Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 25: ❦ Growing Things

Notes:

i have rewritten this chapter a million times, and im finally really happy with it

Chapter Text

❦

Bilbo Baggins had been engaged in a disagreement with the beans in his garden for the greater part of the morning, and by eleven o'clock it had become painfully clear that the beans were winning.

 

This was not, in and of itself, remarkable. Beans had several advantages over hobbits: they were numerous, entirely without shame, and possessed of that peculiar confidence common to growing things, which permits them to reach into places where they have not been invited and afterwards behave as though they had always belonged there. Bilbo, who had met much the same quality among goblins, dwarves, and Sackville-Bagginses, had been prepared for resistance - but he had underestimated the vivacity of the enemy.

 

"No," he said, disentangling one adventurous runner from the sugar snap peas for the second time. "You have a perfectly fine pole of your own, and there is no earthly reason for you to go bothering somebody else's."

 

The bean curled stubbornly around his finger.

 

Bilbo sighed.

 

Gardening had many advantages. Plants might be greedy, unreasonable, and forever trespassing over boundaries which had been plainly set before them, but at least they did not come to one's door expecting luncheon, nor inquire why one had not married, nor suggest that travelling east of Bree had produced some permanent weakness of the mind.

 

Bilbo had long ago discovered that being thought peculiar was not altogether an inconvenience. Indeed, once one's neighbours had abandoned hope of one's sensible behaviour, a great many liberties then became possible. One might walk at odd hours, purchase maps for no obvious reason, correspond with dwarves, and cultivate one's garden according to taste rather than whatever was thought of as fashionable that year.

 

The beans, however, remained unimpressed by his reputation.

 

Bilbo freed his finger, tucked the runner back towards its proper support, and sat upon his heels to admire the result. A small breeze travelled up the Hill and set the leaves stirring. Somewhere beyond the hedge a cart rattled along the road towards Hobbiton, and a lark sang over the fields with the tireless cheerfulness of a creature which had never been obliged to weed anything.

 

Bilbo had just reached for a length of string when a deep voice behind him spoke up.

 

"I see your foes have somewhat diminished in stature."

 

Bilbo froze.

 

"Though it appears your ferocity has not."

 

For one strange instant the morning seemed to continue without him. The bean remained between his fingers. The lark went on singing. A bee, having no understanding of dramatic occasions, buried itself industriously in the lavender by the path.

 

There are some thing which memory preserves very poorly. Faces alter in it, though one seldom catches them doing so. Rooms grow larger or smaller according to whether one longs for them. Colours fade until some chance glimpse restores them and makes one wonder how one had ever been content with the limitation.

 

Voices were no exception to that.

 

Bilbo had not thought that he had forgotten Thorin's voice. Had anyone asked, he would have said that he remembered it perfectly: deep, grave, rather too inclined to lend importance to ordinary remarks, and once accustomed to being obeyed by thirteen dwarves and one Hobbit.

 

Yet in that moment, Bilbo realized that what he had carried in memory was no more Thorin's voice than a thin brown line upon a map was a mountain. 


Slowly, he turned. 

 

Thorin Oakenshield stood beyond the garden gate, as if he physically could not open it unless invited - though that had certainly not been a problem for him at his last visit.

 

Time had been at work upon him. Bilbo noticed this first because memory had preserved him too stubbornly. His hair, already grey when Bilbo last saw him, had lightened considerably, and white ran thickly through it now as through his beard - not as snow hides a field but as summer grass pales towards harvest, changing the colour without diminishing what lies beneath. The road had browned his face and neck, and the years had deepened the lines around his eyes and mouth just subtly enough for Bilbo to take notice.

 

His sky-blue hood remained, faded somewhat and marked by travel, but there was no silver tassle. there was no gold, no heavy belt, no bright stone or chain. His clothes were good but plain, his boots dusty, and a travelling pack rested against fence next to the gate as though it had been sat there for weeks.

 

He looked neither like the dispossessed prince who had once come uninvited to Bag End, nor the King beneath the Mountain whom Bilbo had last known in Erebor - yet he looked unquestionably like himself. Like Thorin and only Thorin. The thought struck Bilbo with more force than seemed reasonable.

 

Then Thorin smiled.

 

Bilbo had seen that face proud, furious, exhausted, grief-stricken, and once terribly still. Uncomplicated happiness had never sat upon it often enough for Bilbo to grow accustomed to the sight. Apparently he remained unaccustomed to this day.

 

"Thorin." he said, but it came out more like a breath.

 

There was nothing clever to it, and that was perhaps why it was enough.

