Chapter Text
The Misty Mountains were considerably less beautiful when one was expected to climb them.
Bilbo Baggins reached this conclusion on the fourth morning after leaving Rivendell, when he awoke to discover that the pleasant chill of the previous evening had transformed into a cold so thoroughly unpleasant that even the tips of his ears seemed to ache. His blankets were damp with dew, his boots had acquired a distressing amount of mud, and the small stone that had somehow found its way beneath his sleeping mat had left him with an ache between his shoulders.
He missed his bed.
He missed his fireplace.
Most particularly, he missed waking to the comforting knowledge that the greatest difficulty awaiting him was deciding whether to have mushrooms or eggs for breakfast.
The mountains rose around them in endless ridges of grey stone, their upper reaches concealed behind thick clouds. Narrow paths wound along steep slopes, sometimes disappearing beneath loose rocks or crossing streams fed by melting snow. The air grew thinner with every passing day, and the wind possessed a remarkable talent for finding its way beneath even the most carefully fastened clothing.
Bilbo had never been particularly fond of heights. He was discovering that he liked them even less when accompanied by the possibility of falling several hundred feet.
“Careful there, Master Baggins.”
Bofur's cheerful voice came from behind him as Bilbo negotiated a particularly unpleasant stretch of loose stones.
“I am being careful,” Bilbo replied, gripping his walking stick.
“Of course you are. Just thought I'd mention it.”
“Very thoughtful.”
“Wouldn't want you rolling all the way back to Rivendell.”
Bilbo stopped and looked over his shoulder. “Do you suppose they'd let me keep my room?”
Bofur laughed. “Aye, probably. Though I imagine they'd charge you for the damage.”
“What damage?”
“The hole you'd make coming through the roof.”
Despite himself, Bilbo smiled.
Ahead of them, Kíli was attempting to persuade Fíli that the clouds gathering above the eastern peaks were perfectly harmless.
“They're only clouds.”
“They're storm clouds,” Fíli corrected.
“Clouds nonetheless.”
“Very observant.”
“I've always thought so.”
Fíli sighed and returned his attention to the path.
Thorin travelled near the front with Dwalin, studying the mountain slopes with an intensity that had become familiar to the Company.
He remembered these mountains.
Not every turn of the path, nor every sheltered hollow where they had made camp, but enough.
He remembered the storm, the giants, and the cave that had promised safety before delivering them into the hands of goblins. He remembered the Great Goblin's laughter, Azog's name spoken in those foul underground halls, and the desperate flight across bridges that seemed determined to collapse beneath their feet.
And he remembered Bilbo disappearing.
That last memory troubled him more than he cared to admit.
In his first life, he had not known where the hobbit had gone. He had been angry, exhausted, and far too quick to assume the worst. Only afterward had Bilbo returned, emerging from the trees with that familiar expression of bewildered determination.
Thorin had spent many nights since his awakening thinking about that moment.
He would not make the same mistake again.
But he was beginning to understand that remembering an event and knowing how to prevent it were two very different things.
“Thorin.”
Dwalin's voice drew him from his thoughts.
“What?”
“The western path looks clearer.”
Thorin examined the narrow trail cutting across the slope. In his memory, they had travelled farther east before the storm overtook them. He had hoped to avoid that route entirely.
“Fíli,” he called.
His nephew immediately approached. “Yes, Uncle?”
“Come here. Tell me what you make of these paths.”
Fíli looked surprised, but joined him. Together, they studied the mountainside.
“The western trail is shorter,” Fíli said after a moment, “but it looks exposed. If the weather turns, we'll have nowhere to shelter.”
“And the eastern?”
“Longer. There are more places where we might find cover, but the rock looks unstable.”
Thorin nodded. “Which would you choose?”
Fíli considered carefully.
“The eastern route, provided we move before the rain begins.”
Dwalin glanced toward Thorin.
The king studied the clouds for another moment.
“Agreed.”
Fíli blinked. “Agreed?”
“You've judged the risks correctly. Take the lead with Dwalin.”
His nephew straightened.
“Of course.”
As Fíli hurried forward, Kíli leaned toward him.
