Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 6: ⛰︎ Heavy Lies the Crown

Chapter Text

⛰︎

Morning lingered pale upon the eastern slopes when the Dwarves of the Iron Hills began their departure from Erebor.

 

The celebrations had not ended so much as loosened their grip upon the Mountain. Though the halls still carried the remnants of wine, song, and ceremony, guests had begun gathering their cloaks, tightening their belts, searching for misplaced possessions, and extending farewells far beyond what any other departure would have required. Messengers moved between chambers with final copies of agreements, sealed letters, and invitations offered too late to be useful but too warmly meant to refuse. Beneath it all the Mountain had already resumed its ordinary rhythm: carts rolling, hammers waking, voices calling across corridors, fires being fed in kitchens and forges alike. Erebor had celebrated her restoration; now she had returned, steadily and without ceremony, to the labour of remaining.

 

Thorin and Fíli stood together upon one of the outer balconies overlooking the eastern road. They had come there intentionally, as was fitting. Dáin was kin as much as ally, and though the meeting two days prior had frayed tempers more than honour demanded, no bitterness had remained since the unveiling of the monument. Dwarves were rarely gentle in anger, but neither were they always inclined to preserve it once it had spent its force. Dáin had embraced half the household before breakfast, insulted the ale of Erebor while requesting another cask for the road, and loudly praised the monument.

 

Far below the balcony, the departing company arranged itself into something that aspired toward order and achieved instead the familiar controlled disorder of Dwarves preparing for travel. Pack animals stamped upon stone. Wagons creaked beneath secured loads. Guards shouted to one another across the road while younger dwarves hurried back and forth carrying bundles that should have been loaded the night before. Dark banners of the Iron Hills stirred heavily in the cold morning air, and beyond them the road wound eastward through the lower slopes before disappearing among ridges still pale with the early morning light.

 

Fíli leaned both forearms upon the stone railing and watched Dáin stride through the confusion below with all the subtlety of a boulder deciding to roll downhill.

 

“I give it another moment before he turns the entire procession around because someone forgot something important.” he said.

 

“The hard part of getting him out of the Mountain is over. Once Dáin is on the road there is no turning back unless lives are at stake.” Thorin replied.

 

“You have greater faith in him than I do.”

 

“I have greater knowledge of him.”

 

Below, several dwarves broke away from the line and hurried back toward the gate carrying empty crates between them. Fíli pointed without attempting to hide his satisfaction at being right.

 

”There.”

 

”They may be carrying farewell gifts.”

 

”They are running.”

 

”Then the gifts must be urgent.”

 

Fíli laughed, and the sound passed out over the road with the morning wind. For a time the two of them stood in companionable silence while the first wagons began to move. Thor in watched the wheels settle into the road’s old grooves and felt, by habit, the familiar count begin within him: riders, guards, provisions, distance, weather, the state of the eastern shelves after winter. Such calculations had shaped him for too many years to leave him merely because one decision had formed in the dark of the night before. 

 

Yet beneath those thoughts lay another, broader and stranger. The road itself seemed clearer to him that morning than it had in years. Not as a route requiring repair or negotiation, nor as a line upon a map tied to trade, alliance or defence, but simply as a road - stone giving way to distance and distance giving way to lands unseen from the Mountain’s gates. The sight did not call to him, not exactly. It was too soon for that. It merely existed before him without asking anything of his crown.

 

“The Iron Hills seemed satisfied enough.” Fíli said after a while. “I heard Dáin praising the metalwork to Glóin, even though Glóin was not even involved in the construction.”

 

“Dáin told Glóin that the hammer-head could use more iron.”

 

”That is high praise from the Iron Hills.”

 

”That is hunger from the Iron Hills.”

 

”Glóin looked ready to strike him with one of the ceremonial lanterns.”

 

”I would have allowed it.”

 

”Balin would not.”

 

”Balin ruins many fine moments in the name of diplomacy.”

 

Fíli smiled, though the expression turned thoughtful almost at once. He had been tired when they came out, but it was the clean tiredness of work completed and well received, not the grey heaviness Thorin had come to recognize in himself. Formal blue still marked him as prince of Erebor, yet the wind had loosened several strands of hair from his braids, and there remained, stubbornly, a faint dark line near one cuff where charcoal or soot had survived every attempt at ceremony.

 

”You did well with them.” Thor in said.

 

Fíli glanced sideways.

 

”With the Iron Hills?”

 

”With all of it.”

 

The younger dwarf’s expression shifted, wariness stirring beneath the morning ease. 

 

“That is broad enough to mean nothing.”

 

”It means what I said.”

 

”I oversaw a monument and survived one meeting.”

 

”You speak as though either were small.”

 

”I speak as though you are beginning a conversation from the wrong end, uncle.”