 

Bilbo got to his feet so quickly that the shears beside his knee were kicked into the thyme. He crossed the garden with considerably less dignity than one would have wished for at such a reunion, tripping over his own feet and forgetting all sensible things he might have otherwise done - brush the soil from his trousers, straighten his waistcoat, or consider whether hands black to the knuckles were fit to touch another person's clothes.

 

He fumbled only once with the latch before swinging the gate open. Welcome, perhaps. Or that it was good to see him. Or one of the dozen better sentences he had imagined at odd moments without ever admitting to himself that he was imagining them.

 

Instead, Bilbo threw his arms around the tall dwarf in front of him.

 

Thorin rocked half a pace backwards beneath the force of it, and the pack at his feet tipped against the hedge. It was then that Thorin's arms closed around Bilbo and drew him in tightly, and Bilbo discovered, with a shock almost absurd in its simplicity, that he had forgotten the physical fact of him. Memory had preserved shape without weight, had kept the breadth of Thorin's shoulders without the solidity of them, and had forgotten altogether the roughness of travelling wool beneath Bilbo's cheek and the warmth beneath that. There was dust in the cloth and the faint scents of leather, woodsmoke, and cold night air. There were very small things, but small things are often the ones which undo us.

 

Bilbo laughed softly.

 

"Oh," he said, and heard his voice crack slightly, "It is good to see you."

 

Thorin's answer came low beside his ear.

 

"And you, Master Baggins."

 

They remained like that for a while, and neither seemed in any hurry to be the first to alter it. Bilbo had thrown himself into the embrace and therefore, after what he thought a respectable interval, began to loosen his arms.

 

Thorin did not.

 

Bilbo stopped.

 

Thorin held him a moment longer, then tightened his arms once and drew a deep breath, letting it out slowly above Bilbo's head.

 

That was all - there was no great declaration in it, no gesture large enough to be noticed from the road, and yet the breath carried such weariness and such relief together that Bilbo's smile faded. He did not ask what it meant. He merely rested his cheek against Thorin's shoulder once more and let him have the moment. The garden rustled behind them. A bird called somewhere in the hedge. The ordinary morning went on around two people for whom, just then, very little felt ordinary.


At last Thorin released him, and Bilbo stepped back. For the first time they properly looked at one another from an arm's length, and something about that was almost more exposing than the embrace had been. Bilbo became aware of the earth upon his knees, the uneven roll of his sleeves, and a leaf caught against his waistcoat. Thorin's gaze moved over him with the peculiar attention of someone comparing a remembered place with the country itself, then returned to his face.

 

"You are well?" Bilbo asked.

 

"I am."

 

"Truly?"

 

Thorin's expression softened.

 

"Truly."

 

"Good." Bilbo answered with a nod.

 

The answer came more quietly than he intended, and for a moment he had nothing else. There were years behind them, well over half a decade in fact. Years in which one life had gone beneath stone and another beneath a green Hill. Yet with Thorin standing before him, none of that vanished. It simply ceased to be the most important thing in the garden.

 

Thorin looked at him in turn.


"And you?" he asked.

 

"I am well." Bilbo said and found, with some surprise, that he meant it. "Not entirely improved, but well enough."

 

Thorin smiled again, and Bilbo felt the old ease stir between them, not yet as quick or sharp as it had once been, but alive and well nonetheless.

 

"You look well." Thorin said.

 

"So do you." Bilbo began and realized that honesty, once begun, proved troublesome to stop. "Better than I expected, in fact."

 

"I am uncertain whether that is meant as praise or insult." Thorin's brows rose slightly.

 

"It was meant as praise."

 

"Then I thank you, my friend."

 

Bilbo looked at his hair again and immediately wished he had not. There was more white in it than he had first thought, and the morning sun seemed particularly fond of those strands, catching upon them whenever Thorin moved his head. Bilbo had known Thorin handsome once. No, handsome was too tidy a word, suitable for young Tooks at weddings or polished portraits in respectable halls. Thorin had always seemed made of something rougher. Striking, perhaps. Severe. Magnificent on occasion. Beautiful once or twice, though Bilbo had always found that word embarrassing even in private. Nearly seven years had not cured the problem, though this was a realization that Bilbo quickly decided to place firmly aside.

 

Thorin had turned towards the Hill.

 

"I had forgotten how green it is."

 

Bilbo followed his gaze. The Shire lay around them in its late summer abundance, hedges thick with leaf, fields folding one into another in long gentle slopes, trees standing dark where the road dipped and vanished between them. Green was so common here that most hobbits scarcely thought it remarkable, it belonged to the land in the same way roofs belonged to houses and smoke to chimneys.

