Chapter Text
Bilbo floated in a vast expanse of blindingly white nothingness, unable to tell up from down or account for how much time had passed since he became aware of his presence there. If anything at all existed in this place besides himself, he saw no evidence of it. Then again, he wasn’t even sure if he existed, considering he couldn’t actually feel his body. It was rather disconcerting, though he should probably be grateful for it, given the particularly violent nature of his final memory before finding himself here.
It was all a bit of a blur.
He vaguely remembered stabbing Azog in the back, then there was a horrible crunching feeling in his chest that stole his breath away, then the sensation of flying through the air like a golf ball on the Greenfield. (A terrible game, golf.) Then there was nothing. Literally.
If this was death, he was decidedly unimpressed. And more than a little annoyed.
Where were the Eternal Gardens of the Green Lady? Where were the fields of flowers, and unending feasts, and the welcoming party with all his passed on loved ones in attendance? Where were the comforts of home?
When he first reawakened to find himself once again in the master bedroom of Bag End several months ago, he was disappointed at the prospect of it being the setting of his afterlife. He didn’t want to spend the rest of eternity puttering around the empty halls of his smial. Death was supposed to be the next great adventure!
Still, however unappealing that existence sounded, it was far preferable to whatever this ridiculous non-existence was.
Of course, he had far better things to be doing than feasting, puttering, or floating around in the afterlife. And by “better things” he meant making sure his block-head dwarves were still breathing.
The annoyance gave way to worry.
They must be alive, right?
From what he could remember, all the dwarves he’d been with were mostly unscathed, save for Dwalin whose face was a bloody mess and Bifur who lost the axe in his skull. But they were both still on their feet, last he saw. Thorin was on the ground, but hopefully Bilbo’s ill-fated attempt to save him had bought him time to collect himself and keep fighting.
As for the other half of the Company, Bilbo had no way of knowing how they fared. Getting separated as they did was not part of the plan, and he didn’t like it. How was he supposed to keep an eye on everyone if they insisted on running off?
He had, as he was sure Thorin did, heard the scream. He was reasonably certain it came from Kili. Whether the young dwarf—no, his nephew—had been injured himself or witnessed someone else get hurt, he could only guess.
Whatever happened, it was only an injury. It had to be.
Bilbo didn’t come all this way just to fail because he was too slow to get out of Azog’s way after sticking him like a pin-cushion and making him angry. Not his finest moment, to be sure, but what else was he supposed to do? Watch Azog murder the love of his life for a second time? Absolutely not.
No doubt Thorin would be furious with him.
Which he supposed was only fair, since he himself was furious after the end of that first adventure, when their roles were reversed and Thorin had the gall to die and leave him behind.
Goodness, Bilbo hoped he wasn’t dead. He didn’t want to put his dwarf through that sort of pain.
Eventually, his fretting gave way to boredom. Which was unfortunate because if there was anything Bilbo Baggins had learned about himself throughout the course of his entirely too long life, it was that boredom was his worst form of torture, likely to drive him mad if left unchecked. It was made even worse by his inability to move, or indeed do anything at all.
With nothing but his own thoughts to entertain him, Bilbo recited the entirety of the Baggins family tree as far back as he could remember. And when he’d done that, he recited the Took tree, too. He mentally mapped every road, track, and path in the Shire that he knew, which were a great many given his fondness of walking holidays. He named every winner of the annual mid-summer tomato competition for the past one hundred twenty years (of which he won seventeen and Lobelia only won two, not that it mattered, of course—he would never boast about such a thing.)
It was around the time he found himself listing every kind of flower he could think of and their individual meanings and what they meant paired together in a bouquet that he noticed he could wiggle his toes and felt a warm breeze tickling the hair on his feet. The air smelled like good earth, sunlight shone through his closed eyelids, and the ground beneath him was a soft bed of grass.
He opened his eyes to stare up into the rustling leaves of a tall oak and was momentarily fascinated by the dappled light shifting in the foliage. And then he heard the singing. A soft and strangely familiar voice sang a wordless tune that he knew by heart. A short burst of excitement told him it was his mother, but when he turned his head, it was not Belladonna Baggins who sat in the grass several paces away from him, weaving together clusters of yarrow blossoms with quick fingers.
