Chapter Text
It wasn’t long before the lands that stretched out before them grew flatter and drier, and the paths became speckled with little white stones that glowed in the moonlight and basked in the warm summer sun.
All distinctive signs of Elves, Bilbo realised. They’d almost reached Rivendell; he’d felt it in the air once they’d crossed over the border of the Wildlands and into the Hidden Valley.
The Company were almost at the Ford of Bruinen when the grumbling of the dwarves started to get louder and longer, and Bilbo knew that his friends had realised their proximity, too.
(He tried not to take too much notice of their utter disdain of a place he had so loved. He knew they meant no harm.)
“Looks very quaint,” Nori said shrewdly once they'd finished the trek up the long and winding road, eyeing the smooth walls in the distance that looked so delicate they could have been blown over with one breath. A chorus of assenting grunts rang through the party.
“Looking at it too long hurts my eyes,” Kili agreed loftily, haughty look on his face and his chin tilted upward. Myrtle tossed her hair back and whinnied, stamping a hoof on the ground.
“You and me both, girl,” Bilbo said quietly. He wouldn’t begrudge them their feelings, but Bilbo was glad that at the very least it was not Thranduil who lived in the Valley of Imladris; things could have gone pear-shaped rather quickly, and then he wouldn’t have gotten to enjoy his lovely armchair by Elrond’s fire.
(Bilbo, of course, did not realise until later that evening that because of the whole slipping-back-through-time-somehow business, this armchair was nowhere to be found because he himself had not yet placed it there, and he had to compose himself very quickly so he didn't kick up a great fuss.)
Though he’d made the choice to leave it behind, Rivendell had been Bilbo’s home in the latter years, when his body had started to fail and he could no longer withstand the grating gazes of every hobbit in the Shire. To breathe the air that whispered through the leaves above them again, and to watch the sky break over the glittering-white rooftops of the Last Homely House, brought Bilbo a renewed calm he had not realised until then he’d been in need of, and he felt swiftly reassured that he was on the right path.
The sun and moon were crossing their paths at dusk when the Company reached the bridge across the Hidden Valley and gazed more closely upon the house of Elrond. In the distance, Bilbo could see the tall, graceful figures of Elves descending the stairs to meet them, robes swirling at their feet.
At once, the dwarves seemed to converge around each other in a ring, hands reaching without thinking for weapons and dark looks on their faces, shielding one another with their bodies. Any trace of the joking and jibing from earlier had vanished.
“Stay sharp,” Bilbo heard Thorin mutter to some of the others behind him, and he let out an irritated huff, sending the hair in front of his eyes fluttering.
If there was one thing about the Shire he was glad of, it was that hobbits had made no enemies, and that they were wary of all other peoples in the world equally. To do otherwise was bothersome beyond belief, and to be amongst others that held such contempt for each other rather felt like Bilbo had walked into his own home to find someone had trod mud all through the carpet. The dwarves were very well just lucky he already liked them so much, and the Elves were fortunate they were so unceasingly polite.
(Bilbo knew in his heart they had their reasons to be wary, which made holding onto his annoyance all the more difficult. He knew their usual relationships with outsiders; he’d seen and heard tell of them himself. He just wished he could explain that it was Elrond, who'd befriended dwarves before, and who would never, ever harm them, and if they could all just settle down a little, it would make things much easier.)
It was Elrond who came to greet them, along with Lindir and an exceedingly graceful blond fellow Bilbo thought might have been called Glorfindel. Loud, renewed grumbling erupted behind him when Gandalf began to converse with Elrond in Sindarin, and Bilbo very maturely did not roll his eyes when they ceased immediately following the offer of food.
“It is my hope that you will all feel welcome here for as long as you may care to stay,” Elrond Halfelven called. His eyes swept over each of them, and over Bilbo most especially, who forced himself to keep his eyes up and his breathing even. Gandalf thanked Elrond generously, craftily concealing Thorin’s scowl with his own body, and soon the three Elves turned to lead them away.
It was a distinctly strange feeling to Bilbo, as the group made their way up the steps, having to pretend like he didn’t know all of it like the back of his hand, like he hadn’t befriended some of the very Elves who greeted them years beforehand. He placed himself deliberately toward the back of the pack, out of any lines of questioning or curiosity, and simply trailed along after them all to gaze out at the Valley of Imladris.
There were lush trees of evergreen and silver-white waterfalls cascading like pearls down the walls of rock lining the valley, and the light of the fading sun blending with the moon in the sky washed all around it in a rosy red-gold. It was nothing short of breathtaking. It had always been that way, for Bilbo, and he knew that the picture of Rivendell resting on the edges of the valley, as if placed there by beings older than time itself, would linger steadfast in his memories for as long as he lived.
