Chapter 1: A Dwarf Walked Into My Office
Chapter Text
Night was complete under the branches of Mirkwood. Thorin turned at the little gates of the Woodland city, a small gate, a gate younger than him. It led to the Starwatcher’s Hill just outside the Woodland City, and beyond that a secret way to the east-west road. Behind him, through the open doors, he could see the lamps and the winding roots that made up the streets of his home. The shadows of Balin and Dwalin were cut out against the warm lights.
“Did you find a proper blanket, laddie?” Balin said. Thorin couldn’t see his face with the light at his back, but there was a tremble in his voice. “Is your pack comfortable?”
“I’ve got everything I need, Balin, I promise,” Thorin embraced him one last time. “Keep strong, be stone.” He gripped Dwalin's shoulder. "Look after them all. The City turned on me because I was asking too many questions, but it won't end with me."
Thorin turned towards the complete darkness of the well-kept, dwarf-built path and began to walk away from his Woodland home, knowing he would likely never see it again.
–
Bilbo was about to lock the door of the office when the dwarf appeared on the other side of the bullseye glass window like a wraith. Bilbo gave a little jump and put his hand to his heart. The dwarf took the knocker and rapped sharply, apparently unaware that Bilbo was on the other side, as it was still midsummer and the hallway was darker than the rough Bree street outside.
Bilbo pulled open the door at once, a little for the effect, as he was somewhat annoyed at being surprised. The fellow gave only a slight raise of the eyebrows to show he was surprised in turn.
He was not a bad sight for anyone’s doorstep. His clothes had been of a fine-spun make once, a dyed linen shirt emerging from a dark, blue doublet under a velvet-lined wool coat that hung to his knees. The cut and embroidery on the hems were from some far-distant workshop, definitely not Bree or Shire make. But Bilbo noticed that the velvet was worn a little at the ends of the sleeves, the elbows patched in cheap leather to match each other but by an inexpert hand, not part of the original tailor’s design. The dwarf had taken the effort to keep his beard trimmed and his hair combed, but no one had cut his hair at the back for a long time. But bless his toes, he was certainly more handsome than most of the local ore-traders and smiths in this town.
“Can I help you?”
The dwarf tucked his thumbs in his belt, which pushed the coat back to nicely frame the shape of his chest and waist. “Are you Mr Baggins?”
Bilbo pointed at the bronze, engraved sign hanging beside the door.
B. BAGGINS
PROFESSIONAL BURGLAR
"Things Found and Found Out"
The dwarf cleared his throat. “I have a job for you. You came highly recommended.”
“By who, if you don’t mind me asking?”
Bilbo had been trying to wind down his profession for over a year now, taking on fewer and less lengthy assignments, with as little danger as possible. The 'B' in B. BAGGINS had actually been 'Belladonna', when the office had opened nineteen years ago. She had been the real professional, though he’d always tried to be a good apprentice. He’d been a grown hobbit when they had come to Bree, and he always thought he had started burglaring rather too late in life to learn the trade properly. Bella had often said she’d add ‘& SON’ to the sign, but she never did, perhaps because her pride was too strong to ever consider his apprenticeship quite over. Then one night seven years ago, his mother had gone to bed, bright and stubborn as always, and the next morning he’d found her peacefully cold and dead, still sitting up with a blackmail letter on her lap that a client had asked her to find the writer of. Her magic ring hung in the little pouch around her neck, and without thinking Bilbo had taken it out and put it in his pocket, tucked the blackmail letter into the inbox on his desk, and then called the undertaker. He’d solved the blackmailer later that month.
After these seven years of being the only B. BAGGINS, PROFESSIONAL BURGLAR in Bree, Bilbo was ready to go home. Whatever his mother had been running from - whatever it was that had killed his father, nineteen years ago, on the parlour floor of Bag End, while Belladonna and Bilbo were on an evening walk to see shooting stars - it had never found them in Bree. All Bilbo knew of it was the hissing whisper they’d heard as they’d come in the front door and the creature had disappeared out the parlour window, “Took, Bellaaa Tooook.” That was the only clue, apart from what it had done to his poor, fat, innocent father. It had not been enough for Bilbo to solve the mystery, but he suspected it was enough to tip off his mother, for the very hour after Bungo was buried she signed a ten-year lease for Bag End to the Sackville-Bagginses and spirited herself and Bilbo off to Bree. And here they had lived ever since, renewing the lease to the Sackville-Bagginses just the once. But Bilbo had now exchanged several over-polite letters to his cousins, giving them six months to vacate Bag End, so he could finally return to Hobbiton and a quiet, unproductive life.
The dwarf answered him at last, “A wizard, named Gandalf.”
“I see,” Bilbo swallowed. “You’d better come in.” He stepped back and swept his arm towards the open hallway. “First door on the left. Would you like tea?”
“No tea, please; coffee if you have it.”
Bilbo glanced around to check no one was loitering and watching as the dwarf entered, and then he shut the door, turned the latch and followed him inside.
The office itself was a large, high-ceilinged room by Bree standards, with a wallpaper of pale grey patterned with a print of willow branches. Opposite the window, the open hearth was cold today, but in winter it burned merrily. The large, bay window had a lattice of bullseye glass panels, letting in the sun but providing anonymity to clients unless - like the dwarf practically had at the front door - you pressed your face right up to the panes. There were two armchairs furnished in green and gold, with high backs for human clients and low seats for hobbit sized ones; humans simply had to sit with their knees a little high, but that put their faces closer to Bilbo’s height when he sat on the far side of his large desk.
The dwarf took off his coat as he entered and hung it on the rack by the door. So he was already more well-mannered than most of Bilbo’s clients. He settled himself on the chair closest the window, which was angled so the noon sun was slightly at his back. Bilbo did have a little coffee pot, as it happened, and he put the kettle on in the kitchen at the back of the house. It was half boiled already, and soon he returned with two cups on a small tray and laid it on the desk, offering one to the dwarf.
“Excuse me, I haven’t asked your name.”
“Thorin, son of Thrain,” said the dwarf, taking the coffee and sipping it eagerly before it was properly cooled. He closed his eyes for a moment to savour it. “Ah. You brew it in the Eastern style.”
“It’s how my mother always made it,” Bilbo said, sitting behind the desk and entwining his fingers in front of him. “Is Gandalf a friend?”
“He claims to be, though he called himself mine before I’d met him,” Thorin leaned back in the armchair. “He said he was an old friend of my father, and attached himself to me when I was on the road, so we were travelling companions for a while. That was to my good fortune, as it happens, as he is an intimidating creature and I have not held a sword nor shield for many long years. Since I saw him last I have been to the Blue Mountains and back, before I ran into him again yesterday, in the Prancing Pony, and got to speaking of how little my troubles had improved since I last met him.”
“Good to get straight the point,” Bilbo drew his coffee in closer and leaned his elbows on the desk. “Are these the same troubles you have come to me for?”
Thorin inclined his head in acknowledgement.
“And do you want to tell me about them?”
Thorin paused now, holding his gaze. At last he said, “I am from the City, as you may have guessed.”
Ah! Of course, that was the make of his clothes. Bilbo should have guessed; his mother would have chastised him for missing it, but he gave himself some sympathy. It was so rare to see a dwarf from the great city near the borders of Mirkwood. The Woodland City, known even this far to the West as simply the City, for though there were many others in Middle Earth who claimed the title of ‘city’ on maps, none of them compared to that great metropolis in the forest. The centre of light and learning in the continent, the wellspring of the most clever and fine objects of use and beauty; even Bilbo’s coffee pot with its reliable filter was made in the City, though traded through who knew how many merchants before it came all the way to Bree.
“I suspected,” Bilbo shrugged.
Thorin’s face was grim. “I am an exile from the City, and from my people who still dwell there. I was…” his face shifted a little, not as if he was trying to hide something, but as if he was trying to decide for himself what the truth was. “...important, as important as a dwarf can be in that place.”
“Why were you exiled?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin shook his head. “I was accused of theft, a large theft of money from a large number of dwarves. There was to be some semblance of a trial, but I was forewarned that the sentence would be exile, though that is a high punishment for theft when no blood had been spilled. And no dwarf that has been sent into exile from the City has ever been heard from again. So I left of my own accord before I could face the elf king’s justice.”
“Your king,” Bilbo corrected, to see how he would react. There was only one king crowned in Mirkwood.
“Ay,” Thorin said reluctantly. “My king.” He sipped his coffee. “That was two years ago. Since then I have been wandering in search of other dwarves from the City, particularly my father, who left the Woodland many decades ago. I went first to my cousin in the Iron Hills, but he and his kin had heard nothing of my father. I went next to the Blue Mountains, but in Ered Luin they were simply befuddled that I left the City of my own choice. Dwarves of Erebor outside the Woodland are few and scattered, and most left many decades ago, when at least a few miles of the forest were still green.”
“And… did you do it? The theft?”
Thorin’s brows tightened a little. Bilbo waved his hand. “I’m sorry for the pertinent question, but you will appreciate my pertinent self when you hire me.”
“No,” Thorin said in a low voice. “I stole nothing. The money belonged to my people, given to my keeping for good works, so I deserve some guilt for its vanishing. But I took not a coin for myself, nor know any who did.”
Bilbo nodded. “So you want me to go to the City, find the thief, and clear your name?”
Thorin shook his head. “There are much deeper questions I wish to pursue. But it is a longer tale to tell, and I would like your assurances of confidence before I tell it.”
“I have time,” Bilbo said, “And all prospective clients have my confidence. Learning secrets is part of my job, but I would quickly go out of business if I shared the ones I’m not paid to share, wouldn’t I?”
Thorin took a moment to savour the coffee. At last he began to speak. “I was not born in the City, but in the great dwarven manor of Erebor, built inside the Lonely Mountain, further east of Mirkwood. Do you know what happened to Erebor?”
Bilbo nodded. So this dwarf was old; he wasn’t much of a judge of ages, but he would not have guessed he was quite that old. He must have lived a well-fed and gentle life; there was little grey in his hair, and his hands were solid but not rough. “A little. Probably only the children’s stories. A dragon came, and ate them all up, but they were saved by the elves and built the City as it is today.”
“You have the bones of it,” Thorin nodded. “Erebor was first tunnelled by my ancestors, but it was reclaimed by my grandfather and rebuilt more splendid than any dwarf kingdom left in this part of the world. So he became King Under the Mountain in those days.”
Bilbo raised his eyebrows; so ‘important’ had not been an exaggeration.
Thorin continued, his gaze drifting as if searching his memories, “When Smaug the terrible came out of the North, he laid waste to Dale for the cruelty of it, and then breached the mountain and would have destroyed us all. But in the moment of our despair, Thranduil of the woodland realm came to our aid. I knew him only a little, for I had once arbitrated an old grudge between him and my grandfather, over something as petty as payment for services. Thranduil had seen the signs of the dragon far off from his palace and arrived with a great cavalry and many spears, and harried the wyrm within our front hall, which allowed many of my folk to escape who would otherwise have perished. Thranduil himself took a small host of elves to pursue the dragon deeper into the mountain, while I led the survivors to safety. Only half of that host returned, including the elven king himself. Erebor was lost; but Thranduil opened the doors of his palace to us, and gave us hospitality and healing.
“I do not know how we would otherwise have survived, a broken and scattered bunch of refugees in the wide world, but in the Woodland we found a haven. Friendship grew between our peoples, and a particular friendship between myself and the Elf king. There were still divisions: my father and grandfather had their pride to nurse, and were keen always to retake Erebor and rebuild, but it seemed an impossible task while the dragon lived. Yet there were many among the dwarves who soon came to care for the elves. Together, our people found a great fertility for our crafts; for the wisdom of elves and dwarves is very different, and from difference springs new and unexpected fruits. As the dwarves of Moria in bygone days found fellowship with Eregion, so it was between the artisans and scholars of my people and Thranduil's. If you have heard tales of the City, you will know - our magic can harness the sun upon rocks and shadowed mirrors, as the trees do upon their leaves, so that the city is lit by a thousand, thousand lamps that burn without fire, warmed by hearths that require no wood or coal, water brought into every home and fountain from deep reservoirs beneath the earth. The year I left, one of our cleverest tinkers, Bifur, even found a way to build a small forge without fire: we dammed a branch of the Forest River to turn the weight of water into heat enough to forge steel.
“In such security, children of both races were born and survived their infancy in greater numbers, and grew strong and were quick to learn. They mingled together in the streets and woods like brothers and sisters. All the old dwarves from the Mountain had hope they would live long enough to see their great-grandchildren marry. And Thranduil was glad that our blended kingdoms prospered, for he is the only elf lord left in the world who refuses to let his people diminish, or sail west to other lands. He intends to use strength to build peace with the spreading race of men, so that his works and children endure the coming ages. In order to learn that endurance, he looks to dwarves. His ambitions and love for his people were the heart of our accord, and I respected him for it, as I wanted the same for my own kind. Those of us who had been born under stone never entirely lost our wariness for the open skies, but we grew to love the cool, deep trees, and the many beautiful ways to shape wood and timber. And our children who have never known any other life are swift-footed and far-sighted, and can climb like elves, if you can imagine it.
“But all this prosperity is built upon a soul of Mithril - alloys of Mithril, mixed drop by drop into great vats of copper and pulled into wires and beaten into sheets. But Mithril is the rarest of all metals, and the richest mines were in the lost kingdom of Moria. So, not long after our scholars and the elves had begun their experiments, my father and grandfather went west to the Misty Mountains to try and take back the halls of their fore-fathers. Our army was small, as many of our people did not want to risk death when they had new families and comfortable lives in the forest. I went with them because I felt it was my duty, but though I am ashamed to admit it, I wished dearly to stay behind. I did not want to leave our people leaderless and my young sister alone if the worst should happen. And happen it did; after many battles my grandfather was slain by orcs in the Dimrill Dale, and when my father fled back to the City, a great host of orcs pursued us and our surviving warriors for days and days into the forest, until we were nearly upon the threshold of the elf king's palace. There we were caught, and made a last stand, and many were slain, including my brother. Thranduil sent out his guard to drive back the orcs, but my father and I were two of the few who still lived by the time they reached us, along with some of my cousins. After this bloody incursion into his lands, Thranduil grew fearful of further warmongering, and forbade all weapons within the Woodland kingdom, save those carried by the City’s evergreen Guard. Even butchers and tanners must have a license for their knives. My father objected, for no dwarf had been admitted to the City guard at that time. Without saying so, this law meant all our folk must give up their weapons to be melted down, even heirlooms that had been passed through families for hundreds of years. Our defence would forever be at the mercy of the elves, even if the City was attacked from the outside. But Thranduil would not bend, and in his despair at this humiliation my father walked away from our City and never returned.
“So I was left to lead our people as best I could, and for a while it seemed that my friendship with the king would see the bitterness healed. The City traded its creations far across the world, and wealth poured into all our coffers, and the City grew, new palaces and halls and streets spreading out into the forest. But over the years, the indignities began to grow with it. Rules upon rules, which always claimed to treat all as equals, yet seemed most to constrain the dwarves; rules governing how our children are educated, when we may pass in and out of the gates, even who we may choose to marry. And when the rules are broken, fines are levied that enrich the royal treasury further. And for the direst crimes, the punishment is exile without hope of return or even the solace of a letter from home. For many decades I sat on Thranduil's council and had some say in the decisions of his realm, and sovereignty over the dwarves and their houses; but over time, he began to keep secret councils, and his court was closed to me and my kin, and he no longer heard my petitions. The heart of the City, I believe, has a rot inside it that is spreading; but I do not know where the infection started. I only know that perfumes and glamours can not hide its stench forever."
Bilbo had listened in silence, but here Thorin stopped, and looked into his mug, where his half-drunk coffee had gone cold. Bilbo had finished his cup and put it down gently on the saucer. "So what's my job in all of this? To enter the City and learn - what? You seem to know the king’s mind far better than me, even if you don’t know all of it."
Thorin's gaze lifted to meet his. "No, Mr Baggins. Remember I said that Mithril is the soul of the City, and the City is still growing. But here is my first question, which I’d like you to answer: where is the Mithril coming from?" He tilted his head. "In the beginning, it was gifted by my people, from what they carried or wore as they fled the mountain. That store is long expended, yet small shipments appear whenever the City engineers need them. What Mithril mines are left on this earth? Moria perhaps, but even if Thranduil were willing to trade with goblins, they do not have the skill of extracting the ore. From the East? The few, poor veins of Mithril in that part of the world are drained and what dust is left it dearly fought over by the dwarves in those parts; they would not give it up to an Elven king. But there is one place left where Mithril lies already purified, smelted and shaped: in Erebor, hoarded in heaps, collecting dust. I have long believed that if my folk could return to the mountain, we could use that Mithril to restore it to a splendor beyond even the wildest imagining of my grandfather - for we would bring home all that we have learned and invented with the elves. Erebor filled with light, with fresh water, with heat and the magic needed to grow food underground, no longer dependent on anyone outside our halls. The only small difficulty is the dragon guarding it," he sat forward a little. "But think: no one has seen the dragon for many years. What if Smaug is dead? Or so infirm that he cannot lift a claw to defend his hoard? And what if Thranduil knows this, and this is where he gets his Mithril, secretly building his power upon the stolen treasure of my grandfather? Perhaps in Erebeor he has found himself the stock of Mithril he needs to keep his city in health and wealth as long as he likes, until the last of the Erebor-born dwarves are dead. Is he simply waiting for us to forget we ever had a life beyond the woods, and lose all desire for freedom?" He shook his head. "These were the questions I was asking, quietly and carefully, when I was suddenly accused of theft and threatened with exile. And this is the second question I am asking you to find out for me: is there still a live dragon in Erebor?"
Bilbo waited to be sure Thorin was ready to end the story. He tried to keep his expression neutral, but his heart was beating fast. He had been so ready to retire back to Bag End, but this dwarf - and it didn’t hurt that he really was such a handsome dwarf - had awoken something of his mother’s spirit in him. He’d found his way into castles and barrows and army camps successfully, and satisfied many a happy customer, but he’d never taken on such a quest: to cross half the world to investigate a mountain thought to be guarded by a sleeping dragon.
“It’s a big job, it will be a big fee,” he said, to give himself time to think.
“If you take it on commission and I am right, you will be richly rewarded. If I am wrong and Erebor cannot be reclaimed, I may have a harder time paying you,” Thorin admitted. “I will tell you straight; I have little, only enough saved from honest work on my wandering, which will barely cover your travelling expenses. Beyond that, I have my name and the skills of my hands.”
“And what are they? Can you make your magic Mithril lanterns and so forth?” Bilbo said hopefully.
Thorin smiled, apologetic and teasing both at once. “No. But I can write you a fair and watertight contract.”
Bilbo returned the smile. “Very well. We can set a small base fee if I’m successful, plus a small share of the treasure if your theory proves correct: that way the risk may balance the reward for me, but you won’t be too out of pocket if you’re wrong. I’ll take you on, if you’re willing to act as my guide back to the Mountain,” he stood up and reached across the desk to shake Thorin’s hand. “And I will help you if I can.”
—
It was a clear morning in late autumn, and the trees glowed red from one end of the City to the other. It had been several months since Thorin had walked into the office of Bilbo Baggins, in Bree half a world away. But Fili did not know that; he had not seen his uncle for two and a half years and did not even know if he was alive or dead.
The air was cool despite the warmth that flowed through pipes across the city. Fili sat opposite Dwalin, each nursing a warm mug of mead. They were in a small pub made of beams of wood slotted together without visible groove and curved into arches like the tunnel of a cave mouth, open to the dwarvish street where shoppers, families and craftspeople meandered past. The barkeep laid out clean glasses on the tables at the back. There were no other customers this early in the morning.
“I can’t believe you invited him,” Dwalin rumbled.
“I trust him,” Fili said. “And we need him. With all due respect, you’re one dwarf and you’re used to fighting in caves and mountains. We need someone who can use the trees, and elvish weapons, someone who can teach the younger ones how to really survive in the forest.”
“With all due respect yourself, Fili, the lad thinks he’s half elf. His heart’s turned to wood, not a drop of iron left,” Dwalin shook his head. “If we bring him in, he’ll run straight to his beloved Captain and sell us right up the flue.”
“He won’t,” Fili hissed. “You don’t know what you’re talking about, Dwalin. I know his heart a bloody sight better than you. And even if there was a splinter in it, we’ve reached the limit of what you can teach. You’re rusty,” he said firmly. “And you know it.” He glanced over his shoulder. “Ah, there he is!” Fili whistled. “Hey, Kili! Over here!”
Dwalin gave a last grumble and drank a deep draft as a figure waved at them and strode across the street. He was in a narrow-cut uniform of dark grey-green, with a sword on each hip and his bow slung on his back. His sleek, dark hair was combed into a single braid down his back. He beamed at them and bent to embrace Fili without sitting down. He looked like the perfect young recruit of the City Guard, distinguished from his fellows only by a few feet of height. Fili thought ruefully that he didn’t even smell like a dwarf anymore, he smelled something like a cross between sword oil and fresh baking.
“Hello! So what’s this about? Couldn’t it wait for dinner?” Kili asked. It wasn’t urgency that had kept Fili from discussing this at home; he just didn’t want their mother overhearing anything.
“Sit down and I’ll get you a drink,” Dwalin said in a low voice.
“Oh, no I can’t,” Kili leaned one hand on the back of Fili’s chair. “I’ve just come off the night patrol. I have to check these in at headquarters before I go home,” Kili patted one of the swords at his belt.
“Five minutes,” Fili said, tugging on Kili’s free hand. “Please.”
Kili frowned at him. “Alright, really now, what’s going on?”
Fili glanced at Dwalin. “We need your help with something. Something you can’t tell anyone about.”
Kili drew his head back a little, giving a sly smile. “Something good or something bad?”
“Kili, please just sit down—“
There was a shout down the street, not the bellow of a dwarf but the clear voice of an elf yelling unusually loudly. Kili jerked out of his brother’s grip and stepped away from the open awning of the pub. Legolas, the commander of the City guard, was coming at speed towards him. Two other senior constables followed, trying in vain to look smooth and composed while matching his pace.
The elf prince drew up sharply in front of Kili. There were the faintest blotches on his neck and his brows were deep and wrinkled. “Don’t move. Put your weapons down.”
Kili looked up at him with a visible gulp. “I wasn’t drinking, sir, I swear. I just finished my shift and was heading back—“
“Throw your weapons down,” Legolas intoned, each word drawn out through gritted teeth. Fili had met the elf prince only a handful of times, and usually in a crowd of some kind, and he had never seen him anything less than serenely composed. In fact, Fili didn’t think he’d ever seen any elf so angry, not in his entire life. He looked between Dwalin and Kili, trying to figure out if Dwalin knew what this was about. Dwalin looked as baffled as he felt.
“Of course, yes sir,” Kili said in a rush, unbelting his swords. For a moment he hesitated, and then moved to put them on the table in front of Fili. Legolas barked, “Put them on the ground!”
Kili crouched to put down the swords and his bow, then straightened up, shoulders back and arms at his side.
“Take him into custody,” Legolas said. The two constables stepped forward and one seized each of Kili’s arms.
Fili jumped to his feet and locked his hand over the nearest constable’s, around the place where he was gripping his brother’s arm so tight Fili could feel the dents in Kili’s flesh. “What are you doing? You can’t treat him like this!”
He didn’t keep his voice quiet; there were dwarves up and down the street looking at them now. Everybody on this street knew who Kili was, and most of them would have recognised Legolas on sight. This was outrageous. If Kili had done something wrong, he should have been taken aside in private, by his lieutenant, and given a chance to explain himself. This had to be some kind of deliberate humiliation, and one done to maximise the number of dwarves who would go home and tell their families about it. But Fili was beyond confused about what excuse Legolas could give to relieve Kili of his duties. As far as he was aware - and Kili told him everything, he was sure - his brother was a model officer of the Guard.
Legolas shot him a dark look. “He is to be detained in the palace dungeon until trial. Let him go, or I’ll have you sent down too.”
“Trial for what?” Fili snarled. “For getting above his station?”
Legolas said coldly. “For the murder of Captain Tauriel.”
Fili felt a cold shiver run across the back of his neck. He turned from Legolas to look at Kili. His brother’s cheeks had turned a chalky pale, his eyes wide and all expression wiped from his face. He was staring at Legolas, but he said nothing. He sank a little towards the earth, and if the constables had not been gripping his arms so tightly it seemed certain he would have kept sinking into the dust.
“You do not even deny it?” Legolas said to him.
Kili just continued to stare at him. He didn’t seem to hear Fili saying, loudly for the watching crowd to hear. “It’s not true. He’s done nothing.”
They took Kili away, still silent and putting up no resistance. Fili felt himself reel around, looking first to Dwalin and then to the gathered crowd. He scrubbed his hands down his face. “Tauriel?” he said quietly to Dwalin. “It can’t be. She was at our house after dinner last night, she was perfectly well.”
Kili wasn’t even home when Tauriel had come round. He had been out on patrol since sundown. Tauriel had come to speak with their mother. Fili briefly wondered, could Ma have something to do with this? Dis had no love for Kili’s famous Captain of the Guard, for reasons which she had made clear to both her sons. In fact, it would not be unfair to say that in recent weeks, when she’d learned the truth about Kili and Tauriel, Dis’ dislike of Tauriel might even be described as hatred. But even if Dis had had it in her to commit murder, last night had been different. When Fili got back to the house after dinner and found Tauriel and Ma sitting in the parlour together drinking tea, the two of them were smiling as if they had come to a friendly accord. As far as Fili was aware, Tauriel had left soon after and Ma had gone to bed.
No, this news was nothing to do with anyone in their family, he was immediately and utterly sure. Something had happened to Tauriel after she’d left their house.
“He wasn’t even there,” Fili repeated, again loud enough to make a show of it to the watching street. He put his hand to his brow and let out a long, slow breath. “I’ve got to find Ma.”
“Ay,” Dwalin said, folding his arms. “And watch yourself as you go. He won’t be the first, Fili. It’s happening now, just as Thorin said it would.”
Chapter 2: The Examination
Chapter Text
The morning after he met Thorin, Bilbo packed up a bag, dressed in a set of comfortable clothes and belted his mother’s sword to his side. His mother’s ring was always in his vest pocket, but he checked it twice anyway. He shouldered the pack, locked the office, left the key with the housekeeper with instructions to check it once a week, and walked down to the Prancing Pony.
There were two ponies, and someone else’s tall, white horse tied up to the rail in front of the inn. Thorin was waiting at a table just inside the door. He was in the same clothes as the day before, but somehow still looking clean and uncreased. There were the remains of a small breakfast on the table in front of him, a pack resting on the floor, and the tall shape of a grey-clad wizard sitting beside him.
Bilbo drew back a little. “Gandalf. I did not know you were available to hire.”
Thorin glanced at the wizard sharply, as if expecting him to be offended by this. But Gandalf smiled and held out one arm to welcome Bilbo into a brief embrace. “Not at all, my young Master Baggins,” he chuckled. “I simply happen to be going in the same direction, and thought you might like the extra company on at least part of your journey.”
“What a remarkable coincidence,” Bilbo said knowingly. “And please, ‘Master Baggins’ might have enticed me when I was in my thirties, but I’m far too cynical for that now. It’s Bilbo to you. Have you been busy? Getting other folks into trouble?”
Gandalf grimaced. “Only when they really need it.”
Bilbo laughed, and waved them both towards the door. “Come on. If everyone’s eaten, let’s not waste any more of the day.”
He would never turn down the wizard’s offer of help, but all the same, he couldn’t help being just a little annoyed on two fronts: firstly, he had hoped to impress his new client by being the most experienced adventurer in their party of two, a title with which he could never compete against Gandalf. And second, though he would not have admitted it on pain of death, he had been rather curious about the idea of getting to know Thorin alone. But camping on the road did not lend itself to private conversations. Still, he was probably letting his imagination run away with him. Thorin might well turn out to be terrible company, and it was a long journey to be stuck with a boor or a nitpick.
Gandalf took the lead as they rode out of Bree, not really surprising given his horse at the withers had about four hands height on their ponies. Bilbo took up the rear, but as the road widened in the open countryside, Thorin fell back to ride beside him.
“I did not realise you were so familiar with our mutual wizard,” he said quietly, his eyes on the back of Gandalf’s hat. “I am beginning to feel this arrangement has been somewhat contrived. If you both have some lengthy scheme in mind, I can assure you, I was not lying about being out of pocket. I am not worth extorting."
“If there’s a scheme, I promise it was not cooked up by me,” Bilbo leaned towards him a little and said out the corner of his mouth. “I make no promises about our companion,” he straightened up and smiled. “Gandalf was a dear friend of my mother’s. In her youth she was a well-respected lass, but one day she disappeared from her quiet home in the Shire and ran away to follow the wizard into the wide world. She didn’t tell anyone much about her adventurers, but despite her poor reputation when she returned, my dear, frumpy, old father married her and built her a beautiful home - mostly with the chest of gold she’d brought home with her, I might add. I have fond memories of Gandalf visiting us when I was a child. But he was not there when my father died and we moved to Bree; perhaps he knew by then that my mother could take care of herself. I suppose he must have been keeping an eye on us, in some manner, since you say he recommended me.”
“Do you think we can trust him?” Thorin asked. Bilbo assumed he would ask the same question about Bilbo to Gandalf when he had the chance, and compare answers.
Bilbo nodded. “My mother always did. I can’t say more than that.”
Thorin glanced him up and down. He said, “At least you look like a professional, as promised. Yours is rather more impressive than mine.”
“Sorry?” Bilbo spluttered. Thorin pointed at Bilbo’s hip and then flicked back the tail of his own coat to show the sword at his belt. It was unadorned and the leather at the handle was fraying a little. It looked like something he’d purchased in Bree, second-hand from the local dwarven blacksmith. Bilbo collected himself. “Ah. Yes, this little sword is another legacy of my mother. She named it Sting. It’s elvish, apparently. Perhaps it’s from the City.”
“No, it looks older, and somebody loved making it,” Thorin said. “The swords in the city are made for use and weathering, not to keep for a lifetime.”
“I thought you said there were no weapons in the city?” Bilbo asked. “Or none for dwarves, anyway.”
Thorin looked ahead again, his eyes scanning the distant hills but now with a small smile on his mouth. “I said none except those carried by the city Guard, which had no dwarves at the time the law was made. But there was a single dwarf admitted to the Guard, just these two years past,” he smiled fully at Bilbo now. “Perhaps the first of many - perhaps there are already more, I have been away so long. There is little that dwarves cannot do when they turn their stubbornness on a problem, Mr Baggins.”
“I hope you’re right,” Bilbo answered.
–
It was six months before Thorin left the City, and Kili nocked an arrow.
He took a breath and drew his bow.
The drawn weight of the bow was heavy, to make the distance with the power he’d need to pierce the painted target at the far end of the archery range, but he’d practised this movement so many times it felt no more difficult than raising his arm. It was a beautifully made recurve bow, especially commissioned for him, for this day. He couldn’t manage the elvish longbows used by many of the guards for obvious reasons. The workshop who’d made the bow had presented it to him a few months ago, insisting it was a gift, even though Thorin had ordered it with the full intention of paying for it.
“It was a delight to design something new,” the head crafter said, and winked at Kili. “And hopefully we’ll be making more soon enough, eh, lad?”
The weight of all their expectations; heavier than the draw of the bow, that was for certain.
Far away at the end of the archery range stood two targets. His friend Berior had already finished his shots and was standing aside and slightly behind Kili so as not to distract him. On the other side stood their trainer, an older elf named Telion who had been teaching young archers so long that he even had the wisp of a beard on his chin. Beside him was the judge, who Kili didn’t know, and Prince Legolas stood behind them. As commander of the entire City Guard, the standing army and watch-folk of the Woodland realm, Legolas would of course have an interest in any new recruits. But given the guard consisted of almost two thousand elves, everyone was also well aware that it was unusual for him to actually sit in on the examinations.
Behind Kili, there was a small, raised dais separated from the range by a low railing. Under normal circumstances, a few chairs could be set up here, for friends and family members. Berior had one friend watching, his cousin Haered who had just finished the examinations yesterday and won his place in the Guard with his swordwork. But around Haered were two rows of benches packed in with Kili’s supporters, crammed close to the front to make extra standing room behind. Every inch of space was full of dwarves - and a handful of elves, mostly schoolfriends. His mother, brother and uncle were front and centre, but around them were cousins, neighbours, dwarvish school peers, and a few noble or important dwarves Kili didn’t know that well. Squeezing into any other free spaces were quite a few dwarves Kili didn’t even recognise. All here to see the last of his trials; the test of proficiency with the candidate’s chosen weapon.
No one breathed. They all waited.
It had been Fili’s idea, originally. About two years ago, Thorin had come home silent and seething about something. When Dis had settled him with a glass of wine and Kili had flopped into the armchair across from him and teased him into conversation, he had just muttered. “Delays, delays, delays.” And after some further prompting, “The mason’s guild is trying to send new apprentices for training in the Iron Hills. They are already two weeks late, but the Guard have rescheduled us a third time. It’s starting to feel personal.”
This was the law; no caravan or company may leave the woodland without at least a token guard. It had not been followed to the letter when Kili was young, especially for lone travellers on their own or on personal errands. But for the past few years, there had been orcish bandits on the roads, and the gates of the realm were now strictly controlled. No one may pass without record of their name and business, and an assigned force from the Guard as befitted the value of their party and the goods they carried. But the Guard was kept busy with encroachments from the Misty Mountains and spiders breeding in the hollows of the forest, and it had become increasingly slow and difficult to get the assigned protection. So shipments and travelers were held up, or cancelled entirely.
“Why don’t they train more Guards just for the roads?” Fili said from the corner of the room. He had his nose in some papers; something to do with their mother’s business. “It’s affecting trade, and what bothers trade bothers the king, surely. There must be scores of young dwarves keen for an excuse to stretch their legs and come back with a story about swinging a sword vaguely near a goblin’s neck. Stick a uniform on them and let them babysit the easy routes to the Iron Hills, so the City Guard can get back to their real jobs. Why not?”
Thorin twisted his head around to give him a wry look. “You know why.”
“There’s no law that says a dwarf can’t join the Guard,” Fili countered.
Thorin gave a bitter laugh and drank deep from the wine. “The examinations are set against any dwarf. No one’s tried in decades.”
“They’re not impossible,” Fili insisted, putting the papers down at last. He turned in his seat, resting his elbow on the desk. “I’m sure the last dwarf who tried was probably closer to your age, and went at the trials like a stubborn, stone-bred warrior. But that’s the wrong way to approach it. Someone younger should have a go. Someone born in the forest, who can move and fight and think more like an elf. There’s only one area where they really have an advantage.”
Throin raised his eyebrow. “A bold claim.”
Fili waved his hand “There’s trials of the mind, but anyone who can speak Sindarin and play Three Dwarf Morris can pass those.”
“Well, that’s me out,” said Kili, whose Sindarin was so poor he’d had to repeat his final language exam a year late at school.
“Your accent’s fine, you just can’t spell,” Fili shook his head at him. “Then there’s the trials that a dwarf could pass easily - strength and stamina, that sort of thing. So the only thing that a dwarf actually needs to train for is speed and dexterity. And a weapon - but all the other young applicants would have to do that training too, so young elves have no advantage over dwarves there. I’m not saying it’s easy, but it would only take one of us to make it in, and then there’d be no more excuses. All the young dwarrows in the City would sign up for the next round of recruiting.”
Thorin took another small sip of his wine. “Are you volunteering?”
“Yes,” Fili said. “As I said, why not? We’re Thror’s line, we should be leading the way. When’s the next recruitment?”
“Two years from now.” The Guard put out a call for new recruits about every three years, and took only a handful of new recruits each time. Despite the spreading shadows in this part of the world, deaths even in the Guard were extremely rare, and most attrition was simply due to resignations or, occasionally, dismissals for repeatedly drinking on duty.
“Plenty of time to train,” said Fili. He looked at his brother. “Kili?”
“Yes! Let’s do it,” Kili thumped his fist on his knee. “Even if we end up on our arses it’ll be good for a laugh.”
He had meant that, when he’d said it. They’d almost certainly fail, but signing up for the Guard examinations was going to be a bit of entertainment in their otherwise peaceful lives. And it would get the attention of the dams his age, which didn’t hurt either.
And now, two years later, and all that training, all that work, and all those people behind him, watching him. One more arrow and it would be over.
The examinations were essentially competitive; there were usually ten to twenty applicants, and only the five best were chosen according to a balance of many skills. They took place over a single week in midsummer, with candidates required to excel in at least one field. They would be dropped from further trials if they performed particularly badly in any individual test. There were trials of memory, speech and language, which Fili had passed easily and which Kili had, well, scraped through. Then the tests were mostly physical. Speed and agility had been the hardest, of course; and despite all their training Fili had lost out at that early stage. Kili had gotten lucky; he had passed only because he wasn’t in the bottom two, and that was only because he’d beaten Fili and one elf, who had tripped in a squirrel-hole in the forest and turned his ankle badly. But after that came tests of strength, endurance, and tactics, and suddenly Kili had found himself in the top half of the pack or better each time. The field of candidates dwindled around him and he was still in the running. Four of the other young elves had now been offered a place, as they’d shown their skills in the sword or the lance. He and Berior, who’d been training together under Telion, were the only two who’d chosen the bow, so they were the last two in the running. Only one of them would be in that list of five; and there was only one more arrow.
Kili really hadn’t expected to get this far, but now he was here, he had never wanted anything more in his life.
It wasn’t about guarding caravans to the Iron Hills anymore. It wasn’t about impressing dams. It wasn’t even about making Thorin and Ma proud. It was about something unnameable, not just for him, but for all of them. That swelling, haunting shadow of the City that had been there for Kili’s entire life until he wasn’t sure if it had really grown, or if he’d just learned to see it more clearly.
It worked like this: at the beginning, when the people of Erebor had made an accord with the Woodland realm, they had had different laws and different ideas about how a person should live, of course they had. So in trying to find some common ground, Thror and Thranduil had distilled it down to one key principle: each race could govern themselves within their own spheres of influence as they liked, but over this the city would have a common law under which all were equal. Nothing would be written, or set into precedent, in which the word ‘elf’ or ‘dwarf’ could appear.
That had been well over a century ago, long before Kili was born. But at some point, when he and Fili were old enough to ask difficult questions, Thorin explained how it really worked. The gates of the City and the roads in and out of the forest were a good example. Everyone had to state their business and be accompanied by a guard when they left the City. That sounded sensible on paper; everyone was equally protected. But the guards were limited - who got priority, who was delayed or refused an escort? That was up to the whims of whoever happened to be in charge on the day. And who was in charge? The city Guard, who were all elves. So somehow, without it being law, elves could come and go as they pleased from the city and dwarves suffered - as Thorin had complained - ‘delays, delays, delays’, until it was hardly worth doing the paperwork.
There were other examples; in these days of plenty and fertility for both races, all children had to be educated by trained teachers, and educated together for the benefit and fellowship of both. But the guild of teachers required many years working as governors or tutors, and referees of good standing to vouch for their skill in these roles. This became such a long and onerous process to qualify that there were almost no dwarvish teachers in the city’s schools, and those that were tended to be old. They retired within a few decades, while their elvish colleagues stayed at their posts. So although plenty of elvish teachers had the best of intentions, almost none spoke Khuzdul, or knew more than the bare bones of dwarvish history. So Fili and Kili had grown up beside their elvish friends learning to spell in Sindarin and the common tongue but barely able to understand the language of their grandparents’ generation, nor able to name more than the first few kings of the Longbeards - even they, the descendants of those same kings.
And then another example was intermarriage; there was an old law in the Woodland realm, benignly accepted for many thousands of years, that if any youth wished to marry before two hundred years old, if their future spouse was many years their senior, then they must wait until their third century before they wed or dwelled together. It was a law made to protect rash young elves from any subtle predation by their elders. Yet it excluded almost every pairing of dwarves and elves who had sought an exception over the years, else it cruelly forced them to wait until the dwarvish half of the couple’s life was mostly gone. Thorin himself, though he clearly found such private matters uncomfortable to talk about, had even petitioned Thranduil to have the law rewritten to specify that it only applied to elvish couples - but that golden rule was held sacrosanct: all were equal. There could be no law in which the word ‘elf’ or ‘dwarf’ could appear. So the law was still applied equally to all, and only a tiny handful of dwarf-elf couples had ever managed to skirt it.
When Kili had once complained about this to an elvish friend, they had been surprised. For elves truly in love, sharing a bed by choice was sufficient to make them married, so what did it matter if there was a sanctioned ceremony? Your fëa knew you were married. If your elders didn’t approve, that was their problem. It had been so hard for Kili to explain that it did matter. That dwarves didn’t really believe marriage was about your spirits uniting and all that warm and cuddly poetry. And yes, of course, dwarves had trysts before marriage, if they could get away with it without their parents finding out. But that didn’t make you married. It was important to have the ceremony, it had to be public and recognised by at least your family and your priests. You would never be seen as united in dwarvish society without it: you would always just be two people messing around.
These differences came into sharp contrast even when it came to the punishment for breaking the laws. Imprisonment was a rare consequence in the Woodland realm, save for the safety of a criminal or their victim. The usual method of sanction was a fine or the loss of titles and privileges. Thorin had given an example to his young nephews of how this worked in practise: “There was an elf and a dwarf, each in their prime, both from noble families, who were neighbours. The dwarf had been given a fine house by his father, and some money to start a business, which was in good order; and the elf lived in a small hall built by some distant ancestor, and had guardianship over an orchard in the forest, which he tended and traded the fruits of, as his mother and grandfather had done before him. These two became friends, and oft went hunting together. There was another neighbour across the way that they came to dislike, because of some petty grudge, and one day the friends got to drinking, and talking of this neighbour, and the fools talked themselves into waylaying him on his way home and roughing him up. He escaped with some injuries, and once they were sober they both admitted to the brutality and showed remorse. The magistrate declared each must relinquish half of their personal wealth, some of which went to the victim and some to the crown’s coffers. The dwarf had to sell his house, and his business was ruined. Unable to support his family, whom he loved more than his own life, his wife and sons went to live with his in-laws. And in despair he came to worse griefs later of his own making. And could anyone say he did not deserve it? No. He did a terrible thing.
“But his friend the elf, what did he give up? His house belonged to his family, and the orchard that was his livelihood was a place in the forest he cared for, not an encircled garden that the law said he owned. The wood elves keep their lands and homes collectively, by lineage or fellowship, or they do not keep them at all but manage them in harmony with nature. They do not use coins between their own kind, they barter or they lend, for they have long lives and memories. They can gift their creations and skills freely in the expectation something else will be given to them in turn, with time or need. So in the eyes of the law they are not wealthy, and little wealth can be taken from them. And this elf had to give up only some small possessions, and a little money, not much more than would buy a plain set of boots. The same crime, the same cause, and all treated equally, yet two very different punishments. Is this the justice of the law?”
Thorin gave the children a moment to ask questions, or voice their stark opinion, as children like to do. But after this lesson Fili and Kili had been very quiet, and only discussed it later between themselves, as if they already sensed this open secret was not to be shouted about in the street. And unbeknownst to Thorin, they both had a memory together, which they compared and found their memories resembled each other close enough that they must be real: several years earlier, when they had been just wee bairns, they had been playing with some other children on the roots of a great oak taller than the houses. As they sat aside to compare bruises from the game, an elf in an emerald cloak appeared as if out of thin air.
“Hello,” he said.
“Hello,” said Kili.
“Do you remember me?” The elf asked, crouching down to look at them. Fili shook his head. “I’m your Uncle Delos. I’ve known you since you were born. You’ve grown so much!” When the children didn’t answer, he reached into his bag. “Would you like some pears? They’re from my orchard, there’s none better in the woodland realm.”
“Thank you,” they both said politely, but as they bit into the sweet flesh, they heard their mother shouting.
She came at a run, her skirts hitched up, and grabbed them both by their hands. “Stay away from us, Delos.”
“Forgive me, Dis,” the elf said, taking a step back and wringing his hands. “I just wanted to see how they are. I miss them.”
“Don’t come near them again. You’ve ruined our lives.” Dis dragged them away and told them never to speak to the elf again.
Later, Kili asked Fili who the elf was. Fili shrugged. “Maybe he was a pervert.”
“What’s a pervert?”
“Ma says elves who chase after dwarves are perverts. But she doesn’t say it in front of Thorin, so it must be a bad word.”
That sounded terrifying. For some years afterwards, Kili assumed there were elves who hunted dwarves for sport. It was only later, after Thorin’s story, that they put it all together, who Delos was, who the story was really about, of the two friends who were punished by the law. And Kili couldn’t bring himself to be angry at Delos. He had looked so sad when he had told Dis, ‘I miss them’. He hadn’t lost gold or his house, maybe, but the disharmony of the law had taken something he dearly loved from him. They never saw Delos again, or if they did pass on the street, Fili and Kili had grown so much that they forgot Delos’ face and he did not recognise them.
All this, three years of training, all those memories, this history, these laws, these two races entwined within a single city, was wrapped up and squeezed into the moment that Kili drew back the string of the bow, and released.
The arrow flew as true as he’d ever shot. He knew before it had even struck the target. He lowered the bow and stood breathing out slow, even breaths to keep his heart from bursting as the judge walked the length of the range, carrying the flag he would use to indicate the winner. Behind him, Kili could hear the crowd murmuring, some of the dwarves asking the elves in the stands, “I can’t see from here. Can you see?”
The judge’s keen eyes took little time to inspect the two targets, each with three arrows from their three shots. In a moment, too long and yet too quick for Kili to prepare himself, he raised his flag towards Kili’s target.
