Chapter Text
The gates of the Woodland Realm opened beneath the roots of the mountain, and Thorin Oakenshield found that he could not bring himself to admire them.
He remembered their grandeur. He remembered the pale stone, the bridges suspended above dark waters, the innumerable lanterns glowing like captured stars beneath the earth. He remembered the winding passages and the great halls carved into the living rock, where the wood-elves dwelt in splendour while the rest of the forest slowly surrendered to darkness.
Most of all, he remembered the cells.
He had spent enough time behind their doors in his first life to know precisely how the iron hinges sounded when they closed.
Yet now, as Legolas led the Company across the first bridge, Thorin scarcely noticed the armed guards or the curious faces turning toward them.
His attention remained fixed upon the entrance behind them.
Bilbo had not appeared.
Not when the elves gathered their belongings after the spider attack. Not when the Company began its long march through the forest. Not when they passed the watchposts hidden among the trees, nor when the guards called down from the branches to announce their arrival.
Every rustle of leaves had made Thorin turn.
Every unexpected footstep had brought a moment of unbearable hope.
And every time, there had been nothing.
“Uncle.”
Fíli's voice reached him from somewhere nearby.
Thorin looked toward his nephew.
“You'll stumble into the river if you keep walking backward,” Fíli said quietly.
Thorin glanced down. They had reached a narrow bridge crossing an underground stream, its black water flowing swiftly between smooth stone banks.
He turned forward.
“I'm watching the entrance.”
“I know.”
“He should have caught up by now.”
Fíli hesitated before answering. “Perhaps he has.”
Thorin looked sharply at him.
“Bilbo has surprised us before,” his nephew continued. “And he's clever enough not to announce himself while we're surrounded by armed elves.”
Thorin wanted to believe him.
He remembered Bilbo appearing in the goblin tunnels when he had been certain the hobbit was lost. Remembered the courage with which he had fought the spiders. Remembered, too, that in another life Bilbo had somehow found his way into these very halls and freed thirteen dwarves from imprisonment.
But memories were not promises.
The spiders had attacked differently this time. Thorin's precautions had changed the course of the battle, and with every alteration, the future grew less familiar.
What if Bilbo had been injured?
What if he had fallen?
What if—
“Uncle.”
Fíli touched his arm.
Thorin forced himself to meet his eyes.
“He's resourceful,” Fíli said. “You taught him that.”
Thorin swallowed.
“Aye.”
“And he has a habit of finding us.”
The faintest smile touched Thorin's mouth.
“He does.”
“Then let him find us again.”
Ahead, Legolas glanced over his shoulder.
“The king is expecting you.”
Thorin straightened.
He could not search the forest while surrounded by elven guards. He could not protect Bilbo by provoking another ruler into imprisoning the Company.
But perhaps he could accomplish something useful while he waited.
“Then we should not keep him waiting,” he answered.
__________
Bilbo Baggins had never imagined that entering an elven kingdom could involve so much hiding behind pillars.
He had expected guards, naturally. Gandalf had warned him often enough that elves possessed excellent eyesight and hearing, and Bilbo had already discovered both qualities to be profoundly inconvenient.
What he had not expected was the sheer number of places in which an unsuspecting hobbit might become lost.
The halls seemed to extend in every direction. Staircases curved around enormous columns, bridges crossed underground waterways, and lantern-lit passages disappeared into chambers whose ceilings were so high that Bilbo could scarcely distinguish them from the darkness above.
It was beautiful.
Under different circumstances, he would have liked to spend an entire afternoon examining the carvings.
At present, however, he was chiefly concerned with not being discovered.
The Ring rested upon his finger.
He had worn it for much of the journey, removing it only when he could safely conceal himself behind trees or among the rocks. Each time he slipped it off, an unpleasant reluctance stirred somewhere deep within him.
He did not like that feeling.
He liked even less how quickly it vanished whenever he put the Ring on again.
Now, following the dwarves through the palace, Bilbo found himself increasingly eager to remove it.
The world seemed strangely distant while he wore it, as though he were walking through a cold imitation of the halls around him.
He could hear the elves speaking, but their voices sometimes sounded thin and far away.
He could see Thorin.
That, at least, was enough to keep him moving.
The dwarf walked near the front of the Company, his dark hair falling loose around his shoulders where the battle had disturbed its braids.
Bilbo noticed the missing braid immediately.
He had spent a good deal of time arranging that hair.
It seemed terribly inconsiderate of the spiders to ruin his work.
The thought almost made him smile.
