Chapter Text
By the third morning of their journey, Dwalin had begun to suspect that something was seriously wrong with Thorin Oakenshield.
He had considered several possibilities.
Illness seemed unlikely. Thorin rode as straight-backed as ever, ate without complaint, and had spent the previous evening sharpening his sword with the same grim concentration he had displayed for as long as Dwalin could remember. An injury was equally improbable. Dwalin had watched him lift a fallen tree branch out of their path without so much as a wince.
That left enchantment, madness, or some terrible secret.
Dwalin was beginning to favor enchantment.
The trouble had started at Bag End, when Thorin had embraced his nephews as though they had returned from the dead. It had continued when he wagered ten perfectly good gold pieces on the arrival of a hobbit he had never met before that evening. And now, three days into a journey that promised hardship, hunger, and almost certain danger, Thorin Oakenshield was behaving like a dwarf who had discovered an entirely new personality.
He had smiled six times that morning.
Dwalin had counted.
More disturbingly, four of those smiles had been directed at Bilbo Baggins.
The hobbit was currently riding beside their leader, explaining at considerable length why a proper breakfast ought to consist of more than a handful of dried fruit and whatever unfortunate creatures could be persuaded to surrender their eggs.
Thorin was listening.
Actually listening.
“And I don't mean to suggest that your provisions are inadequate,” Bilbo continued, carefully adjusting his position upon his pony, “but there is something rather disheartening about waking before sunrise and discovering that breakfast is apparently an optional affair.”
“Breakfast is not optional,” Thorin replied.
Bilbo brightened. “Precisely!”
“Though I fear we cannot promise six meals every day.”
“Six?” Bilbo looked offended. “Good heavens, no. That would be excessive.”
Thorin raised an eyebrow.
“Seven is generally sufficient,” Bilbo explained.
The dwarf king laughed.
Dwalin nearly rode into a tree.
Beside him, Balin watched the exchange with an expression of quiet amusement.
“You'll frighten your pony if you keep staring like that,” Balin remarked.
“Something's wrong with him.”
“Who? The pony?”
“Thorin.”
Balin glanced toward their leader, who was now patiently listening to Bilbo describe the difference between elevenses and luncheon.
“He seems rather well to me.”
“He offered the hobbit the last apple yesterday.”
“Very generous.”
“He likes apples.”
“So does Master Baggins.”
Dwalin scowled. “You're enjoying this.”
“Immensely.”
___________
Ahead of them, Thorin heard every word.
He chose not to acknowledge either dwarf.
Instead, he watched Bilbo struggle to tuck a loose strand of curly hair behind his ear while keeping hold of his reins. The morning sunlight caught the gold and chestnut in those curls, and for one painful moment Thorin remembered them damp with melting snow.
He forced the memory away.
The road beneath their ponies was firm, the air pleasantly cool, and Bilbo was alive beside him. Those were the things that mattered.
Still, the knowledge of what lay ahead never entirely left him.
He remembered the trolls. He remembered the goblins beneath the Misty Mountains, the pale orc who hunted his bloodline, and the terrible forest where even the trees seemed determined to swallow unwary travellers.
Most of all, he remembered how quickly an ordinary evening could become a disaster.
Consequently, the Company had begun travelling under rather stricter rules than before.
There were now two dwarves on watch whenever they camped, even in country that appeared perfectly peaceful. No one was permitted to wander beyond sight of the others without informing someone. Thorin inspected their supplies each morning and insisted that every pony be properly secured before nightfall.
Dwalin approved of the precautions.
He simply wished he understood what had inspired them.
Thorin, meanwhile, had already discovered the first difficulty with changing the future.
Every decision created another uncertainty.
If they travelled more quickly, would they encounter the trolls sooner? If they chose another road, would Azog's hunters find them somewhere worse? If he warned Gandalf about dangers that had not yet appeared, how long would it take the wizard to demand an explanation?
He could not simply tell them everything.
Not yet.
And so he watched the road, guarded his companions, and tried not to let the weight of remembered deaths steal the joy of seeing them alive.
