Actions

Work Header

thunder and the riversong

Chapter 10: from now on

Notes:

happy belated birthday to bilbo and frodo my little loves <3

some quick disclaimers:

a) i have borrowed dwalin’s mentioned injury from sansûkh because i love sansûkh and continuity, and i will also be borrowing gloin’s wife’s name in the next chapter, and

b) time travel aus are my LIFEBLOOD and i crave thorough reveals in them like nothing else so bilbo is going to be quite extensive in his storytelling in this chapter bc that’s what he tends to do! just thought i should forewarn that he will be explaining the plot of lotr in quite a lot of detail at various points in case that bores anyone or seems like bad storytelling on my part. it’s a little cheesy also but they’ve earned it

title taken from the song “from now on” from the greatest showman

okay let’s fucking go

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“When are you going to tell us, then, Bilbo?”

“I beg your pardon?”

Presently, it was the kind of time of day where it could have been classed as any time, when the sky had just opened from darker lilac to palest cornflower-blue, and all fifteen members of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield had scattered themselves about inside the healer’s tent in such a way that Bilbo had started to wonder whether they were ever going to extract themselves from one another at all. 

Not all of them had escaped the dreadful battle unscathed. Half of Dwalin’s face was wrapped up in a cloth, rusty-brown with how much it had bled already, and Bilbo’d heard several Elves discussing the dire outlook of his eye while Dwalin grumbled like a brewing geyser below them. Gloin’s beard was bloodied, and Ori could barely keep his eyes open; the band of his slingshot had snapped and lay in a dismal little puddle beside him on his bedroll. Nori was groaning very splendidly in the corner about a bruised set of ribs, and Dori was clucking his tongue above him, saying things like Yes, yes, we’ve all heard it already, you ruddy imbecile.

There was also Kili, who lay on the roll two over from his uncle’s where Bilbo still was perched, his leg propped on a small stack of sandbags and the joint of his knee looking as if somebody had taken a cheese-grater right to the skin. It was Kili who’d spoken, and he was sporting a grin far cheekier than Bilbo thought his current situation should have permitted. He only raised a single eyebrow.

“About the first quest. Like your stories,” Kili elaborated. “Tell us what it was like, what you thought of all of us. What happened after… after.”

“You are modest, Bilbo,” said Gandalf, then, from where he was tucked away in the very furthest corner of the tent, watching them with a strangely sentimental look in his eye. “However, my friend, your way with words is quite beautiful, and I do think we would all dearly love to hear it.”

“You told us you would once it was over, did you not?” Balin said then, smiling. “What better time than now?”

Bilbo looked around at them all in the tent, at his dwarves, bandaged and bruised and living and breathing, and at the very last moment met Thorin’s ever-steady blue eyes resting softly on him, always on him.

“Tell us, Master Baggins,” the rumble came, low and gentle. 

Bilbo sighed. 

“Very well,” he said. “But I must tell you, this will not be like my other stories. I am going to try and speak as truthfully as I can manage, and it is close to my heart beyond anything else, so you will — well, you will have to forgive me.”

They bunched around him in a cluttered circle, on makeshift beds piled together in the tent and all facing Bilbo where he was sat beside Thorin’s legs at the base of his roll. It was more of an oblong than a circle, really; Kili had been expressly forbidden by Oin from getting out of bed under any circumstances whatsoever short of a second goblin-raid, so they expanded themselves instead to scoop him into the fray.

Bilbo cleared his throat very importantly, feeling suddenly incredibly nervous at the thought of doing something he’d had to remind himself not to do their whole journey to Erebor. “Oh, it’s so infuriating to have to straighten all this out into a neat line! Are you quite sure I need to tell you?”

You’re stalling, Bilbo Baggins.

He was.

He bit down, amid the jeers, and let out a cool breath. And then he began.

“All — all right. Well, first I must tell you all that I… well, I have something of a secret, and it is quite important to the story.” Bilbo looked at the floor, or perhaps the bedcovers; he couldn’t much tell, now. His eyes were blurring. This really was not going to be easy. “Very important to the story.”

He touched at the little pocket of his jacket and stared off into the distant nothing, feeling suddenly entirely sick, hoping that this would be the very last time he would have to feel for the blasted Ring, that he would never find anything in that godforsaken pocket ever again.

He’d have it stitched up, he resolved. Or torn off, maybe. Left pockets were for silly old fools who liked to tempt fate and lose.

“As I said,” Bilbo reminded them, “it has been eighty-odd years since it first happened, but our journey was much the same to begin with, though I was far more unprepared and inexperienced, so none of you initially thought overmuch of me. We encountered all of the same things. The Shire, the rain, the trolls, the Elves. But once we reached the Misty Mountains we hit a snag, and all of you were taken prisoner in Goblintown when we sheltered from the storm.

“I was not taken. I fell quite out of sight, instead, and I found something, both this time and the last — that’s the reason I was so insistent on turning back,” Bilbo said, looking briefly and guiltily at an owl-eyed Bofur. “It is a… trinket of sorts. A ring. A plain gold one.”

Bilbo closed his eyes and exhaled, acknowledged the ceaseless hammering of his own heart, and then pulled the Ring out into the light, resting it on the flat of his palm.

He detested the sight of it, as if a bloody, rusted knife was lying in his hand, but Bilbo no longer feared touching it with his bare skin — not after he’d been able to wear it once more and take it off. It had become truly and utterly meaningless to him, and he could not wait until he was rid of it permanently. 

“It doesn’t look like much, but among other things it has the power to make the wearer invisible. No, I will not put it on,” he said, when he saw Kili leaning forward on his elbows in wonder, and Dwalin and Dori eyeing the thing skeptically, though Thorin was gazing at him with such an inscrutable expression that Bilbo could not tell what he was thinking at all. 

He swallowed.

“I have sworn that I will not ever wear it again, but I promise you with everything I am, everything I am, that I am telling the truth.”

Bilbo told them of how with it he’d snuck into places and fought spiders, and named his little sword, and broken them out of the Woodland cells and crept up on a dragon. How he’d conspired on the journey in Laketown without them and brought Bard into the fold once more with black bow and arrow in hand. How they had spared the Long Lake from burning, and how Bilbo had lured Smaug away to line up the shot with the use of the Ring.

He pushed past the worst of it fast. 

“I have told all and sundry the specifics of what happened in the battle, as you… as you know.” He steadied himself for a moment, not yet willing to watch their faces. “Dain was crowned. They held the funerals. And I went home with the well-wishes of lifelong friends tucked into my pockets.”

Bilbo ducked his head properly then, too bashful to smile at them with the full force of his fondness, though no doubt his dwarves were entirely unsurprised by now at either the extent of his eccentricities or the sheer size of his heart.

“I lived alone in Bag End as I always had, after that,” he said, “though of course they all thought I was mad as a bat, and that I had gone off stealing from trolls. A few of you came to visit me over the years, and every time it brought peace to my weary old heart. You were my friends for the rest of my days no matter how far our distance. And of course, there was Frodo.

“After a long while, after I’d left the Shire for good and settled in with the Elves, there was a gathering of people in Elrond’s halls to hold counsel against the coming darkness.” A sort of shadow fell as he spoke of it, blanketing the cheeriness of the tent, and Bilbo tried his best to let go of the guilt coiling vine-like within him for asking what he was about to ask. If he’d raised the question in the Shire, he would have been fairly slapped with a crowd of nothing but gawking faces, wondering if he was perhaps speaking in tongues; they wouldn’t have had the faintest, foggiest clue. But dwarves had cause to know, and cause to know the danger.

“You know of the Enemy? The Dark Lord Sauron?” he forced out finally. He was met with nods, and continued on. “Do you know of his Rings of Power?”

“Yes.” 

Thorin. Of course. His father had worn it, hadn’t he? Bilbo could have stood up and turned around and kicked himself to kingdom come for his tactlessness, but instead he only huffed out a little grunt and shifted on Thorin’s bedroll and pushed on.

“Yes, well, the Elves have three, and you dwarves had seven, and the Men had nine, but there was also the One, worn by the Enemy himself, and it held power over all others, over all of Middle-Earth. All would fall to ruin and horror if he were to regain it. There would be nothing left. Nothing at all.”

He locked eyes with each of them and smiled crookedly. If this was the last of the harsh truths he must deliver, he would deliver it head-on.

“I wonder if any of you have put it together yet.” Bilbo felt for the Ring one more time with a thumb, resting so unnassumingly in the palm of his hand, and watched the pale golden sheen of it for a moment longer before his eyes flicked upward again to his rapt audience.

A deep sense of foreboding lay over all of them, so potent as to be nearly unbearable, and many of his friends looked as if they did not want him to continue on. They’d begun to realise how very dire the story was. The guilt tightened around his middle.

But he had warned them. And it was almost done, now.

Bilbo opened his mouth to recite the inscription he knew lay on the Ring, but his voice had stuck fast in his throat, and he found he couldn’t speak. He frowned, shook himself, and then tried again, fruitlessly. No such luck.

Oh, this was excruciating. Bilbo turned rather frantically to the corner of the room and stared desperately at the wizard.

“It is written in Black Speech. I — Gandalf —”

“If I am correct,” Gandalf said slowly, fixing him with a look far more complex than merely pity, “the inscription reads,

One Ring to rule them all,

One Ring to find them.

One Ring to bring them all

And in the darkness, bind them.”

His voice was dark and grave, and it was as if clouds crept across the roof of the tent when he spoke the words, blackening the walls and brushing scorch-marks up the sides and releasing a haze of smog into the air. Bilbo’s throat was the slightest bit croaky when he spoke again.

“This ring.” He drew his eyes back to face them. “This is the One.”

His dwarves all looked as though they’d crumbled inward, or outward, or simply all over the place; they looked vaguely sick, wrath and worry and defiant shock all sloshing together to create a single-minded hatred for what they knew now was far, far more than simply just his little magic ring. 

“A company was chosen from within that council,” Bilbo kept on stubbornly, “to bear the Ring to Mordor so that it could be destroyed in the fires of Orodruin. Four hobbits, two Men, one Elf, one dwarf. And Gandalf, of course.” And he smiled at the words, grimly, but fondly, even despite the subject matter they’d followed, even despite the manner in which he’d said them. “Two of the hobbits were my cousins in some way or another, and one was the child of a dear friend. The other was my nephew. My Frodo. He was — he —“ Bilbo’s voice broke. “He was the Ringbearer.”

