Chapter Text
Bilbo slept for two weeks. His dwarves poured broth down his throat at intervals, Gandalf’s magic supported him, and permission was grudgingly given to the elves to assist. But Bilbo did not know that until later.
He knew he woke in darkness. He felt warm. His nose was buried in the folds of what smelled like his musty eiderdown. Since orcs did not have eiderdowns, and the men’s homes along with their beds had all burned, and he could not imagine elves allowing their bed linens to ever become musty, he deduced he must be at Erebor. He was resting in a proper bed. He saw the low glow of fire coals in a hearth. Feeling leadened aching muscles, he struggled and failed to shift himself upright.
A noise. Bilbo was not alone.
“Kíli?” he rasped.
“No. Not Kíli.”
His heart lurched. For a time, his breath did not come easily. He desperately struggled to release his weakened arms from beneath his bedding because everything within him yearned to embrace his dwarf.
Thorin gently wrapped a strong arm around his shoulders and lifted him. It was not an embrace. It was careful steadying of a weakened body as he raised water to sickbed-parched lips.
Bilbo drank deeply, and his relief was immense even though swallowing felt uncomfortable. He stared at him above the rim of his cup, and Thorin resolutely refused to return his gaze. He stared at him gently tucking the blankets around him. He stared after him when he left.
Bilbo must be dead. He concluded he must be dead (escape from a battle so far outnumbered by orcs was impossible), but he could not account for the presence of a hobbit in the dwarves’ Halls of Waiting, because this stone chamber certainly did not belong to Yavanna’s Gardens. Perhaps Yavanna and her husband recognized he would never be happy there.
Thorin returned with warm broth slightly thickened with something vegetable and tasting medicinal. Again securely tucking his arm beneath Bilbo, he helped him slowly drink.
Between swallows, Bilbo severely revised his assumptions and observed, “You are alive.”
Thorin finally met his eyes. “I am.”
“How?”
“You understand how far better than I do.”
“Out on the ice, I kept calling for you and calling for you, but you never came.”
He looked a little guilty. “My brother, Frerin, punched me in the nose. He told me to make amends and not excuses.”
A slow smile lifted the corners of Bilbo’s lips. “I like your brother. He’s sensible.”
He scoffed incredulously, but the noise was fond.
Bilbo swallowed the last of his broth. Thorin set the cup aside and made to reposition him upon the bed to rest alone, but Bilbo did not fight this hard only to relinquish all so easily. He weakly knotted his hand in Thorin’s tunic and clung to his ribs.
With a wary look, Thorin silently capitulated. He settled himself upon the bed with Bilbo reclining in his arms.
“In that matter, I agree Frerin was the sensible one.”
Thorin’s voice rumbled in his chest where Bilbo had pressed his ear.
“He made me return at your call. By the time I regained my wits, you were gone, and I felt so weak I could barely crawl. Beorn found me. He carried me to the Mountain.”
He lifted his head. “Kíli? Fíli? I saw Glóin, and Nori and Ori—?”
“All live. The Company are all well.”
A great tension seizing Bilbo’s shoulders for all this time finally relaxed. His relief was so sudden, he practically felt woozy. He pillowed his curls against Thorin’s chest again and greedily drew comfort from the steady hammer of his heartbeat and the slow bellows of his lungs.
“Every one of the Company acquitted himself well. Fíli, in fact, earned his battle name.”
“He did?”
Bilbo rattled his memory for what grand thing Fíli had done to earn such an accolade, knowing dwarves never awarded the honor frivolously. Granted, he hadn’t a view of every part of the battlefield, but he didn’t know of any mighty struggle Fíli had opportunity to fight.
Thorin must have recognized his puzzlement, because he said, “It happened after—after you parted ways.”
Affronted, Bilbo exclaimed, “I sent him after Dwalin!”
“He went to Dwalin,” replied Thorin calmly.
“And?”