Then Thorin looked back toward the gates again, and Bilbo's amusement faded.
He had never seen him look so tired.
I'm here, he wanted to say.
But the guards were close, and the opportunity had not yet come.
So Bilbo followed.
____________
When the dwarves were led toward a guarded chamber, Thorin and two others were separated from the Company.
Bilbo recognized Fíli and Balin accompanying him.
He hesitated.
Then he slipped behind a column and listened.
“His Majesty will receive the leader of your Company,” one of the guards explained. “The others will remain here until his decision is made.”
Dwalin grumbled something unpleasant about elven hospitality.
Bilbo watched Thorin disappear down a passage with Fíli and Balin.
Then he made his decision.
He would find the others first.
After all, a burglar ought to know where his companions were being kept.
Thranduil had been informed of Thorin Oakenshield's arrival before the Company reached the gates.
He had also received a considerably more unusual report from his son.
“A hobbit?” he repeated.
Legolas stood before the throne, his bow resting across his back.
“So they claim.”
“You did not see him?”
“No.”
“And yet you searched for him?”
“At Thorin Oakenshield's insistence.”
Thranduil regarded his son.
Legolas's expression remained composed, though there was something faintly troubled about his eyes.
“Insistence,” the Elvenking repeated.
“He nearly fought the patrol when he discovered the hobbit was missing.”
That earned a raised eyebrow.
“Over a hobbit?”
“He seemed prepared to die rather than leave the forest without him.”
Thranduil was silent for a moment.
He remembered Thorin as a younger dwarf, proud and furious, standing amid the ruins of his people's hopes. He remembered the bitterness of their last encounters and the stubbornness with which the House of Durin guarded its grievances.
He did not remember Thorin Oakenshield displaying such desperate concern for a companion.
“And the dwarves surrendered their weapons?”
“Without resistance.”
“How extraordinary.”
Legolas inclined his head.
“I thought you would find it so.”
Thranduil rose.
“Bring them before me.”
_____________
The throne room was exactly as Thorin remembered.
That was perhaps the most unsettling thing about it.
The great antlered throne rose above the hall, pale and magnificent, framed by twisted columns and the warm glow of countless lanterns. The air smelled faintly of polished wood, stone, and the strange sweetness of the forest.
Thranduil sat above them, his silver hair falling over dark robes, his expression as cold and unreadable as winter moonlight.
Fíli stood to Thorin's right.
Balin remained slightly behind them.
Neither spoke.
Thorin stopped at the foot of the steps.
For a moment, two kings regarded one another.
Then Thorin inclined his head.
“King Thranduil.”
The Elvenking's eyes narrowed almost imperceptibly.
“Thorin Oakenshield.”
His gaze moved briefly over the dwarf's torn clothing and the marks left by the spider battle.
“You have travelled far to arrive uninvited in my kingdom.”
“Necessity rarely waits for invitations.”
“No,” Thranduil agreed. “And it appears necessity has done little to improve your manners.”
Thorin's mouth twitched.
“Perhaps not. But I have not come to quarrel with you.”
A silence followed.
Fíli glanced sideways at his uncle.
Balin looked as though he were trying very hard not to react.
Thranduil leaned back.
“Have you not?”
“No.”
“Then you have changed considerably since our last meeting.”
“Time has a habit of doing that.”
Something flickered in the Elvenking's eyes.
“And what is it you seek?”
“Passage through your realm. Supplies for my Company. And the opportunity to discuss a bargain.”
“A bargain?”
Thorin held his gaze.
“One that may benefit both our peoples.”
Thranduil considered him for a long moment.
Then he gestured toward the space before his throne.
“Speak.”
Thorin drew a slow breath.
“In Erebor's treasury there are jewels that rightfully belong to your house. The white gems of Lasgalen.”
The silence that followed was immediate.
Even the guards seemed to become still.
Thranduil's expression did not change.
But his fingers tightened slightly upon the arm of his throne.
“You speak of treasures you do not possess.”
“I speak of treasures I intend to recover.”
“And you believe I should trust the word of a dwarf whose grandfather refused to honour his own agreements?”
Thorin felt the old anger rise.
For an instant, he remembered his grandfather's pride, the glittering halls of Erebor, and the bitterness that had poisoned the relationship between their peoples.
He remembered standing before this very throne in his first life, furious and humiliated, choosing defiance when diplomacy might have spared them all.
He forced himself to breathe.
“My grandfather's decisions are not mine.”
Thranduil's gaze sharpened.
