Actions

Work Header

The Road Back to You

Chapter 3: Chapter Three — The Road to Rivendell

Chapter Text

By the time the Company had been travelling for nearly four weeks, Bilbo Baggins had discovered several things about dwarves that no respectable hobbit had ever thought to mention.

The first was that dwarves could argue about absolutely anything.

They argued about the weather, the quality of their provisions, the proper way to sharpen an axe, and whether Bombur's cooking had improved since leaving the Shire. They argued about which road was shortest, which pony was most stubborn, and whether Kíli had deliberately put a beetle inside Nori's boot.

The second discovery was that dwarves were remarkably affectionate creatures, although they preferred to disguise this beneath insults, complaints, and occasional threats of bodily harm.

Kíli, for example, had taken to riding beside Bilbo whenever possible.

At first, the youngest prince had seemed determined to discover whether hobbits possessed any interesting secrets. He had asked whether they truly lived underground, whether they could see in the dark, and whether Bilbo had ever encountered a dragon.

Bilbo had informed him that hobbit-holes were perfectly respectable dwellings, that he could see no better in darkness than anyone else, and that dragons were not generally invited to tea.

Kíli had laughed so hard that he nearly fell from his pony.

After that, they had become friends.

Their conversations now ranged from the peculiarities of hobbit customs to Kíli's childhood in the Blue Mountains, and Bilbo had discovered that the young dwarf possessed an apparently endless collection of embarrassing stories about his elder brother.

“And then Fíli fell straight into the river,” Kíli announced one sunny afternoon, looking delighted by the memory.

“I did not fall,” Fíli corrected from ahead of them. “You pushed me.”

“I merely encouraged you to move.”

“With both hands.”

Bilbo laughed.

“And what happened afterward?”

“Mother made him apologize,” Kíli said.

Fíli turned in his saddle. “You spent the following week cleaning the stables.”

“An entirely unreasonable punishment.”

“You'd frightened three horses.”

“They were easily frightened horses.”

Bilbo shook his head, smiling.

“You sound rather like my cousins.”

Kíli brightened. “Are they handsome?”

“They are Tookish.”

“That wasn't the question.”

“In my experience, it is usually an adequate warning.”

Kíli laughed again.

__________

 

A short distance behind them, Balin watched the exchange with unmistakable fondness.

The older dwarf had grown particularly attached to their burglar over the preceding weeks. Bilbo was polite, thoughtful, and possessed a surprisingly sharp tongue when properly provoked. He also listened with genuine interest whenever Balin spoke of Erebor, asking questions about its halls, its people, and the lives they had built in exile.

More importantly, Balin had noticed something that none of the others could entirely explain.

Bilbo Baggins made Thorin happy.

Not constantly, of course. Thorin remained stubborn, proud, and occasionally as disagreeable as ever. He still argued with Dwalin about their route, issued orders with the authority of a king, and had very little patience for foolishness when danger threatened.

But he smiled more often.

And when Bilbo laughed, Thorin nearly always looked toward him.

Balin had known Thorin since he was a boy. He remembered the bright, determined prince who had once raced through Erebor's halls with his sister, before dragonfire and exile had taken so much from him.

Sometimes, watching Thorin now, Balin caught glimpses of that younger dwarf.

It warmed his heart.

It also worried him.

Because there were other moments.

Moments when Thorin watched Fíli and Kíli with an expression so full of sorrow that Balin could scarcely bear to see it.

Moments when he woke from nightmares and sat staring into the darkness until dawn.

And moments when his eyes followed Bilbo with something that looked painfully like relief.

Whatever had changed their king, Balin suspected it was not entirely a happy thing.

___________

 

That evening, they made camp beside a narrow stream.

The weather had been pleasant for several days, and the Company was in unusually good spirits. Bombur had managed to purchase fresh vegetables from a passing farmer, while Bofur had discovered a patch of wild mushrooms that Bilbo enthusiastically declared suitable for supper.

Thorin was examining their map when Bilbo approached him with a familiar wooden comb.

“Thorin?”

The dwarf looked up.

“Yes?”

“Your braid is coming loose.”

