Actions

Work Header

Westward

Chapter 26: ❦ Tea After Supper

Notes:

thank you for all of your kind comments, i am putting a ridiculous amount of time and effort into these last chapters to make sure they are absolutely perfect, and the support really motivates me!

Chapter Text

❦

The remains of supper had disappeared some hours ago, but the remains of what Bilbo had firmly maintained was not a second supper still occupied one end of the kitchen table.

 

Supper was supper, while the bread and cheese brought out several hours later belonged to that broad and respectable category of food which existed simply because one happened to still be awake - but Thorin, who had watched Bilbo disappear into the pantry after declaring that neither of them could possibly want another thing, had greeted his return with an expression of such quiet amusement that Bilbo had nearly taken the plate back again.

 

He had not, of course. There were principles involved.

 

Thorin had been at Bag End only a few days, and there was as of yet none of the blind ease that comes when two people have shared rooms long enough to know which board creaks beneath the other's foot and which cup he reaches for without thinking. Thorin still asked where things belonged before putting them away. Bilbo occasionally opened a cupboard and remembered, with a small start, that a dwarf slept in the room at the end of the passage.

 

Yet some of the formality had begun to wear thin around the edges. Not enough to be called habit, only enough that neither now seemed compelled to fill every silence.

 

Perhaps it was the hour. Bilbo had always thought there was something dangerous about kitchens after midnight. Parlours expected good behaviours, drawing-rooms expected conversation to sit upright. Kitchens, once the dishes had been pushed aside and the fire had settled itself for the night, had no such ambitions. Words loosened there. One might say a thing across a kitchen table which would never have survived the journey to a writing-desk.

 

Thorin sat opposite him with one arm resting upon the table, and Bilbo had been trying for the better part of an hour not to find this distracting.

 

He was failing.

 

It was not Thorin's fault. Indeed, Thorin seemed entirely unaware that he had committed any offence. His boots and travelling clothes had been abandoned for the evening, leaving him in a dark tunic loose at the throat and plain trousers, with a pair of slippers Bilbo had unearthed from a cupboard after some searching. They were fractionally too large and should have made him ridiculous.

 

They did not.

 

His beard remained long and proud, because apparently civilisation had certain boundaries even in Bag End. His hair had fared less well. He had twisted it behind his head into a rough knot which had begun the evening respectably enough and had since yielded several pale strands about his temples and neck. In the lamplight the white among the grey caught gold at the edges, like frost upon grass when morning first touches it.

 

Bilbo had known Thorin in armor. He had known him soaked through on the road, half starved beneath Mirkwood, dishevelled after imprisonment, and dressed in all the heavy dignity of Erebor.

 

He had not known him in slippers, and there was something deeply unreasonable about discovering that this was worse.

 

Bilbo raised his cup, found it empty, and set it down again.

 

"You did not even bring a handkerchief." Thorin said from across the table, with the air of a man producing evidence long kept in reserve.

 

"I had hoped that, after all these years, you might have found some more flattering detail of my conduct to preserve." Bilbo muttered as he looked over the rim of his cup at the dwarf in front of him.

 

Thorin's eyes had that dark, amused gleam which Bilbo remembered from rare evenings upon the road.

 

"You have forgotten?"

 

"Certainly not. I was merely wondering why you had chosen to resurrect one of the less dignified moments of my life at this hour."

 

"One of them?" Thorin continued, and there was such satisfaction in the recollection of the moment that Bilbo could not even pretend to be offended for that long.

 

Looking backwards, the beginning of the Quest had acquired a ridiculous innocence. There had ben Bilbo Baggins tearing down the lane towards Bywater with no hat, no proper breakfast, and not even a handkerchief, while thirteen dwarves waited impatiently upon ponies for the burglar who was supposed to help them rob a dragon. Nobody would have believed, seeing him then, that before the journey ended he would speak with Smaug beneath the Mountain, walk unseen through an elven fortress, and stand between armies with the fate of kingdoms tangled in his hands.

 

"I don't suppose I made a very impressive sight." Bilbo admitted.

 

"No." Thorin said at once.

 

"There is gratitude." Bilbo said as he looked up in mock outrage.

 

"You did not look like a burglar."

 

"I did not feel like a burglar."

 

"That was abundantly clear."

