Chapter Text
The smell of grain and wildgrass on the breeze told Bilbo where he was before he’d opened his eyes.
With them still closed, Bilbo could see the hull of the Elven-ship in his mind’s eye, the white of it gleaming as they sailed farther and farther away from the shore. The pinkish palette of the sky painted on top of the water, and the varnished wood beneath his feet, the tap-tapping it made against the stick he was using as a support to walk. Sea-salt blew through the fine wisps of his grey hair and speckled his pockmarked cheeks. The amber glow of the sunset against the tower that stood lonely on the western shore marked the last point of the world. Bilbo had thought it odd that such a sight was called the Grey Havens when he’d never seen so much colour.
Three figures stood against the railing on the bow, watching the shoreline; two in graceful, flowing white robes, tall and still, and a smaller one in simple beiges and browns with a cord tied round his waist. Bilbo had sheltered behind them, quiet and frail with the marks of rapid age, and he’d smiled slowly to himself, feeling it wrinkle the folds of his face. His deteriorating voice came out as nothing more than a creak when he spoke.
“I think I’m quite ready,” he said to them, or maybe to himself, “for another adventure.”
After a moment he became slowly aware of a touch to his forehead from long and gentle fingers, but when his eyelids blinked open Gandalf and Galadriel were still standing either side of Frodo, both watching Bilbo as he felt himself drift. There was a silent, puzzling understanding in their gazes, and he wondered what exactly it was they were understanding.
Wondering was quite tiring. He sat down.
His shaky line of sight slipped to eye level, and he felt the lingering remnants of what must have been dismay. A single silver tear-track had crept its way down Frodo’s face.
Who had put that there? Bilbo felt sure he would have noticed it, being Frodo’s guardian as he was. Though, in truth, he wasn’t awfully sure how long ago that had been. It was as though there were clouds in his head where before there had been thoughts.
It was no matter, anyhow. He must have been there if Frodo had needed him.
There was suddenly a voice somewhere in the distance that was trying to part the clouds. Bilbo squinted blearily in an attempt to hear better.
“You have lived long and served well, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire,” it said, in a silken voice that must have belonged to the Lady of Lórien. White petals seemed to rain down around her as she spoke, but then, no; they were on a boat, in the middle of the ocean! No trees to be found. No petals. His eyes had just gone misty again. Bilbo closed them and felt it like the folding of paper.
“Not of the Shire anymore, are we?” he whispered — or thought he might have. He’d heard that scratchy noise that seemed to be him now, at any rate. “Not anymore, Frodo. We’re of the sea and the waves now.”
He couldn’t quite remember who’d spoken to him, and thought it must have been Frodo, since that was who he’d replied to, but it was Galadriel still standing in all her glory before him. The other figure in his vision Bilbo knew to be Gandalf — but then it wasn’t Gandalf, somehow, because Bilbo distinctly remembered that Gandalf always wore a hat.
But it was Gandalf, wearing a different colour, for some strange reason. How peculiar! Bilbo tried to frown but felt that his eyes were simply too tired, so he closed them once more.
“You should get some rest, Bilbo,” he heard his boy say from far, far, away, and Bilbo made to murmur back but found instead that he was falling, falling down into himself, his thoughts slowly turning to nothing but quiet. It felt as though he was floating in a steadily encroaching mist, his limbs made of air and his head lightening, lightening more than it had since the earliest days of Rivendell. His curls tangled in the breeze, and it raised gooseflesh on his weathered skin.
The realisation lured Bilbo with a sudden jolt of clarity from his dreamlike state, and he realised with an acute thud of his heart that he really was floating, high above the ship and watching it start to cut through the water, away from where he was nothing but a breath on the wind.
Bilbo very quickly felt the beginnings of panic, then took the smallest of moments to marvel at the fact he could panic, at the fact he was awake at long last from the sleepiness of great age and an absent mind, alive in a body that felt like his own again.
He hastily glanced downwards, and let himself calm once he realised he’d taken his body with him wherever he seemed to be adrift in the air. There’d been one awful, frightening moment where he’d been sure his body had finally failed him and delivered him to death, right then and there on Elrond’s ship, only moments after setting sail. It would have broken Frodo. It would have —
Bilbo blanched.
Oh, Frodo.
The two figures silhouetted in white turned back to face the greying shoreline, and rows of trees were shrinking into nothing more than inkblots in the distance, but as Bilbo watched them, their faces seemed to lift towards his. No, that wasn’t right; they were facing him, Galadriel and Gandalf both still as carven statues and watching him on the skyline with unmoving eyes. Frodo still stood between them with his cloak wrapped round his slim shoulders, but he was looking away, somewhere off to the side, unaware that Bilbo was leaving him.
A dreadful pang rang suddenly through his chest. The tear-track still glistened on Frodo’s face.
Bilbo looked away.
When he spoke, he wasn’t sure if it was aloud or if the wind was simply carrying his thoughts in its fingers towards the drifting ship.
“Where am I going?” he asked, though his voice made no sound when he spoke, and the gusts were pulling him further and further away. He hadn’t meant to word it quite like that. He’d been intending on asking something more like what on Earth is happening to me! but instead of any breath in his lungs there was only the breeze cradling him in the air.
Gandalf brought the sleeves of his robe together across the hull of the boat and bent his head.
“You know, of course, why we sail for the West, Bilbo?” he asked simply, and Bilbo gave a slow nod.
Then Galadriel raised her head to the heavens, and an indescribable expression broke across her face.
“If your hurts grieve you still and the memory of your burden is heavy, then you may pass into the West, until all your wounds and weariness are healed,” she sang, her eyes glowing like faraway moonlight. She was quoting something, though Bilbo did not know what.
“Yes!” he cried, mad urgency leaking into the wispiness of his non-voice. More and more he was starting to sound and feel like his old self again, prim and persnickety, and the thought brought with it a strange flourish of hope mixed in with growing terror. “Yes, which is why I was told I was to be coming with you! My burden was heavy for sixty years!”
It was becoming an effort to maintain a sense of alarm, however, when he could feel his bones settling back into themselves for the first time in years, and his speech was sounding more and more like what it had been for most of his life instead of the faded rasp it had become.
Gandalf’s smile was ancient and fond when he looked at Bilbo once more.
“And yet,” he said slowly, “I sense that your heart will never truly be at rest so far from all that awakened it in the first place.”
“My heart…” Bilbo muttered absently, and looked around himself; at the silver light on the water, the fog that crept along the edges of the ship, the purple of the mountains stretched outward on either side of the bay. The landscape was unfamiliar to him, and yet somehow an echo of what he already knew. He’d recognised it as soon as they’d stepped out of the cart; his failing mind just hadn’t been able to connect the thought to anything tangible. This was a strange, western mirror of other mountains lying in the East, far away from here. Ones that, even as his thoughts had blurred and his mind decayed, he wouldn’t ever have been able to forget.
It took Bilbo only a short moment to understand what it was Gandalf was telling him.
“My heart?” Disbelief clutched at his throat and dried his mouth with the wind.
Galadriel smiled. “It is not our doing, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire,” she said. Her entire form was lit like an angel in silver and pearl, her face serene. “It seems fate would not take you where you might not find peace. It is carrying you there instead.”
Bilbo bristled at once, and he started up into a great splutter.
“I haven’t even gotten a say in any of this! What if I don’t want to go back there, what if it’s just as miserable and I’ve just been left there with no say of my own in the matter, what if —”
But he faltered, knowing deep in his sorry old heart that even as he protested, there wasn’t an ounce of truth to any of it. He’d wished for this every day for the last eighty years.
“My dear Bilbo,” Gandalf said, and his eyes were alight, peaceful in a way Bilbo realised he had never truly seen in Gandalf until now, not in any of all his long, long years in Middle-Earth. He seemed to look past Bilbo, back toward the shore at the shipwright’s lone tower, his mouth twitching. “You and Frodo were always coming on this journey to bring your hearts peace after the torments they have endured at the hands of Sauron the Enemy. You are the Ringbearers. You have been touched by darkness others can scarcely imagine.”
Bilbo could only speak in a whisper. “And are you sure this is truly where I am meant to go?”
He watched as Gandalf raised his hand and touched his heart in answer, holding his gaze. It was a rare gesture — one from long ago, when the world had been far different. Beside him, Galadriel opened her twilight eyes and did the same.
Bilbo touched his own fingers to his chest.
“I wish you all the luck in the world, Bilbo,” Gandalf called, very far away now — Bilbo could hardly see Frodo anymore. There wasn't enough time to say goodbye. “Let your heart rest. Let the darkness fade once more.”
The feeling of floating on the wind now was less like something pulling him back towards the world he’d left and more like he’d been caught by a gentle breeze. And when Bilbo woke, and smelt the grain and the wildgrass, opening his eyes was like turning the page of a book.
It seemed about mid-morning, to Bilbo’s reckoning, from the way the sunlight was filtering a gentle orange through the window, cracked open slightly so the scents of the garden could float into his bedroom. He stared up at the ceiling, not quite registering the sight, flexing his fingers one by one and trying not to reprimand himself too harshly for being giddy about the feeling of his joints cracking again. It was a long, long time before he felt brave enough to sit up and blink around at the little bedroom in Bag End.
It’d been twenty years since he’d last seen it, and somehow it felt to Bilbo like meeting an old, old friend from an age that had long passed. A patchwork quilt half-thrown across the armchair in the corner, a handkerchief with the initials BB carefully stitched along the edge, several pouches of pipeweed lined up neatly on the bedside table, held in green velvet casing. A watercolour of Tuckborough and its rolling green smials on the wall opposite, the sky a soft blue and the clouds scattered on the canvas like afterthoughts. His beautiful fountain pen and ink-pot resting on the little table against the wall.
The pen had been a gift from his mother to his father when Bilbo was still young, one that she’d gotten on her semi-annual trips to Bree. The make of it had always seemed a little unfamiliar and strange to Bilbo, something so Elven about the glide of it, so unlike the trusty scratchiness of their own writing tools in the Shire. The older and more proprietary he’d become, the more he’d gotten a secret little thrill out of picking it up, like he was breaking some unspoken rule by using something so un-Shirelike in a space so distinctly hobbitish.
The idea was preposterous to think back on now, and Bilbo almost threw the pen right out the window in utter mortification. Oh, go outside your door once in a while, you complete fool! Pens and paintings, indeed! How about you set a foot past the end of your row!
Frankly, the pen was very lucky it had once belonged to Belladonna Took.
Many things were still missing from his bedroom, too, that would find their way to him in the years to come, but Bilbo could still picture each one of them as if it were only yesterday: the stack of letters bound with twine that had always sat in pride of place on the top shelf of his bookcase, the small chest in the corner, the wood old and decrepit but its latches still sturdy. The paper sailboat Frodo had made for him. The scroll of parchment with his own signature scrawled in ink across the bottom, and the exquisite shirt of silver mail that he’d eventually lent to the Mathom-house in Michel Delving, and then again to Frodo.
The notebook bound in red leather.
Bilbo threw the covers back and bustled over to the bookshelf as soon as his eyes caught a slight sliver of red. He took down the book and opened it gently, heart all the way in his throat.
Each and every one of the pages were blank. There was no There and Back Again. No Return of the King. There was nothing in it at all.
Another nasty pinprick of guilt poked at him when Bilbo let his eyes wander up to the calendar he always kept hung on the wall beside his bookcase, and saw very plainly written there: April twenty-sixth of the year 1341 in the Shire-reckoning. There would be no Frodo yet either. Not for twenty-seven more years.
The mists of the Grey Havens swirled through his mind again, the colours of sundown flitting against the water, the three lone figures silhouetted across the backdrop of the horizon. Gandalf’s whispered words reverberated themselves through his head.
And yet I sense that your heart will never truly be at rest so far from all that which awakened it in the first place.
Bilbo remembered very clearly his last morning in Bag End. The sunlight had fallen through the window in just the same way. He’d packed the valuables up, tucked all his papers into his bags, left the envelope with the — with it sealed tightly inside on the mantel for Frodo. He’d tottered down Bagshot Row for the final time underneath the stars, and hadn’t travelled west of the Misty Mountains since, until their very last journey.
To bring my heart peace.
There was only one meaning that could possibly have, and Bilbo already knew very well in his heart what it was. Oh, certainly, he’d been one of the most blessed hobbits in and around all the Shire, all that nasty business with the Enemy and his personal belongings aside. His life had been long, and he’d been exceedingly lucky; he prided himself on it.
It was only that he’d lost those he loved a long time before they should have been taken, and he’d never gotten a chance to know his life with them in it. The skin over the wound had always stayed tender no matter how many years had passed them by.
A horrible lump had started to creep its way up into Bilbo’s throat. He blinked a few times in a vain attempt to fight it back — don’t you dare cry, you silly old thing! — but his eyes were already unseeing, and all that was in his head were echoes from far, far away.
So he spent an embarrassing few minutes with his face in his hands, the tears hot where they dripped through the gaps in his fingers, his shoulders shaking terribly. The choking in his throat had broken free, and Bilbo could barely begin to recognise the sound of his own voice, it was so twisted-up and awful.
He could think of nothing but what it meant for him to be here again, and why, and who it meant he would see, and who he had left behind. He’d left Frodo behind and gone on without him, abandoned him completely and utterly and entirely. And there were only a few scant hours before it all began again.
Bilbo’s adventure had been the pride of his life. It was why he’d always spoken of it with such passion and such care, why he brought up the dragon, and the barrels, and the dear friends he’d made time and time again, never once tiring of the tale in all his years; why he’d been known to all and sundry as Mad Old Baggins.
But to be back here — to be back then —
He hung his head in his hands and stared wide-eyed between his fingers. The thought of anything at all was overwhelming beyond belief.
And what was it the Lady of Lórien had said to him? Until all your wounds and weariness are healed.
He grimaced. There was a strange sort of understanding in that. Bilbo’s hurts had never lay in Middle-Earth because the cause of them had already departed from it, and he would only have carried them along with him all the way to the Undying Lands. He could travel the world a thousand times over and not ease the ache with the distance.
It was that which the Lady Galadriel had been telling him. The West could do no more for his grief than any other place he had tried to travel to, for grief did not let you leave it behind when you walked away from it. And whichever power had whisked him all the way back here had surely known it, too.
Bilbo allowed himself one more dismal little sniffle into his own hands and then pushed himself up abruptly to pace up and down in front of the bedroom window. The tip of his nose and the corners of his eyes were surely still red, but he paid them no mind.
All right, old lad, he thought instead, with a fickle sort of determination. Pull yourself together. There is work to be done.
Clearly, he’d been set a task. Or — not a task, perhaps, but a goal. A chance. For now, Bilbo could do nothing but push all thoughts of why to the back of his mind and keep them for another day.
He looked down at the blank pages of what had once been his most beloved work again, and felt his nose twitch. There really wasn’t a single speck of ink to be found in the entire book.
He flipped a page and peered downward, tilted his head, then took up his father’s pen and meticulously began to scratch out notes in the margins.
It was only a full hour later when he set it down and propped the volume against the table. He couldn’t quite bear to tear the page out just yet, couldn’t bear to damage the book that had once held his life’s work.
Bilbo squinted down at it.
It wasn’t a heavy volume, all things considered. Bringing it along would be manageable. Perhaps he could stand to go without a few of his other items on the trek, anyway; Bilbo had always found, in all the years since that first venture outside his door, that sentiment and meaning far outweighed comfort. He wished he still had his own map up on the wall, so he could tuck it away into the book, too, and carry it with him just in case.
He’d only managed to fill a couple of the Red Book’s pages with writing, but Bilbo scrambled to open it once more and run his trembling fingers over the letters, as if committing them to memory would somehow calm him.
Some had turned out quite skittish and only half-formed, his mind moving too fast for the ink to keep up, and wasn’t that something Bilbo had missed with an almost guilty fierceness!
Faster trail ?? — Can’t skip Sting — but trolls ??? Perhaps eagles food for thought — how to ask Gandalf without seeming suspicious ???
There was also:
Avoid barrels — do Elves have rowboats ??? Something to ask Elrond (or maybe Lindir)
And some were notes, ideas, mantras Bilbo knew he would need in his head when each of the most important moments from their adventure came. He found himself murmuring the words as he scanned each of the lines, desperate to remember, terrified he would leave something vital out.
Must stop Laketown from burning.
Must find the Ring the you-know-what. At all costs. Avoid goblins if possible.
Must not tell anyone anything if you know what’s good for you.
Must deal with the Arkenstone as soon as am able.
That one made him grimace, but there was nothing to be done about it, really, and he knew very well now there were worse things that could happen than the King Under the Mountain alive and hating him.
Right at the very bottom, a line was written in a shakier, sprawling script:
You must keep them alive.
There hadn’t really been a need to write it down in words, because it had been and would be in Bilbo’s thoughts every single day onward, but to leave it be felt in his bones like a betrayal. To write it down was a promise — and, he thought, a secret wish, like a whispered offering to whichever strange higher being had promised him a settled heart, just in case they hadn’t known quite what it was he was searching for.
Bilbo looked over the book for a moment longer, holding his breath, then straightened his linen waistcoat and snapped the cover closed. He checked his pocketwatch, blew a breath out his teeth, then snatched his pipe up from where it was resting on the windowsill and hurried out to the front garden.
He was very nearly late for a meeting with Gandalf.
“Good morning!”
“What do you mean?” said Gandalf the Grey. “Do you wish me a good morning, or do you mean that it is a good morning whether I want it or not? Or, perhaps, that you feel good on this morning? Or that it is simply a morning to be good on?”
Bilbo had to fight not to let the skin at the corners of his eyes crinkle with fondness when he spoke. He’d dearly missed the way the wizard’s hat had always been pulled low over his face. He’d missed those twinkling eyes.
Gandalf's usual smoke-rings were billowing out of the mouth of his pipe and up into the sky as he peered down his nose at Bilbo sitting in front of him. It really was a good morning, Bilbo thought, letting himself muse on the way the water trickled down into the river and lapped at the edges of the rolling hills in the sunshine. He patted down the end of his own pipe with his fingers and screwed up his face in a shrewd expression.
“I’m quite sure you’ve already selected which one it is you think I mean, Gandalf, regardless of what you say to me, and so you may as well tell me what brings you to Hobbiton after so many years away,” Bilbo said. Quite matter-of-factly and to the point, he thought. He had to work hard to make sure none of the amused satisfaction he was feeling showed on his face.
Gandalf, for his part, looked mildly startled, but took Bilbo’s cheek in stride with only a twitch of his beard and his bushy eyebrows.
“I must say, Bilbo Baggins,” he remarked, “I am impressed you remember my name after such a long time, let alone myself at all.”
“Yes — uh, well,” Bilbo said, suddenly flustered, “you were… you were dearly loved by my mother, don’t you know? She used to tell me stories about you when I was young.”
And she had, though Bilbo had not remembered it until well after he’d set off with Gandalf and the dwarves the first time. The way Belladonna Took had spoken with such reverence and affection about the wandering wizard who had walked with her through thickets and green fields and across all the plains of the West, and of the kindly smile in his eyes beneath the grey brim of his hat. It had taken Bilbo a long time to recognise the Grey Pilgrim Gandalf presented himself to be as the wanderer who wove magic through every one of his mother’s stories, and even then, he had only recognised that side of Gandalf once he had come home again.
He knew enough now, however, to recognise the sparkle in the wizard’s eye at the mention of Belladonna, and a surprising warmth blossomed in his chest at the sight.
“This is excellent news to hear!” Gandalf exclaimed. “Perhaps, then, you’ve inherited her penchant for adventures? I am searching for a hobbit to share in one, and I must admit,” and here he paused, raising his extravagantly wiry eyebrows and widening his eyes at Bilbo sitting on his bench, “I rather hoped that it would be you.”
Bilbo was quiet for a moment. He let out his Old Toby in a steady stream and pursed his lips.
“And I assume I’m not going to get any more information out of you about this adventure?” he asked dryly, looking up at the wizard. He couldn’t resist prodding to see if Gandalf would let up about what it was he was keeping secret, because it was quite a lot, and quite a lot of it was incredibly important information.
“Oh, all in good time, I assure you,” Gandalf said cheerfully, adjusting his grip on his staff.
So he was keeping his lips sealed then, Bilbo noted, and not without his fair share of distaste. He wrinkled his nose begrudgingly.
These wizards and Elves and Men. They’re very well lucky us hobbits are so accommodating.
“I see,” Bilbo said. “Well, I shall have to hear what you have to say on the matter further, but for now…” Bilbo’s eyes flitted up to Gandalf’s as he stood to make his way up the little cobbled path, patting down the pockets of his waistcoat. He met Gandalf’s gaze steadily. “I suppose you shouldn’t count me out, just yet.”
Gandalf seemed dreadfully pleased, and he shook his sleeves out merrily. “I will be around for tea this evening then. Look sharp, my dear fellow! A spot of supper, too, if you can spare it,” he said, turning away as he made to depart.
A convenient way to hide your nefarious purposes, you conniving old man, Bilbo thought, striding up his garden path.
He’d almost reached the freshly forest-green door when it occurred to him to ask what should have been quite an important question. Bilbo was a little miffed at himself that he hadn’t thought to ask it the first time Gandalf had shown up at his gate — but then again, he’d been so utterly frazzled by Gandalf’s peculiarity that the idea had completely slipped his mind.
And really, it was terrible manners of him, to go around inviting guests willy-nilly into other people’s homes and expecting Bilbo to be completely and utterly at peace with the situation. He was certainly lucky this time around that Bilbo had his wits about him, and that he already held their guests in the highest honour. If wizards weren’t already renowned for their terrible manners, then they very well should be.
Bilbo turned and scurried back down the steps.
“Gandalf! Are we to have company when you come back for tea?” he pushed, taking care to put emphasis into every word and widening his eyes imploringly. “I’d hate to be unprepared.”
There. See what the wizard would do with that one.
Gandalf stopped at the gate, his hand resting on the well-worn latch. His head turned halfway to the side, and Bilbo watched his mouth pull upward at the edge. The outstretched brim of his hat hid his eyes from view once more.
He turned away, smoke-rings floating into the air after him. And Bilbo wasn’t sure if it was just a trick of the light, or if some of them really had been different colours.
“Company indeed, Master Baggins. Company indeed.”
Bilbo spent almost the entire rest of the day holed up in his kitchen with pots and pans covering every surface he could spare. He’d scoured every corner and square inch of his pantry for food, every nook and cranny in every shelf in Bag End. He’d carefully picked vegetables and herbs from his little garden in the front yard, and even given the Gamgees down in Bagshot Row some coins for a few of their famously marvellous potatoes.
He’d brought out the porcelain crockery tucked away in his mother’s bedroom that was embossed with soft pink-and-blue flowers on the edging, and tidied every knife and fork and napkin that was laid out until all of them were set uniformly and exactly to plan. Every chair that could possibly be found in his house lined the table, and he’d even managed to scrounge up a battered, wayward little stool for himself to sit on once he’d found the set-up one seat short.
It was only well after the sun had tucked itself behind the hills, when he had a moment to stop and breathe, hair a bedraggled mess and droplets of sweat congregating on his brow without any invitation, that Bilbo was forced to face rather head-on what was about to happen very imminently. He’d kept busy all day long to keep any of it from being able to cross his mind, but now he could think of nothing else, and his hands began to shake.
There were only a precious few moments until he would have to open his eyes out of the dream, out of the mellow haze he’d been floating in for longer than he could remember, and he was not sure if he could bear it. He could feel his throat becoming stuck with unspoken words and tears, and worried a little frantically that all he would be able to get out upon the opening of the door would be an awful wailing.
Bilbo had left behind just seven of the Company when he’d made to sail away from Middle-Earth; the others had been lost to either the Mountain or to Moria. But there were thirteen dwarves coming to visit, and it had been eighty long years since he’d seen some of them, and there was no way in any corner of the land or sea that Bilbo was ever going to feel ready deep down in his soul to face the dead.
(For those few precious months with them, he'd felt wide awake for the very first time in his life, after spending the first fifty years of it half-asleep. He’d been able to see the world with open eyes, and became enamoured with what it really was; all the colour he’d been missing.
And then he’d watched them lay the bodies to rest, and it had felt like falling asleep again.)
Some days Bilbo had hated it. Sometimes he’d even hated him. He adored Frodo, and he’d never, ever come close to wishing that the rest of his life had gone any way other than the one it did, and yet he’d never quite been able to wake up again, after that very first time traipsing out his door. Something in him had finally, finally flickered to life out in the wild parts of the world, trudging through mud and mountains and marshes, and only a few months later he had felt it shrivel up and die. He’d gotten so many more years of his life than he should have, and yet all of them had been split between what could be and what might have been.
But Bilbo’d had his time with Frodo. They’d had their days in Bag End, the windows cracked open to let the breeze in, the light glinting off the dark curls on Frodo’s head. They were some of the most treasured moments of his life, and Bilbo knew in his bones that he would never have given Frodo up for anything — not for all the gold in Erebor. Not even if, the heavens help him, he could have somehow kept the piece of his heart alive that he’d instead had to bury with a sword and gemstone cradled against his chest. It was simply a fact of Bilbo Baggins that Frodo meant far too much to him.
But as he walked to the entryway of his home to wait, competing tremors of sick hope and cold dread running all up and down his limbs, Bilbo thought once more of what Gandalf and Galadriel had told him, what Elrond and the other Elves in Rivendell had said.
We sail for peace, and for healing. To give our weary souls rest after the unending pain and hurt they face on the shores of Middle-Earth. You sail with us so in time, you may forget the hold the Ruling Ring has had on you, and the suffering you and yours have seen after being touched by it.
He’d set off with one foot still on the shore, because half of his hurts had not come from the Enemy at all; they’d been buried in the East all those decades before. He just couldn’t quite understand why it was he’d been given a place back here. He could not understand what he’d ever done to warrant the chance to take that hurt away.
Oh, what was he doing? Bilbo wished with everything he had that he could go out and touch his hand to the steady oak tree in his garden, press his forehead to the trunk and breathe in the wood as familiar to him as the sight of the far-off mountains, but it wouldn’t be there — hadn’t even been planted yet. The thought made him feel suddenly, woefully stranded.
It didn’t matter. He would handle himself without it. He was determined to keep his head on straight as persistently and admirably as he could, no matter what, or who, he was soon to come face to face with. Bagginses could stay calm and civil if they so chose, and so Bilbo was going to keep his confusticating emotions in check if it killed him.
Amongst all this bothersome thinking, Bilbo’s ears slowly became attuned to a soft, crunching sort of noise from outside, like stones sliding underneath heavy footfalls. His stomach flipped over, curled up, then sunk into his toes.
There was a faint scuffle, and a grunt, and then a knock at the door.
He cracked the door open and the cool night air rushed in, swirling through the flames in each of the candles on the mantel and raising fresh goosebumps all along Bilbo’s arms.
He had to fight down what would have been a bizarre smile at the feeling of it. He still couldn’t believe how good it was to feel things again. His skin hadn’t fit this well since the last time he’d stepped over this doorway to leave it.
It had only been a decade or two since Bilbo had seen Dwalin, really, but by the time he’d had made his dramatic escape from the Shire and arrived from his journey in Dale, Dwalin had been a much older, much greyer dwarf, and the signs of all the battles he’d seen had started to show.
He cut as intimidating a figure as ever against the calmer twilight of the Shire, his shoulders breaking across the skyline and cloaked in a dark-green dwarven travelling hood. The ink on his bare forearms was a starker black than the last time Bilbo had seen it, the long years not yet wearing away at them, and the parts of his face not hidden in shadow were set in a flat scowl.
Bilbo beat him to it.
“Bilbo Baggins, at your service,” he said, bowing so deeply he couldn’t even see Dwalin’s boots from behind his own hair falling in his face. When he rose again, Dwalin was watching him cautiously, although Bilbo could see in his eyes and the way he held himself that he’d made a reluctantly good first impression, and that it was rather grating on the dwarf’s nerves. Bilbo smiled gently, making sure to hold his gaze.
“Dwalin, son of Fundin, at yours,” Dwalin said roughly, pulling his shoulders back — presumably in a display of intimidation, or some such. Bilbo valiantly stopped himself from rolling his eyes and stepped back from the doorway to gesture towards the warm glow of his kitchen.
“Please will you join me for dinner? I’ve prepared as best I could, and you must have had a long and difficult journey.”
Dwalin just barely inclined his head and stepped through, though Bilbo noted that he took care to wipe his boots on the doormat, making him hum happily.
Balin had been next, and it seemed like no time at all before the second knock at the door came; certainly not enough time for Bilbo to have even slightly prepared himself for it.
He could not think of many sights more familiar to him than the one of Balin standing in front of his green door, hands clasped behind his back and hood lowered, and he almost could not keep the joy off his face. Bilbo bowed again, deeply, and with a wobbly smile, and Balin bowed in return, and it was a struggle to keep his distance, to not greet him as an old and cherished friend would. Balin had crossed this very threshold several times over the years before his journey to Khazad-dûm, always for tea and always right on time, his braids done especially neat for the occasion. The sight of the dwarf standing in his doorway, and his white hair and long jolly beard, was very dear to Bilbo, and in those last few decades he had missed it terribly.
He led his old friend through the entrance and along to where Dwalin was standing at the end of the table, and together they seemed to take in the spread with a sort of shock.
Bilbo had worked quite hard on it, and he was pleased that he’d able to put together something that they seemed so astounded by. He’d never gotten the chance to properly cook them a decadent hobbit feast before, and on his own grounds and all, with no horrible element of surprise this time to stump him. He was a little more than eager to impress.
He'd almost made it to the doorknob after the third knock came when he remembered with a jolt who exactly it was that had come next, and how he’d last seen them. His heart stuttered in his chest, and he came to a stop.
Twin smiles that now lived on only in dreams and stories; one golden-haired, one dark. The knowledge that dwarvish lifespans were more than twice that of hobbits, and he was now far older than either of them had ever gotten the chance to be.
They knocked again, and Bilbo shook himself and strode over, throwing the door open before he could lose his nerve. The dead were not going to be kept waiting for something so fragile as his memories.
The chill rushed in and bit at him from the inside out.
“Welcome, my dear dwarves.”
He watched them bow in unison. Oh, they both looked so alive.
Bilbo was quickly realising that he’d forgotten the way Kili’s hair fell messily across his forehead, and the way the ends of Fili’s moustache-braids shook when he smiled. Kinetic energy bounced off them in waves. Bilbo had lived a very, very long time, and hadn’t ever seen many others like them, and he’d never known whether that fact had broken his heart even further or not. Two brothers with so much to give the world and so much to take from it, only to be taken themselves before they’d gotten the chance at all.
His fist clenched involuntarily at his side, and Bilbo stuffed it hastily in his trouser-pocket. He hadn’t even realised how glassy his eyes had become until two faces leant in to peer at him in concern.
“Are you all right, Master Baggins?” Kili said.
“Oh, dear!” Bilbo exclaimed, floundering, his cheeks heating with embarrassment. “Yes, I’m quite all right. it’s just, well — springtime allergies, you know. Bag End can be quite dusty when you live here all alone!”
Their eyebrows furrowed at the same time, and Bilbo felt the split down his middle even more.
“How on earth can you be allergic to your own house?” Kili asked incredulously, his eyes bright. Bilbo laughed a little wetly and quickly pressed the heel of one hand to his eye.
“Oh, well,” he said, sniffing once more before he backed away from the door to let the two dwarves past and casting around madly for an excuse, “my, uh — father built this hobbit-hole for my mother. I couldn’t leave it for anywhere else in the Shire. I don’t mind putting up with a bit of sneezing every now and then.”
That was going to be a lie he told now, then. Bilbo began to wonder with an increasing amount of panic if he was in much too over his head. He’d already burst into tears and worked himself up into a complete bluster, and it had only been eleven minutes.
Keep your head on your shoulders, old fellow. You’ve encountered things more difficult than this!
Kili’s beaming face knocked Bilbo’s resolve backward even further. “Well, that’s a relief!”
When they were gone, instead of shuffling back into the kitchen to hover around the quartet, Bilbo made sure to stay by the door with it propped wide open, so when the rest of them arrived in a bumbling line up his cobblestone steps, he only had to usher them in with a wry smile and an absolutely withering glance at Gandalf.
Watching them walk past him one by one — Bifur, Bofur, Oin, Gloin, Dori, Nori, Ori, and Bombur — was like watching a painting as it floated backwards through time, the way their familiar faces tugged at his heartstrings, how young they all were. He’d seen most of them on his last visit to Dale, when all of them had been giddy and greying in the light of the prospering Lonely Mountain, and Gloin he’d of course seen in those last days at Rivendell when they’d waved their boys off and everything had started slowly to blend together.
It was a bitter sort of warmth, seeing them the way they had been back then, or now, Bilbo supposed. Back again. All of them together, as they should always have been, and younger, and so very jovial, and eager for the chance to win back what had once been theirs. And yet, Bilbo couldn’t wander into the fray the way he used to, to ask Gloin about how his lad Gimli was faring in Ered Luin, or to mention to Bombur that he had a few of his grandmother’s best recipes for mushrooms tucked away in one of the cupboards to loan him. He could not even trust that Balin or Bofur knew where the plates and spoons were, because they did not know this house yet, and he was still a stranger to them.
He simply stood a little ways away from the table and watched them dig in, politely answering scattered questions about whether he had this or that kind of ale and if he might possibly be able to spare another bowl.
There were more than a couple of occasions where he even found himself walking into bits of furniture he’d moved later on, or reaching for something and finding that nothing was there. Whenever this happened, the dwarves would give him strange, assessing looks, and Bilbo’s ears would suddenly feel like they were being boiled in a hot kettle. He was entirely sure that all the blood thundering into them was going to make them fall off, and then he’d faint from blood loss and the Company would leave him lying there on his kitchen floor like a complete twit and he wouldn’t make it onto the quest at all.
Bilbo was perhaps not managing as well as he had initially hoped.
He cursed under his breath after ramming his toe for the third time into the leg of a table he’d thrown out years later, and ducked his head so they wouldn’t see his ears neatly bypassing red and turning an atrocious shade of purple.
“Won’t you come and have a seat, Bilbo?” Gandalf called, watching him with fonder eyes than Bilbo thought he probably deserved just yet. Bilbo flashed a grimace at him.
“That’s all right, Gandalf. I’ll sit down to dinner once everyone has arrived. If I am not mistaken, we’re still waiting on one more, aren’t we?”
His heart was thumping like a drum, and he'd tucked both of his hands deep in his trouser-pockets to hide their incessant shaking. He did not miss the curious expression that washed over Gandalf’s face.
The silence stretched out. His legs felt like they were made of twigs. His mind was filling with sand.
Quite like clockwork, there was one final knock at the door.
Bilbo had always heard that when you reunited with a loved one after a long time apart, you saw details you’d forgotten, and noticed things you hadn’t before. He’d wondered which parts of his mother’s face he would have to relearn, when the time came, and whether it was at all possible that he could ever have forgotten the image of the statue carved into the mountainside.
The person looking back at him in the doorway was like out of a perfectly preserved memory. His silver-linked shirt, stitched together with threads of dark blue, strips of animal hide draped for warmth across the shoulders. The scruff of his beard, short and blunt against his face.
Oh, his face. How could anyone ever begin to describe the way it felt to look upon a face long lost to you?
One you hadn’t seen in nearly a century and yet you knew you saw every time you woke from sleep. One you’d last seen serene and still, peaceful the way it never quite had been in life, encased within a pool of dark hair fanning outwards like the deep rays of the moon.
Sometimes, in Bilbo’s memories of Ravenhill, where everything had gone so terribly, terribly wrong, the snow was falling down, and sometimes the wind would be whipping at the two of them, catching at the tangles of Thorin’s dampening hair and not letting him lie still.
He’d been talking, rasping in the way of someone whose lungs were starting to fail them, and whose heart had finally decided that it was time to stop trying, and all Bilbo had thought, over and over and over, had been Just keep talking.
Just keep talking, Thorin Oakenshield.
Don’t you dare look away from me. Don’t you dare go.
Because for those awful last few moments, laid out on the ice with the frost biting at their skin, Bilbo had known with absolute certainty that Thorin was not going to live. And so he’d watched him talk, and breathe, and watched him choke out an apology already forgiven, and all the while he’d been thinking about how quickly the moment was already approaching when he was going to have to let go. And he’d had no time to gather any of his thoughts before that moment had come, and he’d watched the fire that was in those eyes shutter out at last. And then Bilbo had sat there and cried for a very, very, very long time.
The funerals had been worse. They’d still been in those early days, when it had felt like his heart was crushing down into his chest, when the tips of his fingers were numb and everyone he spoke to had to repeat all their words because he had not been able to hear them.
He had watched a person pulled down into death he’d only just realised he’d needed in life. The colour had just melted away, the way raindrops slipped down the glass of your windows on days when the clouds were drenched and dark. The heavens had opened above him and then closed right back up. He'd drowned in how heavy the silence had been.
Bilbo hadn’t been able to bear touching Thorin that last time. He hadn’t been able to bear the thought that his skin wouldn’t be warm under his fingers when Thorin had only ever burned with life. His hands were almost aching now with the effort not to reach out, not to run his knuckles along one of his cheekbones, soft as a butterfly’s wing. He could almost physically feel it when he had to bottle it all up and hide it away, to pretend like he didn't know him.
Bilbo lifted his chin, then swallowed gently and let his head fall ever so slightly to the side. He took care to blink slowly and take careful breaths. He let his eyes travel along all of Thorin’s sharpened edges, up the line of his throat and along the base of his chin and clenching jaw, over the ridge of his nose and up to familiar eyes; blue, blue, blue.
It's been so very long, my dear.
It was so good to see those eyes again.
“You’re a tad late for supper, Master Oakenshield,” Bilbo said calmly, eyes settling firmly on the clasp of Thorin’s furs resting against his clavicle. “I was beginning to worry you hadn’t made it at all.”
Then he turned gently aside, the ageing floorboards creaking under his feet as he walked back into his home and away from Thorin Oakenshield.
It took Gandalf quite a long time to notice that Bilbo was not sitting with the rest of them at the table, but was propped up on his little stool in the corner, slurping up soup with a wooden ladle and watching them over the rim of his bowl with his eyes twinkling. It took much longer than that for any of the dwarves to even notice he was there in the first place, and as soon as they had, they’d started up that dreadful song about knives and forks and whatever else, the sound ringing in Bilbo’s ears. He made sure to keep his face neutral and kept his nose firmly in his dinner so he wouldn't be tempted to grin.
It was more difficult than he’d expected to watch the way they all moved with each other, the yellow light flickering overhead as bits of food soared this way and that and foaming mugs of beer slopped unceremoniously onto his beautiful redwood table, all their raucous and rowdy noise bouncing off the walls of the dining room and down all of his winding hallways. It was like he was watching a frame out of time, and the thought made him worry with a sudden sharpness that it wasn't real.
Maybe his mind had finally truly cracked. It would certainly be less surreal than what was happening in front of him.
Nevertheless, the sight made Bilbo glad that somewhere far away, in another lifetime, or perhaps still to come in this one, his old hallways would be echoing with the feet of little Gamgees for years and years to come. They would not be allowed to grow old in despair and decay as he had begun to. He spared another gentle thought for his Frodo, and for Frodo’s Sam, and wondered how both of them were faring, wherever they were in the world.
(He wondered if Frodo had made it to Valinor. Perhaps the journey was only ever taken by Elves because it took hundreds and hundreds of years.
Perhaps Bilbo was still on the way there and all of this was a very vivid and torturous daydream somebody had put together for him.
Perhaps Valinor didn’t even exist.)
So anxious was Bilbo over all of this wondering that he missed the booming call of his name from Gandalf until he shook himself awake and found fourteen sets of eyes suddenly fixated on him, some in piqued interest and some with very noticeable disdain.
“Sorry, Gandalf. Lost in my own thoughts like a silly old hobbit!” he joked, taking no notice of the bemused smile Gandalf sent his way and rising from where his legs were crossed on the stool with a lit lantern in hand. Gandalf spread a worn map across the head of the table as he approached.
Bilbo knew this map. He’d had a copy hung on the wall behind the desk in his study for years and years. He could have sketched it with his eyes closed.
He watched all thirteen dwarves lean in a little closer as Gandalf began.
“This, of course, is a map of the lands around the Lonely Mountain and the city of Erebor. It also,” Gandalf said, deftly unfolding a silver key from between his fingers and peering around at his rapt audience, “gives us the location of the secret door, which is of dwarven make, and thus even now remains invisible to the eye.”
Bilbo couldn’t quite bring himself to watch Thorin when his eyes landed heavily on the key. He could not quite bring himself to look Thorin’s way at all. He watched Gandalf watch him instead.
“How did you come by this?”
Thorin Oakenshield’s spoken voice was quiet, despite the deep rumbling cadence it had always had, and his words came out slowly, as if all the world hung in the balance when he spoke. It was the sort of voice you could feel brushing against your skin, low and woody and lingering.
“It was given to me by your father,” Gandalf said, returning Thorin’s gaze. Bilbo watched the key change hands from wizard to dwarf, still unable to watch the rawness that broke over Thorin’s expression, the reminder of his father’s peril and the worry of not knowing if he was lost to him forever.
“Now,” Gandalf continued, “having a way in, you see, whilst giving you an advantage, does not by any means guarantee your success. For you to re-enter and retake the Lonely Mountain will require courage, and trust, and stealth, and strength, and most importantly, when you make it to the hidden door, it will require one of you to go first."
It was here that his gaze meandered over to Bilbo standing next to him at the table, the stillness of the room and of the thirteen dwarves palpable all around them.
“In other words, a burglar.”
“Indeed,” said Thorin, his top lip curling in a show of contempt, but contempt that, this time, Bilbo was prepared for. “An excellent one.” He turned to the side and fixed Bilbo darkly with something that wasn’t quite a glare, but was clearly meant to assess him, even to unnerve him. Bilbo watched the vague vicinity Thorin was sitting in right back, calm and unflinching.
“I assume you no doubt have experience in burglary, Master Baggins?” Thorin asked. His voice was gravelly, still underused, and it pressed impossibly thick against Bilbo on all sides.
“Oh, I’ve stolen here and there in my time,” Bilbo said very deliberately to Bofur’s hat and not to Thorin. There being, of course, from under the nose of the very same dragon. “Enough to know I’m most certainly up to the job.”
There was a chorus of scoffs and disbelieving titters from the table. Bilbo closed his eyes and smiled softly to himself.
“You may all laugh, but you might well be surprised by what I have to offer and how helpful my experience may come to be, once we reach the Lonely Mountain.”
“And what is it you do have to offer?” Thorin continued in the same deep voice that had appeared in every one of Bilbo’s dreams and every one of his nightmares. Bilbo’s brows twitched together.
“Light feet. A quick mind. A fair amount of luck. And I know I do not look it, but I can manage well enough on my own in a fight.”
“Luck, you said?” someone called — it might have been Dori, or possibly Oin.
Bilbo slowly opened his eyes, the smile on his face growing. He’d stumped them quite a bit, he guessed. Either that or they thought he was completely batty, but he was quite used to that.
“Luck indeed,” he said wryly. “I’ve been told by quite a few folks that I seem to be rather lucky. You might just see, if the time ever comes.”
He probably wasn’t doing himself any favours, being so cryptic, but he could not even bring himself to mind. He’d missed his friends far too much not to have his fun toying with them a little bit.
“Now, I mean no disrespect, laddie,” Balin said, not unkindly, and Bilbo appreciated that he was at least being polite about it, “but are you sure a gentlehobbit like yourself will be able to keep up where we’re going? Simple luck is not very much to go on.”
“Aye,” piped up Gloin from further down the table, and distinctly less kindly, “he looks more like a grocer than a burglar.”
Even knowing this would happen, Bilbo bristled - after all, he actually had something to say for himself this time, and clearly they would still not hear a bit of it, stubborn-minded as they were - but he was saved, thankfully, by Gandalf coming to his defence, a wildness in his eyes as he rose suddenly in his chair and gripped the end of his staff.
“If I say Bilbo Baggins is a burglar, then a burglar he is!” he bellowed, looming over them all, the candles snuffing out one by one as he drew the shadows closer, and really, if Bilbo hadn’t known him as well as he did, he would have been frightened out of his wits. “He is the fourteenth member of this company that I have chosen, and that ought to be enough for all of you. He is the only person I believe is right for the job. If not him, Thorin Oakenshield, then you shall have no one at all.”
The silence afterwards prickled at his skin, and Bilbo felt a little guilty, even if he hadn't done anything.
“It’s fine if you don’t trust me just yet,” he said to them quietly. “Really. I would not ask you to when we do not know one another, and you have no reason to believe that I am anything more than what I seem, but I will prove my worth to you if and when I can, and I only ask that you do not judge me too unkindly before then.”
He knew they had good reason to be wary and mistrusting of outsiders. They’d suffered greatly in the wandering years, and in settling amongst the Blue Mountains when it was so far from every other home they had lost. They were overlooked, ostracised, and underestimated by every other race in Middle-Earth.
But Bilbo also knew that, as he was here because they brought him peace, he would in time be able to bring it to them, too.
“Very well,” Thorin said, scowling again, watching Gandalf with a flicker of tension visible in his shoulders. “We will have Master Baggins as our burglar. I assume he has a clear idea of how he plans to go about his job?” His eyes turned in the direction of Bilbo, and Bilbo’s dropped at once to the table.
“I hardly think any of us will be able to form detailed plans until we’ve actually seen the place, surely?” he shot back, and Thorin at least had the grace to look somewhat humbled, though Bilbo could tell that his guard was up in the coolness of his face. No matter. He’d fully resolved to crack that shell, as soon as he got the chance.
“A plan will come when we are in need of one, I should think. And you will all see your Mountain and your city again, I am sure of it.”
The hush that swept around the room at that tugged at the threads of nostalgia that had laid themselves in Bilbo’s heart, and sure enough, it was not much later when he heard the stirrings of slow, mournful song in front of the crackling fireplace, and he could not help but think.
Bilbo’s last few years had seen a Dale that was colourful and musical and thriving, and an Erebor that was strong and sturdy and had stoutly withstood the onslaught of the Enemy in the face of gravest danger.
It would stand again. He was sure of it. He knew, somehow, that he was not quite here to ensure the success of their quest when they’d already done it once themselves.
No, Bilbo had his own musings about the reason he was truly back here, even if he didn’t understand at all why he of all people had been given such a chance, and he did not think it was only for himself. He could bring life back to the Mountain that had never gotten to see it reborn, give the dwarves back their leader and their young ones, and heal every one of their hearts as well as his own. He was here, he suspected, to save the only love he had ever known; to deliver to him at last the title of King Under the Mountain.
Dawn broke with the quiet sounds of sleep and bodies waking, and it was still half-dark with the blue of morning when thirteen dwarves began to wearily trundle into the little kitchen in Bag End, only to come quite to a stop at the sight of the spread laid out before them.
There were apple and cherry and raspberry tarts laden down with fresh cream and butter and bright red fruit. There were sausages and ham and scones and toast with bumblebee honey and sun-yellow egg yolks and poppyseed cakes and orange slices and mint leaves. There were jugs of elderflower water and loose-leaf lemon tea. And in the middle of it all, amongst the mismatched chairs and his curls being quite crushed against the gingham tablecloth, lay Bilbo, the tips of his fingers dark with juice and a small pile of mulberries lying next to him on the table where they’d made it only halfway to a plate.
Everyone was quiet for a long time. Then, “Did he even sleep?” asked Gloin, the utter shock they were no doubt all feeling bleeding into his voice.
“He did,” said Gandalf, who had a biscuit in his mouth and was sitting quite unannounced in the corner of the room with his cloak bundled up about him, watching Bilbo Baggins with a rather intrigued look on his face. “He went to sleep a little later than the rest of you, and woke in the very smallest hours of the night to bustle around some more, and then slept again, and then woke to add the finishing touches and quite fell asleep in the middle of doing so.”
Gandalf watched on with the rest of them as Bilbo seemed to stir for a second, scrunching up his nose, and then relaxed back into sleep. He turned to peer at all of them curiously.
“I have no idea how he knew them, but he insisted that he was going to make all of your favourites.”
“He will be too weary for the day’s journey,” Thorin said gruffly, a deep scowl staining his face. He was glaring around at all the food as though it was offending him.
Gandalf sat up straighter in his chair and fixed an assessing eye on the dwarf. “He will be atop a pony, Thorin. He can doze as he needs to. And I must say, all of you are now acting like most ungrateful guests, after what he has prepared for you.”
And with that, the dwarves looked around abashedly at each other, and then pulled out their chairs and tucked in.
Quite some time passed before the hobbit began to wake to an insistent prodding, and he opened his eyes slowly to the sight of Ori peering at him in hesitation with one finger outstretched towards his ribcage. He looked around, bleary eyes adjusting to the morning clutter and still heavy with sleep, and seemed to realise after a moment that most of the breakfast plates and bowls had been cleared away, and that nothing much was left on the table except for scattered crumbs and empty pots of marmalade. He flushed bright pink and leapt to his feet.
“Oh, hell, I’ve been such a terrible host, falling asleep on all of you like this! Are we leaving soon? What’s the time? Did you all eat enough for breakfast? I bought the sausages especially.” His hair was sticking up in all sorts of directions, and he kept patting it down and running his fingers through it, like he was worried about being less than presentable in front of them.
Really, it was exceedingly strange.
Several heads turned towards their leader, but Thorin Oakenshield did not speak, so it was Gandalf who replied, “Indeed, Bilbo, we were planning to leave in just a few minutes.” The wizard then acknowledged Thorin with a shrewd look, clutching at his staff with his shoulders bent against the hobbit-sized roof, but the dwarf merely looked back at him with the same air of stoicism.
“Give me just a moment to finish my packing, and I will be on my way,” Bilbo said.
When Master Baggins walked back into the room with a pack strapped to his back and a travelling coat on his shoulders, a few of the other dwarves glanced down at his bare feet for a moment, frown, and then shrug their shoulders and turn away. Fili and Kili, however, did not seem to have acquired this same level of subtlety.
“Will you really go without boots the whole journey, Mr Baggins?” Kili asked, Fili peering down alongside him.
The hobbit wrinkled his nose at the question. He seemed to do that a lot, though this time, his lips were quirked at the corners.
“My dear boys, have you ever heard of a hobbit wearing shoes? I’d rather my feet be cut up on mountain rocks and fall clean off than have to step foot anywhere near a pair of boots. Shoes, indeed!” he chuckled.
“To be honest with you,” Fili said diplomatically as they made their way out the door and down Bagshot Row, “many of us have hardly heard of hobbits at all.”
But at that, Bilbo Baggins only chuckled again.
They strolled for a little while down the winding Shire paths, shouldering their packs and grumbling and kicking at each others’ heels when one of them walked too slowly. Many of them thought the hobbit should have been showing them where they were supposed to be going, but instead he was trotting along at the very back of the pack with a pensive sort of look on his face, and this rather perturbed them. It did not bode well for the rest of their journey if he was going to refuse even to guide them in his home country.
Before long, they’d reached an outcrop of trees near Frogmorton, where a beautiful dozen-and-then-some of ponies were roped in a little line and waiting patiently for them.
The wizard Gandalf strode forward and began murmuring to each of the ponies, running a wrinkled hand along each of their hides. He turned back to them once and inclined his head to the rest of the ponies with a single raised eyebrow.
“Don’t dally just because they are not a mode of transportation you frequent, Master Dwarves. This should allow us to make up some ground nicely. And all perfectly sized!”
The Company saddled up slowly, strapping bags and satchels and bedrolls to the sides of their ponies with stirrups and bits of rope. Some of them were tossing each other bits of food to gnaw on before they set off properly. Gandalf craned his neck over the many dwarf heads to keep an assessing eye on the hobbit down at the end of the line, who was stroking the nose of his pony affectionately.
Bilbo Baggins must have known Gandalf exceptionally well, because he sensed the wizard’s gaze at once and turned his head to look. Gandalf smiled at him.
“My dear fellow, you've run some mulberry juice through your hair,” he commented.
The hobbit seemed to startle at this, lifting his hands to the curls bouncing in front of his eyes and touching them lightly, and then realising belatedly that his fingers were still stained richly purple-pink. A real smile broke across his face, then, and it quite changed his whole demeanour.
Strange, on such a small, round face, just starting to be lined at the corners. He seemed to almost light from within.
They were on their way.
Bilbo had mulberry juice in his hair like a clothead, and he could not look at Thorin Oakenshield properly without the breath falling right out of his chest, but he'd been paired with Myrtle again, and he’d remembered a handkerchief this time, so turnabout was fair play, if he said so himself!
If all went well, Bilbo would only ever return to Bag End once more after they took the Mountain. The thought meant nothing to him, now. He’d cut his ties here long ago, and it was only the lingering picture of dark curly hair and youthful wide eyes that made him pause, and turn back to look one last time.
He smiled tightly. He was going where Frodo could not follow, and where Bilbo would never have asked him to even if it was possible. It wasn’t quite fair that the two people who meant the most to him could not exist at the same time, in the same life.
Maybe that was why he was here again. Maybe it could only be one or the other, and he had spent a lifetime yearning so profoundly for the other that he’d somehow caught the attention of powers higher than he.
It was a waste of effort, and magic, in Bilbo’s opinion. There were others who deserved it far more than he did; he could have rattled off a long list of them. There was nothing he could remember doing in his life that had ever warranted a gift like this one, and Bilbo was very conscious of the fact he did not know when or where he would find the catch.
But still. No matter. Onward he would go.
Notes:
obviously there are not many bagginshield interactions happening yet, mostly because bilbo is clearly still in a bit of a state and thorin still thinks he’s the dirt on his boots, but please bear with! once we get further along in the journey the bilbo/thorin interactions will dramatically increase in both quantity and romantic undertone <3
i have a twitter if you would like to find me anywhere (please be warned it’s a bit all over the place because i have lots of interests bouncing around in a very small brain)
also thank you to my ride or die moonyism for beta-ing for me!
aiming to have the second chapter up as soon as i can!
Chapter 2: strange
Notes:
thank you to moonyism for betaing again i love you <3
also: the meanings of any and all flowers mentioned in the chapter will be in the end notes!
(title for this chapter is the song "strange" by celeste (i highly recommend))
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Bilbo always forgot, until he tried to leave it, how very big the Shire was, and how far its borders stretched.
He’d remembered that very first May on the road, the sunlight glinting off the green leaves in the canopies above them and the weather fine and fresh. But after a good while of riding through lazing fields and reed-riddled creeks, he began to tire of it, wanting more and more just to be east already. The four Farthings seemed to stretch on and on and on, blanketing the land further and further and making Bilbo feel as though his ears and eyes were still smothered, like he was being cushioned before the great wide world suddenly broke open all around him.
He was very nearly sick of it, to tell the truth. He’d left the Shire once, forever, and he was eager to make his way beyond its edges again. He knew now that he had been made for lands with more to see. Lands whose peaks rose higher, and whose grasses grew as tall as he himself stood, and whose trees were both more lovely and more menacing.
None of the dwarves had paid very much attention to him, yet. But Bilbo still rode on, content in watching the way they bounced off each other, and the way they would rib at each other loudly. He could see it, this time; how they showed their affection in the little things. How they would form rank around Fili, Kili and Ori almost without speaking, always to protect and provide as best as they could. How they would share out meals, and each one of them would wait to eat until everyone else had gotten their bowls, and how they would gather their blankets together and decide who should get which depending on the weather that particular day.
At first Bilbo’d thought it was a rather hobbitish way of doing things, the share and care and community of it. Then he’d had the belated realisation that maybe it was the dwarvish way after all, and hobbits and dwarves were more similar than anyone had ever taught either of them.
For the most part, he would ride near the rear of the Company, and sometimes Gandalf would join him, though sometimes he would not. Bilbo was content not to rush his dwarves for their friendship, and knew that in time, he would gain it from all of them.
He had a sneaking suspicion they were still puzzling out what to do with him, and that none of them had quite made up their minds about him yet. Bilbo had an easy familiarity that probably seemed quite strange to dwarves, who often had no other allies to be found in the world, and he knew that even for a hobbit, he was really quite peculiar.
Thorin, of course, had already made his own judgements about Bilbo — but that was to be expected, and Bilbo spent much of his time on this second go-around having to conceal a smile rather than spending day after day wondering why on all of the Earth he’d set foot outside his doorstep in the first place.
Bilbo knew more of the things that made up Thorin Oakenshield, now. He knew that if he unfolded Thorin, he would find a steadily-beating heart covered in scars and hurt and mourning, for his people and his city, and for his own mistakes.
(It didn’t mean that Thorin wasn’t behaving as much like an absolute donkey’s behind as ever, but someone Bilbo didn’t find that he cared quite as much.)
In fact, most of the time, Bilbo simply lay back atop Myrtle with his face to the sky and let the rhythmic fall of her hooves lull him into a doze. He was small and stable enough that he could manage without any fear of falling off — even if it seemed to utterly perplex the dwarves.
He had the strangest sort of feeling somehow that Myrtle knew him, or that he at least smelled familiar to her. She had been nothing but gentle with him since their first day setting out, when he’d scratched at her nose, and so well did she know how to carry him where he needed to go that it made Bilbo wonder quite a lot.
“Master Baggins?” Kili called one day; the sort of day where even if you had your eyes closed, you could see the brightness of the sky through the thin film of your eyelids. The utter gloriousness of the weather was helping to calm Bilbo’s erratic nerves, which had been flitting ceaselessly between worrying that he would blurt something out in a panic and make himself completely untrustworthy, or worrying that the nerves were because he was beginning to have visions of dwarves in his old age and this was in fact a very, very elaborate nervous breakdown.
(These kinds of days had been Frodo’s favourite. Their shared birthday was in autumn, but Frodo had always been a child of summer.)
Bilbo cracked one of his eyes open and looked tentatively up at Kili.
“Hm?”
“What are you doing?”
He supposed Kili was referring to the laying-down-atop-a-moving-steed business, and looked back up at the sky, the clouds suspended like wisps in its fingers. They looked like the plant they called Old Man’s Beard, back in the Shire. Like vines you could have stuck knitting needles into.
“I am watching the clouds chase us,” Bilbo said matter-of-factly.
Kili looked upwards in alarm, but the clouds only drifted on in their lazy way, and after a moment he sent a scrunched-up frown down at Bilbo. Bilbo chuckled.
“Aren’t you worried you’re going to fall off your pony?” Kili asked hesitantly. He seemed to not know what to do with Bilbo at all. It was a feeling Bilbo had become incredibly used to.
“Myrtle would never drop me, would you, girl?” Bilbo sang, rubbing at her chestnut coat with one hand and pulling himself upright so he could lean forward and slip an apple between her teeth. She whinnied, and Bilbo smiled in satisfaction, looking back at Kili. “She’s clever. She knows the way. Besides,” he pointed out, “all she needs to do is follow you lot.”
Kili seemed to be fighting back a bemused smile, and Bilbo could see his confusion at the fact washing over his face.
“Master Baggins, why did you decide to come on this journey with us?”
Bilbo tilted his head a little to the side and brushed his fingers through Myrtle’s mane.
“Well, someone’s got to know what they’re doing, don’t they?” He turned to the dwarf and winked, watching that cheeky grin he’d known so well finally creep onto Kili’s face.
“Would you like an apple for Daisy?” Bilbo asked. Kili held up one hand and caught the apple Bilbo tossed, slipped it between Daisy’s teeth, and then lay down atop her with his hands contently clasped across his chest.
Bilbo smiled.
They stopped often along the Great East Road to set up camp, most times not very far from the side of the road as the woods were less dense there, and the stray branches that littered the ground made for excellent firewood.
Thorin hadn't paid any of the dwarves much attention when they'd started being open to talking with Bilbo a little more, but somehow, Bilbo could tell he was still listening. He seemed alert to everything. It didn’t take Bilbo very long now to realise he was watching the wilderness around them for signs of trouble.
He’d watch the shoulders tense, the fingers flex, and was almost tempted to raise a brow at the sight. Easy, love. They were in no danger, and Thorin was wearing himself out, in Bilbo’s entirely objective opinion.
(But if there was anything at all they’d ever shared, it was stubbornness enough between them to break mountains.)
At the moment, Bilbo had his back propped against a tree, and the firelight was flickering darkly across his face in a deep burnt-butter orange. He was watching Nori tell a story, his arms held wide as he spoke, looking around seriously at them all as he imparted his oh-so-enlightening wisdom. Gloin was stretching his mouth wide in an almighty yawn, and Oin in turn was smacking his lips and blinking tiredly. A few of the others were still slurping down Bombur’s stew.
Nori finished his tale with a blunt flourish and Bilbo opened his eyes where he’d started to close them, noticing the settling silence a moment after it fell.
“You got any tales of hobbit-folk to share, then, Master Baggins, or are they all about gardening?” Bofur joked over the pipe between his teeth, winking at him good-naturedly. The laughter that echoed out at that rolled around the trunks of all the nearby trees, and Bilbo lowered his head a little, smiling in graceful defeat.
“Oh, I’m sure none of the tales in Hobbiton are of any interest to you, such mighty dwarves as you all are,” he said, pointedly and shamelessly, snorting a little as a spoon or two went flying across the campsite to even more shouts, “but I’ll try my hand at telling a story all the same. I’m rather good at it.”
He waited till something of a hush had fallen over the camp, and cleared his throat. He wouldn’t really be making the tale up, and he felt a smidge guilty about telling them so, but the need to impress them all won out, as it always had and likely always would. He glanced worriedly over at Gandalf, knowing he was treading in dangerous waters with the wizard around to listen in, but thankfully he already seemed to be asleep, hat dropped low over his face and his legs stretched out along a bedroll.
“Once,” Bilbo began softly, “when the days that covered the Earth were blacker, and the lands were falling into ruin, and each and every being lived in fear of what was ever creeping nearer, there lived three of the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth.”
He looked around the clearing. The mood had died down a little, perhaps from all the talk of darkness, but Bilbo pushed on, feeling the spark inside him coming slowly to life.
He had a proper story to tell, after all, and he’d always liked to deliver to an audience.
“But these three were not just any regular folk you would find a day’s walk from you. They came from far afield, each from different corners of the world, and they had met only by very slim chance; the chance to overthrow the growing terror once and for all. There was a dwarf, of red beard and rough skin, whose axe swung like the legends of old when he wielded it with a mighty roar. There was an Elf,” and here he watched the Company all groan and protest and roll their eyes, “and his bow was long and woven with fine silver, and he was graceful and nimble and true. And there was a Man, with dark hair and bright eyes, and he came from the High Kings of ancient times, and his greatness would sing through his sword.
“Now, these peculiar three had been on a long and perilous journey, through the deep caverns of the world, and along jagged places of rock and ruin, and down into the flowing waters of lands that lie far south of here. It had taken them an age, but all that they had seen and done together had forged an unlikely friendship, and it was indeed the strongest that the world would ever see. Yes,” Bilbo said, pausing the story again to watch the faces of the dwarves closest to him in amusement, “even the dwarf and the Elf, though I know you’ll object to it.” Kili looked particularly betrayed by the story, and Dwalin and Gloin seemed to be glaring at him outright for even daring to suggest it.
Oh, all in good time, my dear Gloin. Be patient.
Bilbo huffed dramatically, though of course he was not actually angered: appearances had to be kept up, and such. “If it’s really so displeasing to you all that a made-up dwarf and a made-up Elf are partners in battle, I should end the story right here and now, and then none of you will find out what happens to them!” The looks being sent his way became suddenly bashful.
“Aye, it’s just a story,” said Balin lightly, his expression strained, but urging him on. “Go on, laddie.”
Bilbo cleared his throat importantly and continued.
“Well, these three friends and warriors had found themselves in the lands beyond the Misty Mountains, and they were carrying out a rescue mission, for some of their allies had been taken by enemies, and they were fiercely protective of them. And so they ran, through cliff-face and hillside, through endless plains roughened by the stampeding of horses and the wearing of weather, and not once did they stop, not even when days and days had gone by with no food or shelter or sleep. They ran for many hundreds of miles, faster than any soldiers ever had before, and they were known henceforth as the Three Hunters. For the Elf would dash ahead and watch out, onto the fields, and see in the distance the evil they were chasing, and the Man would follow the smallest markings in the earth to keep them on the treacherous path, and the noble dwarf would be ever-present, urging them on, carrying their strength with his bare hands and running all the while.
“After a time, the Hunters began to grow worried that their journey was in vain, and that their enemies had already killed the friends they hoped to save, but still they gave chase, until they found themselves in a forest. But this was a forest of deep and ancient magic, and the trees could walk in the waking world, and they would creak and moan and kept evil at bay, and so the Three Hunters’ hearts were roused once more. They ran on, first on foot and then on horseback — which perhaps meant that the dwarf was the bravest of them all — until they came to the battlements of what was once a kingdom in its prime. It was there that the enemy turned to them instead, intending to take out these mighty warriors who had shown without doubt they would die for one another.
“And they fought a great battle that day, long into the night after all hope had been lost, and deep in the hollows of the mountains they had been backed into, until at last the dawn broke over the melee and the Three Hunters had won with the help of the walking trees and the people of those southern lands. And you will all be very pleased to hear that the axe of that mighty dwarf had been the most fearsome weapon in the battle that day, and claimed more lives of evil than anyone else who had fought, most notably including the Elf and his bow. For the blood of kings and warriors ran in him, and he wished to do his father proud.”
It was as if, once Bilbo finished his story, the very air surrounding them all had stilled. The fire barely flickered, and his words echoed heavily in the silence, the eyes of all his dwarves downcast and the sound of rustling leaves in the night seeming to blur.
For a small moment, Bilbo wondered if he might have made a mistake.
“You certainly have a way with words, Master Baggins,” Balin said then, softly, and it brought the rest of them out of their reverie.
Bofur seemed, for once, to have nothing to say; his eyes were a little wide. So were Fili and Kili’s. Bifur had stopped with his spoon halfway to his mouth, and Ori and Dori’s mouths had fallen right open. Even the constant frown-lines across Dwalin’s forehead had almost entirely disappeared.
And beyond them, Bilbo could see Thorin watching him silently, his gaze unmoving. He didn’t look angry; only contemplative, as he had the whole trip so far, and as made Bilbo’s heart perpetually hover somewhere in his throat with equal parts worry and longing.
Bilbo dipped his head again, rather embarrassed.
“Oh, please don’t flatter me! To tell you the truth, it was a tale I’d heard whispers of, around and about in different places, and I simply took it and made it my own. I’m not much of a creator in my own right. Not for stories, at least, although I do love to write.”
“But what about the hobbits?” said Kili suddenly. Bilbo’s heart very nearly skipped a beat.
“I'm sorry?”
He’d made no mention of Merry or Pippin or Sam or Frodo. He hadn’t said a word.
Kili frowned and settled back into the spot where he was resting in front of the fire. “Well,” he said slowly, “surely if these Three Hunters were representing the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth, they should have brought a hobbit along, and had four hunters, if it was going to be fair. Now that we’ve got one, it seems quite wrong to leave you out.”
That had a sweet feeling blooming in Bilbo’s chest, and he wished, not for the first time, that he could be truly, truly honest with them all, and tell them everything that had happened in his long, long life, and all that it meant to him to see them like this again. He swallowed it down like always.
“Ah, but Kili,” he smiled, “I think you’ll find they did know a few hobbits in their time, and held great love for them. One of the hobbits may well have even been a Baggins, for all we know, though certainly not the Baggins sitting in front of you!" Bilbo quipped, to a few hearty chuckles. "But I quite think stories of hobbits and adventures should wait for another day.”
“I agree,” that deep voice said, unmistakeable. Bilbo had been expecting it to interject before then.
“That’s enough. It’s already late,” Thorin said in a gravelly voice. And he stood and turned his back on their camp, on Bilbo, and walked into the darkness to scout til he was bone-weary once more.
Bilbo trained his eyes on the ground and did not watch him go.
Another day for storytelling, however, seemed to come only the very next day, when Bilbo found that while he’d been riding along the road absently, lost in his pondering and trusting Myrtle to steer him back on course if needed, several dwarves had sidled up next to him and were watching him with an avid interest: Kili, Bofur, Ori, and Dori, and Bilbo could even see Balin lingering nearby on Minty. Bilbo blinked at them, and they shied away, and in fact it was Gandalf who eventually brought the whole thing up.
“Have you ever thought of publishing your stories, Bilbo?”
Bilbo startled. Heavens, he hadn’t even seen Gandalf ride up behind him. He shifted a little in his saddle.
“Were you… not asleep, then?” he asked, cursing the jumpiness in his voice. If Gandalf unravelled the web of half-truths he’d woven now — well, he was well and truly done for.
Pull yourself together, you fool!
“Merely dozing,” the wizard replied, fixing his eyes steadily on Bilbo underneath his crooked hat. Bilbo momentarily drifted into wondering how on the Earth Gandalf the White had managed any of his conversations without a hat to hide his eyes under, since Gandalf the Grey seemed so incredibly partial to it. “I did hear bits and pieces of your tale, my dear fellow, and it was very well-told! I wonder if you could impress even the Elves.”
The equal absurdity and accuracy of it made Bilbo chuckle. “Oh, I’m not so talented as all that, Gandalf,” he dismissed. “Besides, if I did publish them, who in the world would ever read them?”
“Oh, Elves love to hear stories, although many of theirs are of the long ago they all remember, when the world was new and the air was different. But I think your stories would excite them, to hear something so different from their own, and so distinctly told. Perhaps you shall even get a chance, soon enough.” He raised one eyebrow meaningfully.
“We have purpose for books too, Master Baggins,” another voice chimed in. It was Dori, cantering a little closer and looking earnestly at Bilbo. “Ori uses them often in his craft, especially since he’ll be approaching his Mastery now, and there are others who do the same when we need certain tasks to be completed. Though Balin has told us the texts we have in Ered Luin are a poor replacement for what we had before Smaug.”
“It is a cobbled-together life in the Blue Mountains,” Balin agreed, with a resigned sort of smile. “None of us but Thorin and I have known anything else. Not even Dwalin, though he is old enough to remember the long years in-between, when we were nothing but poor travellers on the road.”
Ori still seemed a little shy of him, but it was then that he piped up.
“Is writing your craft, Master Baggins?”
Bilbo hummed. “I suppose you’d say it’s my craft, yes,” he said, “though we don’t really have such formal positions in the Shire. Folks mostly just make do where they like.”
That sent them round the circle, and each of them spoke with great pride to him about the love their hands had for stone, or woodwork, or tailoring, or toy-making, or wielding the sharp edge of an axe. He could feel the devotion in their voices as they spoke, and the careful honour they each carried with them in their trades, and thought again that those who imagined dwarves to be cold and unfeeling with love for only gold and silver could not be more wrong.
“So you really haven’t written any books?” Bofur pressed. Bilbo felt the weight of the red volume currently being jostled around in the pack on his back and smiled ruefully.
“I’m not experienced enough for all that. Mostly I write poetry, or historical accounts — though I have written some songs in my time.”
This caught their attention, and Bofur of course brightened immediately, a swaggering grin stretching across his face. Bilbo thought offhandedly to himself that Bofur would be an absolute riot down at the Green Dragon, and would probably give all the hobbits in the Westfarthing a run for their money, to boot.
“Give us a sample, laddie!”
There was only one real choice as to which song to sing for them, for it was theirs, after all, and it reminded him of them wherever he went. Bilbo opened his mouth and neatly began to sing.
“The Road goes ever on and on,
Down from the door where it began
Now far ahead the Road has gone,
And I must follow, if I can
Pursuing it with eager feet,
Until it joins some larger way
Where many paths and errands meet
And whither then? I cannot say.”
Bilbo finished his tune to raucous applause and a ridiculous echo of “And whither then? I cannot say!” from Bofur with a huge grin on his face.
Then he turned quite suddenly to look at Kili, who chirped up another, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Dori, who smoothly sung, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Nori, appearing quite out of nowhere and exclaiming, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and to Ori piping up with, “And whither then? I cannot say!”, and back to Bilbo, who was chuckling in surprise when he joined in with, “And whither then? I cannot say!”
This went on for quite a long time, until they were all behaving like a complete gaggle of geese, repeating one after the other and collapsing all over the place on their ponies with childlike laughter. In fact, they did not show any signs of stopping at all until Fili of all people slowed from where he’d been riding up ahead and politely asked them if they could please stop singing the same thing over and over again because it was getting rather annoying and their ears were all going to fall off.
Bilbo had looked back toward Gandalf at this, who’d only winked with a twinkle in his eye.
The days went on and on. Occasionally the dwarves’ voices would rise up in chorus as they journeyed along the Great East Road, sometimes jolly and sometimes painful and sombre. Occasionally they’d even prod at Bilbo until he trundled out a tune, though he only ever sang the same song to them, and the others had been completely and utterly banned from repeating any of the lines after the utter chaos it had caused.
(Though they had finally started calling him Bilbo again, which made the world feel a little more like it was tilted the right way.)
Bilbo was reminded often of how unused to him they were by all manner of things. His bare face and the quirks of his expressions, the politely odd way he spoke. His bootless feet and the tufts of hair covering them; his linen clothes and their simple earthen colours and buttons all over. His familiarity and warmth, for he knew that even for a hobbit he was usually quite uppity, and for it to dissipate so rapidly with the dwarves was strange to both them and Gandalf, he was sure, though Gandalf was likely just glad he didn’t have to warm any icy waters between them.
One such day, it was a small spot of cultural difference between their two peoples that had both Bilbo and the dwarves stumped.
“How on Earth can you not know what a harmonica is, Bofur!”
All Bilbo’d done was tell Bofur that he thought he’d make an excellent harmonica player, and that if he hadn’t already, he should give it a try, and now Bofur was looking at Bilbo like he’d suddenly grown feet out his ears.
“Aren’t you a toymaker?” Bilbo cried. Bofur was convinced he was making things up that simply didn’t exist, and for some infuriating reason Gandalf refused outright to attest to Bilbo’s honesty. He was an inch away from pulling his own hair out. The two of them swayed in tandem as their ponies picked up to a steady trot, following the curve the Company made.
“You blow into it, just like your flute.” Bilbo insisted desperately, ignoring Gandalf’s amused smile lurking in his periphery. “You’d be a natural!”
“Oh, aye, Bilbo, it sounds beautiful, if it were only real!”
“Oh, for — I’ll show you how to make them so you and Bifur can sell them in your toy shop. I’ve not done it before, but it’s not like you’ll know the difference even if it’s utterly terrible, will you!” Bofur threw his head back and laughed, clutching at the back of his hat so it didn’t fall off.
Bilbo always forgot how much he’d missed Bofur until he saw him again. The merry laughter rang in his ears long after they’d moved onto talking about something else.
All in all, his second-go-around was travelling rather swimmingly. The only real problem, of course, was that Bilbo still could not look at Thorin.
It had been weeks now, and he could not make himself look the King Under the Mountain in the eye. It was getting to be exceedingly bothersome, to tell the truth, and Thorin spoke little to him enough as it was, which certainly didn’t help matters. Bilbo refused to count up every instance and fawn over them like a ditzy lass in the throes of infatuation.
(But so far they had been, as follows):
“Your turn to carry the cookery, Master Burglar.”
“We turn east at sundown.”
“Pheasant stew.”
“If you want to collect more mushrooms, be our guest.”
“Wake up.”
“Wake up.”
“Wake up.”
“You’re late.”
“Bundle up your bedding more tightly.”
“I will take the watch.”
Grumpy, but watchful, taking Bilbo into his company more reluctantly than Bilbo had ever seen anyone do but still making sure to do it nevertheless. It was as if he were a rosebush overgrown with thorns.
At that moment, a brown satchel clunked to the ground right in front of Bilbo and startled him quite entirely out of his wits. He squeaked and jerked backward at the sudden noise, then cut his gaze over to where Thorin’s boots were trudging away beyond the outskirts of the camp. He’d dropped the rucksack of pots and pans at Bilbo’s feet. He hadn’t even looked at Bilbo once while he’d done it.
Not quite a rosebush, then. Perhaps he was more like a thistle of weeds that shocked you silly when it managed to grow one measly little flower. Bilbo glared.
But even then, he could not bring himself to look.
(It was quite simple, really. He was terrified that if he did, he would find that Thorin’s eyes had closed again.)
The only times Bilbo ever felt brave enough to look Thorin Oakenshield in the face were when everything and everyone else was still and silent with sleep, and so each night, he would lay unseen by all but the stars and let his eyes rest gently on Thorin.
He thought of the King Under the Mountain, asleep under the rock for eternity, bearing both against and within his chest the heart of the kingdom of Erebor. He thought of his still and unbroken face, his hair splayed out behind him like a dark halo. How a piece of his own soul had been left there when he’d turned away.
Bilbo remembered it well, as well as if it were an imprint behind his eyelids. The ten of them left, standing together and smiling so terribly sadly as he walked away from them with staff and pack in hand. The way he’d turned one final time and raised his hand towards the Mountain in unspoken farewell, for there had been no words for the chasm that had opened in his chest, and he could not bear to say goodbye.
The way he had walked for many long miles with tears sticking on his face, the December wind whipping and pulling at him as he and Gandalf walked quietly side by side, back towards the West. The way Gandalf had told him that he would no longer be able to see the Lonely Mountain once they reached the feet of the Grey Mountain-range and the edge of Mirkwood, and Bilbo had not turned back to look upon it. Not even once.
He'd felt like the final page had been ripped out of a storybook. Or wondered if maybe the reason nobody much liked adventures in the Shire was because they did not like to talk about what came after they ended.
If matters could’ve been made any worse, Bilbo was sure he would have done so, no matter how desperately he wished otherwise. For it was also true that he’d only realised the depth of the feeling in his heart when he’d been left alone on the ice, numbness and nothingness tearing at his skin like blunt bramble-knots, and known with a sudden, hollowing clarity that grieving a love who had never known you loved them at all was the worst heartache a soul might be able to bear.
Bilbo thought about how he had never written his grief over Thorin into his book, had never once mentioned it aloud to a single living soul, though no doubt those who knew had been able to see it all over him plain as day. He had never been able to put on paper what he felt, and how the loss had pressed against him on all sides, pushing at his ribcage for much longer than he had made out to anyone else.
How Thorin had become a presence in the back of his mind, sleepy and soothing after he’d had time to heal and the acorn planted in his garden had blossomed into her beautiful oak, the warmth like coming home again after a long time away.
(Oh, Bilbo had missed him so dearly.)
Sometimes, when he was a boy, Frodo would ask him if he missed his dwarf-friends, and Bilbo would smile and say Yes, my lad. I miss them very much, and I love them all like family. But that was the end of it. Thorin had simply stayed nestled in his heart, twining his way around Bilbo’s arms and hands and nerves and knitting his fragile skin back together until the thought of him was warm rather than deathly cold, even if still bittersweet.
I would have liked to show you the sun, my dear.
I would have liked to lay in the grass on the hillside with you, and look at the sky, and smell the change in the air when springtime came.
To read to him, or let his own fumbling fingers be taught how to weave through dwarven hair, or wander through the garden and show him how to ask the plants to grow. To slide their fingers together against each other’s palms, for he had never, not once, gotten the chance.
Some years after the battle, Balin had come to visit, and memory meant they’d sat as always in their assigned places at Bilbo’s table from that one long-ago unexpected evening.
“How goes the Mountain?” Bilbo asked, late at night over steaming mugs of tea and spiced rum cradled in their hands.
Balin had told him how they were prospering at last, after so long in hardship and squalor, and how more and more dwarves flocked to Erebor as time went on and their reign of peace continued, and how no servants of evil would dare to come near the base of the Mountain, for they could not succeed.
“He tells us when they are near. With Orcrist.” And he had smiled, with ages drawn in the lines of his face, the weary fondness of someone who was remembering someone else long gone. “He protects us, even still.”
Bilbo had turned away after he’d left, and pulled his knees and elbows up in front of the fireplace, and cried, and cried, and cried.
He did not know how to think of Thorin in his grief, for he did not even know where dwarves were taken when their bodies departed from the realm of the living. Thorin on his deathbed had spoken of the dwarven halls of waiting, and Bilbo imagined great pillars of beautiful marbled rock, and gems of all kinds nestled sweetly in the caverns, and golden lining everywhere among all the forefathers of old. He often wondered if Thorin would be happy there.
Well, now, he didn’t need to wonder, did he? Thorin was living and breathing and given back to him, and yet Bilbo could not shake what had become habit after so very long with loss filling his chest. This Thorin was a mirage, a glimpse at possibility, and Bilbo did not dare look at him too long lest he disappear.
The dwarf in question turned back and looked over all of them, his eyes alert and on guard, his mind so clearly working at doubled pace. Bilbo scratched at Myrtle’s ears and looked away silently.
You are still so far from me.
He watched Thorin watching in the night for signs of danger, never sleeping, laying down but with blue eyes open. His furs would be piled around him, and he was always hidden in shadow, tucked into a rock or beside a knoll of grass, never too close to the warmth of the fire’s embers or the bodies of his kin all nestled together. His face never once changed expression.
Bilbo chastised himself with an inward scowl. And really, it wasn’t as though when he looked at Thorin he only saw the body left behind — lidless eyes staring upwards and a chest that stayed still and fingers that were bitterly, bitingly pale. He wasn’t the sort to burst into tears at every sight of him; it had been many years, and Bilbo liked to think he had at least a little more sensibility than that.
But oh, the ache. To remember the way he’d moved, the way his feet fell against the earth in that steady stride, the way his low voice hummed like ash across the fire the rare times he spoke at night. To see him raise his head to the sky to look ahead on their journey, shaking the hair from his face, and know that if Bilbo were to close his eyes and fall into a dream, all of his memories would look exactly the same. Knowing that such a tangible presence had been stolen from its place among the living broke Bilbo’s heart, and he spent much of his time with a hum in his chest, whispering I missed you, how I missed you, how I had to miss you.
Thorin did not like it, of course, though he never made it known to Bilbo. It was disrespectful, to look away from a king, and yet Bilbo could do nothing else. He feared that if he reached out to touch him, he’d fade away like mist. He feared that he was whirling through some Elvish vision to calm him or placate him through the journey beyond the sea, and all the while he was still old and frail and fading aboard the ships out of the Grey Havens. He feared that this flicker of a second life wasn’t real, and that if it was, he would not be enough to save them. And if Bilbo failed, he feared he would not get the chance to try again, and he would spend all of eternity in Valinor with an utterly broken heart.
Tthe Company would most often stop at midday to eat and replenish their energy, and on one of these occasions they happened to come across a field of low-rising flowers. Nothing quite like the meadows of unimaginable colour Bilbo knew lay beyond the Misty Mountains, but the rosy pink of the petals that speckled the downy grass still brought a sigh to his heart. They were dainty, the colour of strawberry milk when they muddled it together in the Shire; the colour of his mother’s brushes.
He could see Fili wandering at the edge of the group with a few strips of jerky in his hand, and walked over just as the dwarf knelt down with a curious sort of frown towards the flowers waving at them.
“It’s a peony,” Bilbo said gently, when Fili’s cautious hand seemed to pause before it could touch the pale bud closest to him. They’d been Frodo’s favourite flower. Bilbo knew like the back of his own hand that they told of love, honour, prosperity, and bashfulness. They also told of impending doom.
His throat crushed up into itself.
“A what?” Fili asked, sounding confused. He stood, and moved to take a step just as Bilbo bent down to brush the peony with his fingers.
“Don’t step on it,” Bilbo said quickly.
Fili’s lifted boot lowered back to the ground, and they blinked at each other from two different heights. Bilbo flashed an offbeat smile at him and looked back towards the washed-out flower field.
Hello, Frodo. I wonder if this is you here, telling me you’re still thinking of little old me.
The softer colours had always been the ones Frodo loved best, but Bilbo suddenly wished with a regret that threatened to choke him that he’d tucked a yellow peony into Frodo’s pack before they’d left Middle-Earth for the sea, so he could have given him his new beginning before he left him behind.
Better to forget, my lad, he thought sadly. Better to rest.
“They’re very special to hobbits. We have no language of our own, so the flowers are our secret way of speaking.” Bilbo rose and turned to wander back towards the ponies, and Fili fell into step beside him. “I love flowers,” he admitted.
“But they die,” Fili said, still sounding a little hesitant. It made sense; dwarves loved gemstones more than anything else, and the beauty of a grown garden was so vastly different that Bilbo thought he may as well have told Fili he worshipped sand, or dirt, or some other preposterous thing.
He tilted his head back and shrugged instead. “So do lots of things.”
“What’s your favourite flower, then, Bilbo?” Fili tore into a piece of jerky with his teeth and began to chew.
Bilbo was quiet for a while, and a soft, secret smile crept onto his face that he was sure told more of a story than anything else he had said.
“Lily-of-the-valley. It means ‘the return of happiness’.” He tucked his hands into his trouser-pockets as they strolled back to the rest of their scattered-about group. “It’s a white flower, quite small, and it has little bells for petals that hang all the way along the stems. I remember my mother used to pick sprouts of it and dangle them in my face so the bells would tickle my nose. When I was a very little hobbit, she used to hold them out of my reach, and I’d jump up and try to catch them.”
He closed his eyes briefly. “Flower-speech is the closest thing we have to our own tongue, and using them that way is like being able to use a hundred words at once. The flowers tell a story. It’s certainly no Khuzdûl, but sometimes… well, sometimes they’ve been the only way I could say what I really meant.”
They’d made it back to the Company, then, and the other dwarves had begun to listen in curiously after hearing Bilbo chastise Fili about the peonies.
“I planted a flower-garden once to tell a story, a long time ago,” Bilbo said, in gentle explanation, blinking his eyes open. “I used to stand in the middle of it with my eyes closed and let the breeze blow right by. I know you dwarves can sometimes find things like that silly,” he smiled, “but I think you would have liked my little garden.”
Purple and white hyacinths. Poppies and rosemary and sweetpea and lilac and butterfly weed. Red carnations and forget-me-nots and gardenias and blue and red salvia. And snapdragons.
He couldn’t help but squint in the sunlight at his sudden audience. All of them were watching him. Even Thorin was watching him, though the expression on his face was not fond. It rather looked as though Bilbo’s words had somehow caught his notice, and that this notice had greatly displeased him.
If Bilbo was honest with himself, that was the way Thorin had always looked at him, in those long-ago days before they’d made it through the Misty Mountains and past the goblins chasing them. Bilbo rather thought that instead of suddenly realising his worth all at once the way it had seemed, Thorin had felt Bilbo very slowly growing on him like a weed, and had been exceedingly irritated by the fact.
(It was how Bilbo had always thought of Thorin, after all, when he’d woken up one day and realised how deeply he'd come to care for the dwarf’s opinion, and how woven amongst them all he now was. It was like he’d blinked and the colour had suddenly bled into the world, all over his hands and staining the pages of his books, only for Bilbo to realise that it’d been there all along and he’d simply needed to open his eyes.)
They’d always been circling each other in that first lifetime, really. Thorin had gotten stuck in his head and hadn’t let go, almost from the very first day, when he’d sung the sorrow of his people and drawn a line from his own soul to Bilbo’s in doing it. So Bilbo thought he might have gotten stuck in Thorin’s head in the same way, and that after a while on their first journey, Thorin had simply stopped pushing back.
It hadn’t been in the same way, of course; Thorin had trusted him, and sought his opinion, had led and been led by him, but Bilbo carried his heart alone, cupped in the weary palms of his hands.
It struck him that it was a very bittersweet thing to think.
“We will go around the flowers,” said Thorin gruffly, saddling up his pony. His eyes sifted over Bilbo as they passed across his Company, and he drew them away so Bilbo could not reciprocate the gaze even if he had wanted to. There was a hollow nestled in his jaw where he’d clenched it, and his expression was jade-sharp and stormy. The clouds were rolling in.
No, Thorin was not fond at all.
But they would go around the flowers.
Bilbo had forgotten, in hindsight, however, how hard the rain came down.
It turned streams and creeks a sickly milk-brown, and the sky the colour of thunder, and the ground beneath them to thick, stinking sludge. The ponies had to work twice as hard to pull their feet from the mud and mess, and the peacefully brisk pace they’d set since leaving Bag End slowed to an unbearable drag, the wind wild and whipping at their faces like needle-points.
The ponies had fallen to half-stumbling blindly through the whitewash in front of them before Thorin made the call for them to stop, defeated and shivering, huddling under whatever shelter they could salvage from the overhanging trees. If there had been one thing Bilbo could have done without reliving, it would have been this forced cowering from the constant wind.
It was barely any time at all after they’d made shelter before a sense of deep unease began to creep its way up Bilbo’s limbs. The chill crawled into his waterlogged skin and chattering teeth and clutched at his nerves until he was sure something was dangerously wrong — as if they shouldn’t have come here. His skin itched with it.
It wasn’t until he saw Gandalf storming furiously away from Thorin and into the grey haze that he realised what exactly the itch was and his stomach tried to upend itself in panic.
“He can’t leave.”
He’d said it quietly, almost without meaning to, and he vaguely registered Bofur turning to glance at him, hat sopping-wet and dripping water into his eyes.
“Don’t you worry, Bilbo! He’ll be back sooner or later.”
Bilbo stood up quite suddenly from the log he’d been hovering on, upsetting Bofur’s balance and tipping him headfirst onto the ground. His heart was pounding.
“He can’t leave. We’re not safe here.” He turned quickly, eyes flitting around in rapidly-increasing desperation, but the darkness had neatly swallowed Gandalf up without a trace. They were alone.