He could not say more than that. He’d put it to rest, now, anyhow. He would not make excuses they would not understand; he no longer needed to.

(He made a note in his mind to begin the sourcing of some quality peony seedlings at once.)

“Also in this Fellowship were the Three Hunters, whom you know from my stories,” Bilbo said, “and who you have all met, in one way or another — though they will not become so for another eighty years, if this life plays out in the same way, which I dearly hope it will not. I do not know if any of you saw him, but there was a child in Rivendell while we were there. He is the Man in the story, though as of right now he does not know it yet; as we speak, his name is Estel, but when I knew him in his prime, he was Aragorn son of Arathorn, and the rightful king of Gondor. The Elf you know in passing, for we saw him in Mirkwood, and he fought in the battle alongside us. His name is Legolas Thranduilion, son of the Elvenking.”

“And the dwarf?” Kili queried rather impatiently.

Ah. That. Bilbo felt a most peculiar expression pass across his face, as if a grimace had wiggled its way into a grin. He was only the messenger of such information, after all, though he doubted they’d remember that when he uttered his next words. Perhaps he should call one of the Elven healers back in before delivering such news — Gloin was rather liable to faint, after all. Medical attention on hand might become very quickly necessary.

The Company were all on tenterhooks, crouching closer like a cluster of fauntlings and blinking wide eyes at him, and Bilbo chuckled wryly, his eyelids creasing at the corners.

“Oh, I’m quite sure you’re all familiar with his name,” he mused. “A mighty warrior, he is, in the latter-most days. Truly, for all the years I have lived, there has been no dwarf more renowned among the fickle worlds of Men and Elves than Gimli son of Gloin.”

“Gimli!”

Bless his dear old heart, Gloin was up on his feet and storming up a gale before he’d closed his mouth again, his hands clutching his cheeks like some silly damsel in a tale, and Bilbo had to very hastily stifle his laughter, turning it into an earnestly-performed cough when several pairs of accusing eyes were shot at him.

Oh, surely he couldn’t be blamed all that much, though; really, it was quite ridiculous.

“An Elf-lover, oh, what did I do wrong, how in bloody Mahal’s name have I failed him so utterly!” Gloin cried. “What is his mother going to say! She’ll have my head — Kili, Nori, stop laughing!” He looked as if he would start weeping, his cheeks splotched a brilliant scarlet beneath his own fingers scrabbling at them. “Oh, Gimli!”

“He’s not here, you buffoon!” Bofur called out, clutching his stomach with one hand and his hat with the other. Gloin’s face reddened even further.

“And lucky for him! Oh, I’ll tie that boy’s beard in knots and see how he feels then!”

“I know it will displease you beyond words to hear it,” Bilbo chipped in cheerfully amidst the chaos, “and I never had the chance to see them in person, but I have heard that there is not a friendship in all the world like that of Legolas and Gimli.”

Gloin’s face turned rapidly entirely purple, and in a rather spectacular finale to all the dramatics, he fell to his knees right there on the tent floor with his fingers in his hair and cried out to the sky as if his maker might hear him and take some sort of pity. Bilbo couldn’t help it. He burst out laughing.

It took rather a long time to calm everybody down after such a revelation, and Bilbo almost would’ve regretted that he’d said anything at all but for the chuckle he knew he would get from the memory for as long as he lived. 

Eventually, though, they carried on.

“You all fought, of course. Can’t leave a situation alone to save your lives, can you? There were many battles and fronts and skirmishes that broke out all over Middle-Earth, in fact,” Bilbo explained, “though I did not see a single one, tucked away as I was in my cozy little room in Elrond’s house with my mind decaying out my ears.” He smiled sadly, and bent his head. “But what I know of it is that they approached you for information. You protected me stoutly. They made war. So really, it was my fault you were besieged, and you lost your king. Another of your kings.”

There was a coarsely familiar voice that interrupted, then, as always. Poking his nose where Bilbo had not asked for it to be.

(Though, Bilbo Baggins could pretend all he liked that it hadn’t stroked a lovely shade of pink up his neck and across the apples of his cheeks. It didn’t, of course, convince anybody.)

“He would have been proud to stand alongside you,” Thorin said quietly, speaking for almost the first time since the whole tale had begun. “It is our highest honour, Master Baggins.”

They made eye contact, though Bilbo had to look quickly away.

“Well, anyhow, all that business was cleared up, and the Nine Walkers succeeded in their task, and the Ring was no more. It was a few years after that when Elrond and all his clan began to make preparations to depart, in the way that Elves do, and they asked me if I would like to accompany them. And I decided that I did, rather.

“I did it too, you know. I sailed West, with the Elves, and with Frodo. Never to see the shores or streams of Middle-Earth again. And then, wouldn’t you know it,” Bilbo said, smiling, his rosy cheeks aching, in fact, from how hard he beamed then, “I found myself in Bag End, didn’t I, and there were dwarves knocking at my door.” He lifted his head, and peered round at all his battered, beloved friends, all hale if not quite whole, and had to look very quickly away before the strength of the affection on their faces made him quite unfit for public appearance and he collapsed at once into tears.

All in all, perhaps every emotion ever come to pass under the Sun blew its way through the little tent in which the Company were assembled on that early morning after the Battle of Five Armies. And at the end of Bilbo’s story, when his voice was hoarse and his throat stung, each of his dwarves, his dear friends, Balin and Dwalin, Oin and Gloin, Ori, Nori and Dori, Bifur, Bofur and Bombur, Fili and Kili, and Thorin, Thorin, Thorin, rose to give him once more the forehead-touches of Laketown, tender as trees and  firm as mountains. And Bilbo met every one with all the giddy glory in his heart.


Piecing Erebor back together, however, was somehow not very much like Bilbo had imagined it in his head.

It was extremely slow-going. The dwarves counted their dead and laid each of them to rest in caverns deep below the Mountain, the highest honour they could have bestowed upon the slain, and those whose families wished to return them to their home in the Iron Hills were carefully laid in carts, blankets wrapped around their bodies to keep them safe from the chill.

There were beds to clean, wounds to heal; there was rubble in the corridors leading to the many hundreds of rooms strewn about the Mountain, lying scattered across the desolate land all around them, and Bilbo knew the dwarves still did not dare venture further into the city for fear of finding things far worse than lost treasure or broken belongings. There were, after all, many more dead in the Lonely Mountain than just those of the battle to count.

The task now was for them to begin to rebuild, but Erebor did not have the numbers to properly begin the immense task before them, nor did they have the strength after the grave extent of the battle. Thorin sent ravens to Ered Luin as soon as he was able, but it would be a few months yet before their brothers and sisters joined the dwarves in their homeland. Many of the Lake-men travelled back and forth from Esgaroth to help, now that they had no tragedy of their own to deal with other than lives lost in the battle. Bard, especially, could be seen traipsing here and there around the base of the Mountain, through the ruins of Dale, standing in the doorway of the hall full of gold with a hand brushing his beard in contemplative silence. It was, somehow, strangely bittersweet to Bilbo to have the space around them so full of others when it had for so long been only the fourteen of them.

Gloin took great joy in starting the painfully tedious task of collecting and relocating the gold, being a banker by craft. He’d assembled a small team to help him stack the coins in piles and cart them off to makeshift treasury rooms elsewhere in the Mountain, and he’d dragged a few of the Company along in order to keep them occupied — and to keep them together, Bilbo suspected, when he caught wind of it. Sometimes he sat with Ori and Fili and fondly watched them trying not to fall asleep as they scooped up piles and piles of glittering jewels.

Not once did Thorin enter the hall where the gold lay.

Bilbo did not wear rose-coloured glasses, of course. He’d seen every ugly bit of the one he loved, had hands held against him and the very real threat of violence in his face. He had watched Thorin turn into someone who ate away at others, who was corruption and destruction, and knew very well it was not a light thing to forgive. 

But it had only ever made Bilbo miss him all the more, because he’d seen how different it could be when Thorin awoke. And he could not tell if this self-imposed exile of Thorin’s from the hall of his father was taken out of precaution or penance.

This didn’t mean, however, that Bilbo didn’t see Thorin. 

He was confined for a short while to the healer’s tent in the aftermath of the fight, and grew increasingly grouchy the longer he was told to stay in bed by Elven healers. He grew even more incensed when his single ally in Oin only echoed the sentiment.

“Am I not even to be allowed the use of my legs?” Thorin growled, looking entirely unintimidating in his bedclothes and with the blankets drawn up around him. Bilbo politely averted his eyes and pretended not to smile. Oin deigned not to answer the question, pointedly setting his ear-horn on the table next to them with a thud and wrenching Thorin’s bandages tighter until had he not been one of the most stubborn people alive he would surely have yelped. Bilbo was delighted.

Once he was given the all-clear to re-enter Erebor, Thorin dedicated himself to gaining back all the strength he had lost from bedrest as well as to the restoration of his left arm — handlessness be damned. Soon, he’d begun to drag them all down to one of the abandoned tournament-chambers deep within the Mountain, and then he would spar with Dwalin or Fili or Kili, or Dori or Gloin or Dain, and sometimes they’d even rustle up a strained-looking Balin for a go. 

The Company of Thorin Oakenshield started to spend much of their time together in the sparring chamber, now that the injured of them were no longer required in the healing tents, and with the unspoken understanding that they could not enter the Hall of Treasures as one. They’d laze about and watch the best of them run at each other with glittering swords, freshly shone and sharpened, and the weakest of them undercut each other with wiley tactics and gleeful grins. It always had poor Oin turning a brilliant purple in the face.

“Stop it, for goodness’ bloody sake, do none of you have any self-control —“

Thorin, currently mid-spar with his cousin, swept the sweaty hair back from his face with the same fingers he was still using to clutch the sword, and Bilbo could practically see the steam coming out of Oin’s ears at the sight. Thorin was breathing hard, his face flushed with exertion, and he moved his left arm in front of him to stare down at the empty space there for a moment before looking up with a determined grit.

“I must learn, Oin. The lack of a limb does not mean a fight will not come again,” he said gruffly. “And I enjoy it.”

“Oh, trust me,” Bilbo bit out drily from his perch up in the spectators’ seats, hand under his chin and a book in his lap as he pretended very resolutely that he hadn’t already been watching, “we’re all very well aware.”

He’d tried to refrain from attending these ridiculous bouts, at first, on the grounds of disinterest and also intensely-baffled concern at the fact Thorin — and Dwalin, for that matter — were so desperate to throw themselves in front of blades after they’d only just begun to heal from what had been disastrously grievous blade-inflicted injuries. 

