Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

Strange Alloys

Summary:

Bilbo is a professional burglar in Bree who is only six months from retirement. But when Thorin knocks on his door with questions about dragons and the Lonely Mountain, Bilbo can't resist taking on this one last case.

Thorin claims he was framed for a crime he did not commit. The dwarves of Erebor and the wood elves of Mirkwood are entwined closer in friendship than any in Middle-Earth, yet Thorin believes that there is a dark rot in the heart of the woodland city, and needs Bilbo to help him uncover it.

But prying into the secrets of the Woodland City will entangle everyone Thorin cares about, with deadly consequences.

Notes:

Apologies that this is a complete repost of chapter 1 from a few hours ago, as I had a formatting issue I could not solve in the original post, fingers crossed it is fine now.

Thanks again to Flollius for the beta-reading, advice and support.

Chapter 1: A Dwarf Walked Into My Office

Chapter Text

Night was complete under the branches of Mirkwood. Thorin turned at the little gates of the Woodland city, a small gate, a gate younger than him. It led to the Starwatcher’s Hill just outside the Woodland City, and beyond that a secret way to the east-west road. Behind him, through the open doors, he could see the lamps and the winding roots that made up the streets of his home. The shadows of Balin and Dwalin were cut out against the warm lights.

“Did you find a proper blanket, laddie?” Balin said. Thorin couldn’t see his face with the light at his back, but there was a tremble in his voice. “Is your pack comfortable?”

“I’ve got everything I need, Balin, I promise,” Thorin embraced him one last time. “Keep strong, be stone.” He gripped Dwalin's shoulder. "Look after them all. The City turned on me because I was asking too many questions, but it won't end with me."

Thorin turned towards the complete darkness of the well-kept, dwarf-built path and began to walk away from his Woodland home, knowing he would likely never see it again.

–

Bilbo was about to lock the door of the office when the dwarf appeared on the other side of the bullseye glass window like a wraith. Bilbo gave a little jump and put his hand to his heart. The dwarf took the knocker and rapped sharply, apparently unaware that Bilbo was on the other side, as it was still midsummer and the hallway was darker than the rough Bree street outside.

Bilbo pulled open the door at once, a little for the effect, as he was somewhat annoyed at being surprised. The fellow gave only a slight raise of the eyebrows to show he was surprised in turn.

He was not a bad sight for anyone’s doorstep. His clothes had been of a fine-spun make once, a dyed linen shirt emerging from a dark, blue doublet under a velvet-lined wool coat that hung to his knees. The cut and embroidery on the hems were from some far-distant workshop, definitely not Bree or Shire make. But Bilbo noticed that the velvet was worn a little at the ends of the sleeves, the elbows patched in cheap leather to match each other but by an inexpert hand, not part of the original tailor’s design. The dwarf had taken the effort to keep his beard trimmed and his hair combed, but no one had cut his hair at the back for a long time. But bless his toes, he was certainly more handsome than most of the local ore-traders and smiths in this town.

“Can I help you?”

The dwarf tucked his thumbs in his belt, which pushed the coat back to nicely frame the shape of his chest and waist. “Are you Mr Baggins?”

Bilbo pointed at the bronze, engraved sign hanging beside the door.

B. BAGGINS

PROFESSIONAL BURGLAR

"Things Found and Found Out"

The dwarf cleared his throat. “I have a job for you. You came highly recommended.”

“By who, if you don’t mind me asking?”

Bilbo had been trying to wind down his profession for over a year now, taking on fewer and less lengthy assignments, with as little danger as possible. The 'B' in B. BAGGINS had actually been 'Belladonna', when the office had opened nineteen years ago. She had been the real professional, though he’d always tried to be a good apprentice. He’d been a grown hobbit when they had come to Bree, and he always thought he had started burglaring rather too late in life to learn the trade properly. Bella had often said she’d add ‘& SON’ to the sign, but she never did, perhaps because her pride was too strong to ever consider his apprenticeship quite over. Then one night seven years ago, his mother had gone to bed, bright and stubborn as always, and the next morning he’d found her peacefully cold and dead, still sitting up with a blackmail letter on her lap that a client had asked her to find the writer of. Her magic ring hung in the little pouch around her neck, and without thinking Bilbo had taken it out and put it in his pocket, tucked the blackmail letter into the inbox on his desk, and then called the undertaker. He’d solved the blackmailer later that month.

