathing faded away that they moved again.

Disgusted, Thorin glanced over at Bilbo, who at some point had drawn Sting.

In the soft glow of his sword, the hobbit’s face was pale and grim.

“Let’s go,” Bilbo said quietly, and he started walking again.

Putting a hand on the hobbit’s shoulder, Thorin stopped him. “Maybe it would be better to wait while. I do not want to risk that thing seeing us and running off to alert the rest of the mountain that we are here.”

Bilbo just shook his head and kept walking.

With a sigh, Thorin drew his sword and followed him.

It wasn’t long before Thorin began to feel a change in the stone around them. It was not so smothering as it had been before. He was sure that they were getting close to an exit.

He said as much to Bilbo, but his relief was snuffed out like a candle flame seconds later when they once again heard that thing up ahead as it began singing. Thorin listened to a few of the words of its song then did his best to shut it out, deciding that he would rather not know.

“We passed another branch of the tunnel not five minutes ago. If we turn back, we could take that path instead,” Thorin suggested.

“Nonsense,” Bilbo said, turning to him. “You said it yourself, the exit is that way. There’s no point in turning around now.”

Thorin scowled. “I did not say it is that way. I said it is nearby.”

“Fine. I say it’s that way.”

Exasperated, Thorin looked up at the ceiling above them. Maybe they had finally reached a part of the mountain that Bilbo recognized. After all, the during the first quest, the hobbit was separated from the rest of the Company and ended up escaping through these very tunnels. And hadn't he also mentioned a run in with some horrible creature that lead him out of the mountain? Thorin wouldn’t be at all surprised if that thing singing in the cavern up ahead was the creature Bilbo told them about. But that didn’t mean they should go and meet it, if it could be avoided. Thorin was sure he could find another way out that didn’t involve word games with a creature in the dark.

“Bilbo—”

“Shh. Do you hear that?”

Once again, Thorin ended up with a hand covering his mouth and he glared.

How many times is he going to interrupt me before I finally have the chance to speak? He wondered angrily.

There was no time for him to voice his complaint, though. He had barely jerked away from Bilbo when something pale and gangly dropped down on him from above and knocked him to the ground.

Rather than asking what he could hear, a more appropriate question would have been what he couldn’t hear.

The singing had stopped.

Chapter 14: I See Fire

Summary:

Bilbo and Thorin race to find the rest of the Company.

Notes:

Oof. Alright, here's the next chapter, finally. As always, I apologize for the long wait. I wrote the majority of this chapter within the past 24 hours and it hasn't gone through any editing whatsoever. But it's late and I want to get this posted before I go to bed. If you find any grammar/spelling issues, please don't hesitate to tell me. I would be forever grateful.
Also, thank you to everyone who has left comments. I haven't had the chance to respond, but your words mean the world to me <3

(5/11/25)
Edit: Added the part with the troll-coin.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo was too preoccupied in his argument with Thorin to notice when the singing in the cavern just ahead stopped. It wasn’t until an angry creature dropped from the ceiling above, hissing and screaming, that he realized. And by then it was too late.

Thorin was knocked to the ground by the attack and Bilbo stumbled back with a yelp. It took him a moment to regain his balance, by which time his companion was wrestling a sickeningly familiar creature that haunted his dreams for many years after his first journey ended—then again during the War of the Ring.

Shaking himself, Bilbo forced his thoughts back to the present then raised his sword and lunged forward to help.

Gollum’s long fingers were straining to wrap around Thorin’s throat as the dwarf cursed loudly in khuzdul and held him off.

The moment Sting’s sharp point touched Gollum’s neck, the foul thing let out a furious hiss and turned to leap on Bilbo, but stopped abruptly when the blade pointed to the place just above his heart.

“Get off of him,” Bilbo demanded.

Gollum glared at him hatefully, but when he was poked lightly with the sword he clambered off the dwarf and backed away.

Thorin angrily rose to his feet and moved to Bilbo’s side, heaving his own sword up and pointing it at Gollum threateningly.

“Akhamân,” he grumbled.

“Nê aglub uduhu,” Bilbo responded without a second thought.

From the corner of his eye, he saw Thorin look at him in surprise and he silently cursed himself for the blunder. He was sure he’d have to explain away the mistake later. Maybe he could say that one of the other dwarves had taught him some simple phrases. Fili or Kili would probably make the best excuse, they were young and brash and it might be believable that they had broken their people’s traditions of secrecy. It was a problem to deal with some other time, though. At the moment, there were more important things to worry about.

He turned his attention back to Gollum, who was in the middle of talking to himself.

“They’ve gots elvish blades, but they’re not elfs. No, the hairy ones a nasty dwarvses. Its meats is tough and hard to chew. But not the other. It’s not elfs or dwarvses. What is it, precious? Is it soft? Is it juicy?”

Thorin growled and pointed Orcrist threateningly. “Watch your tongue or you will lose it.”

“What I am is none of your concern. Given the chance, you would eat me nonetheless,” Bilbo said distastefully while shooting a small glance at Thorin.

“Let’s just kill the thing and get out of here.”

When the dwarf took a step forward, Bilbo threw out a hand to stop him. “We are not going to kill him,” he hissed.

“We have wasted enough time as it is. We need to find the others—”

“Are they lost, precious?”

“Quiet, you little—”

“Yes actually,” Bilbo interrupted. “We are lost, and we’d like to get unlost as quickly as possible.”

“Ooh! We knows! We knows safe paths! Safe paths through the dark!” Gollum blurted out, sounding much more cheerful than he had moments before. Then he scowled darkly and spat. “Shut up.”

“Fantastic. Is there anyway I could convince you to show us the path?”

“This is no time for riddles, Bilbo,” Thorin hissed.

Bilbo furrowed his brows and glanced over at him. “Who said anything about riddles?”

The dwarf looked ready to start tearing his beard out, but he didn’t get the chance to respond. He was cut off by a gurgling sound let out by Gollum.

“Riddles, precious? We loves riddles!” he rasped, his grotesque blue orbs widening in delight as he turned them on Bilbo. “Does it like games? Does it, does it? Does it like to play?”

Riddles it is, Bilbo thought. He hadn't really intended on challenging Gollum to a competition this time around, but there was no going back now.

Thorin groaned. “No—”

“Not you!” Gollum spat.

Seizing his chance, Bilbo spoke up quickly. “I’ll tell you what. You and I will have a game of riddles, just the two of us. And when we’re done, you will show us the way out.”

“Yes, yes! But only if it wins. If it loses, we eats it whole.”

“Fair enough.” Thorin made a sound of protest and Bilbo shot him a look. “Shush.”

Grumbling indignantly, the dwarf made no further attempt to argue, but continued to watch Gollum like he was ready to jump forward and thrust his sword through the creature’s chest at any given moment.

Bilbo shook his head then looked back to Gollum and sheathed Sting. “Would you prefer to go first, or shall I?”

 

***

 

The game went by much faster than Bilbo remembered, but then, he did have all of the answers to Gollum’s riddles memorized. With each riddle that passed, his opponent grew increasingly frustrated, and Bilbo wasn’t too hopeful that he would actually lead them out of the mountain. Still, this was better than outright killing him. As much as Bilbo disliked the creature, there was no way of knowing how Gollum’s premature death might affect future events. It was too big of a risk—and not one he was willing to take.

So they played.

“All things it devours; birds, beasts, trees, flowers. Gnaws iron, bites steel, grinds hard stones to meal.” Gollum had perched himself on top of a rock so that they were at eye level to each other.

Bilbo knew the answer, of course. This was the riddle that he had gotten stuck on all those many years ago. The next one would be the last, though, so he hesitated a second or two before responding. “The answer is time.”

Letting out an agonized shriek, Gollum flung himself to the ground and began banging his hands on the stone, like a particularly spoiled child throwing a tantrum after being told 'no.'

Bilbo watched with distaste and silently thanked Yavanna that Frodo had never been so badly behaved. He was grateful that Primula had managed to teach her son good manners before the end.

Once Gollum calmed and regained some semblance of control over himself, he sat back on his haunches and looked at Bilbo with glittering, hungry eyes. “One more, then we tastes its juicy flesh.”

Up until that point, Thorin had thankfully stayed quiet, but he growled at Gollum for the comment.

Bilbo ignored him and kept his focus on Gollum. “Very well. Listen close because I’m only saying it once.”

“Give us the riddle.”

“Small in size I may be, but not in power. If a man uses me, his mind I devour. I will give him greed. His love I will take. To destroy me he’ll bleed, but I will not break.” Bilbo finished reciting the riddle, then gave a curt nod, and stood up straight.

Gollum’s face scrunched up, making him look even more like a shriveled and rotten squash than before. When he started muttering to himself, Bilbo took the chance to glance at Thorin.

“Look across the cavern. Do you see a tunnel anywhere?” he whispered.

Thorin huffed irritably but did as he asked, peering into the deeper darkness that Bilbo’s eyes couldn’t pierce. Then he nodded. “I see one.”

“Good. Get ready to run.”

Surprisingly, Thorin didn’t give any further argument.

Just as he turned his attention back to Gollum, the creature’s huge eyes filled with something close to understanding and he met Bilbo’s gaze.

“Oh, but how does it know, precious? How does it know?” His voice was unnervingly soft.

Bilbo’s hand tightened around the hilt of his sword and his body tensed. Gollum would realize the Ring was missing soon enough. He prayed that Thorin could lead them out because he certainly wouldn’t be able to remember the path they would need to take to escape.

“It doesn’t matter. It won’t know anymore once it’s dead.” Sure enough, Gollum reached for the pouch of his grungy little loincloth. His face went paler—if such a thing was even possible—then he was rooting around in the pocket and started pulling out pebbles and strings and other things, looking more and more desperate. “Where is it?!” he wailed, and spun in a circle, searching the ground at his feet. He stopped and whirled to look at Bilbo again. “It knows! The nasty thief! It stoles it!”

Heart in his throat, Bilbo shoved his hand into his pocket and closed his fingers around something metal and cold. "If you want it so badly, go get it!"

He cocked his arm back, then threw with as much strength as he could manage. The troll-hoard coin glinted gold and disappeared in the darkness, then clattered against stone a few moments later.

Gollum howled with rage and went tearing after it.

For a moment, Bilbo couldn’t move. Then a hand strong hand around his arm dragged him out of his stupor into a run.

“Time to go!” Thorin yelled.

Bilbo stumbled, then got his balance and blindly followed the dwarf. He could hardly see anything in the dark, yet by some miracle he managed not to trip over anything. He could just make out the gaping entrance to the tunnel when an ugly shriek echoed off the walls of the cavern around them, followed by unintelligible cursing.

Bilbo just kept on running.

He skidded out of the cavern into the tunnel, and heard the sound of bare feet slapping against stone behind him. Then a heavy weight crashed into his back and sent him tumbling to the floor. For a moment, there were hands squeezing his neck and he was surrounded by Gollum’s putrid scent. Then he was gone.

Coughing and sputtering, Bilbo sat up just as Thorin threw Gollum down and raised his sword.

“No!”

The dwarf froze for half a second and looked at him. It gave time for Gollum to lunge, but not fast enough. Thorin turned back, and for a brief moment Bilbo feared he would cut Gollum down, but instead he struck the creature over the head with the butt of his sword.

Gollum collapsed on the ground, dazed, and Bilbo stared at him until a strong hand gripped his arm and pulled him to his feet. Thorin let go of him just long enough to take his hand. Then they ran.

 

***

 

They burst out of the mountain into the cool night air at a full sprint.

There was no sign they were being followed, but neither of them wanted to take the chance of slowing down. They didn’t stop until they were several yards away from the tunnel mouth.

Panting heavily, Bilbo put his hands on his knees and fought to regain his breath.

Several moments passed before he stood straight again, and when he did it was to find Thorin staring at him.

“What is it?”

“Bilbo, there is something I must tell you—” Thorin stopped and sucked in a sharp breath, looking at something over Bilbo’s shoulder.

Confused, Bilbo turned, then felt a pit of dread suddenly drop in his belly.

The slopes below them were ablaze, the flaming trees glowing red against the dark sky.

How they hadn’t noticed it sooner, he had no idea. The air smelled of smoke and if he listened closely, he could hear the faint roar of the raging fires.

Immediately, Thorin ran past him and went hurtling down the hill. There was nothing Bilbo could do but follow him.

Luckily, they didn’t cross paths with any stray wargs or orcs on their way down. None that were alive, at least. The trail of bodies lead them directly towards the cliff, and with each step they took, Bilbo’s heart sunk lower.

Before long, they could hear the shouting.

Thorin stopped so suddenly that Bilbo ran into him. He had no time to say anything before the dwarf dragged him behind a large boulder.

They both peeked over the top of it and Bilbo let out a shuddering breath.

Twelve dwarves were perched precariously in the tree at the very edge of the cliff, along with Gandalf who was providing them with flaming pinecones. Bilbo couldn’t see well enough to tell if any of them were injured, but he was relieved to see they were all there. It was only a small comfort, though.

Two wargs were at the base of the tree, slamming their full weights against the trunk over and over again so that it shook dangerously. Over a dozen orcs cheered them on and threw taunts at their cornered prey in their own harsh language.

In the middle of them all, sitting astride a white warg, was Azog.

Bilbo couldn’t help but close his eyes at the sight. The Pale Orc was yet another figure that had plagued his nightmares for many years. Moreso, even, than Gollum. It was he, after all, who had ultimately brought an end to his adventure. He who had caused the hollowness in Bilbo’s heart that had never truly gone away, even in his old age when his memory began to fail him. No, that was a hurt that had never healed.

Shaking away the unpleasant thoughts, Bilbo glanced over at Thorin.

The dwarf’s face was full of rage and grief...and determination. Bilbo noted how tight his grip on Orcrist was, his knuckles white. How he looked ready to spring into action at any moment.

Bilbo reached out and caught hold of Thorin’s coat just as he made a move to climb on top of the boulder.

“Don’t you dare,” he hissed.

Thorin’s gaze didn't waver, hatred making his blue eyes burn as bright as the fire that surrounded them. “I could kill him now, before he ever has the chance to—”

“What do you keep in that thick skull of yours? Rocks?” When he still didn’t look away, Bilbo sighed and softened his tone slightly. “If you go charging in there right now and get yourself killed, none of us will ever to make it to Erebor. Don’t throw this quest away for the sake of blind revenge.”

Thorin wavered, then his shoulders slumped. “You are right.”

“Of course I am,” Bilbo said and resisted the urge to let out a relieved sigh.

“What do you suggest we do?”

“We need a plan.”

“Do you have any ideas?” Thorin asked.

“One,” Bilbo answered, shooting a glance at him. “But you’re not going to like it.”

 

***

 

He was right; Thorin hated it. And if he was being entirely honest, he hated it too, but they didn’t know what else to do. So after several minutes spent arguing in quiet whispers, they finally came to an agreement.

“You know exactly what you’re supposed to do?”

“Yes,” Thorin said, sounding upset.

Nodding curtly, Bilbo got to his feet and made to head off, but Thorin grabbed his hand and stopped him mid-step.

There was a strange look in his eyes and when he spoke his tone was even stranger. “No matter what happens, do not place yourself between me and Azog again. I cannot do this without you.”

Then he was gone and Bilbo was left gaping like a fish out of water.

Again? What did he mean again? This was the first time they had come across Azog on their journey. Further still, Bilbo had never thrown himself in front of Thorin like the dwarf had implied. Not in this lifetime, anyway. And it wasn’t as though the Thorin knew about any of that—

No. Surely not.

Head spinning, Bilbo took a deep breath and struggled to reel in his thoughts. He didn’t have time for wild speculation. He needed to save his friends.

It was with great difficulty that he pushed everything to the back of his mind and snuck a glance around the side of the boulder.

All of the orcs had their full attention on the dwarves above them, who at this point had all stopped throwing their flaming pine cones and were now clutching at the branches around them. The wargs were still attacking the trunk, and with every hit the tree shook and swayed.

Taking advantage of everyone’s distraction, Bilbo kept his head down and scampered from tree to tree to rock, making his way closer to the cliff’s edge. Before long, he reached the tree closest to the one that held the Company and—keeping as quiet as he could manage—he climbed up into its branches.

By the time he reached a height where he was reasonably sure nobody could reach him, his hands and legs were scuffed and bleeding. He ignored the stinging scrapes and surveyed the ground below him. It seemed that he had managed to avoid detection, which was a small blessing. If he was spotted, this would probably never work. Granted, it probably wouldn’t work anyways.

Putting his hands up to his mouth, he hooted twice like a barn owl and once like a brown owl.

His signal was answered two seconds later by an identical call, then a deep voice rang out across the clearing. “Azog!”

The single word alone was enough to cause an outcry. The dwarves all let out a deafening cheer and the orcs screeched and howled, spinning to locate where the voice had come from and brandishing their crude weapons.

From where Bilbo sat, he got a perfect view of Azog’s grotesque smile just before the orc turned his warg and put his back to the rest of the Company.

Bilbo couldn’t help but lean forward to catch a glimpse of what was happening, and what he saw took his breath away.

Halfway up a tall pine, Thorin stood steady on a thick branch, gazing down at Azog with cold fury. Orcrist glowed blue in his hand. The flickering light of the fires made him seem almost otherworldly. He looked...well, Bilbo didn’t know how to describe it. Just that in that moment, there could be no question as to who was the rightful King of dwarves.

The Defiler shouted something in black speech that was very obviously a taunt and pointed his metal claw at Thorin.

The dwarf’s face twisted into a snarl and he yelled something back, but Bilbo didn’t know what was said. All he could hear was the deep groan of the Company's tree as it slowly leaned back over the cliff’s edge.

Whipping around, Bilbo noted with no small amount of alarm that the tree was barely clinging to the earth with its roots. A few more hits and it would tip. Utterly rabid, the wargs aimed to do just that.

Bilbo tore open his rucksack and grabbed a hefty stone off the top. Then, winding up, he threw it with as much strength as he had and sent it soaring through the air to hit one of the wargs on its rump. When it turned to face its attacker, it promptly caught another to the eye. It yelped and stumbled, shaking its head madly. When it stopped, its uninjured eye landed straight on Bilbo. With a roar, the warg charged at his tree and slammed into it like a battering ram.

It shook enough that he had to grab onto the branch to keep his balance, and he immediately pulled his feet up, wary of the beast’s foaming jaws and snapping fangs. Frozen for a moment, Bilbo couldn’t help but stare down at it as it tried again and again to jump high enough to reach him.

There was a creak, a groan, and a crack, then somebody—Ori, it sounded like—let out a piercing scream.

Snapped out of his daze, Bilbo watched with horror as the tree finally toppled.

It went down with a crash and left the entire Company dangling in the open air.

The second warg was hit by the tree's roots as they were ripped from the ground and was thrown several feet away. It lay stunned for a moment, then clambered back to its feet. Setting its sights on the dwarves that were now well within reach, it prowled closer.

With the realization that the added weight of the warg was likely to send the entire tree tumbling off the cliff, Bilbo scrambled to grab another rock, but his hand only found bark.

His pack was gone.

Looking down, he found that the warg had paused in its attempt to reach him in favor of ripping his supplies to hundreds of little pieces.

Desperately, Bilbo looked between the two wargs several times.

“Dear Yavanna, this is a terrible idea,” he muttered.

Then, with nothing else to do, he drew his sword, took a deep breath, and pushed off the branch.

The warg below didn’t even have time to look up before his blade was thrust straight through the top of its head.

The impact knocked the breath out of Bilbo and he wheezed, pushing himself off the ground. Stumbling, he fell against the dead warg and nearly gagged at the awful stench of it. He stood again and grabbed a hold of Sting, giving three big tugs before he managed to pull it from the warg’s skull.

He swung around to find that the other warg hadn’t even noticed him and was just beginning to climb onto the tree, its eyes locked on Dwalin.

Scooping a rock off the ground, Bilbo said a silent prayer and let it fly.

It found its mark.

The warg whirled around with a furious snarl and its attention settled on him.

Bilbo heard Fili scream a warning, then the warg charged. He watched it get closer, rooted to the spot and unable to move. Just as he saw the whites of its eyes, he dropped to the ground.

The warg leapt.

Bilbo threw his arms over his head, waiting for the teeth that would surely turn him to ribbons.

But nothing happened.

Instead, there was a skidding noise, then a yelp.

Bilbo looked up just as the warg went off the cliff.

He sat there in shock for several moments, then got the presence of mind to turn his attention back to the clearing. By some miracle, his wild endeavor to take on two wargs single-handedly had gone unnoticed.

Thorin was performing his role well. He was still shouting insults at the orcs and wargs swarming his tree, and had taken to chucking rocks down into the fray below and swinging his sword at any who managed to climb within his reach.

Azog still sat upon his warg, silently watching the dwarf’s efforts.

For a few short moments, Bilbo almost thought that Thorin would be able to keep their enemies distracted until the eagles arrived. Then he spotted a lone orc near the outskirts of the pack.

In its hands, it held Kili’s bow. It was in the process of taking aim.

Straight at Thorin.

Bilbo didn’t wait to consider his options. He was on his feet and sprinting at the orc before he even knew what he was doing. Somebody yelled at him to stop, but he didn’t so much as falter.

Halfway to his target, a familiar object caught his eye and he slowed long enough to heave it off the ground. It was much lighter than he would have expected, and felt as though it molded perfectly to his arm.

Where the oak shield had come from and how it had gotten there, Bilbo didn’t care.

He slammed into the orc just before it released its arrow.

 

***

 

What happened after that, he wasn’t entirely sure. All he knew was that he ended up on the ground, his sight going in and out of focus and his head feeling like it had been cracked open like the first summer melon. The noise and chaos surrounding him was muffled and far away, the ringing in his ears far louder than anything else. As his eyes dimmed, he could have sworn he saw a woman in green standing encompassed by flames, watching him with calm eyes.

Then everything went dark.

Notes:

Akhamân - thanks
Nê aglub uduhu - don’t mention it

Khuzdul courtesy of TheDwarrowScholar

Chapter 15: Of Concussions and Confessions

Summary:

After escaping the Misty Mountains, the Company stops at the Carrock for some much needed rest and Thorin finally gets a chance to have a long awaited conversation with his hobbit.

Notes:

Greetings! I won't go into a long explanation for my extended absence. Suffice to say, I've been on a roller-coaster from hell for the past six months and the ride won't be ending any time soon. I wish I could tell you I'm going to start updating more regularly again, but that would likely turn out to be a big fat lie. My only promise is that this story WILL be completed. I have no intention of abandoning it. It might just take a while.

That being said, this entire chapter was written over the span of the past two days, and I don't really have the energy to edit it. If there's any glaring mistakes, please let me know <3

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It was decided. Thorin hated flying.

Getting snatched up from the cliff in the talons of a giant eagle, then unceremoniously dropped onto the back of another was honestly worse than being sacked by a trio of mountain trolls. And he found that he didn’t regret being unconscious for the flight on the first journey. At least half-dead, he hadn’t had the chance to look down.

Now, with his fists buried in the bird’s feathers and holding on as tightly as he dared, it was all he could do to keep himself from peering past the wings that carried him and down to the ground far, far below.

Dwarves were not meant for the sky.

Fortunately, there were plenty of other things to worry about, and they kept him mostly distracted from the fear that came with being so high above the world.

He was continuously counting the rest of his companions, relieved every time he got to fourteen. They were all safe for now, assuming the eagles didn’t decide to drop them. As far as he could tell, they had all sustained minor cuts and bruises from the ordeal of traveling through the mountains and the fight on the cliff, but no one was seriously injured.

Or, almost no one.

Bilbo and Gandalf were both perched on an eagle ahead of him. He wasn’t at the right angle to see if their burglar was awake or not, but he knew Bilbo had been hit on the head hard enough to knock him out cold. He could only hope that was the worst of his injuries.

The memory of Bilbo charging across the clearing with sword and shield in hand was still fresh on his mind. It was an image he wasn’t sure he could ever forget. Thorin would have been in awe of the sight if not for the pure terror that had spiked through him, knowing that his One was on the ground and in reach of any orc or warg who may have a mind to go after him.

Luckily, he had done his job at keeping the horde distracted, and none of them seemed to notice the hobbit.

That is, none of them noticed until said hobbit slammed into an orc like a battering ram and sunk his blade hilt-deep into its back.

The orc released its arrow at the impact, but its aim was thrown off and the arrow left a deep graze across Thorin’s arm. Just a few inches to the side and it would have gone straight through his heart.

The orc let out a dying scream then collapsed dead to the ground, knocking Bilbo off balance on its way down.

After that, the hobbit had everyone’s attention.

A moment seemed to pass in utter silence as the orcs turned to face him, then all at once the frenzy began again with new fervor.

They rushed at Bilbo and Thorin cried out, sure his friend was about to die, but then another cry rose into the night and Dwalin—axes drawn and roaring—hurtled past Bilbo and met the orcs head on, several other dwarves hot on his heels.

Thorin was frozen to the spot for a few seconds, unable to make himself move. Then he saw an orc manage to slip past the Company and head straight for the hobbit who was just barely wrenching his sword free from the corpse at his feet. Any and all thoughts of keeping the orcs distracted until the eagles arrived left Thorin’s mind and he was out of the tree and launching himself into the fray. Azog forgotten, he focused on fighting his way toward his friends. He arrived just in time to see Bilbo get hit and he sprinted forward to take out the orc that had its club raised and ready to deliver a killing blow.

It wasn’t long after that they were being picked up and flown out of the fire and away from the cliff.

The last thing Thorin saw as he was being whisked away to safety was the Pale Orc, still seated on his mount and fire glowing in his dark eyes, sharp teeth bared in a garish smile.

 

***

 

It was a relief when Thorin finally slid off the eagle’s back and planted his boots on solid ground once again, but the feeling was short lived.

Already, his companions were gathering into a tight group on top of the Carrock, avoiding the steep edges as best they could.

He caught a flash of golden hair and Thorin strode closer, shouldering his way past people.

As soon as his hand was on Fili’s shoulder, his sister-son turned to him, green eyes lighting up and a bright grin crossing his face.

“Were you hurt?” Thorin asked anxiously, scanning him from head to toe, looking for any injuries. The braids of his mustache were unraveling and his face was covered in dirt and soot, but otherwise he seemed alright.

“We’re fine, Uncle. You don’t need to worry so much.”

Kili appeared at his elbow then, with a smile wide enough to match his brother’s. “We were afraid you’d gotten lost again. It took you long enough to—”

Thorin pulled them both into a hug, cutting off Kili’s rambling. “I am glad you are both safe,” he said, voice muffled by Fili’s hair.

His sister-sons both returned his embrace. When they pulled away, Kili’s eyes fixed on something over Thorin’s shoulder, and his expression turned anxious.

“Is Bilbo okay?”

Turning on his heel, Thorin saw that the wizard and the hobbit had landed, and the last of the eagles was flying away.

Gandalf had a steadying hand planted on Bilbo’s shoulder, but the hobbit still swayed on his feet, his face pale beneath the blood and his eyes looking dazed. He still held Thorin’s shield, hugging the oak branch tightly to his chest as though he was afraid to let it go.

Immediately, Thorin headed toward them, ignoring the greetings and questions that followed in his wake.

When he stopped in front of them, it took a few moments for the teetering hobbit to even notice he was there. Then Bilbo looked up at him, blinking several times, his pupils dilated and face confused.

“Thorin?” His voice was soft and almost hopeful.

He opened his mouth, but before he could get so much as a word out, Bilbo’s eyes shut and he crumpled. Thorin barely managed to catch the hobbit before he hit the ground and he sent Gandalf a desperate look. “Can you not do something?”

It came out sharper than he meant it to, but at the moment he couldn’t bring himself to care if he was being rude. When Thorin had been the one unconscious and injured atop the Carrock, the wizard was able to help him, so why was he doing nothing for Bilbo?

Gandalf didn’t seem to notice Thorin’s tone. That, or he didn’t care. He was looking at Bilbo with an unreadable look in his old eyes, his lips pursed tightly together.

Eventually, he shook his head. “Bilbo will be alright. I suspect he has a concussion. He needs to rest.”

Thorin forced himself not to bristle at the response, and he instead glanced over at the rest of his Company. Several of them were pointing at Erebor in the distance and talking excitedly. Others were sitting on the ground looking appropriately haggard, given the circumstances. Fili and Kili were watching him and whispering to each other, mischief written clearly across their faces.

Exasperated, he looked away from them and shifted his grip on Bilbo, who seemed to only be partially conscious and was mumbling incoherently under his breath.

Gandalf was right. He needed to rest.

They all needed to rest.

 

***

 

After a two hour climb down the steep stairs carved into the face of the Carrock and a very long nap that lasted well past noon, Thorin was standing in the shallows of the river, doing his best to scrub all the grime from his skin. As he washed himself, he half listened to Kili and Fili as they gave an animated account of their escape from the goblin tunnels, with other members of the Company chiming in every few moments to add their own details to the tale.

Most of them had made their way to the river after they’d slept off the exhaustion from their most recent exploits, and they all seemed to be in much better spirits than they were that morning.

Thorin was grateful for the small reprieve from the chaos of the past several days. Even more so, he was grateful that this ragtag family of his had cause to be cheerful. After all, they had made it out of the Misty Mountains alive and relatively unharmed, and they'd just gotten their first glimpse of the homeland they were on their way to reclaim. Erebor was still a long ways off, granted, but the fact that they had made it this far was a victory in its own right.

At least, that was how he himself had felt the first time he stood atop the Carrock and gazed into what he believed would be a prosperous future for himself and his people.

Instead, it ended in only ruin and death.

This time around, he wasn't nearly as entranced by the sight of his home off in the distance.

There were more important things on his mind.

Like whether he wanted to kiss the hobbit for once again saving his life, or throttle him for throwing himself into danger as Thorin had expressly told him not to.

Seeing as Bilbo passed out before he could decide between the two, the decision was still up in the air.

With that thought in mind, Thorin waded out of the water and retrieved his shirt. It was still somewhat damp from when he had washed it out earlier, but he pulled in on anyway, wincing when the movement sent a twinge through his arm. The slice across his bicep was hardly anything to worry about—it likely wouldn’t even scar—but it still stung.

He glanced to the group of dwarves in the water while he dressed, making sure that his sister-sons were still too preoccupied with their story to stick their boots into his business, then he turned away from the river and headed for camp.

It took him all of three minutes to make it back to the spot where they had all collectively agreed to stay the night. With most of the Company still bathing, camp was nearly empty.

Bombur was there, having stayed behind to start putting together some kind of supper and take stock of whatever meager supplies they had left. Ori volunteered to help him—probably with the intent of getting some space from Dori, who had been practically hanging over him since that morning—but the small pile of packs he was meant to be sorting through were abandoned and the young dwarf was sitting cross-legged on the ground several paces away, chatting quietly with Dwalin of all people.

Odd, but Thorin brushed it off and continued to walk across the clearing.

He passed Gandalf, who was leaning back against a boulder with his long legs stretched out in front of him, hands clasped over his chest, and his hat pulled down low over his face. Even wizards got tired, it seemed.

Finally, he came to a stop before Bilbo.

The hobbit sat alone on a half-rotted log with Gloin’s cloak draped over his shoulders, puffing smoke from Balin’s pipe. When he looked up at Thorin, his eyes were clear. And though there was still a nasty knot on his temple, he was far more aware now than he’d been earlier that morning.

Bilbo gave him a tight smile. “Have a nice bath, then?”

Thorin scowled and dropped down onto the log, holding out his hand.

Wordlessly, Bilbo passed him the pipe.

They sat that way for several minutes, neither of them saying a word until the silence eventually became too much for Thorin to handle.

“What were you doing?” he asked, voice low, and glanced over at Bilbo.

The hobbit raised a brow at him and shook his head. “What was I doing when?”

Thorin was in no mood to let his friend play at being oblivious. His voice was a harsh whisper when he spoke. “I expressly told you not to throw yourself between me and danger.”

Bilbo snorted and looked away again. “First of all, you told me not to throw myself between you and Azog. You never said anything about other orcs.” He opened his mouth to reply, but the hobbit plowed on, as though he’d been rehearsing this argument all day. “Secondly, I have no interest in being bossed around by you.”

“Bilbo, you could have been killed.”

“What was I supposed to do, stand there and do nothing while you got shot?”

“Yes.”

Thorin became keenly aware of the fact that they had both raised their voices. He didn’t have to look to know that the others in camp were watching them.

Grinding his teeth together, Thorin stood abruptly and turned away.

Before he could take so much as a step, his wrist was caught in a tight grip. When he looked back at Bilbo again, his hazel eyes were alight with anger.

“If I have to stand between you and every danger from here to Erebor to keep you alive, I will. I refuse to watch you die, Thorin.”

The words hit him like a punch to the gut and he drew in a sharp breath.

When Bilbo let go of his wrist, he turned and walked away.

 

***

 

Hours later, when the sun had finally gone down and evening turned to night, Thorin found himself sitting alone in a stand of trees just outside of camp. He’d been there long enough that the rest of the Company had returned from the river—he could hear them talking, though they were quieter than they had been during the day. His body was stiff from sitting still for so long, but he wasn’t in the right state of mind to care all that much.

All he cared about at the moment were the words Bilbo had spoken to him earlier.

I refuse to watch you die.

He ran the sentence through his mind over and over again until it became something of a mantra and no matter how hard he tried, he couldn’t get it to stop. He’d avoided thinking about his death ever since he woke up in that little room in Bree, telling himself there were far more important things to worry about. Deep down, though, he knew the real reason he avoided it was because he was afraid.

Because every time he thought about it, he found himself back on Ravenhill, bleeding out on the ice, a crying hobbit hovering over him.

He was there now.

And for the first time, he wondered if Bilbo ever found himself there, too.

I refuse to watch you die.

Thorin no longer had any doubts about whether or not the hobbit had been sent back in time as well. In his heart, he knew he was right. And he knew that the word ‘again’ was left unspoken at the end of Bilbo’s declaration from earlier.

He had already seen Thorin die once. What else had the hobbit seen? Because Thorin noticed the haunted look in his friend’s eyes whenever he thought no one was looking—noticed the way he watched the Company, like he was surrounded by ghosts—he just hadn’t understood why until now.

A shudder passed down Thorin’s spine and he shook his head, as if the motion might somehow clear his thoughts.

It didn’t, of course. This particular burden was a bit too heavy to simply let it slide off his shoulders in the same way he might slide off a coat.

But, then…

Maybe it wasn’t a burden he had to carry alone.

After hours of sitting still, Thorin finally found the strength he needed to stand.

 

***

 

It was surprisingly easy to convince Bilbo to leave the warmth of the fire and the rest of the Company’s chatter. Actually, Thorin didn't need to say anything at all. The moment he laid his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder, the hobbit took one look at him and got to his feet.

Thorin resolutely ignored the whispers and giggles of his sister-sons—as well as a few more of the Company—and together they wandered over to a shallow cleft in the stone base of the Carrock and sat down.

They were quiet for a few moments, but it didn’t last long.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit just hummed in response, idly playing with the frayed hem of his coat.

Finally, Thorin thought.

“How many times are you going to save me?” he asked.

Bilbo glanced at him, then quickly looked away again, shrugging. “You make it sound like it happens a lot.”

“Does it not? I can think of at least a dozen times off the top of my head.”

The hobbit snorted. “You’re exaggerating. I saved you from the trolls, then I saved you on the cliff. I suppose we could count Gollum, but I really don’t think he would have stood a chance against you.” As he spoke, he counted each instance off on his fingers. When he was finished, he held up his hand. “There, see? The heroics of Bilbo Baggins has saved the mighty King Under the Mountain a total of three times.”

Amused, Thorin shook his head and took Bilbo’s outstretched hand in his own.

He looked somewhat startled by the action, but Thorin ignored it and leaned closer. “You and I both know that isn’t true, bâhaê.”

Bilbo blinked, then opened his mouth and promptly closed it again, like he was suddenly unable to speak. He shifted nervously, eyes darting between Thorin’s face and their hands. It took him several moments to respond, and when he did, his voice was thin and weak. “I’m not quite sure I know what you mean.”

“I think you do.”

He shook his head, but Thorin didn’t miss it when the hobbit started trembling.

Thorin took a deep breath to steady himself, then softly asked, “did you plant your trees, Bilbo?”

Notes:

bâhaê - my friend

Chapter 16: Old Friends

Summary:

Bilbo learns that he isn't as alone as he's believed himself to be, and the Company heads for the house of Beorn.

Notes:

Greetings, friends! I pounded out the majority of this chapter today in an attempt to escape the harrowing darkness of depression. It didn't work. However, you get an update, so at least something good came out of this shitty day.

There is no proofreading here, we die like dwarves with far too much pride and a reckless amount of hubris.

Buckle up because things are HAPPENING and our dear Bilbo is truly getting into the thick of it now.

Chapter Text

“Did you plant your trees, Bilbo?”

He gaped at the dwarf, thoughts spinning through his head like a windstorm. The question was an echo of words that were spoken to him once, a very long time ago. Still, it was a memory so vivid, he could almost feel the hard ice under his knees and the warm blood on his hands. He’d never been able to forget the feeling of it. Nor had he forgotten the final words his best friend ever said to him, no matter how much it hurt to remember.

This wasn’t possible.

Then again, nothing that happened over the past several months should have been possible. He was supposed to be in Valinor with Frodo, not here, reliving this adventure. The dwarf in front of him was supposed to be dead, for Yavanna’s sake! Yet here they both were, alive and well. Those blue eyes Bilbo had long yearned to see again were staring down at him, and they were far more knowing than they should be.

You are not alone.

Was this what Lady Galadriel had meant that day in Rivendell?

Bilbo buried his face in his hands.

Wizards, elves, whatever that Bombadil creature in the Old Forest was—why did immortals always have to be so gods-damned cryptic? Would it kill them to speak plainly for once in their incredibly too long lives? He enjoyed a good riddle, but there was a time and place for those things. And that time was certainly not several decades into his past, in the middle of a dangerous quest, when the leader of his Company was apparently...

He took a few steadying breaths that really didn’t do much to calm his pounding heart, then slowly lowered his hands and looked at the dwarf sitting before him.

“Thorin?”

Any small bit of uncertainty in the dwarf’s expression up until that point melted away and Thorin gave him one of those bright smiles that made his whole face light up, and his voice was soft when he spoke. “Hello, Bilbo.”

He stared. He hadn't seen that smile since…

Well, since…

Really it didn’t matter how long it had been. A very long time, to say the least. Long enough that Bilbo had told himself he was over that smile and all the complicated feelings that came with it—and by the time he was old, he almost believed it.

The past was in the past, after all, and it was far too late to do anything with those feelings in any case.

Of course, that was until he woke up one fateful morning to find that the past was once again his present and there were dwarves on his doorstep.

Ever since then, he'd been telling himself that it didn’t matter if his heart skipped a beat every time he looked at a certain dwarf king because while the dwarf certainly was Thorin, it wasn’t his Thorin.

Not to say that Thorin had ever actually been his, of course, but—

Well, that was beside the point. The simple fact of the matter was that the dwarf Bilbo had fallen for all those years ago was dead. This Thorin didn’t have any memory of their friendship or the dangers they went through together, and that was the end of it. So, Bilbo had taken all those lingering feelings and shoved them down deep and decided that his focus had to be on keeping this Thorin alive. Anything he might have felt for the dwarf in the past didn’t matter.

But now…

Throughout his life, Bilbo came up with countless scenarios, imagining what he might do if he ever came face to face with Thorin Oakenshield again. He imagined yelling at the dwarf for his recklessness. Sometimes he thought he would pull the dwarf into a hug and never let him go again. There were a few times, when he was particularly upset, he pictured himself slapping Thorin across his stupid, beautiful face. But out of all the hundreds of daydreams Bilbo came up with over the years, he never once thought he would laugh.

It started out as a small giggle—a high pitched, nervous sound. It quickly grew into a chuckle, then an all out laughing fit that had him gasping for breath, his whole body shaking.

“What is so funny?” The look of complete bafflement on Thorin’s face only made him laugh harder.

He couldn’t help himself.

Clutching at his stomach, Bilbo wheezed and shook his head. There were tears streaming down his face.

Maybe all the pent up frustration and anxiety from the past few months were finally rising to the surface, or maybe it was just the sheer absurdity of the situation.

“I am far too old for this nonsense.” The words came out in heavy gasps, and Bilbo couldn’t say anything else after.

Thorin looked even more confused than before and he shook his head, but that smile was coming back—and wasn’t that a lovely sight?

Bilbo stopped and blinked a few times, caught off guard by the thought. Then he started laughing again.

Oh. He was in so much trouble.

 

***

 

The entire Company probably would have benefitted from another day of rest there at the base of the Carrock, but by dawn the next morning everyone was awake and packing up whatever meager supplies they had left, getting ready to move on. It hadn’t been outright decided that they would be setting out soon, but they all seemed to be in silent agreement. Azog was tracking them, and though their flight on the eagles would have done much to hide their trail, it was only a matter of time before the orcs caught their scent once again. Nobody wanted to stick around to find out exactly how long it would take for that to happen.

Wrapped in a thin blanket to fight off the early morning chill, Bilbo headed across camp to where Thorin, Bombur, and Balin were quietly speaking. He stood a few feet back, not wanting to interrupt their conversation—Bombur had decided they only had enough food for three days if they rationed it right. Not ideal, but Bilbo knew their supplies would be refilled soon enough, as long as they managed to get on Beorn’s good side again, so he wasn’t too concerned.

There was something more pressing on his mind, in any case.

The moment the three dwarves were finished, Bilbo hurried over to Thorin and caught his sleeve just as he took his first step towards his two nephews.

Thorin paused and turned, his eyes lighting up the moment they settled on Bilbo. Then the light was gone, replaced by worry. “What is it? Are you alright?” he asked, looking him up and down as if expecting him to be injured.

Ignoring the urge to roll his eyes at the unnecessary concern, Bilbo shook his head. “I’m fine. But before we leave, we should talk to Gandalf.”

“The wizard?” Thorin’s gaze flickered over to the spot where the old man was perched on a rock, pipe in hand. “Why?”

“Because apparently I’m not the only person reliving this journey, and I think the wizard needs to be made aware of the most recent development in the situation.”

The dwarf scowled. “I do not like the idea of others being aware of the situation, as you say. The less people who know, the better.”

This time, Bilbo did roll his eyes. “Well, like it or not, Gandalf has known about me since the beginning. And, after our stop at Rivendell, so does the rest of the White Council. I’m not going to suddenly leave him in the dark just because of your silly trust issues.”

Thorin’s wince was almost imperceptible, but Bilbo noticed. Before he could say anything about it, though, Thorin gave a terse nod.

“Fine, if this is what you think is best. But make it quick. I am anxious to leave this place.”

With that, Thorin started off towards Gandalf, not waiting for a response. Surprised, Bilbo just stared after him for a moment. He had honestly expected a bit more argument over the matter. Shaking his head, Bilbo hurried to follow.

When they reached the wizard, Bilbo almost wondered if he hadn’t noticed they were there, as his focus remained locked on his pipe. After a moment, though, he blew out a smoke ring then looked up at them. His gaze went over Thorin once before he turned to Bilbo, studying him.

“How is your head?”

“Fine, thank you.” Bilbo waved off the question and went on. “There’s something more important we need to speak with you about.”

Gandalf raised a bushy brow. “Oh?”

Turning to Thorin, Bilbo gave him a look, but the dwarf looked thoroughly unmoved by it and didn’t seem at all inclined to be the one to start this conversation. So, stifling an exasperated sigh, he looked back to Gandalf.

“Our esteemed Master Oakenshield has brought it to my attention that I am not, in fact, the only person present who has more knowledge than I should about future events.” He said the last few words a bit more quietly than the rest, not wanting to risk anyone else from the Company hearing him and asking questions.

To anyone who didn’t know Gandalf well, it would seem like the wizard was entirely unfazed by what he had just been told. Bilbo, however, noticed the way his old friend paused in the middle of puffing on his pipe and how his eyes widened ever so slightly.

Gandalf studied Thorin for a moment, as if expecting the dwarf to somehow deny what Bilbo had just said. Thorin only scowled back at him in response.

“Interesting,” Gandalf said eventually.

“Interesting? Is that all you have to say about this?” Thorin growled, then immediately went quiet again when he caught a well aimed jab of an elbow to his ribs.

Ignoring the dwarf’s small sound of indignance, Bilbo kept his attention on Gandalf. “Please tell me you’ve got some idea what’s going on here. I know the Council wasn’t able to come to any kind of conclusions, but I need something to go on.”

Gandalf was already shaking his head before Bilbo even finished. “I have no more idea of why this is happening than you do, my friend. I do not understand how you were sent back or for what purpose. And I am not sure—”

“Actually, I may be able to help with that.”

Blinking, Bilbo turned to Thorin, who looked as if he had just bitten into something sour. “What do you mean?”

“I mean, while I cannot say how you ended up here, Bilbo, I—” Thorin paused and glanced around for a moment before stepping closer to them both and lowering his voice. “I am here by choice. After my death, I was granted the opportunity by the Maker to return and fix my mistakes.”

Bilbo choked at the words, and even Gandalf’s surprise was plain.

“You spoke to Aulë?” the wizard asked.

Thorin glared. “I spoke to Mahal, and he gave me a choice. Accept my death and join my loved ones in the Halls, or come back and ensure that the line of Durin does not fail.”

His mind racing, Bilbo suddenly felt a spark of hope. Ever since that day all those months ago when he woke up in Bag End to find himself in the past, he had no idea why he was here, but he had made the decision and given himself one purpose—relive the quest, retake Erebor, and make sure that this time, all of his friends lived to see their home thrive once again. That was his promise, to himself and all of them.

They would live.

Of course, there was always that nagging thought in the back of his mind that he might fail. That it might be impossible to save Fili and Kili and Thorin from their fates, and he would be forced to relive the pain of losing them once again.

But if what Thorin was saying now was true…

Maybe there was a chance that he could succeed. Maybe he truly could fix things before they ever got the chance to break.

And if one of the Valar believed it could be done, surely that had to count for something.

Bilbo couldn’t help the grin that slowly began to form on his face.

When he came back out of his own thoughts, it was to find that both his friends were staring at him—Thorin, with a strange look in his eyes.

He didn’t care how silly he probably seemed in that moment. Bouncing on his toes, Bilbo nodded once. “Right, then. Let’s get this show on the road, shall we?”

At the words, Gandalf stood up from his place on the rock and tucked his pipe away. “I think that would be wise, but we should return to this conversation later. We have much to discuss.”

“Agreed. But for now, we head for the home of Master Beorn.” Bilbo paused and glanced at Thorin, but the dwarf just nodded in agreement, so he looked back to Gandalf. “I assume you can lead us there?”

“Beorn? You mean the skin-changer?”

Thorin snorted at the response, but they both ignored it.

“Yes, yes. Who else would I mean? Can you get us there or not?” Bilbo asked.

“I can,” Gandalf said, putting on his hat and grabbing his staff. “But I should warn you, he is not overly fond of dwarves.”

Standing at his full height, Bilbo looked the wizard directly in the eye. “Leave that to me.”

 

***

 

It took four days to reach their destination. The first three went peacefully, with a surprising absence of the orcs that were sure to be tracking them. The Company was in good cheer and Bilbo had begun to think that maybe they could avoid an altercation altogether.

Of course, his hope had come a bit too soon.

It was mid-morning of the fourth day, when they made a brief stop at a stream to refill their water, that they heard the first warg howl. With everyone much more alert now than they’d been before, they picked up the pace.

Bilbo, Gandalf, and Thorin were the only ones who knew they were headed straight for the lands of a creature just as dangerous as the ones that lay behind—more so, maybe, since even Azog wouldn’t dare cross the borders of Beorn’s territory. Still, when the Company began to murmur among themselves with the worry that there was no shelter to hide them now since leaving the mountains behind them for open fields, Gandalf mentioned that there was a house ahead where they might take refuge. It helped their spirits somewhat, but it didn’t last long.

Astride their snarling warg mounts, the orcs seemingly appeared from nowhere, and were far too close for the Company to attempt outrunning them.

Cursing, Bilbo drew his sword alongside the dwarves, and turned to face the oncoming attack.

The first warg was taken out by Kili’s arrow and crushed its rider beneath it when it fell. The second was shot through the chest and stumbled, but the orc riding it managed to escape unharmed and it reached them on foot, brandishing its crude blade and screeching.

It was immediately dispatched by a swing of Dwalin’s axe, but then the rest of the orc pack crashed over them and they were fighting for their lives.

Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur all seemed to take it upon themselves to protect him and surrounded him the moment the first orc fell, and Bilbo didn’t have time to complain that they were coddling him. Not that it mattered much. The onslaught was too heavy to keep him entirely shielded from the fight, despite their best efforts, and Bilbo found himself protecting his dwarves just as much as they were protecting him.

An orc that lunged for Bombur was knocked away by a great swing of Bofur’s mattock, just as Bombur killed one with its eyes set on Bifur, who was holding his own with his boar spear, impaling adversaries left and right and leaving them dead on the ground at his feet. When an orc lifted a curved blade aiming for Bofur’s back, Bilbo didn’t hesitate to step in before its stroke fell, using Sting to slash at its legs and ending it with a quick stab to the chest when it fell to its knees.

It went on for several minutes, the four of them fighting in tandem and watching each other’s backs. There was too much chaos for Bilbo to really take stock of what was happening, but the voices of the Company rang out over the sounds of the battle, and he had to take that as reassurance that they were okay.

The noise was nearly deafening—metal crashing against metal, howls and shrieks, and battle cries that echoed from orc and dwarf alike.

Then, a roar like thunder rose over the field, and as if time itself had come to a standstill, everything stopped.

Silence lasted for about three seconds and suddenly the orcs were screaming out in that horrible language of theirs and pulling back, their fight with the dwarves suddenly forgotten. They practically scrambled to retreat, racing for wargs to ride, pushing and shoving each other out of the way in their haste.

Then the crowd parted enough for Bilbo to see through the mass of bodies, and he understood why.

Some huge beast was barreling across the field, heading straight for the fight, its roars so loud the ground shook beneath his feet.

Beorn.

In the distraction, Thorin called the Company to him and they all hurried to fall back. When they reached him, Bilbo allowed himself a short moment of relief to see that Thorin seemed to be unharmed, as did Fili and Kili.

Gandalf appeared, disheveled and panting, his hat sitting lopsided on his head. “Don’t just stand here, you fools! This way! Quickly!”

And then they were running, trampling their way through a field of purple and white wildflowers, headed for a stand of trees off in the distance.

To their luck, the bear had its sights set on the orcs that were attempting to retreat, and either he hadn’t spotted the dwarves or he was too preoccupied at the moment to concern himself with them. Either way, it gave them the chance they needed to get away.

As Beorn fought off the wargs and orcs, the Company only moved faster when they caught sight of the large house sitting in the shade of a stand of huge oak trees. Sprinting past beehives and grazing sheep, they burst into the yard at full speed and didn’t stop until they were inside with the door shut and barred behind them.

For a minute, they all just stood there and tried to regain their breath and listened to the distant roars of the bear.

Ori was the first to speak. “What is that?!”

At the question, everyone turned to look at Gandalf. The wizard met their gazes, unwavering. “That is our host. His name is Beorn. He’s a skin-changer.”

He didn’t say anything more, probably still too breathless to really launch into an explanation. The dwarves stared at him for about three seconds before they erupted all at once, shouting over each other so much that their words were practically indiscernible.

Bilbo and Thorin stood at the edge of the group, the only two not joining the argument. Bilbo kept his eye on Gandalf, watching as the wizard slowly got more and more annoyed, the air around him beginning to darken.

It was Thorin, however, who put a stop to it.

“Enough!” The Company fell silent, turning to look at him. “There is no point in arguing. We stay here for the night and hope that our host is in a more agreeable mood in the morning. We cannot go back out there now, and that is the end of it.”

After that, there were no more complaints greater than some disgruntled mumbles, and the Company dispersed to settle down and take stock of their wounds.

“Are you hurt?”

Bilbo turned to Thorin and shook his head. “I think the running was worse than the actual fight. I’m sure I’ll be stiff and sore in the morning. You?”

The corner of Thorin’s mouth quirked up at the comment. “I am well.” As he said it, he glanced over to where his nephews were standing across the room.

“You should check on them,” Bilbo said, nodding at the two young dwarves. “We’ll talk more later.”

Thorin seemed to hesitate for a moment, but then he patted Bilbo’s shoulder and stepped away.

Bilbo watched him go, then went to find an empty corner where he could sit in a pile of comfy hay and get off his aching feet.

 

***

 

Late that night, when the Company finally settled in and the house was filled with the sound of snoring dwarves, Bilbo couldn’t sleep.

He laid in his pile of hay, wide awake and staring at the ceiling above him, tracing the rafters with his eyes and desperately trying to think of something—anything—to distract himself from the weight of the object currently sitting in his pocket. Such a small thing, yet he could still feel it there. Could feel it caressing the back of his mind, like a cat rubbing up against a person’s legs, begging for attention.

Up until now, it wasn't too much of a struggle to ignore it. Over the past four days, they had always been on the move, and he was focused on watching for signs of Azog’s hunting party catching up with them. He’d had plenty to occupy his mind, what with his newfound discovery concerning Thorin.

But they weren’t moving now.

Now, they were safe (relatively speaking, anyways) and he was finally getting the chance to think about other things. But he really didn’t want to.

Because this thing in his pocket was evil. He wanted nothing more than to throw it away in some deep, dark hole and never look at it again.

Before their confrontation with Gollum in the goblin tunnels, Bilbo hadn’t considered how difficult it might be to carry the Ring with the knowledge he now possessed. After many long years, he forgot how it felt to bear the weight of it. Now, with it back in his pocket, as if it had never left, he wondered how he could have ever forgotten. How he could have forgotten its whispers.

Eventually, it became too much for him to bear.

With a shaking hand, Bilbo carefully pulled the Ring from his pocket.

It sat in his palm, just a golden trinket, glinting in the dim light of the few candles lit around the house. Yet, for a trinket, it felt heavy as a mountain.

He stared at it, imagining he could see the glowing inscription around the band.

‘Hello, thief.’

Bilbo jolted and nearly dropped the Ring on the ground. Heart hammering, he looked around the room, looking for any sign that someone else had heard the soft whisper, like a hiss.

Nobody stirred.

Had he imagined it?

He looked back to the Ring, the hair at the nape of his neck standing on end.

‘I never thought to meet you again, Bilbo Baggins.’

“What?” Bilbo winced at the sound of his own voice in the quiet of the house, high pitched and shaking.

‘You are different than when I last saw you. Smarter. Younger.’

Bilbo closed his eyes and shook his head, like he might be able to banish the voice from his mind. Or it would somehow wake him up from a bad dream.

When he opened his eyes again, the Ring gleamed, and he had the horrible sensation that it knew he was afraid.

‘Have you missed me, old friend?’

Chapter 17: Honey Cakes and Memories

Summary:

The Company has reached Beorn's home and with the rare moment of peace, Thorin takes the chance to ask Bilbo some questions.

Notes:

Hi. I have nothing to say for myself in regards to how long it took me to write this chapter. But I would like to sincerely thank everyone who has left comments over the past several months. As always, the kind things you've all said are what motivated me to finally start writing again, and I appreciate it more than I can say.
Anyways, enjoy :)

Chapter Text

Thorin woke at dawn to someone shaking him. It was unusually difficult to drag himself to consciousness that morning, likely due to the softer sleeping arrangements. Still, after a few moments, he opened his eyes to see Bilbo hovering over him.

He jolted and sat up quickly, already reaching for his sword. “What is it? Is something wrong?”

“Oh, calm down, you silly dwarf.” Bilbo sat back on his haunches, looking exasperated. “Nothing’s wrong. It’s only that Beorn is outside, and I think the sooner that we introduce ourselves, the better.”

Relaxing a bit, he nodded. “You are right.”

“Of course I am. Now come on and help me wake the others.”

Amused, Thorin watched the hobbit move away and head towards where Bofur and Nori were sleeping, the former of the two snoring loudly and sprawled out so he was half on top of his partner. Then he stood and kicked Dwalin’s outstretched boot on his way to wake Kili and Fili, snickering when his friend snapped awake and hit Gloin in his struggle to get to his feet.

It wasn’t long before the whole Company was up and awake, yawning and grumbling irritably at being woken up so early on a day they weren’t actually running for their lives.

Granted, if their host wasn’t feeling very charitable, that might change soon enough.

Just like he said he would a few days ago at the Carrock, Bilbo was taking it upon himself to lead the introductions to Beorn, which was likely a good idea. If anyone could talk an angry skin-changer out of ripping them all to pieces, it was Bilbo. So Thorin had no issue with letting the hobbit—who was standing in front of them all with his hands on his hips, looking for all the world like a mother lecturing a group of unruly dwarflings—take charge for a while.

“Gandalf and I will go out first and talk to him, then I’ll wave for Thorin to join us. After that, you’ll come out in small groups at a time when, and only when, I wave for the next group. Balin will keep watch and send you out when I give the signal. Dori, Ori, and Nori will come out first. Then Oin and Gloin. Then Fili and Kili. Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur. Balin and Dwalin will be last. Any questions?”

Clearing his throat, Dori took a small step forward and spoke. “I have one. This is nothing against you of course, Master Baggins, but if he’s really so dangerous, would it not be better to let the wizard speak with this skin-changer first?”

“I was wondering the same thing, actually,” Gandalf piped up from where he stood at the back of the group.

Bilbo simply raised a brow. “If we were expecting a fight, we wouldn’t be going out there to speak with our host at all. As it is, this interaction is about making a good first impression, meaning we need a certain amount of tact and good manners.”

The old wizard actually looked offended at that and Thorin coughed, trying to mask his laugh, but Bilbo must have heard it because he spoke again.

“That’s also why we’re not sending Thorin out first.”

Several members of the Company didn’t even try to hide their laughter at that comment, a certain pair of princes being the loudest of the bunch, and Thorin scowled.

“Anyone else? No? Good.” Bilbo took a step towards the door, then paused and gave them all a stern look. “Remember what Gandalf said. Master Beorn isn’t overly fond of dwarves. Wait for my signal, and when you come out, introduce yourselves then keep quiet. Don’t crowd him. And definitely don’t draw your weapons.”

The hobbit let his gaze settle on a certain bald headed warrior.

“What’re you looking at me for?” Dwalin spluttered.

Bilbo didn’t respond and just headed for the door, catching Thorin’s eye as he passed and sending him a small wink.

Thorin couldn’t help but smile as he watched the hobbit disappear outside with Gandalf close behind.

 

***

 

The introductions to Beorn went fairly well in comparison to the first journey, and Beorn seemed to take a liking to Bilbo rather quickly, which likely helped keep him amiable even as thirteen dwarves began coming out of his house.

A few hours later, after recounting the tale of their journey so far to their host and eating their fill of the food that he provided, the Company had dispersed and were enjoying the rare instance of peace and safety. Many were snoring in the hay piles, catching up on lost sleep. Those who weren’t napping had found their own ways to entertain themselves, either sitting quietly inside or enjoying the nice weather.

And with the Company distracted, that meant Thorin finally had the chance to have a long awaited conversation with his burglar.

He found Bilbo sitting on a bench at the huge dining table, his feet kicking back and forth from where they dangled almost comically high above the floor. He was humming cheerfully to himself, all of his attention focused on the pile of honey cakes in front of him.

A warm feeling bloomed in Thorin’s chest at the sight, and for a moment he just stood there and watched. He shook himself out of it soon enough, though, and took another step closer. “Bilbo.”

The hobbit jumped slightly then turned, a smile lighting up his face a moment later. “Thorin.”

“I was hoping to speak with you for a while. That is, if you’re not busy.”

“Oh, not at all,” Bilbo said quickly. He turned and grabbed several of the honey cakes then hopped down from the bench and walked over to Thorin.

He led the way to the door, and they passed Fili and Kili on their way out. The moment his sister-sons saw them, they grinned and Kili leaned over to whisper something in his brother’s ear, making Fili snort out a laugh.

Thorin rolled his eyes and kept walking, then sighed after the two disappeared inside the house. “Those two.”

“They don’t mean any harm,” Bilbo pointed out. His voice held an affectionate tone, but there was something wistful to it as well. “I’m just happy to hear them laugh.”

Thorin just nodded in silent agreement, and neither of them said anything more as they turned towards the garden. They kept walking until the house was hidden by a row of trees and they found a secluded spot behind some rose bushes. Stopping at a patch of grass, Thorin sat down and patted the spot beside him, motioning for Bilbo to join him. The hobbit did so, dropping to sit crisscross on the ground, leaving a small space between the two of them.

Bilbo took a honey cake off the top of his pile and held it out to him. “What do you want to talk about?”

Pausing for a moment to gather his thoughts, Thorin took the offered cake, but didn’t take a bite out of it yet. Eventually, he said, “everything, but first, I want to apologize.”

“What for?”

“For the awful way I treated you when we finally reached Erebor.”

“Oh.” Bilbo’s smile fell and he stopped eating. “Thorin, that really isn’t necessary—”

He interrupted the hobbit before he could finish. “Please, Bilbo, let me get it off my chest. It has weighed heavily on me for the past few months.”

Bilbo sighed, then nodded. “Alright, then. Go on.”

Despite his eagerness to finally speak honestly, Thorin hesitated. One of his biggest regrets of the first journey was that he never had the chance to properly apologize to Bilbo—or any other members of the Company—for his actions after they retook the mountain. There was nothing he could ever do to make up for what he put them all through. All he could do now was make sure that it never happened again. That goal was what kept him from spiraling into his guilt. After all, any apology he tried to make now would only create more questions that he had no way of answering. At least, that was what he had thought up until that moment in Rivendell all those weeks ago, when he realized that there may be one person who would understand. But now that he had his chance, what could he possibly say to make it right? No apology could erase past hurts. Still, he had to try.

“In my madness, I could think of nothing but the Arkenstone. I let it cloud my judgement. Let it taint my trust in the people I love most. My own family. Somehow, I believed that you were all conspiring to keep it from me. And then that day at the gate...it was like my worst fears had come true. I said such hateful things to you. I can hardly bear to think about it now.” He paused, grimacing. None of it was coming out the way he wanted it to.

Bilbo had listened to him ramble patiently, but spoke up before Thorin could make another attempt at saying what was on his mind. “You were sick, Thorin. And you were hardly the only one at fault for what happened that day. I did betray you. I gave the Arkenstone to Thranduil of all people. Your anger wasn’t entirely undeserved.”

“You did not deserve any part of what I did to you.” It came out sharper than he meant them to, and he winced, then softened his tone. “You were only doing what you thought was best. And gold sickness or no, I still did it. I know I hurt you, and for that I am deeply sorry.”

For several long moments, Bilbo didn’t say anything, and the look on his face was unreadable, though there was an undeniable sadness in his hazel eyes. Thorin held the hobbit’s gaze for as long as he could, then looked down to his lap and stared at the honey cake still in his hands.