Lindir and possibly-Glorfindel departed, and they were soon being led by two unfamiliar Elves in long robes down the winding paths of the Elven realm when Balin fell back into step beside him and said, “You look as if you’ve seen all the treasures of the world at once, laddie.”
“Oh, Balin, don’t pretend like you’re not a little impressed by all this!” Bilbo watched Balin chuckle beside him, then tilted his head up to look at the last rays of daylight filtering in, casting golden shadows against the wall opposite them. “It’s like magic.” Balin smiled kindly at him.
“I wish you could have seen the Mountain in its prime,” he said, and Bilbo could hear how ancient the homesickness was in his voice, how tethered he was to the memory of Erebor and its warm marble halls. Balin nodded towards the other dwarves in front of them, some of them knocking into each other and cracking jokes, some silent as stone and watching the Elves in front of them warily. “I wish they had all seen it. There was nothing like to it in the world. There is nothing at all like the Dwarf Kingdoms in any other places, and most of all the ones we have lost, but Erebor in the height of her glory was grand beyond measure.”
“It sounds beautiful,” Bilbo said gently.
Balin turned to look behind them, to where Elrond was taking long, slow strides and speaking with Gandalf in low voices, and then looked back at Bilbo, the white in his hair and beard catching the shine of the rising moonlight.
“Aye. Thorin misses it more than anything, and I cannot forsake him that. It is written into his very blood. I would be a traitor and a fool if I had not accompanied him on this quest.”
“Are you and he close?” Bilbo asked softly.
Balin smiled. “I’ve known him almost all my life, and he’s known Dwalin since he was a wee lad. Thorin has always been my friend before he is my King, and he will always be both.” A sadness crept into his eyes, suddenly, dimming them. “I know it seems as though he’s hard on you, Bilbo, but -”
“Oh, please don’t, Balin!” Bilbo cried. He ducked his head. “I don’t mind. I know it may not appear that way, but - I do understand. It doesn't bother me.” He did not miss the doubtful look Balin gave him.
“I know you all can have a hard time with outsiders. Hobbits are like that, too,” he explained. “We keep to our own, and we can be downright sceptical and unkind, if any Elves or Men or dwarves chance across our path. Even Shire-hobbits find the Breelanders strange for cohabiting with the Big Folk.” And their pipeweed was truly atrocious.
“As for me, though," Bilbo said, "I don’t feel I’m much like anyone else in Hobbiton, or even the Westfarthing. I was once, and I’m sure I would have been horrified by you all charging headlong into my house and ransacking my cupboards, but I gave up on that a long time ago.” He could feel himself smiling, and he turned his face away from Balin, always trying to hide the fondness that burst from him at the sight of them. “I care much more now for comfort than politeness, and I don’t mind if that makes me the oddest hobbit in all the Shire.”
Bilbo did not accompany Balin or Thorin or Gandalf to read the moon-runes that night. He didn’t need to; he knew them well enough he could have recited them from memory, and he did not wish to give Thorin a reason to distrust him even more. Instead, he took to weaving and wandering around the halls of Rivendell and reminiscing with a clarity his mind hadn’t had when he’d visited them last.
It was more of a bittersweet experience than he had expected. Instead of seeing places where he’d smiled or feasted with friends or where he’d gone on walks in the gardens, Bilbo found himself recognising spot after spot where he remembered falling asleep, or waking up from a nap, or closing his eyes and having to shake his greying head a little to recall what it was he’d just forgotten. He was realising with an almost overwhelming amount of shame what his life had truly been like after relinquishing… relinquishing Isildur’s Bane.
I am not sure if it was good for my heart, he thought, for me to stay here so long.
Not for as long as he had, at least. Rivendell’s valleys and vast halls had been love at first sight the moment Bilbo had first crested its hill, and he had found comfort nowhere in the world more than he had here, with the Elves and their endless music. But the longer he’d remained here at the end of his life, the more it had felt like a daydream, a blur that shifted and blew in the wind and never quite sharpened.
Dinner that night, however, was as outrageous an affair as always. Lettuce leaves and bits of bread flew every which way over their heads, and burgundy elfwine slopped over the sides of cups, and there was much thumping and thudding on the tops of all the tables. Bilbo astutely kept his manners and politely nibbled on all the dishes they’d been offered, but he chuckled along with everyone else at the boisterousness of the dwarves - and really, it was awfully amusing how startled all of the Elves looked.
