Actions

Work Header

thunder and the riversong

Chapter 2: strange

Notes:

thank you to moonyism for betaing again i love you <3

also: the meanings of any and all flowers mentioned in the chapter will be in the end notes!

(title for this chapter is the song "strange" by celeste (i highly recommend))

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo always forgot, until he tried to leave it, how very big the Shire was, and how far its borders stretched.

He’d remembered that very first May on the road, the sunlight glinting off the green leaves in the canopies above them and the weather fine and fresh. But after a good while of riding through lazing fields and reed-riddled creeks, he began to tire of it, wanting more and more just to be east already. The four Farthings seemed to stretch on and on and on, blanketing the land further and further and making Bilbo feel as though his ears and eyes were still smothered, like he was being cushioned before the great wide world suddenly broke open all around him.

He was very nearly sick of it, to tell the truth. He’d left the Shire once, forever, and he was eager to make his way beyond its edges again. He knew now that he had been made for lands with more to see. Lands whose peaks rose higher, and whose grasses grew as tall as he himself stood, and whose trees were both more lovely and more menacing.

None of the dwarves had paid very much attention to him, yet. But Bilbo still rode on, content in watching the way they bounced off each other, and the way they would rib at each other loudly. He could see it, this time; how they showed their affection in the little things. How they would form rank around Fili, Kili and Ori almost without speaking, always to protect and provide as best as they could. How they would share out meals, and each one of them would wait to eat until everyone else had gotten their bowls, and how they would gather their blankets together and decide who should get which depending on the weather that particular day.

At first Bilbo’d thought it was a rather hobbitish way of doing things, the share and care and community of it. Then he’d had the belated realisation that maybe it was the dwarvish way after all, and hobbits and dwarves were more similar than anyone had ever taught either of them.

For the most part, he would ride near the rear of the Company, and sometimes Gandalf would join him, though sometimes he would not. Bilbo was content not to rush his dwarves for their friendship, and knew that in time, he would gain it from all of them.

He had a sneaking suspicion they were still puzzling out what to do with him, and that none of them had quite made up their minds about him yet. Bilbo had an easy familiarity that probably seemed quite strange to dwarves, who often had no other allies to be found in the world, and he knew that even for a hobbit, he was really quite peculiar.

Thorin, of course, had already made his own judgements about Bilbo — but that was to be expected, and Bilbo spent much of his time on this second go-around having to conceal a smile rather than spending day after day wondering why on all of the Earth he’d set foot outside his doorstep in the first place.

Bilbo knew more of the things that made up Thorin Oakenshield, now. He knew that if he unfolded Thorin, he would find a steadily-beating heart covered in scars and hurt and mourning, for his people and his city, and for his own mistakes.

(It didn’t mean that Thorin wasn’t behaving as much like an absolute donkey’s behind as ever, but someone Bilbo didn’t find that he cared quite as much.)

In fact, most of the time, Bilbo simply lay back atop Myrtle with his face to the sky and let the rhythmic fall of her hooves lull him into a doze. He was small and stable enough that he could manage without any fear of falling off — even if it seemed to utterly perplex the dwarves.

He had the strangest sort of feeling somehow that Myrtle knew him, or that he at least smelled familiar to her. She had been nothing but gentle with him since their first day setting out, when he’d scratched at her nose, and so well did she know how to carry him where he needed to go that it made Bilbo wonder quite a lot.

“Master Baggins?” Kili called one day; the sort of day where even if you had your eyes closed, you could see the brightness of the sky through the thin film of your eyelids. The utter gloriousness of the weather was helping to calm Bilbo’s erratic nerves, which had been flitting ceaselessly between worrying that he would blurt something out in a panic and make himself completely untrustworthy, or worrying that the nerves were because he was beginning to have visions of dwarves in his old age and this was in fact a very, very elaborate nervous breakdown.

(These kinds of days had been Frodo’s favourite. Their shared birthday was in autumn, but Frodo had always been a child of summer.)

Bilbo cracked one of his eyes open and looked tentatively up at Kili. 

“Hm?”

“What are you doing?” 

He supposed Kili was referring to the laying-down-atop-a-moving-steed business, and looked back up at the sky, the clouds suspended like wisps in its fingers. They looked like the plant they called Old Man’s Beard, back in the Shire. Like vines you could have stuck knitting needles into.

“I am watching the clouds chase us,” Bilbo said matter-of-factly.

Kili looked upwards in alarm, but the clouds only drifted on in their lazy way, and after a moment he sent a scrunched-up frown down at Bilbo. Bilbo chuckled.

“Aren’t you worried you’re going to fall off your pony?” Kili asked hesitantly. He seemed to not know what to do with Bilbo at all. It was a feeling Bilbo had become incredibly used to.

“Myrtle would never drop me, would you, girl?” Bilbo sang, rubbing at her chestnut coat with one hand and pulling himself upright so he could lean forward and slip an apple between her teeth. She whinnied, and Bilbo smiled in satisfaction, looking back at Kili. “She’s clever. She knows the way. Besides,” he pointed out, “all she needs to do is follow you lot.”

Kili seemed to be fighting back a bemused smile, and Bilbo could see his confusion at the fact washing over his face.

“Master Baggins, why did you decide to come on this journey with us?”

Bilbo tilted his head a little to the side and brushed his fingers through Myrtle’s mane.

“Well, someone’s got to know what they’re doing, don’t they?” He turned to the dwarf and winked, watching that cheeky grin he’d known so well finally creep onto Kili’s face.

“Would you like an apple for Daisy?” Bilbo asked. Kili held up one hand and caught the apple Bilbo tossed, slipped it between Daisy’s teeth, and then lay down atop her with his hands contently clasped across his chest.

Bilbo smiled.


They stopped often along the Great East Road to set up camp, most times not very far from the side of the road as the woods were less dense there, and the stray branches that littered the ground made for excellent firewood.

Thorin hadn't paid any of the dwarves much attention when they'd started being open to talking with Bilbo a little more, but somehow, Bilbo could tell he was still listening. He seemed alert to everything. It didn’t take Bilbo very long now to realise he was watching the wilderness around them for signs of trouble.

He’d watch the shoulders tense, the fingers flex, and was almost tempted to raise a brow at the sight. Easy, love. They were in no danger, and Thorin was wearing himself out, in Bilbo’s entirely objective opinion.

(But if there was anything at all they’d ever shared, it was stubbornness enough between them to break mountains.)

At the moment, Bilbo had his back propped against a tree, and the firelight was flickering darkly across his face in a deep burnt-butter orange. He was watching Nori tell a story, his arms held wide as he spoke, looking around seriously at them all as he imparted his oh-so-enlightening wisdom. Gloin was stretching his mouth wide in an almighty yawn, and Oin in turn was smacking his lips and blinking tiredly. A few of the others were still slurping down Bombur’s stew.

Nori finished his tale with a blunt flourish and Bilbo opened his eyes where he’d started to close them, noticing the settling silence a moment after it fell.

“You got any tales of hobbit-folk to share, then, Master Baggins, or are they all about gardening?” Bofur joked over the pipe between his teeth, winking at him good-naturedly. The laughter that echoed out at that rolled around the trunks of all the nearby trees, and Bilbo lowered his head a little, smiling in graceful defeat.