 

Thorin allowed himself a faint smile at that, but it faded as his hands settled upon the railing. The stone was cold beneath his palms, worn smooth by weather and the hands of those who had stood there before him. Far below, the first line of Dáin‘s company rounded slowly towards the north-east. The rest followed in staggered motion - shouting, adjusting, correcting one another and arguing about loads that were by now already tied down.

 

”When you look at Erebor,” Thorin said slowly. “what do you see?”

 

”I see Erebor.” Fíli said as he turned fully to face his uncle.

 

”That is not an answer.”

 

”It is the only answer your question deserves.”

 

”You know what I ask.”

 

”No,” Fíli said, though without sharpness. “I suspect that you know what you ask, which is not always the same thing.”

 

Thorin looked at him then, and for a moment something like amusement passed between them. Fíli had grown increasingly difficult to corner in conversation these past years. Once he would have answered too quickly and defended the answer too stubbornly. Now he circled questions when he sensed hidden edges in them, and that was perhaps something he had learned more from Balin than from Thorin.

 

Still, he considered it. His gaze moved across the Mountain below them, over the lower roads leading toward Dale, the outer workshops already needing more room, the gates through which carts entered and departed, and the visible ridge lines where new watch-posts had been discussed but not yet built. What began as caution gradually softened into attention.

 

”I see what it might become.” he answered the question at last, and seemed almost surprised by the plainness of his own answer.

 

Thorin remained still. “Tell me.”

 

Fíli frowned, then gave a small shrug as though to diminish the answer before fully offering it.

 

”The southern workshops are crowding each other already. If trade continues as it has, we will need new storage halls before the decade passes, and proper space for visiting merchants before they overrun every lower corridor with crates and complaints. The road to Dale should be widened near the second bend - not at once perhaps, but soon enough before someone attempts to send three wagons abreast through a path made for one and blames the Mountain when they wedge themselves there until winter.”

 

Despite himself, Thorin huffed a quiet laugh. Encouraged, Fíli continued, his thoughts gathering speed the more he spoke.

 

”Dale is growing too, faster than Bard’s council seems willing to admit, and if we do not plan with them rather than beside them, we will spend the next twenty years discovering that Men build roads precisely where Dwarves would prefer to place drainage channels.”

 

This time Thorin did not laugh, though some warmth passed through him at the shape of Fíli’s irritation. The younger dwarf was not reciting reports. He was seeing a kingdom in motion - roads not yet laid, halls not yet carved, difficulties not yet fully born but already requiring thought. Fíli stopped abruptly when he seemed to realise how long he had spoken.

 

”I am rambling.”

 

”No,” Thorin said. “you are not.”

 

The wind moved between the pillars behind them, carrying with it faint sounds from the waking Mountain. Somewhere deep below, a hammer struck metal. The note rose thinly through the morning air before it disappeared into the greater murmur of Erebor. Thorin looked upon his nephew and saw again the crowd gathered around the monument, the workers turning naturally towards him, the craftsmen explaining details he already knew, Dáin arguing with him not as one indulging a prince but as one answering another dwarf whose mind had become worth testing.

 

”When I look at Erebor,” Thorin said quietly. “I see what was restored.”

 

Fíli’s expression changed, not with understanding yet, but with recognition that the conversation had found its true road at last.

 

”I see halls rebuilt.” Thorin continued. “Mines reopened. Trade recovered. Debts honoured. Promises kept. I see the distance between exile and return, and I measure every stone against what was lost before the dragon came. That has been my work, and I do not regret it.”

 

”No one in their right mind would ask you to regret it, uncle.”

 

”No.” Thorin looked eastward at the last of the Iron Hills’ company had already put distance between them and the Mountain. “But you look upon the same halls and se what has not yet been made. That is not merely youth. It is vision.”

 

Fíli pushed himself away from the railing slightly, unease rising at last through his posture. 

 

"If this is another way of praising how i handled the council-“

 

"It is not.”

 

"Then what is it?”

 

Thorin did not answer immediately. For all the certainty that had carried him through the night, the words themselves remained heavy. Once spoken, they would not return to him unchanged. He thought briefly of Dís in the hall after the feast, of her careful hope and gentle talk of happiness and family. He thought of noble daughters placed near him through five years of feasts, councils and seasonal gathering - all of the courteous and intelligent, many of them admirable yet none of them stirring in him anything beyond the wary knowledge of what others expected him to want. For a long while he had assumed some desire would come in its proper season, as spring comes beneath snow. It had not come. After enough years, even absence takes on the shape of truth.

 

"When your mother speaks of marriage," Thorin said at last, "she does so because she believes I have merely delayed it."

 

Fíli blinked, thrown entirely.

 

"I suppose she does."