“Yet you bear his crown.”
“Not yet.”
“And when you do?”
Thorin straightened.
“When I reclaim Erebor, I will return the white gems to your house. I will have the agreement witnessed and recorded before we leave these halls.”
Fíli looked at him with unmistakable surprise.
Balin's expression softened.
Thranduil studied the dwarf for several moments.
“You offer me what should already have been returned.”
“I do.”
“And in exchange?”
“Safe passage. Provisions. The return of our weapons. An escort to the eastern edge of your territory, preferably as far as the route toward Lake-town.”
Thranduil's eyes narrowed.
“You ask much.”
“I offer more.”
“Do you?”
Thorin glanced briefly toward Fíli.
His nephew stood straight and attentive, listening to every word.
One day, if all went as Thorin hoped, Fíli would stand before rulers of his own.
He would negotiate treaties, settle disputes, and carry the weight of a kingdom upon his shoulders.
Thorin wanted him to see that strength did not always require a sword.
“I also offer renewed trade between Erebor and the Woodland Realm,” Thorin continued. “Timber, crafted goods, metals, stonework, and whatever other arrangements our representatives may negotiate in good faith.”
Thranduil regarded him with renewed interest.
“And you believe your people would welcome such an arrangement?”
“Some will object.”
“An understatement, I suspect.”
“Then they may object to their king.”
Fíli lowered his head to conceal a smile.
Thranduil noticed.
“And your heir agrees with this proposal?”
Thorin turned slightly.
“Fíli?”
The young dwarf looked up.
He had not expected to be addressed.
But he recovered quickly.
“I believe,” he said carefully, “that Erebor will need allies as much as it needs walls. My uncle has taught me that a kingdom cannot thrive upon gold alone.”
Thorin felt something warm and painful settle in his chest.
Thranduil's gaze moved between them.
“A thoughtful answer.”
Fíli inclined his head.
“Thank you, Your Majesty.”
Thorin could almost hear Dwalin's disbelief if he had witnessed the exchange.
Two members of the House of Durin speaking politely to an elven king.
The world truly had changed.
But Thorin had not yet made his most important request.
“There is another matter,” he said.
Thranduil's expression cooled.
“Of course there is.”
“Lake-town.”
The Elvenking became still.
“What of it?”
“If we succeed in entering Erebor, Smaug may awaken.”
“Indeed.”
“And if he leaves the mountain, the people of Lake-town may suffer for it.”
Thranduil regarded him in silence.
“You would have me send my army against a dragon?”
“No.”
The answer came immediately.
Thranduil paused.
Thorin continued.
“I would have you save those who cannot fight one.”
The Elvenking's eyes narrowed.
“Explain.”
Thorin stepped forward.
“If there are signs that Smaug has left the mountain, your scouts could warn the settlement. Your people know the forest and waterways better than any others. They could help guide civilians toward safer ground, assist with boats and evacuation, and prepare places of refuge.”
He hesitated.
In his mind, Lake-town burned.
He remembered the dragon's shadow passing over the rooftops. Remembered flames reflected upon the water and the cries of people fleeing into the night.
He remembered the survivors gathering among the ruins of Dale.
Hungry.
Cold.
Desperate.
He had seen what happened when a king cared more for his treasure than for those suffering beyond his gates.
He would not become that king again.
“And if the town is destroyed,” Thorin continued, his voice lower, “the survivors will need food, blankets, clean water, medicine, and shelter. They will need healers. They will need somewhere to take their children.”
Thranduil watched him closely.
“You speak as though this disaster is inevitable.”
“I hope it is not.”
“Yet you would have me prepare for it.”
“Yes.”
“And you offer payment for this?”
“Additional treasure from Erebor's treasury, beyond the gems already promised. A substantial sum, to be agreed upon in writing, for the preparations and aid your people provide.”
Thranduil rose slowly from his throne.
His robes whispered against the steps as he descended.
“You offer me gold to care for Men?”
Thorin met his eyes.
“I offer you gold to prepare for a disaster I may be responsible for unleashing.”
For the first time, Thranduil looked genuinely surprised.
“A remarkable admission from a son of Durin.”
Thorin's jaw tightened.
“I have learned that a crown does not excuse a king from the consequences of his decisions.”
Silence settled over the hall.
Thranduil stood before him, tall and pale, his gaze searching.
“You speak of this calamity as though you have already witnessed it.”
Thorin felt his heart stumble.
For one dreadful moment, he thought of Ravenhill.
Of blood staining the snow.
