Actions

Work Header

To Fix What Was Broken

Chapter 29: Of Pride and Honor

Notes:

You may have noticed that I have changed the final chapter count to 32 instead of 30. I decided I needed to cut the chapters in half because they were too daunting to work on and I couldn't get myself to start writing again. So after this chapter, there will be three more instead of just one. You're welcome/I'm sorry.

Anyway, this chapter isn't perfect, but I've decided it's good enough and I need to move on, or I'll never get this fic finished.

As always, if you notice any mistakes, don't hesitate to let me know!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The White Gems glittered like stars in the small chest, despite the dark gloom of the morning, and the sight of them put a foul taste in Thorin’s mouth. 

“How came you by these, thief?” he growled, tearing his eyes from the Gems to glare at the elf prince who held them.

Legolas met his anger with a cool stare. “I am no more a thief than your own heir, and I would thank you not to make such accusations. Prince Fili gave me these Gems in exchange for the elvish blades that were taken from you. It was a fair trade.”

“Fair trade,” Thorin repeated flatly.

“We honored the terms of the deal made between you and my father—” Legolas paused, snapping the chest in his hands shut with a loud crack, snuffing out the Gems’ light and narrowly avoiding catching the elf king’s questing fingers in the lid. Thranduil’s eyes dimmed and he snatched his hand back, leveling a hard glare at his son, but the prince  went on, unflinching. “Now that your deal is settled, you can move on to the matter of the orc army bearing down on us.” 

“Now that it is settled, I will take what is mine and leave these accursed lands,” Thranduil snapped.

“You will not.”

Under other circumstances, Thorin may have laughed at the brief appalled expression that crossed the elf king’s face at his son’s defiance. But the near tangible tension in the tent, along with his own fraying patience, didn’t give him much room for humor. Nor did the icy, dangerous anger that replaced Thranduil’s surprise moments later.

But Legolas did not waver in the face of his father’s wrath. He simply raised his chin and spoke calmly. “The Greenwood is in danger and these Gems blind you to the approaching peril. I know what they mean to you, Ada, but I will not return them until our people and home are safe.”

“You will give them to me now.”

“No.”

The elf king’s fair face twisted then into something ugly and terrible and the menacing step he took towards Legolas had the rest of the people in the tent flinching back or discretely reaching for their weapons, fearing violence.

Before Thranduil could say or do anything more, though, he was interrupted by an ear-piercing shriek.

“What was that?” Bard’s right hand man, Percy, asked anxiously.

Axe in hand, Dwalin only made it a single step toward the exit before stopping short at the sight of a giant Eagle. It swept in for a landing in the center of the stone courtyard outside the tent, the flap of its great wings sending a strong gust of freezing wind at them all.

Bard was reaching for his bow, but stopped short when a grey figure slid from the Eagle’s back and stumbled upon his feet hitting the ground. The old man nearly fell and had to grab onto the Eagle to steady himself. Once he found his balance, he started limping quickly towards the tent. With another shriek, the Eagle took off again.

“Cease whatever petty squabble is happening here! You are all in grave danger.” 

Gandalf reached the tent and stopped, panting and leaning heavily on his gnarled wooden staff. His face was caked with blood and dirt and his ratty robes were torn.

Thranduil’s stony mask slid back into place and he looked at the old man disdainfully, apparently uncaring of his dramatic entrance or disheveled appearance. “Spare us from your mad ramblings, Mithrandir, they are not welcome.”

“I bring dark tidings from the south—”

“What tidings?” Bard interrupted, looking wholly baffled now. “Who are you?”

Thorin spoke before anyone else could. “Gandalf the Grey is a wizard and a friend of my Company. His council is good and if he says there is danger, then danger there is.”

As soon as he finished, he and the old man blinked at each other, and it was unclear which was more surprised by the words.

After a moment, Gandalf cleared his throat and dipped his head. “Thank you, Thorin.”

He grimaced. “Pray don’t mention it.”

Thranduil scoffed.

“If you do not wish to see your people destroyed, Thranduil Oropherion, then you will do well to listen,” Gandalf snapped, turning on the elf king with a glower.

With dread coiling in his belly, Thorin said, “Tell us, Tharkûn.” 

“Azog the Defiler leads an army of Guldur orcs to the mountain. They use were-worms to tunnel under the south-east hills and plan to ambush you.”

What followed was a great deal of raised voices, both in panic and argument.

During a lull in the noise, Balin spoke up. “How long do we have?”

“They will be here by nightfall.”

“So soon?” Percy gasped.

