Chapter Text
Bilbo was too preoccupied in his argument with Thorin to notice when the singing in the cavern just ahead stopped. It wasn’t until an angry creature dropped from the ceiling above, hissing and screaming, that he realized. And by then it was too late.
Thorin was knocked to the ground by the attack and Bilbo stumbled back with a yelp. It took him a moment to regain his balance, by which time his companion was wrestling a sickeningly familiar creature that haunted his dreams for many years after his first journey ended—then again during the War of the Ring.
Shaking himself, Bilbo forced his thoughts back to the present then raised his sword and lunged forward to help.
Gollum’s long fingers were straining to wrap around Thorin’s throat as the dwarf cursed loudly in khuzdul and held him off.
The moment Sting’s sharp point touched Gollum’s neck, the foul thing let out a furious hiss and turned to leap on Bilbo, but stopped abruptly when the blade pointed to the place just above his heart.
“Get off of him,” Bilbo demanded.
Gollum glared at him hatefully, but when he was poked lightly with the sword he clambered off the dwarf and backed away.
Thorin angrily rose to his feet and moved to Bilbo’s side, heaving his own sword up and pointing it at Gollum threateningly.
“Akhamân,” he grumbled.
“Nê aglub uduhu,” Bilbo responded without a second thought.
From the corner of his eye, he saw Thorin look at him in surprise and he silently cursed himself for the blunder. He was sure he’d have to explain away the mistake later. Maybe he could say that one of the other dwarves had taught him some simple phrases. Fili or Kili would probably make the best excuse, they were young and brash and it might be believable that they had broken their people’s traditions of secrecy. It was a problem to deal with some other time, though. At the moment, there were more important things to worry about.
He turned his attention back to Gollum, who was in the middle of talking to himself.
“They’ve gots elvish blades, but they’re not elfs. No, the hairy ones a nasty dwarvses. Its meats is tough and hard to chew. But not the other. It’s not elfs or dwarvses. What is it, precious? Is it soft? Is it juicy?”
Thorin growled and pointed Orcrist threateningly. “Watch your tongue or you will lose it.”
“What I am is none of your concern. Given the chance, you would eat me nonetheless,” Bilbo said distastefully while shooting a small glance at Thorin.
“Let’s just kill the thing and get out of here.”
When the dwarf took a step forward, Bilbo threw out a hand to stop him. “We are not going to kill him,” he hissed.
“We have wasted enough time as it is. We need to find the others—”
“Are they lost, precious?”
“Quiet, you little—”
“Yes actually,” Bilbo interrupted. “We are lost, and we’d like to get unlost as quickly as possible.”
“Ooh! We knows! We knows safe paths! Safe paths through the dark!” Gollum blurted out, sounding much more cheerful than he had moments before. Then he scowled darkly and spat. “Shut up.”
“Fantastic. Is there anyway I could convince you to show us the path?”
“This is no time for riddles, Bilbo,” Thorin hissed.
Bilbo furrowed his brows and glanced over at him. “Who said anything about riddles?”
The dwarf looked ready to start tearing his beard out, but he didn’t get the chance to respond. He was cut off by a gurgling sound let out by Gollum.
“Riddles, precious? We loves riddles!” he rasped, his grotesque blue orbs widening in delight as he turned them on Bilbo. “Does it like games? Does it, does it? Does it like to play?”
Riddles it is, Bilbo thought. He hadn't really intended on challenging Gollum to a competition this time around, but there was no going back now.
Thorin groaned. “No—”
“Not you!” Gollum spat.
Seizing his chance, Bilbo spoke up quickly. “I’ll tell you what. You and I will have a game of riddles, just the two of us. And when we’re done, you will show us the way out.”
“Yes, yes! But only if it wins. If it loses, we eats it whole.”
“Fair enough.” Thorin made a sound of protest and Bilbo shot him a look. “Shush.”
