Actions

Work Header

The Road Back to You

Summary:

Thorin Oakenshield died with a kingdom reclaimed, a heart full of regrets, and a love confessed too late.

When he awakens outside a familiar green door in the Shire, he is given a second chance to change everything.

But rewriting fate is no easy task, especially when the hobbit he loves has yet to fall in love with him

Notes:

Hello, and welcome to The Road Back to You!

This is my little attempt to give Thorin and Bilbo the second chance they deserved. Expect a slow-burn romance, plenty of fluff, a little heartbreak, protective Thorin, and a Company that has absolutely no idea what's gotten into their king.

I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoy writing it!

Chapter 1: Chapter One — A Door Once Opened

Chapter Text

The last thing Thorin Oakenshield remembered was the snow.

It had been falling gently over Ravenhill, settling upon the broken stones and the bodies of the fallen, turning the battlefield into something almost peaceful. Beneath him, however, the snow was stained dark with blood. His blood. It soaked through his clothing, spread beneath his shoulders, and melted the delicate white crystals wherever it touched them. The wound in his chest burned with every shallow breath, though the pain was already beginning to fade into a terrible, creeping cold.

Bilbo Baggins was kneeling beside him.

That was all Thorin could truly concentrate on.

The hobbit's curls were dishevelled, his face streaked with dirt and tears, and his small hands pressed desperately against the wound as though determination alone might prevent the life from leaving Thorin's body.

“Thorin, please,” Bilbo whispered. “Please, you mustn't. We can find Gandalf. Or Óin. Someone will know what to do.”

Thorin wanted to tell him that it was too late. He wanted to spare him the terrible hope that shone through his fear, but the words would not come.

Instead, he lifted one trembling hand and touched Bilbo's cheek.

The hobbit went very still.

“I am sorry,” Thorin murmured.

Bilbo shook his head fiercely. “Don't.”

“For everything I said to you. For doubting you when you deserved my trust.”

“Thorin, none of that matters now.”

“It matters to me.”

His breath caught painfully. Bilbo leaned closer, his expression crumpling.

Thorin had spent so much of their journey misunderstanding the extraordinary creature before him. He had mistaken kindness for weakness, caution for cowardice, and a love of home for an unwillingness to face the world. He had questioned Bilbo's loyalty even after the hobbit had risked his life to save him.

And somewhere along that long, dangerous road, without Thorin quite understanding when it had happened, Bilbo Baggins had become dearer to him than the kingdom he had spent his life trying to reclaim.

“If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold,” Thorin whispered, “it would be a merrier world.”

Bilbo made a small, wounded sound.

Thorin tried to smile.

“I wish I had met you sooner.”

“You did meet me,” Bilbo answered desperately. “And we went on this dreadful adventure, and now you're going to come home with us. You're going to show me those gardens you said could be made inside the mountain, and you're going to complain about my cooking, and—”

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit's mouth trembled.

“There is something I should have told you.”

“Then tell me when you're better.”

“I love you.”

The words were scarcely louder than a breath.

Bilbo stared at him.

Thorin had imagined saying them beside a quiet campfire, or perhaps in one of the gardens they had spoken of building in Erebor. He had imagined Bilbo laughing, blushing, or looking at him with that fond exasperation Thorin had come to treasure.

He had never imagined confessing his heart while dying in the snow.

“I have loved you,” he whispered, “for longer than I understood.”

Bilbo's face crumpled.

“Oh, you foolish, impossible dwarf.”

Then he bent forward, pressing his forehead against Thorin's.

“I love you too,” he sobbed. “So you are not allowed to leave me. Do you understand? Thorin, please—”

Thorin wanted to answer.

He wanted to promise Bilbo a thousand mornings, a warm hearth, and a garden where nothing dangerous would ever find them. He wanted to hold him without blood between them.

But the cold had reached his heart.

The last thing he felt was Bilbo's hand against his cheek.

And then there was nothing.

__________

 

Birdsong.

That was the first thing Thorin heard.

Not the clash of swords or the cries of wounded soldiers, but birdsong, bright and cheerful, accompanied by the distant bleating of sheep.

A breeze touched his face. It smelled of grass, flowers, and woodsmoke.

Thorin opened his eyes.

He was standing on a narrow garden path beneath an evening sky.

For several moments, his mind refused to understand what he was seeing. Rolling green hills stretched into the distance, dotted with round doors and little windows glowing warmly against the gathering dusk. A white fence bordered a carefully tended garden, and somewhere nearby, someone was baking bread.

Before him stood a round green door with a brass knob in its center.

Thorin knew that door.

He knew the little steps leading toward it, the flowers beneath the windows, and the brass bell hanging beside the entrance.

Bag End.

His breath caught.

He looked down at himself.

His armor was gone. He wore the dark travelling clothes and heavy coat he had worn at the beginning of the Quest. Orcrist was nowhere at his side. There was no blood on his hands.

He pressed his palm against his chest.

No wound.

No pain.

Only the steady, impossible beating of his heart.

Thorin staggered backward, catching himself against the garden fence.

He remembered dying.

He remembered Bilbo crying over him.

He remembered the terrible cold.

Yet here he stood, beneath a peaceful sky in the Shire, before the home of a hobbit he had watched grow brave, stubborn, loyal, and impossibly dear.

From behind the green door came a tremendous crash.

Someone shouted in Khuzdul.

A second voice erupted into laughter.

And then Thorin heard Kíli.

His nephew's unmistakable laugh rang through the house, young and carefree.

Thorin's knees nearly gave way.

Kíli.

Alive.

And Fíli would be there too.

For one terrible moment, Thorin wondered whether this was some strange mercy granted to the dead. Perhaps Mahal had taken pity on him and fashioned a dream from everything he had lost.

But the evening breeze was real against his skin. The fence was solid beneath his hand.

And from somewhere inside came an indignant voice.

“Those are my plates!”

Bilbo.

Thorin closed his eyes.

He had heard that voice in his dreams during the journey, imagined it filling the great halls of Erebor, wished for it in the final moments of his life.

Now it was complaining about crockery.

A laugh escaped him, so unexpected and so painfully close to a sob that he pressed a hand over his mouth.

Then he approached the door and knocked.

Footsteps sounded from within.

The door swung open.

And Bilbo Baggins stood before him.

He wore a dressing gown over his waistcoat, his curls were slightly dishevelled, and his expression suggested that the evening had already exhausted every measure of his patience.

Thorin forgot how to breathe.

Bilbo was alive.

There was no blood upon his hands, no grief in his eyes, no terrible knowledge of death upon his face.

He was simply Bilbo, warm and living and looking at Thorin with considerable suspicion.

“Yes?” the hobbit asked.

Thorin stared.

Bilbo's eyebrows rose.

“Can I help you?”

There were a hundred things Thorin wanted to say.

I am sorry.

I have missed you.

You told me you loved me.

Instead, he stood motionless on the doorstep, fighting the ridiculous urge to gather the bewildered hobbit into his arms.

Bilbo looked him up and down.

Then recognition dawned—not of Thorin himself, but of the sort of visitor standing before him.

“Oh, for goodness' sake. Another one?”

Thorin swallowed.

“Thorin Oakenshield,” he managed.

Bilbo blinked.

Before he could reply, a familiar voice called from deeper within the smial.

“Ah! Thorin! At last!”

Gandalf appeared behind Bilbo, his grey hat nearly brushing the ceiling.

“We were beginning to wonder what had become of you.”

Thorin looked at the wizard.

Gandalf stood before him exactly as he remembered, with his long beard, weathered face, and eyes that seemed to miss very little.

“Gandalf,” Thorin said quietly.

Something in his voice made the wizard pause.

But Bilbo had already stepped aside, muttering about how there could not possibly be room for another dwarf.

Thorin crossed the threshold.

Warmth surrounded him.

And then he saw them.

Dwalin sat near the table, broad-shouldered and scowling at something Bofur had said. Balin was smiling over a cup of ale. Bombur had apparently discovered another plate of food, while Bifur and Óin were engaged in a noisy conversation.

Dori was attempting to keep Ori away from the last of the seed cakes. Nori looked suspiciously pleased with himself. Glóin was arguing with someone about the proper care of weapons.

And near the hearth stood Fíli and Kíli.

Alive.

Both of them.

Kíli noticed him first.

“Uncle!”

The young dwarf grinned, and Thorin felt something inside him fracture.

“We thought you'd gotten lost!”

Fíli smiled. “Or decided to leave us to eat all the food.”

Thorin could only stare.

He remembered Fíli's body.

He remembered Kíli's blood.

He remembered believing that his ambition had destroyed the sons of his sister.

Now Kíli was laughing, and Fíli was looking at him with affectionate amusement.

Thorin crossed the room before he could think better of it.

He caught Kíli by the shoulder, drew him into a fierce embrace, and reached for Fíli with his other arm.

Both nephews froze.

“Uncle?” Fíli asked, bewildered.

Thorin held them tighter.

For one brief, desperate moment, he allowed himself to believe they were truly there.

Then he released them.

Kíli stared at him.

“Well,” he said slowly, “it's good to see you too.”

Fíli's expression had softened.

“Is everything all right?”

Thorin looked between them.

“Yes,” he answered, his voice rough. “Everything is quite all right.”

Across the room, Balin watched him with growing concern.

Gandalf watched him too.

And Bilbo, standing near the doorway, wondered what sort of dwarf embraced his relatives as though he had just returned from a war.

__________

 

The meeting began much as Thorin remembered.

There was the map of Erebor, spread across Bilbo's table. There was Gandalf's explanation of the secret door, the dragon Smaug, and the possibility of reclaiming the Lonely Mountain.

There were questions about weapons, treasure, and the terrible dangers ahead.

And there was Bilbo, standing near his own furniture, looking increasingly horrified by the prospect of being involved.

Thorin watched him whenever he could.

He remembered this evening differently.

He remembered arriving with a heart full of bitterness, seeing a comfortable little hobbit and immediately deciding that Gandalf had made a terrible mistake.

Now he could scarcely comprehend how he had ever looked at Bilbo and seen anything less than extraordinary.

“Gandalf,” Glóin said, “you cannot seriously expect this hobbit to be our burglar.”

Bilbo straightened indignantly.

“I beg your pardon?”

“He doesn't look particularly fierce,” Dwalin observed.

“I'm not supposed to look fierce!” Bilbo protested. “I'm not supposed to be involved in any of this!”

A few dwarves laughed.

Thorin did not.

“Master Baggins has not yet agreed to accompany us,” he said calmly. “Perhaps we might allow him to decide before discussing his shortcomings.”

The room fell strangely quiet.

Dwalin turned toward him.

Balin lowered his cup.

Even Gandalf raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo looked at Thorin with surprise.

“Well,” he said, recovering himself, “thank you. Though I should point out that I have already decided.”

“Have you?” Thorin asked gently.

“Yes. I am not going.”

Thorin felt the familiar ache of memory.

He remembered the following morning. The empty place among the ponies. The sound of approaching footsteps and Bilbo shouting that he had signed the contract.

He knew how this would end.

But Bilbo did not.

And Thorin would not take that choice away from him.

“Then I respect your decision,” he answered.

Silence.

Kíli looked at Fíli.

Fíli looked at Balin.

Dwalin looked as though someone had struck him over the head with a shovel.

Gandalf regarded Thorin with an expression of intense interest.

Bilbo, meanwhile, seemed entirely unprepared for such a reasonable answer.

“Oh,” he said. “Well. Good.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“Of course, should you reconsider, you would be most welcome among us.”

Bilbo blinked again.

“That's very kind, but I really don't think—”

“There is no need to explain.”

Thorin smiled.

It was a small smile, but genuine.

And Bilbo Baggins, who had spent the evening surrounded by dwarves apparently determined to consume everything in his pantry, found himself unexpectedly flustered.

The discussion continued.

When the contract was produced, Bilbo examined it with increasing alarm.

“Incineration?” he demanded. “What do you mean, incineration?”

Bofur began explaining the dragon's unfortunate habit of breathing fire.

Bilbo grew pale.

Thorin immediately rose.

“Perhaps Master Baggins would prefer to sit.”

“I am perfectly capable of standing, thank you.”

“Of course.”

Thorin remained close enough to catch him when, moments later, the hobbit's nerves finally overcame him.

Bilbo swayed.

Thorin's hand closed gently around his arm.

“Easy,” he murmured.

Bilbo looked up at him.

For a heartbeat, Thorin forgot where he was.

He remembered holding that same arm beside a campfire. Remembered Bilbo laughing at something Kíli had said. Remembered the warmth of the hobbit's hand against his cheek on Ravenhill.

Then Bilbo pulled himself upright.

“I'm quite all right.”

“I know.”

Thorin released him immediately.

Dwalin was staring.

Balin was smiling into his beard.

And Gandalf's eyes had narrowed thoughtfully.

__________

 

Later, when the Company gathered to sing of the Lonely Mountain, Thorin found himself unable to join them.

The familiar voices filled Bag End, deep and solemn, carrying memories of ancient halls, lost treasures, and a home stolen by fire.

He had heard those voices on the first night of the Quest.

He had heard them again around campfires, beneath mountain skies, and inside the stone halls of Erebor.

He had believed some of them silenced forever.

Now they surrounded him.

Kíli sang beside Fíli. Balin's voice was steady and warm. Dwalin's deep tones joined the others.

Thorin sat with his hands clasped tightly together, struggling to master himself.

Across the room, Bilbo listened with an expression that slowly changed from discomfort to something softer.

The song stirred something in him, just as it had before.

Thorin watched the firelight touch his face.

And for the first time since waking outside Bag End, he began to believe that perhaps this was not a punishment.

Perhaps it was a gift.

__________

 

The Company eventually settled for the night.

Bilbo retreated to his bedroom after making it abundantly clear that he had no intention of joining their adventure. The dwarves found places to sleep among the chairs, rugs, and cushions, and Bag End gradually grew quiet.

Thorin remained awake.

He sat near the dying fire, listening to the gentle breathing of his companions.

He had never imagined silence could feel so precious.

“Something troubles you.”

Thorin looked up.

Balin stood nearby, holding two cups of tea.

The older dwarf offered him one and settled beside him.

“You've scarcely spoken all evening,” Balin continued. “And when you have, you've been rather unlike yourself.”

Thorin accepted the cup.

“Have I?”

Balin gave him a patient look.

“You embraced your nephews as though you'd not seen them in twenty years. You agreed with Gandalf without arguing. And you were positively courteous to our prospective burglar.”

“Is courtesy so unusual?”

“From you? Toward a stranger? Under these circumstances?”

Thorin almost laughed.

Balin studied him more carefully.

“You look tired, lad.”

The familiar affection in his voice struck Thorin unexpectedly.

He remembered Balin kneeling beside him in Erebor, pleading with him to abandon the madness that had taken hold of his mind.

He remembered the disappointment in those kind eyes.

“I have been thinking,” Thorin said.

“About Erebor?”

“About many things.”

Balin waited.

Thorin looked toward the hallway leading to Bilbo's bedroom.

“Tell me something, Balin. Do you believe a man can change?”

The older dwarf considered the question.

“I should hope so. Otherwise there would be little point in living long enough to grow old.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

Balin rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“Whatever burdens you carry, you needn't carry them alone.”

Thorin lowered his eyes.

He wanted to tell him.

He wanted to explain everything: the mountain, the gold, the madness, the battle, the terrible sight of his nephews lying dead.

But how could he?

How could he look into Balin's face and tell him that he remembered a future that had not yet happened?

“Thank you,” Thorin said instead.

Balin squeezed his shoulder before rising.

__________

 

From the shadows near the doorway, Gandalf watched their exchange without interrupting.

He had known Thorin Oakenshield for many years.

He knew the dwarf's pride, his temper, his fierce loyalty, and the sorrow he carried for his people.

But tonight he had seen something new.

Thorin had looked at his nephews with grief.

He had looked at Bilbo Baggins with tenderness.

And he had looked at the map of Erebor with something remarkably close to fear.

Gandalf did not know what had happened to him.

But he intended to find out.

__________

 

Morning arrived with sunlight spilling through the windows and the smell of fresh bread.

Bilbo awoke to an astonishing discovery.

His house was clean.

The dishes had been washed and put away. The furniture stood where it belonged. The pantry, although considerably diminished, had been left in respectable order.

And the dwarves were gone.

For a while, he wandered through the quiet rooms, uncertain whether to feel relieved or disappointed.

Then he found the contract.

It lay upon the table beside a short note explaining where the Company would be waiting.

Bilbo picked it up.

He read the terms again.

He thought about dragons.

He thought about mountains, goblins, and all the dreadful things that could happen to a respectable hobbit far from home.

Then he thought about the song.

About the longing in the dwarves' voices.

About the strange, dark-haired leader who had treated him with such unexpected kindness.

Thorin Oakenshield had looked at him as though he were someone worth listening to.

As though his opinion mattered.

As though, somehow, the dwarf had already decided to trust him.

Bilbo stared at the contract.

“Oh, bother.”

A few minutes later, the front door of Bag End flew open.

And Bilbo Baggins ran.

__________

 

The Company had already left Hobbiton behind when Kíli decided that the morning required entertainment.

“I wager the hobbit doesn't come.”

Dwalin snorted.

“That's hardly a wager worth making.”

“Then you agree?”

“Of course I agree.”

Nori joined in immediately, followed by Bofur and several others.

“He looked ready to faint at the mention of a dragon,” Glóin remarked.

“He did faint,” Dori corrected.

“Nearly,” said Ori.

“Near enough.”

Gandalf, riding a little ahead, smiled beneath the brim of his hat.

“I wouldn't be so certain, if I were you.”

Kíli brightened.

“Are you wagering that he'll come?”

“I am.”

Balin nodded.

“As am I.”

Kíli looked delighted.

“Excellent! Two against the rest of us.”

“Three,” Thorin said.

The conversation stopped.

Fíli turned in his saddle.

“Uncle?”

“Three,” Thorin repeated. “I believe Master Baggins will join us.”

Dwalin stared at him.

“You?”

“Yes.”

“The same Thorin Oakenshield who spent the better part of last month questioning Gandalf's choice of burglar?”

Thorin glanced at him.

“I have reconsidered.”

Kíli looked as though he had just witnessed a mountain begin to dance.

“Since when?”

“Since last evening.”

Balin coughed into his beard.

Gandalf's eyes twinkled.

Kíli recovered enough to ask, “How much are you wagering?”

“Ten gold pieces.”

Dwalin nearly dropped his reins.

“Ten?”

Thorin nodded.

“Unless you are afraid to lose.”

Kíli immediately accepted.

So did Nori.

Dwalin muttered something about madness running in the royal family.

Thorin barely heard them.

He was looking back along the road.

He remembered this morning.

He remembered the sunshine, the rolling hills, the gentle rhythm of the ponies.

And he remembered a familiar voice shouting in the distance.

He waited.

A minute passed.

Then another.

For the first time, uncertainty stirred in his chest.

What if Bilbo did not come?

What if the future had already changed?

What if—

“Wait!”

Thorin's heart stopped.

“Wait for me!”

Around the bend came a small figure running as fast as his legs would carry him, a coat flapping behind him and a folded parchment clutched in one hand.

Bilbo Baggins.

Thorin laughed.

It escaped him before he could stop it, a warm, breathless sound that made Fíli turn sharply toward him.

Bilbo reached the Company, panting.

“I signed it!”

Gandalf smiled.

“Splendid!”

Bilbo held up the contract.

“I signed the contract!”

Kíli groaned.

Dwalin looked thoroughly disgusted.

Balin began chuckling.

And Thorin dismounted.

That, more than anything, silenced the Company.

Their leader crossed the short distance between himself and the breathless hobbit.

Bilbo looked up, still struggling to catch his breath.

“Master Oakenshield,” he managed.

“Master Baggins.”

Thorin smiled.

Not the restrained expression he had offered the previous evening, but a genuine smile that softened his entire face.

“I am very glad you came.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Oh. Well. Thank you.”

“You are certain of your decision?”

Bilbo looked down at the contract, then toward the distant hills.

“No,” he admitted.

Thorin's smile grew.

“An honest answer.”

“I suspect I'll regret it terribly.”

“Perhaps.”

Bilbo looked up again.

“But I think,” Thorin continued gently, “that you may also discover things you never imagined.”

Something in his voice made Bilbo pause.

The dwarf looked at him with such warmth, such unmistakable happiness, that Bilbo found himself smiling despite his nerves.

“Well,” he said, “I suppose there's only one way to find out.”

“Indeed.”

Thorin stepped aside as the others prepared a pony for their newest companion.

Behind him, Kíli leaned toward Fíli.

“Did Uncle just smile at the hobbit?”

Fíli watched Thorin carefully.

“He did.”

“And he bet ten gold pieces on him.”

“He did.”

Kíli frowned.

“Do you think he's ill?”

Fíli considered the question.

Then he looked toward their uncle, who was patiently helping Bilbo adjust the straps of his borrowed saddle.

“I think,” Fíli answered quietly, “something has happened to him.”

Balin, riding nearby, heard the exchange.

He said nothing.

But his gaze lingered on Thorin for a long moment.

Gandalf, meanwhile, watched the dwarf king with an expression that was thoughtful rather than amused.

There were many things the wizard understood about the world.

And many things he did not.

But he knew this much: Thorin Oakenshield had arrived at Bag End carrying a sorrow that had not been there before.

And somehow, Bilbo Baggins seemed to be the answer to it.

__________

 

As the Company continued eastward, Bilbo struggled to settle comfortably upon his pony.

“I really must insist,” he said, “that someone explain why these creatures insist upon moving quite so much.”

Bofur laughed.

Kíli offered several entirely unhelpful suggestions.

Thorin guided his own pony closer.

“Hold the reins a little more loosely,” he advised. “And sit back. She will follow the others.”

Bilbo tried.

The pony immediately settled.

“Oh,” he said, surprised. “That's much better.”

Thorin smiled.

“Good.”

For a while they rode together in companionable silence.

Bilbo looked around at the green hills, the open sky, and the unfamiliar road stretching before them.

Then he glanced at Thorin.

“You seem remarkably certain that I'll be useful.”

“I am.”

“But you hardly know me.”

Thorin's fingers tightened briefly around his reins.

He looked at the hobbit beside him.

The Bilbo who had once stood against a dragon.

The Bilbo who had defended him before an army.

The Bilbo who had held him while he died.

I know you better than you can imagine, Thorin thought.

Instead, he said, “I believe there is more to you than you realize, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo's cheeks grew faintly pink.

“Well. That's very generous of you.”

“It is merely the truth.”

Bilbo looked away, smiling to himself.

Thorin watched him for a moment before turning his gaze toward the road.

Ahead lay trolls, goblins, orcs, enchanted forests, and a mountain filled with gold.

Somewhere beyond them waited Azog.

Somewhere waited the Arkenstone.

And somewhere, upon a cold and lonely hill, waited the place where Thorin Oakenshield had once died.

He did not know whether he could change what was coming.

He did not know why he had been returned to the beginning, or whether some greater power had granted him this impossible mercy.

But Fíli and Kíli were alive.

His Company was whole.

And Bilbo Baggins rode beside him, complaining cheerfully about the absence of a proper breakfast.

Thorin listened to every word.

He had once possessed a kingdom and lost everything that mattered.

Now he had nothing but a road, a borrowed future, and the company of a hobbit who did not yet love him.

It was more than enough.

And this time, Thorin Oakenshield intended to make every moment count.

Chapter 2: Chapter Two — The Things That Refuse to Change

Chapter Text

By the third morning of their journey, Dwalin had begun to suspect that something was seriously wrong with Thorin Oakenshield.

He had considered several possibilities.

Illness seemed unlikely. Thorin rode as straight-backed as ever, ate without complaint, and had spent the previous evening sharpening his sword with the same grim concentration he had displayed for as long as Dwalin could remember. An injury was equally improbable. Dwalin had watched him lift a fallen tree branch out of their path without so much as a wince.

That left enchantment, madness, or some terrible secret.

Dwalin was beginning to favor enchantment.

The trouble had started at Bag End, when Thorin had embraced his nephews as though they had returned from the dead. It had continued when he wagered ten perfectly good gold pieces on the arrival of a hobbit he had never met before that evening. And now, three days into a journey that promised hardship, hunger, and almost certain danger, Thorin Oakenshield was behaving like a dwarf who had discovered an entirely new personality.

He had smiled six times that morning.

Dwalin had counted.

More disturbingly, four of those smiles had been directed at Bilbo Baggins.

The hobbit was currently riding beside their leader, explaining at considerable length why a proper breakfast ought to consist of more than a handful of dried fruit and whatever unfortunate creatures could be persuaded to surrender their eggs.

Thorin was listening.

Actually listening.

“And I don't mean to suggest that your provisions are inadequate,” Bilbo continued, carefully adjusting his position upon his pony, “but there is something rather disheartening about waking before sunrise and discovering that breakfast is apparently an optional affair.”

“Breakfast is not optional,” Thorin replied.

Bilbo brightened. “Precisely!”

“Though I fear we cannot promise six meals every day.”

“Six?” Bilbo looked offended. “Good heavens, no. That would be excessive.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Seven is generally sufficient,” Bilbo explained.

The dwarf king laughed.

Dwalin nearly rode into a tree.

Beside him, Balin watched the exchange with an expression of quiet amusement.

“You'll frighten your pony if you keep staring like that,” Balin remarked.

“Something's wrong with him.”

“Who? The pony?”

“Thorin.”

Balin glanced toward their leader, who was now patiently listening to Bilbo describe the difference between elevenses and luncheon.

“He seems rather well to me.”

“He offered the hobbit the last apple yesterday.”

“Very generous.”

“He likes apples.”

“So does Master Baggins.”

Dwalin scowled. “You're enjoying this.”

“Immensely.”

___________

 

Ahead of them, Thorin heard every word.

He chose not to acknowledge either dwarf.

Instead, he watched Bilbo struggle to tuck a loose strand of curly hair behind his ear while keeping hold of his reins. The morning sunlight caught the gold and chestnut in those curls, and for one painful moment Thorin remembered them damp with melting snow.

He forced the memory away.

The road beneath their ponies was firm, the air pleasantly cool, and Bilbo was alive beside him. Those were the things that mattered.

Still, the knowledge of what lay ahead never entirely left him.

He remembered the trolls. He remembered the goblins beneath the Misty Mountains, the pale orc who hunted his bloodline, and the terrible forest where even the trees seemed determined to swallow unwary travellers.

Most of all, he remembered how quickly an ordinary evening could become a disaster.

Consequently, the Company had begun travelling under rather stricter rules than before.

There were now two dwarves on watch whenever they camped, even in country that appeared perfectly peaceful. No one was permitted to wander beyond sight of the others without informing someone. Thorin inspected their supplies each morning and insisted that every pony be properly secured before nightfall.

Dwalin approved of the precautions.

He simply wished he understood what had inspired them.

Thorin, meanwhile, had already discovered the first difficulty with changing the future.

Every decision created another uncertainty.

If they travelled more quickly, would they encounter the trolls sooner? If they chose another road, would Azog's hunters find them somewhere worse? If he warned Gandalf about dangers that had not yet appeared, how long would it take the wizard to demand an explanation?

He could not simply tell them everything.

Not yet.

And so he watched the road, guarded his companions, and tried not to let the weight of remembered deaths steal the joy of seeing them alive.

“Thorin?”

Bilbo's voice drew him from his thoughts.

“Yes?”

“You've gone rather quiet.”

“My apologies.”

“Oh, there's no need to apologize.” Bilbo hesitated. “I only wondered whether I'd said something wrong.”

Thorin looked at him in surprise.

“Not at all.”

“Good. Because I was about to explain afternoon tea, and I would hate to discover that I've already exhausted your patience.”

A smile tugged at Thorin's mouth.

“Please continue, Master Baggins.”

Behind them, Dwalin groaned.

___________

 

The rain arrived late that afternoon.

It began as a fine mist drifting between the hills, but within an hour it had become a steady downpour that soaked cloaks, darkened the road, and transformed every hollow into a muddy puddle.

Bilbo bore it with admirable determination for approximately twenty minutes.

Then he began shivering.

Thorin noticed immediately.

Without interrupting the conversation between Bofur and Bombur, he guided his pony alongside Bilbo's and removed the heavy outer cloak from his shoulders.

“Here.”

Bilbo looked at the offered garment.

“Oh, no, I couldn't.”

“You're cold.”

“So are you, surely.”

“I am accustomed to travelling in worse weather.”

“That hardly seems a sensible reason to make yourself miserable.”

Thorin almost smiled. He remembered that stubbornness very well.

“Humor me.”

Bilbo studied him for a moment before accepting the cloak. It was far too large, falling over his shoulders and nearly covering his knees, but it was wonderfully warm.

“Thank you,” he said, somewhat shyly.

“You're welcome.”

Thorin reached across to straighten the collar where it had folded beneath Bilbo's chin, then withdrew his hand before the gesture could become too familiar.

Bilbo's cheeks warmed despite the rain.

Behind them, Kíli leaned toward his brother.

“Do you think Uncle has realized he gave away his cloak?”

Fíli glanced at Thorin.

“I suspect he knows.”

“But he hates being wet.”

“He does.”

Kíli considered this with deep suspicion.

“Perhaps the hobbit has enchanted him.”

Fíli shook his head, though his expression was thoughtful.

“Perhaps.”

___________

 

By evening, the rain had stopped, leaving the forest smelling of wet earth and pine needles. The Company made camp beneath a rocky overhang, where the ground was relatively dry and the trees offered some protection from the wind.

Thorin supervised the arrangements while Dwalin and Glóin gathered firewood. Fíli helped secure the ponies, Kíli complained about being assigned to the first watch, and Bombur began preparing supper.

Bilbo sat upon a fallen log, attempting to dry his feet near the fire.

His toes were cold, his curls were damp, and he was beginning to suspect that adventures had been invented by people who had never properly appreciated the comforts of a well-furnished sitting room.

Nevertheless, he was not entirely unhappy.

The dwarves were noisy, occasionally impossible, and possessed a remarkable talent for arguing over matters that seemed entirely unimportant. Yet they had begun including him in their conversations, and Bofur had spent much of the afternoon teaching him an absurd drinking song.

And then there was Thorin.

Bilbo did not quite know what to make of him.

The dwarf was clearly their leader. His companions obeyed him without hesitation when danger threatened, and even Dwalin listened when Thorin's voice took on that particular commanding tone.

But toward Bilbo, he was almost unfailingly gentle.

It was rather bewildering.

At present, Thorin sat a short distance away, examining a map by firelight. His dark hair had come loose from its usual arrangement, and several strands were tangled around the leather fastenings of his coat.

Bilbo noticed immediately.

He tried not to.

He truly did.

But after several minutes of watching Thorin absently push the tangled hair away from his face, Bilbo could bear it no longer.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf looked up.

“Yes, Bilbo?”

“Your hair.”

Thorin blinked.

“My hair?”

“It's terribly tangled.”

Several nearby dwarves stopped talking.

Thorin glanced down at the loose strands falling across his shoulder.

“Travelling tends to have that effect.”

“Yes, but surely it must be uncomfortable.”

“A little.”

Bilbo frowned.

“Well, that won't do.”

He rummaged through his travelling bag and produced a small wooden comb.

“Would you like me to braid it for you?”

Fíli choked on his tea.

Kíli's spoon slipped from his fingers and landed in the stew.

Balin became very interested in the contents of his cup.

Thorin went perfectly still.

For a moment, the crackling fire seemed impossibly loud.

Bilbo looked around, confused.

“What?”

Fíli cleared his throat.

“Master Baggins, perhaps you don't understand. Among dwarves, braiding another person's hair is rather—”

“Fíli.”

Thorin's voice was quiet, but it carried unmistakable authority.

His nephew stopped immediately.

Thorin looked at Bilbo.

“You would not mind?”

Bilbo appeared genuinely puzzled.

“Of course not. My mother always said there was no excuse for allowing one's hair to become a bird's nest, and yours is very nearly approaching that condition.”

Kíli made a strangled noise.

Thorin's expression softened.

“Then I would be grateful.”

The silence that followed was extraordinary.

Dwalin slowly turned his head.

Glóin stared openly.

Even Gandalf, seated near the edge of the firelight, lowered his pipe.

Bilbo, entirely unaware of the significance of what had just occurred, smiled with satisfaction.

“Excellent. Come and sit here, then. I shall need better light.”

And Thorin Oakenshield, King under the Mountain in all but possession of his kingdom, obediently rose and sat upon the ground in front of a hobbit.

Kíli looked as though he might faint.

Bilbo settled behind Thorin upon the log, carefully gathered the dark hair over his shoulders, and began working through the tangles with his comb.

Thorin closed his eyes.

He had forgotten how gentle Bilbo's hands could be.

In his first life, he had learned the shape of those hands through countless small acts of kindness: a bandage tied around an injured wrist, a cup of water offered after a difficult climb, fingers resting briefly upon his arm in reassurance.

And, at the very end, those same hands had tried desperately to keep him alive.

Now they moved carefully through his hair.

Bilbo worked with patient concentration, occasionally murmuring an apology when the comb caught a stubborn knot. Thorin assured him each time that he was perfectly comfortable.

He was more than comfortable.

He felt as though some long-frozen part of him had finally begun to thaw.

Among his people, hair carried history and meaning. Braids could signify kinship, allegiance, mourning, and courtship. To allow someone outside one's family to tend one's hair was an act of profound trust, and to accept a braid offered with affection could mean considerably more.

Thorin knew precisely what he was allowing.

He also knew Bilbo did not.

He would never hold the innocent gesture against him or presume it meant something the hobbit had not intended.

But he could treasure it.

“There,” Bilbo said at last, fastening the finished braid with a narrow strip of dark leather. “Much better.”

Thorin lifted a hand, feeling the neat arrangement against his shoulder.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo looked pleased.

“You have lovely hair, you know. It's simply a shame to let it become so tangled.”

Thorin turned slightly.

For a moment, his expression was so openly tender that Bilbo forgot what he had been about to say.

“You are very kind to me,” Thorin murmured.

Bilbo blinked.

“Well, you've been very kind to me.”

Thorin smiled.

Across the fire, Fíli slowly covered his face with one hand.

Kíli leaned closer.

“He knows what it means, doesn't he?”

“Of course he does,” Fíli whispered.

“Then why did he let him?”

Fíli watched their uncle carefully.

“I think,” he answered, “that's the question we ought to be asking.”

Dwalin looked toward Balin.

Balin merely smiled.

Gandalf drew thoughtfully upon his pipe.

And Bilbo, completely oblivious, began explaining that a little oil would prevent the ends from splitting.

___________

 

Later that evening, Gandalf found Thorin standing beyond the firelight.

The dwarf was looking toward the dark trees, one hand resting upon the hilt of his sword.

His newly braided hair lay neatly over his shoulder.

Gandalf noticed it, of course.

He chose not to mention it.

“You seem troubled,” the wizard observed.

Thorin did not turn.

“The road is dangerous.”

“It has always been dangerous.”

“Some roads more than others.”

Gandalf studied him.

“For several days, you have behaved as though you expect an attack at any moment. You have changed our route twice, insisted upon additional watches, and questioned every traveller we have passed.”

“I am responsible for thirteen lives.”

“Fourteen, including your own.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

Gandalf stepped closer.

“And yet I cannot help wondering whether there is something you are not telling me.”

Thorin remained silent.

The wizard's voice softened.

“You behave, at times, as though you know what awaits us around every corner.”

A chill passed through Thorin.

He turned toward Gandalf, carefully controlling his expression.

“I have spent many years on dangerous roads.”

“So have I.”

“Then you understand my caution.”

“I understand caution. I do not understand why you looked toward the northern hills yesterday before we heard the wolves.”

Thorin said nothing.

Gandalf regarded him for a long moment.

“Have you been dreaming, Thorin?”

The question struck closer than the wizard could possibly know.

“Dreaming?”

“Of things that have not yet happened.”

Thorin looked away.

“I have had enough dreams to last a lifetime.”

Gandalf did not press him further.

Instead, he glanced toward the darkening forest.

“There are troubling signs in these lands. I intend to investigate them tomorrow. I shall rejoin you farther along the road.”

Thorin remembered.

In his first life, Gandalf had departed after a bitter disagreement, leaving the Company to face the trolls without him.

This time, there had been no argument.

Yet the wizard was leaving all the same.

Thorin felt a cold unease settle in his stomach.

Some events, it seemed, were determined to repeat themselves.

“Be careful,” he said.

Gandalf raised an eyebrow.

“Are you worried about me?”

“I would prefer not to lose our wizard before we reach the mountains.”

A faint smile touched Gandalf's face.

“Then I shall endeavor to return.”

Thorin watched him walk back toward the fire.

For a moment, he considered telling him everything.

But the memory of Bilbo's tears upon Ravenhill rose before him, followed by the sight of Fíli and Kíli lying dead.

He could not bear to speak those things aloud.

Not while they were still alive.

___________

 

The following afternoon, Gandalf departed.

The Company continued eastward beneath a sky heavy with clouds, travelling through increasingly wild country where the roads were narrow and the trees grew close together.

Thorin recognized the landscape.

He remembered the miserable rain, the missing ponies, and the three trolls whose appetites had nearly brought their Quest to an early end.

This time, he would avoid them.

He chose a different path through the hills and ordered the Company to camp well away from the place he remembered.

Dwalin questioned the decision.

“The old road would have been quicker.”

“It would also have left us exposed.”

“Exposed to what?”

Thorin looked toward the trees.

“Whatever might be watching.”

Dwalin did not look satisfied, but he obeyed.

By evening, they had established camp in a sheltered hollow. The ponies were secured near the trees, and Thorin assigned Fíli and Kíli to watch them while Bombur prepared supper.

Bilbo sat beside the fire, helping Bofur peel potatoes.

For a while, everything seemed peaceful.

Then Kíli returned.

“Uncle?”

Thorin looked up.

“One of the ponies is missing.”

The knife in Thorin's hand went still.

“Which one?”

“The grey mare.”

“Did you see what happened?”

Kíli shook his head.

Thorin rose immediately.

“Fíli?”

“Still watching the others.”

A familiar dread settled in Thorin's chest.

He had changed their campsite.

He had changed their route.

And yet—

A distant, ugly laugh echoed through the trees.

Thorin closed his eyes briefly.

Of course.

He drew his sword.

“Dwalin. With me.”

Bilbo stood.

“What is it?”

“Trouble,” Thorin answered.

Then he looked at the hobbit, who was already reaching for his small travelling blade.

Thorin remembered what happened next.

He remembered Bilbo's courage.

And he remembered how badly he had misjudged him.

“Master Baggins,” he said, “I may need your help.”

Bilbo straightened.

“My help?”

“Yes.”

The hobbit swallowed, but nodded.

“Of course.”

The trolls were larger than Bilbo had imagined.

Much larger.

They sat around a roaring fire in a clearing, arguing over the best way to prepare their stolen supper. One was holding a pony's bridle, another was stirring a foul-smelling pot, and the third appeared to be complaining about the quality of the meat.

Bilbo crouched behind a tree, his heart hammering.

Thorin knelt beside him.

“Stay low,” the dwarf murmured.

Bilbo nodded.

“They're enormous.”

“They are.”

“And rather ugly.”

“Very.”

Bilbo glanced at him.

“You don't seem particularly surprised.”

Thorin looked toward the trolls.

“I have encountered their kind before.”

That, at least, was true.

He had encountered these very trolls before.

He had also been tied inside a sack while they discussed how best to cook him.

It was not an experience he wished to repeat.

Unfortunately, fate appeared to have other ideas.

Bilbo attempted to retrieve the ponies while the trolls argued, but one of the creatures turned unexpectedly and caught sight of him.

A huge hand closed around his coat.

“Well, what's this?”

Bilbo gave a startled cry.

Thorin moved immediately.

“Release him!”

The clearing erupted into chaos.

Dwalin charged from the trees, followed by the others. Steel flashed in the firelight as the dwarves attacked, but the trolls were immensely strong, and their heavy clubs sent several members of the Company sprawling.

Thorin fought fiercely, keeping himself between Bilbo and the nearest creature whenever possible.

He had hoped to avoid this.

Instead, his efforts had brought them into the same danger by a different road.

One troll seized Bilbo and lifted him into the air.

“Drop your weapons!”

Thorin froze.

Bilbo dangled helplessly above the ground.

The troll tightened its grip.

“Or we'll tear his arms off!”

Thorin's blood turned cold.

He remembered this moment.

He remembered lowering his sword, furious at Bilbo for being captured.

But looking at the frightened hobbit now, Thorin felt no anger.

Only terror.

“Put him down,” he said, his voice dangerously quiet.

The troll grinned.

“Weapons first.”

Thorin dropped his sword.

The others reluctantly followed.

Within minutes, the Company had been bound and dragged toward the fire.

Bilbo was released, though he remained under the trolls' watchful eyes.

__________

 

Thorin struggled against the ropes around his wrists.

He knew what had to happen.

They needed time.

Sunrise would destroy the creatures, but dawn was still some way off.

And Gandalf was nowhere to be seen.

Bilbo, meanwhile, was watching the trolls argue over their cooking pot.

A familiar expression appeared upon his face.

Thorin recognized it immediately.

The hobbit was thinking.

“Excuse me,” Bilbo called.

One troll turned.

“What?”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Well, if you're planning to cook dwarves, I really wouldn't recommend boiling them.”

Several dwarves stared at him.

The troll frowned.

“Why not?”

“Because they'll taste dreadful.”

Thorin lowered his head to conceal a smile.

Bilbo continued, gaining confidence.

“Very tough, dwarves. Particularly these ones. You'd be much better off roasting them slowly.”

“Roasting?” another troll repeated.

“No, boiling!” the third argued.

The trolls began shouting at one another.

Bilbo stepped closer to the fire.

Thorin caught his eye.

For one brief moment, their gazes met.

Thorin gave the smallest nod.

Keep going.

Bilbo seemed to understand.

“Well, of course,” he said loudly, “there's also the matter of seasoning.”

“Seasoning?”

“Oh, absolutely. You can't simply throw dwarves into a pot and expect a decent supper.”

Kíli stared at his uncle.

“Is he trying to get us eaten?”

“Quiet,” Thorin murmured.

“But—”

“Trust him.”

The words silenced his nephew.

Bilbo continued talking.

He discussed herbs, cooking temperatures, and the unfortunate consequences of preparing meat without proper consideration.

The trolls argued.

Minutes passed.

The sky slowly began to lighten.

Thorin watched the eastern horizon.

Come on, Gandalf.

One troll finally lost patience.

“Enough talking!”

It seized Bilbo by the back of his coat.

Thorin surged against his bonds.

“Leave him!”

The creature ignored him.

“We're eating now!”

Then a familiar voice rang through the clearing.

“The dawn will take you all!”

Gandalf stood upon the rocks above them.

He raised his staff.

With a tremendous crack, the stone split apart, allowing the first brilliant rays of sunlight to flood the clearing.

The trolls screamed.

Their bodies hardened.

Their faces twisted in expressions of horror.

And within moments, three enormous stone figures stood where living creatures had been.

Silence followed.

Then Bilbo sat down rather suddenly upon the grass.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Thorin was at his side as soon as his bonds were cut.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked up.

“Are they really—?”

“Stone,” Thorin assured him.

“Entirely?”

“Entirely.”

Bilbo exhaled shakily.

“Good.”

Thorin knelt beside him.

“Are you hurt?”

“Only my dignity, I think.”

Thorin examined the hobbit's wrists, where the troll's rough grip had left angry red marks.

His expression darkened.

Bilbo noticed.

“Oh, it's nothing serious.”

“That does not mean it should be ignored.”

He carefully released Bilbo's hands.

“You were very brave.”

Bilbo blinked.

“I was terrified.”

“Courage does not require the absence of fear.”

For a moment, Bilbo simply looked at him.

Then a shy smile appeared.

“Thank you.”

Behind them, Dwalin was watching with an expression of profound confusion.

Thorin turned toward the Company.

“Master Baggins bought us the time we needed. Remember that.”

Balin smiled warmly.

Bofur clapped Bilbo upon the shoulder.

Kíli grinned.

And Bilbo, who had expected to be blamed for the entire disaster, found himself unexpectedly pleased.

__________

 

The trolls' cave lay concealed beneath a rocky hillside.

Inside, the Company discovered stolen supplies, old coins, weapons, and enough unpleasant smells to convince Bilbo that trolls possessed no understanding whatsoever of proper housekeeping.

Gandalf examined the weapons carefully.

“These are no ordinary blades.”

Thorin approached.

He already knew what lay before him.

Glamdring.

Orcrist.

The swords of Gondolin.

In his first life, he had regarded the elven weapons with considerable reluctance.

Now he remembered Orcrist in his hand during countless battles.

He remembered the blade flashing beneath the mountains and against Azog's hunters.

He also remembered losing it before the final battle.

Gandalf offered him the sword.

“Will you take it?”

Thorin accepted without hesitation.

“It is a fine weapon.”

Gandalf raised an eyebrow.

“An elven weapon.”

“A useful one.”

Dwalin stared.

Gandalf's mouth twitched.

“Indeed.”

Nearby, Bilbo was examining a smaller blade discovered among the treasure.

Thorin recognized it immediately.

Sting.

The sight of it brought an unexpected warmth to his chest.

Bilbo had carried that little sword through darkness and danger, using it to defend himself and others when many larger warriors would have fled.

Thorin approached.

“That one suits you.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Do you think so?”

“It is light enough for your hand, but well made.”

Bilbo studied the blade.

“I've never really used a sword.”

“You will learn.”

There was no doubt in Thorin's voice.

Bilbo looked at him for a moment before carefully returning the weapon to its sheath.

“Then I suppose I ought to practice.”

“I would be glad to teach you.”

The hobbit smiled.

“I should like that.”

Thorin felt an ache of tenderness so fierce that he had to look away.

He had been given another chance.

Not merely to save lives, but to witness moments he had once taken for granted.

Bilbo learning to hold a sword.

Kíli laughing beside the fire.

Fíli arguing with Dwalin.

Balin smiling over a cup of tea.

Small things.

Precious things.

Things no amount of gold could ever replace.

__________

 

They left the trolls' clearing before midday.

Gandalf rode beside Thorin for some time, occasionally glancing at the dwarf's newly braided hair.

Eventually, he spoke.

“You were remarkably calm during that unpleasant business.”

Thorin looked ahead.

“I did not feel calm.”

“No?”

“No.”

Gandalf considered him.

“And yet you seemed quite certain that Master Baggins knew what he was doing.”

“He did.”

“You trusted him.”

“Yes.”

“Despite having known him only a few days.”

Thorin turned toward the wizard.

“Must trust always be earned through years of acquaintance?”

“Not always.”

“Then perhaps I simply recognized a good heart when I saw one.”

Gandalf smiled faintly.

“Perhaps.”

But his expression remained thoughtful.

That evening, when the Company stopped beside a narrow stream, Thorin volunteered to inspect the surrounding woods before supper.

He took Dwalin with him.

They found the tracks less than half a mile from camp.

Heavy boots.

Clawed footprints.

The marks of wolves.

Thorin crouched beside a patch of disturbed earth, brushing aside the fallen leaves.

His stomach tightened.

He recognized the pattern of the tracks.

Orcs.

Not wandering goblins or a small band of raiders, but organized hunters moving through the wilderness.

Azog's hunters.

Dwalin knelt beside him.

“Orcs?”

Thorin nodded.

“How many?”

“Enough.”

Dwalin studied the ground.

“They're travelling west.”

“Toward us.”

His companion looked up sharply.

“How can you be certain?”

Thorin stared at the tracks.

He remembered the burning trees.

He remembered Azog standing beneath the moonlight, calling for his head.

He remembered the terrible sound of wolves closing around the Company.

And he remembered Bilbo running toward danger because Thorin had fallen.

“Because,” he answered quietly, “they are hunting someone.”

Dwalin's expression hardened.

“Us?”

Thorin rose.

“Yes.”

They returned to camp without speaking.

That night, Thorin doubled the watch.

He made certain Fíli and Kíli slept near the center of the camp, where they would be protected if an attack came unexpectedly. He checked the ponies himself and walked the perimeter twice before finally sitting beside the dying fire.

Bilbo was already there.

The hobbit looked up from the small book he had been reading.

“You look troubled.”

Thorin sat beside him.

“There are dangers ahead.”

Bilbo closed the book.

“I rather suspected there might be.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“You are not frightened?”

“Oh, I'm absolutely frightened,” Bilbo replied. “I think I've been frightened since the moment I left my front door.”

“Yet you remain.”

Bilbo looked toward the sleeping dwarves.

“Someone has to make sure you all eat properly.”

Thorin laughed softly.

Then Bilbo noticed the braid resting over his shoulder.

“Oh! It's still holding.”

Thorin glanced down.

“Yes.”

“Good. I was worried the leather might come loose.”

“It has held perfectly.”

Bilbo smiled with satisfaction.

“I could do the other side tomorrow, if you'd like.”

Thorin looked at him.

For a moment, the world seemed impossibly gentle.

The fire crackled between them, the trees whispered in the night breeze, and Bilbo Baggins sat beside him offering to braid his hair as though such a thing were perfectly ordinary.

Thorin swallowed.

“I would like that very much.”

Bilbo smiled again and returned to his book.

Thorin remained beside him, listening to the quiet sounds of the camp.

He had changed the route.

He had avoided the old campsite.

He had treated Bilbo differently, trusted him sooner, and accepted help he once would have rejected.

Yet the trolls had still found them.

Gandalf had still departed.

And Azog's hunters were still moving through the wilderness.

Thorin looked toward the darkness beyond the firelight.

Perhaps the future could be changed.

Perhaps it could not.

But one thing had become painfully clear.

Knowing what was coming did not mean he could prevent it.

Beside him, Bilbo turned a page.

Thorin glanced at the hobbit, at the peaceful expression upon his face and the soft curls falling over his forehead.

Then he looked toward the sleeping forms of his nephews.

He would not surrender them to fate.

Not again.

Whatever darkness awaited them beyond the hills, Thorin Oakenshield would face it.

And this time, he would not allow fear, pride, or a mountain full of gold to blind him to what was truly worth protecting.

Chapter 3: Chapter Three — The Road to Rivendell

Chapter Text

By the time the Company had been travelling for nearly four weeks, Bilbo Baggins had discovered several things about dwarves that no respectable hobbit had ever thought to mention.

The first was that dwarves could argue about absolutely anything.

They argued about the weather, the quality of their provisions, the proper way to sharpen an axe, and whether Bombur's cooking had improved since leaving the Shire. They argued about which road was shortest, which pony was most stubborn, and whether Kíli had deliberately put a beetle inside Nori's boot.

The second discovery was that dwarves were remarkably affectionate creatures, although they preferred to disguise this beneath insults, complaints, and occasional threats of bodily harm.

Kíli, for example, had taken to riding beside Bilbo whenever possible.

At first, the youngest prince had seemed determined to discover whether hobbits possessed any interesting secrets. He had asked whether they truly lived underground, whether they could see in the dark, and whether Bilbo had ever encountered a dragon.

Bilbo had informed him that hobbit-holes were perfectly respectable dwellings, that he could see no better in darkness than anyone else, and that dragons were not generally invited to tea.

Kíli had laughed so hard that he nearly fell from his pony.

After that, they had become friends.

Their conversations now ranged from the peculiarities of hobbit customs to Kíli's childhood in the Blue Mountains, and Bilbo had discovered that the young dwarf possessed an apparently endless collection of embarrassing stories about his elder brother.

“And then Fíli fell straight into the river,” Kíli announced one sunny afternoon, looking delighted by the memory.

“I did not fall,” Fíli corrected from ahead of them. “You pushed me.”

“I merely encouraged you to move.”

“With both hands.”

Bilbo laughed.

“And what happened afterward?”

“Mother made him apologize,” Kíli said.

Fíli turned in his saddle. “You spent the following week cleaning the stables.”

“An entirely unreasonable punishment.”

“You'd frightened three horses.”

“They were easily frightened horses.”

Bilbo shook his head, smiling.

“You sound rather like my cousins.”

Kíli brightened. “Are they handsome?”

“They are Tookish.”

“That wasn't the question.”

“In my experience, it is usually an adequate warning.”

Kíli laughed again.

__________

 

A short distance behind them, Balin watched the exchange with unmistakable fondness.

The older dwarf had grown particularly attached to their burglar over the preceding weeks. Bilbo was polite, thoughtful, and possessed a surprisingly sharp tongue when properly provoked. He also listened with genuine interest whenever Balin spoke of Erebor, asking questions about its halls, its people, and the lives they had built in exile.

More importantly, Balin had noticed something that none of the others could entirely explain.

Bilbo Baggins made Thorin happy.

Not constantly, of course. Thorin remained stubborn, proud, and occasionally as disagreeable as ever. He still argued with Dwalin about their route, issued orders with the authority of a king, and had very little patience for foolishness when danger threatened.

But he smiled more often.

And when Bilbo laughed, Thorin nearly always looked toward him.

Balin had known Thorin since he was a boy. He remembered the bright, determined prince who had once raced through Erebor's halls with his sister, before dragonfire and exile had taken so much from him.

Sometimes, watching Thorin now, Balin caught glimpses of that younger dwarf.

It warmed his heart.

It also worried him.

Because there were other moments.

Moments when Thorin watched Fíli and Kíli with an expression so full of sorrow that Balin could scarcely bear to see it.

Moments when he woke from nightmares and sat staring into the darkness until dawn.

And moments when his eyes followed Bilbo with something that looked painfully like relief.

Whatever had changed their king, Balin suspected it was not entirely a happy thing.

___________

 

That evening, they made camp beside a narrow stream.

The weather had been pleasant for several days, and the Company was in unusually good spirits. Bombur had managed to purchase fresh vegetables from a passing farmer, while Bofur had discovered a patch of wild mushrooms that Bilbo enthusiastically declared suitable for supper.

Thorin was examining their map when Bilbo approached him with a familiar wooden comb.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf looked up.

“Yes?”

“Your braid is coming loose.”

Thorin glanced at the dark hair resting over his shoulder.

“So it is.”

Bilbo frowned.

“You've been sleeping on it again.”

“I find that difficult to avoid.”

“Well, you could at least try not to make such a dreadful mess of it.”

Thorin's mouth curved.

“I shall endeavor to improve.”

Bilbo held up the comb.

“Would you like me to fix it?”

“Very much.”

Across the fire, Kíli made a peculiar choking noise.

Fíli closed his eyes.

Dwalin muttered something in Khuzdul.

Thorin ignored them all.

He moved to sit upon the ground before Bilbo, who settled comfortably on a fallen log and began loosening the old braid.

It had become something of a routine between them.

Bilbo had first offered to braid Thorin's hair during their second week on the road, after becoming thoroughly offended by the state of the dwarf's tangled locks. Since then, he had repeated the task several times, usually in the evenings when the Company had settled around the fire.

He saw nothing particularly remarkable about it.

Thorin, however, knew exactly what it meant.

Among dwarves, the tending of another's hair was a gesture of intimacy and trust. Family members braided one another's hair, as did close companions, but certain arrangements carried meanings associated with courtship and devotion.

The simple braid Bilbo favored was not itself a formal declaration.

Nevertheless, allowing someone outside one's family to tend one's hair so regularly was hardly insignificant.

Especially for a king.

Especially for Thorin Oakenshield.

And especially when the dwarf in question had spent most of his adult life refusing to allow anyone except his closest kin such familiarity.

Bilbo gently worked through a stubborn knot.

“Honestly, Thorin, I don't understand how you manage this.”

“Manage what?”

“To make such a mess of perfectly good hair.”

“I suspect the wind is responsible.”

“The wind cannot be blamed for everything.”

“An unfortunate limitation.”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin closed his eyes, allowing himself to enjoy the quiet sensation of the hobbit's fingers moving through his hair.

He remembered another life in which he had spent months yearning for such ordinary closeness, too proud and too frightened to reach for it.

Now Bilbo touched him without hesitation.

Not because he remembered loving Thorin.

Not because he owed him anything.

Simply because he cared enough to notice when his hair was tangled.

Thorin treasured that distinction.

A little distance away, Fíli watched them with growing concern.

“Uncle,” he began carefully, “might I speak with you later?”

“Of course.”

“Privately?”

Thorin opened one eye.

“If you wish.”

Kíli leaned toward his brother.

“You're going to ask him about the braids, aren't you?”

Fíli elbowed him.

Bilbo looked up.

“What about the braids?”

“Nothing,” Thorin said smoothly.

Fíli gave him a disbelieving look.

Bilbo shrugged and returned to his work.

When he finished, he secured the dark hair with a narrow leather tie and gave the braid a satisfied pat.

“There. Presentable again.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“My thanks, Bilbo.”

“You're welcome.”

For a moment, their eyes met.

Bilbo found himself noticing how handsome Thorin looked when he smiled.

It was a rather inconvenient observation.

He quickly busied himself putting away his comb.

__________

 

Later, when Thorin and Bilbo had gone to inspect the stream for a suitable place to refill their waterskins, the Company finally addressed the matter.

Dwalin was the first to speak.

“This has gone on long enough.”

Kíli looked up from his supper.

“What has?”

“Don't pretend you don't know.”

Kíli grinned.

“Oh, you mean Uncle allowing our burglar to fuss over his hair like a newlywed?”

Fíli nearly dropped his bowl.

“Kíli!”

“What? That's what it looks like.”

Óin, who had been cleaning his hearing trumpet, frowned.

“It is rather unusual.”

“Unusual?” Dwalin repeated. “I've known Thorin for decades. The last time I tried to straighten his hair before an important meeting, he threatened to break my fingers.”

“That sounds like him,” Glóin observed.

“And now he sits there every evening letting a hobbit comb it!”

Bofur smiled into his cup.

“Well, Master Baggins does seem to have a talent for it.”

Dwalin glared.

“This is not about his talent!”

Balin chuckled softly.

“Perhaps Thorin simply enjoys the company.”

Fíli shook his head.

“That's what concerns me.”

Kíli's amusement faded slightly.

“What do you mean?”

Fíli glanced toward the stream.

“He's different. Not merely with Bilbo. Haven't you noticed?”

Óin nodded.

“He sleeps poorly. I've seen him awake long after the watches have changed.”

“He checks on us constantly,” Fíli continued. “Sometimes he looks at Kíli and me as though—”

He stopped.

“As though what?” Kíli asked.

Fíli lowered his voice.

“As though he's afraid we'll disappear.”

The fire crackled quietly.

Dwalin's expression hardened.

“I've noticed.”

Óin rubbed his beard.

“I've examined him twice. No fever, no obvious injury, nothing to suggest illness. Yet he carries himself like a dwarf recovering from a terrible shock.”

“Perhaps he's worried about Erebor,” Ori suggested.

“Thorin has been worried about Erebor for years,” Dwalin replied. “That doesn't explain the rest.”

Kíli looked toward the darkness beyond the camp.

For once, he had nothing humorous to say.

Balin set down his cup.

“Whatever troubles him, I believe Master Baggins brings him comfort.”

Fíli sighed.

“I don't object to Bilbo. I like him.”

“So do I,” Kíli said immediately.

“We know,” Nori muttered. “You haven't stopped talking to him for three weeks.”

Kíli ignored him.

“But Uncle knows what those braids mean,” Fíli continued. “And Bilbo clearly doesn't.”

Balin's expression softened.

“Then perhaps we ought to trust Thorin to understand the difference.”

Dwalin grunted.

“I'd trust him more if he'd explain what in Mahal's name is going on.”

Nobody had an answer.

And when Thorin returned with Bilbo a few minutes later, the conversation ended so abruptly that even the hobbit noticed.

He looked around the fire.

“Have I interrupted something?”

“Not at all,” Balin answered pleasantly.

Dwalin stared into his supper.

Kíli began whistling.

Bilbo regarded them suspiciously.

“Dwarves,” he muttered.

Thorin heard him and smiled.

__________

 

The nightmare came two nights later.

Thorin dreamed of Ravenhill.

He dreamed of snow stained red, of Fíli hanging lifeless above the ruined courtyard, and of Kíli falling beneath an enemy's blade. He dreamed of Azog's laughter and the terrible weight of the Arkenstone in his hands.

Then he saw Bilbo.

The hobbit was kneeling beside him, crying.

But this time, when Thorin reached for him, Bilbo disappeared.

Thorin woke with a strangled gasp.

His hand shot toward his chest.

No wound.

No blood.

Only the cold night air and the quiet sounds of the sleeping Company.

He sat upright, struggling to breathe.

“Thorin?”

The voice came from nearby.

Thorin turned sharply.

Bilbo stood a few paces away, wrapped in his blanket.

“I heard you,” the hobbit said softly. “You sounded terribly distressed.”

Thorin stared at him.

Alive.

Warm.

Unharmed.

“Bilbo.”

The name escaped him with such relief that Bilbo immediately approached.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin wanted to say yes.

Instead, he reached for the hobbit's hand.

Bilbo looked surprised, but did not pull away.

Thorin held it gently, feeling the warmth of living fingers against his own.

“A dream,” he managed.

“A bad one?”

“Very.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

For a while, neither spoke.

The stars shone above the trees, and the dying fire cast a faint orange glow across the camp.

“My mother used to say that dreams are only shadows,” Bilbo murmured eventually. “They cannot hurt us once we've woken.”

Thorin looked down.

“Some shadows remain.”

Bilbo considered that.

“Perhaps. But they are easier to bear when one isn't alone.”

Thorin closed his eyes briefly.

“You are wiser than you know.”

Bilbo gave a small, embarrassed laugh.

“I wouldn't go that far.”

They remained together until Thorin's breathing settled.

Bilbo did not demand explanations.

He simply stayed.

And when he eventually returned to his blankets, Thorin watched him go with an ache that was almost unbearable.

He had loved Bilbo in one lifetime.

Now, given another chance, he was discovering that loving him again was not a choice.

It was as natural as breathing.

___________

 

The following afternoon, Thorin began teaching Bilbo to use Sting.

They had stopped beside a clearing to rest the ponies, and the weather was pleasant enough that several dwarves were practicing with their weapons.

Bilbo had been examining his little sword when Thorin approached.

“Would you like a lesson?”

Bilbo looked up.

“Now?”

“Unless you have other plans.”

“Well, I was considering a nap.”

Thorin smiled.

“Then I shall endeavor to make this brief.”

Bilbo rose reluctantly.

He had expected Thorin to be a stern instructor.

Instead, the dwarf was remarkably patient.

He showed Bilbo how to hold the blade, how to balance his weight, and how to move without losing his footing.

“Keep your shoulders relaxed,” Thorin instructed.

Bilbo attempted to follow the advice.

“Like this?”

“Almost.”

Thorin stepped closer, carefully adjusting the position of Bilbo's wrist.

Bilbo became suddenly aware of how near he was standing.

Thorin smelled faintly of leather, woodsmoke, and the clean scent of the soap Bilbo had insisted he use on his hair.

It was a distracting discovery.

“Bilbo?”

“Yes?”

“Your sword.”

“Oh! Right.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

They continued practicing.

When Bilbo successfully parried a gentle strike, Thorin smiled with unmistakable pride.

“Well done.”

Bilbo felt absurdly pleased.

Across the clearing, Kíli watched them.

“Do you think Uncle would teach me that patiently?”

Fíli glanced over.

“He taught you to fight when you were twelve.”

“Yes, and he shouted at me for dropping my sword.”

“You dropped it on his foot.”

“An accident.”

“You were laughing.”

Kíli grinned.

“Still an accident.”

___________

 

Radagast arrived three days later.

The Company had been travelling through increasingly wild country when an extraordinary sound came from the trees.

Branches snapped.

Leaves scattered.

And a small wooden sled burst onto the road, pulled by an astonishing number of enormous rabbits.

Bilbo stared.

The driver was a peculiar-looking wizard with a tangled beard, a weather-beaten brown robe, and a hat that appeared to have survived several unfortunate encounters with birds.

Gandalf immediately stepped forward.

“Radagast!”

The brown wizard looked deeply relieved.

“Gandalf! I've been looking everywhere for you!”

Thorin felt his stomach tighten.

He remembered this meeting.

The spiders.

The sickness spreading through Mirkwood.

The dark fortress of Dol Guldur.

And the ancient evil gathering strength within it.

Radagast spoke rapidly, describing the corruption overtaking the forest, the enormous spiders moving through the trees, and the unnatural darkness he had encountered.

Bilbo listened with growing alarm.

“Giant spiders?” he repeated faintly.

Radagast nodded.

“Terrible creatures. Much larger than they ought to be.”

Thorin's hand tightened around his sword.

He remembered those spiders.

He remembered Bilbo fighting them alone.

He remembered the terror of waking bound in their webs.

Gandalf noticed his expression.

Radagast continued, speaking of Dol Guldur and the shadow that had taken residence there.

Then he produced a dark, ancient blade.

Gandalf's face grew grave.

Thorin recognized it.

The Morgul blade.

He knew what it meant.

He knew the Necromancer was no mere wandering sorcerer.

“Sauron,” he murmured.

The word escaped before he could stop it.

Gandalf turned sharply.

“What did you say?”

Thorin went still.

Radagast looked between them.

“Did he say—?”

“Nothing,” Thorin answered.

Gandalf's eyes narrowed.

“Thorin.”

“I said the name of an ancient enemy.”

“And why would that name come to your mind?”

Thorin looked toward the blade.

“Because there are few powers in Middle-earth capable of such darkness.”

It was a reasonable answer.

Not a particularly convincing one.

Gandalf studied him for several moments before turning back to Radagast.

Bilbo, standing nearby, noticed the exchange.

He also noticed the way Thorin's face had gone pale.

Quietly, he stepped closer.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin looked down at him.

“Yes.”

Bilbo did not seem entirely convinced.

But before he could ask anything further, a distant howl echoed through the hills.

Thorin's blood ran cold.

Wargs.

The attack came sooner than Thorin expected.

A scout appeared upon a distant ridge, mounted upon a great grey wolf. Another followed, then a third.

The Company gathered their weapons.

Dwalin swore.

“Orcs!”

Thorin drew his sword.

He remembered the chase.

He remembered Radagast drawing the hunters away while Gandalf led them toward Rivendell.

But the road was different now.

Their earlier changes had brought them farther north, where the hills were steeper and the rocky passages less familiar.

Thorin looked toward Gandalf.

“Can you lead us to safety?”

The wizard nodded.

“There is a hidden valley not far from here.”

“Then we must move.”

Radagast climbed onto his sled.

“I can distract them!”

Gandalf hesitated.

“Radagast—”

“I've done it before!”

The brown wizard snapped his reins.

His rabbits surged forward.

Within moments, the sled was racing across the hills, with the orc scouts turning in pursuit.

__________

 

The Company ran.

Bilbo struggled to keep pace over the uneven ground, his shorter legs carrying him as quickly as possible.

Thorin remained near him.

“Keep moving!”

“I am moving!”

A warg howled behind them.

Thorin turned.

One of the hunters had broken away from Radagast's distraction and was racing toward the Company.

“Down!”

He caught Bilbo by the shoulder and pulled him aside just as the creature leapt.

Its jaws snapped shut where the hobbit's head had been.

Thorin struck with Orcrist.

The blade flashed.

The warg fell.

Bilbo stumbled backward, breathing hard.

For one terrible moment, Thorin saw Ravenhill again.

Blood.

Snow.

Bilbo crying.

He seized the hobbit's shoulders.

“Are you hurt?”

“No!”

“Are you certain?”

“Yes, Thorin!”

The dwarf's grip tightened briefly.

Bilbo looked up at him.

“I'm all right,” he said more gently.

Thorin forced himself to release him.

“I know.”

But his voice shook.

Fíli appeared beside them.

“Uncle! We have to go!”

Thorin nodded.

They ran.

Ahead, Gandalf led the Company between towering rocks toward a narrow passage concealed by hanging branches.

More wargs appeared upon the ridge.

Dwalin and Glóin turned to defend the rear.

Thorin joined them, his sword flashing as the creatures closed in.

Then a horn sounded.

Not an orc horn.

An elven horn.

Mounted warriors swept across the hillside, their armor gleaming beneath the afternoon sun.

At their head rode Elrond of Rivendell.

The elves charged the hunters, driving them away from the narrow passage.

Thorin stood motionless for a heartbeat.

In his first life, he had resented their arrival.

Now he felt nothing but relief.

His Company was alive.

Bilbo was alive.

And help had come.

“Thorin!” Gandalf called.

The dwarf turned.

“Into the passage!”

He obeyed without argument.

Dwalin stared at him as though he had lost his mind.

But there was no time to question it.

__________

 

The Company hurried through the hidden entrance, following Gandalf into the sheltered valley beyond.

Rivendell was more beautiful than Bilbo had imagined.

Waterfalls tumbled down distant cliffs, their silver streams catching the sunlight. Elegant bridges crossed clear rivers, and pale buildings rose among trees whose leaves whispered in the gentle breeze.

The air smelled of flowers and fresh water.

Bilbo stopped walking.

“Oh,” he breathed.

Thorin, beside him, watched his expression.

He remembered how much Bilbo had loved this place.

He remembered the hobbit lingering over books, admiring the gardens, and speaking with quiet wonder about the beauty of elven craftsmanship.

In his first life, Thorin had been too consumed by resentment to appreciate any of it.

Now he found himself looking at Rivendell through Bilbo's eyes.

“It is beautiful,” the hobbit whispered.

“Yes,” Thorin answered.

Bilbo glanced at him in surprise.

“You think so?”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“I am capable of appreciating beauty, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo flushed.

“I didn't mean—”

“I know.”

They walked a little farther.

Then Thorin spoke again.

“There are beautiful places in Erebor as well.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Are there?”

“Great halls carved from living stone. Underground rivers. Gardens built beneath openings where sunlight reaches deep into the mountain.”

Bilbo's eyes brightened.

“Gardens?”

Thorin nodded.

“My people once grew flowers and herbs in sheltered courtyards. There were trees too, brought from distant lands.”

Bilbo smiled.

“I should like to see that.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Then I shall show you.”

The promise came so naturally that Bilbo scarcely noticed its significance.

But Thorin felt the weight of it.

He had once promised Bilbo a future and died before he could give it to him.

This time, he intended to keep his word.

__________

 

Elrond welcomed them in the courtyard.

His expression was courteous, though his eyes lingered upon Thorin with unmistakable curiosity.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

“Lord Elrond.”

The dwarf inclined his head.

It was a small gesture.

But for those who knew Thorin, it was astonishing.

Dwalin looked as though he might choke.

Gandalf smiled.

Elrond's eyebrows rose slightly.

“You are welcome in Rivendell.”

“We are grateful for your assistance,” Thorin replied.

The silence that followed was remarkable.

Kíli slowly turned toward Fíli.

“Did he just thank an elf?”

Fíli closed his eyes.

“Yes.”

“Voluntarily?”

“Yes.”

Kíli looked deeply troubled.

“I think we need Óin.”

Elrond, meanwhile, had noticed something else.

Thorin's dark hair was neatly braided, the arrangement simple but carefully maintained.

There was nothing unusual about a dwarf wearing braids.

What interested Elrond was the way Bilbo reached up without hesitation to straighten a loose strand near Thorin's shoulder.

And the way Thorin immediately lowered his head to make the task easier.

Elrond's gaze moved between them.

Understanding flickered across his face.

Gandalf noticed.

The wizard's mouth twitched.

Thorin noticed that too.

For the first time since leaving the Shire, he felt genuinely embarrassed.

Bilbo, entirely unaware, finished adjusting the braid.

“There,” he murmured. “Much better.”

Thorin cleared his throat.

“Thank you.”

Elrond's expression remained perfectly composed.

“Shall we go inside?”

Thorin nodded.

“Of course.”

Behind them, Kíli leaned toward Balin.

“Do elves know what braids mean?”

Balin smiled.

“Some of them.”

Kíli looked toward Elrond.

“Oh.”

Fíli sighed.

“Oh, indeed.”

__________

That evening, the Company was shown to comfortable rooms overlooking the gardens.

Bilbo had scarcely finished admiring the carved furniture and soft bedding when he discovered that Thorin's room was only a short distance down the corridor.

For reasons he did not care to examine, he found this rather pleasing.

He told himself it was simply because Thorin was familiar.

The dwarf had become a comforting presence during their weeks on the road, someone Bilbo could rely upon when the world became too large, too dangerous, or too strange.

There was nothing unusual about wanting a familiar face nearby.

Nothing at all.

Outside, the evening bells of Rivendell rang softly through the valley.

Thorin stood upon the balcony of his room, looking toward the distant mountains.

He had survived the trolls.

He had brought his Company safely through the warg chase.

He had accepted Elrond's help without allowing old bitterness to guide him.

And Bilbo was sleeping only a few doors away.

Yet the future remained uncertain.

Azog still hunted them.

Smaug still waited beneath the Lonely Mountain.

And somewhere in the darkness, Sauron was gathering his strength.

Thorin rested his hands upon the stone railing.

He had changed much already.

But he had not changed enough.

Not yet.

Behind him, a quiet knock sounded.

Thorin turned.

“Come in.”

The door opened.

Bilbo stood there, holding a small wooden comb.

Thorin stared.

The hobbit smiled sheepishly.

“I noticed your braid was coming loose again.”

For a moment, Thorin could only look at him.

Then he smiled.

“Would you care to fix it?”

Bilbo's expression brightened.

“Of course.”

Thorin stepped aside to let him enter.

And as the door closed behind them, the King under the Mountain found himself thinking that perhaps the future was not something he needed to conquer.

Perhaps it was something he needed to build.

One quiet moment at a time.

Chapter 4: Chapter Four — Whispers Beneath the Stars

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins had decided, after nearly four weeks of travelling with thirteen dwarves and a wizard, that Rivendell was quite possibly the most wonderful place in Middle-earth.

It was not simply the beauty of the valley, although he had never seen anything quite like it. Waterfalls descended from impossible heights, turning silver beneath the morning sun, while delicate bridges crossed streams so clear that every stone upon their beds could be counted. The buildings seemed to grow naturally from the surrounding cliffs, their pale columns and graceful arches intertwined with trees whose leaves whispered whenever the wind passed through them.

Nor was it merely the food, though Bilbo had nearly wept upon discovering that the elves served breakfast at a perfectly respectable hour and possessed an understanding of fresh bread that bordered upon miraculous.

No, the greatest wonder of Rivendell was its beds.

Proper beds, with mattresses and clean sheets and pillows that did not consist of a rolled-up cloak stuffed beneath one's head.

Bilbo had slept for almost ten uninterrupted hours on his first night, waking only when sunlight slipped through his curtains and warmed his face. For several glorious minutes, he lay perfectly still, listening to birdsong and contemplating whether it might be possible to persuade Gandalf to abandon the Quest entirely.

Then someone knocked upon his door.

“Bilbo! Are you awake?”

He recognized Kíli's voice immediately.

“Unfortunately,” Bilbo called.

“Excellent! Come along!”

“Where?”

“Breakfast!”

Bilbo considered the matter.

“Give me a moment.”

“Fíli says you've already missed the first sitting.”

Bilbo threw back his blankets.

“Why didn't you begin with that?”

Kíli's laughter followed him as he hurried to dress.

By the time Bilbo emerged into the corridor, the young dwarf was leaning against the opposite wall, looking entirely too pleased with himself. His dark hair was still damp from washing, and he had apparently made some attempt to arrange it neatly, although one stubborn lock refused to remain where he wanted it.

Bilbo reached up automatically and smoothed it down.

“There.”

Kíli blinked.

“What?”

“Your hair.”

The dwarf stared at him for a moment before bursting into laughter.

“What is it with you and our hair?”

Bilbo frowned.

“Someone has to keep you all presentable.”

“Careful. You'll have the entire Company lining up outside your door.”

“I shall charge them.”

“How much?”

“One silver piece per head.”

Kíli considered this gravely.

“Uncle could afford it.”

“Your uncle,” Bilbo replied, beginning down the corridor, “is considerably better behaved than the rest of you.”

Kíli made a strangled noise.

Then he laughed so loudly that an elf passing through the hall turned to look at them.

“Oh, Bilbo,” he managed. “You have absolutely no idea.”

Bilbo glanced back, bewildered.

“No idea about what?”

“Nothing!”

“Kíli.”

“Come on. Bombur will eat everything.”

That was sufficiently alarming to end the conversation.

__________

 

The Company had settled into Rivendell with varying degrees of enthusiasm.

Balin appeared to have made peace with their hosts almost immediately. He spent his mornings walking through the gardens, his afternoons resting beneath the shade of the trees, and his evenings discussing history with anyone willing to listen. Ori had discovered a particular fondness for elven architecture and filled several pages of his journal with sketches of bridges and towers.

Bofur appreciated the music, although he maintained that the songs would benefit considerably from a faster rhythm.

Bombur remained deeply suspicious of the portions.

“I don't understand it,” he complained over breakfast, examining the elegant arrangement upon his plate. “There's barely enough here to feed a child.”

“You've had four servings,” Glóin reminded him.

“And I'm still hungry.”

“That is hardly the elves' fault.”

Dwalin, meanwhile, seemed personally offended by nearly everything.

The chairs were too delicate, the cups too small, and the corridors contained entirely too many elves.

Thorin endured these complaints with a patience that had become increasingly disturbing to his companions.

He sat at the head of their table, listening as Bofur and Nori argued about the proper preparation of mushrooms, and occasionally contributed a dry remark that left Bilbo laughing into his tea.

That, more than anything, continued to trouble Dwalin.

He had known Thorin Oakenshield for most of his life. He remembered the proud young prince who had once filled Erebor's training yards with laughter, but the years of exile had changed him. Responsibility, grief, and disappointment had hardened him into a king who rarely permitted himself moments of uncomplicated happiness.

Yet here he was, smiling because a hobbit had made some ridiculous observation about breakfast.

Dwalin looked toward Balin.

His brother was watching Thorin with an expression of quiet satisfaction.

“Don't,” Dwalin muttered.

Balin raised an eyebrow.

“Don't what?”

“Look so pleased.”

“I am pleased.”

“That is precisely the problem.”

Balin chuckled.

“Perhaps you ought to try it sometime.”

Dwalin grunted and returned to his food.

Across the table, Kíli was explaining to Bilbo why dwarven celebrations frequently lasted several days.

Bilbo listened with growing admiration.

“Several days?”

“Sometimes longer.”

“And there's food throughout?”

“Of course.”

Bilbo sat back.

“I may have misjudged your people.”

Thorin laughed.

It was a warm, genuine sound.

Dwalin stared at him again.

Balin merely smiled.

___________

 

Bilbo discovered Rivendell's library on their second afternoon.

He had intended to spend only a little while exploring, but the moment he stepped inside, all thoughts of returning to the Company vanished.

Shelves rose toward the high ceiling, filled with volumes bound in leather, cloth, and materials he could not identify. Sunlight filtered through tall windows, illuminating reading tables scattered with maps and manuscripts. The air smelled pleasantly of parchment, polished wood, and old books.

Bilbo wandered between the shelves in something approaching reverence.

He was examining an illustrated history of the northern kingdoms when a courteous voice interrupted him.

“May I help you find something?”

Bilbo turned to discover an elf standing nearby.

“Oh! I'm terribly sorry. I wasn't disturbing anything, was I?”

“Not at all,” the elf assured him. “I am Lindir.”

“Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

Lindir inclined his head.

“Is there something in particular you are looking for?”

Bilbo hesitated.

His gaze returned to the illustration before him.

“Actually, I was wondering whether you had anything about Erebor.”

“The Lonely Mountain?”

“Yes.”

Lindir considered this before leading him toward another section of the library.

“We have several accounts of the kingdom beneath the Mountain. Some were written before its fall.”

He selected a substantial volume bound in dark green leather.

“This one contains descriptions of its architecture and daily life.”

Bilbo accepted it eagerly.

“Thank you very much.”

“You are welcome, Master Baggins.”

The elf departed without further ceremony, leaving Bilbo to settle beside a window overlooking the gardens.

__________

 

For the next hour, he read.

There were descriptions of vast halls illuminated by thousands of lamps, of markets filled with merchants from distant lands, and of workshops where craftsmen shaped precious metals into extraordinary works of art.

But what interested Bilbo most were the smaller details.

There had been schools beneath the mountain. Kitchens large enough to feed hundreds, courtyards where children played, and gardens built wherever sunlight could reach through openings in the stone.

He found an illustration of a sheltered garden surrounded by pale columns, its pathways winding between flowering trees.

Bilbo studied it for a long time.

He had heard Thorin speak of Erebor before. Usually, the dwarf spoke of his people's suffering, their lost kingdom, and the duty that compelled him to reclaim it.

But this book described something different.

A place where people had laughed, worked, argued, raised families, and lived ordinary lives.

A home.

Bilbo wondered what Thorin had been like before Smaug.

Before exile.

Before the burden of becoming king had settled upon his shoulders.

It was a question he found himself increasingly eager to ask.

Thorin discovered Bilbo in the gardens shortly before sunset.

The hobbit was sitting beneath a flowering tree, the book resting open upon his knees. Beyond him, a waterfall descended into a clear pool, sending a fine mist drifting through the warm evening air.

Thorin approached quietly.

“Studying?”

Bilbo looked up and smiled.

“Oh! Yes. Lindir helped me find a book about Erebor.”

Thorin glanced at the illustration.

He recognized the courtyard immediately.

For a moment, he could almost hear his mother's laughter.

“May I?”

Bilbo shifted to make room.

“Of course.”

Thorin sat beside him, his shoulder nearly touching the hobbit's.

Bilbo turned the book toward him.

“Was it really like this?”

Thorin studied the drawing.

“Yes. Though the artist has made the columns rather taller than I remember.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Artists do have a habit of improving things.”

“An unfortunate tendency.”

They sat quietly for a moment.

Then Bilbo asked, “What was it like growing up there?”

Thorin looked at him.

The question was so simple that he scarcely knew how to answer.

Most people asked about Erebor's treasure, its defenses, its great halls, or the wealth of its kings.

Very few asked about his childhood.

“It was a good place to grow up,” he said eventually.

Bilbo waited.

Thorin glanced toward the waterfall.

“My mother had a garden much like this one. It stood near her chambers, beneath an opening in the mountain where the sunlight reached the stone for several hours each day.”

“Did she grow flowers?”

“Many. Some rather unsuccessfully.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Not everyone has a talent for gardening.”

“She certainly believed she did.”

Thorin's mouth curved.

“She would argue with the gardeners whenever they suggested a particular plant could not survive beneath the mountain.”

“And who won?”

“My mother, usually.”

“Ah. So stubbornness runs in the family.”

Thorin turned toward him.

Bilbo looked perfectly innocent.

“I have no idea what you mean.”

“Of course not.”

Thorin chuckled, then returned his attention to the distant water.

“My brother Frerin and I used to hide in that garden when we wished to avoid our lessons. Dís would find us eventually, though whether she intended to bring us back or join us depended entirely upon her mood.”

Bilbo's eyes brightened.

“You have a sister?”

“Yes. Dís.”

“What's she like?”

“Terrifying.”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin smiled.

“She is clever, stubborn, and entirely too fond of giving orders. Even as a child, she behaved as though the rest of us existed solely to carry out her wishes.”

“And did you?”

“More often than I care to admit.”

Bilbo grinned.

“I should like to meet her.”

Thorin imagined Dís meeting Bilbo.

His sister would take one look at the hobbit, recognize exactly what he meant to Thorin, and proceed to make his life thoroughly unbearable.

The thought was strangely comforting.

“I believe you would get along rather well.”

“Do you?”

“Unfortunately for me.”

Bilbo laughed again.

Encouraged, Thorin began telling him about the trouble he and his siblings had caused.

There was the occasion when Dís persuaded her brothers to steal honey cakes from the kitchens, only for all three to be discovered beneath a table with crumbs covering their clothes. Another time, Frerin had attempted to teach a young mountain goat to follow commands, resulting in the animal escaping into a formal gathering of visiting merchants.

Bilbo laughed until his eyes watered.

“A goat?”

“A particularly ill-tempered one.”

“And what did your grandfather say?”

“He was not amused.”

“I can't imagine why.”

Thorin shook his head, smiling at the memory.

For a little while, he was no longer the king who had died upon Ravenhill.

He was simply a dwarf remembering his childhood.

Bilbo watched him with quiet fascination.

Thorin looked younger when he smiled like that. The stern lines around his mouth softened, and his blue eyes became bright with an amusement that Bilbo had only recently begun to recognize.

“I think,” Bilbo said thoughtfully, “I should have liked to meet you when you were little.”

Thorin turned toward him.

Something warm and painful stirred beneath his ribs.

“I suspect we would have caused each other a great deal of trouble.”

“Certainly not. I was a perfectly respectable child.”

“Were you?”

“Mostly.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo nudged his arm.

“Oh, don't look at me like that.”

They laughed together.

Eventually, Bilbo asked about Frerin.

The smile upon Thorin's face faded.

“He died many years ago.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Oh, Thorin. I'm sorry.”

Thorin looked down at his hands.

“He was very young. Brave, foolish, and always eager to prove himself.”

“He sounds rather like Kíli.”

Thorin swallowed.

“Yes,” he said quietly. “He does.”

Bilbo closed the book.

For a moment, he considered offering some comforting words, but nothing seemed quite sufficient.

Instead, he remained beside Thorin, close enough that their shoulders touched.

Thorin did not move away.

After a while, Bilbo spoke.

“I think I understand a little better now.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Understand what?”

“Why you want to go home.”

The dwarf's breath caught.

Bilbo glanced toward the book.

“It's not really about the gold, is it? Or even the mountain itself. It's about everything that happened there. Everyone who lived there.”

Thorin stared at him.

In another lifetime, Bilbo had understood him better than anyone.

And here he was, doing so again.

“No,” Thorin answered softly. “It was never only about the gold.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Then I hope we find your garden.”

Thorin looked toward the fading sunlight.

“So do I.”

And for the first time in many years, he imagined returning to Erebor not as a king claiming a throne, but as a man coming home.

__________

 

Fíli found his uncle upon a balcony later that evening.

Thorin stood with his hands resting upon the stone railing, watching the first stars appear above the valley.

“Uncle?”

Thorin turned.

“Fíli.”

“May I speak with you?”

“Of course.”

The young prince approached, but instead of immediately beginning, he stood beside Thorin and looked toward the mountains.

Thorin waited.

He knew that expression.

Fíli had worn it since childhood whenever he wished to ask something difficult.

Finally, his nephew sighed.

“Are you well?”

Thorin frowned.

“Of course.”

“Truly?”

“Why would you ask?”

Fíli turned toward him.

“Because you've been different since we left the Shire.”

Thorin's expression became guarded.

“Different?”

“You hardly sleep. You insist upon checking every watch yourself, even when Dwalin has already arranged them. You worry about things before there's any reason to worry.”

Thorin looked away.

“And sometimes,” Fíli continued more quietly, “you look at Kíli and me as though you're afraid we'll disappear.”

The words struck painfully close to the truth.

Thorin gripped the railing.

Fíli watched him.

“I know the Quest is dangerous. I know you're worried about us. But this feels like something else.”

Thorin remained silent.

His nephew took a breath.

“Has something happened that you haven't told us?”

Yes.

Everything.

Thorin remembered Fíli's body suspended above the courtyard at Ravenhill. He remembered the terrible stillness of his nephew's face, the blood upon his clothing, and the knowledge that he had been too late.

He remembered Kíli dying only a short time afterward.

And he remembered how little his crown had mattered then.

“Uncle?”

Thorin turned.

Fíli's expression was earnest and worried.

So painfully alive.

Thorin reached out and rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“There are things I fear,” he admitted.

Fíli waited.

“Things I cannot easily explain.”

“Then let us help you.”

Thorin's throat tightened.

“You already do.”

Fíli looked confused.

“Simply by being here,” Thorin added.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then Thorin drew his nephew into an embrace.

Fíli stiffened in surprise before returning it.

Thorin held him tightly, feeling the solid warmth of his shoulders beneath his hands.

He had been given another chance.

He would not waste it.

When they finally separated, Thorin kept one hand upon Fíli's shoulder.

“There is something I wish you to understand.”

Fíli straightened instinctively.

Thorin almost smiled.

Even now, his nephew responded to that particular tone as though expecting an official royal decree.

“Whatever happens in the years to come,” Thorin began, “whether I marry or remain alone, whether I have children of my own or not, you will always be my heir.”

Fíli blinked.

“Uncle?”

“You are the Crown Prince of Erebor. And when my time comes, you shall be its king.”

Fíli stared at him.

“I never doubted—”

“I know.”

Thorin's voice softened.

“But I would have you hear it from me. Not because you are my sister's son, nor merely because you are the eldest of her children. You will inherit the throne because I trust you.”

Fíli swallowed.

“I trust your judgment,” Thorin continued. “Your courage. Your heart. I have watched you grow into a dwarf worthy of leading our people, and nothing will change that.”

He tightened his hand upon Fíli's shoulder.

“Not even a son or daughter of my own.”

Although, Thorin reflected with a sudden and entirely inappropriate flicker of amusement, considering that, should I ever marry, I fully intend to marry a certain stubborn, curly-haired hobbit, the likelihood of producing children of my own is rather slim.

He maintained a perfectly solemn expression.

Fíli, fortunately, remained unaware that his uncle had just contemplated marrying their burglar in the middle of a discussion about royal succession.

Thorin cleared his throat.

“You have my complete confidence.”

Fíli looked down.

For a moment, Thorin thought his nephew might argue.

Instead, the young dwarf drew a shaky breath.

“Thank you.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“You need not thank me for speaking the truth.”

Fíli looked up.

There was moisture in his eyes.

“I only hope I can become the king you believe I'll be.”

Thorin felt something twist painfully inside him.

“You already possess everything that matters.”

Fíli shook his head.

“I still have much to learn.”

“As do I.”

That earned a faint smile.

Thorin stepped closer.

“I am proud of you, Fíli. More than I have ever properly told you.”

His nephew embraced him again.

This time, neither hurried to pull away.

When Fíli eventually stepped back, he studied his uncle with renewed concern.

“Are you expecting something to happen to you?”

Thorin went still.

“No,” he answered carefully. “But a king must consider the future of his people.”

Fíli nodded, though he did not appear entirely satisfied.

Then he managed a small smile.

“Whatever happens, Uncle, Kíli and I will look after you too.”

Thorin's chest tightened.

“I shall remember that.”

After Fíli departed, Thorin remained upon the balcony for a long time.

He had promised his nephew a crown.

Now he had to make certain Fíli lived long enough to wear it.

__________

 

The following evening, Elrond examined the map of Erebor.

The Company gathered in a chamber overlooking the valley, where pale moonlight spilled through the open windows.

Bilbo stood beside Gandalf, watching with considerable interest as the elf lord studied the parchment.

Thorin remained near the table.

He knew what Elrond would find.

He remembered the moon-runes, the hidden door, and the instructions that would guide them toward the secret entrance.

Nevertheless, when Elrond raised the map toward the moonlight and the concealed writing appeared, Thorin allowed himself a measured expression of interest.

“Moon-runes,” Elrond announced.

Bilbo leaned forward.

“Moon-runes?”

“Runes that can only be read by the light of a moon of the same shape and season as the day upon which they were written.”

Kíli looked impressed.

“Clever.”

Elrond examined the writing.

Then he read aloud the instructions concerning the grey stone, the thrush, and the last light of Durin's Day.

Bilbo listened carefully.

Thorin watched the map.

He remembered standing before that hidden door in his first life, desperate and furious when the sun disappeared before they had found the keyhole.

He remembered Bilbo noticing the moonlight.

He remembered how close they had come to failure.

This time, he would be prepared.

When Elrond finished, Gandalf turned toward him.

“You do not seem particularly surprised.”

Thorin met the wizard's gaze.

“My grandfather was fond of secrets.”

“Indeed.”

“I have long suspected there was more to the map than we could see.”

Gandalf studied him.

“A fortunate suspicion.”

“Perhaps.”

Thorin looked back toward the parchment.

He could feel the wizard's eyes upon him.

Gandalf had been watching him more closely since Radagast's arrival.

Thorin knew he would eventually have to explain something.

But not yet.

Not while he was still trying to understand what could be changed and what remained beyond his control.

__________

 

Gandalf found Elrond upon a terrace later that night.

The elf lord stood beneath the stars, his hands folded behind his back.

“You seem troubled,” Elrond observed.

Gandalf sighed.

“I find myself increasingly uncertain about Thorin Oakenshield.”

Elrond turned.

“He is not quite the dwarf I expected.”

“No,” Gandalf agreed. “Nor is he quite the dwarf I remember.”

Elrond considered that.

“He has been remarkably courteous.”

“Which would ordinarily be cause for celebration.”

“And yet?”

Gandalf drew upon his pipe.

“He knows things, Elrond. Things he ought not know.”

“Such as?”

“The dangers along our road. The darkness gathering at Dol Guldur. Matters concerning his own companions.”

Elrond frowned.

“Has he spoken of visions?”

“I asked him something similar. He neither confirmed nor denied it.”

Gandalf looked toward the distant mountains.

“He behaves like a man who has already suffered consequences that have yet to occur.”