Of Bilbo weeping over him.
He lowered his gaze briefly.
“I have witnessed what happens when rulers fail to consider the cost of their ambitions.”
Thranduil's expression changed.
Only slightly.
But something in his eyes grew less cold.
“You have learned an unusual lesson.”
“One I would rather not learn again.”
The Elvenking studied him for a long time.
Then he turned away.
“Lake-town lies beyond my borders. I have no obligation to risk my people for its inhabitants.”
“I know.”
“Nor will I send warriors to challenge Smaug.”
“I have not asked you to.”
“And if your quest fails, your promises are worth nothing.”
Thorin inclined his head.
“That is true.”
Thranduil looked back.
“You are remarkably willing to acknowledge uncertainty.”
“I have discovered that refusing to acknowledge it does not make it disappear.”
Balin nearly smiled.
Thranduil returned to his throne.
At last, he spoke.
“I will consider your proposal.”
Thorin waited.
“The white gems shall be returned upon the restoration of Erebor. Trade may resume under terms to be negotiated by our representatives. Your Company will receive provisions and an escort through my territory.”
Fíli drew a quiet breath.
Thranduil continued.
“As for Lake-town, I will authorize preparations for evacuation assistance and relief should the dragon threaten it. My scouts will watch the eastern approaches. Supplies may be assembled, and healers made ready. The extent of our assistance will depend upon the danger and the resources available.”
Thorin bowed his head.
“You have my gratitude.”
“Do not mistake prudence for friendship, Thorin Oakenshield.”
“I would not presume to.”
A faint, almost imperceptible smile touched Thranduil's mouth.
“Then perhaps we understand one another.”
____________
The agreement took considerably longer to write than Thorin had anticipated.
Elves, he discovered, possessed an extraordinary talent for turning a simple promise into several pages of precise language.
Balin appeared delighted by the process.
Fíli listened carefully as terms were discussed, occasionally asking questions that earned approving glances from the elven scribes.
Thorin endured it all with diminishing patience.
But when the final document was presented, he examined it thoroughly before placing his name beneath the promises he had made.
Fíli signed as witness.
Balin followed.
Thranduil's representatives added their own names.
And with that, something changed.
It was not friendship.
It was not forgiveness.
But it was a beginning.
When the scribes departed, Thranduil remained seated, regarding Thorin with an expression of faint curiosity.
“There is another matter.”
Thorin looked up.
“My son tells me you lost a companion in the forest.”
The sudden mention of Bilbo struck him like a blow.
“We were separated.”
“A halfling, I believe.”
“A hobbit.”
“Of course.”
Thranduil folded his hands.
“And this hobbit is important to you.”
Thorin's expression tightened.
“He is a member of my Company.”
“That was not what I asked.”
Fíli looked very carefully at the floor.
Thorin met the Elvenking's gaze.
“Yes.”
Thranduil waited.
Thorin drew a slow breath.
“He is very dear to me.”
The words hung between them.
There was no embarrassment in Thorin's voice.
Only a quiet certainty.
Thranduil regarded him for a moment.
Then he inclined his head.
“I shall instruct my scouts to continue searching.”
Thorin's throat tightened unexpectedly.
“Thank you.”
The Elvenking looked away.
“Do not thank me until he is found.”
_____________
Bilbo found the Company by following the sound of Dwalin complaining.
It was, he reflected, an extraordinarily reliable method of navigation.
The dwarves had been given a spacious chamber with carved wooden furnishings, a long table, and several benches. Two guards remained outside the door, but the Company had been provided with water, fresh bread, fruit, and enough food to convince Bombur that their circumstances were improving considerably.
Bilbo slipped inside when a servant entered carrying another tray.
He waited behind a carved screen until the elf departed.
Then he removed the Ring.
The world seemed to warm around him.
He drew a shaky breath.
For a moment, he simply stood there, feeling the familiar weight of his body return.
The Ring rested in his palm.
He stared at it.
Then, with a sudden unpleasant shiver, he tucked it deep into his pocket.
“Bilbo?”
Ori's startled voice made him look up.
The young dwarf stood beside the table, a piece of bread halfway to his mouth.
Bilbo smiled weakly.
“Hello.”
The bread fell.
For one extraordinary moment, nobody moved.
Then Kíli shouted.
“BILBO!”
The room erupted.
Bofur nearly overturned a chair. Bombur abandoned his meal. Dori demanded to know where the hobbit had come from, while Nori immediately began laughing.
Kíli reached him first.