Thorin glanced at the dark hair resting over his shoulder.

“So it is.”

Bilbo frowned.

“You've been sleeping on it again.”

“I find that difficult to avoid.”

“Well, you could at least try not to make such a dreadful mess of it.”

Thorin's mouth curved.

“I shall endeavor to improve.”

Bilbo held up the comb.

“Would you like me to fix it?”

“Very much.”

Across the fire, Kíli made a peculiar choking noise.

Fíli closed his eyes.

Dwalin muttered something in Khuzdul.

Thorin ignored them all.

He moved to sit upon the ground before Bilbo, who settled comfortably on a fallen log and began loosening the old braid.

It had become something of a routine between them.

Bilbo had first offered to braid Thorin's hair during their second week on the road, after becoming thoroughly offended by the state of the dwarf's tangled locks. Since then, he had repeated the task several times, usually in the evenings when the Company had settled around the fire.

He saw nothing particularly remarkable about it.

Thorin, however, knew exactly what it meant.

Among dwarves, the tending of another's hair was a gesture of intimacy and trust. Family members braided one another's hair, as did close companions, but certain arrangements carried meanings associated with courtship and devotion.

The simple braid Bilbo favored was not itself a formal declaration.

Nevertheless, allowing someone outside one's family to tend one's hair so regularly was hardly insignificant.

Especially for a king.

Especially for Thorin Oakenshield.

And especially when the dwarf in question had spent most of his adult life refusing to allow anyone except his closest kin such familiarity.

Bilbo gently worked through a stubborn knot.

“Honestly, Thorin, I don't understand how you manage this.”

“Manage what?”

“To make such a mess of perfectly good hair.”

“I suspect the wind is responsible.”

“The wind cannot be blamed for everything.”

“An unfortunate limitation.”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin closed his eyes, allowing himself to enjoy the quiet sensation of the hobbit's fingers moving through his hair.

He remembered another life in which he had spent months yearning for such ordinary closeness, too proud and too frightened to reach for it.

Now Bilbo touched him without hesitation.

Not because he remembered loving Thorin.

Not because he owed him anything.

Simply because he cared enough to notice when his hair was tangled.

Thorin treasured that distinction.

A little distance away, Fíli watched them with growing concern.

“Uncle,” he began carefully, “might I speak with you later?”

“Of course.”

“Privately?”

Thorin opened one eye.

“If you wish.”

Kíli leaned toward his brother.

“You're going to ask him about the braids, aren't you?”

Fíli elbowed him.

Bilbo looked up.

“What about the braids?”

“Nothing,” Thorin said smoothly.

Fíli gave him a disbelieving look.

Bilbo shrugged and returned to his work.

When he finished, he secured the dark hair with a narrow leather tie and gave the braid a satisfied pat.

“There. Presentable again.”

Thorin turned toward him.

“My thanks, Bilbo.”

“You're welcome.”

For a moment, their eyes met.

Bilbo found himself noticing how handsome Thorin looked when he smiled.

It was a rather inconvenient observation.

He quickly busied himself putting away his comb.

__________

 

Later, when Thorin and Bilbo had gone to inspect the stream for a suitable place to refill their waterskins, the Company finally addressed the matter.

Dwalin was the first to speak.

“This has gone on long enough.”

Kíli looked up from his supper.

“What has?”

“Don't pretend you don't know.”

Kíli grinned.

“Oh, you mean Uncle allowing our burglar to fuss over his hair like a newlywed?”

Fíli nearly dropped his bowl.

“Kíli!”

“What? That's what it looks like.”

Óin, who had been cleaning his hearing trumpet, frowned.

“It is rather unusual.”

“Unusual?” Dwalin repeated. “I've known Thorin for decades. The last time I tried to straighten his hair before an important meeting, he threatened to break my fingers.”

“That sounds like him,” Glóin observed.

“And now he sits there every evening letting a hobbit comb it!”

Bofur smiled into his cup.

“Well, Master Baggins does seem to have a talent for it.”

Dwalin glared.

“This is not about his talent!”

Balin chuckled softly.

“Perhaps Thorin simply enjoys the company.”

Fíli shook his head.