“Careful, brother. At this rate, Uncle will have you organizing the entire kingdom before we've even reached it.”
Fíli gave him a patient look.
“Someone will have to organize you.”
“An impossible task.”
“I'm aware.”
Their laughter carried faintly through the cold air.
Thorin watched them go.
Dwalin remained beside him.
“You've been giving the lad more responsibility.”
“He is capable of it.”
“Aye. He is.”
Thorin looked toward Fíli, who was already discussing the route with Nori.
“He will make a fine king.”
Dwalin's expression softened.
“That he will.”
Neither spoke for a while.
Then Dwalin added, “You might tell him that more often.”
Thorin glanced at him.
“I have.”
The older warrior looked faintly surprised.
Then he smiled beneath his beard.
“Good.”
___________
By the time evening arrived, the Company had found shelter beneath a broad overhang of stone.
It was hardly comfortable, but the rock offered some protection from the wind, and Bombur managed to prepare a respectable supper over a small fire.
Bilbo ate two servings of stew and half a loaf of bread before announcing that he could not possibly eat another bite.
Five minutes later, he accepted a piece of cheese from Balin.
Kíli watched him with amusement.
“I thought you were full.”
“I am.”
“Then why are you eating?”
“Because it would be terribly wasteful not to.”
Balin chuckled.
“A sensible philosophy.”
The temperature dropped sharply after sunset.
Bilbo wrapped himself in his cloak, pulled his blanket around his shoulders, and settled near the fire with the firm intention of remaining there until morning.
Unfortunately, the wind seemed determined to make that impossible.
He had just begun contemplating whether sleeping inside his pack might provide additional warmth when he noticed a second blanket folded beside him.
Bilbo frowned.
He recognized it.
Thorin's.
The dwarf was sitting several feet away, speaking quietly with Balin while wearing only his heavy travelling cloak.
Bilbo looked from the blanket to Thorin.
Then back again.
“Oh, absolutely not.”
Kíli, who was cleaning his bow nearby, looked up.
“What?”
Bilbo snatched the blanket and marched across the small camp.
“Thorin Oakenshield.”
Thorin turned.
The use of his full name was sufficiently alarming to attract Dwalin's attention.
“Bilbo?”
“Did you give me your blanket?”
Thorin glanced at the object in his hands.
“You looked cold.”
“I am cold. We are in the mountains.”
“Precisely.”
“And what, may I ask, do you intend to sleep beneath?”
“My cloak.”
Bilbo stared at him.
Thorin maintained a perfectly reasonable expression.
It was infuriating.
“You cannot possibly think that's sensible.”
“I have endured colder nights.”
“That is not an answer.”
Balin suddenly became very interested in his tea.
Thorin looked faintly amused.
“Bilbo, I assure you—”
“No. You may assure me of whatever you like after you've stopped behaving like a complete fool.”
Kíli made a choking noise.
Fíli covered his mouth.
Dwalin looked as though someone had just challenged the foundations of the universe.
Thorin, however, merely raised an eyebrow.
“A fool?”
“A very noble fool, perhaps, but a fool nonetheless.”
Bilbo sat beside him and unfolded the blanket.
“There. We'll share them.”
Thorin went still.
“We?”
“Yes, we. Unless you have some objection to being warm.”
Thorin looked at the hobbit.
Bilbo looked back with an expression that suggested he was prepared to argue for the remainder of the evening.
Thorin knew when he had lost.
“None whatsoever.”
“Good.”
Bilbo arranged the blankets across both their shoulders and settled comfortably beside him.
For several moments, Thorin could only stare into the fire.
In another life, he had died wishing for the chance to hold Bilbo once more.
Now the hobbit was sitting against his side, complaining about the cold and entirely unaware of what he was doing to Thorin's heart.
It seemed almost unfair.
Across the fire, Kíli leaned toward Fíli.
“Do you think—”
“No,” Fíli whispered.
“But—”
“Leave them alone.”
Kíli considered this.
Then he smiled and returned to cleaning his bow.
___________
Beside Thorin, Bilbo tucked the blankets more securely around them.
“You really ought to take better care of yourself.”
Thorin glanced down.