“Oh, I’m sure none of the tales in Hobbiton are of any interest to you, such mighty dwarves as you all are,” he said, pointedly and shamelessly, snorting a little as a spoon or two went flying across the campsite to even more shouts, “but I’ll try my hand at telling a story all the same. I’m rather good at it.”

He waited till something of a hush had fallen over the camp, and cleared his throat. He wouldn’t really be making the tale up, and he felt a smidge guilty about telling them so, but the need to impress them all won out, as it always had and likely always would. He glanced worriedly over at Gandalf, knowing he was treading in dangerous waters with the wizard around to listen in, but thankfully he already seemed to be asleep, hat dropped low over his face and his legs stretched out along a bedroll.

“Once,” Bilbo began softly, “when the days that covered the Earth were blacker, and the lands were falling into ruin, and each and every being lived in fear of what was ever creeping nearer, there lived three of the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth.”

He looked around the clearing. The mood had died down a little, perhaps from all the talk of darkness, but Bilbo pushed on, feeling the spark inside him coming slowly to life.

He had a proper story to tell, after all, and he’d always liked to deliver to an audience.

“But these three were not just any regular folk you would find a day’s walk from you. They came from far afield, each from different corners of the world, and they had met only by very slim chance; the chance to overthrow the growing terror once and for all. There was a dwarf, of red beard and rough skin, whose axe swung like the legends of old when he wielded it with a mighty roar. There was an Elf,” and here he watched the Company all groan and protest and roll their eyes, “and his bow was long and woven with fine silver, and he was graceful and nimble and true. And there was a Man, with dark hair and bright eyes, and he came from the High Kings of ancient times, and his greatness would sing through his sword.

“Now, these peculiar three had been on a long and perilous journey, through the deep caverns of the world, and along jagged places of rock and ruin, and down into the flowing waters of lands that lie far south of here. It had taken them an age, but all that they had seen and done together had forged an unlikely friendship, and it was indeed the strongest that the world would ever see. Yes,” Bilbo said, pausing the story again to watch the faces of the dwarves closest to him in amusement, “even the dwarf and the Elf, though I know you’ll object to it.” Kili looked particularly betrayed by the story, and Dwalin and Gloin seemed to be glaring at him outright for even daring to suggest it.

Oh, all in good time, my dear Gloin. Be patient.

Bilbo huffed dramatically, though of course he was not actually angered: appearances had to be kept up, and such. “If it’s really so displeasing to you all that a made-up dwarf and a made-up Elf are partners in battle, I should end the story right here and now, and then none of you will find out what happens to them!” The looks being sent his way became suddenly bashful.

“Aye, it’s just a story,” said Balin lightly, his expression strained, but urging him on. “Go on, laddie.” 

Bilbo cleared his throat importantly and continued.

“Well, these three friends and warriors had found themselves in the lands beyond the Misty Mountains, and they were carrying out a rescue mission, for some of their allies had been taken by enemies, and they were fiercely protective of them. And so they ran, through cliff-face and hillside, through endless plains roughened by the stampeding of horses and the wearing of weather, and not once did they stop, not even when days and days had gone by with no food or shelter or sleep. They ran for many hundreds of miles, faster than any soldiers ever had before, and they were known henceforth as the Three Hunters. For the Elf would dash ahead and watch out, onto the fields, and see in the distance the evil they were chasing, and the Man would follow the smallest markings in the earth to keep them on the treacherous path, and the noble dwarf would be ever-present, urging them on, carrying their strength with his bare hands and running all the while.

“After a time, the Hunters began to grow worried that their journey was in vain, and that their enemies had already killed the friends they hoped to save, but still they gave chase, until they found themselves in a forest. But this was a forest of deep and ancient magic, and the trees could walk in the waking world, and they would creak and moan and kept evil at bay, and so the Three Hunters’ hearts were roused once more. They ran on, first on foot and then on horseback — which perhaps meant that the dwarf was the bravest of them all — until they came to the battlements of what was once a kingdom in its prime. It was there that the enemy turned to them instead, intending to take out these mighty warriors who had shown without doubt they would die for one another.

“And they fought a great battle that day, long into the night after all hope had been lost, and deep in the hollows of the mountains they had been backed into, until at last the dawn broke over the melee and the Three Hunters had won with the help of the walking trees and the people of those southern lands. And you will all be very pleased to hear that the axe of that mighty dwarf had been the most fearsome weapon in the battle that day, and claimed more lives of evil than anyone else who had fought, most notably including the Elf and his bow. For the blood of kings and warriors ran in him, and he wished to do his father proud.”

It was as if, once Bilbo finished his story, the very air surrounding them all had stilled. The fire barely flickered, and his words echoed heavily in the silence, the eyes of all his dwarves downcast and the sound of rustling leaves in the night seeming to blur.

For a small moment, Bilbo wondered if he might have made a mistake.

“You certainly have a way with words, Master Baggins,” Balin said then, softly, and it brought the rest of them out of their reverie. 

Bofur seemed, for once, to have nothing to say; his eyes were a little wide. So were Fili and Kili’s. Bifur had stopped with his spoon halfway to his mouth, and Ori and Dori’s mouths had fallen right open. Even the constant frown-lines across Dwalin’s forehead had almost entirely disappeared.

And beyond them, Bilbo could see Thorin watching him silently, his gaze unmoving. He didn’t look angry; only contemplative, as he had the whole trip so far, and as made Bilbo’s heart perpetually hover somewhere in his throat with equal parts worry and longing.

Bilbo dipped his head again, rather embarrassed. 

“Oh, please don’t flatter me! To tell you the truth, it was a tale I’d heard whispers of, around and about in different places, and I simply took it and made it my own. I’m not much of a creator in my own right. Not for stories, at least, although I do love to write.”

“But what about the hobbits?” said Kili suddenly. Bilbo’s heart very nearly skipped a beat.

“I'm sorry?”

He’d made no mention of Merry or Pippin or Sam or Frodo. He hadn’t said a word.

Kili frowned and settled back into the spot where he was resting in front of the fire. “Well,” he said slowly, “surely if these Three Hunters were representing the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth, they should have brought a hobbit along, and had four hunters, if it was going to be fair. Now that we’ve got one, it seems quite wrong to leave you out.”

That had a sweet feeling blooming in Bilbo’s chest, and he wished, not for the first time, that he could be truly, truly honest with them all, and tell them everything that had happened in his long, long life, and all that it meant to him to see them like this again. He swallowed it down like always.

“Ah, but Kili,” he smiled, “I think you’ll find they did know a few hobbits in their time, and held great love for them. One of the hobbits may well have even been a Baggins, for all we know, though certainly not the Baggins sitting in front of you!" Bilbo quipped, to a few hearty chuckles. "But I quite think stories of hobbits and adventures should wait for another day.”

“I agree,” that deep voice said, unmistakeable. Bilbo had been expecting it to interject before then.

“That’s enough. It’s already late,” Thorin said in a gravelly voice. And he stood and turned his back on their camp, on Bilbo, and walked into the darkness to scout til he was bone-weary once more. 