 

Bilbo reached for the teapot, more for something to do than from thirst.

 

"And yet Gandalf chose me."

 

"I thought he had lost his senses entirely."

 

"On that point we were agreed."

 

A small smile moved beneath Thorin's beard.

 

"I thought you soft."

 

Bilbo's fingers paused around the pot.

 

There was no insult in the words now. Thorin spoke of the old judgement almost as one might speak of an error in an old map - something plainly there, and plainly wrong.


"And were you very disappointed," Bilbo asked, "when I stubbornly refused to become sensible enough to prove you right?"

 

"Frequently" Thorin said, his smile deepening.

 

This startled a laugh from Bilbo. Thorin joined him, and the sound warmed the room more effectively than the fire had managed for some time.

 

For a little while they remembered the Quest in that fashion - not as songs remember things, all banners and battles and great deeds, but as travellers remember roads after the rain has dried from their cloaks. They argued mildly over whether Bilbo had truly been as miserable during those first days as Thorin remembered him, and Bilbo maintained that his misery had been both reasonable and dignified.

 

"You wished to turn back." Thorin said. 

 

"Repeatedly."

 

"You complained of the food."

 

"There was very little of it."

 

"You complained of the weather."

 

"Travelling in the rain instead of waiting out the storm is entirely unreasonable."

 

"You complained of us."

 

Bilbo regarded him over his cup.

 

"At last, something no one can dispute."

 

Thorin laughed, and Bilbo found himself looking at him again.

 

He had forgotten, or deliberately ceased remembering, what laughter did to Thorin's face. The new lines around his eyes deepened, severity did not vanish so much as open the way a dark hedge suddenly shows birds and blossoms when sunlight falls through it. 

 

"You did improve rather alarmingly." Thorin said. "By the time we reached the Mountain you had stolen keys from the Elvenking, escaped his halls, faced Smaug alone, and stolen from beneath my nose."

 

The amusement vanished from Thorin's face almost as soon as the words had left him.

 

Bilbo's thumb tightened against the handle of his cup.

 

Then Thorin began, carefully.

 

"The Arkenstone-"

 

Bilbo moved.

 

It was no more than the reaching of a hand towards the teapot, but it happened so quickly that the cup beside it knocked faintly against its sauceer.

 

The sound was tiny, yet in the hush of the kitchen it seemed enormous. 

 

For one treacherous instant the room beneath the Hill fell away, and another room rose in its place - vast, cold and glittering. Treasure lay beneath torchlight like frozen fire. Thorin's voice, stripped of everything Bilbo knew in it, rang against stone. There was a hand upon him - too hard - and behind him nothing but air and distance and the terrible knowledge that love could stand before you wearing the face of fury and not know you at all.

 

Bilbo's stomach drew tight.

 

The memory came with no order to it. Not a scene, only pieces - gold-light, stone beneath his feet, Thorin's eyes burning like lamps seen through smoke, the word traitor made larger by the kingdom around them.

 

He set the teapot down with care. Too much care.

 

"Well," he said, and heard the brightness in his own voice, "I did more or less steal the trolls' key."

 

Thorin went still, and Bilbo was afraid to look at him.

 

"The wood-elves' keys as well, come to that. So I think we may safely say my professional reputation improved after all."

 

"Bilbo."

 

"And there was the cup from Smaug, although I suppose that can hardly be called theft when one has specifically been hired to-"

 

"Bilbo."

 

The second time his name was quieter.

 

"I have not forgotten what I did to you." Thorin said.

 

There was no drama in the words, and perhaps that was what made them heavier. They settled over the table like the first frost upon a garden, silencing things which had been alive a moment before.

 

Bilbo's fingers curled once against the wood. He knew Thorin remembered, and that was precisely why he did not wish to speak of it.

 

Not here, with the smell of bread still in the room and Thorin sitting opposite him in a loose tunic, his hair falling out of its knot. Not tonight, when the Mountain was far away and Bag End was warm around them. Bilbo had no desire to draw that old darkness through the round door merely because they had happened to stumble across its name.

 

He had forgiven more than he had forgotten, which was a distinction he preferred not to examine too closely.

 

"Thorin." he said.

 

Thorin's face was very still now. Guilt had begun to gather there with terrible familiarity, like storm-clouds piling beyond a green horizon.