 

"So does half the Mountain. The other half discusses it less politely."

 

"That is, unfortunately, probably true."

 

"There was a time I believed them right. I thought the wish for such things would come when Erebor was secure, or when grief had passed, or when the work left space for anything beyond necessity." He kept his gaze upon the road while he spoke, not from shame necessarily, but because some truths are easier offered to distance than to another face.

 

"It did not." he then concluded.

 

Fíli said nothing for several moments. Beneath them, the last visible riders from the Iron Hills had disappeared beyond the first bend, their banners having folded into distance. When he finally spoke, his voice had quieted.

 

"You are saying you do not intend to marry."

 

"Yes."

 

"And there will be no children of yours."

 

"No."

 

The answer settled between them with a force Thorin had expected and still found difficult. Fíli looked down toward the road, and Thorin could almost see the pieces shifting in his mind: years of deflections, the careful efforts of Dís, the strange stillness that followed every conversation of heirs, the fact that everyone had treated Fíli's place in the succession as temporary - not because they doubted him, but because they assumed Thorin's line would eventually continue elsewhere.

 

"And because of that," Fíli said slowly, "you mean the line shall pass through me."

 

"Yes."

 

The younger dwarf absorbed it, then shook his head once sharply as though rejecting not the statement itself but the unseen thing gathering behind it.

 

"One day."

 

"Sooner than one day."

 

"No."

 

Thorin turned toward him fully then. Fíli's refusal came not as political resistance, nor even uncertainty of his own abilities. It came with the immediate force of a wound touched without warning.

 

"No." he repeated. "You do not get to stand her on a cold morning after too little sleep and tell me that the shape of our house has changed because you spent one night thinking too deeply beside a dark hearth."

 

"It was not one night."

 

"Then one week. One month. One year. I do not care." Fíli's voice rose, then lowered again when he seemed to remember the road below still held distant ears. "You are not too old. You are not failing. The Mountain is not turning against you. You are loved here, uncle."

 

"I know, Fíli."

 

"Then stay."

 

The simplicity of it struck Thorin more sharply than any argument might have done. Fíli looked at him with open frustration now, but beneath it lay fear, and beneath that something younger still.

 

"If this is because you feel restless, then be restless. If you cannot sleep, do not sleep. If the councils bore you, let Balin bury you in them until you come to your senses. If you need to leave Erebor for a season, then leave it for a season and return. Kings have travelled before without surrendering crowns."

 

"This is not about restlessness alone."

 

"Then explain it." Fíli pleaded.

 

"I am trying." Thorin replied with near equal frustration.

 

"Try plainly."

 

Thorin looked back toward the Mountain. Plainly, then. Yet plainness had never been as simple as dwarves often liked to claim, for the truest things often lay beneath words in caverns of their own. He took a slow breath followed by and let the morning air steady him.

 

"Erebor needs a king who knows where she is going." He finally stated in a soft yet secure voice.

 

Fíli stared at him ready to respond to the statement, but Thorin continued before the younger dwarf could answer.

 

"I know where she has been. I know every road between loss and restoration, every debt paid to bring these halls from ruin to life. I know how to defend what we reclaimed. I know how to remember. But when I look forward now, beyond the work already done, I see no road clearly enough to lead others upon."

 

"That cannot be true, uncle!"

 

"It is." Thorin spoke calmly and without bitterness. "Last night proved it to me."

 

"The monument?"

 

"The people around it."

 

Fíli's anger faltered slightly.

 

"I stood before a work that honoured everything I value: craft, labour, endurance, the making of a kingdom by many hands. I saw its worth and its beauty. I knew why the hall answered it with pride, yet I stood outside that joy as one might stand outside a closed gate and remember the path within without being able to enter." 

 

Thorin looked toward Fíli once more before continuing.

 

"But you were within it, Fíli. Not because you forced yourself there. Not because ceremony placed you there. You were part of the life moving through that chamber, and it answered you."

 

Fíli looked away quickly, his jaw tightening.

 

"That is not kingship, uncle."

 

"It is nearer to it than many things called by that name."

 

"You are making poetry of a crowd enjoying a sculpture."

 

"No," Thorin said. "I am making a judgment."

 

The word struck differently. Fíli looked back.

 

"A king's judgment?"

 

"Yes."

 

For a while the younger dwarf said nothing. Now all movement had vanquished from the roads beneath them, only a faint layer of dust lingered in the air. The silence left behind the departure of Dáin and his company seemed larger than ever, as if the Mountain had exhaled and now waited.

 

"I hate this." Fíli said at last.

 

"I know."

 

"You are asking me to take your place."

 

"No." Thorin shook his head. "I am asking you to take your own."

 

Fíli let out a sharp breath through his nose, almost a laugh, though there was no amusement in it.