Bilbo trained his eyes on the ground and did not watch him go.


Another day for storytelling, however, seemed to come only the very next day, when Bilbo found that while he’d been riding along the road absently, lost in his pondering and trusting Myrtle to steer him back on course if needed, several dwarves had sidled up next to him and were watching him with an avid interest: Kili, Bofur, Ori, and Dori, and Bilbo could even see Balin lingering nearby on Minty. Bilbo blinked at them, and they shied away, and in fact it was Gandalf who eventually brought the whole thing up.

“Have you ever thought of publishing your stories, Bilbo?”

Bilbo startled. Heavens, he hadn’t even seen Gandalf ride up behind him. He shifted a little in his saddle.

“Were you… not asleep, then?” he asked, cursing the jumpiness in his voice. If Gandalf unravelled the web of half-truths he’d woven now — well, he was well and truly done for.

Pull yourself together, you fool!

“Merely dozing,” the wizard replied, fixing his eyes steadily on Bilbo underneath his crooked hat. Bilbo momentarily drifted into wondering how on the Earth Gandalf the White had managed any of his conversations without a hat to hide his eyes under, since Gandalf the Grey seemed so incredibly partial to it. “I did hear bits and pieces of your tale, my dear fellow, and it was very well-told! I wonder if you could impress even the Elves.”

The equal absurdity and accuracy of it made Bilbo chuckle. “Oh, I’m not so talented as all that, Gandalf,” he dismissed. “Besides, if I did publish them, who in the world would ever read them?”

“Oh, Elves love to hear stories, although many of theirs are of the long ago they all remember, when the world was new and the air was different. But I think your stories would excite them, to hear something so different from their own, and so distinctly told. Perhaps you shall even get a chance, soon enough.” He raised one eyebrow meaningfully.

“We have purpose for books too, Master Baggins,” another voice chimed in. It was Dori, cantering a little closer and looking earnestly at Bilbo. “Ori uses them often in his craft, especially since he’ll be approaching his Mastery now, and there are others who do the same when we need certain tasks to be completed. Though Balin has told us the texts we have in Ered Luin are a poor replacement for what we had before Smaug.”

“It is a cobbled-together life in the Blue Mountains,” Balin agreed, with a resigned sort of smile. “None of us but Thorin and I have known anything else. Not even Dwalin, though he is old enough to remember the long years in-between, when we were nothing but poor travellers on the road.”

Ori still seemed a little shy of him, but it was then that he piped up.

“Is writing your craft, Master Baggins?”

Bilbo hummed. “I suppose you’d say it’s my craft, yes,” he said, “though we don’t really have such formal positions in the Shire. Folks mostly just make do where they like.”

That sent them round the circle, and each of them spoke with great pride to him about the love their hands had for stone, or woodwork, or tailoring, or toy-making, or wielding the sharp edge of an axe. He could feel the devotion in their voices as they spoke, and the careful honour they each carried with them in their trades, and thought again that those who imagined dwarves to be cold and unfeeling with love for only gold and silver could not be more wrong.

“So you really haven’t written any books?” Bofur pressed. Bilbo felt the weight of the red volume currently being jostled around in the pack on his back and smiled ruefully. 

“I’m not experienced enough for all that. Mostly I write poetry, or historical accounts — though I have written some songs in my time.”

This caught their attention, and Bofur of course brightened immediately, a swaggering grin stretching across his face. Bilbo thought offhandedly to himself that Bofur would be an absolute riot down at the Green Dragon, and would probably give all the hobbits in the Westfarthing a run for their money, to boot.

“Give us a sample, laddie!”

There was only one real choice as to which song to sing for them, for it was theirs, after all, and it reminded him of them wherever he went. Bilbo opened his mouth and neatly began to sing.

“The Road goes ever on and on,

Down from the door where it began

Now far ahead the Road has gone,

And I must follow, if I can

Pursuing it with eager feet,

Until it joins some larger way

Where many paths and errands meet

And whither then? I cannot say.”

Bilbo finished his tune to raucous applause and a ridiculous echo of “And whither then? I cannot say!” from Bofur with a huge grin on his face.

Then he turned quite suddenly to look at Kili, who chirped up another, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Dori, who smoothly sung, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Nori, appearing quite out of nowhere and exclaiming, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Ori piping up with, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and back to Bilbo, who was chuckling in surprise when he joined in with, “And whither then? I cannot say!”

This went on for quite a long time, until they were all behaving like a complete gaggle of geese, repeating one after the other and collapsing all over the place on their ponies with childlike laughter. In fact, they did not show any signs of stopping at all until Fili of all people slowed from where he’d been riding up ahead and politely asked them if they could please stop singing the same thing over and over again because it was getting rather annoying and their ears were all going to fall off.

Bilbo had looked back toward Gandalf at this, who’d only winked with a twinkle in his eye.


The days went on and on. Occasionally the dwarves’ voices would rise up in chorus as they journeyed along the Great East Road, sometimes jolly and sometimes painful and sombre. Occasionally they’d even prod at Bilbo until he trundled out a tune, though he only ever sang the same song to them, and the others had been completely and utterly banned from repeating any of the lines after the utter chaos it had caused.

(Though they had finally started calling him Bilbo again, which made the world feel a little more like it was tilted the right way.)

Bilbo was reminded often of how unused to him they were by all manner of things. His bare face and the quirks of his expressions, the politely odd way he spoke. His bootless feet and the tufts of hair covering them; his linen clothes and their simple earthen colours and buttons all over. His familiarity and warmth, for he knew that even for a hobbit he was usually quite uppity, and for it to dissipate so rapidly with the dwarves was strange to both them and Gandalf, he was sure, though Gandalf was likely just glad he didn’t have to warm any icy waters between them.

One such day, it was a small spot of cultural difference between their two peoples that had both Bilbo and the dwarves stumped.

“How on Earth can you not know what a harmonica is, Bofur!”

All Bilbo’d done was tell Bofur that he thought he’d make an excellent harmonica player, and that if he hadn’t already, he should give it a try, and now Bofur was looking at Bilbo like he’d suddenly grown feet out his ears.

“Aren’t you a toymaker?” Bilbo cried. Bofur was convinced he was making things up that simply didn’t exist, and for some infuriating reason Gandalf refused outright to attest to Bilbo’s honesty. He was an inch away from pulling his own hair out. The two of them swayed in tandem as their ponies picked up to a steady trot, following the curve the Company made.

“You blow into it, just like your flute.” Bilbo insisted desperately, ignoring Gandalf’s amused smile lurking in his periphery. “You’d be a natural!”

“Oh, aye, Bilbo, it sounds beautiful, if it were only real!”

“Oh, for — I’ll show you how to make them so you and Bifur can sell them in your toy shop. I’ve not done it before, but it’s not like you’ll know the difference even if it’s utterly terrible, will you!” Bofur threw his head back and laughed, clutching at the back of his hat so it didn’t fall off.

Bilbo always forgot how much he’d missed Bofur until he saw him again. The merry laughter rang in his ears long after they’d moved onto talking about something else.

All in all, his second-go-around was travelling rather swimmingly. The only real problem, of course, was that Bilbo still could not look at Thorin.

