Chapter Text
“No.”
“My dear boy. You must reconsider—”
“Gandalf, no.” His hushed voice trembled with tightly tamped down fury. Bilbo had thought his kitchen a safe enough spot to hide from a troop of noisy rude dwarves who were busy in the dining room eating the entire contents of his pantry. Pity it was not enough to hide him from wizards.
The wizard was nothing but persistent. “Their quest will not succeed without your intervention.”
Bilbo cried out, “My intervention is worthless! I am not my mother. She had compassion for any pitiable creature suffering outside of the Shire, but I am not her!”
He furiously chopped carrots and onions and firmly ignored the pleading eyes of the wizard sitting at his scrubbed kitchen worktable.
The hobbit’s thinned lips turned down slightly in genuine regret. In a more measured tone he said, “It’s not that I haven’t any pity. I simply do not believe I have enough.”
His knife stilled. He met Gandalf’s troubled gaze. “You understand, don’t you? I can’t help them. I’m not sure there’s anyone in the Shire capable of being the kind of safeguard those dwarves will need.”
He huffed and turned back to his vegetables with a mutter, “I mean, dragons! They’ll all be roasted! They need common sense more than they need a hobbit.”
After a silence, Gandalf said, “I have known hobbits for a great many years.”
Bilbo could sense a speech swelling in the old wizard’s voice. He stifled a sigh and said agreeably, “My mother often spoke fondly of her journeys with you.”
“She was a kind companion. She was the most compassionate being I have ever met in all my days.”
“I agree with you, obviously.” Eyes narrowing, he gestured with his kitchen knife, “But you can’t think flattering the memory of my mother is enough to convince me, do you?”
“The men and elves of the west protect the Shire, and have done so for generations, and will continue to do so in gratitude for the wonders of hobbits worked in an earlier age.” Gandalf’s voice grew firm, “But I wonder if they have done their duty too well, since hobbits in this age hoard their gift as jealously as a dragon does its gold!”
His shoulders crept up to his ears. He silently consoled himself that the guilt of the Shire’s collective dereliction was surely not his responsibility alone?
Gandalf filched a bit of carrot and munched thoughtfully. “It’s gossiped that adventure is what drew Belladonna Took from the Shire again and again. But you and I know adventure was the furthest thing from her mind whenever she ventured out.”
Bilbo had not missed his mother so intensely in a long time. The hobbit sniffled and huffed and decided to blame the onions. He could not meet Gandalf’s eyes.
“I am not my mother. Truly, I’m sorry I am not.”
But what Bilbo Baggins did not know then as he bustled about and fed hungry dwarves and worried about the eventual disposition of his grand aunt’s West Farthing china and silently fumed over a rude dwarven king, was what miracles would be eventually caused by the great upwelling of pity in the depths of his heart as he sat in darkness and listened to the dratted dwarves sing. That longing for home seeping from their heartbreaking song into his own soft heart, that was enough. That convinced him. Adventure didn’t make Bilbo rush out his door in the morning with a pack in hand and in such a hurry he forgot his handkerchief. He hadn’t a name for it yet, but it wasn’t adventure.
All through the troll incident, Bilbo held in his mind’s eye horrid visions of spitted, roasted, and ultimately partially digested dwarves. He vaguely wondered if his mother ever encountered anything of the like and had merely redacted such gruesome details from his bedtime stories. To his revulsion, he silently calculated and anticipated exactly what he should do first if any of his companions were to be eaten. To his relief, Gandalf arrived before the question shifted from academic to practical, and the trolls became stone without ever eating anybody.
Gandalf privately reassured the Company’s shivering hobbit, “You would have had everything well in hand, I’m sure.”
“Now I know you’re a liar!” he retorted in a sharp whisper. “Not even the most benevolent hobbit in all ages of the world could have had that in hand!”
“Nonsense. You are here for such an eventuality, and I am glad that in the end your intervention was not necessary.”
With head in hands, Bilbo wilted upon a stone with an inarticulate groan.
Rivendell was beautiful. The resplendent gardens wore their finest June herbage and blossoms nestled against graceful elven architecture. The dwarves muttered spitefully about hay fever and flimsy engineering. Nor was the prevailing dwarven opinion lightened any when impassive Lord Elrond’s expression finally broke into a smile to be introduced to the final member of their Company, Bilbo Baggins.