There was an instant, convulsive roar of joy from the crowd. Kili turned to see the dais nearly buckling under the sudden leaps and stamps. Dwarves were hugging each other, and some were even hugging the elves beside them. Fili was punching the air over and over, and Thorin was on his feet and thumping the railing, bellowing, “Yes, Kili! Yes, you splendid lad! Baruk Khazâd!” Even his dour mother was smiling and raising her arms above her head to clap.
Kili realised he was grinning wide enough to make his cheeks ache, and that his eyes were overflowing. He wiped them quickly as Berior approached, his hand outstretched. “Well done. I’m so glad for you.”
“Well done yourself,” Kili shook his hand. “I hope there’s no hard feelings.”
“Of course not,” Berior gave a small bow. “I’ll apply again in three years. Plenty of time to keep training until I catch up with you.”
Kili turned to the judge, who was speaking with Prince Legolas. Their heads were bent together to hear each other above the noise of the crowd. The judge’s brow was furrowed, and he was shaking his head at something the prince had apparently asked. Telion stepped close to listen and he began to frown as well. Kili felt his knees beginning to shudder a little and the smile fade from his face. After a moment, the crowd sensed the disruption and the cheering died rapidly to whispers and mutters.
Telion waved his hand at Kili. “Well, please, my lord, explain it to him. Because I’m not sure I understand.”
Legolas looked as flustered as a prince of the woodland realm was permitted to look. He cleared his throat, and then said loud enough for all to hear. “I must confer with my father. The king should have the final confirmation.”
“Why?” Telion argued. “Do you not approve of my training? You are the commander of the Guard; it is in your purview to approve the candidates.”
Legolas shot him a swift glare. “This situation is irregular.”
Berior practically leapt into the cluster. “No, it’s not! I lost. He won. He’s the fifth recruit.”
The crowd had gone very silent. Kili looked at them and saw Thorin leaning forward over the railing, as if he was about to vault over it and bring his authority into the fight. Dis grabbed his shoulder and gripped it tight. She knew what Kili knew; there could be no question over his candidacy, no accusations of nepotism. Kili looked back at Prince Legolas. He couldn’t bring himself to plead out loud, but he felt his face begging for understanding. From one prince to another.
Telion folded his arms and muttered, soft enough that Kili just made it out. “Your highness, you will start a riot. Don’t delay this.”
Legolas nodded. He strode forward and put his hand out. “Congratulations. Welcome to the Guard.”
Kili took the hand with a weak smile. “Thank you, commander,” he tried to say, but his voice was drowned out by another explosion of cheering from behind him.
Chapter 3: The Road to the Fey King
Chapter Text
The days passed slowly on the road, especially at the beginning when the hills and woods all looked the same after the first hour of trees and more trees. Then when Bilbo lay down to sleep, the time would pass too quickly, and soon enough he would be woken by the sun and the sound of Gandalf humming as he fed and tended the mounts. But in between, there was breakfast time and supper and when he could, Bilbo cooked up a second supper at dusk, and that meant there was time to sit and enjoy each other’s company. Gandalf was as good-humoured and full of interesting songs and stories as Bilbo remembered from his childhood in the Shire. These days Bilbo had plenty of stories of his own, of course, and was not afraid to boast, especially in front of a client.
Thorin seemed content to let them parry and posture. After that first long tale in the office, and the brief mention of his family on the first day, he mentioned little of himself or his home. He would sometimes speak in a voice of wonder about his journey to and from the Blue Mountains. But he seemed somewhat apart from Bilbo and Gandalf, as if his thoughts were only ever half in their current location, wherever that happened to be.
At the beginning, Bilbo had asked him about the City and his life there, but his answers were short and factual, the sort of thing you might read in a book. Perhaps a civil engineer’s guide, even. This was particularly frustrating for Bilbo, whose trade was at least half in the stories he could learn from people, and what they revealed about the ways into a place - both in the form of secret tunnels but also gaps in the social boundaries; who might accept a bribe, who was allied with who, who could be played off each other with subtle jibes. Thorin’s plan seemed to be to focus on the Lonely Mountain as Bilbo’s first point of call, but Bilbo was very determined that it would be his last stop in solving his client’s mysteries. He did not plan to enter the mountain if the dragon could be studied from a distance instead. But trying to get any interesting information out of Thorin seemed as productive as trying to squeeze gold out of a rock with his bare hands.
They had passed through the Trollshaws without incident and in the distance, the misty mountains were rising above their faces, growing closer each day. Gandalf and Thorin seemed to have decided on a route together and Bilbo could only trust their confidence.
As the road grew rougher, Thorin kept himself remarkably clean and tidy, combing and rebraiding his hair each morning and trimming his beard almost daily, using a small polished glass and scissors wrapped together in a small leather wallet. One morning, they camped close to a small, clear stream. While he ate breakfast, Bilbo was able to watch Thorin’s morning rituals without looking like he was spying.
“You said your grandfather was the King Under the Mountain,” Bilbo said, as Thorin put his mirror away. “Is that why it’s so important that you… well, how do I put it? That you look your best, even though we’re in the middle of nowhere and Gandalf and I are covered in road dust?”
Thorin had just washed his hands off in the stream and he shook the drops off as he stood up. He didn’t answer for a moment, and Bilbo wondered if he was offended, but it seemed he was just thinking because he said at last, “No. It must be something about the Woodland City that has driven it into me, like a fencepost. Everything there is about maintaining the mask. But no, in Erebor I had servants to dress me, even when I was plenty old enough to dress myself,” he gave a bright, deep laugh like it was an unthinkable idea now. “Many of the older dwarves I know can plait their hair and beards into forms as elaborate as lace, but do you know, I never learned more than the simplest braids? I always had someone else to do them for me. That’s what I get for being born with a silver hammer in my hand.”
It was more than he’d said on any personal topic since their journey had begun some weeks earlier. Bilbo thought about his sudden loquaciousness all that morning, and he came to the realisation like a slow but inevitable turn of a clock: it was because Thorin had started talking about Erebor. A time before the dragon came, before the City even existed. As they took the ponies up a winding sheep-path through the foothills, he asked Thorin. “So, when you lived in the mountain, did you actually live in the mountain, or did you have nice holes like us hobbits, and just dig up gems there?”
“Holes!” Thorin cried, and for a moment Bilbo thought his jibe had gone too far, but then the dwarf grinned at him. “No offense to whatever you call a ‘nice hole’ Mr Baggins, but Erebor was far more than a gem-mine. I wager the front hall alone would be large enough for all of Bree to squeeze inside. Beyond that lay a city of a thousand homes, streets of the finest workshops in the dwarven world, and above it all the great palace built by my grandfather, every angle of its columns and lintels as beautiful and precise as the movements of the stars. The Woodland City is large, but it is an overgrown back-garden compared to the beauties of Erebor.”
He went on like this for not a short while. It was more than he’d said in one go since the entire journey had started.
Bilbo felt extremely self-satisfied that he had finally cracked this small but tricky puzzle. In between his lyrical musings on childhood memories of his grandfather and all the kings and courtiers who had come to visit them and see the wonders of the Mountain, Bilbo gleaned quite a lot about not just Erebor, but Thorin’s life in the Woodland realm since the dragon came. Reading between the lines, it sounded like something of a tinderbox sitting inside the veneer of a utopia. And there was more to learn, he was sure, that Thorin was not telling.
–
They crossed a pass through the Misty Mountains in good weather, mostly having to walk uphill for two days, leading the ponies, as the path was too narrow and rough to ride. At last they reached the apex of the pass. There, a wide saddle of wind-blown, green-grey tussock made a nice pasture for the ponies, and they were able to sit down low out of the wind and have some lunch. Nearby was a brown tarn of brackish snow-melt that buzzed with dragonflies. Though Gandalf insisted this was the highest point of their journey, it looked to Bilbo like the mountains ahead still went on forever in every direction that he looked.
“Is this the way you and my mother went, on her great adventure?” Bilbo asked Gandalf.
Gandalf chuckled. “Oh, we never made it so far. We were caught by goblins halfway up the mountain, with our companions, and through various turns of luck both ill and good, Bella and I made it through their tunnels to the far side and came out further north, near what they called the Carrock.”
“Companions?” Bilbo sat up a little. “It wasn’t just the two of you?”
“No, there were five of us.”
“Well, who were the others? What happened to them? Mother never mentioned anyone except for you.”
Gandalf was quiet for a moment, then he said. “Their luck was all ill and no good. They never made it out of those tunnels.” Gandalf tapped at his pipe, which seemed to have gone out due to the wind. “Bella and I went on together for a year, to give the news to their kin and return by the far south through the Gap of Rohan. We got ourselves into many more scrapes along the way, and often getting out of them only by Bella’s quick thinking and light footsteps. I think your mother might have gone on adventuring for the rest of her days, but the loss of our companions in these mountains was a wound that never really healed. She was always looking for someone, someone who she could only see in her imagination after that, and in the end I suppose she went back to the Shire to find them. And a good thing for you, or she’d never have met your father!”
Bilbo took a moment to process this. Although Bella had told him various fairytales, woven into the barest hints of her time outside the Shire, she had never given him the full picture nor written any of it down. It was lost with her when she passed, and part of him felt a little like he was betraying her by letting Gandalf reveal her secrets. At last he said, “I don’t think my father was her great love story, though they got along well enough.”
“She seemed very happy, when I visited,” Gandalf said.
“She was happy to see you, you daft old wizard,” Bilbo laughed. “But I do wonder if she married my father in the hopes that her children would turn out more like him than like her. Homebodies in Hobbiton.”
“Ah, a fool’s errand, trying to shape young ones,” Gandalf said. He’d got the pipe alight now and tried to blow a smoke ring, but the wind tossed it away into nothing before it had even formed.
They still had to walk and lead the ponies, but now at least the way was mostly downhill. At last, the peaks parted and into view came the flatlands east of the mountains and beyond that, a great, dark fur of woodland that seemed to go on and on forever like an ocean.
As their path converged with a more visible, well-kept road that led east, Gandalf made the sudden announcement that he would be leaving them. Bilbo attempted a weak protest, though he knew he had no say in the matter.
“I always said I would keep you company while we were heading in the same direction, but now my business is to the north.” He glanced at Thorin. “Are you still planning to take the Old Forest Road? You are not in a hurry, as your dragon is either alive or dead and a few weeks won’t change that. You could still make your way south, take the Woodmen’s paths through the narrow forest neck and find passage on a boat up the Celduin.”
“I don’t fancy spending winter out of doors. The Old Road has been kept clear and passable by all accounts,” Thorin said. “And I’ve never heard of spiders setting their ambushes directly on the road.”
“I was not worried about spiders,” Gandalf narrowed his eyes. “The Woodland Traders were thick on that road last time I went that way, along with the City’s Guard. Do you think none of them will know your face?”
Thorin shrugged. “I’ll keep my hood up when we meet company. Besides, Mr Baggins will do the talking, won’t you?” He slapped Bilbo on the back, almost knocking him over.
Bilbo recovered his breath and nodded. “I’ll play the part of the eccentric Hobbit tourist, travelling with my brooding dwarvish bodyguard. No one will look twice at Thorin.”
Gandalf laughed. “A part you were born to play.”
“Watch that cheek, it’ll get you into trouble one day,” Bilbo held out his hand. “May we meet again soon, Gandalf.”
Gandalf shook his hand and climbed back onto his fine horse with far too much grace for the form of an old man.
“Farewell. And do let me know what you find. I would very much like to know what has become of Smaug the terrible,” Gandalf said, turning his horse. “Farewell again!”
Thorin and Bilbo watched him canter off across the grassland, and then mounted their own ponies and headed towards the distant forest. It was hidden by the foothills now, but Thorin seemed confident about their direction.
“So, perhaps I should have asked earlier, how are we actually planning to get into the mountain?” Bilbo asked. “I’m assuming we can’t knock on the front door.”
“I believe there is another way in.”
“A secret tunnel?” Bilbo asked. “I like the sound of that.”
“That’s the plan. My father told us about it, before he left the Woodland,” Thorin glanced around as if to make absolutely sure there were no spy in the empty grasslands. “This was after the disastrous attempt to retake Moria, and Thranduil’s backlash against weapons within the city. My father was trying to find a way to restore the dwarves to strength as he saw it, and he thought reclaiming Erebor was one way to do that. He showed us a map and a key that my grandfather had given to him, which Thror had used to escape the dragon’s wrath the day he destroyed our home. My father planned to leave the map with us, and go to the mountain with the key to see if the secret entrance was still open and if the way was safe. But he left that night without even a farewell, and we never saw him again.”
“So you have the map?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin shook his head. “We had something of a disagreement before he left. In the end, he took it with him. Perhaps he feared the risk if someone outside our family discovered it. Perhaps he…” Thorin’s head sank a little. “Perhaps he did not trust me with it. He knew that Thranduil held me in his confidence, in those days. My father may have believed I would betray our people and hand Thranduil the secrets to our home and our riches. Who knows? It was a difficult time for all of us. He had lost a father and a son, and the burden of kingship weighed heavy on him. Even moreso because we had no kingdom.”
“So he passed the burden to you,” Bilbo said softly. “Though you’d lost just as much.”
“I didn’t know his mind, at the end,” Thorin said. “I went looking for him, after I exiled myself, but no one had news of him. Perhaps he found the secret door. Perhaps he didn’t. But it does exist,” Thorin looked at Bilbo. “And I memorised that map well enough. We’ll find it, and if my father has gone ahead of us and opened the door, then maybe you’ll have a chance to earn your fee, Mister Baggins.”
–
Thorin had been quiet as he listened to Bilbo and Gandalf banter about Bilbo’s mother during their lunch. He tried to remember what it was to be so young you could still be easily shaped by the world. Before Smaug came to the mountain, he supposed, and the fire set him hard, glazed his colours, like clay in a kiln.
He had made his first visit to the Woodland perhaps four or five years before Erebor fell. A diplomatic trip, with a mind to further contracts for gem-setting and metalworking. Balin was supposed to be the king’s representative on the trip, but right at the final hour he had gotten sick, and Thorin had asked his grandfather if he could take Balin’s place. His first chance to be a prince beyond the boundaries of Thror’s realm. The first time Thror really put his trust in him.
Thror agreed. Thorin could see Dwalin was outrageously jealous, as he’d been sure he’d be picked; but Dwalin was not a diplomat, even then. Balin had been too indisposed to give Thorin any guidance, but Oin was part of the group, and as they rode out of the mountain he’d leaned over and said quietly. “Watch yourself. The wood elves aren’t like those delicate folks from the West that came through here last winter. They look skinny and pretty, but they’re wild once there’s food and wine on the table.”
Thorin could not imagine any creature that could out-drink Oin, so he was sure this was merely an exaggerated warning that he should not embarrass himself on his first serious outing from the Mountain.
The Woodland was as different from home as a trip to the bottom of the ocean. Though there was a great palace surrounded by a hodgepodge of rough halls and treetop homes, Thorin was told that these were only used during bad weather or the extremely rare incursion of enemies into the forest. Although it was mid autumn, nothing was indoors, not the summit or the private meetings with the trade ministers. Even their guest quarters were temporary structures of wicker and woven creepers and grasses, built from the detritus of the clearing season, for the elves explained that they wasted nothing if a use could be found for it. Besides, there was no way to get rid of waste except by burning, which they abhorred.
The elves spoke in a mix of languages, all the time, thoughtlessly and - it seemed to Thorin, when he could understand them, for his Sindarin was very basic - often rather mockingly. But he soon realised they spoke to each other like that as well as to the dwarves, even elves who seemed to be dear friends. They even spoke up teasingly to their elders. There did not seem to be much of a social hierarchy, or if there was, it was not much respected.
The boring parts of the trip had gone well, and Oin had slapped him on the back as they headed to their ‘bedrooms’ to refresh themselves before the feast. “I will tell your grandfather how you spoke well, my prince,” he beamed at Thorin. “Now we can let ourselves relax a little.”
The festivities, like everything else, were outside. They were held in a huge clearing surrounded by towering trees, strung with lights of many colours. The air was filled with some kind of dark-winged moth that clustered around the lights and whose huge wings cast shadows across the tables and guests, enhancing the sense that they were feasting on the bed of a rushing river. Music filled the air, not from a corralled orchestra up on a balcony, as it would be at a dwarven feast. Instead, individual musicians roamed around the clearing space, so that even when sitting still Thorin found himself treated to first a rather saucy love song, than a tragic crooning battle hymn, then a jaunty jig, all before he’d finished his first course.
The party of dwarven envoys had been seated at a low table near the centre of the gathering, and were attended by what Thorin guessed were the most mild-mannered and polite of the Woodland diplomats and servants. Thorin tried to nurse his flagon and listen more than he spoke. But at some point the king’s golden son, Legolas, appeared at his elbow and said, “Come to our table, Prince Thorin, go on. Leave your elders and betters.”
Thorin glanced quickly at Oin, who raised his eyebrows at him as he took a deep draught of his flagon. Thorin felt like it would be rude to refuse, but he was determined to keep both his head and his manners. He let Legolas lead him to the high table, though it was distinguished from those around it only by the particular density of wood elves dancing and singing nearby. The king sat on a chair no larger than his subjects, dressed in flowing silver and crowned in autumn leaves. Thorin bowed to him, and did his best to give a formal introduction of himself, and speak honour towards his host. Thranduil stood and poured wine and served it to Thorin, asking him to join for the evening. So of course, he couldn’t refuse to drink.
He’d been so young that night: old enough to be a captain in his grandfather’s guard but not technically of age, not old enough to marry. He was giddy with the foreignness of it all. And as the evening wore on, he found the wood elves were so much fun. He never went back to the dwarven envoy.
He spent the night at the king’s table, and later, dancing in the woods as the party spread into the forest like a splash of wine on cloth. Somewhere among the colourful lights and the laughing elves, he remembered sitting in the grass and talking to their king, answering question after question about wine, and music, and beards, and boots, and politics, and about the differences between the wood and the mountain, and why art was beautiful in one place but would look ugly on the walls of a different home; the sort of things you talk about lying in the grass, drunk, with a king - or so Thorin assumed. He couldn’t remember if at the time, he’d thought this was just how all diplomatic missions were supposed to go. He didn’t remember at what point he left the gathering. He awoke in his own bed in the wicker-and-grass guesthouse with the worst headache of his life.
He went back to Erebor, and if the object of the mission had been to cement friendship between their kingdoms, it seemed to have been a great success. Twice, Thranduil came himself to see the halls under the Lonely Mountain, and two or three times, Thorin and an entourage were sent back to foster the Woodland’s acquaintance into a true alliance with signed treaties and royal gifts exchanged to symbolise their union. And later, he was able to smooth over the spat over the necklace of white gems. Thror’s sickness was already creeping through his mind in those days, and it might have gotten very ugly, but Thorin spent hours talking him around.
“We may need the elves,” Thorin told his grandfather. “We cannot throw away their friendship because of a petty argument over an invoice.”
“Why would we need them?” Thror growled. “The world is at peace. And if it were not, nothing can harm us, behind these walls. Why would we need a gaggle of prancing twig-fondlers who can’t build a wall straight or lift a war-hammer to save themselves?”
“Did you build Erebor alone?” Thorin replied. “Did you carve every tunnel with your own hands, set each stone in each mosaic from your own design? None of us creates good things alone, grandfather.”
In the end, Thror relented, and gave Thranduil the gems he wanted for the agreed price. And when the dragon came, Thorin wanted to believe that Thranduil would have helped them and welcomed them no matter what. But it was true to say that when the refugees arrived in the Woodland and Thranduil arranged the first council of two kings, he listened to Thror, and he listened to Thrain, all without comment, and then he turned and said, “And Prince Thorin, what do you think?”
There was no doubt that he saw Thorin as more reasonable than his grandfather, and that he wanted Thror to know it.
As it became clear that the mountain would not easily be reclaimed, and that they would rely on the elves for their survival, no one had complained about the influence Thorin had with Thranduil. It was seen only as an advantage in those days. Thror and Thrain used Thorin’s friendship with the king to their own ends. They would act bullish and stubborn in any negotiations, and then send Thorin in afterwards, or simply stand back and let him step into the conversation right there in the room, to walk the middle ground that their pride would not let them tread on. Though the dwarves called Thror their king, even the oldest folks checked with Thorin before they made any petition to Thranduil, and asked him first to advise before any dealings with the elves, and went to him if they had grievances. He was the power behind his grandfather’s diminished throne, and they all knew it.
So it went for years, and years, the hard years and the difficult years as the City laboured to be born out of conflict and destitution.
After his grandfather died, after weapons were forbidden in the City, Thrain was named King Under the Mountain by the remnants of the Erebor council. But the elves did not use the title, and Thranduil did not acknowledge it in his court. That was when Thrain began to talk to Thorin and Dis about reclaiming the Mountain. Thorin tried to discourage him; to go in there alone was a vanity, a wasted and suicidal attempt at glory. But Thrain would not be dissuaded.
“I’m not ready to lead our people without you,” Thorin begged him. They sat in front of the fire in a home more humble than the simplest artisan in Erebor had owned. He reached out, across the table where the map of the secret door lay, and touched his father’s hand. “If you won’t stay for me, stay for Dis. She’s still a child.”
“Maybe I should stay for Dis,” Thrain said bitterly. “Maybe I should stay until her naming ceremony, and then declare Dis my heir when I leave. She would be a good queen.”
Thorin withdrew his hand sharply. “What have I done to offend you, father?”
Thrain looked at him with his scarred, single-eyed gaze. “I love you, my son. But your proclivities with the elven king are a danger to all of us.”
“What are you talking about?” Thorin snarled. “I have never acted against you. I have never so much as spoken a word in his presence without thinking first of the welfare of our people.”
Thrain nodded. “I know. Yet still you believe you can bend him to your will, with sweet words, by wearing the clothes he offers like courting gifts, by giving him your companionship at his feasts. He has always been the one holding the reins, Thorin. You will see that soon.”
“Your prejudices blind you,” Thorin countered. “We are allies, nothing more. We are already laying the foundations for a kingdom greater than the sum of our two realms. For our children, and their children.”
“Your children?” Thrain asked. “You know you will have no children, my dear son. I care not, your grandfather cared not. But do not, in your barrenness, in your kingly beneficence, lay claim to all of Erebor’s children and give their care over to Thranduil. He will never love them as I love you and Dis, as I loved your brother.”
The next morning, Thrain had gone, and so had the map and the key.
Chapter 4: Keeping Warm
Chapter Text
The first night without Gandalf was uneventful. The moon was not due to rise until late in the night and the clouds were thick over the stars, and it did not take long for the darkness to become too oppressive to sit up around the fire much longer. They settled down wrapped in their blankets, as close to the flames as possible, for the night air was becoming very chilly as summer turned in fits and starts into autumn.
Bilbo awoke with his toes and nose prickling from the cold. He raised his head a little, wondering if it was worth banking up the fire. But there were only a few thin sticks left in their foraged pile of deadwood, and he did not fancy rummaging for more in the pitch black. He sighed and lay on his side, trying to curl into himself. But it was no good, the chill kept sneaking around the edges of his blanket every time he twitched.
There was one other source of heat nearby. Bilbo raised his head a little and listened to Thorin’s breathing. It was slow and heavy. The dwarf lay on his back, his arms lying loosely across the chest. Bilbo got up, crouched low and tried to employ all his hobbitish skills in stealth as he crept up close and laid his blanket down so that it slightly overlapped Thorin’s. Then he wriggled in towards Thorin’s arm until he could benefit from the heat that was practically rolling off the dwarf. Bilbo usually woke first, and was sure Thorin would never know he’d been here.
He was just drifting off when there was a sound somewhere, not so close but not so far away either. Bilbo in a state of near-unconsciousness did not process it, but Thorin came awake like he’d been struck by lightning and sat up, jostling Bilbo aside. In the faintest light of the dying fire, his hand was on his sheathed sword and his head was turning like an owl’s searching for the direction of the sound.
“Did you hear that?”
“It was probably a deer,” Bilbo rubbed his eyes.
“It sounded like someone moving in the grass,” Thorin hissed. The camp was in a shallow bowl in the midst of the tundra, and despite the darkness, Bilbo could just make out the shapes of the surrounding landscape against the clouded sky. He was sure if there had been a person, they would have seen them silhouetted against the ridge.
Thorin slowly relaxed back onto his elbows, though he didn’t yet take his hand off his sword. “We should have set a watch.”
“Let’s do it tomorrow,” Bilbo yawned, trying to get comfortable again.
Thorin looked down at where Bilbo was lying beside him. After a moment, he lay down as well, curling on his side with his hand around his sword. Nevertheless, he shuffled slightly backwards so that the now-sleeping Bilbo was close enough to share his warmth.
–
The next day started with a clear sky and a pleasant breeze, and they were both in good spirits as they packed up breakfast and saddled the ponies. By mid-afternoon they had reached the banks of the upper Anduin, following an ancient, dirt road so well-trodden it had sunk into the grassland like a collapsed grave. At the end of the road, they met the ford at the river, where the Anduin spread wide across the floodplains and braided between stony sandbanks. They climbed off the ponies and went to look at the depth of the water. In summer it would be passable by wading, even for Bilbo, but there must have been rain somewhere in the far north, because there were deep, fast-flowing patches between the islets that would come up to Bilbo’s waist. He was very sure that he couldn’t keep his footing even in that flat, relatively sedate waterway, and he frankly didn’t feel like getting soaked up to his vest anyway.
“The ponies can wade it,” Thorin said. “You ride, I’ll put the bags on the other and lead them across.”
“Are you sure it’s not too deep for you over there?” Bilbo asked, pointing to the widest part of the river.
“Dwarves have a heavy tread, and I can swim a few yards if I have to,” Thorin insisted. He stripped off his heavy coat and boots, and strapped them onto the saddlebags of his pony. Bilbo tied his own pack on top of Thorin’s saddle. He was just about to climb up onto his own pony when he heard Thorin mutter, “Kakhuf inbarathrag.”
Bilbo followed his gaze. Five men were stalking towards them through the grass, apparently having managed to creep close at a crouch in the tall tussocks and hidden by a low ridge just downstream. They were all dressed in rough, mismatched clothes and were brandishing various flavours of blade in a way that was meant to be seen and feared.
“Alright, lads, keep your hands in front of you,” said the lead man, who had the thickest, reddest eyebrows Bilbo had ever seen.
Bilbo put his hands up; Thorin kept one hand in front and one hand on his pony’s bridle. “I knew someone was spying on us last night.” He muttered. He gave a brief glance over his shoulder. This was clearly a favourite spot for trapping travellers, with the river behind and only bare grassland in every other direction.
Bilbo took a step forward. “Well met, my friends. I assume you’d like something from us? We’d be happy to pay for our safe passage.”
“We’ll be taking the ponies, and we’ll have a look at your bags if you don’t mind,” Redbrow said, pointing his long, chipped dagger at Bilbo.
“A fair bargain,” Bilbo nodded. “I don’t want to get your hopes up, though. We’re travelling light, it’s just supplies for the road, there’s really nothing of particular value.”
“We’ll be the judge of that.”
He whistled at two of his companions, one of whom headed towards Bilbo’s nervously stamping pony and started rummaging through Bilbo’s bag. He called a complaint to his leader, “I thought you said they looked like merchants. I don’t see any merchandise here.”
“They’ll have gold. Dwarves always have gold,” Redbrow barked.
The other headed for Bilbo, who took a step back despite his attempted bravado. The man lunged forward and grabbed him by the collar with one filthy hand. Behind Bilbo, Thorin stepped forward with a low growl.
“Oi, stand still, you little rat.” The man grinned gap-toothily at Bilbo. “What are you, anyway? Some kind of sickly elf?”
“I’m a hobbit actually, from the Shire,” Bilbo kept his hands raised as the man pulled him closer. “Don’t suppose you fine gentlemen get out that far West.”
“That wee knife you’ve got looks expensive. Give it to me,” the man jabbed at his belly with a short, rather blunt-looking dagger. Bilbo sighed and began to unclip the loops of Sting’s sheath. As the man’s gaze fell to it, he frowned. “There’s something in your pocket.”
Bilbo’s heart began to beat harder now, and he said too quickly. “No, there isn’t.”
“I saw a flash of gold,” the man’s frown grew deeper, but he sounded uncertain. He suddenly shook Bilbo roughly and his voice rose. “Turn out your pockets!”
Before Bilbo could even begin to think what to do, there was a sword raised over his shoulder and pressing into the man’s throat.
“Let him go,” Thorin’s low voice rumbled from behind Bilbo. This did not feel like much of an improvement on the situation, as the bandit still had a knife against Bilbo’s belly. The man’s face twisted into a snarl, and at once he shoved Bilbo to one side and tried to turn Thorin’s sword. As Bilbo stumbled and just managed to keep from falling on his arse by catching a high lump of tussock with one hand, he heard the shriek of blades and a meaty sound, and felt a splash of damp on one of his cheeks.
He touched it and saw blood on his fingertips as he heard the bandit wail. “He cut me! Ah, my fingers!”
There were at least two gone, and most of the third. Bilbo dashed to huddle behind Thorin, who was sweeping his sword around in a warning to the remaining four bandits. The one who had been rummaging through the ponies stepped back from
Thorin’s blade. They all had their weapons pointed at Thorin, now. But even Bilbo could tell they were inexpertly held.
“Get on your pony,” Thorin said quietly, reaching one hand behind him to gesture at Bilbo without taking his eyes off their attackers. The bandit that Thorin had cut was groaning and bent over, looking for his fingers in the long grass. Thorin roared, “Come on, you filthy dogs! Come and try your luck!”
Bilbo didn’t see that he had much choice at this point but to do as Thorin said. He took two steps back, grabbed the edge of the stamping pony’s saddle and clambered up like he was a child scrambling up the oak in his garden back in Bag End. The poor pony was tossing her head and huffing in fear at the voices and the smell of blood, and Bilbo tried to soothe her with a pat on her neck, but his efforts were quickly ruined as Thorin turned and cried, “Ride fast, I’ll find you!” and slapped the poor beast on the haunches.
The pony whinnied and bolted into the river, raising a great, white spray around her as she slipped and leaped over the large, weedy stones. Bilbo looked over his shoulder at Thorin, who had grabbed his own pony and pushed it to follow its comrade, riderless, which it did in a panicked stumble. Thorin was backing up into the water, sword still extended towards the bandits.
Bilbo couldn’t see if they were following Thorin, and at that moment he twisted around too far at the worst time. The pony splashed into the widest and deepest part of the ford, slipped and tilted like a galleon with a leak on one side. Bilbo had been clinging to the saddle and the water made it slippery and before he could think he was falling.
The shock of being under the cold water was so sudden that Bilbo’s chest locked up and his limbs flailed as if to pull the surface down to him. The water was not so deep, perhaps only to his shoulders, but it was swift and there was an array of large rocks beneath the surface, all too slick with river-slime to grab, so that under the water he was bashed and rolled from one to the other like a ball between racquets. He couldn’t get his footing no matter how he tried, and soon he found his lungs were beginning to burn. He managed to roll onto his back and kick off one of the rocks just enough to get his face above the water to gasp a mouthful of air, and heard the shouts and curses of the already-distant bandits pursuing Thorin, and then an eddy of the river pulled him under again. He was dragged and rolled on and on faster than even a good horse could have run.
His thoughts were as tossed around as the rest of him, but he became aware to his horror that he was past the ford now and the river was reconstituting into a single, deep current once more. The boulders on the bed were not knocking him about because they were several feet below him. He was in deeper water than the height of a man, though at least it was now more predictable. Bilbo was finally able to tread back to the surface, doggy-paddling with his hands, and catch another breath. But the current was also growing faster as the river narrowed and deepened. Trees had appeared on the east bank, still sparse above grassy floors, but increasingly thick and threatening looking. He didn’t know how long he floated, just barely keeping his head up as his sodden clothes weighed him down.
He couldn’t swim much longer, and he had to get to the shore before he hit rapids or got sucked down by an undercurrent. Blinking the water out of his eyes as he tried to keep his head up, he spotted a steep, grey beach up ahead, on the east bank of the river. He started to swim with a last burst of strength, moving sideways but with the current. The water was so swift that he almost missed the beach, but just as it was passing out of his reach he felt earth under his toes and made a final, desperate lunge, grabbing handfuls of sand as if to anchor himself. The water rolled him over onto his back as he tried to kick his way onto the solid ground and he rolled with it and flipped around onto his front, lying face-down on the beach with his chest out of the water and the river still pulling at his legs.
For a moment he lay, gasping for air and trying to collect himself. The water tugged at his clothes and feet. He crawled further up until he was on warm, sun-dried sand, and then let himself lie down again, his breath slowly returning to normal. He ached with new bruises and the overexertion of his muscles.
Distantly, he thought he heard the shouting of the bandits, though in truth he couldn’t be sure if it was just the pounding of his blood in his ears. He fumbled at his pocket for his mother’s ring. Incredibly, it had not fallen out in the river, and he shoved it onto his finger just to be safe.
Through the blur of the ring’s shadows, he closed his eyes and tried to calm down. The sand was hot under his cheek and the swim in cold water had completely drained him. As his heartbeat started to slow down, he found exhaustion washing over him, and against all odds or sense he drifted towards sleep.
—
Bilbo awoke to a distant voice sinking into his dreams. He opened his eyes to the weak afternoon sunlight drizzling through the clouds, and raised his sand-sticky head.
“Bilbo? Where are you?”
He could hear Thorin calling from somewhere up on the grassy bank. He realised he still had the ring on and wrenched it off his finger. He stood up slowly. All the aches from the river boulders were even worse after who-knew-how-long lying in an awkward position on the sand.
He brushed himself off as best he could. His teeth were chattering and the rest of him was shaking: the wind was still cool and he’d been soaked through.
“I’m h-here,” he called, raising his head.
Thorin was just under the trees, leading both ponies as he searched the riverbank for Bilbo. At the sound of Bilbo’s voice he dropped the pony’s reins and bounded out of the tree line and down the beach. “Oh, thank the first-fathers! I saw a wet hobbit-shape on that sand but you weren’t there, I’ve been walking up and down for an hour looking for you. I thought for sure you were drowned.”
Bilbo staggered up towards him. Thorin was wet to the waist but there was no sign of blood or any bruises on him, and his sword was back in its sheath. He seemed to have emerged from the disaster in rather better shape than Bilbo.
“No thanks to you,” Bilbo snapped, stomping past Thorin towards the ponies. “I had it under control, what did you go swinging a sword around for? What are you paying me to do, if not get you out of difficulty?”
“I didn’t hire you to swing a sword. I can do that just fine, even if I’m a little out of practice,” Thorin followed him under the trees. “And I’d rather keep you alive until we get to Erebor, even if you’re happy to get sliced to ribbons by bandits.”
“We’re lucky to be alive,” Bilbo was looking for his pack, but he was furious to see it was missing. Presumably it had fallen off Thorin’s saddle in the escape. Most of his dry clothes and his only blanket had gone with it. “They could have killed us! The ponies and your pride were not worth dying for.”
“Don’t be naïve. They would have killed us anyway once they got what they wanted,” Thorin insisted. “Come on, we need to keep moving. They weren’t keen to cross the river, they know the City Guard occasionally patrols this far, but they may find their courage when night falls.”
They walked deeper under the trees for cover, leading the ponies and keeping the sound of the river on their left so they knew they were heading back north towards the Old Forest Road. However, before long Bilbo found himself stumbling and tripping on every root. Thorin slowed and put his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. It brushed the side of Bilbo’s neck, and he felt a shudder run through him at the contact with Thorin’s skin.
“Mahal, you’re freezing,” Thorin said.
“I’ll j-just h-have to d-dry on the w-walk,” Bilbo could barely get the words out. He felt a little woozy.
“Under these trees? No, we need to stop and get you warm before you fall over.” Thorin loosely tied the reins of both ponies to the nearest low branch and then found his own blankets in the saddle bags. “I’m wet too, I’ll get changed and then get a fire going.”
“No f-fires. Those ruffians m-might be s-s-searching,” Bilbo said, sitting himself down on the nearest fallen log. His hands hung between his knees. He was so cold and tired he didn’t think he could stand up again.
He thought no time had passed, but suddenly Thorin was back, in a dry set of clothes with a blanket draped over his shoulders. His spare shirt was thin linen which he’d only just started to button up. Bilbo found himself staring at the dark curls of hair poking out between the open buttons at the top. Before he could take his eyes off it, Thorin was tugging at Bilbo’s jacket, trying to peel the wet brocade off his shoulders.
“Come on, stay awake, let’s get you out of this. You’ll catch your death, you’re so bloody small.”
Bilbo nodded and managed to wriggle and strain until his wet jacket and shirt were gone. He shivered in the cold air until Thorin threw his own spare blanket around him, right over the top of Bilbo’s head with his face sticking out like he was wearing a cloak and hood. The blanket smelled of dust, of pony fur, and faintly of Thorin’s hair.
“One day without the wizard and look at us.” Thorin said as he hung their dripping clothes from the nearby branches and then settled himself on the grass beside Bilbo’s log. For a moment there was quiet, but for their breathing, a few songbirds and the crunch of the ponies’ teeth tearing up a little grass.
“I’m still so cold,” Bilbo said. It was true, but he knew he was trying to be daring. Just to see what Thorin would do.
Thorin looked at him. He raised his near arm, holding his own blanket open. “Come on, then.”
Bilbo shuffled off the log and onto the grass beside Thorin, ducking under his arm and leaning into him, twisting so that they were nearly chest to chest. Thorin was so warm it was like pressing against a great, round boulder that had been standing out in the sun for hours. He dropped his arm over Bilbo’s shoulders. His head tilted to rest his cheek on top of Bilbo’s hair.
“That’s better,” said Bilbo quietly. “I like this.”
After a moment Thorin said, just as quietly. “I like this, too.”
Chapter 5: Stargazers
Chapter Text
In the cell deep beneath the royal palace, Kili thought back on that moment on the archery range when Legolas had shaken his hand and welcomed him to the Guard. He wondered if he had ever been so happy, and if somehow his hubris had been the cause of all the grief that followed. Six months after that day at the archery range, Thorin had been accused of theft, and disappeared before a trial could sentence him to banishment.
He never got a proper conversation with Thorin before he left. Thorin left no note for Kili, nothing to promise he still felt the pride he’d shown that day. The night he must have been preparing to flee, Kili had walked in on Thorin and Fili in some quiet conversation, but they’d gone silent as he opened the door. And Fili never told him what that last conversation was about, even though Kili told him everything, everything, he even told him about Tauriel before he had told Tauriel herself. When Kili asked, Fili just said “It was nothing,” but Kili knew he was lying.
Kili understood now that it wasn’t that they didn’t love him or trust him, but that they were trying to protect him. In making himself a model citizen and warrior of the Guard, he had also made himself a target. He had to be above suspicion in all things.
But he hadn’t figured that out until it was too late.
His mother had been the one to step in and stop him, but she was too late as well. He had been in the Guard for two years by then. He had kept up with the other recruits, he had made friends, he had killed spiders, everything that was expected of him and which as his uncle had been hoped would prove him worthy. Dwarves recognised him on the street, even without his uniform, and wanted to talk to him, tell him that they, or their son, was thinking of applying at the next call for recruits. And as he’d hoped at the beginning, the dams had taken notice too. He was never short on drinks at the pub, or conversation from pretty dwarves who’d added a little gold powder to their brows for the night out; dams, dwarrows, everybody wanted a smile and a chat.
But he’d made one stupid mistake. He’d gotten arrogant in the worst possible way. With all those choices laid out before him, he’d fallen in love with the absolute worst person he could have found, for more reasons than he could count: his superior officer, a personal friend of Commander Legolas, and an elf.
When he was at home the second summer after he joined the Guard, he lay on the deck under the distant stars, smoking a pipe with Fili. “I’m in love with Captain Tauriel,” he said dreamily. Two years he had been training under lieutenant Fainthel, who reported directly to Captain Tauriel, so he had had plenty of time to think about Tauriel as she walked around calling the recruits to order and barking at her lieutenants. The surety of his statement was beyond doubt in his own mind.
Fili gave such a sudden burst of laughter he nearly shoved his pipe stem up his nose. “Did you fall out of a tree and crack your skull?”
“No,” Kili murmured. “And she’s in love with me too. I haven’t asked her, obviously, but I can sense it. We have a connection.”
“By all that’s green, you are an idiot,” Fili laughed. “Just keep quiet about it. Find someone nice round this neighborhood to bury your fever in. This will pass.”
But it didn’t pass, and unfortunately for Kili, he was right. She felt the same. And for a few brief and blissful months that summer and into autumn they had carried on in secret, meeting in the forest or in deep halls beneath the roots of the City, where the water of the underground forest river covered the sound of their voices. They were both trained Guards; they knew how to keep a straight face, how to hide when they needed to and bluff their way out of suspicious questions. Maybe some suspected, but no one knew - except Fili, and he would never tell. But there was one person Kili couldn’t fool forever.
Dis was incandescent when she figured it out. Thorin had been gone for more than two years, and she had been steadily rebuilding their family’s reputation, crafting herself as the legitimate heir to Thror’s rule of their people. She had picked up so much that Thorin had left off, abandoning her business to focus on mediating dwarvish spats, raising funds for libraries and repairs to the temple roof, holding community meetings and bringing their petitions to royal councils. Kili was supposed to be part of her propaganda campaign, a proof to both races that there could be peace even as the dwarves could prepare for war, that dwarves could be trusted with weapons in defense of their home. And Dis was furious that he was going to throw it all away on an elf that frankly, even as elves went, Dis did not like.
“At least pick one that laughs and drinks,” she growled at Kili, in between shouting at him. “Not the snobbiest one in the whole damn City.”
“She’s not snobby,” Kili snapped back. “She’s shy.”
“Not shy enough!” Ma crowed. “You’re seventy-six. She’s - what? A thousand? Ten thousand? For shame!”
Kili said, furious but also a little tempted to goad her, “Fourteen hundred and seven, next month.”
“I’ll wring her bloody neck for doing this to you!” Ma roared. “She should know better! She’s your superior officer, how is this not disgraceful conduct?”
“She’s not even really my boss,” Kili said. He’d never seen such a gale of fury from his regal mother, and it took everything in him not to laugh at her because he didn’t know what else to do. “We report to Lieutenant Fainthel. Fainthel’s the one who reports to Tauriel.”
“That makes it worse, Kili!” Dis practically shrieked. “Does the Guard have no standards? I’ll see to it she loses her position! She’ll be sweeping leaves off the streets for the rest of her long days, if I have anything to say about it!”
“Ma, calm down,” Kili said, which was definitely not the right thing to say. But after some time, she did calm down, and hugged him, and apologised for the worst of her words.
“I’m afraid for you,” she said, cupping his face with her hands. “You’ve worked so hard. You are forging a new path for our people. They will use this against you, if they find out.” Kili nodded and ducked his head, but Dis waited for him to meet her eye again. Now her voice was low and clear, its anger expended. “Kili, someone destroyed your uncle because he stepped over the line one too many times. Because he was sticking his big nose where it didn’t belong. I don’t know who it was but it goes deep, and it goes high. You do not get the luxury of breaking the rules when you are in the middle of trying to beat them. Do you understand me?”
He couldn’t argue. He did understand. She’d shaken him, with the mention of Thorin, who everyone else refused to talk about. Kili had only ever known the Woodland, he had only ever lived in a comfortable city house. He’d never even been as far as Laketown. If he had to run for it like Thorin, he’d be leaving everything and everyone he knew. And maybe love was worth that risk if he’d been ordinary, but Ma was right: he was Thror’s great-grandson and he had a responsibility to his people.
The next night, he managed to get a message to Tauriel. They met outside the city as she was coming back from patrol and he was going out, on the great mound to the North and East that was known as the Stargazing Hill. It was a smooth, gently inclining walk to the top, which was bare of trees. There was a ring of great, rain-weathered boulders low around its crest like a crown, each one at least twice the height of a dwarf and broad like molar teeth, forming a rough and gappy three-quarter circle. The grass inside the stone ring was long and soft and perfect for lying on under the open sky and watching the heavens. They’d been here many times.
Tauriel joined him as he waited on the crest of the hill for her, and tried to take his hands. He tucked them under his arms and he told her he’d let his youth lead him astray, but now they had to end it. The moonlight was bright enough to see her face as she broke, silently wiping the tears away and trying to tell him she understood and she would of course treat him as fairly as any other member of the Guard. He felt sick and miserable and his head ached like he had suddenly come down with a raging cold. He felt a moment of daring, and raised his sword to cut a thin braid from behind his ear. When he had done his hair this morning he’d closed the end with a little silver clip, stamped with the crest of Durin, a naming-day present from Thorin some years earlier. He’d worn it in the hopes of channeling some of Thorin’s dignity for his conversation with Tauriel tonight. He sealed the cut end of the braid into the clip, to make a circle of woven hair the size of his palm.
“Keep this. So you know I’m not doing this as a cowardly way of escaping you,” he said, putting it in her hand and closing her fingers over it. “Things are changing in the City. Maybe this doesn’t have to be forever.”
She nodded, and touched the little circle of hair to her mouth, and hid it in an inner pocket of her bodice. They said goodbye, but didn’t kiss, and went down the hill in different directions in case anyone saw them. Kili felt himself putting the shades around the flame he carried for her, but knew he’d never stop loving her, never.
They avoided meeting alone after that. Their duties rarely overlapped, so it was easy to avoid each other. A few times, they passed in the headquarters and nodded a greeting, barely making eye contact, as if they’d never been anything other than comrades in arms.
Two weeks later she was dead and Kili was in the cell beneath the palace, accused of her murder.
—
“When we get to the Mountain—” Thorin began.