“I could say the same of you.”
“I take excellent care of myself.”
“You nearly walked off a ledge this morning.”
“I slipped.”
“Toward a ledge.”
“A small one.”
“A considerable one.”
Bilbo gave him an indignant look.
Thorin smiled.
Eventually, the conversation faded into comfortable silence.
Bilbo watched the flames, listening to the wind sigh through the rocks.
After a while, he asked, “Do you miss your family?”
Thorin looked toward him.
“Very much.”
“Your sister?”
“Yes.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“I was thinking about what you told me in Rivendell. About her and your brother.”
Thorin's expression softened.
“Dís would like you.”
“You said that before.”
“And I meant it.”
Bilbo hesitated.
“Do you think she'll be waiting in Erebor when we arrive?”
“No. She remains with our people in the Blue Mountains.”
“Oh.”
Thorin watched a spark rise from the fire.
“But if we succeed, I intend to send for her.”
Bilbo nodded.
“I hope you do.”
Thorin looked at him.
“And perhaps, one day, you might meet her.”
Bilbo smiled.
“I should like that.”
Thorin returned his gaze to the flames before the hobbit could see how much those simple words meant to him.
Later, when Bilbo's head grew heavy and settled against his shoulder, Thorin remained perfectly still.
He did not sleep for a long time.
But for once, his wakefulness was not entirely unpleasant.
___________
The storm arrived two days later.
At first, it seemed little more than another gathering of clouds.
The morning had been cold and grey, with a sharp wind descending from the higher peaks. By midday, the sky had darkened considerably, and the first drops of rain began striking the stones around them.
Thorin looked upward.
A familiar dread settled in his stomach.
“We need shelter.”
Dwalin followed his gaze.
“The next ridge might offer some.”
“Then we move quickly.”
Fíli immediately began organizing the Company.
He sent Nori and Bofur ahead to examine the path while instructing Kíli to remain near Bombur, whose pony had become increasingly nervous.
Thorin watched his nephew with quiet approval.
Then thunder rolled across the mountains.
The sound was enormous.
It seemed to shake the very stone beneath their feet.
Bilbo flinched.
“Good heavens.”
A flash of lightning illuminated the distant peaks.
For one brief instant, Thorin saw something move against the mountainside.
Something far too large to be an ordinary creature.
His blood turned cold.
“Dwalin!”
The warrior turned.
“Get everyone away from the cliff!”
Another tremendous crack echoed through the valley.
A vast shape shifted among the rocks.
Bilbo stared.
At first, his mind refused to understand what he was seeing.
Then an enormous arm rose from the mountainside.
Stone moved against stone.
A face emerged from the cliff, its features formed from jagged rock and ancient earth.
The mountain itself appeared to stand.
“Oh,” Bilbo whispered.
A second giant rose opposite the first.
And then the world erupted.
A colossal boulder flew across the ravine, striking the mountainside with a deafening crash. Rock shattered, sending fragments tumbling toward the narrow path.
“MOVE!” Thorin roared.
The Company scattered.
Dwalin seized Ori by the collar and dragged him beneath an overhang. Fíli shouted instructions while Kíli helped Bombur control the terrified ponies.
Bilbo stumbled backward as a shower of stones struck the ground beside him.
Thorin caught his arm.
“This way!”
They ran.
The path trembled beneath their feet.
Above them, the giants fought with terrible, ancient fury, tearing enormous pieces from the mountains and hurling them at one another.
Lightning flashed across their immense bodies.
The thunder of their blows drowned out every other sound.
Thorin remembered this.
He remembered the ledges breaking apart, the Company separated upon moving stone, and Bilbo hanging over a terrible drop.
He had chosen a different path.
Yet here they were.
“Fíli!” he shouted.
His nephew turned from farther ahead.
“Get everyone beneath that ridge!”
Fíli nodded and began directing the others.
Thorin kept Bilbo close.
They had almost reached the shelter when the ground lurched.
A tremendous impact struck the mountainside above them.
The narrow ledge cracked.
Bilbo lost his footing.
For one horrible instant, his boots slipped across the wet stone and there was nothing beneath him but empty air.
