Chapter Text
The morning after he met Thorin, Bilbo packed up a bag, dressed in a set of comfortable clothes and belted his mother’s sword to his side. His mother’s ring was always in his vest pocket, but he checked it twice anyway. He shouldered the pack, locked the office, left the key with the housekeeper with instructions to check it once a week, and walked down to the Prancing Pony.
There were two ponies, and someone else’s tall, white horse tied up to the rail in front of the inn. Thorin was waiting at a table just inside the door. He was in the same clothes as the day before, but somehow still looking clean and uncreased. There were the remains of a small breakfast on the table in front of him, a pack resting on the floor, and the tall shape of a grey-clad wizard sitting beside him.
Bilbo drew back a little. “Gandalf. I did not know you were available to hire.”
Thorin glanced at the wizard sharply, as if expecting him to be offended by this. But Gandalf smiled and held out one arm to welcome Bilbo into a brief embrace. “Not at all, my young Master Baggins,” he chuckled. “I simply happen to be going in the same direction, and thought you might like the extra company on at least part of your journey.”
“What a remarkable coincidence,” Bilbo said knowingly. “And please, ‘Master Baggins’ might have enticed me when I was in my thirties, but I’m far too cynical for that now. It’s Bilbo to you. Have you been busy? Getting other folks into trouble?”
Gandalf grimaced. “Only when they really need it.”
Bilbo laughed, and waved them both towards the door. “Come on. If everyone’s eaten, let’s not waste any more of the day.”
He would never turn down the wizard’s offer of help, but all the same, he couldn’t help being just a little annoyed on two fronts: firstly, he had hoped to impress his new client by being the most experienced adventurer in their party of two, a title with which he could never compete against Gandalf. And second, though he would not have admitted it on pain of death, he had been rather curious about the idea of getting to know Thorin alone. But camping on the road did not lend itself to private conversations. Still, he was probably letting his imagination run away with him. Thorin might well turn out to be terrible company, and it was a long journey to be stuck with a boor or a nitpick.
Gandalf took the lead as they rode out of Bree, not really surprising given his horse at the withers had about four hands height on their ponies. Bilbo took up the rear, but as the road widened in the open countryside, Thorin fell back to ride beside him.
“I did not realise you were so familiar with our mutual wizard,” he said quietly, his eyes on the back of Gandalf’s hat. “I am beginning to feel this arrangement has been somewhat contrived. If you both have some lengthy scheme in mind, I can assure you, I was not lying about being out of pocket. I am not worth extorting."
“If there’s a scheme, I promise it was not cooked up by me,” Bilbo leaned towards him a little and said out the corner of his mouth. “I make no promises about our companion,” he straightened up and smiled. “Gandalf was a dear friend of my mother’s. In her youth she was a well-respected lass, but one day she disappeared from her quiet home in the Shire and ran away to follow the wizard into the wide world. She didn’t tell anyone much about her adventurers, but despite her poor reputation when she returned, my dear, frumpy, old father married her and built her a beautiful home - mostly with the chest of gold she’d brought home with her, I might add. I have fond memories of Gandalf visiting us when I was a child. But he was not there when my father died and we moved to Bree; perhaps he knew by then that my mother could take care of herself. I suppose he must have been keeping an eye on us, in some manner, since you say he recommended me.”
“Do you think we can trust him?” Thorin asked. Bilbo assumed he would ask the same question about Bilbo to Gandalf when he had the chance, and compare answers.
Bilbo nodded. “My mother always did. I can’t say more than that.”
Thorin glanced him up and down. He said, “At least you look like a professional, as promised. Yours is rather more impressive than mine.”
“Sorry?” Bilbo spluttered. Thorin pointed at Bilbo’s hip and then flicked back the tail of his own coat to show the sword at his belt. It was unadorned and the leather at the handle was fraying a little. It looked like something he’d purchased in Bree, second-hand from the local dwarven blacksmith. Bilbo collected himself. “Ah. Yes, this little sword is another legacy of my mother. She named it Sting. It’s elvish, apparently. Perhaps it’s from the City.”
“No, it looks older, and somebody loved making it,” Thorin said. “The swords in the city are made for use and weathering, not to keep for a lifetime.”
“I thought you said there were no weapons in the city?” Bilbo asked. “Or none for dwarves, anyway.”
Thorin looked ahead again, his eyes scanning the distant hills but now with a small smile on his mouth. “I said none except those carried by the city Guard, which had no dwarves at the time the law was made. But there was a single dwarf admitted to the Guard, just these two years past,” he smiled fully at Bilbo now. “Perhaps the first of many - perhaps there are already more, I have been away so long. There is little that dwarves cannot do when they turn their stubbornness on a problem, Mr Baggins.”