He felt skittish. Jittery. He could feel prickles of nervous dread and anticipation running along his shoulder-blades, and he’d never mourned the lack of Sting quite as sharply as he did at that moment. Bilbo hadn’t ever fully mastered the swing of it, trusting instead on rage and the wild thud of his heart in every moment he’d needed to use it, but the emptiness of the little sword in the notch of his belt felt then like the phantom ache of a limb.
He’d been too complacent. What was he thinking? This wasn’t just a holiday with old friends; he hadn’t been given a second chance only to spend all his time smiling stupidly and telling stories and mooning over Thorin’s ceaseless frowning. He’d come back to keep them all safe.
Oh, pull yourself together, you old ninny! You managed this part without Sting the first time, and you shall manage without it again!
“Fili,” Bilbo said hesitantly. “I need your knife.”
That got the attention of quite a few of the dwarves ducking out of the wind, as he’d hoped it would not but suspected it might. Dwalin looked scandalised. Fili himself looked increasingly protective, and one of his hands had gone to his weapons belt, but he seemed to be considering the request, at least. His careful eyes fell on Bilbo.
“Why? Bilbo, you —”
“Please. I need you to trust me,” Bilbo whispered, knowing he sounded completely absurd. “We are not alone.”
As if on cue, a loud and terrible crack rang through the treeline, shaking the boughs above them and causing a flock of birds to stir from their sheltering-places up into the night. Afterwards, there came what sounded like boulders tumbling down a mountain; what was likely the sound of gigantic, ugly footsteps.
Several heads snapped back towards Bilbo, but he was off, on two feet and creeping methodically through the underbrush, grabbing at tree trunks and peeking his head out from behind them to scope out the forest up ahead.
“What is it, Bilbo?” asked Balin, who’d never been one to doubt him. Bilbo was filled with profound gratitude. “What do you see?”
Those blasted trolls.
Bilbo had the best eyes of all of them above ground, but before he could speak, Thorin answered instead.
“There is a light, up amongst those trees.” His voice was low and entirely stoic, and he only briefly glanced Bilbo’s way, turning instead towards Fili and Kili with a grave look in his eye. “Check the ponies.”
They returned soon after with predictably matching expressions of alarm.
“We’re four down,” Kili said worriedly.
“Exactly,” said Bilbo, quiet urgency in his voice. “I need to poke around and see if there’s anything we can do. We can’t all go charging off without a single idea of what we’re up against, and I am the smallest here. Which is why I need your knife, Fili.”
“Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, and the ever-growing lump in Bilbo’s throat came back with a vengeance. “Do you think it entirely wise to go charging into an enemy camp barely armed? You are not a fighter. A dagger is not enough to defend yourself.”
Bilbo wrestled madly with the urge to roll his eyes in Thorin’s face, knowing he’d take it abysmally.
"I have been brought on this quest as a burglar, Master Oakenshield, and so burgling is what I shall do.”
And really, there wasn’t any reason to be fussing. One little hobbit, shoeless, silent, skirting round the bushes with a measly borrowed knife didn't exactly invite violence. He smoothed down the folds of his coat and turned to the others with bright eyes.
“You should stay close, but hide in the trees. You must hide. Don’t move or make the slightest sound, not unless it’s either completely fine or all gone horribly wrong, or unless I make it very clear that I need you.” He got a few warily trusting nods, but Thorin’s scowl was still all over his face.
“They will catch you,” he argued bluntly.
Bilbo turned around and began to walk, not deigning to bother with Thorin when his ears were clearly full of rocks.
“I have a plan for that, too,” he shot over his shoulder.
He was utterly silent as he crept out of the trees and made a stealthy beeline for the atrocious excuse of a pen the trolls had fashioned for Myrtle, Minty, Daisy and Bungo, a line of dwarves trailing after him in the distance. Far above him, the trolls were arguing, and their groaning and moaning and belching rang like a cacophony against Bilbo’s eardrums, but he tried to block them out as best he could, instead exhaling a breath of cool air through his teeth and continuing on his way into the clearing.
He soon reached the line of rope cutting the ponies off, drew Fili’s little blade from his trouser-pocket, and got right to work, glad it hadn’t shorn through the lining of his clothes.
All too soon, however, he was regretting the thought, and was in fact rather incensed at the stubborn distrust of dwarves, even after you have become friends and all, it seems! Oh, confusticate every one of them for not bearing to part with a single weapon for five minutes!
Fili had given Bilbo what was the worst knife he had possibly ever laid eyes on, and he was barely making a dent in the thick line of rope strung up across the ponies’ pen. Worse still, the rope was made with such coarse twine, and the knife so blunt and pocked with chips and scrapes, that every stroke made an awful screeching noise, no matter how quietly or slowly Bilbo tried to slice. He swallowed every bit of nerve and heart that was resting in his throat and carried on uselessly while trying to devise a backup plan, searching round the nearby grass for signs of jagged rocks.
But the noise of the blunt knife was so sharp in the darkness, that just when Bilbo’s arms were beginning to tire and he was almost considering creeping back into the leaves beyond the camp to ask for a knife that actually worked, a loud, rumbling bellow echoed out from behind him, and Bilbo knew his time was up.
He dropped his hands to his sides, spun, and ducked just as a fist the size of his whole dining table swiped out at him, dashing out from the pen into the centre of the clearing, just past the troll’s bonfire and clearly in plain sight. The heat from it was scorching up close, and Bilbo felt himself begin to drip with sweat.
“Blimey, Bert, Bill, look what’s scurrying round in the bushes! What is it, d’ya reckon?” one of the three trolls boomed with a voice like a rockslide, swinging his huge hands again towards Bilbo, who dropped immediately, scrambling back until he was out of reach of their colossal, grabby arms.
“Well? What are ya, then?” The troll - Tom, he guessed - said, and Bilbo was suddenly faced with three pairs of huge bloodshot, blinking eyes towering over him on the ground. He felt like an ant looking up at a pair of boots. He stared up at them defiantly, feeling the cold rush of adrenaline flood through him, telling him to survive, save them, get your sword, and be on your way.
“Why, I’m a fellow traveller looking for a meal, of course,” Bilbo countered, quite calmly, “and I was just on my way to catch some dwarves when I stumbled upon you lot.”
“Dwarves?” Bert exclaimed, and the quaking roar in his voice shook the trees around them.
“Yes, dwarves,” Bilbo said in exasperation, hiding the trembling of his hands surreptitiously behind his back. “There’s an encampment of dwarves, just nearby, and I can lead you right to them.” He bit his lip and closed his eyes for a beat at the sudden angry whispers filtering out from the forest, fear clutching at his throat, but they quietened before the trolls stopped arguing with each other long enough to focus again on Bilbo, leering.
“You think we’ll believe you after ya tried to set our dinner loose?” Bill said accusingly, and Bilbo clenched his eyes shut even tighter, breathing out a curse, knowing they could very well see the knife glinting out from behind his back. He opened his eyes and rolled them mightily, hoping against hope he was selling every bit of his performance to this trio of half-wits.
“The ponies will trot right on back to their masters, and we can follow them the whole way there. I’m doing you three a favour, I should think.” He paused. “Big, hulking, ugly dwarves they are, too, and nothing but rocks and stones in their heads, besides. An easier meal than having to gut and carve up a couple of ponies, I’m sure.”
Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo could see the outraged faces of several of the dwarves crouching in the undergrowth, the betrayal clear in the bright anger of their eyes, but still they all stayed quiet and did not move a muscle.
All of them, that was, except Thorin, whose face Bilbo could see starkest against the shadows of the forest, and who was watching him with a coldness that seemed to stroke its way up Bilbo’s spine. He could see in Thorin’s eyes that he did not trust Bilbo at all, and that every word Bilbo was speaking to the trolls was driving the wedge deeper and deeper.
Bilbo fixed his eyes sharply on Thorin’s, pleading with him silently to trust him, trust him. They could not take the trolls by force, and they could not leave without the ponies or the blades still hidden deep in the grime of the troll-hoard nearby. There was no other way for them to play this. He knew what he was doing.
With horror, Bilbo watched as Thorin shook his head slightly, his braids swinging as he began to step forward from out of the thicket of leaves, heavy boots crushing the shoots beneath his feet. Bilbo quickly let the tips of his fingers twitch upwards from his side, motioning for Thorin to stay still, to wait. He took a shuddering breath.
Thorin stilled.
Please. Please trust me.
But the crunch of the boots had already echoed through the stillness of the camp, and with the trolls peering at him as closely as they were, the one nearest to him leant in, squinting down at him and then over to the bushes where the dwarves were all concealed. Bilbo held his breath against the hot air washing over his face, the smell of it like rotting flesh.
“What was that?”
Bilbo stood his ground, holding himself so still he thought his jaw might crack with the force of it. He cast around wildly, hoping the sun was near, hoping the dawn would hurry.
“Well, it’s - probably one of them running away! You’d best follow me, and quickly, otherwise the cowardly thing might make it back to camp and let the others know of your plans before you can gobble them all up in time.”
The trolls were still sneering and snotting at him, but Bilbo could see their eyes alight with the temptation of fresh meat ripe for the taking. “Tom, grab the sacks,” Bill said, flashing the nubs in his mouth that passed for teeth in a horrible smile.
They’d barely taken a step away from the camp and from the trees the dwarves were hiding in when he heard what were unmistakably the cries of battle. Bilbo’s stomach sank down into his knees.
All of them, all of them, had raced into the clearing with axes aloft and eyes ablaze and were waging war on whatever parts of the trolls they could get to, their hands, their ankles and legs, their beady, bloody eyes looking down in surprise.
Bombur was spinning like a top, a hammer in each hand, and Dwalin’s angry snarl was like out of a tapestry of the First Age, and Nori was dancing and weaving through the trolls’ stumbling feet, and Kili’s blade sliced at their limbs with such striking ferocity that Bilbo felt utterly aghast. He did not know what to do. He didn’t have a single weapon on him apart from Fili’s useless knife, not a slingshot or a sword or even a toothpick, and he began to shout with increasing panic.
“Oh - dear, they’ve gotten the jump on us! Look here, you trolls, I’ll lead them away, and you wait in the trees to take them by surprise when I circle back -” Oh, you thickheaded, stubborn, pieces of work, you couldn’t leave me alone for a second!
The howls of the trolls shook the branches of the forest. There were knives flying, crashes of immense limbs, bits of dirt kicking up and spraying the sky. The flames of the fire began to grow. All the dwarves were bellowing to each other in Khuzdûl, their voices hardened in the brawl. Bilbo saw one of the trolls’ faces distort into a gruesome scowl, its features twisting and muddying into something grotesque, and he took a few steps back, twigs snapping under his bare feet.
Then there was a desperate shout, and the blood under his skin turned to ice.
Bilbo spun around. The largest of the trolls had gripped Kili by the ankles and was dangling him high in the air like a piece of limp bait on a fishhook. Kili’s eyes were wide with panic, and he was shouting down to the dwarves below him, hair in his eyes as he thrashed and threw his body around to desperately try and hack at the troll’s fingers.
His eyes raced once more around the clearing in terror; Bombur was being dragged along the ground by the weediest of the trolls, Bifur and Bofur chasing after him and throwing their weapons uselessly, Dwalin had lost one axe, and Thorin, Thorin was wielding his broadsword like a dagger, fingers gripped round the hilt and angling it downwards as he stabbed, hair wild around his face. A huge hand swiped for him and he ducked out of the way, sliding across the floor and cutting at the troll’s calves. Bilbo felt sick with fear. The panic was truly setting in, now, and he began to stammer in his haste to stop it and save the situation from catastrophe.
“Oh, dear, maybe not that one!” he almost screamed over the din at the one still tossing Kili about. “He seems to be - yes, I can see it now, he’s riddled! Riddled all over, with parasites, and in fact, if he’s riddled, then the rest of them must be - ah, now that I can see them clearly, it seems they’re all riddled, must have all caught the same disease, now, that’s horrid luck! I’m afraid you won’t be able to eat them after all, Master Trolls, not unless you want to make yourselves terribly sick, I’m so sorry for leading you on such a goose-chase when you’ll have nothing to - Oh!"
The rock split. Light began to pour in.
“The dawn will take you all!”
Gandalf had come.
The trolls turned to see who’d made such a noise, but it was too late. The boulder fell to one side with a staggering crash, and daylight spilled through in a great cascade. All three trolls realised what lay ahead in unison and threw their hands up in terror, the action tossing Kili through the air like a ragdoll. The heavy hollowness that rang out when he hit the ground seized at Bilbo’s chest like a coil around his heart.
The shrieking stopped. They were stone once more.
Each of the dwarves slowly began to pick themselves up from where they’d been strewn around the clearing like toys littering the floor in a child’s playroom, breathing hard from the exertion. Kili got to his feet and touched at his forehead a little. His sleeve was torn, and his head was likely ringing quite badly, but he seemed all right. Bilbo watched as Fili dashed over to pummel him in the arm and admonish him for being so reckless in the fight.
Oin soon hurried over to where Fili and Kili were standing, his ear trumpet tucked under one bustling arm, and Bilbo made to follow him until a loud grunt from somewhere nearby stopped him quite in his tracks.
In front of him, Thorin Oakenshield began to stagger to his feet. Their eyes met.
“You should not,” Thorin said lowly, “have done something so risky, Master Burglar.”
He wasn’t quite spitting the words out, but Bilbo could see that there was real anger behind that ever-present appearance of stone. “You had no way of knowing what they would do.”
The coldness of his eyes had Bilbo bristling at once.
“Actually, I rather think that I had it under control, thank you, and I did ask you to follow my lead. I cannot help it if you go tearing into places without a second thought.”
Nearly got yourselves all killed, I should think. And what would I have done then, Thorin? What would I have done then?
“You should have told us what you planned to do before you blindly walked in there,” Thorin said more loudly, and the tone of his voice had sharpened to ice. His eyes were fixed on Bilbo with a look of utter contempt. “You are unarmed and alone, and there are thirteen of us with experience. You would have gotten yourself killed.”
It was then that the already-shortening fuse on Bilbo’s temper snapped.
“As you’ve kindly pointed out, Master Oakenshield, I am not a fighter, and I am small and defenceless, and so I must use the tools at my disposal to best my enemies instead. How would you feel if you were locked in battle with an orc, and I came and tapped you on the shoulder in the middle of things and told you you were doing it wrong? I nearly had them, before you all raced in. And I do appreciate you helping me, truly, but you do not have to needlessly put yourselves in danger when I know quite well what I am doing and how I am doing it!”
“You are under our protection -”
“Oh, don’t give me that rot, Thorin Oakenshield,” Bilbo snapped, anger flaring. “You don’t need or want to protect me any more than you have to.”
Thorin’s jaw hardened, and his eyes were dark as night. It was as though they were locked in combat, and the other dwarves around them were a silent, eager audience. Bilbo imagined the air crackling around them. If someone had lit a match between them at that exact moment, there might even have been an explosion.
“You are right. I do not,” Thorin said harshly. “You are lucky to have made it out of there.”
Bilbo’s voice cracked as he spoke, but he pushed on, adrenaline, embarrassment and fiercely lingering worry all working to keep him aflame.
“I’ve managed quite a long time in my life without you,” Bilbo said angrily, “and I can manage without you again.” He whirled round and stormed off in a righteous huff.
Anger prickled at his skin and the corners of his eyes infuriatingly. He pushed right past where Gandalf was leaning against his staff and waiting patiently for them to put themselves back together.
“Shouldn’t we be looking for the cave they crawled out of?” Bilbo asked through gritted teeth, marching off into the thicket of trees and straight towards his beloved, obedient sword.
Gandalf did not speak for a moment as he followed, but Bilbo could tell he was greatly amused, and the thought darkened his mood even further. He felt like a thundercloud walking around on legs. He supposed it matched the dismal weather.
“Indeed, my dear fellow. I see you are already leading the way. On we go!”
Bilbo took to riding at the front of the pack after that.
He knew this rather royally aggravated Thorin, and that his sudden protectiveness after spending so long content to blend in at the back would be irksome, but he found he did not much care. It calmed him, just as being able to feel for the hilt of Sting at his belt now calmed him; he’d spent eighty years with the little sword by his side, and even if he was no warrior, he felt better with than without it.
He would drift back every so often to wander next to the ones trailing at the end of the line, which was usually Oin or Bifur or Ori, and he’d spend the briskness of quiet mornings alongside them, asking about each of their lives, for he knew Ori was a scribe, and Oin a healer, and Bifur a toymaker.
A few times, he and Oin got to talking about the plants that grew high up in the Blue Mountains, and the differences in herbs between there and the Shire. Bilbo had quietly told him that when he was a very small child, Belladonna had always used a dwarvish recipe for soup with healing properties that she’d learnt when she was still a traveller, and Oin had smiled and told him that it was indeed a staple of dwarvish medicine, and that his mother had been blessed.
Once, he’d asked Bifur if he’d like to learn the language of the flowers that grew from the Shire.
“You cannot speak it, and it isn’t even really a language, if I’m being honest, but then we’d both know the meaning of something not written in words.”
Bifur had nodded, pleased, and pressed his fingers against his chest lightly. Bilbo had been touched by the gesture, and wished there was more vegetation growing around the outskirts of Erebor that he could have shown Bifur once they reached the Lonely Mountain.
Bilbo would always drift further up the line of ponies as the morning went on, sometimes riding in quiet companionship with Bombur, or watching Gloin as he regaled Fili and Kili with stories of their little cousin Gimli to much laughter, for he was back at home and seething that he’d missed out on the quest. Often he’d share a pipe or two with Bofur, and sometimes he’d even let the dwarf have a pinch of Old Toby instead of that awful acrid stuff the dwarves loved to smoke.
But by midday, he would make it back to the front of the Company and ride alongside or in front of Thorin, and often Balin and Dwalin as well.
Thorin would usually spend the rest of the day glowering darkly at him when he did this, but Bilbo made sure to ignore him. He could see in Thorin’s face that he could not argue with Bilbo’s desire to watch over them all, and even agreed with it, but that Bilbo including him in the circle of protection was making him murderous, not least because he now had Orcrist resting at his belt.
(The sight seemed more complete, somehow.)
The fear that had clutched coldly at his insides when he’d seen Kili dangling in the air like a strung-up bit of meat had shocked Bilbo. He hadn’t realised it consciously until that moment, but he could not even begin to bear parting with any of them again. Not Kili, not Bombur, not any one of them. He was sure it would drown him. He would have to do whatever his body and brain could manage to keep them from harm.
He would not be at peace until all thirteen of them were safe, he knew. Until they had their Mountain once again, and all of them had made it through what was still to come. All of them.
“You are getting in the way,” Thorin said in a low voice when Bilbo rode up to trot beside him.
“Good,” Bilbo replied. “Maybe when the orcs find us you’ll see that I do in fact know which end of a sword I’m supposed to be holding.”
“Very noble, Master Burglar, but must you ride in front of me?”
“We’re going the same way, aren’t we? Through the Hidden Valley, if I’m not mistaken.”
The lines of anger that streaked across Thorin’s face grew deeper, but his voice was cool and indifferent when he replied, “You and the wizard seem to think so, and I have not been able to change your minds.”
He was well aware Thorin thought of him as a thorn in his side, or a bothersome speck of dust floating around in his face, or an insect he couldn’t quite seem to swat away. But if Thorin thought Bilbo was going to defer to him after the complete mess he’d made of Bilbo's beautiful plan to draw the trolls out, he was even more blindly stubborn than Bilbo remembered.
And none of the other dwarves minded his traipsing back and forth, always eager for a chat or a song, so Bilbo continued to hover, and Thorin continued to scowl.
Notes:
meanings of the flowers in bilbo's garden (this will be a recurring theme):
poppies: peace in death, eternal sleep
salvia (blue): i am thinking of you, i miss you
rosemary: remembrance
gardenias: a secret love
hyacinth (purple): sorrow, forgiveness
red carnation: deep love, my poor heart aches
hyacinth (white): sending prayers to someone
lilac: moving on
butterfly weed: let me go
sweetpea: a blissful farewell
forget-me-nots: i will not ever forget you, do not forget me
salvia (red): forever minemy twitter if you need to find me!
Chapter 3: peace
Notes:
this chapter kicked my ass but i wrangled her into shape eventually (with the help of moonyism as per). chapter title comes from the song “peace” by taylor swift (the lyrics of which i seriously debated naming this fic after). enjoy!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
It wasn’t long before the lands that stretched out before them grew flatter and drier, and the paths became speckled with little white stones that glowed in the moonlight and basked in the warm summer sun.
All distinctive signs of Elves, Bilbo realised. They’d almost reached Rivendell; he’d felt it in the air once they’d crossed over the border of the Wildlands and into the Hidden Valley.
The Company were almost at the Ford of Bruinen when the grumbling of the dwarves started to get louder and longer, and Bilbo knew that his friends had realised their proximity, too.
(He tried not to take too much notice of their utter disdain of a place he had so loved. He knew they meant no harm.)
“Looks very quaint,” Nori said shrewdly once they'd finished the trek up the long and winding road, eyeing the smooth walls in the distance that looked so delicate they could have been blown over with one breath. A chorus of assenting grunts rang through the party.
“Looking at it too long hurts my eyes,” Kili agreed loftily, haughty look on his face and his chin tilted upward. Myrtle tossed her hair back and whinnied, stamping a hoof on the ground.
“You and me both, girl,” Bilbo said quietly. He wouldn’t begrudge them their feelings, but Bilbo was glad that at the very least it was not Thranduil who lived in the Valley of Imladris; things could have gone pear-shaped rather quickly, and then he wouldn’t have gotten to enjoy his lovely armchair by Elrond’s fire.
(Bilbo, of course, did not realise until later that evening that because of the whole slipping-back-through-time-somehow business, this armchair was nowhere to be found because he himself had not yet placed it there, and he had to compose himself very quickly so he didn't kick up a great fuss.)
Though he’d made the choice to leave it behind, Rivendell had been Bilbo’s home in the latter years, when his body had started to fail and he could no longer withstand the grating gazes of every hobbit in the Shire. To breathe the air that whispered through the leaves above them again, and to watch the sky break over the glittering-white rooftops of the Last Homely House, brought Bilbo a renewed calm he had not realised until then he’d been in need of, and he felt swiftly reassured that he was on the right path.
The sun and moon were crossing their paths at dusk when the Company reached the bridge across the Hidden Valley and gazed more closely upon the house of Elrond. In the distance, Bilbo could see the tall, graceful figures of Elves descending the stairs to meet them, robes swirling at their feet.
At once, the dwarves seemed to converge around each other in a ring, hands reaching without thinking for weapons and dark looks on their faces, shielding one another with their bodies. Any trace of the joking and jibing from earlier had vanished.
“Stay sharp,” Bilbo heard Thorin mutter to some of the others behind him, and he let out an irritated huff, sending the hair in front of his eyes fluttering.
If there was one thing about the Shire he was glad of, it was that hobbits had made no enemies, and that they were wary of all other peoples in the world equally. To do otherwise was bothersome beyond belief, and to be amongst others that held such contempt for each other rather felt like Bilbo had walked into his own home to find someone had trod mud all through the carpet. The dwarves were very well just lucky he already liked them so much, and the Elves were fortunate they were so unceasingly polite.
(Bilbo knew in his heart they had their reasons to be wary, which made holding onto his annoyance all the more difficult. He knew their usual relationships with outsiders; he’d seen and heard tell of them himself. He just wished he could explain that it was Elrond, who'd befriended dwarves before, and who would never, ever harm them, and if they could all just settle down a little, it would make things much easier.)
It was Elrond who came to greet them, along with Lindir and an exceedingly graceful blond fellow Bilbo thought might have been called Glorfindel. Loud, renewed grumbling erupted behind him when Gandalf began to converse with Elrond in Sindarin, and Bilbo very maturely did not roll his eyes when they ceased immediately following the offer of food.
“It is my hope that you will all feel welcome here for as long as you may care to stay,” Elrond Halfelven called. His eyes swept over each of them, and over Bilbo most especially, who forced himself to keep his eyes up and his breathing even. Gandalf thanked Elrond generously, craftily concealing Thorin’s scowl with his own body, and soon the three Elves turned to lead them away.
It was a distinctly strange feeling to Bilbo, as the group made their way up the steps, having to pretend like he didn’t know all of it like the back of his hand, like he hadn’t befriended some of the very Elves who greeted them years beforehand. He placed himself deliberately toward the back of the pack, out of any lines of questioning or curiosity, and simply trailed along after them all to gaze out at the Valley of Imladris.
There were lush trees of evergreen and silver-white waterfalls cascading like pearls down the walls of rock lining the valley, and the light of the fading sun blending with the moon in the sky washed all around it in a rosy red-gold. It was nothing short of breathtaking. It had always been that way, for Bilbo, and he knew that the picture of Rivendell resting on the edges of the valley, as if placed there by beings older than time itself, would linger steadfast in his memories for as long as he lived.
Lindir and possibly-Glorfindel departed, and they were soon being led by two unfamiliar Elves in long robes down the winding paths of the Elven realm when Balin fell back into step beside him and said, “You look as if you’ve seen all the treasures of the world at once, laddie.”
“Oh, Balin, don’t pretend like you’re not a little impressed by all this!” Bilbo watched Balin chuckle beside him, then tilted his head up to look at the last rays of daylight filtering in, casting golden shadows against the wall opposite them. “It’s like magic.” Balin smiled kindly at him.
“I wish you could have seen the Mountain in its prime,” he said, and Bilbo could hear how ancient the homesickness was in his voice, how tethered he was to the memory of Erebor and its warm marble halls. Balin nodded towards the other dwarves in front of them, some of them knocking into each other and cracking jokes, some silent as stone and watching the Elves in front of them warily. “I wish they had all seen it. There was nothing like to it in the world. There is nothing at all like the Dwarf Kingdoms in any other places, and most of all the ones we have lost, but Erebor in the height of her glory was grand beyond measure.”
“It sounds beautiful,” Bilbo said gently.
Balin turned to look behind them, to where Elrond was taking long, slow strides and speaking with Gandalf in low voices, and then looked back at Bilbo, the white in his hair and beard catching the shine of the rising moonlight.
“Aye. Thorin misses it more than anything, and I cannot forsake him that. It is written into his very blood. I would be a traitor and a fool if I had not accompanied him on this quest.”
“Are you and he close?” Bilbo asked softly.
Balin smiled. “I’ve known him almost all my life, and he’s known Dwalin since he was a wee lad. Thorin has always been my friend before he is my King, and he will always be both.” A sadness crept into his eyes, suddenly, dimming them. “I know it seems as though he’s hard on you, Bilbo, but -”
“Oh, please don’t, Balin!” Bilbo cried. He ducked his head. “I don’t mind. I know it may not appear that way, but - I do understand. It doesn't bother me.” He did not miss the doubtful look Balin gave him.
“I know you all can have a hard time with outsiders. Hobbits are like that, too,” he explained. “We keep to our own, and we can be downright sceptical and unkind, if any Elves or Men or dwarves chance across our path. Even Shire-hobbits find the Breelanders strange for cohabiting with the Big Folk.” And their pipeweed was truly atrocious.
“As for me, though," Bilbo said, "I don’t feel I’m much like anyone else in Hobbiton, or even the Westfarthing. I was once, and I’m sure I would have been horrified by you all charging headlong into my house and ransacking my cupboards, but I gave up on that a long time ago.” He could feel himself smiling, and he turned his face away from Balin, always trying to hide the fondness that burst from him at the sight of them. “I care much more now for comfort than politeness, and I don’t mind if that makes me the oddest hobbit in all the Shire.”
Bilbo did not accompany Balin or Thorin or Gandalf to read the moon-runes that night. He didn’t need to; he knew them well enough he could have recited them from memory, and he did not wish to give Thorin a reason to distrust him even more. Instead, he took to weaving and wandering around the halls of Rivendell and reminiscing with a clarity his mind hadn’t had when he’d visited them last.
It was more of a bittersweet experience than he had expected. Instead of seeing places where he’d smiled or feasted with friends or where he’d gone on walks in the gardens, Bilbo found himself recognising spot after spot where he remembered falling asleep, or waking up from a nap, or closing his eyes and having to shake his greying head a little to recall what it was he’d just forgotten. He was realising with an almost overwhelming amount of shame what his life had truly been like after relinquishing… relinquishing Isildur’s Bane.
I am not sure if it was good for my heart, he thought, for me to stay here so long.
Not for as long as he had, at least. Rivendell’s valleys and vast halls had been love at first sight the moment Bilbo had first crested its hill, and he had found comfort nowhere in the world more than he had here, with the Elves and their endless music. But the longer he’d remained here at the end of his life, the more it had felt like a daydream, a blur that shifted and blew in the wind and never quite sharpened.
Dinner that night, however, was as outrageous an affair as always. Lettuce leaves and bits of bread flew every which way over their heads, and burgundy elfwine slopped over the sides of cups, and there was much thumping and thudding on the tops of all the tables. Bilbo astutely kept his manners and politely nibbled on all the dishes they’d been offered, but he chuckled along with everyone else at the boisterousness of the dwarves - and really, it was awfully amusing how startled all of the Elves looked.
Too, Bilbo was thoroughly enjoying the chance to eat a full, respectable, hobbit-sized meal for once, and was not going to pass up any sort of reprieve from their travelling rations (as grateful as he was for all of Bombur’s efforts).
Bilbo realised after he’d reached back to fill his plate for a fourth time and caught a couple of wayward glances that he was most probably drawing attention to another one of his oddities. In his defence, however, and the defence of his home, none of them knew it was odd outside the Shire to eat seven square meals a day, and Bilbo still rather thought the oddity lay on the rest of Middle-Earth, not on hobbits.
“You sure can put some food away, Master Baggins!” Kili called just as Bilbo was swiping at a bit of cranberry sauce with his thumb to stick into his mouth. Bilbo smiled and popped a couple more walnuts in for good measure, chewing them on one side.
“And proudly, Kili! How is anyone to know if you’ve enjoyed your meal if you don’t look it by the end?”
Their faces at that seemed a little blank - aside from Dwalin’s, who muttered out a snide, “Don’t know how you enjoyed that meal” - and in the silence Bilbo remembered another of the complexities he knew lay between hobbits and dwarves.
It was a fact that dwarves ate for survival. Their portions were quite small when compared to their sturdiness and strength, and their food was colourless and strict and made for filling rather than for enjoying. They lived a life of necessity borne from long years of struggle through the harsh seasons of Middle-Earth.
Hobbits, however, ate for joy. Their meals were made of love and life, and every vegetable and fruit and piece of game was tended with nothing but care. Meals were for sharing, and eating a belly’s worth of food could only ever make one healthier, even if you grew wider than you did tall.
Bilbo looked at them all dearly, and decided he’d lost all care for propriety a long time ago.
“You know, if you were all hobbits, my mother would have sat you down and tied you to the table until you had at least three good meals in you. Proper meals, mind, not any of that travelling jerky or soup.”
“Or lettuce leaves?” Ori asked. Bilbo rolled his eyes fondly.
“When we take back Erebor,” he said, “I promise I’ll make you all the grandest feast that has ever been in or outside the Shire!”
His outburst was met with a pleased sort of bemusement from them all. “You have already made us a feast, Mr Bilbo,” Gloin said. “Two, in fact.” Bilbo wrinkled his nose.
“Well, I am a Took as well as a Baggins, Master Gloin, and Tooks believe that there are more than a few occasions where you can be happy, and if good healthy eating is what brings that to a person, then I don’t see any problem. Cooking for you all is how I feel I can best - ah, show my affection.”
He coughed into the silence. What a terribly awkward finish. He floundered, hastily trying to continue.
“What I mean is that I suppose we show our care in different ways than others. A warm meal all together, and seeing the flowers dance in the fields, and a silly chat about absolutely nothing of importance with a friendly face… those things are what bring hobbits together. Although,” he laughed tightly, refusing to let his smile drop, “I must confess, I’ve never been quite as good at that last part.”
“What are you talking about?” chimed Fili in surprise. “Bilbo, you’re the chattiest creature any of us have ever met. You make great conversation!”
Bilbo’s mouth pulled then into a thin line. “Not according to hobbits, I don't,” he said wryly. “I - well, I am seen as standoffish, among them. I am not a socialite, and I don’t care to associate with people whom I don’t like, which I’m a little ashamed to say is most people. And I have never quite gotten the gift of the gab, as they see it in the Shire. Most hobbits spend their days enjoying the simplest things, but it means that quite a lot of the time, there is nothing to do except talk about what other people are doing. There’s a very fine art to it, and I am most certainly no artist.”
“So, as an example, you might hear from your next-door neighbour who was told by her cousin that lives over the Hill and across the Water who saw it happening in someone’s field one day that Daisy Baggins and Griffo Boffin had begun an understanding with each other, even though Daisy was far too young for him and in fact her parents had gotten into a spot of grief a few years prior when Dudo Baggins had kissed Gerda Bolger instead of his wife Paisley Proudfoot at the Midsummer’s Party, and then Paisley had gone on to have an affair with the Master of Buckland’s brother right afterwards and that’s how they’d ended up with Daisy in the first place!”
Bilbo finished his tirade and was met with thirteen nonplussed faces staring back at him. He solidified the point by waving his arms.
“You see what I mean! It’s all sticky-beaking nonsense, and most of them already think I’m a few marbles short of a bag, never mind the fact that I refuse to talk to them if I don’t want to.” He sniffed importantly. “Nasty, uncomfortable business, if you ask me. But anyhow - the point I am trying to make is, it took me quite a while to realise I was never made for the ins and outs of conversation in the Shire, so I like to cook for my friends instead. And - well, I suppose that is now… all of you.”
It became very quickly apparent to Bilbo that the silence had stretched on for far longer than it should have, and that he’d filled it with nothing but drivel about nonsense and the petty Shire squabbles he loathed. He did not look in any of the dwarves’ eyes, and determinedly fixed his own somewhere in the middle-distance, feeling his cheeks ripen red as raspberries.
He wished pitifully that he could withhold himself from rambling so very much, but it was them, and he could not help it.
“You are a kind, strange little fellow, Master Baggins,” someone spoke up suddenly. It was Balin, and he was smiling, his eyes twinkling in that way Balin had of somehow always seeming to know more than he let on. “I cannot imagine that any other hobbit we brought along on our journey would have been quite like you.”
The tips of Bilbo’s ears were still aflame, but his heart softened, and he blinked. Across the table, Bofur threw one of the dainty bread-rolls at him. Bilbo picked it up and stuffed it in his mouth cheekily, smiling from ear to ear.
Towards the end of their fortnight-long respite in Rivendell (one week and five days, when being exact), the sun was just starting to float through mid-afternoon, and Bilbo’s eyes were slowly lulling into their usual post-lunchtime doze, when he was approached directly by Elrond Peredhel.
He stood at once, immediately feeling a little silly, but holding his ground against the way his dwarves were all looking on nosily, in the midst of wringing out and rebraiding their damp hair after gallivanting in the Elves’ fountains. Kili had the gall to raise an eyebrow at him, and Bilbo indignantly scrunched up his nose in response. Bofur snorted.
Gandalf, who had been standing against the balcony with the wind blowing through his beard, made to move towards Elrond, but Elrond held up a hand to still him. His eyes were fixed with intrigue on Bilbo, though outwardly he ever showed nothing but calm.
“I would like to speak with the halfling alone, if I may,” he said, gazing at Bilbo a moment longer, before turning to look at Gandalf, who was leaning on his staff with both hands and tilting the brim of his hat upwards. The wizard pushed his lips together so they wrinkled; something Bilbo had noticed after so many years that he especially liked to do when he felt vexed, and Bilbo’s mouth twitched very slightly.
“With Bilbo?” Gandalf said, something not quite a question in his voice. Elrond inclined his head slowly.
“It will not take long, and Mr Baggins can tell me your tale,” he continued. He turned once again to watch Bilbo with that penetrating gaze. “It is clear to me he has travelled a very long way.”
Bilbo’s heart sped at once up into his throat and then collapsed down somewhere among his intestines.
Well, it really was only a matter of time.
He could see Thorin in the corner watching him warily, as always. Their eyes met only briefly: one set wide, one set narrowed, and Bilbo looked away. He swallowed hard, then smiled quickly without showing any teeth.
“Of course, my lord Elrond,” Bilbo said. He glanced over at Gandalf’s pursed expression, then around at the dwarves leaning in now to watch, both curiosity and suspicion painting their faces; Fili, Kili, Dwalin, Gloin. “I’d love to visit the library as well, if I may? I’ve heard from - ah, others - that your books are glorious.”
Elrond smiled, nodded once more, and swept from the room, his hands clasped in front of him and hidden by the fall of his elven robes.
They wandered through the library in tense silence, Bilbo anxiously touching at the spines of all the books he had loved over the years, towards the end of his life, trying to ground himself. None of them were dusty. Bilbo didn’t know if it was because the elves were so well-read, because they were such avid cleaners, or because a magic lay over the room that protected everything within. He had a sneaking suspicion it was all three.
It was Bilbo who broke the silence first, unable to bear it a moment longer.
“What is it exactly that you know, Elrond?”
The Elf looked down at him, then around the room, before pushing open the pair of doors nearest to them and indicating that Bilbo should follow.
They strode out into a sunroom with curved windows and gaps in the butter-white walls where the smell of flowers was drifting in. The light in here was softer, more yellow, and it made Bilbo think of marmalade on toast, apricots and peaches. Yellow peonies.
“We have met elsewhere, Bilbo Baggins,” Elrond said, peering down at him with that same composure he’d kept in all the days Bilbo had known him. The darkness of his hair was pulled back in a high arc from his forehead. “Though it has not yet happened here.”
Bilbo bowed his head. There wasn’t any point in denying it. Elrond possessed sight further than those of them who were mortal, and even than those who lived forever. If there was anyone in Middle Earth who could have seen the truth of Bilbo’s mind and memories, he should've guessed it would have been him, descendant of Númenor and of the High Elves, bearer of one of the Three, father to Arwen Evenstar. There was no path out of this but the one that lay forward.
“Yes.” Bilbo looked up and saw that calm coolness still there. He smiled a little crookedly. “We were great friends, too; I hope you saw that in your foresight. You have been very kind to me, Elrond. I owe you a great deal.”
With a grave smile, Elrond said, “And I, too, owe you and your kin, I think."
With no small amount of horror, Bilbo felt his smile begin to wobble.
Oh, Frodo.
The feeling only worsened when a crease appeared across Elrond’s forehead, and he leant a little closer to Bilbo, having to bend his back to reach down to Bilbo’s height. The closeness stung at Bilbo’s skin. He could not even hold Elrond’s gaze.
“Something troubles you,” Elrond said quietly.
Any of Bilbo’s attempts at maintaining a calm demeanour dropped, and he strode over to the window to escape it, knowing more so than hearing that Elrond followed. His thoughts were very rapidly spiralling downwards, and the sting became sharper and sharper.
“You know I am from the past?” he asked plainly, without beating around the bush, and sensed Elrond nod behind him.
“Though for us, you have passed through time not yet lived.”
Bilbo tugged at the bottom of his waistcoat, tilted his head sideways for a beat, and then opened his mouth.
“And do you know what it is that happened before I came here?” he asked, turning to face the Elf stiffly, his chin set so it did not tremble. Elrond’s expression remained astoundingly neutral.
“Not all of it is clear; that is not how foresight is given to those of us who possess it,” he said. “But yes, Bilbo Baggins. I have seen glimpses of what you and your nephew will bear. Who shall fall in the war. Who shall rise from the ashes.” His eyes seemed to glance back towards the door, and Bilbo startled at the sudden realisation that Aragorn son of Arathorn had grown up in Elrond’s home - would be living here now.
The thought was utterly bizarre. Little King Elessar. Little Estel, rushing around the woods with a giddy ten-year-old smile. Chief of the Dúnedain indeed.
I wonder what the Ranger looks like with missing front teeth.
He turned back to the window, stepping up onto the ledge against the wall and rising on his toes to look out at the world beyond. He folded his arms and rested them atop the windowsill.
Bilbo imagined then Frodo’s wonder, seeing it for the first time, how he’d have looked up at the magic of the trees, and a dreadful lump caught in his throat.
“I am thankful that I have been given a chance to come back to the ones I love,” Bilbo said softly, “thankful beyond all explanation, and I do not wish at all to be anywhere other than here, but… I cannot help but wonder if I deserve it, or if I should have stayed behind to care for Frodo as he cared for me.”
He had been thinking it for a while, in the smallest corners of his mind, and the thought had become louder and larger with every eastward step he took. He almost wondered if saying the words aloud would undo the spell. Maybe even the feeling of doubt itself that he’d done the right thing would be enough to revoke Bilbo's second chance.
“I was losing myself by the end, Elrond. My mind would escape from me more often than not. I could barely use my body. All my age had caught up to me at once, I think, and it did not let me tend to him the way I should have after he came back. But I am in this body again, and I feel every morsel of guilt and anguish that I could not when my mind was gone, and I remember the dreadful way he was, so I cannot help but feel that it is not fair so heavy a burden was placed on such a gentle soul when it was I who brought the burden to light.”
Elrond looked down at him, not unkindly.
“It is a miracle you have been given, not one that you must earn through your actions. Though I do not think anyone would argue that it is one you do not deserve.”
Bilbo laughed dryly, not smiling. “But why me?” he said, more to himself than his companion. “Why me? I thought about it - for so many years I thought about what it would be like if I could - but it was him who lost everything!”
He let his head fall forwards and pressed his forehead against his arms. “I am just one silly old hobbit, and my Frodo-lad saved Middle-Earth, and they gave me my life back instead of giving him his. You remember, Elrond. You must have seen the way he was on that ship. I have - I’ve never seen him like that. That thing utterly destroyed him, and I gave it to him.”
That thing. Isildur’s Bane. The dreaded thing, the looming danger on the horizon, the gold that crept at Bilbo’s shoulders and raked all through his mind.
The One Ring, the Ruling Ring, waiting in the mountains for him to claim it.
How could he in good conscience let Frodo go through that again? Bilbo felt torn in two, like he was crawling towards the only thing he’d ever wanted, had yearned for with all his heart, and yet it was like he was trodding on the shoulders of his dear boy. Bilbo could hear him on the wind the further east they went.
Where are you, Bilbo? Why do you look ahead?
And when he turned back, it became Thorin’s murmur, the rumble of twelve other voices.
Where are you, Bilbo? Why do you look behind?
“I thought that coming here," he said, "meant that my pain would leave me be. I thought it was to bring me peace. That is what they told me.”
Elrond’s voice was steady as he spoke to Bilbo. “There is more complexity to peace than many with finite lifespans truly understand. You must make peace also with the things that have happened to you. The things you have or have not done.”
The last sentence slammed into Bilbo like a punch to the stomach.
He hadn’t done anything at all, had he? He’d unearthed the source of all evil in the world and delivered it with his nephew to where the teeth of Death could snap at him.
He had destroyed his own flesh and blood.
So much for your protection, then, wasn’t it, Mad Old Baggins?
Bilbo lifted his head, and turned once more, unable to even bring himself to look out the window anymore. His blurring eyes wouldn’t adjust to the light.
“Your life was tampered with, and the Dark Lord sought to hurt and warp you while you were in possession of the One Ring," Elrond said calmly. "You aged irregularly. Your body and mind were dangerously stretched out, and your life was touched by its power, no matter how little you used it by the end. You may not have been scarred by his Ring in the way your nephew was, for his wounds ran much deeper than almost all others in Middle-Earth, and he carried a weight heavier than all of us will ever know. But you bear the scars nonetheless.”
“He should not have had to carry it!" Bilbo burst out angrily. "Why is it that I have been given this life to live again, when he only got to live half of one before I stole the rest from him? I have the gift of my heart given back to me beyond the grave itself, a wonder I could have never dreamed of, and yet it is Frodo who has had to pay the price!”
Elrond, though benevolent and kind, had never been the most gentle person Bilbo had met, but there was sorrow in his face, and Bilbo had to look away. His eyes were hot, the skin around them itching with every built-up, unshed feeling in his body, and he stubbornly ignored all of it.
“It was Mithrandir who explained this to you, was it not? You and Frodo Baggins have both been in the clutches of great evil, and both of you were instrumental in its destruction. His peace will come to him, but your peace is here, and so you have been brought to find it instead.”
He folded the edge of his cloak down, and rose to his full height once more, looking down at Bilbo. “There were those of the Elder Days who made the choice you also have made, Bilbo Baggins. Those offered a life of healing from their hurt in the Undying Lands, but who instead chose to stay, and to remember. Those who would rather a mortal death with their loved ones returned to them than to live in bliss but have forgotten.”
Elrond had never looked so intensely at Bilbo as he did at that moment, and he spoke again. “It is better that he forget. The one he loves will follow him, when it is time, into the West. But the one you love was taken from you. It is better for you to remember.”
If only Bilbo could have seen Frodo again, after the ship. Just to say goodbye to him. Just to explain, in his right mind, all that he was sorry for, and all that he hoped for Frodo, and all that he wished he could have given him. Just to tell him where he was going.
Elrond reached over Bilbo’s head and pressed a hand against the window so it opened outward and let the afternoon breeze in. They could see the leaves moving in the tallest trees, the pollen floating gently past. He pulled his hand away.
“You are the first and only bearer to let go of the Ring of your own will,” he said. “It does not touch you anymore. Now you must find all the years that you lost to it.”
Bilbo hoped that wherever Frodo was, far in the West and away from him, that he had his toes in the grass, and that he was smiling.
It was much later when Bilbo Baggins was perched on the uppermost ramparts of the Last Homely House of Elrond Halfelven, his bare feet dangling over the side of the ledge and brushing against the breeze. His silhouette fell like a painting against the sky, the archway behind him outlined in shadow; a dark and lonely figure sitting on the floor and illuminated in the deep midnight-blue that crested the hours between very late and very early. Tiny stars were scattered across the horizon like faraway jewels.
The dinner festivities that night had long settled, and he imagined that everyone else was now sleeping soundly in the decadent halls below him, mouths open and snoring something awful the way they always did.
Bilbo was so entirely lost in his own thoughts beneath the never-ending sky that footsteps approached him closely before he heard them at all.
“You seem to enjoy it here, Master Baggins,” the low voice murmured. He did not phrase it as a compliment.
And of course it was Thorin; nobody else other than the two of them was ridiculous enough to be awake at this hour, and nobody else spoke with that formidable tone, rough and yet resounding throughout all the valley. It seemed that Thorin could not leave Bilbo well enough alone, in either death or in life.
Bilbo sighed softly and looked down into the cleft far below.
“I do not have the same problem with our hosts that you all do, so yes, I like it here very much. The days are content. And the library is beautiful.”
“Is that what you wish for your life?" Thorin questioned. "To find peace and settle down with your books?”
He hadn’t spoken altogether mockingly, but Bilbo could feel the disdain that simmered in every word; the belief that a hobbit from somewhere as quaint as the Shire could never understand what true hardship was, and that he had nothing to run from.
“Would it be so bad if it was?” Bilbo asked simply, turning his head to the side and just catching the outline of Thorin at the edge of his vision.
There wasn’t any need to be rude. Bilbo knew it was a tall ask in present company, but really.
“I think,” said Thorin lowly, that same indifference in his voice, and a distant pang ran through Bilbo at how far from warmth it still was, “that if you are under the impression you will find such contentment where we are headed, you are sorely mistaken.” Bilbo bristled at once.
“Well, I think that’s a very presumptuous thing for you to say, and that you don’t know me half as well as you think you do, Master Oakenshield.” He stood and turned around properly, and Thorin was standing across from him, arms folded against his broad chest so it was as though he’d been shaped from cold marble. His cheekbones gleamed in the washed-out starlight.
“I am not wrong in knowing that you are a creature of comfort, Master Baggins.”
“And what is that supposed to mean?” Bilbo countered crossly. “Softness doesn't have anything to do with weakness, and I'll thank you not to imply that it does.” He tilted his head and looked up into the coolness of Thorin’s face, eyebrows furrowing.
Where are you in there, dear heart? Why won’t you open your eyes?
He’d known, of course he’d known, what Thorin would be like at first. He’d counted on it. Bilbo knew with absolute certainty that he would not in a thousand ages have been able to handle Thorin Oakenshield as he was by the end at their second first-meeting.
And yet he could not untangle the blackness in his mind at the thought that still he had to wait for his heart to come home. To be confronted with him so closely pulled at the painful freshness of Bilbo’s wounds, and he clenched his jaw against the sudden pressure in his own head. All of Elrond’s whispers of pain and of tragedy without cause were still echoing in his mind. The world was becoming muffled.
And something else the Elf had said to him, too; Bilbo folded in on himself at the window with his head bowed and throat constricted, Elrond standing tall beside him, cloaked in pale white and gold and his head aloft in that slow, regal way.
“I worry that you feel this guilt for your nephew so potently because your mind has not yet accepted that you are with your dwarf again. Your guilt that you could not save either of them is one and the same, and you are substituting one with the other.”
“I’m not quite sure it matters when the guilt is still here," Bilbo had replied.
Elrond had looked at him almost kindly, then, far too kindly for someone whom he did not yet know.
“It is not a detriment to feel regret or despair, Master Baggins. It is that which makes up the gift of mortality. But you have not reconciled with the losses you have suffered in their entirety, and it will do you more hurt than help if you continue on this way. The mourning you feel is not for this lifetime.”
Bilbo had laughed wetly, thanked Elrond for his guidance, and left to wander up here and look at the sky. He hadn’t moved since that afternoon.
Thorin’s face in front of him was beginning to blur, the lines of it hazy and indistinct, and he might have been saying something, still, but Bilbo could not hear anything at all over all the cotton wool in his ears and the sudden rushing wind.
He could see somewhere a little boy with tangled curls, and a stone statue carved into a mountainside, and a weary thing with tired eyelids and a scar on his shoulder and neck, and a figure fallen in battle, too delicate against the jut of the icy cliff with his hair fanned out and a ribbon of scarlet trailing out from underneath him.
Why won’t you open your eyes?
Where are you, dear heart?
Where are you?
(I’ve lost you, I’ve lost you, I’ve lost you, I’m sailing, I’m floating, I’m falling, I -)
Then there was rough skin against his fingertips, not like it had always seemed in his dreams, gentle and soft and far away. There were lines on the face in front of him, and the skin was worn and flecked with dirt from their time on the road. It dimpled beneath Bilbo's fingers.
The cloudiness slowly lifted from Bilbo’s eyes, and he saw that he was touching a faintly trembling hand to the side of Thorin’s face, right against his temple, and so gently he wasn’t even sure Thorin was able to feel it. The tips of his fingers slid ever so slightly into the darkly peppered hair just above his ear, and after a moment, he could feel the dull thud of Thorin’s heartbeat telling Bilbo he was alive.
Not lost. Not the visions of an elderly hobbit losing his clutches on memories. Thorin truly was alive. He could feel it, in the rhythmic pulse against his temple, and see it in his eyes, and watch it in the steady rise and fall of his chest, standing closer to the bearer of his heart than he’d been able to in eighty long years.
A tear slipped down Bilbo's cheek. He grit his teeth and tried in vain to keep himself together.
“Sorry - allergies, sometimes, I - Fili and Kili might have - well, anyway, they make my eyes water, you know. Don’t - don’t think anything of it. It’s quite manageable.” He did not let himself wipe the tear away, and the night air let it grow cold on his cheek.
Thorin did not speak for a long time, and was instead deathly silent. His eyes betrayed no emotion at all.
That was, if he was even feeling any emotion at Bilbo’s total lack of self-control. He must have thought Bilbo a soft, pathetic little creature, crying all alone up on the ramparts instead of getting a good night’s rest like a sensible person. Bilbo could almost see him in that moment wondering why they’d brought someone who so clearly could not brave the wild without needing so much as a handkerchief.
Eventually, and with what seemed like gargantuan effort, he said, “I suggest you try and keep that under control, Master Burglar." Bilbo dropped his gaze, shame making his face startlingly warm.
“It was not my intention to argue with you,” he said awkwardly. A silver-brown lock of hair crept in between Bilbo’s index and middle fingers, and he absent-mindedly let himself sweep it up and back from Thorin’s face.
Thorin did not reply.
It took Bilbo several moments to realise that he’d been holding his breath. It took him several moments longer to realise that he was touching Thorin’s face. That he was still touching Thorin’s face.
He yanked his fingers back like they’d brushed hot pokers and clutched at them in horror.
“Oh, dear me, I’m so sorry! I’m sorry, I -” Oh, hell and horrors - “we hobbits can be very touchy, and I quite lost my head there - lost in my own thoughts and forgot my place!” Had he so forgotten the sensation of feeling? It felt as though all the blood in Bilbo's body had migrated to his face. “I’m - I’m sorry.”
His ears glowed hot with embarrassment. He knew he hadn’t done himself any favours, and that he’d probably peeled back what little faith their conversation had managed to scrounge up in Thorin, but what was done was done.
Thorin was alive, and he would not die again under Bilbo’s watch. Not until he was old and white-haired and bending sharply at the spine with a walking stick. It was high time Bilbo pulled himself together.
“You should not apologise so much,” Thorin said quietly. His voice was a river; Bilbo could hear the way it dragged upon the rocks.
“I don’t do it to offend you,” Bilbo said, still frazzled, “it’s just what I’ve been taught.” He looked up at Thorin’s indecipherable gaze. “Perhaps you were not taught the same.”
An imperceptible change came over Thorin’s face for the slightest of seconds before it shuttered out. He watched Bilbo with that dark expression for a moment longer, and Bilbo watched him back, standing his ground even while his cheeks still burned red-hot. The air was still, and clouds were starting to stretch over the moon.
Thorin walked away.
Bilbo was beyond mortified by his behaviour the next day. Touching at Thorin’s face like some hobbit lass of twenty five, and then crying on top of it all. He was terribly worried that all of it would finally be seen as a real reason for Thorin to put his foot down, to remove Bilbo’s whole part in this quest and send him on his way home.
(Not that Bilbo would go, of course. He’d follow them through the bushes the whole sorry way to Erebor, if he had to. Heaven knew his dwarves would need him one way or another, and he wasn’t going to let them wander off into the wilderness without even a burglar to watch over them.)
But Thorin did nothing, and actually, he seemed to be remarkably content with pretending their disastrous encounter up on the ramparts had never happened at all. He did not seek Bilbo out, preferring to stay away from him with the same degree of reticence he’d kept since they’d set out from Bag End, and Bilbo was glad for it.
Speaking with Elrond had loosened his tongue far too much, and he’d entirely lost his head trying to make sure that he was really real, that he was really there. It had badly shocked him, to find someone else who had known the truth, and he’d been sure the whole conversation that he'd finally fallen into total madness in his decrepit state.
But in the sun-warm light of morning, with a fresh mind and a fresh heart, Bilbo knew now that he had not dreamt up what was happening around him. He had been given a true blessing, and although he rather felt his actions meant he didn’t deserve it, the moments he was living again were surely sacred.
He did not need a pulse to know Thorin was alive when Bilbo could feel the beat of his own heart firm inside his chest. He did not need to check and check and check when the blue of those eyes were right in front of him, distant as they had ever been but still bright in the depths of his unflinching face. And it was pointless to sit and mope around waiting for Thorin’s wariness and dismissal to mellow when Bilbo knew quite well when and where that was going to happen. I have missed him every day for a lifetime, so what is a few more?
The guilt he carried would still sit in the pit of his stomach, but one day Bilbo would unravel it, and find the peace he sought. For Frodo, and the Company, and for the bitter tang that had come with their victory the first time around, after all that they had lost. His heart would learn to settle yet, and for now, the tears would have to stay.
Notes:
i'm so sorry this took a little while and that it's a bit shorter than the others, but i'm hoping to have the next chapter out a little sooner to make up for it! we will be partying with gollum and the occasional action sequence next chapter so everyone get super duper excited
as always, my twitter!
Chapter 4: shrike
Notes:
thank you once again moonyism for helping me edit this chapter (which is the longest so far!)
title comes from the song "shrike" by hozier and is the most bilbo song in all the world ever
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Every step became harder once they reached the mountain range. Bilbo had not expected it.
They were well on their way to the High Pass, the broad shoulders of the mountains looming ever nearer, their crests tipped with snow that dripped downward on all sides and made the air chill even in the middle of June.
But the lightness in his chest and his mind had slowly dwindled since they’d left Rivendell, and now it was all but gone as they came closer and closer to the cliff-drops and tunnels, and to the eerie underground lake in the cavern that had haunted Bilbo’s dreams for so many years.
Bilbo knew he was becoming jumpy, and that it was starting to worry some of his companions as they walked on. He would startle at small noises in the mountains and along the rock, and his blossoming habit of turning to check behind them for danger was becoming irksome to everybody, especially those who had walked this track before. He could not seem to keep up his usual cheer any longer, and he began to talk less and less, all the while treading crookedly on to perils he could see no escape from and had to bear anyway.
It was a hard thing, that he and his dwarves had to beat and suffer through so much danger before they could finally close their eyes and rest their heads. There were stone giants to flee from and goblins to skirt around and great evils to steal from under the nose of creatures that crept in the dark.
Perhaps it was his penance for what he had done to Frodo.
Bilbo had tried with all his might to keep pushing the thought from his mind, to wait until they were out of danger, until he could have a moment’s rest, but the walls of the river had burst, and it was all he could do to keep them at bay.
It was like an ache in his side, the awareness of what he had truly put Frodo through in the finding of the Ring. It had not left his mind since they departed from Rivendell; since they’d set out from Bag End, even. It tore at every step he took along the ragged mountainside, and often he would be left quietly gasping back sobs, thinking of his little boy in Bag End with his wide eyes and mop of tangled hair, and thinking of how it was entirely because of him Frodo had had to learn words like fear and starvation and pain.
And then Fili or Kili would spot him at the back of the line, and playfully call out, “Allergies again, Master Baggins?” And Bilbo would have to crush down his guilt and wipe his nose and smile, and silently carry the ache again, until the next time he looked up to the mountain peaks and pictured instead a ring of scalding fire at the top.
(If he had just left it alone. If he had just kept his hands to himself. If. If. If.)
It hadn’t mattered what he’d said to Elrond, in the small room in Rivendell. He could not push his guilt aside when it hung so heavily like a black cloud over the mountains. He had become so accustomed to missing all of his loved ones since before he was even grown that he did not know how to set it aside as though it were simply a book he could pick up again later.
What on Earth would Elrond know, anyhow? Bilbo prided himself on knowing quite a bit about Elves for someone who wasn’t one himself, and he knew enough to understand that Elven emotions did not brush the heartstrings in quite the same way as they did the emotions of mortals. That was the way Elvish legend told that the Second Children had been shaped in the Music. Their lives were shorter, and all the more potent for it; they laughed louder and mourned more. Their hearts broke more messily in two. They felt their losses sharply, and were taken from the world because of it where the First Children were not.
So it was far too rich for Elrond to stroll around in his Homely House and tell Bilbo that he should simply stop mourning.
(Bilbo wasn’t being fair. He’d heard whispers of the things Elrond Halfelven had given up over the course of his limitless life. He knew the toll it could take when immortal beings lost a mortal love and had to go on without them. Mourning was all the same wherever you went and whoever you were, he guessed, and it was just as unbearable on all sides.
But he’d let himself be unfair and cross for a little while longer.)
They crept higher. Bilbo spoke little, listening to the whistling wind and looking only at his feet moving underneath him. They had to stop and camp in sharp clefts huddled against the rock, and the days were bleak and shrouded in fog so high up. Soon, even the sunniest of their bunch were finding it hard to carry on with the same cheerfulness.
(It was true that the Company of Thorin Oakenshield should have given themselves some leniency in the whole situation. The High Pass through the Misty Mountains was one of the few paths that remained from ancient days, and hardly anyone still attempted it at all, much less with such vigour as they had. But Bilbo was not quite up to thinking of this in his sorry state, so think of it he did not.)
On the third evening, after they’d stopped trekking for the day and he’d settled himself just far enough from the camp that he could be alone with his thoughts but still keep an eye on all of them, Bilbo decided that for once, the wind would have to listen to his whispers instead.
“I often wonder if you are there yet, Frodo, wherever there may be,” he said softly into the night air. “I’m sure it’s been an awfully long journey, out there on the ship among the Sea. I hope you pestered Gandalf as much as you were able.”
He looked down, at the black nothing far below, the ground a haze of silvermist from how high in the mountain ranges they were.
“I hope you will think of me kindly, and won’t be too upset that I left you so soon. But don’t - don’t think of me too often, my dear boy. I don’t want you to be sad.”
Bilbo did not know if he talked to Frodo because he thought that somehow Frodo would hear him, or would know somewhere in his heart, or because he simply had a lot to say, and there was no one else to listen. Not even Gandalf, who’d known Frodo better than almost anyone in Middle-Earth and who had seen him through all the adventures Bilbo had not been there for. Gandalf the Grey of this time was not Gandalf the Grey of the last years of the Third Age, and he was not yet Gandalf the White, formidable in his grace and valour.
The wind blew then through all of Bilbo’s clothes and hair and then onward to the West, and he wondered if it was carrying all of his thoughts with it.
(If only he had gotten to say goodbye in a proper state of mind. The thought was almost insurmountable.)
“Perhaps it is better that you forget me," he whispered, "and when we see each other a long time from now, you can remember me all over again.” His voice cracked, and he bent his head. “I am so sorry, Frodo, my lad.”
“Who do you talk to?” a gruff voice said behind him.
It was so sudden that Bilbo startled quite badly and almost slipped off the face of the rock, but caught himself in time. He turned his head to see Thorin leaning against the cliff-face behind them with his arms folded, watching Bilbo with an unreadable expression. A few of the other dwarves scattered nearby had looked up at the noise, and Balin’s eyes were resting on him with what looked strangely like pity.
“Nobody,” Bilbo said, and was not quite able to keep his weakened voice steady. “Just myself.”
Looking up at Thorin after being so lost in guilt over Frodo made Bilbo feel as though he was untethered to the earth, floating in the mists that covered every inch of the rock they stood on. It had not been his brightest idea.
“You must focus, Master Baggins,” Thorin said. “This is the High Pass. It is no gentle Shire-track.”
There was nothing accusing in his voice, nothing cruel or unkind, but nor was there anything much to be found of comfort. There wasn’t anything at all. There was only his unmoving eyes lingering on Bilbo.
Bilbo realised with blunt embarrassment that Thorin had been watching him for much longer than he’d been aware of.
“Yes, well, I will be much better for it when we are over this pass and out of these mountains,” he got out, clambering up and wiping his damp hands on his trousers.
“There is no danger up here,” Thorin said, eyes trained heavily on Bilbo’s squinting ones. “Someone will be sure to catch you if you fall.”
It was strange, the slow indifference he spoke with and how it clashed with the intensity of those eyes. He seemed almost impatient, like he was trying to shake Bilbo out of whatever stupor he’d fallen into so they could keep on going, but for all his outward roughness he still did not poke or pry. Once or twice his line of sight fell to the ground beneath Bilbo’s feet as he hauled himself back up the rock, and Bilbo realised with a bright twinge of embarrassment that he was watching to ensure Bilbo was not going to slip.
“Get some sleep,” Thorin ground out, gaze on Bilbo for a moment longer before he turned to look around at the other dwarves. “We’re leaving here at first light.”
That night Bilbo watched Thorin lay with his back against the stone floor, face angled up at the moon. His eyes were wide open for hours; he seemed barely to want to close them. The vastness of the night sky was like a smother over them all, and to be so high up in the ridges felt as though they were merely pinpricks amongst endless blackness.
Bilbo woke sometime on the cusp of dawn, earlier than he’d meant to, and looked over once more to see Thorin in the same still position, though his eyes were closed now in sleep, and his nose struck his face like a knife-edge. A ghosting unease fell over Bilbo at the sight and he rolled over, pulling his blanket up around his shoulders and staring wide-eyed out at the far-off grey hills.
The stillness reminded him far too much of the funerals.
Bilbo had been watching, since they’d left Rivendell, spending long hours at night looking through the firelight at Thorin Oakenshield. He moved always with his head bent, almost like he was bowing to forefathers long passed, or praying to them. He seemed a wanderer never at rest, and was every bit the hardened king Bilbo had always remembered.
Thorin seemed to not ever look at Bilbo if he could help it, and Bilbo had started to wonder if maybe it was deliberate, if the memory of shamefully unwanted fingers on his face in the dead of night caused him discomfort. Maybe Bilbo’s fretful, forlorn nature was grating at him. Maybe he thought Bilbo a weight holding them down in the mountains, or a nuisance to be babysat. Maybe he would try to send him home yet.
Bilbo would not ever let him.
It was the next night that the storm came. The rock was slick and wet, and the rain lashed at their faces, and the collision of the rock-giants was like nothing any of them had ever heard. It was as if they'd crashed head-on into a hurricane and it was doing its best to batter them off the side of the mountain, down into the depths below.
There was a suddenly-located open crevice in the rock-face, and a cheer, and then they were clambering, all of them, into a cave that was dry and sandy on the bottom but safe from the rain and the almighty thunder. Fili and Kili were already at the back, scouting, and Gloin had collapsed down onto the floor in complete exhaustion.
A deadly prickle crept across the back of Bilbo’s neck. This cave was familiar.
His heart skipped in his chest.
“We cannot stop here.”
A few of them turned back to face him standing still out in the cold, blinking in the downpour. Some of them had already started unravelling their bedrolls inside. Bilbo charged forward, wiping the rain from his eyes.
“We have to keep going, find shelter further down the path. It isn’t safe here.”
Heavy footfalls made their way slowly out from the cave until Thorin was standing at the entrance once more, his sopping hair thrown back and one foot propped up on the outcrop beside him. There must have been gallons of water weighing down his coat, and he looked worn down, Bilbo noticed, with a lopsided sort of jolt.
Thorin's voice was dark. “You do not think we should stop for shelter when we have not been able to find any before now?”
Bilbo scowled, water getting into his eyes and ears and sticking his eyelashes together until they were thick and glassy. Hail was starting to come down all around them, and the clashing echo of the boulders in the near distance rang in their ears as if they were the very source of all the thunder and lightning.
“There are things that live in these mountains, and we are right at the centre of them if we stop," Bilbo pressed. "We have to make more headway along the pass.” All of his waterlogged clothes squelched as he moved, and he felt himself beginning to shiver terribly.
Thorin’s face was closing off the more he spoke, his eyes narrowing and his fingers beginning to harden into fists against the edge of the cave mouth.
“We are half-drowned and hungry, Master Baggins. We need rest and warmth. We cannot push on because you are scared of what sort of creatures might be hiding in the shadows.”
Bilbo grit his teeth stubbornly and pushed on, not budging one inch. “Gandalf is not with us, so we are without protection, and you are not invincible, Thorin.”
Far over their heads, rocks boomed and broke, shaking the mountain. They were going to be killed if they did not move. It was only a matter of whether it would happen one way or the other.
Thorin snarled. “I am the leader of this Company -”
“And I am telling you, we are not safe here!”
Thorin’s eyes rested on him for a very long while, and there was real animosity and warning there, now, and still Bilbo stood his ground.
Bilbo had absolutely no way of knowing if Gandalf would make it to them in time again, or if their luck in the foul caverns of Goblintown would hold once more, so he would not risk it. They could be angry at him all they wanted. He didn’t care one bit.
“Fine,” Thorin snarled, his eyes like daggers turned right onto Bilbo. “We will do it your way.”
A chorus of groans echoed all around. Bilbo ignored them.
Thorin turned again so his back was to Bilbo and the wailing winds beyond, the fur atop his coat matted and discolouring in the storm. He half-glanced back at Bilbo, looking down his nose at where Bilbo was standing barefoot on the slippery black rock-face.
“I trust you will have no problems with walking ahead and leading the rest of us, since you are so eager to carry on. You have been so eager to lead our Company thus far, after all,” he said, and oh, Bilbo could smack him.
Stubborn, arrogant, bone-headed dwarves!
If only you were mine, and then I could kiss that argumentative frown off your face, you thick idiot, he thought tiredly, turning without a word to the path ahead and squinting uselessly through the rain.
Hate me all you want, my dear. You are still alive and in front of me, and it is only a bit of rain.
(A bit of rain that Bilbo was sure was going to give him pneumonia in the very near future, but beggars could not very well be choosers.)
Soon enough, there were thirteen grumbling voices trailing out of the cave after him, drenched to the bone and shooting him their fair share of scowls, though most of the dwarves looked simply too weary to even think about pointing accusing fingers at anybody.
Bilbo did not know what had tripped the mechanism of the goblin gate last time, and he did not know how quickly they would be alerted to intruders on their doorstep, but even the fact that bedrolls had been laid out had him already feeling uneasy, and he was chill all over with icy water and wind and a sense of deep foreboding.
He could sit idle no longer. They were moving on borrowed time.
Despite how high they were in the mountain pass, it was not terribly long before they came out into a grove of trees, and the ground gradually faded from rock to dirt and tree-roots. There was an especially thick canopy of pine and fir overhead in one of the smaller clearings, and after a few quick glances between them the Company all but collapsed into heaps on top of each other.
“I don’t know if lighting a fire is the best idea,” Bilbo began tentatively, “there may still be watchers in the woods -”
But he could see that he’d pushed his limits, and that no one would listen to him any further tonight.
Thorin gazed over at him stonily from across the camp, his arms folded.
“We have fighters amongst us, Master Baggins, and we will all die of cold, otherwise. I am sure they will be able to protect us from anything,” and here he paused, clenching his jaw to fully exact his disdain, “lurking in the woods.”
Bilbo rolled his eyes and turned to wring the water from his coat. He didn’t mind if they did not believe him, as they hadn’t seen hide nor hair of the goblins and didn’t know what would be waiting for them up ahead, but they could at least be a little more polite about it.
“Don’t mind him, laddie," Balin said kindly, coming up next to him. "We’re still just getting used to the skittishness of hobbits, I suppose.”
Bilbo’s eyebrows furrowed, and he squinted at Balin through the thick drops of rain still falling through the gaps in the canopy above. “You've known me for nearly three months, Balin. You know I'm not skittish.”
Balin’s eyes rested on him, and Bilbo could see how tired he was, and abjectly refused to feel guilty about it.
“We’re quite safe here, Bilbo. There's nothing to worry about. The wizard will be with us again soon.”
Bilbo looked out into the darkness that lay the way they’d come and did not reply.
He could hardly be cross with them, since they had no way of knowing the dangers all around, and he knew that if he was in their place, he’d probably find his constant worry just as tiresome. But he’d hoped they’d realise that his fear was very real, and not simply hobbitish fright or cowardice due to his apparent lack of experience in the Wild. He could feel eyes on them from afar. He knew there were things hiding out, sizing them up.
He would have to go sooner rather than later, if he wanted to find the Ring, and he could find out how much time they had before the goblins were upon them.
“Bofur,” Bilbo whispered a few hours later. “Bofur, get up. Oh, honestly,” he said, and he pulled Bofur’s hat right off and smacked him across the shoulder with it so Bofur jerked awake, blearily blinking sleep out of his eyes.
Bilbo eyed him. “You dwarves sleep like the dead."
“Hmm?”
“Are you any decent with hunting game?" Bilbo asked quickly. "I spotted a rabbit earlier, just down the grove from here, but I can’t kill it myself.”
“Sure you can, Bilbo!” Bofur said encouragingly, that signature wide grin stretched across his face as he nestled his beloved hat back on his head. “You’ve got a weapon now!”
“I’m not going to cut down a helpless little rabbit with this mighty thing, am I?” he countered, exasperated, gesturing to Sting.
Bofur’s smirk widened, and he tilted his head to the side, the flaps of his hat bouncing merrily. “Aye, but would you call that mighty?”
Bilbo rolled his eyes and wondered if they might fall out of his head at some point. Confusticate dwarves who were too snarky for their own good.
“All right, lad. I’m no good with a bow and arrow, but I’m not a bad aim with a slingshot. We can nick Ori’s and slip it back before anyone’s noticed.”
It was no time at all before the rabbit Bilbo had spotted hiding under a nearby shrub was out cold and Bofur was ambling up to it, gently breaking its neck to put it out of its misery.
“What d’you need game for, anyhow, Bilbo?” The dwarf was still as friendly as ever, but his smile had faded slightly, and he was watching Bilbo with a careful sort of look in his eye. Bilbo swallowed.
“I’m going back to scout the area, and I can’t take any of the Company’s food or they’ll try and stop me. I should only be gone for the night at most. I’m not leaving, so don’t worry about that, but we’re not safe here, and the only person who seems to believe so is me.”
He looked back at Bofur, whose smile had fallen to a feeble sort of grimace, weary and resigned, like he was getting ready to say goodbye.
“I’m not leaving you, Bofur," Bilbo said firmly. "I promise. Wait here for Gandalf in the meantime. All of you need to rest.”
Bofur clapped a sturdy hand to Bilbo’s shoulder, and seemed to linger like he wanted to lean forward and touch his head to Bilbo’s before talking himself out of it.
“Good luck, our burglar.”
The journey back up the rock was treacherous, and horribly bitter, and Bilbo wished uselessly that he could just leave the damned Ring where it was, and the goblins would miraculously leave them alone, and everyone could be quite done with it already. But he knew by now that that was not the way things were, and so he scurried on, shoulders hunched against the whistling wind and rain-soaked shirt sticking uncomfortably to his skin.
He slowed almost to a total stop once he reached the mouth of the cave, hoping that his hobbitish ways would not fail him now, and he’d stay silent and hidden from whatever horrors lurked within. Bilbo pulled the rabbit carcass tighter against his back and prayed that the goblins could not smell the blood.
When he poked the tiniest sliver of his face around the side of the cave, Bilbo saw immediately that he’d been right, and a pit of anxiety opened up in his stomach. There was a crack in the floor like a great gash, and beyond the opening he could see movement, and hear voices, and the sound was like slick choking coming up from the dangerous depths below. Bilbo shuddered, and then closed his eyes briefly and pushed his forehead against the wall of the cave in a silent prayer.
No goblins had come through the Front Gate and into the cave yet, thankfully, and Bilbo crept like he was made of smoke and mist, not daring to disturb a single rock or pebble. When he reached the farthest edge of the opening in the floor, he dropped the rabbit from his back and tied it to his belt with some spare rope so it hung there alongside Sting like a ridiculous ornamental decoration. He resisted the mad urge to laugh, and then cocked his head, wrinkled his nose, and went on, gripping the edge of the rock gently with both hands and swinging as quietly as he could manage, down into the upper arches of Goblintown.
He dropped right into the shadows, keeping his breathing as still as he could manage. There were goblins clambering back and forth along their bridges like a swarm of ants, carrying hideous weapons along the rafters. Not a single one of them noticed the little shape that had appeared in the dark.
Bilbo really was lucky. Not even the pack of them closest to him had moved an inch, instead standing around to argue with each other in Orcish and making crude gestures in the direction Bilbo had come from.
They know we’re near, he realised, and the frantic fear inside him grew, though he swallowed it down and began to walk soundlessly backwards, one step at a time along the bridge. He did not dare draw his sword.
I shall have to be quick, then, shan’t I?
He’d nearly made it all the way off the rope-bridge and onto solid ground when there was a dull crack, and the slats of the bridge began to shudder in a perfect ricochet. The rabbit had slipped off its rope and crashed onto the floor.
The goblins all fixed their eyes on him.
Bilbo quickly reattached the rope, then turned and ran like hell itself was after him, eyes wide and panicked as the walls of rock blew past him and searching with urgency for the sight of anything remotely familiar at all in this wretched, stinking place. He didn’t know exactly where he’d fallen last time, and he did not know which of the underground tunnels led where, or whether any of them led to the right cave at all.
There were feet, clawing, closing in behind him. They were all far bigger than he; they would easily outpace him even if he ran until his legs collapsed out from under him. Shouting flew over his head to who-knows-where, and answering roars of glee echoed in the red abyss below him. He could hear the chuckles of the Goblin-King as if they were taunting him alone. Whitening panic slid swiftly down into Bilbo’s heaving chest as he ran and ran and ran.
But then, all of a sudden, he felt a dip in the floor below his feet, and he wrenched his eyes open, and there it was. The plunging drop into darkness, the little cliff-face jutting down, down, into winding tunnels deep within the belly of the mountains. He hurtled over the side without a second thought and disappeared from view.
Bilbo hit the ground hard, so hard his ears began to ring, and he had to raise himself woozily on all fours until his head felt like it had settled.
He felt for his belt. Sting, and the rabbit fastened to his rope; both still there. The sickness of blind panic and quite plausible concussion faded slightly, and reluctantly Bilbo began to drag his way through the shards of rock on hands and knees, feeling around, hoping against hope that he’d see the horrid thing before he touched it. The thought of having to come into contact with that cursed little ring again made Bilbo’s skin crawl.
All of a sudden, on the rocky path just ahead, a few paces from him, there appeared in his vision a dull band of gold.
Bilbo had to turn away.
He’d known he would be able to find it with relative ease. It made no sense in Bilbo’s mind that whichever powers in the Blessed Realm that had given him another chance would let something as ridiculous as finding the Ring in a cave be a setback on his quest.
He wondered if it could sense him, if it could feel the traces of blackness once coiled around his body and mind even though they had not yet done so in this life.
Bilbo carefully took out his handkerchief from the pocket of his trousers and pinched the Ring between his fingers, not even brave enough to pick up the band with bare skin. He could feel his own thudding pulse in his teeth and in his fingertips, and wondered whether he was imagining the distant thrum beneath the handkerchief too.
He did not want to touch it. He barely wanted to look at it, a glowing-red beam in his mind’s eye like the entrance to a darkness below where all the worst monsters slept. He wished he could simply tuck it away in a rock somewhere and come back for it later, that he did not have to be so near to something that had turned so many to evil, that had wound around his mind like steel wire and tightened every day.
He slipped the Ring into his front-pocket and looked up, gritting his teeth to repress a shiver. The whole subterranean cavern was utterly quiet, only the slow drip, drip of water from high stone stalactites echoing in the gloom. There was no sign of another living creature anywhere.
Perhaps Bilbo wouldn’t even need the rabbit, after all. The thought made him sigh loudly, and he trudged back up the rock to where he’d fallen from.
He had almost made it to the tunnel opening when, very quietly, Bilbo began to hear something slinking, snaking up from the black edge of the water, and noises like wet fingerprints touching at the bones scattered all around, and the faintest tap-tapping like a tiny boat was lapping at the shore of the lake, kissing up against the rock. Dread crept up and settled in his throat.
Bilbo turned as slowly as he could, and saw the pale gleam of eyes like orbs, the sickly pallor of an elongated body, fish-like in the darkness. He dared not draw his sword. He could not move at all.
“Sméagol,” Bilbo whispered.
The creature stopped.
There was no sound in the cave, no wind, no crunch of bone or rock. No breath, for Bilbo was holding his, scared out of his wits. He felt blindly at the hilt of Sting beneath his coat and closed his eyes for one terrible moment.
“It knows us, precious,” the thing whispered. “How does it knows us, we wonders?”
The sound of the creature had spent so long drifting through Bilbo’s nightmares that hearing it aloud again was almost a relief, for it was worse and yet not quite as terrible as he remembered. This Gollum was not a ghost, and though he crept and haunted the cave and the lake below the goblin tunnels, he could not creep or haunt anywhere else.
But even so, he hated to be in this dank, dreary cavern again, the very air stale and wet and suffocating to breathe, and for just a moment, he wished again that he had never taken the Ring and doomed himself to crawling around in here with a thing like Gollum.
Then Bilbo shook himself and set his jaw, and thought that it did not really matter whether he wished it or not; he had taken it, and although the guilt of it pulled at him even still, he knew that the fate of the world had been better for it, in the very end, and so he would have to take it once more.
No use complaining, you silly old thing. You are here now, and the journey must go on.
“My name is Bilbo Baggins,” he said to Gollum. “I’ve brought you a gift. So you won’t have to eat any goblins or nasty fish from the lake for a little while.”
“Bagginses? We’ve never met any Bagginses before, precious. Does it bring us birthday presents?”
“Yes, I do,” Bilbo said, untying the rope from his belt and holding it up with one hand. “See? A nice, fat rabbit, fresh from the woods.”
The white-green eyes lit up gleefully, and Gollum reached out with spindly, bony fingers to tear at the flesh of the rabbit, hacking up dreadful noises that Bilbo thought might have been laughter. He averted his eyes.
“I brought it for you so I could come and talk to you, Sméagol. I’ve come to talk about your… your other birthday present.”
The creature’s eyes sharpened immediately, his bulbous lids falling and his teeth bared. Bilbo hurried to amend the situation in a panic.
“I don’t want to take it, I promise!” he called, holding up both hands in pathetic surrender and taking a single step backward. There was a suspicious crack of something that might have once been a skeleton underneath his foot. “It is yours, Sméagol. Not mine.”
The words were bitter on his tongue, and he swallowed back bile.
Mine. Mine. My precious.
“I am only curious about how special it is,” he said, knowing he could well be sealing his own death sentence by even speaking the words. “You must love it a lot.”
Gollum slowly settled back, though his limbs were still tense, and he peeled at the carcass of the rabbit much more warily. Bilbo knew he was making a huge gamble by willingly drawing Gollum’s attention to the Ring; he may as well have been playing with lit matches around a firecracker. And yet, it was Gollum who had destroyed it, in the end, and it was Gollum who he had shown mercy to, in the ghostly darkness beneath the beds of the mountains, and it was Gollum who had taken it into the fire. Not Frodo.
Bilbo’s feelings towards Gollum were so complex as to not be put into words. Anger, such anger towards him for Frodo and Sam, and even Frodo’s poor finger, and guilt, for being the one who had caused Gollum to creep his way back into the light, and a miserable, sick sort of recognition, like Gollum was an omen of what was in store, like he was the demon that clung to Bilbo’s shoulder and whispered in his ear. Bilbo felt as though he was looking down into the lake at a horrifying sort of reflection.
The sight was awful. The way the teeth were ground down to brown nubs, nothing but dark, bloody holes in the gums where the rest had once been. The limp few strings of black hair that hung from the crown of his head, scabbing at the roots and torn at the ends.
He pushed forward.
“Sméagol, do you know who the Precious belongs to?”
Gollum hissed at him, creeping closer across the floor. “It’s ours, precious, and nobody else’s!”
“Yes, of course. It was your birthday present,” Bilbo agreed calmly. “But do you know who gave it to you? Do you know where they got the Precious from?”
Gollum peered dubiously at him, but Bilbo could see the slightest intrigue begin to spark in his hideous face, and knew the smallest part of him that loved riddles and games was curious about such a mystery. He tilted his head, perching like a great frog on the tip of a rock.
“We finds it ourselves, precious,” he hissed. “Nobody gives it to us.”
Bilbo pressed forwards earnestly. “Yes, you found it yourself, and it is your treasure. But it was put there by the Enemy. By Him.”
This approach was not working. Bilbo could see Gollum’s face darkening, the limbs stretching out insidiously. The creature had his teeth bared again. Bilbo tried a new tactic.
“Do you remember your grandmother, Sméagol?” he asked, and Gollum’s demeanour changed at once.
“Yes, yes, we does!” he howled excitedly, eyes growing wide. “She taught us to suck eggses!”
“Do you remember what she looked like?” Bilbo held his breath.
“Sméagol doesn’t… doesn’t remember.” Gollum's bony shoulders seemed to slump in on themselves, and he was so very pitiful that Bilbo wondered again if running him through with a sword wouldn’t be the more humane option after all. “I don’t remember.”
I don’t remember. I. Not we. Not Sméagol.
“The Ring took her from you, Sméagol,” Bilbo said carefully, keeping his tone as even as he could. He did not look away once from Gollum’s eyes. “It made her scared of you.”
But the bumps of Gollum’s spine seemed suddenly to jut out, and he turned his head slowly, terribly, baring his yellowing teeth in the eerie green darkness.
Bilbo’s blood ran cold. His time was up.
“Baggins is trying to steal it,” Gollum hissed, and he leapt on Bilbo with a scream.
There were slippery, slimy arms all around him, and rotting breath in his ears, on the back of his neck, hot against his skin and making it crawl. Bilbo madly threw his arm backwards with as much force as he could muster, letting his elbow connect with hard bone, and the creature let out a sickening shriek. He could feel the filthy nails scrabbling at his clothes, his skin, digging in, trying to rip and tear at him. He grasped wildly at where the arms were touching him and kicked with his legs, wriggling like an eel to get away from Gollum.
His hand came up, connected with Gollum’s skull, forced him off of Bilbo with a painfully clenched fist. The creature howled, and the walls of the cave threw the noise against each other so it rang dreadfully in their ears and curdled Bilbo’s blood. He threw himself at the nearest upward climb, clawing at the rock with desperate, grubby fingers, and dashed away from the horror of the lake as though both of his lives depended on it.
It was like one of Bilbo’s nightmares come to life, the way the creature howled out Baggins from further and further away, the screaming of the rock underneath his feet as he raced out of the tunnel and back towards the goblins.
There was movement all around, and shouts in unfamiliar, drawling speech as he whipped past the goblins once more, the ones lurking in the depths and guarding each of the gates hidden within the rock. The sound was like oil slick dripping from their mouths. He did not stop.
Bilbo ducked and weaved and hurtled out of the tunnels, out through the little gap in the gate and all the way down the side of the mountain, hoping with all he had that the Company had waited for him, that he had not forgotten the way. The balls of his feet were pounding against the packed dirt, stones and twigs and little tufts of grass flying in all directions as the ground kicked up behind him.
He had no way of knowing if he’d delayed Gollum’s capture by the armies of Mordor or only spurred it on faster. He knew, too, that running in broad daylight with no way of hiding himself would likely lead the goblins right towards them if they saw him, but he was a hobbit, after all, and he could be quiet and hidden of his own accord.
He would not put the Ring on. Not ever again.
Bilbo was sucking in air and still thumping his flat feet on the ground when he began to hear voices nearby, and he stumbled to a stop, leaning against a tree with his hands and bowing his head as he tried to catch his breath. Trickles of the deep rumbling of dwarves filtered through the trees, and he closed his eyes in relief. They were still here.
He concentrated, still a little ways away from the clearing but just able to catch glimpses of them through the trees, and realised that they were in the midst of what seemed to be a heated argument. Predictably, Thorin’s voice was clearest over the din.
“It does not matter what Master Baggins said to you, Bofur. It’s clear he has no plan on returning.” There was the sound of grit crunching under boots, and Bilbo could see the set of Thorin’s shoulders between a gap in the branches.
“We cannot stay here any longer. We are losing time by sitting here and awaiting someone who has abandoned us.”
Even from this distance, Bilbo could see the way Bofur’s face tightened into a troubled frown. A tall figure turned to the side to fix their eyes on the assorted members of the Company, and Bilbo realised with another immense spark of relief that it was Gandalf, reunited with them from Rivendell.
“What exactly happened, Bofur?” Gandalf asked, patiently but imploringly, and a few of the others murmured in agreement. There was a distinctly morose feeling between them all, settling across the Company and clouding the sullen air. Bilbo had not realised that they had grown so fond of him.
Bofur rolled his shoulders and fixed them all with a look as if to test them, and Bilbo’s heart grew light as air.
“He woke me and asked for help with catching some game for food, and when I asked him what he needed it for, he said he was going to scout behind us, like I told you. He seemed awfully convinced that there was something lurking in the mountains, waiting for us, and he told me not to leave until Gandalf arrived.”
“Yet Gandalf is here,” Thorin murmured, “and our burglar is not.”
“It does seem odd that he needed a whole rabbit for a journey that takes only a couple of hours,” Bombur added unsurely, looking around at them all.
“Well - aye, that is true, but we all know hobbits eat a lot," Bofur said. “I’ve no idea what he expected to do with it, but I wasn’t going to question him in the middle of the night.” He took off his hat and began to fiddle with it in his fingers. Bilbo had never in his life seen Bofur without it before the previous night, and the sight was still completely bizarre. “Something’s spooked him, Thorin. He seemed so worried.”
“The mountains haven’t been sitting well with him,” chipped in Dori. “He’s been acting twitchier than usual.”
“Well, who can blame him?” Nori shot back, throwing an arm vaguely towards the towering treeline. “We here all knew we might be walking toward our deaths, but are we so sure he was ever told as much?”
“That is quite enough,” boomed a voice like thundering iron. Bilbo watched as Gandalf rose to his full height, his expression like a great statue hanging over the rest of them and his pointed hat trembling on his head.
“If you all still believe our hobbit is to be spooked by such simple things as walking and climbing after all he has done for you,” he said fiercely, “then you are much blinder than I imagined, and I am ashamed to be amongst you. He has been a friend to every one of you, and now, you would forsake him to the Wild like he is expendable weight!”
“If he is our friend, Gandalf,” said Thorin quietly, “then where is he?”
Gandalf’s narrowed eyes pierced him at once, and Bilbo could feel the tension that settled over the ring they stood in. A brief, strange burst of sympathy ran through him as he watched Thorin very deliberately lift his chin to meet the wizard’s glare.
Oh, your stubbornness is admirable, my heart, but you are never in all your days going to win against Mithrandir.
“He could be in danger!” Gandalf cried. “The Misty Mountains are treacherous. There is every chance he could have been taken captive or gravely hurt by now, no doubt trying to keep all of you safe!”
This seemed to incense Thorin even further, and Bilbo had no way of knowing if it was because he thought Gandalf was wrong, or because he thought he was right.
“Do none of you recall what he said at the Trollshaws?” Thorin said, turning to face the others. His voice had become almost a growl. “Master Baggins informed us he can protect himself just fine, but he could not brave the mountains, so he cut his losses and slipped away. We will not be seeing our burglar again.”
Bilbo knew it had come time for him to step out and end this unpleasant haggling, but he first spared a moment to admire how Thorin could command attention even when he was being thick as a blunt axe, and how it really wasn’t quite fair the way his brows sat when he was mad. Ridiculous.