“THORIN!”
Thorin moved before he had time to think.
He threw himself forward, caught Bilbo's wrist, and dropped to one knee as the hobbit's weight pulled against him.
Bilbo struck the cliff face with a gasp.
His walking stick vanished into the darkness below.
Thorin tightened his grip.
“Hold on!”
Bilbo's free hand scrabbled against the rock.
“I am trying!”
Another tremor shook the ledge.
Thorin's boots slid.
For a heartbeat, the world seemed to narrow to Bilbo's frightened face.
He remembered blood upon snow.
A trembling hand against his cheek.
A voice begging him not to leave.
Not again.
“Dwalin!”
The warrior was already moving.
He dropped beside Thorin, seized the back of his coat, and braced himself against the rock.
“Pull!”
Together, they dragged Bilbo onto the ledge.
The hobbit collapsed against Thorin, shaking violently.
Thorin wrapped both arms around him.
For several seconds, he could do nothing else.
Bilbo clutched his coat.
“I'm all right,” he gasped.
Thorin barely heard him.
“I'm all right,” Bilbo repeated, a little more firmly.
Thorin pulled back just enough to look at him.
His face was pale beneath the rain.
There was a scrape upon his cheek, but he was breathing.
Alive.
Thorin pressed a trembling hand against the back of his head.
“Stay close to me.”
Bilbo nodded.
“I will.”
Dwalin glanced between them.
Whatever he saw upon Thorin's face made him say nothing.
Instead, he hauled Bilbo upright.
“We need to move.”
Thorin forced himself to release the hobbit.
Together, they ran.
___________
By the time the Company found shelter, they were soaked, exhausted, and thoroughly miserable.
The cave lay within a narrow opening between two cliffs, its entrance partially concealed by fallen stones.
Dwalin inspected it first.
“Looks clear.”
Thorin stood outside, staring into the darkness.
He remembered a cave.
He remembered believing it safe.
And he remembered waking beneath the mountain with goblins surrounding them.
“Wait.”
Fíli turned.
“Uncle?”
Thorin stepped inside.
The cave was broad and dry, its walls smooth in places and rough in others. A shallow depression near the rear offered enough space for the Company to settle.
It was not precisely as he remembered.
Or perhaps his memories had blurred.
He examined the floor.
Nothing seemed unusual.
“Thorin?” Gandalf asked.
The wizard stood near the entrance, watching him.
“Something troubles you.”
Thorin looked toward the dark recesses of the cave.
“We should keep a watch.”
“Of course.”
“A proper watch. No one is to sleep without someone awake.”
Dwalin frowned.
“We always keep watch.”
“Then tonight we shall be particularly careful.”
Gandalf studied him.
“Do you expect trouble?”
Thorin hesitated.
“Yes.”
The wizard's eyes narrowed slightly.
“What kind?”
Thorin looked toward the Company.
Bilbo was sitting beside Balin while Óin examined the scrape upon his cheek. Kíli had begun wringing water from his sleeves, and Bombur was complaining that his boots would never dry.
They were tired.
They needed rest.
And Thorin could not explain why a cave that appeared perfectly ordinary filled him with dread.
“Goblin territory,” he said at last. “We are too near their tunnels.”
Gandalf's expression became grave.
“A reasonable concern.”
He glanced toward the cave floor.
“Very well. We shall be cautious.”
Thorin nodded.
But caution had not saved them before.
The Company settled as comfortably as circumstances allowed.
Bombur managed to prepare a small meal, though he complained bitterly about the absence of proper firewood. Wet cloaks were spread across the rocks, and the dwarves huddled beneath their blankets while the storm continued outside.
Bilbo sat near the wall, allowing Óin to inspect his scraped cheek.
“Nothing serious,” the healer declared.
“I told you.”
“You also told me you weren't cold yesterday.”
“That was entirely different.”
Óin chuckled and handed him a clean cloth.
“Keep it clean.”
Bilbo nodded.
When the healer moved away, he noticed Thorin standing near the entrance.
The dwarf had scarcely sat down since they arrived.
He kept looking toward the darkness beyond the cave, one hand resting upon the hilt of Orcrist.