“I hope you’re right,” Bilbo answered.
–
It was six months before Thorin left the City, and Kili nocked an arrow.
He took a breath and drew his bow.
The drawn weight of the bow was heavy, to make the distance with the power he’d need to pierce the painted target at the far end of the archery range, but he’d practised this movement so many times it felt no more difficult than raising his arm. It was a beautifully made recurve bow, especially commissioned for him, for this day. He couldn’t manage the elvish longbows used by many of the guards for obvious reasons. The workshop who’d made the bow had presented it to him a few months ago, insisting it was a gift, even though Thorin had ordered it with the full intention of paying for it.
“It was a delight to design something new,” the head crafter said, and winked at Kili. “And hopefully we’ll be making more soon enough, eh, lad?”
The weight of all their expectations; heavier than the draw of the bow, that was for certain.
Far away at the end of the archery range stood two targets. His friend Berior had already finished his shots and was standing aside and slightly behind Kili so as not to distract him. On the other side stood their trainer, an older elf named Telion who had been teaching young archers so long that he even had the wisp of a beard on his chin. Beside him was the judge, who Kili didn’t know, and Prince Legolas stood behind them. As commander of the entire City Guard, the standing army and watch-folk of the Woodland realm, Legolas would of course have an interest in any new recruits. But given the guard consisted of almost two thousand elves, everyone was also well aware that it was unusual for him to actually sit in on the examinations.
Behind Kili, there was a small, raised dais separated from the range by a low railing. Under normal circumstances, a few chairs could be set up here, for friends and family members. Berior had one friend watching, his cousin Haered who had just finished the examinations yesterday and won his place in the Guard with his swordwork. But around Haered were two rows of benches packed in with Kili’s supporters, crammed close to the front to make extra standing room behind. Every inch of space was full of dwarves - and a handful of elves, mostly schoolfriends. His mother, brother and uncle were front and centre, but around them were cousins, neighbours, dwarvish school peers, and a few noble or important dwarves Kili didn’t know that well. Squeezing into any other free spaces were quite a few dwarves Kili didn’t even recognise. All here to see the last of his trials; the test of proficiency with the candidate’s chosen weapon.
No one breathed. They all waited.
It had been Fili’s idea, originally. About two years ago, Thorin had come home silent and seething about something. When Dis had settled him with a glass of wine and Kili had flopped into the armchair across from him and teased him into conversation, he had just muttered. “Delays, delays, delays.” And after some further prompting, “The mason’s guild is trying to send new apprentices for training in the Iron Hills. They are already two weeks late, but the Guard have rescheduled us a third time. It’s starting to feel personal.”
This was the law; no caravan or company may leave the woodland without at least a token guard. It had not been followed to the letter when Kili was young, especially for lone travellers on their own or on personal errands. But for the past few years, there had been orcish bandits on the roads, and the gates of the realm were now strictly controlled. No one may pass without record of their name and business, and an assigned force from the Guard as befitted the value of their party and the goods they carried. But the Guard was kept busy with encroachments from the Misty Mountains and spiders breeding in the hollows of the forest, and it had become increasingly slow and difficult to get the assigned protection. So shipments and travelers were held up, or cancelled entirely.
“Why don’t they train more Guards just for the roads?” Fili said from the corner of the room. He had his nose in some papers; something to do with their mother’s business. “It’s affecting trade, and what bothers trade bothers the king, surely. There must be scores of young dwarves keen for an excuse to stretch their legs and come back with a story about swinging a sword vaguely near a goblin’s neck. Stick a uniform on them and let them babysit the easy routes to the Iron Hills, so the City Guard can get back to their real jobs. Why not?”
Thorin twisted his head around to give him a wry look. “You know why.”
“There’s no law that says a dwarf can’t join the Guard,” Fili countered.
Thorin gave a bitter laugh and drank deep from the wine. “The examinations are set against any dwarf. No one’s tried in decades.”
“They’re not impossible,” Fili insisted, putting the papers down at last. He turned in his seat, resting his elbow on the desk. “I’m sure the last dwarf who tried was probably closer to your age, and went at the trials like a stubborn, stone-bred warrior. But that’s the wrong way to approach it. Someone younger should have a go. Someone born in the forest, who can move and fight and think more like an elf. There’s only one area where they really have an advantage.”
Throin raised his eyebrow. “A bold claim.”
Fili waved his hand “There’s trials of the mind, but anyone who can speak Sindarin and play Three Dwarf Morris can pass those.”
