Actions

Work Header

The Road Back to You

Chapter 4: Chapter Four — Whispers Beneath the Stars

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins had decided, after nearly four weeks of travelling with thirteen dwarves and a wizard, that Rivendell was quite possibly the most wonderful place in Middle-earth.

It was not simply the beauty of the valley, although he had never seen anything quite like it. Waterfalls descended from impossible heights, turning silver beneath the morning sun, while delicate bridges crossed streams so clear that every stone upon their beds could be counted. The buildings seemed to grow naturally from the surrounding cliffs, their pale columns and graceful arches intertwined with trees whose leaves whispered whenever the wind passed through them.

Nor was it merely the food, though Bilbo had nearly wept upon discovering that the elves served breakfast at a perfectly respectable hour and possessed an understanding of fresh bread that bordered upon miraculous.

No, the greatest wonder of Rivendell was its beds.

Proper beds, with mattresses and clean sheets and pillows that did not consist of a rolled-up cloak stuffed beneath one's head.

Bilbo had slept for almost ten uninterrupted hours on his first night, waking only when sunlight slipped through his curtains and warmed his face. For several glorious minutes, he lay perfectly still, listening to birdsong and contemplating whether it might be possible to persuade Gandalf to abandon the Quest entirely.

Then someone knocked upon his door.

“Bilbo! Are you awake?”

He recognized Kíli's voice immediately.

“Unfortunately,” Bilbo called.

“Excellent! Come along!”

“Where?”

“Breakfast!”

Bilbo considered the matter.

“Give me a moment.”

“Fíli says you've already missed the first sitting.”

Bilbo threw back his blankets.

“Why didn't you begin with that?”

Kíli's laughter followed him as he hurried to dress.

By the time Bilbo emerged into the corridor, the young dwarf was leaning against the opposite wall, looking entirely too pleased with himself. His dark hair was still damp from washing, and he had apparently made some attempt to arrange it neatly, although one stubborn lock refused to remain where he wanted it.

Bilbo reached up automatically and smoothed it down.

“There.”

Kíli blinked.

“What?”

“Your hair.”

The dwarf stared at him for a moment before bursting into laughter.

“What is it with you and our hair?”

Bilbo frowned.

“Someone has to keep you all presentable.”

“Careful. You'll have the entire Company lining up outside your door.”

“I shall charge them.”

“How much?”

“One silver piece per head.”

Kíli considered this gravely.

“Uncle could afford it.”

“Your uncle,” Bilbo replied, beginning down the corridor, “is considerably better behaved than the rest of you.”

Kíli made a strangled noise.

Then he laughed so loudly that an elf passing through the hall turned to look at them.

“Oh, Bilbo,” he managed. “You have absolutely no idea.”

Bilbo glanced back, bewildered.

“No idea about what?”

“Nothing!”

“Kíli.”

“Come on. Bombur will eat everything.”

That was sufficiently alarming to end the conversation.

__________

 

The Company had settled into Rivendell with varying degrees of enthusiasm.

Balin appeared to have made peace with their hosts almost immediately. He spent his mornings walking through the gardens, his afternoons resting beneath the shade of the trees, and his evenings discussing history with anyone willing to listen. Ori had discovered a particular fondness for elven architecture and filled several pages of his journal with sketches of bridges and towers.

Bofur appreciated the music, although he maintained that the songs would benefit considerably from a faster rhythm.

Bombur remained deeply suspicious of the portions.

“I don't understand it,” he complained over breakfast, examining the elegant arrangement upon his plate. “There's barely enough here to feed a child.”

“You've had four servings,” Glóin reminded him.

“And I'm still hungry.”

“That is hardly the elves' fault.”

Dwalin, meanwhile, seemed personally offended by nearly everything.

The chairs were too delicate, the cups too small, and the corridors contained entirely too many elves.

Thorin endured these complaints with a patience that had become increasingly disturbing to his companions.

He sat at the head of their table, listening as Bofur and Nori argued about the proper preparation of mushrooms, and occasionally contributed a dry remark that left Bilbo laughing into his tea.

That, more than anything, continued to trouble Dwalin.