But Thorin had asked after him, after a while; gently and hesitantly, a low hope in his voice when he met Bilbo in the hall one evening. They were all sleeping in close quarters — Thorin had insisted in placing every one of them in rooms alongside the King’s, which sat far in the north of the wings of Erebor and had been for the most part unpillaged by the parasite that had infested it. 

“You do not have to come. I know swordplay is not your preferred hobby, Master Baggins, but I would like it if you were there. We do not see each other as often as I’d like.”

”Such a sentimental dwarf,” Bilbo said, rolling his eyes, the embarrassed flush bright and hot on his cheeks and made all the worse when Thorin smiled that infinitesimal smile down at him.

(And the sparring really was lovely to watch. Bilbo was only one hobbit, after all. He could not be expected to uphold moral righteousness and sensibility in every single situation he happened across. And sometimes the situations he happened across involved damp and sweaty dwarves grunting and showing off and holding blades longer than half his body while their hair fell in their eyes. So sue him.)

They’d all started insisting, too, bewilderingly, that Bilbo take a braid. It’d started during one of the sparring matches, even though all Bilbo ever did to anyone else’s eyes was sit in the stands and mind his own business.

“Oh, come on, Bilbo, it’s as if you’ve been growing your hair out for it!”

“It’s the perfect length and all —“

“Just one bead, a little one, I’ll make it myself, come on —“

“I’ll not have it!”

“It is for valour, Master Baggins.”

“Oh, wasps, you are, the lot of you!”

The point was, Bilbo didn’t quite know where they now stood, he and Thorin Oakenshield, and he did not know where Thorin thought they stood. He wasn’t even sure if the thought had crossed Thorin’s mind, to be frank. They were caught in a terribly sticky stalemate, and he felt almost like a pebble being tossed around in a landslide, the sea-swept sickness of waiting excruciating.

But Thorin no longer bowed his head so deeply he could not see Bilbo. He was warm again. He would try. 

And the smile he gave whenever Bilbo entered the sparring chamber, or his quarters, or his work-rooms, such as they were in the cobbled-together Mountain, was far more sacred than Bilbo had anywhere near the sort of stuff inside him to deal with. Thorin smiled like the sight of such a peculiar little hobbit soothed him, sleep-soft if only for the fact he had had no sleep. The smile was half as much in the slight pull of his mouth as in his eyes, and they would gleam like polished pearls.

It was all rather uncalled for, to be perfectly honest. Bilbo felt half-mad. Really, Thorin would have to watch the way he threw around such clear friendship towards a hobbit, else he’d be accused of inter-race favouritism and be exiled in truth by the more prickly of the Iron Hills lot.

(To the view of all others, of course, though they never spoke it, it was almost as though the two were dancing around each other, the hobbit and the dwarf, one oblivious, one yearning, both of their breaths catching when the other’s head was turned. It seemed a wonder that Bilbo Baggins could not see the way Thorin Oakenshield looked at him.)

And best of all, Bilbo could see. 

Though it was still dilapidated in places, scarred and weeping, or long, long abandoned and unable to settle into the past so quickly, the way the city that lay inside the Lonely Mountain wove outward from its heart was magnificent. 

This had been a city of life, sprouting forth from its roots, spreading upward through the Mountain, and as they slowly, slowly began to scrape away the worst of it, they found places that could and would begin anew. Bilbo saw the look of wonder in Thorin’s eyes when they’d venture inward, to places he’d known, to the deepest caverns still standing and the highest, loftiest rooms that had not quite been broken in the fall.

“It is grand,” he’d whisper, and Bilbo would nod.

They had not lied, his dwarves. There was nothing like to it in all the world. Erebor would soon again be grand beyond measure.


And so, the work began.

In the Mountain it continued, and Bilbo and all the rest helped Thorin and Fili and Kili carry supplies or clear debris back and forth, though Bilbo himself was sure to snit all the while at how they should still all be resting. They met with the abashedly-new King of Dale and his people frequently, and with all the lords of the Iron Hills whenever it was required.

Erebor had begun slowly to aid the poverty of Laketown crafted so cleverly by the Master, offering men and women and all kinds of people jobs wherever they could be found, housing families if it was at all a possibility in what parts of the Mountain were yet usable, and giving aid in turn to the task of rebuilding the city of Dale. Bard had put his entire back into it, and he was rarely off his feet; he frequently met with Thorin or Balin and passed their messages far afield, and there was not a day where he was not seen walking among his people, willingly offering them his time and labour.

The Master had fled, of course. Had picked up his skirts and run. And even if he had not been of the line of Girion, the people of Esgaroth would have had no other as their king but the Dragonslayer.

But the real work had begun in Bilbo’s mind when they got to work on crafting Thorin a replacement hand.

Thorin himself was determined, and bent his entire unruly brow to the task, working often into the small hours of the morning with Fili and Bifur and Bofur, scratching up designs for the replacement on spare bits of old paper — and, when they had none to spare, sometimes the walls too fell victim. Dain, for his part, was awfully smug about the whole thing, and would stroll around the Mountain nodding approvingly and roguishly calling out things like, “It seems the only sorts of rulers who have any sense must be missing a limb, then! I’m so glad you finally realised it, Oakenshield, you old coot, I could’ve told you a century ago!”

If Bilbo ever tiptoed around late at night and happened to find himself peeking through certain doorways, he would often see the two sitting together and stooped over a table, Dain sketching designs while Thorin quietly dictated the ideas to him. Every so often, Dain would murmur back and turn to Thorin with a serious or questioning expression, and Thorin would tilt his head a tad and tap at the page where he thought they needed adjustment. Bilbo’s heart always softened entirely to slush at this. 

Dain Ironfoot had gone to war for a hobbit he had met only briefly, only once, when he’d likely lost far more in the same battle that had split Bilbo’s life in two halves. He had staked the Mountain and his own life on his people’s kinship with Bilbo Baggins in the War of the Ring. He’d been King Under the Mountain in another life, until the very last breath.

So Bilbo could learn to get on rather well with the Lord of the Iron Hills, he thought. And there were not many dwarves that had earned from him a higher level of respect.

It was fascinating, too, to watch the dwarves work. Bilbo knew that they were renowned for their invention, for breathing life into their creations from the earth; that their technological advancements had been heralded by the Elves who most loved those things in the elder days of their friendship. But he had never before with his own eyes gotten to see it. Thorin worked with a quiet focus that was almost startling to see. He’d murmur in a low voice to the others, Dain and the toymakers and his nephew, the end of the graphite he drew with held between his lips as he thought with a mighty frown on his face.

There was also rather a lot of arguing about epithets. Which Bilbo thought was ridiculous.

“You can’t be Ironhand! You’ll steal all of my thunder, you great idiot! Make it from something else, what about Oakenfist, that was right there —“

Eventually, however, after far too many late nights of work, they were done.

Bifur and Bofur took the designs and painstakingly fashioned Thorin a wooden hand from the sparse few oak trees that grew by the banks of the River Running, at the point where its mouth spilled out into the Long Lake. They brought it to him to fit it at once.

”It’s magnificent, Bofur,” Bilbo said in astonishment when he saw it, running a hand over the smooth gleam of the fresh polish on the wood, slipping his fingers idly between Thorin’s new ones. “It looks just like the real thing. I’ve never seen anything like it.”

He could see the segments of each knuckle, the way they slotted together, round and glossy. There was a cleft in the palm just as on a flesh-and-bone hand, and Bilbo drew the tip of his index finger across it delicately; the oak felt smooth as marble, but sturdy beneath his touch. He swiped a thumb across it, marvelling, then looked up and pulled his hands cleanly away when he saw Thorin staring utterly silent and unreadable back at him. His eyes were gleaming moon-like in the dark.

Bifur took the hand and showed Thorin how to put it on himself, how he would need to wrap his arm in cloth before he wore it, how if he pressed a lever at the base of the wrist he could make the fingers close. They had thought of everything, even things Bilbo foolishly hadn’t realised needed to be thought of, and Bofur spent rather a lot time declaring all of his plans to fashion an attachment that instead of bearing a hand would hold a smithing-tool, so Thorin would lose no work. Bilbo listened to every bit of it with his jaw entirely, embarrassingly agape.

He couldn’t help it. It was utterly, utterly magic.

“Just a big toy, isn’t it? Easy as pie,” Bofur said when he saw Bilbo looking, a hearty grin on his face. “The best of toys for our best of kings.”

But it was only because Bilbo was already looking that he did not miss the way Thorin’s jaw clenched.


It soon became clear, after that. Bilbo didn’t have the faintest idea how he hadn’t seen it before, particularly when he prided himself on having so much practice at spotting it.

There was something wrong.

It was par for the course, of course. The story of his life with this ridiculous dwarf, Bilbo supposed, huffing out a sigh. Really, it was enough to turn all the hair on one‘s head white: he should check a mirror soon, just to make sure, or he’d be caught unawares.

Thorin had donned the replacement hand, and it had been brilliant, for a while. Bifur and Bofur were excitedly working on more attachments that were less hand-shaped, and Bofur had even told Bilbo in confidence that he was one day hoping to craft a new shield which could be attached to Thorin’s wrist and used in battle, if ever more battle came.

It became obvious quite quickly, however, that it pained Thorin to wear it.

Not that Thorin ever willingly spoke of the oak hand causing him pain. Chafing was all he’d offhandedly said. I will get used to it. Bilbo had needed to pester and needle the living daylights out of him and had worked the both of them up into quite a strop and a row by the time Thorin had shouted that of course his hand and wrist were aching.

Bilbo had pushed him out the door with explicit instructions to either speak to Oin or die trying and slammed it in his face while Thorin glowered black as night. Then he’d paced in a single circle around and around the room for hours, hands behind his back and muttering unmentionable curses at the floor until he’d exhausted himself and had to retire to bed early.

That fool. He’s learned nothing. He will not accept help, will not accept anything from you at all, and yet here you are, Bilbo Baggins, aren’t you, still pushing him onward anyway!

It was only when Oin had pulled Bilbo aside and explained it to him the next day that he properly understood.

“He will feel it for long years, Bilbo. He will feel a hand he cannot flex, and the blade passing through it as if a phantom is haunting him. It’s incredibly common, and not to be helped, unfortunately. It’s just the way it is.”

He’d found Thorin the next day and very stubbornly stared at the space beside his head instead of right at him as he apologised.