“I wouldn’t be quite so sure of that, Master Oakenshield.”
Fourteen heads spun as one, and their faces broke open with relief. Bilbo felt stupidly warm with affection for all of them.
“Bilbo!” several of them cried, staggering towards him and smacking him affectionately on the back or the shoulders. Kili’s grin was especially huge, and Bilbo winked at him.
“Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said, and Bilbo could see the warm relief in his twinkling smile. “You are indeed a sight for sore eyes.”
“Yes, yes, it’s all a miracle and I’m very grateful you’re all so relieved, but we need to get out of here,” Bilbo said, smiling quickly but trying to handle their most pressing matters with all the haste he could muster. “They are coming. We need to get into the trees, or they will catch us.”
“Who?”
Bilbo huffed exasperatedly. “The goblins. I was scouting the area, I told you. There are goblins on our trail.”
At the suddenly-sheepish looks on their faces, Bilbo’s eyes narrowed.
“You really didn’t believe me, did you?”
“Well,” Gloin said, a note of apology in his voice, “it’s just that we wouldn’t have blamed you, Bilbo, if you’d decided to turn around after all. You don’t have any personal stake in this quest.”
That sent Bilbo into even more of a huff, and he strode forward before he could give it a second thought, jabbing Gloin hard in the chest with a pointed finger.
“Now, look here, I may be small, and easily hidden, but I rather thought I’d shown you all by now that I’m made of stronger stuff than I seem. Do you honestly think I would have come along on this quest at all if I hadn’t had at least an inkling of what I was getting into?”
He petered out quite suddenly, and decided to frown for good measure. Gloin looked positively abashed, and not one of the others was holding eye contact with him any longer, except for Bofur and Balin.
Bilbo saw Thorin glance at him, and directed the next part of his speech straight to him. If Thorin did not want to look at him, well, he was going to have to just grit his teeth and bear it.
“There is no one else in the world who is willing to stop and help you, so it is me who must do what I can. You may not feel the same way, but you are all my friends,” he said, breathing out slowly, gazing around at these faces he’d so loved, “and I would not be a friend at all if I did not carry on with you when things got difficult. I am not going to leave you.”
Thorin was watching him, the look in his eyes unreadable, unrelenting. There'd always been something in those eyes that Bilbo could never place.
And for once, Bilbo let his gaze wander, over the speckled streaks of grey that swept back through the darkness of his hair, the ample slope of his nose, the twin braids hanging down by his shoulders and the gold clasps threaded through them. His forearms, shot with scars; the marks of a blacksmith who excelled at his work. The meshed material across his chest and his close-cropped beard, almost too neat and tidy to seem like it belonged to Thorin. Bilbo had imagined the feel of it under his fingers more times than he could count.
After a long silence, where Bilbo held his ground, Thorin bent his head downwards and then looked back up to Bilbo, his eyebrows no longer as tense, his eyes no longer so harsh, almost like he was yielding. Like he had wanted to be proven wrong, and Bilbo had succeeded. Bilbo knew it for the silent acquiescence it was, and a little smile twitched onto his face without him quite meaning it to.
Bofur clapped him on the shoulder and squeezed gently. Ori and Dori smiled at him, and so did Oin and Gloin, and Fili and Kili, and Bifur and Bombur, and Balin inclined his head, and Dwalin rolled his eyes mightily and turned to watch Thorin instead. Bilbo met Gandalf’s eyes over the fabric of Bofur’s hat, and they were glowing with something otherworldly that looked rather satisfied with the whole turn of events. They watched each other, and Gandalf tipped his hat so slightly that Bilbo wasn’t sure if he was just imagining things. For just a second, all of them breathed in a single moment of quiet.
It was then, in the distance, that the drums began.
Bilbo’s heart stopped. His eyes frantically snapped back to Thorin's, still heavy on him.
“We have to get to the trees,” he said.
Thorin didn’t hesitate, whipping around roughly and calling out, “Into the trees! Now!”
All fifteen of them, dwarves and a hobbit and Gandalf the Grey, raced towards the trees, the thud of their leather-soled boots thunderous amongst the rustle of leaves and the steady boom, boom, boom of danger coming closer.
Bilbo couldn't hear how close they were; couldn't hear anything over the sudden hammering in his ears, and he reached a tree and gripped at the branches like he was trying to tear them down with his own hands, his head swivelling side to side as he counted each of his dwarves.
Bifur up. Bombur up. Fili, Kili, Ori, Nori, where is Dori, where is - Dori, Oin, Gloin; Dwalin, you fool, you cannot take them all yourself, get into a tree!
Thorin up, in a tree far away from Bilbo’s, and Bilbo could see the faint luminous blue of his sword glowing beneath his hands like a pinprick in the sky. He was closest to Gandalf, Balin and Bofur, and distantly Bilbo felt himself clutch at his chest through the loose fabric of his shirt, as though he was making sure it was still there.
The tips of pine-needles were like blades against their throats as they waited, nobody daring to breathe in or out, the entire world utterly still and the drums drawing closer. Cackles started to ring in the distance, and the goblins poured in.
There was a vile way the taunts dripped from their lips, their mouths like torn gashes in their faces. They had creeping, curling tongues and wicked grins that stung at your skin with fear. Bilbo clung to the trunk of the tree and wished he was higher up, scrabbling with one hand in the twigs above for pinecones to use if it came to it once again. Wargs snapped and howled at the base of each tree, great hulking masses like creatures from the depths of hell itself, ghostly-white and bred by shadow. Their jagged claws gouged into the bark and shook the trees terrifyingly.
The goblins were mocking them, dancing around in rings below them, jeering and laughing, sadistically stringing songs together about their bones shrivelling and cracking and the skin peeling from their faces. Bilbo felt utterly ill with fear and revulsion, and weakly pressed his forehead against the trunk of the tree. And still the goblins growled, their sickly grins menacing and creeping closer and closer in their awful dancing to where each of the trees was full of dwarves.
Then, suddenly, one of them yelped out in pain and clutched the back of its head, aghast. A compact little stone had struck from somewhere behind and to the left of it.
Ori’s slingshot, Bilbo realised. They were distracting the goblins, trying to lead them astray, confuse them. He reached upwards and plucked a pinecone from the branch above him. His leaning caused the branch to creak, just slightly, and the air in his lungs turned into empty, hollow space in his chest.
When in doubt due to mortal peril, one must turn to what one knows.
All thirteen of the dwarves started to shout back at them, calling down to the goblins from the treetops and throwing all sorts of things to enrage them even further; more pinecones, lit with Gandalf’s white-blue flame, and sticks, and rocks, and someone’s fur-lined boot soaring through the air to crack against one of the goblin’s noses.
Then, the air became quite still, and the world seemed to slow down, as one of the goblins’ mouths fell open and it crumpled to the ground, thick blood gushing from a slash in the side of its head. Bilbo’s head whipped around.
It was Nori, hanging from the tree with only his legs wrapped around the trunk and his arm still outstretched from where the knife had left his hand.
The moment snapped. Any merriment was utterly gone from every one of the goblins’ faces, and they swarmed as one on the pine trees, hacking at them with axes and hammers and their bare fingers tearing into the gouges left by the wargs. The laughter was dark and foreboding and rang in Bilbo’s ears, and he prayed with all his might for the eagles to hurry, hurry, hurry already!
But the goblins weren’t spread evenly against each tree. More and more were surrounding the base of Nori’s, climbing on top of each other’s bodies in a horrid writhing heap and clawing at the tree to reach the culprit. Bilbo could see Nori scurrying higher in the branches, but he couldn’t reach the top, and Bifur and Ori were clambering desperately after him, and Dori was crying out to them across the glade, and the pale bodies of the goblins began to reach their arms out towards the dwarves up in the branches.
There was a sudden deep and gut-wrenching roar, the sort of noise that tore from you and bruised the walls of your throat with the sheer violence of it. Bilbo wanted nothing more than to squeeze his eyes shut, but forced himself to keep them open.
There Thorin stood, out of the tree and alone in the clearing against thirty goblins, his sword a piercing blue across the front of his body. His entire frame was heaving; Bilbo could see it even from this distance. His mouth was pulled back in anger, and his eyes were clear and focused. He was trying to draw their attention. Bilbo watched him bellow at them again, and couldn’t bear the sound of it.
The blade of Orcrist swept upwards in a perfect, deadly arc, and Thorin cleaved the closest goblin in two.
Bilbo immediately dropped like a stone out of the tree, taking no notice of the wild yell Kili let out after him or the pain that ricocheted through his knees when he hit the forest floor, and he ran like mad.
He'd done it so suddenly that the goblins nearest to him had no chance to close in before he was gone, dashing madly through the underbrush and weaving around the thick roots of trees as tall as mountains. Vines and low-hanging branches split at his face, and the sound of his feet against the hard-packed earth rang like a gong through the eerie battle-quiet in his head.
To their credit, the dwarves had taken out quite a few of the goblins, Gandalf's fire circling in a ring around them so a number of them could not pass through. Several had fallen to the ground in howling pain, clutching at their knees or heads or the base of their necks, and Bilbo knew Ori must be aiming as hard as he could. Dwalin was on the lowermost rung of the tree, hacking at their hands and faces wildly and swinging his axes with a roar.
But goblins were still rushing at Thorin like a wave, and he was whipping Orcrist through the air like a wildstorm, the Elven gleam mirroring the blue of the fire around them until the very air was glowing. He was cutting them down, and yet it was not fast enough, and time seemed to trickle on like water as the tallest one approached with its weapon raised. Thorin’s head was turned the other way.
There was a hammer, and a sickening crack. Thorin dropped to his knees. Bilbo’s vision went white.
Almost out of his body, he could see the goblin still looming over Thorin mockingly, the mallet-like hammer swinging by its side and its body wracked with laughter as Thorin slumped to the ground, his eyes huge.
Huge, but still open, and focusing, with some effort, on Bilbo.
Bilbo urged his frantic feet to move faster, and dashed into the path of the goblin so he was standing between its body and Thorin’s, Sting slipping faithfully in his hand. He could hear Thorin’s gasping breaths behind him, and tried to remind himself that the dwarf was all right, possibly, probably, though he could barely think over the thundering in his ears and the wild pounding of his heart. He set his footing and gripped the hilt of his sword in both hands.
“You can cut me down,” he spat, “but you will not touch him.”
The goblin threw its head back and laughed, and then began to stalk towards them both, moving in for the kill.
Bilbo bit down on his lip, hard, and closed his eyes for just a second, feeling the cold night air rustling the ends of his hair and washing over him like a stream. He could feel nothing but the wind, and the smooth curve of his little sword in his fingers, and the churned-up earth beneath his feet. He opened his eyes and ran forwards with Sting clasped in both hands and only the thud of his beating heart echoing in his ears, and let the blade sink deep into the goblin’s foul stomach. It screamed.
He pulled the sword out, drove it in again, hard, at its throat this time. Blood the colour of ichor began to spurt from its mouth and run down the sides, and its eyes rolled back until only the bloodshot whites were visible. Bilbo bared his teeth as he climbed off the body, staggering back and throwing his sword out to the side, his whole body heaving with wild adrenaline. He waited for the next danger to approach, willing them to even try. Sting slashed at the air in front of him.
From very, very far away, almost as if underwater, he could hear other voices calling out, and he began to breathe, slowly falling back into himself. Bilbo. Bilbo.
“Bilbo!” he heard someone - Ori, maybe - cry, and he whipped around to see the rest of them climbing up, up, further through the trees, and beyond them, a soar of great black shadows descending from the sky.
The eagles had come.
Bilbo dropped Sting at his feet and knelt to look over Thorin, his chest lurching. Thorin was awake, and still alive, but his eyes were barely open, and there was a ghastly, blackening bruise staining his collarbone and the base of his throat. All he seemed to be able to do was keep breathing in and out, unable to move his head at all, or pull his eyes away from Bilbo. They had precious few moments before the goblins would set in.
Bilbo looked up at the skyline again, and then threw himself forwards, grabbing at the front of Thorin’s coat and screaming out, “Help! We’re here!” He could see Gandalf, high up in the fir tree and calling to the eagles, who were plucking the dwarves out of the trees one by one.
The greatest of them all, a grey-feathered and regal creature with wise, ancient eyes, flew down and clasped Thorin’s body in its huge yellow-black talons, lifting him off the ground. Thorin’s eyes fell down to Bilbo as the eagle began to rise up into the sky, and Bilbo realised a split-second before the others did that the eagle had not seen him, small as he was, and that he would find himself left behind on this goblin-infested cliff if he didn’t do something fast. He picked up Sting, sheathed it, and took a running leap forwards, as high as his legs could carry him and only just managing to grip onto Thorin’s dangling arm below the talons of the eagle.
Thorin’s only reaction was a pained grunt. It seemed to be all he could do not to pass out, his chest rising and falling in great gaping breaths like he was drowning in his own lungs. Bilbo had no way of knowing if he was well enough to even speak, or if his rapid breathing was using up all of the air in his chest, and cold fear clawed at his throat. He squeezed Thorin’s arm even tighter.
He clung on for dear life the entire flight, one of his hands around Thorin’s bicep just below his shoulder and one clutching at his forearm, his grip so tight he was sure the blood wouldn’t be able to run to Thorin’s head and he really would pass out. There were no words for how biting the wind was, this high, and his fingers began to go numb. He did not let go.
They landed on the Carrock, Bilbo’s toes stinging after so long in the air with nothing but a terrifyingly sheer drop below him, and the eagle laid Thorin down on a flat plateau of rock. The other dwarves all crowded around him as they landed one after the other, clambering to get nearer and watching on with tight fear in their faces. Gandalf had to fight his way through the circle to reach him.
“Accursed dwarves! I need to see to him, and you are all blocking the way!”
They parted, though their expressions were stormy, and Bilbo could see them all glaring at Gandalf in expectation that he would fail, doubting that he could do anything for their leader. It wasn’t all too surprising. They hadn’t yet seen wizardry up close, and they still only knew Gandalf as a guide and a fighter, not as a tender of wounds or weaver of magic.
Thorin was lying on his back and staring unseeing at the sky, his breaths coming in stuttered gasps as he tried to choke the air down into his lungs. He seemed awake, still, but something was clearly wrong, and grim pressure began to build in Bilbo’s throat and eyes and jaw. Gandalf knelt at his side and passed a withered hand over Thorin’s face, and then rested his palm gently against Thorin’s chest, his fingers splayed out right across the centre. There was a dreadful moment of utter stillness.
Then, Bilbo could see Thorin starting to come back to himself, the rapid rising of his chest slowly evening out. The bruise across his neck was fading into a green-tinged yellow before their eyes, and Gandalf continued to murmur quietly above Thorin’s body, one hand clutched tightly around his staff as he knelt.
Thorin blinked, and his eyes came into focus. Everyone’s shoulders visibly loosened.
“Master Baggins?” Thorin croaked out, blinking away the glare of the daybreak and looking up at Gandalf leaning over him.
Gandalf's voice was gravelly and sounded tired, but soft, when he replied, “It’s all right. Bilbo is unhurt, and quite safe.”
Even amongst the wild bloom of giddy relief that went up like a flare in his chest, Bilbo found himself frowning, and had to restrain the petulant urge to cross his arms. The cuts and scrapes all over his face might have said something quite different, not to mention the state of his knees after his tumble out of the tree!
Bilbo decided to ignore Gandalf, and instead watched on restlessly as Thorin rose with some effort onto his elbows to look back at him. His face was the same stone mask it ever was, and his mouth was set into a tense line.
“You should not have done that,” Thorin said quietly. He gripped the arm Dwalin was offering to him and hauled himself to his feet, staggering a little unsteadily and catching the dwarves closest to him by the shoulders. But he held his head high, and his expression did not change.
Bilbo felt rooted to the spot by the intensity of those eyes on him atop the rock-face. They looked lighter, almost, in the early morning.
“You are a risk for us to have in this Company. You are reckless, and irresponsible, and you rely far too much on your own cleverness than you should.”
Thorin paused for a moment. His balance still seemed a little off, but his eyes were clear. Possibly a little concussed then, or maybe just weak from effort and having the breath knocked right out of him.
It was a hard thing for Bilbo not to roll his eyes at all the theatrics. He tried to look like he was being properly chastised, but in actuality he was wondering if Thorin would be able to muster up the nerve to hug him again, and quite wishing he would get on with it already.
I know your tricks this time, you ridiculous thing. You can’t fool me.
“And you have saved my life.”
Finally, they were turning towards each other like faraway ships in the night.
Thorin took a step forward, and the whole world exhaled with him. The way he approached Bilbo was hesitant, not like the last time, when he’d marched forward in a blaze after scaring Bilbo half to death and pulled him up into his chest before Bilbo had quite known what on Earth was going on. This time Thorin’s steps were slower, more unsteady, and his eyes seemed to open up the closer he got to Bilbo. The vulnerability on Thorin’s face stunned him quite into silence.
Thorin stopped in front of him, and his throat moved as he swallowed, looking down at Bilbo with his mouth parted slightly, his whole face moving and alive. They stood in silence for a moment, and then a few more moments.
It was right as Bilbo decided he was sick of waiting that Thorin wrapped his arms around him and pulled Bilbo into his chest.
Immediately, it all came rushing back to him. Bilbo clutched at Thorin tightly, drawing one arm up around his shoulders and tugging at him like he was trying to pull him down to his own height. There was no astonishment, this time, only warmth, so much of it, and the feel under his fingers that he was home, that his heart had joined together again.
Oh, my love, he thought. Oh, my love.
This broody, moody, ridiculous creature of his heart, the one who spoke little but listened to everything, who barely slept but never faltered, who had borne every burden of the hardship of his people for longer than a century. Whose smiles were rare and sacred, and who wore his beard short as a sign of eternal mourning, and whose closed-off heart had once opened so completely to Bilbo he could not quite remember the way he walked through the world without the memory of Thorin by his side.
He felt Thorin’s hand drag up his back and gently grasp the back of his neck, touching at his brown curls with more gentleness than Bilbo could have imagined. The other hand brushed at the top of his spine, and Bilbo did the same, feeling sleek ends of hair amongst the fur beneath his fingers on Thorin’s back.
He could barely hear the din behind them until Thorin pulled away from him, and then the outlandish cheering of the rest of the dwarves hit his ears with embarrassing clarity. He could see them all past Thorin’s shoulder, and they were shaken and a bit battered, but unharmed. He had to fight back the calibre of the grin that threatened to spring across his face.
“I am sorry I doubted you,” Thorin said, in his slow baritone, and his head was tilted with a clear new tenderness now, a reluctance towards everything Bilbo did that had become gratefulness the longer they’d travelled together. “I am truly thankful you have joined us.”
“Oh, dear, Gandalf, I think you might have to take another look at Master Oakenshield here. I think he’s gone round the bend!” Bilbo called, smiling, and the whole Company roared with laughter.
Someone soon took out some pieces of their trusty jerky, and they all flopped down on various bits of mossy rock, utterly worn out (and not the least Bilbo, who had not been able to rest his eyes for well over twenty-four hours).
Bilbo sat facing southward, looking far along the line of the distant, roaming mountain range, stretching further than hobbit eyes could see and down to where Bilbo knew was a country of horsemen, and past that, to where the White Tree would stand in years to come.
Lothlórien lay along the path, too. Bilbo spared a thought for the Lady of the Golden Wood. He had never visited her realm, and wondered if this time around he just might have to. He’d heard the flowers there were beautiful unlike anything else that had ever been in this world.
He’d heard all too much about the Elvish waybread they made there, too, from his nephew and younger cousins and little Sam Gamgee. Lembas. His stomach growled, and he looked down at the jerky forlornly. Bilbo wondered if it would make him a terrible person to ask one of the eagles if perhaps they had any spare eggs lying about.
His pulse was still thudding from the aftermath of the fight, and from Thorin’s dramatic display, and Bilbo clutched his own wrist in his hand gently, taking a deep breath to calm himself and then shaking his head.
They’d crossed what he saw as the first real hurdle that lay in their path, and quite successfully, all things considered. He’d managed to steer them from the goblins’ doorstep, and they’d all held their own in the battle beautifully once more.
And Thorin was all right. Dreadfully winded, and probably dazed, and if they were any of them sensible hobbits he probably would have been told to rest for a day before journeying on, but they were distinctly lacking in any of those, so Thorin’s stubborn resolve would have to win out.
Bilbo firmly believed that Thorin would not die again. He’d clung to it with unshakeable fortitude their whole journey so far. He would not ever have been given this life back if it was to go the same way, and Bilbo trusted to his own mind that he would be able to see them all through to the end. But this first brush had been a test, and it had been close, and Bilbo did not want anything to brush closer than it already had.
There was no need to worry, however. He felt he might have an inkling of what he was going to do about it.
Notes:
as always, my twitter is here!
also full disclosure, i'm worried that my aim to get chapters out as quickly as possible has meant i've been burning myself out, and i don't want to force myself to post anything i'm not happy with or didn't enjoy writing. because of this, i'm not sure when the next chapter will be out, and it might not be for a little while (although it shouldn't be too long, i promise!) thank you all for understanding!
UPDATE 05/05/2023: hi guys! i have no idea if anyone checks these notes, but i just wanted to pop in and say thank you all so much for being so patient and so sweet to me after i said i’d be back and then dipped for months. i absolutely promise that i will come back to this fic and i will keep posting chapters once i feel up to it - i do have a lot of the fic written including the epilogue, but it’s been a hectic year and i don’t want to force out subpar content just for the sake of posting on time.
i’m also in my final semester of uni and have accidentally fallen headfirst into a new hyperfixation so my brain isn’t really focused on this at the moment, but i promise i will be back and i will keep posting when i can. i’m so sorry i’ve kept you all waiting so long, but everyone being so lovely has made me smile a lot and i’m very grateful. feel free to find on twitter if you want to! i’m so sorry again!
Chapter 5: hello, my old heart
Notes:
all much-needed notes will be at the end :]
title taken from the song "hello, my old heart" by the oh hellos
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
“Do you have much experience in throwing knives, by any chance, Nori?” Bilbo asked through a mouthful of stew.
They’d set up camp at the foot of the Carrock after the long climb down the staircase, and the fire was crackling away in the dusky light, Oin and Gloin poking and prodding at it with drywood sticks. Nori was at present picking at his teeth with a dried-out reed from the riverbank nearby, and he pulled it out of his mouth to properly ponder Bilbo’s question, tilting his head to the side.
“Suppose I’ve got a bit, if you want to know,” he said. “More than anyone else here, at least.” He spun the reed between his fingers for a moment, then dropped it into the grass and leant back on both of his hands.
“They’re more of a sneak’s weapon. Most of us would gladly go charging off into battle with all sorts of hammers in our hands, but I’ve never been as inclined to brute strength as others, like Dori or Dwalin, for instance.” Nori paused for a moment. “Or Thorin.”
“Well, I’m sure even the strongest hobbit in all the Shire would be a great deal weaker than you lot,” Bilbo said astutely, and they all snickered.
“Why do you ask, Bilbo?” Balin questioned, pipe in hand and blinking at him over the flickering fire. Bilbo scrunched up his eyebrows in a frown and stared back the way they’d come.
“I saw Nori throw one when we were up in the trees. I would like to learn.”
This was met with some splutters from all directions, and a great deal of murmuring, though Bilbo could see when he cast his eyes around the camp that most of it was considering rather than doubtful.
“One taste of battle for that sword and you’re out for more orc-blood, Bilbo! Who knew!” Bofur cried, and the others all began to holler in agreement. Bilbo rolled his eyes, and was certain they were going to fall out of his head before journey’s end if he kept the habit up at such a pace.
“You are all utterly hopeless,” he mocked, and they chortled and cheered, and he could not quite keep the grin off his face.
“Really, though, I cannot go rushing off into the thick of battle every time we get ourselves into trouble. I was lucky today, but I am bound to be knocked down easily if I lose my sword, and I would rather have multiple ways of defending myself from danger. And," he added, "I am not a bad hand at conkers, as I have already made sure you all know.”
There was a moment of silence. “Have you?” Bombur asked unsurely.
Oh, Bilbo thought. That was the first journey, not the second. Well, no matter.
“Perhaps I haven’t, then,” Bilbo said, trying not to seem flustered. “The point is, I have something of an eye for throwing and aiming, and I would rather rely on something I can become skilled at than something I will never master, like Dwalin’s axes.”
He gestured vaguely off to the side, where Dwalin was propped up on the ground and running a sharpening tool along the curve of Grasper.
“I cannot wield great weapons, and Sting is enough for me, but I would still like to be sure.”
“Sting?” Thorin asked quietly.
His sudden voice startled Bilbo, his skin prickling with the memory of arms around him and whispered words in his ear. He had hardly been able to look at Thorin all day.
He cleared his throat, shaking his head into focus and pulling back the frayed edge of his coat to reveal the little sword sheathed in his belt. Thorin’s eyes were utterly unreadable over the fire as he watched the movement, and Bilbo had to swallow.
Kili’s eyes, however, brightened immediately.
“You really are out for blood now, aren’t you, Mr Bilbo! Naming your blade and all!” He looked around at the others, who were all still laughing merrily, and called out, “Orcs shall tremble at the thought of the mighty Sting!”
Bilbo flushed and looked back to Nori, who was grinning roguishly and looking quite pleased at the turn of events.
“So?”
“Ah, I wish you had asked me earlier, Bilbo,” Nori said, smirking. “I could have made off with a few more odds and ends from that Rivendell lot.”
Dwalin scowled.
“That’s all right,” Bilbo said. “We can make do for the moment, and I’m sure we can ask around once we arrive in Laketown. Or I’ve no doubt something will be lying around under the Mountain in this supposed treasure hoard of yours.”
“Aye, indeed,” Dori interjected, quite pointedly. “Lying around under a dragon, it seems.”
“Oh, bother old Smaug!” Bilbo said vehemently. “I don’t want to think about him until we absolutely have to!” He only felt a little guilty about how affronted Dori looked.
“It is a good idea, Bilbo,” Thorin said. He was holding one hand outward to the fire now, warming it up against the night air. His eyes flickered up to Bilbo’s once more, and his expression mellowed out, as though almost making one final peace offering.
Bilbo’s heart stuttered very momentarily in his chest. It was the first time Thorin had said his name.
Nori pulled three little flyblades from a hidden pocket in his cloak, and held them out to Bilbo. The sight of the sharp knife-edges was a little daunting, but Bilbo shook himself and took them with a sort of grim determination, clenching his jaw and trying to get used to the unfamiliar weight and curve in his fingers.
They could be quite hobbitish weapons, he supposed, the flyblades and Sting. Like one could be his pins and the other his needles. He chuckled at the thought.
Nori was by no means an expert, but all the dwarves at least knew how to throw, and so each of them helped him. Bilbo gradually learnt how to grip the handle of each knife, how to angle and direct them and throw with enough power that they would lodge in a tree, or hopefully, a throat, though he was still far from accomplished at that. By the end of the night his wrists were sore and could hardly move, and Bilbo felt almost bleary-eyed with exhaustion, but there was a warmth in his chest that would not settle, and he fell asleep in his bundle with a smile on his face.
It was short-lived. They were at it again the next morning, Nori letting Bilbo amateurly flick his knives as they walked across the broad plains and Fili and Kili making a game of who could find them in the grass the quickest, when Thorin seemed to materialise in front of them like a looming cloud.
(Bilbo’s feelings about him were still very muddled. He could still feel roughened fingers on the back of his neck. Having Thorin back to him was one thing, but having Thorin look at him with gentleness instead of disdain had completely floored Bilbo all over again.)
“I think you have practised enough for now, Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, falling into heavy step beside him. Nori had mysteriously disappeared almost immediately, and after some searching Bilbo found him far on the other side of the Company, seemingly in heated discussion with several other dwarves, including both of Thorin’s nephews. Fingers were pointing and flying in all directions, and at one point Nori turned back to him and smirked.
Peculiar.
Bilbo’s eyebrows creased in the middle. “It’s barely been a day.”
“It is not good for you.”
Thorin’s tone was low and decisive, and made Bilbo turn to look at him. His face was utterly still, betraying no emotion, and he did not look back at Bilbo, only trudging on forwards and keeping his eyes very firmly on the road.
“What in the world do you mean?” asked Bilbo crossly. “I’m not totally useless, you know. In fact, you do know now, so what exactly is the problem with me throwing a blade or two?”
You’d quite think having one's life saved would be enough to wake someone up.
He could see the sinews in Thorin’s jaw clench, the angle of his face tightening as he adjusted his shoulders and still did not look at Bilbo.
“It can be dangerous to practise too intensely with weapons when you are unused to them. You will hurt yourself.”
He said it quite stiffly, almost like he was forcing it out through his teeth. Bilbo frowned, now quite confused, and more than a little incensed.
“Shouldn’t I be trying to learn as fast as I am able?” I would have thought you would want me to help you on the journey, Thorin, my dear.
Thorin did not speak for a moment.
“Of course,” he said, after Bilbo had all but given up on him ever responding, “but you are going to damage your wrists if you keep at it like that. It is no good if you overwork yourself and cannot move at all.”
“I’m sure I can manage,” Bilbo bit back sarcastically.
Then Thorin’s mouth moved, and Bilbo realised in utter amazement that he was smiling very, very faintly. It changed all the lines in his face, smoothed them out and softened him so he was no longer the cool granite of the impervious King Under the Mountain; he was Thorin, Bilbo’s Thorin, and it was difficult not to draw a hand closer to brush the hair from his face.
“You should bind your wrists with cloth when you’re practising.” It was only in that moment that he finally looked back at Bilbo, eyes unusually open and that softened quirk of the mouth still there, and they walked side by side, studying each other’s faces. “You should be taking care of all the tools you have at your disposal, including the ones you use to wield your weapons.”
“Alright,” Bilbo conceded, not quite managing to keep the crossness out of his voice, “but there’s no need for you to hover over me like I cannot manage my own problems.”
“You have been hovering over us the entire journey.”
“Yes, well, I feel quite responsible for you all, and especially you, since… since you are the leader.”
Thorin brought his face back up to the path in front of them. “And we are all grateful for it, Master Baggins," he said, "but we can take care of ourselves.”
Bilbo’s nose twitched upwards, and a crease formed between his eyebrows. “Yes, that’s very evident after you nearly got yourself beheaded by orcs not two days ago.” His eyes cleared, and he looked over again to Thorin, who grunted in lieu of responding, because apparently he was now able to be sincere and lovely while still behaving as rude as ever.
His face was quiet and still, and his hair was blowing every which way in the wind.
(Bilbo could have watched Thorin’s hair for hours, though he couldn’t say what drew him so deeply to it. It spilled over everything like forks of dark lightning, what Bilbo imagined the sea in the West must look like on moonless nights, like ink spilling out across the vast expanse.)
He reminded Bilbo of the night, slowly coming into the day. And if Bilbo heard a murmured “Thank you”, too under his breath to say for certain, well, then, that was neither here nor there.
They walked by day and stopped only once the sun was fully set, the Great River of Anduin behind them and the creeping shadows of the treeline of Mirkwood inching closer and closer.
Quite a few of their Company had started to complain of aching limbs, weary from the battle and the lack of real rest they’d had since Rivendell, and they were desperate to stop for a day or two to replenish supplies and tend to their wounds. Bilbo felt terrible about having to push them onward, not least because he was sore and aching too, but Gandalf blessedly took the brunt of it for him.
“They are going to come after us,” he told them, in the early morning the day after their awful brush with the goblins, when the sky was still just purple wisps on the horizon and everybody’s eyes were still half-open. “It would be incredibly foolish to imagine that the goblins will stop hunting us after the damage we have done to their armies. You killed many of them, and they will want revenge.”
He’d told them that he knew of shelter nearby, only a couple of days journey more, and that it was the safest place they would likely find this side of the Wildlands. Bilbo had quickly piped up to say that he thought it was a grand idea, and that they were clearly quite lucky indeed they’d turned up so close to someone who seemed much more likely to help than hurt them.
He was deeply glad that he would get to see Beorn again. The part of Bilbo that came straight out of the Shire had been utterly enamoured by the gardens around the skin-changer’s house, and the painstakingly tender care he took of them, of all his creatures and seeds and fruits and flowers in equal measure. On his later return to Dale, Bilbo had even brought a little pocket-sized book and pencil to jot down the names of Beorn’s flowers in, in the hope that he could somehow give the information to Frodo or perhaps convince the Rivendell Elves that they needed to plant more than whimsical trees and green-leaved plants.
He’d been quite devastated to learn that Beorn had passed away some years before, and though his son and the rest of the Beornings had taken lovely care of his gardens, they hadn’t been the same. Then, Bilbo had felt awful that he was worrying about flowers and gardening upon hearing such news, and awful that he hadn’t ever written Beorn after their journey, so sure that one way or another he would see him again.
But then again, Beorn would likely have fallen in the War of the Ring, and Bilbo would have lost another friend anyhow.
He shook his head. No more of that. He blew the tangled locks from his face.
Each night they sat around a crackling campfire, and Bilbo told his stories, and the dwarves all sang songs, and they would patch clothes and sharpen blades for the day to come with their heads propped against each other’s legs, or a log, or the ground. Gandalf sat on the outskirts of the group and smoked his pipe with an unchanging expression of serene but sharp watchfulness.
He seemed to do that a lot, quite content to sit back and let the rumbling chatter of thirteen dwarves and one hobbit wash over him, only interjecting when one of them asked him a question, or they needed steering or saving. Bilbo was glad for the ease in his demeanour, for he was sure that Gandalf would have picked up on the true extent of his oddities if he was paying any closer attention.
Bilbo remembered a hardened wizard, weary and worn from the long years of the Third Age and the trials and tribulations it took to close them. He liked being able to see again a Gandalf who fell asleep against the trunks of trees with his hat over his face.
One night several of them went around and spoke fondly about their partners, telling Bilbo with such vividness about the homes they’d left behind and the little ways each of them had found their loved ones. Bombur asked Bilbo if he had anybody back at home, and Bilbo dropped his eyes and politely answered that no, he didn’t, that most of the hobbits in the Shire thought he was strange, and that truthfully he had never really been looking for any love he had not found already. He pretended very stubbornly that he could not see Balin watching him intently through the spirals of smoke floating upward.
To Bilbo’s complete and utter surprise, it was Thorin that spoke next.
“When our maker carved us from the mountains,” he said softly, “he split each of us in two, that we may be drawn back to our other half and become one heart in the stone again.” He seemed distant as he spoke, detached, like he could not feel any of the emotion his words evoked. Like it was all but foreign to him.
A few of the others echoed what he’d said, a chorus of soft ayes floating about the camp, like Thorin had said something heavier than Bilbo could tangibly feel. He kept on watching Thorin’s darkened face in the shadows.
“It is what we are told, when we are children, but I have never felt the pull the way others have described it to me. I do not think I was ever intended for it. I have been given responsibility instead.”
If others had been watching, they might have wondered whether the dwarf quite believed the words he’d spoken, when they saw the way the hobbit angled his body toward Thorin’s, their figures outlined in charcoal against the glow of the fire, their silhouettes bowed unconsciously and ever so slightly towards each other.
Others, perhaps, might have noticed that the hobbit’s body made gentle points of contact with the dwarf, at their hip-and-knee, at the brush of their shirts, chainmail catching on worn cloth, at the ends of Thorin’s hair and the top of Bilbo’s arm, dark threads kissing lightly at brown skin loved by sun. They might have noticed, even, that the dwarf had tilted his head ever so slightly downward, and that his eyes were resting unreadably on the line of the hobbit’s face, and his nose cutting bluntly against the darkness, his lips quirked in a soft smile and his hair hanging in his eyes.
The skyline was indigo and orange and deep hazel-pink, and it was like someone had upturned pots of syrupy-soft paint onto everyone’s heads, and still Bilbo and Thorin watched the fire flicker and let their gently mingling shadows cast into the colour behind them.
It was the last light of dusk the next day when Bilbo spotted the cottage in the distance, and around it, the fields of flowers in every colour imaginable.
They’d approached from behind, and Bilbo was sure only he and Gandalf had seen the intimidating figure hacking at the wood in the front garden, for they knew what to look for. The axe Beorn held was so large it made a great swooping noise through the air as he brought it downwards and split the trunk in two. Then he stepped back with one foot, lifted his head, and turned very suddenly to look them dead in the eye, like he’d heard them on the wind.
The sheer size of him was so intimidating Bilbo had to swallow and pull his shoulders up about him, even when he knew Beorn as a friend and not a danger.
“Good morning!” Gandalf said jovially, no tinge of apprehension or worry in his voice, though Bilbo knew it was very present in both of their minds. He lowered his head just slightly, and Bilbo followed suit by bending his back at far too deep an angle than was probably healthy for his body even at this age.
“Who are you,” said Beorn, in that booming voice, like the boughs of trees crashing down around them, “and what do you want?”
“I am Gandalf the Grey, kindred of Radagast the Brown of Rhosgobel, whom you know, I believe. I am counted as one of the Wise,” Gandalf said. Beorn’s mighty expression tweaked into one of shrewdness.
“A wizard, you say? And you have brought a rabbit with you!”
Oh, for heaven’s sake.
“We have come seeking shelter after a spot of bad luck in the mountains. We were ambushed by the goblins who dwell there, and our party is in need of rest and recuperation before we journey onward to the Long Lake.”
“Your party?” Beorn said, immediately suspicious, and here we go, Bilbo thought with a grimace, remembering the tedious way Gandalf had revealed them all, one after the other. Beorn’s incredibly bushy brows had already risen halfway up his forehead. “I do not call two a party, wizard.”
Bilbo watched Gandalf assemble his wrinkled, ageless features into an appropriately abashed expression, tilting the brim of his hat just so.
“I did not want to startle you with so many companions all at once and overextend your hospitality, but we -”
“Dwarves!” Bilbo blurted in a rising panic.
Gandalf and Beorn both peered down at him with mirrored expressions of curiosity, though Gandalf’s was far too eager, and Beorn’s far too hostile.
Bilbo decided that cursing under his breath about his blunder was going to be rather useless, so he didn’t bother. He’d dug the grave, and now he would simply have to lie in it.
“There are dwarves, accompanying us,” Bilbo said. “Thirteen of them, you should know, no point beating around the bush about it, and of course we’ve heard that you don’t like dwarves all too well, and you’re probably quite right to be wary of unfamiliar folk around these parts, I should think, but they are kind dwarves, and I rather think they might surprise you!”
Beorn did not even acknowledge a single word Bilbo had said.
“He is not a rabbit at all,” he said, immediately turning towards Gandalf, his voice quite even-tempered for one so easy to aggravate the way Bilbo just had. “He is too chattery. A squirrel.”
Bilbo bit the bottom of his lip quite hard, urging himself not to roll his eyes. It really was becoming a terrible habit.
“I am not a squirrel, Master Beorn, I am a hobbit, and I have been hired for a most important task, but we’ve run into some trouble on the way, and I would like it if my friends were safe for a day or two, if you please. I promise you they will be on their best behaviour.”
Beorn bent at the knee and knelt down closer to Bilbo, so his enormity was more apparent, and Bilbo’s lack of even more so.
“You are a very long way from home, little halfling. Why do you travel with a band of dwarves?”
“Quite right, my dear fellow. I think it is only fair that our burglar should tell you the story,” Gandalf said, immediately putting Bilbo on the spot, no doubt in retaliation, and only glancing down at him with a cryptic smile when Bilbo looked upwards in betrayal.
And so he began, using every bit of his wits, and the traces he could remember of Gandalf’s tale the first time around, and what little skill he still remembered from when he was young and Belladonna had told him stories of all her days out in the wide world beyond. He told Beorn of trees miles tall, towering in the gully with goblins all around like a ring of terror closing in. He told of wargs with pink-stained teeth like knife blades, and the frantic dash from the front door of the caves all the way to the cliffside, and the last hope of the eagles coming for them like a beacon in the night.
By the end of it all, he was quite out of breath and his voice was sore. He watched Beorn mouth at a pipe clasped between his large fingers, leaning back against several bales of hay and eyeing them both with renewed interest.
“Your tale is a grand one, even if there might be untruth in it, and I am glad of your courage against those foul goblins in the mountains. I do not like them. I will let you stay.”
The following morning brought spaces next to him amongst the hay that were body-warm and smelt like straw, and a bleary-eyed Bilbo tottering into the larger room to find his dwarves strewn about the place, the table laden with thickly dripping honey-cakes and warm white bread and fresh fruit like rubies in large wooden bowls. The tea leaves Beorn had in jars lining the walls were loose and leafy-green, not like any sort of tea Bilbo had tasted before, and they left a sagey sweetness floating in his mouth.
(The gargantuan size of the house made Bilbo realise how utterly strange it had been to stay somewhere made for his own size, that single day he’d spent back in Bag End. He’d been living for far too long amongst Big Folk. Even the staggering enormity of the Lonely Mountain didn’t seem so intimidating anymore, though Bilbo was sure he’d change his tune once he was face to face with the dragon living inside again.)
Gandalf disappeared for much of that first day, of course, as did Beorn, which was probably fortunate for everyone in their Company who was not Bilbo, since that way they would not be able to see the disgruntled expression Beorn had been wearing since the dwarves had entered his house. The rest of them spent most of it lazing around, resting aches and knuckling at knots in their backs from twinged muscles. Poor Oin was rushing around all day with herbs clasped in his hands, now that they had time to spare and a place to heal for a little while before the journey had to carry on.
Bilbo mostly spent his time, and, indeed, the few days after that, in the meadows surrounding Beorn’s house. The green plains and heatherfields stretched impossibly on for miles, unbroken by rolling hills or streams like the ones of his home country.
He’d forgotten how big the bees were.
A few times, Bofur or Kili or Ori wandered outside and visited him for a chat, and Bilbo spent quite a lovely afternoon walking Bifur through the thickets of flowers and teaching him the meanings of each and every one. Bifur had been delighted to discover that not only did each flower tell them something different, but that the colours of flowers told different stories, too. He had been utterly taken by all the yellows in every variety of rose and pansy, and he and Bilbo had picked yellow carnations in Beorn’s garden to give to all the other dwarves as a token of strengthened friendship, to much cheer and gratitude.
He lived within the promising smell of rain, welcome now in the fading of summer rather than the dreary trudging through mud and muck they’d struggled through back in the West. The gentle golden showers that lit the morning in fragments of sunlight reminded Bilbo of the Shire of his childhood, and of easy moments with his mother in their garden, touching at the dewdrops that rested on every leaf in wonder and listening to her spin tales of faeries living in mushrooms and acorns while holding her hand in his fingers.
One morning, he’d even woken up to Thorin Oakenshield peering down at him from where he was standing above.
“What on earth are you doing? It's very odd to watch someone while they’re asleep, you know.”
“You had your mouth open,” Thorin said. He seemed inquisitive. Bilbo bristled.
“And you’re the picture of serenity when all your defences are down, are you?”
“Fili and Kili wanted to put things in it.”
“Oh, that’s -”
But most of the time, Bilbo was alone in the sun, the dew cool under his feet and his eyes closed to the warm air. It felt like years were falling off his shoulders.
He could not explain what drew him so dearly to the flowers and the breeze, except that it felt like he was standing among friends. His friends in the house, and his solace in the flowers that had been a comfort where there’d been nothing else, and the love that had blossomed in his chest so long ago and bloomed still every day.
There were many happy moments in Bilbo’s long life where he had stopped in the thick of them and realised that they would be gone far too soon, that they would fade from present tense to past tense, like fingering through a journal and touching at the worn pages with a bittersweet smile. The night he’d left Frodo and the Shire had been like that, and he’d felt it deeply, the knowledge that their strange little semblance of a family would become something that had once been rather than something that still was. It was something he had only become conscious of after the first journey, when he hadn’t realised the importance of every tiny moment with the thirteen of them, or the three of them, or the one that flickered in his heart like gentle trees in the breeze.
It was very slowly dawning on Bilbo that he didn’t have to exist on only memories anymore.
(Unbeknownst to Bilbo, there was a dwarf that would sometimes sit on the steps of the house, leaning against the bannister and silently watching the little figure far away in the fields. He was quite perplexed by the hobbit, and the way he would stand utterly still for hours, just breathing, hearing the wind whisper and the bees buzz.
It was very probable that Thorin Oakenshield did not know what to make of Bilbo Baggins, especially after he’d finally succumbed enough and let down his guard. He was a curious creature, and Thorin almost felt compelled to study him, wondering what in the world it was he could be doing out there amongst the grass and sky.)
It was on one such occasion when Bilbo Baggins was standing in a meadow of deep pinks and pale blues and greens and dazzling oranges, eyes closed, the content smile he always seemed to wear resting on his face.
Nearby, a dwarf cloaked in furs and mail and royal blue slowly made his way up to the hobbit, paying close attention so as to not disturb him, so peaceful did he look among the amber-lit blossoms blowing gently in the wind.
As the dwarf watched, a lone tear slipped down Bilbo’s cheek, and though he had not spoken, the hobbit sensed him anyway.
“It isn’t allergies.”
He did not turn around, but brought his hand up to wipe at his cheek and nose before letting it drop again.
“I was just - thinking,” the hobbit said. “I had a beautiful garden, back at home, and sometimes I miss it very much.”
“I remember.”
Bilbo’s eyes flickered open and focused on Thorin, and the ends of his hair were blowing gently in the breeze, and his eyes must have seemed an even richer brown, somehow, in the late afternoon sun. Thorin Oakenshield continued, more slowly.
“You told Fili and Kili of it once. I remember.”
“I didn’t realise you were listening.”
Bilbo Baggins bent at the waist, bringing his face closer to the rows of colour and the pollen dust spiralling up from them, so slowly it was like they were suspended in water. His entire body seemed to soften as the dwarf watched, and all the lines in his shoulders and face disappeared.
“Yes, well, the flowers are simply reminding me of it, somehow. Do you know what it is any of them are for? ” He turned to look inquisitively at Thorin, who shook his head slowly.
“Not many dwarves deal with plants,” he said, angling his head a little so he was facing away from the glare of sunlight. “Oin is one of the few I have known who do, and he works mainly with medicinal herbs, not with plants grown for beauty. I... suppose not many of my people ever stop to see the beauty in living things.”
Bilbo Baggins let his mouth tug upward, looking up at the face now cast in cool shadow, the eyes washed out in grey and angled down to him.
“Oh, I don’t know. I think that jewels and precious stones are living things, in their own way,” he said. “They’re shaped by the world, the same way rivers and hills are.”
“I would not think you had seen many beautiful stones in the Shire.”
The hobbit closed his eyes. “Well, there’s always my imagination.”
He brushed his fingers gently up the stem of a flowerbud, till he was cupping the petals in his palm.
“They’re tulips.” He spoke softly, and there was a small smile on his face, and Thorin looked away, squinting out at the horizon in the distance instead. “I used to love tulips, when I was a lad. They mean passionate and romantic love, and some say they symbolise love that is maddening, all-consuming. I would run all around the little hills and gullies and pretend that I was in a storybook, and that someone was going to fall madly in love with me after I saved them from dragons and trolls.”
That soft smile hadn’t moved from Bilbo’s face, and the warmth of the sunset flecked in his hair and made his eyes glow as he rose to his feet. “Sometimes my dear dad would say that I was being completely silly, and that love should mean you have your head set on your shoulders properly and you don’t go batty when you look at them, or they look at you. But my mother thought he was full of tosh, and they were more in love than anyone I knew.” He smiled wider. “Ah, but Bilbo, she would say, if you are not a little mad about your dear heart when you find them, then what is the use of anything at all? She used to gift him tulips, red ones, just to make him laugh.”
“She sounds charming.”
“She was friends with Gandalf.”
Thorin cut his eyes to the side at once, and Bilbo laughed.
“Yes, I know. It is a wonder I took so much convincing to accompany you on this quest when I was raised by Belladonna Took.”
Thorin kept looking at him. “I do not recall you taking much convincing at all,” he said quietly.
Bilbo blinked, and his eyes softened. He was beginning to get the look he got when things far away were whirling gently through his mind, and he became lost in them.
“No. No, I suppose I did not, in the end.” He looked away, squinting into the distance at the setting sun and the gold film it created over everything they could see. “I must have known that I would need to follow you, Thorin Oakenshield.”
Thorin’s gaze dropped to the field of flowers before them, looking very intently at the red tulips by his knees. His face was contemplative. He furrowed his brow.
“Before the dragon came,” he said, lowly, hesitantly, “there were flowers that grew around the Mountain. Snapdragons. My sister loved them, and she used to make us pick them with her.” He paused. “I remember the way that they smelled.”
This made Bilbo laugh and tilt his head upward, though his eyes had somehow become inexplicably sad.
“Snapdragons were one of the flowers in my garden.”
Snapdragons for strength, grace and power, for they grew in barren and rocky places when no other life would, and nothing had ever reminded him of Thorin Oakenshield so much.
He closed his eyes again. Anyone watching the two would have noticed the way Thorin’s eyes passed over the freckles on Bilbo’s nose, sure that there had been less the last time he’d looked, the flecks dark against his brown skin. They ran down the wide slope of it to spread outwards along his cheeks, and spanned further out across his forehead and down around his mouth and chin.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said finally, after neither of them had spoken for more than a couple of moments, “why did you come out here?”
The dwarf was quiet, for a moment, perhaps because he did not have the answer himself, perhaps because to speak too soon would disturb the silence.
“You have come out here each day since we arrived,” he settled on, watching Bilbo out of the corner of his eye. “I wished to know why. I wished to… atone for my actions, Master Baggins.”
“Thorin, I have not taken your wariness of me personally. Please don’t feel guilty. I am not upset, and you don’t need to try and make nice with me over it.”
At that, however, a touch of the old anger crept into Thorin’s face.
“I would not speak to you out of obligation, or for some shallow reason you seem to think I am capable of,” the dwarf said, his voice like embers, his gaze unbreaking. “You are part of our Company. You saved my life. And somehow, you are more steadfast and loyal than even I feel leading my own people.” He seemed to steady himself, watching the grassblades in the breeze beyond Bilbo for a moment before his eyes focused on the hobbit again. “You seem as though you have a lot to teach people, Master Baggins, and I would like to learn.”
(It could be said, some might suggest, that the dwarf was starting to feel some sort of something about the hobbit. Kinship, perhaps, or rare, true friendship he had never thought to search for beyond the borders of his own kind, for no one had ever shown it to him in return. Awareness, certainly. A presence of the hobbit in his mind where he hadn’t been before, of where he stood in the group and where he was at Thorin’s side, bare-footed, tousle-haired, and as chirpily cross as ever. A Bilbo-Baggins-shaped thought in his slow breaths and quiet contemplation, and an unfurling in his chest.)
So long living in Elven halls of clear cold air with streams and flowers and birds all around had left Bilbo very ill-prepared for their journey into Mirkwood, and once they’d gone in, his head immediately began to swim.
They had left Beorn’s cottage at first light, each armed to the teeth with stockpiles of food and water, as much as Bilbo had been able to force them all to carry, and they’d bid farewell to Gandalf at the border; an ordeal that had been much less dramatic with two voices rather than one reassuring them all that they would be fine.
(Bilbo was very sorry to see Beorn and his honey-cakes go, and he was sure not a few of the dwarves were feeling similarly downtrodden about it, but he’d auspiciously asked his old friend for the recipe, and he was planning a mighty surprise for them once this whole mess was over and done with.)
The last time he’d travelled through the forest, in the later days of his life, the air had been clean and fresh through the trees, and the memories of eyes in the dark and horrors in the shadows had faded out like gentle running water through his fingers. It made going back into the endarkened forest a great deal harder than it had been then.
Bilbo tried his hardest to keep the cheer of the Company up, knowing they would have no fires and no warmth and nowhere that was quite safe for some time, and it did work for a little while. He told them stories and jokes, and he asked each of them about all the little parts of their lives, and he threw knives at the moss-covered ground with Nori because they were both wary of throwing them at the trees and accidentally angering whatever was lurking behind or within. And Bilbo had never heard tell of it, so he was sure he was acting quite paranoid, but he felt that the trees in this forest were alive, too, and he would not make himself an enemy of them.
He watched Bifur and Bofur whittle down twigs and old bits of branch into tiny wooden toys, delicate and lovely resting in their hands, and he resolved to ask them for help on a birthday present once Frodo was born in this lifetime. He lent Ori his pencils when Ori dropped his own on the forest floor and a prowling limb crept out from below a tree root and snatched them away.
But the darkness ate away at them slowly, and Bilbo had to work harder and harder to keep their hearts light and looking ahead, to the peak of the Lonely Mountain so far in the distance. It was no form of darkness they were used to, either; dwarves were borne of the safety and sturdy endurance of stone and rock, and they felt at home deep beneath the earth, but this darkness was thick and muggy in their throats and wet on their breaths, and the twisting canopy of the trees that reached out with creeping fingers above them made it feel as though they’d been trapped below the surface of a lake. Every day, eyes would gather in the gloom and watch them, faint yellow and grinning menacingly at their camp all huddled together in fear. They did not dare light a single fire or use a single flint, and they lived on all the additional bread and nuts Bilbo had been able to beg off Beorn.
The air became stagnant and foul, and all the while it grew darker and darker, as if they were being boiled in a pot of soup and had started to drown. The trees shuddered all around them. It was as though the darkness in the ruins of Dol Guldur was slithering up through the forest, and they could do nothing but trudge onward, stumbling and choking on the tepid air like a black breath all around. They slept in piles huddled up against each other, hiding from the cold and the dark and using their own bodies for what little safety and warmth they could find.
Every now and again they would see traces of spiderweb skirting the path, dewy against the damp leaves coating the floor and twining through all the tree roots like a net cast over everything. Bilbo would hurriedly lead them as close to the other side of the path as he dared when this happened, and the few strange or questioning looks he got did not worry him nearly as much as the thought of those hulking black bodies and limbs and eyes, everywhere.
He knew his Sting could handle them, and that if he must, he would brave the spiders as valiantly as he had before, but the thought of legs crawling all over had plagued his dreams long after he had set foot in Bag End again, and the memory of Sam and Frodo’s hushed whispers of nightmares that lurked in the high passes of Mordor were still fresh and painful in his mind.
Sometimes Bilbo glumly wondered why he couldn’t have woken up a little closer to the Mountain, in a nice cosy bed in Laketown, perhaps, or even inside of a barrel floating down a river. And then he would sit under the black canopy with nothing but looming shadows all around, and think about the darkest places of the world, ones he could scarcely imagine and yet ones his loved ones had had to brave, and he would muster up the courage to keep putting one foot in front of the other.
“Do you remember the story I told months ago around the fire, the one about the Three Hunters?” Bilbo asked, yawning, leant backwards against the damp log he was resting on.
“How could we forget, Bilbo?” Bofur called back.
“Indeed,” Balin said, smiling fondly at Bilbo from where he was sitting nearby. “The marvel of hobbits.”
“That traitorous dwarf,” Kili said feistily. “What I wouldn’t do to get my hands on him and give him a good shake!”
“What about the Three Hunters?” Thorin asked. He was sitting further along Bilbo’s log, near Fili.
“Well, I was thinking about whether there were any other songs of mine I could teach you all, perhaps once we’re out of here. The Man in that story was descended from the High Kings of old, and I made up a song for him.”
He looked up at them all blinking at him, and only when Thorin extended his hand out in a silent gesture to begin did he belatedly realise it was in anticipation. He cleared his throat.
“All that is gold does not glitter
Not all those who wander are lost,
The old that is strong does not wither
Deep roots are not reached by the frost
From the ashes a fire shall be woken
A light from the shadows shall spring,
Renewed shall be Blade that was Broken
The crownless again shall be king.”
The dwarves all applauded, but quietly, still wary of things following them in the woods. “That was beautiful, laddie,” Balin said, and he got quite a few noises of approval.
“It was a good story, and well-told,” Thorin agreed, and Bilbo very carefully did not think about what a contrast it was between how he’d reacted upon hearing the story the first time, and he very carefully did not let the tips of his ears turn pink. For a small second, he was rather thankful it was so dark in this dreadful, nasty forest.
“Oh, it’s nothing special,” Bilbo said, waving Thorin away. “I’ve been tinkering with it for years.”
“Why did you choose an Elf and a dwarf?” Fili asked, from Thorin’s other side. Both of them were watching him, their silhouettes so similar; Fili’s gaze curious and Thorin’s heavy as always. Bilbo decided to ignore the latter for the moment.
“I think that in times of peril,” he said, “old hatreds will always be cast aside, and I think there are more important things in the world than spite from long ago.”
“You sound like the wizard,” Thorin said gruffly. Bilbo laughed in delight.
Thorin seemed to peer at him through the gloom, and it was infuriating how inscrutable he was. He was watching Bilbo calmly, his eyes trained steadily on Bilbo’s, though sometimes they would fall to the sides of his face or flit upwards whenever Bilbo blew a lock of hair out of his eyes. The intensity of his stare had not faded through time, and Bilbo occasionally got the feeling that Thorin was watching on long after Bilbo lost the courage to hold his gaze.
“You knew we would not take so kindly to it,” he said. Bilbo scoffed, though he meant it good-naturedly.
“Well, then, it’s good that I have a backbone, isn’t it?”
The sides of Thorin’s mouth quirked upward slightly, and Bilbo looked away.
So strange, how such a small smile could change a whole face so completely, just the smallest tug at the corner of the lips. So strange how he’d remembered every detail of it so perfectly, and yet even still it managed to capture his breath.
“Indeed,” Thorin was saying, a dash of humour in his voice. “They might start to call you Bilbo Braveheart, if you’re not careful.”
Bilbo chuckled, feeling his face warm and cursing his ridiculous Baggins genes for granting him the gift of being perpetually flustered. Belladonna Took would be ashamed of him, crumbling completely at the first sight of any affection at all. He must chase you into the hills, Bilbo!
He’s not going to be chasing me anywhere, Ma, except out of his mountain very soon whilst brandishing a sword.
“I’m glad you think so now,” Bilbo said.
Thorin looked at him sharply. “What?”
“Well, when you hated me -”
“I didn’t hate you.”
Bilbo blinked at Thorin, his face only half-visible in the overgrown darkness. Thorin swallowed softly, and spoke again.
“I did not hate you, Master Baggins. I didn’t… understand you. You were not at all what I expected.” He seemed to look up at Bilbo then, though Bilbo couldn’t be sure. His head had not moved.
“You were much kinder. It unsettled me. And I did not listen when you told us you were capable.”
His mouth made a strange movement sort of akin to a smirk, more a flash of teeth in the dark, really, and he turned to the side to look through the shadowy trees. “I know now what a blunder that was. You’ve never let any of us forget it, have you, Bilbo?”
Bilbo felt equal parts affronted and stupidly pleased.
They kept on the path. Bilbo had no idea how far in they were. To his memory the journey had only taken a matter of days the first time, but the sprawling darkness was so thick in their eyes and noses and mouths that all his thoughts of Mirkwood dragged on and on, until he wasn’t sure whether they were even taking the right path at all, and started to feel sure they must have been inside for months on end.
He wondered if he should climb up into the treetops once more, but all of them were so very tired, and he was terrified that he would wake the spiders by touching their webs without meaning to.
The darkness was suffocating. It almost felt as though the cold silence of the leaves above were dripping down around their necks, along their shoulders and in their eyes so their heads became heavier with it. The exhaustion was potent, and all of them could feel it creeping into their conversations with more and more sharpness.
“This forest is not well.”
They were marching in a line, in a pack, the bags strapped to their backs now all but empty. It was Bilbo who had spoken, his quiet voice going unheard by most of them in the muggy nothingness. He cleared his throat and called out again. “We have to ration our food better, or we are going to starve.”
A few of them looked around, or hesitated, looking back at the path ahead, but Thorin trudged on, not looking down at Bilbo or even making any acknowledgement of the fact he had spoken for a long moment until he gruffly replied, “We are already starving.”
His browbone was so deeply bent into a frown that it looked as though he were perpetually carrying around boulders that hung from his forehead. The line between his eyebrows was carved like a scar.
Bilbo kept on stubbornly. “I know that, but this forest is bigger than you think, and the road is long. It is better to conserve what we have.”
“How can you know that?”
“Because I read, Thorin,” Bilbo said, bristling immediately. His already questionable temper had shortened to a nub in this forest.
“There is much more to embarking on a quest than reading books, Master Baggins,” Thorin said in that low, unwavering voice of his. “Your resolve is admirable, but we cannot afford to sacrifice any more than we have already. We are weak enough as it is.”
“I’m hungry, too! But I would rather be hungry now and alive later, than starved and lost in the woods until I crumble away into dust. We aren’t yet close enough to the edge.”
Bilbo marched faster, right up to Thorin and in front of him before whirling himself around so Thorin had no choice but to stop.
“It is the forest that’s draining us,” Bilbo insisted, now wholly aggravated. “There is a shadow upon it, which you well heard Gandalf and Beorn say, too, so don’t you frown at me with those irritating eyebrows of yours!”
“You have never even seen this forest before, much less travelled through it -”
“All the more reason to rely upon my common sense! You can’t think you know everything just because you lived in the North once upon a time, you stubborn -”
A heavy object thwacked against Bilbo’s arm, and he cried out, startled. Both his and Thorin’s heads whipped around to see Fili watching them a little guiltily, arm aloft, but with a determined frown on his face.
“Sorry, Bilbo, that was intended for my uncle, but - will you two give up? You are both being much too loud, and we aren’t safe here. You’re attracting danger!”
Bilbo cleared his throat at once and shuffled away from Thorin, embarrassed. Thorin scowled at Fili. Every one of them had stopped walking, now, and were gathered in a cluttered little circle in front of the guilty party. They all looked exhausted down to their very bones, and Bilbo swallowed down the rush of guilt it brought to fix his frown on the vexatious creature to his right.
“If Bilbo thinks we should ration, then we should ration,” Nori said.
“Ration what? We are living on scraps as it is,” growled Dwalin, crossing his arms and turning his gaze to their leader. The others all followed suit.
Thorin’s expression was not angered, but he held his body very still, as though he was trying to restrain himself, or keep some semblance of calm. His eyes hadn’t strayed from Bilbo’s, who shot back a triumphant glare and tried not to push out his jaw too much in satisfaction.
“Thorin,” Balin said, somewhat placatingly, “we can replenish when we are safely out of these woods, fill our bellies all we want, but Bilbo is right. We are of no use to anyone if we run out of supplies before we reach safety. We will fade away into nothing.”
Thorin watched Balin with an utterly unreadable gaze, and then looked back at Bilbo standing impudently in front of him. They stared each other down. Bilbo wished he could have been standing on an incline so he could have given Thorin a good and proper eyeing, but he’d made do so far.
“Trust me,” he said, never letting his eyes move from Thorin’s face.
Thorin was very still for several moments. “Very well,” he said quietly, eyes thunderous, clearly restraining himself, watching Bilbo with the weight of those boulders on his brow. “I will trust you.”
Bilbo took a step back, nodding once and huffing out an exasperated sigh. Good, then. At least he was finally listening to some outside opinion instead of simply charging on like a mad bull.
“I trust your books tell you what to do when we’ve lost the path, Master Baggins?”
Oh, that was it. And really, he’d had quite enough of dwarvish tempers in his first lifetime.
“Oh, you’re one hundred and ninety-five, Thorin,” Bilbo snapped. “Stop acting like a fauntling without his breakfasts.”
“Breakfast,” Dwalin of all people corrected automatically, before frowning and looking to Bilbo like he was aggravated Bilbo had snuck his way into his train of thought.
“Breakfasts. We have two in the Shire.”
Thorin’s eyes widened, just barely, and Bilbo knew him well enough to know this was an expression of alarm.
“Have we not been feeding you properly?” someone cried from across the opposite side of the group. Bilbo thought it might have been Ori.
It was so bizarre and out of place in the festering darkness and the near-argument they’d all found themselves in that Bilbo laughed, loudly, throwing back his head and chuckling towards the weak slants of light fingering their way through the treetops. It sounded unnatural in the ringing quiet of the forest.
“I am quite all right, don’t worry. I make do with what we all have." He smiled at them all. “And second breakfast is more for the littluns anyway, while they’re young and still growing. I’d make do with nothing but a cup of tea every now and again, if we had any to spare.” He crushed a handful of dampened leaves under his toes until they flaked into pieces, mourning briefly the loss of a good brew of tea leaves, or better yet, a solid batch of pipeweed.
“You are not starving me, Thorin. I’m tougher than nails, little old me.”
“Yes," Thorin said, the fight all but gone from the frame of his body, "I’m beginning to think you are.”
They began to walk again. After some silence, Thorin said, “I had not realised that I had told you my age.” When Bilbo hummed and looked up at him, the dwarf was already watching him in guarded curiosity.
“Oh -" well, then "- you hear things, here and there, you know. You didn’t think I spent all that time chatting with the entire Company just to twiddle our thumbs and talk about different types of grass, did you?”
“How old are you then, Bilbo?” piped up Bofur, and Bilbo scratched at his throat absent-mindedly as he walked, debating on his answer for a moment.
“Well, I suppose I am fifty, and very nearly fifty-one.”
Before the dwarves could do much more than blanch at his words, their eyes wide in identical expressions of shock, Bilbo held up his arms to placate them.
“Please don’t all lose your heads, you silly things! Hobbits live for much less time than dwarves. I am well into adulthood, and well on my way to my greying years, if you must know. But the oldest hobbit that ever was lived to be one hundred and thirty-two, and he was a Baggins.”
He tried very hard not to sound too pleased with himself. It really was one of his proudest achievements, if Bilbo was being honest.
(Which of course, he was not.)
Perhaps the worst of the long, dragging days in the chasm of the forest was its utter stagnancy. Each day was the same, and each the same as the nights. They had no way of knowing whether it was dawn or dusk or the smallest hours of the morning for certain. The trek became one single suffocating pull into the darkness; no reprieve, and no replenishing.
“I suppose I should simply learn to deal with it, shouldn’t I, my lad?”
There was no wind to carry his words to Frodo, and so Bilbo would have to hope that they’d find their way on the leaves. He hoped they wouldn’t curdle with sickness the way the forest had. He didn’t want Frodo to worry about him.
He was sat a small ways away from the rest already dozing, staring down the dark, face tilted upwards to give his whispers the best chance of finding their way.
“I can’t help but think of you and Sam, out there in the cold, up in the mountains with the wind battering you.” He looked down at his hands, buried again in the remains of leaves, brown like mulch against his fingers. “I’m barely able to imagine it, Frodo. I would have curled up until the wolves found me. I hope you aren’t still plagued with nightmares.”
“You are whispering again,” Thorin’s unmistakable voice said softly behind him.
Bilbo startled and pulled his shoulders up, glancing back to the shadowed figure looming close by. They watched each other for a moment, barely even black shapes in the darkness, before Bilbo looked again out at the unknown void.
“Were you praying?”
The rumble of his voice felt almost like the floor was shaking underneath their feet. Like the air was shaking. Bilbo shook his head lightly and ground his fingers into the soil.
“Not praying. Remembering.” He didn’t mind as much, now, if the others saw him talking to the wind, but to explain it to them was much too heavy an ask.
“You were remembering then, too, weren’t you?” Thorin asked. “In the Misty Mountains.” Bilbo looked over at him and nodded wordlessly.
The silence held for a few more moments, and then: “I am sorry I did not show you empathy.”
There was a crease between Thorin’s brows when Bilbo looked towards him, and his eyes were wide and open in his face. It took Bilbo a moment to recognise it as regret, and the gesture as an apology.
He knew Thorin carried his own dead with him, brother and mother and lost father, and that he understood now the burden Bilbo had shouldered. He wished he could smooth that little crease away with his fingers.
“It’s quite all right, Thorin. I cannot spend all my time thinking over things that have already passed.”
If he told it to himself enough times, one day he might even believe it.
Thorin turned to watch the trees the way Bilbo had been, the fabric of his trousers brushing the skin of Bilbo’s leg.
“We dwarves speak to our dead sometimes, too. We believe that our forefathers are watching over us, and that their guidance will lead us to where we need to go.”
Bilbo’s mouth twisted and he dropped his eyes to the ground. “Well, I don’t know about that,” he said, “but I find talking to the wind more helpful than keeping everything all bottled up inside.”
“Is there somewhere in particular you wish for it to carry your words?”
Bilbo looked down at the darkness in front of them. “If there is, I don’t know if they will find it.”
He turned his head to the side and looked back at their camp not far away. A thin slice of moonlight had cut its way through the canopy and illuminated the pile the Company had haphazardly assorted themselves into, making them all look too still, too eerie for Bilbo’s liking. He watched their breaths, counted them. Tried not to think of Frodo, and of every other person he had ever known who had been lost. He wished with almost a burning ferocity that just once, they could have lit a fire in the forest, given themselves warmth and light and brought cheer amongst all of it.
“Thorin?”
Bilbo turned back to see Thorin looking in the same direction he had been, watching over them, ever his way. He made a quiet noise of acknowledgement, and Bilbo swallowed.
“Do you remember your mother?”
Thorin looked back at him, and Bilbo felt his own expression contort in pity. Thorin’s face looked as though it were being held together by porcelain in the dim light; his eyes were heavy and his mouth thin.
“You were very young when she passed, weren’t you?”
“I remember her,” Thorin said quietly, his voice deep and rasping. He ducked his head, and strands of hair fell forwards to hang around his face. Together they looked down at the forest floor, watching a line of black ants crawl past in the dirt.
“She looked like my brother. She acted like him, too; my sister and I were graced with much more of our father’s bearing.” There was such reverence in the solemn way he spoke that Bilbo could feel how much Thorin missed them as deeply as if the dwarf had wept openly in front of him.
“Did you have siblings, Master Baggins? Do you?” He did not look at Bilbo as he spoke.
“No,” he said quietly, watching Thorin watch the forest move with trepidation. Their breaths felt thick in the silence and the darkness of each leaf and vine congealing above their heads. He wished again that they could be far, far away from Mirkwood. “I have lost family that I love with all my soul, but it was only ever me growing up in my hobbit-hole.”
“Is it that which makes you seem so lonely?”
They looked at each other.
“Not quite, I don’t think,” Bilbo said gently.
Their supplies dwindled, and the fourteen of them continued to portion out what precious little they had, bare sips of water from skins that eventually dried up and nibbles here and there of the blandest nuts they still had left. The hunger was not any easier to bear the second time.
Bilbo let himself bear the brunt of it, trudging on and telling himself that it would soon clear, that continuing on was all they could do while the hunger crept in, and so continue on they must. He kept his head down and his hand clenching gently at his sides, clutching at the strap of his pack with tense, pale fingers like it would somehow anchor him to the ground in case his weakening knees got the better of him.
It was why when, one night amongst their pile of huddled dwarves-and-one-hobbit, he heard a murmured, “There’s a light in the distance,” from Dwalin, he was so awfully, terribly, drastically unprepared.
“Keep your head down”, you complete ninny, well now it’s not going to matter at all whether you held out from starving when you’re all locked up in the dungeons again!
Bilbo was utterly furious with himself, and he pushed himself up from the wet forest floor with the intention of stopping the conversation before it began, staggering a little before he made it upright. But to his horror, Dwalin was already on his feet, one sturdy hand against the bark of a tree as he leant forwards to peer into the gloom at the devilish little ray of light, and others were following him, musing sluggishly about whether they might find food or aid, and how they had better just go check, just in case. They were all moving in a complete daze, endless days in shadow and the lack of food or water eating away at them, and everything seemed to slow down as Dwalin beckoned with his other hand.
“Come on.”
Oh, no. Bilbo hadn’t realised how close they were to the Elves, how close they were to -
How could you have not planned for this? What on Earth did you think was going to happen when we reached the Elves, or god forbid, the spiders?
They were stumbling, then racing, through the strangled tree-roots and the sodden leaves rotting in the darkness, towards that faint, flickering glow.
Bilbo could barely raise his own voice, weak and weary as they all were, and he chased after them uselessly on feet that felt like leaden weights attached to his legs. He called out to them over and over, begging them to stop running, please, it’s not safe, Fili, Oin, Gloin, we have to stay together, you don’t know what that light is! But not one of them turned around.
They were getting closer now, and Bilbo could see the lines of logs in the fire, and the dancing of the light as the Elves twirled round and round. The Company were beginning to reach the edge of the clearing; heads of light and dark hair were receding into the trees, ready to pull the darkness over their eyes, and with a mounting sense of dread, Bilbo pushed himself hard against the dizziness creeping in and threw himself at Thorin.
It wouldn’t ever have worked on a normal day, when the both of them were rested and fed and Thorin had the wits of a warrior about him, but Thorin’s knees buckled under the sudden weight and the two of them went crashing down. He immediately began to thrash around, going for his belt, his boots, the inner pockets of his coat for weapons, but Bilbo clapped a surprisingly strong hand over his mouth and clung to him with all four limbs like a stubborn insect making a home on Thorin’s back. Slowly, he stilled, and Bilbo kept his fingers firm across Thorin’s mouth, and the two of them watched from amongst lichen-sprawled roots as every elven torch was suddenly extinguished and the night went utterly dark.
Notes:
hi, everybody.
firstly, i just want to say i’m so, so incredibly sorry for the huge wait time of this chapter and the fact i went essentially MIA for so long. i mentioned this in the last chapter’s notes, but i was in my final semester of university and have also fallen very deeply into a new hyperfixation, so i was nowhere near at the headspace i needed to be to write for bilbo and thorin (especially when i felt so unmotivated by this chapter).
in saying that, you’ve all been nothing but absolutely lovely and i haven’t once felt pressured to upload faster by anyone, and all your comments made my day every time i saw them, so thank you so, so much, genuinely :(
also i'm sorry for the cliffhanger LMAO but i have the next chapter well on the way and will definitely be posting it sooner than this one! i am fully committed to finishing this fic no matter how long it takes me because it means a lot to me and i want to do it justice, so don't worry about it being abandoned - i will get back to it at some point no matter what!
i hope you all enjoyed this chapter and that it makes up a little for my absence! as always, my twitter is here (tho with everything el*n is doing who knows how long that'll last lol)
Chapter 6: kingdom dance
Notes:
happy holidays everybody sorry i went awol i was making bad bitch moves (having meltdowns about my writer's block)
title taken from the song "kingdom dance" from tangled (i recommend listening during the very last scene of this chapter)!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
It was some time before either Bilbo or Thorin could see again. The earliest touches of dawn began to push through what little crevices they could find in the dense canopy, and dancing firelight started up again in the far distance, just enough that they could both see there was no trace of any of the other dwarves. The clearing was completely silent; both dwarves and Elves had vanished into thin air.
When they both seemed to have deemed the coast clear, Thorin wrestled his way out of Bilbo’s grip, stumbling to his feet and looking around wildly. There were twigs tangled in his hair. Bilbo could not quite bring himself to point them out.
“Why did you do that, you —”
“Shhh!”
They stared at each other, Thorin looking utterly mutinous, though the effect was rather dulled by all the aforementioned twigs. Bilbo lifted a finger to his mouth and held it there silently, his eyes wide and imploring.
“Where are the others?” Thorin said in a low voice.
“They have been taken by the Elves, and we would have been, too,” Bilbo hissed back. “I didn’t have a choice.”
Thorin muttered darkly in what was definitely Khuzdûl and swung Orcrist through the air, dried-up leaves crushing under the heavy fall of his boots as he paced back and forth in anger. Bilbo shook his head with a scoff and began sneaking through the underbrush, hoping with everything he had he’d remembered the right way to go.
It took him a few moments to realise Thorin had been so caught up in his useless, stony brooding that he hadn't even noticed he’d been quite left behind in the clearing. Bilbo called out to him, and, when there was no response, called out louder in exasperation, already well on the path down to the Elven kingdom.
“Aren’t you coming, then?”
He crept up through the grove, careful of how the trees thinned out the closer they got to the edge of the forest, the red-brown leaves fading out into murky greens that lined the roots buried deep within the earth.
From afar, Bilbo could hear Thorin stomping his way closer, and could not be bothered to even roll his eyes about it, instead hiding himself behind a great beech tree not far from the Elven Gate. The bark beneath his fingers was gnarled, and slowly withering from the sickness that lay over the forest.
(Bilbo understood now that Thranduil Oropherion held great love for the Greenwood and desired greatly to protect it, and that the blackness cast across it from the shadows of Dol Guldur was hurting him and his Elves very deeply. His journey to Dale in later years had been so green and lively in comparison that Bilbo had quite forgotten what Mirkwood had been like in the clutches of the Enemy, and he longed to escape from it as soon as they possibly could.)
Very carefully, he let a sliver of his face peek out to watch the great Gate beyond the bridge just below them, the curls of his hair half-falling in his eyes and his own breath warm against his fingers touching the tree. He could see no sign of the rest of the Company; they’d very likely already been tucked away in their cells below the surface.
Two Elven guards were stationed on either side of the entrance to the kingdom, each bearing long oaken spears and watching the woods cautiously. Bilbo watched them a moment longer, exhaling slowly as if all the air around him had gone completely still, and then turned and tucked himself behind the trunk again, facing Thorin with his back against the wood and his mind whirring.
“Thorin,” he murmured, barely even breathing out the word, for he was all too conscious of the fact Elves had abnormally enhanced hearing and several of them were only a stone’s throw away, “we have no way of breaking them out that will not also get ourselves captured.” He paused for a moment. “You have to make the Elvenking an offering of peace.”
Thorin’s eyes flashed, and his face drew at once into a rather ugly scowl. “You —”
“I know there is tension between your two peoples,” Bilbo interrupted urgently, his voice a whisper in the quiet, “especially with the Mirkwood Elves — believe me, I know — but we have no other choice at the moment. They will not yield. You know they won’t.”
“So,” Thorin said slowly, half of his face still in shadow under the shade of the beech tree, “you would have me walk in there of my own free will?” His tone was wary, dark, leaning into the old brimstone from when they’d known each other less, but his stance and gaze had steadied, and he waited for Bilbo to speak. Bilbo sunk backward with a sigh, feeling his spine press up against the trunk of the tree.
“These Elves keep to themselves," he said slowly. "They are wary of outsiders and protect their own. Do you not also know what that is like?”
Their gazes held, the only sound the distant chorus of the river rushing below, and the blessedly-missed chirping of birds — Bilbo had almost forgotten what they sounded like. “Thranduil is ancient. He is not beyond reason, but he will not respond well to anger from those he perceives as a threat.”
Thorin’s face darkened, the shutters suddenly closing entirely, and he looked to the side, back the way they’d come from the clearing. His jaw was tight.
“I understand… what it is you are trying to do, Master Baggins. I do,” he said, looking back to where Bilbo was pinned like a butterfly, heart tick-ticking away inside his chest in tepid anticipation. “But their King turned from us long ago. I owe him no allegiance, no false niceties. I cannot do what you ask.”
Bilbo exhaled, the front of his hair fluttering, and tried in rather questionable vain to restrain his temper, or think of any other solution he possibly could to Thorin’s almighty stubbornness. Each one of his fingertips alternated between drumming against the trunk of the tree and scrunching at the bottom of his jacket.
“Give me Orcrist,” he said very suddenly. Thorin was still for a moment, and then alight with rage.
“Bilbo,” he growled out, but Bilbo gave him a look of such petulant defiance that he fell silent. He turned from Thorin again to lean forward against the tree, peeking his curly head round the side to gaze down once more at the bridge below them, and after a moment felt Thorin come up to stand beside him.
“I have a plan for if it doesn’t work,” he said, so very quietly, “but it requires a distraction. He will hear what it is you have to say, Thorin. You are a king. And it truly does not matter if you mean one lick of it or not — you can go back to loathing him and his Elves to your heart’s content tomorrow, but they… I cannot sneak in there and get them out myself.”
They looked at each other then, and after a long moment, several long moments, in which Bilbo had almost started wondering whether it would be more prudent to just knock Thorin out and throw him in the river (and whether their fledgling friendship would even withstand such a thing), Thorin bowed his head the slightest bit and asked, “What will you do?”
“You must keep him talking, for as long as you can.” Bilbo said quietly, conscious of where it was they were, conscious of who it was they were. “You must, Thorin. Explain that there has been — a misunderstanding, and that we bear them no ill will. We were passing through. We wish for peace between you and they.” He took a long breath and scrunched his eyes shut for a moment. “You cannot lose your temper. You must try, as best you can. There is more at stake here than a feud with Thranduil.”
He opened his eyes and looked directly into Thorin’s face as he said it, and after a moment, Thorin nodded, expression firm.
“Give me Orcrist, and I will keep it safe for you,” Bilbo said again, holding out a hand. He could see Thorin’s jaw twitching, knew that this request was forcing even Thorin to his utter limits, and pushed on stubbornly.
“Thorin, they will take it from you. It is an Elvish blade, and we have no proof at all that Elrond bid you keep it, and anyway, it is a sign of goodwill that you walk into their kingdom with no weapon on you.”
After a moment of more tedious jaw-twitching, Thorin drew the blade and held the hilt out toward Bilbo, who took it delicately, holding it high in front of his face. The silver shone in the quiet of the forest clearing.
“Keep it safe.”
“I promise.”
It was long, much longer than Sting — almost twice the size if he had to hazard a guess — and the weight of it was such that it made his wrist ache, but Bilbo held it steadily, his shaky exhaled breath misting the flat of the blade. He looked up at Thorin, who was gazing at him with the most peculiar sort of expression all of a sudden, his eyes focused only on Bilbo’s face rather than on the sword and standing utterly still. Bilbo’s eyebrows furrowed.
“What?” he needled.
“It is odd,” Thorin said quietly, his mouth just barely moving. There was no word to describe the strangeness of the expression on his face. “It suits you.”
And then he smiled, a genuine glow in his face and his eyes suddenly alight in the undergrowth.
(It was the first real one in this lifetime, and it made Bilbo think of acorns and hallways and the hair pulled back from Thorin’s face.
His heart ached.)
They slipped out of the clearing soon after that, Orcrist strapped haphazardly to Bilbo’s back beneath his coat and Thorin’s rasp ringing in his ears. He crouched down, moving noiselessly through the brush and never tearing his eyes away as he watched Thorin calmly walk down to the end of the bridge. The Elf-guards moved as if lightning at the first sight of him, and Thorin brought his hands up, arms wide and head bowed in surrender.
“I am the leader of the company of dwarves you hold within your walls,” his booming voice rang out over the roaring river. “I wish to negotiate peacefully with your King.”
One of the Elves lowered her spear and looked upon Thorin with a scrutinising expression, though she held herself with such quiet grace that Bilbo saw Thorin pull back his shoulders and lift his head to meet her dark eyes. They studied each other for a moment, the Elf and the dwarf.
“You bear no ill will?” she said, her voice challenging, and loud over the rushing water below.
“I am not armed,” Thorin replied lowly, and he opened his heavy coat outward to reveal his empty belt.
The Elf turned to exchange looks silently with her other guards, who looked sideways at each other, and then lowered their spears in unison and marched forward through the gargantuan doors of the Gate.
Not one of them noticed the little figure that, when all was clear, darted out from the foliage nearby and tiptoed unnoticed after them, slipping silently through the crack in the door just before it swung closed.
“You would walk into my halls and ask for the release of those I have imprisoned, with nothing in return?”
“They have done nothing wrong. We are weak and starving, and they saw your merriment in the forest and hoped to find safety and shelter. Instead, they have found bars.”
Too harsh. Gentler, dear heart.
The voices of Thranduil and Thorin were so sonorous and clear in the Woodland realm’s winding walkways that Bilbo could hear them quite easily from where he was creeping in the shadows towards the guards’ room. He’d remembered vaguely where it had been, and he’d watched from within a hidden little nook in the wall as the guards had escorted Thorin through the doors and then made their way downwards. He could picture the scene above, the colours of autumn twisting through the branches overhead, the great throne of the Elvenking basking on the raised platform and draped in silks of fine gold. Thorin standing below him on the outcrop, head bowed and cool stoicism painting his face, his hair falling long and bedraggled in his eyes. Bilbo could almost see the working of Thorin’s jaw as he tried to keep his promise to stay calm, to keep his cool and find their way out of here with nothing but his words.
It was a long shot, and Bilbo had his original plan in motion just in case, but safe passage from Mirkwood and an ally in the King of the Woodland realm may yet be able to change the tide of the battle to come. Bilbo had to trust in Thorin that he would do what he could. The Elvenking was calculating, and held great patience where others would be rash. They would have to get the balance exactly right.
“I do not consider ensuring the safety of my people from intruders an unjust action.” Thranduil did not sound angered, but assessing, and his voice flowed like water through the halls, as if rustling green leaves in the wind.
“We have no quarrel with you, Elvenking. We do not threaten your safety.”
In his mind’s eye, Bilbo could see the berries threaded through the long shards of oak that made a circlet atop Thranduil’s head, and how in the autumn half-light underground they would glow a deep plum-red when he moved.
“Three times your people attacked my Elves,” said Thranduil.
“What other path is there that would let us travel east? There is danger all around. Goblins in the north, and darkness in the south. Your road is the only one where passers-by can still hope to live, and if that is displeasing to you, then I would question your judgement, Thranduil.”
Bilbo bit his lip and let his head fall forward against the arched wall nearest him.
Please, Thorin.
He knew Thorin had realised the same thing when he began to speak again, his voice quieter and almost monotonous, ringing out into the curving corridors. Bilbo’s heart was in his throat, and his mouth twitched despite his worry at how deeply Thorin was trying.
“I am sorry for the harm we may have caused your Wood-Elves," Thorin said slowly. "I did not intend it, and I do not wish for distrust to build between us.”
The dark laughter in Thranduil’s voice at that was chilling. “What is your purpose through my wood, nogoth? What brought you into the forest at all?”
Thorin sighed. “I cannot tell you that,” he said.
“I am owed an explanation for why you continually harassed my people in their merrymaking. You ask for safe passage from my realm, and for your folk to walk free, and yet you will not even confess for what purpose you are here?”
Bilbo could almost see him rising from the chair then, the throne, the golden robes descending to the floor and enveloping all but the two of them in a radiant shadow.
“I am demanding payment from you in truth,” Thranduil said simply. Thorin took some time to answer.
“I will give you your jewels, if you will allow me my silence.”
Bilbo started, and the memory flashed by. White gems, of pure starlight.
“And how," the King said, "will you get those?”
Thorin did not speak.
Thranduil’s voice became cold as frosted glass, and his words bit at Bilbo like ice. “You have no way into the Mountain where my jewels are kept, and you will never find one. You cannot give me anything but what I have asked for.”
Still Thorin stayed silent. Bilbo’s fragile little plan was crumbling all around him, but he knew that even if Thorin spoke now to Thranduil like spun sugar rested on his tongue, there was nothing more he could say.
He huffed out a sigh. Once more into the fray, then.
“Time in my cells with the rest of your kin may change your mind. I will keep you safe and secure until you are ready to talk, no matter how long it may take.”
All at once, a struggle of people appeared, a walkway or two below where Bilbo crept, and there he could see that mane of hair as Thorin tried and failed to wrench his forearms from the grip of the Elf-guards. Bilbo began to walk faster, as fast as he could without the pads of his feet making noise as they hit the ground. The sounds of Thorin’s protests were fading away as he ran, as they carried Thorin deeper and deeper.
It had taken him days to find where Thorin had been imprisoned last time, and Bilbo had no guarantee at all that the Elves would lead him to the same cells, or whether Thorin had managed to incur less or more of Thranduil’s wrath this time around. He darted past offshoots of branches and hallways, feet making no sound at all on the oakwood floors, keeping as great a distance as he dared between him and the guards who were handling Thorin none too gently by his arms, but hovering close enough that they stayed in his line of sight. He would not have another chance like this one to pocket the keys without the Ring, and he would not be able to keep them for much longer without alerting anyone to a thief in their halls.
Bilbo reprimanded himself gently. You are a burglar, not a thief, he thought. No need to lower yourself to the level of common criminals. After all, he was rather skilled at the job.
He dashed nimbly down into the guards' room, nabbed the keys, tucked them into his belt and then settled in to wait with ears pricked and eyes alert, until his foot was cramping something rather awful and he was pretty sure his back had molded itself to the shape of the doorway he’d been hiding in. Eventually, however, there were no murmurs of robe or voice; the coast was clear, and Bilbo practically trotted down the swirling staircases, creeping up on where each of his dwarves were caged and frantically hushing the celebration that erupted from every cell he unlocked. It took time, perhaps too much time if one was considering changes in guards and the fact that even a single sighting would unravel his entire cobbled-together plan, but soon they were all following Bilbo in a neat little line, boots clobbering the steps of the Elven halls in a racket that made his hobbitish ears wince, though the path remained mercifully empty.
He had no choice but to follow the trail he only vaguely remembered to the caverns where the deeper dungeons were, wondering how long it would take to find Thorin buried so far underground, hoping with all his might that there were no guards lingering, but it was a shorter journey than it had once been to find Thorin kneeling in the corner of his cell, the air decaying and dusty and the dim light all but gone.
Bilbo held up a hand to the others to wait, and crept slowly forwards, his feet silent against the ground. Thorin’s head was bowed, the curtain of dark hair hanging limply in his face; it hid everything but his eyes watching the floor, unseeing.
(He looked beautiful, even barely visible, even as disheveled as he was locked in an underground cell. It was truly becoming a problem how little Bilbo cared about the state of Thorin's appearance. How easily he could have let himself push the hair back from that stony, striking face.)
Bilbo cleared his throat, and Thorin’s head whipped up.
“You can start feeling sorry for yourself after we’re safely out of here, Master Oakenshield,” he teased softly, keeping his voice quiet in the dark.
“Bilbo?”
