Chapter Text
The first arrows fell before the sun had cleared the mountains.
They came from the northern slopes in a dark, hissing cloud, striking shields, stone, and the abandoned roofs of Dale. A warning cry rose from the elven ranks, followed by the thunder of dwarven shields locking together. Somewhere beyond the ruins, a horn answered the call of the enemy, its ugly note rolling through the valley like the growl of something enormous awakening beneath the earth.
Thorin Oakenshield stood upon the lower steps of Erebor, watching the armies of the north advance.
He had seen this before.
Not precisely like this. The positions of the allied forces were different, the gates of Erebor stood open rather than barred against the world, and Dáin's warriors were already fighting beside the elves and men instead of preparing to turn their weapons against them. The changes Thorin had made over the past year had reshaped almost everything about this morning.
Yet the orcs were still coming.
And somewhere beyond the battlefield, Azog the Defiler was waiting.
“My king.”
Dwalin approached through the gathering smoke, his armour already marked by the first exchanges. He carried his axe across one shoulder, though his expression was unusually grave.
“The eastern line is holding. Dáin has placed his shield-bearers before the ruins, and the elves are covering the northern approach. Bard's archers have taken the upper walls of Dale.”
Thorin nodded, studying the valley.
“Have the men withdraw behind the second barricade if the orcs breach the lower street. The buildings will narrow their approach.”
“Aye.”
“And tell Dáin not to pursue if they retreat. Azog will want us separated.”
Dwalin regarded him.
“You sound certain.”
Thorin's fingers tightened around the hilt of Orcrist.
“I know our enemy.”
It was not quite a lie.
Dwalin looked as though he wanted to ask something more, but another volley of arrows struck the stone nearby, and the moment passed.
Thorin descended the steps.
Around him, the warriors of Erebor moved into formation beneath banners that had not flown over their ancestral home in generations. Dwarves who had spent their lives in exile now stood shoulder to shoulder with those who had come from the Iron Hills. Beyond them, the green and silver of the Woodland Realm mingled with the rougher colours of Dale.
Thorin remembered a battlefield divided by suspicion.
He remembered looking upon Thranduil and seeing an enemy, upon Bard and seeing a thief, upon Dáin and seeing an army he might command to defend his gold.
Today, Thranduil's archers were protecting Dáin's flanks, and Bard's men were carrying wounded dwarves to safety.
It should have been enough to reassure him.
But then he saw Fíli and Kíli moving toward the forward ranks, and the cold hand of memory closed around his throat.
“Fíli!”
Both nephews turned.
Fíli approached first, adjusting the strap of his shield.
“Yes, Uncle?”
“You will remain with Dáin's second company. Neither of you is to pursue an enemy beyond the eastern barricade.”
Kíli frowned.
“We know.”
“And if the northern flank breaks, you fall back toward the gates.”
“We know that too,” Kíli said.
Thorin looked at him sharply.
The younger dwarf's expression softened.
“Uncle,” he said, lowering his voice, “we heard you last night.”
Thorin's gaze flickered toward the faint bruise across his own jaw.
Kíli noticed.
For an awkward moment, neither spoke.
Then Kíli stepped closer and briefly squeezed Thorin's shoulder.
“I'm sorry I struck you.”
Thorin looked at his nephew's face, so alive and painfully young beneath the edge of his helmet.
“I know.”
“I was angry.”
“You had reason to be.”
“That doesn't mean I should have done it.”
“No,” Thorin agreed gently. “It doesn't.”
Kíli nodded, visibly relieved that they could speak of it without another argument.
Fíli glanced toward the battlefield, where the first orcs had reached the outer barricades.
“We should go.”
Thorin caught his eldest nephew by the forearm.
“Stay together.”
Fíli gave him a small smile.
“We intend to.”
Thorin released him.
He watched them run toward Dáin's ranks, Fíli's golden hair and Kíli's dark braids disappearing among the helmets.
For one terrible instant, he saw them lying motionless upon Ravenhill.
Then Kíli turned and shouted something outrageous at his brother, earning a shove in return, and the vision shattered.
They were alive.
Thorin would keep them that way.
______________
By midmorning, the valley had become a place of smoke, iron, and shouting.
The first wave of orcs struck Dáin's shield wall with enough force to drive the front ranks backward several paces. Steel scraped against steel, and the air filled with the harsh cries of dwarves struggling to hold their ground. Behind them, elven arrows passed overhead in disciplined volleys, cutting down enemies attempting to climb the ruined walls.