“Well, that’s me out,” said Kili, whose Sindarin was so poor he’d had to repeat his final language exam a year late at school.
“Your accent’s fine, you just can’t spell,” Fili shook his head at him. “Then there’s the trials that a dwarf could pass easily - strength and stamina, that sort of thing. So the only thing that a dwarf actually needs to train for is speed and dexterity. And a weapon - but all the other young applicants would have to do that training too, so young elves have no advantage over dwarves there. I’m not saying it’s easy, but it would only take one of us to make it in, and then there’d be no more excuses. All the young dwarrows in the City would sign up for the next round of recruiting.”
Thorin took another small sip of his wine. “Are you volunteering?”
“Yes,” Fili said. “As I said, why not? We’re Thror’s line, we should be leading the way. When’s the next recruitment?”
“Two years from now.” The Guard put out a call for new recruits about every three years, and took only a handful of new recruits each time. Despite the spreading shadows in this part of the world, deaths even in the Guard were extremely rare, and most attrition was simply due to resignations or, occasionally, dismissals for repeatedly drinking on duty.
“Plenty of time to train,” said Fili. He looked at his brother. “Kili?”
“Yes! Let’s do it,” Kili thumped his fist on his knee. “Even if we end up on our arses it’ll be good for a laugh.”
He had meant that, when he’d said it. They’d almost certainly fail, but signing up for the Guard examinations was going to be a bit of entertainment in their otherwise peaceful lives. And it would get the attention of the dams his age, which didn’t hurt either.
And now, two years later, and all that training, all that work, and all those people behind him, watching him. One more arrow and it would be over.
The examinations were essentially competitive; there were usually ten to twenty applicants, and only the five best were chosen according to a balance of many skills. They took place over a single week in midsummer, with candidates required to excel in at least one field. They would be dropped from further trials if they performed particularly badly in any individual test. There were trials of memory, speech and language, which Fili had passed easily and which Kili had, well, scraped through. Then the tests were mostly physical. Speed and agility had been the hardest, of course; and despite all their training Fili had lost out at that early stage. Kili had gotten lucky; he had passed only because he wasn’t in the bottom two, and that was only because he’d beaten Fili and one elf, who had tripped in a squirrel-hole in the forest and turned his ankle badly. But after that came tests of strength, endurance, and tactics, and suddenly Kili had found himself in the top half of the pack or better each time. The field of candidates dwindled around him and he was still in the running. Four of the other young elves had now been offered a place, as they’d shown their skills in the sword or the lance. He and Berior, who’d been training together under Telion, were the only two who’d chosen the bow, so they were the last two in the running. Only one of them would be in that list of five; and there was only one more arrow.
Kili really hadn’t expected to get this far, but now he was here, he had never wanted anything more in his life.
It wasn’t about guarding caravans to the Iron Hills anymore. It wasn’t about impressing dams. It wasn’t even about making Thorin and Ma proud. It was about something unnameable, not just for him, but for all of them. That swelling, haunting shadow of the City that had been there for Kili’s entire life until he wasn’t sure if it had really grown, or if he’d just learned to see it more clearly.
It worked like this: at the beginning, when the people of Erebor had made an accord with the Woodland realm, they had had different laws and different ideas about how a person should live, of course they had. So in trying to find some common ground, Thror and Thranduil had distilled it down to one key principle: each race could govern themselves within their own spheres of influence as they liked, but over this the city would have a common law under which all were equal. Nothing would be written, or set into precedent, in which the word ‘elf’ or ‘dwarf’ could appear.
That had been well over a century ago, long before Kili was born. But at some point, when he and Fili were old enough to ask difficult questions, Thorin explained how it really worked. The gates of the City and the roads in and out of the forest were a good example. Everyone had to state their business and be accompanied by a guard when they left the City. That sounded sensible on paper; everyone was equally protected. But the guards were limited - who got priority, who was delayed or refused an escort? That was up to the whims of whoever happened to be in charge on the day. And who was in charge? The city Guard, who were all elves. So somehow, without it being law, elves could come and go as they pleased from the city and dwarves suffered - as Thorin had complained - ‘delays, delays, delays’, until it was hardly worth doing the paperwork.
There were other examples; in these days of plenty and fertility for both races, all children had to be educated by trained teachers, and educated together for the benefit and fellowship of both. But the guild of teachers required many years working as governors or tutors, and referees of good standing to vouch for their skill in these roles. This became such a long and onerous process to qualify that there were almost no dwarvish teachers in the city’s schools, and those that were tended to be old. They retired within a few decades, while their elvish colleagues stayed at their posts. So although plenty of elvish teachers had the best of intentions, almost none spoke Khuzdul, or knew more than the bare bones of dwarvish history. So Fili and Kili had grown up beside their elvish friends learning to spell in Sindarin and the common tongue but barely able to understand the language of their grandparents’ generation, nor able to name more than the first few kings of the Longbeards - even they, the descendants of those same kings.