Thorin stood, hurrying to the door of the cell and throwing his hands against it. He’d been stripped of his coat, his beautiful blue coat, and he stood much like the others in only the underlayers of his clothes. His hair was still bedraggled from the forest, and his eyes were bright.
“Yes, hello,” Bilbo said, a bit bashfully, pulling the great loop of keys from the notch in his belt and quickly getting to work.
“You have them?” Thorin asked, his voice quiet, a little unbelieving.
Bilbo’s eyes flickered up, not replying, and he watched as Thorin’s travelled from the set of keys to the trail of dwarves waiting at the stairs, all making motions at him that fell somewhere between strained relief and wild celebration. Thorin's eyes fell back onto Bilbo as the lock clicked.
Bilbo lifted a hand and let his fingers close around where Thorin’s own were clutching the bars of the cell tightly, and he leant his forehead against the door. They watched each other silently through the bars, unmoving.
Bilbo’s heart was thudding in his throat, a wild, ceaseless rhythm of get the keys, unlock the doors, into the barrels, get him out, get him out, get him out. The line of Thorin’s entire body was pressed against the bars of the door — his fingers had not moved underneath Bilbo’s; neither had his eyes.
He did not speak, seemingly stunned into silence. Bilbo soon took pity on him.
(In fact, Bilbo could not even begin to put the depth of the expression on Thorin’s face into words, and it did not occur to him in that moment outside the cell in the dark halls of Mirkwood to wonder exactly why that was.)
“Your quest is not over yet, Thorin Oakenshield,” he whispered. He squeezed the bar their fingers were wrapped around once, gently, and then stepped back to pull the door open.
The fourteen of them raced as quietly as they could through the corridors, taking several wrong turns with muttered curses and climbing back up toward the main chamber so they could creep down into the cellars.
Once they had made it to the offshoot they’d have to travel through to reach the belly of the Mirkwood cellars — close enough that he could have thrown a stone through the doorway and heard it bounce — Bilbo ushered them all into an adjacent hidden corridor and then took a steadying breath, leaning against the curved wall and closing his eyes for a moment.
He would have to do this utterly perfectly. To make a slight misstep would mean a life sentence in the deepest depths of the Elvish realm, and he did not have the luck of timing or invisibility on his side this go around, but luck he still had, and so he would make do. He turned to the others with a grimace.
“I am going to get us out of here, I promise you. But you have to hide, and you must trust me.”
The Company all shuffled further into the shadows, watching him with their uneasy, curious eyes, and Bilbo swallowed as he turned toward the doorway, closing his own eyes for a moment.
He knew Elven ways, and knew them well. The last twenty years of his life had been spent among the last lines of the High Elves, and he knew the lull and lilt of their voices, the musical cadence with which they spoke.
The Sindarin rolled off his tongue with almost practised ease.
“The Elvenking requests an audience with the Chief of the Guard and his people.”
The strength of his voice in the cavernous wood-carved hall surprised even Bilbo, and his eyes opened to find a huddle of dwarves, all watching him with axe-sharp eyes and looking quite clearly flabbergasted.
(He could not even blame them. He hadn’t sounded like himself at all; his words had come out with such rich, woody lightness that he might have even been convincing.)
He took a controlled breath and continued.
“The dwarf has chosen to speak rather than stay silent in his cell. The King wishes to discuss this with you. Go now. He is waiting in the upper chamber.”
They watched from the shadows as only a few moments later, the Keeper of the Keys and four others in his guard stepped past them and rose up and out of sight. Bilbo hadn’t the faintest idea where Thranduil was, but as long as the King wasn’t anywhere near here, then all would still be well.
The murmuring started up almost immediately, all of them pressing him with questions and raised eyebrows and disgruntled mumblings and pointed interjections until Bilbo could do nothing but send a helpless look towards Thorin, who called to them once in Khuzdul in a deep voice. The lot of them fell silent at once.
“You speak their tongue?” Dwalin ground out, his voice like a sledgehammer against Bilbo’s increasing headache. His eyes were narrowed.
Oh, we do not have time for this!
“Yes,” Bilbo said with equal parts exasperation and mounting panic, pulling at Dwalin’s elbow and trying to hurry the rest of them through the entrance with frantic eyes, “and I really do not think we have the time for an argument about it just now, so keep it to yourself for a moment, if you please!”
It worked, and the fourteen of them staggered into the guards’ chamber at the mouth of the cellars, blinking around. A great hollowed-out space had been carved so delicately it was as though the walls were made of marble, and tree-roots from the forest far above stretched from floor to ceiling in gigantic twisting patterns, interspersed among the tables and chairs scattered about. Almost all of the lanterns had been doused in a hurry, and Bilbo could see the extinguished smoke wafting up in lazy white tendrils, but the few that had been left lit the room in an unusually cozy ambient light. It reminded Bilbo of his room in Rivendell, almost, the one with the fireplace and the armchair where he had written his silly songs and sung them to a king.
It was clear he’d been convincing enough — there wasn’t a soul in sight, and Bilbo almost felt all of their shoulders sink as one in exhausted relief. Oin and Gloin leant back against a wall and closed their eyes in tandem, seemingly trying to take a nap right then and there. Bilbo’s mouth twitched fondly, and he clapped them both on the shoulder to wake them up, managing a sheepishly apologetic smile.
Fili turned back to the doorway to peer up through the empty corridor.
“Well, that’s lucky,” he said thoughtfully.
There was a single beat where nobody moved, and then thirteen pairs of eyes turned suddenly to focus on Bilbo in unconcealed accusation. He flashed them a bemusedly crooked little smile.
“I have been telling you all, haven’t I?”
“You must speak like a native, if they responded to you in such a way,” said Oin. Bilbo felt his ears flush.
“Yes, well, I am quite good at it.”
“What did you say to them?” Kili asked curiously, staring. Bilbo waved a dismissive hand and carried on walking to the other side of the room.
He guided them all further down the winding oak paths of the lower Woodland realm, and when they came to the door of the cellars, Bilbo repeated his show of Sindarin, this time telling old Galion the butler that the King had requested some of his best wine be brought to his rooms in the upper halls, and ignoring the torn stares of all the dwarves as the unfamiliar words floated off his tongue and through the air.
Galion soon hastened past their hiding-place with two large flasks of Elven wine, and Bilbo felt his mouth twitch imperceptibly at the sight. Mustn’t’ve been taste-testing them today then, Galion, old fellow?
As soon as he was gone, Bilbo rushed them through the wide arching doorway and down the steps to the familiar and not-altogether-welcome sight of a large, warmly lit room lined with nothing but bottles and flasks and, on the far side from where they stood, two dozen empty mead barrels, all neatly lined up against the side of the cellar in rigid rows and with their lids propped open as if enticing the Company to take a dip in the river below. There sat nearest them a lone table and chair, upon which was scattered a plate of half-eaten bread and cheese and a still-filled glass of ruby red wine. The scoundrel! Bilbo thought with a chuckle.
He took a breath, then hopped down the last couple of steps onto the wooden floor and turned with reluctance to face the dwarves all watching him expectantly in their underclothes, still standing in the entranceway. He was thankful they all liked him well enough by now, because he surely was not going to be making any friends in a moment.
“I am really very sorry, but there’s simply no other way I can think to do this. I’m afraid you are going to have to get into the barrels.”
The outcry was instantaneous, and all of the shouting over the top of each other rang around the walls and was surely floating up the stairs to alert any one of their captors as to their plan and whereabouts. Bilbo quickly put his foot down.
“Now, look, there are dozens of guards between here and the Gate, and I cannot simply talk them all away without anyone becoming curious about the disembodied voice echoing through all of the halls, and who it belongs to!” he shouted, and was faced with thirteen abashed-looking faces, though some still grumbled, and some still eyed the barrels with vast amounts of disdain.
Bilbo walked over to the barrel closest to him and wrenched the lid aside to reveal the deceptively spacious interior designed for holding the supplies the Lakemen traded with the Wood-Elves, and pretended he was not trying to convince himself the whole situation was far better than it was.
They had no other choice. They’d done it before. And really, this was one of the easiest things they’d had to do the whole journey, if one looked at it from a certain angle (and one squinted very, very hard). He pointed into the inside of the barrel he’d revealed.
“They will not realise we are gone instantly if we go quietly through the river, and we will very easily wash up at Laketown. It is faster than going by foot, and I’m sure you will all be moaning and groaning by the end of it, but if anyone else seems to have any bright ideas, then I am sure I would love to hear them!”
They fell silent, glancing at each other. Bilbo tried not to feel too smug.
He packed them up neatly into each of their barrels, putting in as much straw and spare cloth as he could find so it would not be as rough a journey as it had been the last time. And all the while, Bilbo was fretting, wondering whether doing as he had before was even wise, and then wondering why he was so eager to change his plan when it had gotten them safely to Laketown in the first place.
He did not know if his distraction had been a good enough ruse, and he did not know if the noise of the lever being pulled would alert the guards from high up in the Mirkwood halls. But he could not think of anything else to do, not when Thorin’s meeting with Thranduil had fallen so cleanly to pieces even after Thorin had tried to stay peaceable. He supposed that he had had to choose between barrels and spiders, and Bilbo knew his Sting was good in a pinch, but he did not want to have to put it to work if he could avoid it. The thought of black legs crawling and creeping and climbing even now still made him shudder.
When footsteps and irritated voices began to echo above them, Bilbo tucked Orcrist inside and then climbed into his own barrel at the end of the pile, sealing the lid shut and breathing out slowly. The action fluttered some of the straw nearest his nose, and he spent the next few moments fighting back a catastrophic sneeze as Elves made their way into the room, grumbling back and forth.
Where has Galion gotten to now?
You can never know with that one. He’s always rushing off somewhere or asleep on his feet.
Or at his table!
Here, see, he hasn’t even sent back these empty barrels yet, and now they’re going to be late!
Bilbo realised that he was again the only one who could understand them, and imagined with a lopsided pang the others all tensed up inside their barrels, hands pressed against the walls and barely taking a breath for fear of Elven ears. Not knowing whether they were about to be caught, or whether the Elves were becoming suspicious; whether they’d even noticed that any of the dwarves were gone. He closed his eyes and hoped they would hold out.
Quite without warning, there was a clanking sound, and a muffled grunt, and then the doorway below them opened so quickly they barely had time to gasp in alarm before the fourteen of them were splashing down into the raging river and away from the captivity of Mirkwood at last.
(And if a couple of the barrels shouted as they dropped, well, the Elves were just going to have to wonder about it in vain until the stars winked out of the sky.)
Bilbo had tried as best he could to pack them all securely, but all of the dwarves were still aching and waterlogged and hungry by the time he peeled back the lids of the barrels the next day, and there was as much grumbling as ever, though he did not take it to heart. They stumbled up onto the bank and threw themselves against the shoreline in utter exhaustion, and Bilbo waited patiently until a few of them had started to come to their senses and he could hasten them on.
Fili and Kili were as spritely as ever and seemed eager to start the next leg of their journey, though they complained as much as the rest.
“We reek of apples,” Fili had said immediately after stepping out of his barrel, shaking out the golden mane of his hair and wrinkling up his nose in distaste.
Bilbo had, as usual, rolled his eyes. “Then I suppose you shall have to hope you don’t run into any horses.”
One by one he managed to drag them up onto a wooden wharf extending out into the water not too far from where they stood wringing out their drenched coats and cloth, but the grumbling all at once stopped as each of them turned to the north and gazed at long, long last upon the Lonely Mountain.
The tip of it loomed purple-grey in the distance of the sky stretched out before them, and clouds were gathered all around, like gentle arms reaching across its face, sheltering it from the view of the world. It sat like a forgotten beacon watching over the lake of Men; an ancient giant. The silence at the sight was almost holy.
Bilbo hated to tear them away from it, but they needed to move; it was almost dusk, and the first grasps of winter were already in the air. He urged them up, and moved them on, gently touching at shoulders and giving them each a strained smile, and soon they were plodding along the boardwalks of outer Laketown, the wood damp and rotting under their feet. Men, presumably guards, spotted them in the distance, and by the time they had made it to the edge of town they were met by no small number of people all watching on curiously.
The Master of Laketown pushed through, scowling, and Bilbo wrinkled up his nose at once. The reality of seeing the man again with his own two eyes only soured Bilbo’s memories even further; the pompous sneer that stretched across his mouth, the decadent robes that had become old and moth-eaten, the battered-yet-priceless jewellery that adorned each of his stubby fingers. Bilbo wished that he could knock that silly hat clean off the ridiculous shoulders it sat on.
“Greetings to the Master and the Men of Laketown! We do not wish to trespass, but are seeking shelter and food, if we are able,” Balin said amicably, bowing a little. The Master’s face twisted even further; he looked as if he had suddenly eaten several lemons.
“And who, may I ask, are you?” he spat, looking to the front of the group.
Thorin’s words came out just as Bilbo had remembered them.
“I am Thorin,” he said, stepping forward, his voice like quiet thunder, “son of Thrain, son of Thror. King Under the Mountain. And we have come to reclaim our homeland.”
It was like he’d fallen into a memory, the ring of people in the dusky light, the damp, creaking steps up to the Master’s house where he would sit sneering down at his people living in squalor. Bilbo remembered the songs, the cheering, the chanting of his wealth shall flow in fountains and the rivers golden run! He remembered thinking for the first time that his little part in their quest might be much bigger than he’d imagined, that he might have come for more than a little treasure and helping his new friends find a home again.
And of course, he remembered what a disaster all of that had become. But now was not the time.
All of the faces around them looked tentatively, sincerely hopeful at Thorin's words, as though a blessing in their desperate favour had come at long, long last. All but one, and Bilbo found him instantly.
Bard had not spoken, and Bilbo knew he would not, but he knew at the same time that Bard was both his greatest danger and greatest ally in preventing the catastrophe on the Long Lake. For some time he’d been thinking over whether approaching him was wise, or whether knowing the true extent of their intentions would force Bard to try and stop them even more intensely. But it was he who would listen to Bilbo’s warnings that all was not well in the Mountain, and it was he who would be the asset Bilbo had not had last time. He was going to have to reach into Bard by force and pull out the Dragonslayer.
The feast that night was grand and merry; all of them had been draped in gilded fineries of red and gold, and seated at the High Table beside the Master and his attendees. Bilbo could not seem to stop himself thinking how beneath his pompous robes and false smile was a heart of utter selfishness, who did not care one bit for his people and who would leave them to starve and die, and so he avoided the Master as much as he could. He chose a seat as far away from them all as possible, and although it meant he was not close to Thorin or Fili or Kili or Balin, he sat comfortably and chatted with Dori, Bifur and Bombur, and they all turned quite a few heads with the roars of their laughter.
The Company was given the same house to stay in as before, though all of them more or less ended up nestled on the floor amongst each other’s limbs the way they had been during the long days in the forest; half because they’d quite fallen asleep on their feet and hadn’t made it into any the beds scattered about the house, and half because the sleep-pile was a blanket of safety, protection they’d desperately needed and felt too wary to give up.
They spent the better part of a fortnight resting, washing, singing, working out knots in their muscles, eating their fill after so long deliriously underfed, sitting in a circle with the map of Erebor in the centre and attempting to work out a plan to approach the Mountain. There were several conversations with the Master and his accursed advisor about the specifics of payment for their kindness and support for Erebor’s old ally, but these were few and far between; the man had made no efforts to masquerade as anywhere near politically gifted, and he did not care about anything but the gold.
Bilbo propped every one of his limbs up at every moment he was able and spent his days lounging around, curly head buried in books thicker than his arms or simply gazing at the cover of the red-leather journal pulled from his pack, never opening it but not wanting to part from it all the same.
He really was beginning to need a haircut, too. He’d had to keep tossing his hair right out of his eyes, and he was sure it looked nothing short of ridiculous.
Once, only a few days after they had arrived and settled in Laketown, Thorin Oakenshield walked into a mostly-empty room in the Company’s staying-house to find Bilbo Baggins standing on a stool with his hands on his hips, quite intently staring up into the shelves on the wall. When the dwarf looked further, he spotted the little stack of books collecting dust high in the corner, and the way Bilbo was eyeing the rest of them with an almost challenging intrigue. It must have tweaked a memory in his mind of something the hobbit had told them, for he asked with some hesitation, “Are you doing research?”
Bilbo did not even turn his head, utterly focused on peering at the spines of each book one after the other like they were making a bid for whichever he deemed most worthy. A shrewd sort of expression rested upon his face.
“Of sorts,” he said, after the quiet had lingered for a little while. He turned to look over his shoulder at Thorin. “These Laketown Men don’t have their own tongue, and I don’t think their books can teach me anything I do not already know.” There was such a clear annoyance in his voice that the corners of Thorin’s mouth lifted slightly.
“You do not wish to lower yourself enough to read anything in Common Speech?” he asked, amused. The hobbit squinted at him, disgruntled, though the dwarf knew they had both been only teasing.
Bilbo glanced back up at the shelves with the books, so much taller than he. The entrancement was clear upon his face.
“I love languages,” he said. “The translation of texts has always been one of my favourite things to write.” His nose wrinkled. “I don’t want to waste time or page space writing down things I’ve read so many times my eyes will fall out.”
Thorin Oakenshield took a step closer to the bookshelf, the wood below them creaking under his boots. He gazed up at the sight that seemed to so captivate his companion.
“It is a pity you cannot learn Khuzdûl.”
Bilbo scoffed. “Yes, well, even if I did know it, I could not translate any of your texts, because you are all so secretive,” he pointed out in a nettled sort of tone, wobbling on unsteady feet as he reached up for another book.
(Warm brown skin crept out from beneath the half-untucked shirt he wore. Eyes were lowered.)
“And the Elves are not?” Thorin asked quietly.
The hobbit turned back from the bookshelf with a thick leather-bound volume in his hands. The tome had to have been decades old, one of the few remnants to have made it out of the ruin that had become of Dale in the wake of the dragon.
“Well, I suppose they are,” Bilbo said thoughtfully, “but they have never seemed to mind with me.” His brows furrowed in the centre of his face, and Thorin’s eyes seemed drawn to the little crease they left between them. “Maybe it’s because I am a hobbit, and they do not wholly think of me as an equal. It’s the same everywhere you turn. It’s why we are known by others as halflings, although hobbits greatly resent that name. We are not half of anything, thank you very much.”
The dwarf swallowed, and the line of his throat seemed to bob, the sunlight falling through the window and pooling on the floor as their bodies faced each other. The air was so brisk outside that the little room in the upper floor of the house felt almost stifling. Dust particles drifted through the air, splintering in the light from the window, though that too was fading day by day as winter descended upon them.
“If I'm honest, I’ve read more than anyone else I know," Bilbo said absent-mindedly, almost to himself. "I’ve had a lot of time for it.”
“Is that why you can speak their language?”
Bilbo looked at Thorin, and his expression was not quite placeable; to anyone else, he might have even looked a little upset. “Sindarin, it’s called. And only somewhat. I made an effort to speak to as many Elves as I could find, when I was younger.”
The hobbit looked back to the dusty shelf for a moment more and then hopped off the stool. His feet made no sound at all when they hit the ground, and Thorin seemed to realise this, like if he hadn’t been able to see Bilbo, the hobbit would have been nothing but a shadow.
“Aren’t you going to lecture me for it, then?” Bilbo asked, and the dwarf seemed perplexed.
“What?”
“Thorin, I saw your face in the Elven-tunnels. It pains you that I involve myself with them.”
A twinge appeared in Thorin Oakenshield's jaw, though he did not raise his voice. “You should have told me your plan in full. We were working together.”
“Are you so sure you would have trusted me to be able to do it?”
“Yes,” Thorin said simply. Bilbo’s ears went pink. He looked away.
Thorin took a step towards the hulking bookshelf, circling round the side of a table and chairs resting in the centre of the room until he was in line with Bilbo. They stared at each other.
“You are clever, Bilbo, and I fear we may all still be stuck in prison or have weapons lodged in our backs, if not for you,” Thorin said, in that rumble of his. His eyes were trained so very intently on Bilbo it must have been almost hard to look at him. “But you do not tell us everything.”
Bilbo laughed, tucking the books more securely under his arm. “I should think I’ve been boring you all to pieces enough with how much I talk as it is. I don’t believe for a moment any of you want me to talk even more.”
“You’ve been leading us more even than I. But you cannot rely on luck alone in order to survive. Not even you can do that, Bilbo.”
Bilbo let out a huff. “That’s what you dwarves think.”
Thorin frowned. “This is a company, not a person in charge and the rest of his followers. If you have ideas, we want to hear them. We want to know.”
“And I told you months ago that I know quite well what I am doing and how exactly I am doing it!”
His face and ears had flushed a rosy red, if not quite in anger then certainly in irritation, and he placed the books down on the table in order to adequately point a finger at Thorin Oakenshield.
“I think, Thorin, that you’d better remember that it is me who has to face Smaug alone in the dark, so it doesn’t much matter what my plans are, does it?”
Thorin’s expression became unreadable, and his eyes flickered down for a moment to where Bilbo’s index finger hovered in the space between them.
“I would offer you aid in that, as much as we are able. You are our burglar," he said lowly.
A weary sort of appearance crossed the hobbit’s face; his eyes seemed to soften, and the lines that rested on his skin mellowed until they were smooth. He lowered his hand, turning to the side and brushing his fingers over the embossed cover of the book resting at the top of his little stack.
“I’m sorry — I shouldn’t have raised my voice. It’s not your fault — not any of your faults. And I agreed, didn’t I? I knew what it was I was signing up to do.”
The dwarf looked at him with a piteous sort of expression.
“Bilbo —”
“Oh, please don’t worry, Thorin. I’m all right.” And he smiled, creasing the corners of his eyes and the apples of his cheeks blooming rosy as Thorin watched. The hobbit took up his books once more and shook the unruly hair from his face, making his way importantly from the room with a farewell and leaving the dwarf standing alone among the faded pages of books.
(A dwarf, who had lost so much and given all of himself to his people, and who would sit in the corner of the room in the lavish little house they were staying in on the water and watch Bilbo Baggins as he wove rich stories through the air, his hands fanning out in front of him and his eyes alight, not noticing the way his audience would sit enraptured by how he could paint pictures in their minds, and the way he seemed to fit amongst them without thinking, hobbit though he was.
And sometimes Thorin Oakenshield would close his eyes, and lay his weary head against whatever he was resting on, and listen to the sound of Bilbo’s voice; for you could hear the Shire in every lilt of it, the sound like cups of tea and well-loved pages of books, his words floating around the room the way the smell of home would when you opened your door at the end of the day.
It was strange, one might feel, for someone who had gone so long without the feeling of home to hear it in a child of the kindly West. And yet, Thorin would listen to the stories in the wood-slatted house on the lake, and every day he thought of how deeply he had underestimated Master Baggins of Bag End, and of all that they might have lost had it not been for their burglar. Of all that they might have gone without. He was a statue whose blood had begun to sing again.)
Another such day saw Bilbo sat and watching each set of brothers rebraid each other’s hair with such profound tenderness, such care, that it almost made even him homesick. Dwalin and Balin, Oin and Gloin, Dori and Ori placating a rather reluctant Nori, Bofur and Bombur each braiding one side of their cousin’s hair and sniping back and forth about whose was better, Fili and Kili laughing at each other throughout. Thorin had done his own, the usual two long strands that hung by his ears, though he let Fili close the clasps that bound them together.
Most hobbits, if it could be believed, did not have cause to know how exactly to weave their fingers through each other’s hair; almost each and every one of them wore their hair loose, preferring to let it tangle and muss wildly in the air, and even the lads and lasses who wore their hair long and curly scrunched it into ponytails or plaits more tangled than the wind left it. But Bilbo had often, on lazy afternoons when the breeze lulled and the pollen kissed at evergreen leaves, sat in his mother’s favourite patchworked chair and let little Frodo lay back against his legs while Bilbo carded his fingers through the boy's dark hair.
Bilbo had never had any ability to braid, although the style always brought a dear fondness to him, so he wouldn’t ever do much of anything with Frodo’s curls but pull them apart from one another and brush his fingers through them as tenderly as he was able.
(Frodo had his mother Primula’s hair, who’d had her father’s, and the Brandybucks always seemed to grow their offspring with hair that was thin and wispy rather than the more unruly Tookish thickness or the Bagginses’ ever-present suggestion of auburn. Whenever Frodo let him tend to his hair like this, it always reminded Bilbo exactly of a duckling’s down.)
“...and then Mirabella and Gorbadoc had your mother, who had you, so really, my lad, we are even more related as Tooks than we are Bagginses.”
“Bilbo?” Frodo’d said once, maybe a year after he’d come to live with Bilbo — he’d still been quite young, then, and Bilbo had already started keenly mourning the fact that he had not cared enough to know this bundle of curiosity and playful wryness since the day he’d been born; he would surely have spoiled him rotten.
“Hmm?”
“Why did you never come to any of the gatherings our family held? I never saw you. Everyone in Brandy Hall had to remind each other who you were when you came to get me.”
Bilbo huffed out a half-laugh through his teeth and shook his head, though Frodo could not see him. “I’m not a very nice hobbit, I’m afraid, my boy. None of them like me all too much.”
Frodo had sat with this for a moment and then piped up, “But all the littluns like you.”
Bilbo smiled, a twinkle in his eye. "That’s because I tell them stories."
He smiled again now. There were such similarities between the ways dwarves and hobbits showed their love that he mourned their peoples’ separation from each other, and each of them in turn from the outside world. He’d noticed the same thing months ago, when they’d first set out from Hobbiton, though now it felt as though the whole world had shifted since then. But time together, and physical touch to show one’s affection, and community rather than loneliness; he could see every single one of them in the way all of his dwarves interacted, and in why he had flocked so desperately to them the first time without ever quite knowing why. He loved the Shire with all of his heart, but he had never matched Shire life, never found the companionship of any other hobbits aside from Frodo the way he had with rough and roguish dwarves out on the road.
So, one day, once their stay was nearly up and once they’d recuperated enough to no longer worry, he decided to tell them so.
“Would any of you take offence if I told you you all behave quite hobbitishly?” Bilbo had said. It was late afternoon, and the autumn wind had picked up a little outside, a chill rising off the water under all of their feet and through the cracks in the floorboards. Bilbo had found himself surprised that the lake had not already begun to frost, this far north.
Not one of his dwarves seemed to know how to respond to that. Bilbo saw Kili scrunch up his nose, and a few of them seemed to raise disbelieving brows, like maybe they were surprised he had the nerve to say something so bold or so blasphemous, but he set his jaw, and he pushed on stubbornly.
“It’s not that I think you’re snobbish and softhearted like me, but more… well…”
Bilbo trailed off and settled back into the Man-sized armchair he was curled up in, tilting his head back against the dusty velvet and glancing up at the ceiling. Unfortunately, he was well aware of the delicacy of dwarven sensibilities, stoic as they might seem.
“You set store on family, much more than Elves or Men seem to. That is how we live, too. I’ve always found the independence of the Big Folk strange.” Cold and pristine. You had to work hard to pull grins from Elven faces, and they fell from dwarvish ones like honey. “I like it much better here with you.”
He could see quite a few of them smiling now. “And we are glad to have you, Master Baggins,” Balin said, against a chorus of assenting noises echoing round the room, though some of them seemed a little bemused. Bilbo hastened to explain himself, waving his hands, feeling a little silly for being so sentimental. He couldn’t help it. He felt sure anyone in his place would have been exactly the same.
“Oh, you must all think I’m a complete sap, but I don’t think any of you understand! You — you didn’t see me before that day in the Shire, the way I lived before. It was… I lost my parents quite close together, and I've been alone for a long time, almost a lifetime, really. I have other relatives, and my mother had ten siblings, but I was never a huge worry to them, and so they never thought to check up on me much, I suppose.”
Oh, dear. He could feel himself ramping up into a story, all his unspoken words starting to fall out at once, ever the grand gesture over quiet fondness. Here we go, then.
So he told them all of how exceedingly strange he’d been to them, prim and proper and burying himself in books as he’d always done, never talking to the neighbours much to the ghastly horror of his extended family. How he’d despised — still despised — how much everybody else’s noses were always in your business, how it had been the bane of his and Frodo’s existence when they’d still been new to each other, a still-young Frodo tottering about the garden and everybody but the Gamgees trying to stickybeak at him about his poor parents or whatever those silly Brandybucks had been getting on with over in Buckland. He told them of how he’d begun to be called odd, and though he hadn’t minded the names or the space it had given him to hide away in, it had always been quite a large hobbit-hole, and he had always been quite a small hobbit.
Bilbo looked up at the room, his captive audience, his dear, lovely friends. He wished with everything he had that he could tell them how dear, just once. Pieces of my heart to bring my heart peace. He smiled inwardly.
“What I am saying," he finished, "is that you are my family now, in a way. All of you.”
There was a moment’s pause as the confession swept around all the walls and settled on everyone’s ears. Bilbo twiddled his thumbs and acted rather awkward, worrying more and more that they were all thinking he’d fallen right off the deep end, wondering for a mad moment if he’d somehow made them think he should be left behind from the journey to the Mountain on account of his sudden softness.
Then, slowly, each of the dwarves rose and moved forward, one by one, to gently kneel and press their foreheads against his, cupping the back of his neck and closing their eyes with a look of such peace that Bilbo found he could not speak.
Dori, Nori, then Ori, then Bifur and Bombur, and Oin and Gloin, and Bofur, and Balin, and Fili and Kili with identical grins streaked across their faces, and then Dwalin, solemn and almost glaring at Bilbo but showing his gratitude all the same.
Then last in the line was Thorin, and he did not bring his face towards Bilbo’s or touch their foreheads together, but he reached forward and grasped Bilbo’s wrists, facing them upwards so their hands were linked together like the slots of a chain. The feel of Thorin’s fingertips were worn and rough against his skin, and anchored Bilbo in that one moment, amongst damp wooden slats and the smell of barrels of fish and his heart alive in front of him.
“You honour us, Master Baggins,” Thorin said, his voice low and sincere. “Each of us are indebted to you a lifetime over. And all of us are glad to have you.”
Oh, heavens, Bilbo could feel the waterworks propelling towards him at full force, and he pushed the heels of his feet hard into the floorboards to bite them down, deliberately looking away from Thorin’s gaze. He’d done so well, not a tear in weeks! Don’t lose it now, you fool, not when finally you are happy and not grieving!
He managed a shaky smile, looking up at the thirteen of them in front of him, feeling Thorin’s fingers still on his forearms. “I do not know who chose this path for me, but they have been too generous. I know others who deserve this more than I.”
He had carried them with him all this way, thinking always of Elrond’s guidance that he must let go of things that could not be helped, and knowing that it was much harder to do than it was to simply know one should. How could he think of those he had loved without feeling the threads of guilt and sorrow ever tightening around him, when he had long learned to live with such threads in the years following Thorin and Fili and Kili?
Thorin’s eyes heavy on his felt as if a line ran directly between them, tying them to each other. The way he was knelt, down on one knee and Bilbo’s hands in his - Bilbo felt utterly flustered, and felt a flush bloom across his skin up to the roots of his hair.
“We would not wish for anyone else," he said.
“I know,” Bilbo murmured. He closed his eyes, reminding himself that he was here, and very obviously here to stay. It did not quite matter whether he deserved it or not.
He’d long torn out the page he’d written in, that first day he’d come back, but he thought then of the Red Book, a quiet comfort to him on days where his mind drifted to all that he had done in his first life, and he found himself imagining his and Frodo’s spidery handwriting mixing on the pages. Two chapters of the same story. Would there be three chapters now, Bilbo wondered? He mourned the fact he would never get the chance to write this adventure down alongside its predecessors.
He’d simply have to tell Frodo all about it one day, when they saw each other again.
Thorin pulled his hands away and settled back, an odd smile on his face like he wasn’t completely sure what to make of Bilbo’s spectacular outburst. Bilbo very stubbornly refused to feel embarrassed.
“Having thirteen dwarves and a wizard inside must have seemed awfully crowded after so long alone in Bag End,” he said after a moment.
Bilbo felt his face break into a smile, just as Thorin's turned away.
“I’m sure it did, once,” said Bilbo, tilting his head as if he had to even think about it, “but now, I think thirteen dwarves and a wizard fit rather perfectly.”
Several of the dwarves audibly groaned at the mention of Gandalf, which Bilbo thought was quite hilarious considering how desperate they’d all been to keep him at the entrance to Mirkwood.
“You know," said Thorin, "for someone who seems so lonely, you have a very big heart, Master Baggins.”
Bilbo laughed gently. Pieces of his heart to bring his heart peace, indeed.
“Oh, but the room in my heart has all been taken up by you lot.”
It was fast-fading twilight when Bilbo slipped out through the crack in the door and started out towards the other side of Laketown. It took almost no time at all for him to pick his way across the docks and piles of fishing nets and rope, and he was knocking at the battered-looking door before he’d entirely worked out what he was going to say.
It swung open, and there was Bard, gruff and imposing the way he’d always been, his dark hair bedraggled in the dim light. Bard-not-yet-the-Dragonslayer. He looked down at Bilbo.
“You are the halfling that has come with the King,” he said.
“The hobbit, yes,” Bilbo said, a little crossly, and Bard seemed amused, though the grim lines of his face ran far too deep. “My name is Bilbo Baggins. And you’re Bard. I’ve come to ask you for help.”
Bard watched on silently, still holding the door half-open. Bilbo felt his ears flush red and stubbornly surged onward.
He cast his eyes to the floor. There was no other way about it.
“Do you know that we are planning to march upon the Mountain by winter’s coming?”
Bard’s expression darkened at once, his face becoming grisly and his teeth clenched, and Bilbo saw in the set of his shoulders the warrior and king he would become. He thought with some guilt that he dearly wished he’d visited Bard once more, before he died and Bain had become king of Dale.
“You are going to wake the dragon,” Bard said lowly. He had not pulled his gaze from Bilbo’s once, and it was becoming unnerving. Bilbo furrowed his brows.
“Yes, I think so too,” he said. “I fear it greatly. It is what I have come to discuss with you.”
Bard let him in.
“Where are your children?” Bilbo asked as he made his way inside, looking around curiously and not realising his mistake until he trotted almost directly into Bard’s back, who had come to a stop in the middle of the room.
“How would you know if I had children?”
“I, ah — well, I’m sorry, but I assumed —” Bilbo stammered, cursing his own stupidity, and angered that he’d let his guard down so fickly after so long in perfect pretence. The man was sharper than a whip, and he had no reason to trust Bilbo; in fact had every reason not to, after what Bilbo had just asked him.
Bard was eyeing him with some suspicion, but Bilbo could see in his face that he was not angered, and was perhaps even a little impressed at Bilbo’s apparently astonishing display of intuition. He sighed.
“You guessed correctly. I have three; two girls and a boy. They’re visiting with one of the ladies in town who helps care for them while I am working.” He said everything with a vague neutrality, like everything in his life happened with a sort of dull resignation and weariness. Bilbo could see premature lines on his forehead, and felt suddenly incredibly guilty at the extent of his own age.
They sat across from each other, and Bilbo explained the plan he’d been constructing in the edges of his mind, one he still wasn’t sure he should dare to try for all that could go desperately, disastrously wrong. He was choosing to play his cards very recklessly, but something inside his chest could not envision a single other way.
Bard was incredibly dubious, and that ever-present pessimism he’d always shown flared out again as their discussion went round and round in circles. How will someone as small as you ever be able to lure a dragon from its hoard? How will you control it? How can you guarantee you won’t die before you can do so? How can you be sure there is a way to kill it at all?
It was very tiresome, and Bilbo’s long admiration for Bard’s stoutness in the face of danger began to wilt like a cut sprout.
(There was nothing in this world quite like the distrust of Men. Bilbo had never had qualms with them the same way those like Elrond did, but it seemed the universe had decided to thoroughly test that theory.)
“Look, Bard, my apologies, but you are going to have to trust me either way, because we don’t have much of a choice!” Bilbo cried after a while, and Bard’s gloomy eyes fixed on him sharply.
“We do not have any choice if you and your Company do not back down from this. You are putting lives at risk.”
Bilbo noted the dull jab of guilt it was meant to cause and resolutely ignored it, gripping the arms of the chair more firmly and setting his jaw.
“I’m sorry,” he said stubbornly, feeling awful and defiant both, knowing he might be terrible for saying it but already resolving that his friends had always, would always, come first, “but that is not a deal I can make. I’m trying my best to keep you all safe, but it is them that are my priority.”
He sat forward in his armchair and glanced out the window, not wanting to keep eye contact with Bard as he laid out just how dire the situation was. A row of termites were creeping along the windowsill, no doubt looking to burrow down into the wet rot of Bard’s ramshackle house. Bilbo wondered how long each of the buildings on the lake would have lasted had he and the dwarves not barged their way through and reignited the long-ago people of Dale. He wrinkled up his nose for a moment and reluctantly continued.
“I can’t tell you how or why I know, but the dragon has two weaknesses, and we are using both of them. It will come regardless of what we do. This is the only plan we have, and I trust you more than anyone else to be able to save your people. Your Master is going to do nothing, and I don’t believe the dwarves have truly realised the danger that lies in the Mountain. We’ve all been putting it out of our heads until the final steps of the journey.”
Bard’s stoic expression softened so slightly Bilbo very nearly missed it. He leant back in his chair and swung an arm over the side, watching Bilbo with a reserved sort of curiosity. It was clear he found Bilbo exceedingly peculiar, and perhaps a little suspicious, but the time was long gone for any of them to be acting based on wariness. Bilbo knew they had one shot to free the Mountain and the Long Lake, and that that one shot was Bard the Bowman.
“I believe you, hobbit, and I will do what I can. We will not let the lake burn. But I confess,” and here he stretched a leg out, and really, Big Folk were all sorts of strange, “I cannot seem to understand how you are going to exploit the beast’s weakness for gold. He has all the gold he wants; far too much of it.”
Bilbo smiled grimly. Bard had found his way to the heart of the problem, the part that worried him more than anything else ever had.
“Not all of it,” he said quietly.
Two days later, under an increasingly dreary mid-morning, Thorin gathered the fourteen of them and looked at each of them very seriously in turn.
“I wish to tell the Master of this town that we are departing tomorrow for Erebor,” he said. “Durin’s Day is in three days’ time. We need to gather supplies, transport; ponies, to make the journey between the shore and the Mountain. Get what things you have together. Balin,” he said then, looking to his side, “come with me.”
Balin followed, collecting several papers he’d spent their last few days painstakingly drafting up — contracts and predictions of tallies of money and other such things — and making careful eye contact with Thorin, who turned back and called, “Dwalin! Bilbo! With us!”
The two of them moved forward — one marching, one scurrying — at once.
This was the third meeting they had attempted to call with the Master, and the first he had deigned to actually attend himself instead of sending his snivelling assistant to make his excuses. Bilbo had no idea what it was exactly the Master thought he was achieving by doing this; Laketown was not large, and if he was expecting to negotiate some sort of donation of goodwill or mutual assistance, he certainly had not endeared himself to any of the dwarves thus far.
He sat before them now, lounging on the threadbare remains of what had once surely been a grand armchair in such a disrespectful manner that Bilbo furiously refused to maintain eye contact with him and stared right out the window instead.
Balin lowered his hood and bent at the neck and the waist.
“We humbly ask you now for assistance in our approach to the Mountain,” he said, eyes resting steadily on the Master’s dreadful sneer below that thin moustache. “Of course, this will be recompensed as soon as we are able.”
The other three of them did not bow with Balin; Bilbo did try to make himself smaller and more unthreatening than he already was despite his determination to not look upon the man, but Thorin and Dwalin stood with their hands clasped behind their backs, tough as towers, and neither moved a muscle.
Bilbo thought warmly to himself that it was rather sweet that each of the Fundinson brothers had become Thorin’s second in different ways; Dwalin the warrior and Balin the intellectual. He felt sure, however, that for all their camaraderie and closeness this thought would be a touch too sentimental to share, even for him. But then, aren’t they all?
“And I suppose you are just going to wish the dragon away?” The Master sneered. All of the man’s syllables were drawled out in an infuriatingly aristocratic slur, and all of them could hear with their own ears as the words dripped right down the Master’s nose onto the floor by their feet.
Balin kept his gaze steady. His wispy white beard did not even quiver. “Smaug is our responsibility, your Highness.”
“I should hope so!” The Master spat, spraying all their faces with the putrid stench of his saliva. “It’s your damned fault he lurks in the first place! Your greed brought him here - don’t deny it!” He emphasised the point by wagging a finger in all of their faces, the fingernail yellowed and bitten. Bilbo had to bite down very hard on the inside of his cheek to resist the temptation of rolling his eyes. “Is it not said that the downfall of the dwarves is their relentless greed?”
“Is this greed you are somehow immune to, Master?” Thorin said quietly.
The room felt suddenly stiller, like all the candles had paused in their breathing to watch, like the Master and his slimy shadow Alfrid had quite frozen in time, so shocked were they by his nerve.
Thorin took a mighty step forward, the warped floorboards screaming out underneath his boots, and like this he was glorious, and he was captivating, and Bilbo knew at once that he'd been right when he’d thought as they talked in the flower-fields outside Beorn’s cottage that it was an honour to love him. It was an honour every day. He held it against his chest like a flame.
“We are not blind, and we have spent more time amongst your people these past weeks than I predict you have in as many months.”
And Thorin, the way his name had always sat on Bilbo’s tongue, the roll of it like the strength of trees and the gleam of polished wood. Thorin Oakenshield. He could still feel the weight of Thorin’s already-cold hand in his like a phantom breath from long ago, the two of them frozen to the ice, one single heart now beating in a chest made for the both of them.
It was not even remotely the time, but Bilbo could not help but think it.
It has been an honour to carry you with me all these years, Thorin Oakenshield. There has been no honour higher.
The Master’s pursed mouth was gaping open like a fish, and he’d sat upright in his chair, like he had only just now thought to pay attention once somebody had dared to reprimand him in his own house.
“I would see Dale and Erebor prospering again," Thorin said with finality. "We do not have to agree on anything else but that.”
Bilbo looked to the front of the room then, and watched real anger flash across the Master’s face before it settled again into a pristine mask of smug serenity. He was sure none of the others had caught it, and he was sure he knew why. If Dale rose again, the Master would lose every bit of his power and prestige, and his unpopularity would have him scrounging in the streets. He only wished he could tell the Master right to his snobbish face that he’d be scrounging no matter what, and that his days were numbered. Bard was the true King of Dale.
“We will bring what fortune we can. The lake will shine again.”
Perhaps realising what a blunder he had begun to make, the Master insisted on throwing another feast for them, with more merriment and platters of food and gold-strung lights that flickered above their heads once twilight fell. Bilbo could almost smell the ploy to buy their good favour in hopes of recompense; or perhaps, a public spectacle of the Master’s sheer good-naturedness, so that if the dwarves’ promise to share their gold fell through, he could appeal to the people of his town, because every one of them had borne witness to his oh-so-selfless treatment of them. It was vile, but there was nothing they could do for the people of Laketown yet.
There was music that played long into the night on fiddles and flutes, and Bilbo ran all around asking uselessly if anybody had a harmonica on them so he could finally show Bofur. Everywhere he was met with disappointment, and Bofur started to poke and prod at him with a cocky grin on his face, telling him that he’d made up something that didn’t exist, to much protest from Bilbo.
He’d never been a social drinker, or much of an ale drinker at all, preferring a glass of rich red wine if he ever deigned to partake in it, but the atmosphere drew him like a moth to a flame; the anxious anticipation of what lay ahead in the coming days, the headiness of being with his dwarves and being able to see the love of his heart, day after day, the knowledge that soon, finally, finally, it would be over and they could rest by each other’s sides for a long while. He clashed his mug with everyone else’s, and they all slopped beer everywhere, and that final night was spent roaring tunes from Ered Luin, songs of cheer and hope and happiness.
Of course it wasn’t long before the Company all began to beg Bilbo for a song, and not your one about the road going ever on, Bilbo, we’ve all started hearing it in our sleep, and he couldn’t seem to say no to them any longer. He longed to give the simplest parts of their quest a send-off, to the Shire and the Misty Mountains and Beorn’s lovely garden before their dastardly reality began to creep up on him.
“Oh, you’ve all asked for it,” he said, laughing and rolling his shoulders back. If only his little cousins Merry and Pippin could have seen him now! He made them clear a circle, and he began to twirl round and round.
Oh, you can search far and wide
You can drink the whole town dry
But you’ll never find a beer so brown
Oh, you’ll never find a beer so brown
As the one we drink in my home-town!
As he was dancing, he threw his mug up to the sky and his head backward, and he looked to see Thorin standing quite still in the middle of the group, arms folded across his chest and his eyes slightly wider than normal. He seemed astonished at the sight of Bilbo.
Bilbo felt a giddy grin crack across his face as he closed his eyes and sang with all his heart. He hadn’t felt so young in decades.
You can keep your fancy ales
You can drink them by the flagon
But the only beer for the brave and true
Comes from the Green Dragon!
Notes:
OKAY. i'm not going to make promises this time because i don't want to give anyone false hope but just know that whatever happens however long gaps between chapters are i am never going to abandon this fic. i'm so so sorry that this one took so long again, but it quite literally beat my ass to hell and back to finish it :(
i'm also updating this in the aftermath of a cyclone/widespread flooding hitting my area (classic ao3 author things) so it's a tiny bit more delayed than i'd hoped but! she is here extremely late nevertheless!
thank you thank you all for supporting me again and big things are to come next chapter so i'm feeling motivated :]
as always here is my twitter!
Chapter 7: something in the orange
Notes:
hello bffs it’s only been three months and not six i know you’re all as surprised as i am
i had to split this chapter in half as it ended up being almost 20k (lol) so you will notice the overall chapter count of the fic has gone up!
title taken from the song “something in the orange” by zach bryan (specifically z&e's ver, it’s one of my main songs for these two and always makes me cry)
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
After their Laketown send-off followed several days of sailing, then riding, then walking, then trudging, and then complaining before the Company of Thorin Oakenshield made it up the rock-face to the westerly Hidden Door and were waiting in the fading sunlight for the face of the moon to rise. Bilbo had very even-temperedly bitten his tongue and held off from pointing out the staircase built into the side of the Lonely Mountain, even when it meant they’d all been bumbling around like fools for far longer than they should have, but he’d had to sidestep all confusion about the last light of Durin’s Day for sheer peace of mind and simply pretended to have a rather inspired epiphany.
“Now what’s that line it says again?” he’d said, cocking his head to the side for a little extra believability. “About the light upon the keyhole? Do you suppose it could mean any light at all, rather than daylight? Perhaps the moon, for instance?”
The looks blinking back at him had been almost comical, and Balin had smiled at him in gratitude. “Every day I remain so glad Gandalf chose you for our Company, Bilbo.”
They huddled in to wait, passing around cram and the last of their Laketown apples, and sure enough, of course, once the silver moon had climbed high enough it was peeking its nose out from behind the scattered clouds, the key had gone in and the door had been opened, and thirteen faces had turned towards him with a trepidation that bordered on unease if not outright alarm. Bilbo pushed his shaking shoulders back and strode forward.
He felt as though he had reached a terrible, inevitable fork in the road, which was a little ridiculous, really, since this was in some ways the simplest task he had yet to achieve. He had done every bit of this before, knew exactly what to expect from the Mountain and the pesky parasite that lived within.
But this would also be the biggest change he had made so far to their journey, and to the fate of the world.
He was one hobbit. He did not have the physical strength to fight off a dragon. If Smaug got the better of him, Middle-Earth would likely fall to ruin within a matter of months.
(But the dragon had not before, so he would not again.)
Bofur hugged him before he left, and the rest of him waved him off, all of their faces fighting a war between hope beyond hope at the prospect of finally being so near, and abject dread at the thought of what was to come. At the thought of their hobbit, all alone in the dark, nothing but his Sting to bear aloft before him. There were whispers of goodwill and hearty claps on his shoulders as he walked, and the grim little smile he gave everyone did not seem to be doing anything to quell either their fear or their hope.
“If you — well, if you hear any sort of noises, dragon-like or otherwise,” Bilbo said with a grimace, turning to face them with one hand on the door, “whatever you do, don’t all of you come running in, or I will have a much harder time doing what it is you have hired me to do. I have a plan, should anything go sideways, but with any luck the old thing will be asleep, and I can escape with all the hair on my head!”
He was spouting absolute tosh right through his teeth and knew it, and Bilbo wondered privately whether it had occurred to any of them at any point that should Smaug be asleep they would still have had to find a way to get him out of Erebor, but it wasn’t to be helped, and it wasn’t going to happen, anyhow.
“We will follow your lead, Master Burglar,” an unmistakable voice murmured nearby.
His head was bent, the shine of the moon catching the silver streaks in his hair and causing them to appear almost luminescent in the fading twilight. His voice had been so soft, so quiet over the breeze. He was looking at Bilbo steadily, arms folded in front of his body as if to brace himself; from the wind, from the cold, from apprehension or fierce anticipation, who on Earth knew.
Bilbo looked at Thorin for a moment longer, and let his mouth quirk up at one of the corners, feeling so nervous he could barely even think to speak. Thorin did not make a sound, just held his gaze with those heavy eyes like boulders, like pools, and gave a very slow nod.
Bilbo swallowed, eyes flicking between both of Thorin’s, and then turned away, pushing open the door in the rock-face with splayed fingers and slipping inside. The heavy door swung closed with a crunch, shutting out the moonlight and the frozen faces of his friends so he was submerged in utter darkness. Only the faintest, faintest streaks of jasper-orange light against the far entrance to the stairway gave any suggestion at all that Bilbo was not alone.
He took one more moment to pause and close his eyes, taking a breath, calming himself, clenching his jaw very tightly so it would cease the trembling his body would not stop exhibiting, even though his mind was set. His heart was beating fast as a hummingbird’s wings.
(All that apprehension and anticipation and so on and so forth.)
He exhaled. He adjusted his fingers, one by one. He wrinkled his nose.
He began to creep down, down, down.
Bilbo remembered all too well how he’d felt the first time he’d walked this path, and how he’d had to stop, standing stock-still with his eyes squeezed shut and willing his weary feet to move — to move forward, to turn back, to charge onward, to flee. How the terror had clutched at him, how it had brought guilt and bitter regret, and a stinging sense of determination. How he had taken a single step, and then another, the crimson light flickering against the wall, the smell of ash growing and filling the caverns until all he was breathing in was thick hot soot.
He did not stop this time, but it was a near thing. The red was like blood against the walls. The stench was all but ruin.
He very nearly even reached for the Ring, then, trekking through the darkness, touching cautiously at the walls with the pads of his fingers, and only when his hand was already half-outstretched towards the front pocket of his coat did Bilbo remember himself with a jolt.
He would not. He’d made a promise.
Nearly a century of sneaking in the shadows and you still haven’t figured out how to do it without your little magic trick? I don’t think so, old lad.
A plan had formed in his head, back at Bard’s, and even earlier, and Bilbo knew it was grisly and dangerous and would get them all slaughtered if, heaven and hell forbid, something went wrong, but it would save the people of Esgaroth from peril, and so he would have to try.
I am not a fighter, and I am small and defenceless, and so I must use the tools at my disposal to best my enemies instead. How long ago had he said that to Thorin? And now it had finally come time for him to honour his word. Hah!
He slipped his fingers inside one little jacket pocket, and then the other. He did not intend to use the Ring, and never would again.
But that did not mean he was not going to put it to work.
It was far too soon when Bilbo reached the accursed door, beyond which lay the Great Hall of Thrain; the glorious Hall of Treasures. Somehow, he was sure he’d remembered the tunnel being longer, taking him hours and hours to crawl down as if it were a doorway to the underworld and he was willingly marching to his own doom.
Oh, the smell. It smelt like smoke, like the tang of blood, the way blood tasted like metal. Like a tomb.
The door did not creak when he opened it; the air did not move, the stillness did not shift. Gargantuan walls loomed a faint scarlet on all sides, higher than any ceiling Bilbo had ever seen before or since, and they were lined with great marbled pillars that had blackened in the bitter air. The scale of such a room was not to be conceived by either Bilbo’s eyes or thoughts.
And nothing could be seen by the eye except gold upon gold upon gold.
Bilbo held his breath as he tiptoed gently down the stairs, plunged into the gold and began searching, wading through endless rivers of coin and scooping them between his fingers in a vain search for his prize. He remembered very vaguely where he thought it might be hiding, and it was a monumental ask for a person of his size to cross a hall this grand even without the obstruction of what surely must be thousands of tons of treasure blocking his path. But he kept at it, and he squinted here and there in the sinister light, and he did not let himself make a single sound.
Of course, it did not matter. Soon enough — far too soon — he heard it.
“Are you going to keep me waiting, Thief in the Shadows?”
The horror of his growl reverberated around the hall like a tremor of the earth itself, ricocheting off all the walls and into Bilbo’s skull until there were a thousand Smaugs laughing cruelly at the little hobbit and the nightmares that clutched at his shoulders. His throat was dry. He opened his mouth, uselessly; nothing came out.
“Don’t be shy — come into the light,” the dread rumble sounded. “And let me lay my eye upon he who dares steal from the King Under the Mountain.”
Bilbo stepped out from the darkness of the pillar he’d hidden himself behind, and a sliver of glowing red-gold light was cast down his side, though his torso still lay in shadow. He held Sting before him in both of his trembling hands and gripped the hilt tightly.
“I am no thief, O Smaug the Golden-scaled,” Bilbo called, his voice surprisingly steady and strong in the great awful silence of the golden hall. “I am but a traveller who has come to look upon your magnificence. Truly, no stories in all the world hold a candle to your magnitude, Most Radiant and Renowned of all the beasts of the North.”
There was silence, a silence so tense Bilbo dared not break it, dared not look upward at where he knew the dragon was unfurling from his nest and rising slowly into the air.
“A traveller?” Smaug hissed.
Bilbo nodded earnestly, head wobbling on his shoulders like a fool. He stepped entirely out from behind the pillar and let himself be seen in full by the monster, not letting his own gaze falter as he did.
“If I may be so bold, Smaug, mightiest of the drakes of Morgoth, I am in fact not just any humble traveller, but a seeker with knowledge and riches that I sincerely desire to bestow upon you. I have travelled from incredibly far away to have such an honour. And — and even now, your magnitude is beyond any I had scarcely imagined, O Smaug, Greatest and Most Terrifying of All Beings.”
“For I am so lacking in riches,” Smaug drawled, lashing his tail. Obsidian spines the size of three lengths of Bilbo’s body peppered the sides. Bilbo hastily drew his eyes away from them as Smaug spoke again.
“And who are you to bestow such things upon me?”
Bilbo pulled his shoulders back and bit down all his fear.
“I am he who is blessed with long life. I am Luckwearer, Treasure-finder, Ringbearer, and Death-defier. I have seen the shores of immortality and turned aside. I have given my friends to mighty beasts to be eaten, and I have drowned them and drawn them alive again from the water. I have remade the very universe for my own satisfaction.”
“Such grand titles. Most impressive, Luckwearer,” Smaug remarked, and Bilbo could tell that the dragon did not believe a word he’d said, but that he had succeeded in piquing his interest all the same.
He had intentionally left out his title of Barrel-rider, for it had been his greatest fumble during his first encounter with Smaug, and he’d felt horribly guilty for long days afterwards about alerting the dragon to the people of the Lake and the aid they had given the Company, feeling that their blood was now on his hands because he had not been able to keep his warbling mouth shut.
Smaug did not have any reason to move on Laketown, this time, and though Bilbo knew he could still well assume where they’d come from and who was closest to the Mountain, he felt confident that the lure of the treasure in his pocket would be stronger. His fingers brushed once more the cloth the Ring was wrapped in.
“I am here for one other reason. I wish to offer to you, O Smaug, the Tremendous and the Terrible, something singularly worthy of such a mighty king. Something worth far, far more than all the treasure in this mountain put together.”
The drake drew himself up to his full height, his long neck arched up to the roof and the folds of his great red-black wings opening as he pushed himself above the churning sea of gold. Bilbo could do nothing but watch on, helpless, knowing with absolute certainty that he was no bigger than one of the claws on Smaug’s toes, and gritting his jaw hard against the terrifying glint in his eye. The hilt of Sting was slick between his sweaty palms.
“You doubt my wealth?”
The sound was terrible in the desecrated, lifeless hall. Bilbo started, his eyes wide.
“No, never, Your Magnificence! All have heard tell of the deeds of Smaug, the Greatest of Calamities, and even in far-away places we have heard of your unimaginable hoard of glittering gems and iron-encrusted armour.” He’d heard absolutely no such thing before he’d set foot out his door, but he wasn’t about to tell Smaug that. “That is why I have brought you such a gift. I assure you, I do not exaggerate its importance. Only you, of all beings in Middle-Earth, are fit to bear such treasure, wealthy and wondrous as you are. I can think of no other.”
The plan he’d concocted was beyond dangerous, and it was the first time in this journey that Bilbo had been truly terrified of what could happen if all went wrong. He'd more or less trusted himself so far, but now he was playing with much, much more than his own life by making a gamble such as this.
But he could not think of any other way, and so there was nothing else for it but to hold fast to the same trust.
Now was the time, when he had Smaug’s attention, when he’d been adequately bathed in flattery. He closed his eyes briefly to let out a breath and muster up his nerves, more shudder than exhale, and then quickly pulled out the Ring.
The recoil that went through the dragon at the sight of it drew all the blood from Bilbo’s skin, until the chamber felt cold as an icy wind. His bloodshot eyes were filled with a sudden hunger, and he dragged his hulking body up through the chamber, closer and closer to the prize, nostrils flared and baring black-yellow teeth sharp as blades. His claws hooked onto the walls on either side of the room, making an awful grinding noise as they clambered up and up. His eyes were locked right on Bilbo, who stood fast against his own terror, the Ring still aloft in his hand and glinting in the chamber-light.
The fork of Smaug’s tongue lashed out like a serpent’s. He licked his lips.
“Surely you don’t need such a little thing, Luckwearer? Such a little ring. And yet, I think it will do finely in my collection. You are wise to bring it to me.” His eyes were beady, barbaric. The air was thick as melting molasses and smelt of festering smoke; it was making Bilbo’s head swim. “It is quite… precious.”
Bilbo pulled his arm down, though he kept the Ring visible, and prepared himself to invoke the dragon’s rage with every bit of stubborn determination he could muster.
“I am glad you think so,” he called out cheerfully. “But I shall not part with it so easily, Smaug the Colossal, the Wicked. I worked rather hard to find it, and I shall have to see if you quite deserve it first.”
The air itself grew warmer between one breath and the next, all of a sudden stifling within the high stone walls. Bilbo felt more than ever the oppressive sense of being underground, of being alone. It was as if he was trapped within a volcano that had not yet erupted, but was brewing and bubbling deep beneath the ground. Smaug’s underbelly was a glowing amber, each scale revealing a glimpse of the hellish insides. His chest heaved, and he crept closer still. Steam burst from his nose. Heaven, but it’s warm in here.
“Deserve it, you say?” the dragon hissed, black as ice, red as flame.
“This is no mere trinket. I cannot pass it out to anyone but those who wholly understand its worth. And actually —” Bilbo said, feeling wild now, forcing the words out through his teeth with his heart hammering so loudly it was in his ears, “I have decided that I am still quite partial to my little treasure, so you shall have to take it from me by force!”
He threw the Ring high in the air, tantalising — Smaug’s expression twisted into a righteous, bloody fury, and his wings spread; Bilbo took a running leap, jumped in the air, caught the Ring and landed hard among heaving hordes of treasure. And then he began to run.
He skidded down the mountain of gems and threw himself at the next crest, fingers grasping at the coins sliding slick out from under him like a deadly golden tide. There was crashing all around him, the dragon’s roar cacophonous, deafening, bursting through his eardrums, shaking the ground below him. Flames engulfed the chamber at his back; the heat quickly became dizzying, and Bilbo could feel himself becoming frantic. The gold was moving, churning, and Smaug was airborne, was flying, was chasing, and stone was crumbling, and Bilbo was desperately, desperately running, and before he could think at all he had made it to the stairs and was hurtling out of the Front Gate down into the water below. The cold of the plunge stole the breath right out of his lungs.
He dragged himself upright, stumbling in the moat that lay beneath the battlements and pushing sopping-wet hair from his eyes to look upward for his pursuer. His heart was in his mouth, and he half-felt as though he were having some sort of attack where the air would simply not enter his lungs. He kept himself still as a statue, trusting the blackness of the water to conceal his small shape as all at once a dreadful shadow from the depths of the earth itself flew right over his head and blanketed the night.
In the deepest distance, Bilbo could see a row of tiny figures lined up atop the ruins of the city of Dale, their silhouettes blotched against the sky. All of them were still, and each seemed to be holding a bow drawn against the great face of the Lonely Mountain.
Bard had come.
They had devised a plan between the two of them, a plan far too flimsy and reliant upon both the skill of Men who were fallible and the desires of a creature far more ancient than they, but a plan that flared to life as the monster drew ever closer, searching in vain for the thief in the shadows.
“Dale is an old city. There will be an archer’s tower, and that is where you must go. The belly of the Mountain opens out right in front of it.
Nock your arrows. Wait as long as you can to shoot, because when you do, he’ll see you, and he will come. If… if it doesn’t work, hide as quickly as you can, and do not move a muscle, whatever you do. I will try and distract him again.”
If Bilbo planted Bard right in front of the dragon’s lair and he somehow did not hit it, there would be no one left in Laketown to defend it, and all would fall utterly to ruin. He was deeply unsettled by the fact that he had chosen to veer off the course of his first lifetime, but there was no other way about it. He had only this chance to save Laketown from the dragon-fire, and he had Bard and his black arrows, and he would have to hope that it was enough. There was nothing more he could do.
As he watched, the first arrows rained down against the iron of Smaug’s armour, and slipped straight off as if they were made of water. Not one of them did a lick of damage; Smaug did not even appear to have felt them, though he’d certainly seen them, and his rage only grew more terrible at the sight.
“Thief! Luckwearer! I will have my prize, and no Men of the Lake can stop me!” He howled, voice shaking the darkness and crashing against the face of the rock behind them so it filled every inch of Bilbo’s mind. More arrows were nocked; more were loosed. None hit their mark. Bilbo felt sick with dread; his bones felt like they had become stone. He could hear distant yells, the Men on the tower calling wildly to each other and trying to form new plans.
He’d ruined it. He’d doomed them all. Bard would be the first to go, and then so would everyone else. All because he’d tried to be so terribly clever. Because he’d thought himself above Fate itself.
Every man and woman and child in Esgaroth. Every one of his dwarves. Bilbo felt his knees buckle, and he crashed back down into the water.
The shouts grew louder, their desperation clear. He could hear the wings of the dragon beating, as deafening as a thunderstorm that cracked the heavens open. He forced himself to drag his head upward and keep on watching the massacre.
Smaug seemed to have pinpointed the ringleader of his attackers, where Bard was standing right in the middle of the line, and there he began to swoop lower, angled so his speed grew as he descended. His chest glowed red-hot with the brewing of his flame, and Bilbo’s heart thudded like three hundred drums were beating at once inside him.
He was too close now. They were goners. Freezing water seeped like needles into the legs of Bilbo’s trousers and crept up into his very soul as Smaug opened his great mouth and —
A scream like out of hell split the air asunder, shaking the Mountain and the lake and all those who dwelled in between. The dragon fell from the sky.
Bard had shot the black arrow.
Smaug’s body crashed to the ground in a terrible quake, the ruins around him collapsing to the ground under the sheer force, his cries of lamentation echoing underneath the dark, dark sky.
The Men upon the walls began to collapse against one another in relief, surely sapped of all their strength by sheer terror but blessedly — and beyond hope — alive. Bilbo could hear faint shouts again from Dale, this time of joy, and almost fell right onto his hands with the sudden force of his exhaustion and colossal, unimaginable relief.
The foul stench of brimstone was passing over the landscape, and steam was rising from the enormous carcass as the glowing chamber in his chest finally cooled.
The tiny figure that was Bard lowered his mighty bow, backlit by the shallow moon coming out of hiding once more from the clouds. He seemed to turn, back toward the Mountain, and after a long moment he raised one arm to Bilbo.
Bilbo could do nothing else but raise one back.
The water of the River Running was freezing, and as the panic ebbed from Bilbo’s body he became aware of his lower legs growing utterly numb with cold. He clambered out of the moat awkwardly, trousers saturated and already beginning to stiffen in the chill wind at the foot of the mountain. Foamy mists rose off the water and thickened in the air with the cold, and Bilbo hunched his shoulders down against it, already berating himself for not thinking such a foolhardy plan all the way through.
Oh, yes, he thought, rolling his eyes, shaking out the water from his sleeves and wondering with a grimace if it would possibly make the situation better or worse if he took off his jacket to wring it out. Jump over the ramparts into the river and leave yourself without a way back in. That’s the way, old lad. He’d already been grievously lucky that the river had not frosted over yet.
Perhaps he could try to signal to Bard’s men? But Bilbo could already scarcely see their silhouettes as it was, and he knew he would shout himself hoarse before he could make himself heard over the wind a mile away.
It had been a weak thought anyway. He was going to have to bite down his nerves, cut all of his losses, and wait for his chance to strike.
Bilbo knew the noise of all the fire and death would have sent the dwarves into a tizzy, and that even with their vow to him they’d surely by now have abandoned their post at the Hidden Door and come dashing down into Erebor to see whether he was all right or was nothing but a charred pile of ash.
Surely enough, after a little while, Bilbo’s ears began to catch the very faintest calls drifting from the mouth of the Mountain, the smallest suggestions of his would-be rescuers racing down to join him, though they quickly became louder and louder, and grew only more frantic the nearer they came to the Gate.
“Bilbo! Bilbo! Dori, he can’t’ve —”
“Be quiet, Nori, you’re hardly helping! Oh, if only I could get through this damnable gold —”
“Bilbo!”
That was Fili, sounding utterly torn through with fear, and Bilbo’s still-sodden heart cracked neatly in two. He sprang to his feet from his little riverbed patch opposite the Gate and began to cry out with every bit of breath his flimsy old lungs could muster.
“Here, Fili! I’m down here! I’m alright, I’m alive, I’m in the moat, I’m —”
“Bilbo?”
“Bilbo!”
“Where’s it coming from?”
“Lads, he’s here, he’s —”
“Out of the way, you idiots!” Bilbo heard Dwalin growl, and he felt silly for being so touched.
And then faces appeared one by one over the side of the battlements, high up in the air, and Bilbo held one hand to his eyes to block out the wind and squinted up at them with a daft smile on his face. All thirteen of them were talking over each other, spluttering and shoving and shouting their what-fors and why-haves down at him with frazzled looks of panic still half-stuck to their faces. Very rarely had he seen so many eyes so wide.
“What the blazes are you doing down there?” Gloin cried, a rowdy chorus of agreements tumbling down after him. Bilbo held up his sopping-wet jacket with one hand in explanation.
“I had to give the old thing the slip!” he called back up, and heard not a few short barks of laughter at his honesty. He wrung out the jacket once more, though it didn’t do him a lick of good, slipped it on and then looked back up at his captive audience.
“I don’t suppose anyone has a rope?”
There were several grunts, and some shuffling out of sight, and then Dwalin and Thorin tossed a thick cord of black rope over the wall of the Front Gate, and Bilbo began to climb.
The wind could really only have been described as vengeful as he climbed, icy fingers battering and buffeting him every which way, eagerly pulling at his hands and clothes. The stone, too, was freezing against the soles of his feet, and his fumbling fingers felt stiff and stupid grabbing at the knots of the rope. At first, they tried to haul him up themselves, as if he were a pail of water at the bottom of a well, but the jolting movement only caused Bilbo to slip, and he very nearly dropped like a stone. He swore snappishly up at them.
They rather let him get on with it, after that.
His arms ached like he’d himself been hauling around mountain-peaks when he reached the top and clambered wearily over the battlements only to very nearly stumble right down onto the floor below, but Thorin reached out with one arm and caught him gruffly around the middle, setting him down so that he was facing all of his dwarves, white-faced and stricken, and they were all facing him.
They converged on him like a particularly lumbering hive of bees — a herd of horses, perhaps — and grabbed at any part of him they could reach, pinching and poking at his skin and hair in wondrous relief, and then Bilbo was scooped up by all of them into an enormous and distinctly dwarvish embrace, and his ears flushed right up to the points.
“Enough, enough, dear me, you’re going to crush me until there’s nothing left!” he cried, feeling suddenly giddy with relief and abated terror and probably no small amount of hysteria woven in. He couldn’t seem to pull the grin from his face if he tried.
“There’s already nothing left,” Dwalin of all people grumbled with the sort of churlish disposition that Bilbo knew secretly meant he was exceedingly relieved. “How is it you weigh so little when you eat so much, hobbit?”
Bilbo fixed him with a mighty stare and very graciously did not mention the rudeness of such a question. “Because we hobbits are not so very hardheaded,” he said pointedly, and a great roar went up around the group as they laughed at his audacity. Bilbo rather suspected there was a little delirium in their joy just as was in his, no doubt from the anticipation and fear they must all have been sitting on for several hours.
He turned back to face the battlements, and there was Thorin, watching him with an intensity that knocked Bilbo backward. His eyes were very wide, his mouth parted on a breath, and he seemed to be combing Bilbo all over, eyes skittering rapidly up and down Bilbo’s waterlogged trousers and sorry excuse for a jacket as if he might find someplace where Bilbo was concealing a mortal wound.
“It’s dead?” he asked after a moment in a gravelly voice. Bilbo nodded wordlessly, unable to summarise, and instead waved a hand in the direction of the enormous black shape marring the gentle spill of moonlight that poured out onto the barren moors between where they and Dale stood.
Thorin looked upon what had become of Smaug for a long moment, his chest heaving. Then, he turned back to face them, and his face was lined with streaks of gold, his eyes like diamonds, every inch of it blown wide open in a way Bilbo had scarcely ever seen. He felt the bottom of his stomach do a traitorous little flip.
“You are extraordinary, Master Baggins,” Thorin said, and his smile was as radiant as the sun. “I have never met anyone like you in all my life.”
Mad Old Baggins. You’d do it all over again just to see that look, wouldn’t you?
Their celebrations went on for hours, though they had no drink, no guests and only their slim rations of food. Bilbo insisted to them over and over that he had not killed the dragon, but cries of “Our hobbit has done it!” washed over him everywhere he turned after they’d made their way back down into the great chamber of treasure, and soon Nori was gathering up dainty little gemstones of emerald and opal and alexandrite and pelting the lot of them, and Oin and Gloin were singing a raunchy drinking song with their arms linked and imaginary ales raised while the rest of them laughed and laughed. Fili and Kili dragged out all kinds of armour and long-lost cloaks of royal make from hooks upon the walls, and Thorin bestowed one upon each of them with a bowed head, donning himself his ancestral attire and that magnificent raven crown.
He turned last to Bilbo. Cloaked in blue furs and twinkling mail, he looked resplendent. Bilbo’s mouth felt rather dry, and several moments trickled past in which neither of them spoke, simply watching each other instead with seemingly-stilled breath.
“This hobbit,” Thorin said suddenly, his voice a resounding boom around the vast hall of marble and gold, every one of the twelve remaining heads snapping towards him, “I am indebted to for all of my life. It is he who has brought the Mountain back to us. Our hobbit.” He smiled. “Our excellent burglar.”
Thorin’s eyes were alight, his smile contained but bursting at the edges with gratitude and fondness. He looked down at Bilbo, entire face lit with nothing short of wonder.
It was a peculiarly sort of expression, really, that Thorin wore on his face, like he had been awestricken by Bilbo’s craftiness and at the same time was marvelling at the fact he could still be surprised by such a strange creature. It was one Bilbo had become well-accustomed to, in both his first and second lifetimes, and had always been one of his favourites.
Bilbo looked back at Thorin, there amongst hills and pillars and endless towering piles of gold, and, beaming, said back to him, “Didn’t I tell you? The crownless again shall be king.”
There was such deep warmth in Thorin’s expression that Bilbo had to turn away.
Far, far later, when the hall had stilled and the lights extinguished, a smallish sort of creature could just barely be spied making haste across the tides of gold as silently and strategically as he was able, heart thump-thumping against his ribcage.
He cast his eyes about, racing between piles of coins and frantically levelling them as he searched for the accursed Arkenstone, knowing far too well that he was working on a very scant amount of borrowed time. The hall in the dark seemed ghostly, and the size did not help; Bilbo would have bet a fine sum of money that if you plucked the village of Hobbiton up from its place atop the Hill and lay it down again where he stood, it would have fit rather snugly inside.
After several long, tense minutes, where Bilbo likely disturbed every single prized piece of treasure in the place in his inane search and one of the Company might well have awoken and entered the room for all that Bilbo could hear over his heart drumming a death-march in his ears, a sliver of fragmented rainbow caught the very edge of his eyeline, and slowly, slowly, he turned.
There it lay, winking at him with a thousand colours, tucked surreptitiously amongst goblets and gemstones a hill-crest or two from the far end of the hall. The opening of night air above the Front Gate had bathed the Arkenstone completely in moonlight, making it seem as if it had been placed there by all-powerful hands simply to ensure that he would see it.
Had Bilbo been a normal burglar with no dragons or lifetimes to contend with, it would surely have taken him days upon days to find it. But as it was, he clambered his way up to the ridge and plucked it ever-so-gently from its resting place, the crystal cool under his fingertips. It was just large enough that he could hold it with one hand if he splayed his fingers wide, though it was a near feat.
Bilbo gazed upon it with trepidation, swallowing around his suddenly-dry mouth. He held no love for the jewel that had rested with Thorin in his grave, and remembered only the destruction it had wrought amongst his friends, the disaster that had befallen every one of them at the sight of it. He knew the reverence Thorin and the others held it in, that it was sacred as few other things had ever been to the folk of Durin. He did not care.
And it truly was magnificent, as if capturing the stars themselves within their own heavenly case of glass, displaying the wonders of the earth to all those who were blessed enough to see it, but looking upon it, clutching the treasure with his own hand, brought him only a deep and uneasy foreboding.
Bilbo’s eyes wandered up again to the opening of the Front Gate above the hall and atop the stairs, watching the face of the moon watch him back.
Without looking down at it, he slipped the Arkenstone into his pocket.
The last time, Bilbo had felt the touch of a pull at the sight of all that gold, coaxing him towards the tidepools of coins and cups and trinkets scattered through the halls. It was why he had first pocketed the Arkenstone; for his own gain, the dizzying lure of its enchantment and the way the pearlescent gleam of it split into a hundred thousand different colours in his fingers. He had soon shaken it off, and spent the long weeks locked up in the Mountain with the pit of dread growing heavy in his stomach, but the pull had been there all the same.
This time, he felt nothing, and for a slight moment, the very slightest of moments, he was glad to have held the Ring, if only to have had the chance to let it go.
(For what call could gold and bright gemstones give, when you had once held the power of the whole world at your fingertips, and had cast it aside?)
He knew the ways your mind began to rot away, and your thoughts became one steady beating black heart, whispering precious, precious, precious. No piece of treasure would hold sway over him again.
They’d made camp in one of the entrance halls to the Hall of Treasures so as to be close enough to both the Front Gate and the Hidden Door, but Bilbo of course had his own suspicions as to their proximity to such twinkling treasure, and just as he’d feared, it was not long after that the fall began.
Within days of their victory, Thorin had fallen into the habit of shutting and bolting himself within the rooms of his grandfather with only Balin or Dwalin for company, sitting at what desks to be found that were unscathed by dragon fire and smoothing his hands over the wood. When he would emerge, he passed through the halls as if a spectre from a lost time, heavy cloak blanketing the ground after him and lavishing the gold as he went, and he would stand for long hours upon the platform overlooking the hall of his father, gazing out at his sea of gold and wringing his hands behind his back, over and over and over.
His expression when he did this was a puzzle; he could not seem to capture what it was that entranced him so, but rapt he was all the same. Bilbo wondered with an understanding he reviled what it was his mind could be whispering to him. He wondered if their whispers had ever sounded alike.
Thorin had become both quicker to laughter and quicker to anger with every one of them; he would smile, and just as soon as it had come that smile would fall, and his face would darken. It was as if blackening clouds had begun to gather above the Mountain, circling, spitting thunder and lightning that threatened to smite the ground where they stood.
Bilbo’s own mind was a swirling, tangled snarl of emotion from both his exertion and exhaustion, so many thoughts seeping into one another and colouring his every waking moment that he could hardly begin to pull them apart. He felt more fatigued than he ever had on the quest thus far with the burden of what he had to do, what he must try to prevent. Battle-weary, though there had been no battle, and so very tired of feeling the pressure behind his eyelids that he was almost sick with it.
The others had slowly begun to notice his hesitation, his grim, forlorn disposition, and they would look warily to him or to Thorin, and to each other, sensing that something was looming on the horizon but not quite knowing why. Bilbo’s fierce love of them caused his very bones to ache at the sight, and he felt stretched thin as a cotton thread, heart brimming so much and in so many directions that he could not do much of anything for anybody. For the very, very briefest of moments, he envied that Frodo had passed on from the shores of Middle-Earth, where the darkness could still touch.
(Later, he was so aggrieved at his own carelessness for someone he dared to call a loved one and whose time with him had ended so catastrophically that tears sprang to his eyes.)
Anger would burst forth from him in such sharp, lancing strikes that it alarmed Bilbo, and he would have to stop himself from clutching a hand to his own chest. And he knew well that it was anger borne of self-hatred, anger borne of unfairness, and guilt, such guilt, and fear, and silliest of all, anger borne of grief. How preposterous it was, to mourn someone alive and well in front of you. Why are you so sad, you mad hobbit? he would think to himself as he walked the halls, reluctantly miming his own desperate search for a jewel he already very well knew the location of. Why is it you are always feeling so terribly sorry for yourself?
But he could not help it. The gold hummed all around him, like it sensed its brethren that lay in his pocket and sang for them to be reunited. He heard Thorin’s murmurs as they echoed along the walls, my right, my prize. My precious. He could hardly stand to listen to it.
Watching him deteriorate this way was far worse that Bilbo knew now with exact recollection how it felt to fall.
He saw the pull it held over Thorin, and felt it himself like a mirrored echo. He would watch desire grow in Thorin’s eyes and feel sick at the familiarity it brought.
He would sit atop mountains of gold, turning gemstones over in his hands and wracking his faulty old brain for some way to ease Thorin’s gold-sickness, all the while knowing that the only way to break free of the hold was — impossibly — to break out of it yourself. And that was the tallest ask in all of Middle-Earth.
(Bilbo, of course, did not know that beings far greater than he had fallen to the lure of gems and treasures, and cities had been wrecked, and mountains destroyed, and the shape of the very world changed. He did not know this, and so he could not register that every bit of empathy he rightfully held for Thorin Oakenshield and Frodo Baggins should have also been turned toward himself.)
Worse still was the way Thorin would look at him. There was such tenderness in his expression when their eyes met, and he would smile softly like he’d seen something wonderful, and Bilbo could not bear to hold his gaze even once. The feel of it burned against his skin, knowing that the treasure of his heart was an arm’s reach and yet a lifetime away, knowing that it was not real, it was not him, knowing the greed and anger that lurked beneath that gentle smile. He did not know how much of it was genuine and how much was the dark possessiveness of the gold whispering over Thorin's shoulders. He could not watch something that should have been warm and lovely and secret become warped by smudged and creeping fingers.
“Enter.”
Bilbo gave the heavy door he’d been knocking at a push with his shoulder and made his way into the room, knuckles still smarting on one hand from how solid the wood had been.
Opposite him and alone sat Thorin, upright in a bareboned chair and bent forward over a muddled pile of papers that lay on the knee-high table in front of him. It was still quite early in the morning, and uncommonly dark, even as far underground as they surely were; the torches in each corner of the room burnt low, and clouds of dust floated listlessly through the pools of light they left.
One half of the room was bare of all belongings save Thorin’s little table and chair and, in the far corner, a gorgeously lustrous mahogany desk quite commanding its own attention, and the other half appeared as though a giant had woken up and taken a mighty swing at it with a battering-ram. Pages and pages of parchment and scrolls and what had once been cabinets and drawers lining the right-hand wall were cluttered about the floor, and whatever other grandness had once existed inside this room lay obliterated amongst the ruins.
It was clear in this chamber that what had not been incinerated on impact had rotted away in the century-and-a-half since the dragon had come and the dwarves had either fled or perished. It looked as if a demolishing had taken place and been only half-finished, and Bilbo was quite thunderstruck at how sad the sight made him. Even in their happiness, in their reclamation of their home long-lost, everywhere his dwarves turned lay tragedy.
This had been Thror’s study chambers in the highest days of Erebor’s splendour and majesty, and suddenly, though he had not the faintest idea at all what dwarven fauntlings looked like, Bilbo could not help but imagine a much smaller Thorin leaning up to look over the desk at his grandfather, blue-eyed and serious, determinedly watching the King Under the Mountain in all his glory and taking note of everything he did so that he might be a great king too.
“Bilbo?” Thorin said, looking up from his reading to watch as Bilbo slipped through the door and strode forward. His smile was slight, but soft, and he only let his eyes fall again once Bilbo had reached his side.
Bilbo looked over Thorin’s shoulder with cautious interest, grasping the back of the chair slightly so he could lean forward to squint down at the documents Thorin held, but upon seeing them, he turned away, jaw tensing.
He’d been half-heartedly hoping that Thorin had started to look over Balin’s contracts and calculations for their future alliance with and compensation toward the Lakemen, that somehow he had pulled himself back from drowning and was choosing of his own right-minded volition to honour his word and his deeds.
But not one of the dozen scrolls that Thorin had in front of him contained numbers. Instead, every available space was stained with a scrawled, hasty font, like the author’s mind had been working far too erratically for his penmanship; lines and lines of text lay atop and in between one another, were cramped into corners and smudged black into the page, and every word he could see was not Common but written instead in the Khazad-runes of Angerthas.
“We have still not yet found it,” Thorin said, gaze roaming hungrily over every meaningless word on the parchment in front of him.
Even if Bilbo had not been painstakingly aware of it, there was little question what it was he was talking about; each and every member of the Company had been alternating their time on hands and knees, eagerly feeling around for the sacred jewel they so craved and brimming still with false hope. It had touched all of them, Bilbo knew, but Thorin had been taken hold of worst of all, and one by one they would wake from it until only he was left. His mind had bent utterly to it, and Bilbo knew miserably well that nothing he said from then on would turn it away.
“Well, there are rather a lot of things in this Mountain of yours,” Bilbo said shrewdly. “It’s no wonder it’s taking some time.”
Thorin chuckled, throwing his head back for a moment from his scouring of his grandfather’s last testaments. “I do not mind,” he said, thumbing the side of a faded scroll. “We are close to truly retaking our homeland. And it is you, Master Baggins, who have brought us this close.”
There was a shuffle of fabric and the creak of a chair, and Bilbo knew that Thorin had turned to look at him, but he only bit the inside of his cheek and kept his eyes trained on the rest of the room, floating about the wreckage, over the desk and the little chips in its wood. A silence grew between them.
It had not yet been so long that they had begun to feel stifled within the Mountain and its muggy, stagnant air, that they could not still take joy in the suggestion of sky and clouds and cool breeze showing itself over the distant battlements of the Front Gate, but they were a far way from the Front Gate, and no light penetrated here. He itched to free himself from this, to open up a window and look out at the world beyond for just one moment of peace.
(But they were so very deep within the Mountain.)
Instead, Bilbo ambled over to one of the torches lining the wall to watch the shadow of the flames dance languidly against the stone, a strange mirror of reeds in a riverbed. He likely should have felt terrified at the sight, considering the very recent nature of his brush with dragon-fire, but he felt only mesmerised.
“What would you have me give you, Master Baggins?” Thorin said then.
Bilbo’s attention was pulled quite away from his wallowing with haste. He spun around at once to where Thorin was watching him quietly, startled.
“I beg your pardon?”
Thorin had risen from the chair and was making his way over to Bilbo slowly, enshrouded as he was in his navy kings’ cloak. “In gratitude,” he said, tilting his head downward and looking at Bilbo with those twinkling eyes. He seemed a tad amused, but it soon ebbed into a look of imploring, his face open and trusting and all the more painful to look upon for it. “For what you have done. What would you have me give you?”
What on Earth are you talking about, you silly creature?
“You can’t possibly think — you have given me more than I have ever asked for, Thorin.”
Really, he’d signed a contract, and as far as Thorin was aware, Bilbo was to be receiving some sort of portion of riches equal to the rest of the Company, and no more or no less, though he was of course perfectly happy to simply swipe up that chest of troll-gold for a rainy day and be on with it.
Thorin frowned, his face darkening, illuminated strangely in the flickering light. “I have given you nothing,” he said, voice low, and Bilbo swallowed.
Perhaps this was the worst of it. That Bilbo could still see him somewhere in there, so golden-hearted, so sacrificial. Warm, and clear, and coloured with life.
Not gone, yet. But going all the same.
Bilbo smiled, though it felt like clouds had gathered over his face, and tilted his head to the side, looking up at Thorin’s brows bent together crookedly.
“Your friendship,” he said simply.
The countenance of the King Under the Mountain cleared, and at length he turned and strode back toward the chair and table, stooping to gather the scattered papers and making his way back to place them on his grandfather’s desk. Though he seemed calm, his gaze had clouded over, like his thoughts were descending downward, and Bilbo trailed after him unsurely, both of them coming to a stop in front of the desk and facing each other. Thorin reached out and leant upon it with one hand, his eyes trained on Bilbo.
“Perhaps we could plant you another garden,” he said.
I beg your pardon? Bilbo had to force himself not to say yet again, stupidly. His expression must have betrayed his thoughts somehow, however, because it was then that Thorin’s eyes creased with a smile like daisies sprouting, and earthworms very suddenly dug their way up through Bilbo’s insides and burrowed themselves into his chest.
“Your garden, back in the Shire. You said it had meaning to you,” Thorin said quietly. “Will you tell me?”
One of the torches crackled gently behind them, though the rest of the room was utterly still; no noise had filtered through the door at all, and Bilbo had not the faintest idea where anybody else was, but he was surely glad there were no Balins or Dwalins around to see him becoming all afluster. He might have even been convinced once more that all was miraculously well and the tendrils snaking their way across Thorin’s chest had somehow loosened their hold, if not for the brightness of Thorin’s eyes, the fondness of his smile.
Too bright. Too trusting. Bilbo wilted, stubbornly, painfully, and then pushed on.
“Oh, my little garden was beautiful. I planted it such a long time ago, the rings had all bled together,” he said, pushing down his ridiculous tangle of thoughts and pretending he could not hear the wobble within his own voice. “The outer circle was full of red carnations and rosemary, for symbolising remembrance and an aching — aching heart. Then white hyacinths, to carry your prayers, and in amongst them were gardenias, which tell of a secret love. Poppies for eternal sleep. Blue salvia to mean ‘I am thinking of you’, and red to mean ‘forever mine’. Purple hyacinths for forgiveness and sorrow.”
He ducked his head. He could not look Thorin in the eye.
“Sweetpeas, which mean a blissful goodbye, and butterfly weed, which means ‘let me go’. Lilacs for moving on. And, at the very heart, well — I’m sure you can guess what forget-me-nots mean.”
When Bilbo looked up once more, Thorin was still watching him, no longer a smile on his face but the look in his eyes such that Bilbo knew if he had been given a thousand lifetimes to search for it, there would not have been a jewel within the earth he could have found that would have come close to the shine of Thorin’s expression.
It was this, oddly enough, this gentleness, that shook Bilbo out of whatever slumber he had begun to fall into, the spell Thorin was under clutching at him too, and he scrunched up his nose, letting his eyes fall from Thorin’s transfixed ones.
Enough, he thought. Enough, you simpering fool. They were not two hobbits in their twenties falling over each other with giddy smiles and silly promises. Whatever glimmered in Thorin’s eyes was not affection but fever, and whatever fanciful musings Bilbo had been letting himself fall into in this tucked-away room were nothing but fiction. An undercurrent of danger and dread lay beneath this conversation, underneath every step Thorin took in these halls that should have done nothing but welcome him home, and that wild spark of anger shot through Bilbo again so quickly it stunned him.
He closed his eyes. He turned away.
“But I’m not so sure that it would work — most of the plants are accustomed to milder climates, and you cannot find much milder than the Shire,” Bilbo said, imagining himself picking the conversation with one hand like the petal of a flower and crushing it under his heel. He turned more firmly to the doorway and made to leave — it was a foolish decision, really, to come here in the first place, and he wasn’t sure what in the world he been expecting — but again, that voice arrested him.
“The snapdragons will still grow.”
Bilbo trotted to a halt, the soles of his feet skimming the dust in the quiet of the room, and then turned back to face Thorin. “I’m sorry?”
Thorin took a step forward, so that they were once more angled towards each other. He looked over Bilbo’s face, across his hair and neck and ears, down at Bilbo’s chest, gaze glancing over the lines of his lapels and the dusty handkerchief stuffed in his breast pocket before climbing up again.
“You spoke of snapdragons, in Beorn’s garden, as did I,” he said, the baritone of his voice a crackling hearth as it settled over Bilbo. “They have grown here in the past. My sister will like them.”
He walked forward once more, until they stood booted foot to bare toe, and looked for a long-stretching moment to the now-empty table at the foot of the chair before fixing his eyes intently on Bilbo’s. “We can plant them here, Bilbo. We can transport them right from the Shire. You will have your garden all to yourself.”
Bilbo’s cheeks flushed far too warmly with affection, and with dagger-sharp anguish, and he bent his head to fumble for a moment in his jacket pocket — the right one, not the dreaded left — for his handkerchief, not pulling it out but clutching at it tightly enough that his knuckles went white.