After these seven years of being the only B. BAGGINS, PROFESSIONAL BURGLAR in Bree, Bilbo was ready to go home. Whatever his mother had been running from - whatever it was that had killed his father, nineteen years ago, on the parlour floor of Bag End, while Belladonna and Bilbo were on an evening walk to see shooting stars - it had never found them in Bree. All Bilbo knew of it was the hissing whisper they’d heard as they’d come in the front door and the creature had disappeared out the parlour window, “Took, Bellaaa Tooook.” That was the only clue, apart from what it had done to his poor, fat, innocent father. It had not been enough for Bilbo to solve the mystery, but he suspected it was enough to tip off his mother, for the very hour after Bungo was buried she signed a ten-year lease for Bag End to the Sackville-Bagginses and spirited herself and Bilbo off to Bree. And here they had lived ever since, renewing the lease to the Sackville-Bagginses just the once. But Bilbo had now exchanged several over-polite letters to his cousins, giving them six months to vacate Bag End, so he could finally return to Hobbiton and a quiet, unproductive life.

The dwarf answered him at last, “A wizard, named Gandalf.”

“I see,” Bilbo swallowed. “You’d better come in.” He stepped back and swept his arm towards the open hallway. “First door on the left. Would you like tea?”

“No tea, please; coffee if you have it.”

Bilbo glanced around to check no one was loitering and watching as the dwarf entered, and then he shut the door, turned the latch and followed him inside.

The office itself was a large, high-ceilinged room by Bree standards, with a wallpaper of pale grey patterned with a print of willow branches. Opposite the window, the open hearth was cold today, but in winter it burned merrily. The large, bay window had a lattice of bullseye glass panels, letting in the sun but providing anonymity to clients unless - like the dwarf practically had at the front door - you pressed your face right up to the panes. There were two armchairs furnished in green and gold, with high backs for human clients and low seats for hobbit sized ones; humans simply had to sit with their knees a little high, but that put their faces closer to Bilbo’s height when he sat on the far side of his large desk.

The dwarf took off his coat as he entered and hung it on the rack by the door. So he was already more well-mannered than most of Bilbo’s clients. He settled himself on the chair closest the window, which was angled so the noon sun was slightly at his back. Bilbo did have a little coffee pot, as it happened, and he put the kettle on in the kitchen at the back of the house. It was half boiled already, and soon he returned with two cups on a small tray and laid it on the desk, offering one to the dwarf.

“Excuse me, I haven’t asked your name.”

“Thorin, son of Thrain,” said the dwarf, taking the coffee and sipping it eagerly before it was properly cooled. He closed his eyes for a moment to savour it. “Ah. You brew it in the Eastern style.”

“It’s how my mother always made it,” Bilbo said, sitting behind the desk and entwining his fingers in front of him. “Is Gandalf a friend?”

“He claims to be, though he called himself mine before I’d met him,” Thorin leaned back in the armchair. “He said he was an old friend of my father, and attached himself to me when I was on the road, so we were travelling companions for a while. That was to my good fortune, as it happens, as he is an intimidating creature and I have not held a sword nor shield for many long years. Since I saw him last I have been to the Blue Mountains and back, before I ran into him again yesterday, in the Prancing Pony, and got to speaking of how little my troubles had improved since I last met him.”

“Good to get straight the point,” Bilbo drew his coffee in closer and leaned his elbows on the desk. “Are these the same troubles you have come to me for?”

Thorin inclined his head in acknowledgement.

“And do you want to tell me about them?”

Thorin paused now, holding his gaze. At last he said, “I am from the City, as you may have guessed.”

