Chapter Text
The path to Ravenhill was narrow, steep, and treacherous beneath the boots of those who had come to reclaim it.
Thorin knew every turn.
He remembered the broken watchtower overlooking the valley, the narrow ledge where snow had gathered around his boots, and the dark waters beneath the ice. He remembered the terrible sound of Fíli's body striking the stone far below Azog's position. He remembered Kíli's death, though he had not witnessed it himself, and the unbearable knowledge that he had led both his sister's sons into a place from which none of them would return.
In another life, he had climbed this mountain because he wanted Azog dead.
Now he climbed it because Bilbo was alive somewhere above him.
That difference should have comforted him. Instead, it made every step feel like a struggle against the past.
“There's a second path through the eastern rocks,” Legolas said, crouching beside a weathered outcrop. His pale hair had been drawn back from his face, and a thin cut marked his temple. “It is difficult to see from below, but it reaches the old watchtower without crossing the main approach.”
Dwalin studied the slope. “How many guards?”
“Eight along the lower path. Perhaps twice that number near the tower. More concealed among the ruins.”
Kíli muttered something unpleasant beneath his breath.
Fíli stood beside him, checking the fastening of his brother's shoulder armour. The gesture was so familiar that Thorin's chest tightened. He had watched Fíli do the same thing a hundred times throughout their lives, usually while Kíli complained that he was perfectly capable of dressing himself.
Today, Kíli said nothing.
“Azog wants us to climb the main path,” Thorin said. “He'll have prepared it for an attack.”
“Then we don't give him one,” Dwalin replied.
Thorin looked toward the ruined watchtower.
The urge to run was almost unbearable. Every moment they spent planning was another moment Bilbo remained in Azog's hands. Thorin could imagine the hobbit frightened and injured, perhaps calling for him, perhaps wondering whether anyone would come.
But he remembered Bilbo shouting across the battlefield.
It's a trap.
Even then, Bilbo had been trying to protect him.
Thorin would not repay that courage with recklessness.
“Legolas, take your archers along the eastern path. Find a position overlooking the courtyard, but do not reveal yourselves unless Bilbo is in immediate danger. Dwalin, take the lower passage with six warriors. Keep the retreat open.”
“And us?” Fíli asked.
Thorin turned toward his nephews.
“You will remain with Dwalin until the guards are occupied. Then approach from the eastern side.”
Kíli frowned. “And you?”
“I will go where Azog expects me.”
“Alone?”
“Not without you watching my back.”
Fíli's expression remained troubled.
Thorin placed a hand upon his shoulder.
“I know what you are thinking.”
“Do you?”
Thorin hesitated.
No. Fíli could not possibly know what his uncle remembered.
But he knew enough.
“I am not going there to die,” Thorin said quietly.
Kíli stepped closer.
“We're bringing Uncle Bilbo home.”
Thorin looked at him.
“All three of us,” Kíli added.
Thorin's hand moved to the small silver bead beneath his armour.
“All four of us,” he corrected.
For a moment, Kíli's eyes shone.
Then he nodded.
____________
Bilbo had never been so cold.
The wind swept through the broken stones of Ravenhill, finding every tear in his coat and every gap between the ropes binding his wrists. His shoulder ached where an orc had struck him, and dried blood pulled unpleasantly at the skin along his cheek.
He had been forced to kneel beside a ruined pillar, with two guards standing behind him.
Beyond the courtyard, the Battle of Five Armies continued.
From this height, the valley looked terribly small. The armies moved like dark currents through the ruined streets, their banners scarcely visible beneath the smoke. Bilbo could hear horns and distant shouting, but individual voices were lost to the wind.
He wondered where Fíli and Kíli were.
He wondered whether Óin had escaped.
And, despite everything that had happened between them, he wondered whether Thorin was safe.
A heavy footstep sounded behind him.
Bilbo turned.
Azog the Defiler approached through the ruins.
He was enormous, even compared with the other orcs, his pale skin crossed by old scars and his metal prosthetic ending in a wicked blade. His expression held none of the mindless fury Bilbo had seen in lesser creatures. There was calculation in his eyes.
Bilbo found that far more frightening.
Azog stopped before him.
“So,” he said in a rough voice, “this is what Oakenshield keeps beside him.”