“I’m very grateful, Thorin, but I do not much think there would be any point,” he said, brushing his fingers over the silk, scrunching, smoothing, scrunching again.
He’d completely forgotten about this handkerchief, truth be told, until he’d woken up in his little bedroom in Bag End again. He’d made all that fuss about it the first time around, hadn’t he? All that and it hadn’t mattered one bit in the grand scheme of things.
Sleek and satiny, it was, and one of his old favourites, though as he rubbed it he could feel the build-up of months and months’ worth of grime and filth from their long days on the road, and his nose wrinkled. Not good, not good at all. A wash, he thought diplomatically, smoothing, scrunching, smoothing. Needs a good wash, that’s all.
But they had very little water and even less supplies with which to clean down here in the Mountain, so really, it was pointless to think on it at all. All that fuss! All that over a handkerchief and he hadn’t even thought to bring a spare in case it got ruined, hadn’t thought at all. He hadn’t thought, had he? He scrunched, smoothed —
— and jerked his head upward as quite without warning Thorin Oakenshield had begun to brush the unruly curls back from Bilbo’s face and up across his temple, forge-rough fingertips lingering over the point right where the skin of his cheekbone met his hair.
Immediately, Bilbo stumbled back and brought his hand up to ruffle at his own hair nervously, hoping the ridiculous length it had grown to would hide how bright his cheeks had gotten. “Oh!”
“There you are, Master Baggins,” Thorin murmured, and oh, why were his addled eyes always so confusticatingly earnest?
Thorin pulled his hand back, though it hovered between them rather than falling down to his side. They gazed at each other for one long moment more, Bilbo making a rather valiant attempt at keeping his head aloft while his fingers fumbled and every bit of blood in his body seemed to be trying to make its way to his cheeks. Thorin looked at him steadily.
”Where do you go?” he asked quietly, warm eyes gleaming in a face so cold. “When you are remembering?”
Bilbo smiled lopsidedly at him, bright with embarrassment and tearfulness both. His face felt like paint that had cracked on a wall. Or perhaps the roots of a tree that had broken through long-dry earth to find that they had missed the rain.
“Nowhere, Master Oakenshield.”
Nowhere at all, for there was nowhere to run. All he could do was watch, and all he could do was wait.
Thorin frowned, and it changed his face, the caverns deeper, the lights extinguished. The diamond-bright smile was no more.
This time, when Bilbo turned away and made to leave the room, Thorin let him.
Notes:
thank you to everyone for your well-wishes on the last chapter! everyone who has been reading this is so endlessly lovely to me and i am so, so grateful for you all :( and thank you thank you also to my beautiful angel fairytekoo who has betaed chapters six, seven and eight for me and is a saint
i hope you all enjoyed and my twitter is here <3
next chapter up in a week!
Chapter 8: don’t you remember
Notes:
:)
title taken from the song “don’t you remember” by adele
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Days went by.
It was never-ending, Bilbo thought, and the thought was a dismal one. The lure of a dragon’s hoard, and the torment of its crown jewel; so strong, and so sickly.
Night and day bled and blurred into one another, smearing the mountainside in an endless, endless grey-gold haze, and a growing tremble began under foot as the Mountain began to murmur. The warm wooden halls and salt-bitten air of days past seemed nothing but a dream that had floated in and out again between Mirkwood and the Mountain. They had simply exchanged the canopy of leaves for stone.
On and on the dwarves combed the halls, weary and stumbling on their feet, sharing the burden of stalking up and down among towering pillars of gems and knocking them over to dig their fingers through the takings in the hope of finding the Arkenstone. Bilbo could scarcely stand to watch it, and had to turn his face away when it was not he himself who was putting up the flimsy front of hunting back and forth for the accursed thing.
Each day the crevice of Thorin’s brow bent deeper, and his smile became shadowed and sunken as they came to him one by one with no news of his cherished prize. Dull bruises began to paint themselves underneath his eyes, and his head bent ever downward, so that when he would look up his gaze became menacing, and he lurked more and more in shadow.
But for Bilbo alone the clouds would part, and he would smile and say Bilbo or Our hobbit so tremendously fondly it stung at Bilbo’s sides. He could hardly bear to look at the way Thorin’s eyes darkened every day, the way he’d become twisted into a bare shadow of what he used to be, and the way his gaze fell further and further to the floor, searching endlessly for his prize and not caring at all that he was home.
He slunk as if snakelike; he had donned his raven crown permanently, and it was as though the very light in the Mountain had dimmed, as if a rot had stirred awake in the beds of the stone. The air felt sick, and rooms were thick with decay, and everything smelled moth-eaten, like a fire had long blown out and grown cold.
The Men had not yet come to bother any of them. Bilbo supposed that they’d likely been waiting on one of the dwarves to exit the Mountain themselves to make the offering of goodwill they had promised only days beforehand, and to begin discussing what sort of portions of gold they could extend to begin rebuilding Dale and the North in exchange for food and aid. They had been given no reason yet to think that Thorin Oakenshield and his kindred would not keep the word he had offered so freely. They did not yet know.
But Bilbo did, just as he knew that this time Bard was aware that he, at the very least, had not perished in the dragon-fire, though the dwarves themselves were of course not aware of this information.
It was inevitable, then, that after one full week and then some had passed with only silence from the Mountain, the Men of Esgaroth made their first approach at twilight. Nori had espied the congregation from afar with his shining new Erebor-made eyeglass all rimmed with bronze, and called down that many of the apparent Lakemen were looking suspiciously Elven.
Just as with the reading of the moon-runes in Rivendell, Bilbo did not make his presence known at their parley through the wall and instead hid himself away in a little nook nearby, knowing already that it was only going to fan the growing flames of Thorin’s rage.
(Rather shamefully, his absence was also because he did not want to witness the look of reproach that would surely blotch all over Bard’s face at the sight of him cozied-up and cowering within the arms of the Mountain. Never mind the fact that he’d just saved dozens of Bard’s people from death by tossing himself over the battlements.)
It was true that the people of Laketown had given the dwarves aid they would have suffered dearly without at the expense of their own livelihood. They had been instrumental on the journey, sheltered them, fed and watered them, celebrated their return and given their blessing where others had only scorned or stopped them.
It was true, also, that approaching the Lonely Mountain with an army at your back and nothing of any sort of treaty beforehand could be very well perceived as a threat, and that a threat overshadowed by a dragonspun desire to protect what had once been taken so viciously would be perceived as an act of war.
The Men were right, and had every right, and yet if Bilbo thought about it at certain angles, so too did the dwarves. And so there was nothing for it, and nothing that would come of it, and a sharp revulsion curdled in Bilbo’s belly at his constantly-having to pull at the strings of his friends to move them the way he desired as if he were a terrible puppet-master.
As it was, he heard their back and forth from the crevice in the wall he’d nestled himself in to eavesdrop; Bard’s bullheadedness and Thorin’s greed, the threat of arrows and the answering besiegement. The stamping of the feet of hundreds of Elves and Men and horses outside rocked the mountain to its roots, sending tremors skyward on all sides so that inside the walls it shuddered with a dreadful anticipation, and Bilbo’s mood soured even further.
Truly, there were few things he found more tedious than the incessant peacocking all these Big Folk felt obliged to in order to get through business. The pomp and performance, the bruised egos and lashing of unkind tongues to lick the wounds. Curse the stubborn pride of all the races of Middle-Earth! He had not the slightest bit of time for it, cooped up as they were with nothing but reminders of what lay ahead, naught but faint flickers day in and day out that told him he could not change a thing, not just now, not just yet.
Finally, Thorin shouted down his threats of death and struck the bitter blow, and Bard stormed away with fury no doubt etching deeper lines into his ever-stony face. There was much muttering and murmuring from the Company as he departed, and Bilbo shifted impatiently inside his little nook with an exasperated huff, watching the wall for the slightest signs of movement so he could calculate the perfect approach.
After what seemed an age and a half, the dwarves trickled back down the battlement staircase and into the Hall, cursing blackly under their breath and their faces shrouded in anger, though Bilbo could see too the lingering unsteadiness that patchworked every one.
Only three remained atop the ramparts. Thorin himself, no doubt looking out in distaste as the Men turned tail and marched back to their lines drawn in the sand, his brow pressed steeply downward by the thumb of the crown against his forehead. Standing on either side of him were not Fili and Kili, as Bilbo had first assumed, but each of the sons of Fundin, both of his seconds at the hand of their King.
When all was quiet and still, Bilbo crept out from his hiding-place, hating and yet relishing how exceedingly good at it he had become, as if all of Erebor were a maze and he alone had discovered the secrets it stretched out. Voices began to echo out once more from the Front Gate, bluntly hewing the silence.
“Thorin, you have given your word. You gave it on behalf of our kindred. That is no small detail.”
Calm and measured, Bilbo thought approvingly. No less than what he would expect from Balin. He imagined the old fellow patting his wispy beard, fixing Thorin with one of those clear-as-day looks that somehow turned your thoughts to glass in your face while he watched you with twinkling eyes.
The sudden boom of Thorin’s response was an avalanche against the mountainside.
“You would wish me beholden to the words I made to a people who approach us unprompted with weapons and armies behind them? Who bring Elves before me, as if Thranduil and his kindred have any claim at all over what lies in this mountain?”
The stone steps wound their way back and forth, threading a stitch up the spine of the Gate until they plateaued at the top and gave way to the upper ramparts. Bilbo reached them and settled one, then both of his feet atop them as he began stealthily to climb, pressing one hand wide against the wall so he would not stumble and give himself away. He listened with a lowered head and a twisted-up face as Balin’s voice and demeanour did not change, steady as he had ever been in the face of danger.
“If we wish to reestablish Erebor as the stronghold of the North,” he said matter-of-factly; rather bravely, to Bilbo’s ear, “it is a fact you must consider very heavily. The Lake and the Wood are our neighbours, no matter how much you may resent it. We will need them as greatly as they need us.”
Thorin’s pacing back and forth was heavy against the stone, so heavy it beat a rhythm against the floor in terrible time with Bilbo’s skipping heart.
“One hundred and seventy years I have been parted from what is mine,” Thorin whispered lowly, and the wind began to whistle louder than before, until he was almost inaudible over the din. He seemed pained, tormented, as if the yearning and grieving and gold-lust had intertwined within his very blood and become instead one terrible, monstrous hunger. As if Thorin had run his loving fingers along the edge of the ramparts and they had come back stained.
Balin made an objecting noise. “Thorin —”
Thorin spat something harshly in Khuzdûl rather than deigning to grace him with a response. There was a great sigh, and then a silence that seemed balanced on the point of a dagger, no sound at all but the eerie wail of the wind.
Bilbo crept up and up until he had reached about halfway and angled his ear to hear more clearly through the stone, tilting his head this way and that and squinting up at the ramparts far above as if it might make any difference whatsoever.
He turned once more and abruptly came face to face with Balin opposite him, descending the stairs in the dim dusk-light.
Bilbo blanched, eyes blowing wide, and Balin held up a steady hand to put him at peace, giving him a placating sort of smile, though it was tight, and very plainly did not reach his eyes; it barely lingered upon his mouth.
A gruff voice broke the weeping wind above them.
“Are we to waste away in here until we starve?” Dwalin said, his voice darker and hoarser than Bilbo had ever heard it.
“A small price to pay, is it not?” the response bit back.
The two of them looked up from the staircase, as if there they would find the thunderstorm of Thorin’s wrath spilling over the battlements and enveloping them both in a thick fog. Bilbo pressed his mouth together and looked back down at Balin, whose face had grown even wearier between one glance and the next.
“Balin,” he whispered, “this is madness.”
Helpless. They were helpless, he felt helpless. Balin took another step down so that they were level with each other.
“Aye, laddie. I know.” Worry bloomed bright and oleander-soft in Balin’s gentle face, and Bilbo swallowed rather showily.
He could not have said what possessed him then to ask it. Perhaps it was that more than ever he felt half-lost in a memory, every moment following one another just as it had once before, a tumbling stack of cards; no matter what he did or said, an unchanging omen of coming doom.
Drumming, drumming, in the deep.
“Have you found it?” Bilbo said. He did not need to specify what.
“No,” Balin answered quietly, shaking his head minutely. “No, I’m afraid we have not.” He bowed his head but kept his eyes on Bilbo, imploring, and Bilbo’s breath had caught somewhere in his throat, entangling in his chest before it could find its way out of his mouth.
They stared at each other, poised upon the half-step.
”Have you?” Balin said. His voice was softer than snowfall, and quieter than the grave.
Bilbo opened his mouth, and nothing came out.
“We need aid, Thorin,” Dwalin ground out far above. “Allies of our own. Do we not wish to send ravens to Dain in the Iron Hills, and your sister in Ered Luin? To our kin?”
There was a plaintiveness to his words, the bitter air half-obscuring them from Bilbo and Balin’s eavesdropping ears, that touched Bilbo far more than he had expected. If Thorin’s heart was crafted from gold, Dwalin’s beat as if lined with iron, unbroken, unyielding, and Bilbo was grateful for his fortitude.
Balin watched him, no judgement on his face, his eyebrows gently raised as if trying to coax the answer from Bilbo’s careless tongue, and Bilbo felt split in two, one half ahead, one looking back, always, always, never sure enough, never satisfied.
(For every bit of this had been horribly familiar. Bilbo remembered it, in another room, another day, and he could have whispered along to everything Balin said as if he were reciting a final testament.)
Oh, what was the point? What good could he do, when the pieces had all started to fall the same way no matter how he pushed them? It was Mirkwood all over again, it was the goblin-fight in the trees, it was the trolls and their hoard. All he touched in this mountain stayed as stone, and would not bend beneath his un-dwarven fingers.
One final rumble rang out from atop the Gate, and Bilbo’s heart drummed in time with every wretched word Thorin spoke.
“Aye,” he said, and the clouds gathered, and dusk gave way to midnight, and still Bilbo could not alter the path that snaked through the beds. Could not turn back the fall.
“I will send word to Dain. I will tell him to prepare an army.”
Bilbo was perched upon the platform that stood sentinel high above the Hall of Treasures, looking out with a tight expression at the slit of moonlight still to be seen from afar atop the Front Gate. He was quite alone, and quite muddled up in his melancholy thoughts. The world was black and white over the barricade of the Front Gate with night sky and star, awash in a monochrome film, and if he concentrated Bilbo could almost see the faraway movements that had begun in Dale, the little lights that told of the growing numbers of the army surrounding them. Even from here, they could feel the frost sweeping in and the stone walls trapping the cold, and Bilbo wondered with a shiver how the dwarves had kept Erebor warm through every winter in the past. All those forges, he supposed.
A crunch of boot sounded out suddenly behind him, and he spun with his stomach somewhere down around his knees to find Thorin Oakenshield on the step, one silver-cuffed hand grasping the doorway and his eyeline following Bilbo’s out across the golden expanse below them.
Bilbo’s hands went to his pockets in a panic, nonsensically, until he remembered he had hidden the stone away days beforehand and tried to play off the movement as if he was readjusting his lapels with what must surely be a primrose-pink face. He settled, then squinted.
Thorin looked terrible. Dark hollows had settled themselves underneath his eyes, and though they had not yet been locked away long enough to feel the effects of hunger, his cheeks were becoming gaunt, everything about him seemingly sharpened beneath a whetstone. His skin was pale and greying in the perpetual shadow of the closed city, so much so that it appeared almost waxy, and his hands were closed to fists at his sides. And still, still, he wore the raven crown.
“Bilbo,” he murmured, eyes lingering a moment more on the vastness of his riches before drawing themselves to him. Bilbo stilled, and swallowed.
“Hm?”
Thorin took a step closer, letting his hand fall from the wall. He did not move as a proud leader would, nor a warrior; every movement was stilted, hunched over, as if his kings’ cloak had brought down weights upon his shoulders.
He reached inside that cloak and drew from it a small bundle of silver, and Bilbo’s breath stuttered, his eyes surely growing to the size of tea-saucers.
Oh, he thought, rather bittersweetly. Oh, of course.
“I wish for you to have this.”
And of course he knew what it was going to be before Thorin unfolded and held up the glittering shirt of mail, dark eyes resting intently on Bilbo’s face.
It truly was beautiful, exquisite beyond any conceivable notion of the word, the mithril glimmering spectacularly in the light of the few torches they had lit along the walls. Bilbo almost reached out to touch it, to run his fingers across stones he’d so cherished, and then fought madly with himself to keep his hands by his side. He caressed it tenderly with his eyes instead.
Here is where I took a knife, he thought, and here is where Frodo took a trollspear, if he’s told me correctly. And here is where I got knocked quite hard in the back with a rock!
He looked at the collar swooping in a sleek curve underneath the back of the neck, and the shoulder woven with truesilver like silken threads of starlight. Two wounds the shirt had not saved.
Bilbo wrinkled up his nose. Enough reprimanding. He should be steeling himself against such thoughts. There wasn’t any time for them now. He’d done what he could, hadn’t he? He had not been himself, had barely been anyone at all.
And he had not made the shirt. He’d only passed it on. He would have coated every single inch of Frodo in mithril if he’d had even a smidgen of the means.
“Have what?” he said instead.
Thorin leant closer, the entire line of his body bending towards Bilbo as if he were a sunflower quenching its thirst for sunlight. His eyes were so bright, so charming, even worn down as he was. And the most awful thing was that he looked so terribly happy.
“You say you will not plant your garden, so I would ask you to take this. A token, of our friendship. It will keep you safe.”
Bilbo shot him a quick smile that must have looked like someone had trodden on his foot and did not ask Thorin what the mithril would keep him safe from. He knew Thorin would not have an answer.
He could not take it. How could he take it?
(But it was his, and it was Frodo’s. To accept it felt tainted, but he was a fool beyond all fools if he did not and then ran headlong into battle not a fortnight from now.)
“It is mithril. The most beloved metal of my people,” Thorin said softly. “It cannot be pierced by blade, bow or spear.”
He was holding it aloft, expression glowing as he watched Bilbo, and Bilbo cast his eyes downward, feeling suddenly far too tired.
“Thorin, I’m not worth all this,” he tried.
A flash of something sparked in Thorin’s eye, and as was the case more and more often these days, Bilbo could not tell what it was. Dark, and prideful, and greedy.
“You would doubt my sincerity?” The voice was cold, quiet. Something about it raced up Bilbo’s spine, one uneasy lick that had all the hairs on his arms and feet standing on end. His throat dried out, and he did not speak.
Thorin’s mouth twitched, and the facade fell, just for a moment, the fangs lengthening in his mouth, the black in his eyes. His face was half-bathed in darkness, concealed in shadow.
The facade. But it wasn’t a facade, was it?
“You are loyal, Bilbo,” Thorin said, and Bilbo could almost see with his own eyes the warring within him, the bobbing of his throat, the shoulders so stooped it was as though vultures had preyed themselves upon his raiment. “You — I am… drawn to you. I cannot trust any other, it seems.”
He held out the shirt of mail again, and Bilbo took it with trembling fingers, removing his coat and slipping the mithril gently over his head. It lapped at his skin like water at the banks of a stream, and Bilbo marvelled at it even still, that forged steel could be so delicate and yet so strong.
He pulled his curly head through the collar, replaced his jacket and looked back up, feeling inexplicably lost at sea, and it was then that Thorin curled down over Bilbo and whispered, as Bilbo had known and dreaded he would, “One of them has stolen it.”
His eyes lowered to Bilbo’s chest, to his collarbone, where the diamond gleamed from beneath his jacket. They lingered there, dark and heavy, before Thorin pulled them up once more to rest them on his face.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said, steadying himself, “how can you be sure?” Speaking with Thorin like this felt as if he were sneaking around the den of a bear. Thorin’s lip twisted in disgust, and he shook his head, striding towards the edge of the platform and staring out unseeing at the golden sea and its black horizon above.
“I cannot make treaties with Elves nor Men nor my own kindred,” he said, with such venom in his voice that had Bilbo not heard it before he would have flinched. “They would all seek to steal from me. Allow enemies to gather at my door to pick at my spoils.”
There was no our in his speech, no camaraderie or care for the Company any longer. There was light in his eyes, but only in bursts, and only for that which had grown itself from evil. A dread-filled sort of resolve began to unfurl itself deep in the pit of Bilbo’s stomach.
He looked to Thorin once more, his broad shoulders and back to Bilbo, standing arrested at the sight of the Hall of Treasures. Lit by the light of but a few lanterns, hands clasped behind his back, dark cloak, dark hair, dark circlet atop his head, dark sky looming before him. He was blinded, deafened, to everything around him but his terrible, terrible fixation on the gold.
(Oh, but he looked like a painting. A painting of war. Of when the world fell apart.)
Bilbo found himself almost scampering away in his haste, chest heaving like he’d run a mile in a millisecond. He did not know if Thorin had even heard him go.
He tucked himself away in some offshooting corridor — where it was exactly he didn’t know and did not much care, as long as he was far away from that unbearable hall and its dreadful platform — and leant his head backward until it pressed against the cool stone, closing his eyes.
There was nothing lovely about Thorin like this, no matter how saccharine his words might be. The gold had run its slippery fingers all over him, had drawn him entirely under, and it was more difficult than ever to watch him when Bilbo now knew how it felt to succumb, too.
He longed to draw Thorin into the circle of his arms until his head was pressed against Bilbo’s own chest, to kiss his nose and mouth, to pull his mind from his head somehow and wash it clean with his own fingers. Lay down your head, my dear, he wanted to whisper. Close your eyes, just for a moment.
But this helplessness was familiar and counted upon, and Bilbo grounded himself with it. His fingertips tapped against the wall gently, and he concentrated until he had slowed his breathing, and thought with a pang of the mantra of years long passed, the waking thought that had beat in his sternum and speckled all of his memories.
What do I do now?
Laying the table for one and wondering why it felt like he’d forgotten someone when nobody else had ever been there. Watching the colours in his garden bloom, the petals floating through the air as they fell from their stems at the change of the seasons.
What do I do now?
Feeling like every day had come to a complete stop, like he was holding his breath until the next adventure, like his house was far too still with quiet he wasn’t used to, and wondering how he was ever meant to move through the space when something was now so clearly irreplaceably missing.
What do I do now?
At first it had been helpless heaving, sobbing, choking, and water had filled and flooded his lungs, and it was all he could do even to take a step. Over time, it changed, to a cry, then a stutter, then a whisper, and then to a thought, and the thought had changed its shape as it travelled companionably along through the years with him.
I love him.
I love him.
One foot in front of the other, that’s the way.
Oh, I do miss you terribly some days, Thorin. I hope you’re sleeping soundly.
I spoke to the oak tree today.
And today.
And today as well. She’s always kind to me.
The sweetpeas were a nice touch, I think. You’d have liked my lilacs, too.
Frodo-lad, if you had done that to a pair of Thorin’s boots, he’d’ve glared at you so hard you’d have fallen over, and I would have laughed and laughed.
Isn’t it warm in the sunshine, my dear?
He could bear it no longer. He had to go.
Bilbo would not argue himself away this time with talk of shares and a fourteen-way-split. He knew it did not matter. And he would not keep on waiting around again and wasting precious time feeling sorry for himself so that they could all half-starve in the siege. If less time had passed for Thorin to stumble around and gorge himself on the sight of gold, there might have been less time for the gold-lust to grow, and it might be easier to snap him out of it.
(Wishful thinking, he knew, but he wished for it nevertheless.)
He did not truly know what had woken Thorin from the stupor the first time. Whether it had been the roaring of battle, or the real danger of masses upon masses of his kin falling among the slain, or the force of Bilbo’s betrayal itself, the way the film over his eyes had seemed to tear in two as Bilbo spoke. He did not know how to go about waking him again, but he’d spent the entire second journey relying on luck and the grace of a second chance, the peace promised to him at the end. So though he had been able to change nothing in all their time in the Mountain, he supposed he could not very well shake his faith now.
He’d done what he could. He was doing all he could. The world would just have to do the rest.
Bilbo knew he had fortitude enough that to betray Thorin a second time would not break him. But seeing him this way was like drinking a wine when you knew it had been poisoned; he seemed half-drunk on his own gluttony, and Bilbo felt half-drunk on watching him. It caused him to wonder how foolish he must have been when he’d chosen to do this the first time.
Yes, I’ll just pop down to the enemy’s tent and slip them the most prized possession in all of Middle-Earth backwards or frontways and be on my merry way because I hold this flimsy little paper contract that tells me I’m allotted some coins of my own.
He had known Thorin would be angered. But he could never once have guessed at the depth of betrayal Thorin would feel, with dragon-sickness and gold-hunger amplifying every emotion a hundredfold, like a cord between them had snapped and every memory the fourteen of them had ever shared vanished like smoke.
You naive hobbit. You utter, utter fool.
Bilbo looked down at his hands. Hands shaped for tilling earth, and which had instead spent their time touching paper and pen, the leather spines of books. Hands that stole jewels and wielded swords and wore rings.
How cruel of stories, that the worst had to come so near to the end. How cruel that he could not simply turn the pages faster.
Later that night, Bilbo crept up to the battlements of the Front Gate to find that it was Bombur’s turn on watch, and he was sitting with his back against one of the outer pillars, watching the sky span out above the ramparts and puffing pleasantly on a pipe.
Bilbo’s nose twitched at the sour tang of the smoke. Awful taste in pipeweed, these dwarves. He would have to get as large a shipment of Old Toby to the Mountain as he could manage, when everything was all over, and then see what they thought of that.
“Evening, Bombur.”
Bombur’s face was red and jolly when he turned around, and he smiled at Bilbo brightly.
“Hello, Bilbo!”
These dear friends, Bilbo thought. The dearest friends a hobbit could ever ask for. The Arkenstone he’d retrieved earlier that evening felt even more like a leaden weight in his pocket, a ticking clock counting down to the dreadful fall.
“I was just coming up to see how you were faring. I can take the early watch, if you’d like. I haven’t been sleeping well, and I may as well put it to some use, I think.” He could sense the dark coil of rope tucked behind the wall of stone like a grease-burn against his back. He’d already secured it to one of the pillars the very night Smaug had fallen.
Bombur sat up straighter and adjusted the braided loop of his beard against his front. “Are you quite sure? I am tired, but I don’t mind taking my turn watching, even if it is dreadfully cold up here.”
He was right. It had still only just turned winter, but the cold bite of the wind was relentless, and tore at the sides of the Mountain as if trying to scrape them all away and leave the rock exposed. It only set Bilbo’s resolve more that he had to get the whole thing over with as soon as he could. He couldn’t stand to keep all of them cooped up in the dark for longer than they needed to be, with no food or water or warmth to be found.
“I am sure. I’m likely to be awake all night, at this rate, and it is quite useless if more of us go without sleep than we need. Get some rest, my dear fellow.” He’d sat down next to Bombur against the pillar, and he brought his hand up to rest lightly on the dwarf’s shoulder. “I can wake you at sunrise, if you’d like. Somehow, I don’t think we will be hiding out in here much longer.”
“I hope you’re right. What I wouldn’t give for a stiff drink and a bed to lie down on after a hot meal!” Bombur exclaimed heartily. He clambered to his feet and peered down at Bilbo, looking suddenly worried. “Try to stay warm, Master Baggins. There aren’t any blankets down in the Mountain, but you might freeze up here.”
Bilbo crossed his legs on the ground in front of him and pulled his pipe out of the inside of his coat, fiddling with it in his hands. He’d run out of pipeweed to smoke in Mirkwood, and he wasn’t setting a single toe near that horrid stuff his dwarves used. He smiled wearily up at Bombur, not really focusing on the conversation anymore.
“I’ll be okay.”
Bilbo waited until Bombur had left and the quiet had settled to tiptoe over to the turret-edge and slip down the rope, his feet utterly silent against the stone, barely breathing until he was far, far down the face of the battlement wall and hidden in the shadows.
He made the slightest splash as he hit the water, and he stilled, not even daring to exhale, knowing there was every chance one of the dwarves would come to check on him and peep over the wall to see him making a hasty and very visible escape. Then, when nothing had happened, he waded over to the edge of the moat and climbed out, eyes fixed on the lights of the camp in the distance, and he began to walk.
“Bilbo Baggins.”
The long-awaited voice of Gandalf the Grey rumbled over him as Bilbo lifted the flap of the largest tent in the camp and was met with the faces of three of the most important persons in Middle-Earth. The Elvenking and the Dragonslayer both watched him shrewdly, though Bard’s gaze held a touch more trust within it, but Gandalf’s eyes were warm with relief as they looked upon him. He shook his head, his face far wearier than it had been only weeks before, the ancient grooves somehow deeper. But he smiled tiredly at Bilbo, and said only, “You are a sight for sore eyes.”
“This is the halfling, then,” Thranduil said coolly, angling his head downward to gaze upon Bilbo, who came to only his hip. His eyes held a strange, potent sort of glow in the flickering light of the lantern placed on the table between the three of them, and his crown no longer held berries and autumn leaves; instead, it was tipped with everlasting droplets of ice, crystalline and silver-white against the long shards of oak. Bard, clad in a dark, ramshackle sort of winter coat, simply nodded at Bilbo in lieu of any greeting, and Bilbo could hardly blame him; a Glad to see you haven’t been burned to a crisp, dear fellow would have felt a little weak after having been on such extreme tenterhooks. He cleared his throat and stood very straight.
“You’re all gathered here already, so I shall get this over with as quickly as I am able,” Bilbo said stiffly. No use drawing out the inevitable with talks of suspicion and distrust and how many archers to line the walls of the Mountain with. He bowed his head quickly to Thranduil, a little abashedly, glanced once more at Bard, who simply watched him back, and then drew the Arkenstone from his pocket. In the torchlight, it looked as if it had been set ablaze.
All of their eyes snapped to him, and Bilbo was struck in the chest with equal gazes of confusion, worry and fascination. Thranduil took a step closer to the table, the sweep of his green-gold robe circling at his feet, and tilted his head to the side so the icicles upon his crown glimmered as if in flame.
“The Heart of the Mountain,” he said curiously.
Bard's eyes lay upon it for several long moments, and then they slid slowly to Thranduil, and then to Bilbo and Gandalf. His expression was solemn, grim, yet starkly determined. Bilbo could almost see the cogs working inside his head, and he did not pull his own gaze away, swallowing down his own apprehension.
“How is this yours to give?” Bard asked.
Bilbo reddened at once, and stubbornly ignored it. “It is — well, it’s not, if you truly must know, but I hope you will forgive me for it. There is nothing else to be done, and there is no other way to go about it. I have been thinking on it for far longer than you know.” He clasped his hands firmly behind his back and began to pace.
“I was hired as a burglar, and a burglar I have been. I am afraid I, uh —” he coughed, “burgled a set of keys and a dozen barrels from your halls so as to escape with,” he said delicately, looking to Thranduil as untouchable as amber opposite him, the shadows flickering across his angular face in the candlelight. “I have stolen this so that you may make an offering of peace and trade with it. I cannot watch much more of this nonsense go on, and I will not let them starve needlessly in that mountain when I can put a stop to it anytime I please by handing over that jewel. I cannot bear to lengthen their pain. It is tearing me apart inside, to see him this way and know there is nothing I can do or say that will pull him back from such madness.”
To know that I must betray his trust, he thought, but did not say. That I must watch whatever care he held for me break apart in his eyes.
“You have become quite wise, in all your adventures, Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said, looking down upon him intuitively, and the corner of Bilbo’s mouth tugged upwards.
“Oh, I’ve been wise for quite a while, Gandalf,” he said, managing the smallest of teasing tones as their eyes met fondly. “You ought to pay more attention.”
Thranduil was staring at him strangely, and Bilbo’s throat seized up, and he thought for one dizzying moment that maybe the Elvenking sensed it, that he knew. That he saw through all of Bilbo’s grand declarations dressed up in pretty words and knew what it was they concealed underneath, just as Elrond had known.
But Bilbo held his gaze, and tried to challenge him with his eyes as best he could, and Thranduil did not speak, though he watched Bilbo for the rest of the night as they discussed in muttered voices what they should do with their sudden hobbitish advantage.
When Thranduil came to stand beside him much later that night, the two of them silent figures in the doorway of the tent and looking out across the still-coming dawn, Bilbo’s poor stomach had just about set up a permanent residence in his mouth, and he dared not say a word for fear it would fall out on the floor.
He’d braced himself as much as he was able, and tensed at the inevitable bearing of his secrets from another’s mouth as if he had no right to his own mind and whatever oddities lay inside of it. No Elf was going to catch him unawares again, that was for sure, not even the King of the Greenwood.
“You love him.”
Oh, dear. A clever little fool you are, aren’t you?
Bilbo was suddenly exceedingly glad for the atrociously messy state of his hair at that moment; it lent him a discreet cover so the Elvenking could not see his ears staining themselves red as raspberries.
He hadn’t ever once considered the possibility of somebody else speaking it aloud, least of all Thranduil himself. Not the truth of Bilbo’s mind but the truth of his heart, the rich green blooming within his chest.
And really, it was entirely unsurprising, now that he thought about it properly. Bilbo knew he was not subtle with his feelings and gave them away freely, and he knew that the only reason more hadn’t figured it out was that they’d barely had the time to sit down and notice. But it was clearly not a question, in either Thranduil’s words or in Bilbo’s mind, and he was glad. It had been a truth of his life for nearly a hundred years, and it was relieving, so relieving, to hear the truth aloud.
The sky is blue, the grass is green. The Green Dragon is packed on Sunday afternoons. Thorin Oakenshield is dead.
But by the heavens, did Bilbo Baggins love him.
“Yes,” Bilbo said quietly, his arms folded. “Very deeply.” He glanced at Thranduil surreptitiously out of the corner of his eye.
“Does he love you?” He seemed intrigued, if not entirely invested. A simple question of bland curiosity that nevertheless hit Bilbo between the shoulderblades as though it were an arrow.
“I’m not sure.”
No.
Bilbo was very sure. He had never had Thorin in the first place, not as the bearer of his heart, not as one who loved Bilbo with all the quiet intensity that Bilbo had loved him. It didn’t matter at all.
“If I were you, halfling, I would not think the worst,” Thranduil said, his voice thick and syrupy, “but then again, neither would I think the best.”
A typical Elvish answer. Bilbo smiled brokenly and tilted his head back to look up at the stars, glimmering like fireflies against the great cloak of midnight. It was some time before he spoke again.
“It’s quite all right. It’s nothing I haven’t dealt with before.”
And to Bilbo’s surprise, when he looked up at the King, his ancient eyes held in them true sadness.
His venture back to the Mountain was swift, and he climbed the rope quick as a dormouse, tucking it away and tip-toeing down into the sleeping area to rouse Bombur with the guilt pressing steady as ever on his chest. It was almost as if it had started to congeal, or tighten, vines twisting in all amongst his lungs and weighing down the beating of his heart so he could hear each individual thump slow in his ears.
No more was there time for garden-flowers and stories, or smiles that lit the air like they held in them magic. The precipice was fast approaching.
All the next day Bilbo sat chewing the skin off his lips, gnawing his thumbs to the quicks of his nails as the waters churned, brewing and brimming till they were about to break. He stumbled around in a haze, trying to keep out of sight, and shying away from anyone who cast a fond look his way. He could not bear it.
He concealed Sting in the same crevice where his rope lay and then stared out across the ramparts at the ground far below, the white Elven tents that dotted the desolate land intermingling with the beige-and-brown marquees of Men. The Elvenking’s sat in the very centre of the camp, larger than any other and drawn with thin golden lines along the edges and down through the folds, and as he watched Bilbo saw a pointed grey hat emerge from within and make its way nimbly into a russet-coloured tent nearby. Above them all ravens had begun to circle, their inky pinpricks against the sky indistinguishable from carrion-birds.
A wretched hopelessness came over him then, perhaps brought on by the wind, and his face crumpled.
Oh, all of this was pointless. It had been pointless the first time, and he had tried to stop it as best as he could, and yet it had happened anyway, to nothing but sorrow and ruin. Bilbo wished with an acrid bitterness that he could have done something more to prevent the coming confrontation, that the cleverness he’d been so boastful of their whole journey here had come to any amount of use at all, blessed as he apparently was with foreknowledge. Perhaps he should have beaten everybody’s heads together until his message somehow got through their thick skulls!
(But he knew well by now that that was not the way of things, much as he might resent the fact. And it would have been no small feat, to change the tide of a war, let alone to prevent one altogether.)
He remained atop the battlements, too sick with dread to even consider climbing back down the winding staircase, until at long last horns were blown and the two armies outside the Lonely Mountain called once again for their parley. Bilbo grit his teeth and made his way over to gather with the rest of his dwarves on feet that felt instead like heaping bags of sand.
Thranduil and Bard rode to the front and called their greetings up to the Company; Thorin met them with jeers and scathing condemnation, the cloak of his forefathers hanging limply across his shoulders and gathering like a dead thing at his feet.
“You would return so soon after your first attempt to pillage us, then?” he snarled. Bright anger leapt into all the lines of Bard’s face.
They questioned back and forth — exchanging blows, as it were — of debts and alliances to uphold, and of unjust shows of force against a small people with no army. The voices of the three parties all rather washed over Bilbo, who instead was trying in vain to calm his hammering heart, feeling his sweaty palms slide against his trousers.
It would be all right. It was going to be all right. He would be fine. He remembered this moment more clearly than almost any other, and had come out the other side, hadn’t he? No matter how it went, they were nearing the end of all this.
Bilbo heard them, then. The dreadful words. The intakes of breath all around him.
The Elvenking held aloft a white jewel that caught the daylight and cast it all about, like sun-golden leaves unfurling from the most divine of flowerbuds. It was bewitching, and more than beautiful, and seemed to chill the very air.
“And what of the Arkenstone?” Thranduil’s voice rang out as he clutched their most sought-after prize, the sacred, stolen, beating heart of the Mountain and its King.
The sight sent a recoil through the thirteen he stood with, as if they had all been lashed as one. Outrage broke upon their faces, and they began to call down to the Elves and Men who had besieged them, calling them thieves and backstabbers and betrayers.
A cold and bone-deep resignation filled Bilbo to bursting, and he let all of the screwed-up tension leave his body in a flood.
“It is impossible,” Thorin hissed.
Never had Bilbo so felt the severance of his two lives as profoundly as he did then.
Oh, dear one. My dear one.
Forgive me.
“It’s quite possible, actually,” Bilbo said. He stepped forward, and his voice did not waver, not even as every eye above and below turned onto him until he had a captive audience all to himself. “They got it from me.”
It was as if what little sun they could see winked out, and all that was left was a cold light, as Thorin turned his look of loathing from his attackers and onto Bilbo.
“You.”
The malice in him was indescribable, and the downpour drew ever closer, its long fingers touching the tips of the clouds and crackling like lightning in the air. Bilbo kept his chin upright and looked Thorin in the eyes evenly as he spoke, not raising his voice, not cowering in fear as the cold-marbled face bore down on him.
“I promise you, Thorin, that I did not take the stone as an act of betrayal. Only as an act of necessity.”
The air was still around them, and yet it was howling, weeping, whipping at them with a viciousness Bilbo could hardly feel, caught as he was in the eye of the storm. Thorin’s fingers had curled into fists, and his shoulders and head were bent deeper than ever.
One last wobble tried in vain to run a thumb across his jaw, but Bilbo squashed it before it could with the stubborn grit of his teeth. He had dug the roots in. He would see it through to the bitter end.
“Kili, nock an arrow,” Thorin said.
Bilbo watched Kili’s eyes widen in panic and his head whip sideways to stare at Thorin next to him, whose blade-tipped gaze was levelled on Bilbo with such contempt that Bilbo felt thorns growing in his lungs and threading all through his stomach, strangling the breath from him as they wound their way around his ribcage and burst through his chest.
What do I do now? What do I do now?
Almost there, old lad. It was this he’d been preparing for all this way, this that he had tripped and stumbled through every futile attempt at changing the course of the journey for, though he may as well have been wailing on the wind himself for all the good he had done since the ghastly dragon had been dealt with. It had been like Thorin was dying in front of him, his valour and selflessness and his ability to ceaselessly endure all ebbing away as the dragon-sickness sapped at his mind.
And Bilbo had had him back for so little time before he’d been taken away again.
“Kili.”
Kili stepped forward guardedly, boots crunching on the rock in the aching silence, and drew his bow, pulling the arrow taut against the string. Bilbo could see his lip trembling, and the subtle shake of his hands.
“It’s alright, Kili,” he said softly, looking Kili right in the eyes.
“Shut up, thief,” Thorin spat.
“Thorin,” Kili murmured, his lips pressed against the string of the bow, his eyes never leaving Bilbo’s. “Thorin, think for a moment. This is Bilbo we’re talking about. Bilbo. Our hobbit.”
“Our hobbit,” Thorin laughed, humourlessly, the words dripping like venom from his tongue. “This rat, this sneaking, festering vermin, is nothing of mine.” He turned to look at Kili, and his face had never been so cold as it was then. He had become utterly encased in stone once more.
“Get rid of him.”
Kili was staring at Bilbo, and his fingers were shaking terribly on the string now, his whole face white like he would faint at any moment. Bilbo watched him apologetically, and tried to give him a thin-lipped smile.
Then, quite suddenly, Kili took one step to the side and shot, the arrow sailing over the battlements and away into the distance of the mountainside. All the Elves and Men gathered in front of them watched it fly as one.
Kili lowered his bow and stepped backwards, never lowering his gaze, and never looking at Thorin. “I won’t do what you ask,” he said quietly, and Bilbo felt his heart splinter inward.
Thorin’s rage at once seemed to swell before them, his jaw harsh and unyielding against his face as he stalked towards Bilbo, shoulders back, head aloft, a portrait of the King Under the Mountain that had been blurred in water. He reached to his side and drew the long Elven blade he carried from its sheath, the curve of it almost beautiful in the pale winter light. Orcrist.
He stopped only a couple of paces away from Bilbo, sword held straight out in front of him like a line directly to Bilbo’s heart where it was hammering away inside his chest. They stood facing each other, Thorin’s eyes black as the moon, Bilbo’s shining with emotion that had been cooped up in his weary heart for so long, so long.
Bilbo took one last shaky breath, and then stepped up until the point of the sword was pressed directly against his chest.
He looked Thorin dead in the eyes. They were wide and frenzied in his sallow face, his lips just barely parted in disbelief, and the raven crown sat high on his brow, pulling the dark hair back from his forehead so it spilled out behind him in a never-ending sea. But when the tip of the blade pressed against his clavicle, there came a crystal chord like the clinking of windchimes, and all the tendrils ensnared them both as the look in Thorin’s eyes contorted down to a knifepoint.
“You wear the mithril I gave you.” He said it like he’d said everything in recent days, half-hearted and hollow with paranoia and callously barked out, like he was ever trying to figure out which of his Company would betray him next. Bilbo held his head high as he answered, and did not let his voice falter.
“It was a gift from you, as much as you may regret it now, for not so long ago you believed I had done enough to be deserving of it. It would be rude of me not to.”
Thorin’s lips pulled back in a hellish snarl, and the washed-out white of the sky behind them only illuminated his bared teeth, lengthening the longer Bilbo could stand to look.
“It is too good for you, traitor.” And he lunged forward and grabbed Bilbo by his collar, yanking him upwards until they were nose to nose and Bilbo had to rise up on the balls of his feet to touch the ground. Thorin’s gaze flickered between each of Bilbo’s eyes, fenced as they were behind ridiculous curls, and it truly was as if a wild animal had taken over. A monster wearing Thorin Oakenshield’s face.
I cannot wake you up from this, love, Bilbo thought brokenly, even as he tried to wriggle free of the iron grip Thorin had on him, and as he drew Orcrist upward once more in a graceful, gleaming arc until it was pressed deftly against the line of Bilbo’s throat. You have to find yourself again. Find your way out of the hold it has on you.
It was like watching a mirror of what he himself had almost been, what he could have turned Frodo into, what he had seen in the dreadful, sickening creature that lurked beneath the depths of mountains far away, and against all his wishes Bilbo began to feel tears run hot and glassy down his face.
They had all become so very entwined, and he could not watch one more moment, could not bear to see every inch of his lifelong guilt play out like a nightmare in front of him.
“Don’t you dare cry, like you deserve to, miserable sneak,” Thorin hissed. “You, who are spineless, and lack all faith, and still you cower in front of me like a dog!”
Bilbo bent all of his will into a glare, aconite anger catching and alighting within him even as tears still ran down his cheeks. “I am not cowering in fear, King Under the Mountain,” he said defiantly. “I simply cannot watch you tear yourself apart.”
He slid his fingers up to the wrist of Thorin’s hand that held the blade, feeling his thundering pulse, grasping it underneath his own and squeezing, trying in desperately-familiar vain to wake him up.
“You do not need this gold, Thorin. It will do nothing for you that it cannot do for the people of Laketown.”
“That is very well for you to say, burglar, when you have never known hardship or hunger a day in your life! I have spent decades in the Blue Mountains, working tirelessly for my people, and I deserve —”
“Then where is that king now!” Bilbo cried, and he hadn’t meant to raise his voice, but he could not help it, could not watch Thorin decaying before his very eyes like this a moment longer. “Where is he, Thorin, because he is not you!”
At once, Thorin stumbled back, letting go of Bilbo’s collar and swinging Orcrist away so it hung pathetically at his side. His chest was heaving; he looked as if he had been knocked backward. Great moons for eyes hung in the hollows of his face, huge and tormented and lost in the fever that had taken him, and a milk-pearl sheen had engulfed them, almost as if he were… as if he…
Bilbo reached up to brush his fingers quickly over the skin of his own throat. He pulled his hand away and looked down. It came back clean.
Even after all that had happened, he still had not drawn blood.
He looked up determinedly, marching forward a few steps. If Thorin Oakenshield was going to shake the beds of the mountain, then he was going to burst its banks right back. “There is a sickness upon that treasure, Thorin. It lies heavily upon the Arkenstone, and you must let it go to heal your mind! It is destroying you!”
Those beloved eyes narrowed in hatred. “And what would you know of sickness, of gold?”
“More than you!” Bilbo screamed. “More than any of you, how many times have I told you, I know what I am doing! I had to take it from you!”
His breathing was ragged, the frostbitten air screaming and shredding at his lungs, throat raw and stitched back together with white-hot needles. His head had begun to swim, and he started to thrash as Fili grabbed him from behind and held his arms tightly. Tears sprang anew to his eyes like lost dewdrops.
“If I had to steal from you a thousand times, I would! I didn’t know what else to — What was I supposed to do, Thorin? You don’t know — you stubborn fool — I had to watch them bury you, and then I had to walk away!”
He clawed at the grip Fili had on him, stamping on his foot, not tearing his gaze away from Thorin, always Thorin, who had stilled quite suddenly and was staring at him as if he had never met him before, the fire in his eyes all but out.
“You have to wake up, Thorin Oakenshield, or this madness is going to take you, and it’ll be too late to save you, and I am going to lose you again, I cannot watch you fall again!”
The arms wrapped around him let go, and Bilbo stumbled forward, the force stinging his feet. Fili’s face was utterly white. All of their faces were suddenly like bare sheets of paper, translucent in the morning sun.
“Bury him?” Fili asked brokenly.
The wind’s screams had ceased. The crying of the ravens above was no more, and Bilbo felt cold, as though he were watching from a distance, floating high above the ground and wondering if he was being blown back to the shores of the Grey Havens, that now he’d spat out the second chance he’d been given like it was a curse, it would be taken away.
All around him were shoulders heaving with laboured breath, and misted exhales rising like steam into the air. Everyone seemed to have stumbled back in shock. Even the armies of Bard and Thranduil were still, silently watching as Bilbo fell apart.
He had told Thorin of his death.
He’d told all of them. All of them.
He hung his head in sickened shame.
Thorin was not facing him any longer. He was standing flush up against the battlements, staring out at the rows and rows of armies lined up and on guard, their arrows raised to the sky. His eyes were huge and unseeing, knuckles pale and rigid against the rock and long tendrils of hair whipping against his face in the wind.
“Leave us,” the King commanded.
Wake up, Bilbo thought. Wake up, dear heart.
Come back to me.
Bilbo did.
Notes:
LMAO imagine if i kept this all one chapter
next one might be a while again because it’s obviously going to be a long and important one but i shall see you all when i see you :] much much much love to my beautiful betas & please come and find me on twitter!
Chapter 9: lover, please stay
Notes:
happy botfa everybody this absolute monster marathon of a chapter is twenty-seven thousand words long so strap in
title taken from the song “lover, please stay” by nothing but thieves
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Sitting in his armchair by the fire and letting his head fall back against the padding was Bilbo’s favourite pastime nowadays, if it could be believed.
Oh, once, yes, he’d been the strangest little fellow west of Rivendell and the Riddermark, and he was rightly proud of it. Once he’d waved a sword around and fallen in love with climbing hills and been whip-sharp with a pen and his tongue both, even if half of Middle-Earth didn’t quite have the understanding to appreciate it.
But now, somehow, he could not seem to bring himself to do much of anything at all.
Except sitting. Sitting was lovely; it really was. Comforting, and familiar-warm, and guaranteed to carry him off to sleep better than he could’ve managed himself.
And Bilbo rather thought he was old enough to warrant a bit of a nap now and then, anyhow, so bebother all the rest! One hundred and twenty-nine and all, he was! There weren’t many at all that could have said that, were there — well, except of course, all of these blasted Elves he lived with now, and a fair number of dwarves, too, and oh, well! It was far too bothersome to bear thinking about. He closed his eyes.
A nap, that was it. A nap in his favourite armchair by the fire would do him some good.
It was only at this particular moment that Bilbo remembered he was keeping company, and he heard himself let loose a strange startled noise in the back of his throat.
Oh, how unbelievably rude of him! Treasured company and all, too, and that wasn’t to do at all! He hauled himself up again with a great effort, enough that he was sitting of his own feeble accord in his seat, and peeled back the crinkly film of his eyelids to peer blearily at his beloved Frodo.
The poor dear! He’d likely been ever so bored, nodding with the glass growing over his eyes and smiling politely at his silly old uncle going over and over the same old story when he hadn’t yet finished telling his own. Oh, Bilbo was a terrible Baggins, wasn’t he! He tried to wrinkle his mouth into some sort of apology, but lost it halfway there.
He blinked himself awake, looking around all afluster, and — yes, that was his Rivendell fireplace, Shire-trinkets all laid out neatly in a row along the mantel, and by the window his desk, and his inkpots, and scraps of paper and half-finished notations sticking out every which way from each nook and cranny. There was his blanket, thick and woven with what always felt like a swan’s feathers, and opposite him a simple chair upon which his dear nephew was perched, hands clasped together as he patiently watched his daft uncle muddle his way through a simple thought.
Bilbo glanced downward, and noticed with some surprise there was a book in his hands. That was right, wasn’t it? He’d been dictating the changes he’d made to his journey and puzzling out the wording of the Elvish songs he’d written down, for he couldn’t quite remember how exactly it was they’d gone, and even brazen and un-shy as he was he was still a tad too embarrassed to ask them.
He took a great big breath that rattled all down his chest and into his rickety old bones, and asked, “Whatever did become of my old ring, Frodo? You were taking it away, weren’t you?”
His fingers were slipping quite against his will, and after a moment the great volume he had propped open fell gently into his lap. Frodo reached forward to take the book from his hands and close it, then rose from his seat to place it back on the tidy little stack by his bed; Bilbo had started to keep his most important ones there because he was finding more and more these days that he simply could not remember where they were if he left them anywhere else.
Frodo turned back to him, stuffing his hands in his pockets and smiling sadly.
“Indeed, Bilbo, and I’m afraid I lost it,” he said. “It’s gone out of the world, now.”
Ah. That was unfortunate, then.
For though it had been a very long time, and though he could have sworn he hardly ever meant to think of his old trinket anymore, there seemed always a place in his heart, reaching, reaching, outstretching its arms as he could no longer, grasping at what he had left behind.
What had been there before? Something certainly had. Something else that was gone.
Well, no matter. He should like to sit and curl up now and remember his old ring, and that was enough.
“What a pity,” Bilbo heard himself say. “I should have liked to see it again, one last time. But then… it is better that it is gone, isn’t it? And you’d told me all of this before and all, too, hadn’t you? How silly of me!”
And what a creaky old voice he had! Really, it was becoming rather unappetising for singing songs round the room, as the Elves of Imladris loved for him to do — though now he’d thought of it, Bilbo could not quite remember the last time he’d done so.
His forgetfulness really was becoming terrible in his old age, if he was being frank, and Bilbo had half a mind to scold himself for it, were he not so… so tired.
He looked up again as Frodo sat gently back down, squinting through the haze that always seemed to settle wherever it was he looked. Frodo looked ever so frail, skin pale as a lily and his eyes enormous in his fragile face. Somebody really needed to feed him up good and well. It wasn’t at all proper for a hobbit to be walking around at such a frail size. Good grief, who’d let that happen to him?
From far away, Bilbo felt himself frown.
“I’m rather tired after the journey, Bilbo,” Frodo said quietly, folding his fingers together.
Oh, well that wasn’t right, that wasn’t right at all. No good, that. Adventures were meant for creeping under your skin and waking all of you up, didn’t Frodo know that? Silly boy. Bilbo sat up, reaching out for something to grab with his hands, though he wasn’t the slightest bit sure what.
“A spot of tea, I think, Frodo,” he creaked and croaked. “You’ll be alright with some good, strong Elvish tea. You’ll find there is nothing it cannot help.”
Though they didn’t hardly use leaves robust enough for it here, if he was being entirely honest, and there wasn’t a lick of milk to be found in the place. Had he still had the form or function, Bilbo would more than likely have rolled his eyes.
But rose-sugar and honey, and flowers to flavour, and the warmth of the cups in their hands; that was something they’d both done since the very first day Frodo had set his feet on the doorstep of his beloved Bag End. Bilbo could hardly believe he’d forgotten.
He felt his tired head tip backward, wispy-fine hairs catching on the soft velvet of the armchair behind him. The rusty old voice that seemed to be his nowadays scratched its way up from within him.
“I’m ever so sorry I keep falling asleep, my boy. I simply get so sleepy here, you know! You caught me at a bad time, that’s all. I am all ears now.”
And he waggled them for good measure, flexing what muscles he could still move and making his Frodo-lad smile, his cheeks appling, and ah, there, yes; he certainly looked much healthier that way. Bilbo closed his eyes again fondly.
That was good. That was good.
“Oh, Bilbo, I don’t blame you at all,” Frodo said, far away on the breeze. “But it’s far too much to tell, unfortunately. I’ll write it down for you, shall I? So you can read it whenever you like.”
That ache in his chest was back again, and Bilbo lifted a tired hand to rub at his front, grumbling under his breath. Pestering thing, that ache. He was entirely sick of it.
But an ache for what?
“I should like that, Frodo. I should like that very much.”
Didn’t adventures ever have an end?
Whoever in the Blessed Realm had come up with the bright idea of thinking was most definitely not going to be receiving any thank-yous from Bilbo Baggins if he ever somehow made it there.
He had been sitting for most of the day on his little bunk in whichever backwater tent they’d chosen to dump him into in this godforsaken encampment of Men and Elves, and most aggressively staring a hole into the bedcovers as he did nothing but thought and thought and thought.
Really, the mind wasn’t made for it. Not at all.
(Of course, that was all the mind did, and to suggest otherwise was plainly ridiculous, so the thought had Bilbo scowling at himself for thinking it, which would then send him into an entirely fresh funk for thinking anything at all. To tell the truth, it was all rather excruciating.)
He had been thinking about Frodo. And he’d been thinking about the aftermath of the dreadful debacle up on the battlements, turning it over and over in his mind like a stone caressed by water until it ran smooth and colourless as glass.
He’d ambled out of the moat below the Gate like some bedraggled, half-drowned, unloved little creature and been led straight to the tent of Thranduil the Elvenking once more, marched on each side all the while by Elf-guards in shining-silver armour past desperately curious and hurriedly-pulled-together faces; far, far too many to count.
Yes, well, I hope you all enjoyed the show!
Bilbo’d stood stiffly as the tent-flap opened and there its three occupants stood, already gathered and waiting expectantly after their foray at the Gate. The familiarity of the whole scenario grated further at all his frayed edges as if bits of him were flaking off and fluttering away on the wind. He felt like all the insides had already fallen out of his body, and so he may as well stomp them down into a pulp while he could.
And if he never had to stand in a war-tent again for as long as he lived, it would still be far too soon.
Not a single one of them spoke, at first, looking down at him with expressions utterly unable to be unpicked for their complexity, and Bilbo wondered absently if it was at all possible to burn up and away with deep, dreadful shame.
Gandalf the Grey, familiar face adorned with a merry smile and exhausted eyes and looking down at Bilbo with an expression that was uncommonly kind, if a little pitying. Bard of Esgaroth and Dale, barrel-broad arms folded across his chest and a frown chipped deeply through the middle of his face as he peered dubiously downward. And Thranduil, jewel-laden hands clasped at his front and draped with the silver-grey sleeves of his robe. The fall of it was quite unlike anything Bilbo had ever seen, water-like in the way it moved but the colour so captivating the eye could not look away, as if it were made of a flowing river of metal. He wore no crown this time, and his translucent hair fell long and loose around his face, though Bard’s was still pulled back in the blunt mess accustomed to by Men, and Gandalf’s rather dishevelled at the nape and the beard the way a wizard’s ought to be.
Bilbo huffed out a sigh that ruffled his own hair at the front and pretended that his hands were not trembling so badly somebody else had had to open the tent for him.
(He should lop it all off, the hair. There wasn’t any need for it.)
“Bilbo, my dear fellow,” Gandalf said, “I do not mean to push you, but I am afraid I do have to ask what all of that was about.”
Bilbo almost laughed out loud. What a preposterously poor way to broach the subject.
“I would think you know already, Gandalf,” he said, feeling his face flick through expressions as if the pages of a book. He quenched the equal pinpricks of dread and irritation that flared up in him at such a simple question; one that barely began to encompass all that had happened, and all that had gone so very, disastrously wrong.
The Grey Pilgrim fixed him with a most auspicious stare, lowering the brim of his hat and pinning Bilbo to the wall with far-seeking eyes.
“If I am not mistaken,” he said, more intently, “you have travelled a long way, my friend, and you must be rather tired.”
Bilbo did laugh at that, his voice collapsing halfway through. A hobbit no more, he was. He was a candle blown out halfway down its wick. He was an ash-blackened match.
“I am, Gandalf,” he said quietly, closing his eyes and feeling it for the first time, and for the thousandth time. It wasn’t fair, how unkind time was. Would that he could have swept the lot of them up in the palms of his hands and dropped them in a mountain free of dragons and darkness. Would that sweetness and joy and peace and calm did not always, always have to come hand in hand with things that tasted so bitter. “And now I fear I have utterly destroyed all of it.”
He was catastrophising utterly terribly and he knew it, but it was a thought that had not quite been able to leave his head since he’d set his feet upon the ramparts.
They knew.
The terrible truth. The unspeakable reality. They knew all of it.
They knew, and he had not even been able to tell Frodo before leaving him behind, and he had not yet had the chance to change what it was he’d come back to, and instead he’d written it right into this life just as it had been written in the last.
You die. You die, you die, you die, and I live. I still live.
And, Bilbo thought, it was only going to get worse, and he was only going to have to flay open the wound when the skin was still pink and healing, spill more blood over the rotting carcass of the Mountain. Because in truth, they did not yet know all of it — not even half. Not the worst of it. And he would still have to tell them.
(If they would ever trust him enough to speak to him again.)
“I do not think it’s possible you’ve destroyed it, my dear fellow, and I do not think you should worry yourself over it,” Gandalf mused matter-of-factly, a rumbling softness in his speech that would once have eased Bilbo right down to the core, but did nothing at all, now. “It is clear that greater powers than you or I have granted you passage here, and they would not do so if you did not need it. Now, do you know why you are here?”
Bilbo smiled grimly.
“I do, but I am afraid I must keep it to myself for a little longer, because the full story requires some explanation, and not all of it will please you. In fact, most — most of it may rather disturb you.”
Gandalf twinkled down at him. “I wouldn’t be so sure of that, Bilbo.”
Bilbo’s mouth twisted unhappily. “Oh, I would.”
“Enough of this,” a lighter voice demanded. “You are foresighted?”
“Is that what it is? You see the future?”
Thranduil and Bard, in quick succession. They looked to each other, and Bard’s jaw was tight; he had not had a shave in several days, and his beard was growing in. He swept a hand over it.
“We had a soothsayer on the Lake, when I was young,” he said in clarification to the room, in such a short way that it prompted no elaboration or permittance of questions. “Before the Master took over.”
The Elvenking swept from his place at Gandalf’s side and cut a path in front of the table separating them to stand at its third edge, the table upon which the Arkenstone had lain only last night, though of course it felt like a year and a lifetime had passed since those early hours of the morning.
Thranduil looked down at him very seriously, but beneath it Bilbo could still see the brush of intrigue.
“Does Imladris know of this?”
Bilbo nodded, trying to keep his frustration beneath his skin and knowing he was doing a rather abysmal job, though at this Thranduil looked only mildly amused amidst his studiousness.
“Yes, Elrond knows. And in answer to your first question, no. Much to my displeasure, true foresight isn’t a gift us mortals have ever had bestowed upon us.” It had been a fair guess, really, and wasn’t unheard of by those who knew the Elven lords and ladies that still walked these shores, but it was quite frankly ridiculous to suggest it had been given to a simple hobbit from the Shire. “So no, I do not see the future. It is simply that I have — well, I have lived it before.”
Thranduil seemed, if not disquieted, then considering, watching Bilbo with a new weight and focus that had Bilbo almost tugging at his collar in his itch to be long rid of this tent, to be out somewhere else, anywhere else, away from this ghastly reminder.
There was rather a lot more debating and discussion, after that, of how he had come to know of his twice-lived nature, how he had been gifted the chance, how far on he had lived before coming back, how he was sure of events and sure of his place here. Less questions of his sanity than he had expected, though Bilbo was sure this was only because he held the trust of Gandalf and Elrond.
“This is how you knew there would be a clear shot at the dragon?” Bard had asked at one point. Bilbo nodded.
“And how I knew to come to you,” he confirmed, looking up at Bard looming high above him with a grave expression on his face. Oh, why could none of these other races ever be seated when they wanted to have a conversation? “It was going to be you who would slay Smaug whatever way it happened. The only difference this time was that we were able to save Esgaroth from burning.”
Bard looked as if supreme skepticism was warring inside of him with something akin to awe.
“What did you do in your past life, Mr Baggins?”
He seemed astonished, and curious. Grateful. And why wouldn’t he be? But it wore at the tatters of Bilbo’s emotions like a blunt knife.
“Nothing,” Bilbo said hollowly. “I did nothing at all.”
After a long while — far too long — Bilbo was finally allowed to leave the tent with Gandalf in equal step beside him; no easy feat, for someone whose strides were twice his own. Gandalf pressed a hand against his back for a moment, and though Bilbo did not look up, he knew that Gandalf had donned a well-worn smile.
“I rather suspected something about you, dear fellow” he said amicably. “The depth of your knowledge and attachment were both very intriguing to me.” He looked down at Bilbo, who flushed faintly rosy and did not look back. “You spoke of Lord Elrond, but I assume there is no one else who knows?”
Bilbo shook his head silently.
There was silence for some time, as they wove to and fro between people and tents and caches of weapons, and Bilbo pretended very pointedly and painfully that he could not see every passing eye fixed directly on him. The ground was terribly cold under his feet, and thorny rock gnawed at the soles with every step he took until his toes were numb and unfeeling.
One foot in front of the other, he thought. That’s the way.
“Why do you say you fear you have destroyed what you have been sent for?” Gandalf asked.
Bilbo breathed very deeply through his nose and ignored the sting.
“I was — returned here. To bring me peace.”
He’d have left it at that, but a stiff glance up at the wizard and his excruciating fondness caused Bilbo to clench his jaw and carry stubbornly on. “It’s certainly within reach. Was within reach. But I — I am deathly afraid I may have shattered that half of my heart too greatly for me to find it again.”
Gandalf hummed, a small melody that washed over Bilbo as a chill breeze he could not feel.
“I think he may surprise you yet,” was all he said.
There were several more moments of quiet, in which Bilbo only waited with teeth set on edge, knowing Gandalf far too well to think he was quite done yet, and then Gandalf piped up with, “It was quite a story you told, all those months ago, about the Elf and the Man and the dwarf. I did wonder.”
A brilliant flush of colour crept its way up Bilbo’s neck and over the tips of his ears. “I hadn’t realised you were awake.”
Not till the next morning, and he had done well to block it out since. Gandalf smiled, closing his eyes.
“That is exactly how I intended it.”
After that, Bilbo had retired into the tent he’d been given, though had others told it they might have used the word scarpered, and had been sat on his bunk each day since, wringing the threadbare covers in his hands and thinking and thinking and thinking.
And yet, not.
A cloudy sheen of persistent worry had settled over Bilbo, muted only by a likewise-pervasive apathy. He could not feel anything with his fingers; he was utterly and completely numb. He could not bear to be around anyone; he could not bear to think at all.
It wasn’t even the betrayal, that was the thing. That was nothing at all, now, really. Bilbo had done it long ago, and he’d very quickly do it again — already had, in fact. He felt no guilt, anymore, only a dulled remorse that it had to be this way, and if that made him terrible, then so be it. It was only one more thing to add to his ever-growing list.
But to look Thorin Oakenshield in the face, and say to him, I will bury you. To imagine it. To do it in front of his loved ones, the ones fighting for him to be their king. The ones Bilbo loved, too.
It was unforgivable. He felt like a glass of milk that had spilt all over the floor.
All the heavens help him, Bilbo was even beginning to feel his sympathy for Bard grow, now that he too could do nothing but sit in the silence of the Mountain looking down upon him like a great unspeaking judge. It was half of the reason he spent so much time indoors; he could not bear its great eye.
The other half, of course, was all the incessant gawking.
Oh, Bilbo could understand it, all right. It wasn’t enough that he’d told his dearest friends of the whole dirty secret — he’d practically summoned an audience to hear it as a grand proclamation. And really, had somebody in the Shire begun raving about knowing things that had not yet happened and their neighbours dropping dead, their family would have been quickly and quietly taken aside and had it suggested to them that they not go out in public anymore.
So Bilbo understood it. He just wasn’t required to like it, and like it he did not.
He threw himself backward onto the bedroll in a miserable huff, glowering at the mud-brown ceiling with all the force of someone whose insides felt like they had been scooped out and dumped unceremoniously on the floor. Oh, he was infuriating himself! Aching and miserable and cast out and the heavens knew what else. Pull yourself together, you miserable fool!
He stood back up at once, walked in a neat little lap around the bareboned tent with his hands firmly behind his back, then sat back down, ramrod-straight and blinking with a fast-working jaw.
Whose the tent was, Bilbo had not cared to learn, but they’d clearly left in a hurry to leave such a moping little creature to their own devices. There was almost nothing in it but some meagre foodstuffs and a few uncared-for weapons that lay in the corner — what looked to be a mallet, and perhaps a crossbow and some feathered arrows, though the string had long snapped and looked fairly pitiful. His mithril shirt and Sting were tossed in a corner like a fauntling’s old toys.
Really, it was petulant. It is not anybody else’s fault but your own, what you have done, sticking your foot entirely in your mouth, so you should not be dealing with its consequences in so childish a manner. And the fact that he had not awoken at once in Valinor or been sent right to the Halls of Mandos and then swiftly onward into the deep deep dark was entirely a miracle.
He stood up again, sat down again. It would be nice if they’d left him anything he could possibly hurl at the ground to soothe his terrible self-pity — a more solid wall to walk himself into, perhaps!
Bilbo was in fact very nearly considering storming off into the night to have another good sulk when the first raven came.
It fluttered through the doorway and startled him so badly he almost fell over his own feet. He stood at once in a dither and marched over, helplessly holding his hands out to — catch the bird? Offer it peace and goodwill? Who on the good Earth knew — and the raven slowed its flapping to settle in his cupped palms.
“Good morning!” Bilbo cried, losing his head.
He hadn’t the faintest idea what time of the day it was, and rather suspected it was much closer to suppertime, but the raven only fixed its beady eye assessingly on him in the dusky shroud of the tent and said, “You are the burglar of Erebor?”
Bilbo was so affronted that he forgot for a moment to be miserable and scoffed quite loudly at the raven’s audacity.
“If that is what I have been named, then yes, I suppose that is who I am. Who are you, might I ask?” he said, squinting.
The creature ruffled its glossy black wings and tilted its head back. It was truly impressive to behold. Bilbo imagined all the little larks and sparrows and honeyeaters of the Shire would’ve gotten an awful fright if ever they’d seen one of these great things about.
“I am Vörn, son of Roäc. I come at the behest of the Lonely Mountain. Will you hear my counsel?”
Gandalf’s counsel had been rather falling on deaf ears as it was, so Bilbo hardly thought that Vörn the mountain-raven was going to be able to do anything to change things. He sighed.
“First I should hear what it is you have to say, and then I shall make up my mind one way or another.”
The raven cleared its throat, so to speak.
“The dwarves of Erebor wish to speak with you on the matters discussed at the Front Gate three days hence. They ask you back to the Lonely Mountain at once, and would impart upon you the importance of such knowledge and the necessity of yourself to share it with them regardless of its sensitivity.”
As Bilbo’d suspected, really. Cold and impersonal. There was nothing in it of warning, nothing to clue him in as to whether he would be somehow heard out and given one more desperate chance or was being lured back to the ramparts only to be thrown over the side.
Bilbo bent his head.
(He was being awfully cruel. He knew his dwarves better than that. But, then again, he had never before betrayed their friendship so utterly and completely as this.)
“What is your response?” Vörn pressed, and Bilbo breathed out an unhappy laugh. Heavens, but he was exhausted.
“Give a fellow a moment to think, if you please!”
The raven shifted its head all the way to one side, blinking wide-eyed at him, if birds could be called wide-eyed, its black pupil like a glassy pearl.
Then, again: “What is your response?”
Bilbo’s mouth and heart both did a funny little flip, the broken frays of his temper flaring, and his fragmented emotions jumped right up into his throat and came out in a terrible tangle.
“Nothing, then,” he snapped. “I do not have one. I will not force myself upon them when they must feel more unsure of me than ever, and I won’t allow you to force me to either, Mr. Vörn, thank you very much. I bid you a safe flight back to Ravenhill, or wherever else it is you reside.”
And he let the tent flap fall.
The next morning Bilbo ambled out of his hiding-place in a plan to locate somebody who could point him in the direction of more substantial food, as although he’d have preferred to remain in his nice, cozy, dark little tent with no peeping eyes and peering whispers, his starving stomach and its frustratingly-stubborn penchant for second breakfast would wait for nothing and nobody else.
The second raven swooped down upon him at once.
”Bilbo Baggins of the Company. I am Väre, son of Vörn, grand-offspring of Roäc, descendant of Carc of Ravenhill upon the Lonely Mountain.”
Quite a grand pronouncement, from such a small creature. Bilbo inclined his head and shoulders and shamefully stammered out a faulty greeting. Väre puffed up all his feathers and raised himself squarely on his spindly legs, opening the sleek shine of his beak and fixing Bilbo with a look so focused Bilbo could do nothing but stand helplessly and receive whatever horrendous message he had been sent back for so rude a response.
”I have been informed by my father that you do not take his counsel; nay, you do not heed the words he brings you at all.”
Well, this one certainly had a personality on him. The Gondorians were sometimes known to keep falcons as pets, and Bilbo was sure that had Väre son of Vörn found himself among their falconry he would certainly have given them all his what-fors. He tilted his head and squinted down at the raven.
“I rather think your father neglected to mention to you several of the more specific details of his conduct, Väre, but I suppose he is not… entirely wrong in his assessment.”
Väre adjusted the grip of his talons on Bilbo’s arm, shuffling a little closer to the crook of his elbow, and Bilbo thought it a credit to himself that he did not wince at the dig of the claws into his Shire-soft skin.
“The dwarves of Erebor implore you to speak with them. Will you refuse?” Väre prodded. Bilbo bristled at once.
“I am not refusing. I am delaying,” he corrected, rather stubbornly. “There is a significant difference, if you must know.”
Väre stretched his wings and beat them once in the cold air.
“Their requests are urgent, and they have formally asked for your presence to discuss matters which to them are of utmost personal significance. Your decisions are unwise.”
Well!
Bilbo held Väre out at arms’ length, away from his body, fully aware he was frowning rather terribly now. But, really! “Should you not be one of the ones they sent off to the Iron Hills, and not lingering around here?”
To tell me off like I am some child with soup down his front when the circumstances are far, far more dire than that!
“It was I who was chosen,” Väre said. “I have returned. Dain marches forth-hence, with an army five hundred strong.”
All the fight dissipated from Bilbo in one sharp breath. They were marching to their deaths. Because Bilbo hadn’t even managed to blurt out something useful in the colossal fumble everyone in the entire North had had a front-row seat to.
He sent Väre away.
Of course, he was entirely unsurprised when, late that night, as he sat miserably in the cold underneath the lantern-light and pretended to be enjoying a pipe he could not taste over the melancholy of his own thoughts, a third raven came.
This one, though, he recognised. He was almost that of an eagle to Bilbo, regal even in his great age, perched on his knee and larger than almost any single bird Bilbo had seen that was not Gwaihir himself. His talons were gnarled, his feathers duller and his back more bent than his predecessors, but at the sight of him Bilbo shut quite entirely up.
”I am Roäc,” the old raven said simply. “I come to you, Bilbo Baggins, as you know, at the request of the dwarves of Erebor. They wish to hold counsel with you urgently, and wish also for you to know that they are not angered, that they sincerely desire only to speak with you and nothing else.”
“Oh, indeed, I’m sure the dwarves of Erebor desire to speak with me very much,” Bilbo said derisively.
(In his heart of hearts, Bilbo knew that on some level he was acting rather ridiculous. They were not going to force him out into the town square and throw old tomatoes at him because he’d said something far-fetched. They were not going to forget every fondness for one handful of blackened words.
It very likely didn’t help that they’d discovered he’d stolen their most prized possession not five minutes before he’d uttered it. But it wasn’t to be helped.)
But he knew they would all of them be back at the very first step. Back in Bag End, in front of the fire. It would… it would be as if they had not even sung for him.
Oh, would you stop moping, you poor, sad, wretched little excuse for a burglar!
Roäc had said nothing to his lack of composure, and Bilbo was embarrassed that he could not seem to behave like himself for all the world.
“Surely you are much too elderly to be flying around like this,” he muttered instead.
“You will not hear anybody else.”
Bilbo threaded his fingers through his own hair and pulled at the ends, dropping his head forward and holding himself up with his elbows.
”And how exactly is that surprising to you? You have all brought me this news at the behest of the dwarves, one by one, but neglect to mention what is the most important part, and then wonder why I do not come.”
For wasn’t angered only one emotion of so many others?
Bilbo forced a breath out his teeth, and it misted in the freezing air before him. It had started to snow, the gentlest fall of flakes from the sky blanketing the ground, speckling his own hair and Roäc’s feathers. He was going to catch a cold if he did not stop behaving like a complete twit soon. And then how much help will you be?
”What of the King, then, Roäc?” he asked quietly.
Roäc was silent for several moments, and Bilbo blinked sleet-drops from between his eyelashes.
“The King Under the Mountain does not speak. He has opted to have his advisors deliver this message in his place.”
Alright.
”I’ll — I’ll think on it,” Bilbo said.
That was the best he could do. He did not make it known to Roäc that it was all he had been doing.
“Very well. I have spoken.”
And away the bird went.
Bilbo was sitting on a pile of rock some way away from the Mannish camp and parallel to the Mountain, legs crossed and his ever-wringing hands resting in his lap.
It had been one full day since Roäc’s departure, and night had fallen a long time ago, the scattered stars creeping out to blink coldly down at them all. There were likely several people wondering where he was, considering he’d stolen away out here several hours ago, but he could not bear to be any closer one way or the other, at the minute.
Perhaps he was being ridiculous.
Of course you are, you colossal fool! he reprimanded himself at once.
Surely it was extraordinarily poor behaviour to refuse a raven’s aid so thoroughly. He most certainly had not made himself any friends in his rudeness, but every time he looked upon anything at all, the black birds or the cliffs chain-linked along the ragged mountainside or his own guilt-riddled hands in front of him, he was only reminded of it. All of it.
Bilbo imagined looking any of his dwarves in the eye. Ravens! he’d say. That’s rather opportune, isn’t it, that you’ve sent me ravens, because believe it or not I can tell you a thing or two about ravens, and Ravenhill, and what happens there, and who falls. You all heard me mention that, did you not? Heard me loud and clear?
Your King. Your King Under the Mountain is dead.
Bilbo had taken an axe to him with his own hands.
The crunch of gravel under foot echoed out suddenly behind him. There was a moment of slight grunting, and then Bilbo could sense a figure sitting down next to him, the familiar smell of gritty cloth and sweat and poor pipeweed cloaking him, comforting and dread-ridden both.
He closed his eyes, unsurprised.
“He is asking to speak with you,” said Dwalin. His tone was utterly emotionless, as unceremoniously gruff as always, and within it Bilbo couldn’t for the life of him figure out his true feelings on the situation. He had no idea how Dwalin was able to keep such composure. He’d been feeling sick about it all night and all day and all night again.
“So I’ve heard,” Bilbo replied, too mind-weary to put any bite in it. He tilted his head back, inhaling the night air through his nose, the tip of it entirely numb with cold. He could not make himself look at Dwalin. “But I’ve decided I rather doubt any of you will want to see me again for a very long time.”
Dwalin grunted in acknowledgement, letting it linger for a few moments.
“You’re leaving us, then?” he said finally.
Bilbo frowned, and he shook his head, fumbling at the hems of his trousers where they ended below his knobbly knees.
“Of course not,” he said, a tad irritably. “I was going to give you all a long while to think on it before I came back, but I will not abandon you, no matter which way you may feel about it. You are why I am here, after all.”
“Why you are here.” It wasn’t a question, and was said with a slight undercurrent of accusation, the smallest stirrings of what was surely disbelief. Bilbo nodded obstinately. “Why you are here on this quest?”
There really wasn’t any point beating around the bush, not when the bush in question had been shouted aloud for every Man and Elf and member of the Company to hear. Bilbo swallowed, throat reedy, and nodded.
“Why I am here on this quest once more.”
“How old are you truthfully, Bilbo?” another voice asked roughly, and Bilbo’s eyes shot open in surprise. Bofur was sitting in front of him, hatless and all with a scrutinising expression on his face, and beside him stood Balin, watching Bilbo with an all-too-knowing look, his face creased.
Bilbo wrinkled his nose and shot a look at Dwalin.
“I thought you’d come alone,” he said, a little accusingly. He’d been equal parts touched and terrified that it was Dwalin who had chosen to come, but that was apparently not quite the case. He squinted.
Dwalin leant back against the rock-shelf behind them, making himself quite comfortable and even stretching a leg out to settle in.
“That’s not my problem,” he said in the same surly tone, fixing Bilbo with a very intent stare. Bilbo was getting the distinct feeling he was rather pleased with himself.
He lowered his head, watching the ground at his feet, soot-stained dust mingling with the harsher slate underneath.
Now, it seemed, they were all here to mop up his spill.
“I… I don’t think I should talk about it, not at least while there are so many of you missing. I’m not sure if I should talk about it at all, to be honest with you. I didn’t ever intend to. I didn’t mean to say anything at all, it just… Well.” He scoffed in self-revulsion. “You all saw, didn’t you?”
There were a few mutterings and murmurs amongst the three of them, and though Bilbo could not feel his ears in the needling wind he was sure they were flushing so deeply plum-red as to be purple with shame; hot, writhing, burning, shame.
Fool of a hobbit. You complete fool of a hobbit.
“It was certainly brave of you, laddie,” said Balin, and the others echoed their agreement. Bilbo barked out a laugh. The sound rang out tinny and hollow, and his face shrivelled up like a dried-out prune.
“Don’t make me laugh, Balin. It was not brave of me to steal from you and then burden all of you in that way on top of it. You should not ever have found out something like that, not if I could help it, and I could help it. He —” His voice broke. He couldn't say the name. Could barely think it.
(And wasn’t life so circular that way?)
“He should not ever have had to find out something so awful.”
Bilbo couldn’t imagine in his deepest, dizziest nightmares being told directly to his face that he was going to die. He couldn’t see how any of them could go on. He couldn’t see how any of them were not holding him responsible for striking what may as well have been the killing blow.
”You regret it, then?” Dwalin asked darkly, his face suddenly twisted. “Stealing from us?”
Bilbo glowered. “You think I don’t?”
Well, he didn’t. But that was quite entirely beside the point.
“Aye, well,” Balin said, “that’s another matter in itself, but we do in part understand, even if some of us were… not entirely pleased about it. And all personal feelings on the Arkenstone aside, none of us can argue that it hasn’t had an effect.”
Bilbo looked up.
“What?”
Balin’s mouth was tensed, but kind, and he was looking down at Bilbo with a drawn sort of pity, as if finding out such an awful truth had only made him want to assure Bilbo all the more.
“It has brought him back to himself.”
Bilbo smiled unhappily and forced himself not to scoff aloud again, though the idea was so ludicrous he would have been well within his right, in his own opinion. His mouth tugged up cynically at one corner.
“How can you know that?”
“You didn’t see it, laddie, but he stood on that rampart all day after you left us, not moving or speaking at all, standing there like to a statue. When he came down into Erebor that night, his crown was in his hand instead of on his head.”
“Oin thinks his mind was at war with itself,” Bofur added.
Well. That was certainly a spanner in the works of his own wallowing, but not one Bilbo couldn’t contend with.
For there was far, far worse on the horizon now than a dwarven hunger for gold.
“I… well, I’m glad for that, I truly am,” Bilbo said, but I do not quite understand, Balin, why it is you think that changes anything at all.”
“Bilbo.” It was Bofur again, smiling at him with just as much teasing, just as much good-heartedness as usual, and Bilbo could not understand. “We knew there was something about you, lad.”
“Yes, something! Something means that I sleep with my eyes open as an Elf does, or that I talk to myself as if somebody else is there, not that I am — that I know —“
He curled into himself, staring at the barren ground, the salt-lines and minerals in the rock beneath his toes, no doubt older than the entire Shire. He was muddling his words, and panicking, and oh, this was terrible, this was torment and torture, why hadn’t they listened to their dratted ravens!
“How can you act as though you trust me like nothing has happened?” he demanded stubbornly. “How can you sit here and tell me you understand, that you know, that you are not waiting in secret with more arrows nocked, treasonous as I am!”
“Oh, aye, it’s Master Baggins, the great big scary burglar-hobbit. I’m shaking in my boots,” drawled Dwalin, cocking his outstretched leg at the knee and picking up one of his axes to sharpen with a mightily-unimpressed eye-roll. “You being a thieving little snake doesn’t make you a shred scarier than you were before, hobbit.”
“Don’t behave as if you don’t know what I’m talking about,” Bilbo snapped. “I am — I have —“ He took a breath, closing his eyes momentarily and sucking in all the courage he could muster through his teeth in the freezing air.
“If somebody had told me all of a sudden that someone I loved was going to die,” he said shakily, thinking of dark curls and a weary smile aboard a boat to nowhere, the cloudy smear of his thoughts, “I cannot see that I would ever speak to them again. Ever.”
He would have wrought havoc if he had known. If in his right mind, he had been able to see.
Balin smiled at him very softly. “But you would know in your heart that it was true, wouldn’t you?”
Here, so far from the camp and its lights dangling among the tents, the midnight sky had enveloped them with all the stars of Elbereth, strung like pearls across the sky. All four of them were still, Bilbo’s heart pumping so hard he wondered absently if he should be worrying, and then Balin moved, and after a moment he had seated himself down beside Bilbo on his little rock outcrop, wrapping his cloak up about him.
“Bilbo, how much do you know of dwarf-lore? Of our history?”
Bilbo scrunched up his face. Useless question. And Balin knew the answer.
”Scarcely anything, as I’ve told you, and I believe you are well within your right not to share an inch of it with anybody but yourselves. I know as much as I’ve been able to find on my own, and that is all I need.”
“But you know of Durin?”
Bilbo stifled a rude laugh, thinking it would probably have been uncouth even in present company, and especially when they were being so bafflingly polite. But then again — of course he did. Durin’s Day. Durin’s Folk. Durin’s Bane. He’d seen the name, and what history he’d read told that there had been six of them who’d borne it, stretching out all through the ages from the very beginning, before even the Elves.
But as they began to speak, he realised.
It seemed the six were one.
”There are others of our race who have lived more than one lifetime,” Balin explained slowly. Dwalin shifted forward, bringing his hand-axes with him. Poor replacements for Grasper and Keeper, but they’d had to make do.
”Aye, the very first of us, the founder of Khazad-dûm. The Deathless. He has come back again and again to live among our people.”
Bilbo began to get the creeping feeling that this was not something he was supposed to be told.
And it was all irrelevant anyway, and he said as much to them, waving his hands around helplessly and feeling increasingly like the rug would be be pulled out from underneath him any minute now, any second. They could not possibly mean what he thought they meant.
“I appreciate your meaning, but I am hardly Durin!” he said weakly, eyes darting back and forth between them, to Balin, to Bofur, to Dwalin; Balin, Dwalin, Bofur. “I am not the tallest or the bravest or the richest or the hardiest. I am not a king.”
Even as drawn as he looked, Balin still managed the ghost of a smile.
“But you are the oldest, aren’t you?”
Bofur grinned; a small one, dimmed by the cold and the circumstances, but there nevertheless. “The oldest hobbit who ever lived was a Baggins, the way I’ve heard it. No, you certainly aren’t any sort of Durin, not at all. You’re Bilbo — Bilbo the Second, if I am not mistaken.”
“Well, you are mistaken, for I haven’t died yet,” Bilbo objected snappishly, then felt his cheeks heat till they were crimson.
Dwalin made a noise, and a slow smirk stretched across his grim face. He glanced to Bilbo, assessing him, then back down studiously to his whetstone and blades.
“Bilbo the Deathless, then,” he grunted.
Oh, what on Earth and all the heavens were they talking about!
“Surely this is blasphemy against your own people!” he cried, arms thrown wide. “I have not been reborn, or reincarnated, or whatever it is. I have just been — I don’t know what I have been, but I have ended up here again. That’s all it is.”
Whisked away. Hurled backward. Lain here beside my sleeping heart. Floated in on a spring breeze.
Balin looked away from Bilbo and back to Bofur with a peculiar sort of expression.
“And, it seems, we are all the more lucky for it.”
Bilbo supposed it was high time he resigned himself to the fact he would not be getting rid of them, and he sighed, exhaustion riddling him in every pore.
“Well, what do we do, then? The quest hasn’t quite finished yet. There is more to come, far more that I must tell you, and it is that which I am most afraid of. It was there that he… that…” An invisible hand seemed to grip at Bilbo’s windpipe, and he could not say another word.
“I told you already,” Dwalin said, the rhythmic slice of his whetstone echoing out beneath him and the blade of one axe clasped in his fingers, “that he is asking to speak with you.”
Fine, then. If they were going to pester him anyway, then he’d tell them everything, but only when it was over. He’d lay all his cards bare when the battle had been won.
Even set in his resolve as he was, now that they’d managed to convince him that at the very least he wasn’t going to be entirely ostracised by the lot of them, it took Bilbo almost the whole of the next day to muster up the dregs of his courage and make the approach to the Mountain. He made his way over at dusk, when the sky was equal parts the softest of lemon-yellows and the lightest of lavenders, the onset of winter washing out the coming sunset so far north but nevertheless beautiful. A sign, his mother would have called it. Look, my Bilbo. Look at the magic of the sky, to hold so many colours at once. Look how people can do it also.
It watched him silently as he walked, eyes narrowing the closer he got, head looming ever taller, until he could no longer see the peak in his proximity. He reached the lip of the riverbank at the base of the Front Gate, and stood for a long moment in its shadow, colossal and silent, only hoping that he would not be judged too harshly.
“No time like the present, is there!” Bilbo muttered to himself with a grimace, his feet feeling like water, or perhaps like the muddy sludge you found in a swamp, his stomach slipping and sliding and becoming queasier with every step. It was a very small mercy that at the very least he did not have to wade through any more moat-water, as the River Running had finally frozen over, and he could make his way across easily enough, though the ice was thin and clear, and he took care to tread lightly.
Bilbo reached the far side, summoned up every last measly crumb of his own battered courage, and tried hard not to think that he was calling for his own doom.
“Ho, the Mountain!” he bellowed.
There was a few moments of pause, during which he swallowed around a throat that felt like a washrag and pinched himself once more, just in case, and then the rope came down, and it was his rope, still tied on and all, for Bilbo could see nobody clinging on to the other end.
It’s a wonder they haven’t sawn it off and cast it to the wolves, he thought drily, and hated himself for it, moving gingerly forward and taking it in hand with numb and shaking fingers.
He climbed and climbed, and hands grasped him as he reached the top, hauling him by the shirtsleeves and catching him steadily when he clambered over the barricade onto the top steps of the battlements. Bilbo looked up in trepidation, sure that he was going to burst if he had to suffer much longer like this, and there with one hand still on his shoulder was Fili watching him very intently, raising his eyebrows the slightest bit and bending his gaze down to Bilbo’s.
“All right, Master Baggins?”
He smiled at Bilbo, though it was only slight, not nearly half as mirthful as he’d been before, and Bilbo had to set his shoulders very squarely not to crumple. That was just it, wasn’t it? Now it would be small smiles, all tentative, all timid, like they didn’t quite know what to do with him, like he was now a far-distant stranger rather than a friend. And Bilbo supposed that for all intents and purposes he was, which only made it all the worse.