Ah! Of course, that was the make of his clothes. Bilbo should have guessed; his mother would have chastised him for missing it, but he gave himself some sympathy. It was so rare to see a dwarf from the great city near the borders of Mirkwood. The Woodland City, known even this far to the West as simply the City, for though there were many others in Middle Earth who claimed the title of ‘city’ on maps, none of them compared to that great metropolis in the forest. The centre of light and learning in the continent, the wellspring of the most clever and fine objects of use and beauty; even Bilbo’s coffee pot with its reliable filter was made in the City, though traded through who knew how many merchants before it came all the way to Bree.

“I suspected,” Bilbo shrugged.

Thorin’s face was grim. “I am an exile from the City, and from my people who still dwell there. I was…” his face shifted a little, not as if he was trying to hide something, but as if he was trying to decide for himself what the truth was. “...important, as important as a dwarf can be in that place.”

“Why were you exiled?” Bilbo asked.

Thorin shook his head. “I was accused of theft, a large theft of money from a large number of dwarves. There was to be some semblance of a trial, but I was forewarned that the sentence would be exile, though that is a high punishment for theft when no blood had been spilled. And no dwarf that has been sent into exile from the City has ever been heard from again. So I left of my own accord before I could face the elf king’s justice.”

“Your king,” Bilbo corrected, to see how he would react. There was only one king crowned in Mirkwood.

“Ay,” Thorin said reluctantly. “My king.” He sipped his coffee. “That was two years ago. Since then I have been wandering in search of other dwarves from the City, particularly my father, who left the Woodland many decades ago. I went first to my cousin in the Iron Hills, but he and his kin had heard nothing of my father. I went next to the Blue Mountains, but in Ered Luin they were simply befuddled that I left the City of my own choice. Dwarves of Erebor outside the Woodland are few and scattered, and most left many decades ago, when at least a few miles of the forest were still green.”

“And… did you do it? The theft?”

Thorin’s brows tightened a little. Bilbo waved his hand. “I’m sorry for the pertinent question, but you will appreciate my pertinent self when you hire me.”

“No,” Thorin said in a low voice. “I stole nothing. The money belonged to my people, given to my keeping for good works, so I deserve some guilt for its vanishing. But I took not a coin for myself, nor know any who did.”

Bilbo nodded. “So you want me to go to the City, find the thief, and clear your name?”

Thorin shook his head. “There are much deeper questions I wish to pursue. But it is a longer tale to tell, and I would like your assurances of confidence before I tell it.”

“I have time,” Bilbo said, “And all prospective clients have my confidence. Learning secrets is part of my job, but I would quickly go out of business if I shared the ones I’m not paid to share, wouldn’t I?”

Thorin took a moment to savour the coffee. At last he began to speak. “I was not born in the City, but in the great dwarven manor of Erebor, built inside the Lonely Mountain, further east of Mirkwood. Do you know what happened to Erebor?”

Bilbo nodded. So this dwarf was old; he wasn’t much of a judge of ages, but he would not have guessed he was quite that old. He must have lived a well-fed and gentle life; there was little grey in his hair, and his hands were solid but not rough. “A little. Probably only the children’s stories. A dragon came, and ate them all up, but they were saved by the elves and built the City as it is today.”

“You have the bones of it,” Thorin nodded. “Erebor was first tunnelled by my ancestors, but it was reclaimed by my grandfather and rebuilt more splendid than any dwarf kingdom left in this part of the world. So he became King Under the Mountain in those days.”

Bilbo raised his eyebrows; so ‘important’ had not been an exaggeration.