“I have a sharp tongue, you know,” Bilbo said, “and it has gotten me into far too much trouble for my own good. I shouldn’t have turned it on you, especially not over something that is hurting you. You do not have to share with me anything of your injury, Thorin. Please don’t think you do. I shall very well keep my mouth shut next time!”

Then Bilbo wrenched his eyes to Thorin’s and forced himself to keep them there, even if it was infuriating how excellent Thorin was at hiding his thoughts in his own head. Bilbo conjured instead the image of his mother. Don’t cower, my darling. It’s not at all polite.

“Please just tell me if you are hurting,” he said softly, “and I will try to be gentle.”

Thorin did not move for a long time, standing halted in the corridor, looking down the slope of his nose at Bilbo and not even having the decency to give a hint as to what he thought of Bilbo’s measly little apology.

Then, all at once, he walked forwards and clasped a hand against Bilbo’s shoulder. 

“You are gentle enough, Master Baggins. I will not break.”

The hand slid down his arm, and then was gone, and Bilbo was left standing there in its wake having not the faintest idea what he was supposed to do with it. 

He’d thought it was that, for a little while. That adjustment to the new hand was causing Thorin more grief than he had predicted, and that that was what was ailing him. That it was only a phantom ache.

But the longer Bilbo went on, and the more he watched, the sooner he realised it wasn’t that. It wasn’t that at all.

“Thorin.”

There was a grunt. They were sat at the grand table in the room Thorin had chosen to nestle his work in, citing it after a while as his study. He had not returned to his grandfather’s rooms since the dragon-sickness, and Bilbo hadn’t had the heart in him to ask Thorin why.

It was a simple space: likely an old inner council chamber, only containing the table circled by littered-about chairs and a roaring fireplace in the corner. Thorin was poring over an outrageous smattering of papers with another page half-crushed in his wooden hand, and his silhouette struck the lantern-light like a blot from a pen. He was in the thick of it, Bilbo assumed, and had only half-heard him speak at all. Either that or he was already halfway to sleep.

”Thorin,” Bilbo said again, his voice still breeze-soft. Thorin didn’t stir.

It had become a daily ritual, in the smallest hours of the evening, for Bilbo to knock very gently and let the door creak open, and to slip in until he was pulling back the chair closest to Thorin and seated by his side as he worked slowly and meticulously.

The very first time, Bilbo had been utterly unable to sleep, in his designated rooms in the royal wing. They were all sleeping close by one another, of course; but any quarters were far from close when you had practically been sleeping inside one another’s pockets for the better part of half a year. He lay in the stone room, lantern sinking burnt-butter low, only the wisp of a flame still petering on as his ever-rioting mind would not cease either its thought or its over-thought. He’d lay there for what felt like hours with his eyes wide open, feeling as if he were frozen in a dream.

It was far too quiet. Bilbo could not stomach it. He hopped out of bed with cold feet on the floor and slipped into the hallway, and when he pushed open the door of the study, a dull amber glow leaking out from behind the cracks, Thorin had looked surprised, but the exhaustion cloaked all over him had coated it too deeply to stick.

”What are you doing awake?”

Bilbo made no answer and sank down into the chair, tucking one knee up beneath him. He wished he had a blanket of some sort to wrap around himself, in the flickering darkness; some scrap of anything would be sorely comfortable about now.

”I believe I’m sitting with you.”

Thorin had smiled very slightly and very wearily; there were still faint purple-and-brown bruises beneath his eyes that only time would clear, and time was something that Bilbo was not sure Thorin had too much of to spare now that he was King Under the Mountain.

“To do what?” he had asked. 

What else?

“I’ve a mind to write down my story,” Bilbo’d said softly, the familiarity of the words a comfort and a plunge into the deep in equal measure. “The details are so fresh in my mind that I think it will turn out even better this time.”

It was unimaginably quiet now, however, only the faintest crackles of the fire in the corner spitting out into the warm silence. 

“Thorin.”

Thorin hummed, a low sound in the back of his throat, and finally looked up at Bilbo, who swallowed.

“Why is it you write so carefully?” It hadn’t been the question he’d meant to ask, but the words had poured forth, now, so it would have to make do.

“Smithing requires both hands, and I can use both well enough,” Thorin replied slowly. “But I scribe with my left more often than not, so I must re-train myself.”

Ah. Bilbo had thought since Thorin wielded his sword with his right hand, that it would have been his dominant one. But it made no sense once he thought on it for more than a split-second, and he felt exceedingly foolish. He was Thorin Oakenshield, not Thorin Swordhand. It was one and not the other he was most proficient with.

“Oh, don’t be silly,” Bilbo said instead. “I’ll scribe for you.”

He slipped down into his seat, leaning over with his arms crossed on the table and the just-barely-there brush of Thorin’s shirtsleeves against his bare elbow.

“But you are writing your book,” Thorin said, frowning at him. His voice was quiet, his hair hanging long and loose on either side, the firelight filtering in fragments through the strands. It was entirely unbraided; Bilbo wasn’t sure why, but as it was, his mouth had become rather dry, and he tucked a few of his own tragedy of curls behind his ear.

(Perhaps… well, perhaps braids weren’t such a terrible idea, at least while he was away from Bag End and a reputable barber.

Though he’d take the thought to the grave with him, if any of them ever asked.)

“My book can wait its turn,” Bilbo decided with a nod. “Or I will train myself to write with my opposite hand, and then I can write with both at once using each half of my brain, and you can just sit back and watch.”

“Master Baggins.”

Bilbo felt his nose twitch at the name and tried to smooth it over. Really, that was needling at him too, if he was being entirely truthful, but Bilbo put it aside for now. He didn’t want to start an argument. Not when he had not the foggiest clue what time it was and the fire was so low and their voices were so soft in the quiet.

“I do not want to distract you from your work,” Thorin said. “Mine is not so important as all that. You do not owe me your time.”

Bilbo elected very pointedly to ignore the second half of the sentence, and said only, “I’d say it might be at least a little important, on account of how you are the King Under the Mountain Returned, and all that, you oaf.”

Thorin did not reply, the crack in his jaw surely splintering his teeth, but Bilbo held his own silence rather than breaking it.

There was the something-that-was-wrong again, creeping around the corner. I cannot fix it for you, my dear. I can only lend my aid.

He gathered up all his courage, then, and his wits, and whatever other what-not one seemed to require when one decided to go past one’s doorstep, and said what he’d first wanted to say.

“You haven’t been into your father’s hall.”

Thorin unravelled, shaking the hair from his face and rolling his spine upward until he was looking sidelong at Bilbo with a bebotheringly-inscrutable expression, his gaze sleepy and loose and lingering.

“I have not,” he murmured hoarsely.

Bilbo cleared his throat. “Do you suppose you will?’”

“No,” Thorin said, and his eyes had fallen from Bilbo’s face, his skin awash in tinged golden light. “I do not suppose.”

There were several more moments of silence, during which Bilbo’s eyebrows crept higher and higher on his face, inviting some form of explanation, and the great log-headed lug before him just started blankly back. Finally, Thorin sighed, and swept the oak hand back through his unbound tide of hair, brushing back over the peppery point of his widow’s peak. He looked at Bilbo for one long, relentless, incomprehensible moment, his eyes lidded by the fire, then turned away and spoke instead into the steady-warm quiet.

”If you must know, I do not want it… to tempt me.”

He looked gaunt, still, Bilbo was realising, with an unsettlingly-growing dread. Not as much — not nearly. But his eyes were hollows; he looked exhausted. He was better than before, but nowhere close to better enough. And under all that, there lay a lingering sickness, a sense that whatever had ebbed was only dormant.

Well, there was to be none of that. Bilbo opened his mouth.

“You remember what I said, don’t you?” he asked, seeking Thorin’s eyes and finding them, letting himself watch, letting Thorin watch him back, his eyes full to bursting with whatever aching, earnest sort of something it was they were always full of when they settled on Bilbo. “I know what it is like, more than anyone else living. And you know, now. What I meant.” He brushed his fingers against his pocket once, lightly, and then drew them back.

Thorin looked away, and Bilbo bit down until his jaw was clenched and his teeth hurt. 

All of it was so bittersweet, even still. Pebbles in a landslide. Threads that had been tied together. Why did they have to wait so long?

He watched Thorin defiantly, wanting those fervent eyes back on him, sending him every enraged thought that had curdled in his head over every day he’d had to think them.

You’re not getting away from me so easily, Thorin Oakenshield.

You will fight it. Day by day. You will win.

But when Thorin spoke again, his voice held such a defeat that the wind was taken out of even Bilbo’s sails just a little, and he was left wondering what on Earth else they had to do to fix what he’d naively thought they already had.

Thorin’s mismatched hands lay on the table, bent softly into fists. “You must hold the faith I do not have, Master Baggins,” he said, in such a low rumble that had Bilbo been any other hobbit he could almost have pretended he hadn’t heard it.

What must I do?


Another day, perhaps a fortnight later, Balin drew Bilbo away from where he had been sitting and staring into the deepest of space in the Hall of Treasures, half-heartedly clutching a handful of silver and bronze coins in one hand and doing utterly nothing with them.

“Need something to occupy you, Bilbo?”

Bilbo flushed. Balin had a very knowing, very telling smile on his face.

“Don’t worry yourself, laddie,” he said. “I’ve got something I think you’ll like much more than carting coins for Gloin.”

They trotted away together along winding hallways and raised bridges, skirting round all the parts where the stone had been cracked or eroded away. Little groups of dwarves were already tinkering with the gaps, sitting around in groups and stroking their beards as they discussed in low voices how best to patch up all of Smaug’s scars. Many times, they would mumble in Khuzdûl only to abruptly stop when they saw Bilbo and Balin coming, and Bilbo very sternly told himself not to feel insulted by it whenever it happened. They had every right. 

He wondered if far below them was where the mines of the mountain were kept. They were headed towards the southern wing of the city, he’d realised — the Mountain had begun to open up into wider and wider chambers, becoming more caverns than anything. Some had clearly been hollowed out by dragons’ wings, if the decrepit state of them was anything to go by, but some had formed naturally, and the swooping ceiling of the mountain-rock crested above them in magnificent, smooth archways. And he was probably going entirely round the bend, but all the curves reminded Bilbo the slightest bit of the roundness of a hobbit-hole.

”It’s wonderful, Balin,” Bilbo said softly, not wanting to disrupt the ancient silence of the sweeping curves of rock many times larger than he.