Too, Bilbo was thoroughly enjoying the chance to eat a full, respectable, hobbit-sized meal for once, and was not going to pass up any sort of reprieve from their travelling rations (as grateful as he was for all of Bombur’s efforts).
Bilbo realised after he’d reached back to fill his plate for a fourth time and caught a couple of wayward glances that he was most probably drawing attention to another one of his oddities. In his defence, however, and the defence of his home, none of them knew it was odd outside the Shire to eat seven square meals a day, and Bilbo still rather thought the oddity lay on the rest of Middle-Earth, not on hobbits.
“You sure can put some food away, Master Baggins!” Kili called just as Bilbo was swiping at a bit of cranberry sauce with his thumb to stick into his mouth. Bilbo smiled and popped a couple more walnuts in for good measure, chewing them on one side.
“And proudly, Kili! How is anyone to know if you’ve enjoyed your meal if you don’t look it by the end?”
Their faces at that seemed a little blank - aside from Dwalin’s, who muttered out a snide, “Don’t know how you enjoyed that meal” - and in the silence Bilbo remembered another of the complexities he knew lay between hobbits and dwarves.
It was a fact that dwarves ate for survival. Their portions were quite small when compared to their sturdiness and strength, and their food was colourless and strict and made for filling rather than for enjoying. They lived a life of necessity borne from long years of struggle through the harsh seasons of Middle-Earth.
Hobbits, however, ate for joy. Their meals were made of love and life, and every vegetable and fruit and piece of game was tended with nothing but care. Meals were for sharing, and eating a belly’s worth of food could only ever make one healthier, even if you grew wider than you did tall.
Bilbo looked at them all dearly, and decided he’d lost all care for propriety a long time ago.
“You know, if you were all hobbits, my mother would have sat you down and tied you to the table until you had at least three good meals in you. Proper meals, mind, not any of that travelling jerky or soup.”
“Or lettuce leaves?” Ori asked. Bilbo rolled his eyes fondly.
“When we take back Erebor,” he said, “I promise I’ll make you all the grandest feast that has ever been in or outside the Shire!”
His outburst was met with a pleased sort of bemusement from them all. “You have already made us a feast, Mr Bilbo,” Gloin said. “Two, in fact.” Bilbo wrinkled his nose.
“Well, I am a Took as well as a Baggins, Master Gloin, and Tooks believe that there are more than a few occasions where you can be happy, and if good healthy eating is what brings that to a person, then I don’t see any problem. Cooking for you all is how I feel I can best - ah, show my affection.”
He coughed into the silence. What a terribly awkward finish. He floundered, hastily trying to continue.
“What I mean is that I suppose we show our care in different ways than others. A warm meal all together, and seeing the flowers dance in the fields, and a silly chat about absolutely nothing of importance with a friendly face… those things are what bring hobbits together. Although,” he laughed tightly, refusing to let his smile drop, “I must confess, I’ve never been quite as good at that last part.”
“What are you talking about?” chimed Fili in surprise. “Bilbo, you’re the chattiest creature any of us have ever met. You make great conversation!”
Bilbo’s mouth pulled then into a thin line. “Not according to hobbits, I don't,” he said wryly. “I - well, I am seen as standoffish, among them. I am not a socialite, and I don’t care to associate with people whom I don’t like, which I’m a little ashamed to say is most people. And I have never quite gotten the gift of the gab, as they see it in the Shire. Most hobbits spend their days enjoying the simplest things, but it means that quite a lot of the time, there is nothing to do except talk about what other people are doing. There’s a very fine art to it, and I am most certainly no artist.”
“So, as an example, you might hear from your next-door neighbour who was told by her cousin that lives over the Hill and across the Water who saw it happening in someone’s field one day that Daisy Baggins and Griffo Boffin had begun an understanding with each other, even though Daisy was far too young for him and in fact her parents had gotten into a spot of grief a few years prior when Dudo Baggins had kissed Gerda Bolger instead of his wife Paisley Proudfoot at the Midsummer’s Party, and then Paisley had gone on to have an affair with the Master of Buckland’s brother right afterwards and that’s how they’d ended up with Daisy in the first place!”
Bilbo finished his tirade and was met with thirteen nonplussed faces staring back at him. He solidified the point by waving his arms.
“You see what I mean! It’s all sticky-beaking nonsense, and most of them already think I’m a few marbles short of a bag, never mind the fact that I refuse to talk to them if I don’t want to.” He sniffed importantly. “Nasty, uncomfortable business, if you ask me. But anyhow - the point I am trying to make is, it took me quite a while to realise I was never made for the ins and outs of conversation in the Shire, so I like to cook for my friends instead. And - well, I suppose that is now… all of you.”
