Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 23: Of Sleeping Monsters

Summary:

While they prepare to leave Laketown, Thorin shares his worries about the gold-sickness with Bilbo and attempts to get his hands on the one weapon in the land that can kill a dragon.

Notes:

This is a really short one--just a small scene between our favorite hobbit and dwarf. It was meant to be the beginning of a much longer chapter, but I don't have the energy to finish it right now. I just want to post something in honor of Bilbo's birthday, even if it isn't much. I'll get around to finishing it eventually. Be patient with me.

Happy Hobbit Day!

 

EDIT:

Hello! It's been almost a year since I originally posted the first scene of this chapter, and I've finally finished writing the rest of it! At this point, we're all aware of my abysmal ability to update regularly, so I'm not going to even try to make any promises or predictions about when the next chapter will be out because I always end up turning myself into a liar, BUT I just graduated from college and lost my job, so I have absolutely nothing to do with my life at the moment. Ideally, that means I'll finally have time to write and maybe get a little more frequent with my updates. Fingers crossed!

As always, please let me know if you notice any mistakes so I can fix them.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“Bilbo.”

“Hm?”

The room was fairly drafty, allowing the breeze off the lake to slip in through the cracks in the house and drape everything in a light chill. Thorin barely felt the cold, but he knew hobbits didn’t have the same natural resistance to harsh weather as dwarves did. Even Bilbo, who was far more tried and tested than others of his kind could not fend off the fast approaching winter. It was why they had ended up here, sitting side by side on Thorin’s bed with their shoulders pressed together and a fire roaring in the hearth.

The rest of the house was completely silent. It was a stark contrast to their first journey. Back then, the night before leaving for the mountain had been one of celebration, filled with song and food and drink. Maybe a bit too much, in the case of the last one, considering that more than a few of their Company had been incredibly hung over the next morning. 

This time was a different story.

No one seemed too eager to celebrate tonight, though Thorin was sure he wouldn’t be hard pressed to find a few drinking dwarves in the house if he tried.

He didn’t mind the lack of a party. Really, sitting there in the quiet was preferable, given that this was the last quiet night they would get for the foreseeable future. He only wished he could enjoy it, but the heavy weight in his chest and the sour taste of dread in his mouth made it difficult.

When Thorin didn’t say anything else, Bilbo nudged him.

This journey so far was just one hard conversation after another. He was getting tired of it. Still, this was important. And as much as he wanted to never speak of it at all, he knew this wasn’t something he could stay silent on.

So, he sighed and kept his eyes locked firmly on his hands when he spoke. “The Arkenstone…”

The hobbit tensed beside him. “What about it?”

“If you find it, do not give it to me. Do not even tell me you have it.”

Outside, the wind howled and the house around them shook. He couldn’t stand to look, but he could feel Bilbo staring at him.

“Thorin—”

“Please, Bilbo.” He hated the desperation in his own voice. “Hide it somewhere safe and leave it there until the dragon is gone and the battle is over. Promise me.”

He stole a glance at the hobbit to see that his brows were furrowed and his lips pursed. But his eyes were clear, and there was a sad sense of understanding in them.

Bilbo nodded once. “I promise.”

Thorin let out a long and slumped a bit, letting his shoulders relax and leaning his head back against the wall.

For several minutes, nothing more was said and Thorin thought the conversation was over.

Then Bilbo took another sip of his tea and spoke again, his voice calm. “Do you mind if I ask what it is you’re so worried about?”

“Do you not know?”

“Tell me anyway.”

Thorin sighed and dragged a hand over his face. It was not something he wanted to dwell on. The sea of treasure stretching on in all directions. The heavy weight of his grandfather’s crown resting on his brow and jeweled rings on his fingers. The way his thoughts were muddled and his words harsh—his actions harsher. The light of dragon-fire glinting on gold that seemed more enchanting than dangerous. The whispers in his mind. All of it was too much.

Still, he answered his hobbit. How could he not?

“I worry that when we enter the mountain, the gold-sickness will consume me once again. It was like being in a haze. I knew what I was doing, but I did not care. I am afraid I will hurt you all in my blind greed once again. That I will turn on you as I did before. I am afraid of becoming that…monster again.”

Bilbo was quiet, then—

“I don’t think that’s going to happen, Thorin,” he said softly.

“Why not?”

“Because this time, we know it’s coming.”

He said it in such a matter-of-fact tone that Thorin turned and looked at him, incredulous. “That does not make me feel better.”

Bilbo snorted and set his tea down on the bedside table, then reached out to take Thorin’s hand. “Maybe not, but knowing makes it easier to handle it when it comes. Not easy, but easier.”

