Chapter Text
Sitting in his armchair by the fire and letting his head fall back against the padding was Bilbo’s favourite pastime nowadays, if it could be believed.
Oh, once, yes, he’d been the strangest little fellow west of Rivendell and the Riddermark, and he was rightly proud of it. Once he’d waved a sword around and fallen in love with climbing hills and been whip-sharp with a pen and his tongue both, even if half of Middle-Earth didn’t quite have the understanding to appreciate it.
But now, somehow, he could not seem to bring himself to do much of anything at all.
Except sitting. Sitting was lovely; it really was. Comforting, and familiar-warm, and guaranteed to carry him off to sleep better than he could’ve managed himself.
And Bilbo rather thought he was old enough to warrant a bit of a nap now and then, anyhow, so bebother all the rest! One hundred and twenty-nine and all, he was! There weren’t many at all that could have said that, were there — well, except of course, all of these blasted Elves he lived with now, and a fair number of dwarves, too, and oh, well! It was far too bothersome to bear thinking about. He closed his eyes.
A nap, that was it. A nap in his favourite armchair by the fire would do him some good.
It was only at this particular moment that Bilbo remembered he was keeping company, and he heard himself let loose a strange startled noise in the back of his throat.
Oh, how unbelievably rude of him! Treasured company and all, too, and that wasn’t to do at all! He hauled himself up again with a great effort, enough that he was sitting of his own feeble accord in his seat, and peeled back the crinkly film of his eyelids to peer blearily at his beloved Frodo.
The poor dear! He’d likely been ever so bored, nodding with the glass growing over his eyes and smiling politely at his silly old uncle going over and over the same old story when he hadn’t yet finished telling his own. Oh, Bilbo was a terrible Baggins, wasn’t he! He tried to wrinkle his mouth into some sort of apology, but lost it halfway there.
He blinked himself awake, looking around all afluster, and — yes, that was his Rivendell fireplace, Shire-trinkets all laid out neatly in a row along the mantel, and by the window his desk, and his inkpots, and scraps of paper and half-finished notations sticking out every which way from each nook and cranny. There was his blanket, thick and woven with what always felt like a swan’s feathers, and opposite him a simple chair upon which his dear nephew was perched, hands clasped together as he patiently watched his daft uncle muddle his way through a simple thought.
Bilbo glanced downward, and noticed with some surprise there was a book in his hands. That was right, wasn’t it? He’d been dictating the changes he’d made to his journey and puzzling out the wording of the Elvish songs he’d written down, for he couldn’t quite remember how exactly it was they’d gone, and even brazen and un-shy as he was he was still a tad too embarrassed to ask them.
He took a great big breath that rattled all down his chest and into his rickety old bones, and asked, “Whatever did become of my old ring, Frodo? You were taking it away, weren’t you?”
His fingers were slipping quite against his will, and after a moment the great volume he had propped open fell gently into his lap. Frodo reached forward to take the book from his hands and close it, then rose from his seat to place it back on the tidy little stack by his bed; Bilbo had started to keep his most important ones there because he was finding more and more these days that he simply could not remember where they were if he left them anywhere else.
Frodo turned back to him, stuffing his hands in his pockets and smiling sadly.
“Indeed, Bilbo, and I’m afraid I lost it,” he said. “It’s gone out of the world, now.”
Ah. That was unfortunate, then.
For though it had been a very long time, and though he could have sworn he hardly ever meant to think of his old trinket anymore, there seemed always a place in his heart, reaching, reaching, outstretching its arms as he could no longer, grasping at what he had left behind.
What had been there before? Something certainly had. Something else that was gone.
Well, no matter. He should like to sit and curl up now and remember his old ring, and that was enough.
“What a pity,” Bilbo heard himself say. “I should have liked to see it again, one last time. But then… it is better that it is gone, isn’t it? And you’d told me all of this before and all, too, hadn’t you? How silly of me!”
And what a creaky old voice he had! Really, it was becoming rather unappetising for singing songs round the room, as the Elves of Imladris loved for him to do — though now he’d thought of it, Bilbo could not quite remember the last time he’d done so.
His forgetfulness really was becoming terrible in his old age, if he was being frank, and Bilbo had half a mind to scold himself for it, were he not so… so tired.
He looked up again as Frodo sat gently back down, squinting through the haze that always seemed to settle wherever it was he looked. Frodo looked ever so frail, skin pale as a lily and his eyes enormous in his fragile face. Somebody really needed to feed him up good and well. It wasn’t at all proper for a hobbit to be walking around at such a frail size. Good grief, who’d let that happen to him?
From far away, Bilbo felt himself frown.
“I’m rather tired after the journey, Bilbo,” Frodo said quietly, folding his fingers together.
Oh, well that wasn’t right, that wasn’t right at all. No good, that. Adventures were meant for creeping under your skin and waking all of you up, didn’t Frodo know that? Silly boy. Bilbo sat up, reaching out for something to grab with his hands, though he wasn’t the slightest bit sure what.
“A spot of tea, I think, Frodo,” he creaked and croaked. “You’ll be alright with some good, strong Elvish tea. You’ll find there is nothing it cannot help.”
Though they didn’t hardly use leaves robust enough for it here, if he was being entirely honest, and there wasn’t a lick of milk to be found in the place. Had he still had the form or function, Bilbo would more than likely have rolled his eyes.
But rose-sugar and honey, and flowers to flavour, and the warmth of the cups in their hands; that was something they’d both done since the very first day Frodo had set his feet on the doorstep of his beloved Bag End. Bilbo could hardly believe he’d forgotten.
He felt his tired head tip backward, wispy-fine hairs catching on the soft velvet of the armchair behind him. The rusty old voice that seemed to be his nowadays scratched its way up from within him.
“I’m ever so sorry I keep falling asleep, my boy. I simply get so sleepy here, you know! You caught me at a bad time, that’s all. I am all ears now.”
And he waggled them for good measure, flexing what muscles he could still move and making his Frodo-lad smile, his cheeks appling, and ah, there, yes; he certainly looked much healthier that way. Bilbo closed his eyes again fondly.
That was good. That was good.
“Oh, Bilbo, I don’t blame you at all,” Frodo said, far away on the breeze. “But it’s far too much to tell, unfortunately. I’ll write it down for you, shall I? So you can read it whenever you like.”
That ache in his chest was back again, and Bilbo lifted a tired hand to rub at his front, grumbling under his breath. Pestering thing, that ache. He was entirely sick of it.
But an ache for what?
“I should like that, Frodo. I should like that very much.”
Didn’t adventures ever have an end?
Whoever in the Blessed Realm had come up with the bright idea of thinking was most definitely not going to be receiving any thank-yous from Bilbo Baggins if he ever somehow made it there.
He had been sitting for most of the day on his little bunk in whichever backwater tent they’d chosen to dump him into in this godforsaken encampment of Men and Elves, and most aggressively staring a hole into the bedcovers as he did nothing but thought and thought and thought.
Really, the mind wasn’t made for it. Not at all.
(Of course, that was all the mind did, and to suggest otherwise was plainly ridiculous, so the thought had Bilbo scowling at himself for thinking it, which would then send him into an entirely fresh funk for thinking anything at all. To tell the truth, it was all rather excruciating.)
He had been thinking about Frodo. And he’d been thinking about the aftermath of the dreadful debacle up on the battlements, turning it over and over in his mind like a stone caressed by water until it ran smooth and colourless as glass.
He’d ambled out of the moat below the Gate like some bedraggled, half-drowned, unloved little creature and been led straight to the tent of Thranduil the Elvenking once more, marched on each side all the while by Elf-guards in shining-silver armour past desperately curious and hurriedly-pulled-together faces; far, far too many to count.
Yes, well, I hope you all enjoyed the show!
Bilbo’d stood stiffly as the tent-flap opened and there its three occupants stood, already gathered and waiting expectantly after their foray at the Gate. The familiarity of the whole scenario grated further at all his frayed edges as if bits of him were flaking off and fluttering away on the wind. He felt like all the insides had already fallen out of his body, and so he may as well stomp them down into a pulp while he could.
And if he never had to stand in a war-tent again for as long as he lived, it would still be far too soon.
Not a single one of them spoke, at first, looking down at him with expressions utterly unable to be unpicked for their complexity, and Bilbo wondered absently if it was at all possible to burn up and away with deep, dreadful shame.
Gandalf the Grey, familiar face adorned with a merry smile and exhausted eyes and looking down at Bilbo with an expression that was uncommonly kind, if a little pitying. Bard of Esgaroth and Dale, barrel-broad arms folded across his chest and a frown chipped deeply through the middle of his face as he peered dubiously downward. And Thranduil, jewel-laden hands clasped at his front and draped with the silver-grey sleeves of his robe. The fall of it was quite unlike anything Bilbo had ever seen, water-like in the way it moved but the colour so captivating the eye could not look away, as if it were made of a flowing river of metal. He wore no crown this time, and his translucent hair fell long and loose around his face, though Bard’s was still pulled back in the blunt mess accustomed to by Men, and Gandalf’s rather dishevelled at the nape and the beard the way a wizard’s ought to be.
Bilbo huffed out a sigh that ruffled his own hair at the front and pretended that his hands were not trembling so badly somebody else had had to open the tent for him.
(He should lop it all off, the hair. There wasn’t any need for it.)
“Bilbo, my dear fellow,” Gandalf said, “I do not mean to push you, but I am afraid I do have to ask what all of that was about.”
Bilbo almost laughed out loud. What a preposterously poor way to broach the subject.
“I would think you know already, Gandalf,” he said, feeling his face flick through expressions as if the pages of a book. He quenched the equal pinpricks of dread and irritation that flared up in him at such a simple question; one that barely began to encompass all that had happened, and all that had gone so very, disastrously wrong.
The Grey Pilgrim fixed him with a most auspicious stare, lowering the brim of his hat and pinning Bilbo to the wall with far-seeking eyes.
“If I am not mistaken,” he said, more intently, “you have travelled a long way, my friend, and you must be rather tired.”
Bilbo did laugh at that, his voice collapsing halfway through. A hobbit no more, he was. He was a candle blown out halfway down its wick. He was an ash-blackened match.
“I am, Gandalf,” he said quietly, closing his eyes and feeling it for the first time, and for the thousandth time. It wasn’t fair, how unkind time was. Would that he could have swept the lot of them up in the palms of his hands and dropped them in a mountain free of dragons and darkness. Would that sweetness and joy and peace and calm did not always, always have to come hand in hand with things that tasted so bitter. “And now I fear I have utterly destroyed all of it.”
He was catastrophising utterly terribly and he knew it, but it was a thought that had not quite been able to leave his head since he’d set his feet upon the ramparts.
They knew.
The terrible truth. The unspeakable reality. They knew all of it.
They knew, and he had not even been able to tell Frodo before leaving him behind, and he had not yet had the chance to change what it was he’d come back to, and instead he’d written it right into this life just as it had been written in the last.
You die. You die, you die, you die, and I live. I still live.
And, Bilbo thought, it was only going to get worse, and he was only going to have to flay open the wound when the skin was still pink and healing, spill more blood over the rotting carcass of the Mountain. Because in truth, they did not yet know all of it — not even half. Not the worst of it. And he would still have to tell them.
(If they would ever trust him enough to speak to him again.)
“I do not think it’s possible you’ve destroyed it, my dear fellow, and I do not think you should worry yourself over it,” Gandalf mused matter-of-factly, a rumbling softness in his speech that would once have eased Bilbo right down to the core, but did nothing at all, now. “It is clear that greater powers than you or I have granted you passage here, and they would not do so if you did not need it. Now, do you know why you are here?”
Bilbo smiled grimly.
“I do, but I am afraid I must keep it to myself for a little longer, because the full story requires some explanation, and not all of it will please you. In fact, most — most of it may rather disturb you.”
Gandalf twinkled down at him. “I wouldn’t be so sure of that, Bilbo.”
Bilbo’s mouth twisted unhappily. “Oh, I would.”
“Enough of this,” a lighter voice demanded. “You are foresighted?”
“Is that what it is? You see the future?”
Thranduil and Bard, in quick succession. They looked to each other, and Bard’s jaw was tight; he had not had a shave in several days, and his beard was growing in. He swept a hand over it.
“We had a soothsayer on the Lake, when I was young,” he said in clarification to the room, in such a short way that it prompted no elaboration or permittance of questions. “Before the Master took over.”
The Elvenking swept from his place at Gandalf’s side and cut a path in front of the table separating them to stand at its third edge, the table upon which the Arkenstone had lain only last night, though of course it felt like a year and a lifetime had passed since those early hours of the morning.
Thranduil looked down at him very seriously, but beneath it Bilbo could still see the brush of intrigue.
“Does Imladris know of this?”
Bilbo nodded, trying to keep his frustration beneath his skin and knowing he was doing a rather abysmal job, though at this Thranduil looked only mildly amused amidst his studiousness.
“Yes, Elrond knows. And in answer to your first question, no. Much to my displeasure, true foresight isn’t a gift us mortals have ever had bestowed upon us.” It had been a fair guess, really, and wasn’t unheard of by those who knew the Elven lords and ladies that still walked these shores, but it was quite frankly ridiculous to suggest it had been given to a simple hobbit from the Shire. “So no, I do not see the future. It is simply that I have — well, I have lived it before.”
Thranduil seemed, if not disquieted, then considering, watching Bilbo with a new weight and focus that had Bilbo almost tugging at his collar in his itch to be long rid of this tent, to be out somewhere else, anywhere else, away from this ghastly reminder.
There was rather a lot more debating and discussion, after that, of how he had come to know of his twice-lived nature, how he had been gifted the chance, how far on he had lived before coming back, how he was sure of events and sure of his place here. Less questions of his sanity than he had expected, though Bilbo was sure this was only because he held the trust of Gandalf and Elrond.
“This is how you knew there would be a clear shot at the dragon?” Bard had asked at one point. Bilbo nodded.
“And how I knew to come to you,” he confirmed, looking up at Bard looming high above him with a grave expression on his face. Oh, why could none of these other races ever be seated when they wanted to have a conversation? “It was going to be you who would slay Smaug whatever way it happened. The only difference this time was that we were able to save Esgaroth from burning.”
Bard looked as if supreme skepticism was warring inside of him with something akin to awe.
“What did you do in your past life, Mr Baggins?”
He seemed astonished, and curious. Grateful. And why wouldn’t he be? But it wore at the tatters of Bilbo’s emotions like a blunt knife.
“Nothing,” Bilbo said hollowly. “I did nothing at all.”
After a long while — far too long — Bilbo was finally allowed to leave the tent with Gandalf in equal step beside him; no easy feat, for someone whose strides were twice his own. Gandalf pressed a hand against his back for a moment, and though Bilbo did not look up, he knew that Gandalf had donned a well-worn smile.
“I rather suspected something about you, dear fellow” he said amicably. “The depth of your knowledge and attachment were both very intriguing to me.” He looked down at Bilbo, who flushed faintly rosy and did not look back. “You spoke of Lord Elrond, but I assume there is no one else who knows?”
Bilbo shook his head silently.
There was silence for some time, as they wove to and fro between people and tents and caches of weapons, and Bilbo pretended very pointedly and painfully that he could not see every passing eye fixed directly on him. The ground was terribly cold under his feet, and thorny rock gnawed at the soles with every step he took until his toes were numb and unfeeling.
One foot in front of the other, he thought. That’s the way.
“Why do you say you fear you have destroyed what you have been sent for?” Gandalf asked.
Bilbo breathed very deeply through his nose and ignored the sting.
“I was — returned here. To bring me peace.”
He’d have left it at that, but a stiff glance up at the wizard and his excruciating fondness caused Bilbo to clench his jaw and carry stubbornly on. “It’s certainly within reach. Was within reach. But I — I am deathly afraid I may have shattered that half of my heart too greatly for me to find it again.”
Gandalf hummed, a small melody that washed over Bilbo as a chill breeze he could not feel.