“I am deeply honored to meet your acquaintance, Master Baggins,” he said with a sweeping bow as graceful as a dancer’s. He bowed to a hobbit when the dwarven king merited but a polite incline of his head. (Thorin was hardly polite himself, so perhaps the slight was deserved.) “We have a place for you here if you should ever wish to follow after your mother’s ways.”
“Likewise, I am honored!” Bilbo replied with a polite bow because his mother raised him with proper manners. “But, er, I’m afraid I can’t stay long. I have a contract with these gentledwarves.”
“A contract?” An elegant eyebrow arched upwards. “Is that enough to hold the regard of a hobbit?”
His gaze wavered towards a cool bearded glare belonging to a dwarven king before meeting their elven host’s eyes. He smiled politely. “They insisted.”
Despite dwarvish scowls, the elf shook his head slightly as if to yet again wonder at the incomprehensible nature of Aulë’s children. “Then a contract will have to do. I pray it is enough.”
During their long stay at the elven lord’s house waiting for midsummer moonrunes to show themselves, Bilbo defied the grumbling of one dwarven royal by his frequent morning strolls with their host.
Elrond did not natter on like a hobbit, but talk flowed easily and Bilbo felt deeply gratified by their varied and deeply interesting conversations. Happy memories of his mother was a frequently shared topic of theirs.
The hobbit breathed appreciably at the sweet scent of the season’s final apple blossoms as they walked past trees clouded with white. “Did my mother ever mention dealing with an unlucky sort who’d gotten themselves eaten?”
“If she ever did, she did not mention such an occurrence to me.”
“No. Me either. But I was wondering.”
Elrond raised one brow. “For both our sakes, I sincerely hope you will never come bearing such a tale to me.”
Bilbo huffed.
“The dwarves do not know of hobbits,” observed Elrond.
He held no censure in his tone, but Bilbo heard it plainly. The dwarven Company’s hobbit drew himself up and would have looked down his nose at him if the elf had not stood at such a lofty height.
“They most certainly do know of hobbits! They crossed the entire length of the Shire in my company, after all. I’ve been with them over six weeks!”
Elrond gave him an unimpressed look.
“No,” admitted Bilbo in quiet resignation. “They do not know of hobbits.”
“Do you wish me to tell them in your behalf? Should I speak to Thorin alone?”
“No,” he said quickly. “No, I’d rather you did not. I wish the dwarves to become my friends. If they knew… well, things won’t ever be the same.”
“Is it wise? I fear their ignorance will only cause a regrettable tragedy.”
“We were lucky against the trolls. And those wargs, too! Perhaps luck will be with us yet?”
“May the Valar be willing,” he conceded.
The flowers wafted a fine perfume, the breezes pleasantly shook green leaves hanging overhead, the stream chattered merrily, but for a time none of these beauties were comprehended by the hobbit shuffling at the elven lord’s side.
“Gandalf insists I will do the Company good. I… I don’t think he is right. I am not half the hobbit my mother was.” Careful to avoid meeting Elrond’s eyes, he scuffed his furry toes against the green grass. “Sorry to disappoint.”
They did not speak but tread among paths of mossy stone that wound through hillocks of flowers nodding on their stems.
“I understand the fear of following behind a greatly accomplished parent,” said Elrond suddenly when Bilbo had thought their conversation already finished. “I was quite grown before I came to accept that I am not my father, nor would he want me to be. I would be a fool to expect your accomplishments to perfectly match those of your mother. You will grow into yourself given time.”
“I hope you are right. I haven’t the confidence you or Gandalf put in me.”
“Mithrandir says you are enough. He is fond of saying that small hinges are always enough to open very great doors.”
He sighed. “I am a very, very small hinge, indeed.”
“Nevertheless, he believes you are enough,” Elrond retorted with a kind smile. “So do I.”
Bilbo would never admit it in a thousand years, but Gandalf was right: the Company absolutely required a hobbit’s intervention. He didn’t understand how right until the Company inadvertently camped out on the back porch of a goblin town.
Their unexpected fall was long and the ground unforgiving. Most were saved by the virtue of being asleep when it happened and falling atop their packs or bedrolls. But not Bofur.