“I forgive you. I have forgiven you, Thorin.” Bilbo said it with no amount of uncertainty.

It was as though the words lifted a weight from his chest, and Thorin drew in a deep breath. Still, he couldn’t stop himself from questioning the response. “After everything, you forgive me just like that? That easily?”

“Believe me, it was anything but easy.” Bilbo sighed tiredly. “I may not look it, but I am old, Thorin. For me, these things happened a very long time ago. And I’ve had a very long time to make peace with it.”

“How long?”

“Around eighty years, give or take a few. I started to lose count near the end.” Something in the hobbit’s tone changed and he chuckled a bit.

Thorin didn’t laugh. Instead, it felt like the breath was knocked out of him and he looked up again so quickly it almost hurt his neck. “Eighty years.”

Bilbo shot him a smile and puffed up slightly, something like pride crossing his face. “You are looking at the longest lived hobbit in history. I suppose I cheated, though. I never would have lasted as long as I did if not for…”

He trailed off slowly, a far away look appearing in his eyes, and one of his hands moved to hover over his jacket pocket.

“Bilbo?”

He snapped back to the present and immediately took his hand away from his jacket, instead grabbing one of his honey cakes and jamming half of it into his mouth. He chewed for several seconds then swallowed and cleared his throat before speaking again, not quite meeting Thorin’s gaze. “Anyways, the point is, I forgave you a long time ago, so there’s no point in you holding onto all that guilt. It’s all in the past.”

Before he could reply, Bilbo started eating again, and Thorin sighed before taking a bite of his own cake.

They sat in silence for several minutes and Thorin took the time to sort through his thoughts. It was a relief to have finally apologized, though he knew he wouldn’t be able to completely let go of the guilt for a long time to come, no matter what Bilbo said. Even more relieving was the fact that Bilbo had apparently lived a very long life. Over the past few days, he found a part of himself beginning to worry that something terrible may have happened to the hobbit in order for him to be sent back in time as well, seeing as Thorin’s second journey was a result of his own untimely death. He wasn’t sure he could bear it if it turned out that Bilbo had died soon after him and didn’t end up surviving the quest after all.

Granted, that raised the question of what did happen after he died there on Ravenhill. If eighty years had truly gone by, then that meant Bilbo was starting over a much larger part of his life than this quest alone.

As if the hobbit could read his thoughts, he finally spoke again. “What else were you wanting to talk about, then?”

“I would like to know what happened after my death.”

He didn’t miss the way that Bilbo flinched at the words, but his reply came out jokingly, if not a bit tense. “You really are going straight for the fun topics, aren’t you?”

Thorin did say anything, just giving him an expectant look.

Bilbo sighed and finished off his honey cake, then looked up at the sky.

“Very well. After you…” his voice shook and he paused for a moment before going on. “A couple days after the battle, we had the funeral and then Dain was crowned king.”

Thorin nodded, having already known about Dain becoming king. “And the rest of the Company? I know about Fili and Kili,” he swallowed thickly before finishing his question. “But did the others make it?”

“Yes. There were some injuries, but everyone else lived.”

He felt himself relax at the news and found himself silently thanking Mahal for it. After a moment, he returned his attention back to Bilbo. “And you?”

“Gandalf and I left the next morning, and we reached the Shire by late spring.”

It was comforting, really, to know that despite all the danger that he dragged the hobbit into, he still went on to live a long life. He made it back to his home, with his armchair and his books and his garden, and had hopefully never been dragged onto any more dangerous adventures.

“I am glad,” he said quietly. He could have left it at that. Should have, really. But a small thought in the back of his mind sparked his curiosity and he spoke again before he could stop himself. “And what of your life after you made it home? Were you happy? Did you...ever marry?”

He regretted the words the moment they came out of his mouth and he winced, silently cursing himself. Why would ask such a stupid question?

Bilbo stilled, and gave him an odd look. Then, after several seconds, he shook his head. “No, I never married. I couldn’t bring myself to consider it after… Well, at any rate, it didn’t matter at all. No hobbit would have wanted to marry old Mad Baggins anyways.” The statement left them in an uncomfortable silence as Thorin pondered what that could have meant, but Bilbo perked up after a moment. “I wasn’t alone the whole time, of course. Eventually I had Frodo to keep me company.”

“Frodo?” Thorin asked, glad for the change of subject.

“Yes, my nephew. Well, I say nephew, but really he’s my cousin. The boy always insisted on calling me his uncle though, and I gave up on correcting him after a while.” Bilbo grinned, shaking his head a bit. “I adopted him after his parents drowned in a boating accident. Sad business, that was, but I have to say I was ever so grateful to have him. Bag End was beginning to get a bit too quiet for me to handle, and he brought a bit of life into the place. I often found myself thinking he and his friends would get on with Kili and Fili quite well.”

And just like that, whatever discomfort lingering between them melted away. Bilbo started rambling about his life, and Thorin found that he was quite content to sit back and listen.

Hearing that the hobbit returned home at the end of his journey to find his belongings all being auctioned off irritated Thorin immensely, but Bilbo just shook his head when he recalled the memory, seeming mildly amused. The more he talked, the more Thorin found himself disliking the other inhabitants of the Shire. From what he could understand, the hobbits all treated Bilbo as an outcast upon his return from his adventure, calling him mad and whispering about him behind his back. Apparently, he lost all respectability in the eyes of his kin, and he never really managed to regain it all.

At one point, Thorin interrupted to point out that Bilbo had saved all of the Company’s lives multiple times and should have been regarded as a hero. Bilbo just laughed in response and shook his head, saying that his so-called “heroics” were only more reason for his family and neighbors to look down on him.

“They didn’t quite like hearing that I’d gone up against trolls and orcs and dragons. A lot of people were convinced that I simply wandered off and gotten myself lost somewhere for a year and ended up eating too many hallucinogenic mushrooms.” Bilbo chuckled, somehow amused by the idea, then went on. “The children all seemed to enjoy my tales, though. When we had parties I’d end up surrounded by nearly every fauntling in Hobbiton, all begging for me to tell them another story.”

He brightened at whatever new memory that brought up and grinned. “Speaking of parties, the best was by far my hundred and eleventieth birthday. It was like a festival. Half the Shire showed up, and Gandalf brought fireworks, and there was music and dancing. And I gave a speech long enough to rival one of yours, Thorin!”

At that, Thorin jolted and half sat up from where he had lain back on the grass, letting out a sound of protest and ready to argue that his speeches weren’t that long, but Bilbo just laughed and kept talking.

“Though, I think my speech was far more entertaining than any of yours. I insulted all of my relatives. You should have seen their faces! Then I snuck away and left the party in chaos and by the time I made it back to Bag End, Bofur, Nori, and Bifur were all there waiting for me. They were traveling back to Erebor from Ered Luin, you see, and I intended to go with them. I was getting so bored in the Shire, and I wanted to go on another adventure.” Bilbo’s voice turned a bit sad, then, but there was still a soft smile on his face as he spoke. “I only made it as far as Rivendell before I realized my legs were too old to carry me through the Misty Mountains. I was so disappointed. I never did get to see Erebor again.”

Frowning, Thorin rolled onto his side and propped his head up to look at the hobbit. “Did you turn back, then?”

“No. I ended up staying with the elves for a fair amount of time. It gave me the chance to finish writing my— Oh don’t make that face, Thorin Oakenshield, I quite enjoyed my time in Rivendell and Elrond was a good friend of mine by then.”

Thorin hadn’t even realized he’d grimaced at the mention of Bilbo living with the elves. Huffing, he muttered out an apology, and couldn’t help but return the hobbit’s smile a moment later. He opened his mouth to speak, but didn’t get the chance.

Bilbo’s gaze slid up to the sky and he blinked. “Why did you let me go on for so long?”

Glancing to where Bilbo was looking, Thorin saw that the sun was just beginning to set behind the Misty Mountains. He blinked, too, not having noticed just how long they’d been sitting there together.

He sat up and stretched, getting a satisfying crack from his spine, then got to his feet. “I liked listening,” he said, then held out a hand to help Bilbo up. “Besides, we had nothing more important to be doing.”

Bilbo smiled at him. “I suppose you’re right. Shall we head back to the house? I believe we should be having supper soon.”

Thorin nearly agreed with the suggestion, but stopped when he caught movement from the corner of his eye. It was barely noticeable, and could have easily just been a squirrel scampering up the side of a tree or maybe a bird, but something told him that it wasn’t. Forcing himself to return Bilbo’s smile, he shook his head. “You go ahead. I will be there in a few minutes.”

The hobbit stared up at him curiously for a moment, then just shrugged. “Alright.” He turned to go, but stopped and reached out, touching Thorin’s arm. His next words were hushed, and that odd look from earlier returned to his eyes. “I really did miss you, you know.”

If it weren’t for the fact that he suspected that they had an audience, Thorin may have done something more. As it was, he just nodded and put his hand over Bilbo’s, squeezing in what he hoped was a reassuring gesture. After a few moments, Bilbo smiled up at him then pulled away and started towards the house. Thorin watched him go, then once the hobbit was out of sight he turned and started going in the opposite direction, heading towards a small clump of trees not far off from where they had been sitting. He reached the tree that he had seen the movement by, and walking around it, sure enough, he found a certain red-headed thief.

“How much of that did you hear?” he growled angrily.

Nori looked up at him, spinning a knife he had been using to pick at his fingernails. “How much did I hear of what?”

Glowering, Thorin drew himself up taller and folded his arms over his chest, not at all amused by the feigned ignorance.

“Alright, fine,” Nori said, putting the knife away and standing up straighter. “I heard all of it, but don’t go blaming me. Believe it or not, I wasn’t eavesdropping intentionally. It’s not my fault you two decided to talk so close to where I was napping and woke me up.”

Cursing, Thorin turned away and started to pace, dragging a hand through his tangled hair. He walked back and forth a few times, then stopped and grabbed onto Nori’s arm tightly, staring down at him. “Not a word of this to anyone,” he hissed. “Understand?”

The dwarf raised a braided eyebrow, seemingly unconcerned by the furious glare Thorin was giving him. “Just to be clear, you don’t want me to tell anyone that our king and our burglar have both been sent back from the future to redo this quest that apparently ended in disaster the first time around?”

“Nori.”

“Yeah, fine.” Nori shook his head, looking exasperated. He looked Thorin up and down for a moment, then said, “I won’t tell anyone. Not that they’d believe me if I did. I’m not even sure that I believe it.”

Thorin finally let go of Nori’s arm and took a few steps back, sighing. He’d forgotten about his exhaustion and stress for a while—the talk with Bilbo served as a good distraction—but it was beginning to weigh on him again like he had the entire Lonely Mountain sitting atop his shoulders. He could only hope that Nori would keep his word and not tell anyone about what he heard. He had considered telling the Company about it, but until he made his decision he didn’t want them finding out from someone else. No, if they learned of what he and Bilbo had experienced, they would hear it from their king.

“Cheer up, Thorin. I’m sure everything will work out alright in the end. There’s no need to tie yourself up in knots over it.” Nori clapped him on the shoulder, his large grin visible even from beneath his beard, then he turned and walked away, headed for the house.

Watching him go, Thorin couldn’t help but think that he wouldn’t be saying such a thing if he knew what lay in wait ahead of them.

Chapter 18: Into the Woods

Summary:

Bilbo learns something new about Dwalin, and the Company arrives at Mirkwood.

Notes:

Two chapters within the span of a month! I'm counting this as a win ;)
Just a warning: I didn't do a lot of editing for this chapter, so the writing quality may be a bit questionable in places

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The fortress was ruined and crumbling, overgrown with vines of thorns and overhung with dark clouds that cast it in unending shadow, just as it had been for centuries. At first glance, it seemed entirely abandoned. But Dol Guldur was anything but dead. In fact, for the first time in an age, its inner halls were teeming with life of a dark sort—gathered in anticipation for the coming of the darkest of them all.

After a three thousand year wait, it wouldn’t be long, now.

And when he returned, all of Middle Earth would feel his wrath.

Soon, but not yet. There were still things that needed to be done. Things that needed to be found.

A Pale Orc astride a white warg rode to the fortress. And when he dismounted, those with any amount of sense cowered from him, diving out of his path as he passed them by and avoiding his raging gaze.

He ignored them all, climbing up staircase after cracked staircase, and soon emerged onto a platform high above it all.

The heavy air grew colder. A foul wind began to cry.

And a formless shadow—blacker than the night and far more sinister—erupted into view.

A voice, guttural and sharp, spoke from everywhere and nowhere all at once in a language long forgotten by most. The orc responded in the same tongue. The meaning of what they said was indiscernible. Or, at least, most of it was. But the last part of the exchange was easily understood, despite the language remaining unchanged.

“What of Oakenshield?” the orc asked.

“War is coming.”

“You promised me his head.”

“Death will come to all.”

The wind grew with the words, until its ghostly howl was all one could hear. Then the shadow disappeared, gone just as quickly as it had come.

 

***

 

Bilbo jolted awake and drew in a deep gasp of breath, his eyes flying open.

For a moment, his surroundings were unfamiliar and he felt a seed of panic in his chest, but then his mind cleared and he remembered.

Beorn’s house. That’s where he was. Not some dark ruin in a dead forest.

He was safe.

“Alright there, Bilbo?”

He jumped and sat up to see a red-maned dwarf looking at him from where he stood several feet away.

Relaxing slightly, Bilbo did his best to smile at Gloin, though it probably looked more like a grimace. “I’m fine, thank you.”

The dwarf studied him for a moment, expression unreadable beneath his thick beard, then he shrugged. “Just as well you’re awake, I was coming to get you up.”

“Has something happened?” he asked, scrambling to get to his feet.

“No, nothing’s wrong. Dwalin wants you outside.”

He furrowed his brows. “Dwalin?”

“Aye, and I suggest you make it quick. He’s not the most patient of dwarves.”

With that, Gloin turned and left the house.

Bilbo watched him go, then released a slow, shuddering breath. He stood there for several moments before he slowly became aware that he was holding something.

He raised his hand from his side and blinked. It was clenched into a tight fist, and he could feel cool metal biting into his palm. With dread coiling in his belly, he forced himself to open his hand and his blood turned to ice in his veins.

The Ring sat there, gleaming in the early morning sunlight streaming in from a window on the wall behind him.

When had he picked it up? Had he taken it out of his pocket in his sleep? Was that why he’d had such a terrible dream? Already, the details of it were fading, but he could still clearly hear those words in black speech. Had the Ring put that in his head?

As if hearing his thoughts—maybe it could—a whispery voice caressed Bilbo’s mind.

‘You will fail.’

Bilbo trembled.

‘You cannot save him from his fate.’

His throat tightened painfully.

‘You are not strong enough, little halfling. But I can help you. I can give you the power to destroy any who might harm him.’

I don’t want your help, Bilbo thought, though the words sounded meek even in his own head.

‘Then you will watch your dwarf die, just as you once did. You—’

Fear like a vice grabbed at his heart, but beneath the fear was something else. A white hot rage that felt so out of place, it almost startled him. But that anger gave him something to hold onto. Something to drag him out of his dread and steel him against the fear. And when he spoke, his voice didn’t waver.

“I will not let that happen. I will save him. I will save all of them. And then I am going to destroy you.”

A terrible screeching echoed in his mind and for a split second, he was no longer standing in Beorn’s home, but in a pitch black void. Lit only by a great ball of flame.

He shoved the Ring into his pocket, and the noise and vision both vanished.

Forcing his hands to stop shaking, Bilbo strode for the door, the image of a fiery eye still burning on the backs of his eyelids.

Outside, he was a little surprised to find the entire Company spread out around the grassy meadow. It seemed they were all taking advantage of their last day of peace for what was sure to be a long while, since they were setting out for Mirkwood at dawn the next morning. At the sight of the group in the middle of the meadow, however, Bilbo had a sneaking suspicion that he would not be relaxing today.

Sighing slightly, Bilbo started heading towards them.

On his way, he passed by Bofur, who was humming quietly and had all his attention focused on a chunk of wood in his hand that he was carving into what looked like a half-finished flute. Nori was with him, his head pillowed on Bofur’s legs and his eyes were closed, so Bilbo assumed he was asleep. Bombur was nearby, sprawled out in the shade and snoring loudly, and Bifur sat beside him with a bundle of wildflowers.

In the meadow, Thorin and Fili both had their swords drawn and were exchanging blows so quickly, Bilbo could hardly keep up with their movements. The sound of metal clanging against metal echoed again and again, and the intensity of both dwarves’ expressions was such that he would have thought they were actually fighting each other had it not been for Kili standing a few yards away yelling out encouragement and teasing remarks to both his brother and uncle.

The moment the youngest Durin noticed Bilbo’s approach, he shot a glance at Thorin, a sparkle of mischief in his eyes, then his grin grew and Kili called out to him cheerfully. “Bilbo!”

At Kili’s greeting, Thorin’s gaze flickered away from his nephew and when he saw Bilbo, a small smile curved at the corner of his lips.

The distraction lasted only a second, but it was enough.

Fili took his chance, sweeping his uncle’s feet out from underneath him. Thorin hit the ground hard and let out a wheeze when the breath was knocked out of him. Then the tip of Fili’s sword was lightly touching the center of his chest, effectively pinning him on his back.

“Do you surrender?” Fili asked seriously.

The two dwarves stared at each other for a few moments, and the shock on Thorin’s face changed to a scowl—though there was pride sparkling in his eyes that he either couldn’t or wouldn’t hide. “Fine, you win.”

Fili grinned and moved his sword away, offering out a hand and pulling Thorin back to his feet.

Thorin turned to glare at Kili, who was laughing so much he was doubled over and had his arms wrapped around his stomach.

“You’re going to regret that in a minute.”

Kili had no response other than to laugh even harder.

Thorin rolled his eyes.

Having watched the whole exchange take place, Bilbo had a hand over his mouth, trying to hide his grin. But when Thorin shot him an exasperated look, he couldn’t help but let out a small laugh.

Thorin’s smile was immediate and Bilbo felt his heart skip a beat. It may have been several decades ago, but he was sure that the dwarf had never smiled so brightly or so often the first time they had taken this journey. A shame, really, because his smile truly was beautiful.

The thought caught him a bit off guard and Bilbo shook his head to be rid of it, then turned his attention away from the three Durins.

Several yards away, Dwalin had one of his axes in hand. Ori was next to him with his other axe, and seemed to be attempting to copy the bald dwarf’s stance.

Bilbo walked closer, but stayed a few paces away, just in case one of them started swinging.

Dwalin noticed him after a minute and turned to Ori, muttering something a bit too quiet for Bilbo to hear.

The young scribe nodded and returned Dwalin’s axe and took a few steps towards the edge of the meadow before he stopped, then promptly turned around and instead joined Fili on the ground to watch Thorin and Kili spar, his cheeks slightly red and a grimace on his face.

Confused, Bilbo looked over to the edge of the meadow.

Balin and Oin were playing checkers on a rather larger-than-normal board, with Gloin smoking a pipe and watching their game. Then there was Dori. The dwarf was sitting beside Gloin, but his attention wasn’t on the checkers. Rather, he was glaring daggers at Dwalin so intently it was like he hoped he could make the dwarf implode just by staring hard enough.

Dwalin didn’t seem to notice that another Company member looked like he was plotting his death. Or maybe he just didn’t care. Either way, he was ignoring Dori completely, and was now looking down at Bilbo.

“Er…” Bilbo shifted uncomfortably on his feet. By the end of the first journey, he and the tattooed warrior were friends, but he had never gotten to know Dwalin as well as he had known some of the others. So far the second time around, the dwarf hadn’t spoken to him much—not that it was any real surprise. At any rate, standing before him now without much clue of what he was doing there made Bilbo rather nervous. Not that he was intimidated by the mountainous dwarf, of course. Just that he wasn’t sure what to expect. “Gloin said you wanted to see me?” he eventually managed to say.

“Draw your sword.”

“What for?”

Dwalin just stared at him.

Apprehensively, he pulled Sting from its sheath. “Alright?”

“Give it a few swings.”

Feeling slightly self conscious with the dwarf’s gaze fixed on him, Bilbo turned and did as he was told. From the corner of his eye, he could tell that the dwarf was getting more and more irritated with each swing. He was about to speak up and ask what this was all about, but Dwalin beat him to it.

“Mahal faslmagânu zanatul, hobbit!”

Startled by the sudden outburst, Bilbo let his sword fall limp to his side and turned back to the dwarf. “What?”

“You handle that sword worse than a dwarfling who’s just learned to walk!” Dwalin exclaimed. “Do they teach you nothing in the Shire?”

Spluttering indignantly at being compared to a dwarf toddler, Bilbo said, “we have no need for sword fighting in the Shire! Hardly anyone even owns a weapon, let alone knows how to use it!”

“But what happens if there ever is a need for it? You don’t even prepare for the possibility of needing to defend yourselves? What if— Never mind, that isn’t the point.” Dwalin cut himself off and shook his head. Then he sent Bilbo a glare. “I thought keeping an eye on Thorin was bad, but at least he knows how to fight when he gets himself in trouble! But you. You dive head first into danger when you don’t even know how to hold your sword right! After trolls, goblins, orcs, and wargs, how are you still alive?”

Bilbo blinked. He wasn’t sure he’d ever heard Dwalin say so much in one go before. But that wasn’t even the truly baffling part of this conversation. Looking at the dwarf more closely, it occurred to him that maybe it wasn’t irritation in his expression like he had originally thought. “Dwalin, you’re worried about me.”

Dwalin’s eyes narrowed, but he didn’t deny it. “You and I are staying on this field until I’m convinced you can keep a proper stance.”

Stunned, Bilbo glanced back over his shoulder. Fili and Kili were wrestling each other, and Ori was watching them. But Thorin’s attention was focused solely on Dwalin. He showed no hint of surprise at his best friend’s words, as Bilbo expected. Instead, Thorin looked rather pleased, and more than a little amused.

When he noticed Bilbo watching him, Thorin just shrugged and gestured to Dwalin, then turned his focus to where Fili currently had his brother pinned face down in the grass.

Looking back to Dwalin, Bilbo cleared his throat a bit. “Well, I suppose it would be a bit silly of me to refuse, though I get the feeling you wouldn’t take no for an answer anyways.”

The dwarf only grunted in response and pointed at Sting expectantly.

 

***

 

They set out at dawn the next morning, when the sky was barely beginning to get light. Despite the early hour, the Company seemed to be in good spirits, Bilbo included. He’d slept comfortably through the night, without any hint of nightmares, which he was grateful for. Even better, he hadn’t woken to another unpleasant conversation with the Ring—though the fact that he even could speak with the Ring unnerved him. He’d heard its whispering before, of course, when it first came into his possession. But back then, it had never been so clear. Then during those long years in the Shire, it eventually faded to silence, as if it had gone dormant. He didn’t know what to make of the fact that its voice was so strong now, but he had the feeling it wasn’t a good sign.

Worse, it was apparent that the Ring recognized him. Like, somehow, its memory was unaffected by time.

It didn’t help that he couldn’t stop thinking about the last thing he had said to the Ring.

I will destroy you.

He had known before even leaving the Shire that he would come across the Ring again, and that eventually he would have to figure out what to do with the damned thing, seeing as he certainly couldn’t keep it. But he hadn’t really let himself think about it in more detail than that. He’d decided early on that taking back Erebor—and keeping all his dwarves alive and whole—was his first priority. He would deal with the Ring later. Maybe it was a selfish decision, or a cowardly one, to focus on saving three dwarves when the fate of all of Middle Earth was in the balance. Maybe. But even if it was, that didn’t change anything.

Still, he had made his intentions perfectly clear when the Ring tried to tempt him, and he worried that it would try to find its way into someone else’s hands. Someone who may be more easily manipulated to return it to its true master.

As much as he hated carrying the horrible thing around in his pocket, he didn’t dare bury it deep in the bottom of his knapsack like he so desperately wanted to. Not when that made the risk of losing it so much greater. So he’d settled on keeping it in his pocket, but had stuffed it into a little pouch and tied it tightly shut. At least that way, he’d be less likely to take it out in his sleep again.

Around midday, his mind was still focused on the Ring when another pony fell into step beside his own, and he glanced over to see that it was Thorin riding next to him.

He shook himself from his thoughts and did his best to smile at the dwarf, but Thorin studied him for a moment before saying, “you seem worried. At least, more worried than usual.”

“Yes, well, our last trip through Mirkwood didn’t necessarily go well. I can hardly be blamed for having some stress over doing it again.” The half-lie fell from Bilbo’s lips easily enough, and Thorin seemed to accept it without question.

“I am not too thrilled to go back in there, either.” Thorin scowled. “I have the feeling that we will not be able to avoid the elves, though that is my intention.”

Bilbo had to agree, and he was no happier about it than Thorin. He didn’t think it would be possible for them to make it all the way through the woods without Thranduil noticing. Especially not when they were a bunch of dwarves. There was no way the elf king would allow them to pass through his lands unhindered. Which meant they were most certainly going to find themselves being taken prisoner once again. Being the only one who wasn’t captured, Bilbo had been incredibly stressed during the weeks spent in those dungeons—avoiding guards at every turn and trying to find a way to release the Company so they could escape. It was terrible, and that didn’t even include how positively boring it had been. The only good part of the whole ordeal was that it gave him the perfect chance to actually get to know a certain dwarf king.

Thorin had been kept in a cell far away from the rest of the dwarves, and it had taken Bilbo several days to finally find him. After that, he would take every chance he got to sit on the floor in front of Thorin’s cell and talk. At first, it was just to plan their escape. Then it slowly changed into something more. It may have just been the boredom that started it, but they began telling each other about themselves, sharing stories from their lives and talking about their homes. Thorin once spent hours sharing all his memories of Erebor. In turn, Bilbo had told him about the Shire. And their conversations became more personal, and there were things that were said there—quiet whispers in the dark with a door of iron bars between them—that Bilbo was sure neither of them had ever told anyone else before.

So, despite the less than ideal circumstances, that dungeon was where they had planted the seeds of their friendship. And when they emerged into the world again after their escape, that friendship blossomed.

Of course, it never would have been possible had Bilbo not had a magic Ring that turned him invisible when worn. Which reminded him—

He shot a glance at his friend and tried to choose his words carefully. “Er, Thorin?” The dwarf only hummed in response, so he lowered his voice a bit and went on. “Last time, we made it out because I was able to avoid being caught, but what are we going to do if I’m taken prisoner along with the rest of you?”

Thorin raised a brow at him. “I do not think that will be the case.”

He imagined putting the Ring back on and wearing it for such a long period of time, and the thought made him nauseous. But there was no way he could remain hidden for so long without it. “I appreciate your confidence in me, but I would still feel better if we had another plan to fall back on.”

For a few minutes, neither of them said anything.

When Thorin spoke, he had a sour look on his face. “He offered me a deal.”

“I remember,” Bilbo said softly. He had, after all, witnessed that particular altercation. It hadn’t ended well. “If...if he offers again, and we know there’s no way I’ll be able to get us out, will you take it?”

They went quiet again, and Thorin looked to be deep in thought.

“I am not sure what I would do.” He was staring straight ahead as he said it, voice sounding strained and barely loud enough for Bilbo to hear. “Logically, I know it would be the best choice. What he asked was a small price to pay for our freedom. And yet… As much as I hate to say it, Gandalf was right when he said pride would be my downfall. I allow my pride to cloud my judgement more often than I like to admit. I know this, but it changes nothing. Would I accept Thranduil’s deal if there was no other choice? I want to say yes, but I fear that in the moment, my hatred for him would take over and I would refuse once again.”

Stunned at the confession, Bilbo struggled to find a response, then gave up. What was there that he could possibly say to that?

So they rode in silence for a long time, and said nothing more on the subject.

 

***

 

That evening, they finally reached the entrance to the path they would be taking through Mirkwood. After taking one look at it, the vote to make camp for the night and start their trek through the forest in the morning was unanimous. Nobody was looking forward to sleeping in those woods. So they found a spot that was a comfortable distance away from the trees and went about setting up camp.

Bilbo was grateful when his feet finally touched solid ground after such a long time on the pony, and he was quite ready to sit down and have a smoke.

At least, that was what he intended to do.

He didn’t even get the chance to light his pipe before Dwalin approached him and demanded that Bilbo draw his sword and show him that he still remembered what he’d learned the day before.

So, instead of relaxing like he wanted, Bilbo spent the next hour mimicking Dwalin’s stance and movements, practicing how to position his feet to keep his balance and learning how to block blows from an opponent. By the time Bombur announced supper was done, Bilbo was getting rather fed up with it all.

He stomped over to the fire, where a decent stew was boiling in a large pot, dished two bowls, then went and dropped down onto a log beside Thorin on the outskirts of camp where he was keeping watch.

The moment he noticed Bilbo’s expression, Thorin barked out a laugh. “Enjoying your time with Dwalin?”

Bilbo scowled at him and started shoveling stew into his mouth so he wouldn’t have to answer the question. Neither of them said anything else while they ate.

A few minutes later, with his bowl empty and food in his belly, Bilbo felt a bit better. The annoyance wasn’t completely gone, though.

He glanced at Thorin. “You don’t seem too surprised that Dwalin is suddenly taking an interest in me. Did you put him up to this?”

Thorin laughed again and shook his head. “No, but I did not have to. His interest is not as sudden as you may think. I was wondering how much longer it would be before he finally broke down and helped you. Some of the others were betting on it.”

“What? Why?”

“Because the fact that you have no training in combat has been driving him mad since the day we left the Shire. And ever since the incident with the orcs, he has been even more wound up about it.”

“But why?” Bilbo asked, baffled. “Nobody else seems to be bothered.”

“Oh, the others worry about you plenty, make no mistake,” Thorin said as he pulled out his pipe from his coat and went about lighting it. “But while the others worry about you getting hurt during a fight, Dwalin has anxiety over it.”

That only confused him more, and he stared at Thorin, waiting for him to explain.

After puffing on his pipe for a minute, the dwarf glanced at him. “It is a bit of a long story.”

“We have time.”

Thorin sighed, then nodded, and his voice was quieter when he spoke again. “I will do my best to explain it, if you really want to know. Just do not mention it to Dwalin. It brings up painful memories that he tries not to dwell on.”

Despite his curiosity, Bilbo asked, “are you sure he’d be okay with you telling me?”

A small smile pulled at Thorin’s lips and he shook his head once. “The rest of the Company knows, along with every dwarf in Ered Luin. It is not a secret.”

Nodding, Bilbo gestured for him to go on.

For several moments, Thorin just stared up at the sky—at the stars that were just beginning to appear, like he might find the right words to say among them. “A long time ago, during our first few years in Ered Luin, there were small bands of goblins roaming the mountain. We did our best to hunt them all down and get rid of them, but there were still some we had not killed yet. One day, a few dwarflings were outside the mountain and strayed too far from the front gates.”

Bilbo had a nasty feeling he knew where this was going, and the sad look in Thorin’s eyes only confirmed it. Rather than make him say it, Bilbo quietly asked, “and Dwalin?”

Blowing out a breath of smoke, Thorin took a moment to respond. “Dwalin was standing guard at the gate that day. When he realized the dwarflings were gone, he left his post to find them. By the time he got there, it was too late. He ran back to the mountain to get help, but after leading a few more guards to the scene, he disappeared. I will never forget when he returned home the next day, covered in blood and dirt, and told me he had tracked down the goblins that did it and killed every single one of them.”

Bilbo wordlessly accepted the pipe when Thorin passed it to him.

"No one thought it was his fault, of course, but he blamed himself for not getting there in time to save them. After that, he took it upon himself to ensure that every dwarfling old enough to venture outside learned how to defend themselves. And he has been teaching ever since. There is not a young dwarf in Ered Luin who has not trained with him."

A heavy silence settled between them for a while, and Bilbo was doing his best not to imagine something similar happening in the Shire—where children could go out on their own and not return home until sunset and parents never once worried for their safety. Bilbo himself had wandered the hills around Hobbiton when he was young and only headed back to Bag End after dark, trailing mud and fireflies in his wake. Frodo had been much the same in those early years after Bilbo had taken him in, dragging young Samwise out on little adventures. The thought of the two of them ever being attacked in such a way…

Bilbo stopped that trail of thought immediately and said the first thing that came to mind, just to give him something else to focus on. "I never really imagined Dwalin was the type to like children."

"Most people think that at first. It is his appearance, I think." There was a note of relief in Thorin's voice, like he, too, was glad to move on from such sad thoughts. "He does not really look like the nurturing type, but looks can be deceiving. All dwarves treasure children; Dwalin adores them."

"Huh. The more you know," Bilbo said, handing back the pipe.

Thorin hummed in agreement.

After several moments of consideration, Bilbo spoke up again. “There’s one thing I’m not getting, though. Why did he decide to teach me? I’m not a child.”

Thorin laughed. “No, you are not. And Dwalin knows it. But I think he will always see something childish in hobbits—” Bilbo made an indignant noise and Thorin shook his head, amused. “Try not to take it personally. It has nothing to do with your own maturity. More, I think his perception of hobbits reminds him too much of the dwarflings we lost. He is afraid to see anyone else without the knowledge to defend themselves get hurt. So Dwalin teaches you because he fears that if he does not, something bad will happen to you and he will feel responsible for not helping when he had the chance.”

Despite his annoyance at being seen as a helpless child, something about it still put a warm feeling in his chest, and Bilbo smiled slightly.

 

***

 

Gandalf was leaving.

And though Bilbo had been expecting it, he still wasn’t happy when the wizard made the announcement. On the last journey, he’d been worried about how the Company would make it through the forest without his guidance. Now, he was more worried about his friend’s safety. He had a fairly good idea of where Gandalf was disappearing to, and he knew just how dangerous this little detour would turn out to be. So, despite knowing how important it was that Gandalf discovered the source of the darkness growing in Dol Guldur, he still didn’t want him to leave.

The wizard was checking through his supplies when Bilbo approached him. “Is there any way to convince you to stay?” he asked quietly, even though he already knew what the answer would be.

“I’m afraid not.” Gandalf’s voice lowered and he glanced around to make sure none of the dwarves were listening in on their conversation. “Darkness is stirring, Bilbo. Foul things are seeping from the cracks of the world, and I need to find out why.”

He sighed glumly. “I know.”

Gandalf studied him intensely for a few moments. “You know what I will find, don’t you?”

Grimacing, Bilbo nodded. “Am I still not allowed to tell you anything?”

“No, not yet. Though I feel there will soon come a time when that may change.”

Neither of them said anything for the next minute or two as Gandalf finished adding food to his pack. Then the wizard straightened and placed a comforting hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “Don’t despair, my friend. I am confident that you and Thorin will be able to take care of the Company in my absence, and I intend to find you again before this quest is over.”

Bilbo didn’t necessarily disagree that he could handle it, but that didn’t mean he was happy about it.

“Wait!” As Gandalf turned away to mount his horse, Bilbo reached out and grabbed onto his sleeve. When the wizard glanced back at him, he sighed. “Just...be careful. Trust your instincts about the necromancer.”

When Gandalf nodded, Bilbo let him go.

Then he watched as the wizard rode away.

“We will make do without him. We did it before.”

Bilbo jumped and turned to see Thorin a few steps behind him. The dwarf nodded towards the entrance to Mirkwood, where the Company was gathered. Waiting for him, he realized. “Shall we get this over with?”

With one last glance at Gandalf’s figure slowly shrinking in the distance, he took a deep breath and followed Thorin.

They passed through the archway into what felt like a little courtyard, overgrown with vines and weeds, with a dried out fountain in the middle. A path of cracked pave-stones lead into the woods and disappeared into the shadows. Bilbo wanted nothing less than to follow it, but he would. For the sake of his dwarves. He would.

Thorin moved forward to be at the front of the Company, taking his first steps into the woods. “Remember, we do not leave the path!”

The dwarves all started walking, and Bilbo went to follow them, but he stopped halfway through the courtyard, a flash of red catching his eye. Curiously, he moved closer to the derelict statue of a beautiful elf woman and reached out to push a curtain of vines aside and saw that a red eye had been painted onto her chest.

His entire body froze and he stared at the symbol, an image of a fiery eye flashing through his mind and he could practically feel the weight of the Ring in his pocket.

“Bilbo?”

Snapping out of his daze, he glanced away from the statue to see that the rest of the Company was gone, save for Bofur.

“Are you coming? We don’t want to be leaving our hobbit behind.” He said it cheerfully enough, but there was a hint of concern in his eyes.

Bilbo did his best to shake off his anxiety and nodded. “Sorry. Let’s go.”

 

***

 

The Mirkwood proved to be just as terrible as Bilbo remembered it.

The atmosphere of the tunnel-like path they followed was heavy, weighing down on each of the Company and making it difficult to continue moving forward. The air, thick and suffocating as it was, didn’t help any. The forest was unnaturally silent and devoid of life, yet at night, eyes still watched them from the darkness as they slept.

They still had enough food rations to last them another week, but water was beginning to run low. And when they reached the river, the argument they’d all had over whether or not it was safe to drink from lasted close to an hour, then abruptly ended when a scrawny squirrel ran past, tried to jump to a branch overhanging the water, and missed. When the poor creature resurfaced moments later, it was either unconscious or dead. The sight was enough to convince everyone that they shouldn’t touch the water, and that was that.

It wasn’t until after they crossed the river that the disorientation started kicking in, as if the air itself was some sort of hallucinogenic. And on the third occasion of someone wandering off the path and nearly getting lost, Bilbo had finally had enough.

When he yelled for them all to stop, thirteen dwarves obediently came to a stumbling halt. Thorin left his spot at the front of the line to stand in front of him, his gaze fixed on a point at Bilbo’s left.

“What is it?”

Bilbo snapped his fingers in front of Thorin’s face and the dwarf jumped, then looked at him and blinked several times.

“At this rate, we’re going to start losing people. We need to find a way to make sure we all stick together.”

“And how do you suggest we do that?” Thorin asked.

Pursing his lips, Bilbo glanced back at all the dwarves behind him. In the Shire, hobbits who had a lot of children would often have them all hold hands to keep them together whenever they went out. He doubted he’d be able to convince the entire Company to hold each other’s hands like a group of children. And even if he could, they were all so disoriented, he didn’t think it would be long before someone let go.

But maybe…

Bilbo turned around fully and let out a sharp whistle to get their attention. When everyone was looking at him—or at the very least, in his general vicinity—he asked, “does anyone have any rope?”

There was a lot of muttering between them before Ori’s voice piped up.

“Dori has some!”

“What? No I don’t!” Dori argued, then turned and hit Nori in the arm, glaring at him.

Nori scowled. “What’re you hitting me for? I didn’t say anything.”

Sighing, Bilbo walked back to the three brothers before they could start a fight. When he stopped, he found that he was standing face to face with himself. He stared at the other Bilbo for a moment, then squeezed his eyes shut. And when he opened them again, he was looking at Dori.

“Blast this confounded forest,” he whispered to himself, and walked around Dori.

Sure enough, there was a coil of thin rope hooked to the dwarf’s rucksack.

As soon as Dori saw the rope, he blinked, looking surprised. “Where’d that come from?”

“You’ve been carrying it this whole time, boulder-brain,” Nori grumbled, stepping out of reach as his older brother clumsily swung at him again.

“Knock it off, both of you,” Bilbo snapped, and looked down at the rope, studying it for a moment, then nodded. It would have to do.

Five minutes later, Bilbo was at the front of the line and they were on the move again, though there was a substantial amount of complaining coming from the dwarves behind him and he kept almost tripping due to the incessant tugging at the rope tied around his waist.

“Are all hobbits so resourceful, or did I just have the luck to find a gem in a copper mine?”

He felt his face get warm, but snorted at the question. “Don’t compliment me yet. If we lose the path now, it will be because I led us astray.”

“You have never led me astray before. I do not believe you will do so now.”

Bilbo glanced over his shoulder to see that Thorin was smiling at him and he stumbled.

The dwarf reached out to steady him, his smile growing slightly. “Careful, ‘Ibinê.”

Notes:

Mahal faslmagânu zanatul - Mahal's hairy balls

‘Ibinê - my gem

Chapter 19: The Price of Freedom

Summary:

Thorin's hopes of making it out of Mirkwood without any run-ins with spiders or elves are dashed. And with Bilbo being captured alongside the rest of the Company, he has to face the challenge of negotiating for their freedom without letting his anger ruin their chances of being released.

Notes:

So, I've got good news and bad news. The good news is, I used NaNoWriMo to work on this fic and I've nearly gotten all of it written--save for a few major scenes that I'm still hashing out. The bad news is, it's finals season, meaning I have two big papers to write and a Spanish exam to study for so I can't actually get around to finishing those scenes. My hope is that once the semester ends, I'll be able to start posting a new chapter once a week until it's done. Fingers crossed. No promises.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When Thorin awoke, he felt worse than he did the day before. His entire body was stiff and aching and he could practically feel the weight of hunger pressing down on him. They’d run out of water two days ago, now, and their food a day before that. They wouldn’t make it much farther if they didn’t find some way to replenish their supplies, but they hadn’t come across so much as a stream since crossing the enchanted river and there was no food to be seen save for the occasional scrawny squirrel that crossed their path, and those were no good to eat. Kili shot one several days ago and they’d tried cooking it over a fire that released putrid smoke and drew biting insects to them. He’d taken one bite and spat it out—the meat tasted like it was rotted, as if the squirrel had been decomposing even as it was scurrying around the miserable forest.

Mirkwood was proving to be just as bad as he remembered it.

His only consolation was that they had yet to lose the path. That, and the warm creature that slept beside him.

Opening his eyes, Thorin had to blink away the bleariness then allow his vision to adjust to the dim light. Dawn was nearing, but the sun had not yet risen and the long shadows of the forest were still so thick as to seem nearly tangible. Avoiding looking at any of those shadows too closely, Thorin cast his gaze around the area, taking a mental count of his companions, and was relieved to see that they were all still there. Everyone else was still asleep, besides Bofur and Bifur who were on the last watch of the night.

Normally, the watch would only require one dwarf to be awake at a time, but shortly after entering the woods the Company collectively agreed that they’d all feel safer if they took watch in pairs. So that was the way they’d been doing it for nearly three weeks, now.

Satisfied that no one was missing, Thorin finally looked to Bilbo.

The hobbit was curled up against his side, breathing softly in sleep, one arm draped over Thorin’s torso and his face pressed into his shirt. Thorin’s fur overcoat was laying over him like a blanket, as he’d woken in the middle of the night to find Bilbo shivering with cold.

What the Company thought when they woke up each morning to find their King and their burglar wrapped around each other, he didn’t know. No one had so much as mentioned it—not even his nosy sister-sons who normally wouldn’t miss a chance to tease him. If they’d been anywhere but where they were, they certainly would have teased him. But this was Mirkwood, where the air was heavy and the nights were cold, and they had all taken to huddling together for warmth as they slept.

He hated it there. But at least, he thought as he looked down at the hobbit beside him, he wasn’t alone.

When the dawn came, it took less than half an hour for everyone to wake up and start walking again. Despite the fatigue and hunger and exhaustion, they were all eager to get out of the forest and that was motivation enough to start moving. That, and they were all afraid of staying in one place for too long. They stopped at night out of necessity—it was so dark, they could barely see their own hands in front of their faces and if they tried to continue on, they would lose the path for sure. Not to mention each other. It was always a relief when dawn came, if only so that they could actually see their surroundings and be sure none of their friends had gone missing during the night.

So they walked, and though there was no such thing as a “good day” underneath those dreaded trees, it was slightly less miserable than the others. Though the air was still thick and hard to breathe, it wasn’t causing hallucinations or disorientation. At least, not as much as usual. They were clear minded enough, in fact, that they didn’t have to tie themselves together to ensure that no one wandered off. Thanks to the lack of rope tugging at their waists, the Company was in a considerably better mood. So much so that Thorin even heard the occasional joke that was met with a short bout of scattered laughter.

It gave him hope that maybe they were reaching the other side of the forest and that they would soon find themselves leaving the trees behind. After all, they managed to stay with the path much longer and further than they did the first time they went through the woods. They had to be coming close to the end of it.

He should have known better.

It was around mid-afternoon when he felt someone tug insistently at his sleeve and he glanced back to see Bilbo’s anxious face.

“What is it?” he asked, automatically looking back on the line of dwarves behind him and counting heads until he got up to twelve.

“I think we’re getting close to a spider nest,” Bilbo said.

Furrowing his brows, Thorin looked at their surroundings then stopped walking and blinked a few times.

Sure enough, there were webs littered throughout the trees around them. And as he looked ahead, he saw they grew thicker and thicker farther up the path. How had he not noticed them before?

“Why did we stop?”

Dwalin’s distant voice calling from the back of the line snapped him out of his daze and he turned back to look at the Company, then back down to Bilbo. “Do you think they will be on the path?”

“I don’t know, but we can’t leave it.” Bilbo peeked around him to look ahead then drew back and shook his head. “I think the best we can do is avoid touching the webs and stay quiet. Hopefully they won’t even notice we’re here.”

Pursing his lips, Thorin decided against pointing out that it would be hard not to notice thirteen dwarves and a hobbit. Bilbo was right, of course. Leaving the path proved to be disastrous the first time and he wasn’t inclined to do it again. Though, he also wasn’t inclined to face a hoard of giant spiders again, either. Still, between possibility of disaster and certainty of one, he’d prefer to go with the former. They would just have to keep quiet.

After a few moments of thought, he relayed the orders to the Company and they moved on.

For their part, the dwarves did well at keeping the noise they made to a minimum, though Thorin found himself wincing at every boot that crunched on fallen leaves or twigs. He wished they all had the light step of hobbits like Bilbo, who was walking beside him on silent feet.

They only made it like that for ten minutes.

Just as Thorin was thinking maybe they could sneak through without being caught, somebody let out a yell and he whirled around in time to watch Kili careen off the path and fall directly into one of the webs.

For a moment, there was complete silence, as if the world held its breath. Then there was a low rumbling noise and the entire forest started to shake.

The Company leapt into action. Fili and Ori both lunged forward to help pull Kili out of the web as everyone else drew their weapons and fell into a defensive circle so they had eyes in every direction. Thorin glanced over at Bilbo as the hobbit drew Sting from its sheath, a resigned look on his face. He caught Thorin’s gaze and grimaced.

“I hate spiders,” the hobbit said.

Thorin had just enough time to grumble an agreement before several massive creatures appeared from the treetops above and dropped down onto them. In his peripheral vision, Thorin saw some of his friends take a hesitant step back in the face of the massive spiders.

He took a steadying breath, raised Orcrist, and shouted. “Du-bekâr!”

The rest of the Company echoed him, Bilbo’s voice among them, and they plunged into the fight.

The spiders seemed endless. One fell and two more took its place, and that wasn’t even mentioning all the normal sized spiders that covered parts of the forest floor like a moving carpet. It took all the focus Thorin had to defend himself from the onslaught and keep an eye on the others at the same time—all while he concentrated on fighting his way to his sister-sons.

Fili and Kili were holding their own, but he still would feel better if he were fighting at their side. Just to be safe.

Thorin hacked the leg off a spider that lurched towards him, then plunged his sword through its eyes as it screamed. He leapt over its fallen carcass and kept going.

He wasn’t worried about Bilbo. The hobbit was fairing just as well as the rest of them, and he had fallen to fighting side by side with Dwalin. He knew his best friend would protect the smallest member of their Company to the death if need be, so he continued past them without hesitation. Though, he did pause momentarily to help pull the legs off a spider that managed to knock Dori to the ground and was snapping its sharp pincers at the dwarf’s face. As soon as the spider was dead, he and Gloin each grabbed one of the disheveled dwarf’s hands and pulled him to his feet. Dori gave a breathless word of thanks before he turned and lunged for a spider that had Ori cornered against a tree.

Thorin only managed to take about half a dozen more steps towards his sister-sons when a high, piercing sound rose above the noise of the fight and he swore.

It was the Horn of the Mirkwood.

Meaning the elves had just joined the party.

Sure enough, within moments a scouting party fell upon them, appearing from the tree canopy high above, weapons ready before they even hit the ground. Among them, Thorin spotted a familiar pale-haired prince who went as far as using a tendril of spider web like a rope to slide down, firing arrows as he went.

Perfect.

He swore again.

It was over within a minute, the majority of the spiders dead and the few who still lived fled into the trees, closely pursued by several of the elves.

The ones who remained immediately turned their focus to stealing the Company’s weapons and herding them into a close circle. Thorin snarled at the elf who took Orcrist, but did nothing to stop him. What was the point? They were outnumbered and clearly outmatched, as much as he was loath to admit it. If the Company wasn’t exhausted and half starved to death, it would be a much different story. As it was, they followed Thorin’s lead and surrendered without much resistance.

At least they were all alive, he thought. All of his dwarves were there, and Bilbo…

Thorin cast his gaze around and whatever hope he had that the hobbit had gotten away was dashed as soon as he spotted a head of honey-golden curls beside Balin. A burst of anxiety coursed through him at the sight, but he didn’t get the chance to question how they would escape the dungeons. Before he could think much of anything at all, Legolas Thranduilion was standing before him, Orcrist in hand. And behind him stood a red-headed she-elf holding Sting.

“Where did you get these?”

Thorin didn’t deign to answer, knowing he’d be called a thief and a liar no matter his response. Rather, he just glowered at the elf in silence.

He never cared for the elf prince, even before Thrór fell to the gold-sickness and relations between the dwarves of Erebor and the elves of Mirkwood were strained, and then subsequently irrevocably shattered when Thranduil refused to send aid after the dragon attacked. He met Legolas a total of three times before that fateful day, and each time Thorin had gotten the distinct impression that he was just as stuck up as the rest of his kin. More so, even, thanks to his parentage. The prince always looked down his nose at Thorin and was just as patronizing and condescending as his kakhuf inbarathrag father.

In fact, Legolas was sneering down at him now.

When it became clear that Thorin wasn’t going to give him an answer, the elf turned away and shouted out a command in Sindarin to his guards. Thorin took the chance to shoot a glance back to his hobbit. Bilbo met his gaze and he shook his head slightly, looking apologetic. He didn’t have the time to think on it much, since the elves started pushing them into a line and led them into the forest—and away from the path.

 

***

 

As he found himself being led into the depths of the caves of Mirkwood once again, Thorin felt a heavy pit of dread start to build in his gut. He had not readily forgotten all those weeks spent in a deep, dark cell far from the rest of the Company. He was not ready to go back there again. Back to the constant fretting over the safety of his kin, and the anger at being held captive by one of the people he hated most, and the humiliation that came with knowing there was nothing he could do about it. And yet, despite being one of his lowest points in the whole quest, it had also become one of his most treasured.

Because as miserable as it had been, there were several light moments to interrupt the unending darkness.

He could still remember the feeling of relief he’d had when a familiar head of curly hair appeared at the door of his cell in one of the deepest levels of the dungeon. It took Bilbo nearly a week to finally find him there, and seeing that the hobbit had somehow evaded capture gave him a spark of hope. At that point, he was more than used to Bilbo saving them from difficult situations and tight spots, so he’d had no doubt that the hobbit would do it again. Still, it took time to solidify their escape plan, and in that time was when he finally had the chance to get to know his Company’s burglar more. It was also when he finally started to admit to himself that the hobbit truly was his One. Up until then, he had been doing everything he could to deny it. But after spending so much time alone together, their conversations becoming more and more personal as the days went by, he didn’t have much of a chance to continue that denial.

He ended up telling Bilbo things that he had never voiced out loud, even to Dwalin.

He gained a confidant down in those dungeons. More than that, he gained a true friend.

And just as Thorin knew he would, Bilbo got them out.

But now…

The Mirkwood guards continued to shepherd them deeper into the elvish kingdom until they eventually reached a divergence in the path. One path continued forward. The other sloped downward.

Three of the guards pulled Thorin out of the line as the rest of the Company was led onto that sinking path. A path that would take them to the dungeons far below.

With a lump in his throat, Thorin watched as they trooped past him, sending him apprehensive looks as they went. Bilbo was near the end of the line, and as he neared Thorin, his pace slowed despite the urging of the guard at the rear for him to keep moving.

The hobbit had not managed to evade capture this time. He had been taken prisoner along with the rest of the Company. That subtle disappearance in times of danger that Thorin had gotten so used to—had come to depend on, even—had not happened. And that meant they were going to have to find another way to get out of there. No, it meant that he was going to have to find another way out. He was their leader and this responsibility fell to him. It was unfair of him to have let himself place that expectation on Bilbo alone. He would have to apologize for that later.

Bilbo looked at him worriedly, and as he passed by, he spoke softly under his breath. “Stay steady, Thorin.”

He couldn’t find the words to respond, so he let out a shuddering breath and watched as his friends disappeared one by one. He had no idea how long it would be before he got to see them again. And with Bilbo captured, too… Thorin would be well and truly alone down in that dark cell in the deepest part of the dungeon if he didn’t succeed in negotiating their way out.

As soon as the Company was out of sight, their footsteps still echoing through the caverns, the guards who remained with Thorin surrounded him and they started walking again.

He recognized the path well enough to know where it would take them.

Their arrival to the throne room was much the same as it had been the first time around. Thranduil sat languidly upon that ridiculous throne of his that stood at least ten feet above the floor and required a staircase to get to, a glass of deep red wine in one hand, his clothes and jewelry shimmering in the bright lamplight of the room.

The elf king watched them file into the room through half-lidded pale eyes, looking for all the world entirely disinterested in them.

The guards stopped at the entrance, effectively blocking his only exit, but Thorin continued on until he reached the middle of the room. He stood tall with his head held high and met the King’s gaze challengingly.

Thranduil blinked at him slowly then turned his head away and drank from his glass.

Bristling, Thorin had to bite his tongue to stop himself from spitting out any words he would probably come to regret. He waited there in silence, watching as Thranduil slowly drained the wine. It wasn’t until the drink was gone and a servant stepped forward from behind the throne to take the empty glass that Thranduil finally turned his attention back to the dwarf standing before him. They stared at each other for several moments and Thorin refused to look away.

“Some may imagine that a noble quest is at hand. A quest to reclaim a homeland and slay a dragon. I myself suspect a more prosaic motive. Attempted burglary, or something of that ilk.”

Thorin glowered at the elf. He had heard this little speech before, of course, but he still didn’t appreciate the suggestion that he and his Company were nothing but thieves. Still, he forced himself to keep his silence.

Thranduil leaned forward, looking down on him as if he were a speck of dirt of the polished floor. “You have found a way in. You seek that which would bestow upon you the right to rule. A King’s jewel. The Arkensto—”

At the mention of the stone, Thorin felt his thin thread of control begin to fray. “We seek a home that is rightfully ours. I do not need a sparkling stone to tell me I am the true King. I have earned that right over a hundred and seventy years of leading my people through peril and poverty.”

He ignored the small voice in the back of his mind that said he was a liar—that he would never be king without the stone in his possession—and kept his focus on Thranduil.

The elf’s expression was unreadable, though one of his eyebrows raised ever so slightly. His voice, however, held a thinly veiled tone of condescension. “And yet, there is no army at your back. Tell me, Thorin son of Thrain, son of Thror, if you truly do not need the stone to be King, then why have your people not answered the call to take back their home?"

“We have lost enough to dragon-fire,” Thorin said lowly.

“And what makes you think they will not be soon losing their King as well, when he insists on walking straight into a dragon’s hoard with nothing more than twelve dwarves and a halfling?”

“Hobbit.”

“What?”

“He is a hobbit. He is not half of anything.”

Thranduil studied him closely for a moment, something like curiosity flitting across his face for a brief moment. Then the look was gone, replaced once again by cool indifference. “Tell me, why should I release you and risk the awakening of the dragon?”

“I would think you would be perfectly content to watch us be killed by Smaug. You were happy enough to do it once before.” Thorin couldn’t help but let the accusation slip, a vicious bite in his voice.

Thranduil’s eyes flashed dangerously and he sat back in his throne abruptly. Thorin didn’t miss the way the elf’s slender hands gripped the armrests tighter, his knuckles going white. He wasn’t quite sure what it was about the words that elicited the change, but he felt a spark of satisfaction that he had obviously hit a nerve.

A minute or two passed by in silence before either of them spoke again.

“Perhaps we can come to an agreement.”

He braced himself, knowing what was going to come next.

“Within that mountain lies something that I, too, desire. A chest of White Gems of pure starlight. Swear to return them to me, and I will let you go.” The elf king’s voice was casual enough, but he saw the greed lying just under the surface.

Thorin bit down on his tongue to stop himself from letting his initial reply escape.

Stay steady, Thorin, a familiar voice said in the back of his mind.

Bilbo. The hobbit knew it would come to this, somehow. As they were leaving Beorn’s, he even tried to warn Thorin. Why he hadn’t just said it outright, Thorin didn’t know, but it wasn’t important right now. What was important was that Bilbo knew how easily he might lose his temper and condemn them all. And he knew that he didn’t want to let Bilbo down. He didn’t want to let any of them down.

The Company was counting on him, and they were worth more than his own pride. It was a small price to pay.

Drawing in a steadying breath, Thorin forced himself to speak, albeit begrudgingly. “A box of Gems is well worth our freedom.”

Thranduil’s gaze was heavy on him. “Do you swear it?”

Thorin held the elf’s stare, considering.

Careful. He had to be careful here.

Steady, Thorin.

“If I swear to return your Gems, you will swear to release all fourteen members of my Company, return our weapons to us, and allow us to leave your kingdom unhindered.”

The ghost of a smirk pulled up at the corner of Thranduil’s mouth, as if the specific wording of Thorin’s demand amused him. “I will release all thirteen dwarves and the hobbit and will allow you to leave, yes.”

Thorin’s eyes narrowed. “And our weapons?”

“I will return them all.” Thranduil paused for half a moment, then spoke again. “All but two. The elvish blades you carried when my scouts caught you will remain with me until the White Gems are returned, as insurance to compel you to keep your word.”

His stomach tightened, as if he had swallowed a rock, and he had to slam back the wave of fury that rose in him at the words.

Orcrist and Sting.

He had no desire to part with his sword, and had no doubt Bilbo would feel the same. After all, the hobbit had gone through the effort to reclaim the two blades when they were passing through the Trollshaws. But would Bilbo be willing to give up Sting if it meant the Company’s freedom?

As much as he hated it, Thorin knew the answer to that question would be a firm yes.

Steadying himself, Thorin looked up at the elf king sitting high above him and grit his teeth. “It is a deal.”

“Very well.” Thranduil relaxed back in his throne, looking satisfied, and motioned for the elves that still stood a silent guard at the entrance. “In one week hence, you will be released from my dungeons.”

It took a moment for the words to sink in, then Thorin lunged forward in outrage just as the guards reached him and held him back. “You gave your word!”

Thranduil looked thoroughly unimpressed at Thorin’s anger as he took a sip of his newly filled glass of wine that had just been placed in his hand. “And I will keep it. However, you come in a time of celebration and I have not the guards to spare to escort you and your Company to the borders of the Greenwood.”

“We need no escort! Bring us to the path and we will leave ourselves!”

“And allow a bunch of dwarves to wander freely through my kingdom? I think not.”

Thorin swore at him, but the King gave no reaction.

“You have one week, Thorin Oakenshield. I suggest you rest while you have the chance.”

Notes:

Du-bekâr -- to arms

kakhuf inbarathrag -- goat turd

 

As always, the khuzdul came from the Dwarrow Scholar

Chapter 20: A Small Blade is Better Than None

Summary:

The Company is on their way out of Mirkwood when they're attacked once again, but at least they're not in barrels.

Notes:

This chapter didn't get a lot of editing. I hope it doesn't feel too choppy. Let me know if you notice any mistakes! :)

 

Edit: Thanks to Swirl_O_Whirl for pointing out that I had the timeline a little wrong concerning how long Bilbo had the Ring!

Chapter Text

The dungeon echoed with angry shouting and loud clangs as the cell doors slammed shut. Bilbo didn’t particularly care for being manhandled by an elf, so he slipped into his cell without complaint and was soon followed by Gloin who had to be half thrown in. He reached out to help the dwarf get his balance before he fell, but Gloin was too busy grumbling something about ‘goblin mutants’ to acknowledge him.

Sighing, Bilbo stepped around him to take a look outside.

On the other side of the narrow chasm, he watched the red-haired guard captain as she led Kili to a cell where Fili was already sitting on the floor and glaring at the wall across from him—they’d managed to find all of his daggers and knives, then.

The younger prince didn’t need to be forced into the cell, but he paused on the threshold and turned to the elf. Bilbo couldn’t hear what was said, but the elf’s lips twitched into something of a smile before pointing at the cell again. She closed the door behind Kili and there was a goofy grin on his face as he watched her walk away.

Bilbo snorted and shook his head. He hadn’t ever interacted with the elf on the first journey, but he remembered Bofur telling him about their time in Lake-town when Smaug attacked. Apparently, she showed up to heal Kili’s wound from the orc arrow he’d taken in the knee during their trip down the river and afterwards Kili was none too subtle about his adoration for her. He also remembered that she witnessed the youngest Durin’s death and was found crying over his body when the battle was over. After that, no one knew where she had gone. She just disappeared.

He often wished that he’d had the chance to speak with her at least once before she left. They both lost someone they loved on that dreadful day, after all, and he felt that she might have understood his pain better than anyone else.

Bilbo’s chest tightened and he immediately pushed the thought away. What did it matter? They were all alive and well, yet, and he had every intention of keeping it that way. There was no point in dwelling on a past that no longer existed.

So he turned his attention back to the present.

He could only see a fraction of the Company from where he stood, but he knew they were all there. He counted them during their long walk through the elvish kingdom and made sure that none of them looked to be seriously injured. To his relief, everyone seemed to be alright, save some scrapes and bruises.

As soon as all the cell doors were closed, the elves disappeared and the Company was left alone. The noise didn’t subside at all, though.

Several dwarves were shouting, their voices bouncing off the stone walls of the dungeon.

In the cell directly above the two princes, Dwalin was trying to use his body as a battering ram against the steel bars holding him prisoner and was spitting out a string of curses in khuzdul of which Bilbo understood just enough to recognize that they were particularly nasty ones.

It went on for a minute or so before Balin’s voice rose above the din. “Enough! There is no way out! No one leaves here but by the King’s consent.”

That was enough to silence them all. Even Gloin stopped his grumbling.

With that, Bilbo lowered himself to the floor and leaned back against the hard wall, stretching his sore legs out in front of him.

They were quiet for a long while. Then, eventually, Bofur’s voice spoke up rather hesitantly.

“Where d’you suppose they’ve taken him?”

Balin’s face appeared before the bars of the cell he shared with his brother and his gaze was fixed on the next level up above where Bilbo was.

“To meet with King Thranduil, I expect,” the old dwarf said, sounding more than a little put out at the thought.

Bilbo couldn’t blame him. He wasn’t too thrilled at the idea of Thorin speaking with that conceited ponce of a King all on his own, either. The dwarf was liable to lose his temper at any moment in the elf’s presence, and then where would they be?

Stuck there in that dungeon forever, probably.