Grumbling indignantly, the dwarf made no further attempt to argue, but continued to watch Gollum like he was ready to jump forward and thrust his sword through the creature’s chest at any given moment.
Bilbo shook his head then looked back to Gollum and sheathed Sting. “Would you prefer to go first, or shall I?”
***
The game went by much faster than Bilbo remembered, but then, he did have all of the answers to Gollum’s riddles memorized. With each riddle that passed, his opponent grew increasingly frustrated, and Bilbo wasn’t too hopeful that he would actually lead them out of the mountain. Still, this was better than outright killing him. As much as Bilbo disliked the creature, there was no way of knowing how Gollum’s premature death might affect future events. It was too big of a risk—and not one he was willing to take.
So they played.
“All things it devours; birds, beasts, trees, flowers. Gnaws iron, bites steel, grinds hard stones to meal.” Gollum had perched himself on top of a rock so that they were at eye level to each other.
Bilbo knew the answer, of course. This was the riddle that he had gotten stuck on all those many years ago. The next one would be the last, though, so he hesitated a second or two before responding. “The answer is time.”
Letting out an agonized shriek, Gollum flung himself to the ground and began banging his hands on the stone, like a particularly spoiled child throwing a tantrum after being told 'no.'
Bilbo watched with distaste and silently thanked Yavanna that Frodo had never been so badly behaved. He was grateful that Primula had managed to teach her son good manners before the end.
Once Gollum calmed and regained some semblance of control over himself, he sat back on his haunches and looked at Bilbo with glittering, hungry eyes. “One more, then we tastes its juicy flesh.”
Up until that point, Thorin had thankfully stayed quiet, but he growled at Gollum for the comment.
Bilbo ignored him and kept his focus on Gollum. “Very well. Listen close because I’m only saying it once.”
“Give us the riddle.”
“Small in size I may be, but not in power. If a man uses me, his mind I devour. I will give him greed. His love I will take. To destroy me he’ll bleed, but I will not break.” Bilbo finished reciting the riddle, then gave a curt nod, and stood up straight.
Gollum’s face scrunched up, making him look even more like a shriveled and rotten squash than before. When he started muttering to himself, Bilbo took the chance to glance at Thorin.
“Look across the cavern. Do you see a tunnel anywhere?” he whispered.
Thorin huffed irritably but did as he asked, peering into the deeper darkness that Bilbo’s eyes couldn’t pierce. Then he nodded. “I see one.”
“Good. Get ready to run.”
Surprisingly, Thorin didn’t give any further argument.
Just as he turned his attention back to Gollum, the creature’s huge eyes filled with something close to understanding and he met Bilbo’s gaze.
“Oh, but how does it know, precious? How does it know?” His voice was unnervingly soft.
Bilbo’s hand tightened around the hilt of his sword and his body tensed. Gollum would realize the Ring was missing soon enough. He prayed that Thorin could lead them out because he certainly wouldn’t be able to remember the path they would need to take to escape.
“It doesn’t matter. It won’t know anymore once it’s dead.” Sure enough, Gollum reached for the pouch of his grungy little loincloth. His face went paler—if such a thing was even possible—then he was rooting around in the pocket and started pulling out pebbles and strings and other things, looking more and more desperate. “Where is it?!” he wailed, and spun in a circle, searching the ground at his feet. He stopped and whirled to look at Bilbo again. “It knows! The nasty thief! It stoles it!”
Heart in his throat, Bilbo shoved his hand into his pocket and closed his fingers around something metal and cold. "If you want it so badly, go get it!"
He cocked his arm back, then threw with as much strength as he could manage. The troll-hoard coin glinted gold and disappeared in the darkness, then clattered against stone a few moments later.
Gollum howled with rage and went tearing after it.
For a moment, Bilbo couldn’t move. Then a hand strong hand around his arm dragged him out of his stupor into a run.
“Time to go!” Thorin yelled.