Elrond was quiet for several moments.

Then, almost casually, he asked, “Tell me, Gandalf, how long has Thorin Oakenshield been courting your burglar?”

Gandalf inhaled sharply.

The resulting cough was so violent that he nearly dropped his pipe.

Elrond waited with admirable patience.

When Gandalf finally recovered, he stared.

“Courting?”

“Unless I have misunderstood certain dwarven customs.”

Gandalf blinked.

Elrond's expression remained composed.

“I am not an expert in every tradition of Durin's folk, but I know enough to recognize the significance of allowing another to tend one's hair so intimately.”

Gandalf slowly lowered his pipe.

“The braids.”

“Precisely.”

For several moments, the wizard looked utterly bewildered.

Then he began to laugh.

“Oh, Thorin.”

Elrond raised an eyebrow.

“You were unaware?”

“I knew he was fond of Bilbo. Unusually fond, in fact. But I had not considered—”

Gandalf stopped.

His amusement faded.

Elrond noticed.

“What is it?”

“Thorin behaved as though he already knew the hobbit on the night they met.”

Elrond listened.

“He was gentle with him from the beginning,” Gandalf continued. “Patient. Protective. Almost desperately relieved whenever Bilbo remained near him.”

“And the hobbit?”

“Has no notion of what is happening, I suspect.”

Elrond glanced toward the gardens.

“Then perhaps Thorin's affection is not as simple as it appears.”

“No,” Gandalf murmured.

He remembered Thorin's expression when his nephews laughed.

The strange grief in his eyes.

The way he sometimes watched Bilbo as though afraid the hobbit might vanish.

“I fear, my friend, that Thorin Oakenshield knows considerably more about this journey than he ought.”

Elrond studied him.

“Do you believe he has seen the future?”

Gandalf was silent.

“I do not know.”

Below them, the waterfalls continued their endless song.

At last, Elrond spoke.

“Whatever the truth, I would advise caution. Knowledge can become a terrible burden when one believes oneself responsible for changing what is to come.”

Gandalf nodded.

“I know.”

He looked toward the rooms where the Company slept.

“And I fear Thorin knows it too.”

___________

 

The White Council gathered the following morning.

Gandalf, Elrond, Galadriel, and Saruman spoke at length concerning the growing darkness in the east, the Morgul blade recovered by Radagast, and the strange power gathering within Dol Guldur.

Saruman dismissed many of Gandalf's concerns.

Elrond remained troubled.

Galadriel listened in silence, her expression thoughtful.

And Gandalf, remembering Thorin's whispered mention of Sauron, found himself increasingly uneasy.

Meanwhile, the Company prepared to depart.

The weather had begun to change.

Cold winds descended from the mountains, carrying the promise of rain.

Thorin inspected their supplies, checked their weapons, and questioned Dwalin about the condition of the ponies.

He also insisted that everyone carry additional blankets.

“It's summer,” Kíli protested.

“In the valleys,” Thorin replied. “The mountains are another matter.”

Fíli exchanged a glance with Dwalin.

Neither argued.

Bilbo, meanwhile, was attempting to fit several books into his travelling pack.

Balin watched him struggle.

“Master Baggins, are you planning to carry the entire library?”

“Certainly not.”

Bilbo pushed another volume beneath his spare shirt.

“Only a few particularly interesting ones.”

Balin chuckled.

“You may find the mountains less accommodating than Rivendell.”

“I know.”

Bilbo sighed and reluctantly removed two books.

Then he noticed Thorin approaching.

“Are we leaving tomorrow?”

“At first light.”

Bilbo looked toward the distant mountains.

They rose beyond the valley like enormous walls of grey stone, their highest peaks hidden beneath clouds.

For the first time since arriving in Rivendell, he felt a flicker of unease.

Thorin noticed.

“You need not be ashamed of being afraid.”

Bilbo looked up.

“I wasn't.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Well,” Bilbo admitted, “perhaps a little.”

“There is no shame in that.”

Bilbo studied him.

“Are you afraid?”

Thorin looked toward the mountains.

He remembered thunder.

Stone giants.

Goblin-town.

The darkness beneath the earth.

“Yes,” he answered.

Bilbo blinked.

He had not expected such honesty.

Thorin turned back toward him.

“But fear need not prevent us from continuing.”

Bilbo considered that.

Then he smiled.

“I suppose you're right.”

Thorin returned the smile.

“Occasionally.”

“Only occasionally?”

“I would not wish to become predictable.”

Bilbo laughed.

On their final evening in Rivendell, Bilbo found Thorin standing alone upon a balcony.

The mountains were dark against the starlit sky.

The dwarf had been studying them for some time, his thoughts far away.

Bilbo approached quietly.

“Mind if I join you?”

Thorin turned.

“Never.”

Bilbo stepped beside him.

For a while, they stood in comfortable silence.

Then Bilbo began telling him about a particularly stubborn gardener in Hobbiton who had once attempted to grow roses in the middle of winter.

Thorin listened.

The story was entirely ordinary.

There were no dragons, no ancient kingdoms, no terrible prophecies.

Only a hobbit, a gardener, and an unfortunate collection of frozen rosebushes.

And somehow, that was exactly what Thorin needed.

When Bilbo finished, Thorin was smiling.

“You have a remarkable talent for finding trouble in the most peaceful places.”

Bilbo looked offended.

“I do not find trouble.”

“No?”

“Trouble finds me.”

Thorin laughed softly.

“Yes,” he murmured. “I believe it does.”

Bilbo leaned against the railing.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Do you ever think about what you'll do when we reach Erebor?”

Thorin looked toward the stars.

“All the time.”

“Will you be happy there?”

The question caught him unexpectedly.

In his first life, he had believed reclaiming Erebor would make him happy.

He had been wrong.

He had gained his kingdom and nearly lost his soul.

Now he understood that happiness was not something waiting beneath the mountain.

It was something he had to choose.

“I hope so,” he answered.

Bilbo nodded thoughtfully.

“I hope so too.”

Thorin looked at him.

“And you, Bilbo? What will you do when our journey is finished?”

The hobbit smiled.

“Go home, I suppose. Tend my garden. Read my books. Have proper meals again.”

Thorin felt a familiar ache.

Of course.

Bilbo had a home.

A life.

A future that did not necessarily include him.

He had no right to expect otherwise.

“That sounds peaceful,” Thorin said.

“It does.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Although I think I shall miss everyone.”

Thorin turned.

“Everyone?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo looked embarrassed.

“Even Dwalin, probably.”

Thorin laughed.

“A generous sentiment.”

“And Kíli. And Balin. And Fíli.”

He paused.

Then, more quietly, he added, “And you.”

Thorin's smile faded into something softer.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked up.

For a moment, Thorin wanted to tell him everything.

That he had loved him before.

That he had died with Bilbo's name upon his lips.

That every ordinary moment they shared felt like a miracle.

Instead, he simply said, “I shall miss you too.”

Bilbo smiled.

And Thorin thought that perhaps, for now, it was enough.

__________

 

They departed Rivendell at dawn.

The valley lay beneath a veil of silver mist, its waterfalls glimmering in the pale morning light.

Elrond offered them provisions and wished them safe passage.

Gandalf exchanged a final, meaningful glance with the elf lord before joining the Company.

Thorin thanked their host.

Dwalin still looked uncomfortable about it.

But he said nothing.

The dwarves mounted their ponies, adjusted their packs, and began the long climb toward the mountains.

Bilbo lingered for a moment, looking back at Rivendell.

He had grown fond of the place.

Its gardens, its books, its peaceful halls.

Yet when he turned toward the road, he found himself looking for Thorin.

The dwarf was waiting a short distance ahead.

Bilbo urged his pony forward.

“Mind if I ride beside you?”

Thorin smiled.

“Not at all.”

Bilbo settled comfortably at his side.

Ahead of them, Kíli glanced back.

For a moment, he seemed ready to call something teasing over his shoulder.

Then he noticed the quiet happiness upon his uncle's face.

He smiled to himself instead and rode forward to join Fíli.

Behind them, Rivendell disappeared among the trees.

Before them rose the Misty Mountains.

Thorin looked toward their dark peaks, remembering the terrible things waiting beyond them.

He knew that the peace of Rivendell could not last.

But Bilbo was riding beside him, humming softly beneath his breath, and the morning sun was beginning to break through the clouds.

For now, Thorin allowed himself to enjoy it.

Whatever waited in the mountains, they would face it together.

Chapter 5: Chapter Five — Beneath the Mountains

Chapter Text

The Misty Mountains were considerably less beautiful when one was expected to climb them.

Bilbo Baggins reached this conclusion on the fourth morning after leaving Rivendell, when he awoke to discover that the pleasant chill of the previous evening had transformed into a cold so thoroughly unpleasant that even the tips of his ears seemed to ache. His blankets were damp with dew, his boots had acquired a distressing amount of mud, and the small stone that had somehow found its way beneath his sleeping mat had left him with an ache between his shoulders.

He missed his bed.

He missed his fireplace.

Most particularly, he missed waking to the comforting knowledge that the greatest difficulty awaiting him was deciding whether to have mushrooms or eggs for breakfast.

The mountains rose around them in endless ridges of grey stone, their upper reaches concealed behind thick clouds. Narrow paths wound along steep slopes, sometimes disappearing beneath loose rocks or crossing streams fed by melting snow. The air grew thinner with every passing day, and the wind possessed a remarkable talent for finding its way beneath even the most carefully fastened clothing.

Bilbo had never been particularly fond of heights. He was discovering that he liked them even less when accompanied by the possibility of falling several hundred feet.

“Careful there, Master Baggins.”

Bofur's cheerful voice came from behind him as Bilbo negotiated a particularly unpleasant stretch of loose stones.

“I am being careful,” Bilbo replied, gripping his walking stick.

“Of course you are. Just thought I'd mention it.”

“Very thoughtful.”

“Wouldn't want you rolling all the way back to Rivendell.”

Bilbo stopped and looked over his shoulder. “Do you suppose they'd let me keep my room?”

Bofur laughed. “Aye, probably. Though I imagine they'd charge you for the damage.”

“What damage?”

“The hole you'd make coming through the roof.”

Despite himself, Bilbo smiled.

Ahead of them, Kíli was attempting to persuade Fíli that the clouds gathering above the eastern peaks were perfectly harmless.

“They're only clouds.”

“They're storm clouds,” Fíli corrected.

“Clouds nonetheless.”

“Very observant.”

“I've always thought so.”

Fíli sighed and returned his attention to the path.

Thorin travelled near the front with Dwalin, studying the mountain slopes with an intensity that had become familiar to the Company.

He remembered these mountains.

Not every turn of the path, nor every sheltered hollow where they had made camp, but enough.

He remembered the storm, the giants, and the cave that had promised safety before delivering them into the hands of goblins. He remembered the Great Goblin's laughter, Azog's name spoken in those foul underground halls, and the desperate flight across bridges that seemed determined to collapse beneath their feet.

And he remembered Bilbo disappearing.

That last memory troubled him more than he cared to admit.

In his first life, he had not known where the hobbit had gone. He had been angry, exhausted, and far too quick to assume the worst. Only afterward had Bilbo returned, emerging from the trees with that familiar expression of bewildered determination.

Thorin had spent many nights since his awakening thinking about that moment.

He would not make the same mistake again.

But he was beginning to understand that remembering an event and knowing how to prevent it were two very different things.

“Thorin.”

Dwalin's voice drew him from his thoughts.

“What?”

“The western path looks clearer.”

Thorin examined the narrow trail cutting across the slope. In his memory, they had travelled farther east before the storm overtook them. He had hoped to avoid that route entirely.

“Fíli,” he called.

His nephew immediately approached. “Yes, Uncle?”

“Come here. Tell me what you make of these paths.”

Fíli looked surprised, but joined him. Together, they studied the mountainside.

“The western trail is shorter,” Fíli said after a moment, “but it looks exposed. If the weather turns, we'll have nowhere to shelter.”

“And the eastern?”

“Longer. There are more places where we might find cover, but the rock looks unstable.”

Thorin nodded. “Which would you choose?”

Fíli considered carefully.

“The eastern route, provided we move before the rain begins.”

Dwalin glanced toward Thorin.

The king studied the clouds for another moment.

“Agreed.”

Fíli blinked. “Agreed?”

“You've judged the risks correctly. Take the lead with Dwalin.”

His nephew straightened.

“Of course.”

As Fíli hurried forward, Kíli leaned toward him.

“Careful, brother. At this rate, Uncle will have you organizing the entire kingdom before we've even reached it.”

Fíli gave him a patient look.

“Someone will have to organize you.”

“An impossible task.”

“I'm aware.”

Their laughter carried faintly through the cold air.

Thorin watched them go.

Dwalin remained beside him.

“You've been giving the lad more responsibility.”

“He is capable of it.”

“Aye. He is.”

Thorin looked toward Fíli, who was already discussing the route with Nori.

“He will make a fine king.”

Dwalin's expression softened.

“That he will.”

Neither spoke for a while.

Then Dwalin added, “You might tell him that more often.”

Thorin glanced at him.

“I have.”

The older warrior looked faintly surprised.

Then he smiled beneath his beard.

“Good.”

___________

 

By the time evening arrived, the Company had found shelter beneath a broad overhang of stone.

It was hardly comfortable, but the rock offered some protection from the wind, and Bombur managed to prepare a respectable supper over a small fire.

Bilbo ate two servings of stew and half a loaf of bread before announcing that he could not possibly eat another bite.

Five minutes later, he accepted a piece of cheese from Balin.

Kíli watched him with amusement.

“I thought you were full.”

“I am.”

“Then why are you eating?”

“Because it would be terribly wasteful not to.”

Balin chuckled.

“A sensible philosophy.”

The temperature dropped sharply after sunset.

Bilbo wrapped himself in his cloak, pulled his blanket around his shoulders, and settled near the fire with the firm intention of remaining there until morning.

Unfortunately, the wind seemed determined to make that impossible.

He had just begun contemplating whether sleeping inside his pack might provide additional warmth when he noticed a second blanket folded beside him.

Bilbo frowned.

He recognized it.

Thorin's.

The dwarf was sitting several feet away, speaking quietly with Balin while wearing only his heavy travelling cloak.

Bilbo looked from the blanket to Thorin.

Then back again.

“Oh, absolutely not.”

Kíli, who was cleaning his bow nearby, looked up.

“What?”

Bilbo snatched the blanket and marched across the small camp.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

Thorin turned.

The use of his full name was sufficiently alarming to attract Dwalin's attention.

“Bilbo?”

“Did you give me your blanket?”

Thorin glanced at the object in his hands.

“You looked cold.”

“I am cold. We are in the mountains.”

“Precisely.”

“And what, may I ask, do you intend to sleep beneath?”

“My cloak.”

Bilbo stared at him.

Thorin maintained a perfectly reasonable expression.

It was infuriating.

“You cannot possibly think that's sensible.”

“I have endured colder nights.”

“That is not an answer.”

Balin suddenly became very interested in his tea.

Thorin looked faintly amused.

“Bilbo, I assure you—”

“No. You may assure me of whatever you like after you've stopped behaving like a complete fool.”

Kíli made a choking noise.

Fíli covered his mouth.

Dwalin looked as though someone had just challenged the foundations of the universe.

Thorin, however, merely raised an eyebrow.

“A fool?”

“A very noble fool, perhaps, but a fool nonetheless.”

Bilbo sat beside him and unfolded the blanket.

“There. We'll share them.”

Thorin went still.

“We?”

“Yes, we. Unless you have some objection to being warm.”

Thorin looked at the hobbit.

Bilbo looked back with an expression that suggested he was prepared to argue for the remainder of the evening.

Thorin knew when he had lost.

“None whatsoever.”

“Good.”

Bilbo arranged the blankets across both their shoulders and settled comfortably beside him.

For several moments, Thorin could only stare into the fire.

In another life, he had died wishing for the chance to hold Bilbo once more.

Now the hobbit was sitting against his side, complaining about the cold and entirely unaware of what he was doing to Thorin's heart.

It seemed almost unfair.

Across the fire, Kíli leaned toward Fíli.

“Do you think—”

“No,” Fíli whispered.

“But—”

“Leave them alone.”

Kíli considered this.

Then he smiled and returned to cleaning his bow.

___________

 

Beside Thorin, Bilbo tucked the blankets more securely around them.

“You really ought to take better care of yourself.”

Thorin glanced down.

“I could say the same of you.”

“I take excellent care of myself.”

“You nearly walked off a ledge this morning.”

“I slipped.”

“Toward a ledge.”

“A small one.”

“A considerable one.”

Bilbo gave him an indignant look.

Thorin smiled.

Eventually, the conversation faded into comfortable silence.

Bilbo watched the flames, listening to the wind sigh through the rocks.

After a while, he asked, “Do you miss your family?”

Thorin looked toward him.

“Very much.”

“Your sister?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“I was thinking about what you told me in Rivendell. About her and your brother.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Dís would like you.”

“You said that before.”

“And I meant it.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Do you think she'll be waiting in Erebor when we arrive?”

“No. She remains with our people in the Blue Mountains.”

“Oh.”

Thorin watched a spark rise from the fire.

“But if we succeed, I intend to send for her.”

Bilbo nodded.

“I hope you do.”

Thorin looked at him.

“And perhaps, one day, you might meet her.”

Bilbo smiled.

“I should like that.”

Thorin returned his gaze to the flames before the hobbit could see how much those simple words meant to him.

Later, when Bilbo's head grew heavy and settled against his shoulder, Thorin remained perfectly still.

He did not sleep for a long time.

But for once, his wakefulness was not entirely unpleasant.

___________

 

The storm arrived two days later.

At first, it seemed little more than another gathering of clouds.

The morning had been cold and grey, with a sharp wind descending from the higher peaks. By midday, the sky had darkened considerably, and the first drops of rain began striking the stones around them.

Thorin looked upward.

A familiar dread settled in his stomach.

“We need shelter.”

Dwalin followed his gaze.

“The next ridge might offer some.”

“Then we move quickly.”

Fíli immediately began organizing the Company.

He sent Nori and Bofur ahead to examine the path while instructing Kíli to remain near Bombur, whose pony had become increasingly nervous.

Thorin watched his nephew with quiet approval.

Then thunder rolled across the mountains.

The sound was enormous.

It seemed to shake the very stone beneath their feet.

Bilbo flinched.

“Good heavens.”

A flash of lightning illuminated the distant peaks.

For one brief instant, Thorin saw something move against the mountainside.

Something far too large to be an ordinary creature.

His blood turned cold.

“Dwalin!”

The warrior turned.

“Get everyone away from the cliff!”

Another tremendous crack echoed through the valley.

A vast shape shifted among the rocks.

Bilbo stared.

At first, his mind refused to understand what he was seeing.

Then an enormous arm rose from the mountainside.

Stone moved against stone.

A face emerged from the cliff, its features formed from jagged rock and ancient earth.

The mountain itself appeared to stand.

“Oh,” Bilbo whispered.

A second giant rose opposite the first.

And then the world erupted.

A colossal boulder flew across the ravine, striking the mountainside with a deafening crash. Rock shattered, sending fragments tumbling toward the narrow path.

“MOVE!” Thorin roared.

The Company scattered.

Dwalin seized Ori by the collar and dragged him beneath an overhang. Fíli shouted instructions while Kíli helped Bombur control the terrified ponies.

Bilbo stumbled backward as a shower of stones struck the ground beside him.

Thorin caught his arm.

“This way!”

They ran.

The path trembled beneath their feet.

Above them, the giants fought with terrible, ancient fury, tearing enormous pieces from the mountains and hurling them at one another.

Lightning flashed across their immense bodies.

The thunder of their blows drowned out every other sound.

Thorin remembered this.

He remembered the ledges breaking apart, the Company separated upon moving stone, and Bilbo hanging over a terrible drop.

He had chosen a different path.

Yet here they were.

“Fíli!” he shouted.

His nephew turned from farther ahead.

“Get everyone beneath that ridge!”

Fíli nodded and began directing the others.

Thorin kept Bilbo close.

They had almost reached the shelter when the ground lurched.

A tremendous impact struck the mountainside above them.

The narrow ledge cracked.

Bilbo lost his footing.

For one horrible instant, his boots slipped across the wet stone and there was nothing beneath him but empty air.

“THORIN!”

Thorin moved before he had time to think.

He threw himself forward, caught Bilbo's wrist, and dropped to one knee as the hobbit's weight pulled against him.

Bilbo struck the cliff face with a gasp.

His walking stick vanished into the darkness below.

Thorin tightened his grip.

“Hold on!”

Bilbo's free hand scrabbled against the rock.

“I am trying!”

Another tremor shook the ledge.

Thorin's boots slid.

For a heartbeat, the world seemed to narrow to Bilbo's frightened face.

He remembered blood upon snow.

A trembling hand against his cheek.

A voice begging him not to leave.

Not again.

“Dwalin!”

The warrior was already moving.

He dropped beside Thorin, seized the back of his coat, and braced himself against the rock.

“Pull!”

Together, they dragged Bilbo onto the ledge.

The hobbit collapsed against Thorin, shaking violently.

Thorin wrapped both arms around him.

For several seconds, he could do nothing else.

Bilbo clutched his coat.

“I'm all right,” he gasped.

Thorin barely heard him.

“I'm all right,” Bilbo repeated, a little more firmly.

Thorin pulled back just enough to look at him.

His face was pale beneath the rain.

There was a scrape upon his cheek, but he was breathing.

Alive.

Thorin pressed a trembling hand against the back of his head.

“Stay close to me.”

Bilbo nodded.

“I will.”

Dwalin glanced between them.

Whatever he saw upon Thorin's face made him say nothing.

Instead, he hauled Bilbo upright.

“We need to move.”

Thorin forced himself to release the hobbit.

Together, they ran.

___________

 

By the time the Company found shelter, they were soaked, exhausted, and thoroughly miserable.

The cave lay within a narrow opening between two cliffs, its entrance partially concealed by fallen stones.

Dwalin inspected it first.

“Looks clear.”

Thorin stood outside, staring into the darkness.

He remembered a cave.

He remembered believing it safe.

And he remembered waking beneath the mountain with goblins surrounding them.

“Wait.”

Fíli turned.

“Uncle?”

Thorin stepped inside.

The cave was broad and dry, its walls smooth in places and rough in others. A shallow depression near the rear offered enough space for the Company to settle.

It was not precisely as he remembered.

Or perhaps his memories had blurred.

He examined the floor.

Nothing seemed unusual.

“Thorin?” Gandalf asked.

The wizard stood near the entrance, watching him.

“Something troubles you.”

Thorin looked toward the dark recesses of the cave.

“We should keep a watch.”

“Of course.”

“A proper watch. No one is to sleep without someone awake.”

Dwalin frowned.

“We always keep watch.”

“Then tonight we shall be particularly careful.”

Gandalf studied him.

“Do you expect trouble?”

Thorin hesitated.

“Yes.”

The wizard's eyes narrowed slightly.

“What kind?”

Thorin looked toward the Company.

Bilbo was sitting beside Balin while Óin examined the scrape upon his cheek. Kíli had begun wringing water from his sleeves, and Bombur was complaining that his boots would never dry.

They were tired.

They needed rest.

And Thorin could not explain why a cave that appeared perfectly ordinary filled him with dread.

“Goblin territory,” he said at last. “We are too near their tunnels.”

Gandalf's expression became grave.

“A reasonable concern.”

He glanced toward the cave floor.

“Very well. We shall be cautious.”

Thorin nodded.

But caution had not saved them before.

The Company settled as comfortably as circumstances allowed.

Bombur managed to prepare a small meal, though he complained bitterly about the absence of proper firewood. Wet cloaks were spread across the rocks, and the dwarves huddled beneath their blankets while the storm continued outside.

Bilbo sat near the wall, allowing Óin to inspect his scraped cheek.

“Nothing serious,” the healer declared.

“I told you.”

“You also told me you weren't cold yesterday.”

“That was entirely different.”

Óin chuckled and handed him a clean cloth.

“Keep it clean.”

Bilbo nodded.

When the healer moved away, he noticed Thorin standing near the entrance.

The dwarf had scarcely sat down since they arrived.

He kept looking toward the darkness beyond the cave, one hand resting upon the hilt of Orcrist.

Bilbo watched him for a while.

Then he rose and approached.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf turned immediately.

“Bilbo. Is your cheek troubling you?”

“No.”

“Your wrist?”

“A little, but Óin says it's only bruised.”

Thorin looked at his hand.

Bilbo noticed the concern.

“I'm quite all right.”

Thorin nodded.

Yet his expression remained tense.

Bilbo hesitated.

“You know, you're allowed to rest.”

“I shall.”

“When?”

“Soon.”

Bilbo folded his arms.

“That sounds suspiciously like something someone says when they have no intention of resting.”

Thorin almost smiled.

“Does it?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo glanced toward the cave.

“Dwalin and Fíli are perfectly capable of keeping watch.”

“I know.”

“Then let them.”

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo's expression softened.

“You can't protect everyone every moment of the day.”

The words struck harder than Bilbo intended.

Thorin looked away.

He had tried.

In another life, he had failed.

And now, even with the future laid before him like a map, he could not prevent every danger.

“I know,” he answered quietly.

Bilbo stepped closer.

“Then perhaps you ought to trust us a little.”

Thorin looked down at him.

There was no accusation in the hobbit's voice.

Only concern.

“I do trust you.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Good. Then come and sit down before you fall over.”

Thorin allowed himself to be guided toward the others.

He sat beside Bilbo, accepted a cup of warm broth from Balin, and made a genuine effort to appear less troubled.

It did not entirely work.

But when Bilbo leaned against his shoulder a little later, Thorin finally closed his eyes.

For a few precious minutes, he rested.

__________

 

Bilbo awoke sometime after midnight.

The fire had burned low.

Most of the Company slept beneath their blankets, their breathing mingling with the distant sound of rain.

Dwalin stood near the entrance, his axe resting against his shoulder.

Bofur was awake as well, sitting beside the dying fire and examining a small wooden carving.

Bilbo sat up carefully.

His wrist ached.

He looked toward Thorin.

The dwarf was sleeping nearby, though even in rest his expression remained troubled.

Bilbo watched him for a moment.

Then he quietly rose.

He had been thinking about leaving.

Not because he disliked the Company.

Quite the opposite.

That was what made the thought so difficult.

He had grown fond of Kíli's laughter, Fíli's steady kindness, Balin's stories, and Bofur's cheerful nonsense. Even Dwalin, who sometimes looked at him as though he were an especially inconvenient piece of luggage, had begun treating him with something approaching respect.

And Thorin—

Bilbo looked back at the sleeping dwarf.

Thorin had been nothing but patient with him.

He had taught him how to use Sting, listened to his stories, and treated him as though his presence mattered.

Yet Bilbo could not forget the feeling of slipping over that ledge.

Or the terror upon Thorin's face when he had pulled him to safety.

He was slowing them down.

Putting them at risk.

Perhaps the kindest thing he could do was leave before someone was hurt trying to protect him.

Bilbo moved quietly toward his pack.

“Going somewhere?”

He froze.

Bofur looked up from his carving.

Bilbo sighed.

“Couldn't sleep.”

“Aye. Happens to the best of us.”

The dwarf watched him for a moment.

Then his gaze drifted toward the pack.

“Thinking of heading home?”

Bilbo looked down.

“I don't know.”

Bofur set aside the carving.

“Nothing wrong with missing home.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

“I do miss it.”

“I imagine you do.”

“My garden must be a dreadful mess by now. And I left several books unfinished.”

Bofur smiled.

“Terrible tragedy.”

Bilbo gave a weak laugh.

Then his expression became serious.

“I don't think I'm much use to you.”

Bofur frowned.

“What makes you say that?”

“Today, Thorin nearly fell trying to save me.”

“He did save you.”

“But he might have died.”

Bofur studied him.

“Bilbo, we've all needed saving at one time or another.”

“Yes, but—”

“No buts. You helped us with those trolls, didn't you? And you've kept up with us through country no respectable hobbit ought to be walking.”

Bilbo looked unconvinced.

Bofur's expression softened.

“Look, lad. If you want to go home, no one has the right to stop you. You've a good life waiting there, and there's no shame in wanting it back.”

Bilbo stared into the embers.

“But don't go because you think you're a burden.”

The words settled heavily between them.

Bofur glanced toward Thorin.

“And for what it's worth, I think our king would be rather miserable without you.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Would he?”

Bofur smiled faintly.

“Aye. I believe he would.”

Bilbo's cheeks warmed.

He looked away.

“I hadn't really thought—”

A faint scraping sound interrupted him.

Both turned.

Somewhere beneath the cave, stone shifted against stone.

Bofur frowned.

“Did you hear that?”

Bilbo nodded.

Then the floor moved.

A sharp crack split the silence.

Before either could stand, the stone beneath the sleeping Company broke apart.

Bilbo shouted.

The cave collapsed into darkness.

___________

 

Thorin awoke to the sound of screaming.

For one terrible instant, he did not know where he was.

Then the floor vanished beneath him.

He fell amid a chaos of broken stone, blankets, and shouting dwarves.

Something struck his shoulder.

He twisted, reached for a handhold, and found only empty air.

The fall ended with a violent impact upon a wooden platform.

Thorin rolled, instinctively reaching for Orcrist.

A harsh voice shrieked from the darkness.

“Get them!”

Goblins poured from every direction.

They were small, twisted creatures with pale skin and sharp teeth, armed with crude blades and hooked spears.

Thorin drew his sword.

“COMPANY! TO ME!”

Fíli appeared beside him, already fighting.

Kíli struggled to free himself from beneath a broken plank.

Dwalin swung his axe, sending two goblins sprawling.

For a moment, Thorin believed they might break through.

Then dozens more emerged from the tunnels.

A net dropped over Nori and Ori.

Another caught Bombur.

Goblin spears pressed against their throats.

Thorin fought until a heavy blow struck his injured shoulder and drove him to one knee.

Several creatures seized his arms.

Orcrist was torn from his grasp.

He snarled and struggled, but there were too many.

“Uncle!”

Fíli tried to reach him.

A goblin struck the young dwarf from behind.

Thorin's heart lurched.

“FÍLI!”

His nephew fell, then immediately struggled upright.

Alive.

Thorin forced himself to breathe.

The goblins bound their wrists and dragged them toward the deeper tunnels.

Thorin searched desperately among the captives.

Dwalin.

Balin.

Fíli.

Kíli.

Bombur.

Bofur.

Ori.

Nori.

Glóin.

Óin.

Dori.

Bifur.

Bilbo.

He found the hobbit near Bofur, pale and frightened but apparently uninjured.

Relief washed through him.

Bilbo caught his eye.

Thorin gave him a small nod.

Stay calm.

Bilbo swallowed and nodded back.

Then the goblins forced them onward.

Gandalf was nowhere among the prisoners. Thorin had seen the wizard standing near the cave entrance when the floor gave way, and could only hope that he had managed to escape the trap.

Goblin-town was every bit as foul as Thorin remembered.

The tunnels opened into a vast underground cavern filled with rickety wooden bridges, platforms, and crooked stairways. Fires burned in iron baskets, casting an ugly orange light across the stone.

Hundreds of goblins crowded the walkways.

Their shrill voices echoed through the cavern as the prisoners were dragged toward a broad platform.

Upon it sat the Great Goblin.

Thorin remembered him immediately.

The creature was enormous, pale, and grotesque, his heavy body sprawled upon a crude throne.

“Well, well,” he crooned. “What have we here?”

The goblins shoved the Company forward.

“Dwarves!” one shrieked.

“Thirteen of them!”

“And a little one!”

The Great Goblin leaned forward.

His eyes settled upon Bilbo.

“What is that?”

“A hobbit,” Bilbo answered before anyone else could speak.

The creature blinked.

“A what?”

“A hobbit.”

“How peculiar.”

Thorin moved slightly in front of Bilbo.

The Great Goblin noticed.

“Oh? And who might you be?”

Before Thorin could answer, a goblin rushed forward carrying Orcrist.

“Look what we found!”

The moment the Great Goblin saw the blade, his expression changed.

He recoiled.

“The Biter!”

A frightened murmur spread through the crowd.

Thorin stood straighter.

The Great Goblin's eyes narrowed.

“That sword belonged to the enemies of our kind.”

His gaze returned to Thorin.

“Who are you?”

Thorin lifted his chin.

“Thorin, son of Thráin.”

The cavern seemed to fall silent.

Then the Great Goblin smiled.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

The name passed through the surrounding goblins like a whisper.

The creature leaned back upon his throne.

“Oh, this is wonderful.”

Thorin remained still.

He knew what was coming.

“The Pale Orc will be very pleased.”

Kíli stiffened.

Fíli looked toward his uncle.

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“Azog,” he said.

The Great Goblin laughed.

“So you know he's alive!”

Thorin said nothing.

He remembered Azog standing upon Ravenhill.

Remembered the blade that had pierced him.

Remembered the blood spreading across the snow.

The Great Goblin grinned.

“He'll pay handsomely for your head.”

Dwalin struggled against his captors.

“Come and take it, then!”

Several goblins struck him with their spears.

Thorin's expression darkened.

“Touch another member of my Company,” he said coldly, “and you will regret it.”

The Great Goblin laughed so loudly that his enormous stomach shook.

“Such a proud little king!”

He leaned forward.

“Let's see how proud you are when Azog arrives.”

Thorin looked toward his nephews.

Fíli met his gaze.

The young dwarf's expression was steady.

Kíli stood beside him, frightened but determined.

Thorin forced himself to remain calm.

He knew Gandalf would come.

He remembered the wizard's arrival, the sudden light, and the chaos that followed.

He only needed to keep everyone alive until then.

But remembering the future had already failed to keep them from Goblin-town.

And Thorin could not entirely silence the fear that Gandalf might not arrive this time.

The Great Goblin lifted one thick hand.

“Take their weapons. Search them. And if any of them cause trouble—”

A brilliant white light erupted across the cavern.

The goblins screamed.

A thunderous crack shook the platform.

Thorin threw himself forward as the nearest guards stumbled.

Gandalf stood upon a distant walkway, his staff blazing.

“Thorin!”

The dwarf's heart leapt.

“Gandalf!”

The wizard raised his staff again.

“RUN!”

The escape became a blur of shouting, steel, and splintering wood.

Thorin recovered Orcrist from a fallen goblin and immediately began cutting a path toward the nearest bridge.

“Fíli! Kíli! With me!”

His nephews followed.

Dwalin seized a discarded weapon and drove the goblins back while Balin helped Ori and Nori scramble onto the walkway.

Gandalf moved at the rear, his staff flashing whenever the pursuing creatures drew too close.

The bridges swayed beneath their feet.

Wooden planks broke apart.

Arrows struck the railings.

Thorin remembered this desperate flight.

He remembered the collapsing platforms and the Great Goblin's furious pursuit.

But he also remembered something else.

Bilbo disappearing.

He looked back.

The hobbit was running beside Bofur, clutching Sting in one hand.

“Bilbo!”

Bilbo turned.

“I'm here!”

“Stay close!”

“I am!”

A goblin lunged from a side passage.

Bilbo stumbled backward, raising Sting.

Before the creature could strike, Bofur swung his pickaxe and knocked it from the walkway.

“Keep moving, lad!”

They ran.

Ahead, Fíli and Kíli were fighting their way across a narrow bridge.

Thorin followed, keeping one eye upon Bilbo.

Then a terrible crash echoed through the cavern.

The Great Goblin had forced his enormous body onto the platform behind them.

The wooden supports groaned.

“YOU WON'T ESCAPE!”

Gandalf turned.

“Keep going!”

Thorin hesitated.

The wizard struck the platform with his staff.

A section of the walkway shattered.

The Great Goblin roared.

The bridge lurched violently.

Bilbo lost his balance.

He reached for the railing.

His fingers caught wet, rotten wood.

“Bilbo!”

Thorin turned.

For one instant, their eyes met.

Then the railing broke.

Bilbo fell backward into the darkness.

Thorin lunged.

His hand closed upon empty air.

“BILBO!”

The hobbit vanished beneath the walkway.

A distant crash echoed from somewhere below.

Thorin stood frozen.

He remembered this.

He remembered Bilbo disappearing.

But memory offered him no comfort.

Not now.

Not when he had watched the hobbit fall.

“THORIN!”

Dwalin seized his arm.

“We have to move!”

Thorin wrenched free.

“Bilbo's down there!”

“I know!”

“Then we go back!”

A volley of arrows struck the walkway around them.

Kíli cried out as one grazed his shoulder.

Fíli immediately moved to shield him.

Thorin saw the blood.

His stomach twisted.

The goblins were closing in.

Behind them, the platform began to collapse.

Gandalf appeared through the smoke.

“Thorin! We cannot stay!”

“Bilbo—”

“I saw him fall!”

“Then help me find him!”

Gandalf's expression tightened.

For a moment, the wizard looked toward the darkness beneath the bridge.

Then another explosion of splintering wood shook the cavern.

The walkway tilted.

Dwalin grabbed Thorin again.

“Your nephews need you!”

Thorin turned.

Fíli was holding Kíli upright.

Balin and the others were struggling to reach the next passage.

The goblins were almost upon them.

Thorin looked back toward the darkness.

Somewhere below, Bilbo was alone.

He remembered the hobbit returning in his first life.

He remembered his voice, his smile, the quiet courage that had carried him through impossible dangers.

But what if this time was different?

What if the path had changed?

What if Bilbo had struck the rocks below?

“Thorin!”

Fíli's voice cut through the chaos.

His nephew stood at the far end of the bridge, one arm around Kíli.

“Please!”

Thorin closed his eyes for a heartbeat.

He had promised to protect them.

All of them.

Yet the mountain was forcing him to choose.

Gandalf gripped his shoulder.

“Trust him,” the wizard said urgently.

Thorin opened his eyes.

The words struck something deep within him.

Trust Bilbo.

He had failed to do that once.

He would not fail again.

But trusting him did not make turning away any easier.

Thorin looked down into the darkness one final time.

“Bilbo,” he whispered.

Then he turned and ran.

Gandalf followed close behind, using his staff to hold back the goblins while the Company fled along the last narrow passage.

They had not gone far when Thorin stopped abruptly.

“Wait.”

Dwalin turned, breathing hard. “What now?”

Thorin ignored him. His eyes moved over the Company, counting each familiar face.

“Balin. Dwalin. Óin. Glóin. Dori. Nori. Ori. Bifur. Bofur. Bombur.”

His gaze found his nephews.

“Fíli. Kíli.”

Then he looked toward Gandalf, who stood behind them with his staff raised against the approaching goblins.

Thirteen dwarves, himself included.

One wizard.

Fourteen.

There should have been fifteen.

Thorin counted again, although he knew perfectly well who was missing.

“Bilbo.”

Fíli watched his uncle's expression change.

“Uncle…”

“Thirteen dwarves,” Thorin said quietly. “One wizard.”

His gaze returned to the passage they had just escaped.

“We are missing our burglar.”

Gandalf lowered his staff slightly.

“I know, Thorin.”

“Then we are not all here.”

“No,” Gandalf answered gently. “We are not.”

A distant shriek echoed through the tunnels.

Dwalin tightened his grip upon his axe.

“More are coming.”

Thorin stood motionless for another heartbeat.

Then he turned toward the darkness.

“Bilbo is still down there.”

“And we shall do everything we can to find him,” Gandalf replied. “But if we remain here, the goblins will have us all.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

He looked at Fíli, then Kíli, whose shoulder was bleeding beneath his torn coat. He looked at the others, exhausted and frightened, but still waiting for his command.

Finally, he nodded.

“Move.”

They continued toward the distant promise of daylight.

Behind them, the tunnels echoed with the cries of pursuing goblins.

And far below the mountain, beyond the reach of Thorin's voice, Bilbo Baggins lay alone in the darkness.

Chapter 6: Chapter Six — A Hobbit's Courage

Chapter Text

The first thing Thorin noticed when they emerged from the mountain was the sunlight.

It spilled across the rocky slopes in long, golden shafts, warming the damp stone and illuminating the thin mist drifting between the peaks. Somewhere below, a river rushed through a narrow gorge, its distant roar mingling with the wind. After the suffocating darkness of Goblin-town, the open sky should have been a blessing.

Thorin scarcely saw it.

He stumbled through the narrow opening with Orcrist in his hand, his lungs burning from the climb and his shoulder throbbing beneath his torn coat. Behind him, the Company emerged one by one, their boots scraping against loose stones as they struggled into the daylight.

Gandalf came last, his staff raised until he was satisfied that no goblins were following.

For several moments, nobody spoke. Bombur sank heavily onto a boulder, Óin immediately began examining Kíli's injured shoulder, and Dori helped Ori remove a splinter from his palm. The others gathered in exhausted clusters, grateful simply to be standing beneath the sky again.

Thorin turned toward the mountain.

The passage behind them disappeared into darkness.

Somewhere within that terrible labyrinth, Bilbo was alone.

He had seen the hobbit fall. Had watched the rotten railing break beneath his fingers and reached for him a heartbeat too late. The memory played relentlessly through Thorin's mind, each repetition ending with that small, frightened face vanishing into the abyss.

He remembered Bilbo surviving Goblin-town before.

But the first time, he had not witnessed the fall.

And this time, so much had already changed.

“We need to move farther from the entrance,” Dwalin said, approaching him. “Those creatures may yet follow.”

Thorin did not turn.

“We are going back.”

Dwalin stopped.

“Thorin.”

“We are going back,” he repeated, his voice harder. “Bilbo is still down there.”

“Aye, and I know it. But those tunnels are crawling with goblins.”

“Then we shall fight our way through them.”

Dwalin stared at him. “With what strength? Look at us!”

Thorin finally turned. His eyes swept over the Company, lingering upon Kíli, who sat grimacing while Óin cleaned the cut upon his shoulder. Fíli crouched beside his brother, one hand resting reassuringly against his back.

They were exhausted. Several were injured. They had barely escaped with their lives.

Thorin knew all of this.

It changed nothing about the image of Bilbo falling.

“He may be injured,” Thorin said. “He may be trapped somewhere beneath the mountain. We cannot simply abandon him.”

“Nobody is suggesting we abandon him,” Balin answered gently.

“Then gather your weapons.”

“Thorin,” Gandalf interrupted, stepping between him and the mountain entrance. “Listen to me.”

“I have listened enough.”

“Then listen once more. Returning through those tunnels would be suicide.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“What would you have me do?” he demanded. “Walk away knowing he may be lying injured somewhere beneath that mountain? Leave him alone in the dark?”

His voice had risen, carrying across the clearing.

Several dwarves looked up.

Dwalin's expression changed.

He had heard Thorin angry before. He had seen him furious enough to challenge kings and desperate enough to lead hopeless battles. But this was something else entirely.

There was fear in Thorin's voice.

Not the controlled concern of a commander responsible for his people, but something raw and deeply personal.

Glóin stepped forward, looking uncomfortable.

“He is one hobbit, Thorin. A brave little fellow, I'll grant you, but we cannot risk the entire Company—”

“He is our hobbit!”

The words rang through the clearing.

Silence followed.

Thorin stood breathing heavily, his fingers tightening around Orcrist's hilt.

Balin watched him with an expression of quiet understanding.

“We know, lad,” he said softly. “We know.”

But Thorin barely heard him.

He remembered Bilbo kneeling beside him upon Ravenhill, his face wet with tears. Remembered the warmth of his hands, the tremor in his voice, and the terrible realization that they had discovered their love only when there was no time left to live it.

He had been given another chance.

He could not lose Bilbo before that chance had truly begun.

“I'll go,” Kíli said suddenly.

Fíli turned sharply.

“You most certainly will not.”

“I can still fight.”

“You can barely lift your arm.”

“It's a scratch.”

“Then stop bleeding on my boots.”

Ordinarily, Thorin might have smiled at their exchange.

Instead, he looked toward his youngest nephew and felt another painful tightening in his chest.

“No,” he said firmly. “Neither of you is going back.”

Kíli frowned. “But Bilbo—”

“I know.”

Fíli rose slowly.

“Uncle, we want him back too.”

Thorin looked at him.

His eldest nephew's expression was earnest, troubled, and far older than it had seemed when they left the Shire.

“But we cannot help him if we all die down there.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

The words were reasonable.

That was precisely what made them so unbearable.

Gandalf approached more gently this time.

“Bilbo is resourceful, Thorin. Far more resourceful than you realize.”

Thorin opened his eyes.

I know exactly how resourceful he is.

He had seen that courage carry the hobbit through impossible dangers. Had seen him stand before enemies that should have terrified him into helplessness.

Yet courage could not protect someone from a fatal fall.

Gandalf rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“We shall search the surrounding slopes. There may be other passages leading out of the mountain. But we must not throw away fourteen lives in blind desperation.”

Thorin looked toward the dark entrance once more.

At last, with visible effort, he lowered his sword.

“Then we search.”

__________

 

Far beneath the mountain, Bilbo Baggins awoke with a headache.

It was a particularly unpleasant headache, accompanied by aching ribs, a bruised shoulder, and the dreadful realization that he was lying on cold stone in complete darkness.

For several moments, he remained still, trying to remember what had happened.

The bridge.

The goblins.

Thorin shouting his name.

Then falling.

Bilbo sat up too quickly and immediately regretted it.

“Oh, bother.”

His voice sounded very small in the darkness.

He felt around for his sword and found Sting lying a short distance away, its blade giving off a faint blue glow.

“Well,” he murmured, picking it up, “at least that's something.”

He was searching for his pack when his fingers brushed against a small, smooth object upon the ground.

Bilbo lifted it toward the light.

A golden ring.

It appeared perfectly ordinary, without ornament or gemstone, though its surface gleamed strangely in the darkness.

He turned it between his fingers.

“How curious.”

There was no time to examine it properly. Somewhere beyond the faint circle of Sting's light, water dripped steadily from the cavern ceiling.

Bilbo slipped the ring into his pocket and rose unsteadily.

He had to find a way out.

More importantly, he had to find Thorin.

The thought surprised him.

Not because he was unwilling to admit his affection for the dwarf, but because Thorin had become the first person he wanted whenever something went terribly wrong.

Back in the Shire, he would have thought of his comfortable armchair, his pantry, or perhaps Gandalf.

Now, standing alone beneath an unfamiliar mountain, he found himself wishing for a familiar deep voice telling him where to step and a strong hand reaching back to help him across difficult ground.

Bilbo swallowed.

“Well, Master Baggins,” he whispered, “you shall simply have to manage without him for the moment.”

He began walking.

The tunnels grew narrower, their walls damp and strangely smooth. After what felt like an eternity, he reached the edge of an underground lake, black and still beneath the cavern roof.

Something moved upon the water.

Bilbo stopped.

A small boat drifted toward him.

Within it crouched a pale, thin creature with enormous eyes and long fingers.

The creature stared at him.

Bilbo stared back.

And somewhere in the darkness, a thin voice whispered, “What's this, precious?”

___________

 

Aboveground, Thorin had searched every accessible crevice along the mountainside.

He had examined narrow cracks between boulders, followed old animal tracks toward the cliff face, and climbed two dangerous slopes despite Dwalin's increasingly irritated objections.

Nothing.

No sign of Bilbo.

No footprints.

No familiar voice complaining about the indignity of the situation.

Only stone, wind, and the distant cries of birds.

Eventually, Gandalf persuaded the Company to gather beneath a stand of twisted mountain pines.

Thorin remained apart from them.

He stood with his back to the others, staring toward the mountain.

Fíli approached quietly.

“Uncle?”

Thorin did not answer immediately.

“Óin says Kíli will be fine,” Fíli continued. “The cut isn't deep.”

“Good.”

“He's complaining about being treated like an invalid.”

“That is also good.”

Fíli managed a small smile.

Then he stepped beside him.

“Bilbo may still find his way out.”

Thorin's expression tightened.

“I know.”

Fíli studied him.

He had noticed his uncle's growing affection for the hobbit weeks ago. The shared conversations, the patient lessons with Sting, the way Thorin's expression softened whenever Bilbo approached.

And, of course, the braids.

Fíli knew what they meant among dwarves.

He had wondered whether Thorin understood what he was allowing.

Now he was beginning to suspect that his uncle understood perfectly well.

What Fíli could not comprehend was the depth of it.

Thorin had known Bilbo for only a handful of weeks.

Yet he looked as though he were grieving someone he had loved for a lifetime.

“Uncle,” Fíli said carefully, “what is Bilbo to you?”

Thorin turned.

For a moment, something unguarded crossed his face.

Then his expression closed.

“He is a member of this Company.”

Fíli did not look convinced.

“I know that.”

“Then you have your answer.”

His nephew hesitated.

“Is that truly all?”

Thorin looked away.

He could have lied.

He could have dismissed the question, reminded Fíli of his duties, and ended the conversation.

But he remembered their talk in Rivendell, and the trust he had promised his nephew.

“No,” he admitted quietly. “It is not.”

Fíli's eyes widened slightly.

Thorin offered nothing more.

After a moment, Fíli nodded.

“Then I hope we find him.”

Thorin looked at him.

“So do I.”

Nearby, Balin watched their conversation without approaching.

Dwalin joined him.

“Something's wrong with him.”

Balin sighed.

“Aye.”

“You've noticed it too.”

“I would have to be blind not to.”

Dwalin folded his arms.

“He's known that hobbit for weeks, Balin. Weeks. Yet he's behaving as though—”

“As though he's in love?”

Dwalin turned sharply.

Balin merely looked at him.

The warrior opened his mouth, closed it, and glanced toward Thorin.

Then he muttered something rather uncomplimentary beneath his breath.

Balin's mouth twitched.

“Love is not always reasonable, Dwalin.”

“No, but Thorin usually is.”

Balin raised an eyebrow.

Dwalin considered his words.

“Occasionally.”

___________

 

Bilbo had never expected his survival to depend upon answering riddles.

Yet there he was, sitting upon a cold stone beside an underground lake, desperately searching his memory for every riddle he had ever heard at a family gathering.

Across from him, Gollum crouched upon a rock, his enormous eyes shining with hungry interest.

The creature had promised to show him the way out if Bilbo won.

If he lost, however, Gollum intended to eat him.

Bilbo considered this a thoroughly unfair arrangement.

Nevertheless, he played.

He answered questions about mountains, teeth, darkness, and time, while Gollum grew increasingly frustrated by the unexpected cleverness of his guest.

Eventually, Bilbo found himself with no proper riddle left.

His hand slipped into his pocket.

His fingers closed around the small golden ring.

“What have I got in my pocket?” he murmured.

Gollum's head snapped upward.

“What?”

Bilbo blinked.

He had not meant to ask it aloud.

But Gollum was already demanding guesses, and Bilbo, realizing that his accidental question might save him, allowed the game to continue.

When Gollum failed, his mood changed.

The creature began searching frantically for something he called his precious.

Bilbo watched him with growing unease.

Then Gollum turned toward him, his face twisted with fury.

“Thief!”

Bilbo ran.

He fled through the tunnels with Gollum shrieking behind him, his heart hammering so violently that he could scarcely hear his own footsteps.

At one point, he stumbled and fell.

The ring slipped onto his finger.

And suddenly Gollum rushed past without seeing him.

Bilbo stared at his own hands.

They were gone.

Or rather, he could feel them perfectly well, but he could no longer see them.

For several astonished moments, he remained crouched against the wall.

Then he understood.

The ring.

He followed Gollum through the tunnels, keeping his footsteps quiet.

Eventually, they reached a narrow passage where daylight shone faintly through the rocks.

Gollum crouched before the opening, blocking his escape.

Bilbo drew Sting.

He could kill the creature.

One quick strike, and the way would be clear.

Gollum was small, frightened, and utterly unaware of the invisible hobbit standing behind him.

Bilbo raised the blade.

Then he hesitated.

The creature's face was twisted with grief, his eyes wet and desperate as he mourned the loss of his precious.

Bilbo felt a sudden, painful pity.

Whatever Gollum had become, he had once been something else.

And Bilbo could not bring himself to kill him.

He lowered Sting.

Then, gathering every ounce of courage he possessed, he leapt over the creature and scrambled toward the light.

Gollum screamed behind him.

Bilbo did not look back.

By the time Bilbo emerged from the mountain, the afternoon sun had begun its descent.

He stumbled through a narrow crack between the rocks, pulled the ring from his finger, and collapsed upon the grass.

For several moments, he simply breathed.

Fresh air.

Sunlight.

Birdsong.

He had never been so grateful for ordinary things.

__________

 

Then he remembered the Company.

Bilbo struggled upright.

He followed the slope downward, searching for tracks or voices, until at last he heard someone speaking beyond a cluster of trees.

He recognized the voice immediately.

Thorin.

Bilbo stopped.

The dwarf sounded angry.

“We have searched every opening along this ridge.”

“And found nothing,” Dwalin answered.

“Then we search farther.”

“Thorin, darkness is approaching.”

“I am aware.”

“We cannot remain here indefinitely.”

Bilbo moved closer, still hidden behind the trees.

Thorin stood in the clearing, his coat torn and his face pale with exhaustion. Gandalf was beside him, while several dwarves sat nearby.

Bilbo's heart tightened.

Thorin looked dreadful.

“I will not leave him,” the king said.

The words were quiet, but there was something in them that made Bilbo stop breathing for a moment.

Gandalf sighed.

“Thorin—”

“No. I have already left him once today. I will not do so again.”

Bilbo stepped forward.

“Then it's rather fortunate that you won't have to.”

Every head turned.

For one heartbeat, nobody moved.

Then Thorin saw him.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit managed a small smile.

“Hello.”

Thorin crossed the clearing so quickly that Bilbo barely had time to react.

Strong arms wrapped around him, lifting him almost entirely off his feet.

Bilbo gasped in surprise.

“Oh!”

Thorin held him fiercely, one hand pressed against the back of his head.

For several moments, he said nothing.

Bilbo could feel the dwarf trembling.

His surprise softened into something warm and aching.

Slowly, he wrapped his arms around Thorin's shoulders.

“I'm all right,” he murmured.

Thorin tightened his embrace.

“I thought—”

He stopped.

Bilbo rested a hand against his back.

“I know.”

The Company had fallen completely silent.

Kíli stared openly.

Glóin looked bewildered.

Dwalin glanced toward Balin, who was smiling with suspiciously bright eyes.

Thorin finally lowered Bilbo to the ground, though he kept both hands upon his shoulders.

“Are you injured?”

“Only a little bruised.”

“Your head?”

“Still attached.”

“Bilbo.”

“Honestly, Thorin, I'm quite all right.”

Thorin searched his face, as though unwilling to believe him without examining every inch.

Then he drew a long, shaking breath.

Bilbo looked past him toward the others.

“I'm terribly sorry. I didn't mean to worry everyone.”

“Worry us?” Kíli exclaimed. “We thought you'd been eaten!”

Bilbo looked offended.

“Really?”

“Or crushed,” Bofur supplied.

“Or lost,” Ori added.

“Thank you,” Bilbo said dryly. “How reassuring.”

A few dwarves laughed, the tension finally beginning to ease.

Thorin did not.

He was still looking at Bilbo.

“You could have gone home,” he said quietly.

Bilbo blinked.

“What?”

“When you escaped the mountain. You could have taken the road west, returned to the Shire. No one would have blamed you.”

Bilbo considered him.

“Well, yes,” he admitted. “I suppose I could have.”

He glanced toward the Company.

“And I do miss home. I miss my books, my armchair, my garden. I miss knowing where I'm going to sleep at night, and having a proper breakfast without someone telling me we haven't time for it.”

Bombur nodded sympathetically.

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“But the thing is, I have a home waiting for me. A place where I belong, where I can go back whenever all this is over.”

His expression grew more serious.

“You haven't had that for a very long time. Your home was taken from you, and you've spent years dreaming of seeing it again.”

He looked at Balin, then Fíli and Kíli, and finally Thorin.

“So perhaps I don't belong on this adventure quite as much as the rest of you. Perhaps I am only a burglar who doesn't know the first thing about burgling.”

Bofur shook his head, but Bilbo continued.

“But I want to help you. I want to help you take your home back.”

Thorin stared at him.

He remembered those words.

Not merely their meaning, but the earnestness in Bilbo's voice and the determined way he lifted his chin.

He had heard them before, beneath another sky, in another life.

Then, he had been ashamed of his own harshness.

Now he felt something far more overwhelming.

Gratitude.

Bilbo had chosen them again.

Even without knowing what awaited him.

Even without knowing how much his choice meant to the dwarf standing before him.

Thorin reached for his hand.

“You belong here, Bilbo,” he said, his voice low but certain. “Never doubt that.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

For a moment, neither looked away.

Then Kíli cleared his throat.

“Well, now that we've established our burglar is alive, could we perhaps find somewhere to sleep?”

Fíli elbowed him.

“What? I'm tired!”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin finally smiled.

And when he turned toward the Company, his eyes moved automatically over the familiar faces.

Fíli.

Kíli.

Balin.

Dwalin.

The others.

Gandalf.

Bilbo.

Thirteen dwarves.

One wizard.

One hobbit.

Fifteen.

All accounted for.

Bilbo noticed.

“Are you counting us?”

Thorin glanced down.

“Making certain I haven't lost anyone.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Well, I'm here.”

“Yes,” Thorin answered softly.

His fingers tightened briefly around Bilbo's hand.

“Yes, you are.”

__________

 

They did not have long to enjoy their reunion.

The first howl came shortly before sunset.

It rose from the forest below, long and terrible, followed by another and then several more.

Thorin stopped walking.

He knew that sound.

Dwalin drew his axe.

“Wargs.”

Gandalf turned toward the trees.

“Quickly. We must find higher ground.”

The Company hurried through the forest, but the howls followed, growing louder with every passing moment.

Bilbo ran beside Thorin, struggling to keep pace over the uneven ground.

“Are those wolves?”

“Worse,” Thorin answered.

A dark shape appeared between the trees.

Then another.

The first warg lunged.

Dwalin struck it with his axe, but more creatures emerged from the shadows, their riders shouting in harsh voices.

“Into the trees!” Gandalf commanded.

The dwarves scrambled upward.

Fíli helped Kíli climb, while Bofur boosted Bombur toward a low branch. Dori seized Ori by the collar and practically threw him into the nearest pine.

Thorin caught Bilbo around the waist and lifted him toward a sturdy branch.

“Climb!”

Bilbo obeyed.

Below them, the wargs circled, snapping at the trunks.

Thorin climbed after him, settling upon a broad branch while the others gathered in the surrounding trees.

Then a pale figure emerged from the forest.

Azog.

Thorin's blood turned cold.

The orc sat upon his enormous white warg, his scarred face twisted into a cruel smile.

Thorin remembered him.

Remembered charging toward him in blind fury.

Remembered the blow that had thrown him to the ground, leaving him helpless beneath the creature's weapon.

And remembered Bilbo running to his defence.

He would not repeat that mistake.

“Stay in the trees!” Thorin ordered.

Dwalin glanced toward him.

“Thorin—”

“We do not engage him on the ground.”

Azog shouted something in the Black Speech.

The orcs began gathering beneath the trees.

Gandalf drew a burning pinecone from the branches above, setting it alight with his staff.

“Catch!”

The dwarves began hurling flaming cones toward the wargs.

Fire spread rapidly across the dry forest floor.

The creatures shrieked and scattered, but the flames climbed the trunks, forcing the Company farther along the branches.

Bilbo clung to the tree beside Thorin.

“Is this part of the plan?”

“Not particularly.”

“I thought not!”

The tree shuddered.

A burning branch broke away, striking the trunk below them.

Thorin seized Bilbo's arm.

“Move higher!”

They climbed.

Across the clearing, Kíli lost his footing when a branch snapped beneath him.

Fíli caught his wrist.

“Hold on!”

Thorin turned immediately.

His nephews struggled together, their tree leaning dangerously toward the burning ground.

Thorin began moving along the branches toward them.

Then a massive warg struck the base of his own tree.

The trunk cracked.

Bilbo cried out.

Thorin caught him against his chest as the tree tilted.

For one terrible moment, the world seemed to slow.

Fire.

Smoke.

Azog waiting below.

The same terrible danger, returning despite everything Thorin had done to avoid it.

The trunk split.

Thorin pushed Bilbo toward a neighbouring branch.

“Jump!”

Bilbo leapt.

He caught the branch with both hands, scrambling desperately to pull himself up.

Thorin followed, but the burning trunk collapsed beneath his feet.

He fell.

The impact drove the breath from his lungs.

Orcrist slipped from his hand.

Above him, Bilbo screamed his name.

Thorin struggled to rise, but pain shot through his injured shoulder.

A shadow fell across him.

Azog approached.

The orc's laughter carried through the smoke.

Thorin reached for his sword.

Too far.

He looked upward.

Bilbo was climbing down.

“No,” Thorin whispered.

The hobbit dropped from the lowest branch, landed awkwardly, and drew Sting.

“BILBO, STAY BACK!”

But Bilbo was already running.

He threw himself between Thorin and the approaching warg, slashing wildly with Sting.

The creature recoiled.

Bilbo stumbled but recovered, planting himself before Thorin with his small sword raised.

He was trembling.

Thorin could see it.

Yet he did not move away.

“Leave him alone!” Bilbo shouted.

For one terrible instant, Thorin saw two moments overlapping.

Bilbo standing before Azog in the burning forest.

Bilbo kneeling beside him upon Ravenhill.

Both brave.

Both terrified.

Both willing to risk everything for him.

Not again.

Thorin forced himself upright.

He seized Orcrist and stepped beside Bilbo just as another warg lunged.

Together, they drove it back.

Then the forest erupted with a sudden rush of enormous wings.

The eagles had come.

One swept low across the clearing, seizing a warg in its talons. Another struck the orcs gathered near the burning trees.

Gandalf shouted for the Company to climb aboard.

Thorin grabbed Bilbo's hand.

“Come!”

They ran through the smoke.

An eagle descended before them, its great wings beating the air into a furious wind.

Thorin lifted Bilbo onto its back and climbed after him.

The bird launched itself into the sky.

Below, Azog roared in fury as the forest disappeared beneath them.

Thorin scarcely looked back.

His arms were wrapped around Bilbo, holding him securely against the eagle's feathers.

Bilbo leaned into him, exhausted and shaking.

Neither spoke.

There were no words large enough for what had almost happened.

The eagles carried them far from the burning forest.

___________

 

They soared above valleys filled with mist, over dark rivers and endless stretches of woodland. The mountains gradually fell behind them, their jagged peaks glowing beneath the last light of evening.

Bilbo had never imagined he would fly.

Under different circumstances, he might have found the experience rather wonderful.

As it was, he spent most of the journey clinging to the eagle's feathers and trying not to look down.

Thorin remained close behind him.

Whenever the great bird banked or dipped, the dwarf's arm tightened protectively around his waist.

Eventually, Bilbo relaxed enough to look at the world passing beneath them.

It was beautiful.

Terrifying, certainly.

But beautiful.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Have you ever flown before?”

Thorin hesitated.

He remembered this journey.

Remembered waking upon the Carrock after the eagles had carried them from the burning trees.

But in this life, he had not yet experienced it.

“No,” he answered.

Bilbo looked over his shoulder.

“Neither have I.”

Thorin's mouth curved faintly.

“I had gathered as much.”

Bilbo gave an indignant little huff.

“I think I'm handling it rather well.”

“You have only screamed twice.”

“Once.”

“Twice.”

“The second was entirely justified.”

Thorin laughed.

It was quiet, almost lost beneath the wind, but Bilbo felt the sound against his back.

And somehow, despite the enormous eagle carrying them through the sky, he felt safe.

They reached the Carrock shortly before dawn.

The eagles descended upon a broad, rocky summit overlooking a vast wilderness of forests and distant mountains.

One by one, the Company climbed from their feathered rescuers, stumbling across the stone with varying degrees of dignity.

Bombur immediately sat down.

“I am never doing that again.”

“You said the same thing about riding ponies,” Bofur reminded him.

“And I meant it then too.”

Gandalf thanked the eagles, bowing deeply as their great leader spread his wings.

Then the birds departed, disappearing into the pale morning sky.

Thorin stood watching until they were gone.

Only then did he turn toward the Company.

He counted.

Fíli.

Kíli.

Balin.

Dwalin.

The others.

Gandalf.

Bilbo.

Fifteen.

All alive.

He released a breath he felt he had been holding since Goblin-town.

Óin examined the injured while Bombur searched their remaining supplies for something resembling breakfast. Kíli complained about his shoulder until Fíli threatened to tie his arm to his chest.

Gradually, the Company settled.

__________

 

Thorin found Bilbo sitting near the edge of the summit, watching the sunrise.

The hobbit had drawn his knees toward his chest, his curls stirred by the morning breeze. His coat was torn, his hands scraped, and there was a small bruise darkening his cheek.

Yet he was smiling.

Thorin approached quietly.

“May I join you?”

Bilbo looked up.

“Of course.”

Thorin sat beside him.

For a while, they watched the sun rise above the distant forest.

The world seemed impossibly peaceful.

Bilbo sighed.

“I suppose I ought to be grateful we're alive.”

“A reasonable sentiment.”

“Though I should like to survive an entire week without being chased, captured, or nearly eaten.”

Thorin smiled.

“I shall see what I can arrange.”

“Wonderful. Perhaps you might also arrange a proper bath.”

“That may prove more difficult.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

Then he turned toward Thorin.

“You've been very quiet.”

Thorin looked at him.

“There is something I wished to say.”

“Oh?”

“Thank you.”

Bilbo blinked.

“For what?”

“For saving my life.”

The hobbit's expression softened.

“Oh, Thorin.”

“You placed yourself between me and Azog. You could have been killed.”

Bilbo looked down at his hands.

“I couldn't simply stand there and watch him hurt you.”

Thorin's chest tightened.

“I know.”

Bilbo glanced at him.

“Besides, you saved me in the mountains.”

“That hardly makes your actions less dangerous.”

“No,” Bilbo admitted. “But it does mean we're rather even, doesn't it?”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“Then I suppose we're even.”

Bilbo considered this.

Then he smiled.

“I rather hope we're not keeping count.”

Thorin laughed.

A genuine laugh, warm and surprised.

Bilbo looked pleased with himself.

But as Thorin watched the hobbit turn back toward the sunrise, he remembered all the times Bilbo had saved him in his first life.

From enemies.

From his own pride.

From the darkness that had nearly consumed him.

And finally, upon Ravenhill, from dying without ever knowing that he was loved.

No, Thorin thought.

If they were keeping count, he would owe Bilbo far more than the hobbit could possibly imagine.

The morning breeze stirred Bilbo's curls.

After a moment, the hobbit shifted closer, allowing his shoulder to rest against Thorin's arm.

Thorin looked down.

Bilbo did not move away.

Instead, he settled more comfortably beside him, his gaze fixed upon the distant mountains.

Thorin allowed himself a small smile.

For the first time since awakening outside Bag End, he felt something stronger than fear.

Hope.

They had survived the mountains.

His nephews were alive.

His Company was together.

And Bilbo Baggins was sitting beside him, warm and breathing, with an entire future still waiting to unfold.

Thorin did not know what dangers lay ahead.

He knew only that he would face them differently this time.

Not alone.

Not blinded by pride.

And, if Mahal was merciful, not without the hobbit whose hand had somehow found its way into his own.

Chapter 7: Chapter Seven — The Long Road East

Chapter Text

The first morning after the eagles carried them from the burning forest began with an argument about breakfast.

Bilbo Baggins, who had survived goblins, riddles, enormous wolves, and the rather alarming experience of travelling through the sky upon the back of a giant eagle, had hoped that surviving such extraordinary circumstances might entitle him to a proper meal. He considered this a modest expectation. Unfortunately, the Company possessed precisely three remaining strips of dried meat, a handful of nuts, and a quantity of hard bread that appeared better suited to repairing damaged masonry than human consumption.

“That's not breakfast,” Bilbo declared, examining the portion Bofur had handed him. “That's an insult.”

“It's food,” Dwalin replied.

“An insult disguised as food.”

Bofur laughed and offered him another piece of bread. Bilbo accepted it with the solemn resignation of someone who had recently discovered that starvation and broken teeth were equally unpleasant possibilities.

Thorin watched the exchange from a short distance away, where he and Gandalf had spread their map across a broad stone. The morning sun illuminated the valleys beneath the Carrock, revealing a wilderness of rolling hills, scattered woodland, and distant rivers. Beyond them lay the vast shadow of Mirkwood, though its dark canopy remained too far away to distinguish clearly.

It was beautiful country, and dangerous.

“We have gained a considerable distance from Azog,” Gandalf said, following the course of the Anduin with one finger. “The eagles have carried us beyond his immediate reach.”

“But not beyond his interest,” Thorin answered.

“No.”

Thorin studied the map. In his first life, they had found Beorn's lands much sooner after their rescue. Yet their changed route, the need to avoid pursuit, and the Company's injuries made him reluctant to rush eastward. The wilderness offered few roads worth trusting, and the valleys were vast enough to swallow travellers who chose their paths carelessly.

He had learned, through bitter experience, that knowing where danger waited did not mean he could simply walk around it.

“We'll keep away from the eastern tracks,” he decided. “Travel beneath the western hills until we find a safer crossing. Fíli can lead the scouts.”

Gandalf glanced at him.

“You have become rather fond of caution.”

“I have become rather fond of keeping everyone alive.”

The wizard's expression softened, though he said nothing.

Behind them, Bilbo was attempting to persuade Bombur that a proper breakfast required at least two separate dishes. Thorin heard the hobbit's indignant voice rise above the others and found himself smiling.

Gandalf noticed.

Of course he noticed.

“Something amusing?” the wizard asked.

“Not particularly.”

“Indeed.”

Thorin folded the map before Gandalf could say anything else.

___________

 

They departed the Carrock that morning, fifteen travellers descending into the wild country beneath a sky of pale blue.

And for the first time in many weeks, they were not running.

The first fortnight passed beneath warm days and increasingly cool nights.

They followed the folds of the western hills, sometimes travelling beside narrow streams and sometimes through grasslands where the wind bent the stalks into long, rippling waves. The mountains remained visible behind them, immense and blue-grey against the horizon, while the eastern forests slowly grew larger.

Their progress was not swift.

Kíli's shoulder required several days before he could comfortably draw his bow again, and Óin insisted upon inspecting it every evening despite the younger dwarf's complaints. Their supplies were poor, forcing them to spend hours gathering edible plants, setting snares, and fishing in shallow streams. Twice, heavy rain made the ground so treacherous that Thorin ordered them to remain sheltered rather than risk unnecessary injuries.

Yet the slower pace gave the Company something they had lacked since leaving Rivendell.

Time.

Time to speak without shouting over the noise of battle. Time to laugh around small fires. Time for Bilbo to discover that Ori possessed an astonishing talent for drawing birds, that Bombur could identify edible mushrooms with remarkable accuracy, and that Dwalin considered almost every plant in Middle-earth suspicious unless it had already been eaten by someone else.

It also gave Bilbo time to notice things about Thorin.

He noticed, for instance, that the dwarf almost never sat down until everyone else had settled.

He noticed that Thorin frequently surrendered the better portions of food to his nephews, though he disguised the gesture by claiming he was not hungry.

And he noticed that whenever the Company stopped, Thorin's first instinct was to check the surrounding hills rather than rest.

___________

 

One evening, after a particularly long day, Bilbo found him sitting beside a small fire with a needle in one hand and his torn coat spread across his knees.

The dwarf was attempting to repair a seam near the shoulder.

He was not succeeding.

Bilbo watched for several moments before approaching.

“Whatever did that poor coat do to deserve such treatment?”

Thorin looked up.

“I am mending it.”

“Are you?”

The dwarf examined the crooked line of stitches.

“It will hold.”

“Yes, well, so would tying it together with a length of rope, but I wouldn't recommend that either.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo held out his hand.

“Give it here.”

“I can manage.”

“I'm sure you can. But being capable of doing something doesn't mean you must do absolutely everything yourself.”

Thorin went still.

The words were spoken without ceremony, accompanied only by Bilbo's expectant expression and the faint impatience of someone accustomed to dealing with stubborn relatives.

Yet something about them struck deeper than the hobbit could have known.

For years, Thorin had been expected to manage everything.

His people's hunger. Their wandering. Their grief. His grandfather's legacy and his father's absence. Every difficult decision, every failure, every hope placed upon the shoulders of a king without a kingdom.

In his first life, Bilbo had been one of the few people who had ever looked beyond those burdens.

Apparently, he intended to do so again.

Thorin surrendered the coat.

Bilbo settled beside him, inspected the damage, and began carefully removing the worst stitches.

“Honestly,” he murmured, “you would think someone raised in a royal household might have learned the value of a decent tailor.”

“We had tailors.”

“Clearly you didn't listen to them.”

Thorin chuckled.

Bilbo smiled down at his work.

A little later, when the coat was properly repaired, he returned it with considerable satisfaction.

“There. That should last longer than five minutes.”

Thorin examined the neat seam.

“Thank you.”

“You're welcome.”

Bilbo began gathering the thread, then paused.

“Have you eaten?”

Thorin hesitated.

Bilbo narrowed his eyes.

“You haven't.”

“I was occupied.”

“Of course you were.”

The hobbit rose, disappeared toward the fire, and returned with a bowl of stew.

Thorin looked at it.

“Bilbo—”

“Eat.”

The king of Durin's Folk obeyed.

Across the camp, Dwalin witnessed the exchange with an expression of profound bewilderment.

Balin, sitting beside him, continued polishing his spectacles.

“Don't,” he said mildly.

“I haven't said anything.”

“You were about to.”

Dwalin watched Thorin accept a second spoonful of stew after Bilbo informed him that he looked exhausted.

“I've fought beside that dwarf for decades.”

“I know.”

“He once refused to eat for two days because he was too stubborn to admit he had a fever.”

“Yes, I remember.”

“And now a hobbit tells him to eat, and he eats.”

Balin smiled.

“Remarkable, isn't it?”

Dwalin grunted.

He did not sound entirely displeased.

__________

 

By the third week, Bilbo had begun to look forward to the evenings.

There were still unpleasant days, certainly. Days when his feet ached and his stomach complained, when rain soaked through his coat, and when he longed so fiercely for Bag End that he could almost smell the fresh bread cooling upon his kitchen table.

But the Company had become familiar in ways he had not expected.

He knew which dwarves preferred the earliest watches and which would complain about them regardless. He knew that Fíli hummed quietly while sharpening his blades, that Kíli talked in his sleep, and that Bofur always seemed to have a story ready whenever the mood grew too solemn.

And he knew where Thorin would sit.

Usually near the edge of camp, with a clear view of the surrounding country and his sword within reach.

Bilbo had gradually developed the habit of joining him.

At first, he had done so because Thorin possessed the maps, and Bilbo wanted to know precisely how far they had travelled. Then he began staying to ask questions about Erebor, about the languages of dwarves, and about the distant places Thorin had visited.

Eventually, he stopped needing a reason.

One particularly cold evening, the Company made camp beneath a grove of ancient trees. Their branches formed a broad canopy overhead, sheltering the small fire from the wind. Supper had been eaten, the watches arranged, and most of the dwarves were enjoying a rare opportunity to sit without immediately being ordered onward.

Thorin was studying a map against a fallen log when Bilbo approached with his blanket.

“May I?”

Thorin looked up.

“Of course.”

Bilbo settled beside him, tucking his feet beneath the blanket.

For a while, they discussed the following day's route. Bilbo asked about a river marked upon the map, and Thorin explained the difficulties of crossing it during the rainy season.

The hobbit listened attentively.

Then his questions grew less frequent.

Thorin felt a gentle weight settle against his shoulder.

He looked down.

Bilbo had fallen asleep.

His cheek rested against Thorin's upper arm, his curls brushing the dwarf's beard. One hand lay loosely upon the blanket between them, and his breathing had become slow and even.

Thorin stared at him.

He had imagined many things during the long, miserable nights of his first life.

A reclaimed kingdom.

His nephews surviving.

Bilbo smiling at him across a table.

But he had never imagined that simply having the hobbit asleep against his shoulder could make the entire world feel peaceful.

Carefully, he adjusted his cloak around Bilbo.

Then he returned to his map, holding it at an awkward angle so that he would not disturb him.

Unfortunately, the Company had eyes.

Dwalin noticed first.

He had been sharpening his axe when his gaze wandered across the fire.

The whetstone stopped moving.

He looked again.

Then he turned toward Balin.

His brother was smiling.

“What?” Dwalin whispered.

“Nothing.”

“Balin.”

“He's comfortable.”

“I can see that.”

“Then what's troubling you?”

Dwalin stared at the pair across the fire.

Thorin had shifted his cloak over Bilbo's shoulders and was now holding his map with one hand, apparently unwilling to move the arm upon which the hobbit slept.

“That's Thorin,” Dwalin said.

Balin glanced toward him.

“I'm aware.”

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

“Yes, brother.”

“He's letting someone sleep on him.”

Balin's smile widened.

“Apparently so.”

“Last winter, he threatened to break my nose because I used his shoulder as a pillow.”

“Perhaps Bilbo is more comfortable company.”

Dwalin looked deeply offended.

Nearby, Fíli had noticed the arrangement too.

He sat beside Kíli, who was attempting to balance a small stone upon the end of his nose.

Fíli nudged him.

Kíli looked up, followed his brother's gaze, and promptly dropped the stone into his lap.

“Oh.”

Fíli smiled.

Kíli's expression brightened.

“Oh!”

“Quiet,” Fíli warned.

“I didn't say anything.”

“You were about to.”

Kíli grinned but obediently returned his attention to the stone.

Fíli continued watching his uncle.

He remembered Thorin's desperate expression outside Goblin-town, the way his voice had broken when he refused to abandon Bilbo. At the time, Fíli had been frightened by the intensity of it.

Now, watching Thorin sit so carefully beside the sleeping hobbit, he felt something warmer.

His uncle looked happy.

Not triumphant, not relieved after surviving another battle, but genuinely content.

Fíli could scarcely remember the last time he had seen him like that.

Across the fire, Glóin followed the others' glances and frowned thoughtfully.

He had grown fond of Bilbo. The hobbit had proved himself brave, loyal, and far more useful than Glóin had initially expected.

Nevertheless, Thorin was their king.

Erebor would demand much of him if they succeeded, and affection could become a dangerous complication when entire kingdoms were involved.

Glóin said nothing.

Beside him, Dori looked as though he were struggling to decide whether someone ought to intervene.

Nori noticed his expression and smirked.

“Something wrong, brother?”

“His Majesty is being used as a pillow.”

“Yes. I can see that.”

“In front of everyone.”

“And yet the sky hasn't fallen.”

Dori gave him a disapproving look.

Ori, meanwhile, was studying the scene with open curiosity.

“Do you think Thorin's arm has gone numb?”

Nori nearly choked on his drink.

Bombur glanced up from his supper, considered the sleeping hobbit, and returned to eating.

Bofur merely smiled.

Gandalf, seated beyond the fire with his pipe, watched Thorin over the rim of his hat.

There was something remarkable about the gentleness with which the dwarf regarded Bilbo.

Something that seemed older than their acquaintance.

The wizard had suspected for some time that Thorin was carrying knowledge he should not possess. Yet the mystery of that knowledge was becoming inseparable from the question of what Bilbo Baggins meant to him.

Gandalf drew thoughtfully upon his pipe.

__________

 

Across the clearing, Bilbo stirred.

He blinked, realized where he was, and immediately straightened.

“Oh! I'm terribly sorry.”

Thorin looked down.

“For what?”

“I fell asleep on you.”

“I noticed.”

“I didn't mean to. You must be uncomfortable.”

Bilbo began moving away, but Thorin gently caught his hand.

“You needn't move.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Are you certain?”

“Quite.”

For a moment, the hobbit looked at him with an expression Thorin could not entirely decipher.

Then he smiled sleepily.

“Well, if you're sure.”

He settled against Thorin again.

Thorin returned to his map.

Across the fire, Dwalin stared as though someone had informed him that the Lonely Mountain had sprouted wings.

Balin laughed quietly into his beard.

__________

 

The fourth week brought rain.

It arrived in heavy grey curtains that turned paths into mud and filled the streams until they spilled across their banks. The Company travelled beneath dripping branches, their cloaks dark with water and their tempers increasingly strained.

One evening, after hours of trudging through the downpour, they found shelter beneath the spreading roots of an enormous oak.

The ground was reasonably dry, and the branches provided enough cover for a small fire.

Most of the Company fell asleep quickly.

Bilbo did not.

He lay listening to the rain, thinking of Bag End and the familiar sound of water tapping against his windows.

Eventually, he noticed that Thorin was missing.

He found the dwarf sitting beneath the outer branches, looking into the darkness.

“Couldn't sleep?” Bilbo asked.

Thorin turned.

“Neither could you, apparently.”

Bilbo settled beside him.

For a while, they listened to the rain.

Then Thorin spoke.

“My mother used to enjoy storms.”

Bilbo glanced at him.

“Did she?”

“She said they made the mountain sound alive.”

His expression softened with memory.

“When we were children, she would take us to one of the great windows overlooking the valley. Dís would insist upon counting the lightning, and Frerin would hide whenever the thunder grew too loud.”

Bilbo smiled.

“And you?”

“I informed everyone that I was not frightened.”

“Were you?”

“Terrified.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

Thorin's smile faded into something gentler.

“She knew, of course. She always knew.”

He looked down at his hands.

“Sometimes I can remember everything about those evenings. The smell of the candles, the sound of the rain, the way she would pull Frerin into her lap.”

He paused.

“But I cannot always remember her voice.”

Bilbo's expression changed.

Thorin stared into the darkness.

“That troubles me more than I care to admit.”

For several moments, the hobbit said nothing.

Then he drew his blanket more closely around himself.

“I think that's the cruelest thing about losing someone,” he said quietly. “Not that you stop loving them, but that you begin forgetting all the little things you thought you'd remember forever.”

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo watched the rain.

“My mother used to sing while she worked in the garden. Nothing particularly grand. Silly little songs, mostly. I remember the words to some of them, but sometimes I can't remember exactly how she sounded.”

He smiled sadly.

“And my father had this habit of tapping his fingers against the table whenever he was thinking. I used to find it terribly irritating.”

“Do you miss it?”

“Very much.”

Thorin regarded him with quiet understanding.

Bilbo turned toward him.

“I suppose that's why the memories we do have become so precious.”

“Yes,” Thorin said.

The rain continued around them.

After a while, Bilbo shifted closer, and Thorin rested his temple briefly against the hobbit's curls.

Neither spoke.

There was no need.

___________

 

By the fifth week, the eastern forests had begun to dominate the horizon.

The Company travelled through a region of low hills and scattered settlements, though they avoided most inhabited places. Gandalf warned that Azog's hunters might question travellers or watch the roads, and Thorin was unwilling to expose the Company unnecessarily.

Still, they occasionally encountered wandering merchants.

One afternoon, they crossed paths with a small caravan carrying wool, tools, and preserved food between distant villages.

The merchants were wary at first, but their manner changed when an elderly dwarf among them recognized Thorin.

“By Mahal,” he exclaimed. “Thorin Oakenshield?”

Thorin inclined his head.

The merchant bowed deeply.

They exchanged news and purchased supplies with what little coin remained. The merchant spoke eagerly of the scattered families of Durin's Folk, of rumours concerning Erebor, and of the hope that their king might someday return.

Then, with the cheerful boldness of an older dwarf who believed himself entitled to offer advice, he mentioned that several noble families would undoubtedly be delighted to discuss a suitable marriage once Thorin reclaimed his throne.

Bilbo, who had been examining a sack of dried apples, looked up.

A marriage?

He had never considered that.

Of course, Thorin was a king. Kings married. They had responsibilities, alliances, and all sorts of important matters that ordinary hobbits did not need to worry about.

It was perfectly sensible.

For some reason, Bilbo disliked the thought.

He disliked it even more when the merchant began listing the virtues of a particularly accomplished dwarven lady from the Iron Hills.

Thorin politely redirected the conversation.

Bilbo returned to the apples with rather more concentration than they deserved.

Later, as the Company resumed its journey, he found himself walking beside Thorin.

“May I ask you something?”

“Of course.”

“Do dwarven kings generally have to marry someone important?”

Thorin looked at him.

“Not necessarily.”

“Oh.”

They walked several steps.

“Why do you ask?”

“No particular reason.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“Indeed?”

“Well, that merchant seemed rather determined to find you a wife.”

“He did.”

“Does that happen often?”

“More often than I would prefer.”

Bilbo frowned.

“That sounds dreadful.”

“It can be tiresome.”

“Especially if you don't like the person.”

Thorin glanced down at him.

“Especially then.”

Bilbo appeared relieved.

Thorin studied him for a moment.

“And what of hobbits? Are marriages arranged among your people?”

“Good heavens, no. Well, families certainly have opinions, but I should think marrying someone simply because your relatives approved would be a dreadful mistake.”

“I agree.”

Bilbo looked up.

“You do?”

“Entirely.”

Something warm and inexplicable settled in Bilbo's chest.

He turned his attention back to the road before Thorin could notice his smile.

Thorin, meanwhile, was privately grateful that years of royal training had taught him how to maintain a composed expression.

He had faced the merchant's suggestions with admirable patience.

Bilbo's sudden interest in his marital prospects was considerably more difficult to endure.

___________

 

A few days later, Thorin and Fíli walked ahead of the Company, studying the route through a narrow valley.

The younger dwarf had been responsible for selecting their campsites for several weeks, and Thorin was pleased by the care with which he approached the task.

“We should cross the stream before sunset,” Fíli suggested. “The banks are lower farther north, but we'd lose half a day reaching them.”

Thorin examined the terrain.

“And if the water rises overnight?”

“Then we'll be on the safer side.”

“Good.”

Fíli smiled.

They continued in companionable silence.

Eventually, the younger dwarf glanced toward his uncle.

“May I ask you something?”

“You may.”

“When we reclaim Erebor, what do you think will be the hardest part?”

Thorin considered the question.

Once, he might have answered without hesitation.

Rebuilding the halls. Restoring the treasury. Negotiating with neighbouring kingdoms.

Now he understood that those things, difficult though they were, represented only part of the burden.

“Learning how to be a king in peace,” he answered.

Fíli looked surprised.

Thorin continued.

“We have spent so many years fighting to survive that we have forgotten what it means to live without an enemy before us. Erebor will need more than warriors. It will need patience, wisdom, and people willing to listen when others disagree.”

Fíli considered this.

“You've been doing more of that lately.”

Thorin glanced at him.

“Have I?”

“Yes.”

A small smile touched his nephew's mouth.

“It's rather strange.”

Thorin huffed.

“Thank you.”

“I didn't say it was bad.”

They walked a little farther.

Then Fíli spoke again.

“I think you'll be a good king.”

Thorin looked at him.

The words struck with unexpected force.

He remembered the king he had become in his first life.

The suspicion. The greed. The cruelty with which he had treated those who loved him.

And he remembered how close he had come to destroying everything he had fought to reclaim.

“I intend to try,” he said quietly.

Fíli nodded.

“That seems a good place to start.”

Thorin rested a hand briefly upon his shoulder.

He hoped his nephew would remember that lesson when his own time came to rule.

___________

 

The conversation that stayed with Bilbo most happened several evenings later.

They were walking behind the Company, following a narrow trail through golden grass beneath a sky streaked with the colours of sunset.

The air smelled of dry leaves and distant rain.

Bilbo had been telling Thorin about the Shire.

Not the grand parts, for there were no grand parts by dwarven standards, but the ordinary things he loved.

The market at Hobbiton. The view from Bag End in spring. The peculiar habits of his neighbours and the endless disagreements among the Baggins relations.

Thorin listened with an attention Bilbo found increasingly pleasant.

“And what will you do,” the hobbit asked eventually, “when Erebor is yours again?”

Thorin looked toward the eastern horizon.

“There will be much to rebuild.”

He spoke of the ruined halls, the forges that had stood silent for decades, the scattered families who might finally return, and the alliances that would need restoring.

He spoke of Fíli's education and Kíli's future, of Dís and the possibility of bringing his sister home.

Bilbo listened.

It was a great deal of responsibility.

More than he could imagine carrying.

“And after all that?” he asked.

Thorin smiled faintly.

“I imagine there will always be more to do.”

“That sounds exhausting.”

“It may be.”

Bilbo considered him.

“Will you ever have time to leave?”

“Leave?”

“Erebor. Just for a little while.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“Why?”

Bilbo suddenly found the question rather difficult.

“Well, I was thinking that perhaps you might visit the Shire someday.”

Thorin stopped walking.

Bilbo took another step before noticing.

He turned.

“Only if you wanted to, of course. I know you'll be terribly busy, and it's a very long journey, and I wouldn't expect you to—”

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit fell silent.

Thorin regarded him with an expression so gentle that Bilbo felt unexpectedly warm.

“If you invited me, I would come.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Even with all your responsibilities?”

“I believe I could find time.”

“Oh.”

Thorin smiled.

“And would you visit Erebor?”

Bilbo considered the question.

He imagined the great halls Thorin had described, the restored gardens, the sound of hammers ringing through the mountain.

He imagined Fíli and Kíli greeting him at the gates, Balin showing him the libraries, and Bombur insisting that he taste every dish prepared in the royal kitchens.

Then he imagined Thorin waiting for him.

The thought made him smile.

“I suppose I might.”

“You would always be welcome.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Always?”

“Always.”

For several moments, they stood facing one another while the evening wind moved through the grass.

Then Bilbo smiled.

“I should like that very much.”

Thorin offered him his arm as they resumed walking.

Bilbo took it without hesitation.

Neither noticed that they had fallen several minutes behind the others.

Or perhaps they noticed and simply did not care.

That night, Bilbo lay awake beneath his blanket, thinking about Bag End.

He pictured his garden, his bookshelves, and the familiar green door.

He had spent weeks dreaming of returning home.

Yet when he imagined sitting alone at his kitchen table, the picture felt strangely incomplete.

He tried adding Gandalf.

That helped a little.

Then he imagined Thorin sitting opposite him, drinking tea and looking faintly disapproving of the low ceiling.

Bilbo smiled into his blanket.

Yes.

That was better.

He fell asleep wondering when, exactly, he had begun planning his future around the possibility of a dwarf king visiting for breakfast.

__________

 

The sixth week brought the first unmistakable signs of pursuit.

Dwalin discovered tracks beside a shallow stream.

They were broad, clawed impressions pressed deep into the mud.

Wargs.

Fíli found more the following morning, accompanied by bootprints that could only belong to orcs.

The hunters were still some distance behind them, but they were moving east.

Thorin studied the tracks in silence.

Azog had not forgotten him.

Of course he had not.

“We need to increase our pace,” he said.

Gandalf nodded grimly.

“And I know someone who may offer us shelter.”

Dwalin looked up.

“Who?”

“A man named Beorn.”

Thorin felt the familiar tightening of recognition.

Beorn.

The enormous skin-changer whose home stood near the borders of Mirkwood.

In his first life, they had survived the night beneath his roof and eventually earned his hospitality.

Thorin remembered his strength, his hatred of orcs, and the great black bear that prowled his lands.

He also remembered how dangerous it had been to arrive uninvited.

“A friend of yours?” Bilbo asked.

“An acquaintance,” Gandalf replied.

“That's not quite the same thing.”

“No, indeed.”

They continued walking.

Bilbo waited.

Eventually, he sighed.

“Is there something else we ought to know about this acquaintance?”

Gandalf adjusted his hat.

“He is a skin-changer.”

Bilbo frowned.

“A what?”

“A man who can take the form of a bear.”

The hobbit stopped.

“A bear?”

“A very large bear.”

Bilbo looked toward Thorin.

The dwarf's expression remained suspiciously composed.

“So,” Bilbo said slowly, “we're going to ask an enormous bear for somewhere to sleep?”

“He is generally a man during the day,” Gandalf explained.

“Oh. Well, that's rather better.”

“Though it would be wise not to approach him while he is in his other form.”

Bilbo considered this.

“And how, precisely, are we supposed to arrange that?”

Gandalf did not answer immediately.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“I thought so.”

They reached Beorn's lands on a moonless evening.

The forest had grown dense around them, its trees tall and dark, their branches woven together overhead. The air carried the smell of damp earth and fallen leaves, and somewhere beyond the undergrowth a stream moved quietly through the darkness.

The Company had been travelling since dawn.

Everyone was tired.

Even Kíli had stopped complaining.

Thorin walked near the rear beside Bilbo, keeping one hand close to Orcrist.

He remembered this country.

Remembered the distant outline of Beorn's house, the enormous wooden doors, and the dreadful sound of the bear approaching through the trees.

He had hoped to reach the house before nightfall.

They had not.

A low growl rolled through the forest.

Every dwarf stopped.

Bilbo turned slowly.

“What was that?”

Nobody answered.

Then something enormous moved among the trees.

Branches cracked.

A dark shape emerged from the undergrowth, taller than any ordinary bear Bilbo had ever imagined.

Its black fur gleamed faintly beneath the starlight, and its eyes reflected the distant glow of the sky.

For one terrible moment, the creature simply stared at them.

Bilbo felt his stomach drop.

“Oh,” he whispered.