He threw both arms around Bilbo so enthusiastically that the hobbit staggered backward.
“You're alive!”
“Yes, well, I was rather hoping to remain so!”
Fíli and Balin entered at that exact moment.
Both stopped.
Balin's face softened.
Fíli stared.
Then he grinned.
“Oh, Uncle is going to lose his mind.”
Bilbo blinked.
“Your uncle?”
“Where is he?” Kíli demanded.
“With the Elvenking,” Fíli answered. “He should be here shortly.”
Bilbo's smile faded slightly.
He remembered Thorin calling his name in the forest.
The fear in his voice.
The way he had looked back again and again.
“Is he all right?” Bilbo asked quietly.
Fíli's expression gentled.
“He will be.”
Thorin entered the chamber several minutes later.
He was still speaking to Balin about the agreement when he heard a familiar voice.
“Well, I must say, that went considerably better than I expected.”
He stopped.
The words were ordinary.
Cheerful.
A little breathless.
And so achingly familiar that for a moment he could not understand what he was hearing.
Then he looked up.
Bilbo stood beside the table.
His curls were tangled, his clothes filthy, and there was a fresh scrape along one cheek.
He looked exhausted.
He looked alive.
He looked like the most beautiful thing Thorin had ever seen.
“Bilbo?”
The hobbit smiled.
“Hello, Thorin.”
Thorin crossed the room.
He did not remember moving.
One moment he stood in the doorway, and the next Bilbo was in his arms.
Thorin held him tightly, one hand pressed against the back of his head, the other wrapped around his shoulders.
Bilbo made a startled sound.
Then he returned the embrace.
“Oh,” he whispered.
Thorin buried his face against the hobbit's curls.
For a moment, he could not speak.
He could feel Bilbo breathing.
Could feel the warmth of him.
Could hear his heartbeat.
Alive.
Alive.
Alive.
“I thought—”
His voice failed.
Bilbo tightened his arms.
“I know.”
“I couldn't find you.”
“I know.”
Thorin drew him closer.
“Bilbo…”
“I'm here.”
The hobbit's voice trembled.
“I'm right here, Thorin.”
Thorin closed his eyes.
In another life, he had held Bilbo while dying.
He remembered the warmth of the hobbit's hands against his face, the desperate tears, the words they had exchanged too late.
He remembered believing that he would never hear Bilbo's voice again.
And now—
Now Bilbo was holding him.
Not in grief.
Not in farewell.
But because he had returned.
Thorin's breath shuddered.
Bilbo gently rubbed his back.
“You'll have to forgive me,” the hobbit murmured. “I seem to have made rather a dramatic entrance.”
A broken laugh escaped Thorin.
“You have a talent for it.”
“So I've been told.”
They remained together for another moment.
Around them, the Company had fallen quiet.
Even Kíli did not interrupt.
At last, Thorin drew back just enough to look at Bilbo's face.
“You're hurt.”
“Only a little.”
“Your cheek—”
“A branch.”
“Your shoulder?”
“Another branch.”
Thorin frowned.
“How many branches did you encounter?”
Bilbo considered.
“An unreasonable number.”
Thorin laughed again.
This time, the sound was steadier.
He rested his forehead briefly against Bilbo's.
“You frightened me.”
Bilbo's expression softened.
“I know.”
“Do not do it again.”
“I shall endeavour to be considerably less troublesome in future.”
Thorin gave him a look.
Bilbo smiled.
“Although I cannot promise miracles.”
Their relief was interrupted by a knock.
A guard entered.
“King Thranduil requests the presence of the hobbit.”
Bilbo went pale.
“Oh.”
Dwalin folded his arms.
“Seems the Elvenking's heard about our burglar.”
Thorin's expression hardened.
“He will not go alone.”
The guard hesitated.
“His Majesty has requested—”
“Then inform His Majesty that I shall accompany him.”
Bilbo glanced up at Thorin.
For a moment, he looked as though he might protest.
Then he sighed.
“Well. I suppose I was going to meet him eventually.”
_____________
Thranduil regarded the hobbit standing before his throne with unmistakable curiosity.
Bilbo bowed.
Rather awkwardly.
“Your Majesty.”
“So,” the Elvenking said. “You are the missing halfling.”
“Hobbit, actually.”
Thranduil's eyebrow rose.
“Indeed.”
“Yes. Bilbo Baggins, at your service.”
“How curious.”
Bilbo swallowed.
Thorin stood beside him, his expression carefully neutral.
Thranduil leaned forward.