“Thorin?”
Bilbo's voice drew him from his thoughts.
“Yes?”
“You've gone rather quiet.”
“My apologies.”
“Oh, there's no need to apologize.” Bilbo hesitated. “I only wondered whether I'd said something wrong.”
Thorin looked at him in surprise.
“Not at all.”
“Good. Because I was about to explain afternoon tea, and I would hate to discover that I've already exhausted your patience.”
A smile tugged at Thorin's mouth.
“Please continue, Master Baggins.”
Behind them, Dwalin groaned.
___________
The rain arrived late that afternoon.
It began as a fine mist drifting between the hills, but within an hour it had become a steady downpour that soaked cloaks, darkened the road, and transformed every hollow into a muddy puddle.
Bilbo bore it with admirable determination for approximately twenty minutes.
Then he began shivering.
Thorin noticed immediately.
Without interrupting the conversation between Bofur and Bombur, he guided his pony alongside Bilbo's and removed the heavy outer cloak from his shoulders.
“Here.”
Bilbo looked at the offered garment.
“Oh, no, I couldn't.”
“You're cold.”
“So are you, surely.”
“I am accustomed to travelling in worse weather.”
“That hardly seems a sensible reason to make yourself miserable.”
Thorin almost smiled. He remembered that stubbornness very well.
“Humor me.”
Bilbo studied him for a moment before accepting the cloak. It was far too large, falling over his shoulders and nearly covering his knees, but it was wonderfully warm.
“Thank you,” he said, somewhat shyly.
“You're welcome.”
Thorin reached across to straighten the collar where it had folded beneath Bilbo's chin, then withdrew his hand before the gesture could become too familiar.
Bilbo's cheeks warmed despite the rain.
Behind them, Kíli leaned toward his brother.
“Do you think Uncle has realized he gave away his cloak?”
Fíli glanced at Thorin.
“I suspect he knows.”
“But he hates being wet.”
“He does.”
Kíli considered this with deep suspicion.
“Perhaps the hobbit has enchanted him.”
Fíli shook his head, though his expression was thoughtful.
“Perhaps.”
___________
By evening, the rain had stopped, leaving the forest smelling of wet earth and pine needles. The Company made camp beneath a rocky overhang, where the ground was relatively dry and the trees offered some protection from the wind.
Thorin supervised the arrangements while Dwalin and Glóin gathered firewood. Fíli helped secure the ponies, Kíli complained about being assigned to the first watch, and Bombur began preparing supper.
Bilbo sat upon a fallen log, attempting to dry his feet near the fire.
His toes were cold, his curls were damp, and he was beginning to suspect that adventures had been invented by people who had never properly appreciated the comforts of a well-furnished sitting room.
Nevertheless, he was not entirely unhappy.
The dwarves were noisy, occasionally impossible, and possessed a remarkable talent for arguing over matters that seemed entirely unimportant. Yet they had begun including him in their conversations, and Bofur had spent much of the afternoon teaching him an absurd drinking song.
And then there was Thorin.
Bilbo did not quite know what to make of him.
The dwarf was clearly their leader. His companions obeyed him without hesitation when danger threatened, and even Dwalin listened when Thorin's voice took on that particular commanding tone.
But toward Bilbo, he was almost unfailingly gentle.
It was rather bewildering.
At present, Thorin sat a short distance away, examining a map by firelight. His dark hair had come loose from its usual arrangement, and several strands were tangled around the leather fastenings of his coat.
Bilbo noticed immediately.
He tried not to.
He truly did.
But after several minutes of watching Thorin absently push the tangled hair away from his face, Bilbo could bear it no longer.
“Thorin?”
The dwarf looked up.
“Yes, Bilbo?”
“Your hair.”
Thorin blinked.
“My hair?”
“It's terribly tangled.”
Several nearby dwarves stopped talking.
Thorin glanced down at the loose strands falling across his shoulder.
“Travelling tends to have that effect.”
“Yes, but surely it must be uncomfortable.”
“A little.”