Rather, he saw a tall, willowy figure with skin the color of rich, tilled earth. She wore a fine spring-green gown of silk, covered with intricately embroidered vines and flowers and leaves. Her hair, thick and dark and curly, was left loose to sway in the breeze, save for a single braid that ended with a shining mithril bead.
The sight of it startled him out of his idle stupor.
Bilbo sat up and groped at his own hair, then felt a wave of relief to find his own braid and bead exactly where he’d left them. Comforted by their presence and the Lady’s continued humming, he studied their surroundings with interest.
Cottony clouds drifted lazily across a sapphire sky. Gently rolling hills wore necklaces of winding streams and crowns of wildflowers in full bloom. Groves of elm and beech trees stood guard over the fields, and bees and butterflies danced with the swaying grasses. And far beyond it all, rising out of the horizon, were purple mountains cloaked in mist and an emerald forest.
The sight of them roused an old longing in his heart that he could never quite be rid of and Bilbo had to tear his eyes away, or he might take off running.
“Where are we?” he finally asked, loathe to interrupt the peaceful quiet, yet unable to ignore the itch of idleness beginning to prick at the soles of his feet.
“Inbetween,” Yavanna said simply.
Because of course this was Yavanna. The Green Lady of the Eternal Garden needed no introduction.
Humming, Bilbo shifted to lean back against the trunk of the oak, finding a nice spot nestled between the roots. It reminded him of his parents’ tree, planted atop Bag End the day Belladonna first realized she was with child, as was Shire tradition. Or, a variation of it, anyway. Their choice to plant a tree rather than a new flower bed raised some eyebrows, but the couple had never quite done what was expected of them.
Bilbo and the oak grew up alongside each other, and it always served as a place of safety and comfort for him—both things that he was in need of at the moment, if he was to ask his next question.
“Am I dead?”
Yavanna’s nimble fingers never faltered in their weaving, and she didn’t look at him when she responded. “Not quite.”
It was, Bilbo supposed, a better answer than yes, though no would have been preferable. In his opinion, not quite dead sounded awfully close to very nearly dead and while he wasn’t afraid of dying, that didn’t mean he was eager to do so.
He unconsciously reached for his braid again and held onto Thorin’s bead, the metal warm against his skin.
“Am I going to die?”
Considering the severity of his injuries, it seemed likely. Granted, he didn’t know exactly what those injures were, but he was sure something broke that wasn’t meant to. Or a great many somethings, more like.
“Everyone dies, Bilbo.”
He leveled a disgruntled look at her, not caring to wonder if it was perhaps a little too disrespectful of a reaction, given that she was one of the Valar. Honestly, what was it with immortals and their penchant for answering simple questions with riddles?
Yavanna’s laugh was reminiscent of a wind-chime hanging in a summer breeze. “When you will die is yet unseen. It could happen now, or it may happen later. It is your choice.”
“What do you mean?”
The Lady’s hands finally stilled and when she looked him in the eye, Bilbo was unable to look away. His first impression was that her eyes were the green of young spring leaves. But no, they were honey-golden. Now raincloud grey. Now the exact shade of Auntie Donnamira’s blueberry preserves.
So mesmerized was he by the shifting colors, he almost didn’t realize she was speaking.
“Your life hangs by a thread. Those who love you work to heal your wounds, but whether or not they are successful depends on you. If you so choose, you can cut the thread and return home.”
Her words sparked a flash of memory—one where his mother sang in the kitchen of Bag End, and his father’s voice sang with her, drifting in through the open window from the garden outside. It was the home of his youth, the one that existed only in memories of a life long past. He was old, and he didn’t often think of it anymore, if he could help it. Yet this was the second time in the past months it had come to him unbidden.
“It was you,” he said, not sure if he meant to sound accusing or simply baffled. “You lead me to the troll-hoard?”
Yavanna just dipped her head, and that mithril in her hair glimmered.
