Chapter Text
After a night of sleeping on the very outskirts of the abandoned city, listening to the wind whisper through the charred remains of destroyed buildings, the Company had decided that they’d prefer to travel around Dale rather than through it. The route would add about half a day’s travel to their trek to the mountain, but they unanimously agreed that the delay was worth it. No one was eager to wander through those empty streets.
So they went around, and they spent the first several hours of the day walking in silence—whether out of respect for the dead or fear of them.
Thorin wasn’t sure he believed in ghosts, but he could have sworn he felt the weight of accusing eyes bearing down on him, and he refused to allow his gaze to linger on the ruins for too long, lest he start to imagine figures that moved in the shadows.
Sometime around noon, he found himself walking beside Dwalin.
“Dori has looked like he wants to gut you even more than usual.” He said casually, pulling out his water-skin for a drink.
Indeed, the silver-haired dwarf had spent the past two days watching Dwalin with death in his eyes, fingering the axe at his side like he might actually go on the attack. Not that it was unusual—Dori had been carrying a grudge against the warrior for the entire journey this side of the Misty Mountains.
From the corner of his eye, he saw Dwalin’s expression turn incredibly smug. “Seems Ori was missing from their room our last night on the lake.”
Thorin followed his best friend’s gaze to the young scribe that walked several yards ahead of them—side by side with Bilbo and Balin, who chatted amongst themselves quietly—and sucked in a sharp breath, then immediately regretted it as he began to choke on his water.
Dwalin pounded him on the back a few times, and Thorin looked at him incredulously, his voice a little hoarse. “You didn't.”
The warrior’s smug smirk only grew, confirming that he most certainly had.
“He is going to rip you to pieces as soon as his shoulder is healed.”
It wasn’t an exaggeration. The Ri brothers were known for their strength. Dori, who had enough over-protectiveness of his youngest brother to rival that of an angry mother bear, was particularly fearsome. Those who were smart did everything they could to avoid crossing him and his dangerous temper. He didn’t need a blade—if he wanted to, he could tear Dwalin apart with his bare hands.
Not that Dwalin seemed worried about that very real danger.
“He can try.”
“He has beaten you before,” Thorin pointed out.
In fact, Dori was among the small few who had ever bested Dwalin in a fight.
“I’m not the one he needs to worry about.” Dwalin shrugged, then caught his questioning glance and elaborated. “He’ll have to get past Ori first. The lad is getting fed up with the coddling. I’d bet all the gold in Erebor he’ll win that fight without lifting a finger.”
Thorin shook his head, baffled.
Had this happened before?
He couldn’t remember ever noticing that there was some sort of relationship blooming between his shield-brother and the Company’s young scribe on the last journey. Was he just that blind, or had something on this journey changed to allow the unlikely pair to come together? He was sure nothing had changed that drastically, though. Could it just have been their extended stay in Lake-town that caused this?
The way Dwalin was staring ahead at Ori was bordering on affectionate.
“Dwalin, is he—”
He didn’t even get the chance to finish the question.
“Aye.”
The answer didn’t help his confusion. “How long have you known?”
Dwalin glanced at him and gave a one shoulder shrug. “A while.”
A while. How long was a while? Since the quest started? Longer? Surely Thorin would have noticed his best friend finding his One if it had happened last time, right?
His eyes slid to his own One consideringly. He’d have to ask Bilbo. Maybe he would know—
“When are you going to tell him?”
“What?”
“The burglar.”
“What about him?”
“You’ve been staring at his ass all day.”
Thorin tore his eyes away from Bilbo. “I have not—”
Dwalin snickered and Thorin stopped spluttering, scowling at his friend in annoyance.
“We all know what he is to you, there’s no use in denying it.”
“I do not deny it,” Thorin grumbled.
After all, he hadn’t made much an attempt to hide it as of late. He knew full well that the rest of his Company had been betting on him and Bilbo since before Beorn’s and opted to ignore it to protect his own sanity, but he wasn’t going to pretend that his heart didn’t belong to the hobbit. He’d tried, for a while, but found his efforts to be useless and abandoned them completely by the time they left Rivendell. He was sure everyone between here and the Misty Mountains knew of his affection for his burglar at this point—save for Bilbo himself, who seemed to remain willfully oblivious to it, no matter how many innuendos or teasing remarks were thrown his way by nosy dwarves who didn’t know how to mind their own business.