Fíli stood in the second rank when the first breach appeared.
Three orcs forced their way between two shields, one carrying a hooked spear that caught a dwarven warrior beneath the arm.
Fíli moved before the wounded dwarf had finished falling.
He drove his sword beneath the spear-bearer's guard, twisted free, and caught the next attack upon his shield. The impact jarred his shoulder, but he held firm until Kíli appeared beside him and buried a blade in the creature's side.
“Left!” Fíli shouted.
“I have eyes!”
“Then use them!”
Kíli ducked beneath a swinging axe.
“I was using them to admire your leadership!”
Fíli almost smiled.
Almost.
A fourth orc came over the barricade, and both brothers turned to meet it.
They had fought together since they were old enough to hold practice swords, first beneath their mother's watchful eye and later under Thorin's demanding instruction. Fíli knew the exact moment Kíli would shift his weight before striking. Kíli knew when his brother needed space to draw one of the knives concealed beneath his armour.
They moved together without thinking.
When the immediate danger passed, Kíli leaned against the barricade, breathing hard.
“Do you think Uncle Bilbo is all right?”
Fíli glanced toward the mountain.
“He's with Óin.”
“That wasn't what I asked.”
Fíli understood.
He remembered Bilbo curled between them the previous night, crying because he thought the family he loved might no longer want him.
“He'll be all right,” Fíli said.
Kíli wiped his blade.
“We promised them we'd come back.”
“Then we'd better keep that promise.”
A horn sounded from the eastern line.
Fíli straightened.
“Come on.”
They returned to the fighting.
_____________
Bilbo had never imagined that battle would smell so much like wet wool.
There was blood, certainly, and smoke from burning timbers, and the unpleasant sharpness of spilled lamp oil. But beneath it all lingered the scent of soaked cloaks, muddy boots, and the blankets Óin had ordered carried from Erebor's storerooms.
The healing station had been established within the remains of a large stone building behind the allied lines. Its roof was partly missing, but three walls remained standing, and the surviving chambers offered some protection from the arrows that occasionally passed over the ruins.
Bilbo had spent the morning carrying water, fetching bandages, and doing his best not to get in Óin's way.
“Not that one,” Óin barked when Bilbo reached for a bottle. “The brown jar.”
Bilbo exchanged the bottle for the correct jar.
“Sorry.”
“And stop apologizing. You're doing fine.”
Bilbo managed a tired smile.
An injured dwarf lay on the table before them, his shoulder wrapped in bloodstained linen. Bilbo held a fresh bandage while Óin worked, trying not to look at the wound itself.
Outside, another horn sounded.
Bilbo's hands tightened.
Óin noticed.
“They're still holding.”
“You can't possibly know that.”
“If they weren't, we'd have considerably more company.”
Bilbo gave a weak laugh.
Óin tied the bandage securely and motioned for the wounded warrior to be helped away.
“Go and get yourself something to drink, lad.”
“I've only just—”
“Bilbo.”
The hobbit sighed.
“Yes, Óin.”
He stepped into the courtyard, where several volunteers were distributing water among the wounded. Beyond the broken archway, he could see the distant movements of the battle.
He searched instinctively for dark armour and a familiar blue cloak.
There were too many dwarves.
Too much smoke.
He could not distinguish one figure from another.
He wondered whether Thorin had eaten anything that morning.
The thought was so ordinary that it hurt.
Only yesterday he would have found some excuse to bring him food, scolding him gently for neglecting himself. Thorin would have complained about being fussed over, though he would eventually have eaten whatever Bilbo put before him.
Bilbo rubbed his eyes.
He still loved him.
That had not changed.
But the memory of the treasure hall remained, and whenever he imagined returning to Thorin's arms, he heard the words that had driven him away.
Perhaps I was a fool to give you a place in my family.
Bilbo lowered his hand.
No.
Fíli and Kíli had made one thing very clear.
Whatever happened between him and Thorin, he had not lost them.
He touched his loose curls, remembering Kíli's arms around him and Fíli's quiet promise.
Then he picked up another bucket and returned to work.
______________
From Ravenhill, Azog watched the battle unfold with growing displeasure.
The pale orc stood upon a high platform of weathered stone, surrounded by his most trusted hunters. Below him, the valley spread out in a confusion of ruined streets and moving armies.
His first assault had failed to break the dwarven line.