“I think he may surprise you yet,” was all he said.
There were several more moments of quiet, in which Bilbo only waited with teeth set on edge, knowing Gandalf far too well to think he was quite done yet, and then Gandalf piped up with, “It was quite a story you told, all those months ago, about the Elf and the Man and the dwarf. I did wonder.”
A brilliant flush of colour crept its way up Bilbo’s neck and over the tips of his ears. “I hadn’t realised you were awake.”
Not till the next morning, and he had done well to block it out since. Gandalf smiled, closing his eyes.
“That is exactly how I intended it.”
After that, Bilbo had retired into the tent he’d been given, though had others told it they might have used the word scarpered, and had been sat on his bunk each day since, wringing the threadbare covers in his hands and thinking and thinking and thinking.
And yet, not.
A cloudy sheen of persistent worry had settled over Bilbo, muted only by a likewise-pervasive apathy. He could not feel anything with his fingers; he was utterly and completely numb. He could not bear to be around anyone; he could not bear to think at all.
It wasn’t even the betrayal, that was the thing. That was nothing at all, now, really. Bilbo had done it long ago, and he’d very quickly do it again — already had, in fact. He felt no guilt, anymore, only a dulled remorse that it had to be this way, and if that made him terrible, then so be it. It was only one more thing to add to his ever-growing list.
But to look Thorin Oakenshield in the face, and say to him, I will bury you. To imagine it. To do it in front of his loved ones, the ones fighting for him to be their king. The ones Bilbo loved, too.
It was unforgivable. He felt like a glass of milk that had spilt all over the floor.
All the heavens help him, Bilbo was even beginning to feel his sympathy for Bard grow, now that he too could do nothing but sit in the silence of the Mountain looking down upon him like a great unspeaking judge. It was half of the reason he spent so much time indoors; he could not bear its great eye.
The other half, of course, was all the incessant gawking.
Oh, Bilbo could understand it, all right. It wasn’t enough that he’d told his dearest friends of the whole dirty secret — he’d practically summoned an audience to hear it as a grand proclamation. And really, had somebody in the Shire begun raving about knowing things that had not yet happened and their neighbours dropping dead, their family would have been quickly and quietly taken aside and had it suggested to them that they not go out in public anymore.
So Bilbo understood it. He just wasn’t required to like it, and like it he did not.
He threw himself backward onto the bedroll in a miserable huff, glowering at the mud-brown ceiling with all the force of someone whose insides felt like they had been scooped out and dumped unceremoniously on the floor. Oh, he was infuriating himself! Aching and miserable and cast out and the heavens knew what else. Pull yourself together, you miserable fool!
He stood back up at once, walked in a neat little lap around the bareboned tent with his hands firmly behind his back, then sat back down, ramrod-straight and blinking with a fast-working jaw.
Whose the tent was, Bilbo had not cared to learn, but they’d clearly left in a hurry to leave such a moping little creature to their own devices. There was almost nothing in it but some meagre foodstuffs and a few uncared-for weapons that lay in the corner — what looked to be a mallet, and perhaps a crossbow and some feathered arrows, though the string had long snapped and looked fairly pitiful. His mithril shirt and Sting were tossed in a corner like a fauntling’s old toys.
Really, it was petulant. It is not anybody else’s fault but your own, what you have done, sticking your foot entirely in your mouth, so you should not be dealing with its consequences in so childish a manner. And the fact that he had not awoken at once in Valinor or been sent right to the Halls of Mandos and then swiftly onward into the deep deep dark was entirely a miracle.
He stood up again, sat down again. It would be nice if they’d left him anything he could possibly hurl at the ground to soothe his terrible self-pity — a more solid wall to walk himself into, perhaps!
Bilbo was in fact very nearly considering storming off into the night to have another good sulk when the first raven came.
It fluttered through the doorway and startled him so badly he almost fell over his own feet. He stood at once in a dither and marched over, helplessly holding his hands out to — catch the bird? Offer it peace and goodwill? Who on the good Earth knew — and the raven slowed its flapping to settle in his cupped palms.
“Good morning!” Bilbo cried, losing his head.
He hadn’t the faintest idea what time of the day it was, and rather suspected it was much closer to suppertime, but the raven only fixed its beady eye assessingly on him in the dusky shroud of the tent and said, “You are the burglar of Erebor?”
Bilbo was so affronted that he forgot for a moment to be miserable and scoffed quite loudly at the raven’s audacity.
“If that is what I have been named, then yes, I suppose that is who I am. Who are you, might I ask?” he said, squinting.
The creature ruffled its glossy black wings and tilted its head back. It was truly impressive to behold. Bilbo imagined all the little larks and sparrows and honeyeaters of the Shire would’ve gotten an awful fright if ever they’d seen one of these great things about.
“I am Vörn, son of Roäc. I come at the behest of the Lonely Mountain. Will you hear my counsel?”
Gandalf’s counsel had been rather falling on deaf ears as it was, so Bilbo hardly thought that Vörn the mountain-raven was going to be able to do anything to change things. He sighed.
“First I should hear what it is you have to say, and then I shall make up my mind one way or another.”
The raven cleared its throat, so to speak.
“The dwarves of Erebor wish to speak with you on the matters discussed at the Front Gate three days hence. They ask you back to the Lonely Mountain at once, and would impart upon you the importance of such knowledge and the necessity of yourself to share it with them regardless of its sensitivity.”
As Bilbo’d suspected, really. Cold and impersonal. There was nothing in it of warning, nothing to clue him in as to whether he would be somehow heard out and given one more desperate chance or was being lured back to the ramparts only to be thrown over the side.
Bilbo bent his head.
(He was being awfully cruel. He knew his dwarves better than that. But, then again, he had never before betrayed their friendship so utterly and completely as this.)
“What is your response?” Vörn pressed, and Bilbo breathed out an unhappy laugh. Heavens, but he was exhausted.
“Give a fellow a moment to think, if you please!”
The raven shifted its head all the way to one side, blinking wide-eyed at him, if birds could be called wide-eyed, its black pupil like a glassy pearl.
Then, again: “What is your response?”
Bilbo’s mouth and heart both did a funny little flip, the broken frays of his temper flaring, and his fragmented emotions jumped right up into his throat and came out in a terrible tangle.
“Nothing, then,” he snapped. “I do not have one. I will not force myself upon them when they must feel more unsure of me than ever, and I won’t allow you to force me to either, Mr. Vörn, thank you very much. I bid you a safe flight back to Ravenhill, or wherever else it is you reside.”
And he let the tent flap fall.
The next morning Bilbo ambled out of his hiding-place in a plan to locate somebody who could point him in the direction of more substantial food, as although he’d have preferred to remain in his nice, cozy, dark little tent with no peeping eyes and peering whispers, his starving stomach and its frustratingly-stubborn penchant for second breakfast would wait for nothing and nobody else.
The second raven swooped down upon him at once.
”Bilbo Baggins of the Company. I am Väre, son of Vörn, grand-offspring of Roäc, descendant of Carc of Ravenhill upon the Lonely Mountain.”
Quite a grand pronouncement, from such a small creature. Bilbo inclined his head and shoulders and shamefully stammered out a faulty greeting. Väre puffed up all his feathers and raised himself squarely on his spindly legs, opening the sleek shine of his beak and fixing Bilbo with a look so focused Bilbo could do nothing but stand helplessly and receive whatever horrendous message he had been sent back for so rude a response.
”I have been informed by my father that you do not take his counsel; nay, you do not heed the words he brings you at all.”
Well, this one certainly had a personality on him. The Gondorians were sometimes known to keep falcons as pets, and Bilbo was sure that had Väre son of Vörn found himself among their falconry he would certainly have given them all his what-fors. He tilted his head and squinted down at the raven.
“I rather think your father neglected to mention to you several of the more specific details of his conduct, Väre, but I suppose he is not… entirely wrong in his assessment.”
Väre adjusted the grip of his talons on Bilbo’s arm, shuffling a little closer to the crook of his elbow, and Bilbo thought it a credit to himself that he did not wince at the dig of the claws into his Shire-soft skin.
“The dwarves of Erebor implore you to speak with them. Will you refuse?” Väre prodded. Bilbo bristled at once.
“I am not refusing. I am delaying,” he corrected, rather stubbornly. “There is a significant difference, if you must know.”
Väre stretched his wings and beat them once in the cold air.
“Their requests are urgent, and they have formally asked for your presence to discuss matters which to them are of utmost personal significance. Your decisions are unwise.”
Well!
Bilbo held Väre out at arms’ length, away from his body, fully aware he was frowning rather terribly now. But, really! “Should you not be one of the ones they sent off to the Iron Hills, and not lingering around here?”
To tell me off like I am some child with soup down his front when the circumstances are far, far more dire than that!
“It was I who was chosen,” Väre said. “I have returned. Dain marches forth-hence, with an army five hundred strong.”
All the fight dissipated from Bilbo in one sharp breath. They were marching to their deaths. Because Bilbo hadn’t even managed to blurt out something useful in the colossal fumble everyone in the entire North had had a front-row seat to.
He sent Väre away.
Of course, he was entirely unsurprised when, late that night, as he sat miserably in the cold underneath the lantern-light and pretended to be enjoying a pipe he could not taste over the melancholy of his own thoughts, a third raven came.
This one, though, he recognised. He was almost that of an eagle to Bilbo, regal even in his great age, perched on his knee and larger than almost any single bird Bilbo had seen that was not Gwaihir himself. His talons were gnarled, his feathers duller and his back more bent than his predecessors, but at the sight of him Bilbo shut quite entirely up.
”I am Roäc,” the old raven said simply. “I come to you, Bilbo Baggins, as you know, at the request of the dwarves of Erebor. They wish to hold counsel with you urgently, and wish also for you to know that they are not angered, that they sincerely desire only to speak with you and nothing else.”
“Oh, indeed, I’m sure the dwarves of Erebor desire to speak with me very much,” Bilbo said derisively.
(In his heart of hearts, Bilbo knew that on some level he was acting rather ridiculous. They were not going to force him out into the town square and throw old tomatoes at him because he’d said something far-fetched. They were not going to forget every fondness for one handful of blackened words.
It very likely didn’t help that they’d discovered he’d stolen their most prized possession not five minutes before he’d uttered it. But it wasn’t to be helped.)
But he knew they would all of them be back at the very first step. Back in Bag End, in front of the fire. It would… it would be as if they had not even sung for him.
Oh, would you stop moping, you poor, sad, wretched little excuse for a burglar!
Roäc had said nothing to his lack of composure, and Bilbo was embarrassed that he could not seem to behave like himself for all the world.
“Surely you are much too elderly to be flying around like this,” he muttered instead.
“You will not hear anybody else.”
Bilbo threaded his fingers through his own hair and pulled at the ends, dropping his head forward and holding himself up with his elbows.
”And how exactly is that surprising to you? You have all brought me this news at the behest of the dwarves, one by one, but neglect to mention what is the most important part, and then wonder why I do not come.”
For wasn’t angered only one emotion of so many others?
Bilbo forced a breath out his teeth, and it misted in the freezing air before him. It had started to snow, the gentlest fall of flakes from the sky blanketing the ground, speckling his own hair and Roäc’s feathers. He was going to catch a cold if he did not stop behaving like a complete twit soon. And then how much help will you be?
”What of the King, then, Roäc?” he asked quietly.
Roäc was silent for several moments, and Bilbo blinked sleet-drops from between his eyelashes.
“The King Under the Mountain does not speak. He has opted to have his advisors deliver this message in his place.”
Alright.
”I’ll — I’ll think on it,” Bilbo said.
That was the best he could do. He did not make it known to Roäc that it was all he had been doing.
“Very well. I have spoken.”
And away the bird went.
Bilbo was sitting on a pile of rock some way away from the Mannish camp and parallel to the Mountain, legs crossed and his ever-wringing hands resting in his lap.
It had been one full day since Roäc’s departure, and night had fallen a long time ago, the scattered stars creeping out to blink coldly down at them all. There were likely several people wondering where he was, considering he’d stolen away out here several hours ago, but he could not bear to be any closer one way or the other, at the minute.
Perhaps he was being ridiculous.
Of course you are, you colossal fool! he reprimanded himself at once.
Surely it was extraordinarily poor behaviour to refuse a raven’s aid so thoroughly. He most certainly had not made himself any friends in his rudeness, but every time he looked upon anything at all, the black birds or the cliffs chain-linked along the ragged mountainside or his own guilt-riddled hands in front of him, he was only reminded of it. All of it.
Bilbo imagined looking any of his dwarves in the eye. Ravens! he’d say. That’s rather opportune, isn’t it, that you’ve sent me ravens, because believe it or not I can tell you a thing or two about ravens, and Ravenhill, and what happens there, and who falls. You all heard me mention that, did you not? Heard me loud and clear?
Your King. Your King Under the Mountain is dead.
Bilbo had taken an axe to him with his own hands.
The crunch of gravel under foot echoed out suddenly behind him. There was a moment of slight grunting, and then Bilbo could sense a figure sitting down next to him, the familiar smell of gritty cloth and sweat and poor pipeweed cloaking him, comforting and dread-ridden both.
He closed his eyes, unsurprised.
“He is asking to speak with you,” said Dwalin. His tone was utterly emotionless, as unceremoniously gruff as always, and within it Bilbo couldn’t for the life of him figure out his true feelings on the situation. He had no idea how Dwalin was able to keep such composure. He’d been feeling sick about it all night and all day and all night again.
“So I’ve heard,” Bilbo replied, too mind-weary to put any bite in it. He tilted his head back, inhaling the night air through his nose, the tip of it entirely numb with cold. He could not make himself look at Dwalin. “But I’ve decided I rather doubt any of you will want to see me again for a very long time.”
Dwalin grunted in acknowledgement, letting it linger for a few moments.
“You’re leaving us, then?” he said finally.
Bilbo frowned, and he shook his head, fumbling at the hems of his trousers where they ended below his knobbly knees.
“Of course not,” he said, a tad irritably. “I was going to give you all a long while to think on it before I came back, but I will not abandon you, no matter which way you may feel about it. You are why I am here, after all.”
“Why you are here.” It wasn’t a question, and was said with a slight undercurrent of accusation, the smallest stirrings of what was surely disbelief. Bilbo nodded obstinately. “Why you are here on this quest?”
There really wasn’t any point beating around the bush, not when the bush in question had been shouted aloud for every Man and Elf and member of the Company to hear. Bilbo swallowed, throat reedy, and nodded.
“Why I am here on this quest once more.”
“How old are you truthfully, Bilbo?” another voice asked roughly, and Bilbo’s eyes shot open in surprise. Bofur was sitting in front of him, hatless and all with a scrutinising expression on his face, and beside him stood Balin, watching Bilbo with an all-too-knowing look, his face creased.
Bilbo wrinkled his nose and shot a look at Dwalin.
“I thought you’d come alone,” he said, a little accusingly. He’d been equal parts touched and terrified that it was Dwalin who had chosen to come, but that was apparently not quite the case. He squinted.
Dwalin leant back against the rock-shelf behind them, making himself quite comfortable and even stretching a leg out to settle in.
“That’s not my problem,” he said in the same surly tone, fixing Bilbo with a very intent stare. Bilbo was getting the distinct feeling he was rather pleased with himself.
He lowered his head, watching the ground at his feet, soot-stained dust mingling with the harsher slate underneath.
Now, it seemed, they were all here to mop up his spill.
“I… I don’t think I should talk about it, not at least while there are so many of you missing. I’m not sure if I should talk about it at all, to be honest with you. I didn’t ever intend to. I didn’t mean to say anything at all, it just… Well.” He scoffed in self-revulsion. “You all saw, didn’t you?”
There were a few mutterings and murmurs amongst the three of them, and though Bilbo could not feel his ears in the needling wind he was sure they were flushing so deeply plum-red as to be purple with shame; hot, writhing, burning, shame.
Fool of a hobbit. You complete fool of a hobbit.