Bilbo stumbled, then got his balance and blindly followed the dwarf. He could hardly see anything in the dark, yet by some miracle he managed not to trip over anything. He could just make out the gaping entrance to the tunnel when an ugly shriek echoed off the walls of the cavern around them, followed by unintelligible cursing.
Bilbo just kept on running.
He skidded out of the cavern into the tunnel, and heard the sound of bare feet slapping against stone behind him. Then a heavy weight crashed into his back and sent him tumbling to the floor. For a moment, there were hands squeezing his neck and he was surrounded by Gollum’s putrid scent. Then he was gone.
Coughing and sputtering, Bilbo sat up just as Thorin threw Gollum down and raised his sword.
“No!”
The dwarf froze for half a second and looked at him. It gave time for Gollum to lunge, but not fast enough. Thorin turned back, and for a brief moment Bilbo feared he would cut Gollum down, but instead he struck the creature over the head with the butt of his sword.
Gollum collapsed on the ground, dazed, and Bilbo stared at him until a strong hand gripped his arm and pulled him to his feet. Thorin let go of him just long enough to take his hand. Then they ran.
***
They burst out of the mountain into the cool night air at a full sprint.
There was no sign they were being followed, but neither of them wanted to take the chance of slowing down. They didn’t stop until they were several yards away from the tunnel mouth.
Panting heavily, Bilbo put his hands on his knees and fought to regain his breath.
Several moments passed before he stood straight again, and when he did it was to find Thorin staring at him.
“What is it?”
“Bilbo, there is something I must tell you—” Thorin stopped and sucked in a sharp breath, looking at something over Bilbo’s shoulder.
Confused, Bilbo turned, then felt a pit of dread suddenly drop in his belly.
The slopes below them were ablaze, the flaming trees glowing red against the dark sky.
How they hadn’t noticed it sooner, he had no idea. The air smelled of smoke and if he listened closely, he could hear the faint roar of the raging fires.
Immediately, Thorin ran past him and went hurtling down the hill. There was nothing Bilbo could do but follow him.
Luckily, they didn’t cross paths with any stray wargs or orcs on their way down. None that were alive, at least. The trail of bodies lead them directly towards the cliff, and with each step they took, Bilbo’s heart sunk lower.
Before long, they could hear the shouting.
Thorin stopped so suddenly that Bilbo ran into him. He had no time to say anything before the dwarf dragged him behind a large boulder.
They both peeked over the top of it and Bilbo let out a shuddering breath.
Twelve dwarves were perched precariously in the tree at the very edge of the cliff, along with Gandalf who was providing them with flaming pinecones. Bilbo couldn’t see well enough to tell if any of them were injured, but he was relieved to see they were all there. It was only a small comfort, though.
Two wargs were at the base of the tree, slamming their full weights against the trunk over and over again so that it shook dangerously. Over a dozen orcs cheered them on and threw taunts at their cornered prey in their own harsh language.
In the middle of them all, sitting astride a white warg, was Azog.
Bilbo couldn’t help but close his eyes at the sight. The Pale Orc was yet another figure that had plagued his nightmares for many years. Moreso, even, than Gollum. It was he, after all, who had ultimately brought an end to his adventure. He who had caused the hollowness in Bilbo’s heart that had never truly gone away, even in his old age when his memory began to fail him. No, that was a hurt that had never healed.
Shaking away the unpleasant thoughts, Bilbo glanced over at Thorin.
The dwarf’s face was full of rage and grief...and determination. Bilbo noted how tight his grip on Orcrist was, his knuckles white. How he looked ready to spring into action at any moment.
Bilbo reached out and caught hold of Thorin’s coat just as he made a move to climb on top of the boulder.
“Don’t you dare,” he hissed.
Thorin’s gaze didn't waver, hatred making his blue eyes burn as bright as the fire that surrounded them. “I could kill him now, before he ever has the chance to—”
“What do you keep in that thick skull of yours? Rocks?” When he still didn’t look away, Bilbo sighed and softened his tone slightly. “If you go charging in there right now and get yourself killed, none of us will ever to make it to Erebor. Don’t throw this quest away for the sake of blind revenge.”