His second had driven the men from an outer barricade, only for elven archers to turn the narrow approach into a killing ground.
And Oakenshield had not come.
Azog had expected him.
The dwarf king had pursued vengeance for decades. He had crossed mountains and kingdoms with hatred burning in his heart, and Azog knew well enough how to use that hatred.
Ravenhill was the perfect place to finish what had begun outside Moria.
He had left his strongest guards among its broken towers, prepared narrow approaches where dwarves could be separated and surrounded, and positioned his hunters along the paths leading upward.
But Thorin Oakenshield remained below.
Worse, he was commanding the allied forces with an infuriating patience.
Azog watched him direct reinforcements toward the eastern line, then pull his warriors back before an apparent retreat could lure them into the open.
The dwarf was refusing every invitation.
Azog bared his teeth.
Beside him, a lieutenant shifted uneasily.
“The dwarves will not break.”
“They will.”
“Their king will not leave the field.”
Azog turned his pale gaze upon him.
“Then we will give him a reason.”
He looked back toward the valley.
Oakenshield was standing beside a broken wall, speaking with another dwarf. His sword hung at his side, and his attention appeared fixed upon the fighting.
Then, for the briefest moment, the king turned his head.
Not toward Ravenhill.
Toward the rear of the allied lines.
Azog followed his gaze.
Near the ruined buildings beneath Erebor, small figures moved among the wounded. He saw dwarves carrying stretchers, men fetching water, and one unusually small creature with darkened golden-brown curls helping an injured warrior across a courtyard.
Azog might have dismissed the creature entirely.
But Oakenshield was still watching.
And when the little figure disappeared safely through an archway, the dwarf king's shoulders eased.
Azog narrowed his eyes.
A few minutes later, a small group of orcs pushed toward that same section of the ruins.
Oakenshield reacted immediately.
He signalled for reinforcements, sending a dozen warriors to strengthen the approach before the attackers had come within striking distance of the healing station.
Azog watched.
Then he began to smile.
“The little one,” he said.
His lieutenant followed his gaze.
“A halfling?”
Azog had heard reports of such a creature travelling with the dwarves. He had dismissed them as unimportant. Oakenshield's company had always been a collection of peculiar fools.
Now he wondered.
“Bring him to me.”
The lieutenant hesitated.
“The halfling?”
“Alive.”
Azog turned fully toward him.
“And make certain Oakenshield knows who has taken him.”
The orc bowed and hurried away.
Azog looked down at the battlefield again.
He had spent years trying to destroy the line of Durin.
Perhaps he had been looking at the wrong weakness.
_______________
The fighting worsened after midday.
A fresh wave of orcs emerged from the northern slopes, driving toward the space between Bard's men and the elven archers. Thranduil answered with a charge that carried his warriors through the ruined streets, their blades flashing beneath the grey sky.
Thorin saw the movement from his position near the eastern barricade.
“Dwalin!”
His friend turned.
“Take twenty warriors to the northern crossing. Bard must not be cut off.”
“Aye.”
“And send word to Dáin that the enemy is trying to draw us apart.”
Dwalin studied him briefly.
“Still worried about Ravenhill?”
Thorin looked toward the distant height.
“Yes.”
He could almost see the place where Fíli had fallen.
The memory came without warning: Kíli's cry, the terrible emptiness that followed, and the certainty that he had failed them both.
He forced himself to look away.
“Azog is waiting for us to make a mistake.”
Dwalin nodded and hurried off.
Thorin remained beside the barricade, directing the movement of his warriors while the battle shifted around him.
At intervals, he found himself looking toward the healing station.
He told himself it was because the wounded needed protection.
That was true.
But he was also searching for a small figure moving between the ruined walls.
Once, he saw Bilbo crossing the courtyard with a bundle of clean cloth beneath one arm.
Even at that distance, Thorin recognized the determined way he walked.
He felt a painful rush of relief.
Bilbo was alive.
He watched until the hobbit disappeared inside.
Then he returned his attention to the battle.
He did not know that, high above the valley, someone had watched him do it.
_____________
The first warning came when an injured man arrived at the healing station without the two guards who had been escorting him.
Bilbo was helping Óin prepare another bed when the man stumbled through the archway, his face grey with shock.
“Orcs,” he gasped. “Behind the western wall.”
Óin looked up sharply.
“How many?”
“I don't know. They came through the lower passage.”
