Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 7: ⛰︎ Whoever Remains After

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

⛰︎

A year had passed, and the sixth anniversary of Erebor's reclamation came beneath a clear morning sky.

 

Above the Lonely Mountain the early light struck stone and snow with a brightness almost severe, and by the time the sun climbed fully above the eastern ridges the roads below had already filled with banners. They came from the Iron Hills, from Dale, from smaller halls and kin scattered across the North, from merchants' houses and guilds and families who had known the long years of exile and now came dressed not for mourning or remembrance, but for a coronation. The Mountain received them all with open gates.

 

Erebor had changed in the year since Thorin first spoke to Fíli upon the balcony above the eastern road. Not suddenly. Not in any way that might have seemed alarming to those living in her halls day by day. Yet change had moved through the kingdom like water through old channels newly cleared of stone - like fact of it was new but the movement felt ancient. 

 

At first Fíli stood beside Thorin in council as he had done for the past few years, listening, answering when asked, offering suggestions when the matter touched roads, guilds, trade or workers' grievances. Then, gradually, the questions had begun turning toward the younger dwarf before Thorin had even needed to redirect them there. Guildmasters sought his opinion on expansions. Dáin sent letters addressed to them both and replies meant plainly for Fíli's eyes. Messengers from Dale began waiting for Fíli if Thorin was delayed. Workers in the lower halls had long since ceased straightening in surprise when the prince appeared among them with questions of his own.

 

The transition had been felt long before it had been announced. By late winter, even those who disliked change had begun speaking of Fíli's future reign not merely as possibility but as approaching fact. By mid-spring, the councils had adjusted around him. By summer, the Mountain had begun answering to him in small ways no decree could have commanded. Thorin had watched it happen with careful attention and greater pain than he had expected, though not the pain of envy. It was stranger than that. Something nearer to the aching stretch of an old wound healing wrong and then, at last, being set properly.

 

Now the day had finally come.

 

The great hall chosen for the crowning stood deeper within Erebor than the chamber of the monument. It was older and more solemn, built in an age when the kingdom's pride had needed neither apology nor restraint. Its vaulted ceiling vanished into shadow high above, where lanterns hung like captured stars among carved ribs of stone. Pillars lined the hall in long ranks, each banded with metal and inscribed with names from the line of Durin. Along the walls hung banners of the gathered clans. Beneath them stood dwarves from every part of the restored kingdom, their voices lowered by the weight of the hour despite the excitement moving among them.

 

At the far end of the hall stood the throne beneath the Mountain. For five years Thorin had sat upon it as king. For one year he had sat upon it while teaching another how to rise toward it. Today he stood below it, not beside the throne but before the gathered people, dressed in dark ceremonial garments without the crown resting upon his brow.

 

The absence had drawn many eyes when he first entered.

 

Not shock. The announcement had been made a few months ago - after winter councils, after letters to allied halls, after long conversations with Dís, Dáin, Balin, Dwalin, and those whose support could not be taken for granted. Yet knowledge does not always lessen the force of seeing. Thorin could feel the moment pass through the hall when they looked upon him bareheaded. The King under the Mountain stood before them still, but already the image had begun changing into memory.

 

Fíli stood several paces away from him, speaking quietly with Glóin and one of the guild representatives before the ceremony began. That, more than the crown waiting upon its cushion, revealed the truth of the day.

 

He did not look untouched by nerves. No dwarf of sense could have stood at the edge of such an hour and felt none. Yet Fíli did not look misplaced. His shoulders held tension, yes, but not uncertainty. When a messenger approached with some last question concerning the order of oaths, Fíli answered without casting a glance toward Thorin. When Dáin leaned close to mutter something that made the younger dwarf's brows rise sharply, Fíli replied with quiet amusement and just enough firmness that the old lord of the Iron Hills barked a laugh and slapped him hard upon the shoulder.

 

Erebor already begun making room for him.

 

'Or perhaps', Thorin thought, 'she had made room long ago, and only now can I see the shape of it - the Mountain already knows its king'.

 

It was a comforting thought, but not one that Thorin was allowed much time to elaborate on as a horn sounded from the upper gallery and the hall stilled.

 

Balin stepped forward first. Age had bent him somewhat in the past year, though not in spirit, and his white beard had been braided and neatly tucked into a ceremonial belt for the occasion. In his hand he held the record of oaths, not because he needed to read from it, but because such things simply ought to be held. His voice, when it rose, carried clearly through the hall.

 

"People of Erebor, kin of Durin, friends and allies gathered beneath the Mountain," he began, "we stand this day upon a threshold few among our people have lived to see - not the crowning of a king after death, nor after ruin, nor war, but the passing of a crown from one living hand to another in a kingdom thriving."

 

A murmur moved faintly through the hall, solemn and low.

 

Balin continued.

 

"Thorin Oakenshield, sone of Thráin, son of Thrór, reclaimed the throne beneath the Mountain from the dragon Smaug and restored to Durin's Folk the halls long denied them. By his labour, by his endurance, and by the hands of all who stood beside him, Erebor lives. Yet no kingdom endures by memory alone. Stone must be maintained. Roads must be opened. Fire must be tended. Those who restore a hall must not always be the ones to fill it with the years to come."