Dwalin spat out a filthy curse. “Dáin is still days away. He won’t make it in time.”

Thorin inhaled deeply.

This is what they feared, when Bilbo pointed out things seemed to be happening too quickly. Thorin had been silently praying he was wrong, but, as he had come to learn, the hobbit was rarely wrong about anything.

He exhaled.

Reaching out, he squeezed Dwalin’s shoulder. “Then we hold Erebor until he gets here.” With Dwalin’s determined nod, he turned to the men. “Will you ride ahead to warn everyone that we prepare the mountain for siege? You will get there the fastest.”

Looking grim, Bard nodded and left, closely followed by Percy.

“We should go, too,” Balin said. “They’ll need our help with the bridge.”

Thorin nodded his agreement, but made no move to leave. Instead, he steeled himself, thinking of his sister-sons who could befriend and negotiate with elves in peace, and then he turned his attention to those still in the tent. To Legolas, who stood empty-handed and watching his father with worry—what he had done with the White Gems, Thorin had no idea, but the chest that held them was nowhere to be seen. And to Thranduil, who may as well have been a statue with how still he stood, silvery eyes far away. He imagined Bilbo’s voice in his head, urging him to stay steady.

And then he spoke.

“King Thranduil.”

The elf stirred, then came back to himself and turned his eyes on Thorin, but said nothing.

“This city is too exposed. Your people will not be safe here. Ally with us and take refuge in the mountain, before it is too late and you are cut off.”

Thranduil sneered, but it was far more subdued than usual. “And what is stopping me from taking my people and returning home? It is your kingdom under siege, not mine.”

“Ada!” Legolas cried admonishingly, but he was ignored.

Anger rolled inside Thorin at the thought of this immortal king once again turning his back on the dwarves and men of these lands and abandoning them to destruction. He hated Thranduil, and he was sure that would never change, no matter what alliances were reforged or how many long years passed. It was a hurt that ran too deep to truly ever heal. But Thorin looked deep into Thranduil’s eyes and his anger cooled slightly, for the fear he found in them was all too familiar to him.

“Once they have taken Erebor, the orcs’ eyes will turn to the Greenwood, and there will be no one near enough to aid you. We must fight together, or we will die alone.”

A long, taut silence stretched between them, until Thranduil finally looked away.

The elf king turned to his brown-haired captain who stood silently in the corner. “Give the order. We move to Erebor.”

 

***

 

They left Dale to make the trek across the valley soon after, and the wizard walked with them for a while. A good amount of time passed before any of them spoke. Thorin was too preoccupied considering all the possible outcomes of the coming days, taking stock of what few advantages they had and trying to anticipate what disadvantages they may face and how he might avoid them. But it was difficult. Even if nothing at all had changed since he first fought this battle, things would still be greatly unpredictable. He couldn’t fathom what changes he and Bilbo could have possibly wrought in this time-line for the battle to begin more than a week early.

He could only hope they would withstand the onslaught.

Thorin glanced to the side and up at Gandalf. The old man didn’t look to be a very formidable opponent at the moment, and not at all the intimidating figure Thorin knew he could be. He just looked, well, old. But the wizard was not their only ally in this. 

“What of the Eagles, Tharkûn?” 

“Landroval returns to the Eyrie as we speak. He brings news of the orc armies to Lord Gwaihir, and there is little that the Eagles hate more than orcs. They will come.” He trailed off, then sighed. “Yes, they will come, but I don’t expect they will arrive any sooner than Dáin.” 

Thorin nodded. That, at least, was some good news.

From the corner of his eye, he saw the wizard stumble. “Are you well?”

Gandalf grunted. “Well enough. But I think I’ll sit and rest a while. If you see Bilbo, tell him I wish to speak to him when I get there.”

So they left him behind and picked up their pace, hurrying to the mountain. There were many preparations to be made, and little time to do it all.

None of them spoke again until they came close enough to make out the figures outside the front gate, and Dwalin growled.

“He’s with that damn elf again.”

Indeed, Kili was on the ground, and sitting cross-legged beside him was an ever more familiar red-haired elf. 

Thorin despaired at the sight of her, wishing that Kili’s heart could have chosen literally anybody else. He did not, however, despair at the roar of laughter that burst from both his sister-sons in response to something the elf said.

He shook his head. “Ignore it.”

“But—”

“Not now, Dwalin,” Thorin snapped, and he could practically feel the surprised looks that reaction gained him. He sighed and stopped walking, then turned to face his two oldest friends. “When this battle is over and we have secured the mountain, I will talk to Kili. Until then, I will say no more on the matter. And neither will you.”