Bilbo set down the blankets.
The western passage connected the ruined streets to the narrow courtyard behind the healing station. It had been guarded throughout the morning, though the fighting had gradually drawn warriors toward the main barricades.
Óin swore.
“Get everyone who can walk inside the mountain. Now.”
The courtyard erupted into movement.
Bilbo helped an elderly dwarf rise from his chair, guiding him toward the eastern exit while other volunteers gathered the wounded.
A cry sounded beyond the western wall.
Then steel rang against stone.
Bilbo looked back.
Three guards were fighting beneath the broken archway.
Behind them, dark figures were climbing through the ruins.
Orcs.
“Bilbo!” Óin shouted. “Move!”
Bilbo hurried the elderly dwarf toward the eastern passage.
They had almost reached it when an arrow struck the wall beside them.
The old dwarf stumbled.
Bilbo caught him beneath the arm.
“Come along,” he urged. “Just a little farther.”
A volunteer rushed forward to help.
Together they brought the dwarf through the passage, where two armed warriors were waiting to escort the wounded toward Erebor.
Bilbo could have gone with them.
He knew that.
He could have run into the mountain and waited until the danger passed.
Instead, he heard someone crying behind him.
A young dwarven soldier lay beside an overturned stretcher, one leg trapped beneath a fallen beam. He was barely older than Fíli, with blood running down the side of his face.
The other volunteers were already retreating.
Bilbo looked toward the safety of the passage.
Then back at the soldier.
“Oh, bother,” he whispered.
He ran toward him.
“Can you move?”
The dwarf shook his head.
Bilbo knelt beside the beam and pushed.
It did not budge.
He tried again, planting his feet against the stones.
The wood shifted slightly.
The soldier cried out.
“I'm sorry,” Bilbo gasped. “I'm terribly sorry, but we must get you out.”
A crash sounded behind them.
The western archway had fallen.
Bilbo glanced over his shoulder.
An orc stepped through the dust.
Then another.
Bilbo's heart hammered.
His hand went instinctively toward the pocket where the Ring lay hidden.
For one desperate moment, he imagined slipping it onto his finger and vanishing.
He could escape.
But the wounded dwarf could not.
Bilbo withdrew his empty hand.
“Listen to me,” he told the soldier. “When I lift this, you must pull your leg free.”
“I can't—”
“Yes, you can.”
He braced himself against the beam.
“One. Two. Three!”
With a strength born entirely of desperation, Bilbo heaved.
The beam rose just enough.
The dwarf dragged his leg free.
“Go!” Bilbo cried.
The soldier scrambled toward the eastern passage.
Bilbo turned to follow.
A heavy hand seized him by the back of his coat.
He was lifted bodily from the ground.
Sting flashed into his hand.
He slashed backward, and the orc holding him roared as the blade cut across its arm.
Bilbo dropped hard onto the stones.
He scrambled to his feet.
Another orc blocked the passage.
Bilbo raised Sting.
“Get away from me!”
The creature lunged.
Bilbo ducked beneath its arm, but a second attacker struck him across the shoulder with the haft of a weapon.
Pain exploded through his side.
He fell.
Before he could rise, rough fingers closed around his wrists.
He kicked, twisted, and bit the hand nearest his face.
The orc cursed.
“Hold still, little rat!”
Bilbo fought harder.
He had survived trolls, goblins, spiders, and a dragon. He was not about to surrender quietly to a handful of ugly brutes.
Then a third orc approached, taller than the others, with a jagged scar crossing one eye.
It looked down at Bilbo.
“That's the one.”
Bilbo went cold.
The orc seized his chin, forcing his face upward.
“The dwarf king's little pet.”
Bilbo spat at him.
The creature struck him across the face.
His head snapped sideways, and for a moment the world blurred.
“Careful,” another orc warned. “Azog wants him alive.”
Bilbo stopped struggling for half a heartbeat.
Azog.
He knew that name.
He knew what the pale orc had done to Thorin's family, how many years of grief and hatred lay between them.
And suddenly he understood.
They had not stumbled upon the healing station by chance.
They had come for him.
Bilbo's stomach twisted.
“No,” he whispered.
The scarred orc laughed.
“Oh, yes.”
It hauled him upright and bound his wrists with coarse rope.
Bilbo twisted toward the eastern passage.
The wounded soldier had escaped.
At least there was that.
Then the orcs dragged him through the ruined archway and into the smoke.