Thorin continued, his gaze drifting as if searching his memories, “When Smaug the terrible came out of the North, he laid waste to Dale for the cruelty of it, and then breached the mountain and would have destroyed us all. But in the moment of our despair, Thranduil of the woodland realm came to our aid. I knew him only a little, for I had once arbitrated an old grudge between him and my grandfather, over something as petty as payment for services. Thranduil had seen the signs of the dragon far off from his palace and arrived with a great cavalry and many spears, and harried the wyrm within our front hall, which allowed many of my folk to escape who would otherwise have perished. Thranduil himself took a small host of elves to pursue the dragon deeper into the mountain, while I led the survivors to safety. Only half of that host returned, including the elven king himself. Erebor was lost; but Thranduil opened the doors of his palace to us, and gave us hospitality and healing.

“I do not know how we would otherwise have survived, a broken and scattered bunch of refugees in the wide world, but in the Woodland we found a haven. Friendship grew between our peoples, and a particular friendship between myself and the Elf king. There were still divisions: my father and grandfather had their pride to nurse, and were keen always to retake Erebor and rebuild, but it seemed an impossible task while the dragon lived. Yet there were many among the dwarves who soon came to care for the elves. Together, our people found a great fertility for our crafts; for the wisdom of elves and dwarves is very different, and from difference springs new and unexpected fruits. As the dwarves of Moria in bygone days found fellowship with Eregion, so it was between the artisans and scholars of my people and Thranduil's. If you have heard tales of the City, you will know - our magic can harness the sun upon rocks and shadowed mirrors, as the trees do upon their leaves, so that the city is lit by a thousand, thousand lamps that burn without fire, warmed by hearths that require no wood or coal, water brought into every home and fountain from deep reservoirs beneath the earth. The year I left, one of our cleverest tinkers, Bifur, even found a way to build a small forge without fire: we dammed a branch of the Forest River to turn the weight of water into heat enough to forge steel.

“In such security, children of both races were born and survived their infancy in greater numbers, and grew strong and were quick to learn. They mingled together in the streets and woods like brothers and sisters. All the old dwarves from the Mountain had hope they would live long enough to see their great-grandchildren marry. And Thranduil was glad that our blended kingdoms prospered, for he is the only elf lord left in the world who refuses to let his people diminish, or sail west to other lands. He intends to use strength to build peace with the spreading race of men, so that his works and children endure the coming ages. In order to learn that endurance, he looks to dwarves. His ambitions and love for his people were the heart of our accord, and I respected him for it, as I wanted the same for my own kind. Those of us who had been born under stone never entirely lost our wariness for the open skies, but we grew to love the cool, deep trees, and the many beautiful ways to shape wood and timber. And our children who have never known any other life are swift-footed and far-sighted, and can climb like elves, if you can imagine it.

“But all this prosperity is built upon a soul of Mithril - alloys of Mithril, mixed drop by drop into great vats of copper and pulled into wires and beaten into sheets. But Mithril is the rarest of all metals, and the richest mines were in the lost kingdom of Moria. So, not long after our scholars and the elves had begun their experiments, my father and grandfather went west to the Misty Mountains to try and take back the halls of their fore-fathers. Our army was small, as many of our people did not want to risk death when they had new families and comfortable lives in the forest. I went with them because I felt it was my duty, but though I am ashamed to admit it, I wished dearly to stay behind. I did not want to leave our people leaderless and my young sister alone if the worst should happen. And happen it did; after many battles my grandfather was slain by orcs in the Dimrill Dale, and when my father fled back to the City, a great host of orcs pursued us and our surviving warriors for days and days into the forest, until we were nearly upon the threshold of the elf king's palace. There we were caught, and made a last stand, and many were slain, including my brother. Thranduil sent out his guard to drive back the orcs, but my father and I were two of the few who still lived by the time they reached us, along with some of my cousins. After this bloody incursion into his lands, Thranduil grew fearful of further warmongering, and forbade all weapons within the Woodland kingdom, save those carried by the City’s evergreen Guard. Even butchers and tanners must have a license for their knives. My father objected, for no dwarf had been admitted to the City guard at that time. Without saying so, this law meant all our folk must give up their weapons to be melted down, even heirlooms that had been passed through families for hundreds of years. Our defence would forever be at the mercy of the elves, even if the City was attacked from the outside. But Thranduil would not bend, and in his despair at this humiliation my father walked away from our City and never returned.