Bilbo glanced at the distant mountains again and his chest ached. His fears from that bright, empty place returned to him. “Can you tell me—are they—did they—”
“The Defiler is dead. You barufu ikh-kurdu lives.”
The khuzdul rolled off her tongue easily, but in a light, melodic way that contrasted greatly with the typical dwarvish way of speaking.
Bilbo sagged in relief.
They’d actually done it. No matter how many times he told himself they would, there was always that hint of doubt, that worry that their quest was doomed to end with the same suffocating grief as it had before. Or something even worse. But no. His dwarves were alive. All thirteen of them.
He could have wept with the joy of it, if his own fate were not currently hanging in the balance.
“And if I choose to return to them?”
“Durin’s sons live, but the world is far from saved.”
He swallowed thickly. “The Ring.”
It wasn’t a question, but her silence was confirmation enough. From the very first moment that he realized he was truly back in time, reliving his life, he’d known in his heart that it would come to this. As much as he tried to avoid thinking of it, it was always there in the back of his mind, right beside the presence of the Ring itself.
Except he couldn’t feel the Ring now. His own voice was the only one occupying his thoughts. There wasn’t even a hint of a whisper. The silence was blissful.
Bilbo took a moment to just close his eyes and breathe, savoring the warmth and fresh air and the scent of green growing things. Considering the current state of Erebor, it would be quite some time before he got to enjoy such comforts again. He wouldn’t have to give them up at all if he stayed. Nor would he ever have to speak to the Ring again.
“I must warn you, both choices come at a cost.”
He would have thought such a statement unnecessary, and the price of both choices seemed clear. He looked at her again and was taken aback to see that Yavanna looked almost…guilty?
“What haven’t you told me?”
And so she explained, and Bilbo listened, and neither of them were happy about it.
Every word she spoke dropped another rock in his gut. By the time she finished, he thought his ears might be ringing.
Bilbo wanted to laugh, if only to keep himself from crying, but he didn’t even have the energy for that. Valar save him, he felt so old. Granted, the Valar were a big part of the reason he was in this mess to begin with, so he didn’t think they’d be much help. Not if the pitying look Yavanna was giving him was anything to go by.
Of course nothing could ever be simple. Of course everything had to have consequences. It wasn’t fair. Such was life, he supposed. And apparently, such was death. Maybe he would think it poetic if he wasn’t stuck in the middle of it all. From where he sat, it was just cruel. There were no good choices here.
And on the subject of choices…
“Why now?”
She said nothing and he had to stop himself from glaring at her.
“Why are we having this conversation now? Thorin—” Bilbo’s voice cracked and he swallowed thickly, then pushed on. “He got to choose to be sent back to the beginning of the quest. Why was I not given the same choice until now?”
Except it wasn’t the same choice. Not really. This was far worse.
Maybe it was foolish to demand answers from a being such as she. He couldn’t really bring himself to care, though. Not after everything she’d just told him. It was a question he’d had on his mind ever since he learned of Thorin’s own meeting with Mahal, though the dwarf never mentioned a conversation like this one. He never mentioned such costs or anything of the like.
“It is my fault,” Yavanna finally confessed after a long silence, though she sounded reluctant. “Time is a tricky thing. Something I cannot fully explain, as I do not fully understand it myself. My best answer for you is that by the time I found out my husband was sending your Thorin back, it was too late for me to speak with you first. I had to send you back at the exact moment he was, or not at all. I was hasty, and I did not fully realize the consequences my actions would have. I did not know to account for the Ring.”
Well, that barely explained anything at all, and raised more questions than it did answers. Then a thought occurred to him, and he looked at Yavanna with bewilderment.
“Hold on, did you kill me?”
He was sure he saw her wince at the question, but her tone was carefully neutral when she answered him.
“Everyone dies.”
This time, he really did laugh. It was just one little disbelieving hiccup of a sound, followed by another long stretch of silence.