He must have said it a little pointedly, because Balin smiled at him and said, “Indeed, but it isn’t what I brought you here for, Bilbo. Be patient.”

After a while, a slim double doorway made of an aged grey-brown wood appeared before them at the end of the corridor, and Balin pressed one hand against it, turning back to Bilbo and winking once before he pushed the door open.

The sight within almost caused Bilbo to burst into tears.

This had once been a grand library. It was beautiful. Beautiful, and so very sad. High, intricately-carved shelves, lining each wall and trailing their way down the centre of the room, made from wood carvings of dark red and chocolate-brown and dusty mauve and smoke. But on them, instead of books, there lay only the terrible shells of their remains, as far as the eye could see.

Pages had rotted away, covers were blown off and burned, and scattered along the shelves there was ash, everywhere; Bilbo had to force down his own coughing. He walked forwards and touched a decaying book lying on the shelf closest to him, felt the warping, aged leather on the cover, opened it, and let loose a cloud of ash that was so thick as it spiralled upward it caused him to sneeze.

Bilbo turned back to Balin helplessly, every word his mind could produce dying utterly on his tongue. What words were there? This room had been a work of art, marred by horror — the same horror that they had come all the way here to bloody well fix.  

Well, we shall simply have to heal its wounds, then, won’t we? 

Balin was smiling at him very knowingly from the doorway. “Many of the texts in here are written in Angerthas,” he reminded Bilbo. “You won’t be able to read them.” Bilbo rolled his eyes and waved a hand.

“Oh, Balin, I don’t care.”

This was a dream. He could not possibly be awake at this minute. He had to stop himself from asking his dear friend to pinch him; it really would have been unbecoming. And he could not for the life of him stop staring around at it all, at the sweeping shelves, the creeping walls, the husks of papers and pens and stories. 

(It was no Rivendell. Not by half. But it would be. And it would become so under the care of Bilbo’s own hands.)

”Oh, you must show Ori,” Bilbo cried suddenly, struck with the realisation. “Balin! You should have showed him before me!”

So the next day they were back with Ori and Thorin in tow, Bilbo babbling to the both of them all the way there about his plans for the place and nodding eagerly along with Ori when he made his own suggestions on scribing or preservation or translation. Ori gave an astonished little gasp when they finally entered the room, and Bilbo smiled in self-satisfaction. He’d known Ori would understand.

It faltered slightly, however, when moment after moment crept on without a sound from Thorin, and Bilbo turned around.

He was standing, hand still resting idly against the door and other arm down by his side, staring with a guarded expression at the far wall. At the very back of the room was a grand — albeit damaged, as everything was damaged — mural displayed along the wall, spanning almost the entire central space so there was no mistaking what it was. Bilbo’s eyes had glossed over it the day before, too enraptured by the contents of the library in front of him to recall much about the edges.

That was being proven to be a grave oversight now that he was looking at it. For it was a mural of Thror. 

“He commissioned this room for my grandmother,” Thorin said in quiet explanation. His voice was low, almost inaudible, and Bilbo did not ask him to speak up, too afraid of what else he would hear in it if the sound was any clearer. “It belonged to everyone in Erebor, but most of all it belonged to her.”

Thror looked so like Thorin. He was much greyer, but his greying had begun from the same roots of hair as his grandson’s, and his nose was wide and angular and sat proudly on his face. The damage to the walls meant that he was missing half of his crown.

Thorin looked away.

His jaw was working furiously, and his eyes were wide, staring askance down at the floor; he’d let go of the door to let it swing closed and was absently clutching at the end of his wooden wrist, wringing it back and forth in his fingers. Bilbo frowned.

“You should not be ashamed of him.” 

Thorin swallowed. “I can be ashamed of nothing else.”

“Thorin,” he shot back crossly, “you —“

“Do not worry yourself, Master Baggins. It is not my grandfather I am ashamed of. He was —“ Thorin swallowed again, and lifted his gaze to fix it defiantly on Bilbo, his jaw clenched rough as sandpaper.

“I looked to him as I did not look to anyone else,” he said in a gravel-thick voice. “I wished to be just like him as a boy. My younger brother Frerin always teased me for it.” He turned back to the mural and looked upon it for one more long, terrible moment. “It is funny, the way life gifts you your wishes.”

It had been an error to bring him here. Bilbo could see that. But there was nothing he could do about it now, so he decided to take a hearty stab at changing the subject of their conversation.

“If it was a gift for her,” he asked, furrowing his brow, “why’d he add a great big portrait of himself?”

Thorin’s face cleared momentarily, and he looked back at Bilbo with lighter eyes, moving a few steps closer so he came further into the room. He clasped both hands behind his back.

“To make her laugh. He was… very affectionate. Before.”

Before. They had circled back. 

Bilbo held his tongue and kept his eyes very firmly on Thorin, who was staring with his chin held high at the mural of his grandfather as if it was going to leap off the wall and challenge him to a fight. A bout for their honour: who could most courageously withstand the sickness?

“He’d hate what has been done to Erebor by that beast,” Thorin said harshly then. “It would have broken his heart.”

And it was precisely then that Bilbo felt the first spark of an idea, familiar and new and lightning-bright.

A History of Erebor And the Lonely Mountain: From the Accounts Of Thorin II Son Of Thrain And As Scribed By Bilbo Baggins Of the Shire

A working title, but not too shabby for a first draft, he thought. He already had a writing project to contend with in this lifetime, after all. What was one more?

“Well,” Bilbo said, stepping closer to Thorin, close enough that they were side by side and just barely touching at the sleeves. He felt it when Thorin breathed out at his proximity, the tiny movement letting their arms brush together, the two of them standing in full view of a glimpse of the future, purveyors of the quiet. “Then there’s no choice but to build it from the ground up again, is there?”


Life, Bilbo Baggins found, almost always suggested the most fantastical of things to you on the most uneventful of days. It was practically formulaic.

There was the day he’d been caught up in a dwarvish, dragonish journey and whisked halfway across the world. The days his mother and father had been felled without any warning at all. The day he had travelled to Brandy Hall and decided to take in a little rascal of a fauntling named Frodo. The day he’d given up the One Ring and thrown a double-birthday party to boot.

Such things would happen, and Bilbo would find himself on guard in the days afterward, waiting for the next adventure to crop up out of the blue and quite without invitation. And then, life would laze about as it ever did, and he would loosen from his wound-up tightness, and soon enough he’d find himself going about his days with not a single thought for when the next story was going to catch him unawares and place him into the next chapter.

This day was no different.

Over the weeks, Balin, Thorin and Dain had amalgamated a small party of dwarves who’d volunteered to act as an advisory council to the King while their numbers in Erebor still dwindled. Some were the descendants of dwarves who had themselves fled the Mountain in Smaug’s attack and relocated to settle in the Iron Hills. Some were committed to remaining west of their home until Erebor was re-established in its entirety and able to stand on its own, and some, Bilbo suspected, were rather hoping to nose their way into other people’s business and see if they couldn’t get something out of it for themselves.

They had only met a handful of times thus far, and none as officially as this. The council had been called into one of the old advisory rooms, one of the very oldest that still stood, though it bore its fair share of signs of the battering. They were seated now around a thickly-laid, artfully-polished circular table, perhaps a round dozen of them alongside Balin, Thorin and Bilbo. Empty shelves lined one wall, and the table was so circumferentially large that Bilbo rather thought it was meant for a much greater number of dwarves than they currently had.

(But they would get there, in time.)

There’d been a seat crafted especially for the king in here, too. Bilbo’d seen it, poking his nose in when he’d heard Balin and Thorin arguing the evening before, on his way to see if he could find some supper and perhaps Dori or Bofur or Bombur to have a lazy moan about the weather with. It wasn’t quite a throne, per se, but it was far more ornate than the rest of the cluttered seating; a little larger, a little roomier, the back a little straighter. It loomed at the very centre of the table, in pride of place opposite the doorway, and Balin and Thorin were merely shadowed figures behind it.

“Get it out of here, Balin. I will not have it.”

“Thorin, I know we did not use such… self-important things in Ered Luin, but the seat is not —“

“I said get it out.”

Bilbo winced. 

(Hence, something was wrong.)

The elder dwarves of the Iron Hills had requested a more formal council-meeting in order to get the ball rolling on Thorin’s kingly duties, as it were, and despite his blatant avoidance of such official things, Thorin begrudgingly agreed. They’d marked on the agenda to discuss all manner of things: trade relations, tariffs, rebuilding, living quarters, robes, ceremonies, transportation of goods and people from Ered Luin. Bilbo, for his part, had been asked to the meeting as a personal advisor to the King, and had hoped that he could meander his way through the whole thing calmly and easily.

All things considered, it was going rather poorly.

The council had spent the better part of several hours all reminding Thorin extremely pointedly of the fact he’d made commitments, that he had promised things in the taking of the Mountain he could not walk back on, of the graveness of accepting outsiders, the necessity to build themselves from the ground upward and accept no help other than from their own people, warbling out such a long list of requirements and specifications and expectations based on past historical rules from a dozen kingdoms that had all fallen into disrepair that none of them could’ve made head nor tail of it if they tried.

Arguments had only begun to truly break out in the last few minutes, however. They’d moved onto the topic of what Balin had gingerly introduced as the King’s past tendency and obligation to present his kingdom with a united front in its leadership.

In other words —

“You owe your people a consort,” said a mousy-haired, mohawked fellow named Onar; rather snootily, in Bilbo’s opinion, and he suppressed yet again the urge to scoff. “You must establish a complete kingdom, your Oakenshieldness.”

I mean, what on all the good Earth —

“Aye, there has never been a dwarven ruler of majority-age who has not taken one!”

Thorin scowled, leaning back in his chair in an almighty slump and looking entirely at the end of his rope, and entirely weary; Bilbo felt a pang, and forced it down with great effort.

“My people are not here to speak for me of what it is they want,” Thorin ground out.

Another piped up, then, and Bilbo hadn’t even taken care enough to remember his name, instead yawning through all of his incessant droning. 

“You should not bring the ways of the Blue Mountains here. An unlovely, unloved place, that is. Darkness still lies from ages past. It is a scar.”

Perhaps Bilbo too had reached the end of his own tether, because as he was wont to do, he decided then to chime in with his own thoughts on the whole debacle and entirely stick his foot in it.

“Now, see here,” he found himself snapping, “this is not your kingdom.”