“It was certainly brave of you, laddie,” said Balin, and the others echoed their agreement. Bilbo barked out a laugh. The sound rang out tinny and hollow, and his face shrivelled up like a dried-out prune.
“Don’t make me laugh, Balin. It was not brave of me to steal from you and then burden all of you in that way on top of it. You should not ever have found out something like that, not if I could help it, and I could help it. He —” His voice broke. He couldn't say the name. Could barely think it.
(And wasn’t life so circular that way?)
“He should not ever have had to find out something so awful.”
Bilbo couldn’t imagine in his deepest, dizziest nightmares being told directly to his face that he was going to die. He couldn’t see how any of them could go on. He couldn’t see how any of them were not holding him responsible for striking what may as well have been the killing blow.
”You regret it, then?” Dwalin asked darkly, his face suddenly twisted. “Stealing from us?”
Bilbo glowered. “You think I don’t?”
Well, he didn’t. But that was quite entirely beside the point.
“Aye, well,” Balin said, “that’s another matter in itself, but we do in part understand, even if some of us were… not entirely pleased about it. And all personal feelings on the Arkenstone aside, none of us can argue that it hasn’t had an effect.”
Bilbo looked up.
“What?”
Balin’s mouth was tensed, but kind, and he was looking down at Bilbo with a drawn sort of pity, as if finding out such an awful truth had only made him want to assure Bilbo all the more.
“It has brought him back to himself.”
Bilbo smiled unhappily and forced himself not to scoff aloud again, though the idea was so ludicrous he would have been well within his right, in his own opinion. His mouth tugged up cynically at one corner.
“How can you know that?”
“You didn’t see it, laddie, but he stood on that rampart all day after you left us, not moving or speaking at all, standing there like to a statue. When he came down into Erebor that night, his crown was in his hand instead of on his head.”
“Oin thinks his mind was at war with itself,” Bofur added.
Well. That was certainly a spanner in the works of his own wallowing, but not one Bilbo couldn’t contend with.
For there was far, far worse on the horizon now than a dwarven hunger for gold.
“I… well, I’m glad for that, I truly am,” Bilbo said, but I do not quite understand, Balin, why it is you think that changes anything at all.”
“Bilbo.” It was Bofur again, smiling at him with just as much teasing, just as much good-heartedness as usual, and Bilbo could not understand. “We knew there was something about you, lad.”
“Yes, something! Something means that I sleep with my eyes open as an Elf does, or that I talk to myself as if somebody else is there, not that I am — that I know —“
He curled into himself, staring at the barren ground, the salt-lines and minerals in the rock beneath his toes, no doubt older than the entire Shire. He was muddling his words, and panicking, and oh, this was terrible, this was torment and torture, why hadn’t they listened to their dratted ravens!
“How can you act as though you trust me like nothing has happened?” he demanded stubbornly. “How can you sit here and tell me you understand, that you know, that you are not waiting in secret with more arrows nocked, treasonous as I am!”
“Oh, aye, it’s Master Baggins, the great big scary burglar-hobbit. I’m shaking in my boots,” drawled Dwalin, cocking his outstretched leg at the knee and picking up one of his axes to sharpen with a mightily-unimpressed eye-roll. “You being a thieving little snake doesn’t make you a shred scarier than you were before, hobbit.”
“Don’t behave as if you don’t know what I’m talking about,” Bilbo snapped. “I am — I have —“ He took a breath, closing his eyes momentarily and sucking in all the courage he could muster through his teeth in the freezing air.
“If somebody had told me all of a sudden that someone I loved was going to die,” he said shakily, thinking of dark curls and a weary smile aboard a boat to nowhere, the cloudy smear of his thoughts, “I cannot see that I would ever speak to them again. Ever.”
He would have wrought havoc if he had known. If in his right mind, he had been able to see.
Balin smiled at him very softly. “But you would know in your heart that it was true, wouldn’t you?”
Here, so far from the camp and its lights dangling among the tents, the midnight sky had enveloped them with all the stars of Elbereth, strung like pearls across the sky. All four of them were still, Bilbo’s heart pumping so hard he wondered absently if he should be worrying, and then Balin moved, and after a moment he had seated himself down beside Bilbo on his little rock outcrop, wrapping his cloak up about him.
“Bilbo, how much do you know of dwarf-lore? Of our history?”
Bilbo scrunched up his face. Useless question. And Balin knew the answer.
”Scarcely anything, as I’ve told you, and I believe you are well within your right not to share an inch of it with anybody but yourselves. I know as much as I’ve been able to find on my own, and that is all I need.”
“But you know of Durin?”
Bilbo stifled a rude laugh, thinking it would probably have been uncouth even in present company, and especially when they were being so bafflingly polite. But then again — of course he did. Durin’s Day. Durin’s Folk. Durin’s Bane. He’d seen the name, and what history he’d read told that there had been six of them who’d borne it, stretching out all through the ages from the very beginning, before even the Elves.
But as they began to speak, he realised.
It seemed the six were one.
”There are others of our race who have lived more than one lifetime,” Balin explained slowly. Dwalin shifted forward, bringing his hand-axes with him. Poor replacements for Grasper and Keeper, but they’d had to make do.
”Aye, the very first of us, the founder of Khazad-dûm. The Deathless. He has come back again and again to live among our people.”
Bilbo began to get the creeping feeling that this was not something he was supposed to be told.
And it was all irrelevant anyway, and he said as much to them, waving his hands around helplessly and feeling increasingly like the rug would be be pulled out from underneath him any minute now, any second. They could not possibly mean what he thought they meant.
“I appreciate your meaning, but I am hardly Durin!” he said weakly, eyes darting back and forth between them, to Balin, to Bofur, to Dwalin; Balin, Dwalin, Bofur. “I am not the tallest or the bravest or the richest or the hardiest. I am not a king.”
Even as drawn as he looked, Balin still managed the ghost of a smile.
“But you are the oldest, aren’t you?”
Bofur grinned; a small one, dimmed by the cold and the circumstances, but there nevertheless. “The oldest hobbit who ever lived was a Baggins, the way I’ve heard it. No, you certainly aren’t any sort of Durin, not at all. You’re Bilbo — Bilbo the Second, if I am not mistaken.”
“Well, you are mistaken, for I haven’t died yet,” Bilbo objected snappishly, then felt his cheeks heat till they were crimson.
Dwalin made a noise, and a slow smirk stretched across his grim face. He glanced to Bilbo, assessing him, then back down studiously to his whetstone and blades.
“Bilbo the Deathless, then,” he grunted.
Oh, what on Earth and all the heavens were they talking about!
“Surely this is blasphemy against your own people!” he cried, arms thrown wide. “I have not been reborn, or reincarnated, or whatever it is. I have just been — I don’t know what I have been, but I have ended up here again. That’s all it is.”
Whisked away. Hurled backward. Lain here beside my sleeping heart. Floated in on a spring breeze.
Balin looked away from Bilbo and back to Bofur with a peculiar sort of expression.
“And, it seems, we are all the more lucky for it.”
Bilbo supposed it was high time he resigned himself to the fact he would not be getting rid of them, and he sighed, exhaustion riddling him in every pore.
“Well, what do we do, then? The quest hasn’t quite finished yet. There is more to come, far more that I must tell you, and it is that which I am most afraid of. It was there that he… that…” An invisible hand seemed to grip at Bilbo’s windpipe, and he could not say another word.
“I told you already,” Dwalin said, the rhythmic slice of his whetstone echoing out beneath him and the blade of one axe clasped in his fingers, “that he is asking to speak with you.”
Fine, then. If they were going to pester him anyway, then he’d tell them everything, but only when it was over. He’d lay all his cards bare when the battle had been won.
Even set in his resolve as he was, now that they’d managed to convince him that at the very least he wasn’t going to be entirely ostracised by the lot of them, it took Bilbo almost the whole of the next day to muster up the dregs of his courage and make the approach to the Mountain. He made his way over at dusk, when the sky was equal parts the softest of lemon-yellows and the lightest of lavenders, the onset of winter washing out the coming sunset so far north but nevertheless beautiful. A sign, his mother would have called it. Look, my Bilbo. Look at the magic of the sky, to hold so many colours at once. Look how people can do it also.
It watched him silently as he walked, eyes narrowing the closer he got, head looming ever taller, until he could no longer see the peak in his proximity. He reached the lip of the riverbank at the base of the Front Gate, and stood for a long moment in its shadow, colossal and silent, only hoping that he would not be judged too harshly.
“No time like the present, is there!” Bilbo muttered to himself with a grimace, his feet feeling like water, or perhaps like the muddy sludge you found in a swamp, his stomach slipping and sliding and becoming queasier with every step. It was a very small mercy that at the very least he did not have to wade through any more moat-water, as the River Running had finally frozen over, and he could make his way across easily enough, though the ice was thin and clear, and he took care to tread lightly.
Bilbo reached the far side, summoned up every last measly crumb of his own battered courage, and tried hard not to think that he was calling for his own doom.
“Ho, the Mountain!” he bellowed.
There was a few moments of pause, during which he swallowed around a throat that felt like a washrag and pinched himself once more, just in case, and then the rope came down, and it was his rope, still tied on and all, for Bilbo could see nobody clinging on to the other end.
It’s a wonder they haven’t sawn it off and cast it to the wolves, he thought drily, and hated himself for it, moving gingerly forward and taking it in hand with numb and shaking fingers.
He climbed and climbed, and hands grasped him as he reached the top, hauling him by the shirtsleeves and catching him steadily when he clambered over the barricade onto the top steps of the battlements. Bilbo looked up in trepidation, sure that he was going to burst if he had to suffer much longer like this, and there with one hand still on his shoulder was Fili watching him very intently, raising his eyebrows the slightest bit and bending his gaze down to Bilbo’s.
“All right, Master Baggins?”
He smiled at Bilbo, though it was only slight, not nearly half as mirthful as he’d been before, and Bilbo had to set his shoulders very squarely not to crumple. That was just it, wasn’t it? Now it would be small smiles, all tentative, all timid, like they didn’t quite know what to do with him, like he was now a far-distant stranger rather than a friend. And Bilbo supposed that for all intents and purposes he was, which only made it all the worse.
He swallowed the lump that had stuck itself fast in his throat and nodded jerkily, then steadied a hand on the balustrade of the Gate for a small moment, taking a deep breath and feeling as if his lungs were full of moth-wings. Then, he walked gently forward, reaching the winding staircase and seeing below at last his Company gathered in a ring around the base.
There they all stood, staring at him with looks he could not and would not begin to decipher: Bifur, Bombur, Nori, Dori, Oin, Gloin, Kili, Ori. Balin. Dwalin. Bofur. Only after his wrung-out eyes had traversed them all and come up short did Bilbo spy the figure standing partway to the side, and his heart leapt and sunk and collapsed inward and unfurled till it surely filled every inch of his body.
There, standing sentinel at the edge of the Company, a body apart, a being in exile as he had been longer than Bilbo had drawn breath in the world, was Thorin Oakenshield.
Bilbo fought not to let his face cleave itself in two.
The dragon-sickness had sucked all life from him; he seemed to have utterly shut down from the inside out. His clothes hung limply at his sides, his hair was dead, lifeless, and a subterranean sheen lay over his skin — what little of it Bilbo could see, at least, since he was half-turned away from the rest and staring into the distance, looking at nothing and no one. The half-moon of his face was devoid of any emotion; there was no anger, no affection, neither relief nor rancour. There was almost no indication that he felt anything at all but for the haunted look in his eyes.
That dastardly crease between his brows seemed to have made a permanent home there in the couple of days Bilbo had been gone, and Bilbo mourned with a terrible bittersweetness that it had not even been more than a week since those hands had cupped his cheek and touched so gently at his temple.
After an eternity, Bilbo reached the bottom of the staircase, and when he stepped towards Thorin, the wellpools of his guilt and sorrow threatening to break across the floor, Thorin took a step away, angling his head towards Bilbo in a perverse and terrible bow. They stopped, and looked at each other; the world around them had utterly stilled, as if everything else had simply fallen away.
Ah.
“Well,” Bilbo croaked out intelligently. The sound clanged sharp and ugly in the silence. He may as well have clobbered them all over the head with it.
Oh, dear, this was awful.
He could hardly begin to look at any of them. How could he have thought he could come down here, could be amongst such friends when he’d cut them down and thrown their trust and care at his feet for stomping on? It didn’t matter an inch or a mile what Balin and Dwalin and Bofur said — they couldn’t be sure, they hadn’t asked, they’d only assumed —
He did not know what to do, what to say, how to breathe. He was walking along untrodden soil; last time, after his betrayal, they had not come together as one Company again until Thorin and Fili and Kili were already dead and laid to rest. Last time there had been no last time. His thieving and fleeing had been the very last.
Alright, then.
Bilbo turned abruptly around and began to pace.
“I’m sorry. I’m so very sorry, oh, I cannot believe what a clothead I have made of myself! What I must have put you all through, what I — I am kicking myself, I have never — I wish I had not —“
He stopped, took a breath, and turned back around, his eyes bypassing them all and lifting to the empty space above their heads. He addressed every word to it determinedly.
“It was never, ever my wish that you would have to find out something so awful, and it is entirely because I could not keep my own head that it came to light at all. I hope very much that I haven’t made an enemy out of any of you, with my lying and sneaking and telling you that — oh, I am so very, deeply, indescribably sorry. And if — if you do not trust me any longer, I will not blame you in the slightest. I will keep my distance.”
Better that they live a life apart from him, but live all the same. His heart could still rest, that way.
Bilbo bowed low, so low had he crouched on bent knees his nose would have touched the floor, and his tattered hair was hanging in his eyes, for once blessedly curtaining his face from the terrible weight of their judgement bearing down on him. He was half-sure that the guilt had settled so deeply within him that the peace he’d been promised would mean nothing at all in the end, now. He’d cut it out with his own bloodied hands. From his own traitorous tongue.
”You should not forgive me if you do not wish it,” Bilbo rasped at the cracking granite beneath his toes. “But you must — you must know, every word I said was true. I have never told you untruths of my own feelings, have never had time for them when it was not absolutely necessary, for you are truly all more dear to me than I can ever say.”
There. It was done.
It was done.
Bilbo’s chest was moving up and down like he’d run the length of the Mountain, and he dared not look up, at first, not even when second after second passed in only ear-splitting silence. But then:
“You are a mighty fool and a clever little sneak, Bilbo.”
Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut very tightly, bracing himself, and then looked up from where he was bowed to find his Company still standing there, the most bemusing sort of expressions on their faces and not helping the snaking of his insides in the slightest. All of them stood looking at him with astonishment, of all things, wonder and disbelief and no small amount of indignation at finding out the truth of Bilbo’s grand deception.
“Yes, I suppose I am,” Bilbo confirmed simply, with what he hoped was an apologetic grimace. But Dori — it was Dori who’d spoken, then — was smiling; slight, but very clearly there. And he was not the only one.
“I —“ Bilbo looked again at Bofur and Dwalin, each twirling his hat on his fingers and with his great forearms crossed in front of him, respectively. “What have you — ?”
His voice petered out into nothing, and he bit the inside of his lip. How much have you told them? How much do they know?
Dwalin rolled his shoulders back. ”All have heard tell of Bilbo the Deathless,” he said wryly. Bilbo tilted his head and scrunched his nose up, blowing out a long-suffering breath.
“That nonsense again,” he muttered, cutting his eyes upward in a roll before he remembered himself and reddened to the roots of his hair.
And then Gloin chimed in helpfully with, “Aye, Roäc told us you were looking grey as an old bedsheet,” and that sent him into a full-scaled bluster.
”Oh, really — how can you expect me to believe you are all taking this so casually! How have you not run me out with pitchforks for being a raving lunatic!”
“We told you, laddie,” Balin said kindly, “and though I’m sure we’d all like to think it, it is not a surprise we are not the only beings in Middle-Earth with pathways of re-entering the world.”