Bilbo’s ignorance of his feelings served Thorin’s purposes well enough, even if it frustrated him at times.
“So?” Dwalin said.
Thorin knew what he was asking, and wished he wouldn’t. “I cannot tell him.”
“What are you waiting for, an invitation? You do know he adores you?”
Of course he knew the hobbit loved him—how could he not? Bilbo wasn’t exactly discrete about it, either, even if he was utterly clueless.
“That is exactly why he cannot know.” Dwalin just gave him an empty look, and Thorin went on, not sure why he felt the need to explain himself, but a little desperate to all the same. He was careful to keep his voice low, to avoid any of the others overhearing. “I may die in this battle. How can I offer myself to him now, knowing I might take it all away again before the week is done? It would be selfish of me.”
He still couldn’t forget the way Bilbo had sounded that day at the Carrock, only hours before they were officially reunited with one another.
I refuse to watch you die, Thorin.
The hobbit deserved everything Thorin could give and more, but he could not guarantee his own survival. He did not want to make any promises he knew he might not keep. It wouldn’t be fair.
“Please tell me you’re joking,” Dwalin said, exasperated.
Thorin said nothing.
Snorting, Dwalin knocked him in the shoulder hard enough to make him stumble. “That is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.”
Thorin glared at him and snapped, “What would you have me do?”
“Mahal’s sake, Thorin, he may be dumber than a rock sometimes, but give Bilbo some credit. You didn’t force him to come on the quest, and he knew the risks better than any of us. Has it occurred to you that maybe he’d want you to tell him?”
The words were strangely familiar and made a sense of defensiveness rise in him, though he couldn’t quite recall why. Thorin’s brows furrowed and his mouth opened and closed uselessly as he failed to come up with a suitable response.
As he struggled, Dwalin snorted at him again and picked up his pace, leaving Thorin behind.
***
Far off in the distance, the sun was beginning to set behind the Misty Mountains, painting the horizon in a smear of glowing golden light. The ruins of Dale, hidden as they were within the hills at the foot of Erebor, were already cast into shadow, and its crumbling silhouette was eerie. They’d chosen to camp at the top of one of those hills, tucked behind a stand of sharp boulders that blocked them from the city’s sight, and it would hopefully grant them some measure of peace as they slept—none of them had been comfortable traveling so near to the city’s remains, and as soon as they’d escaped its looming shadows, several of the Company had nervously joked about the sensation of feeling watched as they passed by.
Soon after stopping for the night, though, Thorin found himself venturing back into the open with Bilbo at his side. Carrying the Company’s empty water-skins, they made their way down the craggy slope of the hill, headed for a stream that gurgled at the bottom.
Dwalin’s words from earlier wouldn’t stop echoing in his mind, and Thorin watched the hobbit from the corner of his vision, wondering if his shield-brother was right.
Was it foolish of him not to tell Bilbo what he was to him while he still had the chance to do so? Maybe he should.
“Bilbo.”
The hobbit only hummed in response.
“I want to ask…” He stopped.
Bilbo looked over his shoulder at him with a raised brow. “Yes?”
In the endless darkness following his death, Thorin had wished he’d had more time with his One. He’d wished he could have told Bilbo everything. But there had been plenty of opportunities over these past months, and he found that he wasn’t ready to give voice to those feelings, no matter how much he had yearned to do so in that dark place between worlds.
Or maybe he was just a coward.
So he pushed away the thought of making any kind of confession and moved to a different topic. “Do you know if Dwalin and Ori were ever…” He trailed off, unsure of exactly how to finish the question, but Bilbo brightened.
“Oh, I suppose you wouldn’t know about that!” The hobbit laughed and shook his head, grinning. “It caused quite a lot of drama back in the day. It wasn’t until several years after the mountain was reclaimed that the two announced their marriage. They’d gone off and eloped without a word to anyone, if you can believe it. I’m sure you can imagine the tizzy that sent Dori into as soon as he found out.” Bilbo’s smile fell slightly and he looked contemplative. “Now that you mention it, though, it is odd that they seem to be together already. I wonder what that’s all about.”