 

Thorin heard the words without flinching. Once, perhaps, they would have cut. On this day, however, they settled with a strange gentleness. 

 

Balin turned toward him.

 

"My lord Thorin, King under the Mountain, do you come before your people by your own will?"

 

Thorin stepped forward.


"I do."

 

"Do you lay down crown and throne freely, without coercion, deceit, or failing of honour?"

 

"I do."

 

"Do you name before Durin's Folk the one who shall succeed you?"

 

Thorin then turned toward Fíli, and the hall seemed to draw breath.

 

For a moment he saw the boy from the quest - bright-haired, eager, impatient, too young to understand how close death walked beside all great purposes. Then he saw the prince beneath the monument scaffolds, charcoal upon his brow, giving orders with more ease than he knew. Then the dwarf in the council chamber turning argument into agreement. Then finally the one who had stood upon the balvony and spoken of roads, workshops, trade, valleys, and years yet unbuilt.

 

"I name Fíli, son of Dís, of the line of Durin." Thorin spoke. "Let him be named my heir. Let him be crowned King under the Mountain."

 

Fíli stepped forward.

 

He did not look at Thorin immediately. His gaze moved first over the hall, over the gathered clans, the workers, the nobles, the kin, the people who had become his before the crown ever touched him. Then at last he looked toward Thorin, and in that look remained everything the ceremony could not hold or make room for: grief, gratitude, fear and love.

 

Balin turned to him.

 

"Fíli, son of Dís, will you take up the crown of Erebor?"

 

Fíli's voice came steadier than Thorin had expected yet less steady than the hall perhaps heard.

 

"I will."

 

"Will you hold the Mountain not as treasure possessed, but as trust given into your keeping?"

 

"I will."

 

"Will you guard Durin's Folk in prosperity as in hardship, in peace as in war, remembering exile without making an idol of it, and seeking the good of those yet unborn beneath these halls?"

 

At that Fíli's jaw tightened faintly for only a second before he answered with steady security.

 

"I will."

 

Dís stood among the front ranks with both hands clasped before her. She had wept earlier, privately and angrily, and then warned both Thorin and her son that if either of them looked at her during the ceremony she would never forgive them. Naturally, they had both looked and now she was holding onto herself with the pride of one who had already lost enough to know that joy too could hurt.

 

The clan oaths followed.

 

Dáin came first, as lord of the Iron Hills and kin by blood. He approached heavily, all ceremony seeming to fit him poorly and yet magnificently at the same time. Like armour never polished because it had seen better use. He clasped Fíli's forearm instead of kneeling at once, holding him there long enough to speak too quietly for the whole hall to hear but not quietly enough for Thorin to miss.

 

"Do not grow too wise too quickly," Dáin muttered with a twinkle in his eye. "It makes young kings unbearable."

 

Fíli's mouth twithched.

 

"I shall attempt to remain foolish enough for your comfort."

 

"Good."

 

Then Dáin knelt before him.

 

The sight struck the hall more deeply than Thorin expected. Dáin Ironfoot, who bent easily to no one and complained of most things before agreeing to them, lowered himself before Fíli and swore the loyalty of the Iron Hills. His voice rang rough and strong across the hall, and when he rose again the approval that moved through the gathered dwarves was not polite but it was full-throated and sure.

 

After him came the other clans.

 

Some oaths were in Khuzdul, in ancient form, full of names older than Erebor. Some were briefer, offered by dwarves more comfortable with axe and ledger than ceremonial speech. Guildmasters came too, and though they did not swear as clans swore, they offered pledges of craft, labour and service. One old miner stumbled over half the formal wording, cursed softly under his breath, and finally said something that Thorin was too distracted to catch, but it caused the hall to break into laughter. The ring of laughter was warm and irreverent, and Fíli laughed with them.

 

Thorin watched.

 

He had wondered, in the year between decision and crowning, whether the final moment would reopen doubt. Not his own doubt, perhaps, but the doubt of others. Whether the clans would accept because duty demanded it rather than because their hearts did. Whether the hall would turn toward Fíli with respect but not yet love. Whether some part of Erebor would remain looking back over its shoulder toward the king who had reclaimed it.

 

But the Mountain did not hesitate. Thorin saw it in the faces before him. In the ease with which workers called Fíli's name when laughter swelled. In the solemnity of the clan oaths. In the way even those who had resisted the abdication months earlier now seemed not resigned but ready. Fíli had not replaced him. That was not the shape of it. Rather, the kingdom had widened toward its next age, and Fíli stood already within that widening, visible at last to all.

 

Balin approached the cushion upon which the crown rested.

 

He slowly lifted the crown, and the hall stilled so completely that even the distant forges seemed to pause.

 

Fíli knelt.

 

For one heartbeat, Thorin felt the old world and the new meet within the space between crown and brow. All the years of exile. The dragon's shadow. The road to Erebor. The battle. The rebuilding. The monument. The balcony. A year of teaching and arguments and ledgers and laughter caught unexpectedly in council rooms.

 

Then Balin set the crown upon Fíli's head.