It had been weeks now, and he could not make himself look the King Under the Mountain in the eye. It was getting to be exceedingly bothersome, to tell the truth, and Thorin spoke little to him enough as it was, which certainly didn’t help matters. Bilbo refused to count up every instance and fawn over them like a ditzy lass in the throes of infatuation.

(But so far they had been, as follows):

“Your turn to carry the cookery, Master Burglar.”

“We turn east at sundown.”

“Pheasant stew.”

“If you want to collect more mushrooms, be our guest.”

“Wake up.”

“Wake up.”

“Wake up.”

“You’re late.”

“Bundle up your bedding more tightly.”

“I will take the watch.”

Grumpy, but watchful, taking Bilbo into his company more reluctantly than Bilbo had ever seen anyone do but still making sure to do it nevertheless. It was as if he were a rosebush overgrown with thorns.

At that moment, a brown satchel clunked to the ground right in front of Bilbo and startled him quite entirely out of his wits. He squeaked and jerked backward at the sudden noise, then cut his gaze over to where Thorin’s boots were trudging away beyond the outskirts of the camp. He’d dropped the rucksack of pots and pans at Bilbo’s feet. He hadn’t even looked at Bilbo once while he’d done it.

Not quite a rosebush, then. Perhaps he was more like a thistle of weeds that shocked you silly when it managed to grow one measly little flower. Bilbo glared.

But even then, he could not bring himself to look.

(It was quite simple, really. He was terrified that if he did, he would find that Thorin’s eyes had closed again.)

The only times Bilbo ever felt brave enough to look Thorin Oakenshield in the face were when everything and everyone else was still and silent with sleep, and so each night, he would lay unseen by all but the stars and let his eyes rest gently on Thorin.

He thought of the King Under the Mountain, asleep under the rock for eternity, bearing both against and within his chest the heart of the kingdom of Erebor. He thought of his still and unbroken face, his hair splayed out behind him like a dark halo. How a piece of his own soul had been left there when he’d turned away.

Bilbo remembered it well, as well as if it were an imprint behind his eyelids. The ten of them left, standing together and smiling so terribly sadly as he walked away from them with staff and pack in hand. The way he’d turned one final time and raised his hand towards the Mountain in unspoken farewell, for there had been no words for the chasm that had opened in his chest, and he could not bear to say goodbye.

The way he had walked for many long miles with tears sticking on his face, the December wind whipping and pulling at him as he and Gandalf walked quietly side by side, back towards the West. The way Gandalf had told him that he would no longer be able to see the Lonely Mountain once they reached the feet of the Grey Mountain-range and the edge of Mirkwood, and Bilbo had not turned back to look upon it. Not even once.

He'd felt like the final page had been ripped out of a storybook. Or wondered if maybe the reason nobody much liked adventures in the Shire was because they did not like to talk about what came after they ended.

If matters could’ve been made any worse, Bilbo was sure he would have done so, no matter how desperately he wished otherwise. For it was also true that he’d only realised the depth of the feeling in his heart when he’d been left alone on the ice, numbness and nothingness tearing at his skin like blunt bramble-knots, and known with a sudden, hollowing clarity that grieving a love who had never known you loved them at all was the worst heartache a soul might be able to bear.

Bilbo thought about how he had never written his grief over Thorin into his book, had never once mentioned it aloud to a single living soul, though no doubt those who knew had been able to see it all over him plain as day. He had never been able to put on paper what he felt, and how the loss had pressed against him on all sides, pushing at his ribcage for much longer than he had made out to anyone else.

How Thorin had become a presence in the back of his mind, sleepy and soothing after he’d had time to heal and the acorn planted in his garden had blossomed into her beautiful oak, the warmth like coming home again after a long time away. 

(Oh, Bilbo had missed him so dearly.)

Sometimes, when he was a boy, Frodo would ask him if he missed his dwarf-friends, and Bilbo would smile and say Yes, my lad. I miss them very much, and I love them all like family. But that was the end of it. Thorin had simply stayed nestled in his heart, twining his way around Bilbo’s arms and hands and nerves and knitting his fragile skin back together until the thought of him was warm rather than deathly cold, even if still bittersweet.

I would have liked to show you the sun, my dear. 

I would have liked to lay in the grass on the hillside with you, and look at the sky, and smell the change in the air when springtime came.  

To read to him, or let his own fumbling fingers be taught how to weave through dwarven hair, or wander through the garden and show him how to ask the plants to grow. To slide their fingers together against each other’s palms, for he had never, not once, gotten the chance.

Some years after the battle, Balin had come to visit, and memory meant they’d sat as always in their assigned places at Bilbo’s table from that one long-ago unexpected evening.

“How goes the Mountain?” Bilbo asked, late at night over steaming mugs of tea and spiced rum cradled in their hands.

Balin had told him how they were prospering at last, after so long in hardship and squalor, and how more and more dwarves flocked to Erebor as time went on and their reign of peace continued, and how no servants of evil would dare to come near the base of the Mountain, for they could not succeed.

“He tells us when they are near. With Orcrist.” And he had smiled, with ages drawn in the lines of his face, the weary fondness of someone who was remembering someone else long gone. “He protects us, even still.”

Bilbo had turned away after he’d left, and pulled his knees and elbows up in front of the fireplace, and cried, and cried, and cried.

He did not know how to think of Thorin in his grief, for he did not even know where dwarves were taken when their bodies departed from the realm of the living. Thorin on his deathbed had spoken of the dwarven halls of waiting, and Bilbo imagined great pillars of beautiful marbled rock, and gems of all kinds nestled sweetly in the caverns, and golden lining everywhere among all the forefathers of old. He often wondered if Thorin would be happy there.

Well, now, he didn’t need to wonder, did he? Thorin was living and breathing and given back to him, and yet Bilbo could not shake what had become habit after so very long with loss filling his chest. This Thorin was a mirage, a glimpse at possibility, and Bilbo did not dare look at him too long lest he disappear.

The dwarf in question turned back and looked over all of them, his eyes alert and on guard, his mind so clearly working at doubled pace. Bilbo scratched at Myrtle’s ears and looked away silently.

You are still so far from me.

He watched Thorin watching in the night for signs of danger, never sleeping, laying down but with blue eyes open. His furs would be piled around him, and he was always hidden in shadow, tucked into a rock or beside a knoll of grass, never too close to the warmth of the fire’s embers or the bodies of his kin all nestled together. His face never once changed expression.

Bilbo chastised himself with an inward scowl. And really, it wasn’t as though when he looked at Thorin he only saw the body left behind — lidless eyes staring upwards and a chest that stayed still and fingers that were bitterly, bitingly pale. He wasn’t the sort to burst into tears at every sight of him; it had been many years, and Bilbo liked to think he had at least a little more sensibility than that.

But oh, the ache. To remember the way he’d moved, the way his feet fell against the earth in that steady stride, the way his low voice hummed like ash across the fire the rare times he spoke at night. To see him raise his head to the sky to look ahead on their journey, shaking the hair from his face, and know that if Bilbo were to close his eyes and fall into a dream, all of his memories would look exactly the same. Knowing that such a tangible presence had been stolen from its place among the living broke Bilbo’s heart, and he spent much of his time with a hum in his chest, whispering I missed you, how I missed you, how I had to miss you. 