 

"That sounds like something Balin would say when trying to make bad news seem inevitable."

 

"Balin would take longer."

 

Despite himself, Fíli's mouth twitched into a discreet smile. It was gone quickly, and in its place was a slight frown and worried eyes.

 

"You truly believe this?"

 

"I know it."

 

The younger dwarf turned again to the railing and gripped it with both hands. His gaze remained fixed upon the empty road below, though Thorin doubted he saw much of it.

 

"When I was young," Fíli said after a long silence. "I thought being king meant standing where all could see you. I thought the weight of it was in the crown, the hall, the songs. Later I learned that was the least of it."

 

"What frightens you now?"

 

"That I understand why you are asking."

 

The answer came quietly, and because it came quietly it carried further.

 

"If I thought this to be because of sorrow, I would fight you on this. If I thought this to be because of weariness, I would send for my mother and Balin and let them take turns speaking sense into you until even the stone begged for mercy. But I saw you last night."

 

He swallowed, but then continued even more firmly than before.

 

"No one else would have noticed. You smiled. You spoke. You honoured the work properly, but you looked at the hall as though the celebration were happening somewhere very far away. At the time I believed you were withholding feeling. Now, I understand that you were waiting for it."

 

Thorin did not reply, letting the silence settle between them answer.

 

"Did it come?" Fíli asked, looking up at his uncle with a mixture of hope and concern.

 

"No."

 

The younger dwarf nodded once, small and pained. He remained silent for a long while afterward, and Thorin did not press him. Acceptance, if it came, deserved space enough to arrive in its own shape. Below, a raven settled upon one of the lower walls and shook its feathers against the wind. From within Erebor, far behind them, came the faint sound of hammers working once more.

 

"One year." Thorin said at last. "I will not force this upon you and depart in the same breath. I wish to prepare what must be prepared, to teach you what I know - and if you do not wish to sit upon the throne by the next Durin's day then I shall remain on the throne until my last breath. But do not reject the crown because you think me more deserving of it. My desire to step down comes from pride and accomplishment, not doubt or restlessness."

 

"Alright. One year."

 

"Balin will teach you what I do not know. Dís will remind us both when we are being fools."

 

At that, Fíli's expression changed, grief and humour touching the same place.

 

"She will be furious."

 

"Yes."

 

"Mainly with you."

 

"Likely, but she will understand in time."

 

Fíli groaned and rubbed one hand across his face.

 

"A year is not long." 

 

"It is enough."

 

"And if at the end of it I still say no?"

 

"In a year, you will not." Thorin looked at the younger dwarf with a renewed strength to his posture and a steadiness in his eyes.

 

"That is arrogance, uncle."

 

"It is faith."

 

"That is often what arrogant people call it."

 

This time Thorin laughed, and Fíli did too, though softly and without much ease. The laughter did not mend what had opened between them, but it made the shape of it less terrible.

 

For a long while they stood without speaking. The road below lay empty now, pale in the morning, marked only by wheel-ruts and the fading trace of Dáin's departure. It ran eastward out of sight, but not only eastward. From the Mountain all roads eventually bent elsewhere: to Dale just below the mountain, to the Iron Hills, to Mirkwood, to old lands and to unknown lands. Thorin found himself looking at it with a feeling to slight yet to be named hope, but no longer only duty or memory.

 

At last Fíli drew a slow breath.

 

"One year." he said. "You stay. You teach me properly. Not only the matters written in ledgers or spoken in council, but the things no one writes down because everyone assumes kings are born knowing them. The mistakes. The bargains. The names that matter more than their titles. The old grudges that pretend to be policy. The doors you avoid opening until there is no choice."

 

"There are many of those."

 

"Then we shall need the year."

 

Thorin inclined his head.

 

"And at the end?"

 

Fíli kept his gaze upon the road a moment longer before answering. 

 

"At the end, if you still believe Erebor is better served with me upon the throne, and if I can stand before the Mountain without feeling I have taken something from you..." he stopped, then corrected himself with visible effort. "No. Not if. When."

 

The word settled between them like stone placed true.

 

"When." Fíli said again, more firmly. "Then I will take the crown."

 

The Mountain continued around them. Somewhere below, workers returned to scaffolds. Somewhere above, smoke lifted from chimneys into the pale morning. In the halls behind them, guests finished their farewells, children complained of cold breakfasts, and half of Erebor carried on unaware that the future of the throne had shifted quietly upon a balcony just above the road.

 

Thorin looked one last time toward the empty eastern path, then toward the younger dwarf beside him. The agreement stood between them newly forged and still hot enough to burn, but it stood. Neither of them spoke of farewell. Neither of them spoke of what must be grieved before the year ended.

 

For that morning, it was enough that the thing had been named.

⛰︎