And that drew Bilbo up quite short, for every word of it was true, and he could not believe he had forgotten. He even went so far as to scoff aloud at himself in disbelief, eyes wide. How many Elvish books had he read in the latter days that told the lore of their second-lived, and now he was having to be unknowingly reminded of it by dwarves, of all things!
(Though if he was being especially contrary, it was not in the waking world that they spent their days, only in the bright daylight of Valinor and Eldamar, basking in the paths of the sun and moon across the sky.
Although, that fellow Glorfindel…)
Fili stepped forward then, from where he’d faltered at the bottom step behind Bilbo, likely not wanting to set him off any further when he was already displaying signs of cracking at the seams. His voice was soft, but steady, and firm, and the abrupt thought that he was going to make the most wonderful king in the years to come hit Bilbo with such swiftness that he very nearly lost every bit of composure he’d managed to snatch back then and there.
“We haven’t wanted to lie to you, Bilbo,” Fili said. “It startled us all, and some of us at first quite badly.” He looked down at Bilbo and smiled sadly, eyes shining in the dim light, and Bilbo realised with another awful twinge that Fili was talking about himself. His own guilt reared its fangs once more. “But you’re sorely mistaken if you think you’ve scared us off wanting to know when all you’ve done is the exact opposite.”
“Aye, we’re a sturdy lot,” Bofur added. “It’s not so frightening, the thought that you are from elsewhere. You can tell us. And it could help.”
And this was exactly why thinking should be entirely eradicated, and emotions, too, besides, Bilbo reasoned with growing hysteria, because he felt like a bowl that had far too much poured into it, like a drowned pot-plant left out in the rain, like a broken thread in the eye of a needle. He had not the slightest idea what to do with all of the feeling he had suddenly dumped into his hands. He could barely stand to bear witness to their gazes; could not understand them at all.
You did promise, you know. Not in so many words, of course, but who would he be if he did not deliver now? Hadn’t Dwalin traipsed halfway to Dale just to inform Bilbo that Thorin wanted to speak with him?
Well, Thorin most certainly wasn’t asking now. But the rest of them were.
Bilbo sighed. There was nothing for it, then. Onward he must go.
“There is still more I need to tell you,” he began slowly. “Not all of it, mind you; there are things still to come, both near-ways and far off, and I do not want to waste time waffling on when it is not yet needed. But I will tell you a little.”
Rip the bandage off, old lad, that’s the way.
“You know I am from somewhere else, or somewhen else, I suppose, and that I have come back, or reappeared, or whatever it is you dwarves call it. But I’m worried I might give you a bit of a shock when I tell you how far away the when is that I have come from.”
Bilbo turned back to them, chagrinned, and closed his eyes one last time. “I was fifty when I came with you on this adventure the first time, but now it has been eighty-three years, or thereabouts, and I am one hundred and thirty-two. This is my second time living this portion of my life, and it has all been for this quest.”
Whispered exclamations followed this, of course, but Bilbo very stubbornly pushed on, affecting a variation on the voice he used teaching fauntlings to read, knowing the only way out was through, and that at least now the worst was over.
Well. Most of the worst.
“Most of the big things are the same. Little things have been different. Conversations I have had with all of you, and the ways you have all started to trust me. Our friendships formed a little faster, and I’m sure it is because I could not keep my love for all of you to myself, and perhaps because you all realised a little earlier that I was useful after all.”
He shoved his hands in his pockets and rocked back and forth on the pads of his feet. ”After — after, I went back to Bag End, and you all stayed here in your Mountain, of course. And when my nephew came to live with me, I raised him on stories of dwarves and dragons and Thorin Oakenshield, because I knew it would be silly to pretend that the strings of my heart were not wound up with you all.”
The tips of his ears warmed, and he bowed his head very slightly.
Dwalin whistled.
“Such flattery,” somebody whispered, and someone else likewise piped up with a, “You are entirely silver-tongued, Bilbo!”
“Yes, well,” Bilbo said gravely, “if I were you, I would not speak too soon, for you may well scorn me still, when you hear the rest.”
For they were being so kind, so very dearly kind to him, and yet they all still talked around it, the very it he had been incessantly thinking himself sick about. His grand declaration of doom. His omen, signed, sealed and delivered.
And still they did not know.
What on all the Earth was he supposed to do? Tell them all of it, or tell them none? He wrung his hands, tugged at his own sleeves and stared at them helplessly, his heart beating a rapture against his chest. They’d all started to falter, now, perhaps sensing his distress, and Thorin, Thorin would not meet his eyes. He hadn’t once in all the time since Bilbo had started to speak.
Bilbo had to finish, had to tell them all of it. It would tear him in two all over again, but then, that was nothing new from the last week of his life, over and over shredding himself apart and stitching his weary mind back together.
”You do not understand yet. This is not the end.” The words felt dry and wrong-fitting on Bilbo’s supposedly-silver tongue. He could hardly form them at all.
But he had to. He must. He closed and unclosed his hands, and met their eyes.
“If you must know, you have to be aware that there is no happy news to come. It will only hurt you more. But the more I think to tell you, the more I cannot see a way out with all of you still in the dark.”
Death-defier, Deathless, and now Death’s deliverer.
“We have a little more time. I… well, I — uh, anyway, things happened a little earlier than they did the last time. We still have some time left before they come.”
“Before who comes, Bilbo?” Ori asked.
It was a terrible, terrible mirror of his enraptured audience in Laketown, as he’d sat in their staying-house and lathered them in fondness, told them of his feelings of family and friendship, only now, Bilbo was peeling it away.
“The goblins have followed us here. They are on wargs. They will try to take the Mountain. It is there that you… that I…”
Bilbo’s eyes flickered to Thorin, a figure in the dark; they fell very quickly, and his voice collapsed into a pathetic nothingness, an absence. He couldn’t lift his eyes to theirs.
“It is there. And it is not only you who was lost, Master Oakenshield.”
The Company seemed to take this all in stride, though they’d clearly blanched, and oh, he had to get this over with right now — he couldn’t stand being the bearer of news like this over and over and over again. His heart was going to give out.
At the front and centre of the cluster, Kili was frowning, his brows creeping together on his face. He looked steadily at Bilbo, who could only look powerlessly back.
”Who?”
Bilbo thought he might have shattered, then, as stalactites when spring came.
“I’m sorry.” A dreadful quiver struck itself across his bottom lip, and he had to bring a hand to his mouth to cover it, eyes wide and glassing over as he looked desperately at them all. Oh, how could he say it?
He squeezed his eyes shut, biting the blasted lip until it was stinging, but it no longer mattered. He could see them.
One golden-haired, one dark. Twin smiles, watching him in anticipation.
Oh, my boys. I’m so sorry.
Bilbo opened his eyes and watched those smiles for a moment more, thinking of seeing them at his door, knowing they would never appear quite like this again, after what he told them. He drew his hand away and clenched it in a fist.
”The line of Thrain begins the assault with four,” he said, “and ends with one.”
He did not even wait for the lance to strike before he was hastening frantically on, eyes wild and heart beating and hands spread wide as if to shield the truth he’d just revealed. ”But you listen to me, all right?” Bilbo urged, as fiercely as he was able. “I’m promising you now, and you have trusted me all this while, haven’t you? I will not let you fall again.”
He would not. None of them. It was not even a question in the mind. Bilbo realised his vision had gone quite blurred, and he focused on the point of the floor where their boots were all lined up in a neat little row. His frail old chest was hammering like a war-drum.
”Your allergies,” a voice called.
Kili’s voice. Bilbo’s brief smile was watery and wobbling in his face when he replied with all the weight of two worlds, one held in each hand.
“My allergies,” he confirmed.
Fili had gone entirely white and was staring at his brother, and his face would have looked blank had the thickness of his emotions not at that moment felt so potent in the air. His mouth opened, but there was no sound that poured forth — after all, what conceivable thing was there to say?
There’d been other sounds that had burst from his friends at the words, sounds of grief and anger and sorrow, but Bilbo could not pay heed to any of them. Dwalin’s face had not changed aside from the sudden hardening of his eyes, and still, he looked heartbroken. Balin’s eyelids were closed, a single silver path drawing a gentle line down his cheek.
And the King had turned entirely away.
“I think that very soon, Master Baggins,” Fili said in the hoarsest of voices, swallowing, “we will owe you debts we cannot ever repay.” The sentiment was quickly echoed by all the others, but Fili’s eyes were shining-gold as they looked upon only Bilbo, and Bilbo shook his head so adamantly it might have flown right off.
He would not see them fall even if he had to beg on hands and knees to change it a thousand times over. Not for long, long years yet. And if they had not realised the determination of a hobbit set on achieving his own way by now, then all the more fool them.
Bilbo screwed up his face, straightened his waistcoat and looked them all dead in the face.
They knew, now. So now the work began.
“Not a chance, you confusticating things. I know it’s horrible. It was horrible then. But you, all of you, will live to see the sun rise.”
It was far later when Bilbo Baggins found himself atop the battlements of the Front Gate of the Lonely Mountain once more, though this time it had been his choice, and this time he was entirely alone, gazing out wonderingly at what they’d dubbed the desolation of Smaug.
It looked different, in this almost-darkness. A black sea, spilling across the plains of the Mountain, broken only by the conglomeration of tents erected by the camps of Mirkwood and Laketown, tiny lantern-lights flecked across a midnight moor. The sky that bloomed above was the deep blue of paint-pots, of fine satin and lupine thistles. Bluebells and lobelias.
Bilbo wrinkled his nose.
The moon was only a slither of cream-yellow in the uppermost corner of the sky, and the evening was young enough that the stars had not entirely woken yet, so the whole effect was of a deep watercolour blurring into darkest black.
Bilbo leant forward further, folding his arms more tightly against his chest and tucking them against the bannister lining the ramparts. The stone was so cold as to be freezing when he touched it, and Bilbo imagined the skin of his arms and the pads of his fingers sticking to the ice, holding him there until deep in his chest was eased the guilt that still swelled in him like hot, sour bile.
Behind him, there began to echo faint, booted footsteps, making their way forward slowly in order not to disturb the quiet, or to break the gentle spell the sky had cast. Bilbo closed his eyes against the night for a moment and breathed out a quiet sigh.
He could sense it when Thorin had walked up to stand beside him, the two of them bent forward over the bannister and watching out over the dull lights of the camp in the distance. They did not look at each other.
Beside was rather a strong word for it, Bilbo supposed — there was a gap of several feet between them, enough that if Thorin truly desired it, he could pretend he contemplated the dusk in solitude, that nobody was there and nobody had burdened him with the weight of mountains upon his chest.
Thorin spoke first.
“You have a nephew.”
It was a question and yet not, and his voice was raspy and coarse and quiet, so terribly quiet, but not cold. Not harsh. It was hardly anything at all.
Bilbo’s mouth tugged upwards.
“Not yet. His parents are still quite young at present, but yes. I had a nephew.” He frowned and angled his head to the side. “Technically he is a first-cousin-once-removed on my mother’s side and a second-cousin-once-removed on my father’s, but that’s all Shire semantics.”
“He was close to you.”
Another statement. Bilbo knew, of course he knew, why Thorin was being so distant, and his own smile felt hard-won and bittersweet across his lips. It had all been said and done, now, and one way or another they had to set about picking up the pieces, and he only wished he could tell Thorin there was nothing so broken they could not mend it in a way that Thorin would believe.
Please don’t hide yourself away again. I only just got you back.
“I’d always wished you could have met him,” Bilbo said in reply. “He was quite lucky his ears never fell off from all the times I talked about you.”
There was quiet for a little while. Bilbo tried not to contemplate too deeply what it meant.
“Is it him you always speak to, when you are alone?”
He looked to the side, and the moon was blue, the sky tipped teal and indigo and royal silk, dark enough that he could barely distinguish between the outline of Thorin’s silhouette and the blotted spill of night behind him. Carved from the mountainside. A figure brush-stroked against the dark.
It felt so strange to say it out loud, to talk about Frodo at all when not a single person in this lifetime remembered him. Bilbo was used to carrying the memories of someone who was gone, and keeping them to himself, and to have spoken them aloud twice now felt like opening up the inside of his chest for everyone to see.
“Yes.”
There was no noise at all around them, these two lonely figures against the battlements. It was probably the thing that unsettled Bilbo the most about the Mountain, and had meant he could never quite lie still or settle even when he’d been sheltered here all those years ago. The long-ago destruction all around them meant there were no plants for crickets to chirp in, or moths to flit about in wonder, nothing for flies to pester or bees to pollinate. Only the gentlest brushes of night air, and the barest crushing of ice atop the river below them, as winter crept in and the frost found its way all over the Mountain.
In the dark, Thorin’s knuckles tightened against the bannister, and he lowered his head.
”I was blind,” he whispered.
“Thorin.”
Bilbo didn’t say it so much as breathe it, the absence of a whisper in the ink-dark quiet. “I have known many great kings, Thorin. You are a great king. You cannot blame yourself for falling to torment that others have fallen to.”
Every line in Thorin’s body had hardened; he seemed as if he’d been molded in a kiln, the heat too bright, and the clay had split his face from the inside out, cracked inside a porcelain bowl.
“Do not speak of it. Please.”
Bilbo took a cautious step closer, resting a gentle hand on the bannister near where Thorin’s had curled into fists, biting into the stone. It really was strange, to think that this might have been the most plainly they had ever truly spoken to each other. Everything about the both of them had been entirely stripped away, and now here they stood, no more dwarf and hobbit, no King or burglar; hollowed out, the skeletons of trees in a dead forest.
“I know what it is,” he said, “for something to have such a hold on you, to feel as though it is choking you, slowly, and that only holding onto it tighter will get it to stop. You are not the only person that has felt like this. I am broken too.”
He looked away, back towards the sky. He could feel Thorin staring in his direction, the intensity of his words demanding an explanation in kind, and had to swallow down the lump that grew in his throat.
Not just yet, love. There is still a battle to win.
“You cannot know,” Thorin murmured, with no anger in it. ”You cannot speak to me of it as if you could possibly know.”
No anger in it, but no love. No familiarity. Not anymore. Whatever fondness Thorin had held for him had been butchered, had been severed and stripped away.
But Bilbo had known it would happen, anyhow. He’d known. He would live to fight another day. In the grandest scheme of things, it didn’t matter at all.
(In the less grand, however — well, that was neither here nor there.)
Thorin had forgiven him once. All he could do was hope that it would happen again.
“Surely you heard me screaming it about all the Mountain,” Bilbo joked softly, having decided that if they were going to speak of it, he would shove his finger right into the bruise if it would at least get them somewhere.
Thorin scoffed, though the sound did not have the slightest shred of humour in it, and he bent his head to look down at his own hands. Bilbo watched him helplessly. He could not remember ever feeling so out of place at Thorin’s side, not since the very beginning. He could not recall ever being able to read so little of what was in Thorin’s shoulders, in his brow.
The stillness stretched on, and Bilbo opened his mouth.
“I will tell you, when it is over and we both live through this,” he said quietly, meaning it. “I promise.”
Thorin’s head rose, and he looked out at the land beyond, lowering his hands till they were by his side. His jaw cut an indent into the side of his face, and worked, and worked, and worked.
”You brought my mind back from ruin. We owe each other nothing more.”
Bilbo stood for a little while longer, watching Thorin weakly and utterly unable to think of a single thing to say. The wind was whipping at them, hastening the creeping, dead fingers of the cold, and Bilbo withstood it for as long as he possibly could, but after a long while he conceded defeat. There would be nothing more said between them. And Thorin still would not look back at him.
Bilbo stepped away, freezing feet padding their way to the top of the stairs, reaching out a hand to grip the balustrade for fear he would slip in the numbness. His body was hunched against the cold, and he turned one last time to look back at Thorin, who still stood unmoving, facing the direction of the outstretching mountainside. His head was raised to look out at the armies still at his door, and behind him the sky was utterly dark, the ghostly moon enshrouded now by passing cloud, the horizon black like the ink of a fountain pen, black like tar, black like the inside of your own eyelids, the absence of anything at all.