Bilbo frowned.
“Well, that won't do.”
He rummaged through his travelling bag and produced a small wooden comb.
“Would you like me to braid it for you?”
Fíli choked on his tea.
Kíli's spoon slipped from his fingers and landed in the stew.
Balin became very interested in the contents of his cup.
Thorin went perfectly still.
For a moment, the crackling fire seemed impossibly loud.
Bilbo looked around, confused.
“What?”
Fíli cleared his throat.
“Master Baggins, perhaps you don't understand. Among dwarves, braiding another person's hair is rather—”
“Fíli.”
Thorin's voice was quiet, but it carried unmistakable authority.
His nephew stopped immediately.
Thorin looked at Bilbo.
“You would not mind?”
Bilbo appeared genuinely puzzled.
“Of course not. My mother always said there was no excuse for allowing one's hair to become a bird's nest, and yours is very nearly approaching that condition.”
Kíli made a strangled noise.
Thorin's expression softened.
“Then I would be grateful.”
The silence that followed was extraordinary.
Dwalin slowly turned his head.
Glóin stared openly.
Even Gandalf, seated near the edge of the firelight, lowered his pipe.
Bilbo, entirely unaware of the significance of what had just occurred, smiled with satisfaction.
“Excellent. Come and sit here, then. I shall need better light.”
And Thorin Oakenshield, King under the Mountain in all but possession of his kingdom, obediently rose and sat upon the ground in front of a hobbit.
Kíli looked as though he might faint.
Bilbo settled behind Thorin upon the log, carefully gathered the dark hair over his shoulders, and began working through the tangles with his comb.
Thorin closed his eyes.
He had forgotten how gentle Bilbo's hands could be.
In his first life, he had learned the shape of those hands through countless small acts of kindness: a bandage tied around an injured wrist, a cup of water offered after a difficult climb, fingers resting briefly upon his arm in reassurance.
And, at the very end, those same hands had tried desperately to keep him alive.
Now they moved carefully through his hair.
Bilbo worked with patient concentration, occasionally murmuring an apology when the comb caught a stubborn knot. Thorin assured him each time that he was perfectly comfortable.
He was more than comfortable.
He felt as though some long-frozen part of him had finally begun to thaw.
Among his people, hair carried history and meaning. Braids could signify kinship, allegiance, mourning, and courtship. To allow someone outside one's family to tend one's hair was an act of profound trust, and to accept a braid offered with affection could mean considerably more.
Thorin knew precisely what he was allowing.
He also knew Bilbo did not.
He would never hold the innocent gesture against him or presume it meant something the hobbit had not intended.
But he could treasure it.
“There,” Bilbo said at last, fastening the finished braid with a narrow strip of dark leather. “Much better.”
Thorin lifted a hand, feeling the neat arrangement against his shoulder.
“Thank you.”
Bilbo looked pleased.
“You have lovely hair, you know. It's simply a shame to let it become so tangled.”
Thorin turned slightly.
For a moment, his expression was so openly tender that Bilbo forgot what he had been about to say.
“You are very kind to me,” Thorin murmured.
Bilbo blinked.
“Well, you've been very kind to me.”
Thorin smiled.
Across the fire, Fíli slowly covered his face with one hand.
Kíli leaned closer.
“He knows what it means, doesn't he?”
“Of course he does,” Fíli whispered.
“Then why did he let him?”
Fíli watched their uncle carefully.
“I think,” he answered, “that's the question we ought to be asking.”
Dwalin looked toward Balin.
Balin merely smiled.
Gandalf drew thoughtfully upon his pipe.
And Bilbo, completely oblivious, began explaining that a little oil would prevent the ends from splitting.
___________
Later that evening, Gandalf found Thorin standing beyond the firelight.
The dwarf was looking toward the dark trees, one hand resting upon the hilt of his sword.
His newly braided hair lay neatly over his shoulder.
Gandalf noticed it, of course.
He chose not to mention it.
“You seem troubled,” the wizard observed.
Thorin did not turn.
“The road is dangerous.”