“So I was left to lead our people as best I could, and for a while it seemed that my friendship with the king would see the bitterness healed. The City traded its creations far across the world, and wealth poured into all our coffers, and the City grew, new palaces and halls and streets spreading out into the forest. But over the years, the indignities began to grow with it. Rules upon rules, which always claimed to treat all as equals, yet seemed most to constrain the dwarves; rules governing how our children are educated, when we may pass in and out of the gates, even who we may choose to marry. And when the rules are broken, fines are levied that enrich the royal treasury further. And for the direst crimes, the punishment is exile without hope of return or even the solace of a letter from home. For many decades I sat on Thranduil's council and had some say in the decisions of his realm, and sovereignty over the dwarves and their houses; but over time, he began to keep secret councils, and his court was closed to me and my kin, and he no longer heard my petitions. The heart of the City, I believe, has a rot inside it that is spreading; but I do not know where the infection started. I only know that perfumes and glamours can not hide its stench forever."

Bilbo had listened in silence, but here Thorin stopped, and looked into his mug, where his half-drunk coffee had gone cold. Bilbo had finished his cup and put it down gently on the saucer. "So what's my job in all of this? To enter the City and learn - what? You seem to know the king’s mind far better than me, even if you don’t know all of it."

Thorin's gaze lifted to meet his. "No, Mr Baggins. Remember I said that Mithril is the soul of the City, and the City is still growing. But here is my first question, which I’d like you to answer: where is the Mithril coming from?" He tilted his head. "In the beginning, it was gifted by my people, from what they carried or wore as they fled the mountain. That store is long expended, yet small shipments appear whenever the City engineers need them. What Mithril mines are left on this earth? Moria perhaps, but even if Thranduil were willing to trade with goblins, they do not have the skill of extracting the ore. From the East? The few, poor veins of Mithril in that part of the world are drained and what dust is left it dearly fought over by the dwarves in those parts; they would not give it up to an Elven king. But there is one place left where Mithril lies already purified, smelted and shaped: in Erebor, hoarded in heaps, collecting dust. I have long believed that if my folk could return to the mountain, we could use that Mithril to restore it to a splendor beyond even the wildest imagining of my grandfather - for we would bring home all that we have learned and invented with the elves. Erebor filled with light, with fresh water, with heat and the magic needed to grow food underground, no longer dependent on anyone outside our halls. The only small difficulty is the dragon guarding it," he sat forward a little. "But think: no one has seen the dragon for many years. What if Smaug is dead? Or so infirm that he cannot lift a claw to defend his hoard? And what if Thranduil knows this, and this is where he gets his Mithril, secretly building his power upon the stolen treasure of my grandfather? Perhaps in Erebeor he has found himself the stock of Mithril he needs to keep his city in health and wealth as long as he likes, until the last of the Erebor-born dwarves are dead. Is he simply waiting for us to forget we ever had a life beyond the woods, and lose all desire for freedom?" He shook his head. "These were the questions I was asking, quietly and carefully, when I was suddenly accused of theft and threatened with exile. And this is the second question I am asking you to find out for me: is there still a live dragon in Erebor?"

Bilbo waited to be sure Thorin was ready to end the story. He tried to keep his expression neutral, but his heart was beating fast. He had been so ready to retire back to Bag End, but this dwarf - and it didn’t hurt that he really was such a handsome dwarf - had awoken something of his mother’s spirit in him. He’d found his way into castles and barrows and army camps successfully, and satisfied many a happy customer, but he’d never taken on such a quest: to cross half the world to investigate a mountain thought to be guarded by a sleeping dragon.

“It’s a big job, it will be a big fee,” he said, to give himself time to think.

“If you take it on commission and I am right, you will be richly rewarded. If I am wrong and Erebor cannot be reclaimed, I may have a harder time paying you,” Thorin admitted. “I will tell you straight; I have little, only enough saved from honest work on my wandering, which will barely cover your travelling expenses. Beyond that, I have my name and the skills of my hands.”