It became very quickly apparent to Bilbo that the silence had stretched on for far longer than it should have, and that he’d filled it with nothing but drivel about nonsense and the petty Shire squabbles he loathed. He did not look in any of the dwarves’ eyes, and determinedly fixed his own somewhere in the middle-distance, feeling his cheeks ripen red as raspberries.
He wished pitifully that he could withhold himself from rambling so very much, but it was them, and he could not help it.
“You are a kind, strange little fellow, Master Baggins,” someone spoke up suddenly. It was Balin, and he was smiling, his eyes twinkling in that way Balin had of somehow always seeming to know more than he let on. “I cannot imagine that any other hobbit we brought along on our journey would have been quite like you.”
The tips of Bilbo’s ears were still aflame, but his heart softened, and he blinked. Across the table, Bofur threw one of the dainty bread-rolls at him. Bilbo picked it up and stuffed it in his mouth cheekily, smiling from ear to ear.
Towards the end of their fortnight-long respite in Rivendell (one week and five days, when being exact), the sun was just starting to float through mid-afternoon, and Bilbo’s eyes were slowly lulling into their usual post-lunchtime doze, when he was approached directly by Elrond Peredhel.
He stood at once, immediately feeling a little silly, but holding his ground against the way his dwarves were all looking on nosily, in the midst of wringing out and rebraiding their damp hair after gallivanting in the Elves’ fountains. Kili had the gall to raise an eyebrow at him, and Bilbo indignantly scrunched up his nose in response. Bofur snorted.
Gandalf, who had been standing against the balcony with the wind blowing through his beard, made to move towards Elrond, but Elrond held up a hand to still him. His eyes were fixed with intrigue on Bilbo, though outwardly he ever showed nothing but calm.
“I would like to speak with the halfling alone, if I may,” he said, gazing at Bilbo a moment longer, before turning to look at Gandalf, who was leaning on his staff with both hands and tilting the brim of his hat upwards. The wizard pushed his lips together so they wrinkled; something Bilbo had noticed after so many years that he especially liked to do when he felt vexed, and Bilbo’s mouth twitched very slightly.
“With Bilbo?” Gandalf said, something not quite a question in his voice. Elrond inclined his head slowly.
“It will not take long, and Mr Baggins can tell me your tale,” he continued. He turned once again to watch Bilbo with that penetrating gaze. “It is clear to me he has travelled a very long way.”
Bilbo’s heart sped at once up into his throat and then collapsed down somewhere among his intestines.
Well, it really was only a matter of time.
He could see Thorin in the corner watching him warily, as always. Their eyes met only briefly: one set wide, one set narrowed, and Bilbo looked away. He swallowed hard, then smiled quickly without showing any teeth.
“Of course, my lord Elrond,” Bilbo said. He glanced over at Gandalf’s pursed expression, then around at the dwarves leaning in now to watch, both curiosity and suspicion painting their faces; Fili, Kili, Dwalin, Gloin. “I’d love to visit the library as well, if I may? I’ve heard from - ah, others - that your books are glorious.”
Elrond smiled, nodded once more, and swept from the room, his hands clasped in front of him and hidden by the fall of his elven robes.
They wandered through the library in tense silence, Bilbo anxiously touching at the spines of all the books he had loved over the years, towards the end of his life, trying to ground himself. None of them were dusty. Bilbo didn’t know if it was because the elves were so well-read, because they were such avid cleaners, or because a magic lay over the room that protected everything within. He had a sneaking suspicion it was all three.
It was Bilbo who broke the silence first, unable to bear it a moment longer.
“What is it exactly that you know, Elrond?”
The Elf looked down at him, then around the room, before pushing open the pair of doors nearest to them and indicating that Bilbo should follow.
They strode out into a sunroom with curved windows and gaps in the butter-white walls where the smell of flowers was drifting in. The light in here was softer, more yellow, and it made Bilbo think of marmalade on toast, apricots and peaches. Yellow peonies.
“We have met elsewhere, Bilbo Baggins,” Elrond said, peering down at him with that same composure he’d kept in all the days Bilbo had known him. The darkness of his hair was pulled back in a high arc from his forehead. “Though it has not yet happened here.”
Bilbo bowed his head. There wasn’t any point in denying it. Elrond possessed sight further than those of them who were mortal, and even than those who lived forever. If there was anyone in Middle Earth who could have seen the truth of Bilbo’s mind and memories, he should've guessed it would have been him, descendant of Númenor and of the High Elves, bearer of one of the Three, father to Arwen Evenstar. There was no path out of this but the one that lay forward.