Bilbo lifted his chin.
Azog studied him.
“A halfling. I thought my hunters had mistaken a child for one of his companions.”
Bilbo said nothing.
Azog crouched, bringing his terrible face nearer.
“Does the dwarf king send you to carry his messages? Polish his treasures?”
Bilbo looked away.
A low laugh escaped the orc.
“I have hunted Oakenshield since before you were born, little creature. I have watched his people crawl through exile, clinging to a crown that belonged to a dead kingdom.”
Bilbo's jaw tightened.
Azog noticed.
“I took the head of his grandfather,” he continued. “Thrór, who thought himself mighty beneath the mountain. His blood ran across the stones of Moria.”
Bilbo had heard that story.
He remembered Thorin speaking of his grandfather only rarely, his voice growing distant whenever the subject arose.
“You must be very proud,” Bilbo said bitterly, “to boast about murdering someone's family.”
Azog's eyes narrowed.
Then he smiled.
“Ah. You know the story.”
Bilbo regretted speaking.
Azog rose and began circling him.
“His father vanished. His grandfather died beneath my blade. Yet Oakenshield still believes he can protect what remains of his miserable bloodline.”
Bilbo's thoughts flew immediately to Fíli and Kíli.
Azog watched his expression change.
“Two young dwarves,” he observed. “Golden-haired and dark-haired. They fight beneath his banner.”
Bilbo pulled against his bindings.
“Leave them alone.”
Another smile.
“So they matter too.”
Bilbo forced himself to be silent.
Azog paced toward the edge of the courtyard, looking down at the distant battle.
“I had intended to kill Oakenshield here,” he said conversationally. “I thought it would please me to watch him come crawling up this mountain, desperate to settle an old debt.”
Bilbo's stomach tightened.
“He was always eager to fight me. Proud. Angry. So easily led by his hatred.”
Azog turned.
“But today he would not come.”
Bilbo stared at the ground.
“So I wondered what had changed.”
The orc approached again.
“I watched him from above. I saw him look toward the wounded, again and again. I saw him send warriors whenever danger came near a particular building.”
Bilbo's breath caught.
Azog saw it.
“There,” he murmured.
Bilbo looked up sharply.
Azog leaned closer.
“What is a king doing, watching a little halfling when his enemies stand before him?”
“Perhaps,” Bilbo said, struggling to keep his voice steady, “he simply doesn't like seeing innocent people killed.”
Azog laughed.
“Perhaps.”
He straightened.
“Then I shall kill him first.”
Bilbo went white.
Azog watched with sudden, terrible interest.
“I shall drive my blade through his chest and leave him upon the stones. Perhaps I shall let his nephews watch.”
“Don't you dare!”
The words escaped before Bilbo could stop them.
Azog became very still.
Bilbo felt the blood drain from his face.
The orc slowly lowered himself until they were eye to eye.
“You did not flinch when I threatened you.”
Bilbo said nothing.
“But speak of Oakenshield's death, and you forget your courage.”
Azog reached out and caught Bilbo's chin.
Bilbo tried to pull away.
“Interesting.”
He released him and stood.
Bilbo stared after him, his heart hammering.
He had told Azog nothing.
Yet somehow, he had told him far too much.
_____________
Thorin emerged into the courtyard beneath a sky heavy with smoke.
Azog was waiting.
The pale orc stood beside a broken pillar, his enormous weapon resting against his shoulder. Around him, guards occupied the surrounding ruins.
And at his feet knelt Bilbo.
Thorin's heart seemed to stop.
Bilbo's hands were bound. His coat was torn, and there was blood upon his face. One side of his body was held stiffly, as though moving caused him pain.
But he was alive.
“Bilbo.”
The hobbit looked up.
Relief flashed across his face, followed almost immediately by terror.
“Thorin, you shouldn't have come.”
Thorin took one step forward.
Azog seized Bilbo by the collar and hauled him upright, dragging him against his chest. The curved edge of his weapon came to rest beneath Bilbo's jaw.
Thorin stopped.
“Release him.”
Azog smiled.
“Oakenshield.”
His voice carried the satisfaction of a hunter whose trap had finally closed.
“I wondered whether you would come.”