The bear roared.

“RUN!” Gandalf shouted.

The Company scattered along the path.

Thorin seized Bilbo's hand and pulled him forward as the enormous creature crashed through the trees behind them.

The ground seemed to tremble beneath its weight.

Branches snapped.

Someone shouted that they could see the house.

Bilbo ran as fast as his short legs would carry him, his lungs burning and his heart hammering against his ribs.

Ahead, an enormous wooden building appeared beyond the trees.

Its roof rose high above the surrounding fields, and warm light shone faintly through its windows.

“The doors!” Dwalin roared.

Fíli and Kíli reached them first, throwing their weight against the heavy timber.

The doors swung inward.

Dwarves poured into the house.

Thorin remained beside Bilbo, refusing to release his hand.

“Go!” he urged.

Bilbo stumbled over a root.

Thorin caught him before he fell.

Behind them, the bear roared again.

They reached the threshold just as Dwalin shouted for the doors to be closed.

Thorin pushed Bilbo inside and followed.

The enormous doors slammed shut.

A heartbeat later, something massive struck them from outside.

The entire house shook.

Bilbo staggered backward.

Bombur sat down rather abruptly.

Dwalin and Glóin braced themselves against the timber while Gandalf raised his staff.

Another heavy impact rattled the hinges.

Then silence.

For several moments, nobody moved.

Bilbo stared at the doors.

His face was pale.

His curls were dishevelled.

He looked toward Gandalf.

“You did mention he was a bear.”

Gandalf adjusted his hat.

“Yes, well. I had rather hoped we would meet him under different circumstances.”

Bilbo opened his mouth.

Closed it.

Then turned toward Thorin.

“Your wizard has a remarkable talent for understating things.”

Thorin, despite the danger, began to laugh.

It escaped him before he could stop it.

A warm, genuine laugh that made Bilbo stare.

Then the hobbit smiled too.

Thorin looked at him, still holding his hand, and felt the familiar, impossible tenderness rise within him.

Six weeks.

They had spent six more weeks together.

Six weeks of shared meals, quiet conversations, laughter, and small kindnesses.

Six weeks in which Bilbo had begun reaching for him without hesitation.

And Thorin was beginning to suspect that the greatest danger awaiting him in Beorn's house might not be the enormous bear outside.

It might be the simple prospect of spending another evening close enough to Bilbo Baggins to remember exactly how badly he wanted to kiss him.

He released the hobbit's hand before that thought became visible upon his face.

Bilbo, apparently unaware of the dwarf's predicament, was examining the enormous room with growing interest.

“Well,” he said, “at least it's dry.”

Bofur laughed.

“Always looking on the bright side, eh, lad?”

“Someone has to.”

The Company gradually settled inside the unfamiliar house, keeping a wary distance from the doors. The room was enormous, furnished with heavy wooden tables, benches, and great carved pillars. Bundles of herbs hung from the rafters, and the air smelled faintly of honey, woodsmoke, and fresh hay.

Bilbo noticed the smell immediately.

“Is that bread?”

Bombur lifted his head.

“Where?”

Thorin shook his head fondly.

Outside, the bear moved through the darkness.

For the moment, at least, they were safe.

__________

 

The night passed uneasily.

They dared not explore too far into their host's home, though Gandalf assured them that Beorn would be far more dangerous if they attempted to flee into the forest.

The dwarves arranged themselves near the hearth, using their cloaks as bedding. A few remained awake on watch, listening for movement outside.

Bilbo sat beside Thorin upon a broad wooden bench.

He had found a small comb in his pack and was attempting to untangle his curls.

Thorin watched with quiet amusement.

“You'll pull half your hair out.”

“It's already halfway there.”

“Would you like assistance?”

Bilbo glanced at him.

“Are you offering to comb my hair?”

“If necessary.”

The hobbit smiled.

“I think I can manage.”

He worked at a particularly stubborn knot, then looked toward Thorin's hair.

“Yours has come loose again.”

Thorin touched the braid near his temple.

It had indeed begun to unravel during their flight.

Bilbo considered it.

“I could fix it for you.”

Thorin's heart gave an entirely unreasonable leap.

“Now?”

“Well, unless you'd prefer to wait until morning.”

The dwarf glanced toward the others.

Most were settling down. Dwalin was speaking quietly with Balin, and Fíli had already begun arranging blankets for Kíli.

Thorin looked back at Bilbo.

“Perhaps tomorrow.”

Bilbo nodded.

“Of course.”

He returned to his curls.

Thorin watched him for another moment before looking away.

Tomorrow, then.

He had survived goblins, orcs, and the claws of Azog.

Surely he could survive having Bilbo Baggins braid his hair.

Though as he watched the hobbit lean closer to examine the loose strands beside his temple, Thorin began to suspect that his confidence might be misplaced.

Dawn arrived slowly over Beorn's lands.

The first light crept through the tall windows, illuminating the wooden beams and the sleeping Company.

Outside, birds began calling among the trees.

Bilbo woke beneath Thorin's cloak, which had somehow found its way over him during the night.

He sat up, blinking.

Thorin was already awake.

Of course he was.

The dwarf stood near the hearth, speaking quietly with Gandalf.

Bilbo watched him for a moment.

His dark hair had come almost entirely loose from its braids, falling around his shoulders in heavy, slightly tangled waves.

Bilbo smiled to himself.

He would have to do something about that.

Then a heavy sound came from beyond the doors.

Footsteps.

Slow, deliberate, and approaching.

Gandalf stopped speaking.

Thorin turned.

One by one, the dwarves began waking.

The great doors opened.

An enormous man stood upon the threshold.

He was broad-shouldered and powerfully built, with thick dark hair and a beard that framed a distinctly unfriendly face. His eyes moved slowly across the room, taking in the scattered blankets, the dying fire, the weapons, and the unexpected collection of travellers occupying his home.

Thirteen dwarves.

One wizard.

One hobbit.

The man's expression darkened.

“Who are you,” he asked, his deep voice filling the room, “and what are you doing in my house?”

Bilbo glanced toward Thorin.

Thorin straightened, every inch the king.

Gandalf stepped forward with what Bilbo considered an altogether suspiciously cheerful smile.

“Good morning, Beorn.”

The enormous man looked at him.

Then at the dwarves.

Then at Bilbo.

His eyes narrowed.

And Bilbo Baggins, who had spent six weeks growing increasingly certain that the world contained nothing more alarming than goblins, wargs, and angry dwarven kings, began to wonder whether he had been rather optimistic.

Beside him, Thorin rested a reassuring hand against his shoulder.

Bilbo looked up.

Thorin offered him the smallest of smiles.

Whatever happened next, they would face it together.

And for reasons Bilbo was not yet ready to examine, that thought made the enormous stranger standing in the doorway seem just a little less frightening.

Chapter 8: Chapter Eight — The Warmth Before the Dark

Chapter Text

Beorn was not pleased to discover fifteen strangers in his house.

This became apparent almost immediately.

The enormous man stood in the doorway, his broad shoulders nearly filling the entrance, while his dark eyes travelled from the scattered blankets to the weapons stacked beside the hearth. His gaze lingered upon the enormous table, where Bombur had been examining a wooden bowl with the hopeful expression of someone who suspected it might once have contained food.

“Thieves,” Beorn said.

Bilbo straightened.

“Well, technically—”

Thorin placed a hand upon his shoulder.

Bilbo closed his mouth.

Gandalf, apparently untroubled by the possibility of being thrown bodily out of the house, smiled beneath his hat.

“Not thieves, my good Beorn. Merely travellers in rather desperate circumstances.”

“Travellers who broke into my home.”

“The doors were unlocked.”

“They were closed.”

“A fortunate distinction, considering what was pursuing us.”

Beorn's expression darkened.

“What was pursuing you?”

“A bear,” Bilbo answered before anyone could stop him.

Silence followed.

Beorn slowly turned his head toward the hobbit.

“A bear?”

“An extraordinarily large one,” Bilbo clarified. “Though I suppose you would know more about that than I would.”

Kíli made a strangled noise behind his hand.

Gandalf closed his eyes briefly.

Thorin wondered whether it was possible to die of affectionate exasperation.

Beorn studied Bilbo for several long moments. Then, to everyone's astonishment, one corner of his mouth twitched.

“You have a sharp tongue for something so small.”

“I've been told that before.”

“And what are you?”

“A hobbit.”

“A hobbit,” Beorn repeated, as though considering whether the word described a particularly unusual kind of rabbit.

Bilbo drew himself up.

“Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

Beorn looked toward Gandalf.

“And these?”

“Dwarves. Thirteen of them, including Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thráin.”

Recognition flickered across Beorn's face, though it brought little warmth.

“Dwarves,” he muttered. “I have no great love for dwarves.”

“Nor do I expect you to,” Thorin answered.

The calmness of his response surprised several members of the Company.

Thorin stepped forward, inclining his head with the dignity of a king addressing another master beneath his own roof.

“We entered without permission because our lives were in danger. For that, I offer my apologies. We have no wish to trouble you.”

Beorn regarded him suspiciously.

“And what danger brings the son of Thráin wandering through my lands?”

“Orcs,” Thorin replied. “Led by Azog the Defiler.”

The change was immediate.

Beorn's expression hardened, his great hands curling slowly at his sides.

“Azog?”

“He hunts us,” Thorin said. “His wargs followed us from the mountains.”

Beorn was silent for a long time.

Then he stepped aside.

“You will tell me everything.”

Gandalf smiled.

“Certainly. Though perhaps we might do so over breakfast?”

Beorn stared at him.

From somewhere behind Thorin, Bombur's stomach growled with such impressive volume that even Dwalin turned to look.

Beorn's mouth twitched again.

“Come, then.”

__________

 

By the time Gandalf finished recounting their escape from Goblin-town, the Company had been provided with a meal so magnificent that Bilbo briefly considered abandoning the Quest and taking up permanent residence beneath Beorn's roof.

There was fresh bread, still warm from the oven, accompanied by bowls of golden honey and thick butter. There were apples, berries, cheese, steaming porridge, vegetables, and pitchers of fresh milk.

Bilbo stared at the table.

He had nearly forgotten what proper food looked like.

“Is that butter?” Kíli whispered.

Fíli looked at him.

“Yes.”

“Real butter?”

“No, Kíli. It's an elaborate deception.”

Kíli ignored him.

“And fresh bread.”

“Yes.”

“And honey!”

Bofur leaned across the table, looking equally overwhelmed.

“If you start crying, lad, I won't judge you. I nearly did when I saw the cheese.”

Bombur, already chewing, nodded solemnly.

Bilbo took a thick slice of bread, spread it generously with butter, and added a little honey.

He took one bite.

His eyes closed.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Thorin glanced at him.

“Enjoying yourself?”

Bilbo opened his eyes.

“Thorin, if you interrupt this moment, I may never forgive you.”

The dwarf laughed softly.

Beorn, seated at the head of the table, watched the exchange with an expression of increasing bewilderment.

“Have you people not eaten?”

“Not properly,” Bofur answered, reaching for another piece of bread, “since we left Rivendell.”

“Six weeks,” Bilbo supplied mournfully.

“Six weeks?” Beorn repeated.

“Of roots, dried meat, suspicious mushrooms, and bread hard enough to kill someone if thrown with sufficient force.”

“Those mushrooms were perfectly safe,” Bombur protested.

“One of them made Nori's tongue turn blue.”

“It was only blue for an afternoon,” Nori replied.

Beorn stared at them.

Then he laughed.

It was a deep, rumbling sound, surprising enough that Ori nearly dropped his spoon.

Thorin watched Bilbo return happily to his breakfast.

When the hobbit noticed that Thorin's plate was nearly empty, he placed another slice of bread upon it without asking.

“Eat,” Bilbo murmured.

Thorin accepted it.

Beorn noticed that too.

He said nothing, but his eyes lingered thoughtfully upon them.

Beorn allowed them to remain for several days.

He was not particularly friendly toward the dwarves at first, but his hatred of orcs outweighed his suspicion, and Gandalf's account of their journey interested him greatly. After questioning Thorin and the others, he disappeared for much of the first day, returning with confirmation that goblins and wargs had indeed been moving through the surrounding country.

He was less suspicious after that.

___________

 

The Company, meanwhile, discovered that Beorn's hospitality extended beyond food.

There were clean places to sleep.

There were towels.

There was soap.

And, most astonishing of all, there was hot water.

Kíli discovered this last blessing shortly before midday.

“FÍLI!”

His brother appeared in the doorway almost immediately, one hand already reaching for a weapon.

“What happened?”

Kíli stood beside a great wooden bathing tub, staring into it.

“It's warm.”

Fíli blinked.

“What?”

“The water. It's warm.”

“Yes, Kíli. That's generally the purpose of heating it.”

“We haven't had warm water in weeks!”

Bofur appeared behind them.

“Did someone say warm water?”

From farther along the passage came Bilbo's delighted voice.

“AND THERE'S SOAP!”

Fíli closed his eyes.

For the first time in weeks, he was beginning to suspect that the Company might actually be happy.

The baths quickly became the most popular attraction in Beorn's enormous house.

Even Dwalin, who declared that he had never required anything more elaborate than a river and a reasonably clean cloth, emerged from his bath looking considerably less murderous.

Bofur spent so long soaking that Bombur threatened to eat his portion of lunch.

Kíli used an impressive quantity of soap, then emerged with his hair standing in several improbable directions.

Fíli took one look at him and laughed so hard that he had to sit down.

Bilbo, however, was the undisputed champion of bathing.

He sank into the warm water with a sigh so heartfelt that it might have been mistaken for a prayer.

The tub was enormous by hobbit standards. He could stretch his legs comfortably, and the water smelled faintly of herbs.

For the first time since Rivendell, there was no icy stream beneath his feet, no rain running down his collar, and no possibility of an orc appearing halfway through washing his hair.

He intended to enjoy every moment.

Nearly an hour later, someone knocked.

“Master Baggins?” Bofur called.

“I'm alive!”

“You've been in there nearly an hour!”

“And I intend to remain here until I become a prune!”

“Thorin wants to know whether you're coming to supper.”

There was a pause.

Then a tremendous splash.

“WHY DIDN'T YOU SAY THAT FIRST?”

__________

 

Thorin had endured many difficult things in his life.

The destruction of Erebor. Exile. Hunger. War. The deaths of those he loved.

He had faced a dragon and an orc chieftain, and he had looked death in the face more than once.

None of those experiences had prepared him for Bilbo Baggins emerging from a warm bath.

The hobbit appeared in the great hall wearing freshly washed clothes, his curls softer and more unruly than usual. His cheeks were pink from the heat, and he smelled faintly of soap and the herbs Beorn kept beside the bathing tubs.

He looked comfortable.

Happy.

Entirely too lovely.

Thorin forgot what Balin had been saying.

“Thorin?”

“Hm?”

Balin followed his gaze.

Understanding dawned.

“Ah.”

Thorin turned sharply.

“Don't.”

“I haven't said anything.”

“Keep it that way.”

Balin smiled into his beard.

Bilbo approached them.

“There you are!”

Thorin straightened.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked at him, then frowned.

“Your braids have come undone.”

Thorin's hand rose instinctively toward his hair.

He had washed it earlier, and the loose strands now fell around his shoulders.

“So they have.”

“You promised I could fix them.”

“I did.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Well, come along, then.”

Thorin glanced toward Balin.

His old friend looked positively delighted.

Traitor.

___________

 

They found a quiet corner near one of the tall windows, where the late afternoon sunlight fell across a broad wooden bench.

Most of the Company remained occupied elsewhere. Kíli and Bofur were arguing over whose bath had been more luxurious, while Bombur was attempting to discover whether Beorn had any more honey cakes.

Thorin sat down.

Bilbo stood before him with his small comb and a length of dark thread.

“Hold still.”

“I am holding still.”

“You haven't started moving yet.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo smiled and began separating the hair beside his temple.

The first touch of his fingers was gentle.

Familiar.

Thorin had grown accustomed to Bilbo tending his braids during their journey, but the intimacy of it had never become ordinary.

And today, with the hobbit standing directly before him, it was considerably worse.

Bilbo leaned closer to examine a stubborn tangle.

Thorin stopped breathing.

This was becoming a problem.

A rather serious problem.

The hobbit's fingers brushed his cheek as he carefully separated another strand. His curls fell forward, catching the afternoon light, and Thorin could see the little flecks of gold within his hazel eyes.

He wondered whether Mahal had given him a second life merely to test the limits of his self-control.

“Thorin?”

“Hm?”

“Your hair is much easier to manage when it's clean.”

“Is it?”

“Yes. Though it's still terribly thick.”

Thorin made a noncommittal sound.

Bilbo frowned.

“You're very quiet.”

“Am I?”

“Usually you have something to say about how I'm doing it.”

“You are doing it perfectly.”

Bilbo smiled.

Mahal help me.

“Well, that's a first.”

Thorin's gaze dropped, quite involuntarily, to the hobbit's mouth.

He wondered how long a dwarf could reasonably be expected to endure this before kissing someone.

A minute?

Ten?

He had already survived considerably longer than seemed fair.

Bilbo leaned closer again.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“You're staring.”

“I was thinking.”

“About what?”

About kissing you until neither of us remembers why you came over here in the first place.

“The road to Mirkwood.”

Bilbo paused.

“That must be a very interesting road.”

Thorin nearly laughed.

Instead, he looked down at his hands and attempted to summon some fragment of royal dignity.

Bilbo resumed his work.

For several minutes, the only sounds were the distant conversation of the Company and the quiet movements of the animals outside.

Then Bilbo's fingers brushed Thorin's cheek again.

This time, they lingered.

Thorin looked up.

Bilbo was already looking at him.

Their faces were close enough that Thorin could see the faint blush rising beneath the hobbit's freckles.

For a moment, neither moved.

Thorin's heart beat heavily against his ribs.

He could kiss him.

It would take scarcely any movement at all.

He remembered another lifetime, another terrible moment, when he had finally confessed his love with blood upon his lips and death approaching.

He remembered Bilbo's tears.

The words they had exchanged.

The kiss they had never been given time to share.

But this Bilbo did not remember any of that.

He was discovering his feelings for the first time, and Thorin would not steal the choice from him merely because he already knew what his own heart wanted.

So he remained still.

Bilbo swallowed.

“I think,” the hobbit said softly, “I ought to finish this.”

Thorin's mouth curved.

“Probably.”

Bilbo looked down, smiling despite himself.

He completed the first braid and moved to the other side, his fingers slightly less steady than before.

When he finally stepped back, he examined his work with satisfaction.

“There.”

Thorin reached up to touch the neat braids.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo tilted his head.

“They suit you.”

“Do they?”

“Very much.”

The hobbit smiled.

“You look rather handsome.”

Silence.

Bilbo's eyes widened.

Thorin stared at him.

The colour in Bilbo's cheeks deepened spectacularly.

“I mean—well, obviously, you always look perfectly respectable, but the braids make you look particularly—oh, bother.”

Thorin's smile became impossible to suppress.

“Handsome?”

Bilbo covered his face with one hand.

“Please forget I said that.”

“I don't believe I can.”

“Thorin.”

“It was a very kind compliment.”

Bilbo peeked at him through his fingers.

The dwarf's expression was warm, entirely without mockery.

Slowly, Bilbo lowered his hand.

“Well,” he murmured, “it was true.”

Thorin felt something inside his chest soften.

“Then I shall treasure it.”

Bilbo smiled.

And Thorin decided, with considerable resignation, that he was utterly lost.

___________

 

That evening, Beorn found Thorin outside near the gardens.

The enormous man had been tending to his animals, speaking to them with a gentleness that seemed almost impossible to reconcile with the terrifying creature that had pursued the Company through the darkness.

Thorin stood beside the fence, watching the distant treeline.

“The little one,” Beorn said suddenly.

Thorin turned.

“Bilbo?”

“Is he yours?”

Thorin's expression sharpened.

“He belongs to no one.”

Beorn regarded him.

“That wasn't what I asked.”

Thorin said nothing.

The skin-changer leaned against the fence.

“He's a curious creature. Spent half the morning speaking to my horses. Asked whether the bees ever grew tired of making honey.”

Despite himself, Thorin smiled.

“That sounds like him.”

“He's brave, too. Not many small creatures would stand in front of me and argue about breakfast.”

“He is braver than most people realize.”

Beorn studied him for a moment.

“You care for him.”

Thorin looked toward the house.

Through one of the windows, he could see Bilbo laughing at something Bofur had said.

“Yes,” he answered quietly.

Beorn followed his gaze.

“Then keep him close. The forest ahead is no place for the careless.”

Thorin's smile faded.

“I know.”

___________

 

On their final full day beneath Beorn's roof, the conversation turned toward Mirkwood.

Beorn spread a rough map across the table, his enormous finger tracing the path that led into the forest.

“You must remain on the road,” he warned. “Do not leave it, no matter what you hear or see. There are things beneath those trees that have forgotten the ways of the world outside.”

Bilbo studied the dark shape of the forest upon the map.

“And the spiders?”

“Large enough to make a meal of you,” Beorn answered.

Bilbo looked distinctly unhappy.

“Wonderful.”

“There is a stream you must not drink from,” Beorn continued. “Its waters carry enchantment. Keep your senses about you, and do not wander.”

Thorin listened carefully.

He remembered the darkness beneath those trees.

The hunger.

The spiders.

The terrible moments when he had believed he might lose members of his Company forever.

This time, he intended to be prepared.

He discussed watches with Fíli, checked their provisions, and ensured that everyone understood the importance of remaining together.

Then Gandalf announced that he would not accompany them all the way through Mirkwood.

The Company reacted with predictable outrage.

“You're leaving us?” Kíli demanded.

“I have business elsewhere,” Gandalf replied.

“Convenient business,” Dwalin muttered.

“Necessary business.”

Thorin said little.

He had known this moment would come.

But knowing did not make it easier.

Bilbo noticed the tension in his shoulders.

Later, when the others were occupied, he approached the dwarf quietly.

“Are you worried?”

Thorin looked down at him.

“Yes.”

Bilbo seemed surprised by the honesty.

“About the forest?”

“Among other things.”

The hobbit considered him.

Then he rested a hand briefly upon Thorin's arm.

“We've managed rather well so far.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“We have.”

“And I don't intend to let a few spiders spoil everything.”

“A few?”

“Well, I sincerely hope there won't be more than a few.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo grinned, pleased with himself.

It was becoming one of his favourite sounds.

____________

 

The final evening arrived warm and quiet.

Beorn provided another generous supper, and the Company ate with the enthusiasm of travellers who knew that their next meals would be considerably less pleasant.

Kíli declared that he intended to remember the taste of Beorn's honey for the rest of his life.

Bofur announced that he would compose a song about the baths.

Dwalin threatened to throw him into the nearest river if he did.

Bombur asked whether there would be breakfast before they departed.

Beorn assured him there would.

The entire table seemed relieved.

Afterward, the Company gradually retired to their beds.

Bilbo lingered near the hearth for a while, watching the flames settle into glowing embers.

Then he noticed that Thorin was missing.

He found him outside beneath the stars.

The night air was cool, carrying the scent of flowers and fresh grass. Beyond the fields, Mirkwood stretched across the horizon like an enormous dark shadow.

Bilbo approached quietly.

“Thinking about tomorrow?”

Thorin turned.

“Yes.”

Bilbo joined him beside the fence.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then the hobbit sighed.

“I suppose I ought to admit something.”

Thorin looked at him.

“I'm frightened.”

There was no shame in the words, only quiet honesty.

Thorin regarded him gently.

“So am I.”

Bilbo blinked.

“You?”

“Of course.”

“But you've faced dragons.”

“Not successfully enough to recommend the experience.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

Thorin turned toward him.

“Courage is not the absence of fear, Bilbo. You have proved that more times than I can count.”

The hobbit looked down at his hands.

“I don't always feel brave.”

“You needn't.”

Bilbo raised his eyes.

Thorin continued quietly.

“You need only remember that you are not alone.”

For a moment, Bilbo simply looked at him.

Then he stepped closer.

Thorin remained still as the hobbit took his hand.

Bilbo's fingers curled gently around his own.

And then, with a small, almost shy movement, Bilbo leaned forward and rested his forehead against Thorin's.

The dwarf closed his eyes.

The gesture was so simple.

So trusting.

And it nearly undid him.

He could feel the warmth of Bilbo's breath, the softness of his curls, the gentle pressure of his hand.

For one extraordinary moment, the world seemed to narrow to the space between them.

Thorin wanted to kiss him.

He wanted it with an intensity that made his chest ache.

But Bilbo was here, alive and safe, choosing to stand close to him beneath the stars.

For now, that was enough.

Thorin squeezed his hand.

Bilbo remained where he was for several heartbeats longer.

When they finally drew apart, the hobbit's cheeks were pink.

“Well,” Bilbo murmured.

Thorin smiled.

“Well.”

Bilbo laughed quietly.

“We should probably go inside.”

“Probably.”

Neither moved immediately.

Then Bilbo gave his hand one final squeeze and turned toward the house.

Thorin followed.

___________

 

Inside, the great hall had grown quiet.

Kíli was already asleep, sprawled across his bedding with one arm hanging over the edge. Fíli had apparently attempted to straighten his blanket before surrendering to exhaustion himself.

Bofur was still awake, though barely.

“Best bread I've ever tasted,” he murmured as Bilbo passed.

Bilbo smiled.

“Goodnight, Bofur.”

“Best bath, too.”

Then he fell asleep.

Bombur was snoring softly nearby.

Dwalin sat beside the dying fire, sharpening a blade with slow, deliberate movements. He glanced up as Thorin and Bilbo entered together.

His eyes moved briefly to their joined hands.

Then he returned to his work.

Balin, already settled beneath his blanket, smiled to himself.

Bilbo released Thorin's hand reluctantly when they reached their sleeping places.

“Goodnight,” he said.

“Goodnight, Bilbo.”

The hobbit hesitated.

Then he smiled.

“And thank you.”

Thorin tilted his head.

“For what?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“For making all of this a little less frightening.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“You have done much the same for me.”

Bilbo's smile widened.

He settled into his bed, drawing the warm blankets around himself.

Thorin remained standing for a moment, watching him.

Then he turned toward his own resting place.

The house gradually fell silent.

___________

 

Outside, the stars shone above the fields, and the dark forest waited beyond the horizon.

Bilbo lay beneath his blankets, thinking about Thorin's smile.

About the warmth of his hands.

About the way the dwarf had looked at him while he braided his hair.

And, most troublingly, about how close their faces had been.

He turned onto his side.

He wondered what might have happened if he had leaned just a little closer.

The thought made his heart beat faster.

____________

 

Across the room, Thorin lay awake, staring into the darkness.

He remembered Bilbo's fingers against his cheek.

The shy compliment.

The gentle pressure of their foreheads beneath the stars.

He had loved Bilbo Baggins once before.

He had loved him through hardship, through betrayal and forgiveness, through the terrible final moments of his first life.

But this was different.

This time, he was being given the extraordinary privilege of watching Bilbo discover him.

And perhaps, if fate allowed it, of being loved in return without death waiting at the end of the road.

Thorin closed his eyes.

Tomorrow, they would enter Mirkwood.

There would be darkness ahead, and danger, and choices he could not yet predict.

But tonight, Bilbo was safe.

His nephews were alive.

His Company slept beneath a warm roof, their stomachs full and their spirits restored.

And somewhere across the quiet room, the hobbit he loved was smiling into his pillow, wondering why he suddenly wished he had kissed him.

Neither knew the other's thoughts.

Eventually, beneath Beorn's sheltering roof, they both fell asleep.

For one last night, the world was kind.

Chapter 9: Chapter Nine — Beneath the Greenwood's Shadow

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins had never considered himself particularly sentimental about breakfast.

He had always appreciated a good one, naturally. Indeed, he considered breakfast among the most important accomplishments of civilized society, second only to second breakfast and perhaps a properly prepared afternoon tea. But until that morning, he had never experienced the profound sorrow of knowing that a perfectly respectable breakfast might be his last for several weeks.

He regarded the remains of Beorn's magnificent table with genuine grief.

“It's a terrible shame,” he murmured, spreading honey over another slice of warm bread.

“What is?” Bofur asked.

“That we cannot take the table with us.”

Bofur considered the enormous piece of furniture, then glanced toward Bombur.

“Between the three of us, we might manage it.”

“Absolutely not,” Fíli said without looking up.

“We haven't even tried,” Kíli protested.

“We are not carrying a table through Mirkwood.”

“Not the whole table,” Bofur said reasonably. “Just the part with the food.”

Across from them, Beorn made a sound suspiciously like a laugh.

Thorin sat beside Bilbo, listening to the conversation with quiet amusement. His hair was neatly braided, the dark strands falling over his shoulders in a fashion that had become increasingly familiar to the Company. Bilbo noticed that the braid nearest his temple had survived the night without a single loose strand and looked rather pleased with himself.

Thorin caught his glance.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“You're smiling.”

“Am I not allowed?”

“Of course you are.”

“Then I shall continue.”

Thorin smiled in return, and Bilbo found himself suddenly very interested in his bread.

__________

 

It had been an extraordinarily pleasant stay. Three days of warm meals, clean clothes, comfortable beds, and the reassuring knowledge that the roof above their heads was unlikely to collapse because a goblin had decided to pull the wrong lever.

Bilbo had slept better than he had in weeks.

So had most of the Company.

Even Dwalin appeared marginally less inclined to threaten everyone within hearing distance.

But beyond Beorn's fields waited Mirkwood.

And the morning's happiness could not entirely disguise the knowledge that they were about to enter it.

Beorn accompanied them partway toward the forest, his great strides carrying him easily alongside the ponies he had provided.

He had supplied them generously with food, water, and equipment, though he made it clear that the animals were not to be taken beneath the trees.

“They know the way home,” he told Thorin. “Release them at the forest's edge.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“You have my word.”

Beorn studied him for a moment.

“Keep your people on the path, Oakenshield.”

“I intend to.”

“Intention is not always enough.”

Thorin met his gaze.

“No,” he answered quietly. “It is not.”

Beorn seemed satisfied by that response.

Before departing, he crouched slightly to address Bilbo, who was adjusting the straps of his pack.

“And you, little burglar. Try not to get eaten.”

Bilbo looked up.

“I shall make every effort.”

“Good.”

Beorn straightened.

“There's courage in you. Don't let the forest convince you otherwise.”

Bilbo blinked, unexpectedly touched.

“Thank you.”

The enormous man gave a short nod and turned toward home.

They watched him go until the hills swallowed his figure.

Then the Company continued east.

__________

 

By midday, the trees of Mirkwood rose before them.

Bilbo had seen forests before. He had wandered through the woods around Hobbiton, admired the beautiful groves of Rivendell, and travelled beneath ancient branches during their long journey.

But this was different.

The trees were enormous, their trunks dark and twisted, their branches woven together so tightly that the sunlight seemed reluctant to enter. Thick roots rose from the ground like the backs of sleeping creatures, and a heavy silence hung beneath the leaves.

The forest did not appear to welcome visitors.

Bilbo drew closer to Thorin.

“It's rather gloomy.”

“Indeed.”

“I don't suppose there's another way around?”

“Not one that would bring us to Erebor in time.”

Bilbo sighed.

“I thought not.”

Gandalf stood at the beginning of the narrow path, his expression unusually grave.

“This is where I must leave you.”

The protests began immediately.

“You cannot be serious,” Glóin said.

“Now?” Kíli demanded.

“In front of that?” Bofur added, gesturing toward the forest.

Gandalf raised a hand.

“I have matters of great importance to attend to. You must continue without me.”

Bilbo looked distinctly unhappy.

“But you said you'd help us reach the mountain.”

“And I have helped you come this far.”

“That's not quite the same thing.”

“No,” Gandalf admitted. “It isn't.”

Thorin remained silent until the others had finished arguing.

Then he approached the wizard.

“A word.”

Gandalf followed him a short distance from the Company.

“You are taking this rather well,” he observed.

“I know you must go.”

The wizard studied him.

“Do you?”

Thorin looked toward the dark canopy.

“The Necromancer is not a threat to be underestimated.”

Gandalf's expression sharpened.

“You speak as though you know what awaits me.”

“I know enough to fear it.”

“And how, Thorin, have you come by such knowledge?”

Thorin said nothing.

For a moment, the wizard seemed prepared to press him further.

Instead, he sighed.

“You have changed, my friend. I cannot decide whether that should comfort me or concern me.”

“Perhaps both.”

Gandalf's eyes softened.

“You cannot protect them from every sorrow.”

Thorin looked toward the Company.

Fíli was helping Kíli adjust his pack. Balin was speaking with Dori, and Bilbo stood beside Bofur, looking up at the forest with a worried frown.

I know.

He knew better than anyone.

But he had been given another chance, and he would not squander it.

“I can try,” he answered.

Gandalf rested a hand briefly upon his shoulder.

“Then remember to let them help you.”

___________

 

The first days beneath Mirkwood's canopy were almost beautiful.

Strange flowers grew among the roots, their pale petals luminous in the dim light. Delicate mushrooms clustered against fallen trunks, and enormous ferns brushed against the travellers' legs as they passed.

Bilbo examined everything with fascinated curiosity.

He asked questions about unfamiliar plants, wondered aloud whether the forest had ever been cultivated, and stopped so frequently to admire peculiar insects that Dwalin eventually threatened to carry him.

“I should like to see you try,” Bilbo replied.

Dwalin grunted.

Thorin concealed a smile.

But the forest changed as they travelled deeper.

The flowers became scarce.

The air grew damp and stale.

There were no birds singing overhead, and the silence seemed to press against their ears.

Even the light behaved strangely, fading and brightening without any obvious change in the hour.

After four days, Bilbo stopped asking questions about the plants.

After six, Kíli stopped making jokes about the trees.

By the eighth day, nobody was entirely certain whether it was morning or afternoon.

Thorin maintained strict rules.

Nobody left the path. Nobody travelled alone. The Company counted its numbers at every rest, and their remaining supplies were divided with care.

Fíli led the morning watches while Dwalin supervised the rear.

Thorin moved constantly between them.

He checked their water.

He checked their weapons.

He checked Bilbo.

Especially Bilbo.

The hobbit noticed.

At first, he found the attention rather sweet.

Then it became exhausting.

“I'm perfectly well,” he assured Thorin one morning.

“I didn't ask.”

“You were about to.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo smiled, but there was tiredness behind it.

__________

 

The forest was beginning to wear upon them all.

The first strange voices came on the tenth night.

Kíli was keeping watch beside Fíli when he heard someone calling his name.

It was faint, barely distinguishable from the rustling leaves.

Yet he recognized the voice immediately.

“Mother?”

Fíli looked up.

“What?”

Kíli stared into the trees.

“I heard Dís.”

His brother went still.

Their mother was hundreds of miles away.

“Kíli,” Fíli said carefully, “don't move.”

“But—”

“Look at me.”

Kíli turned reluctantly.

Fíli caught his arm.

“Whatever you heard, it wasn't Mother.”

For a moment, Kíli seemed prepared to argue.

Then the voice came again.

This time Fíli heard it too.

Soft.

Familiar.

Calling them both.

He tightened his grip upon his brother.

They remained beside the fire until the sound faded.

Neither slept much afterward.

___________

 

The following evening, Bofur claimed to hear music drifting through the trees. Ori saw distant lights that vanished whenever he looked directly at them.

Bilbo began dreaming of Bag End.

He dreamed of his kitchen, his garden, and the comforting smell of fresh bread.

But whenever he approached the familiar green door, he felt something watching him from the windows.

He woke with his hand clenched around the little golden Ring hidden in his pocket.

He stared at it in the darkness.

The Ring gleamed faintly against his palm.

He remembered Gollum's desperate cries beneath the mountains.

My precious.

Bilbo swallowed.

He had never told anyone about it.

Not Gandalf.

Not Thorin.

Sometimes he wondered whether he ought to.

Yet whenever he imagined showing it to someone, a strange reluctance rose within him.

He closed his fingers around it.

A twig cracked behind him.

Bilbo spun.

Thorin stood nearby.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit quickly slipped the Ring away.

“What have you there?”

“Nothing.”

Thorin glanced toward his closed hand.

“Bilbo.”

“I said it's nothing.”

The sharpness of his reply surprised them both.

Thorin's expression changed.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then Thorin inclined his head.

“Very well.”

He did not ask again.

Bilbo watched him walk away and felt an uncomfortable knot of guilt settle beneath his ribs.

__________

 

Thorin heard the voices two nights later.

He had been keeping watch while the Company slept, seated against a tree with Orcrist resting across his knees.

The forest was silent.

Then someone called his name.

“Uncle?”

Thorin froze.

He knew that voice.

He knew its frightened urgency.

“Uncle Thorin?”

Fíli.

But not the Fíli sleeping beside the fire.

This voice was weaker.

Broken.

The voice of a young dwarf dying upon the cold stones of Ravenhill.

Thorin's breath caught.

Another voice followed.

“Uncle?”

Kíli.

The sword slipped slightly in his hands.

He rose before he realized he was moving.

The darkness between the trees seemed to deepen, and somewhere beyond the path he heard the sound of distant fighting.

He remembered blood upon the snow.

Remembered reaching too late.

Remembered the terrible stillness of his nephews' bodies.

“Thorin?”

A different voice.

Warm.

Sleepy.

Real.

He turned.

Bilbo stood beside the fire, wrapped in his blanket.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin stared at him.

Then his gaze moved toward the sleeping Company.

Fíli lay beside Kíli, both breathing steadily.

Alive.

Safe.

For now.

Thorin lowered himself slowly beside them.

Bilbo approached without speaking.

He sat beside the dwarf and rested a hand against his back.

Thorin closed his eyes.

The voices had stopped.

But the memories remained.

__________

 

The argument came the following afternoon.

Bilbo had scarcely eaten, and Thorin had asked him twice whether he felt ill.

When he asked a third time, the hobbit stopped walking.

“Thorin.”

The dwarf turned.

“What?”

“You've asked me that three times today.”

“Because you've barely touched your food.”

“Neither have you!”

Thorin fell silent.

Bilbo folded his arms.

“And you haven't slept properly in days.”

“This forest is dangerous.”

“I know that.”

“Then you understand why I must be careful.”

“Careful, yes. But you cannot spend every moment watching me as though I'm about to disappear.”

The words struck Thorin with painful force.

Because you did.

Because I lost you once.

He looked away.

Bilbo's frustration softened slightly, but he continued.

“I know you're worried. I appreciate it, truly. But sometimes I feel as though you're waiting for something terrible to happen to me.”

“I am trying to keep you safe.”

“And I'm trying to tell you that I need to be allowed to breathe without frightening you!”

Thorin stared at him.

Bilbo's cheeks flushed.

He had not intended to raise his voice.

But the forest had exhausted him, and the strange weight of the Ring in his pocket seemed to make every emotion sharper.

“I'm sorry,” he began.

Thorin shook his head.

“No. You have every right to speak.”

He looked toward the dark trees.

“I have lost people because I failed to protect them.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“I know.”

Thorin swallowed.

“Because I know what happens when I fail to protect the people I love.”

Silence settled between them.

Bilbo went very still.

“The people you love?” he repeated quietly.

Thorin realized what he had said.

He could have corrected himself.

Could have spoken of the Company, of his nephews, of his duty as their king.

But Bilbo was looking at him with such open, startled tenderness that the thought of denying his own words became unbearable.

“Yes,” he answered.

Bilbo's cheeks warmed.

“Oh.”

Neither knew quite what to say afterward.

Eventually, Bilbo looked down.

“I didn't mean to upset you.”

“You haven't.”

“I'm still rather cross.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“I gathered.”

Bilbo almost smiled.

Then he sighed.

“I only wish you'd trust me to look after myself sometimes.”

“I do trust you.”

“Then perhaps you might show it.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“I shall try.”

Bilbo nodded.

It was not a perfect resolution.

But it was a beginning.

__________

 

That evening, the Company made camp in a narrow clearing beside the path.

They dared not light a large fire, but a small flame provided enough warmth to gather around.

Thorin sat apart from the others, studying their map with tired eyes.

He had barely slept for several nights.

His shoulders ached, his head throbbed, and every sound from the forest seemed to demand his attention.

Bilbo watched him for a while.

Then he made a decision.

He approached carrying a folded blanket.

“Thorin.”

The dwarf looked up.

“Bilbo.”

“I'm sorry I snapped at you.”

Thorin set the map aside.

“And I am sorry I made you feel as though I doubt your judgment.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

“I know you're trying to protect me.”

“I am.”

“But I want to protect you too.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“I know.”

“Then perhaps we ought to try doing it together.”

For a moment, Thorin simply looked at him.

Then he smiled.

“I should like that.”

“Good.”

Bilbo unfolded the blanket and arranged it beside the fire.

“Now, you're going to rest.”

Thorin blinked.

“I have a watch to keep.”

“Dwalin has the watch.”

“I must review tomorrow's route.”

“Fíli has already done that.”

“There are other matters—”

“Thorin.”

The dwarf fell silent.

Bilbo sat with his back against a broad tree root and patted his lap.

“Lie down.”

Thorin stared.

“I beg your pardon?”

“You heard me.”

“Bilbo—”

“Your head. Here.”

Bilbo patted his lap again.

Across the fire, Dwalin stopped sharpening his axe.

Thorin glanced toward the others.

“This is hardly necessary.”

“Neither is staying awake until you collapse, but you seem determined to do that.”

“I am perfectly capable of—”

“Thorin Oakenshield, if you finish that sentence by telling me you're perfectly capable of looking after yourself, I shall remind you of the time you attempted to mend your own coat.”

A muscle twitched in Thorin's jaw.

Bilbo smiled sweetly.

“Now. Lie down.”

And to the astonishment of everyone within hearing distance, Thorin obeyed.

He lowered himself carefully onto the blankets, resting his head upon Bilbo's lap.

Fíli slowly lowered his cup.

Kíli's mouth fell open.

Bofur stared.

Balin looked positively delighted.

Bilbo, apparently unaware that he had just overturned several decades of established dwarven authority, began gently running his fingers through Thorin's hair.

“There. That wasn't so difficult, was it?”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“You are remarkably persistent.”

“So I've been told.”

Bilbo carefully loosened one of the braids beside his temple.

Thorin opened an eye.

“You only braided that a few days ago.”

“I know.”

“Then why are you undoing it?”

“Because I'm going to braid it again.”

Thorin considered this.

“Why?”

Bilbo's fingers paused.

Then he smiled down at him.

“Because you always seem calmer when I do.”

Thorin went very still.

Bilbo had noticed.

Not the traditions surrounding dwarven braids, nor the intimacy such gestures could carry among his people.

He had noticed something simpler.

That Thorin was tired.

That he was frightened.

And that gentle hands could sometimes quiet the thoughts he could not put into words.

“Bilbo…”

“Shh. You're supposed to be resting.”

Thorin closed his eyes again.

Bilbo began working slowly, separating the dark strands and weaving them together with practised movements.

He occasionally brushed his fingertips over Thorin's scalp, smoothing away loose hairs.

Thorin's breathing gradually slowed.

Bilbo spoke quietly about Hobbiton.

He told him about a neighbour who had once mistaken a particularly large pumpkin for a stolen wheelbarrow, and about a disastrous attempt to teach his younger cousins how to make seed cakes.

Thorin listened.

At least, he did at first.

After several minutes, his responses became quieter.

Then they stopped.

Bilbo glanced down.

Thorin Oakenshield was asleep.

Not merely resting his eyes.

Asleep.

His face had softened, his breathing deep and even, and one hand lay loosely upon the blanket beside Bilbo's knee.

Bilbo smiled.

“Finally,” he whispered.

Across the fire, the Company was experiencing a collective crisis.

Dwalin leaned toward Balin.

“Is he dead?”

Balin gave him a look.

“Don't be ridiculous.”

“He's not moving.”

“He's sleeping.”

“Thorin doesn't sleep like that.”

“Apparently he does.”

Dwalin stared.

“I've spent twenty years telling that stubborn bastard to get some rest.”

“Yes.”

“Twenty years.”

“I heard you.”

“And the hobbit tells him to put his head in his lap, and he just—”

Dwalin gestured helplessly.

Balin's eyes sparkled.

“Perhaps you should have tried braiding his hair.”

Kíli made a choking noise.

Fíli buried his face in his hands.

Bofur turned away, his shoulders shaking with silent laughter.

Bilbo glanced toward them.

“Would you mind keeping your voices down?” he whispered. “He's finally asleep.”

Dwalin opened his mouth.

Closed it.

Then lowered his voice.

“Of course, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Thank you.”

Balin watched him return to gently stroking Thorin's hair.

“Well,” he murmured to his brother, “at least we know who'll be ruling Erebor.”

Dwalin nearly dropped his axe.

__________

 

Four hours passed.

The forest remained quiet, though nobody mistook that silence for safety.

Fíli and Dwalin kept watch while the others rested. The Company had agreed to stop longer than usual, partly because everyone needed sleep and partly because nobody seemed willing to disturb their king.

Bilbo remained seated against the tree.

His legs had grown stiff.

His back ached.

But Thorin was sleeping so peacefully that he could not bring himself to move.

He finished the braid long ago.

Now he simply rested one hand in the dwarf's hair, smoothing it whenever Thorin stirred.

Eventually, Fíli approached.

“Master Baggins?”

Bilbo looked up.

“Yes?”

“We ought to be moving.”

Bilbo glanced down.

“Oh. Of course.”

Fíli hesitated.

“Would you mind waking him?”

Bilbo blinked.

“Why don't you?”

Fíli looked at his sleeping uncle.

“Because I rather enjoy being alive.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes.

He gently brushed a few strands of hair away from Thorin's forehead.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf did not move.

“Thorin, darling, we have to go.”

Fíli froze.

Behind him, Kíli made a strangled sound.

Bilbo appeared not to notice what he had said.

Thorin stirred.

His eyes opened slowly, and for a moment he looked up at Bilbo with an expression of such unguarded tenderness that the hobbit forgot what he had intended to say.

Then Thorin blinked.

“How long?”

“About four hours.”

The dwarf immediately tried to sit up.

“Four hours?”

Bilbo placed a hand against his shoulder.

“Yes, and before you start complaining, Dwalin and Fíli kept watch. Nobody died, the forest hasn't swallowed us, and your kingdom is still waiting for you.”

Thorin looked at him.

Then he smiled.

“Very well.”

He sat up without another argument.

Dwalin, watching from beside the fire, turned slowly toward Balin.

“I don't understand.”

Balin patted his shoulder.

“Neither do I, brother. But I suggest we enjoy it.”

Thorin rose, then noticed Bilbo attempting to straighten his legs.

“Are you uncomfortable?”

“Only a little stiff.”

“You should have woken me.”

Bilbo looked up.

“You needed the rest more than I needed comfortable legs.”

Thorin's expression softened.

He offered his hand.

Bilbo accepted it.

As the hobbit stood, Thorin steadied him carefully.

“Thank you,” he murmured.

Bilbo smiled.

“You're very welcome.”

Behind them, Kíli leaned toward Fíli.

“Did he call Uncle darling?”

Fíli closed his eyes.

“Yes.”

“Does Uncle know?”

“I suspect so.”

Kíli considered this.

“Do you think we should—”

“No.”

“But—”

“Absolutely not.”

___________

 

The enchanted stream appeared two days later.

It crossed the path beneath a low canopy of twisted branches, its dark water moving so slowly that it seemed almost motionless.

Thorin recognized it immediately.

His stomach tightened.

He remembered Bombur falling.

Remembered the terrible sleep that had followed.

This time, he would not allow it.

“Stop,” he ordered.

The Company halted.

“No one touches the water.”

Dwalin frowned.

“We know Beorn's warning.”

“Then heed it.”

Thorin studied the crossing.

The old stones were slippery, and the fallen tree that might once have served as a bridge had begun to rot.

Fíli examined the banks.

“We could use rope,” he suggested. “Secure it between the trees and cross one at a time.”

Thorin nodded.

“Do it.”

They worked carefully.

Dwalin crossed first, testing each step while holding the rope. Fíli followed, then Glóin and the others.

Bilbo waited beside Thorin.

The water looked strangely inviting.

Its surface reflected pale shapes that did not resemble the branches overhead.

He felt an odd desire to kneel beside it.

To look more closely.

His hand drifted toward his pocket.

Thorin touched his shoulder.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit blinked.

“What?”

“Stay with me.”

Bilbo looked toward the water again.

Then he nodded.

“Of course.”

They crossed near the end.

Kíli was ahead of them when the rotten bark beneath his boot gave way.

He slipped.

Fíli lunged forward.

“Kíli!”

Thorin moved before anyone else could react.

He caught his nephew's arm while Fíli seized the back of his coat.

For one terrible moment, Kíli hung above the dark water.

Then Dwalin hauled him onto solid ground.

Kíli landed heavily, gasping.

The Company crowded around him.

“I'm fine,” he insisted.

Fíli gripped his shoulders.

“You nearly fell!”

“But I didn't.”

Thorin stood very still.

His hands were trembling.

He remembered another lifetime.

Another crossing.

Another moment when he had been too late.

Bilbo approached quietly.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf looked at him.

“He's safe,” Bilbo said.

Thorin swallowed.

“Yes.”

Fíli watched his uncle with growing concern.

Later, when the Company resumed walking, he fell into step beside him.

“You looked frightened.”

Thorin glanced toward Kíli, who was already arguing with Bofur about whether the stream had deliberately tried to trip him.

“I was.”

“Because he nearly fell?”

Thorin looked ahead.

“Because I know how quickly a single mistake can take someone from us.”

Fíli was silent for a moment.

Then he nodded.

“I'll remember that.”

Thorin rested a hand briefly upon his shoulder.

“I hope you will.”

__________

 

The forest grew darker after the stream.

The path narrowed, and the trees pressed closer together. Their branches twisted overhead like enormous fingers, shutting out what little daylight remained.

Food became scarce.

The Company travelled more slowly, their bodies weary despite the rest they had taken.

Even Bilbo's cheerful stories became less frequent.

But something had changed between him and Thorin.

The argument had not vanished from memory, nor had the secrets they carried.

Yet Thorin no longer asked Bilbo whether he was well every hour.

And Bilbo, in return, made a point of telling him when he was tired or frightened rather than pretending otherwise.

Sometimes they walked together in silence.

Sometimes Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's.

And sometimes Thorin looked at him with such quiet tenderness that Bilbo found himself wondering whether he ought to ask what those looks meant.

He never quite gathered the courage.

Not yet.

___________ 

 

On the fourteenth night beneath Mirkwood's canopy, the Company made camp in a narrow clearing.

There was no fire.

Only darkness, damp earth, and the faint rustling of leaves overhead.

Bilbo settled beside Thorin, exhausted.

“Do you think we're nearly through?” he whispered.

Thorin looked toward the trees.

“Not yet.”

Bilbo sighed.

“I was afraid you'd say that.”

He rested his head against Thorin's shoulder.

The dwarf adjusted his cloak around them both.

“Sleep,” he murmured.

“And you?”

“I'll keep watch.”

Bilbo made a small, dissatisfied sound.

“You promised to rest.”

“I did rest.”

“Four hours.”

“Nearly five.”

Bilbo smiled sleepily.

“Stubborn dwarf.”

“Persistent hobbit.”

The hobbit's breathing gradually deepened.

Thorin remained still, listening to the forest.

Then he heard something.

A faint rustling overhead.

He looked up.

For a moment, he saw nothing.

Then a branch shifted.

Something enormous moved among the leaves.

Long, dark legs curled around the bark.

A pale glimmer caught the faint light.

Thorin's blood turned cold.

He knew those shapes.

He remembered the webs.

The helplessness.

The terrible knowledge that Bilbo had once been left to face those creatures alone.

Above them, another branch moved.

Then another.

The spiders were watching.

Waiting.

Thorin carefully tightened his cloak around Bilbo, keeping the sleeping hobbit close.

His free hand closed around Orcrist.

He looked toward the dark shapes hidden among the branches.

Not again.

Not while he still drew breath.

“Not this time,” he whispered.

Chapter 10: Chapter Ten — The Webs of Fate

Chapter Text

The first thing Thorin noticed was that the spiders made almost no sound.

For creatures so enormous, they moved with a dreadful grace, their long legs finding purchase upon branches that should never have supported their weight. The leaves barely stirred as they passed. Only the occasional glimmer of a pale eye or the faint sheen of silk betrayed their presence among the tangled canopy.

Bilbo slept against his shoulder, blissfully unaware.

Thorin kept perfectly still.

He could feel the hobbit's warm breath against his neck, the slight weight of his curls where they brushed his cloak. One of Bilbo's hands rested loosely upon his arm, his fingers curled into the fabric as though he had reached for Thorin in his sleep.

It was a small, trusting gesture.

And above them, something hungry was watching.

Thorin's grip tightened around Orcrist.

He remembered the spiders from his first journey through Mirkwood. Remembered waking bound in silk, unable to move, the terrible confusion of hearing his companions struggling around him. He remembered Bilbo appearing when all hope had seemed lost, small and determined, fighting creatures many times his size.

He had been proud of him then.

He was proud of him now.

But pride did nothing to quiet the cold fear settling in Thorin's stomach.

Carefully, he shifted his shoulder.

“Bilbo,” he murmured.

The hobbit made a dissatisfied noise.

“Not yet.”

“Bilbo.”

“If it's morning, I should like another five minutes.”

Thorin almost smiled.

“It isn't morning.”

“Then I refuse to acknowledge that we're supposed to be awake.”

“There are spiders.”

Bilbo opened his eyes.

For a moment, he stared at Thorin.

Then he sat upright.

“...I withdraw my complaint.”

Thorin pressed a finger briefly to his lips.

Bilbo followed his gaze toward the branches.

Something moved overhead.

The hobbit went very pale.

“Oh,” he whispered. “Those are rather large.”

“Stay beside me.”

“I had no intention of going anywhere else.”

Thorin rose slowly, keeping one hand near Bilbo's shoulder while he signalled to Dwalin.

The warrior approached with his axe already in hand.

“What is it?”

Thorin pointed upward.

Dwalin squinted into the darkness.

For several moments, he saw nothing.

Then a thick strand of webbing drifted between two branches.

Dwalin's expression hardened.

“How many?”

“At least three.”

“And the rest?”

“That is what concerns me.”

Dwalin looked toward the sleeping Company.

“I'll wake them.”

“Quietly.”

“Aye.”

___________

 

Within minutes, Fíli had joined them, followed by the others. The dwarves gathered their belongings without complaint, though Bombur looked particularly miserable when informed that breakfast would have to wait.

Kíli stared into the branches.

“Are those the spiders Beorn warned us about?”

“No,” Bofur murmured. “I expect these are the friendly ones.”

Nobody laughed.

Thorin studied the path ahead.

“We move together. No one leaves the trail, and no one falls behind.”

Fíli stepped forward.

“Kíli and I can take the front. If there are webs across the path, we'll find them before the others walk into them.”

“Good,” Thorin answered. “Dwalin, take the rear. Bofur, stay near Bombur.”

Bilbo adjusted Sting at his hip.

“I can watch for the smaller webs,” he offered. “I'm closer to the ground than most of you.”

Thorin considered him.

In another life, he might have ordered Bilbo to remain safely in the middle of the Company.

Now he remembered a conversation beside a dying fire.

Then perhaps we ought to try doing it together.

He nodded.

“Keep your eyes on the roots. Tell us if you see anything.”

Bilbo straightened slightly.

“I shall.”

For the briefest moment, their eyes met.

Then Thorin turned toward the darkness.

“Move.”

_____________

 

They travelled for nearly an hour without incident.

The path twisted between enormous trunks, occasionally disappearing beneath carpets of dead leaves. Thick roots rose across their way, and the trees crowded so closely together that the Company sometimes had to pass through narrow gaps one at a time.

Above them, the spiders followed.

Thorin could hear them now.

A faint clicking.

The scrape of hard legs against bark.

Once, a pale shape moved directly overhead, and Kíli raised his bow.

“Don't,” Thorin whispered.

Kíli lowered it reluctantly.

Bilbo was the first to notice the web stretched across the path.

“Wait.”

The Company stopped.

The hobbit crouched beside a root and pointed toward a nearly invisible thread running between two trees.

“There.”

Fíli leaned closer.

“Well spotted.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

They carefully stepped around it.

Farther ahead, Dwalin discovered another.

Then a third.

By the time they reached a fallen tree, Thorin was beginning to understand what the spiders were doing.

They were not merely following.

They were guiding them.

He stopped.

“Something is wrong.”

Dwalin looked around.

“Besides the enormous spiders?”

“The webs are becoming more frequent.”

Fíli frowned.

“They're trying to force us toward something.”

Thorin nodded.

“Exactly.”

A branch cracked overhead.

Kíli looked up.

A monstrous spider emerged from the leaves, its swollen body suspended beneath a thick strand of silk.

“Above us!”

The creature dropped.

Dwalin met it with his axe.

The blade struck one of its legs, sending the spider shrieking backward. Fíli drew his sword, and Thorin stepped forward with Orcrist raised.

The spider retreated into the branches.

For one hopeful moment, Thorin thought they had frightened it away.

Then the ground moved.

A hollow trunk beside the path split open with a terrible cracking sound.

Something enormous burst from within.

Bombur shouted as a spider struck him sideways, knocking him into Bofur. Both dwarves fell among the roots.

Another creature emerged from beneath the fallen tree.

Then another.

The forest erupted into movement.

“DEFEND YOURSELVES!” Thorin roared.

The spiders were everywhere.

Their legs struck against bark and stone, their shrieks echoing beneath the canopy. Thick strands of silk shot through the darkness, catching on branches, weapons, and clothing.

Kíli fired an arrow into the nearest creature's face.

It screamed and lunged.

Fíli shoved his brother aside, but a strand of webbing caught Kíli around the arm and dragged him backward.

“FÍLI!”

His brother spun.

“KÍLI!”

Thorin heard them.

For one dreadful instant, he saw Ravenhill instead of Mirkwood.

Snow.

Blood.

His nephews dying beyond his reach.

Then Fíli shouted again, and the present returned with brutal clarity.

Thorin charged toward them.

But a spider dropped between him and the brothers.

Orcrist flashed blue.

The creature recoiled, one leg severed, and Thorin drove his blade into its body.

He barely had time to pull the sword free before another attacked.

____________

 

Meanwhile, Bilbo found himself separated from the others.

He had been trying to reach Bombur when a spider struck the ground beside him, throwing him against a root.

His shoulder collided painfully with the wood.

Sting slipped halfway from its sheath.

The creature turned toward him.

Its eyes were black and shining.

Its mouth opened, revealing terrible curved fangs.

Bilbo's heart hammered.

He was frightened.

More frightened than he cared to admit.

But somewhere beneath that fear, he remembered Thorin standing beside him during their sword lessons, patiently correcting his grip.

You need not be stronger than your opponent. You need to be quicker.

The spider lunged.

Bilbo rolled beneath its front legs.

Sting flashed upward.

The blade struck soft flesh.

The creature shrieked.

Bilbo scrambled to his feet and drove the sword forward again.

The spider collapsed.

For several seconds, he stood trembling, staring at the enormous body.

He had killed it.

He had actually killed it.

Then Kíli cried out.

Bilbo turned.

The young dwarf was tangled in webbing, struggling desperately while Fíli fought to keep another spider away.

Bilbo ran toward them.

He had almost reached the brothers when something struck the root beside him.

The impact threw him sideways.

He landed hard among the leaves.

Something slipped from his waistcoat pocket.

A small golden circle bounced against the bark.

Rolled between two roots.

And vanished beneath a fallen branch.

Bilbo stopped breathing.

The Ring.

His Ring.

He dropped to his knees.

“No…”

His fingers scraped through damp leaves.

It had been there.

He had seen it.

Where had it gone?

A spider shrieked somewhere behind him.

Bilbo scarcely heard.

His heart pounded with a sudden, desperate terror that seemed entirely different from the fear of the creatures surrounding him.

He had to find it.

He had to.

His hands clawed at the earth, scattering leaves and broken twigs.

Then he saw it.

A faint golden glimmer beneath the roots.

Relief struck him so fiercely that his eyes stung.

He reached for it.

“Mine,” he whispered.

His fingers closed around the Ring.

For one dreadful moment, the entire world seemed to settle into place.

Then Bilbo heard himself.

Mine?

He stared at the little circle resting against his palm.

What a strange thing to say.

What a dreadful, ugly little word.

“BILBO!”

He barely registered the shout.

“BILBO!”

A shadow fell over him.

Steel flashed.

Something enormous crashed against the roots.

Thorin seized Bilbo by the shoulder and hauled him backward just as a spider's fangs struck the ground where his head had been.

“What in Mahal's name are you doing?”

Bilbo stared at him.

“I—”

Thorin's face was pale beneath the dirt.

“You could have been killed!”

“I dropped something.”

“Then leave it!”

“No!”

The word tore from Bilbo's throat.

Thorin went still.

Bilbo was breathing hard, his fingers clenched so tightly around the Ring that its edges pressed painfully into his skin.

For a moment, the dwarf looked almost frightened of him.

Not because Bilbo had raised his voice.

Because there had been something in it that Thorin recognized.

Something desperate.

Possessive.

Something that reminded him horribly of the Arkenstone.

“Bilbo,” he said more quietly. “Is it worth your life?”

The hobbit looked down at his closed fist.

He could not answer.

Then Kíli screamed again.

Bilbo flinched.

He looked toward the brothers.

Fíli was struggling beneath the weight of a spider, and Kíli could barely move.

The Ring seemed to burn against his palm.

Bilbo swallowed.

Then he forced his fingers open long enough to push it deep into his pocket.

“No,” he whispered.

He drew Sting.

And ran.

____________

 

Fíli was losing ground.

The spider towering above him had already knocked his sword aside, and its long legs struck at him with terrifying speed.

Kíli struggled against the silk binding his arm.

“Fíli!”

“I'm rather occupied!”

The creature lunged.

Fíli raised his remaining dagger.

Then a small figure darted beneath the spider's body.

Sting flashed blue.

The creature shrieked as Bilbo drove the blade into its side.

Fíli seized the opportunity.

He recovered his sword and struck.

Together, they brought the spider down.

Bilbo immediately turned toward Kíli.

“Hold still!”

“I am holding still!”

“You're wriggling!”

“Because I'm stuck!”

“Then stop being stuck!”

Despite everything, Fíli almost laughed.

Bilbo cut through the webbing with Sting.

Kíli stumbled free.

“Thank you,” he gasped.

“You're welcome. Now please don't get caught again.”

“I'll do my best.”

They barely had time to recover before another spider emerged from the trees.

Fíli looked toward his uncle.

Thorin was fighting beside Dwalin, his sword moving with deadly precision.

But another creature was descending behind him.

“UNCLE!”

Thorin turned.

Too late.

Fíli hurled himself forward.

His sword struck the spider's leg just as it lunged, knocking the creature sideways.

Thorin spun and drove Orcrist into its body.

The spider collapsed between them.

For a moment, uncle and nephew stared at one another.

“You saved me,” Thorin said.

Fíli was breathing hard.

“You've been teaching me to watch my surroundings.”

Thorin looked at him.

At the young dwarf who had died in his arms in another lifetime.

Alive.

Fighting.

Strong enough to save his king.

Something painful tightened in his chest.

Then Fíli gave him a breathless grin.

“Try to remember your own lessons, Uncle.”

Thorin laughed once, astonished.

“I shall.”

__________

 

The sound of another shriek cut through the clearing.

The battle was not over.

Bilbo did not know exactly when he put on the Ring.

One moment, he was scrambling beneath a fallen branch as another spider approached.

The next, the golden circle was on his finger.

And the world changed.

The forest seemed colder.

The shadows deepened.

The spiders' voices became horribly clear.

Little morsel.

Where has it gone?

Find it.

Bilbo pressed himself against a tree, trembling.

The spider passed directly in front of him.

It did not see him.

For a moment, he felt an extraordinary rush of relief.

He could escape.

He could slip away from the spiders, from the darkness, from all this dreadful danger.

He could simply leave.

The thought was so tempting that he took one step toward the deeper forest.

Then he heard Thorin.

“BILBO!”

The dwarf's voice carried through the fighting.

Frightened.

Desperate.

Bilbo stopped.

He remembered Thorin asleep in his lap, his face peaceful for the first time in days.

Remembered the quiet admission beside the fire.

The people I love.

Bilbo turned around.

“No,” he whispered.

He tightened his grip upon Sting.

Then he ran back toward the Company.

Invisible, he moved between the spiders, striking at their legs and cutting through webs that bound the dwarves.

The creatures shrieked in confusion.

One fell beneath Dwalin's axe.

Another fled into the trees.

And slowly, painfully, the Company began to regain control.

Then arrows hissed through the darkness.

A spider dropped from the branches with a shaft buried in its head.

Another fell.

And another.

The dwarves turned.

Figures moved between the trees.

Tall.

Swift.

Clad in the muted colours of the forest.

Wood-elves.

___________

 

“Hold your positions!”

The command came from a fair-haired elf standing upon a broad root, his bow drawn.

More elves emerged around him, their arrows trained upon the surviving spiders.

The creatures retreated, shrieking angrily as they vanished into the canopy.

For a moment, the clearing fell into an exhausted silence.

Then the elves turned their weapons toward the dwarves.

“Lay down your arms,” the fair-haired elf ordered.

Dwalin bristled.

“After we just fought those things?”

“You are trespassing in the Woodland Realm.”

Thorin stepped forward.

He recognized the elf.

Legolas.

Thranduil's son.

In his first life, the sight of an armed elven patrol would have been enough to provoke him into a furious argument.

This time, he lowered Orcrist.

“We mean no harm to your people.”

Legolas regarded him suspiciously.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

“Prince Legolas.”

A flicker of surprise crossed the elf's face.

“You know me?”

“I know of you.”

Legolas studied him for another moment.

Then he gestured toward the Company.

“You will accompany us to my father.”

Thorin inclined his head stiffly.

“We shall.”

Dwalin stared at him.

Balin looked faintly relieved.

The elves began collecting weapons.

Thorin allowed Orcrist to be taken, though every instinct protested.

Then he turned toward his companions.

Fíli.

Kíli.

Balin.

Dwalin.

Glóin. Óin. Dori. Nori. Ori.

Bifur. Bofur. Bombur.

Twelve dwarves.

With himself, thirteen.

There should have been fourteen.

Thorin looked around.

“Bilbo?”

No answer.

He glanced behind Bombur.

Then toward the fallen trees.

“Bilbo?”

His voice grew sharper.

Fíli looked up.

“Uncle?”

Thorin ignored him.

A moment ago, Bilbo had been fighting beside them.

He remembered seeing Sting flash blue among the roots.

Remembered the hobbit's frightened face when he had nearly been killed retrieving something from the ground.

And now—

“Where is the hobbit?”

Legolas frowned.

“What hobbit?”

Thorin turned toward him.

“The hobbit who was with us!”

“There was no hobbit among those we captured.”

For one terrible instant, Thorin could not breathe.

Then he moved.

He pushed past the nearest elf, ignoring the bows immediately raised against him.

“BILBO!”

Dwalin caught his arm.

“Thorin—”

“Let go!”

“Listen to me—”

“He was here!”

The words broke from him with such raw desperation that Dwalin loosened his grip in shock.

Thorin looked wildly toward the trees.

There were spiders out there.

Hundreds, perhaps.

There were webs hanging in the darkness, creatures waiting beneath roots, horrors that could swallow a hobbit without leaving a trace.

And Bilbo was gone.

Again.

“BILBO!”

He tried to push past the elves.

Two stepped into his path.

Legolas raised his bow.

“You will remain where you are.”

Thorin turned on him.

“Get out of my way.”

“You will not enter the forest alone.”

“Then you will have to kill me.”

Silence fell.

Even Legolas hesitated.

Thorin stood rigid, his breathing uneven, his hands trembling with a fury that was little more than terror.

He had promised himself.

He had promised that this time he would not lose them.

Not Fíli.

Not Kíli.

Not Bilbo.

Especially not Bilbo.

“Uncle.”

Fíli approached carefully.

Thorin did not look at him.

“He's out there.”

“We don't know that.”

“He wouldn't leave us!”

“I know.”

“He wouldn't!”

Fíli stepped closer.

“Uncle, look at me.”

Something in his nephew's voice finally reached him.

Thorin turned.

Fíli's expression was grave.

“Bilbo survived Goblin-town alone. He saved Kíli and me from the spiders. He's clever, and he knows how to hide.”

Thorin swallowed.

“He's still out there.”

“Then we have to trust him.”

Thorin stared at his nephew.

Trust.

That was what Bilbo had asked of him.

What Gandalf had told him.

What he had been trying, and failing, to learn since the moment he awoke outside Bag End.

He remembered the first journey.

Bilbo had found a way into the Elvenking's halls.

He had rescued them.

Thorin had never understood how.

Perhaps he could do so again.

But the knowledge offered only the smallest comfort.

He turned toward Legolas.

“Send someone to search for him.”

The prince studied him.

Then, after a moment, he signalled to two of his warriors.

“Search the nearby trees. Look for a small traveller.”

The elves disappeared into the darkness.

Thorin waited.

Every moment seemed an eternity.

When they returned, they had found nothing.

No hobbit.

No tracks.

No sign that Bilbo had ever been there.

Thorin felt the ground shift beneath him.

Legolas lowered his bow.

“We must go.”

Thorin looked toward the trees one final time.

Fíli rested a hand upon his arm.

“Come, Uncle.”

And at last, Thorin allowed himself to be led away.

__________

 

Bilbo stood only a few feet behind them.

Invisible.

Shaking.

He had watched everything.

He had seen Thorin push past the elves, heard the terrible desperation in his voice, and watched Fíli struggle to convince him that Bilbo might still be alive.

He had wanted to take off the Ring.

More than anything, he had wanted to run to Thorin and throw his arms around him.

But the elves were everywhere.

And if he allowed himself to be captured, who would help the Company?

He had reached toward Thorin once, his fingers hovering inches from the dwarf's hand.

Then he had stopped.

He could not risk revealing himself.

“I'm here,” he whispered.

Thorin did not hear.

“I'm right here.”

The dwarf walked away.

Bilbo felt something twist painfully beneath his ribs.

He had known Thorin cared for him.

He had seen it in countless small gestures, in the careful way the dwarf watched over him, in the tenderness of his smiles.

But he had never seen Thorin so frightened.

Never imagined that his disappearance could cause such devastation.

The Ring felt strangely warm upon his finger.

For a moment, Bilbo wanted to turn around.

To leave the elves behind.

To escape this dreadful forest and return to the quiet comforts of Bag End.

Then he looked toward Thorin.

The dwarf was walking between two elven guards, his shoulders rigid, his gaze constantly turning toward the trees.

Searching.

Still searching.

Bilbo swallowed.

He remembered Thorin's head resting in his lap.

Remembered the quiet warmth of his hand.

Remembered how safe he had felt beneath the dwarf's cloak.

And he knew, with sudden and startling certainty, that he could not leave him.

Not now.

Perhaps not ever.

Bilbo tightened his grip upon Sting.

“Oh, you ridiculous dwarf,” he whispered into the darkness. “Did you really think I would abandon you?”

Ahead, the elves began their journey toward the halls of the Elvenking.

Thorin looked over his shoulder one last time.

He saw nothing.

But Bilbo was there.

And as the Company disappeared beneath the ancient trees, their invisible burglar followed.

Chapter 11: Chapter Eleven — A Bargain Between Kings

Chapter Text

The gates of the Woodland Realm opened beneath the roots of the mountain, and Thorin Oakenshield found that he could not bring himself to admire them.

He remembered their grandeur. He remembered the pale stone, the bridges suspended above dark waters, the innumerable lanterns glowing like captured stars beneath the earth. He remembered the winding passages and the great halls carved into the living rock, where the wood-elves dwelt in splendour while the rest of the forest slowly surrendered to darkness.

Most of all, he remembered the cells.

He had spent enough time behind their doors in his first life to know precisely how the iron hinges sounded when they closed.

Yet now, as Legolas led the Company across the first bridge, Thorin scarcely noticed the armed guards or the curious faces turning toward them.

His attention remained fixed upon the entrance behind them.

Bilbo had not appeared.

Not when the elves gathered their belongings after the spider attack. Not when the Company began its long march through the forest. Not when they passed the watchposts hidden among the trees, nor when the guards called down from the branches to announce their arrival.

Every rustle of leaves had made Thorin turn.

Every unexpected footstep had brought a moment of unbearable hope.

And every time, there had been nothing.

“Uncle.”

Fíli's voice reached him from somewhere nearby.

Thorin looked toward his nephew.

“You'll stumble into the river if you keep walking backward,” Fíli said quietly.

Thorin glanced down. They had reached a narrow bridge crossing an underground stream, its black water flowing swiftly between smooth stone banks.

He turned forward.

“I'm watching the entrance.”

“I know.”

“He should have caught up by now.”

Fíli hesitated before answering. “Perhaps he has.”

Thorin looked sharply at him.

“Bilbo has surprised us before,” his nephew continued. “And he's clever enough not to announce himself while we're surrounded by armed elves.”

Thorin wanted to believe him.

He remembered Bilbo appearing in the goblin tunnels when he had been certain the hobbit was lost. Remembered the courage with which he had fought the spiders. Remembered, too, that in another life Bilbo had somehow found his way into these very halls and freed thirteen dwarves from imprisonment.

But memories were not promises.

The spiders had attacked differently this time. Thorin's precautions had changed the course of the battle, and with every alteration, the future grew less familiar.

What if Bilbo had been injured?

What if he had fallen?

What if—

“Uncle.”

Fíli touched his arm.

Thorin forced himself to meet his eyes.

“He's resourceful,” Fíli said. “You taught him that.”

Thorin swallowed.

“Aye.”

“And he has a habit of finding us.”

The faintest smile touched Thorin's mouth.

“He does.”

“Then let him find us again.”

Ahead, Legolas glanced over his shoulder.

“The king is expecting you.”

Thorin straightened.

He could not search the forest while surrounded by elven guards. He could not protect Bilbo by provoking another ruler into imprisoning the Company.

But perhaps he could accomplish something useful while he waited.

“Then we should not keep him waiting,” he answered.

__________

 

Bilbo Baggins had never imagined that entering an elven kingdom could involve so much hiding behind pillars.

He had expected guards, naturally. Gandalf had warned him often enough that elves possessed excellent eyesight and hearing, and Bilbo had already discovered both qualities to be profoundly inconvenient.

What he had not expected was the sheer number of places in which an unsuspecting hobbit might become lost.

The halls seemed to extend in every direction. Staircases curved around enormous columns, bridges crossed underground waterways, and lantern-lit passages disappeared into chambers whose ceilings were so high that Bilbo could scarcely distinguish them from the darkness above.

It was beautiful.

Under different circumstances, he would have liked to spend an entire afternoon examining the carvings.

At present, however, he was chiefly concerned with not being discovered.

The Ring rested upon his finger.

He had worn it for much of the journey, removing it only when he could safely conceal himself behind trees or among the rocks. Each time he slipped it off, an unpleasant reluctance stirred somewhere deep within him.

He did not like that feeling.

He liked even less how quickly it vanished whenever he put the Ring on again.

Now, following the dwarves through the palace, Bilbo found himself increasingly eager to remove it.

The world seemed strangely distant while he wore it, as though he were walking through a cold imitation of the halls around him.

He could hear the elves speaking, but their voices sometimes sounded thin and far away.

He could see Thorin.

That, at least, was enough to keep him moving.

The dwarf walked near the front of the Company, his dark hair falling loose around his shoulders where the battle had disturbed its braids.

Bilbo noticed the missing braid immediately.

He had spent a good deal of time arranging that hair.

It seemed terribly inconsiderate of the spiders to ruin his work.

The thought almost made him smile.

Then Thorin looked back toward the gates again, and Bilbo's amusement faded.

He had never seen him look so tired.

I'm here, he wanted to say.

But the guards were close, and the opportunity had not yet come.

So Bilbo followed.

____________

 

When the dwarves were led toward a guarded chamber, Thorin and two others were separated from the Company.

Bilbo recognized Fíli and Balin accompanying him.

He hesitated.

Then he slipped behind a column and listened.

“His Majesty will receive the leader of your Company,” one of the guards explained. “The others will remain here until his decision is made.”

Dwalin grumbled something unpleasant about elven hospitality.

Bilbo watched Thorin disappear down a passage with Fíli and Balin.

Then he made his decision.

He would find the others first.

After all, a burglar ought to know where his companions were being kept.

Thranduil had been informed of Thorin Oakenshield's arrival before the Company reached the gates.

He had also received a considerably more unusual report from his son.

“A hobbit?” he repeated.

Legolas stood before the throne, his bow resting across his back.

“So they claim.”

“You did not see him?”

“No.”

“And yet you searched for him?”

“At Thorin Oakenshield's insistence.”

Thranduil regarded his son.

Legolas's expression remained composed, though there was something faintly troubled about his eyes.

“Insistence,” the Elvenking repeated.

“He nearly fought the patrol when he discovered the hobbit was missing.”

That earned a raised eyebrow.

“Over a hobbit?”

“He seemed prepared to die rather than leave the forest without him.”

Thranduil was silent for a moment.

He remembered Thorin as a younger dwarf, proud and furious, standing amid the ruins of his people's hopes. He remembered the bitterness of their last encounters and the stubbornness with which the House of Durin guarded its grievances.

He did not remember Thorin Oakenshield displaying such desperate concern for a companion.

“And the dwarves surrendered their weapons?”

“Without resistance.”

“How extraordinary.”

Legolas inclined his head.

“I thought you would find it so.”

Thranduil rose.

“Bring them before me.”

_____________

 

The throne room was exactly as Thorin remembered.

That was perhaps the most unsettling thing about it.

The great antlered throne rose above the hall, pale and magnificent, framed by twisted columns and the warm glow of countless lanterns. The air smelled faintly of polished wood, stone, and the strange sweetness of the forest.

Thranduil sat above them, his silver hair falling over dark robes, his expression as cold and unreadable as winter moonlight.

Fíli stood to Thorin's right.

Balin remained slightly behind them.

Neither spoke.

Thorin stopped at the foot of the steps.

For a moment, two kings regarded one another.

Then Thorin inclined his head.

“King Thranduil.”

The Elvenking's eyes narrowed almost imperceptibly.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

His gaze moved briefly over the dwarf's torn clothing and the marks left by the spider battle.

“You have travelled far to arrive uninvited in my kingdom.”

“Necessity rarely waits for invitations.”

“No,” Thranduil agreed. “And it appears necessity has done little to improve your manners.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“Perhaps not. But I have not come to quarrel with you.”

A silence followed.

Fíli glanced sideways at his uncle.

Balin looked as though he were trying very hard not to react.

Thranduil leaned back.

“Have you not?”

“No.”

“Then you have changed considerably since our last meeting.”

“Time has a habit of doing that.”

Something flickered in the Elvenking's eyes.

“And what is it you seek?”

“Passage through your realm. Supplies for my Company. And the opportunity to discuss a bargain.”

“A bargain?”

Thorin held his gaze.

“One that may benefit both our peoples.”

Thranduil considered him for a long moment.

Then he gestured toward the space before his throne.

“Speak.”

Thorin drew a slow breath.

“In Erebor's treasury there are jewels that rightfully belong to your house. The white gems of Lasgalen.”

The silence that followed was immediate.

Even the guards seemed to become still.

Thranduil's expression did not change.

But his fingers tightened slightly upon the arm of his throne.

“You speak of treasures you do not possess.”

“I speak of treasures I intend to recover.”

“And you believe I should trust the word of a dwarf whose grandfather refused to honour his own agreements?”

Thorin felt the old anger rise.

For an instant, he remembered his grandfather's pride, the glittering halls of Erebor, and the bitterness that had poisoned the relationship between their peoples.

He remembered standing before this very throne in his first life, furious and humiliated, choosing defiance when diplomacy might have spared them all.

He forced himself to breathe.

“My grandfather's decisions are not mine.”

Thranduil's gaze sharpened.

“Yet you bear his crown.”

“Not yet.”

“And when you do?”

Thorin straightened.

“When I reclaim Erebor, I will return the white gems to your house. I will have the agreement witnessed and recorded before we leave these halls.”

Fíli looked at him with unmistakable surprise.

Balin's expression softened.

Thranduil studied the dwarf for several moments.

“You offer me what should already have been returned.”

“I do.”

“And in exchange?”

“Safe passage. Provisions. The return of our weapons. An escort to the eastern edge of your territory, preferably as far as the route toward Lake-town.”

Thranduil's eyes narrowed.

“You ask much.”

“I offer more.”

“Do you?”

Thorin glanced briefly toward Fíli.

His nephew stood straight and attentive, listening to every word.

One day, if all went as Thorin hoped, Fíli would stand before rulers of his own.

He would negotiate treaties, settle disputes, and carry the weight of a kingdom upon his shoulders.

Thorin wanted him to see that strength did not always require a sword.

“I also offer renewed trade between Erebor and the Woodland Realm,” Thorin continued. “Timber, crafted goods, metals, stonework, and whatever other arrangements our representatives may negotiate in good faith.”

Thranduil regarded him with renewed interest.

“And you believe your people would welcome such an arrangement?”

“Some will object.”

“An understatement, I suspect.”

“Then they may object to their king.”

Fíli lowered his head to conceal a smile.

Thranduil noticed.

“And your heir agrees with this proposal?”

Thorin turned slightly.

“Fíli?”

The young dwarf looked up.

He had not expected to be addressed.

But he recovered quickly.

“I believe,” he said carefully, “that Erebor will need allies as much as it needs walls. My uncle has taught me that a kingdom cannot thrive upon gold alone.”

Thorin felt something warm and painful settle in his chest.

Thranduil's gaze moved between them.

“A thoughtful answer.”

Fíli inclined his head.

“Thank you, Your Majesty.”

Thorin could almost hear Dwalin's disbelief if he had witnessed the exchange.

Two members of the House of Durin speaking politely to an elven king.

The world truly had changed.

But Thorin had not yet made his most important request.

“There is another matter,” he said.

Thranduil's expression cooled.

“Of course there is.”

“Lake-town.”

The Elvenking became still.

“What of it?”

“If we succeed in entering Erebor, Smaug may awaken.”

“Indeed.”

“And if he leaves the mountain, the people of Lake-town may suffer for it.”

Thranduil regarded him in silence.

“You would have me send my army against a dragon?”

“No.”

The answer came immediately.

Thranduil paused.

Thorin continued.

“I would have you save those who cannot fight one.”

The Elvenking's eyes narrowed.

“Explain.”

Thorin stepped forward.

“If there are signs that Smaug has left the mountain, your scouts could warn the settlement. Your people know the forest and waterways better than any others. They could help guide civilians toward safer ground, assist with boats and evacuation, and prepare places of refuge.”

He hesitated.

In his mind, Lake-town burned.

He remembered the dragon's shadow passing over the rooftops. Remembered flames reflected upon the water and the cries of people fleeing into the night.

He remembered the survivors gathering among the ruins of Dale.

Hungry.

Cold.

Desperate.

He had seen what happened when a king cared more for his treasure than for those suffering beyond his gates.

He would not become that king again.

“And if the town is destroyed,” Thorin continued, his voice lower, “the survivors will need food, blankets, clean water, medicine, and shelter. They will need healers. They will need somewhere to take their children.”

Thranduil watched him closely.

“You speak as though this disaster is inevitable.”

“I hope it is not.”

“Yet you would have me prepare for it.”

“Yes.”

“And you offer payment for this?”

“Additional treasure from Erebor's treasury, beyond the gems already promised. A substantial sum, to be agreed upon in writing, for the preparations and aid your people provide.”

Thranduil rose slowly from his throne.

His robes whispered against the steps as he descended.

“You offer me gold to care for Men?”

Thorin met his eyes.

“I offer you gold to prepare for a disaster I may be responsible for unleashing.”

For the first time, Thranduil looked genuinely surprised.

“A remarkable admission from a son of Durin.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“I have learned that a crown does not excuse a king from the consequences of his decisions.”

Silence settled over the hall.

Thranduil stood before him, tall and pale, his gaze searching.

“You speak of this calamity as though you have already witnessed it.”

Thorin felt his heart stumble.

For one dreadful moment, he thought of Ravenhill.

Of blood staining the snow.

Of Bilbo weeping over him.

He lowered his gaze briefly.

“I have witnessed what happens when rulers fail to consider the cost of their ambitions.”

Thranduil's expression changed.

Only slightly.

But something in his eyes grew less cold.

“You have learned an unusual lesson.”

“One I would rather not learn again.”

The Elvenking studied him for a long time.

Then he turned away.

“Lake-town lies beyond my borders. I have no obligation to risk my people for its inhabitants.”

“I know.”

“Nor will I send warriors to challenge Smaug.”

“I have not asked you to.”

“And if your quest fails, your promises are worth nothing.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“That is true.”

Thranduil looked back.

“You are remarkably willing to acknowledge uncertainty.”

“I have discovered that refusing to acknowledge it does not make it disappear.”

Balin nearly smiled.

Thranduil returned to his throne.

At last, he spoke.

“I will consider your proposal.”

Thorin waited.

“The white gems shall be returned upon the restoration of Erebor. Trade may resume under terms to be negotiated by our representatives. Your Company will receive provisions and an escort through my territory.”

Fíli drew a quiet breath.

Thranduil continued.

“As for Lake-town, I will authorize preparations for evacuation assistance and relief should the dragon threaten it. My scouts will watch the eastern approaches. Supplies may be assembled, and healers made ready. The extent of our assistance will depend upon the danger and the resources available.”

Thorin bowed his head.

“You have my gratitude.”

“Do not mistake prudence for friendship, Thorin Oakenshield.”

“I would not presume to.”

A faint, almost imperceptible smile touched Thranduil's mouth.

“Then perhaps we understand one another.”

____________

 

The agreement took considerably longer to write than Thorin had anticipated.

Elves, he discovered, possessed an extraordinary talent for turning a simple promise into several pages of precise language.

Balin appeared delighted by the process.

Fíli listened carefully as terms were discussed, occasionally asking questions that earned approving glances from the elven scribes.

Thorin endured it all with diminishing patience.

But when the final document was presented, he examined it thoroughly before placing his name beneath the promises he had made.

Fíli signed as witness.

Balin followed.

Thranduil's representatives added their own names.

And with that, something changed.

It was not friendship.

It was not forgiveness.

But it was a beginning.

When the scribes departed, Thranduil remained seated, regarding Thorin with an expression of faint curiosity.

“There is another matter.”

Thorin looked up.

“My son tells me you lost a companion in the forest.”

The sudden mention of Bilbo struck him like a blow.

“We were separated.”

“A halfling, I believe.”

“A hobbit.”

“Of course.”

Thranduil folded his hands.

“And this hobbit is important to you.”

Thorin's expression tightened.

“He is a member of my Company.”

“That was not what I asked.”

Fíli looked very carefully at the floor.

Thorin met the Elvenking's gaze.

“Yes.”

Thranduil waited.

Thorin drew a slow breath.

“He is very dear to me.”

The words hung between them.

There was no embarrassment in Thorin's voice.

Only a quiet certainty.

Thranduil regarded him for a moment.

Then he inclined his head.

“I shall instruct my scouts to continue searching.”

Thorin's throat tightened unexpectedly.

“Thank you.”

The Elvenking looked away.

“Do not thank me until he is found.”

_____________

 

Bilbo found the Company by following the sound of Dwalin complaining.

It was, he reflected, an extraordinarily reliable method of navigation.

The dwarves had been given a spacious chamber with carved wooden furnishings, a long table, and several benches. Two guards remained outside the door, but the Company had been provided with water, fresh bread, fruit, and enough food to convince Bombur that their circumstances were improving considerably.

Bilbo slipped inside when a servant entered carrying another tray.

He waited behind a carved screen until the elf departed.

Then he removed the Ring.

The world seemed to warm around him.

He drew a shaky breath.

For a moment, he simply stood there, feeling the familiar weight of his body return.

The Ring rested in his palm.

He stared at it.

Then, with a sudden unpleasant shiver, he tucked it deep into his pocket.

“Bilbo?”

Ori's startled voice made him look up.

The young dwarf stood beside the table, a piece of bread halfway to his mouth.

Bilbo smiled weakly.

“Hello.”

The bread fell.

For one extraordinary moment, nobody moved.

Then Kíli shouted.

“BILBO!”

The room erupted.

Bofur nearly overturned a chair. Bombur abandoned his meal. Dori demanded to know where the hobbit had come from, while Nori immediately began laughing.

Kíli reached him first.

He threw both arms around Bilbo so enthusiastically that the hobbit staggered backward.

“You're alive!”

“Yes, well, I was rather hoping to remain so!”

Fíli and Balin entered at that exact moment.

Both stopped.

Balin's face softened.

Fíli stared.

Then he grinned.

“Oh, Uncle is going to lose his mind.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Your uncle?”

“Where is he?” Kíli demanded.

“With the Elvenking,” Fíli answered. “He should be here shortly.”

Bilbo's smile faded slightly.

He remembered Thorin calling his name in the forest.

The fear in his voice.

The way he had looked back again and again.

“Is he all right?” Bilbo asked quietly.

Fíli's expression gentled.

“He will be.”

Thorin entered the chamber several minutes later.

He was still speaking to Balin about the agreement when he heard a familiar voice.

“Well, I must say, that went considerably better than I expected.”

He stopped.

The words were ordinary.

Cheerful.

A little breathless.

And so achingly familiar that for a moment he could not understand what he was hearing.

Then he looked up.

Bilbo stood beside the table.

His curls were tangled, his clothes filthy, and there was a fresh scrape along one cheek.

He looked exhausted.

He looked alive.

He looked like the most beautiful thing Thorin had ever seen.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit smiled.

“Hello, Thorin.”

Thorin crossed the room.

He did not remember moving.

One moment he stood in the doorway, and the next Bilbo was in his arms.

Thorin held him tightly, one hand pressed against the back of his head, the other wrapped around his shoulders.

Bilbo made a startled sound.

Then he returned the embrace.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Thorin buried his face against the hobbit's curls.

For a moment, he could not speak.

He could feel Bilbo breathing.

Could feel the warmth of him.

Could hear his heartbeat.

Alive.

Alive.

Alive.

“I thought—”

His voice failed.

Bilbo tightened his arms.

“I know.”

“I couldn't find you.”

“I know.”

Thorin drew him closer.

“Bilbo…”

“I'm here.”

The hobbit's voice trembled.

“I'm right here, Thorin.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

In another life, he had held Bilbo while dying.

He remembered the warmth of the hobbit's hands against his face, the desperate tears, the words they had exchanged too late.

He remembered believing that he would never hear Bilbo's voice again.

And now—

Now Bilbo was holding him.

Not in grief.

Not in farewell.

But because he had returned.

Thorin's breath shuddered.

Bilbo gently rubbed his back.

“You'll have to forgive me,” the hobbit murmured. “I seem to have made rather a dramatic entrance.”

A broken laugh escaped Thorin.

“You have a talent for it.”

“So I've been told.”

They remained together for another moment.

Around them, the Company had fallen quiet.

Even Kíli did not interrupt.

At last, Thorin drew back just enough to look at Bilbo's face.

“You're hurt.”

“Only a little.”

“Your cheek—”

“A branch.”

“Your shoulder?”

“Another branch.”

Thorin frowned.

“How many branches did you encounter?”

Bilbo considered.

“An unreasonable number.”

Thorin laughed again.

This time, the sound was steadier.

He rested his forehead briefly against Bilbo's.

“You frightened me.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“I know.”

“Do not do it again.”

“I shall endeavour to be considerably less troublesome in future.”

Thorin gave him a look.

Bilbo smiled.

“Although I cannot promise miracles.”

Their relief was interrupted by a knock.

A guard entered.

“King Thranduil requests the presence of the hobbit.”

Bilbo went pale.

“Oh.”

Dwalin folded his arms.

“Seems the Elvenking's heard about our burglar.”

Thorin's expression hardened.

“He will not go alone.”

The guard hesitated.

“His Majesty has requested—”

“Then inform His Majesty that I shall accompany him.”

Bilbo glanced up at Thorin.

For a moment, he looked as though he might protest.

Then he sighed.

“Well. I suppose I was going to meet him eventually.”

_____________

 

Thranduil regarded the hobbit standing before his throne with unmistakable curiosity.

Bilbo bowed.

Rather awkwardly.

“Your Majesty.”

“So,” the Elvenking said. “You are the missing halfling.”

“Hobbit, actually.”

Thranduil's eyebrow rose.

“Indeed.”

“Yes. Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

“How curious.”

Bilbo swallowed.

Thorin stood beside him, his expression carefully neutral.

Thranduil leaned forward.

“My guards searched the forest for you.”

“Yes, Your Majesty.”

“They found nothing.”

“So I understand.”

“And yet you are now standing inside my kingdom.”

Bilbo shifted his weight.

“Yes.”

“How?”

A silence followed.

Bilbo glanced toward Thorin.

The dwarf did not rescue him.

But he did offer the smallest encouraging nod.

Bilbo drew a breath.

“Well, I followed your guards.”