He swallowed the lump that had stuck itself fast in his throat and nodded jerkily, then steadied a hand on the balustrade of the Gate for a small moment, taking a deep breath and feeling as if his lungs were full of moth-wings. Then, he walked gently forward, reaching the winding staircase and seeing below at last his Company gathered in a ring around the base.
There they all stood, staring at him with looks he could not and would not begin to decipher: Bifur, Bombur, Nori, Dori, Oin, Gloin, Kili, Ori. Balin. Dwalin. Bofur. Only after his wrung-out eyes had traversed them all and come up short did Bilbo spy the figure standing partway to the side, and his heart leapt and sunk and collapsed inward and unfurled till it surely filled every inch of his body.
There, standing sentinel at the edge of the Company, a body apart, a being in exile as he had been longer than Bilbo had drawn breath in the world, was Thorin Oakenshield.
Bilbo fought not to let his face cleave itself in two.
The dragon-sickness had sucked all life from him; he seemed to have utterly shut down from the inside out. His clothes hung limply at his sides, his hair was dead, lifeless, and a subterranean sheen lay over his skin — what little of it Bilbo could see, at least, since he was half-turned away from the rest and staring into the distance, looking at nothing and no one. The half-moon of his face was devoid of any emotion; there was no anger, no affection, neither relief nor rancour. There was almost no indication that he felt anything at all but for the haunted look in his eyes.
That dastardly crease between his brows seemed to have made a permanent home there in the couple of days Bilbo had been gone, and Bilbo mourned with a terrible bittersweetness that it had not even been more than a week since those hands had cupped his cheek and touched so gently at his temple.
After an eternity, Bilbo reached the bottom of the staircase, and when he stepped towards Thorin, the wellpools of his guilt and sorrow threatening to break across the floor, Thorin took a step away, angling his head towards Bilbo in a perverse and terrible bow. They stopped, and looked at each other; the world around them had utterly stilled, as if everything else had simply fallen away.
Ah.
“Well,” Bilbo croaked out intelligently. The sound clanged sharp and ugly in the silence. He may as well have clobbered them all over the head with it.
Oh, dear, this was awful.
He could hardly begin to look at any of them. How could he have thought he could come down here, could be amongst such friends when he’d cut them down and thrown their trust and care at his feet for stomping on? It didn’t matter an inch or a mile what Balin and Dwalin and Bofur said — they couldn’t be sure, they hadn’t asked, they’d only assumed —
He did not know what to do, what to say, how to breathe. He was walking along untrodden soil; last time, after his betrayal, they had not come together as one Company again until Thorin and Fili and Kili were already dead and laid to rest. Last time there had been no last time. His thieving and fleeing had been the very last.
Alright, then.
Bilbo turned abruptly around and began to pace.
“I’m sorry. I’m so very sorry, oh, I cannot believe what a clothead I have made of myself! What I must have put you all through, what I — I am kicking myself, I have never — I wish I had not —“
He stopped, took a breath, and turned back around, his eyes bypassing them all and lifting to the empty space above their heads. He addressed every word to it determinedly.
“It was never, ever my wish that you would have to find out something so awful, and it is entirely because I could not keep my own head that it came to light at all. I hope very much that I haven’t made an enemy out of any of you, with my lying and sneaking and telling you that — oh, I am so very, deeply, indescribably sorry. And if — if you do not trust me any longer, I will not blame you in the slightest. I will keep my distance.”
Better that they live a life apart from him, but live all the same. His heart could still rest, that way.
Bilbo bowed low, so low had he crouched on bent knees his nose would have touched the floor, and his tattered hair was hanging in his eyes, for once blessedly curtaining his face from the terrible weight of their judgement bearing down on him. He was half-sure that the guilt had settled so deeply within him that the peace he’d been promised would mean nothing at all in the end, now. He’d cut it out with his own bloodied hands. From his own traitorous tongue.
”You should not forgive me if you do not wish it,” Bilbo rasped at the cracking granite beneath his toes. “But you must — you must know, every word I said was true. I have never told you untruths of my own feelings, have never had time for them when it was not absolutely necessary, for you are truly all more dear to me than I can ever say.”
There. It was done.
It was done.
Bilbo’s chest was moving up and down like he’d run the length of the Mountain, and he dared not look up, at first, not even when second after second passed in only ear-splitting silence. But then:
“You are a mighty fool and a clever little sneak, Bilbo.”
Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut very tightly, bracing himself, and then looked up from where he was bowed to find his Company still standing there, the most bemusing sort of expressions on their faces and not helping the snaking of his insides in the slightest. All of them stood looking at him with astonishment, of all things, wonder and disbelief and no small amount of indignation at finding out the truth of Bilbo’s grand deception.
“Yes, I suppose I am,” Bilbo confirmed simply, with what he hoped was an apologetic grimace. But Dori — it was Dori who’d spoken, then — was smiling; slight, but very clearly there. And he was not the only one.
“I —“ Bilbo looked again at Bofur and Dwalin, each twirling his hat on his fingers and with his great forearms crossed in front of him, respectively. “What have you — ?”
His voice petered out into nothing, and he bit the inside of his lip. How much have you told them? How much do they know?
Dwalin rolled his shoulders back. ”All have heard tell of Bilbo the Deathless,” he said wryly. Bilbo tilted his head and scrunched his nose up, blowing out a long-suffering breath.
“That nonsense again,” he muttered, cutting his eyes upward in a roll before he remembered himself and reddened to the roots of his hair.
And then Gloin chimed in helpfully with, “Aye, Roäc told us you were looking grey as an old bedsheet,” and that sent him into a full-scaled bluster.
”Oh, really — how can you expect me to believe you are all taking this so casually! How have you not run me out with pitchforks for being a raving lunatic!”
“We told you, laddie,” Balin said kindly, “and though I’m sure we’d all like to think it, it is not a surprise we are not the only beings in Middle-Earth with pathways of re-entering the world.”
And that drew Bilbo up quite short, for every word of it was true, and he could not believe he had forgotten. He even went so far as to scoff aloud at himself in disbelief, eyes wide. How many Elvish books had he read in the latter days that told the lore of their second-lived, and now he was having to be unknowingly reminded of it by dwarves, of all things!
(Though if he was being especially contrary, it was not in the waking world that they spent their days, only in the bright daylight of Valinor and Eldamar, basking in the paths of the sun and moon across the sky.
Although, that fellow Glorfindel…)
Fili stepped forward then, from where he’d faltered at the bottom step behind Bilbo, likely not wanting to set him off any further when he was already displaying signs of cracking at the seams. His voice was soft, but steady, and firm, and the abrupt thought that he was going to make the most wonderful king in the years to come hit Bilbo with such swiftness that he very nearly lost every bit of composure he’d managed to snatch back then and there.
“We haven’t wanted to lie to you, Bilbo,” Fili said. “It startled us all, and some of us at first quite badly.” He looked down at Bilbo and smiled sadly, eyes shining in the dim light, and Bilbo realised with another awful twinge that Fili was talking about himself. His own guilt reared its fangs once more. “But you’re sorely mistaken if you think you’ve scared us off wanting to know when all you’ve done is the exact opposite.”
“Aye, we’re a sturdy lot,” Bofur added. “It’s not so frightening, the thought that you are from elsewhere. You can tell us. And it could help.”
And this was exactly why thinking should be entirely eradicated, and emotions, too, besides, Bilbo reasoned with growing hysteria, because he felt like a bowl that had far too much poured into it, like a drowned pot-plant left out in the rain, like a broken thread in the eye of a needle. He had not the slightest idea what to do with all of the feeling he had suddenly dumped into his hands. He could barely stand to bear witness to their gazes; could not understand them at all.
You did promise, you know. Not in so many words, of course, but who would he be if he did not deliver now? Hadn’t Dwalin traipsed halfway to Dale just to inform Bilbo that Thorin wanted to speak with him?
Well, Thorin most certainly wasn’t asking now. But the rest of them were.
Bilbo sighed. There was nothing for it, then. Onward he must go.
“There is still more I need to tell you,” he began slowly. “Not all of it, mind you; there are things still to come, both near-ways and far off, and I do not want to waste time waffling on when it is not yet needed. But I will tell you a little.”
Rip the bandage off, old lad, that’s the way.
“You know I am from somewhere else, or somewhen else, I suppose, and that I have come back, or reappeared, or whatever it is you dwarves call it. But I’m worried I might give you a bit of a shock when I tell you how far away the when is that I have come from.”
Bilbo turned back to them, chagrinned, and closed his eyes one last time. “I was fifty when I came with you on this adventure the first time, but now it has been eighty-three years, or thereabouts, and I am one hundred and thirty-two. This is my second time living this portion of my life, and it has all been for this quest.”
Whispered exclamations followed this, of course, but Bilbo very stubbornly pushed on, affecting a variation on the voice he used teaching fauntlings to read, knowing the only way out was through, and that at least now the worst was over.
Well. Most of the worst.
“Most of the big things are the same. Little things have been different. Conversations I have had with all of you, and the ways you have all started to trust me. Our friendships formed a little faster, and I’m sure it is because I could not keep my love for all of you to myself, and perhaps because you all realised a little earlier that I was useful after all.”
He shoved his hands in his pockets and rocked back and forth on the pads of his feet. ”After — after, I went back to Bag End, and you all stayed here in your Mountain, of course. And when my nephew came to live with me, I raised him on stories of dwarves and dragons and Thorin Oakenshield, because I knew it would be silly to pretend that the strings of my heart were not wound up with you all.”
The tips of his ears warmed, and he bowed his head very slightly.
Dwalin whistled.
“Such flattery,” somebody whispered, and someone else likewise piped up with a, “You are entirely silver-tongued, Bilbo!”
“Yes, well,” Bilbo said gravely, “if I were you, I would not speak too soon, for you may well scorn me still, when you hear the rest.”
For they were being so kind, so very dearly kind to him, and yet they all still talked around it, the very it he had been incessantly thinking himself sick about. His grand declaration of doom. His omen, signed, sealed and delivered.
And still they did not know.
What on all the Earth was he supposed to do? Tell them all of it, or tell them none? He wrung his hands, tugged at his own sleeves and stared at them helplessly, his heart beating a rapture against his chest. They’d all started to falter, now, perhaps sensing his distress, and Thorin, Thorin would not meet his eyes. He hadn’t once in all the time since Bilbo had started to speak.
Bilbo had to finish, had to tell them all of it. It would tear him in two all over again, but then, that was nothing new from the last week of his life, over and over shredding himself apart and stitching his weary mind back together.
”You do not understand yet. This is not the end.” The words felt dry and wrong-fitting on Bilbo’s supposedly-silver tongue. He could hardly form them at all.
But he had to. He must. He closed and unclosed his hands, and met their eyes.
“If you must know, you have to be aware that there is no happy news to come. It will only hurt you more. But the more I think to tell you, the more I cannot see a way out with all of you still in the dark.”
Death-defier, Deathless, and now Death’s deliverer.
“We have a little more time. I… well, I — uh, anyway, things happened a little earlier than they did the last time. We still have some time left before they come.”
“Before who comes, Bilbo?” Ori asked.
It was a terrible, terrible mirror of his enraptured audience in Laketown, as he’d sat in their staying-house and lathered them in fondness, told them of his feelings of family and friendship, only now, Bilbo was peeling it away.
“The goblins have followed us here. They are on wargs. They will try to take the Mountain. It is there that you… that I…”
Bilbo’s eyes flickered to Thorin, a figure in the dark; they fell very quickly, and his voice collapsed into a pathetic nothingness, an absence. He couldn’t lift his eyes to theirs.
“It is there. And it is not only you who was lost, Master Oakenshield.”
The Company seemed to take this all in stride, though they’d clearly blanched, and oh, he had to get this over with right now — he couldn’t stand being the bearer of news like this over and over and over again. His heart was going to give out.
At the front and centre of the cluster, Kili was frowning, his brows creeping together on his face. He looked steadily at Bilbo, who could only look powerlessly back.
”Who?”
Bilbo thought he might have shattered, then, as stalactites when spring came.
“I’m sorry.” A dreadful quiver struck itself across his bottom lip, and he had to bring a hand to his mouth to cover it, eyes wide and glassing over as he looked desperately at them all. Oh, how could he say it?
He squeezed his eyes shut, biting the blasted lip until it was stinging, but it no longer mattered. He could see them.
One golden-haired, one dark. Twin smiles, watching him in anticipation.
Oh, my boys. I’m so sorry.
Bilbo opened his eyes and watched those smiles for a moment more, thinking of seeing them at his door, knowing they would never appear quite like this again, after what he told them. He drew his hand away and clenched it in a fist.
”The line of Thrain begins the assault with four,” he said, “and ends with one.”
He did not even wait for the lance to strike before he was hastening frantically on, eyes wild and heart beating and hands spread wide as if to shield the truth he’d just revealed. ”But you listen to me, all right?” Bilbo urged, as fiercely as he was able. “I’m promising you now, and you have trusted me all this while, haven’t you? I will not let you fall again.”
He would not. None of them. It was not even a question in the mind. Bilbo realised his vision had gone quite blurred, and he focused on the point of the floor where their boots were all lined up in a neat little row. His frail old chest was hammering like a war-drum.
”Your allergies,” a voice called.
Kili’s voice. Bilbo’s brief smile was watery and wobbling in his face when he replied with all the weight of two worlds, one held in each hand.
“My allergies,” he confirmed.
Fili had gone entirely white and was staring at his brother, and his face would have looked blank had the thickness of his emotions not at that moment felt so potent in the air. His mouth opened, but there was no sound that poured forth — after all, what conceivable thing was there to say?
There’d been other sounds that had burst from his friends at the words, sounds of grief and anger and sorrow, but Bilbo could not pay heed to any of them. Dwalin’s face had not changed aside from the sudden hardening of his eyes, and still, he looked heartbroken. Balin’s eyelids were closed, a single silver path drawing a gentle line down his cheek.
And the King had turned entirely away.
“I think that very soon, Master Baggins,” Fili said in the hoarsest of voices, swallowing, “we will owe you debts we cannot ever repay.” The sentiment was quickly echoed by all the others, but Fili’s eyes were shining-gold as they looked upon only Bilbo, and Bilbo shook his head so adamantly it might have flown right off.
He would not see them fall even if he had to beg on hands and knees to change it a thousand times over. Not for long, long years yet. And if they had not realised the determination of a hobbit set on achieving his own way by now, then all the more fool them.
Bilbo screwed up his face, straightened his waistcoat and looked them all dead in the face.
They knew, now. So now the work began.
“Not a chance, you confusticating things. I know it’s horrible. It was horrible then. But you, all of you, will live to see the sun rise.”
It was far later when Bilbo Baggins found himself atop the battlements of the Front Gate of the Lonely Mountain once more, though this time it had been his choice, and this time he was entirely alone, gazing out wonderingly at what they’d dubbed the desolation of Smaug.
It looked different, in this almost-darkness. A black sea, spilling across the plains of the Mountain, broken only by the conglomeration of tents erected by the camps of Mirkwood and Laketown, tiny lantern-lights flecked across a midnight moor. The sky that bloomed above was the deep blue of paint-pots, of fine satin and lupine thistles. Bluebells and lobelias.
Bilbo wrinkled his nose.
The moon was only a slither of cream-yellow in the uppermost corner of the sky, and the evening was young enough that the stars had not entirely woken yet, so the whole effect was of a deep watercolour blurring into darkest black.
Bilbo leant forward further, folding his arms more tightly against his chest and tucking them against the bannister lining the ramparts. The stone was so cold as to be freezing when he touched it, and Bilbo imagined the skin of his arms and the pads of his fingers sticking to the ice, holding him there until deep in his chest was eased the guilt that still swelled in him like hot, sour bile.
Behind him, there began to echo faint, booted footsteps, making their way forward slowly in order not to disturb the quiet, or to break the gentle spell the sky had cast. Bilbo closed his eyes against the night for a moment and breathed out a quiet sigh.
He could sense it when Thorin had walked up to stand beside him, the two of them bent forward over the bannister and watching out over the dull lights of the camp in the distance. They did not look at each other.
Beside was rather a strong word for it, Bilbo supposed — there was a gap of several feet between them, enough that if Thorin truly desired it, he could pretend he contemplated the dusk in solitude, that nobody was there and nobody had burdened him with the weight of mountains upon his chest.
Thorin spoke first.
“You have a nephew.”
It was a question and yet not, and his voice was raspy and coarse and quiet, so terribly quiet, but not cold. Not harsh. It was hardly anything at all.
Bilbo’s mouth tugged upwards.
“Not yet. His parents are still quite young at present, but yes. I had a nephew.” He frowned and angled his head to the side. “Technically he is a first-cousin-once-removed on my mother’s side and a second-cousin-once-removed on my father’s, but that’s all Shire semantics.”
“He was close to you.”
Another statement. Bilbo knew, of course he knew, why Thorin was being so distant, and his own smile felt hard-won and bittersweet across his lips. It had all been said and done, now, and one way or another they had to set about picking up the pieces, and he only wished he could tell Thorin there was nothing so broken they could not mend it in a way that Thorin would believe.
Please don’t hide yourself away again. I only just got you back.
“I’d always wished you could have met him,” Bilbo said in reply. “He was quite lucky his ears never fell off from all the times I talked about you.”
There was quiet for a little while. Bilbo tried not to contemplate too deeply what it meant.
“Is it him you always speak to, when you are alone?”
He looked to the side, and the moon was blue, the sky tipped teal and indigo and royal silk, dark enough that he could barely distinguish between the outline of Thorin’s silhouette and the blotted spill of night behind him. Carved from the mountainside. A figure brush-stroked against the dark.
It felt so strange to say it out loud, to talk about Frodo at all when not a single person in this lifetime remembered him. Bilbo was used to carrying the memories of someone who was gone, and keeping them to himself, and to have spoken them aloud twice now felt like opening up the inside of his chest for everyone to see.
“Yes.”
There was no noise at all around them, these two lonely figures against the battlements. It was probably the thing that unsettled Bilbo the most about the Mountain, and had meant he could never quite lie still or settle even when he’d been sheltered here all those years ago. The long-ago destruction all around them meant there were no plants for crickets to chirp in, or moths to flit about in wonder, nothing for flies to pester or bees to pollinate. Only the gentlest brushes of night air, and the barest crushing of ice atop the river below them, as winter crept in and the frost found its way all over the Mountain.
In the dark, Thorin’s knuckles tightened against the bannister, and he lowered his head.
”I was blind,” he whispered.
“Thorin.”
Bilbo didn’t say it so much as breathe it, the absence of a whisper in the ink-dark quiet. “I have known many great kings, Thorin. You are a great king. You cannot blame yourself for falling to torment that others have fallen to.”
Every line in Thorin’s body had hardened; he seemed as if he’d been molded in a kiln, the heat too bright, and the clay had split his face from the inside out, cracked inside a porcelain bowl.
“Do not speak of it. Please.”
Bilbo took a cautious step closer, resting a gentle hand on the bannister near where Thorin’s had curled into fists, biting into the stone. It really was strange, to think that this might have been the most plainly they had ever truly spoken to each other. Everything about the both of them had been entirely stripped away, and now here they stood, no more dwarf and hobbit, no King or burglar; hollowed out, the skeletons of trees in a dead forest.
“I know what it is,” he said, “for something to have such a hold on you, to feel as though it is choking you, slowly, and that only holding onto it tighter will get it to stop. You are not the only person that has felt like this. I am broken too.”
He looked away, back towards the sky. He could feel Thorin staring in his direction, the intensity of his words demanding an explanation in kind, and had to swallow down the lump that grew in his throat.
Not just yet, love. There is still a battle to win.
“You cannot know,” Thorin murmured, with no anger in it. ”You cannot speak to me of it as if you could possibly know.”
No anger in it, but no love. No familiarity. Not anymore. Whatever fondness Thorin had held for him had been butchered, had been severed and stripped away.
But Bilbo had known it would happen, anyhow. He’d known. He would live to fight another day. In the grandest scheme of things, it didn’t matter at all.
(In the less grand, however — well, that was neither here nor there.)
Thorin had forgiven him once. All he could do was hope that it would happen again.
“Surely you heard me screaming it about all the Mountain,” Bilbo joked softly, having decided that if they were going to speak of it, he would shove his finger right into the bruise if it would at least get them somewhere.
Thorin scoffed, though the sound did not have the slightest shred of humour in it, and he bent his head to look down at his own hands. Bilbo watched him helplessly. He could not remember ever feeling so out of place at Thorin’s side, not since the very beginning. He could not recall ever being able to read so little of what was in Thorin’s shoulders, in his brow.
The stillness stretched on, and Bilbo opened his mouth.
“I will tell you, when it is over and we both live through this,” he said quietly, meaning it. “I promise.”
Thorin’s head rose, and he looked out at the land beyond, lowering his hands till they were by his side. His jaw cut an indent into the side of his face, and worked, and worked, and worked.
”You brought my mind back from ruin. We owe each other nothing more.”
Bilbo stood for a little while longer, watching Thorin weakly and utterly unable to think of a single thing to say. The wind was whipping at them, hastening the creeping, dead fingers of the cold, and Bilbo withstood it for as long as he possibly could, but after a long while he conceded defeat. There would be nothing more said between them. And Thorin still would not look back at him.
Bilbo stepped away, freezing feet padding their way to the top of the stairs, reaching out a hand to grip the balustrade for fear he would slip in the numbness. His body was hunched against the cold, and he turned one last time to look back at Thorin, who still stood unmoving, facing the direction of the outstretching mountainside. His head was raised to look out at the armies still at his door, and behind him the sky was utterly dark, the ghostly moon enshrouded now by passing cloud, the horizon black like the ink of a fountain pen, black like tar, black like the inside of your own eyelids, the absence of anything at all.
”Master Burglar.” the voice rumbled, and Bilbo slowed, wrapping his arms about himself to protect his body from the chill. He made no answer, only the pause of his feet, but after several more moments of silence Thorin spoke. “What was his name?”
Bilbo smiled softly.
“He was called Frodo. Frodo Baggins.”
Bilbo woke to the jostling of caravan wheels and a bumpier road than he should have liked, grumbling to himself inaudibly and smacking his lips as he pulled his aged body from sleep into waking and blinked his bleary eyes.
Ah, that was right. They were on the road again.
There was a weight beside him, a weight that was moving and making noise, and as he painstakingly peeled back his own cloudiness he realised all at once that it was his Frodo-lad again, speaking to his uncle in a gentle, gentle voice.
“I’ve left our book with Sam, now, Bilbo, don’t you know?” He was smiling, but it seemed so terribly sad.
Oh, it really was a puzzle, wasn’t it! What in all the world could that boy have to be sad about, such early little lines around his eyes and mouth and creases along his brow where there ought to be none for a few long years yet, not at the ripe young age he was at, only yet still a flower in spring.
“He’ll put it in the Mathom-house for certain,” Frodo was saying, still saying, and Bilbo realised belatedly that he had entirely forgotten to listen. “Or take it out at Yuletimes and read it to all his children until they’re scared out of their breeches, and Merry and Pippin will come and act out all the parts. Did you hear? I suppose you wouldn’t have, would you? He and Rosie had a little girl.”
But when had there been lines around Frodo’s eyes? Bilbo couldn’t quite recall seeing those there before, either. Had it really been so long since they’d seen each other after Frodo’s little adventure? Bilbo felt as if he’d only fallen asleep yesterday and Frodo had been there, packing up his books for him and tucking a blanket up round his ears as he sat in his favourite old spot by the fire.
He’d left it behind now, though, hadn’t he? Off they were, on a shiny new adventure, in their caravan with Elves on all sides and Samwise Gamgee sitting up the front with Gandalf.
A dreadfully croaky old voice spoke up, and after a moment Bilbo realised in the spidery recesses of his mind that it was his.
“Rosie… Rosie?”
How many years had it been, then? For he distinctly remembered celebrating his last birthday in Rivendell, and gifting all the Elves poems he’d hand-written in curling script with his best pen that had probably looked awfully like the scratches of chickens to them, never mind that Elves did not even keep chickens! He’d turned one-hundred and thirty… thirty…
“Rosie Cotton,” Frodo said, patiently. “Remember old Farmer Cotton, down past the Hill in Bywater?”
“Oh!” Bilbo cried. “Oh, yes, of course. Only just the other day, don’t you know, he was up buying potatoes from me rather than eating his own!”
One hundred and thirty-one.
Two years, then.
But two years for what? He couldn’t for the life of him remember what it was he’d been thinking so hard about. Oh, it couldn’t have been all that important. He shook himself and focused back on Frodo.
“Well, Rosie and Sam have been living with me in Bag End, and their daughter is called Elanor, like the flower that grows in Lothlórien, and she is just as beautiful.”
His dear eyes were fond, so fond as he spoke, and he’d begun to look away into the distance one looked into when one was thinking of things that were no longer there. Bilbo folded his brittle face into a tired smile.
“That’s good, that’s awful good to hear. It’s yours, now, you know, Frodo. Left you everything in it.” He closed his eyes. All this travelling was really rather tiring, in truth. “I shan’t be seeing it again, I don’t think.”
Elanor. Elanor. Did Elves give their flowers meanings? Bilbo’d never thought to ask, which seemed a large oversight on his behalf, considering his position in an Elven house for almost two decades now. He resolved to do it after he woke from his nap by the fire.
“No, Bilbo. I don’t think you shall.”
And if he forgot, it was all right.
Frodo was here. Frodo could tell him.
They barely spoke between then and the battle.
Bilbo spent most of his time in tents with the leaders of each army, Thranduil and Bard and Dain, once he and his forces arrived en masse and in haste and were informed of what was to occur, and all the while Gandalf watched over his shoulder with bent back and staff in hand.
Thorin did not attend. He sent Balin with Bilbo instead to each of the meetings, to talk on his behalf of battle strategy and suggest plans to counteract what Bilbo predicted they’d face based on what had happened the first time.
“Two battlefronts,” Bilbo had said in a leaden voice, grimacing, “one beyond the Front Gate and one an ambush from the far side of the Mountain. We were unprepared for it last time, and that is where our dead rose.”
Nobody spoke to him of what he’d said atop the battlements other than to ask if there was anything else he remembered that could be of help, or whether they should send for aid and more armies from further abroad, or who had led what in the first battle — all of which was no small amount of daunting considering Bilbo had never planned a battle in his life, had been invisible for much of the first one, and with only occasional exceptions, preferred to stay well away from such things. Nobody mentioned that the death toll had one name already very publicly placed there — and yet, of course, it crept at his mind every single hour of the day.
Whenever Bilbo saw Thorin, he was usually traipsing back and forth up on the highest point of the battlements, alone, or with Balin or Dwalin, or his nephews, and watching the wind blow through the huddle of tents far away. He would look back sometimes at Bilbo and stand arrested, never nodding or speaking or moving otherwise, never quite making eye contact, and would look away again as if burned, with his head lowered and the curve of his jaw harsh as stone. Only once did he manage to choke out a Master Burglar in greeting, and it had not happened since.
Dain Ironfoot was very fascinated by all of these developments, of course, particularly since he had not witnessed the row upon the ramparts, and nobody had thought it appropriate to explain to him the specifics of Bilbo’s existence or how exactly it was they’d come upon the knowledge of the battle. He’d taken one look at the great carcass Bard had shot down on his arrival, surveyed it with whip-sharp, calculating eyes, then turned to his onlookers and called out, “Anyone fancy dragon for dinner?” in a wry, booming voice, clear amusement colouring his grin.
One such day, they were departing a meeting to forage the camp for some rations, a meeting in which Bilbo had mostly sat in the corner with his head in his hands and reminded the rest of them intermittently that the approaching army would not be on foot but on wargs, which were much faster and much harder to contend with. He’d made at once for the Mountain, knowing Balin and Dain were likely lingering behind to spar words with Thranduil but hoping to catch Fili or Ori in some mindless chatter to ease his twisted-up nerves. He’d only gotten a handful of paces before Gandalf entirely accosted him with the smack of his staff against the ground.
“Do you perhaps know, Bilbo, if Master Oakenshield will be joining us during the battle?” he asked pleasantly, striding up to join Bilbo as he walked, and Bilbo narrowed his eyes.
“Of course he will,” he replied irritably. And really, what a ridiculous question. Thorin had been spending all his time sourcing armour and helms and weapons within their hoard and anywhere else in the Mountain they could find them, though Bilbo could see it pained him to do it, and he had kept his distance. He may be the most stoic and solemn Bilbo had ever seen him, but for all of that, out of the clutch of the sickness, he had never been the sort of leader who would abandon his people to their fate.
If Thorin cloaked in illness had walked as a husk or a spectre, Thorin on the other side of it took every single step as if he were in mourning, marching round and round the wake and singing that sombre song that had so long ago called out to the very deepest caverns in Bilbo’s boarded-up heart.
“Then do you not think it is unwise for him to be absent at every meeting?” Gandalf prodded. “Dain is a mighty warrior and a grand strategist, but plans passed along through mouths rather than eyes and ears are seldom carried out the way they are intended.”
The wizard was eyeing him very shrewdly as he said this, hands clasped on the staff at his side, and for some reason it was this of all unlikely, inconsequential things that caused Bilbo to realise that he had quite reached the end of his tether.
”Gandalf,” he said, feeling like the frayed end of an old bit of rope, and unsure whether his hacked-up emotions were more anger or exhaustion, “what exactly is it you expect me to be able to do about that?”
“My dear fellow, whatever do you mean?”
Bilbo looked upon him for one long moment, summoning every last bit of the strength of his will not to shout, and then turned his back and marched away, fully aware that he was stomping so hard over rocks and stones his feet would likely bruise.
”You won’t get anywhere by asking me about it except sticking a finger in a wound I am already well aware of, thank you very much! He will not speak to me. He will not even look at me. I repulse him.”
”Bilbo, you fool,” Gandalf muttered snappishly, slowing, and Bilbo slowed with him unthinkingly, before remembering once more that he was incensed and speeding right up again. Gandalf, to his displeasure, followed with ease, cupping a worn pipe to his mouth and puffing out three clean-sailing smoke-rings, before pursing his lips and fixing Bilbo with a familiar earth-shaking stare. ”Do you truly think it is because you repulse him?”
Bilbo whirled his body around to face his companion and held out an accusatory finger, knowing full well that he was likely poking the beast but deciding he did not care.
”What else, Gandalf! I am naught but an omen of doom for him, on two legs and walking around, talking and laughing! Every day I must remind him of it!”
His chest was drumming up and down rapidly, and he knew his eyes must be shining something wild, overgrown thicket of hair lashing around his face in the whispering wind. He felt as if he had been unspooled, and everything that rested in his head had congealed on the floor, and there was nothing else in his mind, nothing more he could do.
Thorin would not speak, would barely eat, would hardly look at Bilbo. He stared out at the theatre of his own demise every day and surely wondered where it was he would fall, how his own blood might run. No doubt he constantly remembered that too, his sister-sons would fall, would die, and he would tear his only living family from the rest of hers, and he would never again see the Lonely Mountain as it had once been.
Bilbo could scarcely even begin to imagine with any bone in his body the wretchedness Thorin must be feeling. The searing fact of his own mortality, and a date given to him for when it would strike. A matter of days. A ticking clock. And only the desperate word of a soft little creature from the Shire for comfort, who had been keeping secrets from him every single moment they’d known one another. He didn’t begrudge Thorin his silence one bit — and not least because he was still wrangling with the fact his dwarves did not seem to care a whit at how exceedingly odd he truly was and how exceedingly thoroughly he had done them wrong.
Gandalf levelled his gaze downward, looking more clearly at Bilbo. He adjusted the grip on his staff, leaning on it more heavily, and tilted his head with a sad smile.
”Bilbo,” he said, if not softly, then without any of his characteristic flint, “you remind him of the nearness of your own death, not of his. It is not you or your actions which repulse him. It is Thorin who repulses himself.”
Bilbo stopped squarely in his tracks.
Well.
Well!
It seems I have fallen for a fellow without a brain!
After that, he’d spluttered and blubbered a whole lot of nothing, and marched away to shut himself in the dark of his borrowed tent and do some more accursed thinking, eyes darting back and forth across the scrunched-up sheets, eyeing the wall, the map, the leather book from his pack he’d taken to carrying around nonsensically that had held notes in it six months ago which knew nothing of anything at all.
Bilbo felt as if he had been smacked over the head. With a club, perhaps. Or a frying pan. Had he done, it would’ve echoed like an emptied water-drum, for all the sense he had stored in it.
What a colossally pointless excuse to be leaving yourself out of plans. What colossal idiocy. As if all of them here had been idly making arrangements for when next to have tea and not how they were going to target two separate opposing armies thousands strong who were very clearly ready to kill whomever and however they chose!
What a fool. What an absolutely preposterously stone-brained, hard-headed, illogical, unmovable fool.
From then, it was hardly any time at all before Balin was confronted with a very determined hobbit on a single-minded mission.
“He must come. We need him. He knows the Mountain like none other here living, he knows the ravens, the landscape, the entries and exits —“
“You know he won’t, laddie.”
“I couldn’t really care less, Balin.”
They stopped in synchronicity, and looked at each other, Balin’s face troubled, tired, owlish, and Bilbo’s blazing. Balin blinked. Bilbo stared him down.
He wouldn’t let up, either. Everything hung in the balance, and if they did not all get it by now he would have to drag them kicking and screaming no matter what they said about it any which way. He could not make nice-and-polite for a king who was apparently an imbecile any longer. Even one so unfortunately nestled inside of his heart.
“Very well. I’ll see what I can do.”
“Hail, King Under the Mountain.”
Thorin made no indication that he’d heard Bard at all as he entered the makeshift set-up of their battle room aside from an incremental incline of his head and the line of his jaw suddenly tightening to breaking. He did not speak.
He swept about the room, eyes roaming once over the walls and skimming across its occupants to quickly settle on the spread of lines across the table they had all circled around.
“Oh, so now he shows his face, does he?” Dain teased as Balin entered the tent behind him, grimacing as Thorin’s shoulders only stiffened, though his gaunt eyes flickered up to his cousin in acknowledgement. Gandalf clasped his hands together.
“Well, let’s not delay. What news have you to bring, Thorin Oakenshield?”
Thorin bowed his head and began to speak.
He was stiff and stilted, but he spoke quietly and offered knowledge and strategy, telling them of the gathering of tools and armour in the Mountain and promising to distribute them as soon as was possible. There was some debate about numbers and logistics, or some other such; Bilbo only watched the stillness that Thorin had set himself in and didn’t focus on much of anything else.
“Much is destroyed, or still lost in rubble and buried under gold,” Thorin said. “But we are doing all we can.”
“All of you will fight?” Bard asked, bent halfway over one of their cobbled-together diagrams with an arm outstretched. Thorin frowned slightly.
“I would not have asked my kin here if I did not believe I needed their aid.”
Bard straightened from the table and looked very intently at Thorin. “My apologies,” he said. “I only meant to ask — you, also, will fight?”
A dreadful hush spread.
The tent was very quiet. Bilbo saw instantly that Thorin took as much offence to the question as Bilbo himself had on his behalf. Even Dain was frowning now, staring at Bard with a hardened gaze.
Thorin stood to his full height, which wasn’t much of a help in this tent of Big Folk, but his shoulders rolled back and his chest drew upward; a warrior’s stance. He lifted his head fully for the first time all meeting and fixed Bard with an indecipherable look, one that was an acknowledgement and a challenge both to the Man who would question him, and there, Bilbo saw it at last; there was life in him again.
“I understand,” Thorin boomed, “that my conduct towards both your kindred and my own in recent days has been questionable, and would cause you to doubt my ability as a leader. But it will be a cold day in the grave before I abandon my people to die alone for a cause I called them to. You may think whatever you wish of me, Dragonslayer, and I urge you to place more of your trust in both Dain son of Nain and Balin son of Fundin as you already have been. But if nothing else, I ask that you trust in my ability to fight where I know I am needed.”
He lingered for a moment longer, letting the words sit heavy in the silence as all of them stood stock-still and watching him, and then he lifted the tent-flap and stormed out.
Bilbo dashed after him, shoving the fabric of the tent aside and racing to catch up before he disappeared again. Outside, a gentle sleet had begun, the fall of winter petals, like raindrops that rested on the wings of birds.
At the sound of his feet Thorin looked back at Bilbo once, and his eyes widened so slightly few others would have caught it on his face; they held each other’s gaze for several moments, Thorin’s blank and Bilbo’s ablaze now that he saw right through that silly facade of stoicism.
“You left the meeting,” Thorin said quietly.
Bilbo waved a dismissive hand and strode forward. “Of course I did. That was absolutely entirely uncalled for, and I’m sorry you had to hear it — I mean, really, what poor form from Bard!”
“They will not be forced to suffer through my presence again.”
Bilbo’s feet pattered to a stop, right there in the middle of the greyed-out camp.
“What?”
Thorin stopped as he did, though when he turned, it was only slightly, enough that Bilbo could see half of his face, and he was not quite looking over his shoulder. He didn’t speak, and so his words hung all the more in the silence. Bilbo took a step forward and spoke up for him.
“That was it?” he pressed, in disbelief. “That is as long as you are willing to stay for?”
Thorin turned away again, back towards the Mountain, and he clasped his hands behind his back, standing rigid and statuesque, as if sculpted there from the earth.
“Dain and Balin will inform me of the rest. I am not leading our armies. I do not need to regularly attend. He has brought the majority of our forces, not I.”
“On your command!” Bilbo snapped, marching his way around so he was standing in front of Thorin and the bullheaded thing could not turn away from him any longer. “And what do you suppose I am doing at the meetings, Thorin? Am I to be leading anybody’s armies?” Thorin only looked askance at him and held his silence, so Bilbo pushed on irritably. “Do you not think it would be wise to engage with the allies you will have around you in the years to come? With your kin, who know you as a king?”
At that Thorin looked as if a thousand words to say had floated through his mind, all of them causing him grave injury, but after several moments of swallowing so the jut of his throat bobbed up and down, he said only, “I would not think they would wish me there.”
Bilbo let his own face crumple up into the most withering look he could muster.
“Perhaps you spoke truth after all. You are blind.”
The muscle in Thorin’s jaw clenched so a harsh line struck itself across his face, but he did not speak. There they stood, opposite one another, Bilbo’s heart jumping out of his sternum, out of his ribcage and into the open air; drumming, drumming, drumming.
Bilbo had had far, far too much of silences and skirting looks and tip-toeing about for the sake of what amounted to absolutely nothing at all. He was going to make this ridiculous dwarf talk to him if he had to stick a hand down his throat and fish out the words himself.
He planted both of his hands on his hips and opened his mouth.
“Look, Master Oakenshield, I don’t care one iota if you aren’t leading anybody from the Iron Hills, and if I may hazard a guess, neither does anyone else. You still have a Company, and they will follow you above all others, and you know it.”
There were several moments of pause. Then: “I thank you for your words, Master Baggins. I will… think on them.”
And, of all things, Thorin turned his back on Bilbo, and made to walk away, and Bilbo very abruptly and with all the pent-up frustration of a bonfire decided he’d had quite enough of that.
He lunged out at once and clapped a hand down hard against Thorin’s leather-clad forearm, grabbing a firm hold and hauling with all the strength he could dredge up, digging his heels into the ground until this aggravating, infernal, vexatious dwarf was forced to cease his march out of the camp and turn back around.
He turned his head, first eyeing the hand on his bracer and then the face of the hobbit attached to it, and that expressionlessness, those eyes like a tomb — that was what curdled Bilbo’s insides more than anything. Thorin refused to feel. He refused to let down his guard, to push his emotions outward, but they were in him somewhere, those cavernous spaces smothered by his self-pity and righteous loathing. They were not gone. Bilbo would simply have to irritate them out.
“What can you possibly think it is you are going to achieve by pretending we are no longer friends, like we don’t hardly know each other from every Tom and Dick in Dale! Confusticating dwarf, skulking around like a kicked puppy with your great shaggy head, tail between your legs!”
Thorin’s eyes flashed wide, and he stared at Bilbo as if he’d grown feet out his ears, but solemn as he was he did not speak. Wild, untempered anger flared inside Bilbo, spiralling red and up and outwards, and he tugged hard on Thorin’s arm again, gritting his teeth and likely pushing his jaw out entirely unattractively, but it wasn’t to be helped.
“Well? Out with it!” Bilbo demanded.
Black irritation flashed across Thorin’s face in one single bolt before it smoothed, and the clay-cracks were back in place, and in his utter lack of expression and the mournful greyness painted all over him Bilbo could see plain as day the hatred he had been turning back on himself simmering underneath.
Oh, that look. Bilbo couldn’t stand it one bit. Thorin looked a clam that had closed up, a flower that had sealed and shrivelled its petals instead of opening them out. The shutters had closed, the embers had died. What little life had been lit within him was gone as if it had never been. He looked just like Bilbo had felt when he’d first set his foot over the threshold of Bag End again that very first time after thirteen months away, a mirrored match of what remained of his house; ransacked and pilfered, the insides gutted and torn down to their bare bones.
All that, Bilbo thought. All that, and still you have been made dead to me anyway.
At long last, Thorin brought his steely eyes to Bilbo’s, and when he spoke, his voice was hoarse, as if the sides of his throat had rusted in the speckled rain.
“I would not harm you further, Master Burglar. I will not harm you again.”
So endlessly, unnecessarily noble. He was every bit of him still a king, and it made Bilbo want to hit him in the chest.
“And that is all good and well,” he said, letting every bit of his well-practiced snobbishness leak in until he sounded stern as an old ox, “but it is a far cry from acting as if we have never met and never spoken!”
Thorin had so far stood frozen, watching Bilbo with that sickening nothing drenching him all over, but now he began to pace, hands clasped once more and his boots crunching across the chipped rock beneath them. He seemed — agitated. Not quite so caring as to be agitated, maybe, but certainly something was beginning to build.
Come on, Thorin. You are in there, love. You are so close to the surface.
“It was not my intention to anger you,” Thorin said, no longer looking at Bilbo, not even in Bilbo’s direction, eyes cast instead down somewhere between the lip of the nearest tent and the shoal lining the ground. “It is that I do not wish to force my presence upon you. If that… displeases you, I am truly sorry.”
Right. Bilbo was now properly peeved.
“You listen here, you great stubborn thing. You died.” Bilbo’s lip trembled, and he bit down on the inside of his cheek, stilling it, narrowing his eyes at the maddening creature before him, who clearly would not let a single word he’d said filter into his great stubborn head. “You spoke your words of farewell to me, and you left the world. And I went home.”
“I wish you would stop saying that,” Thorin muttered.
“And I wish you would listen!” He threw his hands out to the side, aware that he was beginning to splutter, but there was nothing else for it. “What is going to convince you? Hm? You are so despondent about all this, about something I frankly could not care less about, and yet you have not even said a simple ‘forgive me’. That seems a good place to start, don’t you think?”
There was a tension-line running right from Thorin’s chin to the cleft beneath his ear when he replied, ”I would not ask you to do something I cannot do myself.”
Oh, for —
”Oh, you bebothering oaf, you aren’t listening! Listen to my words, and not what you have convinced yourself it is I am saying in your head!”
When Thorin finally looked back at him, he was struck with a wild glare from Bilbo. It served him right. Bilbo wrought every ounce of his scathing temper into it, sure that he would scorch the ground anew and wondering if that of all things might get through to this blind buffoon.
“I understand why you would push me away, Thorin, I do. I know the reason I was gifted the chance to come back here again, and it is because my mind was hurt by something too. I became consumed by it, just like your Arkenstone.”
“Please do not mention it by name.”
Bilbo sighed. “The gold, then. You don’t think I am flawed? That all of us are flawed? We are not so different, Thorin. You have no idea how mirrored our stories have been.”
Thorin’s face had darkened, and he was not looking at Bilbo but out at the Long Lake, and Mirkwood beyond, his gaze so very far away.
“It is impossible,” he murmured. An echo of the ramparts; so different, now. He looked back.
“Master Baggins.” Master Baggins, my hat. Where are you, Thorin? Where are you in there? “I am grateful for what you wish to do for me. You show me allegiance and loyalty even still, when I deserve none from you, when I should be grovelling at your feet for all the honour you have shown the world that I have not. But I am alone in what my people’s gold has done to me.”
“You are not listening to me —”
“And you are not listening to me!”
Their shoulders heaved in tandem, eyes wide; Thorin looked so very haunted, what Bilbo could only imagine a person already buried would look like had he not seen it for himself and known this was the opposite.
This was the spark. He must blow on the tinder.
“How can you expect me to even look you in the eye?” Thorin demanded, and he could not be drawn away from Bilbo now that they were here; no self-hatred in all the world could do it. “How can you think I would trust myself in your presence, that you would trust me to be close to you when I have laid hands on you, laid my blade against you!”
“And have you forgotten what it is I’ve done?” Bilbo snapped right back. “For the answer is all of this before. I’ve betrayed you, and I have watched you betray me, and I have forgiven you, long, long, ago. And still I came back here to save you all. Think about that in your incessant brooding, if you will, Master Oakenshield.”
Thorin was silent. Bilbo calmed his breathing, closing his eyes for a moment.
“I told you of my nephew.”
“Frodo Baggins,” the murmur came.
“The very same. Well, you should know also that I hurt him. I hurt him very badly, and it is my burden to bear. So if there is anyone at all who most knows that you would not hurt those you wish to protect without a reason, it is me.”
Bilbo sucked in a breath. He could not speak any plainer. He had no other way of getting anything at all through that thick-set head but with his words. It was what he had taught himself in. It was all he had to wield.
Bilbo began to pace, himself, up and down, eyes skittering wildly about the oatmeal-beige tents, the charcoal-grey ground. He had half a mind to stick his fingers in his hair and pull at the ends in frustration.
“I cannot understand why it is you do not all hate me, and you most of all,” he said, still pacing, not looking at Thorin once. “I delivered you to death in the most brutal way possible. I delivered it to your loved ones. Better that you threaten me with empty actions and have the excuse of not being in your right mind than having all of your wits and still shouting aloud what I shouted for all the Mountain to hear.”
“Empty actions, you call them.” Thorin laughed hollowly. “I almost had you killed.”
Bilbo rolled his eyes. “Do you think I give a single fig about that? I don’t care —“
“You should care!” Thorin roared, whirling on Bilbo, hair flying about his face like the vines of a forest, the great strings of a spider’s web. And it was bizarre, and he knew himself bizarre for it, but somehow in that very moment Bilbo found himself having to gulp down his smile.
At last, something had ignited him, and he was Thorin once more.
“I could not have cared less what you said to me upon the battlements, Master Baggins. I am not young anymore. I do not care that it is me. I owe you many debts I can never repay, the latest of which being that you do not curse my name to my face and spit at my feet, though you would have every right. But I wondered… why it was you looked at me with such weight. For so long, I — And now I know. You knew what was coming, what I would do —”
He swallowed, eyes wide and unseeing in the distance, and one hand was closing and unclosing, as if he could not even fathom what it was he was thinking. “You have told me I died in selfishness, in greed, coveting what should never have been mine. Lost. And you tell me Fili and Kili — and after what I have done to you — what I —“ He shook his head, and his great mane of hair moved with it. Bilbo’s eyes could not help but follow the beads in each braid. “I am undone.”
Enough of this.
Bilbo launched forwards with a suddenness that surprised even him to grip Thorin’s hand and wrench it back until it pressed flat against his own chest, then stretched an arm out and did the same, so that all at once his thieving hand lay over the place where Thorin’s heart would be.
There they stood, locked together, as if snow and sunlight too had frozen them there and they could move no longer, Bilbo holding one hand to Thorin’s sturdy chest and using the other to keep Thorin’s fingers nestled against his own. Thorin looked up, and there, their eyes met.
“Do you feel that?”
Their chests rose and fell in unison, Bilbo’s heartbeat surely fluttering all over the place as it always did, Thorin’s steady, steady as the roots of trees, of mountains and gulleys. Thump. Thump. Thump.
He adjusted his fingers over the left side of Thorin’s chest, brushing the rough fabric and feeling it crush beneath his hand. Bilbo smiled wearily. It was the furthest cry possible from the midnight velvet of the royal cloak he’d favoured in the Mountain. And it was Thorin.
“I am alive, Master Oakenshield,” Bilbo said, softer than he’d meant to. “You torture yourself over something that has not come to pass.”
Then, suddenly, there was a hitch of breath that was not Bilbo’s, deep and quiet and deafening nonetheless, sharp as a sword in the blunt silence. Bilbo’s nerves flared, ridiculously, and then all at once he noticed the trajectory of Thorin’s eyes like the bolt of an arrow, and he reddened so quickly it was as if he’d quite fallen into a fireplace.
Oh, dear.
Somehow — oh, dear! — his collar was open, frayed down the parting with the wear and tear of rough travel, and there in the telling gap shone the mithril mail, the prize of kings and princes. Bilbo looked down at it with very wide eyes, and then back up to Thorin mirroring him exactly, gulping down a shaky breath.
They watched each other; Bilbo could do nothing else, and was adamant someone was going to have to slice them apart with some sort of weapon because they were both surely stuck here now, not doing anything, crystal-pressed in the midst of one moment and the next.
Thorin swallowed heavily.
“It is not only me who has tortured himself,” he said in a low voice.
Bilbo stepped backward at once, letting both of his hands drop from Thorin, losing their warmth, and pulling his treacherous collar up angrily so the pearl and diamond that gleamed beneath could no longer see the light of day.
”Quite right, and I’ll thank you to keep your snooping nose out of it, Thorin Oakenshield.”
Bilbo held out a finger in accusation, and it was shaking, so great then was his rage. The sheer impropriety of it. The nerve he had. As if — as if —
But Thorin beat him to it.
“You tell me you understand me, you say you have felt what I feel when I look within the halls of my fathers, and yet you will not allow any other comparison for fear I might bring your hurts to light.” Thorin was staring very intently at him, dark eyes wide. “So what is it you want from me?”
“I want you,” Bilbo said, voice trembling, “to care about saving yourself in the battle you know is coming. I want it to matter that other people care. And I want you, as I have told you, you incessantly rock-headed dwarf, to stop insisting that you know better than I do with regards to my own actions. I know what I am doing.”
There was silence for a moment, hanging as whispers in the air. Thorin’s head was bowed.
“Will you not also take your own advice?”
Bilbo scoffed in disbelief. “Oh, if you only knew how many manners you’re ignoring, Thorin, I would —”
“The news you think you destroyed us with,” Thorin said over him, though it was just as low, just as quiet. “It does not matter. Not any further than knowing I must guard my sister-sons with my life now more than ever. You speaking it aloud does not mean you struck the blow, Master Baggins.”
My blood is not on your hands.
Bilbo didn’t know if he could believe it, just yet. He drew his eyes from Thorin’s face to his temple, to his chest, and they breathed, breathed.
“Then surely a blow unstruck is not a blow at all,” he whispered. Thorin’s face twisted in a self-inflicted scowl.
“Had it fallen, it would have landed.”
“Had the person letting it fall had any faith whatsoever in the people he associated himself with, he would know we are not all so stupid as to stand by and let ourselves be cut in half with swords.”
Thorin’s spine straightened, and he turned his back, standing there for a long while, clouded in a storm of his own making.
“That may be so, Master Baggins, but I still held the blade.”
Bilbo let his jaw work, hot with embarrassment that his agitation could so clearly be seen in every inch of his body but carrying on nonetheless.
“You do not get to tell me I am tortured and parade yourself around your Mountain as if you have had your wings clipped,” he retaliated, as fiercely as he could fathom. “You cannot shun me against my will and my words to you and then act as if it is me who has done the shunning.”
He took one single step closer, raising his chin so they were as eye-to-eye as they could be. Thorin’s head was ever-bowed, and his eyes were so very vivid, sapphire-stones and forget-me-nots, and Bilbo breathed out, ”You must trust me. You must, Thorin. You have this far, haven’t you?”
He waited with held breath, as if his breath had caught and all the world caught with it, latched upon a hook and awaiting an unknown verdict. But after some time, it was clear that Thorin did not have a response to what Bilbo had asked of him, just as he hadn’t the last time they’d spoken. Bilbo supposed he couldn’t blame him.
Bilbo nodded bluntly, once, and turned to go.
(Back to Gandalf, or to Balin and Dain, he wasn’t sure. As it was he was trying very hard not to think of himself as running with his tail between his legs.)
And then, again, Thorin surprised him.
”Master Baggins.”
Of course, Bilbo knew far too well by now that a seemingly-ended sentence from Thorin Oakenshield only meant the beginning of a question, so he let himself hum in reply, and he waited.
“Did I give it to you? In your life before?”
Bilbo turned.
Thorin’s eyes had not lowered from his face, and his jaw was tighter than ever, but it was immediately clear what he’d meant, and Bilbo did rather well, in his own opinion, to keep the pinking from his cheeks. He brought an absent hand up to rub at the gap in his shirt at the neckline, the cool silver of the mithril meeting the tips of his fingers smooth as water.
”Yes, Master Oakenshield,” he said, swallowing, “and it saved me and mine.”
The days went on as they waited and prepared and planned, and the sky darkened, and an ominous feeling crept over all the Mountain. The inevitable battle was coming closer, and all of them could feel it. Scouts from Mirkwood had ridden back to Dale in a frightening hurry declaring that they’d sighted a horde of orc armies days before, that they would likely have made quick time behind them and would soon make their approach.
But in amongst all of their talks and distribution of supplies and battle tactics there was one last thing on Bilbo’s mind, one last loose thread, and he knew it could not wait any longer. He made his excuses to the Company, one late afternoon, telling them there was something small he needed to do, that shouldn’t take too long at all. Not a few of them had seemed quite worried, and Bofur had blinked wide-eyed at him, rather reluctant all of a sudden.
”You’re not going off to hide somewhere and fight them alone, are you?” he’d asked.
Bilbo laughed fondly and shook his head. ”You ridiculous things! I’ll be back in a tick, don’t worry yourselves. I only need a moment alone.”
He needed to say goodbye.
He stashed the necessities in a satchel and departed from the Mountain, wandering for a while, until there was no noise at all and he was far away from any armies and tents and living souls. There was a little outcropping of rock at the base of one of the Mountain’s outstretched arms, with a little nook carved into the edge of it, presumably by the wind. Bilbo gently sank to the ground in front of it and crossed his legs.
He wished desperately and painfully that there were any flowers nearby, even some sort of measly daffodil or chrysanthemum if it could be spared, but the scarred land stretched so far that it hurt Bilbo to look upon it for too long, knowing that nothing had grown here since the dwarves had lost their home. When they all survived this, he decided, he would scrounge around for books wherever he could possibly manage it, and he would research which plant life would best survive the terrain of northern rock and wind. He already had a few flowers in mind.
And there would be snapdragons galore.
Bilbo had even asked Gandalf softly if he was able to conjure up flowers at all, if that was how wizardry worked; he wasn’t entirely sure. Gandalf had seemed a mix of oddly pitying and nettled by the request, and told him that it was much more in Radagast the Brown’s line of work.
Bilbo took the book bound in its red leather out of the little brown satchel slung across his hip and propped it open on the ground so he could gently tear one, then two pages out of it. One by one, tucking the other under his knee so it wouldn’t blow away in the bitter wind, he very delicately folded each page bit by bit until they resembled petals with a twisted stem underneath. Paper-flowers, a favourite of his mother’s, because she’d always known how much he missed seeing the blossoms when the ground froze over in the colder months. Bilbo thought wistfully that it would have been better if they’d held any colour, but then, the paper-flowers matched the palette of the landscape around them, white winter snow and grey swirling clouds and the dull blue of the Lonely Mountain at his side.
He gently placed the two flowers against the granite, tucking them into the soft curve in the rock so they lay out of the wind and rested peacefully against each other. Then, he drew out from the satchel a sliver of graphite, opened the cover of the book once more, and leant over to scrawl inside it carefully.
The Downfall of the Lord of the Rings and the Return of the King
He sat back, admiring the unassuming words for a moment longer, and then neatly tore another two pages out of his lovely notebook — one was the very first page of the book, lying adjacent to his little label, and the other the very last. He held them up to the daytime, so the sunlight filtered through, and then set them alight using the embers of his pipe, letting them slowly crumble away into ash until there was nothing for him to hold onto at all.
Now the story would have no beginning and no end. It could just be.
Bilbo knew in his heart that he still thought it should have been Frodo instead of him who got to do his life over, who got his chance at happiness instead of having to bear the weight of all of Middle-Earth on his shoulders. He knew he would until the day he died. But he did not resent himself for it, and he knew that this was the way the moon and stars and the powers-that-be had chosen, and so he would question it no longer.
Frodo's heart would go to him, one day. Sam had borne the Ring, and he would cross the shores of Middle-Earth to the lands that lay beyond. Frodo did not belong in the Shire anymore, and the pain he had suffered needed to heal, and friends of both Bilbo and Frodo’s were taking him to the place where he would be safest to do so.
Bilbo's pain was borne from things that had been taken from him, from a life of knowing the chance he might have had if things had gone but slightly differently. Half of his heart had been laid to rest, to sleep with gems and ancient blades of the North under miles of mountain-stone, and now the moment had come at last when he could reverse it.
“My Frodo-lad,” he said gently, for it was always out loud when he spoke to Frodo, and uttered in his head like a secret when he spoke to Thorin. “I hope you know that if I could have, I would have borne it all in your place.” He closed his eyes, and his voice was shaking, but he let it. “In… in our next lifetime, then, dear boy.”
It was too much to bear, suddenly, to speak it aloud, to whisper to Frodo when he was no longer there and Bilbo didn’t know if the wind could carry his words so far. He bent his head, and brushed the petals of the flowers with his numbed fingertips.
I am sorry I took your life from you, Frodo. I hope you can still allow me mine.
There was a beautiful view of the lake from the little rock outcrop when he turned, the water like a porcelain mirror and glittering in the pale wintry light, the faraway wooden houses just barely visible in the distance. Behind him, the two little flowers were nestled in their crevice together, one leaning gently against the other.
Bilbo left the book there beside them. He could have taken it with him back into the Mountain, tucked it safely away, but somehow, he didn’t want to take it from Frodo. He could do nothing else but believe that they would all make it through the day through sheer determination, and there would be no more mourning, not for a long time, but if they did not, or he did not, he wanted to be laid to rest with Frodo.
Sleep a while, my boy. I’ll see you sometime or other.
When he turned his face upwards, Bilbo could see small flakes of ash still floating high in the air and away on the wind, making their way slowly west.
Then at last, all at once, it was upon them.
Bilbo’s meticulous worrying over and puzzling out how long it had taken the goblins to reach them in the past, how likely it was this timing had changed, and how accurate his memories of the exact date were after almost a century between them — and other such unnecessarily stressful matters — had come to good after all; they had been more or less accurate, at the very least, and the lookouts had sounded the alarm that the goblins and their wargs were closing in.
They’d rallied at once: each encampment had split off into their own sectors and begun organising in earnest, dividing up the hardiest of their shieldfolk, making preparations to hold the front line, calling out commands and speaking in hurried voices. Each of the dwarves of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield seemed to have their own rites and rituals as they readied themselves, and Bilbo found it rather fascinating. He’d seen them fight before, of course, in their skirmishes along the journey as well as great battles long past, but still he watched as they linked together and piled on the gold-and-iron-plated armour, sharpened weapons, rebraided their hair.
Bilbo himself did not have much readying to do, thankfully. A sword on his belt, mithril under his collar, helm in his hands, and he was set.
And then all of a sudden the fourteen of them were stood together atop the battlements in the mouth of the Mountain and facing each other, all adorned in chestplates and roughened mail, and Bilbo looked each of them in the eyes, one by one; Dwalin, then Fili, then Kili, Ori, Dori, Bombur, Bofur, Nori, Balin, Oin, Gloin, Bifur, and then Thorin directly opposite him in the very centre. Every single one of them bore identical expressions of determination, the fierce glint of anticipation and morbid acceptance of their own mortality in the set of their jaws and eyes, the clang of swords already ringing in the distance in the way they each looked at him.
He’d given his luck to Fili and Kili already, pulled them aside and apologised one last time for having to tell them what he had told them, and hugged them close in an entirely uncomely show of his affection. He did not know what he would do if this was the last time they saw each other. He’d let himself trust devotedly and wholeheartedly in his second chance the entire way through the quest, and he hoped with everything in him that it was not going to fail him now. He did not know if he could pick himself up again.
But if all went well, he would not have to.
Bilbo whistled out a low breath, and opened his mouth.
“Don’t any of you dare die on me,” he said very stubbornly. And there was no laugh, but it pulled grim smiles from each of their faces as they nodded back at him.
“Aye, we wouldn’t dare,” said Gloin and hear-hears rang round as well as a “Count on it, Bilbo!” from Bombur, all of their spines straightening at the call and kindling the fire in their eyes.
But Bilbo’s eyes were trained on Thorin, and he did not move them once, and Thorin did not look away. His eyes were grimly set, white-blue and icy against the skyline sapped of all colour in the bitter winter. They breathed as one; his chest rose as Thorin’s did, and Thorin’s fell when he exhaled.
Bilbo thought of the last words they’d exchanged in their colossal argument, scarcely a handful of days before, in the last moment before they had parted. Thorin watched him now, his eyes heavy, steady, unmoving. He stood tall and proud, no crown, no helm, the irresponsible, vociferous thing — Bilbo would have to try and rectify that, if there was any time. The threads drawn between them had twined their way around his own arms, and Bilbo could feel them more keenly than ever. He could almost see them looped around Thorin’s fingers like they were rings.
“You keep what I said in mind, alright?” Bilbo said simply. Thorin said nothing, but there was the slightest incline of his head in a bow, and the threads remained. Bilbo exhaled.
I cannot watch you fall again.
He had only trust, now. Trust and the quickness of his own hands.
The dwarves all raised their weapons to the sky, and even with such darkness approaching, every minute that they lingered, and with the very second chance he’d come back for balancing on a knife-point in front of him, it was true at that very moment that there was not one other place in the world Bilbo would rather have been.
“Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!”
Drums.
Drums.
Drums, but not in the deep, in the open, approaching ever closer like a raging tide, a black wave out of the underworld, out of the Void beyond the very farthest stars into deepest, deepest Night.
Was this what the Númenóreans had seen? Was this what they’d looked on in the Dagorlad?
Bilbo was getting ahead of himself, he knew. But all the same, it was the battle he had hated most, and the one he was proudest of, and the one he recalled the most sadly and the most fondly, so he grit his teeth quite firmly and set about mustering up every last bit of stubborn old courage he had in the body that had carried him there and back again. He scrunched up his nose, and breathed out harshly through his mouth.
Just one more time, old lad. Just one more time.
He was with Sting, and his mithril, and his Company, and Frodo resting atop the mountainside, watching over him.
There was no dwarven army to meet on the battlefield, of course; the fleet of warriors from the Iron Hills had been well prepared from their arrival days before, the time Bilbo had bought them by stealing the Arkenstone earlier making a remarkable difference. There was nothing to do but watch and wait, and hear the wild screams come ever closer. In the distance, the cap of the Mountain seemed tipped blood-red against the darkening sky.
And then a sea of churning bodies split the horizon. The battle-horns sounded.
The goblins were upon them.
So began the clang and clash, the scream of metal against flesh and bone, the slashing sounds of blood-hungry wargs and wicked goblins echoing terribly over the vast wasteland. The smell of blood was thick-red and cloying and stained the air like rust.
Bilbo did not fight directly if he could help it. He wouldn’t delude himself into thinking he could take on dozens of orcs twice his height, not even now he was halfway decent at throwing blades and with his trusty Elven letter-opener, and he didn’t much want to deal out such death, anyhow. Instead, he darted around and acted as the perpetual thorn in their side, light on his feet, ducking and weaving to slice at ankles or furry hides and buy their armies time. He shouted in warning to Elves and Men and dwarves, and he guided each of his friends away from gravest danger where he could, shouting at them in a shrill little voice to please use some of that common sense, for the love of all things, or so help me I will knock you out and drag you away myself!
It was carnage. Utter carnage. Black blood spattered the ground.
In the lead-up to battle, Bilbo had spent hours thinking, thinking, thinking, worrying his lip and wondering if intervening in a single one of his friends’ movements during the fight would mean the difference between life and death. What if he hindered an opponent of Dwalin’s and left another a clear opening? What if he swung for an orc attacking Ori or Dori and missed?
He held Sting with both hands like a flame, and reminded himself over and over that they had more back-up, they were more prepared, they were ready; and yet Thorin was in the battle already, and neither he nor any of the others would stay back the way Bilbo had suggested to, and at any moment one of them could be struck down, and that would be it, and it would be the end.
But in the thick of things, it all fell by the wayside. He simply fought, as he had done, as he had known he would do. He would join them in one last great victory.
The thunder crashed on and on, and darkness seemed to creep into every corner of the land, and the goblins’ numbers were never-ending, their screwed-up faces pulled back in awful grins as they prowled the battlefield. Their forces met in waves, clashing, spraying, receding, moving forward once more; gore spilt across the ground, lines of men and orcs fell, and their armies carved one another up. The very air around them seemed almost hungry for death, still and stagnant in the deep bone-cold of terror.
At one moment, Bilbo had been forced to the outskirts by the tide, and he was dashing a path along the crumbling walkways of Dale, looking for a vantage point to assess the goings-on as well as he could manage in the current state of things. He’d no idea how much time had passed, but the hilt of his Sting was slick with filth; he wiped it and the hand holding it against the material of his trousers and fought back a grimace.
He would likely have to burn these clothes. Unfortunate. But no matter.
He ran almost headlong into Gandalf the Grey striding his way up the cobblestone, who stopped in his tracks to stare down at him with wild eyes.
”I believe you have somewhere you’re supposed to be, Bilbo!” he exclaimed, quite flabbergasted. Bilbo frowned and grit his teeth together.
”You don’t need to tell me twice!” he called darkly, eyes darting about to each of the exits from the city and the glimpses of the rest of the battlefield he could see from afar.
Where should he make for? Head to Ravenhill, or enter the fray again and hope somehow he’d find the clothead he was here for? He could linger closer to Dain, to Dwalin, to Bofur and Bombur, but there was no guarantee at all that would yield any better results.
Orcs were infiltrating the ruins and running at them with their teeth bared; Bilbo ducked abruptly as a mace swung, missed, and slammed into an enemy behind him with a crunch that had him feeling quite entirely sick, and then shoved it down in annoyance. Oh, pick yourself up by your bootstraps, or whatever the silly saying is.
Gandalf swept a smooth hand out to his side and felled another half-dozen orcs slinking their way forwards. His hat was gone, and he looked tired, and Bilbo remembered with a pang that he had danced a battle with the Necromancer only very recently.
His weary friend. They’d have a pipe, after all this was done. Gandalf the Grey had those in Middle-Earth who watched over him, too.
“Well, if you are looking for them, I am sure I saw them last on the western border, my dear fellow. They are sticking fast to your demands, I imagine. And so they should,” he twinkled downward.
Bilbo pushed a sigh out his tightened mouth, forcing the hair back from his face in a grunt. “Now there is just the figuring out of how to get there,” he said, to himself; for Gandalf was already gone.
In his haste to locate Thorin, the second force took Bilbo almost entirely by surprise; he’d quite lost track of all time, and the writhing wave crested the western side of the Lonely Mountain in an avalanche.
This was the moment, then, if all went to plan. The turning of the tide. Dain’s bellow echoed over the swooping sea of their clustered armies, ricocheting up and off the mountainside and booming out in a sound that rang loud as any battle-horn. The Ironfoot was well and truly come.
Bilbo had clambered his way up near to the crown of Ravenhill to confirm Gandalf’s words; as best as he could, anyhow. His eyes were far keener in daylight, and beside that red tuft of hair leading the charge he saw a white head, a bald head, a gold-and-dark pair.
But the midnight tide. He couldn’t see. His eyes flicked around frantically; he could not see it at all.
There were hundreds of dwarves, and Men, and Elves — even a very distinctive bear, now, if Bilbo’s eyes were serving — and he was being utterly ridiculous in expecting himself to identify each and every one of them by a pinprick of the backs of their heads, beneath helms and war-braids.
But somehow he could feel the threads around him, pulled taut, stretching, stretching outward, far afield. The moment was coming, hurtling toward them.
He would not let them fray. Not as long as he drew breath in this twice-lived world.
All he had to do was find Thorin. Fili and Kili were protected, for now, and Bilbo knew he would only find them either amongst the Company or at their mother’s brother’s side til the very end, for they had fallen defending him to the last breath.
And yet the battlefield was endless. Everywhere were bodies strewn across the barren lands beneath the shadow of the Mountain, bent at odd angles and eyes closed in sleep everlasting. The masses of orcs and Elves and Men were churning as angry fish in a sea, as a wild pack of animals, the mouth of a raging river. The ground had cracked open. Warg-feet pounded the dirt, lashing the scarred earth, and horses stamped, and everywhere flew hammers and scythes and arrows with poison-darts.
Bilbo grew more and more frustrated as he hunted around for an avenue. Surely it was impossible. Memory of this battle had served, yes, but clearly it had not served enough; he had no way at all of entering the thicket and making it out the other side. What had happened? This battle was devastating, it was the harshest of awakenings, but it had still been won, he had still fought just as hard the last —
Bilbo’s stomach sank into the floor.
He knew, then. What the difference had been.
He felt at his pocket with trembling fingers. The weight of it bore down on him, even now, a world away. Even such a little ring.
He’d had its help, hadn’t he? The last time. It had gotten him away with his life.
And he would never make it across in time if he did not. He would never be able to find Thorin before the killing blow had been struck.
Bilbo undid the button with one hand, looked down, saw the dull gold nestled there, so very unassuming. His fingers paused before they could touch it. He closed his eyes tightly, and drew in a breath.
It will be my burden to bear. Just one last time.
He slipped the Ring on.
The world lurched.
It was like being plunged into a vat of boiling water, and sinking down, down, until the sky above was nearly black and the sun had faded out of sight until utter doom had come.
He was buried in the reedy, murky, mud-slick shallows of a great river ages past, and he was alone and cold on black rock that bit at his back in the depths of the cavern beneath the mountains, and he was tucked into a pocket and shut away in a drawer and carried through all the world to the very end and cast down into eternal fire.
The force of it knocked him back, and it was only when he blinked the battlefield back into focus that Bilbo realised his vision had gone white. He gasped for breath, shuddering, clutching at his throat, his lungs burning dry and red-raw.
He waited until it settled, hoping and pleading and half-out of his mind with fear that it wouldn’t settle, that he’d be dragged down below the surface once more, in one last, most terrible end. But in time, the feeling mellowed, and Bilbo felt himself return to his body, and the cool band of metal against his skin. He spun it once with his thumb so the inscription was facing inward, looking down at it through the grey mist it cast with hard eyes.
Bilbo knew that he had been the only Ringbearer who had ever relinquished Isildur’s Bane of his own choosing. He would not walk back on his promise.
It was not his anymore. He didn’t have to bow to it. He did not have to bend to its will ever again.
He raced off, ducking and weaving, sprinting across the moors in the most open paths he could find, heaving back too-short breaths of equal panic and exhaustion. He ran all the way to where he’d spied the Company, on the western border just as Gandalf had said, and neatly stung with his sword the hide of a silver-black warg that screamed and thrashed in agony to the ruin of its master.
”Dwalin! Where is Thorin!” he cried, coming to a stop and doubling over, embarrassingly heaving in air as if he had nearly drowned. He was dearly glad nobody could see him, at the minute.
”Covering our flank last I saw, but he got separated!” Dwalin roared, spinning his axes as if they were no lighter than air, as if he were a sculptor in the throes of a masterpiece. Orcs fell at his command, and he fought as if effortless, with that signature steel-sharp look on his face. His eyes flashed downward, noticing nothing but air, and his brows creased in the middle. “Where — ?”
”Do you know which way he went?” Bilbo pressed loudly, hopping swiftly out of the way so Dwalin could cleave a warg and goblin-rider apart from one another; the warg fell to the side, and the weedy orc dashed off in a fright before he could do any further damage.
Dwalin’s head spun from side to side in search of Bilbo, but he could not afford to focus on his confusion and knew it, and he took a moment to catch his breath, eyeing very seriously the new oncoming surge and looking back to Dain calling his commands ahead.
”He’d be on the outskirts, or forced to the back!” he yelled to the air. Bilbo was gone before another word had come from his mouth.
He ran, ran, ran, panting something absolutely unbelievable, forcing himself onward, ducking and weaving and dodging and swinging. He reached the flanks of their forces and crested a small hill, the churned-up earth utterly stampeded and flecked with blackening blood.
And there at last, all at once, he could see it.
Thorin, Orcrist at his side, his hair pulled back and his clothes filthy with grime, wiping the sweat from his brow and searching for the others with fierce eyes. Behind him, alone on the moors, separated as they were from the swelling mass of five armies, a creature lurking closer, its eyes half-bulging in their sockets and the devilish grin it wore cold as ice.
Bolg, Bilbo thought his name was. He remembered him from the battle before. He’d forgotten how utterly bone-chilling he was.
Thorin had begun to run, noticing his isolation from the rest of their forces and realising its danger at once, and the orc followed, picking up his speed, prowling across the desolation with a gnarled smile on his face.
Bolg was clever; Thorin had not seen him, the battle-blood surely pounding in his ears. The orc drew a weapon, slick and stealthy, the metal battered, matching the contraptions on his head and torso. He was closing the gap between them, and had even begun to laugh as he neared, a low, hungry noise that slid like stinking oil from his mouth. Thorin heard, and began to turn, but it was rapidly becoming clear that it was not in time; Bolg was too close, and already bore a weapon and a terrible smile.
Bilbo came to a stop. And he thought.
He thought of Thorin before, cold as glass, hair like a halo, untouchable, unreachable for ever more, a hollow space where there should have been a heart. What do I do now? What do I do now? Red poppies like dark blood on ice, eternal sleep, the empty space beside him, at his table, under the tree with the acorns in his garden, King Under the Mountain below the earth with a white stone upon his chest.
He thought of every moment in this lifetime and the last, Thorin’s hair between his fingers, his pulse thudding, skin warm, warm, warm, his hoarse voice, his quiet ache, the way he said Bilbo’s name, the way he looked at him over and over, snapdragons for his favourite flower and his eyes gleaming blue. You’ve never let any of us forget it, have you, Bilbo? I have never met anyone like you in all my life.
Bilbo closed his eyes, opened them. He slid his trembling fingers around the cool handle of the flyblade in his trouser-pocket, drew it out, measured the bearings of his wrist like he had done every day for months, just like Nori and the others had taught him. He watched the goblin loom, watched Thorin fail to counter a blow in time. Watched him start to fall.
If more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merrier place.
He let the knife fly.
Thorin cried out, a roar of anguish, and Bilbo’s heart was frozen solid in his chest, a thin film over a gushing, rushing stream, a waterfall, that was bursting, bursting —
The orc stumbled, reached a confused hand up to feel for the blade embedded in the very centre of his temple; it took his fingers a couple of attempts to reach their mark. He turned to the side groggily to fix a menacing growl on whatever culprit had dared to strike him, with his teeth like slashes, the green-red pits of his eyes.
But of course, there was nobody there.
Bilbo drew again, threw again. His aim was worse, the second time, but it struck true nevertheless, below Bolg’s collarbone, and he staggered backward, roaring out a scream that curdled the blood so completely it almost sent Bilbo to his knees right there in the blood-soaked dirt.
(Even then, however, Bilbo could not help but pity him, this Bolg fellow. And he could not help but detest the fact it was his hand causing this pain.)
He could not see Bilbo, but he’d discovered the trajectory of the knives, now, and his face screwed up in a foul hatred, snarling, the grunts misting from his nostrils in the cold. He took one step, and another, teeth bared for a roar, that metal-sheathed arm lifting, poised for attack —
Bilbo deftly flicked his third knife just as one last bellow sounded out behind him, cleaving the air over the din of the battle, and the sound was so mighty there was only one possible answer to where it had come from.
The blade struck him dead-centre in his pasty forehead, and had Bilbo not been so simultaneously weary and wound-up in a panic he would have cried aloud; Bolg made a horrific gurgling noise, stumbled, and then his head with its great blasted knife stuck between the eyes toppled to the ground rather separate from his body, and behind him stood Thorin Oakenshield, his eyes so wild they were almost black, almost white, Orcrist clutched in a single hand.
Thorin fell to his knees and murmured something in Khuzdûl, one arm held tightly to his heaving chest, staring at the empty space where Bilbo stood rooted to the ground.
Cries from afar began to trickle through the white noise in Bilbo’s ears, but they did not sound like those of grief, and he looked up, squinting in the grey glare of the clouds.
The Eagles had come.
“Let me see him, let me see him!”
Lifelong friendship or not, Bilbo was going to find a ladder and climb atop it just so he could smack that merry facade right off Gandalf the Grey’s smiling face if he did not move out of the bleeding way of the door right this very minute.
”Bilbo,” Gandalf said, the placating calm in his voice so very clear and condescending, and Bilbo was seconds away from blowing another of his dwindling fuses, “it has hardly been any time at all since the battle ended. Thorin is quite alright; he has been tended to, and is mending, I assure you. The Elves have left him alone to look after others in need —“
”I could not give a single sod whether they’re nursemaiding him or not, I want to see him! I need to —“ he swallowed, “I must look with my own eyes. There is nothing else for it.”
“This is a tent of healing, and fortunately or not, you are not injured, my dear fellow.”
Bilbo’s eyes narrowed to needle-points. He was going to wreak havoc, very soon, and all the armies in the North were not going to be able to stop him.
“Gandalf, I swear to every power underneath the Sun and above it —”
With one last shrewd look, the wizard stepped aside and drew the flap of the tent entryway back, and Bilbo stumbled through in a single heartbeat. His mind felt like pumice-stones, like quicksand, blind flashes of panic like lightning across the sky.
It was empty but for one — the King warranted privacy, he supposed, and it was a small tent, regardless — and its single occupant was awake, and alive, and looking right at Bilbo. They each were pinned, for a moment, eyes wide and with purple-grey bags likely halfway down their cheeks in exhaustion.
Bilbo broke their eye contact and looked up and down Thorin’s half-unclothed body, taking account of everything he could see. Bits of him were bandaged, or covered by blankets, and there was a small section of matted blood in his hair, but he seemed — he seemed all right.
Bruised, likely fractured all over in places, but mendable, all mendable, all survivable, and the thought was a burst of sunlight in the dawn.
Thorin leant up from underneath the blankets as Bilbo sat down on the bedroll, entirely aware that his breathing was coming a little fast. They couldn’t quite seem to stop staring at each other. Bilbo’s brain had fallen entirely out of his head and was only calling out the words alive alive alive, beating him over the back with it, and he could not concentrate on a single other thing. Thorin lowered his eyes, then brought them back up; so tempered. He spoke.
”You are alright?”
His voice was croaky, less a baritone than a deep-forest murmur, and Bilbo could seem to do nothing but nod.
”Right as rain. No orc could catch me, you know.”
Thorin smiled softly, only the very corners of his mouth pulling themselves upwards. ”I do not doubt it,” he said. There was silence as they looked over each other, seemingly unable to do anything else, and then Thorin spoke again, his voice low.
“It was you, Master Baggins. Wasn’t it?”
Bilbo blinked once, sitting up quite straight, and then said in a faltering voice, “Indeed.”
Thorin breathed out deeply and nodded, as if this had confirmed some suspicion he’d had of Bilbo. “How — ?”
“Oh, I don’t think it’ll be much longer now. You’ll find out very soon, I’m sure.”
Thorin opened his mouth and tried to sit up further but only groaned as something in his side twinged and he let himself fall back on one elbow, catching his breath. He seemed to be favouring his right side; the injury must have been in a left rib, or somewhere or other, but he was still smiling that infinitesimal smile.
Bilbo squinted.
It wasn’t just him, he realised. Thorin truly did look a little lopsided, and he was still holding one of his arms rather close to his body, pushing himself up again to sitting with only the right and trying to pretend as if the grunts of pain were not coming from him.
Bandages covered the other arm, the left one, from halfway down the forearm all the way to the end, and they’d been wrapped so thick they could have passed for an animal’s hide if one only glanced by them. The very end of the gauze was flushed a dulled scarlet from the wound, the colour of blood blurring pinkish in water. It was wrapped so awfully neat and tiny, Bilbo wondered how in the world Thorin had any feeling left in his —
His hand.
Thorin grimaced rather wryly, and inclined his head, letting his gaze fall. Bilbo’s eyes followed, and together they both looked down at what had once been the hand that held the oaken shield; what was now nothing more than a stump, murky and ragged still with a steady stream of blood.
Bilbo felt every last inch of his own drain out of his face.
“Oh, Thorin. Oh, why of all the —“
You couldn’t have been a second quicker, could you! Training and training with Nori and Dwalin and every other dwarf you could guilt into it and still you were too slow, what in all the lands of Middle-Earth would your mother think, you absolute —
“It’s alright, Master Burglar.”
There was a scratchy pressure on his forearm, and when Bilbo looked it was the arm with the missing hand; Thorin’s face was tightened in pain, but he set his jaw and his wide eyes stubbornly on Bilbo. He’d probably forgotten it wasn’t there, wasn’t used to it. Bilbo felt a hurtling stab of empathy.
”I do not mind,” Thorin said quietly. “I do not care. Truly. I am sure I would have, in some other circumstance, but it is not this one.”
Bilbo stared at him, his eyes feeling stretched to dinner-plates in his face. He could not seem to find the words to speak. Could not think of one single thing to say. His eyes had gone all misty, and Thorin frowned.
”Why is it you are so sad? Better this and all of you still alive. Far better. Master Baggins.” He shifted a little again, grunting in pain, and Bilbo pressed an exasperatedly-distressed hand against his chest to force him back down onto his elbows once more. “You of all people must know that.”
Bilbo’s cheeks were muddling with the effort he was having to exert not to let the tears in his eyes fall, and he raised them to the ceiling of the tent in desperation, pressing the heel of one hand to the underneath of his eye and laughing a little desperately, the sound wet. The tips of his ears flushed in shame and ruddy joy.
“Oh, when did you grow a brain inside that head!” he cried, and Thorin breathed out a laugh, still too injured to let there be any force behind it. He forced himself up from his elbows once more with his remaining hand, grimacing but not letting a sound escape this time, and Bilbo glared at him.
“You’re right, of course,” he snapped at the infuriating individual before him. “Ignore me, won’t you? I’m simply losing it, I think.”
Bilbo shifted his body so he was facing the tent wall rather than Thorin, sitting side-saddle on the bedroll. His hands were wringing themselves between each other, and he ducked his head, suddenly entirely unable to conceal his trace of a smile.
He looked back to Thorin watching him. Alive. Alive. Alive.
“You are all right. That is all I care about. And that has been more than any Baggins deserves.”
”It is thanks to you,” Thorin said, very quietly, the sound so low it wouldn’t have been audible had they not been alone in the quiet, the very deepest undertones of music.
A funny noise came out of Bilbo's mouth without meaning to, then, a aborted little whimper that seemed something between a laugh and a long-choked-back sob, and quite without thinking he reached out, grasped Thorin softly by the back of his neck, and pulled him forward until at last their foreheads were touching.
Thorin exhaled deeply, his breath steady and warm on Bilbo's face, and he could almost hear Thorin’s slight smile in the creak of his teeth. Neither of them said a word. Neither of them opened their eyes.
Very, very gently, Bilbo drew his hand from the base of Thorin’s neck and around to tuck a long tendril of hair behind his ear, his fingers so tenderly soft and tangling in Thorin’s hair. He felt like Thorin was made of crystal, and so unreal in his fingers that he was almost scared to touch him. Thorin responded by warmly cupping the back of Bilbo’s bedraggled head, the way he had all those months ago, far away in the West, and pushing their foreheads more firmly together. He seemed to hum very quietly, and Bilbo could feel the gentle rumble of it under his skin, his pulse thudding a steady, steady rhythm in his veins.
Tears began to drip down his nose and fell hot against Thorin’s cheeks as they sat there in the quiet, the only two people alone in the tent, or maybe in all the world, the press of their foreheads an anchor that tethered them at long last to one another, that threaded them until they were bound.
And, just this once — wouldn’t you know it? — Bilbo let them fall.
Notes:
we’re out of the woods now :]
i’ve been working on the final two chapters so the next one should definitely be up faster than this one was, and my goal is to HOPEFULLY have the entire thing posted by the end of 2024 (we’re so close yall i’m going to fucking bawl my eyes out when i finish this fic)
also, just out of curiosity (and i really can’t make any promises LOL i have saddled myself with so many wips for different fandoms it’s not even funny): would anybody be interested in reading a samfro au if i wrote one? i have an idea simmering and i’m debating whether to write it or not — it wouldn’t be as long as this i’m envisioning more of a long oneshot but! thoughts?
i hope you all enjoyed and my twitter is here! (and thank you to my bff moonyism for betaing this one)
also shoutout to japan for lending the concept of origami i’m sorry for making bilbo baggins steal it
Chapter 10: from now on
Notes:
happy belated birthday to bilbo and frodo my little loves <3
some quick disclaimers:
a) i have borrowed dwalin’s mentioned injury from sansûkh because i love sansûkh and continuity, and i will also be borrowing gloin’s wife’s name in the next chapter, and
b) time travel aus are my LIFEBLOOD and i crave thorough reveals in them like nothing else so bilbo is going to be quite extensive in his storytelling in this chapter bc that’s what he tends to do! just thought i should forewarn that he will be explaining the plot of lotr in quite a lot of detail at various points in case that bores anyone or seems like bad storytelling on my part. it’s a little cheesy also but they’ve earned it
title taken from the song “from now on” from the greatest showman
okay let’s fucking go
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
“When are you going to tell us, then, Bilbo?”
“I beg your pardon?”
Presently, it was the kind of time of day where it could have been classed as any time, when the sky had just opened from darker lilac to palest cornflower-blue, and all fifteen members of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield had scattered themselves about inside the healer’s tent in such a way that Bilbo had started to wonder whether they were ever going to extract themselves from one another at all.
Not all of them had escaped the dreadful battle unscathed. Half of Dwalin’s face was wrapped up in a cloth, rusty-brown with how much it had bled already, and Bilbo’d heard several Elves discussing the dire outlook of his eye while Dwalin grumbled like a brewing geyser below them. Gloin’s beard was bloodied, and Ori could barely keep his eyes open; the band of his slingshot had snapped and lay in a dismal little puddle beside him on his bedroll. Nori was groaning very splendidly in the corner about a bruised set of ribs, and Dori was clucking his tongue above him, saying things like Yes, yes, we’ve all heard it already, you ruddy imbecile.
There was also Kili, who lay on the roll two over from his uncle’s where Bilbo still was perched, his leg propped on a small stack of sandbags and the joint of his knee looking as if somebody had taken a cheese-grater right to the skin. It was Kili who’d spoken, and he was sporting a grin far cheekier than Bilbo thought his current situation should have permitted. He only raised a single eyebrow.
“About the first quest. Like your stories,” Kili elaborated. “Tell us what it was like, what you thought of all of us. What happened after… after.”
“You are modest, Bilbo,” said Gandalf, then, from where he was tucked away in the very furthest corner of the tent, watching them with a strangely sentimental look in his eye. “However, my friend, your way with words is quite beautiful, and I do think we would all dearly love to hear it.”
“You told us you would once it was over, did you not?” Balin said then, smiling. “What better time than now?”
Bilbo looked around at them all in the tent, at his dwarves, bandaged and bruised and living and breathing, and at the very last moment met Thorin’s ever-steady blue eyes resting softly on him, always on him.
“Tell us, Master Baggins,” the rumble came, low and gentle.
Bilbo sighed.
“Very well,” he said. “But I must tell you, this will not be like my other stories. I am going to try and speak as truthfully as I can manage, and it is close to my heart beyond anything else, so you will — well, you will have to forgive me.”
They bunched around him in a cluttered circle, on makeshift beds piled together in the tent and all facing Bilbo where he was sat beside Thorin’s legs at the base of his roll. It was more of an oblong than a circle, really; Kili had been expressly forbidden by Oin from getting out of bed under any circumstances whatsoever short of a second goblin-raid, so they expanded themselves instead to scoop him into the fray.
Bilbo cleared his throat very importantly, feeling suddenly incredibly nervous at the thought of doing something he’d had to remind himself not to do their whole journey to Erebor. “Oh, it’s so infuriating to have to straighten all this out into a neat line! Are you quite sure I need to tell you?”
You’re stalling, Bilbo Baggins.
He was.
He bit down, amid the jeers, and let out a cool breath. And then he began.
“All — all right. Well, first I must tell you all that I… well, I have something of a secret, and it is quite important to the story.” Bilbo looked at the floor, or perhaps the bedcovers; he couldn’t much tell, now. His eyes were blurring. This really was not going to be easy. “Very important to the story.”
He touched at the little pocket of his jacket and stared off into the distant nothing, feeling suddenly entirely sick, hoping that this would be the very last time he would have to feel for the blasted Ring, that he would never find anything in that godforsaken pocket ever again.
He’d have it stitched up, he resolved. Or torn off, maybe. Left pockets were for silly old fools who liked to tempt fate and lose.
“As I said,” Bilbo reminded them, “it has been eighty-odd years since it first happened, but our journey was much the same to begin with, though I was far more unprepared and inexperienced, so none of you initially thought overmuch of me. We encountered all of the same things. The Shire, the rain, the trolls, the Elves. But once we reached the Misty Mountains we hit a snag, and all of you were taken prisoner in Goblintown when we sheltered from the storm.