“That's what concerns me.”

Kíli's amusement faded slightly.

“What do you mean?”

Fíli glanced toward the stream.

“He's different. Not merely with Bilbo. Haven't you noticed?”

Óin nodded.

“He sleeps poorly. I've seen him awake long after the watches have changed.”

“He checks on us constantly,” Fíli continued. “Sometimes he looks at Kíli and me as though—”

He stopped.

“As though what?” Kíli asked.

Fíli lowered his voice.

“As though he's afraid we'll disappear.”

The fire crackled quietly.

Dwalin's expression hardened.

“I've noticed.”

Óin rubbed his beard.

“I've examined him twice. No fever, no obvious injury, nothing to suggest illness. Yet he carries himself like a dwarf recovering from a terrible shock.”

“Perhaps he's worried about Erebor,” Ori suggested.

“Thorin has been worried about Erebor for years,” Dwalin replied. “That doesn't explain the rest.”

Kíli looked toward the darkness beyond the camp.

For once, he had nothing humorous to say.

Balin set down his cup.

“Whatever troubles him, I believe Master Baggins brings him comfort.”

Fíli sighed.

“I don't object to Bilbo. I like him.”

“So do I,” Kíli said immediately.

“We know,” Nori muttered. “You haven't stopped talking to him for three weeks.”

Kíli ignored him.

“But Uncle knows what those braids mean,” Fíli continued. “And Bilbo clearly doesn't.”

Balin's expression softened.

“Then perhaps we ought to trust Thorin to understand the difference.”

Dwalin grunted.

“I'd trust him more if he'd explain what in Mahal's name is going on.”

Nobody had an answer.

And when Thorin returned with Bilbo a few minutes later, the conversation ended so abruptly that even the hobbit noticed.

He looked around the fire.

“Have I interrupted something?”

“Not at all,” Balin answered pleasantly.

Dwalin stared into his supper.

Kíli began whistling.

Bilbo regarded them suspiciously.

“Dwarves,” he muttered.

Thorin heard him and smiled.

__________

 

The nightmare came two nights later.

Thorin dreamed of Ravenhill.

He dreamed of snow stained red, of Fíli hanging lifeless above the ruined courtyard, and of Kíli falling beneath an enemy's blade. He dreamed of Azog's laughter and the terrible weight of the Arkenstone in his hands.

Then he saw Bilbo.

The hobbit was kneeling beside him, crying.

But this time, when Thorin reached for him, Bilbo disappeared.

Thorin woke with a strangled gasp.

His hand shot toward his chest.

No wound.

No blood.

Only the cold night air and the quiet sounds of the sleeping Company.

He sat upright, struggling to breathe.

“Thorin?”

The voice came from nearby.

Thorin turned sharply.

Bilbo stood a few paces away, wrapped in his blanket.

“I heard you,” the hobbit said softly. “You sounded terribly distressed.”

Thorin stared at him.

Alive.

Warm.

Unharmed.

“Bilbo.”

The name escaped him with such relief that Bilbo immediately approached.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin wanted to say yes.

Instead, he reached for the hobbit's hand.

Bilbo looked surprised, but did not pull away.

Thorin held it gently, feeling the warmth of living fingers against his own.

“A dream,” he managed.

“A bad one?”

“Very.”

Bilbo sat beside him.

For a while, neither spoke.

The stars shone above the trees, and the dying fire cast a faint orange glow across the camp.

“My mother used to say that dreams are only shadows,” Bilbo murmured eventually. “They cannot hurt us once we've woken.”

Thorin looked down.

“Some shadows remain.”

Bilbo considered that.

“Perhaps. But they are easier to bear when one isn't alone.”

Thorin closed his eyes briefly.

“You are wiser than you know.”

Bilbo gave a small, embarrassed laugh.

“I wouldn't go that far.”

They remained together until Thorin's breathing settled.

Bilbo did not demand explanations.

He simply stayed.

And when he eventually returned to his blankets, Thorin watched him go with an ache that was almost unbearable.

He had loved Bilbo in one lifetime.

Now, given another chance, he was discovering that loving him again was not a choice.

It was as natural as breathing.