Dragons, dwarvish kings, time travel, meddling Valar, evil magic rings, and now this—how he always managed to get himself tangled up in such insane situations, Bilbo would never understand. In his first life, he often liked to blame Gandalf. It was the wizard, after all, who pushed him out his door in the first place. But he couldn’t use that excuse anymore. No, this nonsense was all his own fault. And the fault of the Valar, to an extent. Though it seemed even they were not all knowing.
He thought longingly of his parents and the Gardens and peaceful rest. But it wouldn’t be peaceful, would it? Not if what Yavanna said was true—and he had no doubt that it was. He would face an eternity that mirrored a life he’d already lived, full of regret and guilt and longing for something he could never have. The mountains would forever be out of his reach.
But would going back be any better? He may very well be dooming all of Arda if he returned and wasn’t strong enough to do what needed to be done. If the Ring took him, what chance was there of it being destroyed? How long could he resist it? Not to mention what Thorin would think of it all. They’d see each other again, but there was no telling how his dwarf would react when he learned the truth.
Which was worse—to be hated or to be missed?
He wished he could talk to Thorin before making a choice that would change both their lives forever—not to mention the lives of everyone else in Middle Earth. But that wasn’t an option and this was a decision only he could make. So, what to choose?
He knew the answer already, though he prayed he wouldn’t come to regret it.
“Send me back.”
“Are you certain?”
“I already promised I would do this, and I think I must try.”
Yavanna’s hands clenched in her lap and her head bowed, dark hair falling like a curtain to hid her face, but not before Bilbo caught a glimpse of the sorrow there. “I have no right to ask your forgiveness,” she said, then paused. Her shoulders slumped. “But know that I am sorry. You were so sad for so long, and it hurt to watch. I could not stand the thought of that sadness following you to the Garden, but I fear I have only made it worse.”
He couldn’t bring himself to be angry with her. How could he, when he thought he understood fairly well how she was feeling in that moment?
He did not know what it was like to be one of the Valar, couldn’t even comprehend it, but he did know what it was like to be a parent. Or something like it. He knew what it was like to realize that his own actions, no matter how well-intentioned, had placed his child into grave danger. And he remembered how much it hurt to see the state Frodo was in after the war—even after sailing to Valinor—knowing that he was the one to pass such a terrible burden on to him.
So Bilbo moved away from the oak to kneel beside Yavanna, and he didn’t hesitate to reach out and lay his hands on hers. “My Lady, you did only what I would have chosen for myself, given the opportunity. There is nothing to forgive.”
There was no other choice. Not for him.
She let out a slow breath and turned her hands to hold onto his. “My brave hobbit.”
The path ahead of him was wrought with darkness and Shadow, but there was also light, and he would not regret walking it. Though…
“I do fear Thorin will be very cross with me for not asking him first.”
An understatement, considering the gravity of what he was about to do. He meant to express the concern with levity, but he couldn’t quite hide the tremor in his voice.
But Yavanna smiled, and despite how grim the tone of their conversation had been so far, she suddenly looked delighted. “I would not worry so much. He makes his own choices while you sleep.”
Her happiness should have been enough to reassure him that all was well, but the words only served to plant a seed of wariness in him.
“And…how long exactly have I been asleep?”
“Nearly a week.”
A week.
There was any number of hare-brained things Thorin might do without proper supervision in that amount of time, and Bilbo didn’t want to imagine the chaos he might find upon returning to the land of the living. Fili and Kili had to get it from somewhere, after all.
For all he knew, he might be landing himself directly into the middle of another war. Though hopefully the Lady’s optimism on the matter meant it wasn’t anything as terrible as that.
He sighed. “What has he done now?”
“It is not my place to say. He deserves the chance to tell you himself.” Her smile grew. “I think you underestimate his love for you.”
Bilbo felt himself blush and he spluttered a bit, but didn’t try to contradict her. He hoped she was right. They’d only just begun courting a few days ago, and making this choice without Thorin’s input felt…presumptuous, but that was too light a word. He didn’t look forward to explaining it, and now he was worried what the state of things would be when he woke up. But, as Gandalf would say, needs must. And Bilbo absolutely needed to go back to deal with the pesky Ring problem himself. He couldn’t in good conscience leave the task for someone else, no matter what the personal consequences might be.