”Master Burglar.” the voice rumbled, and Bilbo slowed, wrapping his arms about himself to protect his body from the chill. He made no answer, only the pause of his feet, but after several more moments of silence Thorin spoke. “What was his name?”
Bilbo smiled softly.
“He was called Frodo. Frodo Baggins.”
Bilbo woke to the jostling of caravan wheels and a bumpier road than he should have liked, grumbling to himself inaudibly and smacking his lips as he pulled his aged body from sleep into waking and blinked his bleary eyes.
Ah, that was right. They were on the road again.
There was a weight beside him, a weight that was moving and making noise, and as he painstakingly peeled back his own cloudiness he realised all at once that it was his Frodo-lad again, speaking to his uncle in a gentle, gentle voice.
“I’ve left our book with Sam, now, Bilbo, don’t you know?” He was smiling, but it seemed so terribly sad.
Oh, it really was a puzzle, wasn’t it! What in all the world could that boy have to be sad about, such early little lines around his eyes and mouth and creases along his brow where there ought to be none for a few long years yet, not at the ripe young age he was at, only yet still a flower in spring.
“He’ll put it in the Mathom-house for certain,” Frodo was saying, still saying, and Bilbo realised belatedly that he had entirely forgotten to listen. “Or take it out at Yuletimes and read it to all his children until they’re scared out of their breeches, and Merry and Pippin will come and act out all the parts. Did you hear? I suppose you wouldn’t have, would you? He and Rosie had a little girl.”
But when had there been lines around Frodo’s eyes? Bilbo couldn’t quite recall seeing those there before, either. Had it really been so long since they’d seen each other after Frodo’s little adventure? Bilbo felt as if he’d only fallen asleep yesterday and Frodo had been there, packing up his books for him and tucking a blanket up round his ears as he sat in his favourite old spot by the fire.
He’d left it behind now, though, hadn’t he? Off they were, on a shiny new adventure, in their caravan with Elves on all sides and Samwise Gamgee sitting up the front with Gandalf.
A dreadfully croaky old voice spoke up, and after a moment Bilbo realised in the spidery recesses of his mind that it was his.
“Rosie… Rosie?”
How many years had it been, then? For he distinctly remembered celebrating his last birthday in Rivendell, and gifting all the Elves poems he’d hand-written in curling script with his best pen that had probably looked awfully like the scratches of chickens to them, never mind that Elves did not even keep chickens! He’d turned one-hundred and thirty… thirty…
“Rosie Cotton,” Frodo said, patiently. “Remember old Farmer Cotton, down past the Hill in Bywater?”
“Oh!” Bilbo cried. “Oh, yes, of course. Only just the other day, don’t you know, he was up buying potatoes from me rather than eating his own!”
One hundred and thirty-one.
Two years, then.
But two years for what? He couldn’t for the life of him remember what it was he’d been thinking so hard about. Oh, it couldn’t have been all that important. He shook himself and focused back on Frodo.
“Well, Rosie and Sam have been living with me in Bag End, and their daughter is called Elanor, like the flower that grows in Lothlórien, and she is just as beautiful.”
His dear eyes were fond, so fond as he spoke, and he’d begun to look away into the distance one looked into when one was thinking of things that were no longer there. Bilbo folded his brittle face into a tired smile.
“That’s good, that’s awful good to hear. It’s yours, now, you know, Frodo. Left you everything in it.” He closed his eyes. All this travelling was really rather tiring, in truth. “I shan’t be seeing it again, I don’t think.”
Elanor. Elanor. Did Elves give their flowers meanings? Bilbo’d never thought to ask, which seemed a large oversight on his behalf, considering his position in an Elven house for almost two decades now. He resolved to do it after he woke from his nap by the fire.
“No, Bilbo. I don’t think you shall.”
And if he forgot, it was all right.
Frodo was here. Frodo could tell him.
They barely spoke between then and the battle.
Bilbo spent most of his time in tents with the leaders of each army, Thranduil and Bard and Dain, once he and his forces arrived en masse and in haste and were informed of what was to occur, and all the while Gandalf watched over his shoulder with bent back and staff in hand.
Thorin did not attend. He sent Balin with Bilbo instead to each of the meetings, to talk on his behalf of battle strategy and suggest plans to counteract what Bilbo predicted they’d face based on what had happened the first time.
“Two battlefronts,” Bilbo had said in a leaden voice, grimacing, “one beyond the Front Gate and one an ambush from the far side of the Mountain. We were unprepared for it last time, and that is where our dead rose.”
Nobody spoke to him of what he’d said atop the battlements other than to ask if there was anything else he remembered that could be of help, or whether they should send for aid and more armies from further abroad, or who had led what in the first battle — all of which was no small amount of daunting considering Bilbo had never planned a battle in his life, had been invisible for much of the first one, and with only occasional exceptions, preferred to stay well away from such things. Nobody mentioned that the death toll had one name already very publicly placed there — and yet, of course, it crept at his mind every single hour of the day.
Whenever Bilbo saw Thorin, he was usually traipsing back and forth up on the highest point of the battlements, alone, or with Balin or Dwalin, or his nephews, and watching the wind blow through the huddle of tents far away. He would look back sometimes at Bilbo and stand arrested, never nodding or speaking or moving otherwise, never quite making eye contact, and would look away again as if burned, with his head lowered and the curve of his jaw harsh as stone. Only once did he manage to choke out a Master Burglar in greeting, and it had not happened since.
Dain Ironfoot was very fascinated by all of these developments, of course, particularly since he had not witnessed the row upon the ramparts, and nobody had thought it appropriate to explain to him the specifics of Bilbo’s existence or how exactly it was they’d come upon the knowledge of the battle. He’d taken one look at the great carcass Bard had shot down on his arrival, surveyed it with whip-sharp, calculating eyes, then turned to his onlookers and called out, “Anyone fancy dragon for dinner?” in a wry, booming voice, clear amusement colouring his grin.
One such day, they were departing a meeting to forage the camp for some rations, a meeting in which Bilbo had mostly sat in the corner with his head in his hands and reminded the rest of them intermittently that the approaching army would not be on foot but on wargs, which were much faster and much harder to contend with. He’d made at once for the Mountain, knowing Balin and Dain were likely lingering behind to spar words with Thranduil but hoping to catch Fili or Ori in some mindless chatter to ease his twisted-up nerves. He’d only gotten a handful of paces before Gandalf entirely accosted him with the smack of his staff against the ground.
“Do you perhaps know, Bilbo, if Master Oakenshield will be joining us during the battle?” he asked pleasantly, striding up to join Bilbo as he walked, and Bilbo narrowed his eyes.
“Of course he will,” he replied irritably. And really, what a ridiculous question. Thorin had been spending all his time sourcing armour and helms and weapons within their hoard and anywhere else in the Mountain they could find them, though Bilbo could see it pained him to do it, and he had kept his distance. He may be the most stoic and solemn Bilbo had ever seen him, but for all of that, out of the clutch of the sickness, he had never been the sort of leader who would abandon his people to their fate.
If Thorin cloaked in illness had walked as a husk or a spectre, Thorin on the other side of it took every single step as if he were in mourning, marching round and round the wake and singing that sombre song that had so long ago called out to the very deepest caverns in Bilbo’s boarded-up heart.
“Then do you not think it is unwise for him to be absent at every meeting?” Gandalf prodded. “Dain is a mighty warrior and a grand strategist, but plans passed along through mouths rather than eyes and ears are seldom carried out the way they are intended.”
The wizard was eyeing him very shrewdly as he said this, hands clasped on the staff at his side, and for some reason it was this of all unlikely, inconsequential things that caused Bilbo to realise that he had quite reached the end of his tether.
”Gandalf,” he said, feeling like the frayed end of an old bit of rope, and unsure whether his hacked-up emotions were more anger or exhaustion, “what exactly is it you expect me to be able to do about that?”
“My dear fellow, whatever do you mean?”
Bilbo looked upon him for one long moment, summoning every last bit of the strength of his will not to shout, and then turned his back and marched away, fully aware that he was stomping so hard over rocks and stones his feet would likely bruise.
”You won’t get anywhere by asking me about it except sticking a finger in a wound I am already well aware of, thank you very much! He will not speak to me. He will not even look at me. I repulse him.”
”Bilbo, you fool,” Gandalf muttered snappishly, slowing, and Bilbo slowed with him unthinkingly, before remembering once more that he was incensed and speeding right up again. Gandalf, to his displeasure, followed with ease, cupping a worn pipe to his mouth and puffing out three clean-sailing smoke-rings, before pursing his lips and fixing Bilbo with a familiar earth-shaking stare. ”Do you truly think it is because you repulse him?”
Bilbo whirled his body around to face his companion and held out an accusatory finger, knowing full well that he was likely poking the beast but deciding he did not care.
”What else, Gandalf! I am naught but an omen of doom for him, on two legs and walking around, talking and laughing! Every day I must remind him of it!”
His chest was drumming up and down rapidly, and he knew his eyes must be shining something wild, overgrown thicket of hair lashing around his face in the whispering wind. He felt as if he had been unspooled, and everything that rested in his head had congealed on the floor, and there was nothing else in his mind, nothing more he could do.
Thorin would not speak, would barely eat, would hardly look at Bilbo. He stared out at the theatre of his own demise every day and surely wondered where it was he would fall, how his own blood might run. No doubt he constantly remembered that too, his sister-sons would fall, would die, and he would tear his only living family from the rest of hers, and he would never again see the Lonely Mountain as it had once been.
Bilbo could scarcely even begin to imagine with any bone in his body the wretchedness Thorin must be feeling. The searing fact of his own mortality, and a date given to him for when it would strike. A matter of days. A ticking clock. And only the desperate word of a soft little creature from the Shire for comfort, who had been keeping secrets from him every single moment they’d known one another. He didn’t begrudge Thorin his silence one bit — and not least because he was still wrangling with the fact his dwarves did not seem to care a whit at how exceedingly odd he truly was and how exceedingly thoroughly he had done them wrong.
Gandalf levelled his gaze downward, looking more clearly at Bilbo. He adjusted the grip on his staff, leaning on it more heavily, and tilted his head with a sad smile.
”Bilbo,” he said, if not softly, then without any of his characteristic flint, “you remind him of the nearness of your own death, not of his. It is not you or your actions which repulse him. It is Thorin who repulses himself.”
Bilbo stopped squarely in his tracks.
Well.
Well!
It seems I have fallen for a fellow without a brain!
After that, he’d spluttered and blubbered a whole lot of nothing, and marched away to shut himself in the dark of his borrowed tent and do some more accursed thinking, eyes darting back and forth across the scrunched-up sheets, eyeing the wall, the map, the leather book from his pack he’d taken to carrying around nonsensically that had held notes in it six months ago which knew nothing of anything at all.
Bilbo felt as if he had been smacked over the head. With a club, perhaps. Or a frying pan. Had he done, it would’ve echoed like an emptied water-drum, for all the sense he had stored in it.
What a colossally pointless excuse to be leaving yourself out of plans. What colossal idiocy. As if all of them here had been idly making arrangements for when next to have tea and not how they were going to target two separate opposing armies thousands strong who were very clearly ready to kill whomever and however they chose!
What a fool. What an absolutely preposterously stone-brained, hard-headed, illogical, unmovable fool.
From then, it was hardly any time at all before Balin was confronted with a very determined hobbit on a single-minded mission.
“He must come. We need him. He knows the Mountain like none other here living, he knows the ravens, the landscape, the entries and exits —“
“You know he won’t, laddie.”
“I couldn’t really care less, Balin.”
They stopped in synchronicity, and looked at each other, Balin’s face troubled, tired, owlish, and Bilbo’s blazing. Balin blinked. Bilbo stared him down.
He wouldn’t let up, either. Everything hung in the balance, and if they did not all get it by now he would have to drag them kicking and screaming no matter what they said about it any which way. He could not make nice-and-polite for a king who was apparently an imbecile any longer. Even one so unfortunately nestled inside of his heart.
“Very well. I’ll see what I can do.”
“Hail, King Under the Mountain.”
Thorin made no indication that he’d heard Bard at all as he entered the makeshift set-up of their battle room aside from an incremental incline of his head and the line of his jaw suddenly tightening to breaking. He did not speak.
He swept about the room, eyes roaming once over the walls and skimming across its occupants to quickly settle on the spread of lines across the table they had all circled around.
“Oh, so now he shows his face, does he?” Dain teased as Balin entered the tent behind him, grimacing as Thorin’s shoulders only stiffened, though his gaunt eyes flickered up to his cousin in acknowledgement. Gandalf clasped his hands together.
“Well, let’s not delay. What news have you to bring, Thorin Oakenshield?”
Thorin bowed his head and began to speak.
He was stiff and stilted, but he spoke quietly and offered knowledge and strategy, telling them of the gathering of tools and armour in the Mountain and promising to distribute them as soon as was possible. There was some debate about numbers and logistics, or some other such; Bilbo only watched the stillness that Thorin had set himself in and didn’t focus on much of anything else.
“Much is destroyed, or still lost in rubble and buried under gold,” Thorin said. “But we are doing all we can.”
“All of you will fight?” Bard asked, bent halfway over one of their cobbled-together diagrams with an arm outstretched. Thorin frowned slightly.
“I would not have asked my kin here if I did not believe I needed their aid.”
Bard straightened from the table and looked very intently at Thorin. “My apologies,” he said. “I only meant to ask — you, also, will fight?”
A dreadful hush spread.
The tent was very quiet. Bilbo saw instantly that Thorin took as much offence to the question as Bilbo himself had on his behalf. Even Dain was frowning now, staring at Bard with a hardened gaze.
Thorin stood to his full height, which wasn’t much of a help in this tent of Big Folk, but his shoulders rolled back and his chest drew upward; a warrior’s stance. He lifted his head fully for the first time all meeting and fixed Bard with an indecipherable look, one that was an acknowledgement and a challenge both to the Man who would question him, and there, Bilbo saw it at last; there was life in him again.
“I understand,” Thorin boomed, “that my conduct towards both your kindred and my own in recent days has been questionable, and would cause you to doubt my ability as a leader. But it will be a cold day in the grave before I abandon my people to die alone for a cause I called them to. You may think whatever you wish of me, Dragonslayer, and I urge you to place more of your trust in both Dain son of Nain and Balin son of Fundin as you already have been. But if nothing else, I ask that you trust in my ability to fight where I know I am needed.”
He lingered for a moment longer, letting the words sit heavy in the silence as all of them stood stock-still and watching him, and then he lifted the tent-flap and stormed out.
Bilbo dashed after him, shoving the fabric of the tent aside and racing to catch up before he disappeared again. Outside, a gentle sleet had begun, the fall of winter petals, like raindrops that rested on the wings of birds.
At the sound of his feet Thorin looked back at Bilbo once, and his eyes widened so slightly few others would have caught it on his face; they held each other’s gaze for several moments, Thorin’s blank and Bilbo’s ablaze now that he saw right through that silly facade of stoicism.
“You left the meeting,” Thorin said quietly.
Bilbo waved a dismissive hand and strode forward. “Of course I did. That was absolutely entirely uncalled for, and I’m sorry you had to hear it — I mean, really, what poor form from Bard!”
“They will not be forced to suffer through my presence again.”
Bilbo’s feet pattered to a stop, right there in the middle of the greyed-out camp.
“What?”
Thorin stopped as he did, though when he turned, it was only slightly, enough that Bilbo could see half of his face, and he was not quite looking over his shoulder. He didn’t speak, and so his words hung all the more in the silence. Bilbo took a step forward and spoke up for him.
“That was it?” he pressed, in disbelief. “That is as long as you are willing to stay for?”
Thorin turned away again, back towards the Mountain, and he clasped his hands behind his back, standing rigid and statuesque, as if sculpted there from the earth.