Bilbo watched him for a while.
Then he rose and approached.
“Thorin?”
The dwarf turned immediately.
“Bilbo. Is your cheek troubling you?”
“No.”
“Your wrist?”
“A little, but Óin says it's only bruised.”
Thorin looked at his hand.
Bilbo noticed the concern.
“I'm quite all right.”
Thorin nodded.
Yet his expression remained tense.
Bilbo hesitated.
“You know, you're allowed to rest.”
“I shall.”
“When?”
“Soon.”
Bilbo folded his arms.
“That sounds suspiciously like something someone says when they have no intention of resting.”
Thorin almost smiled.
“Does it?”
“Yes.”
Bilbo glanced toward the cave.
“Dwalin and Fíli are perfectly capable of keeping watch.”
“I know.”
“Then let them.”
Thorin looked at him.
Bilbo's expression softened.
“You can't protect everyone every moment of the day.”
The words struck harder than Bilbo intended.
Thorin looked away.
He had tried.
In another life, he had failed.
And now, even with the future laid before him like a map, he could not prevent every danger.
“I know,” he answered quietly.
Bilbo stepped closer.
“Then perhaps you ought to trust us a little.”
Thorin looked down at him.
There was no accusation in the hobbit's voice.
Only concern.
“I do trust you.”
Bilbo smiled.
“Good. Then come and sit down before you fall over.”
Thorin allowed himself to be guided toward the others.
He sat beside Bilbo, accepted a cup of warm broth from Balin, and made a genuine effort to appear less troubled.
It did not entirely work.
But when Bilbo leaned against his shoulder a little later, Thorin finally closed his eyes.
For a few precious minutes, he rested.
__________
Bilbo awoke sometime after midnight.
The fire had burned low.
Most of the Company slept beneath their blankets, their breathing mingling with the distant sound of rain.
Dwalin stood near the entrance, his axe resting against his shoulder.
Bofur was awake as well, sitting beside the dying fire and examining a small wooden carving.
Bilbo sat up carefully.
His wrist ached.
He looked toward Thorin.
The dwarf was sleeping nearby, though even in rest his expression remained troubled.
Bilbo watched him for a moment.
Then he quietly rose.
He had been thinking about leaving.
Not because he disliked the Company.
Quite the opposite.
That was what made the thought so difficult.
He had grown fond of Kíli's laughter, Fíli's steady kindness, Balin's stories, and Bofur's cheerful nonsense. Even Dwalin, who sometimes looked at him as though he were an especially inconvenient piece of luggage, had begun treating him with something approaching respect.
And Thorin—
Bilbo looked back at the sleeping dwarf.
Thorin had been nothing but patient with him.
He had taught him how to use Sting, listened to his stories, and treated him as though his presence mattered.
Yet Bilbo could not forget the feeling of slipping over that ledge.
Or the terror upon Thorin's face when he had pulled him to safety.
He was slowing them down.
Putting them at risk.
Perhaps the kindest thing he could do was leave before someone was hurt trying to protect him.
Bilbo moved quietly toward his pack.
“Going somewhere?”
He froze.
Bofur looked up from his carving.
Bilbo sighed.
“Couldn't sleep.”
“Aye. Happens to the best of us.”
The dwarf watched him for a moment.
Then his gaze drifted toward the pack.
“Thinking of heading home?”
Bilbo looked down.
“I don't know.”
Bofur set aside the carving.
“Nothing wrong with missing home.”
Bilbo sat beside him.
“I do miss it.”
“I imagine you do.”
“My garden must be a dreadful mess by now. And I left several books unfinished.”
Bofur smiled.
“Terrible tragedy.”
Bilbo gave a weak laugh.
Then his expression became serious.
“I don't think I'm much use to you.”
Bofur frowned.
“What makes you say that?”
“Today, Thorin nearly fell trying to save me.”
“He did save you.”
“But he might have died.”
Bofur studied him.
“Bilbo, we've all needed saving at one time or another.”
“Yes, but—”
“No buts. You helped us with those trolls, didn't you? And you've kept up with us through country no respectable hobbit ought to be walking.”
Bilbo looked unconvinced.