There were groans and harsh exclamations of Khuzdul. The sound of Bombur’s cookpot falling down the rocks rang out like a gong.
“Quick!” came the order. “Gather your weapons! They are coming!”
Hobbit eyes were not made for the dark like dwarven eyes, so Bilbo did not see who was coming until fluttering goblin torchlight fell upon them. It was then he saw Bofur, his empty eyes staring upwards at nothing.
It was instinct. A reflex. At the same instant desperate dwarven blades clashed against goblin weaponry, Bilbo flung himself over the dead dwarf—his friend, perhaps his only friend among the dwarves.
When he was a fauntling, his mother told him grief was love sung to a different tune. Love could be happy, or sad, or painful, or patient, or wide enough to fit all the flowers of spring. Love was always the same words, but could be sung to many different tunes. More tunes than you or I can ever name, my dearest, she told him when she tucked him in at night.
Bilbo had never done this sort of a thing in all his life, and being such an odd lonesome sort, he never anticipated he ever would, but he immediately recognized this thrill of shock and terrible throbbing in his heart he felt the moment he saw his friend dead—it was love. He held it. He made it bloom.
The wet-sounding crack of shattered vertebrae rejoining themselves was so loud Bilbo felt the noise of it in his chest pressed up against Bofur’s body, but the sound was lost in the noise of shouting and fighting. At the same moment, he felt a corresponding heat, a fire, in his own neck and back.
“Oh, Yavanna’s mercy!” sobbed Bilbo. His tears broke with a choke when a clawed hand hauled him up by the straps of his pack. Another goblin jerked Bofur’s coat lapels. The dwarf yowled and flailed up onto his feet. The entire Company was overwhelmed, snatched, shoved, howled at by an immense mob of ugly goblins who escorted them deeper into goblin town.
Being smaller than the dwarves and smaller than the goblins, it only took a little sidestep into the dark and a little dodge of grasping claws and Bilbo slipped behind them all. But not having eyes suited for living within a mountain, he misjudged his feet just as an unlucky goblin snatched at him, and they fell together down, down, down into the depths of the mountain.
On the backside of the mountain--after breaking his fall on the unfortunate goblin, after riddling with a monster, after sprinting for his life through the dark by sheer dumb and gutsy luck toward a sliver of daylight and discovering fresh air again—Bilbo rejoined the Company.
Even in the moment Thorin and the others voiced their doubts to his bravery, his suitability, Bilbo frankly agreed with them and felt his heart overfull. He wasn’t brave. He wasn’t suitable. But he promised these dwarves he would help them win their home back, and he told them so there in the midst of the pines on the backside of the Misty Mountains. He never felt more sincere in his life. The echo of feeling seemed reflected in the pleased expressions surrounding him. Perhaps he did have a place among them, no matter how much Thorin frowned. But even Thorin’s frown seemed more thoughtful now than hostile. Perhaps battling goblins, though brief, made brothers of them all. Bilbo had little time for self-reflection, however, because Gandalf hurried them along. They heard the howls of wargs.
Bilbo knew he had made a deadly mistake the moment Azog’s cruel eyes fixed upon him in the flickering shadows cast by the light of burning pines. He bravely held out his little sword, as if that could fell an orc-chief, and crouched between Thorin’s body and Azog.
The orc smiled. What slithering evil was in that slow smile!
“Perian.”
How an orc could make a fair elvish word sound so vile, he would never know.
Then Azog shouted aloud in Black Speech, and whatever it was he said, the orcs surrounding him grew frenzied. Bilbo didn’t think it was his imagination that their frenzy was particularly directed at reaching him and the fallen king. But the Company fought beside him with all their might and then the eagles came.
From the feathered shoulders of the eagle he rode upon, Bilbo worried and peered through moonlight at the limp figure of the dwarven king. He had been so rushed, he couldn’t do a proper job of it. It had been the slapdash work of a moment, and he prayed Yavanna it had been enough. For he knew as the minutes crept into an hour and beyond that there was no hope reviving Thorin now if his soul had slipped away to the Halls of Waiting during the fight.
At the Carrock, Gandalf finished what Bilbo began, and the hobbit’s legs felt weak with relief to watch Thorin stagger upright, in pain, but alive. To his shock, he was then embraced with words suffused with gratitude and apology.