“How can you be so sure?”

“If I can do it, I have no doubt you can, too.” 

His eyes darkened for a moment, expression falling, then his small smile was back so quickly, Thorin almost thought he’d imagined it. He swallowed and laced his fingers with the hobbit’s.

Bilbo’s smile grew. “Let’s make a deal, shall we?”

His hand was warm from holding the mug of tea, and he smelled of chamomile. It was calming, and the look on his face quelled Thorin’s questions for the moment, though he was confused. He waited.

“I’ll keep an eye on you and your behavior, and if at some point I’m worried that you’re starting to let the sickness cloud your judgement, I’ll tell you. Or knock some sense into you. Whichever I think will be more effective.”

He had no doubt of that. Thorin chuckled. “And what would you ask of me in return?”

“Simple. I’ll keep an eye on you as long as you promise to do the same for me.” Bilbo shrugged, as though trying to look nonchalant, but there was something somber that lingered.

“What for?”

Smile falling, Bilbo sighed deeply and looked away. “I told you how the Ring gets into people’s heads. In a way, I suppose it’s similar to the gold-sickness in that regard.”

“You have been struggling with it?”

Thorin’s throat tightened and he gripped Bilbo’s hand a little tighter. He knew well enough the evils of gold. He knew better than most. The thought of Bilbo going through anything remotely similar to the gold-sickness was nauseating. A memory, distant and near forgotten, flashed in his mind—in the tunnels under the Misty Mountains, when he found a Ring in the dark and it showed him the treasure hoard of Erebor and, for a brief moment, it brought the sickness back. That terrible spark of anger when Bilbo took the Ring from his hand.

“I’ve been managing it so far, but there’s no guarantee I can resist forever.” Bilbo looked down at their hands, and his eyes softened slightly. There was something both annoyed and weary in his next words. “It has a tendency to latch onto your greatest desires and constantly tries to find ways to exploit them. To prove that it can help you achieve them, if only you put it on.”

He spoke as though the Ring had a mind of its own. It unnerved him, but Thorin didn’t try to ask more. If Bilbo wanted him to know, he’d tell him.

They sat quietly together for a while longer, but when Bilbo yawned for the fourth time in a span of a few minutes, Thorin glanced down at him and quirked a slight smile. “It is going to be an early start. You should rest.

The hobbit looked ready to protest, but was interrupted by yet another yawn. With a huff, he nodded his agreement and moved to stand. 

Thorin felt the loss of his touch keenly, but ignored it. He got to his feet, too, and followed Bilbo to the door. He reached for the knob to open it, but then Bilbo’s hand was on his wrist, stopping him.

Pausing, he looked down at him and suddenly forgot how to breathe.

Bilbo was so close—just inches away from his chest, round face tilted back, hazel eyes looking up at him intently with all the weight of a mountain in their gaze.

And then Bilbo rose up on his toes and pressed his lips softly to his cheek and Thorin’s mind went utterly blank.

It lasted mere seconds, and then the hobbit was pulling away and taking a step back. His cheeks were slightly pink, but his quiet voice was steady when he spoke, if not a bit rueful. “For the record, I never thought you were a monster.”

He turned and slipped out the door before Thorin had the chance to stop reeling.


***

Despite telling Bilbo to get some rest, Thorin had trouble following his own advice. He laid awake for hours, staring up at the ceiling above him, his mind too loud to sleep. There was just too much to think about—too much that could go wrong within the next couple of weeks, between the gold-sickness and the dragon and the battle and Azog. He was worried for his sister-sons. For Fili, who was putting up a brave front and pretending to be unbothered by the news of his own death. And for Kili, who had barely eaten or spoken a word to anyone in days. He worried for Bilbo and what the Ring might be doing to him. He worried for his entire Company.

They would all follow him to the very end, he knew—he was just afraid of what that end might be.

His one comfort was that Mahal himself had sent him back to see this quest fulfilled. And if the Maker believed it could be done, then it must be possible. Still, knowing it was possible didn’t get him any closer to knowing what exactly it was that he needed to do. And it certainly didn’t help with the problem of the dragon.

Somehow, they had to bring Smaug down—preferably before he got the chance to leave the mountain and take out his wrath on the people of Lake-town.

He spent the night working through scenario after doomed scenario, trying to find one that seemed plausible. Then, an hour or two before dawn, he had an idea. So he got out of bed, pulled on his boots, and snuck out of the house into the frigid cold.