Or until Gandalf eventually reappeared and convinced Thranduil to release them.

Either way, if Thorin couldn’t keep his anger in check, their chances weren’t looking good.

This was exactly what he had been afraid of.

Bilbo felt a flash of guilt and his hand slipped into his pocket of its own accord, wrapping his fingers around the little pouch that resided there. Then he pursed his lips. Maybe it was selfish of him to refuse to put on the Ring to help the Company. If he had, he could already be well on his way to helping them escape. Instead, there he was, just as trapped as the rest of them. But there was nothing for it. He couldn’t stand the thought of wearing that accursed Ring again. Actually, the idea terrified him. He couldn’t help but fear that he would once again be caught under its influence, and if that happened…

Bilbo couldn’t shake the feeling that the Ring was stronger now. It didn’t make the slightest bit of sense—and for the life of him, he couldn’t figure out how or why—but the Ring knew more than it should. It spoke more than it should. And it recognized him. And if he put it on and allowed it into his head, he shuddered to think what would happen.

The truth was, he didn’t know if he would be able to resist it.

Even after sixty years of carrying it with him wherever he went, using it to avoid relatives and for cheap party tricks, somehow this time was different.

He could not—would not—put it on ever again.

Even if that meant he had to find a different way to get through this quest.

 

***

 

It couldn’t have been more than an hour when the elvish guards reappeared with Thorin in tow. And Bilbo felt a spark of hope. If they were bringing Thorin to be with the rest of the Company rather than isolating him in a lonely cell far below, surely that was a good sign.

The moment they came into sight at the top of the stairs, someone let out a whoop and then everyone was crowding up to their cell doors to call out a greeting to their leader and jeer at the elves leading him. Bilbo scrambled to his feet and wrapped his hands around two of the bars, and when the group of four passed his cell, Thorin paused and met his gaze despite the elves urging him onward.

“How did it go?” he asked quietly.

There was a stormy look in Thorin’s eyes and he grimaced at the question, but he nodded in response.

Bilbo felt himself deflate a bit in relief.

Once Thorin was out of sight—it sounded like he was put in a cell two or three down from his own—he turned away from the door, intent on returning to his spot on the ground, but he paused when he found Gloin standing directly behind him.

The dwarf had an odd look on his face and he looked at Bilbo scrutinizingly. He stared back for a few moments, then shifted on his feet uncomfortably.

“What?”

Gloin’s eyes narrowed, but he shrugged and turned away. “It’s nothing.”

That was odd, but Bilbo didn’t have the energy to try and get an answer, so he shrugged too and sat down again.

 

***

 

Bilbo jolted awake in a cold sweat, heart hammering wildly and echoing in his ears. His eyes opened to find Gloin leaning over him, looking worried. Blinking, Bilbo looked around. It took several moments for him to recognize his surroundings and when he did, he let his head fall back against the wall with a dull thud and closed his eyes. The hand on his shoulder that had shaken him awake fell away and he heard the dwarf shuffle back to sit against the opposite wall.

The lights in the dungeon were dimmed, and he guessed it must be the middle of the night. He didn’t remember falling asleep. Given that he was still half sitting up with his back against the wall and a crick in his neck, sleep had likely come over him before he could take the time to at least try and find a more comfortable position. Not that it would have been easy, given that he was surrounded by nothing but stone walls and floors.

“Are you alright, lad?”

He opened his eyes again to look at Gloin, who was watching him closely. “I'm fine.”

The dwarf hummed, and for a moment, Bilbo thought he wouldn’t say anything more. Then he let out a long breath and spoke again, his voice a bit softer. “There’s no shame in it.”

“Sorry?”

“Bad dreams,” the dwarf said. “We all get them from time to time. Especially after everything we’ve been through over the past few months. None of us would think any less of you for it.”

Bilbo blinked, then sat up a little straighter, stifling a groan as his stiff muscles pulled and a twinge went through his neck. He couldn’t help the small bit of surprise at the admission.

If he noticed, the sincerity on Gloin's face didn’t waver. “If you ever need to talk about it, my ears are open. And I’ve no doubt the same goes for the rest of the Company. Well...except Oin, of course.” He chuckled a bit at that.

Gloin had always been kind to him, even if he hadn’t been as close to the dwarf as some of the others. At least, not until several decades after the quest was over and they met again in Rivendell. They became good friends there in the valley of elves, catching each other up on their lives since they’d last seen one another at the gates of Erebor. Then, after the Ring was destroyed and the Fellowship returned, Bilbo helped the dwarf work through the emotional turmoil of finding out that his son was going to marry an elf—an elf who was the “spawn” of Thranduil, no less.

He smiled slightly at the memory. “Thank you, Gloin. Truly.”

“Bah! Don’t thank me.” Gloin waved away the thanks, though he did give Bilbo a half smile in return and his voice softened again. “It’s no less than I’d do for any of the others.”

 

***

 

As glad as Bilbo was to be leaving the halls of Mirkwood behind them—and as relieved as he was that Thorin actually managed to keep his head and work out a deal with Thranduil—he wasn’t particularly pleased that it came at the price of Sting. He told himself that it was a necessary sacrifice and that, really, it wasn’t forever, as long as Thranduil deigned to keep his word and return the elvish blades once the White Gems were returned to him. Still, it didn’t change the fact that without the familiar weight of his sword on his hip, Bilbo felt rather exposed. He supposed he should at least be grateful that his mother’s dagger was returned to him, along with the rest of the Company’s weapons. Given the circumstances, they had gotten off fairly well.

Quickening his pace a little, he said as much to Thorin.

The dwarf had been in an incredibly stormy mood ever since they were released from the dungeons nearly two hours ago. In part because of Orcrist, but also because Thranduil insisted on sending them with an escort out of the woods.

Thorin snorted, but didn’t give a reply, and Bilbo followed his gaze to the front of the line where the Guard Captain was. Walking beside her was Kili, and the young dwarf prince was perfectly happy to jabber on in conversation with the red-haired elf.

Rolling his eyes, Bilbo elbowed Thorin in the ribs. “Don’t get your knickers in a bunch. This isn’t so bad.”

“I fail to see anything good about the situation,” Thorin grumbled, moving out of Bilbo’s reach.

“Well, maybe not. But it could certainly be worse.” When the dwarf didn’t say anything, Bilbo tugged on his sleeve and shot a pointed glance towards the river. “At least it’s not barrels.”

To his satisfaction, the corner of Thorin’s mouth twitched slightly. “I seem to remember that the barrels were your idea.”

“True. But personally, I find walking to be much more to my liking.”

“Leave it to you to plan a prison-break involving white water rapids when you cannot swim. When we finally made it to the bank, there were a few minutes where I was sure you had drowned.”

Bilbo made an indignant sound at that, but there was nothing he could say in argument, so he opted for elbowing him in the ribs again. “At least I had a plan. You were going to sit there in the dark forever out of spite. Besides, I had to get you bumbling lot out somehow.”

Finally, Thorin tore his gaze away from the odd pair at the front of the group and looked at him. He gave Bilbo a slight smile. “This is true. I am not sure we ever would have gotten out if not for you.” Thorin paused, then something in his eyes darkened and his smile fell. When he spoke again, his voice was much quieter. “Speaking of which, I have been meaning to ask you how you knew you would not be able to evade the elves this time.”

Bilbo drew in a sharp breath and his chest tightened. On instinct, his hand drifted to his pocket. “Er, well, you see…”

He had yet to come up with a suitable answer to the question, though he had anticipated it would come sooner or later.

Luckily, they were interrupted and he was given the excuse he needed not to answer.

Unluckily, they were being attacked by orcs.

The moment the first orc showed its ugly face, Thorin drew his sword—the dwarven made one he’d been carrying before the trolls—and shoved Bilbo behind him. He cried out in protest, though he had to admit that his little dagger really didn’t give him a very good advantage against the grotesque creatures appearing from every direction. Still, it was better than nothing.

Moreso, it was very good that the elves had returned the dwarves’ weapons because given the numbers of orcs coming out of the trees, their small troop of elvish escorts wouldn’t be enough to fight them all off on their own.

Thorin wasn’t able to shield him for long, and it was hardly a minute before they were surrounded and Bilbo turned so that they could fight back to back. Small as it may be, his dagger was certainly a help.

A particularly nasty looking orc lunged at him and Bilbo ducked, avoiding the jagged blade by mere inches. Missing him threw the orc off balance and Bilbo took his chance. He grabbed the orcs arm and pulled, making it stumble towards him, then sank his dagger hilt deep into its chest. For half a moment, the orc stared at him with hate filled eyes before it let out a gurgling noise and slumped dead to the ground. He pulled the dagger out and swung around just in time to make a deep slice across another orc’s abdomen as it hurtled past and a moment later a swing of Thorin’s sword sent its head flying.

It went on like that for what felt like forever, and Bilbo found himself beginning to slip. He hardly noticed that he and Thorin were steadily drifting apart from one another—it was all he could do to continue dodging attacks and wielding the dagger. He was breathing hard and his arm was beginning to ache terribly, but he kept going. Until he heard a scream that most definitely did not belong to any orc. He faltered and whipped his head around, trying to see who it was. The distraction cost him.

He saw the orc from the corner of his eye. Saw it raise a heavy club in the air, ready to deal a killing blow. For a moment, he was sent back to the Misty Mountains on that damned cliff where he’d gotten beat over the head. He’d escaped with a concussion last time, but he didn’t think he would be so lucky again. He wasn’t fast enough to try and block the blow.

Flinching, Bilbo stumbled back a few steps, fully expecting to feel his skull shatter in on itself.

But something odd happened.

Just as it was about to bring its arm down in a blow that would surely kill him, the orc went sprawling to the ground and slammed face first into a rock. It didn’t get up again.

Wide eyed, Bilbo stared in amazement.

Dwalin, who had appeared from the fray and seemed to have been readying himself to bury his axe into the orc’s back stood frozen for a moment as well, looking just as surprised as Bilbo felt.

But Bilbo wasn’t looking at him.

He was staring at the ground near the unfortunate orc’s feet, where he was nearly certain he had seen a tree root move just enough to trip his would-be killer.

Dwalin recovered much quicker than he himself did and sprang forward to slam his axe into another orc’s gut as it went for Bilbo, and when it doubled over, he split the creature’s head open down the middle for good measure. Bilbo didn’t get the chance to give the dwarf any sort of thanks before he felt himself being swept off his feet.

“Time to go, hobbit!”

He let out a rather undignified yelp as the world spun around him for a moment, then he found himself hanging over Dwalin’s shoulder like a sack of potatoes. He got his breath back after a moment then yelled, “pardon me! Put me down!”

The dwarf didn’t respond. Dwalin was holding onto him with one arm, and with the other he wielded his axe, mowing down orcs left and right as he ran through the fray. All the while, Bilbo was bouncing against his shoulder, and he was sure his ribs would be bruised by the time it was all over.

One advantage of being treated like luggage was that his position gave him a better view point of what was going on, though it was difficult to really focus on anything given how much he was being jolted around. From what he could tell, though, the orcs were beginning to find themselves outnumbered as more and more of them fell or fled. Then they hurtled past a cluster of boulders, and atop them stood two archers, taking advantage of the higher ground.

It was a sight that was almost poetic, worthy of songs and great stories—an elf and a dwarf, fighting as One despite centuries of hostility between their two peoples. Kili and Tauriel fired arrow after arrow, working together to clear the river banks of orcs. When one started to pursue Dwalin, she took it out with an arrow straight through the left eye. At the same time, when an orc set its sights on Legolas, the young dwarven prince didn’t hesitate a second before he brought it down.

There was no room for petty feuds between them. Not in that moment.

For some reason, Bilbo felt a burst of pride at the sight. But the feeling was short lived as he realized where the scream had come from.

Bilbo hadn’t noticed just how far he had been separated from everyone. The majority of the Company, including Thorin, had placed themselves into a protective circle and were fighting off whatever orcs were left. In the middle of them all, Dori laid on the ground motionless, with Oin hovering over him. He couldn’t tell where the injury was, but he could see blood. A lot of blood.

Fear gripped him so tightly that by the time Dwalin finally put him down, he didn’t even try to kick the dwarf in the shins. Rather, he immediately ran towards Thorin and landed a foot on the back of an orc’s knee, causing it to fall. Thorin stuck his sword through the orc's middle then yanked out the blade and shoved the body out of the way. He panted out a thanks to Bilbo, but he ignored it.

“What happened?” he yelled as he and Thorin both spun towards the same orc. Bilbo caught it in the ribs and Thorin its neck.

“I do not know,” he said, jaw clenched tightly. “I did not see.”

Bilbo hazarded a glance back at the white haired dwarf, who he hoped was only unconscious. Then he tripped back a few steps when Thorin grabbed his arm and tugged him out of the way of the swing of an orc’s sword—the blade would have gone straight through his middle. As it was, only the tip of it caught at his jacket.

“Focus, Bilbo!”

He forced himself to look away from his injured friend and nodded, and Thorin let go of him.

Over the next couple of minutes, the orc attack finally started to slow. Whether they were running out of forces or had made the decision to retreat, Bilbo didn’t know. Either way, he was grateful for it. He wasn’t sure how much longer he could keep it up.

Then, from the corner of his eye, he saw one of the few remaining orcs manage to knock Bofur to the ground and placed its foot on his chest to keep him down. It raised its jagged sword, a slash of a smile on its face.

A split second later, an arrow head protruded from its garish mouth. It froze, then its eyes rolled back into its head and it fell dead to the ground, barely missing landing directly on top of Bofur. The dwarf sat up, hat askew and looking a bit pale and looked around for the archer that saved him.

Bilbo did the same, immediately looking to where Tauriel and Kili were a few minutes before, but the two were gone.

Then he spotted movement about a dozen yards down the river and sighed in relief.

It was Bard.

Once it was all over, Bilbo found himself sitting beside Dwalin, watching from afar as Oin tended to Dori. There was a rather deep slice running from his right shoulder and halfway down his chest. At first, the entire Company crowded around their fallen friend, afraid that he was dead. Oin quickly put a stop to that, shouting at them that while Dori was still alive, he might not stay that way for long if they didn’t give him room to work. The only ones allowed to stay were Dori's brothers.

There were dwarves scattered along the riverbank, tending to their wounds, washing dirt and blood from their skin, or just resting. Quickly after Oin shooed them all away, Thorin and Balin went to speak with Bard—presumably to procure safe passage to Lake-town. They were far enough away that Bilbo couldn’t hear their conversation, but the man had a sour look on his face that suggested he wasn’t too happy about whatever the dwarves were saying.

He himself was unharmed, despite a few close calls. Which reminded him…

He shot a glare at Dwalin, who was currently cleaning his axes with a bloodied rag. “What was that for?”

The dwarf just raised a brow and didn’t look at him. “What was what for?”

Bilbo snorted. “You know perfectly well what I’m talking about. I was doing just fine, thank you very much!”

For several moments, the dwarf didn’t respond, then he set his axe down so it was resting across his lap and turned to Bilbo. He studied him for a moment, then nodded.

“Aye, you were doing beautifully. You remembered your lessons well.”

Bilbo blinked, caught off guard by the compliment, but it didn’t deter him from wanting an answer to his question. He gave Dwalin a pointed look and the dwarf rolled his eyes.

“Look, your safety and Thorin’s safety is my top priority. And you were in the middle of it all on your own. I won’t apologize for getting you out.”

“I don’t see you throwing Thorin over your shoulder like a sack of potatoes,” Bilbo grumbled irritably. Dwalin had a point, of course, but he still didn’t appreciate being treated like some damsel in distress.

Dwalin huffed out what may have been a laugh if not for the exhaustion that was in it. “One, trying to carry Thorin like that would be like carrying a boulder. I’d break my back. Two, Thorin would strangle me if I so much as tried. And three,” he paused and looked Bilbo straight in the eye, his voice taking on an odd tone. “If anything happens to you, Bilbo, it will destroy him. I can’t afford to rely on your unusual good luck to ensure that doesn’t happen.”

The dwarf shot a glance over to where the Company’s leader was still dealing with the bargeman—for some reason, Legolas had joined in on their conversation. Odd, but Bilbo didn’t have enough attention to spare to wonder why. For a moment, Bilbo was confused, then he noticed the look in Dwalin’s eye and immediately felt his face get hot.

“I-I’m not sure I quite know what you’re talking about.”

Dwalin didn’t respond. He just gave Bilbo a look that suggested he wasn’t at all convinced, then he stood and walked away—headed towards Ori, it seemed. The young dwarf was sitting several feet away from Dori, with visible tear tracks running down his dirty face. He was staring at the ground blankly, like the world around him didn’t exist. It was his scream that Bilbo heard earlier. Poor Ori saw his brother be cut down by the orc.

He watched Dwalin go, then sniffed and looked away, pointedly making the effort not to look in a certain dwarf king’s general direction. The tips of his ears still felt hot thanks to Dwalin’s unspoken suggestion that Thorin actually had some sort of feelings for their Company’s resident burglar.

It was an absurd idea, really. Thorin was a king—or at least, he would be, if Bilbo had any say in the matter. What possible reason could he have to hold any kind of affection for a simple hobbit? They were close, certainly. Even more so, now that they knew they weren’t alone in their mission to save the Line of Durin, but that didn’t mean there was anything more between them than friendship.

Absurd, indeed.

He decided to ignore whatever part of him that was saying otherwise.

He didn’t have time to entertain his silly infatuation. There were more important things to worry about—like figuring out how they could get rid of Smaug without sacrificing the poor people of Lake-town, and how to ensure that the entire Company stayed alive so Thorin could be crowned King. And after that, well…

Unconsciously, Bilbo let his hand drift to his pocket to touch the little pouch that resided within. Or, he would have, if the pouch was there.

He looked down at the tattered scrap of his coat, remembering the orc that tried to cut him in half earlier.

There was a giant, gaping hole in Bilbo’s pocket.

Panic seized him immediately and he jumped to his feet, searching the ground around him for the little pouch that he’d been carrying since Beorn’s, but he didn’t see it anywhere.

The Ring was gone.

Bilbo whirled around and scanned the river bank, trying to pinpoint where he was standing when the orc cut his jacket. But everything happened so quickly, and it wasn’t as though he was really focused on his location. He had been rather busy avoiding any fatal stab wounds. So he started walking in that general direction, frantically looking at the ground as he went. It didn’t help that the pouch was brown. It would blend in pretty much everywhere!

His chest tightened and his breathing grew quicker as he felt more and more that he wasn’t getting enough air.

This was very, very bad.

The Company would be leaving soon—once they convinced Bard to give them transport and Oin decided they could safely move Dori. But Bilbo couldn’t leave without the Ring. It was too important for the future survival of Middle Earth. If it fell into the wrong hands…

Bilbo knew this would happen. He expected the Ring to try and make its way to another after he made his intention of its destruction perfectly clear. Why hadn’t he done more to ensure that it wouldn’t get away? Surely he could have put it somewhere safer than his jacket pocket.

The full panic had nearly set in when Bilbo’s gaze landed on a particular dwarf, half a dozen yards away from where he stood.

He watched as Kili bent and picked something up from the ground, inspecting it curiously in the palm of his hand. There was no reason for Bilbo to think it was the pouch. No reason but the faraway look in Kili’s eyes. It reminded him of how Thorin looked when he picked the Ring up in the Goblin Tunnels.

Bilbo practically sprinted over to Kili and snatched the pouch from the young dwarf’s hands just as he was about to open it. “Oh, good, you found it! I’ve been looking for it everywhere!”

His voice was a little too high pitched for it to sound convincing, but Kili didn’t seem to notice. He scowled at Bilbo for a short second, then blinked and the expression disappeared, replaced by confusion.

“What is it?” Kili asked, his eyes still fixed on the pouch.

Bilbo slipped the pouch into the pocket of his trousers—he would find a better way to carry it soon—and gave the dwarf a tight smile. “A good luck charm from the Shire. I know it’s a rather silly thing to be carrying around, but it’s comforting to me.”

“Good luck charm.” Kili repeated, his eyes locked on Bilbo’s pocket. His voice sounded distant. “But it feels—”

At that moment, Thorin’s voice echoed over the area, calling for everyone to gather so they could leave.

Bilbo thanked Yavanna for the timing and hurried to rejoin the rest of the Company.

Chapter 21: Secrets Yet Unspoken

Summary:

After a few relatively calm days in Laketown, the quiet will soon come to an end when certain truths are finally spoken aloud.

Notes:

Spring semester starts on monday, so I'll be back to classes and work, but I'm hoping I can at least get the next chapter up before then. No promises.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

To say that Thorin was annoyed was an understatement.

True, his and Balin’s negotiations with Bard hadn’t been going very smoothly. Somehow, the man was even more distrustful now than he had been on the first journey—despite the fact that they weren’t even fugitives from the elves this time around. He wasn’t too agreeable to the idea of transporting a group of dwarves who had just been attacked by orcs. What difference it made was beyond Thorin, but the man was adamant that he would not carry them to Lake-town. And true, Bard was being so stubborn, he hadn’t even been sure if they could sway him or not.

But that did not mean he in any way appreciated elves sticking their noses into his business.

After they had been arguing with the man for a good ten minutes, Legolas appeared from wherever he and the rest of his guards had run off to, looking for all the world that he hadn’t just been involved in a fight with orcs—there wasn’t even a strand of hair out of place—and interrupted their conversation. Apparently, the elvish princeling and Bard knew each other to some extent and it only took a short, terse exchange between the two before Bard finally agreed to allow the dwarves onto his barge.

Eventually, Thorin might acknowledge the fact that if Thranduil’s spawn had gone so far as to procure them passage to Lake-town, then the White Gems might be a much more valuable bargaining chip than he originally imagined. But for now, he was rather set on being angry about it.

The fact that they had just sustained their first major injury of the journey did nothing to help his sour mood.

Oin said that Dori would survive, though the dwarf’s wound would take some time to fully heal, and he would be left with a significant scar. Dori, thank Mahal, was awake and present enough to be annoyed with the Company’s fussing, though he didn’t have the strength to stop them when they piled him with every blanket and cloak they could to protect him from the bitter cold of the lake. Presently, he was sitting near the back of the barge with his brothers on either side of him, looking incredibly pale and incredibly grouchy.

Though Thorin was in no way happy that one of his Company was hurt, he was silently grateful that it wasn’t Kili. On the last journey, the younger of his sister-sons had been shot in the leg by an orc arrow during their escape down the river and by the time they made it back to solid land, Thorin was already too caught up in the growing gold-sickness to take the time to allow the wound to be properly tended to. He was so focused on reaching Erebor as soon as possible that he went as far as leaving members of the Company behind in his haste, including Fili and Kili. They joined them in Erebor later, after the death of the dragon, but Thorin never actually bothered to ask how Kili’s leg healed so quickly.

It was just another of his many failings on the quest, and a mistake that he refused to make again, no matter who was injured and what the circumstances were—he would not leave anyone behind.

Thorin stood at the front of the barge, staring into the mists ahead and only half listening as the others went about gathering the funds they needed to pay their unwilling transport for his services. It seemed Gloin was arguing again, though he knew that it wouldn’t last for long.

Soon enough, the fog parted. He didn’t have to turn around to know that the ensuing silence meant that the Company had seen what he was watching for.

The Lonely Mountain stood tall in the distance.

He knew from experience that the others’ silence was caused by reverence, but the sight only made his stomach tighten painfully with a sense of foreboding.

Thorin didn’t even notice Bilbo’s presence until a warm hand took his and he tore his gaze away from the mountain to look down at him. The look on his face was hard to read, so full of conflicting emotions that Thorin wasn’t sure if it was longing, grief, or dread in the hobbit’s eyes—maybe it was all three. He remembered that Bilbo never once returned to Erebor after it was reclaimed.

With a lump in his throat, he held Bilbo’s hand tighter and prayed they would soon have the chance to look upon Erebor with hope for the future rather than fear of the past.

That this time, things would be different.

 

***

 

They had been in Lake-town for three days. Three days of sleeping in actual beds—threadbare and thin as they may be—and of having a roof over their heads, and Thorin was grateful for it. At least, he much preferred this to hiding out in Bard’s house and sneaking around town like fugitives.

Upon reaching Lake-town, they were allowed through the checkpoint without issue—apparently, a letter from King Thranduil of Mirkwood was enough to get them into Lake-town and taken straight to the Master, no smuggling inside barrels of fish required. He resented being grateful for it, but Thorin wasn’t sure they would have been able to pull off sneaking in given the shape that Dori was in. When Legolas had even given the letter to Bard, he had no idea. He hadn’t seen it during their “negotiations” and he certainly had no idea what was written in it.

As it turned out, the sight of thirteen dwarves and a hobbit trooping through town led by four of the Master’s guards and his deputy—that greasy little weasel of a man—was a strange enough occurrence that by the time they made it to the town hall, crowds were already gathered to see what was going on.

That served Thorin’s purpose well enough, seeing as the Master was more likely to be generous if he had a crowd to cheer him on.

His assumption was correct.

The speech he gave about sharing in the wealth of Erebor did its job in getting the people excited about the Company’s presence. Paired with the elf’s letter, no one even bothered questioning his identity or his honor. Even without it, he still silently vowed to himself that this time, he would fulfill his oath. The people of Lake-town deserved better lives just as much as his own people did—they had all suffered great losses thanks to the dragon—and he intended to do everything he could to ensure that they would all thrive once again.

All in all, their negotiations with the Master went over well, though the man wasn't too thrilled when Thorin declined the offer of a feast in his honor and asked instead to be provided shelter for a week as they made their preparations to move on to the mountain. Despite his dismay, the Master was unable to refuse the request with the entire town as his audience, so he set the Company up in a two-story house near the edge of town. The house was furnished, yet apparently unoccupied, and Thorin had the distinct impression that whoever lived there previously had been evicted—though there was enough dust about that he assumed the house had been standing empty for some time.

The thought made him feel guilty, especially considering how many people were left homeless and living outside, unprotected from the harsh weather. His only comfort was that with the dragon gone and Erebor reinhabited by the dwarves, this town would soon be rebuilt and made prosperous once again.

Still, he was glad that for this last leg of their journey before facing the dragon, the Company would have the chance to get some proper rest—there was no question they needed it.

Thorin, however, was struggling to take advantage of the rare instance of down-time they had been given. He was just as tired as everyone else, but there was far too much on his mind for him to get any kind of peace. There they were on the brink of finishing their journey—after facing trolls, and elves, and orcs, and spiders, and a myriad of other nasty things—yet the true danger of the quest hadn’t even begun. No, they had merely just begun to toe at the edge of a cliff so steep that if they fell, there would be no climbing back up again.

He wondered how long it would take for the ledge to crumble beneath their boots and send them plummeting. Somehow, the fall had been less terrifying the first time, before he knew what they would face as soon as they reached the bottom. They would have to hit the ground running if they wanted any chance of survival.

The mere thought of it was exhausting.

Wandering through the house on his way to the kitchen, Thorin was confused at how quiet it was until he remembered that a large chunk of the Company planned on going out into town that afternoon. They invited him to go along, but the thought of pushing his way through a marketplace crowded full of men and stinking of dead fish was anything but appealing, so he declined. Plus, with the house mostly empty, it would give him a good opportunity to speak with a certain hobbit alone and without interruption.

If Thorin had been restless over the past few days, then Bilbo was full of pure nervous energy. The hobbit seemed to be incapable of staying still for more than a few minutes at a time. Sure enough, when he peeked into the kitchen, it was to see Bilbo standing in the middle of the room, bouncing on his toes and staring at a large pot hanging over the fireplace.

Thorin watched him for a second or two, then took a few steps into the room. “Bilbo, do you have a moment to—”

The moment he spoke, Bilbo jumped slightly, as if he hadn’t noticed him come in, then interrupted him before he could finish.

“Oh, Thorin! I’m glad you’re here!” The hobbit scooped a large mug off the counter and shoved it into Thorin’s hands. “Could you do me a favor and take this up to Dori?”

He blinked down at the steaming mug, then looked back to Bilbo. “Actually, I was hoping to—”

“I came down here to get it for him, but then Bombur had to run to the market and asked me to keep an eye on his pot so it doesn’t boil over. By the time I get the chance to bring it up, the tea will be cold.” As he spoke, Bilbo turned back to the pot and stirred it a few times.

“But—”

“It will only take a minute.”

Giving up, Thorin stifled a heavy sigh and nodded. He had been meaning to check in on their injured friend at some point, anyways, and he had a sneaking suspicion that Bilbo was a bit too distracted to have a conversation. “Is there anything else he needed?”

“No, that’s it. Thank you.”

Thorin hesitated at the threshold of the room and glanced back over his shoulder. “Bilbo?”

“Hm?”

“I would like to speak with you, when you have the time.”

“Sure, alright.”

The response was less than reassuring, and he wasn’t even sure Bilbo actually heard him, but Thorin let it go and headed for the stairs. He had waited this long to talk to Bilbo about what was on his mind. What difference could a little more time make?

At the top on the stairs, Thorin turned left into the hallway and stopped at the second door on the right. It was cracked open, but he tapped on the door anyway and waited for an invitation to go inside. The room was small, barely big enough to have two beds pushed against either wall and still have walking space in between.

Dori was in the bed on the left, beneath the one tiny window, with several layers of blankets piled on top of him. As soon as Thorin entered, the dwarf opened his eyes and blinked at him several times before noticing what he carried.

“I brought you some tea.”

Immediately, he began struggling to sit up and Thorin hurried forward, setting the mug down on the bedside table so he could help. Once Dori was propped up against his pillow, Thorin handed him the tea then sat on the edge of the other bed.

Grumbling his thanks, Dori took a sip of his drink then relaxed a little, slumping back against the pillow with a groan.

“How are you feeling?”

“Stiff and sore, but better than I was.” His voice was a little hoarse when he spoke.

“I am glad to hear it.”

The two dwarves fell quiet while Dori drank his tea, and Thorin took the moment to study him closely. He hadn’t yet gotten the chance to speak with Dori since the fight at the river—mainly due to Oin’s insistence that nobody was allowed in the room except for himself and the two younger Ri brothers—and he was glad to see that the rest was doing him some good. Dori was still a little paler than usual, but his eyes were as sharp and focused as always and his hands didn’t shake as he held the mug to drink. His hair had been re-braided at some point, though the braids which were normally immaculate looked slightly sloppy. Ori had likely been the one to fix his brother’s hair, Thorin supposed, seeing as Dori’s shoulder was in no shape to be put under any kind of strain. The young scribe had been practically glued to Dori’s bedside—much to Oin’s ire, no doubt—and hardly left him over the past few days other than to fetch food and water. Thorin was honestly a little surprised that the others managed to coax Ori out of the room, let alone out of the house entirely.

Thorin continued his musing until Dori finished the tea, and he took the empty mug and set it aside.

After a few moments of thought, he asked, “will you be healed enough to make the trip to Erebor come the end of this week?”

Dori tensed up immediately and there was a defensive tone in his voice when he responded. “I’m fine! Don’t you dare get any ideas about leaving me here.”

“Relax. I have no intention of leaving you behind, my friend.” He shook his head to rid himself of the image of Kili’s betrayed eyes looking up at him, then smiled and leaned forward to brace his arms on his knees. “I simply want to be sure you feel confident you can make it. We will have to keep a fast pace if we want to reach the mountain by Durin’s Day, and there will be the dragon to deal with after that. It is your choice, and I will respect whatever decision you make. As will the rest of the Company. No one will think any less of you for needing more time to heal.”

“I can do it.” Dori’s face was determined, leaving no room for argument.

Thorin nodded. The last time he’d done this, he was so focused on getting his hands on the Arkenstone, he forgot that everyone else had a personal stake in the quest as well. They all joined him on this journey for a reason, and he disregarded all of that the moment he saw the Lonely Mountain looming over the Long Lake.

Not this time.

He would gladly keep them all by his side as long as they wanted to stay.

Dragging himself out of his thoughts, he sat a little straighter. “I want you to focus on getting as much rest as you can in the meantime, then. And do whatever Oin tells you to.”

Dori grimaced and looked ready to protest, but Thorin held up a hand to stop him. “I know, but the more you listen to him now, the less time we will have to spend convincing him you are well enough to continue the journey when it comes time to leave.”

He had been at the old healer’s mercy enough times by now, he understood Dori’s dismay. Oin was positively ruthless when it came to bedrest and he wasn’t one to negotiate. Tough love was likely the most accurate way to describe it—but more often than not, it was just tough.

Still a little sour-faced, Dori looked ready to argue, but before he could say anything, the door swung open. Ori walked into the room, holding a large skein of grey-green yarn in his arms.

“Dori! Look what—” the young dwarf paused as soon as he noticed Thorin and his face went a little red. “Oh. Sorry, I didn’t mean to interrupt.”

“No need to apologize, I was just leaving.” Thorin shook his head and stood, then shot a glance at Dori. “Let us know if there are any supplies you need to get before we leave and we will try to find it for you.”

As Thorin stepped past Ori on his way to the door, he patted his shoulder and paused for a short moment. Smiling slightly, he nodded toward Dori. “Keep an eye on your brother and make sure he is listening to Oin, hm?”

Ori grinned at him and Thorin left the room, followed by Dori’s protests that he didn’t need anyone to keep an eye on him.

Thorin made it to the stairs the moment Dwalin reached the top step. All it took was one look at the smug smile on his best friend’s face for him to change direction and walk with him down the hall.

Keeping his voice casual, he asked, “and how many coins did you spend on that?”

“Does it matter?” Dwalin responded, then rolled his eyes when Thorin shot him a pointed look. “I couldn’t help it. He said it matched my eyes then got all sad when Nori said it was time to go. Besides, the woman at the stall gave me a discount.”

“I cannot imagine why. Certainly not for your good looks and charm,” Thorin said with a snort, jabbing his elbow into his ribs.

Dwalin shoved him back just hard enough to make him stumble before replying. “Ori spent a good ten minutes talking knitting patterns and complimenting her craft. Went straight over my head, but it buttered her up.”

“Softie.”

They stopped walking and stared at each other for a moment, then Dwalin said, “maybe I am, but you’ve got no room to talk. You take one look at the hobbit and get all doe-eyed. You don’t even try to hide it anymore.”

Thorin blinked. Then, before he could get another word in, Dwalin shot him a small smirk and walked into his room.

Scowling, Thorin continued to the next door and slipped through it, shutting it firmly behind him.

 

***

 

About an hour later, Thorin was in his room, peering out the little window that gave him an underwhelming view of a small alleyway below that was entirely deserted save for some barrels and litter strewn about the ground. If he pressed close to the glass and craned his head a little, though, it was possible to get a slight glimpse of the mountain standing in the distance. And that was exactly what he was doing—his breath fogging up the window pane and obscuring what little view he had of Erebor—when there was a quiet and unmistakable knock on his door.

He sighed and wiped the glass before turning his back on the window.

“Come in!”

Bilbo slipped into the room, his bare feet hardly making a sound against the hardwood floor.

Not for the first time, Thorin found himself wondering how the hobbit could stand walking around in such cold temperatures without boots to keep his feet warm—and he may have asked if it wasn’t for the anxious look on his friend’s face. Immediately, he felt a spike of worry and stood a little straighter.

“What is it? Are you alright?”

“Yes.” Bilbo stopped then shook his head. “Well, no. But yes. Can we talk?”

Thorin studied him for a moment, then crossed the room to stoke the fire, motioning to one of the two chairs in front of it. “Of course. Come sit down.”

The hobbit hesitated by the door for a moment before he moved closer and sat on the edge of the seat, looking entirely uncomfortable. If anything, he was acting rather restless, like whatever was on his mind was making it impossible for him to sit still. It wasn’t much different from his behavior over the past few days, actually. Since their arrival there in Lake-town, Bilbo had been acting odd. Distracted. Jumpy, even. Though, whatever it was that was on his mind, Thorin hadn’t the chance to find out. Bilbo hardly stayed still long enough for him to get more than a few words in before making some excuse and scurrying away.

Now, though...

Once the flames were burning higher again, Thorin sat in the chair facing Bilbo and asked again. “What is wrong?”

Bilbo made a funny little noise in the back of his throat that was half nervous laugh and half whine. Then he launched into speaking so fast that Thorin could hardly keep up. “See, I’m not entirely sure where to start. There’s just so much and up to this point I haven’t told you because I know how stressed you are already with the dragon and the battle and all that and I really don’t want to make things harder on you. But I’m also worried that this could have an impact on our success in the coming weeks and I can’t keep it to myself anymore. Not to mention the fact that if something happens to me—”

Not liking where his rambling was going, Thorin interrupted. “Bilbo.”

“Right, sorry. Where to start… Er… I suppose the Misty Mountains, since that’s where you first enter the picture in relation to this particular issue.”

“Issue? What—”

“Do you remember when we fell off that cliff?” Bilbo asked suddenly.

Bemused, Thorin nodded. “I do not think I could easily forget it.”

“And you remember how I made us go into the Goblin Tunnels even though you really didn’t want to?”

“Yes. If I remember correctly, you challenged me with the fact that a hobbit would go underground even as a dwarf refused.”

“Right. And do you remember—” Bilbo paused again and his face twisted into a grimace. “Do you remember that Ring you picked up from the ground? The one that I took?”

At that, Thorin couldn’t help but wince. That particular moment of their escapade through the Misty Mountains was one he remembered a little too well. He could never quite forget the fear in Bilbo’s eyes as he snatched the golden trinket from his hand and hid it away. Nor could he forget the split second vision of himself standing in the treasury of Erebor, half-mad and surrounded by a sea of wealth. “If this is about the sickness, I—”

“Sickness?” Bilbo’s brows furrowed in confusion for a moment, then there was a spark of understanding and he was shaking his head quickly. “No! That’s not what this is at all, Thorin. It’s...it’s about the Ring in particular.” Bilbo bit his lip, then plowed on. “I’m going to start talking about a lot of really random things all at once and I know it’s not going to make any sense, but I promise I have a point.”

Confused, Thorin just nodded and sat back. “Take your time, Bilbo, I am listening.”

“Right. Alright. Okay.”

The hobbit fell quiet for several long moments where he seemed to be trying to relax. Thorin found Bilbo’s difficulty speaking to be more concerning than anything he’d actually said so far. His friend had always seemed to be gifted with a silver tongue, able to say the right things at the right times to make a situation turn in his favor. The only times Thorin ever noticed that to not be true was when Bilbo was either caught off guard or incredibly nervous. And given that he was capable of keeping his head in the face of things as dangerous as trolls and dragons, whatever was bothering him at that moment had to be huge. Thorin forced himself to be patient and wait, despite his ever growing concern and curiosity.

Eventually, Bilbo drew in a deep breath and nodded once, as if coming to some kind of resolve. Then he spoke.

“Back in the Goblin Tunnels, the creature we met, Gollum, accused me of stealing from him. Which I did, sort of, though the thing I took doesn’t actually belong to him seeing as he originally stole it himself. But that’s beside the point. The point is that on the first journey, the Ring is largely the reason I was so successful as the Company’s burglar. It’s what allowed me to stay hidden in Thranduil’s dungeons and avoid capture, and how I survived Smaug, and how I managed to make it to Ravenhill during the battle.”

“How?”

Bilbo winced slightly, but answered the question nevertheless. “It’s magic. Anyone who puts on the Ring is rendered invisible.”

Thorin blinked. He had no idea where he thought this conversation had been going, but this was not it. Worry over how to kill the dragon, or how they would go about surviving the battle looming on the horizon, or how they would face winter inside the mountain with minimal supplies—those were all things he could reasonably see them talking about. Magical rings, however, were not a part of that list.

Of course, by now, he should have been used to dealing with unexpected twists in their story. It seemed to become a theme over the past several months.

So he let himself process for a few moments, reign in the whirlwind of questions that was flying through his head, then slowly asked, “so...if the Ring is what allowed you to stay free of the elves before, why did that change this time? Is it...not working?”

“Oh, no, it’s working just fine. At least, I assume it is. I haven’t put it on to test it, you see.”

“Why not?”

Bilbo let out another nervous laugh and was immediately on his feet, pacing back and forth in front of the fire and wringing his hands anxiously. “Because it…it caused so much pain and suffering. And you must understand, I had no idea what it was. No idea. Not until I was old. And by then, it was too late—”

He was babbling again. Thorin wouldn’t have interrupted if it weren’t for the actual words that Bilbo was saying. He did not like where they were going.

“I do not understand what you are talking about.”

“I know, I’m sorry. This is such a difficult subject for me. I’m afraid that the damned thing still has a hold of me, even now. I can hardly bear to look at it, much less speak of it.”

For nearly a minute, Bilbo continued his pacing in silence, and his constant movement was getting to the point where Thorin felt that he himself was beginning to become restless. But he forced himself to wait—to stay still and give the hobbit as much time as he needed to work out whatever it was that he was building up to. Even if the dread that was slowly rising in him like the tide was beginning to feel a little suffocating.

After what felt like forever, Bilbo came to a stop almost abruptly and stood in front of the fire with his back to Thorin. His voice was much quieter than it had been before.

“Back in Beorn’s garden, when I was telling you of my life after the quest, I can honestly say that I told you the truth. But I didn’t tell you all of it.”

Letting out a slow breath, Thorin reached out and caught hold of Bilbo’s hand, which was clenching and unclenching at his side. Gently, he pulled Bilbo closer until he was facing him, then grabbed his other hand so they were both cradled in his own. He hated how distressed he was. Looking up into Bilbo’s nervous eyes, he spoke softly.

“Bilbo. Bâheluh. Please, just tell me. Whatever it is, we will deal with it together.”

To his surprise, the hobbit immediately burst into tears.

 

***

 

Thorin stared at Bilbo. Stared and stared and felt as though he had gone deaf, other than a high pitched ringing in his ears. It seemed so impossible. Impossible, yet so painfully in line with all the other insane things that were happening lately.

The One Ring.

And Bilbo carried it for sixty years. He was carrying it now, in his pocket.

Somehow, it seemed only right. He came back to save the line of Durin and retake Erebor—he should have known that wouldn’t be the end of it. Three dwarves alone were not important enough for the Valar to alter the very passage of time. Of course there was more. Of course.

He may have laughed at the pure ridiculousness of it all if Bilbo didn’t look like he was going to be sick. Because the implications of what having that Ring meant… He knew Bilbo too well to so much as think for a second that he would leave it for Frodo to destroy again. He could see it in the fear and determination in the hobbit’s eyes—knew that Bilbo had already come to the same conclusion.

Letting out a long, shaking breath, Thorin stood up and pulled Bilbo into his arms. The hobbit relaxed against him almost immediately and hugged him back. He was trembling.

“We will figure it out. I promise.” Thorin whispered, and it was reassurance for himself as much as it was for Bilbo. “I promise.”

They sat in silence for nearly an hour, and at some point moved to the bed—it was no more comfortable than the chairs, but at least they could sit beside each other there.

After such a monumental confession from Bilbo, anything else they could speak of seemed inconsequential. But Thorin had been formulating an idea in the back of his mind for the past few days, ever since seeing Erebor through the fog as they crossed the Long Lake, and now he was more sure than ever of what needed to be done.

It felt wrong to break the quiet, but he couldn’t wait any longer. “Bilbo.”

“Hm?” The hobbit had his head leaned back against the wall with his eyes closed. He looked as exhausted as Thorin felt.

“I would like your opinion on something.”

“Alright.”

He hesitated, then decided there was no point in beating around the bush. “I think we should tell the others what we know.”

That got Bilbo’s attention.

The hobbit sat up straight and looked at Thorin closely. When he responded, he spoke slowly and carefully. “What, exactly, do you want to tell them?”

“Nothing about the Ring. Not yet. But,” Thorin pursed his lips and thought for a moment, searching for the right words. “I do not feel comfortable moving forward without telling them of the danger we will face. The dragon they are aware of, but the battle...it is not something they came here expecting to do. It does not feel right to let them face what is coming entirely unprepared when we have the opportunity to warn them. To give them a choice.”

For several long moments, Bilbo said nothing. He just stared at Thorin with an entirely unreadable look on his face. Then he nodded and let out a shaky breath. “I think you’re right.”

“And...I would like to tell them tonight.”

That, at least, seemed to catch Bilbo by surprise.

“Tonight?”

“Yes. It would mean we have the next few days for everyone to come up with a plan to take out Smaug together. Their input could be invaluable, and we will need as much help as we can get.”

“Well…” Bilbo almost looked like he was going to be ill, but he cracked a small smile anyways. “There’s no time like the present, I suppose.”

 

***

 

Thorin had made up his mind that telling the Company the truth was the right thing to do, and his resolve had not changed in that decision. But sitting there before his friends and family, he found himself at a loss for words. He now understood why it was so difficult for Bilbo to tell him about the Ring earlier that evening—he didn’t even know where to start. It was such a big confession to make.

It was too late to change his mind, though, even if he wanted to. After his conversation with Bilbo nearly an hour before, he caught Balin in the hall on his way downstairs and asked him to spread the word that he was calling a meeting and they were all to gather in the dining room as soon as supper was done. It took a while for everyone to get there, but now they were all accounted for.

From the head of the table, Thorin could practically feel the growing impatience around him at his prolonged silence. Pursing his lips, he shot a glance at Bilbo. The hobbit gave him a sympathetic look, but didn’t make any effort to get the conversation started. They had already agreed it would be best for Thorin to be the one to begin—not because the Company would be more likely to doubt Bilbo’s word, but because it was Thorin who recruited them for this quest and Thorin who led them across Middle Earth to get where they were now. It seemed only right that he be the one to tell them the truth of things.

But how to start?

There was just so much to be said and the majority of it would likely sound mad. And, if he was being honest with himself, it was an intimidating thought to finally share a secret he’d been keeping for so long.

Still, if Bilbo could do it, he could as well.

Before he could change his mind, Thorin finally managed to speak, keeping his gaze fixed on a spot in the middle of the table.

“We—Bilbo and I—have something we must tell—”

He didn’t even have the chance to finish before a certain young dwarf piped in cheerfully. “You’re finally courting!”

Immediately, several people started murmuring all at once as they passed coins around between themselves. Thorin opened his mouth to tell them off, but two others beat him to it.

“What?” Bilbo’s voice was a little higher than usual and it cracked oddly.

At the same time, Fili cuffed his brother over the back of his head. “No they’re not, boulder-brain. No bead.”

Everyone’s attention turned to Bilbo, as if to confirm that he did not, in fact, have a bead in his hair. With no small amount of grumbling, the coins were passed back around again. Thorin glared at them all, waiting until they quieted again before speaking.

“May I go on, or would you all rather continue settling your silly wagers?” After several seconds of silence, he shot a glance over at Bilbo. The hobbit's eyes were locked resolutely on his hands, seeming to make every effort not to meet Thorin’s gaze. His cheeks and the tips of his ears were slightly red. Stifling a heavy sigh, he turned his attention back to the Company. “I feel I must ask your forgiveness. There are things that I have neglected to tell you about this quest and, in some ways, I have lied to you.”

All at once, the energy in the room shifted into something more serious and Thorin stood slowly, leaning forward to brace his hands on the table. He wanted nothing more than to avoid looking at the friends and family around him directly, but he forced himself to meet each of their gazes one by one as he continued.

“I cannot keep the truth from you any longer. If we are to have any hope of reclaiming our home and keeping it, you must know what I know. More importantly, you must know because for me to lead you any further than this without warning of what we will face would be inexcusable. You have a right to know, and a right to decide for yourselves if you wish to continue onward.”

Thorin’s eyes met Fili’s and he paused for a short moment. The golden-haired dwarf’s expression was confused and his shoulders were tense.

“What are you talking about, Uncle?”

The memory of seeing the light fade from those clever green eyes and watching as his sister-son’s broken body fell from the top of the tower on Ravenhill made Thorin’s heart clench and he swallowed thickly. He held Fili’s gaze as he spoke. “After we reclaim Erebor, an army of orcs led by the Defiler will march on the mountain and attempt to take it from us. The battle will be bloody, and if we are not careful, we may not all make it out alive.”

“You can’t possibly know that, lad.” Balin’s voice was tight and Thorin tore his focus away from his sister-son to see that his old friend’s face was pale.

“One year ago, I set out from the Shire with twelve dwarves, a hobbit, and a wizard to reclaim a lost mountain from a dragon. Five months ago, I faced Azog in battle atop Ravenhill and killed him, but lost my own life in turn.” From the corner of his eye, Thorin thought he saw Bilbo flinch, but he faltered for only a moment before pressing on. “After my death, I awoke in the Halls and met the Maker. I was given a choice—join my lost loved ones in Waiting, or return to Middle Earth at the start of this quest to fix my mistakes and ensure that the Line of Durin would not fall. So I returned. In April, I awoke at the inn in Bree with a letter from Gandalf telling me how to get to the home of our prospective burglar in the Shire.”

Pausing to take a breath, Thorin glanced around the table at his Company. They were all staring at him with varying degrees of shock and disbelief. He could not blame them for it. He would likely feel the same about the story he had just told, if not for the fact that he was the one living it.

Thorin lowered his tone and spoke quietly, willing his voice to stay steady. “I know how impossible this all sounds. Believe me, I do. But it is the truth.”

They all remained deathly still for nearly a full minute and Thorin matched the stares of the dwarves, standing tall and unyielding before them. In the corner of his vision, he could see Bilbo clenching his handkerchief so tightly in his hands that his knuckles were turning white. It felt as if the universe itself was holding its breath, waiting to see what would happen next.

Then, all at once, the spell of silence hanging over them seemed to lift.

And the room erupted.

Notes:

Bâheluh - friend of all friends

 

Once again, the khuzdul came from The Dwarrow Scholar

Chapter 22: Family of the Heart

Summary:

Bilbo and Thorin deal with the fallout of telling the Company the truth. Then, the next day, the Company are acting strangely generous and Bilbo can't figure out why.

Notes:

Yeah...it's been almost a year. Sorry 'bout that. This chapter has been really fucking difficult to write for some reason. On the bright side, it turned out to be the longest chapter so far, so there you go. Happy holidays!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Chairs clattered to the floor as several dwarves leapt to their feet and the shouting started all at once—their voices twisting together and yelling over each other in a fight to be heard. 

“What?”

“I thought it was a joke!”

“You’re not serious—”

“You bastard! That’s cheating—” 

“I am going to strangle you—”

“Dori, sit down or Mahal help me— ”

Ori practically threw himself over Dori as Oin barked from across the room, knocking the furious dwarf back into his seat. He completely ignored his oldest brother trying to shove him off his lap, though, in favor of looking at Nori with wide eyes. “Wait, you were actually telling the truth?”

Bilbo quickly forgot his anxiety and instead found his gaze flickering between all of the dwarves around the table with a growing sense of bafflement. He had expected yelling. These were his dwarves, after all, and they were practically incapable of doing anything quietly. What he hadn’t anticipated was that none of the yelling was being directed at either himself or Thorin—who looked just as confused as Bilbo felt.

Instead, everyone had their attention turned to Nori.

The red-haired dwarf was one of the few who had yet to say a word. Instead, he was lounging comfortably in his seat, with an incredibly smug look on his face.

When Nori’s gaze met his, Bilbo could have sworn the dwarf winked at him before letting out a piercing whistle that immediately had everyone falling silent.

As soon as he had all their attention, Nori grinned. “Pay up.”

The words set off another bout of yelling.

“That’s not fair!” Kili howled as he struggled to pull out of his brother’s grip.

Fili, who had a firm hold on the back of Kili’s jacket to prevent him from vaulting across the table at the middle Ri brother, looked just as irritated. 

“You’re the one who took the bet.” Nori said with a shrug, his grin growing wider. “It’s not my fault you didn’t believe me when I said they’re from the future.”

Several members of the Company started grumbling to each other, then coins were being passed around once again—and many were chucked a bit forcefully at Nori’s head. He caught them all with a self-satisfied smirk and piled on the table in front of him. Beside him, Bofur looked rather exasperated.

Bilbo watched the exchange with wide eyes, then he choked. “You knew?”

At the same time, Thorin finally spoke up angrily. “Nori! What did I say about keeping your mouth shut?”

He whipped his head around to look at Thorin. “You told him?”

“I did not tell him, he was eavesdropping on our conversation at Beorn’s!”

“Oi! I already told you that wasn’t my fault!” 

“And I told you not to tell anyone else! You gave me your word—”

“Technically, I kept my promise—” 

“You agreed not to tell anyone.” 

“Well, yeah, but Bofur doesn’t count.” Thorin’s snort made it obvious that he wasn’t impressed with the explanation, but Nori plowed on anyway. “You can’t really expect me to keep something like that from my husband. Besides, I didn’t actually tell any of the others.”

Bofur grinned a little sheepishly. “I may have let it slip to the lads at some point.”

“And he never promised anything, so it’s not his fault,” Nori added.

Getting more and more alarmed by the second, Bilbo interrupted the argument. “Why didn’t you tell me?”

“You were already stressed. I did not want to worry you more,” Thorin said, his glower turning to something a little closer to guilt when he looked over at Bilbo. 

Rather than point out the stupidity of the excuse, Bilbo glanced around the room anxiously at the rest of the Company. The reactions to the whole argument were varied. Bombur had his beard clutched in his hands and was wringing it nervously as his eyes darted back and forth between them. Oin was muttering something about portents to Gloin, who was nodding along solemnly. Fili and Kili were whispering urgently to each other. Others didn’t say a word—like Dwalin, who was being uncharacteristically quiet and staring intensely at Thorin. Beside him, Balin had his eyes shut tight and was slowly shaking his head, looking like he might be ill. 

Bilbo bit his lip. 

How much had they been told? How many details of that conversation in Beorn’s garden had Nori shared? Going over all the things he had told Thorin as they sat in the cool grass of what he had assumed was a private place, he started to feel an uncomfortable mixture of dread and embarrassment start to bubble up in his chest. He hadn’t exactly divulged anything he wanted kept secret, but still—

He finally looked back at Nori a little desperately. “You all knew?”

Nori shrugged. “Sure, but nobody actually believed it except Bofur, Bifur, and me.”

At the mention of his name, Bifur—who had been bouncing uncontrollably in his seat for the past several minutes—spoke up, the rush of khuzdul accompanied by a string of excited hand motions.

Finally, Thorin seemed to give up. With a groan, he dropped back into his chair and buried his face in his hands. 

Too anxious to sit still any longer, Bilbo stood up and started to pace. 

“Cheer up, you two. It’s not like I told them all the gritty details. You can still do that.” Nori sounded a little too unbothered about the whole situation.

Bilbo scowled and was about to shoot him a sharp reply, but someone else beat him to it.

Compared to his younger brother, Dori was considerably less calm. His voice was shrill and he sounded almost scared. “Excuse me, but can we back up to the part of this being true? You’re not actually serious!”

Bilbo stopped pacing and glanced at Thorin, but the dwarf was still hiding his face in his hands and made no attempt to respond, so he looked to Dori and nodded. “It’s true. Every word of it.”

Dori looked like he might faint—though that could have been a result of him straining his shoulder a bit too much during his attempt to throttle Nori. 

Fili and Kili fell quiet and Ori clambered out of Dori’s lap and the three young dwarves returned to their seats.

No one was grumbling now. Instead, they were all staring at Bilbo and Thorin like they each had spontaneously grown extra heads. The room was silent, save for the quiet clinking of metal on metal, thanks to Nori who was not-so-discreetly counting his winnings. 

Rather than meet the eyes of the dwarves, Bilbo resumed his pacing and briefly wished he could just disappear. He shoved his hands into his trouser pockets to stop them from wringing, then drew them back out again when he felt the fabric of a small pouch—he hadn’t yet had the chance to find a cord to wear it around his neck, so that damned Ring was still in his pocket. 

As though the mere thought of it was enough to gain its attention, Bilbo heard a familiar voice hiss at him.

‘I could help you disappear, if that is what you desire.’

Gritting his teeth, Bilbo thought back to it angrily. Shut up.

It was a relief when one of the dwarves spoke up and pulled his thoughts away from the Ring again.

“Why now?”

Dwalin’s eyes were fixed on Thorin, gaze unwavering, and Bilbo thought he saw something close to hurt in the warrior’s expression. 

Thorin finally pulled his hands away from his face and sat up, looking at his best friend warily. The two stared each other down for a few moments before Dwalin went on.

“Why are you only telling us this now? Why not at the beginning? Do you not trust us?” 

It was nearly unnoticeable, but Bilbo spotted the way Thorin tensed up at the mention of trust. Concerned, he took a small step closer, but Thorin’s posture relaxed again. The dwarf sighed and leaned back in his chair heavily, looking exhausted. 

“I have been asking myself the same question for months and I have come up with countless excuses for why I kept this from you all for so long, but the truth of it is that I am too ashamed. I—” His voice cracked and he stopped speaking.

Finally, Bilbo returned to his dwarf’s side and placed a hand on his shoulder. Thorin’s gaze flickered up to him gratefully, then he looked back to the Company. When he spoke again, his voice was a little steadier. “When we reached the mountain, I fell to the dragon sickness the same way my grandfather did, and I made many mistakes. I said and did terrible things and hurt every one of you in the process. My actions led to so many deaths—deaths that could have been avoided if only I had resisted the madness or come to my senses sooner. Too much blood was spilled in that battle. Too many lives were lost, all for the sake of my own greed and pride. It was my fault.” 

Bilbo opened his mouth to disagree with him—it hadn’t been all his fault, he had no way of knowing Azog was leading an army to destroy them all—but he didn’t get the chance to say anything.

“Earlier you said you came back to save the Line of Durin.” Fili’s expression was grave and his posture tense. “We died, too, didn’t we? Kili and me.”

Thorin didn’t respond, looking pained, and Kili’s face went white. 

Looking at the young princes, Bilbo felt a familiar ache in his chest. He answered the question, voice soft. “Yes. We lost all three of you that day.”

The reaction from the Company was immediate. All around the table, faces filled with grief and horror. There were several gasps and whatever lingering disbelief seemed to disappear—even Dori’s anger melted away with the admission, and his attention flickered over to his youngest brother fearfully. Ori had clapped his hands over his mouth and his brown eyes were wide, peeking out above his stained knitted gloves. 

Balin opened his eyes and looked at Thorin, tears soaking his cheeks.

Thorin met his advisor’s gaze and let out a shaky breath. Then he looked around at his Company one by one. He ended with his eyes back on Dwalin. “I did not tell you because I was too ashamed to admit what my mistakes cost us. I am so sorry.”

Dipping his head in acceptance of the apology, Dwalin sat back in his seat and said nothing more. 

Bilbo squeezed Thorin’s shoulder reassuringly and the dwarf glanced at him. They held each other’s gaze for a few long moments, and Bilbo felt himself begin to relax. Sure, things were a little bit rocky so far, but it could be a lot worse. He had feared that everyone would flat out refuse to believe them. Maybe there was a small advantage to Nori telling everyone beforehand, after all. It gave everyone time to warm up to the idea, even if they had all thought it was a joke until now. 

At the thought of the star-haired thief, Bilbo looked over towards Nori, but caught Bofur’s eyes instead.

His friend’s voice was grave and there was a hesitant question in his usually cheerful eyes. “Then...if Thorin came back after dying in battle…”

He trailed off, but Bilbo could guess at where his thoughts were going. 

Then everyone was looking at him, waiting for his response. The concern in their expressions made his throat tighten a little and he swallowed thickly before he answered the unspoken question.

“I didn’t die. At least, not in the battle. I stayed long enough for the...for the funeral,” he winced at the word, but hurried on, not daring to look at Fili or Kili. “And to see Dain crowned King. Then I went home. I was one hundred thirty-two years old and living out the rest of my life with the elves—I must have died in my sleep.”

“Did you see Mahal, too, then?” Ori asked abruptly.

Bilbo shook his head. “No, nothing like that. Unlike Thorin, I didn’t really get a choice in the matter. I simply fell asleep one night and woke up in the morning to find myself eighty years in the past. At first I thought I was dreaming or in the afterlife, but then Gandalf showed up with a troop of dwarves in tow who I hadn’t seen in decades…” He trailed off for a moment, remembering how it had felt to have so many of his dead friends appear on his doorstep. Clearing his throat, he went on. “None of you remembered me or our friendship. I didn’t say anything because I knew you considered me to be a complete stranger and I didn’t want to be left behind for sounding mad. It wasn’t until after we made it through the Misty Mountains that I found out about Thorin.”

“You had the chance to stay home where it was safe, yet you still came with us anyway, even knowing the danger we would face?” Gloin asked, looking at him with an odd look in his eye.

Taken aback by the question, Bilbo spluttered for a moment before finding his voice again. “Well, of course!” 

“But why?”

“Why—do you really need to ask?”

Gloin didn’t say anything and Bilbo looked around at the rest of the Company to see that they were all staring at him, waiting for his answer. Even Thorin had turned in his seat a bit to look up at him curiously. Bilbo opened his mouth then closed it again and shook his head. 

Exasperated, he said, “You dwarves can be incredibly thick in the head sometimes, you know that?”

There were a few grumbles around the table, but no one said anything, still waiting for him to explain. 

Sweet Yavanna, they’re stupid.

Letting out a long breath, Bilbo finally relented. “Look, I’ve always been considered an odd hobbit, even before I went off adventuring with a bunch of dwarves. I was an only child with no family to speak of—not counting cousins, of course. Most of the time, I was on my own. And that’s why I came with you. Because on the first journey, that’s what you became to me. Family, I mean. I could hardly stay there in Bag End knowing you lot were running off to dive head first into danger. Especially when, quite honestly, you all would have died a dozen times over before ever reaching Erebor if it weren’t for me. You’re really quite hopeless.” 

He expected some argument against that last statement. Maybe some indignation at the suggestion they were all incompetent. Instead, there were a few sniffles and several of the dwarves were whispering urgently to each other in khuzdul. The rest were looking at him with reverent expressions.

“You see us as family, lad?” Balin asked, sounding choked up.

Baffled, Bilbo shot a glance at Thorin, hoping for some help, but he was no better than any of the others. He was looking at Bilbo with his blue eyes shining and a soft smile. 

Bilbo felt his face starting to get warm and he scowled, looking away from Thorin quickly. From the corner of his eye, he saw the dwarf’s smile widen. He grit his teeth and raised his voice a little, eager to change the subject. “Can we please get back to the point of this meeting? There’s a fire-breathing dragon in that mountain—” he threw a vague gesture at the wall in the direction of Erebor. “—and we need your help coming up with a plan to kill it. Preferably before it gets the chance to slaughter half of Lake-town.” 


***

 

The meeting lasted for several hours, and it wasn’t until well after midnight that everyone finally went to bed. While plenty of ideas had been thrown around about how to deal with the upcoming weeks, they still didn’t have a very solid idea of what they were going to do. Despite how little progress they had made, it was still a draining ordeal. At least, for Bilbo it was. He was so tired by the end that when he finally made it back to his room and collapsed on his bed, he was asleep almost immediately.

He didn’t usually make a habit of sleeping in, but given how late they had all stayed up, he felt justified in taking a couple of extra hours to stay in bed. And he supposed the others would likely do the same, anyway.