Well, that answered that question.
Thorin wasn’t sure he could picture Dwalin married to anyone, least of all the Company’s soft-spoken scribe. Then again, he’d never pictured himself falling in love with a hobbit, either, so maybe he needed to broaden his imagination a bit.
“Do you think—”
A chorus of shouting behind them interrupted him and stopped him in his tracks.
His eyes met Bilbo’s, and a second later, both of them were sprinting back up the hill, weapons in hand, abandoning the water-skins.
They returned to camp to find most of the Company standing crowded together, muttering worriedly to each other or shouting at his sister-sons.
Thorin shoved his way through the group in time to see Dwalin wrap his arms around Kili and drag him, kicking and struggling, away from his brother.
Dropping his sword, Thorin rushed forward to grab Fili under the arms and haul him off the ground. His sister-son was disheveled and angry with a split lip, blood leaking into his beard.
“What in Mahal’s name is going on?” Thorin demanded.
“Ask him,” Fili snapped, pointing at his brother and trying to yank away from Thorin. “He attacked me.”
He didn’t let Fili go, but turned his attention to the younger of the two princes—still held firmly in Dwalin’s grip, he had gone limp, breathing hard and wide-eyed. “Kili?”
“I don’t—I don’t know why I—I didn’t mean to—” Kili stuttered, and Thorin saw he was trembling.
When he was sure his heir wasn’t about to fall over or start another fight, Thorin released his hold on Fili.
He took a step towards Kili and Dwalin, but paused when Bilbo rushed past him.
Turning, Thorin saw Bilbo crouch a few feet away from where his sister-sons had been wrestling with each other. When the hobbit stood, there was a glint of gold in the palm of his hand. “You,” Bilbo spat down at the trinket he held, face white with fury. “How dare you! You leave that poor boy alone this instant!”
Thorin took a step toward the hobbit, concerned. “Bilbo—”
Behind him, Dwalin bit out a sharp curse and several of the Company gasped. Thorin whirled around again.
Kili was straining against Dwalin’s hold, a dark hunger on his face focused solely on Bilbo and the Ring.
Alarmed, Thorin moved towards Kili at the same time that Fili placed himself in front of the hobbit, shielding Bilbo from his brother’s view with a fierce glare.
Kili met the glare with a snarl and slammed an elbow into Dwalin’s stomach. “Let go of me!”
“Enough!” Thorin shouted, coming to a stop in front of the struggling pair. “Kili, calm down!”
But Kili just writhed more, fighting to get free of Dwalin’s iron grip.
“Kili, ankuk e!”
The young dwarf went still, finally tearing his focus away from his brother to meet Thorin’s gaze. There was nothing of his sister-son in the black eyes that stared back at him, hard and cruel.
Horror clenched at Thorin’s heart and on instinct he stepped forward to wrap his arms around Kili, even he hissed and snarled like a wild animal. He grabbed the back of Kili’s head firmly to stop his attempts at head-butting Dwalin in the nose and pressed his mouth to Kili’s ear, murmuring to him so quietly that none but his sister-son would hear.
“Kasamhili, inkhi rumu du e. Inkhi rumu, Karkukhal.”
The sound of his inner name being spoken aloud snapped Kili out of it. He went utterly still, and Thorin slowly pulled back, until they were nose to nose.
That darkness in Kili’s eyes faded back to its usual brown and that horrible hunger disappeared, changing to confusion, then fear.
“Uncle,” Kili croaked. The shimmer of unshed tears welled in his eyes. “I—” His voice cracked.
“I know,” Thorin said softly, ignoring the roiling nausea in his gut.
Valar damn him, he knew. He should have seen it sooner. The signs of gold-sickness were obvious. If he wasn’t so afraid of confronting his own mistakes, he might have prevented this.
He looked at Dwalin and nodded. His shield-brother hesitated, but released Kili and stepped away, leaving the prince to stand on shaky legs.