“Dain and Balin will inform me of the rest. I am not leading our armies. I do not need to regularly attend. He has brought the majority of our forces, not I.”
“On your command!” Bilbo snapped, marching his way around so he was standing in front of Thorin and the bullheaded thing could not turn away from him any longer. “And what do you suppose I am doing at the meetings, Thorin? Am I to be leading anybody’s armies?” Thorin only looked askance at him and held his silence, so Bilbo pushed on irritably. “Do you not think it would be wise to engage with the allies you will have around you in the years to come? With your kin, who know you as a king?”
At that Thorin looked as if a thousand words to say had floated through his mind, all of them causing him grave injury, but after several moments of swallowing so the jut of his throat bobbed up and down, he said only, “I would not think they would wish me there.”
Bilbo let his own face crumple up into the most withering look he could muster.
“Perhaps you spoke truth after all. You are blind.”
The muscle in Thorin’s jaw clenched so a harsh line struck itself across his face, but he did not speak. There they stood, opposite one another, Bilbo’s heart jumping out of his sternum, out of his ribcage and into the open air; drumming, drumming, drumming.
Bilbo had had far, far too much of silences and skirting looks and tip-toeing about for the sake of what amounted to absolutely nothing at all. He was going to make this ridiculous dwarf talk to him if he had to stick a hand down his throat and fish out the words himself.
He planted both of his hands on his hips and opened his mouth.
“Look, Master Oakenshield, I don’t care one iota if you aren’t leading anybody from the Iron Hills, and if I may hazard a guess, neither does anyone else. You still have a Company, and they will follow you above all others, and you know it.”
There were several moments of pause. Then: “I thank you for your words, Master Baggins. I will… think on them.”
And, of all things, Thorin turned his back on Bilbo, and made to walk away, and Bilbo very abruptly and with all the pent-up frustration of a bonfire decided he’d had quite enough of that.
He lunged out at once and clapped a hand down hard against Thorin’s leather-clad forearm, grabbing a firm hold and hauling with all the strength he could dredge up, digging his heels into the ground until this aggravating, infernal, vexatious dwarf was forced to cease his march out of the camp and turn back around.
He turned his head, first eyeing the hand on his bracer and then the face of the hobbit attached to it, and that expressionlessness, those eyes like a tomb — that was what curdled Bilbo’s insides more than anything. Thorin refused to feel. He refused to let down his guard, to push his emotions outward, but they were in him somewhere, those cavernous spaces smothered by his self-pity and righteous loathing. They were not gone. Bilbo would simply have to irritate them out.
“What can you possibly think it is you are going to achieve by pretending we are no longer friends, like we don’t hardly know each other from every Tom and Dick in Dale! Confusticating dwarf, skulking around like a kicked puppy with your great shaggy head, tail between your legs!”
Thorin’s eyes flashed wide, and he stared at Bilbo as if he’d grown feet out his ears, but solemn as he was he did not speak. Wild, untempered anger flared inside Bilbo, spiralling red and up and outwards, and he tugged hard on Thorin’s arm again, gritting his teeth and likely pushing his jaw out entirely unattractively, but it wasn’t to be helped.
“Well? Out with it!” Bilbo demanded.
Black irritation flashed across Thorin’s face in one single bolt before it smoothed, and the clay-cracks were back in place, and in his utter lack of expression and the mournful greyness painted all over him Bilbo could see plain as day the hatred he had been turning back on himself simmering underneath.
Oh, that look. Bilbo couldn’t stand it one bit. Thorin looked a clam that had closed up, a flower that had sealed and shrivelled its petals instead of opening them out. The shutters had closed, the embers had died. What little life had been lit within him was gone as if it had never been. He looked just like Bilbo had felt when he’d first set his foot over the threshold of Bag End again that very first time after thirteen months away, a mirrored match of what remained of his house; ransacked and pilfered, the insides gutted and torn down to their bare bones.
All that, Bilbo thought. All that, and still you have been made dead to me anyway.
At long last, Thorin brought his steely eyes to Bilbo’s, and when he spoke, his voice was hoarse, as if the sides of his throat had rusted in the speckled rain.
“I would not harm you further, Master Burglar. I will not harm you again.”
So endlessly, unnecessarily noble. He was every bit of him still a king, and it made Bilbo want to hit him in the chest.
“And that is all good and well,” he said, letting every bit of his well-practiced snobbishness leak in until he sounded stern as an old ox, “but it is a far cry from acting as if we have never met and never spoken!”
Thorin had so far stood frozen, watching Bilbo with that sickening nothing drenching him all over, but now he began to pace, hands clasped once more and his boots crunching across the chipped rock beneath them. He seemed — agitated. Not quite so caring as to be agitated, maybe, but certainly something was beginning to build.
Come on, Thorin. You are in there, love. You are so close to the surface.
“It was not my intention to anger you,” Thorin said, no longer looking at Bilbo, not even in Bilbo’s direction, eyes cast instead down somewhere between the lip of the nearest tent and the shoal lining the ground. “It is that I do not wish to force my presence upon you. If that… displeases you, I am truly sorry.”
Right. Bilbo was now properly peeved.
“You listen here, you great stubborn thing. You died.” Bilbo’s lip trembled, and he bit down on the inside of his cheek, stilling it, narrowing his eyes at the maddening creature before him, who clearly would not let a single word he’d said filter into his great stubborn head. “You spoke your words of farewell to me, and you left the world. And I went home.”
“I wish you would stop saying that,” Thorin muttered.
“And I wish you would listen!” He threw his hands out to the side, aware that he was beginning to splutter, but there was nothing else for it. “What is going to convince you? Hm? You are so despondent about all this, about something I frankly could not care less about, and yet you have not even said a simple ‘forgive me’. That seems a good place to start, don’t you think?”
There was a tension-line running right from Thorin’s chin to the cleft beneath his ear when he replied, ”I would not ask you to do something I cannot do myself.”
Oh, for —
”Oh, you bebothering oaf, you aren’t listening! Listen to my words, and not what you have convinced yourself it is I am saying in your head!”
When Thorin finally looked back at him, he was struck with a wild glare from Bilbo. It served him right. Bilbo wrought every ounce of his scathing temper into it, sure that he would scorch the ground anew and wondering if that of all things might get through to this blind buffoon.
“I understand why you would push me away, Thorin, I do. I know the reason I was gifted the chance to come back here again, and it is because my mind was hurt by something too. I became consumed by it, just like your Arkenstone.”
“Please do not mention it by name.”
Bilbo sighed. “The gold, then. You don’t think I am flawed? That all of us are flawed? We are not so different, Thorin. You have no idea how mirrored our stories have been.”
Thorin’s face had darkened, and he was not looking at Bilbo but out at the Long Lake, and Mirkwood beyond, his gaze so very far away.
“It is impossible,” he murmured. An echo of the ramparts; so different, now. He looked back.
“Master Baggins.” Master Baggins, my hat. Where are you, Thorin? Where are you in there? “I am grateful for what you wish to do for me. You show me allegiance and loyalty even still, when I deserve none from you, when I should be grovelling at your feet for all the honour you have shown the world that I have not. But I am alone in what my people’s gold has done to me.”
“You are not listening to me —”
“And you are not listening to me!”
Their shoulders heaved in tandem, eyes wide; Thorin looked so very haunted, what Bilbo could only imagine a person already buried would look like had he not seen it for himself and known this was the opposite.
This was the spark. He must blow on the tinder.
“How can you expect me to even look you in the eye?” Thorin demanded, and he could not be drawn away from Bilbo now that they were here; no self-hatred in all the world could do it. “How can you think I would trust myself in your presence, that you would trust me to be close to you when I have laid hands on you, laid my blade against you!”
“And have you forgotten what it is I’ve done?” Bilbo snapped right back. “For the answer is all of this before. I’ve betrayed you, and I have watched you betray me, and I have forgiven you, long, long, ago. And still I came back here to save you all. Think about that in your incessant brooding, if you will, Master Oakenshield.”
Thorin was silent. Bilbo calmed his breathing, closing his eyes for a moment.
“I told you of my nephew.”
“Frodo Baggins,” the murmur came.
“The very same. Well, you should know also that I hurt him. I hurt him very badly, and it is my burden to bear. So if there is anyone at all who most knows that you would not hurt those you wish to protect without a reason, it is me.”
Bilbo sucked in a breath. He could not speak any plainer. He had no other way of getting anything at all through that thick-set head but with his words. It was what he had taught himself in. It was all he had to wield.
Bilbo began to pace, himself, up and down, eyes skittering wildly about the oatmeal-beige tents, the charcoal-grey ground. He had half a mind to stick his fingers in his hair and pull at the ends in frustration.
“I cannot understand why it is you do not all hate me, and you most of all,” he said, still pacing, not looking at Thorin once. “I delivered you to death in the most brutal way possible. I delivered it to your loved ones. Better that you threaten me with empty actions and have the excuse of not being in your right mind than having all of your wits and still shouting aloud what I shouted for all the Mountain to hear.”
“Empty actions, you call them.” Thorin laughed hollowly. “I almost had you killed.”
Bilbo rolled his eyes. “Do you think I give a single fig about that? I don’t care —“
“You should care!” Thorin roared, whirling on Bilbo, hair flying about his face like the vines of a forest, the great strings of a spider’s web. And it was bizarre, and he knew himself bizarre for it, but somehow in that very moment Bilbo found himself having to gulp down his smile.
At last, something had ignited him, and he was Thorin once more.
“I could not have cared less what you said to me upon the battlements, Master Baggins. I am not young anymore. I do not care that it is me. I owe you many debts I can never repay, the latest of which being that you do not curse my name to my face and spit at my feet, though you would have every right. But I wondered… why it was you looked at me with such weight. For so long, I — And now I know. You knew what was coming, what I would do —”
He swallowed, eyes wide and unseeing in the distance, and one hand was closing and unclosing, as if he could not even fathom what it was he was thinking. “You have told me I died in selfishness, in greed, coveting what should never have been mine. Lost. And you tell me Fili and Kili — and after what I have done to you — what I —“ He shook his head, and his great mane of hair moved with it. Bilbo’s eyes could not help but follow the beads in each braid. “I am undone.”
Enough of this.
Bilbo launched forwards with a suddenness that surprised even him to grip Thorin’s hand and wrench it back until it pressed flat against his own chest, then stretched an arm out and did the same, so that all at once his thieving hand lay over the place where Thorin’s heart would be.
There they stood, locked together, as if snow and sunlight too had frozen them there and they could move no longer, Bilbo holding one hand to Thorin’s sturdy chest and using the other to keep Thorin’s fingers nestled against his own. Thorin looked up, and there, their eyes met.
“Do you feel that?”
Their chests rose and fell in unison, Bilbo’s heartbeat surely fluttering all over the place as it always did, Thorin’s steady, steady as the roots of trees, of mountains and gulleys. Thump. Thump. Thump.
He adjusted his fingers over the left side of Thorin’s chest, brushing the rough fabric and feeling it crush beneath his hand. Bilbo smiled wearily. It was the furthest cry possible from the midnight velvet of the royal cloak he’d favoured in the Mountain. And it was Thorin.
“I am alive, Master Oakenshield,” Bilbo said, softer than he’d meant to. “You torture yourself over something that has not come to pass.”
Then, suddenly, there was a hitch of breath that was not Bilbo’s, deep and quiet and deafening nonetheless, sharp as a sword in the blunt silence. Bilbo’s nerves flared, ridiculously, and then all at once he noticed the trajectory of Thorin’s eyes like the bolt of an arrow, and he reddened so quickly it was as if he’d quite fallen into a fireplace.
Oh, dear.
Somehow — oh, dear! — his collar was open, frayed down the parting with the wear and tear of rough travel, and there in the telling gap shone the mithril mail, the prize of kings and princes. Bilbo looked down at it with very wide eyes, and then back up to Thorin mirroring him exactly, gulping down a shaky breath.
They watched each other; Bilbo could do nothing else, and was adamant someone was going to have to slice them apart with some sort of weapon because they were both surely stuck here now, not doing anything, crystal-pressed in the midst of one moment and the next.
Thorin swallowed heavily.
“It is not only me who has tortured himself,” he said in a low voice.
Bilbo stepped backward at once, letting both of his hands drop from Thorin, losing their warmth, and pulling his treacherous collar up angrily so the pearl and diamond that gleamed beneath could no longer see the light of day.
”Quite right, and I’ll thank you to keep your snooping nose out of it, Thorin Oakenshield.”
Bilbo held out a finger in accusation, and it was shaking, so great then was his rage. The sheer impropriety of it. The nerve he had. As if — as if —
But Thorin beat him to it.
“You tell me you understand me, you say you have felt what I feel when I look within the halls of my fathers, and yet you will not allow any other comparison for fear I might bring your hurts to light.” Thorin was staring very intently at him, dark eyes wide. “So what is it you want from me?”
“I want you,” Bilbo said, voice trembling, “to care about saving yourself in the battle you know is coming. I want it to matter that other people care. And I want you, as I have told you, you incessantly rock-headed dwarf, to stop insisting that you know better than I do with regards to my own actions. I know what I am doing.”
There was silence for a moment, hanging as whispers in the air. Thorin’s head was bowed.
“Will you not also take your own advice?”
Bilbo scoffed in disbelief. “Oh, if you only knew how many manners you’re ignoring, Thorin, I would —”
“The news you think you destroyed us with,” Thorin said over him, though it was just as low, just as quiet. “It does not matter. Not any further than knowing I must guard my sister-sons with my life now more than ever. You speaking it aloud does not mean you struck the blow, Master Baggins.”
My blood is not on your hands.
Bilbo didn’t know if he could believe it, just yet. He drew his eyes from Thorin’s face to his temple, to his chest, and they breathed, breathed.
“Then surely a blow unstruck is not a blow at all,” he whispered. Thorin’s face twisted in a self-inflicted scowl.
“Had it fallen, it would have landed.”
“Had the person letting it fall had any faith whatsoever in the people he associated himself with, he would know we are not all so stupid as to stand by and let ourselves be cut in half with swords.”
Thorin’s spine straightened, and he turned his back, standing there for a long while, clouded in a storm of his own making.
“That may be so, Master Baggins, but I still held the blade.”
Bilbo let his jaw work, hot with embarrassment that his agitation could so clearly be seen in every inch of his body but carrying on nonetheless.
“You do not get to tell me I am tortured and parade yourself around your Mountain as if you have had your wings clipped,” he retaliated, as fiercely as he could fathom. “You cannot shun me against my will and my words to you and then act as if it is me who has done the shunning.”
He took one single step closer, raising his chin so they were as eye-to-eye as they could be. Thorin’s head was ever-bowed, and his eyes were so very vivid, sapphire-stones and forget-me-nots, and Bilbo breathed out, ”You must trust me. You must, Thorin. You have this far, haven’t you?”
He waited with held breath, as if his breath had caught and all the world caught with it, latched upon a hook and awaiting an unknown verdict. But after some time, it was clear that Thorin did not have a response to what Bilbo had asked of him, just as he hadn’t the last time they’d spoken. Bilbo supposed he couldn’t blame him.
Bilbo nodded bluntly, once, and turned to go.
(Back to Gandalf, or to Balin and Dain, he wasn’t sure. As it was he was trying very hard not to think of himself as running with his tail between his legs.)
And then, again, Thorin surprised him.
”Master Baggins.”
Of course, Bilbo knew far too well by now that a seemingly-ended sentence from Thorin Oakenshield only meant the beginning of a question, so he let himself hum in reply, and he waited.
“Did I give it to you? In your life before?”
Bilbo turned.
Thorin’s eyes had not lowered from his face, and his jaw was tighter than ever, but it was immediately clear what he’d meant, and Bilbo did rather well, in his own opinion, to keep the pinking from his cheeks. He brought an absent hand up to rub at the gap in his shirt at the neckline, the cool silver of the mithril meeting the tips of his fingers smooth as water.