It wasn’t until about midmorning that his grumbling stomach finally became too much to ignore and he dragged himself out of his room in search of food. 

His assumption that everyone else would still be asleep was wrong. 

As it turned out, he actually seemed to be the last person awake.

The house was bustling with dwarves who stopped to give him a series of happy ‘good mornings’ as he passed. He wasn’t yet awake enough to really return the greetings with more than some grumbles and small waves as he trudged toward the kitchen, and he certainly wasn’t awake enough to question why everyone seemed to be in such a good mood. 

He was only a few feet from his destination when he found his path blocked by someone with a hat and a curled mustache. 

“There you are, Bilbo!” Bofur’s cheerful voice was loud in his ear and the boisterous dwarf took his arm, pulling him down the hall away from the kitchen. “You’ve been shut up in your room so long, we were starting to worry you died in your sleep again.”

Bilbo barely heard him, and just glanced back at the kitchen longingly. “Er, Bofur, I’m actually trying to get breakfast—”

“Good! We knew you’d be hungry. Here—” Bofur dragged him into the dining room and sat Bilbo down into a seat at the table. “You hang on for just a moment.”

Twisting in his seat, Bilbo tried to protest, but Bofur was already gone. 

He didn’t have to wait long. But instead of Bofur, it was Bombur who bustled into the room a minute later. The air was suddenly filled with an aroma Bilbo hadn’t smelled in months and he gaped as a plate heaping with bacon, eggs, and toast slathered with dark red jam was set in front of him.

Mouth watering at the sight and smell of the food, Bilbo was tempted to dig in immediately. He held back, though, and tore his eyes away from the plate to look up at the Bombur. The dwarf was grinning at him brightly and looked almost expectant.

“Where did this come from?” Bilbo asked, baffled. 

They’d been living on what meager rations they’d been able to afford by the time they reached Lake-town, and that certainly didn’t include anything that was currently on his plate. He couldn’t even fathom how the dwarf had gotten his hands on any of it.

Bombur bounced on his heels a bit. “I thought you deserved a nice breakfast. It’s been so long since we’ve had proper food.”

That didn’t answer his question at all. Really, it only confused him more. If it weren’t for the complaints of his empty stomach, he probably would have spent more time pushing for an explanation. But, well, he hadn’t eaten anything but dried fish, cram, and watered down stew for the past several days and he was hungry.

He resolved to ask questions later and returned his friend’s smile. “Thank you, Bombur.” 

Puffing up proudly, the dwarf gave him a deep bow and left the room just as quickly as he’d come. 

Bilbo watched him go, then shrugged and turned to his breakfast.

 

***

 

As it turned out, the food was just the beginning of a very unusual day. 

He was just leaving the kitchen after washing his dishes when he was ambushed by Bofur again. Rather than grabbing his arm and dragging him to a different part of the house, though, the dwarf swept off his hat and bowed. Then he stood tall again, pulled his hat back onto his head, and held out his hands with a large grin.

Laying across his palms was a small wooden flute, with an intricate pattern of leaves carved into its length.

Bilbo recognized the flute as the one that Bofur had been working on since Beorn’s. “You finished it! That looks wonderful!”

Grin growing wider, Bofur said, “I’m glad you like it. It’s for you, after all.”

He blinked. “Me?”

“Of course. See?” Bofur turned the flute a little and pointed to a spot where, half hidden in the leaves, he had carved the initials BB.

“But I don’t know how to play.”

“That’s no matter. I’ll just have to teach you sometime.”

Bofur was unwavering, holding the flute out to him insistently, so Bilbo took it after a few moments. He ran his fingers over the smooth wood, then looked back up.

“Thank you.” 

Bofur clapped him on the back then was gone.

Shaking his head, Bilbo started down the hall once again, intent on finding Thorin to tell him about the odd morning he was having. He only made it a few steps before he was stopped again, however.

This time it was Bifur, who appeared out of nowhere, already speaking in a flurry of khuzdul as he always did. Bilbo only managed to to understand a couple of the words—khajam and bâha—before an egg-shaped ball of grooved metal was pushed into his hands. He nearly dropped both the egg and the flute and he pulled them both close to his chest quickly.

“Er, a-akhamân,” he stuttered.

Seeming satisfied, Bifur said something else, then bowed and disappeared.

As soon as he was gone, Bilbo looked down at the flute and the egg, baffled. “What on Arda has gotten into them?” 

It didn’t stop there.

Over the next few hours, it felt like he couldn’t turn a corner without running into yet another dwarf with some sort of gift for him—none of which, of course, was the dwarf he was looking for. 

Oin gave him a small jar with some sort of concoction containing mint in it that smelled so strong it cleared Bilbo’s sinuses as soon as he took a sniff of it. 

Ori came in while he was making a cup of tea and bashfully gave him a portrait of himself drawn on a somewhat crumpled piece of parchment. 

He was rustling up a sandwich with leftover bacon from that morning when the other two Ri brothers came into the kitchen. Dori strode straight over to Bilbo and pointed at him in an almost threatening manner with his uninjured arm. 

“Take off your vest,” he demanded. 

“Excuse me? ” 

“It needs mending.”

The two stared at each other for a moment and when it was clear that the white haired dwarf wasn’t going to back down, Bilbo put his sandwich down and hurriedly slipped off his jacket and waistcoat, then handed over the latter of the two. Without another word, Dori turned and swept out of the kitchen. 

As soon as his jacket was back on, Nori walked over to him and pushed something into his hands. “Here, you can have this back.”

Bilbo stared down at the silver object with confusion. Then recognition. Gaping, he whipped his head up to look at the sticky-fingered thief. “Hey, wait a sec—”

Too late, Nori had already snatched up his lunch from the counter and sauntered out of the room.

Scowling, he shoved the spoon in his pocket and went about fixing himself another sandwich. He hadn’t even managed to eat half of it before yet another dwarf strode in and Bilbo groaned.

Fili grinned at him.

If the news of his own death from the night before troubled him, the prince didn’t show any sign of it. He looked just as confident as ever, with his head held high and that usual swagger in his step.

“Hey, Bilbo, I’ve got something for you.”

“I’m sure you do,” he grumbled quietly.

Not quietly enough, apparently, because Fili snickered as he pulled something out of his sleeve and held it out to him.

It was a knife—one of many weapons the young dwarf seemed to carry on his person at all times. The blade was simple, free of any decoration save for an intricate geometric pattern etched into the hilt. The pattern looked familiar, though Bilbo couldn’t quite place it. 

He stared at it for a few moments, then looked at Fili suspiciously. “What’s going on?”

“Nothing’s going on.” The glitter of mischief in those green eyes said otherwise.

“You’re all acting weird today.”

“I have no idea what you mean.” 

Bilbo sighed irritably and pinched the bridge of his nose. “Where’s your uncle?”

Fili’s grin widened at the question. “He left earlier this morning with Balin and Dwalin to speak with the Master.”

“Of course he did.” Bilbo took the knife reluctantly and watched Fili walk away.


***

 

Slipping out of the room on quiet feet so as not to gain the attention of any dwarves who might try and call him back, Bilbo headed for the stairs and hoped he wouldn’t run into anyone else.

The rest of the day had been relatively quiet and things had calmed down a bit after Fili had gifted him the knife. He still hadn’t gotten the chance to speak to Thorin, to his annoyance. As soon as their leader returned to the house, he’d been dragged into the kitchen by Bombur and Dwalin had gotten into Bilbo’s path, demanding to see his weapons. Reluctantly, Bilbo had joined several members of the Company in the sitting room and given his mother’s dagger to Dwalin, who immediately began to sharpen the blade. 

By the time Bilbo left, Ori had moved to sit beside the warrior and was knitting while Dori watched from the other side of the room with a dark glower on his face—which everyone seemed intent on ignoring, Bilbo included. He wasn’t entirely sure what was going on between the three dwarves, but he decided there were bigger things to be worrying about and it wasn’t any of his business anyway.

He was just passing the dining room when someone stepped into the hall and ran into him.

Stumbling back a few steps, Bilbo steadied himself then glanced up at the dwarf.

It was Kili. 

The young prince was pale faced with dark circles under his eyes.

“Hey, are you—” Bilbo reached out to touch his arm, but Kili jerked back like he’d been burned and he let his hand fall back to his side. “Are you alright?”

“I’m fine.” His voice was hoarse in a way that sounded almost painful. There was something haunted in his eyes as they flickered down to Bilbo’s bulging pockets and he swallowed thickly, taking a couple steps back. He looked like he was going to be ill. For a moment, he opened his mouth, looking like he might say something else. Then he pursed his lips and hurried away without another word. 

Bilbo watched him go worriedly, then turned and headed for the stairs. 

When Bilbo pushed the door open and walked into his tiny bedroom, he was met with a rush of warm air and a cozy light. He had fully expected the room to be cold. The last embers had been dying earlier that morning when he left his room and he hadn’t attempted to stoke the flames back to life the few times he had been in there throughout the day—not to mention that he had used the last of his firewood the night before. Yet a fire crackled happily in the fireplace and a few small logs and sticks were stacked in a neat pile beside it. 

For a moment, he just stared in confusion. Then he spotted the tinder box sitting on the floor beside the wood and it clicked.

Gloin must have come in at some point and started a fire to get the room warmed up for him before he went to bed. Just when he thought maybe he could get through the rest of the day without another dwarf popping up to coddle him.

“There’s just no getting away from it, is there?” he grumbled to himself.

“Getting away from what?”

The question came from so close behind him that Bilbo nearly jumped out of his skin. Then he spun on his heel and pointed accusingly. “You!”

Thorin looked confused. “You are trying to get away from me?”

“What? No.” Bilbo snorted. “I’ve been trying to find you all day.”

“I was—”

“Speaking with the Master, yes, I know. Come here.” 

He walked into the room without waiting to see if the dwarf would follow and dumped the contents of his pockets onto the bed, rummaging through them aimlessly. He heard the door close, then Thorin came to stand at his side. 

“This day has been ridiculous.” Grabbing one of the objects from the pile, Bilbo turned to Thorin and waved it in his face. “Look at this! Look what Nori gave me! What is it?”

“It is a spoon.” Thorin said bemusedly.

“Yes. My spoon. When I got home, my good set of silverware was one spoon short. I spent decades thinking Lobelia had managed to sneak it away hidden in her hat, but no! Come to find out, one of my dwarves had it the entire time! I hope he put it to good use, the scoundrel.”

Thorin opened his mouth to say something, but Bilbo ignored him and plowed on.

“Balin gave me the last of his pipeweed, Dori is mending my clothes, Dwalin took my mother’s dagger. And look at all of this!” Bilbo dropped the spoon and gestured at the pile. He grabbed an object at random, and ended up with the metal egg. “I don’t even know what this is.”

Thorin laughed and took the egg from Bilbo’s hand and pointed out a small groove on one side with a round gear embedded in it. “Here, you wind it up like this and—”

He turned the gear a few times then let the egg sit flat on his palm and they watched as it started to unfold itself, morphing into the shape of a small bird. It flapped its wings three times before curling back into the egg and falling still. 

Bilbo blinked, forgetting his rant for a moment. “Did Bifur make that?”

“Bifur is a toymaker. It is his craft.”

He nodded. He knew that. Of course he did. After all, he had ordered dozens of toys from Dale to give as presents on his one hundred eleventieth birthday, and a great many of them had been crafted and delivered by Bifur himself. But while all of those toys had been perfectly wonderful, he just didn’t remember any of them being quite as beautiful as this. 

After a moment, he took the egg back and set it down—a little more carefully than before—and Thorin peered over his shoulder to look at the rest of his little collection.

“Fili gave you one of his knives?” he asked, sounding surprised.

Bilbo shrugged. “Yes. I don’t know what he expects me to do with it, though.”

Thorin didn’t say anything and Bilbo glanced back at him to see that he was staring at the knife with an unreadable expression, his brows furrowed slightly. 

“What?”

“I suppose no one bothered to explain the purpose of the gifts.”

“Well, I tried to ask your nephew, but he pretended he didn’t know what I was talking about.” 

Shaking his head, Thorin looked back to Bilbo. His smile was back, a bit softer than it had been before. “Last night, you claimed us all as barufu ikh-kurdu. Family of the heart. It is considered a high honor in our culture and the traditional response is to give a gift both to accept that claim and to claim you in return.”

“What? I didn’t—” The realization hit him then—the way the dwarves reacted the night before when he had explained his reason for coming on the quest—and he made an exasperated noise. “That’s what this is all about? Honestly, you dwarves! I could tell you your hair looks nice and it might suddenly become a ceremonial occasion!”

“Is it wrong for us to want to express our affection for you, Master Burglar?” Thorin asked, looking amused.

“All I’m saying is that if you want to tell me you care about me, it would be so much easier to skip all the formalities and just say so.”

“You will have to forgive us. We dwarves are rather fond of our formalities. And, to be fair, telling a dwarf you like their hair is actually a very high compliment.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes, but couldn’t help the smile pulling at his lips. “Why am I not surprised?”

“I hope you can endure one more gift, because I have one for you as well.”

His smile faltered a little. “Thorin—”

“Just humor me, Bâheluh. Besides, I think you will find this one to be a little more useful than a stolen spoon.”

There wasn’t much point in arguing—Thorin had that familiar determined look in his eye that said he wasn’t going to back down easily, just the same as all the others that day. 

Bilbo sighed. “Oh, go on, then.”

Despite his reluctance, Bilbo still felt a spark of curiosity as Thorin reached under the collar of his shirt and fished about for a moment. Then his hand reemerged holding onto a necklace—a dark leather cord with a silver pendant strung onto it. He watched as Thorin pulled it off and held it out to him.

“Here.”

The pendant swung a little as Thorin offered him the necklace. His brows furrowed in confusion, but he didn’t get the chance to ask before Thorin explained. “I know you have been worried about carrying... it in your pocket. I thought maybe this would help.” 

“Oh.” Bilbo had been so distracted thanks to all the attention from the rest of the Company that he hadn’t taken much time to think about that moment when he’d finally told Thorin the truth about the Ring the night before. Not that he wanted to think about it all that much, anyway—it was too embarrassing, what with all that crying he had done. Looking back on it, though, he supposed he did have a vague memory of mentioning his concern about carrying it. “That’s...perfect, actually.”

After a moment, he reached out and took the necklace.

The pendant was warm in the palm of his hand and up close, he saw that the pattern etched into the pendant matched the one on Fili’s knife. Tracing his fingers over the symbol curiously, he almost asked what it meant. But then the whispering that had been ever present in the back of his mind since that afternoon suddenly grew louder, and his question was forgotten. 

Swallowing hard, he did his best to ignore it and looked back to Thorin. “Thank you.” 

The dwarf didn’t respond right away. He was studying Bilbo closely, and there was a hint of concern in his expression. “Is something wrong?”

There were plenty of things wrong, starting with the fact that a dangerous magical object was in his head continuously trying to manipulate him into helping it bring about the end of the world. And that it seemed insistent on harassing him until he either gave it what it wanted or it drove him insane. Or both. But what was he supposed to say?

He had no intention of telling Thorin he was hearing voices. Absolutely not. He didn’t have the energy to go into all of that right now. He needed more time to think it through. No, that was a conversation best left for another day. Or, better yet, never. 

So Bilbo shook his head. “No, no. I’m fine.” 

To his relief, Thorin didn’t push. The dwarf just looked back at the pile of gifts on the bed for a moment with an unreadable look in his eyes, then he looked back to Bilbo. “Balin asked me to go speak with him again. I should probably go find him before he decides to retire for the night.” 

The memory of Kili’s pale face went through his mind. “Oh! You might want to check on your nephews. Fili seemed to be doing alright, but I ran into Kili in the hall and he looked pretty upset.”

Worry flashed on Thorin’s face, but then it cleared and he nodded. “I am not surprised, after last night. I will talk to him.” 

The two walked to the door, and Bilbo reached out to turn the knob, but Thorin caught his hand and stopped him.

Bilbo looked at him curiously to see that there was a humorous glint in his eyes. 

“I care about you, Bilbo Baggins.”

He blinked, then snorted and shook his head, doing his best to ignore the heat in his cheeks. “You’re teasing me, Thorin Oakenshield.”

“Maybe a little.” Thorin paused, then his voice softened. “I mean it though. We all do.” 

Glancing over at the bed, Bilbo felt a sudden surge of affection for all of his dwarves. As exasperated as he was at their antics, he’d be lying if he said he didn’t find it endearing, if not entirely unnecessary. He didn’t need gifts to tell him they cared. They already did that on a day to day basis, every time they snuck him a little extra food, or kept him steady on a steep path, or insisted that he learned to hold his sword correctly. They had a tendency to be remarkably dramatic about the simplest things even on the best of days. And even if they didn’t go out of their way sometimes to make sure he knew he was one of them, it didn’t matter. They were his dwarves no matter what—gifts or no gifts, whether they wanted to be his or not.  

He wouldn’t trade them for the world.

Bilbo smiled slightly and nodded. “I know you do.”

The bright smile that Thorin gave him in return made his heart stutter oddly in his chest—yet another thing that Bilbo did his best to ignore. He was one hundred thirty-two (or was it thirty-three?) years old, for pity’s sake—there was no reason for him to be acting like some twitterpated tween around his first crush. He was not going to let himself swoon just because this dwarf with pretty eyes was smiling at him.

Some of that amusement from earlier returned to Thorin’s expression and he squeezed his hand slightly before letting go. “Goodnight, Bilbo.”

“Goodnight.”

Bilbo watched him leave and as soon as the door closed and the footsteps faded down the hall, he let out a breath he didn’t even realize he was holding. Honestly, these dwarves. They were going to be the death of him at some point, with all their silly wagers, and dragging him off for impromptu training sessions, and their overdramatic tendencies.

Utterly ridiculous, the lot of them.

He looked down at the necklace sitting in his palm and felt another flutter in his chest. Then he snorted. “I’m ridiculous.” 

Bilbo started to turn back towards the bed to figure out what to do with all of the gifts when, for the first time in several hours, the whispering in the back of his head stopped. Then it was replaced by something worse.

‘You just got your family back. It would be a shame if you were to lose them again so soon.’

The Ring’s voice was like a bucket of ice water being poured down his spine and Bilbo froze, then he scowled and dug the little pouch out of his pocket, though he didn’t dare open it. 

“I’m not going to lose them,” he said firmly, though took care to keep his voice quiet, lest a passing dwarf in the hall hear him talking to himself.

‘Without my help, you will.’

“I don’t want your help.” 

‘You will need me, before the end. You will see.’

The end.

Bilbo’s mind flashed to an imagined picture of a far away volcano that he had only heard of in Frodo’s stories. 

It was a thought that the Ring didn’t like, apparently.

The screeching hiss it let out was a truly horrendous sound, so awful it had Bilbo moving to clap his hands over his ears to try and drown it out, despite the noise being inside his head. His vision swam and he stumbled.

Bilbo’s knees hit the ice and he stared at the gaping wound fearfully. It was bad. He didn’t want to touch it, but he swallowed his nausea and leaned forward to put pressure on it anyway. 

There was so much blood. 

Blood seeping through his fingers, staining his dirty hands red. Blood pooling in the snow. It soaked the material of his trousers where he kneeled in it.

There was too much.

Bilbo choked on a sob.

His King was dying. 

After everything they’d gone through. After trolls, and goblins, and orcs, and spiders, and elven dungeons, and gold-sickness, and dragon-fire. All of it—just to end up here, sitting on a frozen waterfall with a terrible battle waging far below them.

It wasn’t fair. His adventure wasn’t supposed to end this way. There was still so much he needed to say. There were so many apologies he needed to make, and twice as many thanks he needed to give to this dwarf. There was so much that his heart hadn’t yet had time to figure out. And now it seemed he would never get that time. 

It wasn’t fair.

Even as he told him to wait, to just hold on a little longer until the eagles arrived, he knew no one would come in time. He gave up on trying to slow the bleeding and instead held onto his friend’s hand as tightly as he could.

When Thorin released his final shuddering breath, Bilbo felt the air leave his own lungs. “No. No, no! Thorin. Thorin, don’t you dare! Don’t—” 

It was too late.

He was gone.

The high pitched keening noise building in Bilbo’s throat was interrupted by a sly voice whispering in the back of his mind. 

‘I warned you this would happen. You should have listened to me. If you had, maybe they would still be alive.’

The words caused an icy dread to settle over him and Bilbo slowly tore his eyes away from Thorin, then immediately wished he hadn’t. 

A dozen familiar figures lay strewn across the frozen ground. None of them moved. There wasn’t so much as a single breath being drawn. They were dead.

His dwarves.

Gone. All of them gone.

And he was the only one left. Utterly alone.

The vision ended, and he was back in his little room in the house on the lake, no longer surrounded by ice and snow and dead dwarves. Bilbo sucked in a gasp of breath, relieved for once that there was the scent of fish in the air—anything was better than the stench of blood. He kneeled there on the wooden floor for a few long minutes, trying to calm his furiously beating heart and clamp down on his nausea. 

Once he had caught his breath, Bilbo furiously snatched the pouch up from where he had dropped it on the floor and shook it. “You keep your horrible thoughts to yourself.” 

The Ring gave no further response beyond a cackling laugh that echoed in his mind. Bilbo ignored it, tying the pouch to the necklace with shaking hands. Then he slipped it over his head and clutched at the silver pendent—a reminder that Thorin was alive and well, and so were all the others. And they were going to stay that way.

He repeated the thought to himself a dozen times, and then a dozen more for good measure.

It made him feel slightly better, but it was hours before he managed to banish the memory of sightless blue eyes staring up at the sky from his mind.

Notes:

Akhamân - thank you

barufu ikh-kurdu - family of the heart

Chapter 23: Of Sleeping Monsters

Summary:

While they prepare to leave Laketown, Thorin shares his worries about the gold-sickness with Bilbo and attempts to get his hands on the one weapon in the land that can kill a dragon.

Notes:

This is a really short one--just a small scene between our favorite hobbit and dwarf. It was meant to be the beginning of a much longer chapter, but I don't have the energy to finish it right now. I just want to post something in honor of Bilbo's birthday, even if it isn't much. I'll get around to finishing it eventually. Be patient with me.

Happy Hobbit Day!

 

EDIT:

Hello! It's been almost a year since I originally posted the first scene of this chapter, and I've finally finished writing the rest of it! At this point, we're all aware of my abysmal ability to update regularly, so I'm not going to even try to make any promises or predictions about when the next chapter will be out because I always end up turning myself into a liar, BUT I just graduated from college and lost my job, so I have absolutely nothing to do with my life at the moment. Ideally, that means I'll finally have time to write and maybe get a little more frequent with my updates. Fingers crossed!

As always, please let me know if you notice any mistakes so I can fix them.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“Bilbo.”

“Hm?”

The room was fairly drafty, allowing the breeze off the lake to slip in through the cracks in the house and drape everything in a light chill. Thorin barely felt the cold, but he knew hobbits didn’t have the same natural resistance to harsh weather as dwarves did. Even Bilbo, who was far more tried and tested than others of his kind could not fend off the fast approaching winter. It was why they had ended up here, sitting side by side on Thorin’s bed with their shoulders pressed together and a fire roaring in the hearth.

The rest of the house was completely silent. It was a stark contrast to their first journey. Back then, the night before leaving for the mountain had been one of celebration, filled with song and food and drink. Maybe a bit too much, in the case of the last one, considering that more than a few of their Company had been incredibly hung over the next morning. 

This time was a different story.

No one seemed too eager to celebrate tonight, though Thorin was sure he wouldn’t be hard pressed to find a few drinking dwarves in the house if he tried.

He didn’t mind the lack of a party. Really, sitting there in the quiet was preferable, given that this was the last quiet night they would get for the foreseeable future. He only wished he could enjoy it, but the heavy weight in his chest and the sour taste of dread in his mouth made it difficult.

When Thorin didn’t say anything else, Bilbo nudged him.

This journey so far was just one hard conversation after another. He was getting tired of it. Still, this was important. And as much as he wanted to never speak of it at all, he knew this wasn’t something he could stay silent on.

So, he sighed and kept his eyes locked firmly on his hands when he spoke. “The Arkenstone…”

The hobbit tensed beside him. “What about it?”

“If you find it, do not give it to me. Do not even tell me you have it.”

Outside, the wind howled and the house around them shook. He couldn’t stand to look, but he could feel Bilbo staring at him.

“Thorin—”

“Please, Bilbo.” He hated the desperation in his own voice. “Hide it somewhere safe and leave it there until the dragon is gone and the battle is over. Promise me.”

He stole a glance at the hobbit to see that his brows were furrowed and his lips pursed. But his eyes were clear, and there was a sad sense of understanding in them.

Bilbo nodded once. “I promise.”

Thorin let out a long and slumped a bit, letting his shoulders relax and leaning his head back against the wall.

For several minutes, nothing more was said and Thorin thought the conversation was over.

Then Bilbo took another sip of his tea and spoke again, his voice calm. “Do you mind if I ask what it is you’re so worried about?”

“Do you not know?”

“Tell me anyway.”

Thorin sighed and dragged a hand over his face. It was not something he wanted to dwell on. The sea of treasure stretching on in all directions. The heavy weight of his grandfather’s crown resting on his brow and jeweled rings on his fingers. The way his thoughts were muddled and his words harsh—his actions harsher. The light of dragon-fire glinting on gold that seemed more enchanting than dangerous. The whispers in his mind. All of it was too much.

Still, he answered his hobbit. How could he not?

“I worry that when we enter the mountain, the gold-sickness will consume me once again. It was like being in a haze. I knew what I was doing, but I did not care. I am afraid I will hurt you all in my blind greed once again. That I will turn on you as I did before. I am afraid of becoming that…monster again.”

Bilbo was quiet, then—

“I don’t think that’s going to happen, Thorin,” he said softly.

“Why not?”

“Because this time, we know it’s coming.”

He said it in such a matter-of-fact tone that Thorin turned and looked at him, incredulous. “That does not make me feel better.”

Bilbo snorted and set his tea down on the bedside table, then reached out to take Thorin’s hand. “Maybe not, but knowing makes it easier to handle it when it comes. Not easy, but easier.”

“How can you be so sure?”

“If I can do it, I have no doubt you can, too.” 

His eyes darkened for a moment, expression falling, then his small smile was back so quickly, Thorin almost thought he’d imagined it. He swallowed and laced his fingers with the hobbit’s.

Bilbo’s smile grew. “Let’s make a deal, shall we?”

His hand was warm from holding the mug of tea, and he smelled of chamomile. It was calming, and the look on his face quelled Thorin’s questions for the moment, though he was confused. He waited.

“I’ll keep an eye on you and your behavior, and if at some point I’m worried that you’re starting to let the sickness cloud your judgement, I’ll tell you. Or knock some sense into you. Whichever I think will be more effective.”

He had no doubt of that. Thorin chuckled. “And what would you ask of me in return?”

“Simple. I’ll keep an eye on you as long as you promise to do the same for me.” Bilbo shrugged, as though trying to look nonchalant, but there was something somber that lingered.

“What for?”

Smile falling, Bilbo sighed deeply and looked away. “I told you how the Ring gets into people’s heads. In a way, I suppose it’s similar to the gold-sickness in that regard.”

“You have been struggling with it?”

Thorin’s throat tightened and he gripped Bilbo’s hand a little tighter. He knew well enough the evils of gold. He knew better than most. The thought of Bilbo going through anything remotely similar to the gold-sickness was nauseating. A memory, distant and near forgotten, flashed in his mind—in the tunnels under the Misty Mountains, when he found a Ring in the dark and it showed him the treasure hoard of Erebor and, for a brief moment, it brought the sickness back. That terrible spark of anger when Bilbo took the Ring from his hand.

“I’ve been managing it so far, but there’s no guarantee I can resist forever.” Bilbo looked down at their hands, and his eyes softened slightly. There was something both annoyed and weary in his next words. “It has a tendency to latch onto your greatest desires and constantly tries to find ways to exploit them. To prove that it can help you achieve them, if only you put it on.”

He spoke as though the Ring had a mind of its own. It unnerved him, but Thorin didn’t try to ask more. If Bilbo wanted him to know, he’d tell him.

They sat quietly together for a while longer, but when Bilbo yawned for the fourth time in a span of a few minutes, Thorin glanced down at him and quirked a slight smile. “It is going to be an early start. You should rest.

The hobbit looked ready to protest, but was interrupted by yet another yawn. With a huff, he nodded his agreement and moved to stand. 

Thorin felt the loss of his touch keenly, but ignored it. He got to his feet, too, and followed Bilbo to the door. He reached for the knob to open it, but then Bilbo’s hand was on his wrist, stopping him.

Pausing, he looked down at him and suddenly forgot how to breathe.

Bilbo was so close—just inches away from his chest, round face tilted back, hazel eyes looking up at him intently with all the weight of a mountain in their gaze.

And then Bilbo rose up on his toes and pressed his lips softly to his cheek and Thorin’s mind went utterly blank.

It lasted mere seconds, and then the hobbit was pulling away and taking a step back. His cheeks were slightly pink, but his quiet voice was steady when he spoke, if not a bit rueful. “For the record, I never thought you were a monster.”

He turned and slipped out the door before Thorin had the chance to stop reeling.


***

Despite telling Bilbo to get some rest, Thorin had trouble following his own advice. He laid awake for hours, staring up at the ceiling above him, his mind too loud to sleep. There was just too much to think about—too much that could go wrong within the next couple of weeks, between the gold-sickness and the dragon and the battle and Azog. He was worried for his sister-sons. For Fili, who was putting up a brave front and pretending to be unbothered by the news of his own death. And for Kili, who had barely eaten or spoken a word to anyone in days. He worried for Bilbo and what the Ring might be doing to him. He worried for his entire Company.

They would all follow him to the very end, he knew—he was just afraid of what that end might be.

His one comfort was that Mahal himself had sent him back to see this quest fulfilled. And if the Maker believed it could be done, then it must be possible. Still, knowing it was possible didn’t get him any closer to knowing what exactly it was that he needed to do. And it certainly didn’t help with the problem of the dragon.

Somehow, they had to bring Smaug down—preferably before he got the chance to leave the mountain and take out his wrath on the people of Lake-town.

He spent the night working through scenario after doomed scenario, trying to find one that seemed plausible. Then, an hour or two before dawn, he had an idea. So he got out of bed, pulled on his boots, and snuck out of the house into the frigid cold.

It took longer than he liked to navigate Lake-town—the boardwalks had no apparent organization system, and many of them ended in dead ends—but he eventually found his destination, more through sheer luck than anything else. He started up the wooden stairs, stepping as lightly as possible to avoid waking anyone. By the time he stood before the weather-beaten door, the sky was beginning to grow lighter.

Steeling himself for what he was about to do, he knocked three times.

Despite the early hour, only a few seconds passed before the door opened. Seeing as Bard was already bundled up in a thick coat, Thorin supposed the man would be heading out onto the lake soon.

Bard scowled the moment his eyes landed on Thorin. The man had been no more happy about learning the dwarves’ purpose this time than he had the last. “What is it?”

“You are a descendant of Girion, Lord of Dale.”

Bard stared at him blankly, then gave a slight nod. “My great grandfather.”

“May I come in?”

After several moments during which Thorin was sure the door was going to be slammed in his face, he was invited in. It was substantially warmer inside the home, and he was grateful for it.

“Well?” the man asked.

“Had the city not fallen, you would likely be its Lord today.”

Bard shrugged and turned his back on Thorin, walking into his kitchen where he seemed to be filling a knapsack with food. “What could have been does not matter. Such fancies do not put food on my table.”

“No, it does not. But if you had the chance to change things, would you take it?” He took a few steps further into the house and glanced around the room, searching, though he hoped he merely looked curious.

“I do not have time for what ifs, Master Dwarf.” Closing the knapsack, he looked at Thorin again. “Unless you have something of actual substance you would like to say to me, I have work to do. The barrels of Mirkwood will not collect themselves, and it is a long journey to the mouth of the river.”

“If Dale were restored to its former glory, would you take your rightful place as its king?”

The man’s eyes narrowed. “I have no desire for power.”

“Even if it would bring your people out of poverty and into prosperity once more?”

At that, Bard said nothing.

Finally, Thorin’s eyes found what he was looking for. There.

With no more reason to continue beating around the bush for time, he looked back to Bard. “Come with us.”

“What.”

Before he had the chance to second guess himself, Thorin went on. “When Girion climbed the tower and tried to kill the dragon with the wind-lance, he had three black arrows. The first missed. The second made a hole in Smaug’s armor, loosening the scale on the chest under the left wing—”

“I would not put so much stock into myths and stories.”

“I have lived through myths and stories, Master Bard. They should not be so lightly dismissed.”

Unmoved by the admission, Bard responded dryly. “What is your point?”

“He never had the chance to fire the third black arrow. Supposedly, no one has seen it since, but I hardly believe that the Line of Girion would have so easily abandoned an heirloom so important as that. Help us destroy the dragon. Do what your forefather could not.”

There was a long silence in which Bard clenched his jaw and turned away from Thorin, his shoulders tight. He braced himself against the dining table, with his head bowed, dark hair falling to shroud his face.

When he finally spoke, his voice was low. Harsh. “You would risk the lives of everyone here on a fool’s hope.”

Thorin bit the inside of his cheek and forced himself to take a deep breath. It would help nothing for him to allow his temper to get the best of him. “A fool’s hope, maybe, but it is the only hope I have left to me.”

That, evidently, was not the right thing to say.

Bard whirled on him and his dark eyes burned with anger. “There are children in this town, Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror. My children are in this town. I cannot stop you on this path, but I will take no part in it. You will bring ruin on us all.”

The memory of Esgaroth burning bright as it was ravaged by the dragon crossed his thoughts, followed by the image of hundreds of survivors, dragging themselves into Dale for shelter. He felt the spark of his own anger go out. He knew how it felt to watch his people travel over the lands, homeless and hopeless.

He let out a long breath. “I do not blame you for it, though you are right that you cannot stop me. I will return to Erebor, with or without your help. But if you will not come with me, please, give me what I need to kill the dragon before it ever gets the chance to leave the mountain. The black arrow.”

“What makes you so sure I have it?”

Thorin glanced above the table to where a rod of black steel was hung with pots and pans and other things. An interesting place to keep it, given that it was the only weapon in the land capable of bringing down a raging dragon.

Bard’s expression soured. Then his shoulders slumped slightly and he leaned back against the table, looking suddenly exhausted and aged. “And if you fail? If the dragon leaves the mountain and sets his sights here? Why should I give you our only hope of defense against the beast?”

As much as he hated to admit it, the man had a point. Especially given how terribly everything had gone last time, though Bard had no way of knowing about that. He was right to fear. But Thorin would not fail again. Not this time. Not in this. So he squared his shoulders, stood tall, and looked the man in the eye. “I know you have no reason to trust me, but on the graves of my forefathers I swear this—I will not allow that dragon to kill a single living soul in these lands or any other ever again. Its time is finished.”

Bard looked away from him and didn’t respond for several long moments of tense silence. When he did speak, Thorin’s heart sank.

“The Lord of Silver Fountains. The King of Carven Stone. The King Beneath the Mountain, shall come unto his own. And the bells shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King’s return. But all shall fade in sadness, and the lake will shine and burn.” He recited the prophecy with a faraway look on his face, then met Thorin’s gaze again, and his voice was quiet but firm. “I cannot give you what you seek.”

“But—”

“Go.”

There was no point in arguing. Thorin could see in Bard’s eyes that he had made up his mind, and he didn’t want to make an enemy of the man. 

And who was he to challenge that decision, when he himself would do the same had their roles been reversed?

So he bowed his head in farewell, then turned and stepped out into the dawn of a new day.

 

***

 

Bilbo found him before he could even make it through the front door, falling into step beside him as Thorin headed for his room.

“I was wondering where you got off to.”

“I am sorry if I worried you,” he said quietly.

“I knew you'd be back.” The hobbit stopped walking and grabbed Thorin’s sleeve, looking up into his eyes. There was some concern on his face. “You look exhausted.”

He didn’t ask, but Thorin could hear the unvoiced question in his tone. So he sighed and dragged a hand through his hair. “I asked Bard to come with us. Or to at least let me have the black arrow.”

If Bilbo was surprised, he didn’t show it. “I’m guessing it didn’t go well.”

“No. It did not.”

Bilbo studied him closely for a few moments, though Thorin didn’t have the energy to meet his gaze.

“Well, at least you tried.”

The hobbit linked arms with him and guided him through the house that was waking up. They passed the kitchen, where the smell of frying bacon was wafting out from. Bombur must already be up, then. Good. Breakfast would be important if they were to start traveling to the Lonely Mountain in an hour. Durin’s Day was in four days, and after that…

They would need their strength.

Neither of them spoke again until the door closed behind them in Thorin’s room. Bilbo let go of him and moved to stoke the fire back to life. 

“You’re better than me, in any case,” the hobbit said over his shoulder. 

Thorin thought his tone was rather too cheerful, given the circumstances.

“I do not know what you mean.” He dropped down into the chair by the fire and sighed, wishing he had slept.

Bilbo turned to him, a smile tugging at the corner of his lips and a note of mischief gleaming in his hazel eyes. “At least you asked. I was up half the night trying to decide if I should sneak over to Bard’s house and steal it.”

Despite how tired he was, Thorin couldn’t help his slight smile. “The house?”

“The hou—” The hobbit stopped abruptly and gave him an exasperated look. “The arrow, Thorin.”

He chuckled and felt himself relax a bit. “Why didn’t you? Steal it, I mean.”

Bilbo’s smile fell and he turned back to the fire, poking at it half-heartedly. “I’ve learned from experience that people don’t necessarily want to be friends with you after you steal from them.” Thorin felt his mouth go dry at the comment, but Bilbo went on before the guilt could really start to settle in. “More importantly, I can’t stand the thought of leaving all these people completely defenseless in case something goes wrong.”

His words were practically an echo of what Bard had said to him earlier. Somehow, Thorin found it comforting.


***

 

Less than a minute after Bilbo left to gather his things, there was a knock on Thorin’s door. He left his pack open on the bed and went to answer it, thinking the hobbit had forgotten something and come back. Instead, he found one of his sister-sons waiting impatiently in the hall. 

Fili stood with his usual confidence, head held high and shoulders back. To most who looked, he would seem the sure and steady crown prince he had been raised from birth to be. But Thorin knew him well enough to recognize the unease in his stature and the worry in his eyes. To notice the slight shift in his weight from one side to the other, struggling to settle with whatever thoughts were putting that look on his face.

Thorin stiffened. “What is it?”

Jaw clenching tight, Fili said nothing and just glanced over Thorin’s shoulder into the bedroom.

He stepped aside to allow his heir to come in.

It wasn’t until the door was shut that Fili spoke in a low voice, as though he didn’t want to risk any other hearing him. 

“Something is wrong with Kili.”

The words sent ice through him that had Thorin clenching his hands tightly at his sides—the sting of his blunt fingernails digging into his palms served as a reminder to himself that there was no need to sprint out the door and seek out the younger of his sister-sons. If Kili was in any kind of immediate danger, Fili would have started with that, and neither of them would still be standing there. 

He barely had enough time to reassure himself of such before Fili went on.

“He’s been in a terrible mood ever since we reached Lake-town. At first, I thought he was just—” He stopped abruptly, grimacing.

“Thought he was just what?”

Fili gave a sharp shake of his head. “It doesn’t matter. The point is, I don’t think it’s just a bad mood anymore. He hasn’t been eating. He barely sleeps. I think he’s sick, but he insists he’s fine and refuses to go to Oin.” 

Thorin hadn’t seen Kili since the night before last, having sought him out at Bilbo’s suggestion. His sister-son had seemed unwell at the time, but insisted he was just having difficulty sleeping. Thorin suspected his sleep troubles likely had something to do with the knowledge of how the quest had ended once before, but Kili had refused to speak of it, and Thorin hadn’t blamed him for that. He’d given the young dwarf space to try and rest as it was late at night and the conversation wasn’t going anywhere.

He hadn’t known about Kili not eating, however. 

That was troubling.

“I will speak with him.” 

He cursed himself for not doing so sooner—for not pulling them both aside and speaking to them as soon as that initial confession to the whole Company was over. Despite all his intentions of keeping his sister-sons as his top priority on this journey, he still somehow managed to allow them to slip to the back of his mind the past few days, overshadowed by how busy they’d all been getting ready to make their last push to the mountain.

It was a mistake he could not afford to continue making, yet he found that he kept making it. Again and again and again.

He would fix it right now. He would take Fili with him and they would go to Kili together, then he’d speak to both of them. Their departure from Lake-town would likely be delayed a bit, but—

“He went to the docks already with some of the others.”

Thorin had to take a slow breath to stop himself from cursing.

Of course he’d already left. It would have to wait a while longer, then.

He half expected that to be the end of the conversation, but Fili wasn’t done. He spoke again, though the words were strained, like he had to force himself to say them. “Uncle, there’s something else.”

Tensing, Thorin braced himself for what would come next.

Fili hesitated.

The elder of his sister-sons rarely faltered in words or action. Once he’d made a decision to say or do something, he did so without waiting, sticking to that decision for better or for worse. But now, he looked to be second-guessing himself.

Thorin approached him, reaching out to put a steadying hand on his shoulder. “Tell me, Fili.”

Fili nodded, but didn’t quite meet his eye when he spoke. “He didn’t give Bilbo a khajamu a’khuf.”

It took a moment to process what he’d said, then another for Thorin to be sure he’d actually heard correctly. Then he shook his head.

When someone claimed another as barafu ik-kurdu, it was custom to accept that claim with a gift. To not give a khajamu a’khuf was nothing short of rejection. It was a refusal to consider the other as kin.

That, more than anything else Fili had said about his brother’s behavior, was worrying. Kili loved their hobbit just as much as the rest of them did. If he’d yet to accept the family bond that was offered…something was even more wrong than Thorin originally thought.

“Has he said why?”

“No,” Fili said quietly. “I tried to ask him, but he got angry. I was hoping maybe Bilbo had told you something.”

The hobbit hadn’t said anything to him about lacking a gift from the youngest member of their Company. Then again, why would he? Bilbo was not familiar with their customs and thought the gifts to be unnecessary. He would not recognize such a rejection for what it was. After receiving so many gifts all at once, he probably had not even noticed one was missing. 

“We will figure it out. Kili will be alright.”

Thorin said it out loud, and he wasn’t entirely sure if the words were meant to comfort Fili or himself.

Fili nodded once, gripping Thorin’s forearm. Then he let go and ducked away from his touch, taking a step towards the door. “We should go. We’re wasting daylight.”

Thorin caught him, putting a hand on his chest to stop him. “How are you faring?”

Fili paused and met his gaze with a raised brow, a lightness back in his green eyes that had been missing before. The corner of his mouth curled up, though not enough to be a smile. “If you are referring to how I feel about the news of my apparent death in another time-line, I’m fine.”

“Fili—”

“The Fili who died in that battle was not me. I will not agonize myself over his fate.”

There was no lie in the words. No hint of doubt in them. Thorin didn’t have the heart to disagree with him, though he didn’t understand it.

Then again, Fili had no memory of that day. He could not remember the echoing sound of his dying scream on the frozen air, could not remember the jagged blade that pierced his back or the fall to ice far below.

Thorin could never forget it.

“Uncle.” Their gazes met, and there was a stone-solid certainty in Fili’s eyes, even as he grinned. “I’m still here. Don’t grieve for me while I’m standing right in front of you. It’s weird.”

Pushing past that heavy rock in his chest, Thorin did his best to return the smile, though he was sure it looked strained. “I am sorry.” 

Fili just shrugged, brushing off the apology. “Let’s get out of here. I’m sick of the stench of fish.”

Notes:

khajamu a’khuf - gift of acceptance
barafu ik-kurdu - family of the heart

Chapter 24: Fire On Water

Summary:

Bilbo and Company begin the last leg of their journey to Erebor.

Notes:

This chapter feels kind of all over the place to me, but I'm going out of town for the weekend and wanted to have this posted before I leave, so there you go.

I just want to point out to anyone who many not have noticed that I did update Chapter 23 last week and it is now much longer than when I first posted it a year ago. If you're not sure if you've read the updated version or not, I suggest going back to check before you read this chapter :)

Chapter Text

That night, they made camp high in the foothills above the northern shore of the Long Lake. Settled in the imposing shadow of the Lonely Mountain, the Company kept their voices low as they spoke. Whether it was from fear of gaining the dragon’s attention, or reverence for being so close to their legendary lost homeland, Bilbo wasn’t sure. A mixture of both, maybe. Either way, he was glad to note that most of his dwarves seemed to be in high spirits, with only a few exceptions.

Dori had been in a dreadful mood all day, snapping and snarling at anyone who dared try to speak to him, arguing with Oin every time the old healer checked on his wounds during the break, and keeping an especially venomous glare fixed on Dwalin’s back—as always, the warrior either didn’t notice or didn’t care.

Everyone gave Dori a wide berth to steer clear of his wrathful mood, but Ori in particular seemed to be avoiding his oldest brother. Which was odd, given that he’d practically been glued to Dori’s side since he was injured.

And then there were Fili and Kili. 

Thorin sat with them now at the outskirts of camp, talking quietly enough that Bilbo couldn’t even hear the rumble of his voice as he spoke. The princes were unusually subdued. Kili was still out of sorts, pale and tight-lipped and bearing great resemblance to a dark cloud threatening an oncoming storm. Fili watched his brother intently, his usual confident swagger replaced with worry. 

“What’s that?”

Bofur’s voice broke through the quiet and Bilbo’s attention snapped away from the Durins to the hatted dwarf, then turned to look in the direction that his friend was pointing.

Squinting into the darkness, it was a few moments before he saw it—a dim flickering of light over the crest of the hill behind them. 

“Looks like fire,” Nori said.

A wave of murmuring broke over the Company. Sure enough, as they watched, the light slowly grew brighter.

From where they were camped, in a bowl between two hills to block them from the wind, they couldn’t see the source of the orange glow of the flames. But if they were to climb to the top of the hill to look, Bilbo had no doubt what they would see.

“It’s coming from Lake-town,” he said quietly.

From the corner of his eye, he watched Thorin spring to his feet. “Gloin, put our fire out. Dwalin, Bofur, take first watch.”

“You think we’ll be attacked?” Dwalin asked, automatically reaching for him war-hammer resting against the rock beside him.

Thorin didn’t answer the question, already striding away from camp and up the hill, with both nephews and half the Company hot on his heels.

Bilbo briefly considered following them, but decided against it. He didn’t trust himself to climb the hill in the dark, even if the light of the moon was decent. He’d probably wind up getting more scraped and bruised than he really wanted, and standing there gawking at the burning town—if that fire was indeed at the lake—wouldn’t be helpful in anyway.

So he left the handful of dwarves to hurry up the hillside without him, and turned to watch mournfully as their little campfire spluttered and died, resigning himself to night spent out in the cold. Winter was fast approaching, and though he’d managed to get his hands on a cloak and thicker clothing from the market in Lake-town, he didn’t expect they’d be enough to keep him completely warm. 

He stood as close as possible to the still-smoldering cinders in the fire, hoping to soak up any last bit of warmth he could, and tried not to listen to the horrified voices coming from the top of the hill. 

Several minutes later, a hand closed around his shoulder and turned to look up into Thorin’s grim face.

“Lake-town, is it…” He trailed off.

“It is burning,” Thorin confirmed. 

“But..but why?” 

It didn’t make any sense. This didn’t happen last time. At least, not until the dragon went on a rampage. And Smaug certainly wasn’t out there right now setting fire to poor fishing villages.

Thorin just shook his head. “It is too far for us to see what is happening. But I do not want the light of our own fire to lead anyone to us if Esgaroth has been attacked.”

As if to emphasize the lack of campfire, a cold wind blew through camp and Bilbo shuddered, pulling his coat and cloak tighter around himself.

The dwarf’s expression softened somewhat. “Come lay beside me. I do not want you to freeze.”

There were far more important things to worry about at the moment, but Bilbo felt his face grow uncomfortably warm at the invitation and he silently admonished himself for the reaction, hoping Thorin couldn’t see his flush in the dim light of the dwindling embers. What was there to be embarrassed about? They’d slept beside each other every night in Mirkwood for the same purpose, up until the elves captured them. It was practicality. Besides, he was a hobbit. He wasn’t about to deny such a simple comfort when it was offered. And if accepting that offer meant that he had a reasonable excuse to steal a cuddle from the dwarf that he so admired, well, that was all the better. 

So he smiled gratefully and nodded. “I think I’ll do just that, thank you.”

Snatching up his pack and bedroll, he followed Thorin over to where his things were, not far from where he’d been sitting with his nephews previously. Both of the princes still stood at the top of the hill, staring out at the lake with some of the others.

Still, Bilbo lowered his voice in the hopes he wouldn’t be overheard. 

“How is Kili?”

The moonlight was enough for him to see the way that Thorin grimaced at the question.

“I have tried speaking with him. He insists he is fine.”

“But?”

Sighing, Thorin spread his bedroll and sat down. “Fili is worried enough that he came to me this morning. He thinks Kili is sick.”

Bilbo nodded in agreement immediately. Anyone with eyes could tell that Kili was unwell. There was little question of it, considering how pale he’d been of late, and how dark the circles under his eyes were. And anyone who knew the young dwarf would know that his behavior was all wrong, his usual cheer and mischief absent and replaced with anxiety and a shadowy gloom. The question wasn’t whether or not something was wrong, the question was what was causing it.

“And he hasn’t told Fili anything about what’s bothering him?”

Thorin shook his head. “That is what worries me.”

Bilbo said nothing more as he kicked a few rocks out of the way and laid out his own bedroll. He lowered himself to the ground slowly, mindful of his aching muscles—it seemed the couple weeks sitting mostly idle in Mirkwood and Lake-town had chipped away at some of his endurance for travel, and spending the entire day walking up hill had taken its toll on his legs. He positioned his pack to be a pillow and laid back on it with a deep sigh.

From the corner of his vision, he saw Thorin’s eyes narrow, but before he could ask what was wrong, Bilbo found himself being grabbed around the waist and hauled against the dwarf’s chest with an undignified yelp.

Laughter rumbled from various members of the Company that hadn’t left camp and Bilbo huffed, scowling at Thorin rather than acknowledge the continuing warmth in his cheeks. “What was that for?”

“You were too far away.”

“I was right next to you!” 

Thorin just hummed.

“Have I ever told you you have the worst manners of anyone I’ve ever met?”

“Worse than trolls and goblins and spiders and wood-elves?” Thorin asked, a teasing edge in his tone that conflicted with the solemn look on his face.

Bilbo’s scowl deepened, even as he felt the urge to laugh. “I stand by what I said.”

“Worse than Lobelia Sackville-Baggins?”

He opened his mouth to tell the ridiculous dwarf that yes, he most definitely was worse than even that horrible hag, then thought better of it. He huffed and rolled his eyes. “Fine, you’ve got me there. I’d certainly rather freeze to death than cozy up to her in any case. Dreadful woman.” 

“But you would cozy up to a troll?”

“Who says I’m not already?”

Thorin made an offended noise and Bilbo chuckled, but neither of them had the chance to get another word in before someone else interrupted.

“Oi, you two!” Nori called. “Stop your flirting! Some of us are trying to sleep.”

They both shut up.

Flirting? Flirting?

One of these dwarves would be flirting with the sharp end of his dagger pretty soon if they didn’t start minding their own business. Him? Flirting with Thorin? Of all the ridiculous notions! He would never—

Well, okay, maybe he would. Maybe he was. But that didn’t mean he needed any of the others to point it out, thank you very much. 

This was exactly the type of thing he’d promised himself he wouldn’t do at the beginning of this mad (second) adventure across Middle Earth. The flirting, that was. Or the pining. Or anything else. Of course, telling himself he wouldn’t fall in love (again) was a much easier decision to make when he wasn’t being confronted with those wonderful blue eyes every time he turned around and getting the breath sucked out of his lungs a few dozen times a day whenever Thorin spoke to him.

And all the more of a fool that made him, to indulge himself in an old infatuation from a lifetime ago when he knew full well it couldn’t last. 

Sooner or later, he’d have no choice but to leave the Company behind and set out on another quest. He’d have to—

But no. Better not to think about it, really. The Ring had been so quiet over the past few days. He hardly wanted to draw its attention again by thinking of such things. He didn’t need it showing him any more visions of dead friends.

The arms around him tightened slightly and Bilbo was drawn out of his sulking thoughts. Looking up, he found that the good humor in Thorin’s face had gone, and he was staring out into the distance with a worried furrow between his brows.

“Do you think I made a mistake telling them of their deaths on the last quest?”

Bilbo craned his neck to look behind him, following Thorin’s gaze to where it rested on two figures still at the top of the hill, just dark silhouettes against the glow of fire. The princes were alone, the rest of the Company having returned to camp by now.

An image of their lifeless bodies laying still on stone tables came unbidden to his mind, and it was no vision except one from his own memories.

He shoved it away stubbornly, reminding himself that they were still alive, and would remain that way for a long, long time to come. 

“No,” Bilbo whispered. “They deserved to know the truth.”

Even if the truth hurt.

 

***

 

The next afternoon, they crested the top of a rocky hill and any quiet chatter amongst the Company fell to silence as they all stopped in their tracks. They’d come to the edge of a high cliff, and in the valley below stood the ruins of Dale. Beyond that, the River Running snaked around hills and across barren fields of ash and rock, like a glimmering ribbon of mithril leading straight to the Lonely Mountain.

At long last, here they were. If they kept up the pace, they could reach Dale by sunset and seek shelter from the wind for the night. Though, whether any of them actually wanted to make camp among ghosts was still undecided.
Once, the Overlook had been a sign that the end of their long journey was in sight. A relief, really, even knowing that they still had a dragon to face.

Now, Bilbo looked at the empty lands stretched out before them and all he could see was the chaos of a battlefield. The silence would be broken by battle-cries and dying screams. The river would run red with blood. He stubbornly refused to allow himself to look at the distant outline of Raven Hill, even as the shape of it hovered at the edge of his blurring vision.

Someone came to stand beside him wordlessly.

“It seems so much smaller than I remember. But then, I suppose everything appeared big to me in those days.”

A warm hand grasped his and he realized he was shaking. He held onto Thorin tightly and forced himself to take a few deep breaths, stubbornly pushing away all the old memories threatening to rise to the surface.

When he was sure his voice wouldn’t break, he cleared his throat and spoke again. “I wish I could say we should wait here for Gandalf, but I fear we’d be here for a long time.”

“Where is he?”

“On his way to Dol Guldur, I expect, if he isn’t there already.”

Bilbo shuddered. He’d never laid eyes on the old fortress himself—a fact that he was grateful for. A place like that was better left firmly to the imagination. He’d already seen enough nasty parts of the world to last him a lifetime, though he had a horrible inkling that he would see many more such places before this second lifetime was done. The thought was equally horrifying and exhausting.

“Dol Guldur,” Thorin repeated, and when Bilbo glanced up at him, he looked caught off guard. “Why?”

Unconsciously, Bilbo reached for the pouch that hung on a cord around his neck, then jerked his hand away as soon as he realized what he was doing. He shook his head sharply. “I’ll tell you later. I fear talking about it now will bring bad luck down on our heads.”

Thorin studied him for a moment, then nodded and squeezed his hand. “I am sure he will be fine. Tharkûn can take care of himself.”

“You’re right,” Bilbo said, though he didn’t feel overly confident in the statement. He stared out at the land for a few moments longer, then turned his back on the view to face Thorin. “Well, I suppose there’s no point in dallying. Shall we move on?”

Thorin opened his mouth to respond, but before he could get a single word out, a high, clear whistle rang through the air.

“Wait!” someone cried out.

The Company—many of whom had sat on the ground to take a rest, or were standing at the edge of the Overlook staring out at Dale—scrambled to their feet and turned to look behind them, peering down the rocky slopes for any sign of who had yelled. A few moments later, a white horse appeared from behind an outcropping of large boulders, bearing two tall riders on its back, one red-haired and one pale blond.

That was all Bilbo got to see before he was pulled roughly by the arm behind Thorin and found himself with a face full of fur. All around them, metal whined as dwarves drew their weapons.

Spitting out the fur from Thorin’s coat that had ended up in his mouth, Bilbo freed his arm from the dwarf’s grip and stepped back to his side, glaring up at him indignantly. “Excuse you, Mister Oakenshield—”

“You do not have your sword, Bilbo.”

He scoffed. “I hardly need it at the moment. It’s only Legolas and—”

“Tauriel!”

Kili, who had been so quiet and upset for the past week and a half, sounded almost back to his normal self with the single word. His voice was delighted, if not a little hoarse, and he lowered his bow and took several steps forward as the elves and their mount came to a halt a few yards away from the Company.

The guard captain swung down from the horse’s back and landed gracefully on her feet, a tentative smile crossing her lips as her eyes found the young dwarf prince. But then her attention moved across the Company, scanning their faces until she found Thorin.

His hand tightened around the handle of his sword and he drew it a few inches from its sheath before Bilbo caught his wrist.

Seeming undeterred by the hostility being aimed at her, she came closer, but was forced to stop when several dwarves stepped into her path.

On the horse, Legolas made a move to grab one of his own blades.

“Oh, for goodness sake! Put those down!” Bilbo snapped, both exasperated and more than a little annoyed by their antics.

To his surprise, the dwarves all listened to him after a moment of hesitation. A few even had the decency to look somewhat sheepish.

The elf prince relaxed and Tauriel shot Bilbo a grateful look. Rather than try to approach again, she just returned her attention to Thorin and dipped her head in a respectful bow. Then she straightened and reached behind her to unstrap a long object wrapped in canvas from her back.

“Bard of Lake-town requested I bring this to you,” she said calmly.

Hope sparked in Bilbo’s chest at the words. If the package had come from Bard, there was only one thing it could possibly be. He glanced at the dwarf beside him, but he didn’t look nearly as thrilled.

Instead, Thorin looked like he’d just bitten into a lemon and probably would have stood there forever if Bilbo didn’t elbow him sharply in the ribs.

The dwarf scowled down at him and Bilbo stared back, utterly unimpressed.

Grumbling, Thorin relented and left Bilbo’s side to approach Tauriel. He held out his hand and she gave him the package. As he unwrapped the canvas, a wave of murmurs broke out over the Company, a mixture of shock and confusion, and they crowded in closer to get a better look.

“What is that?” Bofur asked.

“A spear,” Ori suggested.

Fili shook his head. “It’s like no spear I’ve ever seen.”

Bilbo stayed back, knowing what he would see. He was unsure if the roiling in his stomach was excitement or apprehension, but it hardly mattered. There was already a whirlwind of thoughts in his mind—ideas of how they could use this to their advantage.

“Is that what I think it is?” Gloin asked, voice almost reverent.

“Aye,” Balin said. “A black arrow.”

“Why would he give me this now?” Thorin asked.

It was Legolas who answered him. “Orcs attacked Esgaroth late in the night. There were few casualties, but the town burned, and the people were forced to evacuate.”

That broke him from his thoughts and Bilbo cringed. All those poor people. He had hoped they could avoid the destruction of Lake-town this time around—hoped that if they could kill the dragon before it ever got the chance to leave the mountain, then all those innocent lives would be spared.

At least now, if Smaug did manage to reach the town again, it would be empty. Surely Bard would have the sense to keep everyone out of sight in the event of a dragon attack, since he had given up his only weapon to them.

“Bard said he has no use for this now. He didn’t explain more than that, just said that you would understand,” Tauriel said.

“What of his children? Are they safe?”

“None of them were harmed.”

Bilbo didn’t remember Bard’s children well. He’d only met them briefly, and couldn’t recall his daughters’ names. Bain, Bard’s only son, had been crowned King of Dale after his father’s death, but Bilbo knew no more of them than that. Still, it was a relief to hear they were all safe.

Nodding once, Thorin said tightly, “Thank you.”

Bilbo blinked, surprised by the words. Thorin Oakenshield thanking an elf? He never thought he’d see the day.

Tauriel tilted her head slightly to the side, as if curious, but she said nothing more and started walking back to her horse. She stopped in her tracks when Kili caught her hand and said something quiet enough that Bilbo couldn’t make out the words.

It was at that moment that Thorin spun on his heel and came striding back towards Bilbo, scowling once again.

Bilbo coughed to cover up his laugh, sure that the dwarf wouldn’t appreciate his amusement at the situation. As soon as Thorin reached his side, he turned his attention to the arrow clutched tightly in his hands, still partially unwrapped from the thick canvas. Reaching out, he ran his fingers along the cool, dark metal wonderingly.

He’d never actually seen the black arrow with his own eyes. It was much longer than he had ever imagined it being—not quite twice his own height, but nearly—and had an interesting twist in the metal of the sharp tip that made him wonder if it would spiral through the air when shot. Like a drill, maybe. Still, it seemed like such a small thing to kill a dragon.

“Well, this was certainly unexpected.” He drew his hand away from the arrow and met Thorin’s eye, feeling more hopeful about their ability to take on Smaug than he had in months. “Do you think it will be enough?”

“It was enough to kill the giant slug last time. There is no reason it should not work now. We just need a plan.” Despite continuing to look rather rankled, Thorin managed to keep most of the irritation out of his voice. He took one last look at the arrow before re-wrapping it in the canvas covering. He seemed ready to say something else, but was interrupted before he had the chance.

“Tauriel, there is no time to waste!”

Legolas sounded impatient—apparently, he wasn’t too thrilled about the friendship between his guard captain and the dwarf prince, either.

Bilbo found himself quite looking forward to the day that the elf prince finally crossed paths with Gimli once again. He chuckled.

“It is not funny.”

Rolling his eyes, Bilbo nudged Thorin. “Oh, lighten up. There’s no use in griping about it. We’ll need all the help we can get from the elves if we want to win the battle. Besides, at least he’s smiling again.”

Sure enough, Kili was wearing that familiar bright grin on his face that had been missing lately, though it shrunk slightly when Tauriel turned away from him again to heed Legolas.

“Where are you going?” Kili called after her.

Tauriel swung up into the saddle behind Legolas, then leaned around him to answer the question. “We ride to Gundabad.”

The Company had remained relatively quiet since the reveal of the black arrow, but at the mention of the fortress, several of them voiced their surprise.

Bofur’s voice rose above the rest, sounding baffled. “Gundabad? Why on Arda would you ever want to go there?”

A hint of a scowl crossed Legolas’s fair features, but he answered the question anyway. “I recognized the orc who led the attack on Esgaroth. His name is Bolg, spawn of the Defiler. He bore the mark of Gundabad, and fled into the north. Dark things are stirring in the shadows. I fear the old fortress is abandoned no longer.”

Before anyone could comment or ask anymore questions, Legolas urged their horse into a gallop and the elves were gone.

 

***

 

There was a walking path from the Overlook down into the valley that Bilbo imagined used to be well-maintained, if the broken paving stones peeking out from under the dirt and lichen were anything to go by. But now it was only half visible, and the cracked edges of the paving stones were sharp, and the left side of the path was crumbled away in many places. One wrong step and he might go sliding down the steep slope to the valley floor below—a fall that probably wouldn’t kill him, but certainly would not leave his pride intact. 