Bofur's expression softened.
“Look, lad. If you want to go home, no one has the right to stop you. You've a good life waiting there, and there's no shame in wanting it back.”
Bilbo stared into the embers.
“But don't go because you think you're a burden.”
The words settled heavily between them.
Bofur glanced toward Thorin.
“And for what it's worth, I think our king would be rather miserable without you.”
Bilbo looked up.
“Would he?”
Bofur smiled faintly.
“Aye. I believe he would.”
Bilbo's cheeks warmed.
He looked away.
“I hadn't really thought—”
A faint scraping sound interrupted him.
Both turned.
Somewhere beneath the cave, stone shifted against stone.
Bofur frowned.
“Did you hear that?”
Bilbo nodded.
Then the floor moved.
A sharp crack split the silence.
Before either could stand, the stone beneath the sleeping Company broke apart.
Bilbo shouted.
The cave collapsed into darkness.
___________
Thorin awoke to the sound of screaming.
For one terrible instant, he did not know where he was.
Then the floor vanished beneath him.
He fell amid a chaos of broken stone, blankets, and shouting dwarves.
Something struck his shoulder.
He twisted, reached for a handhold, and found only empty air.
The fall ended with a violent impact upon a wooden platform.
Thorin rolled, instinctively reaching for Orcrist.
A harsh voice shrieked from the darkness.
“Get them!”
Goblins poured from every direction.
They were small, twisted creatures with pale skin and sharp teeth, armed with crude blades and hooked spears.
Thorin drew his sword.
“COMPANY! TO ME!”
Fíli appeared beside him, already fighting.
Kíli struggled to free himself from beneath a broken plank.
Dwalin swung his axe, sending two goblins sprawling.
For a moment, Thorin believed they might break through.
Then dozens more emerged from the tunnels.
A net dropped over Nori and Ori.
Another caught Bombur.
Goblin spears pressed against their throats.
Thorin fought until a heavy blow struck his injured shoulder and drove him to one knee.
Several creatures seized his arms.
Orcrist was torn from his grasp.
He snarled and struggled, but there were too many.
“Uncle!”
Fíli tried to reach him.
A goblin struck the young dwarf from behind.
Thorin's heart lurched.
“FÍLI!”
His nephew fell, then immediately struggled upright.
Alive.
Thorin forced himself to breathe.
The goblins bound their wrists and dragged them toward the deeper tunnels.
Thorin searched desperately among the captives.
Dwalin.
Balin.
Fíli.
Kíli.
Bombur.
Bofur.
Ori.
Nori.
Glóin.
Óin.
Dori.
Bifur.
Bilbo.
He found the hobbit near Bofur, pale and frightened but apparently uninjured.
Relief washed through him.
Bilbo caught his eye.
Thorin gave him a small nod.
Stay calm.
Bilbo swallowed and nodded back.
Then the goblins forced them onward.
Gandalf was nowhere among the prisoners. Thorin had seen the wizard standing near the cave entrance when the floor gave way, and could only hope that he had managed to escape the trap.
Goblin-town was every bit as foul as Thorin remembered.
The tunnels opened into a vast underground cavern filled with rickety wooden bridges, platforms, and crooked stairways. Fires burned in iron baskets, casting an ugly orange light across the stone.
Hundreds of goblins crowded the walkways.
Their shrill voices echoed through the cavern as the prisoners were dragged toward a broad platform.
Upon it sat the Great Goblin.
Thorin remembered him immediately.
The creature was enormous, pale, and grotesque, his heavy body sprawled upon a crude throne.
“Well, well,” he crooned. “What have we here?”
The goblins shoved the Company forward.
“Dwarves!” one shrieked.
“Thirteen of them!”
“And a little one!”
The Great Goblin leaned forward.
His eyes settled upon Bilbo.
“What is that?”
“A hobbit,” Bilbo answered before anyone else could speak.
The creature blinked.
“A what?”
“A hobbit.”
“How peculiar.”
Thorin moved slightly in front of Bilbo.
The Great Goblin noticed.
“Oh? And who might you be?”
Before Thorin could answer, a goblin rushed forward carrying Orcrist.