Apologies were also tunes that sang of love, he thought with a happy smile, remembering his mother.
They were battered, with precious few supplies, and still far from the Lonely Mountain, but the Company were all alive. Bilbo felt content.
They had respite at Beorn’s.
When they arrived, the giant bear-man who grumbled at so many dwarves cluttering up his doorstep blinked at Bilbo and gasped in wonder, “Perian!”
And that was that. They were freely given shelter, supplies, new gear, and shared a generous table. The dwarves were so relieved to receive it, that they did not question Beorn’s hospitality.
“Master Baggins? Are you well?”
Bilbo sat in the dewy green cool of the morning in Beorn’s garden with his pipe between his teeth, although he had lost his bag of pipeweed somewhere beneath the Misty Mountains. He opened his eyes and watched Thorin ease himself down beside him to the fallen log that served as his bench.
“Gracious, Thorin, shouldn’t I be asking you that?”
Ignoring his question, he insisted, “Were you injured any in the mountain? By those orcs?”
“No worse than anyone else. We all got our share of scrapes and bruises—and poor Kíli with that arrow, too.”
“You move but slowly. Carefully. Are you sure you are not injured? I will go fetch Óin—”
Bilbo caught at his sleeve and the dwarf slumped back down to the log.
“You are one to talk. You move like a little old man,” he tutted. “Three days ago and I wouldn’t have been able to manhandle you like I did just now.”
Thorin glared at him. But it was a mild glare, so Bilbo did not feel at all discomfited by it.
“I cannot have a member of this Company hiding his injuries from me.”
“I’ve some bruises. They are tender, but that is all,” he admitted. He peered curiously at the other. “What about you? Was Gandalf able to mend your wounds? I don’t think any of the others were close enough to see how very bad off you were. It was a close thing.”
“I… I am well.”
Bilbo turned a skeptically arched eyebrow upon him.
“I blacked out,” he amended. He rubbed at his beard while staring at his boots. He admitted quietly, “I felt your hand on my side. I saw you stand before Azog. I saw him smile. But I’m afraid I don’t recall…”
“No matter,” said Bilbo quickly. “The eagles came about then.”
“I am well enough,” said Thorin. His hand rested warm and heavy on Bilbo’s shoulder.
Some of the dwarves were generous with their touches and embraces, but not Thorin. His physical gestures of comradery were limited to Balin, Dwalin, and his sister-sons. And now Bilbo was included among the number. Something warm and pleasant swelled within his chest.
“I live and breathe because of you, Bilbo Baggins. I will not forget my debt.”
“No!” he said sharply, and Thorin was startled by his vehemence.
“No,” Bilbo repeated more temperately. “There is no debt. Hobbits never mark matters of life and death as something to be bought or sold. It is always a gift given. It is an insult to tally it up like a debt in a ledger.”
Thorin was silent for a moment before he rumbled quietly, “I thank you for the gift.”
Bilbo smiled at him. “You’re welcome.”
The dwarf’s small smile in return warmed Bilbo more than sunshine.
During their stay with Beorn, the hobbit gladly ate his fill at the bear-man’s generous table with the rest. He felt inexpressibly glad to scrub the grime of travel from his body and his clothes, too. The entire Company was in good spirits now that they were clean (or as clean as one got in one’s travel clothes) and with full bellies.
They had all worried for several days over Kíli who suffered after Azog’s attack from an orc arrow in his thigh. They wished hopelessly for Gandalf’s magic, but the wizard had left them for business in the south before they realized that Kíli’s wound was so grave. He grew worse and worse until Bilbo told them that he suddenly recalled an old hobbit remedy. He administered his remedy to the poor boy as a strong tea spooned between ashen lips. Kíli grew worser still in the night.
A great deal of excitement interrupted the Company’s tense midnight vigil when Beorn called them out to drive off an unexpected incursion of orc scouts.
“The Little Bunny must stay here,” he insisted with a growl, and his eyes lingered on the hobbit. “He is useless against orcs, but well-suited to tend to your young one in his sickbed.”
By sunrise when the Company all limped back, footsore and having seen few signs of orcs or wargs at all, Kíli was as well as if nothing at all had been the matter (although he complained of being desperately hungry), and even his inflamed wound was nearly healed over into a new scar.