___________

 

The following afternoon, Thorin began teaching Bilbo to use Sting.

They had stopped beside a clearing to rest the ponies, and the weather was pleasant enough that several dwarves were practicing with their weapons.

Bilbo had been examining his little sword when Thorin approached.

“Would you like a lesson?”

Bilbo looked up.

“Now?”

“Unless you have other plans.”

“Well, I was considering a nap.”

Thorin smiled.

“Then I shall endeavor to make this brief.”

Bilbo rose reluctantly.

He had expected Thorin to be a stern instructor.

Instead, the dwarf was remarkably patient.

He showed Bilbo how to hold the blade, how to balance his weight, and how to move without losing his footing.

“Keep your shoulders relaxed,” Thorin instructed.

Bilbo attempted to follow the advice.

“Like this?”

“Almost.”

Thorin stepped closer, carefully adjusting the position of Bilbo's wrist.

Bilbo became suddenly aware of how near he was standing.

Thorin smelled faintly of leather, woodsmoke, and the clean scent of the soap Bilbo had insisted he use on his hair.

It was a distracting discovery.

“Bilbo?”

“Yes?”

“Your sword.”

“Oh! Right.”

Thorin's mouth twitched.

They continued practicing.

When Bilbo successfully parried a gentle strike, Thorin smiled with unmistakable pride.

“Well done.”

Bilbo felt absurdly pleased.

Across the clearing, Kíli watched them.

“Do you think Uncle would teach me that patiently?”

Fíli glanced over.

“He taught you to fight when you were twelve.”

“Yes, and he shouted at me for dropping my sword.”

“You dropped it on his foot.”

“An accident.”

“You were laughing.”

Kíli grinned.

“Still an accident.”

___________

 

Radagast arrived three days later.

The Company had been travelling through increasingly wild country when an extraordinary sound came from the trees.

Branches snapped.

Leaves scattered.

And a small wooden sled burst onto the road, pulled by an astonishing number of enormous rabbits.

Bilbo stared.

The driver was a peculiar-looking wizard with a tangled beard, a weather-beaten brown robe, and a hat that appeared to have survived several unfortunate encounters with birds.

Gandalf immediately stepped forward.

“Radagast!”

The brown wizard looked deeply relieved.

“Gandalf! I've been looking everywhere for you!”

Thorin felt his stomach tighten.

He remembered this meeting.

The spiders.

The sickness spreading through Mirkwood.

The dark fortress of Dol Guldur.

And the ancient evil gathering strength within it.

Radagast spoke rapidly, describing the corruption overtaking the forest, the enormous spiders moving through the trees, and the unnatural darkness he had encountered.

Bilbo listened with growing alarm.

“Giant spiders?” he repeated faintly.

Radagast nodded.

“Terrible creatures. Much larger than they ought to be.”

Thorin's hand tightened around his sword.

He remembered those spiders.

He remembered Bilbo fighting them alone.

He remembered the terror of waking bound in their webs.

Gandalf noticed his expression.

Radagast continued, speaking of Dol Guldur and the shadow that had taken residence there.

Then he produced a dark, ancient blade.

Gandalf's face grew grave.

Thorin recognized it.

The Morgul blade.

He knew what it meant.

He knew the Necromancer was no mere wandering sorcerer.

“Sauron,” he murmured.

The word escaped before he could stop it.

Gandalf turned sharply.

“What did you say?”

Thorin went still.

Radagast looked between them.

“Did he say—?”

“Nothing,” Thorin answered.

Gandalf's eyes narrowed.

“Thorin.”

“I said the name of an ancient enemy.”

“And why would that name come to your mind?”

Thorin looked toward the blade.

“Because there are few powers in Middle-earth capable of such darkness.”

It was a reasonable answer.

Not a particularly convincing one.

Gandalf studied him for several moments before turning back to Radagast.

Bilbo, standing nearby, noticed the exchange.

He also noticed the way Thorin's face had gone pale.

Quietly, he stepped closer.

“Are you all right?”

Thorin looked down at him.

“Yes.”

Bilbo did not seem entirely convinced.

But before he could ask anything further, a distant howl echoed through the hills.