He glanced between Balin and Dwalin, meeting their taken aback expressions with narrowed eyes, silently demanding their agreement. Now was not the time to go picking fights with their own, and any misgivings they might have could be dealt with later.

After a short stare-off, Dwalin shrugged. “Yeah, fine. He’s not my sister-son.”

Balin nodded, too, though the look on his face was strange.

With time and patience running low, Thorin elected to ignore it.

He turned on his heel and continued his march to the gate, noting that the elf was nowhere to be seen and his sister-sons’ laughter had ended. Now on their feet, they quietly watched his approach. Kili fidgeted nervously under his gaze, but his brother remained still and calm, with the dragon-tooth hilt of Orcrist peeking over his shoulder.

Thorin came to a stop before his heir, narrowing his eyes and growling. “Fili.”

“Uncle.”

Fili held his head high and met his accusing glare, unflinching.

“What is this about you dealing with elves?”

“Someone had to do it.”

The words were said with full confidence, in the same tone he had always used as a dwarfling when he was caught doing something he shouldn’t. Fili had never been in the habit of denying true accusations brought against him.

It was both an admirable quality, and one that had given Thorin more than a few grey hairs over the years.

“It was not your place—”

Fili’s eyes and voice hardened. “Am I to be Crown Prince of Erebor or not?”

“You went behind my back,” Thorin ground out.

“I negotiated with the prince of a neighboring kingdom to resolve a small issue, so that our kings might turn their focus to the war nearly on our doorstep. Be as angry as you like, Thorin. I won’t apologize for it.”

It was an echo of the elf prince’s earlier words, but from Fili, it was just as much a challenge as it was an explanation—a challenge which, infuriatingly, Thorin wasn’t sure he could meet. For what was there to say? If Fili—and Kili, who no doubt had a hand in this as well—had not dealt with Legolas, then he very well may still be back in that tent, arguing over the Gems rather than preparing for the impending siege. And he was right that as Crown Prince, there would be times when he would have to make decisions and take action without first consulting Thorin, and he would just have to trust that his heir was competent and capable enough to fulfill that role. 

He knew it, but Mahal, he did not like it. Not for lack of confidence in Fili’s judgement, but because it made him feel old. He remembered bouncing a golden-haired babe on his knee like it was yesterday. Yet here he was, going toe-to-toe with a grown dwarf, that babe gone in all but memory.

Thorin stared, unsure if he wanted to laugh or yell or cry or skip all those steps and jump to immediately ripping all his hair out.

Fili stared back.

They could have gone on that way until the remaking of the world, if not for the hobbit who appeared at Thorin’s side seemingly from nowhere and broke the tense silence.

“Look at it this way, dear,” Bilbo said cheerfully. “At least it wasn’t the Arkenstone.”

Somebody—Dwalin, maybe—choked, and Thorin scowled at his hobbit, though there was no real heat behind it.

Bilbo grinned wider.

Thorin buried the urge to groan in frustration and just waved a hand at his unruly sister-sons. “Did you know about this?”

“I didn’t have the faintest clue. And I, for one, couldn’t be prouder.”

Fili and Kili both brightened at that, matching Bilbo’s grin with their own. 

Knowing he was outmatched, he finally relented with a shake of his head and a snort. “You would be, Burglar.”

Despite his lingering irritation, Thorin did feel warm pride in his chest, and he dipped his head to Fili, who sent him an easy smile in return and unslung Orcrist from his back.

“I think you’re going to need this, Uncle.”

The familiar weight of the sword eased some of the tension in him. And though he knew it was ridiculous to be so attached to any single blade—an elvish one, no less—it was a comfort to have, regardless. Orcrist had been at his side at the end of his last journey, and it felt right that it would be there once more, though hopefully this end would prove to be a better one.

“Thorin?”

He turned his attention back to Bilbo to find that his One’s good humor had gone, replaced with an anxious look. And he wasn’t the only one. Bofur, Bombur, and Ori had come outside and were crossing the bridge to join them, all with near identical expressions to the hobbit.

“What happened? Bard says that Gandalf showed up with news that Azog is nearly here. What are we going to do? The orcs aren’t supposed to be here yet! What—”

“Peace, Bilbo. We knew this was a possibility.” Thorin said, and did his best to look and sound as certain as he could. “It is not ideal, but war never is. If we must withstand a siege, there is no place better to do so than Erebor. We need only to hold the mountain for a few days until Dáin arrives, and the Eagles should not be far behind. We are not without allies in this.”