The third time he slipped on a patch of loose gravel, a hand caught him under his arm, holding him steady until he managed to get his feet under him again and grumbled out his thanks.

Thorin hummed and let go of him. “You are distracted.”

Sighing, he adjusted the straps of his pack on his shoulders. “Yes, I suppose I am.”

“What is wrong?”

“It’s probably nothing.”

“Tell me anyway.”

They started walking again and Bilbo considered his thoughts, trying to get them in order. His worry had started the night before, when they first spotted the glow of the flames in the direction of the lake and had been growing steadily worse as time went on. At first, he assumed it was just concern for the people of Lake-town. But if that were the case, surely the news from the elves that the people were safe should have helped calm him. Instead, he was even more uneasy than ever. 

Finally, he asked, “We’re meant to have at least a few weeks between Durin’s Day and the battle, right?”

“I was too preoccupied to keep track of the days.” There was a hint of guilt in Thorin’s tone and he paused, but it was gone when he went on. “But yes, it would have taken Dain and his army about a week to get here from the Iron Hills, and I did not send for him until the elves and men arrived in Dale. Why?”

“It’s just, I could have sworn the orcs attacked Lake-town the same night Smaug did. But if Bolg’s pack is already on its way to Gundabad, I’m worried…” He trailed off.

Thorin caught his arm and pulled him aside. They stood as far to the right as they were able and allowed the dwarves behind them to move ahead. Oin, Gloin, Nori, and Bofur passed them by with nods and a wide grin from the last, but Dwalin paused beside them, giving Thorin a questioning look. He just waved the warrior on, so Dwalin shrugged and kept walking. 

Once the others were several paces ahead of them, Thorin looked down at Bilbo. “You think we might not have as much time as we expect before Azog arrives with his armies.”

“Exactly.” Bilbo had spent the majority of this journey doing his best not to think too much about the battle yet to come, but the closer they came to the mountain and the battlefield itself, the harder it was to ignore such thoughts. There were so many things that they had no control over. That they had no way of predicting. It was dizzyingly terrifying if he let himself dwell on it for too long. He swallowed thickly, shaking his head. “I could be wrong, of course. My memories are a bit fuzzy at times. It all happened so long ago.”

He hoped that was all this was—just a case of him incorrectly remembering something from eighty years ago—but he had a terrible feeling he was right.

Thorin considered him for several long moments, then started walking again. With their arms still hooked together, Bilbo had little choice but to follow him.

A minute passed in silence, and Bilbo got impatient, so he nudged Thorin. “Well? What do you think?”

“It is worrying. Should the battle start even a few days earlier, it could be disastrous. But there is nothing we can do about it at the moment. All we can do right now is figure out how to defeat the dragon.”

He was right, of course, but… “That doesn’t make me feel better.”

“I promise you, I will find a raven and call for Dain as soon as the dragon is dead. We will do everything in our power to be prepared for the battle when it comes.”

Bilbo nodded.

He only hoped it would be enough.

Chapter 25: The Evils of Gold

Summary:

Thorin has a difficult conversation with his sister-sons.

Notes:

Three chapters in three weeks! I'm on a roll!
I made myself cry a little bit while writing this one. I hope you enjoy it :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

After a night of sleeping on the very outskirts of the abandoned city, listening to the wind whisper through the charred remains of destroyed buildings, the Company had decided that they’d prefer to travel around Dale rather than through it. The route would add about half a day’s travel to their trek to the mountain, but they unanimously agreed that the delay was worth it. No one was eager to wander through those empty streets.

So they went around, and they spent the first several hours of the day walking in silence—whether out of respect for the dead or fear of them.

Thorin wasn’t sure he believed in ghosts, but he could have sworn he felt the weight of accusing eyes bearing down on him, and he refused to allow his gaze to linger on the ruins for too long, lest he start to imagine figures that moved in the shadows.

Sometime around noon, he found himself walking beside Dwalin.

“Dori has looked like he wants to gut you even more than usual.” He said casually, pulling out his water-skin for a drink.

Indeed, the silver-haired dwarf had spent the past two days watching Dwalin with death in his eyes, fingering the axe at his side like he might actually go on the attack. Not that it was unusual—Dori had been carrying a grudge against the warrior for the entire journey this side of the Misty Mountains. 

From the corner of his eye, he saw Dwalin’s expression turn incredibly smug. “Seems Ori was missing from their room our last night on the lake.”

Thorin followed his best friend’s gaze to the young scribe that walked several yards ahead of them—side by side with Bilbo and Balin, who chatted amongst themselves quietly—and sucked in a sharp breath, then immediately regretted it as he began to choke on his water. 

Dwalin pounded him on the back a few times, and Thorin looked at him incredulously, his voice a little hoarse. “You didn't.”

The warrior’s smug smirk only grew, confirming that he most certainly had.

“He is going to rip you to pieces as soon as his shoulder is healed.”

It wasn’t an exaggeration. The Ri brothers were known for their strength. Dori, who had enough over-protectiveness of his youngest brother to rival that of an angry mother bear, was particularly fearsome. Those who were smart did everything they could to avoid crossing him and his dangerous temper. He didn’t need a blade—if he wanted to, he could tear Dwalin apart with his bare hands. 

Not that Dwalin seemed worried about that very real danger.

“He can try.”

“He has beaten you before,” Thorin pointed out.

In fact, Dori was among the small few who had ever bested Dwalin in a fight.

“I’m not the one he needs to worry about.” Dwalin shrugged, then caught his questioning glance and elaborated. “He’ll have to get past Ori first. The lad is getting fed up with the coddling. I’d bet all the gold in Erebor he’ll win that fight without lifting a finger.”

Thorin shook his head, baffled.

Had this happened before? 

He couldn’t remember ever noticing that there was some sort of relationship blooming between his shield-brother and the Company’s young scribe on the last journey. Was he just that blind, or had something on this journey changed to allow the unlikely pair to come together? He was sure nothing had changed that drastically, though. Could it just have been their extended stay in Lake-town that caused this? 

The way Dwalin was staring ahead at Ori was bordering on affectionate.

“Dwalin, is he—”

He didn’t even get the chance to finish the question.

“Aye.”

The answer didn’t help his confusion. “How long have you known?”

Dwalin glanced at him and gave a one shoulder shrug. “A while.”

A while. How long was a while? Since the quest started? Longer? Surely Thorin would have noticed his best friend finding his One if it had happened last time, right?

His eyes slid to his own One consideringly. He’d have to ask Bilbo. Maybe he would know—

“When are you going to tell him?”

“What?”

“The burglar.”

“What about him?”

“You’ve been staring at his ass all day.”

Thorin tore his eyes away from Bilbo. “I have not—” 

Dwalin snickered and Thorin stopped spluttering, scowling at his friend in annoyance.

“We all know what he is to you, there’s no use in denying it.”

“I do not deny it,” Thorin grumbled.

After all, he hadn’t made much an attempt to hide it as of late. He knew full well that the rest of his Company had been betting on him and Bilbo since before Beorn’s and opted to ignore it to protect his own sanity, but he wasn’t going to pretend that his heart didn’t belong to the hobbit. He’d tried, for a while, but found his efforts to be useless and abandoned them completely by the time they left Rivendell. He was sure everyone between here and the Misty Mountains knew of his affection for his burglar at this point—save for Bilbo himself, who seemed to remain willfully oblivious to it, no matter how many innuendos or teasing remarks were thrown his way by nosy dwarves who didn’t know how to mind their own business. 

Bilbo’s ignorance of his feelings served Thorin’s purposes well enough, even if it frustrated him at times. 

“So?” Dwalin said.

Thorin knew what he was asking, and wished he wouldn’t. “I cannot tell him.”

“What are you waiting for, an invitation? You do know he adores you?”

Of course he knew the hobbit loved him—how could he not? Bilbo wasn’t exactly discrete about it, either, even if he was utterly clueless. 

“That is exactly why he cannot know.” Dwalin just gave him an empty look, and Thorin went on, not sure why he felt the need to explain himself, but a little desperate to all the same. He was careful to keep his voice low, to avoid any of the others overhearing. “I may die in this battle. How can I offer myself to him now, knowing I might take it all away again before the week is done? It would be selfish of me.”

He still couldn’t forget the way Bilbo had sounded that day at the Carrock, only hours before they were officially reunited with one another.

I refuse to watch you die, Thorin.

The hobbit deserved everything Thorin could give and more, but he could not guarantee his own survival. He did not want to make any promises he knew he might not keep. It wouldn’t be fair.

“Please tell me you’re joking,” Dwalin said, exasperated.

Thorin said nothing.

Snorting, Dwalin knocked him in the shoulder hard enough to make him stumble. “That is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.”

Thorin glared at him and snapped, “What would you have me do?” 

“Mahal’s sake, Thorin, he may be dumber than a rock sometimes, but give Bilbo some credit. You didn’t force him to come on the quest, and he knew the risks better than any of us. Has it occurred to you that maybe he’d want you to tell him?”

The words were strangely familiar and made a sense of defensiveness rise in him, though he couldn’t quite recall why. Thorin’s brows furrowed and his mouth opened and closed uselessly as he failed to come up with a suitable response. 

As he struggled, Dwalin snorted at him again and picked up his pace, leaving Thorin behind. 

 

***

 

Far off in the distance, the sun was beginning to set behind the Misty Mountains, painting the horizon in a smear of glowing golden light. The ruins of Dale, hidden as they were within the hills at the foot of Erebor, were already cast into shadow, and its crumbling silhouette was eerie. They’d chosen to camp at the top of one of those hills, tucked behind a stand of sharp boulders that blocked them from the city’s sight, and it would hopefully grant them some measure of peace as they slept—none of them had been comfortable traveling so near to the city’s remains, and as soon as they’d escaped its looming shadows, several of the Company had nervously joked about the sensation of feeling watched as they passed by.

Soon after stopping for the night, though, Thorin found himself venturing back into the open with Bilbo at his side. Carrying the Company’s empty water-skins, they made their way down the craggy slope of the hill, headed for a stream that gurgled at the bottom. 

Dwalin’s words from earlier wouldn’t stop echoing in his mind, and Thorin watched the hobbit from the corner of his vision, wondering if his shield-brother was right. 

Was it foolish of him not to tell Bilbo what he was to him while he still had the chance to do so? Maybe he should.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit only hummed in response.

“I want to ask…” He stopped.

Bilbo looked over his shoulder at him with a raised brow. “Yes?”

In the endless darkness following his death, Thorin had wished he’d had more time with his One. He’d wished he could have told Bilbo everything. But there had been plenty of opportunities over these past months, and he found that he wasn’t ready to give voice to those feelings, no matter how much he had yearned to do so in that dark place between worlds.

Or maybe he was just a coward.

So he pushed away the thought of making any kind of confession and moved to a different topic. “Do you know if Dwalin and Ori were ever…” He trailed off, unsure of exactly how to finish the question, but Bilbo brightened.

“Oh, I suppose you wouldn’t know about that!” The hobbit laughed and shook his head, grinning. “It caused quite a lot of drama back in the day. It wasn’t until several years after the mountain was reclaimed that the two announced their marriage. They’d gone off and eloped without a word to anyone, if you can believe it. I’m sure you can imagine the tizzy that sent Dori into as soon as he found out.” Bilbo’s smile fell slightly and he looked contemplative. “Now that you mention it, though, it is odd that they seem to be together already. I wonder what that’s all about.”

Well, that answered that question.

Thorin wasn’t sure he could picture Dwalin married to anyone, least of all the Company’s soft-spoken scribe. Then again, he’d never pictured himself falling in love with a hobbit, either, so maybe he needed to broaden his imagination a bit. 

“Do you think—”

A chorus of shouting behind them interrupted him and stopped him in his tracks.

His eyes met Bilbo’s, and a second later, both of them were sprinting back up the hill, weapons in hand, abandoning the water-skins.

They returned to camp to find most of the Company standing crowded together, muttering worriedly to each other or shouting at his sister-sons.

Thorin shoved his way through the group in time to see Dwalin wrap his arms around Kili and drag him, kicking and struggling, away from his brother.

Dropping his sword, Thorin rushed forward to grab Fili under the arms and haul him off the ground. His sister-son was disheveled and angry with a split lip, blood leaking into his beard. 

“What in Mahal’s name is going on?” Thorin demanded.

“Ask him,” Fili snapped, pointing at his brother and trying to yank away from Thorin. “He attacked me.”

He didn’t let Fili go, but turned his attention to the younger of the two princes—still held firmly in Dwalin’s grip, he had gone limp, breathing hard and wide-eyed. “Kili?”

“I don’t—I don’t know why I—I didn’t mean to—” Kili stuttered, and Thorin saw he was trembling. 

When he was sure his heir wasn’t about to fall over or start another fight, Thorin released his hold on Fili.

He took a step towards Kili and Dwalin, but paused when Bilbo rushed past him.

Turning, Thorin saw Bilbo crouch a few feet away from where his sister-sons had been wrestling with each other. When the hobbit stood, there was a glint of gold in the palm of his hand. “You,” Bilbo spat down at the trinket he held, face white with fury. “How dare you! You leave that poor boy alone this instant!” 

Thorin took a step toward the hobbit, concerned. “Bilbo—”

Behind him, Dwalin bit out a sharp curse and several of the Company gasped. Thorin whirled around again.

Kili was straining against Dwalin’s hold, a dark hunger on his face focused solely on Bilbo and the Ring.

Alarmed, Thorin moved towards Kili at the same time that Fili placed himself in front of the hobbit, shielding Bilbo from his brother’s view with a fierce glare. 

Kili met the glare with a snarl and slammed an elbow into Dwalin’s stomach. “Let go of me!”

“Enough!” Thorin shouted, coming to a stop in front of the struggling pair. “Kili, calm down!” 

But Kili just writhed more, fighting to get free of Dwalin’s iron grip.

“Kili, ankuk e!”

The young dwarf went still, finally tearing his focus away from his brother to meet Thorin’s gaze. There was nothing of his sister-son in the black eyes that stared back at him, hard and cruel. 

Horror clenched at Thorin’s heart and on instinct he stepped forward to wrap his arms around Kili, even he hissed and snarled like a wild animal. He grabbed the back of Kili’s head firmly to stop his attempts at head-butting Dwalin in the nose and pressed his mouth to Kili’s ear, murmuring to him so quietly that none but his sister-son would hear.

“Kasamhili, inkhi rumu du e. Inkhi rumu, Karkukhal.”

The sound of his inner name being spoken aloud snapped Kili out of it. He went utterly still, and Thorin slowly pulled back, until they were nose to nose.

That darkness in Kili’s eyes faded back to its usual brown and that horrible hunger disappeared, changing to confusion, then fear.

“Uncle,” Kili croaked. The shimmer of unshed tears welled in his eyes. “I—” His voice cracked.

“I know,” Thorin said softly, ignoring the roiling nausea in his gut. 

Valar damn him, he knew. He should have seen it sooner. The signs of gold-sickness were obvious. If he wasn’t so afraid of confronting his own mistakes, he might have prevented this.

He looked at Dwalin and nodded. His shield-brother hesitated, but released Kili and stepped away, leaving the prince to stand on shaky legs. 

Thorin supported him, wrapping his arm around Kili’s shoulder and keeping him close. He looked back at Fili, who still stood protectively in front of Bilbo—the hobbit didn’t even seem to notice, still glaring venomously down at his clenched fist—and jerked his head. “Come help me collect the water.”

When he was sure Fili would follow, Thorin guided Kili back towards the stand of boulders. The Company separated around them, some gaping at Kili, some worried, some grim. No one said a word. Thorin wanted to snap at them all to stop staring and mind their own business, but he held his tongue. When he met Balin’s watery eyes, he spoke quietly.

“Keep everyone in camp. Do not wait for us to eat supper.”

Balin nodded and stepped aside to let them pass.

So Thorin led his sister-sons away, and halfway down the craggy hill, they collected the water-skins that he and Bilbo had left behind.

None of them said a word as they reached the bank of the stream and knelt to collect the water. Beside him, Kili’s hands shook so hard, he kept dropping his water-skins, so Thorin took those too and filled them himself. 

He tried not to look too closely at his own warped and wavering reflection in the stream. Had he, too, been so unrecognizable in his sickness as Kili had just been? Had his eyes been filled with that same darkness when he threatened Dwalin’s life? When he had his hands around Bilbo’s neck, ready to throw him from the rampart for his betrayal? The possibility made him sick.

When he stoppered the final skin, he splashed some of the freezing cold water in his face, hoping it would do something to erase his haunted expression. Then he finally turned to look at his sister-sons.

Both Fili and Kili had their eyes downcast, avoiding looking at him or each other. Fili still had blood drying on his chin and a red bruise was beginning to form beneath one eye. Kili’s gray, tired face was filled with apprehension and no small amount of guilt as he avoided looking at his brother.

Drawing in a steadying breath, Thorin dug in his pocket to find Bilbo’s handkerchief—the hobbit had once again left it behind in the house in Lake-town and Thorin picked it up on his way out and had yet to give it back. It was no longer perfectly white as it had been at the beginning of this journey. The cloth was stained and fraying in one corner, the blue of the embroidered initials faded, but it was clean. He dipped it in the stream then wrung out the excess water and offered it to Fili.

His heir took the handkerchief and held it to his split lip without a word.

“What happened?” 

He already had a good idea of exactly what had happened, but he wanted to hear it from them. 

Fili just shook his head and looked at Kili, and the youngest Durin ducked his head, shoulders hunching up to his ears. “I started it, Uncle. Don’t be mad at Fi.”

“I am not angry with either of you.” How could he be? This was no one’s fault but his own. “Just tell me.”

Swallowing thickly, Kili hesitated several long moments before slowly answering him. “I was looking at the Ring, and when Fili saw it and asked what it was, for some reason…I don’t know. I thought he was going to take it from me, and I just got so…angry all of a sudden.”

Thorin understood all too well the anger that Kili spoke of, jealous and all-consuming within an instant when triggered, immune to all rational thought. The memory of it—of the violence he had committed under the influence of that anger—left an oily stain on his soul that he wasn’t sure would ever wash away.

“Where did you get the Ring?”

“Bilbo dropped it,” Kili said miserably. He paused, then rushed to add, “I swear I was going to give it back! I just wanted to look at it.”

Sighing, Thorin dragged a hand through his hair, fingers getting caught on tangles that he hadn’t taken the time to comb out today.

On the last journey, his sister-sons had been almost as unaffected by the gold sickness as Bilbo. They’d been some of the few who had dared to argue with him in his madness, whose minds had been clear enough to see that things were wrong. They’d faced the family curse and overcome it when he could not. Or so he told himself. He had spent the past several months refusing to allow himself to dwell on the topic. He didn’t like remembering how monstrous he’d become in those shining golden halls. And pretending his sister-sons were safe from the sickness had made it all the easier to try and forget.

He was such a fool.

Foolish. Selfish. Proud.

Feeling sick, Thorin forced himself to face it.

Kili was staring intently at the ground, avoiding looking at him, so Thorin met Fili’s gaze and held it. “I am sorry. I have failed you again.”

“What are you talking about?” Fili asked quietly.

“The gold-sickness.” Thorin drew in another slow, calming breath. “It is a conversation I should have had with you long before we ever left Ered Luin.”

Fili didn’t so much as blink. “You said before that the sickness is the reason the last quest failed, but you never explained how.”

“No, I did not.” 

“Then tell us now.”

A few long moments of silence passed between the three of them and Thorin itched to return to camp. To not say another word. To not recount all that he had done and lay out all his many mistakes for their judgement. He never wanted to speak of it again.

He had to.

But to start with the sickness was too painful.

“It began in the Shire, the night we arrived at Bag End to recruit our burglar.”

And he told them everything. He told them about the nervous gentle-hobbit who fainted at the mere mention of dragons and almost didn’t join the quest at all, about their first confrontation with the trolls, about Radagast the Brown and his sled pulled by rabbits—they were skeptical of his claims about Bilbo ever being that soft, and Fili accused Thorin of making things up when it came to the wizard, but the story eased some of the tension between the three of them. 

By the time they reached their escape from Thranduil’s dungeons, some color had returned to Kili’s face and he was hanging off of Thorin’s every word.

“He put us in barrels?” Kili asked, a tinge of delight making its way into his tone.

“He did.” Thorin chuckled and shook his head. “And then he sent us floating down the river, over waterfalls and through whitewater rapids, and all the while we were being chased by angry elves and orcs trying to murder us from the banks.” The memory of the orcs drained away what amusement he had for the memory, though, and he grimaced. “We were nearly caught at the border of Thranduil’s kingdom, where a barrier stretched across the river. Kili left his barrel to raise the gate and was struck in the leg by an orc’s arrow.”

Any good humor in his sister-sons’ faces faded to something more solemn.

And as much as he wanted to end the story there, Thorin forced himself to continue. “It was in Lake-town that the gold-sickness finally got its hold on me.” 

Every word that followed, Thorin had to drag from his own throat, forcing himself to speak them aloud, no matter how foul of a taste they left on his tongue. From Bard smuggling them into his home, to their attempt at stealing weapons and their capture, to the grand promises he made to the people of Lake-town—he remained carefully steady through it all, but when it came to the abandonment of his kin, he wavered.

“Kili…Kili was sick with infection from his wound. I was blinded by my focus on the mountain, and I did not see how desperately he needed medicine. All I cared about was that he was too weak to travel and he would slow us down.” He drew in a shaking breath, and couldn’t bring himself to look either of his sister-sons in the eye. “We argued, Fili. I wanted you to come with me, but you refused to be parted from your brother. Oin chose to stay with you. No one knew where Bofur was. I did not have the patience to wait. I-I left all four of you behind that day.”

It was but the first of his many damning mistakes. 

Thorin spoke of them all, refusing to allow himself to skip a single one—goading the dragon into attacking Lake-town, his lack of concern for the safety of the Company members who had been left behind, his obsession with the Arkenstone, choosing to go to war rather than fulfill the oaths he had made in Lake-town, his treatment of Bilbo, leaving the dwarves from the Iron Hills to fight and die while he hid inside the mountain. He told them of every terrible thought and deed that had come from his gold-sick mind.

Through it all, neither of his sister-sons said a single word, letting him speak without interruption.

Thorin was too afraid look at their expressions, so he kept his eyes locked on his hands clasped tightly in his lap.

“Ravenhill was a trap. I sent you straight into Azog’s hands.”

He had to stop, then, when he realized he was shaking. 

By now, dusk was fading into true night. The little stream gurgled and the ruins of Dale seemed to moan in the distance with the wind that blew through its empty streets, but the three sons of Durin stayed silent for a long minute. Thorin knew they were waiting for him to continue the story, but he wasn’t sure if he could bear it.

Then…

“Hand,” Kili said.

“What?” Thorin asked, glancing up at his sister-son.

Kili smiled at him, though it was strained. “Azog only has one.”

Fili let out an un-princely snort and elbowed his brother in the ribs.

Shaking his head, Thorin made a strangled sound that was meant to be a laugh, but came out more like a pathetic sob. 

“Uncle.”

Finally, Thorin looked Fili in the eye, and he was sure his heir could see his fear. “Do you truly wish to know the details of this part?”

He prayed the answer would be no, but knew better than to expect it.

The two brothers looked at each other for a moment, communicating in that silent way they had perfected as children. Then Fili met Thorin’s eye again and nodded. “Tell us everything.”

So, reluctantly, he pushed on.

“Bilbo came to warn us of the trap, but by then, it was too late. Azog captured you, Fili. We were too far away to do anything but watch as he killed you, then dropped your body from the top of the tower.” 

Unable to control his raspy breath or the hot tears that leaked down his cheeks, Thorin stopped again. If he closed his eyes, he would be there again—surrounded by stone and ice, covered in blood, unable to breathe as Fili’s dying scream faded on the wind and the Defiler looked down on him, gloating and triumphant. And he had no one to blame but himself. His heir was gone. That bright young dwarf who he loved as a son, dead—

A heavy weight crashed into him from the side and Kili’s arms wrapped tightly around him. 

His vision was so blurred he could barely make out the golden-haired figure that knelt before him and pressed their brows together.

“I’m right here, Uncle,” Fili said.

Thorin wept.

It was a long while before he managed to get control of himself once again, the tears flowing to a stop and his breath calming. Never before had he allowed himself to cry so openly in his sister-sons’ presence, but if it bothered them, they showed no sign of it. 

Fili just tugged on one of Thorin’s braids before pulling away to sit back on his heels.

Kili remained pressed against his side, and his voice was a little muffled when he spoke, breath hot on Thorin’s neck where his face was buried. “What about me?”

Releasing a shuddering breath, Thorin pulled Kili a little closer. “I did not witness your death. Bilbo has told me you died fighting Bolg, but I know no more than that.” Regret pierced through him, making his chest ache. “I tried to reach you, but Azog found me first. We faced each other on the ice, and I killed the filth, but not before he dealt me a mortal wound. I died soon after.”

He couldn’t tell them about Bilbo—about how the hobbit held his hand as the life seeped out of him, begging him to hold on just a little longer. His One’s anguished cry as he drew his final breath would forever haunt him.

Thorin met Fili’s gaze, and there was a steely determination in his sister-son’s green eyes that he wasn’t sure he’d ever seen in them before. Those eyes flickered to his younger brother before returning to him, and Thorin didn’t need to ask. The meaning of that look was clear as crystal.

Fili would choose death without hesitation if it meant Kili had a chance of survival. 

Thorin understood. He would die for Dís in an instant—and would have gladly stepped between Frerin and the blade that killed him all those years ago, so his little brother could live.

A rock lodged itself in his throat and Thorin swallowed thickly, then nodded to Fili in agreement. No matter what, Kili would survive this. Even if they both had to die to make it happen.

It would not come to that. He would not allow it. Whether by his life or death, Dís would not lose her sons.

Unaware of the silent conversation being held between his brother and uncle, Kili spoke again, his voice a little clearer. “You won’t fall to the gold-sickness again. We’ll help you.”

Breaking from Fili’s stare, Thorin grasped Kili’s shoulders and gently pushed him away so they could look each other in the eye. “We will help each other,” he said firmly. “If I notice either of you showing signs of the sickness again, I will snap you out of it, and you will do the same for me. We avoid the treasury as much as possible. If you happen to find the Arkenstone, do not let me see it. Give it to Bilbo immediately. He has already sworn to keep it somewhere safe. Agreed?”

Both his sister-sons nodded, and Thorin felt himself relax slightly. 

Pulling away from Thorin entirely, Kili turned to his brother, some lingering guilt appearing in his expression. “I’m sorry, Fi.”

Shrugging, Fili got to his feet and offered a hand to help Kili up. “Already forgiven, boulder-brain. Come on, if we hurry, we might get some supper before Bilbo and Bombur eat it all.”

The two grabbed a few water-skeins each and bolted up the hillside.

Shaking his head, Thorin stood and groaned at the ache of his stiff joints. He stretched to crack his back, then looked up at the sky. He found the seven stars that made up the constellation of Durin’s Crown, and silently prayed they would all make it through this.

Notes:

I'd like to note that the khuzdul in this chapter is probably incorrect. I did the best I could piecing it together with what resources I had ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Ankuk e - look at me
Kasamhili, inkhi rumu du e - please, come back to me
Inkhi rumu - come back
Karkukhal - raven of peace

I've chosen "Karkukhal" as Kili's inner name. I have my reasons, but I'm not sure they'll ever actually be relevant to this fic, so just go with it

Chapter 26: To Slay A Dragon

Summary:

The Company finally reaches Erebor and faces Smaug.

Notes:

I'm not entirely happy with this chapter, but if I keep trying to mess with it, it will be months before I finish it. I hope you like it more than I do!
As always, let me know if you notice any mistakes and I'll fix them :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The door leading into the mountain was a dark, gaping maw of some horrible creature waiting to swallow the Company whole. Or, at least, that was how Bilbo felt staring into the shadowy passage that would lead them straight into the heart of Erebor, where the dragon slumbered on his bed of gold.

Bilbo had encountered so many things on this journey that, in his old age, he never imagined he might see again. From dead friends to old enemies, people and places filled with life where before they had been empty. So much of it left his heart feeling like an open wound, raw and bloody and near unbearable at times. But this—standing at the doorway to what had turned out to be the beginning of the end of his most terrible and treasured adventure…

It had him frozen to his core.

The dwarves stood around him, no one saying a word.

Whatever any of them were thinking, Bilbo could only guess. Some had never seen the glittering halls of Erebor. For others, the mountain was once their home. Now, it was a tomb to countless friends and loved ones—and a lair to the monster that killed them.

The warm hand that settled on the small of his back made him jump, and he tore his eyes away from the door to look at Thorin, who had come to stand at his side.

Bilbo let out a shaky breath. “Well, here we are.”

Thorin’s face was unreadable, and he dipped his head in a small nod. When he spoke, the words were meant for all of them. “If any of you wish to stay here, you will bear no judgement from me.”

A murmur of dissent rose up among the Company.

“Don’t be an idiot,” Dwalin growled.

Gloin sounded genuinely offended at the suggestion. “We’ve come this far. What makes you think we’d turn back now?”

Several of them voiced their agreement.

“We’re with you, laddie,” Balin said from Bilbo’s other side, voice thick with emotion, but certain and unwavering. “To whatever end.”

Fili came to stand beside his uncle and Thorin turned away from Bilbo to face his nephew.

With a grim smile, Fili offered his hand. “Amnâs.”

Thorin reached out and they grasped each other’s forearms. “Akrâg.”

“Rumush mudtu,” they said as one, pressing their brows together. 

When they separated, Bilbo could have sworn he saw the gleam of tears in Thorin’s eyes, but it was gone by the time he turned to face the rest of the Company.

“We are clear on the plan?”

“We’ve only gone over it about a hundred times,” Dwalin grumbled.

It was true. They’d spent the entire day discussing exactly how their go about defeating Smaug. With the black arrow at their disposal, picturing their victory was somewhat easier than it had been over the past weeks. The plan they settled on was a mad one—fairly similar to what they tried to do on the first journey, really—but then, none of their plans had ever been particularly sane to begin with.

Thorin snorted, and his eyes once again settled on Bilbo. “Ready?”

Taking a deep breath, Bilbo nodded once and tried to sound more confident than he really felt. “Let’s go slay a dragon.”

Entering the mountain, the Company remained utterly silent, save for their quiet breathing and the occasional scrape of boots against stone. Every step brought them closer to the belly of the mountain, and Bilbo was incredibly grateful that this time, he wasn’t going in alone.

Creeping down the shadowy passageway, it wasn’t long before they lost the light and it became so dark, he could barely see Thorin’s silhouette walking ahead of him.

And then Bilbo felt the unwelcome sensation of a presence brushing up against the back of his mind.

'Down into the dark again, thief?’

Not now, Bilbo thought irritably.

The Ring hadn’t spoken to him at all since that night in Lake-town when it showed him the vision of a field full of corpses, and Bilbo had been perfectly happy with its silence. The reprieve from its treacherous whispering was a welcome one. Except it hadn’t been silent at all during that time—it had simply turned its attention elsewhere, to a young dwarf already vulnerable to the call of gold.

And, oh, Bilbo was still furious with himself for not realizing it sooner. He should have known the Ring would attempt to find a new bearer. It had already tried to leave him once, during the fight in Mirkwood, and very nearly made it into Kili’s curious hands. He should have expected it to try again.

His lack of diligence cost them dearly the previous evening, with poor Kili bearing the brunt of it, and Bilbo had no intention of allowing it to happen again. Since it somehow managed to free its pouch from Bilbo’s necklace, the Ring itself was now strung on the cord, resting heavily against his chest between layers of clothing—he couldn’t stand to have it touching his bare skin.

'The young prince has such interesting desires. How could I resist?’

Bilbo didn’t want to hear a single thing about Kili’s desires from the Ring, though he could hazard to guess what it may be referring to. 

Shut up, he thought.

‘You should not dismiss me so readily.’

I’m busy.

Bilbo stumbled over a raised portion of the floor and reached out ahead of him, catching Thorin’s arm to steady himself.

‘Why kill the dragon? He could be useful t o us. Imagine having a fire-drake on our side. Your precious dwarves need never step foot out onto the battlefield.’

So, that was its game. Bilbo would have scoffed if not for the need for silence. The very suggestion that Smaug would ever ally himself with dwarves—or the dwarves with him—was easily the weakest lie the Ring had conjured so far. Pathetic.

‘The dragon will submit to the Lord of the Ring.’

There is only one Lord of the Ring, Bilbo retorted. And he’s busy squatting in a crumbling ruin like the vermin he is.

The Ring, apparently, didn’t like that very much.

It raised a piercing shriek in his mind, so shrill it hurt, and sent a wave of dizziness crashing over him. Bilbo staggered and came to a stop, bracing himself against the wall of the tunnel and squeezing his eyes shut in an attempt to ward off the rising nausea. When he opened them again, he was no longer in Erebor.

The ruins of Dol Guldur were overhung with dark clouds, so thick they blocked out the moonlight. Shadows cast by scattered fires writhed and roiled on the walls as legions of orcs marched from the bowels of the fortress. They marched to war. Clashing metal rattled the air. Wargs howled, thirsty for blood. An old man cried out in pain.

A grey figure lay crumpled on a platform high above the swarm, battered and beaten, struggling to stand as a huge orc advanced on him. The orc landed another blow. Another. Another. The wizard was half-dead, too weak to escape the cruel onslaught. Soon he would die, and his corpse would be picked clean by the crows.

Watching over it all was a mass of living darkness. It hovered near the highest tip of Dol Guldur. 

A hissing voice drowned out all other sound.

‘The Dark Lord grows stronger by the day. Soon, His power will stretch across all of Middle Earth. Your time is running short, halfling.’

Bilbo gasped sharply and doubled over, head spinning as a great, flaming Eye flashed in his vision. It took several blinks before the Eye dissipated and he found himself in the darkness of Erebor once more.

“Bilbo?” Thorin was right in front of him, voice barely more than a whisper, and his hands on Bilbo’s shoulders steadied him. “What is wrong?”

Heart still pounding, Bilbo struggled to focus. How much of that vision was real? Was Gandalf truly in danger, or was it just another one of the Ring’s tricks, meant to scare him? Was the army from Dol Guldur already marching on the mountain?

He took a few deep breaths, willing himself to calm down. 

It didn’t matter if any of it was true or not. There was nothing he could do about it. He had more immediate problems to worry about. Like slaying a dragon.

Gathering his wits, he managed to whisper back to Thorin in a semi-steady voice. “Nothing. I just tripped, is all.”

It wasn’t a very believable lie, but the dwarf didn’t ask him any more questions.

Instead, Thorin released his shoulders and took Bilbo’s hand instead, guiding him onward. “Come on. We are almost there.”
 

***

 

Despite his feeling that everything was much smaller than he remembered them being, the same could not be said for the treasure hoard of Erebor.

When they emerged from the tunnel, a few of the Company gasped, and they all stood there staring at the vast sea of gold and jewels before them, transfixed by the sight. The treasure cast shimmering patterns on the walls like light reflecting through water. There was no denying it was beautiful in its own right.

Bilbo might like it better if he didn’t know that somewhere, buried under all that wealth, lay a sleeping dragon.

Tearing his gaze away from the gold, Bilbo looked around until he found Thorin.

The dwarf had released his hand as soon as they left the tunnel and moved a small distance away from the rest of the Company. He stood stalk-still, expression unfocused, jaw clenched tightly.

Careful not to disturb any stray coins that littered the landing they stood on, Bilbo weaved around his dwarves until he reached Thorin and touched his elbow lightly. He jolted, like he’d forgotten he wasn’t alone, then glanced down at Bilbo. There was still a bit of a glazed look in his eyes that he blinked away.

“Okay?” Bilbo mouthed, not daring to make an actual sound.

Thorin nodded and turned to the rest of the Company to get their attention. It took several moments for them all to look at him, some seeming reluctant to stop staring at the treasure, but they all followed without complaint when he gestured for them to move on.

Leaving the treasury was a nerve-wracking experience. There were places where they were forced to walk across the gold, and while their attempts to remain silent were admirable, it simply wasn’t possible for thirteen dwarves not to make noise while slipping and sliding across a hillside of loose coin. Every step they took made Bilbo wince, expecting Smaug to come roaring out of the treasure at any moment.

Somehow, they managed to make it out of the room without incident and everyone relaxed a little as their feet returned to solid ground and they left the treasury behind them. They weren’t safe, of course. Far from it. But at least they were putting some distance between them and the dragon.

For now.

They crept through the halls, air thick and stale in their lungs, leaving bootprints in the thick layer of dust on the floors. They were mindful of the rubble strewn about from broken pillars and collapsed walkways—the clatter of a single kicked pebble had the potential of alerting the mountain’s current resident of their presence. That was, if their journey through the treasury hadn’t already done so.

Their course was fairly straight-forward, as all they needed to do to reach the front gate was follow the dragon’s path of destruction through the mountain.

Bilbo forced himself not to wonder at the lack of bodies lining the path. He didn’t want to think too hard about why that might be, lest it make him ill. 

Eventually, the gate came into view ahead of them and they finally turned into a smaller hallway, its walls lined with statues of armored dwarves on either side. At last, they had reached the armory.

Pace quickening, they entered a long chamber filled with armor and every kind of weapon imaginable. Swords, axes, spears, flails, daggers, bows—there were hundreds of them, a little dusty, but ready and waiting for an army of dwarves to appear and prepare for battle.

An army that had been absent from Erebor for far too long.

Thirteen dwarves and a hobbit were hardly an army, but they would be enough for what needed to be done. 

Hopefully.

The dwarves wasted no time in scattering throughout the room to gather the things they’d agreed would be the most useful and stash anything they didn’t want to carry with them while they ran about the mountain trying to slay a dragon.

Bilbo tucked his pack away in a corner, then hovered by the wall and did his best to stay out of everyone else’s way.

They worked quickly, and it wasn’t long before the Company gathered at the entrance of the armory once again. Some bore heavy-looking crossbows and large spears, while others had no weapons beyond what they usually carried—none of them wore extra armor, either, as it couldn’t do anything against dragon-fire and would only serve to slow them down. 

They all stood there silently for several long moments, just looking at each other.

Knowing what was coming next, Bilbo felt a lump in his throat. It was a wonder to him that Thorin was able to find it in himself to speak at all.

“Are there any questions before we do this?”

There was some murmuring and the shaking of heads.

Thorin looked around the circle at each of their faces, and when his eyes fixed on Bilbo, they lingered the longest. There was an air of certainty about their leader that hadn’t been there before. Whether it was true confidence or just a mask meant to encourage them, he didn’t know, but it settled Bilbo’s nerves somewhat.

Bilbo nodded at him and Thorin nodded back, then turned his attention to Kili.

There were still circles under the young prince’s eyes, but his face had more color and there was more life in him than there had been in the past weeks. He bore two bows over his shoulders, each heavier and larger than the one he’d carried since the start of the journey, which was being left behind in the armory to be retrieved later. Kili stood taller under his uncle’s appraising gaze, head held high.

Not breaking eye contact with his nephew, Thorin reached behind him and unstrapped the black arrow from his back, then held it before him with a steady hand.

Kili stared at it, then reached out and took the arrow.

“Remember, watch—”

“The chest under the left wing,” Kili interrupted, and he grinned slightly. “I know.”

There was pride in Thorin’s voice when he spoke again. “You are a son of Durin. Your aim and heart are true. If any of us here can make the shot, it is you.”

“Thank you, Uncle.”

Clapping a hand on Kili’s shoulder, Thorin turned to Fili. “You belong with your brother. Do not leave his side.”

“Not a chance.”

To Dwalin, Thorin said, “Take care of them.”

The warrior huffed and rolled his eyes. “We’ll be fine. Worry about yourself.”

With that, the three dwarves walked away.

As they disappeared, Bilbo felt a piece of his heart go with them, and he silently prayed they would be okay. Dwalin was right, though. Out of everyone, their group was likely to be the safest of them all—they, at least, weren’t on their way to wake a fire-breathing dragon from its nap.

 

***

 

Hunkered down in the shadows behind a stone column and listening to mountains of gold shift as the newly awoken dragon hunted for him, Bilbo found himself seriously questioning his life choices. He must be truly out of his mind, volunteering to venture into the lair of such a monster alone to wake it. Mad Baggins, indeed. 

Then again, he wasn’t completely alone. Not this time. His dwarves were here somewhere, whether down here on the gold or high above on stone walkways and bridges, waiting to distract the dragon and give him an escape should the need arise. 

The knowledge didn’t give him much comfort, though. Not when Smaug spoke, his rumbling voice echoing about the cavernous room, and far too close for his liking.

“Well, thief, where are you?” 

Acutely aware of the fact that he didn’t have the advantage of invisibility this time, Bilbo sat paralyzed, knowing he was supposed to respond but struggling to actually do so.

Smaug, likely aware of the terrifying effect he was having on his current prey, kept talking, the words almost a taunting croon. “Come now, don’t be shy. It’s not often I have guests. Step into the light.”

Swallowing several times to rid himself of the rock lodged in his throat, Bilbo forced himself to call out in answer. “Forgive me, O Smaug the Magnificent. It was not my intent to wake you.” His voice only shook a little bit.

“No, I would think not. You hoped to come into my mountain and steal my treasure without my notice.” 

Bilbo steeled himself and carefully peered around the side of his pillar.

Smaug was a hundred yards or so away, crouched low and still half buried in treasure, casting his gaze across the hoard in an almost casual manner. 

“I did not come to steal from you, Smaug the Stupendous. I merely wanted to see if the tales of your glory were true.” 

The dragon’s head turned lazily in his direction. “Flattery means nothing from the mouth of a liar.” His voice and eyes sharpened. “Do not think I don’t know why you are here.”

Bilbo pulled back behind the pillar in a moment of panic, then grit his teeth and forced himself to look again.

The dragon came gliding through the gold in his direction, like a great serpent swimming in the sea. There was no rush to his movement, but his tone grew harsher. “You and your filthy dwarf friends are here for the stone. You mean to murder me in my own halls, as if you might somehow accomplish what their warriors of old could not.”

“No, you’ve got that all wrong. There are no dwarves here. I’ve come alone.”

The dragon was getting too close. Bilbo slid down the hill of gold a little farther and ducked behind a different pillar, in an effort to keep some distance between them.

“Alone? Yes.” Smaug purred, and the rush of coins as he slithered through them quieted a bit. He’d come to a stop. “They sent a halfling in here as bait while they skulk in the shadows like rats.”

Something about the words unsettled him, and Bilbo snuck another peek to see that the dragon was sniffing at the hiding spot he’d just vacated moments before. Smaug lingered there for a moment, then moved on, slinking off in a different direction. Sighing, Bilbo leaned his head back against the stone pillar.

The small relief fizzled out moments later.

“There is something you carry. Something precious. It whispers such interesting things.”

Bilbo froze, every muscle in his body tensing as dread filled him.

“I-I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

He cursed himself for the waver in his voice and turned to look for the dragon again, but a flicker of movement caught his eye. Searching for a moment, he saw it again. 

It was Bofur, further down the hill, crouched behind a set of stairs and waving his hat in the air to get Bilbo’s attention. As soon as Bilbo saw him, the dwarf started beckoning for him frantically. 

He took a couple steps away from the pillar then stilled when the dragon spoke again, voice far nearer than he’d been before.

“Tell me, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, have your people ever known dragon-fire?”

Terror like he’d never felt before filled him and Bilbo clapped a hand over his mouth to stop himself from screaming. 

No. No, no, no—

The Ring cackled and his vision went out of focus for a moment.

Instead of gold, all Bilbo could see was Hobbiton. The rolling green hills were burning, the Party Tree stood like a gleaming torch in the night, and his friends and neighbors fled for their lives as a dragon flew overhead, blasting fire at them all.

When the image cleared, Bilbo found himself staring directly into a giant orange eye.

“There you are, Ringbearer.”

He scrambled backwards until his back hit the pillar and he could go no farther. Trapped. He was about to be dragon food. And then what? The Ring would be lost. Smaug couldn’t have the Ring, it was his. It was— 

In a panic, Bilbo drew a knife from his belt and threw it. To his horrified amazement, the blade sank hilt deep into the dragon’s glowing eye. 

Smaug threw his head back and roared so loud the mountain shook.

Wasting no time, Bilbo half ran and half skidded down the hill of gold. He would have slid straight past the stairs if Nori didn't lunge forward and catch the collar of his jacket. Gasping his thanks, he bolted straight past both dwarves and climbed the stairs as fast as his feet would carry him. He didn’t have to look back to know that Bofur and Nori were close behind.

Roaring and cursing, Smaug thrashed about so much that great waves of gold and jewels went flying through the air and he sent several huge pillars crashing to the ground. 

It gave them time to get away from the treasury floor, up to the bridges that crisscrossed through the air high above, and Bilbo was able to spot the others—Bombur and Bifur, and Thorin and Gloin. The dragon noticed the dwarves only moments after he did, though, and then the chase really began.

They were meant to help be a distraction, but he, Bofur, and Nori didn’t need to say anything to agree that they should avoid drawing the dragon’s attention. So they made their way to the meeting point, doing their best to remain unseen. For their part, the other two groups did fine without their help, winding Smaug into more and more of a tizzy as they shouted and threw spears at him. 

That was, they were doing fine until the dragon managed to corner Bombur and Bifur. He reared back, mouth opening wide so he could either eat them or burn them to a crisp.

Cursing, Bilbo stopped running and cupped his hands around his mouth, shouting as loud as he could manage. “Here, you gigantic slug!”

The dragon froze and whipped his head around. “Baggins!”

Dwarves forgotten, Smaug began barreling in their direction, focus set on Bilbo, and they ran again.

“What’d you go and tell him your name for?” Bofur panted beside him.

“I didn’t tell him anything,” Bilbo snapped.

Stupid Ring. Stupid dragon. Stupid—

Skidding through the doorway at the end of the bridge, he slammed face first into a hard body. Hands on his arms steadied him and Bilbo stumbled back a step, dazed. He looked up, straight into familiar blue eyes.

“Thorin,” he gasped, then sagged against the dwarf, wheezing for breath.

He allowed Bilbo to use him as support for a few seconds, but then another deafening roar echoed through the mountain and the unmistakable glow of dragon-fire exploded at the far end of the corridor, far too close for comfort.

“I think I’ve made him angry,” Bilbo said dumbly. 

Thorin’s laugh was rough, and the dwarf tried to pushed him away. “Quickly, follow Bofur. I will lead Smaug to the forges.”

Bilbo meant to listen. Really, he did. But there was a mixture of adrenaline and pure terror burning through his veins and he couldn’t get his stupid fingers to let go of Thorin’s tunic. Staring up at his friend, Bilbo had the thought that he wasn’t going to survive this. The damned Ring was going to get him killed, one way or another, and probably sooner rather than later if the raging dragon bearing down on them was anything to go by. 

Swearing under his breath, Bilbo did something he’d probably regret later.

He stepped forward and, rising up on his toes, he smashed his lips against Thorin’s in a clumsy kiss. 

Somewhere further down the hall, Nori yelled at him, sounding exasperated. “Is now really the best time?”

Tearing himself away from Thorin, he didn’t give the surprised dwarf the chance to say anything. He ran, catching up with Nori, and the two of them sprinted down the hall. Behind them, Smaug’s huge body crashed around the corner and slammed into a wall, making everything shake. Both of them stumbled and Bofur lunged out to grab them, dragging them through a doorway just in time to avoid the blast of fire that singed Bilbo’s heels. Despite the danger, there was a huge grin on the miner’s face.

Scowling at the dwarf as he passed, Bilbo yelled over his shoulder. “Not a word!”

“I didn’t say anything!” Bofur shouted back cheerfully.

They accidentally passed the turn to the forges, then doubled back when Balin’s voice called after them. The old dwarf met them in the middle of the room and Bofur clapped him on the shoulder.

“You owe me ten gold pieces.”

“Do I, really?” Balin blinked and turned his pale eyes on Bilbo, bushy brows raising up to his hairline. 

Deciding he didn’t want to know the details of whatever bet had just been settled, Bilbo strode past them and headed straight for the doorway where Ori had just popped his head out, looking nervous.

“How long do we have?”

“A few minutes, if we’re lucky.” Bilbo slipped into the room and surveyed the work-table strewn with jars and powders. Oin and Dori were there, twisting lids onto a few dozen palm sized ceramic containers, and Bilbo jumped in to help. 

When they heard the tell-tale sound of a rampaging dragon coming closer, Bilbo stuffed as many of the flash-flames into his pockets as he could manage then stepped out of the workroom. He was just in time to see Thorin and Gloin sprint into the forges through the giant metal grate that spanned the length of the far wall, both of them shouting increasingly creative insults over their shoulders as they ran. It may have been funny if Smaug wasn’t so close behind, climbing the walls of the shadowy pit that lay beyond the grate.

Behind Bilbo, Ori gasped.

“Get away from there, both of you,” Dori hissed.

And then Bilbo was yanked back into the workroom and behind the wall.

He scowled at the oldest Ri brother and Dori gave him a withering look strong enough to cow a troll into submission. Before either of them could say a word to each other, though, Ori piped up fearfully.

“Where are Bifur and Bombur?”

“Don’t worry about them, lad, they’re just running a little behind, is all,” Bofur said, coming over to push Ori’s slingshot into his hands with a wink. “You’ll want to hold onto this.”

Face reddening, Ori took the slingshot and opened his mouth to say something, but was interrupted by a thunderous roar. 

Bilbo peeked out the door and watched Thorin and Gloin dive for cover, but there was no explosion of heat and flames, and the forges didn’t spring to life with great billows of black smoke. Nothing happened—nothing except for the great crash as Smaug threw his body against the heavy metal bars that separated him from his prey. Again, and again, and again.

The two dwarves continued throwing their insults at the wyrm, trying to provoke him into releasing the blast of fire that would kick off the next part of their plan. But it had no effect. With every hit, the metal gave an unnerving groan and buckled a little more. Just a few more, and he would break through. Smaug seemed utterly deaf to their taunting, his focus on only one thing.

“Halfling!”

Valar save him, having the dragon’s attention locked solely on him had not been part of the plan.

Taking a deep breath, Bilbo left the workroom again before anyone could stop him, though several of the dwarves called for him to come back. He ignored them, digging a flash-flame from his pocket as he ran. Pulling back his arm, he aimed and threw the small bottle as hard as he could. He hit his mark, right on the dragon’s snout.

Smaug paused for a moment to look straight at Bilbo, and smoke billowed from his flared nostrils.

Bilbo dove behind the first forge just in time to avoid the blast of dragon-fire sent in his direction. For a moment, it seemed like nothing would happen, but then the flame caught and the forge lit. Perfect.

He ran from forge to forge, slick with sweat, provoking the dragon to light two more. 

But between the third and fourth forges, the grate finally gave way to the dragon’s battering and exploded inwards.

Bilbo fell, and scrambled back across the floor as the dragon slunk towards him like a cat stalking a mouse. Smaug had blood dripping down one side of his face from his eye, splattering on the floor with each step he took, but the injury hardly seemed to bother him, and only served to make him more terrifying.

“I tire of your games,” Smaug snarled. “Give me the—”

A flash of light exploded right below his good eye and he faltered for a moment, hissing.

Bilbo glanced to his right to see Ori standing several yards away in the rubble of the destroyed grate—the young dwarf was already fumbling to load another flash-flame into his slingshot, shaking but determined. He let the second one fly, hitting the dragon in the face again. And then the other dwarves were there, all throwing flash-flames at Smaug and shouting, trying to distract him.

But the dragon recovered from the shock of the blinding lights and started stalking towards Bilbo again, ignoring it as flash-flame after flash-flame struck him in the head and face. “You will burn.”

Bilbo finally managed to stand again and took several stumbling steps back, mind whirling.

Three lit forges weren’t nearly enough for this plan to work. They needed all seven of them burning. If only he could—

Distantly, Bilbo heard someone scream his name and tell him to move, but his feet were glued to the floor and he found himself staring wide-eyed and stupid down the depths of the dragon’s throat as the fire built within him—a fire that went out a moment later when a cascade of water spewed from the mouths of the giant dwarf statues against the wall. Spluttering and steaming like a boiled over teapot, Smaug slipped on the wet floor and fell in a tangle of wings. 

High above, Nori was pulling down on the water-lever with a sharp grin on his face. A lash of the dragon’s tail sent the stone platform crumbling down, though, and Nori fell with it.

Bilbo yelled and dodged out of the way of some flying debris. He only made it one step in Nori’s direction before a hand on his arm dragged him to a stop. 

“Oh, no you don’t!”

“But Nori—”

“I’ll get Nori,” Bofur said firmly, and shoved him in the opposite direction, away from the dragon. “He’ll be fine. Go!” 

Smaug was already half standing again, so Bilbo gave up on the argument and bolted. He was followed by yet another thundering roar.

The Ring chose that moment to speak, and its voice sounded terribly gleeful. ‘Better run faster, little thief.’

“Shut up,” Bilbo snarled, weaving around some of the rubble of the grate. 

The Ring laughed.

“Come on, Bilbo!”

Without a thought, he changed his course towards that voice, and shouted. “Thorin, the forges—”

“Forget about the forges!”

Bilbo reached Thorin and nearly stopped, but the dwarf grabbed his hand and started running, so Bilbo had to keep up the pace unless he wanted to be dragged across the floor. Not that he wanted to slow down—he could hear the dragon chasing them and didn’t dare look back to see how much of a head-start they had. They were headed toward the far end of the room, where the floor seemed to come to an abrupt stop. Beyond that, all Bilbo could see was open air. It seemed like a dead end.

“What about the gold?” He gasped, trying to ignore the painful stitch in his side.

Without the gigantic golden statue of King Thrór there to distract Smaug, it would be difficult to provide Kili with a clear shot. This entire plan hinged on their ability to get the dragon to stand still long enough for the young prince to take aim and loose the black arrow. If they couldn’t do that—

“Give me the Ring!”

Reaching the ledge at the room’s end, Thorin led them over the side without hesitation. Bilbo felt the nauseating sensation of being in a free fall for about two seconds before landing hard on a steep incline. A moment later, a searing blast of fire exploded over their heads. 

They skidded down the slope at breakneck speed and used the momentum to fling themselves into a sprint when they hit the bottom.

“What are we going to do?”

“Lead him to the Gallery of the Kings. The others should be there by now.” Thorin said, somehow sounding just as confident as he had right before they woke the dragon, as if things weren’t going terribly wrong. “How does he know about the Ring?”

Bilbo stumbled and Thorin pulled him back to his feet without missing a step.

That was hardly an easy question to answer while they had an angry dragon on their tail, intent on turning them to ash. He should have told Thorin about the Ring’s whispers back in Lake-town. He shouldn’t have kept it a secret. It was too late to regret that decision now, though. Any more conversation about the Ring would have to wait.

He could feel the dreadful thing bouncing against his chest with every step he took, far heavier than something that small had any right to be. 

“I’ll tell you later,” Bilbo said, panting.

From the corner of his eye, he saw Thorin open his mouth—probably to argue—but he didn’t get the chance to say anything else.

“Thorin! Bilbo!”

Up ahead, Bombur was standing in a doorway on their left, waving to get their attention. 

They sped towards him and followed him through the door into a tall, long chamber lined with marble columns, cut in half by a second intersecting chamber at the center that stretched off to the left and right. They didn’t make it very far before the wall above the doorway exploded inwards and Smaug crashed into the room.

All three of them ducked behind the towering columns to avoid the chunks of stone flying through the air and braced themselves for the heat of fire, but were met only with Smaug’s furious hissing.

Bilbo peered around the column and might have laughed at the sight that greeted him if he wasn’t scared out of his mind and struggling to breathe.

In a rare stroke of luck, one of the gigantic tapestries that had been hanging on the now destroyed wall seemed to have gotten tangled around Smaug’s wings and the dragon was struggling to free himself, bucking and trying to catch it with his fangs to no avail.

With the dragon preoccupied, they followed Bombur across the chamber until they reached the intersection and turned to the left into the room where the huge statue mold stood against the far wall.

Somehow, everyone had managed to get here from the forges and were spread out around the perimeter of the room, armed with spears and crossbows and flash-flames. Bilbo moved to join them, but Thorin caught his shoulder and held him back.

“Not you. Go in there and stay out of sight.” Thorin pointed towards a small alcove in the wall, where Bilbo could just make out the first few steps of a shadowy stairwell. 

“What? But—”

“He is looking for you. If you are out of sight, maybe it will confuse him enough for Kili to take the shot.”

Bilbo wanted to argue, but there was no time. The sound of ripping fabric filled the air—Smaug had just managed to free himself. 

“Fine,” Bilbo snapped, and dug the flash-flames from his pockets to shove them into Thorin’s empty hands. Then he turned and darted into the stairwell. 

His friends’ shouts and enraged roars of the dragon chased him up two flights of stairs and Bilbo stopped just shy of the top, peering across the floor of the balcony that overlooked the gallery. He was at a bad angle to see most of the action happening below with the dwarves, but his view of Smaug was perfect. And he didn’t like what he saw.

The dragon seemed a far cry from the suave and cunning creature that he’d started as. There was a crazed look in his eye as he batted away spears and arrows, with blood still oozing down his face and great strings of saliva dripping from his maw. The sight reminded Bilbo of that time one of Farmer Maggot’s dogs went rabid and turned on the very sheep it was meant to be guarding. By the time Maggot and his boys were able to trap it—out of its mind, soaked with blood, and foaming at the mouth—the dog had slaughtered its way through half the flock. They’d had no choice but to put it down. 

Against his better judgement, Bilbo crawled out to the balcony’s edge to get a better look at what was happening down on the gallery floor. 

The dwarves were doing their best with what they had, but it wasn’t enough. Smaug’s distraction with the flash-flames could only last so long, and it wouldn’t be worth anything at all if he didn’t stay still enough for Kili to get a good shot. Bilbo could see both of Thorin’s nephews now, on the wooden scaffolding behind the statue mold, a little lower than the balcony where Bilbo sat. Fili kneeled with his back to the dragon, the black arrow resting on his shoulder. Before him, his brother had the black arrow nocked to the bowstring and drawn back as far as possible, brows furrowed with concentration. But Smaug was too wild and moving too unpredictably—Kili couldn’t release the arrow until he knew for certain he’d hit his mark. He only had one chance at it.

If only their plan with the forges had worked. They needed the gold to distract Smaug—

Gold.

Right.

This was going to work, or he was going to be burned to a crisp in the next ten seconds—either way, it would hopefully give Kili the angle he needed. 

Cursing himself for what he was about to do, Bilbo scrabbled for the cord around his neck and tore it over his head, then got to his feet. 

“Here!” He shouted and thrust out his hand, the Ring and Thorin’s pendant dangling from his fist. “Look here! This is what you want, isn’t it?”

The roaring stopped and Smaug slowly turned on Bilbo, raising his head until he was level with the balcony. The dragon’s blazing eyes locked on him, looking far too similar to another Eye—one that plagued Bilbo’s nightmares—and in the heat of his gaze, the Ring began to glow. Spidery elvish crawled across its smooth surface, and Bilbo had to force himself not to recoil as the Ring started to whisper, hissing in a dark language. An old language.

Smaug went utterly still, transfixed.

And Kili let his arrow fly.

It whistled through the air, its path straight and true, and spiraled straight into the dragon’s heart. 

Smaug reared back with a scream and fell. He thrashed around on the floor, sending out great gusts of wind with every frantic flap of his leathery wings and spitting fire in every direction. Bilbo dropped down to his belly to avoid being knocked off the balcony, but he didn’t take his eyes off the dragon. It went on for nearly a full minute before the storm ended at the light in his eyes spluttered out.

Smaug’s final cry was matched by the raging scream of the Ring, and the dragon fell still.

He was dead.

In the stark silence that followed, dwarves cautiously emerged from behind the great stone columns where they’d taken cover. Bilbo barely had the mind to count them each as they came into sight, and only dimly felt the relief when he reached thirteen. Everyone was alive.

It was Fili who first broke the silence, letting out a crow of triumph and hauling his brother into a tight embrace. “You did it!” He shouted. “Kili, you killed the dragon!”

Roused from their shocked states, the rest of the dwarves raised their voices in a cheer that echoed through the chamber.

Wide-eyed, Kili just gaped down at Smaug’s corpse and said nothing.

Bilbo didn’t have the energy to celebrate with them. 

With the Ring still clenched tightly in his fist, he rolled over onto his back and cried.

Notes:

Amnâs - Loyalty
Akrâg - Honor
Rumush mudtu - A willing heart

Chapter 27: For the Love of a Burglar

Summary:

Thorin and Company recover from their fight with the dragon, and begin preparing for the oncoming battle.

Notes:

This took a bit longer than I meant it to because I couldn't get it written the way I wanted it. It's still not exactly right, but hopefully you all enjoy it anyway. As always, if you notice any mistakes, please let me know. This chapter is almost completely unedited, so I'm sure I've missed some things.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When his sisters-sons came down from the scaffolding, Thorin was the first to reach them and dragged them both into a tight embrace. Then he pulled back to study them closely. Fili was grinning from ear-to-ear and looked hardly worse for wear, while Kili’s smile was a little more subdued and he kept sending nervous glances at the dragon’s corpse like it might rise from the dead at any second and eat them all. Neither had a single scratch on them.

At least that part of the plan had gone right.

“I am so proud of both of you,” Thorin said.

“I didn’t do anything,” Fili threw an arm around his brother’s shoulders, not at all disappointed to be refusing to take any credit. “It was all Kili.”

Tearing his eyes away from Smaug, Kili protested. “You helped! I couldn’t have done it without you.”

Fili snorted and jostled Kili a little. “Don’t be so modest. You didn’t need me there.”

“He is right, Kili. It was an incredible shot,” Thorin said, interrupting before it could turn into an argument.

Several shouts of agreement rose up from the nearest members of the Company.

“You were amazing, Kili!” Ori yelled from a few yards away, standing with his brothers who were both currently being subjected to Oin’s attentions.

“Aye,” Bofur added cheerfully as he dabbed blood from his husband’s face. “Worthy of at least a song or seven.”

Nori ducked away from Bofur and grinned, despite looking like he’d taken a club to the head. “I hope you’re ready for everyone to call you Kili Dragon-slayer.” 

“And a karashu amdât.” Dwalin clapped Kili on the back.

Kili’s face reddened under all the praise, but his smile grew and he looked at Dwalin a little hopefully. “You really think so?”

There was no question of it. Dís would bestow the mark to Kili herself, tattooing him with one hand while simultaneously beating Thorin to death with the other for daring to bring her sons anywhere near a dragon. Thorin chuckled. He never thought the day would come when he was actually looking forward to facing his little sister’s wrath, but he hadn’t seen her in nearly two years—he was starting to miss her, volcanic temper and all.

Over the next couple of minutes, the entire Company gathered in the front corner of the gallery and Thorin was relieved to see them all alive and relatively unharmed. Well, the entire Company, minus one.