“Yes.” Bilbo looked up and saw that calm coolness still there. He smiled a little crookedly. “We were great friends, too; I hope you saw that in your foresight. You have been very kind to me, Elrond. I owe you a great deal.”
With a grave smile, Elrond said, “And I, too, owe you and your kin, I think."
With no small amount of horror, Bilbo felt his smile begin to wobble.
Oh, Frodo.
The feeling only worsened when a crease appeared across Elrond’s forehead, and he leant a little closer to Bilbo, having to bend his back to reach down to Bilbo’s height. The closeness stung at Bilbo’s skin. He could not even hold Elrond’s gaze.
“Something troubles you,” Elrond said quietly.
Any of Bilbo’s attempts at maintaining a calm demeanour dropped, and he strode over to the window to escape it, knowing more so than hearing that Elrond followed. His thoughts were very rapidly spiralling downwards, and the sting became sharper and sharper.
“You know I am from the past?” he asked plainly, without beating around the bush, and sensed Elrond nod behind him.
“Though for us, you have passed through time not yet lived.”
Bilbo tugged at the bottom of his waistcoat, tilted his head sideways for a beat, and then opened his mouth.
“And do you know what it is that happened before I came here?” he asked, turning to face the Elf stiffly, his chin set so it did not tremble. Elrond’s expression remained astoundingly neutral.
“Not all of it is clear; that is not how foresight is given to those of us who possess it,” he said. “But yes, Bilbo Baggins. I have seen glimpses of what you and your nephew will bear. Who shall fall in the war. Who shall rise from the ashes.” His eyes seemed to glance back towards the door, and Bilbo startled at the sudden realisation that Aragorn son of Arathorn had grown up in Elrond’s home - would be living here now.
The thought was utterly bizarre. Little King Elessar. Little Estel, rushing around the woods with a giddy ten-year-old smile. Chief of the Dúnedain indeed.
I wonder what the Ranger looks like with missing front teeth.
He turned back to the window, stepping up onto the ledge against the wall and rising on his toes to look out at the world beyond. He folded his arms and rested them atop the windowsill.
Bilbo imagined then Frodo’s wonder, seeing it for the first time, how he’d have looked up at the magic of the trees, and a dreadful lump caught in his throat.
“I am thankful that I have been given a chance to come back to the ones I love,” Bilbo said softly, “thankful beyond all explanation, and I do not wish at all to be anywhere other than here, but… I cannot help but wonder if I deserve it, or if I should have stayed behind to care for Frodo as he cared for me.”
He had been thinking it for a while, in the smallest corners of his mind, and the thought had become louder and larger with every eastward step he took. He almost wondered if saying the words aloud would undo the spell. Maybe even the feeling of doubt itself that he’d done the right thing would be enough to revoke Bilbo's second chance.
“I was losing myself by the end, Elrond. My mind would escape from me more often than not. I could barely use my body. All my age had caught up to me at once, I think, and it did not let me tend to him the way I should have after he came back. But I am in this body again, and I feel every morsel of guilt and anguish that I could not when my mind was gone, and I remember the dreadful way he was, so I cannot help but feel that it is not fair so heavy a burden was placed on such a gentle soul when it was I who brought the burden to light.”
Elrond looked down at him, not unkindly.
“It is a miracle you have been given, not one that you must earn through your actions. Though I do not think anyone would argue that it is one you do not deserve.”
Bilbo laughed dryly, not smiling. “But why me?” he said, more to himself than his companion. “Why me? I thought about it - for so many years I thought about what it would be like if I could - but it was him who lost everything!”
He let his head fall forwards and pressed his forehead against his arms. “I am just one silly old hobbit, and my Frodo-lad saved Middle-Earth, and they gave me my life back instead of giving him his. You remember, Elrond. You must have seen the way he was on that ship. I have - I’ve never seen him like that. That thing utterly destroyed him, and I gave it to him.”
That thing. Isildur’s Bane. The dreaded thing, the looming danger on the horizon, the gold that crept at Bilbo’s shoulders and raked all through his mind.
The One Ring, the Ruling Ring, waiting in the mountains for him to claim it.
How could he in good conscience let Frodo go through that again? Bilbo felt torn in two, like he was crawling towards the only thing he’d ever wanted, had yearned for with all his heart, and yet it was like he was trodding on the shoulders of his dear boy. Bilbo could hear him on the wind the further east they went.
Where are you, Bilbo? Why do you look ahead?
And when he turned back, it became Thorin’s murmur, the rumble of twelve other voices.
Where are you, Bilbo? Why do you look behind?