“We’re not going to the Mountain yet,” Bilbo cut him off.
They were standing on the deck of a small ferry, slowly making its way up the River Running, south of the Long Lake. There were about a dozen other passengers, mostly travelling with rare materials; amber, incense-gum, sea oils, and Rhûn silks, to sell in Esgaroth or direct to the Woodland City. In the quieter, wider parts of the river, the crew poled the boat, and when the water was narrow and fast they threw thick tow-ropes to teams of oxen on the shore that heaved the vessel along well-built tow-paths. It was slow going, but still somewhat faster and easier than walking.
They had met the ferry after almost two weeks along the Old Forest Road, thankfully a less exciting journey than their first two days to the Anduin. At the end of the road, the marshes had been drained across a large area to build a comfortable and busy town, made to manage the flow of goods in and out of the three great city-states of the central east; the Woodland City, Esgaroth, and the Iron Hills. That meant the settlement was absolutely lousy with Woodland merchants and their attached Guards. After the relatively peaceful trip through the forest, Thorin was forced to skulk at the edges and hide his face whenever anyone wearing grey-green uniforms passed nearby, but Bilbo was happy to step in and prove his use. He left Thorin hiding in a small, disreputable-looking tavern, little more than a three-walled shack at the edge of the town. Within an hour, he had returned, having sold the ponies for a decent price, restocked their travelling supplies, and found them passage on the ferry first thing in the morning, which he scouted in advance to check it was crewed by Lakemen rather than elves from the Woodland. He’d also managed to pick up a new set of clothes so that he could finally replace those lost during the fight with the bandits; a set of dark blue, dwarven children’s clothes, a little baggy in the arms and shoulders and tight around the waist but warmer than his increasingly foul and fraying Bree clothes.
Now they were out on the water and could simply sit and rest for the first time in weeks. Bilbo had folded his bag under his head and slept for the first few hours. His stomach woke him up at lunchtime, and he and Thorin ate and sat on the edge of the ferry and watched the forest pass in endless rows of dense, tall trees on the west side of the river.
Now Thorin looked at him.
“I’m paying you as a professional burglar to enter Erebor,” Thorin said quietly so the other passengers didn’t hear, his hand propped up on his hip. “Are you saying you won’t go into the mountain?”
Bilbo finished his bite of chewy day-old bread and wiped his mouth. “You’re paying me to find a dragon and the source of King Thranduil’s mithril. The latter is hardly something I can learn in the Lonely Mountain, and the former may be answerable by other means. I know you have a plan, but as you said, I am the professional.” He turned to hold Thorin’s eye, waiting to see how he’d react.
“We’ve come all this way,” Thorin said, with an angry edge to his tone.
“Yes. And we’re exactly on track,” Bilbo smiled cautiously. “I want to talk to the Lakemen. They live nearest the mountain. They may know more about the dragon. After that, I may have to go the Woodland.”
Thorin shook his head. “You can’t be seen in there. It’s far too dangerous.”
“I have my ways of staying unseen,” Bilbo patted Thorin’s thigh. “Trust me.” He squinted a little. “Everyone I’ve spoken to talks about the Woodland as a haven of peace and plenty. What is it that you’re so afraid of in there? Why do you insist it’s so dangerous?”
“It’s hard to explain,” Thorin said testily.
“I’m not saying you’re mad or lying,” Bilbo assured him. “I just need to understand.”
Thorin watched the passing trees. Bilbo remembered something he’d said weeks ago, when he’d asked Thorin why he always kept his beard so neat. …it was driven into me, like a fencepost…
Bilbo tried to prompt him. “My mother used to say, 'Go not to the Elves for counsel for they will answer both no and yes.’”
“In the City we say, ‘Careful which end you’re speaking to, they both wear masks’,” Thorin raised an eyebrow at him. “If you catch my drift.” Bilbo laughed but Thorin sighed. “They used to say it about the Wood-elves. Now I hear it said about anyone in the city, elf or dwarf, who says one thing and does another.”
“Your people are blending together,” Bilbo said. “And you don’t like what that means.”
“No, it’s not that,” Thorin shook his head. “The City wants us to believe we are blended, that we are the same, but then it treats us as if we are not. I thought once that in entwining our fates, Thranduil and myself, we were creating something new, something of great craft and spirit that would survive the coming ages.” He drew in a long, shuddering breath. It seemed like he couldn’t find the words to explain what he meant. At last he said, “You cannot trap a wolf with fire and iron and hope to get anything from it but its skin and teeth. But you can lure a starving wolf pup, with meat and shelter, and it will forget how to hunt, and its grandsons will become the dogs that beg and fetch on your command, for nothing more than scraps.”
Bilbo waited until his stomach settled a little. He said, “Dogs don’t tell stories or make plans. You can’t tame a person.”
Thorin rumbled. “No. The only thing you can do with a disobedient dog is put it down.”
—
Thorin did not understand his father’s warning until many, many years after Thrain had disappeared.
Everything had changed since those dark days. The City was young but beginning to take shape. Thranduil had sourced enough Mithril to get them through the lean times. Back then, Thorin never questioned where it had come from; it was a blessing from the Valar. He was simply glad to see the teams of dwarves and elves working together, labouring - arguing, teasing, laughing as they went - to build new homes and new defensive walls and new streets paved in stone but lined with trees. The rivers had been redirected into canals to carry goods from one side of the realm to the other, the reservoirs tapped to bring clean water up from the depths of the earth, and every new home and path hung with the Mithril-touched lights, carrying the sun’s glow and warmth into the shadows and shelters of their halls. The Erebor council, a dwindling collection of noble cousins and guildmasters from before the fall of the Mountain, was shrinking as its members aged, but the consortium of trade and business was growing as money began to fill dwarvish coffers. Dis was married, and happily living with her husband in a beautiful house near the edge of the City. She had not made any announcements yet, even to Thorin, but Balin had started talking about “when she’s given the line of Durin new princelings,” as if they were ordered and paid for like an ironmonger’s shipment.
Thorin sat on Thranduil’s small council, and sometimes when the long and dreary business of state was over, the two of them would take tea or wine in one of the quiet parlours of Thranduil’s palace, on a balcony overlooking the city. Thorin had stopped using any title of ‘King’ for himself some years earlier, but he also didn’t use it for Thranduil: he addressed Thranduil only by his name, and was never corrected even in public.
That day, Thranduil said, “Give my congratulations to your sister.”
Thorin raised his eyebrows. “She has not told me any news of note.”
Thranduil chuckled. “Ah, then my apologies to her for spoiling the surprise. I saw her yesterday at the trade meeting.”
“She told you she was with child?”
“No, but a healer knows these things.”
Thorin took a large sip of his wine. “That is wonderful news, I almost wish you hadn’t said anything. It’ll be a hard job for me to keep my mouth shut.”
“And I hope our family, too, will be so blessed,” Thranduil smiled. “My son still acts like a young bachelor, but he has affections for one elf in particular. I think he is too proper to act on it while he is Commander of the Guard, though, as she is one of his captains and is beholden to his orders.”
“He will speak when he feels ready. These are good times to be young. A time for marriages,” Thorin said.
Without warning, Thranduil’s long arm reached across the table and snagged a lock of Thorin’s hair, near the temple. “You have some grey.”
Thorin pulled away without thinking. The hair fell away from Thranduil’s fingers. Thorin brushed it behind his ear.
“I can give you something for that,” Thranduil said softly.
Thorin laughed. “Absolutely not. I’ve just started to get the old fellows to call me ‘Your Majesty’ instead of ‘Laddie’. I need the grey.”
There was a look on Thranduil’s face that he did not expect, a flicker of anger and disgust. And then it was gone and they moved on to other topics of discussion.
But a week later they were having supper, talking about something to do with food imports. Thranduil offered him a glass, but as soon as he sipped it, he put it down in a hurry.
“Ugh, this wine has gone bad.”
“It’s distilled with a remedy,” Thranduil said, folding his cloak across his lap and leaning back in his chair. “Finish it, it will do you good.”
“A remedy for what?”
Thranduil said, “For your grey. And those wrinkles around your mouth.”
Thorin stared at him. “I’m not drinking this.”
“It’s just herbs, and a simple spell of renewal. It will make you feel and look younger. It’s not dangerous, it’s an old recipe of mine.”
“Why would you do that? Without asking me?”
“Because you’re my favourite, and I’d like to delay the inevitable,” Thranduil said. “Drink it, it will go to waste otherwise.”
Thorin could not find any words to answer. He put the glass aside, and tried to turn the conversation back to grain stocks. He left the meeting with his food untouched and his heart racing.
All those years later, when he walked into Bilbo’s office in Bree, he told the tale as if Thranduil was the one who had pushed him out of power on a whim. But the truth was, Thorin was the one who turned cold, who stepped away from their decades of friendship. He no longer met Thranduil in private, and was more cautious in what he promised in council meetings. He never again took any food or drink that Thranduil gave him.
He could tell that Thranduil was offended, and soon Thorin’s invitations to the palace dried up and it was clear to everyone that his days of influence over the elven king had waned. But the horror of the attempted violation stayed in Thorin’s bones, in his marrow, and when he spoke to Thranduil it was with all the deference and distance of two rulers meeting for the first time, unsure and wary of any alliance.
—
Bilbo had been in Laketown for about a week, living out of a single room in one of the many inns, when he found their breakthrough.
The inn, called the Black Arrow House, was run by a tall, jolly landlady named Inga, with some help from what seemed like innumerable children, as her dour husband seemed to be away on his boat most of the day. They had picked this particular inn because the ferrymen that had brought them recommended it. Not because it was the best, but because for a few extra coin - some of the last they had left - Inga said she would forget to record them in the records all innkeepers sent to the Master, the records of travellers coming and going from the large town. They didn’t give their real names anyway, of course. They went by Mr Underhill and Mr Luznâ from the Blue Mountains, but pseudonyms were not enough for Bilbo; he wanted no trace of them to be written down for anyone who might come snuffling around later.
Thorin did not stay in Laketown past the first day. He was determined to make a trip to the Lonely Mountain, even if it was alone and on foot, to search for the hidden doorway he remembered from his father’s map. To this end he hitched a ride to the north shore of the lake with Inga’s husband, Bard, under the cover of dusk. Bard was apparently picking up some cargo from there, though Bilbo didn’t ask what had to be picked up at night from the least inhabited side of the lake. He let Thorin go, and hoped to Yavanna he would see him again.
Then, making his way around town, he began to ask about dragons. He played the part of the excitable eccentric where possible, feigning the effects of drink where necessary. But he soon discovered that the people of Esgaroth were the worst kind of informers: they talked too much about the dragon. Bilbo could not get a consistent story out of any of them. Everybody claimed to have seen the dragon, although sometimes he took the form of a strong wind on the lake, sometimes a bolt of lightning and thunder on a dry day, sometimes a distant roar that might have just been a stag in the hills but surely was actually Smaug the Terrible. Everybody had a second cousin’s friend who had snuck up to the front door and glimpsed the dragon lying on his hoard, or who had been out with his sheep and was snaffled up in the night leaving only a smear of blood and entrails. Everybody knew an old song that foretold where and when the dragon would strike next, or described him in particularly lurid detail. It was amazing how quickly stories about a dragon became boring, when told by a lot of boring fisherfolk with nothing else to do but regale you.
After several days, Bilbo skipped his usual evening questioning old men at the pubs, and had his dinner in the Black Arrow instead. Inga served him a lovely meat pie and boiled vegetables, as Bilbo decided he had earned a proper meal. It was necessary for his hobbitish health. He told her to put it on Thorin’s tab and retired to a quiet table in the corner of the Inn, going through the pencilled notes he’d made of the dragon rumours.
“My wife tells me you’re a pleasure-seeker,” said a voice. Bilbo raised his head quickly. Inga’s husband, Bard, was sitting in a chair by the fire, smoking a pipe and repairing some piece of child’s clothing with a thick needle. The eponymous Black Arrow for which the inn was named, apparently a relic of the destruction of Dale, hung above the mantelpiece behind him, as dark and brooding as the bargeman himself.
“Sorry?” Bilbo asked.
“You know. Come to see the sights. Get a bit of local colour. Things you can’t get at home,” Bard said without looking up. “Inga said you’ve given a false name and been out at a different establishment every night since you arrived.”
Bilbo raised his hand. “Oh, no, no, no, it’s absolutely not what you think.”
Bard raised an eyebrow. “We may be considered the backwater of the continent but we’re not so conservative as I hear they are in the West. We get so many people through this town, you see a bit of everything.”
“No, no, honestly, I’m not here for—” Bilbo winced, and tried to think how he could salvage the reputation of his invented Mr Underhill. “I’m actually writing a book. About dragons.”
Bard looked up from his needlework at last. He took the pipe from his mouth. “About dragons?” He asked.
“Yes. I’m sure you can tell me all about how you friend’s wife’s father-in-law once saw Smaug tossing sheep into the lake one Sunday—”
“I’m sure I could. People talk a lot of rot about things they fear but have never seen,” Bard said grimly. After a moment he added, “I don’t know anything about dragons. But you’ll want to talk to the Starwatcher.”
Bilbo sat up a little. “And who’s that when he’s at home?”
Bard waved the stem of his pipe vaguely towards the window. “Old fellow, lives at the end of the pier off Roe End, in a tall house you can’t mistake. He’s batty as a belfry, but if anybody has really seen the dragon, it’s him. Go in the evening, he sleeps during the day.”
Bilbo nodded. “Thank you. I’ll try him tomorrow.”
“If he can’t help, head to the Woodland. Their scholars are wiser than any folk you’ll find in these parts,” Bard said, going back to his darning. “Even their King himself. He comes through Laketown sometimes, to treat with the Master about trade and hiring men to build roads. He knows about the dragons of old, when the drakes of the North were more numerous than starlings.”
“Have you met him?” Bilbo asked. “I don’t know anything about him, honestly.”
“I have,” Bard bit off the thick thread with a rip that made Bilbo wince. “I owe him everything precious to me, in fact. When my wife was in labour with our second son, he was passing through on some errand. She and the babe were dying and my sister-in-law found him and begged for his help. He is a great healer, and he saved them both, though she was a common boatman’s wife in a leaking, rough house by the canal. He is a good king, who cannot turn his heart from the poor and wretched, and he has a skill in healing unmatched even in his own realm.”
Bilbo listened curiously. It was such a different character after the impression he’d got from Thorin, who had outlined the picture of a callous tyrant. But he reminded himself that Thorin and Thranduil must have been friends, once. Perhaps it was this side of Thranduil that Thorin had once seen, the king that Bard knew.
“‘Both ends wear masks’,” he said, half to himself.
Bard looked up at him with a canny eye. “They say that in the City,” he said with a careful tone. “But I thought you and your companion were newcomers here?”
Bilbo gave a little laugh. “Oh, just something I heard on the boat up the river. I don’t remember who said it.”
—
Thorin spent five days around the Lonely Mountain, walking the slopes and trying to recognise the ridges and valleys that he remembered when they were thick with pines and alive with birds and deer. He climbed high up until he reached sheer rocks that still held sheets of ice and frost until late in the afternoons. He felt the stone there with his hands, pressed his cheek close and listened to it. It had the texture and colour and scent of the heart of raw stone that made up the walls of the hidden kingdom below his feet, and just to be near it was a balm to the spirit.
He found the doorstep outside the hidden tunnel on the fourth day. He was sure this was the place, a level stoop leading to a grassy clifftop step between high walls of crumbling stone and carved masonry. The wall at the back looked natural but was just a little too smooth, the lichen growing in a way that suggested different ages of stone in the rough outline of a door. But as he’d feared, it was closed, and there was no sign of a keyhole, handle or hinge. There was no sign at all that the door had been opened for over a century, since Smaug had taken the mountain. Thrain had not made it this far. Like all the other places Thorin had searched, no trace of him could be found.
Thorin sat on the step outside and contemplated the door for some time. There must be a secret he hadn’t seen on the map, which his father had not revealed or perhaps did not know himself. He had felt sure that when he came here, he would find some sign of his father, or a sense of his presence even if he was long dead. But the place was empty and wild, untouched by dwarvish hands since the day Thror must have closed it long ago.
“Where did you go, Father?” he whispered to himself as stared over the lake, back towards Mirkwood. He could just make out a different texture to the trees in the place where he knew the City lay under the canopy. It looked so close from this vantage point, a straight line as the raven flies. How had Thrain lost his way?
There was nothing more to do but return to Laketown, especially since his food was running low. He was disappointed but not bitterly so. It had always been a long shot, breaking into the mountain through a secret entrance that no one else had found all these years. He was glad he’d come, but he had gained more questions than answers.
He walked the rough road around the lake to the bridge on the east shore, and slipped through into Laketown by tagging close behind a group of merchants, past the watchmen who were sleeping or laughing to each other without checking who was coming and going into the town.
It was late afternoon when he walked into the Inn and found Bilbo in their room looking through a pile of papers. Bilbo jumped up and practically ran to greet him. Thorin felt a warm glow at such a welcome.
“Did you find the secret door?” Bilbo asked.
“Yes, and no,” Thorin said. “It is shut. Without the key, we cannot get in that way.”
“Nevermind, nevermind,” Bilbo took his arm and tugged him to the small table under the window. “Take off your boots, sit, you’ve come at a perfect time. Inga is bringing up tea and some cakes shortly.”
“You’ve found something?” Thorin guessed.
“Yes, although it may not be all good news,” Bilbo sounded rather too cheerful for someone giving bad news.
Thorin pulled a second chair up beside him and sat down. The table was small and he and Bilbo were sitting practically knee to knee. He could faintly smell a woody soap-smell coming off him, from the Inn’s bath. He already looked better fed than after their weeks on the road. Thorin hated to think what he smelled like after five days wandering the mountain eating hard tack and dried fish.
“There’s an old man, an astronomer, who’s lived in Laketown his whole life. His great-grandfather was a renowned scholar in Dale, and the family has lived as teachers and wisemen here since Dale was destroyed. But they’ve always watched the skies, tracking eclipses and comets and so forth, and their records are exemplary.”
“I don’t think we need to know about comets,” Thorin said. “Only fools believe comets precede a change in fortunes.”
“They watch the skies, Thorin,” Bilbo repeated. “The old man was very happy to talk to someone curious. He let me look through all the record books of any notable changes in the night sky. I found more than two dozen times where the dragon was seen flying from the mountain, since the family came to Laketown, including one only fifteen years ago,” looked up at him. “That means Smaug was alive recently.”
Thorin felt his stomach sink. “This is grave news. So my theory that Thranduil is slowly robbing the mountain cannot be true.”
“Unless he has some magic that allows him to pass unseen,” Bilbo suggested. “Such things do exist.”
“There is some wood-elf magic that might allow him to pass stealthily, unnoticed to weak minds, but even his strongest spells could not make him invisible to a dragon’s keen eyes and nose,” Thorin shook his head.
Bilbo opened his mouth, but at that moment there was a knock on the door and Inga came in carrying a tray with tea and two slices of a thick, chewy rectangle-thing that was sweet and somewhat cake-like. Bilbo fell silent as Thorin took the tray and thanked her. Once she’d gone, he pulled out his notebook again and showed Thorin a scribbled list of dates and notes.
“The old man thinks the flights are when the dragon is hungry. But there’s a somewhat regular pattern that he pointed out to me - these are the dates I wrote down. It’s a bit all over the place for the first few decades after the fall of Erebor, but after that it’s almost exactly every seven years in the same direction. Other years he goes all everywhere, there’s no rhyme to it, but this seven year pattern he repeats. Look at the compass direction the dragon flies.”
“West by South-west,” Thorin said. It took him a moment to picture the map in his mind. Then he looked at Bilbo with wide eyes. “Directly towards the City.”
Bilbo nodded. “How often would you say those mysterious Mithril shipments arrive?”
Thorin shook his head. “Less than once a decade is not far off, but it’s hard to say. I did try to find records, before I fled the city, but unlike most palace imports the mithril doesn’t end up on the court’s books of state. Mithril stocks are not managed by the trade guild, they seem to be handled by…” Thorin looked back at the notes Bilbo had taken and felt a creeping cold in his limbs. “By the praetorians. The king’s personal guard. Half of them are made up of the twenty elves who survived entering Erebor the day it fell. They’re considered heroes to the dwarves. The only ones who faced dragon fire to save our people.”
He was quiet for a moment. Bilbo was still fidgeting with excitement. “Do you see what I’m thinking? Perhaps Thranduil doesn’t have to rob the mountain. Perhaps the treasure is delivered to him.”
Thorin propped his elbow on the table and rested his head against his hand. “It makes no sense. Why would the beast do Thranduil’s bidding? The monster has no honour or mercy. It would not gift a coin from its hoard to buy any creature’s friendship, even another dragon.”
“I don’t know. Perhaps Thranduil has some way of threatening it?”
“My sister and I have tried proposing weapons for killing dragons, over the years, something like the old Windlances, designs improved by the City engineers and the elvish magicians together,” Thorin rubbed his brow. “Thranduil always found a way to delay paying for such a weapon. I don’t know how else you would threaten a dragon.” He shook his head. “I don’t know, Bilbo. Perhaps it’s nothing. You got this list of dragon sightings from a mad star-gazer’s inherited weather-almanac, and on this happenstance you’re trying to answer both of my questions in one strike of your hammer—”
He stopped, staring at the top of the paper, at the first date on the list which Bilbo had indicated. Bilbo, heedless, said defensively, “I’m not saying I’ve solved the whole mystery, I’m just saying it’s something to look into further…are you alright?”
“This date,” Thorin pointed. “The first flight towards the City.”
“Oh, yes, I don’t know about that one,” Bilbo peered at it. “It’s more than twenty years before the pattern really gets going, so that might be nothing.”
“I remember this day,” Thorin said faintly.
Bilbo glanced at him. “Are you sure? That was a long time ago. I barely remember what date my milk bill is due in Bree, and that comes every month.”
“I know it,” Thorin whispered. “Seven days before the winter solstice. He left the first night of the winter festivities. I know the year because my sister came of age the next year, and I had to do the ceremony. Because I was her only family. Because my father had left us a week before the solstice,” and then, feeling his chest shudder as he tried to breathe, he corrected himself. “Because my father disappeared that day.”
The silence fell between them for a very long while. At last, Bilbo said, “I think it’s time I went into the City.”
Chapter 6: The Fig Garden
Notes:
I’m just gonna make this an author’s note because it’s entirely my fault for the confusion:
This chapter and the next chapter (Bilbo’s timeline, essentially) is still catching up with Kili’s timeline; this chapter occurs before Tauriel’s death.
Chapter Text
When Bilbo had put on his ring and slipped into the City, he thought he must have hit his head, got his spirit mixed up on its way out of his body, and accidentally gone straight to the undying realms.
He took off the ring and did his best to keep his hood up. In his experience, unless someone was talking right in his face, he could pass for a dwarven child. Especially if he kept moving and looked like he knew where he was going; people didn’t tend to stop you if you looked like you knew where you were going.
But it was hard to hide his face when there was so much to see. It was like something out of a story book. As he had approached the main gate of the city, the forest had opened up into a huge avenue of trees, wide enough for more than twenty elves to ride abreast. On either side, selected trees had been left standing and trimmed until their trunks were like the columns of an ancient temple rising so high that birds flying between their topmost twigs looked like tiny specks. Although Bilbo had never been into one of the ancient halls of the great dwarf lords, he’d seen drawings and read descriptions in books, and there was no doubt that this welcoming esplanade in front of the city was modelled on those ancient, underground halls, so that a traveller arriving here would have no doubt that his place was a union of elven and dwarven craft and beauty.
Once he slipped invisible through the gates, he found himself on the long, smooth streets, lit by the flameless lamps. They swept in graceful ribbons between tall, arched buildings of wood many stories high. What a marvel, to build five or even six stories all of wood and not have it fall down on your head - only dwarven mathematics could have managed it, only elven patience and understanding of the grain and strength of wood could have raised them.
The City had been built within the living forest without razing it entirely: huge trees predating the buildings still stood everywhere, the roads curving around them. Their branches supported walkways and smaller shelters, or extended right through purpose-built gaps in the buildings, so that even when walls had corners they rarely had many right-angles. The air had a pleasant warmth, and was full of changing scents as the greenery and the open-air eateries mingled in different measures. There was not the stink of the towns and cities that Bilbo was used to, the ever-present smell of waste, animals and industry. Everything distasteful was drawn away by hidden waterways; clean fountains emerged from spouts on street-corners every few dozen yards.
Elves and dwarves filled the streets, on foot or occasionally pulled in small carts by ponies, so that if Bilbo let himself get distracted by the sights he was constantly in danger of being knocked over. Everybody seemed to be smiling and dressed in fine cloth, in fashions that made Bilbo feel the urge to rush to the nearest tailor and beg to have a new wardrobe made at once before he embarrassed himself. And there were children everywhere, of all sizes, running with their school books under their arm, clustered together with heads bent in gossip, climbing across the roofs and tree-branches while governesses and grandmothers called to them from below, warning them of the consequences if they didn’t come down at once.
It was a dreamland. How could Thorin have left? Bilbo thought if he’d been in Thorin’s place, he would have risked the trial rather than walk away. Imagine trading all this for Bree.
He spent most of the first day trying to get his bearings in the large and winding neighbourhoods. He found the Palace easy enough: at the heart of the city rose a great hill of stone, surrounded by cliff-shadowed rivers and filled with natural caves that had been furnished and extended. This had once been the entire permanent abode of the wood-elves, large enough to shelter all of them in times of war, yet now it was only the smallest and oldest district in the City. Bilbo did not yet want to put the ring back on and head straight into the centre of Thorin’s proposed conspiracy, so he left the palace for now. Instead, he went looking for the address that Thorin had given him, just so he would know where it was if he needed help in a pinch.
It took him until the early evening to find Thorin’s house. It was in what seemed to be the core of the dwarven-dominated part of the city, on the nicest street, but all the same it was an unremarkable terraced cityhouse, no larger than its neighbours, with a pale blue door and many, large windows. He waited on a curb nearby with a small pastry he’d managed to swipe from a busy bakery, leaving behind a Laketown coin on the counter that he hoped would cover the cost. He didn’t want to risk any conversations with shopkeepers, so he would have to feed himself by theft after this, and he was out of money anyway.
After a short while, he watched a dark-haired, regal-clothed dwarrowdam returning. She had a younger dwarf walking beside her, also dark-haired and wearing the grey-green uniform of the guard; although Bilbo only saw their faces briefly before they turned away, they seemed to be laughing about something. The two of them fitted the description Thorin had given of his sister and his younger nephew, Kili. All seemed well between them, so after they’d gone inside and he’d finished his pastry, Bilbo loitered in front of a nearby front garden, admiring the flowers he had no names for, and some time after another young dwarf came out, yellow-haired and with a long blue cloak: evidently this was Fili. He seemed to have a furtive look about him, and Bilbo was too intrigued by that to leave well enough alone.
Bilbo followed Fili through the quiet, residential streets until they reached what seemed to be a busy district of smithies and carpenter’s workshops. Bilbo watched him pull up his hood and take several corners in quick succession and seemingly at random. Bilbo was sure Fili didn’t know he was there, but he was clearly worried about being followed. At the edge of the workshops, the streets merged into an area of warehouses, and Bilbo had to drop back a little as the crowds disappeared. He nearly lost Fili around the side of one of the warehouses, but he heard a distant murmur of conversation and then the thud of a heavy door. Bilbo hurried around the corner and found only a single, dwarf-sized wooden door in the side of one of the smaller warehouses, which overlooked a canal.
Bilbo put on the ring and carefully tried the door, which seemed to be bolted from the inside. He circled the building until he was blocked by a wall, which he managed to scale, thankfully still wearing the ring as he was far from graceful. On the far side was a small, exclosed courtyard extending to a dock over the water. There were loading doors facing the canal but also a small, grimy, narrow window low down, looking into what seemed to be a large basement. Bilbo pressed his face to it and could just make out a gathering of many dwarves, more than three dozen at a glance. They seemed to be standing and listening to a voice somewhere out of Bilbo’s sight, but he couldn’t make out the words or many details.
He was getting distracted by it all. He was here to do a job, and he wouldn’t find the answers here. He needed to get into the palace and hope that he had sharper ears than the elves.
—
Dis was just sitting down in the comfortable chair in the living room. She had been up since dawn in her official royal reception room, which was a small parlour with a few chairs and a desk, attached to the side of the Tinkerer’s academy. She could be found there most waking hours of most days. There she had meetings with dwarves and elves from across the City, ordinary people with ordinary lives, bringing her small complaints and grievances that for them were enormous and world-altering disasters. The parlour was leased from the academy for a peppercorn rent, and almost everything inside it was donated by merchants and trade-dwarves who considered her royal status to still have any meaning. Who still, quietly, greeted her as ‘your highness’ and gave her the traditional bows when they said farewell.
She’d had a small business before Thorin had disappeared, in gem appraisals and mineral studies for the mines. But she’d sold everything to cover the missing money and smooth things over with the dwarven families who donated it for the Khuzdul school. This was the school that Thorin had said he was going to build, but no stone of which ever materialized. Thorin had constantly said there were delays; every building he tried to lease pulled out of the contract, or suddenly had permission denied by its neighbours, or no carpenter would provide a quote to renovate it to their needs. Finally he’d found one rundown old hall in the warehouse district of the City and gathered the coin needed to purchase it outright; Dis had seen the chest when he brought it home. The same day, there had been a banging on the door and a forced search of their house by the Guard, looking for contraband weapons, which Thorin had raged and roared was a charge beyond offensive in its ridiculousness. At the time, he’d warned the constables he would raise the issue directly with Thranduil, as they were walking out empty-handed without any sign of the reported weapons. Hours later he’d come to Dis looking greyer and older than she’d ever seen him, and sat down on the same old chair where she now sat, with his hands shaking.
“It’s gone. Every coin I took out to buy the deeds tomorrow, for the school house. The chest is missing. It was the Guard, they must have taken it, they must have… it has all been a conspiracy against me, all the delays to the school, all along, because I am a threat, any dwarf who stands out or tries to lead our people is a threat…”
She didn’t know whether to believe him or not. The story of a long trail of persecution was as convenient as it was mysterious and unprovable. It played into Dis’ prejudices so neatly that she didn’t know whether she could trust her own judgement. When their grandfather had been in the grip of madness, he had seen conspiracies everywhere, too. Before the dragon came, when gold flowing through Thror's fingers. Perhaps Thorin had finally gone the same way.
When the story of the missing money got out, the Guard wasted no time in charging Thorin with embezzlement, and he fled before the threat of exile could play out in court. Of course, her boys were completely on Thorin’s side, and believed every word their uncle said before he left. Dis supported Thorin’s story in public while paying off the missing money in private. In her heart she did not want to think that he could have robbed his own people, his own kin.
But why would he have run if he wasn’t guilty?
Dis was thinking of Thorin that evening, looking at the portrait of the three siblings on the wall above the bookcase. It was a small picture painted in thick brushstrokes by a skilled, dwarvish hand, with paints and pastel-powders from the Woodland. It had been made a few years after they arrived here, after the Mountain was lost. Dis was in the centre, so young she hadn’t a whisker on her face, in little princess braids and a dark green, silk dress that the painter had embellished with imaginary pearls; the real dress had been a re-sewn, secondhand robe gifted by one of Thorin’s elven friends. Thorin himself stood behind her left shoulder, brows heavy and brooding, hair as black as a raven’s wing, his coat a dark, royal blue. He looked so young it was hard to reconcile him with the greying, faded brother she remembered the night before he fled. Behind her right shoulder stood Frerin in a dark, burgundy robe. His pose and three-quarter profile were a perfect mirror of his older brother, but for his hair a faint shade fairer, and brushed little sleeker, and of course the smile broad on his face. His eyes were as warm as hearth-stones; he had Thorin’s nose but Kili’s smile. Frerin was just as she remembered him, of course. He had never gotten much older than his portrait.
Dis tried to find the energy to get up and make herself some supper when the knock on the door came.
She flinched at the thought of having to deal with yet another complaint, in the evening and at home. She didn’t have the patience for this princess business. She shoved herself to her feet and marched towards the door, trying to compose a politer way to say, “Go away or I’ll show you where you can stick it!”
But when she opened the door with a wrench of the handle, there was no one there. She boiled with fresh anger. How dare they, how dare someone play tricks? Her grandfather had been a king. If she’d had a sword in her hand and she’d caught the blighter who’d knocked, she’d have shown him some tricks, oh yes.
As she turned to close the door, she realised there was a piece of paper under her left foot. Dis frowned and looked at it for a moment, thinking it was something she’d dropped on the way in. Then she shut the door quietly, crouched and picked it up. The weight of the paper was cheap, the edge torn as if from a bound notebook. She unfolded it and pencilled within, it read: Please meet me at eleven tonight in the fig garden behind your street; yours, an honourable burglar in your family’s service.
Dis read it over three times. Then she went back to the kitchen stove and burned the paper before Fili got home.
Her son was very late. He would not say where he’d been, and he wanted to pick a fight with her as soon as he got in the door. Being late and secretive had not been unusual for Fili, at least recently, but starting arguments with his mother was definitely uncharacteristic. As always, the thing that had got his hackles up was his brother.
“He told me everything you said. Why would you do that?” Fili griped. “I hope you’re happy with your meddling, because he’s gone and broken it off with Tauriel, as of some time this evening.”
“Good,” said Dis. “I’m happy to hear it. That’s what I wanted.”
“It wasn’t any of your business, Ma!”
“It was all of our business. We are not common diggers. We are the elder line of Durin,” Dis hissed at him. “I can’t believe you kept it secret from me. You’re supposed to be the sensible one, Fili. Ah, Mahal hear my prayer, I wish he’d sent me daughters, since sons cannot see beyond the tips of their—”
“Ma, he’s a grown dwarf! Let him make his own mistakes!”
“It’s done. I won’t speak another word about it. If anyone else finds out what Kili and that catamount were doing, it will be the end of his commission in the Guard, you mark me. Tell no one, pretend it never happened. I’m going to bed,” Dis snapped, and shut the bedroom door in his face.
She waited until he’d stopped moving around the house and seemed to have settled in his own bedroom, and then she took a dark cloak and slipped out into the street. The bells of the dwarven temples struck their last chimes at ten, so all she knew was that it was some time later than that.
The fig garden was an old piece of disused land not far from her house, between a row of narrow, wooden homes and a tall factory block. It had been one of the earliest dwarven burial plots in the City, back when this area had still been half-wild woodland, but the bodies had been moved to a newer graveyard some decades ago, and the families who’d laid their relatives down here had fought over what to do with the consecrated but now empty slice of land for so long that they themselves had mostly died or left. Wild figs, honeysuckle and fat pines had grown up through the empty graves and choked the forgotten headstones until it was unofficially reclaimed as a public garden. There was an open gateway at each end, so it was particularly popular for trysts where the lovers wanted to enter and leave without being seen together.
The handwriting on the note had been as unfamiliar as the make of the paper. Dis had no idea who she was looking for, but she was not worried. This was a dwarf neighbourhood. Who would hurt the last princess of the Longbeards? Even if some mad political assassin was plotting against her, they’d want to make a public statement, not do away with her in secret in the shadows.
There was a small, polite cough right behind her. Dis turned more quickly than was dignified.
There was someone sitting on one of the old, ivy-covered gravestones that she had just passed. It was a small person, curly-haired and beardless, but with a face that was far from childlike. Somehow in the dark she had not seen him, though she must have walked within a yard of him.
The person hopped off the headstone and bowed. She was baffled to see that his feet were bare and he was wearing a sheepskin-hemmed jacket in a Laketown fashion. His voice was polite as he straightened up and asked, “Would you be the Lady Dis?”
“I’d be the Princess Dis,” she said firmly, not bowing in return.
“My apologies. Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit lately of Bree in the West, at your service,” he pressed one hand to his chest. “I’ve been sent to speak with you as discretely as we are able.”
“By who?” Dis narrowed her eyes.
“By my employer,” Bilbo bobbed a little. “Your brother.”
Dis stared at him for several long seconds, while Bilbo gave her a smile that seemed both apologetic and impertinent. At last she said, “I think we should retire to my house, it’s very close.”
“Oh, really? This seemed like such a good spot, an abandoned graveyard at midnight; though I didn’t want to keep you up that late, so I made it eleven.”
“Anyone could come upon us, especially at this time of night,” she said, businesslike and gathering her skirts so they would not catch on the thorn bushes as she turned. “Come along, and quickly. Your shape will be memorable if we’re seen together. How did you get into the City?”
“Trade secret, I’m afraid. Is there anyone else home? Thorin said I should speak to nobody, but if I had to speak to somebody, it should be you.”
“My eldest is, but he’s well asleep,” Dis insisted.
A few minutes later, they were ensconced in Dis’ kitchen, around a tiny table with a mug each of lukewarm coffee from a pot left on the stove earlier in the night. Dis watched the hobbit. He had a nervous energy, like a rabbit, but Dis also had the sense that Bilbo wanted to appear nervous, to put her at ease and to make himself seem more harmless. Anybody who could enter the City undetected and walk straight up to the ancestral leader of the City’s dwarves was not, in her opinion, anything close to harmless.
“How long have you been watching me?” she asked.
“A couple of days. Only when you’re out and about, mind you, I’m not a spy,” he said with a roll of his eyes. “I just need answers to a few questions, and this place is shut up tighter than a dowager’s coin-purse. Everybody talks in riddles, even when they don’t know I’m listening.”
“What questions?”
Bilbo gave her a pained smile. “Thorin said you have kept journals, all your life, or at least, all your life here in the forest. He needs to know about certain dates, some very long ago.”
“Why?”
“I’m afraid I’m only being paid to answer Thorin’s questions,” Bilbo set his mug quietly on the table and rested his fingers around the rim, turning it slowly. “And some of the answers may be very dangerous.”
“Is my brother safe?” Dis said quietly.
“If he stays where he is,” Bilbo shrugged.
Dis felt the corner of her eyes sting. “I didn’t know if he was alive,” she whispered. “He disappeared, like our father. Our cousin Balin insisted he would be safe, but what did he know of what happens beyond the borders of this forest? We know nothing of the world, cloistered here in our mansion of wonders and tranquility.”
Bilbo was quiet for sometime, looking at her with some deeper pity than she thought the rant had warranted. At last he said, “I can’t promise you that he can ever come back to the City, but it’s clear that since he left he’s done nothing but think of you all and scheme about how to change the fortune of all the dwarves. If you help me, it will help him.”
“Of course I will,” Dis said, slumping back in her chair. “What dates does Thorin want to know about?”
Bilbo pushed his mug aside and from his coat, he produced a small book wrapped in amber-coloured leather, full of scribbled notes. He flipped it open to a marked page and began to read them out to her.
Dis went to the box at the end of her bed and found the stacks upon stacks of journals she had kept since she was a child. They were in fairly good order, and after asking him twice to repeat the list, she managed to find the corresponding book for each one. She set the empty mugs by the sink and piled the books on the table between herself and Bilbo.
“I don’t know if they’ll be of that much use,” she said. “It’s mostly pretty dry and sparse, a few words or lines for each day, unless something particularly interesting happened to me personally.”
“We’ll see,” Bilbo said, and read her the first date on the list. “Can you tell me what happened then, and perhaps a couple of days either side–”
That was an old journal, the pages yellow and sticking together from being long squashed at the bottom of the box. Dis flicked through the dates and shrugged. “Nothing in particular. Apparently I was still doing my apprenticeship as a rock-surveyor. I complained about my master.”
“Check a few days on either side,” Bilbo said.
Dis scanned the pages. “Let’s see… I was planning a trip to the Mirkwood Mountains, for my education. Before that… hmm, some personal thoughts I had about another dwarf,” she blushed slightly. “No need to read those. Ah, and some gossip. A dwarf had gone into a rage and killed his wife and her sister, a week or so before. He confessed, and was exiled. I write some youthful opinions opposing marriage traditions. Not very original.”
Bilbo’s expression was more careful and controlled than at any time since he’d appeared to her in the fig garden. He said, very casually, “Interesting. Well, what about this date?”
It was a few years later. Dis found the next book she’d selected from her archives and turned to the relevant page. She read a handful of days worth of entries. “I am working for Thorin. I say it’s very boring,” she turned back a page. “I’m still complaining about Thorin being boring. And…” she stopped, looking back in time through the dense, precise lines of her own handwriting as if peering through a spy-glass. “...and a dwarf is caught trying to light fires in the autumn trees. He’s declared mad, but still exiled.”
She looked up at Bilbo, who was now very clearly keeping his face utterly blank. He said after a moment. “And was that common, back then? Such a harsh punishment? Maybe if we picked a date at random, we’d find the same?”
“No,” said Dis. “Very rare, or I would not have mentioned it.”
They went on to the next date and the next book. “I’m courting my future husband. I think he’s the most delightful thing Mahal ever made. This occupies most of my journal entries for the whole week,” she flicked back through the days. “Here. A dam is accused of trying to blackmail her lover into murdering her husband. Her lover reports her to the Guard. She is exiled.”
She retrieved the next book. She saw now that Bilbo was writing in Westron next to each date: dwarf exiled.
“This week: I’m heavy with child and writing about all the miseries and how hard he kicks. Right into my ribs. The midwife says that means it’s a boy,” she turned the page. “A smith is found forging weapons against the prohibition, though he insists they are only for decorative purposes. He is exiled.”
The next book. “I am pregnant again, I’m not as sick this time. The kicks seem much gentler. The midwives are sure it’s a girl,” Dis glanced wryly at Bilbo. “It wasn’t.” She ran her finger over the faded, ink dates that she had laid down so many decades ago. “A dwarrow’s young babe dies in suspicious circumstances. Horrible rumours. A trial, the magistrate declares her guilty of deliberately smothering him, she is exiled.”
The next date, she shook her head. “I… it was a difficult time. I didn’t record most days. There’s nothing, no entries for weeks.” They try the next one. “We are living in Thorin’s old house, before he moved here. My boys fill most of my writings, I don’t talk about anything else. Let’s go to the next one, here it is. I don’t think there’s… ah, yes. No details, but a name, a dwarrow. I knew her a little from Temple, I write that I took her for a drink to comfort her. Her brother has been exiled, it doesn’t say why.” They went to the next date. “The lads have just started at a new finishing school, the City had to build a new one because there were so many young dwarves and elves growing up at that time. I write: a professor at the engineer’s academy has been accused of seducing his students by threatening them with failure. He’s to be exiled,” the next book, “A dwarf gets into a fight, his opponent falls in a river and drowns. Many witnesses, a quick trial, he is exiled,” she grabbed the next book as Bilbo reads the date. “I’m building my new business. I think I was very busy, because I don’t write much, I can’t see anything useful. The next one? Hmm… history scholar. Accused of encouraging violence against the City Guard. A dwarven student attacked a constable, the student is fined, the professor is exiled. I write about it a lot, because no one considers it justice.” They turn to the next book. “Here, I can’t see any exiles, but there is something I mention… a dwarf vanished and was never found. I remember this, it was not so long ago. He was an old Erebor nobleman who had always opposed our settlement in the Woodland, always harping on about it. He was a conservative old boar but it was a strange case. Tell me the next one? Yes, here’s another: I write that a dwarf was found keeping his elderly, sick father imprisoned, in squalid conditions, in order to cover up years of thieving from his father’s business. Exiled. What’s the next date?”
Bilbo looked up from his notebook. “That’s the last one.”
“That was a decade ago. Weren’t they regular, before then?”
“Roughly every seven years, give or take,” Bilbo nodded, looking back down at his list, his tongue briefly sticking out the corner of his mouth as he made some quick calculation. “But yes, there’s been nothing since then. If the pattern had held, there should have been another date in my list in 2938 or 2939, though it’s not that predictable. Was there anything noteworthy, around then?”
Dis felt her fingers clench around the journal in her hand. She said hoarsely. “Perhaps. Thorin left in late 2938.”
Bilbo’s head shot up, his eyes wide. After a moment he closed his notebook, got up and went to the kitchen bench. He picked up his cup and swallowed the cold dregs of his coffee, as if his throat had grown suddenly dry, and finally turned to her with his arms folded. “How much do you know about why he left?”
“He fled before he could be tried for theft. The rumour was he would be charged as an enemy of the people, because it was supposed to be a state school, so the theft was harm to the whole City even though the money was from private donors. He thought that he would be exiled. I couldn’t believe the magistrate would do something so outrageous, not to Thror’s grandson,” Dis answered. After a moment she said, “I know he was asking questions, before the money disappeared. Questions he would only hint at. He’d never acted so secretive before. There were days I thought…” she hung her head. “He was paranoid. I thought perhaps he was going mad.”
The hobbit didn’t answer. She realised suddenly that she had been lured into giving up everything he’d asked for and had been given almost nothing in return. What a fool. She really was rubbish at this politics business, she wished she was still a gem-appraiser. She leaned forward in her chair. “Bilbo, where did my brother find these dates? You didn’t come here knowing any of this. What do these days mean to you, to Thorin? What else happened on those days?”
Bilbo tapped his pencil on his chin and then tucked it behind his ear distractedly. “It might be more than your life is worth to know the answer. I don’t think Thorin would forgive me if I put you in danger.”
“Danger from who? I’ve already helped you, I’m part of this business now.”
Bilbo shook his head. “All I can say is that I don’t think Thorin was paranoid enough.”
Dis slammed her fist into the table, making the pile of discovered journals slip over like a small rockslide. “Curse Thorin, he cannot do this alone! They are my people too, they are my responsibility! Tell me what happened on those days!”
Bilbo held her gaze. He had not flinched at her outburst. At last he said, “Dragon flights.”
“What does that mean?”