“My guards searched the forest for you.”
“Yes, Your Majesty.”
“They found nothing.”
“So I understand.”
“And yet you are now standing inside my kingdom.”
Bilbo shifted his weight.
“Yes.”
“How?”
A silence followed.
Bilbo glanced toward Thorin.
The dwarf did not rescue him.
But he did offer the smallest encouraging nod.
Bilbo drew a breath.
“Well, I followed your guards.”
Thranduil stared.
“You followed them.”
“Yes.”
“Through the forest.”
“Yes.”
“Past the watchposts.”
“More or less.”
“And through the gates of my kingdom.”
Bilbo winced.
“When you put it like that, it does sound rather improper.”
Legolas, standing beside the throne, looked deeply offended.
“You were behind us?”
Bilbo turned toward him.
“Not all the time.”
“Where were you?”
“Sometimes beside you.”
Legolas stared.
Thranduil slowly turned his head toward his son.
Legolas looked as though he wished the floor would open beneath him.
Bilbo hurried to explain.
“I'm terribly sorry. I didn't mean to cause trouble. But my friends had been taken away, and I wasn't certain what would happen to them, and I thought perhaps I might be able to help.”
Thranduil studied him.
“And none of my guards saw you?”
Bilbo gave an apologetic little shrug.
“Hobbits are rather good at moving quietly.”
“Apparently.”
“I assure you, Your Majesty, your guards were very impressive.”
“Were they?”
“Oh, exceedingly.”
“And yet you passed them all.”
Bilbo hesitated.
“Well, they were rather occupied with thirteen dwarves.”
Thorin made a suspicious sound.
Bilbo glanced at him.
The dwarf was looking toward the ceiling with extraordinary concentration.
Thranduil noticed.
“And you find this amusing, Thorin Oakenshield?”
“Not at all.”
“You are smiling.”
“A misunderstanding.”
“Indeed.”
Bilbo wished desperately that someone would change the subject.
Thranduil folded his hands.
“Tell me, Master Baggins. Did you enter my halls intending to steal something?”
Bilbo looked genuinely scandalized.
“Certainly not!”
“You call yourself a burglar.”
Bilbo blinked.
Then he turned toward Thorin.
“Did you tell him that?”
Thorin looked mildly guilty.
“It may have been mentioned.”
Bilbo sighed.
“Well, yes, technically, but I haven't actually burgled anything here.”
Thranduil regarded him.
“An impressive distinction.”
“Thank you.”
“I was not complimenting you.”
“Oh.”
For the first time, the Elvenking's mouth curved very slightly.
Thorin stepped forward.
“Master Baggins is a member of my Company. He came here to ensure our safety, and he has taken nothing from your halls. I ask that he be included under the terms of our agreement.”
Thranduil looked between them.
His gaze lingered upon the way Thorin stood slightly closer to Bilbo than necessary.
Then he inclined his head.
“Very well.”
Bilbo exhaled.
“Thank you, Your Majesty.”
“Though I would advise you not to make a habit of entering my kingdom unnoticed.”
Bilbo nodded earnestly.
“Of course.”
Thranduil turned toward Legolas.
“And perhaps our guards might benefit from reviewing their procedures.”
Legolas closed his eyes briefly.
“Yes, Father.”
Thorin's shoulders shook once.
Bilbo elbowed him.
Gently.
But with considerable meaning.
______________
Later that evening, Thranduil stood upon a balcony overlooking the underground river.
Legolas joined him.
For a while, neither spoke.
Then the prince said, “You believe the hobbit's explanation?”
“Parts of it.”
“He could not have followed us without being seen.”
“And yet he did.”
Legolas frowned.
“There is something unusual about him.”
“Undoubtedly.”
“And Thorin Oakenshield?”
Thranduil looked toward the distant halls.
“More unusual still.”
Legolas hesitated.
“He was not what I expected.”
“No.”
“He surrendered his weapons. He negotiated. He offered to return the gems.”
“And he asked us to prepare aid for Men who have not yet suffered any disaster.”
Legolas nodded.
“Why?”
Thranduil was silent for a long moment.
He remembered Thorin's expression when he spoke of Lake-town.
The grief behind his eyes.
The terrible certainty with which he described suffering that had not yet occurred.
“I do not know,” the Elvenking answered.
Then, more quietly, “But he speaks like a king who has already witnessed the ruin of his kingdom.”
Legolas looked toward him.
Thranduil did not explain further.
Instead, he turned back toward the river.
“See that our guests are properly supplied tomorrow.”