“It has always been dangerous.”
“Some roads more than others.”
Gandalf studied him.
“For several days, you have behaved as though you expect an attack at any moment. You have changed our route twice, insisted upon additional watches, and questioned every traveller we have passed.”
“I am responsible for thirteen lives.”
“Fourteen, including your own.”
Thorin's jaw tightened.
Gandalf stepped closer.
“And yet I cannot help wondering whether there is something you are not telling me.”
Thorin remained silent.
The wizard's voice softened.
“You behave, at times, as though you know what awaits us around every corner.”
A chill passed through Thorin.
He turned toward Gandalf, carefully controlling his expression.
“I have spent many years on dangerous roads.”
“So have I.”
“Then you understand my caution.”
“I understand caution. I do not understand why you looked toward the northern hills yesterday before we heard the wolves.”
Thorin said nothing.
Gandalf regarded him for a long moment.
“Have you been dreaming, Thorin?”
The question struck closer than the wizard could possibly know.
“Dreaming?”
“Of things that have not yet happened.”
Thorin looked away.
“I have had enough dreams to last a lifetime.”
Gandalf did not press him further.
Instead, he glanced toward the darkening forest.
“There are troubling signs in these lands. I intend to investigate them tomorrow. I shall rejoin you farther along the road.”
Thorin remembered.
In his first life, Gandalf had departed after a bitter disagreement, leaving the Company to face the trolls without him.
This time, there had been no argument.
Yet the wizard was leaving all the same.
Thorin felt a cold unease settle in his stomach.
Some events, it seemed, were determined to repeat themselves.
“Be careful,” he said.
Gandalf raised an eyebrow.
“Are you worried about me?”
“I would prefer not to lose our wizard before we reach the mountains.”
A faint smile touched Gandalf's face.
“Then I shall endeavor to return.”
Thorin watched him walk back toward the fire.
For a moment, he considered telling him everything.
But the memory of Bilbo's tears upon Ravenhill rose before him, followed by the sight of Fíli and Kíli lying dead.
He could not bear to speak those things aloud.
Not while they were still alive.
___________
The following afternoon, Gandalf departed.
The Company continued eastward beneath a sky heavy with clouds, travelling through increasingly wild country where the roads were narrow and the trees grew close together.
Thorin recognized the landscape.
He remembered the miserable rain, the missing ponies, and the three trolls whose appetites had nearly brought their Quest to an early end.
This time, he would avoid them.
He chose a different path through the hills and ordered the Company to camp well away from the place he remembered.
Dwalin questioned the decision.
“The old road would have been quicker.”
“It would also have left us exposed.”
“Exposed to what?”
Thorin looked toward the trees.
“Whatever might be watching.”
Dwalin did not look satisfied, but he obeyed.
By evening, they had established camp in a sheltered hollow. The ponies were secured near the trees, and Thorin assigned Fíli and Kíli to watch them while Bombur prepared supper.
Bilbo sat beside the fire, helping Bofur peel potatoes.
For a while, everything seemed peaceful.
Then Kíli returned.
“Uncle?”
Thorin looked up.
“One of the ponies is missing.”
The knife in Thorin's hand went still.
“Which one?”
“The grey mare.”
“Did you see what happened?”
Kíli shook his head.
Thorin rose immediately.
“Fíli?”
“Still watching the others.”
A familiar dread settled in Thorin's chest.
He had changed their campsite.
He had changed their route.
And yet—
A distant, ugly laugh echoed through the trees.
Thorin closed his eyes briefly.
Of course.
He drew his sword.
“Dwalin. With me.”
Bilbo stood.
“What is it?”
“Trouble,” Thorin answered.
Then he looked at the hobbit, who was already reaching for his small travelling blade.
Thorin remembered what happened next.
He remembered Bilbo's courage.
And he remembered how badly he had misjudged him.
“Master Baggins,” he said, “I may need your help.”
Bilbo straightened.
“My help?”
“Yes.”
The hobbit swallowed, but nodded.
“Of course.”