“The dragon was seen flying from the Mountain to the City. And perhaps… and this is only an educated guess on Thorin’s part, we haven’t found any evidence of this yet… new mithril appeared in the City’s vaults.”
In the quiet that followed, Dis heard her own heart thudding in her ears. And then they both heard something else: the sound of a door creaking in the house. Dis had only a moment to sweep the journals off the surface of the table and shove them into the shadows behind the legs of her chair, before Fili walked into the kitchen.
“Ma, what are you awake for?” He rubbed her eyes. “I heard a bang.”
Dis glanced towards where Bilbo stood, but he was gone. Like he’d been a ghost all along. The doorway to the front hall stood open and well-lit, but Dis had not seen the hobbit move nor heard the front door open.
“I’m alright. I dropped something,” she bent and picked up one of the journals off the floor. “Here. I was just writing.”
Fili looked at her, and then at the two empty coffee mugs beside the sink. “By yourself?”
Dis stood up. “Yes. Go back to bed.”
Fili would not be deterred. He put one hand on his hip. “You had a visitor? At this hour?”
“And if I did? Do I have to share names with you?” Dis said haughtily. “I’m a grown dam.”
He snorted and scrubbed his hand through his hair, yawning. “Very well. I won’t ask.” He started back towards his bedroom.
Dis said, before she could stop herself, “Fili?”
He looked back at her, one hand on the door frame. She remembered how hard he used to kick her in the ribs, before she’d ever seen his face. She should never have let her sons go, never let them run further than her arms could reach.
They were all impossible to hold onto. She’d begged Frerin and Thorin not to go to Moria with their grandfather, not to leave her all alone. Frerin had promised her he would come back; Thorin was wise enough even at that age not to make such promises. But it was Thorin who had returned, along with their father. Thrain was diminished by the losses; where he should have grown and ascended into the kingship, he had seemed to shrink away from it, using the bitter excuse that the elves didn’t recognise his authority. As if a lack of official titles had ever stopped Thorin in the years before then. But she couldn’t blame her father: he had lost his wife to Smaug, his father in the Dimrill Dale, his loud and cheerful son in the final orcish massacre. He was left with an angry daughter and his dour and distant eldest son, all of them divided by their shared anguish.
Thrain believed the dwarves of Erebor had gone soft, that if they had only gone to war in greater numbers, Moria would have been won. Dis could see that he blamed Thorin for that softness, because Thorin had forged their union with the elves, Thorin had fed their people with the elves' hospitality. He couldn’t see what Dis could: that Thorin was the only one of them whose core of obsidian dwarvishness was still holding strong in those strange and malleable days. Thorin had been able to change his face, his dress, learn Sindarin and foreign etiquette, because he had complete surety in who he was underneath. The surface was mere glamour.
When their father showed them the map and the key and had spoken of returning to Erebor, Dis threw herself into his lap and pleaded like she was a little child again, sobbed to him that she couldn’t lose her father, too. But her tears hadn’t been enough for Thrain. He vanished: their own father had abandoned them, orphaned them.
Dis was determined she would not be the last one left. “Fili, whatever you’re hiding, keep it secret,” she said quietly. “Even from me. Protect yourself.”
“I don’t know what you mean,” he smiled. “I’m the sensible one, remember?”
She nodded. “And please, please, don’t get your brother involved. I think he's truly respected in the Guard, but they're always watching. He can’t make any more missteps.”
Fili held her eye, trying to read her like a journal, but at last he seemed to give up. He shrugged, “I’ll try my best. He does whatever he wants, Ma, you know that.”
He slipped away into the darkened hall back to bed. After his door had shut in the distance, Dis thought of the trees burning, not the ancient trees of the woodland, but the young pines on the mountain, and the screams of the dwarves who escaped, half-alive, dying upon the threshold. Her mother had been among them, unnoticed in all the terror, perishing alone beneath the Mountain’s cold gaze.
In the quiet house, she swore she heard soft footsteps on the polished wood and then the click of the door outside. She went to check the door was closed, and when she returned she noticed there was a new note torn from Bilbo’s book and lying in the middle of the kitchen table: If you need me, summon me with a candle in the front window. Something colourful, please! –BB
Chapter Text
Tauriel kept her hood over her face until she stepped through the gate of the fig garden, then she pushed back the cloak and walked silently between the empty graves.
There was a little mist in the cool, autumn air, but even in the dulled shadows she could see Princess Dis waiting for her. She sat on a worn, wooden bench at the edge of the garden. Around her rose old, broken stones, the runes long worn to smoothness and creepers wrapped around their feet. Dis did not hear her until Tauriel was standing right in front of her. Tauriel saw her jump a little and put her hand on her heart.
“I suppose I deserve that,” Dis said, nodding at her. She added drily, “Thank you for leaving your swords behind. I’m sure you were tempted.”
The princess was a solid-framed, tall dwarrowdam, her hair even more solid black than her brother’s; or at least, she had plaited it in such a way as to hide any grey. She’d kept her beard thick on the chin but without a moustache. She looked more like her elder son than her younger, which was some comfort.
“Why did you bring me here?” Tauriel asked. “You don’t need to warn me off. Kili asked me to stay away from him, and I will.”
Dis held her gaze. Her eyes were hard, and haughty. It occurred to Tauriel that Dis sat proudly upon a lineage that traced its name back to the first age, great names through battles and civilisations that would echo long after both of them were dead; while she, Tauriel, came from nowhere and had a name nomadic and unwritten in any great text. So maybe there was not just prejudice, but snobbery in the dwarf-woman’s eyes as well.
“I need help,” said Dis at last.
“From me?” Tauriel laughed bitterly. “Do you command me, now?”
“No, but I trust you. I think he acted unwisely, but he did not choose you for your pretty face,” Dis said. Tauriel bristled. And she noticed that Dis wouldn’t even say Kili’s name in front of Tauriel. The princess must consider even that unsavoury. But then Dis’ tone changed. There was a note of humbleness in it for the first time. “And since Thorin left, I don’t have a lot of friends in the palace.”
Tauriel narrowed her eyes. “This isn’t to do with Kili, is it?”
“No and yes. It is to do with all of us, all the children of Erebor,” Dis sighed and slumped back against the bench. “Will you sit with me?”
Tauriel would have rather stood, but her curiosity was getting the better of her. She sat down at the other end of the bench, so there was plenty of space between them. Dis twisted the rings on her fingers and looked around to be sure there was no one else in the garden.
“What are you afraid of?” Tauriel asked.
“This City,” Dis said quietly. She met her eye again. “I need to know what happens to the dwarves who are exiled for the most serious crimes. After they’re taken from the city, I need to find out where they go.”
Tauriel said irritably, “Not just dwarves, your highness. The law treats all the same, and elves suffer exile too. You must know what happens to them, as you still rule your people, for your small part.” She felt pleased at the jibe, and guilty at the same time, but Dis didn’t even react.
“The dwarves are the ones that matter,” said Dis. “I thought about trying to find the court records, but I doubt there’s any trace of them there after their sentence is passed.”
“There will be no record of them anywhere in the city. They are set upon the narrow east-west way that runs through the forest to the City, with food and clothing. Once their feet touch that path no resident of this City may speak to them or give them comfort or help, nor receive or send messages to them. You know this. And if you’re trying to contact your brother, he banished himself, and there will be even less known of his fate.”
“And who puts them on the path?” Dis pressed, leaning towards her, voice lowered to a deep baritone. “Who sees them disappear into the forest? Who sees them walk into the shadows and stops them returning?”
“The Guard,” said Tauriel.
“You? Have you seen it?” Dis hissed. “Have you, in all your long years in the service of this city, seen any poor soul try to return?”
“To return is death—”
“Would you not risk death to see those you love, one last time?” Dis asked her, which felt like a taunt. “Why have we never heard of any dwarf trying to sneak back home? Or trying to clear their name from exile? The Iron Hills are not beholden to our laws, nor Ered Luin. Why don’t letters come from there, on behalf of exiles, begging the king or his magistrates for forgiveness?”
Tauriel felt sure she had an answer, but when she tried to think of it, too many half-made excuses came to mind. Perhaps few survived the journey alone; it would be sad, but this was the risk a criminal took when they chose to break the laws.
Dis shook her head. “You’ve never seen them exiled with your own eyes, have you?” She asked. “It’s not done by the forest patrols or the City watch. It’s the praetorians who carry out the sentence, isn’t it?”
Tauriel looked at her askance. “How do you know that?”
Dis said softly. “They are the hands of the king. They stood by him against the dragon fire. They carry out his justice and purge the worst criminals from his halls. They guard his Mithril, without which the City itself would die,” she nodded at Tauriel. “If anyone has a record of the exiled dwarves’ fate, it will be the praetorians. Do you have access to their quarters?”
“No,” Tauriel shook her head. “They don’t come to the central barracks, except perhaps to train. They have rooms in the palace.”
“I know,” said Dis. “And as I said, I have no way into the palace. But I have been told that there is a door in the praetorian quarters, sometimes they go in and come out with papers. There must be archives in there, but there is no way in. You are one of Thranduil’s favourites, I hear. You can walk where you will.”
“I am not going to break into the praetorians’ quarters on your demand!” Tauriel snapped.
“You don’t need to. All I need you to do is find a key to that door, and slide it into the gap under the bookshelf in the Praetorian’s mess room. After that we will take care of the rest.”
“We?” Tauriel asked, and when she saw Dis pause, her face blank but her jaw suddenly stiff as she realised the mistake, Tauriel guessed, “You’re not looking for news of your brother. He’s already here, isn’t here?”
“Of course not. Everyone in this city knows his face.”
“I shall report all of this. You can spout your conspiracy theories to the Guard when we arrest you.”
“Do as you will,” Dis shrugged. “See how quickly they leap at the chance to charge me with plotting and treason, and exile me, too. Then at least I’ll find out the truth the hard way.” Her eyes grew hard. “See how long my sons last before the City’s ‘justice’ takes care of them, too. Thorin and Thranduil built this city together before your king denied him our sovereignty and drove him away. The line of Durin will always be a shadow over Thranduil’s throne. They’re going to pick us off one by one. Kili will be next. You can sit back and watch it happen if you like.”
Tauriel fumed at her. “You’re a manipulative harridan, your highness. And you’re as mad as your brother. No one is out to get you and your family. I don’t know how you managed to bear such decent and good-hearted sons, quite frankly.” She stood up. “Good night. Don’t try and speak to me again.”
She turned and strode away, refusing to look back to see whether Dis was smiling or glaring at her.
—
The next night after midnight, Tauriel was in the praetorian’s quarters carrying a ring of keys. She was cursing Princess Dis the entire time, but silently. If she was caught here, she would lose everything she still held dear. But she had not been able to stop thinking about the Princess’ questions since their meeting in the fig garden.
She had come to the Palace on the pretense of visiting Prince Legolas. She had to admit she had missed spending time with him recently, as he was one of her oldest and dearest friends. They walked the upper paths above the palace over the course of the evening, among the hanging gardens. Epiphytes and mats of evergreen flowers grew in hollows and naturally shaped balconies of soil formed in the boughs of the huge, many-thousand-year-old trees. Their roots cradled the roofs of the Palace caves, the heart and oldest part of the ancient realm.
Legolas had been more than a little excited to see her, although you had to know him well to be sure. He said she had seemed distant and reticent for months, and that he’d feared he’d offended her, or that some darker trouble was on her heart. She did not tell him that she had been so caught up in her forbidden romance with Kili that she had had little spare time, a had thought little of how that would afffect their friendship.
“There's no burden I carry in my heart,” she insisted. “I was just distracted, the last few weeks.”
“You don’t look well. Has something happened? Has someone hurt you?”
She was such a bad liar. She tried to think of a way to answer the question without giving more away. She was still full of anger at Princess Dis, and it suddenly turned to annoyance at her friend for prying, though he’d done nothing wrong. “I don’t wish to dwell on it,” she said sharply. “Can we speak of other matters?”
He’d withdrawn his questions, but after a pleasant hour or so she asked that they go back to his room for tea and then, as early as possible, made her excuses to leave. As he bade her farewell, Legolas asked to see her again sooner rather than later. She promised they would find a few days to go away together soon, perhaps just wandering in the wildlands that bordered the forest, like when they were younger.
As soon as they’d parted, Tauriel made for the praetorian’s hall. At this time of night most of the elite guard were out on duty or resting in their own homes. Most doors in the palace did not have locks, and Tauriel found her way into their mess hall without passing anyone in the dark. She saw that there was indeed a bookcase, standing on low, carven feet. She crouched and slipped the ring of keys, that she had stolen from Legolas’ chambers, onto the floor underneath it. Although the praetorians took their orders directly from the king, as the commander of the Guard, Tauriel was sure Legolas would still have the keys to anything in their quarters.
Then she slid into the shadows and waited.
—
After telling Dis what he needed only a day earlier, Bilbo was delighted to find she was an efficient agent. When he checked the bookshelf, there were indeed a ring of keys. He had to resist laughing to himself at how well this was all going as he tried them on the door of the praetorians’ cellar.
Inside was a tunnel of descending stairs at the back of the quarters. He slipped down and found himself entering a deep, windowless dark. He was sure he’d hear even an elf coming down those stairs, so he slipped off his ring to see better and looked around. There was a lamp hanging on the wall nearby which he managed to heave down and light with the twist of a switch.
He was standing in a series of small storage cellars off a central passage. These seemed to be mainly locked cupboards. Bilbo swung the ring of keys from his free hand and began to try them one by one. He found an armoury, a storeroom of uniforms, banners and basic supplies, and then finally came across what looked like a records archive.
Bilbo began to go through the shelves one by one. There were shelves of log books, piles of old schedules, reports on battles long won and adversaries long defeated, and chests full of papers going back thousands of years with the names of praetorians past and present. And then, at the back of the room, almost hidden between two narrow rows of shelves, he found what looked like a small, iron-fronted vault, as narrow as his chest and a yard tall, built into the stone wall itself. Imprinted on the door was a symbol he had grown familiar with in the palace: the sigil of the elven king himself. After some fumbling, one of the keys opened it.
Inside was an array of little narrow niches, small enough for a letter and barely wide enough to slide a hand inside. Each one had a tiny date carved into its shelf to label it, and beside that, two words. Some said “White Star” and some said “Green Star”.
Bilbo dragged over a chest packed with old papers so he could stand on top and reach up into the first niche. This was the oldest, marked with a date over five hundred years earlier - a “white star”. Inside was a small clutch of bound paper, and the moment he saw it he knew he’d found what he was looking for. The paper was a report, with some personal notes and signed records, of an elf who’d been tried and exiled for murder half a millennia ago.
As he ran his fingers down the rest of the labels, he noticed that all the early records were white stars, and only in the last hundred and fifty years was there a proliferation of green stars - since the dwarves had come to live in the Woodland. So the green stars must be dwarves.
He checked a few quickly, but the pattern was not perfect. There were one or two dwarves labelled as white stars, but almost all were green. There were no elves labelled as green stars. Bilbo began to browse some of the dwarven records at random; murders, arson, treason, abuse. They each matched one of the exiles that Dis had described from her journals. Most of the crimes would elicit no sympathy, but Bilbo had to remind himself that Thorin might have shared their fate if he had stayed to face justice, and yet he had always claimed innocence. How many of these despised exiles would have pleaded the same?
There was something else he noticed: where the white star records ended with a log of their punishment with the words, “exiled on the road” followed by a date, each of the green stars instead read, “exiled on the hill”, followed by a date, and then a measurement, slightly different each time: ‘3 oz’, ‘5 & 1/2 oz’, ‘4 oz’.
Aha. Could this be it? Could Thorin have been right? Did 3 ounces mean mithril - and was that a lot, enough to feed the city for seven years? Bilbo felt his heart race. He wished he didn’t feel quite so gleeful at the thought of telling this to Thorin, since it was not exactly a nice discovery.
He’d already been here too long, he had to leave before somebody came to get a fresh uniform and saw his lamplight down here. He made sure to reshelve each of the records, and then he noticed that one of the niches had something else in it. It was the very first green star, just above his eyeline. He put his hand in the niche and pulled out the whole bundle of papers within.
There was a solid object wrapped in squashed, folded vellum, all tied together with the paper records. Bilbo slid the vellum out of the ribbons to read more, and saw the name on the record, which said only:
Thrain.
A cold wave spread up his body as if the cellar had been suddenly flooded with snow-melt. He flicked through the record, no longer thrilled at bringing his discovery back to Thorin and confirming their worst fears. There was no crime recorded, no details, only the name, and a written order from King Thranduil, and the words on the final page: Exiled on the hill: 2809 : Dec : 13 : 12 oz.
Bilbo hesitated to put the bundle back in the niche. If it was noticed missing, it would be a disaster. But surely these records were not checked regularly - every seven years or so, perhaps. And it would mean so much to Thorin.
Bilbo pocketed the bundle, shut the vault and left the storeroom. He locked everything behind him, turned off the lamp and rehung it on the wall, and then hurried up the steps as silently as a hobbit could tread. He stepped into the mess hall and took one step into the room.
“Caught you,” said a soft voice.
Bilbo froze and raised his hands as he felt cool steel under his chin. Idiot. Why hadn’t he put the ring on downstairs? His eyes still adjusting to the dimness after the bright lamplight, he turned his head slowly to see an elf woman in a dark, green uniform, a short sword outstretched in her hand.
She narrowed her eyes. “So you are Princess Dis’ thief? You are not who I was expecting.”
“Please, some respect, I’m not a thief,” Bilbo raised his eyebrows at her. “I’m a professional burglar. I do honest work for honest folks.”
The elf took a step towards him and flicked back the lapel of his jacket to reveal the bundle of papers bulging in the pocket inside. “It looks like stolen goods to me.”
“Merely a trade in information for my client,” he smiled at her. “How about you just let me be on my way, and when I’m done, I’ll bring it all back? On my oath.”
“Your client? The princess?” The elf woman raised an eyebrow. “No - you’ve been sent by her brother, haven’t you? I’m afraid you won’t be leaving this palace with a pile of state secrets in your pocket, especially not to deliver them to a wanted criminal.”
“Fair call,” Bilbo tilted his head. He needed her to relax enough to look away from him, even for a moment, so he could disappear. “Go on. March me off to the cells. I promise I’ll come quietly.”
The elf woman instead grabbed one of his arms. “I’m not turning you in. I want answers, and I think you’ll be more willing if Dis is there to give them to me. Walk,” she shifted her grip to his shoulder and propelled him a few steps forward. “That wasn’t a request.”
Bilbo did his best to keep up with her long strides without tripping. “Ah, I’m really not supposed to be here, if anyone sees me we’re both going to have a very bad night.”
The elf paused to pull his hood over his head with her free hand. “Not if you stop struggling. No one will think twice about a dwarf walking around here, even a particularly small one. Say nothing to anyone and keep your head down, or I’ll raise every guard in this palace to hunt you.”
—
Dis was making progress on some particularly dull paperwork when the knock on the door came, jolting her out of her focus. She wondered if she could ignore it, but then it came again, louder and more frantic. She sighed and got up to answer.
Tauriel stood outside, leaning down a little to peer through the window set into the door. Dis took a step back. The elven captain was in her uniform this time, and carrying her swords. She also had one hand balled around the collar of a very sheepish looking Bilbo Baggins.
“I just caught this creature in the palace. Can I come in?” Tauriel asked with a glare.
“Er, please do,” Dis tried to compose herself. She felt ruffled and underdressed. Her braids were half undone and she had already taken off her jewelry for the night. She opened the door wide and waited until Tauriel and Bilbo were across the threshold before she gave a quick glance up and down the street and then shut it behind her.
“Tauriel. Bilbo. I admit, I was not expecting either of you, let alone together,” Dis said, self-consciously combing her hair flat with her hand. “Is this a polite call to let me know I’ve been reported for plotting and will be arrested shortly, or…?”
Tauriel shook her head, leaning back to look through the inner doorways of the house. “Are we alone?”
“Yes, Fili’s off on some late business and Kili left for a night patrol an hour ago.”
Tauriel relaxed a little, though Dis could not ignore the flash of disappointment on her face as well. She turned to Dis. “I did as you asked. I gave your burglar the keys and he seems to have found what you were looking for. Now you owe me an explanation as to why.”
Dis looked at Bilbo, who gave an embarrassed nod. “I have what we need. I’d rather you didn’t tell Thorin about the hiccough. Let’s say I always meant to bring this gentle elvish lady in on the plan?”
Dis waved them through to the parlour. “Come, sit, let’s take a moment to both compose ourselves.”
“I need you to tell me what you were looking for,” Tauriel growled, finally releasing Bilbo’s collar. He winced and rolled his shoulders.
“Take a dwarvish lesson and sit still for a bit. Do you want tea or coffee?”
“Water,” Tauriel said, and then, as if remembering something, she said. “Tea, if you don’t mind.”
It was always polite to accept a hot drink when you were a guest, even if you didn’t drink it. A lesson that Dis had drilled into her sons many times as youngsters, when they’d been forced to visit boring or decrepit distant cousins and important nobles. So at least some manners had rubbed off on Tauriel from her time with Kili.
“Coffee for me, please,” said Bilbo brightly.
Once they were settled with a cup each, Bilbo reached into his coat and brought out a wrinkled, half-crushed, lumpy sheet of vellum and began to unroll it. Dis put down her cup too quickly and nearly splashed tea across the little parlour table. She knew that sheet even before she could read it properly in the flickering lamps. She reached for it with numb hands.
“This is my father’s map of Erebor,” Dis murmured. As Bilbo flattened it out, the object within rolled on to the table. “His key. The key to the side door.” Dis picked it up, trembling as she held it to the light. “How did you come by these?”
“In the praetorian archives,” Bilbo said. He held out the rest of the papers to her. “With a record of your father’s exile. This was what Thorin really sent me to find proof of. I’m sorry I didn’t tell you earlier.”
Tauriel was looking down at the map, her hands hanging between her knees. She looked over-large and uncomfortable in the low, dwarf-made chair. Her skin was a little sallow, as if she hadn’t slept. Before Dis could take the bundle of papers from Bilbo’s hand, she reached across and grabbed them, her gaze scanning across them. She shook her head, sinking deeper into the chair. “This doesn’t make sense.”
Dis shook her head. “My father wasn’t exiled. He went east, looking for a way to reclaim the Mountain.”
Tauriel raised her head to look at her. “No, your highness. According to these papers, he did not leave the woodland of his own free will.”
Dis put the key down slowly, as if the iron was as fragile as dried grass. Her fingers moved over the faded ink lines on the map. “So he didn’t abandon us.”
Tauriel put the bundle down beside the map except for one small letter covered in thin, elegant writing, “Look here, the order for exile was written by my lord Thranduil himself. I know his hand. Now you must tell me, why?”
Dis closed her eyes. She fought to keep the tears from overflowing. Her father, her brave and stubborn father. Thrain should have lived a hundred more years, he should have seen his grandchildren born and grown into fine dwarrows, he should have died old and shrunken in his bed with his daughter by his side. And they had taken him away. And cruelest of all, they had made Dis and Thorin believe he had left his children and never looked back.
Dis felt the hatred burn through her veins. Thranduil had done this.
She picked up the last page of the papers, which showed her father’s name, the date of his exile and then - there, at last, the proof that Thorin had guessed and feared: ‘12 oz’. A record, she was sure, of payment received. Dis breathed deep and said, “We only know that the dragon comes, and the exiles go. Thorin thinks it is to do with Mithril. From the Mountain.”
“The dragon?” Tauriel stared between them. There was almost a smile on her lips, but then it slowly transformed into horror. “What do you mean?”
Bilbo said drily, “The City needs Mithril. Smaug has all Mithril you could ever want. And every seven years, a dwarf is ‘exiled’ and never heard from again. What do you think it means, Captain?”
Tauriel was silent. She said at last, “Then we have to stop it.”
Dis shook her head. “Not yet. Say nothing to anyone. If anyone learns we are on their scent, they will bury everything. We’ll never be able to prove it.”
Tauriel looked troubled. In the silence, they heard the front door. Dis snatched the map and key and tucked them quickly into a pocket deep in the folds of her dress. Bilbo picked up his coffee cup and took a few steps backwards, silently moving towards the door to the kitchen. When Dis glanced at him, he had completely vanished around the corner.
Fili walked in whistling, and stopped as he saw the pair of them. He stared between them with utter bafflement on his face. To her credit, Tauriel smiled at him warmly. “Hello.”
“Good to see you,” Fili said cautiously, with a glance at the swords on her bandoliers. He turned to Dis. “Is this your secret visitor?”
Dis jumped up, grabbing his shoulders and pulling him into a quick hug. “Darling, I really wish you would tell me what time you’re going to be home. I can’t plan anything around you.”
“You mean you can’t hide anything?” Fili hugged her back quickly. He frowned at her, cupping the side of her head. “Ma, are you alright? You look tearful,” he glanced at Tauriel.
“Yes, yes, I’m tired is all. Why don’t you sit down and have a cup of tea with us? We’re trying to make up as best we can, aren’t we, Captain? I decided I don’t need enemies in the Guard and asked Tauriel here so I could apologise.”
Fili gave Tauriel a very skeptical glance over Dis’ shoulder, and Tauriel nodded far too enthusiastically.
“Sure,” he said slowly. “I’ll come join you.”
“Actually, you can have my tea, I haven’t touched it,” Tauriel unfolded herself gracefully from the small chair and bowed to them both. “I really must get back to headquarters, they’ll be expecting me back from patrol. Thank you for taking the time with me, Princess Dis. We’ll talk again soon.”
“Mahal, make it so. I’ll see you out,” Dis took her by the elbow and led her to the door. In the moment of privacy they had on the threshold she said, “Where are you going in a hurry?”
“Just to return these keys before anyone notices them missing,” Tauriel held up the ring she had taken back from Bilbo.
“Tell no one what we have learned. I will send this news to Thorin, and when he replies, I promise I will call on you again. You have my gratitude beyond measure, Captain Tauriel. Please trust me in turn, and keep this secret between us.”
Tauriel gave her a pained look. “It is too terrible a weight to bear. We must act. What if someone else is exiled while we dither? I’ll never forgive myself.”
“I understand. But the risk is too great, if we act alone.” Dis squeezed her hand. “We need more help. Even if you have no affection for me, and I would not blame you a groat for hating me, can we be united in this?”
Tauriel nodded. Dis held the door for her and she went out into the night.Dis shook her head. Dis watched her go.
That was the last time they would speak, though Dis could not know that yet.
--
Fili tried to ask Dis what had happened, but she answered vaguely in single words and he soon gave up.
“I’m seeing Kili in the morning, after he gets off patrol,” he said, dropping into the chair Tauriel had just vacated and peeling his boots off. “Should I tell him that you’ve been inviting Tauriel over for tea?”
Dis looked at him for a long time. All of a sudden her objection to Tauriel seemed so mild, the anxieties of a lonely and overprotective mother. She had been doing what she thought was best for Kili. She still thought it was for the best, but these fears were nothing compared to the new horrors that the last few days had revealed. She wished more than anything that Thorin was here.
She shook her head. “Don’t tell him. It’ll get his hopes up and he might do something reckless. Give me time.”
He nodded, though he looked unhappy about it. They sat for a while, talking about ordinary things, while Fili finished off Tauriel’s tea. The map and key in Dis’ pocket felt as heavy as an anvil and hammer. But she tried to chatter and act as if nothing was wrong.
At some point, Dis found she had fallen asleep in the big armchair, and Fili had turned the lights out and draped a blanket over her. The house was quiet, but something had woken her. Her mind slowly came around to it; a quiet knock on the doorframe. She sat up to see Bilbo standing there.
“Sorry to wake you. I was hiding in the kitchen until your son went to bed.”
“You wanted to say goodbye?” Dis shook herself.
“Not quite,” Bilbo held out his hand. “I need to take the map and the key to Thorin. Fair to say I’ve earned my fee: this is more than he could have hoped for, though it’ll be hard news to break.”
Dis nodded. She took the map and the key out of the pocket of her dress and looked at them again, feeling the weight of her father’s ghost on them. She got up and gave them to Bilbo. “What’s he going to do?”
Bilbo drew a long breath through his nose. At last he said, “I don’t know. And I’m… I’m rather afraid to find out.” After a moment he added, “If you really need us, you can send a raven to the Laketown roost and they can send it on. Address it to Mr Luznâ, at the Black Arrow Inn. The landlady there is good at keeping secrets, for an extra coin.”
Dis watched him go from the front doorstep. She wished she could go with him. She wanted to see Thorin, wanted to be there when Bilbo confirmed what had happened to their father, wanted to share his grief. But Thorin would have told her to be strong as stone, and stay here in the City where she would be safe for now.
The next morning, she got up later than usual, drained by the revelations of the night before. She ate and dressed, and was just preparing to leave the house when Fili burst in and told her his brother had been arrested for murder.
Notes:
I will be away from digital access for about a week so there will be no new chapters until September, then posting will resume.
In the meantime, have a lovely end of the summer, bless you all, and I appreciate everyone reading; but please if you are enjoying this fic, comments are always appreciated.
Chapter 8: Convergence
Chapter Text
For the first day after Kili was arrested, everything for Fili seemed to be held both motionless and spinning, like a child's mobile. Kili was being held somewhere in a cell under the palace, but the praetorians seemed to have taken charge from the regular City Guard and no one was able to tell Fili much about where or how long he would be held. On the second day, they let Dis visit Kili, while Fili sat and waited for her on the street outside the palace. She was there for almost two hours, and came back looking as pale and old as he had ever seen his mother. She had been crying, though her cheeks were dry now. Fili held out his elbow and she linked her arm through it and clung tight.
"He's alright," she told Fili as they walked away. "They're treating him coldly but not unkindly. He's just frustrated and alone. They've told him nothing about why he's been accused. He asked to see Tauriel's body, but of course he doesn't want to tell them why, and even if he did, nobody will even consider it. I asked one of the guards if I could go and pay my respects, for myself - for whatever that's worth, I'd like to say sorry for my part - but the praetorian said she's already been buried in a small ceremony. She didn't have a lot of family, from what Kili said."
Fili glanced around before he spoke. "What do you mean, 'for your part'? Ma, tell me the truth, you didn't have something to do with this?"
"Of course I didn't!" Dis' voice regained a little of its usual brashness. "Fili, don't be stupid. Even if I'd wanted to... even when I was most angry at her for, for... for seducing my boy... I would never have been so silly. I would have guessed that Kili would be their first suspect. Exactly as it's played out."
"But then who?" Fili whispered. "She was... well, she seemed quiet, and inoffensive. And she's so close to Prince Legolas. Who would dare...?"
Dis' mouth was hard and thin. "She had an impulsiveness in her, that I think she would have claimed was her heart speaking. Reckless girl. Do you think she'd have chased Kili if she was a good elf? She was a rule-breaker, too. No wonder he liked her so much."
"How do you know? You barely knew her."
"She was helping me with something, something Thorin asked for," Dis said very softly. "And I told her to be careful. I think she didn't listen. But it’s my fault for meddling, for getting her involved." She added, almost to herself. "Mahal, when we get him out of this mess, he'll never be the same."
Fili tried to find out everything he could about what was going to happen next. A crime of this magnitude was simply so rare in the Woodland that it was hard to know what precedent would be followed and what would have to be invented by the clerks and magistrates of the law. Normally, if it was safe, anyone accused of a crime in the City which they denied would be released to their home until trial, with the assurance that their family would watch them and keep them confined. But Fili was not surprised to be told that such a thing was not permitted for murder. Eventually, unable to get much out of the officials in the halls of the palace, he spoke to Telion, Kili's archery trainer and the oldest elf he knew. Telion did have a memory of another contentious murder trial long ago, where the suspect was found to be wrongly accused; centuries and centuries he said, well before Tauriel was even born. But it had been a different time, when the Woodland realm could fit all of its populace into the king's palaces when danger threatened, and everybody was cousin or third-cousin of everybody else.
"Is there anything we can do?" Fili pleaded with Telion. "They won't tell us anything. We don't even know how she died."
Telion shook his head. "I fear these dark days are not some unlucky strike of lightning, but the bud of something poisonous growing across the whole City. Watch your step, Master Fili. Your mother has lost her father, her brothers and now one of her sons. I know you will give anything to help your brother, but think of her as well."
"She hasn't lost him," Fili said firmly. "Kili is innocent. That will be obvious at the trial."
Telion did not scoff at him, though he did not say he believed him, either.
–
Bilbo had left the City the night Dis and Tauriel had had their final conversation, carrying Thrain's key and nmap with no idea of everything that had happened afterwards. He had reached Laketown the next afternoon, after a long walk along the banks of the Forest River with the ring on his finger. Once he was past the gates of the Woodland realm, he was able to secretly hitch a ride on one of the many barges taking goods to and from Esgaroth.
Now he sat in the rented room of the Black Arrow inn. When he’d walked through the door an hour earlier, Inga greeted him as if he’d just come back from a trip to market, and not as if he’d been away for more than a week. She told him Thorin was still paying for the room, although she wasn’t sure exactly when he came and went. Still making trips to the mountain to scout out other possible ways in, Bilbo suspected.
He had accepted a meal from Inga and a chance to rest his feet in the room. Thorin’s bed was neatly made, his bag with most of his belongings tidily packed on the floor. Bilbo realised that after today, he would have completed everything Thorin had asked him. But unless Thorin returned from his latest trip to the Mountain with a few stolen treasures from the dragon’s hoard, Thorin had no way to pay him for the job.
Perhaps, he thought, he could use that as an excuse to stick around until Thorin could cover the debt. He tried to be rational. He needed to go back to Bree and close up the treasure hunting business at last. He was supposed to be retiring. If he didn’t return by the date he’d given the Sackville-Bagginses to move out of Bag End, and supervise their exit himself, his cousins would absolutely use it as an excuse to dig their heels in. He tried to remember how much he had missed his childhood home, how desperately these last few years he had wanted to return and replant the garden, spend his days decorating the house and reading all the books his mother had put in storage. He’d had a vague plan to write down his memoirs, all the wildest jobs he’d taken on, perhaps even make copies as a serialised publication if he could get the book-binders down in Bywater to collaborate. ‘The adventures of Bilbo Baggins, Professional Burglar’, that had been the plan. If he could invite Gandalf over for a visit, he might even be able to get more details about Bella’s life before her marriage and write a biography of her as well.
He’d been looking forward to retirement. And now he was staring at the empty bed in this grubby downtown inn, and he thought, I’m not ready to go home.
Perhaps what he’d found could clear Thorin’s name and allow him to return to the City in triumph. If he did, perhaps Bilbo could follow him - with the intention of chasing payment for his fee, of course. And then, if Thorin was restored to a place of respect among the dwarves of the City, he’d probably be willing to recommend Bilbo to others. There must be lots of need for a burglar in a place as rich and full of industry as the City, lots of backroom dealings that needed someone to listen in, lots of runaway husbands who needed catching under their assumed names, and plenty of stolen gems in need of investigating and recovery. Bilbo could probably start a very successful career in the City. And of course, he’d always have time in the schedule book for when the uncrowned King of the Dwarves came by with a new quest—
He was lost in this daydream when he heard heavy footsteps on the stairs. He sat up quickly as the real Thorin walked in, looking rather greyer and more tired than the glorious image in Bilbo’s mind. His face lit up with a broad smile as he saw Bilbo.
“Inga didn’t mention that you were back!”
Bilbo climbed off the bed. He remembered the news he had for Thorin and he couldn’t bring himself to smile in return. Thorin’s expression soured a little. “Was it not a successful trip?”
“It was more than successful,” said Bilbo, and waved him over to the table. “I think you should sit down.”
A few minutes later, he watched as Thorin turned the key over and over in his hand, examining it from all angles as if he hoped it was a forgery. The map lay in front of them. Beside it, Bilbo had placed the rest of the papers from the archives, laid out like fortune-telling cards.
“I’m sorry you were right,” Bilbo said quietly.
Thorin touched the card with his father’s name. “Twelve ounces,” he murmured. “The life of my father, for twelve ounces of Mithril. Some would say that is a fair ransom for a king, but I would not have sold him for the whole hoard of Thror.” He shook his head and put the key down on top of the map. “And all those others, walked to their fate without knowing until far too late…”
At last, Thorin looked up at Bilbo. “Thank you, Mr Baggins. You have performed more than admirably. Gandalf did well to recommend you.”
“You’re very welcome,” said Bilbo. “Now, I realise that since the mountain did not turn out to be unguarded, you may have some trouble covering my fee, but I’m happy to defer payment for as long as you need—”
“It’s alright, I’ve found a solution. After you left for the City I sent a raven from the Laketown roost to my cousin Dain, in the Iron Hills. He’s already replied to say he’ll loan me the money to settle things with you. His house does plenty of trade here, so he has accounts with the Esgaroth moneylenders. It took a day to arrange, but here. Dain has lent me enough to pay your expenses back to Bree as well, so you shouldn’t be out of pocket.”
Thorin reached into his coat and took out a small bag that sagged with the weight of coin inside. He put it down on the table in front of Bilbo.
“Here. Count it, and let me know if you think I’ve cut you short.”
He sat back in the chair and folded his arms, still staring at the map and the key.
“Oh,” Bilbo said. His stomach sank. Just like that, the adventure was over. It had just been another professional job, after all. Why had he expected anything else? “Well, what are you going to do next? With this information? ”
“Go to the Iron Hills and get Dain fully on my side,” Thorin said morosely. “From there, we shall have to see. Dain can get messages to my friends and family in the City. We need to be careful before we reveal this, or no one will believe it. It will take time.”
“To what end?” Bilbo asked. “What is all this for? You can try to start a revolution against Thranduil, revenge your father’s death, perhaps clear your own name, and likely get a lot of dwarves and elves killed in the process. But the City will still need Mithril.”
He felt puffed-up and annoyed at Thorin for so casually discarding him. He knew this was both completely unfair - Thorin had never promised him anything other than the fulfillment of a contract - and unkind - Thorin had just had his worst fears confirmed about his father’s disappearance. But he couldn’t help it. He had really imagined that Thorin thought of him as more than just a contract.
Thorin nodded. “My eyes are not swayed from the Mountain, but now I have the means to win the dwarves of the City back to my side. If the Iron Hills are with us, we may have a chance to finally kill the dragon at the heart of this foul arrangement. Destroy the rot, and both the City and Erebor may be renewed.”
“You have one dwarf on your side. Your sister,” Bilbo assured him.
Thorin sighed. “And therefore in the most danger if Thranduil realises his secret is out. But nevermind,” he rubbed his beard. “We have time. Thranduil took lessons from us; but from him, I have learned patience.”
“So we have one last night together,” Bilbo said, trying to sound cheerful instead of melancholy.
Thorin put his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder and squeezed it. Bilbo found himself leaning into Thorin’s grip, tipping his head so that it brushed the back of Thorin’s warm hand. “Shall we go out and make the most of it? Let me buy you a drink, to thank you. Perhaps even dinner.”
“Yes,” Bilbo smiled at last. “I think we can finally relax.”
The sun was low by the time they left the Inn. They had found a warm pub in a part of the town with a breeze flowing through the open windows, which blew the smoke and smell of the town away to the east. There was a large bay window overlooking the water where they sat and ate. From here, on the west side of the town, their view of the mountain was blocked by the rambling buildings and towers, but still Thorin’s eyes seemed to drift towards it in moments of quiet.
“Bilbo,” Thorin said, as they were finishing their meal. “You seem a little morose, if you don’t mind me saying. Have I done something to offend?”
Bilbo thought about smiling and assuring him no, everything was perfectly fine. But then, he was not beholden to politeness anymore - if he ever had been. He might be able to get a ferry tomorrow and simply leave, and make it back over the mountains before winter hit and the passes were blocked. The risk of making things awkward had dropped considerably.
“I will admit, I was a little put out,” he huffed, pushing his tankard to the side and knotting his fingers on the table in front of him. “That now that you got what you needed, you would cut me loose so easily, after our journey all this way.”
Thorin’s eyebrows rose and he leaned forward, one elbow on the table. “Cut you loose?”
“Yes,” Bilbo said primly. “Paid and sent on my way.”
“Send you on your way?” Thorin echoed.
Bilbo felt himself getting a little hot under the collar. “Am I talking to myself? Yes. Expenses back to Bree. All done, Mr Baggins, thank you very much.” He swept his hand through the air to illustrate the dismissal.
A small smile tugged at the corner of Thorin’s mouth. “I didn’t say you had to be on your way,” he said quietly, leaning forward even further until a few locks of his hair fell loose around his face. “I just wanted to clear all debts between us, so that you were no longer in my employ.”
Bilbo frowned at him. “Well, I appreciate it very much, but that’s not the point.”
“It is entirely that point,” Thorin said. “I paid you so that you are free to go or stay, as you like.”
Bilbo opened his mouth and then closed it again before he could dig himself in any deeper. His frown deepened, and then relaxed, and he glanced out the window at the reddening sky and then back to Thorin as he tried to think. At last he asked, “Do you want me to stay?”
“Yes,” Thorin said with a small laugh. “Very much.”
As if he’d stepped backwards and tumbled out the window into the lake, Bilbo’s mind rushed to reorient himself. Thorin held his eye and waited for him. Bilbo gulped and said. “Well, in that case. Have we, er, have we paid the bill?” He waved a finger at the nearly empty plates strewn around the table.
“I paid at the bar,” Thorin nodded.
“Then shall we go?” Bilbo glanced at Thorin’s hands and then back to his face. “Somewhere more private, perhaps?”
“Certainly, Mr Baggins,” Thorin stood up with no more encouragement. Bilbo linked arms with him and they sauntered through the dining room of the pub and out the front doors. Through the streets, their heads bent together, they hurried back through the crowded and ramshackle streets. The paths and canals were still full of traders and workmen, mingling now with drunks and youths dressed up for the night.
When they reached the Inn, there were several patrons stumbling out the front door and they could hear loud singing and the roars of drunk revellers inside. Thorin grabbed Bilbo’s hand and tugged him around the back, onto a thin path over the canal that ran behind the building and ended in a dead-end corner leading to a back door, and only a couple of small windows high above their heads. A few small, wooden buoys painted in cheerful colours bobbed merrily in the water below the path. The lights of the houses on the far side winked and rippled in the water of the canal.
“If it wasn’t for the smell of this town, it’d be almost lovely,” Thorin said, looking up at a few white stars above them.
“It’s very romantic. Now let’s get inside,” the back door led directly through to the Inn’s guest rooms, so Bilbo reached for the handle of the door. Before he could turn it, he felt Thorin’s hand on his shoulder and found himself backed against the wall as Thorin took his face and kissed him.
Bilbo nearly melted into him. For several minutes they simply held each other, pressed together, and then there was the clatter of the door being flung open. Thorin sprang back with a cough as light flooded their private little path and pinned them as clearly as if they were on a theatre stage. Inga and Bard’s oldest daughter, Sigrid, stepped out onto the path. She saw them and looked away quickly with a roll of her eyes, crouched to grab the mooring line for one of the buoys and hauled up a locked crate filled with bottles of sweet wine that were being kept chilled in the water. She determinedly did not make eye contact with them as she took two bottles and turned to go back into the inn, but she called over her shoulder, “Please go to your room like normal people, before you fall in the canal.”
Bilbo covered his face with his hands and groaned as the door slammed shut and the light with it, leaving them in the shadows again. “I feel like a tweenager hiding from his parents.”
Thorin stroked the hair back from Bilbo’s brow. “Being old has some advantages,” he said quietly. “Experience. Perhaps a little wisdom.” He grinned, “A sense of urgency.”
“I thought you’d learned patience?” Bilbo asked.
“I have been patient,” Thorin kissed him again. “I have been patient for weeks.”
There was a crash and once again they were lit up by the glow of the Inn. Inga was standing in the doorway, leaning out to look at them. Bilbo jumped and stepped forward. “Inga, I am so sorry, you’re absolutely right, we’ll go upstairs right away and stop blocking your back door–”
“It’s not that, Mr Underhill,” Inga said, holding something out. “It’s a letter for Mr Luznâ. It came after you both left this evening. It’s marked both private and urgent.”
Thorin pushed past Bilbo and grabbed the letter, cracking open the wax and unfolding it. His body slumped and his eyes widened. He looked at Bilbo. “It’s from my sister.”
He held out the letter for Bilbo to read. In an elegant but practical hand, with no salutation, it read simply: Kili has been arrested. No trial yet scheduled. If they find him guilty it will be exile, by now you must know what this means. I am not too proud to beg but your high friend in the palace refuses to see me. In my despair I pray he may listen to your counsel as he once did. Please come, but take great care.
Bilbo raised his head quickly as he took it in. “There’s been no exile for nine years. They’re overdue. They’ll be looking for any excuse to make the trade.”
“If he’s found guilty…” Thorin shook his head. He turned to Inga, who had been pretending to busy herself with something by the door but had left it open and was clearly listening with interest. “Can your husband take me to the mouth of the Forest River? As far as his boat will go?”
“Not before tomorrow morning,” Inga said with a frown.
“Who can ferry me at this time of night?”
“No one will brave the rocks in this darkness,” she shook her head. “Or if they did, they must be idiots and I wouldn’t recommend you trust them at the tiller.”
“Ask him to be ready as soon as he can,” Thorin pleaded.
“It’ll cost you,” Inga raised her eyebrows. “He’ll have to delay other jobs.”
Bilbo fumbled in his coat and shoved the bag of coins at Thorin. “Take it out of this. You said you overpaid me for travel expenses I don’t need, yet.”
Thorin hesitated, and then took the bag with a quiet, “Thank you.”
Inga said she’d talk to Bard as soon as he was home for the night, and then shut the door to give them their privacy back. The sparkling lights and lapping water had lost any romantic appeal. Thorin was practically vibrating with frustration at being so far from his family’s troubles.