“I thought that coming here," he said, "meant that my pain would leave me be. I thought it was to bring me peace. That is what they told me.”
Elrond’s voice was steady as he spoke to Bilbo. “There is more complexity to peace than many with finite lifespans truly understand. You must make peace also with the things that have happened to you. The things you have or have not done.”
The last sentence slammed into Bilbo like a punch to the stomach.
He hadn’t done anything at all, had he? He’d unearthed the source of all evil in the world and delivered it with his nephew to where the teeth of Death could snap at him.
He had destroyed his own flesh and blood.
So much for your protection, then, wasn’t it, Mad Old Baggins?
Bilbo lifted his head, and turned once more, unable to even bring himself to look out the window anymore. His blurring eyes wouldn’t adjust to the light.
“Your life was tampered with, and the Dark Lord sought to hurt and warp you while you were in possession of the One Ring," Elrond said calmly. "You aged irregularly. Your body and mind were dangerously stretched out, and your life was touched by its power, no matter how little you used it by the end. You may not have been scarred by his Ring in the way your nephew was, for his wounds ran much deeper than almost all others in Middle-Earth, and he carried a weight heavier than all of us will ever know. But you bear the scars nonetheless.”
“He should not have had to carry it!" Bilbo burst out angrily. "Why is it that I have been given this life to live again, when he only got to live half of one before I stole the rest from him? I have the gift of my heart given back to me beyond the grave itself, a wonder I could have never dreamed of, and yet it is Frodo who has had to pay the price!”
Elrond, though benevolent and kind, had never been the most gentle person Bilbo had met, but there was sorrow in his face, and Bilbo had to look away. His eyes were hot, the skin around them itching with every built-up, unshed feeling in his body, and he stubbornly ignored all of it.
“It was Mithrandir who explained this to you, was it not? You and Frodo Baggins have both been in the clutches of great evil, and both of you were instrumental in its destruction. His peace will come to him, but your peace is here, and so you have been brought to find it instead.”
He folded the edge of his cloak down, and rose to his full height once more, looking down at Bilbo. “There were those of the Elder Days who made the choice you also have made, Bilbo Baggins. Those offered a life of healing from their hurt in the Undying Lands, but who instead chose to stay, and to remember. Those who would rather a mortal death with their loved ones returned to them than to live in bliss but have forgotten.”
Elrond had never looked so intensely at Bilbo as he did at that moment, and he spoke again. “It is better that he forget. The one he loves will follow him, when it is time, into the West. But the one you love was taken from you. It is better for you to remember.”
If only Bilbo could have seen Frodo again, after the ship. Just to say goodbye to him. Just to explain, in his right mind, all that he was sorry for, and all that he hoped for Frodo, and all that he wished he could have given him. Just to tell him where he was going.
Elrond reached over Bilbo’s head and pressed a hand against the window so it opened outward and let the afternoon breeze in. They could see the leaves moving in the tallest trees, the pollen floating gently past. He pulled his hand away.
“You are the first and only bearer to let go of the Ring of your own will,” he said. “It does not touch you anymore. Now you must find all the years that you lost to it.”
Bilbo hoped that wherever Frodo was, far in the West and away from him, that he had his toes in the grass, and that he was smiling.
It was much later when Bilbo Baggins was perched on the uppermost ramparts of the Last Homely House of Elrond Halfelven, his bare feet dangling over the side of the ledge and brushing against the breeze. His silhouette fell like a painting against the sky, the archway behind him outlined in shadow; a dark and lonely figure sitting on the floor and illuminated in the deep midnight-blue that crested the hours between very late and very early. Tiny stars were scattered across the horizon like faraway jewels.
The dinner festivities that night had long settled, and he imagined that everyone else was now sleeping soundly in the decadent halls below him, mouths open and snoring something awful the way they always did.
Bilbo was so entirely lost in his own thoughts beneath the never-ending sky that footsteps approached him closely before he heard them at all.
“You seem to enjoy it here, Master Baggins,” the low voice murmured. He did not phrase it as a compliment.
And of course it was Thorin; nobody else other than the two of them was ridiculous enough to be awake at this hour, and nobody else spoke with that formidable tone, rough and yet resounding throughout all the valley. It seemed that Thorin could not leave Bilbo well enough alone, in either death or in life.
Bilbo sighed softly and looked down into the cleft far below.
“I do not have the same problem with our hosts that you all do, so yes, I like it here very much. The days are content. And the library is beautiful.”
“Is that what you wish for your life?" Thorin questioned. "To find peace and settle down with your books?”