Thorin's hand tightened around Orcrist.
“You have me. Let him go.”
Azog looked down at Bilbo.
“So eager.”
He pressed the blade closer.
Bilbo winced.
Thorin's sword lowered an inch.
Azog noticed.
His smile widened.
“I thought this little creature was a servant. Perhaps a favourite pet.”
“Don't touch him.”
Azog loosened his grip slightly.
Thorin breathed.
Then the orc tightened it again.
Thorin's entire body went rigid.
Azog laughed softly.
“There it is.”
Bilbo closed his eyes.
He understood now what Azog had been looking for.
“You could not save your grandfather,” Azog told Thorin. “You could not save your father. Shall I show you how easily I can take this one too?”
Thorin felt the old hatred rise.
He remembered Azog standing over Thrór's body. He remembered the years of exile, the grief upon his father's face, the endless burden of carrying a broken kingdom's hopes.
He remembered Ravenhill.
The snow.
His own blood.
And Bilbo weeping over him.
For a moment, his vision narrowed until there was nothing in the world but Azog's pale face.
Then Bilbo made a small, frightened sound.
Thorin looked at him.
The anger did not vanish.
But it ceased to command him.
“Whatever you want from me,” Thorin said, “you will not have it by hurting him.”
Azog tilted his head.
“Then throw down your sword.”
Thorin hesitated.
“Thorin, no,” Bilbo whispered.
The blade moved against his throat.
Thorin dropped Orcrist.
It struck the stones with a ringing sound.
Azog's smile became almost delighted.
“The King under the Mountain,” he murmured, “brought low by a halfling.”
Thorin did not answer.
“On your knees.”
Bilbo struggled.
“No!”
Thorin slowly lowered himself.
His eyes never left Bilbo's face.
The hobbit felt something inside him twist painfully.
Only yesterday, Thorin had looked at the Arkenstone when Bilbo asked whether he still loved him.
Now Thorin was kneeling before his greatest enemy, surrendering his sword because Bilbo's life mattered more than his pride.
Bilbo had wanted proof that the dwarf he loved still existed beneath the sickness.
He had never wanted it like this.
Azog raised his weapon.
And Bilbo saw the change in his grip.
The blade at Bilbo's throat shifted away.
Not because Azog intended to release him.
Because he was preparing to strike Thorin.
Bilbo's heart lurched.
“No!”
Thorin looked up.
Azog smiled.
And Bilbo understood that neither of them was meant to leave Ravenhill alive.
The Ring lay against Bilbo's palm inside his pocket.
He had carried it for so long that its weight had become familiar. Through mountains and forests, beneath the eyes of elves and dwarves, through the burning streets of Lake-town, he had guarded its secret.
He remembered Gollum's terrible hunger for it.
He remembered the strange coldness that sometimes accompanied its touch.
And he remembered how frightened he had been to tell Thorin.
After the Arkenstone, that fear had only grown.
What would Thorin think if he learned Bilbo had concealed another treasure? Something far stranger, and perhaps far more dangerous?
For one terrible moment, Bilbo imagined Thorin looking at the Ring with the same possessive hunger he had shown the Arkenstone.
Then Azog raised his blade toward Thorin's unprotected chest.
And suddenly, none of those fears mattered.
Not the secret.
Not the Ring.
Not even what Thorin might think of him afterward.
Bilbo would not stand helplessly and watch him die.
He closed his fingers around the golden band.
Then he slipped it onto his finger.
_____________
The world changed.
Azog's grip closed upon empty air.
The orc staggered, snarling in astonishment as the small prisoner vanished from beneath his arm.
Thorin's eyes widened.
“Bilbo?”
There was no answer.
Azog whirled.
“What sorcery—”
A sharp pain struck behind his knee.
Sting flashed briefly through the air, held by a hand no one could see.
Azog roared and stumbled.
“NOW!” shouted a voice from above.
An arrow struck the throat of the nearest guard.
Then another.
Legolas stood upon the broken eastern wall, his bow already drawn again.
Dwalin's battle cry echoed from the lower passage as dwarven warriors surged into the courtyard.
Thorin moved.
He snatched Orcrist from the stones and rolled aside as Azog's weapon crashed down where his head had been.