“Thorin, let’s talk about this. You can’t just walk back into the City,” Bilbo took his elbow. “You’ll be arrested yourself, as soon as you set foot in the Woodland. They might take you straight off to the–” the glanced at Inga and lowered his voice. “The you-know-what with all the teeth and claws.”
“If I can get into the palace and speak to the king, maybe…” Thorin shook his head. “I don’t know who else knows about this bargain with the dragon, but none have challenged Thranduil in all these years, that much is clear. If I make him see what he is doing, through my eyes, through the eyes of my people, perhaps he can be reasoned with.”
“We’ll go first thing in the morning, then,” Bilbo said. “Arrested… If the City is worth anything as a civilised place, this sort of bureaucratic nonsense will take weeks. We may not be in a rush at all.”
“All the same. I would like to be there by tomorrow night,” Thorin folded his arms. Then he flinched and looked at Bilbo. “We?”
“I’ll come with you, of course. If this is a stitch-up as it was with you, your nephew will have one thing that you didn’t have on your side. A professional burglar.” Bilbo patted his arm. “Things found and found out. That was my mother’s sign on the door, remember?”
“Bilbo,” Thorin said, the hand on his arm loosened but did not release him. “You don’t have to come. Our contract is settled. If you are caught entering the City without the leave of the Guard, you will be answerable to the City’s laws. You owe me and my family nothing.”
Bilbo nodded and looked at him. “Then when it’s all done, we can talk about billable hours and overtime. But until then, I want to help.”
Chapter 9: The Trial
Chapter Text
Two nights after Kili was arrested, Fili was awoken by his mother before the sun was even bright enough to outshine the City lamps. "Get your coat. There was a messenger, the trial's happening today."
"Today? I thought it would be weeks away," Fili jumped up and blearily dressed and shoved a piece of yesterday's bread in his mouth as they headed outside into the lamplight. Balin and Dwalin, who lived nearby, had been roused by the messenger as well. Dis embraced them both quickly. "Will you put the word out and tell everyone to get down to the administration halls? I think it will help if we are not alone, whatever happens next."
"Of course," Balin gave a quick bow. "We'll see you there."
The community buildings that administered the City's central needs were a cluster of high-ceilinged halls and offices, their roof beams and door posts made of a pale wood polished until they shone almost white. They stood in a rough circle, as if back-to-back, surrounded by a wide ring-road of newish, dwarven paving stones. When Fili and Dis arrived, the lamps were finally flickering out and the winter sun was filtering through the distant arches of the trees that filled the City avenues. Beneath their shade, a crowd was already gathering outside the central hall of justice.
It turned out there had been no need to summon reinforcements. Somehow, despite the short notice, word had gotten out about the trial. There were two dozen dwarves, of all ages, but more coming all the time. Among them at the front, marking the clearest faction of coordinated supporters, were Kili’s friend Berior from the archery range and another three tall, elven schoolfriends, along with at least half a dozen dwarves. The strawberry-haired Ori, who had always rather idolised Kili and occasionally helped him cheat on homework, seemed to be the leader of this group. Fili was amazed to see that on presumably short notice, Ori had coordinated both the dwarves and elves so that they all wore a dark blue - a coat, vest or scarf - the old colour of the line of Durin. So their purpose here was loud and clear, for good or for ill. Fili had been so busy the last two days trying to figure out how to get his brother out of the cells he had not realised there were parallel efforts to help him.
On the far side of the steps there was a small group of young elves in uniform, who Fili recognised as some of the members of Kili's unit in the Guards. That they had worn their uniforms was notable, as it was normally not permitted unless on duty. All four of the elves who had been recruited with Kili were there, and two older ones from the same unit, and their lieutenant, who was standing back a little and looking troubled. The cause of her trouble was obvious; two of the elves in the group had started arguing with each other.
Fili grabbed his mother's arm. "Can you go to the top of the steps and look, well, you know...?"
"Majestic?" Dis raised her eyebrow.
"And a little bit fragile, if you don't mind," Fili gave her a gentle push.
"Fili, we don't want to be seen leading a riot--"
"I'm not going to start a riot, I'm going to try and stop one," Fili insisted. He gave her a gentle push, trying to make it look like he was just guiding her onwards, and the crowd parted around them. Everyone was looking at them. As Dis walked up the steps, Fili darted over to the group of young Guards. Just as he got there, the arguing rose a notch and one of them shoved the other in the chest.
"Hey!" Fili jumped in between them and they looked down at him in surprise. He pointed up the steps at Dis. "You're in your bloody uniforms! Can you please try to keep the peace, for my mother's sake?"
Lieutenant Fainthel, looking a little embarrassed, stepped in as well. "Yes, lads, we are here to observe, nothing more."
"You know this is wrong, Fainthel!" One of the two arguing guards said. Fili vaguely remember his name as Annúngil. "I passed Kili four times on patrol that night, on our route in the forest. I can give him an alibi. But the magistrate won't let me speak at the trial."
"We don't know anything," Haered, the elf who had been shoved, smoothed down his jacket. He had been recruited to the guard at the same time as Kili and, as he was Berior’s cousin and closest friend, had come out drinking with Kili and his brother many times. Now his face was cold and his tone stinging. "You have not seen the evidence. Your alibi only covers the night, but she could have been killed while he was returning to the barracks. He always acted odd when the captain was around, we all knew it. Unnatural urges, that’s what I think.”
“You’re a prejudiced, bitter fool, Haered,” Annúngil went for him again, but Fili held his ground between them like a rock and blocked him from touching Haered again. “You’ve never liked him!”
Fili raised his hands to try and get their attention. "Both of you, please, keep your heads. Tauriel would want justice to be done, and that won’t happen with you fighting each other over speculations on the front steps."
When they seemed mollified, he looked back over at the cluster of blue-clad dwarves and elves crowding around the bottom of the steps. Dis was speaking to them quietly. After a moment she hurried over to Fili and whispered in his ear. "They've been told no one will be admitted to the chamber, not even family. The clerk inside said it was too small. They're starting the trial now."
"What?" Fili gaped at her. He chewed his lip and then touched her shoulder. "Do your best to keep everyone calm. We'll sort this out." He dashed over to Lieutenant Fainthel. "Can you come with me to speak to the magistrate inside? They're trying to keep the trial behind closed doors."
Fainthel drew herself up a little, her chest and shoulders stretching the smooth lines of her uniform. "Of course, surely that cannot be right. Everything should be open to the sunlight."
Within a few minutes, Fili and Fainthel returned. The crowd of dwarves had swelled even more, now. Balin and Dwalin had made their way to the front to stand with Dis, trying to respond to questions to which they had no real answers. Dis turned to Fili as she heard him come up behind her. "Well?"
"Fainthel's convinced them they're risking serious unrest if they don't delay the trial to allow us and the prosecution to select observers. I saw Prince Legolas in there as well, he was making the same demand, even he was not happy to hear they were trying to hold the trial in secret. We've got an hour. They're moving everything to the Great Hall next door. They said they'll let us in, and as many as can sit in the gallery at the back of the room. It’s got a small bench that looked barely enough for ten dwarves, give or take the size of the dwarf," Fili looked around the crowd until he spotted an older fellow whose callused hands were folded over his chest. "Ginnar! Just who I need," Fili darted between the blue-clad faction to clap him on the shoulder. "How fast can you get wood and hammers, and how many hands would you need to build a tiered stand?"
"You planning a stick-ball tournament?" Ginnar raised his eyebrows. He grinned. "How long have we got?"
"Less than an hour," said Fili grimly. Before Ginnar could even start looking for his apprentices in the crowd, he had several of the blue-clad supporters rushing forward to volunteer for errands. Fili caught Berior and Ori, “We’ll make as much room as we can, but if you could choose five dwarves and two elves who you think can sit quietly and respectfully in the court, we’ll bring them in with us. The rest should stay out here and relay any information we can. If they don’t want people watching, we’ll make sure the crowd outside hears every word as soon as it happens,” once that was sorted, he went to Fainthel with the same offer, “Can you pick three of your recruits? A balance of opinions. And you’ll come yourself, if you would? We can’t have them saying we packed the court with intimidating partisans. I want good witnesses.”
He was counting in his head as he went, trying to estimate the size of the gallery stands Ginnar had yet to build, but Fainthel caught his eye as he tried to leave. “You speak as if the crime was still in progress. Your brother will be treated fairly, Master Dwarf. The Woodland realm cares for its people.”
“Tell me that to my face at the end,” Fili answered, and then shook his head. “I’m sorry, you don’t deserve my ire. Forgive me.”
“You are forgiven,” she waved her hand. “I will see you inside.”
Fili turned to his mother. "Do you want me to find you somewhere to sit? You don't look yourself."
"I'm perfectly well," said Dis, but her hand was shaking when Fili reached for it. "This is worse than I imagined. I thought, I thought... perhaps it was all a mistake, and they would release him once they’d properly investigated. But they are rushing this through... did you speak to the magistrate who will convene the trial? Did you catch their name?"
"Tulus," said Fili.
Dis gave a soft groan and touched her brow as if she had a sudden pain. "One of Thranduil's closest advisors. He was one of the Dragon Guards, he used to be a praetorian. He has been chosen for this purpose. Fili, we can't let this happen, we can't let them do this. There are things I haven't told you, things even Thorin didn't know until now. Tauriel, she helped us..." But there were people all around them, and she cut herself off as a few ears turned towards her voice.
“It'll be alright, Ma. I promise." Fili had never seen her so gaunt and wan. His strong, single-minded mother, who as a child had watched her home burn and her own mother with it, who had raised two boys without her husband, who had taken her brother's place as their leader with all the courage of a warrior stepping over the body of a fallen commander. He put his arm round her and eased her away from the crowd. "Dwalin, please, can you take her inside? Find her some water, perhaps?"
"Aye, you keep things smooth out here," Dwalin nodded, and despite some weak protests from Dis, he escorted her up the steps and through the doors of the great hall.
--
Kili had no idea what was going on. He'd been woken before dawn for a short breakfast and chance to wash and dress. They’d taken his uniform and given him plain clothes to wear, slightly oversized, but he managed to roll the sleeves and the hems up until they didn’t look too humiliating. Then he’d been led through tunnels and over bridges and under lower levels of the City until they came through a small door to a simple chamber with a large desk and two chairs. For some time he waited here, with guards on the doors. He assumed he was finally going to be questioned for the investigation, and was trying to remember everything that could possibly be relevant in the days leading up to Tauriel’s death, and practise the words in Sindarin because he thought that might help. Then a clerk came in and said, “The magistrate and the prosecutor will be in shortly.”
“The magistrate? For what?”
The clerk stared at him for a moment. “Your trial.”
Kili felt like he was falling through the floor. “My trial? Now? But no one’s even asked me for my side of the story.”
“You will have your chance to answer their questions, and speak in your own defence,” the clerk assured him. “Once all sides of the story have been told, the magistrate will decide the truth of the matter.”
“S-speak?” Kili balled his fists on his knees. “Can’t I… can’t someone speak for me?”
The clerk shook his head. He was short for an elf, and very slight, his clothes of a particularly fine weave with a long silk shirt beneath a tunic, his skin pale and unfreckled. He did not look like he had left the heart of the City for years. Nevertheless, he didn’t seem to have any fear of Kili, even though Kili was unbound and sitting a few feet from him. So Kili must not look like a brutal murderer. That was a good sign, wasn’t it?
“I… in dwarven courts, you usually have a friend who’s a good orator, or pay someone if you can, to present your case…” Kili said weakly.
“That’s not how it’s done by the City law,” the Clerk explained. “But you could have requested it if you’re really afraid to speak. I don’t think there’s time, now.”
“No one told me!”
The clerk looked a little irritated. “Ignorance is no excuse. You’ve lived here your whole life, haven’t you?”
“Yes, but I’ve never been arrested before!” Kili burst out, jabbing both his hands towards the magistrate’s empty desk. “Can I not have anyone with me? My brother–”
“I’m sorry, the room is too small to allow it.”
The door opened behind him, but it was just someone with a message. Kili buried his face in his hands and tried to think. He was trying to be brave, but he knew that at some point, they would surely ask him about the death. Which meant they would have to tell him about the death. Which meant he would have to hear someone describe to him how Tauriel had died. Forget speaking in his own defence: he didn’t think he could sit there listening to that and not throw himself on the floor and scream until his lungs gave out. He had spent the last two days trying not to imagine it. He had not slept very much.
The small clerk returned. “There’s been a delay. Wait here.”
He nodded and waited. He thought it would be a few minutes, but it went on and on. He wished they would just get it over with. He wanted water, but he didn’t want to ask the guards. Not out of fear, he just felt too proud to need something from them, when they were complicit in this whole ordeal.
After what must have been nearly an hour, the clerk returned and on his instruction, the guards got Kili up and took him out of the room again. Kili wondered if they’d decided to skip the trial and just declare him guilty. The clerk said as they walked a short distance to the door he’d already come through, “They’re moving the proceedings to the Great Hall nearby.”
“Why?”
“To allow family and friends.”
Before Kili could ask if the clerk meant his or Tauriel’s, they crossed a small courtyard and went in through a simple, arched wooden door. On the far side, Kili found himself in a large hall, the columns formed of what looked like the trunks of several ancient, red-barked conifers, the branches grown with patience and direction until they formed the roof beams on which planks had been laid far above. At the end where Kili had been brought in, there was a raised dais with a large desk placed on it, at an angle so that it faced an empty space that seemed to almost glow with malice. The place where the accused would stand when being questioned.
Two wings of railed seats stood on either side of the dais. On the far side sat Prince Legolas and three senior members of the Guard; all fellow captains. Kili knew them all by name and face. They all wore shades of dark, formal clothes. Mourning clothes.
There was one other figure in the far seats, a red-haired elf woman. For the briefest moment, Kili’s mind gave a desperate leap and saw Tauriel sitting beside Legolas, alive and robed in cream and sage. But it was bitterly obvious that it was another elf, who looked nothing alike in face and was narrower in the shoulders. Kili vaguely remembered meeting her once before. Tauriel was an orphan, but she had some more distant relatives; this elf was Mírior, a second cousin on Tauriel’s father’s side. She had a placid look on her face, but she did not take her eyes off Kili as he was led to his seat.
At the other end of the room, several dwarves seemed to be literally building a three-tiered seating structure, hammering the last nails into one end while there were dwarves and elves already filing in to sit at the other end. Kili the first flash of lightness he'd felt in days when he saw his brother, his throat closing up. Fili looked like he’d slept in his braids and dressed in a hurry, in a wrinkled shirt and an old, comfortable doublet. Fili met his eye and nodded at him, and pressed both hands to his chest before he sat down. Their mother came to sit beside him, holding onto Dwalin’s arm, with Balin close behind.
As the guards led Kili to the enclosed seats below the dais, on the opposite side of the room from Legolas, Kili leaned around them to catch Balin’s eye. He mouthed Balin’s name, and gave a small beckoning motion.
Balin glanced around. He hitched up his belt and strode across the hall to where the guards had sat Kili down. He leaned over the rail in front of Kili. “Are you alright, laddie?”
“Balin, they said I have to speak in my own defence,” Kili hissed. “But I can’t, I’ll mess it up, I’m rubbish. Can you…?”
Balin looked at where the gallery at the back was growing increasingly full. Kili could see many of his friends, wearing blue like the colour of his house, and several of his fellow recruits in their uniforms, and even his lieutenant. They didn’t all meet his eye, but they were here. They wanted to see the truth. He had been very glad to see Ma and Fili, and even Dwalin, who he was sure would have defended him even if he’d been caught with a bloodied knife in his hand standing over the body. But the rest of them… they were about to witness possibly the worst day of his life. He wasn’t sure how he felt about them spectating.
“Of course, Kili,” Balin patted his hand. “Let me take care of it.”
The small clerk had appeared beside Balin. “Master Dwarf, you’ll have to return to the gallery.”
“Ah, no, I will not,” Balin raised his bushy eyebrows at him. “I’m the lad’s representative for these proceedings. I’ll be making our case to the magistrate.”
The clerk made a pained face. . He looked like he wanted to protest, but at last decided it was not worth the trouble. “Very well. I’ll note it in the records.”
Balin came around the side of the rail and sat down in the seat beside Kili. He patted Kili’s knee, which Kili realised too late was shaking and tried to make it still. “Right. We’ve got a few seconds. Can you tell me, honestly, is there anything I need to know before this starts?”
Kili had been pressing his chin into his knotted fingers. He glanced sharply at Balin. “Like what? Do you think it was me?”
“I don’t think anything. But it’ll help to have the truth. It sounds like the two of you had your secrets.”
“Balin, no. I would have rather died than hurt her,” Kili shook his head and looked back across the hall at Prince Legolas, who was staring at him with a stony expression. “And if I find out who did it, I’ll kill–”
Just at that moment, the entire court went quiet as a tall, gaunt elf in a long, grey robe emerged through the side door at the back of the hall and walked up to the dais. The last two words out of Kili’s mouth hung in the air, and the clerk who was still standing nearby shot him a sharp glance. Kili buried his face in his hands and tried not to groan out loud, but no one else reacted. However, he was sure that Prince Legolas’ keen ears would have made out his words. He’d watched the commander react to a spider’s web tremble from a hundred yards away. Kili was sure that even if this entire farce cleared his name, Legolas would never see him unstained by the crime. He would never be readmitted to the Guard. Everything he’d worked for was gone.
But at least if he was found innocent he would not be banished. He had always felt like such a worldly adventurer, traipsing around Mirkwood with his fellow young recruits, showing off to his cloistered school friends at home. Few dwarves his age had even completed the relatively safe trip to the Iron Hills to visit family or expand their trade. But Kili had never even gone that far, never even left the boundaries of the forest. He had never needed to. Everyone he cared for was here, in the Woodland City. This was the only home he’d ever known. To be thrown out and never return, to be alone out there trying to make his way without any idea of how anything worked, to never see Fili or Ma or any of his friends again - it was more terrifying than facing a nest of spiders in the dark.
The magistrate, Tulus, called over the clerk for some quiet conversation, pointing at the crowd who were now crammed into the newly-expanded gallery. The clerk winced but shook his head. Kili could only make out the words, “…as many as could sit, you said, I didn’t know they’re make more seats…” Tulus’ face was stormy, but after a moment he collected himself. He intoned some formal introduction of the proceedings. Then, to Kili’s shock, it was Mírior who stood up and was introduced next. She would be speaking for the dead, to make the case against the accused. Kili had not imagined the horror of this. He didn’t know if it was traditional to have a relative present the prosecution case, but he was absolutely sure that it was no accident they had chosen someone who vaguely resembled Tauriel. His knee began to shake again.
The magistrate finally raised his head and pinned Kili with his gaze. “I will give you a final chance here, to confess and receive some clemency in return.”
Kili had not expected a question directed at him so soon. He felt frozen in place, until Balin patted his back. Kili glanced at him and shook his head. Balin spoke up instead, “Your grace, he will not lie. He has no confession to give.”
“I was not asking you,” Magistrate Tulus said.
“I speak on his behalf,” Balin insisted. “You’ll get no other answer.”
“Very well. Then we will continue.”
“My Lord Legolas, we request that you approach,” the clerk called. Legolas stood to his full height and made his way to the dais to stand in front of the magistrate, his hands folded neatly in front.
Mírior stalked across the width of the hall between them, her cream robes flowing behind her, until she could stand and address Legolas while still half turned towards the magistrate. When she spoke, her voice was clear and perfect, and loud enough to be heard around the entire hall. At least she sounded nothing like Tauriel.
“My lord, will you describe what you found, three mornings prior to today?”
Legolas’s jaw grew stiff, and his neat hands clenched around each other. “The body of my friend, Captain Tauriel of the City Guard.”
Kili couldn’t have reacted even if he’d wanted to. His body had become as cold and unyielding as stone, except for his twisting stomach. Everything he’d been afraid to hear was about to come out.
“Will you describe what you saw, in detail?” Mírior asked, as lightly as if requesting he bring her a cup of tea.
Legolas looked down and nodded. His voice croaked when he finally answered. “She was in a narrow, quiet street behind the headquarters of the Guard. She was unarmed. She had been stabbed, here, above the left breast, with her own shortsword,” he pressed his hand above his heart. “There were bruises on her throat. I tried to lift her but she was already heavy.”
The imagining of it filled Kili’s mind, washed over him in beating waves. He closed his eyes and it was worse. He wanted to pluck his own eyes out. Tauriel, all that life inside her, those thousands of years ahead of her, her laugh, her silent tread, her fanciful musings on the world when everything around was quiet, all draining out with the blood. He could not stop himself thinking how much it would have hurt, and wondering whether it had been hard for her to breathe, if she’d known what was happening, or if it had all been too quick.
“How did you know she was there?” Mírior asked.
“I had called a meeting with my captains, inside the Guard’s hall, and Tauriel was missing. We all remarked on it, because it was so unusual for her to be late. Then an elf boy I didn't know came in the door and asked for us to come at once. It was this boy who had found her. He said he heard something and came to look, but he did not look closely before he ran for help. We were the first to see the body up close.”
“When had you last seen Tauriel?”
Legolas said, “The evening before. When she finished her patrol she came to see me at the palace, for a walk in the gardens. She seemed troubled, but wouldn’t tell me why. Some hours later, after midnight, I saw her leaving the palace. There was a dwarf with her,” Legolas said darkly. “The two of them didn’t know I had seen them. They seemed to be keeping to the shadows.”
“Can you name the dwarf she was with?”
Legolas looked directly at Kili, but at last he said, “No. He wore a long cloak and a hood. I couldn’t see his face. But from the neck down, I’m certain he did not have much of a beard.”
There was a murmur from the gallery. Kili resisted the urge to touch his chin self-consciously. Who had Tauriel been with? It couldn’t have been him. He’d been miles away, on his forest patrol. But how many beardless dwarves would Tauriel be sneaking around with after midnight? Legolas must be simply lying.
“Was there anything else of note that you found with Tauriel’s body?”
“Yes,” Legolas swallowed and waved his hand at the desk where Tulus sat, his quill poised. “I believe it was given to the magistrate for inspection. It’s on his desk.”
“Will you show the magistrate, and the court, to confirm it’s what you found?”
Legolas stepped up to the desk and took a small, silk bag that had been laid beside Tulus’ papers. From within, he lifted out a long, dark braid of hair with a glint of silver at the end and held it up, turning so that no one could miss it.
Kili thought he would throw up. He knew exactly what that was.
“A braid of hair,” Legolas said, his voice growing louder. “It was clutched in her hand so tight we had to work to unlock her fingers and retrieve it. Torn from her killer’s head as she struggled against him. It is tied at the end with a clasp, imprinted with a sigil of Durin the Deathless.”
There was at last a reaction from the crowd; many reactions, gasps of shock and anger, and Dwalin raising his voice in disbelief. Kili couldn’t look at them. He didn’t hear his mother or brother among the cacophony. He stared at the wood of the railing right in front of. He was doomed. How could he possibly pretend it wasn’t his hair? Even Fili and Mother must be questioning his innocence, now.
“And who do you think this braid belongs to?” Mírior asked.
“Him.”
Kili could sense Legolas pointing at him, like a hot beam of sunlight, but he couldn’t bring himself to raise his head. He wished he could shrink into something mindless, like a mushroom, perhaps, and just melt away under that burning beam.
“Do you know the accused?” Mírior asked Legolas. “Do you know if he knew Captain Tauriel well?”
Here it was. Of course they knew about their affair. Of course they would use it against him. Legolas said bitterly, “I know he was too familiar with her, though she vastly outranked him. I know he followed her out of the Guard's barracks sometimes, when he thought no one was looking. She was too kind and she did not report his little idolatries, but his lieutenant, Fainthel, discussed her suspicions with me. I believe he was obsessed with her.”
Kili raised his head to look at the crowd in the gallery. Across the vast space, Fainthel met his eye for a moment, and then looked away, a faint flush rising in her neck. Kili wasn’t sure, but he thought he saw her shake her head a little. Fainthel had asked Kili once, during a pause in regular training in the barracks, “The Captain’s always hanging around when our unit is sparring, isn’t she?” and Kili had said too quickly, “I don’t know what you’re talking about. I’ve barely noticed her.” Fainthel had shrugged and tossed him a towel. “I’m just saying, son, if you don’t feel you can turn her down, you let me know. I’ll have a word, tell her I don’t want you distracted and she’s to leave you be.” Kili had stammered a protestation, and she had never mentioned it again. She had clearly suspected something, but if she had really discussed it with Legolas, he was sure it would have been in regards to Kili’s welfare, not Tauriel’s. But perhaps whatever words Fainthel had used, Legolas had heard something different.
Mírior turned as she spoke next, gesturing to the magistrate and then to the crowd. “Thank you, my lord. You may go.”
Legolas started to step away from the magistrate’s desk, but before he could, a low voice called, “Excuse me, my lord Legolas. May I approach?”
Kili looked up at Balin, who had risen to his feet and raised his hand. Legolas paused and looked to Tulus for guidance. Tulus nodded, “Of course.”
Balin went around the side of the railing. Smiling, he walked towards the dais. Alone on the wide, herringbone floor, he looked too small for the shape of the room. But like Mírior, his voice carried loud and well. He said, “May I come up on the dais? My old neck can’t take the craning to look up at you.”
Tulus paused in his writing to wave his hand. “I’ll allow it.”
“Thank you, your grace,” Balin climbed up the steps and stood facing Legolas, like two players on a stage. He clasped his hand behind his back. “Could you show us one more time, where the sword was? In Captain Tauriel. Just so we are absolutely sure.”
Legolas gave him a dark look, but again he touched the spot above his heart. “Here.”
“And you say it was her sword? And she was unarmed?”
Legolas nodded.
Balin turned a little, as if considering. “This was the standard style of shortsword carried by the Guard? Usually twinned, worn on the hip or behind the shoulders?”
“Yes,” Legolas said.
“And did Tauriel usually carry these twin swords?”
“Yes,” Legolas said again.
“But there was no other sword?” Balin pressed. When Legolas finally shook his head, Balin asked, “Did you search for it?”
“The street was searched for anything unusual,” Legolas said at last. “Nothing more was found.”
“Was it common for Tauriel to forget one of her swords, on the way to a meeting with her commander and her fellow captains?”
Legolas’ face was furious, now. “Of course not. She was an exemplary warrior of my Guard. She was my best Captain.”
“So her killer must have taken the second sword? If anyone else had encountered the body, it would be a dangerous thing to steal. A thief would be liable to be arrested themselves, for carrying a weapon within the City bounds. And if it had been discarded soon after, anyone who found it would surely have reported it by now.”
“I suppose.”
“Kili was seized not five hundred yards from the Guard’s headquarters, if I have been told correctly, and perhaps half an hour after you found Tauriel’s body. He was not hiding. In fact, he claimed he was returning to the headquarters.”
“Yes.”
“Did he have the sword?”
Legolas said, though gritted teeth. “No. But we don’t know when she died. He could have had hours to hide it.”
“She lay on a public street without discovery? For hours? Even at that time of the morning?”
“We have no way to know,” Legolas insisted.
“Of course. Thank you, those are my questions. I apologise if I’ve caused you distress,” Balin turned and went back down the steps of the dais. His footsteps seemed very loud as he crossed back to sit down with Kili.
The magistrate finished writing something down and then said dryly, “You may go, Legolas.”
“Ah, yes, of course,” Legolas hurried down the dais.
“Do you wish to speak to anyone else, Mírior?”
“I would like to speak to the accused,” Mírior said.
“The accused should approach the dais,” the clerk called. Balin stood up to let Kili past, and Kili walked what seemed like miles, the hall so silent he could hear his own heart pounding. He stood in the open space where he was told, where Legolas had been standing a minute before. He felt dizzy with the number of faces turned towards him, the myriad of different expressions, hostility and hope and uncertainty. He tried to focus on Fili and Ma. They were completely blank, like wooden models of themselves carved and painted to look like real dwarves.
Mírior stood a few feet from the dais, her hands clasped in front of her. "You are the son of Vili, son of Vali, is that correct?"
Kili shrugged. "Yes."
"Your father was also convicted of a violent act, is this true? He beat his elven neighbour half to death, not so long ago?"
Kili frowned. "That was decades ago. I haven't seen my father in years. He left the family when I was barely in trousers. He lives in an alms house somewhere, with a head injury, unable to speak more than a word at a time. My mother pays for his upkeep."
“Who raised you, then?”
“My uncle, for the most part.”
"Ah yes - would this be the uncle who was accused of a serious theft and disappeared before his trial, true?"
There was an audible ripple of grumbles from the dwarves at the back of the room.
"My uncle was the grandson of the King Under the Mountain," Kili said, feeling heat rise around his collar. "He was wrongly accused because he was too well-liked in this City and somebody wished to bring him low. He was building a new school with donations from rich dwarves, and he was accused of training child soldiers. But it was not true, it was a Khuzdul language school. The money was taken when the authorities searched his house, probably by some corrupt minor official. My uncle stole nothing."
Mírior nodded. "And you thought yourself special as well, did you? The first dwarf to be admitted to the Guard, to be permitted to carry a weapon in the City since the law was made. Did you think yourself apart from others, deserving of more than your fellows? Did you think yourself so big and brave that Captain Tauriel might even love you, if you pursued her long enough?"
"How we felt about each other is none of your business," Kili spat. "You'll just twist anything I say."
There was a noise of someone loudly and dramatically clearing their throat, and Balin stood up. "Excuse me, your grace. May we pause so that I can have a word with my charge?"
Tulus folded his hands in front of him, his face neutral. After a moment he said. "You have a minute," he waved his hand at Kili. "Master Dwarf, please go down to your representative."
Kili hurried down the steps. Balin had come out onto the floor and met him halfway, but took his shoulder and bent him down close so they could not easily be overheard. "Kili, do you understand that this is a show trial? And that means you have to put on a show?"
"Why? Everyone's already decided on my guilt," Kili said bitterly.
"For your mother's sake, please collect yourself and listen to me. Think about what you've just given them; that your father is a destitute criminal, that your disreputable uncle fled justice rather than obey the law, and that you are hiding some secret to do with Tauriel. Is that what you meant to say, or were you briefly possessed by some dark spirit?"
Kili hissed. "It's not fair. It's all a sham."
"You have to convince them," Balin said patiently. "Forget about Mírior and forget about the Magistrate. Think about your friends and your people in that crowd. Convince them. Even think about defending yourself to Prince Legolas, your commander. He wants the truth to come out as much as you do," Balin pointed at the gallery. "They have not yet made up their minds. They want to believe in you. When Mírior asks a question, tell the truth, but don't give her more information than you need to. She is trying to get you to run ahead of her into a trap. Think about what you say before you say it; channel a little of Thorin's patience. And look humble, for Mahal's sake. I know that's difficult for you."
Kili nodded. "I'll try."
"Please return to your place, Master Dwarf," the magistrate said in a bored voice.
Balin gripped his arm and nodded at him. "When she's finished with you, it will be my turn."
Kili went back up to stand on the dais. Mírior paced in front of him, apparently for the effect of it, and then stopped and looked at him. "Legolas has already said that you were too familiar with Captain Tauriel. What did he mean by that?"
Kili swallowed. He tried to think about how Legolas had managed to stand here and look dignified. He folded his arms in front and dropped the hunch out of his shoulders. Thinking of what Balin had said, he tried to make his voice sound humble as he answered. "We were in love."
He'd taken caution too far and spoken too quietly. Mírior had heard him, and Tulus paused in his writing to focus on him, but Mírior glanced at the gallery to confirm they were leaning forward to listen. "Could you say that again?"
"I said, we were in love," Kili repeated, louder this time. There were whispers from the gallery, a few nods between people who had clearly heard some gossip and were pleased to have it confirmed.
"Was that what you believed? Think to yourself. Does it really seem likely, in the light of day, that Captain Tauriel was interested in a... low-ranking recruit?"
Kili let out a long, slow breath until all the curses he wanted to spit at her faded. "We kept our relationship secret. We met at least once a week for the past six months. After our shifts, never on duty. We talked about marriage, about petitioning for an exception to the age laws. But she wanted to wait until I could request reassignment under a different captain."
"And can anyone confirm these meetings took place?"
"No. I just said it was a secret relationship," Kili said. To his relief, this earned a few, small laughs from the gallery at the back.
"But no one else can back up your claim that Tauriel loved you as you loved her? No one knew?" Mírior insisted.
"Oh, as it turns out, everyone knew," Kili said. More laughs, some a little louder. For just a moment, he actually wanted to smile, but he caught himself. He didn't think Magistrate Tulus would take that well.
Mírior looked a little annoyed now. "And did you meet her the night she died?"
Kili shook his head. He said, "We had stopped our trysts, two weeks before Tauriel… before all this happened. I told her I was ending it. My mother had figured out what we were doing together, and she said I was risking my position in the Guard. She didn't want me to ruin my future."
He glimpsed a movement in the gallery, and looked over to see Dis with her face in her hands, leaning into Dwalin's side. After a moment she raised her head, pushing her hair back into place. Kili looked back at Mírior.
"You ended the relationship?" Mírior pressed.
"Yes. I told my brother right away. You can ask him."
"Your brother is not a neutral witness."
Mírior went close enough to the dais that she could reach out to take the braid of dark hair that Legolas had put back on the corner of Tulus' desk. She held it up again. "Is this yours?"
Kili hesitated. It felt like the worst thing he could admit to, after how Legolas had described it. It would be like admitting that a pile of bloodied clothes were his. He glanced quickly at Balin, who shook his head: don't give them this. Mírior waited only a moment longer before she answered for him. "It has the crest of your family. Who else would wear such a trinket? It's clearly not your brother's. If it's not yours, then who did it come from? Your mother?"
"It's mine," Kili said in a rush. He wanted to explain more, but Balin had told him to do no more than answer her questions. But he needed to make them see it differently.
Mírior put the braid back on the desk. "Thank you. The story seems clear to me. Perhaps there was a mutual relationship, perhaps there was not. But it had ended. I think you shirked your patrol duties to meet Tauriel at the palace the night before her death; perhaps that’s when she told you to stay away. But you couldn’t control yourself. You had to see Tauriel one last time. You knew her schedule, you knew she would be at the headquarters that day. You waited for her, lured her into the quiet back-street. She refused your advances, whatever your intentions were. In a rage you throttled her and killed her with her sword, so that there would be no blood on your own weapons. But as she died she managed to rip the braid from your head. You fled with the second sword and disposed of it somewhere, perhaps some waterway, and pretended you had just returned from your patrol outside the city when Prince Legolas caught you."
Kili felt his spirit growing smaller and smaller inside his body, like it was being compressed into a cold, dead, seed of whatever he had been before. It was a horror story worse than he could have believed. He could see it in his own mind, Mírior painted such a convincing picture; his hand around Tauriel’s neck, the blade gripped in an awkward stabbing position, her ripping at his hair in desperation. He wished he could at least sit down, instead of standing here as all those eyes held him, crushing into his place.
"I have no more questions," said Mírior. She started to walk back towards the benches where Legolas and the captains were sitting, but again there was a noise from Balin for attention.
"My gentle lady, would you mind remaining for a moment?" He took a few steps towards her.
Mírior frowned at him, and then at Tulus. At last she said. "Of course."
"Thank you. If you could stand here, just as you are," Balin cleared his throat. "Your grace, would you permit Kili to come and stand with us? Then he may return for further questions."
Tulus narrowed his eyes a little. "You may not intimidate the counsel for the dead, Master Dwarf."
"I won't, your grace, I intend to do quite the opposite," Balin raised his hands. At last, Tulus nodded, and Balin beckoned for Kili to come and stand beside him. Tulus had to lean forward slightly to see them all over the rim of the desk, and there was a growing series of whispers from the gallery of observers. Legolas had leaned forward as well, though he looked poised as if ready to leap up and defend Mírior if this was somehow a way of threatening her.
Balin stood Kili as close to Mírior as seemed comfortable, so they were both facing Tulus at his desk. Then Balin took hold of Kili's right arm as if he was a marionette and raised it up. "There we go lad, can you raise it any higher?" He asked loudly.
Kili shook his head. He was not sure what Balin was doing. He hand was just barely high enough that he could have grabbed Mírior’s neck if he’d wanted to. This seemed to prove nothing.
"Thank you. Now," Balin began to pace between the two of them and Tulus' desk. Kili wasn’t sure what he was supposed to do with his hand so he left it hanging in the air. "Prince Legolas was very clear that Tauriel was struck once in the heart, from above. It is a long time since I've held a sword, even a short one, but the principle should be clear even to our younger friends who've never seen battle. In order to achieve such a motion, her killer would have to generate the strength and range to pierce deep enough to reach her heart. To do that, they would direct the sword in an arc from above the point of contact. Perhaps beginning their strike even higher than Tauriel's head, certainly higher than her left breast. Kili, can you reach that high, even standing fully upright?"
Kili mumbled, "No, sir."
"No, not even close. It would be impossible for a dwarf to execute such a motion. If a dwarf wanted to strike an elf in the heart, especially a dwarf who knew how to use a sword, as Kili does, they would strike from below, under the ribs and through the liver."
Kili felt himself flinch and dropped his arm. Mírior opened her mouth to say something, but it was Tulus who spoke. "Perhaps he forced her to her knees. There is the bruising on her throat."
Balin looked at him sharply. There was a yell from someone in the gallery - Kili thought it sounded like Ori - "You're not supposed to take sides!" The heckler was hurriedly hushed by someone else.
Balin raised his hands, indicating that he was done with Mírior and that Kili should return to his place on the dais. While they both went back to their places, Balin continued to speak. "Perhaps, yes. Perhaps this strong Captain, an exemplary warrior of the Guard, who had defended these woods from orcs and spiders for over a thousand years, perhaps she was overcome and disarmed by one young recruit only two years into his probationary duties. Or perhaps he stood on a chair? Or hung from a rope ladder? Which I'm sure he disposed of in a canal somewhere with the second sword."
Tulus straightened up, and for the first time he had a flicker of emotion on his face. "Do not mock these proceedings, Master Dwarf, or I will have you removed from the hall and the accused can speak for himself."
"My apologies," Balin put his hand on his heart and bowed quickly. "I only mean to show you the ridiculousness of Mírior’s story, and draw you all to the conclusion that seems undeniable to me. Tauriel was not murdered by a dwarf. She was killed by someone at least as tall as her."
His gaze swept around the room, lingering nowhere but touching all the watching elves in particular. He waited to see if Mírior or Tulus had anything else to counter him, and when they didn't speak, he began to pace again. “Legolas says he saw Tauriel with a beardless dwarf in the palace, at midnight. Where were you around midnight, Kili?”
Kili swallowed. “On patrol somewhere north of the Stargazer Hill, I believe.”
“How far is that from the palace?”
“About five miles.”
“Did any of your comrades see you, during your patrol?”
Kili shrugged. “Maybe not precisely at midnight, but our patrol routes did cross a few times.”
Balin turned to Tulus. “May I call additional witnesses, your grace?”
Tulus glowered. “No. You should have requested that before we began.”
Balin let that answer sit tensely in the air for a moment, and gave the gallery a knowing glance. At last he continued. “Very well. Let us view this from the other perspective: if Kili had shirked his duties, his captain Fainthel and his fellow guards would surely be able to tell us, and it would lay great suspicion on the accused. Mírior would surely have called them herself, if it was the case. I would conclude, therefore, that Kili was on patrol that night, and whoever Tauriel was meeting at the palace was someone else. This sighting by Lord Legolas - of someone glimpsed at night from a distance, with their hood up - is therefore entirely irrelevant to the question at hand.”
“That’s quite a conclusion,” Mírior said loudly from where she sat.
“I don’t believe it’s your turn to speak,” Balin replied calmly. He went closer to the desk. "Would you let me look at this famous braid, your Grace?"
Tulus sighed and reached over to pick it up in two fingers and drop it into Balin's gloved hands. Balin took a moment to examine it. The untied end was beginning to come apart, but he tried to hold it together as he held it up. "I do not mean to quibble," he said, looking over at Mírior, who was now sitting next to Legolas again. "But this braid has been repeatedly described as 'torn' and 'ripped'. That is not how it appears to me. The end is not frayed or ragged, the strands are all of even length. It appears, to me, to have been cut."
He brought the braid close to Mírior, as if showing it to her for the first time. "Can you tell me otherwise?" When she didn’t answer, he went to hold it towards Tulus as well to make the point. Finally, he turned to Kili. "Did you cut this from your own head?"
Kili nodded. "Yes."
"Why?"
Kili tried to speak loudly and clearly, as Balin was doing, but all he could manage was a hoarse whisper. "I gave it to her, two weeks ago, when I asked that we end the affair. As a promise that what I felt for her wouldn’t change." He tilted his head and drew back his hair over one shoulder to show the place at the base of his neck where the small patch of hair was shorn. “Here.”
Balin stretched his neck, but from down below and several feet away he probably couldn’t see much. Kili turned a little to show Tulus. “Can you see it, your grace?”
Tulus leaned forward a little too, squinting. He said neutrally. “Perhaps. It’s not clear.”
Balin nodded and jumped in before the confusion could disrupt the flow of his story. "But you admit the braid was yours. And she had it with her when she died - was holding it so tight they could not easily wrest it from her hand," Balin carefully curled the braid into a circle and went to put it down in front of Mírior. "Prince Legolas believed it was her dying message to identify her killer - but I don't think so. I think this was a treasure that she was holding for comfort, in her last moments. Perhaps she wanted to show that she, too, had kept her promise. Not the behaviour of an elf who had tried to escape the unwanted affections of her former lover."
Balin met Kili’s eye, and then looked away quickly. Kili realised his vision was blurring and wiped his eyes quickly, hanging his head to try and hide it.
Balin continued, addressing the magistrate directly. "What seems more likely, your grace? That one of the finest warriors in this city was careless with both her swords, was disarmed and brought low, and defeated by one young recruit? Or that she was the one wielding the second sword, against not a dwarf but a fellow elf, and someone skilled and experienced in battle, who took one of her weapons and turned it against her? Does the braid show her final attempt to hurt her attacker, or is it a last token of love that she clutched as she realised her life had been cut short?" Balin spread his arms wide and turned from Tulus to the rest of the room, first to Legolas and his captains, then the watching dwarves and elves in the gallery, and finally around to Kili standing on the dais. "The answer seems clear. Kili was an easy scapegoat, but he is not a murderer. He is telling the truth."
Kili could see several people nodding in the crowd in the gallery, and some thudding of hands on knees in agreement. Legolas was sitting back in his seat, his arms folded, but his face looked drawn and tired rather than angry, now. Someone in the crowd called, "Here, here!"
Tulus slapped his hand down on the surface of the desk. "I will have quiet. The proceedings are not over. Mírior, do you have any answer to this?”
Mírior paused for a moment. She stood up from her seat but did not approach the dais. "I have no more questions, your grace, because none more are needed. There is only one suspect. Master Balin weaves an absurd tale full of strange coincidences. A beardless dwarf skulking in the shadows of the palace, who cannot be named or found. A mystery assassin who appears in Master Balin's story and then disappears without leaving any trace behind. All of this to explain away details that point to the obvious murderer. No elf would have reason to harm Tauriel, who was beloved by many and hated by none. This was a crime of youthful, base passions by a lovestruck boy--"
Again, a voice from the crowd, and this time Kili thought he recognised Fainthel. "He's not a child, Mírior, he's a grown dwarf!"
Mírior raised her voice to drown out the heckling, "--from a violent, criminal lineage of dwarves--"
Now the outrage came from multiple voices, Dwalin's loudest among them, "How dare you insult the royal line of our people--"
"--and his refusal to admit to his proclivities only speaks further of his danger to this City--"
“—you lying, point-eared hypocrites—!”
"Enough!" Tulus stood up and roared at last. The growing noise of the rabble went silent. He leaned forward and rested his fingertips on the desk, scowling at the gallery. "If counsel has no further case to make, I will retire to consider what I have heard. I will not be disturbed until that time."
He gathered up his papers and stormed towards the door. As he went, he crooked two fingers at Mírior and she hastily climbed down from her seat and followed at a slightly undignified jog. Kili was left standing on the dais until the small clerk said. "You can sit down, if you want."
Balin followed him back to the seat and settled beside him. He patted his knee again. "We did the best we could, laddie. And I think there are many who believe you."
"Many? How could anyone think otherwise?" Kili said, finding himself cracking his knuckles to loosen the tension in his hands. Every muscle in his body felt like he'd been standing rigid to attention in a cold storm for hours. "You proved it. You did so much, Balin. I'd never have seen all those holes in their claims. I didn't have a clue what happened until you laid it all out."
"Aye, of course you didn't," Balin said. "You wouldn't know how she was killed if you weren't there, would you?"
“And you’re right. It had to be an elf, someone skilled. Someone from the Guard. Not Legolas, I’m sure of it, his hatred of me when he arrested me couldn’t have been an act. And now we’ll have a chance to find the real killer.”
“We?” Balin asked.
“Fili and I, we’ll get them.” Kili said confidently. “I’m going to hunt them down and reveal them, no matter who they are. They’re not going to get away with it.”
“Yes. Of course.” Balin said quietly.
Kili looked over at the gallery. Dis and Fili were the only ones sitting silent and watchful, both looking about as exhausted as Kili felt. The rest of the spectators were in excitable discussions with each other. Fainthel and Berior had their heads together, and although Haered seemed to be twisting around in his seat to argue with them, they both dismissed him quickly. Kili could see some of the dwarves at the back of the stands hurrying out and others returning, despite what looked like some feeble protests from the guards that they should remain seated. They must be going out to spread the news about what had just happened. He felt a growing glow of hope in his chest. That meant there were people outside waiting to hear his fate. He wasn't alone. He'd never been as alone as he'd felt in that cell.