 

"I suppose you might." Bilbo said. "There is rather a lot of it."

 

Thorin smiled faintly, but his gaze remained upon the fields.

 

"It is beautiful."

 

Bilbo looked at him.

 

There was no politeness in the words. Thorin did not say it because he stood in Bilbo's garden and thought his host might be pleased. He seemed, for the moment, to have forgotten Bilbo was watching him at all.

 

"Yes," Bilbo said after a while. "It is."

 

He loved the Shire. That had never ceased to be true, though others often seemed to think his affection must have been broken by the same journey that had broken his reputation. The trouble was only that the Shire had once seemed large enough to contain everything worth knowing, and Bilbo could no longer pretend this was so. He had seen mountains and great rivers, forests that swallowed the daylight, cities of Men and halls of Elves. He had discovered that a home might remain beloved after ceasing to be the whole world. At times this had troubled him, but now it seemed merely true.

 

Thorin's gaze came back towards the garden. His eyes travelled over the beds, taking in the cabbages, the roses, and the herbs that had been allowed to crowd rather too freely against the path. He did not merely glance over them, as Bilbo had half expected him to do, but looked with the same grave attention he might once have given a map laid out before the Company. Presently he stepped nearer the low border and bent to examine the rosemary, whose woody stems had grown thick with age and were spilling untidily over the stone.

 

Bilbo watched him pinch one narrow leaf between finger and thumb and rub it absently before lifting his hand to catch the scent. It was a small movement, and there was no earthly reason why Bilbo should have attended it so closely. Yet he found himself noticing the brown of Thorin's fingers against the pale green leaves, the little scars that crossed his knuckles, and the silver-white fall of his hair when he bent his head. The latter had escaped somewhat from beneath the blue hood and lay across his shoulder in a fashion Bilbo found unacceptably distracting.

 

He looked at the rosemary instead.

 

"You have done well with your garden." Thorin said.

 

It was a simple compliment, but Bilbo was absurdly pleased by it. There had been a time, he thought, when Thorin could scarcely have stood still long enough to notice a garden. Not because he had been blind to beautiful things, Bilbo knew better than that, but because there had always been something beyond the thing before him - another road to walk, another task unfinished, a Mountain drawing every thought eastward as surely as the moon draws the tide. Even in rest there had been purpose in him, and purpose had sat heavily upon Thorin in those days.

 

Now there was nothing at all to prevent him from spending a late summer morning smelling rosemary.

 

"Thank you." Bilbo replied before glancing towards the beans, one of which had already begun undoing his. morning's work. "Though I would reserve judgement until you have been properly acquainted with everything."

 

Thorin straightened and followed his gaze.

 

"They appear healthy."

 

"They are insubordinate."

 

The corner of Thorin's mouth moved, and a flicker of mischief appeared in his eyes.

 

"They learnt from the best."

 

"You have been here scarcely long enough to insult me." Bilbo stated and tried to give Thorin a stern look, though it was difficult to put much severity into it when Thorin was plainly pleased with himself.

 

"I did not insult you."

 

"You compared me to a bean."

 

"A healthy bean."

 

Bilbo made a sound of disgust and turned away, but not before he caught Thorin smiling. There were deeper lines around his eyes when he did that now. Bilbo had noticed them at the gate. Now he noticed them again, and something small and warm turned beneath his ribs before he could prevent it.

 

It was the reunion, he decided. One could hardly be expected to meet an old and dearly missed friend after so long and remain entirely unmoved by it.

 

This explanation seemed satisfactory enough, provided he did not examine it too closely.

 

Bilbo looked down at his boots only to notice the dust upon Thorin's boots and the great pack still resting against the fence.

 

"You must be weary," he said, turning towards it. "Here, allow me-"

 

"Do not strain yourself on my behalf, friend." 

 

"You have carried it far enough." Bilbo insisted, looking back up at Thorin.

 

"I am quite able to carry it a few steps further."

 

"And I am quite able to help." Bilbo stated stubbornly.

 

He seized the strap before Thorin could object further. The pack scarcely moved.

 

Behind him, Thorin said nothing, though this silence had. a quality to it.

 

Bilbo planted his feet more firmly and tried again. The pack rose perhaps the height of his hand before its weight dragged his shoulder down with it, and he was obliged to let it fall. Something inside struck something else with a heavy metallic knock.

 

"What on earth have you got in there?" He asked as he slowly straightened himself, attempting to regain some level of dignity.