Thorin supported him, wrapping his arm around Kili’s shoulder and keeping him close. He looked back at Fili, who still stood protectively in front of Bilbo—the hobbit didn’t even seem to notice, still glaring venomously down at his clenched fist—and jerked his head. “Come help me collect the water.”
When he was sure Fili would follow, Thorin guided Kili back towards the stand of boulders. The Company separated around them, some gaping at Kili, some worried, some grim. No one said a word. Thorin wanted to snap at them all to stop staring and mind their own business, but he held his tongue. When he met Balin’s watery eyes, he spoke quietly.
“Keep everyone in camp. Do not wait for us to eat supper.”
Balin nodded and stepped aside to let them pass.
So Thorin led his sister-sons away, and halfway down the craggy hill, they collected the water-skins that he and Bilbo had left behind.
None of them said a word as they reached the bank of the stream and knelt to collect the water. Beside him, Kili’s hands shook so hard, he kept dropping his water-skins, so Thorin took those too and filled them himself.
He tried not to look too closely at his own warped and wavering reflection in the stream. Had he, too, been so unrecognizable in his sickness as Kili had just been? Had his eyes been filled with that same darkness when he threatened Dwalin’s life? When he had his hands around Bilbo’s neck, ready to throw him from the rampart for his betrayal? The possibility made him sick.
When he stoppered the final skin, he splashed some of the freezing cold water in his face, hoping it would do something to erase his haunted expression. Then he finally turned to look at his sister-sons.
Both Fili and Kili had their eyes downcast, avoiding looking at him or each other. Fili still had blood drying on his chin and a red bruise was beginning to form beneath one eye. Kili’s gray, tired face was filled with apprehension and no small amount of guilt as he avoided looking at his brother.
Drawing in a steadying breath, Thorin dug in his pocket to find Bilbo’s handkerchief—the hobbit had once again left it behind in the house in Lake-town and Thorin picked it up on his way out and had yet to give it back. It was no longer perfectly white as it had been at the beginning of this journey. The cloth was stained and fraying in one corner, the blue of the embroidered initials faded, but it was clean. He dipped it in the stream then wrung out the excess water and offered it to Fili.
His heir took the handkerchief and held it to his split lip without a word.
“What happened?”
He already had a good idea of exactly what had happened, but he wanted to hear it from them.
Fili just shook his head and looked at Kili, and the youngest Durin ducked his head, shoulders hunching up to his ears. “I started it, Uncle. Don’t be mad at Fi.”
“I am not angry with either of you.” How could he be? This was no one’s fault but his own. “Just tell me.”
Swallowing thickly, Kili hesitated several long moments before slowly answering him. “I was looking at the Ring, and when Fili saw it and asked what it was, for some reason…I don’t know. I thought he was going to take it from me, and I just got so…angry all of a sudden.”
Thorin understood all too well the anger that Kili spoke of, jealous and all-consuming within an instant when triggered, immune to all rational thought. The memory of it—of the violence he had committed under the influence of that anger—left an oily stain on his soul that he wasn’t sure would ever wash away.
“Where did you get the Ring?”
“Bilbo dropped it,” Kili said miserably. He paused, then rushed to add, “I swear I was going to give it back! I just wanted to look at it.”
Sighing, Thorin dragged a hand through his hair, fingers getting caught on tangles that he hadn’t taken the time to comb out today.
On the last journey, his sister-sons had been almost as unaffected by the gold sickness as Bilbo. They’d been some of the few who had dared to argue with him in his madness, whose minds had been clear enough to see that things were wrong. They’d faced the family curse and overcome it when he could not. Or so he told himself. He had spent the past several months refusing to allow himself to dwell on the topic. He didn’t like remembering how monstrous he’d become in those shining golden halls. And pretending his sister-sons were safe from the sickness had made it all the easier to try and forget.
He was such a fool.
Foolish. Selfish. Proud.
Feeling sick, Thorin forced himself to face it.
Kili was staring intently at the ground, avoiding looking at him, so Thorin met Fili’s gaze and held it. “I am sorry. I have failed you again.”
“What are you talking about?” Fili asked quietly.