Thranduil stared.

“You followed them.”

“Yes.”

“Through the forest.”

“Yes.”

“Past the watchposts.”

“More or less.”

“And through the gates of my kingdom.”

Bilbo winced.

“When you put it like that, it does sound rather improper.”

Legolas, standing beside the throne, looked deeply offended.

“You were behind us?”

Bilbo turned toward him.

“Not all the time.”

“Where were you?”

“Sometimes beside you.”

Legolas stared.

Thranduil slowly turned his head toward his son.

Legolas looked as though he wished the floor would open beneath him.

Bilbo hurried to explain.

“I'm terribly sorry. I didn't mean to cause trouble. But my friends had been taken away, and I wasn't certain what would happen to them, and I thought perhaps I might be able to help.”

Thranduil studied him.

“And none of my guards saw you?”

Bilbo gave an apologetic little shrug.

“Hobbits are rather good at moving quietly.”

“Apparently.”

“I assure you, Your Majesty, your guards were very impressive.”

“Were they?”

“Oh, exceedingly.”

“And yet you passed them all.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Well, they were rather occupied with thirteen dwarves.”

Thorin made a suspicious sound.

Bilbo glanced at him.

The dwarf was looking toward the ceiling with extraordinary concentration.

Thranduil noticed.

“And you find this amusing, Thorin Oakenshield?”

“Not at all.”

“You are smiling.”

“A misunderstanding.”

“Indeed.”

Bilbo wished desperately that someone would change the subject.

Thranduil folded his hands.

“Tell me, Master Baggins. Did you enter my halls intending to steal something?”

Bilbo looked genuinely scandalized.

“Certainly not!”

“You call yourself a burglar.”

Bilbo blinked.

Then he turned toward Thorin.

“Did you tell him that?”

Thorin looked mildly guilty.

“It may have been mentioned.”

Bilbo sighed.

“Well, yes, technically, but I haven't actually burgled anything here.”

Thranduil regarded him.

“An impressive distinction.”

“Thank you.”

“I was not complimenting you.”

“Oh.”

For the first time, the Elvenking's mouth curved very slightly.

Thorin stepped forward.

“Master Baggins is a member of my Company. He came here to ensure our safety, and he has taken nothing from your halls. I ask that he be included under the terms of our agreement.”

Thranduil looked between them.

His gaze lingered upon the way Thorin stood slightly closer to Bilbo than necessary.

Then he inclined his head.

“Very well.”

Bilbo exhaled.

“Thank you, Your Majesty.”

“Though I would advise you not to make a habit of entering my kingdom unnoticed.”

Bilbo nodded earnestly.

“Of course.”

Thranduil turned toward Legolas.

“And perhaps our guards might benefit from reviewing their procedures.”

Legolas closed his eyes briefly.

“Yes, Father.”

Thorin's shoulders shook once.

Bilbo elbowed him.

Gently.

But with considerable meaning.

______________

 

Later that evening, Thranduil stood upon a balcony overlooking the underground river.

Legolas joined him.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then the prince said, “You believe the hobbit's explanation?”

“Parts of it.”

“He could not have followed us without being seen.”

“And yet he did.”

Legolas frowned.

“There is something unusual about him.”

“Undoubtedly.”

“And Thorin Oakenshield?”

Thranduil looked toward the distant halls.

“More unusual still.”

Legolas hesitated.

“He was not what I expected.”

“No.”

“He surrendered his weapons. He negotiated. He offered to return the gems.”

“And he asked us to prepare aid for Men who have not yet suffered any disaster.”

Legolas nodded.

“Why?”

Thranduil was silent for a long moment.

He remembered Thorin's expression when he spoke of Lake-town.

The grief behind his eyes.

The terrible certainty with which he described suffering that had not yet occurred.

“I do not know,” the Elvenking answered.

Then, more quietly, “But he speaks like a king who has already witnessed the ruin of his kingdom.”

Legolas looked toward him.

Thranduil did not explain further.

Instead, he turned back toward the river.

“See that our guests are properly supplied tomorrow.”

“Yes, Father.”

“And Legolas?”

The prince paused.

“You will accompany them.”

Legolas inclined his head.

“As you wish.”

Thranduil's gaze returned to the darkness beyond the halls.

“Watch them carefully.”

“The dwarves?”

“The hobbit.”

Legolas frowned.

“You believe him dangerous?”

Thranduil's expression remained perfectly composed.

“No. I believe he is considerably more interesting than he wishes us to think.”

By the time the Company had finished supper, Bilbo was beginning to feel human again.

Or hobbit, rather.

He had eaten more than was strictly necessary, washed the worst of the forest from his hands and face, and finally sat down beside Thorin with a cup of warm tea.

The others were scattered around the chamber.

Bombur had fallen asleep after his second helping of supper. Bofur was quietly singing while repairing a strap. Kíli and Fíli were arguing about whether elven architecture was impressive or merely unnecessarily complicated.

Dwalin had announced that he distrusted the entire kingdom.

Then he had eaten three servings of its food.

Bilbo considered this a promising beginning.

Thorin sat beside him, unusually quiet.

The hobbit glanced at him.

“Are you tired?”

“A little.”

“Your hair has come undone.”

Thorin touched the loose braid near his temple.

“So it has.”

Bilbo set down his tea.

“Would you like me to fix it?”

Thorin looked at him.

For a moment, his expression softened in a way that made Bilbo's stomach flutter.

“Yes,” he answered.

Bilbo shifted closer.

He gently gathered the loose strands, smoothing them between his fingers.

Thorin lowered his head to make the task easier.

For several minutes, neither spoke.

The room was warm.

The Company's quiet conversations drifted around them.

Beyond the doors, the underground river murmured against the stone.

It was almost peaceful.

Then Thorin spoke.

“How did you escape the spiders?”

Bilbo's fingers paused.

“I hid.”

“And the elves?”

“I followed them.”

“Without being seen.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Yes.”

Thorin was silent.

He remembered Bilbo crouched among the roots, desperately searching for something.

Remembered the strange expression upon his face.

The sharp, possessive refusal when Thorin told him to leave it.

He could ask.

He could demand an explanation.

He could insist that Bilbo reveal whatever secret he had been keeping.

But he remembered the hobbit's words in Mirkwood.

You cannot protect me from everything.

And he remembered how much courage it had taken for Bilbo to return to them.

Thorin lowered his gaze.

“I'm glad you found us.”

Bilbo's hands resumed their work.

“So am I.”

A pause.

“Thorin?”

“Hm?”

“I heard you in the forest.”

Thorin went still.

Bilbo carefully separated another strand of hair.

“When the elves took you. I heard you calling for me.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“I thought you were dead.”

“I know.”

“I thought—”

He stopped.

Bilbo gently rested a hand against his shoulder.

“You don't have to explain.”

Thorin turned slightly.

The hobbit's eyes were warm and earnest.

“I was frightened too,” Bilbo admitted. “But I knew I couldn't leave you there.”

Thorin looked at him for a long moment.

Then he reached for Bilbo's hand.

He held it carefully between his own.

“You have given me more reasons to be grateful than I know how to name.”

Bilbo's cheeks warmed.

“Oh, well.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“An eloquent answer.”

“I am capable of better ones when I'm not being stared at.”

“Then I shall endeavour to stare less.”

“I didn't say that.”

The words escaped before Bilbo could stop them.

Thorin's smile deepened.

Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.

For a moment, the air between them seemed to grow very still.

Then Kíli shouted from across the chamber.

“BILBO! FÍLI SAYS ELVEN BREAD IS BETTER THAN DWARVEN BREAD!”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

Thorin sighed.

“Does he?”

“HE DOES!”

Fíli's indignant voice followed.

“I SAID IT WAS GOOD BREAD!”

Bilbo began to laugh.

The moment passed.

But when he returned to Thorin's braid, the dwarf remained close enough that their shoulders touched.

Neither moved away.

_____________

 

The following morning, the Company discovered that Thranduil had honoured his promises.

Their weapons were returned, cleaned and properly maintained. Orcrist was placed in Thorin's hands by an elven guard who looked distinctly reluctant to surrender such a blade.

Bilbo received Sting with visible relief.

There were fresh provisions, waterskins, blankets, medicinal supplies, and enough food for several days' travel.

Bofur inspected the bundles appreciatively.

“Now this,” he declared, “is the sort of hospitality I can understand.”

Dwalin grunted.

“Don't get accustomed to it.”

Bombur was already examining the food.

Thorin approached Thranduil near the entrance to the halls.

The Elvenking stood with Legolas and several armed warriors.

“Your escort is prepared,” Thranduil said. “My son will lead you through the remaining forest and toward the river route to Lake-town.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“You have kept your word.”

“As I expect you to keep yours.”

“I shall.”

Thranduil regarded him for a moment.

Then his gaze moved toward Bilbo, who was standing beside Fíli and Kíli, examining a small packet of herbs provided by an elven healer.

“Your hobbit appears considerably less distressed than he did yesterday.”

Thorin looked toward him.

Bilbo was smiling at something Kíli had said.

The sight warmed him.

“He is resilient.”

“So I have observed.”

Thranduil paused.

“See that he does not wander into my kingdom unnoticed again.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“I shall endeavour to prevent it.”

“I suspect you will find that difficult.”

Thorin looked at Bilbo once more.

“Aye,” he admitted. “I suspect I shall.”

For a moment, the two rulers stood together in silence.

Then Thranduil inclined his head.

“May your road be less troubled than the one that brought you here.”

Thorin returned the gesture.

“And may your people know peace.”

It was not friendship.

Not yet.

But when Thorin turned away, he found that the old bitterness no longer weighed quite so heavily upon him.

_____________

 

The Company departed beneath the morning light.

Legolas led the escort, accompanied by several Woodland Realm warriors whose bows and blades gleamed beneath their cloaks.

Fíli and Kíli walked near the front, arguing cheerfully about who had killed more spiders.

Dwalin remained suspicious of the elves.

Balin seemed quietly delighted by the successful negotiations.

And Bilbo walked beside Thorin, his pack newly filled, his sword at his hip, and his curls still slightly damp from the morning's washing.

For a while, they travelled in comfortable silence.

Then Bilbo noticed a small flowering plant growing beside the path.

He stopped.

“Oh!”

Thorin looked down.

“What is it?”

“Look at that.”

Thorin examined the plant.

It had narrow silver-green leaves and tiny pale blossoms.

“A flower.”

Bilbo gave him an exasperated look.

“Yes, thank you. I had gathered that much.”

Legolas, walking a few paces ahead, glanced back.

“That is a moonbell.”

Bilbo brightened immediately.

“A moonbell?”

“It flowers only beneath the oldest trees. Its petals close when touched.”

Bilbo crouched beside it.

“How extraordinary.”

Legolas approached.

“They were once common throughout Greenwood. Now they are rarely seen so far east.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Does it require a particular sort of soil?”

Legolas considered the question.

Then, to Thorin's considerable surprise, he knelt beside the hobbit.

“It does. The roots prefer damp earth beneath beech and oak, though they may survive beneath other trees if the ground remains shaded.”

Bilbo listened with unmistakable fascination.

“And do they grow from seeds?”

“Sometimes. More often from spreading roots.”

“Oh, how interesting!”

Thorin watched them.

Then he glanced toward Fíli.

His nephew was smiling.

Kíli, however, looked distinctly unimpressed.

“It's a flower,” he muttered.

Fíli grinned.

“I believe that's already been established.”

Bilbo asked another question.

Legolas answered.

And as the Company resumed its journey, the hobbit fell into step beside the elven prince, discussing the plants of Mirkwood with an enthusiasm that seemed entirely unaffected by the fact that the forest had recently attempted to eat him.

Kíli watched them go.

Then he looked at his brother.

“Since when does Bilbo like elves?”

Fíli laughed.

Thorin shook his head, though there was a faint smile upon his face.

Ahead, Bilbo's delighted laughter carried through the trees.

And for the first time in many days, Thorin allowed himself to believe that perhaps the road before them might hold something other than sorrow.

He had changed the course of their journey.

He had negotiated where once he had fought.

He had made promises that might save lives.

And Bilbo was beside him.

Alive.

Smiling.

Safe, at least for now.

Yet beyond the trees, the Lonely Mountain waited.

And somewhere in the wilderness, orcs still hunted the heirs of Durin.

Thorin knew better than to believe that danger had passed.

But as he watched Bilbo enthusiastically question Legolas about a particularly ancient tree, he found himself smiling.

For the moment, that was enough.

Chapter 12: Chapter Twelve — The Things We Hold Dear

Chapter Text

For the first time in what felt like an age, Bilbo Baggins woke to the sound of birdsong rather than the expectation of imminent death.

It was a considerable improvement.

He lay beneath his blanket for a few moments, listening to the unfamiliar melody drifting through the trees. The forest around them was still dark beneath its enormous canopy, but the air smelled pleasantly of damp earth, woodsmoke, and the faint sweetness of flowers. Somewhere nearby, Bombur was already making enough noise with the cooking equipment to suggest that breakfast was being prepared.

Bilbo opened one eye.

Thorin sat several feet away, speaking quietly with Balin over a map.

His hair was loose around his shoulders, save for the braids Bilbo had repaired the previous evening, and the morning light caught the silver threads woven through the dark strands. He looked tired, certainly, but there was something different about him now. Some of the tension that had followed him since they entered Mirkwood seemed to have eased.

Perhaps it was the knowledge that his Company had escaped the spiders. Perhaps it was their newly secured passage toward Lake-town, or the fact that they had left Thranduil's halls with their weapons, provisions, and dignity largely intact.

Or perhaps, Bilbo thought rather fondly, Thorin was simply enjoying the rare pleasure of having something go according to plan.

The dwarf looked up.

Their eyes met.

Thorin smiled.

Bilbo felt an absurd little flutter in his stomach.

Oh, bother.

That had been happening rather frequently lately.

“Good morning,” Thorin said.

“Is it?”

“I believe so.”

Bilbo sat up and pushed his curls out of his eyes. “Well, I shall reserve judgment until I've seen breakfast.”

Thorin chuckled.

“Bombur has been awake for some time.”

“In that case, I withdraw my objections.”

He began gathering his blanket, only to discover that a second cloak had been laid over him during the night.

A familiar, heavy cloak.

Bilbo looked down at it.

Then at Thorin.

The dwarf had already returned his attention to the map, wearing an expression of studied innocence.

Bilbo smiled to himself.

He folded the cloak carefully before carrying it over.

“You know,” he said, setting it beside Thorin, “I do possess a perfectly serviceable blanket.”

“So I've noticed.”

“And a cloak of my own.”

“Indeed.”

“And yet I seem to wake up wearing yours rather often.”

Thorin looked up.

“Does it trouble you?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“No,” he admitted. “Not particularly.”

“Then I see no problem.”

Bilbo shook his head, but his smile lingered as he walked toward breakfast.

Behind him, Balin watched Thorin fold the returned cloak with rather more care than the task required.

The old dwarf said nothing.

He had learned that there were certain things best left to unfold in their own time.

___________

 

The Woodland Realm looked remarkably different when one was not stumbling through it half-starved, frightened, and pursued by monstrous spiders.

Bilbo had never imagined he would find himself thinking kindly of Mirkwood, yet as the Company followed the elven escort along a narrow path beneath the trees, he began to understand why its inhabitants loved it.

Sunlight filtered through the canopy in long golden shafts, illuminating moss-covered roots and delicate ferns. Tiny white flowers grew beside the path, and the air was filled with the soft murmur of leaves.

The elves moved almost silently.

The dwarves did not.

Dwalin complained about the roots. Glóin complained about the elves. Bombur complained that the morning meal had been insufficient, despite having eaten considerably more than anyone else.

Bilbo, meanwhile, had become distracted by a bird.

“That cannot possibly be a thrush,” he murmured.

Thorin, walking beside him, glanced upward.

“Why not?”

“The song is wrong.”

“Perhaps it's an unusual thrush.”

Bilbo gave him a look.

“Thorin.”

“What?”

“You cannot simply call every unfamiliar bird an unusual thrush.”

“I wasn't aware there were rules.”

“There are certainly standards.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

Ahead of them, Legolas slowed his pace.

“It is a silverthroat,” he said.

Bilbo brightened.

“A silverthroat?”

“They nest among the older beeches. Their songs change with the seasons.”

“How fascinating! We have song thrushes in the Shire, of course, but nothing quite like that.”

Legolas tilted his head toward the branches.

“If you listen carefully, you may hear its mate answering.”

Bilbo stopped.

A moment later, another melody drifted through the trees.

“Oh!” he exclaimed. “There it is!”

Legolas smiled.

And so began a conversation that lasted nearly the entire morning.

____________

 

Bilbo discovered that Legolas possessed an astonishing knowledge of woodland plants, birds, and trees. Legolas discovered that hobbits, or at least this particular hobbit, were remarkably knowledgeable about gardening.

“You grow all of these plants yourself?” the elf asked.

“Good heavens, no. Some are terribly particular about where they'll grow. But I've managed roses, lavender, rosemary, several varieties of mint, and a respectable number of vegetables.”

“Vegetables?”

Bilbo looked scandalized.

“Of course vegetables. What else would one grow in a proper garden?”

“Flowers, perhaps.”

“Flowers are lovely, but one cannot make a satisfactory supper out of them.”

Legolas laughed.

Behind them, Kíli narrowed his eyes.

Fíli noticed immediately.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“Then why are you glaring at the elf?”

“I'm not glaring.”

“You look as though he's stolen something.”

Kíli folded his arms.

“He has.”

Fíli followed his brother's gaze.

Legolas was pointing out a climbing vine while Bilbo listened with obvious delight.

Fíli stared at Kíli.

Then he began to laugh.

“Oh, don't start,” Kíli muttered.

“Our hobbit?”

Kíli scowled.

“He's been talking to him all morning.”

“We've only been walking for an hour.”

“An hour is a long time.”

“Not for an elf, apparently.”

Kíli looked deeply offended.

Fíli laughed harder.

Several paces ahead, Thorin heard enough of the conversation to understand the problem.

He glanced toward Bilbo.

The hobbit was smiling, asking another question about the forest.

Thorin felt no particular resentment toward Legolas. He had seen too much death in one lifetime to begrudge Bilbo a new friendship, especially one that brought him such obvious happiness.

Besides, the elven prince was proving a capable guide.

But Kíli's expression was another matter entirely.

Thorin looked away before his nephew could catch him smiling.

____________

 

They stopped for their midday meal beside an enormous oak.

Its roots twisted through the earth like the backs of sleeping serpents, and the trunk was so wide that Bilbo suspected half the Company could have stood behind it without being seen.

Legolas approached the tree and rested a hand against its bark.

“This one was already old when my grandfather ruled the Greenwood.”

Bilbo stared upward.

“Good gracious.”

“Many of the oldest trees have survived the darkness, though their growth has changed.”

“Changed how?”

“Their branches turn away from places where the shadow has taken hold. Some no longer flower. Others have ceased producing seeds.”

Bilbo's delight softened into sadness.

“That is dreadful.”

Legolas nodded.

“There was a time when this forest was known as Greenwood the Great. Its paths were brighter then.”

Bilbo studied the enormous oak.

After a moment, he said, “Well, if the roots are still alive, there's hope, isn't there?”

Legolas looked at him.

“You believe the forest can recover?”

“Of course. Gardens can be stubborn things. I've seen roses survive winters that ought to have killed them and trees recover after losing nearly every branch. Sometimes they need time. Sometimes they need someone willing to care for them.”

Legolas smiled faintly.

“You speak as though the forest were a garden.”

“Isn't it? Only a rather enormous one.”

The elf laughed.

Nearby, Thorin had been listening.

If the roots are still alive, there's hope.

The words settled somewhere deep within him.

He thought of Erebor, abandoned beneath the mountain.

Of his people, scattered and grieving.

Of the throne he had once reclaimed only to lose himself upon it.

And of the impossible gift of another chance.

Perhaps Bilbo was right.

Perhaps even things that had been broken for a very long time could grow again.

When Bilbo returned to him, carrying a small leaf that Legolas had given him, Thorin reached for his hand.

Bilbo looked up in surprise.

“You are a remarkable creature, Bilbo Baggins.”

The hobbit's cheeks turned pink.

“Oh, nonsense.”

“I mean it.”

“Well, I should hope so. Otherwise you've developed a very strange habit of complimenting people for no reason.”

Thorin smiled.

Bilbo smiled back.

And when Thorin released his hand, the hobbit found himself wishing he hadn't.

___________

 

That evening, Bilbo discovered something rather alarming about himself.

He was beginning to suspect that he was in love with Thorin Oakenshield.

The realization came while he was sitting beside the campfire, attempting to repair a small tear in his waistcoat.

Thorin had approached with Bilbo's cloak in his hands.

“You left this beside the stream.”

“Oh. Thank you.”

The dwarf crouched before him.

“Your clasp is loose.”

“Is it?”

Before Bilbo could investigate, Thorin gently adjusted the fastening beneath his chin.

His fingers brushed the side of Bilbo's neck.

The hobbit went very still.

It was such a small gesture.

Thorin had helped him countless times throughout their journey. He had offered his hand over difficult ground, carried Bilbo's pack when he was exhausted, and wrapped blankets around him during cold nights.

But lately, every touch seemed to linger in Bilbo's thoughts.

“There,” Thorin murmured.

Bilbo swallowed.

“Thank you.”

Thorin brushed a stray curl from his forehead.

“You've leaves in your hair again.”

“Occupational hazard of travelling through a forest.”

“Apparently.”

His hand lingered for a moment before falling away.

When Thorin returned to his place beside Balin, Bilbo remained staring at his sewing.

He had never been particularly interested in romance.

There had been pleasant hobbits in the Shire, certainly, and his relatives had occasionally suggested suitable matches, but none had ever made him feel quite like this.

None had made him look forward to the sound of their footsteps.

None had made him notice the absence of their voice in a crowded room.

And certainly none had made his heart behave so foolishly over something as ordinary as having his cloak straightened.

Bilbo glanced toward Thorin.

The dwarf was listening to Balin, his expression thoughtful.

Bilbo found himself imagining something entirely unreasonable.

A quiet evening.

A warm hearth.

Thorin sitting in one of his armchairs at Bag End, reading while Bilbo prepared tea.

Or perhaps Bilbo himself sitting beside a fire in Erebor, listening to Thorin speak about his day.

The setting hardly mattered.

That was the truly extraordinary part.

For the first time in his life, Bilbo found himself thinking that home might not be a place at all.

It might be a person.

He looked down at his sewing.

Oh dear.

He was in considerable trouble.

_____________

 

By the second afternoon, Kíli had reached the limits of his patience.

Legolas had spent the morning explaining the medicinal properties of various plants to Bilbo.

Then he had shown him how to identify the age of certain trees.

Then they had discussed birds.

Again.

Kíli had attempted to participate.

It had not gone well.

“What kind of tree is this?” Legolas asked, gesturing toward a towering trunk.

Kíli examined it.

“A large one.”

Bilbo laughed.

Legolas remained politely composed.

“Yes. But what kind?”

Kíli looked up.

“A very large one.”

Fíli made a strangled noise.

Bilbo pressed a hand over his mouth.

Kíli glared at them.

“Well, it is!”

“It certainly is,” Bilbo managed.

Kíli decided he had suffered enough humiliation for one day.

At their next resting place, he sat upon a fallen log with his arms folded, wearing the expression of a dwarf who had been personally betrayed by the world.

Bilbo found him several minutes later.

“Kíli?”

No answer.

“Good heavens. Who died?”

“Nobody.”

“Has someone stolen your lunch?”

“No.”

“Has your brother finally decided to abandon you in the wilderness?”

Kíli looked up indignantly.

“Fíli wouldn't do that.”

“Quite right. He's far too patient for his own good.”

“I heard that!” Fíli called from nearby.

“You were meant to!” Bilbo answered.

Kíli remained stubbornly silent.

Bilbo studied him.

Then understanding dawned.

“Oh, you ridiculous creature.”

Kíli frowned.

“What?”

“Is this about Legolas?”

“No.”

“Kíli.”

“Perhaps.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

“Whatever has he done to upset you?”

Kíli looked at him as though the answer were obvious.

“He's stealing you.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Stealing me?”

“You spend all your time with him now.”

“Good heavens, Kíli, we've been travelling together for months.”

“Exactly!”

“And you think a few conversations about trees are going to make me forget you?”

Kíli looked away.

Bilbo's expression softened.

Somewhere along the road, these two young dwarves had become terribly dear to him.

He worried about them. He scolded them. He found himself making sure they had eaten properly and checking whether they were warm enough at night.

It was rather like acquiring two particularly troublesome younger relatives.

“Oh, come here.”

Kíli looked suspicious.

“Why?”

“Because you're being a silly thing.”

Before the dwarf could protest, Bilbo gently caught his face between his hands and pressed a warm kiss against his forehead.

Kíli froze.

Bilbo smiled.

“There. Will that cure your terrible suffering?”

For several seconds, Kíli simply stared at him.

Then a delighted grin spread across his face.

“Yes.”

Bilbo chuckled.

“Good. Now listen to me. Making another friend doesn't mean I care for my old ones any less.”

Kíli nodded.

“And you're very dear to me.”

“Very?”

“Very.”

“More than the elf?”

Bilbo sighed.

“Kíli.”

“Just asking.”

Bilbo laughed and smoothed a rebellious strand of hair away from his forehead.

“Go and help your brother with the firewood.”

Kíli rose immediately.

He had never looked happier.

_____________

 

Unfortunately, Fíli had witnessed everything.

And so had Thorin.

Fíli approached his uncle with the unmistakable expression of someone preparing to make himself extremely unpleasant.

Thorin recognized it immediately.

He had seen that particular smile before broken furniture, missing tools, and several childhood incidents involving Kíli and an unfortunate goat.

“Uncle.”

“Fíli.”

“Lovely afternoon.”

Thorin glanced toward the canopy.

“We haven't seen the sun in two days.”

“Wonderful weather for the trees, then.”

Thorin narrowed his eyes.

“What do you want?”

Fíli folded his arms.

“Nothing. I was merely thinking how affectionate our burglar has become.”

Thorin's hands stopped moving.

“Has he?”

“Oh, yes.”

Fíli glanced toward Kíli, who was helping Bofur gather wood with the expression of a dwarf who had personally conquered Erebor.

“Quite affectionate.”

Thorin exhaled.

“Master Baggins is entitled to show affection toward his friends.”

“Of course.”

“Particularly when one of those friends is behaving like a child.”

“Certainly.”

A pause.

“Though I must admit, I hadn't expected Kíli to receive the first kiss.”

Thorin turned slowly.

Fíli smiled.

“Something troubling you, Uncle?”

“Not in the slightest.”

“Because you look rather—”

“Finish that sentence carefully.”

“—thoughtful.”

Thorin stared at him.

Fíli's grin widened.

“It's understandable, really. You've spent months being terribly attentive to Bilbo, and then Kíli sulks for five minutes and—”

“Fíli.”

“—receives a kiss.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“Do you have nothing useful to occupy yourself with?”

“Not particularly.”

“Find something.”

Fíli laughed.

But then his gaze drifted toward his brother again.

Kíli was still smiling.

Still looking unbearably pleased with himself.

Fíli's own amusement faded slightly.

Thorin noticed.

One dark eyebrow rose.

“Something troubling you, Fíli?”

“No.”

“Because you look rather thoughtful.”

Fíli frowned.

“That is entirely different.”

“Is it?”

“Obviously.”

Thorin folded his arms.

“Then perhaps you should explain the difference.”

Fíli opened his mouth.

Before he could answer, a familiar voice interrupted them.

“Good heavens. What's happened to the two of you?”

Bilbo stood a few steps away, carrying a small bundle of herbs.

Fíli immediately straightened.

“Nothing.”

Thorin answered at precisely the same moment.

“Your princes are behaving like children.”

“Your princes?” Fíli repeated indignantly.

Bilbo looked between them.

Then his gaze settled upon Fíli.

He studied the young dwarf's folded arms, the stubborn set of his jaw, and the way his eyes kept drifting toward Kíli.

Understanding dawned.

“Oh.”

Fíli frowned.

“Oh, what?”

Bilbo's mouth twitched.

“Fíli, are you jealous?”

The prince looked scandalized.

“Of Kíli?”

“Well, yes.”

“Certainly not!”

Bilbo raised an eyebrow.

“Of course not.”

“I'm the Crown Prince of Erebor.”

“Yes, dear, I'm aware.”

“I do not become jealous because my younger brother receives a little attention.”

“Quite right.”

“Especially not over something as ridiculous as a kiss on the forehead.”

“Absolutely.”

Thorin made a suspicious choking noise.

Fíli glared at him.

Bilbo sighed with the patience of someone dealing with a particularly stubborn child.

Then he stepped closer.

“Oh, come here, you silly thing.”

“Bilbo, what are you—”

The hobbit reached up, gently caught Fíli by the shoulders, and pulled him down just enough to press a warm kiss against his forehead.

Fíli went completely still.

Bilbo smiled at him.

“There. You're both very dear to me, and I won't have either of you thinking otherwise.”

For several seconds, Fíli simply stared.

Then his expression changed.

A slow, delighted smile spread across his face.

“Oh.”

Bilbo chuckled.

“Better?”

“Considerably.”

“Good.”

He patted Fíli's cheek and turned away, apparently satisfied that he had resolved the matter.

Fíli watched him go.

Then, very slowly, he turned toward Thorin.

The king had not moved.

His expression was extraordinary.

Not angry, exactly.

Not even particularly annoyed.

Rather, he looked like a dwarf who had just watched the universe commit a personal injustice.

Fíli's smile grew.

“Well,” he said pleasantly.

Thorin stared straight ahead.

“Don't.”

“I wasn't going to say anything.”

“Good.”

A pause.

“Though I suppose that makes two of us.”

Thorin inhaled.

Slowly.

Deeply.

“Fíli.”

“Yes, Uncle?”

“Go away.”

Fíli laughed so hard that he nearly doubled over.

Across the clearing, Kíli finally noticed what had happened.

“WAIT!”

Both dwarves turned.

Kíli was staring at his brother in outrage.

“BILBO KISSED YOU TOO?”

Fíli immediately straightened, looking unbearably smug.

“He did.”

“THAT WAS MY THING!”

Bilbo stopped walking.

He looked over his shoulder.

“Your what?”

“Nothing!” Kíli shouted.

Fíli folded his arms.

“Jealous, brother?”

Kíli looked betrayed.

Thorin looked exhausted.

And Bilbo, after observing all three members of the House of Durin for several moments, came to the perfectly reasonable conclusion that dwarves were in desperate need of supervision.

______________

 

Thorin remained in a peculiar mood for the rest of the afternoon.

It was ridiculous.

He knew it was ridiculous.

Bilbo's kisses had been affectionate gestures toward two young dwarves who had become extraordinarily attached to him. There had been nothing romantic about them, and Thorin was perfectly aware of that.

Indeed, watching Bilbo care for his nephews had stirred something far deeper than jealousy.

He remembered Fíli as a solemn little child who had tried desperately to behave like a grown dwarf after his father died.

He remembered Kíli falling asleep against his shoulder after long days of training, still young enough to believe his uncle could protect him from anything.

And he remembered their bodies upon Ravenhill.

The memory came without warning.

Fíli, broken and lifeless.

Kíli, bloodied and still.

Two sons of Durin who had followed him into a war from which they had never returned.

Thorin stopped walking.

Ahead, Fíli laughed at something his brother had said.

Kíli shoved him playfully.

Both were alive.

Both were happy.

And Bilbo had kissed their foreheads with the easy tenderness of someone who loved them.

Thorin lowered his gaze.

Perhaps, he thought, there were worse things than watching his nephews receive affection from the hobbit he adored.

A hand touched his arm.

“Thorin?”

He looked down.

Bilbo stood beside him, his expression concerned.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin swallowed.

“Aye.”

“You looked rather far away.”

“Only thinking.”

“Dangerous habit.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's.

The gesture was so unexpected that Thorin forgot what he had been about to say.

Bilbo looked straight ahead, his cheeks faintly pink.

“I thought,” the hobbit murmured, “that perhaps you might like some company.”

Thorin's fingers closed around his.

“Very much.”

They continued walking.

Neither released the other's hand.

And behind them, Fíli caught sight of the gesture.

He nudged Kíli.

His brother looked.

Then both princes exchanged identical, delighted smiles.

For once, neither said a word.

______________

 

That evening, Bilbo found Thorin sitting beside the stream beyond the camp.

The water moved quietly over smooth stones, reflecting the pale light of the stars that could just be glimpsed through the branches. The air smelled of damp earth and woodsmoke, and the distant murmur of the Company drifted between the trees.

Thorin had removed his outer coat and was attempting to untangle a stubborn knot in one of his braids.

Bilbo watched him for a moment.

Then he approached.

“You know,” he said, “you would have a much easier time if you simply asked for help.”

Thorin looked up.

“I was managing.”

“You've been managing that knot for ten minutes.”

“Have you been watching me?”

Bilbo's cheeks warmed.

“Only because you're sitting directly in front of me.”

Thorin smiled.

“Of course.”

Bilbo settled beside him.

“Give it here.”

Thorin obediently turned his head.

The hobbit began working through the tangled strands, his fingers moving with the familiarity of long practice.

For several minutes, they sat in comfortable silence.

Then Thorin spoke.

“Bilbo?”

“Hm?”

“May I ask you something?”

“You've been asking me things for months, Thorin. I hardly think you need permission now.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“Does my company ever grow tiresome?”

Bilbo blinked.

“What an extraordinary question.”

“An answer would be appreciated.”

“Well, of course it does.”

Thorin's expression fell so quickly that Bilbo almost laughed.

“Oh, don't look at me like that. You can be terribly stubborn, and you have an unfortunate habit of deciding that everyone around you requires protecting from things they are perfectly capable of handling themselves.”

“I see.”

“And you worry far too much.”

“Bilbo—”

“And you have an absolutely dreadful temper when you're hungry.”

Thorin sighed.

“Are you quite finished?”

“Not remotely.”

Bilbo smiled, but his expression softened as he looked at the dwarf sitting before him.

“Because despite all of that, I find that I'd rather spend an afternoon arguing with you than an entire week in the company of almost anyone else.”

Thorin became very still.

Bilbo felt his own cheeks warming.

“And when something interesting happens,” he continued more quietly, “you're usually the first person I want to tell. And when I'm frightened, I look for you. And when you're unhappy, I find that I can't quite be happy myself.”

Thorin turned toward him.

Bilbo's fingers slipped from his hair.

For a moment, the hobbit considered looking away.

He had spent so many years living comfortably alone, so certain that he understood what he wanted from life.

A warm hearth.

A well-stocked pantry.

A peaceful garden.

And now he found himself sitting beside a dwarf king in a dangerous forest, with no certainty of what tomorrow would bring, and somehow he had never felt more certain of anything.

“I don't think,” Bilbo admitted softly, “that I've ever felt quite this way about anyone before.”

Thorin's breath caught.

He had heard Bilbo confess his love once before.

On Ravenhill.

With blood upon the stones and death closing around him.

But this Bilbo had not lost him.

This Bilbo was discovering those feelings for the first time.

And Thorin wanted desperately to let him discover them without fear.

“You have become very dear to me,” he said quietly.

Bilbo's mouth curved into a nervous smile.

“I should hope so. I've spent an unreasonable amount of time making sure you don't get yourself killed.”

Thorin laughed softly.

Then he reached for Bilbo's hand.

The hobbit allowed him to take it.

Thorin turned it gently between his fingers, studying the small scratches and calluses that months of travelling had left upon Bilbo's skin.

Then, slowly enough to give him every opportunity to pull away, he lifted the hobbit's hand and pressed a kiss to his knuckles.

Bilbo fell silent.

The touch was brief.

Warm.

Unmistakably deliberate.

When Thorin lowered their hands, Bilbo was still staring at him.

“Was that all right?” Thorin asked.

Bilbo swallowed.

“Yes.”

A pause.

“Actually,” he added, his voice barely above a whisper, “I think I'd rather like it if you did that again sometime.”

Thorin smiled.

“Then I shall remember.”

Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.

He could feel his heartbeat in his throat.

He had kissed Fíli and Kíli earlier without a second thought. They were dear to him, and comforting them had felt as natural as breathing.

But the thought of kissing Thorin was altogether different.

He wondered what it would feel like to press his lips against the dwarf's cheek.

Against the corner of his mouth.

Or—

Bilbo's face grew hot.

Thorin noticed.

“Bilbo?”

“Nothing!”

One dark eyebrow rose.

“I haven't asked anything.”

“No, well, I thought perhaps you might.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo covered his face with his free hand.

“Oh, you're impossible.”

“Am I?”

“Entirely.”

Thorin gently lowered Bilbo's hand.

Their eyes met.

For a moment, Bilbo thought Thorin might kiss him.

He found, rather astonishingly, that he wanted him to.

But Thorin only brushed his thumb across the hobbit's cheek.

“There is no hurry,” he murmured.

Bilbo looked at him.

Something warm and tender settled in his chest.

“No,” he whispered. “I suppose there isn't.”

They remained beside the stream for a long while afterward, speaking quietly of the Shire, of Erebor, and of all the places they might visit when the journey was finally over.

When they returned to camp, their hands were still joined.

____________

 

The third morning began with an uneasy silence.

At first, Bilbo scarcely noticed it.

He was occupied with examining a small packet of seeds Legolas had given him, accompanied by an explanation of how they might be grown in the gentler climate of the Shire.

Kíli had been watching the exchange with renewed suspicion.

“He gave you seeds?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Yes. Isn't that thoughtful?”

Kíli stared at the packet.

“Seeds.”

“Quite.”

“You can find seeds anywhere.”

“Not these particular ones.”

Kíli looked toward Fíli.

His brother raised an eyebrow.

“Don't.”

“I wasn't going to say anything.”

“You were thinking loudly.”

Bilbo tucked the packet carefully into his bag.

“I think they're lovely.”

Kíli sighed.

Then he reached into his pocket and produced a small, smooth stone.

“Here.”

Bilbo blinked.

“What's this?”

“A stone.”

“Yes, I can see that.”

“I found it yesterday.”

Bilbo accepted it.

The stone was dark grey, with a narrow band of pale quartz running through its centre.

“Oh, Kíli.”

The young dwarf looked suddenly uncertain.

“It's not much.”

“Nonsense. It's beautiful.”

Bilbo turned it over in his palm.

“I shall keep it.”

Kíli brightened.

“Really?”

“Of course.”

He tucked it into a separate pocket.

Kíli looked positively triumphant.

Fíli leaned toward him.

“Congratulations. You've defeated the elf with a rock.”

Kíli elbowed him.

Bilbo laughed.

But the sound faded when Legolas suddenly stopped walking.

The elf stood perfectly still, his head tilted slightly toward the trees.

Thorin noticed immediately.

“What is it?”

Legolas did not answer at once.

Then he said, “The birds.”

Bilbo listened.

The forest was silent.

No silverthroats.

No rustling wings.

Even the breeze seemed to have withdrawn from the branches.

Thorin felt a familiar chill settle along his spine.

He remembered the river.

The barrels.

The orcs pouring from the trees.

He remembered Kíli crying out as an arrow struck his leg.

And he remembered the terrible sickness that followed.

“Weapons,” Thorin ordered.

The Company reacted immediately.

Dwalin drew his axes. Fíli and Kíli reached for their swords, while the elven warriors spread silently among the trees.

Legolas drew an arrow.

An elven scout appeared from the undergrowth.

“Tracks,” he reported. “Orcs. Many of them.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“How far?”

“Close.”

Legolas looked toward the narrow river crossing ahead.

“They mean to intercept us.”

Thorin surveyed the terrain.

The path descended between rocky slopes before reaching a wooden bridge spanning the river. Trees crowded both banks, their branches forming a tangled canopy above the water.

It was an excellent place for an ambush.

“Fíli,” Thorin said.

His nephew approached immediately.

“Uncle?”

“Take Kíli and Bofur to the rear. Protect the supplies and keep the path open.”

Fíli nodded.

“Dwalin, with me. Balin, keep the others together.”

Legolas studied the slopes.

“My archers will take the higher ground.”

Thorin met his gaze.

“Then we hold the crossing.”

For a moment, dwarf and elf regarded one another.

Then Legolas inclined his head.

“Agreed.”

Bilbo drew Sting.

The blade gleamed faintly blue.

Thorin looked down at him.

“Stay close.”

Bilbo lifted his chin.

“I intend to.”

“And Bilbo?”

“Yes?”

Thorin reached for his hand.

Just briefly.

“Be careful.”

Bilbo squeezed his fingers.

“You too.”

______________

 

Then the first arrow flew.

It struck the tree beside Dwalin's head.

The dwarf roared.

“ORCS!”

The forest erupted.

Dark figures poured from the slopes, their armour clattering as they descended through the undergrowth. Arrows hissed between the branches, striking trunks and splintering against rocks.

Legolas fired before the first orc reached the path.

His arrow struck its target cleanly.

Another followed.

Then another.

The elven warriors answered from the trees, their arrows cutting through the attackers with deadly precision.

But the orcs kept coming.

Thorin met the first with Orcrist.

Steel rang against steel.

He drove the creature backward, turned, and struck another across the chest.

Beside him, Dwalin fought like a storm, his axes flashing beneath the trees.

“Keep them away from the bridge!” Thorin shouted.

The Company obeyed.

Fíli took position near the rear, directing Ori and Bombur toward the safer side of the path while Kíli loosed arrows over their shoulders.

Bofur defended the supplies with his mattock.

Nori and Dori fought side by side.

And Bilbo—

Bilbo moved.

He was smaller than the orcs, quicker than they expected, and armed with a blade that seemed to shine brighter with every approaching enemy.

When an orc lunged toward an injured elven warrior, Bilbo darted forward and drove Sting into its side.

The creature collapsed.

Bilbo staggered backward, breathing hard.

The elf looked at him in surprise.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Quite all right.”

Then another orc appeared.

Bilbo raised his sword.

He had no time to be frightened.

Not yet.

Across the crossing, Legolas dropped from a low branch and landed beside Thorin.

“More are coming from the eastern slope!”

Thorin glanced toward the rocks.

“Then we must force them toward the river.”

Legolas nodded.

“I can cover the bank.”

“Do it.”

The elf moved.

Thorin turned toward his Company.

“Dwalin! Push them back!”

The dwarves advanced.

For several moments, the battle became a furious clash of steel and shouting.

Then Thorin saw him.

Kíli.

Standing near the bridge.

Bow drawn.

And above him, upon a rocky ledge, an orc lifted a black-fletched arrow.

Thorin's blood turned cold.

He knew that arrow.

He remembered the wound.

The poison.

The fever.

The desperate race against death.

“KÍLI!”

His shout tore through the battle.

The young dwarf turned.

“DOWN!”

Kíli dropped instinctively.

The arrow struck the wooden post behind him.

Thorin heard it bury itself deep in the timber.

For one terrible instant, he could not move.

Then Fíli reached his brother.

“Kíli!”

“I'm fine!”

“Are you hit?”

“No!”

Thorin forced himself forward.

An orc charged him.

He killed it almost without seeing its face.

Kíli was alive.

The arrow had missed.

He had changed it.

But the battle was not over.

A harsh cry sounded from the trees.

Legolas turned.

An orc had climbed onto a fallen trunk behind him, its blade raised.

Kíli saw it first.

“ELF!”

Legolas looked over his shoulder.

Too late.

Kíli fired.

The arrow struck the orc beneath the arm, knocking it backward before it could bring its weapon down.

Legolas spun, drew his knife, and finished the creature as it fell.

Then he looked toward Kíli.

The young dwarf lowered his bow.

For a moment, they simply stared at one another.

Legolas inclined his head.

“My thanks.”

Kíli shrugged.

“Don't mention it.”

“You saved my life.”

“Yes, well.”

Kíli glanced toward Bilbo, who was helping the wounded elf retreat behind the rocks.

“Bilbo would've been upset if something happened to his new friend.”

Legolas followed his gaze.

Then he smiled.

“Of course.”

Kíli scowled.

“Don't look at me like that.”

“Like what?”

“Like you're amused.”

“I would never.”

Kíli muttered something unflattering about elves.

Then another orc charged, and both turned to fight.

Bolg had expected the dwarves to be exhausted.

He had expected them to be poorly armed, scattered, and vulnerable after their passage through the forest.

He had not expected elven arrows.

From his position among the rocks, he watched his warriors fall beneath the combined assault of dwarves and Woodland Realm soldiers.

His lip curled.

“Cowards!” he snarled as two orcs stumbled backward from the bridge.

An arrow struck the rock beside his head.

Bolg ducked.

Across the clearing, Legolas had already drawn another.

The orc commander bared his teeth.

“Kill the elf!”

Three warriors rushed forward.

Two fell before they reached him.

The third was intercepted by a dark-haired dwarf with a bow.

Bolg's rage deepened.

This was not the battle he had planned.

The dwarves were holding their ground.

The elves controlled the trees.

And Thorin Oakenshield remained alive.

Bolg looked toward the river.

The crossing was becoming impossible to hold.

He snarled an order.

“Fall back!”

Several orcs hesitated.

Bolg struck one across the face.

“NOW!”

The surviving attackers began retreating toward the deeper forest.

Some were cut down by elven arrows.

Others disappeared among the rocks.

Bolg himself withdrew beneath the trees, furious but unwilling to sacrifice the remainder of his warriors in a battle he could no longer win.

Thorin saw them retreat.

“Hold!”

Dwalin turned toward him.

“We can finish them!”

“No.”

Thorin surveyed the wounded and the scattered supplies.

“We do not abandon our own to chase them.”

Dwalin's jaw tightened.

Then he nodded.

The orcs vanished into the forest.

And slowly, the sounds of battle faded.

_______________

 

For several moments, nobody spoke.

The river continued flowing beneath the bridge, indifferent to the blood staining its banks.

An elven warrior knelt beside a wounded companion.

Bofur began gathering scattered provisions.

Dori checked Ori for injuries with such thoroughness that the younger dwarf eventually protested.

And Thorin—

Thorin looked for his nephews.

Fíli stood beside Kíli near the bridge.

Both were alive.

Both were uninjured.

Kíli was speaking animatedly, apparently describing the exact manner in which he had saved Legolas from certain death.

Fíli looked exhausted.

Thorin crossed the clearing.

“Kíli.”

The young dwarf turned.

“Uncle!”

Thorin caught him by the shoulders.

“Are you hurt?”

“No.”

“Anywhere?”

“Not a scratch.”

Thorin looked toward Fíli.

His elder nephew shook his head.

“He's fine.”

Thorin drew a slow breath.

Then he pulled both of them into his arms.

Fíli stiffened in surprise.

Kíli blinked.

But neither resisted.

Thorin held them tightly.

For one moment, he allowed himself to remember Ravenhill.

Then he forced the memory away.

They were here.

Alive.

Warm.

His.

“Uncle?” Kíli asked softly.

Thorin closed his eyes.

“Just a moment.”

Fíli's expression changed.

He wrapped an arm around Thorin's back.

Kíli followed.

And for a little while, the three of them stood together beside the river.

______________

Bilbo found Thorin several minutes later.

He had been helping Legolas tend the wounded elf, using clean cloth and the medicinal herbs they had been given in the Woodland Realm.

The injury was painful but not fatal.

Once the bleeding had been stopped, Bilbo hurried toward the dwarves.

“Thorin!”

The king turned.

Bilbo stopped in front of him.

There was blood near his eyebrow.

A shallow cut.

Nothing serious.

But Bilbo's stomach twisted.

“Oh, honestly.”

Thorin blinked.

“What?”

“Hold still.”

Bilbo reached up and caught his face between his hands.

Thorin froze.

“You're bleeding.”

“Only a scratch.”

“Yes, well, I'd prefer you without scratches.”

Thorin's expression softened.

Bilbo gently brushed the blood away with a clean cloth.

His fingers trembled slightly.

Thorin noticed.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked at him.

For a moment, the noise of the Company seemed to fade.

“I was frightened,” Bilbo admitted.

Thorin lifted a hand to cover one of his.

“So was I.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“I don't particularly like watching people try to kill you.”

“I cannot say I enjoy it either.”

Bilbo gave a shaky laugh.

Then he leaned forward and rested his forehead against Thorin's.

The dwarf closed his eyes.

His hands settled gently at Bilbo's waist.

Neither spoke.

They simply stood together, breathing the same air, grateful for the warmth of one another.

A few paces away, Fíli noticed.

He nudged Kíli.

His brother glanced over.

For once, neither smiled.

Neither teased.

They simply looked away and gave their uncle and Bilbo the privacy they deserved.

______________

 

The Company made camp beyond the crossing before nightfall.

The wounded elf was resting comfortably, the supplies had been recovered, and Legolas had sent scouts to ensure the retreating orcs did not return.

Thorin remained troubled.

He had saved Kíli from the poisoned arrow.

That mattered.

But several orcs had escaped.

And he knew too well what could happen when an enemy carried news to its master.

That evening, Bilbo sat beside him near the fire.

Without a word, the hobbit slipped his hand into Thorin's.

Thorin looked down.

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“You're worrying again.”

“Aye.”

“About the orcs?”

“Among other things.”

Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.

“You cannot prevent every terrible thing from happening.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“I know.”

“But you can do your best.”

“Aye.”

“And today, your best was rather extraordinary.”

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo's expression was warm and earnest.

“You saved Kíli.”

Thorin swallowed.

“Yes.”

“And you helped everyone get through that dreadful battle.”

“Not everyone escaped unhurt.”

“No,” Bilbo admitted. “But they're alive. And that's something.”

Thorin looked toward the fire.

Beyond it, Fíli and Kíli sat together, sharing a meal while Bofur entertained them with an increasingly ridiculous story.

Legolas spoke quietly with the wounded elf.

The Company was tired.

Bruised.

Shaken.

But alive.

Thorin turned toward Bilbo.

“You are right.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Of course I am.”

Thorin laughed softly.

Then he lifted Bilbo's hand and pressed another gentle kiss against his knuckles.

The hobbit's cheeks warmed.

“You remembered.”

Thorin smiled.

“I said I would.”

Bilbo rested his head against Thorin's shoulder.

And this time, when the dwarf wrapped an arm around him, neither felt the need to pretend that the gesture meant anything less than it did.

Far from the river crossing, beneath the blackened branches of a ruined forest, three orcs stumbled into a clearing.

Their armour was damaged.

Their weapons bloodied.

One limped badly from an arrow wound in his thigh.

Azog watched their approach without speaking.

Bolg stood nearby, his expression murderous.

“Where are the others?” Azog demanded.

The largest of the surviving orcs lowered his head.

“Dead.”

Azog's pale fingers tightened around the haft of his weapon.

“Thirteen dwarves,” he said slowly. “You were sent to kill thirteen dwarves.”

“They weren't alone.”

Azog became still.

The orc swallowed.

“Elves, Master. Woodland elves. Armed warriors. They were travelling with the dwarves.”

For several moments, the Pale Orc said nothing.

Then he turned toward Bolg.

“Elves?”

Bolg bared his teeth.

“Legolas, son of Thranduil, was among them.”

Azog's expression darkened.

Thorin Oakenshield had somehow persuaded the Woodland Realm to aid him.

The dwarf who had once been driven from his mountain was gathering allies.

And he was moving closer to Erebor.

“Then Oakenshield has become more troublesome than I thought,” Azog said.

He turned toward the survivors.

“Did you kill any of Durin's blood?”

The orcs exchanged uneasy glances.

“No, Master.”

Azog's face twisted with rage.

“Then you have brought me nothing but your failure.”

The wounded orc fell to his knees.

But Azog was no longer looking at him.

His thoughts had turned eastward, toward the Lonely Mountain and the king who continued to escape him.

“Let the elves protect him in their forest,” he growled. “They cannot follow him everywhere.”

Bolg stepped closer.

“What are your orders?”

Azog stared into the darkness.

For a long moment, he said nothing.

Then his mouth twisted into a cruel smile.

“Let Oakenshield reach the mountain.”

Bolg frowned.

“Master?”

“He believes he is reclaiming his kingdom.”

Azog's pale eyes gleamed.

“Let him.”

He turned toward the distant eastern horizon.

“And when he has gathered everything he wishes to protect…”

His smile widened.

“…we shall take it all from him.”

Chapter 13: Chapter Thirteen — A Place to Call Home

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins had never imagined that the sight of an ordinary blue sky could make him quite so emotional.

Yet there he stood, at the very edge of Mirkwood, staring through the thinning branches at a vast stretch of pale autumn blue as though someone had just presented him with the most magnificent treasure in Middle-earth.

The trees had begun to change almost an hour earlier. Their trunks grew farther apart, the oppressive shadows retreated, and the air gradually lost the heavy, stagnant quality that had accompanied them through the forest. Now a cool breeze moved freely between the branches, carrying the unmistakable scent of open water.

Bilbo closed his eyes and drew a long, grateful breath.

“Oh, thank goodness.”

Beside him, Thorin smiled.

“Something pleasing you, Master Baggins?”

Bilbo opened his eyes and gave him a look.

“Something? Thorin, there is sunlight. Actual sunlight. And air that doesn't smell like something has been rotting beneath a tree for the last three centuries.”

“I thought you had grown rather fond of the forest.”

“I've grown fond of certain things in the forest. There is a considerable difference.”

Thorin chuckled, and Bilbo found himself smiling despite his exhaustion.

It was becoming increasingly difficult not to smile whenever Thorin did.

The realization was both pleasant and deeply inconvenient.

Behind them, the Company emerged from the trees in a disorderly procession. Bombur immediately declared that he intended to celebrate their escape with a proper meal, while Dwalin muttered that he would celebrate once they were safely across the river. Glóin was complaining about the mud on his boots, and Ori had already produced his journal, apparently determined to record the exact moment they left the Woodland Realm.

Fíli and Kíli walked together near the rear, speaking quietly until Kíli noticed Legolas approaching Bilbo.

The younger prince sighed.

Fíli glanced at him.

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“You've said that rather often lately.”

“Perhaps you should stop asking.”

Fíli followed his brother's gaze and smiled.

“Ah.”

Kíli scowled.

“Don't.”

“I haven't said anything.”

“You were going to.”

“I was merely wondering whether you'll survive another five minutes without our burglar's undivided attention.”

Kíli elbowed him.

Fíli laughed.

Legolas, entirely unaware of the latest disagreement he had inspired, stopped before Bilbo with a small leather pouch in his hand.

“I wished to give you something before we part.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Oh! That's terribly kind, but you've already given me those seeds.”

“These are different.”

The elf placed the pouch in Bilbo's palm.

Inside lay several dark seeds, each marked with a delicate silver line.

“They come from one of the oldest flowering trees in our kingdom,” Legolas explained. “They are difficult to grow, but I believe the soil of your Shire may suit them.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Oh, Legolas.”

“They will need patience.”

“Well, I've had a great deal of practice with difficult things.”

His eyes flickered toward Thorin.

The dwarf raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo smiled innocently.

Legolas laughed.

“I hope you will tell me if they grow.”

“Of course! Though I cannot imagine how one sends a gardening report all the way to Mirkwood.”

“Letters have travelled farther.”

“Then you shall have one. And if you ever find yourself in the Shire, you must visit Bag End. I insist.”

“I would be honoured.”

“Tea at four, preferably. Although I suppose exceptions can be made for guests who have travelled several hundred miles.”

“Very generous.”

“And do bring an appetite.”

Behind them, Kíli made a quiet noise of disbelief.

Bilbo turned.

“Oh, for goodness' sake.”

Kíli immediately straightened.

“What?”

“Come here.”

The young dwarf approached suspiciously.

Bilbo reached up and adjusted the collar of his tunic, which had folded awkwardly beneath his cloak.

“There. You look as though you've been dragged through a hedge.”

“We have been travelling through a forest.”

“That is hardly an excuse.”

Kíli glanced toward Legolas.

The elf's expression remained composed, though amusement shone in his eyes.

Bilbo patted Kíli's cheek.

“And you needn't look quite so delighted that we're leaving. It's terribly rude.”

“I wasn't.”

“Of course not.”

Fíli laughed.

_____________

 

Thorin watched them with a warmth that still occasionally surprised him.

He remembered the first journey. The suspicion, the arguments, the distance he had kept between himself and the hobbit who would eventually become the most important person in his life.

This time, Bilbo had been welcomed from the beginning.

Not without difficulties, certainly. Thorin was still capable of being stubborn, and Bilbo had never possessed much patience for being ordered about.

But there had been laughter.

Trust.

Affection.

And now, watching his nephews compete for Bilbo's attention, Thorin found himself imagining something he had scarcely dared to consider.

A family.

Not merely the family he had been born into, but one he might build.

The thought settled gently in his chest.

For once, he allowed it to remain.

_____________

 

Their transport arrived shortly afterward.

A broad wooden boat rounded a bend in the river, its dark hull cutting steadily through the current. A tall man stood near the stern, guiding it toward the bank with the practiced ease of someone who had spent most of his life upon the water.

He wore plain clothing beneath a weathered coat, and a bow rested within easy reach beside the cargo.

His gaze moved over the assembled Company.

Thirteen armed dwarves, a hobbit, and a party of Woodland Realm elves were evidently not what he had expected.

“Bard,” Legolas greeted him.

The man inclined his head.

“Prince Legolas.”

His eyes shifted toward Thorin.

“And these?”

“Thorin Oakenshield and his Company. They require passage to Lake-town.”

Bard's expression changed.

“Oakenshield?”

Thorin stepped forward.

“I am Thorin, son of Thráin, son of Thrór.”

Bard studied him for a long moment.

Then he looked toward the distant eastern horizon.

“Erebor.”

“Aye.”

“You mean to go there.”

“We do.”

Bard's jaw tightened.

“There is a dragon beneath that mountain.”

“I know.”

“And you intend to wake him?”

Thorin did not bristle.

He had expected the question.

More importantly, he understood it.

“I intend to reclaim my people's home,” he answered. “But I have no wish to bring destruction upon yours.”

Bard looked unconvinced.

“Wishes mean little to a dragon.”

“No,” Thorin agreed quietly. “They do.”

The answer seemed to surprise him.

Legolas stepped forward before the conversation could sharpen.

“My father anticipated these concerns.”

He produced a folded letter bearing the royal seal of the Woodland Realm.

“King Thranduil requests that Lake-town provide safe passage, lodging, and reasonable assistance to this Company. He has also reached an agreement with Thorin Oakenshield concerning trade and the protection of civilians should danger arise from the mountain.”

Bard accepted the letter.

His eyes narrowed as he examined the seal.

“Thranduil himself?”

“Yes.”

Bard looked toward Thorin again.

Whatever he had expected of the exiled king, it had clearly not involved arriving under the protection of the Woodland Realm.

“The Master will want to see this.”

“I imagine he will,” Thorin replied.

Bard folded the letter carefully.

“Then get aboard.”

The Company began loading their packs and supplies.

Legolas remained on the bank.

Bilbo hesitated before turning back toward him.

“I suppose this is goodbye.”

“For now.”

Bilbo smiled.

“For now.”

Legolas placed a hand over his heart.

“May the road be kind to you, Bilbo Baggins.”

“And may your forest grow green again.”

The elf's expression softened.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo hurried toward the boat.

Kíli immediately offered him a hand aboard.

Bilbo accepted it, though he looked suspiciously at the young dwarf's cheerful expression.

“You seem unusually happy.”

“Do I?”

“Very.”

“Must be the fresh air.”

Fíli nearly choked on his laughter.

As the boat pushed away from the bank, Bilbo turned to wave.

Legolas stood with his warriors beneath the last trees of Mirkwood, watching until the river carried the Company around the bend.

Only then did the elves turn back toward their forest.

_____________

 

Bard was not an especially talkative man.

Bilbo discovered this within the first hour.

He answered questions politely enough, but seemed to prefer watching the water to participating in conversation. His hands moved confidently over the steering oar, guiding the heavily laden boat through channels that looked alarmingly shallow.

Bilbo sat near the middle, tucked between Thorin and Bofur, watching reeds bend along the banks.

The landscape was unlike anything he had seen before.

Wide stretches of marshland surrounded the river, dotted with pools that reflected the grey-blue sky. Waterbirds rose from the reeds as the boat passed, and distant mountains stood against the horizon like dark teeth.

Somewhere beyond them waited Erebor.

Bilbo looked toward Thorin.

The dwarf had been watching the mountain for some time.

There was longing in his expression.

But there was something else, too.

Concern.

Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's beneath the edge of their cloaks.

Thorin looked down.

Bilbo offered a small smile.

The dwarf's fingers closed around his.

Neither spoke.

At the stern, Bard had noticed the gesture, though he gave no indication of it.

Instead, he addressed Thorin.

“Do you know what happened the last time the dragon came down from the mountain?”

Thorin's expression grew grave.

“I know.”

“My grandfather spoke of Dale. Of the fire. Of people running through the streets with nowhere to hide.”

Thorin lowered his gaze.

“I have heard those stories.”

“Then you'll understand why I don't welcome the thought of him waking.”

“I do.”

Bard studied him.

“You say that easily.”

“Because it is true.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“I cannot promise that Smaug will remain asleep. But I have spoken with King Thranduil about what must be done if he attacks.”

Bard's hands tightened slightly on the oar.

“What arrangements?”

“Warning scouts. Boats prepared for evacuation. Food, blankets, healers, and shelter for those forced to flee.”

Bard stared at him.

“You arranged this before reaching Lake-town?”

“Aye.”

“Why?”

Thorin glanced toward Fíli and Kíli, who were arguing quietly over the contents of a food bundle.

“Because I know what it means to lose a home.”

Bard said nothing.

After a moment, Thorin added, “And because I will not ask others to bear the consequences of my choices without doing everything I can to protect them.”

The boat drifted through a narrow channel.

Bard looked away toward the water.

“I have three children,” he said eventually.

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Three?”

“Two daughters and a son.”

“How lovely. How old are they?”

Bard answered, and before long Bilbo had managed to draw him into a conversation about his family.

He spoke of Sigrid's steady nature, Tilda's curiosity, and Bain's growing determination to follow in his father's footsteps.

Thorin listened quietly.

He could hear the affection beneath Bard's reserved manner.

And when Bard spoke of worrying whenever his children were beyond his sight, Thorin glanced toward his nephews with such immediate understanding that the boatman noticed.

“You have children?” Bard asked.

Thorin shook his head.

“No.”

Then his expression softened.

“But I have two nephews who have given me more than enough practice at worrying.”

“Uncle!” Kíli protested.

Fíli sighed.

“Must you encourage him?”

Bard's mouth twitched.

It was the first time Bilbo had seen him come close to smiling.

______________

 

Lake-town appeared through the mist like something from a strange and rather damp fairy tale.

Bilbo stared as the boat approached.

Wooden houses rose above the water on enormous stilts, connected by narrow bridges and walkways. Boats moved between the buildings, carrying barrels, fish, timber, and people wrapped in thick cloaks against the cold.

Smoke drifted from chimneys.

Bells rang somewhere in the distance.

The entire settlement seemed to creak gently with the movement of the lake beneath it.

“Good heavens,” Bilbo murmured. “It's all built on water.”

“Very observant,” Dwalin said.

Bilbo ignored him.

“How does anyone keep their furniture dry?”

Bofur laughed.

“Carefully, I imagine.”

Bard guided the boat toward a guarded entrance between two rows of buildings.

Several armed men stood upon the platform above.

One of them leaned forward.

“Bard!”

The voice was sharp and unpleasant.

Bilbo looked up.

A thin, sour-faced man in richly trimmed but rather ill-fitting clothing stood beside the guards. His expression suggested that the mere sight of Bard had ruined an otherwise excellent day.

“Alfrid,” Bard replied.

“What is this?”

“A boat.”

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

Thorin looked away.

Alfrid's face darkened.

“I can see that, you insolent—”

“Then why ask?”

One of the guards coughed suspiciously.

Alfrid leaned farther over the railing.

“Who are those people?”

“Travellers.”

“Armed travellers?”

“Apparently.”

“Bard!”

The boatman sighed.

“They require passage into town.”

Alfrid's gaze moved over the Company.

His expression became increasingly offended.

“Dwarves?”

Glóin bristled.

“Have you a problem with dwarves?”

“I have a problem with strangers entering Lake-town without permission!”

“And I have a problem with that face of yours,” Dwalin muttered.

Bilbo elbowed him.

Alfrid pointed accusingly.

“The Master has not authorized this!”

Bard reached inside his coat.

“Then perhaps you should show him this.”

He held up Thranduil's letter.

Alfrid squinted.

“What is that?”

“A letter.”

“Yes, I can see that!”

“From King Thranduil.”

The man's expression changed.

Bard lifted the seal into clearer view.

“The Woodland Realm requests that these travellers be granted safe passage and assistance.”

Alfrid stared.

For a moment, Bilbo could almost see the calculations moving behind his narrow eyes.

Lake-town depended heavily upon trade with the Woodland Realm.

Its merchants profited from the elves' purchases, its warehouses stored their goods, and its Master had no desire to offend a king whose wealth and influence extended far beyond the forest.

Alfrid cleared his throat.

“Well. That is a different matter.”

“Is it?” Bard asked.

“Of course it is! Why didn't you say so immediately?”

“I tried.”

Alfrid ignored him.

“Open the gate!”

The guards obeyed.

As the boat passed beneath the raised barrier, Bilbo leaned toward Thorin.

“Charming fellow.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“An unforgettable first impression.”

“I do hope we don't meet many more like him.”

“Given our luck,” Thorin murmured, “I would not count on it.”

___________

 

The Master of Lake-town received them in a richly furnished hall that smelled of expensive food, strong wine, and too many people attempting to conceal unpleasant things beneath perfume.

Bilbo disliked him almost immediately.

The man reclined upon an elaborate chair, dressed in fine garments that seemed designed to advertise his wealth rather than his taste. His fingers glittered with rings, and his eyes moved over the Company with the calculating interest of someone inspecting merchandise.

Alfrid stood beside him.

Bard remained near the entrance.

Thorin stepped forward.

“Master of Lake-town.”

The Master smiled.

“Thorin Oakenshield. Well, well. A rather unexpected visitor.”

“I appreciate your willingness to receive us.”

“Oh, naturally. Naturally.”

The Master gestured toward the letter resting upon his desk.

“King Thranduil speaks most favourably of your arrangements.”

Bilbo privately suspected that Thranduil had written nothing remotely resembling praise.

But the Master continued.

“Trade, cooperation, mutual benefit. Such promising words.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“I believe there is much our peoples might gain from peaceful dealings.”

“Indeed!”

The Master's smile widened.

“And should Erebor be restored…”

“Trade may resume,” Thorin finished. “Provided agreements are fair to all involved.”

For the briefest moment, the Master's expression faltered.

Then he laughed.

“Of course! Fairness is the foundation of all good business.”

Behind Thorin, Nori made a quiet noise that sounded suspiciously like disbelief.

Bilbo kept his expression carefully neutral.

The negotiations continued for some time.

Thorin requested lodging, food, medical supplies, and assistance preparing for the journey toward the mountain. The Master attempted to turn every request into an opportunity for personal advantage.

Thorin did not rise to the bait.

He remained courteous.

Firm.

Patient.

And absolutely unwilling to promise the wealth of Erebor to a man who had not yet provided so much as a clean bed.

Balin occasionally offered advice, while Bard stood nearby, observing with increasing interest.

Eventually, the Master agreed.

The Company would receive rooms in a respectable inn, provisions for their onward journey, and access to the town's merchants.

In return, Thorin agreed to discuss future trade once Erebor was reclaimed.

Nothing more.

The Master looked disappointed.

But Thranduil's letter remained upon his desk, its seal a silent reminder that refusing assistance might prove considerably more expensive than granting it.

“Well!” he declared at last. “Then let us welcome our distinguished guests!”

Bilbo smiled politely.

He suspected the man would have sold his own grandmother for a sufficiently attractive price.

______________

 

By the time they reached their lodging, the Company was exhausted.

The inn stood near one of Lake-town's broader walkways, its upper windows overlooking the water. It was warm, reasonably clean, and possessed the three things Bilbo had missed most desperately during their travels.

Proper beds.

Hot baths.

And a kitchen.

Bombur nearly wept.

Bofur embraced the innkeeper.

Dwalin immediately inspected the doors and windows.

Glóin demanded to know whether the rooms were secure.

Dori began arranging Ori's belongings before the younger dwarf had even removed his cloak.

Bilbo stood in the entrance hall, breathing in the smell of fresh bread.

“Oh,” he whispered reverently.

Thorin glanced down at him.

“Something wrong?”

“Nothing whatsoever.”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“I believe I've found paradise.”

Thorin laughed.

Their rooms were arranged along the upper floor.

Fíli and Kíli were given a room together, though both immediately protested that they were perfectly capable of sleeping separately.

Thorin ignored them.

Balin received a room near the stairs.

Bilbo was assigned a small, comfortable chamber beside Thorin's.

When the innkeeper handed him the key, Bilbo stared at it for a moment.

A room.

With a door.

And a bed.

And no spiders.

He was beginning to feel quite emotional.

The remainder of the afternoon passed in a blur of warm water, clean clothing, and an extraordinary quantity of food.

Bilbo spent nearly an hour in the bath.

He washed the forest from his curls, scrubbed the dirt from his feet, and emerged feeling almost respectable again.

His waistcoat had survived the journey surprisingly well, though several repairs remained visible. He dressed in his cleanest shirt, combed his hair, and looked at himself in the small mirror above the washstand.

He looked older than the hobbit who had left Bag End.

Not in years, perhaps.

But there were faint scars upon his hands now, and his eyes held memories that had not existed before.

He thought of the trolls.

The goblins.

The spiders.

The terrible battle beside the river.

And Thorin.

Always Thorin.

Bilbo rested his hands against the edge of the washstand.

The memory of the dwarf kissing his knuckles returned with such clarity that his cheeks warmed.

He had wanted Thorin to do it again.

He still did.

But lately, he had begun wanting something more.

The thought made him smile nervously at his reflection.

“Really, Bilbo,” he murmured. “You are becoming quite ridiculous.”

His reflection offered no argument.

______________

 

Downstairs, the Company had gathered around a large table.

Fíli and Kíli were already eating when Bilbo arrived.

“Bilbo!” Kíli called.

The hobbit approached.

“Good heavens. Have you been here long?”

“Long enough to discover they make excellent stew.”

“That's the third bowl,” Fíli observed.

Kíli shrugged.

“I was hungry.”

“You're always hungry.”

“I'm growing.”

“You're nearly grown.”

“Then I'm finishing.”

Bilbo laughed and settled beside them.

Across the table, Thorin looked up.

For a moment, his expression softened so completely that Bilbo forgot what he had intended to say.

“You look rested,” Thorin observed.

“I feel almost civilized.”

“An improvement.”

Bilbo narrowed his eyes.

“Careful.”

Thorin smiled.

Their gazes lingered.

Fíli noticed.

Kíli noticed.

Then Bombur arrived with another platter of food, and the entire table descended into chaos.

_____________

 

Later that afternoon, Bard returned to speak with Thorin.

The boatman had brought information about the northern approaches to Erebor, the condition of the roads, and the supplies they would need for the final journey.

They sat near the inn's quieter rear room, with Balin and Dwalin joining them.

Bilbo remained nearby, reading through a list of provisions while occasionally contributing suggestions.

Bard spread a rough map across the table.

“The old routes are dangerous,” he said. “Some are flooded. Others have fallen into disrepair.”

Thorin studied the markings.

“We will need to approach from the western side.”

“That would be safest.”

Bard hesitated.

Then he looked directly at Thorin.

“And the dragon?”

The room grew quieter.

Thorin rested his hands upon the table.

“We intend to enter the mountain without drawing his attention.”

“And if you fail?”

Thorin did not answer immediately.

He had spent months considering that question.

He knew what Smaug could do.

He remembered the dragon's fire.

The destruction.

The screams.

And he remembered the people of Lake-town fleeing through burning streets.

“We will not leave your people without warning,” he said.

Bard's expression tightened.

“You cannot know when he might attack.”

“No. But we can prepare.”

Thorin explained the arrangements made with Thranduil: the scouts, the evacuation boats, the healers and provisions, and the promise of refuge for those forced to flee.

Bard listened carefully.

“You truly believe the Elvenking will honour this?”

“I do.”

“Even for Lake-town?”

“Especially for civilians in danger.”

Bard looked toward the window.

Outside, children ran along a wooden walkway, laughing as they chased one another between the buildings.

“My children live here,” he said quietly.

“I know.”

“So do hundreds of others.”

Thorin's expression grew grave.

“And I have no intention of forgetting them.”

For a long moment, Bard studied him.

Then he nodded.

“I'll speak with the boatmen. Quietly. We can prepare vessels without alarming the whole town.”

“That would be wise.”

“And I'll make certain my children know where to go if the warning comes.”

Thorin inclined his head.

“Thank you.”

Bard gathered his papers.

At the doorway, he paused.

“I still think going to that mountain is dangerous.”

“It is.”

“But at least you understand what you're risking.”

Thorin looked toward the distant silhouette of Erebor beyond the window.

“More than you know.”

____________

 

By evening, Lake-town had settled beneath a blanket of cold mist.

Lanterns glowed along the walkways, their reflections trembling upon the dark water. Somewhere nearby, a musician played a gentle tune, and the smell of roasting fish drifted from the kitchens below.

Bilbo stood outside Thorin's door for nearly a minute before knocking.

He had no particular reason to be nervous.

They had spent months travelling together.

He had slept beside Thorin on cold nights, braided his hair, held his hand, and leaned against him beneath the stars.

Yet somehow, standing outside the dwarf's room in a warm inn felt considerably more frightening than facing an army of spiders.

He knocked again.

“Come in.”

Bilbo opened the door.

Thorin stood near the window, wearing a loose dark tunic and comfortable trousers. His hair was freshly washed, falling freely around his shoulders, and he had been examining a small map by lamplight.

He looked up.

“Bilbo.”

The warmth in his voice made the hobbit's stomach flutter.

“I hope I'm not disturbing you.”

“Never.”

Thorin set the map aside.

“Come in.”

Bilbo closed the door behind him.

The room was larger than his own, with a broad bed, a small table, and a window overlooking the lake. A fire burned quietly in the hearth, filling the chamber with comfortable warmth.

Bilbo approached the window.

“It's rather beautiful at night.”

Thorin joined him.

“Aye.”

For a while, they stood together, watching the lanterns move across the water.

Then Bilbo spoke.

“It's strange.”

“What is?”

“Being so close.”

Thorin knew immediately what he meant.

“Erebor.”

Bilbo nodded.

“We've been travelling for months. Sometimes I thought we'd never reach it.”

“And now?”

“Now it feels as though everything is happening terribly quickly.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“Does that trouble you?”

Bilbo hesitated.

“A little.”

“Because of the dragon?”

“Partly.”

Thorin waited.

Bilbo looked down at his hands.

“But that's not the only reason.”

The dwarf's expression softened.

“Tell me.”

Bilbo drew a slow breath.

“I've been thinking about what happens afterward.”

“After Erebor?”

“Yes.”

Thorin remained silent.

Bilbo looked toward the lake.

“You'll have your kingdom. Fíli and Kíli will have their home. Everyone will have somewhere they belong again.”

“And you?”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“I have Bag End.”

“A beautiful home.”

“It is.”

He swallowed.

“And I miss it. I miss my garden, and my books, and my pantry, and knowing exactly where everything belongs.”

Thorin nodded.

“Of course.”

“But…”

Bilbo stopped.

His fingers tightened around the edge of his sleeve.

“But?” Thorin prompted gently.

Bilbo looked up.

“I think I shall miss you more.”

Thorin went still.

Bilbo laughed nervously.

“Rather terribly, actually. I've been trying not to think about it, but I suppose there's no point pretending otherwise.”

“Bilbo…”

“I know you have a kingdom waiting for you. And I have a home waiting for me. But somewhere along the way, I've grown rather accustomed to having you in my life.”

Thorin turned fully toward him.

“And who says you must leave it?”

Bilbo blinked.

“What?”

“My life.”

The dwarf's voice softened.

“Who says you must leave it?”

Bilbo stared at him.

For a moment, he could scarcely hear the water beneath the window.

“Thorin, are you asking me to stay?”

“I am asking whether you would want to.”

Bilbo swallowed.

He thought of Bag End.

His garden.

His books.

The little round door he had once believed he would never willingly leave behind.

Then he looked at Thorin.

“I think,” he whispered, “that home has begun to mean something rather different to me.”

Thorin reached for his hand.

“Bilbo…”

But this time, Bilbo did not wait for him to finish.

He stepped closer.

His free hand rose to Thorin's cheek, fingers brushing against the familiar line of his beard.

And then he kissed him.

For the briefest instant, Thorin forgot how to breathe.

The kiss was gentle and a little uncertain, warm with all the affection they had spent months learning to express. Bilbo's fingers trembled against his cheek, but he did not pull away.

Thorin's hand settled carefully at his waist.

Then he returned the kiss.

Not desperately.

Not with the frantic grief of a dying man who knew there would be no tomorrow.

But slowly, tenderly, as though he had been given something precious and intended to treasure it.

Bilbo made a small, surprised sound against his mouth.

Thorin smiled.

When they finally parted, neither moved far.

Their foreheads rested together.

Bilbo's cheeks were pink, his eyes bright.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Thorin laughed softly.

“Oh?”

Bilbo smiled.

“I rather think I've wanted to do that for some time.”

Thorin brushed his thumb across the hobbit's cheek.

“So have I.”

Bilbo looked at him.

There was something in Thorin's expression that made his smile soften.

The dwarf's eyes had grown suspiciously bright.

“Thorin?”

“Hm?”

“Are you all right?”

Thorin swallowed.

He remembered Ravenhill.

The cold stone beneath his back.

The terrible pain.

Bilbo's tears.

The confession they had shared when there was no time left to do anything with it.

He remembered wishing for one more day.

One more chance.

One moment in which he could tell Bilbo he loved him without death waiting to take the words away.

And now Bilbo stood before him, warm and alive, looking at him with such tenderness that Thorin could scarcely bear it.

“Nothing is wrong,” he whispered.

Bilbo studied him.

“Then why do you look as though you might cry?”

Thorin laughed shakily.

“Because I'm happy.”

Bilbo's expression softened completely.

“Oh, Thorin.”

He stepped forward and wrapped his arms around the dwarf.

Thorin held him tightly.

For a long while, neither spoke.

Then Bilbo drew back just enough to look at him.

“Would it be terribly forward of me to ask for another kiss?”

Thorin smiled.

“Terribly.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Then I suppose I shall have to be terribly forward.”

This time, Thorin met him halfway.

_____________

 

They did not intend to fall asleep together.

That was the important thing.

At least, Bilbo would later insist upon it.

After their second kiss, and then a third that had somehow occurred while they were attempting to discuss whether the first two had been satisfactory, they settled upon the edge of Thorin's bed.

Bilbo had been curious about Erebor.

Not the treasure.

Not the throne.

The gardens.

“Did you truly have gardens inside the mountain?” he asked.

Thorin smiled.

“Not in the deepest halls. But there were terraces near the eastern openings, where sunlight reached the stone.”

“What grew there?”

“Flowers. Small trees. Herbs brought from the valleys.”

Bilbo's eyes brightened.

“Fruit trees?”

“A few.”

“Could they be restored?”

Thorin looked at him.

“I would like that.”

Bilbo smiled thoughtfully.

“I could help.”

The words were spoken so simply that Thorin felt something tighten in his chest.

“You would?”

“Of course. Though I should warn you, I'm rather particular about pruning.”

“I shall make certain the royal gardeners are informed.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Oh, don't be ridiculous.”

Thorin smiled.

They spoke for a long time.

About Erebor.

About Bag End.

About whether dwarves appreciated proper gardens and whether hobbits could be persuaded to enjoy underground halls.

Bilbo insisted that any future home required a respectable pantry.

Thorin assured him that Erebor possessed several.

Bilbo demanded to know whether any of them were properly organized.

Thorin admitted that he could not remember.

This was apparently a serious failing.

Eventually, Bilbo leaned against Thorin's shoulder.

The dwarf wrapped an arm around him.

The fire burned lower.

Their conversation slowed.

Bilbo yawned.

“Forgive me.”

“For what?”

“I'm being dreadfully poor company.”

“You are wonderful company.”

“Flatterer.”

Thorin smiled and brushed a curl away from his forehead.

“You should sleep.”

“In a moment.”

Bilbo shifted, settling more comfortably against him.

Thorin leaned back against the pillows, intending only to give the hobbit somewhere more comfortable to rest.

Bilbo followed without protest.

Somehow, they ended up lying side by side beneath the blanket, still fully dressed.

Bilbo rested his head against Thorin's chest.

The dwarf's arm settled around his waist.

For a while, they continued talking.

Bilbo described the rosebushes beneath his kitchen window.

Thorin told him about the great halls of Erebor and the sound of hammers echoing through the mountain.

Bilbo asked whether the dwarves had ever considered installing more windows.

Thorin laughed.

Then Bilbo's answers became quieter.

His breathing slowed.

And eventually, he fell asleep.

Thorin looked down at him.

The hobbit's curls lay scattered against his shoulder, one hand resting loosely upon his chest. His face was peaceful, the tension of months upon the road finally eased.

Thorin brushed a strand of hair away from his forehead.

He remembered holding Bilbo upon Ravenhill.

Remembered the terrible helplessness of knowing he was dying.

Remembered wishing, with everything he had left, that he could remain beside him.

Now there was no blood upon the stones.

No battle raging around them.

No desperate farewell.

Only the quiet crackle of a fire and the steady breathing of the person he loved.

Thorin pressed a gentle kiss to Bilbo's hair.

“Goodnight, my dear hobbit,” he whispered.

Then he closed his eyes.

And for the first time in longer than he could remember, Thorin Oakenshield fell asleep without fearing what his dreams might bring.

_____________

 

Bofur had a problem.

It was not a particularly serious problem, but it was inconvenient enough to require the attention of their king.

The innkeeper had informed him that several items on the Company's supply list could not be obtained until the following morning, and Bofur wanted to know whether Thorin preferred substitutes or intended to wait.

Ordinarily, he would have asked Balin.

Unfortunately, Balin had disappeared into a discussion with Bard about transport arrangements.

And Dwalin had already informed Bofur that if he asked one more question about blankets, he would personally throw him into the lake.

So Bofur climbed the stairs.

He reached Thorin's door and knocked.

No answer.

He waited.

Knocked again.

Still nothing.

“Thorin?” he called quietly.

Silence.

Bofur frowned.

Perhaps the king had gone downstairs.

He tried the handle.

The door opened.

“Sorry to disturb you, but I wanted to ask—”

He stopped.

The room was warm and dimly lit.

The fire had burned low.

And upon the bed, beneath a neatly arranged blanket, Thorin Oakenshield was fast asleep.

That alone would have been remarkable.

But he was not alone.

Bilbo Baggins lay curled against his chest, one arm draped across the dwarf's middle. Thorin's arm rested securely around the hobbit's waist, his hand loosely holding Bilbo's.

Their faces were peaceful.

Their breathing slow and even.

Bofur stared.

Then his expression softened.

A broad smile spread across his face.

“Well,” he whispered.

He remained in the doorway for another moment.

Then, very carefully, he stepped backward and closed the door.

The question about supplies could wait.

Downstairs, the common room was still lively.

Dwalin sat near the fire with a mug of ale.

Glóin was discussing something with Nori, while Dori attempted to persuade Ori to stop writing and eat the rest of his supper.

Bombur had discovered that the innkeeper possessed an excellent recipe for honey cakes and was now engaged in a conversation of considerable importance.

Balin sat near the window, examining a list of supplies.

Bofur descended the stairs with an expression that immediately attracted attention.

Nori looked up.

“What are you grinning about?”

Bofur settled into an empty chair.

“Oh, nothing.”

Dwalin narrowed his eyes.

“That's never true.”

Bofur laughed.

“Well, I went upstairs to ask Thorin about tomorrow's provisions.”

“And?” Balin asked.

“He was asleep.”

Dwalin grunted.

“Good. The fool needs rest.”

“Aye,” Bofur agreed cheerfully. “Though he wasn't resting alone.”

Balin looked up.

Nori's eyebrows rose.

Dwalin paused halfway through lifting his mug.

“What?”

Bofur smiled.

“Bilbo's with him.”

There was a brief silence.

Then Nori laughed.

“Well, there's a surprise.”

“Is it?” Balin asked mildly.

“Not particularly.”

Dwalin stared at Bofur.

“You mean they're—”

“Asleep,” Bofur interrupted. “Both of them. Fully dressed, before you start imagining anything.”

Glóin shook his head.

“About time those two stopped pretending they don't spend every waking moment looking for one another.”

Ori blushed.

Dori sighed.

“Would you all leave them alone?”

“I did!” Bofur protested. “Closed the door and everything.”

Bombur looked up from his honey cake.

“Does this mean Thorin won't be joining us for supper?”

“He's already eaten,” Balin reminded him.

“Oh. Good.”

Nori laughed again.

Dwalin took a long drink of ale.

Then he set the mug down.

“Never thought I'd see the day.”

Balin glanced toward him.

“What day?”

“When Thorin Oakenshield would rather sleep beside a hobbit than spend the evening worrying over maps.”

Balin smiled.

“I suspect it's a considerable improvement.”

“Aye,” Dwalin admitted.

Bofur leaned back in his chair.

“They looked happy,” he said quietly.

The conversation softened.

He glanced toward the stairs.

“Really happy. I've never seen Thorin sleep so peacefully.”

Balin's expression grew thoughtful.

He had known Thorin since he was young.

Had watched him lose his home, his grandfather, his father, and far too many people he loved.

He had seen the weight of duty settle upon the shoulders of a prince who had scarcely been given time to grieve.

And throughout their journey, he had watched Bilbo Baggins slowly coax laughter, tenderness, and something resembling hope back into him.

Balin smiled into his cup.

“Then let them sleep.”

Dwalin grunted in agreement.

Dori returned to his supper.

Nori made one final joke, which earned him a disapproving look from Glóin.

And gradually, the conversation moved on.

After all, the Company had spent months watching Thorin and Bilbo grow closer.

Finding them asleep together was hardly the most surprising thing that had happened on their journey.

____________

 

Fíli and Kíli knew nothing of it.

They had spent the evening accompanying Bard to collect supplies from a merchant near the western docks, and afterward Bard had invited them to his home for a simple meal.

Bain had been fascinated by their weapons.

Tilda had asked whether dwarves truly lived beneath mountains.

And Sigrid had laughed when Kíli attempted to convince her that his brother was incapable of smiling before breakfast.

By the time the two princes returned to the inn, the common room had begun to empty.

Bofur was already upstairs.

Balin had retired.

Dwalin was finishing his ale.

Kíli glanced around.

“Where's Bilbo?”

Dwalin looked at him.

“Asleep.”

“Oh.”

“And Uncle?”

“Asleep.”

Fíli nodded.

“Good. He needs it.”

Neither prince asked another question.

Dwalin watched them climb the stairs.

Then he looked into his mug.

A slow, amused smile appeared beneath his beard.

Tomorrow, he suspected, would be interesting.

Above the quiet streets of Lake-town, the mist thickened over the water.

Lanterns flickered in the darkness.

Boats rocked gently against their moorings.

And far beyond the town, the Lonely Mountain stood beneath the stars, its vast halls silent and its ancient treasure guarded by a sleeping dragon.

The danger had not passed.

The quest was not finished.

There were still promises to keep, enemies to face, and choices that might change the fate of kingdoms.

But for this one night, Thorin Oakenshield dreamed of none of them.

He slept with Bilbo Baggins safe in his arms, the warmth of the hobbit's body pressed against his own and the memory of their first kiss lingering like a promise.

For once, the past did not follow him into sleep.

And for once, the future did not seem quite so frightening.

Chapter 14: Chapter Fourteen — The Last Light of Durin’s Day

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins woke to the unfamiliar sensation of having nowhere particularly urgent to be.

For several peaceful moments, he remained perfectly still, listening to the gentle creaking of Lake-town's wooden buildings and the distant calls of waterbirds beyond the window. Morning sunlight filtered through the curtains, laying pale golden stripes across the floorboards. Somewhere below, a door slammed, followed by a burst of laughter and the unmistakable sound of someone arguing about breakfast.

It was all rather pleasant.

What was considerably more pleasant, however, was the warm arm resting around his waist.

Bilbo opened one eye.

Thorin Oakenshield lay beside him, his dark hair thoroughly dishevelled against the pillow, one hand resting loosely against Bilbo's back. They had fallen asleep fully clothed the previous evening, after what Bilbo privately considered the most extraordinary conversation of his life. He remembered the kiss, the way Thorin's hands had trembled when he touched him, and the quiet promises they had made about a future neither of them could yet properly imagine.

He remembered Thorin crying, too.

Not with sadness, though there had been something almost painful in his expression. Bilbo had held him until the trembling passed, and eventually their conversation had wandered from kingdoms and uncertain futures to considerably more important matters, such as whether Erebor possessed suitable kitchens and how many cupboards a respectable pantry ought to contain.

Apparently, they had fallen asleep somewhere between discussing gardens and Bilbo's insistence that no sensible household needed quite so many ceremonial dining rooms.

“You are staring,” Thorin murmured.

Bilbo nearly jumped.

“I am doing nothing of the sort.”

“You have been awake for several minutes.”

“And you have apparently been pretending to sleep.”

Thorin opened his eyes. There was an unfamiliar softness in them, one that Bilbo was rapidly discovering he liked very much.

“I was comfortable.”

“Well,” Bilbo replied, trying unsuccessfully to suppress a smile, “I suppose that is a reasonable excuse.”

Thorin's arm tightened briefly around him. He leaned forward and pressed a gentle kiss to Bilbo's forehead.

For a moment, neither spoke.

It was astonishing how easily Bilbo could imagine becoming accustomed to mornings like this.

Then someone knocked.

“Uncle?” Fíli called from the corridor. “Are you awake?”

Thorin closed his eyes.

Bilbo bit his lip.

“Uncle, Balin says we need to discuss the supplies before breakfast, and Kíli has already eaten something that was apparently meant for Bombur.”

“That is a malicious accusation!” Kíli protested from farther down the corridor.

“You had jam on your face.”

“That proves nothing!”

Bilbo made the mistake of laughing.

Silence fell outside.

“...Bilbo?” Fíli asked.

Thorin sighed.

Bilbo buried his face against the pillow.

“Perhaps,” he whispered, “we could climb out of the window.”

“We are above the water.”

“I am aware.”

“And you cannot swim particularly well.”

“Then I suppose you had better answer the door.”

Thorin rose with the expression of a king preparing to face a particularly tiresome diplomatic negotiation.

Unfortunately, Bilbo decided to help.

By the time Thorin reached the door, Bilbo had retrieved his waistcoat and was standing near the washstand, attempting to make his curls resemble something other than a bird's nest.

Thorin opened the door.

Fíli stood outside, with Kíli peering over his shoulder.

“Good morning,” Thorin said.

“Morning, Uncle.” Fíli glanced past him. “Balin wanted—”

His eyes settled on Bilbo.

Bilbo froze with a comb in his hand.

Kíli leaned sideways to see around his brother.

There was a long, magnificent silence.

Then Kíli's mouth fell open.

“Bilbo?”

“Good morning, Kíli.”

“Why are you in Uncle Thorin's room?”

Bilbo looked at Thorin.

Thorin looked at Bilbo.

Fíli looked between them, and understanding dawned across his face with almost alarming speed.

“Oh,” he said.

Kíli frowned.

Then his eyes widened.

“Oh!”

“Nothing happened,” Bilbo said quickly.

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo turned scarlet.

“I mean—we slept! That is, we were sleeping. Quite ordinarily. There was talking beforehand, and—oh, bother.”

Fíli pressed his lips together.

Kíli stared at his uncle as though Thorin had suddenly announced an intention to become a travelling minstrel.

“You let him sleep in your bed?”

“Yes,” Thorin answered.

“And you didn't tell us?”

“I was unaware that my sleeping arrangements required your approval.”

Fíli finally lost his battle against laughter.

Kíli looked personally betrayed.

“I am your favourite nephew!”

“You are my youngest nephew.”

“That is not a denial!”

Thorin stepped into the corridor and closed the door behind him, leaving Bilbo a moment to recover his dignity.

“Breakfast,” he said firmly.

Fíli fell into step beside him, grinning.

Kíli hurried after them.

“Does Balin know?”

“Yes,” Thorin replied.

“Dwalin?”

“Yes.”

“Bofur?”

“Apparently.”

Kíli stopped walking.

“The entire Company knows?”

From somewhere behind the door came Bilbo's muffled groan.

Fíli laughed so hard he had to lean against the wall.

___________

 

Their final day in Lake-town passed in a flurry of preparations.

Balin and Glóin inspected their remaining provisions, Dwalin checked weapons, and Bombur became embroiled in a lengthy disagreement with a merchant who believed dried fish constituted an acceptable substitute for proper travelling rations.

Bilbo spent part of the afternoon helping Bard's youngest daughter draw a hobbit-hole.