“And he saw the battle faring poorly. He made Dwalin catch a battle ram that lost its rider. He tied himself into the saddle.”
“Oh, that blasted dwarf!”
“Dáin had been struck down—he yet lives and will recover—but he was struck down. The orcs pressed the advantage. But Fíli arrived and rallied both dwarves and men. He inspired them to stand, and he fought as boldly as Durin himself.”
His voice warmed, and Bilbo thought to himself how it was very like Thorin to boast of his nephew’s deeds, but not so much as mention his own battle that slew Azog.
“I’m told it was as if the orcs were dashing themselves against a wall. Fíli did not yield. He would not move.”
“Let’s have it then. What is he now called? His ‘battle name’?”
“Fíli the Well-Seated.”
Gobsmacked, Bilbo stared. “Fíli the Well-Seated?”
“It sounds more grand in Khuzdul.”
“We’ll have to work on that Westron, then.” He suggested, “Fíli the Unmoved?”
Thorin winced. “Mm, it sounds very bad in Khuzdul.”
“Hm. I’ll think on it.”
(Invented by clever Ori some days later, the prince’s battle name he wore all his life was Fíli Holdfast.)
“I owe both the lives of my sister-sons to you,” said Thorin quietly.
Bilbo narrowed his eyes.
“Beg pardon.” He revised, “You gifted us the lives of my sister-sons… several times.”
“They’re young. They deserve good gifts.”
His voice grew rough. “I am inexpressibly grateful for such gifts. I treasure your gifts beyond all others.”
“You’re welcome, Thorin. I’m happy to give.”
Thorin’s face darkened. “I am ashamed. I am the burglar. I stole that which is most precious when it was not freely given.”
“What in all Arda are you talking about?”
“I threatened you. I raised my hand to you. I cursed your name and banished you. How could you then possibly grant my life as a gift?” He shook his head, guilt clouding his features. “I coerced you, just like one of the old kings of an earlier age. In my madness, I told you I would, and I did.”
The memory of it was a cold flutter in Bilbo’s gut, but it passed as a shiver and was gone.
Bilbo said slowly, “I confess, hearing you talk to the others about ‘the halfling’ like I was your possession you intended to keep!—well, it hurt me a great deal. It was then I understood you were wholly lost to gold-sickness.”
Thorin’s voice was hushed and ashamed. “That night in the treasury when you begged me to abandon my search for the Arkenstone and find rest, I stole kisses that were never mine.”
Bilbo turned his head away. “I didn’t like that much, either.”
He could hear Thorin’s heart beating as if he were sprinting for his life and not lying quietly on a bed with his words trembling in his throat.
“I used you most terribly. I do not deserve your friendship, your regard, or your forgiveness. I am not worthy of any of them. I ask you for none of them. But I offer my apologies, and I beg you will accept them.
“Thorin—”
“I pledge no gold, no lifeless gem shall ever rise in my regard above my family, my friends, my people. The cost is too dear, and too late I’ve learned the love of hoarded gold is a cheat that will rob me of my greatest treasures.”
“Oh, Thorin,” sighed Bilbo.
He took no pleasure in the misery clouding Thorin’s eyes. But something in it felt to him like the relief of cool water after a long terrible journey beneath an unrelenting sun. Bilbo then thought of his mother and recalled coming to her once as a fauntling in guilt and apology, and she told him, There, there, my dear lamb, dry your tears. Don’t you know forgiveness is the tune of love with the most beautiful melody of all?
“I forgive you,” said Bilbo. “I accept your apology. Can we be friends again?”
Thorin blinked owlishly at him as if unable to comprehend such frank, plain words. But hardly stupid, he replied huskily, “I would like that.”
Bilbo settled his head more comfortably upon his chest. Now it felt less like he had pillowed himself upon an unwilling dwarf and more like sharing a comforting embrace with Thorin. The heart he heard in his pointed ear steadied into calm, but he could not help but notice the tension in his dwarf’s body refused to be eased into softness. Tentative fingers gently touched his curls.