The room went death-silent. Balin had a roaring grimace on his face, and Bilbo elected thereafter to not look at his friend for fear he would lose all of his steam. He held up a finger and stuck his other hand squarely on his hip and frowned crossly.

“I do not mean any offence, and I do not mean to insinuate that I have more right to speak here than you Iron Hills folk do — I very well do not, and I am far beyond thoroughly aware of it, believe me.”

Against the will of his own mind, he chanced the slightest glance at Thorin, out of the corner of his eye. He was sitting forward, one elbow on the table and his chin propped on his hand, idly stroking his beard, watching Bilbo with total focus; watching only Bilbo. His eyes drifted for a moment up to Bilbo’s forehead, then to his ears, to his chin, across his nose, as they inexplicably and often did, and Bilbo felt the tips of his ears flush the colour of pomegranate seeds.

Enough of that. Now was hardly the time. Bilbo breathed out a huff and hopped back to it.

“This place has been stripped to its bare bones,” he said, gazing around at them all. “You must build it from the ground up. To bring old practices from archaic times and implement them as if nothing has changed is an unwise decision — and to be quite honest, it’s foolish.”

Immediately: outrage, black and rolling, indignation, disgust, betrayal — the lot of it. Bilbo cast his thoughts away from every bit, knowing he had to finish his piece. Onar tried to beat him to it, the shaven parts of his half-bald head flushed with anger.

“Our custom requires —“

“I do not mean to press my fingers on wounds that are still fresh, and I’m sorry for it,” Bilbo interrupted smoothly. “Your customs are significant, and your culture is significant. Do not assume I do not think it. I know, however distantly, just how much it means to you. But your kingdom is in pieces, and it is not the first to fall. You have lost so much of yourselves. You must make anew.” 

He looked around at them all and threw up his hands. “Can’t you see how silly it is to act as if everything is normal? You’re sitting in a room cluttered with stone debris, all your chair-legs are burned at the bottoms, and the whole place smells of dragon dung!” 

(Entirely untrue, obviously, but Bilbo allowed himself a little artistic liberty in his tirade, and hoped they’d all forgive him for it, otherwise a very shunned hobbit he would be.)

“This is no ordinary meeting of dwarves advising their lord. This is of an unprecedented scale, and we — you must discuss it accordingly. You cannot pretend as if your folk have not suffered this loss now that you have it back. You must let it make you stronger.”

“Master Baggins is right.”

Thorin Oakenshield rose at once from his chair at the centre of the table, clasped his hands behind his back, and began to pace.

“I have been thinking such things since almost the moment the battle was won.” He spoke with that distinctive voice, low and woody and lingering, embers and rivers, quiet thunder, thick ash. “Did not many of you settle in the Hills after your loved ones were lost in Azanulbizar? Do not some of you have kin who have lived always in the Blue Mountains from the times of our awakening, who welcomed us into their midst when we had no home at all to turn to, our people slaughtered in their thousands?”

He turned to move in the other direction along the table, and Bilbo saw that rather than clasping his hands equally, he was brushing the fingers of his right hand repeatedly across the sleek oaken one, back and forth almost idly, as if it grounded him.

“We are dwarves. Khazâd. We are slow to move. For so long we have had only each other, and we must open ourselves now to the allyship — friendship, rather, that has been extended to us, by Dale, by the Shire, and by… by Mirkwood, if necessary. We must open our eyes to the world around us, what the earth and the sky may teach us. What our uprooted lives have had to teach us: that the road ahead is long, but we will weather it. We must, as Master Baggins put it, make anew.”

After that, however, was when the aforementioned life began to pull on Bilbo’s finicky little strings.

Instead of settling back into his seat and giving himself a satisfied pat on the back after a speech of such significance and such pretty words, Thorin whirled on the room so suddenly that his cloak clipped the leg of his chair and it fell to the floor with a clatter, and he stormed out. 

Most of the dwarves brushed it off with a shrug, but several were eyeing each other most auspiciously, and staring at the open doorway Thorin had left with displeasing looks on their faces. Bilbo shot them a withering glance after collecting all his papers and inks and marched out after him.

(He hoped Thorin wasn’t going to make this a habit after important meetings. It was terribly irritating.)

“Thorin?” Bilbo called out at his retreating back. Thorin only grunted. His strides were long and unflinching, and he blew like a gale down the hall, a stormcloud striding into the night, broiling the rivers around him. Bilbo had no choice but to run along ridiculously to keep up, and his fondness for Thorin Oakenshield was dwindling every minute by the time they reached Thorin’s study and the door banged resoundingly aside. Bilbo caught it before it could fall closed and breezed in after him; he could already see the black clouds gathering, and rolled his eyes.

“Is there —“ he panted, out of breath from the sudden apparent battle-march, “ — a problem?”

“What do you think?”

Petulant Thorin, then. Bilbo had almost begun to miss him. This was clearly his heaped and steaming serving of be careful what you wish for.

“You had councillors in Ered Luin, did you not?” he ventured. Really, he couldn’t make head nor tail of what the problem was. It had gone as smoothly as he’d expected, especially for a first meeting. Bilbo could feel his own eyebrows only gathering closer and closer together on his face.

“Yes.”

Bilbo pushed an impatient breath out his teeth. “How did it normally go there, then?”

Thorin spun around and glowered at him, then collapsed into a chair and breathed out only the kingliest of hard done-by sighs. Bilbo had to stifle a snicker — but really, all these dramatics! Heaven forbid he ever let them rub off on him!

“Much of the time we would spend our meetings sitting around and yelling over the top of each other,” Thorin managed, grumpily, “but these folk are not used to it. We had an understanding of one another. They do not.”

It sounded very like the Shire. Equal portions of primp and poshness, and hurling food at each other if one did not get one’s way. If there was no argument, well, then, things were not really being run.

Bilbo scrunched up his nose. “Surely Dain would —“

“Dain does not wish to enter my council,” Thorin said darkly. “He has insisted otherwise, but it is because he does not wish to overstep.” He lifted his shaggy head to stare into the fire, the tawny silhouette of his body lit weakly by the flames. “I cannot hate that they are wary, that they are being so critical. That is the worst part of it. There are demands of me, demands I cannot fulfill. How is this a way to reignite a kingdom?”

“Reignite,” Bilbo scoffed. “Honestly, do you hear how you sound?” He was feeling awfully like the other shoe had dropped and he hadn’t the faintest idea from where.

Using dwarvish expressions, now, are we? What shoe have you on your feet to drop, you ninny?

“Leave me,” Thorin muttered, suddenly, facing away from Bilbo. 

“What? Thorin —“

“Leave me.”

Bilbo rolled his eyes a second time and moved towards the insufferable oaf.

“Tell me what this is about.”

“No.”

“Thorin, you did absolutely beautifully. The Thain himself couldn’t have said it better to the mayor. The King of Gondor couldn’t. What is it you are talking about!”

“I can do nothing!”

The banks of the river broke; Thorin took off his raven crown and hurled it, in a full-shouldered throw that had Bilbo crying out in alarm and despair, because oh, he hadn’t meant — had not wanted — oh, the crown —

He needn’t have worried; the dark metal thunked against the wall gracefully and then fell to the floor, blessedly unharmed. It lay there, silently watching the two of them, one figure’s shoulders heaving and the other utterly, utterly still.

“What am I able to do for them?” Thorin roared. “King! I am no king. What king must rely so heavily on others to bolster him at every turn? What king is weakened in the mind?”

“Uh, I daresay every single one? You fool.”

But Thorin had not heard him, or was pretending very valiantly that he hadn’t, which was exceedingly rude, in Bilbo’s opinion, The hairs on the back of his neck began to bristle in anger, rising to the challenge.

“I am not a king,” Thorin rasped. “I have never been a king in truth. We were exiled; I had no mother or father or grandfather to give me their wisdom once tragedy struck us. I have but tided things over until we found our way home again.”

He faltered, his eyes bright, unseeing; he walked, stopped, fiddled mindlessly with the juncture between skin and wood at his wrist. His voice was a crushed tree-branch, a cracked geode.

“And they expect all this of me, as if I am a learned hand at such things, as if they don’t know far more than I do about the true — methods, customs — they ask about payment, mines, crown jewels, consorts — I cannot —“

Thorin stopped himself, then swallowed, and it was odd, but Bilbo had never seen him look quite so vulnerable. They both turned to the side, to the crown discarded on the floor, its shadow stretching eerily along the stone wall.

“It has taken me,” Thorin muttered so quietly it had barely even been words.

Oh, what absolute nonsense.

“It very well hasn’t,” Bilbo snapped. “You’d broken free of it, by the end, and you know it. You are stronger than this, Thorin.”

Thorin swallowed again, the jut of his throat the only thing in the room that moved.

“How can that be, when I still feel it?”

His gaze dropped to Bilbo’s hands on the table, palms flat on the wood. His voice was only a murmur, as if he was hauntingly humming out a lullaby.

“I see it in your hand.” He took a breath and his chest rumbled, and the fire flickered, and his eyes drew up, dark and guarded with decades of practice. “The Arkenstone. I wake from sleep, and my mind glows. My dreams… my dreams are full of it. Full of gold.” His eyes slid, from Bilbo’s hair to his ankles, and up again.

Bilbo flushed furiously in embarrassment and ragged recognition. They sounded just the same.

Thorin wasn’t done. “And I know you have said you understand,” he croaked, watching Bilbo with those heavy, heavy eyes before glancing back at the shadows. “And I am grateful. But it is not your job to save all of us.”

He was right, and Bilbo hated it, and decided then and there that his patience had been worn too thin. Gold had played far too much a part of his life for far too long, so he would very well have to deal with it himself.

“Blast that,” he said vehemently. 

Thorin looked warily over at him, and something in Bilbo’s fierce face must have caught him, finally, because he did not look away.

“You aren’t getting rid of me,” Bilbo said stubbornly. “Not for a million years. I have been where you are. You know this. There is no one else who understands what you felt, what you feel, the way I do. I didn't know it, but the Ring had me for the rest of my life.”

My dreams are full of it. Full of gold. It had sent chills through Bilbo, up his spine and down his fingers until he half-felt like shaking even in the warmth of the room. It was as if Thorin had plucked the thought from his own head, from a world away.

They were hashing this out, right now.

“You might think your mind is a little bit broken. Well, mine is too, so it doesn’t quite matter, does it? If there are more bad days, then we will be there to help you through them, Thorin. We won’t let you fall. We are your Company.”

But Thorin’s eyes were wide and sightless, and his throat bobbed up and down. He seemed to be almost steeling himself to speak, like he was sick with the thought of it.