Tilda had decided that a house beneath a hill sounded far superior to one built over water, particularly after Bilbo explained that hobbit-holes generally did not sway in the wind.

“Do you have dragons in the Shire?” she asked.

“Good heavens, no.”

“Not even little ones?”

“Certainly not. We have a few particularly disagreeable geese, but that is quite enough excitement.”

Bain laughed from the doorway.

Later, Bard accompanied Thorin to inspect the boats arranged for their departure.

They stood together on the narrow dock while the afternoon wind stirred the dark water beneath them.

“I've spoken with the men I trust,” Bard said quietly. “If there's trouble from the mountain, they'll begin moving families toward the southern waterways. We've prepared boats and supplies.”

Thorin nodded.

“I am grateful.”

Bard studied him for a moment.

“You understand that I still think this is dangerous.”

“I do.”

“And that I have three children who will be here if that dragon wakes.”

Thorin turned to face him fully.

“I have not forgotten them.”

There was no grand promise of victory, no boast about the strength of dwarven kings. Bard seemed to appreciate that more than he would have appreciated either.

“Then I hope you know what you're doing,” he said.

So do I, Thorin thought.

He had crossed this country once before, certain that reclaiming Erebor would restore everything his family had lost.

He knew better now.

That evening, the Company gathered for one final supper beneath Lake-town's roofs. The food was simple but plentiful, and for once nobody complained about sleeping arrangements, cold feet, or the unfortunate tendency of travelling cloaks to smell like wet wool.

Kíli, however, had not finished discussing the morning's discovery.

“I'm only saying,” he announced, “that certain developments should be communicated to immediate family.”

“Your uncle's courtship is not a military campaign,” Balin observed.

“It could be,” Nori suggested.

Dwalin snorted into his cup.

Bilbo, who had endured enough embarrassment for one day, pointed his fork at Kíli.

“If you continue, I shall tell Tilda that you are frightened of spiders.”

Kíli looked horrified.

“Bilbo!”

“And that you screamed when one landed on your shoulder.”

“It was enormous!”

“It was smaller than a walnut.”

Fíli began laughing again.

Across the table, Thorin caught Bilbo's eye and smiled.

It was a small smile, almost private.

Bilbo returned it.

For the first time since leaving Bag End, the thought of what awaited them at the end of the road seemed to contain as much hope as fear.

_____________

 

They departed Lake-town early the following morning.

Bard accompanied them to the boats, his children waving from the dock until the town dwindled behind them into a collection of wooden roofs and narrow walkways upon the water.

The journey north was quiet at first. Mist drifted across the lake, and the distant shape of Erebor rose beyond it, immense and solemn against the morning sky.

Bilbo sat near the bow with his cloak pulled tightly around him.

Thorin joined him.

“Cold?”

“A little.”

Without comment, Thorin settled beside him, close enough that their shoulders touched.

Bilbo glanced at him.

“You know, I am perfectly capable of surviving a chilly morning.”

“I have never doubted it.”

“Then why are you looking at me like that?”

“Like what?”

“As though you are considering wrapping me in three blankets and carrying me the rest of the way.”

Thorin considered the suggestion.

“Four blankets, perhaps.”

Bilbo laughed, and Thorin allowed himself to enjoy the sound.

Behind them, Fíli and Kíli were arguing about which of them would be first to see the mountain's gates. Bofur had begun humming, and Bombur was already investigating the food baskets.

It should have been an ordinary morning.

Yet Thorin could scarcely look at any of them without remembering how close he had come to losing everything.

By midday they had reached the northern shore and begun the overland journey.

The first day passed beneath pale sunshine. Old roads emerged from the grass, their stones worn smooth by generations of feet and wagon wheels. Here and there stood the remains of waymarkers, some bearing inscriptions that had almost disappeared beneath moss.

Thorin recognized them.

He remembered riding these roads as a young prince, with his grandfather's banners flying above the caravans and merchants calling greetings as they passed.

Now the roads were empty.

By the second day, even the birds had grown scarce.

The land around Erebor bore the scars of Smaug's destruction. Blackened trees stood like broken fingers against the sky. Abandoned walls crumbled beneath weeds, and the wind carried dust across fields where crops had once grown.

Fíli walked beside his uncle for much of that afternoon.

“Was it beautiful?” he asked eventually.

Thorin looked toward the mountain.

“Yes.”

“What was it like?”

For a moment, Thorin thought of treasure: rivers of gold, carved pillars, halls illuminated by thousands of lamps.

But those were not the things he wanted his nephew to remember.

“There were markets outside the gates,” he said. “Dwarves came from every corner of our halls to trade. There were workshops where the smiths began before sunrise, and kitchens where the bakers worked through the night. On feast days, you could hear music from one end of the mountain to the other.”

Kíli drifted closer to listen.

“Was Grandfather there?” he asked.

“Your grandfather was often in the armouries. He could spend hours examining a sword and still find something to complain about.”

Fíli smiled.

“Sounds familiar.”

Thorin gave him a sideways look.

Kíli grinned.

“And were you troublesome?”

“Never.”

Balin, walking behind them, made a distinctly sceptical noise.

Thorin ignored him.

“You were worse than either of these lads,” Balin informed Bilbo.

“Balin.”

“Climbed everything in sight. Once managed to get himself stuck on a ledge above the western workshops.”

Bilbo turned delighted eyes toward Thorin.

“Did he?”

“I was investigating the architecture.”

“You were hiding from your lessons,” Balin corrected.

Fíli and Kíli burst into laughter.

Thorin endured it with what dignity he could muster.

But as their amusement faded, he looked again at the mountain.

His nephews had never seen the kingdom he remembered. Their childhoods had been shaped by exile, by stories of lost splendour and promises of return.

If he succeeded, they would inherit something better than gold.

They would have a home.

____________

 

They made their final camp within sight of Erebor.

The mountain filled the northern horizon, its vast slopes dark beneath a sky scattered with stars. No fires burned upon its heights. No voices carried from its gates.

It seemed almost impossible that anything living could remain inside.

After supper, the Company settled gradually into silence. Dwalin took the first watch, while Bombur arranged himself beneath his blankets with a sigh of considerable satisfaction.

Thorin sat a little apart from the others.

Bilbo found him near a low ridge, looking toward the mountain.

“May I join you?”

Thorin held out his hand.

Bilbo took it and settled beside him, drawing his cloak around them both.

For a while, they watched the stars.

“Are you frightened?” Bilbo asked eventually.

Thorin could have lied.

He had spent much of his life learning how to conceal fear beneath certainty. A king was expected to be resolute, especially when others depended upon him.

But Bilbo had never demanded that sort of certainty.

“Yes,” he admitted.

Bilbo's fingers tightened around his.

“So am I.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“I have brought you a very long way from your home.”

“You have.”

“And tomorrow we may find ourselves standing before dangers greater than any we have faced.”

“Quite possibly.”

“You could still turn back.”

Bilbo gave him a look of such affectionate exasperation that Thorin almost smiled.

“My dear Thorin, I believe we settled this matter somewhere around the Misty Mountains.”

“I remember.”

“Then you ought to know better than to suggest it again.”

Thorin lowered his gaze to their joined hands.

“I do not know what awaits us inside,” he said softly.

It was not entirely true. He knew far too much about what awaited them: the dragon, the treasure, the Arkenstone, and the darkness that had once taken root within his own heart.

What he did not know was whether he could change it.

Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.

“Then we'll discover it together.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

In another life, he had held Bilbo's hand while dying, knowing there would be no mornings together, no gardens, no ordinary days in which to grow old.

Now Bilbo sat beside him beneath the stars, warm and alive.

Thorin lifted their joined hands and kissed his knuckles.

“I should like that,” he whispered.

Later, after Bilbo had fallen asleep near the fire, Thorin quietly checked on his nephews.

Fíli lay on his side with one arm beneath his head. Kíli had somehow stolen half his brother's blanket, though Fíli appeared too deeply asleep to notice.

Thorin crouched beside them.

For several moments, he simply watched them breathe.

Then he carefully drew the blanket back over Fíli's shoulder.

“Sleep well, lads,” he murmured.

He remained there a little longer than necessary.

________________

 

Durin's Day dawned cold and clear.

The Company broke camp before sunrise, their anticipation growing with every mile. Erebor rose before them, no longer a distant shape upon the horizon but an immense presence of stone and shadow.

Thorin guided them along the western slopes, following narrow paths and ancient landmarks half-hidden beneath loose rock.

He remembered this climb.

He remembered the frustration, the fading light, and the terrible fear that they had come so far only to fail at the very threshold of their home.

This time, he knew where to look.

By afternoon, they had reached the narrow ledge where the hidden entrance lay concealed.

The Company spread out, searching the stone face for any sign of a doorway.

Bilbo examined the map while Balin traced old markings along the rock.

Then Thorin found the familiar outline.

“There,” he said.

They gathered around him.

At first, there seemed to be nothing but smooth stone. Yet when the light shifted, the faint edges of an ancient door became visible, its seams so perfectly fitted that they might have been drawn upon the mountain itself.

Kíli reached out and touched the rock.

“It's really here.”

Fíli stood beside him, silent.

Balin approached more slowly.

His hand trembled when he laid it against the stone.

“I remember this passage,” he whispered. “I remember the day the king ordered it sealed.”

His voice broke.

Dwalin stepped nearer, resting a steadying hand upon his shoulder.

For a long while, nobody spoke.

Then the sun began its descent.

They waited.

The final golden rays crept across the mountain's face, touching the hidden door before slowly withdrawing.

Nothing happened.

Ori glanced nervously toward the darkening sky.

“Have we missed it?”

“No,” Thorin answered.

He could feel every heartbeat in his chest.

He remembered the moon-runes Elrond had read, the ancient words concerning Durin's Day, and the moment in his first life when the moon had revealed what sunlight could not.

“Wait,” he said quietly.

The last sunlight disappeared.

The mountain darkened.

Then, above the distant ridges, the moon emerged from behind a thin veil of cloud.

Its pale light fell upon the stone.

A tiny silver gleam appeared.

“The keyhole,” Bilbo breathed.

Kíli gave a startled laugh.

Fíli caught his brother's arm.

And Thorin stood motionless.

He had reached this place before. He had stood upon this very ledge, filled with triumph and hunger for the kingdom that lay beyond.

He had believed the hardest part of his journey was over.

How little he had understood.

In his first life, this mountain had given him back his crown and taken almost everything else.

He remembered Fíli lying still upon the stone. Kíli's blood upon the battlefield. Bilbo kneeling beside him on Ravenhill, weeping as Thorin struggled to speak the words he should have said long before.

The memories came so sharply that he nearly staggered.

“Thorin?”

Bilbo's voice reached him through the darkness.

Thorin looked at him.

The hobbit stood only a step away, his curls stirred by the mountain wind, his face full of quiet concern.

Alive.

Thorin turned toward his nephews.

Fíli was watching the keyhole with an expression of solemn wonder. Kíli stood beside him, barely containing his excitement.

Alive.

Both of them.

And suddenly Thorin could not bear the distance between them.

“Fíli. Kíli.”

They turned immediately.

“Come here, lads.”

Something in his voice made them approach without question.

Thorin looked at them for a long moment.

He remembered holding Fíli as an infant, astonished by how small his sister's firstborn had been. He remembered Kíli learning to walk, determined to follow his older brother everywhere, even when his little legs could scarcely keep up.

He remembered teaching them to fight, watching them grow, and fearing that exile would steal from them every opportunity they deserved.

And he remembered losing them.

Thorin reached out and placed a hand on each nephew's shoulder.

“I have not said this nearly often enough,” he began.

Fíli's brow furrowed.

“Uncle?”

“I am proud of you.”

Both young dwarves fell silent.

“Not merely because you have fought bravely, though you have. Nor because of the blood you carry.” Thorin swallowed. “I am proud of the men you have become. Of your loyalty, your courage, and the kindness you have shown even when the road gave you little reason for it.”

Kíli's expression softened.

Thorin looked toward Fíli.

“You have carried the responsibilities of your birth with more grace than I had any right to ask of you. One day, you will make a fine king.”

Fíli's eyes shone.

“Uncle, I—”

Thorin drew him forward before he could finish.

He rested his forehead against Fíli's, one hand cradling the back of his nephew's head.

Fíli closed his eyes.

For a few precious moments, Thorin allowed himself to remember the little boy who had once fallen asleep against his chest after demanding another story.

Then he pressed a kiss to Fíli's forehead.

When they drew apart, Fíli was blinking rapidly.

Thorin turned to Kíli.

“And you,” he said, his voice unsteady, “have brought more light into our lives than you will ever know.”

Kíli gave a watery laugh.

“Even when I cause trouble?”

“Especially then, though I would appreciate a little less of it.”

Kíli smiled.

Thorin pulled him close and rested their foreheads together.

He remembered a young dwarf falling beneath enemy blades. He remembered arriving too late. He remembered a grief so terrible that it had hollowed him out.

Now Kíli's hands gripped the back of his coat.

“Love you, Uncle,” Kíli whispered.

Thorin's eyes closed.

“And I love you, lad.”

He kissed Kíli's forehead, then gathered both nephews into his arms.

Neither protested.

Fíli wrapped an arm around his uncle's shoulders. Kíli held on tightly, his face buried against Thorin's coat.

Around them, the Company remained respectfully silent.

Balin wiped his cheeks with a handkerchief. Dwalin stared determinedly toward the horizon, though his own eyes had grown suspiciously bright.

Bilbo stood nearby, watching with an aching tenderness.

He did not know what memories haunted Thorin at that moment.

But he understood that this was not merely a king returning to his kingdom.

It was a family coming home.

Eventually, Thorin stepped back.

He looked between his nephews, smiling through tears he made no attempt to conceal.

“Whatever waits beyond this door,” he told them, “remember that neither crown nor treasure could ever make me prouder than I am of you.”

Fíli nodded, unable to speak.

Kíli wiped his face with his sleeve.

Thorin reached beneath his coat and withdrew the ancient key.

For a moment, he held it in his palm, studying the worn metal that had survived decades of exile.

Then he turned toward his youngest nephew.

“Kíli.”

Kíli looked up.

Thorin held out the key.

“Will you help me open our home?”

Kíli stared at him.

“Me?”

“You.”

His eyes darted toward Fíli.

His older brother smiled and nudged him forward.

“Go on.”

Kíli accepted the key with both hands, as though afraid it might vanish if he held it carelessly.

Together, he and Thorin approached the door.

The moonlight illuminated the tiny keyhole, its silver gleam trembling against the ancient stone.

Thorin placed his hand over Kíli's.

“Steady,” he murmured.

Kíli nodded.

They guided the key into the lock.

For a heartbeat, nothing happened.

Then Thorin felt the mechanism catch.

He looked at his nephew.

“Together.”

They turned the key.

Deep within the mountain, something shifted.

A low, ancient sound rolled through the stone, followed by the grinding of mechanisms that had slept for generations.

Dust drifted from the doorway.

The great slab of stone moved.

Kíli gasped.

Fíli stepped forward, one hand rising to his mouth.

And slowly, impossibly, the hidden door opened.

Beyond it waited darkness.

The air that emerged was cold and still, carrying the faint scent of old stone and forgotten halls.

Balin made a broken sound.

“Oh,” he whispered. “Oh, my dear old home.”

Dwalin caught him by the shoulder as the older dwarf began to weep.

Fíli slipped an arm around Kíli, who was staring into the passage with tears running freely down his cheeks.

Thorin stood before the open doorway.

He could hear his grandfather's voice in memory. His father's laughter. The ring of hammers, the music of the halls, the voices of a people who had once believed their home would endure forever.

He could also remember fire.

Death.

Madness.

The terrible cost of placing a kingdom above those who loved him.

Then a smaller hand slipped into his.

Bilbo.

Thorin looked down.

The hobbit smiled at him, his own eyes bright.

“Welcome home, Thorin.”

For a moment, Thorin could not answer.

He looked at Fíli and Kíli, standing shoulder to shoulder. At Balin, weeping openly. At Dwalin and the others, weary from their journey but alive, every one of them.

Then he looked back at Bilbo.

His heart ached with everything he remembered and everything he still feared.

But beneath that fear was something he had scarcely dared to feel since waking into this second life.

Hope.

Thorin tightened his fingers around Bilbo's hand.

“Thank you,” he whispered.

He turned once more toward the darkness beyond the threshold.

Erebor waited.

And this time, he would not mistake its treasure for the people who had brought him home.

Chapter 15: Chapter Fifteen — The Heart of the Mountain

Chapter Text

For a long while after the hidden door opened, no one moved.

The passage beyond was narrow and dark, its walls fashioned from stone so precisely joined that the seams were almost impossible to distinguish. Cold air drifted from within, carrying the dry, ancient scent of a place that had remained untouched for generations. Somewhere in the darkness, water fell in slow, distant drops, each one echoing faintly through the mountain.

Thorin stood at the threshold with Bilbo's hand in his, listening to the breathing of the dwarves gathered behind him.

He had imagined this moment more times than he could count.

During the years of exile, he had dreamed of returning to Erebor as a conqueror, driving the dragon from his grandfather's halls and restoring the kingdom stolen from his people. After Ravenhill, when death had finally taken him, he had believed those dreams were finished forever.

Yet here he stood again.

And this time, Fíli was beside Kíli, Balin was wiping tears from his cheeks, and Bilbo's fingers were warm against his palm.

“Uncle?” Fíli asked quietly.

Thorin turned. His eldest nephew was looking into the passage with an expression that mingled wonder and apprehension.

“Shall we?”

Thorin glanced once more at Bilbo, who gave him an encouraging smile.

“Yes,” he answered. “Let us go home.”

They entered slowly, carrying lanterns whose golden light crept across walls carved with the geometric patterns of Durin's folk. Dust lay thick upon the floor, disturbed only by their footsteps. In places, the stone bore the marks of tools abandoned long ago, and Thorin recognized the careful workmanship of masons whose names he had known as a child.

Balin walked close to the wall, occasionally reaching out to touch the carvings.

“I remember this,” he murmured, pausing before a narrow alcove. “There used to be a lamp here. The guards kept it burning through the night.”

“Did you ever use this passage?” Ori asked.

“Once or twice. Though not for anything nearly so adventurous as this.” Balin smiled sadly. “I remember being sent to fetch a master craftsman who had taken refuge here to escape an argument with his wife.”

Bofur chuckled, and even Dwalin's mouth twitched.

The small moment of laughter eased the tension, but it faded as they descended farther into the mountain.

Thorin knew these corridors.

He remembered the narrow staircase ahead, the turn toward the old guardroom, and the place where the passage opened onto a gallery overlooking the lower halls. He remembered something else, too: the terrible sound of Smaug's breathing beneath the gold.

He had once mistaken entering Erebor for victory.

He would not make that mistake again.

When they reached a wider chamber, Thorin raised his hand.

“We stop here.”

Dwalin immediately began inspecting the adjoining passages while Glóin and Bofur set down their packs. The others gathered around a stone table, its surface covered in dust.

Bilbo watched Thorin examine the corridor leading downward.

“You know where we're going, don't you?” he asked.

Thorin hesitated.

“The old maps show the treasury beneath the central halls. There should be a way down from here.”

It was true, though not the whole truth.

“And the dragon?” Bilbo asked.

“Likely among the treasure.”

The answer settled heavily over the Company.

Kíli looked toward the dark passage.

“So we find him, and then what?”

“We do not find him,” Dwalin said sharply. “Not unless we wish to be roasted before supper.”

“Our first task is to learn whether he remains inside,” Thorin replied. “And whether the Arkenstone can be found without waking him.”

Bilbo looked up.

“I suppose that would be my part.”

Thorin's stomach tightened.

He had known the moment was coming from the instant they left Lake-town. He had rehearsed a dozen ways to approach it, imagined precautions, planned routes of retreat, and considered whether there was any possibility of avoiding it altogether.

There was not.

Smaug knew the scent of dwarves. A single breath might betray any of them long before they came close enough to see the treasure hall.

Bilbo, however, had approached the dragon before.

And survived.

Thorin hated that knowledge more than he could express.

“No,” Kíli said immediately. “Absolutely not. We cannot send Bilbo down there alone.”

“Who else would you suggest?” Bilbo asked.

“Someone larger.”

“An excellent qualification for sneaking past a dragon.”

“Bilbo—”

“I am the burglar, Kíli. I was hired for precisely this sort of thing.”

“You were hired before you became family,” Fíli pointed out.

Bilbo's expression softened, but his resolve did not.

“And I am very glad of that. Nevertheless, being fond of you all does not mean I intend to become useless.”

Thorin looked at him.

There was no bravado in Bilbo's face, only determination and a fear he was trying not to show. He had travelled through mountains and forests, faced goblins and spiders, and stood beside the Company when retreat would have been easier.

Thorin could not ask him to become someone else simply because loving him had made the prospect of losing him unbearable.

“Bilbo,” he said quietly, “come with me.”

They stepped into a smaller alcove beyond the others' hearing.

For a moment, Thorin said nothing. He studied Bilbo's face, committing to memory the familiar curls, the faint crease between his brows, and the stubborn set of his mouth.

“You do not have to do this,” Thorin told him.

Bilbo sighed gently.

“I know.”

“I mean it. The Arkenstone is not worth your life. Neither is the treasure, nor any crown that might be waiting for me.”

“I know that too.”

Thorin looked away.

In another life, he had forgotten it.

He remembered Bilbo standing before him in the ruined halls, frightened but resolute, and the terrible rage that had consumed him when he discovered the Arkenstone was gone. He remembered threatening the very person he had loved most.

Bilbo knew none of it.

The hobbit reached for his hand.

“Thorin, look at me.”

Reluctantly, Thorin obeyed.

“I am frightened,” Bilbo admitted. “I would be a fool not to be. But I cannot let you go down there, and neither can any of the others. If there is a chance I can learn something useful without waking Smaug, I must try.”

Thorin drew a slow breath.

“If he wakes, you run. Do you understand? Forget the Arkenstone. Forget everything else. Find your way back to us.”

“I promise.”

“And if you cannot find the jewel—”

“Then I return without it.”

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit squeezed his hand.

“I promise, Thorin.”

Thorin brought Bilbo's fingers to his lips, holding them there a moment longer than necessary.

Then Bilbo rose onto his toes and kissed him.

It was brief, warm, and terribly precious.

“I shall be back before you have time to miss me,” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin managed a faint smile.

“I already miss you.”

Bilbo's answering expression was so tender that Thorin nearly asked him to stay after all.

Instead, he released his hand.

___________

 

Bilbo waited until the voices of the Company had faded behind him before stopping in the darkness.

He leaned against the cold stone wall and took several careful breaths.

There was no use pretending he wasn't afraid. His heart had been beating far too quickly since the moment Thorin mentioned the treasury, and every creak of the ancient mountain seemed to promise something dreadful waiting around the next corner.

Still, he had one advantage the others knew nothing about.

He reached into his waistcoat pocket.

The little golden Ring lay against his palm, perfectly ordinary in appearance.

Bilbo turned it between his fingers.

He had thought of telling Thorin about it more than once. The thought had returned especially often during their quieter evenings together, when keeping secrets from someone who trusted him so completely had begun to feel uncomfortable.

Yet each time he considered speaking, something held him back.

He could never quite explain why.

Now, however, he was grateful for its peculiar gift.

He slipped the Ring onto his finger.

His hands vanished.

Bilbo looked down at the empty space where his body ought to have been, swallowed, and continued.

The passage sloped steeply downward, opening eventually into a vast corridor lined with broken statues. Their faces had been battered beyond recognition, and several lay shattered across the floor. Far ahead, a dim golden glow illuminated the darkness.

Bilbo followed it.

The corridor ended at a broad opening.

Beyond it lay the treasure hall.

For several seconds, Bilbo forgot to breathe.

Gold stretched farther than he could see, rising in enormous dunes beneath pillars that disappeared into the darkness overhead. Jewels glittered among the coins like fragments of captured starlight. Silver vessels, ancient crowns, necklaces, armour, and weapons lay scattered across the hoard, buried beneath wealth accumulated over centuries.

He had heard stories of Erebor's riches.

None had prepared him for this.

Bilbo took a cautious step forward.

Coins shifted beneath his feet with a soft metallic whisper.

He froze.

Nothing happened.

He ventured farther into the chamber, moving carefully around the taller piles. The sheer size of the hall was bewildering. He could have searched for days and still examined only a fraction of its contents.

The Arkenstone, he reminded himself.

Thorin had described it as a jewel of extraordinary brilliance, the Heart of the Mountain, unlike any other stone in the world.

Bilbo scanned the glittering slopes.

How was anyone supposed to find one jewel among millions?

Then something moved.

Not visibly, at first.

A low vibration passed through the gold beneath his feet, followed by a sound like wind travelling through an enormous cavern.

Bilbo stopped.

The sound came again.

Breathing.

Slow.

Deep.

Impossibly vast.

He turned toward a towering mound of treasure at the far end of the hall.

Something enormous lay beneath it.

A curved shape emerged from the coins, dark red and scaled, followed by the faint outline of a folded wing.

Bilbo's mouth went dry.

Smaug.

_____________

 

The dragon was larger than any creature Bilbo had ever imagined. Even partially concealed beneath the treasure, he seemed to occupy half the chamber. His scales gleamed like burnished copper, and every breath stirred the gold around him.

Bilbo took one careful step backward.

A coin slipped beneath his heel.

It rolled down the mound with a bright, delicate clatter.

The breathing stopped.

Bilbo stood perfectly still.

Then a great golden eye opened.

“Well,” said a voice like stone grinding against stone. “What have we here?”

Bilbo's heart nearly stopped.

The dragon's head rose slowly from the treasure, sending coins cascading down his neck and shoulders. His enormous nostrils flared.

“I smell something.”

Bilbo pressed a hand over his mouth.

“Something small,” Smaug continued. “Something that does not belong.”

His head moved from side to side, searching.

“But where, I wonder?”

Bilbo considered fleeing.

Then he remembered the narrow corridor behind him, the distance to the Company, and the fact that the dragon could probably burn the entire passage before he reached it.

Perhaps conversation would be safer.

For the moment.

“Greetings,” he called, surprised that his voice emerged at all.

Smaug became very still.

“Ah.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“O Smaug the Tremendous.”

The dragon's eye narrowed.

“An invisible guest. How... unusual.”

Bilbo forced himself to continue.

“I am a traveller from beneath the hills, a wanderer of winding roads, and an admirer of magnificent things.”

“An admirer?”

“Indeed. And I must say, your reputation scarcely does you justice.”

Smaug's enormous mouth curved.

“Does it not?”

“Not remotely. I had heard tales of your size and splendour, but I find them rather inadequate.”

The dragon shifted, sending another avalanche of gold sliding across the floor.

“Flattery,” he purred. “A charming little beginning. Yet I wonder what brings such an admirer into my halls.”

Bilbo carefully moved behind a pillar.

“Curiosity, principally.”

“Curiosity.”

“And perhaps a desire to see whether the stories were true.”

Smaug laughed.

The sound rolled through the chamber like thunder.

“You have travelled far merely to look upon me?”

“Very far.”

“Then you must be a remarkable fool.”

Bilbo could hardly disagree.

Smaug lowered his head, his great eye searching the empty air.

“You speak in riddles, little wanderer. But your scent tells a rather different story.”

Bilbo went cold.

“Does it?”

“Oh, yes.”

The dragon inhaled slowly.

“Green grass. Damp earth. Woodsmoke. Something pleasant and soft from a land I have never troubled myself to burn.”

Bilbo thought desperately of the Shire.

“And beneath it,” Smaug continued, his voice darkening, “iron. Leather. Old stone.”

His nostrils flared.

“Dwarves.”

Bilbo did not move.

Smaug smiled.

“Ah. There it is. That little flutter of fear.”

“I assure you—”

“Do not insult me.”

The words cracked through the chamber.

Smaug raised his head, unfolding part of one immense wing.

“I know the smell of dwarves. I remember them fleeing these halls, screaming as my fire consumed their precious works. I remember their king and his miserable treasures.”

Bilbo gripped the edge of the pillar.

“And now,” Smaug murmured, “someone has brought their scent back to me.”

His eyes narrowed.

“Tell me, little thief. Has the line of Durin finally gathered enough courage to return?”

Bilbo's silence was answer enough.

Smaug's laughter was softer this time.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

Bilbo felt his stomach twist.

“Such a proud name for such a little king. Does he still dream of sitting upon his grandfather's throne?”

“I wouldn't know what he dreams about,” Bilbo answered carefully.

“Wouldn't you?”

The dragon lowered his head until his eye was level with the pillar.

“Curious. You carry his scent more strongly than the others. His leather, his cloak, the smoke of his fires. You have spent a great deal of time near him.”

Bilbo's cheeks burned despite the cold.

Smaug noticed the change in his breathing.

“Oh,” he said, almost delighted. “How interesting.”

Bilbo took another cautious step backward.

“What has Oakenshield promised you?” the dragon asked. “A share of my gold? A fine little house? Perhaps a title among his people?”

“Nothing of the sort.”

“No?”

“No.”

“Then why come here?”

Bilbo thought of Thorin kneeling beside Fíli and Kíli at the hidden door, pressing his forehead against theirs. He thought of the long journey, of laughter around campfires, of a dwarf who had learned to listen when others spoke.

“Because I chose to,” he said.

Smaug regarded the empty space before him.

“Loyalty,” he murmured. “How touching. How very foolish.”

He shifted again, revealing a vast expanse of gold beneath his body.

“Do you know what became of Thrór, little thief?”

Bilbo said nothing.

“He loved his treasure. Counted it. Guarded it. Feared every hand that might reach for it. In the end, he scarcely remembered what else there was to love.”

Bilbo's fingers tightened.

“And his grandson,” Smaug continued, “will be no different.”

“You don't know Thorin.”

Smaug's eye flashed.

“I know his blood.”

“That isn't the same thing.”

A low growl vibrated through the chamber.

Bilbo knew he ought to stop speaking. Every sensible instinct he possessed was urging him to retreat, to flatter the dragon again, to avoid anything that might provoke him.

But Smaug's certainty angered him.

“You speak as though every dwarf is the same,” Bilbo said. “As though all they care about is gold. But you know nothing about the people who've travelled here.”

“I know they have come for what is mine.”

“What you stole.”

Silence fell.

Bilbo immediately regretted his words.

Smaug lifted his head.

“Stole?”

Bilbo swallowed.

“These halls belonged to the dwarves long before you came.”

A thin curl of smoke escaped the dragon's nostrils.

“And you believe Oakenshield will reward such devotion?” Smaug asked softly. “When he finds the Heart of the Mountain, do you imagine he will still look at you with such fondness?”

Bilbo's breath caught.

Smaug smiled.

“Ah. So there is fondness.”

Bilbo said nothing.

“Poor little creature. You have mistaken a king's affection for something lasting. Gold changes dwarves. The Arkenstone most of all. When he holds it, you will discover how little your devotion is worth.”

“No,” Bilbo said.

Smaug's eye narrowed.

“No?”

“You're wrong about him.”

“Am I?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo's voice trembled, but he continued.

“Thorin has had opportunities to choose treasure over people, and he hasn't. He's stubborn, and proud, and sometimes so impossible that I could cheerfully throw a teapot at his head, but he is not the creature you describe.”

Smaug stared at him.

Then he laughed.

It was not an amused sound.

“You love him.”

Bilbo's heart hammered.

The dragon's smile widened.

“Oh, how delightful. A little burglar who has given his heart to a dwarven king.”

Bilbo backed away.

“Tell me,” Smaug whispered, “when the Arkenstone lies before him, will Oakenshield choose you?”

Bilbo remembered Thorin's words in the alcove.

Neither the treasure nor any crown is worth your life.

“Yes,” he answered.

Smaug's amusement vanished.

“You are a fool.”

“Perhaps.”

“A foolish little creature who has crawled into my kingdom to defend a king who cannot even protect his own halls.”

Bilbo straightened despite himself.

“At least he knows the difference between a home and a hoard.”

For one dreadful instant, Smaug did not move.

Then the dragon's jaws parted.

The first blast of fire struck the pillar beside Bilbo.

Heat slammed into him with such force that he stumbled backward, throwing an arm across his face. The stone erupted in sparks, and the air filled with the deafening roar of flame.

Bilbo ran.

He scarcely knew where he was going. Gold slid beneath his feet, and every breath burned his throat. Behind him, Smaug rose from the treasure, his enormous body sending waves of coins crashing across the floor.

“Insolent little thief!”

Bilbo scrambled over a fallen statue and ducked beneath a stone arch as fire swept through the space behind him.

The Ring remained on his finger, but invisibility offered little comfort when the entire chamber seemed to be burning.

Smaug could hear him.

Smell him.

And worse, the dragon was beginning to anticipate where he would run.

Bilbo darted behind a column, pressing himself against the stone as another torrent of flame roared past. His coat smoked at the hem. He slapped at it desperately, then stumbled onward.

He needed the passage.

He needed to reach Thorin.

But every turn seemed to lead him deeper among the pillars, and the smoke was growing thicker.

Above him, somewhere beyond the enormous ceiling, stone trembled.

___________

 

The first roar reached the Company like a thunderclap.

Dust fell from the ceiling.

Ori stumbled against the table, and Bombur nearly dropped his lantern.

For a moment, nobody spoke.

Then came the fire.

Even through the thick stone walls, they heard its dreadful rush.

Thorin was on his feet before the sound had finished echoing.

“Bilbo.”

Dwalin caught his arm.

“Thorin, wait!”

Another roar shook the chamber.

Thorin pulled free.

“He's down there.”

“We know, but Smaug will smell you!”

Thorin was already moving.

“Uncle!” Fíli shouted.

Thorin did not stop.

He raced into the passage, boots striking the ancient stairs. Behind him, he heard Dwalin curse and the others calling his name, but their voices seemed impossibly distant.

He knew the way.

He remembered the turn toward the upper galleries, the broken staircase, the narrow passage overlooking the treasury.

He had walked these corridors in another life.

He had watched fire consume them.

And now Bilbo was somewhere below.

Alone.

Not again.

Thorin ran faster.

The air grew hot. Smoke curled along the ceiling, and the distant glow of flames flickered across the walls.

He rounded the final corner and emerged onto a high stone gallery.

The treasure hall spread beneath him.

And there was Smaug.

The dragon towered above the gold, his wings half-unfurled, his immense body twisting between the pillars. Fire smouldered across the floor, illuminating the chamber in terrible shades of orange and red.

Thorin gripped the stone railing.

“Bilbo!”

For one dreadful moment, he saw nothing.

Only gold.

Smoke.

Fire.

Then movement caught his eye.

Far below, a small figure stumbled from behind a pillar.

Bilbo.

Visible.

His coat was torn, his curls darkened with soot, and he was running with one hand pressed against his side.

Thorin's heart lurched.

“BILBO!”

The hobbit looked up.

Their eyes met across the enormous chamber.

Relief flashed across Bilbo's face, followed almost immediately by horror.

“THORIN, GO BACK!”

Smaug turned.

The dragon's great head swung toward the sound, his eyes narrowing as he caught sight of the small figure below.

Bilbo had removed the Ring moments earlier, desperate to free his hand after a chain had caught painfully around his finger. Now he fumbled for it again, his breath coming in ragged gasps.

Smaug's chest began to glow.

Thorin knew what was coming.

He remembered that light.

The swelling heat beneath the dragon's scales.

The moment before everything became fire.

“BILBO, RUN!”

Bilbo threw himself toward the shelter of a nearby pillar.

His fingers found the Ring.

He slipped it on.

And vanished.

At the same instant, Smaug unleashed his fire.

The flames struck the pillar and exploded outward, swallowing the place where Bilbo had stood.

Thorin saw him disappear.

One moment, Bilbo had been there.

The next, there was nothing but fire.

“No.”

The word escaped Thorin's lips almost soundlessly.

He leaned over the railing, searching desperately through the flames.

“Bilbo?”

The fire continued to roar.

“Bilbo!”

There was no answer.

Thorin could not reach the place where Bilbo had vanished. The gallery stood far above the treasure hall, with no staircase nearby, and the dragon's enormous body occupied the space between them.

He searched anyway.

He looked for movement behind the pillar, for a shadow, for anything that might tell him Bilbo had escaped.

There was nothing.

His breath caught painfully in his chest.

He remembered Ravenhill.

The snow beneath his back.

Bilbo's tear-streaked face.

The unbearable knowledge that he had discovered love only when there was no time left to live it.

He had been given another chance.

He had crossed the world again, changed the path of their journey, saved his nephews, and brought everyone safely to Erebor.

And now—

Now Bilbo was gone.

Thorin's knees nearly gave way.

He caught the railing with both hands, staring at the flames below.

He had promised himself he would protect him.

He had promised.

A terrible sound rose from his throat, somewhere between a gasp and a sob.

“Bilbo...”

____________

Far below, Bilbo lay curled behind the pillar, invisible and trembling.

The stone at his back was hot enough to hurt, and his lungs burned from the smoke. He pressed his sleeve over his mouth, fighting the urge to cough.

He was alive.

Barely, perhaps, but alive.

The Ring had hidden him from sight just as the fire struck, and the pillar had sheltered him from the worst of the flames.

Yet Smaug remained close.

The dragon's enormous claws scraped against the stone nearby, and Bilbo could hear his breathing above the crackle of burning debris.

Then he heard Thorin.

“Bilbo!”

The anguish in that cry struck him harder than the heat.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

Oh, Thorin.

He wanted to answer. More than anything, he wanted to call out that he was alive, that he was frightened but unharmed, that Thorin must not come any closer.

But Smaug was listening.

And the dragon had already begun to turn toward the gallery.

Bilbo pressed himself farther into the narrow shelter of the pillar.

He could not reveal himself.

Not yet.

____________

 

Smaug lifted his head.

His nostrils flared.

For a moment, he seemed almost puzzled.

Then his eyes brightened with recognition.

“Ah.”

The word rolled through the treasure hall.

“A dwarf.”

Thorin stood motionless above him.

Smaug raised himself higher, his enormous neck arching toward the gallery.

“Not merely a dwarf,” he murmured. “That scent...”

His smile widened.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

Thorin slowly straightened.

Below him, the flames continued to burn around the pillar.

Smaug watched him with cruel delight.

“So the little king has finally returned.”

Thorin's hand moved to Orcrist.

“I have.”

Smaug laughed.

“Come to reclaim your grandfather's gold? Your stolen throne? Your precious mountain?”

Thorin drew the sword.

Its pale blade caught the firelight.

The dragon's gaze shifted briefly toward the burning treasure below.

Then back to Thorin.

“Oh,” Smaug whispered.

His expression changed.

He had understood.

“That little creature,” he said, savouring every word. “Was he precious to you?”

Thorin's grip tightened until his knuckles whitened.

Smaug smiled.

“How unfortunate.”

The dragon's laughter filled the hall.

Thorin could scarcely hear it.

He saw only the place where Bilbo had disappeared.

He remembered a different fire, a different battle, and a different failure. He remembered molten gold pouring through the forges, a great golden statue collapsing, and Smaug emerging alive from the very trap meant to destroy him.

That would not work.

He knew it.

But Erebor was filled with passages, gates, ancient machinery, and chambers built to withstand the strength of mountains.

There were other ways.

Other possibilities.

And beneath the grief threatening to tear him apart, something cold and dangerous began to take shape.

Smaug lowered his head.

“Tell me, Oakenshield. Was your little burglar worth the journey?”

Thorin raised Orcrist.

His eyes burned, but his voice was steady when he answered.

“You have taken enough from me.”

Smaug's jaws parted in a terrible smile.

“Then come, little king. Let us see what else you have left to lose.”

Thorin stepped toward the edge of the gallery, his sword gleaming in the firelight.

He knew this dragon.

He knew the mountain.

And though grief had hollowed him out, one thought remained with terrible clarity.

He would not repeat the mistakes of his first life.

But he would make Smaug pay.

Chapter 16: Chapter Sixteen — A King Without His Heart

Chapter Text

The dragon laughed, and Thorin Oakenshield felt something inside him break.

Below the gallery, fire still crawled across the treasure hall. The pillar where Bilbo had vanished stood blackened and cracked, surrounded by burning debris. Thorin searched the shadows around it one final time, though he knew there was no way for the hobbit to have escaped the flames.

He had seen him disappear.

For months, Thorin had lived with the memory of Ravenhill. He had woken from nightmares with Bilbo's name upon his lips, terrified that the second chance granted to him might prove nothing more than a cruel illusion. He had changed their journey, spared his nephews the dangers he remembered, and sworn never again to let his pride cost him those he loved.

Yet he had sent Bilbo into the dragon's hall.

And now Bilbo was gone.

“Look at you,” Smaug purred, his immense head rising toward the gallery. “The mighty heir of Thrór, trembling over a creature small enough to crush beneath my claw.”

Thorin's fingers tightened around Orcrist.

“Be silent.”

“Oh, but he was entertaining. Such devotion! Such certainty that you would choose him over your precious jewel.” The dragon's golden eyes narrowed with pleasure. “I wonder whether he believed it even as he burned.”

Thorin seized a loose fragment of stone from the damaged railing and hurled it toward the dragon's eye. Smaug jerked aside, more offended than injured, and the stone struck his scales with a harmless crack.

The dragon's laughter ceased.

“You dare?”

Thorin stepped backward toward the archway.

“I dare far more than you know.”

Smaug inhaled.

Thorin threw himself into the passage as fire struck the gallery, shattering the railing and sending burning fragments into the hall below.

He hit the floor hard, rolled, and scrambled upright. Behind him, the stone glowed red.

He knew what he had to do.

Not the forges. Not the molten gold.

He remembered that failure too clearly: the enormous golden statue collapsing around Smaug, the dragon emerging unharmed, and the terrible realization that they had accomplished nothing except driving him toward Lake-town.

There had to be another way.

Thorin ran through the smoke-filled passage, his mind racing through the old plans of Erebor. The lower halls had once housed machinery powerful enough to move enormous blocks of stone. There were counterweights, chains, and gates designed to seal dangerous mining passages.

If he could lure Smaug into the old ore-transfer chamber, perhaps they could bring the eastern barrier down upon him.

Perhaps they could bury him beneath the mountain itself.

“Thorin!”

Fíli's voice echoed ahead.

Thorin rounded a corner and nearly collided with his nephews. Dwalin followed close behind, carrying an axe, while Balin and the others hurried through the passage.

“Where is Bilbo?” Kíli demanded.

Thorin stopped.

The question struck harder than any blow.

Fíli saw his expression change.

“Uncle?”

Thorin opened his mouth, but no words came.

Kíli looked past him toward the firelit corridor.

“No,” he whispered.

Thorin turned away.

“Smaug is moving toward the western galleries. We must reach the old transfer chamber before he does.”

“Where is Bilbo?” Fíli repeated.

Thorin's voice was barely audible.

“He is gone.”

For a moment, the passage seemed to fall silent.

Bofur made a small, broken sound. Balin closed his eyes, and Kíli stared at Thorin as though he had spoken in a language none of them understood.

Then Fíli stepped forward.

“What happened?”

“Fire.”

One word.

It was all Thorin could manage.

Kíli shook his head violently.

“No. Bilbo knows how to hide. He could have—”

“I saw it.”

Thorin's voice cracked.

“I saw him.”

Fíli reached for his uncle's arm, but Thorin pulled away.

“We have little time. The dragon must be stopped.”

“Thorin,” Balin began gently.

“Now!”

The command rang through the corridor.

Dwalin exchanged a troubled glance with Balin before following as Thorin strode away.

Fíli remained still for another heartbeat, watching his uncle disappear into the darkness.

Then he hurried after him.

_____________

 

Bilbo Baggins had never been so frightened in his life.

He crouched behind the scorched pillar, invisible beneath the Ring's strange power, listening to the dragon move somewhere above him. Every breath scraped painfully against his throat, and his left hand trembled so badly that he had to press it against his chest.

He had heard Thorin call his name.

Worse, he had heard the silence that followed.

Bilbo understood what Thorin must have seen. The flames had swallowed the pillar just as he vanished, and from the gallery above there could have been no sign of his escape.

He thinks I'm dead.

The realization made Bilbo feel sick.

He wanted to shout. He wanted to run into the open and tell Thorin that he was alive, that the dragon had missed him, that everything would be all right.

But Smaug was still hunting.

The enormous creature moved away from the gallery, his claws scraping against the stone as he followed the scent of dwarves into the adjoining halls.

Bilbo waited until the sound had faded before crawling from his hiding place.

The treasure beneath his feet was painfully hot. He stumbled across a mound of coins, caught himself against a broken statue, and searched desperately for an exit.

The passage by which he had entered was now blocked by fallen masonry.

Another opening lay farther along the wall, half concealed behind a collapsed column.

Bilbo limped toward it.

_____________

 

Somewhere above, the mountain shook.

The ore-transfer chamber had once been among the busiest places in Erebor.

Enormous platforms stood above deep shafts through which carts of stone and metal had travelled between the mines and the workshops. Heavy chains hung from the ceiling, and a great barrier of reinforced stone rested above the eastern passage, held in place by counterweights and locking mechanisms.

Thorin remembered watching the machinery operate as a boy.

His grandfather had once explained that the barrier could seal the entire passage if a mining shaft collapsed.

It had never been intended to stop a dragon.

But it was the strongest gate Thorin knew.

“Glóin, Bofur, take the upper platform,” he ordered. “Find the release levers. Dwalin, help me secure the western passage.”

The dwarves scattered into position, though their movements were heavy with shock.

Fíli caught Thorin's shoulder.

“Uncle, look at me.”

“We have no time.”

“Then make time.”

Thorin turned sharply.

Fíli's eyes were bright with unshed tears, but his expression was determined.

“You told us that no crown or treasure mattered more than our lives. You stood at the hidden door and made us believe you meant it.”

“I did mean it.”

“Then why are you behaving as though yours no longer matters?”

Thorin flinched.

Fíli lowered his voice.

“Bilbo would not want this.”

“Do not.”

“He wouldn't.”

Thorin looked away, his jaw trembling.

“I sent him down there.”

“He chose to go.”

“I should have stopped him.”

“You couldn't have known.”

“I knew enough!”

The words burst from him with such anguish that Fíli fell silent.

Thorin pressed a hand against his face.

For a moment, he was no king, no warrior, no leader of a Company. He was simply a man who had lost the person he loved and could not understand why the world had continued moving.

Fíli stepped closer.

“You still have us,” he whispered.

Thorin looked at him.

“And we still need you.”

Behind them, Kíli stood near the machinery, his face pale and miserable. He had been unusually quiet since learning what had happened to Bilbo.

Thorin stared at both his nephews.

Alive.

They were alive.

He had not been given this second chance merely to throw himself into a dragon's jaws.

Slowly, he lowered his hand.

“You are right,” he said hoarsely.

Fíli's shoulders relaxed.

Thorin gripped his nephew's arm.

“We stop him if we can. But if the barrier fails, everyone retreats. No one stays behind.”

“Not even you?”

Thorin swallowed.

“Not even me.”

_____________

 

Smaug entered the western passage in a fury.

The dragon had followed the dwarven scent through the lower galleries, crushing pillars and tearing through ancient doorways as though they were made of rotten wood.

Thorin waited on the far side of the ore-transfer chamber, standing upon a raised platform overlooking the central floor.

“Smaug!”

The dragon's head appeared through the shattered archway.

“Still alive, little king?”

Thorin raised Orcrist.

“Come and claim your victory.”

Smaug's eyes narrowed.

“You have brought me to another of your pathetic halls.”

“This one was built by my people long before you crawled into their home.”

The dragon snarled.

Thorin stepped backward, drawing him farther inside.

Above, Bofur and Glóin crouched beside the release mechanisms. Dwalin stood ready at the western gate, while Fíli and Kíli waited near the secondary counterweights.

Smaug advanced.

His enormous body scraped against the pillars, and his tail swept a broken cart into the darkness.

“You think stone will protect you?”

“No,” Thorin answered.

He glanced toward the upper platform.

“But it may delay you.”

He raised his sword.

“NOW!”

Glóin struck the first locking pin with his hammer.

Bofur threw his weight against the release lever.

A tremendous metallic crack echoed through the chamber.

The counterweights dropped.

High above Smaug, the enormous stone barrier began to fall.

The dragon looked up.

For the first time, surprise flashed across his face.

He tried to retreat, but Dwalin released the western gate, blocking the narrow exit behind him.

The eastern barrier crashed down across Smaug's shoulders with a deafening impact.

Stone shattered.

Chains snapped taut.

The entire chamber shook.

Smaug roared in fury as the barrier forced him against the floor, pinning one wing beneath its immense weight.

“Move!” Thorin shouted.

The Company fled toward the upper passages.

Behind them, Smaug thrashed violently, sending cracks racing through the stone.

The barrier held.

For now.

___________

 

Bilbo emerged from a narrow maintenance tunnel into a deserted corridor.

He could hear the dragon roaring somewhere below, but the sound was muffled by several layers of stone. The floor trembled beneath him, and dust fell from the ceiling.

He leaned against the wall, breathing heavily.

The Ring felt strangely cold against his finger.

Bilbo stared at the empty space where his hand should have been.

He had escaped.

Somehow, impossibly, he had escaped.

Now he had to find Thorin.

He removed the Ring and tucked it deep into his pocket.

His body reappeared in the dim lantern light.

Bilbo was inspecting a painful burn along his sleeve when he heard footsteps.

Many footsteps.

And voices.

“Keep moving!” Dwalin shouted.

“The barrier won't hold!” Glóin answered.

Bilbo pushed himself away from the wall.

“Hello?”

The footsteps stopped.

He stepped into the centre of the passage.

“Would someone mind telling me where—”

“BILBO?”

Kíli's voice cracked.

The young dwarf stared at him, his mouth hanging open.

Bilbo blinked.

“Oh. Hello, Kíli.”

For one extraordinary moment, nobody moved.

Then Bofur made a noise somewhere between a laugh and a sob.

“Sweet Mahal!”

Kíli ran forward and nearly knocked Bilbo off his feet.

“You're alive!”

“Apparently!”

“We thought—Thorin said—”

“I know,” Bilbo whispered.

Over Kíli's shoulder, he saw Thorin.

The dwarf stood several paces behind the others, utterly motionless.

His face had gone white.

Orcrist slipped from his hand and struck the stone floor.

Bilbo gently disentangled himself from Kíli.

“Thorin?”

Thorin stared at him.

Bilbo took a step forward.

“I'm sorry. I couldn't call out. The dragon was still there, and I—”

Thorin crossed the distance between them.

He caught Bilbo in his arms so fiercely that the hobbit lost his breath, lifting him from the ground and burying his face against Bilbo's shoulder.

For a moment, Bilbo could only cling to him.

Then he felt Thorin shaking.

Not slightly.

His entire body trembled.

“Thorin,” Bilbo whispered, wrapping his arms around the dwarf's neck. “I'm here.”

Thorin made a broken sound.

“I saw—”

“I know.”

“The fire—”

“I know, darling.”

Thorin held him tighter.

Bilbo felt tears against his neck.

“I thought I'd lost you.”

The words were barely recognizable.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Oh, Thorin.”

He pressed a kiss into the dwarf's hair.

“You haven't. I'm here. I'm all right.”

Thorin drew back just enough to look at him.

His eyes were red, his face streaked with soot and tears. He touched Bilbo's cheek with trembling fingers, as though he feared the hobbit might vanish again.

Bilbo caught his hand and kissed his palm.

“See? Quite real.”

Thorin gave a shaky, disbelieving laugh.

Then he kissed him.

It was desperate and unsteady, filled with everything he had been unable to say when he believed Bilbo dead.

Bilbo returned it without hesitation.

Around them, the Company stood in respectful silence.

Balin wiped his eyes.

Fíli placed an arm around Kíli's shoulders, and Kíli leaned into him, laughing shakily through his own tears.

For one precious moment, the mountain seemed almost peaceful.

Then a tremendous crash shook the corridor.

The ceiling trembled.

Thorin pulled Bilbo protectively against his chest.

Far below, Smaug roared.

The sound was different now.

Not merely furious.

Triumphant.

“The barrier,” Dwalin said grimly.

Another crash followed.

The ancient machinery had failed.

Thorin closed his eyes for a brief moment, pressing his forehead against Bilbo's.

“We have to go.”

Bilbo nodded.

“I know.”

Thorin took his hand.

This time, he did not let go.

_____________

 

Smaug tore himself free beneath a shower of shattered stone.

The barrier lay broken across the chamber, its great chains hanging uselessly from the ceiling. One wing ached where the weight had pinned it, and several scales along his shoulder had cracked.

The pain only deepened his fury.

He had been deceived.

Trapped.

Humiliated by creatures he considered scarcely worth noticing.

Smaug raised his head, tasting the air.

The dwarves were fleeing.

He could follow them through the mountain, burn their passages, and crush them beneath the ruins of their ancestral home.

But another scent lingered upon them.

Woodsmoke.

Fish.

Cold lake water.

Smaug remembered the small settlement upon the Long Lake, its wooden houses crowded together above the dark water.

Men.

The men who had sheltered Oakenshield.

The men who had helped the dwarves return.

A cruel smile spread across the dragon's face.

“So,” he murmured, “you have found yourselves allies.”

He turned toward the great southern halls.

The mountain trembled beneath his steps.

“Let us see how much your friends are willing to lose.”

The Company reached the upper passages as a deep, terrible rumbling spread through Erebor.

Thorin stopped.

He knew that sound.

He had heard it before, in another life, when Smaug abandoned the mountain and turned his wrath upon Lake-town.

“No,” Thorin whispered.

Bilbo looked up at him.

“What is it?”

Thorin's blood ran cold.

The dragon was leaving.

Not defeated.

Not dead.

Leaving.

And beyond the mountain, hundreds of innocent people slept in wooden houses above the lake.

Bard.

His children.

The families who had welcomed them, fed them, and helped them reach Erebor.

Thorin remembered flames reflected upon black water, screams rising through the night, and the terrible cost of a dragon's vengeance.

He had warned Bard.

He had arranged for boats and evacuation routes.

He could only pray it would be enough.

Far beneath their feet, Smaug roared once more.

Then came the sound of enormous wings unfolding.

Thorin tightened his grip on Bilbo's hand.

“The dragon is going to Lake-town.”

The words left the Company silent.

And somewhere beyond the mountain, the last light of evening faded over the Long Lake.

Chapter 17: Chapter Seventeen — Fire Upon the Water

Chapter Text

The first thing Thorin noticed was the silence.

Not true silence, for the mountain still groaned beneath their feet, and somewhere in the depths of Erebor, stones continued to fall from ceilings weakened by the dragon's fury. Yet the terrible roar of Smaug had faded, replaced by the distant rush of enormous wings beating against the night.

The Company emerged onto a broad terrace overlooking the eastern slopes of the mountain. The air was bitterly cold after the suffocating heat of the treasure halls, and several dwarves stopped to draw grateful breaths. Their clothes were stained with soot, their faces exhausted, and more than one bore burns or bruises from their desperate flight.

Thorin scarcely noticed his own injuries.

His hand remained wrapped around Bilbo's.

He had not released it since finding the hobbit alive.

Even now, with Bilbo standing beside him and breathing the same cold mountain air, Thorin found himself glancing down every few moments, searching his face as though expecting him to vanish.

Bilbo noticed, of course.

He always noticed.

"I'm still here," he murmured, squeezing Thorin's fingers.

Thorin looked at him.

"I know."

Bilbo's expression softened. He leaned against Thorin's side, offering the simple reassurance of his presence without demanding anything in return.

Below them, the valley stretched toward the Long Lake, its dark waters reflecting the last faint colours of evening. Lake-town lay upon its surface like a scattered collection of lanterns, peaceful and impossibly distant.

Then a shadow passed across the mountainside.

Kíli looked up.

"There!"

Smaug emerged from the southern face of Erebor.

His enormous wings unfolded against the darkening sky, catching the last traces of sunset along their crimson edges. He circled once above the mountain, and even from their distant vantage point, the Company heard his furious cry.

Then he turned south.

Toward the lake.

Balin stepped closer to the terrace's edge.

"Merciful Mahal."

"He's going to Lake-town," Fíli whispered.

Thorin watched the dragon's silhouette diminish against the evening sky.

He knew what came next.

He remembered flames spreading across wooden rooftops, the screams of fleeing families, and the terrible sight of the town collapsing into the water.

In his first life, Smaug had died that night.

But so had many innocent people.

Thorin gripped the stone railing.

"Please," he whispered, too quietly for anyone but Bilbo to hear. "Let the warning have been enough."

_____________

 

Bard had been expecting trouble since the dwarves departed.

He had not known precisely when it would come, nor whether the dragon would truly awaken, but Thorin Oakenshield's warning had been delivered with such unmistakable seriousness that Bard had refused to dismiss it.

For three days, he had quietly prepared.

Boats had been moved closer to the outer walkways. Families had been instructed where to gather if the alarm sounded. Supplies had been packed, and several of the older fishermen had agreed to help ferry children and those unable to swim toward the shore.

More importantly, the Woodland Realm had kept its promise.

Elven scouts watched the northern approaches, while small groups of healers and guards waited along the lakeshore with provisions. Legolas had arrived that morning with another company, bringing additional boats and word that his father was prepared to send further assistance if necessary.

Some of Lake-town's inhabitants had laughed at the precautions.

Others had complained that Bard was frightening people unnecessarily.

The Master had been particularly displeased.

"Do you intend to empty my town every time a bird flies over the mountain?" he had demanded.

Bard had ignored him.

Now, standing upon a watchtower as the last daylight faded, Bard saw an enormous shape moving against the distant clouds.

For a heartbeat, he could scarcely comprehend its size.

Then the creature opened its jaws.

Fire illuminated the horizon.

"THE DRAGON!"

The warning rang across the town.

Bard seized the alarm rope.

The bell began to toll.

Within moments, other bells answered, their frantic ringing spreading from one end of Lake-town to the other.

Doors flew open. People poured onto the walkways, clutching children, blankets, and whatever belongings they could carry.

Bard descended the tower at a run.

"Bain!"

His son appeared near the foot of the stairs, already carrying a bundle of supplies.

"Father!"

"Take your sisters to the northern boats. Find the elves. Do not wait for me."

Bain hesitated.

"But—"

"Do as I say."

The boy swallowed and nodded.

Bard caught his shoulder before he could leave.

"Keep them safe."

"I will."

______________

 

Bard watched him disappear into the gathering crowd, then turned toward the town.

There were still people who needed help.

And somewhere above the lake, the dragon was coming.

The first blast of fire struck the southern watchtower.

Wood exploded outward in a shower of sparks, and the structure collapsed into the water with a deafening crash. Screams rose from the walkways as burning fragments scattered across the rooftops.

Smaug swept over Lake-town, his enormous body blotting out the stars.

"I am fire!" he roared.

Another torrent of flame followed.

But the town was not entirely unprepared.

Boats were already moving toward the northern shore. Fishermen shouted instructions as they helped frightened families aboard, while guards directed the crowds away from the burning districts.

At the outer docks, Legolas stood beside a line of elven archers.

"Keep the passage clear!" he called. "The boats must not stop!"

An arrow flew from his bow toward the dragon, followed by several others. They struck Smaug's scales and fell uselessly into the water.

Legolas lowered his weapon.

They could not kill him.

But they could save those beneath him.

"Forget the dragon!" he ordered. "Help the people!"

The elves immediately turned their attention to the evacuation.

Some carried children across damaged walkways. Others cut loose burning boats before the flames could spread. At the northern landing, elven healers received the injured and wrapped shivering survivors in blankets.

A little girl stumbled near the edge of a broken pier.

Legolas caught her before she fell.

"Where is your family?"

She pointed toward a crowded boat, crying too hard to speak.

He lifted her into his arms and carried her through the smoke.

Above them, Smaug circled again.

_______________

 

The Master of Lake-town had no intention of dying poor.

While his subjects fled their burning homes, he stood inside his private chambers, shouting at Alfrid and two guards who were struggling to carry a heavy chest toward the door.

"Carefully, you fools! That is worth more than your miserable lives!"

Alfrid coughed as smoke drifted through the windows.

"My lord, the southern district is already burning. We must leave!"

"Not without my gold!"

Another chest was dragged into the corridor.

Then another.

By the time they reached the private landing, the Master's boat was already dangerously low in the water.

Alfrid stared at the growing pile of treasure.

"Surely, my lord, we should leave some behind?"

The Master rounded upon him.

"Leave it? For thieves? For that wretched bargeman and his rabble?"

A nearby roof collapsed, sending burning timber into the lake.

Alfrid flinched.

The Master climbed aboard and ordered the guards to follow.

"Push off!"

The boat lurched away from the dock.

Water immediately spilled over its edge.

"My lord," Alfrid said faintly, "I believe we're sinking."

"Nonsense!"

Another wave struck them.

One of the chests slid across the deck.

The boat tilted sharply.

Alfrid looked at the gold, then at the approaching shore, where an evacuation boat was passing within reach.

For perhaps the first time in his career, he made a decision without consulting his employer.

He jumped.

The Master stared after him.

"ALFRID! YOU COWARD!"

The overloaded boat lurched again.

A chest toppled into the water, dragging a length of rope with it. The rope caught around the Master's ceremonial robes.

He seized the edge of the boat, desperately trying to pull the treasure back aboard.

"My gold!"

The boat overturned.

For a moment, his hand remained visible above the dark water, still clutching the rope.

Then the weight of the chest dragged it beneath the surface.

The Master of Lake-town disappeared with his fortune.

_________________

 

The lake closed over both.

Bard climbed the damaged watchtower with the last black arrow in his possession.

Below him, the town burned.

He had already seen the northern boats escaping, and somewhere among them were his daughters. But Bain had returned, refusing to abandon his father while the dragon remained alive.

"You should have stayed with your sisters!" Bard shouted.

"They're safe!" Bain answered. "The elves have them!"

Bard looked at his son.

There was no time to argue.

Smaug wheeled overhead, flames spilling from his jaws as he turned toward another crowded section of the town.

Bard raised the black arrow.

He had only one chance.

The dragon's underside glittered in the firelight, its scales overlapping like plates of armour. Bard searched desperately for the weakness he remembered from the old tales.

Then he saw it.

A small, unprotected place upon the dragon's breast.

A missing scale.

"Bain," he said, his voice suddenly steady. "Come here."

The boy obeyed.

Bard positioned the arrow against the makeshift support of his broken bow, steadying it with Bain's help.

The dragon turned.

For one dreadful instant, Smaug's golden eyes seemed to find them.

Then he began to descend.

Bard drew back.

He thought of his daughters.

Of the people struggling through the smoke.

Of the homes that had stood upon the lake for generations.

And of the promise he had made to protect them.

He released.

The black arrow flew through the burning air.

It struck the exposed place beneath Smaug's scales.

The dragon's roar shattered the night.

His wings faltered.

Fire burst from his jaws in one final, uncontrolled torrent as his enormous body twisted above the town.

Then Smaug fell.

He struck the lake with such force that a wave surged outward, overturning abandoned boats and extinguishing fires along the nearest docks.

For a moment, the water seemed to boil.

Then the dragon vanished beneath it.

The sky grew dark.

Smaug the Terrible was dead.

From the terrace of Erebor, the Company watched the distant glow of Lake-town flicker against the night.

They had seen the dragon descend.

They had seen the terrible brightness of his fire.

And then, suddenly, they had seen him fall.

For several moments, nobody spoke.

"Did he...?" Ori began.

Balin leaned forward, squinting toward the lake.

The enormous shadow did not rise again.

The flames in the sky had vanished.

"I believe," Balin said slowly, "that the dragon is dead."

Kíli let out a disbelieving breath.

Fíli gripped his brother's shoulder.

Dwalin lowered his axe.

Yet no one cheered.

The town was still burning.

Thorin stood motionless, watching the orange light spread across the water.

He had imagined this moment for nearly two centuries.

The death of Smaug.

The freedom of Erebor.

The end of his people's exile.

But looking toward the ruined town, he felt no triumph.

Only a terrible awareness of the price others had paid.

Bilbo slipped an arm around his waist.

"Thorin."

"I knew he would go there," Thorin whispered.

Bilbo looked up.

"You warned Bard."

"And still the town burns."

"Yes," Bilbo said softly.

He did not try to deny it.

Below them, the distant flames continued to rise.

Thorin closed his eyes.

"I brought him upon them."

Bilbo tightened his embrace.

"Smaug chose to burn those people. Not you."

Thorin shook his head.

"They sheltered us. Fed us. Helped us reach this mountain. And now their homes are gone."

Bilbo was quiet for a moment.

"Then we must help them rebuild."

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo's face was pale beneath the soot, and the sleeve of his coat was scorched. He had nearly died only hours earlier, yet there was no hesitation in his expression.

"You cannot undo what happened tonight," Bilbo continued. "But you can decide what happens tomorrow."

Thorin stared at him for a long moment.

Then he drew him closer.

______________

 

By midnight, the northern shore of the Long Lake had become a refuge.

Elven lanterns glowed among the trees, illuminating rows of temporary shelters. Fires had been lit for warmth, and healers moved between the injured with bowls of water, bandages, and clean blankets.

Legolas stood near the landing, helping a fisherman lift an elderly woman from a boat.

"Take her to the eastern shelter," he instructed. "There are healers waiting."

A familiar voice called his name.

He turned.

Thranduil approached through the trees, accompanied by several guards and a company of elves carrying supplies.

His silver hair was braided back, and his expression was grave as he surveyed the exhausted survivors.

"How many?" he asked.

"We do not yet know," Legolas answered. "The northern evacuation succeeded, but several districts were struck before everyone could leave."

Thranduil's gaze moved toward the burning town.

"And the dragon?"

"Dead. Bard of Lake-town killed him."

For a moment, the Elvenking said nothing.

Then he nodded.

"Send more boats. There may still be survivors in the water."

"Already done."

"Good. Have the healers establish another shelter. The wounded must not remain exposed to the cold."

Legolas bowed his head and hurried away.

Thranduil continued toward the fires.

He found Bard seated upon a fallen log, his arm wrapped in a bloodstained bandage. Bain stood beside him, while Sigrid and Tilda slept beneath a thick blanket nearby.

Bard rose immediately.

"My lord."

"Sit," Thranduil said.

Bard hesitated, then obeyed.

"I am told you killed the dragon."

Bard looked toward the lake.

"Yes."

"A remarkable feat."

"It does not feel remarkable."

Thranduil followed his gaze.

Beyond the trees, Lake-town still burned.

"No," he said quietly. "I imagine it does not."

Bard rubbed a hand across his exhausted face.

"My people have lost everything."

"Not everything."

Bard looked up.

Thranduil glanced toward the sleeping children.

"Many live because you prepared them. My people will provide food, shelter, and healing. We shall not abandon them."

Bard swallowed.

"Thank you."

The Elvenking inclined his head.

"Save your gratitude until the living have been cared for. There is much work to do."

For the first time that night, Bard allowed himself to believe that his people might survive the days ahead.

_______________

 

The fires burned until dawn.

From Erebor, the Company watched the movement of lanterns along the distant shore. Even from so far away, they could distinguish the steady procession of boats carrying survivors toward safety.

Balin stood beside Thorin, his expression weary.

"The elves are helping them."

Thorin nodded.

He could see the lights moving between the trees, too orderly to belong to frightened refugees alone.

"Thranduil kept his word," he murmured.

"He did."

Kíli stood nearby, watching the lake.

"Do you think Bard's children are safe?"

Fíli glanced at him.

Kíli's voice was unusually quiet.

"Tilda promised she'd show me how to catch fish properly if we ever came back."

Thorin looked toward the distant shore.

"I hope so."

Fíli rested a hand upon his brother's shoulder.

Neither spoke again for some time.

At last, the first pale light appeared above the eastern hills.

The dragon was dead.

The mountain belonged to Durin's folk once more.

Yet as dawn illuminated the ruined town, Thorin understood that reclaiming a kingdom and deserving to rule it were two very different things.

Balin turned toward him.

"Your Majesty."

The title settled between them.

Thorin looked at the old dwarf.

Balin's eyes were bright.

"Erebor is yours."

Thorin gazed toward the mountain behind them, its halls filled with the gold that had consumed his grandfather's thoughts and destroyed so much of his family.

Then he looked back toward the lake.

"No," he said quietly. "Erebor belongs to our people."

He straightened.

"At first light, we open the stores. Food, blankets, medicines, whatever remains usable. Send word to Bard and the Elvenking that we will provide what aid we can."

Dwalin stepped forward.

"And the treasure?"

Thorin glanced toward him.

For an instant, he felt the old, familiar pull of the mountain's riches. The gold of his ancestors lay waiting beneath his feet, and somewhere among it was the Arkenstone.

His grandfather's jewel.

His family's inheritance.

The thought stirred something possessive and uncomfortable within him.

Thorin pushed it aside.

"The treasure can wait."

Balin's face softened.

Fíli smiled faintly.

Beside Thorin, Bilbo slipped his hand into his.

Thorin looked down at him, remembering the terrible emptiness of the previous night and the impossible relief of finding him alive.

He squeezed Bilbo's fingers.

"Tell them," Thorin continued, his voice growing firmer, "that Erebor will not close its gates to those who helped us reclaim it. We have spent too many years without a home to turn our backs upon people who have lost theirs."

Balin bowed.

"As you command, my king."

Thorin watched the old dwarf depart to gather the others.

Behind him stood the kingdom he had spent his life trying to reclaim.

Before him lay a town in ruins, its people waiting for help.

And beside him stood Bilbo Baggins, alive and warm and holding his hand.

For the first time since returning to Erebor, Thorin felt something other than grief or fear.

He felt the weight of a crown he had not yet placed upon his head.

And this time, he intended to bear it differently.

Chapter 18: Chapter Eighteen — The Weight of Gold

Chapter Text

The first morning after Smaug's death began with the smell of burnt porridge.

It was not, Bilbo thought, the most dignified beginning to a new age in the history of Erebor, but it was certainly a familiar one.

Bombur had discovered an old kitchen adjoining the upper residential halls, and after considerable inspection, several complaints about the state of the ovens, and a spirited argument with Bofur concerning the proper use of a century-old cooking pot, he had declared it serviceable. The chimney drew well enough, there was clean water from a spring-fed cistern, and the Company still possessed a respectable quantity of provisions from Lake-town.

Unfortunately, nobody had remembered that the ancient stove burned considerably hotter than their campfires.

Consequently, breakfast was served with a faint smell of smoke and several apologies.

Kíli ate three bowls.

Bilbo was beginning to suspect the young dwarf would have eaten four if his brother had not reminded him that they were supposed to be rationing their supplies.

“Rationing?” Kíli repeated indignantly. “We've just reclaimed the richest kingdom in Middle-earth.”

“Gold is not particularly nutritious,” Fíli replied.

“Have you tried it?”

“Have you?”

“Not recently.”

Bofur laughed into his cup.

For the first time since entering the mountain, the Company sounded almost like itself again.

Balin had spent much of the morning inspecting the nearby chambers, accompanied by Glóin and Ori. They had returned with stories of abandoned workshops, collapsed passages, and a small collection of objects that had somehow survived the dragon's occupation. Among them was a wooden horse, one of its legs broken, which Balin had discovered beneath a fallen bench.

He had held it for a long while without speaking.

Thorin remembered the toy.

It had belonged to a young dwarven child whose family had lived near the eastern galleries. He could no longer remember the child's name, only that she had once chased him through a corridor, demanding that the prince repair her horse.

He wondered whether she had survived the fall of Erebor.

There were so many names he could no longer remember.

So many people who would never come home.

He set the thought aside when Bilbo rose from the table.

“Where are you going?”

The question came so sharply that several conversations stopped.

Bilbo blinked.

“To fetch another cup of tea.”

Thorin looked toward the kitchen doorway.

“I shall come with you.”

“Thorin, it's scarcely twenty paces.”

“I know.”

Bilbo studied him for a moment, then smiled faintly.

“Very well, if you insist.”

Thorin stood and followed.

Behind them, Kíli glanced at his brother.

Fíli said nothing, but his expression grew thoughtful.

___________

 

By midday, Thorin had accompanied Bilbo to the kitchen twice, the adjoining storeroom once, and a small chamber where Óin had established a place to treat the Company's injuries.

When Bilbo expressed an interest in exploring the upper galleries with Bofur, Thorin immediately volunteered to accompany them.

When Bilbo mentioned that he might rest afterward, Thorin suggested that they first inspect the royal chambers together.

And when Bilbo stepped out of the room to retrieve his forgotten handkerchief, Thorin looked up from the maps he had been examining and asked where he was going.

Again.

Bilbo stopped in the doorway.

“Thorin.”

“Yes?”

“I'm fetching my handkerchief.”

“Of course.”

“From the next room.”

“I heard you.”

“Then I shall endeavour to survive the journey.”

Dwalin coughed into his fist.

Thorin looked faintly embarrassed.

Bilbo returned a moment later, waving the handkerchief in triumph.

“A narrow escape, but I prevailed.”

Kíli burst out laughing.

Thorin attempted a stern expression.

It was considerably less effective than usual.

Yet beneath the humour, something troubled Bilbo.

He had seen Thorin frightened before. He had witnessed the dwarf's concern for his nephews, his anxiety before dangerous crossings, and the moments when the weight of leadership pressed particularly heavily upon him.

This was different.

Whenever Bilbo moved beyond his reach, Thorin's attention followed him.

And whenever Bilbo returned, the relief upon his face was unmistakable.

Bilbo knew why.

He remembered the sound of Thorin calling his name above the dragon's fire.

He had not forgotten it.

But neither could he spend the rest of his life walking only where Thorin could see him.

___________

 

That afternoon, Thorin entered the treasure hall alone.

The fires had burned themselves out, leaving blackened pillars, broken machinery, and great stretches of gold scattered across the floor. Smaug's passage had carved enormous furrows through the hoard, and several ancient statues lay shattered beneath fallen stone.

Yet the wealth remained.

More than any one kingdom could reasonably count.

Thorin descended the steps slowly.

His boots disturbed the coins, sending them sliding across one another with a sound like distant rain.

He remembered standing here in his first life.

He remembered the overwhelming certainty that everything before him belonged to his bloodline, that every coin taken from the mountain was an insult, and that anyone who approached his treasure must surely intend to steal it.

He had believed those thoughts reasonable.

Even righteous.

Now, as he looked across the endless gold, a familiar unease stirred within him.

They will come.

The thought arrived unbidden.

Men. Elves. Dwarves from the other houses. They will all come asking for what is yours.

Thorin stopped.

His gaze moved toward a mound of jewels near the base of a broken statue.

Somewhere within this vast chamber lay the Arkenstone.

The Heart of the Mountain.

His grandfather's greatest treasure.

He imagined holding it again, imagined the authority it would grant him when the other dwarven houses arrived.

Then another thought followed.

Keep it safe. Keep everything safe. Let no one take it.

Thorin's stomach tightened.

He knew that voice.

Not because it spoke aloud, but because he remembered obeying it.

He remembered threatening Bilbo over a jewel.

He remembered the faces of his companions as they watched their king become someone they scarcely recognized.

And he remembered dying with the knowledge that he had nearly lost everything worth loving.

“No,” he whispered.

His voice disappeared into the enormous chamber.

Thorin looked down at the gold beneath his feet.

It was beautiful.

He could not deny that.

But beauty had never made something worthy of worship.

He turned away.

The sound of shifting coins followed him toward the stairs.

For the moment, he had won.

He was not foolish enough to believe the struggle was finished.

_____________

 

Bilbo was sitting near a small fire when Thorin found him.

His coat lay folded beside him, and he was carefully examining the burn along his left forearm. Óin had already treated it, but the skin remained tender.

Thorin stopped in the doorway.

Bilbo looked up.

“There you are.”

Thorin crossed the room.

“Does it hurt?”

“A little. Óin says it'll heal perfectly well.”

Thorin sat beside him and examined the bandage.

Bilbo watched his face.

“You've been looking at me like that all day.”

“Like what?”

“As though you're expecting me to disappear.”

Thorin's hands became still.

The fire crackled softly between them.

At last, Thorin asked the question he had been avoiding.

“How did you survive?”

Bilbo lowered his eyes.

“I hid behind the pillar.”

“I saw that.”

“The stone sheltered me from the flames. After Smaug moved away, I found a maintenance passage.”

Thorin nodded slowly.

Then he looked directly at him.

“Bilbo, I saw you disappear.”

Bilbo's breath caught.

Thorin's voice remained quiet, but there was something terrible beneath it.

“One moment you were standing there. The next, you were gone. Not hidden by smoke. Not obscured by the pillar. Gone.”

Bilbo stared at the fire.

He could feel the Ring resting in his waistcoat pocket.

For a moment, he considered taking it out.

He imagined placing it in Thorin's palm and explaining everything: Gollum's cave, the strange discovery, the way the Ring made him invisible.

But the thought of surrendering it made something inside him recoil.

He did not understand why.

“Bilbo?”

The gentleness in Thorin's voice made the silence harder to bear.

“There is something I haven't told you,” Bilbo admitted.

Thorin went very still.

“Something about the dragon?”

“About how I escaped.”

“Then tell me.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“I want to. I simply... I don't think I'm ready.”

For a moment, Thorin felt fear sharpen into something less reasonable.

Bilbo had nearly died.

There was something he was concealing.

Something that had allowed him to vanish before Thorin's eyes.

Thorin wanted to demand an answer.

He wanted to know every detail, every danger, every secret that might threaten to take Bilbo away from him again.

Instead, he looked at the hobbit's anxious face.

And remembered how it had felt to stand before someone who loved him while guarding a terrible secret of his own.

“Are you in danger?” he asked.

Bilbo hesitated.

“I don't believe so.”

Thorin did not find that entirely reassuring.

But he nodded.

“Very well.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Very well?”

“When you are ready, you may tell me.”

“You aren't angry?”

“Frightened,” Thorin admitted. “Confused. But not angry.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Thank you.”

Thorin brushed a stray curl from his forehead.

“I trust you.”

He meant it.

Even if trusting Bilbo sometimes frightened him more than facing an army.

______________

 

The difficulty came an hour later.

Bofur appeared in the doorway, carrying a lantern and looking pleased with himself.

“Master Baggins! I've found what might be an old pantry near the eastern residential halls. Thought you might like to have a look.”

Bilbo brightened immediately.

“A pantry?”

“A very large one.”

“Good heavens. Lead the way.”

He had barely risen when Thorin spoke.

“No.”

Both hobbit and dwarf turned toward him.

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“The eastern halls haven't been inspected properly. You will stay here until Dwalin confirms they're safe.”

Bofur looked uncomfortable.

“The passage is clear, Thorin. I've just come through it.”

“There may be structural damage.”

“I can examine it myself,” Bilbo said.

“No.”

The second refusal was sharper.

Bilbo stared at him.

Then he slowly sat down again.

“Bofur, would you mind giving us a moment?”

Bofur glanced between them.

“Of course.”

He withdrew, closing the door behind him.

For several seconds, Bilbo said nothing.

Thorin found the silence unbearable.

“I am only trying to keep you safe.”

“I know.”

“You were nearly killed yesterday.”

“I remember.”

“Then surely you understand why—”

“Thorin.”

Bilbo's voice was gentle, but firm enough to stop him.

“I cannot spend the rest of my life standing where you can see me.”

Thorin looked away.

“I don't ask that.”

“Don't you?”

The question struck him.

Bilbo moved closer.

“I know you were frightened. I know what you thought happened in the treasure hall. But I am here now, and I cannot live as though the world ends every time I walk into another room.”

Thorin pressed his lips together.

Bilbo reached for his hand.

“You cannot love me so tightly that I forget how to breathe.”

For a moment, Thorin could not answer.

The words had been spoken without cruelty.

That made them hurt all the more.

He thought of the treasure hall.

Of the desire to guard everything.

To keep it.

To make certain nothing precious ever passed beyond his reach.

And suddenly he understood why the same feeling had followed him whenever Bilbo walked away.

The gold was not the only thing he feared losing.

“I am sorry,” Thorin whispered.

Bilbo squeezed his fingers.

“I know you are.”

“I thought I watched you die.”

Bilbo's expression crumpled.

“I know.”

Thorin bowed his head.

“I cannot seem to forget it.”

Bilbo moved into his arms.

For a long while, they remained together beside the fire.

At last, Bilbo kissed his cheek.

“Then we'll learn how to live with the memory. But we mustn't let it decide everything for us.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

He had spent months trying to change the future.

Perhaps he also needed to learn that the future could not be controlled.

_______________

 

By late afternoon, the Company had begun preparing aid for Lake-town.

Most of Erebor's ancient food stores had long since spoiled, and many of the blankets had been ruined by damp or neglect. Yet the mountain still contained useful supplies: sealed stores of grain, tools, metal vessels, preserved cloth, and medicines that Óin judged safe after careful inspection.

Balin organized the inventory while Glóin and Dori prepared the first bundles.

Thorin dictated a letter to Bard, acknowledging his courage in killing Smaug and offering whatever immediate assistance Erebor could provide. A second message went to Thranduil, thanking him for keeping his promise and inviting both leaders to discuss the future of the mountain and the rebuilding of Lake-town.

Fíli joined his uncle over the maps as the others worked.

“You're giving away a great deal,” he observed.

Thorin looked up.

“Do you believe we should not?”

“No. I was wondering how you decide what we can afford.”

Thorin studied him for a moment, then drew another chair beside the table.

“Sit.”

Fíli obeyed.

For the next hour, Thorin explained the difference between wealth and resources, the importance of securing food before rebuilding grand halls, and the danger of promising more than a kingdom could deliver.

Fíli listened carefully, occasionally asking questions that made Thorin pause and reconsider his answers.

At last, the young dwarf looked toward the doorway.

Bilbo and Kíli were arguing about whether Erebor ought to recognize second breakfast as an official meal.

Kíli appeared to be losing.

Fíli smiled faintly.

“May I ask you something?”

“Of course.”

“What's the most important thing a king must protect?”

Thorin followed his gaze.

Bilbo was laughing at something Kíli had said.

For a moment, Thorin simply watched him.

Then he turned back to his nephew.

“The people who trust him.”

Fíli considered the answer.

“And if protecting them means giving up something valuable?”

“Then a good king must learn the difference between what is valuable and what is priceless.”

Fíli nodded slowly.

After a moment, his expression grew more serious.

“Uncle... about Bilbo.”

Thorin's hand tightened around his pen.

“What about him?”

“He isn't going to disappear simply because you let him walk out of a room.”

Thorin looked at him sharply.

Fíli held his gaze.

“I know you're frightened. We all were. But Bilbo needs you to trust him.”

Thorin lowered his eyes.

“I am trying.”

“I know.”

Fíli hesitated, then placed a hand upon his uncle's shoulder.

“And we still need you too.”

Thorin covered his nephew's hand with his own.

“I know that as well.”

_______________

 

That evening, Thorin and Bilbo retired to one of the smaller royal chambers.

The room had survived the dragon's occupation remarkably well. Its furnishings were dusty, and one tapestry had been badly damaged, but the bed remained intact, the fireplace drew properly, and a narrow balcony overlooked the valley.

Bilbo had already declared that the room would be greatly improved by a proper rug, several cushions, and a teapot that did not smell faintly of old metal.

Thorin had agreed to all three.

Now Bilbo sat near the fire in a borrowed nightshirt, struggling with a particularly stubborn knot in his curls.

“Oh, bother.”

Thorin looked up from the blanket he was folding.

“Trouble?”

“My hair has apparently decided to become one enormous tangle.”

“Come here.”

Bilbo raised an eyebrow.

“Are you offering assistance?”

“I am.”

“Do dwarven kings commonly spend their evenings untangling hobbit curls?”

“Only particularly fortunate ones.”

Bilbo laughed.

He settled upon a cushion between Thorin's knees, handing him the comb.

Thorin worked carefully, separating the curls with his fingers before attempting the more stubborn knots. His touch was patient and surprisingly gentle, and Bilbo gradually relaxed against him.

For a while, neither spoke.

The fire crackled.

Beyond the balcony, the mountain lay quiet beneath the stars.

Then Bilbo noticed Thorin dividing a small section of his hair into three strands.

“Thorin?”

“Hmm?”

“Are you braiding my hair?”

Thorin's fingers paused.

“I was going to ask whether you would permit it.”

Bilbo turned slightly.

“Permit it?”

Thorin looked faintly embarrassed.

“There are traditions among our people concerning braids.”

Bilbo's curiosity awakened immediately.

“What sort of traditions?”

“Some are given by family. Others mark achievements, promises, or affection.”

“And this one?”

Thorin looked at the strands resting between his fingers.

“A courtship braid.”

Bilbo went very still.

“Oh.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“It is not a marriage proposal, if that concerns you. But it is a declaration of serious affection. I would not give you one without your understanding.”

Bilbo considered this.

Then his expression changed.

“Thorin.”

“Yes?”

“When you say that braiding someone's hair can be a courtship gesture...”

Thorin looked at him.

“Does that apply when a hobbit does it?”

A small silence followed.

“It can.”

Bilbo stared.

“Even if the hobbit has absolutely no idea what he's doing?”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“Bilbo—”

“Oh, good heavens.”

Bilbo turned fully around.

“Thorin Oakenshield, have I been proposing to you for the past six months?”

Thorin laughed.

It was a genuine, helpless laugh, and Bilbo might have enjoyed hearing it if he had not been so thoroughly horrified.

“No,” Thorin assured him. “You have not.”

“Are you certain?”

“Quite.”

“Because I have braided your hair rather often.”

“I remember.”

“Frequently.”

“Yes.”

“Sometimes in front of everyone!”

Thorin's shoulders shook.

Bilbo covered his face.

“Oh, this is dreadful.”

Thorin gently drew his hands away.

“Bilbo, listen to me. Intent matters. You knew nothing of our customs, and I never considered those gestures a promise.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“Then why didn't you tell me?”

Thorin's smile softened.

“Because you were offering affection freely. I would not have you believe you had committed yourself to something you did not understand.”

Bilbo fell quiet.

He remembered a cold evening beneath the trees when Thorin had sat beside him, exhausted after a difficult day's march. Bilbo had offered to tidy the dwarf's loosened braids, and Thorin had agreed without hesitation.

He remembered another evening when Thorin had fallen asleep while Bilbo's fingers worked through his hair.

And another, when Thorin had smiled quietly after Bilbo finished a particularly crooked braid.

At the time, Bilbo had thought little of it.

Now those memories seemed entirely different.

“You knew,” he whispered.

Thorin nodded.

“All those times?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo studied his face.

Something warm and aching settled in his chest.

“How long?”

Thorin's expression changed.

“How long what?”

“How long have you loved me?”

The question hung between them.

Thorin thought of Bag End.

Of an unexpected journey that had ended in blood and snow.

Of Bilbo weeping over him on Ravenhill, and the confession they had made when there was scarcely time left for another breath.

He could not tell Bilbo that.

Not yet.

Perhaps not ever.

But he could tell him something true.

“Longer than you know.”

Bilbo's eyes softened.

He reached up and touched Thorin's cheek.

“You foolish, wonderful dwarf.”

Thorin leaned into his palm.

“I have been called worse.”

“You should have told me.”

“Would you have believed me?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“Probably not.”

“Then perhaps I chose wisely.”

Bilbo laughed softly, though his eyes had grown suspiciously bright.

He leaned forward and kissed him.

When they parted, Thorin rested his forehead against Bilbo's.

“May I give you the braid?” he asked.

Bilbo smiled.

“I would be honoured.”

Thorin drew him close again and began carefully weaving the strands.

His fingers trembled once.

Bilbo noticed.

He reached back, caught Thorin's hand, and pressed a kiss against his knuckles.

“I'm here,” he whispered.

Thorin closed his eyes.

“I thought I would never have the chance to do this.”

Bilbo assumed he meant because of Smaug.

He turned and kissed Thorin's fingers again.

“Well, you do now.”

Thorin finished the braid and secured it with a small silver bead bearing the mark of Durin.

It was not taken from the treasure hall.

He had carried it for years, one of the few personal possessions that had remained with him throughout exile.

Bilbo touched it reverently.

“It's beautiful.”

“It belonged to my family.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Thorin...”

“I would like you to have it.”

For a moment, Bilbo could not speak.

Then he turned around.

“My turn.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Your turn?”

“To braid your hair.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Bilbo, you need not—”

“I know.”

Bilbo smiled.

“But this time, I know what it means.”

Thorin became very still.

Bilbo climbed onto the bed behind him and carefully gathered a section of his dark hair.

He had done this many times before.

Yet tonight, every movement felt different.

He worked slowly, concentrating on keeping the strands even. The finished braid was slightly crooked, and Bilbo immediately frowned.

“Oh, dear. Let me redo that.”

Thorin caught his hand.

“No.”

“But it's uneven.”

“I know.”

“Thorin—”

“I would not change it.”

Bilbo looked at him.

Thorin touched the braid with an expression Bilbo had never seen upon his face before.

Wonder.

Almost disbelief.

Bilbo leaned forward and wrapped his arms around his shoulders.

“There,” he whispered against his ear. “Now you know I meant it.”

Thorin turned and kissed him.

For a long while afterward, they sat together beside the fire, their hands intertwined.

At last, Thorin brushed his lips against Bilbo's temple.

“Sleep well, ghivashel.”

Bilbo smiled sleepily.

“Good night, darling.”

He did not think to ask what the unfamiliar word meant.

Not until the following morning.

_______________

 

Fíli was sorting through a collection of old household records when Bilbo approached him.

“Fíli, might I ask you something?”

“Of course.”

“What does ghivashel mean?”

Fíli stopped moving.

Very slowly, he looked up.

“I'm sorry?”

“Ghivashel. Or something similar. I'm afraid my pronunciation is probably dreadful.”

Fíli stared at him.

“Where did you hear that?”

“Thorin called me that last night.”

Fíli went pale.

Bilbo frowned.

“Good heavens. Is it something dreadful?”

“No!”

“Then why do you look as though I've announced the mountain is collapsing?”

Fíli opened his mouth.

Closed it.

Then looked toward the doorway.

Unfortunately, Kíli was standing there.

And he had heard everything.

“Oh, for Mahal's sake, Fíli!”

Fíli turned.

“Kíli.”

“Why are you still surprised?”

“He called Bilbo ghivashel.”

“Yes, I heard.”

“In Khuzdul.”

“Yes.”

“In front of a hobbit!”

Kíli took a bite of his apple.

“Fíli, our uncle has been looking at Bilbo as though he personally invented sunlight for months. At this point, I'm surprised he hasn't taught him the entire language.”

Bilbo turned scarlet.

“Kíli!”

“What? It's true.”

Fíli rubbed his forehead.

“We do not use our language so freely before outsiders.”

Kíli shrugged.

“Apparently, Uncle has decided that being hopelessly in love is more important than several centuries of tradition.”

Bilbo folded his arms.

“Would one of you please tell me what it means?”

Both brothers fell silent.

At last, Fíli sighed.

“It means something like... treasure of all treasures. Someone more precious than anything else.”

Bilbo stared.

“Oh.”

Kíli grinned.

“Yes. Oh.”

Bilbo looked down at the silver bead woven into his curls.

For several moments, he said nothing.

Then he smiled.

It was such a tender expression that even Kíli had the decency not to tease him further.

For approximately five seconds.

“So,” Kíli began, “does this mean I may officially call you Uncle Bilbo?”

Bilbo laughed.

“You've been doing that already.”

“Yes, but now I can be particularly obnoxious about it.”

Fíli shook his head.

“You require no encouragement.”

Kíli looked delighted.

______________

 

Later, Fíli found Thorin examining a damaged doorway near the royal chambers.

“Uncle.”

Thorin looked up.

“Yes?”

“Did you call Bilbo ghivashel?”

Thorin paused.

“Yes.”

Fíli stared.

“You know we do not share Khuzdul with outsiders.”

Thorin's expression grew thoughtful.

“Bilbo is not an outsider.”

Fíli fell silent.

Thorin rested a hand against the ancient stone.

“He has travelled beside us, fought for us, and risked his life for this family. He is the one I intend to spend my life with. I will not speak to him as though he is a stranger standing at my gates.”

Fíli looked at him for a long moment.

He loved Bilbo.

That had never been in question.

But he also knew the responsibilities waiting beyond these walls. The other dwarven houses would come. Nobles would have opinions. Questions of succession, tradition, and royal marriage would inevitably follow.

As Crown Prince, Fíli would be expected to navigate those difficulties.

Kíli could simply threaten anyone who insulted Bilbo.

Fíli would have to be considerably more diplomatic.

Yet looking at his uncle, he understood that some matters were not open for negotiation.

“Then I shall make certain everyone else understands that too,” he said quietly.

Thorin's expression softened.

“Thank you.”

A familiar voice came from the doorway.

“Does this mean Uncle Bilbo gets to learn all our embarrassing childhood nicknames?”

Thorin and Fíli turned together.

“Kíli!”

The younger dwarf disappeared, laughing.

Thorin sighed.

Fíli smiled.

For a moment, they were simply an uncle and his nephew again.

______________

 

That afternoon, Bilbo announced that he intended to accompany Bofur to inspect the old kitchens.