“Look what we found!”
The moment the Great Goblin saw the blade, his expression changed.
He recoiled.
“The Biter!”
A frightened murmur spread through the crowd.
Thorin stood straighter.
The Great Goblin's eyes narrowed.
“That sword belonged to the enemies of our kind.”
His gaze returned to Thorin.
“Who are you?”
Thorin lifted his chin.
“Thorin, son of Thráin.”
The cavern seemed to fall silent.
Then the Great Goblin smiled.
“Thorin Oakenshield.”
The name passed through the surrounding goblins like a whisper.
The creature leaned back upon his throne.
“Oh, this is wonderful.”
Thorin remained still.
He knew what was coming.
“The Pale Orc will be very pleased.”
Kíli stiffened.
Fíli looked toward his uncle.
Thorin's jaw tightened.
“Azog,” he said.
The Great Goblin laughed.
“So you know he's alive!”
Thorin said nothing.
He remembered Azog standing upon Ravenhill.
Remembered the blade that had pierced him.
Remembered the blood spreading across the snow.
The Great Goblin grinned.
“He'll pay handsomely for your head.”
Dwalin struggled against his captors.
“Come and take it, then!”
Several goblins struck him with their spears.
Thorin's expression darkened.
“Touch another member of my Company,” he said coldly, “and you will regret it.”
The Great Goblin laughed so loudly that his enormous stomach shook.
“Such a proud little king!”
He leaned forward.
“Let's see how proud you are when Azog arrives.”
Thorin looked toward his nephews.
Fíli met his gaze.
The young dwarf's expression was steady.
Kíli stood beside him, frightened but determined.
Thorin forced himself to remain calm.
He knew Gandalf would come.
He remembered the wizard's arrival, the sudden light, and the chaos that followed.
He only needed to keep everyone alive until then.
But remembering the future had already failed to keep them from Goblin-town.
And Thorin could not entirely silence the fear that Gandalf might not arrive this time.
The Great Goblin lifted one thick hand.
“Take their weapons. Search them. And if any of them cause trouble—”
A brilliant white light erupted across the cavern.
The goblins screamed.
A thunderous crack shook the platform.
Thorin threw himself forward as the nearest guards stumbled.
Gandalf stood upon a distant walkway, his staff blazing.
“Thorin!”
The dwarf's heart leapt.
“Gandalf!”
The wizard raised his staff again.
“RUN!”
The escape became a blur of shouting, steel, and splintering wood.
Thorin recovered Orcrist from a fallen goblin and immediately began cutting a path toward the nearest bridge.
“Fíli! Kíli! With me!”
His nephews followed.
Dwalin seized a discarded weapon and drove the goblins back while Balin helped Ori and Nori scramble onto the walkway.
Gandalf moved at the rear, his staff flashing whenever the pursuing creatures drew too close.
The bridges swayed beneath their feet.
Wooden planks broke apart.
Arrows struck the railings.
Thorin remembered this desperate flight.
He remembered the collapsing platforms and the Great Goblin's furious pursuit.
But he also remembered something else.
Bilbo disappearing.
He looked back.
The hobbit was running beside Bofur, clutching Sting in one hand.
“Bilbo!”
Bilbo turned.
“I'm here!”
“Stay close!”
“I am!”
A goblin lunged from a side passage.
Bilbo stumbled backward, raising Sting.
Before the creature could strike, Bofur swung his pickaxe and knocked it from the walkway.
“Keep moving, lad!”
They ran.
Ahead, Fíli and Kíli were fighting their way across a narrow bridge.
Thorin followed, keeping one eye upon Bilbo.
Then a terrible crash echoed through the cavern.
The Great Goblin had forced his enormous body onto the platform behind them.
The wooden supports groaned.
“YOU WON'T ESCAPE!”
Gandalf turned.
“Keep going!”
Thorin hesitated.
The wizard struck the platform with his staff.
A section of the walkway shattered.
The Great Goblin roared.
The bridge lurched violently.
Bilbo lost his balance.
He reached for the railing.
His fingers caught wet, rotten wood.
“Bilbo!”
Thorin turned.