“That’s nice,” murmured Bilbo.
Encouraged by his words, Thorin slowly carded his fingers through Bilbo’s hair.
“Thorin?”
“Mm?”
“I do wish you would kiss me. I’m a bit too tired to kiss you properly, myself.”
Bilbo felt slow movement beneath him. He felt whiskered lips pressed fervently to his brow. A shaky huff of breath stirred his curls.
He started to move away, but Bilbo’s words stopped him.
“That is a gift I wish none other to give me. I treasure each one.”
“The gift of a kiss is a poor recompense for a gift of life.”
With a sigh, Bilbo raised his head tiredly to meet his gaze. “You insist we are to do this the dwarvish way, then? Fine. Your life in exchange for your kiss. All’s settled now. The debt is absolved.”
“That’s hardly fair.”
“I’m satisfied I am paid in full, because your love for me is not so small, is it?”
Thorin stared at him.
Bilbo did not know exactly what realization Thorin arrived at, but he saw the moment it finally burst upon him like sunlight breaking through the clouds. His expression crumpled and he pressed another shaky kiss to Bilbo’s brow. Bearded kisses rained upon his cheeks, his nose, his lips, his chin, his neck, his eyes. Thorin’s shoulders shook and he wept even as he pressed fervent kisses to his precious hobbit cradled in his arms.
In return, Bilbo was a constant prattle of loving bromides and soft reassurances, and he wished he had strength to raise his arms and pet his hair, but Thorin did not seem to mind the lack. There in the dark and quiet, Bilbo basked in the warmth of Thorin’s love and felt like the richest creature in all the Lonely Mountain.
The following day after Bilbo had slept, bathed, eaten a meal that involved chewing, and tottered about his sickroom just to prove he could do it, the Company invaded his room. Thorin made Bilbo remain in his bed, even though he complained strenuously that it was unseemly to receive visitors while in bed! Dwarves simply didn’t understand these things. But despite Bilbo’s lack of manners, it was a loud, happy reunion. Most of the Company bore injuries from the battle, but none grievous, and he saw for himself both princes were as well as they had ever been.
He did allow himself a moment to yell at Fíli.
Hardly cowed, Fíli protested, “My legs were shaky, but my arms were not!”
After he exhausted his ire, Bilbo leaned his brow against his in the dwarven manner of affection, told him he was glad he was safe and well, and congratulated him on his new battle name. Fíli looked proud.
Late to the gathering, Gandalf joined them. They welcomed him, no matter Bilbo’s little sickroom was already overcrowded with fourteen.
Then Bilbo could not bear his ignorance one moment more. He asked the Company what happened to the orcs.
They quieted and looked to Kíli to answer first, because he had been the closest to everything. Kíli fidgeted with his gloves.
“You screamed,” he said. “I thought you’d gotten stabbed behind my back and fell, but when I looked, there wasn’t any orc there.”
“Then those strange bushy things appeared,” said Ori.
Ori’s arm was in a sling, and three of his fingers splinted, but he had told Bilbo that Óin said with a few more weeks of healing, he would write again without difficulty. Dwarves, apparently, healed faster than hobbits.
“They sprouted up, quick as a wink! I’d never seen a natural plant move like that before,” added Bofur. His head was bandaged and he had actually foregone his hat today because of it. “Where every orc stood, one of ‘em grew up at his feet and curled like a vine, all ‘round his legs, his arms, up over his head—! Never been terrified of a bush, in my life. But those were terrifying.”
The members of the Company who witnessed it muttered in agreement.
“They were not blackberry bushes,” said Fíli, looking grim. “Shiny dark green leaves with thorns—long, thick curved thorns longer than a man’s hand.”
With a shiver, Ori murmured, “It was one big scream, then nothing.”