“I cannot help but feel it. It isn’t right. I am — the leader, I am supposed to be an example, to lead my people with only strength. I cannot be a stumbling fool who collapses at the sight of coins. It is a weakness.”

Well.

Bilbo stopped.

That was the truth out then, wasn’t it?

He leant back, lifting his hands from the table to pull them down uselessly by his sides. He let his expression drop to complete unreadability, and his voice was coolly neutral when he said, “If that’s what you really think about it, then I will leave right now.”

Nothing happened.

Thorin was serious. He really was. Bilbo was a little gobsmacked he’d had the gall to say it — but he was the one who’d chosen the stubbornest of any dwarf of all the ages since Durin, wasn’t he?

Perhaps he should cut his losses, then. For now, anyway. He would not clutch at strings if there was nothing for him to clutch at. He could not make himself heard if the ears were not ready to hear, and there was only so very much one could say.

His room was calling out for a visit just about now, anyhow. Or maybe the library, where Bilbo could whittle away the hours with a candle and the comfort of the old shelves. Dead books couldn’t speak, at least. A small blessing. They would not be likely to stick their boots so entirely in their mouths.

Bilbo made to turn, and to leave, but Thorin had already risen to his feet with a clatter, the chair-legs gouging out a shrieking path along the stone.

“Wait!” 

Blbo scoffed, humourlessly. 

“There’s hardly anything to wait for, is there?”

Thorin took a single step towards him, his hands held out in placation, though he lowered them when he no doubt saw the look on Bilbo’s face.

“I am sorry.”

“Yes, I’m quite sure you are,” Bilbo retaliated. If Thorin was going to grovel, he would not be doing it with an inch of help from him.

Thorin only blinked at him. “I did not mean that. It was callous to speak that way.”

“But it’s what you think, isn’t it? You can’t lie to me, Thorin, so do not even pretend to try.”

Thorin’s face had screwed up, the carved statue crumbling, and his head lowered the slightest amount.

“Not of others. Only myself, Master Baggins. I swear it.”

Master Baggins.  

If he’d been asked after the fact, Bilbo could not have said why it was then he chose to snap as a twig in a forest. Perhaps he’d simply reached the rather generous end of his many tethers. Perhaps fate had gotten sick and tired of them both plodding about like farm animals. Get your heads out of your behinds!

But as it was, Bilbo decided then and there it had been more than long enough, and he slammed his hands down against the table so suddenly that Thorin’s neck snapped upward as if he thought they were under attack.

“Oh, out with it, already!” he snapped.

Thorin looked nonplussed.

“I’m sorry?”

“You know very well what I mean.”

Thorin had of course not followed Bilbo’s skittering train of thought to reach the exact topic he was speaking of without introducing it, so he did not, in fact, know what Bilbo meant, but Bilbo ignored this for the moment. He raised his eyebrows, and when there was no forthcoming response, he stalked his way around the side of the table and right over to crowd himself into Thorin’s space, both of them now right in front of the flickering fire.

“Why have you stopped calling me by my name?”

It was hard to tell, in the dim and already-warm light, the moment that Thorin’s skin flushed, but flush it did, though he kept his eyes level.

“Baggins is your name,” he said. Bilbo scrunched up his nose and blew the hair from his eyes.

“You know what I mean. My first name.”

Thorin’s eyes drifted downward, and he watched Bilbo openly, surely knowing now that any sort of deference would only rile Bilbo up further but not quite able to keep himself from lowering his head as if in a bow.

“I did not think I… that is, I did not know if you would still want me to, after what I did to you. I did not know if I held the same level of trust.” He breathed out a hollow laugh. “It would be no surprise if I didn’t.”

“You —“

“I know, Master Baggins.” He held up a hand, and he was smiling very slightly; a soft, worn old thing. “It is not you. You’ve given me no indication of anything of the like. You have given me nothing but trust. But I cannot change my thoughts so easily, and many of them have begun to wonder what I will do if it happens again.”

Bilbo was so very tired of speaking around this stubborn gold that would not slip off the pair of them no matter what he did. Let it take him, and me, he thought, with a gritted jaw, with set teeth. Let it try and take the both of us. 

It shall be no match for me.

“I can’t pick you up from this, you know,” he said quietly into the silence. “And it’s not my job, besides.”

Thorin did not wince. Bilbo reached forwards to touch his arm very gently with just the pads of his fingertips, and kept on going, hoping with all he had that his voice would not shake.

“I can tell you all I like about how I understand what it is you are feeling, how your mind has had to carry so much, how you shouldn’t be unkind to it. But you must listen to me. I cannot spend all this time saying things you do not hear. And if you hear them, you must open yourself to what it is they mean.”

Thorin bowed his head. Bilbo resisted the urge to reach out again and lift his chin.

No bowing. No guilt. Enough of it.

“What would you have me hear?” Thorin asked quietly. Bilbo smiled a little.

“Illness is not weakness, Master Oakenshield. Weaknesses are not weakness. You have been hurt. You are not unfixable. You are not in the Blue Mountains anymore, and you have a home again. You are not alone. You don’t need to lead that way.”

Thorin’s body was hunched down, curled inward against the fire, watching Bilbo with an expression somehow so closed off and so open in equal measure Bilbo could hardly stand to look at him. He chewed the inside of his lip.

It wasn’t his job to fix Thorin’s mind, and he knew it. He was sure that Thorin knew it, too, even before Bilbo’d said it. But to hell with it if he couldn’t put him on the path — if he couldn’t show him the way through the door.

There was really only one thing for it. His words, as he’d always had. Bilbo took a deep breath before beginning.

He would tell one more story.

“Once,” he said, “long ago, a curious little creature from far in the West set out on what was to be the biggest adventure of his sensible little life. He was rather coerced into it, if you must know, by a peculiar pilgrim and a band of intimidating dwarves from the mountains, but after an annoying sort of bout of complaining, he slowly settled into his life on the road with the rest of his companions.”

Thorin hummed out a quiet noise in the back of his throat, and Bilbo knew it to mean that he was surrendering, letting himself listen instead of pushing him away. He forced himself not to reach out across the space between them and brush his fingers through Thorin’s tangled hair.

“One day, however, this strange assortment of individuals fell into some trouble, and found themselves trapped in the clutches of things that wanted to hurt them. The little fellow was lost in the struggle to escape, and fell deep down into the caverns of a mountain, where he came across an underground lake. But the lake was not unoccupied, and a danger lurked in the shadows.”

He swallowed.

“It tried to harm him. He’d picked up something that belonged to it, you see, without knowing quite what it was, and for some strange reason he felt he’d rather like to hold onto his new little trinket. He barely got away with his life.

“Not long afterwards, the creature discovered that his new treasure was magic, and he used it to slip into all sorts of nooks and crannies, for his friends insisted on constantly finding themselves in danger. And he dearly loved his little trinket for many years, and used it to hide from those he found bothersome, and looked upon it with awe whenever he felt the need to take it out and admire it, which became increasingly often, though of course he did not notice this growing habit.

“After many long years, he decided to leave his home in the West, and leave with it the pr — the treasure he’d collected, for his nephew to look after in his place. But it was very hard for him to give up his little trinket. It was… he was startled, afterwards, by how hard it had been. It had felt to him like someone was peeling away the layer of skin that hid his mind from the open air. Like his thoughts had become cloudy after running a race. Like he was waking from the blackness of sleep to the pink nothing of having your eyes closed.

“He spent quite a few years free of the mist it had spread over his mind, and he almost thought himself better for it, but it had already worked its magic. He couldn’t keep his eyes open much longer than a few hours at a time. He couldn’t remember things, things that were especially close to his heart. He began to — forget what his love had looked like, before he had been lost. It had hurt him, his little trinket, and he was one of its lucky owners. And still, that little creature was blind, and he did not know what it was that had left his mind so absent, what had crept quietly into his head and touched every corner it could find until he was a shadow of himself. He thought himself finally succumbing to old age. He could not think without it also being a part of his thoughts. His hair had turned white in a matter of days.

“One day a lot of people came to visit the house where he was staying, and there was a grand meeting of the peoples of Middle-Earth, of which he was a part. And his nephew took out that little trinket of his and proclaimed it to be the darkness that was taking over the world they lived in. Evil? the little fellow thought. That old treasure of mine? But then he remembered, with growing horror, the fog in his mind that he’d barely noticed until it was lifted, and the frightening rage he had felt at even the suggestion of letting it go. And he suddenly knew with all his soul that it was true. And it was then that he realised what he had truly done in picking it up all those years before, from the lake in the cavern, and what his beloved nephew would have to do in order to fix his mistake. That he had sentenced him to wounds that were deep, that would never be soothed. And the creature knew that if it had not already broken him so, that if his mind had moved as it once did, the thought would have broken his heart.”

Bilbo did not look at Thorin once he was done, gazing instead right into the fire and seeing straight through it.

“Would you say he was weaker for being sick?”

“No.”

Bilbo looked up out the window then, the sky winestain-dark outside, feeling Thorin’s eyes on him. “Would you say it about his nephew?”

“Never. Master Baggins. I am sorry.”

The quiet held for a moment, and Bilbo held himself still in turn. It was odd to look out the window, hearing the sounds of a warm hearth, and see only a barren land, desolation mixing in with the unforgivingness of winter and stripping the earth bare. It wasn’t snowing, yet, but the contrast was altogether strange.

“It is not a terrible thing, that we should both be a little bit damaged, Thorin,” he said softly. “We must simply push each other back together. It isn’t that difficult, when you think about it.”

He looked back, finally, to find Thorin was staring at him very strangely. Very strangely. In fact, Bilbo was sure that Thorin Oakenshield had never once looked at him quite like this, and a very strange anticipatory sort of feeling began to creep up the back of his neck in return.

Thorin’s voice was the rumble of thunder beckoning in the distance.

“Your love.”

Bilbo’s frail little heart stuttered to a complete stop.

“What?” 

He felt absurdly like a trained songbird. What? What did you say, dear heart? Oh, yes, let me come and cater to your every whim. Terribly embarrassing. He could stand to have a little more decorum than that.

“You said,” Thorin spoke softly, sounding reverent, almost like he’d fallen asleep and wasn’t sure yet whether he was awake, “that he began to forget what his love had looked like. That is what you said.”

What?

What did you say, my dear heart?

But Thorin was still going, and Bilbo could not summon the wit to tell him to shut up. He felt like he’d been slapped in the face with a fish.