He hadn’t spoken altogether mockingly, but Bilbo could feel the disdain that simmered in every word; the belief that a hobbit from somewhere as quaint as the Shire could never understand what true hardship was, and that he had nothing to run from.
“Would it be so bad if it was?” Bilbo asked simply, turning his head to the side and just catching the outline of Thorin at the edge of his vision.
There wasn’t any need to be rude. Bilbo knew it was a tall ask in present company, but really.
“I think,” said Thorin lowly, that same indifference in his voice, and a distant pang ran through Bilbo at how far from warmth it still was, “that if you are under the impression you will find such contentment where we are headed, you are sorely mistaken.” Bilbo bristled at once.
“Well, I think that’s a very presumptuous thing for you to say, and that you don’t know me half as well as you think you do, Master Oakenshield.” He stood and turned around properly, and Thorin was standing across from him, arms folded against his broad chest so it was as though he’d been shaped from cold marble. His cheekbones gleamed in the washed-out starlight.
“I am not wrong in knowing that you are a creature of comfort, Master Baggins.”
“And what is that supposed to mean?” Bilbo countered crossly. “Softness doesn't have anything to do with weakness, and I'll thank you not to imply that it does.” He tilted his head and looked up into the coolness of Thorin’s face, eyebrows furrowing.
Where are you in there, dear heart? Why won’t you open your eyes?
He’d known, of course he’d known, what Thorin would be like at first. He’d counted on it. Bilbo knew with absolute certainty that he would not in a thousand ages have been able to handle Thorin Oakenshield as he was by the end at their second first-meeting.
And yet he could not untangle the blackness in his mind at the thought that still he had to wait for his heart to come home. To be confronted with him so closely pulled at the painful freshness of Bilbo’s wounds, and he clenched his jaw against the sudden pressure in his own head. All of Elrond’s whispers of pain and of tragedy without cause were still echoing in his mind. The world was becoming muffled.
And something else the Elf had said to him, too; Bilbo folded in on himself at the window with his head bowed and throat constricted, Elrond standing tall beside him, cloaked in pale white and gold and his head aloft in that slow, regal way.
“I worry that you feel this guilt for your nephew so potently because your mind has not yet accepted that you are with your dwarf again. Your guilt that you could not save either of them is one and the same, and you are substituting one with the other.”
“I’m not quite sure it matters when the guilt is still here," Bilbo had replied.
Elrond had looked at him almost kindly, then, far too kindly for someone whom he did not yet know.
“It is not a detriment to feel regret or despair, Master Baggins. It is that which makes up the gift of mortality. But you have not reconciled with the losses you have suffered in their entirety, and it will do you more hurt than help if you continue on this way. The mourning you feel is not for this lifetime.”
Bilbo had laughed wetly, thanked Elrond for his guidance, and left to wander up here and look at the sky. He hadn’t moved since that afternoon.
Thorin’s face in front of him was beginning to blur, the lines of it hazy and indistinct, and he might have been saying something, still, but Bilbo could not hear anything at all over all the cotton wool in his ears and the sudden rushing wind.
He could see somewhere a little boy with tangled curls, and a stone statue carved into a mountainside, and a weary thing with tired eyelids and a scar on his shoulder and neck, and a figure fallen in battle, too delicate against the jut of the icy cliff with his hair fanned out and a ribbon of scarlet trailing out from underneath him.
Why won’t you open your eyes?
Where are you, dear heart?
Where are you?
(I’ve lost you, I’ve lost you, I’ve lost you, I’m sailing, I’m floating, I’m falling, I -)
Then there was rough skin against his fingertips, not like it had always seemed in his dreams, gentle and soft and far away. There were lines on the face in front of him, and the skin was worn and flecked with dirt from their time on the road. It dimpled beneath Bilbo's fingers.
The cloudiness slowly lifted from Bilbo’s eyes, and he saw that he was touching a faintly trembling hand to the side of Thorin’s face, right against his temple, and so gently he wasn’t even sure Thorin was able to feel it. The tips of his fingers slid ever so slightly into the darkly peppered hair just above his ear, and after a moment, he could feel the dull thud of Thorin’s heartbeat telling Bilbo he was alive.
Not lost. Not the visions of an elderly hobbit losing his clutches on memories. Thorin truly was alive. He could feel it, in the rhythmic pulse against his temple, and see it in his eyes, and watch it in the steady rise and fall of his chest, standing closer to the bearer of his heart than he’d been able to in eighty long years.
A tear slipped down Bilbo's cheek. He grit his teeth and tried in vain to keep himself together.