Thorin did not like it, of course, though he never made it known to Bilbo. It was disrespectful, to look away from a king, and yet Bilbo could do nothing else. He feared that if he reached out to touch him, he’d fade away like mist. He feared that he was whirling through some Elvish vision to calm him or placate him through the journey beyond the sea, and all the while he was still old and frail and fading aboard the ships out of the Grey Havens. He feared that this flicker of a second life wasn’t real, and that if it was, he would not be enough to save them. And if Bilbo failed, he feared he would not get the chance to try again, and he would spend all of eternity in Valinor with an utterly broken heart.


Tthe Company would most often stop at midday to eat and replenish their energy, and on one of these occasions they happened to come across a field of low-rising flowers. Nothing quite like the meadows of unimaginable colour Bilbo knew lay beyond the Misty Mountains, but the rosy pink of the petals that speckled the downy grass still brought a sigh to his heart. They were dainty, the colour of strawberry milk when they muddled it together in the Shire; the colour of his mother’s brushes. 

He could see Fili wandering at the edge of the group with a few strips of jerky in his hand, and walked over just as the dwarf knelt down with a curious sort of frown towards the flowers waving at them. 

“It’s a peony,” Bilbo said gently, when Fili’s cautious hand seemed to pause before it could touch the pale bud closest to him. They’d been Frodo’s favourite flower. Bilbo knew like the back of his own hand that they told of love, honour, prosperity, and bashfulness. They also told of impending doom.

His throat crushed up into itself.

“A what?” Fili asked, sounding confused. He stood, and moved to take a step just as Bilbo bent down to brush the peony with his fingers.

“Don’t step on it,” Bilbo said quickly.

Fili’s lifted boot lowered back to the ground, and they blinked at each other from two different heights. Bilbo flashed an offbeat smile at him and looked back towards the washed-out flower field.

Hello, Frodo. I wonder if this is you here, telling me you’re still thinking of little old me.

The softer colours had always been the ones Frodo loved best, but Bilbo suddenly wished with a regret that threatened to choke him that he’d tucked a yellow peony into Frodo’s pack before they’d left Middle-Earth for the sea, so he could have given him his new beginning before he left him behind.

Better to forget, my lad, he thought sadly. Better to rest.

“They’re very special to hobbits. We have no language of our own, so the flowers are our secret way of speaking.” Bilbo rose and turned to wander back towards the ponies, and Fili fell into step beside him. “I love flowers,” he admitted.

“But they die,” Fili said, still sounding a little hesitant. It made sense; dwarves loved gemstones more than anything else, and the beauty of a grown garden was so vastly different that Bilbo thought he may as well have told Fili he worshipped sand, or dirt, or some other preposterous thing. 

He tilted his head back and shrugged instead. “So do lots of things.”

“What’s your favourite flower, then, Bilbo?” Fili tore into a piece of jerky with his teeth and began to chew.

Bilbo was quiet for a while, and a soft, secret smile crept onto his face that he was sure told more of a story than anything else he had said.

“Lily-of-the-valley. It means ‘the return of happiness’.” He tucked his hands into his trouser-pockets as they strolled back to the rest of their scattered-about group. “It’s a white flower, quite small, and it has little bells for petals that hang all the way along the stems. I remember my mother used to pick sprouts of it and dangle them in my face so the bells would tickle my nose. When I was a very little hobbit, she used to hold them out of my reach, and I’d jump up and try to catch them.”

He closed his eyes briefly. “Flower-speech is the closest thing we have to our own tongue, and using them that way is like being able to use a hundred words at once. The flowers tell a story.  It’s certainly no Khuzdûl, but sometimes… well, sometimes they’ve been the only way I could say what I really meant.”

They’d made it back to the Company, then, and the other dwarves had begun to listen in curiously after hearing Bilbo chastise Fili about the peonies.

“I planted a flower-garden once to tell a story, a long time ago,” Bilbo said, in gentle explanation, blinking his eyes open. “I used to stand in the middle of it with my eyes closed and let the breeze blow right by. I know you dwarves can sometimes find things like that silly,” he smiled, “but I think you would have liked my little garden.”

Purple and white hyacinths. Poppies and rosemary and sweetpea and lilac and butterfly weed. Red carnations and forget-me-nots and gardenias and blue and red salvia. And snapdragons.

He couldn’t help but squint in the sunlight at his sudden audience. All of them were watching him. Even Thorin was watching him, though the expression on his face was not fond. It rather looked as though Bilbo’s words had somehow caught his notice, and that this notice had greatly displeased him.

If Bilbo was honest with himself, that was the way Thorin had always looked at him, in those long-ago days before they’d made it through the Misty Mountains and past the goblins chasing them. Bilbo rather thought that instead of suddenly realising his worth all at once the way it had seemed, Thorin had felt Bilbo very slowly growing on him like a weed, and had been exceedingly irritated by the fact.

(It was how Bilbo had always thought of Thorin, after all, when he’d woken up one day and realised how deeply he'd come to care for the dwarf’s opinion, and how woven amongst them all he now was. It was like he’d blinked and the colour had suddenly bled into the world, all over his hands and staining the pages of his books, only for Bilbo to realise that it’d been there all along and he’d simply needed to open his eyes.)

They’d always been circling each other in that first lifetime, really. Thorin had gotten stuck in his head and hadn’t let go, almost from the very first day, when he’d sung the sorrow of his people and drawn a line from his own soul to Bilbo’s in doing it. So Bilbo thought he might have gotten stuck in Thorin’s head in the same way, and that after a while on their first journey, Thorin had simply stopped pushing back.

It hadn’t been in the same way, of course; Thorin had trusted him, and sought his opinion, had led and been led by him, but Bilbo carried his heart alone, cupped in the weary palms of his hands. 

It struck him that it was a very bittersweet thing to think. 

“We will go around the flowers,” said Thorin gruffly, saddling up his pony. His eyes sifted over Bilbo as they passed across his Company, and he drew them away so Bilbo could not reciprocate the gaze even if he had wanted to. There was a hollow nestled in his jaw where he’d clenched it, and his expression was jade-sharp and stormy. The clouds were rolling in.

No, Thorin was not fond at all.

But they would go around the flowers.


Bilbo had forgotten, in hindsight, however, how hard the rain came down.

It turned streams and creeks a sickly milk-brown, and the sky the colour of thunder, and the ground beneath them to thick, stinking sludge. The ponies had to work twice as hard to pull their feet from the mud and mess, and the peacefully brisk pace they’d set since leaving Bag End slowed to an unbearable drag, the wind wild and whipping at their faces like needle-points.

The ponies had fallen to half-stumbling blindly through the whitewash in front of them before Thorin made the call for them to stop, defeated and shivering, huddling under whatever shelter they could salvage from the overhanging trees. If there had been one thing Bilbo could have done without reliving, it would have been this forced cowering from the constant wind. 

It was barely any time at all after they’d made shelter before a sense of deep unease began to creep its way up Bilbo’s limbs. The chill crawled into his waterlogged skin and chattering teeth and clutched at his nerves until he was sure something was dangerously wrong — as if they shouldn’t have come here. His skin itched with it. 