“I am —Forgive me, if I am — I do not wish to presume. I —“ Thorin’s voice was raspy and low, and so quiet Bilbo could hardly hear him. He looked up, and his eyes were a furnace, were an inferno, were switching between each of Bilbo’s like his mind was too scattered to focus on anything at all. “You had a love?”

“I — well, I —“

Oh, Bilbo’d trodden in it now. Well and truly terribly trodden in it like the colossal, pin-headed, witless fool he was. The battlements had only been a premonition of what was to come.

I wonder if it’s too late to catch one of those boats from here to Mirkwood, he thought, taking several stumbling steps backward as if to leave right then and there.

“You what, Master Baggins?” Thorin had walked forwards. Why had he walked forwards? Why was he coming closer, oh, dear —

“I’ve just remembered I have something terribly important on, so I’m afraid I have to go, Balin should have mentioned —“

“Bilbo.”

Bilbo froze, his arms aloft, his feet firmly planted on the floor, though really he felt as if he was floating above both their heads.

“Bilbo,” Thorin said again, so quietly, heart-achingly, tenderly, and Bilbo’s eternally-bleeding heart broke upon the letters that made up his name. “I did not know you felt for me as I have felt for you. For so —”

He stopped, as if the thickness in his throat had become too great to go on; the firelight danced, roared, blazed, and Thorin’s forget-me-not eyes were sparkling in that ever-soft way as he stood and watched Bilbo, whose heart had fallen clean out.

He was so dull. He was so utterly blind.

Well, that won’t do at all, will it?

“Oh, my dear one,” Bilbo whispered, standing completely still, watching Thorin’s eyes dance; guarded, yes, the way he was, but hopeful, now, and lit like a gemstone. The constantly-present feeling swelled in his chest. “How could I not?”

Thorin’s lips parted, but he did not speak; he seemed unable to. He took a tentative step towards Bilbo.

It seemed obvious, now. It was probably outrageously obvious to anybody who passed by them. Who’d ever heard of them. Probably the whole of Middle-Earth were rolling their eyes at that silly dwarf and even sillier hobbit up there in that mountain who were blundering around with blindfolds over their eyes.

But he had never thought, could never have thought. What right did he have to?

Oh, my love.

And still Thorin Oakenshield was looking at him, the mask he hid his face behind utterly fallen away. The baritone of his voice was deep and lush and reverent as he quietly called out a hoarse, “Bilbo.”

Bilbo took a step towards him, wrapping his jacket up about himself, trembling fingers clutching tightly at the worn fabric. His heart was beating so quickly he was worried it would burst, and so loudly he thought somebody was going to come rushing in and ask what all the noise was, so he’d better very well say his piece before they were interrupted on account of it.

”Thorin Oakenshield,” he said, quirking a smile, softer than the grass that grew daisies in a flowerbed, “why on Earth would I be planting gardenias in my garden if I didn’t adore you with everything in me?”

He reached out, slowly, and touched one last time at Thorin’s temple, and the hair that swept back from there, and along the line of his cheekbone, and feather-light underneath his chin so Thorin’s head tilted upwards. His beard scratched at Bilbo’s fingertips, and he smoothed a thumb over the dark hairs underneath Thorin’s lip.

Thorin looked as if the shape of the very stone had been changed underneath his feet. His voice was raspy, so raspy, when he spoke, and softer almost than the crackling fire. His eyes were wide; Bilbo could not imagine how he was ever going to find a hope of looking away from them ever again.

“Your garden was for me?”

Bilbo laughed in delight. 

“You silly dwarf. Oh, you are a fool. How you were ever made a leader, I’ve got no idea. Not one. I can’t believe you’d —”

He stopped, and laughed again, stepping even closer to Thorin, who was looking down at the floor, his hands hanging by his sides. Strands of hair were falling over his eyes, so Bilbo lifted a hand and brushed them backward when he looked up once more.

“What are gardenias for?” Thorin asked lowly.

Bilbo felt his face pink up in sharply-shy embarrassment, but he couldn’t have cared less for all the world and a day. The happiness ringing in his chest felt like it was going to crack him clean in two.

“A secret love,” Bilbo whispered.

He cupped the back of Thorin’s neck, fingers threading up into his midnight hair, and Thorin reached a hand out to scrunch at Bilbo’s shirt, right above his heart where it rose and fell and rose.

And Bilbo let his words run free.

“I love you. There aren’t words for how tremendously I do. You are my dear one. The tulips in my garden, Thorin. The one I went racing over the hills brandishing a sword for like my mother always told me. I have known it nearly a hundred years.”

And all at once Thorin Oakenshield lowered his head and caught Bilbo Baggins’s mouth with his own, pushing into it the longer their lips pressed together so Bilbo’s head began to tilt backward with the strength that Thorin kissed him with. He pulled away slowly, lips chapped and eyes still closed, and leant up to press his mouth to Bilbo’s forehead, cradling the back of Bilbo’s head with such tenderness it was like the breeze kissing at his hair.

“I have never wanted to entirely know anyone,” Thorin said, his voice so deep, his fingers cupping the back of Bilbo’s neck, trembling, “so much as I want to know you.”

Bilbo made a gruff little noise in the back of his throat and kissed him again.

He thought of the sleeping adventurer within him gifted to him by his mum. How happy she would have been to see him like this, to see who he’d chosen. How much she would have laughed at Thorin’s sullen moods, tapped him on the ears and told him he needed to eat something or that frown would get stuck to his face. How delighted she would have been to meet him.

Bilbo had thought he’d known love, had felt the strongest flares of it in those long years in-between. Had known what it was to soar.

He had not.

Thorin’s beard was scratchy; Bilbo huffed out a little laugh and dragged his fingers through it, resting them against Thorin’s chin, his cheek, drawing a line down his beautiful nose with his thumb and his eyes still closed. Thorin had a fist crushed tightly in the back of his hair; Bilbo was absolutely certain it was going to stick in every ruddy direction after this, but he didn’t for a single second care. He’d shear it off. He’d grow it til it touched the floor. He’d wear a hat just like Bofur’s for the rest of his life.

The oaken hand came up to cup Bilbo’s face, so tenderly, and Bilbo took it and pressed it more firmly against his cheek, twining his own fingers around the wood until they were indistinguishable. He could not stop smiling. He was rather worried he’d never stop again. A single silver tear slipped down his cheek, and Thorin, feeling it soft against his own mouth, reached up with his thumb to brush it away.

My dear heart, Bilbo thought and thought and thought. Oh, you’ve come home to me. You’ve come home to me at last.

Their noses slotting together, the lines of their faces drawn together, every bit of them together as they should never have been apart. It was so very quiet in the room; Bilbo could hear Thorin’s breathing, the press of his mouth, the shift of his own coat as he stretched an arm upward and wrapped it entirely around Thorin’s shoulders to pull him closer. It was the eye of the storm; though, no, that wasn’t quite it, was it? There was no storm. They had weathered it. They had weathered it at long last.

They broke apart and pressed their faces side by side instead, and then they were breathing, just breathing, fusing together until the two of them were one whole beating heart once more.

“You know, you cannot know how I… how I mourned you,” Bilbo said, so quietly he wasn’t sure if even Thorin would hear. “In all the years that went by after you were gone, I thought of you. And it was silly, because I’d never really had you in the first place.”

He smiled softly, sadly, and felt fingers in his hair again. “I could not even mourn you in the way we hobbits do. The land around the Mountain is barren and cold, and no flowers grew here for me to lay atop your chest when you died.” He squeezed Thorin’s hand, and Thorin squeezed back. “But if I could have, I would have given you red carnations and rosemary, and hyacinths and gardenias, and poppies, and salvia, and sweetpeas, and butterfly weed, and lilacs. And forget-me-nots.”

Thorin growled against the skin of Bilbo’s throat. ”Muhudel,” he whispered, hand still threaded through the tufts of Bilbo’s hair, and his forehead lifted to press against Bilbo’s.

“Oh, so I’m allowed to hear your secret whisperings now?” Bilbo teased him. “What does that mean, then?”

He couldn’t see Thorin’s smile then so much as he could feel it against the downy skin on his face as Thorin leant in. His nose was pressing insistently against Bilbo’s cheek. 

“I can’t tell you that, Master Baggins. You’ll translate it. Put it in all your books.”

“Bilbo,” Bilbo corrected obstinately.

“Bilbo,” Thorin said, his voice hazel and earthy and warm, his tongue pillowing around the word. “You have blessed me more than you can possibly know. I would have watched you from the halls of Mahal until the day you left the world too. I would have watched over you until the day you died.”

“Well,” Bilbo said, “thank all the powers who reside in whatever place there is across the Sea that you will not have to.”

There was a clearing of a throat, and a nudge against the side of his face.

“Does this mean you will you permit a braid now?”

Bilbo laughed.

“Alright, you soppy, mad thing. Alright.”

The grey in Thorin’s hair seemed to all start from the tip of his widow’s peak, right at the top of his forehead and threading outwards across the rest of his hair. Bilbo leant up on the tips of his toes and kissed it, finally, finally.

“You know,” he said against the wispy crown of Thorin’s hair, “I have never been able to grow old. Not in the way I should have.” He fell back down onto flat feet to look Thorin in the face, and there was such a glow in his eyes that Bilbo had to close his own against it for fear he would lose his head entirely. He leant forward to kiss him again just to find something else to occupy himself.

It was this that meant he could feel it when Thorin smiled.

“So you will grow old with me.”

Amidst the burst of colour that brought in his brain, a snotty little voice he’d never quite been able to stamp out whispered how presumptuous, and Bilbo rather had to agree. He said as much, and Thorin’s mouth stretched wider against his until they were both smiling against each other and there wasn’t much of any kissing going on anymore. So Bilbo felt it when Thorin whispered, with a beating heart that was alive, alive, with a mouth that was warm and wonderful. 

“Thank you for coming back to me.”

Notes:

muhudel = blessing of blessings

this one was a little interludey for the purposes of bagginshield finally getting their shit together but i still have a few little tricks up my sleeve for the next chapter! the dís/female oc tag is also at long last going to come into play, as is thorin’s newfound ability to use gay dwarvish petnames, so i’m VERY excited for you all to read

thank you to anyone who leaves me kudos or bookmark tags or comments especially, you make my day with all of them — i am so grateful for how kind everyone has been to me the entire time i’ve been writing this and i really cannot believe it’s going to be over soon :(