“Yes, Father.”
“And Legolas?”
The prince paused.
“You will accompany them.”
Legolas inclined his head.
“As you wish.”
Thranduil's gaze returned to the darkness beyond the halls.
“Watch them carefully.”
“The dwarves?”
“The hobbit.”
Legolas frowned.
“You believe him dangerous?”
Thranduil's expression remained perfectly composed.
“No. I believe he is considerably more interesting than he wishes us to think.”
By the time the Company had finished supper, Bilbo was beginning to feel human again.
Or hobbit, rather.
He had eaten more than was strictly necessary, washed the worst of the forest from his hands and face, and finally sat down beside Thorin with a cup of warm tea.
The others were scattered around the chamber.
Bombur had fallen asleep after his second helping of supper. Bofur was quietly singing while repairing a strap. Kíli and Fíli were arguing about whether elven architecture was impressive or merely unnecessarily complicated.
Dwalin had announced that he distrusted the entire kingdom.
Then he had eaten three servings of its food.
Bilbo considered this a promising beginning.
Thorin sat beside him, unusually quiet.
The hobbit glanced at him.
“Are you tired?”
“A little.”
“Your hair has come undone.”
Thorin touched the loose braid near his temple.
“So it has.”
Bilbo set down his tea.
“Would you like me to fix it?”
Thorin looked at him.
For a moment, his expression softened in a way that made Bilbo's stomach flutter.
“Yes,” he answered.
Bilbo shifted closer.
He gently gathered the loose strands, smoothing them between his fingers.
Thorin lowered his head to make the task easier.
For several minutes, neither spoke.
The room was warm.
The Company's quiet conversations drifted around them.
Beyond the doors, the underground river murmured against the stone.
It was almost peaceful.
Then Thorin spoke.
“How did you escape the spiders?”
Bilbo's fingers paused.
“I hid.”
“And the elves?”
“I followed them.”
“Without being seen.”
Bilbo swallowed.
“Yes.”
Thorin was silent.
He remembered Bilbo crouched among the roots, desperately searching for something.
Remembered the strange expression upon his face.
The sharp, possessive refusal when Thorin told him to leave it.
He could ask.
He could demand an explanation.
He could insist that Bilbo reveal whatever secret he had been keeping.
But he remembered the hobbit's words in Mirkwood.
You cannot protect me from everything.
And he remembered how much courage it had taken for Bilbo to return to them.
Thorin lowered his gaze.
“I'm glad you found us.”
Bilbo's hands resumed their work.
“So am I.”
A pause.
“Thorin?”
“Hm?”
“I heard you in the forest.”
Thorin went still.
Bilbo carefully separated another strand of hair.
“When the elves took you. I heard you calling for me.”
Thorin closed his eyes.
“I thought you were dead.”
“I know.”
“I thought—”
He stopped.
Bilbo gently rested a hand against his shoulder.
“You don't have to explain.”
Thorin turned slightly.
The hobbit's eyes were warm and earnest.
“I was frightened too,” Bilbo admitted. “But I knew I couldn't leave you there.”
Thorin looked at him for a long moment.
Then he reached for Bilbo's hand.
He held it carefully between his own.
“You have given me more reasons to be grateful than I know how to name.”
Bilbo's cheeks warmed.
“Oh, well.”
Thorin smiled faintly.
“An eloquent answer.”
“I am capable of better ones when I'm not being stared at.”
“Then I shall endeavour to stare less.”
“I didn't say that.”
The words escaped before Bilbo could stop them.
Thorin's smile deepened.
Bilbo looked down at their joined hands.
For a moment, the air between them seemed to grow very still.
Then Kíli shouted from across the chamber.
“BILBO! FÍLI SAYS ELVEN BREAD IS BETTER THAN DWARVEN BREAD!”
Bilbo closed his eyes.
Thorin sighed.
“Does he?”
“HE DOES!”
Fíli's indignant voice followed.
“I SAID IT WAS GOOD BREAD!”
Bilbo began to laugh.
The moment passed.
But when he returned to Thorin's braid, the dwarf remained close enough that their shoulders touched.
Neither moved away.
_____________
The following morning, the Company discovered that Thranduil had honoured his promises.
Their weapons were returned, cleaned and properly maintained. Orcrist was placed in Thorin's hands by an elven guard who looked distinctly reluctant to surrender such a blade.
Bilbo received Sting with visible relief.
There were fresh provisions, waterskins, blankets, medicinal supplies, and enough food for several days' travel.