“The gold-sickness.” Thorin drew in another slow, calming breath. “It is a conversation I should have had with you long before we ever left Ered Luin.”
Fili didn’t so much as blink. “You said before that the sickness is the reason the last quest failed, but you never explained how.”
“No, I did not.”
“Then tell us now.”
A few long moments of silence passed between the three of them and Thorin itched to return to camp. To not say another word. To not recount all that he had done and lay out all his many mistakes for their judgement. He never wanted to speak of it again.
He had to.
But to start with the sickness was too painful.
“It began in the Shire, the night we arrived at Bag End to recruit our burglar.”
And he told them everything. He told them about the nervous gentle-hobbit who fainted at the mere mention of dragons and almost didn’t join the quest at all, about their first confrontation with the trolls, about Radagast the Brown and his sled pulled by rabbits—they were skeptical of his claims about Bilbo ever being that soft, and Fili accused Thorin of making things up when it came to the wizard, but the story eased some of the tension between the three of them.
By the time they reached their escape from Thranduil’s dungeons, some color had returned to Kili’s face and he was hanging off of Thorin’s every word.
“He put us in barrels?” Kili asked, a tinge of delight making its way into his tone.
“He did.” Thorin chuckled and shook his head. “And then he sent us floating down the river, over waterfalls and through whitewater rapids, and all the while we were being chased by angry elves and orcs trying to murder us from the banks.” The memory of the orcs drained away what amusement he had for the memory, though, and he grimaced. “We were nearly caught at the border of Thranduil’s kingdom, where a barrier stretched across the river. Kili left his barrel to raise the gate and was struck in the leg by an orc’s arrow.”
Any good humor in his sister-sons’ faces faded to something more solemn.
And as much as he wanted to end the story there, Thorin forced himself to continue. “It was in Lake-town that the gold-sickness finally got its hold on me.”
Every word that followed, Thorin had to drag from his own throat, forcing himself to speak them aloud, no matter how foul of a taste they left on his tongue. From Bard smuggling them into his home, to their attempt at stealing weapons and their capture, to the grand promises he made to the people of Lake-town—he remained carefully steady through it all, but when it came to the abandonment of his kin, he wavered.
“Kili…Kili was sick with infection from his wound. I was blinded by my focus on the mountain, and I did not see how desperately he needed medicine. All I cared about was that he was too weak to travel and he would slow us down.” He drew in a shaking breath, and couldn’t bring himself to look either of his sister-sons in the eye. “We argued, Fili. I wanted you to come with me, but you refused to be parted from your brother. Oin chose to stay with you. No one knew where Bofur was. I did not have the patience to wait. I-I left all four of you behind that day.”
It was but the first of his many damning mistakes.
Thorin spoke of them all, refusing to allow himself to skip a single one—goading the dragon into attacking Lake-town, his lack of concern for the safety of the Company members who had been left behind, his obsession with the Arkenstone, choosing to go to war rather than fulfill the oaths he had made in Lake-town, his treatment of Bilbo, leaving the dwarves from the Iron Hills to fight and die while he hid inside the mountain. He told them of every terrible thought and deed that had come from his gold-sick mind.
Through it all, neither of his sister-sons said a single word, letting him speak without interruption.
Thorin was too afraid look at their expressions, so he kept his eyes locked on his hands clasped tightly in his lap.
“Ravenhill was a trap. I sent you straight into Azog’s hands.”
He had to stop, then, when he realized he was shaking.
By now, dusk was fading into true night. The little stream gurgled and the ruins of Dale seemed to moan in the distance with the wind that blew through its empty streets, but the three sons of Durin stayed silent for a long minute. Thorin knew they were waiting for him to continue the story, but he wasn’t sure if he could bear it.
Then…
“Hand,” Kili said.
“What?” Thorin asked, glancing up at his sister-son.
Kili smiled at him, though it was strained. “Azog only has one.”
Fili let out an un-princely snort and elbowed his brother in the ribs.
Shaking his head, Thorin made a strangled sound that was meant to be a laugh, but came out more like a pathetic sob.
“Uncle.”