Óin was especially interested to learn of this wonderful hobbitish remedy until Bilbo pulled him aside and whispered that dwarves were not the only race with secrets. It was a hobbit remedy that required a hobbit, and so the tea was quite useless in the hands of a dwarf, no matter how skilled. Óin frowned at that, but pestered Bilbo no more.
“You ought to drink some of your miracle tea yourself,” urged Kíli as he tucked into a hearty bowl of stewed beans and vegetables and thick brown bread spread with honeybutter. “You look pale, Bilbo.”
“Oh, I’m fine, Kíli. Don’t you worry about me.”
“I bet your tea tastes really disgusting, doesn’t it? Not even hobbits like to drink it!” he laughed.
Bilbo felt a happy warmth to hear that laugh again.
“I don’t remember it,” said Kíli around a mouthful of bread, “but I’m told it made all the difference in the end.”
“Lucky for us Beorn grows herbs in his garden, then, eh?” smiled Bilbo even though he felt a bit weak and feverish that morning.
“Very lucky!”
On the afternoon of their final day at Beorn’s, they were lazing about a summer meadow thick with wildflowers and fat bumblebees. Bilbo knew dwarves usually lived inside mountains away from the sun, but every dwarf he saw stretched happily in the warm sunshine like they had all turned into hobbits. He did not mind it one bit. They smoked the last of their pipeweed and passed around pipes to those who had none.
Their easy talk then took an unpleasant turn to their recent passage under the mountains. Bilbo felt his shoulders grow tense.
“I was clocked out cold, there in the bottom of that goblin cave,” Bofur said with a slightly unsettled look that he was attempting to cover over with a smile. He shook his head, “The strangest thing of it—I thought I saw me amad!”
“In a goblin cave?” wondered Fíli.
“No…somewhere else.”
Bombur leaned forward, longing in his earnest face. “Did Amad say anything to you?”
“She kissed me, and told me I was too skinny and why don’t I find me a nice dam like you did?”
The dwarves laughed. Bilbo did not laugh. Neither did Thorin. Kíli was busy slipping flowers and tall grasses into Fíli’s hair when he wasn’t looking.
Bofur’s smile that was always so easy, did not reach his eyes. “Then she scolded me for dawdling when clearly my hobbit ‘twere asking me to go back so urgently!” He puffed nervously on his borrowed pipe. “Wasn’t that the strangest thing?”
Mirkwood smelled of death. It was an old permeating smell that settled in every murky hollow dip of the earth, in every boggy bit of ground. The entire forest, Bilbo decided, was sick and dying. From his childhood, he heard winter tales of hobbits reviving blighted lands and poisoned wells. But a forest as large as this! Bilbo wagered it would take every hobbit in the Shire to bring it back to life. But he tried. In his foolishness, he tried.
One night, the Company camped beneath a tall spreading tree that should have been a proud monarch of the forest, but now had bits of slime mold oozing from knotholes and craggy bits of bark, and its wood felt peculiarly spongy in some places. Bilbo felt such pity, he rested his hands on its gnarled roots and tried.
He barely stumbled out of camp to vomit up what little he had eaten for supper. He felt dizzy and foul and overwhelmed by nausea. He quite lost his senses for a moment.
“Bilbo! Are you alright?”
When he next was aware, he felt a steadying embrace surrounding him and in the gloom he saw Bofur’s concerned face very near his own.
“Yes,” he croaked. “I think so.”
“You were a bit out of your head, I think. You were asking for your ma.”
“Oh.”
“I mean, I’m hardly a substitute for anybody’s amad, but can I help?”
“You are helping.”
“Then I’ll just stand here for a bit?” His strong dwarven arms held him a little more securely.
“At least until the trees stop spinning, if you would be so kind.”
Bofur stood as steady as a rock and with just as much patience as he waited for Bilbo to gather himself.
After Bofur dragged him back into camp, Bilbo endured Óin’s manhandling and patiently insisted more than once that, no, he did not eat anything growing off the ground. He did not drink the oily looking water. He was not stupid, thank you very much.
Óin finally declared that walking through this foul forest to a hobbit must be like tunneling through weak loess to a dwarf. Bilbo didn’t quite understand what he meant by that, but the rest of the Company apparently did and gave him sympathetic pats on the shoulder. Óin gave him a bit of dried spicy root to chew that settled his stomach. Thorin pressed his waterskin into his hands without saying anything at all.