_____________
Thorin first realized something was wrong when the reinforcements he had sent toward the healing station failed to return.
A moment later, a dwarven runner stumbled through the eastern ranks.
“My king!”
Thorin caught him by the shoulders.
“What happened?”
“Orcs breached the western passage. The wounded are being evacuated, but—”
The dwarf hesitated.
Thorin felt the blood drain from his face.
“But what?”
“The halfling, my lord. Master Baggins. He stayed behind to help one of the injured.”
Thorin released him.
“Where is he?”
“We don't know.”
The sounds of battle seemed to recede.
For one terrible instant, Thorin was back in Lake-town, searching through smoke and burning timbers while Bilbo remained nowhere to be found.
Then he heard another voice.
“Thorin!”
Dwalin was running toward him.
Behind his friend, a group of dwarves had gathered near the ruined wall, their weapons raised toward the western streets.
Dwalin's expression told Thorin everything before he spoke.
“There's something you need to see.”
Thorin followed him through the broken barricade.
Beyond the ruins, a narrow road climbed toward the northern slopes.
Several orcs stood upon it.
Between them struggled a small figure in a torn green coat.
Bilbo.
Thorin stopped breathing.
His hands were bound. Blood marked one cheek, and his coat hung crookedly from his shoulders, but he was standing.
Alive.
Then one of the orcs seized Bilbo by the hair and forced his head back.
Thorin surged forward.
Dwalin caught his arm.
“Wait!”
“Let go!”
“Thorin, look!”
The scarred orc raised a curved blade beside Bilbo's throat.
Across the distance, its voice rang out.
“Oakenshield!”
Thorin went utterly still.
The creature grinned.
“The pale one belongs to Azog now!”
Bilbo struggled violently.
“Thorin, don't!”
The orc jerked him backward.
“Quiet!”
Bilbo ignored it.
“It's a trap!”
Thorin's heart twisted at the sound of his voice.
He could see how frightened Bilbo was, though the hobbit was doing his best to conceal it. His curls had fallen across his face, and one sleeve was dark with blood.
Yet he was still trying to protect Thorin.
Even now.
Even after everything.
Dwalin tightened his grip.
“They want you to follow.”
Thorin knew.
He knew with a certainty that made him sick.
Azog had waited upon Ravenhill for the proud king who would come seeking vengeance.
When that king refused, Azog had found another way to draw him out.
Thorin looked toward the distant height.
Somewhere among those broken towers, the pale orc was watching.
Waiting.
He remembered another life in which he had gone to Ravenhill and never returned.
He remembered Fíli dying alone.
Kíli falling.
Bilbo kneeling beside him in the snow.
And now Azog had Bilbo.
Thorin felt the familiar darkness stir at the edges of his thoughts, urging him toward rage, toward reckless violence, toward the terrible certainty that he must destroy anything threatening what belonged to him.
His fingers closed around Orcrist.
Then, beneath his armour, he felt the small silver bead pressing against his chest.
I still love you. That's what makes this so difficult.
Thorin shut his eyes for one brief moment.
When he opened them, Dwalin was watching him.
“Thorin?”
The orcs were already dragging Bilbo farther up the road.
Every instinct in Thorin's body screamed at him to pursue.
But he remembered the promise he had made to himself before the gates of Erebor.
He would not lose his family to Azog again.
Not Fíli.
Not Kíli.
Not Bilbo.
And he would not save one by carelessly sacrificing the others.
“Find Legolas,” Thorin said, his voice rough but steady. “Tell him I need eyes upon every path leading north.”
Dwalin nodded.
“And Fíli and Kíli?”
Thorin looked toward the battlefield.
“Bring them to me. Quietly. I will not have them riding blindly into this.”
Dwalin gripped his shoulder once before turning away.
Thorin remained beside the ruined wall.
High above him, Ravenhill stood against the darkening sky.
And somewhere upon its slopes, Bilbo was being carried toward the creature who had murdered Thorin's grandfather and sworn to extinguish the line of Durin.
Thorin pressed his hand against the silver bead beneath his armour.
He had crossed time itself to save the people he loved.
Now the enemy who had taken everything from him once was trying to do it again.
But this time, Thorin Oakenshield knew the cost of answering hatred with hatred.
He watched the orcs disappear among the rocks.
Then he turned back toward his army.
He would go after Bilbo.
He would bring him home.
But he would not give Azog the broken, reckless king he was expecting.