It took longer than he liked to navigate Lake-town—the boardwalks had no apparent organization system, and many of them ended in dead ends—but he eventually found his destination, more through sheer luck than anything else. He started up the wooden stairs, stepping as lightly as possible to avoid waking anyone. By the time he stood before the weather-beaten door, the sky was beginning to grow lighter.

Steeling himself for what he was about to do, he knocked three times.

Despite the early hour, only a few seconds passed before the door opened. Seeing as Bard was already bundled up in a thick coat, Thorin supposed the man would be heading out onto the lake soon.

Bard scowled the moment his eyes landed on Thorin. The man had been no more happy about learning the dwarves’ purpose this time than he had the last. “What is it?”

“You are a descendant of Girion, Lord of Dale.”

Bard stared at him blankly, then gave a slight nod. “My great grandfather.”

“May I come in?”

After several moments during which Thorin was sure the door was going to be slammed in his face, he was invited in. It was substantially warmer inside the home, and he was grateful for it.

“Well?” the man asked.

“Had the city not fallen, you would likely be its Lord today.”

Bard shrugged and turned his back on Thorin, walking into his kitchen where he seemed to be filling a knapsack with food. “What could have been does not matter. Such fancies do not put food on my table.”

“No, it does not. But if you had the chance to change things, would you take it?” He took a few steps further into the house and glanced around the room, searching, though he hoped he merely looked curious.

“I do not have time for what ifs, Master Dwarf.” Closing the knapsack, he looked at Thorin again. “Unless you have something of actual substance you would like to say to me, I have work to do. The barrels of Mirkwood will not collect themselves, and it is a long journey to the mouth of the river.”

“If Dale were restored to its former glory, would you take your rightful place as its king?”

The man’s eyes narrowed. “I have no desire for power.”

“Even if it would bring your people out of poverty and into prosperity once more?”

At that, Bard said nothing.

Finally, Thorin’s eyes found what he was looking for. There.

With no more reason to continue beating around the bush for time, he looked back to Bard. “Come with us.”

“What.”

Before he had the chance to second guess himself, Thorin went on. “When Girion climbed the tower and tried to kill the dragon with the wind-lance, he had three black arrows. The first missed. The second made a hole in Smaug’s armor, loosening the scale on the chest under the left wing—”

“I would not put so much stock into myths and stories.”

“I have lived through myths and stories, Master Bard. They should not be so lightly dismissed.”

Unmoved by the admission, Bard responded dryly. “What is your point?”

“He never had the chance to fire the third black arrow. Supposedly, no one has seen it since, but I hardly believe that the Line of Girion would have so easily abandoned an heirloom so important as that. Help us destroy the dragon. Do what your forefather could not.”

There was a long silence in which Bard clenched his jaw and turned away from Thorin, his shoulders tight. He braced himself against the dining table, with his head bowed, dark hair falling to shroud his face.

When he finally spoke, his voice was low. Harsh. “You would risk the lives of everyone here on a fool’s hope.”

Thorin bit the inside of his cheek and forced himself to take a deep breath. It would help nothing for him to allow his temper to get the best of him. “A fool’s hope, maybe, but it is the only hope I have left to me.”

That, evidently, was not the right thing to say.

Bard whirled on him and his dark eyes burned with anger. “There are children in this town, Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror. My children are in this town. I cannot stop you on this path, but I will take no part in it. You will bring ruin on us all.”

The memory of Esgaroth burning bright as it was ravaged by the dragon crossed his thoughts, followed by the image of hundreds of survivors, dragging themselves into Dale for shelter. He felt the spark of his own anger go out. He knew how it felt to watch his people travel over the lands, homeless and hopeless.

He let out a long breath. “I do not blame you for it, though you are right that you cannot stop me. I will return to Erebor, with or without your help. But if you will not come with me, please, give me what I need to kill the dragon before it ever gets the chance to leave the mountain. The black arrow.”

“What makes you so sure I have it?”

Thorin glanced above the table to where a rod of black steel was hung with pots and pans and other things. An interesting place to keep it, given that it was the only weapon in the land capable of bringing down a raging dragon.

Bard’s expression soured. Then his shoulders slumped slightly and he leaned back against the table, looking suddenly exhausted and aged. “And if you fail? If the dragon leaves the mountain and sets his sights here? Why should I give you our only hope of defense against the beast?”

As much as he hated to admit it, the man had a point. Especially given how terribly everything had gone last time, though Bard had no way of knowing about that. He was right to fear. But Thorin would not fail again. Not this time. Not in this. So he squared his shoulders, stood tall, and looked the man in the eye. “I know you have no reason to trust me, but on the graves of my forefathers I swear this—I will not allow that dragon to kill a single living soul in these lands or any other ever again. Its time is finished.”