Bilbo felt stunned. He’d killed Bolg’s orcs? Him, who caught spiders in his smial and released them into the garden? Him, who bought his chickens from market rather than raise them himself despite the price because he didn’t like the thought of wringing their necks? He’d killed the orc who stabbed Kíli, and he’d killed Smaug, too, but that felt different. They killed his friends first, and would have done it again if they weren’t stopped. But that didn’t mean Bilbo didn’t feel dreadful to think on it.
“It was more merciful than what the orcs intended for you all,” said Gandalf quietly, as if he knew Bilbo’s thoughts. “Who knows what mischief they designed. They were not many, but enough to have been a deadly trouble in these lands for many years.”
“Yes. Yes, I suppose so,” said Bilbo, knotting his fingers into his bedclothes. His eyes darted to meet the gazes of Ori, Fíli, Bofur, and the rest ringed about the room. “I’m sorry to have frightened you. That wasn’t my intention.”
“I didn’t notice it,” said Kíli.
His brother scoffed, “I don’t see how you couldn’t notice.”
“Because Uncle Bilbo died!” Kíli blindly reached out for Bilbo and caught onto his sleeve like a child seeking reassurance from a parent. “You didn’t see how he went so pale and limp and just stared.”
“I’m alright now, Kíli,” said Bilbo quietly, patting his hand.
Kíli relaxed.
“Did you mean to do it? With the thorn bushes?”
“I… no. Yes? Perhaps? I wanted to protect you all. Hobbits make things grow, but, um… but not like that.”
Gandalf observed wisely, “Hobbits are not warriors, but there are none fiercer in all Arda when it comes to defending their loved ones.”
“I don’t know about that…” frowned Bilbo.
“Your people have forgotten the deeds of their ancestors in the last age. They once changed the fates of entire kingdoms! And here, a hobbit has done so again.”
Gandalf looked a little smug. Bilbo felt a little nettled.
At Gandalf’s words, the Company all looked solemn and Bilbo’s thrill of irritation shrank into a troubled somersault in his stomach. But then the flutter of his doubts was wholly quelled when Thorin caught his eye. Thorin looked quietly adoring.
“Well, perhaps,” Bilbo conceded grudgingly. “But I doubt I could do anything like that again, even if I tried!”
Said Ori, “We forgot to mention the other plants.”
Bilbo looked at him blankly. “Other plants? What plants?”
“After the orcs,” said Bofur.
Fíli disagreed, “No, it was before. I’m certain it must’ve been just before.”
“It was all at once, wasn’t it?” said Ori with a considering frown. “It seemed all at once. There was so much, it was difficult to tell.”
“What did happen, then?” wondered Bilbo.
Fíli replied, “You yelled, the bushes sprang up, and maybe just before, maybe just after, this massive burst of greenery grew up through the snows!”
“More thorn bushes?” asked Bilbo, feeling even worse.
They shook their heads.
“They were knee-high weeds all filled with little white flowers. What did that lady elf call it?” wondered Bofur aloud to Nori before recalling the name, “Athelas! Kingsfoil.”
“An entire field of flowers,” said Nori.
Óin added, “‘Tis used for healing. ‘Tis mighty useful to have a plentiful supply so late in the season.” He said to Bilbo, “You saved more lives than you know to give us a whole field of fresh kingsfoil.”
“Smelled nice, too,” said Bofur. “Like spring.”
Fíli said, “You and Kíli were sat in the very center. It spread out all around you, like an enormous starburst.”
“And… everyone saw?” said Bilbo hesitantly.
He was glad of the good it had done, certainly glad, but in saving those thirty-odd dwarves, elves, and men, did he just condemn the Shire to an inadvertent evil? He was a hobbit. He understood how gossip spread. He knew his dwarves could be trusted, and he believed he could convince Bard to mind his tongue—Tauriel, too. (He was certain he spied her distinct red hair in the furor.) But all those others—he didn’t know them all by sight, let alone by name.