Thorin looked up from his maps.

His first instinct was immediate.

Go with him.

He could already imagine the dangers: damaged stairs, loose stones, unexplored corridors.

But then he looked at Bilbo.

At the small silver bead resting among his curls.

At the warm, trusting smile upon his face.

And he remembered their conversation beside the fire.

“Be careful,” Thorin said.

Bilbo's expression softened.

“I shall.”

“And return before supper.”

“I wouldn't dream of missing it.”

Bilbo leaned down and kissed his cheek.

Then he departed with Bofur.

Thorin watched the doorway for a long moment.

He was still afraid.

Perhaps he would be afraid for some time.

But Bilbo had gone because he wished to, and Thorin had let him.

It was a small beginning.

Later, when Bilbo returned, Thorin was waiting with tea.

Bilbo settled beside him, resting his head against his shoulder.

“You see?” he murmured. “I came back.”

Thorin kissed his hair.

“You did.”

Outside the royal chambers, the mountain was slowly awakening.

Supplies were being gathered for Lake-town. Messages had been sent to Bard and Thranduil. Fíli was learning the responsibilities of a crown he would one day wear.

And far below, the Arkenstone still lay hidden among the gold.

Thorin knew the days ahead would not be easy.

There would be negotiations, old grievances, and enemies who had not forgotten the House of Durin.

Indeed, before evening fell, Dwalin returned from inspecting the lower approaches with troubling news.

Orc tracks had been found near the eastern slopes.

Recent ones.

Thorin listened in silence, then ordered additional watches.

He remembered Azog.

He remembered Ravenhill.

But when he returned to his chamber, Bilbo was sitting beside the fire, carefully examining a book rescued from the old library.

The hobbit looked up and smiled.

Thorin crossed the room and sat beside him.

For tonight, the mountain was theirs.

For tonight, his nephews were safe.

And for tonight, the person he loved most was alive, wearing his braid, and waiting to share a cup of tea.

Thorin rested his hand over Bilbo's.

He could not promise that fear would never return.

He could only promise himself that he would not allow it to become another kind of prison.

And when Bilbo leaned against him, warm and content, Thorin found that he did not need to hold him tightly to know he was there.

Chapter 19: Chapter Nineteen — A Crown of Promises

Chapter Text

The first thing Gandalf said upon entering Erebor was that he had expected a considerably less welcoming reception.

The second was that someone ought to explain why Kíli was carrying a sack of potatoes through the royal halls.

“We're expecting guests,” Kíli answered, as though this explained everything.

Gandalf looked from the potatoes to the young dwarf's cheerful expression, then toward the enormous stone passage stretching behind him.

“An excellent reason, I'm sure. Though I confess I have rarely seen royalty personally transport vegetables.”

“That's because you've never seen my brother attempt to cook,” Fíli remarked from the doorway.

“I heard that!”

“You were meant to.”

Gandalf's eyebrows rose.

Then, to the considerable surprise of everyone present, the wizard laughed.

It was a warm, delighted sound that echoed beneath the vaulted ceiling, and for a moment the great halls of Erebor seemed less like the abandoned remains of a kingdom and more like a home.

Bilbo emerged from the adjoining chamber carrying a teapot.

“Gandalf!”

The wizard turned just in time to receive a rather enthusiastic embrace around the waist.

“My dear Bilbo!”

“You're back!”

“So it would appear.”

Bilbo drew away, beaming. “We wondered when we'd see you again. There's so much to tell you! Smaug is dead, of course, though I imagine you've heard that already, and Bard killed him with a black arrow, and Thorin has been organizing supplies for Lake-town, and we've found the most extraordinary kitchens, though half the ovens appear determined to burn everything placed inside them—”

“Bilbo,” Gandalf interrupted affectionately, “breathe.”

Bilbo laughed.

Gandalf's gaze softened as he looked at him. The hobbit was thinner than when they had departed the Shire, and there was a healing burn upon his arm, but he appeared remarkably well considering everything that had happened.

Then the wizard noticed the braid.

A small section of Bilbo's curls had been carefully woven together, secured with a silver bead bearing a familiar mark.

Gandalf's eyes narrowed with interest.

“Well,” he murmured.

Bilbo blinked. “Well what?”

“Nothing at all.”

The wizard's expression suggested precisely the opposite.

Before Bilbo could question him, Thorin appeared at the far end of the passage.

For a moment, Gandalf simply watched him approach.

There was something different about the dwarf.

The old pride remained, as did the commanding bearing Gandalf remembered from their first meeting. Yet Thorin's expression softened immediately when his eyes found Bilbo, and when he reached them, his hand settled briefly against the hobbit's back with an ease that spoke of long familiarity.

“Gandalf,” Thorin greeted him.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

The wizard inclined his head.

“Or should I say Your Majesty?”

“Thorin will suffice.”

“How remarkably accommodating of you.”

Thorin gave him a dry look.

Bilbo smiled into his tea.

Gandalf noticed that too.

He had known Thorin for years, had watched him endure exile, humiliation, and the slow erosion of hope. He had expected the reclamation of Erebor to bring joy, certainly, but also a fierce and difficult struggle over the treasure.

He had not expected to find Thorin Oakenshield standing beside a hobbit with an expression approaching contentment.

It was an encouraging discovery.

And, Gandalf suspected, one that would require further investigation.

_____________

 

The following morning, Erebor prepared to receive its first official guests in nearly two centuries.

Balin had insisted that the negotiations take place in one of the smaller council chambers rather than the enormous throne hall.

“We are discussing rebuilding homes, not demonstrating the height of our ceilings,” he had explained.

Thorin had agreed.

The chamber was impressive enough without being intimidating. Tall pillars supported an arched ceiling, and narrow windows admitted pale autumn sunlight. A long stone table stood at its centre, with chairs arranged for the visiting delegations.

Bilbo arrived early, wearing his best available waistcoat and looking increasingly uncertain.

He examined the chairs.

Then the doorway.

Then the chairs again.

Fíli, who had been arranging several documents upon the table, noticed.

“Is something wrong?”

“Not precisely.”

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit sighed.

“Where am I supposed to sit?”

Fíli looked genuinely confused.

“Beside Uncle.”

“Yes, but these are official negotiations.”

“I am aware.”

“And I am not a king, or a prince, or even a particularly important hobbit.”

Fíli set down his papers.

“Bilbo, you helped reclaim Erebor.”

“So did everyone else.”

“You saved my uncle's life.”

“More than once,” Kíli supplied from behind them.

Bilbo turned.

“Must you always appear when someone is trying to have a serious conversation?”

“Yes.”

Fíli ignored his brother.

“You are part of this family. Uncle wants you beside him.”

Bilbo looked down at the silver bead resting among his curls.

“I simply don't wish to cause difficulties.”

Something in Fíli's expression changed.

He understood that concern rather better than Bilbo realized.

As Crown Prince, he knew the traditions surrounding royal marriages. He knew that other dwarven houses might question his uncle's choice, and that a hobbit consort would be something entirely unfamiliar to many of them.

But he also knew how his uncle looked at Bilbo.

And he remembered the sound of Thorin's voice when he had declared that Bilbo was not an outsider.

“You won't,” Fíli said firmly.

Kíli leaned against the table.

“And if anyone objects, they can sit somewhere else.”

“That is not how diplomacy works,” Fíli informed him.

“Perhaps diplomacy would be improved if it did.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then Thorin entered, took one look at the three of them, and asked why they were arguing over furniture.

When Bilbo explained, Thorin simply pulled out the chair beside his own.

“Here.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“Are you certain?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“Entirely.”

Bilbo sat.

And when Thorin briefly touched the braid in his hair, the hobbit decided that perhaps the matter was not quite so complicated after all.

______________

 

Bard arrived shortly before midday.

He wore no crown, and his clothing remained practical rather than ceremonial, but there was a new gravity about him. The destruction of Lake-town had placed a responsibility upon his shoulders that he had never sought.

Beside him walked two representatives of the survivors, both weary-looking and carrying records of the supplies their people needed.

Thranduil followed with a small elven delegation.

He entered the chamber in robes of dark silver and deep green, his expression composed and unreadable. Legolas walked near his father, accompanied by several guards.

Gandalf joined them shortly afterward.

And trailing behind Bard's delegation, looking as though he had every right to be there, came Alfrid.

Bard noticed him only when they reached the table.

His expression tightened.

“Alfrid.”

“Master Bard.”

“What are you doing here?”

“Representing the interests of Lake-town, naturally.”

“You were not invited.”

“Surely one cannot conduct negotiations concerning the people without a representative of the former Master's administration.”

Bard closed his eyes briefly.

Across the chamber, Thranduil regarded the newcomer with the faintest suggestion of distaste.

Thorin looked toward Balin.

Balin gave an almost imperceptible shrug.

Apparently, the question of how Alfrid had gained entry was one nobody particularly wished to answer.

The negotiations began regardless.

Thorin welcomed Bard formally and thanked him for destroying Smaug.

Bard accepted the acknowledgment with a solemn inclination of his head.

“You warned us,” he said. “Without that warning, far more would have died.”

“Not enough were saved,” Thorin replied.

“No,” Bard agreed quietly. “But many were.”

For a moment, they regarded one another across the table.

There was no accusation in Bard's expression.

Only exhaustion, grief, and the determination of a man who had survived long enough to discover that victory did not immediately end suffering.

Thranduil spoke next.

“My people have established temporary shelters along the forest's southern approaches. We can continue providing food and medical assistance, but the survivors cannot remain there indefinitely.”

Bard nodded.

“Winter is approaching. We need permanent shelter before the worst weather arrives.”

Fíli unfolded a map.

“We have examined the eastern stores. There are tools, iron fittings, and enough usable timber to begin repairs in Dale. We can also provide craftsmen once the lower workshops are cleared.”

Bard leaned forward.

“Dale?”

“It lies closer to the mountain than Lake-town,” Fíli explained. “Its foundations remain. Rebuilding there may be faster than attempting to restore everything upon the water.”

Bard studied the map.

“That is worth considering.”

Thranduil inclined his head.

“A sensible proposal.”

Fíli looked quietly pleased.

Thorin noticed.

And despite everything weighing upon him, he felt a moment of pride.

His nephew was learning.

Not merely how to command warriors, but how to listen, calculate, and build something that might outlast him.

Then Bard mentioned gold.

“The supplies are appreciated,” he said carefully. “But rebuilding an entire town will require resources beyond food and tools. We will need funds to purchase what Erebor cannot provide.”

Thorin's fingers tightened against the armrest.

Gold.

The word seemed to linger in the chamber.

He looked toward the map.

He knew Bard's request was reasonable.

He had intended to offer assistance himself.

Yet a cold thought rose unbidden.

They have already received supplies. Now they want the treasure.

Thorin felt his jaw tighten.

For one dreadful moment, he remembered standing before these same men in another life, convinced that every word they spoke concealed a demand for something that belonged to him.

He remembered the fury.

The suspicion.

The certainty that yielding even a single coin meant surrendering his kingdom.

“Erebor will contribute,” he said.

His voice sounded colder than he intended.

Bard noticed.

So did Gandalf.

Thranduil's gaze sharpened.

Fíli glanced toward his uncle, then spoke calmly.

“We could establish a rebuilding fund, with agreed quantities released as construction progresses. That would allow both our peoples to plan responsibly.”

Thorin looked at him.

For a moment, he wanted to object.

To insist that the treasury must first be counted, secured, guarded.

Then Bilbo's hand settled lightly against his beneath the table.

Thorin drew a slow breath.

“That would be reasonable,” he said.

Fíli nodded.

The discussion continued.

And Thorin silently thanked his nephew for offering him a way forward.

_____________

 

For nearly an hour, Alfrid managed to remain merely irritating.

He interrupted Bard twice to explain matters Bard already understood.

He complained that the evacuation boats had been overcrowded.

He suggested that the dwarves ought to compensate survivors for the inconvenience of sleeping outdoors.

When Fíli patiently explained that Erebor could provide blankets and shelter materials, Alfrid demanded to know whether the blankets would be of sufficient quality.

Kíli began making increasingly desperate efforts not to laugh.

Even Gandalf appeared to be finding the discussion trying.

Then Alfrid noticed Bilbo.

More precisely, he noticed where Bilbo was sitting.

“Forgive me,” he interrupted, “but why is that little fellow seated beside the king?”

The chamber grew quiet.

Bilbo looked up.

“I beg your pardon?”

Alfrid gestured toward him.

“These are negotiations between rulers and representatives. Surely there is somewhere more appropriate for a servant to sit.”

Thorin's expression hardened.

Bilbo answered first.

“I was invited to sit here.”

“By whom?”

“By the king.”

Alfrid gave a short, unpleasant laugh.

“Well, that hardly makes you royalty.”

Fíli slowly set down his pen.

Kíli stopped smiling.

Bilbo's expression remained polite, though his fingers tightened around his cup.

“I never claimed it did.”

“Then perhaps you ought to remember your station.”

Bard leaned forward.

“Alfrid, that is enough.”

But Alfrid had apparently mistaken the room's silence for interest.

His gaze settled upon Bilbo's hair.

“And what is that ornament you're wearing?”

Bilbo instinctively touched the silver bead.

“A gift.”

“A gift?”

Alfrid's eyes narrowed.

“It looks rather expensive for someone like you.”

Thorin went utterly still.

The mark of Durin caught the sunlight.

It was a small thing, that bead.

A piece of silver worn smooth by generations of careful hands.

But it had belonged to Thorin's family long before Smaug came to Erebor, and Thorin had carried it through exile, war, and every hardship of the road.

He had given it to Bilbo because there was nothing in the mountain's vast treasure he considered more fitting.

Alfrid leaned forward.

“Or perhaps you helped yourself to something from the treasury? I understand you were employed as a burglar.”

Bilbo's smile disappeared.

The accusation landed with a peculiar cruelty.

He remembered Thorin's trembling hands as he had woven the bead into his hair.

He remembered the quiet tenderness of that night.

And now a stranger was speaking of it as though it were stolen property.

“I did not steal it,” Bilbo said.

“Of course you wouldn't admit it.”

“Alfrid,” Bard warned.

The man ignored him.

“Really, Your Majesty, you ought to be more careful. First you allow a common thief into your halls, then you let him decorate himself with your family's treasures.”

Fíli rose.

Slowly.

There was no anger visible upon his face.

That was what made it frightening.

Kíli's chair scraped against the floor.

Thorin's hand closed around the edge of the table.

But Alfrid continued.

“Unless, of course, the little creature has found some other way to earn your favour.”

Bilbo went pale.

Alfrid smiled.

“I suppose a king grows lonely during his travels. Still, one might expect a monarch to have better taste than to keep a thieving little bedwarmer at his side.”

The silence that followed was absolute.

Even the fire seemed to have stopped crackling.

Thorin began to rise.

He had never wanted to strike another man quite so badly.

Fíli's expression had become colder than Bilbo had ever seen it.

Kíli looked ready to cross the table.

Dwalin's hand moved toward his belt.

And then—

“Enough.”

The voice came from the opposite end of the chamber.

Thranduil had not raised it.

He had not even stood.

Yet every eye turned toward him.

The Elvenking regarded Alfrid with an expression of such complete contempt that the man visibly faltered.

“You have entered another sovereign's halls without invitation,” Thranduil said. “You have interrupted negotiations to which you contribute nothing. You have insulted the host who has offered your people aid.”

Alfrid swallowed.

“Your Majesty, I was merely—”

“I have not finished.”

The words were soft.

They were also final.

Thranduil's gaze moved briefly toward Bilbo.

“And now you presume to insult an honoured companion of this Company, a guest of my own halls, and someone whose courage has earned him more respect than you could hope to command.”

Alfrid opened his mouth.

Thranduil continued before he could speak.

“You have accused him of stealing an ornament whose significance you are plainly too ignorant to comprehend.”

His eyes rested upon the silver bead.

He recognized the mark of Durin.

He understood enough of dwarven customs to know that such a gift was not given lightly.

And he understood, perhaps better than most, what it meant for someone to offer a treasured piece of their family history to the person they loved.

Thranduil turned toward his guards.

“Remove him.”

Alfrid stared.

“What?”

“Escort this man from the mountain. He is not to return to these negotiations.”

Two elven guards stepped forward.

Alfrid looked desperately toward Bard.

“Master Bard! Surely you cannot allow this!”

Bard's face was thunderous.

“You were never invited, Alfrid.”

“But I served the Master of Lake-town!”

“And you have spent the morning demonstrating precisely why that should concern us.”

The guards took Alfrid by the arms.

He began protesting.

Thranduil finally rose.

“If you wish to continue speaking, I suggest you do so beyond the gates. I have no desire to hear another word.”

Alfrid was escorted from the chamber.

His protests faded down the corridor.

For several moments, nobody moved.

Thorin remained standing.

Fíli stood beside him, his expression still dangerously cold.

Kíli's hands were clenched.

Bilbo stared down at the table.

Then Thranduil turned toward him.

“Master Baggins.”

Bilbo looked up.

“I trust you understand that the words of that man reflect neither the opinion of my court nor my own.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Thank you, Your Majesty.”

Thranduil inclined his head.

“Your place at this table is not in question.”

The words were simple.

But Bilbo felt something in his chest loosen.

Across the table, Thorin slowly sat.

He looked toward the Elvenking.

For a long moment, neither spoke.

Then Thorin inclined his head.

“Thank you.”

Thranduil returned the gesture.

It was not friendship.

Not yet.

But it was something neither king would have imagined possible when they first met.

Respect.

And perhaps the beginning of trust.

____________

 

The negotiations continued after a short recess.

Bard apologized privately to Bilbo, though Bilbo assured him that Alfrid's behaviour was hardly his responsibility.

Thorin remained quieter than before.

The insult had awakened a fury that still simmered beneath his skin, and he knew that part of it was being fed by something more dangerous than ordinary anger.

He had wanted to protect Bilbo.

He had also wanted to make Alfrid afraid.

The distinction troubled him.

When the discussions resumed, Fíli took a greater role.

He presented a careful proposal for rebuilding Dale, including supplies, labour, and a contribution from Erebor's treasury once its contents had been properly assessed.

Bard accepted the framework.

Thranduil agreed to continue providing assistance while the survivors established permanent shelter.

The matter of the white gems was also raised.

Thorin felt the familiar tightening in his chest, but he met Thranduil's gaze.

“Our agreement stands,” he said.

The Elvenking studied him.

“I am pleased to hear it.”

“The gems will be returned when they are found.”

“Then I shall trust your word.”

Thorin nodded.

It was not easy.

But he had given his word.

And he intended to keep it.

_____________

 

Later that afternoon, Gandalf found Bilbo standing upon a balcony overlooking the valley.

The hobbit had been unusually quiet since the meeting.

Gandalf approached without speaking.

For a while, they stood together.

At last, Bilbo sighed.

“I suppose I ought not to let one unpleasant man upset me.”

“Why not?”

Bilbo looked at him.

Gandalf raised an eyebrow.

“Being brave does not mean that cruel words cannot hurt you.”

Bilbo looked down.

“He made it sound so... ugly.”

Gandalf waited.

Bilbo touched the silver bead.

“Thorin gave me this. It belonged to his family.”

“I gathered as much.”

“And Alfrid spoke of it as though I'd stolen it.”

Gandalf's expression softened.

“Bilbo, the value of a gift is not diminished by the ignorance of someone who fails to understand it.”

Bilbo was quiet for a moment.

Then he smiled faintly.

“You always did have a way of making things sound simple.”

“Only when they are.”

Gandalf looked toward the distant slopes.

“There is something else troubling you.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Thorin has been... different.”

“In what way?”

“He's still himself. Mostly. But sometimes he looks at the treasure as though he's afraid someone will take it. And sometimes he looks at me the same way.”

Gandalf's expression grew serious.

“The wealth of Erebor has weighed heavily upon the House of Durin before.”

“Do you think it will happen again?”

“I think,” Gandalf answered carefully, “that your Thorin is fighting a battle he may not fully understand.”

Bilbo looked toward the mountain.

“He does understand some of it.”

“Then that is encouraging.”

Gandalf rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“But remember, my dear Bilbo, you cannot fight every battle for him.”

Bilbo nodded.

He knew that.

It did not make watching any easier.

_______________

 

Fíli found Bilbo shortly before supper.

The hobbit was sitting beside a window, attempting to read a book he had rescued from the old library.

“May I join you?”

“Of course.”

Fíli sat.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then the young dwarf looked at the silver bead in Bilbo's hair.

“I wanted to apologize for what happened today.”

Bilbo frowned.

“You have nothing to apologize for.”

“I should have stopped him sooner.”

“You were about to.”

Fíli's mouth tightened.

“I was.”

Bilbo studied him.

“You looked rather frightening, actually.”

That earned a small smile.

“Good.”

Bilbo laughed softly.

Fíli's expression grew serious again.

“There will be others who question your place here.”

Bilbo looked down.

“I thought as much.”

“Some may be nobles. Some may be members of the other dwarven houses. They may not understand why Uncle has chosen a hobbit.”

Bilbo was silent.

Fíli leaned forward.

“But they will understand that you are family.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“And when I wear the crown,” Fíli continued quietly, “that will not change.”

For a moment, Bilbo could not speak.

Then he reached across the table and squeezed the young dwarf's hand.

“Thank you, Fíli.”

Fíli smiled.

“You've looked after us often enough. It seems only fair that we return the favour.”

A voice came from the doorway.

“I've already begun a list.”

They turned.

Kíli stood there holding a piece of parchment.

Bilbo blinked.

“A list of what?”

“People who are not invited to your wedding.”

Fíli closed his eyes.

“Kíli.”

“Alfrid is first.”

“Of course he is.”

“I've left room for additions.”

Bilbo began laughing.

Kíli looked pleased with himself.

“And if anyone else is foolish enough to insult you, Uncle Bilbo, I'll be happy to explain the situation.”

“With words?” Fíli asked.

Kíli considered.

“Initially.”

Bilbo laughed harder.

For the first time since the negotiations, the hurt in his chest began to fade.

________________

 

As evening approached, Legolas sought permission to investigate the suspicious movements reported near the eastern slopes.

Dwalin had found tracks beyond the lower approaches, and several scouts had reported signs of movement along the northern routes.

Thranduil listened carefully.

“Take a small party,” he instructed. “Do not engage unless necessary.”

Legolas nodded.

“I will return with what I find.”

Bilbo met him near the gates before he departed.

“Do be careful.”

Legolas smiled.

“I intend to.”

“And if you happen to discover a suitable place for a garden while you're out there, I should be grateful.”

Legolas laughed.

“I shall keep my eyes open.”

Kíli, standing nearby, folded his arms.

“Apparently, saving the mountain isn't enough. Now the elf is helping plan the gardens.”

Bilbo gave him an affectionate look.

“Jealous?”

“Of gardening? Certainly not.”

Legolas's smile widened.

“I shall bring you a flower, Master Kíli.”

“Please don't.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then Legolas mounted his horse and departed with his scouts.

________________

 

Thorin watched them disappear beyond the gates.

His expression was grim.

He knew what lay beyond those mountains.

He knew the orcs were gathering.

And he knew that somewhere to the east, his cousin Dáin Ironfoot would soon march toward Erebor with an army.

In his first life, that army had come to defend the mountain against Men and Elves.

This time, Thorin had no intention of allowing such a conflict to begin.

He had already instructed Balin to send word to the Iron Hills, requesting assistance and warning Dáin to approach peacefully.

But he had not explained why the message was so urgent.

Nor had he told anyone that he expected war.

How could he?

How could he explain that he remembered watching Fíli die upon Ravenhill?

That he remembered Kíli falling?

That he remembered his own blood staining the snow?

He looked toward the distant peaks.

History had changed.

Smaug was dead.

Bard and Thranduil were allies rather than enemies.

Bilbo was alive.

Yet Thorin could not shake the certainty that the greatest danger still lay ahead.

That night, Balin found Thorin standing alone in the council chamber.

The maps remained spread across the table.

Several markers indicated the mountain's gates, the northern passes, and the roads leading toward the Iron Hills.

Balin studied them.

“You've been thinking about defence.”

Thorin nodded.

“Dwalin found more tracks.”

“So I heard.”

Balin moved closer.

“Do you expect trouble, laddie?”

Thorin looked toward the northern mountains.

“Yes.”

Balin frowned.

“From whom?”

Thorin hesitated.

He could not tell him about Azog.

Not yet.

Not without explaining how he knew.

“Orcs,” he answered.

Balin's expression darkened.

“Then we should prepare.”

“We will.”

“And Dáin?”

“He will come.”

Balin looked at him.

“You sound very certain.”

Thorin met his gaze.

“My cousin has never abandoned his kin.”

That, at least, was true.

Balin nodded slowly.

“Then we shall be ready.”

After he departed, Thorin remained beside the maps.

He looked at the marker representing Ravenhill.

His hand trembled.

He remembered the cold.

The blood.

The terrible silence after the fighting.

And Bilbo's voice calling his name.

Thorin closed his eyes.

He had changed so much already.

He had saved his nephews from dangers that had nearly killed them before.

He had made peace with Thranduil.

He had warned Bard.

He had reclaimed Erebor without sacrificing the people he loved.

But the battle was still coming.

And this time, he could not afford to lose.

_______________

 

Bilbo found him later.

He entered quietly, carrying two cups of tea.

“I thought you might be here.”

Thorin looked up.

Bilbo set one cup beside him.

“You missed supper.”

“I wasn't hungry.”

“That's a dreadful excuse.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

Bilbo stepped closer.

For a moment, he looked at the maps.

Then he looked at Thorin.

“Something is troubling you.”

Thorin hesitated.

“Yes.”

“Would you like to tell me?”

Thorin looked toward the distant mountains.

He wanted to.

More than anything, he wanted to tell Bilbo everything.

About the first journey.

About Ravenhill.

About the terrible moment when he had understood that his love had come too late.

But the words remained trapped behind his teeth.

“Not tonight,” he said.

Bilbo studied him.

Then he nodded.

“All right.”

Thorin looked at him.

“You aren't going to insist?”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“You gave me time when I needed it. I can do the same for you.”

The words struck Thorin with unexpected force.

He reached for Bilbo's hand.

“Thank you.”

Bilbo squeezed his fingers.

“Come to bed, Thorin.”

Thorin looked once more toward the maps.

Then he turned away.

They walked together through the quiet halls.

Behind them, the mountain held its ancient treasures.

Before them lay an uncertain future.

And somewhere beyond the northern passes, armies were beginning to move.

Thorin knew Dáin would come.

He knew Azog would come.

He knew that soon, the peace they had fought so hard to win would be tested by steel and blood.

But this time, he would not allow his pride to turn allies into enemies.

This time, he would not mistake gold for the measure of a kingdom.

And this time, when the battle came, he would fight not merely to reclaim his home, but to protect the life he had been given a second chance to live.

Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's as they reached the royal chambers.

Thorin looked down at him.

The silver bead in Bilbo's hair caught the torchlight.

And for a moment, the memory of Ravenhill loosened its grip.

He had been given another road.

He intended to walk it differently.

Chapter 20: Chapter Twenty — The Gathering Storm

Chapter Text

The first indication that Dáin Ironfoot had arrived was the sound of someone shouting outside Erebor's gates.

The second was Kíli abandoning his breakfast so abruptly that his chair nearly overturned.

“That's Dáin!”

Fíli looked up from the documents he had been reviewing. “You cannot possibly know that.”

“I know my cousin's voice.”

“He's our cousin.”

“Then you ought to recognize him too.”

Bilbo, who had been enjoying a particularly good piece of toast, watched Kíli race toward the doorway.

“Is he always this enthusiastic about family visits?”

Thorin, seated beside him, sighed.

“Unfortunately, the enthusiasm is mutual.”

From outside came another tremendous shout, followed by laughter and the unmistakable sound of Kíli yelling something incomprehensible.

Thorin closed his eyes.

“He hasn't even entered the mountain.”

Bilbo smiled. “I think I shall like him.”

“You may reconsider.”

_____________

 

Dáin Ironfoot arrived at the head of several hundred dwarven warriors, their armour bearing the marks of the Iron Hills. They had marched hard, and dust covered their boots and cloaks, but their formation remained disciplined as they gathered before the gates.

Their commander, however, appeared considerably less interested in discipline.

“THORIN!”

Dáin dismounted before his guards could assist him.

He was broad, heavily armoured, and possessed a magnificent red beard. His expression was fierce enough to intimidate an entire battlefield until he caught sight of Thorin descending the steps.

Then his face split into a grin.

“You stubborn old bastard!”

Bilbo made a small, startled noise.

Thorin laughed.

Actually laughed.

Dáin seized him in an embrace that looked rather like two mountains colliding.

“I heard you'd reclaimed the place, but I wasn't believing a word until I saw you standing here!”

“You received my message.”

“Aye, and a bloody strange message it was! Come quickly, bring warriors, bring craftsmen, and don't start a fight with the elves.” Dáin released him, looking offended. “What sort of greeting is that?”

“A necessary one.”

“Necessary, he says!”

Dáin turned toward Fíli and Kíli.

His expression softened.

“Look at you two.”

Kíli grinned. “Missed us?”

“Not particularly.”

He pulled them both into a crushing embrace.

Fíli endured it with considerably more dignity than Kíli, who complained loudly that his ribs were being broken.

For a moment, Thorin simply watched.

In another life, he had never seen this reunion.

Dáin had come to Erebor only to inherit a kingdom purchased with the deaths of three members of his family.

Now Fíli was laughing, Kíli was struggling to escape their cousin's embrace, and Dáin was scolding them both for nearly getting themselves eaten by a dragon.

Thorin's throat tightened.

Then Dáin noticed Bilbo.

“And who's this?”

Bilbo straightened.

“Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

Dáin looked down at him.

“A hobbit?”

“Yes.”

“The burglar?”

Bilbo sighed. “I do wish people would stop introducing me that way.”

Dáin laughed.

Then his eyes caught the silver bead woven into Bilbo's curls.

His laughter stopped.

He leaned closer.

Bilbo leaned backward.

Dáin looked at the bead.

Then at Thorin.

Then at the matching braid in Thorin's hair.

For several seconds, nobody spoke.

Finally, Dáin turned very slowly toward his cousin.

“Thorin.”

“Yes?”

“Have you been courting a hobbit?”

Kíli made a delighted noise.

“Oh, this is going to be wonderful.”

Dáin stared.

“You went off to reclaim a kingdom, kill a dragon, and restore the House of Durin, and somewhere along the way you found time to court a hobbit?”

“Technically,” Fíli supplied, “the courtship began before we reached the mountain.”

“Fíli,” Thorin warned.

“Although Bilbo didn't realize it,” Kíli added.

Dáin blinked.

“He didn't realize?”

Bilbo covered his face.

“Please don't.”

Kíli ignored him.

“He kept braiding Uncle's hair without knowing what it meant.”

Dáin burst into laughter so tremendous that several warriors turned to look.

Thorin regarded his nephews with the expression of a king contemplating banishment.

But when Dáin finally looked at Bilbo again, his amusement softened.

“Well, Master Baggins.” He extended a hand. “If you've managed to make this miserable old stonehead smile, you're welcome in my family.”

Bilbo shook it.

“Thank you. Though I suspect he wasn't quite so miserable before I arrived.”

Dáin looked at Thorin.

Thorin looked away.

“Aye,” Dáin said quietly. “Perhaps not.”

_______________

 

By afternoon, Erebor was alive with activity.

Dáin's warriors established camps along the lower approaches while dwarven engineers examined the gates, bridges, and damaged fortifications. Bard sent representatives to coordinate supplies, and Thranduil's guards maintained watch along the forest roads.

Thorin should have been pleased.

They had allies, provisions, and a defensible mountain.

Yet the arrival of so many strangers awakened an uneasiness he could not entirely suppress.

He watched Dáin's soldiers pass through the outer halls and found himself wondering how many had seen the treasure.

How many knew where it was stored.

How many might eventually claim a share.

The thoughts disgusted him.

They came regardless.

“Uncle?”

Fíli stood beside the council table, waiting.

Thorin realized he had missed the question.

“Repeat that.”

“The first shipment for Dale. Bard's people are ready to receive it.”

“How much?”

Fíli consulted the records.

“Tools, timber fittings, food, and the agreed allocation of coin.”

Thorin's expression hardened.

“The coin can wait.”

Fíli looked up.

“We agreed—”

“I know what we agreed.”

The sharpness of his voice surprised them both.

Fíli fell silent.

Thorin looked down at the records.

He remembered another Thorin standing before the gates, convinced that the people of Lake-town wanted to rob him.

He had promised himself he would never become that man again.

“Send the supplies,” he said at last. “I will review the treasury allocation tonight.”

Fíli hesitated.

Then he bowed his head.

“As you wish.”

Thorin watched him leave.

He knew his nephew had noticed.

That troubled him almost as much as the thoughts themselves.

_____________

 

Bilbo found the Arkenstone entirely by accident.

He had gone into the treasure hall looking for a small chest.

Not an especially valuable chest, nor one containing jewels or ancient weapons. He simply wanted something sturdy enough to store the seeds Legolas had given him until he could begin planning his garden.

Unfortunately, Erebor's treasure hall contained a great many chests, most of which appeared to have been buried beneath several centuries' worth of gold.

Bilbo had spent nearly half an hour investigating a promising corner when his foot dislodged a small cascade of coins.

Something beneath them caught the light.

He crouched.

At first, he thought it was a piece of polished crystal.

Then he brushed away the gold.

The jewel beneath was unlike anything he had ever seen.

White light shimmered within it, shifting into delicate colours as he turned it in his hands. It seemed almost alive, as though some distant star had been captured inside the stone.

Bilbo's breath caught.

“Oh.”

He knew what it was.

Thorin had spoken of the Arkenstone during their journey, though rarely without sorrow. The Heart of the Mountain. The jewel his grandfather had treasured. The symbol of his family's kingship.

Bilbo stood slowly.

His first instinct was to find Thorin.

He could already imagine the surprise upon his face.

Perhaps even happiness.

Then he remembered Thorin's expression that morning when Fíli mentioned the gold promised to Dale.

The sudden coldness.

The suspicion.

Bilbo looked down at the jewel.

A dreadful thought occurred to him.

What if finding it makes everything worse?

He remembered the way Thorin sometimes stood among the treasure, so still that Bilbo could scarcely recognize him.

He remembered Gandalf's warning.

And he remembered Thorin confessing, with visible difficulty, that the mountain sometimes made him feel as though everything he loved might be taken away.

Bilbo closed his fingers around the Arkenstone.

He would tell him.

Of course he would.

But perhaps not today.

Perhaps when the war was over, when Thorin had slept properly, when the treasure no longer seemed to trouble him quite so much.

He slipped the jewel into an inner pocket.

For some reason, the small weight felt terribly heavy.

______________

 

Dáin found Thorin in the treasure hall shortly before supper.

He stood watching his cousin from the entrance for several moments.

Thorin had not noticed him.

His attention was fixed upon a broad stretch of gold where several dwarves had been searching earlier that day.

“Still looking for it?”

Thorin turned.

“For what?”

Dáin raised an eyebrow.

“Don't insult me, cousin.”

Thorin said nothing.

Dáin approached, his boots disturbing the scattered coins.

“I remember Thrór.”

The words made Thorin stiffen.

Dáin continued quietly.

“I remember how he looked at this place. How he began counting every coin as though the world would end if one went missing.”

“I am not my grandfather.”

“No,” Dáin agreed. “You're not.”

Thorin looked away.

“But I know that look.”

A long silence followed.

Dáin rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“You've got your kingdom back. Your nephews are alive. You've even found yourself someone to love.” He glanced toward the entrance. “Don't let all this convince you those things aren't enough.”

Thorin swallowed.

“I know what matters.”

“Then remember it.”

Dáin squeezed his shoulder before departing.

Thorin remained where he was.

He stared at the gold until its glittering surface seemed to shift beneath his eyes.

Somewhere within these halls lay the Arkenstone.

His inheritance.

His birthright.

The heart of his kingdom.

And for one terrible moment, he wanted it more desperately than he wanted to admit.

_______________

 

Legolas returned at dusk.

His horse was exhausted, and the scouts accompanying him looked as though they had ridden without rest.

Thranduil met his son in the courtyard.

One look at Legolas's expression was enough.

“What have you found?”

Legolas dismounted.

“An army.”

Thranduil's face hardened.

“How large?”

“Larger than we anticipated. Orcs and wargs are moving toward the mountain.”

Bard, who had been speaking with Gandalf nearby, approached.

“From the north?”

“From more than one direction.”

Legolas looked toward Erebor.

“There is a second force. It is approaching through the northern passes, using routes that will allow it to strike behind us.”

Gandalf's expression darkened.

“Then they mean to trap us.”

Legolas nodded.

“And there is something else.”

He hesitated.

“Among them are creatures bred for war. They have brought heavy weapons and beasts capable of breaking fortifications.”

Thranduil turned toward the mountain.

“Summon Thorin.”

The council gathered within the hour.

Dáin listened to Legolas's report with growing fury.

“Let them come,” he growled. “They'll find more than a few frightened miners waiting for them.”

“They intend to attack from multiple directions,” Bard reminded him. “We cannot afford to underestimate them.”

Thranduil studied the map.

“If their northern force reaches the valley before we establish defences, our position becomes considerably more dangerous.”

Thorin stood at the head of the table.

He had expected this.

Azog.

Bolg.

The armies gathering beneath the shadow of Ravenhill.

He could almost see the snow stained red.

“Then we must prevent them from dividing us,” he said.

He ordered additional guards at the gates, strengthened the northern approaches, and instructed Dáin's engineers to examine the mountain's older defensive passages.

He also forbade Fíli and Kíli from leading any expedition toward Ravenhill.

Fíli frowned.

“Uncle, if the northern routes require scouting—”

“Someone else will do it.”

“But—”

“That is an order.”

Kíli exchanged a glance with his brother.

Neither understood.

Thorin could bear their confusion.

He could not bear another memory of their bodies upon that hill.

Then Gandalf raised a different concern.

“The noncombatants should be moved somewhere safer before the armies arrive.”

Thorin's attention sharpened.

“Bilbo will leave.”

Bilbo, seated beside him, looked up.

“I beg your pardon?”

“You will go with the first group of civilians.”

“No, I won't.”

Thorin's jaw tightened.

“This is not a discussion.”

Bilbo stared at him.

“Then perhaps you should have informed me before deciding my future.”

Several people suddenly became very interested in the map.

Thorin lowered his voice.

“Bilbo, the mountain may become a battlefield.”

“I understand that.”

“You could be killed.”

“So could you.”

“That is different.”

Bilbo's expression changed.

“Why?”

“Because I am king.”

“And I am apparently someone whose wishes needn't be considered?”

Thorin flinched.

“That is not what I meant.”

“Then what did you mean?”

Thorin looked at him.

He saw Bilbo beneath the shattered stones of another battlefield.

He remembered blood upon his own hands and the terrible certainty that he would never see those beloved eyes again.

Fear tightened around his chest.

“I cannot lose you,” he said.

Bilbo's anger softened, though it did not disappear.

“Then don't push me away.”

The words struck painfully close to something Thorin had been trying not to acknowledge.

He looked toward the others.

“We will discuss the evacuations tomorrow.”

Bilbo sat back.

It was not an agreement.

But it was better than an order.

_______________

 

That night, Bilbo returned to their chambers before Thorin.

He removed his waistcoat and carefully placed the Arkenstone inside a folded cloth at the bottom of his travelling bag.

For a long while, he stared at it.

He had never kept anything from Thorin that felt quite so dangerous.

Except, perhaps, the Ring.

Bilbo closed the bag.

He told himself again that he would explain everything soon.

When Thorin finally arrived, he looked exhausted.

Bilbo was sitting beside the fire with a book.

Thorin stopped in the doorway.

“Are you angry with me?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“A little.”

Thorin nodded.

“I shouldn't have made that decision without you.”

“No,” Bilbo agreed. “You shouldn't.”

Thorin crossed the room and sat beside him.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then Bilbo reached for his hand.

“I know you're frightened.”

Thorin looked at their joined fingers.

“You cannot know how much.”

Bilbo leaned against him.

“Then tell me.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

He could not.

Not without telling him everything.

So he simply drew Bilbo closer.

Bilbo allowed it.

And for a little while, they sat together as they once had during the journey, with the fire crackling softly and the world beyond their little circle of warmth seeming very far away.

Eventually, Bilbo fell asleep against his shoulder.

Thorin carried him to bed.

He settled the blankets around him and gently brushed a curl away from his forehead, careful not to disturb the silver bead woven into his hair.

Bilbo stirred.

“Thorin?”

“I'm here.”

“Come to bed.”

“In a moment.”

Bilbo reached sleepily for his hand.

Thorin held it until the hobbit drifted off again.

Then he lay beside him.

He dreamed of Ravenhill.

Of ice beneath his knees.

Of Fíli's body falling.

Of Kíli's blood upon the stones.

And then Bilbo was there, kneeling beside him in the snow.

Thorin remembered the warmth of his hands.

The tears upon his face.

The words he had spoken too late.

He tried to reach for him.

But the snow became gold.

It rose around them in glittering waves, burying the battlefield, the mountain, and the small figure desperately calling his name.

Thorin woke with a strangled gasp.

For a moment, he did not know where he was.

Then he felt warmth beside him.

Bilbo.

Alive.

Sleeping peacefully beneath the blankets.

Thorin turned toward him and pulled him close.

Bilbo murmured something incomprehensible, then settled against his chest.

Thorin buried his face in his curls.

He could still smell the faint sweetness of the soap Bilbo had found in the royal stores.

Still feel the steady rhythm of his breathing.

Still hold him.

“I won't lose you,” Thorin whispered.

Bilbo slept on.

Beyond the chamber windows, the wind moved through the mountain passes.

Far to the north, armies marched beneath the darkness.

And somewhere among Bilbo's belongings lay the Heart of the Mountain, hidden from the king who had spent his life longing to possess it.

Thorin tightened his arms around the hobbit.

He did not know that the treasure he sought was already within his own chambers.

Nor did he know how close he was to losing something infinitely more precious.

Chapter 21: Chapter Twenty-One — The Weight of a Silver Bead

Chapter Text

The mountain had begun to sound like war.

From dawn until long after sunset, the great halls of Erebor rang with hammer blows and the grinding of stone. Dáin's engineers laboured to reinforce the gates, while dwarven soldiers carried weapons from armouries that had stood untouched for nearly two centuries. Beyond the mountain, Bard's men constructed barricades along the approaches to Dale, and Thranduil's elves maintained watch upon the roads leading into the valley.

There was little laughter now.

Even Kíli had grown quieter.

Thorin stood at the council table, studying a map of the northern passes while Fíli reviewed the latest supply records.

“The second shipment for Dale is ready,” his nephew said. “Bard has requested the remaining iron fittings, and the craftsmen believe they can begin repairing the eastern shelters before—”

“No.”

Fíli looked up.

“Uncle?”

“The iron stays here.”

“But we agreed—”

“We agreed to provide assistance, not empty our stores while an army marches toward our gates.”

Fíli glanced at the figures before him. “We have more than enough iron for our own defences.”

Thorin's expression hardened.

“Have you counted every piece?”

“No, but—”

“Then you cannot know that.”

Silence settled between them.

Fíli slowly lowered the parchment.

He had seen his uncle angry before. He had seen him exhausted, frightened, and burdened by responsibilities that would have crushed lesser men.

But lately, something else had begun appearing in his eyes whenever the treasury was mentioned.

Something cold.

Something that reminded Fíli of stories Balin had told him about Thrór.

“Uncle,” he said carefully, “the people of Dale have kept their promises to us.”

Thorin looked at him.

“And I intend to keep mine.”

“Then—”

“When I am satisfied that Erebor is secure.”

Fíli's jaw tightened, but he bowed his head.

“As you wish, Your Majesty.”

The title struck Thorin unpleasantly.

Fíli rarely used it when they were alone.

Before Thorin could say anything, his nephew gathered the records and departed.

Dáin, who had been standing near the doorway, watched him go.

“You're frightening the lad.”

Thorin returned his attention to the map.

“He needs to learn that a king cannot grant every request.”

“Aye,” Dáin replied. “And a king ought to learn when a request is reasonable.”

Thorin said nothing.

Dáin studied him for another moment, then shook his head and left.

Only when the chamber was empty did Thorin close his eyes.

He knew what they were seeing.

Worse, he knew they were right.

Yet beneath the guilt, another thought whispered that they simply did not understand how much he stood to lose.

____________

 

Bilbo had never imagined that holding a jewel could make him feel quite so miserable.

The Arkenstone lay upon Gandalf's table, wrapped in a square of dark cloth. Even in the dim chamber, pale light shimmered across its surface.

Gandalf regarded it without touching it.

“So,” the wizard said at last, “you found it.”

Bilbo nodded.

“Three days ago.”

“And Thorin does not know?”

“No.”

Gandalf sighed.

Bilbo clasped his hands together.

“I meant to tell him. Truly, I did. But every time someone mentions the treasury, he becomes so terribly angry, and yesterday he ordered another two guards outside the treasure hall, and—”

He stopped.

Gandalf waited.

Bilbo looked down.

“I'm frightened of what it might do to him.”

The wizard's expression softened.

“And are you frightened of Thorin himself?”

Bilbo was silent for a long time.

“Not in the way you mean,” he answered eventually. “I know he would never deliberately hurt me.”

Then his eyes filled with an uncertainty Gandalf had never seen there before.

“But sometimes he looks at me as though he's trying to decide whether he can trust me. And I don't know what I've done to deserve that.”

Gandalf leaned forward.

“You have done nothing to deserve suspicion, Bilbo. But you must understand that keeping this hidden may deepen the very mistrust you fear.”

“I know.”

“Then what will you do?”

Bilbo looked at the Arkenstone.

He thought of Thorin's laughter upon seeing Dáin, of the silver bead nestled among his curls, of the night Thorin had promised him a future beneath the mountain.

And he remembered the tenderness with which those promises had been made.

“I'll tell him tonight.”

Gandalf nodded.

“Then speak to the Thorin you know, my dear boy. Not the one you fear he is becoming.”

Bilbo carefully wrapped the jewel.

He wished he felt as brave as Gandalf seemed to believe he was.

_____________

 

Thorin missed supper.

Bilbo waited until the food had grown cold, then asked Bombur to save him a portion.

It was not the first evening this had happened.

He carried a small plate toward the royal chambers, hoping Thorin might return before it became too late. When he found him there, however, Thorin was standing beside the window, examining a list of missing treasures.

“You haven't eaten,” Bilbo said gently.

“I will.”

“You said that yesterday.”

Thorin rubbed his forehead.

“Bilbo, please.”

The words were not especially harsh.

Perhaps that was why they hurt.

Bilbo set down the plate.

“You've barely slept either.”

“There is a war approaching.”

“I know.”

“Then you understand why I cannot spend every evening sitting beside the fire.”

Bilbo went still.

He had not asked for every evening.

He had only wanted one.

“Of course,” he said quietly.

Thorin looked up.

Something in Bilbo's expression made him regret the words immediately.

“Bilbo—”

“It's all right.”

But it wasn't.

Later, when Thorin finally sat beside the fire, Bilbo approached with a comb.

“Your hair's become rather tangled,” he said, attempting a smile. “May I?”

Thorin nodded distractedly.

For a few moments, the familiar motion soothed them both. Bilbo gently worked through the dark strands, separating a small section near Thorin's temple.

Then Thorin noticed the treasury records lying beyond his reach.

He shifted.

Bilbo's fingers caught in his hair.

“Just a moment—”

“Bilbo, not now.”

Thorin pulled away.

The comb slipped from Bilbo's hand and struck the floor.

Neither moved.

Thorin turned.

Bilbo stood behind him, his hands still half-raised, as though he had forgotten what to do with them.

“I'm sorry,” Thorin said.

Bilbo bent to retrieve the comb.

“It's quite all right.”

“No, I—”

“You have important things to attend to.”

He placed the comb upon the table.

Then he smiled.

It was a small, careful smile that made Thorin feel worse than anger would have.

“I'll leave you to them.”

Thorin watched him go.

He almost followed.

But the records remained upon the table, and somewhere beneath the mountain lay the Arkenstone.

He told himself he would apologize properly tomorrow.

______________

 

By the time Bilbo entered the treasure hall that evening, Thorin had been searching for nearly two hours.

Lanterns burned along the pillars, their light falling across mountains of gold. The vast chamber seemed to stretch endlessly into darkness, filled with wealth that could have fed kingdoms and rebuilt cities.

Thorin stood beside a half-open chest.

He looked tired.

More than tired.

Bilbo could see the strain around his eyes, the tension in his shoulders, the way his fingers kept closing around the edge of the chest.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf turned.

For one brief moment, his expression softened.

“Bilbo.”

And there he was.

The Thorin Bilbo knew.

The man who had carried him through the wilderness when his feet were blistered, who had listened patiently to his stories about the Shire, who had kissed him beneath the stars and promised that wherever they went, they would find a way to make a home.

Bilbo nearly lost his courage.

“I need to tell you something.”

Thorin straightened.

“What is it?”

Bilbo approached slowly.

“First, I want you to know that I never meant to hurt you.”

A faint crease appeared between Thorin's brows.

“Bilbo?”

“I found something. A few days ago. I wanted to give it to you immediately, but then I thought perhaps it would be better to wait, and I realize now that was wrong.”

He reached into his pocket.

Thorin's eyes followed the movement.

Bilbo unfolded the cloth.

The Arkenstone caught the lantern light.

Everything changed.

Thorin stopped breathing.

For several seconds, he could only stare.

The Heart of the Mountain.

His grandfather's treasure.

The jewel he had searched for since entering Erebor.

It was lying in Bilbo's hands.

“Where,” Thorin asked very quietly, “did you get that?”

Bilbo swallowed.

“In the treasure hall. I found it beneath some coins.”

“When?”

“Three days ago.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Three days?”

“Yes.”

“And you kept it?”

Bilbo tightened his fingers around the cloth.

“I was going to tell you.”

“But you did not.”

“No.”

Thorin stepped closer.

“Did you intend to tell me at all?”

“Of course!”

“Then why have you concealed it?”

Bilbo looked into his face.

“Because I was worried about you.”

Something cold moved behind Thorin's eyes.

“Worried?”

“You haven't been yourself lately. The gold, the searching, the way you've been speaking to Fíli and Bard—”

“You decided I could not be trusted with my own inheritance?”

“That isn't what I said.”

“It is what you did.”

Bilbo flinched at the sharpness of his voice.

“Thorin, please listen to me.”

“I have listened.” Thorin's gaze dropped to the jewel. “For days, I have listened to you assure me that everything would be well, while you kept the one thing I have been searching for hidden from me.”

“I was afraid!”

The words escaped before Bilbo could stop them.

Thorin went still.

“Of what?”

Bilbo's eyes shone.

“Of losing you.”

For a heartbeat, something shifted in Thorin's expression.

Then he asked, almost inaudibly, “Or were you afraid of me?”

Bilbo could not answer.

Because the truth was more complicated than either of them wanted it to be.

He was not afraid Thorin would strike him.

He was afraid of the coldness in his voice. Of watching the gentle man he loved disappear behind suspicion. Of waking one morning to discover that Thorin had begun loving the mountain more than the life they had promised each other.

His silence was answer enough.

Thorin stepped back.

“You believe me capable of becoming a monster.”

“No!”

“Then why?”

“Because I can see what this place is doing to you!”

His voice cracked.

“Because you barely sleep, and you hardly eat, and when I try to speak to you, you look at me as though I'm keeping you from something more important!”

Thorin's face hardened.

“You have been keeping something from me.”

Bilbo stared at him.

The accusation hung between them.

Then Thorin looked at the Arkenstone again.

“When you told me you loved me,” he asked, “were you already hiding it?”

Bilbo felt the blood drain from his face.

“What?”

“You heard me.”

“Thorin, my love for you has nothing to do with that stone.”

“Yet you lied to me.”

“I made a mistake!”

“You took what belongs to my house.”

Bilbo's mouth fell open.

“I didn't take it for myself.”

“You were hired as a burglar.”

The words struck like a blow.

For a moment, Bilbo could only stare at him.

He remembered Alfrid's sneering face.

First you allow a common thief into your halls...

Thorin seemed to realize what he had said.

But before he could take it back, another thought rose from the dark, possessive place that had been growing within him.

Perhaps Bilbo had never understood what it meant to belong to the House of Durin.

Perhaps he had been foolish to trust so much.

“Perhaps,” Thorin said, his voice low and terrible, “I was a fool to give you a place in my family before I knew whether you could be trusted with it.”

Silence.

Bilbo stopped moving.

The lanterns flickered across his face, illuminating the terrible stillness that had settled over his features.

Thorin felt a sudden, sickening twist in his stomach.

“Bilbo—”

The hobbit looked down.

His hand rose slowly toward his curls.

At first, Thorin did not understand.

Then Bilbo began undoing the braid.

“Bilbo, what are you doing?”

Bilbo's fingers trembled as he worked at the woven strands.

It was not an elaborate braid. Thorin had made it simple, knowing Bilbo's curls were shorter and softer than dwarven hair.

He remembered sitting behind Bilbo on their first peaceful night in Erebor.

He remembered Bilbo laughing when he discovered the meaning of courtship braids.

Have I been proposing to you for the past six months?

And he remembered the expression upon Bilbo's face when Thorin had given him the silver bead.

Wonder.

Happiness.

Love.

Now those same fingers struggled to remove it.

“Stop,” Thorin whispered.

Bilbo did not.

“Please.”

The braid came loose.

Bilbo held the bead in his palm.

It looked impossibly small.

“I didn't know,” he said quietly, “that belonging to your family was something I could lose.”

Thorin felt the words settle somewhere beneath his ribs.

“You haven't lost—”

“You said you were a fool to give me a place in it.”

“I was angry.”

Bilbo looked up.

His eyes were wet.

“So was Alfrid.”

Thorin recoiled.

Bilbo's voice trembled.

“He called me a thief. He said I didn't belong beside you. And you were so angry with him that I thought—”

He stopped, struggling to breathe evenly.

“I thought you understood how much that hurt.”

Thorin opened his mouth.

Nothing came.

Bilbo stepped toward the table.

The Arkenstone lay upon the dark cloth.

Beside it, he placed the silver bead.

His hand lingered.

With a small, unconscious movement, he straightened the bead so that the mark of Durin faced upward.

Thorin remembered how Bilbo used to straighten his crooked braids during the journey.

Even now, Bilbo treated the gift with tenderness.

“There,” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin stared at the two objects.

The Heart of the Mountain shone brilliantly.

The silver bead barely caught the light.

“Now you have both.”

Thorin reached toward him.

Not to seize him.

Only to touch his hand.

Bilbo drew back.

The movement was small, instinctive, and utterly devastating.

Thorin stopped immediately.

His hand remained suspended between them for a moment before falling to his side.

Bilbo wiped at his cheek, frustrated when another tear followed.

“I would have loved you without any of this,” he said.

He gestured helplessly toward the gold.

“Without Erebor. Without a crown. Without the Arkenstone.”

His voice broke.

“I would have lived in a cave with you, Thorin. I would have been happy with a fire, a little garden, and somewhere to put my books.”

Thorin could scarcely breathe.

“I know.”

“Do you?”

Bilbo looked at him.

“Because I don't think you understand what you gave me when you put that bead in my hair.”

Thorin's eyes burned.

“You were giving me a home,” Bilbo continued. “A family. A future. And I believed you.”

“I meant every word.”

“Then why does it feel as though I have to earn them all over again?”

Thorin had no answer.

Bilbo looked down at the Arkenstone.

“I thought if I waited, I might be able to give this to you without losing the man I love.”

He swallowed.

“But perhaps I've already lost him.”

“No.”

The word escaped Thorin desperately.

“Bilbo, no.”

The hobbit looked at him for a long moment.

Then he asked, very softly, “When you look at me now, Thorin, do you still see the person you wanted to spend your life with?”

Thorin's throat tightened.

“Of course I—”

“Or do you only see the burglar who took something that belonged to you?”

Thorin went still.

He wanted to say that Bilbo was everything.

That he had loved him before the mountain was reclaimed, before the dragon was slain, before Bilbo had ever known the meaning of the braids in his hair.

But the Arkenstone lay between them.

And somewhere inside him, a dreadful voice was still demanding that he pick it up.

That he secure it.

That he never allow anyone to take it from him again.

Thorin looked at the jewel.

Only for a moment.

But Bilbo saw.

The last fragile hope in his expression faded.

“I see.”

“Bilbo—”

The hobbit stepped backward.

Thorin took an instinctive step after him, then stopped when Bilbo's shoulders tightened.

He had never seen Bilbo look at him like that.

As though even one more word might break something that could not be repaired.

Bilbo drew a shaky breath.

“Goodnight, Your Majesty.”

Thorin felt the title more keenly than any blade.

Not Thorin.

Not my love.

Not even the affectionate, exasperated you impossible dwarf that had accompanied so many of their arguments.

Your Majesty.

Bilbo turned and walked toward the doors.

His steps were quiet upon the stone.

Thorin wanted to call him back.

He wanted to tell him that the bead had never been payment for loyalty, that Bilbo had never needed to earn his place, that he would surrender every jewel beneath the mountain before willingly losing him.

But he had already spoken.

And Bilbo had heard him.

The doors closed.

Thorin remained motionless.

His own hair was still braided.

The small, slightly crooked braid Bilbo had made for him remained tucked behind his ear, exactly where Bilbo had placed it on the night they promised each other a future.

Bilbo had not asked for it back.

On the table, the Arkenstone glittered beside the little silver bead.

One had been the greatest treasure of his grandfather's kingdom.

The other had been the most precious gift Thorin had ever given.

He had spent days searching for the first.

And tonight, he had been handed it at the cost of the second.

Chapter 22: Chapter Twenty-Two — Before the Dawn

Chapter Text

For a long time after leaving the treasure hall, Bilbo could not remember how he had found his way through the corridors of Erebor.

He remembered the sound of his own footsteps, strangely loud against the stone. He remembered passing two dwarven guards who had bowed to him, and how he had nearly turned around to tell them not to bother. He remembered the terrible effort it had taken to keep walking when every part of him wanted to sit down somewhere and simply stop.

Most of all, he remembered Thorin looking at the Arkenstone.

It had been only a glance.

Bilbo knew that. He had watched Thorin long enough to recognize the difference between an intentional cruelty and an involuntary movement, and somewhere beneath the hurt he understood that the sickness had reached for the jewel through Thorin's eyes.

But understanding did not make the memory less painful.

He had asked Thorin whether he still saw the person he wanted to spend his life with.

And Thorin had looked at the stone.

Bilbo eventually found himself outside a guest chamber on one of the upper residential levels. It was a lovely room, furnished with carved oak and deep green curtains, with a hearth already laid for the night. He had passed it several times since the Company reclaimed Erebor, though he had never imagined he would have any reason to sleep there.

His place had been beside Thorin.

Until tonight.

He entered, shut the door, and stood in the middle of the room with his arms wrapped around himself.

His fingers rose automatically toward his hair.

They found only loose curls.

Bilbo lowered his hand.

He had not realized how accustomed he had become to the small weight of the silver bead. Thorin had braided it into his hair with such extraordinary care, explaining the old customs of his people while Bilbo sat between his knees, feeling wonderfully, impossibly loved.

You needn't wear it unless you wish to.

And Bilbo had wished to.

He still did.

That was perhaps the cruelest part of it.

A quiet knock interrupted his thoughts.

“Bilbo?”

Fíli.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“I'm quite all right.”

There was a pause.

“May I come in?”

He considered refusing. The thought of anyone seeing him like this was almost unbearable, particularly someone who had always looked at him with such easy affection.

But Fíli was waiting patiently outside, and Bilbo had never been particularly good at turning either of Thorin's nephews away.

“Of course.”

Fíli entered carrying a small lamp. His golden hair was untidily braided, and he still wore the leather tunic he had used throughout the day's preparations. He looked exhausted.

His expression softened when he saw Bilbo.

Then his gaze lifted to Bilbo's hair.

The change was immediate.

“Bilbo,” he said quietly. “Where is your bead?”

Bilbo attempted a smile.

“I've taken it out.”

Fíli set the lamp down.

“Why?”

“Oh, it's rather complicated.”

Fíli looked at him for another moment, then crossed the room and sat beside him on the edge of the bed.

“All right,” he said. “Then we have time.”

Bilbo stared at his hands.

He had intended to say something reassuring. Something about Thorin being tired, or the strain of preparing for battle, or the terrible influence of the treasure beneath their feet.

Instead, he whispered, “I gave him the Arkenstone.”

Fíli went very still.

Bilbo told him everything.

_____________

 

Not easily, and not all at once. He stumbled over the explanation of finding the jewel three days earlier, of hiding it because he feared what possessing it might do to Thorin. He admitted that he should have spoken sooner. He explained the argument, Thorin's accusations, and finally the words that had made the world seem to fall away beneath him.

Perhaps I was a fool to give you a place in my family before I knew whether you could be trusted with it.

Fíli's face had become frighteningly pale.

“He said that?”

Bilbo nodded.

“He was angry.”

“That is not what I asked.”

“I know.” Bilbo rubbed at his eyes. “I know, Fíli. But he isn't himself. You know that as well as I do.”

Fíli looked toward the hearth, his jaw working.

“Yes,” he said eventually. “I know.”

Another knock came at the door, followed almost immediately by Kíli's familiar voice.

“Fíli? I was told you came this way. Dáin wants to know whether—”

He entered before finishing.

His eyes moved from his brother to Bilbo, then stopped at the loose curls around the hobbit's face.

For once, Kíli had nothing to say.

Fíli rose and crossed to him. They exchanged a few low words, too quiet for Bilbo to hear, though he saw Kíli's expression darken.

Then Kíli came directly to the bed.

“Bilbo?”

Bilbo looked up.

“Hello, Kíli.”

The young dwarf sat on his other side.

“What's happened?”

Bilbo opened his mouth.

Nothing came out.

Kíli glanced at Fíli, who shook his head slightly.

“First,” Fíli said, “we're getting him something to eat.”

“I don't think—”

“When did you last have supper?” Fíli asked.

Bilbo considered this.

He had brought Thorin supper. He remembered the plate, and Thorin barely touching it.

His own meal seemed to have disappeared somewhere in the confusion of the evening.

“Oh.”

Fíli sighed.

“I thought so.”

He sent Kíli to fetch food and tea, ignoring Bilbo's protests that neither was necessary.

When Kíli returned, he carried enough provisions for a small expedition, including bread, cheese, apples, honey cakes, and a teapot wrapped in a cloth to keep it warm.

“I wasn't sure what you'd want,” he explained.

“Apparently everything in Erebor's kitchens,” Fíli observed.

“I exercised restraint. Bombur wanted to send a pie.”

Under other circumstances, Bilbo might have laughed.

Tonight, he merely managed a faint smile.

Kíli poured the tea and placed a cup carefully in Bilbo's hands.

“Come on, Uncle Bilbo,” he said gently. “Just a little.”

Bilbo froze.

The cup trembled.

Kíli's smile faded.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit stared at him.

He had been holding himself together with the last scraps of his composure, telling himself that he was being foolish, that Thorin was ill, that the world was facing a war and there were far more important matters than his broken heart.

But Kíli had called him Uncle Bilbo.

Just as he always did.

As though nothing had changed.

Bilbo made a small, strangled sound.

Fíli reached for the cup before it slipped from his fingers.

“Bilbo?”

“You still—”

His voice broke.

Kíli leaned closer.

“Still what?”

Bilbo tried to answer, but the tears came too quickly. He pressed a hand over his mouth, horrified by the sob that escaped him.

“You still called me Uncle.”

Kíli stared at him.

“Of course I did.”

Bilbo shook his head helplessly.

“But Thorin said—he said perhaps he shouldn't have made me part of your family, and I thought—”

Another sob interrupted him.

“I thought perhaps that meant I wasn't anymore.”

For several seconds, the room was utterly silent.

Then Kíli moved.

He gathered Bilbo into his arms with such immediate determination that the hobbit scarcely had time to react. Bilbo clutched at his tunic, burying his face against the young dwarf's shoulder as everything he had been struggling to contain finally broke loose.

“Oh, Uncle Bilbo,” Kíli whispered.

The familiar name only made Bilbo cry harder.

Fíli moved closer and wrapped an arm around him from the other side, his hand settling warmly between Bilbo's shoulders.

“Listen to me,” Fíli said, his voice low but steady. “You did not become our family because Uncle Thorin put a bead in your hair.”

Bilbo tried to catch his breath.

“You became our family long before that,” Fíli continued. “Somewhere on the road, I think. Perhaps even before we knew it ourselves.”

Kíli nodded against Bilbo's curls.

“And you're stuck with us now.”

Bilbo gave a broken little laugh that dissolved into another sob.

“I love you,” he managed. “Both of you. Oh, I love you boys so terribly much, and I don't think I've ever told you properly.”

Kíli's arms tightened.

“I couldn't bear losing you too,” Bilbo whispered. “I know Thorin is your uncle, and he's your king, and I would never ask you to choose, but I thought perhaps if he didn't want me anymore—”

“Stop,” Kíli said, very softly.

Bilbo fell quiet.

Kíli drew back just enough to look at him.

His own eyes were bright.

“You don't ever have to ask us to choose whether we love you.”

Fíli took Bilbo's hand.

“Whatever happens between you and Thorin, you remain our family. That isn't his decision to make.”

Bilbo looked between them.

“But he's your uncle.”

“And so are you,” Kíli replied.

That undid him all over again.

He leaned into both of them, crying without trying to hide it now, while Fíli held him securely and Kíli murmured quiet reassurances into his hair.

Neither brother told him to stop.

Neither asked him to be reasonable or reminded him that Thorin was suffering too.

They simply stayed.

After a long while, when Bilbo's sobs had softened into exhausted hiccups, he whispered, “Perhaps I ought to go back to the Shire.”

Kíli's expression flickered.

Fíli's fingers tightened briefly around Bilbo's hand.

“If that's what you want,” Fíli said carefully, “we'll help you.”

Bilbo looked up in surprise.

“We'll see you home safely,” Kíli added. “And then we'll visit so often you'll regret knowing us.”

“Both of you?”

“Both of us,” Fíli promised.

“Though Fíli will probably insist on bringing paperwork,” Kíli said. “Something terribly important about trade agreements.”

“Someone must ensure the Shire survives your visits.”

Bilbo laughed weakly.

Kíli smiled, but there was something fiercely earnest beneath it.

“But if you want to stay, Uncle Bilbo, then stay. This is your home too. You don't need anyone's permission to be our family.”

Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.

He thought of Bag End, of his books and his garden, of the little round door beneath the Hill.

Then he thought of these two impossible dwarves, who had somehow become as dear to him as any relative he had ever known.

“I don't want to leave you,” he whispered.

Fíli pressed a kiss to the top of his head.

“Then don't.”

_______________

 

It was nearly midnight when Bilbo finally fell asleep.

Fíli sat against the headboard, one arm around the hobbit's shoulders, while Kíli remained on his other side with Bilbo's hand clasped between both of his.

They had spent the better part of an hour coaxing him to eat, listening to stories of the Shire, and allowing Kíli to recount increasingly ridiculous incidents from their childhood.

Bilbo had laughed more than once.

He had cried again, too.

Eventually, exhaustion claimed him.

Even in sleep, his fingers occasionally drifted toward the place where Thorin's braid had been.

Kíli watched the movement with an expression Fíli had rarely seen on his brother's face.

“He kept apologizing,” Kíli whispered.

Fíli looked down at Bilbo.

“I know.”

“As though he'd done something wrong by being upset.”

Fíli gently adjusted the blanket around the hobbit's shoulders.

They waited until Bilbo's breathing had settled into a deep, even rhythm before carefully easing him onto the pillows.

Kíli tucked the blanket beneath his chin.

Then he stood.

“I'm going to speak to Uncle.”

Fíli rose beside him.

“We both are.”

_____________

 

Thorin had not moved the Arkenstone.

It lay upon the table where Bilbo had placed it, surrounded by the wealth of his ancestors. Beside it rested the small silver bead, its engraved mark of Durin catching the light of a nearby lamp.

Thorin had spent hours looking at them.

He remembered another life.

Another argument over this very jewel.

Bilbo standing before him, frightened but determined, while Thorin accused him of betrayal. The terrible rage that had made him forget everything Bilbo had done for him. The moment he had nearly cast the hobbit from the walls of Erebor.

He had believed that knowing the future would prevent him from becoming that dwarf again.

Yet tonight he had looked into Bilbo's eyes and seen the same hurt.

Worse, perhaps.

Because this Bilbo had trusted him enough to love him.

The doors opened.

Fíli and Kíli entered together.

Thorin rose immediately.

“Is Bilbo all right?”

Neither answered at once.

That silence frightened him more than anger would have.

“He's asleep,” Fíli said eventually.

Thorin exhaled.

“May I see him?”

“No,” Fíli replied.

Thorin flinched.

Kíli stepped forward.

“He cried himself to sleep.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“He thinks he isn't our family anymore,” Fíli continued. “He asked whether he should return to the Shire.”

Thorin gripped the edge of the table.

“No.”

“He was frightened we'd stop loving him,” Kíli said.

Thorin looked up sharply.

“What?”

Kíli's face was pale with anger.

“He started crying because I called him Uncle Bilbo.”

Thorin stared at him.

“He thought he wasn't allowed to be our uncle anymore,” Kíli continued, his voice beginning to shake. “He told us he loved us, and then he cried because he thought he'd lost us too.”

“Kíli,” Thorin whispered.

“He kept apologizing. Even while he was crying, he kept trying to defend you.”

Thorin looked away.

“I know I hurt him.”

“No,” Kíli said. “I don't think you do.”

He stepped closer.

“He trusted you. He trusted you more than anyone. And you made him think he had to earn his place in our family.”

Thorin swallowed.

“I never intended—”

“You told him he didn't belong!”

“I know!”

The words escaped Thorin more sharply than he intended.

Kíli recoiled.

For an instant, Thorin saw the frightened boy he had once carried through the streets of Ered Luin after a nightmare.

And then Kíli struck him.

It happened too quickly for anyone to stop.

One furious punch caught Thorin across the jaw, sending him stumbling against the table. The lamp rattled, and Fíli seized his brother's arm before he could move again.

“Kíli!”

Silence fell.

Kíli stood rigid, breathing hard.

Thorin slowly straightened.

His jaw throbbed.

He looked at his youngest nephew.

Kíli's anger had vanished, replaced by something far more painful.

Horror.

“Uncle,” he whispered. “I'm sorry.”

Thorin touched his jaw.

“Kíli—”

“I shouldn't have done that.”

“No,” Thorin said quietly. “You shouldn't.”

Kíli lowered his eyes.

Thorin stepped toward him, then stopped.

“But I understand why you're angry.”

Kíli's face crumpled.

“I love you,” he said, his voice breaking. “That's the problem. I love you, and I love Bilbo, and I don't know how to make you see what you're doing.”

Thorin's breath caught.

“You raised us,” Kíli continued. “You taught us that family comes before everything. You taught us to protect the people who trust us.”

He glanced toward the Arkenstone.

“And now I don't recognize you when you're standing beside that thing.”

Fíli released his brother's arm.

He turned to Thorin.

“We know you're sick, Uncle. We know this isn't the dwarf who raised us. But Bilbo is the one being hurt, and knowing why doesn't make it hurt him any less.”

Thorin looked at his eldest nephew.

Fíli's voice remained steady, though his eyes were wet.

“You told me once that a king's greatest responsibility is to protect the people who place their trust in him.”

“I remember.”

“Bilbo trusted you.”

Thorin bowed his head.

“And I am not speaking as your heir tonight,” Fíli continued. “I'm speaking as someone who loves Bilbo. I will not stand by while he is made to feel unwelcome in his own home.”

Thorin's gaze moved to the silver bead.

“He returned it,” he whispered.

“We know.”

“He told me he would have loved me without the mountain. Without the crown. Without any of this.”

His voice broke.

“And I looked at the stone.”

Neither nephew spoke.

Kíli wiped angrily at his eyes.

Then he looked at the small braid still woven into Thorin's dark hair.

“He didn't ask you to take your braid out, did he?”

Thorin went still.

Slowly, his hand rose to the crooked little braid Bilbo had made for him.

“No,” he whispered.

Kíli swallowed.

“Then perhaps you should think about that.”

For a long time, Thorin said nothing.

Finally, he looked at his nephews.

“I want to make this right.”

Fíli's expression softened slightly.

“Then you must give him time.”

“I know.”

“And you must understand that he may not forgive you tomorrow.”

Thorin nodded.

“If he will allow me to try, I will. And if he will not...” He looked down at the bead. “Then I will still make certain he knows he belongs here.”

Kíli hesitated.

“Uncle?”

“Yes?”

“Are you still our uncle?”

Thorin felt something inside him break.

He crossed the distance between them and placed a trembling hand against Kíli's cheek.

“Always.”

Kíli nodded, but uncertainty remained in his eyes.

When Thorin asked once more whether he might see Bilbo, Fíli shook his head.

“Let him sleep, Uncle. He's spent enough of tonight hurting because of you.”

Thorin lowered his hand.

“All right.”

He watched them leave.

Then he turned toward the table.

For the first time since entering Erebor, he looked at the Arkenstone and felt nothing resembling triumph.

He picked up the jewel, carried it to a locked chest, and shut it inside.

When he returned, he took Bilbo's silver bead into his palm.

It was so small.

So terribly light.

He closed his fingers around it and pressed his hand against his heart.

______________

 

Morning arrived beneath a sky the colour of cold iron.

Bilbo woke to the smell of tea and the sound of Kíli arguing with Fíli about whether honey cakes were an acceptable breakfast.

“They contain honey,” Kíli insisted. “Honey comes from bees. Bees are part of nature. Therefore they're practically vegetables.”

“That is the worst argument you've ever made.”

“I've made considerably worse.”

Bilbo opened his eyes.

Both brothers looked toward him.

“Good morning, Uncle Bilbo,” Kíli said.

The words made Bilbo's throat tighten again.

But this time, he managed a smile.

“Good morning, you dreadful boy.”

Kíli beamed.

They ate together beside the hearth. Fíli kept Bilbo's cup filled, while Kíli stole pieces of bread from his plate and complained whenever Bilbo caught him.

For a little while, the world felt almost ordinary.

Then someone appeared in the doorway.

Thorin.

He had changed into dark travelling clothes beneath his armour, and there was a faint bruise along his jaw.

Bilbo noticed it immediately.

His smile disappeared.

Thorin saw.

Something painful crossed his face, but he did not look away.

“Bilbo,” he said softly. “May I speak with you?”

Fíli glanced at Bilbo.

Kíli's hand settled briefly over his.

Bilbo looked at Thorin.

Then he nodded.

The brothers rose without a word.

Kíli paused beside Bilbo long enough to squeeze his shoulder.

“We'll be just outside.”

Thorin waited until the door closed.

______________

 

For several moments, neither spoke.

Finally, Thorin stepped forward.

“I owe you an apology.”

Bilbo looked down at his hands.

“Yes,” he whispered. “You do.”

Thorin accepted the words without flinching away from them.

“What I said last night was cruel. I accused you of betraying me when you were trying to protect me. I questioned your place in my family when you have done nothing but give us your loyalty, your courage, and your love.”

His voice grew rough.

“I made you feel that your home here depended upon my approval. That was wrong.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

Thorin took another breath.

“The sickness is upon me. I know it is. But that does not excuse what I said, and I will not ask you to forgive me simply because I am frightened of what I am becoming.”

He looked at Bilbo's loose curls.

“I love you. I have not stopped loving you for a moment.”

Bilbo shut his eyes.

For a heartbeat, Thorin thought he might come closer.

Instead, Bilbo wrapped his arms around himself.

“I believe you're sorry, Thorin.”

Thorin remained still.

“I do,” Bilbo continued. “And I know that wasn't truly you speaking last night. I've seen what this mountain is doing to you.”

A tear slipped down his cheek.

“But yesterday I was afraid you no longer loved me. And I don't know how to forget what that felt like simply because you've changed your mind this morning.”

Thorin's eyes burned.

“I understand.”

“I wanted to come home with you,” Bilbo whispered. “Not because of the mountain. Not because of your crown. Because wherever you were, I thought that was where I belonged.”

Thorin swallowed hard.

“You do belong with me.”

Bilbo shook his head.

“I need to feel that again. And right now, I don't.”

Thorin lowered his gaze.

He wanted desperately to reach for him, to hold him, to press a kiss into his curls and promise that nothing would ever hurt him again.

But promises were what had brought them here.

So he remained where he was.

“I will wait,” he said. “However long you need.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“I still love you.”

Thorin's breath caught.

“That's what makes this so difficult.”

Before Thorin could answer, a horn sounded.

Deep.

Long.

The note rolled through Erebor like thunder.

Then another answered it.

And another.

Bilbo turned toward the window.

Outside, voices rose in alarm.

_______________

 

A moment later, Fíli threw open the door.

“Uncle!”

Thorin was already moving.

“What is it?”

“Orcs. They've entered the valley. Dáin is assembling his warriors, and Bard's men are taking their positions.”

Kíli appeared behind him.

“Legolas reports a second force approaching from the north.”

Thorin's blood turned cold.

He knew those armies.

He knew what waited beyond the gates.

And he remembered the snow upon Ravenhill, the cold of the blade beneath his ribs, and Bilbo's face above him as the world went dark.

Not again.

He turned to his nephews.

“Find Dwalin. Tell him I want the eastern approach secured. Neither of you is to go near Ravenhill without my express command.”

Fíli frowned.

“Uncle—”

“Promise me.”

Something in Thorin's expression silenced him.

“We promise,” Fíli said.

The brothers hurried away.

Thorin turned back toward Bilbo.

For a moment, the war outside seemed impossibly distant.

Bilbo stood beside the hearth, pale and frightened, his curls loose around his face.

Thorin wanted to kiss him.

More than anything, he wanted to kiss him.

But Bilbo had not invited him closer, and Thorin would not take even that small comfort without knowing it was welcome.

He touched the place beneath his armour where the silver bead rested against his heart.

“Stay safe, Bilbo,” he whispered. “Please.”

Bilbo's eyes shone.

“You too, Thorin.”

Neither moved.

Then another horn sounded, closer this time, and Thorin forced himself to turn away.

He walked out without touching him.

Bilbo stood listening to his footsteps fade along the corridor.

Only when they were gone did he lift a hand toward the empty place in his hair.

Beyond Erebor's gates, the valley had become a sea of movement.

Dáin's dwarves formed ranks beneath their iron banners. Bard's men gathered among the ruins of Dale, while Thranduil's elves took their positions with bows already strung. Across the distant slopes, dark shapes poured between the rocks.

Thorin stood upon the steps of his reclaimed kingdom, the cold wind tugging at his cloak.

He had died here once.

He had watched his nephews die here.

And now he had come perilously close to destroying the love for which he had crossed time itself.

His hand closed over the silver bead beneath his armour.

The Arkenstone lay locked away.

His nephews were alive.

Bilbo was alive.

And somewhere inside the mountain, the hobbit he loved was waiting for a future Thorin had nearly thrown away.

He looked toward the approaching armies.

This time, he would not let the gold decide what mattered.

Thorin Oakenshield drew his sword.

And the Battle of Five Armies began.

Chapter 23: Chapter Twenty-Three — The Price of Tomorrow

Chapter Text

The first arrows fell before the sun had cleared the mountains.

They came from the northern slopes in a dark, hissing cloud, striking shields, stone, and the abandoned roofs of Dale. A warning cry rose from the elven ranks, followed by the thunder of dwarven shields locking together. Somewhere beyond the ruins, a horn answered the call of the enemy, its ugly note rolling through the valley like the growl of something enormous awakening beneath the earth.

Thorin Oakenshield stood upon the lower steps of Erebor, watching the armies of the north advance.

He had seen this before.

Not precisely like this. The positions of the allied forces were different, the gates of Erebor stood open rather than barred against the world, and Dáin's warriors were already fighting beside the elves and men instead of preparing to turn their weapons against them. The changes Thorin had made over the past year had reshaped almost everything about this morning.

Yet the orcs were still coming.

And somewhere beyond the battlefield, Azog the Defiler was waiting.

“My king.”

Dwalin approached through the gathering smoke, his armour already marked by the first exchanges. He carried his axe across one shoulder, though his expression was unusually grave.

“The eastern line is holding. Dáin has placed his shield-bearers before the ruins, and the elves are covering the northern approach. Bard's archers have taken the upper walls of Dale.”

Thorin nodded, studying the valley.

“Have the men withdraw behind the second barricade if the orcs breach the lower street. The buildings will narrow their approach.”

“Aye.”

“And tell Dáin not to pursue if they retreat. Azog will want us separated.”

Dwalin regarded him.

“You sound certain.”

Thorin's fingers tightened around the hilt of Orcrist.

“I know our enemy.”

It was not quite a lie.

Dwalin looked as though he wanted to ask something more, but another volley of arrows struck the stone nearby, and the moment passed.

Thorin descended the steps.

Around him, the warriors of Erebor moved into formation beneath banners that had not flown over their ancestral home in generations. Dwarves who had spent their lives in exile now stood shoulder to shoulder with those who had come from the Iron Hills. Beyond them, the green and silver of the Woodland Realm mingled with the rougher colours of Dale.

Thorin remembered a battlefield divided by suspicion.

He remembered looking upon Thranduil and seeing an enemy, upon Bard and seeing a thief, upon Dáin and seeing an army he might command to defend his gold.

Today, Thranduil's archers were protecting Dáin's flanks, and Bard's men were carrying wounded dwarves to safety.

It should have been enough to reassure him.

But then he saw Fíli and Kíli moving toward the forward ranks, and the cold hand of memory closed around his throat.

“Fíli!”

Both nephews turned.

Fíli approached first, adjusting the strap of his shield.

“Yes, Uncle?”

“You will remain with Dáin's second company. Neither of you is to pursue an enemy beyond the eastern barricade.”

Kíli frowned.

“We know.”

“And if the northern flank breaks, you fall back toward the gates.”

“We know that too,” Kíli said.

Thorin looked at him sharply.

The younger dwarf's expression softened.

“Uncle,” he said, lowering his voice, “we heard you last night.”

Thorin's gaze flickered toward the faint bruise across his own jaw.

Kíli noticed.

For an awkward moment, neither spoke.

Then Kíli stepped closer and briefly squeezed Thorin's shoulder.

“I'm sorry I struck you.”

Thorin looked at his nephew's face, so alive and painfully young beneath the edge of his helmet.

“I know.”

“I was angry.”

“You had reason to be.”

“That doesn't mean I should have done it.”

“No,” Thorin agreed gently. “It doesn't.”

Kíli nodded, visibly relieved that they could speak of it without another argument.

Fíli glanced toward the battlefield, where the first orcs had reached the outer barricades.

“We should go.”

Thorin caught his eldest nephew by the forearm.

“Stay together.”

Fíli gave him a small smile.

“We intend to.”

Thorin released him.

He watched them run toward Dáin's ranks, Fíli's golden hair and Kíli's dark braids disappearing among the helmets.

For one terrible instant, he saw them lying motionless upon Ravenhill.

Then Kíli turned and shouted something outrageous at his brother, earning a shove in return, and the vision shattered.

They were alive.

Thorin would keep them that way.

______________

 

By midmorning, the valley had become a place of smoke, iron, and shouting.

The first wave of orcs struck Dáin's shield wall with enough force to drive the front ranks backward several paces. Steel scraped against steel, and the air filled with the harsh cries of dwarves struggling to hold their ground. Behind them, elven arrows passed overhead in disciplined volleys, cutting down enemies attempting to climb the ruined walls.

Fíli stood in the second rank when the first breach appeared.

Three orcs forced their way between two shields, one carrying a hooked spear that caught a dwarven warrior beneath the arm.

Fíli moved before the wounded dwarf had finished falling.

He drove his sword beneath the spear-bearer's guard, twisted free, and caught the next attack upon his shield. The impact jarred his shoulder, but he held firm until Kíli appeared beside him and buried a blade in the creature's side.

“Left!” Fíli shouted.

“I have eyes!”

“Then use them!”

Kíli ducked beneath a swinging axe.

“I was using them to admire your leadership!”

Fíli almost smiled.

Almost.

A fourth orc came over the barricade, and both brothers turned to meet it.

They had fought together since they were old enough to hold practice swords, first beneath their mother's watchful eye and later under Thorin's demanding instruction. Fíli knew the exact moment Kíli would shift his weight before striking. Kíli knew when his brother needed space to draw one of the knives concealed beneath his armour.

They moved together without thinking.

When the immediate danger passed, Kíli leaned against the barricade, breathing hard.

“Do you think Uncle Bilbo is all right?”

Fíli glanced toward the mountain.

“He's with Óin.”

“That wasn't what I asked.”

Fíli understood.

He remembered Bilbo curled between them the previous night, crying because he thought the family he loved might no longer want him.

“He'll be all right,” Fíli said.

Kíli wiped his blade.

“We promised them we'd come back.”

“Then we'd better keep that promise.”

A horn sounded from the eastern line.

Fíli straightened.

“Come on.”

They returned to the fighting.

_____________

 

Bilbo had never imagined that battle would smell so much like wet wool.

There was blood, certainly, and smoke from burning timbers, and the unpleasant sharpness of spilled lamp oil. But beneath it all lingered the scent of soaked cloaks, muddy boots, and the blankets Óin had ordered carried from Erebor's storerooms.

The healing station had been established within the remains of a large stone building behind the allied lines. Its roof was partly missing, but three walls remained standing, and the surviving chambers offered some protection from the arrows that occasionally passed over the ruins.

Bilbo had spent the morning carrying water, fetching bandages, and doing his best not to get in Óin's way.

“Not that one,” Óin barked when Bilbo reached for a bottle. “The brown jar.”

Bilbo exchanged the bottle for the correct jar.

“Sorry.”

“And stop apologizing. You're doing fine.”

Bilbo managed a tired smile.

An injured dwarf lay on the table before them, his shoulder wrapped in bloodstained linen. Bilbo held a fresh bandage while Óin worked, trying not to look at the wound itself.

Outside, another horn sounded.

Bilbo's hands tightened.

Óin noticed.

“They're still holding.”

“You can't possibly know that.”

“If they weren't, we'd have considerably more company.”

Bilbo gave a weak laugh.

Óin tied the bandage securely and motioned for the wounded warrior to be helped away.

“Go and get yourself something to drink, lad.”

“I've only just—”

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit sighed.

“Yes, Óin.”

He stepped into the courtyard, where several volunteers were distributing water among the wounded. Beyond the broken archway, he could see the distant movements of the battle.

He searched instinctively for dark armour and a familiar blue cloak.

There were too many dwarves.

Too much smoke.

He could not distinguish one figure from another.

He wondered whether Thorin had eaten anything that morning.

The thought was so ordinary that it hurt.

Only yesterday he would have found some excuse to bring him food, scolding him gently for neglecting himself. Thorin would have complained about being fussed over, though he would eventually have eaten whatever Bilbo put before him.

Bilbo rubbed his eyes.

He still loved him.

That had not changed.

But the memory of the treasure hall remained, and whenever he imagined returning to Thorin's arms, he heard the words that had driven him away.

Perhaps I was a fool to give you a place in my family.

Bilbo lowered his hand.

No.

Fíli and Kíli had made one thing very clear.

Whatever happened between him and Thorin, he had not lost them.

He touched his loose curls, remembering Kíli's arms around him and Fíli's quiet promise.

Then he picked up another bucket and returned to work.

______________

 

From Ravenhill, Azog watched the battle unfold with growing displeasure.

The pale orc stood upon a high platform of weathered stone, surrounded by his most trusted hunters. Below him, the valley spread out in a confusion of ruined streets and moving armies.

His first assault had failed to break the dwarven line.

His second had driven the men from an outer barricade, only for elven archers to turn the narrow approach into a killing ground.

And Oakenshield had not come.

Azog had expected him.

The dwarf king had pursued vengeance for decades. He had crossed mountains and kingdoms with hatred burning in his heart, and Azog knew well enough how to use that hatred.

Ravenhill was the perfect place to finish what had begun outside Moria.

He had left his strongest guards among its broken towers, prepared narrow approaches where dwarves could be separated and surrounded, and positioned his hunters along the paths leading upward.

But Thorin Oakenshield remained below.

Worse, he was commanding the allied forces with an infuriating patience.

Azog watched him direct reinforcements toward the eastern line, then pull his warriors back before an apparent retreat could lure them into the open.

The dwarf was refusing every invitation.

Azog bared his teeth.

Beside him, a lieutenant shifted uneasily.

“The dwarves will not break.”

“They will.”

“Their king will not leave the field.”

Azog turned his pale gaze upon him.

“Then we will give him a reason.”

He looked back toward the valley.

Oakenshield was standing beside a broken wall, speaking with another dwarf. His sword hung at his side, and his attention appeared fixed upon the fighting.

Then, for the briefest moment, the king turned his head.

Not toward Ravenhill.

Toward the rear of the allied lines.

Azog followed his gaze.

Near the ruined buildings beneath Erebor, small figures moved among the wounded. He saw dwarves carrying stretchers, men fetching water, and one unusually small creature with darkened golden-brown curls helping an injured warrior across a courtyard.

Azog might have dismissed the creature entirely.

But Oakenshield was still watching.

And when the little figure disappeared safely through an archway, the dwarf king's shoulders eased.

Azog narrowed his eyes.

A few minutes later, a small group of orcs pushed toward that same section of the ruins.

Oakenshield reacted immediately.

He signalled for reinforcements, sending a dozen warriors to strengthen the approach before the attackers had come within striking distance of the healing station.

Azog watched.

Then he began to smile.

“The little one,” he said.

His lieutenant followed his gaze.

“A halfling?”

Azog had heard reports of such a creature travelling with the dwarves. He had dismissed them as unimportant. Oakenshield's company had always been a collection of peculiar fools.

Now he wondered.

“Bring him to me.”

The lieutenant hesitated.

“The halfling?”

“Alive.”

Azog turned fully toward him.

“And make certain Oakenshield knows who has taken him.”

The orc bowed and hurried away.

Azog looked down at the battlefield again.

He had spent years trying to destroy the line of Durin.

Perhaps he had been looking at the wrong weakness.

_______________

 

The fighting worsened after midday.

A fresh wave of orcs emerged from the northern slopes, driving toward the space between Bard's men and the elven archers. Thranduil answered with a charge that carried his warriors through the ruined streets, their blades flashing beneath the grey sky.

Thorin saw the movement from his position near the eastern barricade.

“Dwalin!”

His friend turned.

“Take twenty warriors to the northern crossing. Bard must not be cut off.”

“Aye.”

“And send word to Dáin that the enemy is trying to draw us apart.”

Dwalin studied him briefly.

“Still worried about Ravenhill?”

Thorin looked toward the distant height.

“Yes.”

He could almost see the place where Fíli had fallen.

The memory came without warning: Kíli's cry, the terrible emptiness that followed, and the certainty that he had failed them both.

He forced himself to look away.

“Azog is waiting for us to make a mistake.”

Dwalin nodded and hurried off.

Thorin remained beside the barricade, directing the movement of his warriors while the battle shifted around him.

At intervals, he found himself looking toward the healing station.

He told himself it was because the wounded needed protection.

That was true.

But he was also searching for a small figure moving between the ruined walls.

Once, he saw Bilbo crossing the courtyard with a bundle of clean cloth beneath one arm.

Even at that distance, Thorin recognized the determined way he walked.

He felt a painful rush of relief.

Bilbo was alive.

He watched until the hobbit disappeared inside.

Then he returned his attention to the battle.

He did not know that, high above the valley, someone had watched him do it.

_____________

 

The first warning came when an injured man arrived at the healing station without the two guards who had been escorting him.

Bilbo was helping Óin prepare another bed when the man stumbled through the archway, his face grey with shock.

“Orcs,” he gasped. “Behind the western wall.”

Óin looked up sharply.

“How many?”

“I don't know. They came through the lower passage.”

Bilbo set down the blankets.

The western passage connected the ruined streets to the narrow courtyard behind the healing station. It had been guarded throughout the morning, though the fighting had gradually drawn warriors toward the main barricades.

Óin swore.

“Get everyone who can walk inside the mountain. Now.”

The courtyard erupted into movement.

Bilbo helped an elderly dwarf rise from his chair, guiding him toward the eastern exit while other volunteers gathered the wounded.

A cry sounded beyond the western wall.

Then steel rang against stone.

Bilbo looked back.

Three guards were fighting beneath the broken archway.

Behind them, dark figures were climbing through the ruins.

Orcs.

“Bilbo!” Óin shouted. “Move!”

Bilbo hurried the elderly dwarf toward the eastern passage.

They had almost reached it when an arrow struck the wall beside them.

The old dwarf stumbled.

Bilbo caught him beneath the arm.

“Come along,” he urged. “Just a little farther.”

A volunteer rushed forward to help.