”Yes, Master Oakenshield,” he said, swallowing, “and it saved me and mine.”
The days went on as they waited and prepared and planned, and the sky darkened, and an ominous feeling crept over all the Mountain. The inevitable battle was coming closer, and all of them could feel it. Scouts from Mirkwood had ridden back to Dale in a frightening hurry declaring that they’d sighted a horde of orc armies days before, that they would likely have made quick time behind them and would soon make their approach.
But in amongst all of their talks and distribution of supplies and battle tactics there was one last thing on Bilbo’s mind, one last loose thread, and he knew it could not wait any longer. He made his excuses to the Company, one late afternoon, telling them there was something small he needed to do, that shouldn’t take too long at all. Not a few of them had seemed quite worried, and Bofur had blinked wide-eyed at him, rather reluctant all of a sudden.
”You’re not going off to hide somewhere and fight them alone, are you?” he’d asked.
Bilbo laughed fondly and shook his head. ”You ridiculous things! I’ll be back in a tick, don’t worry yourselves. I only need a moment alone.”
He needed to say goodbye.
He stashed the necessities in a satchel and departed from the Mountain, wandering for a while, until there was no noise at all and he was far away from any armies and tents and living souls. There was a little outcropping of rock at the base of one of the Mountain’s outstretched arms, with a little nook carved into the edge of it, presumably by the wind. Bilbo gently sank to the ground in front of it and crossed his legs.
He wished desperately and painfully that there were any flowers nearby, even some sort of measly daffodil or chrysanthemum if it could be spared, but the scarred land stretched so far that it hurt Bilbo to look upon it for too long, knowing that nothing had grown here since the dwarves had lost their home. When they all survived this, he decided, he would scrounge around for books wherever he could possibly manage it, and he would research which plant life would best survive the terrain of northern rock and wind. He already had a few flowers in mind.
And there would be snapdragons galore.
Bilbo had even asked Gandalf softly if he was able to conjure up flowers at all, if that was how wizardry worked; he wasn’t entirely sure. Gandalf had seemed a mix of oddly pitying and nettled by the request, and told him that it was much more in Radagast the Brown’s line of work.
Bilbo took the book bound in its red leather out of the little brown satchel slung across his hip and propped it open on the ground so he could gently tear one, then two pages out of it. One by one, tucking the other under his knee so it wouldn’t blow away in the bitter wind, he very delicately folded each page bit by bit until they resembled petals with a twisted stem underneath. Paper-flowers, a favourite of his mother’s, because she’d always known how much he missed seeing the blossoms when the ground froze over in the colder months. Bilbo thought wistfully that it would have been better if they’d held any colour, but then, the paper-flowers matched the palette of the landscape around them, white winter snow and grey swirling clouds and the dull blue of the Lonely Mountain at his side.
He gently placed the two flowers against the granite, tucking them into the soft curve in the rock so they lay out of the wind and rested peacefully against each other. Then, he drew out from the satchel a sliver of graphite, opened the cover of the book once more, and leant over to scrawl inside it carefully.
The Downfall of the Lord of the Rings and the Return of the King
He sat back, admiring the unassuming words for a moment longer, and then neatly tore another two pages out of his lovely notebook — one was the very first page of the book, lying adjacent to his little label, and the other the very last. He held them up to the daytime, so the sunlight filtered through, and then set them alight using the embers of his pipe, letting them slowly crumble away into ash until there was nothing for him to hold onto at all.
Now the story would have no beginning and no end. It could just be.
Bilbo knew in his heart that he still thought it should have been Frodo instead of him who got to do his life over, who got his chance at happiness instead of having to bear the weight of all of Middle-Earth on his shoulders. He knew he would until the day he died. But he did not resent himself for it, and he knew that this was the way the moon and stars and the powers-that-be had chosen, and so he would question it no longer.
Frodo's heart would go to him, one day. Sam had borne the Ring, and he would cross the shores of Middle-Earth to the lands that lay beyond. Frodo did not belong in the Shire anymore, and the pain he had suffered needed to heal, and friends of both Bilbo and Frodo’s were taking him to the place where he would be safest to do so.
Bilbo's pain was borne from things that had been taken from him, from a life of knowing the chance he might have had if things had gone but slightly differently. Half of his heart had been laid to rest, to sleep with gems and ancient blades of the North under miles of mountain-stone, and now the moment had come at last when he could reverse it.
“My Frodo-lad,” he said gently, for it was always out loud when he spoke to Frodo, and uttered in his head like a secret when he spoke to Thorin. “I hope you know that if I could have, I would have borne it all in your place.” He closed his eyes, and his voice was shaking, but he let it. “In… in our next lifetime, then, dear boy.”
It was too much to bear, suddenly, to speak it aloud, to whisper to Frodo when he was no longer there and Bilbo didn’t know if the wind could carry his words so far. He bent his head, and brushed the petals of the flowers with his numbed fingertips.
I am sorry I took your life from you, Frodo. I hope you can still allow me mine.
There was a beautiful view of the lake from the little rock outcrop when he turned, the water like a porcelain mirror and glittering in the pale wintry light, the faraway wooden houses just barely visible in the distance. Behind him, the two little flowers were nestled in their crevice together, one leaning gently against the other.
Bilbo left the book there beside them. He could have taken it with him back into the Mountain, tucked it safely away, but somehow, he didn’t want to take it from Frodo. He could do nothing else but believe that they would all make it through the day through sheer determination, and there would be no more mourning, not for a long time, but if they did not, or he did not, he wanted to be laid to rest with Frodo.
Sleep a while, my boy. I’ll see you sometime or other.
When he turned his face upwards, Bilbo could see small flakes of ash still floating high in the air and away on the wind, making their way slowly west.
Then at last, all at once, it was upon them.
Bilbo’s meticulous worrying over and puzzling out how long it had taken the goblins to reach them in the past, how likely it was this timing had changed, and how accurate his memories of the exact date were after almost a century between them — and other such unnecessarily stressful matters — had come to good after all; they had been more or less accurate, at the very least, and the lookouts had sounded the alarm that the goblins and their wargs were closing in.
They’d rallied at once: each encampment had split off into their own sectors and begun organising in earnest, dividing up the hardiest of their shieldfolk, making preparations to hold the front line, calling out commands and speaking in hurried voices. Each of the dwarves of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield seemed to have their own rites and rituals as they readied themselves, and Bilbo found it rather fascinating. He’d seen them fight before, of course, in their skirmishes along the journey as well as great battles long past, but still he watched as they linked together and piled on the gold-and-iron-plated armour, sharpened weapons, rebraided their hair.
Bilbo himself did not have much readying to do, thankfully. A sword on his belt, mithril under his collar, helm in his hands, and he was set.
And then all of a sudden the fourteen of them were stood together atop the battlements in the mouth of the Mountain and facing each other, all adorned in chestplates and roughened mail, and Bilbo looked each of them in the eyes, one by one; Dwalin, then Fili, then Kili, Ori, Dori, Bombur, Bofur, Nori, Balin, Oin, Gloin, Bifur, and then Thorin directly opposite him in the very centre. Every single one of them bore identical expressions of determination, the fierce glint of anticipation and morbid acceptance of their own mortality in the set of their jaws and eyes, the clang of swords already ringing in the distance in the way they each looked at him.
He’d given his luck to Fili and Kili already, pulled them aside and apologised one last time for having to tell them what he had told them, and hugged them close in an entirely uncomely show of his affection. He did not know what he would do if this was the last time they saw each other. He’d let himself trust devotedly and wholeheartedly in his second chance the entire way through the quest, and he hoped with everything in him that it was not going to fail him now. He did not know if he could pick himself up again.
But if all went well, he would not have to.
Bilbo whistled out a low breath, and opened his mouth.
“Don’t any of you dare die on me,” he said very stubbornly. And there was no laugh, but it pulled grim smiles from each of their faces as they nodded back at him.
“Aye, we wouldn’t dare,” said Gloin and hear-hears rang round as well as a “Count on it, Bilbo!” from Bombur, all of their spines straightening at the call and kindling the fire in their eyes.
But Bilbo’s eyes were trained on Thorin, and he did not move them once, and Thorin did not look away. His eyes were grimly set, white-blue and icy against the skyline sapped of all colour in the bitter winter. They breathed as one; his chest rose as Thorin’s did, and Thorin’s fell when he exhaled.
Bilbo thought of the last words they’d exchanged in their colossal argument, scarcely a handful of days before, in the last moment before they had parted. Thorin watched him now, his eyes heavy, steady, unmoving. He stood tall and proud, no crown, no helm, the irresponsible, vociferous thing — Bilbo would have to try and rectify that, if there was any time. The threads drawn between them had twined their way around his own arms, and Bilbo could feel them more keenly than ever. He could almost see them looped around Thorin’s fingers like they were rings.
“You keep what I said in mind, alright?” Bilbo said simply. Thorin said nothing, but there was the slightest incline of his head in a bow, and the threads remained. Bilbo exhaled.
I cannot watch you fall again.
He had only trust, now. Trust and the quickness of his own hands.
The dwarves all raised their weapons to the sky, and even with such darkness approaching, every minute that they lingered, and with the very second chance he’d come back for balancing on a knife-point in front of him, it was true at that very moment that there was not one other place in the world Bilbo would rather have been.
“Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!”
Drums.
Drums.
Drums, but not in the deep, in the open, approaching ever closer like a raging tide, a black wave out of the underworld, out of the Void beyond the very farthest stars into deepest, deepest Night.
Was this what the Númenóreans had seen? Was this what they’d looked on in the Dagorlad?
Bilbo was getting ahead of himself, he knew. But all the same, it was the battle he had hated most, and the one he was proudest of, and the one he recalled the most sadly and the most fondly, so he grit his teeth quite firmly and set about mustering up every last bit of stubborn old courage he had in the body that had carried him there and back again. He scrunched up his nose, and breathed out harshly through his mouth.
Just one more time, old lad. Just one more time.
He was with Sting, and his mithril, and his Company, and Frodo resting atop the mountainside, watching over him.
There was no dwarven army to meet on the battlefield, of course; the fleet of warriors from the Iron Hills had been well prepared from their arrival days before, the time Bilbo had bought them by stealing the Arkenstone earlier making a remarkable difference. There was nothing to do but watch and wait, and hear the wild screams come ever closer. In the distance, the cap of the Mountain seemed tipped blood-red against the darkening sky.
And then a sea of churning bodies split the horizon. The battle-horns sounded.
The goblins were upon them.
So began the clang and clash, the scream of metal against flesh and bone, the slashing sounds of blood-hungry wargs and wicked goblins echoing terribly over the vast wasteland. The smell of blood was thick-red and cloying and stained the air like rust.
Bilbo did not fight directly if he could help it. He wouldn’t delude himself into thinking he could take on dozens of orcs twice his height, not even now he was halfway decent at throwing blades and with his trusty Elven letter-opener, and he didn’t much want to deal out such death, anyhow. Instead, he darted around and acted as the perpetual thorn in their side, light on his feet, ducking and weaving to slice at ankles or furry hides and buy their armies time. He shouted in warning to Elves and Men and dwarves, and he guided each of his friends away from gravest danger where he could, shouting at them in a shrill little voice to please use some of that common sense, for the love of all things, or so help me I will knock you out and drag you away myself!
It was carnage. Utter carnage. Black blood spattered the ground.
In the lead-up to battle, Bilbo had spent hours thinking, thinking, thinking, worrying his lip and wondering if intervening in a single one of his friends’ movements during the fight would mean the difference between life and death. What if he hindered an opponent of Dwalin’s and left another a clear opening? What if he swung for an orc attacking Ori or Dori and missed?
He held Sting with both hands like a flame, and reminded himself over and over that they had more back-up, they were more prepared, they were ready; and yet Thorin was in the battle already, and neither he nor any of the others would stay back the way Bilbo had suggested to, and at any moment one of them could be struck down, and that would be it, and it would be the end.
But in the thick of things, it all fell by the wayside. He simply fought, as he had done, as he had known he would do. He would join them in one last great victory.
The thunder crashed on and on, and darkness seemed to creep into every corner of the land, and the goblins’ numbers were never-ending, their screwed-up faces pulled back in awful grins as they prowled the battlefield. Their forces met in waves, clashing, spraying, receding, moving forward once more; gore spilt across the ground, lines of men and orcs fell, and their armies carved one another up. The very air around them seemed almost hungry for death, still and stagnant in the deep bone-cold of terror.
At one moment, Bilbo had been forced to the outskirts by the tide, and he was dashing a path along the crumbling walkways of Dale, looking for a vantage point to assess the goings-on as well as he could manage in the current state of things. He’d no idea how much time had passed, but the hilt of his Sting was slick with filth; he wiped it and the hand holding it against the material of his trousers and fought back a grimace.
He would likely have to burn these clothes. Unfortunate. But no matter.
He ran almost headlong into Gandalf the Grey striding his way up the cobblestone, who stopped in his tracks to stare down at him with wild eyes.
”I believe you have somewhere you’re supposed to be, Bilbo!” he exclaimed, quite flabbergasted. Bilbo frowned and grit his teeth together.
”You don’t need to tell me twice!” he called darkly, eyes darting about to each of the exits from the city and the glimpses of the rest of the battlefield he could see from afar.
Where should he make for? Head to Ravenhill, or enter the fray again and hope somehow he’d find the clothead he was here for? He could linger closer to Dain, to Dwalin, to Bofur and Bombur, but there was no guarantee at all that would yield any better results.
Orcs were infiltrating the ruins and running at them with their teeth bared; Bilbo ducked abruptly as a mace swung, missed, and slammed into an enemy behind him with a crunch that had him feeling quite entirely sick, and then shoved it down in annoyance. Oh, pick yourself up by your bootstraps, or whatever the silly saying is.
Gandalf swept a smooth hand out to his side and felled another half-dozen orcs slinking their way forwards. His hat was gone, and he looked tired, and Bilbo remembered with a pang that he had danced a battle with the Necromancer only very recently.
His weary friend. They’d have a pipe, after all this was done. Gandalf the Grey had those in Middle-Earth who watched over him, too.
“Well, if you are looking for them, I am sure I saw them last on the western border, my dear fellow. They are sticking fast to your demands, I imagine. And so they should,” he twinkled downward.
Bilbo pushed a sigh out his tightened mouth, forcing the hair back from his face in a grunt. “Now there is just the figuring out of how to get there,” he said, to himself; for Gandalf was already gone.
In his haste to locate Thorin, the second force took Bilbo almost entirely by surprise; he’d quite lost track of all time, and the writhing wave crested the western side of the Lonely Mountain in an avalanche.
This was the moment, then, if all went to plan. The turning of the tide. Dain’s bellow echoed over the swooping sea of their clustered armies, ricocheting up and off the mountainside and booming out in a sound that rang loud as any battle-horn. The Ironfoot was well and truly come.
Bilbo had clambered his way up near to the crown of Ravenhill to confirm Gandalf’s words; as best as he could, anyhow. His eyes were far keener in daylight, and beside that red tuft of hair leading the charge he saw a white head, a bald head, a gold-and-dark pair.
But the midnight tide. He couldn’t see. His eyes flicked around frantically; he could not see it at all.
There were hundreds of dwarves, and Men, and Elves — even a very distinctive bear, now, if Bilbo’s eyes were serving — and he was being utterly ridiculous in expecting himself to identify each and every one of them by a pinprick of the backs of their heads, beneath helms and war-braids.
But somehow he could feel the threads around him, pulled taut, stretching, stretching outward, far afield. The moment was coming, hurtling toward them.
He would not let them fray. Not as long as he drew breath in this twice-lived world.
All he had to do was find Thorin. Fili and Kili were protected, for now, and Bilbo knew he would only find them either amongst the Company or at their mother’s brother’s side til the very end, for they had fallen defending him to the last breath.