The words were meant for himself just as much as they were for his friends who looked to him now for reassurance. For their sakes, he had to believe they would make it through this. 

“And the elves?” Bilbo asked hesitantly. “We can’t win this battle without their help. If they leave—”

Dwalin snorted loudly. “I wouldn’t worry about that, lad. The elves aren’t going anywhere.”

“But surely they can’t stay in Dale. It’s too dangerous. They’ll be slaughtered.”

Thorin grimaced. “Not in Dale.”

“What do you mean? Where else will they go?” Kili asked.

Before he could answer, Dwalin cut him off. “Thorin invited the tree-shaggers to a slumber party.”

Dori, who reached them just in time to hear that declaration, stopped in his tracks and spluttered. “Excuse me, what?” 

Everyone ignored him in favor of voicing their own surprise and looking to Thorin for an explanation.

He glared at Dwalin, who just smirked in response, then spoke stiffly. “I offered them sanctuary in Erebor and secured a temporary alliance. They will fight with us.”

The words tasted bitter on his tongue, but they were worth it, to see Bilbo’s face light up like a child’s on Yule.

Fili moved to stand by the hobbit and elbowed him, grinning. “See? I told you he’d be fine without your supervision.”

But Bilbo didn’t seem to hear him. He just looked at Thorin with wide, hopeful eyes. “Truly?” 

“It was necessary,” Thorin said begrudgingly, unsure if he should be offended that Bilbo had clearly been doubting him.

He didn’t have time to decide because between one breath and the next, he found himself with an armful of hobbit and then he was being soundly kissed, right there for all to see. He only distantly noticed the sound of Kili gagging and the teasing remarks and laughter around them, and could only grin into the kiss when Bilbo threw a very rude and particularly dwarvish hand gesture at their audience without so much as looking at any of them. 

Yes, it was definitely worth it.

 

***

 

Later, standing atop the battlement wall, Thorin watched Thranduil’s army slowly file through the small excavated doorway into the mountain and was silently grateful his father and grandfather were not there to see it. For his own hatred of elves was naught but a pebble in comparison to the mountain of sheer loathing that they had borne.
 
So great was Thrór’s fury at Mirkwood’s betrayal in the years after the dragon, he had declared that any dwarf still loyal to him was obligated to take vengeance on his behalf upon any elf they crossed paths with. Most, of course, were too busy ensuring they had clothes on their backs and food in their children’s mouths to heed such an extreme ruling. There were those few, however, who had lost too much and had nothing left to them but their anger, and their actions cast all dwarves in a terrible, violent light that made it ever harder for anyone to find work and sympathy from the various people’s of Middle Earth.
 
Had Thrór still been alive today, he would execute Thorin for allying Erebor with Thranduil once again, no matter how dire the circumstances. And then he would execute Fili and Kili, then the rest of the Company for good measure. There would be no mercy in his wrath, not even for his own kin.
 
As for his father, well.
 
Thráin would be unlikely to resort to such violence, but his grief ran deep and he had come to blame Thranduil personally for the death of his beloved Frís. He would take Thorin’s braids and beard and cast him out for the decision he made today. Death would be the kinder punishment.
 
But Thrór was dead and Thráin long gone, and Thorin would not face either of their judgement until he entered the Maker’s Halls.
 
The judgement of his people, however, was another matter entirely.
 
Many would condemn his actions, and it would no doubt have long-lasting consequences that would make his life very difficult indeed, should he live long enough to face them.
 
It was these dark thoughts he was pulled from when he heard boots coming up the steps behind him and someone came to stand by his side.
 
“Elves in Erebor once more. I never thought I’d see the day.”
 
The words were free of both reproach and approval, spoken blandly, as one might comment on the weather. But Thorin felt the underlying weight beneath them, and he braced a hand against the wall, hoping the stone might help anchor him.
 
“There was no other way.”
 
And, Mahal, he prayed that was true. If there was any other option that would not lead to everyone’s demise, he could not see it, no matter how many long nights on this journey he’d lain awake, turning the problem over and over in his mind, searching for an option that did not include betraying his people. 
 
He hoped someday they would forgive him for it.
 
“You have been my King since the day you lead us to victory at Azanulbizar, and have been my friend for far longer than that.” Balin stared down at the elves for several long moments before turning to him, and he once again wore that same strange expression from earlier. “Yet if I did not already know your story, I would not have recognized you today. You have changed, Thorin.” 
 