“And what are they? Can you make your magic Mithril lanterns and so forth?” Bilbo said hopefully.

Thorin smiled, apologetic and teasing both at once. “No. But I can write you a fair and watertight contract.”

Bilbo returned the smile. “Very well. We can set a small base fee if I’m successful, plus a small share of the treasure if your theory proves correct: that way the risk may balance the reward for me, but you won’t be too out of pocket if you’re wrong. I’ll take you on, if you’re willing to act as my guide back to the Mountain,” he stood up and reached across the desk to shake Thorin’s hand. “And I will help you if I can.”

—

It was a clear morning in late autumn, and the trees glowed red from one end of the City to the other. It had been several months since Thorin had walked into the office of Bilbo Baggins, in Bree half a world away. But Fili did not know that; he had not seen his uncle for two and a half years and did not even know if he was alive or dead.

The air was cool despite the warmth that flowed through pipes across the city. Fili sat opposite Dwalin, each nursing a warm mug of mead. They were in a small pub made of beams of wood slotted together without visible groove and curved into arches like the tunnel of a cave mouth, open to the dwarvish street where shoppers, families and craftspeople meandered past. The barkeep laid out clean glasses on the tables at the back. There were no other customers this early in the morning.

“I can’t believe you invited him,” Dwalin rumbled.

“I trust him,” Fili said. “And we need him. With all due respect, you’re one dwarf and you’re used to fighting in caves and mountains. We need someone who can use the trees, and elvish weapons, someone who can teach the younger ones how to really survive in the forest.”

“With all due respect yourself, Fili, the lad thinks he’s half elf. His heart’s turned to wood, not a drop of iron left,” Dwalin shook his head. “If we bring him in, he’ll run straight to his beloved Captain and sell us right up the flue.”

“He won’t,” Fili hissed. “You don’t know what you’re talking about, Dwalin. I know his heart a bloody sight better than you. And even if there was a splinter in it, we’ve reached the limit of what you can teach. You’re rusty,” he said firmly. “And you know it.” He glanced over his shoulder. “Ah, there he is!” Fili whistled. “Hey, Kili! Over here!”

Dwalin gave a last grumble and drank a deep draft as a figure waved at them and strode across the street. He was in a narrow-cut uniform of dark grey-green, with a sword on each hip and his bow slung on his back. His sleek, dark hair was combed into a single braid down his back. He beamed at them and bent to embrace Fili without sitting down. He looked like the perfect young recruit of the City Guard, distinguished from his fellows only by a few feet of height. Fili thought ruefully that he didn’t even smell like a dwarf anymore, he smelled something like a cross between sword oil and fresh baking.

“Hello! So what’s this about? Couldn’t it wait for dinner?” Kili asked. It wasn’t urgency that had kept Fili from discussing this at home; he just didn’t want their mother overhearing anything.

“Sit down and I’ll get you a drink,” Dwalin said in a low voice.

“Oh, no I can’t,” Kili leaned one hand on the back of Fili’s chair. “I’ve just come off the night patrol. I have to check these in at headquarters before I go home,” Kili patted one of the swords at his belt.

“Five minutes,” Fili said, tugging on Kili’s free hand. “Please.”

Kili frowned at him. “Alright, really now, what’s going on?”

Fili glanced at Dwalin. “We need your help with something. Something you can’t tell anyone about.”

Kili drew his head back a little, giving a sly smile. “Something good or something bad?”

“Kili, please just sit down—“

There was a shout down the street, not the bellow of a dwarf but the clear voice of an elf yelling unusually loudly. Kili jerked out of his brother’s grip and stepped away from the open awning of the pub. Legolas, the commander of the City guard, was coming at speed towards him. Two other senior constables followed, trying in vain to look smooth and composed while matching his pace.

The elf prince drew up sharply in front of Kili. There were the faintest blotches on his neck and his brows were deep and wrinkled. “Don’t move. Put your weapons down.”