Bofur inspected the bundles appreciatively.
“Now this,” he declared, “is the sort of hospitality I can understand.”
Dwalin grunted.
“Don't get accustomed to it.”
Bombur was already examining the food.
Thorin approached Thranduil near the entrance to the halls.
The Elvenking stood with Legolas and several armed warriors.
“Your escort is prepared,” Thranduil said. “My son will lead you through the remaining forest and toward the river route to Lake-town.”
Thorin inclined his head.
“You have kept your word.”
“As I expect you to keep yours.”
“I shall.”
Thranduil regarded him for a moment.
Then his gaze moved toward Bilbo, who was standing beside Fíli and Kíli, examining a small packet of herbs provided by an elven healer.
“Your hobbit appears considerably less distressed than he did yesterday.”
Thorin looked toward him.
Bilbo was smiling at something Kíli had said.
The sight warmed him.
“He is resilient.”
“So I have observed.”
Thranduil paused.
“See that he does not wander into my kingdom unnoticed again.”
Thorin's mouth twitched.
“I shall endeavour to prevent it.”
“I suspect you will find that difficult.”
Thorin looked at Bilbo once more.
“Aye,” he admitted. “I suspect I shall.”
For a moment, the two rulers stood together in silence.
Then Thranduil inclined his head.
“May your road be less troubled than the one that brought you here.”
Thorin returned the gesture.
“And may your people know peace.”
It was not friendship.
Not yet.
But when Thorin turned away, he found that the old bitterness no longer weighed quite so heavily upon him.
_____________
The Company departed beneath the morning light.
Legolas led the escort, accompanied by several Woodland Realm warriors whose bows and blades gleamed beneath their cloaks.
Fíli and Kíli walked near the front, arguing cheerfully about who had killed more spiders.
Dwalin remained suspicious of the elves.
Balin seemed quietly delighted by the successful negotiations.
And Bilbo walked beside Thorin, his pack newly filled, his sword at his hip, and his curls still slightly damp from the morning's washing.
For a while, they travelled in comfortable silence.
Then Bilbo noticed a small flowering plant growing beside the path.
He stopped.
“Oh!”
Thorin looked down.
“What is it?”
“Look at that.”
Thorin examined the plant.
It had narrow silver-green leaves and tiny pale blossoms.
“A flower.”
Bilbo gave him an exasperated look.
“Yes, thank you. I had gathered that much.”
Legolas, walking a few paces ahead, glanced back.
“That is a moonbell.”
Bilbo brightened immediately.
“A moonbell?”
“It flowers only beneath the oldest trees. Its petals close when touched.”
Bilbo crouched beside it.
“How extraordinary.”
Legolas approached.
“They were once common throughout Greenwood. Now they are rarely seen so far east.”
Bilbo looked up.
“Does it require a particular sort of soil?”
Legolas considered the question.
Then, to Thorin's considerable surprise, he knelt beside the hobbit.
“It does. The roots prefer damp earth beneath beech and oak, though they may survive beneath other trees if the ground remains shaded.”
Bilbo listened with unmistakable fascination.
“And do they grow from seeds?”
“Sometimes. More often from spreading roots.”
“Oh, how interesting!”
Thorin watched them.
Then he glanced toward Fíli.
His nephew was smiling.
Kíli, however, looked distinctly unimpressed.
“It's a flower,” he muttered.
Fíli grinned.
“I believe that's already been established.”
Bilbo asked another question.
Legolas answered.
And as the Company resumed its journey, the hobbit fell into step beside the elven prince, discussing the plants of Mirkwood with an enthusiasm that seemed entirely unaffected by the fact that the forest had recently attempted to eat him.
Kíli watched them go.
Then he looked at his brother.
“Since when does Bilbo like elves?”
Fíli laughed.
Thorin shook his head, though there was a faint smile upon his face.
Ahead, Bilbo's delighted laughter carried through the trees.
And for the first time in many days, Thorin allowed himself to believe that perhaps the road before them might hold something other than sorrow.
He had changed the course of their journey.
He had negotiated where once he had fought.
He had made promises that might save lives.
And Bilbo was beside him.
Alive.
Smiling.
Safe, at least for now.
Yet beyond the trees, the Lonely Mountain waited.
And somewhere in the wilderness, orcs still hunted the heirs of Durin.
Thorin knew better than to believe that danger had passed.
But as he watched Bilbo enthusiastically question Legolas about a particularly ancient tree, he found himself smiling.
For the moment, that was enough.