A boulder dropped in Thorin’s stomach, pushing the air from his lungs, and he remembered another day much like this one, when he’d stood in this exact spot and heard those words spoken to him.
 
It was not a good memory.
 
“Balin,” he said, unable to help the pleading edge in his voice. Though what he was asking for, he did not know.
 
Reassurance? Disapproval?
 
Both possibilities seemed just as painful.
 
Somehow, the opinion of this one dwarf mattered more than all others. Condemnation from him now would hurt more than anything his father or grandfather could ever have done. For Thrór had been mad with gold-lust, and Thráin mad with grief, and their words and actions would have been a result of unstable minds. But Balin… he was the most level-headed person Thorin had ever known, always the voice of reason in times of doubt. Always the one to speak truth.
 
In this, he feared what that truth would be, yet needed to hear it all the same. Even if it was too late to take back what he’d done.
 
“You know I will follow you, no matter the path you choose,” Balin said.
 
He did know. Balin’s loyalty was absolute and unbending, no matter if Thorin deserved it. But loyalty and approval were not the same. 
 
“But is this path the wrong one?” 
 
“That, I cannot tell you.” 
 
Thorin looked away with a clenched jaw, gaze turning to the elves once again. Even with the sun blocked out by dark clouds, their armor still seemed to gleam, and every movement was filled with a grace that normally served only to infuriate him. Now, he had to remind himself that it was a sign of each warrior’s skill, of which everyone in this mountain would soon depend on as they waited for the dwarves of the Iron Hills to arrive.
 
Without the elves, they’d all be slaughtered before sunrise the next morning.
 
“What I do know is that I have never been more certain than I am now that you will be the greatest king on Erebor’s throne since Thráin I built these halls.”
 
It took a moment for him to process what Balin had said, and then his head whipped around so fast, his neck cracked.
 
“You…what?” he said dumbly.
 
“A king’s pride is not worth much if it comes at the expense of his kingdom.” The conviction in Balin’s voice was staggering, leaving no room for doubt. “It is a lesson that many fail to learn during their reign.”
 
Thorin stared at him and Balin stared back. Whatever he’d been expecting him to say, it wasn’t this. If he didn’t know this dwarf as well as he did, he would think it an exaggeration. But Balin was not one to make such statements lightly.
 
Eventually, Thorin swallowed thickly, clearing his throat. “And you think I have learned it?”
 
“You tell me.” Balin shot a pointed glance at the elves below them. Then he smiled. “Just do me a favor, laddie.”
 
“Anything.”
 
“Don’t you dare die before I get to see you crowned. I have waited far too long for this just to see Dáin on the throne. My heart couldn’t take it.”
 
Despite still reeling a bit at this turn in conversation, Thorin barked a laugh at the genuine trepidation in Balin’s expression, then reached out to grasp his shoulder. “I promise you, I will do everything in my power to live, so long as you swear to do the same so that you will be there to crown me.”
 
“Me? But I’m—”
 
“My oldest friend and most steadfast advisor, whom without I never would have come this far. Who else, if not you?”
 
Balin looked incredulous. “What about Dís? That role should go to her.”
 
“It is my right to choose whom I will as my officiant. Dís will agree with my decision.”
 
Balin just shook his head, seemingly speechless.
 
Undeterred, Thorin went on. “Do you remember what you said to me, that night in Bag End? You told me that I have built a good life for us in Ered Luin, and that I have done honorably by our people. But I could not have done half as much if I did not have you to guide me.”
 
“Thorin—”
 
“You deserve just as much credit, if not more, for the survival of our people.” There were tears shining in Balin’s eyes and Thorin grasped his other shoulder, then pulled him closer, pressing their foreheads together. “I will kneel to no dwarf but you, Bahirdannûn. Will you do this for me?”
 
Balin’s tears fell and he released a shuddering breath. “You honor me, Uzbadê.”
 
Despite all the dangers ahead of them, despite the two orc armies converging on the mountain, despite the elves marching into his kingdom, Thorin smiled.
 
“I can give no greater thanks for all you have done for myself and our people. The honor is mine.”

Notes:

Bahirdannûn - wise guide-man
(This is Balin's inner name)

Uzbadê - my king

 

When I get to the sequel, I'll explain this concept more, but my headcanon is that in dwarvish culture, being chosen to officiate a coronation when you're not an immediate blood relative (like a parent or sibling) to the one being crowned is a high honor and a sign of extreme respect for the officiant.
ALSO, my headcanon is that Balin gave Thorin his inner name a long time ago as a way to swear fealty/declare his loyalty.