They did not have to wait long. The guards at the back door announced the return of the Magistrate. There was hushing and then utter silence as Tulus and Mírior returned. Mírior went back to sit beside Legolas, who appeared too lost in thought to greet her. Tulus stood on the dais, in the same place Legolas and Kili had stood, and folded his hands in front of him.
"The accused will come forward," he said.
Balin stayed at Kili's side as they went forward to the centre of the hall, looking up at Tulus. Balin had been right; you had to really crane your neck back from down here, and it made you feel smaller and weaker than ever. Just another part of the City that had, unspoken, been designed to put dwarves at a disadvantage.
"Kili, son of Vili, I have determined that you are guilty of the murder of Captain Tauriel," Tulus said. "You will be exiled forthwith from this City--"
Whatever else he said was lost in the gale of rage and jeers from the back of the hall. Balin said nothing, but out of the corner of his eye, Kili saw him bow his head in resignation. Kili managed to keep standing, though he could no longer feel his legs. He stared at Tulus, and then looked down, and then back over his shoulder. His mother was leaning over the railing, her hand on her mouth, and though he could hear no sound from her, her face was twisted as if in a scream. Almost all the dwarves and elves in the gallery were on their feet, shouting and pointing and thumping their chests. As if it would do any good. Nothing they could have done would do any good. It had been fated from the beginning, he realised. From the moment Tauriel's body was discovered, he had been doomed.
Fili vaulted over the railing and dashed the length of the hall. He reached Kili's side and seized his hand, calling to Tulus. "I'll go with him. You can't send him alone."
"You cannot. No resident of this City may help him or give him guidance in his banishment. He is to be treated as one dead," Tulus replied. The roars from behind them quieted down a little as the crowd listened to this exchange. Kili was hearing everything but it felt like his mind was very far away, unable to react or stop Fili.
"Then I renounce this city and any claim it has on me!" Fili cried. "Make me an outlaw too if you will, but I'm not leaving his side!"
At the back of the room, Kili heard his mother scream, "Fili, no, Fili, don't do this! I can't lose you both!"
Tulus shook his head. "You do not want to share his fate, son."
"Don't bloody tell me what I want!" Fili growled. "This is my choice!"
"Very well. Then I sentence you both to exile," Tulus nodded at the guards. "Bind them and take them away."
Kili didn't fight as they tied his arms, though he heard Fili struggling a little, "This is ridiculous. I'm coming of my own free will. Give us some dignity, for Mahal's sake."
The only thing that could make him shudder was the sound of his mother continuing to scream Fili's name as they were marched away.
--
Legolas was troubled.
He waited where he sat until the rest of the hall was almost empty, though Mírior tried to call him to walk with her. He couldn't read her face. He wanted to ask her why she had been allowed to follow Tulus out of the hall for the final deliberations, while Master Balin was not so privileged. What had there been to discuss in private? But he couldn't think of how to phrase the question in a way that wasn't an accusation, so he just waved her to go.
It didn't make sense. Not anymore. He tried to think of how the fatal blow could have happened. He had sparred with Tauriel many times, had seen her in combat with many foes. She never fell. She never got off-balance. Would she really have ended up on her knees so easily, on the smooth and familiar streets of her home? And if she had been standing, how could the dwarf have struck such a blow, with such force, with such precision? Why hadn’t Legolas seen it before?
The narrative had seemed so blindingly obvious, when he'd first found the braid in her hand. He thought he had seen them in the palace together, confirming all his suspicions of their intimacy, his fears that he would never have Tauriel’s affection. The story was so clear: that what he had seen in the palace was Tauriel ending the affair, and that her lecherous, spurned lover, strong enough to knock her over and arrogant enough from his ill-gotten success in the Guard, had killed her in the street and left her there for hours like a discarded piece of clothing. And she had been dead for hours. Legolas knew death. Tauriel’s body had been cold and immobile when he'd touched her, tried desperately to rouse her, tried to hold her and give some life from his own fea. Her spirit had flown long before he found her.
The seeds of his doubt had started to grow in the days before the trial. Fainthel had taken Legolas aside and told him, "My commander, Kili was on patrol in the forest all night. His comrades saw him. I saw him. How did he get back to headquarters in time to ambush Tauriel?"
Whoever he had seen in the palace with Tauriel, it was not Kili. Nevertheless, Legolas adjusted the story in his own mind. Obviously Kili had killed her in the morning, as she was walking to meet Legolas at the headquarters. He gripped Fainthel’s shoulder and assured her, "The trial will answer everything."
He had been so sure. It wasn't the sword or the braid that had really convinced him. It was Kili's face, when Legolas and the two constables had seized him on the street outside that pub. His guilt and fear of punishment seemed as clear as the words in a book. But now, when Legolas tried to grasp that surety, it smeared in his fingers like wet ink dripping off the pages.
Had he just helped convict an innocent dwarf?
When there was only a clerk and one of the guards remaining, Legolas got up and walked towards the side door closest to him, away from where they had taken the two condemned dwarves. He could hear the distant rumbling of a crowd outside, and he had no intention of facing them. He knew a route out the back of the hall that would take him back to the palace and to quiet places to think. He wanted to go up to the rooftop gardens, walk the paths he has taken with Tauriel the night before she died. Perhaps he could bring back some sense of her, some trace of her spirit. Perhaps she would tell him what had really happened.
But it seemed his movements were too predictable. As he left the hall and tried to slip away down the corridor, he heard a cry and saw the shape of the dwarf’s mother, Princess Dis, as she threw herself on him. Her cousins, Balin and Dwalin, stood back in the shadows as if they didn't know whether to pull her away or join her. Legolas flinched, reaching for the knives he would have worn when on duty, but he was in formal robes and unarmed. But the dam was not attacking him; she fell to her knees and gripped his legs, looking up at him in supplication.
"Please, my lord, please stop this," she sobbed. "You can speak to your father. He can change the sentence to life imprisonment, put him in a cell beneath the City, never let him see daylight again, you cannot say it will not be a fitting punishment. And then his brother will stay in the City and live."
Legolas swallowed. He crouched down, forcing her to release her grip but bringing their faces almost level. "My father cannot change the law for the pity of one dwarf," he said gently. "Every family would plead for his mercy whenever justice is meted out."
"It is not justice. You were there. You have eyes, you have ears, you have a heart. Do not let your grief cloud your judgement," Dis' voice was edged with accusation now. "Please don't let them take both my children, my Lord, I will do anything. Tell your father I will take their place in exile."
"That is not how it is done," Legolas insisted. "Take heart that they will be together in their banishment."
"Together in death," Dis whispered. "Let them take me, I will be the victim of the king’s justice, if he will only spare my sons. Please, go to your father while there is still time."
"What do you mean?"
"I will swear to the king, on the lives of my children, I will keep silent even at the ruin of my own people," she said, and tears flowed down her face as she suppressed a heaving sob. "I cannot lose them both, not like this."
Legolas stood up. "Gods give you fortitude," he said quietly. "I must go."
He left her kneeling, weeping into her hands, as Dwalin tried to lift her to her feet.
Chapter 10: The Beacons
Chapter Text
Kili had not said anything since they had been marched out the great hall. Not a single word. They were taken through tunnels under the City, away from the crowds, until they reached one of the smaller gates that led out into the forest. There, the regular Guard had handed them over to the praetorians, to Fili’s surprise. The praetorians were rarely seen outside of the palace, and he didn’t know them by their faces, only their dark uniforms with the king’s sigil emblazoned on the chest.
“Can’t we pack a bag?” Fili asked them. “We’re allowed to take spare clothes and some personal things. I thought that was how this worked.”
“You’ll be provided for,” the captain of the praetorian’s said stiffly. “Follow me, please.”
So at least the praetorians were polite. It was slow and uncomfortable walking through the increasingly root-knotted and uneven forest path with their arms bound. Kili tripped once, but one of the praetorians knelt and helped him up, saying almost kindly, “There you go, Master Dwarf, take more care.”
Slowly their path began to rise. Fili wasn’t familiar with this part of the forest, but it was clear that Kili was, as he made the turns without waiting for the praetorians to direct them and was almost striding ahead by the time the trees began to thin and they crested the ridge. At last Fili realised they were nearly at the top of the Stargazing Hill, the only high point in Mirkwood close to the City. He’d been here once for a summer solstice festival, years earlier. It looked very different when it was empty of tents and hanging ribbons. It was a peaceful place, with a contemplative view across a swathe of forest and over the Long Lake. A grassy meadow lay sheltered between the ring of huge boulders that sat just below the peak, like a crown on a huge, green head.
“Go inside the circle,” the captain pointed towards the ring of boulders.
“Why are we here?” Fili asked. He tried to catch the captain’s eye. “What is going on?”
Kili followed their orders without question, and there was not much Fili could do except stick close to him. Once they were near the centre of the summit, within the circle of stones, the praetorians undid their bonds. The captain took out a small bottle of dark, brown glass. “Have some of this; about half each should be more than enough, but you don’t have to take it all at once.”
“What is it?” Fili asked. He didn’t reach for the bottle.
“It’s a tincture. It will make you calmer, make you not care,” the captain said.
“We’re not taking that,” Fili snapped. The captain held out the bottle to Kili. After a moment Kili shook his head.
“As you wish,” the elf tossed the bottle in the grass. “It’s there if you change your mind. We will be going now, but my archers will be posted around the entire hill. If you try to leave the stone circle, you will be shot. No warnings.”
“Then when can we leave?” Fili asked. It was late in the afternoon, and he did not fancy walking in the dark.
“Everything will become clear,” the captain nodded his head, almost like a salute. He seemed about to go, half turning away. Then he spoke again. “They said you are here only for your brother. You are very brave. I am sorry for you.”
Fili’s throat was dry. “Kili is innocent. Neither of us should be here.”
“Perhaps,” the captain said. “But our stocks are low, and this has to be done.”
As the captain walked away, Kili sat down in the long grass and crossed his arms over his knees, facing the widest gap in the mismatched boulders. Fili sat down beside him. They both looked out across the tree-tops, waves of silver flickering across the leaves as the breeze passed over them. They could see all the way to the far side of the lake. It struck Fili with some awe, after spending most of his life enclosed by trees and buildings. Beyond the water was the tiny, dark arrow of the Lonely Mountain, that long-lost home of their parents and grandparents. Once the praetorians let them go, Fili decided they would head in that direction.
Fili had been to Esgaroth a couple of times, with Thorin, before Thorin ran away. It seemed like that would be the most sensible place to go once they were released onto the road and their exile officially began. They might even find news of their uncle there, or if not, they could carry on towards the Iron Hills, where Fili knew they had some distant cousins. He didn’t know what they’d do for food and money, but surely someone would have work for two young and healthy dwarves. All that mattered was that they stuck together and looked after each other.
“By all that’s green, I’m thirsty,” Fili said, breaking off a few grass stalks and absent-mindedly beginning to plait them, just for something to do. “I haven’t had anything to drink since Ma and I left the house this morning.”
Kili still didn’t say anything. His face looked so empty, Fili wondered if he’d even heard the words.
“At the trial,” Fili said cautiously. “You know you said Thorin was wrongly accused of training child soldiers?”
Still no reply, except perhaps a slight narrowing of Kili’s eyes, but that might just have been against the glare of the late afternoon sun.
“Well, Thorin was trying to train child soldiers. The plans for a Khuzdul school were real, but it was always a front for a secret training camp.”
Kili’s head whipped around, his eyes wide. “What?”
Fili could not stop himself laughing at his brother’s face, which finally looked like Kili again. “Not actually kids, of course not. But young dwarves, school leavers and upwards, everyone born after the weapons prohibition. He wanted us to be ready, in case we had to survive outside the City. So that one day, when we retook Erebor, we could hold it and defend it. He was going to teach us all to fight. Him and a few old warriors he trusted, Dwalin and Oin and some others.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“We couldn’t,” Fili looked out over the forest. “If we’d been caught and anything was linked back to you, you’d have lost your position in the Guard for sure. After Thorin left, Dwalin and I picked everything up, as best we could. We’ve been running the school in basements around the City ever since.”
Kili stared at him. He jabbed at his chest. “What about me? I thought that was the whole point of me joining the Guard, I thought he wanted more dwarves in the Guard!”
Out of the corner of Fili’s eye, Fili saw movement at the edge of the stone circle. They both looked over to see two praetorians climbing up onto one of the taller, flat-topped boulders. A third praetorian began to pass what looked like long, thick logs of dry wood up to them. Quickly, the elves were constructing some kind of tall, stacked tower of wood. Fili looked around and saw another team constructing something similar on a boulder on the other side.
“I was going to tell you, the morning you were arrested,” Fili tossed his plaited grass-stalks into the wind. “I needed your help. We have three hundred trainees in the school who can swing an old-fashioned sword or a dwarvish warhammer, but don’t know which way up to hold a bow or how to use their off-hand for anything more than scratching their sacks. I wanted you to train them,” he sighed. “I guess it’s Dwalin’s problem, now.”
“Why did I bother going through all this Guard stuff if Thorin was just going to break the law anyway?” Kili muttered.
Fili turned back to his brother. “You think Thorin didn’t have a contingency plan? Thorin was always playing one hand behind the other. Ma acts like Thranduil is the mighty schemer in this City but he had to be, or he’d have lost control to Thorin years ago. Of course Thorin wasn’t expecting the entire reclamation of the Lonely Mountain and rebuilding of Erebor to depend on you surviving your basic training,” Fili laughed again.
“It’s not funny. I worked really hard. I thought he was relying on me,” Kili grumbled. He folded his arms across his knees, buried his face in his forearms and swore, colourfully and a little tearfully. He finished the outburst with, “It isn’t fair.”
Fili touched his arm. “Thorin was proud of you. He will still be proud of you, when we find him. And we’ll all be together, at least.”
Kili raised his head, sniffing and rubbing his eyes with his shoulder. “Except Ma. We’ll never see Ma again.”
Fili looked over at the praetorians who had apparently finished building their two pyres on opposite sides of the stone circle. They were large bonfires, and the elves were now threading some kind of long, dry, leafy branches through the lattice of kindling. The leaves looked a strange, powdery white, like they were covered in some kind of crushed stone or minerals.
“We’ve got time. Things are changing in the City. A lot of people think you’re innocent, and not just the dwarves. Maybe Ori or Balin will be able to clear your name and they’ll let you come back.”
Kili’s face went grim and cold. “I need to go back. I need to find out who really killed Tauriel.”
Fili sighed. “We need to survive in the world outside until then. Let’s focus on that.”
He shuffled closer and reached his arms around Kili’s shoulders. Kili leaned into him, hiding his face in Fili’s hair, and gripped Fili’s shoulder as his body heaved with deep sobs. Fili held him close and mumbled whatever came to mind. “It’s alright. I’ll be with you. We’ll figure it out together.”
Over Kili’s shoulder, he saw that the sun was just starting to brush the tops of the Misty Mountains. On the boulders, one praetorian stood beside each of the newly-built bonfires. As Fili watched, the light began to fade towards dusk. At last, the praetorians handed up a torch to each of their comrades beside the pyre, and the fire was put to the wood. As the stacks began to burn, and the powdered leaves caught, Fili saw that the flames dancing along the leaves were not the colour of the sunset but tinged instead with a bright, green glow.
—
The sun had almost vanished as Bilbo and Thorin came along a quiet forest path to the edge of the City. When Bilbo had come here alone, he had entered via the main road, through the huge cathedral of trees that formed the promenade in front of the main west gate. This time, Thorin led him to a small gate on the north side, not much larger than a double-leafed door in an ordinary house. The daylight was just starting to fade, and the doors to the City were still thrown wide open.
“It looks like we could just walk in,” Bilbo said, taking a step out of the thick trees.
“No!” Thorin grabbed his arms. “There’ll be regular patrols along the walls, even by day. We’ll wait for one to pass, then slip in before the next comes.”
Bilbo huffed. He felt impatient, both from the urgency of Dis’ letter and for his stomach, which was beginning to rumble after a full day travelling from Laketown. Once they were inside, he was hoping they’d first head for Thorin’s sister’s house, and maybe she would feed them while they caught up with the situation and planned what to do next. They probably had days or weeks before Kili’s trial.
Bilbo looked up at the surrounding trees. “I bet I can see over the wall from up there,” he pointed. “Let me have a look for the patrols. When it’s safe, I’ll whistle down, and you go in first. Wait for me inside, I won’t be long.”
Thorin made a step from his own hands and heaved Bilbo up into the lowest branches of a tall conifer standing close to the wall. From there, the branches were thick enough that Bilbo could clamber up with only a brief, nervous glance towards the forest floor far below. The light was still good under the canopy, but he didn’t want to delay. The shadows under the trees were growing deeper as dusk wore on, and it would not be so long before darkness would make it difficult to climb back down. He could not imagine trying to survive alone in the branches overnight. He’d probably have to ask Thorin to call the forest Guard to come and rescue him with their keen elven eyes, like a kitten stuck in a tree. He’d rather be taken into the City in shackles than fall to his death in the night.
He climbed as high as he could, until the thin branches near the top were only just supporting his weight. He’d picked a good tree, as the conifer stood a little higher than the canopy surrounding it, and was definitely higher than the wall. He peered out as far as he could dare. Within the City wall, there was still a great deal of trees, but they were sparser and more well-trimmed, and between them were strung long lines of Mithril-lamps that were already glowing in the early dusk. Tucked between the branches were the many curved roofs with their red clay tiles or grey slates, their beams and lintels shaped into swoops or carved patterns like braids and twisted rope. There were a few people walking in the mild evening air, an occasional laugh carrying all the way to where Bilbo watched. It looked beautiful and very peaceful. It was hard to believe this was all built on the blood of sacrifices to a dragon.
The street that followed the line of the wall had been kept clear and open of trees, presumably to stop branches overhanging the wall on either side. Bilbo could see the regimented uniforms of two elves on patrol walking along the inner path, just past the gate.
“I think it’s safe to go in,” he called down.
From below, Thorin’s voice floated back. “Sh!”
As Bilbo tried to establish his route back down through the increasingly shadowed branches, he looked behind him at the wild forest. “Hold on,” He murmured, mostly to himself, and then called down to Thorin. “There are new lights above the forest, to the north.”
“Keep it down, Mr Baggins, elves have keen ears!”
“Two green lights,” Bilbo said to himself, squinting at the two glowing points that were shining above the growing gloom of the forest. Something was nagging at his thoughts. His thoughts strayed to his instruction to Dis, after they’d first met days ago, to put a colourful candle in her window to summon him if she needed him. The huge, starry dome of the sky arched above him, white stars shining between the clouds. Bilbo called down to Thorin again, “Is there a hill, maybe three miles or so to the north of here?”
After a moment Thorin replied, “Yes, that’ll be Stargazer Hill. Can you come down and stop yelling, if you please?”
Bilbo felt all heat drain from the night air. His heart began to race. “Green stars, up the hill,” he whispered. He grabbed for the branches below him and began to swing himself down as fast as he could go, no longer thinking about the drop or getting stuck. He half-climbed and half tumbled off the lowest branches of the tree. Thorin was waiting to catch him but Bilbo gave him no warning and missed him entirely, just barely landing on his feet in the piled leaves. He grabbed Thorin’s arm. “Green stars. They’re called green stars in the records. The praetorians light green beacons for Smaug, and the records said the dwarves are exiled on the hill - they’re talking about Stargazer Hill. Thorin, it’s happening now. Tonight.”
Thorin rasped, “They’re summoning the dragon. Kili is up there.”
“If we hurry can rally dwarves from the City—“
“You go. Find my sister, tell her everything. Maybe she can still stop it,” Thorin’s eyes stared through the trees. “I have to go up there.”
“Up there?” Bilbo frowned at him. “Thorin, what on earth are you going to do? They won’t let you just walk in and take him away! And you certainly can’t fight the dragon on your own!”
Thorin met his eye at last. A spasm of regret crossed his face. “I will not stand here and watch it happen again.”
“Thorin,” Bilbo said, more desperately. “Don’t do what I think you’re going to do. Please. I… I don’t want you to. That’s all I can say.”
Thorin smiled at him, soft and full. He leaned in and kissed him once, quickly, his large hand ghosting briefly over Bilbo’s cheek. And then he was gone, and Bilbo was left in the cold, alone, staring into the shadows of the trees.
--
Dis was in her office off the Tinkerer’s guild, taking a moment to try and gather herself. She had spent the day doing whatever she could to cause trouble in public. She hoped that if she was loud enough and difficult enough, if she convinced enough people that this was worth the fight, it would somehow, somehow, somehow bring them back.
Ori and Berior had arranged a gathering outside the Great Hall, with a rota of dwarves and young elves chanting and handing out papers outlining their case for Kili’s innocence. Dwalin had his own network of young dwarves, who he said were friends of Fili’s. Dwalin had sent them to watch any Guards on patrol around the City, in case there was any sighting or news of her sons. He explained they were all awaiting the signal to mobilise on her command, to try to bring the exiles back by force if they had to. But a fighting force was no good if nobody knew where they were, and even if they had known, Dis was not ready to go down the route of open violence yet. They did not have any supply of weapons, only wooden toys and tools, and despite Dwalin’s confidence, she did not think a horde of ardent young dwarves could possibly take on the elite praetorian Guard. She did not want any other grieving mothers on her conscience.
Twice she had tried to go to the palace to speak to Thranduil directly, and twice she had been turned away at the door. The insult was almost as painful as the failure. This City was supposed to exist upon the dual strands of its two people. It had been a long time since anyone had pretended there were two kings in the City, but she would still have expected some recognition as the heir of Thror. Thorin would not have stood for this treatment, she thought. But what would he have done? Without weapons, without his title, without the political capital granted by his friendship with the elven king, would he have been just as impotent? She had sent her brother the letter to Laketown hoping against hope that it would reach him in time and he would come and magically fix everything - but time was running out.
Ori and Dwalin were bringing her news from their respective efforts when a tall figure could be seen through the stippled glass door of the office. Dis went and pulled it open before they could even knock.
Prince Legolas stood on the other side, in his commander’s uniform and armed. He said quietly, “I need your help.”
“Come in, then,” she said. “If you’re willing to be seen with me. Have you spoken to your father?”
“No, I’ve been from one end of the city to the other all afternoon. I haven’t had a chance.”
“Then I have nothing for you,” she said.
“Your highness, I am afraid it may come to bloodshed if we don’t find some common ground,” Legolas pleaded. “The engineering apprentices are blockading the utilities and threatening a work stoppage. Three times the Guard has dispersed a crowd from the steps of the great hall. The third time they came back with banners.”
“Your father’s secrecy has fed the flames,” Dis picked up a folded wedge of paper from her desk, bound in rough thread, and handed it to him. “The dwarves at the trial have written up their own transcript and copies are being printed and handed out on the street. I have control of the story now, my prince. I will keep pushing this until something breaks. Give me back my sons and we can talk about peace.”
Legolas flicked through the roughly printed tract. “Not very flattering description of me,” he muttered, and dropped it back on the desk. “We may not agree on many things, but neither of us wants to see our City riven and more innocent blood on the streets. We both want to convince my father to at least show his face outside the palace.”
“Then go and convince him–”
“I want you to come with me, Dis,” Legolas cut her off. “Let him hear the pain that is the cause of all this.”
She looked him in the eye. At last she said, “A moment, I’ll just get my coat.”
–-
After they had gone, there was a knock on the door.
“If it’s more elf princes, we’ve had enough for tonight,” growled Dwalin. A small, beardless face peered around the edge of the door, panting as if he had just been sprinting. Dwalin and Ori stared at the face. “Who the blazes are you?” Dwalin asked.
“Uh, my name is Bilbo Baggins. Professional burglar,” Bilbo said, wiping the sweat off his face with his sleeve. “I work for the family, or at least, I did until recently.”
“The family?” Dwalin frowned. “What are you talking about? Where did you even come from?”
“I’m looking for Dis,” Bilbo said. “It’s extremely urgent, is she here?”
Ori shook his head. “She just left. I’m sure she won’t be too long.”
Bilbo sighed heavily. He let himself into the office, despite Dwalin’s warning growl, and threw himself into an empty chair beside the desk. “I’ve been to her house and they sent me here. I’ve run practically all the way from Laketown since this morning and I’ve not had a single proper meal. Can either of you bring me a cup of coffee, at least?”
Dwalin started to bluster a colourfully spoken protest at his brazenness, but Ori said, “Of course!” and went into the side room to fetch a cup. The pot in the little kitchen had some lukewarm and well-brewed tea at the bottom. He added a generous spoonful of honey to balance the bitterness of the over-soaked leaves, brought it back to Bilbo and put it in his free hand. “There you are, Mr Baggins. You can wait here for the princess.”
Bilbo had only one hand free because with the other, he was holding the small, roughly-printed booklet that Dis had shown to Legolas. He had read the first few pages already. He took the cup without looking and sipped it. After a moment he glanced up at Ori, making a pained face.
Ori wrung his hands. “I’m sorry, we only had tea and it is a bit cold, but we’ve all been up to our ears–”
“The tea’s fine. Is this accurate?” Bilbo waved the booklet. “Is this what actually happened at the trial?”
“Oh, yes, I transcribed most of it myself,” Ori said proudly. “Maybe I added a few of the more florid descriptions later, but the spoken words are pretty much all bang on the anvil.”
Bilbo went back to the small booklet, turning the pages with one hand while he drank the tea. He did not take long to finish before he set the cup down on the desk. “I have to go.”
“Do you want us to leave a message for Dis?” Ori asked.
“No, thank you. I think I can solve this murder and clear Kili’s name, but I’ll have to run for it again,” Bilbo bowed quickly. “Thank you for the tea.”
He was out the door before either of them could question him further. Bilbo ran, trying to work out the fastest route to the palace. He’d spent days in this City but it was not an easy place to navigate, as none of the streets ever ran straight for long and there were never any right-angles. But he had to get there before Thorin could do something really stupid.
It was clear from reading Ori’s transcript that nobody at the trial understood what had happened. But if Bilbo could prove who the real killer was, then maybe, maybe, he could force the king, or the praetorians, or anyone else who would listen, to intervene before the dragon arrived.
Bilbo had the advantage of being on the outside, and perhaps the comfort of seeing it all laid out on paper, and also of course, he had direct knowledge of the night in question. Nobody had called him as a witness, but he realised now that he was key to many of the events described in the trial. He and Dis had been the last known people - apart from the killer - to see Tauriel alive. And he had heard some of her final words to Dis, when Dis had asked her not to reveal their newly discovered secret. Tauriel had claimed she was running off in a hurry “just to return these keys.” Bilbo knew that even people trying to hide something tended to speak in half-truths.
Now he was sure he was the only one who could track all of Tauriel’s movements over the night in question, at least until the very end. She had met with Legolas before she caught Bilbo in the praetorian’s quarters. That meant the keys, evidently not hers, almost certainly belonged to Legolas. So when she left Dis’ house, she had been going back to the palace to return them to the prince. Maybe she really had intended just to put the keys back in his rooms - evidently they were not still missing, or Bilbo was sure it would have come out in the trial, and blamed on Kili with everything else - or maybe she had always intended to seek out someone while she was there, and tell them what she had learned. He didn’t know Tauriel well enough to be sure whether she had betrayed Dis or threatened to shout about the dragon in the streets, but he was sure either way that the person she’d met in the palace had silenced her.
After all, she had not been attacked by assassins, who would surely have brought their own weapons. And she would not have spoken of these matters anywhere she would be overheard. So her killer had to be someone she trusted to meet her alone, in the middle of the night, in the palace, who would listen to her story about dragons and dwarves sacrificed for Mithril. Oh, and as Balin had so succinctly determined, it was an elf. So by Bilbo’s estimation, that left an increasingly short list of suspects. He couldn’t know how many trusted friends Tauriel had in the palace, of course, but he knew two for a start.
He reached the gates of the palace only to find, in great despair, that they were shut tight. He glanced up at the stars through a gap in the trees. How long? How long before the dragon was on the wing? Had Thorin already reached the hill? There must still be time, there must be.
Bilbo blew out a frustrated breath, knocked on the doors and slipped on the ring just as he heard hobnail-booted footsteps on the far side. The doors of the palace swung open and a guard looked around in confusion. Unseen, Bilbo slipped under his arm and tried to run as softly as he could.
He had explored this palace thoroughly over the past few days. He would start with the elven king’s rooms. He dodged around a nighttime patrol and under the elbows of a retainer carrying a tray of empty glasses. Up steps and through grand archways and finally, he saw to his relief that the double doors to the king’s private apartments stood open just a crack.
Bilbo squeezed inside. The lamps were lit with a gentle, warm light, but he could not hear and see anybody. He scurried across the polished, wooden floors and began to search. He pulled open drawers and cupboards and lifted up the mattress on the sofa and peeked behind the paintings hanging on the walls. He was just about to leave when he heard a myriad of approaching footsteps.
In his panic and exhaustion, he forgot that he was invisible and dashed to the corner of the room, sliding under the huge desk and tucking himself behind one of its raw wood legs, formed of a natural twist in the ancient oak. From where he was crouching, he saw three pairs of legs walk through the doors, two elves and a dwarf.
Bilbo shook himself. He was perfectly safe with the ring on. None of them would notice if he snuck out. And then, as he prepared to crawl out from under the desk as quietly as he could, he looked across the room to spy the clearest line for the door. From his new perspective low down, his eyes caught sight of a strange shape in the shadows beneath the nearby cabinet.
–
On the top of the hill, Kili was sleeping against Fili’s side, his legs curled up and his head pillowed against his brother’s chest. Fili kept his arm slung around his brother’s shoulders, glad to feel his breath finally grow even and peaceful. Fili didn’t want to sleep, though he was sure he’d wish he had, come the morning. He had no idea what time it was by now. He was really thirsty. He’d have to ask the praetorians for something when they came back to feed the fires. They had periodically returned to add more of the green-burning leaves.
The wind was picking up, the grass shifting around them, rushing over the crest of the hill in a sudden burst like a gale. It was so loud that Kili stirred and raised his head. Something flickered in the moonlight like a handful of falling hail and struck the ground around them. Fili saw one of the glimmers had fallen near him, shining in the grass. His fingers closed around it and he raised it to his face. A silver metal scale, like from a coat of mail armour. Not actually silver, though - it was paler, and as light in the hand as paper.
Fili looked up at the sky and said in a puzzled voice, “It’s raining mithril.”
—
“Father, If you don’t address this now, someone will start a riot,” Legolas was saying.
Dis followed the two of them into the grand reception room in the palace. Thranduil sat down at a large desk carved of a single, curled bough of oak, in a room overlooking the City. The doors to the balcony were wide open and the lamps glittered among the trees and roofs below. He started flicking through the pages of something, and picked up a glass of wine in his other hand. Dis saw, upside down, that the papers were a missive with Tulus’ name signed to each page.
Without looking up, Thranduil said in a flat voice, “We don’t need to discuss this tonight. I’m sure this morning was very distressing for both of you. Go to bed and rest.”
Legolas gritted his teeth. “The City will not rest tonight. Everywhere, people are talking in the streets of this matter. Everybody has an opinion, and some of them are getting very loud.”
“The old dwarves from Erebor have always been obnoxious. Give it a hundred years and we won’t have to worry about them any more.”
“The old dwarves are on your side, from the ones I spoke to,” Dis said. “They say the rule of law is sacrosanct and must be respected. It’s the young ones who are angry.”
Legolas stepped in beside her. “And not just the dwarves. We had to bring off-duty forest guards into the city to help the constables. Fifty of the forest recruits are claiming they are sick and cannot serve, to avoid going against the civilian agitators. Several more are asking me to implement a curfew for all dwarves and begin mass arrests. Everyone, everywhere is divided.”
Thranduil raised one eyebrow. “So you have a handful of partisans in a thousand? Relieve both sides of their duties. The rest of them will fall into place.”
“Father,” Legolas said, “You should have handled this with more delicacy. The boy was very popular.”
“So was his uncle, and nobody talks about him anymore,” Thranduil drawled, tidying up the pages of Tulus’ report and leaning back in his chair.
Legolas let out a slow breath. “He was your friend.”
“I barely knew the boy.”
“I mean Thorin,” Legolas said firmly. “I remember when there was no one else you listened to above him. No one else you called for when our two peoples struggled, suffered together. What really happened to him?”
“He dug his own grave, is what happened,” Thranduil took a sip of wine and gave Legolas a scandalised look. “He was causing trouble, and he didn’t like the consequences.”
“Did you have Thorin framed?” Dis asked quietly.
Thranduil held her gaze. He said nothing. He ran his finger around the rim of the glass.
Legolas said, “I was certain that Kili was the one who killed her. But I think I made a mistake. When we arrested him, I saw the guilt in his face. He never defended himself. I thought it was his outrage that we had caught him so quickly. But now I wonder if it was grief, only grief. I don’t think he knew she was dead until that moment.”
Thranduil met this soliloquy with a heavy sigh. He pushed himself out of his chair and walked to the balcony with his wine. “Then it is well for our city that the law does not base its decisions on your sentiments, but on proof and prudence.”
“Father, if there is someone else who could be responsible, I want them punished,” Legolas felt his voice grow sharp as a sword-edge. The uncertain fear that the killer might still be in the City, free and unknown, felt like a ligature around his throat. He could not bear the not-knowing. He would not be able to wash Tauriel’s bloodless, dead face from his thoughts until he was sure they had suffered even a fraction of what she had suffered.
“The culprit has been punished and exiled. This matter is closed.”
“There is still time to put another in their place,” Dis took a half step forward. “Let me go instead of them.”
Thranduil turned slowly to face her, his eyes locked in hers with a new and dangerous glare. “So, you have secrets of your own, Princess,” he tilted his head. “And you did not even tell your own sons? You did not warn them?”
Dis felt the barb plunge deep and could not make any reply. And in her ear, in that moment of silence, she heard a voice - not unfamiliar - whisper the strangest thing: “The cabinet, Dis. It’s under the cabinet.”
She shook her head as if brushing off a fly. She must be losing her mind.
Legolas picked up the argument. “You need to consider a retrial. The praetorians can recall the exiles, imprison them for now. But show our people and the dwarves that you can be fair and listen to their unease, and you will have their loyalty stronger than ever before.”
Dis said, desperate now. “Call them back. I’ll never reveal what I know, if it saves their lives tonight.”
Again came what sounded to Dis like Bilbo’s voice. “Look! Under! The! Cabinet! The one with the silver things in it.”
Dis turned her head a little. It was definitely Bilbo’s voice. But she could not see the hobbit anywhere. Was this some clever trick his people had, some magic? And why, in the middle of this critical conversation, was he trying to tell her about cabinets?
Thranduil shook his head, sipping the wine. He said quietly, “It is too late, Princess. The beacons are already lit.”
Dis shivered. She had nothing else left to play. She turned to Legolas and she pointed. “There’s something under the cabinet. Over there.”
“What?” Legolas looked as baffled as she felt. “What’s that got to do with anything?”
Thranduil had turned back to look at them both. He looked confused as well, but also wary, as if this sudden change in the wind was tacking towards a place he didn’t want to go. He didn’t attempt to silence Dis as she repeated, “Look under the cabinet. I saw something as we came in, from across the room. I don’t know what, but I think it’s important. Please, I’m not going mad.”
Legolas glanced at his father, and then crossed the room and knelt elegantly. He reached one long-fingered hand under the display cabinet, took a moment to feel around, and then froze. He drew out a short sword, the handle embossed with the sigil of the Guard and the rank of Captain.
There was no sound in Dis’ ears except the thudding of her own heart. She looked at Thranduil. His face was a mask of shock and fury. It seemed he had not realised the sword was there, perhaps had not realised the significance of its absence and so had not looked for it. He made no attempt to disavow any knowledge of it. There was surely nothing he could have said to explain how it had ended up in his private room.
Legolas stumbled backwards as he stood up, cradling the sword on his open palms. He stared at it for a long time. His breath came in small, pained hitches, as if he had been punched in the gut.
At last he snatched a silk scarf from the back of the nearby settee and wrapped up the sword as if it was something delicate and precious. He cradled it in one elbow and put his right hand to his own sword, on his hip. He still had not looked at his father. Then he seemed to change his mind and did not draw his own sword. He turned to Dis.
“We’re going. Now.”
Dis looked between the two elves. Thranduil had put his wine down on the railing of the balcony. He had no weapon, but he looked as if he was preparing for a fight.
“Where?” Dis asked.
“To the praetorians,” Legolas said. “I am taking command of them as of this moment. The king is not capable. I will order them to recall your sons with all haste.”
There came a rending scream from far, far away, yet loud enough and deep enough to make the floor beneath their feet tremble and the wine in the glass ripple. Dis and Legolas flinched and turned to look at the sky through the open doors of the balcony. They had all been present at the burning of Erebor and knew that sound in their bones. After a moment, it came a second time, not so loud or so deep but unmistakable.
“There,” Thranduil said gently, as the last tail of the scream faded. “He has come for them. It is done. Will you let it rest, now?”
–
Three days earlier, Tauriel went straight from Princess Dis’ house to the palace.
She had listened to Dis’ warning. She had considered it. And then she had gone to Thranduil and told him she knew what really happened to the dwarves who were exiled from the city. She did not say how she knew or who she had discussed it with.
“Tell me there is another explanation, my king,” Tauriel said. “I cannot believe it. I will not. Do not let me believe it.”
Thranduil looked at her and turned away, staring out the open balcony at the city beyond. The eternal lights glowed like the stars come to earth, the canals trickled beneath the paths and filled the air with the scent of cool water under the woven ceiling of living branches far above. The most beautiful city in the world, more beautiful than Doriath at its peak, as clever in its workings and fierce in its defenses as the ancient realms of Numenor and Eregion. Nothing compared to their City, to his City.
Thranduil turned back to her. He said, “How many of those old dwarves would have died, if I had not welcomed them to my realm?” He tilted his head. “How many would have perished from their wounds, starved on the road, frozen when that first winter rolled over them?” He touched his chest. “I had to protect them. And once I did, I could not take back my hospitality. They were my responsibility. But they were too many, Tauriel. They grew and they bred, like animals. And still I loved them and wanted to keep them and shelter them. But the woodland palace could not hold us all. The Mithril which powered our early experiments had run out. There was not enough water in the wells. Not enough fuel for the fires. Families were sleeping on the streets or crushed in the halls living in darkness, because we could not build or light the homes they needed. It was an impossible situation,” Thranduil took a long breath through his nose. “And I only gave him criminals, in the beginning. I offered him troubled and despised dwarves who would have been banished by their own kin and died in the wilderness.”
“King Thrain was not a criminal. He was not despised.”
“He was an antiquated obstacle to the progress of his own people,” Thranduil shrugged. “No one even looked for him after he disappeared.”
“You sacrificed them,” Tauriel whispered. “Didn’t you? Like some old worship of Morgoth and the primeval powers, in ancient times.”
“Don’t be dramatic. It was never a gift, I never gave Smaug anything for free,” Thranduil leaned back against the edge of his desk and folded his arms. “The dragon had spoken to me, after I risked my life to buy time for the dwarves to escape the mountain. As we fled from him, he said he liked the sport of chasing us. So when we were in dire need, I went to the mountain and I offered him sport, in exchange for mithril. He prizes it below the gold and gems on which he sleeps, he picks it out of his hoard like a child pushing vegetables to the side of their plate. He was willing to part with a little mithril, a few tiny trinkets, which was all we needed. And in exchange for so few,” Thranduil leaned into the last words, almost hissing them. “It was one dwarf every seven years, give or take. Those few lives bought us so much. Walk through my streets, Tauriel. Tell me how many children you see, elf and dwarf, playing together, growing together in peace and endless delights. Would you rather they lived in war and famine? How many of them would have died before they saw their first birthday, or never have been conceived at all, if we did not live in a city of such safety and plenty?”
Tauriel shook her head, feeling a numb ice flowing through her limbs. “You are a monster. You have poisoned what was good in this place.”
“I have created life from blood and bone, which any good gardener can tell you makes the richest soil,” Thranduil intoned. “Even the uppity little guard that Legolas tells me you have grown too close to. Would he have been born if I had not taken on this burden? If I had not acted as a king should, and protected my people? All my people.”
Tauriel felt the ice in her chest turn molten. “The dwarves do not owe their children to you! You do not own them! And if you think you can distract me with such jibes, don’t bother. I am rid of my affection for the dwarf. It was a passing dream.”
Thranduil raised one sharp brow. “Good. So you have retained some sense,” he turned a little, hands clasped behind his back, looking into the rich blue lake stitched into the tapestry that hung on the wall. “You have spared yourself the grief of watching him change. watching him grow old and ugly. They are impossible to love forever. All mortals transform with time, they wilt like a fallen fruit or grow too hard and dry, and soon enough you can see the bones in them waiting for the worms to bring out. I know,” he said, and met her eye again. “I have made the same mistake. I have been drawn to the glow of their youth, but it is a corpse-light. Love them too much and it will be the death of you, as the elves of old gave up their bodies and freed their spirits when their husbands fell in battle.”
Tauriel held his gaze. “You must stop these… offerings to Smaug.” She said firmly. “We will find another way to feed the City.”
He shook his head. “It does not do to rescind a bargain with a dragon. I would bring the wyrm down on us if I denied him his occasional pleasures.”
“Then we will kill it!” Tauriel pleaded. “We are not helpless prey!”
Again, he simply shook his head. “Let it sit in your heart for a while, Tauriel, and you will come to understand. This is the only way.”
Thranduil had taken her in when she had no family left to shelter her or teach her. She of all his children should understand the danger that the world posed. He had given her a place and a purpose in his realm. He was sure she would understand.
“No,” Tauriel pointed at him. “You will confess. Tell Dis Thrainsdaughter what you have done, and she will summon the greatest of her artificers and make a weapon that can kill the dragon. Then we can be rid of its threat and the City be cleansed of your sins.”
Thranduil gave a small peal of laughter. “You would shatter us as a people. If they learn the truth now, the dwarves will leave and return to the road, or their kin in the miserable halls of distant mountains. The City will be made destitute. I will tell them, in time, once they are ready - not yet, but in two generations, or three, once the City is the only home they know. Once they no longer remember how to live underground.”
“They are free to go where they will,” Tauriel answered. “Let them choose.”
Thranduil did not reply, and she realised she was wrong. They were not free. He was closing the gilded cage around them, slowly, slowly, by offering them over a hundred years of comfort and seclusion, he was bending the bars into place without them even knowing it. He did not want to let them go. They had been guests, but they had become profitable assets.
“You will tell them now, tonight. Come with me and tell Dis,” Tauriel said in a low voice. “Or I will go and explain everything to my lord Legolas. I will ask him to summon your court and rescind your mandate as king. You are not fit to rule and your throne can be usurped for the good of all.”
“Do not threaten me,” he snarled.
“You have until dawn to decide,” she said, and turned to go. As she reached the top of the steps, she felt a hand stronger than steel lock around her elbow. She spun, instinctively reaching for her swords. “Release me!”
“If you speak of this to a soul, you will be stripped of all titles and cast out of my Woodland,” Thranduil hissed. “Daughter you were to me, but I will name you outcast and traitor.”
“Then I will go gladly, and all will know the truth as I walk away!” She tried to pull out his grasp again, but he held firm. With her left hand, Tauriel drew the short sword at her hip. “I recant any vows of service to you, now and forever!”
Thranduil let go of her arm, but in the same movement he grabbed for her sword on her other hip and drew it from its sheath. He turned her blade aside like it was a twig over his path, and seized her around the throat with his free hand. “You will leave when I command it.”
Tauriel tried to strike the sword out of his hand, but they were locked close and both were clumsy. She knocked his arm away and he raised it high to avoid her, but the tip of her blade nicked a few strands of his hair, and scraped the tiniest line of blood across his face, high on his cheekbone, almost at his temple. His lips drew back from his teeth and she saw for a moment that he was overwhelmed by instinct, some memory of wars long passed, taking him over like programmed clockwork.
He drove the blade down in an arc and into her left breast, through the delicately woven brocade, through the silk undershirt, through skin and the filament of muscle between her ribs and skimmed the edge of a lung and in further. All of it happened in a heartbeat, and that was one of her last heartbeats.
She felt her fingers open and the sword in her hand tumbled away with a ringing like a bell, skidding to rest under the cabinet nearby. Tauriel felt herself falling. Thranduil caught her, and cradled her, and she saw the shock and horror in his face. “My daughter, my daughter, forgive me,” he whispered. “Hold strong, I will try to slow the bleeding.” She felt his palm on her chest.
She put her hand over his, and then stretched her fingers to the buttons of her outer vest, looking for the little silk pocket inside. Her fingers touched the soft, braided circle of hair with its silver clasp. She managed to draw it out, clutching it close to her failing heart. She gripped it tight and tried to speak as felt herself being dragged beneath the shadows growing at the edges of her vision, “Tell him, tell him…”
But that was all she managed to say before the darkness took her.
Chapter 11: Smaug
Chapter Text
Thorin was halfway up Stargazer Hill when he saw one of the praetorians. He was not trying to keep quiet - as if it would have done any good, with their keen ears - and in the faint moonlight he saw the archer kneeling in the grass just as they saw him. In a moment, they had an arrow aimed at his throat from thirty feet away. He stopped, his hand on his sword but not drawing it.
“You know me, Bramben,” he said. Before his downfall, Thorin had been part of Thranduil’s inner court for over a hundred years. He knew the king’s most trusted inner ring; their faces, their names, their favourite drink. Sometimes they had even been his friends. “Let me speak to Esgal.”