“Sorry - allergies, sometimes, I - Fili and Kili might have - well, anyway, they make my eyes water, you know. Don’t - don’t think anything of it. It’s quite manageable.” He did not let himself wipe the tear away, and the night air let it grow cold on his cheek.
Thorin did not speak for a long time, and was instead deathly silent. His eyes betrayed no emotion at all.
That was, if he was even feeling any emotion at Bilbo’s total lack of self-control. He must have thought Bilbo a soft, pathetic little creature, crying all alone up on the ramparts instead of getting a good night’s rest like a sensible person. Bilbo could almost see him in that moment wondering why they’d brought someone who so clearly could not brave the wild without needing so much as a handkerchief.
Eventually, and with what seemed like gargantuan effort, he said, “I suggest you try and keep that under control, Master Burglar." Bilbo dropped his gaze, shame making his face startlingly warm.
“It was not my intention to argue with you,” he said awkwardly. A silver-brown lock of hair crept in between Bilbo’s index and middle fingers, and he absent-mindedly let himself sweep it up and back from Thorin’s face.
Thorin did not reply.
It took Bilbo several moments to realise that he’d been holding his breath. It took him several moments longer to realise that he was touching Thorin’s face. That he was still touching Thorin’s face.
He yanked his fingers back like they’d brushed hot pokers and clutched at them in horror.
“Oh, dear me, I’m so sorry! I’m sorry, I -” Oh, hell and horrors - “we hobbits can be very touchy, and I quite lost my head there - lost in my own thoughts and forgot my place!” Had he so forgotten the sensation of feeling? It felt as though all the blood in Bilbo's body had migrated to his face. “I’m - I’m sorry.”
His ears glowed hot with embarrassment. He knew he hadn’t done himself any favours, and that he’d probably peeled back what little faith their conversation had managed to scrounge up in Thorin, but what was done was done.
Thorin was alive, and he would not die again under Bilbo’s watch. Not until he was old and white-haired and bending sharply at the spine with a walking stick. It was high time Bilbo pulled himself together.
“You should not apologise so much,” Thorin said quietly. His voice was a river; Bilbo could hear the way it dragged upon the rocks.
“I don’t do it to offend you,” Bilbo said, still frazzled, “it’s just what I’ve been taught.” He looked up at Thorin’s indecipherable gaze. “Perhaps you were not taught the same.”
An imperceptible change came over Thorin’s face for the slightest of seconds before it shuttered out. He watched Bilbo with that dark expression for a moment longer, and Bilbo watched him back, standing his ground even while his cheeks still burned red-hot. The air was still, and clouds were starting to stretch over the moon.
Thorin walked away.
Bilbo was beyond mortified by his behaviour the next day. Touching at Thorin’s face like some hobbit lass of twenty five, and then crying on top of it all. He was terribly worried that all of it would finally be seen as a real reason for Thorin to put his foot down, to remove Bilbo’s whole part in this quest and send him on his way home.
(Not that Bilbo would go, of course. He’d follow them through the bushes the whole sorry way to Erebor, if he had to. Heaven knew his dwarves would need him one way or another, and he wasn’t going to let them wander off into the wilderness without even a burglar to watch over them.)
But Thorin did nothing, and actually, he seemed to be remarkably content with pretending their disastrous encounter up on the ramparts had never happened at all. He did not seek Bilbo out, preferring to stay away from him with the same degree of reticence he’d kept since they’d set out from Bag End, and Bilbo was glad for it.
Speaking with Elrond had loosened his tongue far too much, and he’d entirely lost his head trying to make sure that he was really real, that he was really there. It had badly shocked him, to find someone else who had known the truth, and he’d been sure the whole conversation that he'd finally fallen into total madness in his decrepit state.
But in the sun-warm light of morning, with a fresh mind and a fresh heart, Bilbo knew now that he had not dreamt up what was happening around him. He had been given a true blessing, and although he rather felt his actions meant he didn’t deserve it, the moments he was living again were surely sacred.
He did not need a pulse to know Thorin was alive when Bilbo could feel the beat of his own heart firm inside his chest. He did not need to check and check and check when the blue of those eyes were right in front of him, distant as they had ever been but still bright in the depths of his unflinching face. And it was pointless to sit and mope around waiting for Thorin’s wariness and dismissal to mellow when Bilbo knew quite well when and where that was going to happen. I have missed him every day for a lifetime, so what is a few more?
The guilt he carried would still sit in the pit of his stomach, but one day Bilbo would unravel it, and find the peace he sought. For Frodo, and the Company, and for the bitter tang that had come with their victory the first time around, after all that they had lost. His heart would learn to settle yet, and for now, the tears would have to stay.