“What must I do?”
Yavanna untangled her hands form his to pick up the wreath of yarrow in her lap and placed it on his head. Then she gestured at the soft grass. “Rest. He will be with you when you wake.”
Well, he’d certainly never say no to a nap.
So Bilbo got comfortable again and almost closed his eyes, but paused. “Thank you.”
Yavanna looked at him, and her ever-changing eyes were fond and loving and sad all at once. “Sleep, Bilbo.”
It was not at all difficult to do as she said, and he soon drifted off to the sound of her singing.
***
Bilbo knew he was awake because every last inch of his body hurt, from the top of is head to the tips of his toes, and a tight pressure wound around his chest made it difficult to draw in a full breath. The air was thick with the smell of bitter herbs, blood, and a scent that familiar to him, yet entirely indescribable—magic. The bed beneath him was lumpy and uncomfortable, and the weight of many blankets pressed down on him, adding to the already suffocating heat.
It was all deeply unpleasant, and in the muddled sludge of his half-conscious mind, he thought he’d rather be asleep.
But there was a voice, deep and familiar, murmuring rhythmically in the language of stone, sounding somewhere between a song and a prayer. That voice held a direct line to his heart and it tugged and pleaded with him to return to the waking world with a desperation impossible to ignore.
Slowly, reluctantly, he managed to pry his eyes open and turn his head. Just that tiny movement was agonizing, but it was worth it.
The dwarf at his bedside was beautiful—dark head bowed and haloed by flickering firelight, long hair falling loose from where it was tied at the nape of his neck. His strong brow, bathed in shadow, was carved with deep worry-lines and his face was wet with tears. But, oh, he was breathtaking.
He sat still as stone save for the movement of his lips and as Bilbo watched, more tears fell and trickled into his beard. Bilbo could practically feel his dwarf’s grief as though it were his own and it hurt.
No, that wouldn’t do at all.
Painfully, he raised a shaking hand to press his palm to Thorin’s cheek.
Deep blue eyes flew open, wet and glistening. “Bilbo.”
His name was a broken gasp and Bilbo felt the warmth of new tears spilling onto his fingers.
“Don’t cry, my dear,” he rasped, then lost what little strength he’d managed to muster and dropped his arm back to the bed.
If anything, Thorin’s broad shoulders shook more and he let out a ragged sob, reaching to take Bilbo’s hand in his own. “You came back.”
“Of course I did.” His cough quickly turned into a strangled cough that sent fire racing through his ribs and lungs and made his vision blur and eyes sting. Cool water dripped between his parted lips and he swallowed it gratefully. It was a minute or two before he managed to get his breath back. “Silly dwarf. You thought I’d leave you to bumble through this on your own?”
Thorin huffed and shook his head, kissing Bilbo’s knuckles. “I thought I lost you.”
There wasn’t much chance of that happening anytime soon—his decision to live made sure of it. But Bilbo wasn’t ready to think about it yet, let alone explain what he’d done, so he smiled instead and tried to make his tone teasing. “Lose me? Impossible.”
Everything hurt and Bilbo could barely move or breathe, but it was worth it, if only so he could see Thorin’s face and hear his voice one more time. It was worth it.
He almost said so, but was interrupted.
“Not at all impossible, Master Baggins, considering that only moments ago, you were dead.”
That was when Bilbo realized they had an audience, and it was with complete incredulity that he turned his head to find none other than King Thranduil himself sitting at his bedside.
The elf was perched on a stool that was far too short for one of his stature and he seemed to be struggling to keep up his usual haughty exterior. There was a grey pallor to his skin and clear signs of exhaustion in the tightness around his eyes, and he stared at Bilbo with nothing short of utter disbelief.
Bilbo imagined his own expression looked quite similar.
He spluttered for a moment, casting around wildly in his mind for a response, but drew a blank. With a lack of anything more appropriate to say, his tongue stumbled over the first two gasping words he could find.
“Good morning!”