The trolls were larger than Bilbo had imagined.
Much larger.
They sat around a roaring fire in a clearing, arguing over the best way to prepare their stolen supper. One was holding a pony's bridle, another was stirring a foul-smelling pot, and the third appeared to be complaining about the quality of the meat.
Bilbo crouched behind a tree, his heart hammering.
Thorin knelt beside him.
“Stay low,” the dwarf murmured.
Bilbo nodded.
“They're enormous.”
“They are.”
“And rather ugly.”
“Very.”
Bilbo glanced at him.
“You don't seem particularly surprised.”
Thorin looked toward the trolls.
“I have encountered their kind before.”
That, at least, was true.
He had encountered these very trolls before.
He had also been tied inside a sack while they discussed how best to cook him.
It was not an experience he wished to repeat.
Unfortunately, fate appeared to have other ideas.
Bilbo attempted to retrieve the ponies while the trolls argued, but one of the creatures turned unexpectedly and caught sight of him.
A huge hand closed around his coat.
“Well, what's this?”
Bilbo gave a startled cry.
Thorin moved immediately.
“Release him!”
The clearing erupted into chaos.
Dwalin charged from the trees, followed by the others. Steel flashed in the firelight as the dwarves attacked, but the trolls were immensely strong, and their heavy clubs sent several members of the Company sprawling.
Thorin fought fiercely, keeping himself between Bilbo and the nearest creature whenever possible.
He had hoped to avoid this.
Instead, his efforts had brought them into the same danger by a different road.
One troll seized Bilbo and lifted him into the air.
“Drop your weapons!”
Thorin froze.
Bilbo dangled helplessly above the ground.
The troll tightened its grip.
“Or we'll tear his arms off!”
Thorin's blood turned cold.
He remembered this moment.
He remembered lowering his sword, furious at Bilbo for being captured.
But looking at the frightened hobbit now, Thorin felt no anger.
Only terror.
“Put him down,” he said, his voice dangerously quiet.
The troll grinned.
“Weapons first.”
Thorin dropped his sword.
The others reluctantly followed.
Within minutes, the Company had been bound and dragged toward the fire.
Bilbo was released, though he remained under the trolls' watchful eyes.
__________
Thorin struggled against the ropes around his wrists.
He knew what had to happen.
They needed time.
Sunrise would destroy the creatures, but dawn was still some way off.
And Gandalf was nowhere to be seen.
Bilbo, meanwhile, was watching the trolls argue over their cooking pot.
A familiar expression appeared upon his face.
Thorin recognized it immediately.
The hobbit was thinking.
“Excuse me,” Bilbo called.
One troll turned.
“What?”
Bilbo swallowed.
“Well, if you're planning to cook dwarves, I really wouldn't recommend boiling them.”
Several dwarves stared at him.
The troll frowned.
“Why not?”
“Because they'll taste dreadful.”
Thorin lowered his head to conceal a smile.
Bilbo continued, gaining confidence.
“Very tough, dwarves. Particularly these ones. You'd be much better off roasting them slowly.”
“Roasting?” another troll repeated.
“No, boiling!” the third argued.
The trolls began shouting at one another.
Bilbo stepped closer to the fire.
Thorin caught his eye.
For one brief moment, their gazes met.
Thorin gave the smallest nod.
Keep going.
Bilbo seemed to understand.
“Well, of course,” he said loudly, “there's also the matter of seasoning.”
“Seasoning?”
“Oh, absolutely. You can't simply throw dwarves into a pot and expect a decent supper.”
Kíli stared at his uncle.
“Is he trying to get us eaten?”
“Quiet,” Thorin murmured.
“But—”
“Trust him.”
The words silenced his nephew.
Bilbo continued talking.
He discussed herbs, cooking temperatures, and the unfortunate consequences of preparing meat without proper consideration.
The trolls argued.
Minutes passed.
The sky slowly began to lighten.
Thorin watched the eastern horizon.
Come on, Gandalf.
One troll finally lost patience.
“Enough talking!”