 

"My belongings."

 

"Your belongings appear to have been quarried."

 

Thorin had folded his arms, and there was an expression upon his face which Bilbo knew perfectly well and did not care for in the least. Thorin's mouth twitched once more, in that way that made Bilbo's neck suspiciously heat up.

 

"Do not." Bilbo said with a frown, pointing warningly at the dwarf.

 

"I said nothing."

 

"You needn't."

 

Bilbo rubbed his shoulder and looked suspiciously at the pack. He had travelled with dwarves long enough to recognize the sound of metal that had no business being carried over several hundred leagues by a person claiming to have abandoned al unnecessary burdens.

 

His eyes narrowed.

 

"Thorin."

 

"Yes?"

 

"Are those tools?"

 

There was a pause so small that it amounted to confession.

 

"A few."

 

Bilbo stared blankly at him, then crouched again and pushed experimentally against the side of the pack. Something broad and solid resisted beneath the leather.

 

"You have carried smithing tools on your back?"

 

"Only those I wished to keep."

 

"Across half the world?"

 

"Yes."

 

There was not the least embarrassment int Thorin's face. If anything, he appeared faintly puzzled that the matter required discussion.

 

Bilbo stood and looked from him to the pack and back again.

 

"You left an entire kingdom behind" Bilbo said at last, "but apparently your favourite hammer was beyond sacrifice."

 

"It is an excellent hammer."

 

That did it.

 

Bilbo laughed out loud, he could not help it. The laugh came out whole and helpless, and the more affronted Thorin attempted to look, the worse it became. There was something wonderfully reassuring in the discovery. Thorin had changed - Bilbo could see that everywhere he looked. The change was written in the ease of his shoulders and the patience with which he had approached, in the plain clothes and the absence of gold, even in the quiet pleasure with which he had looked across the shire. Yet beneath all of it remained a dwarf who might abandon a throne more readily than a tool he considered well made.

 

Time had altered him without replacing him.

 

Perhaps Thorin understood what Bilbo found so funny, for his injured dignity lasted only a little while before it cracked. His own laughter joined Bilbo's, deep and warm in the bright garden, and something which had remained careful between them since the gate loosened at last.

 

"I am glad." Bilbo finally said, wiping at one eye.

 

"About the hammer?" Thorin, whose laughter had at last faded into a smile, asked.

 

"No." the answer slipped out of Bilbo before he had the chance to dress it in anything lighter.

 

Thorin looked at him.

 

Bilbo felt suddenly foolish, but he did not take it back. There was soil beneath his nails, Thorin's absurdly heavy pack at his feet, and a bean somewhere behind them undoing everything Bilbo had accomplished that morning- It seemed a poor setting for solemn declarations, which perhaps made honesty a little easier.

 

"I am glad you came."

 

Something changed in Thorin's face. It was not surprise exactly. The smile simply quieted, and the amusement in his eyes gave way to an affection so open that Bilbo felt it physically like the sensation of stepping unexpectedly from shade into sun.

 

"So am I." Thorin said.

 

There it was again - that traitorous movement beneath Bilbo's ribs.

 

Only this time it did not pass at once. His heart seemed to strike too hard against his chest, and warmth rose beneath his collar despite the breeze coming over the Hill. For a moment nothing existed but the way Thorin was looking at him.

 

When he managed to snap out of it, he turned towards Bag End.

 

'Food', he thought. 'Food is sensible.'

 

There was a traveller in his garden who had come a very long way, and Bilbo was standing about staring at him when any properly raised hobbit ought already to have put a kettle on.

 

"Well," he said, brushing the soil from his palms with rather more attention than was necessary. "Whatever you have been calling meals upon the road, I refuse to believe they would satisfy anybody with a proper pantry."

 

"I ate this morning."

 

"How many hours ago?"

 

"Not so many."

 

Bilbo narrowed his eyes and looked at the dwarf.

 

"Very well" Thorin surrendered with remarkably little resistance.

 

"Good. There is bread, and cheese, and I believe some cold turkey left from yesterday. Unless you have developed an objection to proper eating while travelling?"

 

"I have developed no such thing."

 

"I thought not."

 

Bilbo instinctively bent towards the pack, remembered its contents, and thought better of it. 

 

Thorin noticed, and this time he actually did laugh.

 

"Oh, carry your precious hammer yourself." Bilbo said, and went to retrieve the shears he had abandoned among the thyme. 

 

Behind him came the quiet shift of leather and metal as Thorin lifted the pack. When Bilbo turned again, Thorin had settled it over one shoulder and was waiting for him.