Kili looked up at him with a visible gulp. “I wasn’t drinking, sir, I swear. I just finished my shift and was heading back—“

“Throw your weapons down,” Legolas intoned, each word drawn out through gritted teeth. Fili had met the elf prince only a handful of times, and usually in a crowd of some kind, and he had never seen him anything less than serenely composed. In fact, Fili didn’t think he’d ever seen any elf so angry, not in his entire life. He looked between Dwalin and Kili, trying to figure out if Dwalin knew what this was about. Dwalin looked as baffled as he felt.

“Of course, yes sir,” Kili said in a rush, unbelting his swords. For a moment he hesitated, and then moved to put them on the table in front of Fili. Legolas barked, “Put them on the ground!”

Kili crouched to put down the swords and his bow, then straightened up, shoulders back and arms at his side.

“Take him into custody,” Legolas said. The two constables stepped forward and one seized each of Kili’s arms.

Fili jumped to his feet and locked his hand over the nearest constable’s, around the place where he was gripping his brother’s arm so tight Fili could feel the dents in Kili’s flesh. “What are you doing? You can’t treat him like this!”

He didn’t keep his voice quiet; there were dwarves up and down the street looking at them now. Everybody on this street knew who Kili was, and most of them would have recognised Legolas on sight. This was outrageous. If Kili had done something wrong, he should have been taken aside in private, by his lieutenant, and given a chance to explain himself. This had to be some kind of deliberate humiliation, and one done to maximise the number of dwarves who would go home and tell their families about it. But Fili was beyond confused about what excuse Legolas could give to relieve Kili of his duties. As far as he was aware - and Kili told him everything, he was sure - his brother was a model officer of the Guard.

Legolas shot him a dark look. “He is to be detained in the palace dungeon until trial. Let him go, or I’ll have you sent down too.”

“Trial for what?” Fili snarled. “For getting above his station?”

Legolas said coldly. “For the murder of Captain Tauriel.”

Fili felt a cold shiver run across the back of his neck. He turned from Legolas to look at Kili. His brother’s cheeks had turned a chalky pale, his eyes wide and all expression wiped from his face. He was staring at Legolas, but he said nothing. He sank a little towards the earth, and if the constables had not been gripping his arms so tightly it seemed certain he would have kept sinking into the dust.

“You do not even deny it?” Legolas said to him.

Kili just continued to stare at him. He didn’t seem to hear Fili saying, loudly for the watching crowd to hear. “It’s not true. He’s done nothing.”

They took Kili away, still silent and putting up no resistance. Fili felt himself reel around, looking first to Dwalin and then to the gathered crowd. He scrubbed his hands down his face. “Tauriel?” he said quietly to Dwalin. “It can’t be. She was at our house after dinner last night, she was perfectly well.”

Kili wasn’t even home when Tauriel had come round. He had been out on patrol since sundown. Tauriel had come to speak with their mother. Fili briefly wondered, could Ma have something to do with this? Dis had no love for Kili’s famous Captain of the Guard, for reasons which she had made clear to both her sons. In fact, it would not be unfair to say that in recent weeks, when she’d learned the truth about Kili and Tauriel, Dis’ dislike of Tauriel might even be described as hatred. But even if Dis had had it in her to commit murder, last night had been different. When Fili got back to the house after dinner and found Tauriel and Ma sitting in the parlour together drinking tea, the two of them were smiling as if they had come to a friendly accord. As far as Fili was aware, Tauriel had left soon after and Ma had gone to bed.

No, this news was nothing to do with anyone in their family, he was immediately and utterly sure. Something had happened to Tauriel after she’d left their house.

“He wasn’t even there,” Fili repeated, again loud enough to make a show of it to the watching street. He put his hand to his brow and let out a long, slow breath. “I’ve got to find Ma.”

“Ay,” Dwalin said, folding his arms. “And watch yourself as you go. He won’t be the first, Fili. It’s happening now, just as Thorin said it would.”