“Bilbo!” he shouted.
“I'm here!”
The voice came from somewhere to his left.
Thorin could not see him.
For one dreadful instant, he remembered Lake-town and the impossible disappearance that had nearly driven him mad with fear.
But Bilbo was speaking.
He was alive.
And there would be time for questions later.
“Get clear!” Thorin called.
Azog lunged.
Steel met steel.
The fight that followed was nothing like the one Thorin remembered.
In his first life, he had faced Azog upon the ice, isolated from his companions, his body exhausted and his heart poisoned by vengeance.
Now Dwalin held the lower passage, Legolas's arrows kept the surrounding guards from closing in, and his nephews were fighting their way toward him.
But Azog remained a terrifying opponent.
The pale orc was larger, stronger, and armed with a weapon capable of breaking bone through armour. Every blow drove Thorin backward, his injured shoulder burning beneath the strain.
“You should have stayed beneath your mountain!” Azog roared.
Thorin caught the next strike upon Orcrist.
“And leave you to murder my people?”
Azog drove him against a pillar.
“I will tear your bloodline from the earth!”
Thorin twisted free.
“Not today.”
Across the courtyard, Fíli and Kíli had reached the eastern wall.
“Bilbo!” Kíli shouted.
A small figure suddenly appeared beside a broken stair, stumbling as he pulled a golden ring from his finger.
“Here!”
Kíli ran toward him.
Bilbo had barely managed to steady himself before his nephew caught him by the shoulders.
“Are you hurt?”
“A little.”
“How much is a little?”
“Kíli, your uncle—”
A scream interrupted them.
Fíli had turned to intercept one of Azog's guards, only for a second orc to emerge from behind the ruined wall.
Its spear struck his shield and drove him backward toward the edge of the courtyard.
Thorin saw it.
For one horrible instant, time ceased to move.
Fíli.
The broken tower.
Azog's blade.
His nephew's body falling through empty air.
“No!”
Thorin tried to turn.
Azog struck him across the ribs, sending him stumbling.
Fíli's heel slipped over the edge.
Kíli moved before anyone else.
He caught his brother by the back of his armour and dragged him sideways as the orc's spear plunged into the stone where Fíli had stood.
Both brothers fell hard.
The guard raised its weapon again.
An arrow struck its chest.
Legolas was already reaching for another.
Kíli hauled Fíli upright.
“Are you trying to kill me?” he shouted.
Fíli stared at him, breathless.
“I was rather occupied!”
“Then be occupied somewhere farther from the edge!”
Thorin heard their voices.
Alive.
Both alive.
The relief was so overwhelming that it nearly brought him to his knees.
Azog saw the distraction.
He drove forward, forcing Thorin against the ruined pillar.
“You cannot save them all, Oakenshield.”
Thorin's back struck stone.
Azog raised his weapon.
For one dreadful instant, Thorin saw the end of his first life waiting before him.
Then Bilbo shouted.
“Thorin!”
A small stone struck Azog across the face.
It did no real damage.
But it made him turn.
Bilbo stood several paces away, Sting trembling in his hand.
Azog snarled.
“You.”
He lunged toward the hobbit.
Thorin moved without thinking.
Not from rage.
Not from pride.
From the simple, terrible certainty that he would not let Azog reach him.
He drove Orcrist beneath the orc's raised arm.
Azog roared, staggering backward.
Dwalin surged forward to prevent the remaining guards from intervening.
“Finish it, Thorin!”
Azog swung wildly.
Thorin ducked beneath the blade, feeling it tear through the edge of his cloak.
Then he struck again.
Orcrist drove deep into Azog's chest.
The pale orc staggered.
For a moment, his terrible eyes remained fixed upon Thorin's face, filled with disbelief and hatred.
Thorin held his gaze.
“You will take no more of my family.”
He withdrew the sword.
Azog fell.
The sound of his body striking the stones seemed impossibly loud.
____________
Then the courtyard fell still.
Thorin stood over the creature who had haunted his life, his breathing ragged, blood running down one arm.
Azog the Defiler was dead.
For years, Thorin had imagined this moment.
He had thought it would bring satisfaction, perhaps even peace.
Instead, he felt only an urgent need to turn around.
“Bilbo?”