Bard looked away from him and didn’t respond for several long moments of tense silence. When he did speak, Thorin’s heart sank.

“The Lord of Silver Fountains. The King of Carven Stone. The King Beneath the Mountain, shall come unto his own. And the bells shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King’s return. But all shall fade in sadness, and the lake will shine and burn.” He recited the prophecy with a faraway look on his face, then met Thorin’s gaze again, and his voice was quiet but firm. “I cannot give you what you seek.”

“But—”

“Go.”

There was no point in arguing. Thorin could see in Bard’s eyes that he had made up his mind, and he didn’t want to make an enemy of the man. 

And who was he to challenge that decision, when he himself would do the same had their roles been reversed?

So he bowed his head in farewell, then turned and stepped out into the dawn of a new day.

 

***

 

Bilbo found him before he could even make it through the front door, falling into step beside him as Thorin headed for his room.

“I was wondering where you got off to.”

“I am sorry if I worried you,” he said quietly.

“I knew you'd be back.” The hobbit stopped walking and grabbed Thorin’s sleeve, looking up into his eyes. There was some concern on his face. “You look exhausted.”

He didn’t ask, but Thorin could hear the unvoiced question in his tone. So he sighed and dragged a hand through his hair. “I asked Bard to come with us. Or to at least let me have the black arrow.”

If Bilbo was surprised, he didn’t show it. “I’m guessing it didn’t go well.”

“No. It did not.”

Bilbo studied him closely for a few moments, though Thorin didn’t have the energy to meet his gaze.

“Well, at least you tried.”

The hobbit linked arms with him and guided him through the house that was waking up. They passed the kitchen, where the smell of frying bacon was wafting out from. Bombur must already be up, then. Good. Breakfast would be important if they were to start traveling to the Lonely Mountain in an hour. Durin’s Day was in four days, and after that…

They would need their strength.

Neither of them spoke again until the door closed behind them in Thorin’s room. Bilbo let go of him and moved to stoke the fire back to life. 

“You’re better than me, in any case,” the hobbit said over his shoulder. 

Thorin thought his tone was rather too cheerful, given the circumstances.

“I do not know what you mean.” He dropped down into the chair by the fire and sighed, wishing he had slept.

Bilbo turned to him, a smile tugging at the corner of his lips and a note of mischief gleaming in his hazel eyes. “At least you asked. I was up half the night trying to decide if I should sneak over to Bard’s house and steal it.”

Despite how tired he was, Thorin couldn’t help his slight smile. “The house?”

“The hou—” The hobbit stopped abruptly and gave him an exasperated look. “The arrow, Thorin.”

He chuckled and felt himself relax a bit. “Why didn’t you? Steal it, I mean.”

Bilbo’s smile fell and he turned back to the fire, poking at it half-heartedly. “I’ve learned from experience that people don’t necessarily want to be friends with you after you steal from them.” Thorin felt his mouth go dry at the comment, but Bilbo went on before the guilt could really start to settle in. “More importantly, I can’t stand the thought of leaving all these people completely defenseless in case something goes wrong.”

His words were practically an echo of what Bard had said to him earlier. Somehow, Thorin found it comforting.


***

 

Less than a minute after Bilbo left to gather his things, there was a knock on Thorin’s door. He left his pack open on the bed and went to answer it, thinking the hobbit had forgotten something and come back. Instead, he found one of his sister-sons waiting impatiently in the hall. 

Fili stood with his usual confidence, head held high and shoulders back. To most who looked, he would seem the sure and steady crown prince he had been raised from birth to be. But Thorin knew him well enough to recognize the unease in his stature and the worry in his eyes. To notice the slight shift in his weight from one side to the other, struggling to settle with whatever thoughts were putting that look on his face.

Thorin stiffened. “What is it?”

Jaw clenching tight, Fili said nothing and just glanced over Thorin’s shoulder into the bedroom.

He stepped aside to allow his heir to come in.

It wasn’t until the door was shut that Fili spoke in a low voice, as though he didn’t want to risk any other hearing him. 

“Something is wrong with Kili.”

The words sent ice through him that had Thorin clenching his hands tightly at his sides—the sting of his blunt fingernails digging into his palms served as a reminder to himself that there was no need to sprint out the door and seek out the younger of his sister-sons. If Kili was in any kind of immediate danger, Fili would have started with that, and neither of them would still be standing there. 

He barely had enough time to reassure himself of such before Fili went on.

“He’s been in a terrible mood ever since we reached Lake-town. At first, I thought he was just—” He stopped abruptly, grimacing.

“Thought he was just what?”