It wasn’t until he saw Gandalf storming furiously away from Thorin and into the grey haze that he realised what exactly the itch was and his stomach tried to upend itself in panic.

“He can’t leave.”

He’d said it quietly, almost without meaning to, and he vaguely registered Bofur turning to glance at him, hat sopping-wet and dripping water into his eyes.

“Don’t you worry, Bilbo! He’ll be back sooner or later.”

Bilbo stood up quite suddenly from the log he’d been hovering on, upsetting Bofur’s balance and tipping him headfirst onto the ground. His heart was pounding. 

“He can’t leave. We’re not safe here.” He turned quickly, eyes flitting around in rapidly-increasing desperation, but the darkness had neatly swallowed Gandalf up without a trace. They were alone.

He felt skittish. Jittery. He could feel prickles of nervous dread and anticipation running along his shoulder-blades, and he’d never mourned the lack of Sting quite as sharply as he did at that moment. Bilbo hadn’t ever fully mastered the swing of it, trusting instead on rage and the wild thud of his heart in every moment he’d needed to use it, but the emptiness of the little sword in the notch of his belt felt then like the phantom ache of a limb.

He’d been too complacent. What was he thinking? This wasn’t just a holiday with old friends; he hadn’t been given a second chance only to spend all his time smiling stupidly and telling stories and mooning over Thorin’s ceaseless frowning. He’d come back to keep them all safe.

Oh, pull yourself together, you old ninny! You managed this part without Sting the first time, and you shall manage without it again!

“Fili,” Bilbo said hesitantly. “I need your knife.”

That got the attention of quite a few of the dwarves ducking out of the wind, as he’d hoped it would not but suspected it might. Dwalin looked scandalised. Fili himself looked increasingly protective, and one of his hands had gone to his weapons belt, but he seemed to be considering the request, at least. His careful eyes fell on Bilbo.

“Why? Bilbo, you —”

“Please. I need you to trust me,” Bilbo whispered, knowing he sounded completely absurd. “We are not alone.”

As if on cue, a loud and terrible crack rang through the treeline, shaking the boughs above them and causing a flock of birds to stir from their sheltering-places up into the night. Afterwards, there came what sounded like boulders tumbling down a mountain; what was likely the sound of gigantic, ugly footsteps.

Several heads snapped back towards Bilbo, but he was off, on two feet and creeping methodically through the underbrush, grabbing at tree trunks and peeking his head out from behind them to scope out the forest up ahead.

“What is it, Bilbo?” asked Balin, who’d never been one to doubt him. Bilbo was filled with profound gratitude. “What do you see?”

Those blasted trolls.

Bilbo had the best eyes of all of them above ground, but before he could speak, Thorin answered instead. 

“There is a light, up amongst those trees.” His voice was low and entirely stoic, and he only briefly glanced Bilbo’s way, turning instead towards Fili and Kili with a grave look in his eye. “Check the ponies.”

They returned soon after with predictably matching expressions of alarm.

“We’re four down,” Kili said worriedly.

“Exactly,” said Bilbo, quiet urgency in his voice. “I need to poke around and see if there’s anything we can do. We can’t all go charging off without a single idea of what we’re up against, and I am the smallest here. Which is why I need your knife, Fili.”

“Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, and the ever-growing lump in Bilbo’s throat came back with a vengeance. “Do you think it entirely wise to go charging into an enemy camp barely armed? You are not a fighter. A dagger is not enough to defend yourself.”

Bilbo wrestled madly with the urge to roll his eyes in Thorin’s face, knowing he’d take it abysmally. 

"I have been brought on this quest as a burglar, Master Oakenshield, and so burgling is what I shall do.”

And really, there wasn’t any reason to be fussing. One little hobbit, shoeless, silent, skirting round the bushes with a measly borrowed knife didn't exactly invite violence. He smoothed down the folds of his coat and turned to the others with bright eyes.

“You should stay close, but hide in the trees. You must hide. Don’t move or make the slightest sound, not unless it’s either completely fine or all gone horribly wrong, or unless I make it very clear that I need you.” He got a few warily trusting nods, but Thorin’s scowl was still all over his face.

“They will catch you,” he argued bluntly.

Bilbo turned around and began to walk, not deigning to bother with Thorin when his ears were clearly full of rocks.

“I have a plan for that, too,” he shot over his shoulder.

He was utterly silent as he crept out of the trees and made a stealthy beeline for the atrocious excuse of a pen the trolls had fashioned for Myrtle, Minty, Daisy and Bungo, a line of dwarves trailing after him in the distance. Far above him, the trolls were arguing, and their groaning and moaning and belching rang like a cacophony against Bilbo’s eardrums, but he tried to block them out as best he could, instead exhaling a breath of cool air through his teeth and continuing on his way into the clearing. 

He soon reached the line of rope cutting the ponies off, drew Fili’s little blade from his trouser-pocket, and got right to work, glad it hadn’t shorn through the lining of his clothes.

All too soon, however, he was regretting the thought, and was in fact rather incensed at the stubborn distrust of dwarves, even after you have become friends and all, it seems! Oh, confusticate every one of them for not bearing to part with a single weapon for five minutes!

Fili had given Bilbo what was the worst knife he had possibly ever laid eyes on, and he was barely making a dent in the thick line of rope strung up across the ponies’ pen. Worse still, the rope was made with such coarse twine, and the knife so blunt and pocked with chips and scrapes, that every stroke made an awful screeching noise, no matter how quietly or slowly Bilbo tried to slice. He swallowed every bit of nerve and heart that was resting in his throat and carried on uselessly while trying to devise a backup plan, searching round the nearby grass for signs of jagged rocks.

But the noise of the blunt knife was so sharp in the darkness, that just when Bilbo’s arms were beginning to tire and he was almost considering creeping back into the leaves beyond the camp to ask for a knife that actually worked, a loud, rumbling bellow echoed out from behind him, and Bilbo knew his time was up.

He dropped his hands to his sides, spun, and ducked just as a fist the size of his whole dining table swiped out at him, dashing out from the pen into the centre of the clearing, just past the troll’s bonfire and clearly in plain sight. The heat from it was scorching up close, and Bilbo felt himself begin to drip with sweat.

“Blimey, Bert, Bill, look what’s scurrying round in the bushes! What is it, d’ya reckon?” one of the three trolls boomed with a voice like a rockslide, swinging his huge hands again towards Bilbo, who dropped immediately, scrambling back until he was out of reach of their colossal, grabby arms. 

“Well? What are ya, then?” The troll - Tom, he guessed - said, and Bilbo was suddenly faced with three pairs of huge bloodshot, blinking eyes towering over him on the ground. He felt like an ant looking up at a pair of boots. He stared up at them defiantly, feeling the cold rush of adrenaline flood through him, telling him to survive, save them, get your sword, and be on your way.

“Why, I’m a fellow traveller looking for a meal, of course,” Bilbo countered, quite calmly, “and I was just on my way to catch some dwarves when I stumbled upon you lot.”