Thorin's blood ran cold.

Wargs.

The attack came sooner than Thorin expected.

A scout appeared upon a distant ridge, mounted upon a great grey wolf. Another followed, then a third.

The Company gathered their weapons.

Dwalin swore.

“Orcs!”

Thorin drew his sword.

He remembered the chase.

He remembered Radagast drawing the hunters away while Gandalf led them toward Rivendell.

But the road was different now.

Their earlier changes had brought them farther north, where the hills were steeper and the rocky passages less familiar.

Thorin looked toward Gandalf.

“Can you lead us to safety?”

The wizard nodded.

“There is a hidden valley not far from here.”

“Then we must move.”

Radagast climbed onto his sled.

“I can distract them!”

Gandalf hesitated.

“Radagast—”

“I've done it before!”

The brown wizard snapped his reins.

His rabbits surged forward.

Within moments, the sled was racing across the hills, with the orc scouts turning in pursuit.

__________

 

The Company ran.

Bilbo struggled to keep pace over the uneven ground, his shorter legs carrying him as quickly as possible.

Thorin remained near him.

“Keep moving!”

“I am moving!”

A warg howled behind them.

Thorin turned.

One of the hunters had broken away from Radagast's distraction and was racing toward the Company.

“Down!”

He caught Bilbo by the shoulder and pulled him aside just as the creature leapt.

Its jaws snapped shut where the hobbit's head had been.

Thorin struck with Orcrist.

The blade flashed.

The warg fell.

Bilbo stumbled backward, breathing hard.

For one terrible moment, Thorin saw Ravenhill again.

Blood.

Snow.

Bilbo crying.

He seized the hobbit's shoulders.

“Are you hurt?”

“No!”

“Are you certain?”

“Yes, Thorin!”

The dwarf's grip tightened briefly.

Bilbo looked up at him.

“I'm all right,” he said more gently.

Thorin forced himself to release him.

“I know.”

But his voice shook.

Fíli appeared beside them.

“Uncle! We have to go!”

Thorin nodded.

They ran.

Ahead, Gandalf led the Company between towering rocks toward a narrow passage concealed by hanging branches.

More wargs appeared upon the ridge.

Dwalin and Glóin turned to defend the rear.

Thorin joined them, his sword flashing as the creatures closed in.

Then a horn sounded.

Not an orc horn.

An elven horn.

Mounted warriors swept across the hillside, their armor gleaming beneath the afternoon sun.

At their head rode Elrond of Rivendell.

The elves charged the hunters, driving them away from the narrow passage.

Thorin stood motionless for a heartbeat.

In his first life, he had resented their arrival.

Now he felt nothing but relief.

His Company was alive.

Bilbo was alive.

And help had come.

“Thorin!” Gandalf called.

The dwarf turned.

“Into the passage!”

He obeyed without argument.

Dwalin stared at him as though he had lost his mind.

But there was no time to question it.

__________

 

The Company hurried through the hidden entrance, following Gandalf into the sheltered valley beyond.

Rivendell was more beautiful than Bilbo had imagined.

Waterfalls tumbled down distant cliffs, their silver streams catching the sunlight. Elegant bridges crossed clear rivers, and pale buildings rose among trees whose leaves whispered in the gentle breeze.

The air smelled of flowers and fresh water.

Bilbo stopped walking.

“Oh,” he breathed.

Thorin, beside him, watched his expression.

He remembered how much Bilbo had loved this place.

He remembered the hobbit lingering over books, admiring the gardens, and speaking with quiet wonder about the beauty of elven craftsmanship.

In his first life, Thorin had been too consumed by resentment to appreciate any of it.

Now he found himself looking at Rivendell through Bilbo's eyes.

“It is beautiful,” the hobbit whispered.

“Yes,” Thorin answered.

Bilbo glanced at him in surprise.

“You think so?”

Thorin smiled faintly.

“I am capable of appreciating beauty, Master Baggins.”

Bilbo flushed.

“I didn't mean—”

“I know.”

They walked a little farther.

Then Thorin spoke again.

“There are beautiful places in Erebor as well.”

Bilbo looked up.