Bilbo sat against a broken wall, one hand pressed to his injured shoulder.
He had removed the Ring.
It lay in his palm, catching the weak afternoon light.
Thorin crossed the courtyard so quickly that Dwalin called after him, but he scarcely heard.
He dropped to his knees before Bilbo.
“Are you hurt?”
Bilbo looked up.
There was blood on Thorin's armour.
A great deal of it.
“Oh, Thorin.”
“Bilbo, please.”
“I'm all right.”
“You're bleeding.”
“So are you.”
Thorin's hands hovered helplessly near him, uncertain where he could touch without causing pain.
Bilbo noticed.
Then Thorin's gaze briefly fell upon the golden Ring.
Bilbo's fingers closed instinctively.
His face changed.
Thorin saw the fear.
And understood.
The sight hurt more than his injuries.
He looked away from the Ring immediately.
“I don't want it, Bilbo.”
Bilbo stared at him.
“Whatever it is,” Thorin continued quietly, “whatever you have been carrying, it belongs to you to explain when you are ready.”
Bilbo's eyes filled.
Thorin swallowed.
“I only want to know whether you're hurt.”
For several moments, Bilbo could not speak.
Then he nodded shakily.
“My shoulder. And my side, I think.”
Thorin looked toward the lower passage.
“Óin will see to you.”
“Yes.”
Neither moved.
The wind stirred Bilbo's loose curls.
Thorin's hand lifted slightly, then stopped.
“May I hold you?”
Bilbo's expression crumpled.
He hesitated only a moment.
Then he whispered, “Please.”
Thorin gathered him into his arms.
Carefully at first, mindful of the injured shoulder and the bruises beneath his coat.
But Bilbo reached for him with both arms, clinging so fiercely that Thorin's breath caught.
He buried his face against Thorin's neck.
And began to cry.
Thorin closed his eyes.
He held Bilbo against his chest, one hand spread protectively across his back, the other cradling the curls at the nape of his neck.
For a long time, neither spoke.
The battle continued somewhere below them, distant horns echoing through the valley, but for a few precious moments Thorin could hear only Bilbo's uneven breathing.
“I was so frightened,” Bilbo whispered.
Thorin pressed his cheek against his hair.
“I know.”
“No.” Bilbo's voice broke. “When he said he was going to kill you, I thought—I thought I was going to have to watch it happen.”
Thorin's arms tightened.
“I thought I had lost you when they took you.”
Bilbo shook against him.
“I couldn't let him hurt you.”
“Nor I you.”
Bilbo drew back just enough to look at him.
His cheeks were wet, his eyes red, and there was a bruise forming along his jaw.
Thorin had never seen anything more precious.
“I love you,” he whispered.
Bilbo's mouth trembled.
“I love you too.”
Thorin brushed a tear from his cheek.
Then Bilbo leaned forward and held him again.
They remained like that until Bilbo's breathing steadied.
Eventually, Thorin spoke against his curls.
“I know this does not change what happened between us.”
Bilbo went quiet.
“No,” he whispered. “It doesn't.”
Thorin nodded.
“I understand.”
Bilbo drew back slightly.
“But I'm glad you're alive.”
Thorin's throat tightened.
“So am I, my love.”
He rested his forehead briefly against Bilbo's, careful not to ask for more than the hobbit was ready to give.
Bilbo did not pull away.
_____________
“UNCLE BILBO!”
Kíli's voice rang across the courtyard.
Bilbo barely had time to turn before the young dwarf reached him.
Kíli dropped to his knees and threw his arms around him, almost knocking him sideways.
“Ow!”
Kíli released him immediately.
“Sorry! Sorry, where are you hurt?”
Bilbo laughed through his tears.
“Everywhere, apparently.”
“That isn't funny!”
“It was a little funny,” Fíli said, arriving behind his brother.
His own face was pale beneath the dust, and one sleeve hung torn from his shoulder.
Bilbo's smile faltered.
“Fíli, you're hurt.”
“Hardly.”
“You nearly fell off a mountain!”
Kíli pointed at him.
“That's what I said!”
Fíli sighed.
“Must we discuss this now?”
“Yes,” Bilbo and Kíli answered together.
For a moment, all three stared at one another.