“Dwarves?” Bert exclaimed, and the quaking roar in his voice shook the trees around them.

“Yes, dwarves,” Bilbo said in exasperation, hiding the trembling of his hands surreptitiously behind his back. “There’s an encampment of dwarves, just nearby, and I can lead you right to them.” He bit his lip and closed his eyes for a beat at the sudden angry whispers filtering out from the forest, fear clutching at his throat, but they quietened before the trolls stopped arguing with each other long enough to focus again on Bilbo, leering.

“You think we’ll believe you after ya tried to set our dinner loose?” Bill said accusingly, and Bilbo clenched his eyes shut even tighter, breathing out a curse, knowing they could very well see the knife glinting out from behind his back. He opened his eyes and rolled them mightily, hoping against hope he was selling every bit of his performance to this trio of half-wits.

“The ponies will trot right on back to their masters, and we can follow them the whole way there. I’m doing you three a favour, I should think.” He paused. “Big, hulking, ugly dwarves they are, too, and nothing but rocks and stones in their heads, besides. An easier meal than having to gut and carve up a couple of ponies, I’m sure.”

Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo could see the outraged faces of several of the dwarves crouching in the undergrowth, the betrayal clear in the bright anger of their eyes, but still they all stayed quiet and did not move a muscle.

All of them, that was, except Thorin, whose face Bilbo could see starkest against the shadows of the forest, and who was watching him with a coldness that seemed to stroke its way up Bilbo’s spine. He could see in Thorin’s eyes that he did not trust Bilbo at all, and that every word Bilbo was speaking to the trolls was driving the wedge deeper and deeper.

Bilbo fixed his eyes sharply on Thorin’s, pleading with him silently to trust him, trust him. They could not take the trolls by force, and they could not leave without the ponies or the blades still hidden deep in the grime of the troll-hoard nearby. There was no other way for them to play this. He knew what he was doing.

With horror, Bilbo watched as Thorin shook his head slightly, his braids swinging as he began to step forward from out of the thicket of leaves, heavy boots crushing the shoots beneath his feet. Bilbo quickly let the tips of his fingers twitch upwards from his side, motioning for Thorin to stay still, to wait. He took a shuddering breath.

Thorin stilled.

Please. Please trust me.

But the crunch of the boots had already echoed through the stillness of the camp, and with the trolls peering at him as closely as they were, the one nearest to him leant in, squinting down at him and then over to the bushes where the dwarves were all concealed. Bilbo held his breath against the hot air washing over his face, the smell of it like rotting flesh. 

“What was that?”

Bilbo stood his ground, holding himself so still he thought his jaw might crack with the force of it. He cast around wildly, hoping the sun was near, hoping the dawn would hurry.

“Well, it’s - probably one of them running away! You’d best follow me, and quickly, otherwise the cowardly thing might make it back to camp and let the others know of your plans before you can gobble them all up in time.”

The trolls were still sneering and snotting at him, but Bilbo could see their eyes alight with the temptation of fresh meat ripe for the taking. “Tom, grab the sacks,” Bill said, flashing the nubs in his mouth that passed for teeth in a horrible smile.

They’d barely taken a step away from the camp and from the trees the dwarves were hiding in when he heard what were unmistakably the cries of battle. Bilbo’s stomach sank down into his knees.

All of them, all of them, had raced into the clearing with axes aloft and eyes ablaze and were waging war on whatever parts of the trolls they could get to, their hands, their ankles and legs, their beady, bloody eyes looking down in surprise.

Bombur was spinning like a top, a hammer in each hand, and Dwalin’s angry snarl was like out of a tapestry of the First Age, and Nori was dancing and weaving through the trolls’ stumbling feet, and Kili’s blade sliced at their limbs with such striking ferocity that Bilbo felt utterly aghast. He did not know what to do. He didn’t have a single weapon on him apart from Fili’s useless knife, not a slingshot or a sword or even a toothpick, and he began to shout with increasing panic.

“Oh - dear, they’ve gotten the jump on us! Look here, you trolls, I’ll lead them away, and you wait in the trees to take them by surprise when I circle back -” Oh, you thickheaded, stubborn, pieces of work, you couldn’t leave me alone for a second!

The howls of the trolls shook the branches of the forest. There were knives flying, crashes of immense limbs, bits of dirt kicking up and spraying the sky. The flames of the fire began to grow. All the dwarves were bellowing to each other in Khuzdûl, their voices hardened in the brawl. Bilbo saw one of the trolls’ faces distort into a gruesome scowl, its features twisting and muddying into something grotesque, and he took a few steps back, twigs snapping under his bare feet.

Then there was a desperate shout, and the blood under his skin turned to ice. 

Bilbo spun around. The largest of the trolls had gripped Kili by the ankles and was dangling him high in the air like a piece of limp bait on a fishhook. Kili’s eyes were wide with panic, and he was shouting down to the dwarves below him, hair in his eyes as he thrashed and threw his body around to desperately try and hack at the troll’s fingers.

His eyes raced once more around the clearing in terror; Bombur was being dragged along the ground by the weediest of the trolls, Bifur and Bofur chasing after him and throwing their weapons uselessly, Dwalin had lost one axe, and Thorin, Thorin was wielding his broadsword like a dagger, fingers gripped round the hilt and angling it downwards as he stabbed, hair wild around his face. A huge hand swiped for him and he ducked out of the way, sliding across the floor and cutting at the troll’s calves. Bilbo felt sick with fear. The panic was truly setting in, now, and he began to stammer in his haste to stop it and save the situation from catastrophe.

“Oh, dear, maybe not that one!” he almost screamed over the din at the one still tossing Kili about. “He seems to be - yes,  I can see it now, he’s riddled! Riddled all over, with parasites, and in fact, if he’s riddled, then the rest of them must be - ah, now that I can see them clearly, it seems they’re all riddled, must have all caught the same disease, now, that’s horrid luck! I’m afraid you won’t be able to eat them after all, Master Trolls, not unless you want to make yourselves terribly sick, I’m so sorry for leading you on such a goose-chase when you’ll have nothing to - Oh!"

The rock split. Light began to pour in.

“The dawn will take you all!”

Gandalf had come.

The trolls turned to see who’d made such a noise, but it was too late. The boulder fell to one side with a staggering crash, and daylight spilled through in a great cascade. All three trolls realised what lay ahead in unison and threw their hands up in terror, the action tossing Kili through the air like a ragdoll. The heavy hollowness that rang out when he hit the ground seized at Bilbo’s chest like a coil around his heart.

The shrieking stopped. They were stone once more. 

Each of the dwarves slowly began to pick themselves up from where they’d been strewn around the clearing like toys littering the floor in a child’s playroom, breathing hard from the exertion. Kili got to his feet and touched at his forehead a little. His sleeve was torn, and his head was likely ringing quite badly, but he seemed all right. Bilbo watched as Fili dashed over to pummel him in the arm and admonish him for being so reckless in the fight.

Oin soon hurried over to where Fili and Kili were standing, his ear trumpet tucked under one bustling arm, and Bilbo made to follow him until a loud grunt from somewhere nearby stopped him quite in his tracks.

In front of him, Thorin Oakenshield began to stagger to his feet. Their eyes met.