Their hobbit was nowhere in sight.

“Has anyone seen Bilbo?” Thorin asked, scanning the area again for any sign of a familiar curly head, but not finding it.

“He’s still up there,” Fili said, and gestured toward the balcony above them.

Worried, Thorin nodded his thanks to his sister-son and headed for the stairs.

The sight of his One laying flat on his back and utterly still on the ground sent a momentary burst of panic through Thorin and he dropped to his knees at Bilbo’s side. “Were you hurt?”

Tear-tracks cut through the dirt on Bilbo’s face and his clothes were covered in soot—probably from the floor of the forge—but otherwise there were no obvious signs of injury. Thorin couldn’t see any blood.

The hobbit shook his head, but his eyes stayed shut and he didn’t say anything.

“Bilbo.”

“I’m fine, Thorin,” Bilbo snapped, but then he stopped and shook his head again, and he sounded exhausted. “Just a headache. I’m sorry.”

Drawing in a deep breath, Thorin relaxed. “You do not need to apologize.”

Neither of them said anything for the next few minutes until Bilbo sighed and finally opened his eyes. They were red-rimmed and puffy, and he gazed straight up at the ceiling with a blank stare.

“This Ring is going to be the death of me,” he said miserably.

Thorin glanced at the gleam of gold in Bilbo’s hand. Such a small, unassuming thing, and yet. There was something dark about it. Something malicious. Thorin looked away and took Bilbo’s empty hand in his own. He considered his words carefully before he spoke.

“Smaug knew you had it.”

Not a question. The dragon had made it perfectly clear what he was after. He had known about the Ring—had known Bilbo’s name and the name of the Shire. There was no way the hobbit told Smaug any of that information. He was too smart for that.

Bilbo’s face screwed up into a grimace. “It was calling to him. It knows I intend to destroy it, and is trying to get away from me.”

“What do you mean it was calling to him?”

“The Ring speaks. ” He sounded like he might cry again. “I daresay Kili hears it, too.”

Kili. 

His sister-son had been behaving so strangely, all leading up to that fight the previous night. Thorin assumed it was just the gold-sickness. It hadn’t occurred to him that the Ring itself might have something to do with it. Of course, he should have considered it sooner. Bilbo told him that the Ring had a tendency of getting into people’s heads. He just hadn’t thought that meant it could literally speak.

“I have not heard it.”

Finally, Bilbo looked at him. The corner of his mouth curled up into a small smile, but there was nothing happy in it. “And I hope you never do.” His smile vanished, and he looked troubled. Almost afraid. “I expect it won’t be long before it tries to find another bearer again, though. It’s rather cross with me for ruining its plans tonight.”

Thorin wasn’t sure what words of comfort he could offer that wouldn’t come across as simple wishful thinking. So he squeezed Bilbo’s hand and changed the subject. There was so much that needed to be talked about, but it could wait. “It is late, and we all need rest. We will return to the armory for our things, then find somewhere to make camp.”

Bilbo sighed, but nodded. He allowed Thorin to pull him to his feet, then looked down at the Ring in his hand. He stared at it for a moment, then reluctantly pulled the cord back over his head to hang around his neck and tucked the Ring out of sight, under his shirt. 

“Let’s go, then.”

 

***

 

Thorin was careful not to step on any sleeping dwarves as he weaved his way to the door, pausing only for a moment to add a splintered chair leg to the shrinking fire in the grate. At the door, he glanced back at the Company one last time. No one complained about the tight quarters, and collectively agreed that the small guardhouse at the front gate was the best place to make camp for the night. Save for Dori, Kili, and Bilbo—who were pushed into the three available beds in the back corner of the room—the entire Company slept nearly on top of each other, crowded together thanks to the limited floor space. Thorin should be with them, but as exhausted as he knew he should be, he felt wide awake.

There was simply too much on his mind for him to rest—too many things that needed to be done, too much danger left to face. They may have killed the dragon, but this quest was far from over. And if he was going to be awake, he may as well be doing something useful.

So he left the guardhouse and turned to head deeper into the mountain, mentally picturing the route he would need to take to reach his destination.

He didn’t make it very far before he heard the scuff of a boot behind him and knew he was being followed. Apparently, not everyone had been asleep like he’d thought.

“You should be resting,” he said, not bothering to look over his shoulder.

The footsteps behind him quickened.

“So should you,” Fili said brightly, catching up to walk by his side. “Where are we going?”

Thorin had intended to use this walk as a chance to think without distraction. But then, this would probably be good for Fili. He’d need to see how this was done sooner or later, in any case.

Glancing at his sister-son, Thorin smiled. “What do you remember of your lessons about the ravens of Erebor?”

As dwarflings, both his sister-sons had taken particular delight in the stories about the birds who could speak and carried messages for the dwarves in exchange for shiny things to add to their nests.

Fili lit up at the mention of the ravens, just as Thorin knew he would, but then he stopped walking. “Kili will want to meet them, too.”

Thorin considered it for a moment, then shook his head. “Let him sleep. There will be plenty of time for him to see the ravens later.”

Besides, Fili was more than capable of acting with the proper dignity of a crown prince on his own, but add Kili to the mix and there was sure to be some mischief involved. 

To his silent relief, Fili shrugged and caught up again without any protest. 

“Do we have to go out the secret door and walk all the way around the mountain to get to Ravenhill? Because that will take forever.”

“No, there is another route we can take. If we are lucky, the way will not have been damaged by the dragon. First, we will stop at the treasury to get a gift for the ravens.” In his gold-sick state on the first journey, Thorin was rude in his demands and ungenerous in his gift to Roäc. The old raven hadn’t been pleased, though he’d still agreed to carry a message to Dain for Erebor’s sake. This time, Thorin was determined to handle the interaction the right way—their friendship with the ravens would be crucial in the years to come, and to muddy that friendship would be folly.

He didn’t enjoy having to reenter the treasury, though. Standing at the edge of the hoard of gold, Thorin could feel the sickness like a shadow in the very back corner of his mind. The darkness would spread if he wasn’t careful. 

Fili, at least, seemed entirely unaffected.

“What kind of gift is fit for a raven, anyway?” The prince asked, picking up a jewel-encrusted golden chalice from the ground and dumping a handful of coins out of it. 

Pulling his thoughts away from the sickness, Thorin cleared his throat. “Something small enough for them to carry in their beaks or talons. They care more for how well the gift catches the light than they do the actual value of it, but we go to meet the ravens’ chief and it would not do to give him something cheap.”

“I think we’d be hard-pressed to find something in this treasury that could be considered cheap,” Fili said. He tossed the chalice aside and bent down again to pick up a bracelet of rubies. “Like this?”

As a young prince growing up in these halls and seeing this treasure hoard every day of his life, having never known hunger or poverty, that same bracelet would have been cheap in Thorin’s eyes. In fact, almost every object in this room would have seemed to him near worthless on its own. How different their childhoods had been, for Fili to consider a simple ruby bracelet a rich gift.

Thorin had always considered it a great injustice that his heirs were forced to grow as princes only in blood, deprived of their true birthright and forced to live in worse conditions than the poorest dwarf in Erebor before the dragon came. But…

Maybe it was a good thing Fili had not been raised with a golden spoon in his mouth. 

He would never take for granted the food on his plate or the great wealth that lay beneath his feet. 

“You are going to be a great king.”

Stopping his inspection of the bracelet, Fili looked at Thorin with a raised brow and said pointedly, “I hope someday I will be. A long, long time from now. When I’m gray and old, like you.”

Thorin scowled and turned away, grumbling. “I am not old.”

Behind him, Fili snickered.

Thorin shook his head, but couldn’t help the smile that fought its way to his lips.

It was a relief when they left the treasury and its golden light behind them, and made their way to higher halls where the stale air didn’t smell so much like dragon. 

No matter what anyone might say about Thorin’s sense of direction—which was perfectly fine, thank you—he did not lead them astray on their way to Ravenhill. No amount of time spent away from these halls would be enough for him to forget how to navigate them. They only had to turn back once, due to a collapsed passage, but he was able to find an alternate route soon enough.

They were on the level directly below the royal living quarters, and as they passed a stairway that would take them there, Thorin felt a longing to abandon his current purpose and go explore those rooms where the first two decades of his life were spent. But he ignored that desire and walked a little faster. There would be plenty of time to explore later, when they weren’t under threat of an approaching army of orcs lead by his family’s greatest foe.

“It is just at the end of this passage,” he said.

“What was all that fuss about the secret door for if you knew all along there was a way in through Ravenhill?” Fili asked, a skeptical edge in his voice.

“Because it is not a way in,” Thorin said, sending his sister-son an amused look. “This door can only be opened from the inside, and is designed to reseal itself as soon as there is nothing holding it open. There are a few like it, scattered around Erebor, meant to be used as emergency exits if ever there was a need to flee the mountain.”

On the last journey, the Company had gone to the lower halls in the hopes that they could use one of those doors to escape the angry dragon chasing them, just to find the passage blocked by a cave-in and a room full of their dead kin.

Luckily for them, this door was still intact.

Thorin led Fili into a small room, barely larger than a broom-closet. On the shadowy wall opposite of the entrance, there was an elaborate raven carved at eye-level into the stone, with its wings spread wide and its beak open in a silent cry. Thorin put his hand to the center of the raven’s chest and pushed. 

The entire wall shifted and groaned open to reveal a dark tunnel that sloped upwards.

Fili peered over Thorin’s shoulder. “I suppose you have a plan to not get us locked out of the mountain by a self-sealing door.”

Stepping aside, Thorin let his sister-son walk past him into the tunnel, then shrugged out of his jacket. He bunched it up and set it on the floor, and carefully let the door fall shut. With the jacket stuck between it and the wall, the door was unable to latch. He glanced at Fili.

“Propping open these doors endangers the mountain’s security and is considered a major crime.”

“I won’t tell Dwalin if you don’t,” Fili said, grinning.

With a snort, Thorin started up the tunnel. “Please. The first time we used this door to sneak out after curfew, it was Dwalin’s idea.”

Fili laughed and followed him.

The brisk, pre-dawn air and skiff of snow under their boots as they stepped out of the tunnel left no question that winter was upon them. Over the next few weeks, temperatures would plummet and the weather would take a turn for the worse. It would be a fight to ensure that everyone in the mountain stayed warm and well-fed. If they were not careful, sickness would spread. The cold would be their greatest enemy.

Still, as he climbed the winding stair up towards the tower with Fili at his side, Thorin was glad for the chill. After the scorching heat of dragon-fire, the sharp bite of the cold was a welcome feeling. 

He saw no sign of the ravens as they approached the tower—which was a mini fortress in and of itself, as crumbled and rundown as parts of it were—and he hoped they would not have to actually enter it to find them. It was something he needn’t worry about, though.

As soon as they reached the top of the stairs, a dark shape appeared from a shadowy space in the wall of the tower and glided down to land on a broken half-wall in front of them.

The raven was aged and decrepit looking, with dull feathers and a bald spot on his head and one milky eye that had to be blind. When he opened his beak to speak, the voice that came out was raspy and had a bit of a wheeze to it.

“So, the dwarves of Erebor return to the mountain at last and the dragon is dead. Well met, Thorin son of Thráin and Fili son of Dís.”

From the edge of his vision, Thorin watched his sister-son brighten at the sight of the raven, then immediately make an effort to bury his excitement under a cool exterior. The attempt wasn’t entirely successful, and Thorin had to force himself not to chuckle.

He dipped his head in a small bow of greeting. “Well met, Roäc son of Carc. I am glad to find that the tower is still kept by the ravens after all this time.”

“Most fled into the wilds when Smaug came, but we few remained. Ever has my line kept the tower, since the first stone was laid, and ever shall we stay until the death of the winds.”

“I commend you for your diligence, and hope we might reforge the friendship that our forebears once shared.” 

The old raven stood a little taller, the scraggly feathers on his chest puffing up proudly. “There is no need. Our regard for the stone people has not weakened over time or distance. What can we do for you, Mountain King?”

This was going far better than it had the first time. He was glad that Roäc was acting much more agreeable, now that Thorin himself wasn’t interrupting the raven’s drawn out formalities and barking out demands. 

He retrieved the gifts he’d found in the treasury and held them out. “I have two messages that need to be delivered. One to Lord Dáin of the Iron Hills, and the other to Bard of Lake-town. Will you carry them for me?”

Roäc turned his head so that his good eye faced the sparkling emerald ring and string of opals in Thorin’s hand, studying them critically for a few long moments. Then he nodded and let out a loud kraa sound that echoed off the walls of the tower.

Immediately after, another raven appeared, soaring down to perch beside Roäc. This one was smaller and younger than the chief, with sleek feathers and bright eyes.

“Arec son of Roäc, at your service,” he croaked.

It didn’t take long to give the ravens his messages, and one-by-one they left their perch to pluck the treasures from his hand, and departed. Thorin watched their dark forms take to the sky just as the sun peeked over the edge of the horizon.

Fili had stayed silent for the entire interaction, but once the ravens disappeared from sight, he finally spoke up. “Kili is going to be so jealous.”

“Once the battle is over, we will introduce him to the ravens, then send one to your mother so she knows you are safe.” Thorin clapped Fili on the shoulder, then turned to go back to the tunnel. “Come. There is much that needs to be done.”

 

***

 

They spent the day working in shifts—while half the Company cleared rubble from the front gate to make a door out of the mountain, the other half trooped to the armory to prepare themselves for battle. There was no telling how long they had before the Defiler and his armies arrived, and they needed to be ready when it happened. Around noon, they gathered to have lunch together, then the two groups traded places and went back to work.

Thorin hadn’t gotten a chance to speak to Bilbo yet today—in fact, he was fairly certain the hobbit was avoiding him—but it was likely for the best, as he had no idea what he would say, given the chance. It took him all day to finally come to a decision, and his mind was made up, though he still was unsure if it was the best idea. At this point, he didn’t think he had much of a choice.

He really had meant to wait, no matter Dwalin’s opinion on the matter. He would much rather do this later, when the danger was past and they didn’t have the threat of an approaching orc army hanging over their heads, and he was sure he would survive to see the other side of this battle.

Of course, Bilbo Baggins never did like to let Thorin do things his way.

The infuriating hobbit just had to go and kiss him and make him question his resolve on the matter.

Thorin paused outside the guardhouse, hesitating.

It was ridiculous, really. He had faced many dangers in his life—orcs and trolls and giant spiders and a dragon. He had crossed Middle Earth several times over. He had literally died, for Mahal’s sake. This, of all things, should not scare him.

Steeling himself, Thorin pushed the door open and walked inside.

The majority of the Company was there, sitting around the small fireplace and laughing together. Only a few were missing, including his sister-sons, who he hoped were staying out of trouble. He’d worry about their possible mischief making later, though.

Thorin’s real priority had his back to him, sitting tightly wedged between Bofur and Bombur.

Moving closer, Thorin placed a hand on the hobbit’s shoulder and spoke quietly. “Bilbo.”

Bilbo jolted and turned to look back at him. As soon as his eyes landed on Thorin, the mirth in his expression faded, replaced with something tense and unreadable. He gave Thorin a strained smile. “Oh, there you are. Have you eaten yet?”

Thorin shook his head. “I was wondering if I might speak with you alone.”

The peal of whispers and laughter around the room was in no way subtle. Normally, he would ignore their antics, but the Company’s teasing only made Bilbo stiffen more, so Thorin glared at them all in a silent demand that they shut up. It worked, and the other dwarves looked away quickly, returning to their own conversations. The only one who didn’t was Dwalin, who was staring at Thorin with an infuriating smirk on his scarred face.

Ignoring the urge to say something rude to his shield-brother, Thorin focused his attention back on Bilbo and offered him a hand.

The hobbit sighed and reluctantly allowed Thorin to help him to his feet. As soon as he was standing, though, Bilbo let go of his hand and hurriedly shoved his own hands into his pockets. “Lead the way.”

Thorin hesitated for a moment, unsure what to make of Bilbo’s behavior. He wondered if maybe he should wait until the hobbit was in a better mood, but immediately dismissed the thought. For all they knew, the battle might be tomorrow. He needed to do this now.

So he left the guardhouse, with Bilbo following behind him.

They didn’t go far, and it took them less than a minute to reach the small meeting room that Thorin had chosen for this purpose, already warmed by a fire in the grate and cleared of most of the dust. It was completely empty, save for the stone table that occupied the middle of the room, and the bundle of cloth sitting atop it.

Neither of them had said a word on their way there, but as soon as Thorin closed the door, Bilbo whirled to face him.

There was a somewhat crazed look in the hobbit’s face, and the words that tumbled out of his mouth were clumsy and urgent. “Look, before you say anything, I just want you to know that I really am very sorry. I don’t know—”

“Bilbo.”

“—what got into me. You have every right to be angry—”

“Bilbo.”

“—and I don’t blame you one bit. But I hope that you’ll forgive me for—”

“Bilbo, I am not angry!” 

Bilbo cringed and his mouth clicked shut. 

Shaking his head, Thorin lowered his voice. “You do not need to apologize. There is nothing to forgive.”

“There isn’t?” Bilbo asked weakly.

Thorin drew in a slow breath to steady himself. As soon as he said this, there would be no going back. For better or for worse, everything between them would change. Then again, that change was inevitable—and had probably already happened, anyway. And it would be nice to finally say it out loud, after such a long time of hiding it away. 

“I have wanted to kiss you for a very long time.”

The words were met with silence, and for several long moments, they just stared at each other, both standing still as a statue. Then Bilbo’s expression crumpled briefly, before hardening with anger.

“That isn’t funny,” he said sharply.

“It was not supposed to be,” Thorin responded, taken aback.

But that only seemed to upset the hobbit more, and he stepped forward, poking Thorin hard in the chest. “I have had more than enough dwarves making fun of me about this, Thorin Oakenshield, don’t you dare start, too.”

“What— I am not making fun of you!” 

“Then I don’t want your pity, either!”

“Pity?”

Bilbo straightened, squaring his shoulders and raising his chin, but there was a slight wobble in his voice when he spoke. “I have no delusions that you might ever see me as anything other than a friend, and I don’t need you coddling me to avoid hurting my feelings. I accepted my lot in life a long time ago and—”

Oh. For Mahal’s sake, he could not be serious. Of all the outrageous things he’d ever witnessed this hobbit say and do— 

“How is it that you are the most intelligent creature I have ever met, yet at the same time the most dim-witted?” Thorin burst out, exasperated. 

“Dim-witted?” The hobbit stumbled back half a step, looking shocked. “I beg your par—”

Thorin didn’t let him finish.

He placed his hands on either side of Bilbo’s flushed face then leaned down and pressed their lips together, effectively silencing the hobbit’s affronted spluttering.

It only lasted for a few short moments, then Thorin pulled away again, just far enough that he could look into those wide, hazel eyes that so often haunted his dreams.

“I love you, you ridiculous hobbit.” 

As soon as the words left his mouth, a heavy weight seemed to be lifted from his chest, and he let out a long, slow breath. It was a relief to finally have said it, even if Bilbo’s only response so far was to gape up at him like he’d just grown an extra head.

Brushing his thumbs across the hobbit’s soft cheeks once, Thorin let his hands drop.

The movement seemed to break Bilbo from his frozen state because he lunged for Thorin, gripping the front of his tunic and dragging him back down into an almost desperate kiss.

Every thought in Thorin’s mind disappeared, save for one.

Finally.

Thorin sank into the kiss with a low groan, pulling Bilbo closer. He reveled in the feeling of the hobbit’s warm lips moving against his, of their shared breaths, of their bodies pressed so closely together he couldn’t tell if the hammering heartbeat at his chest belonged to him or to Bilbo.

He forgot everything else—his reasons for wanting to wait to have this conversation, the upcoming battle, the dead dragon in his halls, the looming gold-sickness. All of it was lost to him in the face of holding his One in his arms.

It seemed to last forever, yet at the same time ended far too soon.

When Thorin felt the wetness on his face and realized Bilbo was shaking, he reluctantly pulled away. Tears streamed down the hobbit’s cheeks, and there was something like devastation in his red-rimmed eyes.

It reminded Thorin so much of that day on the ice, it stole his breath away and made his chest ache. Swallowing thickly, he brought his hands back to Bilbo’s face to wipe away the tears, as he’d been unable to do all those months ago in the moments before his death. But the motion was only followed by more tears, and Bilbo’s bottom lip wobbled.

“Please do not cry, ghivashel,” he said softly. He’d never used the endearment before for anyone, but it felt right leaving his tongue. 

“Say that again,” Bilbo demanded, his voice raspy and unstable.

Thorin didn’t have to ask to know he wasn’t talking about the khuzdul.

“I love you, Bilbo Baggins.”

Once again, uttering the words made him feel lighter, and Thorin had the urge to repeat it over and over and over to make up for every time he should have said it in the past but didn’t. But under Bilbo’s fierce glare, he bit his tongue and said nothing.

Notes:

Karashu amdât - mark of valor
(My headcanon is that dwarves earn tattoos by accomplishing great deeds)

Ghivashel - treasure of all treasures

Chapter 28: The Gathering Storm

Notes:

This is by far the longest chapter so far, at just under 11,000 words. It was a bitch to write, but I'm mostly happy with it :)

EDIT:
I will be spending November writing a book for NaNoWriMo, so I'm taking a short break from this fic. I plan to post the last two chapters in December--ideally this fic will be done by Christmas :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo wasn’t even sure why he was angry.

He had spent the past eight decades pining for this dwarf, mourning him, cursing the fates for taking him away so soon. Upon returning home and finding himself once again utterly alone in the hollow halls of Bag End, there were several months where he’d been dangerously close to drowning in his grief. Even after he managed to drag himself back onto the shores of sanity, several years passed him by where he aimlessly wandered the smial and the hills beyond Hobbiton, apparently searching for something that would never appear. It wasn’t until Frodo came along that he finally came back to himself again, finding purpose in having someone else to look after. As he grew older, his bereavement settled around him like a well-worn cloak, and he contented himself with it.

But he’d never stopped wishing for something that could never be.

Wishing for this.

For a different life where Thorin Oakenshield was alive and well, his friend once more, confessing to a love that in reality never even had a chance to sprout. If it ever existed at all.

Bilbo should not be angry. But he was.

“Since when?” he asked, unable to keep the harsh edge from his tone.

His lips were still tingling from the kiss they’d shared, and Thorin’s fingers were still warm on his face. Bilbo jerked away, stumbling back a couple of steps and scrubbing furiously at his own tears.

Thorin stayed where he was, and it was several moments before he answered. “Since Thranduil’s dungeon.”

Snorting, Bilbo shook his head. The dungeons. Nothing so life-altering as love had happened in that place. No, they’d been locked away in separate cells for a week. “We barely even saw each other in the dungeons.”

“On the first journey, Bilbo,” Thorin said gently.

The first…?

Bilbo cast his muddled mind back, searching for what the dwarf was talking about. And he remembered—weeks spent in the deepest depths of the dungeons, soft voices whispering stories in the dark, separated by the iron bars of a cell door and surrounded by damp stone.

“But that was so long ago.”

“Far longer for you than for me.” Thorin's expression twisted into something unhappy. “I am sorry I did not tell you sooner.”

“Well, why didn’t you?”

The words were out before Bilbo had time to even consider them, his anger shifting to indignance.

Thorin grimaced at the question, and the look in his eyes was almost guilty. He raised a hand as if to drag it through his hair, then changed his mind and allowed it to fall limp again to his side. “I waited so long on the first journey for the same reason I have waited on this one. I wanted to tell you after the quest was done, when we were both safe and out of danger. I—”

Bilbo was too impatient to let the dwarf finish, barely able to contain himself. “You were planning to go into battle again without saying a word about this? And you’re calling me dim-witted?” he cried.

How dare he? This confusticating, stupid, rock-brained—

“I felt it would not be fair for me to offer myself to you when I may not outlive the week.”

“Fair,” Bilbo repeated dumbly, staring at Thorin. Fair? Anger flared in him again, hotter than before, and he had the terrible urge to throw something, preferably in the direction of this dwarf’s stupidly beautiful face. He settled instead for stamping his foot like a toddler having a tantrum. “Nothing has ever been fair, Thorin! It wasn’t fair that you didn’t tell me any of this before you went and got yourself stabbed, and it still wouldn’t have been fair if you did tell me! It wasn’t fair that I had to go to your funeral! It wasn’t fair when everyone let you pass into legend and I was the only one left who seemed to remember the actual dwarf behind the stories! It wasn’t…it wasn’t…” He might have cried again if it didn’t suddenly occur to him what Thorin had actually said. “What do you mean ‘offer yourself to me?’”

If Thorin was bothered by the shouting, he didn’t show it. When he responded, his voice was calm. “Do you know what a One is?”

The fire in him fizzled out and died.

Bilbo knew what he spoke of, certainly. It had been explained to him by Ori in his previous life, on the dwarf’s final visit to him in Hobbiton, a few years before his ill-fated quest to reclaim Moria. He’d referred to Dwalin as his One, and seemed surprised when Bilbo didn’t know what that meant.

That conversation bothered him for a long time afterwards, though he did his best not to think on it. For some reason that he refused to acknowledge, it hurt too much. The fact that Thorin brought it up now was unsettling—he couldn’t tell if it was a hopeful sort of feeling growing in his chest, or dread.

“I’m familiar with the concept.”

He held his breath, waiting for whatever Thorin would say next, but he didn’t say anything. Instead, Thorin just stepped past him, approaching the stone table and the bundle that sat atop it. He picked it up then turned back to Bilbo, holding it out to him.

After a moment, his curiosity won out over his urge to demand Thorin explain himself this instant, and Bilbo took the bundle—it was Thorin’s jacket. Unwrapping it, he caught his breath at the glimmer of mithril in the firelight.

“It’s been a while since I’ve seen this,” he said softly. And just like that, all the lingering irritation and anger faded away, replaced with a gratitude that sat heavily in his chest. He glanced back up at Thorin wistfully. “I always wished I could have thanked you for this. It saved my Frodo’s life several times when…when he…”

Better to not bring up the Ring now. It had been seething silently all day, and he didn’t want it interrupting this moment—whatever this was.

A slight smile pulled at Thorin’s lips and he dipped his head. “I am glad to hear it. But at the same time, I must apologize.”

“What for?”

“When I first gave this to you, I was…” Thorin trailed off for a moment, a brief shadow crossing over his face. “I did not do it correctly. In my sickness, I did not explain myself or what the gift meant.”

“You said it was a token of our friendship.”

“I lied.”

Bilbo stood utterly still, unsure if his heart was even beating. He clutched the mithril shirt with white knuckles, staring into those deep blue eyes that he’d never quite been able to forget, no matter how many years passed him by. No matter how many other memories fled his aging mind.

Thorin’s voice was quiet when he spoke next, tinged with regret. “When a dwarf finds their One, it is customary to present them with a meaningful gift as a way to ask for their partnership and love. But I did not give you the chance to reject me. I forced it on you in a misguided attempt to bind you to me, to prevent you from returning home to the Shire. For that, I am deeply sorry. I had no right.”

“What are you saying?” Bilbo asked, hardly breathing.

“You are my One, Bilbo.”

Oh.

Well, then. That was…

Looking back down at the mithril, Bilbo ran his fingers along the cool metal, just as he’d done so many times in those months after the battle. No wonder Ori had been so confused when he asked what a One was. The entire Company had witnessed Thorin give this to him. All those years, why didn't anyone bother to tell him? Had they all simply assumed he knew the significance of what Thorin had given him, as Ori had? Surely someone must have realized he would have no idea. Balin, at least, should have thought of it… Maybe they had thought it would be kinder to let that secret lie in its grave, rather than add to his already monumental grief.

Thorin broke the silence that had fallen between them, sounding urgent.

“It is your choice whether or not you wish to accept what I am offering, but even if you do not—”

“Thorin.”

“—I ask that you accept the gift, regardless. Both as a token of how grateful I am for everything you have done for me, and to keep you safe when—”

“Thorin, shut up.”

The dwarf’s mouth snapped shut and Bilbo shook his head, letting out a long breath. Whatever the reasons the Company may have had to not tell him about this, none of it mattered. Thorin was telling him now. He had a second chance, and he would be a fool not to take it.

Shaking his head again and banishing all his anxieties to be dealt with at a later time, Bilbo grinned up at Thorin. “Why do you think I kissed you, you ridiculous dwarf? Here, hold this for a moment.” He shoved the mithril into the dwarf’s hands and Thorin fumbled with it clumsily, nearly dropping it.

Bilbo stripped off his jacket and waistcoat, leaving them on the table, then motioned to the mithril. “Help me with that, will you?”

Looking a little dazed, Thorin did as he asked, holding the shirt up and helping him to slip it over his head. Bilbo adjusted it until it was sitting correctly, then he looked up at Thorin expectantly.

“Why did you kiss me?”

Oh, honestly.

Bilbo snorted and started redressing. “I kissed you, dear, because I happen to be very much in love with you. Also, I thought we were about to die and I figured there wasn’t much to lose.”

“You thought we were going to die?”

“We were being chased by an angry, fire-breathing dragon. Intentionally.”

Thorin grimaced. “That is fair.”

Straightening his waistcoat, Bilbo slipped his hands into his pockets and paused, feeling something round and cold against his fingers. A familiar flash of fear went through him, and he had to remind himself that the Ring was safe on a cord around his neck. Once he’d calmed, he pulled the object out of his pocket curiously.

“Your acorn,” Thorin said, peering down into Bilbo’s open palm.

“I picked it up in Beorn’s garden—”

“To plant in your own garden at Bag End. I remember.” There was something strangely reverent in the way Thorin said it.

Bilbo glanced up at him and caught his breath at the soft, almost wistful look on the dwarf’s face. And he remembered it, too—that day they’d stood almost exactly like this, Bilbo holding an acorn out between them, and some of the shadows on Thorin’s face lifting. It felt like a brief moment of light in the darkness, and Bilbo had almost thought Thorin might break through the gold-sickness and return to his senses. It was a foolish hope, and one that obviously hadn’t come true.

As if reading his mind, Thorin sighed. “If only I had listened to you that day. Perhaps much would have been different.”

“Well, it doesn’t matter. We’re here now.” Bilbo took Thorin’s hand and placed the acorn in his palm, then curled his fingers around it.

Thorin gave him a confused look. “You are giving this to me?”

“I know it’s nothing as grand as a mithril shirt, but it’s all I have at the moment, so unless you’d prefer a silver spoon…”

“Why?”

“You said it’s custom to give your One a gift.”

The dwarf jolted slightly, and his eyes widened. “I am your One?”

Bilbo would have scoffed at the question if not for the look on Thorin’s face—one caught somewhere between cautious hope and disbelief. So he checked his tone, then asked, “Do you remember that day in Beorn’s garden, when you asked me if I ever married after you were gone?”

“You said no on wanted to marry you after your adventure. You said they called you Mad.” Something darkened in his expression on that last word, but Bilbo ignored it.

“Yes, well, even if they didn’t think that of me, I never would have married any of them, because none of them were you. I didn’t want anyone else. You were it for me.”

Technically, hobbits didn’t have the same concept of a One as the dwarves did. Many were perfectly capable of falling in love more than once. Some fell in and out of love the same way a year falls through the seasons. It was normal, even encouraged, for someone to remarry if they lost a spouse. For the longest time, Bilbo had been one of the strange few that didn’t fall in love at all. Until Thorin, of course. And then he took after his mother in that regard, loving once and loving fiercely. The only difference was that he had survived his grief, though that was likely only because Thorin hadn’t truly been his when he’d died…

Alright, so maybe Thorin had a bit of a point about not wanting to offer something he might not be able to give. But all that meant was that Bilbo would have to make sure that his empty-headed dwarf made it through the battle without doing anything stupid, which, luckily for him, was already the plan anyway.

With that thought, Bilbo smiled. “Yes, Thorin.”

“Yes?” Thorin asked, his voice sounding a little raspy.

His smile widened. “Yes, I accept your courtship and your gift. Yes, I love you. Yes, you are my One. Now, do you dwarves have any other silly traditions to make this official?”

Thorin laughed a little shakily and dug into his pocket with his free hand. “Just one.”

There was a gleam of silver in his palm when he opened it between them.

Bilbo took the bead and found that the metal was warm against his skin, and despite how small it was, there were intricate runes shaped into its surface. “I suppose you’re meant to put this in my hair?”

“If you allow it, yes. Some people prefer to wait—”

Tearing his eyes away from the bead, Bilbo sent the dwarf a sharp look that silenced him immediately. “I have waited for you for eighty years, Thorin Oakenshield. I’m quite over it.” He let his voice soften a little, then offered him the bead. “Go on, then.”

Drawing in what seemed to be a steadying breath, Thorin carefully placed the acorn in his pocket then moved closer, coming to stand on Bilbo’s right side and selecting a chunk of hair. It took him longer to weave in the braid than Bilbo thought was strictly necessary, given how short his hair was, but he didn’t complain. When Thorin finished the braid off with the bead, his hands still hovered by Bilbo’s head, like he was reluctant to pull away, so Bilbo turned to him and took his hand, pressing his face into Thorin’s warm palm.

The smile Thorin sent him was one of those bright ones that lit up his entire face and made Bilbo feel all warm inside.

“How many bets do you think they’ll settle the moment we go back out there?” he asked, glancing towards the door.

Thorin rolled his eyes, but his smile didn’t waver. “Too many. I guarantee there will be at least one fight.”

Bilbo grinned. “How much do you want to bet that fight starts because someone tries to hit Nori?”

“How much do you want to bet Dori is the one who tries to hit him?”

Laughing, Bilbo raised up on his toes to press one last kiss to Thorin’s lips, then he turned and headed for the door. “There’s only one way to find out. Come on, I’m hungry.”

Thorin followed, catching his hand and entwining their fingers.

That warm feeling in Bilbo’s chest grew and he ignored all the worries in the back of his mind that clamored for his attention. There would be time to think about it all soon enough. For now, he’d let himself be happy.

 

***

 

As they’d expected, their return to the guardhouse was quickly followed by congratulatory cheers and several shouted arguments about who owed who money and how much—which seemed like a rather pointless debate considering how large of a fortune they’d each earned by reclaiming the mountain. A few coins over a silly bet didn’t seem to matter much at all in comparison, but Bilbo supposed the arguing was in spirit of principle rather than the actual worth of their winnings. And someone did try to hit Nori, but it wasn’t who they expected. Instead of Dori—who was actually in rather high spirits considering his usual poor temper—it ended up being Oin who lunged at the middle Ri brother, after Nori made a sarcastic comment about the old healer losing his knack for reading portents. Out of everyone, it seemed Oin lost the largest amount of money.

And, of course, there was the teasing. Bilbo tried to meet the various jibes tossed his way with a scowl, but he was sure the effect was ruined by the embarrassed grin that he couldn’t quite get rid of.

Fili and Kili were noticeably absent, and Bilbo was just about to ask where they were when they were all interrupted by a loud caw.

Thorin was the first one to his feet, exiting the guardhouse with the rest of them following quickly behind.

Outside their makeshift camp, perched on top of a broken chunk of stone, was a huge raven. It rustled its wings as they came closer, but didn’t take flight.

“Greetings, Arec. What news?” Thorin asked, stopping a few feet away from the bird.

“Greetings, Stone King. I bear a message from the lake man, Bard.”

Bilbo jolted at the croaky sound of the raven’s voice. He’d never actually heard one of the Ereborian raven speak before, and he’d forgotten they could. When the momentary shock of it wore off, he stepped a little closer in his curiosity—but not too close, out of wariness of the sharp looking talons on the raven’s feet.

“The old Master of Lake-town is dead, and Bard has taken up leadership of his people. He accepts your offer of shelter, and in his appreciation sends you warning. The Elf King approaches, and though he speaks of peace, he comes with an army at his back. As they travel alongside each other, both men and elves will arrive overmorrow before the sun meets its highest peak.”

The mention of Thranduil had several of the Company muttering to each other, all cheer gone from their voices. Beside him, Thorin stiffened, and Bilbo grabbed his hand, squeezing it in encouragement. This was a good thing, after all. As nice as it would be to not have to deal with Thranduil, they needed him there if they were to have any chance at winning the battle.

The tension in Thorin eased somewhat. “Was Tharkûn among them?”

“I saw no sign of the grey wizard.”

Memory of the vision the Ring had shown him of Gandalf beaten and bloodied in the fortress of Dol Guldur made Bilbo shudder, and he silently prayed for the safety of his oldest friend.

“You have my thanks, Arec,” Thorin said.

The raven spread its wings and seemed to give a bow, then launched himself into the air. He circled above them once, then soared towards the front gate and disappeared through the small exit they had managed to excavate during their work that day.

After its departure, the Company remained silent for several long moments, until an excited voice spoke up directly behind Bilbo.

“That was fantastic!”

Bilbo jumped and turned around, shocked to find Kili there, staring at the place where the raven disappeared with wide, excited eyes.

“When did you get here?” Bilbo gasped.

Fili threw his arm around Kili’s shoulder. “What do you mean, Bilbo? We’ve been here the whole time.” His mischievous eyes caught on the bead in Bilbo’s hair and he smirked. He looked like he was about to comment on it, but was interrupted by Thorin.

“Balin, Bilbo, I need you both prepared to join me in negotiations with Thranduil upon his arrival. The rest of you will work on clearing an area to house the people of Lake-town for the winter.” Thorin paused and turned away from the rock where the raven had sat to look appraisingly at his oldest nephew, then seemed to make a decision because he nodded once to himself. “Fili, I would have you join me, as well.”

After Thorin gave out a few more instructions for the following day and assigned Dwalin to first watch, the rest of them piled back into the guardhouse to rest. Unlike the previous night, Bilbo curled up beside Thorin. And despite his worries about the upcoming negotiations, and the looming battle, and what might have happened to Gandalf, sleep came easily.

 

***

 

Shre nasg golugranu kilmi-nudu.

The night was so still among the fortress, one would think the very wind itself had died. The ruins were draped with a suffocating veil of dread. The air became colder, the shadows deeper. Beings long lost crept from the dim, not yet alive, but realer than they’d been in several millennia, since they were cast into the void and forgotten. Their shuddering, transparent forms circled, drawn to the single light alone in the darkness.

Ombi kuzddurbagu gundum-ishi.

The Lady of Light stumbled back and fell, still clutching the fading Istari to her chest, and her radiance was dimmed by fear. She had come to save him, the old fool, but she was not enough to hold off the gathering storm. The world would fail and all would turn to darkness and despair. A new age was coming. When it arrived, no light would have the strength to resist it.

Soon.

Terrible laughter filled the silence, ancient and vile, and a single tear fell down the Lady’s fair cheek.

The Nine drew their blades—

Bilbo woke drenched in a cold sweat, his heart pounding painfully against his ribs. A shadowy figure hovered over him and he flinched, groping blindly for the sword that had been missing from his side for weeks.

“It was just a dream, Bilbo.”

Eyes adjusting a bit to the low light of the guardhouse, Bilbo relaxed when he recognized Thorin. He slumped back against his bedroll with a quiet groan. Every inch of his body shook and ached and he feared he might be sick.

“Are you alright?” Thorin murmured.

Swallowing a few times, Bilbo shook his head. “I think I need some air,” he rasped.

Thorin helped him to his feet and they picked their way around the gaggle of sleeping dwarves scattered across the floor. As soon as they left the guardhouse, Bilbo made a beeline for the front gate.

The air outside was icy cold against him clammy skin and felt sharp in his lungs as he heaved it in, but its bite grounded him somewhat.

“Nightmares again, lad?”

The voice came from behind him and to his right and Bilbo startled, spinning around to find Gloin sitting on a stone block beside the doorway and smoking. He gave Bilbo a sympathetic look and offered him his pipe.

“Again?” Thorin asked.

Sending Gloin a tight smile, Bilbo refused the pipe. “I’ll be alright, thank you. Could you give us a minute?”

The dwarf nodded and stood, cracking his back several times as he stretched, then he headed inside.

When he was gone, Bilbo sighed and dropped heavily onto the stone block Gloin had just vacated.

“Have you been having nightmares often?”

Thorin sounded concerned and Bilbo shrugged, scrubbing a hand down his face in frustration. How to answer that question? Yes, he’d been struggling with nightmares quite a lot lately—especially since crossing the Misty Mountains. But he wasn’t even really sure they were nightmares. They felt so real most of the time, not to mention they often happened while he was awake. The blasted Ring was responsible for it, of course. When it wasn’t torturing him with made up images of his friends all lying dead in the snow, it showed him a place that he could only assume was Dol Guldur. Those dreams—visions?—always felt more true, though for Gandalf’s sake, he hoped they weren’t.

“The last several months have been rather stressful. So far I’ve managed,” he finally said, settling on a non-answer. He didn’t have the energy right now to explain the things the Ring showed him. Not that he’d want to explain even if he wasn’t utterly exhausted.

“Why did you not tell me?”

“It’s really nothing to worry about.”

“You told Gloin.”

The words were grumbled and Bilbo imagined there was a hint of jealousy in Thorin’s tone.

He snorted and shook his head. “Gloin only knows because he woke me up from one when we were in Thranduil’s dungeon. We were cell-mates, you know.”

Apparently unsatisfied with the answer, Thorin’s frown deepened.

“Honestly. I’m fine, Thorin. I—”

A searing pain behind his eyes and a rising shriek made Bilbo gasp and clap his hands over his ears, even though he should know by now that it would do nothing to block out the noise in his head. The Ring screamed louder and louder, the sound filled with rage and pain, and Bilbo’s vision darkened as he was thrust into another vision.

The Lady of Light was terrible and beautiful in her fury as she stood before the Dark Lord, her entire visage darkened with power and a vial of blinding starlight clutched in one hand. Her otherworldly voice commanded that he return to the void where he had remained trapped for so long, weakened and pathetic in his defeat. He would never go back to that place of nothing. Never. But neither could he stay here. Not when that light of hers seared his very spirit down to its rotten core, freezing and burning at the same time.

Screaming in rage, he withdrew. And he fled.

The vision was over as quickly as it began and Bilbo sucked in a sharp breath, eyes snapping open. Thorin was on his knees in front of him, eyes filled with frantic worry and mouth moving quickly as he spoke, but the Ring’s screams were growing louder and Bilbo couldn’t hear what the dwarf was saying.

Surging to his feet, Bilbo stumbled past Thorin and looked up at the sky, not quite sure what he was looking for.

For a moment, everything remained dark. But then in the distance, far to the southwest, a fiery light rose from the shadowy mass that was Mirkwood. It streaked across the sky like a shooting star into the east and disappeared.

As soon as it was out of sight, the screaming in his head stopped, and Bilbo’s hands dropped limply to his sides as he panted and swayed on his feet.

Thorin’s arms were around him in an instant, and he could feel the dwarf’s chest rumbling against his back as he rambled a long string of curses in khuzdul. Then he switched to Westron, sounding somewhat desperate. “What happened? What is wrong?”

But Bilbo barely heard him, unable to tear his eyes away from the eastern horizon, trembling and queasy with dread.

 

***

 

It was a grey day.

The wind that moaned through the lifeless streets of Dale was biting cold with the promise of oncoming winter, and Bilbo was certain the tips of his ears and toes had turned to ice hours ago. The tent where they held their meeting was positioned in a place where it was blocked from the wind, but it was open on two sides and did nothing to protect the occupants from the miserable temperatures—not that King Thranduil seemed at all bothered by the cold, lounging as he was in his throne with a glass of wine always in hand and an arrogant smirk carved into his stony face. 

Bilbo had come into negotiations this morning hopeful that they might be able to come to an alliance peaceably and without incident, but while Bard was willing to do so for the sake of ensuring his people would have shelter for the winter, the dwarves were stubborn and Thranduil was determined to cause problems. He cared for nothing but the White Gems of Lasgalen and refused to believe that orcs marched on the mountain as they spoke, accusing Thorin of a weak attempt to scare him away to avoid giving him his due payment. After hours of circling around the subject like vultures, Bilbo was no longer feeling very charitable in his judgement of Thranduil.

He was cold and miserable and hungry, and for all that he’d been the one lecturing the dwarves on the way here not to start any fights, he found himself battling the urge to take the seemingly bottomless wine bottle from the elf king’s side table and dump it over his pompous, shiny head.

To Thorin’s credit, he somehow managed to keep his own temper mostly in check, despite Thranduil’s constant goading, and the shouting was kept to a minimum. Despite his own annoyance, Bilbo was impressed by his dwarf’s restraint.

“I assure you the White Gems will be returned, but we do not have the time to search for them. Winter and war are upon us and we have bigger things to worry about than some shiny stones.” Thorin spoke the words through gritted teeth.

As unmoved as ever, Thranduil just sipped his wine. “War will be upon you if I am not given what is owed. If you do not bring the Gems to me, I will be forced to retrieve them myself.”

It was not the first time the elf king had hinted at attacking the mountain today, and his threats were putting everyone on edge.

Thorin hissed and returned to pacing back and forth across the length of the tent, while Fili and Balin stood stiffly to one side. Bilbo had long given up on standing with them and was sitting on the cracked stone floor at the back, away from the commotion. Beside him, Bard sat on a wooden chair, elbows on his knees and face pressed into his hands.

He had stopped trying to engage with the two kings and their dispute after a couple hours—not that Bilbo blamed him. The poor man was ragged with exhaustion. After the Master was killed in the orc attack on Lake-town last week, Bard was unwillingly shoved into a position of leadership by the rest of the survivors. Apparently, he had armed people with makeshift weapons and took out several orcs single-handedly during the fight, and those deeds were enough to put him in charge, no dragon-slaying necessary. Despite his reluctance to lead, he’d been working to get his people to shelter ever since. He didn’t look like he’d slept in days, and Bilbo had a feeling he wouldn’t allow himself to rest until his people were settled in the mountain.

After another minute or two of pacing, during which time Thorin seemed to get his temper under control once more, he tried again. “Erebor has no desire to have Mirkwood as an enemy—”

Thranduil’s face twitched—a rare crack in his otherwise stoic facade that seemed to appear anytime someone referred to his kingdom as ‘Mirkwood’ rather than his preferred ‘Greenwood’—and he interrupted Thorin before he could finish. “I imagine not, given that Erebor is nothing more than a handful of travel-worn dwarves and a weak halfling.”

Just as Thorin had discovered the elf king’s sensitivity about the name of his kingdom and insisted on prodding at it every once in a while, so too had Thranduil found that the dwarves were very easily offended if he insulted their burglar. 

Bilbo didn’t much care what Thranduil said about him—as he put very little stock into the opinions of such a petty ponce of an elf—but his dwarves were always quick to defend his honor. He appreciated it, and was rather touched the first couple times it happened, but by now the whole routine was growing tedious.

Sighing, Bilbo got to his feet and moved towards one of the open sides of the tent, then paused when he noticed Thorin watching him worriedly.

He’d been doing it all day yesterday and continued to do it now—sending him anxious look with eyes full of concern every time Bilbo breathed wrong or moved unexpectedly. He’d gone so far as to suggest Bilbo stay behind in the mountain today and rest, which was an idea Bilbo had quickly shot down. Of course, it was all due to the incident the night before last with the nightmare-vision. Thorin apparently didn't like it when Bilbo went totally unresponsive for nearly a whole minute, sitting still as a statue and staring unblinking into space. And now the dwarf was keeping an annoyingly close eye on him, as if Bilbo might collapse at any moment.

Biting back a second sigh that would surely send Thorin into a nervous fit if he heard it, Bilbo sent him a reassuring smile. “Don’t mind me. I’m just stretching my legs.”

He didn’t look convinced, but Thranduil made an impatient sound and Thorin’s expression twisted back into a scowl, then he turned back to the elf king to snap a biting comment.

Bilbo ignored whatever it was the two said to each other and stepped out of the tent.

Unfortunately, the view outside wasn’t much more pleasant than the going-ons inside.

There was a thick wave of stormy black clouds in the north that he didn’t like the look of, slowly but surely crawling their way  towards the mountain. If they were lucky, it would bring nothing but snow in its wake, but he had a feeling it warned of far worse tidings.

Something needed to budge soon, or they’d be stuck there in that tent arguing until the moment Azog showed his ugly face with a legion of orcs at his back.

If nothing else, they needed to get the people of Lake-town into the shelter of the mountain. Bard was refusing to move them to Erebor until the negotiations here were finished, likely because he didn’t want to risk his people getting caught in the middle of a siege if Thranduil actually followed through on his threats to storm Erebor and claim the Gems himself. His hesitation was understandable, but Bilbo looked out at the ruins of Dale and all he could see were the cracked streets stained with blood of the men, women, and children who’d been slaughtered there during the battle. 

The memory made bile rise in the back of Bilbo’s throat.

There was nothing he could do to sway Thranduil—he’d tried earlier, but it seemed the elf king had no interest in listening to a weak halfling unless Bilbo was waving the Arkenstone right under his nose. He’d given up his attempts to make any progress on that front fairly early on, but… Judging the temperatures now, this night promised to be a cold one. Thanks to the forges that had been lit during their face off against Smaug, parts of the mountain were warming up. Not enough to be considered toasty by hobbit standards, but certainly more comfortable than freezing out here. Maybe that would be enough to convince Bard to leave this pointless meeting and move his people to safety.

The more he thought about it, the more Bilbo leaned towards trying. It was better than standing around doing nothing, in any case. He was about to return to Bard’s side when a flash of movement down the street caught his attention and he paused, looking back.

A familiar, pale-haired figure had appeared and was striding purposefully toward the tent. Behind him trailed a white horse and a second person with red hair.

“Legolas!” 

His relief at the sight was enough to make him momentarily forget that he technically wasn’t on a first name basis with the elf prince yet, but he hardly cared. The argument behind him fell silent, and Legolas walked a little faster, coming close enough that Bilbo was able to make out the grim expression on his face.

A few moments later, Legolas brushed past him and strode into the tent, stopping once he stood before his father’s throne. He paid no mind to the dwarves, nor did he look at Bard, who sat up straight and alert.

Legolas didn’t bother with polite greetings or formalities, and simply dove straight into what it was he had come to say, his voice calm save for a faint note of underlying urgency.

“An army of Gundabad orcs approaches from the north. They are led by Bolg, spawn of Azog the Defiler.”

 

***

 

It was around tea-time when they finally ended negotiations for the day—negotiations that just turned out to be hours upon hours of bickering, underhanded insults, and thinly veiled threats. The whole affair was exhausting and, in Bilbo’s opinion, almost completely unproductive. Legolas’s arrival with news about the approaching orc army was really the only progress they’d made on important issues all day. Though, to call it ‘progress’ was an optimistic evaluation at best. Not long after Legolas gave the news, Thranduil called an end to the discussion, claiming that he needed time to speak to his son alone.

Thorin wasn't thrilled with the demand that they leave the tent just as they were finally broaching the topic he’d been pushing for all day, but he reluctantly agreed to reconvene in the morning, after tempers had time to cool and Bard’s people were settled inside Erebor.

Knowing that the orcs were less than a week away was more than enough to convince Bard it was time to move, no temptation about warm halls needed.

So that’s what they were doing now—making the walk from Dale to the front gate of Erebor, crossing the soon-to-be battlefield. Several of the Company met them halfway, coming to help move the people of Lake-town across the valley. Bilbo felt a sense of pride watching his dwarves take over the task of pulling heavy carts and carrying loads of supplies to allow the weary men, women, and children some rest. And he couldn’t help but notice that Thranduil didn't send a single one of his soldiers to aid in the effort, save for Tauriel, but Bilbo had a feeling she wasn’t there on her king’s orders.

It was unsurprising when he noticed the elf woman walking alongside Kili, red hair gleaming like fire in the evening sun, and Bilbo was pleased to see her there. To most eyes, he was sure they made for an unnatural pair, but they looked happy. And to him, that was all that mattered. He had seen too much sorrow in his long years to begrudge them their laughter. Especially now, considering the great danger they would soon be forced to face.

It was also unsurprising that beside him, Thorin was not pleased.

His dwarf’s mood was already sour thanks to the hours spent in close quarters with Thranduil, but it seemed to be growing worse with every moment that he watched his nephew interacting with an elf. The glower on his face was dark and angry, and Bilbo noticed his hand flexing worryingly close to the hilt of the sword on his hip.

Oh no, he’d be having none of that, thank you.

Bilbo made an irritated sound at the back of his throat and caught Thorin’s hand in his own, yanking it purposefully away from the sword.

Thorin’s attention immediately turned onto him, the dwarf’s expression shifting once again to worry. “What is it? Are you tired? Do you need to sit for a moment?”

Ignoring the urge to roll his eyes, Bilbo just nodded in Kili’s direction. “I’m fine. You leave them be.”

In the blink of an eye, Thorin’s stormy glower returned. “I do not like it.”

“They’re not hurting anything,” Bilbo insisted, but his words only made Thorin’s face darken even more and he opened his mouth to respond. Bilbo cut him off before he could say anything. “No, your pride doesn’t count.”

“It is not my pride I am worried about."

“You can’t expect him to give up his friendships to carry on a generational grudge on your behalf, dear.”

“Elves are fickle friends. Kili is young and naive if he thinks she will not turn her back on him the moment her friendship is needed most. I do not expect you to understand.”

The final words had a barbed edge, and Bilbo bit his tongue to avoid giving an equally cutting retort. They were both tired and more than a little on edge after the day they’d had, and turning sharp words on each other wouldn’t help anything, nor would attempting to defend his own friends among the elves. That wasn’t what this was about, in any case.

So Bilbo just shrugged and said calmly, “I don’t appreciate you speaking to me that way.”

With that, some of Thorin’s anger seemed to deflate and he released a heavy sigh. “I am sorry. I just do not want him to be hurt.”

“I know.”

He squeezed Thorin’s hand and they spent the next minute or so walking in silence. As the seconds ticked past, though, Thorin’s tension began to rise again and a quick glance told Bilbo he’d gone back to glaring at Tauriel.

Pursing his lips, Bilbo hesitated, considering what to do. 

Recently, they hadn’t spoken much about how terribly things went during the battle last time. A part of him felt like speaking of it would bring bad luck down upon their heads, so he didn’t bring it up. Every time it came to mind, he told himself there was no point in thinking about it because that was then and things were going to go differently this time. No one was going to die, and that was that.

Mostly, though, he just didn’t bring it up because the anguish in Thorin’s eyes every time he thought of his nephews’ deaths was just too much for Bilbo to bear. There was no point in dredging up those memories. They’d both seen what happened to Fili. And Thorin never asked for details about Kili’s fate, so Bilbo never told him.

But maybe Bilbo’s decision to keep those details to himself were doing more harm than good. Maybe Thorin needed to know the truth of it, no matter how painful it might be speak of.

His mind made up, Bilbo forced himself to speak before he could convince himself otherwise. “Kili died protecting her.”

Thorin’s breath wheezed out of him like he’d been hit, then he stopped walking, frozen to the spot.

“What are you talking about?”

The question would have sounded like a demand if not for the slight crack in Thorin’s voice.

Already half regretting this, Bilbo stopped too and turned to meet his eye. He winced at the raw look in his eyes, like Bilbo had gone prodding at an open wound. His own chest ached with the familiar grief that had haunted him for the rest of his life after that terrible day.

It was too late to take the words back, though, so he swallowed the lump in his throat and went on, speaking gently. “During the battle, Tauriel knew Kili was headed into a trap, and she went to Ravenhill to warn him. Kili found her in a losing fight against Bolg in the tower and stepped in to save her.”

He didn’t speak of Kili’s death again. There was no need to. The look on Thorin’s face was enough to tell him the dwarf understood what he was saying. His expression was filled with that same aching grief Bilbo felt, punctuated by anger and confusion. It wasn’t surprising. 

Looking back on it, Bilbo wasn’t sure if Thorin had ever witnessed any of Kili’s interactions with Tauriel on the first journey. The two befriended each other during the Company’s time in the dungeons, just as they did this time, but Thorin had been separated from the rest of the group back then. He wasn't there to listen to his younger nephew chattering with the guard captain for weeks on end, and Bilbo never mentioned it on his visits to the deepest part of the dungeon because he figured it wasn’t any of his business—and he knew it would only upset Thorin even more than he already was. And he couldn’t imagine that any of the others ever brought it up after their escape, either.

No, the more he thought about it, the more likely it seemed that Thorin had no idea about Kili’s friendship with Tauriel until their most recent stint in Mirkwood.

Bilbo watched the dwarf, worried what his reaction might be, but Thorin said nothing for several long moments. When he finally did speak, his voice was strained.

“And the elf?” he asked.

Bilbo did his best not to grimace. It was a sad story, despite his very limited knowledge of everything that had gone on. In the days after the battle, he was so wound up in his own grief, it hadn’t occurred to him to wonder what became of her. It wasn’t until his old age in Rivendell that he’d learned of her fate.

“She was gravely injured, but she watched over him until the dwarves came to retrieve him, and then she left. Legolas told me many decades later that he never saw her again after that. No one knew what happened to her or where she’d gone, but her grief for Kili’s loss was great.”

He decided not to mention the things that Bofur had told him during one of his visits to the Shire, several years later. About how Tauriel helped them escape Lake-town during the dragon attack, and how afterwards, Kili asked her to go with him to Erebor, and how the young prince gifted her his rune-stone. Bilbo never put much thought to that particular detail, but now that he knew about the dwarvish custom of giving your One a gift when proposing courtship… No, he didn’t think it was his place to share those particular details with Thorin.

Still, Thorin seemed to work some of the unsaid bits out on his own. His expression turned to something unreadable, and his tone was flat when he said, “She healed his leg. After I abandoned him on the lake.”

It wasn’t a question, but Bilbo nodded anyway. His response was slow as he weighed his words carefully. “Bofur and Oin said that he was dying of infection. He never would have made it to the mountain at all if she hadn’t shown up.” He paused, unsure if he should say anything more, and glanced ahead to where Kili and Tauriel still walked side by side. The single elf among men and dwarves. He turned back to Thorin. “She sought out Kili to heal him against orders and Thranduil banished her for it. She disobeyed her king and gave up her position and home to help him.”

Thorin let out another harsh breath and raised a hand to massage his brow, then pinched the bridge of his nose. Eyes closed, he bit out a low curse in khuzdul that Bilbo recognized, but didn’t know the exact translation for.

Stepping slightly closer to his dwarf, Bilbo put a comforting hand on his arm. “I understand why you are upset about this, love, but for Kili’s sake, don’t do anything rash.”

Thorin dropped the hand from his face and met Bilbo’s gaze. He looked exhausted and more than a little unhappy, but he nodded in agreement. “I will think on it. There are bigger things to worry about for now.”

Well, it was better than nothing.

Tracing his hand down Thorin's arm, Bilbo took his hand once again.

“It will all work out in the end, you’ll see.” The words sounded more confident than he truly felt, but he ignored the kernel of doubt in the back of his mind.

There was nothing for him to do but keep moving forward and hope what he said was true.

Thorin said nothing, and the rest of the walk back to the mountain was spent in silence.

 

***

 

If yesterday was a grey day, today was a dark one.

The storm clouds Bilbo hadn’t liked the look of had made their way to the mountain over night, and now he liked them even less. They blocked out much of the dawn light and made the world look dim, and brought the cold of a northern winter with them. If he thought it was cold before, it was nothing compared to this—he’d barely been outside for a full minute, and already his lungs felt like blocks of ice in his chest. Even with Thorin’s coat as an extra layer wrapped around him, he was freezing. He dreaded another day spent in Thranduil’s tent, listening to arguments that got them nowhere, and wished the elf king might be a little more willing to work together now that he had proof of the orc army on its way, though Bilbo’s hope for such a thing wasn’t very high. 

What worried him even more was Gandalf’s continued absence, and the lack of any word from Dain. 

What if something had happened to his oldest friend? What if he was still trapped in Dol Guldur? What if the orcs arrived before the dwarves from the Iron Hills did? What if Thranduil did something foolish, like attempt to retreat from the mountain and return home rather than fight?

There were so many things that could go wrong, it made Bilbo’s head spin.

Stamping his feet in the cold and buried deep in his own grim thoughts, he didn’t hear the heavy sound of boots crunching towards him over the frosty ground, and was startled when someone threw an arm around his shoulders.

“Good morning, Bilbo. Beautiful day, isn’t it?”

Fili’s voice was bright and cheerful, and Bilbo sent him an incredulous look. “No, it’s not.”

Bilbo had no idea how Fili had any energy right now—he and Kili were out late, not returning to their camp in the guardhouse until well past midnight, out doing Valar only knew what. Hopefully not causing any trouble, but that was likely just wishful thinking. He was about to ask where they’d been when the wind picked up in an icy blast that sent a violent shiver all the way from Bilbo’s ears down to his toes, and he wrapped Thorin’s coat tighter around himself.

Fili chuckled and pulled him a little closer, and Bilbo wasn’t too proud to accept the offer for warmth when it was given. Not when he felt sure the tip of his nose might break off if he sniffled too hard.

As if hearing his miserable thoughts, Fili nudged him. “Come back inside, Bilbo. We can’t have our burglar freezing to death.”

“But the meeting,” he protested, glancing over to where Thorin, Balin, and Bard were huddled together having some last minute discussion before they made the trek back to the outskirts of Dale. Dwalin stood glowering a few feet away from them.

“What do they need us for, save as an audience for their bickering?”

It was true, technically. Neither he nor the prince had been asked to contribute to the conversation yesterday—if what happened in that tent could even be counted as a ‘conversation.’ They’d just stood by as silent witnesses. And while Bilbo was impressed by Fili’s unexpected capacity for patience, their presence ultimately served little purpose. But then again…

“I just worry Thorin will lose his temper.”

“He’ll be fine. He managed to negotiate for our freedom all on his own in Mirkwood,” Fili pointed out. When Bilbo still hesitated, he nudged him again. “You can always join him later in the day once it’s warmed up a little. Besides, Kili has something to show you.”

“He does?” That was a bit of a surprise. Kili hadn’t spoken to him much lately, and he had a feeling that poor boy still felt guilty for the whole incident with the Ring, but there just hadn’t been enough time to pull him aside and reassure him. For a moment, Bilbo was glad that they might finally talk and be rid of the tension that had plagued them ever since their arrival to Lake-town. Then he remembered how many hours the two princes spent away from the Company the last few nights and felt a twinge of suspicion. “What is it?”

Sure enough, a bit of that familiar mischief appeared in Fili’s eyes with the question, and Bilbo almost groaned.

He could either go keep an eye on Thorin and make sure he didn’t try and strangle Thranduil with his own perfect hair, or he could go with Fili and take care of whatever trouble-making he and his brother had been up to lately.

If things got out of hand at the meeting, Bilbo had no hope that Dwalin would do anything to stop Thorin from doing something stupid—he’d probably join in, actually—but Balin would surely keep the peace, right?

But with those three at the meeting, there’d be no one left in the mountain to keep an eye on Fili and Kili.

Bilbo sighed. “Oh, alright, I’ll—”

Before he could even finish, Fili grabbed his arm and was pulling him back into the mountain. “Great, let’s go.”