Then Bilbo laughed.
A real laugh, though it ended with a wince.
Fíli knelt beside him.
He checked Bilbo's face, his shoulder, and the bandage Kíli had hastily wrapped around his arm.
Then, apparently satisfied that Bilbo was not about to collapse, he drew him into a careful embrace.
Bilbo clung to him.
“You came back,” he whispered.
Fíli closed his eyes.
“We promised.”
Kíli leaned against them both.
“And we're not finished annoying you.”
Bilbo reached for him with his free arm.
“Oh, my dear boys.”
Thorin watched them.
He remembered the previous night, when Bilbo had cried because he feared he was no longer their uncle.
Now Fíli and Kíli held him between them without hesitation, their relief plain upon their faces.
Thorin felt a deep, painful gratitude.
His nephews had loved Bilbo when Thorin had made him doubt that love.
They had protected him when Thorin had failed.
And they had brought him back.
Heavy footsteps approached.
Dwalin stopped beside Thorin, looking him over with a critical expression.
“You look terrible.”
Thorin managed a weary smile.
“You are hardly an improvement.”
Dwalin snorted.
Then his expression grew serious.
He gripped Thorin's shoulder.
“You frightened us, brother.”
Thorin met his eyes.
He knew Dwalin meant more than the battle.
“I know.”
Dwalin held his gaze for a moment longer.
Then he nodded.
“We'll speak of it later.”
A lighter tread sounded behind them.
Legolas approached, his bow slung across his back.
He looked first at Thorin, then at Bilbo, who was still being fussed over by both nephews.
“I see the rescue was successful,” he observed.
Bilbo looked up.
“Thanks in no small part to you.”
Legolas knelt beside him.
His expression softened as he examined the bruises upon Bilbo's face.
“I believe I promised to show you the gardens of the Woodland Realm one day.”
Bilbo smiled faintly.
“You did.”
“Then I would appreciate it if you refrained from getting yourself killed before I have the opportunity.”
Kíli made an indignant noise.
“That's what I've been telling him!”
Legolas glanced at him.
“Then perhaps he will listen if several of us agree.”
Bilbo sighed.
“I am surrounded by dreadful people.”
“People who are rather fond of you,” Fíli corrected.
Bilbo looked at him.
Then at Kíli.
At Legolas, whose quiet smile held genuine affection.
At Dwalin, standing beside Thorin like the steadfast friend he had always been.
And finally at Thorin himself.
The dwarf king was watching him with an expression so full of tenderness and regret that Bilbo's heart ached.
There were still things between them that needed mending.
Words that could not be forgotten simply because they had survived a battle.
Trust that would have to be rebuilt slowly, with patience and honesty.
But Thorin was alive.
Fíli and Kíli were alive.
And Bilbo was no longer afraid that he had lost his family.
Beyond the ruined walls, horns sounded from the valley.
The battle was not yet over. Orcs still fought beneath Bolg's command, and the allied armies were struggling to hold their positions. There would be more danger before the day was done.
But upon Ravenhill, for one brief moment, the surviving members of Thorin's little company were together.
Thorin sat beside Bilbo, allowing the hobbit to decide how close he wished to remain.
Bilbo leaned against him.
Fíli settled on his other side, while Kíli remained close enough to keep one hand resting upon Bilbo's knee.
Dwalin stood watch near the passage, and Legolas listened to the distant sounds of battle, ready to carry news to the allied commanders.
Thorin looked at them all.
Once, he had died upon this mountain believing that love had come to him too late.
He remembered Bilbo's tears upon his face, the cold creeping through his limbs, and the terrible certainty that he would never see another morning.
Now Bilbo rested against his side.
His nephews were alive.
Azog was dead.
And the future, though still uncertain, stretched before them.
Thorin lowered his gaze to the hobbit beside him.
Bilbo's hand rested upon the stone between them.
After a moment, Thorin placed his own hand nearby, leaving a small space between their fingers.
Bilbo looked down.
Then, quietly, he moved his hand and took Thorin's.
Neither spoke.
There was nothing more that needed saying just then.
For the first time since waking in a world that had given him a second chance, Thorin Oakenshield allowed himself to believe that perhaps, at last, he might truly have one.