Finally, Thorin looked Fili in the eye, and he was sure his heir could see his fear. “Do you truly wish to know the details of this part?”
He prayed the answer would be no, but knew better than to expect it.
The two brothers looked at each other for a moment, communicating in that silent way they had perfected as children. Then Fili met Thorin’s eye again and nodded. “Tell us everything.”
So, reluctantly, he pushed on.
“Bilbo came to warn us of the trap, but by then, it was too late. Azog captured you, Fili. We were too far away to do anything but watch as he killed you, then dropped your body from the top of the tower.”
Unable to control his raspy breath or the hot tears that leaked down his cheeks, Thorin stopped again. If he closed his eyes, he would be there again—surrounded by stone and ice, covered in blood, unable to breathe as Fili’s dying scream faded on the wind and the Defiler looked down on him, gloating and triumphant. And he had no one to blame but himself. His heir was gone. That bright young dwarf who he loved as a son, dead—
A heavy weight crashed into him from the side and Kili’s arms wrapped tightly around him.
His vision was so blurred he could barely make out the golden-haired figure that knelt before him and pressed their brows together.
“I’m right here, Uncle,” Fili said.
Thorin wept.
It was a long while before he managed to get control of himself once again, the tears flowing to a stop and his breath calming. Never before had he allowed himself to cry so openly in his sister-sons’ presence, but if it bothered them, they showed no sign of it.
Fili just tugged on one of Thorin’s braids before pulling away to sit back on his heels.
Kili remained pressed against his side, and his voice was a little muffled when he spoke, breath hot on Thorin’s neck where his face was buried. “What about me?”
Releasing a shuddering breath, Thorin pulled Kili a little closer. “I did not witness your death. Bilbo has told me you died fighting Bolg, but I know no more than that.” Regret pierced through him, making his chest ache. “I tried to reach you, but Azog found me first. We faced each other on the ice, and I killed the filth, but not before he dealt me a mortal wound. I died soon after.”
He couldn’t tell them about Bilbo—about how the hobbit held his hand as the life seeped out of him, begging him to hold on just a little longer. His One’s anguished cry as he drew his final breath would forever haunt him.
Thorin met Fili’s gaze, and there was a steely determination in his sister-son’s green eyes that he wasn’t sure he’d ever seen in them before. Those eyes flickered to his younger brother before returning to him, and Thorin didn’t need to ask. The meaning of that look was clear as crystal.
Fili would choose death without hesitation if it meant Kili had a chance of survival.
Thorin understood. He would die for Dís in an instant—and would have gladly stepped between Frerin and the blade that killed him all those years ago, so his little brother could live.
A rock lodged itself in his throat and Thorin swallowed thickly, then nodded to Fili in agreement. No matter what, Kili would survive this. Even if they both had to die to make it happen.
It would not come to that. He would not allow it. Whether by his life or death, Dís would not lose her sons.
Unaware of the silent conversation being held between his brother and uncle, Kili spoke again, his voice a little clearer. “You won’t fall to the gold-sickness again. We’ll help you.”
Breaking from Fili’s stare, Thorin grasped Kili’s shoulders and gently pushed him away so they could look each other in the eye. “We will help each other,” he said firmly. “If I notice either of you showing signs of the sickness again, I will snap you out of it, and you will do the same for me. We avoid the treasury as much as possible. If you happen to find the Arkenstone, do not let me see it. Give it to Bilbo immediately. He has already sworn to keep it somewhere safe. Agreed?”
Both his sister-sons nodded, and Thorin felt himself relax slightly.
Pulling away from Thorin entirely, Kili turned to his brother, some lingering guilt appearing in his expression. “I’m sorry, Fi.”
Shrugging, Fili got to his feet and offered a hand to help Kili up. “Already forgiven, boulder-brain. Come on, if we hurry, we might get some supper before Bilbo and Bombur eat it all.”
The two grabbed a few water-skeins each and bolted up the hillside.
Shaking his head, Thorin stood and groaned at the ache of his stiff joints. He stretched to crack his back, then looked up at the sky. He found the seven stars that made up the constellation of Durin’s Crown, and silently prayed they would all make it through this.