The elf did not lower the arrow, but he whistled sharply. They had less than a minute to wait before another praetorian appeared around the curve of the hill, and from the crest behind them, at a light jog, came Captain Esgal. The green glow of the pyres shone on his face. These were elves who were old for the most part, who were the sharpest troops in the City and had seen more in their long lives than Thorin could even imagine. But it was still satisfying to see a brief flash of surprise in Esgal’s eyes.
“Thorin, son of Thrain,” Esgal said, with the wary softness bred by the forest’s dangers. “You are a wanted dwarf in these lands. I am charged to bring you home in fetters if I can catch you.”
“Consider me caught. Is my kin up on that hill?” Thorin had no time for banter. Esgal did not answer. Thorin barked. “I know the dragon is coming. Is it Kili? Is that who you’re feeding to the beast tonight? As you gave up my father for a pittance of treasure?”
Esgal drew in a sharp breath, not hiding his shock that Thorin was so well-informed. Then he said, without hiding the pity, “It’s both of your nephews, Thorin. Fili wouldn’t be parted from his brother, even in his exile, and we are under oath to reveal nothing to anyone outside the dragon guard. It’s kinder if they don’t know what’s coming.”
Thorin felt his stomach lurch and his knees weaken. He tightened his hand on his sword. But there were three of them, and he was old and out of practice, and they were all faster with a blade even if they hadn’t had arrows to fill him with holes from a distance. He had only one choice.
“I’ll take their place,” he called. “Let me go up there. The lads will leave if I order them to leave, and they need never know Thranduil’s secret. Let them go and be exiles and I’ll stand in as your payment for the Mithril.”
Esgal looked up at the moon, raising his arm to protect his face as a wind rose and flattened the grass around them. He glanced at Thorin and nodded. “Go, then. Go quickly. He’s coming!” He looked at the other two praetorians. “Spread the word around the hills, let the young ones flee where they will.”
Thorin was already clambering up the last of the slope, wading through thigh-high grass and tussock, stumbling a little in divots and stones in the dark. As he reached the great ring of boulders, the land flattened into a gentle meadow that until now Thorin had always thought of as a place of beauty and tranquility, rising above the shadow of the trees. In the light of the green fires, it was revealed to be an eerie and sickly monument, a place of sacrifice and doom. How many had been traded away here, unwitting until the last moment when the dragon reached out of the darkness and snatched them up, to carry away to its lair, to torment and play with like a mouse under a cat’s paws, to drag out their deaths for who knew how long? He had to save his nephews from that fate. Thorin sprinted past the looming stones that stood like teeth in a mouth and came into the meadow beyond.
Fili and Kili stood in the centre of the ring, very close together, Kili rubbing his eyes as if he’d just woken up. Thorin had not seen them in more than two years, but they had changed little; Fili’s hair was longer, and Kili’s was braided down his back like an elf. Their faces were turned to the east, to the sky, still frowning with confusion rather than fear. Amongst the huge boulders they looked tiny and so, so fragile.
“Run!” Thorin bellowed, not breaking his stride, taking his hand off his sword to wave his arm. “Run, lads!”
Kili turned with a jolt as if someone had slapped him. “Thorin?” he called, and for the briefest moment he smiled.
Thorin wanted only to embrace them, to hold them, to tell them how much he’d missed them and ask them everything he had lost since he had left the City, but there was simply no time.
Fili had not taken his eyes from the night sky. He raised his hand and pointed. For the briefest moment he looked over at Thorin, but his face wasn’t smiling; his expression was curdling into fear. Thorin was yards away now. He could hear the deep, howling pulse of huge, batlike wings.
“Run!,” he roared, and Fili bolted like a hunting dog at a whistle. He grabbed Kili’s shoulder and spun him, shoved him and ran, dragging his brother by the upper arm.
Thorin turned to see Smaug sink out of the sky and settle on two of the huge boulders, perched like an owl above a nest. His scales shone green in the light of the pyres. There came a low, rumbling laugh that Thorin could feel in the earth, through his boots and the soles of his feet. “So,” the dragon said. “The leaf-clad king was feeling generous today, and has given me three toys.”
Thorin found himself looking up into two huge, foul-breathed nostrils. He couldn’t make himself step any closer, but he raised his arms away from his body to look as willing as possible, to try and get the dragon’s attention. He wondered what his father had thought, standing perhaps in this same spot on this same hill, knowing how terribly he had been betrayed by the elven host he had trusted. Thorin focused on his own rage and grief, to suppress the terror at the sight of teeth as long as his arm and the broiling chemical scent from deep in the dragon’s belly.
“I’m the trade, your impotent lizard,” Thorin bellowed. “Don’t let your gluttony give you a stomach ache. One dwarf for the king’s regular pocket money, isn’t that the agreement?”
He didn’t dare look away until the dragon’s wing reached right over the stone circle, arching over Thorin like the bough of a huge yew, and slammed down on the far side. Then he glanced back to see the clawed fingers digging into the soft earth between two of the huge stones, blocking Fili and Kili’s escape. The great tail curled around the outside of the stones. There was no way out.
“My bargain is not with you, dwarf, and you cannot edit the terms in your favour,” Smaug chuckled.
Before Thorin could react, Smaug’s other wing-hand reached out and gripped him, enclosing him from ankles to shoulders. Before the claws tightened completely, he managed to draw the sword and free one of his arms above the dragon’s scaled joint. He felt himself lifted off the ground, and groaned as the pressure pushed the air from his lungs. Smaug began to spread his wings to rise, reaching out towards his nephews to sweep all three of them up together.
Thorin had to do something or Smaug would have them all and he would have given his life for nothing. The dragon’s scales, Thorin knew, were impenetrable, but he saw suddenly that where the claw met the finger-like bone, there was a connection that looked like softer skin. Thorin raised his sword and jammed it as deep as he could into that thin crescent of soft tissue at the base of the claw.
Smaug gave a scream that rippled through Thorin’s bones and deafened him completely. Its toys from the Woodland had always been disarmed before today; it was probably a very long time since it had been hurt. The scream made the trees tremble and flattened the leaves in every direction. The stacked, burning pyres cracked and fell outwards in a shower of sparks. In the City, the scream hummed in the tree trunks and wooden posts of the homes and halls, waking a few old dwarves from dark dreams. In Laketown, the water rippled like in a breeze and old fishermen late on their boats looked up at the sky without knowing why.
Smaug sprang into the air and flew straight up, and for the briefest moment Thorin was able to look down and saw his nephews standing far below on the solid ground, their faces lit by the clashing lights of the dragon’s red glow and the last of the green fire. So they were safe. He had done that much. Thorin gritted his teeth, feeling his ribs and the joints of his body bending in the dragon’s grip, and dug the sword in deeper, twisting it as hard as he could. Smaug howled again and in his pain his claws opened as he flew upwards like an arrow, releasing Thorin into the empty night air.
Thorin felt his breath rush into his lungs at last, and then he began to fall.
—
As the dragon rose away from them and the gaps between the stones opened once more, Fili grabbed his brother and tried to run. Kili’s feet wouldn’t move. He was leaning away from Fili, neck craned back to where the dragon’s wingbeat had lifted the beast higher than the tallest roof in the city. Fili hauled on him until he stumbled backwards, and Fili heard the dragon’s howl of pain ring out a second time.
“Thorin!” Kili screamed, and it was a howl of pure, helpless horror; and then out of the corner of his eye Fili saw and heard something hit the ground near the very peak of the hill.
“Come on!” Fili kept dragging him until Kili’s feet were forced to run or he’d fall over. Fili could not think about what was happening, he could only think about one thing, and that was to get him and his brother away from here. Nothing could be worse than remaining in this exposed circle. This trap they had let themselves walk into.
He got Kili moving and pushed him ahead. They half-fell, half-ran past the circle of stones and down the hill, feet snagging in the grass.
Fili saw a shape rising, twenty feet to his right. He grabbed Kili’s shoulders and pushed him down. There was, very faintly, beneath the dying echoes of the dragon’s wingbeats, the twang of a bow.
Fili felt as if someone had punched him in the back with a closed fist. He stumbled and they both fell. Kili twisted as they went down and caught him around the chest. They ended up in the grass, tangled together with Fili on top. That’s when the pain hit and he made a noise that would have been embarrassing if his mind wasn’t overwhelmed with a black, burning agony radiating from his left shoulder. Kili put his hand over Fili’s mouth and tried to hush him, his head turning towards where the praetorian’s shape was cut out against the stars on the curve of the hill. Fili’s breath came in short, sharp gasps through his nose as he tried to stay quiet.
They heard the captain’s voice from further away. “Hold! Hold your arrows! My orders were to let the young dwarves go!”
There was a surprised reply from the nearby archer, though Fili couldn’t quite make out the Sindarin words. He couldn’t really see or hear much around the pain. At the sound of the praetorian’s exchange, Kili hauled Fili up and stood on Fili’s right side, slipping his arm around Fili’s back, under his shoulders. He hissed, “We have to get into the forest. They won’t find us there.”
“Thorin,” Fili whispered. “Did the dragon get Thorin?”
“No,” Kili said, barely louder than a breath. “It flew away and Thorin fell. From very high.”
Fili made his feet move as Kili half-carried and half-dragged him down the slope and into the trees, keeping their pace as swift as Fili could manage. The shadows closed over them until it was nearly pitch black. Fili had only ever left the city at night for feasts or festive rituals or, very occasionally, youthful outings with friends on a dare; but they had always brought torches with them. He had never been in the forest after dark without lamp-lined paths, or open clearings with strings of little lights like a glimmering mosaic of colour. He had heard all the stories of spiders and orcs and darker things lurking under these trees. Roots and rocks tripped his feet and the branches tugged at his clothes. But Kili moved through it without hesitation, as if he knew every tree, as if he was navigating in broad daylight. This was his forest, his daily duty. He clearly knew where he was going.
“Leave me. Just get out of here,” Fili tried to say, though it came out as mostly a mumble.
Kili must have figured out the gist, though, because he replied. “No. Not even if they kill me. I’m not losing you, too. Stay awake. I’ll bloody kill you if you die on me, Fili. I mean it.”
Deeper into the forest they went, leaving the Stargazer Hill and its sacrificial altar behind.
--
At the top of the hill, Captain Esgal and several of the praetorians entered the ring of stones from all sides, approaching the small, dark shape that lay near the centre of the grassy circle. A few glinting scales of mithril, torn from some ancient, dwarvish armour, lay in the grass around the motionless body. Esgal stepped in close and knelt beside Thorin, laying his hand on the dwarf’s chest in a silent prayer to speed his spirit onwards to the halls of rest. After a moment, he raised his head sharply to look at his troops.
“He’s alive. By the gods, I don’t believe it.”
“Sir, what do we do?” Bramden asked. “The bargain is broken. What if the dragon is aggrieved? Do we leave Master Thorin here, for it to return and claim him?”
“Smaug doesn’t want enfeebled prey,” Esgal shook his head. “It’s too late. Even if we could catch the exiles, I don’t think the dragon is the sort to gracefully accept apologies. Make a litter, we’ll take Master Thorin back to the City. Bramden, run ahead as fast as you can and alert the king of all that has happened.”
Chapter 12: A Quiet Night Under the Trees
Chapter Text
Haered was deep in the forest on patrol when he sensed an ambush. He drew and aimed, finding his target not high in the branches, as he’d expected, but low down: there was a dwarf standing between the trees, not three yards away, raising his hands in surrender. How by all that was green had a dwarf snuck up on him?
“It’s me, Haered, it’s me!”
Haered lowered his bow. “Kili?”
“I’m not armed.” Kili moved a couple of steps out of the thick undergrowth. He was in the same clothes he’d worn at the trial, and carried nothing; no bag, no visible weapons, not even a proper coat for the autumn weather. There was something strange about his face and voice that Haered couldn’t name.
Haered could not understand what his exiled comrade was doing here, far away from the main road. It seemed he had been waiting, or perhaps following, the regular patrol routes, and must have stepped off the path as Haered approached. Haered felt a rush of annoyance at himself for being detected by anyone, even a fellow recruit. He lowered his arrow and gritted his teeth.
“I’m not supposed to talk to you. You’re exiled.”
“I need your help,” Kili cut him off. Haered realised that the strangeness was that the Kili he knew from the Guard was always chatty and cheerful, and now he looked and sounded so cold and grim he was almost unrecognisable. Everything about his expression and bearing had changed from the fellow recruit Haered had spent two years training with.
“You’re a murderer,” said Haered.
Kili took a moment to reply, then he said at last, “My brother’s hurt. No matter what you think of me, you know he’s done nothing wrong. Please, help me, and then we’ll be on our way and no one needs to know.”
Haered slowly put his arrow back in its quiver and stowed his bow. “Show me.”
Kili led him off the path and down a small gully, along a mossy step of rock, sheltered by overhanging roots and leaning trees. A tiny stream trickled past the flat rock, fed by the dripping walls of the gully, and then vanished underground. One of the rare places in the forest where the water was clear and not tinged by the Mirkwood poisons. Even with his elven eyes, there was barely enough moonlight to see a few feet, so Haered found his lamp in his bag and lit it.
Kili was kneeling down to put the back of his hand on his brother’s forehead. Fili lay on his right side, his head pillowed on a rolled up vest. He had his eyes closed and was shivering, but he was not asleep; his hand was gripping tight to his left shoulder, where his clothes were dark with blood. Some torn cloth had been packed around it, but it was soaked through as well. Kili went quickly to the stream, dipping another piece of cleanish cloth. He brought it back to his brother, wringing it out to help and helping him drink.
“What happened?” Haered asked, not yet approaching.
Kili looked up from under his dark brows. “We did everything the praetorians said. They took us up Stargazer Hill and made us wait, no food, no water, no warm clothes. When we tried to leave, they shot at us.”
“Why would they do that? What else happened out there?”
“You wouldn’t believe me if I told you.”
Haered had to admit Kili was right. He didn’t believe this could possibly be the whole story but he also wasn’t willing to trust anything Kili said. He finally knelt down on the mossy rock. Fili opened his eyes and tensed as Haered carefully lifted the bandage from the front of his shoulder. Haered could not stop a sharp intake of breath. It was an elvish arrow, a woodland arrow, identical to those in Haered’s quiver right now. And it was the point that was emerging below Fili’s collarbone; the shaft could be seen on the far side, above the shoulder blade, though it had been expertly snapped off. Haered looked up at Kili with wide eyes.
“They shot him in the back!”
“I told you. We were trying to leave. Look at us, we’re unarmed,” Kili said quietly, as if reciting the rules of grammar in language class. “It’s not just us. This is what they do. That’s why none of the dwarven exiles have ever tried to return,” Kili held his gaze. “They don’t get put on the road to make their way in the world. They die. They all die.”
“You don’t know what you’re talking about. Or you’re lying,” Haered snapped back. "You tried to escape, didn't you?"
He pressed the makeshift bandage back to Fili’s shoulder and Fili gave a small grunt. He finally spoke up, his voice hoarse and his breathing shallow. “Believe him or don’t, but I’d really like to see another sunset.”
“I know the north outpost is less than half a mile along your route. That’s why I was waiting for one of our team,” Kili explained. “There’ll be supplies at the outpost but I can’t risk being seen there. Can you bring me a field surgeon’s kit, and as many clean bandages as you can find, and maybe some rations and a water skin or two? Then you can be on your way and they’ll assume I robbed the place. I’ll take the arrow out and suture it myself, and we’ll head for Laketown as soon as Fili’s able to walk. Tell nobody we came here and we’ll never step foot in the Woodland again, I swear.”
“Please,” Fili added, almost like he was reminding his little brother to be polite.
“Alright,” Haered said. “But only because your brother doesn’t deserve… whatever happened.”
Haered left them at a swift jog. Kili tried to keep Fili drinking water and talking while they waited.
“Why?” Kili kept asking. “If they wanted to execute criminals, why not just line us up against a rock and shoot us full of arrows? Why would Thranduil choose such a horrible way to get rid of us? To keep the dragon content in his ill-gotten hall? So no elf needs to act the executioner themselves? It seems like such a risk of raising the monster’s ire.”
“I don’t know,” rasped Fili. “I think there’s a lot we don’t know.”
“How did Thorin know we were there?”
“I don’t know that either,” Fili closed his eyes. “Can I just sleep, just for a few minutes? You can wake me.”
“No. No, I’ll shake your bad shoulder if you dare. You’ve bled too much.”
Fili grumbled and said, a little petulantly, “Ma and Tauriel were up to something. Maybe they knew about this.”
“What? What do you mean?”
Fili regretted the slip immediately. He wasn’t thinking straight. This was not the right time to talk to Kili about Tauriel. He couldn’t take it back now. “The night before she died, Tauriel was in our house, talking to Ma. I interrupted them when I came home. I thought she was there to talk about you, of course. But I think it was some other secret business, that started after you and Tauriel had separated from each other. Ma thinks she was killed because of it, to keep her silent, I suppose.”
Kili could not speak. He could not believe it was only days since that had happened, three days, but he now felt the ordeals weighing him down in layer after layer as if he was enduring them all anew. Dis had not told him any of this when she’d been granted her one visit to him in the cell, which might have been caution in case she was heard by the elven guards but seemed suddenly like a cruel omission to hide her own responsibility. And Fili had kept this from him, until he was literally on his deathbed? It felt like a conspiracy. They had all been keeping secrets from him, even Tauriel. And Ma would have probably said it was to protect him, their paragon of the dwarvish-elvish union, that he had to be lied to and tricked so that he would be above suspicion. What good had their protection done him? If he’d known what was really going on, perhaps he could have defended himself at the trial. Perhaps he could have proved his innocence when he was arrested, so he needn’t have gone through the misery of that trial at all.
Perhaps if they’d all let him in, he could have protected Tauriel.
Certainly he would have stopped Fili joining him in this fatal exile. Ma must have known; her reaction at the trial, when he’d been sentenced, when Fili had joined him - she had known they being sent to the dragon. And instead of warning Kili, she’d let him walk towards his death with his brother beside him. If she’d only told him, he would have forced Fili to stay in the City at any cost, even if Fili hated him for it.
Before he could recover himself, he heard light footsteps in the forest above their gully. He put his finger to his lips, looking up through the darkness to see if it was Haered, or if their conversation had given them away to another patrol. His heart raced as he heard more than one set of footsteps. He’d piled several good, fist-sized stones from the creek nearby, and now reached silently for one.
“Kili? Are you still here?” a voice called. It wasn’t Haered, but Lieutenant Fainthel. As she climbed down into the gully she lit a lamp with the brief hiss of Mithril-glow. She wasn’t alone; Haered was behind her, and two more of the young Guards from Kili’s unit, older recruits who were several years senior to him and Haered. Kili didn’t let go of the stone, and crouched low in front of Fili.
“Haered!” Kili hissed. “Why would you grass on me?”
Haered looked suitably guilty. Fainthel answered for him, “He turned up at the outpost acting odd and I ordered him to speak. You can thank the gods he did. Let us see your brother.”
“Stay away from us,” Kili raised the stone, bringing it back behind his ear ready to throw. “I mean it, I’ll fight all of you. Try knocking me over, I know you can’t, I know how you all fight.”
Fainthel’s eyes glinted in the lamplight, but her face was half-shadowed and hard to read. “Kili, I want to help. You can trust me.”
“Why?” Kili’s voice rose, cracking at the end. “I can’t trust anyone. I did everything you all asked of me, every one of you, everyone at home. I served the king with everything I had, I was loyal to him, I was loyal to my folk, I walked that sword-edge every day and I never slipped up. I even gave up Tauriel so no one would question my loyalties. I loved her and I was the one who pushed her away. And this is how I’ve been repaid,” Kili drew back the stone as Fainthel stepped closer with slow, careful movements, her gaze locked on his face. “I mean it, Lieutenant, leave us alone, I don’t want your help!”
“Kili,” Fainthel raised her hands slowly, half crouched so she was not leaning over him, gently reaching to put her hands on his shoulders. “I believe you. You didn’t kill Tauriel.”
Kili drew his lips back from his teeth, and he didn’t drop the stone, but he didn’t hurl it at her, either. His shoulders sagged. “Why did they do this to us? It can’t be because of me, because I’m a dwarf stepping out of line. Nobody hates anybody that much.”
“We all heard the noises tonight. They probably heard it as far as Rivendell,” Fainthel held his eye. “I helped the dwarves escape Erebor as it burned, even if the rest of you were too young. I know what the dragon sounds like. Did you see Smaug? Here, in the Woodland? Is that what you were running from when the praetorians shot at you?”
Kili nodded. Fainthel patted the side of his neck. “We can talk about it later, son. I want to look at your brother. Can you put the rock down?”
Kili lowered his arm at last, though he couldn’t bring himself to drop the stone. Fainthel knelt down and inspected Fili quickly. She glanced up at Kili. “We have to take him back to the outpost.”
“Can’t you treat him here?” Kili asked weakly, kneeling down beside her.
“In the dirt, with that brackish water to wash the wound? Even the strongest dwarf constitution will risk blood poisoning.”
Kili looked at his brother. Fili nodded at him. Fainthel called over the rest of the young Guard and they started talking about the best way to move Fili without causing him too much distress. Kili stepped back, feeling bitter and furious with himself for not holding his ground. He was losing control of the situation, and it was going to end with them being taken back to the City. And he had a very, very bad feeling about that.
—
Legolas left the palace with Dis. She said ‘thank you’ as he ushered her through the main gates and ‘really, I should be getting back to my house anyway,’ when he asked if he’d like her to fetch someone to be with her. Her voice sounded polite and distant, as if she was reading from a script without knowing the rest of the play. As they passed the fountain just beyond the palace bridge, she sat down on the edge of the stone balustrade and looked down the quiet street. It was past midnight and the paved path was empty and dark except where the intermittent lamps hung from the branches above. A small animal, a cat or a fox, darted out of the shadows and sauntered away from them.
“I’ll just sit here a moment,” she said softly. “Thank you, Legolas, but there’s nothing more for us to do. And I want you to know that I don’t blame you. This began long before Tauriel died. It is not your doing that led us here.”
There was a pair of guards approaching, eyes on their commander. Legolas wanted to delay whatever new crisis they had for him. He could not stop the thoughts darting in a circle like dancers around the solstice fire: he had loved Tauriel, and Tauriel had fallen in love, but not with him, and his rage against her death may have led to the death of the dwarf she loved, and now wherever she was Tauriel must despise him, and he still loved her, and round and round it went. He had to do something to make this right, even in the smallest way.
“Princess Dis, my father is not himself. Some strange mood has possessed him. I will keep searching for your sons, you have my word.”
“There will be nothing to find,” she answered, still gazing at the long, deep shadows of the street. Her voice finally became more like her usual imperious tone. “Leave me, please.”
The guards reached his side and bowed. “Commander, there are reports that a dragon has been heard north of the City. The praetorians have been waylaid by a mob of dwarves and cannot attend. And one of the forest patrols is overdue, one of the patrols on the north circuit near where the roars were heard. We need you.”
Legolas nodded. “Very well, we’ll go searching for the missing patrol at once and let us only hope we do not meet anything else along the route.”
He took a dozen guards into the forest, two lieutenants with their most senior recruits. He hoped against hope that the patrol was delayed by a twisted ankle or sidetracked by an investigation of new spiderwebs, but they could take no chances. With the unrest in the streets and now the roar of a dragon in the sky, he did not want to be surprised by some new disaster.
“We’ll start by searching the northern circuit from both ends,” he said as they marched away from the lights of the City and the shadows of the tree closed over them. Legolas indicated a path that would have been nearly impossible to see even by daylight and sent one of his lieutenants in that direction. “You lot, go that way round the loop. The rest of you, we’ll go the other way and meet them on the route.”
The seven of them moved on swift feet in a single line. By caution of the unlit forest at night, they said nothing and kept their ears always alert. Less than an hour later, they did not need to be listening too hard when they heard the scream. Legolas raised his hand. After a pause he gave a sign for weapons to be at the ready but not yet drawn and they should follow him at speed.
He was sure of the direction. There was a small outpost nearby, built to hold supplies and provide a little shelter and rest on long nights on duty. In a few minutes Legolas and his guards were at the foot of the small, stone outcrop that supported the outpost, built just high enough that in daylight it stood above a thinner patch of trees and could see at least a short distance into the forest. The windows were lit up with more lamps than were usually allowed in the forest at this time of night; light could draw spiders or fouler things. As they arrayed themselves, there came another, shorter wail from inside. Legolas motioned the guards to draw their weapons now, and then ran silently up the stone steps to the door. With his elves in perfect step behind him, he drew one sword, seized the doorhandle and burst into the room.
He had to keep moving to let the rest of the guards follow, but he took in the scene as he did so and felt himself draw back in surprise. The main room of the outpost was barely big enough to hold the people already in it, let alone seven more elves with bows and shortswords in their hands. Legolas made eye contact with Fainthel, who stood over the dining table that had been dragged into the centre of the small room. Her arms were bloody to the wrists and she was pressing down with two hands and wads of fresh bandages on either side of the shoulder of a dwarf. Three of her unit were in various states of assistance, one holding the dwarf in place, one dipping a pair of pliers into a bowling pot on the stove, and the other handing Fainthel a bowl with some crushed, fresh herb. The dwarf’s face was a bloodless, disheveled mess, but Legolas recognised him from the trial. Even if he hadn’t, he had enough of a clue who he was from Kili standing by his head, clutching his brother’s good arm.
Fainthel stared at Legolas and her eyes flickered across the entire troop that had just burst into her surgeon’s chamber. “Commander!” she cried, “Can you get out, please? I need to focus!”
Legolas opened his mouth and then, turning to the armed guards behind him, said “Outside, make a perimeter, no one enters or leaves here until I say.”
As they did as he ordered, he turned back in time to see Fainthel’s hand withdraw something through the front of Fili’s shoulder with a precise, swift tug. An arrow shaft, Legolas saw at once, coated in blood but still recognisably a City-made arrowhead from the Guard’s armory. Fainthel dropped it onto the table nearby, quickly returning to press the cloth to the entrance and exit wounds. Fili did not make a sound this time, his eyes tightly closed and his breathing growing fainter.
“It’s out, it’s done,” Kili pressed his face to his brother’s hair. “Hold on a bit longer.”
“Haedred, does his shirt look intact?” Fainthel barked. “Could there be any cloth inside the wound?”
The elf who had been leaning on Fili’s chest to hold him down replied, “It looks like it’s all here, Sir.”
“Good. Thread and suture needle,” she ordered. The recruit by the stove handed them over, still steaming from the boiling water, and Fainthel began stitching the entrance wound one-handed.
“Let me help,” Legolas walked towards a bowl of clean water that smelled of lime-powder and began to wash his hands thoroughly. “He’s lost enough blood, we need to move fast.”
Fainthel glanced at him and nodded. In a few minutes, they had finished their work. Fainthel bandaged their patient and let him finally lie on his back, slightly propped to avoid pressure on the entrance wound. Kili was inches away the entire time, holding his brother's head and staring at Legolas with an ugly expression.
At last, Fainthel and Legolas washed the blood off their hands and took a step away to speak to each other, though there was nowhere private in this small, cosy outpost. Legolas said darkly, “I hope you have an explanation for this, Lieutenant.”
Fainthel reached back and picked up the arrowhead, using a spare cloth so she didn’t dirty her newly-cleaned hands. “The Dwarves were hiding in the tractless forest, with this in Fili’s back. They say the praetorians took them away from the City and shot them when they tried to leave. Do you have an explanation for that, sir?” she put the arrow back down swiftly but carefully, as if it burned.
Legolas said after a moment. “Perhaps exile was not enough to hide the truth. There are only three people who we can be sure know whether Kili is a murderer, and one of them is already dead. Perhaps somebody wanted to silence the second.”
He glanced at Kili and twitched his head towards the only other door in the outpost, which led to a small bunkroom. “Come with me.”
“I don’t take your orders,” Kili spat. “You’re not my commander anymore.”
Legolas let out a slow breath. “Come with me, please.”
Kili patted his brother's good shoulder. “You alright?”
“Terrible,” Fili croaked. “But I’m not sure what more you can do about that.”
Kili left him and followed Legolas into the bunk room. Legolas took one of the lamps from the main room and hung it above the small window. There was only a narrow aisle between two rows of bunks of bare wood. The thin, rag-stuffed mattresses were rolled and stowed under oilcloth, each bed a double wide so that up to eight elves could sleep in this tiny room. This was far from the luxuries of the City. They were outside its protection and its overbearing eye. Legolas felt uncomfortable looming over Kili with the lamp behind him, so after a moment he sat on the edge of one of the bunks.
“I need to apologise to you,” he said, folding his arms over his knees. “I know you didn’t kill her.”
Kili leaned back against the post of the bunk but didn’t sit. “How long have you known?”
“Only a couple of hours. I thought I was seeking justice when I spoke against you at the trial,” Legolas said. “But I should have seen it sooner. Fainthel tried to tell me you had an alibi, and I didn’t listen,” he closed his eyes, not sure if he was speaking out of contrition or trying to make excuses for himself. “You were such an easy target for my grief.”
“What changed tonight?”
Legolas wasn’t sure he should speak more, but how could he keep quiet with the truth when he’d been so effusive in spreading the lie? He reached into the bag slung over his back and took out the sword, opening the silk cloth he’d wrapped it in. “I found this, with your mother’s help.”
Kili’s eyes widened and he took half a step forward. “Tauriel’s missing sword.” He looked at Legolas. “Where was it?”
“In my father’s rooms,” Legolas said numbly.
The silence that felt between them was as loud as a rolling drumbeat. Kili’s brow tightened, his mouth opened a little. Anger began to grow on his face. “So either he ordered it, or he did it himself.”
“I don’t know,” Legolas wrapped the sword up again but held it resting on his palms, like the stem of a flower. “But I know you couldn’t have put it there. Here, take it. She’d want you to have it.”
“I’m not sodding touching it,” Kili backed up so fast he bumped into the bunk behind him. “Is that your plan to protect the king? If I’m seen with it, I’ll never clear my name.”
“It’s not a trick. You need something to protect yourself,” Legolas held the sword out further. “It’s clearly not safe for you to return to the City. As soon as your brother is able to walk, I’ll have Fainthel and a unit of guards escort you both to Laketown. I will tell your mother you are alive but no one else - at least until I can figure out what happened and what to do about my father. He is not fit to be king. Tauriel was like a daughter to him. He must be mad. He couldn’t have done this from a place of right thinking.”
“He’s perfectly clear headed. He’s covering up something worse,” Kili shook his head. “You don’t know, do you?”
Legolas frowned. “Know what?”
“Fili and I saw the dragon tonight. Here, in the Woodland. The praetorians summoned him, like he was their trained bear. Your father has some kind of bargain with Smaug. He feeds dwarves to him. He would have taken us too, but my uncle saved us, gave his life for us. Tauriel died because she learned about it all. I’m sure of it.”
Legolas took a moment to process this. Then he thrust the sword at Kili. “Take it. Protect yourself. Tauriel would never forgive me if I let you come to further harm.”
—
Thranduil stood on the balcony looking over his City. From here, he could see it laid out beneath him like a quilt. From a distance, especially at night, one would never believe it was infested with dissidents and ungrateful rabble-rousers. He watched the tiny figures of his son and the dwarven princess leave the palace by the main bridge and walk across the square beyond, pausing to speak at the fountain.
He had been foolish to take such a bold move against the children and grandchildren of Thrain, so openly scapegoating them. If he’d been patient, they would surely have diminished into irrelevance in a few years. Any memory of royalty would soon be no more than an old scrap of family lore. No matter what mortal kings and queens would like their subjects to believe, thrones and crowns were not carried in the blood, the gods did not distill any divine essence into a pedigree. There were hundreds of dwarves in this city alone who could abstractly or sometimes even directly trace at least one ancestor to Durin the Deathless; were they all special, did all deserve the title of prince or princess? Of course not. The only ones who got those titles were the ones who claimed it, by right of power, by killing their rivals or slaying dragons and stealing land, and who kept it by the brutal and constant battle of ruling. Thrain’s family had failed to hold their claim to kingship and so would have disappeared into the mists of history within the span it took an oak sapling to become a spreading tree. Especially if Thranduil had continued to force them subtly into obscurity.
It wasn’t rivalry for the kingship that had spurred him to frame the boy for Tauriel’s death. It wasn’t personal. It was simply that Thranduil had hated to think of Tauriel’s spirit alone, in those unreachable lands beyond the veil of this earth. The dwarf’s life meant nothing. He would have died anyway, sooner or later. Kili’s spirit might as well reunite with Tauriel while he still looked handsome. Thranduil did not pray, as he did not expect the gods to be listening, but he certainly hoped in his secret thoughts that the gods would allow her to receive this one offering of a companion, a gift from her king, a comfort to her as she waited in the halls of the dead. One last kindness he could do for his foster daughter. With luck, the exchange had gone as expected and the dragon was sated with fresh meat, the City resupplied with Mithril, and soon Tauriel would not be alone. He could only hope.
From the balcony he could see bands of the starry sky between the thin, high branches at the tops of the trees. And what he glimpsed up there made him uneasy. He was sure he had seen a shadow up there, between the shifting clouds.
He was beginning to suspect that something had gone wrong at the top of the hill.
He left his watch point and summoned a retainer to follow him into a windowless room deeper in his apartment. Here, the lamps were dimmed above shelves of bottles, folded twists of paper and jars of dried herbs and powders. He found a locked cage at the back of the tallest shelf, filled with thin, narrow bottles sealed with glass stoppers and black wax. The servant held open a crate packed with dried grass and Thranduil carefully placed a dozen bottles inside, arranged them to his satisfaction, and closed the lid.
“Not wine, I suppose, sire?” The retainer asked with a wry smile.
Thranduil chuckled. “No. A tonic for an uninvited guest. I have expected a visit from him for many years and prepared accordingly.”
He hurried down towards the praetorian’s quarters in the lower levels of the palace with the retainer behind him, carrying the box. Only half his elite elven guard were there, the rest having not yet returned from the hill. Many of them had been roused from sleep when the roars of the dragon woke their watchmen, and were still in the process of dressing and eating a little food.
“What do we do, sire?” Their captain asked. “The dragon’s never made his presence known, before. He’s always been quiet as an owl.”
“Arm yourselves. Longspears and good, heavy armour, though you must still be able to climb in it,” Thranduil told them, and opened the crate with the bottles sealed with black wax. “Take one of these each, but be careful not to spill a drop. When he is close, break the seal and coat the blades of your weapons in it. And carry as much of that strong, spider-silk rope as you have in your stores. We will be setting an ambush. Go and tell the stables to prepare a horse as well. Just the one.”
The captain glanced at the elf next to him and then back to the king. “For yourself, my lord?”
“Of course,” said Thranduil. “As the bait.”
Chapter 13: The Broken Bargain
Chapter Text
Dis was not alone for long. She became aware, without noticing him arrive, that Bilbo was sitting next to her on the fountain balustrade. She glanced at him.
“You were too late,” she said bitterly.
“Yes,” Bilbo replied, his arms loosely folded across his lap. “It seems I was.”
There was none of his feigned nerves or sharp tongue from their last few conversations. Bilbo looked as if he’d just survived a shipwreck. His shoulders were slumped low and his eyes were hollow in their sockets.
“You look hungry,” Dis said. “We should go home to get some rest. Perhaps we’ll know more by the morning.”
“Thank you, that’s very kind,” Bilbo gave her a weak smile.
They did not speak further as they walked back to the house. Despite the late hour they found there was a crowd around the door, as there had been earlier, but the mood was measurably different. The dwarves and elves closest to the house, mostly friends or neighbours she knew by name, were silent or speaking in whispers. Many were in their dressing gowns or night clothes as if they’d been just woken up. The rest of the crowd was a clustered group of at least a hundred young dwarves, almost all dwarrows but a few dams in trousers, all dressed for ease of movement as if they’d been awake and waiting for orders for some time. Many were carrying what were clearly improvised weapons; clubs, kitchen cleavers, axes for firewood. As they took notice of Dis, they parted for her like the crowd parting for a condemned woman walking to her hanging.
“What’s happened? Did they bring them back?” Dis grabbed the first dwarf she trusted close to the door, which was Balin. “Is it my boys?”
Balin shook his head, and she saw tears in his eyes. “No. You should go in.”
Dis picked up her skirts and strode to the open door. Somebody must have called in to Dwalin, because he met her in the front hall with arms wide to catch her before she could go farther. “Dis, give me a moment to prepare you before you see him.”
“Which one? Which one?” Dis begged. “Tell me, Dwalin!”
“It’s not one of the lads,” Dwalin said quietly. “It’s Thorin.”
Dis stared at him. Bilbo had come at a jog to join her, and she felt him tense beside her at the sound of Thorin’s name. Dwalin frowned at Bilbo. “This little creature’s been chasing around the city looking for you. Who is he?”
“A friend. He can know anything I need to know,” Dis said. “Is Thorin dead?”
Dwalin swallowed. “Not yet. One of our young dwarves saw the praetorians coming in the north gate carrying a dwarf’s body on a stretcher. Like pallbearers. It was Thorin. The boy raised the alarm, and along came that pack of angry young hotheads out there - they’re Fili’s friends from his combat school.”
“His what?” Dis frowned.
“We’ve been training them, Fili and I, since Thorin left. We should have told you before now. You still have an army loyal to you, Dis, ready to call you queen if you want - a small army, but they’re fit and keen. They’ve been champing at the bit for something to do since the trial this morning, so we rallied them to block the praetorian’s way as they tried to take Thorin’s body to the palace. There was a standoff but no blood. The praetorians gave us the body rather than risk a riot.”
“Body,” Dis echoed. “Why do you keep saying ‘body’? You said he wasn’t dead.”
“He’s alive, but he won’t be for long. You must come and say goodbye.”
“What did they do to him?” Dis snarled, tearing herself out of Dwalin’s arms and finally striding into the house.
She and Bilbo entered the parlour. The furniture had been pushed to the sides and rearranged, with two low tables shoved together to make a knee-high sickbed. It looked like the bier where the coffin would lie at a wake. Thorin had been laid out with his arms by his side, a blanket pulled up to his chest. Apart from the pallour of his skin, some faint, dispersed bruises and an unevenness to his breathing, he did not look badly injured. For a moment Dis could not even see any blood, but then Oin, who was kneeling by his side, gently wiped a trail from his nostril.
Oin looked up as she approached. “Cousin,” he said gravely. “I’m so sorry.”
“What happened to him?” Dis whispered, kneeling on the far side of Thorin’s body.
“I was told he fell from some height. That’s what the praetorians said,” Oin explained. “That would explain his injuries.”
“He’s strong,” Dis said firmly, laying one hand lightly on Thorin’s chest. He gave no response. “He’s alive. He’ll pull through.”
Oin reached across to put his hand over hers. “You need to be ready for the worst.”
“Then we must take him to the healer’s hall. If they arrest him afterwards, so be it, as long as they wait until he’s recovered.”
“He’s not going to recover, Dis,” Oin didn’t move his hand. “And I don’t think we should move him any further. He hasn’t woken, but if any part of his mind is still in there, it’ll cause him more pain for nothing.”
“So we bring the healers here!”
Behind her, she could hear Dwalin’s bootsteps at the threshold of the room. “This is the elven king’s doing. Every blow against your family is an act of subjection against the dwarves of this City. We’re ready, Dis. If you want your revenge, we are ready to follow you.”
Dis thought of the elven prince, who had come to her in desperate hope that she could help him keep the peace, trying to bridge the growing chasm between them. It would be so easy to start tearing their own home to shreds just to make the elves suffer as she was suffering. She yearned for it. But it wouldn’t bring any of them back. It would just end with more dams, like her, weeping over the bodies of their sons and brothers.
“Make those children outside go away, Dwalin,” she said quietly. “Make them put down their toy weapons and go home to their mothers.”
“I don’t know if they will,” Dwalin admitted. When she didn’t reply, he backed out of the room.
Oin squeezed her hand and let it go. “I’ll give you some time alone with him. I think it will be hours, at most, before he passes to the halls of his fathers.”
He got up and started to leave, gesturing to Bilbo with a squint of confusion. “Come along, lad. Leave the princess.”
“Can… can I have just a moment?” Bilbo asked.
“She doesn’t have time for your questions right now.”
“I mean with Thorin,” Bilbo said sharply.
Dis looked over at them, anger flashing at their presence and then subsiding. She twitched a finger at Bilbo. “Come here, Bilbo. Let him stay, Oin, I’m in his debt. And he’s a friend of Thorin’s.”
Oin raised an eyebrow but left, shutting the door quietly behind him. Bilbo didn’t intrude on her closeness, but sat in the big armchair that had been shoved to one side to make room for the makeshift sickbed. It had been Thorin’s favourite chair, and then Fili’s, though Kili would always try and get to it before him in the rare evenings when they were both home at the same time. She would never see them play-fighting over that chair again. Bilbo sat perched on the edge of the seat, his hands on his knees, his face like a death-mask himself. Dis turned back to her brother, smoothing down Thorin’s tangled hair with her hand.
“You’re the only one here who’s known Thorin since he left the City,” Dis said quietly. “What was his life like?”
“I only knew him the past couple of months,” Bilbo said after a moment. “We travelled together from Bree.”
“Just the two of you?”
“For some of the journey.”
“It’s a long journey. You must have talked about something.”
Bilbo didn’t answer for a moment, and then he said, “I’m not sure what you want me to say. He wasn’t unhappy in exile, but only because he was driven, always moving with a purpose. He wanted to get back here, to fix what he believed was broken in this City. I know he missed you all very much. You could hear it in the slightest word he said about you.”
“Do you know how the praetorians caught him?”
“He was going to find your boys,” Bilbo said softly. “He was going to try and save them.”
Dis nodded without looking away from Thorin’s face. She’d guessed, somehow, when he hadn’t appeared with Bilbo. “Thorin went to save them, and was nearly killed. The praetorians brought him back, but not my sons. So Thranduil was right: it was too late, and the dragon has taken them. Thorin was too late. I was too late. They’re gone.”
“They might have–”
“Please, don’t feed me hope,” Dis whispered, folding her arm beside Thorin’s head and laying her cheek down on it, so that she could look at his sharp, pointed profile in the light of the hearth. She thought of another dwarf who had worn that same nose, the same brow, but without the lines and cracks carved by a long life. She hoped Frerin was in those far halls too, waiting at the door to welcome Thorin when he arrived.
She could not imagine her boys in the halls of their ancestors, not out of hope, but out of the dreadful fear that the dragon now had them in its keeping, the fear that it may not have killed them yet but soon would in ways too terrible to imagine. Either way, they were far beyond her reach. In the old stories, the ones about heroes, the mighty princess would have taken up arms and gone to the mountain herself, opened the secret door with her father’s key, killed the dragon and rescued her sons in a blaze of glory. But she was a diminished princess of a captured people, and she had no way to get to Erebor. No dwarf had left that mountain once the dragon had passed the front hall; there was no chance she could save them.
Bilbo twitched. He shook his head. “I’m going to do something,” he stood up, straightening the lapels of his coat. “I don’t know what, but I can’t just sit here. I’m going, and I’ll figure something out and come back.”
Dis did not answer or look at him as the door quietly shut behind him.
—
When he went back into the main room of the outpost, Kili found his brother sitting up and starting to recover some of his colour. Legolas gave Fainthel about half an hour to get him ready to travel, and Kili helped him find a fresh shirt from the supply boxes tucked under the benches, which fit alright across the chest once they’d cut the ends of the sleeves off. Fainthel set Fili’s right arm in a tight sling to stop him pulling his stitches with any sudden movements.
While Haered boiled a little soup for them all, Kili cracked open the door to listen to Commander Legolas. He had gone outside to speak to the half-dozen Guards he had brought with him. Kili could see the distrust in their eyes even in the dim light from the windows of the outpost. All of them were breaking the law by helping an exiled murderer, convicted by the high powers of their City. But Legolas explained nothing other than his commands. Kili heard him recite a simple story; the praetorians had not released the exiles as expected and in the confusion, an unarmed prisoner had been shot; since the praetorians could not be trusted with the job, the forest Guards would carry out the sentence for them and send them on their way to Esgaroth. The route would take them back past the city, along the north side of the wall until they reached the east-west road that ran through the centre of the Woodland realm.
They made their way back along the path without a lamp, as it would have ruined the night vision of most of the party and run the risk of attracting the more dangerous inhabitants of the forest. The elves could see well enough to navigate with only the faintest trace of starlight, and Kili had his own ways of travelling in the darkness of the forest, by a mix of memory and his other senses. One of his first memories of meeting Tauriel had been a few months into the new recruits’ training, after their first solo patrols; Captain Tauriel had asked Fainthel afterwards, “And how does the dwarf manage in the dark?” and Fainthel had said, with obvious pride, “He keeps up. It’s even darker in the deep places underground, Captain, so I suppose it’s in their blood.” Kili had taken it as praise and had grinned so much Haered had kicked him in the ankle because he wasn’t standing to attention properly. Still, they could not travel with the haste that the elves were used to, because Fili had to walk at practically a snail’s pace, his good hand always on his brother’s shoulder.
The wall was in sight and the path took them along a slightly raised, natural dyke crumbling towards a deep ditch, so that between the trees they could sometimes see right over the top of the parapets. They were just about to turn east when the few night-birds calling to each other went suddenly and utterly silent. Kili saw Fainthel, who was in the lead, stiffen and glance upwards. Then the gale of the dragon’s wings hit them all like a wall. Fallen leaves caught in the onslaught stung their faces and forced them to brace wherever they stood. In a moment it had passed over them, and the great, heavy shadow of the dragon with it.
For a moment there was only the silence again.