And then another example was intermarriage; there was an old law in the Woodland realm, benignly accepted for many thousands of years, that if any youth wished to marry before two hundred years old, if their future spouse was many years their senior, then they must wait until their third century before they wed or dwelled together. It was a law made to protect rash young elves from any subtle predation by their elders. Yet it excluded almost every pairing of dwarves and elves who had sought an exception over the years, else it cruelly forced them to wait until the dwarvish half of the couple’s life was mostly gone. Thorin himself, though he clearly found such private matters uncomfortable to talk about, had even petitioned Thranduil to have the law rewritten to specify that it only applied to elvish couples - but that golden rule was held sacrosanct: all were equal. There could be no law in which the word ‘elf’ or ‘dwarf’ could appear. So the law was still applied equally to all, and only a tiny handful of dwarf-elf couples had ever managed to skirt it.
When Kili had once complained about this to an elvish friend, they had been surprised. For elves truly in love, sharing a bed by choice was sufficient to make them married, so what did it matter if there was a sanctioned ceremony? Your fëa knew you were married. If your elders didn’t approve, that was their problem. It had been so hard for Kili to explain that it did matter. That dwarves didn’t really believe marriage was about your spirits uniting and all that warm and cuddly poetry. And yes, of course, dwarves had trysts before marriage, if they could get away with it without their parents finding out. But that didn’t make you married. It was important to have the ceremony, it had to be public and recognised by at least your family and your priests. You would never be seen as united in dwarvish society without it: you would always just be two people messing around.
These differences came into sharp contrast even when it came to the punishment for breaking the laws. Imprisonment was a rare consequence in the Woodland realm, save for the safety of a criminal or their victim. The usual method of sanction was a fine or the loss of titles and privileges. Thorin had given an example to his young nephews of how this worked in practise: “There was an elf and a dwarf, each in their prime, both from noble families, who were neighbours. The dwarf had been given a fine house by his father, and some money to start a business, which was in good order; and the elf lived in a small hall built by some distant ancestor, and had guardianship over an orchard in the forest, which he tended and traded the fruits of, as his mother and grandfather had done before him. These two became friends, and oft went hunting together. There was another neighbour across the way that they came to dislike, because of some petty grudge, and one day the friends got to drinking, and talking of this neighbour, and the fools talked themselves into waylaying him on his way home and roughing him up. He escaped with some injuries, and once they were sober they both admitted to the brutality and showed remorse. The magistrate declared each must relinquish half of their personal wealth, some of which went to the victim and some to the crown’s coffers. The dwarf had to sell his house, and his business was ruined. Unable to support his family, whom he loved more than his own life, his wife and sons went to live with his in-laws. And in despair he came to worse griefs later of his own making. And could anyone say he did not deserve it? No. He did a terrible thing.
“But his friend the elf, what did he give up? His house belonged to his family, and the orchard that was his livelihood was a place in the forest he cared for, not an encircled garden that the law said he owned. The wood elves keep their lands and homes collectively, by lineage or fellowship, or they do not keep them at all but manage them in harmony with nature. They do not use coins between their own kind, they barter or they lend, for they have long lives and memories. They can gift their creations and skills freely in the expectation something else will be given to them in turn, with time or need. So in the eyes of the law they are not wealthy, and little wealth can be taken from them. And this elf had to give up only some small possessions, and a little money, not much more than would buy a plain set of boots. The same crime, the same cause, and all treated equally, yet two very different punishments. Is this the justice of the law?”
Thorin gave the children a moment to ask questions, or voice their stark opinion, as children like to do. But after this lesson Fili and Kili had been very quiet, and only discussed it later between themselves, as if they already sensed this open secret was not to be shouted about in the street. And unbeknownst to Thorin, they both had a memory together, which they compared and found their memories resembled each other close enough that they must be real: several years earlier, when they had been just wee bairns, they had been playing with some other children on the roots of a great oak taller than the houses. As they sat aside to compare bruises from the game, an elf in an emerald cloak appeared as if out of thin air.
“Hello,” he said.
“Hello,” said Kili.
“Do you remember me?” The elf asked, crouching down to look at them. Fili shook his head. “I’m your Uncle Delos. I’ve known you since you were born. You’ve grown so much!” When the children didn’t answer, he reached into his bag. “Would you like some pears? They’re from my orchard, there’s none better in the woodland realm.”