Together they brought the dwarf through the passage, where two armed warriors were waiting to escort the wounded toward Erebor.

Bilbo could have gone with them.

He knew that.

He could have run into the mountain and waited until the danger passed.

Instead, he heard someone crying behind him.

A young dwarven soldier lay beside an overturned stretcher, one leg trapped beneath a fallen beam. He was barely older than Fíli, with blood running down the side of his face.

The other volunteers were already retreating.

Bilbo looked toward the safety of the passage.

Then back at the soldier.

“Oh, bother,” he whispered.

He ran toward him.

“Can you move?”

The dwarf shook his head.

Bilbo knelt beside the beam and pushed.

It did not budge.

He tried again, planting his feet against the stones.

The wood shifted slightly.

The soldier cried out.

“I'm sorry,” Bilbo gasped. “I'm terribly sorry, but we must get you out.”

A crash sounded behind them.

The western archway had fallen.

Bilbo glanced over his shoulder.

An orc stepped through the dust.

Then another.

Bilbo's heart hammered.

His hand went instinctively toward the pocket where the Ring lay hidden.

For one desperate moment, he imagined slipping it onto his finger and vanishing.

He could escape.

But the wounded dwarf could not.

Bilbo withdrew his empty hand.

“Listen to me,” he told the soldier. “When I lift this, you must pull your leg free.”

“I can't—”

“Yes, you can.”

He braced himself against the beam.

“One. Two. Three!”

With a strength born entirely of desperation, Bilbo heaved.

The beam rose just enough.

The dwarf dragged his leg free.

“Go!” Bilbo cried.

The soldier scrambled toward the eastern passage.

Bilbo turned to follow.

A heavy hand seized him by the back of his coat.

He was lifted bodily from the ground.

Sting flashed into his hand.

He slashed backward, and the orc holding him roared as the blade cut across its arm.

Bilbo dropped hard onto the stones.

He scrambled to his feet.

Another orc blocked the passage.

Bilbo raised Sting.

“Get away from me!”

The creature lunged.

Bilbo ducked beneath its arm, but a second attacker struck him across the shoulder with the haft of a weapon.

Pain exploded through his side.

He fell.

Before he could rise, rough fingers closed around his wrists.

He kicked, twisted, and bit the hand nearest his face.

The orc cursed.

“Hold still, little rat!”

Bilbo fought harder.

He had survived trolls, goblins, spiders, and a dragon. He was not about to surrender quietly to a handful of ugly brutes.

Then a third orc approached, taller than the others, with a jagged scar crossing one eye.

It looked down at Bilbo.

“That's the one.”

Bilbo went cold.

The orc seized his chin, forcing his face upward.

“The dwarf king's little pet.”

Bilbo spat at him.

The creature struck him across the face.

His head snapped sideways, and for a moment the world blurred.

“Careful,” another orc warned. “Azog wants him alive.”

Bilbo stopped struggling for half a heartbeat.

Azog.

He knew that name.

He knew what the pale orc had done to Thorin's family, how many years of grief and hatred lay between them.

And suddenly he understood.

They had not stumbled upon the healing station by chance.

They had come for him.

Bilbo's stomach twisted.

“No,” he whispered.

The scarred orc laughed.

“Oh, yes.”

It hauled him upright and bound his wrists with coarse rope.

Bilbo twisted toward the eastern passage.

The wounded soldier had escaped.

At least there was that.

Then the orcs dragged him through the ruined archway and into the smoke.

_____________

 

Thorin first realized something was wrong when the reinforcements he had sent toward the healing station failed to return.

A moment later, a dwarven runner stumbled through the eastern ranks.

“My king!”

Thorin caught him by the shoulders.

“What happened?”

“Orcs breached the western passage. The wounded are being evacuated, but—”

The dwarf hesitated.

Thorin felt the blood drain from his face.

“But what?”

“The halfling, my lord. Master Baggins. He stayed behind to help one of the injured.”

Thorin released him.

“Where is he?”

“We don't know.”

The sounds of battle seemed to recede.

For one terrible instant, Thorin was back in Lake-town, searching through smoke and burning timbers while Bilbo remained nowhere to be found.

Then he heard another voice.

“Thorin!”

Dwalin was running toward him.

Behind his friend, a group of dwarves had gathered near the ruined wall, their weapons raised toward the western streets.

Dwalin's expression told Thorin everything before he spoke.

“There's something you need to see.”

Thorin followed him through the broken barricade.

Beyond the ruins, a narrow road climbed toward the northern slopes.

Several orcs stood upon it.

Between them struggled a small figure in a torn green coat.

Bilbo.

Thorin stopped breathing.

His hands were bound. Blood marked one cheek, and his coat hung crookedly from his shoulders, but he was standing.

Alive.

Then one of the orcs seized Bilbo by the hair and forced his head back.

Thorin surged forward.

Dwalin caught his arm.

“Wait!”

“Let go!”

“Thorin, look!”

The scarred orc raised a curved blade beside Bilbo's throat.

Across the distance, its voice rang out.

“Oakenshield!”

Thorin went utterly still.

The creature grinned.

“The pale one belongs to Azog now!”

Bilbo struggled violently.

“Thorin, don't!”

The orc jerked him backward.

“Quiet!”

Bilbo ignored it.

“It's a trap!”

Thorin's heart twisted at the sound of his voice.

He could see how frightened Bilbo was, though the hobbit was doing his best to conceal it. His curls had fallen across his face, and one sleeve was dark with blood.

Yet he was still trying to protect Thorin.

Even now.

Even after everything.

Dwalin tightened his grip.

“They want you to follow.”

Thorin knew.

He knew with a certainty that made him sick.

Azog had waited upon Ravenhill for the proud king who would come seeking vengeance.

When that king refused, Azog had found another way to draw him out.

Thorin looked toward the distant height.

Somewhere among those broken towers, the pale orc was watching.

Waiting.

He remembered another life in which he had gone to Ravenhill and never returned.

He remembered Fíli dying alone.

Kíli falling.

Bilbo kneeling beside him in the snow.

And now Azog had Bilbo.

Thorin felt the familiar darkness stir at the edges of his thoughts, urging him toward rage, toward reckless violence, toward the terrible certainty that he must destroy anything threatening what belonged to him.

His fingers closed around Orcrist.

Then, beneath his armour, he felt the small silver bead pressing against his chest.

I still love you. That's what makes this so difficult.

Thorin shut his eyes for one brief moment.

When he opened them, Dwalin was watching him.

“Thorin?”

The orcs were already dragging Bilbo farther up the road.

Every instinct in Thorin's body screamed at him to pursue.

But he remembered the promise he had made to himself before the gates of Erebor.

He would not lose his family to Azog again.

Not Fíli.

Not Kíli.

Not Bilbo.

And he would not save one by carelessly sacrificing the others.

“Find Legolas,” Thorin said, his voice rough but steady. “Tell him I need eyes upon every path leading north.”

Dwalin nodded.

“And Fíli and Kíli?”

Thorin looked toward the battlefield.

“Bring them to me. Quietly. I will not have them riding blindly into this.”

Dwalin gripped his shoulder once before turning away.

Thorin remained beside the ruined wall.

High above him, Ravenhill stood against the darkening sky.

And somewhere upon its slopes, Bilbo was being carried toward the creature who had murdered Thorin's grandfather and sworn to extinguish the line of Durin.

Thorin pressed his hand against the silver bead beneath his armour.

He had crossed time itself to save the people he loved.

Now the enemy who had taken everything from him once was trying to do it again.

But this time, Thorin Oakenshield knew the cost of answering hatred with hatred.

He watched the orcs disappear among the rocks.

Then he turned back toward his army.

He would go after Bilbo.

He would bring him home.

But he would not give Azog the broken, reckless king he was expecting.

Chapter 24: Chapter Twenty-Four — What We Choose to Save

Chapter Text

The path to Ravenhill was narrow, steep, and treacherous beneath the boots of those who had come to reclaim it.

Thorin knew every turn.

He remembered the broken watchtower overlooking the valley, the narrow ledge where snow had gathered around his boots, and the dark waters beneath the ice. He remembered the terrible sound of Fíli's body striking the stone far below Azog's position. He remembered Kíli's death, though he had not witnessed it himself, and the unbearable knowledge that he had led both his sister's sons into a place from which none of them would return.

In another life, he had climbed this mountain because he wanted Azog dead.

Now he climbed it because Bilbo was alive somewhere above him.

That difference should have comforted him. Instead, it made every step feel like a struggle against the past.

“There's a second path through the eastern rocks,” Legolas said, crouching beside a weathered outcrop. His pale hair had been drawn back from his face, and a thin cut marked his temple. “It is difficult to see from below, but it reaches the old watchtower without crossing the main approach.”

Dwalin studied the slope. “How many guards?”

“Eight along the lower path. Perhaps twice that number near the tower. More concealed among the ruins.”

Kíli muttered something unpleasant beneath his breath.

Fíli stood beside him, checking the fastening of his brother's shoulder armour. The gesture was so familiar that Thorin's chest tightened. He had watched Fíli do the same thing a hundred times throughout their lives, usually while Kíli complained that he was perfectly capable of dressing himself.

Today, Kíli said nothing.

“Azog wants us to climb the main path,” Thorin said. “He'll have prepared it for an attack.”

“Then we don't give him one,” Dwalin replied.

Thorin looked toward the ruined watchtower.

The urge to run was almost unbearable. Every moment they spent planning was another moment Bilbo remained in Azog's hands. Thorin could imagine the hobbit frightened and injured, perhaps calling for him, perhaps wondering whether anyone would come.

But he remembered Bilbo shouting across the battlefield.

It's a trap.

Even then, Bilbo had been trying to protect him.

Thorin would not repay that courage with recklessness.

“Legolas, take your archers along the eastern path. Find a position overlooking the courtyard, but do not reveal yourselves unless Bilbo is in immediate danger. Dwalin, take the lower passage with six warriors. Keep the retreat open.”

“And us?” Fíli asked.

Thorin turned toward his nephews.

“You will remain with Dwalin until the guards are occupied. Then approach from the eastern side.”

Kíli frowned. “And you?”

“I will go where Azog expects me.”

“Alone?”

“Not without you watching my back.”

Fíli's expression remained troubled.

Thorin placed a hand upon his shoulder.

“I know what you are thinking.”

“Do you?”

Thorin hesitated.

No. Fíli could not possibly know what his uncle remembered.

But he knew enough.

“I am not going there to die,” Thorin said quietly.

Kíli stepped closer.

“We're bringing Uncle Bilbo home.”

Thorin looked at him.

“All three of us,” Kíli added.

Thorin's hand moved to the small silver bead beneath his armour.

“All four of us,” he corrected.

For a moment, Kíli's eyes shone.

Then he nodded.

____________

 

Bilbo had never been so cold.

The wind swept through the broken stones of Ravenhill, finding every tear in his coat and every gap between the ropes binding his wrists. His shoulder ached where an orc had struck him, and dried blood pulled unpleasantly at the skin along his cheek.

He had been forced to kneel beside a ruined pillar, with two guards standing behind him.

Beyond the courtyard, the Battle of Five Armies continued.

From this height, the valley looked terribly small. The armies moved like dark currents through the ruined streets, their banners scarcely visible beneath the smoke. Bilbo could hear horns and distant shouting, but individual voices were lost to the wind.

He wondered where Fíli and Kíli were.

He wondered whether Óin had escaped.

And, despite everything that had happened between them, he wondered whether Thorin was safe.

A heavy footstep sounded behind him.

Bilbo turned.

Azog the Defiler approached through the ruins.

He was enormous, even compared with the other orcs, his pale skin crossed by old scars and his metal prosthetic ending in a wicked blade. His expression held none of the mindless fury Bilbo had seen in lesser creatures. There was calculation in his eyes.

Bilbo found that far more frightening.

Azog stopped before him.

“So,” he said in a rough voice, “this is what Oakenshield keeps beside him.”

Bilbo lifted his chin.

Azog studied him.

“A halfling. I thought my hunters had mistaken a child for one of his companions.”

Bilbo said nothing.

Azog crouched, bringing his terrible face nearer.

“Does the dwarf king send you to carry his messages? Polish his treasures?”

Bilbo looked away.

A low laugh escaped the orc.

“I have hunted Oakenshield since before you were born, little creature. I have watched his people crawl through exile, clinging to a crown that belonged to a dead kingdom.”

Bilbo's jaw tightened.

Azog noticed.

“I took the head of his grandfather,” he continued. “Thrór, who thought himself mighty beneath the mountain. His blood ran across the stones of Moria.”

Bilbo had heard that story.

He remembered Thorin speaking of his grandfather only rarely, his voice growing distant whenever the subject arose.

“You must be very proud,” Bilbo said bitterly, “to boast about murdering someone's family.”

Azog's eyes narrowed.

Then he smiled.

“Ah. You know the story.”

Bilbo regretted speaking.

Azog rose and began circling him.

“His father vanished. His grandfather died beneath my blade. Yet Oakenshield still believes he can protect what remains of his miserable bloodline.”

Bilbo's thoughts flew immediately to Fíli and Kíli.

Azog watched his expression change.

“Two young dwarves,” he observed. “Golden-haired and dark-haired. They fight beneath his banner.”

Bilbo pulled against his bindings.

“Leave them alone.”

Another smile.

“So they matter too.”

Bilbo forced himself to be silent.

Azog paced toward the edge of the courtyard, looking down at the distant battle.

“I had intended to kill Oakenshield here,” he said conversationally. “I thought it would please me to watch him come crawling up this mountain, desperate to settle an old debt.”

Bilbo's stomach tightened.

“He was always eager to fight me. Proud. Angry. So easily led by his hatred.”

Azog turned.

“But today he would not come.”

Bilbo stared at the ground.

“So I wondered what had changed.”

The orc approached again.

“I watched him from above. I saw him look toward the wounded, again and again. I saw him send warriors whenever danger came near a particular building.”

Bilbo's breath caught.

Azog saw it.

“There,” he murmured.

Bilbo looked up sharply.

Azog leaned closer.

“What is a king doing, watching a little halfling when his enemies stand before him?”

“Perhaps,” Bilbo said, struggling to keep his voice steady, “he simply doesn't like seeing innocent people killed.”

Azog laughed.

“Perhaps.”

He straightened.

“Then I shall kill him first.”

Bilbo went white.

Azog watched with sudden, terrible interest.

“I shall drive my blade through his chest and leave him upon the stones. Perhaps I shall let his nephews watch.”

“Don't you dare!”

The words escaped before Bilbo could stop them.

Azog became very still.

Bilbo felt the blood drain from his face.

The orc slowly lowered himself until they were eye to eye.

“You did not flinch when I threatened you.”

Bilbo said nothing.

“But speak of Oakenshield's death, and you forget your courage.”

Azog reached out and caught Bilbo's chin.

Bilbo tried to pull away.

“Interesting.”

He released him and stood.

Bilbo stared after him, his heart hammering.

He had told Azog nothing.

Yet somehow, he had told him far too much.

_____________

 

Thorin emerged into the courtyard beneath a sky heavy with smoke.

Azog was waiting.

The pale orc stood beside a broken pillar, his enormous weapon resting against his shoulder. Around him, guards occupied the surrounding ruins.

And at his feet knelt Bilbo.

Thorin's heart seemed to stop.

Bilbo's hands were bound. His coat was torn, and there was blood upon his face. One side of his body was held stiffly, as though moving caused him pain.

But he was alive.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked up.

Relief flashed across his face, followed almost immediately by terror.

“Thorin, you shouldn't have come.”

Thorin took one step forward.

Azog seized Bilbo by the collar and hauled him upright, dragging him against his chest. The curved edge of his weapon came to rest beneath Bilbo's jaw.

Thorin stopped.

“Release him.”

Azog smiled.

“Oakenshield.”

His voice carried the satisfaction of a hunter whose trap had finally closed.

“I wondered whether you would come.”

Thorin's hand tightened around Orcrist.

“You have me. Let him go.”

Azog looked down at Bilbo.

“So eager.”

He pressed the blade closer.

Bilbo winced.

Thorin's sword lowered an inch.

Azog noticed.

His smile widened.

“I thought this little creature was a servant. Perhaps a favourite pet.”

“Don't touch him.”

Azog loosened his grip slightly.

Thorin breathed.

Then the orc tightened it again.

Thorin's entire body went rigid.

Azog laughed softly.

“There it is.”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

He understood now what Azog had been looking for.

“You could not save your grandfather,” Azog told Thorin. “You could not save your father. Shall I show you how easily I can take this one too?”

Thorin felt the old hatred rise.

He remembered Azog standing over Thrór's body. He remembered the years of exile, the grief upon his father's face, the endless burden of carrying a broken kingdom's hopes.

He remembered Ravenhill.

The snow.

His own blood.

And Bilbo weeping over him.

For a moment, his vision narrowed until there was nothing in the world but Azog's pale face.

Then Bilbo made a small, frightened sound.

Thorin looked at him.

The anger did not vanish.

But it ceased to command him.

“Whatever you want from me,” Thorin said, “you will not have it by hurting him.”

Azog tilted his head.

“Then throw down your sword.”

Thorin hesitated.

“Thorin, no,” Bilbo whispered.

The blade moved against his throat.

Thorin dropped Orcrist.

It struck the stones with a ringing sound.

Azog's smile became almost delighted.

“The King under the Mountain,” he murmured, “brought low by a halfling.”

Thorin did not answer.

“On your knees.”

Bilbo struggled.

“No!”

Thorin slowly lowered himself.

His eyes never left Bilbo's face.

The hobbit felt something inside him twist painfully.

Only yesterday, Thorin had looked at the Arkenstone when Bilbo asked whether he still loved him.

Now Thorin was kneeling before his greatest enemy, surrendering his sword because Bilbo's life mattered more than his pride.

Bilbo had wanted proof that the dwarf he loved still existed beneath the sickness.

He had never wanted it like this.

Azog raised his weapon.

And Bilbo saw the change in his grip.

The blade at Bilbo's throat shifted away.

Not because Azog intended to release him.

Because he was preparing to strike Thorin.

Bilbo's heart lurched.

“No!”

Thorin looked up.

Azog smiled.

And Bilbo understood that neither of them was meant to leave Ravenhill alive.

The Ring lay against Bilbo's palm inside his pocket.

He had carried it for so long that its weight had become familiar. Through mountains and forests, beneath the eyes of elves and dwarves, through the burning streets of Lake-town, he had guarded its secret.

He remembered Gollum's terrible hunger for it.

He remembered the strange coldness that sometimes accompanied its touch.

And he remembered how frightened he had been to tell Thorin.

After the Arkenstone, that fear had only grown.

What would Thorin think if he learned Bilbo had concealed another treasure? Something far stranger, and perhaps far more dangerous?

For one terrible moment, Bilbo imagined Thorin looking at the Ring with the same possessive hunger he had shown the Arkenstone.

Then Azog raised his blade toward Thorin's unprotected chest.

And suddenly, none of those fears mattered.

Not the secret.

Not the Ring.

Not even what Thorin might think of him afterward.

Bilbo would not stand helplessly and watch him die.

He closed his fingers around the golden band.

Then he slipped it onto his finger.

_____________

 

The world changed.

Azog's grip closed upon empty air.

The orc staggered, snarling in astonishment as the small prisoner vanished from beneath his arm.

Thorin's eyes widened.

“Bilbo?”

There was no answer.

Azog whirled.

“What sorcery—”

A sharp pain struck behind his knee.

Sting flashed briefly through the air, held by a hand no one could see.

Azog roared and stumbled.

“NOW!” shouted a voice from above.

An arrow struck the throat of the nearest guard.

Then another.

Legolas stood upon the broken eastern wall, his bow already drawn again.

Dwalin's battle cry echoed from the lower passage as dwarven warriors surged into the courtyard.

Thorin moved.

He snatched Orcrist from the stones and rolled aside as Azog's weapon crashed down where his head had been.

“Bilbo!” he shouted.

“I'm here!”

The voice came from somewhere to his left.

Thorin could not see him.

For one dreadful instant, he remembered Lake-town and the impossible disappearance that had nearly driven him mad with fear.

But Bilbo was speaking.

He was alive.

And there would be time for questions later.

“Get clear!” Thorin called.

Azog lunged.

Steel met steel.

The fight that followed was nothing like the one Thorin remembered.

In his first life, he had faced Azog upon the ice, isolated from his companions, his body exhausted and his heart poisoned by vengeance.

Now Dwalin held the lower passage, Legolas's arrows kept the surrounding guards from closing in, and his nephews were fighting their way toward him.

But Azog remained a terrifying opponent.

The pale orc was larger, stronger, and armed with a weapon capable of breaking bone through armour. Every blow drove Thorin backward, his injured shoulder burning beneath the strain.

“You should have stayed beneath your mountain!” Azog roared.

Thorin caught the next strike upon Orcrist.

“And leave you to murder my people?”

Azog drove him against a pillar.

“I will tear your bloodline from the earth!”

Thorin twisted free.

“Not today.”

Across the courtyard, Fíli and Kíli had reached the eastern wall.

“Bilbo!” Kíli shouted.

A small figure suddenly appeared beside a broken stair, stumbling as he pulled a golden ring from his finger.

“Here!”

Kíli ran toward him.

Bilbo had barely managed to steady himself before his nephew caught him by the shoulders.

“Are you hurt?”

“A little.”

“How much is a little?”

“Kíli, your uncle—”

A scream interrupted them.

Fíli had turned to intercept one of Azog's guards, only for a second orc to emerge from behind the ruined wall.

Its spear struck his shield and drove him backward toward the edge of the courtyard.

Thorin saw it.

For one horrible instant, time ceased to move.

Fíli.

The broken tower.

Azog's blade.

His nephew's body falling through empty air.

“No!”

Thorin tried to turn.

Azog struck him across the ribs, sending him stumbling.

Fíli's heel slipped over the edge.

Kíli moved before anyone else.

He caught his brother by the back of his armour and dragged him sideways as the orc's spear plunged into the stone where Fíli had stood.

Both brothers fell hard.

The guard raised its weapon again.

An arrow struck its chest.

Legolas was already reaching for another.

Kíli hauled Fíli upright.

“Are you trying to kill me?” he shouted.

Fíli stared at him, breathless.

“I was rather occupied!”

“Then be occupied somewhere farther from the edge!”

Thorin heard their voices.

Alive.

Both alive.

The relief was so overwhelming that it nearly brought him to his knees.

Azog saw the distraction.

He drove forward, forcing Thorin against the ruined pillar.

“You cannot save them all, Oakenshield.”

Thorin's back struck stone.

Azog raised his weapon.

For one dreadful instant, Thorin saw the end of his first life waiting before him.

Then Bilbo shouted.

“Thorin!”

A small stone struck Azog across the face.

It did no real damage.

But it made him turn.

Bilbo stood several paces away, Sting trembling in his hand.

Azog snarled.

“You.”

He lunged toward the hobbit.

Thorin moved without thinking.

Not from rage.

Not from pride.

From the simple, terrible certainty that he would not let Azog reach him.

He drove Orcrist beneath the orc's raised arm.

Azog roared, staggering backward.

Dwalin surged forward to prevent the remaining guards from intervening.

“Finish it, Thorin!”

Azog swung wildly.

Thorin ducked beneath the blade, feeling it tear through the edge of his cloak.

Then he struck again.

Orcrist drove deep into Azog's chest.

The pale orc staggered.

For a moment, his terrible eyes remained fixed upon Thorin's face, filled with disbelief and hatred.

Thorin held his gaze.

“You will take no more of my family.”

He withdrew the sword.

Azog fell.

The sound of his body striking the stones seemed impossibly loud.

____________

 

Then the courtyard fell still.

Thorin stood over the creature who had haunted his life, his breathing ragged, blood running down one arm.

Azog the Defiler was dead.

For years, Thorin had imagined this moment.

He had thought it would bring satisfaction, perhaps even peace.

Instead, he felt only an urgent need to turn around.

“Bilbo?”

Bilbo sat against a broken wall, one hand pressed to his injured shoulder.

He had removed the Ring.

It lay in his palm, catching the weak afternoon light.

Thorin crossed the courtyard so quickly that Dwalin called after him, but he scarcely heard.

He dropped to his knees before Bilbo.

“Are you hurt?”

Bilbo looked up.

There was blood on Thorin's armour.

A great deal of it.

“Oh, Thorin.”

“Bilbo, please.”

“I'm all right.”

“You're bleeding.”

“So are you.”

Thorin's hands hovered helplessly near him, uncertain where he could touch without causing pain.

Bilbo noticed.

Then Thorin's gaze briefly fell upon the golden Ring.

Bilbo's fingers closed instinctively.

His face changed.

Thorin saw the fear.

And understood.

The sight hurt more than his injuries.

He looked away from the Ring immediately.

“I don't want it, Bilbo.”

Bilbo stared at him.

“Whatever it is,” Thorin continued quietly, “whatever you have been carrying, it belongs to you to explain when you are ready.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

Thorin swallowed.

“I only want to know whether you're hurt.”

For several moments, Bilbo could not speak.

Then he nodded shakily.

“My shoulder. And my side, I think.”

Thorin looked toward the lower passage.

“Óin will see to you.”

“Yes.”

Neither moved.

The wind stirred Bilbo's loose curls.

Thorin's hand lifted slightly, then stopped.

“May I hold you?”

Bilbo's expression crumpled.

He hesitated only a moment.

Then he whispered, “Please.”

Thorin gathered him into his arms.

Carefully at first, mindful of the injured shoulder and the bruises beneath his coat.

But Bilbo reached for him with both arms, clinging so fiercely that Thorin's breath caught.

He buried his face against Thorin's neck.

And began to cry.

Thorin closed his eyes.

He held Bilbo against his chest, one hand spread protectively across his back, the other cradling the curls at the nape of his neck.

For a long time, neither spoke.

The battle continued somewhere below them, distant horns echoing through the valley, but for a few precious moments Thorin could hear only Bilbo's uneven breathing.

“I was so frightened,” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin pressed his cheek against his hair.

“I know.”

“No.” Bilbo's voice broke. “When he said he was going to kill you, I thought—I thought I was going to have to watch it happen.”

Thorin's arms tightened.

“I thought I had lost you when they took you.”

Bilbo shook against him.

“I couldn't let him hurt you.”

“Nor I you.”

Bilbo drew back just enough to look at him.

His cheeks were wet, his eyes red, and there was a bruise forming along his jaw.

Thorin had never seen anything more precious.

“I love you,” he whispered.

Bilbo's mouth trembled.

“I love you too.”

Thorin brushed a tear from his cheek.

Then Bilbo leaned forward and held him again.

They remained like that until Bilbo's breathing steadied.

Eventually, Thorin spoke against his curls.

“I know this does not change what happened between us.”

Bilbo went quiet.

“No,” he whispered. “It doesn't.”

Thorin nodded.

“I understand.”

Bilbo drew back slightly.

“But I'm glad you're alive.”

Thorin's throat tightened.

“So am I, my love.”

He rested his forehead briefly against Bilbo's, careful not to ask for more than the hobbit was ready to give.

Bilbo did not pull away.

_____________

 

“UNCLE BILBO!”

Kíli's voice rang across the courtyard.

Bilbo barely had time to turn before the young dwarf reached him.

Kíli dropped to his knees and threw his arms around him, almost knocking him sideways.

“Ow!”

Kíli released him immediately.

“Sorry! Sorry, where are you hurt?”

Bilbo laughed through his tears.

“Everywhere, apparently.”

“That isn't funny!”

“It was a little funny,” Fíli said, arriving behind his brother.

His own face was pale beneath the dust, and one sleeve hung torn from his shoulder.

Bilbo's smile faltered.

“Fíli, you're hurt.”

“Hardly.”

“You nearly fell off a mountain!”

Kíli pointed at him.

“That's what I said!”

Fíli sighed.

“Must we discuss this now?”

“Yes,” Bilbo and Kíli answered together.

For a moment, all three stared at one another.

Then Bilbo laughed.

A real laugh, though it ended with a wince.

Fíli knelt beside him.

He checked Bilbo's face, his shoulder, and the bandage Kíli had hastily wrapped around his arm.

Then, apparently satisfied that Bilbo was not about to collapse, he drew him into a careful embrace.

Bilbo clung to him.

“You came back,” he whispered.

Fíli closed his eyes.

“We promised.”

Kíli leaned against them both.

“And we're not finished annoying you.”

Bilbo reached for him with his free arm.

“Oh, my dear boys.”

Thorin watched them.

He remembered the previous night, when Bilbo had cried because he feared he was no longer their uncle.

Now Fíli and Kíli held him between them without hesitation, their relief plain upon their faces.

Thorin felt a deep, painful gratitude.

His nephews had loved Bilbo when Thorin had made him doubt that love.

They had protected him when Thorin had failed.

And they had brought him back.

Heavy footsteps approached.

Dwalin stopped beside Thorin, looking him over with a critical expression.

“You look terrible.”

Thorin managed a weary smile.

“You are hardly an improvement.”

Dwalin snorted.

Then his expression grew serious.

He gripped Thorin's shoulder.

“You frightened us, brother.”

Thorin met his eyes.

He knew Dwalin meant more than the battle.

“I know.”

Dwalin held his gaze for a moment longer.

Then he nodded.

“We'll speak of it later.”

A lighter tread sounded behind them.

Legolas approached, his bow slung across his back.

He looked first at Thorin, then at Bilbo, who was still being fussed over by both nephews.

“I see the rescue was successful,” he observed.

Bilbo looked up.

“Thanks in no small part to you.”

Legolas knelt beside him.

His expression softened as he examined the bruises upon Bilbo's face.

“I believe I promised to show you the gardens of the Woodland Realm one day.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“You did.”

“Then I would appreciate it if you refrained from getting yourself killed before I have the opportunity.”

Kíli made an indignant noise.

“That's what I've been telling him!”

Legolas glanced at him.

“Then perhaps he will listen if several of us agree.”

Bilbo sighed.

“I am surrounded by dreadful people.”

“People who are rather fond of you,” Fíli corrected.

Bilbo looked at him.

Then at Kíli.

At Legolas, whose quiet smile held genuine affection.

At Dwalin, standing beside Thorin like the steadfast friend he had always been.

And finally at Thorin himself.

The dwarf king was watching him with an expression so full of tenderness and regret that Bilbo's heart ached.

There were still things between them that needed mending.

Words that could not be forgotten simply because they had survived a battle.

Trust that would have to be rebuilt slowly, with patience and honesty.

But Thorin was alive.

Fíli and Kíli were alive.

And Bilbo was no longer afraid that he had lost his family.

Beyond the ruined walls, horns sounded from the valley.

The battle was not yet over. Orcs still fought beneath Bolg's command, and the allied armies were struggling to hold their positions. There would be more danger before the day was done.

But upon Ravenhill, for one brief moment, the surviving members of Thorin's little company were together.

Thorin sat beside Bilbo, allowing the hobbit to decide how close he wished to remain.

Bilbo leaned against him.

Fíli settled on his other side, while Kíli remained close enough to keep one hand resting upon Bilbo's knee.

Dwalin stood watch near the passage, and Legolas listened to the distant sounds of battle, ready to carry news to the allied commanders.

Thorin looked at them all.

Once, he had died upon this mountain believing that love had come to him too late.

He remembered Bilbo's tears upon his face, the cold creeping through his limbs, and the terrible certainty that he would never see another morning.

Now Bilbo rested against his side.

His nephews were alive.

Azog was dead.

And the future, though still uncertain, stretched before them.

Thorin lowered his gaze to the hobbit beside him.

Bilbo's hand rested upon the stone between them.

After a moment, Thorin placed his own hand nearby, leaving a small space between their fingers.

Bilbo looked down.

Then, quietly, he moved his hand and took Thorin's.

Neither spoke.

There was nothing more that needed saying just then.

For the first time since waking in a world that had given him a second chance, Thorin Oakenshield allowed himself to believe that perhaps, at last, he might truly have one.

Chapter 25: Chapter Twenty-Five — The Last Shadow

Chapter Text

The death of Azog the Defiler did not bring silence to the valley.

Far below Ravenhill, the Battle of Five Armies raged on.

Smoke hung over the ruins of Dale, turning the afternoon sunlight a sickly grey. The streets were littered with shattered shields and fallen weapons, and the stones beneath the feet of the living had become slick with mud and blood. The cries of the wounded mingled with the clash of steel, while the horns of dwarves, elves, and men struggled to be heard above the terrible noise.

King Dáin Ironfoot stood at the centre of the dwarven line, his red beard darkened with sweat and soot.

“Shields!” he roared.

His warriors obeyed, locking their battered shields together just as another wave of orcs struck.

The impact shook the formation.

Dáin drove his hammer into the nearest enemy, sending the creature sprawling backward. Another took its place almost immediately.

There seemed to be no end to them.

“Hold!” he shouted. “For Erebor! For Durin!”

The dwarves answered with a roar.

Yet Dáin could see the exhaustion spreading through his ranks. Some warriors had fought since dawn without rest. Others stood only because their companions supported them.

The eastern barricade had fallen an hour earlier, and the orcs were pressing toward the main road leading to Erebor.

Dáin knew what would happen if they broke through.

The wounded lay beyond those gates.

The healers.

The families who had survived Smaug.

And the hobbit whom Thorin had apparently decided was worth more than every jewel beneath the mountain.

Dáin struck another orc.

“Not one step farther, you ugly bastards!”

_____________

 

Across the valley, Bard drew his bow.

His fingers were raw, and the muscles of his shoulders burned with every movement. He had long since lost count of the arrows he had loosed.

Beside him, the surviving men of Lake-town fought among the ruins of what had once been Dale's marketplace.

They had lost their homes to Smaug.

Some had lost husbands, wives, children, and friends.

Now they fought to prevent the orcs from taking what little remained.

“Captain!” a young soldier shouted. “They're coming through the southern street!”

Bard turned.

A group of orcs had broken through the barricade, driving several exhausted men backward.

He drew and released.

The first orc fell.

“Fall back to the fountain!” Bard ordered. “Make them come through the narrow passage!”

His men obeyed.

Bard followed, helping a wounded soldier to his feet as arrows struck the stones around them.

He thought briefly of his children, safe within Erebor under the protection of the dwarves.

He had promised them he would return.

He intended to keep that promise.

A horn sounded from the northern ruins.

Bard looked up.

Through the smoke came a line of elven warriors, their silver armour catching what little light remained.

At their head rode Thranduil.

The Elvenking's expression was cold and composed, though blood stained one sleeve and his magnificent armour bore the marks of battle.

He drew his sword.

“Forward!”

The elves struck the orcs' exposed flank with devastating precision.

Bard watched the enemy formation falter.

Then Thranduil turned toward him.

“The western road is lost,” the Elvenking called. “Bolg is gathering his remaining forces for another assault.”

Bard lowered his bow.

“How many?”

“Enough.”

Neither needed further explanation.

Bard looked toward Erebor.

“Then we hold here.”

Thranduil regarded him for a moment.

Then he inclined his head.

“Together.”

______________

 

Gandalf stood upon the remains of a stone stairway overlooking the ruined marketplace.

His robes were torn, his hat had disappeared somewhere during the fighting, and his staff glowed faintly beneath the gathering clouds.

He had spent the day moving between the allied lines, carrying warnings, helping the wounded, and using what strength he could spare to protect those caught in the fighting.

Now he watched the enemy gather beyond the northern streets.

Bolg had taken command.

The enormous orc stood beneath a black banner, surrounded by warriors drawn from the remnants of Azog's army. News of his father's death had spread through the ranks, but rather than retreat, Bolg had driven his followers forward with renewed fury.

Gandalf's expression darkened.

“Foolish creature,” he murmured.

A horn sounded.

Then another.

The orcs surged toward the allied lines.

Gandalf raised his staff.

A brilliant flash of white light burst across the ruined street.

The foremost orcs recoiled, shielding their eyes as the sudden radiance scattered their advance.

“Now!” Gandalf shouted.

Bard's archers released their arrows.

Thranduil's elves followed.

For a moment, the attack faltered.

But the orcs continued coming.

Gandalf lowered his staff, breathing heavily.

Magic could buy them moments.

It could not replace the strength of an army.

He looked toward the mountains.

The clouds were moving strangely.

And somewhere beyond them, he heard a distant cry.

Bolg entered the battle like a creature possessed.

His armour was dark with blood, his enormous weapon crushing shields and breaking spears as he drove toward the dwarven line.

“Where is Oakenshield?” he roared.

Dáin stepped forward.

“Busy killing your father, last I heard!”

Bolg's answering howl shook the nearby warriors.

He charged.

Dáin met him with his hammer, the impact sending a painful shock through his arms.

The two fought amid the collapsing barricade, surrounded by dwarves desperately attempting to hold back Bolg's guards.

Bolg was stronger.

Dáin was faster than his heavy armour suggested, but exhaustion had begun to slow him.

A blow caught his shield and drove him to one knee.

Bolg raised his weapon.

Then the ground seemed to tremble.

At first, Dáin thought another wave of orcs was approaching.

But the sound was different.

He heard frightened screams from the enemy ranks.

Something enormous was moving through them.

A black shape burst from the smoke.

A bear.

Not merely a bear, but a creature of extraordinary size, its dark fur bristling and its jaws open in a terrible roar.

Beorn.

He struck the orc ranks with the force of an avalanche.

Warriors scattered before him. Those who attempted to stand their ground were thrown aside, and the creatures nearest Bolg turned in panic as the great bear charged toward their commander.

Dáin scrambled backward.

“Well,” he gasped, staring, “that's a welcome sight.”

Bolg turned.

Too late.

Beorn struck him with the full weight of his charge.

The orc was hurled from his feet.

He struggled to rise, snarling, but Beorn was already upon him.

For one brief, terrible moment, the two figures struggled amid the shattered stones.

Then Beorn's roar rose above the battlefield.

When he stepped away, Bolg did not rise again.

The son of Azog was dead.

______________

 

The news spread unevenly at first.

A dwarf shouted that Bolg had fallen.

An elven captain repeated it.

Bard heard the cry from the ruined marketplace and looked toward the northern barricade, where the enormous bear stood amid a scattering of terrified orcs.

Then another sound rolled across the valley.

A high, piercing cry.

Gandalf lifted his head.

His weary face changed.

“Oh,” he whispered.

Above the mountains, great shapes emerged from the clouds.

Wings stretched wide against the pale sky.

One became three.

Three became a dozen.

And then the air was filled with them.

“The Eagles!” someone shouted.

The cry passed from warrior to warrior.

“The Eagles are coming!”

They descended upon the mountain slopes, striking the orcs who had occupied the heights and scattering the archers positioned above the allied armies.

Great wings swept through the smoke.

The orcs looked upward in terror.

Their reinforcements, which had been pouring down from the northern passages throughout the day, suddenly found themselves under attack from above.

The pressure upon the valley began to ease.

Gandalf watched the Eagles sweep across the slopes, and relief softened the deep lines of his face.

“About time,” he murmured.

_____________

 

Dáin saw the change first.

Without Bolg's commands, the orcs had begun fighting in scattered groups rather than disciplined formations. Some still attacked with desperate ferocity, but others were already retreating toward the northern roads.

The Eagles struck their positions above.

Beorn drove through the centre.

And the allied armies, battered though they were, still stood.

Dáin raised his hammer.

“Forward!”

His dwarves answered.

Across the ruins, Bard heard the call and rallied his men.

“Drive them from Dale!”

The men surged through the broken streets, reclaiming ground they had defended since morning.

Thranduil's elves moved along the northern passages, preventing the fleeing orcs from regrouping upon the slopes.

The Elvenking stood upon a fallen wall, his sword darkened from battle.

He watched his warriors advance alongside dwarves whose ancestors had once regarded his people with bitter suspicion.

For a moment, his gaze travelled toward Erebor.

He thought of Thorin Oakenshield, of their difficult negotiations in the Woodland Realm, and of the small hobbit who had somehow persuaded a stubborn dwarf king to remember the value of friendship.

Then he turned back toward the fighting.

“Secure the road,” he ordered. “Do not allow them to return.”

The elves obeyed.

By late afternoon, the enemy's final formations had broken.

Some orcs fled into the mountains, pursued until the allied commanders were satisfied they could not immediately regroup. Others continued fighting among the ruins until they were overwhelmed.

Slowly, the sounds of battle diminished.

The horns grew fewer.

The cries of steel upon steel gave way to shouted orders, calls for healers, and the exhausted voices of soldiers searching for missing companions.

At last, Dáin stood beside Bard and Thranduil in the ruined marketplace.

All three were bloodied.

All three were exhausted.

For a long moment, none spoke.

Then Bard looked toward the northern road.

“They're retreating.”

Thranduil nodded.

“Their commanders are dead. Their remaining forces are scattered.”

Dáin leaned heavily upon his hammer.

“And the mountain?”

Bard looked toward Erebor.

“Still standing.”

Dáin let out a long breath.

Then he began to laugh.

It was a tired, disbelieving sound, roughened by smoke and exhaustion.

“By Durin,” he whispered. “We did it.”

Gandalf approached from the ruined stairway.

His expression was solemn despite the relief in his eyes.

“Yes,” he said. “You did.”

He looked around at the wounded, the fallen, and the survivors beginning to emerge from shelter.

“But there is much to do.”

Thranduil lowered his sword.

“Then we begin.”

_____________

 

The first messenger reached Ravenhill as the afternoon light began to fade.

Thorin was sitting against a sheltered wall while Óin examined the wound along his ribs. Bilbo rested nearby, wrapped in a blanket, with Fíli and Kíli refusing to move farther than a few paces from him.

Dwalin stood watch at the passage.

Legolas was the first to hear the approaching footsteps.

A dwarven warrior emerged from the lower path, breathless and covered in dust.

“My king!”

Thorin looked up.

The messenger stopped before him.

“Bolg is dead. Beorn slew him. The Eagles have scattered the orcs upon the slopes, and the enemy has broken.”

Thorin stared.

The dwarf's face split into an exhausted smile.

“Dáin sends word from the valley. Bard and Thranduil have secured the roads.”

He drew himself upright.

“My king, the Battle of Five Armies is over.”

For a moment, Thorin could not speak.

He looked toward the valley.

The smoke was beginning to thin, revealing the broken streets of Dale and the distant banners of the allied armies.

The mountain stood behind him.

His people had survived.

He turned toward Fíli and Kíli.

Both were watching him.

Alive.

Then he looked at Bilbo.

The hobbit's eyes were bright with tears.

“We won?” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin nodded slowly.

“Yes.”

Kíli released a breath that sounded suspiciously like a sob.

Fíli caught his brother by the shoulder.

Dwalin lowered his head, and Legolas looked toward the clearing sky with quiet relief.

Bilbo reached for Thorin's hand.

Thorin took it.

He remembered another ending.

A cold mountainside. His nephews dead. His own strength fading as Bilbo begged him to stay.

For so long, Thorin had carried those memories like a sentence that could never be overturned.

But now the battle was finished.

Azog and Bolg were dead.

His family was alive.

And though there would be grief for those who had fallen, wounds to tend, promises to honour, and trust still to rebuild, there would also be tomorrow.

Thorin looked at the people gathered around him.

He had once believed reclaiming Erebor would mean possessing the mountain and everything beneath it.

Now, with Bilbo's hand resting in his own and his nephews laughing shakily beside him, he understood how little the gold had ever mattered.

The mountain had been reclaimed.

The war had ended.

And for the first time in two lifetimes, Thorin Oakenshield had lived to see the peace that followed.

Chapter 26: Chapter Twenty-Six — The Things That Remain

Chapter Text

Morning came quietly to Erebor.

For the first time since the mountain had been reclaimed, no war horns sounded from the gates. No messengers hurried through the corridors bearing news of approaching armies, and no frightened soldiers gathered beneath the great entrance to watch the northern roads.

The silence, however, was not entirely peaceful.

It was filled with the soft groans of the wounded, the footsteps of healers carrying fresh bandages, and the low voices of those searching for friends who had not returned. Smoke still drifted from the ruins of Dale, and the courtyards of Erebor had become temporary shelters for men, elves, and dwarves alike. The great halls, once abandoned and cold, were crowded with the living.

And with those who mourned the dead.

Thorin stood beside one of the high windows overlooking the valley, his left arm bound against his ribs beneath a clean tunic. Óin had spent a considerable portion of the previous evening informing him that kings were apparently no less capable of bleeding to death through sheer stubbornness than ordinary dwarves.

Thorin had promised to rest.

He had managed perhaps four hours.

Below, he could see the first wagons moving toward Dale, carrying supplies and men strong enough to begin clearing the ruined streets. A group of elven healers crossed the courtyard alongside several dwarves, discussing the best way to transport those too badly injured to walk.

Only weeks earlier, such cooperation would have seemed impossible.

Now it was the reason so many remained alive.

A familiar voice sounded behind him.

“If you're planning to escape through that window, I should warn you that Óin has stationed guards at both staircases.”

Thorin turned.

Bilbo stood in the doorway, dressed in a clean shirt and waistcoat borrowed from the stores of Erebor. His injured shoulder had been carefully bandaged, and a faint bruise still coloured one cheek.

He carried two cups of tea.

Thorin's expression softened.

“I was merely admiring the view.”

“Of course you were.”

Bilbo approached and offered him a cup.

Thorin accepted it carefully.

For a moment, they stood together without speaking.

It was strange, how much had changed between them in so little time. Before their argument, Bilbo would have leaned against Thorin without thinking, perhaps complained about the cold or stolen a sip from his tea. Thorin might have slipped an arm around his waist, or kissed his curls simply because he could.

Now there was a small, uncertain distance between them.

Neither pretended not to notice it.

“Did you sleep?” Thorin asked.

“A little. Kíli apparently decided that if he slept in the chair outside my room, no one could possibly kidnap me again.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

“And Fíli?”

“Found him there at midnight and brought a blanket. Then sat down beside him.”

Thorin lowered his gaze to his tea.

Bilbo watched him.

“They're both all right,” he said gently.

“I know.”

“Thorin.”

The dwarf looked at him.

“They're alive.”

For a moment, something painful moved across Thorin's face.

Then he nodded.

“Yes,” he whispered. “They are.”

Bilbo did not understand the full weight of those words.

But he understood enough to remain beside him.

______________

 

The great healing hall had once been used for feasts.

Now its long tables had been pushed aside to make room for rows of beds. Dwarven blankets covered wounded elves, men slept beneath banners bearing the crest of Dale, and Óin moved among them with the expression of someone personally offended by the number of people who had allowed themselves to be injured.

Thorin entered with Bilbo, Fíli, and Kíli.

The first soldiers who noticed their king attempted to rise.

“Stay where you are,” Thorin ordered.

A young dwarf with a bandaged leg looked embarrassed.

“My king—”

“If Óin discovers you've torn those stitches because you wanted to bow, he'll blame me.”

From across the hall came Óin's voice.

“And rightly so!”

A ripple of tired laughter followed.

Thorin spent the next hour speaking with the wounded.

He listened to their accounts of the battle, thanked those who had defended the gates, and promised assistance to the families of those who would never return. He spoke with a young man from Lake-town whose father had died fighting beside dwarves, and with an elven archer who had lost two companions near the northern barricade.

There were no speeches about glory.

Only names to remember, losses to acknowledge, and promises he intended to keep.

Bilbo watched him from a short distance.

He noticed how Thorin sat beside those too weak to stand. How he listened without interrupting. How, when an elderly dwarf began weeping for his son, Thorin remained beside him until the man could speak again.

At one point, a wounded soldier caught Bilbo's sleeve.

“You're the burglar, aren't you?”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“I suppose I am.”

“The one they took to Ravenhill?”

“Yes.”

The dwarf looked toward Thorin.

“Our king went after you.”

Bilbo followed his gaze.

Thorin was speaking quietly with a young elven healer.

“Yes,” Bilbo answered.

“He's a good king.”

Bilbo looked at the dwarf for a long moment.

Then he said softly, “I think he's learning to be.”

______________

 

The treasury doors opened shortly before midday.

Balin entered first, carrying a ledger thick enough to make Bilbo wonder whether it might be used as a weapon. Dáin followed, accompanied by Dwalin and two royal guards.

Thorin came last.

Bilbo walked beside him.

He had not been certain whether he wanted to return to this place.

The last time he had stood among Erebor's treasures with Thorin, the beauty of the chamber had meant nothing. He remembered the Arkenstone shining between them, Thorin's furious expression, and the terrible moment when he had returned the silver bead that had once rested in his curls.

Perhaps I was a fool to give you a place in my family.

The words still hurt.

Thorin seemed to sense his unease.

“You needn't remain,” he said quietly.

Bilbo looked at him.

“I know.”

Thorin nodded.

He did not ask again.

They continued together.

The treasury glittered beneath the light of newly restored lamps. Gold lay in great heaps, and ancient chests stood open along the walls. Balin had already begun the enormous task of recording what remained of Erebor's wealth.

Dáin surveyed the chamber.

“Well,” he muttered, “there's enough here to keep a hundred accountants miserable for the rest of their lives.”

Balin gave him an unimpressed look.

“An encouraging thought.”

Thorin approached a smaller chest resting upon a stone table.

Bilbo recognized it immediately.

His stomach tightened.

Thorin opened the lid.

Inside lay the Arkenstone.

Its pale light spread across the dark velvet, beautiful and strange, throwing delicate reflections upon Thorin's face.

Bilbo watched him.

He remembered the hunger in Thorin's eyes when he had first seen it. The way his voice had changed, how his fingers had tightened around the stone, and how everything else had seemed to disappear from his attention.

For a moment, Bilbo found himself waiting.

But Thorin merely regarded the jewel.

“The Heart of the Mountain,” Dáin said quietly.

Thorin nodded.

“My grandfather believed it was the greatest treasure of our people.”

“And you?” Balin asked.

Thorin considered the question.

“I believe it is part of our history,” he answered. “And it should be preserved as such.”

He closed the chest.

“Have it placed among the royal heirlooms. It need not sit upon the throne.”

Balin inclined his head and made a note.

That was all.

No argument.

No longing glance toward the closed lid.

Thorin had already turned toward the next matter in the ledger.

Bilbo stared at him.

He had expected Thorin to resist the temptation. He had hoped he would.

He had not expected the Arkenstone to become simply another item requiring a sensible decision.

It was such an ordinary moment.

And perhaps that was what made it extraordinary.

“Now,” Thorin said, “the agreement with Thranduil.”

Balin opened another page.

“The white gems have been located and examined. All are accounted for.”

“Good. Prepare them for return, along with the treasure and provisions agreed upon before the battle.”

Dáin raised an eyebrow.

“You're giving the Elvenking everything promised?”

Thorin glanced at him.

“Of course.”

Dáin folded his arms.

“I merely thought you might wish to renegotiate, now that the war is over.”

“No.”

The answer was calm.

Thorin turned toward a collection of finely carved chests.

“Thranduil honoured his part of our agreement. His people fought beside ours, and many died defending this mountain. I will not repay that sacrifice by breaking my word.”

Dáin studied him.

Then a slow smile appeared beneath his beard.

“Well,” he said, “I suppose there's hope for you yet, cousin.”

Thorin gave him a dry look.

“Your confidence overwhelms me.”

Balin hid a smile behind his ledger.

_____________

 

They continued discussing the distribution of supplies, the restoration of Dale, and the funds needed to repair the roads between the settlements.

Thorin ordered grain, tools, timber, and coin to be provided for the displaced families of Lake-town. He asked Balin to establish a fund for the families of fallen soldiers, regardless of whether they had fought beneath dwarven, elven, or human banners.

Dáin offered workers from the Iron Hills.

Dwalin suggested organizing patrols along the northern roads.

Bilbo listened.

And slowly, something inside him began to ease.

Thorin did not once look back toward the Arkenstone.

Not when Dáin mentioned the royal inheritance.

Not when Balin spoke of the treasury's remaining wealth.

Not even when a guard carried the chest past him.

Bilbo realized, with a strange tightness in his throat, that he had stopped watching for the moment Thorin might change.

He was simply listening to him.

As he once had.

When the meeting ended, Thorin noticed Bilbo lingering near the doorway.

“Are you all right?”

Bilbo looked back toward the treasury.

Then he smiled.

“Yes,” he said quietly. “I think I am.”

______________

 

Thranduil received the chests in one of Erebor's restored audience chambers.

He had changed from his battle armour into dark robes embroidered with silver, though a narrow bandage remained visible beneath one sleeve. Legolas stood beside him, looking considerably less exhausted than anyone who had fought upon Ravenhill had a right to look.

Thorin entered with Balin, Dáin, and Bilbo.

The Elvenking's gaze moved briefly toward the hobbit.

“I am pleased to see you recovering, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo bowed.

“Thank you, Your Majesty.”

“I trust you have no intention of returning to Ravenhill.”

“None whatsoever.”

Legolas's mouth twitched.

Thorin stepped forward.

“These are the white gems belonging to your house,” he said, indicating the first chest. “The remaining chests contain the treasure agreed upon between us. The supplies for your people are being prepared separately.”

Thranduil approached.

He opened the first chest.

For a long moment, he said nothing.

The pale gems gleamed against dark velvet.

Something softened in his expression, so briefly that Bilbo might have missed it had he not been watching.

Thranduil closed the lid.

“You have kept your word, Oakenshield.”

“As you kept yours.”

The Elvenking studied him.

“There was a time when I doubted such a day would come.”

Thorin's mouth curved faintly.

“As did I.”

A silence followed.

Then Thranduil inclined his head.

Not deeply.

But with unmistakable respect.

“May Erebor prosper under your rule.”

Thorin returned the gesture.

“And may the Woodland Realm know peace.”

Bilbo glanced toward Legolas.

The elf smiled at him.

For the first time, the exchange between the two kings felt less like the settling of an old grievance and more like the beginning of something neither had expected.

________________

 

Beorn was considerably less impressed by Erebor's audience chamber.

He stood near the entrance, enormous arms folded across his chest, looking as though he would rather be anywhere else.

“I was told you wished to speak with me,” he said.

Thorin approached.

“I did. You came to our aid when the battle might otherwise have been lost. My people owe you a debt.”

Beorn grunted.

“I did not come for your gold.”

“I know.”

“Those creatures killed my kin. I came because I wanted them dead.”

His voice grew rougher.

“Bolg was payment enough.”

Thorin regarded him quietly.

He remembered their first meeting, when Beorn had offered the Company shelter despite his distrust of dwarves. He remembered the animals moving freely through the skin-changer's home, and the strange gentleness beneath his formidable appearance.

“I would not insult you by offering treasure you do not desire,” Thorin said.

Beorn raised an eyebrow.

“Then why summon me?”

“Because I wish to offer something else.”

Thorin stepped closer.

“You have defended your lands against the orcs for many years. You have done so without the protection of a kingdom or an army. Should such creatures threaten your home again, Erebor will answer your call.”

Beorn's expression changed slightly.

Thorin continued.

“Our patrols will assist in keeping the roads clear. Our craftsmen will be available should you require their skills. And any of your people who seek shelter or safe passage through our lands will find both.”

Beorn studied him for a long time.

“You would send dwarves to protect my home?”

“If you wished it.”

“And what would you demand in return?”

“Nothing.”

The great skin-changer narrowed his eyes.

Thorin met his gaze.

“You came when my people needed you. I cannot return those you lost, Beorn. But I can promise that if darkness threatens your home again, you need not face it alone.”

The silence stretched.

Then Beorn gave a low, thoughtful grunt.

“That,” he said, “is a better gift than gold.”

Bilbo smiled.

Beorn noticed him standing beside Thorin.

“And you.”

Bilbo straightened.

“Me?”

“You look as though you've been trampled by a herd of horses.”

“I assure you, it was considerably less pleasant than that.”

Beorn snorted.

“I leave you with these dwarves for a few months, and you nearly get yourself killed.”

Thorin glanced at Bilbo.

“He saved my life.”

Beorn looked between them.

His expression became thoughtful.

Then he gave another grunt.

“Of course he did.”

Bilbo looked offended.

“What is that supposed to mean?”

“Nothing, little rabbit.”

“I am not a rabbit.”

“No,” Beorn agreed. “Rabbits have more sense.”

Dáin burst into laughter.

Even Thorin could not entirely hide his smile.

_____________

 

It was late when Bilbo found Thorin in the small sitting room adjoining his chambers.

A fire burned low in the hearth, filling the room with warmth. Outside the windows, the last light of evening rested upon the distant mountains.

Thorin sat beside the fire, his injured arm supported by a cushion, a book lying forgotten upon his lap.

He looked up when Bilbo entered.

“Could I speak with you?” Bilbo asked.

“Always.”

Bilbo crossed the room and settled into the chair opposite him.

For a while, he watched the flames.

Then he said, “We should talk about the Ring.”

Thorin closed his book.

Bilbo drew the small golden band from his pocket.

It lay upon his palm, innocent-looking in the firelight.

“I found it beneath the Misty Mountains,” he began. “When I was separated from everyone. There was a creature living down there, and the Ring belonged to him.”

Thorin listened without interrupting.

Bilbo told him about Gollum, about the riddles, and about discovering that the Ring could make him invisible.

He explained how he had used it to escape the burning streets of Lake-town.

And finally, how he had used it upon Ravenhill.

“I don't understand everything about it,” Bilbo admitted. “Sometimes it feels strange. As though it wants to be worn.”

Thorin's expression grew serious.

“That sounds dangerous.”

“I know.”

“Have you told Gandalf?”

“Not yet.”

“Then perhaps we should.”

Bilbo looked up.

Thorin continued gently.

“Not because I wish to take it from you. But because he may know what it is, and whether it can harm you.”

Bilbo nodded slowly.

“I think you're right.”

He closed his fingers around the Ring.

Then, after a moment, he whispered, “I was afraid to tell you.”

Thorin went very still.

Bilbo stared at his hand.

“After the Arkenstone, I thought you might believe I'd been hiding another treasure from you. I thought perhaps you'd look at me the same way again.”

Thorin lowered his head.

For several moments, he could not speak.

Then he said, “I gave you reason to fear that.”

Bilbo's eyes stung.

“Yes.”

Thorin accepted the answer.

“I am sorry, Bilbo. Not merely for what I said, but for making you believe that telling me the truth might cost you my love.”

Bilbo swallowed.

Thorin's voice grew quieter.

“You should never have had to choose between trusting me and protecting yourself from me.”

The fire cracked softly between them.

Bilbo looked down at the Ring.

“I don't want us to have secrets like this.”

“Neither do I.”

“Then we should speak to Gandalf tomorrow.”

Thorin nodded.

“Together.”

Bilbo returned the Ring to his pocket.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then Bilbo noticed something silver resting upon the small table beside Thorin's chair.

His breath caught.

The bead.

The little heirloom Thorin had given him when he explained the dwarven customs of courtship.

It lay beside a folded cloth, carefully polished, its engraved mark of Durin catching the firelight.

Thorin followed his gaze.

“I have kept it with me,” he said quietly.

Bilbo looked at him.

“I thought perhaps you'd put it away.”

“I could not.”

Thorin reached toward the bead, then stopped.

“I know I have no right to ask you to wear it again.”

Bilbo's throat tightened.

He remembered Thorin's hands carefully working the braid into his curls. The tenderness in his voice when he had explained what the bead meant.

He remembered returning it.

How desperately he had wanted Thorin to stop him.

“I didn't give it back because I stopped loving you,” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin closed his eyes briefly.

“I know that now.”

“I gave it back because I thought you regretted giving it to me.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Never.”

The word came without hesitation.

“I regret many things, Bilbo. But loving you has never been one of them.”

Bilbo wiped at his eyes.

For a long moment, he studied the silver bead.

Then he looked at Thorin.

“I watched you today.”

Thorin's expression became uncertain.

“In the treasury,” Bilbo explained. “With the Arkenstone. And with Thranduil. And Beorn.”

Thorin said nothing.

“I kept expecting you to become angry,” Bilbo admitted. “Or to change your mind about giving away the treasure. I kept waiting for that look in your eyes.”

Thorin's face tightened with regret.

“But it never came.”

Bilbo drew a slow breath.

“And eventually I stopped waiting for it.”

Thorin looked at him as though afraid to hope.

Bilbo smiled faintly through his tears.

“I think I'd like us to try again.”

For a moment, Thorin did not move.

“Bilbo…”

“Not pretend nothing happened,” Bilbo said quickly. “And not rush back into everything as though it didn't hurt. Because it did.”

“I know.”

“But I miss you, Thorin.”

His voice trembled.

“I miss us.”

Thorin set his book aside.

“Then we shall take all the time you need.”

Bilbo looked at him.

“You won't mind?”

Thorin's expression softened.

“I would wait a hundred years for you, if that were what you needed.”

Bilbo gave a small, watery laugh.

“I should hope it won't take quite that long.”

“So should I.”

They smiled at one another.

It was a fragile thing, that smile.

But it was real.

After a moment, Thorin extended his hand, palm upward.

Bilbo looked at it.

Then he placed his own hand in Thorin's.

The dwarf lifted it slowly and pressed a gentle kiss against his knuckles.

Bilbo's eyes closed.

For the first time since their argument, the tenderness did not feel like something he had lost.

It felt like something they might find again.

They remained together until the fire burned low.

Eventually, Bilbo rose.

“I should go before Kíli decides I've been kidnapped again.”

Thorin chuckled.

“A reasonable precaution.”

Bilbo reached the doorway.

“Bilbo?”

He turned.

Thorin had risen from his chair.

The silver bead still rested upon the table beside him, waiting for a day neither of them was ready to name.

Thorin looked at Bilbo with quiet tenderness.

“Thank you for giving me another chance, ghivashel.”

Bilbo went still.

The familiar endearment settled over him like the warmth of a home he had feared he would never see again.

His eyes shone.

Then he smiled.

“Don't make me regret it, Thorin.”

Thorin returned the smile, though his own eyes were suspiciously bright.

“I shall spend every day making certain you do not.”

Bilbo lingered a moment longer.

Then, with a warmth in his heart that had been absent for far too long, he wished Thorin goodnight and went to find his room.

And Thorin remained beside the fire, watching the doorway long after Bilbo had disappeared.

There was still much to mend.

But for the first time, the work ahead did not frighten him.

Because Bilbo had not asked for a perfect king.

He had asked for the dwarf he loved.

And Thorin intended to spend the rest of his life becoming someone worthy of that love.

Chapter 27: Chapter Twenty-Seven — The Road Back to You

Chapter Text

Six weeks after the Battle of Five Armies, the Lonely Mountain had begun to sound like a home again.

The great forges burned beneath Erebor, their hammers ringing through the restored corridors from morning until evening. Merchants had returned to the lower halls, bringing cloth, grain, and news from the lands beyond the mountain. Dwarven families arrived almost daily, some carrying possessions rescued from years of exile, others bringing little more than their children and the hope of beginning again.

Beyond the gates, Dale was slowly rising from its ruins. The streets remained scarred by war, but roofs were being repaired, wells cleared, and market stalls erected where soldiers had fought only weeks earlier. Men worked alongside dwarves, while occasional elven caravans passed between the mountain and the Woodland Realm.

Peace, Bilbo had discovered, was rather noisy.

It was also wonderfully ordinary.

He stood in a small courtyard adjoining the royal chambers, examining a patch of freshly turned earth with the grave concentration of a hobbit entrusted with something very important.

Which, in his opinion, he had been.

Legolas had given him several packets of seeds before returning to the Woodland Realm, along with instructions concerning their care. Bilbo had spent the better part of three weeks persuading Erebor's gardeners that a little greenery would not threaten the structural integrity of the mountain.

Now his first seedlings were beginning to appear.

Unfortunately, so was Kíli.

“Uncle Bilbo!”

Bilbo looked up just in time to see the young dwarf stride through the courtyard.

“Kíli, mind the—”

A boot landed directly beside a row of newly planted herbs.

“—plants.”

Kíli froze.

He looked down.

Then slowly lifted his foot.

“Did I kill something?”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Not yet.”

“Excellent.”

“Move.”

Kíli obeyed, stepping backward into a watering can.

The resulting clatter brought Fíli through the doorway.

“What have you done?”

“Nothing!”

Bilbo pointed at the overturned can.

Fíli surveyed the scene.

“Impressive. You've been here less than a minute.”

Kíli folded his arms. “I came to see Uncle Bilbo, not to be insulted.”

“And yet you've managed both.”

Bilbo tried to look stern, but his mouth betrayed him.

“Honestly, the two of you. One would think I was raising a pair of particularly troublesome puppies.”

“Puppies are generally easier to train,” Thorin remarked from the doorway.

All three turned.

The king stood beneath the archway, dressed in a dark blue tunic rather than his formal robes. His hair had been neatly braided, though one particular braid remained noticeably less even than the others.

Bilbo's braid.

Six weeks had passed, and Thorin had never removed it.

Kíli looked between them.

“Are you all going to spend the morning insulting me?”

“Yes,” Fíli answered.

“Probably,” Bilbo agreed.

Thorin considered the question.

“I had intended to wait until luncheon.”

Kíli threw up his hands.

“I am surrounded by traitors.”

His complaint was interrupted when Fíli caught him by the collar and steered him away from the flowerbeds.

“Come along. Balin expects us.”

“Balin expects you.”

“He expects both of us.”

“Then I shall disappoint him.”

“You've already disappointed the gardening committee.”

Bilbo watched them disappear into the corridor, still arguing.

A moment later, Thorin came to stand beside him.

“Has Kíli destroyed anything valuable?”

“Only my patience.”

“An unfortunate loss.”

Bilbo smiled.

Thorin looked down at the tiny green shoots emerging from the soil.

“They're growing well.”

“They are, aren't they?”

Bilbo's face brightened as he began explaining which plants had taken root and which needed more sunlight. Thorin listened with the same attention he gave to reports from his council, occasionally asking questions that made Bilbo suspect he had remembered rather more about gardening than he let on.

It was a small thing.

Six weeks earlier, Bilbo would have struggled to imagine standing beside Thorin so comfortably.

But time had helped.

Not by making him forget.

By giving Thorin the opportunity to show, day after day, that the promises he had made were promises he intended to keep.

Their reconciliation had not happened all at once.

There had been awkward mornings, conversations that ended in uncomfortable silences, and moments when Bilbo remembered the treasury and felt the old hurt return unexpectedly.

Thorin had never told him to stop thinking about it.

When Bilbo needed space, he gave it. When Bilbo wished to speak, he listened. And when Thorin felt the old irritation rising during a difficult council meeting, he had learned to excuse himself rather than allow his temper to become someone else's burden.

There were still days when the weight of the crown troubled him.

But he no longer tried to carry that weight alone.

Fíli had begun attending nearly every meeting of the royal council, and Thorin increasingly entrusted him with decisions concerning trade and reconstruction. Dáin remained in Erebor for several weeks, offering advice that was frequently useful and almost always delivered with enough bluntness to irritate his cousin.

Balin appeared delighted by the changes.

Dwalin, though considerably less inclined to discuss feelings, had stopped watching Thorin with the wary concern that had marked the first days after the battle.

And Bilbo had found himself returning to old habits.

He brought Thorin tea when the king worked late. Thorin accompanied him through the markets, patiently enduring lengthy discussions about flour, mushrooms, and the scandalous prices charged for decent butter.

They shared books again.

Sometimes they sat together beside the fire until the candles burned low, their shoulders touching as Bilbo read aloud.

They had begun holding hands without needing to ask.

Yet neither had tried to reclaim everything at once.

They had not kissed since the argument.

And Bilbo had not returned to Thorin's bed.

It was not because he no longer wanted those things.

Indeed, the wanting had become rather difficult to ignore.

But he had needed to be certain that the warmth between them was no longer something that could disappear beneath the weight of a single mistake.

Now, watching Thorin patiently listen to his explanation of why rosemary required different soil from mint, Bilbo thought perhaps he had found that certainty.

___________

 

That evening, Bilbo visited Thorin's chambers after supper.

He had done so often over the past weeks, usually carrying a book or some small complaint about the arrangements of the kitchens. Tonight, however, he brought nothing.

Thorin sat beside the hearth, reading a letter from Bard.

He looked up when Bilbo entered.

“Good evening.”

“Good evening.”

Thorin set the letter aside.

“Would you like some tea?”

“No, thank you.”

Bilbo crossed the room and settled beside him upon the long cushioned bench.

The fire crackled softly.

For a while, they talked about Dale's rebuilding and the progress of the new road leading toward the Woodland Realm. Thorin mentioned that Fíli had negotiated his first agreement with a group of merchants without requiring assistance.

“He was rather pleased with himself,” Thorin admitted.

“He should be.”

“He attempted to conceal it.”

“Did he succeed?”

“Not remotely.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then, as Thorin turned to retrieve the letter, the firelight caught the braid near his temple.

Bilbo's smile softened.

He reached toward it.

“May I?”

Thorin stilled.

Then nodded.

Bilbo touched the dark strands gently.

The braid was still crooked.

He remembered making it during one of their happiest evenings, when Thorin had patiently explained dwarven courtship traditions and entrusted Bilbo with a small piece of himself.

“You never took it out,” Bilbo murmured.

Thorin's gaze rested upon him.

“You never asked me to.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Even after I returned the bead?”

“Even then.”

His voice was quiet.

“I thought perhaps you might ask me to remove it. But until you did, I could not bring myself to undo something you had given me so willingly.”

Bilbo traced the uneven braid with his fingertips.

“It's terribly untidy.”

“I have grown rather fond of it.”

“You have a strange sense of beauty.”

Thorin smiled.

“I have excellent taste.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes, though his hand lingered in Thorin's hair.

Then he lowered it.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Do you still have my bead?”

Thorin's expression changed.

For a moment, he seemed uncertain whether he had heard correctly.

“Yes.”

“Could I see it?”

Thorin rose and crossed to a small carved chest beside his bed.

Bilbo watched him open it.

When he returned, the silver bead lay upon his palm.

It was exactly as Bilbo remembered: delicately engraved, polished by generations of careful hands, and marked with the symbol of Durin's house.

Thorin sat beside him again.

Bilbo reached for it.

The silver felt cool against his fingers.

“I've thought about this rather a lot,” he admitted.

Thorin remained silent.

“About what happened. About what you said. And about everything that's happened since.”

He turned the bead between his fingertips.

“I was so hurt, Thorin. I thought you regretted loving me.”

Thorin's face tightened.

“I know.”

“But these past weeks…”

Bilbo looked up.

“You've given me time. You've listened when I've been angry, and you've never made me feel foolish for still being frightened sometimes.”

Thorin took a slow breath.

“You were never foolish.”

“I know that now.”

Bilbo smiled faintly.

“And I think I'm finally ready.”

Thorin's eyes moved toward the bead.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit placed it gently in Thorin's hand.

“Would you put it back?”

For several heartbeats, Thorin did not move.

Then he looked at Bilbo with such naked hope that the hobbit's chest ached.

“Are you certain?”

Bilbo nodded.

“I am.”

Thorin swallowed.

“I do not want you to feel obliged—”

“Oh, for goodness' sake.”

Bilbo leaned closer.

“Thorin Oakenshield, I am asking you to court me properly again. Must I submit the request to your council?”

A startled laugh escaped Thorin.

“No.”

“Good.”

Bilbo turned, gathering his curls away from his neck.

“Then get on with it.”

Thorin laughed again, softly this time.

But when he lifted his hands toward Bilbo's hair, they trembled.

He took his time.

The room grew quiet except for the gentle crackling of the fire and the faint rustle of fabric as Bilbo shifted closer.

Thorin separated a small section of curls and began weaving them together with practiced care.

He remembered doing this before.

How nervous Bilbo had been.

How he had smiled when Thorin explained that the bead was not simply an ornament, but a promise.

Thorin had believed then that he could protect Bilbo from anything.

He knew better now.

Love was not a promise that neither of them would ever be hurt.

It was the choice to remain honest, to listen, and to repair what could be repaired when mistakes were made.

His fingers paused.

“Bilbo?”

“Hmm?”

“I cannot promise that I will never make another mistake.”

Bilbo turned his head slightly.

“I should be rather suspicious if you did.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“But I can promise that I will never again use your love against you. Nor make you question whether you belong beside me.”

Bilbo's eyes grew warm.

“That's all I ask.”

Thorin finished the braid.

Then he fastened the silver bead into place.

For a moment, he simply looked at it.

The small heirloom rested among Bilbo's curls as though it had never been removed.

Thorin's throat tightened.

“There,” he whispered.

Bilbo reached up and touched it.

Then he turned.

Thorin was looking at him with an expression Bilbo knew well: tenderness, wonder, and a love that had survived everything they had endured.

Bilbo smiled.

“I've missed you.”

Thorin's breath caught.

“I have been here all along.”

“I know.”

Bilbo moved closer.

“But I've missed this. Being able to look at you without remembering all the things that hurt.”

Thorin raised a hand and gently brushed a curl away from Bilbo's forehead.

“May I kiss you?”

Bilbo's smile trembled.

“I was beginning to think you'd never ask.”

Thorin leaned forward.

Their kiss was gentle at first.

Almost hesitant.

But Bilbo reached for the front of Thorin's tunic and drew him closer, and the familiar warmth of Thorin's lips against his own made something inside him settle.

He had missed this terribly.

The quiet certainty of being loved.

The feeling of Thorin's hand against his cheek.

The knowledge that he could reach for him without wondering whether he would be welcomed.

When they finally separated, Thorin rested his forehead against Bilbo's.

Both were smiling.

Bilbo gave a small, breathless laugh.

“Well.”

Thorin chuckled.

“Well, indeed.”

Bilbo kissed him again.

This time, neither hesitated.

_____________

 

Much later, the fire had burned low.

Bilbo sat curled against Thorin's side, his head resting upon the dwarf's shoulder while Thorin absentmindedly stroked his curls.

Neither had spoken for several minutes.

They were simply enjoying the quiet.

Eventually, Thorin glanced toward the door.

“It is getting late.”

Bilbo made a small sound of agreement.

“You should probably rest,” Thorin continued. “You have been working in the garden since morning.”

Bilbo lifted his head.

“Are you trying to send me away?”

Thorin looked startled.

“Of course not.”

“Good.”

Bilbo settled back against him.

Thorin hesitated.

Then, very softly, he asked, “Would you like to stay?”

Bilbo looked up.

For a moment, he studied the dwarf's face.

Then he smiled.

“I thought you'd never ask.”

Thorin's answering smile was so full of happiness that Bilbo felt his own heart swell.

They rose together, extinguished the candles, and prepared for bed with the comfortable familiarity of two people who had once shared countless evenings in precisely this way.

There was no urgency.

No desperate need to prove that everything had been restored.

Only quiet laughter when Bilbo complained that Thorin had somehow acquired even more pillows, and a brief argument over which side of the bed belonged to whom.

Eventually, Bilbo settled beneath the blankets.

Thorin joined him, and Bilbo immediately moved into his arms.

The dwarf held him close.

Bilbo rested his cheek against Thorin's chest, listening to the steady rhythm of his heartbeat.

It was a sound he had nearly lost upon Ravenhill.

He closed his eyes.

“Thorin?”

“Yes, ghivashel?”

“I love you.”

Thorin pressed a kiss into his curls.

“And I love you.”

Bilbo smiled against his chest.

Outside, Erebor slept beneath the stars.

There would be difficult days ahead. A kingdom still needed rebuilding, old wounds would occasionally ache, and neither of them could know everything the future might bring.

But tonight, Bilbo was warm and safe in the arms of the dwarf he loved.

And Thorin, holding him close, remembered a different night in a different life, when he had died upon the cold stones of Ravenhill with Bilbo's tears upon his face.

He remembered believing that he had found love too late.

Now he could feel Bilbo breathing softly against him, the silver bead resting once more among his curls.

His nephews were alive.

His people had a home.

And tomorrow, when morning came, he would wake beside the person he loved.

For so long, Thorin had believed that fate had given him a second chance to save his kingdom.

But as Bilbo settled more comfortably into his arms, Thorin finally understood that the greatest gift had never been the mountain, the throne, or the gold beneath it.

It was the chance to live.

To love.

To grow old beside someone who had chosen him, even after seeing him at his worst.

Thorin closed his eyes and held Bilbo a little closer.

After a long and terrible road, they had finally found their way back to one another.

And this time, they had all the years ahead of them.

Chapter 28: Chapter Twenty-Eight: Epilogue — Home

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Three years after the Battle of Five Armies, the Lonely Mountain was more beautiful than Thorin Oakenshield had ever dared to imagine.

The great forges burned beneath vaulted ceilings, their hammers ringing through halls that had once stood silent beneath the shadow of a dragon. Merchants crowded the lower markets, children chased one another between carved pillars, and the scent of freshly baked bread drifted from kitchens that had grown considerably busier since the return of the dwarven families.

Beyond the gates, Dale had risen from its ruins. Its streets bustled with traders, its gardens flourished, and the bells of its market squares carried across the valley on clear mornings. Caravans travelled regularly between Erebor and the Woodland Realm, bearing precious metals, timber, cloth, and occasionally letters from an elven prince who seemed determined to ensure that a certain hobbit never ran out of unusual seeds.

It was everything Thorin had once dreamed of.

His people were safe. His kingdom was prosperous. The halls of his ancestors belonged to Durin's folk once more.

And yet, lately, Thorin had begun to understand that the greatest treasure he had reclaimed was not buried beneath the mountain.

It was sitting beside the window of their chambers, reading a letter.

Bilbo Baggins—Bilbo Oakenshield, as the dwarves had delighted in calling him since their wedding—had made himself thoroughly comfortable in Erebor. His garden had become the pride of the royal household, his opinions on the kitchens were treated with something approaching reverence, and the servants had long since stopped questioning why their king's husband occasionally wandered through the corridors barefoot.

He was happy.

Thorin knew that.

But he also knew his husband well enough to recognize the quiet longing that sometimes appeared behind his smiles.

It happened most often when letters arrived from the Shire.

Bilbo would read them by the window, smiling at news of familiar neighbours and shaking his head at the latest scandal involving the Sackville-Bagginses. He would tell Thorin about the spring flowers along the lanes, the markets in Hobbiton, and the old oak tree near Bag End.

Sometimes, when he believed himself unobserved, he would grow quiet.

Thorin had seen him standing in the garden one evening, holding a small sprig of rosemary between his fingers, his eyes fixed upon the distant hills.

He had not been crying.

Somehow, that had made it worse.

Bilbo had never once asked to leave Erebor.

He loved their home beneath the mountain. He loved the family they had built there, and Thorin knew he would remain beside him for as long as he wore the crown.

But Thorin remembered Bag End.

He remembered its round green door, the smell of fresh bread, the comfortable disorder of Bilbo's bookshelves, and the little garden where sunlight fell upon the flowers.

Most of all, he remembered the hobbit who had stood in that doorway, utterly unaware that his life was about to change.

Thorin looked at his husband now.

Bilbo had fallen asleep with the letter resting against his chest.

A small smile remained upon his face.

Thorin approached quietly, lifted the letter from his fingers, and placed a blanket over him.

Then he sat beside the window and looked toward the valley.

For most of his life, he had believed that his duty and his happiness must always be the same thing.

Perhaps, he thought, he had finally reached a time when he could choose both.

The thought had not come to him suddenly.

_____________

 

Over the past three years, Thorin had watched Fíli grow into a leader who no longer needed his uncle's approval before making difficult decisions. The young prince had negotiated trade agreements, overseen the restoration of the western halls, and earned the respect of councillors who had once addressed him as little more than a boy.

Kíli had grown as well, although his enthusiasm for administrative duties remained regrettably limited. He had become a capable commander, fiercely loyal to his brother and surprisingly good at understanding the concerns of ordinary soldiers.

Thorin was proud of them both.

Sometimes, when he watched his nephews laughing together across the council table, he remembered another future.

One in which Fíli had never lived to wear a crown.

One in which Kíli's laughter had been silenced forever.

One in which Thorin himself had died upon the cold stones of Ravenhill, with Bilbo's tears upon his face.

The memories had never disappeared entirely.

But they no longer ruled his waking hours.

There had been other burdens to surrender along the way.

Thorin remembered the afternoon, only weeks after the battle, when Bilbo had finally found the courage to speak to Gandalf about the strange golden Ring he had discovered beneath the Misty Mountains. Although he had confessed its existence to Thorin earlier, it had taken him several more weeks to bring himself to tell the wizard.

Thorin had remained beside him throughout, holding his hand when Bilbo struggled to place the Ring in Gandalf's keeping. The wizard had grown unusually grave upon hearing its history and had asked to take it somewhere safer while he investigated its origins.

Surrendering it had not been easy. Bilbo's fingers had closed around the little golden band more than once before he finally let it go.

But afterward, he had seemed strangely lighter, as though some invisible weight had been lifted from his shoulders.

Thorin remembered the relief in his eyes.

And he remembered being grateful that, when Bilbo had needed him, he had been able to offer patience instead of suspicion.

They had both learned that some things were worth far more than anything one might possess.

Now, looking upon the kingdom he had reclaimed, Thorin found himself wondering whether the crown was another thing he was finally ready to release.

_________________

 

The following morning, Thorin summoned Balin to his study.

The old dwarf arrived carrying three ledgers and the expression of someone prepared to discuss taxation.

He was considerably less prepared for what Thorin actually said.

“I intend to give Fíli the crown.”

Balin stopped halfway through opening his first ledger.

For several moments, he simply stared.

Then he closed it again.

“Your Majesty?”

“Fíli is ready.”

“I have never doubted that, but—”

“He has negotiated treaties, overseen the restoration of our western halls, and earned the loyalty of the council. He knows the people. He understands what they need.”

Balin studied him.

“And what of you?”

Thorin leaned back in his chair.

“I have spent most of my life trying to return to Erebor. I do not regret that struggle. But I find that I no longer wish to spend every remaining year upon its throne.”

Balin's expression softened.

“Does this have something to do with Master Baggins?”

Thorin smiled.

“Everything and nothing.”

He looked toward the window.

“Bilbo misses the Shire. He would never ask me to leave, but I know he does.”

“And you wish to give him his old home?”

“I wish to share it with him.”

Balin was quiet for a long time.

Then he smiled.

“I remember a young prince who believed he would never be happy until he reclaimed his grandfather's kingdom.”

Thorin lowered his eyes.

“I remember him too.”

“He would be rather surprised to see you now.”

“I imagine he would.”

Balin reached across the desk and rested a hand upon Thorin's arm.

“Then I believe it is time you allowed yourself some happiness, my boy.”

______________

 

Bilbo was considerably less composed when Thorin told him.

“You wish to do what?”

Thorin had expected surprise.

He had not expected his husband to nearly drop an entire teapot.

“Give Fíli the crown,” he repeated patiently.

Bilbo stared at him across their sitting room.

“Thorin!”

“Yes, ghivashel?”

“You cannot simply announce that you're giving away a kingdom as though you've decided to replace the curtains!”

“I have been considering it for months.”

“Months?”

Thorin nodded.

Bilbo sat down rather abruptly.

“And what exactly do you intend to do afterward?”

Thorin crossed the room and knelt before him.

“I thought perhaps we might go home.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Home?”

“To the Shire. To Bag End.”

For a moment, the hobbit did not speak.

Then his eyes filled with tears.

“Thorin…”

“I know you miss it.”

Bilbo looked away.

“I never meant for you to notice.”

“That would have been rather difficult. You have described the view from your kitchen window at least seventeen times this month.”

A startled laugh escaped Bilbo, but it quickly faded.

“You cannot do this simply for me.”

“I am not.”

“Thorin, you spent your entire life fighting to reclaim Erebor.” Bilbo's voice trembled. “You crossed mountains, endured exile, fought a dragon, and nearly died defending these halls. This is your home. Your family's home.”

Thorin listened without interrupting.

“And now you're telling me that you wish to leave it?” Bilbo continued. “What if you regret it? What if you wake up one morning and realize you've given away everything you ever wanted?”

Thorin took both his hands.

“Bilbo, look at me.”

Reluctantly, Bilbo obeyed.

“I fought for Erebor because my people had been driven from their home. Because my family deserved to live without fear. Because I wanted Fíli and Kíli to inherit something other than exile and grief.”

His thumbs brushed gently over Bilbo's fingers.

“And they have that now.”

Bilbo swallowed.

“Fíli is ready to rule. Kíli will stand beside him. Our people are safe, and the mountain will remain in good hands.”

“But you love Erebor.”

“I do. And I always shall.”

Thorin lifted one hand to Bilbo's cheek.

“For many years, I believed that home was a mountain I could not reach. I thought that if I could only reclaim these halls, everything I had lost would somehow be returned to me.”

His voice grew softer.

“But then I met a hobbit who opened his door to thirteen dwarves and a wizard, despite having absolutely no desire to do so.”

Bilbo laughed through his tears.

“You were dreadful guests.”

“We were.”

“You ate all my food.”

“Most of it.”

“And broke my dishes.”

“Only some.”

Bilbo shook his head, smiling helplessly.

Thorin brushed away a tear.

“Somewhere along that road, I discovered that I wanted more than a kingdom. I wanted mornings beside you. I wanted to hear you complain about the weather and argue with merchants over the price of tea. I wanted to grow old with you.”

Bilbo's face crumpled.

“Thorin…”

“My home is wherever my heart is, ghivashel.”

Thorin leaned forward until their foreheads touched.

“And my heart has belonged to you for a very long time.”

Bilbo made a small, broken sound before throwing his arms around him.

Thorin held him tightly.

For a while, neither spoke.

Then Bilbo whispered against his shoulder, “Are you truly certain?”

Thorin kissed his hair.

“I did not fight all those years merely to sit upon a throne. I fought so that my family might have a future.”

He drew back enough to meet Bilbo's eyes.

“Fíli has his future here. Kíli has his. And I would very much like to spend mine growing old with you.”

Bilbo kissed him.

It was a rather tearful kiss, and Thorin could taste the salt upon his lips.

When they separated, Bilbo rested his forehead against his husband's.

“Then take me home,” he whispered.

Thorin smiled.

“With pleasure.”

_______________

 

Fíli and Kíli received the news three days later.

For a moment, neither nephew spoke.

Then Fíli stared at his uncle.

“Are you dying?”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“No, Fíli.”

“Are you ill?”

“No.”

“Has Óin examined you?”

“Kíli,” Thorin warned.

“I am merely asking!”

Thorin sighed.

“I am perfectly healthy. I simply intend to abdicate.”

Fíli looked as though someone had struck him over the head with a hammer.

Kíli, meanwhile, was beginning to smile.

“Wait. Does that mean Fíli will be king?”

“Yes.”

Kíli turned toward his brother.

“Fíli!”

Before Fíli could react, Kíli seized him in an enthusiastic embrace.

“My brother! King under the Mountain!”

“Kíli—”

“I always knew you'd make a wonderful king!”

“Kíli, I can hardly breathe.”

“You'll have a crown! And a throne! And everyone will have to listen when you speak!”

Fíli finally managed to free himself.

“Kíli, you do realize that as my brother, you'll have considerably more responsibilities?”

Kíli stopped smiling.

“What?”

“Council meetings. Diplomatic visits. Military inspections.”

There was a long silence.

Then Kíli turned toward Thorin.

“Uncle, I've changed my mind. You cannot abdicate.”

Thorin laughed.

“I am afraid the decision is final.”

Kíli opened his mouth to protest again.

Then something occurred to him.

“Wait. What will you do?”

Thorin exchanged a glance with Bilbo.

“We intend to settle in the Shire.”

The room fell quiet.

Kíli stared.

“The Shire?”

Bilbo nodded.

“Bag End has been waiting for us.”

“But…” Kíli looked between them. “You mean to live there?”

“Yes,” Thorin answered gently.

“Permanently?”

“We shall visit, of course.”

Kíli's expression changed.

The excitement disappeared so quickly that Bilbo felt his heart ache.

“Oh.”

It was a small word.

Far too small for the sadness behind it.

Fíli had gone quiet as well, his gaze fixed upon Thorin.

“You're truly leaving?”

Thorin approached him.

“I am not leaving you, Fíli.”

“But Erebor…”

“Will be yours to guide.”

Fíli swallowed.

“I don't know if I'm ready.”

Thorin rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“I do.”

The young prince looked at him.

For a moment, Thorin saw the little boy who had followed him through the halls of the Blue Mountains, carrying a wooden sword and asking when he would be old enough to accompany his uncle into battle.

He remembered teaching Fíli to read maps, to recognize danger, to think before drawing his weapon.

He remembered how small his nephew's hand had once felt in his own.

And now that same boy stood before him, a grown dwarf with his father's courage and his mother's wisdom.

“I spent many years teaching you how to follow a king,” Thorin said quietly. “Somewhere along the way, you learned how to become one.”

Fíli's eyes filled.

“Uncle…”

“You will make mistakes. Every king does. But you will learn from them, and you will never have to face them alone.”

Fíli tried to speak.

Instead, he stepped forward and embraced Thorin.

Thorin held him tightly.

For a long moment, neither moved.

Then Fíli whispered, “I only ever wanted to make you proud.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“Oh, my boy.”

His voice broke.

“You have made me proud every day of your life.”

Across the room, Kíli turned his face away.

Bilbo quietly reached for his hand.

Kíli held on.

_______________

 

The weeks that followed passed far too quickly.

Preparations for the coronation filled the royal halls, and Fíli found himself surrounded by advisers, craftsmen, and increasingly elaborate discussions about ceremonial robes.

Kíli complained loudly about the amount of work involved in having a king for a brother.

Yet whenever Fíli seemed overwhelmed, Kíli was the first to stand beside him.

Thorin watched them with quiet pride.

One evening, he found Fíli alone in the council chamber, studying a stack of documents.

“You should be resting.”

Fíli looked up.

“So should you.”

Thorin smiled and sat beside him.

For a while, they worked together in comfortable silence.

Then Fíli set down his pen.

“I'm frightened,” he admitted.

Thorin turned toward him.

“Of the crown?”

“Of disappointing you.”

Thorin's chest tightened.

“Fíli…”

“I know what this kingdom means to you. I know what you sacrificed to bring us here.”

Thorin looked at the young dwarf beside him.

“I have made many mistakes in my life,” he said. “Some nearly cost me everything I loved.”

Fíli lowered his eyes.

“But the greatest mistake a king can make is believing that he must never be wrong. Promise me you will listen to those who love you, even when their words are difficult to hear.”

“I promise.”

“And remember that asking for help is not weakness.”

Fíli smiled faintly.

“You make it sound so simple.”

“It is not.”

Thorin placed a hand upon his shoulder.

“But you are not alone. You have Kíli, Balin, Dwalin, and every member of the Company. You have your people.”

He paused.

“And you shall always have me.”

Fíli's composure finally broke.

He leaned forward and embraced his uncle again.

This time, Thorin felt tears gather in his own eyes.

He had once watched Fíli die upon Ravenhill.

He remembered the helplessness of that moment, the terrible knowledge that he had failed the boy entrusted to his care.

Now Fíli was alive.

He was strong.

And tomorrow, he would become king.

Thorin held him a little tighter.

There were some gifts for which no words of gratitude could ever be enough.

__________________

 

That same evening, Bilbo found Kíli sitting in the garden.

The young dwarf was perched upon the low stone wall, turning a small wooden object between his fingers.

“May I join you?”

Kíli quickly slipped the object into his pocket.

“Of course.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

For a while, they watched the last sunlight disappear beyond the mountains.

Then Kíli sighed.

“Everyone keeps saying Fíli will be a wonderful king.”

“He will.”

“I know.”

Kíli smiled faintly.

“He was practically born knowing how to look important.”

Bilbo chuckled.

Kíli picked at a loose thread on his sleeve.

“Sometimes I think everyone knows what they're supposed to become except me.”

Bilbo turned toward him.

“Kíli.”

The young dwarf shrugged.

“Fíli has always been the responsible one. The future king. The one Uncle Thorin could trust with important things.”

“And you believe Thorin doesn't trust you?”

“No. Not exactly.”

Kíli hesitated.

“I just don't know what I'm supposed to be.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“You don't have to become your brother.”

“I know.”

“And you don't have to become Thorin, either.”

Kíli looked at him.

“You have a good heart,” Bilbo continued. “You're brave, loyal, terribly stubborn, and occasionally so foolish that I wonder how you've survived this long.”

“Thank you.”

“But you're also kind. You make people laugh when they most need it. And when someone you love is in trouble, you would cross half of Middle-earth to help them.”

Kíli swallowed.

“Fíli will need that, you know,” Bilbo said. “He'll need someone who can remind him that he's still allowed to laugh.”

Kíli looked down at his hands.

“Do you really think so?”

“I know so.”

Silence settled between them.

Then Kíli leaned sideways and rested his head against Bilbo's shoulder.

“I'm going to miss you, Uncle Bilbo.”

Bilbo's throat tightened.

“Oh, my dear boy.”

He wrapped an arm around Kíli.

“I'm going to miss you too.”

Kíli remained quiet for a while.

Then he whispered, “It's just… you've always listened.”

Bilbo looked down at him.

“Even when everyone else thought I was being ridiculous,” Kíli continued. “You never made me feel stupid for asking questions. Or for being frightened.”

Bilbo blinked rapidly.

“You were never stupid, Kíli.”

“I know.”

A pause.

“Not very often, anyway.”