He had known Thorin Oakenshield for most of his life. He remembered the proud young prince who had once filled Erebor's training yards with laughter, but the years of exile had changed him. Responsibility, grief, and disappointment had hardened him into a king who rarely permitted himself moments of uncomplicated happiness.

Yet here he was, smiling because a hobbit had made some ridiculous observation about breakfast.

Dwalin looked toward Balin.

His brother was watching Thorin with an expression of quiet satisfaction.

“Don't,” Dwalin muttered.

Balin raised an eyebrow.

“Don't what?”

“Look so pleased.”

“I am pleased.”

“That is precisely the problem.”

Balin chuckled.

“Perhaps you ought to try it sometime.”

Dwalin grunted and returned to his food.

Across the table, Kíli was explaining to Bilbo why dwarven celebrations frequently lasted several days.

Bilbo listened with growing admiration.

“Several days?”

“Sometimes longer.”

“And there's food throughout?”

“Of course.”

Bilbo sat back.

“I may have misjudged your people.”

Thorin laughed.

It was a warm, genuine sound.

Dwalin stared at him again.

Balin merely smiled.

___________

 

Bilbo discovered Rivendell's library on their second afternoon.

He had intended to spend only a little while exploring, but the moment he stepped inside, all thoughts of returning to the Company vanished.

Shelves rose toward the high ceiling, filled with volumes bound in leather, cloth, and materials he could not identify. Sunlight filtered through tall windows, illuminating reading tables scattered with maps and manuscripts. The air smelled pleasantly of parchment, polished wood, and old books.

Bilbo wandered between the shelves in something approaching reverence.

He was examining an illustrated history of the northern kingdoms when a courteous voice interrupted him.

“May I help you find something?”

Bilbo turned to discover an elf standing nearby.

“Oh! I'm terribly sorry. I wasn't disturbing anything, was I?”

“Not at all,” the elf assured him. “I am Lindir.”

“Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”

Lindir inclined his head.

“Is there something in particular you are looking for?”

Bilbo hesitated.

His gaze returned to the illustration before him.

“Actually, I was wondering whether you had anything about Erebor.”

“The Lonely Mountain?”

“Yes.”

Lindir considered this before leading him toward another section of the library.

“We have several accounts of the kingdom beneath the Mountain. Some were written before its fall.”

He selected a substantial volume bound in dark green leather.

“This one contains descriptions of its architecture and daily life.”

Bilbo accepted it eagerly.

“Thank you very much.”

“You are welcome, Master Baggins.”

The elf departed without further ceremony, leaving Bilbo to settle beside a window overlooking the gardens.

__________

 

For the next hour, he read.

There were descriptions of vast halls illuminated by thousands of lamps, of markets filled with merchants from distant lands, and of workshops where craftsmen shaped precious metals into extraordinary works of art.

But what interested Bilbo most were the smaller details.

There had been schools beneath the mountain. Kitchens large enough to feed hundreds, courtyards where children played, and gardens built wherever sunlight could reach through openings in the stone.

He found an illustration of a sheltered garden surrounded by pale columns, its pathways winding between flowering trees.

Bilbo studied it for a long time.

He had heard Thorin speak of Erebor before. Usually, the dwarf spoke of his people's suffering, their lost kingdom, and the duty that compelled him to reclaim it.

But this book described something different.

A place where people had laughed, worked, argued, raised families, and lived ordinary lives.

A home.

Bilbo wondered what Thorin had been like before Smaug.

Before exile.

Before the burden of becoming king had settled upon his shoulders.

It was a question he found himself increasingly eager to ask.

Thorin discovered Bilbo in the gardens shortly before sunset.

The hobbit was sitting beneath a flowering tree, the book resting open upon his knees. Beyond him, a waterfall descended into a clear pool, sending a fine mist drifting through the warm evening air.

Thorin approached quietly.

“Studying?”

Bilbo looked up and smiled.

“Oh! Yes. Lindir helped me find a book about Erebor.”

Thorin glanced at the illustration.

He recognized the courtyard immediately.

For a moment, he could almost hear his mother's laughter.

“May I?”

Bilbo shifted to make room.

“Of course.”

Thorin sat beside him, his shoulder nearly touching the hobbit's.

Bilbo turned the book toward him.

“Was it really like this?”

Thorin studied the drawing.

“Yes. Though the artist has made the columns rather taller than I remember.”

Bilbo laughed.

“Artists do have a habit of improving things.”

“An unfortunate tendency.”

They sat quietly for a moment.

Then Bilbo asked, “What was it like growing up there?”

Thorin looked at him.

The question was so simple that he scarcely knew how to answer.

Most people asked about Erebor's treasure, its defenses, its great halls, or the wealth of its kings.

Very few asked about his childhood.

“It was a good place to grow up,” he said eventually.

Bilbo waited.

Thorin glanced toward the waterfall.

“My mother had a garden much like this one. It stood near her chambers, beneath an opening in the mountain where the sunlight reached the stone for several hours each day.”

“Did she grow flowers?”

“Many. Some rather unsuccessfully.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Not everyone has a talent for gardening.”

“She certainly believed she did.”

Thorin's mouth curved.

“She would argue with the gardeners whenever they suggested a particular plant could not survive beneath the mountain.”

“And who won?”

“My mother, usually.”

“Ah. So stubbornness runs in the family.”

Thorin turned toward him.

Bilbo looked perfectly innocent.

“I have no idea what you mean.”

“Of course not.”

Thorin chuckled, then returned his attention to the distant water.

“My brother Frerin and I used to hide in that garden when we wished to avoid our lessons. Dís would find us eventually, though whether she intended to bring us back or join us depended entirely upon her mood.”

Bilbo's eyes brightened.

“You have a sister?”

“Yes. Dís.”

“What's she like?”

“Terrifying.”

Bilbo laughed.

Thorin smiled.

“She is clever, stubborn, and entirely too fond of giving orders. Even as a child, she behaved as though the rest of us existed solely to carry out her wishes.”

“And did you?”

“More often than I care to admit.”

Bilbo grinned.

“I should like to meet her.”

Thorin imagined Dís meeting Bilbo.

His sister would take one look at the hobbit, recognize exactly what he meant to Thorin, and proceed to make his life thoroughly unbearable.

The thought was strangely comforting.

“I believe you would get along rather well.”

“Do you?”

“Unfortunately for me.”

Bilbo laughed again.

Encouraged, Thorin began telling him about the trouble he and his siblings had caused.

There was the occasion when Dís persuaded her brothers to steal honey cakes from the kitchens, only for all three to be discovered beneath a table with crumbs covering their clothes. Another time, Frerin had attempted to teach a young mountain goat to follow commands, resulting in the animal escaping into a formal gathering of visiting merchants.

Bilbo laughed until his eyes watered.

“A goat?”

“A particularly ill-tempered one.”

“And what did your grandfather say?”

“He was not amused.”

“I can't imagine why.”

Thorin shook his head, smiling at the memory.

For a little while, he was no longer the king who had died upon Ravenhill.

He was simply a dwarf remembering his childhood.

Bilbo watched him with quiet fascination.

Thorin looked younger when he smiled like that. The stern lines around his mouth softened, and his blue eyes became bright with an amusement that Bilbo had only recently begun to recognize.

“I think,” Bilbo said thoughtfully, “I should have liked to meet you when you were little.”

Thorin turned toward him.

Something warm and painful stirred beneath his ribs.

“I suspect we would have caused each other a great deal of trouble.”

“Certainly not. I was a perfectly respectable child.”

“Were you?”

“Mostly.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

Bilbo nudged his arm.

“Oh, don't look at me like that.”

They laughed together.

Eventually, Bilbo asked about Frerin.

The smile upon Thorin's face faded.

“He died many years ago.”

Bilbo's expression softened.

“Oh, Thorin. I'm sorry.”

Thorin looked down at his hands.

“He was very young. Brave, foolish, and always eager to prove himself.”

“He sounds rather like Kíli.”

Thorin swallowed.

“Yes,” he said quietly. “He does.”

Bilbo closed the book.

For a moment, he considered offering some comforting words, but nothing seemed quite sufficient.

Instead, he remained beside Thorin, close enough that their shoulders touched.

Thorin did not move away.

After a while, Bilbo spoke.

“I think I understand a little better now.”

Thorin looked at him.

“Understand what?”

“Why you want to go home.”

The dwarf's breath caught.

Bilbo glanced toward the book.

“It's not really about the gold, is it? Or even the mountain itself. It's about everything that happened there. Everyone who lived there.”

Thorin stared at him.

In another lifetime, Bilbo had understood him better than anyone.

And here he was, doing so again.

“No,” Thorin answered softly. “It was never only about the gold.”

Bilbo smiled.

“Then I hope we find your garden.”

Thorin looked toward the fading sunlight.

“So do I.”

And for the first time in many years, he imagined returning to Erebor not as a king claiming a throne, but as a man coming home.

__________

 

Fíli found his uncle upon a balcony later that evening.

Thorin stood with his hands resting upon the stone railing, watching the first stars appear above the valley.

“Uncle?”

Thorin turned.

“Fíli.”

“May I speak with you?”

“Of course.”

The young prince approached, but instead of immediately beginning, he stood beside Thorin and looked toward the mountains.

Thorin waited.

He knew that expression.

Fíli had worn it since childhood whenever he wished to ask something difficult.

Finally, his nephew sighed.

“Are you well?”

Thorin frowned.

“Of course.”

“Truly?”

“Why would you ask?”

Fíli turned toward him.

“Because you've been different since we left the Shire.”

Thorin's expression became guarded.

“Different?”

“You hardly sleep. You insist upon checking every watch yourself, even when Dwalin has already arranged them. You worry about things before there's any reason to worry.”

Thorin looked away.

“And sometimes,” Fíli continued more quietly, “you look at Kíli and me as though you're afraid we'll disappear.”

The words struck painfully close to the truth.

Thorin gripped the railing.

Fíli watched him.

“I know the Quest is dangerous. I know you're worried about us. But this feels like something else.”

Thorin remained silent.

His nephew took a breath.

“Has something happened that you haven't told us?”

Yes.

Everything.

Thorin remembered Fíli's body suspended above the courtyard at Ravenhill. He remembered the terrible stillness of his nephew's face, the blood upon his clothing, and the knowledge that he had been too late.

He remembered Kíli dying only a short time afterward.

And he remembered how little his crown had mattered then.

“Uncle?”

Thorin turned.

Fíli's expression was earnest and worried.

So painfully alive.

Thorin reached out and rested a hand upon his shoulder.

“There are things I fear,” he admitted.

Fíli waited.

“Things I cannot easily explain.”

“Then let us help you.”

Thorin's throat tightened.

“You already do.”

Fíli looked confused.

“Simply by being here,” Thorin added.

For a moment, neither spoke.

Then Thorin drew his nephew into an embrace.

Fíli stiffened in surprise before returning it.

Thorin held him tightly, feeling the solid warmth of his shoulders beneath his hands.

He had been given another chance.

He would not waste it.

When they finally separated, Thorin kept one hand upon Fíli's shoulder.

“There is something I wish you to understand.”

Fíli straightened instinctively.

Thorin almost smiled.

Even now, his nephew responded to that particular tone as though expecting an official royal decree.

“Whatever happens in the years to come,” Thorin began, “whether I marry or remain alone, whether I have children of my own or not, you will always be my heir.”

Fíli blinked.

“Uncle?”

“You are the Crown Prince of Erebor. And when my time comes, you shall be its king.”

Fíli stared at him.

“I never doubted—”

“I know.”

Thorin's voice softened.

“But I would have you hear it from me. Not because you are my sister's son, nor merely because you are the eldest of her children. You will inherit the throne because I trust you.”

Fíli swallowed.

“I trust your judgment,” Thorin continued. “Your courage. Your heart. I have watched you grow into a dwarf worthy of leading our people, and nothing will change that.”

He tightened his hand upon Fíli's shoulder.

“Not even a son or daughter of my own.”

Although, Thorin reflected with a sudden and entirely inappropriate flicker of amusement, considering that, should I ever marry, I fully intend to marry a certain stubborn, curly-haired hobbit, the likelihood of producing children of my own is rather slim.

He maintained a perfectly solemn expression.

Fíli, fortunately, remained unaware that his uncle had just contemplated marrying their burglar in the middle of a discussion about royal succession.

Thorin cleared his throat.

“You have my complete confidence.”

Fíli looked down.

For a moment, Thorin thought his nephew might argue.

Instead, the young dwarf drew a shaky breath.

“Thank you.”

Thorin's expression softened.

“You need not thank me for speaking the truth.”

Fíli looked up.

There was moisture in his eyes.

“I only hope I can become the king you believe I'll be.”

Thorin felt something twist painfully inside him.

“You already possess everything that matters.”

Fíli shook his head.

“I still have much to learn.”

“As do I.”

That earned a faint smile.

Thorin stepped closer.

“I am proud of you, Fíli. More than I have ever properly told you.”

His nephew embraced him again.

This time, neither hurried to pull away.

When Fíli eventually stepped back, he studied his uncle with renewed concern.

“Are you expecting something to happen to you?”

Thorin went still.

“No,” he answered carefully. “But a king must consider the future of his people.”

Fíli nodded, though he did not appear entirely satisfied.

Then he managed a small smile.

“Whatever happens, Uncle, Kíli and I will look after you too.”

Thorin's chest tightened.

“I shall remember that.”

After Fíli departed, Thorin remained upon the balcony for a long time.

He had promised his nephew a crown.

Now he had to make certain Fíli lived long enough to wear it.

__________

 

The following evening, Elrond examined the map of Erebor.

The Company gathered in a chamber overlooking the valley, where pale moonlight spilled through the open windows.

Bilbo stood beside Gandalf, watching with considerable interest as the elf lord studied the parchment.

Thorin remained near the table.

He knew what Elrond would find.

He remembered the moon-runes, the hidden door, and the instructions that would guide them toward the secret entrance.

Nevertheless, when Elrond raised the map toward the moonlight and the concealed writing appeared, Thorin allowed himself a measured expression of interest.

“Moon-runes,” Elrond announced.

Bilbo leaned forward.

“Moon-runes?”

“Runes that can only be read by the light of a moon of the same shape and season as the day upon which they were written.”

Kíli looked impressed.

“Clever.”

Elrond examined the writing.

Then he read aloud the instructions concerning the grey stone, the thrush, and the last light of Durin's Day.

Bilbo listened carefully.

Thorin watched the map.

He remembered standing before that hidden door in his first life, desperate and furious when the sun disappeared before they had found the keyhole.

He remembered Bilbo noticing the moonlight.

He remembered how close they had come to failure.

This time, he would be prepared.

When Elrond finished, Gandalf turned toward him.

“You do not seem particularly surprised.”

Thorin met the wizard's gaze.

“My grandfather was fond of secrets.”

“Indeed.”

“I have long suspected there was more to the map than we could see.”

Gandalf studied him.

“A fortunate suspicion.”

“Perhaps.”

Thorin looked back toward the parchment.

He could feel the wizard's eyes upon him.

Gandalf had been watching him more closely since Radagast's arrival.

Thorin knew he would eventually have to explain something.

But not yet.

Not while he was still trying to understand what could be changed and what remained beyond his control.

__________

 

Gandalf found Elrond upon a terrace later that night.

The elf lord stood beneath the stars, his hands folded behind his back.

“You seem troubled,” Elrond observed.

Gandalf sighed.

“I find myself increasingly uncertain about Thorin Oakenshield.”

Elrond turned.

“He is not quite the dwarf I expected.”

“No,” Gandalf agreed. “Nor is he quite the dwarf I remember.”

Elrond considered that.

“He has been remarkably courteous.”

“Which would ordinarily be cause for celebration.”

“And yet?”

Gandalf drew upon his pipe.

“He knows things, Elrond. Things he ought not know.”

“Such as?”

“The dangers along our road. The darkness gathering at Dol Guldur. Matters concerning his own companions.”

Elrond frowned.

“Has he spoken of visions?”

“I asked him something similar. He neither confirmed nor denied it.”

Gandalf looked toward the distant mountains.

“He behaves like a man who has already suffered consequences that have yet to occur.”

Elrond was quiet for several moments.

Then, almost casually, he asked, “Tell me, Gandalf, how long has Thorin Oakenshield been courting your burglar?”

Gandalf inhaled sharply.

The resulting cough was so violent that he nearly dropped his pipe.

Elrond waited with admirable patience.

When Gandalf finally recovered, he stared.

“Courting?”

“Unless I have misunderstood certain dwarven customs.”

Gandalf blinked.

Elrond's expression remained composed.

“I am not an expert in every tradition of Durin's folk, but I know enough to recognize the significance of allowing another to tend one's hair so intimately.”

Gandalf slowly lowered his pipe.

“The braids.”

“Precisely.”

For several moments, the wizard looked utterly bewildered.

Then he began to laugh.

“Oh, Thorin.”

Elrond raised an eyebrow.

“You were unaware?”

“I knew he was fond of Bilbo. Unusually fond, in fact. But I had not considered—”

Gandalf stopped.

His amusement faded.

Elrond noticed.

“What is it?”

“Thorin behaved as though he already knew the hobbit on the night they met.”

Elrond listened.

“He was gentle with him from the beginning,” Gandalf continued. “Patient. Protective. Almost desperately relieved whenever Bilbo remained near him.”

“And the hobbit?”

“Has no notion of what is happening, I suspect.”

Elrond glanced toward the gardens.

“Then perhaps Thorin's affection is not as simple as it appears.”

“No,” Gandalf murmured.

He remembered Thorin's expression when his nephews laughed.

The strange grief in his eyes.

The way he sometimes watched Bilbo as though afraid the hobbit might vanish.

“I fear, my friend, that Thorin Oakenshield knows considerably more about this journey than he ought.”

Elrond studied him.

“Do you believe he has seen the future?”

Gandalf was silent.

“I do not know.”

Below them, the waterfalls continued their endless song.

At last, Elrond spoke.

“Whatever the truth, I would advise caution. Knowledge can become a terrible burden when one believes oneself responsible for changing what is to come.”

Gandalf nodded.

“I know.”

He looked toward the rooms where the Company slept.

“And I fear Thorin knows it too.”

___________

 

The White Council gathered the following morning.

Gandalf, Elrond, Galadriel, and Saruman spoke at length concerning the growing darkness in the east, the Morgul blade recovered by Radagast, and the strange power gathering within Dol Guldur.

Saruman dismissed many of Gandalf's concerns.

Elrond remained troubled.

Galadriel listened in silence, her expression thoughtful.

And Gandalf, remembering Thorin's whispered mention of Sauron, found himself increasingly uneasy.

Meanwhile, the Company prepared to depart.

The weather had begun to change.

Cold winds descended from the mountains, carrying the promise of rain.

Thorin inspected their supplies, checked their weapons, and questioned Dwalin about the condition of the ponies.

He also insisted that everyone carry additional blankets.

“It's summer,” Kíli protested.

“In the valleys,” Thorin replied. “The mountains are another matter.”

Fíli exchanged a glance with Dwalin.

Neither argued.

Bilbo, meanwhile, was attempting to fit several books into his travelling pack.

Balin watched him struggle.

“Master Baggins, are you planning to carry the entire library?”

“Certainly not.”

Bilbo pushed another volume beneath his spare shirt.

“Only a few particularly interesting ones.”

Balin chuckled.

“You may find the mountains less accommodating than Rivendell.”

“I know.”

Bilbo sighed and reluctantly removed two books.

Then he noticed Thorin approaching.

“Are we leaving tomorrow?”

“At first light.”

Bilbo looked toward the distant mountains.

They rose beyond the valley like enormous walls of grey stone, their highest peaks hidden beneath clouds.

For the first time since arriving in Rivendell, he felt a flicker of unease.

Thorin noticed.

“You need not be ashamed of being afraid.”

Bilbo looked up.

“I wasn't.”

Thorin raised an eyebrow.

“Well,” Bilbo admitted, “perhaps a little.”

“There is no shame in that.”

Bilbo studied him.

“Are you afraid?”

Thorin looked toward the mountains.

He remembered thunder.

Stone giants.

Goblin-town.

The darkness beneath the earth.

“Yes,” he answered.

Bilbo blinked.

He had not expected such honesty.

Thorin turned back toward him.

“But fear need not prevent us from continuing.”

Bilbo considered that.

Then he smiled.

“I suppose you're right.”

Thorin returned the smile.

“Occasionally.”

“Only occasionally?”

“I would not wish to become predictable.”

Bilbo laughed.