“I was not taken. I fell quite out of sight, instead, and I found something, both this time and the last — that’s the reason I was so insistent on turning back,” Bilbo said, looking briefly and guiltily at an owl-eyed Bofur. “It is a… trinket of sorts. A ring. A plain gold one.”
Bilbo closed his eyes and exhaled, acknowledged the ceaseless hammering of his own heart, and then pulled the Ring out into the light, resting it on the flat of his palm.
He detested the sight of it, as if a bloody, rusted knife was lying in his hand, but Bilbo no longer feared touching it with his bare skin — not after he’d been able to wear it once more and take it off. It had become truly and utterly meaningless to him, and he could not wait until he was rid of it permanently.
“It doesn’t look like much, but among other things it has the power to make the wearer invisible. No, I will not put it on,” he said, when he saw Kili leaning forward on his elbows in wonder, and Dwalin and Dori eyeing the thing skeptically, though Thorin was gazing at him with such an inscrutable expression that Bilbo could not tell what he was thinking at all.
He swallowed.
“I have sworn that I will not ever wear it again, but I promise you with everything I am, everything I am, that I am telling the truth.”
Bilbo told them of how with it he’d snuck into places and fought spiders, and named his little sword, and broken them out of the Woodland cells and crept up on a dragon. How he’d conspired on the journey in Laketown without them and brought Bard into the fold once more with black bow and arrow in hand. How they had spared the Long Lake from burning, and how Bilbo had lured Smaug away to line up the shot with the use of the Ring.
He pushed past the worst of it fast.
“I have told all and sundry the specifics of what happened in the battle, as you… as you know.” He steadied himself for a moment, not yet willing to watch their faces. “Dain was crowned. They held the funerals. And I went home with the well-wishes of lifelong friends tucked into my pockets.”
Bilbo ducked his head properly then, too bashful to smile at them with the full force of his fondness, though no doubt his dwarves were entirely unsurprised by now at either the extent of his eccentricities or the sheer size of his heart.
“I lived alone in Bag End as I always had, after that,” he said, “though of course they all thought I was mad as a bat, and that I had gone off stealing from trolls. A few of you came to visit me over the years, and every time it brought peace to my weary old heart. You were my friends for the rest of my days no matter how far our distance. And of course, there was Frodo.
“After a long while, after I’d left the Shire for good and settled in with the Elves, there was a gathering of people in Elrond’s halls to hold counsel against the coming darkness.” A sort of shadow fell as he spoke of it, blanketing the cheeriness of the tent, and Bilbo tried his best to let go of the guilt coiling vine-like within him for asking what he was about to ask. If he’d raised the question in the Shire, he would have been fairly slapped with a crowd of nothing but gawking faces, wondering if he was perhaps speaking in tongues; they wouldn’t have had the faintest, foggiest clue. But dwarves had cause to know, and cause to know the danger.
“You know of the Enemy? The Dark Lord Sauron?” he forced out finally. He was met with nods, and continued on. “Do you know of his Rings of Power?”
“Yes.”
Thorin. Of course. His father had worn it, hadn’t he? Bilbo could have stood up and turned around and kicked himself to kingdom come for his tactlessness, but instead he only huffed out a little grunt and shifted on Thorin’s bedroll and pushed on.
“Yes, well, the Elves have three, and you dwarves had seven, and the Men had nine, but there was also the One, worn by the Enemy himself, and it held power over all others, over all of Middle-Earth. All would fall to ruin and horror if he were to regain it. There would be nothing left. Nothing at all.”
He locked eyes with each of them and smiled crookedly. If this was the last of the harsh truths he must deliver, he would deliver it head-on.
“I wonder if any of you have put it together yet.” Bilbo felt for the Ring one more time with a thumb, resting so unnassumingly in the palm of his hand, and watched the pale golden sheen of it for a moment longer before his eyes flicked upward again to his rapt audience.
A deep sense of foreboding lay over all of them, so potent as to be nearly unbearable, and many of his friends looked as if they did not want him to continue on. They’d begun to realise how very dire the story was. The guilt tightened around his middle.
But he had warned them. And it was almost done, now.
Bilbo opened his mouth to recite the inscription he knew lay on the Ring, but his voice had stuck fast in his throat, and he found he couldn’t speak. He frowned, shook himself, and then tried again, fruitlessly. No such luck.
Oh, this was excruciating. Bilbo turned rather frantically to the corner of the room and stared desperately at the wizard.
“It is written in Black Speech. I — Gandalf —”
“If I am correct,” Gandalf said slowly, fixing him with a look far more complex than merely pity, “the inscription reads,
One Ring to rule them all,
One Ring to find them.
One Ring to bring them all
And in the darkness, bind them.”
His voice was dark and grave, and it was as if clouds crept across the roof of the tent when he spoke the words, blackening the walls and brushing scorch-marks up the sides and releasing a haze of smog into the air. Bilbo’s throat was the slightest bit croaky when he spoke again.
“This ring.” He drew his eyes back to face them. “This is the One.”
His dwarves all looked as though they’d crumbled inward, or outward, or simply all over the place; they looked vaguely sick, wrath and worry and defiant shock all sloshing together to create a single-minded hatred for what they knew now was far, far more than simply just his little magic ring.
“A company was chosen from within that council,” Bilbo kept on stubbornly, “to bear the Ring to Mordor so that it could be destroyed in the fires of Orodruin. Four hobbits, two Men, one Elf, one dwarf. And Gandalf, of course.” And he smiled at the words, grimly, but fondly, even despite the subject matter they’d followed, even despite the manner in which he’d said them. “Two of the hobbits were my cousins in some way or another, and one was the child of a dear friend. The other was my nephew. My Frodo. He was — he —“ Bilbo’s voice broke. “He was the Ringbearer.”
He could not say more than that. He’d put it to rest, now, anyhow. He would not make excuses they would not understand; he no longer needed to.
(He made a note in his mind to begin the sourcing of some quality peony seedlings at once.)
“Also in this Fellowship were the Three Hunters, whom you know from my stories,” Bilbo said, “and who you have all met, in one way or another — though they will not become so for another eighty years, if this life plays out in the same way, which I dearly hope it will not. I do not know if any of you saw him, but there was a child in Rivendell while we were there. He is the Man in the story, though as of right now he does not know it yet; as we speak, his name is Estel, but when I knew him in his prime, he was Aragorn son of Arathorn, and the rightful king of Gondor. The Elf you know in passing, for we saw him in Mirkwood, and he fought in the battle alongside us. His name is Legolas Thranduilion, son of the Elvenking.”
“And the dwarf?” Kili queried rather impatiently.
Ah. That. Bilbo felt a most peculiar expression pass across his face, as if a grimace had wiggled its way into a grin. He was only the messenger of such information, after all, though he doubted they’d remember that when he uttered his next words. Perhaps he should call one of the Elven healers back in before delivering such news — Gloin was rather liable to faint, after all. Medical attention on hand might become very quickly necessary.
The Company were all on tenterhooks, crouching closer like a cluster of fauntlings and blinking wide eyes at him, and Bilbo chuckled wryly, his eyelids creasing at the corners.
“Oh, I’m quite sure you’re all familiar with his name,” he mused. “A mighty warrior, he is, in the latter-most days. Truly, for all the years I have lived, there has been no dwarf more renowned among the fickle worlds of Men and Elves than Gimli son of Gloin.”
“Gimli!”
Bless his dear old heart, Gloin was up on his feet and storming up a gale before he’d closed his mouth again, his hands clutching his cheeks like some silly damsel in a tale, and Bilbo had to very hastily stifle his laughter, turning it into an earnestly-performed cough when several pairs of accusing eyes were shot at him.
Oh, surely he couldn’t be blamed all that much, though; really, it was quite ridiculous.
“An Elf-lover, oh, what did I do wrong, how in bloody Mahal’s name have I failed him so utterly!” Gloin cried. “What is his mother going to say! She’ll have my head — Kili, Nori, stop laughing!” He looked as if he would start weeping, his cheeks splotched a brilliant scarlet beneath his own fingers scrabbling at them. “Oh, Gimli!”
“He’s not here, you buffoon!” Bofur called out, clutching his stomach with one hand and his hat with the other. Gloin’s face reddened even further.
“And lucky for him! Oh, I’ll tie that boy’s beard in knots and see how he feels then!”
“I know it will displease you beyond words to hear it,” Bilbo chipped in cheerfully amidst the chaos, “and I never had the chance to see them in person, but I have heard that there is not a friendship in all the world like that of Legolas and Gimli.”
Gloin’s face turned rapidly entirely purple, and in a rather spectacular finale to all the dramatics, he fell to his knees right there on the tent floor with his fingers in his hair and cried out to the sky as if his maker might hear him and take some sort of pity. Bilbo couldn’t help it. He burst out laughing.
It took rather a long time to calm everybody down after such a revelation, and Bilbo almost would’ve regretted that he’d said anything at all but for the chuckle he knew he would get from the memory for as long as he lived.
Eventually, though, they carried on.
“You all fought, of course. Can’t leave a situation alone to save your lives, can you? There were many battles and fronts and skirmishes that broke out all over Middle-Earth, in fact,” Bilbo explained, “though I did not see a single one, tucked away as I was in my cozy little room in Elrond’s house with my mind decaying out my ears.” He smiled sadly, and bent his head. “But what I know of it is that they approached you for information. You protected me stoutly. They made war. So really, it was my fault you were besieged, and you lost your king. Another of your kings.”
There was a coarsely familiar voice that interrupted, then, as always. Poking his nose where Bilbo had not asked for it to be.
(Though, Bilbo Baggins could pretend all he liked that it hadn’t stroked a lovely shade of pink up his neck and across the apples of his cheeks. It didn’t, of course, convince anybody.)
“He would have been proud to stand alongside you,” Thorin said quietly, speaking for almost the first time since the whole tale had begun. “It is our highest honour, Master Baggins.”
They made eye contact, though Bilbo had to look quickly away.
“Well, anyhow, all that business was cleared up, and the Nine Walkers succeeded in their task, and the Ring was no more. It was a few years after that when Elrond and all his clan began to make preparations to depart, in the way that Elves do, and they asked me if I would like to accompany them. And I decided that I did, rather.
“I did it too, you know. I sailed West, with the Elves, and with Frodo. Never to see the shores or streams of Middle-Earth again. And then, wouldn’t you know it,” Bilbo said, smiling, his rosy cheeks aching, in fact, from how hard he beamed then, “I found myself in Bag End, didn’t I, and there were dwarves knocking at my door.” He lifted his head, and peered round at all his battered, beloved friends, all hale if not quite whole, and had to look very quickly away before the strength of the affection on their faces made him quite unfit for public appearance and he collapsed at once into tears.
All in all, perhaps every emotion ever come to pass under the Sun blew its way through the little tent in which the Company were assembled on that early morning after the Battle of Five Armies. And at the end of Bilbo’s story, when his voice was hoarse and his throat stung, each of his dwarves, his dear friends, Balin and Dwalin, Oin and Gloin, Ori, Nori and Dori, Bifur, Bofur and Bombur, Fili and Kili, and Thorin, Thorin, Thorin, rose to give him once more the forehead-touches of Laketown, tender as trees and firm as mountains. And Bilbo met every one with all the giddy glory in his heart.
Piecing Erebor back together, however, was somehow not very much like Bilbo had imagined it in his head.
It was extremely slow-going. The dwarves counted their dead and laid each of them to rest in caverns deep below the Mountain, the highest honour they could have bestowed upon the slain, and those whose families wished to return them to their home in the Iron Hills were carefully laid in carts, blankets wrapped around their bodies to keep them safe from the chill.
There were beds to clean, wounds to heal; there was rubble in the corridors leading to the many hundreds of rooms strewn about the Mountain, lying scattered across the desolate land all around them, and Bilbo knew the dwarves still did not dare venture further into the city for fear of finding things far worse than lost treasure or broken belongings. There were, after all, many more dead in the Lonely Mountain than just those of the battle to count.
The task now was for them to begin to rebuild, but Erebor did not have the numbers to properly begin the immense task before them, nor did they have the strength after the grave extent of the battle. Thorin sent ravens to Ered Luin as soon as he was able, but it would be a few months yet before their brothers and sisters joined the dwarves in their homeland. Many of the Lake-men travelled back and forth from Esgaroth to help, now that they had no tragedy of their own to deal with other than lives lost in the battle. Bard, especially, could be seen traipsing here and there around the base of the Mountain, through the ruins of Dale, standing in the doorway of the hall full of gold with a hand brushing his beard in contemplative silence. It was, somehow, strangely bittersweet to Bilbo to have the space around them so full of others when it had for so long been only the fourteen of them.
Gloin took great joy in starting the painfully tedious task of collecting and relocating the gold, being a banker by craft. He’d assembled a small team to help him stack the coins in piles and cart them off to makeshift treasury rooms elsewhere in the Mountain, and he’d dragged a few of the Company along in order to keep them occupied — and to keep them together, Bilbo suspected, when he caught wind of it. Sometimes he sat with Ori and Fili and fondly watched them trying not to fall asleep as they scooped up piles and piles of glittering jewels.
Not once did Thorin enter the hall where the gold lay.
Bilbo did not wear rose-coloured glasses, of course. He’d seen every ugly bit of the one he loved, had hands held against him and the very real threat of violence in his face. He had watched Thorin turn into someone who ate away at others, who was corruption and destruction, and knew very well it was not a light thing to forgive.
But it had only ever made Bilbo miss him all the more, because he’d seen how different it could be when Thorin awoke. And he could not tell if this self-imposed exile of Thorin’s from the hall of his father was taken out of precaution or penance.
This didn’t mean, however, that Bilbo didn’t see Thorin.
He was confined for a short while to the healer’s tent in the aftermath of the fight, and grew increasingly grouchy the longer he was told to stay in bed by Elven healers. He grew even more incensed when his single ally in Oin only echoed the sentiment.
“Am I not even to be allowed the use of my legs?” Thorin growled, looking entirely unintimidating in his bedclothes and with the blankets drawn up around him. Bilbo politely averted his eyes and pretended not to smile. Oin deigned not to answer the question, pointedly setting his ear-horn on the table next to them with a thud and wrenching Thorin’s bandages tighter until had he not been one of the most stubborn people alive he would surely have yelped. Bilbo was delighted.
Once he was given the all-clear to re-enter Erebor, Thorin dedicated himself to gaining back all the strength he had lost from bedrest as well as to the restoration of his left arm — handlessness be damned. Soon, he’d begun to drag them all down to one of the abandoned tournament-chambers deep within the Mountain, and then he would spar with Dwalin or Fili or Kili, or Dori or Gloin or Dain, and sometimes they’d even rustle up a strained-looking Balin for a go.
The Company of Thorin Oakenshield started to spend much of their time together in the sparring chamber, now that the injured of them were no longer required in the healing tents, and with the unspoken understanding that they could not enter the Hall of Treasures as one. They’d laze about and watch the best of them run at each other with glittering swords, freshly shone and sharpened, and the weakest of them undercut each other with wiley tactics and gleeful grins. It always had poor Oin turning a brilliant purple in the face.
“Stop it, for goodness’ bloody sake, do none of you have any self-control —“
Thorin, currently mid-spar with his cousin, swept the sweaty hair back from his face with the same fingers he was still using to clutch the sword, and Bilbo could practically see the steam coming out of Oin’s ears at the sight. Thorin was breathing hard, his face flushed with exertion, and he moved his left arm in front of him to stare down at the empty space there for a moment before looking up with a determined grit.
“I must learn, Oin. The lack of a limb does not mean a fight will not come again,” he said gruffly. “And I enjoy it.”
“Oh, trust me,” Bilbo bit out drily from his perch up in the spectators’ seats, hand under his chin and a book in his lap as he pretended very resolutely that he hadn’t already been watching, “we’re all very well aware.”
He’d tried to refrain from attending these ridiculous bouts, at first, on the grounds of disinterest and also intensely-baffled concern at the fact Thorin — and Dwalin, for that matter — were so desperate to throw themselves in front of blades after they’d only just begun to heal from what had been disastrously grievous blade-inflicted injuries.
But Thorin had asked after him, after a while; gently and hesitantly, a low hope in his voice when he met Bilbo in the hall one evening. They were all sleeping in close quarters — Thorin had insisted in placing every one of them in rooms alongside the King’s, which sat far in the north of the wings of Erebor and had been for the most part unpillaged by the parasite that had infested it.
“You do not have to come. I know swordplay is not your preferred hobby, Master Baggins, but I would like it if you were there. We do not see each other as often as I’d like.”
”Such a sentimental dwarf,” Bilbo said, rolling his eyes, the embarrassed flush bright and hot on his cheeks and made all the worse when Thorin smiled that infinitesimal smile down at him.
(And the sparring really was lovely to watch. Bilbo was only one hobbit, after all. He could not be expected to uphold moral righteousness and sensibility in every single situation he happened across. And sometimes the situations he happened across involved damp and sweaty dwarves grunting and showing off and holding blades longer than half his body while their hair fell in their eyes. So sue him.)
They’d all started insisting, too, bewilderingly, that Bilbo take a braid. It’d started during one of the sparring matches, even though all Bilbo ever did to anyone else’s eyes was sit in the stands and mind his own business.
“Oh, come on, Bilbo, it’s as if you’ve been growing your hair out for it!”
“It’s the perfect length and all —“
“Just one bead, a little one, I’ll make it myself, come on —“
“I’ll not have it!”
“It is for valour, Master Baggins.”
“Oh, wasps, you are, the lot of you!”
The point was, Bilbo didn’t quite know where they now stood, he and Thorin Oakenshield, and he did not know where Thorin thought they stood. He wasn’t even sure if the thought had crossed Thorin’s mind, to be frank. They were caught in a terribly sticky stalemate, and he felt almost like a pebble being tossed around in a landslide, the sea-swept sickness of waiting excruciating.
But Thorin no longer bowed his head so deeply he could not see Bilbo. He was warm again. He would try.
And the smile he gave whenever Bilbo entered the sparring chamber, or his quarters, or his work-rooms, such as they were in the cobbled-together Mountain, was far more sacred than Bilbo had anywhere near the sort of stuff inside him to deal with. Thorin smiled like the sight of such a peculiar little hobbit soothed him, sleep-soft if only for the fact he had had no sleep. The smile was half as much in the slight pull of his mouth as in his eyes, and they would gleam like polished pearls.
It was all rather uncalled for, to be perfectly honest. Bilbo felt half-mad. Really, Thorin would have to watch the way he threw around such clear friendship towards a hobbit, else he’d be accused of inter-race favouritism and be exiled in truth by the more prickly of the Iron Hills lot.
(To the view of all others, of course, though they never spoke it, it was almost as though the two were dancing around each other, the hobbit and the dwarf, one oblivious, one yearning, both of their breaths catching when the other’s head was turned. It seemed a wonder that Bilbo Baggins could not see the way Thorin Oakenshield looked at him.)
And best of all, Bilbo could see.
Though it was still dilapidated in places, scarred and weeping, or long, long abandoned and unable to settle into the past so quickly, the way the city that lay inside the Lonely Mountain wove outward from its heart was magnificent.
This had been a city of life, sprouting forth from its roots, spreading upward through the Mountain, and as they slowly, slowly began to scrape away the worst of it, they found places that could and would begin anew. Bilbo saw the look of wonder in Thorin’s eyes when they’d venture inward, to places he’d known, to the deepest caverns still standing and the highest, loftiest rooms that had not quite been broken in the fall.
“It is grand,” he’d whisper, and Bilbo would nod.
They had not lied, his dwarves. There was nothing like to it in all the world. Erebor would soon again be grand beyond measure.
And so, the work began.
In the Mountain it continued, and Bilbo and all the rest helped Thorin and Fili and Kili carry supplies or clear debris back and forth, though Bilbo himself was sure to snit all the while at how they should still all be resting. They met with the abashedly-new King of Dale and his people frequently, and with all the lords of the Iron Hills whenever it was required.
Erebor had begun slowly to aid the poverty of Laketown crafted so cleverly by the Master, offering men and women and all kinds of people jobs wherever they could be found, housing families if it was at all a possibility in what parts of the Mountain were yet usable, and giving aid in turn to the task of rebuilding the city of Dale. Bard had put his entire back into it, and he was rarely off his feet; he frequently met with Thorin or Balin and passed their messages far afield, and there was not a day where he was not seen walking among his people, willingly offering them his time and labour.
The Master had fled, of course. Had picked up his skirts and run. And even if he had not been of the line of Girion, the people of Esgaroth would have had no other as their king but the Dragonslayer.
But the real work had begun in Bilbo’s mind when they got to work on crafting Thorin a replacement hand.
Thorin himself was determined, and bent his entire unruly brow to the task, working often into the small hours of the morning with Fili and Bifur and Bofur, scratching up designs for the replacement on spare bits of old paper — and, when they had none to spare, sometimes the walls too fell victim. Dain, for his part, was awfully smug about the whole thing, and would stroll around the Mountain nodding approvingly and roguishly calling out things like, “It seems the only sorts of rulers who have any sense must be missing a limb, then! I’m so glad you finally realised it, Oakenshield, you old coot, I could’ve told you a century ago!”
If Bilbo ever tiptoed around late at night and happened to find himself peeking through certain doorways, he would often see the two sitting together and stooped over a table, Dain sketching designs while Thorin quietly dictated the ideas to him. Every so often, Dain would murmur back and turn to Thorin with a serious or questioning expression, and Thorin would tilt his head a tad and tap at the page where he thought they needed adjustment. Bilbo’s heart always softened entirely to slush at this.
Dain Ironfoot had gone to war for a hobbit he had met only briefly, only once, when he’d likely lost far more in the same battle that had split Bilbo’s life in two halves. He had staked the Mountain and his own life on his people’s kinship with Bilbo Baggins in the War of the Ring. He’d been King Under the Mountain in another life, until the very last breath.
So Bilbo could learn to get on rather well with the Lord of the Iron Hills, he thought. And there were not many dwarves that had earned from him a higher level of respect.
It was fascinating, too, to watch the dwarves work. Bilbo knew that they were renowned for their invention, for breathing life into their creations from the earth; that their technological advancements had been heralded by the Elves who most loved those things in the elder days of their friendship. But he had never before with his own eyes gotten to see it. Thorin worked with a quiet focus that was almost startling to see. He’d murmur in a low voice to the others, Dain and the toymakers and his nephew, the end of the graphite he drew with held between his lips as he thought with a mighty frown on his face.
There was also rather a lot of arguing about epithets. Which Bilbo thought was ridiculous.
“You can’t be Ironhand! You’ll steal all of my thunder, you great idiot! Make it from something else, what about Oakenfist, that was right there —“
Eventually, however, after far too many late nights of work, they were done.
Bifur and Bofur took the designs and painstakingly fashioned Thorin a wooden hand from the sparse few oak trees that grew by the banks of the River Running, at the point where its mouth spilled out into the Long Lake. They brought it to him to fit it at once.
”It’s magnificent, Bofur,” Bilbo said in astonishment when he saw it, running a hand over the smooth gleam of the fresh polish on the wood, slipping his fingers idly between Thorin’s new ones. “It looks just like the real thing. I’ve never seen anything like it.”
He could see the segments of each knuckle, the way they slotted together, round and glossy. There was a cleft in the palm just as on a flesh-and-bone hand, and Bilbo drew the tip of his index finger across it delicately; the oak felt smooth as marble, but sturdy beneath his touch. He swiped a thumb across it, marvelling, then looked up and pulled his hands cleanly away when he saw Thorin staring utterly silent and unreadable back at him. His eyes were gleaming moon-like in the dark.
Bifur took the hand and showed Thorin how to put it on himself, how he would need to wrap his arm in cloth before he wore it, how if he pressed a lever at the base of the wrist he could make the fingers close. They had thought of everything, even things Bilbo foolishly hadn’t realised needed to be thought of, and Bofur spent rather a lot time declaring all of his plans to fashion an attachment that instead of bearing a hand would hold a smithing-tool, so Thorin would lose no work. Bilbo listened to every bit of it with his jaw entirely, embarrassingly agape.
He couldn’t help it. It was utterly, utterly magic.
“Just a big toy, isn’t it? Easy as pie,” Bofur said when he saw Bilbo looking, a hearty grin on his face. “The best of toys for our best of kings.”
But it was only because Bilbo was already looking that he did not miss the way Thorin’s jaw clenched.
It soon became clear, after that. Bilbo didn’t have the faintest idea how he hadn’t seen it before, particularly when he prided himself on having so much practice at spotting it.
There was something wrong.
It was par for the course, of course. The story of his life with this ridiculous dwarf, Bilbo supposed, huffing out a sigh. Really, it was enough to turn all the hair on one‘s head white: he should check a mirror soon, just to make sure, or he’d be caught unawares.
Thorin had donned the replacement hand, and it had been brilliant, for a while. Bifur and Bofur were excitedly working on more attachments that were less hand-shaped, and Bofur had even told Bilbo in confidence that he was one day hoping to craft a new shield which could be attached to Thorin’s wrist and used in battle, if ever more battle came.
It became obvious quite quickly, however, that it pained Thorin to wear it.
Not that Thorin ever willingly spoke of the oak hand causing him pain. Chafing was all he’d offhandedly said. I will get used to it. Bilbo had needed to pester and needle the living daylights out of him and had worked the both of them up into quite a strop and a row by the time Thorin had shouted that of course his hand and wrist were aching.
Bilbo had pushed him out the door with explicit instructions to either speak to Oin or die trying and slammed it in his face while Thorin glowered black as night. Then he’d paced in a single circle around and around the room for hours, hands behind his back and muttering unmentionable curses at the floor until he’d exhausted himself and had to retire to bed early.
That fool. He’s learned nothing. He will not accept help, will not accept anything from you at all, and yet here you are, Bilbo Baggins, aren’t you, still pushing him onward anyway!
It was only when Oin had pulled Bilbo aside and explained it to him the next day that he properly understood.
“He will feel it for long years, Bilbo. He will feel a hand he cannot flex, and the blade passing through it as if a phantom is haunting him. It’s incredibly common, and not to be helped, unfortunately. It’s just the way it is.”
He’d found Thorin the next day and very stubbornly stared at the space beside his head instead of right at him as he apologised.
“I have a sharp tongue, you know,” Bilbo said, “and it has gotten me into far too much trouble for my own good. I shouldn’t have turned it on you, especially not over something that is hurting you. You do not have to share with me anything of your injury, Thorin. Please don’t think you do. I shall very well keep my mouth shut next time!”
Then Bilbo wrenched his eyes to Thorin’s and forced himself to keep them there, even if it was infuriating how excellent Thorin was at hiding his thoughts in his own head. Bilbo conjured instead the image of his mother. Don’t cower, my darling. It’s not at all polite.
“Please just tell me if you are hurting,” he said softly, “and I will try to be gentle.”
Thorin did not move for a long time, standing halted in the corridor, looking down the slope of his nose at Bilbo and not even having the decency to give a hint as to what he thought of Bilbo’s measly little apology.
Then, all at once, he walked forwards and clasped a hand against Bilbo’s shoulder.
“You are gentle enough, Master Baggins. I will not break.”
The hand slid down his arm, and then was gone, and Bilbo was left standing there in its wake having not the faintest idea what he was supposed to do with it.
He’d thought it was that, for a little while. That adjustment to the new hand was causing Thorin more grief than he had predicted, and that that was what was ailing him. That it was only a phantom ache.
But the longer Bilbo went on, and the more he watched, the sooner he realised it wasn’t that. It wasn’t that at all.
“Thorin.”
There was a grunt. They were sat at the grand table in the room Thorin had chosen to nestle his work in, citing it after a while as his study. He had not returned to his grandfather’s rooms since the dragon-sickness, and Bilbo hadn’t had the heart in him to ask Thorin why.
It was a simple space: likely an old inner council chamber, only containing the table circled by littered-about chairs and a roaring fireplace in the corner. Thorin was poring over an outrageous smattering of papers with another page half-crushed in his wooden hand, and his silhouette struck the lantern-light like a blot from a pen. He was in the thick of it, Bilbo assumed, and had only half-heard him speak at all. Either that or he was already halfway to sleep.
”Thorin,” Bilbo said again, his voice still breeze-soft. Thorin didn’t stir.
It had become a daily ritual, in the smallest hours of the evening, for Bilbo to knock very gently and let the door creak open, and to slip in until he was pulling back the chair closest to Thorin and seated by his side as he worked slowly and meticulously.
The very first time, Bilbo had been utterly unable to sleep, in his designated rooms in the royal wing. They were all sleeping close by one another, of course; but any quarters were far from close when you had practically been sleeping inside one another’s pockets for the better part of half a year. He lay in the stone room, lantern sinking burnt-butter low, only the wisp of a flame still petering on as his ever-rioting mind would not cease either its thought or its over-thought. He’d lay there for what felt like hours with his eyes wide open, feeling as if he were frozen in a dream.
It was far too quiet. Bilbo could not stomach it. He hopped out of bed with cold feet on the floor and slipped into the hallway, and when he pushed open the door of the study, a dull amber glow leaking out from behind the cracks, Thorin had looked surprised, but the exhaustion cloaked all over him had coated it too deeply to stick.
”What are you doing awake?”
Bilbo made no answer and sank down into the chair, tucking one knee up beneath him. He wished he had a blanket of some sort to wrap around himself, in the flickering darkness; some scrap of anything would be sorely comfortable about now.
”I believe I’m sitting with you.”
Thorin had smiled very slightly and very wearily; there were still faint purple-and-brown bruises beneath his eyes that only time would clear, and time was something that Bilbo was not sure Thorin had too much of to spare now that he was King Under the Mountain.
“To do what?” he had asked.
What else?
“I’ve a mind to write down my story,” Bilbo’d said softly, the familiarity of the words a comfort and a plunge into the deep in equal measure. “The details are so fresh in my mind that I think it will turn out even better this time.”
It was unimaginably quiet now, however, only the faintest crackles of the fire in the corner spitting out into the warm silence.
“Thorin.”
Thorin hummed, a low sound in the back of his throat, and finally looked up at Bilbo, who swallowed.
“Why is it you write so carefully?” It hadn’t been the question he’d meant to ask, but the words had poured forth, now, so it would have to make do.
“Smithing requires both hands, and I can use both well enough,” Thorin replied slowly. “But I scribe with my left more often than not, so I must re-train myself.”
Ah. Bilbo had thought since Thorin wielded his sword with his right hand, that it would have been his dominant one. But it made no sense once he thought on it for more than a split-second, and he felt exceedingly foolish. He was Thorin Oakenshield, not Thorin Swordhand. It was one and not the other he was most proficient with.
“Oh, don’t be silly,” Bilbo said instead. “I’ll scribe for you.”
He slipped down into his seat, leaning over with his arms crossed on the table and the just-barely-there brush of Thorin’s shirtsleeves against his bare elbow.
“But you are writing your book,” Thorin said, frowning at him. His voice was quiet, his hair hanging long and loose on either side, the firelight filtering in fragments through the strands. It was entirely unbraided; Bilbo wasn’t sure why, but as it was, his mouth had become rather dry, and he tucked a few of his own tragedy of curls behind his ear.
(Perhaps… well, perhaps braids weren’t such a terrible idea, at least while he was away from Bag End and a reputable barber.
Though he’d take the thought to the grave with him, if any of them ever asked.)
“My book can wait its turn,” Bilbo decided with a nod. “Or I will train myself to write with my opposite hand, and then I can write with both at once using each half of my brain, and you can just sit back and watch.”
“Master Baggins.”
Bilbo felt his nose twitch at the name and tried to smooth it over. Really, that was needling at him too, if he was being entirely truthful, but Bilbo put it aside for now. He didn’t want to start an argument. Not when he had not the foggiest clue what time it was and the fire was so low and their voices were so soft in the quiet.
“I do not want to distract you from your work,” Thorin said. “Mine is not so important as all that. You do not owe me your time.”
Bilbo elected very pointedly to ignore the second half of the sentence, and said only, “I’d say it might be at least a little important, on account of how you are the King Under the Mountain Returned, and all that, you oaf.”
Thorin did not reply, the crack in his jaw surely splintering his teeth, but Bilbo held his own silence rather than breaking it.
There was the something-that-was-wrong again, creeping around the corner. I cannot fix it for you, my dear. I can only lend my aid.
He gathered up all his courage, then, and his wits, and whatever other what-not one seemed to require when one decided to go past one’s doorstep, and said what he’d first wanted to say.
“You haven’t been into your father’s hall.”
Thorin unravelled, shaking the hair from his face and rolling his spine upward until he was looking sidelong at Bilbo with a bebotheringly-inscrutable expression, his gaze sleepy and loose and lingering.
“I have not,” he murmured hoarsely.
Bilbo cleared his throat. “Do you suppose you will?’”
“No,” Thorin said, and his eyes had fallen from Bilbo’s face, his skin awash in tinged golden light. “I do not suppose.”
There were several more moments of silence, during which Bilbo’s eyebrows crept higher and higher on his face, inviting some form of explanation, and the great log-headed lug before him just started blankly back. Finally, Thorin sighed, and swept the oak hand back through his unbound tide of hair, brushing back over the peppery point of his widow’s peak. He looked at Bilbo for one long, relentless, incomprehensible moment, his eyes lidded by the fire, then turned away and spoke instead into the steady-warm quiet.
”If you must know, I do not want it… to tempt me.”
He looked gaunt, still, Bilbo was realising, with an unsettlingly-growing dread. Not as much — not nearly. But his eyes were hollows; he looked exhausted. He was better than before, but nowhere close to better enough. And under all that, there lay a lingering sickness, a sense that whatever had ebbed was only dormant.
Well, there was to be none of that. Bilbo opened his mouth.
“You remember what I said, don’t you?” he asked, seeking Thorin’s eyes and finding them, letting himself watch, letting Thorin watch him back, his eyes full to bursting with whatever aching, earnest sort of something it was they were always full of when they settled on Bilbo. “I know what it is like, more than anyone else living. And you know, now. What I meant.” He brushed his fingers against his pocket once, lightly, and then drew them back.
Thorin looked away, and Bilbo bit down until his jaw was clenched and his teeth hurt.
All of it was so bittersweet, even still. Pebbles in a landslide. Threads that had been tied together. Why did they have to wait so long?
He watched Thorin defiantly, wanting those fervent eyes back on him, sending him every enraged thought that had curdled in his head over every day he’d had to think them.
You’re not getting away from me so easily, Thorin Oakenshield.
You will fight it. Day by day. You will win.
But when Thorin spoke again, his voice held such a defeat that the wind was taken out of even Bilbo’s sails just a little, and he was left wondering what on Earth else they had to do to fix what he’d naively thought they already had.
Thorin’s mismatched hands lay on the table, bent softly into fists. “You must hold the faith I do not have, Master Baggins,” he said, in such a low rumble that had Bilbo been any other hobbit he could almost have pretended he hadn’t heard it.
What must I do?
Another day, perhaps a fortnight later, Balin drew Bilbo away from where he had been sitting and staring into the deepest of space in the Hall of Treasures, half-heartedly clutching a handful of silver and bronze coins in one hand and doing utterly nothing with them.
“Need something to occupy you, Bilbo?”
Bilbo flushed. Balin had a very knowing, very telling smile on his face.
“Don’t worry yourself, laddie,” he said. “I’ve got something I think you’ll like much more than carting coins for Gloin.”
They trotted away together along winding hallways and raised bridges, skirting round all the parts where the stone had been cracked or eroded away. Little groups of dwarves were already tinkering with the gaps, sitting around in groups and stroking their beards as they discussed in low voices how best to patch up all of Smaug’s scars. Many times, they would mumble in Khuzdûl only to abruptly stop when they saw Bilbo and Balin coming, and Bilbo very sternly told himself not to feel insulted by it whenever it happened. They had every right.
He wondered if far below them was where the mines of the mountain were kept. They were headed towards the southern wing of the city, he’d realised — the Mountain had begun to open up into wider and wider chambers, becoming more caverns than anything. Some had clearly been hollowed out by dragons’ wings, if the decrepit state of them was anything to go by, but some had formed naturally, and the swooping ceiling of the mountain-rock crested above them in magnificent, smooth archways. And he was probably going entirely round the bend, but all the curves reminded Bilbo the slightest bit of the roundness of a hobbit-hole.
”It’s wonderful, Balin,” Bilbo said softly, not wanting to disrupt the ancient silence of the sweeping curves of rock many times larger than he.
He must have said it a little pointedly, because Balin smiled at him and said, “Indeed, but it isn’t what I brought you here for, Bilbo. Be patient.”
After a while, a slim double doorway made of an aged grey-brown wood appeared before them at the end of the corridor, and Balin pressed one hand against it, turning back to Bilbo and winking once before he pushed the door open.
The sight within almost caused Bilbo to burst into tears.
This had once been a grand library. It was beautiful. Beautiful, and so very sad. High, intricately-carved shelves, lining each wall and trailing their way down the centre of the room, made from wood carvings of dark red and chocolate-brown and dusty mauve and smoke. But on them, instead of books, there lay only the terrible shells of their remains, as far as the eye could see.
Pages had rotted away, covers were blown off and burned, and scattered along the shelves there was ash, everywhere; Bilbo had to force down his own coughing. He walked forwards and touched a decaying book lying on the shelf closest to him, felt the warping, aged leather on the cover, opened it, and let loose a cloud of ash that was so thick as it spiralled upward it caused him to sneeze.
Bilbo turned back to Balin helplessly, every word his mind could produce dying utterly on his tongue. What words were there? This room had been a work of art, marred by horror — the same horror that they had come all the way here to bloody well fix.
Well, we shall simply have to heal its wounds, then, won’t we?
Balin was smiling at him very knowingly from the doorway. “Many of the texts in here are written in Angerthas,” he reminded Bilbo. “You won’t be able to read them.” Bilbo rolled his eyes and waved a hand.
“Oh, Balin, I don’t care.”
This was a dream. He could not possibly be awake at this minute. He had to stop himself from asking his dear friend to pinch him; it really would have been unbecoming. And he could not for the life of him stop staring around at it all, at the sweeping shelves, the creeping walls, the husks of papers and pens and stories.
(It was no Rivendell. Not by half. But it would be. And it would become so under the care of Bilbo’s own hands.)
”Oh, you must show Ori,” Bilbo cried suddenly, struck with the realisation. “Balin! You should have showed him before me!”
So the next day they were back with Ori and Thorin in tow, Bilbo babbling to the both of them all the way there about his plans for the place and nodding eagerly along with Ori when he made his own suggestions on scribing or preservation or translation. Ori gave an astonished little gasp when they finally entered the room, and Bilbo smiled in self-satisfaction. He’d known Ori would understand.
It faltered slightly, however, when moment after moment crept on without a sound from Thorin, and Bilbo turned around.
He was standing, hand still resting idly against the door and other arm down by his side, staring with a guarded expression at the far wall. At the very back of the room was a grand — albeit damaged, as everything was damaged — mural displayed along the wall, spanning almost the entire central space so there was no mistaking what it was. Bilbo’s eyes had glossed over it the day before, too enraptured by the contents of the library in front of him to recall much about the edges.
That was being proven to be a grave oversight now that he was looking at it. For it was a mural of Thror.
“He commissioned this room for my grandmother,” Thorin said in quiet explanation. His voice was low, almost inaudible, and Bilbo did not ask him to speak up, too afraid of what else he would hear in it if the sound was any clearer. “It belonged to everyone in Erebor, but most of all it belonged to her.”
Thror looked so like Thorin. He was much greyer, but his greying had begun from the same roots of hair as his grandson’s, and his nose was wide and angular and sat proudly on his face. The damage to the walls meant that he was missing half of his crown.
Thorin looked away.
His jaw was working furiously, and his eyes were wide, staring askance down at the floor; he’d let go of the door to let it swing closed and was absently clutching at the end of his wooden wrist, wringing it back and forth in his fingers. Bilbo frowned.
“You should not be ashamed of him.”
Thorin swallowed. “I can be ashamed of nothing else.”
“Thorin,” he shot back crossly, “you —“
“Do not worry yourself, Master Baggins. It is not my grandfather I am ashamed of. He was —“ Thorin swallowed again, and lifted his gaze to fix it defiantly on Bilbo, his jaw clenched rough as sandpaper.
“I looked to him as I did not look to anyone else,” he said in a gravel-thick voice. “I wished to be just like him as a boy. My younger brother Frerin always teased me for it.” He turned back to the mural and looked upon it for one more long, terrible moment. “It is funny, the way life gifts you your wishes.”
It had been an error to bring him here. Bilbo could see that. But there was nothing he could do about it now, so he decided to take a hearty stab at changing the subject of their conversation.
“If it was a gift for her,” he asked, furrowing his brow, “why’d he add a great big portrait of himself?”
Thorin’s face cleared momentarily, and he looked back at Bilbo with lighter eyes, moving a few steps closer so he came further into the room. He clasped both hands behind his back.
“To make her laugh. He was… very affectionate. Before.”
Before. They had circled back.
Bilbo held his tongue and kept his eyes very firmly on Thorin, who was staring with his chin held high at the mural of his grandfather as if it was going to leap off the wall and challenge him to a fight. A bout for their honour: who could most courageously withstand the sickness?
“He’d hate what has been done to Erebor by that beast,” Thorin said harshly then. “It would have broken his heart.”
And it was precisely then that Bilbo felt the first spark of an idea, familiar and new and lightning-bright.
A History of Erebor And the Lonely Mountain: From the Accounts Of Thorin II Son Of Thrain And As Scribed By Bilbo Baggins Of the Shire
A working title, but not too shabby for a first draft, he thought. He already had a writing project to contend with in this lifetime, after all. What was one more?
“Well,” Bilbo said, stepping closer to Thorin, close enough that they were side by side and just barely touching at the sleeves. He felt it when Thorin breathed out at his proximity, the tiny movement letting their arms brush together, the two of them standing in full view of a glimpse of the future, purveyors of the quiet. “Then there’s no choice but to build it from the ground up again, is there?”
Life, Bilbo Baggins found, almost always suggested the most fantastical of things to you on the most uneventful of days. It was practically formulaic.
There was the day he’d been caught up in a dwarvish, dragonish journey and whisked halfway across the world. The days his mother and father had been felled without any warning at all. The day he had travelled to Brandy Hall and decided to take in a little rascal of a fauntling named Frodo. The day he’d given up the One Ring and thrown a double-birthday party to boot.
Such things would happen, and Bilbo would find himself on guard in the days afterward, waiting for the next adventure to crop up out of the blue and quite without invitation. And then, life would laze about as it ever did, and he would loosen from his wound-up tightness, and soon enough he’d find himself going about his days with not a single thought for when the next story was going to catch him unawares and place him into the next chapter.
This day was no different.
Over the weeks, Balin, Thorin and Dain had amalgamated a small party of dwarves who’d volunteered to act as an advisory council to the King while their numbers in Erebor still dwindled. Some were the descendants of dwarves who had themselves fled the Mountain in Smaug’s attack and relocated to settle in the Iron Hills. Some were committed to remaining west of their home until Erebor was re-established in its entirety and able to stand on its own, and some, Bilbo suspected, were rather hoping to nose their way into other people’s business and see if they couldn’t get something out of it for themselves.
They had only met a handful of times thus far, and none as officially as this. The council had been called into one of the old advisory rooms, one of the very oldest that still stood, though it bore its fair share of signs of the battering. They were seated now around a thickly-laid, artfully-polished circular table, perhaps a round dozen of them alongside Balin, Thorin and Bilbo. Empty shelves lined one wall, and the table was so circumferentially large that Bilbo rather thought it was meant for a much greater number of dwarves than they currently had.
(But they would get there, in time.)
There’d been a seat crafted especially for the king in here, too. Bilbo’d seen it, poking his nose in when he’d heard Balin and Thorin arguing the evening before, on his way to see if he could find some supper and perhaps Dori or Bofur or Bombur to have a lazy moan about the weather with. It wasn’t quite a throne, per se, but it was far more ornate than the rest of the cluttered seating; a little larger, a little roomier, the back a little straighter. It loomed at the very centre of the table, in pride of place opposite the doorway, and Balin and Thorin were merely shadowed figures behind it.
“Get it out of here, Balin. I will not have it.”
“Thorin, I know we did not use such… self-important things in Ered Luin, but the seat is not —“
“I said get it out.”
Bilbo winced.
(Hence, something was wrong.)
The elder dwarves of the Iron Hills had requested a more formal council-meeting in order to get the ball rolling on Thorin’s kingly duties, as it were, and despite his blatant avoidance of such official things, Thorin begrudgingly agreed. They’d marked on the agenda to discuss all manner of things: trade relations, tariffs, rebuilding, living quarters, robes, ceremonies, transportation of goods and people from Ered Luin. Bilbo, for his part, had been asked to the meeting as a personal advisor to the King, and had hoped that he could meander his way through the whole thing calmly and easily.
All things considered, it was going rather poorly.
The council had spent the better part of several hours all reminding Thorin extremely pointedly of the fact he’d made commitments, that he had promised things in the taking of the Mountain he could not walk back on, of the graveness of accepting outsiders, the necessity to build themselves from the ground upward and accept no help other than from their own people, warbling out such a long list of requirements and specifications and expectations based on past historical rules from a dozen kingdoms that had all fallen into disrepair that none of them could’ve made head nor tail of it if they tried.
Arguments had only begun to truly break out in the last few minutes, however. They’d moved onto the topic of what Balin had gingerly introduced as the King’s past tendency and obligation to present his kingdom with a united front in its leadership.
In other words —
“You owe your people a consort,” said a mousy-haired, mohawked fellow named Onar; rather snootily, in Bilbo’s opinion, and he suppressed yet again the urge to scoff. “You must establish a complete kingdom, your Oakenshieldness.”
I mean, what on all the good Earth —
“Aye, there has never been a dwarven ruler of majority-age who has not taken one!”
Thorin scowled, leaning back in his chair in an almighty slump and looking entirely at the end of his rope, and entirely weary; Bilbo felt a pang, and forced it down with great effort.
“My people are not here to speak for me of what it is they want,” Thorin ground out.
Another piped up, then, and Bilbo hadn’t even taken care enough to remember his name, instead yawning through all of his incessant droning.
“You should not bring the ways of the Blue Mountains here. An unlovely, unloved place, that is. Darkness still lies from ages past. It is a scar.”
Perhaps Bilbo too had reached the end of his own tether, because as he was wont to do, he decided then to chime in with his own thoughts on the whole debacle and entirely stick his foot in it.
“Now, see here,” he found himself snapping, “this is not your kingdom.”
The room went death-silent. Balin had a roaring grimace on his face, and Bilbo elected thereafter to not look at his friend for fear he would lose all of his steam. He held up a finger and stuck his other hand squarely on his hip and frowned crossly.
“I do not mean any offence, and I do not mean to insinuate that I have more right to speak here than you Iron Hills folk do — I very well do not, and I am far beyond thoroughly aware of it, believe me.”
Against the will of his own mind, he chanced the slightest glance at Thorin, out of the corner of his eye. He was sitting forward, one elbow on the table and his chin propped on his hand, idly stroking his beard, watching Bilbo with total focus; watching only Bilbo. His eyes drifted for a moment up to Bilbo’s forehead, then to his ears, to his chin, across his nose, as they inexplicably and often did, and Bilbo felt the tips of his ears flush the colour of pomegranate seeds.
Enough of that. Now was hardly the time. Bilbo breathed out a huff and hopped back to it.
“This place has been stripped to its bare bones,” he said, gazing around at them all. “You must build it from the ground up. To bring old practices from archaic times and implement them as if nothing has changed is an unwise decision — and to be quite honest, it’s foolish.”
Immediately: outrage, black and rolling, indignation, disgust, betrayal — the lot of it. Bilbo cast his thoughts away from every bit, knowing he had to finish his piece. Onar tried to beat him to it, the shaven parts of his half-bald head flushed with anger.
“Our custom requires —“
“I do not mean to press my fingers on wounds that are still fresh, and I’m sorry for it,” Bilbo interrupted smoothly. “Your customs are significant, and your culture is significant. Do not assume I do not think it. I know, however distantly, just how much it means to you. But your kingdom is in pieces, and it is not the first to fall. You have lost so much of yourselves. You must make anew.”
He looked around at them all and threw up his hands. “Can’t you see how silly it is to act as if everything is normal? You’re sitting in a room cluttered with stone debris, all your chair-legs are burned at the bottoms, and the whole place smells of dragon dung!”
(Entirely untrue, obviously, but Bilbo allowed himself a little artistic liberty in his tirade, and hoped they’d all forgive him for it, otherwise a very shunned hobbit he would be.)
“This is no ordinary meeting of dwarves advising their lord. This is of an unprecedented scale, and we — you must discuss it accordingly. You cannot pretend as if your folk have not suffered this loss now that you have it back. You must let it make you stronger.”
“Master Baggins is right.”
Thorin Oakenshield rose at once from his chair at the centre of the table, clasped his hands behind his back, and began to pace.
“I have been thinking such things since almost the moment the battle was won.” He spoke with that distinctive voice, low and woody and lingering, embers and rivers, quiet thunder, thick ash. “Did not many of you settle in the Hills after your loved ones were lost in Azanulbizar? Do not some of you have kin who have lived always in the Blue Mountains from the times of our awakening, who welcomed us into their midst when we had no home at all to turn to, our people slaughtered in their thousands?”
He turned to move in the other direction along the table, and Bilbo saw that rather than clasping his hands equally, he was brushing the fingers of his right hand repeatedly across the sleek oaken one, back and forth almost idly, as if it grounded him.
“We are dwarves. Khazâd. We are slow to move. For so long we have had only each other, and we must open ourselves now to the allyship — friendship, rather, that has been extended to us, by Dale, by the Shire, and by… by Mirkwood, if necessary. We must open our eyes to the world around us, what the earth and the sky may teach us. What our uprooted lives have had to teach us: that the road ahead is long, but we will weather it. We must, as Master Baggins put it, make anew.”
After that, however, was when the aforementioned life began to pull on Bilbo’s finicky little strings.
Instead of settling back into his seat and giving himself a satisfied pat on the back after a speech of such significance and such pretty words, Thorin whirled on the room so suddenly that his cloak clipped the leg of his chair and it fell to the floor with a clatter, and he stormed out.
Most of the dwarves brushed it off with a shrug, but several were eyeing each other most auspiciously, and staring at the open doorway Thorin had left with displeasing looks on their faces. Bilbo shot them a withering glance after collecting all his papers and inks and marched out after him.
(He hoped Thorin wasn’t going to make this a habit after important meetings. It was terribly irritating.)
“Thorin?” Bilbo called out at his retreating back. Thorin only grunted. His strides were long and unflinching, and he blew like a gale down the hall, a stormcloud striding into the night, broiling the rivers around him. Bilbo had no choice but to run along ridiculously to keep up, and his fondness for Thorin Oakenshield was dwindling every minute by the time they reached Thorin’s study and the door banged resoundingly aside. Bilbo caught it before it could fall closed and breezed in after him; he could already see the black clouds gathering, and rolled his eyes.
“Is there —“ he panted, out of breath from the sudden apparent battle-march, “ — a problem?”
“What do you think?”
Petulant Thorin, then. Bilbo had almost begun to miss him. This was clearly his heaped and steaming serving of be careful what you wish for.
“You had councillors in Ered Luin, did you not?” he ventured. Really, he couldn’t make head nor tail of what the problem was. It had gone as smoothly as he’d expected, especially for a first meeting. Bilbo could feel his own eyebrows only gathering closer and closer together on his face.
“Yes.”
Bilbo pushed an impatient breath out his teeth. “How did it normally go there, then?”
Thorin spun around and glowered at him, then collapsed into a chair and breathed out only the kingliest of hard done-by sighs. Bilbo had to stifle a snicker — but really, all these dramatics! Heaven forbid he ever let them rub off on him!
“Much of the time we would spend our meetings sitting around and yelling over the top of each other,” Thorin managed, grumpily, “but these folk are not used to it. We had an understanding of one another. They do not.”
It sounded very like the Shire. Equal portions of primp and poshness, and hurling food at each other if one did not get one’s way. If there was no argument, well, then, things were not really being run.
Bilbo scrunched up his nose. “Surely Dain would —“
“Dain does not wish to enter my council,” Thorin said darkly. “He has insisted otherwise, but it is because he does not wish to overstep.” He lifted his shaggy head to stare into the fire, the tawny silhouette of his body lit weakly by the flames. “I cannot hate that they are wary, that they are being so critical. That is the worst part of it. There are demands of me, demands I cannot fulfill. How is this a way to reignite a kingdom?”
“Reignite,” Bilbo scoffed. “Honestly, do you hear how you sound?” He was feeling awfully like the other shoe had dropped and he hadn’t the faintest idea from where.
Using dwarvish expressions, now, are we? What shoe have you on your feet to drop, you ninny?
“Leave me,” Thorin muttered, suddenly, facing away from Bilbo.
“What? Thorin —“
“Leave me.”
Bilbo rolled his eyes a second time and moved towards the insufferable oaf.
“Tell me what this is about.”
“No.”
“Thorin, you did absolutely beautifully. The Thain himself couldn’t have said it better to the mayor. The King of Gondor couldn’t. What is it you are talking about!”
“I can do nothing!”
The banks of the river broke; Thorin took off his raven crown and hurled it, in a full-shouldered throw that had Bilbo crying out in alarm and despair, because oh, he hadn’t meant — had not wanted — oh, the crown —
He needn’t have worried; the dark metal thunked against the wall gracefully and then fell to the floor, blessedly unharmed. It lay there, silently watching the two of them, one figure’s shoulders heaving and the other utterly, utterly still.
“What am I able to do for them?” Thorin roared. “King! I am no king. What king must rely so heavily on others to bolster him at every turn? What king is weakened in the mind?”
“Uh, I daresay every single one? You fool.”
But Thorin had not heard him, or was pretending very valiantly that he hadn’t, which was exceedingly rude, in Bilbo’s opinion, The hairs on the back of his neck began to bristle in anger, rising to the challenge.
“I am not a king,” Thorin rasped. “I have never been a king in truth. We were exiled; I had no mother or father or grandfather to give me their wisdom once tragedy struck us. I have but tided things over until we found our way home again.”
He faltered, his eyes bright, unseeing; he walked, stopped, fiddled mindlessly with the juncture between skin and wood at his wrist. His voice was a crushed tree-branch, a cracked geode.
“And they expect all this of me, as if I am a learned hand at such things, as if they don’t know far more than I do about the true — methods, customs — they ask about payment, mines, crown jewels, consorts — I cannot —“
Thorin stopped himself, then swallowed, and it was odd, but Bilbo had never seen him look quite so vulnerable. They both turned to the side, to the crown discarded on the floor, its shadow stretching eerily along the stone wall.
“It has taken me,” Thorin muttered so quietly it had barely even been words.
Oh, what absolute nonsense.
“It very well hasn’t,” Bilbo snapped. “You’d broken free of it, by the end, and you know it. You are stronger than this, Thorin.”
Thorin swallowed again, the jut of his throat the only thing in the room that moved.
“How can that be, when I still feel it?”
His gaze dropped to Bilbo’s hands on the table, palms flat on the wood. His voice was only a murmur, as if he was hauntingly humming out a lullaby.
“I see it in your hand.” He took a breath and his chest rumbled, and the fire flickered, and his eyes drew up, dark and guarded with decades of practice. “The Arkenstone. I wake from sleep, and my mind glows. My dreams… my dreams are full of it. Full of gold.” His eyes slid, from Bilbo’s hair to his ankles, and up again.
Bilbo flushed furiously in embarrassment and ragged recognition. They sounded just the same.
Thorin wasn’t done. “And I know you have said you understand,” he croaked, watching Bilbo with those heavy, heavy eyes before glancing back at the shadows. “And I am grateful. But it is not your job to save all of us.”
He was right, and Bilbo hated it, and decided then and there that his patience had been worn too thin. Gold had played far too much a part of his life for far too long, so he would very well have to deal with it himself.
“Blast that,” he said vehemently.
Thorin looked warily over at him, and something in Bilbo’s fierce face must have caught him, finally, because he did not look away.
“You aren’t getting rid of me,” Bilbo said stubbornly. “Not for a million years. I have been where you are. You know this. There is no one else who understands what you felt, what you feel, the way I do. I didn't know it, but the Ring had me for the rest of my life.”
My dreams are full of it. Full of gold. It had sent chills through Bilbo, up his spine and down his fingers until he half-felt like shaking even in the warmth of the room. It was as if Thorin had plucked the thought from his own head, from a world away.
They were hashing this out, right now.
“You might think your mind is a little bit broken. Well, mine is too, so it doesn’t quite matter, does it? If there are more bad days, then we will be there to help you through them, Thorin. We won’t let you fall. We are your Company.”
But Thorin’s eyes were wide and sightless, and his throat bobbed up and down. He seemed to be almost steeling himself to speak, like he was sick with the thought of it.
“I cannot help but feel it. It isn’t right. I am — the leader, I am supposed to be an example, to lead my people with only strength. I cannot be a stumbling fool who collapses at the sight of coins. It is a weakness.”
Well.
Bilbo stopped.
That was the truth out then, wasn’t it?
He leant back, lifting his hands from the table to pull them down uselessly by his sides. He let his expression drop to complete unreadability, and his voice was coolly neutral when he said, “If that’s what you really think about it, then I will leave right now.”
Nothing happened.
Thorin was serious. He really was. Bilbo was a little gobsmacked he’d had the gall to say it — but he was the one who’d chosen the stubbornest of any dwarf of all the ages since Durin, wasn’t he?
Perhaps he should cut his losses, then. For now, anyway. He would not clutch at strings if there was nothing for him to clutch at. He could not make himself heard if the ears were not ready to hear, and there was only so very much one could say.
His room was calling out for a visit just about now, anyhow. Or maybe the library, where Bilbo could whittle away the hours with a candle and the comfort of the old shelves. Dead books couldn’t speak, at least. A small blessing. They would not be likely to stick their boots so entirely in their mouths.
Bilbo made to turn, and to leave, but Thorin had already risen to his feet with a clatter, the chair-legs gouging out a shrieking path along the stone.
“Wait!”
Blbo scoffed, humourlessly.
“There’s hardly anything to wait for, is there?”
Thorin took a single step towards him, his hands held out in placation, though he lowered them when he no doubt saw the look on Bilbo’s face.
“I am sorry.”
“Yes, I’m quite sure you are,” Bilbo retaliated. If Thorin was going to grovel, he would not be doing it with an inch of help from him.
Thorin only blinked at him. “I did not mean that. It was callous to speak that way.”
“But it’s what you think, isn’t it? You can’t lie to me, Thorin, so do not even pretend to try.”
Thorin’s face had screwed up, the carved statue crumbling, and his head lowered the slightest amount.
“Not of others. Only myself, Master Baggins. I swear it.”
Master Baggins.
If he’d been asked after the fact, Bilbo could not have said why it was then he chose to snap as a twig in a forest. Perhaps he’d simply reached the rather generous end of his many tethers. Perhaps fate had gotten sick and tired of them both plodding about like farm animals. Get your heads out of your behinds!
But as it was, Bilbo decided then and there it had been more than long enough, and he slammed his hands down against the table so suddenly that Thorin’s neck snapped upward as if he thought they were under attack.
“Oh, out with it, already!” he snapped.
Thorin looked nonplussed.
“I’m sorry?”
“You know very well what I mean.”
Thorin had of course not followed Bilbo’s skittering train of thought to reach the exact topic he was speaking of without introducing it, so he did not, in fact, know what Bilbo meant, but Bilbo ignored this for the moment. He raised his eyebrows, and when there was no forthcoming response, he stalked his way around the side of the table and right over to crowd himself into Thorin’s space, both of them now right in front of the flickering fire.
“Why have you stopped calling me by my name?”
It was hard to tell, in the dim and already-warm light, the moment that Thorin’s skin flushed, but flush it did, though he kept his eyes level.
“Baggins is your name,” he said. Bilbo scrunched up his nose and blew the hair from his eyes.
“You know what I mean. My first name.”
Thorin’s eyes drifted downward, and he watched Bilbo openly, surely knowing now that any sort of deference would only rile Bilbo up further but not quite able to keep himself from lowering his head as if in a bow.
“I did not think I… that is, I did not know if you would still want me to, after what I did to you. I did not know if I held the same level of trust.” He breathed out a hollow laugh. “It would be no surprise if I didn’t.”
“You —“
“I know, Master Baggins.” He held up a hand, and he was smiling very slightly; a soft, worn old thing. “It is not you. You’ve given me no indication of anything of the like. You have given me nothing but trust. But I cannot change my thoughts so easily, and many of them have begun to wonder what I will do if it happens again.”
Bilbo was so very tired of speaking around this stubborn gold that would not slip off the pair of them no matter what he did. Let it take him, and me, he thought, with a gritted jaw, with set teeth. Let it try and take the both of us.
It shall be no match for me.
“I can’t pick you up from this, you know,” he said quietly into the silence. “And it’s not my job, besides.”
Thorin did not wince. Bilbo reached forwards to touch his arm very gently with just the pads of his fingertips, and kept on going, hoping with all he had that his voice would not shake.
“I can tell you all I like about how I understand what it is you are feeling, how your mind has had to carry so much, how you shouldn’t be unkind to it. But you must listen to me. I cannot spend all this time saying things you do not hear. And if you hear them, you must open yourself to what it is they mean.”
Thorin bowed his head. Bilbo resisted the urge to reach out again and lift his chin.
No bowing. No guilt. Enough of it.
“What would you have me hear?” Thorin asked quietly. Bilbo smiled a little.
“Illness is not weakness, Master Oakenshield. Weaknesses are not weakness. You have been hurt. You are not unfixable. You are not in the Blue Mountains anymore, and you have a home again. You are not alone. You don’t need to lead that way.”
Thorin’s body was hunched down, curled inward against the fire, watching Bilbo with an expression somehow so closed off and so open in equal measure Bilbo could hardly stand to look at him. He chewed the inside of his lip.
It wasn’t his job to fix Thorin’s mind, and he knew it. He was sure that Thorin knew it, too, even before Bilbo’d said it. But to hell with it if he couldn’t put him on the path — if he couldn’t show him the way through the door.
There was really only one thing for it. His words, as he’d always had. Bilbo took a deep breath before beginning.
He would tell one more story.
“Once,” he said, “long ago, a curious little creature from far in the West set out on what was to be the biggest adventure of his sensible little life. He was rather coerced into it, if you must know, by a peculiar pilgrim and a band of intimidating dwarves from the mountains, but after an annoying sort of bout of complaining, he slowly settled into his life on the road with the rest of his companions.”
Thorin hummed out a quiet noise in the back of his throat, and Bilbo knew it to mean that he was surrendering, letting himself listen instead of pushing him away. He forced himself not to reach out across the space between them and brush his fingers through Thorin’s tangled hair.
“One day, however, this strange assortment of individuals fell into some trouble, and found themselves trapped in the clutches of things that wanted to hurt them. The little fellow was lost in the struggle to escape, and fell deep down into the caverns of a mountain, where he came across an underground lake. But the lake was not unoccupied, and a danger lurked in the shadows.”
He swallowed.
“It tried to harm him. He’d picked up something that belonged to it, you see, without knowing quite what it was, and for some strange reason he felt he’d rather like to hold onto his new little trinket. He barely got away with his life.
“Not long afterwards, the creature discovered that his new treasure was magic, and he used it to slip into all sorts of nooks and crannies, for his friends insisted on constantly finding themselves in danger. And he dearly loved his little trinket for many years, and used it to hide from those he found bothersome, and looked upon it with awe whenever he felt the need to take it out and admire it, which became increasingly often, though of course he did not notice this growing habit.
“After many long years, he decided to leave his home in the West, and leave with it the pr — the treasure he’d collected, for his nephew to look after in his place. But it was very hard for him to give up his little trinket. It was… he was startled, afterwards, by how hard it had been. It had felt to him like someone was peeling away the layer of skin that hid his mind from the open air. Like his thoughts had become cloudy after running a race. Like he was waking from the blackness of sleep to the pink nothing of having your eyes closed.
“He spent quite a few years free of the mist it had spread over his mind, and he almost thought himself better for it, but it had already worked its magic. He couldn’t keep his eyes open much longer than a few hours at a time. He couldn’t remember things, things that were especially close to his heart. He began to — forget what his love had looked like, before he had been lost. It had hurt him, his little trinket, and he was one of its lucky owners. And still, that little creature was blind, and he did not know what it was that had left his mind so absent, what had crept quietly into his head and touched every corner it could find until he was a shadow of himself. He thought himself finally succumbing to old age. He could not think without it also being a part of his thoughts. His hair had turned white in a matter of days.
“One day a lot of people came to visit the house where he was staying, and there was a grand meeting of the peoples of Middle-Earth, of which he was a part. And his nephew took out that little trinket of his and proclaimed it to be the darkness that was taking over the world they lived in. Evil? the little fellow thought. That old treasure of mine? But then he remembered, with growing horror, the fog in his mind that he’d barely noticed until it was lifted, and the frightening rage he had felt at even the suggestion of letting it go. And he suddenly knew with all his soul that it was true. And it was then that he realised what he had truly done in picking it up all those years before, from the lake in the cavern, and what his beloved nephew would have to do in order to fix his mistake. That he had sentenced him to wounds that were deep, that would never be soothed. And the creature knew that if it had not already broken him so, that if his mind had moved as it once did, the thought would have broken his heart.”
Bilbo did not look at Thorin once he was done, gazing instead right into the fire and seeing straight through it.
“Would you say he was weaker for being sick?”
“No.”
Bilbo looked up out the window then, the sky winestain-dark outside, feeling Thorin’s eyes on him. “Would you say it about his nephew?”
“Never. Master Baggins. I am sorry.”
The quiet held for a moment, and Bilbo held himself still in turn. It was odd to look out the window, hearing the sounds of a warm hearth, and see only a barren land, desolation mixing in with the unforgivingness of winter and stripping the earth bare. It wasn’t snowing, yet, but the contrast was altogether strange.
“It is not a terrible thing, that we should both be a little bit damaged, Thorin,” he said softly. “We must simply push each other back together. It isn’t that difficult, when you think about it.”
He looked back, finally, to find Thorin was staring at him very strangely. Very strangely. In fact, Bilbo was sure that Thorin Oakenshield had never once looked at him quite like this, and a very strange anticipatory sort of feeling began to creep up the back of his neck in return.
Thorin’s voice was the rumble of thunder beckoning in the distance.
“Your love.”
Bilbo’s frail little heart stuttered to a complete stop.
“What?”
He felt absurdly like a trained songbird. What? What did you say, dear heart? Oh, yes, let me come and cater to your every whim. Terribly embarrassing. He could stand to have a little more decorum than that.
“You said,” Thorin spoke softly, sounding reverent, almost like he’d fallen asleep and wasn’t sure yet whether he was awake, “that he began to forget what his love had looked like. That is what you said.”
What?
What did you say, my dear heart?
But Thorin was still going, and Bilbo could not summon the wit to tell him to shut up. He felt like he’d been slapped in the face with a fish.
“I am —Forgive me, if I am — I do not wish to presume. I —“ Thorin’s voice was raspy and low, and so quiet Bilbo could hardly hear him. He looked up, and his eyes were a furnace, were an inferno, were switching between each of Bilbo’s like his mind was too scattered to focus on anything at all. “You had a love?”
“I — well, I —“
Oh, Bilbo’d trodden in it now. Well and truly terribly trodden in it like the colossal, pin-headed, witless fool he was. The battlements had only been a premonition of what was to come.
I wonder if it’s too late to catch one of those boats from here to Mirkwood, he thought, taking several stumbling steps backward as if to leave right then and there.
“You what, Master Baggins?” Thorin had walked forwards. Why had he walked forwards? Why was he coming closer, oh, dear —
“I’ve just remembered I have something terribly important on, so I’m afraid I have to go, Balin should have mentioned —“
“Bilbo.”
Bilbo froze, his arms aloft, his feet firmly planted on the floor, though really he felt as if he was floating above both their heads.
“Bilbo,” Thorin said again, so quietly, heart-achingly, tenderly, and Bilbo’s eternally-bleeding heart broke upon the letters that made up his name. “I did not know you felt for me as I have felt for you. For so —”
He stopped, as if the thickness in his throat had become too great to go on; the firelight danced, roared, blazed, and Thorin’s forget-me-not eyes were sparkling in that ever-soft way as he stood and watched Bilbo, whose heart had fallen clean out.
He was so dull. He was so utterly blind.
Well, that won’t do at all, will it?
“Oh, my dear one,” Bilbo whispered, standing completely still, watching Thorin’s eyes dance; guarded, yes, the way he was, but hopeful, now, and lit like a gemstone. The constantly-present feeling swelled in his chest. “How could I not?”
Thorin’s lips parted, but he did not speak; he seemed unable to. He took a tentative step towards Bilbo.
It seemed obvious, now. It was probably outrageously obvious to anybody who passed by them. Who’d ever heard of them. Probably the whole of Middle-Earth were rolling their eyes at that silly dwarf and even sillier hobbit up there in that mountain who were blundering around with blindfolds over their eyes.
But he had never thought, could never have thought. What right did he have to?
Oh, my love.
And still Thorin Oakenshield was looking at him, the mask he hid his face behind utterly fallen away. The baritone of his voice was deep and lush and reverent as he quietly called out a hoarse, “Bilbo.”
Bilbo took a step towards him, wrapping his jacket up about himself, trembling fingers clutching tightly at the worn fabric. His heart was beating so quickly he was worried it would burst, and so loudly he thought somebody was going to come rushing in and ask what all the noise was, so he’d better very well say his piece before they were interrupted on account of it.
”Thorin Oakenshield,” he said, quirking a smile, softer than the grass that grew daisies in a flowerbed, “why on Earth would I be planting gardenias in my garden if I didn’t adore you with everything in me?”
He reached out, slowly, and touched one last time at Thorin’s temple, and the hair that swept back from there, and along the line of his cheekbone, and feather-light underneath his chin so Thorin’s head tilted upwards. His beard scratched at Bilbo’s fingertips, and he smoothed a thumb over the dark hairs underneath Thorin’s lip.
Thorin looked as if the shape of the very stone had been changed underneath his feet. His voice was raspy, so raspy, when he spoke, and softer almost than the crackling fire. His eyes were wide; Bilbo could not imagine how he was ever going to find a hope of looking away from them ever again.
“Your garden was for me?”
Bilbo laughed in delight.
“You silly dwarf. Oh, you are a fool. How you were ever made a leader, I’ve got no idea. Not one. I can’t believe you’d —”
He stopped, and laughed again, stepping even closer to Thorin, who was looking down at the floor, his hands hanging by his sides. Strands of hair were falling over his eyes, so Bilbo lifted a hand and brushed them backward when he looked up once more.
“What are gardenias for?” Thorin asked lowly.
Bilbo felt his face pink up in sharply-shy embarrassment, but he couldn’t have cared less for all the world and a day. The happiness ringing in his chest felt like it was going to crack him clean in two.
“A secret love,” Bilbo whispered.
He cupped the back of Thorin’s neck, fingers threading up into his midnight hair, and Thorin reached a hand out to scrunch at Bilbo’s shirt, right above his heart where it rose and fell and rose.
And Bilbo let his words run free.
“I love you. There aren’t words for how tremendously I do. You are my dear one. The tulips in my garden, Thorin. The one I went racing over the hills brandishing a sword for like my mother always told me. I have known it nearly a hundred years.”
And all at once Thorin Oakenshield lowered his head and caught Bilbo Baggins’s mouth with his own, pushing into it the longer their lips pressed together so Bilbo’s head began to tilt backward with the strength that Thorin kissed him with. He pulled away slowly, lips chapped and eyes still closed, and leant up to press his mouth to Bilbo’s forehead, cradling the back of Bilbo’s head with such tenderness it was like the breeze kissing at his hair.
“I have never wanted to entirely know anyone,” Thorin said, his voice so deep, his fingers cupping the back of Bilbo’s neck, trembling, “so much as I want to know you.”
Bilbo made a gruff little noise in the back of his throat and kissed him again.
He thought of the sleeping adventurer within him gifted to him by his mum. How happy she would have been to see him like this, to see who he’d chosen. How much she would have laughed at Thorin’s sullen moods, tapped him on the ears and told him he needed to eat something or that frown would get stuck to his face. How delighted she would have been to meet him.
Bilbo had thought he’d known love, had felt the strongest flares of it in those long years in-between. Had known what it was to soar.
He had not.
Thorin’s beard was scratchy; Bilbo huffed out a little laugh and dragged his fingers through it, resting them against Thorin’s chin, his cheek, drawing a line down his beautiful nose with his thumb and his eyes still closed. Thorin had a fist crushed tightly in the back of his hair; Bilbo was absolutely certain it was going to stick in every ruddy direction after this, but he didn’t for a single second care. He’d shear it off. He’d grow it til it touched the floor. He’d wear a hat just like Bofur’s for the rest of his life.
The oaken hand came up to cup Bilbo’s face, so tenderly, and Bilbo took it and pressed it more firmly against his cheek, twining his own fingers around the wood until they were indistinguishable. He could not stop smiling. He was rather worried he’d never stop again. A single silver tear slipped down his cheek, and Thorin, feeling it soft against his own mouth, reached up with his thumb to brush it away.
My dear heart, Bilbo thought and thought and thought. Oh, you’ve come home to me. You’ve come home to me at last.
Their noses slotting together, the lines of their faces drawn together, every bit of them together as they should never have been apart. It was so very quiet in the room; Bilbo could hear Thorin’s breathing, the press of his mouth, the shift of his own coat as he stretched an arm upward and wrapped it entirely around Thorin’s shoulders to pull him closer. It was the eye of the storm; though, no, that wasn’t quite it, was it? There was no storm. They had weathered it. They had weathered it at long last.
They broke apart and pressed their faces side by side instead, and then they were breathing, just breathing, fusing together until the two of them were one whole beating heart once more.
“You know, you cannot know how I… how I mourned you,” Bilbo said, so quietly he wasn’t sure if even Thorin would hear. “In all the years that went by after you were gone, I thought of you. And it was silly, because I’d never really had you in the first place.”
He smiled softly, sadly, and felt fingers in his hair again. “I could not even mourn you in the way we hobbits do. The land around the Mountain is barren and cold, and no flowers grew here for me to lay atop your chest when you died.” He squeezed Thorin’s hand, and Thorin squeezed back. “But if I could have, I would have given you red carnations and rosemary, and hyacinths and gardenias, and poppies, and salvia, and sweetpeas, and butterfly weed, and lilacs. And forget-me-nots.”
Thorin growled against the skin of Bilbo’s throat. ”Muhudel,” he whispered, hand still threaded through the tufts of Bilbo’s hair, and his forehead lifted to press against Bilbo’s.
“Oh, so I’m allowed to hear your secret whisperings now?” Bilbo teased him. “What does that mean, then?”
He couldn’t see Thorin’s smile then so much as he could feel it against the downy skin on his face as Thorin leant in. His nose was pressing insistently against Bilbo’s cheek.
“I can’t tell you that, Master Baggins. You’ll translate it. Put it in all your books.”
“Bilbo,” Bilbo corrected obstinately.
“Bilbo,” Thorin said, his voice hazel and earthy and warm, his tongue pillowing around the word. “You have blessed me more than you can possibly know. I would have watched you from the halls of Mahal until the day you left the world too. I would have watched over you until the day you died.”
“Well,” Bilbo said, “thank all the powers who reside in whatever place there is across the Sea that you will not have to.”
There was a clearing of a throat, and a nudge against the side of his face.
“Does this mean you will you permit a braid now?”
Bilbo laughed.
“Alright, you soppy, mad thing. Alright.”
The grey in Thorin’s hair seemed to all start from the tip of his widow’s peak, right at the top of his forehead and threading outwards across the rest of his hair. Bilbo leant up on the tips of his toes and kissed it, finally, finally.
“You know,” he said against the wispy crown of Thorin’s hair, “I have never been able to grow old. Not in the way I should have.” He fell back down onto flat feet to look Thorin in the face, and there was such a glow in his eyes that Bilbo had to close his own against it for fear he would lose his head entirely. He leant forward to kiss him again just to find something else to occupy himself.
It was this that meant he could feel it when Thorin smiled.
“So you will grow old with me.”
Amidst the burst of colour that brought in his brain, a snotty little voice he’d never quite been able to stamp out whispered how presumptuous, and Bilbo rather had to agree. He said as much, and Thorin’s mouth stretched wider against his until they were both smiling against each other and there wasn’t much of any kissing going on anymore. So Bilbo felt it when Thorin whispered, with a beating heart that was alive, alive, with a mouth that was warm and wonderful.
“Thank you for coming back to me.”
Notes:
muhudel = blessing of blessings
this one was a little interludey for the purposes of bagginshield finally getting their shit together but i still have a few little tricks up my sleeve for the next chapter! the dís/female oc tag is also at long last going to come into play, as is thorin’s newfound ability to use gay dwarvish petnames, so i’m VERY excited for you all to read
thank you to anyone who leaves me kudos or bookmark tags or comments especially, you make my day with all of them — i am so grateful for how kind everyone has been to me the entire time i’ve been writing this and i really cannot believe it’s going to be over soon :(
Chapter 11: sweetest devotion
Notes:
this chapter has thrown everything she possibly could at me but i prevailed. i’m really so sorry for the delay, but it was very important to me that i get this one right :]
as i’m sure we’ve all seen the chapter count has also once again gone up because i decided i wanted the epilogue to have its own moment to shine but it’ll be out a couple of weeks after this one!
(title taken from the song “sweetest devotion” by adele)
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
It was almost four months before dwarves from the Blue Mountains began to trickle into Erebor, but when they came, they came en masse, and soon, in quick succession.
They’d come loaded with supplies, to boot; their caravans were stocked with tools, gold, preserved food and fresh produce, clothes and all sorts of cherished possessions. Some came with furniture, and housewarming gifts; some came with precious little but the shirts on their backs and willing hands. All of them were greeted equally by the King Under the Mountain, who recognised every one of their familiar faces, and who welcomed his people with a magnetic blend of grace and gruffness.
Those already in Erebor had more or less rallied the Mountain into some semblance of what could be called up-and-running, helped all the while by Esgaroth and the Iron Hills, and the very beginnings of what would once more become Dale. Dain had only very recently left for home, and they had all found themselves more than a little sorry to see him go.
Now, the Company stood outside Erebor, breath misting in the late-winter air and watching the caravans trundle their way closer in the distance, and Bilbo, for his part, was feeling that he very well may be sick. He was so astoundingly riddled with nerves that it was as if his body were a hive of bees; soon, he was sure all of his insides would leak outside of him and he would become a hobbitish little puddle of sludge that had once upon a time had a rather nervous disposition.
For the ravens had come ahead of the caravans and told the Company that the Lady Dís was to arrive imminently, and Thorin had summoned them all to greet her.
Most of them had summoned themselves, in fact; Thorin had only asked Bilbo if he would accompany him in a gentle voice, and considering Bilbo became rather stupid wherever his dear one was concerned, he could not possibly have said no, but the rest of the Company either knew or knew well of Dís, and were jovially waiting with bated breath to catch her in a head-knock.
Bilbo had never met Dís in his first life. He hadn’t stayed with the rest of the dwarves long enough, missing his home and his garden and a time where he wasn’t pressed in on all sides with reminders of the things he’d found and then lost. He could barely stand to think of her at all, back then, even though he would have loved to meet someone like Thorin Oakenshield’s sister.
But he'd lost dear friends and his own heart. She had lost one brother, then another, a father, a mother, a husband, both of her sons. She’d had everyone stolen away from her between one breath and the next.
Many times, Bilbo had thought about writing to her when he corresponded with the Mountain, but he couldn’t bear the thought that she might take offence, at a little hobbit from far away pretending to know the same pain she had and offering her empty words of healing for so inconsolable a loss. And so he hadn’t.
It was rather suffice to say that as a result he was incredibly nervous — and yet in the same breath, he could not help but be glad. They had entered uncharted territory, had altered the course of not only his life but others as well, and the thought was forged steel against his nerves.
He had only moments left to agonise over what she’d be like, and so agonise over it he did, the feeling itching all over something terrible. Bilbo tugged at his collar, and blew out a fussy little breath, feeling as if he may faint, which would perhaps be the most ridiculous and most embarrassing thing to ever happen upon the mountainside if he followed through on the threat.
Keep it together, you fool. You have faced dragons and won. She is only his family.
Though woe betide him if he ever used that as an excuse!
The caravans approached steadily, closer and closer along the rock-moors, and then all of a sudden they slowed. Dwarves jumped out, stretching, beginning to unload their packs. A lone figure stepped out of the caravan at the very front and set her heavy boots on the ground.
Bilbo swallowed.
She was magnificent.
Tall, the same height as Thorin, and with such regal grace in her every line that she seemed like a figure out of one of Bilbo’s long-ago storybooks. She wore the same blue as her brother, blended with shades of charcoal and deep amaranthine, and her hair was still dark as night across her brow and chin and down her back; no streaks of silver had yet touched it as they had Thorin’s.
For a strange, fleeting moment, Bilbo felt a deep sadness at the fact that he would never be able to see the three siblings as they had been in Thorin’s childhood, elder brother and younger sister with their golden-haired middle child, and he mourned their loss of Frerin like it was his own. He and Thorin would just have to keep telling each other stories, then, wouldn’t they?
He got a flicker of the image soon enough. A glint of gold and of ebony flashed across the field before Fili and Kili were barrelling into their mother. She caught them both by the shoulders, one in each arm, and her untempered cry of joy was a blossom that spiralled upward into the air and lifted Bilbo’s chest to the heavens.
Predictably, the peace did not last.
“Oi!” Dwalin shouted.
The Lady Dís looked around at the ghastly sound, and Bilbo blanched. Dwalin had his arms crossed now over his chest, his remaining eyebrow raised, and he was practically tapping his foot in impatience.
”Well?” someone else called — Gloin, this time — and Heavens and hell, what sort of manners did they think they were promoting!
Only Dís behaved rather strangely, then. She bowed her head and her waist in admittance, but rolled her eyes so mightily she might have rivalled even Bilbo, and then made her way over to them, taking Fili’s offered hand while Kili followed at her other side. She held the openings of her travelling-cloak close to her body, and Bilbo didn’t blame her; it was blistering-cold out here on the rock, and they had a perfectly warm mountain lying in wait right behind them.
She caught each of the dwarves in a clashing hug, slapping them across the back and pulling on their beards when she drew away, making her way down the line of the Company. It was only when her boots had come to a complete stop opposite him that Bilbo realised with a ridiculous jolt of unfounded terror his shining moment had come, and that she was waiting for him to speak with an artfully-raised brow.
For one fleeting moment, he fumbled with the words, any words, wondering what on the good green Earth he thought it was he was supposed to say, and his mouth hung open helplessly like a struck-dumb fool. This was Thorin Oakenshield’s sister. This was Fili and Kili’s mother, and the Princess of Erebor.
Fortunately, he soon regained sense.
“My Lady Dís, I — well, I am terribly sorry if I’m at all overstepping, you understand,” he said, “but I must tell you that it is so very lovely to see you and your boys together at last.”
She stood, tall and proud, hands clasped before her and her shoulders straight and strong. She looked inquisitively down her nose at him, and Bilbo very firmly didn’t fidget.
“You have quite adopted them, if the missives are to be believed,” she said in reply. “You are the hobbit?”
Bilbo nodded graciously.
“I have heard a number of interesting things about you, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire. I have not heard a raven’s voice without hearing how it says your name twenty different ways for the last three months.”
Bilbo flushed crimson-bright and made every effort not to lower his eyes. “I can only beg your forgiveness, my Lady.”
“They say that you are like to Durin,” she said, and he wrinkled his nose in supreme distaste.
“That is a load of rot, and whoever has told it to you is a dirty old liar.”
“Balin, my friend,” she called, not looking away from Bilbo, “do you hear how Master Baggins speaks of you?”
“Aye, but Master Baggins may speak of me however he likes,” Balin called back from further along the hill. “He is likely correct.”
Dís turned briefly to look at the rest of the Company, all clustering off into clumps and moaning and groaning at each other as they prepared for the ascent back into the Mountain, and then she focused once more on Bilbo. Her eyes were fire and brimstone upon him as she watched, but he could see now that they were dancing.
“Other whispers have reached me, you must know,” Dís told him. “I hear you have wrangled that thick-headed brother of mine. It cannot be true, surely?” Her mouth twitched. “My condolences, if so.”
Bilbo grinned. Oh, they were going to get on right as rain.
“You have heard the truth, my Lady Dís, however unlikely it may seem. He behaves himself well enough.”
To the right of him, he could hear Thorin grumbling and spluttering and other such nonsense, and he smiled even wider in a not-quite-concealed laugh. Dís’s eyes drew to where the noise was, and met those of her brother’s.
“Indeed,” she said, a little louder. “And here he is. The fool himself.”
Thorin’s reply was slow and quiet and calm, only the very embers of his mighty voice. ”Welcome to the Lonely Mountain, my sister,” he said. Dís waved a hand in the air.
“Aye, so I have heard, Thorin. Enough of this incessant cold. I’m well sick to death of it. Let’s go.”
She marched forwards past them and the others quickly sidled up alongside her, her sons pushing them all out of the way so they could speak with her themselves. Behind them, Thorin and Bilbo turned to walk in tandem, and as they did Bilbo reached a hand down and pinched the skin of Thorin’s wrist, then soothed it with his thumb, sliding their fingers gently together. Only teasing, you big oaf.
In response, Thorin brought Bilbo’s hand up to his mouth, and kissed it.
The arrival of the other half of Thrain’s descendants was huge cause for celebration; it was in the mind of every Ereborean the true reopening of the Mountain. There were blessedly happy reunions, and a feast of welcome was planned, and invitations were extended to Dale to join them in an effort to forge deeper, more strengthened connections between their two peoples in hopes that they might last all the more.
Long tables were set out in the newly-emptied Hall of Treasures, running the entire length of the room, bare of tablecloths but full to the brim with food. There was not one single remnant of space that was not covered in chairs, and even then it was an effort to cram in all their new arrivals and the groups of Men to boot — just the way, Bilbo suspected, that the dwarves preferred it. The Front Gate was left open, to welcome those who wished to join and keep to their words of friendship, and they kept huge torches burning all around the room to counter the chill of the wind.
Of course, Bard had accepted their invitation and brought his three children with him, so Bilbo spent a most glorious evening making fast friends with the lasses Sigrid and Tilda while Bain clung to his father’s side with the proudest of looks in his eye. Bilbo regaled them with all his best stories, and listened to some of theirs, and it was only when the two girls finally wearied and went to look elsewhere for either their brother or some dessert — whichever made itself known first — that Bilbo sent them off with a smile and sat back satisfied in his chair, nursing his glass of mead.
He’d contently left Thorin to sit with his sister and her sons, wishing them to have a moment to themselves after so long away, but as it happened, Dís immediately joined him once Bard’s daughters had left, Balin at her right side.
“You’re excellent with them, Bilbo,” Balin said, and Dís hummed in agreement, eyeing him with an undisguised sort of intrigue. Bilbo waved them away stuffily.
“I’m terrible with the young ones if I have to feed and care for them myself,” he said with a laugh, “but once they’ve done a bit of living and can hold a conversation, I am the fellow you want! I was made to be an uncle, really.”
“What were you telling them?” asked Balin. “More flower-talk?”
Bilbo went a little pink at the ears, and at once the two dwarves, nosy as they were, leaned forward with interest. Dís in particular was wearing a rather grand grin. Bilbo sniffed, and raised his chin.
(It was important to maintain decorum in these matters, you see.)
“If you really must know, I was explaining the best way to pick a lock.” Their faces positively lit up with glee, and he grumbled witheringly. “Tilda asked.”
At some point later in the evening, Thorin got up to make a speech to all the people gathered for the reinvigoration of the Mountain.
He spoke of longevity, and change, and growth, and of learning from past atrocities and mistakes. He spoke of wisdom being found in the most unlikely of places, and of the greatness that would come to Erebor from the friendships that had been woven with open minds and hearts, and Bilbo pretended astutely that his ears were not red as candied cherries and that nobody could see him growing steadily more embarrassed in the corner. He focused on the bearer of his heart instead.
His hair was long and thick and glossy in the warm light, and he seemed at ease speaking to his people in a way Bilbo had not quite seen of Thorin yet.
(And he revelled with all the wonder in the world that he could think such a thing, now. This was something about Thorin he hadn’t known before. An aspect of him Bilbo had never seen, because he’d never had the chance of time to learn it. Not until now.)
Thorin looked settled. He looked grand and glorious and fond and lovely. He’d started to wear his hair slightly differently, now; for official duties, Bilbo had noticed additional braids, and he had added one each alongside the strands that hung by his ears. He had donned several more beads, as well, and they were each of them crafted from different stones, glinting regal and metallic in the soft light.
“Our exile is ended,” Thorin boomed out across the hall, holding his arms wide, and there was an almighty roar decorated with the loud clinking of tankards and the stamping of feet, and in the very thick of it Bilbo couldn’t have kept the silly smile from his face if he’d tried. “At long, long last, we have returned to Erebor!”
Oh, he looked gorgeous. It was utterly terrible. Like a lacquered oil painting of all the kings of old, like the sketch of a grand portrait — or, perhaps, he would be, but for something — something —
It was only then that Bilbo realised something quite peculiar. Something that the more he thought on it, the more he was shocked with himself for overlooking, for it was very curious, and all the more worrisome for being so. He couldn’t quite believe that he hadn’t noticed it yet, but it’d struck him like a sack of bricks now, and was staring him right in the face, right there across the room.
Not once since his sister had arrived had Thorin worn the raven crown.