They met Kili outside the guardhouse, and he smiled the moment he saw them—a big, bright smile like the one he usually wore before the Ring had sunk its claws into him. And as wary as Bilbo was about what these two were up to, seeing Kili’s happy face was a relief.

So he smiled back at the young dwarf. “Good morning. I’m not sure if I should be grateful that you got me out of what’s sure to be a miserable meeting, or worried that whatever you have to show me is going to get us all into a load of trouble.”

“Why can’t it be both?” Kili asked, and he came to walk beside them.

There was an energetic bounce to his step that had been missing for the past several weeks, and a glimmer of mischief in his dark eyes that mirrored his brother’s a little too much. It was both a welcome sight and a worrisome one.

“I don’t suppose you’re going to tell me what this is all about."

From the corner of his eye, he watched Kili’s smile dim slightly. Kili shrugged and kicked a rock with the toe of his boot, sending it skittering away. “I’ve been meaning to apologize to you.”

“Kili, if this is about the Ring—”

“It’s not!” Kili said quickly, then he shook his head, expression somewhat chagrined. “Well, I guess the gold-sickness is part of it.”

He paused as they walked past the area where the people of Lake-town were staying, in a cavernous chamber off to the side of the main hall. Despite the size of the room, it was still overcrowded, and they’d need more space cleared for them so they weren’t sleeping on top of each other all winter long. For now, though, it would have to do. At least they weren’t still in Dale, like chickens trapped in a hen-house with a fox burrowing its way under the fence. At least the children who laughed and chased each other between rows of makeshift beds wouldn’t have to go through the ordeal of running for their lives from the orcs that did not care how young they were. At least they were safe.

Once they were past the chamber and out of earshot of the people there, Kili went on. “Back in Lake-town, you claimed the Company as barafu ik-kurdu, and I was so wrapped up in the sickness, I never gave you a gift.”

Bilbo once again felt that mixture of exasperated affection that only his dwarves seemed capable of evoking in him. “You don’t have to give me anything, Kili. I don’t need gifts to know you care for me.”

Kili’s brows furrowed and he sent Bilbo a confused look. “But I want to give you something. Do hobbits not give gifts to show their appreciation for each other?”

“Of course we do. I’m only saying—”

“Speaking of gifts,” Fili interrupted. “I pulled this out of the dragon’s eye and cleaned it up for you. Thought you might want it back.”

Fili dug around inside his coat, then pulled out a familiar looking knife—it was the one he’d given to Bilbo in Lake-town.

“Oh! Thank you. I’d forgotten about that.” He took the knife and placed it back into the empty sheath on his belt. 

Fili shrugged, then elbowed Bilbo lightly. “No problem. Do me a favor and try not to lose it, though. Adad made that knife.”

Bilbo spluttered and tripped over an uneven spot on the cracked floor. “Wait, this was your father’s? Are you sure you should give this to me?”

He didn’t know much about the princes’ father. Only that he’d died when they were very young, and Thorin had stepped in to take care of his widowed sister and her children in his place after his death.

“Don’t worry. I have plenty more.” Fili patted his own belt proudly, where a few of his multitude of knives were sheathed. Then he grinned wide. “I think he would have loved you, and he would have been thrilled to know you used it to jab old Smaug in the eye.”

Bilbo knew Fili valued his weapons, but he hadn’t realized how significant of a gift this truly was. It put a warm feeling in his chest, even as he worried it shouldn’t have been given to him. “Well, if you’re certain…”

It was Kili who responded cheerfully. “Fi never does anything unless he’s sure about it. He doesn’t have an impulsive bone in his body.”

Bilbo wasn’t sure if that information made all of the silly stunts he’d witnessed these two pull better or worse. Before he had a chance to voice that thought, though, Kili grabbed his arm and steered him around a corner into what he recognized as the armory hallway.

Instead of going all the way down the hall to the armory, they stopped about a third of the way, where a door was tucked into a shadowy alcove. Kili let go of his arm and pushed the door open, leading the way into the room beyond. It was small—little more than a glorified storage closet—and lit only by a guttering lantern placed on a stone shelf. When Fili closed the door behind them, there was barely enough floor space for the three of them to stand without touching each other.

“Well, this is cozy,” Bilbo grumbled.

Fili snorted—a sound that was immediately followed by a deafening sneeze, probably thanks to all the dust in the air.

Ears ringing, Bilbo pressed his own nose into the crook of his elbow, and his voice was muffled when he spoke. “What are we doing here?”

Kili ignored the question, busy messing with something on a back shelf that Bilbo couldn’t see. After some rustling, the young dwarf spun on his heel, nearly knocking Bilbo in the face with a long object he’d picked up from the shelf.

The first thing Bilbo saw was the huge, rather proud grin on Kili’s face.

The second thing he noticed was that the thing in Kili’s arms was actually two objects—two very familiar objects.

Orcrist and Sting.

Shocked, Bilbo reached out to touch the blades, sucking in a sharp breath—then immediately started choking on a lungful of dust. He began coughing so hard he doubled over, and Fili pounded him on the back a few times in an attempt to help, but only succeeded in knocking the air out of him even more. It was several moments before he recovered and waved Fili away, then looked at Kili suspiciously, eyes streaming.

“Please tell me you didn’t steal those.”

How on Arda they’d even manage to do such a thing, he had no idea, but that was hardly important. What was important was that Thranduil was going to be furious the moment he noticed the swords were missing. Oh Yavanna, he didn’t even want to imagine the storm that would come down on their heads when the temperamental king realized he’d lost the only bargaining chips he had for getting his precious gems back. He might actually follow through on his threats of war, and they couldn’t afford to—

Kili interrupted Bilbo’s panicked thoughts with a scoff, and though his tone was offended, the expression on his face was full of mirth. “Steal them? Come on, Bilbo, give us some credit. We may be idiots, but we’re not stupid.”

The answer was not comforting in the slightest.

Bilbo turned an accusing look on the older of the two brothers, silently demanding an explanation.

Fili just shrugged, seeming entirely unbothered save for the sly smile tugging at the corners of his lips. “Let’s just say we took some princely liberties as Thorin’s heirs and negotiated on his behalf without telling him first.”

That also was not comforting.

“What do you mean? Negotiated with who?”

“It turns out Prince Legolas is far more reasonable than his father.”

Kili added, “You know, despite the whole locking us in the dungeon for a week thing.”

Of course it was Legolas.

Unsure if he should be irritated, amused, or proud of them for going behind Thorin’s back to do such a thing, Bilbo just shook his head and reached for Sting again. The weight of it was familiar in his hands, and some of the tension he’d been carrying in his shoulders loosened a little. It would be a lie if he said he hadn’t been worried about how he’d make it through the battle without his sword—Dwalin had taken it upon himself to search the armory for a blade that Bilbo would be able to use, but so far was unable to find anything small enough.

“I suppose the reason you’ve been disappearing in the evenings is because you were searching for the Gems?”

“Among other things,” Fili said. 

He decided to ignore that—he had no desire to know what those ‘other things’ might be. This was already more than enough trouble as it was.

Unable to help himself, though, Bilbo laughed. “Thorin is not going to like this.”

“Definitely not,” Kili agreed cheerfully.

“After yesterday, it was pretty obvious that Uncle and King Pointy Ears could argue in circles about those Gems for years if we let them.” Fili leaned against one of the shelves on the wall, looking rather pleased with himself and not at all worried about the angry lecture he was sure to receive from Thorin later. “We decided it might be best if we just settled that particular issue for them so they could move on to more important things. When I suggested the idea to Legolas, he agreed.”

He said it as if their peaceful negotiation with an elvish prince wasn’t a ground-breaking accomplishment. As if they hadn’t just defied centuries worth of enmity between dwarves and elves to work together for a common goal.

It shouldn’t be so shocking, he supposed. After all, Legolas and Gimli had proven it to be possible in a past life, when they put aside their differences and formed a bond so strong, their love became legendary across all of Middle Earth (much to both of their fathers’ horror). Kili was already on the verge of doing the same, if the way he looked at Tauriel was anything to go by. And Fili…

He’s going to be an amazing king someday.

The thought hit Bilbo like a frying pan to the back of the head, and he blinked several times in surprise at the realization.

Then, slowly, he grinned.

In that moment, there was no doubt in his mind. Not a single ounce of fear.

These two were going to live. They were going to live, and their mischief-making was going to shake this kingdom to its very foundations.

And Bilbo could not wait to watch it happen. 

Notes:

barafu ik-kurdu - family of the heart

Chapter 29: Of Pride and Honor

Notes:

You may have noticed that I have changed the final chapter count to 32 instead of 30. I decided I needed to cut the chapters in half because they were too daunting to work on and I couldn't get myself to start writing again. So after this chapter, there will be three more instead of just one. You're welcome/I'm sorry.

Anyway, this chapter isn't perfect, but I've decided it's good enough and I need to move on, or I'll never get this fic finished.

As always, if you notice any mistakes, don't hesitate to let me know!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The White Gems glittered like stars in the small chest, despite the dark gloom of the morning, and the sight of them put a foul taste in Thorin’s mouth. 

“How came you by these, thief?” he growled, tearing his eyes from the Gems to glare at the elf prince who held them.

Legolas met his anger with a cool stare. “I am no more a thief than your own heir, and I would thank you not to make such accusations. Prince Fili gave me these Gems in exchange for the elvish blades that were taken from you. It was a fair trade.”

“Fair trade,” Thorin repeated flatly.

“We honored the terms of the deal made between you and my father—” Legolas paused, snapping the chest in his hands shut with a loud crack, snuffing out the Gems’ light and narrowly avoiding catching the elf king’s questing fingers in the lid. Thranduil’s eyes dimmed and he snatched his hand back, leveling a hard glare at his son, but the prince  went on, unflinching. “Now that your deal is settled, you can move on to the matter of the orc army bearing down on us.” 

“Now that it is settled, I will take what is mine and leave these accursed lands,” Thranduil snapped.

“You will not.”

Under other circumstances, Thorin may have laughed at the brief appalled expression that crossed the elf king’s face at his son’s defiance. But the near tangible tension in the tent, along with his own fraying patience, didn’t give him much room for humor. Nor did the icy, dangerous anger that replaced Thranduil’s surprise moments later.

But Legolas did not waver in the face of his father’s wrath. He simply raised his chin and spoke calmly. “The Greenwood is in danger and these Gems blind you to the approaching peril. I know what they mean to you, Ada, but I will not return them until our people and home are safe.”

“You will give them to me now.”

“No.”

The elf king’s fair face twisted then into something ugly and terrible and the menacing step he took towards Legolas had the rest of the people in the tent flinching back or discretely reaching for their weapons, fearing violence.

Before Thranduil could say or do anything more, though, he was interrupted by an ear-piercing shriek.

“What was that?” Bard’s right hand man, Percy, asked anxiously.

Axe in hand, Dwalin only made it a single step toward the exit before stopping short at the sight of a giant Eagle. It swept in for a landing in the center of the stone courtyard outside the tent, the flap of its great wings sending a strong gust of freezing wind at them all.

Bard was reaching for his bow, but stopped short when a grey figure slid from the Eagle’s back and stumbled upon his feet hitting the ground. The old man nearly fell and had to grab onto the Eagle to steady himself. Once he found his balance, he started limping quickly towards the tent. With another shriek, the Eagle took off again.

“Cease whatever petty squabble is happening here! You are all in grave danger.” 

Gandalf reached the tent and stopped, panting and leaning heavily on his gnarled wooden staff. His face was caked with blood and dirt and his ratty robes were torn.

Thranduil’s stony mask slid back into place and he looked at the old man disdainfully, apparently uncaring of his dramatic entrance or disheveled appearance. “Spare us from your mad ramblings, Mithrandir, they are not welcome.”

“I bring dark tidings from the south—”

“What tidings?” Bard interrupted, looking wholly baffled now. “Who are you?”

Thorin spoke before anyone else could. “Gandalf the Grey is a wizard and a friend of my Company. His council is good and if he says there is danger, then danger there is.”

As soon as he finished, he and the old man blinked at each other, and it was unclear which was more surprised by the words.

After a moment, Gandalf cleared his throat and dipped his head. “Thank you, Thorin.”

He grimaced. “Pray don’t mention it.”

Thranduil scoffed.

“If you do not wish to see your people destroyed, Thranduil Oropherion, then you will do well to listen,” Gandalf snapped, turning on the elf king with a glower.

With dread coiling in his belly, Thorin said, “Tell us, Tharkûn.” 

“Azog the Defiler leads an army of Guldur orcs to the mountain. They use were-worms to tunnel under the south-east hills and plan to ambush you.”

What followed was a great deal of raised voices, both in panic and argument.

During a lull in the noise, Balin spoke up. “How long do we have?”

“They will be here by nightfall.”

“So soon?” Percy gasped.

Dwalin spat out a filthy curse. “Dáin is still days away. He won’t make it in time.”

Thorin inhaled deeply.

This is what they feared, when Bilbo pointed out things seemed to be happening too quickly. Thorin had been silently praying he was wrong, but, as he had come to learn, the hobbit was rarely wrong about anything.

He exhaled.

Reaching out, he squeezed Dwalin’s shoulder. “Then we hold Erebor until he gets here.” With Dwalin’s determined nod, he turned to the men. “Will you ride ahead to warn everyone that we prepare the mountain for siege? You will get there the fastest.”

Looking grim, Bard nodded and left, closely followed by Percy.

“We should go, too,” Balin said. “They’ll need our help with the bridge.”

Thorin nodded his agreement, but made no move to leave. Instead, he steeled himself, thinking of his sister-sons who could befriend and negotiate with elves in peace, and then he turned his attention to those still in the tent. To Legolas, who stood empty-handed and watching his father with worry—what he had done with the White Gems, Thorin had no idea, but the chest that held them was nowhere to be seen. And to Thranduil, who may as well have been a statue with how still he stood, silvery eyes far away. He imagined Bilbo’s voice in his head, urging him to stay steady.

And then he spoke.

“King Thranduil.”

The elf stirred, then came back to himself and turned his eyes on Thorin, but said nothing.

“This city is too exposed. Your people will not be safe here. Ally with us and take refuge in the mountain, before it is too late and you are cut off.”

Thranduil sneered, but it was far more subdued than usual. “And what is stopping me from taking my people and returning home? It is your kingdom under siege, not mine.”

“Ada!” Legolas cried admonishingly, but he was ignored.

Anger rolled inside Thorin at the thought of this immortal king once again turning his back on the dwarves and men of these lands and abandoning them to destruction. He hated Thranduil, and he was sure that would never change, no matter what alliances were reforged or how many long years passed. It was a hurt that ran too deep to truly ever heal. But Thorin looked deep into Thranduil’s eyes and his anger cooled slightly, for the fear he found in them was all too familiar to him.

“Once they have taken Erebor, the orcs’ eyes will turn to the Greenwood, and there will be no one near enough to aid you. We must fight together, or we will die alone.”

A long, taut silence stretched between them, until Thranduil finally looked away.

The elf king turned to his brown-haired captain who stood silently in the corner. “Give the order. We move to Erebor.”

 

***

 

They left Dale to make the trek across the valley soon after, and the wizard walked with them for a while. A good amount of time passed before any of them spoke. Thorin was too preoccupied considering all the possible outcomes of the coming days, taking stock of what few advantages they had and trying to anticipate what disadvantages they may face and how he might avoid them. But it was difficult. Even if nothing at all had changed since he first fought this battle, things would still be greatly unpredictable. He couldn’t fathom what changes he and Bilbo could have possibly wrought in this time-line for the battle to begin more than a week early.

He could only hope they would withstand the onslaught.

Thorin glanced to the side and up at Gandalf. The old man didn’t look to be a very formidable opponent at the moment, and not at all the intimidating figure Thorin knew he could be. He just looked, well, old. But the wizard was not their only ally in this. 

“What of the Eagles, Tharkûn?” 

“Landroval returns to the Eyrie as we speak. He brings news of the orc armies to Lord Gwaihir, and there is little that the Eagles hate more than orcs. They will come.” He trailed off, then sighed. “Yes, they will come, but I don’t expect they will arrive any sooner than Dáin.” 

Thorin nodded. That, at least, was some good news.

From the corner of his eye, he saw the wizard stumble. “Are you well?”

Gandalf grunted. “Well enough. But I think I’ll sit and rest a while. If you see Bilbo, tell him I wish to speak to him when I get there.”

So they left him behind and picked up their pace, hurrying to the mountain. There were many preparations to be made, and little time to do it all.

None of them spoke again until they came close enough to make out the figures outside the front gate, and Dwalin growled.

“He’s with that damn elf again.”

Indeed, Kili was on the ground, and sitting cross-legged beside him was an ever more familiar red-haired elf. 

Thorin despaired at the sight of her, wishing that Kili’s heart could have chosen literally anybody else. He did not, however, despair at the roar of laughter that burst from both his sister-sons in response to something the elf said.

He shook his head. “Ignore it.”

“But—”

“Not now, Dwalin,” Thorin snapped, and he could practically feel the surprised looks that reaction gained him. He sighed and stopped walking, then turned to face his two oldest friends. “When this battle is over and we have secured the mountain, I will talk to Kili. Until then, I will say no more on the matter. And neither will you.”

He glanced between Balin and Dwalin, meeting their taken aback expressions with narrowed eyes, silently demanding their agreement. Now was not the time to go picking fights with their own, and any misgivings they might have could be dealt with later.

After a short stare-off, Dwalin shrugged. “Yeah, fine. He’s not my sister-son.”

Balin nodded, too, though the look on his face was strange.

With time and patience running low, Thorin elected to ignore it.

He turned on his heel and continued his march to the gate, noting that the elf was nowhere to be seen and his sister-sons’ laughter had ended. Now on their feet, they quietly watched his approach. Kili fidgeted nervously under his gaze, but his brother remained still and calm, with the dragon-tooth hilt of Orcrist peeking over his shoulder.

Thorin came to a stop before his heir, narrowing his eyes and growling. “Fili.”

“Uncle.”

Fili held his head high and met his accusing glare, unflinching.

“What is this about you dealing with elves?”

“Someone had to do it.”

The words were said with full confidence, in the same tone he had always used as a dwarfling when he was caught doing something he shouldn’t. Fili had never been in the habit of denying true accusations brought against him.

It was both an admirable quality, and one that had given Thorin more than a few grey hairs over the years.

“It was not your place—”

Fili’s eyes and voice hardened. “Am I to be Crown Prince of Erebor or not?”

“You went behind my back,” Thorin ground out.

“I negotiated with the prince of a neighboring kingdom to resolve a small issue, so that our kings might turn their focus to the war nearly on our doorstep. Be as angry as you like, Thorin. I won’t apologize for it.”

It was an echo of the elf prince’s earlier words, but from Fili, it was just as much a challenge as it was an explanation—a challenge which, infuriatingly, Thorin wasn’t sure he could meet. For what was there to say? If Fili—and Kili, who no doubt had a hand in this as well—had not dealt with Legolas, then he very well may still be back in that tent, arguing over the Gems rather than preparing for the impending siege. And he was right that as Crown Prince, there would be times when he would have to make decisions and take action without first consulting Thorin, and he would just have to trust that his heir was competent and capable enough to fulfill that role. 

He knew it, but Mahal, he did not like it. Not for lack of confidence in Fili’s judgement, but because it made him feel old. He remembered bouncing a golden-haired babe on his knee like it was yesterday. Yet here he was, going toe-to-toe with a grown dwarf, that babe gone in all but memory.

Thorin stared, unsure if he wanted to laugh or yell or cry or skip all those steps and jump to immediately ripping all his hair out.

Fili stared back.

They could have gone on that way until the remaking of the world, if not for the hobbit who appeared at Thorin’s side seemingly from nowhere and broke the tense silence.

“Look at it this way, dear,” Bilbo said cheerfully. “At least it wasn’t the Arkenstone.”

Somebody—Dwalin, maybe—choked, and Thorin scowled at his hobbit, though there was no real heat behind it.

Bilbo grinned wider.

Thorin buried the urge to groan in frustration and just waved a hand at his unruly sister-sons. “Did you know about this?”

“I didn’t have the faintest clue. And I, for one, couldn’t be prouder.”

Fili and Kili both brightened at that, matching Bilbo’s grin with their own. 

Knowing he was outmatched, he finally relented with a shake of his head and a snort. “You would be, Burglar.”

Despite his lingering irritation, Thorin did feel warm pride in his chest, and he dipped his head to Fili, who sent him an easy smile in return and unslung Orcrist from his back.

“I think you’re going to need this, Uncle.”

The familiar weight of the sword eased some of the tension in him. And though he knew it was ridiculous to be so attached to any single blade—an elvish one, no less—it was a comfort to have, regardless. Orcrist had been at his side at the end of his last journey, and it felt right that it would be there once more, though hopefully this end would prove to be a better one.

“Thorin?”

He turned his attention back to Bilbo to find that his One’s good humor had gone, replaced with an anxious look. And he wasn’t the only one. Bofur, Bombur, and Ori had come outside and were crossing the bridge to join them, all with near identical expressions to the hobbit.

“What happened? Bard says that Gandalf showed up with news that Azog is nearly here. What are we going to do? The orcs aren’t supposed to be here yet! What—”

“Peace, Bilbo. We knew this was a possibility.” Thorin said, and did his best to look and sound as certain as he could. “It is not ideal, but war never is. If we must withstand a siege, there is no place better to do so than Erebor. We need only to hold the mountain for a few days until Dáin arrives, and the Eagles should not be far behind. We are not without allies in this.”

The words were meant for himself just as much as they were for his friends who looked to him now for reassurance. For their sakes, he had to believe they would make it through this. 

“And the elves?” Bilbo asked hesitantly. “We can’t win this battle without their help. If they leave—”

Dwalin snorted loudly. “I wouldn’t worry about that, lad. The elves aren’t going anywhere.”

“But surely they can’t stay in Dale. It’s too dangerous. They’ll be slaughtered.”

Thorin grimaced. “Not in Dale.”

“What do you mean? Where else will they go?” Kili asked.

Before he could answer, Dwalin cut him off. “Thorin invited the tree-shaggers to a slumber party.”

Dori, who reached them just in time to hear that declaration, stopped in his tracks and spluttered. “Excuse me, what?” 

Everyone ignored him in favor of voicing their own surprise and looking to Thorin for an explanation.

He glared at Dwalin, who just smirked in response, then spoke stiffly. “I offered them sanctuary in Erebor and secured a temporary alliance. They will fight with us.”

The words tasted bitter on his tongue, but they were worth it, to see Bilbo’s face light up like a child’s on Yule.

Fili moved to stand by the hobbit and elbowed him, grinning. “See? I told you he’d be fine without your supervision.”

But Bilbo didn’t seem to hear him. He just looked at Thorin with wide, hopeful eyes. “Truly?” 

“It was necessary,” Thorin said begrudgingly, unsure if he should be offended that Bilbo had clearly been doubting him.

He didn’t have time to decide because between one breath and the next, he found himself with an armful of hobbit and then he was being soundly kissed, right there for all to see. He only distantly noticed the sound of Kili gagging and the teasing remarks and laughter around them, and could only grin into the kiss when Bilbo threw a very rude and particularly dwarvish hand gesture at their audience without so much as looking at any of them. 

Yes, it was definitely worth it.

 

***

 

Later, standing atop the battlement wall, Thorin watched Thranduil’s army slowly file through the small excavated doorway into the mountain and was silently grateful his father and grandfather were not there to see it. For his own hatred of elves was naught but a pebble in comparison to the mountain of sheer loathing that they had borne.
 
So great was Thrór’s fury at Mirkwood’s betrayal in the years after the dragon, he had declared that any dwarf still loyal to him was obligated to take vengeance on his behalf upon any elf they crossed paths with. Most, of course, were too busy ensuring they had clothes on their backs and food in their children’s mouths to heed such an extreme ruling. There were those few, however, who had lost too much and had nothing left to them but their anger, and their actions cast all dwarves in a terrible, violent light that made it ever harder for anyone to find work and sympathy from the various people’s of Middle Earth.
 
Had Thrór still been alive today, he would execute Thorin for allying Erebor with Thranduil once again, no matter how dire the circumstances. And then he would execute Fili and Kili, then the rest of the Company for good measure. There would be no mercy in his wrath, not even for his own kin.
 
As for his father, well.
 
Thráin would be unlikely to resort to such violence, but his grief ran deep and he had come to blame Thranduil personally for the death of his beloved Frís. He would take Thorin’s braids and beard and cast him out for the decision he made today. Death would be the kinder punishment.
 
But Thrór was dead and Thráin long gone, and Thorin would not face either of their judgement until he entered the Maker’s Halls.
 
The judgement of his people, however, was another matter entirely.
 
Many would condemn his actions, and it would no doubt have long-lasting consequences that would make his life very difficult indeed, should he live long enough to face them.
 
It was these dark thoughts he was pulled from when he heard boots coming up the steps behind him and someone came to stand by his side.
 
“Elves in Erebor once more. I never thought I’d see the day.”
 
The words were free of both reproach and approval, spoken blandly, as one might comment on the weather. But Thorin felt the underlying weight beneath them, and he braced a hand against the wall, hoping the stone might help anchor him.
 
“There was no other way.”
 
And, Mahal, he prayed that was true. If there was any other option that would not lead to everyone’s demise, he could not see it, no matter how many long nights on this journey he’d lain awake, turning the problem over and over in his mind, searching for an option that did not include betraying his people. 
 
He hoped someday they would forgive him for it.
 
“You have been my King since the day you lead us to victory at Azanulbizar, and have been my friend for far longer than that.” Balin stared down at the elves for several long moments before turning to him, and he once again wore that same strange expression from earlier. “Yet if I did not already know your story, I would not have recognized you today. You have changed, Thorin.” 
 
A boulder dropped in Thorin’s stomach, pushing the air from his lungs, and he remembered another day much like this one, when he’d stood in this exact spot and heard those words spoken to him.
 
It was not a good memory.
 
“Balin,” he said, unable to help the pleading edge in his voice. Though what he was asking for, he did not know.
 
Reassurance? Disapproval?
 
Both possibilities seemed just as painful.
 
Somehow, the opinion of this one dwarf mattered more than all others. Condemnation from him now would hurt more than anything his father or grandfather could ever have done. For Thrór had been mad with gold-lust, and Thráin mad with grief, and their words and actions would have been a result of unstable minds. But Balin… he was the most level-headed person Thorin had ever known, always the voice of reason in times of doubt. Always the one to speak truth.
 
In this, he feared what that truth would be, yet needed to hear it all the same. Even if it was too late to take back what he’d done.
 
“You know I will follow you, no matter the path you choose,” Balin said.
 
He did know. Balin’s loyalty was absolute and unbending, no matter if Thorin deserved it. But loyalty and approval were not the same. 
 
“But is this path the wrong one?” 
 
“That, I cannot tell you.” 
 
Thorin looked away with a clenched jaw, gaze turning to the elves once again. Even with the sun blocked out by dark clouds, their armor still seemed to gleam, and every movement was filled with a grace that normally served only to infuriate him. Now, he had to remind himself that it was a sign of each warrior’s skill, of which everyone in this mountain would soon depend on as they waited for the dwarves of the Iron Hills to arrive.
 
Without the elves, they’d all be slaughtered before sunrise the next morning.
 
“What I do know is that I have never been more certain than I am now that you will be the greatest king on Erebor’s throne since Thráin I built these halls.”
 
It took a moment for him to process what Balin had said, and then his head whipped around so fast, his neck cracked.
 
“You…what?” he said dumbly.
 
“A king’s pride is not worth much if it comes at the expense of his kingdom.” The conviction in Balin’s voice was staggering, leaving no room for doubt. “It is a lesson that many fail to learn during their reign.”
 
Thorin stared at him and Balin stared back. Whatever he’d been expecting him to say, it wasn’t this. If he didn’t know this dwarf as well as he did, he would think it an exaggeration. But Balin was not one to make such statements lightly.
 
Eventually, Thorin swallowed thickly, clearing his throat. “And you think I have learned it?”
 
“You tell me.” Balin shot a pointed glance at the elves below them. Then he smiled. “Just do me a favor, laddie.”
 
“Anything.”
 
“Don’t you dare die before I get to see you crowned. I have waited far too long for this just to see Dáin on the throne. My heart couldn’t take it.”
 
Despite still reeling a bit at this turn in conversation, Thorin barked a laugh at the genuine trepidation in Balin’s expression, then reached out to grasp his shoulder. “I promise you, I will do everything in my power to live, so long as you swear to do the same so that you will be there to crown me.”
 
“Me? But I’m—”
 
“My oldest friend and most steadfast advisor, whom without I never would have come this far. Who else, if not you?”
 
Balin looked incredulous. “What about Dís? That role should go to her.”
 
“It is my right to choose whom I will as my officiant. Dís will agree with my decision.”
 
Balin just shook his head, seemingly speechless.
 
Undeterred, Thorin went on. “Do you remember what you said to me, that night in Bag End? You told me that I have built a good life for us in Ered Luin, and that I have done honorably by our people. But I could not have done half as much if I did not have you to guide me.”
 
“Thorin—”
 
“You deserve just as much credit, if not more, for the survival of our people.” There were tears shining in Balin’s eyes and Thorin grasped his other shoulder, then pulled him closer, pressing their foreheads together. “I will kneel to no dwarf but you, Bahirdannûn. Will you do this for me?”
 
Balin’s tears fell and he released a shuddering breath. “You honor me, Uzbadê.”
 
Despite all the dangers ahead of them, despite the two orc armies converging on the mountain, despite the elves marching into his kingdom, Thorin smiled.
 
“I can give no greater thanks for all you have done for myself and our people. The honor is mine.”

Notes:

Bahirdannûn - wise guide-man
(This is Balin's inner name)

Uzbadê - my king

 

When I get to the sequel, I'll explain this concept more, but my headcanon is that in dwarvish culture, being chosen to officiate a coronation when you're not an immediate blood relative (like a parent or sibling) to the one being crowned is a high honor and a sign of extreme respect for the officiant.
ALSO, my headcanon is that Balin gave Thorin his inner name a long time ago as a way to swear fealty/declare his loyalty.

Chapter 30: Mountain Under Siege

Notes:

Hi! Writing is hard and these last few chapters are kicking my ass. I finished writing this one ten minutes ago and if I don't post it right now immediately, I'm going to continue staring at it and second guessing myself until the sun implodes. I'm not completely satisfied with it. It's not at all what I originally intended this chapter to be. There's far too much silliness and too little plot. But I'm happy enough. There's probably a few errors I've missed, but I'm not letting myself edit too closely. If there are mistakes, let me know, and I'm sure I'll go back through to fix them later.

To everyone who has left comments in the last several months: thank you. Thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou. I know I don't reply often, but I love and appreciate every single one of you.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Deeper in the halls of Erebor, the crash of boulders slamming into the mountain-side was reduced to a low rumble, like thunder of a distant, angry storm.

Bilbo was glad for it, as he’d barely had a quiet moment to think these past couple days, ever since Azog’s horde burst out of the hillside and lay siege to the mountain. Having tunneled their way into the valley, the orcs unfortunately had no lack of stone to load into their troll-powered war machines, so the barrage rarely ceased. Only when the clouds deigned to thin enough to threaten sunlight and the orcs and trolls were forced back into their nasty tunnels did the current residents of the dwarven kingdom get any measure of peace.

Peace being a relative term, given that very few of those residents were, in truth, dwarves. It seemed that even circumstances such as these were not enough to convince dwarves, men, and elves to set their differences aside long enough to quit their squabbling.

Bilbo kept his nose out of it, mostly. For what business did a hobbit have in a council for war? Even a hobbit so well-traveled as he, who had seen far more violence and battle than his kind had any business witnessing or, indeed, participating in. In any case, his own experience paled in the face of immortal kings and warriors of legend, so he figured that if they turned to him for advice, then they were all in far worse trouble than he thought.

That was what he told himself, anyway.

Really, he just didn’t have the patience for all that shouting. It was likely, at least in part, due to his lack of sleep, of which he’d gotten very little in recent days.

For some unfathomable reason, he found it difficult to rest comfortably with all that noise threatening to deafen him before old age had the chance to do it.

Bilbo had just given up on an attempt at a nap and was leaving the guardhouse when Gandalf approached him and invited him on a walk. Figuring it was as good a way as any to avoid another sneak-attack training session courtesy of Dwalin—honestly, that dwarf was relentless—Bilbo eagerly agreed. So now they were here, slowly wandering further and further from the chaos of the entry hall, where the loudest sounds were their own breathing and the tapping of the wizard’s staff on the stone floor.

It wasn’t the same staff he had carried when they parted at the edge of Mirkwood.

Which wasn’t a great sign, all things considered.

“So,” Bilbo said casually, though he took care to keep his voice down. “Did you learn anything useful on your…detour?”

“It was…illuminating. I found something there I did not expect.” After a few moments of unsettled quiet, Gandalf shook his head. “And there were also things I did expect.” He glanced down at Bilbo. “I must thank you, my friend, for your warning. I fear I would have been woefully unprepared for what happened otherwise.”

Given the state Gandalf had been in when he arrived at the mountain, bloodied and limping, Bilbo wasn’t convinced his warning had helped much at all. Especially not if there was any truth to the things the Ring had shown him of recent events in Dol Guldur.

“What did happen, Gandalf? I saw…” He swallowed. As much as he wanted to know, he wasn’t ready to talk about the Ring. Not yet. “I saw the light in the sky. I saw him flee to the East.”

East. To Mordor.

Bilbo didn’t dare speak the name aloud, fearing it would wake the Ring from whatever dormant state it seemed to have fallen into. Or maybe it was just sulking. Either way, he was wary of saying anything that might draw its attention.

“Now is not the time for the full recount of my…adventures. I fear it must wait.”

Perhaps that was for the best, even if Bilbo felt impatient. After all, he was keenly aware of the danger of eavesdropping ears. It wouldn’t do to have somebody who wasn’t meant to hear them speak of it. He’d learned his lesson from what happened with Nori.

So Bilbo nodded his agreement.

They fell quiet again for a time, and when Gandalf spoke again, he turned to a far lighter subject. “I suppose some congratulations are in order.”

Despite the exhaustion carved into his face, Gandalf’s eyes twinkled and the smile he sent Bilbo’s way was genuine.

Bilbo’s brows furrowed, and he was confused until his old friend very pointedly looked at his hair—at the braid and bead woven into it. He felt himself flush and he wasn’t sure if he wanted to tuck the braid back behind his ear or show it off proudly. The weight of it was still a novelty to him.

Face warm, Bilbo cleared his throat. “Ah. Yes. Thank you.”

“I’m happy for you. Truly. I admit, I was beginning to wonder…”

Gandalf trailed off and Bilbo wasn’t sure he wanted to know what he had meant to say. It was already embarrassing enough that the entire Company was apparently betting on his infatuation with Thorin since before the Misty Mountains. He didn’t think he wanted to know just how long the wizard had been thinking about his love life as well. So he interrupted before the old meddler could decide whether or not to finish the thought.

“Where are we going, Gandalf?”

“I thought you might take me to see the dragon.”

Oh. That was worse, actually.

Bilbo had yet to return to the Gallery of Kings where Smaug’s corpse lay, and he had no desire to do so any time soon. If he never laid eyes on the dragon again, dead or not, it would be too soon.

“Must you?” he asked, expression twisting with distaste.

“Certainly. After that wonderful tale of the Company’s triumph, how could I not?”

It was inevitable, really. For all that being trapped inside a besieged mountain was terrifying, there was very little they could do but sit and wait, and all that sitting and waiting very quickly turned to boredom. From there, it didn’t take long for the Company to realize they had a (quite literally) captive audience at their disposal, and had begun giving dramatic re-tellings of how thirteen dwarves and a hobbit defeated Smaug the Terrible to anyone who would listen. The story, of course, became grander and more embellished every time they told it.

The virtues of dwarves are many, but humility is not often one of them.

At the very least, the members of his ragtag family all had the good sense to omit some details—namely how Bilbo had stopped running from an angry dragon to kiss their King. (He had little hope that good sense would last once they had a proper audience—that is to say, an audience of dwarves rather than elves and men.)

Gandalf was watching him expectantly, and Bilbo sighed. “Fine.”

It’s better than fighting Dwalin again, he reminded himself. At least taking Gandalf sight-seeing wouldn’t require the use of his perpetually aching muscles too much.

When this was all over, he was going to sleep for a week.

They reached the Gallery a few minutes later, and Bilbo hovered anxiously near the entrance as Gandalf approached the gigantic corpse without any hesitation. He got so close as to actually touch the horrible thing, and prodded Smaug’s snout with the butt of his staff.

Even knowing the dragon was well and truly dead, Bilbo couldn’t help but cringe.

“What exactly are you looking for?”

Maybe the wizard was checking for any sign of some foul magic lingering around the body, making sure there were no curses or other nasty things that needed dealing with.

But Gandalf shrugged.

“Nothing in particular.” He circled the dragon’s head to peer at one of his splayed wings, musing aloud. “Shame. I would have liked to be here to see this fellow before his death. He truly is magnificent, terrible as he may be. But needs must, I suppose.”

Bilbo spluttered and moved several steps further into the room. “Why in Yavanna’s name would you want to see him when he was alive?”

His memories of running from a live dragon were still too vivid for his liking—the heart-rending terror and the searing flames that nipped at his heels and the monstrous roaring that still echoed in his ears even a week later. So he couldn’t help but groan in horror as Gandalf practically stuck his head inside Smaug’s gaping maw to tap at a giant fang that was nearly as tall as the wizard himself.

Gandalf seemed utterly unaware of Bilbo’s upset because he responded in a tone that was far too casual. “I have never seen one. After all my many years, it’s not often I come across something entirely new to me, you know.”

“What?” His shout echoed disconcertingly in the large space and Bilbo immediately quieted his voice. “What do you mean you’ve never seen one?”

“They aren’t especially common creatures in this world,” Gandalf pointed out and lit the end of his staff, presumably in an attempt to see further down Smaug’s throat.

“But…never?”

Surely that couldn’t be true. He tried to search his memories, desperately trying to find anything from this life or the last to suggest that the wizard had indeed faced a dragon before. There was nothing.

“My dear Bilbo, surely you didn’t think as young Kili did that as a wizard, I must have fought hundreds of dragons in my time, did you?” Gandalf chuckled, as if such an idea was utterly preposterous. Then he stepped up onto Smaug’s lower lip and leaned forward, bracing a hand against the lolling tongue. “I was rather looking forward to witnessing a dragon at least once in my time here on Arda.”

He actually sounded regretful.

Bilbo let out a strangled noise and scampered forwards to grab onto Gandalf’s boot, nearly gagging at the sulphuric stench invading his nostrils. As he stood there, tugging insistently on his oldest friend’s leg in a desperate attempt to stop him from climbing even further into a dead dragon’s mouth, he had a terrible thought. “Gandalf! Please tell me you didn’t arrange this quest in the hopes you’d get to see a dragon.”

The wizard paused, then thankfully gave up on his exploration to turn and face him, looking down at Bilbo with an indignant expression. “Bilbo Baggins, I would expect you to know full well why I arranged this journey, and my desire to set eyes on a live dragon had nothing to do with it.”

The reminder of what was to come in the future was sobering, and Bilbo’s bafflement ebbed away. Of course, how could he forget? World ending war and all that.

Noticing the shift in his mood, Gandalf stepped down from his perch and returned to the stone floor. He smiled, and there was something teasing about it. “Though, I will admit the thought may have crossed my mind. Once.”

Ridiculous. Utterly and completely ridiculous. Then again, if he wasn’t, Bilbo wouldn’t like him near as much.

Bilbo snorted and shook his head. “You unbelievable old coot. Have you gotten enough of an eyeful of that beast yet? Looking at him makes me itch.”

 

***

 

When Bilbo returned to the entry hall later, the orcs outside were still hurling their boulders, acting like a bunch of naughty tweens throwing stolen eggs at the broad side of a barn. And, honestly, didn’t the monstrous things ever get tired? Surely there had to be something more interesting to do with their lives. Do orcs even have hobbies, beyond murder and war? Perhaps if they took all that energy and put it into something like pottery or sculpture art or whatever else, they could settle down for once and stop making everyone else’s lives miserable. If only their mothers did a better job teaching them manners…assuming orcs have mothers. Were there orc women? He’d never heard of such a thing. But if not, where did they even come from? What—  

As soon as he realized what he was doing, Bilbo stopped the train of thought with a disbelieving snort. That was exactly how he knew he was in desperate need of a nap.

But first, a snack.

And he should probably also check to make sure no kingly dunderheads had managed to kill each other in his absence.

Except, now that he thought about it, there was a suspicious lack of shouting coming from the War Tent (which was a frankly uninspired and boring name, not that anyone had bothered asking his opinion on it), and when he peeked his head inside, he found it empty. The guardhouse, too, was strangely silent when he went to check. 

With no sign of the Company anywhere among the scattered groups of elves and men gathered in the entry hall, Bilbo forgot the things he’d meant to do and instead went to search for his wayward dwarves.

It didn’t take long to find them, though they weren’t where he expected.

The large hall where the Lake-town survivors made their camp had once been something of a marketplace. Not far from the front gates, it was a place where dwarvish craftsmen could sell their wares to outsiders without having to venture to Dale to do it—and without allowing those outsiders to venture deeper into the mountain than necessary. 

Bilbo meant to pass by and continue on to the armory, but altered his course and instead entered the room across the corridor from the camp when he heard the unmistakable timbre of dwarvish voices mixed with the chatter of excited children. He was confused for all of three seconds, then the confusion was quickly replaced with warm fondness as he did a headcount of the Company.

His eyes were drawn first to Thorin, who was closest to the doorway. He had Balin, Gloin, and Oin with him, and the four dwarves were talking to Bard and his advisors. Bilbo was glad to see that there didn’t seem to be any argument happening, though they all carried a tenseness to them the he supposed could only be expected, given the circumstances. Beyond them, the rest of the Company looked more relaxed, or were putting on a good show of it for the sake of the young ones that surrounded them.

Bofur and Bifur sat on the floor with a enraptured audience around them, and Bofur was enthusiastically telling some story that Bilbo hoped was age appropriate, given that he recognized little Tilda sitting front and center with wide eyes and he was sure Bard wouldn’t appreciate anything too scary. In all the noise, he thought he heard the words “giant bear” and “beehives” so he was sure it was probably fine.

Nori sat nearby with three young boys and looked to be playing some sort of game that involved dice and a pile of pebbles on the floor between them, and he was sure that whatever that rascal was teaching them wasn’t age appropriate at all. But the boys were laughing, and Nori had a grin on his face.

He spotted Ori sitting with a woman who had gray-streaked hair, and the two seemed M deep in conversation, even as they focused on their knitting. Dori wasn’t far from his youngest brother, and he too was chatting with a group of women who all had needles and thread in hand. Bombur was in the same group, but resting comfortably on his big belly, cradled in the crook of his elbow, was a small bundle that looked suspiciously like a baby. Bilbo could only guess that the woman sitting right beside the rotund dwarf was its mother.

In the far corner of the room, a very tall red-headed figure sat cross-legged on the floor, and though she wasn’t one of his dwarves, Bilbo took note of her all the same. Tauriel looked equal parts bewildered and delighted to be surrounded by a gaggle of little girls—and a few little boys—all cooing over her hair and talking over each other. She seemed incredibly unsure how to act with them all, and Bilbo wondered if she’d ever even met a child before, of her own race or otherwise, given how rare elvish children were nowadays. Still, she seemed to be handling it alright, allowing the girls to place messy and uneven braids in her hair without complaint.

The most boisterous children were, unsurprisingly, chasing Fili and Kili around in what looked like a rather epic game of capture-the-dwarf. Both of the dwarf princes had at least one child attached to their person, either riding on their backs or wrapped around their legs, trying to trip them up. Still, they were holding their own against their small attackers. Or, they were, right up until the moment laughter like a clear bell joined the sounds of the room and Kili’s head whipped around to look at Tauriel.

The distraction cost him, and he disappeared, barely visible under the pile of children on top of him. Fili, doubled over with laughter, didn’t seem too inclined to listen to his brother’s muffled pleas for aid.

In the very center of the room was a small group that appeared older than the rest, and Bilbo recognized two of them as Bard’s other children. They stood in a loose ring, watching two lone figures in the middle circle each other with wooden sticks in hand.

Bilbo really had no hope at guessing the ages of children of men with any true accuracy, but if he were to guess, he’d say the scrappy thing currently facing off against Dwalin was somewhere around Bain’s age, and certainly couldn’t be as old as Sigrid. Not that that truly meant very much to him.

The girl was about the same height as her opponent, but scrawny and small, all gangly limbs and graceless. What she lacked in skill, she made up for with sheer enthusiasm, and did her best to heed every instruction that was barked at her. She looked far too thrilled to be sparring with a grizzled dwarf warrior, and the sharp, half-feral grin on her face was frighteningly similar to the one that Dwalin himself wore.  

Despite her age and the fact that she was human and not a thick-skinned dwarfling, Dwalin wasn’t going particularly easy on her, and Bilbo cringed when her feet were swept out from under her and she hit the ground hard. But the girl let out a mad cackle and bounced up again, swinging her stick in gleeful retaliation. She seemed entirely unbothered by the fact that she missed.

“Goodness,” Bilbo said to himself, watching in disturbed fascination.

“Don’t fret. My Astrid never stays down long, and the dwarf seems to know how much to push. He didn’t go nearly as hard on the others.”

He jumped and tore his eyes away from the sparring match to look to his right, where a brown-haired woman stood with her arms crossed over her chest. Her features were a mirror to the girl’s, just matured and lacking the awkwardness of youth. Though her face was gaunt and gray with exhaustion, her eyes were sharp and she watched the fighting pair like a hawk.

“Dwalin has trained nearly every child in the Blue Mountains. He knows their limits.” The girl, Astrid, fell again and received a harsh correction on her stance for her trouble. Undeterred, she scrambled up to try again. Bilbo winced. “He won’t give her more than she can handle, but she’ll probably have a few more bruises than she started with.”

The girl was clearly a willing victim to Dwalin’s teaching methods, and if the great brute was distracted training the young ones to defend themselves, perhaps he’d finally give Bilbo a break and his own bruises would get the chance to fade.

The woman hummed. “Few of us ever met a dwarf before now. All we had were stories. They’re…not what I expected.”

“Dwarves can be obstinate, and jealous, and dreadfully prideful. That much is true. But they’re also brave, and compassionate, and kind. The stories tend to forget that part.”

“I’m glad for it. We were running out of ways to distract the children when the two princes showed up and started a game. The others followed soon after. It’s helping.” Finally, the woman looked away from her daughter to give Bilbo a tired smile. “I’m Olga.”

“Bilbo Baggins, at your service. It’s a pleasure to meet you, though I’m sorry it’s under such awful circumstances.”

“We are alive, we have shelter for the winter, and my daughter is laughing. Things are far better than they could be.”

Sparing a moment to look over all his dwarves again—his silly, wonderful dwarves who took the time for games and stories to comfort frightened children while a siege raged outside—Bilbo returned her smile. “You’re right. We have much to be grateful for.”

They stood together quietly for another few minutes, just watching the comfortable chaos of the room.

It wasn’t long before Dwalin finally called a halt to his sparring match with Astrid. There was too much noise to hear what he said to her, but the dwarf clapped her on the shoulder and handed her the stick he’d been using.

Grinning ear to ear and looking immensely pleased, she spun on her heel, eyes falling to a familiar boy who went pale under her gaze. She threw the extra stick at him, and Bain caught it awkwardly. She didn’t wait for him to be ready. True to Dwalin’s method of teaching, she attacked Bain immediately and without mercy. Despite standing several inches taller than Astrid, the poor boy looked terrified as he desperately avoided her wildly swinging stick.

Both Bilbo and Olga chuckled, and he turned to say something to her, but was interrupted.

“Hobbit!”

Bilbo didn’t have to look to know that a certain pair of olive green eyes were boring into him, and he let out an embarrassing squeak of alarm. So much for getting a break.

“Excuse me!” he gasped to his new friend, then he fled.

 

***

 

“Bilbo!”

He jolted awake out of a dead sleep to the sound of a door slamming open and blinked groggily, foggy-brained and confused. He half sat up, but groaned when the movement pulled at his sore muscles and stiff joints and dropped again, then immediately regretted it when the his head hit the ground with a dull thud and he remembered that he was laying on a stone floor and apparently didn’t have the good sense to ball up his jacket as a pillow before losing consciousness.

He groaned again and lifted a hand to rub his face, but it was captured in a tight grip and then a dwarf was leaning over him. “What happened? Are you hurt? Should I get Oin?”

Blue eyes scanned him for injury and Bilbo sighed, amused and exasperated. “Calm down, you big lug. I was only sleeping.”

He managed to sit up fully this time, despite his body’s protests, and rolled his shoulders in a doomed attempt to ease the tension from them.

Thorin studied him for a few more moments until his worry eased, and was replaced by gruff irritation. “Strange place for a nap.”

“Yes, well, I didn’t actually intend to fall asleep when I came in here,” he grumbled.

There wasn’t much dust in the room, which was all that could be said for its comfort. Certainly, if sleep had been his goal, his bedroll would have been a better option. But the guardhouse was far too obvious for his needs, and anywhere less populated would have risked his allergies giving him away. So he’d ended up back here, in the room where only a few days earlier Thorin had braided a bead into his hair and declared him his One.

“The next time you decide to disappear, at least tell someone where you are going first.”

Bilbo climbed to his feet and continued stretching. “It wouldn’t be an effective hiding spot if I told someone I was there, dear.”

He reached one hand as high above his head as he could manage, trying to stretch out the stiffness in his muscles—the other hand was still trapped in Thorin’s grip, and the dwarf didn’t seem inclined to release it.

“Hiding from what?” Thorin asked, ignoring Bilbo’s attempt to tug free from him and remaining stubbornly on the floor.

“From that slave-driver you call a best friend.” Bilbo bent down to touch his toes and cringed at the way his spine cracked. “Obviously, I can’t trust any of you not to cave and tell him where I am if he asks.”

His dwarves were a brave bunch, no doubt about it, but few of them could stand the pressure of Dwalin’s glare for long—they’d turn traitor in an instant to avoid being put through their paces by him themselves—and the ones who could would still give up Bilbo’s location, either because they agreed that their hobbit needed all the training he could get or because they simply got too much enjoyment out of watching him suffer.

No, he wouldn’t stay hidden long enough for accidental naps if he told any of them where he was going.

“You know he means well.”

Thorin, of course, was one of those dwarves that would give Bilbo away on purpose because his sword fighting prowess wasn’t up to par.

“I don’t care what he means, everything aches and I’m tired.” And if he perhaps sounded a bit too much like a whining fauntling being coerced into doing his chores under the threat of no dessert, he didn’t quite care. Because he was tired and everything did hurt and a couple last minute training sessions before the battle would hardly be enough to turn him into a warrior.

“And did sleeping on the bare stone help with that?” Thorin asked, sounding more amused now than irritated.

Bilbo glared down at his dwarf and tried to beat back the smile creeping onto his face. “Hush, yo—”

His words turned into a yelp when Thorin used his captive hand to pull him down, and he fell none too gracefully into the dwarf’s lap. There was no time to protest before he was being smothered, with strong arms wrapped around him and his face pressed into Thorin’s chest. Before he could think to protest being man-handled, his senses were filled with the familiar scent of smoke and stone and he relaxed into the embrace.

This was far more comfortable than lying on the floor, even considering the hard belt buckle that was now digging into his hip, and he found himself rubbing his cheek against the soft fur of Thorin’s coat contentedly. If he could convince his dwarf to stay still for a while, perhaps he’d be able to sneak in another short nap.

But then Thorin spoke, his words muffled against the top of Bilbo’s head. “You were gone for hours.”

Oh.

He leaned away, just far enough that he could look up at Thorin’s face without straining his neck.

A slight smile still tugged at the dwarf’s mouth, but the tight lines around his eyes hinted at the stress he was under, and Bilbo felt a small twinge of guilt at adding to it, even if falling asleep had truly been an accident.

He reached up and cupped Thorin’s cheek, trying to smooth away the tension with his fingertips. “I’m sorry, love. I didn’t mean to worry you.”

Thorin’s sigh was long-suffering, and he gave a small shake of his head, beard rasping against Bilbo’s palm. “Between you, my sister-sons, the men, the elves, and the orcs, I’ll be completely gray by winter’s end.”

“Don’t forget the rest of the Company and Gandalf,” Bilbo added teasingly, even as he eyed the lighter hair around Thorin’s temples and tried to imagine the rest of that thick, raven-dark mane changing to match it. Then he sent him a cheeky grin. “That’s alright, though. I think you’ll look rather fetching in silver.”

“Flatterer,” Thorin accused, voice tender.

His face tilted down ever so slightly, so the tips of their noses brushed, and Bilbo’s heart did a happy little skip.

“I mean every word,” he vowed.

Then, just because he could, Bilbo reached up to bury his fingers in his dwarf’s lovely hair and pressed a light kiss to his lips.

What a wonderful world that would be, in which Thorin Oakenshield lived to grow old. It was a world Bilbo very much wanted to see, maybe more than he’d ever wanted anything else, and one way or another, he was going to make sure it happened.

 

***

 

Back in the entry hall, the never-ending racket was enough to set Bilbo’s teeth on edge. Boulders crashed against the front gates, and the mountain shook. Metal clashed on metal and echoed on the stone walls where the men of Lake-town trained, getting a feel for the dwarven weapons lent to them from the armory of Erebor. And someone up above on the mezzanine where Thranduil had placed his personal tent was getting the dressing-down of their life, if Gandalf’s bellowing was anything to go by. Bilbo couldn’t quite understand what the wizard was saying, and he wasn’t sure he wanted to.

At least he had his dwarves to distract him from the chaos of it all. Their noise was far more bearable to his ears than the rest, and they were still in mostly high spirits after their time spent with the Lake-town children earlier. Since the guardhouse was too small for them to do much more than sleep, they sat at the boots of a half-destroyed statue of a dwarf warrior, loosely gathered around a lit brazier they’d pilfered from an undamaged upper level of the ramparts. As it often happened with the Company, there were half a dozen different overlapping conversations happening all at once around the fire that somehow everybody was a part of.

They discussed the logistics of disposing of Smaug’s corpse—there was a general consensus that they should make use of whatever they could, and many were excited about the idea of dragon-scale armor and tools made of dragon bone.

“What about the meat?” Ori asked innocently. “Do you think we could eat it?”

It was a fair question, given the concern of how they’d make it through the winter.

That lead to Bombur speculating about how one would go about cooking dragon, despite protests that the meat was probably poisonous or cursed.

Balin vehemently insisted that eating the dragon that had feasted on the flesh of their own people would be unethical and Dwalin declared that it would be poetic justice. Whether the warrior actually wanted to eat the dragon or was just getting enjoyment out of working his brother into a tizzy was unclear.

While the Fundinul brothers shouted at each other, many of the others bemoaned the lack of fresh meat in their rations and hoped that Dain would be kind enough to donate some livestock to the winter stores.

“I could go hunting! There’s an elk around here somewhere, and it’s big enough we could get at least a couple good meals out of it.”

Kili’s suggestion was met with keen enthusiasm and Gloin loudly volunteered to join the hunting party. Plenty of ideas about where exactly they might find the beast were tossed around, since none of them had seen hide nor hair of the thing since the elves entered the mountain. Thorin’s theory that Thranduil kept his elk in a place of honor in his own tent was the most popular and elicited a bout of howling laughter all around.

It was Fili finally interrupted to point out that killing the Elf King’s mount and and roasting it over the fire would probably be considered an act of war. Kili just pouted at that and said his brother was no fun.

What followed were a lot of shared opinions about how dwarvish war rams were clearly the superior mount and how stupid it was to ride a fancy deer into battle.

“Doesn’t Dain ride a pig?” Bilbo asked wryly.

Apparently, the pig was a point of contention.

His question was followed by an outcry of bickering that grew louder and louder until Bifur finally shouted something in khuzdul that Bilbo couldn’t parse out.

Kili gasped and jumped to his feet, pointing at Bifur. “Slander! Pikelet the Eighth was a magnificent and fierce warrior! She died honorably!”

More shouting followed and, bemused, Bilbo leaned a little closer to Dori.

“The Eighth?”

Dori hummed in agreement. “Pikelet the First was a gift to Lord Dain from his father when he was just a pebble. Every new pig since has been a descendant of the First and is named in his honor. I believe his current mount is Pikelet the Eleventh. Best not bring it up while Dain is around, though. I’ve heard he talks about those pigs the same way Gloin talks about his wife.”

Bilbo laughed. “Noted.”

Dori snorted and almost said something else, but then his smile dropped and he aimed a baleful glare over Bilbo’s shoulder.

The glare and the whoosh of air behind him were the only hints Bilbo needed and he had the good sense to duck and avoid his head being separated from his shoulders. He scrambled away from the chunk of stone he’d been using as a chair, then rolled to his feet and drew Sting. Whirling on his attacker, he clumsily parried the next blow, the shockwaves of the hit traveling through his sword and up his arms, making his teeth chatter.

There was was something incredibly disturbing and nothing at all friendly about the sharp grin Dwalin wore on his grizzled face. “Good ears.”

“You horrible—” He yelped and stumbled back to avoid the next swipe of Dwalin’s axe. “Dori is going to murder you if you tear my vest! He just mended it!”

“He’s going to murder me anyway,” Dwalin responded, violently cheerful. “Pay attention to your footing, hobbit.”

He danced out of the dwarf’s reach and turned, briefly noting that the nearest men and elves were watching with various expressions of concern. A few were even fingering their own weapons, as though unsure if they should interfere and save the poor little halfling from the bloodthirsty dwarf attempting to fillet him. His dwarves, on the other hand, only cheered as Dwalin continued to advance on him, swinging his axe in dangerous arcs.

“You can do it, Bilbo!”

“Ibkhi' malkûn!”

“Duck!”

He ducked and felt his hair ruffle from the breeze in the axe’s wave.

“Go left!”

He sidestepped to his left and Dwalin had to divert his blow to avoid actually chopping Bilbo in half.

“No, your other left!”

Bilbo grit his teeth, feeling a bead of sweat slip down his spine. “If you lot actually cared about me, you’d come help!”

“Don’t be ridiculous, Bilbo! We’d gladly distract a raging dragon for you, but Dwalin? You’re on your own!” That was Bofur.

The rest of the Company laughed their agreement.

“You’re all horrible and I should have let the trolls eat you!”

“Three coins say Bilbo won’t last another minute if he keeps running his mouth!” Nori shouted.

With a scowl, Bilbo ducked again to avoid another blow and scooped a fist-sized piece of stone off the floor. It flew from his grasp and there was a dull thud followed by Nori’s yelp.

Dwalin cackled. “Nice throw!”

Horrible, awful, rude, incorrigible dwarves. He was going to tie their beards into great knots in their sleep and hide all their left boots in inconvenient places and trap them in a room and make them listen to elvish poetry for hours. He was going to find mushrooms and sneak them into Dwalin’s food. Once Erebor was repopulated, he was going to write a collection of all their most embarrassing moments on the quest and distribute it like the morning news.

“I hope you know I hate all of you!”

There was an offended gasp just as Bilbo tripped backwards and fell, flailing. He had no time to recover and all he could do was watch as the glinting blade of Dwalin’s axe came down on him, but then metal clanged and a sword blocked the blow.

Kili pouted down at Bilbo for a split second, then met another one of Dwalin’s swings. “Surely not all of us.”

Dwalin snarled a wordless threat at the interfering young prince and Bilbo clambered back to his feet, breathing heavily.

“Right you are, Kili,” he said earnestly, falling in at his savior’s side. “You’re by far my favorite dwarf and I love you the most.”

“Even more than Thorin?”

Dwalin’s axe swiped down between them and they sprang apart to avoid it.

“Absolutely.”

Kili grinned widely and swung his sword, but was blocked immediately. “I love you too, Bilbo! You’re my most favorite uncle!”

Somewhere behind them, Thorin spluttered indignantly and Kili’s grin turned smug.

Even between the two of them, they stood no real chance against Dwalin. Kili was an admirable fighter, but he was inexperienced and Dwalin had taught him everything he knew. And Bilbo was no warrior. The only thing they had going for them was that they were lighter on their feet and were decent at dodging. But Dwalin was deceptively fast and had far more endurance.

It didn’t last long, and all it took was one small distraction to end things.

A great flapping sound was the only warning they had before a cloud of feathers, beaks, and talons exploded into the mountain through the upper ramparts, and cries of alarm rang out across the entry hall.

Kili whipped around to see what was happening, just to get slapped in the face by a passing wing, then he went sprawling forward to the ground when Dwalin hit him in the back with the flat of his axe. A second later, Bilbo was swept off his feet. Sting clattered from his hand and he found himself flat on his back, wheezing for air with an axe blade hovering a few inches from his throat, effectively pinning him there.

Dwalin wasn’t even looking at him, instead focused on the ravens that circled over their heads, and Bilbo went limp with a defeated groan.

A single raven broke away from the flock, feathers sleek and what looked to be a string of rubies around its neck. It circled a few times, then angled its wings down an flew towards a golden head.

The bejeweled raven landed on Fili’s shoulder, and the entry hall went quiet, save for the continued flapping of wings above.

If he turned his head slightly, Bilbo was close enough to see the exchange when Fili faced Thorin.

“Uncle, this is Ära daughter of Roäc.”

The bird bowed as deeply as she could manage from her perch, and Thorin bowed his head back respectfully.

“Greetings, Ära. What news from the Ravens?”

They’d been in and out of the mountain for days, passing messages between Erebor and Dáin and acting as scouts, but it was only ever one or two at a time. This was the first time so many ravens had appeared at once, and it surely couldn’t be a good sign.

“Well met, Stone King,” Ära croaked. “The army from Gundabad has arrived, and the Defiler has taken Ravenhill. On behalf of my flock, I ask for sanctuary within Erebor.”

The news was met with a wave of murmurs and worried looks all around. The elves seemed unfazed by the talking bird in their midst, but the men sounded astonished and confused.

“Sanctuary will always be granted to you and your kin. But where is Roäc?”

Ära ruffled her feathers in a way that seemed exasperated. “My father is stubborn. He will not leave the Tower, even as he sends the rest of us away.”

“That is noble of him.”

If a bird could scoff, Ära did so. “Or stupid.”

A slight smile quirked on Thorin’s lips. “Quite so. Your flock is welcome to roost wherever you wish within the mountain. If you have any wounded, we will do what we can for them. Thank you for your warnings.”

After another bow, the raven spread her wings and took off from Fili’s shoulder, launching herself back into the air to rejoin her kin. There was some cawing and what must have been a conversation in the ravens’ own language, then the flock dispersed, finding roosts high along the walls of the entry hall.

After several moments, Bilbo cleared his throat expectantly and scowled when Dwalin looked down at him. “Do you mind?”