Then came the roar and a sound like billowing sails as fire poured out of the night and over the north-west corner of the City, slicing it off from the rest like a red-hot blade through wax. The glow of it lit up the world like a fragment of the sun had fallen on the town, every twig, every detail of their faces. Instantly, the inferno roared up the wooden houses and the trees that lined the curling avenues.
“No!” Fili was the only one to react out loud, and without hesitation he broke away from the group and began to run towards the nearest gate.
The rest of them stayed silent, as if this was just a cluster of spiders coming at them through the night and their voices would attract attention. Some of the Guards glanced at Legolas. Kili realised he, too, was instinctively waiting for orders that he didn’t need to obey and decided he was done with doing what they told him. He sprinted after his brother. Behind him, he heard Fainthel follow swiftly, crying to Haered and the other young recruits, “Hurry - the city Guard will need every pair of hands.”
The gate led through to an ordinary street. A few faces were appearing at windows or in open doorways, faintly lit up by the glow of the fire reflecting off the underside of the leaves above them. From down here, surrounded by houses, no one could see the danger, but the stink of smoke and dragon-vapours was spreading through the air. Anyone who had lived to escape the burning of Erebor knew what that smell meant. And the distraction meant nobody was looking at Kili, which was a relief after several days of being constantly scrutinised.
In the distance at the end of the street, two young dwarves had encountered Fili and were half throwing themselves on him as Kili reached them, one of them asked, “What do you mean, the dragon?”
“Who else is awake?” Fili said. “From the underground school, I mean.”
“Everyone! We’ve been roughing up the praetorians!” the dwarf said cheerfully. “We were going to come looking for you and Kili next, but Dwalin said no, we had to wait for morning at least.”
“Get them all out here, get them to the square in front of the palace. And tell them to bring heavy tools and ropes. If we start pulling down the shops along Vine Street as a firebreak, we may keep the blaze contained to the north markets,” Fili pointed with his good hand. As the two of them shot off with all the thrill of a quest, Legolas arrived beside Kili.
“We can help. What do we do?” Fili looked up at Legolas, sounding much less optimistic than the two youngsters. “We can fight the fire but it doesn’t matter. Smaug is going to kill everyone within the walls.”
“We have to find my father,” Legolas said grimly. “He’s probably the only one who could have seen this coming.”
“Alright. I’ll rally every dwarf I can to join you,” Fili said, his face pale even in the red light, and sweat beginning to bead on his forehead. They could feel the heat rising in the air. “Kili, come on.”
Kili looked between them. Fili reached for his hand, tangling their fingers together. “Come on, Kili!”
“I should stay with the Guard,” Kili said numbly. He had tucked Tauriel’s shortsword into his belt, still wrapped in the silk cloth, but now he pulled it free and let the cloth fall away. “I don’t know how to fight like a dwarf. I only know how to fight like a Woodland Guard. I’ll be more help to them.”
He could see the flash of pain and fear across Fili’s face. His older brother had always encouraged him to go his own way, had always defended any old and crotchety dwarf who said that prancing around the forest wasn’t natural, any jealous young bully who said Kili looked more like an elf these days than a dwarf. It had been Fili’s idea in the first place, it was Fili who had made them all believe that the only way for both peoples to survive was to break down the walls that remained between them, the unseen and unspoken boundaries they walked inside their minds. Fili was following Thorin’s example, but he had pushed Kili even further into that no-man’s-land. It seemed he had not envisioned that despite all their efforts, those gaps would continue to widen, and instead of bringing them together Kili had ended up further and further away.
Fili nodded and dropped his hand. “Alright,” he said. “We’ll see you soon.”
–-
Dis could smell smoke. It was as faint and distant as the horns blowing far away across the city, horns that usually only signified an enemy had been sighted and the City was under attack. The smell of smoke was somewhat foreign in this place built of wood and lit by lamps as clever as magic. At first she wondered if it was in her imagination, if her mind had become so lost that it was slipping back to that childhood day, an age ago, when the mountain had burned around her. She didn’t know how long it had been since Bilbo left. But then Balin, Dwalin and Oin burst in and told her the smoke was no memory; the dragon had been seen and glimpsed through the trees above the City, and the market district in the north was burning.
“We’re waking everyone up and clearing the streets, sending everyone to shelter,” Balin said. “The dragon could return at any moment.”
“Shelter?” Dis raised her head. She stood up slowly, thinking of the families who had tried to shelter in hidden holes in the mountain. None of them had ever come out again. “No, there is no shelter if Smaug has come for us. We need to evacuate.”
“What, the entire city?” Dwalin growled. “It’s impossible, Dis. The roads will be choked before a tenth of our folk have escaped.”
Dis tried to think through what felt like drowning mud. “Take them out the east gates, towards the river. There’s docks and clearings there, even some shelters that the shipyards use for their goods. Those that can walk or ride in the dark keep going, head for the lake. For the rest, we’ll launch every barge in the City’s port, and send fast messengers to Laketown. Get them to send every boat they have up the river to the old barrel-sorting wharf. That’s our only route out.”
Balin and Dwalin looked at each other. Balin said. “Very well. I’ll go out now, pack a bag and you and Dwalin follow when you can.”
“There’s no need,” Dis tried to give him a reassuring smile. “I’ll stay here.”
Dwalin stepped forward. “You will not.”
“I need to stay with Thorin, and if we move him, he’ll die for sure.”
“Dis, we need you too. Thorin is gone. You are the closest thing we have to a queen, now.”
Dis could not stop a brittle laugh. “Queen of what?” she turned and knelt down again. “Give him a chance. I’ll look after him until he wakes, and then we’ll join you.”
“No!” Dwalin bellowed, and seized her around the arms, trying to drag her away from the sickbed. “You mad dwarrowdam, I’ll carry you in fetters if I have to!”
Dis writhed and slammed her elbow backwards into his gut. With a wheeze Dwalin released her and she backed away from him, raising her hand towards him and trying to tidy her hair with her other hand. “Don’t touch me. If I am your queen, then you will obey me. I order you to leave me.”
She could see tears in Dwalin’s eyes as he heaved for breath, winded by her blow. Balin was reaching to her as if in supplication. At last he nodded. “We’ll go, I promise,” Balin glanced at Thorin. “Please Dis, follow us once… once Thorin wakes up.”
She nodded. She waited until they were gone, and then she shut the door and slumped on the old rug by Thorin’s side. She laid her head on his shoulder, entwined her hand with his. She felt his fingers clench a little, his head shift a half-inch away from her. But she knew it was the meaningless twitch of a broken, dying body. She closed her eyes and listened to him breathing, shallow and pained.
“I’m here, brother,” she promised. “It’s alright. I’ll be with you all the way.”
She didn’t want to die. She was as afraid of the flame as any child of Erebor would be. She would have followed Balin and Dwalin if she could. But she couldn’t leave Thorin alone, she could not live knowing he had died alone, as their mother had died alone on some broken, rocky path outside the door of Erebor, in agony with her lungs full of smoke.
Dis would stay until the end, and if by that stage it was too late to run, so be it. She had lived a full life. She had loved a dwarf and been loved by him and taken him as a husband, both the first and the last dwarf that either of them ever shared a bed with. She had taken fine gems newly cut and held them to the light for the first time, seen occlusions and colours more ancient than the woodland, hidden since they were birthed into the rocks eons before any memory on the earth. She had walked the borders of the forest in seasons of golden summer and days of soft mists blanketing the meadows. She had borne children, she had lost her children, but in between she had done her best to guide them and love them. She had seen her people flourish and change to survive. They would go on without her, without her family’s dwindling and diminished dominion over the scattered Durin’s folk. No mortal could expect any more.
She let herself dwell in her memories, and waited for Thorin to go.
–-
As the dragon bore down on the heart of the city, Thranduil willed it to look at him. He stood in the centre of the great, wide street at the entrance to the City, the largest and straightest promenade, easily visible to a dragon’s eyes. He had brought a long banner with him, bronze and sky-blue, which was unfurled and trailing from the pike in his hand. The other held tight to the reins of his horse, a roan, old beast that was the most stalwart steed in his stables. Even she was beginning to toss her head and stamp at the smoke trailing through the air and the roar of the dragon.
He knew Smaug was up there, gliding above the trees, surveilling the growing chaos, perhaps still deciding whether he would prefer to raze the City to ashes immediately or take his time picking the inhabitants off over the course of the night. Smaug would surely have seen the king, in his broad, shining armour and white hair flying in the hot wind. The fire was pulling the air towards itself as it began to rage into an earth-bound storm. It was just a question of whether the dragon would come for him or whether he would dismiss Thranduil’s vain challenge.
“Come to me,” Thranduil whispered. “Come lay your wrath on me, you ugly blight of a monster, you mistake of a bygone age.”
There was the rolling thunder of the wings beating fast and Smaug broke through the trees, slamming down on the east end of the street, crushing houses and halls with his feet and tail. He lowered his head with a long hiss, so low it shivered through the ground. “A pleasure to see you again, little king of silver boughs. I see you have grown wealthy and pompous on the potency of my gifts. Is that why you broke off our arrangement? Your thriftiness will cost you dearly.”
Thranduil ripped the banner from his pike and let the wind carry it away so that it would not impede him when he had to flee. “I broke nothing, wyrm. I have been nothing but generous. You have grown so sluggish you could not even catch your quarry tonight, and now you come to me seeking to renegotiate terms? Well, come then, let us speak somewhere a little more private!”
He spurred the increasingly panicked horse and turned her, urging her to fly as fast as she could towards the great front gate, out of the City, and towards the forest beyond.
To his terror and relief, Smaug roared and sprang to follow him.
Chapter 14: After Ashes
Chapter Text
The dragon pursued Thranduil towards the gate, smashing through the elegant, stone archway that had welcomed travellers for over a century, flinging wide the wrought-iron gates of the Woodland City to crash apart on twisted, broken hinges. Thranduil’s horse made a valiant effort to escape, but even the legendary horses of ancient myth could never have outrun a fully grown dragon for long. Smaug gained four yards for every five that Thranduil fled. But that was enough. He only needed to draw the dragon just outside the City, to the great, open cathedral of trees and bare-packed earth that formed the road right in front of the main gate.
When he got to the end of the huge colonnade of trees, he leaped off the horse and let her gallop into the forest. He spun and snatched the long-necked bottle from his belt. Cracking off the top with the edge of his spear, he tipped the dark, viscous liquid along the length of the blade until it dripped like treacle and hissed upon the grass at his feet.
As Smaug tensed his neck to strike, a thin, silvery rope shot across his eyeline, carried by an arrow from high in one of the columnar trees, which buried itself in a trunk on the far side. Smaug’s keen sight spotted it and drew back a little, like a rambler encountering a single spiderweb across the path and recoiling from the discomfort. Then another rope flew from one side of the trees to the other, and then half a dozen, and then twenty, as the praetorians fired arrow after arrow of anchored cords. They made a net of threads above and below Smaug’s body. He writhed to shake them off, but despite their lightness they were stronger than steel cables, and all that broke was some of the arrows that anchored them into the far trees, the ropes tensing and then pinging through the air to whip or wrap themselves around his wings and tail.
“Pathetic little spiders! You cannot hope to trap me!” Smaug roared.
There was the bright, high peal of a horn and the gaps between the trees were full of the Forest Guard, a mass of grey-green moving in sync to harry the dragon from both sides with arrows and spears. A handful of the bravest and most swift-footed ran across and even between the dragon’s legs, spooling out more of the strong rope from one side of the trees to the other to entangle his ankles.
Smaug began to flail with more frenzy. He could not fully spread his wings between the columns of trees, though he slammed his shoulder from one side to the other, trying to topple them. But their roots went down as deep as their canopies, fifty or even seventy feet into the black, rich soil and stones of the woodland, and only one or two began to lean under the barrage of blows. Even if he had had room to spread his wings, it would have taken an enormous leap with every ounce of his strength to get upwards high enough to clear the top branches, and so get enough clear air beneath himself for a single downstroke, which was the bare minimum he would need to get airborne. Such a leap was not possible until he could get himself untangled from the cursed ropes. On their own they were thin enough to snap when he put his weight against him, or to cut with his teeth when he reached back to bite at them, but there were too many to break at once and he could not turn in the enclosed space to reach them all.
That was when the praetorians high in the branches leaped from their perches, their long spears dripping with black poison. They landed like cats on the dragon’s back, clutching for handholds on his shining scales. The tips of their spears dug in between the scales, stabbing for weak points or trying to lever them up to expose the wiry flesh beneath. But they could not pierce his armour.
Smaug roared, a wail of pure, vainglorious, almost offended rage. He turned, looking over his own shoulder. He opened his mouth and fire poured out, scalding his own back and tail but obliterating several of the filthy fleas that were trying to bite him. He swept the trail of fire around in a great arc, filling the forest on his right flank with fire until his head was facing the elf king again. He drew in a few long, outraged breaths as he stared at the tiny figure of Thranduil, who was brandishing a spear that was to Smaug no larger than a pencil.
“Some of your people I might have spared, as my chattel,” he hissed. “But now - none!”
The rumble of his voice did not seem to fade. It was replaced by the thudding of bootsteps, as a hundred, two hundred, three hundred dwarves poured out the broken gates and through the shattered holes in the walls. They were armed with hatchets, hooks, pick-axes, even large, hand-sized bolts or nails, and they broke over the dragon and began to climb him like termites swarming from a mound; they were young dwarves, born under the trees, and they could climb as well as elves. They went for the wings first, using their weight to pin the thin phalanges down and puncture the membranes between, then some reached his neck and like the praetorians they used the scales and ridges to clamber up. Smaug squirmed, trying to throw them off, but they were sure-footed and strong-gripped and not weighed down by armour, and even when he shook the damned things off some would fall and get up again, limping at worst, and claw their way up again. The sheer weight of dozens of them was enough that his neck bent lower and lower, closer to the ground, as if in supplication before Thranduil.
Smaug opened his mouth and the air rippled as his hot breath boiled in his stomach, but before he could exhale, Thranduil moved swift as a darting swallow and leaped up, into Smaug’s mouth, bracing his feet on the lower row of teeth and stabbing the poison-dripped spear up, into the dragon’s soft palate, deep into his head.
There was a rushing wave of fire and screaming that blew outwards in all directions. The dragon clamped his mouth shut, but Thranduil had propped the spear between his upper and lower jaws and his own strength drove the point further into the tender spaces encompassed by his skull. He flung himself back and forth between the cage of trees, crushing anyone who fell beneath his feet or body, and fire poured indiscriminately from his mouth, but the poison worked its way quickly through his blood to his brain and heart. His frantic writhing began to slow, his joints seemed to seize and then bend under his own weight, and in minutes he lay, claws twitching, eyes rolling, and then was still.
The beautiful columns of living trees were scarred and stripped of their bark, and some leaned outwards on the verge of falling. The fire was spreading in the dry autumn foliage. The air was filled with groans and cries of pain and calls for help. Anyone who could move got to their feet, and carried those who were still speaking or reaching for help. Others, unconscious or beyond survival, were left where they lay. There was no time to even count the dead, let alone retrieve their bodies.
Legolas found himself bruised but standing, calling for his Guards to run, run for the City where the stone wall might provide some shelter, however temporary. He moved as quickly as he could through the mess of torn earth, fallen branches and ruined bodies of elves and dwarves, finding clusters of dazed survivors picking each other up and trying to stem gushes of blood or splint broken limbs. He rallied them and directed them as best he could, trying to convince the most reluctant to leave off their search for their friends and brothers and to save themselves.
At last, afraid to be trapped by the growing fire, he followed them. Fili was at the gate, face streaked with ash, pointing the survivors onwards with his good arm; sending the wounded back towards the main square in front of the palace but keeping back those who looked well enough to walk. It was now the early hours of the morning, and beyond the glow of the street lamps they could see the first red light of dawn between the branches.
Legolas strode up to him, “Your dwarves need to get back on their feet if they can. I’m giving the order to evacuate the city. The fire is in the oldest trees outside the wall. There is no stopping it.”
“We can fight it,” Fili insisted. His voice was hoarse and he was swaying a little. “We contained the fire in the north market. We can slow the forest fire down when it reaches the walls, get trains of buckets from the Ruby Street canal, make another firebreak where New Town meets the palace - even if we save only half the city… even if it’s just to slow the fire…”
“The whole forest is burning.”
“We can’t just give up. This is our home. This is the only home most of us have ever known.”
“I’ve given my orders,” Legolas said firmly. “We’ll carry all the wounded we can and go street to street to get everyone out of their houses. If you can buy us time by slowing the spread of the flames, do as you will, but your dwarves have done more than their share already.”
He turned to begin sorting whoever was left into units as best he could, but Fili called, “Legolas, where’s my brother? Did you see him?” Legolas turned back to him. Fili shook his head. “Kili hasn’t come back through the gate.”
“I saw him charge the dragon with Fainthel when the horn blew, but I have not seen him since. I’m sorry,” Legolas replied, and headed back to his surviving troops.
—
Fire was dancing up the trunks of the huge, ancient trees that lined the great, wide road into the city, dripping upwards along the branches until a tongue or a spark could find purchase on the entwined leaves of the neighbouring trees and spread even further. It was closing into a ring on all sides around the dragon’s body. The rest of the survivors had run for the ruined gap where the main gate had stood, to make the most of the shelter behind the wall. But it wouldn’t be long before the fire leaped over the wall and began to seed itself on the west side of the City.
Kili had never quite lost consciousness, but at some point he must have come pretty close to being crushed, and he could not protect himself. There had been a moment when they had all charged out of the forest together, the young recruits and old veterans of the guard all shoulder to shoulder, and briefly it had seemed like they were a single unit that could not be severed from their comrades. But the chaos and the heat and blood hit them so thick and fast that Kili couldn’t quite remember how he’d ended up at the base of a half-uprooted tree, with his face in the dirt and his ribs aching. He remembered Fainthel sprinting to pull the ropes tight around Smaug’s back leg, and he remembered Haered shoving Kili down onto the ground as the spout of fire went right over their heads, but the heat had sent Haered falling with his hands on his face and Kili could not see either of them now. Now it was quieter, and one of the city constables who he didn’t recognise was shaking his shoulder, telling him to run or die. Kili raised his head and waved him off. “I’m alright. I think I can walk. Help someone else.”
By the time his vision stopped spinning and he managed to stand up, there was no one left but the bodies. Mostly dead, and a few so close to it that it would be a mercy when it came. Kili rubbed his stinging eyes. He was looking for someone in particular. He’d seen him, in that final moment, with his silver-black spear and his white hair flying behind him like a banner. Kili remembered watching him hit the ground as the dragon let out its last blast of fire, before the chaos of its death throes knocked Kili under the exposed roots of the tree. He got to his feet and began to search for Thranduil.
It did not take long before Kili spotted the elven king beside the dragon’s head. The elf king must have been so close to the dragon as he breathed his final burst of flame that he had been able to dive beneath it, into Smaug’s shadow. He had been caught by the teeth or claws at some point: his armour had buckled on the chest and back, but had held just enough that he was not suffocated inside. Kili watched Thranduil pull his ruined breastplate off with a clatter, to shed the weight of it as he sat up labouriously. The arm that had held the poisoned spear was bloodied and bruised, the sleeve hanging in shreds. He was gasping through the miasma that had fueled the dragon’s fire and now oozed from its dead lips. He was on one knee, pausing to gather his strength, when Kili reached him.
Kili came out of the smoke, to get the element of surprise, and got his foot behind Thranduil’s leg to unbalance him and one hand around his throat before Thranduil even knew he was there. With a sweep he shoved him onto his back, one knee on Thranduil’s ribs and the other foot still rooted to the leaf-strewn ground. Thranduil’s legs kicked as Kili’s grip under his chin tightened. Despite being slight for a dwarf, he was still heavy, heavy in his bones and his muscles, and most importantly he knew how to use that weight at the right angle and the right points. He had spent two years sparring with elves.
The tip of Tauriel’s shortsword pressed into Thranduil’s breast, above his heart. Thranduil froze, staring into his eyes. Kili looked for fear there, but he couldn’t see it. He wanted it more than he had wanted anything before this moment.
“Beg me not to kill you,” he hissed through his gritted teeth.
Thranduil heaved for breath through the narrowed passage of his throat. He smiled a little. “They all told me you were so tame,” he whispered. “That you could never be a murderer. Go on, then. What will they say now?”
“Your body will be ashes by morning. No one will know. But I’ll know,” Kili rasped, his eyes widening. “And I’ll live two hundred more years happy that I did one thing right. Can you say that? About anything you’ve ever done in your long life?”
“I don’t care a speck what you think of me, boy,” Thranduil said in a faint croak. “You’re green now, and gone like dry leaves tomorrow.”
Kili raised the sword, felt himself wavering as he reached the apex of his strike. He could tell Thranduil was trying to stand up, trying to roll him off, but the king’s strength was expended. The smoke had reddened his eyes and his breath was choked from the smoke. But his face was still placid. There was no regret there, no apology. The rage at that was unbearable, and Kili tensed to strike.
In the moment of indecision, a voice cried. “Stop, please! Don’t kill him!”
Kili’s eyes slid just a little away from Thranduil’s face. What appeared to be a short, curly-haired dwarf was standing beside them, as if out of nowhere, his cloak drawn across most of his face to try and screen the worst of the smoke. Kili didn’t recognise his eyes; he had never met Bilbo, or indeed any hobbit at all. And though he could not know it, Bilbo did not recognise Kili either - he had only glimpsed him once, from a distance, many days ago in his Guard’s uniform with his hair braided - and now Kili was unrecognisable with his hair coming loose in the wild, red light, in the midst of the growing inferno and the mess in which they found themselves. They were complete strangers facing each other over Thranduil’s fate.
Bilbo’s hand was raised as if wanting to grab Kili’s wrist but afraid he would just provoke him.
“You don’t know what he’s done,” Kili spat at him.
“I do. I do,” Bilbo assured him, his voice muffled through his makeshift mask against the thickly falling ash. “But I need him. He’s the best healer in the City, and someone I love is dying. Please, let him go.”
Kili turned his head at last to stare at the small part of Bilbo’s face he could see above the cloak. Then, slowly, he lowered the sword and took his hand off Thranduil’s throat. He drew in a shallow, shuddering breath. “Fine. If he’s worth something to you, have him.”
He stood up and backed away, and then turned and ran for the relative safety of the gate, hating himself for his own cowardice, and yet weak with relief that someone had stopped him killing the king. The horror came not from what he nearly did, but how easy it had nearly been.
He saw no one left alive as he reached the ruined gate. The fire was already crawling over the grass and bushes on the banks around the walls, turning the stones black in some places. The one blessing was that there was no wind tonight. The inferno was spreading slowly, inches by inches, sending birds and a few panicked squirrels and small deer crashing out of the leaves, some to be trapped against the wall and die butting against it in their confusion. Kili climbed over the fallen stones and into the City.
The familiar streets were turned to a nightmarish maze. Smaug had smashed or scarred many buildings as he’d charged along the street from the palace to the outer promenade. Kili knew he had to head east, away from the fire, but if he went in a straight line he’d end up with the great rocky hill of the palace between him and safety. He tried to choose a side street he thought he knew and followed it until he reached a canal. There was no destruction here, but still some eerie, frozen chaos. Doors hung open and belongings were scattered across the streets. The inhabitants of the houses had gotten outside and abandoned them when they saw the streams of fire or heard the battle against the dragon. A horse galloped past in terror, its bridles only half-buckled. All the shops were still shut tight for the night, so that familiar places looked like blank faces. Kili kept going as best he could, but then as all the Woodland streets did, the path under his feet curled inexorably around the trees and natural hillocks until Kili found he was facing the palace again instead of going around it. The smoke was getting thicker and he began to cough with every breath.
He tried to turn at the next intersection and soon found to his horror that the bridges of the next canal had all been broken to prevent the fire spreading over them. White, raw wood shone in sharp splinters. He followed the canal as far as he could until he found a stone bridge and was able to make his way across. Here, there were less signs of a panicked flight. The fire was further away and the inhabitants must have had more time to gather themselves, with doors shut up and the carts and animals all missing, a good sign that there had been time for an orderly evacuation. But this was an elvish district and Kili didn’t know the streets well. In the pre-dawn light with the smoke making a haze over the rooftops, he couldn’t even figure out which direction the palace was to get his bearings. He cursed. He could navigate a pitch-black forest while tracking a silent giant spider, but now he was lost in the city he’d lived in his entire life?
Somewhere, the fire either reached the central wires or the control building for the City’s Mithril lamps and all the street lights went out in a long tide of spreading darkness. Very distantly, Kili heard a few weak screams, so everything in the city must have gone out at once. At least he knew there were people over there. He tried to judge which direction the voices had come from and started running.
But, Durin’s beard he was back at the palace again. Somehow he’d gotten turned around and was still on its west flank, in the open courtyard out front. It loomed above him, a dark and bulbous shape with the dawn rising behind it. Kili was actually beginning to panic now. The smoke was so thick he could only see the palace and surrounding buildings in snatches. He felt dizzy, but when he tried to suck in a deep breath, it was foul and full of ash and he went into a fit of coughing so hard he ended up on his hands and knees. His eyes were streaming so much he couldn’t see clearly, and as he crawled he found himself putting his hand on another hand. He jerked his arm back. Through his stinging eyes he looked down at the cooling, unmoving body of Lieutenant Fainthel. He realised there were bodies scattered all around him in the courtyard, mainly dressed in the grey-green uniforms of the Guard but some young dwarves as well. They were laid out on blankets or cloaks or with bundled jackets as pillows under their heads. He had stumbled upon the triage area for those wounded by the dragon, and all that was left were the bodies of those who had been carried away from the front gate but had died within minutes. The corpses in this outdoor morgue had been left for the fire by the friends and comrades who had fled as the smoke grew too much to bear.
The air was a little clearer closer to the ground and he got his breath back enough to keep moving. He crawled towards the pale, circular shape of the public fountain in front of the palace, gripping the edge for support. He managed to lean over the rim and splashed some cold, clean water on his face to get the worst of the ash out of his eyes. He crumpled against the wall of the fountain, pulling for breath.
He didn’t know where to go. He couldn’t crawl the length of the city, or at least, not fast enough to outrun the fire. He hoped the smoke would put him to sleep before the flames got to him.
He thought of his mother. He hadn’t even had a chance to say goodbye at the trial. He just had to hope that Fili had made it to safety, or Ma would not be able to live with the grief, he was sure of it. And Thorin. Thorin had given his life to save them both. And Kili had thrown that gift away on a rash, callow chance at a revenge that he couldn’t even follow through with.
He wondered if Tauriel would be waiting for him on the far side of death. He wondered if she’d be as angry with him for dying stupidly as he was angry with himself. Probably she would. Well, if he did see her, at least they’d have the rest of forever to sort it out.
He closed his eyes against the smoke and when he opened them there was a figure, crouched low but moving at a jog towards him, wearing a cloth as a makeshift mask over his nose and mouth. The top half of his face was somewhat protected by a smithy’s eye-mask with polished quartz lenses, presumably pinched from one of the surrounding workshops. Even if Kili couldn’t see his face, he knew him by the familiar sling, now filthy with dust and ash, that Fainthel had made only a few hours earlier.
His brother had come for him.
Fili reached Kili and slapped a wet cloth over his mouth. Kili pressed it close with his own hands, trying to breathe through it. Fili grabbed his shoulder and got him up into a crouch, pulling him wordlessly across the paved courtyard, around the bodies and the broken wreck of a house where Smaug had perched. The pain in his eyes was so bad Kili had to keep them closed almost the entire time, but Fili kept his hand on his shoulder and guided him onwards in steady, staggering steps.
They seemed to be heading right for the palace, and Kili was sure that was a death trap. If they went upwards the smoke would just get thicker, and at ground level those caves were a warren that they’d never find their way out of. He was sure the palace was a dead end.
But Fili pulled him through the front doors, picking up a lantern by the entrance, and within a couple of turns they were heading down, into cool and unfamiliar tunnels where the air was clearer and they could both pull their damp masks down.
Kili was stumbling, finding it still hard to get enough air, half-blind, but Fili held his arm and led him on until they reached what looked like a huge wine cellar. There they reached a small cluster of elves and dwarves, all covered head to toe in ash, clambering down a rope ladder into a dark trap-door through which Kili could hear the sound of churning water.
Kili tried to wipe his eyes with the wet cloth Fili had put over his mouth. He knew the faces of the dwarves and recognized most of the elves. They were not from the Guard but from his own social circles, schoolmates, or various cousins or even just acquaintances from the pubs. Several of them were still in day-clothes and clad in matching blue for some reason. His friend Ori was there, and Berior from his archery lessons, both of them reaching for him and Fili, to guide them around the open mouth of the trap door.
“I can’t believe it!” Berior helped Fili clamber one-handed onto the first few rungs of the ladder. “You found him! We’d just decided to leave without you!”
“I told you we were too stubborn to die,” Fili said wearily.
The ladder led down to a long, bobbing boat, with a shallow draft barely deeper than a punt, loosely moored to an outcrop of rock. They all managed to squeeze into it, with two elves trying to steady it with long poles braced against the narrow stone walls of the tunnel through which the river ran.
Kili found an empty space on the damp floor of the boat and lay down, his head spinning. Fili sat beside him and Kili reached for his good hand. “Thank you,” Kili said. “Thank you.”
“I would never have left without you,” Fili squeezed his hand in return. “But I might stick a bit closer to you next time.”
—
Dis was torn from her memories by a frantic knocking. She raised her head. The lights had all flickered out some time earlier, as the Mithril wires of the City melted and the engineers’ workshops collapsed. The smell of smoke was very strong now, thick enough that Thorin coughed weakly beneath her hand. Dis struggled to her feet and fumbled for the little candle that, what seemed like years ago, she had put in the window to summon Bilbo. She lit it and the parlour appeared in the weak glow. She put it on the mantelpiece and turned towards the sound of knocking.
She wished she had locked the door; no doubt Balin had had a turn of regret and sent someone to drag her away to join the evacuation. Sure enough, she heard the door open as the person knocking finally tried the handle.
She turned to see the last person she could possibly imagine. King Thranduil crouched a little as he stepped through the parlour door. He was in armour and a great cloak as silver as beech-leaves, half-torn and hanging from one shoulder. There was blood on his face, on his armour, and blood soaked the sleeve that was half-covered by the torn cloak.
She stared at him, wondering if the smell of smoke had caused her to fall into some hallucinatory state.
“Princess Dis,” he nodded at her.
“Thranduil,” she acknowledged, but did not stand.
Bilbo squeezed around the elven king and ran to her side, leaning over to listen to Thorin’s breath. He stood up with a sigh. “Thank goodness, we’re not too late,” he bobbed at Thranduil. “I do apologise for dragging you here, I know you probably have a lot of other things to do today. But would you mind, just, perhaps, having a go…?”
The king looked at Dis. In shock, she nodded her permission and stepped away. There was not much space in the parlour by this stage.
Thranduil came in close to put his hand on Thorin’s chest, his ear to Thorin’s mouth. He was silent for a moment, and then he said, “His wounds are very dire. You should have let the praetorians bring him to me straight away.” He straightened up, business-like despite a note of pain in his voice. “But… I suppose the dragon would have distracted me before I could do much.” He looked at Dis. “I need clean cloth, boiled water if you have it.”
“There’ll be some in the kettle, a couple hours old,” Dis mumbled. “I’ll see if the pipes are still running and start boiling more.”
Bilbo helped her gather what they had. Through the window, Dis could see that the sky above was dark with smoke, but the air directly outside was still clear of haze. Without any high wind, the City would be burning slowly, house by house, spark by leaping spark. Somewhere nearby, she could imagine the wall of flame chewing through the beautiful arches of the taverns and markets, running along the carved rails of the bridges, flowing up the pillars of the halls. But it hadn’t reached them yet.
When she and Bilbo returned to the parlour, Thranduil had unbuttoned Thorin’s shirt and tugged it open until his chest and shoulders were exposed. By now, the blossoming, black bruises there were clear even in the dull light of the candle. Thranduil put his hand on Thorin’s belly, just below his ribs, and murmured something in an elvish tongue that Dis did not understand. She saw Thorin’s limbs twitch, and then his muscles clench. His throat made a low noise like someone rising from a fitful sleep.
Bilbo put the bowl of clean water down on the floor nearby. Dis piled the towels and clean linen beside them. She was not clear why they were even needed. She had the growing sense both that Thranduil had used them as an excuse to take command and get them out of the room, and also that she could not leave Thorin alone again. Not with this monstrous snake who had taken so much from their family.
“This will take time,” Thranduil said, “I suggest you both go and get ready to flee the fire.”
“No, I’ll stay,” Dis said.
“So be it,” Thranduil didn’t even look over at her.
She heard the kettle boiling on the fuel stove, one of the few things in the house that was still working. She went to take it off and refill it. When she returned, the first thing she noticed was Bilbo standing in the doorway, heedlessly blocking her way, covering his mouth. The hobbit gave a strange, half-wild little sob and looked at Dis.
Thorin’s eyes were open. His hand clutched Thranduil’s upper arm. His lips were parted and his eyes were wide. Thranduil was leaning over him, neck extended and face lowered almost like a dragon leaning over some prey, his face bare inches from Thorin’s.
Thorin rasped, groggy but alive, “What are you doing to me?”
“Saving your life,” Thranduil’s hand shifted to the centre of Thorin’s chest and he pushed. There was a series of sticky, muffled crunches and Thorin groaned, lifting his head, his brow pressing against Thranduil’s. Dis felt faint at the sound, and the horrific intimacy of it, and the shame that she couldn’t bring herself to interrupt in case she broke whatever ritual Thranduil was weaving. Thranduil’s hand slipped across Thorin’s skin and up his neck, over his face, fingers digging into his hair around his temple, and whispered something too low to hear. Thorin gave another cry of what sounded like pain and something like the relief of an animal being released from a cage. His eyes rolled back for a moment and then opened, blinking, staring at Thranduil, their faces pressed close together.
“What did you do?” He growled. His eyes were sharp and his voice more lucid.
Dis felt tears on her cheeks and didn’t have the strength to wipe them away. She leaned against the doorframe and found herself praying, not to any god but to Frerin, not yet, not yet, go back to your rest. He won’t join you yet.
“What I had to,” Thranduil drawled. His voice dropped to a whisper, but the room was small and they all heard it. “You’re the only other one who knows how it was all built, how it can be done again. I need you to live. I give them all to your charge, our people, our future.”
He helped Thorin lie back, and then stood swiftly. “I’ve done what I can with the time we have. You all need to leave this place.”
—
Thorin lay back and felt the rush of hot, bloody life pulsing through him and then breaking like a wave, fading into his fingertips and his prickling scalp. He stared up at Thranduil. The air smelled of smoke and the only light was a fat candle burning almost to nothing on the mantelpiece. He felt beyond confused. He remembered falling, but he couldn’t be dead, because he’d have to be cursed beyond measure to find Thranduil was the one welcoming him in the next life. He blinked and looked around as far as he could without moving his head too much; the slightest shift shot white-hot headaches behind his eyes.
He was in his own parlour; or, he supposed, it was Dis’ parlour since he had left. His sister stood half-collapsed in the doorway, beaming at him and weeping as he hadn’t seen her cry for decades. Tucked behind her, of all people, was Bilbo. How had he ended up here?
They were all moving with some unnamed urgency. That smell of smoke was stinging his nose. Dis brought over Thorin’s coat and boots, and she and Bilbo helped him swing his legs around and sit up. Every movement hurt, and he was weak as a newborn kitten. Dis heaved him to his feet and put his arm around her shoulders. He leaned heavily into her. Bilbo tucked himself under Thorin’s other arm, a simple comfort of closeness, although frankly he was not doing much work given his height and size.
With slow, careful steps they made their way outside into a muted, grey light. There was no one in sight and no sound but a faint, constant roar and the panicked wings of birds overhead. From the angle of the blotted sunlight, it was dawn, yet the sky was as dark as the heaviest storm. In the distance, Thorin could see the flicker of flames in the tree-tops. Tiny flakes of ash drifted around them. The city was burning.
Thorin knew at once what had happened. He had broken the dragon’s bargain.
Thranduil stood a little way away, facing towards the fire. He looked at them with a derisive glance. “I suggest you move faster.”
“Aren’t you coming, your majesty?” Bilbo asked.
Thranduil turned away. “I will search the City for any other survivors.”
Thorin stared at the back of his head. Thranduil was a ruin, his armour half-discarded, the blood a great stain down the side with the missing arm, trailing his torn cloak as if it was doing him any good beyond adding to his air of despoiled majesty. Yet somehow, he’d kept his hair perfect. Thranduil wanted this to be how he was remembered, he wanted them to take the story back to the survivors and say, oh, but didn’t the elf king die glorious and beautiful.
It had always been about the glamour for him. Beauty at any cost, more precious that gold, more than life itself. Thorin remembered a warm night under coloured lights, a smiling king offering a young dwarf a cup of wine, the whisper to come closer, into the mottled shadows beneath the trees. A temptation, a seduction that had unfolded so slowly over Thorin’s entire adult life. But who had been chasing whom? He had been young but he had never been naïve. He had known how to play coy, and tempting from a distance, and learned fast to use his novelty and exoticism to his advantage in this realm obsessed with beauty and eternal youth. He had been the invader of the elven king’s bountiful hospitality and he had gotten everything he wanted from Thranduil. In a single generation he had turned the Woodland into a place that was dwarven and industrious and fecund. He had made the wood elves love the dwarves, and need them and all their wonderful devices and philosophies. Try to undo it and you would ruin the elves, with their slow lives and reluctance to adapt, but the dwarves would survive and repopulate from any disaster, as they had from the loss of Erebor. It might look from the outside as if the creeping grape vine had encased the stone and smothered it, but rip them apart and see who stood upright, the vine or the stone.
In the process they had both been changed by each other, and of the two, Thorin had at least been the more honest about it. Thranduil had believed he was setting a trap to tame dwarves. If he had realised too late that he was being lured into Thorin’s artifices in turn, well, that had been the game from the beginning, from that first moment that he held out a cup of dark, red wine to a wide-eyed young prince and said, “Come, drink with me.” It was not Thorin’s fault that Thranduil hated losing.
“Thranduil,” Thorin bellowed. “Come with us, you fool. You have thousands of years to atone for what you’ve done, to make yourself anew. I won’t spend my few years left on this earth as your mouthpiece. I’m not going to tell it the way you want it told.”
Thranduil glanced back at them, but looked only at him. A small smile twitched the corner of his mouth. “Goodbye, Thorin, son of Thrain.”
“We have to go,” Dis said firmly. “I understand him; he can’t leave his City to die alone.”
The ash was falling thick enough now that they had to stop and pull up collars or tie handkerchiefs over their mouths and noses. After that they tried to run, Thorin stumbling between them as best he could. They reached a path down to the east gate, joining a few other stragglers hurrying onwards. No one looked twice at them, faces covered by cloth, except a couple of elven Guards directing the last of the evacuees who asked if they needed any help. Dis waved them away. She seemed to know where they were going.
The narrow forest paths grew crowded as they went onwards. They followed the stumbling mass of elves and dwarves. Once they passed the river gate and the rapids, the river was thick with boats carrying the elderly, the children and the infirm. Many were weeping, especially the very young, but most of the people they passed walked onwards in a state of numb determination. They reached the flat, cleared steps of rock where the new port had been built. All the covered docks were empty, every boat launched.
“I have to rest,” Thorin gasped. His muscles were trembling as if they’d been pushed past exhaustion into collapse. They sat him down at the edge of the clustered refugees.
“I’ll find Balin or Dwalin and they’ll get you on a boat,” Dis stood up, searching the crowd for a familiar face.
“No,” Thorin grasped her sleeve. “We must see that everyone else is safe before then. I’ll take the last boat.”
They couldn’t dissuade him, despite Bilbo’s muttering about it and frequent glances back towards the distant smoke. Bilbo was smeared with grey and beneath it, there were deep shadows under his eyes. Thorin remembered he had already looked tired when they had parted outside the walls of the City. Was that only yesterday, or had Thorin been unconscious even longer? How long since either Bilbo or Dis had slept? And where were the lads, had they escaped the dragon?
“And where is the dragon?” Thorin said, out loud but to himself.
“He’s dead,” Bilbo said at once, as if announcing that tea was ready. “I saw him lying dead. Else he’d have destroyed the whole city, I suppose.”
Dis found a train of dwarves bringing water up from the river and went to fetch some. Unable to keep his eyes open, Thorin put his head on Bilbo’s lap. Only a few minutes later, he was woken by Bilbo shaking his shoulder. Dis was leaning over him, holding out a cup of water, and some bread. Thorin tried to break off a piece and hand it to her, and then to Bilbo, but they both refused in turn.
“You eat it. You need it,” Bilbo insisted, which was so unlike him that Thorin could not think how to argue.
Dis held out her arm to help Thorin get to his feet again. “The Guards are saying anyone who can walk should get on the paths east and try to reach the beaches of the Long Lake. The fire is getting closer and they want the port cleared of anyone except the most in need.”
She was right. The smoke was visible in the air, trailing in ribbons above them and oozing from between the trunks of the trees. Thorin felt a little stronger after the food, and was able to walk without their aid, although he was not too proud to take Dis’ arm during a few hilly parts. They followed the trails of elves and dwarves through the trees, making slow progress on the many uneven paths. The mirk was well controlled on this side of the forest and the trees did not loom or crowd together as they did in the deep parts of the wood.
At last they came to the sparsely-forested shores and beaches along the western side of the Long Lake. The late morning sun was so obscured you could look directly at it without discomfort. The sky glowed a heavy orange from one end to the other.
Here, the crowds were even thicker, and the boats out on the water barely had room to maneuver. There were lines of activity up and down the shore: dwarves and elves felling trees as fast as they could, thick trunks as straight as they could find them, trimming them with small handaxes, or even knapped stones that a few old miners still remembered how to make. The youngest dwarves were in the marshy ends of the beach cutting flax and weaving ropes, and anyone who had two working hands was tethering the logs together into makeshift rafts with roughly carved oars. Each raft was pushed out by wading Guards and young dwarves until it could be shoved into deeper water and rowed away with much splashing and not a little arguing. Some were ferried out to larger boats from Laketown that could not approach the beaches but could evacuate many survivors, while many of the bolder rafts made their own way over the lake in long, bobbing lines, shrinking towards the far shore. Shocked, ash-smeared faces on each raft turned back, looking up at the forest burning above them. At a distance, crowded on the rafts, disheveled and wrapped in whatever robes and blankets they had brought as they were roused from sleep and fled their homes, it was hard to tell elf from dwarf among the faces.
You could not see the city from the lake, even from far off, but those out on the water must have been able to see how far the fire had spread, and they must have known it was all gone. The entire City was consumed. Anyone who hadn’t escaped the walls was gone with it.
Dis’ gaze turned constantly as they walked along the beach, searching for a familiar face. “Balin! Dwalin! Has anyone seen them? Has anyone seen our cousins?”
“Over that way, your highness,” an old dwarf from the carpenter’s guild pointed along the beach. He looked at Thorin and his eyes widened, and he bowed deeply. “My lord Thorin. I had heard the worst.”
“I’m glad to prove otherwise,” Thorin nodded.
And then, just a little further along where the carpenter had pointed, there was Balin. Even in the dulled light he was visible from a distance with his red coat and great puff of white hair. And beside him, his left arm in a sling, awkwardly trying to support a scrap of paper as he scribbled something down as Balin spoke, was another familiar figure.
“Fili!” Dis shrieked. She pulled up her skirts and sprinted across the sliding stones. Thorin followed as fast as his aching body would carry him.
Did grabbed Fili’s face as if she could not believe he was real and then began to kiss him ebulliently as he looked between them and stammered. “Ma! Thorin? Durin’s beard, we thought you were lost for sure!”
“Where’s your brother?” Dis demanded.
Before Fili could answer, Kili collided with them, cursing and sobbing as he dragged all four of them into a knot and gripped them tight, as Fili cried in protest, “Ow, ow, watch my shoulder! Kili, you sod, you’ll hug my stitches open!”
Thorin was the one having to hold Dis upright now. She could not even make words as she went from one son to the other, holding them and kissing them and shaking them as if to check they were still there. Thorin maintained some dignity, but he felt the joy swell and fill him up, sharing a space in his chest beside the despair at how many others would be climbing aboard those rafts bereft of a son, a mother, a brother, lost or soon to be lost to the smoke and flames.
He stepped away from the three of them and sat down on the stones, beside Bilbo, who was staring out at the boats and rafts.
“Where are they all going to go?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin squinted his eyes against the spreading smoke to try and make out the Mountain. “To Erebor,” he said. “It’s ours again. The elves will come with us. We could not deny them a share of whatever we can reclaim, after they shared their home with us for so long. It will take a hundred years at least to regrow the Woodland realm. We’ll rebuild everything in Erebor, a new city that will be a child of the old City, and once the Woodland is restored, they can each choose where they want to dwell.”
“A century. I’m sorry I won’t see it,” Bilbo said wistfully. “These twin cities.”
“Neither will I, probably,” Thorin said. He looked at Bilbo and smiled. “But I still have some good years left to plant the seeds, I think.” He raised his brows. “It might be useful to have a professional burglar on my payroll. If you’d be willing to take a job as difficult as this one again.”
Bilbo smiled back at him. “I think I managed this difficult job.” His hand reached out and touched a lock of Thorin’s hair, by the temple. Thorin didn’t pull away. Bilbo frowned. “You had some grey, here, but it’s gone away. Maybe it just looks strange through the ash.”
Thorin nodded. He folded his arms on top of his knees, and tried not to think about the hand pressing down on his chest and the crunch of his bones sliding back into place, and the deeper flicker of a cold, old life passing from the elf into him. “Maybe,” he said. “Only time will tell.”