 

"No." Bilbo said, more firmly than before. "I know you have not forgotten it, and I am not asking you to. But I have no wish to lay that particular memory upon the table between the bread and the teapot tonight."

 

Thorin regarded him for a moment.

 

"You have the right to speak of it whenever you choose." he then said.

 

"Precisely. And tonight I choose not to."

 

A pause followed. Thorin regarded him for a long moment, and Bilbo forced himself not to glance away, though every instinct urged him towards the kettle, the cupboard, anything small and ordinary that might close the door again.

 

At last Thorin inclined his head.

 

"Very well."

 

Relief moved through Bilbo so swiftly that it almost hurt, so he stood at once.

 

"The tea is cold."

 

It was a transparent excuse, and both of them knew it. Thorin, to his credit, let it stand.

 

Bilbo carried the pot to the stove and occupied himself with water and flame. His hands were steady. He was pleased by that. The little domestic motions came easy - fill the kettle, set it down, find the fresh leaves. Behind him Thorin remained quiet.

 

Bilbo could feel the silence like a hand between his shoulder-blades.

 

Then, after enough time had passed for the kettle to begin its low murmur, Thorin spoke again.

 

"Did you steal anything else?"

 

Instinctively, Bilbo's hand was drawn to his pocket where the ring he found during the Quest resided. It was pure habit, a calming gesture, that Bilbo himself did not even notice he did as he looked over his shoulder.

 

The faintest smile had returned to Thorin's face, and Bilbo understood the kindness in it.

 

"Several meals, if you ask Bombur."

 

"Those were communal provisions."

 

"Try explaining that to Bombur."

 

And so the Mountain was put away again - not erased, not forgiven into nonexistence, but merely returned to the locked room where both of them kept certain memories until another day.

 

When Bilbo returned with fresh tea, the conversation found lighter ground. They spoke of the journey not as a history but as one remembers an old road in company - stopping where the recollection pleased them and passing quickly over what did not. Bilbo recalled the first night at Bag End and the ruinous enthusiasm with which the dwarves had attacked his pantry.

 

Their laughter returned slowly, then easily, like birds venturing back into a garden after a sudden noise had scared them off.

 

By the time the second pot of tea had cooled, the kitchen had grown sleepy around them. The lamp burned lower, throwing longer shadows across the table, and the fire had sunk into a red glow scarcely brighter than apples beneath autumn leaves.

 

Bilbo had stopped pretending not to look at Thorin.

 

Bilbo had known Thorin crowned. He had known him armed. He had known him dressed for court and dressed for the road. He had never known what Thorin looked like at the end of an ordinary evening when there was nowhere to go afterward but bed. There was something startlingly intimate in seeing him so reduced in splendour and so entirely undiminished by it.

 

That ought not to have mattered, yet it mattered enormously.

 

Bilbo became aware that he was watching the line of Thorin's forearm where the tunic sleeve had been pushed back, the tendons shifting beneath weathered skin as he turned his cup. His attention travelled upward, caught briefly upon the loose hair at Thorin's neck, and was approaching territory Bilbo had no intention of exploring when Thorin glanced up.

 

Bilbo looked at the breadboard.

 

The breadboard had proved a loyal friend that evening.

 

At last Thorin glanced towards the clock.

 

His brows rose, causing Bilbo to follow his gaze and discover that the evening had disappeared entirely.

 

"I should sleep." Thorin said.

 

He stretched the stiffness from his shoulders, raising both arms for a moment. The loose tunic pulled across his chest and waist before falling again.

 

Bilbo's gaze dropped with such determination that it landed upon the abandoned cheese rind. He studied it. There was probably much to be learned from cheese.

 

"Yes," Bilbo replied, contemplating the rind. "You should."

 

Thorin rose from his chair then walked around the table.

 

Bilbo assumed he meant to collect his cup. 

 

Instead the soft scrape of slippers stopped beside his chair, so he looked up.

 

Thorin stood close enough that Bilbo had to tilt his head back. The lamplight had softened him strangely. His face was tired, though not with the old exhaustion Bilbo remembered from the road - this was only the weariness of a late hour after food and warmth and conversation. Silver hair had escaped almost completely around his face, and his eyes in the low light seemed brighter than usual, shining beneath his brows like an owl's caught among moonlit branches.