“Are there?”

“Great halls carved from living stone. Underground rivers. Gardens built beneath openings where sunlight reaches deep into the mountain.”

Bilbo's eyes brightened.

“Gardens?”

Thorin nodded.

“My people once grew flowers and herbs in sheltered courtyards. There were trees too, brought from distant lands.”

Bilbo smiled.

“I should like to see that.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Then I shall show you.”

The promise came so naturally that Bilbo scarcely noticed its significance.

But Thorin felt the weight of it.

He had once promised Bilbo a future and died before he could give it to him.

This time, he intended to keep his word.

__________

 

Elrond welcomed them in the courtyard.

His expression was courteous, though his eyes lingered upon Thorin with unmistakable curiosity.

“Thorin Oakenshield.”

“Lord Elrond.”

The dwarf inclined his head.

It was a small gesture.

But for those who knew Thorin, it was astonishing.

Dwalin looked as though he might choke.

Gandalf smiled.

Elrond's eyebrows rose slightly.

“You are welcome in Rivendell.”

“We are grateful for your assistance,” Thorin replied.

The silence that followed was remarkable.

Kíli slowly turned toward Fíli.

“Did he just thank an elf?”

Fíli closed his eyes.

“Yes.”

“Voluntarily?”

“Yes.”

Kíli looked deeply troubled.

“I think we need Óin.”

Elrond, meanwhile, had noticed something else.

Thorin's dark hair was neatly braided, the arrangement simple but carefully maintained.

There was nothing unusual about a dwarf wearing braids.

What interested Elrond was the way Bilbo reached up without hesitation to straighten a loose strand near Thorin's shoulder.

And the way Thorin immediately lowered his head to make the task easier.

Elrond's gaze moved between them.

Understanding flickered across his face.

Gandalf noticed.

The wizard's mouth twitched.

Thorin noticed that too.

For the first time since leaving the Shire, he felt genuinely embarrassed.

Bilbo, entirely unaware, finished adjusting the braid.

“There,” he murmured. “Much better.”

Thorin cleared his throat.

“Thank you.”

Elrond's expression remained perfectly composed.

“Shall we go inside?”

Thorin nodded.

“Of course.”

Behind them, Kíli leaned toward Balin.

“Do elves know what braids mean?”

Balin smiled.

“Some of them.”

Kíli looked toward Elrond.

“Oh.”

Fíli sighed.

“Oh, indeed.”

__________

That evening, the Company was shown to comfortable rooms overlooking the gardens.

Bilbo had scarcely finished admiring the carved furniture and soft bedding when he discovered that Thorin's room was only a short distance down the corridor.

For reasons he did not care to examine, he found this rather pleasing.

He told himself it was simply because Thorin was familiar.

The dwarf had become a comforting presence during their weeks on the road, someone Bilbo could rely upon when the world became too large, too dangerous, or too strange.

There was nothing unusual about wanting a familiar face nearby.

Nothing at all.

Outside, the evening bells of Rivendell rang softly through the valley.

Thorin stood upon the balcony of his room, looking toward the distant mountains.

He had survived the trolls.

He had brought his Company safely through the warg chase.

He had accepted Elrond's help without allowing old bitterness to guide him.

And Bilbo was sleeping only a few doors away.

Yet the future remained uncertain.

Azog still hunted them.

Smaug still waited beneath the Lonely Mountain.

And somewhere in the darkness, Sauron was gathering his strength.

Thorin rested his hands upon the stone railing.

He had changed much already.

But he had not changed enough.

Not yet.

Behind him, a quiet knock sounded.

Thorin turned.

“Come in.”

The door opened.

Bilbo stood there, holding a small wooden comb.

Thorin stared.

The hobbit smiled sheepishly.

“I noticed your braid was coming loose again.”

For a moment, Thorin could only look at him.

Then he smiled.

“Would you care to fix it?”

Bilbo's expression brightened.

“Of course.”

Thorin stepped aside to let him enter.

And as the door closed behind them, the King under the Mountain found himself thinking that perhaps the future was not something he needed to conquer.

Perhaps it was something he needed to build.

One quiet moment at a time.