Bilbo would have been inclined to mention it at once to his beloved, if that had been the only strange behaviour he observed in Thorin, after the welcome feast.
But once he had noticed something was amiss, he could not seem to stop.
Thorin had begun to skulk around his Mountain furtively, as if he were almost afraid he was being watched. But by what, for heavens’ sakes? By the gold? By Smaug? But it wasn’t that, and it took Bilbo longer than it should have to pick up on what exactly the difference was, so he was all the more cross with himself about it once he realised.
Thorin wasn’t avoiding being watched by just anyone. He was avoiding being watched by Bilbo.
There were many other meetings, too, meetings that Bilbo was barred from, which he fought very hard not to feel affronted by; he knew it was not his place. But after each and every one Thorin would storm out, hair and cloak billowing behind him as a blackened thundercloud, his stoic face a picture of decorum but the twitch of his lip and his brow betraying all of his rage.
Bilbo didn’t care a whit if he was shut out of every meeting in Erebor; he was grateful for each one he was asked to attend, and he tried his very Baggins best to speak with diplomacy and intelligence and not snap simply because somebody spoke over the top of him or because they were rude to Thorin, but he’d had quite enough of fallacies and gossip and politeness before he’d even made it inside this godforsaken mountain. Alas. Such was always the way of things.
He did not even mind all too much that Thorin could or would not speak to him of what it was the meetings were for. It wasn’t his place. It wasn’t, and Bilbo very well knew it.
It was only that the secrecy had begun to seep outward into the rest of their lives.
Thorin had started to skirt around certain areas of the city, or the chambers, and in other areas, sometimes, he would see Bilbo and dash immediately away like rats had been chomping on his toes.
It seemed he’d even gotten the rest of the Company to join in on it. Bilbo would attempt a subtle creeping down a corridor and find himself accosted by Dwalin and Balin puffing up their chests at him, blocking the way. Or he’d try and find his way downward, spiralling around the staircases to where he might find the mines, only to become entirely sidetracked by Bofur and Bombur or Dori and Nori and be hauled off in a pressing mission to visit the kitchens.
He even mustered up the courage to bring it up to Dís, all this increasingly peculiar behaviour, but she only held his gaze evenly and let the slightest movement of her mouth cross her face.
Once, Ori had sheepishly tried to tell him that the library was needed for other purposes today, and that he would not be able to enter it on that occasion, unfortunately, or possibly for a few more days after that. Bilbo had strode right past him and shoved open the door — and he might’ve kicked it right down, too, if it wouldn’t have broken all his toes.
“Thorin, I know you’re in here!” he shouted.
But try as he might, Bilbo could not find him, even marching up and down every row of shelves and whipping his head to and fro like he was a windmill in a gale, and when he heard stifled footsteps and the slam of the wooden door he nearly yanked his own hair out in frustration.
“What in the world is all this sneaking around!”
For that was what it was, wasn’t it? Slinking about. Keeping secrets. Keeping his great mouth shut when he’d promised Bilbo he would be open now. What could it have possibly been?
Oh, sometimes Thorin was perfectly lovely, and behaved like a completely unexpected darling. Much of the time, even. In fact, Bilbo thought, and the thought was entirely rankling in his current state of irritation, he’d unfortunately very rarely been happier in his life.
He’d resigned himself to this, he supposed, or loved Thorin for it, or whatever silly sort of nonsense infatuated people would say when they possessed a beloved of their own. And one would have had to be deprived of all their senses not to realise that Thorin was known for being a tad stubborn.
But Bilbo could quite not shake the thought of the absence of the crown.
Thorin rarely wore it anyhow, really. He only donned it for the more official or formal procedures, and his most public appearances. He preferred at other times to present himself as he always had, sometimes with a simple braid or two to supplement, but he rarely opted to wear his royal attire if he could help it. It was really probably nothing to be worrying about.
(It was all very Thorin, in perfect honesty. More than half of the time Bilbo was more finely dressed than him.)
He did not stop trying to piece together the puzzle, of course. He’d taken to asking whenever he hoped Thorin might least expect it: surveying the exterior of the Mountain, for example, or on a visit to Bard’s quarters in Dale to discuss the transition from winter to spring, or even hovering at the edge of sleep, tucked up in one another’s arms.
On this particular occasion, he was seated beside Thorin at the table in his well-loved study, and it was later than even they usually deigned to stay awake. The black sky outside held not a single speck of light, deep within the last dregs of the cold months. Faint scratching from the tip of Thorin’s raven-feathered quill was all that tinged the silence, since Bilbo had given up a while ago; his own pages lay crumpled in front of him. Thorin was focused entirely on drafting up documents that were probably terribly important, however. A splot of ink had spilt onto the page from out of its pot, and Thorin was wiping it away with his good thumb and a crease in his brow, and then wiping his thumb on his trousers.
Ghastly behaviour. Bilbo rolled his eyes, and leant in closer to peer down at the papers spread under Thorin’s fingers.
He wrote with a lovely hand, all things considered. Neat but striking, in bold black lines that painted the page in a way that was considered, vitalised, and he’d dramatically improved in the use of his right hand, throwing himself into it like he was in the training ring and his own left-handedness was the final bout. Not that Bilbo could read a word of it, in Angerthas as it was.
Besotted over handwriting. Oh, he was hopeless.
“Need me to write anything down?” Bilbo asked, just for something to say.
Thorin stoppered up his ink pot and placed his own quill down next to it before he answered.
“No,” he sighed, shuffling his pages together to finish up. He looked the picture of a gentle-hobbit sitting in his rooms and sorting his things, and it absolutely should not have had Bilbo as afluster as he was. His face was still, but his voice was quiet and fond, as he turned away briefly to watch the crackling flames in the grate across the room, swaying softly like dainty roses in the earliest days of spring. “I believe I am done, kidhuzurâl. For the night, anyway. Balin is a ruthless dwarf and an even more ruthless councillor.” He looked back at Bilbo next to him and smiled faintly. “He is much like you, in that sense.”
Bilbo smiled, but it must have been more suspicious than his usual grin, because Thorin’s brows drew together at once, and he sat back in his chair.
“What is it?“
Bilbo stared at him for a very long moment and tried desperately not to cross his arms, and then he blew a breath out so sharply the newly-woven braid hanging in his face shifted itself to the side. Thorin’s eyes drew to it immediately, and Bilbo felt a delightful little stab of satisfaction.
“You are going to tell me exactly what it is you’re skulking about the place for,” he said, with a very deliberately-raised eyebrow.
The eyes were back on him in a moment, though Bilbo could see they wanted to linger on his braid, and the bead holding it together at the end. Bilbo couldn’t blame him; sometimes his own eyes were drawn to it, if it ever hovered in his vision, and his stomach would fall clean out no matter what he was doing. It was woven with sapphire, and meant love.
“I don’t know what you mean.”
“Don’t play thick with me, Thorin,” Bilbo bristled. “It’s entirely unflattering.”
Thorin leant forward and lifted a hand to sweep the hair back from Bilbo’s face, tucking his curls behind his ear and then letting his hand rest there as he gazed at Bilbo with such seriousness that Bilbo’s stomach jumped somewhere into his windpipe. His voice was only a murmur when he spoke.
“I have engagements I must attend. I am sorry, Bilbo.”
“Engagements?”
Thorin nodded, and though his eyes were full of affection, no trace of a smile crossed his face, and he watched Bilbo with a deep focus that was unnerving in its potency. His index finger brushed against Bilbo’s braid.
“Many things are happening in Erebor. I must oversee all of them.”
The prickle in Bilbo’s chest grew, a tiny seed of uncertainty that had sown itself without his permission. He leant back from Thorin’s hand, letting it linger in the air before Thorin lowered it, and mustered up a flimsy half-smile to patch the wound.
“And you must oversee that I must not see, is that right?”
He’d hoped to coax out a grin, or even a simple tug of the mouth, but nothing shifted in Thorin’s face. He was as serious as Bilbo had ever seen him.
“Yes, amrâlimê. That is right.”
(Another of those fantastical life-moments came to pass, soon after. And though it was not his, Bilbo was there to witness it, and he treasured it all the more dearly thereafter for it.)
One particular afternoon, he and Dís found themselves in the sitting-rooms of her apartments, cozy and lush and warm with sunken armchairs and a wide window to catch the day, quite relaxed as together they took tea. He’d very quickly discovered that Thorin’s sister took to tea like no other dwarf he had ever befriended, and he was dreadfully glad that at last he had someone who understood him. She particularly liked the robust leaves, strong and earthen and stormy, and he too was an avid fan.
They had initially gathered, really, to discuss something of importance, something Balin had noted down as particularly needing to be sorted sooner rather than later. Trade relations with their Northern allies, or possibly the arrival of the last caravans, or some other such thing; Bilbo could hardly be bothered to keep track. Thorin had taken one look and tossed it aside with a grunt, so it was, of course, down to his superiors to sort through the mess.
“Another, then?” he asked her with a raised eyebrow.
“Oh, go on. This is excruciating.”
Bilbo shuffled forwards until he was at the edge of the seat and leant over to lift the pot, and the water had only just barely begun to pour when all of a sudden over his shoulder there was a creak and a push of the door, and then another dwarf-woman appeared in the entryway, her arms filled with scrolls.
Dís’s expression did not change, nor did her stance in her seat, but her eyes shifted to settle on the newcomer with a slow intensity Bilbo could suddenly feel sifting all throughout the room. His hands quite stopped in their tracks.
“Your Majesty,” the newcomer said, tilting her head downward in a bow, though she did not lower her eyes from where they rested on Dís.
“I have asked you not to call me that, Brynja,” Dís said bluntly. “It is the title of only the king, which I am not, and we do not use titles for others of the line of Durin.”
“Aye, your Majesty. So you have.”
Dís glowered, and the dwarf-woman’s mouth twitched.
She seemed of a height just a tad taller than Bilbo, though her arms were three times as thick as his with muscle, and her hair was a dark auburn avalanche down her shoulders, the highest bits of it braided up into a twist atop her head. Her beard hung in three neat plaits from her chin, and there was a curious lightness in her face Bilbo was beginning to suspect suggested a hidden grin.
Still stooped slightly in her bow, the dwarf-woman — Brynja — turned to Bilbo with half a wink in her eye, and — yes, there, a slow smile, and inclined her head again. And honestly, all this spending time with perhaps the two dwarves in Erebor who smiled the least out of anyone must have done rather a number on Bilbo’s penchant for being unbothered by grins, because he could not quite fathom the expression she held as she peered at him.
(Though, truthfully, it had been a quite a while now since Thorin Oakenshield was rare to a smile.)
“Brynja, daughter of Asta, at your service, Bilbo Baggins.”
Bilbo startled out of his chair and hopped to his feet at once, wringing his hands even as he sunk and stammered his way into his own greeting.
“Well, that’s not very fair!” he exclaimed, looking back up at her and feeling his cheeks ruddy. “You know who I am!”
She smiled even wider, a peculiar sort of glow in her eyes.
”I do.”
Dís rose from her seat then to join them in standing, clasping her hands together in front of her. The darkness of her hair swept across her shoulders and held itself wrapped by her ears in its braids, more decorated than her brother’s. Her poise was impeccable; she stood very still, and only in seeing her carry herself had Bilbo realised just how much Thorin slouched.
She was very intently watching Brynja with her unmistakable air of indifference, and Brynja was watching her right back. It was baffling, how tense the air was in the room, and for some strange reason Bilbo began to feel more and more astutely like he was nothing but a fly on the wall.
Brynja held out the scrolls in her arms.
“I have brought the first sketches for the piece you commissioned of me, your Majesty. I hoped to show them to you.”
Without waiting for an invitation, then, she strode forward towards the table between the two of them and bent to unfurl the largest of her scrolls, unceremoniously plucking each of Dís and Bilbo’s tea-mugs from in front of them and setting them down at either end to weigh the paper. Revealed inside the scroll was the rough outline of a portrait illustrated all in greyscale.
It was of Thorin, and it was exquisite.
Flecks of smudgy graphite swept all across the cream-coloured parchment, dappled on the textured page and sloping down the bridge of his nose, the jut of his chin, the curl of his earlobe. He looked dark and sturdy and gorgeous, enduring where the arc of his jaw ran up into his thick hair, supple where the lines bled together in his lashes and the pupil of his eye, as if he had been coaxed to life in pencil and had almost begun to breathe there on the page.
Bilbo reached out and traced a finger over the widow’s peak, and when he pulled his hand away the tip of his finger was stained with flaky ink.
“Ah,” he managed, stupidly. But it was all that could be said in such circumstances, to be very frank. Ah.
“’Tis yet only a sketch,” Brynja said happily, waving a hand when she saw his face and even daring to wink when Bilbo mustered the strength to look back at her. “Just wait till he gets a little colour.”
Bilbo made a funny, strangled sort of noise in the back of his throat.
“It has always been customary for a coronation, to present artwork of the King, whether it is with carved stone or paint or molded clay,” Dís told Bilbo. “Dain told me of Brynja when I sent a bird to ask him of talent he knew, and he had nothing but endless praise to offer her. I have only confidence in her skill.”
Brynja's entire face lit from within in a wide smile.
“You do, do you?”
There was a very, very pregnant pause. Dís’ expression twitched slightly, an infinitesimal tweak at her jaw before she schooled it back into her unflappable mask.
Oh, dear. The first chink in the armour.
“It is a leader’s duty to know her people inside and out," she eventually said, far too pragmatically.
“So I have heard, your Majesty,” Brynja said slowly, her eyes only on Dís and entirely alight, setting the whole room ablaze. “So I have heard.”
If he’d ever gotten around to drinking it, Bilbo would have choked right then on his cup of tea.
Now, Bilbo Baggins had never claimed to be somebody who minded his own business.
Well, that wasn’t quite true. But he’d certainly never claimed to be somebody who followed through on minding his own business. It was practically a hereditary trait in the Shire to do the exact opposite, particularly if there were curious things afoot, because who in the world could resist having a nose about, even if it was the most hypocritical thing you’d do all day? And who was Bilbo, really, if not the nosiest creature in all of Middle-Earth?
All this was to say — rather simply — that he decided to put his snoopishness to good use, and so he gathered what he could.
Brynja was skilled in pottery, and sculpting, and carving also, and so was rather a valuable asset to have when a rebuild was ongoing, but her heart’s calling lay in painted artwork and colour, bringing to life that which she saw with her own eyes in all the vibrancy it held. She had a voice like the bark of trees and boots that were half-worn away, and she kept more beads in her hair than Bilbo had seen from almost anybody else in the whole Mountain.
Her mother had lived in Erebor, before Smaug, and her father the Red Mountains, and she had come from the Iron Hills with Dain’s forces to fight and then to carry out the workload afterwards. She wished to remain permanently in Erebor if she was able, in whatever role she would be most desirable.
That was what she said, in fact. Word for word, and directly to Dís. In whatever role or capacity you would have me that is most desirable to you.
Bilbo’d blown a long breath out his mouth and fought down the flicker of his grin.
So that was what was to be going on, then.
It was always rather a riot to watch them together, and it became something of a game, to Bilbo, to catch one of them in the proximity of the other and see what it was they’d do; and, indeed, to see how long it took Dís to realise she still had company after the fact.
If she was with Bilbo, and Brynja ever happened to appear around them, she’d slow her movement, her entire body stilling as if it were encased in stone but for her widened eyes. Brynja would laugh and smirk and trudge on past, but her gaze in return would linger, and her dark red braids would swing down her back, and Dís and Bilbo would find themselves stopped in the hallway until the corner was turned and she was gone.
It was in the un-saying of things that was to be found the real game, and it was what made it so extraordinarily and increasingly obvious to everybody that something was very clearly in motion. Really, with all this speak of looks and gazes and eyes, Bilbo was always feeling as if maybe he should be averting his.
But, he reasoned, there were some moments in life you just knew to watch.
(And some you knew to put good money on rather early with Nori in order to make a pretty sum.)
He’d even asked Balin about it, eventually, one evening in the library with only a very focused Ori for company, though at first he had tried to be stealthy.
“I just had a question I wanted to ask, and I cannot ask it of Thorin.”
“Hm. Any reason why?”
Balin had sat there twinkling away at him knowingly, and Bilbo had known there was no sneaky way about it, after that, so he’d promptly abandoned all pretence and gotten right to the heart of the matter.
“Is it very common to take a second loved one? I know that it is the way of your people — that you are split apart from one another in the stone, and find your way to your person in life. So I did not know it was possible to have more than one… other. We do it all the time, of course — but I did… that is, I did not think it was the way of your folk, is all.”
Balin had scratched his chin for a little while, then looked back at Bilbo softly.
“Some have souls that are made to match more than one other. And for some, the concept has just simply never been as important to them.” He’d bent forward to note something down on the parchment in front of him, and then looked up again and said, “She would cut off the head of anyone who tried to tell her what she should do, you know.”
Bilbo nodded decisively.
“Good. Do… do you think he will react well?”
“He will be happy.”
Dori, who’d apparently been tucked away in the shelves somewhere with his brother, had clearly decided eavesdropping was no longer enough and called out to them in a voice dry as a desert.
“Let her get to it first, Bilbo. She’s taking her bloody time!”
It was in the midst of something of a serious conversation between Bilbo and Thorin when he finally decided he must be brave enough to broach the subject.
“Bilbo.”
“Hm?”
They were curled up together, late in the evening, and Bilbo had set about combing his fingers through the wild tangle of Thorin’s hair, picking apart the snarls and patting them down, then pressing a close-mouthed kiss absently to the crown of the grey streak. He could feel a hand buried in his own thatch of curls in return, prying about and doing the heavens-knew-what in there, and smiled.
Bilbo still kept his own rooms in order to have space for thinking, or if he ever needed to procrastinate a little on a bit of work and the library was simply too full of peeping or prying eyes. But in the mornings and the evenings he had nestled himself so thoroughly into Thorin’s bed-chambers that there would likely be a Baggins-shaped hole if he ever left.
This was his favourite place in the world — when Thorin was not hiding, and he was not skirting around, he just was.
Though what he was, presently, was about to douse the peace of their conversation with all the gravity and tact of a bucking horse.
“The Ring.”
Bilbo didn’t respond right away, letting it linger as he kissed the spot against Thorin’s temple, beyond familiar to them both by now.
Yes, he thought. That bothersome old thing.
He had not forgotten it. There wasn’t really any conceivable way in the world he could have. Bilbo had thought on this little snag for a very long time, from almost the first moment he’d woken again with the grain-smell outside the window and the fresh Shire-spring air floating in. But even still, he hated that he had to do it, hated that it was something they had to bring up at all.
So far it had been hidden away, deep beneath the Mountain, in a sealed box of iron and obsidian and tempered glass so it could not run away from him. He knew now that it would try.
Bilbo pulled himself up on both elbows and looked at Thorin.
“I will have to go,” he said. “Just for a little while, and just me.” He reached out to take Thorin’s hand, tugging him in close until they were face to face beside each other and Thorin was looking down his broad nose at him, unreadable face concealing all the things Bilbo knew he was itching to say. Bilbo touched his temple lightly and swept a braid backward. “It won’t be all bad, though, my heart. I will be able to collect my things from my hobbit-hole and leave the Shire behind me.”
“You would live in the Mountain with me?”
Bilbo had been working himself up to go on for quite a while longer, but at that his mind came to a halt in the middle of a thought, and he laughed, in utterly fond bemusement.
“Where else in the world did you suppose I would go?” he asked, bewildered.
Thorin’s voice was gravelly and warm and delicious against him when he thunked his head against Bilbo’s shoulder. He really was like a great shaggy dog: scratch his ears and he would melt. Bilbo glinted out a smile.
“I did not know if you desired it,” Thorin said. “Even to see you once in a blue moon would be enough for me.”
“Flatterer. Who knew you had such a silver tongue?”
In lieu of having to make an answer, Thorin leant forward and pressed a kiss feather-gentle against the skin of Bilbo’s clavicle, peeking out from beneath his sleep-shirt, and Bilbo ducked his face into Thorin’s hair. They eased into their amicable quiet once more, pressed against one another loosely from leg to nose — though, as it was wont to do, Bilbo’s mind began to whir.
Balin had said Thorin would be happy for Dís, but that meant a fat load of nothing if Thorin was too much of a lovely old idiot to notice anything about his sister that was not dangled right in front of his nose.
Now is your time, Bilbo Baggins, master of snooping and thieving and wrangling dwarven kings. Time to nose about some more.
“Speaking of living in the Mountain…” he began cautiously, attempting to feel out the topic, but Thorin only grunted in reply. Good grief, but it is hard to handle these things delicately! “Well, I was just — hm.”
He stopped and pulled back to look properly down at Thorin, who was watching him now, head bowed against the pillow, eyes warmer than anything. Bilbo swallowed with a dry throat.
“Brynja is a wild thing, isn't she?”
Dís had introduced her to Thorin a few days prior with the display of a swirling artwork she’d made of the Iron Hills. It had been gorgeous, gritty and bursting with life and oddly textured, the bristles all curved along the canvas in a wide arc until the pigment had run out and streaked all red-grey along the page in sharp lines. Mesmerising.
“Oh, Dís,” Bilbo had said quietly, sidling up to her as Thorin and Brynja spoke in front of them, Thorin stretching out a hand to point up at the gradient of oils and Brynja nodding animatedly, folding her arms in front of her and cocking her head to the side. “It’s absolutely marvellous. I never knew the Iron Hills were so beautiful.”
Dís did not look at him, and she did not look at the painting, either, watching only the two dwarves ahead of them; and even then, only the one.
“Indeed,” she’d said slowly, and swallowed hard. Her cornflower eyes had not strayed once.
Now, Thorin let a small smile grow and caught Bilbo’s wrists in his hands, pulling him forward until they were nestled down against one another once more.
“She is. I am glad she’s settling here. She’s a worthy addition to Erebor, and far too much of a wanderer for Dain.” He swept a hand over his beard absently, then brought the same hand up to push Bilbo’s little braid out of his face. “I should see if I can’t add her to my inner circle of advisors, if they must keep insisting on sufficient representation from the Hills.”
“Mmm.”
No such luck, then. Thorin — bless him — had absolutely not the slightest idea that there was anything afoot at all. Bilbo would simply have to wait it out, and feed hints to his dear one like birdseed.
He’d meant to say something more, then, of course, but Thorin’s chest had been so warm and the blanket so soft that he’d drifted off to sleep quite without meaning to.
(And he tried to think nothing of it — he did. There was almost nothing to think anything of. It was hardly a worry at all, in the grand scheme of things.
But when Bilbo had woken, he’d woken up cold, and he’d already known without having to open his eyes that Thorin had already gone.)
Then, soon after and quite without warning, Thorin called a meeting between he, Bilbo and Dís.
It was to be held in his study-chambers, and was between only the three of them, which made Bilbo all the more nervous, though he no longer stumbled all over himself trying to flatter or impress Dís. Really, they’d become quite close in the last few weeks; she was constantly asking his opinions on things, especially the state of affairs outside the Mountain, and in places where neither of them had ever been, like Rohan or Gondor or Lórien. He’d promised to fetch her a book or two he thought she’d like, whenever he was able to once more visit Bag End.
But this seemed private. Exceedingly private. And Bilbo was not fool enough to think it had been arranged so formally and distantly on a mere whim.
He was promptly there on time, but found himself nevertheless the last to arrive; he slipped surreptitiously through the door as Thorin paced back and forth along the length of the room while Dís stood and watched, a withering look on her face. He’d come from another meeting with his councillors; there was still more representation of the Iron Hills than was strictly necessary in the assembly, and Bilbo knew that it was grating at Thorin rather intensely.
Bilbo had not attended the council — not because he was asked away, this time, but because he’d simply not been needed. He’d spent a lovely afternoon with Gloin’s wife Mizim and their son Gimli instead.
“They are trying to help Erebor back on her feet. They mean no harm, Thorin,” Dís was saying. She frowned, though it was likely well-warranted. “Most of them, anyway. That Onar is a menace. Dain ought to bloody well take him back.” Thorin waved a dismissive hand in the air and made an ugly noise that was half-agreement and half-anger.
“What is it we’re assuming they mean no harm about?” Bilbo piped up.
Both siblings turned to look at him. A dark scowl had marred Dís’s face, though the rest of her was cool and unreadable as always, but there was a blazing look in Thorin’s eye that reminded Bilbo very suddenly of gold.
(The good kind. Not the dragon-touched kind. Gold like the sun and the moon, like the line of the sky at dawn. Like the heart of a candle by a bedside.)
“It is the coronation,” Thorin forced out with clear reluctance. “They are pushing it upon me.”
Right. That. Bilbo felt unsure, but knew that to tip-toe around such a thing would only feel foolish. He decided he would be honest but tactful in his conjectures. As tactful as one could be talking to this dwarf in particular, anyhow.
“It has been… rather a long time since Erebor was retaken, hasn’t it?”
A deadly silence took hold of the room. Nobody spoke, nobody moved. Then without warning, Thorin whirled around and stood at the window, watching out over the moors, his broad back and shoulders to the pair of them, blurred out against the light.
“From the beginning I have made it clear that I wanted no ceremony to take place until at the very least all of our people had returned and our kingdom was back to a semblance of its former glory,” he said hoarsely, barely even audible, a deadly thrum beneath his voice. “That was my requirement, my minimum requirement. But they are arguing now that because everyone is here, because all of us are home, the people must at once have their King and throw rice and roses and gold as soon as they walk through the Front Gate, and I — I cannot —“
He turned very suddenly so he was facing them both. His eyes were wide; he was breathing heavily, staring with all the sharp, piercing might he was known for, but Bilbo stood his ground stubbornly and stared at Thorin right back. The room was heavy with pause, a bubble fit to burst; Bilbo glanced at Dís, and she was not looking back at him, but he could see past the poise on her face and in her shoulders that she was hearing all of this for the first time, too. There was pale sunlight glinting through the window as the three of them stood, each point of a triangle, head to head to head. Locked, somehow, in combat — though combat against what, Bilbo didn’t know.
“I have asked,” Thorin said roughly. His face was haggard, and washed out by the day behind him; the weariness in his voice was uncanny, and Bilbo’s stomach dropped like a stone. “I have pleaded. They will not budge. I will stand it no longer. It is unthinkable that they would ask me — that they would expect me —“
The tirade broke off, and his face swept to the side, glancing unseeing at the far wall and leaving his audience of two hanging on tenterhooks. Bilbo was a moment away from stamping his foot on the floor in impatience.
“On what? Thorin —“
Thorin’s voice split the air as a mountain splits in two.
“They will not let one who is not a dwarf sit as the consort of the King.”
A brilliant rose stained the apples of Bilbo’s cheeks and mottled itself all down the skin of his neck.
Well.
Didn’t that shut you up, old fellow?
“Dís,” Thorin said quietly.
The children of Thrain looked at one another across the room, and Bilbo almost stopped breathing, not wanting to insert his presence upon how significant a moment this had suddenly become. Thorin was so still, so earnest and unmoving, as he looked at his sister with a guilt and a sorrow that was frightening in its intensity.
“I did not wish to bring this upon you so soon. But it has been months here, and I did not want to deliver such news in correspondence when it is — when it is so dire an ask.” He swallowed, and his eyes lowered, for a moment. Opposite him, Dís stood just as still, watching him and waiting, for whatever plea he was about to deliver that was so terrible it had caused him to become like this.
With a jolt, Bilbo suddenly, finally understood the depth of his blinding stupidity.
It was this that had troubled him so. It was this last puzzle that the infernal creature he cherished so unbelievably could not get out of his head, even when Thorin seemed the happiest Bilbo had ever known him. There had been one last quest for Thorin, still ongoing in his mind. The gold and the stone were but a part of it.
Only ever symptoms of the heaviness of the crown.
There was movement directly in front of him, and Bilbo looked up, startled. Thorin had moved much closer to him, and was reaching forward now to take one of Bilbo’s hands in his own, sliding a calloused thumb across the ridges of his knuckles and then placing the wooden hand atop it. His eyes were firmly and unendingly resting on Bilbo’s, as open as they had ever been.
“Bilbo, you are so good at all of it,” he murmured, the crease between his eyebrows telling of his entirely true and entirely misplaced guilt. “It’s as if you were born to it. I did not wish to take it from you.”
“It doesn’t much seem like you have a choice either way, does it?”
Thorin looked as if he’d been cracked down the middle, and Bilbo ached to lift a hand to his face, to brush the frown-lines away. You’ve been so worried, you silly thing, haven’t you?
“Do you think I came all the way here just to usurp your crown and throw a fit when I didn’t get my way?” he asked Thorin quietly, with a smile so soft he was sure had anyone seen it they’d have rolled their eyes in exasperation. “I shudder to think what you think of me, Master Oakenshield. I could not care a single whit whether you are a pauper or a prince. It is quite frankly one of the least interesting things about you.”
There was suddenly a sharp grunt from behind them.
“Will the pair of you stop speaking in tongues?” snapped Dís, still waiting for an explanation that had not come.
Oh, hell. They’d entirely forgotten their manners. Bilbo felt the heat in his face renew itself all the way to his scalp and flushed even deeper because of it.
“You must know, Dís,” Thorin said quietly. “What I am asking you.”
She only looked at him with lightning in her eyes. “And how am I to have done that, exactly? You’ve hardly said a word that has made any sense. Spit it out, Thorin.”
Thorin held her gaze, though he did not shift from his position in front of Bilbo, their bodies close and hands still intermingled.
“I am relinquishing my place on the throne. I wish to relinquish it to you.”
It became plain very quickly that Dís was not going to speak, and instead had frozen in her place at the side of the room, watching the two of them with her lips parted ever so slightly, one of her hands half-raised in shock. Thorin moved carefully towards her.
”If you tell me you do not want it, I will bear it. I will do nothing you do not agree to.” He was only a step or two from her now, head held high and looking right into her eyes with an intensity such that Bilbo knew it would have been hard to bear. “But I have lived with you all your life, Dís. I know what lives in your heart.”
“You are mad,” was all she said, her eyes flitting all over him, like she was checking him for visible signs of damage.
“I have led our people gladly,” Thorin said in reply, drawing a breath that sounded as if the thought had been tormenting him. “You know that. But I can lead them no further.”
“Thorin —“
“I brought them here,” Thorin cut across her, and when Bilbo looked back at him, he was smiling softly, and perhaps it was even a little sad. “That is enough.”
“You know that is not what they think.”
Dís didn’t move from her position opposite him, her eyes narrowed, and Thorin’s own were clear and blue and bright, as the two held each other’s gazes, and Bilbo watched on. The room was very still.
“It is what I think.”
Dís groaned at once, and whirled around until her back was to Thorin, clenching her fists and pulling such a face that Bilbo’s mouth curled at the corner and he wrinkled his nose. She started to pace back and forth in earnest.
“Thorin. You cannot still think that you are not good enough to lead. Enough with this —“
“It isn’t that.”
Dís rounded on him again and came to a stop, her brimstone eyes fixing him there, and she waited sternly upon the answer. Bilbo breathed out a slow breath, and he watched as Thorin steeled himself. His answer was quite simple when at last he said it.
”I have fought. I am done, now.”
It made Bilbo smile like the sun shone through him.
Quite right, my dear heart, he thought. You and me both.
I have fought. I’ve changed things. I am done, now.
It was well and truly time for peace.
He squeezed Thorin’s hand tighter, each of the rings digging into his fingers, and could not halt his grin.
Thorin was watching Dís very seriously, no trace of the soft smile on his face, now — Bilbo could see that he was using every bit of himself to will his sister to hear him, to will her to understand what it was that he meant. Bilbo could see it, too. Plain as day, really; he was astonished the thought hadn’t occurred to him of its own accord, and the same way that he’d berated himself a moment ago for not realising the source of Thorin’s conflict, he berated himself now for not thinking up such an idea himself.
“I have been King in our people’s exile for almost one hundred years,” Thorin spoke, slowly, so that she would be able to do nothing else but hold onto every word. “But I think I am the sort of leader who is made for hardship rather than prosperity. I do not think there is much more I can do for them that you would not do better. And,” Thorin murmured, and his voice had that rich tone he got sometimes, and Bilbo’s ears warmed at the tips, “I wish to marry the person that I love.”
Dís had let her hand drop, and was clasping them together now, her lips still parted as she breathed, focused only on Thorin, who held her gaze defiantly as she stared him down. A pin could have dropped in the room and they all would surely have flinched. Outside, the morning was sparkling; it was truly a glorious late-winter day. An eternity might have passed before she spoke.
“Very well.” And everything in the way she held herself, her assurance, her dignity, the way she spoke and it rang through the room, told Bilbo that Thorin was right.
“I will be King Under the Mountain.”
They decided together that Thorin would rule for one last year, side by side with Dís, until Bilbo had rid the world of its evils and come home safely again. They would let their people settle back into their home, and when the ground was steady at last under their feet, Thorin Oakenshield would step down for his sister.
As they were leaving the chamber, Dís marched off ahead of them in a way Bilbo knew would become intimately familiar to him in long years to come, and Thorin remained by his side, one hand still in his as they walked down the empty corridor.
“Do you feel better now, then, that you’ve finally gotten all your bebothering secrets off your chest?” Bilbo asked with a smile.
There was a gruff burst of air in place of a laugh, and the length of Thorin’s arm pressed more firmly against Bilbo’s. Bilbo looked up, and his dear heart was already looking down at him with his damning, damnable eyes alight.
“Not quite, sanûrzud,” he said. “Forgive me. But there is one thing more to come.”
Of course, they had to hold another feast to celebrate.
At present, however, Bilbo was leaning rather heavily against a wall, his eyes closed and the stem of his pipe perched pathetically between his lips as he tried valiantly to pretend he was enjoying the Hills’ strain of pipeweed any more than he enjoyed that of Ered Luin.
He’d spent all day carrying a hundred things all over the place, dusting and adjusting and directing and getting increasingly agitated when one of his friends took too long to listen. He’d banished Kili from the hall sometime after elevensies, telling him to go and do anything else, and don’t you look so pleased about it, thank you very much!
Everything had been set and settled, now, and most people had made themselves scarce to get ready for what was to be a grand night, so Bilbo was taking the time to rest both his knees and his eyes, steadfastly ignoring that there were still several small things to do before he too could absent himself. They could get on without him for a while.
“Master Baggins.”
Bilbo spun towards the sudden voice and was abruptly faced with a shock of auburn hair and a smile that was somehow always a little knowing, even if they hadn’t yet shared any words. He cut his eyes upward and huffed out a breath that jolted his braid out of his face.
“I’m sure I’ve told you by now that it’s Bilbo, my dear.” He looked away with a smile, and they stood together, perusing the hall — still near-empty at the minute, but a horde of hungry dwarves all arriving very imminently. “And how are you getting on with everything?”
Brynja laughed next to him, and Bilbo laughed in return when instead of any sort of elaboration on what it was they both knew very well they were talking about she said only, “Chipping away.”
The new King Under the Mountain was as brainless as her brother, then.
“My condolences,” Bilbo said. “If it helps at all, I have the utmost faith in you.”
When he looked at her once more, the both of them leaning against the wall, her grin had softened to an uncharacteristically shy sort of smile. Her eyes flicked across the flat sheen of the steaming silverware at every table that inside it bore mountains of hot food, and then travelled up to the high table at the front of the room, perpendicular to the rest all laid out long-ways. Chairs were set along its length to face the room, enough for each of the members of the council who’d requested to sit with the king, as well as for each and every member of the Company and their families, in pride of place as ever. At the very centre was a high-backed chair, larger than the rest, plush with dark blue fabric and thrown all over with furs. Inlaid in the arch at the very top were tiny stones to emulate Durin’s Crown.
“Has your Master Oakenshield said anything to you of her?” Brynja asked.
Bilbo swallowed his scoff. “Oh, never. He’s definitely not noticed, yet.”
At that her grin lit again, and she turned to him with her teeth showing. “You think?” Bilbo rolled back his shoulders and raised an eyebrow at her.
“I know that clothead’s mind like I know my own. He is daft as a boot.”
There was a moment of companionably-amused silence, and then she said — rather cheekily, Bilbo thought — ”He’s very fond with his affections.”
The sly thing. Bilbo could feel the delicate skin of his cheeks all pinking up.
“I know. I am surprised by it every day.” He looked at Brynja ruefully, and in the light of the hall, her eyes seemed so hazel-brown they were almost orange, like her hair; tawny and fire-lit and glowing. “He thinks it is not obvious,” he said, and she barked out a laugh.
“So does she.”
“My word, these Durins! I am truly glad you’ve come along, my dear. I certainly need some sense to be found in this mountain.” He peered at her. “Do you want me to do some nudging in the right direction, shall we say? To either him or her?”
“Thank you for the offer, Master Baggins,” she said, with that golden-bronze glint in her eye, “but I do not think I will need it.”
It was not long afterwards that the feast kicked into full swing, the tables utterly laden with frankly ridiculous amounts of food, even to Bilbo’s hobbitish eyes, all ripe and fresh and lovely after the stockpiling of the winter and the acquisition of flourishing new trade.
Shouts echoed all throughout the hall, and there was much chatter and music and laughing, and Bilbo spent the whole first part of the evening arguing with Bofur about the proper way to cook mushrooms whilst shovelling pie into his cheeks.
He’d become a dab hand at these things by now, after so much time in the Mountain, and so Bilbo knew very well that with dwarves, where there was dinner, there was music, and where there was music, there was a dance. He didn’t have to wait overlong.
After the noises became less the scraping of knives and forks and more the clattering of plates, the dwarves began to gather in an intriguing pattern. They formed concentric circles, each within the other, gathering in such a way that you’d hardly realised anyone else was up at all before there wasn’t a full seat left at a table and every one of them had slotted into the dance. They were so structured and powerful and attentive in their artwork and the movement of their feet that it was truly and utterly mesmerising to watch, and even living with Elves as he had for nigh on twenty years of his life, Bilbo had never once seen anything quite like this.
It was entirely fascinating. One partner would move first, and then the other, and then they would move in tandem very briefly, only for the whole cycle to begin again. One hand up, at a right angle, and you circled each other, and then back around the other way, and there was some sort of impressive footwork and heel-kicking involved. It was all very complicated, and looked exceedingly, terribly intimate.
“They say our people used to do this bearing flames in their hands, before Durin’s Bane took us,” Thorin told him, watching the movement of the people of Erebor as if enraptured, the lantern-lights already dancing across his skin, now that night had fallen outside.
Bilbo blew an impressed breath out his nose. “I don’t doubt it.”
“You don’t wish to dance?”
Bilbo scoffed, and graced Thorin with a thoroughly disbelieving eyebrow-raise.
“You will not find me embarrassing myself attempting anything such as this. Give me a Green Dragon jig, or a Midsummer flute-song, and then I will teach your feet to move.”
Thorin hummed, low and rumbling, and then turned slightly to Bilbo, his eyes following a beat slower than the tilt of his head.
“I do not know if I should dance,” he murmured. “I will play for you instead.”
Bilbo smiled. “You’ve never played your harp just for me before. What would make you start now?”
Thorin looked at him for a very long moment, the firelight still dancing, and Bilbo did not think he would ever, ever get used to the way Thorin Oakenshield watched him, now that he knew what it was he was watching for.
“It could be said I have found some motivation.”
Bilbo made to taunt back, but it was then that something entirely unpredictable happened in the hall, though it was very possible that it was unpredictable only to Bilbo, and so only he was all the more flabbergasted for it. But as it was, he couldn’t stop himself from gawking a little, though he tried to pass it off as best he could, and he watched surreptitiously instead as Brynja of the Iron Hills approached their high table and stopped at the foot of the future King, standing on the dais.
“If I may ask it, I would have your hand in a dance,” she said, amidst the dancing and sloshing of ale, and had Bilbo not been so close he would not have heard it at all. She looked up, and for once, there wasn’t a single trace of a smile on her face. “Your Majesty.”
Every person watching the scene was silent. Brynja held out a hand, her palm facing upward, and then Dís took it, turned it, pulled it up to her mouth, and kissed it softly before she lowered it, though she did not let it go. Brynja did not look away from her, and for his part, Bilbo didn’t think he could possibly have either.
The future King entered the fray.
(Bilbo knew the history Brynja had with the title. He knew it was in jest for her to say, or in spite of everything Dís nettled her for. He knew it was a way to tease. But the weight of it was different now that it was true.
It was rather presumptuous of Brynja to address her in such a way, now. Exceedingly, in fact, and downright disrespectful, and some might have said even treasonous to boot, to title Dís so when the crowning had not yet occurred, while her brother still sat on the throne. Bilbo absolutely loved her for it.)
There were others all around them, but Dís’ people parted like the mouth of the sea before her and Brynja as they walked hand in hand towards the very centre of the room, through masses of joyous dwarves twirling around and around, their feet kicking up and braids unravelling as they spun and spun and spun. And it was as if the very fires flared, the candles burned hotter, and the light in the room was aglow in orange, as the two of them began to dance.
Dís stood utterly still, a marbled pillar as Brynja danced around her, a flame circling the night; her feet skipped, and there was a great smirk painted all across her fiery face. Then they swapped, and Dís was very quickly flush-warm, though you could hardly tell — the dance, the exertion beading at her brow, the heat of the room and the bodies, the fire lighting the walls. But the rouge of her cheeks was for none of it, and Bilbo knew it all too well.
Oh, her face. The poor dear.
“The poor sod,” Nori agreed, sidling up to him out of thin air on the other side of Thorin, and Bilbo could only nod. ”You might have us all beat on this bet, Master Baggins.”
He’d said it with a clear grimace, and it had Bilbo smiling wickedly.
“Shows what you know, then, doesn’t it!”
There were others dancing, yes, but none of them held a candle to the two women in the very centre, not even the faintest puttering little flicker of one, as they circled round and round, and the firelight burnt amber-low, and the room stopped but for them. Brynja leapt and twisted and gazed as the heft of hammers, as the sleepy leaves of belladonna. She was ale and wine and good hearty mead by the barrel, her red hair flaring outward and wrapping itself around the two of them, and Dís — oh, heavens, Dís was drinking her. Bilbo had to look away.
Dís, my fine friend. I am afraid you are entirely a goner.
“Oh, really, Thorin,” he cried instead, throwing his hands in the air for a little more flair to the whole thing .”Surely you must now be seeing this!”
What is it I am meant to be seeing? he’d expected to hear next, but curiously, there was only silence on Thorin’s part. Bilbo frowned, and turned to say it again — honestly, it was awful manners to ignore your own dear one when they were speaking right to you —
But Thorin was not there.
Bilbo whipped around.
Perhaps he’d simply made his way down into the dance, or along to one of their other friends. Perhaps he was grabbing the both of them more scraps of snacking-food.
But if he had, he was concealing himself awfully well, because he wasn’t anywhere to be found.
“Where’s that fella of yours got off to, then?” Nori said cheekily, nudging Bilbo in the ribs while he stood there quite at a loss.
“You’d know as well as I do, I think,” Bilbo said, and all the punch had quite been taken out of his voice, weak and floaty like he’d lost his way halfway through the sentence. Nori said something else, but Bilbo waved a hand in vague assent, or goodbye, or whatever it was he was waving for — he’d already started moving away, searching out into the crowd.
Where had he got to? What in all the blazes was he doing, and why did he never, ever, ever cease to hide it always from Bilbo? Why, my dear heart, must you always and eternally be up to something?
“I have something I must show you,” a low voice whispered in his ear.
Bilbo jumped entirely out of his skin and spilt half the tankard of ale he’d been nursing across the floor, and promptly felt a sheen of scarlet spreading its way onto his cheeks.
“And you couldn’t have warned me?” he huffed back at Thorin, spluttering and shaking out his wet fingers. There was nothing to be done about the edges of his sleeves, and Bilbo glowered up at where Thorin stood leaning over him with an uncharacteristically bright look in his eye. “I thought you’d disappeared.”
“You are done, are you not?” Thorin asked him quietly. ”You told me you did not wish to dance.”
Politely, Bilbo thought, there wasn’t hardly any room to dance anymore anyhow; not with Dís and Brynja circling each other like lone lovebirds in a wild forest.
“Alright, you pestering thing,” he said.
They were turning in for the night, Bilbo soon realised once they started walking, which was a rarity this early but not entirely unlikely. Bilbo hastened his pace to keep up with Thorin — and, truth be told, in a little more of a hurry to see whatever it was that had him so single-mindedly focused.
“I have something I must show you,” Thorin said again, not turning around as he spoke. Bilbo smiled, a little baffled.
“Yes, you made that clear already.”
“Aye, but I —“ he grunted, shook his head, and then began to walk faster, whirling round the corner and thumping his way down the stone corridor in his heavy boots. Bilbo rolled his eyes and skittered faster on his feet to stay alongside him, down one hall then another, getting huffier and huffier by the second until they reached Thorin’s quarters.
”Honestly, Thorin, what in the —“
He ran straight into the back of Thorin, standing very still in the doorway, his breath a nervous rattle in the quiet. He turned around, tilting his head to look at Bilbo.
“Please give me a moment, kidhuzurâl. One moment.”
Bilbo huffed again, making sure to add as much resignation as was possible so that even his dear nuisance would be able to hear it, and then crossed his arms to wait.
Thorin was watching him very patiently, only the thinnest line at his jaw giving away the fact that he was at all on edge. Bilbo’s eyebrows came together in the middle.
What are you up to, you ridiculous thing?
Thorin’s only response was to swallow, throat bobbing, and then say softly, “Close your eyes, ghivashel.”
Bilbo stared at him for a long moment with them first, and then, with hard-mustered effort, he covered his eyes with one hand.
The door opened, and there was some shuffling, and a few tinkling sounds like maybe something had knocked against the table, and then a warmth in front of him again that meant Thorin had returned. A hand took Bilbo gently by the arm and led him forward over the threshold, still blinded, until they reached the edge of the bed they shared.
“Alright,” Thorin said gruffly. “You can sit.”
Bilbo did, shuffling backwards a tad so he was comfortable, and then oak fingers were brushing against the hand covering his own eyes, and he lowered it, blinking them open to a sight he could not quite comprehend.
He stared downward in wavering puzzlement.
“What’s this, you silly creature?”
The room was almost entirely dark. Thorin had lit only a single sun-yellow candle in the faraway corner, and the bed was blue-ish with night, but the moon outside was bright and full enough through the windowpane that Bilbo did not have any trouble seeing Thorin sitting next to him on the covers with his body turned toward Bilbo’s, or seeing that clasped in his hands in front of them were flowers, though flowers like none Bilbo had ever seen all his life.
They were metallic and dainty and precise, wrought with iron and clearly crafted so tenderly and expertly that they surely must have taken months and months of work. Each one’s stem was so long and so fine it was a wonder they held up the bud at the end, but they did, and it was a well thing indeed, because at the end of each flower were dozens of tiny jewels in all the colours of the world, a shade for each individual bud. The petals were paper-thin and cupped as if they had merely been plucked from a garden and dripped in silver, and they shone with little gem-lights of dazzling blue, and purple, and deep red, and blinding, pearlescent white.
“I have not properly asked for your hand,” Thorin said in a low voice, as if nothing had happened between one moment and the next.
Bilbo spluttered, and then snorted, and it was all rather unattractive, but honestly — what a pile of rubbish.
“I am fairly certain you have told me directly to my face you will be marrying me at least six times, Thorin. That is far enough, surely!” He laughed, though it came out a little frantic, and he could not draw his eyes away from the flowers, his heart drumming a song against each one of his ribs.
“We have barely discussed it, Bilbo,” Thorin chided. “But I wished to make something, to signify its importance to me, and to you. It is our custom.”
Bilbo lifted a hand to the little flowers in equal parts awe and disbelief, but he could not quite bring himself to touch them, hovering a hair’s breadth away. They were so exquisitely crafted they looked as if they would blow away on the wind.
“They’re a wedding gift for me?” he whispered. He couldn’t seem to force himself to move, staring and staring at them while Thorin held his silence, and then, at last, he looked up at Thorin’s dearly-loved face.
Thorin bowed his head slightly and kept on looking at Bilbo, his eyes curved up incrementally in a smile.
“I hope that now you will forgive me my secrets.”
Bilbo looked down again at the flowers. Thorin was holding them loosely in both hands, in more of a bundle than a bouquet, and there were twelve altogether; twelve intimately familiar blossoms all woven with cold iron and bright jewels from out of the strings of Bilbo’s heart.
Purple and white hyacinths. Poppies, rosemary, sweetpea, lilac, butterfly weed. Red carnations and forget-me-nots and gardenias and blue and red salvia.
And holding them all, his beloved snapdragon.
“My little garden,” Bilbo said, almost without sound. “You remembered?”
“I did have to ask some of the others for the names. But yes, I remembered most.”
Oh, where is all your pompousness, Thorin Oakenshield? Where is all your pride? The dwarven king, the mighty warrior, he is nothing but an almighty sap, a darling, wondrous creature who makes all around him smile as if it is their first time seeing the sun.
”I wish to court you,” Thorin said, “and to propose to you with every inch of devotion I intend to show you for the rest of our life together. I could think of nothing else. And I do not know your customs — whether you accept gifts, or public affections, or ask for your intended’s hand from their parents as we do, though that is of course not possible for you and I —“
“Oh, my mother would have loved you,” Bilbo laughed wetly, wiping his hand across his face in such a way that was probably dreadfully disgusting. “She said marrying a fellow with a sturdy nose was the key to a healthy life.”
“Bilbo.”
A hand touched at the underside of his chin, and Bilbo lifted his face from the flowers again to gaze into Thorin’s, and oh, he was still wearing that ridiculous half-smile, wasn’t he, head lowered to look Bilbo right in the eye.
”I told you once that I have never felt the pull of my other half, that I was not made for it. I feel it now. Gentleness, and love, and warmth… we need these things to be alive. I did not realise. I was so bitter, for so long — all that I lost, that I never thought I would find again.” He looked away from Bilbo, then, instead glancing down unseeing at the faint blue-yellow darkness between them, his mismatched hands lying in his lap and still loosely clutching the flowers. “There is so much I have, now, that I did not before.”
Bilbo felt his face crack in half. His smile was watery, and felt like glass. “Me too.”
He twisted his body to fully face Thorin’s on the bed and wriggled a little closer, tucking his own legs up underneath him so he was propped half on his knees. He took one of Thorin’s hands very gently between his, skin cool in the moonlight and the night air amidst the stone, and he splayed his fingers outward and pressed a kiss like flower petals against each one.
The flowers lay next to them now, still gently grasped in Thorin’s other hand where it had moved to rest by his side. Bilbo reached forward and touched at the first one he could find. It was jewelled at the edges, and he could see lapis twirling daintily round the stem and along the edges of each leaf. Blue salvia.
“I miss you, and I am thinking of you,” he whispered against the pads of Thorin’s fingertips, watching Thorin’s face.
Then, carefully, he folded each of Thorin’s fingers inward so they curled into a fist, kissing each knuckle one by one, kissing the skin of his wrist, their breathing quiet in the room, the sound like birds’ wings. The red salvia lay next in line, and Bilbo brushed the cool metal of it with his thumb.
“You are forever mine.” He kissed once more the rough skin of Thorin’s hand, before gently placing it back at Thorin’s side.
The next one was cool at his fingertips, smooth and opalline — the gardenia, Bilbo realised. He leant forward and pressed an open-mouthed grin against the side of Thorin’s face for a brief moment before moving to kiss the highest point of his cheekbone, brushing it softly as he pulled away with the side of his finger.
“My secret love.”
A kiss at Thorin’s forehead, the constant crease between his brows. Bilbo smoothed it down with his thumb beforehand, and smiled as if his heart was made of spun glass. He touched at the stem lined with purple amethyst, and then at the one laden with white pearl. “I forgive you. I am sending my prayers to you.”
Another kiss, against the corner of his mouth, pulling gently against chapped lips. “My heart is aching.”
“Bilbo,” Thorin murmured, his voice deep and gravelly, and beautiful. His entire face was utterly open. Bilbo still couldn’t believe they’d found each other at all, let alone again and again and again.
He knelt up, cupping the side of Thorin’s face with one hand so his fingers threaded into the dark hair behind his ears. He touched at the very last flower without looking, his eyes closed and his lips pressed against Thorin’s widow’s peak, his favourite part of Thorin’s face. The silver locks were soft under his mouth, and Bilbo met them like old friends.
When he whispered, it was against the strands of Thorin’s hair.
“I will not ever forget you,” he said quietly, feeling the beating of Thorin’s heart underneath his fingertips, his gentle-warm breath against Bibo’s face. “Do not forget me.”
Then he leant down, and Thorin leant upward. Their mouths caught.
Bilbo’s heart soared.
Notes:
kidhuzurâl = golden one
sanûrzud = perfect/pure sun
amrâlimê = my loveyes the rumours are true the disbrynja dance scene was entirely inspired by the priory of the orange tree
the last scene of this chapter along with a lot of the next chapter were some of the earliest things i ever wrote for this fic, and they’re also probably my favourite parts of the whole thing. i am so, so excited that everyone is finally going to read them.
see you soon!
(also i just want everyone to know: my family keeps chickens and we used to have a rooster called the witch-king of angmar, but he sadly got eaten recently by a snake — HOWEVER, we just got a new one and are naming it bullroarer took lol)
Chapter 12: sunlight
Notes:
<333
final title taken from the song “sunlight” by hozier — to me, this song is thorin’s pov :]
Chapter Text
For the rest of his second lifetime, Bilbo and Thorin carried on much the same way.
Bilbo mostly kept busy by attending council meetings whenever Dís asked it of him, by gardening around the outskirts of the Mountain and painstakingly maintaining the library, though Ori fast overtook him in that regard, and Bilbo could hardly even convince himself to be annoyed by it.
He had never been the greenest of thumbs, really, back in Bag End; not in comparison to all the rest of the folks of the Shire. All hobbits had something of the natural about them, and he’d found great comfort in the growing of his own crops and his lovely flowers, but his garden was a small one, and it was for memory and sentimentality more so than any unspoken calling. He had only a smidgen of his father’s talent and all of his mother’s lackadaisicality, but even still, he bent himself to the task of coaxing back to life every plant that could bear it on the mountainside until the desolation was no more.
(And if ever there was a plant too stubborn to listen to his hands, Bilbo wrote to his cousin Drogo for advice, because he really was magic with them.)
He still taught the little ones their letters, though that was made more difficult on account of the fact dwarves also used an entirely different runic system and aged into adolescence at a vastly different rate than hobbits, but he enjoyed it just as much, even if it was a tad befuddling to get used to. He read aloud or simply spoke from the mind and the heart, and slowly began to amass a bit of notoriety around Erebor for his way with words and his gentle wit with their children. He still wrote his poetry and his songs, too, and by now he’d planned out rather a large stack of original books to be placed in the library, so Bilbo’s work was quite cut out for him in the writing of them, too.
He spread himself from here to there, as advisor to Balin and support to Dís, as friend and neighbour and uncle to Fili, Kili, Ori, Dori, Bifur, Bofur, Nori, Bombur, Dwalin, Oin, Gloin, and all the rest. He was rightly thick as thieves with the wildflower-lovely Brynja — and there was ever and always Thorin, whom a lifetime of remembering had paled in comparison to.
And tea, of course, was always at four.
When Bilbo started to notice the first threads of silver hair amongst his own curls, he rushed to show Thorin the marvel of ageing; of ageing at a normal rate with a normal life and a normal, dwarven husband who lived in a mountain and who had once been the King. He hadn’t stopped smiling once the entire time he’d explained, and the thought that he might give himself crows-feet wrinkles around his eyes made the grin on his face even wider. Thorin watched him quietly, and once Bilbo was done, took him in his arms and pressed a long kiss to his lips with such intensity that Bilbo was very glad Thorin was already holding him aloft.
“Kidhuzurâl,” he whispered, right against the corner of Bilbo’s mouth, one of his hands wound through Bilbo’s freshly-speckled hair. “My golden one. My sun-love.”
“If I’d known you liked the colour of my hair so much I’d have kept that ring around a little while longer,” Bilbo joked, laughing at the way it made Thorin’s eyes widen at once, his heart filling at the fact that he could let go of the old thing enough to make fun. “I’ll be grey before you know it, I’m afraid!”
Thorin’s answer was quiet but amused, the way he always was.
“Dwarves also cherish silver.”
Bilbo beamed. “You are a sap!”
The Ring had been a nasty business, and Bilbo did not like to think of it very much. But he was glad that Frodo was safe, this time, and that at the very least they’d had the advantage of timing.
All that could be said was that they’d used that tiny, impossible window between the White Council’s banishment of Sauron from Dol Guldur and his return to Barad-dûr in the year following to slip away into the deepest crevices of the dark lands of Mordor and be rid of it for good. It had been only Bilbo and Gandalf, and the trek had been long and awful and nightmarish, and the sight of the Black Gate and the thorny mountain ranges beyond had made Bilbo sick to his stomach in thinking of his dear, darling nephew. But without the threat of the Black Riders roaming or orc armies crawling or the Eye on them, they managed, if just barely.
Bilbo had made the final climb all alone, and held his eyes tightly closed like he would be turned to stone if he dared look upon the One Ring falling into the fire. They’d departed almost as perilously as they’d come, and made a short visit to the Lady of Lórien to soothe their hearts, and she, like Elrond, had looked upon Bilbo with shimmering eyes amidst her long blonde hair.
It was done. It was gone from the world. And if nothing else, Bilbo was glad that he had been able to sew up the last of the old guilt that yet clung to him over Frodo.
On their return to the Mountain they’d taken the long way round, trekking through the endless plains of the horse-country, along the distant White Mountains and through their eventual gap. Bilbo admired Fangorn and glared at Isengard, and he and Gandalf carried on their way along the ancient North-South road.
Very peculiar goings-on, there, too. More than a few orcs, hiding amongst the trees at night. And suspicious-looking Men, all wearing hoods and carrying carts and carts of Shire-produce, of all things!
I mean, really, he thought, I prefer a pipe to almost anything, but who in the world is buying all of this Longbottom Leaf!
His stop in the Shire was a short one, and far less of a hassle this time when he’d remembered to send a note announcing his profound lack of death and extending a general apology to any and all relatives who may possibly have been feeling rather eager to begin the mourning process.
Then, after he’d gotten everything settled and sorted and given the other Shire-Bagginses strict instructions that Bag End was to go to Drogo until such time that he had his first-born son with any Brandybucks he may or may not marry, Bilbo did not visit the West again for more than twenty-five years.
(But that time was still to come.)
Admittedly — and he was rather ashamed about the fact, but a fact it was nevertheless — there were several moments Bilbo felt horrifically guilty about stealing the glory of the kingship from the house of Dain Ironfoot, and his son Thorin Stonehelm.
But on every occasion he would visit, Dain spoke so lovingly and boastfully of his home in the Iron Hills and how he missed it wherever he went, and as fondly as Bilbo had ever heard of the progressions his son had been making there, in their engagements with the wider world and with each other. And Bilbo could only grit his teeth against his own worry and hope that in his last act of burglary he had lifted a great burden off his friend’s shoulders, as it had been lifted from his husband’s.
Watching the King well and truly come into her own meant that Bilbo could never quite feel like something had gone awry, anyhow.
There hadn’t been much more to Dís and Brynja’s eventual union, in truth; Dís was far too proud and far too stubborn to allow it. The two of them had simply retired from her crowning feast together, long after Bilbo and Thorin, and come back down for breakfast late the next morning hand in hand.
That might not have even given up the game, were it not for Brynja’s complete and utter radiance at Dís’s side as they sat at the head of the table, or for her gigantically over-the-top wink in Bilbo’s direction when she laid eyes on him.
Thorin had been bringing a spoon to his mouth, and he’d stopped mid-motion, stew dripping slowly back into his bowl.
“Dís and Brynja,” he commented to Bilbo, very bluntly. Bilbo patted his wooden hand where it was resting on the table and nodded slowly.
“Indeed.”
Thorin stared for another moment, brows slightly furrowed in their familiar crease.
“How —?”
“Cough up, Balin, I said it’d be sooner rather than later, didn’t I, you wiley old scoundrel, don’t you cheat me out of my gold —“
The roaring of Gloin and Dori and Nori and Balin soon caused a complete descent into chaos, and Dís only sat very loftily at her seat in the centre of the table while Brynja tucked in raucously next to her. Her sons both looked truly pleased for their mother, if a little strained at all the rest of the antics, which had Bilbo suspecting either they or she had broached the subject prior to this morning, and he was pleased in turn for them.
Thorin’s wide, ever-blue eyes turned to him in complete shock. He seemed at a total loss of entirely anything to say, and when he saw the smug look on Bilbo’s grinning face, his eyes only narrowed.
“Did you —“
Bilbo held up a hand just as a little bag of money sailed across the room and into his palm with a snap, and smirked at the bearer of his heart.
“Oh,” he said ruefully, “I’m afraid I did.”
Dís’s advisors had preferred that she have a consort upon ascending to the throne, and Dís and Brynja hadn’t wanted to wait, anyway. They weren’t like Thorin and Bilbo, who had both been utterly asleep in terms of romance until they’d stumbled headfirst into each other and fallen unbelievably deep.
Dís had in the months since they’d met begun to call her her ruby, and when Bilbo’d first heard about it he rolled his eyes and simply muttered with a smile, “You dwarves and your precious metals and stones. Honestly.”
So at their whirlwind wedding, at one point later on in the night, he had found himself standing atop the dais with Dís, watching each of their spouses step on each other’s toes as they danced a jig while rip-roaringly drunk.
She breathed out a sigh, next to him, a kind one, and Bilbo turned to look at her inquisitively, one hand still clutching his glass of Elvish wine.
“He would have loved her,” Dís said, not looking at Bilbo, but watching her dear ruby dance with fire in her eyes, and Bilbo knew all at once that she meant the husband she’d lost a lifetime ago; Vili, who had been the father of her two sons. He smiled gently.
“I do believe you are blessed, your Majesty,” he said astutely. “Being watched over and loved by both the living and the dead, you must surely have the very greatest heart in all of Erebor.”
Dís looked to him then, smiling, and she looked so much younger that way, so much like both of her children that Bilbo had brought back to her, that he felt a wild, fleeting bolt of the long-ago sadness, so sharp that it brought tears to his eyes. He pushed it down hastily with a shake of the head.
Let’s not get too sappy here, Master Hobbit. This Elvish wine mustn't claim another victim!
“You are such an absolute flatterer, Bilbo Baggins,” Dís was saying to him. “I do not for a second imagine Thorin had a hope in hell he wouldn’t fall.”
Bilbo’s cheeks and ears turned a rather lovely carnation-pink.
Bilbo and Thorin had a long and lazy engagement, now that they had all the time in the world. There was no rush, and very often no organisation or agreement on anything, since they were attempting to mesh two very distinct sets of customs together into one that celebrated both of them. But Bilbo laughed more than he found himself becoming frustrated, and he rather enjoyed the wait, now that he had the time; now that they both had it.
“It’s tradition to weave flowers into the one you love’s hair for your wedding day, in the Shire,” he’d said one day, poring absently over a book in his beloved library while Thorin dithered about in the background doing who-in-the-Heavens knew what. “And hair is of course very important to your people as well.”
Distantly, Thorin grunted from the next aisle of shelves over, a sign that he was listening if not entirely pleased at whatever it was he was doing — there’d been rather a lot of thumping. Bilbo let go of the page he’d been idly tracing and scrunched his hands together in his lap.
“So I would like to braid your hair, and I would like you to braid mine. And I would like us both to wear flowers.”
The thumping stopped.
In the next moment, Thorin was there, standing by the same line of shelves as Bilbo, and he did not say a word, but his expression was such that Bilbo had to look away or else he was either going to laugh or turn an indescribable shade of scarlet.
“You will have to teach me first, of course,” Bilbo added, flustered, staring at the stretch of books immediately before him. Dwarven Recipes. Maybe he’d have to come back and scour this section a little when he wasn’t so otherwise preoccupied. Maybe he’d even slot some of his own books in. A Footnote: Recipes from the Four Farthings — By Bilbo Baggins, Yet Again!
A hand touched his chin, gently turning his face until he was looking up at Thorin and his wild, tender expression, his inexplicable eyes.
“Until you can do it as well as my own hand,” he said roughly.
(But engagements, as was the way, would all someday find themselves at an end.)
“Onward, then, you old thing?”
They were stood out in the open, at the base of the mountainside, the wind crisp and bright rather than chilling now that winter that year had broken, though snow still rested at the very peak of the Lonely Mountain, offsetting the rock with flecks of lily-white at the very tip of the sky. Bilbo was very aware of the fact that there was rather a large crowd of people all waiting impatiently on the other side of the outcrop they were currently hidden behind, but he could not find a single thing within himself that cared one bit about it.
Thorin Oakenshield turned to him, sliding his fingers, scarred and roughened as they were, across each of Bilbo’s own, where jewels would have sat if his wedding gift to Bilbo had been a ring. Instead, Bilbo wore the iron-and-sapphire woven flower Thorin had made for him in his breast pocket and lily-of-the-valley in his hair, his priceless forget-me-not and his long-awaited return to happiness.
Thorin brought Bilbo’s hand to his mouth to press a wiry kiss against the knuckles. His gaze had never lightened in the years since they had met, and his eyes looked over Bilbo with all the weight of the world, shining brilliantly in the sun. Bilbo shot him an especially silly grin, feeling like he was more than a little bit in a dream, and Thorin leant forward, then, curling his body into Bilbo’s and murmuring something into his ear in Khuzdûl.
(The language was still secret to those who were not blood kin, but he had whispered this one enough times that Bilbo knew now what it meant.)
“I love you like the Seven Stars.”
They entwined their arms so that Thorin could feel the press of his husband’s skin warm against his, and Bilbo looped his fingers in amongst the oaken ones of Thorin’s. The hand was sturdy and familiar, now, and he could trace each of the chips and cuts in it from memory with the very tips of his fingers.
And then, at last, they began to walk.
They stood across from one another at the front of the ceremony, and the King’s First Advisor was in charge of overseeing the proceedings, which of course meant that it was Balin who was smiling ardently at them as they reached him. The rest of their friends were spread across the stand on either side of him, all dressed in their finest, scattered with diamonds and sapphires and with little pink peonies pinned in their buttonholes.
The wedding was threaded all through with red and white and amber-gold, and there were snapdragons in Thorin’s hair and little white bells in Bilbo’s, and during the ceremony they each took a strand of the other’s chosen flower and wove it through their garlands until they wore matching crowns of crimson and cream.
Bilbo did not stop kissing Thorin for most of the day, and it very well might have gone against some sort of dwarven custom, for all he knew, but anyone who mattered already knew quite well that he was very much against listening to what others told him. He simply kept on insisting that their maker should not have made his husband so exceedingly beautiful to look upon — and anyone who looked at Thorin could see from leagues away that there was sunlight in his eyes.
Thorin played his harp at the mountainside party they threw afterwards; a haunting, lovely piece, deep and rich as the earth, with light licks of falsetto-notes and springtime flourishes that made Bilbo cry in a rather embarrassing outpouring of his happiness. He drank ale and wine and laughed with his friends and held his husband by the hand until his cheeks hurt so badly they might never stop aching with a smile.
It was not until the year 2968 of the Third Age, or 1368 of the Shire-Reckoning, as Bilbo sometimes had to remind himself now, that Bilbo bundled up his pack and made the journey back to the Shire, leaving his Thorin, and Fili and Kili and Balin and Bofur and every one of his nieces and nephews (for dwarves lived in very assorted families that all worked in tandem like one loving community, and Bilbo had surely done his fair share of raising Bombur’s cluster of children over the years) behind.
Of course Thorin had wanted to accompany him through the Misty Mountains and all the way to what had once been his door, but Bilbo had flatly, apologetically refused.
“You’ll meet him one day, I’m certain, but I think they might be a little frightened by a dwarf they don’t know, especially around their wee one. They’re all going to be frightened enough by me as it is, coming back after so very long away. They’ll think I’m some overgrown wildling who’s run off with the pixies.”
“I am not quite a pixie,” Thorin said quietly, in that tone he had when he was scowling just so it’d hide his smile.
Thranduil’s Elves walked him through the Greenwood, and the air was so lovely and fresh and light that Bilbo had resolved they should visit more when he was back home in Erebor, though he knew that really only Kili would be up for the idea, wild thing that he was. I wonder if Tauriel’s still hanging about, he thought with a wry grin. Perhaps they could rope in Gloin’s boy, too, while they were at it.
Beorn and his son walked with Bilbo through the Misties, blissfully clear of goblins after that awful battle but no less rocky and ragged. He stayed only a short while with Elrond, and although he was a little disappointed that Aragorn wasn’t there for him to say hello to, he knew he was off fighting battles and holding up kingdoms in the South, down in Rohan or Gondor or wherever the Ranger had chosen to conceal himself for the time being.
He led himself through the wild lands east of Bree, patting each of the stone trolls tenderly and carrying himself on his way. It felt like the stripping back of years, to be walking this path back to a place he hadn’t been in so very long, somewhere that lived only at the edges of his mind when he thought of his nephew fondly and missed him living in the world.
It took Bilbo a moment to set his feet over the edge of the Shirelands when he reached them. It wasn’t his home anymore, and hadn’t been for a long, long time. His home was in warm, rough arms and under piles and piles of mountain stone, and in lit torches and marbled walls and gruff greetings from everyone he walked past.
It didn’t matter, really, though, did it? He had the birth of a nephew to celebrate.
Bilbo looked up towards the hills in the distance, lifted his stick and walked on.
He’d cried like a newborn, like the very newborn he was holding, when he’d reached the heart of Buckland and finally saw and got to hold the swaddled shape of little Frodo.
He was so very young. Barely even a littlun! Just a darling, dainty little thing, fresh-faced and rose-pink, so very indescribably tiny in his old uncle’s arms. Bilbo’d never gotten to see Frodo this small. He couldn’t hardly believe it.
“You have such a brave little boy there, Primula,” he’d said thickly, ridiculous tears still streaming like may-ribbons down his cheeks, and she’d smiled like a sunflower, though he could tell she was a little bemused. She’d been rather young when he’d gone off on his adventure, after all. She likely hardly remembered him, and wasn’t quite sure why so geographically distant a relative seemed so dearly enraptured by her little boy. “The bravest in all the land.”
“I have not one doubt in my heart we do, Bilbo. But how in the world do you know?”
Frodo had blinked awake then, the sleepy, silly little thing, and begun to cry. Bilbo had tapped him softly on the nose with the tip of his finger.
“In his eyes.” He looked up at her, swaying back and forth to calm the little creature, and winked. “The dwarves have taught me secrets of theirs, you know. You can see it, if you know just where to look.”
And he’d looked back down, and thought what he could not say.
I missed you, dear boy. I am so very glad to see you again.
Their next life, at last.
Bilbo wrote Frodo all the time, through the years, and Frodo wrote him back, the letters increasingly filled with wonder and a little bit of cheek as he grew up and grew to know his queer old uncle halfway across the world. Bilbo sent him birthday presents every year, one for his own and one for Frodo’s even though it wasn’t Shire custom; carved wooden toys that moved and crushed ochres to paint with and once a little chest of precious jewels that he got a kind but very stern letter back from Drogo about. The Company always included their own bits and bobs, little notes to Frodo and woven dolls of dragons or dwarves, and Bilbo secretly wondered if they weren’t spoiling him too much — but sheer affection always won out, and Bilbo always explained it away to himself by saying that he hadn’t gotten to know Frodo as young the first time. Sometimes they even sent ravens with spoken messages for him, Väre and Vörn and the rest, though Bilbo could never quite tell if Frodo loved them or if he was bone-deep terrified of them.
Tell your parents that if they’re thinking of going for a float on the Brandywine, there’s a reason hobbits do not swim.
For Frodo’s twenty-first birthday, being that it was when Bilbo had first taken him in, Bilbo asked Brynja to paint a watercolour portrait of Frodo smiling, with flowers in his hair. He and Dís and Thorin sat by her, and Bilbo gently and meticulously explained the way Frodo’s dark curls hung around his ears, the bright hugeness of his blue eyes, his lithe brown fingers covered in moles. She wove white cups of lily-of-the-valley and dozens of yellow peonies through the brushstrokes of his hair, and all the while Bilbo felt Thorin stroking at the back of his neck with his well-worn, well-loved fingers.
Frodo wrote back quickly in excitable, grateful shock.
“Bilbo, how on Earth do you have any idea what I look like when you haven’t come to visit since I was still a faunt!”
“Oh, I can picture you in my mind’s eye when I read your letters, dear boy.”
Of course, to paint such a picture that they only had blue skies for all the rest of their lives would not be entirely realistic or truthful. There were disagreements, issues with the kingdom, issues with the small but infuriating bunch of councillors that seemed to loathe Bilbo no matter what he did. Issues with the Elves, now and again, for dwarves were nothing if not dependable in their feelings, though Bilbo had become excellent at smoothing those over, and he had his collection of Elvish allies in the Mountain now who were the more treacle-tongued among them. Gloin, for his part, never quite knew whether to be the proudest father or the most disappointed that his only son was the chief of the dwarves who were able to use their wit and words to lavish the Greenwood.
(And frankly, Bilbo was not sure if Gloin was aware that Gimli was also lavishing one Greenleaf in particular on these visits, so he opted to keep his nose out of such business.)
Thorin had days where he was more troubled than others, in the hand or the mind, and Bilbo occasionally had his own, too. And of course, they were themselves, so there was many a spat and many a making-up, though they were never too awful to each other, and loved each other all the more for their fire. They knew what to expect. There was nothing now that they could not weather, and they never needed to weather it for long.
By far the darkest of all the days, however, had been the day Bilbo discovered Balin Fundinson was still assembling his expedition to the Dwarrowdelf.
Though he hadn’t said it to them in his first telling of the story, unable to quite bear breaking their hearts so soon after the battle, Bilbo had gathered his dwarves once more, after Dís’s coronation, and explained the truth of Balin and Oin and Ori’s ends in Moria as gently and quickly as he could conceivably manage, not wanting to force them to linger on so inexplicable and violent a loss.
They had listened to his words, and discussed it, and he had answered each of their questions in a sheltered voice, eyes very resolutely fixed to the floor. Not one member of the Company had spoken of it again in all the decades since; there was no need. Not that Bilbo had thought.
But then had come the news.
He’d stormed up to Balin in a righteous rage, shaking so intensely with anger and with such sudden striking fear it was as though it was shaking the base of the Mountain itself. He could not believe it. Could not fathom in the slightest how even now Balin had chosen not to heed his story.
He held his index finger outward and jabbed it toward Balin’s puzzled face.
“How little do you value your own life?”
A weary look came over Balin, and Bilbo had known, then — that this was not at all on a whim, or an idea that had only recently crept once more into Balin’s head. His desperation and desire for their return to Khazad-dûm was so potently clear that Bilbo hated to steal it from him — but he could not even begin to allow the alternative.
“You are my friend, Balin, one of my very closest,” Bilbo said, his voice shaking, a burnt-out wick. “I would not lie. I never have. How is it you still will not believe the truth of my words, even decades after they have been said and proven to be true?”
“We have your foreknowledge, Bilbo,” Balin explained, gently. “We have information we did not, in our folly.”
“And you think foreknowledge is greater than the evils of Durin’s Bane? Even if you manage to single-handedly slaughter every orc in the godforsaken place, it is nothing like Smaug. It is nothing like any of you know. Frodo could barely speak of it at all.”
He swallowed, mouth entirely dry. There had been one truth that Bilbo had concealed, in his original second-hand telling of the tale, because to speak it aloud felt as if he were willing it into the world, as if he were cursing it, and though Bilbo believed wholeheartedly and entirely that they had managed to dodge the worst, it was so terrible a truth that he could not bring himself to invoke it.
But he must, now; there was no other way, and he grit his teeth against it.
“Balin,” Bilbo said quietly, “it killed Gandalf.”
That, as he’d suspected, did its job; Balin did not speak.
“He fell,” Bilbo told him, voice no louder than a whisper, his face twisting itself up. “He was brought back anew, later — but you are not wizards, Balin. You do not have the favour of the Blessed Realm on your side. All of you will die.”
There was a long, long, silence, in which his words settled, and Balin tried to stomach the enormity of the blow that Bilbo had dealt him.
“You are certain that none of us survived?”
Bilbo nodded, hating that he had to bear them bad news even still.
“It was Oin’s nephew who found you all, and who read Ori’s last tale written down on paper. It tore him to pieces. You can’t tell a soul. You must promise me. Balin.” He swallowed, and felt a hand like a lead of a tree settle on his shoulder, felt the plaintive weight of his gaze. Balin looked so torn, and Bilbo felt like he was stamping all over his beating heart. “I can’t let you die like that.”
In the end, it was enough that he had convinced his oldest friend of the truth of his word, and enough that Balin, eventually, after much struggle and more than a few tears of outright anger on Bilbo’s part, had listened.
Thankfully, the years went on. Kili received his Mastery in Music, and Fili in Healing, and they pestered their mother and her wife something awful every day they could, though anyone could see that Brynja loved it and gave every bit as good as she got, and that the King Under the Mountain would flush with pleasure whenever her family were all together.
Fili was a picture, and every day he grew only more and more regal, a perfect image of the future King as he always should have been. He looked the spitting image of his uncle, only with golden hair instead of dark, and it was some decades, in fact, before Bilbo realised that his nephew now had a beard down to the third button on his tunic and his moustache-braids had tripled in both number and thickness.
Gimli Gloinson, however, had come into his rather magnificent beard all at once, and loved nothing more than to make it a competition how long each of their beards were, though he very deftly skirted around Bilbo every time he did so. He was constantly at Kili’s ear querying him on when he was going to sprout some more hair on his chin, or challenging him to a spar in the ring, to see whose beard was really longer. It was a challenge Kili always failed, to good cheer; Gimli was fast becoming the most fearsome warrior in Erebor and indeed possibly in all the North, and only Bilbo was unsurprised.
Speaking of beards, there was now a rather long and luscious one being sported by his husband, though it had come in far more grey-speckled than his hair, and Bilbo had had to fight very hard not to tease too much when it began to make itself known. Truly, he thought it made Thorin look terribly handsome.
He watched as Thorin’s hair became a mirror of what it had been, silver-grey with gentle strands of dark rather than the other way around. He laughed and laughed when Bard’s hairline began to recede and the deadly Dragonslayer lost most of his thickness on top, sending up his blessings for the sturdiness of hobbit and dwarven hair and the fact that he could kiss that lovely widow’s peak until he was old and brittle-boned.
He reached ninety again, and then one hundred. On his eleventy-first birthday (which was really his one-hundred and ninety-second), the Lonely Mountain threw a party even grander than his first one; King Dís strung autumn leaves and gardenias and beautifully scented white orchids through the halls and all over the door to their chambers, to the disgruntled fondness of Thorin.
Bilbo sent invitations to the Bagginses, though he knew that it being Frodo’s coming-of-age meant he was under no obligation to come, and regardless, he had never made the long and hardy trek to the Mountain before. He sent invitations all over the Shire, actually, and took a satisfying sort of amusement in the thought of every hobbit seeing the address on the invitation and clutching their chests in horror at the mere suggestion of adventure. He dearly, dearly wished he could have watched Lobelia Sackville-Baggins open her postbox the morning it arrived.
(He’d decided to send Lobelia an additional gift aside from the usual that year, too, and very generously gifted her Brynja’s beautiful portrait of his beautiful husband from long ago. It had been years of Thorin complaining that he did not enjoy watching himself up on the wall, even if they’d tucked it away so he could only really be seen if one wanted to look, and so Bilbo had shipped it off with great haste when at last he’d thought of the idea. He’d laughed himself halfway to being ill at the thought of the scandalised expression on her face.)
Frodo came to the Mountain. He brought Drogo and Primula along, of course, and he was given pride of place in every one of the festivities. He really had grown like a sprout, long lanky limbs for a hobbit and that head of hair so dearly cherished in each of Bilbo’s memories.
“Your kingdom is beautiful, your Highness,” Frodo said earnestly to Thorin when the three of them first arrived, head swivelling this way and that like a child’s spinning top.
Thorin bent so he and Frodo were of equal height, looking upon him with that tenderness he so often kept to himself, though he was constantly bursting at the very seams with it, and Bilbo could see it plain as day now that he knew where to look.
“Don’t worry, kurkarukê. We do not use such formalities for any but the king here, and it is my sister’s kingdom now.”
Frodo bowed his head and lowered himself a little, then realised what he was doing and stiffened again with only a slight blush. His father had no such qualms, bending until he was a right-angle at the spine and muttering out an unintelligible Baggins-ish greeting to the King while beside her Brynja tried not to laugh. Primula only placed a hand on her husband’s shoulder and winked surreptitiously at Bilbo, who winked right back. Frodo greeted Dís in an even more polite voice than he’d greeted Thorin, and then Thorin straightened once more and clasped his hands behind his back, smiling.
“Would you like to see where your uncle defeated Smaug?” he asked, and Frodo’s big bluebell eyes lit up.
Much later in the night, after they’d both retired to bed, Bilbo and Thorin were woven again into each other like needle and thread, resting in the low lantern-light of the room they shared, dozing gently against the feel of each other’s skin, when Thorin said, “You love him so much, Bilbo.”
Bilbo’s ears flushed to a brilliant chartreuse, but he was awfully pleased.
“Of course I do. He will always be my boy, even when he reaches his 132nd year and outlives me and the Old Took both.”
Thorin smiled at him, then pressed his mouth to the corner of Bilbo’s forehead, closing his eyes. His hair was draped all over Bilbo; his skin smelt like home.
“Are you happy, muhudel?” he murmured. Bilbo smiled into Thorin’s collarbone so that he wouldn’t see it.
“Are you, you silly dwarf?”
He nestled further into Thorin’s chest, fiddling with the sets of beads clasping his braid that seemed to only have grown year by year — beads for royalty, for marriage, for family, for craftsmanship, for love, for love, for love.
“He’s a little younger,” Bilbo said. “Still smart as anything, but he didn’t have to grow up quite so fast, I don’t think. I’m glad for it. It is the best thing for him.”
“When you see him again, your kurkarukê,” Thorin said, and Bilbo knew he did not mean the Frodo only a few doors down from them in the hall, “you must tell him that he was brave.”
Bilbo closed his eyes and gave his husband a fractured sort of smile.
“I’m entirely sure he won’t listen, but I will tell him nothing else for all the rest of my days.”
Thorin picked up the nickname immediately upon laying eyes on Frodo and used almost nothing else. It led to a fair few days of Bilbo trundling around after him, pestering him about what the bloody hell it was he was saying, and pleading that someone just tell him or he would start threatening again to go mad. And at long last, when somebody finally felt a bit of pity and translated for him, Bilbo marched straight up to his stubborn, stone-headed husband and pulled him at once down into a long, long kiss, happiness beading at the corners of his eyes.
Kurkarukê. My tiny raven.
“You are so lovely, you thick-headed thing,” he said, and Thorin only rumbled out a laugh.
Frodo adored it. “Ma, they’ve given me a dwarvish nickname!” he said, fascinated, and Primula smiled and kissed him on the cheek.
“You should fetch us one before we leave as well, Frodo, so we can make all of Brandy Hall jealous.”
Dwarves, of course, did not do anything by halves, particularly when there was cause to create beauty with their own hands and express love for those they were fond of. So, of course, the celebrations went on for quite a few days — though there was only really one day that mattered.
They had feasts all day, feasts that Bilbo refused to let almost anyone else work on else they do it wrong for Frodo’s coming-of-age, and it was only for tea that he finally relinquished the reins of the kitchen and trotted off to catch a quick nap before the festivities.
He commissioned beads for each of the Company and for Dís and Brynja, and sent them onward along with a stash of baked goods prepared by his own hands and a note that said All your favourites. He gave Thorin a beautifully-stitched blue handkerchief with a smile, feeling the tips of his ears pink when his husband laughed and caught him by the hand. He gave Drogo and Primula an exquisite, oiled painting of the view of Bag End, described in painstaking detail to Brynja and based on his own rudimentary sketches and colourings. And to his dear Frodo, he gave now the first and only completed copy of his adventure written down.
Frodo handed him a set of five thick books, bound up with twine and pristine as if they had never been opened, though when Bilbo cracked the spines he knew instantly that they had, many times over. He stared at Frodo in baffled wonder.
“Lord Elrond told me these were the ones you might enjoy having on hand,” he said, smiling a little slyly like he knew just how well he’d done giving Bilbo his very favourites from the library in Rivendell.
“Oh, you are a menace and a half, and don’t think I don’t notice,” Bilbo grumbled, and pretended with a sniff and a one-armed hug that there were not tears in his eyes.
They had fireworks again, though this time it was over the old oak of Dale instead of the Party Tree in the Shire, and there was of course another dance, though Bilbo was very strict about the music and insisted in leading a song or two himself so Frodo’s birthday would still at least be half-proper and hobbitish. Frodo was flattered and bashful and overjoyed and humbled at all of it.
“Sam who lives down the row isn’t even going to believe this, I already know it!” he exclaimed.
Dís and Brynja were the centre of the party as they always were, and by now their people would roar and cheer around them as they danced, the entire scene a dazzling spectacle. Bilbo privately thought that either one of them was rather close to receiving an epithet about it, though he wasn’t at all sure what it would be. Perhaps something like Dís Firefeet, or Brynja Rubyshoes, he chuckled to himself.
Every moment felt like he was threading stitches through cloth, mending a tear in both halves of his life so that they became one with each other. He’d spent endless nights with Frodo in front of the fire in Bag End, telling him of the odd beauty and coldness of the Mountain, doing imitations of each of his dwarves and telling him that you could see the dragon’s skeleton still stretching eerily out of the water if you looked in the right places. It felt deeply, bittersweetly natural to finally be able to show Frodo a place so central to his life, and he hoped, somehow, that every moment this Frodo spent smiling healed a different Frodo far away.
He still had not felt any true signs of weariness, even though his body was miles older than it had been under the fireworks in the Shire, and the grey of his hair had faded in naturally rather than hurtling headfirst into him almost overnight. Thorin was much older too, and yet he held as much strength and wit and grumbliness as ever.
It was only when he reached his one-hundred-and-twentieth year that Bilbo wondered if maybe there was a reason he was still stubbornly sticking around despite the Ring being nothing but a memory. He wondered if he would make it again. It’d be an extraordinary feat; he would have lived an entire lifetime longer than even some dwarves. But Bilbo felt in his heart that there was a reason he was waiting, frailer and older but still as spritely as ever with his husband by his side. And every day that dawned he knew he would’ve given everything for just one more morning with Thorin.
Then, at last, the Lonely Mountain finally received word, first by raven and then from Gandalf himself, that King Elessar had at long last defeated Saruman the Many-Coloured and returned to the throne of Gondor, and Bilbo knew his time was slowly coming.
He asked Thorin to walk with him. Thorin shot back that he wouldn’t have ever let him go alone, you ridiculous thing, my Bilbo.
(So many of Bilbo’s mannerisms had slipped into Thorin’s speech over the years that his parents would probably be horrified when he made it to the Halls of Mahal, which Bilbo knew he was near. They had been holding on for each other, and Bilbo’s journey to the western shore would likely be Thorin’s last in this life. He had never been so over the sun and the moon to see someone’s hair turn completely white.)
It was in early spring of the year 3021 that Bilbo Baggins and Thorin Oakenshield made their preparations to depart from Erebor, packing what little things they would need for travel and the small knick-knacks Bilbo could not quite bear to part with. It didn’t take long. He was well and truly getting on in years, now, and all he needed already lay where he was going.
They slipped away without fanfare. Thorin would return, and bring Bilbo’s blessings with him, but Bilbo knew that his friends in the Company would be all right. He had gotten more time with them then he ever expected, and all of them knew every bit of what he had done for them.
It was slow-going, the journey, and the two of them gave themselves ample time — time enough to rest, for they were far older, now, and the trip was not an easy one. But they managed, stopping in with friends and allies and stocking up on their supplies, resting their aches and pains and taking care not to push themselves further than they could. The journey was kind, if not easy, and each day, Bilbo leant on his stick and wove his fingers through his husband’s. The sunshine as they walked was so warm.
He thought briefly of stopping in Hobbiton on their birthday to say goodbye to his boy, but there was no need. Bilbo had written him a letter, leaving him every single one of his possessions, telling him he had thirteen uncles and two aunts waiting should he ever want for anything at all. Wishing him well.
And anyhow, he would see Frodo very soon.
There had been a small ship readied for Bilbo. Nobody else was departing, but Bilbo had heard many tales by now of the foresight of those who had borne the Three, and none held more than Círdan the Shipwright of the Grey Havens, though he bore Varya no longer.
They stood on the shore a long time, the two of them, once they reached their destination, the sea-wind in their hair and in the white of Thorin’s beard. There was colour all around, held in the sky and the shoals and the crests of the water lapping gently at the docks. There was not one moment they took their eyes off each other, though Thorin’s eyes were dry, and so were Bilbo’s. There was no cause for tears, after all. Bilbo knew now that they would not ever say a final goodbye.
He would simply be sailing away into the glow of the sun. He would watch the white shores until he could no longer see them, and he would smile.
His husband took his hand, the skin crumpled up and thin as paper, now; lifted it to his mouth, and kissed the back of it. Thorin kissed his knuckles, then, and his fingertips, looking very intently at Bilbo. They watched each other amidst the breeze.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said very softly.
“Yes?”
Bilbo smiled.
“I think I might be ready for another adventure.”
And then he spoke one final time, whispering against the corner of his dear heart’s mouth, an exhaled kiss; one of countless, a whole lifetime, and the words carried through all the rest of the ages of the world.
“Wait for me in your halls, dear heart. We’ll find a way. We’ve done it before, haven’t we?”