 

For an instant Bilbo simply looked.

 

It was a strangely ordinary sight. Thorin stood inside his garden gate, beneath the green branches of an apple tree, with a faded blue hood upon whitening hair and a travelling pack slung over one shoulder. No crown marked him. No Company gathered at his back. No song had foretold his comign, and no purpose greater than luncheon waited beyond the round door of Bag End.

 

Bilbo had never seen him look so little like a king. He had never, perhaps, seen Thorin the Dwarf look so entirely himself.

 

"Come along, then." Bilbo said, and they started up the path together.

 

The path from the gate to the door was not long. Bilbo had walked it so often that his feet knew every stone without assistance from his eyes - where the thyme had crept into the cracks, where one slab had sunk slightly at the edge, where rainwater would gather after a storm before slipping away into the grass. Yet he found himself walking more slowly than usual, and after several paces Thorin moved a little ahead of him.

 

That was when Bilbo made the mistake of looking again.

 

The blue hood passed beneath the low branch of the apple tree. Thorin ducked his head without seeming to notice that he had done so, and the movement brought one hand up to steady the pack upon his shoulder. Bilbo's eyes followed it - the broad hand upon the strap, the strength in the wrist, the white and iron-grey of his hair bright against the summer green - and something in him tightened with such sudden familiarity that he stopped.

 

It was not the first time that morning, and the realization came upon him rather unpleasantly. There had been the gate, and the warmth of Thorin's body when he had held Bilbo longer than Bilbo expected. There had been the sunlight in his hair, the lines around his eyes when he laughed, the ridiculous heat in Bilbo's neck when Thorin had nearly smiled at him over the pack. 

 

And now this.

 

Bilbo stood halfway up his own garden path with shears in one hand and watched Thorin waslk towards his front doot.

 

Distance, he thought suddenly, had been a very useful thing.

 

It had a habit of softening what it held. A person became memory. Memory, with time, became something that might be carried quietly. Even when the letters had begun again and Thorin had returned to Bilbo's days by way of ink and paper, there had remained forests and rivers and mountains between them. Bilbo might read a couple of times, or smile over it at breakfast, or think rather longer than necessary about some sentence before folding the page and putting it away.

 

Paper had edges and could be folded. A letter did not stand in one's garden laughing.

 

It did not smell of leather and woodsmoke when it embraced you. It did not grow more silver in the hair and, most unfairly, become more pleasing for it. It did not stand close enough that one could see the little scars upon its hands.

 

Bilbo had made his peace with loving Thorin long ago. He had thought the feeling would pass one day, and when it did not, he had eventually ceased demanding that it should. There was no shame in loving a friend more deeply than that friend could answer in kind, provide one did not turn affection into a debt. Thorin had given Bilbo a friendship dearer than most things in his life. Bilbo had learned to take it for what it was and ask for nothing beyond it.

 

He had become very sensible about the matter.

 

Standing in the garden, Bilbo began to suspect that sensibility had received rather more assistance from geography than he had previously acknowledged. 

 

Thorin reached the top of the path.

 

The round green door stood before him. For a moment he looked at it, and Bilbo wondered what he saw - whether he remembered the first time he had crossed that threshold with twelve other dwarves already inside and an adventure already gathering, or whether the door was only a door to him now, green and round and presently standing betweem him and luncheon.

 

Then Thorin turned.

 

"Bilbo?"

 

Bilbo had not moved.

 

There was no suspicion in Thorin's face, only a mild quesition.

 

"Yes," Bilbo replied, perhaps a bit too quickly. "Coming."

 

He started up the path.

 

There were winters which loosened their hold slowly. Rain came, and then frost returned - patches of old snow survived in the hollows long after the fields had begun to soften, and one might watch spring approaching for weeks without being able to name the morning upon which it arrived. Other winters seemed to end all at once. One looked away from the earth for a little while and, upon looking back, discovered green shoots where yesterday there had apparently been none.

 

Bilbo had thought this particular patch of ground safely dormant. Not dead, never dead. He had known better than that. Only quiet, and he had perhaps mistaken quiet for obedience.

 

By the time he reached the door, Thorin had stepped aside to let him pass. Bilbo went beneath his arms and into Bag End, acutely aware of the dwarf standing close beside him and determined not to be aware of it at all.

 

He would manage, of course he would.

 

Behind them, in the garden, the bean Bilbo had tied twice that morning had already stretched once more towards the neighbouring pole. It had been given perfectly clear instructions. 

 

Growing things, unfortunately, had never cared much for those.

❦