“Thank you,” they both said politely, but as they bit into the sweet flesh, they heard their mother shouting.
She came at a run, her skirts hitched up, and grabbed them both by their hands. “Stay away from us, Delos.”
“Forgive me, Dis,” the elf said, taking a step back and wringing his hands. “I just wanted to see how they are. I miss them.”
“Don’t come near them again. You’ve ruined our lives.” Dis dragged them away and told them never to speak to the elf again.
Later, Kili asked Fili who the elf was. Fili shrugged. “Maybe he was a pervert.”
“What’s a pervert?”
“Ma says elves who chase after dwarves are perverts. But she doesn’t say it in front of Thorin, so it must be a bad word.”
That sounded terrifying. For some years afterwards, Kili assumed there were elves who hunted dwarves for sport. It was only later, after Thorin’s story, that they put it all together, who Delos was, who the story was really about, of the two friends who were punished by the law. And Kili couldn’t bring himself to be angry at Delos. He had looked so sad when he had told Dis, ‘I miss them’. He hadn’t lost gold or his house, maybe, but the disharmony of the law had taken something he dearly loved from him. They never saw Delos again, or if they did pass on the street, Fili and Kili had grown so much that they forgot Delos’ face and he did not recognise them.
All this, three years of training, all those memories, this history, these laws, these two races entwined within a single city, was wrapped up and squeezed into the moment that Kili drew back the string of the bow, and released.
The arrow flew as true as he’d ever shot. He knew before it had even struck the target. He lowered the bow and stood breathing out slow, even breaths to keep his heart from bursting as the judge walked the length of the range, carrying the flag he would use to indicate the winner. Behind him, Kili could hear the crowd murmuring, some of the dwarves asking the elves in the stands, “I can’t see from here. Can you see?”
The judge’s keen eyes took little time to inspect the two targets, each with three arrows from their three shots. In a moment, too long and yet too quick for Kili to prepare himself, he raised his flag towards Kili’s target.
There was an instant, convulsive roar of joy from the crowd. Kili turned to see the dais nearly buckling under the sudden leaps and stamps. Dwarves were hugging each other, and some were even hugging the elves beside them. Fili was punching the air over and over, and Thorin was on his feet and thumping the railing, bellowing, “Yes, Kili! Yes, you splendid lad! Baruk Khazâd!” Even his dour mother was smiling and raising her arms above her head to clap.
Kili realised he was grinning wide enough to make his cheeks ache, and that his eyes were overflowing. He wiped them quickly as Berior approached, his hand outstretched. “Well done. I’m so glad for you.”
“Well done yourself,” Kili shook his hand. “I hope there’s no hard feelings.”
“Of course not,” Berior gave a small bow. “I’ll apply again in three years. Plenty of time to keep training until I catch up with you.”
Kili turned to the judge, who was speaking with Prince Legolas. Their heads were bent together to hear each other above the noise of the crowd. The judge’s brow was furrowed, and he was shaking his head at something the prince had apparently asked. Telion stepped close to listen and he began to frown as well. Kili felt his knees beginning to shudder a little and the smile fade from his face. After a moment, the crowd sensed the disruption and the cheering died rapidly to whispers and mutters.
Telion waved his hand at Kili. “Well, please, my lord, explain it to him. Because I’m not sure I understand.”
Legolas looked as flustered as a prince of the woodland realm was permitted to look. He cleared his throat, and then said loud enough for all to hear. “I must confer with my father. The king should have the final confirmation.”
“Why?” Telion argued. “Do you not approve of my training? You are the commander of the Guard; it is in your purview to approve the candidates.”
Legolas shot him a swift glare. “This situation is irregular.”
Berior practically leapt into the cluster. “No, it’s not! I lost. He won. He’s the fifth recruit.”
The crowd had gone very silent. Kili looked at them and saw Thorin leaning forward over the railing, as if he was about to vault over it and bring his authority into the fight. Dis grabbed his shoulder and gripped it tight. She knew what Kili knew; there could be no question over his candidacy, no accusations of nepotism. Kili looked back at Prince Legolas. He couldn’t bring himself to plead out loud, but he felt his face begging for understanding. From one prince to another.
Telion folded his arms and muttered, soft enough that Kili just made it out. “Your highness, you will start a riot. Don’t delay this.”
Legolas nodded. He strode forward and put his hand out. “Congratulations. Welcome to the Guard.”
Kili took the hand with a weak smile. “Thank you, commander,” he tried to say, but his voice was drowned out by another explosion of cheering from behind him.