“They saw me?”
“I don’t know anyone saw you then,” said Glóin quickly, seeing his distress. “You’re just a little fellow, after all.”
“It was all crying and shouting and a lot of happy tears,” said Bofur with a reassuring grin.
Nori said, “The men wondered if the elves did it, and the dwarves thought maybe Tharkûn saved us.”
“But we didn’t say anything,” assured Kíli. “We just carried you along with the wounded. We said you’d gotten hit in the head.”
Bilbo twisted at the hems of his bedclothes. “I just don’t know how you all can be certain I wasn’t seen! Someone must have noticed. They will talk.”
“Everyone was well distracted,” said Glóin. “They all had plenty to catch their attention rather than one little sleeping hobbit.”
“But how many survived? Fifteen? Twenty? You cannot tell me not one of them isn’t going to think on the peculiarities of that morning and not realize—!”
Fíli huffed with a quiet laugh, being the first to understand. “Bilbo, there was far too much chaos for anyone to realize it was all because of you, because you didn’t just kill the orcs—you unkilled everybody else too!”
“Everybody?”
“Everybody,” smiled Fíli. “You saved us. Your secret’s safe.”
In later years, locals called the thorned bushes, “Baggins Rose.” By way of a curiosity, Bilbo sent starts of the eponymous bushes by raven to the best gardeners he knew—Lord Elrond and old Holman Greenhand—but neither could get the unusual plant to take root at all. There were only one hundred and thirty-eight known bushes in all the world, although there were rumors of many more growing further up the canyon.
Baggins Rose bore late-blooming blood-red flowers that adorned the ceilings and walls in great garlands at any proper Ereborian Durin’s Day celebration. It was also tradition in Erebor to give pride of place on their feasting tables to dishes and desserts incorporating blackberries. Blackberry wine, in particular, was always used to toast the king and his brave Company. No one understood why blackberries were so favored, but supposed it was simply the king’s favorite fruit in season because he insisted on it being served every year. The large blackberry brambles at the foot of the mountain were so lush and full at that time of year, it would be a shame to allow them all to go to the ravens.
Menfolk and elves, who did not recognize the day as marking the new year like dwarves did, were always invited to the celebrations to commemorate the death of the dragon, to remember their dead lost in the great subsequent battle, and to reaffirm their mutual peace and good will.
The last great dwarven caravan from the Blue Mountains plodded up the green grassy incline of the Misty Mountain foothills. The caravan of dwarves returning to their ancestral home was not only notable for being the last after five years of hard work and much effort, but because it was accompanied by a small contingent of elves from Rivendell.
“Did you enjoy your visit to the Shire?” asked Elrond sociably as he walked beside Bilbo’s pony, leading his horse behind him.
Bilbo hadn’t any idea how elves made hiking uphill on an over-warm spring morning look graceful, but Elrond did so easily.
“I did,” he said. “Very much so! But it’s changed. Perhaps I changed. I suppose it’s no matter. The Shire doesn’t have the hold over me as it once did.”
Elrond inclined his head that he understood.
“I felt very glad to visit. I think I surprised half of my relations by merely being alive.”
His eyes fixed on a pony wagon up ahead driven by a hobbit. The young hobbit stood on the swaying wagon, all the reins gathered up in his hands, and he expertly guided the ponies around a large stone in his path. He sat and his wife proudly rubbed at his shoulders.
“I still don’t think Prim and Drogo quite know what they’re doing bringing such a young faunt on this journey,” said Bilbo, “but Prim’s the daughter of a Took same as I am, and the temptation for an adventure was simply too much to resist! On the other hand, Drogo thought it a proper thing to do, to come visit for Thorin’s coronation. It’s only polite. After all, it isn’t everyone who can say they’ve a king in the family. But I do fear for little Frodo!”
“Infant dwarves made this journey many times without hazard these past five years,” assured Elrond.