“You should not,” Thorin said lowly, “have done something so risky, Master Burglar.”

He wasn’t quite spitting the words out, but Bilbo could see that there was real anger behind that ever-present appearance of stone. “You had no way of knowing what they would do.”

The coldness of his eyes had Bilbo bristling at once. 

“Actually, I rather think that I had it under control, thank you, and I did ask you to follow my lead. I cannot help it if you go tearing into places without a second thought.” 

Nearly got yourselves all killed, I should think. And what would I have done then, Thorin? What would I have done then?

“You should have told us what you planned to do before you blindly walked in there,” Thorin said more loudly, and the tone of his voice had sharpened to ice. His eyes were fixed on Bilbo with a look of utter contempt. “You are unarmed and alone, and there are thirteen of us with experience. You would have gotten yourself killed.”

It was then that the already-shortening fuse on Bilbo’s temper snapped.

“As you’ve kindly pointed out, Master Oakenshield, I am not a fighter, and I am small and defenceless, and so I must use the tools at my disposal to best my enemies instead. How would you feel if you were locked in battle with an orc, and I came and tapped you on the shoulder in the middle of things and told you you were doing it wrong? I nearly had them, before you all raced in. And I do appreciate you helping me, truly, but you do not have to needlessly put yourselves in danger when I know quite well what I am doing and how I am doing it!”

“You are under our protection -”

“Oh, don’t give me that rot, Thorin Oakenshield,” Bilbo snapped, anger flaring. “You don’t need or want to protect me any more than you have to.”

Thorin’s jaw hardened, and his eyes were dark as night. It was as though they were locked in combat, and the other dwarves around them were a silent, eager audience. Bilbo imagined the air crackling around them. If someone had lit a match between them at that exact moment, there might even have been an explosion.

“You are right. I do not,” Thorin said harshly. “You are lucky to have made it out of there.”

Bilbo’s voice cracked as he spoke, but he pushed on, adrenaline, embarrassment and fiercely lingering worry all working to keep him aflame. 

“I’ve managed quite a long time in my life without you,” Bilbo said angrily, “and I can manage without you again.” He whirled round and stormed off in a righteous huff.

Anger prickled at his skin and the corners of his eyes infuriatingly. He pushed right past where Gandalf was leaning against his staff and waiting patiently for them to put themselves back together. 

“Shouldn’t we be looking for the cave they crawled out of?” Bilbo asked through gritted teeth, marching off into the thicket of trees and straight towards his beloved, obedient sword.

Gandalf did not speak for a moment as he followed, but Bilbo could tell he was greatly amused, and the thought darkened his mood even further. He felt like a thundercloud walking around on legs. He supposed it matched the dismal weather.

“Indeed, my dear fellow. I see you are already leading the way. On we go!”


Bilbo took to riding at the front of the pack after that.

He knew this rather royally aggravated Thorin, and that his sudden protectiveness after spending so long content to blend in at the back would be irksome, but he found he did not much care. It calmed him, just as being able to feel for the hilt of Sting at his belt now calmed him; he’d spent eighty years with the little sword by his side, and even if he was no warrior, he felt better with than without it.

He would drift back every so often to wander next to the ones trailing at the end of the line, which was usually Oin or Bifur or Ori, and he’d spend the briskness of quiet mornings alongside them, asking about each of their lives, for he knew Ori was a scribe, and Oin a healer, and Bifur a toymaker. 

A few times, he and Oin got to talking about the plants that grew high up in the Blue Mountains, and the differences in herbs between there and the Shire. Bilbo had quietly told him that when he was a very small child, Belladonna had always used a dwarvish recipe for soup with healing properties that she’d learnt when she was still a traveller, and Oin had smiled and told him that it was indeed a staple of dwarvish medicine, and that his mother had been blessed.

Once, he’d asked Bifur if he’d like to learn the language of the flowers that grew from the Shire.

“You cannot speak it, and it isn’t even really a language, if I’m being honest, but then we’d both know the meaning of something not written in words.”

Bifur had nodded, pleased, and pressed his fingers against his chest lightly. Bilbo had been touched by the gesture, and wished there was more vegetation growing around the outskirts of Erebor that he could have shown Bifur once they reached the Lonely Mountain.

Bilbo would always drift further up the line of ponies as the morning went on, sometimes riding in quiet companionship with Bombur, or watching Gloin as he regaled Fili and Kili with stories of their little cousin Gimli to much laughter, for he was back at home and seething that he’d missed out on the quest. Often he’d share a pipe or two with Bofur, and sometimes he’d even let the dwarf have a pinch of Old Toby instead of that awful acrid stuff the dwarves loved to smoke.

But by midday, he would make it back to the front of the Company and ride alongside or in front of Thorin, and often Balin and Dwalin as well.

Thorin would usually spend the rest of the day glowering darkly at him when he did this, but Bilbo made sure to ignore him. He could see in Thorin’s face that he could not argue with Bilbo’s desire to watch over them all, and even agreed with it, but that Bilbo including him in the circle of protection was making him murderous, not least because he now had Orcrist resting at his belt.

(The sight seemed more complete, somehow.)

The fear that had clutched coldly at his insides when he’d seen Kili dangling in the air like a strung-up bit of meat had shocked Bilbo. He hadn’t realised it consciously until that moment, but he could not even begin to bear parting with any of them again. Not Kili, not Bombur, not any one of them. He was sure it would drown him. He would have to do whatever his body and brain could manage to keep them from harm.

He would not be at peace until all thirteen of them were safe, he knew. Until they had their Mountain once again, and all of them had made it through what was still to come. All of them.

“You are getting in the way,” Thorin said in a low voice when Bilbo rode up to trot beside him.

“Good,” Bilbo replied. “Maybe when the orcs find us you’ll see that I do in fact know which end of a sword I’m supposed to be holding.”

“Very noble, Master Burglar, but must you ride in front of me?”

“We’re going the same way, aren’t we? Through the Hidden Valley, if I’m not mistaken.”

The lines of anger that streaked across Thorin’s face grew deeper, but his voice was cool and indifferent when he replied, “You and the wizard seem to think so, and I have not been able to change your minds.”

He was well aware Thorin thought of him as a thorn in his side, or a bothersome speck of dust floating around in his face, or an insect he couldn’t quite seem to swat away. But if Thorin thought Bilbo was going to defer to him after the complete mess he’d made of Bilbo's beautiful plan to draw the trolls out, he was even more blindly stubborn than Bilbo remembered.

And none of the other dwarves minded his traipsing back and forth, always eager for a chat or a song, so Bilbo continued to hover, and Thorin continued to scowl.

Notes:

meanings of the flowers in bilbo's garden (this will be a recurring theme):

poppies: peace in death, eternal sleep
salvia (blue): i am thinking of you, i miss you
rosemary: remembrance
gardenias: a secret love
hyacinth (purple): sorrow, forgiveness
red carnation: deep love, my poor heart aches
hyacinth (white): sending prayers to someone
lilac: moving on
butterfly weed: let me go
sweetpea: a blissful farewell
forget-me-nots: i will not ever forget you, do not forget me
salvia (red): forever mine

my twitter if you need to find me!