 

"Goodnight, Bilbo."

 

Without hesitation, Thorin lifted one hand. His palm settled against the back of Bilbo's head, broad and warm, fingers curving lightly where Bilbo's hair met the nape of his neck. It was a simple gesture, so natural in its affection that Bilbo had no time to contemplate it before Thorin bent.

 

Then Thorin kissed the crown of his head.

 

Bilbo's breath caught as if the world seemed to narrow to that single point of warmth.

 

The kiss itself was brief and innocent, almost familial in its tenderness like a parent would say goodnight to their child without thought.

 

Bilbo's body, however, received it as though struck by summer lightning.

 

He felt heat spread down the back of his neck beneath Thorin's hand. His heart gave one violent leap, then another, until it seemed less like a heart than a trapped bird beating itself against his ribs. Every sense sharpened absurdly - the warmth of Thorin's palm, the faint scratch of beard against hair, leather and soap and the dying fire.

 

Then the hand was gone, and Thorin straightened.

 

He left the kitchen, while Bilbo remained where he was.

 

Bilbo heard the soft shuffle of slippers receding into the passage, and for several seconds he could do nothing but sit with both hands flat upon the table and wait for his body to remember that absolutely nothing extraordinary had occurred. It refused.

 

Thorin had kissed his head, that was all.

 

A gesture of affection. A warm, innocent thing. Parents kissed children so, old friends might, kin often did. There was no reason whatsoever for Bilboto sit there with his breath shortened and every nerve in his neck apparently convinced that something catastrophic had happened.

 

The kitchen, mercifully, offered no judgement.

 

He remained until his heartbeat had begun to resemble something ordinarily found inside a hobbit rather than a frightened animal. Then he stood. The dishes could wait. The lamp could be put out. Morning would restore proportion to things as mornings often did.

 

Bilbo extinguished the light and stepped into the passage. The dark there was gentler, broken only by the small lamp left burning near the bedrooms. The cool air touched his face and seemed, for a moment, to clear it.

 

Then he heard the breathing.

 

Bilbo stopped, as he first thought it came from his own chest.

 

Then another breath sounded around the bend ahead - deep, ragged, pulled in too sharply, followed almost at once by another.

 

The warmth left Bilbo's skin in an instant.

 

"Thorin?"

 

No answer, so Bilbo went forward and rounded the corner.

 

Thorin stood with his back pressed against the wall, and for one terrible instant Bilbo thought he was dying.

 

The change was so complete that the kitchen seemed impossibly far away. Thorin's head rested against the wood behind him, eyes fixed somewhere beyond the passage as though he saw not Bag End at all but some sight invisible to Hobbits. One hand was spread against the wall while the other had closed in the fabric of his tunic over his chest.

 

His breathing came hard enough that Bilbo could see it shake him.

 

"Thorin."

 

This time, Thorin jerked violently and his eyes snapped to Bilbo.

 

Thorin simply looked at him, but the look changed as it rested there. His breath faltered. The colour already high in his face deepened. His eyes dropped for the smallest fraction of a moment - perhaps to Bilbo's shoulder, perhaps nowhere at all - and then returned to his face with such abruptness that Bilbo wondered whether he had imagined it.

 

Then, Thorin smiled as he pushed away from the wall and instead placed one hand on Bilbo's shoulder from a respectable distance.

 

"Goodnight, Bilbo."

 

The words were quieter than before.

 

Bilbo felt something odd move through him, though whether concern or confusion or the lingering wreckage of the kitchen he could not have said.

 

"Goodnight." He responded.

 

With that, Thorin let go of Bilbo's shoulder and turned towards the guest bedroom. His first step was steady, and so was the second. By the time he reached the guest-room door, nothing in his gait would have betrayed what Bilbo had just seen.

 

When the door closed softly behind Thorin, the passage became very still.

 

Bilbo remained where he was, looking at the shut door and listening to the silence settle over Bag End once more. It came slowly, like mist filling a hollow after sunset, obscuring first the edges and then the shapes of things until one could no longer be quite certain what had been seen.

 

He did not know what had happened, and was reluctant to attempt at naming it.

 

There had already been enough naming things for one evening.

❦