The dwarf smirked, but withdrew his axe and offered Bilbo a hand.

With an irritated huff, Bilbo allowed himself to be pulled to his feet and took stock of his body, finding a few new aches and pains—mostly in his tail-bone from his fall—but was otherwise uninjured.

“Was that really necessary?” he grumbled.

“It’s that or I lock you in a broom cupboard to wait out the battle,” Dwalin said.

Then he walked away without another word, headed for Thorin who was already talking with some of the others grimly. He shoved Kili on the way past and the young dwarf face-planted on the ground again with an indignant yell.

Bilbo stooped to pick up Sting, then went to Kili’s side. The prince sat cross-legged on the ground, grumbling petulantly under his breath and rubbing his reddened nose.

Amused despite his own lingering irritation, Bilbo reached out to smooth Kili’s messy hair. “Uncle?”

The grumbling stopped and Kili grinned and nodded, leaning into Bilbo’s touch. “You’re Thorin’s One, so that makes you our uncle, too. Fili and I agreed.” He paused, then looked a little sheepish. “If it’s alright with you?”

Bilbo looked down into Kili’s dark eyes and remembered a time, many decades ago, when a pair of light blue eyes looked up at him with that same tentative hope, after asking almost the same question.

It was just a few months after little Frodo came to stay with him in Bag End. They’d gotten off to an awkward start, both having agreed they wanted to try living together, yet neither quite knowing how to act. After nearly a year in Brandy Hall, surrounded by dozens of rowdy Brandybuck cousins, Frodo was used to being able to fade into the background and go unnoticed by the adults in his life. Bilbo, on the other hand, was so used to being alone, it was impossible not to notice the fauntling in his house, no matter how quiet and unobtrusive the boy was. He was still trying to find a healthy balance between ensuring Frodo’s needs were met and giving him space to breathe without being too overbearing.

That particular day, he was in the midst of an internal crisis. His young ward hadn’t spoken a single word to him in nearly a week, and Bilbo was half-convinced the boy hated him. He thought perhaps he was doing something wrong. Maybe Lobelia was right after all and he was the worst person to look after the poor thing.

Bilbo was in the middle of wondering if he should offer to take him back to the Brandybucks when Frodo appeared in the doorway of his study and called him Uncle Bilbo for the first time and asked if they could have lunch early because he was hungry.

“Uncle?” Bilbo had asked, stunned.

And the boy had shuffled nervously on his feet and looked up at him with big blue eyes and nodded. “Yeah. Is that okay?”

So Bilbo became an uncle, Frodo got a ham sandwich, and the adoption papers were signed the very next day.

The memory made his throat ache and his eyes sting.

Oh, how he missed his nephew.

He pushed the blue eyes to the back of his mind to focus on the brown ones in front of him instead. “Yes. I’d like that.”

“Great!” Kili jumped to his feet and smacked a loud kiss on Bilbo’s cheek before he could stop him. Then he scampered off with a wide grin. “I’ll tell Fili. Thanks, Uncle Bilbo!”

Bilbo watched him go and chuckled wetly, then started searching his pockets for a handkerchief.

Notes:

Fun fact: the pig they used in the movie to play Dain's mount was named Pikelet. (Apparently a "pikelet" is something like a miniature pancake). She was a special kind of New Zealand breed pig called a kunekune and Peter Jackson adopted her after filming was over.

My personal headcanon is that Dain LOVES his pigs. He trains them personally from their birth, and they're all descended from the first pig he ever had as a child. I kept the name Pikelet because I think it's cute and funny and why fix what's not broken? I think Dain likes to brag about the valiant deeds of his pigs and some of those tales have turned into bedtime stories for some of the dwarflings in the family--hence why Kili is so insistent that nobody insult Pikelet the Eighth, who was a regular character in his childhood bedtime stories.

(It's entirely irrelevant, but to anyone wondering, Pikelet the Eighth died during an orc hunt when she charged at an orc and ended up running full speed off a cliff...while Dain was riding her. Obviously, Dain survived the ordeal, and Pikelet the Eighth was buried in high honor lol)

Chapter 31: To Fix What Was Broken

Notes:

Hey, guys! This fic was supposed to be finished two months ago, but then the ao3 curse got me and things have been crazy. There was an unexpected death in the family, followed immediately by a weeklong family reunion up the mountain, and work stress, and worsening health problem. All those things together threw me off my groove and writing has been difficult. Especially considering I was in the middle of THIS chapter. (Have I mentioned how much I hate writing battles? Because I really really hate it. If the fighting feels weird and rushed, that's why. Sorry not sorry.)

Anyways, the good news is that this fic is (nearly) finished! Chapter 32 is already written and will be posted on Monday after I do a final round of edits. I'll also be giving some details about the sequels I plan to write, since the story is far from over even if the fic is done.

Also as a heads up, I'm going to make a slight change to the title of this fic in the next couple of days and it will now be called "To Fix What Was Broken" instead of "To Fix That Which Was Broken" and I'll also be changing my username from "ForgottenAngel15" to "hobbitoutoftime" -- I know that changing fic titles / names can mess with links and things, so I just wanted to give you a warning.

As always, thank you to everyone who has left comments since my last update. Knowing that other people are just as excited as I am about this story has helped motivate me to keep going, and I appreciate it.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The royal armory was accessed through a doorway at the far end of the main armory. It was a heptagonal room with pillars in the seven corners, intricately carved with tales of great battles and victory, and a vaulted ceiling plated with gold. Each wall bore the symbol of Durin—a hammer and anvil, crowned by seven stars—and was lined with armor stands and weapon racks. Some stands were empty, others bore the long lost armor of Ereborian royalty and high ranking lords. 

Placed in the very center of the room, atop a tiled likeness of the Arkenstone, was the golden armor of King Thrór. 

Thorin sat alone on a stone bench and stared at it, wondering if he could get away with melting it down and blaming it on the dragon.

He hated the sight of it. Hated that he could remember its weight encasing his body as he stalked his kingdom’s halls with a heart turned to greed. Hated the reminder of the monstrous deeds he committed while wearing it.

More than anything, he hated that dark corner of his mind that purred at the golden gleam of the lamplight reflecting off the chest-plate and whispered at him to put it on. 

It was, after all, his birthright. The armor may have been commissioned and worn by Thrór, but Thorin was King Under the Mountain now. Why should he not look the part? Why should he not charge onto the battlefield donning the legacy of his forefathers? Their line had been great, once, before madness and grief clouded their judgement. Thorin could return them to that greatness. Thorin could be better.

He benefited from experience and foresight his grandfather lacked during his rule. Thrór had no idea how it felt to lead his starving people across wastelands—what it was like to have nothing. Not until it was too late, anyway. But Thorin did know. And knowing meant that he could properly appreciate the vast wealth of his kingdom in a way the previous king never could. 

He could put the armor on. He could be the Golden King of Silver Fountains. He could do it right.

And then— 

“It looks just as tacky as I remember.”

Ignoring the heavy pounding of his heart, Thorin laughed shakily at the distaste in his hobbit’s expression as he gazed at Thrór’s armor and tried to pretend his wandering thoughts hadn’t been leading him somewhere dangerous. It was a wasted effort, if Bilbo’s knowing glance was any indication. 

Shame and revulsion threatened to bubble up inside him, but Thorin pushed it away. This was no time to start obsessing over all his past wrongs. 

As though to agree with him, Bilbo took his hand and squeezed it. “We need to go soon.”

Indeed, only a few hours ago, Arec returned with news of Dáin’s imminent arrival and sent the mountain into an uproar with final preparations before battle. The army from the Iron Hills would be here soon. They didn’t have long.

“I suppose there is no point in asking you to stay here.”

“Not on your life.” 

Thorin nodded once, having expected that answer. It was the same response he got from his sister-sons when he pulled them aside earlier and asked them to consider staying in the mountain. Still, he couldn’t be blamed for trying. 

His eyes strayed back to the golden armor and bitterness coated his tongue. “So many lives were lost.”

“That was then,” Bilbo said, not needing to ask what he meant. “Things are different now. We’ve done everything we can.”

It was true. Every precaution they could take, every safe guard they could put into place, they’d done it. 

The people of Lake-town were spared from the wrath of the dragon. The lake may have still burned at orc hands, but far more lived to see the sunrise. The survivors would not be slaughtered in Dale. They were as safe as they could possibly be within the walls of Erebor and escape routes had been plotted for those unable to fight, should the worst happen and the orcs make their way into the mountain. 

The elves and dwarves would march into battle side-by-side, rather than at the end of each other’s blades. They were shaky allies, perhaps, but allies nonetheless. The battle itself could not be avoided, but undue blood-shed between their peoples would not be the way it began. 

If Gandalf was to be believed, the Eagles should be near. With any luck, they brought Beorn with them. 

Thorin could only hope it was enough. 

He stood and turned away from his grandfather’s armor to look down at Bilbo, whose hazel eyes were set with grim determination. His hair was braided to keep it out of his face, with Thorin’s courting bead resting beside his ear. A peek of mithril gleamed at his collar and Sting hung on his belt, along with Belladonna’s knife and Fili’s dagger. 

Though its weight was far too light, Thorin imagined he could feel his hobbit’s acorn in his pocket, wrapped in a fraying handkerchief and hidden beneath the protection of the standard armor of an Ereborian soldier that he wore.

He leaned down to press his brow to Bilbo’s, their noses brushing. 

“I am glad to have you with me, Bilbo Baggins.”

Humming, Bilbo’s eyes fell shut.

They stood that way for several moments, taking their last chance of peace to breathe before delving into this most dangerous part of their quest.

Bilbo pulled away first, picking up Thorin’s oak shield from the stone bench beside them and offering it to him. “There’s nowhere I’d rather be.”

Thorin took it and Bilbo tilted his head toward the door that would return them to the main armory, where their family waited. 

“Shall we? They’re getting impatient.”

They left the King’s armory behind, and Thorin didn’t look back.

 

***

 

Thirteen dwarves, one wizard, and a hobbit marched together to the Ravenhill door. 

When they learned Thorin’s plan to confront Azog directly, rather than charging onto the battlefield with the elves and men, his Company refused to be parted from him and insisted they would fight by his side until the last. Not that he’d expected any less. And he was glad for it, for he loved them all fiercely and wanted to protect them just as much as they wanted to protect him and his sister-sons. 

He wouldn’t have it any other way, though he found himself wishing for some cheer. Save for the clanking of armor and the scuff of boots on stone, there was no sound to break the solemn silence that shrouded them, and it was setting Thorin’s teeth on edge. An absurd argument, a bawdy drinking song, an inappropriate joke—he’d welcome anything to lighten the mood and make him feel less like he was leading his own funeral procession. 

“Tauriel!” 

Well, almost anything.

Behind him to his left, Dwalin groaned and Thorin had to fight not to repeat the sentiment as Kili shouldered his way past them and ran ahead to meet the two elves who stood at the end of the corridor. On his other side, Bilbo chuckled quietly.

Silently praying to Mahal for patience, Thorin followed behind his wayward sister-son, who took the red-haired elf’s hand as soon as she was in reach. 

He did his best to ignore it and looked at the blond instead. “Prince Legolas.”

“King Thorin.”

“Why are you here?”

They were too far from the entry hall for this meeting to be a coincidence.

“You go to face the Defiler.”

It was no secret where the Company was going, and Legolas had been present during the meeting when the plan was made. That plan never included elves joining them on the hill. “What of it?”

“We are here to offer our help.”

His only comfort was that the elf princeling looked just as disgruntled making the offer as Thorin felt hearing it.

“Your king did not send you.”

Thranduil made it no secret that he thought this plan idiotic, though he also didn’t protest against it, likely because he didn’t care overmuch if the dwarves did perish. Thorin didn’t imagine he suddenly had a change of heart and sent his son and guard-captain to join them. 

Off to the side, Kili and the elf woman were whispering to each other. 

A muscle in Legolas’s cheek twitched. “No.”

Thorin wanted to refuse on principle—he’d had enough dealing with elves these past few days to last him a lifetime—but the addition of two more experienced warriors to the group to keep an eye on his sister-sons was an advantage he could not pass up. On the bright side, it was a chance to piss off the elf king, with the added benefit of plausible deniability of any blame on his part.

“Fine, but if your father asks, I had nothing to do with it.”

So Legolas nodded and stepped aside. “Lead on, then.”

Behind him, Dwalin made a noise of complaint that cut off abruptly and Thorin looked back to see that Bilbo had grabbed a hold of his shield-brother’s ear and dragged him down to his level to hiss quiet words of admonishment at him. Dwalin’s expression was mulish, but he kept his mouth shut and didn’t try to protest again.

As soon as Bilbo released him, Ori took his place at Dwalin’s side. Dwalin, sap that he was, took one look at the young scribe and his angry demeanor immediately melted into tooth-achingly sweet adoration that Thorin found both fascinating and disturbing. He’d never witnessed his best friend openly show this much affection for anything. Maybe it had something to do with the matching braids that had seemingly appeared in the pair’s hair overnight, though they seemed to prefer that nobody acknowledge it. 

Kili’s expression as he looked up at his elf was a near exact match to Dwalin’s, and Thorin thought he might understand a bit of how Dori felt. At least she didn’t have a courting braid in her hair. Yet.

If the elf’s own expression was anything to go by, he had a feeling it wouldn’t be long before that braid appeared. And then he’d have a decision to make.

Utterly discomfited by the turn of his thoughts, Thorin gave a gruff command for them to move on.

And so thirteen dwarves, a wizard, one hobbit, and two elves left Erebor through the Ravenhill door. 

It sounded like the beginning of a bad joke. 

 

***

 

It had been beautiful, once. A shining fortress of Erebor’s green and gold marble, built on the shores of Zâramukaruk, overlooking the Gate Valley and Dale, it started out as a simple watch tower, back during the reign of Thráin I, with a beacon at the highest point that could be lit to warn the gate-guard of approaching danger. In time, it grew to be a small city district in its own right, with a residential area for the tower-guard and their families, as well as the caretakers of the ravens and those who worked on the reservoir, and a high street with eateries and shops and a bank. 

Now, Ravenhill was little more than a crumbling ruin, scorched by dragon-fire and overrun by orcs and goblins. The beacon-tower, or what was left of it, had been claimed by the invading filth and they’d constructed a system of flags and banners and war-horns to send orders to the armies on the battlefield far below.

Thorin would bet his beard that was where Azog was hiding his ugly mug, and thus was his intended destination—if he ever managed to get off the damn ice.

The band of goblin mercenaries that attacked them when they were halfway across the frozen mouth of the reservoir weren’t the problem. Their numbers made them annoying to deal with, but they were easy to kill. No, the real problem was the troll.

It was a terrible creature, with crude clubs in place of its hands and feet, and heavy chains bolted into its blinded eyes to keep it controlled, and something resembling a saddle drilled into place on its hunched back. It appeared from the ruins just a few minutes into the fight, wild and roaring, and its rider steered it straight onto the ice, uncaring of how many other goblins it trampled in its path. The rider was shot down from its perch by one of the elves up above in the ruins within moments, but the damage was done.

Predictably, under the weight of the troll, the ice shattered.

Now half the Company and a great many goblins were slipping and sliding over sheets of broken ice that pitched and rocked and were made even more slick by the water sloshing up onto them, and all the while, they were still trying to stab at each other whenever they slid within reach. 

Thorin’s feet nearly flew out from under him as he ducked to avoid losing his head to a wild swing of the troll’s club, and he was left scrambling to regain his balance.

“Bofur, either control the wretched thing or get down!” he bellowed.

The miner had somehow managed to haul himself up into the saddle and was gleefully tugging on the chains in an attempt to ride the thing.

“Sorry, Thorin!” Bofur shouted back, not sounding sorry at all.

A half dozen goblins who came swarming out of the ruin were hit by the club and sent squealing through the air, and Bofur and several other members of the Company—who notably had the benefit of being on solid ground—all cheered. Nori, who was on the ice but didn’t seem to be having much issue at all staying on his feet, was cackling like a madman at his husband’s antics.

Those idiots are perfect for each other, Thorin though sourly, then had the breath knocked out of him as the ice jolted in a different direction and he landed flat on his back. 

He laid there for a moment, staring up at the dark clouds and wheezing, and wondered if he could bribe Ori to leave this part of the battle out of the official quest record.

Then his dismal view of the sky was blocked out by a dismal view of Nori’s sharp grin. 

“Comfortable, Majesty?”

Thorin scowled at him and rolled over onto his hands and knees, sinking Orcrist into the ice to anchor himself. “Stop looking so happy,” he grumbled.

“Don’t tell me you’re not having fun.”

The irritated reply he meant to give was interrupted by Dwalin barking at him as he staggered towards them across the unstable ice. “Get up, you lazy ass.”

His shield-brother held a green-tinged hobbit slung under one arm and an axe in the other. Bifur and Dori followed behind him, gripping onto each other for balance. Bifur used his boar spear as a walking stick, stabbing the sharp end down into the ice with each step. 

“Are you hurt?” Thorin asked, searching Bilbo for any sign of injury, even as he took Nori’s offered hand to help him to his feet.

The ice pitched again and they all slid a few inches.

Bilbo’s face paled even more at the movement. “I’m going to be sick.”

“No you’re not,” Dwalin threatened.

Bilbo wisely didn’t disagree with him and just clamped his mouth shut. 

Keeping wary eyes on Bofur’s troll, the six of them stumbled their way across the ever shifting ice, headed for the rocky shore at the base of the tower ruins to rejoin the rest of the Company. They didn’t have to worry about defending themselves from goblins because any time one slid too close, it was promptly felled by an elvish arrow. 

He didn’t have the time to appreciate the relief of stone under his boots.

As soon as they got off the ice, they were plunged into the swarm of goblins and there were too many of them for the elves alone to hold off. 

It was all a blur.

Thorin was aware of Bilbo, Dwalin, and Dori fighting at his side, the four of them watching each other’s backs as they fought their way towards the others. Nori and Bifur went in the opposite direction, presumably headed to get Bofur and Bombur. He didn’t have time to worry about them—besides, he thought he saw a whirl of grey robes up on the broken end of the bridge near the troll and he figured the wizard would keep an eye on them.

So he focused on his immediate surroundings. On dodging jagged blades and protecting the others and leaving a path of goblin bodies in his wake. He blocked out the terrible shrieks of metal on metal, and the blowing of orc-ish horns, and the stinging pain of small wounds, and all the screaming.

He couldn’t block out Kili.

“TAURIEL!”

His sister-son’s voice echoed above the din of the fight, desperate and scared, and Thorin was dragged out of his battle haze immediately.

Cutting down two goblins that lunged for Dori, he whirled and sought out the source of Kili’s fear.

She was on a small balcony on a higher level of the ruin overlooking the shore, practically right above where Thorin stood. It was a good spot for an archer, but a bad place to be cornered.

While he watched, an orc big enough to rival the Defiler himself ripped the bow from the elf’s hands and caught her around the throat, lifting her off the ground. She kicked and clawed, fighting to free herself, but her struggling didn’t make much difference. The orc could snap her neck at any moment. 

Kili must have realized the same thing because he cried out for her again, too far to do anything but watch. 

All Thorin heard were the echoes of Thráin’s agonized howl when his beloved Frís drew her last breath in her sick bed, and of Dís’s scream when she heard the news of Víli’s death in a tunnel collapse. Neither were ever the same afterwards, like some part of them died and followed their Ones to the Halls.

He imagined the light in Kili’s eyes going dim. 

Thorin adjusted his grip on his sword, cocked back his arm, said a quick prayer, and threw.

Bright as a shooting star, the glowing blue blade streaked through the air and Orcrist sunk hilt deep into the orc’s back, straight through its rotting heart. 

The orc fell, and the elf collapsed to her hands and knees, choking and gasping for breath.

Moments later, Kili sprinted past, having made it past the throng of goblins hindering him before. He was headed for the crumbling stair that would lead him up into the ruins. His brother was hot on his heel.

“Uncle!”

Thorin turned to catch the blade Fili tossed to him as they passed by, then fell into step with Balin, who lead the others as they chased after the two princes. Bofur, Nori, and Gandalf were still dealing with the troll when they passed, but Bifur and Bombur took up the rear and followed them up the stairs.

As the Company began their ascent, a horn atop the tower sounded and the orcs appeared in force. They only made it up to the first level when they were forced to stop in a courtyard that acted as an intersection of multiple paths, marked by broken and crumbling archways. Directly across from the stair they’d just come from was another stair leading up to Raven Tower. 

Orcs came down the stairs and out of archways and from behind walls. They were everywhere.

Try as he might, Thorin could not catch up with his sister-sons. Every orc he felled was replaced with two more blocking his path and he could do nothing more than watch as Fili and Kili went through an archway on the left side of the courtyard and disappeared from his sight. 

Heavy fear settled low in his gut and he slashed and hacked at the surrounding enemies ever more ardently to no avail. The orcs were targeting him in particular, not that it was any surprise. It infuriated him, but the focus on him meant others had better luck than he did in getting past.

It was Ori who managed to break through and reach the archway first, wielding a familiar war-hammer with deadly force and splattered helm to boot with gore. The orcs were starting to give the young scribe a wide berth, and Balin took advantage of the opening to go after his apprentice and the princes. He was followed closely by Gloin, Oin, and Dori. 

Then they, too, disappeared.

With each minute that passed, his Company was spreading thinner, and all plans of sticking together were dashed.

At least he still had Bilbo and Dwalin at his side, and Bombur and Bifur weren’t far off. Although…

He ducked and his shield-brother’s axe swung above him to bury itself between an orc’s eyes.

“Dwalin, if you need to go after Ori—”

Dwalin scoffed and tugged his axe free, just to spin and chop off another orc’s head. “Ori has his charge, and I have mine. He can take care of himself.”

The choice of words raised a nagging suspicion in the back of Thorin’s mind that he couldn’t quite put a name to, and he wanted to question Dwalin on what exactly he meant by his charge, but there was no time to dwell on it. Not when Bilbo made a sound like all the air had been knocked from his lungs.

Thorin turned to look at his hobbit.

If Bilbo had looked ill on the ice, it was nothing compared to now. 

He had Sting raised, but the sword quivered in his grasp, and the blue glow of the elvish blade made his face look ghostly pale. His attention was fixed on something that filled his hazel eyes with both anger and despair. 

In his heart, Thorin knew what he would see when followed Bilbo’s haunted gaze, but a small, scared part of him wished he was wrong.

He wasn’t.

Standing atop the stairs to Raven Tower, outfitted in full armor with a mace in hand and a gruesome blade jutting from his mangled arm, was the Defiler. He wore the same garish smile as when they last saw him, on the flaming cliff on the steep slopes of the Misty Mountains. 

A rush of rage and grief left Thorin breathless, and he wasn’t fast enough to block out the memory of that blade sinking through his chest. Of the coldness that crept through his limbs while his life-blood spilled from his body onto the ice. Of the way his lungs felt like they were turning to stone, until they were too heavy to draw another breath. Of the eternity spent in an unending darkness, unsure of even his own existence and wondering if it was punishment for all his many failures. 

He’d spent so long ignoring those memories, but they were like a flood now, drowning him.

An orc with a spiked club bore down on Thorin, but he could do no more than stare.

Dwalin stepped in front of him and absorbed the shock of the heavy blow with his axe. He was shouting, gruff voice barking out commands that Thorin couldn’t understand. 

The others shouted back, but their words were muffled and meaningless to his ears. 

Dwalin cut down the orc while it was unbalanced. Then another. And another.

Thorin twitched. He tried to step forward, to raise his sword and continue fighting at his shield-brother’s side as he had always done, but his boots were stuck to the stone. He couldn’t move. Couldn’t breathe.

His lungs were stone again. And then he was no longer in the courtyard. 

He stood on the blood-stained ice, and all around him were bodies.

There was Dori, hewn nearly in half, his silver hair dirty and in disarray. There was Gloin, beaten and battered with a crushed helm. There was Bofur, his head and hat both missing. There was Nori beside him, and at the end of his wrists were nothing but bloody stumps. There was Oin, blue in the face and frostbitten, looking drowned. There was an old, grey man with a broken staff at his side. There was Bifur with his skull split in two, and Bombur with his guts spilled across the ice.  There was Balin, his too-knowing eyes plucked out by the crows, staring up at the sky with empty sockets. There was Ori, flat on his back and Dwalin on top of him, a spear driven straight through them both and down into the ice. There were Fili and Kili, side-by-side and pierced by many blades and arrows. There was a snapped bow and fiery red hair— 

Jerking away from the sight, Thorin turned and found himself face to face with Bilbo.

Mithril gleamed and the hobbit was entirely unharmed. Tears cut tracks through the dirt and grime on his face, but his eyes blazed and there was hatred in them. 

“You were supposed to save them,” Bilbo hissed in a voice unlike his own. “You were supposed to fix it. You failed.”

The word echoed and pushed in around him on all sides, and he was suffocating.

Failed.

FAILED.

failedfailedfailedfailedfailed

Thorin choked and clutched his chest, unpierced by any blade, yet his heart cleaved apart all the same. 

Gone. They were all gone.

“This is your fault.”

Thorin raised his hands to clap them over his ears, but they were soaked with red and he stared at them.

“You did this.”

He wanted to deny it, to plead for forgiveness, but he had no voice.

His armor was plated with gold. A crown sat heavy on his head. Between them, at their feet, was a glittering stone.

Failure. Disgrace. Weak. Greedy.

“Monster,” Bilbo spat.

Thorin stumbled back—

His back slammed into a stone wall and he wheezed. The only thing that kept him from sinking to his knees were the hands that gripped his shoulders.

Dwalin loomed over him, glaring and a little wild-eyed and very much alive.

“Snap out of it,” his shield-brother snarled, shaking him. 

Thorin’s vision flickered. He was staring up at his best friend, then staring at his butchered family, then staring at the Arkenstone and vast halls of gold, then staring at the hobbit with eyes like blazing chasms. 

Dwalin growled and leaned closer until they were nose to nose. His voice lowered into a rumble that was barely audible.

“Ibkin, Izrênudal.”

Thorin’s eyes snapped open and he sucked in a deep, ragged breath. The battle raged on around him, far from over. He was not on the ice. He was himself.

“Munushmar.”

If it sounded like he was begging, he wasn’t sure what exactly it was that he wanted. But he was desperate for it. 

Dwalin was steady, like an anchor driven deep into the rock, and he yanked Thorin out of his free-fall with unmovable force. “If you don’t pull yourself together, I will drag you back into the mountain by your braids. You will not die on this fucking hill. Do you understand me?”

Thorin took a breath. Then another. He swallowed thickly. When he spoke, his voice was hoarse, like he’d been screaming. “I am sorry. I do not know what happened.” 

“You froze.”

The note of disbelief in Dwalin’s tone was warranted.

Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thráin and Frís, grandson of Thrór and Brína and Yngvi, heir to the line of Durin, did not freeze. It was in his blood to plod on through every danger and hardship with jaw-cracking determination. He never stopped. Not until it killed him. 

Or until something like madness took over his mind and made him falter.

But no, he’d already sworn he wouldn’t fall to it again. He wouldn’t.

So, with some effort, he pushed the terrible vision from his mind and stood tall once again. “It will not happen again. I can do this.”

As they stared at each other, another horn blast sounded from the top of Raven Tower. Then Dwalin finally nodded and released him. 

When they emerged from the sheltered alcove where Dwalin had dragged him off to knock some sense into him, none of the others said a word about whatever strange fit Thorin fell into upon seeing Azog. They were guarding the alcove diligently, refusing to allow a single orc to pass them, and just seemed relieved to have their two most experienced warriors back. Bofur and Nori were with them—though where Gandalf had gone off to was anybody’s guess—and Thorin didn’t want to wonder how long he must have spent trapped in his own mind to miss their return. 

The thought made him feel ill.

His shield-brother plunged straight back into the fight, but before Thorin could follow him, his path was blocked.

Bilbo looked up at him, pale-faced and grim. “It wasn’t real.”

The words sent dread through him, like icy water trickling down his spine, and he had the irrational thought that Bilbo somehow knew exactly what had happened during that waking nightmare, where he was forced to stare down some of his worst fears and had been helpless against them. 

“What are you talking about?” he asked after several moments, voice shakier than he wanted it to be.

“Whatever it showed you, whatever it said, all of it was a lie. That’s what it does. That’s all it can do. It whispers, and it threatens, and it lies.” Bilbo spat the words with a fierce bitterness.

“It?” 

What was he talking about? The vision was nothing more than a product of his own mind. It was madness lingering in the shadows waiting to pounce on him in moments of weakness. It wasn’t— 

Bilbo pressed a hand firmly against the center of his own chest and stared, willing Thorin to understand. 

He stared back, then his confusion turned to comprehension. “You mean—”

“Don’t listen to it.” 

The Ring. 

Thorin wanted to ask. He wanted to know everything that Bilbo knew, and wanted to know if the hobbit had experienced similar visions filled with such doom. But there was no time. Not now, when they were surrounded by orcs and relying on their friends to protect them while they spoke with each other.

So he nodded.

Later. They would talk about it later. 

 

***

 

No matter how hard they fought to follow the other half of the Company, they were driven farther away from the archway where Fili and Kili first disappeared. The orcs were relentless, herding them to the tower stair, then forcing them slowly backwards up the steps. At any moment, Thorin was sure a second band of orcs would descend on them from behind and they would be surrounded, trapped in the middle of the staircase and defending themselves on every side. When the war-horns atop the tower began to blow yet again, he braced himself for it.

But the horn was matched by high, fierce cries and several huge figures plummeted out of the clouds above, wings beating the air into strong winds.

One of the Eagles, with something grey on its back, swooped down and with outstretched talons wrenched the system of flags and banners straight off the top of the tower, and the war-horn fell silent mid-blast.

The orcs on the stairs and in the courtyard below screamed, whether in rage or fear, and fell into panic. Thorin watched many of them throw themselves flat on the ground to avoid the deadly talons that reached for them as Eagles flew low, while many more were unable to escape and found themselves being flung through the air and torn apart by sharp beaks. 

Somewhere far in the distance, maybe down below on the battlefield itself, there was a bone-shaking roar that indicated Beorn had indeed come with the Eagles to their aid.

The others cheered around him and Thorin joined them, allowing himself a short moment of satisfaction as his enemies fled and cowered from the Eagles that were not inclined to show mercy.

Then the moment passed and, bolstered by the newly arrived allies joining the fight, Thorin made up his mind.

He’d far rather go find the others, but with the orcs’ communication system down, it seemed the best time to hunt down Azog and take him out before he regrouped and found another way to send out his orders. So, praying that his sister-sons and the rest of his Company were safe somewhere out there in the ruins, he turned and started to climb, setting his sights on the tower.

The courtyard at the top of the stair was much like the one they’d just left behind, but smaller. And empty. There was nothing but some scattered debris from the banners the Eagle had destroyed up above and a statue of Thráin I, standing tall in the center of the courtyard with a raven perched on his arm. The statue was weather-worn and cracked, but otherwise whole. Behind it was a dark, gaping doorway into the tower.

After all the chaos so far, the stillness was discomfiting. Behind and below them, the shrieks of Eagles and orcs still raged, but the silence in the courtyard was suffocating. 

“Creepy,” Bofur said, and the forced cheer in his tone wasn’t quite enough to hide his unease.

The rest murmured their agreement, and Thorin cautiously led them up the last few steps. From the corner of his eye, he watched Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur all draw closer around Bilbo, and it reassured him.

The Urs weren’t warriors in the traditional sense, but they were deeply loyal and downright lethal when they put their minds to it. More importantly, they loved Bilbo. On both this journey and the last, they were among the first of the dwarves to befriend their odd burglar, and there was no doubt they would protect them as best as they were able, no matter what danger they were about to face.

As he had the thought, both Dwalin and Nori fell in on either side of Thorin and he had the distinct feeling that Bilbo wasn’t the only one being guarded. In another lifetime, it may have rankled. Now, he was just glad to not be alone. 

Dwalin eyed the dark doorway, then spoke gruffly. “If you even think about going in that tower, I’ll kill you myself.” 

“I could go scout it out,” Nori suggested, and was met with immediate disapproval.

“No!” Bombur yelped.

“Absolutely not,” Bilbo snapped.

“No you won’t,” Bofur said at the same time, sending his One a warning look.

Dwalin scoffed. “Don’t be an idiot.”

“Lulukh jublabul.”

“Alright, alright!” Nori dodged Bifur’s attempt to slap him upside the head. “It was just an idea! No need to be hurtful.”

“No one is going in there,” Thorin said firmly.

He’d meant to, but looking at it now, he thought better of the plan. He did not actually want to die, and walking into that darkness seemed a surefire way to meet a bad end. It was too quiet and too empty. Too much like it had been before, last time when he was too stupid to recognize a trap when he saw one.

The tower looked deserted.

He knew better now.

Still, they couldn’t just stand there forever.

So he step determinedly forward and with all the anger and grief of years past at the forefront of his mind, he roared. “AZOG!”

There was a beat of silence, then another. Then, like furious hornets emerging out of a kicked nest, the orcs swarmed from the dark doorway.

 

***

 

In the tower courtyard, time had no meaning. Whether minutes or hours passed as they fought, Thorin couldn’t say. But the bodies piled up, and still the orcs came. He thought their attacks might be slowing, and maybe their numbers were beginning to dwindle, but whether that was truth or only a fool’s hope, he wasn’t sure.

He lost count of how many orcs died at the end of his borrowed blade, and felt exhaustion creeping in. He ignored his burning lungs and muscles and kept going. One wrong move could mean death for himself or his friends, and he wouldn’t allow that to happen.

So he fought.

He thrust his sword through the chest of an orc who raised its club to swing at Dwalin. He slashed at one that set its sights on Bombur. He and Nori both cut one down that lunged at Bofur while he was distracted helping his cousin, who had apparently made the mistake of head-butting an orc that came too close. Somehow, the axe lodged in Bifur’s skull was now also stuck in the skull of the dead orc.

Bombur rushed to help pull them apart, and Bilbo was at his side.

Flashing bright and blue, Sting cut an orc down at the knees that tried rushing at the Urs then beheaded it. The movement was clumsy, but worked all the same.

For a moment, Thorin’s gaze locked with Bilbo’s. Despite all the danger and chaos, there was exasperation in his eyes, and Thorin imagined he could hear his hobbit’s thoughts, griping about the utter ridiculousness of dwarves. 

If he had the breath for it, he might have laughed.

But then Bilbo looked up over his head and his eyes widened, exasperation shifting to panic.

“Behind you!” he yelled.

Thorin whirled.

Blade clashed against blade, and he finally found himself staring up into the pale, cruel face of the Defiler. 

Finally.

It was like living in a memory, but distorted and changed. 

Thorin dodged and rolled away from Azog’s attacks, but it was a spiked mace that he swung, not a chain and stone. It was blood-slicked stone that cracked under the heavy blows, not ice. It was an orc enraged by wrecked plans, not a triumphant one wielding a blade already dripping with Durin blood. It was a dwarf determined to fix his own mistakes, using the echoes of all his remembered grief as fuel, but refusing to be overcome by it.

It was a dwarf who didn’t stand alone.

Dwalin was practically soldered to his side, matching him step for step in the battle-dance they’d been sharing all their lives. When Azog brought his mace down between them, they dodged apart then came together again without missing a beat.

Nori remained a bit behind them, guarding their backs and lingering in their shadows, pointing out potential weaknesses as he spotted them. His quiet suggestions led to their opponent sustaining several wounds, shallow though they may be, and each landed blow was a small victory.

Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur continued to fight off the other orcs in the courtyard, and not a single one managed to slip past their steadfast defense to attempt to come to their leader’s aid. All the while, they alternated between shouting encouragement and insults that grew increasingly more creative.

Bilbo fought alongside the Urs, but every once in a while he stooped, and soon after a flying stone smacked into Azog’s armor or bounced off his head. 

Between the seven of them, their combined efforts wound Azog into a seething fury. 

Slowly, they beat him back until he fought in the shadow of Thráin I’s statue.

Thorin began to hope that they had him cornered, and the battle was almost done. Then, somewhere far off on another part of the hill, there was a scream.

Whether it belonged to Fili or Kili, he couldn’t tell. There was too much other noise to be sure, but he heard it all the same and he knew with a terrible certainty that one of his sister-sons was hurt. And he was too far away to do anything about it. Again.

He didn’t freeze, but the split-second of distraction cost them.

Azog lurched forward, and Thorin was too slow to counter the attack. 

The orc's blade-arm slashed out in a vicious arc that would have sliced Dwalin’s head in half if Nori didn’t grab him and yank him back. But the tip of the blade still raked across the Dwalin’s face and he howled half in rage and half in pain.

Then Azog whipped around and swung his spiked mace.

Thorin barely had enough time to raise his shield over his head, then the impact of the blow forced him down on one knee. Spasming agony shot through his arm, and the oak shield that he had carried for so long, that had earned him his name and saved his life countless times, splintered and cracked.

His own shout was drowned out by Azog’s crazed laughter and a dismayed yell from Bombur.

“Bilbo, no!”

Breath ragged, Thorin looked up and time slowed.

His hobbit—his brave, fierce, stupid hobbit—slipped past the dwarves protecting him and sprinted full tilt at Azog, brandishing Sting with little finesse but plenty intent. The orc’s back was to him, and he didn’t notice the small assailant until Bilbo’s sword sank through a chink in his armor and the glowing point protruded from his belly.

Azog roared and turned.

The movement ripped the sword from the hobbit’s grip and sent him stumbling. The blade remained lodged in the orc’s gut.

Azog raised his mace.

Thorin surged to his feet. Dwalin ripped away from Nori and lunged. The other dwarves cried out in alarm.

Azog swung.

The mace slammed into Bilbo’s chest at full force. The hobbit didn’t make a sound. He flew through the air as though weightless, crashed into a stone column at the edge of the courtyard, then hit the ground with a dull thud.

He didn’t move again.

Time stopped.

The freezing winter air clawed the back of Thorin’s throat, sweat dripped into his stinging eyes, the acrid scent of orc blood burned his nose. His heart beat like a war drum and blood roared in his ears, drowning out any coherent thought.

There was nothing but his One, collapsed and terribly still.

Something in his chest stretched taut. It pulled, tighter and tighter and tighter, straining. Then it snapped.

Thorin screamed.

Time started again in a rush, and many things happened all at once. 

Bofur left his brother and cousin to finish off the final few orcs around them and sprinted to the fallen hobbit’s side.

Dwalin, face covered in blood, brought his axe down on Azog’s arm and the orc’s mace and remaining hand both went flying.

Azog shrieked so loudly, his voice was probably heard even on the battlefield in the valley far below, and he doubled over, clutching at the stump of his arm.

Thorin cast aside the broken pieces of his shield, ignoring the terrible throbbing in his arm, and rushed forward. 

It was over in an instant.

With a final roar and one great swing of Fili’s sword, Azog the Defiler lost his head.

Before the corpse even hit the ground, Thorin was running.

Bofur sat on the ground beside Bilbo looking stricken, hat clutched in his gnarled hands and tears in his eyes. “He’s gone.”

“No, he’s not,” Thorin snarled.

He wasn’t. It was impossible.

The hobbit could survive anything, no matter the peril. He could face trolls and orcs and giant spiders and dragons and come out on top. He could lecture kings of men, elves, and dwarves alike without flinching. He wore luck like a cloak and slipped through danger with nothing worse than a concussion and some missing buttons. He threw parties worthy of legend in the minds of his kin and lived longer than any hobbit in recorded history. He could do anything.

The only thing Bilbo Baggins couldn’t do was die. 

Stripping off his filthy gloves, Thorin dropped to his knees beside his One. Bilbo’s face was pale and dirty and caked with sticky blood from a cut near his temple. His clothes were torn and ragged, and the bead in his hair and the mithril shirt both seemed dull. Thorin reached out to move the collar of Bilbo’s shirt and pressed his fingers to his neck, searching for a pulse. But his fingers were numb from the cold and from gripping his sword so tightly and he couldn’t feel anything.

His hands came away red. 

His stomach turned and Thorin clenched his teeth, ignoring the way he was beginning to tremble and the way his breath hitched. He leaned down, ear close to Bilbo’s mouth and nose, listening for his breathing. But there was no sound, and no air, even faint,  brushed against him.

Thorin pulled back, just enough to see the hobbit’s face.

“Bilbo,” he said, voice strained.

But his One didn’t so much as twitch.

“No. Don’t you dare.” Terror seized him and he put both of his hands to Bilbo’s cold cheeks. Long eyelashes brushed Thorin’s fingertips, but didn’t flutter. “Wake up.”

Bilbo couldn’t die. 

He couldn’t.

This wasn’t how it was supposed to go.

It wasn’t fair.

Distantly, he heard the scraping of boots as the others gathered around. Heard far away murmurs and gasps. Heard the booming voice of the wizard call out, and it sounded panicked. Heard the beating of wings and a piercing cry.

Still, Bilbo didn’t move.

“The Eagles are coming,” Thorin whispered, and his voice broke.

He pressed his brow to Bilbo’s and squeezed his eyes shut, willing himself to wake up. For this must be some terrible dream. A vision sent to him by the Ring. A lie. 

But the cold stone beneath him remained, and the stench of orcs surrounded him, and his hands were sticky with blood.

His tears fell then, and he didn’t care who was there to see it. 

Notes:

I'm sorry. I had to do it to 'em. Don't hate me.

 

Translations:

Zâramukaruk - lake of ravens

Ibkin - awake, wake up

Izrênudal - unyielding dreamer (Thorin’s inner name)

Munushmar - loyal guardian (Dwalin’s inner name)

Lulukh jublabul - idiotic tiny-brain

Chapter 32: A Chance to Choose

Notes:

What's this? A chapter posted exactly when I promised? Inconceivable! (I think this is a first for me.)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo floated in a vast expanse of blindingly white nothingness, unable to tell up from down or account for how much time had passed since he became aware of his presence there. If anything at all existed in this place besides himself, he saw no evidence of it. Then again, he wasn’t even sure if he existed, considering he couldn’t actually feel his body. It was rather disconcerting, though he should probably be grateful for it, given the particularly violent nature of his final memory before finding himself here.

It was all a bit of a blur. 

He vaguely remembered stabbing Azog in the back, then there was a horrible crunching feeling in his chest that stole his breath away, then the sensation of flying through the air like a golf ball on the Greenfield. (A terrible game, golf.) Then there was nothing. Literally.

If this was death, he was decidedly unimpressed. And more than a little annoyed.

Where were the Eternal Gardens of the Green Lady? Where were the fields of flowers, and unending feasts, and the welcoming party with all his passed on loved ones in attendance? Where were the comforts of home?

When he first reawakened to find himself once again in the master bedroom of Bag End several months ago, he was disappointed at the prospect of it being the setting of his afterlife. He didn’t want to spend the rest of eternity puttering around the empty halls of his smial. Death was supposed to be the next great adventure!

Still, however unappealing that existence sounded, it was far preferable to whatever this ridiculous non-existence was.

Of course, he had far better things to be doing than feasting, puttering, or floating around in the afterlife. And by “better things” he meant making sure his block-head dwarves were still breathing.

The annoyance gave way to worry.

They must be alive, right?

From what he could remember, all the dwarves he’d been with were mostly unscathed, save for Dwalin whose face was a bloody mess and Bifur who lost the axe in his skull. But they were both still on their feet, last he saw. Thorin was on the ground, but hopefully Bilbo’s ill-fated attempt to save him had bought him time to collect himself and keep fighting.

As for the other half of the Company, Bilbo had no way of knowing how they fared. Getting separated as they did was not part of the plan, and he didn’t like it. How was he supposed to keep an eye on everyone if they insisted on running off?  

He had, as he was sure Thorin did, heard the scream. He was reasonably certain it came from Kili. Whether the young dwarf—no, his nephew—had been injured himself or witnessed someone else get hurt, he could only guess.

Whatever happened, it was only an injury. It had to be.

Bilbo didn’t come all this way just to fail because he was too slow to get out of Azog’s way after sticking him like a pin-cushion and making him angry. Not his finest moment, to be sure, but what else was he supposed to do? Watch Azog murder the love of his life for a second time? Absolutely not.

No doubt Thorin would be furious with him.

Which he supposed was only fair, since he himself was furious after the end of that first adventure, when their roles were reversed and Thorin had the gall to die and leave him behind.

Goodness, Bilbo hoped he wasn’t dead. He didn’t want to put his dwarf through that sort of pain. 

Eventually, his fretting gave way to boredom. Which was unfortunate because if there was anything Bilbo Baggins had learned about himself throughout the course of his entirely too long life, it was that boredom was his worst form of torture, likely to drive him mad if left unchecked. It was made even worse by his inability to move, or indeed do anything at all.

With nothing but his own thoughts to entertain him, Bilbo recited the entirety of the Baggins family tree as far back as he could remember. And when he’d done that, he recited the Took tree, too. He mentally mapped every road, track, and path in the Shire that he knew, which were a great many given his fondness of walking holidays. He named every winner of the annual mid-summer tomato competition for the past one hundred twenty years (of which he won seventeen and Lobelia only won two, not that it mattered, of course—he would never boast about such a thing.)

It was around the time he found himself listing every kind of flower he could think of and their individual meanings and what they meant paired together in a bouquet that he noticed he could wiggle his toes and felt a warm breeze tickling the hair on his feet. The air smelled like good earth, sunlight shone through his closed eyelids, and the ground beneath him was a soft bed of grass.

He opened his eyes to stare up into the rustling leaves of a tall oak and was momentarily fascinated by the dappled light shifting in the foliage. And then he heard the singing. A soft and strangely familiar voice sang a wordless tune that he knew by heart. A short burst of excitement told him it was his mother, but when he turned his head, it was not Belladonna Baggins who sat in the grass several paces away from him, weaving together clusters of yarrow blossoms with quick fingers.

Rather, he saw a tall, willowy figure with skin the color of rich, tilled earth. She wore a fine spring-green gown of silk, covered with intricately embroidered vines and flowers and leaves. Her hair, thick and dark and curly, was left loose to sway in the breeze, save for a single braid that ended with a shining mithril bead.

The sight of it startled him out of his idle stupor.

Bilbo sat up and groped at his own hair, then felt a wave of relief to find his own braid and bead exactly where he’d left them. Comforted by their presence and the Lady’s continued humming, he studied their surroundings with interest.

Cottony clouds drifted lazily across a sapphire sky. Gently rolling hills wore necklaces of winding streams and crowns of wildflowers in full bloom. Groves of elm and beech trees stood guard over the fields, and bees and butterflies danced with the swaying grasses. And far beyond it all, rising out of the horizon, were purple mountains cloaked in mist and an emerald forest.

The sight of them roused an old longing in his heart that he could never quite be rid of and Bilbo had to tear his eyes away, or he might take off running. 

“Where are we?” he finally asked, loathe to interrupt the peaceful quiet, yet unable to ignore the itch of idleness beginning to prick at the soles of his feet.

“Inbetween,” Yavanna said simply.

Because of course this was Yavanna. The Green Lady of the Eternal Garden needed no introduction.

Humming, Bilbo shifted to lean back against the trunk of the oak, finding a nice spot nestled between the roots. It reminded him of his parents’ tree, planted atop Bag End the day Belladonna first realized she was with child, as was Shire tradition. Or, a variation of it, anyway. Their choice to plant a tree rather than a new flower bed raised some eyebrows, but the couple had never quite done what was expected of them.

Bilbo and the oak grew up alongside each other, and it always served as a place of safety and comfort for him—both things that he was in need of at the moment, if he was to ask his next question.

“Am I dead?”

Yavanna’s nimble fingers never faltered in their weaving, and she didn’t look at him when she responded. “Not quite.”

It was, Bilbo supposed, a better answer than yes, though no would have been preferable. In his opinion, not quite dead sounded awfully close to very nearly dead and while he wasn’t afraid of dying, that didn’t mean he was eager to do so.

He unconsciously reached for his braid again and held onto Thorin’s bead, the metal warm against his skin.

“Am I going to die?”

Considering the severity of his injuries, it seemed likely. Granted, he didn’t know exactly what those injures were, but he was sure something broke that wasn’t meant to. Or a great many somethings, more like.

“Everyone dies, Bilbo.”

He leveled a disgruntled look at her, not caring to wonder if it was perhaps a little too disrespectful of a reaction, given that she was one of the Valar. Honestly, what was it with immortals and their penchant for answering simple questions with riddles?

Yavanna’s laugh was reminiscent of a wind-chime hanging in a summer breeze. “When you will die is yet unseen. It could happen now, or it may happen later. It is your choice.”

“What do you mean?”

The Lady’s hands finally stilled and when she looked him in the eye, Bilbo was unable to look away. His first impression was that her eyes were the green of young spring leaves. But no, they were honey-golden. Now raincloud grey. Now the exact shade of Auntie Donnamira’s blueberry preserves.

So mesmerized was he by the shifting colors, he almost didn’t realize she was speaking.

“Your life hangs by a thread. Those who love you work to heal your wounds, but whether or not they are successful depends on you. If you so choose, you can cut the thread and return home.”

Her words sparked a flash of memory—one where his mother sang in the kitchen of Bag End, and his father’s voice sang with her, drifting in through the open window from the garden outside. It was the home of his youth, the one that existed only in memories of a life long past. He was old, and he didn’t often think of it anymore, if he could help it. Yet this was the second time in the past months it had come to him unbidden.

“It was you,” he said, not sure if he meant to sound accusing or simply baffled. “You lead me to the troll-hoard?”

Yavanna just dipped her head, and that mithril in her hair glimmered.

Bilbo glanced at the distant mountains again and his chest ached. His fears from that bright, empty place returned to him. “Can you tell me—are they—did they—”

“The Defiler is dead. You barufu ikh-kurdu lives.”

The khuzdul rolled off her tongue easily, but in a light, melodic way that contrasted greatly with the typical dwarvish way of speaking.

Bilbo sagged in relief.

They’d actually done it. No matter how many times he told himself they would, there was always that hint of doubt, that worry that their quest was doomed to end with the same suffocating grief as it had before. Or something even worse. But no. His dwarves were alive. All thirteen of them.

He could have wept with the joy of it, if his own fate were not currently hanging in the balance.

“And if I choose to return to them?”

“Durin’s sons live, but the world is far from saved.”

He swallowed thickly. “The Ring.”

It wasn’t a question, but her silence was confirmation enough. From the very first moment that he realized he was truly back in time, reliving his life, he’d known in his heart that it would come to this. As much as he tried to avoid thinking of it, it was always there in the back of his mind, right beside the presence of the Ring itself.

Except he couldn’t feel the Ring now. His own voice was the only one occupying his thoughts. There wasn’t even a hint of a whisper. The silence was blissful.

Bilbo took a moment to just close his eyes and breathe, savoring the warmth and fresh air and the scent of green growing things. Considering the current state of Erebor, it would be quite some time before he got to enjoy such comforts again. He wouldn’t have to give them up at all if he stayed. Nor would he ever have to speak to the Ring again.

“I must warn you, both choices come at a cost.”

He would have thought such a statement unnecessary, and the price of both choices seemed clear. He looked at her again and was taken aback to see that Yavanna looked almost…guilty?

“What haven’t you told me?”

And so she explained, and Bilbo listened, and neither of them were happy about it.

Every word she spoke dropped another rock in his gut. By the time she finished, he thought his ears might be ringing. 

Bilbo wanted to laugh, if only to keep himself from crying, but he didn’t even have the energy for that. Valar save him, he felt so old. Granted, the Valar were a big part of the reason he was in this mess to begin with, so he didn’t think they’d be much help. Not if the pitying look Yavanna was giving him was anything to go by.

Of course nothing could ever be simple. Of course everything had to have consequences. It wasn’t fair. Such was life, he supposed. And apparently, such was death.  Maybe he would think it poetic if he wasn’t stuck in the middle of it all. From where he sat, it was just cruel. There were no good choices here.

And on the subject of choices…

“Why now?”

She said nothing and he had to stop himself from glaring at her.

“Why are we having this conversation now? Thorin—” Bilbo’s voice cracked and he swallowed thickly, then pushed on. “He got to choose to be sent back to the beginning of the quest. Why was I not given the same choice until now?”

Except it wasn’t the same choice. Not really. This was far worse.

Maybe it was foolish to demand answers from a being such as she. He couldn’t really bring himself to care, though. Not after everything she’d just told him. It was a question he’d had on his mind ever since he learned of Thorin’s own meeting with Mahal, though the dwarf never mentioned a conversation like this one. He never mentioned such costs or anything of the like.

“It is my fault,” Yavanna finally confessed after a long silence, though she sounded reluctant. “Time is a tricky thing. Something I cannot fully explain, as I do not fully understand it myself. My best answer for you is that by the time I found out my husband was sending your Thorin back, it was too late for me to speak with you first. I had to send you back at the exact moment he was, or not at all. I was hasty, and I did not fully realize the consequences my actions would have. I did not know to account for the Ring.”

Well, that barely explained anything at all, and raised more questions than it did answers. Then a thought occurred to him, and he looked at Yavanna with bewilderment.

“Hold on, did you kill me?”

He was sure he saw her wince at the question, but her tone was carefully neutral when she answered him.

“Everyone dies.”

This time, he really did laugh. It was just one little disbelieving hiccup of a sound, followed by another long stretch of silence.

Dragons, dwarvish kings, time travel, meddling Valar, evil magic rings, and now this—how he always managed to get himself tangled up in such insane situations, Bilbo would never understand. In his first life, he often liked to blame Gandalf. It was the wizard, after all, who pushed him out his door in the first place. But he couldn’t use that excuse anymore. No, this nonsense was all his own fault. And the fault of the Valar, to an extent. Though it seemed even they were not all knowing. 

He thought longingly of his parents and the Gardens and peaceful rest. But it wouldn’t be peaceful, would it? Not if what Yavanna said was true—and he had no doubt that it was. He would face an eternity that mirrored a life he’d already lived, full of regret and guilt and longing for something he could never have. The mountains would forever be out of his reach.

But would going back be any better? He may very well be dooming all of Arda if he returned and wasn’t strong enough to do what needed to be done. If the Ring took him, what chance was there of it being destroyed? How long could he resist it? Not to mention what Thorin would think of it all. They’d see each other again, but there was no telling how his dwarf would react when he learned the truth. 

Which was worse—to be hated or to be missed?

He wished he could talk to Thorin before making a choice that would change both their lives forever—not to mention the lives of everyone else in Middle Earth. But that wasn’t an option and this was a decision only he could make. So, what to choose?

He knew the answer already, though he prayed he wouldn’t come to regret it.

“Send me back.”

“Are you certain?”

“I already promised I would do this, and I think I must try.”

Yavanna’s hands clenched in her lap and her head bowed, dark hair falling like a curtain to hid her face, but not before Bilbo caught a glimpse of the sorrow there. “I have no right to ask your forgiveness,” she said, then paused. Her shoulders slumped. “But know that I am sorry. You were so sad for so long, and it hurt to watch. I could not stand the thought of that sadness following you to the Garden, but I fear I have only made it worse.”

He couldn’t bring himself to be angry with her. How could he, when he thought he understood fairly well how she was feeling in that moment?

He did not know what it was like to be one of the Valar, couldn’t even comprehend it, but he did know what it was like to be a parent. Or something like it. He knew what it was like to realize that his own actions, no matter how well-intentioned, had placed his child into grave danger. And he remembered how much it hurt to see the state Frodo was in after the war—even after sailing to Valinor—knowing that he was the one to pass such a terrible burden on to him.

So Bilbo moved away from the oak to kneel beside Yavanna, and he didn’t hesitate to reach out and lay his hands on hers. “My Lady, you did only what I would have chosen for myself, given the opportunity. There is nothing to forgive.”

There was no other choice. Not for him. 

She let out a slow breath and turned her hands to hold onto his. “My brave hobbit.”

The path ahead of him was wrought with darkness and Shadow, but there was also light, and he would not regret walking it. Though…

“I do fear Thorin will be very cross with me for not asking him first.”

An understatement, considering the gravity of what he was about to do. He meant to express the concern with levity, but he couldn’t quite hide the tremor in his voice.

But Yavanna smiled, and despite how grim the tone of their conversation had been so far, she suddenly looked delighted. “I would not worry so much. He makes his own choices while you sleep.”

Her happiness should have been enough to reassure him that all was well, but the words only served to plant a seed of wariness in him.

“And…how long exactly have I been asleep?” 

“Nearly a week.”

A week.

There was any number of hare-brained things Thorin might do without proper supervision in that amount of time, and Bilbo didn’t want to imagine the chaos he might find upon returning to the land of the living. Fili and Kili had to get it from somewhere, after all.

For all he knew, he might be landing himself directly into the middle of another war. Though hopefully the Lady’s optimism on the matter meant it wasn’t anything as terrible as that.

He sighed. “What has he done now?”

“It is not my place to say. He deserves the chance to tell you himself.” Her smile grew. “I think you underestimate his love for you.”

Bilbo felt himself blush and he spluttered a bit, but didn’t try to contradict her. He hoped she was right. They’d only just begun courting a few days ago, and making this choice without Thorin’s input felt…presumptuous, but that was too light a word. He didn’t look forward to explaining it, and now he was worried what the state of things would be when he woke up. But, as Gandalf would say, needs must. And Bilbo absolutely needed to go back to deal with the pesky Ring problem himself. He couldn’t in good conscience leave the task for someone else, no matter what the personal consequences might be.

“What must I do?”

Yavanna untangled her hands form his to pick up the wreath of yarrow in her lap and placed it on his head. Then she gestured at the soft grass. “Rest. He will be with you when you wake.”

Well, he’d certainly never say no to a nap.

So Bilbo got comfortable again and almost closed his eyes, but paused. “Thank you.”

Yavanna looked at him, and her ever-changing eyes were fond and loving and sad all at once. “Sleep, Bilbo.”

It was not at all difficult to do as she said, and he soon drifted off to the sound of her singing. 

 

***

 

Bilbo knew he was awake because every last inch of his body hurt, from the top of is head to the tips of his toes, and a tight pressure wound around his chest made it difficult to draw in a full breath. The air was thick with the smell of bitter herbs, blood, and a scent that familiar to him, yet entirely indescribable—magic. The bed beneath him was lumpy and uncomfortable, and the weight of many blankets pressed down on him, adding to the already suffocating heat.

It was all deeply unpleasant, and in the muddled sludge of his half-conscious mind, he thought he’d rather be asleep.

But there was a voice, deep and familiar, murmuring rhythmically in the language of stone, sounding somewhere between a song and a prayer. That voice held a direct line to his heart and it tugged and pleaded with him to return to the waking world with a desperation impossible to ignore.

Slowly, reluctantly, he managed to pry his eyes open and turn his head. Just that tiny movement was agonizing, but it was worth it.

The dwarf at his bedside was beautiful—dark head bowed and haloed by flickering firelight, long hair falling loose from where it was tied at the nape of his neck. His strong brow, bathed in shadow, was carved with deep worry-lines and his face was wet with tears. But, oh, he was breathtaking.

He sat still as stone save for the movement of his lips and as Bilbo watched, more tears fell and trickled into his beard. Bilbo could practically feel his dwarf’s grief as though it were his own and it hurt.

No, that wouldn’t do at all.

Painfully, he raised a shaking hand to press his palm to Thorin’s cheek.

Deep blue eyes flew open, wet and glistening. “Bilbo.”

His name was a broken gasp and Bilbo felt the warmth of new tears spilling onto his fingers.

“Don’t cry, my dear,” he rasped, then lost what little strength he’d managed to muster and dropped his arm back to the bed.

If anything, Thorin’s broad shoulders shook more and he let out a ragged sob, reaching to take Bilbo’s hand in his own. “You came back.”

“Of course I did.” His cough quickly turned into a strangled cough that sent fire racing through his ribs and lungs and made his vision blur and eyes sting. Cool water dripped between his parted lips and he swallowed it gratefully. It was a minute or two before he managed to get his breath back. “Silly dwarf. You thought I’d leave you to bumble through this on your own?”

Thorin huffed and shook his head, kissing Bilbo’s knuckles. “I thought I lost you.”

There wasn’t much chance of that happening anytime soon—his decision to live made sure of it. But Bilbo wasn’t ready to think about it yet, let alone explain what he’d done, so he smiled instead and tried to make his tone teasing. “Lose me? Impossible.”

Everything hurt and Bilbo could barely move or breathe, but it was worth it, if only so he could see Thorin’s face and hear his voice one more time. It was worth it. 

He almost said so, but was interrupted.

“Not at all impossible, Master Baggins, considering that only moments ago, you were dead.”

That was when Bilbo realized they had an audience, and it was with complete incredulity that he turned his head to find none other than King Thranduil himself sitting at his bedside.

The elf was perched on a stool that was far too short for one of his stature and he seemed to be struggling to keep up his usual haughty exterior. There was a grey pallor to his skin and clear signs of exhaustion in the tightness around his eyes, and he stared at Bilbo with nothing short of utter disbelief.

Bilbo imagined his own expression looked quite similar. 

He spluttered for a moment, casting around wildly in his mind for a response, but drew a blank. With a lack of anything more appropriate to say, his tongue stumbled over the first two gasping words he could find.

“Good morning!”

Notes:

Hello! It's been exactly seven years since I posted the first chapter of TFWWB, and I admit I was starting to believe I would never finish it. In a way, I don't regret that it's taken me so long. This fic serves as representation of how much my writing style has grown over the years and it's so special to me. Each new chapter, I can see how my voice developed and improved. I started writing this fic when I was an angsty teenager on the verge of graduating high school, and now I'm two years past my college graduation with a degree in creative writing to show for it. So much has happened between then and now, and I'm so utterly grateful to everyone who's followed me on this journey--whether you were here from the very beginning, or you joined me along the way, or you find this fic after I've finished it. I appreciate you. So so much. Thank you for all your amazing comments over the years. They're truly what motivated me the most to keep going. I hope this final chapter is a satisfying end. Personally, I love it.

Obviously, there are a lot of questions left unanswered and while this fic is done, the story is far from finished. There will be a sequel that follows Bilbo's journey to destroy the Ring, but before that, I'm going to be writing a fic that runs parallel to this one, and includes povs from all the other characters--and especially from the rest of the Company. One of my biggest regrets about this fic is that when I wrote the first half of it, my focus was solely on Bilbo and Thorin. The other dwarves were in the periphery. They were supporting cast and little more than that. But over the years, I've come to love them all dearly and they've become fully fleshed out people in my mind. By the time I realized how much I'd been neglecting them in the narrative and how little screentime they were getting, it was too late to fix it. It would have disrupted the established structure of the fic and I would have had to go back to the very beginning and rework everything. I didn't want to do that, and I still don't, so instead we're getting a separate fic where I dive into everyone else's perspectives as they witness the ridiculousness that is Thorin and Bilbo. And there will probably be a few extra scenes in Thorin and Bilbo's povs that I wish I had come up with earlier. I'm not sure how long it will take for the first chapter to be posted, but I'm working on it, so keep an eye out for it, if that's something you're interested in.

Farewell for now! (See you soon.)