And yet the battlefield was endless. Everywhere were bodies strewn across the barren lands beneath the shadow of the Mountain, bent at odd angles and eyes closed in sleep everlasting. The masses of orcs and Elves and Men were churning as angry fish in a sea, as a wild pack of animals, the mouth of a raging river. The ground had cracked open. Warg-feet pounded the dirt, lashing the scarred earth, and horses stamped, and everywhere flew hammers and scythes and arrows with poison-darts.
Bilbo grew more and more frustrated as he hunted around for an avenue. Surely it was impossible. Memory of this battle had served, yes, but clearly it had not served enough; he had no way at all of entering the thicket and making it out the other side. What had happened? This battle was devastating, it was the harshest of awakenings, but it had still been won, he had still fought just as hard the last —
Bilbo’s stomach sank into the floor.
He knew, then. What the difference had been.
He felt at his pocket with trembling fingers. The weight of it bore down on him, even now, a world away. Even such a little ring.
He’d had its help, hadn’t he? The last time. It had gotten him away with his life.
And he would never make it across in time if he did not. He would never be able to find Thorin before the killing blow had been struck.
Bilbo undid the button with one hand, looked down, saw the dull gold nestled there, so very unassuming. His fingers paused before they could touch it. He closed his eyes tightly, and drew in a breath.
It will be my burden to bear. Just one last time.
He slipped the Ring on.
The world lurched.
It was like being plunged into a vat of boiling water, and sinking down, down, until the sky above was nearly black and the sun had faded out of sight until utter doom had come.
He was buried in the reedy, murky, mud-slick shallows of a great river ages past, and he was alone and cold on black rock that bit at his back in the depths of the cavern beneath the mountains, and he was tucked into a pocket and shut away in a drawer and carried through all the world to the very end and cast down into eternal fire.
The force of it knocked him back, and it was only when he blinked the battlefield back into focus that Bilbo realised his vision had gone white. He gasped for breath, shuddering, clutching at his throat, his lungs burning dry and red-raw.
He waited until it settled, hoping and pleading and half-out of his mind with fear that it wouldn’t settle, that he’d be dragged down below the surface once more, in one last, most terrible end. But in time, the feeling mellowed, and Bilbo felt himself return to his body, and the cool band of metal against his skin. He spun it once with his thumb so the inscription was facing inward, looking down at it through the grey mist it cast with hard eyes.
Bilbo knew that he had been the only Ringbearer who had ever relinquished Isildur’s Bane of his own choosing. He would not walk back on his promise.
It was not his anymore. He didn’t have to bow to it. He did not have to bend to its will ever again.
He raced off, ducking and weaving, sprinting across the moors in the most open paths he could find, heaving back too-short breaths of equal panic and exhaustion. He ran all the way to where he’d spied the Company, on the western border just as Gandalf had said, and neatly stung with his sword the hide of a silver-black warg that screamed and thrashed in agony to the ruin of its master.
”Dwalin! Where is Thorin!” he cried, coming to a stop and doubling over, embarrassingly heaving in air as if he had nearly drowned. He was dearly glad nobody could see him, at the minute.
”Covering our flank last I saw, but he got separated!” Dwalin roared, spinning his axes as if they were no lighter than air, as if he were a sculptor in the throes of a masterpiece. Orcs fell at his command, and he fought as if effortless, with that signature steel-sharp look on his face. His eyes flashed downward, noticing nothing but air, and his brows creased in the middle. “Where — ?”
”Do you know which way he went?” Bilbo pressed loudly, hopping swiftly out of the way so Dwalin could cleave a warg and goblin-rider apart from one another; the warg fell to the side, and the weedy orc dashed off in a fright before he could do any further damage.
Dwalin’s head spun from side to side in search of Bilbo, but he could not afford to focus on his confusion and knew it, and he took a moment to catch his breath, eyeing very seriously the new oncoming surge and looking back to Dain calling his commands ahead.
”He’d be on the outskirts, or forced to the back!” he yelled to the air. Bilbo was gone before another word had come from his mouth.
He ran, ran, ran, panting something absolutely unbelievable, forcing himself onward, ducking and weaving and dodging and swinging. He reached the flanks of their forces and crested a small hill, the churned-up earth utterly stampeded and flecked with blackening blood.
And there at last, all at once, he could see it.
Thorin, Orcrist at his side, his hair pulled back and his clothes filthy with grime, wiping the sweat from his brow and searching for the others with fierce eyes. Behind him, alone on the moors, separated as they were from the swelling mass of five armies, a creature lurking closer, its eyes half-bulging in their sockets and the devilish grin it wore cold as ice.
Bolg, Bilbo thought his name was. He remembered him from the battle before. He’d forgotten how utterly bone-chilling he was.
Thorin had begun to run, noticing his isolation from the rest of their forces and realising its danger at once, and the orc followed, picking up his speed, prowling across the desolation with a gnarled smile on his face.
Bolg was clever; Thorin had not seen him, the battle-blood surely pounding in his ears. The orc drew a weapon, slick and stealthy, the metal battered, matching the contraptions on his head and torso. He was closing the gap between them, and had even begun to laugh as he neared, a low, hungry noise that slid like stinking oil from his mouth. Thorin heard, and began to turn, but it was rapidly becoming clear that it was not in time; Bolg was too close, and already bore a weapon and a terrible smile.
Bilbo came to a stop. And he thought.
He thought of Thorin before, cold as glass, hair like a halo, untouchable, unreachable for ever more, a hollow space where there should have been a heart. What do I do now? What do I do now? Red poppies like dark blood on ice, eternal sleep, the empty space beside him, at his table, under the tree with the acorns in his garden, King Under the Mountain below the earth with a white stone upon his chest.
He thought of every moment in this lifetime and the last, Thorin’s hair between his fingers, his pulse thudding, skin warm, warm, warm, his hoarse voice, his quiet ache, the way he said Bilbo’s name, the way he looked at him over and over, snapdragons for his favourite flower and his eyes gleaming blue. You’ve never let any of us forget it, have you, Bilbo? I have never met anyone like you in all my life.
Bilbo closed his eyes, opened them. He slid his trembling fingers around the cool handle of the flyblade in his trouser-pocket, drew it out, measured the bearings of his wrist like he had done every day for months, just like Nori and the others had taught him. He watched the goblin loom, watched Thorin fail to counter a blow in time. Watched him start to fall.
If more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merrier place.
He let the knife fly.
Thorin cried out, a roar of anguish, and Bilbo’s heart was frozen solid in his chest, a thin film over a gushing, rushing stream, a waterfall, that was bursting, bursting —
The orc stumbled, reached a confused hand up to feel for the blade embedded in the very centre of his temple; it took his fingers a couple of attempts to reach their mark. He turned to the side groggily to fix a menacing growl on whatever culprit had dared to strike him, with his teeth like slashes, the green-red pits of his eyes.
But of course, there was nobody there.
Bilbo drew again, threw again. His aim was worse, the second time, but it struck true nevertheless, below Bolg’s collarbone, and he staggered backward, roaring out a scream that curdled the blood so completely it almost sent Bilbo to his knees right there in the blood-soaked dirt.
(Even then, however, Bilbo could not help but pity him, this Bolg fellow. And he could not help but detest the fact it was his hand causing this pain.)
He could not see Bilbo, but he’d discovered the trajectory of the knives, now, and his face screwed up in a foul hatred, snarling, the grunts misting from his nostrils in the cold. He took one step, and another, teeth bared for a roar, that metal-sheathed arm lifting, poised for attack —
Bilbo deftly flicked his third knife just as one last bellow sounded out behind him, cleaving the air over the din of the battle, and the sound was so mighty there was only one possible answer to where it had come from.
The blade struck him dead-centre in his pasty forehead, and had Bilbo not been so simultaneously weary and wound-up in a panic he would have cried aloud; Bolg made a horrific gurgling noise, stumbled, and then his head with its great blasted knife stuck between the eyes toppled to the ground rather separate from his body, and behind him stood Thorin Oakenshield, his eyes so wild they were almost black, almost white, Orcrist clutched in a single hand.
Thorin fell to his knees and murmured something in Khuzdûl, one arm held tightly to his heaving chest, staring at the empty space where Bilbo stood rooted to the ground.
Cries from afar began to trickle through the white noise in Bilbo’s ears, but they did not sound like those of grief, and he looked up, squinting in the grey glare of the clouds.
The Eagles had come.
“Let me see him, let me see him!”
Lifelong friendship or not, Bilbo was going to find a ladder and climb atop it just so he could smack that merry facade right off Gandalf the Grey’s smiling face if he did not move out of the bleeding way of the door right this very minute.
”Bilbo,” Gandalf said, the placating calm in his voice so very clear and condescending, and Bilbo was seconds away from blowing another of his dwindling fuses, “it has hardly been any time at all since the battle ended. Thorin is quite alright; he has been tended to, and is mending, I assure you. The Elves have left him alone to look after others in need —“
”I could not give a single sod whether they’re nursemaiding him or not, I want to see him! I need to —“ he swallowed, “I must look with my own eyes. There is nothing else for it.”
“This is a tent of healing, and fortunately or not, you are not injured, my dear fellow.”
Bilbo’s eyes narrowed to needle-points. He was going to wreak havoc, very soon, and all the armies in the North were not going to be able to stop him.
“Gandalf, I swear to every power underneath the Sun and above it —”
With one last shrewd look, the wizard stepped aside and drew the flap of the tent entryway back, and Bilbo stumbled through in a single heartbeat. His mind felt like pumice-stones, like quicksand, blind flashes of panic like lightning across the sky.
It was empty but for one — the King warranted privacy, he supposed, and it was a small tent, regardless — and its single occupant was awake, and alive, and looking right at Bilbo. They each were pinned, for a moment, eyes wide and with purple-grey bags likely halfway down their cheeks in exhaustion.
Bilbo broke their eye contact and looked up and down Thorin’s half-unclothed body, taking account of everything he could see. Bits of him were bandaged, or covered by blankets, and there was a small section of matted blood in his hair, but he seemed — he seemed all right.
Bruised, likely fractured all over in places, but mendable, all mendable, all survivable, and the thought was a burst of sunlight in the dawn.
Thorin leant up from underneath the blankets as Bilbo sat down on the bedroll, entirely aware that his breathing was coming a little fast. They couldn’t quite seem to stop staring at each other. Bilbo’s brain had fallen entirely out of his head and was only calling out the words alive alive alive, beating him over the back with it, and he could not concentrate on a single other thing. Thorin lowered his eyes, then brought them back up; so tempered. He spoke.
”You are alright?”
His voice was croaky, less a baritone than a deep-forest murmur, and Bilbo could seem to do nothing but nod.
”Right as rain. No orc could catch me, you know.”
Thorin smiled softly, only the very corners of his mouth pulling themselves upwards. ”I do not doubt it,” he said. There was silence as they looked over each other, seemingly unable to do anything else, and then Thorin spoke again, his voice low.
“It was you, Master Baggins. Wasn’t it?”
Bilbo blinked once, sitting up quite straight, and then said in a faltering voice, “Indeed.”
Thorin breathed out deeply and nodded, as if this had confirmed some suspicion he’d had of Bilbo. “How — ?”
“Oh, I don’t think it’ll be much longer now. You’ll find out very soon, I’m sure.”
Thorin opened his mouth and tried to sit up further but only groaned as something in his side twinged and he let himself fall back on one elbow, catching his breath. He seemed to be favouring his right side; the injury must have been in a left rib, or somewhere or other, but he was still smiling that infinitesimal smile.
Bilbo squinted.
It wasn’t just him, he realised. Thorin truly did look a little lopsided, and he was still holding one of his arms rather close to his body, pushing himself up again to sitting with only the right and trying to pretend as if the grunts of pain were not coming from him.
Bandages covered the other arm, the left one, from halfway down the forearm all the way to the end, and they’d been wrapped so thick they could have passed for an animal’s hide if one only glanced by them. The very end of the gauze was flushed a dulled scarlet from the wound, the colour of blood blurring pinkish in water. It was wrapped so awfully neat and tiny, Bilbo wondered how in the world Thorin had any feeling left in his —
His hand.
Thorin grimaced rather wryly, and inclined his head, letting his gaze fall. Bilbo’s eyes followed, and together they both looked down at what had once been the hand that held the oaken shield; what was now nothing more than a stump, murky and ragged still with a steady stream of blood.
Bilbo felt every last inch of his own drain out of his face.
“Oh, Thorin. Oh, why of all the —“
You couldn’t have been a second quicker, could you! Training and training with Nori and Dwalin and every other dwarf you could guilt into it and still you were too slow, what in all the lands of Middle-Earth would your mother think, you absolute —
“It’s alright, Master Burglar.”
There was a scratchy pressure on his forearm, and when Bilbo looked it was the arm with the missing hand; Thorin’s face was tightened in pain, but he set his jaw and his wide eyes stubbornly on Bilbo. He’d probably forgotten it wasn’t there, wasn’t used to it. Bilbo felt a hurtling stab of empathy.
”I do not mind,” Thorin said quietly. “I do not care. Truly. I am sure I would have, in some other circumstance, but it is not this one.”
Bilbo stared at him, his eyes feeling stretched to dinner-plates in his face. He could not seem to find the words to speak. Could not think of one single thing to say. His eyes had gone all misty, and Thorin frowned.
”Why is it you are so sad? Better this and all of you still alive. Far better. Master Baggins.” He shifted a little again, grunting in pain, and Bilbo pressed an exasperatedly-distressed hand against his chest to force him back down onto his elbows once more. “You of all people must know that.”
Bilbo’s cheeks were muddling with the effort he was having to exert not to let the tears in his eyes fall, and he raised them to the ceiling of the tent in desperation, pressing the heel of one hand to the underneath of his eye and laughing a little desperately, the sound wet. The tips of his ears flushed in shame and ruddy joy.
“Oh, when did you grow a brain inside that head!” he cried, and Thorin breathed out a laugh, still too injured to let there be any force behind it. He forced himself up from his elbows once more with his remaining hand, grimacing but not letting a sound escape this time, and Bilbo glared at him.
“You’re right, of course,” he snapped at the infuriating individual before him. “Ignore me, won’t you? I’m simply losing it, I think.”
Bilbo shifted his body so he was facing the tent wall rather than Thorin, sitting side-saddle on the bedroll. His hands were wringing themselves between each other, and he ducked his head, suddenly entirely unable to conceal his trace of a smile.
He looked back to Thorin watching him. Alive. Alive. Alive.
“You are all right. That is all I care about. And that has been more than any Baggins deserves.”
”It is thanks to you,” Thorin said, very quietly, the sound so low it wouldn’t have been audible had they not been alone in the quiet, the very deepest undertones of music.
A funny noise came out of Bilbo's mouth without meaning to, then, a aborted little whimper that seemed something between a laugh and a long-choked-back sob, and quite without thinking he reached out, grasped Thorin softly by the back of his neck, and pulled him forward until at last their foreheads were touching.
Thorin exhaled deeply, his breath steady and warm on Bilbo's face, and he could almost hear Thorin’s slight smile in the creak of his teeth. Neither of them said a word. Neither of them opened their eyes.
Very, very gently, Bilbo drew his hand from the base of Thorin’s neck and around to tuck a long tendril of hair behind his ear, his fingers so tenderly soft and tangling in Thorin’s hair. He felt like Thorin was made of crystal, and so unreal in his fingers that he was almost scared to touch him. Thorin responded by warmly cupping the back of Bilbo’s bedraggled head, the way he had all those months ago, far away in the West, and pushing their foreheads more firmly together. He seemed to hum very quietly, and Bilbo could feel the gentle rumble of it under his skin, his pulse thudding a steady, steady rhythm in his veins.
Tears began to drip down his nose and fell hot against Thorin’s cheeks as they sat there in the quiet, the only two people alone in the tent, or maybe in all the world, the press of their foreheads an anchor that tethered them at long last to one another, that threaded them until they were bound.
And, just this once — wouldn’t you know it? — Bilbo let them fall.