Fili gave a sharp shake of his head. “It doesn’t matter. The point is, I don’t think it’s just a bad mood anymore. He hasn’t been eating. He barely sleeps. I think he’s sick, but he insists he’s fine and refuses to go to Oin.” 

Thorin hadn’t seen Kili since the night before last, having sought him out at Bilbo’s suggestion. His sister-son had seemed unwell at the time, but insisted he was just having difficulty sleeping. Thorin suspected his sleep troubles likely had something to do with the knowledge of how the quest had ended once before, but Kili had refused to speak of it, and Thorin hadn’t blamed him for that. He’d given the young dwarf space to try and rest as it was late at night and the conversation wasn’t going anywhere.

He hadn’t known about Kili not eating, however. 

That was troubling.

“I will speak with him.” 

He cursed himself for not doing so sooner—for not pulling them both aside and speaking to them as soon as that initial confession to the whole Company was over. Despite all his intentions of keeping his sister-sons as his top priority on this journey, he still somehow managed to allow them to slip to the back of his mind the past few days, overshadowed by how busy they’d all been getting ready to make their last push to the mountain.

It was a mistake he could not afford to continue making, yet he found that he kept making it. Again and again and again.

He would fix it right now. He would take Fili with him and they would go to Kili together, then he’d speak to both of them. Their departure from Lake-town would likely be delayed a bit, but—

“He went to the docks already with some of the others.”

Thorin had to take a slow breath to stop himself from cursing.

Of course he’d already left. It would have to wait a while longer, then.

He half expected that to be the end of the conversation, but Fili wasn’t done. He spoke again, though the words were strained, like he had to force himself to say them. “Uncle, there’s something else.”

Tensing, Thorin braced himself for what would come next.

Fili hesitated.

The elder of his sister-sons rarely faltered in words or action. Once he’d made a decision to say or do something, he did so without waiting, sticking to that decision for better or for worse. But now, he looked to be second-guessing himself.

Thorin approached him, reaching out to put a steadying hand on his shoulder. “Tell me, Fili.”

Fili nodded, but didn’t quite meet his eye when he spoke. “He didn’t give Bilbo a khajamu a’khuf.”

It took a moment to process what he’d said, then another for Thorin to be sure he’d actually heard correctly. Then he shook his head.

When someone claimed another as barafu ik-kurdu, it was custom to accept that claim with a gift. To not give a khajamu a’khuf was nothing short of rejection. It was a refusal to consider the other as kin.

That, more than anything else Fili had said about his brother’s behavior, was worrying. Kili loved their hobbit just as much as the rest of them did. If he’d yet to accept the family bond that was offered…something was even more wrong than Thorin originally thought.

“Has he said why?”

“No,” Fili said quietly. “I tried to ask him, but he got angry. I was hoping maybe Bilbo had told you something.”

The hobbit hadn’t said anything to him about lacking a gift from the youngest member of their Company. Then again, why would he? Bilbo was not familiar with their customs and thought the gifts to be unnecessary. He would not recognize such a rejection for what it was. After receiving so many gifts all at once, he probably had not even noticed one was missing. 

“We will figure it out. Kili will be alright.”

Thorin said it out loud, and he wasn’t entirely sure if the words were meant to comfort Fili or himself.

Fili nodded once, gripping Thorin’s forearm. Then he let go and ducked away from his touch, taking a step towards the door. “We should go. We’re wasting daylight.”

Thorin caught him, putting a hand on his chest to stop him. “How are you faring?”

Fili paused and met his gaze with a raised brow, a lightness back in his green eyes that had been missing before. The corner of his mouth curled up, though not enough to be a smile. “If you are referring to how I feel about the news of my apparent death in another time-line, I’m fine.”

“Fili—”

“The Fili who died in that battle was not me. I will not agonize myself over his fate.”

There was no lie in the words. No hint of doubt in them. Thorin didn’t have the heart to disagree with him, though he didn’t understand it.

Then again, Fili had no memory of that day. He could not remember the echoing sound of his dying scream on the frozen air, could not remember the jagged blade that pierced his back or the fall to ice far below.

Thorin could never forget it.

“Uncle.” Their gazes met, and there was a stone-solid certainty in Fili’s eyes, even as he grinned. “I’m still here. Don’t grieve for me while I’m standing right in front of you. It’s weird.”

Pushing past that heavy rock in his chest, Thorin did his best to return the smile, though he was sure it looked strained. “I am sorry.” 

Fili just shrugged, brushing off the apology. “Let’s get out of here. I’m sick of the stench of fish.”

Notes:

khajamu a’khuf - gift of acceptance
barafu ik-kurdu - family of the heart