For one instant, their eyes met.
Then the railing broke.
Bilbo fell backward into the darkness.
Thorin lunged.
His hand closed upon empty air.
“BILBO!”
The hobbit vanished beneath the walkway.
A distant crash echoed from somewhere below.
Thorin stood frozen.
He remembered this.
He remembered Bilbo disappearing.
But memory offered him no comfort.
Not now.
Not when he had watched the hobbit fall.
“THORIN!”
Dwalin seized his arm.
“We have to move!”
Thorin wrenched free.
“Bilbo's down there!”
“I know!”
“Then we go back!”
A volley of arrows struck the walkway around them.
Kíli cried out as one grazed his shoulder.
Fíli immediately moved to shield him.
Thorin saw the blood.
His stomach twisted.
The goblins were closing in.
Behind them, the platform began to collapse.
Gandalf appeared through the smoke.
“Thorin! We cannot stay!”
“Bilbo—”
“I saw him fall!”
“Then help me find him!”
Gandalf's expression tightened.
For a moment, the wizard looked toward the darkness beneath the bridge.
Then another explosion of splintering wood shook the cavern.
The walkway tilted.
Dwalin grabbed Thorin again.
“Your nephews need you!”
Thorin turned.
Fíli was holding Kíli upright.
Balin and the others were struggling to reach the next passage.
The goblins were almost upon them.
Thorin looked back toward the darkness.
Somewhere below, Bilbo was alone.
He remembered the hobbit returning in his first life.
He remembered his voice, his smile, the quiet courage that had carried him through impossible dangers.
But what if this time was different?
What if the path had changed?
What if Bilbo had struck the rocks below?
“Thorin!”
Fíli's voice cut through the chaos.
His nephew stood at the far end of the bridge, one arm around Kíli.
“Please!”
Thorin closed his eyes for a heartbeat.
He had promised to protect them.
All of them.
Yet the mountain was forcing him to choose.
Gandalf gripped his shoulder.
“Trust him,” the wizard said urgently.
Thorin opened his eyes.
The words struck something deep within him.
Trust Bilbo.
He had failed to do that once.
He would not fail again.
But trusting him did not make turning away any easier.
Thorin looked down into the darkness one final time.
“Bilbo,” he whispered.
Then he turned and ran.
Gandalf followed close behind, using his staff to hold back the goblins while the Company fled along the last narrow passage.
They had not gone far when Thorin stopped abruptly.
“Wait.”
Dwalin turned, breathing hard. “What now?”
Thorin ignored him. His eyes moved over the Company, counting each familiar face.
“Balin. Dwalin. Óin. Glóin. Dori. Nori. Ori. Bifur. Bofur. Bombur.”
His gaze found his nephews.
“Fíli. Kíli.”
Then he looked toward Gandalf, who stood behind them with his staff raised against the approaching goblins.
Thirteen dwarves, himself included.
One wizard.
Fourteen.
There should have been fifteen.
Thorin counted again, although he knew perfectly well who was missing.
“Bilbo.”
Fíli watched his uncle's expression change.
“Uncle…”
“Thirteen dwarves,” Thorin said quietly. “One wizard.”
His gaze returned to the passage they had just escaped.
“We are missing our burglar.”
Gandalf lowered his staff slightly.
“I know, Thorin.”
“Then we are not all here.”
“No,” Gandalf answered gently. “We are not.”
A distant shriek echoed through the tunnels.
Dwalin tightened his grip upon his axe.
“More are coming.”
Thorin stood motionless for another heartbeat.
Then he turned toward the darkness.
“Bilbo is still down there.”
“And we shall do everything we can to find him,” Gandalf replied. “But if we remain here, the goblins will have us all.”
Thorin's jaw tightened.
He looked at Fíli, then Kíli, whose shoulder was bleeding beneath his torn coat. He looked at the others, exhausted and frightened, but still waiting for his command.
Finally, he nodded.
“Move.”
They continued toward the distant promise of daylight.
Behind them, the tunnels echoed with the cries of pursuing goblins.
And far below the mountain, beyond the reach of Thorin's voice, Bilbo Baggins lay alone in the darkness.