 

"Behold Fíli, son of Dís, of the line of Durin," Balin said, and though his voice trembled faintly at the edges, it did not break. "King under the Mountain."

 

The hall erupted.

 

Not ceremonially. Not dutifully. Not with the careful respect owed to a title. The sound that rose from Erebor came from somewhere deeper. Voices struck the vaulted ceiling and returned doubled, tripled, until the whole chamber seemed to ring like an anvil beneath a thousand hammers. Dwarves shouted Fíli's name. Clan banners lifted. Dáin bellowed loud enough to overpower half the hall by himself. Dís covered her mouth for one brief moment and then seemed to give up all effort at restraint.

 

Fíli rose beneath the crown, and the noise did not falter. If anything, it grew.

 

And Thorin, standing aside at last, felt the force of it pass through him. Not around him this time. Through him.

 

For the first time in a long while, feeling came not as something he strained toward, but as something that found him where he stood. Grief first, sharp and deep, for no ending truly blessed came without sorrow. Pride followed, fierce enough to warm him where the grief had cut. Then relief, vast and quiet beneath them both, like a door opened after long years in a room too small to breathe within.

 

The Mountain had accepted another king. Not politely, and not because Thorin asked it, but wholeheartedly.

 

The knowledge did not diminish him. That was the wonder of it. He had feared, in some buried place too proud to confess itself, that seeing Erebor turn so fully toward another might leave him hollowed beyond repair. Instead he felt the strange, aching peace of a burden set down in the place prepared for it.

 

Fíli turned then.

 

Across the roar of the hall, their eyes met.

 

No words could have crossed such a distance in the loud and crowded hall, nor were any needed. Thorin inclined his head once, not as king to king, nor even as uncle to nephew alone, but as one craftsman acknowledging a work completed and handed on. Fíli's face changed in answer, the weight of the crown visible within him now, but so too the strength beneath it. Then the crowd surged closer, and the moment disappeared beneath celebration.

 

The coronation feast began almost before anyone formally declared the ceremony ended.

 

Music rose from the lower end of the hall. Tables were uncovered, casks opened, children released from ceremonial stillness with alarming speed. Dáin seized Fíli by both shoulders and began offering advice that sounded suspiciously like warnings against every mistake Dáin himself had ever made. Dís embraced her son, struck him lightly on the arm for standing too stiffly, and then embraced him again before he could protest. As soon as he let go, Kíli nearly tackled him into the ground in a rough and heartfelt embrace.

 

Thorin remained for a while.

 

He accepted hands clasped in gratitude. He endured praise he no longer needed and farewells not yet understood as farewells. some called him King still, then corrected themselves awkwardly. Others called him Thorin Oakenshield with such reverence that the name felt older than the crown he had laid down. He answered them all with what grace he could, and for once the words did not feel like armour. They were only words, warm and imperfect, exchanged between himself and the people he had loved enough to leave in better hands.

 

At length, as the celebration swelled beyond ceremony into true festivity, Thorin stepped back toward one of the side passages.

 

No one stopped him.

 

That, too, felt right.

 

The hall no longer required his presence to hold its shape. Its heart had shifted - not suddenly, nor by decree, but as rivers slowly alter their course until one morning the old channel stands quiet. Fíli stood surrounded by clan-lords, guildmasters, craftsmen and children bold enough to already tug at the sleeve of their new king. The Mountain had gathered naturally around him.

 

Thorin watched for one final moment, then he finally turned to leave.

 

Only Balin noticed.

 

The old dwarf stood a little apart from the greatest press of the celebration, a silver cup resting lightly in one hand. His eyes had followed Thorin almost from the moment he stepped back from the gathering, though he made no effort to detain him. When Thorin drew level with him, Balin merely regarded him with that familiar expression which had so often held patience enough for them both. 

 

For a heartbeat neither spoke.

 

Then Balin gave a small smile, scarcely more than a softening about the eyes, but filled with warmth and love.


"Go, laddie."

 

The words were quiet enough to vanish beneath the laughter and song filling the hall.

 

Thorin came to a halt.

 

It had been many years since Balin had last called him that. Long before crowns and councils. Before dragons, before exile had carved harder lines into every face they knew. The name belonged to another life, when mistakes were answered with correction instead of dire consequences, and the future still seemed wide enough that no one thought to measure it.

 

Something warm stirred unexpectedly beneath his ribs. Not grief, not quite. Home, perhaps.

 

He looked at Balin, and the old Dwarf only inclined his head, as though there were nothing more that needed saying. Thorin returned the gesture.

 

"Thank you." Thorin said quietly, and though he was not completely sure what exactly it was he was thanking Balin for, the overwhelming feeling of gratitude surging through his veins made the words come out as easy as a soft exhale.

 

Then, he turned away, and for the first time since Erebor had been reclaimed, Thorin Oakenshield left the centre of the Mountain without feeling that he had abandoned it.

⛰︎

Notes:

hope you enjoyed the erebor portion of the story <3

i can reveal so far that the story kind of consists of three different parts (this first part in erebor is the shortest part), and i'm reeeeeally excited for what i'm about to do with the second part of the story :)

hope you will enjoy it going forward!!