In an exaggerated show of regret, Bilbo shook his head sadly. “I greatly fear Frodo will be terribly spoiled by all his adoptive dwarven uncles.”
They watched one of Elrond’s sons approach the hobbits’ wagon, and the faunt’s mother gladly allowed the elf to abscond with her child on his horse, and little Frodo squealed with laughter as they galloped away.
“Only if his adoptive elven uncles don’t spoil him, first,” smiled Elrond.
Bilbo huffed with a pleased look.
“You will keep them safe on your return journey after the coronation, will you?”
“Of course, Bilbo. Such pleasant companions will make the journey home enjoyable indeed.”
Elrond did not call him Master Baggins, and Bilbo felt glad. It took a good deal of cajoling to convince Elrond they were friends enough to dispense with formality. Elrond was friends with his mother for many years; Bilbo insisted her son was no less fond of him.
Bilbo caught sight of a particularly handsome dwarf in worn travel leathers and furs astride a passing pony. With a caravan of this size, Thorin never felt comfortable if he did not periodically circle up and down the length of it to ensure none strayed or were overlooked. Their gazes met and they exchanged small happy smiles. That smile belonged to Bilbo only, and it never failed to bloom a spot of warmth in his chest whenever he saw it upon his husband’s face.
Thorin glanced at Elrond and gave him a gracious nod before urging his pony onward. Funny how Thorin was far more polite to elves when he felt he approached them as equals and not as a desperate beggar with hat in hand.
“You have gained for yourself a reputation,” Elrond said to Bilbo.
Bilbo shrugged. “My relatives and neighbors don’t exactly understand what could ever compel a hobbit to leave the Shire.” (Though he had a pair of Took cousins take one long, lingering look at Thorin and then mutter that everything finally made sense.)
“I mean I have heard tell of you from rumors spread among menfolk in the kingdoms of the south,” said Elrond.
“Oh? I’ve not traveled much ‘til now. Too busy, no time at home, you see. Are you certain they were talking about me, of all people?”
“They say a great healer has taken residence among the dwarves of Erebor.”
Bilbo grumbled, “I never claimed to be a healer.”
“It’s said he allows hope for the hopeless.”
“I cannot save everybody,” he sighed.
Elrond sadly empathized with an understanding glance.
“We have death at Erebor, same as anywhere else,” said Bilbo. “But I do what I can so we have a little less death, a little less grief, a little less mourning.”
“It must be difficult to offer love to strangers.”
“I try. That’s usually enough.”
Bilbo incorrectly assumed they reached the end of that thread of conversation.
He watched the dwarves prodding big ox-drawn wagons forward, or riding on ponies, or steadily trodding forward on their own iron-booted feet. Some sang as they traveled, singing old hopeful songs of home.
Said Elrond after a long contemplative silence, “You have your mother’s gift.”
Bilbo looked at him, and from his spot in his pony’s saddle, he easily met Elrond’s eyes without either of them needing to look up or down.
“My ability is common to all hobbits, you know that.”
“She loved willingly. That is not common at all, not among any people. I believe she must be exceptionally proud of her son.”
“That is kind of you to say so, Elrond.”
Bilbo knew every hobbit of the Shire pitied him—at least a little bit. His self-imposed exile away from the secure greenery of home must be miserable, they said to one another. But Bilbo felt satisfied. He felt lucky. He had friends and family surrounding him, and although he left dear friends and much-loved family behind, he felt himself flourish like he never had before in new promising fields where he could lay down roots.
“Bilbo?”
“Mm?”
The green mountain slopes were covered in great swathes of flowers of yellow, white, and lavender. It was enough to gladden any hobbit heart.
“It is a mere curiosity, no more,” said Elrond.
“It’s a long way to Erebor. I’ve time to entertain many curiosities.”
“Tell me: did you ever encounter an unfortunate one who found himself eaten?”
Bilbo laughed.