Bilbo laughed through his tears.

Kíli sat up and looked at him.

“You're a terribly inconvenient uncle, you know.”

“Am I?”

“You came all this way, made us love you, married our uncle, and now you're running off to the other side of Middle-earth.”

Bilbo's face crumpled.

“Oh, Kíli.”

The young dwarf pulled him into a fierce embrace.

“I'm coming to visit,” he announced against Bilbo's shoulder. “Constantly. You'll be sick of me.”

Bilbo held him tighter.

“Never.”

“I'll eat all your food.”

“You already do.”

“I'll sleep in your best guest room.”

“I shall have it prepared.”

“And if Uncle Thorin complains, I'll remind him that I know where he lives.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then Kíli's voice grew very small.

“Promise you won't forget us?”

Bilbo pulled back immediately.

“Kíli.”

He cupped the young dwarf's face between his hands.

“There is not a road in all of Middle-earth long enough to make me forget my family.”

Kíli's eyes filled.

And this time, he did not try to hide it.

___________________

 

Fíli's coronation took place beneath the great vaulted ceiling of Erebor's throne hall.

The gathered dwarves filled every gallery, their voices falling silent as Thorin approached the throne carrying the crown of Durin's line.

Fíli knelt before him.

For a moment, Thorin could barely breathe.

He remembered another future, one in which this hall had remained empty of his nephews' laughter.

One in which Fíli had never lived to wear a crown.

Thorin steadied his hands.

Then he placed the crown upon his nephew's head.

“Rise, Fíli, son of Dís,” he declared, his voice carrying through the hall. “King under the Mountain.”

The mountain erupted in cheers.

Kíli shouted louder than anyone.

Bilbo stood beside Thorin, tears streaming freely down his cheeks.

And when Fíli turned toward his family, his eyes sought his uncle's first.

Thorin bowed his head.

Not as a king surrendering his throne.

But as a proud uncle honouring the dwarf his nephew had become.

____________________

 

Their departure came four days later.

The morning was bright and clear, with a gentle breeze moving through the valley.

Bilbo had expected a quiet farewell.

He should have known better.

The entire Company had gathered outside Erebor's gates.

Balin stood beside Dwalin, both wearing their finest travelling cloaks. Óin and Glóin were arguing about whether Bilbo had packed enough medicine. Dori was inspecting the straps on their luggage, while Nori offered several entirely unnecessary suggestions about avoiding troublesome border officials.

Ori carried a small bundle of letters.

Bifur embraced Bilbo so enthusiastically that he nearly lifted him off the ground.

Bofur was smiling beneath his familiar hat.

And Bombur had prepared enough food to sustain them through a journey twice as long as the one ahead.

“Bombur,” Bilbo said weakly, examining the enormous basket, “there are only two of us.”

“Aye,” Bombur replied. “And I remember how much Thorin eats.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“I beg your pardon?”

“Nothing, Your Majesty.”

“I'm no longer king.”

“Then I suppose I can finally tell you that you've always been a dreadful judge of seasoning.”

The Company burst into laughter.

Even Thorin smiled.

But as the farewells began, the laughter gradually softened.

Óin pressed a small packet of herbs into Bilbo's hands. Glóin promised to send news of his family. Ori gave them letters from the younger dwarves who had grown fond of Bilbo's stories.

Dori fussed over Bilbo's cloak until the hobbit finally hugged him to make him stop.

Nori slipped something into Thorin's pocket.

Thorin examined the small silver flask.

“Nori.”

“For emergencies.”

“I know perfectly well what you mean by emergencies.”

“Then you'll know when to use it.”

Bofur embraced Bilbo warmly.

“Never thought I'd see the day you took our king home with you.”

Bilbo smiled through his tears.

“Neither did I.”

Bofur's expression softened.

“You look after each other, now.”

“We will.”

Balin was next.

He embraced Thorin first, holding him with the affection of someone who had watched him grow from a frightened young prince into a king.

“Your grandfather would be proud,” Balin whispered.

Thorin closed his eyes.

“I hope so.”

“I know so.”

When Balin stepped away, Dwalin approached.

For a moment, the two dwarves simply looked at one another.

They had travelled together through exile, war, and hardship. Dwalin had stood beside Thorin when the world seemed determined to take everything from him.

Now he stood before a friend who was leaving not because he had been defeated, but because he had finally found peace.

“You'll keep your sword sharp,” Dwalin grumbled.

Thorin smiled.

“I shall.”

“And don't let that hobbit persuade you to spend all day gardening.”

“I make no promises.”

Dwalin's mouth twitched.

Then he stepped forward and embraced Thorin so fiercely that the former king nearly lost his balance.

“Be happy,” Dwalin whispered.

Thorin's throat tightened.

“I intend to.”

When they separated, Dwalin quickly turned away.

Bilbo pretended not to notice him wiping his eyes.

Then Fíli and Kíli approached.

Both carried carefully wrapped parcels.

“We have something for you,” Fíli said.

Thorin looked between them.

“You have already given us more than enough.”

Kíli shook his head.

“Too late. No returning gifts.”

Fíli handed Thorin a small velvet pouch.

Inside lay a silver brooch shaped like an oak leaf, its surface delicately engraved. Upon the reverse was the emblem of Durin's house.

Thorin stared at it.

“I had it made for you,” Fíli explained. “So that wherever you go, you'll carry a little of Erebor with you.”

His voice trembled.

“You may no longer wear the crown, Uncle. But you'll always be our king.”

Thorin's eyes filled.

He closed his fingers around the brooch.

“Fíli…”

“And,” Fíli added softly, “you'll always be my uncle.”

Thorin drew him into his arms.

For a long moment, neither spoke.

Then Kíli cleared his throat rather loudly.

“Right. Before everyone starts crying again.”

He handed Bilbo a small wooden box.

Bilbo opened it carefully.

Inside were neatly arranged packets of seeds and several tiny cuttings wrapped in damp cloth.

He recognized them immediately.

“They're from my garden.”

Kíli nodded.

“I thought you might want to grow some of Erebor at Bag End.”

Bilbo touched the packets with trembling fingers.

Then he noticed the words carved into the inside of the lid.

For Uncle Bilbo, so you never forget us.

His vision blurred.

“Oh, Kíli.”

“Don't,” Kíli warned.

Bilbo looked up.

“Don't what?”

“Cry. Because if you cry, I'll cry, and then Fíli will cry, and we'll have a very embarrassing king on our hands.”

Fíli sniffed.

“You're already crying.”

“I am not!”

“You most certainly are,” Bilbo whispered.

Kíli gave up.

He threw himself into Bilbo's arms.

Bilbo held him tightly, one hand buried in the young dwarf's dark hair.

“I love you,” Kíli whispered.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Oh, my dear boy. I love you too.”

When Kíli finally stepped away, Fíli produced one last gift.

It was a beautifully illustrated map, carefully rolled and tied with blue ribbon.

Bilbo unfolded it.

The road between Erebor and the Shire had been drawn in exquisite detail, with the Lonely Mountain marked at one end and Bag End at the other.

On the back, written in two very different hands, were the words:

No road is too long when it leads to family.

Bilbo covered his mouth.

Thorin looked away, blinking rapidly.

Kíli pointed at the map.

“Just so you know, we've already marked the best places to stop when we come visiting.”

“When?” Thorin asked.

“Frequently.”

“How frequently?”

“Very.”

Fíli smiled.

“We shall visit whenever our duties permit.”

“And I'll visit whenever mine become unbearable,” Kíli added.

“That may be rather often,” Thorin observed.

“Exactly.”

Bilbo laughed through his tears.

Then Thorin opened his arms.

Both nephews stepped into them.

He held Fíli and Kíli tightly, pressing his cheek against their hair.

For a moment, he could not speak.

He remembered holding them when they were children. He remembered their laughter in the Blue Mountains, their arguments, their first lessons with swords.

He remembered the terror of Ravenhill.

And he remembered the impossible joy of seeing them survive.

“My boys,” he whispered.

Kíli made a small, broken sound.

Fíli tightened his arms around his uncle.

“I am so proud of you,” Thorin continued. “Both of you.”

Neither nephew answered.

They simply held him.

When they finally stepped apart, Kíli wiped his face with his sleeve.

“You'd better come back for Yule.”

Thorin smiled.

“We shall try.”

“And my birthday.”

“Of course.”

“And Fíli's.”

“Yes, Kíli.”

“And—”

“Kíli,” Fíli interrupted, laughing through his tears, “let them leave.”

Kíli folded his arms.

“Fine. But I'm coming to Bag End, and I expect a bedroom.”

“Two bedrooms,” Fíli corrected.

Bilbo smiled.

“I suppose I'll have to buy another bed.”

Thorin sighed.

“I begin to suspect retirement will not be nearly as peaceful as I imagined.”

The Company laughed.

And then, at last, it was time.

Thorin mounted his pony and turned to look back at the gates of Erebor.

His people stood gathered beneath the mountain, their faces bright with affection and sorrow.

Fíli stood at their head, wearing the crown of Durin.

Kíli stood beside him, waving far too enthusiastically.

Thorin looked upon them for a long moment.

Then he bowed his head.

Fíli returned the gesture.

And Thorin Oakenshield, once King under the Mountain, turned toward the open road with his husband beside him.

_______________

 

The journey to the Shire took several weeks.

They travelled without haste, stopping in villages, resting beneath the stars, and enjoying the strange pleasure of having nowhere they urgently needed to be.

Sometimes Thorin woke before dawn and watched Bilbo sleeping beside him, astonished by the quiet simplicity of their lives.

There were no armies to command.

No dragon waiting beneath a mountain.

No terrible destiny demanding another sacrifice.

Only the road, the changing seasons, and the hobbit who had somehow become the centre of his world.

When they finally crossed into the Shire, Bilbo grew unusually quiet.

Thorin noticed the way his husband's eyes moved across the green hills, the familiar lanes, and the little stone bridges spanning clear streams.

Then Hobbiton appeared in the distance.

Bilbo stopped his pony.

For a moment, he simply stared.

Thorin drew alongside him.

“Bilbo?”

The hobbit laughed softly.

“I never thought…”

He swallowed.

“I never thought I'd come back like this.”

Thorin reached for his hand.

“Are you happy?”

Bilbo looked at him.

His eyes shone.

“More than I can say.”

They continued toward Bag End.

_______________

 

The familiar green door stood beneath the hill, its brass knob catching the afternoon sunlight. The garden had grown somewhat wild during Bilbo's absence, and the windows were dusty, but the little house remained as welcoming as Thorin remembered.

Bilbo dismounted before they had quite reached the gate.

He hurried up the path, then stopped before the door.

For a moment, he simply stood there.

Thorin joined him.

“Shall we?”

Bilbo nodded.

Together, they opened the door.

The familiar scent of old wood, dust, and dried herbs greeted them.

Bilbo stepped inside.

His eyes moved over the round hallway, the little tables, the shelves, and the rooms he had once believed he would never leave.

Then he turned toward Thorin.

“Welcome home.”

Thorin smiled.

He set down their bags and drew Bilbo into his arms.

“Thank you, ghivashel.”

Bilbo kissed him.

When they separated, he glanced toward the garden.

“I shall have quite a lot of work to do.”

“I noticed.”

“And we'll need to prepare the guest rooms.”

“Unfortunately.”

“And I think Kíli will arrive sooner than he claims.”

“I have no doubt.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then he grew quiet.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Are you certain you won't miss being king?”

Thorin looked around the little hobbit-hole.

There was no throne.

No crown.

No great hall filled with courtiers.

Only warm sunlight through round windows, the promise of tea, and a garden waiting to be tended.

He looked at Bilbo.

At the silver bead resting among his curls.

At the wedding ring upon his finger.

And he thought of Fíli sitting upon the throne of Erebor, with Kíli beside him. He thought of the Company, alive and laughing, and the kingdom he had once feared would remain lost forever.

Everything he had fought to protect was safe.

Everything he had once believed impossible had become real.

Thorin reached for his husband's hand.

“I have everything I ever wanted right here.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

Thorin kissed his forehead.

“My home is wherever you are.”

Bilbo smiled through his tears.

“Then I suppose we're home.”

Thorin drew him close.

“Yes,” he whispered.

“We are.”

______________

 

Outside, the afternoon sun warmed the hills of the Shire.

Somewhere in the distance, children were laughing, birds were singing, and the world continued turning in all its ordinary, wonderful ways.

There would be visitors, of course. Fíli and Kíli would undoubtedly arrive with far too much luggage and very little warning. The Company would find excuses to visit, and Bilbo would complain about the amount of food required to feed them all.

There would be gardens to tend, books to read, and long evenings spent beside the fire.

There would be disagreements, laughter, and mornings when Thorin woke to find Bilbo had stolen all the blankets.

And there would be years.

So many years.

Years that had once been stolen from them.

Years that Thorin had never dared to hope he might possess.

He had crossed mountains, fought monsters, and defied the fate that had once taken everything from him.

But in the end, the greatest victory of Thorin Oakenshield's life was not the crown he had reclaimed.

It was the life he had finally learned to choose.

And when Bilbo took his hand and led him deeper into their little home beneath the hill, Thorin followed without looking back.

For the road had finally brought them where they belonged.

Home.

Notes:

And so, our journey finally comes to an end.

After all the heartbreak, fear, battles, and second chances, Thorin and Bilbo have finally found what they deserved all along: peace, happiness, and a lifetime together.

No more battles to fight, no more mountains to reclaim, no more fear of losing the people they love. Just a quiet home, a family that is alive and well, and all the ordinary, beautiful tomorrows they were once denied.

Thorin's journey began with a second chance to change the past, but somewhere along the way, he found something even greater: a future worth living for.

And to everyone who followed them through this journey, thank you. Thank you for reading, for caring about these characters, and for staying with them through every moment of happiness and heartbreak. It truly means more than I can express.

Their story may end here, but I like to imagine their lives continuing beyond these pages, filled with laughter, love, unexpected visits from Fíli and Kíli, and countless peaceful mornings in the Shire.

Because this time, they didn't just survive.

They got to live.

Thank you for walking this road with them. Until our next adventure ♡

Chapter 29: Wedding Special — A Promise Beyond the Mountains

Chapter Text

The trouble began, as so many troubles in the Shire did, with Gandalf the Grey arriving unannounced.

It was a perfectly ordinary morning in Hobbiton. The sun was shining, the gardens were flourishing, and Lobelia Sackville-Baggins had just settled down to a satisfactory second breakfast when someone knocked upon her door.

She opened it with a frown.

The frown deepened considerably when she discovered who stood upon her doorstep.

“You.”

Gandalf inclined his head.

“A pleasure to see you again, Mistress Sackville-Baggins.”

“Don't you pleasure me, you dreadful wizard! You're the one who took Bilbo Baggins away!”

Gandalf stroked his beard thoughtfully.

“I believe Bilbo made that decision himself.”

“And where is he now, might I ask?” Lobelia demanded. “It's been well over a year! Not a letter, not a visit, not so much as a word to say whether he's alive or dead!”

“Ah,” Gandalf said, looking rather pleased. “That is precisely why I am here.”

Lobelia narrowed her eyes.

The wizard reached into his robes and produced a sealed envelope.

“I have a letter for you.”

“From whom?”

“Bilbo.”

Lobelia stared at him.

Then she stared at the envelope.

Then she looked back at Gandalf.

“Bilbo?”

“Indeed.”

“Bilbo Baggins?”

“The very same.”

“Our Bilbo Baggins? From Bag End?”

“I should hope so. Otherwise, I have made a rather embarrassing mistake.”

Lobelia snatched the envelope from his hand.

She recognized the handwriting immediately.

For several seconds, she said nothing.

Then she shrieked.

“OTHO!”

Her husband appeared from the dining room, still holding a piece of toast.

“What is it, Lobelia?”

“BILBO IS ALIVE!”

Otho dropped his breakfast.

Gandalf, who had anticipated a reaction of this nature, quietly stepped aside.

_______________

 

By noon, the news had spread through Hobbiton.

By afternoon tea, it had reached Bywater.

By supper, half the Shire was discussing the astonishing resurrection of Bilbo Baggins, who had apparently vanished into the wilderness with thirteen dwarves and returned from the dead by means of a letter.

The letters themselves did little to calm the excitement.

Gandalf delivered them to several Took and Brandybuck households, to Bilbo's Baggins relations, and to a handful of old friends and neighbours, including Hamfast Gamgee, who had tended Bag End's garden during its master's long absence.

Some recipients wept upon recognizing Bilbo's handwriting. Others immediately demanded to know where he had been. One elderly Took insisted that he had always known Bilbo would return because there had never been anything ordinary about Belladonna's boy.

But every letter contained essentially the same information.

Bilbo Baggins was alive.

Bilbo Baggins was getting married.

And the wedding would take place in Erebor, beneath the Lonely Mountain.

There was a date, directions, and a polite request for their attendance.

There was no explanation of the bride.

This omission caused considerably more discussion than Bilbo could possibly have imagined.

Or perhaps exactly as much as he had imagined.

“Erebor,” Lobelia repeated that evening, studying the invitation over her spectacles. “A kingdom, apparently.”

“Dwarven kingdom,” Otho corrected, having questioned Gandalf extensively.

“Which means the bride must belong to a wealthy family.”

“Perhaps,” Otho agreed.

“A princess, most likely.”

Gandalf, who had been unfortunate enough to remain for tea, made a peculiar choking sound into his cup.

Lobelia turned sharply.

“Something amusing, wizard?”

“Not at all,” Gandalf replied, his eyes twinkling. “Please, continue.”

“And is she wealthy?” Lobelia demanded.

Gandalf considered the question.

“Extremely.”

“Of noble birth?”

“A very old and distinguished lineage.”

“Does her family own property?”

“Quite a considerable amount.”

Lobelia leaned back, looking thoroughly satisfied.

“Well. I suppose Bilbo has managed something respectable after all.”

Gandalf lowered his teacup to conceal his smile.

“I suspect,” he said, “you will find the wedding most memorable.”

______________

 

By the time the first guests began arriving at Erebor, the mountain had been transformed.

Great banners of blue and silver hung between the pillars of the entrance halls. Fresh flowers had been brought from Dale, their colours spilling from enormous stone urns, while delicate branches of greenery softened the carved arches and stairways. The kitchens had been working for days, and the scent of roasting meat, fresh bread, honey, and spices drifted through corridors normally occupied by guards and merchants.

The royal wedding had become an occasion of considerable importance.

Thranduil and Legolas were among the first to arrive.

The Elvenking entered Erebor accompanied by a modest delegation from the Woodland Realm, his silver robes flowing gracefully behind him. Legolas walked beside him, carrying a carefully wrapped gift and looking considerably more enthusiastic than his father.

Thorin greeted them in the great entrance hall.

“King Thranduil.”

“King Thorin.”

For a moment, the two rulers regarded one another with the measured expressions of men who had once stood on opposite sides of a battlefield.

Then Thranduil's gaze moved toward the wedding decorations.

“I confess,” he said dryly, “that of all the invitations I expected to receive from Erebor, one announcing your marriage was not among them.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Disappointed?”

“Surprised. There is a difference.”

Legolas smiled.

“Where is Bilbo?”

“In the gardens,” Thorin replied. “He has been supervising the flowers for the better part of the morning.”

“Then I shall go and find him.”

Thranduil watched his son depart before turning back to Thorin.

“He seems very fond of your future husband.”

“He is.”

“And you have learned not to object to that?”

Thorin gave him a flat look.

Thranduil's mouth twitched.

“Remarkable progress.”

Before Thorin could respond, Balin arrived to escort their guests to their chambers.

______________

 

Later that afternoon came King Bard of Dale, accompanied by Bain, Sigrid, Tilda, and several members of his household. Bard had been chosen as king by the people who trusted him to rebuild their city, and the crown he wore remained a simpler thing than the ancient jewels of Erebor.

He embraced Thorin warmly.

“I never thought I'd see you looking nervous.”

“I am not nervous.”

“Of course not.”

Bard glanced toward the decorations.

“Although I hear you've ordered the ceremonial hall inspected three times.”

“Four,” Balin corrected from behind them.

Bard laughed.

________________

 

Beorn arrived the following morning, carrying a carved wooden chest and several jars of honey.

He looked at the banners, the polished guards, and the richly dressed courtiers before grunting.

“A great deal of fuss for two people promising to stay together.”

Thorin smiled.

“Bilbo wished for something simpler.”

“Then you should have listened to him.”

“I did. This is simpler.”

Beorn stared at him.

Then he laughed so loudly that two nearby servants jumped.

And through it all, Gandalf moved between the guests with the unmistakable air of someone enjoying the consequences of a particularly successful idea.

__________________

 

The hobbits arrived two days before the ceremony.

Their journey had been long, although Gandalf had arranged comfortable transport and escorts for the more dangerous portions of the road. By the time they reached Dale, most were tired, hungry, and increasingly convinced that Bilbo had gone completely mad.

Then they saw the Lonely Mountain.

The enormous gates.

The guards in polished armour.

The towering halls beyond.

Lobelia stopped so abruptly that Otho nearly collided with her.

“Good heavens.”

One of the Took cousins stared upward.

“It's enormous.”

“Of course it's enormous,” Lobelia replied, although her own voice had become rather faint. “It's a royal residence.”

“Are we certain Bilbo's wedding is being held here?”

“The invitation said Erebor.”

“Yes, but perhaps there's a smaller building nearby.”

At that moment, a dwarven guard approached and bowed.

“Welcome to Erebor. His Majesty has instructed that the guests of Master Baggins be received with every courtesy.”

Lobelia straightened immediately.

“His Majesty?”

“Yes, madam.”

She exchanged a triumphant glance with Otho.

“I told you. A princess.”

The guards led them through the gates.

Several hobbits gasped openly.

The great halls seemed to stretch endlessly beneath the mountain, their ceilings disappearing into shadow above pillars carved with intricate patterns. Lanterns illuminated walls of polished stone, and distant bridges connected galleries high overhead.

Even Lobelia forgot to complain.

Then a familiar voice rang out.

“Goodness gracious! You've arrived!”

Bilbo came hurrying toward them.

He wore a finely embroidered green waistcoat, and his curls were neatly arranged around a silver bead that glimmered near his temple.

For a moment, nobody moved.

Then one of his Took cousins cried, “Bilbo!”

A heartbeat later, the hobbit was nearly knocked off his feet.

Arms wrapped around him. Someone began crying. Another relative kept repeating that they had believed him dead.

Bilbo laughed, although his own eyes quickly filled.

“Oh, now, please! I'm quite all right!”

“You disappeared!”

“I know.”

“For over a year!”

“Yes, I am aware.”

“We thought you'd been eaten!”

“Only nearly,” Bilbo murmured.

“What?”

“Nothing!”

Hamfast Gamgee approached more quietly, removing his cap.

“It's good to see you healthy and well, Mr. Bilbo.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Hamfast.”

He embraced the gardener warmly.

“Thank you for looking after Bag End.”

“Couldn't let the garden go wild, sir.”

Bilbo smiled.

_________________

 

For a moment, surrounded by familiar faces and voices, he felt an unexpected ache of homesickness.

Then Lobelia pushed forward.

“Bilbo Baggins!”

Bilbo closed his eyes briefly.

“Hello, Lobelia.”

“Would you care to explain why you have invited us to a royal palace?”

“It's a kingdom, actually.”

“Don't be clever.”

Bilbo sighed.

“Would everyone care to sit down? I can have refreshments brought—”

“Never mind refreshments! Where is this mysterious bride?”

Bilbo blinked.

“Bride?”

“Yes, bride!”

“Oh.”

Bilbo rubbed the back of his neck.

“Well, you see, there's been a slight misunderstanding—”

“Is she a princess?” Otho asked.

“No, actually—”

“Then perhaps a duchess?”

“Not exactly.”

“Bilbo,” Lobelia demanded, “who are you marrying?”

Bilbo took a breath.

“First of all, I should explain that I'm not marrying a woman.”

Silence.

One of the Brandybucks blinked.

Lobelia stared.

“Not a woman?”

“No.”

“Then who—”

“Bilbo?”

The familiar deep voice came from behind him.

Bilbo turned immediately.

Thorin was approaching from the adjoining corridor, dressed in a dark blue tunic embroidered with silver. His dark hair had been carefully braided, although the small, crooked braid Bilbo had made for him remained untouched.

Bilbo's face brightened.

“Oh! There you are, darling.”

Thorin smiled.

“I've been looking for you.”

He approached, rested a hand gently against Bilbo's back, and kissed his temple.

The hobbits went very still.

Lobelia's mouth fell open.

Thorin glanced at the gathering.

“I see our guests have arrived.”

“They have,” Bilbo replied cheerfully. “And we're having a rather interesting conversation.”

“Are we?”

Lobelia pointed at Thorin.

“Bilbo.”

“Yes?”

“Who is that?”

Bilbo looked between them.

Then he winced.

“Ah.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“I hadn't quite finished explaining,” Bilbo admitted.

“Explaining what?”

“Our wedding.”

Thorin looked at the hobbits again.

Understanding dawned.

Slowly.

“Bilbo.”

“I was going to tell them!”

Lobelia made an outraged noise.

“Tell us what?”

Bilbo sighed.

“Everyone, this is Thorin Oakenshield. My future husband.”

Thorin inclined his head politely.

“It is a pleasure to meet Bilbo's family.”

For several moments, nobody spoke.

Then Otho whispered, “But he's…”

“A dwarf,” Bilbo supplied. “Yes, that was the second thing I was going to explain.”

“A DWARF?” Lobelia exclaimed.

Thorin looked mildly offended.

“I should hope that much is apparent.”

One of the younger Tooks began laughing.

Lobelia clutched her handbag.

“Bilbo Baggins! You're marrying a dwarf?”

“Yes, Lobelia.”

“A dwarf!”

“A very handsome dwarf,” Bilbo corrected.

Thorin's expression softened.

Bilbo took his hand.

“And I would appreciate it if everyone stopped behaving as though I've announced my intention to marry a dragon.”

At that precise moment, Balin appeared from the corridor.

“Your Majesty?”

Every hobbit turned.

Balin bowed.

“Forgive the interruption, Your Majesty, but the representatives from Dale require your approval regarding the seating arrangements.”

Thorin sighed.

“Tell them I shall be there shortly.”

“Of course, Your Majesty.”

Balin departed.

The silence that followed was extraordinary.

Lobelia stared at Thorin.

Then at Bilbo.

Then at the towering pillars, the guards, and the magnificent hall surrounding them.

“Your…” she whispered.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Oh, dear.”

“Majesty?”

Thorin looked at her.

“Yes?”

Lobelia's voice rose.

“YOU'RE THE KING?”

Thorin blinked.

“Yes.”

“OF THIS KINGDOM?”

“Yes.”

“THE ENTIRE KINGDOM?”

“I am afraid so.”

Lobelia swayed.

Otho caught her elbow.

Bilbo hurried forward.

“Lobelia, perhaps you should sit—”

“Does this mean,” she whispered faintly, “that Bilbo will become royalty?”

Thorin answered before Bilbo could.

“He will be my consort.”

Lobelia made a noise like a kettle reaching its final moments.

Then she collapsed into the nearest chair.

Thorin stared.

“Does this happen often?”

Bilbo sighed.

“More often than you might imagine.”

From the corridor came a cheerful shout.

“UNCLE THORIN!”

Kíli rounded the corner, stopped, and surveyed the scene.

His gaze moved from Bilbo to Thorin, then to Lobelia, who was being fanned by an increasingly distressed Otho.

A delighted grin spread across his face.

“Oh,” he said. “The relatives have arrived.”

Behind him, Gandalf began laughing so hard that he had to lean upon his staff.

_______________

 

The morning of the wedding dawned bright and clear.

For the first time in several days, Erebor's royal chambers were unusually quiet.

Thorin stood before a tall mirror while Fíli adjusted the fastening of his ceremonial cloak.

The king wore deep blue and silver, the colours of Durin's house, with intricate embroidery tracing the edges of his sleeves. His hair had been braided carefully, silver clasps catching the morning light.

All except one braid.

That one remained slightly crooked.

Fíli glanced at it.

“Are you certain you don't want me to fix that?”

Thorin immediately raised a hand.

“No.”

Fíli smiled.

“Bilbo's?”

“Yes.”

“Thought so.”

He stepped back to examine his uncle.

“You look very handsome.”

Thorin grunted.

“Your mother said the same thing.”

“She also said you looked terrified.”

“I am not terrified.”

Fíli looked at his uncle's hands.

They were trembling.

His smile softened.

“Uncle.”

Thorin looked away.

Fíli set down the silver clasp he had been holding.

“Are you frightened?”

Thorin considered denying it.

Then he sighed.

“A little.”

“Of marrying Bilbo?”

“No.”

The answer came immediately.

“Never of that.”

Fíli waited.

Thorin looked toward the window, where sunlight spilled across the mountain.

“I have spent so much of my life believing that happiness was something I might earn only after every duty was fulfilled. There was always another journey, another battle, another burden.”

He paused.

“And now…”

“Now you get to be happy,” Fíli finished quietly.

Thorin looked at him.

Fíli smiled, although his eyes were beginning to shine.

“You spent my entire childhood making certain Kíli and I had everything we needed. You gave us a home when we had lost ours. You taught us how to fight, how to lead, and how to stand up again when we failed.”

“Fíli…”

“I think it's about time someone made certain you were happy too.”

Thorin's breath caught.

For a moment, he saw not the grown prince standing before him, but the small child who had once fallen asleep against his shoulder after a long day in the Blue Mountains.

And then, unbidden, came another memory.

Fíli lying motionless upon Ravenhill.

Blood upon the stones.

A future that had ended before it truly began.

Thorin shut his eyes.

“Uncle?”

He opened them again.

Fíli was watching him with concern.

Thorin reached forward and pulled his nephew into his arms.

Fíli returned the embrace immediately.

“I am proud of you,” Thorin whispered.

Fíli laughed softly against his shoulder.

“It's your wedding. You're supposed to be thinking about Bilbo.”

“I am.”

Thorin held him a little tighter.

“And about how fortunate I am that you are here to see it.”

Fíli's arms tightened around him.

When they finally separated, both were blinking suspiciously.

Fíli cleared his throat.

“Well. That's unfortunate.”

“What is?”

“Mother specifically instructed me not to let you cry before the ceremony.”

Thorin gave a watery laugh.

“Then we had better not tell her.”

From the doorway, Dís spoke.

“Too late.”

Both dwarves turned.

Dís stood with her arms folded, smiling through unmistakably bright eyes.

“Oh, honestly,” she murmured. “Both of you.”

She crossed the room and embraced them.

For a moment, Thorin stood between his sister and the nephew he had helped raise, surrounded by the family he had once believed lost.

And he thought that if the wedding never proceeded beyond that morning, he would already have been given more happiness than he deserved.

_________________

 

Across the royal residence, Bilbo was having difficulties of his own.

“Kíli, please stop pulling at that!”

“I'm trying to straighten it!”

“You're going to tear the embroidery!”

“Then stop moving!”

Bilbo stood before a mirror while Kíli attempted to adjust the collar of his wedding clothes.

His outfit combined the best of both worlds: a finely tailored waistcoat in rich green, embroidered with delicate silver leaves, over a cream shirt and elegant trousers. A small chain of dwarven craftsmanship rested across his chest, while the familiar silver courtship bead remained woven into his curls.

Legolas had sent flowers from the Woodland Realm to decorate the chambers, and a Took cousin was arranging them in a vase nearby.

Bilbo looked at Kíli's increasingly frustrated expression.

“My dear boy, I assure you that I am perfectly capable of dressing myself.”

“Not today.”

“Why not?”

“Because you're getting married.”

“I had noticed.”

Kíli finally stepped back.

Then he looked at Bilbo properly.

His expression changed.

Bilbo frowned.

“What?”

Kíli shook his head.

“Nothing.”

“Kíli.”

The young dwarf swallowed.

“You look beautiful.”

Bilbo's face softened.

“Oh.”

Kíli blinked rapidly.

“Oh, no.”

“What?”

“Nothing.”

“Kíli, are you crying?”

“No.”

A tear slipped down his cheek.

Bilbo stared.

“Oh, my dear boy.”

“It's ridiculous,” Kíli muttered, wiping his face. “I don't even know why I'm crying.”

Bilbo stepped closer.

Kíli looked at him.

“You're really going to be my uncle now.”

Bilbo smiled.

“My dear boy, I thought I already was.”

That did it.

Kíli made a small, wounded sound and threw himself into Bilbo's arms.

Bilbo stumbled backward, laughing in surprise, before wrapping his arms around him.

“Oh, Kíli.”

“You don't understand,” Kíli mumbled against his shoulder.

“Then tell me.”

Kíli took a shaky breath.

“You've always listened to me. Even when I was being foolish. Even when everyone else thought I should know better.”

Bilbo's throat tightened.

“You never made me feel as though I had to be like Fíli,” Kíli continued. “Or like Uncle Thorin. You just let me be myself.”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“And now you're staying,” Kíli whispered. “You're really staying with us.”

Bilbo held him tighter.

“Yes, my dear boy.”

Kíli sniffed.

“For good?”

“For as long as your uncle will have me.”

Kíli drew back indignantly.

“He'd better have you forever!”

Bilbo laughed.

“I believe that's rather the point of today's ceremony.”

Kíli smiled through his tears.

Then his expression crumpled again.

Bilbo sighed affectionately.

“Oh, come here.”

He pulled Kíli into another embrace.

By the time Dís arrived to announce that the ceremony would soon begin, she found her younger son and her future brother-in-law sitting side by side, both red-eyed, surrounded by crumpled handkerchiefs.

She stopped in the doorway.

Looked at them.

Then sighed.

“Honestly. Both my sons.”

Bilbo blinked.

“Both?”

Dís smiled.

“Never mind.”

_________________

 

The great ceremonial hall of Erebor had never looked more beautiful.

Dwarven craftsmen had erected an arch of carved stone before the throne, its surface decorated with the symbols of Durin's house and delicate patterns of leaves and flowers. Living greenery had been woven through the carvings, blending the enduring strength of the mountain with the gentle beauty of the Shire.

Silver lanterns illuminated the hall.

Flowers from Dale lined the central aisle.

At the front stood a small young tree in a decorated vessel of earth, waiting to be planted later in the royal gardens.

The guests filled the galleries.

Bard stood with his children near the front. Thranduil and Legolas occupied places of honour beside the representatives of Dale. Beorn stood somewhat awkwardly among the formally dressed guests, looking as though he would have preferred to be outdoors.

Gandalf watched everything with a quiet smile.

The Company had gathered together, unusually well dressed and only moderately disruptive.

Dwalin stood beside Balin.

Bofur had polished his hat.

Bombur was already wondering when the feast would begin.

And among them sat Bilbo's relatives from the Shire.

Lobelia had recovered sufficiently to spend the morning reminding everyone that she was related to the future royal consort.

Thorin stood beneath the arch.

Fíli was beside him.

The hall fell silent.

Then the doors opened.

Bilbo entered with Kíli at his side.

For a moment, Thorin forgot how to breathe.

The hobbit walked slowly beneath the lanterns, his curls catching the light, his green wedding clothes bright against the pale stone. Kíli accompanied him proudly, although his eyes were already suspiciously wet.

Bilbo looked toward Thorin.

And smiled.

Thorin's heart seemed to stop.

He remembered another ending.

Cold stone beneath his body.

The terrible pain of his wounds.

Bilbo's face above him, blurred by tears.

Words left unsaid.

A future that had vanished before it could begin.

For years, Thorin had carried that memory like a wound beneath his ribs.

And now Bilbo was walking toward him.

Alive.

Smiling.

Ready to become his husband.

Thorin felt his vision blur.

Fíli quietly touched his arm.

“Uncle?”

Thorin swallowed.

“I'm all right.”

Fíli looked at him with such tenderness that Thorin nearly lost what little composure remained.

Then Bilbo reached him.

Kíli placed Bilbo's hand in Thorin's.

“Look after him,” he whispered.

Thorin met his nephew's eyes.

“With everything I have.”

Kíli nodded.

Then hurried to stand beside his brother before he began crying again.

Bilbo looked up at Thorin.

His smile softened when he noticed the tears gathering in the dwarf's eyes.

“Oh, Thorin.”

Thorin gave a shaky laugh.

“You are beautiful.”

Bilbo's cheeks flushed.

“So are you.”

“Bilbo.”

“What? You are.”

Thorin laughed quietly.

And the ceremony began.

______________

 

The dwarven elder who officiated spoke first of the traditions of Durin's people: of promises made before stone and kin, of loyalty that endured through hardship, and of the sacred duty to build a home together.

Then Gandalf stepped forward to speak of the Shire.

He spoke of hobbit customs, of love expressed through ordinary kindness, shared meals, open doors, and the quiet comfort of knowing someone would always be waiting at home.

Thorin and Bilbo stood facing one another.

A silver-and-green cord was gently wound around their joined hands, symbolizing two lives bound together by choice.

Then came the vows.

Thorin spoke first.

For a moment, his voice failed him.

He looked at Bilbo.

At the hobbit who had once offered him kindness when he least deserved it.

At the person who had forgiven him, challenged him, loved him, and refused to abandon him even when Thorin had made it painfully difficult to stay.

He took a breath.

“Bilbo Baggins.”

His voice trembled.

“I cannot promise you a life without sorrow, nor a road without hardship. I cannot promise that I shall never make mistakes, or that there will never be days when the world seems too heavy to bear.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

“But I promise that whatever road lies before us, you shall never have to walk it alone.”

Thorin tightened his hold upon Bilbo's hands.

“You gave me kindness when I offered you suspicion. You gave me courage when I had forgotten how to hope. You showed me that home was not merely a place carved from stone, but something built through love, patience, and the choice to remain beside one another.”

His voice broke.

“I have spent much of my life fighting to reclaim what was lost. Today, before our family and our people, I promise to spend the rest of my days cherishing what I have found.”

A tear slipped down Bilbo's cheek.

Thorin smiled through his own.

“You are my heart, my home, and the greatest treasure I shall ever possess.”

He lifted Bilbo's hands to his lips.

“And I choose you. In every life I am given, upon every road I must walk, I choose you.”

Bilbo made a small, broken sound.

Thorin pressed his forehead briefly against his.

Then Bilbo took a trembling breath.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

He laughed softly through his tears.

“I once believed that adventures were things best left to other people. I had a comfortable home, a well-stocked pantry, and absolutely no intention of travelling anywhere more dangerous than the market in Bywater.”

A ripple of affectionate laughter passed through the hall.

“Then you arrived at my door with twelve other dwarves, a wizard, and an extraordinary talent for disrupting my life.”

Thorin smiled.

Bilbo squeezed his hands.

“I thought you were stubborn, proud, impossible, and quite possibly the most infuriating person I had ever met.”

“Only thought?” Thorin murmured.

Bilbo laughed.

“Oh, I still do.”

More laughter followed.

Then Bilbo's expression softened.

“But somewhere between that little green door and this mountain, you became the person I could not imagine living without.”

His voice grew quiet.

“I have seen you at your strongest, and I have seen you when you were afraid. I have seen you make mistakes, and I have watched you find the courage to put them right. And I have never loved you only for the king you are.”

Thorin's breath caught.

“I love the dwarf who worries about his family. The one who pretends not to enjoy my cooking quite as much as he does. The one who keeps a crooked braid in his hair because I made it for him.”

Thorin laughed through his tears.

“And I love the man who, after everything we have endured, still looks at me as though I am something precious.”

Bilbo lifted one hand to Thorin's cheek.

“I cannot promise that I shall always be patient. I cannot promise that I shall never complain when you leave your boots in the wrong place, or when you insist on working through supper.”

“Bilbo…”

“But I promise to choose you. Every morning, every evening, and every day in between.”

He smiled.

“Wherever we go, whatever life brings us, you will never have to wonder whether you are loved.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

When he opened them again, tears were running freely down his cheeks.

Bilbo brushed one away.

“I am yours, Thorin. And you are mine.”

For a moment, the entire hall seemed to hold its breath.

Then the rings were brought forward.

They were simple by royal standards: beautifully crafted bands of gold, each engraved inside with a small leaf and a mountain.

Thorin slipped Bilbo's ring onto his finger.

Bilbo placed the other upon Thorin's hand.

Then came the dwarven wedding bead.

Fíli stepped forward carrying a small velvet cushion.

Upon it rested a silver bead, more intricate than the courtship token Bilbo already wore, engraved with the emblem of Durin's house and delicate leaves representing the Shire.

Thorin lifted it carefully.

“This marks your place within my family,” he whispered.

Bilbo smiled through his tears.

“I thought I already had one.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“You always did.”

He fastened the bead among Bilbo's curls.

Then the officiant spoke the final blessing.

“Before stone and earth, before family and friends, let these promises be witnessed and remembered. May your hearth remain warm, your road lead always home, and your love endure beyond the turning of the years.”

Thorin looked at Bilbo.

Bilbo looked back.

And when they were declared married, Thorin did not wait for anyone to tell him what to do next.

He drew Bilbo into his arms and kissed him.

The hall erupted.

Kíli cheered so loudly that several hobbits jumped.

Fíli was crying openly.

Dís had both hands pressed against her mouth.

Bofur began clapping above his head, Dwalin shouted something encouraging, and Bombur declared that it was about time.

Legolas smiled warmly.

Thranduil applauded with considerably more restraint, although the faintest hint of a smile touched his lips.

Gandalf watched the newlyweds with shining eyes.

And Thorin, holding his husband beneath the mountain he had once fought so desperately to reclaim, thought that no victory in all his years had ever felt quite like this.

_______________

 

The celebration lasted seven days.

By the end of the first evening, the hobbits had discovered that dwarves possessed an alarming enthusiasm for drinking songs, while the dwarves had learned that hobbits considered five meals a day an entirely reasonable beginning to a proper wedding feast.

Bombur and several Took relatives became fast friends.

This proved dangerous for the kitchens.

On the second day, the guests gathered in the royal gardens to watch Thorin and Bilbo plant their wedding tree.

Bilbo insisted upon doing most of the gardening himself.

Thorin insisted upon helping.

The result was a minor disagreement over the proper depth of the hole, followed by Bilbo informing his husband that being king did not automatically make him an expert on trees.

Legolas laughed so hard that he had to turn away.

Thranduil, watching from a nearby bench, remarked that he had never expected to witness Thorin Oakenshield being defeated by a gardening implement.

On the third evening, Bard's children joined the celebrations in the great hall.

Tilda persuaded Kíli to teach her a dwarven dance.

Kíli agreed enthusiastically.

Unfortunately, he had neglected to explain that the dance involved several rapid turns and a considerable amount of stomping.

By the end of the evening, three hobbits had joined them, Bofur was singing, and Dwalin had been dragged into the dancing against his will.

He complained throughout.

Nobody believed him when he claimed not to be enjoying himself.

On the fourth day, Thranduil presented the newlyweds with a beautifully crafted chest containing elven-woven blankets and several rare books from the Woodland Realm.

Legolas added a smaller gift: a collection of seeds from the forests he loved, carefully labelled for Bilbo's garden.

Bilbo embraced him warmly.

Thorin watched with a fond smile.

Thranduil noticed.

“You have become remarkably tolerant,” the Elvenking observed.

Thorin sighed.

“Must you comment upon everything?”

“Only the remarkable things.”

On the fifth day, Beorn's honey was served alongside an enormous selection of cakes.

He spent much of the afternoon speaking with Hamfast Gamgee about gardens, bees, and the proper treatment of fruit trees.

Neither seemed particularly interested in the fact that they were attending a royal wedding.

On the sixth evening, Fíli gave a speech.

He spoke of Thorin's courage, of the years of exile, and of the home his uncle had fought to reclaim.

Then he turned toward Bilbo.

“And I think,” he said, his voice softening, “that our uncle has finally found something he never knew he was searching for.”

Thorin looked down.

Fíli smiled.

“A home that cannot be taken from him by fire or war, because it lives in the person standing beside him.”

Bilbo's eyes filled.

Kíli stood next.

He began with a joke about how Bilbo had somehow managed to tame the most stubborn dwarf in Middle-earth.

The hall laughed.

Then Kíli looked at Bilbo.

His smile trembled.

“I don't remember exactly when you became part of our family,” he admitted. “I only know that somewhere along the road, you stopped being our burglar and started being our uncle.”

Bilbo pressed a hand against his mouth.

“And I'm glad,” Kíli whispered. “Because I can't imagine our family without you.”

By the time he finished, half the Company was crying.

Including Dwalin.

Although he denied it.

Throughout the week, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins underwent a remarkable transformation.

Having initially been horrified by Bilbo's choice of husband, she now took every available opportunity to remind visiting dignitaries that she was related to the royal consort.

Dís found this immensely entertaining.

Kíli found it even more entertaining.

By the final evening, he had introduced Lobelia to no fewer than four dwarven nobles, each time describing her as “our esteemed relative from the Shire.”

Bilbo threatened to stop speaking to him.

Kíli only laughed.

And Thorin, watching his husband attempt to discipline his youngest nephew while Lobelia discussed royal etiquette with a bewildered councillor, decided that marriage had brought him an entirely new collection of problems.

He could not have been happier.

______________

 

On the seventh night, the celebrations finally came to an end.

The last songs faded through the halls.

The guests retired to their chambers.

And Erebor grew quiet.

Thorin closed the door of their rooms behind them.

For a moment, neither he nor Bilbo spoke.

Then Bilbo released a long breath and leaned against the wall.

“Well.”

Thorin smiled.

“Well.”

“I believe,” Bilbo announced, “that I have eaten enough food to sustain me until next winter.”

“Only until next winter?”

“Possibly spring.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo kicked off his shoes with a sigh of relief.

“My feet are killing me.”

“You danced for six hours.”

“Five.”

“Six.”

“Your nephew insisted.”

“Our nephew,” Thorin corrected gently.

Bilbo looked at him.

Then he smiled.

“Our nephew.”

Thorin crossed the room and took his hand.

For a moment, they simply stood together.

The fire burned softly in the hearth. Their wedding gifts had been arranged upon a nearby table, and the small silver beads in Bilbo's curls caught the warm light.

Thorin reached up and touched one.

“My husband,” he whispered.

Bilbo's smile grew.

“You've said that rather often this week.”

“I have.”

“Are you going to continue?”

“Almost certainly.”

Bilbo laughed.

Then he slipped his arms around Thorin's waist.

“My husband.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

The words settled somewhere deep inside him.

For so long, he had lived with memories of a future that should have been impossible to escape.

He remembered death.

He remembered grief.

He remembered the terrible certainty that he would never again see the people he loved.

And now…

Fíli was alive.

Kíli was alive.

His sister had watched him marry.

His friends had celebrated beside him.

And Bilbo stood in his arms, warm and breathing, wearing his ring.

Thorin drew him closer.

Bilbo noticed the change in his expression.

“What is it?”

Thorin shook his head.

“Nothing.”

“Thorin.”

The dwarf smiled faintly.

“Everything.”

Bilbo waited.

Thorin brushed a curl away from his husband's forehead.

“There was a time when I believed I would never have this.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“I know.”

Thorin swallowed.

“I spent so long thinking of everything I had lost that I scarcely knew what to do when life began giving things back.”

Bilbo rested his forehead against his.

“Then perhaps you needn't do anything at all.”

Thorin closed his eyes.

“Perhaps.”

“We don't have to fight anything tonight,” Bilbo whispered. “Or save anyone. Or prove ourselves worthy of anything.”

He lifted Thorin's hand and kissed his wedding ring.

“We're allowed to be happy.”

A tear slipped down Thorin's cheek.

Bilbo wiped it away.

“Oh, my love.”

Thorin laughed shakily.

“I seem to have spent the entire week crying.”

“Not nearly as much as Kíli.”

That drew a genuine laugh from him.

Bilbo smiled.

Then he kissed Thorin gently.

There was no audience now.

No crown to straighten, no vows to remember, no expectations waiting beyond the door.

Only the quiet warmth of their chambers and the simple joy of belonging to one another.

When they separated, Bilbo rested his head against Thorin's chest.

“Do you know what I want most?” he asked.

Thorin stroked his curls.

“What?”

“A lifetime of ordinary mornings.”

Thorin smiled.

“Ordinary?”

“Very ordinary. Tea, breakfast, a little gardening. Perhaps a book or two. And you complaining that I've left my things everywhere.”

“I would never.”

“You absolutely would.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo lifted his head.

“And someday, perhaps, when Fíli is king and Kíli has found his own path, we might go back to the Shire for a while.”

Thorin looked at him.

“To Bag End?”

Bilbo nodded.

“Just for a little peace.”

Thorin brushed his thumb across Bilbo's cheek.

“Then we shall.”

Bilbo smiled.

“You promise?”

Thorin kissed his forehead.

“I promise.”

Neither knew, in that moment, that the promise would one day become a life beneath a green hill, far from the mountain and its throne.

For now, it was enough to imagine it.

Bilbo took Thorin's hand and led him toward the fire.

They settled together upon the sofa, Bilbo curled comfortably against his husband's side, Thorin's arm wrapped around him.

For a long time, they said nothing.

Outside, the mountain slept.

Somewhere in the royal residence, Kíli was undoubtedly still awake, and Fíli was probably attempting to persuade him to go to bed. Dís would be shaking her head at both her sons, and Balin would be making certain that the last of the guests had everything they needed.

Tomorrow there would be duties again.

Letters to answer.

Meetings to attend.

A kingdom to govern.

But tonight, there was only this.

Bilbo tilted his head.

“Thorin?”

“Yes, ghivashel?”

“Are you happy?”

Thorin looked at him.

At the soft curls framing his face.

At the wedding bead resting beside the silver token of their courtship.

At the ring upon his finger.

And he thought of a little hobbit-hole in the Shire, of a door opening, and of the impossible road that had brought him here.

He smiled.

“More than I ever believed I could be.”

Bilbo's eyes shone.

“Good.”

He kissed Thorin once more.

Then he settled against his chest, listening to the steady rhythm of his heart.

Thorin held him close.

For the first time in longer than he could remember, he did not feel the need to look backward.

The past had brought them sorrow, but it had also brought them here.

And whatever the future held, they would face it together.

Not as king and burglar.

Not as companions upon a desperate quest.

But as husbands.

As family.

As two people who had found their way back to one another against every impossible odd.

Thorin pressed a kiss into Bilbo's hair.

“Goodnight, my husband.”

Bilbo smiled against his chest.

“Goodnight, my king.”

And beneath the Lonely Mountain, surrounded by the quiet warmth of the home they had built together, Thorin Oakenshield finally allowed himself to believe that happiness was not something he had to earn through suffering.

It was something he was allowed to keep.

And this time, he intended to keep it for a lifetime.

Chapter 30: Bonus Special — An Unexpected Party, Once Again

Chapter Text

There were certain things Thorin Oakenshield had never expected to do with his life.

He had never expected to retire from the throne of Erebor while still perfectly capable of ruling it. He had never expected to exchange the magnificent halls of his ancestors for a hobbit-hole beneath a grassy hill. And he certainly had never expected to find himself standing in the middle of a vegetable garden on a pleasant summer morning, arguing with a seven-year-old hobbit about the proper size of a dragon.

“They're not that big,” the child insisted.

Thorin looked down at him.

The boy, whose name was Milo Took, stood with his hands upon his hips and the unwavering confidence of someone who had never encountered anything more dangerous than an irritated goose.

“I beg your pardon?”

“My da says dragons are just big lizards.”

Thorin slowly lowered the gardening trowel in his hand.

“Your father,” he said with great dignity, “has clearly never met a dragon.”

Milo considered this.

“Have you?”

“Yes.”

“A real one?”

“Unfortunately.”

“Was he bigger than Farmer Cotton's barn?”

“Considerably.”

“Bigger than the mill?”

“Yes.”

“Bigger than Bag End?”

Thorin sighed.

“Milo, Smaug could have swallowed Bag End without noticing.”

The boy's eyes widened.

From somewhere behind the dwarf came an amused voice.

“Thorin, darling, you're going to give the poor child nightmares.”

Bilbo Baggins stood beside the rosebushes, holding a basket of freshly gathered herbs. His sleeves were rolled to his elbows, his curls were thoroughly dishevelled, and there was a smear of soil across his cheek.

Thorin thought, not for the first time, that his husband was the most beautiful creature in Middle-earth.

“He asked,” Thorin replied.

“And you could have told him about something pleasant.”

“Dragons are not pleasant.”

“Then perhaps you might tell him about the ponies instead.”

Milo looked horrified.

“I don't want to hear about ponies!”

“See?” Thorin said.

Bilbo rolled his eyes.

There were five other children sitting beneath the apple tree, all waiting with varying degrees of patience for Thorin to continue his story. They had arrived nearly an hour earlier, ostensibly to return a borrowed book, although Thorin suspected that none of them had ever intended to leave promptly.

He had been repairing the garden gate when they appeared.

Naturally, he had informed them that he was busy.

Naturally, they had ignored him.

And somehow, within twenty minutes, he had found himself seated upon the grass explaining the difference between mountain trolls and stone giants.

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, approaching him, “you promised to help me with the tomatoes.”

“I am helping.”

“You're telling stories.”

“An important educational service.”

Bilbo looked at the children.

“Has he been telling you about the trolls again?”

Six heads nodded enthusiastically.

“And did he mention that he nearly got himself eaten?”

Thorin gave his husband a wounded look.

“Bilbo.”

“What? It's true.”

“You were there too.”

“Yes, but I wasn't the one threatening to fight three trolls with a sword.”

“You were the one attempting to steal from them.”

The children gasped.

Bilbo straightened.

“Well, I was a burglar.”

Milo stared at him.

“Uncle Bilbo, you stole things?”

“Only when absolutely necessary.”

Thorin made a suspicious noise.

Bilbo pointed at him.

“Not a word.”

The children dissolved into giggles.

_____________

 

It had taken Thorin several months to understand that the children of Hobbiton did not regard him with anything resembling the reverence he had once received in Erebor.

They knew perfectly well that he had been a king.

Their parents had explained it to them, often with considerable pride.

Unfortunately, the children considered this far less interesting than the fact that Thorin could carve wooden animals, repair broken toys, and tell stories about enormous spiders.

One little girl had asked him whether kings were allowed to eat biscuits before supper.

When Thorin answered that they could, she had declared that she intended to become a queen.

Another had asked whether his crown was heavy.

A third wanted to know whether dwarves slept with their beards tucked beneath their blankets.

Thorin had never discovered an appropriate answer to that particular question.

“Very well,” he announced, rising from the grass. “That is enough storytelling for today.”

A chorus of disappointed groans followed.

“But you haven't finished!”

“You promised!”

“What happened to the trolls?”

“They turned to stone,” Thorin replied.

Milo frowned.

“That's not a very good ending.”

“It was an excellent ending. We survived.”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin collected his trowel and turned toward the vegetable beds.

“Now, off with you. Your families will be wondering where you've gone.”

The children reluctantly gathered their belongings.

At the garden gate, Milo turned around.

“Can we come back tomorrow?”

“No.”

“Thursday?”

Thorin hesitated.

Bilbo looked at him.

Thorin looked away.

“Perhaps.”

The children cheered and ran down the path.

Bilbo waited until they had disappeared before folding his arms.

“Perhaps?”

Thorin resumed digging.

“I didn't promise anything.”

“You told Mrs. Cotton last week that Thursday afternoons were convenient.”

“That was before I knew they intended to bring half the village.”

Bilbo approached him and kissed his cheek.

“Of course, darling.”

Thorin glanced at him.

“You're laughing at me.”

“Only a little.”

“I am not particularly fond of children.”

“Certainly not.”

“They're loud.”

“Terribly.”

“And they ask far too many questions.”

“Indeed.”

Bilbo leaned closer.

“Is that why you spent yesterday evening carving six little wooden ponies?”

Thorin stopped digging.

Bilbo smiled triumphantly.

“I thought so.”

______________

 

Life in the Shire had settled around them with a gentleness Thorin had once believed impossible.

Bag End had changed somewhat since the days when thirteen dwarves had descended upon its unsuspecting owner.

The garden was larger now, with new flowerbeds along the winding path and a small stone fountain Thorin had constructed himself. Roses climbed the fence, lavender bordered the vegetable beds, and a young tree stood near the eastern edge of the property.

It had grown from a sapling they had planted together after their wedding.

Thorin had built Bilbo a greenhouse, although Bilbo insisted it was unnecessarily elaborate.

Thorin maintained that anything worth building was worth building properly.

Bilbo had stopped arguing when he discovered that the greenhouse remained pleasantly warm even during the coldest winter days.

Inside, Bag End had become a comfortable mixture of hobbit and dwarven tastes.

Bilbo's books still occupied every available shelf, although Thorin had constructed several more to accommodate the growing collection. A few beautifully carved pieces of dwarven furniture stood beside the familiar round tables and upholstered chairs, and small treasures from Erebor decorated the mantelpiece.

Their wedding portrait hung in the sitting room.

Thorin had objected to displaying it so prominently.

Bilbo had ignored him.

Most evenings followed a familiar pattern.

They would eat supper together, wash the dishes, and settle beside the fireplace with tea and books. Sometimes Bilbo read aloud while Thorin worked on a small carving. Sometimes Thorin read accounts of dwarven history while Bilbo complained that the authors had apparently never learned the importance of brevity.

And sometimes they did very little at all.

On particularly quiet nights, Bilbo would curl against Thorin's side beneath a blanket, his head resting comfortably upon his husband's shoulder. Thorin would stroke his curls, occasionally touching the silver wedding bead still woven among them.

Neither felt any particular need to fill the silence.

It was a kind of peace Thorin had never known in Erebor.

He loved his ancestral home. He always would.

But in the Shire, nobody expected him to solve disputes between mining families or negotiate trade agreements before breakfast.

Instead, Mrs. Goodbody occasionally appeared at his door because her kitchen cupboard had come loose.

Farmer Cotton had once asked whether Thorin might examine a troublesome wagon wheel.

And old Mr. Proudfoot had developed the habit of inviting him for tea whenever he wished to complain about the declining quality of local carpentry.

Thorin had discovered that he rather enjoyed being useful.

Bilbo had discovered that his husband was incapable of refusing someone who genuinely needed help.

Which was why, on one particularly pleasant market morning, they found themselves walking through Hobbiton with a basket of vegetables, a shopping list, and a broken wooden stool.

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, eyeing the stool beneath his husband's arm, “we are supposed to be buying flour.”

“We shall.”

“And tea.”

“Yes.”

“And butter.”

“I remember.”

“Then why are we carrying Mrs. Bracegirdle's furniture?”

“Because one of the legs is loose.”

“She's been asking you to repair it for three weeks.”

“And today I have time.”

Bilbo sighed.

Thorin smiled.

______________

 

The market was already busy when they arrived.

Colourful stalls lined the square, displaying baskets of apples, freshly baked bread, flowers, cheeses, and jars of preserves. Hobbits moved between them, greeting neighbours and exchanging gossip.

“Morning, Thorin!”

“Good morning, Mr. Cotton.”

“Bilbo! Tell your husband I've got that wood he asked for!”

“I shall!”

“Thorin, dear, have you eaten?”

Thorin turned.

An elderly hobbit woman stood behind a stall of baked goods, regarding him with maternal suspicion.

“Yes, Mrs. Underhill.”

“A proper breakfast?”

“Yes.”

“Not just tea?”

“Porridge, eggs, bread, and mushrooms.”

She considered this.

“Good. Here.”

She handed him two warm pastries.

Thorin blinked.

“I haven't paid—”

“Nonsense. Take them.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Thank you, Mrs. Underhill.”

The woman waved them away.

As they continued through the market, Thorin looked down at the pastries.

“Does she do that to everyone?”

“No.”

“Why?”

Bilbo slipped his arm through Thorin's.

“Because she likes you.”

Thorin frowned.

“I repaired her oven door.”

“Three months ago.”

“It was badly fitted.”

“Thorin.”

“What?”

Bilbo smiled.

“People can like you without needing a reason.”

Thorin considered that.

Then he handed Bilbo one of the pastries.

“I suppose,” he admitted, “they are rather pleasant.”

Bilbo laughed.

_______________

 

The unexpected party arrived on a Tuesday.

It was a beautiful morning, warm enough that Bilbo had opened the kitchen windows to let the scent of roses drift inside.

Thorin sat at the breakfast table, reading a letter from Erebor.

Bilbo was spreading butter over a slice of toast.

“Anything interesting?” he asked.

“Fíli says the eastern mines are progressing well.”

“That's wonderful.”

“And the new trade agreement with Dale has been signed.”

“Excellent.”

Thorin turned the page.

“Kíli apparently attempted to reorganize the training schedules.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Successfully?”

“Fíli describes the results as 'an administrative catastrophe.'”

Bilbo laughed.

“Poor Kíli.”

“Poor Fíli, more like.”

Thorin folded the letter and set it aside.

There was a knock at the front door.

Bilbo glanced toward the hallway.

“Oh, that will be young Brandybuck. He promised to return my books this morning.”

Thorin rose.

“I'll get it.”

“Thank you, darling.”

Thorin crossed the hallway, straightened the little rug beside the entrance, and opened the familiar round green door.

For a moment, his mind refused to understand what his eyes were seeing.

Kíli stood upon the doorstep.

He was smiling so broadly that his cheeks must have hurt.

Behind him stood Fíli, looking as though he had not enjoyed a peaceful night's sleep in several weeks.

And behind them, crowding the garden path beneath an astonishing collection of travelling packs, stood Balin, Dwalin, Óin, Glóin, Dori, Nori, Ori, Bifur, Bofur, and Bombur.

Thorin stared.

Kíli beamed.

“HELLO, UNCLE!”

Thorin opened his mouth.

Kíli launched himself forward.

“WE'RE HERE!”

The impact drove Thorin backward into the hallway.

“KÍLI!”

His nephew wrapped both arms around him.

“I MISSED YOU!”

Thorin staggered, caught his balance, and found himself laughing before he could help it.

“By Mahal, boy, are you trying to kill me?”

“No!”

Kíli hugged him harder.

“Although Fíli nearly killed me on the journey.”

From the doorstep, Fíli sighed.

“We have been here for approximately four seconds.”

“Four terrible seconds!”

Thorin looked over Kíli's shoulder.

“Fíli?”

His elder nephew smiled.

“Hello, Uncle.”

Thorin reached for him.

Fíli stepped forward immediately, and for a moment all three dwarves were tangled together in the doorway.

Then, from the kitchen, came the unmistakable sound of a chair scraping violently across the floor.

“Kíli?”

Bilbo's voice rang through the hallway.

A heartbeat later, he appeared around the corner.

He stopped.

His eyes widened.

“FÍLI? KÍLI?”

Both nephews turned.

“UNCLE BILBO!”

Bilbo practically ran toward them.

“Oh, my boys!”

He threw himself into Fíli's arms first, holding him so tightly that the young king nearly lost his balance.

“Look at you!”

Fíli laughed.

“It's good to see you too.”

Bilbo pulled back just enough to examine his face.

“Have you been eating properly?”

“Yes.”

“Sleeping?”

“Mostly.”

“Mostly?”

“Uncle Bilbo—”

Bilbo turned toward Kíli.

“And you!”

Kíli opened his arms.

Bilbo embraced him immediately.

Kíli buried his face against his shoulder.

“I missed you.”

“Oh, my dear boy.”

“I missed your cooking.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Of course you did.”

“And your garden.”

“Yes?”

“And you.”

Bilbo hugged him tighter.

“Especially you.”

Thorin stood watching them, one hand resting upon Fíli's shoulder.

For a brief, impossible moment, the sight of both nephews standing alive beneath the roof of Bag End struck him with such force that he could scarcely breathe.

Then Balin stepped forward.

“Well, laddie,” he said warmly. “Are you going to invite us inside?”

Thorin looked up.

And smiled.

“Balin.”

The older dwarf embraced him.

Then Dwalin.

Then Bofur, who nearly knocked his hat against the doorframe.

Then the others, one after another, until the quiet hallway of Bag End had become a confusion of laughter, travelling cloaks, boots, and voices.

Bilbo finally stepped back and looked at the gathering.

He counted.

Once.

Twice.

Then he turned toward Thorin.

“Darling.”

“Yes?”

“There are thirteen dwarves in my hallway.”

Thorin glanced around.

“Twelve visitors,” he corrected. “I already live here.”

Bilbo gave him a look.

Kíli grinned.

“Surprise!”

Bilbo stared at him.

Then he began laughing.

“Oh, you dreadful creatures.”

________________

 

The complaints began before anyone had finished removing their boots.

“Uncle Bilbo,” Kíli announced dramatically, dropping into the nearest armchair, “you have no idea what I've suffered.”

Bilbo, who was attempting to organize a mountain of travelling cloaks, looked concerned.

“What happened?”

“Fíli.”

Fíli closed his eyes.

“Please don't.”

“He's become a tyrant.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Has he?”

“A terrible one. Meetings, reports, inspections, more meetings. Sometimes he expects me to be awake before sunrise!”

“You are the prince of Erebor,” Fíli reminded him.

“And apparently that means I am forbidden from enjoying life.”

“You missed three council meetings last month.”

“One of them was very boring.”

“You weren't there!”

“I could tell.”

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

Thorin looked at Fíli.

“And how is your brother performing his duties?”

Fíli slowly lowered himself into a chair.

“Uncle, I have never understood you more than I do now.”

Thorin laughed.

“Indeed?”

“He reorganized the guard rotations without consulting anyone.”

“They were inefficient,” Kíli protested.

“He assigned Dwalin to supervise the eastern gate.”

Dwalin grunted.

“Nothing wrong with that.”

“For eighteen consecutive hours!”

“I corrected it,” Kíli muttered.

“After Dwalin threatened to throw you into the river.”

Dwalin shrugged.

“He learned.”

Bilbo was laughing openly now.

Thorin leaned back, looking far too pleased.

“Fíli, I believe I warned you that ruling Erebor would require patience.”

“You neglected to mention that most of it would be spent managing my brother.”

Kíli gasped.

“Uncle Bilbo, do you hear how he speaks about me?”

Bilbo patted his shoulder.

“Poor dear.”

Fíli stared.

“Don't encourage him!”

Kíli smiled triumphantly.

Thorin folded his arms.

“And who is governing Erebor while its king, prince, and most experienced advisers are sitting in my drawing room?”

Fíli's expression became perfectly innocent.

“Mother.”

Thorin blinked.

“Dís?”

“Yes.”

“And she agreed to this?”

“She suggested it.”

Thorin looked suspicious.

Fíli continued.

“She said you and Bilbo deserved a proper visit, and that if she could raise Kíli, she could certainly manage a kingdom.”

Kíli looked offended.

“That is not what she said.”

“It was almost exactly what she said.”

Balin chuckled.

“And she gave us a message for you, Thorin.”

“What message?”

“If you send her a single letter explaining how to govern Erebor, she'll come to the Shire herself and personally remind you what retirement means.”

Thorin stared.

Then he laughed.

A great, helpless laugh that filled the sitting room.

Fíli smiled.

It had been a long time since he had heard his uncle laugh quite like that.

“And how long,” Thorin asked eventually, “are you staying?”

Fíli exchanged a glance with his brother.

“Three weeks.”

Bilbo froze.

“Three?”

Kíli grinned.

“Perhaps four!”

Bilbo looked at the enormous collection of luggage.

Then at his husband.

Then back at the dwarves.

“Well,” he said faintly. “I suppose we'd better put the kettle on.”

________________

 

By midday, Bag End had surrendered to the invasion.

Balin and Thorin sat in the drawing room with Fíli, discussing Erebor over tea while the rest of the Company began making arrangements for their stay.

There was, naturally, not enough room for everyone to sleep beneath Bag End's roof.

Fortunately, Bilbo had become acquainted with practically every respectable family in Hobbiton, and the Green Dragon possessed several rooms that could be made available.

Bofur cheerfully volunteered to stay at the inn.

Bombur volunteered the moment he heard they served supper.

Dwalin declared that he would sleep anywhere with a decent roof.

Nori remarked that roofs were optional.

Dori immediately informed him that they were not.

Meanwhile, Fíli had begun describing the latest developments in Erebor.

“The new western galleries should be completed before winter,” he explained. “Glóin believes the trade routes will improve considerably once the road repairs are finished.”

Thorin listened carefully.

“And the treasury?”

“Healthy.”

“The miners?”

“Better supplied than they were last year.”

“The council?”

“Still argumentative.”

Thorin smiled.

“Some things never change.”

Fíli hesitated.

Then he looked at his uncle.

“It's doing well, you know.”

Thorin met his eyes.

“Erebor?”

Fíli nodded.

“I know you worry.”

Thorin glanced toward the window.

“Of course I do.”

“You don't have to.”

“I know that too.”

Fíli smiled faintly.

“Do you?”

Thorin laughed.

His nephew leaned forward.

“I mean it, Uncle. You taught me everything I needed to know. And when I don't know something, I have Mother, Balin, and the others.”

Thorin regarded him quietly.

Fíli had changed in the years since the quest.

There was greater confidence in his bearing now, a steadiness that came not from pretending to know everything but from understanding that a good ruler must sometimes ask for help.

Thorin felt a fierce swell of pride.

“You have become a fine king.”

Fíli looked down.

“I'm trying.”

“You are succeeding.”

For a moment, Fíli said nothing.

Then he smiled.

“Thank you, Uncle.”

From the dining room came a tremendous crash.

Both dwarves turned.

“NOT THAT TABLE!” Bilbo shouted.

Fíli immediately stood.

“I'll help.”

He hurried into the adjoining room, where several members of the Company were attempting to rearrange the furniture.

Unfortunately, Fíli decided that the quickest solution would be to move the large dining table.

Without first removing the dishes.

Bilbo turned around.

“FÍLI!”

The King under the Mountain froze.

Bilbo pointed at the table.

“Put that down!”

“Uncle Bilbo, I was only—”

“You will take those plates off before moving anything in my house!”

Fíli blinked.

“I can manage—”

“I don't care if you command ten thousand dwarves beneath the mountain, young man! You are not breaking my grandmother's dishes!”

Silence.

Fíli slowly lowered the table.

“Yes, Uncle Bilbo.”

From the doorway, Kíli began laughing so hard that he had to lean against the wall.

Thorin appeared behind him, smiling broadly.

Fíli turned toward his uncle.

“Are you going to help me?”

Thorin took a leisurely sip of tea.

“I'm afraid your uncle has spoken, Your Majesty.”

Kíli collapsed into another fit of laughter.

Bilbo turned.

“And YOU, Kíli. Stop laughing and come help me with the vegetables!”

Kíli straightened immediately.

“Yes, Uncle Bilbo.”

Fíli smiled triumphantly.

Thorin shook his head.

The King under the Mountain and his younger brother followed Bilbo's instructions without another word.

And for the first time in many months, Fíli found himself rather relieved that nobody expected him to be in charge.

_____________

 

Kíli was supposed to be peeling potatoes.

Instead, he was eating cheese.

Bilbo watched him from the other side of the kitchen.

“Kíli.”

“Yes?”

“Those are for supper.”

Kíli looked at the cheese in his hand.

“Oh.”

Bilbo sighed.

“Honestly, you haven't changed at all.”

Kíli grinned.

“Neither have you.”

“I'm considerably older.”

“Still bossy.”

Bilbo pointed his knife at him.

“Potatoes.”

Kíli obediently returned to work.

For a while, they prepared the vegetables together, speaking about the journey, the weather, and the latest news from Erebor.

Then Kíli began asking about their life in the Shire.

“Does Uncle Thorin really go to the market every week?”

“Most weeks.”

“And people just talk to him?”

“Of course.”

“Without bowing?”

Bilbo laughed.

“Kíli, the only person who's bowed to Thorin in months was a little boy pretending to be a knight.”

Kíli stared.

“That's wonderful.”

“It is.”

“And the children?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Oh, they adore him.”

Kíli nearly dropped his potato.

“Uncle Thorin?”

“Yes.”

“Our Uncle Thorin?”

“The very same.”

“Children?”

“Six of them were here yesterday.”

Kíli laughed.

“He must hate that.”

“He claims to.”

Bilbo's smile turned mischievous.

“Although he's carved them all little wooden animals.”

Kíli stopped laughing.

Then he looked toward the doorway.

Then back at Bilbo.

“Oh, I am never letting him forget this.”

Bilbo chuckled.

Kíli resumed peeling.

After a while, he grew unusually quiet.

Bilbo noticed almost immediately.

“Kíli?”

The young dwarf shook his head.

“Nothing.”

Bilbo set down his knife.

“Kíli.”

His nephew looked up.

There was a suspicious brightness in his eyes.

Bilbo sighed.

“Oh, my dear boy. You've been here barely half a day.”

“I know.”

“Are you crying?”

“No.”

A tear slipped down his cheek.

Bilbo stared.

Kíli made a frustrated noise.

“I don't mean to!”

“Oh, sweetheart.”

Bilbo approached him.

Kíli looked at the warm kitchen, the flowers upon the windowsill, and the familiar little hobbit standing before him.

“You're happy,” he whispered.

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Yes.”

“Really happy.”

“Very.”

Kíli swallowed.

“And Uncle Thorin?”

Bilbo smiled.

“Happier than I've ever known him.”

That was apparently too much.

Kíli's face crumpled.

Bilbo barely had time to open his arms before the young dwarf embraced him.

“Oh, Kíli.”

“I missed you,” Kíli mumbled.

“We missed you too.”

“I know, but…”

He sniffed.

“It's different here.”

Bilbo stroked his hair.

“How so?”

Kíli hesitated.

“Everyone's always so busy in Erebor. Fíli has his duties, and I have mine, and Mother is always doing something important. Sometimes I miss when we were all together.”

Bilbo held him tighter.

“You're together now.”

“I know.”

“And you're always welcome here.”

Kíli drew back.

“Always?”

“Of course.”

“Even if we come without warning?”

Bilbo considered the question.

“I might appreciate a letter next time.”

Kíli laughed through his tears.

“But yes,” Bilbo continued, smiling. “Always.”

Kíli hugged him again.

From the sitting room came Thorin's voice.

“Is Kíli crying?”

Fíli answered immediately.

“Almost certainly.”

“I CAN HEAR YOU!” Kíli shouted.

Bilbo laughed.

Then he handed him a clean handkerchief.

“Now dry your eyes, dear boy. Those potatoes won't peel themselves.”

_______________

 

The dinner that evening began with a familiar disaster.

Bilbo had intended to serve a perfectly respectable meal.

Bombur had other ideas.

By late afternoon, the kitchen contained enough food to feed a small army, the dining room had been rearranged twice, and Bofur had discovered the old collection of musical instruments stored in the cupboard.

Dori was polishing cutlery.

Nori was stealing olives.

Ori had begun sketching the garden through the window.

Bifur was helping Bombur prepare the final dishes.

Óin and Glóin were arguing about whether the dining table had always been quite so small.

Dwalin was inspecting a loose hinge on the pantry door.

And Fíli and Kíli had somehow found themselves carrying stacks of plates.

Bilbo entered the room just in time to see Kíli toss one across the table.

“NO!”

Fíli caught it.

Bilbo stopped.

Every dwarf turned.

Kíli slowly smiled.

“Oh.”

Bilbo narrowed his eyes.

“Don't.”

Bofur grinned.

“Does anyone else remember—”

“No.”

Dwalin chuckled.

Kíli tossed another plate.

Fíli caught it neatly.

Bilbo stared.

“Absolutely not!”

Then Bofur began singing.

“Blunt the knives and bend the forks…”

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“Oh, for pity's sake.”

Within moments, the entire room had erupted.

Plates passed from hand to hand.

Bowls were tossed across the table.

Dwalin caught a stack of cups.

Bombur protested that they were making a mess.

Nori pointed out that he had said exactly the same thing years ago.

And Bilbo stood in the middle of it all, staring at the ridiculous collection of dwarves who had once turned his perfectly orderly life upside down.

Then Kíli tossed him a plate.

Without thinking, Bilbo caught it.

Perfectly.

The room fell silent.

Bilbo looked at the plate.

Then at Kíli.

Then he smiled.

And tossed it back.

The Company erupted into cheers.

Thorin, sitting comfortably in his favourite armchair, began laughing.

Bilbo turned toward him.

“And don't you encourage them!”

Thorin raised both hands.

“I haven't said a word.”

“You're smiling!”

“Am I forbidden from smiling in my own home?”

Bilbo pointed at him.

“Don't you start.”

Thorin laughed harder.

____________________

 

By the time the food was finally served, the table was crowded with dishes, mugs, bread, and enough conversation to drown out the evening birds.

They ate.

They laughed.

They argued about old adventures.

Kíli stole food from Fíli's plate.

Fíli retaliated.

Dori told them both to behave.

Dwalin complained that the chairs were too small.

Bofur began another song.

And Bilbo, instead of demanding that everyone leave immediately, kept getting up to bring more food.

At one point, Thorin fell quiet.

He looked around the table.

The same faces.

The same voices.

The same impossible collection of companions.

He remembered another dinner in this room.

A long table.

A reluctant hobbit.

A company preparing to leave the safety of the Shire for a journey none of them truly understood.

He remembered looking at Fíli and Kíli and wondering whether he could protect them.

He remembered the weight of a kingdom that existed only in his dreams.

And he remembered dying.

For a moment, his throat tightened.

Then Bilbo's hand found his beneath the table.

Thorin looked at him.

Bilbo smiled.

“Everything all right, darling?”

Thorin looked at his husband.

At Fíli laughing with Kíli.

At Balin telling a story to Ori.

At Dwalin arguing with Glóin.

At the family he had once believed lost.

He squeezed Bilbo's hand.

“Aye,” he whispered.

“Everything is exactly as it should be.”

_________________

 

The following morning, the Company discovered that Hobbiton was not prepared to be intimidated by thirteen dwarves.

They had barely finished breakfast when Mrs. Underhill appeared at the garden gate carrying a basket of pastries.

“Oh, Thorin, dear! I heard you had visitors.”

Thorin stepped outside.

“Good morning, Mrs. Underhill.”

She looked past him.

“Oh, my goodness.”

Kíli appeared behind his uncle.

“Hello!”

Mrs. Underhill smiled immediately.

“Well, aren't you a handsome young fellow!”

Kíli beamed.

“Thank you!”

Fíli appeared next.

“And who's this?”

“My brother,” Kíli replied.

“Ah. The sensible one, I imagine.”

Kíli burst out laughing.

Fíli looked offended.

Mrs. Underhill handed them the basket.

“Now, make certain everyone eats properly. Travelling is terribly exhausting.”

“Yes, ma'am,” Fíli answered automatically.

She patted his cheek.

“And you ought to smile more, young man.”

Kíli nearly fell off the doorstep.

Thorin turned away to hide his laughter.

Fíli stared after the departing hobbit.

“Did she just…?”

“Yes,” Thorin replied.

“Does she know who I am?”

“Almost certainly.”

Fíli looked bewildered.

Kíli clapped him on the shoulder.

“Welcome to the Shire, Your Majesty.”

_________________

 

Over the following days, the Company became a familiar sight in Hobbiton.

Their first visit to the market attracted considerable attention.

Not because the hobbits were frightened.

Quite the opposite.

They were curious.

Balin was immediately surrounded by several elderly hobbits who wished to discuss the history of Erebor, the age of dwarven kingdoms, and whether it was true that dwarves could remember family lineages for hundreds of years.

He answered every question with patient good humour.

By lunchtime, he had received three invitations to tea.

By the following afternoon, he had received five more.

Balin found this delightful.

Dwalin found it suspicious.

“Why do they keep feeding you?”

Balin smiled.

“Because they're hospitable.”

“They're interrogating you.”

“About history.”

“Exactly.”

Meanwhile, Kíli had somehow befriended half the market.

He helped an elderly hobbit carry her shopping.

He repaired a child's broken toy.

He complimented a baker's apple pies so enthusiastically that she gave him two for free.

And he spent nearly an hour helping a group of young hobbits construct a miniature bridge across a stream.

Fíli watched all this with increasing disbelief.

“He's been here four days.”

Thorin glanced at him.

“Yes?”

“How does everyone already know him?”

Thorin looked toward Kíli, who was laughing with a group of hobbits near the bakery.

“He has always been difficult to ignore.”

Fíli sighed.

“Apparently.”

Bilbo smiled.

“You should try relaxing, Fíli.”

“I am relaxed.”

“Of course you are.”

“Uncle Bilbo.”

“Would you like another pastry?”

Fíli hesitated.

“Yes, please.”

Bilbo patted his arm.

“Good boy.”

Kíli heard.

Naturally.

And spent the next twenty minutes calling his brother good boy whenever the opportunity presented itself.

Fíli threatened to throw him into the stream.

The nearby hobbits found this enormously entertaining.

_______________

 

Dwalin's troubles began beneath the old oak tree near the market square.

Thorin had settled upon a bench with several children gathered around him.

He was halfway through a story about the journey through Mirkwood when Dwalin approached.

“What are you doing?”

Thorin looked up.

“Resting.”

“You're telling stories.”

“Apparently.”

One little girl stared at Dwalin.

Then at his tattoos.

Then at his beard.

“Are you a warrior?”

Dwalin looked down.

“Yes.”

“Have you fought orcs?”

“Yes.”

“How many?”

Dwalin hesitated.

“Quite a few.”

The children's eyes widened.

Another child pointed at his axe.

“Is that real?”

“Of course it's real.”

“Can I hold it?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“Because it's sharp.”

The child considered this.

“Can you show us how to fight?”

Dwalin folded his arms.

“No.”

Thorin smiled.

“Come now, Dwalin. Surely a little instruction wouldn't hurt.”

Dwalin glared at him.

“Don't start.”

Twenty minutes later, Dwalin was standing in the grass holding a wooden practice sword.

Six children stood before him with sticks.

Thorin sat beneath the tree, watching with an expression of extraordinary satisfaction.

“Feet apart!” Dwalin instructed.

The children obediently spread their feet.

“Keep your balance!”

One promptly fell over.

Dwalin sighed.

Thorin laughed.

By the end of the afternoon, Dwalin had somehow acquired eight enthusiastic pupils, three requests for more lessons, and a small hobbit boy who had decided that the best place to watch the proceedings was from Dwalin's shoulders.

Thorin approached him.

“I thought you disliked children.”

“I do.”

“Then why is that one sitting on your shoulders?”

Dwalin looked upward.

“He couldn't see.”

Thorin's smile widened.

“How considerate.”

“Not a word.”

“Of course.”

The child leaned forward.

“Uncle Dwalin tells better fighting stories than you!”

Thorin stopped.

Dwalin grinned.

“Oh?”

The other children nodded enthusiastically.

Thorin stared at them.

“I beg your pardon?”

“His stories have more fighting!”

Dwalin looked insufferably pleased.

Thorin folded his arms.

“Well. I see how it is.”

From behind them came Kíli's laughter.

“Oh, this is wonderful.”

Fíli leaned against the tree, smiling.

“I believe Uncle Thorin has been replaced.”

Thorin gave them both a withering look.

The children cheered for Dwalin.

And Dwalin, despite insisting that he had absolutely no interest in becoming anyone's favourite, returned the following afternoon with several properly carved wooden practice swords.

Thorin never let him forget it.

________________

 

The days passed gently.

There were breakfasts in the garden and long walks beneath the trees.

Bombur spent an entire afternoon exchanging recipes with the local bakers.

Bofur taught several hobbits a dwarven drinking song, although Bilbo insisted that certain verses were entirely unsuitable for children.

Ori filled pages of his sketchbook with drawings of the Shire.

Nori became alarmingly successful at the market games.

Dori worried over everyone.

Glóin spoke proudly of his family and promised to bring Gimli on a future visit.

Óin examined a few medicinal herbs grown by local gardeners and was delighted by their knowledge.

Bifur repaired a damaged garden bench without being asked.

And Fíli discovered the peculiar pleasure of spending an afternoon doing absolutely nothing important.

One morning, he joined Thorin in the garden.

They worked quietly together, trimming branches and repairing a section of fencing.

For a long time, neither spoke.

Then Fíli looked toward the hill, where Hobbiton lay peaceful beneath the summer sunshine.

“I think I understand why you stayed.”

Thorin glanced at him.

“Do you?”

Fíli nodded.

“Nobody expects anything from you here.”

Thorin considered that.

“Not quite.”

Fíli smiled.

“Except repairs.”

“And gardening.”

“And storytelling.”

“And carrying heavy things.”

Fíli laughed.

Thorin set down his tools.

“They expect me to be a neighbour,” he said quietly. “A husband. A friend.”

Fíli looked at him.

“And that's enough?”

Thorin smiled.

“More than enough.”

Fíli was silent for a moment.

Then he nodded.

“I think I'd like that someday.”

Thorin rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“You will have it, if you wish.”

Fíli smiled.

“Perhaps.”

From the garden path came Bilbo's voice.

“FÍLI! THORIN! LUNCHEON!”

Both dwarves turned immediately.

Thorin chuckled.

“Come along, Your Majesty.”

Fíli shook his head.

“You're enjoying this far too much.”

“Immensely.”

______________

 

It was Balin who noticed the change most clearly.

He had known Thorin since he was a boy.

He remembered the young prince who had laughed easily before Smaug came.

He remembered the fall of Erebor, the desperate flight, and the long years of exile.

He remembered Thorin learning to carry responsibility before he was old enough to understand how heavy it could become.

And he remembered the king who had finally reclaimed his home, only to discover that victory did not erase every wound.

Now, sitting in the garden at Bag End with a cup of tea warming his hands, Balin watched Thorin kneeling beside Bilbo in the flowerbeds.

“You've planted that too close,” Bilbo informed him.

Thorin looked at the flower.

“It has plenty of room.”

“It will grow.”

“So will the others.”

“Precisely.”

Thorin sighed.

“Bilbo, I have constructed bridges capable of bearing the weight of fully loaded wagons. I believe I can manage a flower.”

Bilbo folded his arms.

“Then perhaps you should go and build a bridge, darling, and leave the flowers to me.”

Thorin laughed.

Bilbo smiled.

Then he leaned down and kissed his husband's forehead.

Thorin looked up at him with such open affection that Balin felt something tighten unexpectedly in his chest.

He remembered a much younger Thorin standing in the ruins of everything he had known.

He remembered the years when laughter had become rare.

And now here he was.

Arguing about flowers.

Smiling at his husband.

Living beneath a green hill, surrounded by people who loved him simply because he was Thorin.

Balin looked down at his tea.

His eyes had filled.

He wiped them quickly.

Unfortunately, Thorin noticed.

“Balin?”

The older dwarf looked up.

“Hmm?”

“Are you all right?”

“Perfectly.”

Thorin studied him.

Then he rose, brushed the soil from his hands, and crossed the garden.

He sat beside Balin.

“What's wrong?”

Balin smiled faintly.

“Nothing, laddie.”

“You're crying.”

“Aye.”

“Why?”

Balin looked toward Bilbo, who had resumed tending the flowers.

For a moment, he struggled to find the words.

“I remember when you were a boy,” he said at last.

Thorin grew still.

“I remember you running through the halls of Erebor, getting into trouble with your brother, and driving your grandfather half mad.”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“I wasn't that troublesome.”

Balin chuckled.

“You were worse.”

Then his expression softened.

“And I remember what happened afterward.”

Thorin looked down.

Balin continued quietly.

“I watched you lose your home. I watched you become a leader when you should still have been allowed to be young. I watched you spend years carrying burdens that would have broken lesser dwarves.”

He paused.

“And I worried, Thorin.”

Thorin looked at him.

“I worried that even if we reclaimed Erebor, you would never truly find peace.”

For a long moment, neither spoke.

Then Balin looked toward the garden.

Bilbo was scolding Kíli for stepping on the flowers.

Fíli was laughing.

Dwalin had arrived with three small hobbit children trailing after him.

Somewhere near the house, Bofur was singing.

Balin smiled through his tears.

“And now look at you.”

Thorin followed his gaze.

His husband stood beneath the sunshine, laughing as Kíli attempted to explain himself.

His nephews were alive.

His friends were safe.

And beyond the garden gate lay a village that had welcomed him without asking him to be anything more than himself.

Thorin felt his throat tighten.

Balin rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“I think this is the happiest I've ever seen you, laddie.”

Thorin looked toward Bilbo.

His smile came slowly.

“Aye,” he whispered.

“It is.”

Balin squeezed his shoulder.

For a while, they sat together without speaking.

Then Thorin reached for the teapot and refilled Balin's cup.

“More tea?”

Balin laughed softly.

“Thank you.”

And somehow, that simple kindness nearly made him cry again.

_______________

 

By the end of the second week, Hobbiton had accepted the Company as though they had always belonged there.

The children waited eagerly for Dwalin's lessons.

Balin was invited to more afternoon teas than he could reasonably attend.

Kíli had become a favourite among the market vendors, who frequently sent him home with extra pastries.

Fíli had learned that being King under the Mountain did not prevent elderly hobbits from telling him to wear a hat in the sun.

And Thorin had discovered that having his entire family nearby made even the most ordinary days feel extraordinary.

One evening, after a particularly long day of gardening, walking, and visiting neighbours, the Company gathered outside Bag End.

The summer air was warm.

Lanterns glowed along the garden path.

Bilbo had brought out blankets and cushions, and Bombur had prepared a late supper that everyone insisted they were too full to eat.

Naturally, they ate it anyway.

Bofur sang softly.

Ori sketched the stars.

Balin and Glóin spoke quietly about Erebor.

Dori had fallen asleep in a chair.

Nori was attempting to convince Bifur to help him play a harmless trick on Dwalin.

Dwalin, who had spent the afternoon teaching children how to defend themselves against imaginary orcs, was too tired to care.

Fíli sat beside Thorin, his head resting against the back of his chair.

Kíli had curled up on the grass near Bilbo's feet.

For once, the younger prince was quiet.

Bilbo looked down at him.

“Comfortable?”

Kíli nodded sleepily.

“Very.”

“You know there are chairs.”

“I like it here.”

Bilbo smiled.

He reached down and gently brushed a stray lock of hair from Kíli's forehead.

Thorin watched them.

Then he looked toward Fíli.

His elder nephew had fallen asleep.

The King under the Mountain, who spent his days managing councils and commanding armies, was sleeping peacefully in a garden chair beneath the Shire's evening sky.

Thorin smiled.

He reached for a blanket and draped it over Fíli's shoulders.

The young king stirred.

“Uncle?”

“Sleep, lad.”

Fíli's eyes closed again.

Thorin settled back.

For a moment, he remembered another night.

A campfire beneath unfamiliar stars.

His nephews sleeping nearby.

The Company gathered together before another dangerous day.

Back then, every peaceful moment had felt borrowed.

Something fragile that might be taken away without warning.

Now there was no need to wake anyone for the next watch.

No need to check the road for enemies.

No need to wonder whether morning would bring another battle.

There was only the soft sound of familiar voices, the scent of Bilbo's flowers, and the gentle warmth of a summer evening.

Bilbo slipped his hand into Thorin's.

Thorin turned toward him.

His husband smiled.

“Happy?”

Thorin looked around the garden.

At Balin laughing quietly.

At Dwalin pretending not to listen to Bofur's song.

At Fíli sleeping beside him.

At Kíli curled comfortably near Bilbo.

At every familiar face that had once gathered around this same hobbit's table before setting out into the unknown.

He squeezed Bilbo's hand.

“Very.”

Bilbo leaned against his shoulder.

“Good.”

For a while, they watched the lanterns flicker.

Then Bilbo sighed contentedly.

“You know, darling, I believe we've finally managed to have a proper unexpected party.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Proper?”

“Yes.”

“The first one was rather memorable.”

“Oh, it was memorable all right. Thirteen dwarves eating everything in my pantry, breaking into song, and terrifying me half to death.”

Thorin chuckled.

“And this one?”

Bilbo looked around.

His smile softened.

“This one feels rather more like family coming home.”

Thorin kissed his forehead.

“Aye.”

The last notes of Bofur's song drifted into the warm night.

And beneath the familiar round windows of Bag End, Thorin Oakenshield sat with his husband and the companions who had changed both their lives.

He had once believed that home was something he needed to reclaim.

A mountain.

A throne.

A kingdom of stone.

But now he understood that home could be many things.

It could be the halls of Erebor, where his nephew ruled with wisdom and courage.

It could be the garden of Bag End, where children came to hear stories and neighbours arrived with broken furniture.

It could be a crowded table, a warm fire, a familiar song.

And it could be the small hand resting comfortably within his own.

Bilbo looked up at him.

“What are you thinking about?”

Thorin smiled.

“Nothing particularly important.”

Bilbo narrowed his eyes.

“That sounds suspicious.”

Thorin laughed softly.

Then he leaned down and kissed his husband.

“Only that I am a very fortunate dwarf.”

Bilbo smiled against his lips.

“Yes,” he whispered. “I think you are.”

And as the night settled gently over Hobbiton, the laughter of their family drifted through the garden.

No one was leaving on a dangerous quest.

No one was waiting for a battle.

No one was saying goodbye.

For once, there was nowhere else they needed to be.

And Thorin, who had spent so much of his life searching for a place to belong, knew with quiet certainty that he had finally found it.

Home.

Series this work belongs to: