Chapter Text
The first thing Thorin noticed was that the spiders made almost no sound.
For creatures so enormous, they moved with a dreadful grace, their long legs finding purchase upon branches that should never have supported their weight. The leaves barely stirred as they passed. Only the occasional glimmer of a pale eye or the faint sheen of silk betrayed their presence among the tangled canopy.
Bilbo slept against his shoulder, blissfully unaware.
Thorin kept perfectly still.
He could feel the hobbit's warm breath against his neck, the slight weight of his curls where they brushed his cloak. One of Bilbo's hands rested loosely upon his arm, his fingers curled into the fabric as though he had reached for Thorin in his sleep.
It was a small, trusting gesture.
And above them, something hungry was watching.
Thorin's grip tightened around Orcrist.
He remembered the spiders from his first journey through Mirkwood. Remembered waking bound in silk, unable to move, the terrible confusion of hearing his companions struggling around him. He remembered Bilbo appearing when all hope had seemed lost, small and determined, fighting creatures many times his size.
He had been proud of him then.
He was proud of him now.
But pride did nothing to quiet the cold fear settling in Thorin's stomach.
Carefully, he shifted his shoulder.
“Bilbo,” he murmured.
The hobbit made a dissatisfied noise.
“Not yet.”
“Bilbo.”
“If it's morning, I should like another five minutes.”
Thorin almost smiled.
“It isn't morning.”
“Then I refuse to acknowledge that we're supposed to be awake.”
“There are spiders.”
Bilbo opened his eyes.
For a moment, he stared at Thorin.
Then he sat upright.
“...I withdraw my complaint.”
Thorin pressed a finger briefly to his lips.
Bilbo followed his gaze toward the branches.
Something moved overhead.
The hobbit went very pale.
“Oh,” he whispered. “Those are rather large.”
“Stay beside me.”
“I had no intention of going anywhere else.”
Thorin rose slowly, keeping one hand near Bilbo's shoulder while he signalled to Dwalin.
The warrior approached with his axe already in hand.
“What is it?”
Thorin pointed upward.
Dwalin squinted into the darkness.
For several moments, he saw nothing.
Then a thick strand of webbing drifted between two branches.
Dwalin's expression hardened.
“How many?”
“At least three.”
“And the rest?”
“That is what concerns me.”
Dwalin looked toward the sleeping Company.
“I'll wake them.”
“Quietly.”
“Aye.”
___________
Within minutes, Fíli had joined them, followed by the others. The dwarves gathered their belongings without complaint, though Bombur looked particularly miserable when informed that breakfast would have to wait.
Kíli stared into the branches.
“Are those the spiders Beorn warned us about?”
“No,” Bofur murmured. “I expect these are the friendly ones.”
Nobody laughed.
Thorin studied the path ahead.
“We move together. No one leaves the trail, and no one falls behind.”
Fíli stepped forward.
“Kíli and I can take the front. If there are webs across the path, we'll find them before the others walk into them.”
“Good,” Thorin answered. “Dwalin, take the rear. Bofur, stay near Bombur.”
Bilbo adjusted Sting at his hip.
“I can watch for the smaller webs,” he offered. “I'm closer to the ground than most of you.”
Thorin considered him.
In another life, he might have ordered Bilbo to remain safely in the middle of the Company.
Now he remembered a conversation beside a dying fire.
Then perhaps we ought to try doing it together.
He nodded.
“Keep your eyes on the roots. Tell us if you see anything.”
Bilbo straightened slightly.
“I shall.”
For the briefest moment, their eyes met.
Then Thorin turned toward the darkness.
“Move.”
_____________
They travelled for nearly an hour without incident.
The path twisted between enormous trunks, occasionally disappearing beneath carpets of dead leaves. Thick roots rose across their way, and the trees crowded so closely together that the Company sometimes had to pass through narrow gaps one at a time.
Above them, the spiders followed.
Thorin could hear them now.
A faint clicking.
The scrape of hard legs against bark.
Once, a pale shape moved directly overhead, and Kíli raised his bow.
“Don't,” Thorin whispered.
Kíli lowered it reluctantly.
Bilbo was the first to notice the web stretched across the path.
“Wait.”
The Company stopped.
The hobbit crouched beside a root and pointed toward a nearly invisible thread running between two trees.
“There.”
Fíli leaned closer.
“Well spotted.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
They carefully stepped around it.
Farther ahead, Dwalin discovered another.
Then a third.
By the time they reached a fallen tree, Thorin was beginning to understand what the spiders were doing.
They were not merely following.
They were guiding them.
He stopped.
“Something is wrong.”
Dwalin looked around.
“Besides the enormous spiders?”
“The webs are becoming more frequent.”
Fíli frowned.
“They're trying to force us toward something.”
Thorin nodded.
“Exactly.”
A branch cracked overhead.
Kíli looked up.
A monstrous spider emerged from the leaves, its swollen body suspended beneath a thick strand of silk.
“Above us!”
The creature dropped.
Dwalin met it with his axe.
The blade struck one of its legs, sending the spider shrieking backward. Fíli drew his sword, and Thorin stepped forward with Orcrist raised.
The spider retreated into the branches.
For one hopeful moment, Thorin thought they had frightened it away.
Then the ground moved.
A hollow trunk beside the path split open with a terrible cracking sound.
Something enormous burst from within.
Bombur shouted as a spider struck him sideways, knocking him into Bofur. Both dwarves fell among the roots.
Another creature emerged from beneath the fallen tree.
Then another.
The forest erupted into movement.
“DEFEND YOURSELVES!” Thorin roared.
The spiders were everywhere.
Their legs struck against bark and stone, their shrieks echoing beneath the canopy. Thick strands of silk shot through the darkness, catching on branches, weapons, and clothing.
Kíli fired an arrow into the nearest creature's face.
It screamed and lunged.
Fíli shoved his brother aside, but a strand of webbing caught Kíli around the arm and dragged him backward.
“FÍLI!”
His brother spun.
“KÍLI!”
Thorin heard them.
For one dreadful instant, he saw Ravenhill instead of Mirkwood.
Snow.
Blood.
His nephews dying beyond his reach.
Then Fíli shouted again, and the present returned with brutal clarity.
Thorin charged toward them.
But a spider dropped between him and the brothers.
Orcrist flashed blue.
The creature recoiled, one leg severed, and Thorin drove his blade into its body.
He barely had time to pull the sword free before another attacked.
____________
Meanwhile, Bilbo found himself separated from the others.
He had been trying to reach Bombur when a spider struck the ground beside him, throwing him against a root.
His shoulder collided painfully with the wood.
Sting slipped halfway from its sheath.
The creature turned toward him.
Its eyes were black and shining.
Its mouth opened, revealing terrible curved fangs.
Bilbo's heart hammered.
He was frightened.
More frightened than he cared to admit.
But somewhere beneath that fear, he remembered Thorin standing beside him during their sword lessons, patiently correcting his grip.
You need not be stronger than your opponent. You need to be quicker.
The spider lunged.
Bilbo rolled beneath its front legs.
Sting flashed upward.
The blade struck soft flesh.
The creature shrieked.
Bilbo scrambled to his feet and drove the sword forward again.
The spider collapsed.
For several seconds, he stood trembling, staring at the enormous body.
He had killed it.
He had actually killed it.
Then Kíli cried out.
Bilbo turned.
The young dwarf was tangled in webbing, struggling desperately while Fíli fought to keep another spider away.
Bilbo ran toward them.
He had almost reached the brothers when something struck the root beside him.
The impact threw him sideways.
He landed hard among the leaves.
Something slipped from his waistcoat pocket.
A small golden circle bounced against the bark.
Rolled between two roots.
And vanished beneath a fallen branch.
Bilbo stopped breathing.
The Ring.
His Ring.
He dropped to his knees.
“No…”
His fingers scraped through damp leaves.
It had been there.
He had seen it.
Where had it gone?
A spider shrieked somewhere behind him.
Bilbo scarcely heard.
His heart pounded with a sudden, desperate terror that seemed entirely different from the fear of the creatures surrounding him.
He had to find it.
He had to.
His hands clawed at the earth, scattering leaves and broken twigs.
Then he saw it.
A faint golden glimmer beneath the roots.
Relief struck him so fiercely that his eyes stung.
He reached for it.
“Mine,” he whispered.
His fingers closed around the Ring.
For one dreadful moment, the entire world seemed to settle into place.
Then Bilbo heard himself.
Mine?
He stared at the little circle resting against his palm.
What a strange thing to say.
What a dreadful, ugly little word.
“BILBO!”
He barely registered the shout.
“BILBO!”
A shadow fell over him.
Steel flashed.
Something enormous crashed against the roots.
Thorin seized Bilbo by the shoulder and hauled him backward just as a spider's fangs struck the ground where his head had been.
“What in Mahal's name are you doing?”
Bilbo stared at him.
“I—”
Thorin's face was pale beneath the dirt.
“You could have been killed!”
“I dropped something.”
“Then leave it!”
“No!”
The word tore from Bilbo's throat.
Thorin went still.
Bilbo was breathing hard, his fingers clenched so tightly around the Ring that its edges pressed painfully into his skin.
For a moment, the dwarf looked almost frightened of him.
Not because Bilbo had raised his voice.
Because there had been something in it that Thorin recognized.
Something desperate.
Possessive.
Something that reminded him horribly of the Arkenstone.
“Bilbo,” he said more quietly. “Is it worth your life?”
The hobbit looked down at his closed fist.
He could not answer.
Then Kíli screamed again.
Bilbo flinched.
He looked toward the brothers.
Fíli was struggling beneath the weight of a spider, and Kíli could barely move.
The Ring seemed to burn against his palm.
Bilbo swallowed.
Then he forced his fingers open long enough to push it deep into his pocket.
“No,” he whispered.
He drew Sting.
And ran.
____________
Fíli was losing ground.
The spider towering above him had already knocked his sword aside, and its long legs struck at him with terrifying speed.
Kíli struggled against the silk binding his arm.
“Fíli!”
“I'm rather occupied!”
The creature lunged.
Fíli raised his remaining dagger.
Then a small figure darted beneath the spider's body.
Sting flashed blue.
The creature shrieked as Bilbo drove the blade into its side.
Fíli seized the opportunity.
He recovered his sword and struck.
Together, they brought the spider down.
Bilbo immediately turned toward Kíli.
“Hold still!”
“I am holding still!”
“You're wriggling!”
“Because I'm stuck!”
“Then stop being stuck!”
Despite everything, Fíli almost laughed.
Bilbo cut through the webbing with Sting.
Kíli stumbled free.
“Thank you,” he gasped.
“You're welcome. Now please don't get caught again.”
“I'll do my best.”
They barely had time to recover before another spider emerged from the trees.
Fíli looked toward his uncle.
Thorin was fighting beside Dwalin, his sword moving with deadly precision.
But another creature was descending behind him.
“UNCLE!”
Thorin turned.
Too late.
Fíli hurled himself forward.
His sword struck the spider's leg just as it lunged, knocking the creature sideways.
Thorin spun and drove Orcrist into its body.
The spider collapsed between them.
For a moment, uncle and nephew stared at one another.
“You saved me,” Thorin said.
Fíli was breathing hard.
“You've been teaching me to watch my surroundings.”
Thorin looked at him.
At the young dwarf who had died in his arms in another lifetime.
Alive.
Fighting.
Strong enough to save his king.
Something painful tightened in his chest.
Then Fíli gave him a breathless grin.
“Try to remember your own lessons, Uncle.”
Thorin laughed once, astonished.
“I shall.”
__________
The sound of another shriek cut through the clearing.
The battle was not over.
Bilbo did not know exactly when he put on the Ring.
One moment, he was scrambling beneath a fallen branch as another spider approached.
The next, the golden circle was on his finger.
And the world changed.
The forest seemed colder.
The shadows deepened.
The spiders' voices became horribly clear.
Little morsel.
Where has it gone?
Find it.
Bilbo pressed himself against a tree, trembling.
The spider passed directly in front of him.
It did not see him.
For a moment, he felt an extraordinary rush of relief.
He could escape.
He could slip away from the spiders, from the darkness, from all this dreadful danger.
He could simply leave.
The thought was so tempting that he took one step toward the deeper forest.
Then he heard Thorin.
“BILBO!”
The dwarf's voice carried through the fighting.
Frightened.
Desperate.
Bilbo stopped.
He remembered Thorin asleep in his lap, his face peaceful for the first time in days.
Remembered the quiet admission beside the fire.
The people I love.
Bilbo turned around.
“No,” he whispered.
He tightened his grip upon Sting.
Then he ran back toward the Company.
Invisible, he moved between the spiders, striking at their legs and cutting through webs that bound the dwarves.
The creatures shrieked in confusion.
One fell beneath Dwalin's axe.
Another fled into the trees.
And slowly, painfully, the Company began to regain control.
Then arrows hissed through the darkness.
A spider dropped from the branches with a shaft buried in its head.
Another fell.
And another.
The dwarves turned.
Figures moved between the trees.
Tall.
Swift.
Clad in the muted colours of the forest.
Wood-elves.
___________
“Hold your positions!”
The command came from a fair-haired elf standing upon a broad root, his bow drawn.
More elves emerged around him, their arrows trained upon the surviving spiders.
The creatures retreated, shrieking angrily as they vanished into the canopy.
For a moment, the clearing fell into an exhausted silence.
Then the elves turned their weapons toward the dwarves.
“Lay down your arms,” the fair-haired elf ordered.
Dwalin bristled.
“After we just fought those things?”
“You are trespassing in the Woodland Realm.”
Thorin stepped forward.
He recognized the elf.
Legolas.
Thranduil's son.
In his first life, the sight of an armed elven patrol would have been enough to provoke him into a furious argument.
This time, he lowered Orcrist.
“We mean no harm to your people.”
Legolas regarded him suspiciously.
“Thorin Oakenshield.”
“Prince Legolas.”
A flicker of surprise crossed the elf's face.
“You know me?”
“I know of you.”
Legolas studied him for another moment.
Then he gestured toward the Company.
“You will accompany us to my father.”
Thorin inclined his head stiffly.
“We shall.”
Dwalin stared at him.
Balin looked faintly relieved.
The elves began collecting weapons.
Thorin allowed Orcrist to be taken, though every instinct protested.
Then he turned toward his companions.
Fíli.
Kíli.
Balin.
Dwalin.
Glóin. Óin. Dori. Nori. Ori.
Bifur. Bofur. Bombur.
Twelve dwarves.
With himself, thirteen.
There should have been fourteen.
Thorin looked around.
“Bilbo?”
No answer.
He glanced behind Bombur.
Then toward the fallen trees.
“Bilbo?”
His voice grew sharper.
Fíli looked up.
“Uncle?”
Thorin ignored him.
A moment ago, Bilbo had been fighting beside them.
He remembered seeing Sting flash blue among the roots.
Remembered the hobbit's frightened face when he had nearly been killed retrieving something from the ground.
And now—
“Where is the hobbit?”
Legolas frowned.
“What hobbit?”
Thorin turned toward him.
“The hobbit who was with us!”
“There was no hobbit among those we captured.”
For one terrible instant, Thorin could not breathe.
Then he moved.
He pushed past the nearest elf, ignoring the bows immediately raised against him.
“BILBO!”
Dwalin caught his arm.
“Thorin—”
“Let go!”
“Listen to me—”
“He was here!”
The words broke from him with such raw desperation that Dwalin loosened his grip in shock.
Thorin looked wildly toward the trees.
There were spiders out there.
Hundreds, perhaps.
There were webs hanging in the darkness, creatures waiting beneath roots, horrors that could swallow a hobbit without leaving a trace.
And Bilbo was gone.
Again.
“BILBO!”
He tried to push past the elves.
Two stepped into his path.
Legolas raised his bow.
“You will remain where you are.”
Thorin turned on him.
“Get out of my way.”
“You will not enter the forest alone.”
“Then you will have to kill me.”
Silence fell.
Even Legolas hesitated.
Thorin stood rigid, his breathing uneven, his hands trembling with a fury that was little more than terror.
He had promised himself.
He had promised that this time he would not lose them.
Not Fíli.
Not Kíli.
Not Bilbo.
Especially not Bilbo.
“Uncle.”
Fíli approached carefully.
Thorin did not look at him.
“He's out there.”
“We don't know that.”
“He wouldn't leave us!”
“I know.”
“He wouldn't!”
Fíli stepped closer.
“Uncle, look at me.”
Something in his nephew's voice finally reached him.
Thorin turned.
Fíli's expression was grave.
“Bilbo survived Goblin-town alone. He saved Kíli and me from the spiders. He's clever, and he knows how to hide.”
Thorin swallowed.
“He's still out there.”
“Then we have to trust him.”
Thorin stared at his nephew.
Trust.
That was what Bilbo had asked of him.
What Gandalf had told him.
What he had been trying, and failing, to learn since the moment he awoke outside Bag End.
He remembered the first journey.
Bilbo had found a way into the Elvenking's halls.
He had rescued them.
Thorin had never understood how.
Perhaps he could do so again.
But the knowledge offered only the smallest comfort.
He turned toward Legolas.
“Send someone to search for him.”
The prince studied him.
Then, after a moment, he signalled to two of his warriors.
“Search the nearby trees. Look for a small traveller.”
The elves disappeared into the darkness.
Thorin waited.
Every moment seemed an eternity.
When they returned, they had found nothing.
No hobbit.
No tracks.
No sign that Bilbo had ever been there.
Thorin felt the ground shift beneath him.
Legolas lowered his bow.
“We must go.”
Thorin looked toward the trees one final time.
Fíli rested a hand upon his arm.
“Come, Uncle.”
And at last, Thorin allowed himself to be led away.
__________
Bilbo stood only a few feet behind them.
Invisible.
Shaking.
He had watched everything.
He had seen Thorin push past the elves, heard the terrible desperation in his voice, and watched Fíli struggle to convince him that Bilbo might still be alive.
He had wanted to take off the Ring.
More than anything, he had wanted to run to Thorin and throw his arms around him.
But the elves were everywhere.
And if he allowed himself to be captured, who would help the Company?
He had reached toward Thorin once, his fingers hovering inches from the dwarf's hand.
Then he had stopped.
He could not risk revealing himself.
“I'm here,” he whispered.
Thorin did not hear.
“I'm right here.”
The dwarf walked away.
Bilbo felt something twist painfully beneath his ribs.
He had known Thorin cared for him.
He had seen it in countless small gestures, in the careful way the dwarf watched over him, in the tenderness of his smiles.
But he had never seen Thorin so frightened.
Never imagined that his disappearance could cause such devastation.
The Ring felt strangely warm upon his finger.
For a moment, Bilbo wanted to turn around.
To leave the elves behind.
To escape this dreadful forest and return to the quiet comforts of Bag End.
Then he looked toward Thorin.
The dwarf was walking between two elven guards, his shoulders rigid, his gaze constantly turning toward the trees.
Searching.
Still searching.
Bilbo swallowed.
He remembered Thorin's head resting in his lap.
Remembered the quiet warmth of his hand.
Remembered how safe he had felt beneath the dwarf's cloak.
And he knew, with sudden and startling certainty, that he could not leave him.
Not now.
Perhaps not ever.
Bilbo tightened his grip upon Sting.
“Oh, you ridiculous dwarf,” he whispered into the darkness. “Did you really think I would abandon you?”
Ahead, the elves began their journey toward the halls of the Elvenking.
Thorin looked over his shoulder one last time.
He saw nothing.
But Bilbo was there.
And as the Company disappeared beneath the ancient trees, their invisible burglar followed.