It seized Bilbo by the back of his coat.
Thorin surged against his bonds.
“Leave him!”
The creature ignored him.
“We're eating now!”
Then a familiar voice rang through the clearing.
“The dawn will take you all!”
Gandalf stood upon the rocks above them.
He raised his staff.
With a tremendous crack, the stone split apart, allowing the first brilliant rays of sunlight to flood the clearing.
The trolls screamed.
Their bodies hardened.
Their faces twisted in expressions of horror.
And within moments, three enormous stone figures stood where living creatures had been.
Silence followed.
Then Bilbo sat down rather suddenly upon the grass.
“Oh,” he whispered.
Thorin was at his side as soon as his bonds were cut.
“Bilbo.”
The hobbit looked up.
“Are they really—?”
“Stone,” Thorin assured him.
“Entirely?”
“Entirely.”
Bilbo exhaled shakily.
“Good.”
Thorin knelt beside him.
“Are you hurt?”
“Only my dignity, I think.”
Thorin examined the hobbit's wrists, where the troll's rough grip had left angry red marks.
His expression darkened.
Bilbo noticed.
“Oh, it's nothing serious.”
“That does not mean it should be ignored.”
He carefully released Bilbo's hands.
“You were very brave.”
Bilbo blinked.
“I was terrified.”
“Courage does not require the absence of fear.”
For a moment, Bilbo simply looked at him.
Then a shy smile appeared.
“Thank you.”
Behind them, Dwalin was watching with an expression of profound confusion.
Thorin turned toward the Company.
“Master Baggins bought us the time we needed. Remember that.”
Balin smiled warmly.
Bofur clapped Bilbo upon the shoulder.
Kíli grinned.
And Bilbo, who had expected to be blamed for the entire disaster, found himself unexpectedly pleased.
__________
The trolls' cave lay concealed beneath a rocky hillside.
Inside, the Company discovered stolen supplies, old coins, weapons, and enough unpleasant smells to convince Bilbo that trolls possessed no understanding whatsoever of proper housekeeping.
Gandalf examined the weapons carefully.
“These are no ordinary blades.”
Thorin approached.
He already knew what lay before him.
Glamdring.
Orcrist.
The swords of Gondolin.
In his first life, he had regarded the elven weapons with considerable reluctance.
Now he remembered Orcrist in his hand during countless battles.
He remembered the blade flashing beneath the mountains and against Azog's hunters.
He also remembered losing it before the final battle.
Gandalf offered him the sword.
“Will you take it?”
Thorin accepted without hesitation.
“It is a fine weapon.”
Gandalf raised an eyebrow.
“An elven weapon.”
“A useful one.”
Dwalin stared.
Gandalf's mouth twitched.
“Indeed.”
Nearby, Bilbo was examining a smaller blade discovered among the treasure.
Thorin recognized it immediately.
Sting.
The sight of it brought an unexpected warmth to his chest.
Bilbo had carried that little sword through darkness and danger, using it to defend himself and others when many larger warriors would have fled.
Thorin approached.
“That one suits you.”
Bilbo looked up.
“Do you think so?”
“It is light enough for your hand, but well made.”
Bilbo studied the blade.
“I've never really used a sword.”
“You will learn.”
There was no doubt in Thorin's voice.
Bilbo looked at him for a moment before carefully returning the weapon to its sheath.
“Then I suppose I ought to practice.”
“I would be glad to teach you.”
The hobbit smiled.
“I should like that.”
Thorin felt an ache of tenderness so fierce that he had to look away.
He had been given another chance.
Not merely to save lives, but to witness moments he had once taken for granted.
Bilbo learning to hold a sword.
Kíli laughing beside the fire.
Fíli arguing with Dwalin.
Balin smiling over a cup of tea.
Small things.
Precious things.
Things no amount of gold could ever replace.
__________
They left the trolls' clearing before midday.
Gandalf rode beside Thorin for some time, occasionally glancing at the dwarf's newly braided hair.
Eventually, he spoke.
“You were remarkably calm during that unpleasant business.”