Thorin wavered, then his shoulders slumped. “You are right.”
“Of course I am,” Bilbo said and resisted the urge to let out a relieved sigh.
“What do you suggest we do?”
“We need a plan.”
“Do you have any ideas?” Thorin asked.
“One,” Bilbo answered, shooting a glance at him. “But you’re not going to like it.”
***
He was right; Thorin hated it. And if he was being entirely honest, he hated it too, but they didn’t know what else to do. So after several minutes spent arguing in quiet whispers, they finally came to an agreement.
“You know exactly what you’re supposed to do?”
“Yes,” Thorin said, sounding upset.
Nodding curtly, Bilbo got to his feet and made to head off, but Thorin grabbed his hand and stopped him mid-step.
There was a strange look in his eyes and when he spoke his tone was even stranger. “No matter what happens, do not place yourself between me and Azog again. I cannot do this without you.”
Then he was gone and Bilbo was left gaping like a fish out of water.
Again? What did he mean again? This was the first time they had come across Azog on their journey. Further still, Bilbo had never thrown himself in front of Thorin like the dwarf had implied. Not in this lifetime, anyway. And it wasn’t as though the Thorin knew about any of that—
No. Surely not.
Head spinning, Bilbo took a deep breath and struggled to reel in his thoughts. He didn’t have time for wild speculation. He needed to save his friends.
It was with great difficulty that he pushed everything to the back of his mind and snuck a glance around the side of the boulder.
All of the orcs had their full attention on the dwarves above them, who at this point had all stopped throwing their flaming pine cones and were now clutching at the branches around them. The wargs were still attacking the trunk, and with every hit the tree shook and swayed.
Taking advantage of everyone’s distraction, Bilbo kept his head down and scampered from tree to tree to rock, making his way closer to the cliff’s edge. Before long, he reached the tree closest to the one that held the Company and—keeping as quiet as he could manage—he climbed up into its branches.
By the time he reached a height where he was reasonably sure nobody could reach him, his hands and legs were scuffed and bleeding. He ignored the stinging scrapes and surveyed the ground below him. It seemed that he had managed to avoid detection, which was a small blessing. If he was spotted, this would probably never work. Granted, it probably wouldn’t work anyways.
Putting his hands up to his mouth, he hooted twice like a barn owl and once like a brown owl.
His signal was answered two seconds later by an identical call, then a deep voice rang out across the clearing. “Azog!”
The single word alone was enough to cause an outcry. The dwarves all let out a deafening cheer and the orcs screeched and howled, spinning to locate where the voice had come from and brandishing their crude weapons.
From where Bilbo sat, he got a perfect view of Azog’s grotesque smile just before the orc turned his warg and put his back to the rest of the Company.
Bilbo couldn’t help but lean forward to catch a glimpse of what was happening, and what he saw took his breath away.
Halfway up a tall pine, Thorin stood steady on a thick branch, gazing down at Azog with cold fury. Orcrist glowed blue in his hand. The flickering light of the fires made him seem almost otherworldly. He looked...well, Bilbo didn’t know how to describe it. Just that in that moment, there could be no question as to who was the rightful King of dwarves.
The Defiler shouted something in black speech that was very obviously a taunt and pointed his metal claw at Thorin.
The dwarf’s face twisted into a snarl and he yelled something back, but Bilbo didn’t know what was said. All he could hear was the deep groan of the Company's tree as it slowly leaned back over the cliff’s edge.
Whipping around, Bilbo noted with no small amount of alarm that the tree was barely clinging to the earth with its roots. A few more hits and it would tip. Utterly rabid, the wargs aimed to do just that.
Bilbo tore open his rucksack and grabbed a hefty stone off the top. Then, winding up, he threw it with as much strength as he had and sent it soaring through the air to hit one of the wargs on its rump. When it turned to face its attacker, it promptly caught another to the eye. It yelped and stumbled, shaking its head madly. When it stopped, its uninjured eye landed straight on Bilbo. With a roar, the warg charged at his tree and slammed into it like a battering ram.