On their final evening in Rivendell, Bilbo found Thorin standing alone upon a balcony.

The mountains were dark against the starlit sky.

The dwarf had been studying them for some time, his thoughts far away.

Bilbo approached quietly.

“Mind if I join you?”

Thorin turned.

“Never.”

Bilbo stepped beside him.

For a while, they stood in comfortable silence.

Then Bilbo began telling him about a particularly stubborn gardener in Hobbiton who had once attempted to grow roses in the middle of winter.

Thorin listened.

The story was entirely ordinary.

There were no dragons, no ancient kingdoms, no terrible prophecies.

Only a hobbit, a gardener, and an unfortunate collection of frozen rosebushes.

And somehow, that was exactly what Thorin needed.

When Bilbo finished, Thorin was smiling.

“You have a remarkable talent for finding trouble in the most peaceful places.”

Bilbo looked offended.

“I do not find trouble.”

“No?”

“Trouble finds me.”

Thorin laughed softly.

“Yes,” he murmured. “I believe it does.”

Bilbo leaned against the railing.

“Thorin?”

“Yes?”

“Do you ever think about what you'll do when we reach Erebor?”

Thorin looked toward the stars.

“All the time.”

“Will you be happy there?”

The question caught him unexpectedly.

In his first life, he had believed reclaiming Erebor would make him happy.

He had been wrong.

He had gained his kingdom and nearly lost his soul.

Now he understood that happiness was not something waiting beneath the mountain.

It was something he had to choose.

“I hope so,” he answered.

Bilbo nodded thoughtfully.

“I hope so too.”

Thorin looked at him.

“And you, Bilbo? What will you do when our journey is finished?”

The hobbit smiled.

“Go home, I suppose. Tend my garden. Read my books. Have proper meals again.”

Thorin felt a familiar ache.

Of course.

Bilbo had a home.

A life.

A future that did not necessarily include him.

He had no right to expect otherwise.

“That sounds peaceful,” Thorin said.

“It does.”

Bilbo hesitated.

“Although I think I shall miss everyone.”

Thorin turned.

“Everyone?”

“Yes.”

Bilbo looked embarrassed.

“Even Dwalin, probably.”

Thorin laughed.

“A generous sentiment.”

“And Kíli. And Balin. And Fíli.”

He paused.

Then, more quietly, he added, “And you.”

Thorin's smile faded into something softer.

“Bilbo.”

The hobbit looked up.

For a moment, Thorin wanted to tell him everything.

That he had loved him before.

That he had died with Bilbo's name upon his lips.

That every ordinary moment they shared felt like a miracle.

Instead, he simply said, “I shall miss you too.”

Bilbo smiled.

And Thorin thought that perhaps, for now, it was enough.

__________

 

They departed Rivendell at dawn.

The valley lay beneath a veil of silver mist, its waterfalls glimmering in the pale morning light.

Elrond offered them provisions and wished them safe passage.

Gandalf exchanged a final, meaningful glance with the elf lord before joining the Company.

Thorin thanked their host.

Dwalin still looked uncomfortable about it.

But he said nothing.

The dwarves mounted their ponies, adjusted their packs, and began the long climb toward the mountains.

Bilbo lingered for a moment, looking back at Rivendell.

He had grown fond of the place.

Its gardens, its books, its peaceful halls.

Yet when he turned toward the road, he found himself looking for Thorin.

The dwarf was waiting a short distance ahead.

Bilbo urged his pony forward.

“Mind if I ride beside you?”

Thorin smiled.

“Not at all.”

Bilbo settled comfortably at his side.

Ahead of them, Kíli glanced back.

For a moment, he seemed ready to call something teasing over his shoulder.

Then he noticed the quiet happiness upon his uncle's face.

He smiled to himself instead and rode forward to join Fíli.

Behind them, Rivendell disappeared among the trees.

Before them rose the Misty Mountains.

Thorin looked toward their dark peaks, remembering the terrible things waiting beyond them.

He knew that the peace of Rivendell could not last.

But Bilbo was riding beside him, humming softly beneath his breath, and the morning sun was beginning to break through the clouds.

For now, Thorin allowed himself to enjoy it.

Whatever waited in the mountains, they would face it together.