Thorin looked ahead.
“I did not feel calm.”
“No?”
“No.”
Gandalf considered him.
“And yet you seemed quite certain that Master Baggins knew what he was doing.”
“He did.”
“You trusted him.”
“Yes.”
“Despite having known him only a few days.”
Thorin turned toward the wizard.
“Must trust always be earned through years of acquaintance?”
“Not always.”
“Then perhaps I simply recognized a good heart when I saw one.”
Gandalf smiled faintly.
“Perhaps.”
But his expression remained thoughtful.
That evening, when the Company stopped beside a narrow stream, Thorin volunteered to inspect the surrounding woods before supper.
He took Dwalin with him.
They found the tracks less than half a mile from camp.
Heavy boots.
Clawed footprints.
The marks of wolves.
Thorin crouched beside a patch of disturbed earth, brushing aside the fallen leaves.
His stomach tightened.
He recognized the pattern of the tracks.
Orcs.
Not wandering goblins or a small band of raiders, but organized hunters moving through the wilderness.
Azog's hunters.
Dwalin knelt beside him.
“Orcs?”
Thorin nodded.
“How many?”
“Enough.”
Dwalin studied the ground.
“They're travelling west.”
“Toward us.”
His companion looked up sharply.
“How can you be certain?”
Thorin stared at the tracks.
He remembered the burning trees.
He remembered Azog standing beneath the moonlight, calling for his head.
He remembered the terrible sound of wolves closing around the Company.
And he remembered Bilbo running toward danger because Thorin had fallen.
“Because,” he answered quietly, “they are hunting someone.”
Dwalin's expression hardened.
“Us?”
Thorin rose.
“Yes.”
They returned to camp without speaking.
That night, Thorin doubled the watch.
He made certain Fíli and Kíli slept near the center of the camp, where they would be protected if an attack came unexpectedly. He checked the ponies himself and walked the perimeter twice before finally sitting beside the dying fire.
Bilbo was already there.
The hobbit looked up from the small book he had been reading.
“You look troubled.”
Thorin sat beside him.
“There are dangers ahead.”
Bilbo closed the book.
“I rather suspected there might be.”
Thorin smiled faintly.
“You are not frightened?”
“Oh, I'm absolutely frightened,” Bilbo replied. “I think I've been frightened since the moment I left my front door.”
“Yet you remain.”
Bilbo looked toward the sleeping dwarves.
“Someone has to make sure you all eat properly.”
Thorin laughed softly.
Then Bilbo noticed the braid resting over his shoulder.
“Oh! It's still holding.”
Thorin glanced down.
“Yes.”
“Good. I was worried the leather might come loose.”
“It has held perfectly.”
Bilbo smiled with satisfaction.
“I could do the other side tomorrow, if you'd like.”
Thorin looked at him.
For a moment, the world seemed impossibly gentle.
The fire crackled between them, the trees whispered in the night breeze, and Bilbo Baggins sat beside him offering to braid his hair as though such a thing were perfectly ordinary.
Thorin swallowed.
“I would like that very much.”
Bilbo smiled again and returned to his book.
Thorin remained beside him, listening to the quiet sounds of the camp.
He had changed the route.
He had avoided the old campsite.
He had treated Bilbo differently, trusted him sooner, and accepted help he once would have rejected.
Yet the trolls had still found them.
Gandalf had still departed.
And Azog's hunters were still moving through the wilderness.
Thorin looked toward the darkness beyond the firelight.
Perhaps the future could be changed.
Perhaps it could not.
But one thing had become painfully clear.
Knowing what was coming did not mean he could prevent it.
Beside him, Bilbo turned a page.
Thorin glanced at the hobbit, at the peaceful expression upon his face and the soft curls falling over his forehead.
Then he looked toward the sleeping forms of his nephews.
He would not surrender them to fate.
Not again.
Whatever darkness awaited them beyond the hills, Thorin Oakenshield would face it.
And this time, he would not allow fear, pride, or a mountain full of gold to blind him to what was truly worth protecting.