It shook enough that he had to grab onto the branch to keep his balance, and he immediately pulled his feet up, wary of the beast’s foaming jaws and snapping fangs. Frozen for a moment, Bilbo couldn’t help but stare down at it as it tried again and again to jump high enough to reach him.
There was a creak, a groan, and a crack, then somebody—Ori, it sounded like—let out a piercing scream.
Snapped out of his daze, Bilbo watched with horror as the tree finally toppled.
It went down with a crash and left the entire Company dangling in the open air.
The second warg was hit by the tree's roots as they were ripped from the ground and was thrown several feet away. It lay stunned for a moment, then clambered back to its feet. Setting its sights on the dwarves that were now well within reach, it prowled closer.
With the realization that the added weight of the warg was likely to send the entire tree tumbling off the cliff, Bilbo scrambled to grab another rock, but his hand only found bark.
His pack was gone.
Looking down, he found that the warg had paused in its attempt to reach him in favor of ripping his supplies to hundreds of little pieces.
Desperately, Bilbo looked between the two wargs several times.
“Dear Yavanna, this is a terrible idea,” he muttered.
Then, with nothing else to do, he drew his sword, took a deep breath, and pushed off the branch.
The warg below didn’t even have time to look up before his blade was thrust straight through the top of its head.
The impact knocked the breath out of Bilbo and he wheezed, pushing himself off the ground. Stumbling, he fell against the dead warg and nearly gagged at the awful stench of it. He stood again and grabbed a hold of Sting, giving three big tugs before he managed to pull it from the warg’s skull.
He swung around to find that the other warg hadn’t even noticed him and was just beginning to climb onto the tree, its eyes locked on Dwalin.
Scooping a rock off the ground, Bilbo said a silent prayer and let it fly.
It found its mark.
The warg whirled around with a furious snarl and its attention settled on him.
Bilbo heard Fili scream a warning, then the warg charged. He watched it get closer, rooted to the spot and unable to move. Just as he saw the whites of its eyes, he dropped to the ground.
The warg leapt.
Bilbo threw his arms over his head, waiting for the teeth that would surely turn him to ribbons.
But nothing happened.
Instead, there was a skidding noise, then a yelp.
Bilbo looked up just as the warg went off the cliff.
He sat there in shock for several moments, then got the presence of mind to turn his attention back to the clearing. By some miracle, his wild endeavor to take on two wargs single-handedly had gone unnoticed.
Thorin was performing his role well. He was still shouting insults at the orcs and wargs swarming his tree, and had taken to chucking rocks down into the fray below and swinging his sword at any who managed to climb within his reach.
Azog still sat upon his warg, silently watching the dwarf’s efforts.
For a few short moments, Bilbo almost thought that Thorin would be able to keep their enemies distracted until the eagles arrived. Then he spotted a lone orc near the outskirts of the pack.
In its hands, it held Kili’s bow. It was in the process of taking aim.
Straight at Thorin.
Bilbo didn’t wait to consider his options. He was on his feet and sprinting at the orc before he even knew what he was doing. Somebody yelled at him to stop, but he didn’t so much as falter.
Halfway to his target, a familiar object caught his eye and he slowed long enough to heave it off the ground. It was much lighter than he would have expected, and felt as though it molded perfectly to his arm.
Where the oak shield had come from and how it had gotten there, Bilbo didn’t care.
He slammed into the orc just before it released its arrow.
***
What happened after that, he wasn’t entirely sure. All he knew was that he ended up on the ground, his sight going in and out of focus and his head feeling like it had been cracked open like the first summer melon. The noise and chaos surrounding him was muffled and far away, the ringing in his ears far louder than anything else. As his eyes dimmed, he could have sworn he saw a woman in green standing encompassed by flames, watching him with calm eyes.
Then everything went dark.