“Why, there are mushrooms on this tree!” said Ori pointing to a large patch of yellow fungi creeping up the gnarled trunk of their tree. He tilted his head to one side. “I swear they weren’t there, earlier.”
They were all terribly conscious of their dwindling food stores. Dori wondered, “Can we eat them? Bilbo, come see—you’ve the best eye for mushrooms in the Company.”
He barely cast a glance at them. “No. Those are not good to eat.”
“That’s a shame,” said Ori.
“Unfortunate,” frowned Dori. “It would’ve been a welcome spot of luck to have them.”
“No one is to eat anything foraged in these woods,” growled Thorin. “We cannot be slowed by illness.”
Bilbo appreciated how Bofur spread the hobbit’s bedroll between his own and Bifur’s.
“Stay away from Bombur,” he whispered. “He kicks in his sleep like a bad-tempered ram.” He tried to look very wise as if a sleep-twitching Bombur was the worst peril to be found in these woods.
For the rest of their journey through Mirkwood, once named Greenwood, Bilbo tried not to touch anything at all there that was either living or dying.
Chapter 2
Notes:
FYI, Tauriel gets a mention in this chapter, but she’s not really a character in this story. I took some liberties and revised her backstory instead of making up an OC from scratch. I also rearranged the timing of Kíli getting shot by the orc arrow to chapter one instead of this chapter. Just giving everyone a heads up in case it looks like I’m getting sloppy with movie canon when the reality is I’m just ignoring it/rearranging it to suit the story.
But I admit my canon Tolkien lore is a bit murky, so I hope you will especially forgive any dialog about Middle Earth’s hereafter that doesn’t jibe with the wiki. (We can pretend I did it on purpose and attribute any discrepancies to the characters not having a perfect knowledge of it, either.)
And thank you for all of the kudos and kind comments! It feels so validating to get feedback like that. It’s probably unhealthy how often I’ve been checking on my story over the past week, but every time I did, I made a happy little wiggle-dance to discover evidence that y’all have been enjoying this thing! I hope by the time we reach the end, I can stick the landing and give you a satisfying conclusion.
Chapter Text
Bilbo did not care for the elven king’s calculating stare. Maybe it was the sensation of spider venom still roiling through his blood that made him shiver.
“A bargain, then,” offered Thranduil.
Thorin’s voice was terrifying for its calm. “For our freedom?”
He nodded once.
“What would you have of me?”
Bilbo wondered if Thranduil would ask for Erebor’s treasure room. He wondered if Thorin would give it. But he already knew in his gut what Thranduil would demand.
“The halfling. Leave him and you dwarves are free to go.”
It did warm Bilbo’s heart a little how openly staggered Thorin looked to hear the terms of the proposed bargain.
The dwarf composed himself quickly and his glower was truly thunderous. “No. He is not mine to give, nor for you to demand. He is a member of my Company. I will not abandon any one of them.”
Thranduil looked upon him unperturbed as if looking upon a small child throwing a tantrum for a ridiculous whim of fancy.
Before he could open his mouth to retort, Bilbo urged, “For pity’s sake, leave me here and go, Thorin! Don’t you see I am captive either way? I will bear my time here more easily if I know you’re all well and free.”
His glower turned on the hobbit. He snarled, “No!”
Thranduil looked bored. “Take the offer, dwarf. Take it and I promise the halfling will be kept well for all the days of his life. I will give him a comfortable room, plenty of amusements, food from my own table. You can leave him in good conscience.”
Equal parts incredulous and enraged, Thorin spat, “No!”
Thranduil’s eyes sparked. “So be it.”
He snapped his fingers. A guard stepped forward to hear his king’s command.
“To the dungeons. All of them.”
For many hours, hobbit and dwarf sat in their shared prison cell in mutual silence before Thorin spoke. “Master Baggins?”
“Yes?”
“Why do elves like you?”
Bilbo tsked. “I don’t think Thranduil ‘likes’ me.”
“Elrond was eager to make you welcome and invited you to remain in his halls. Thranduil has as good as stolen you. He wishes to possess you. I don’t understand.”
He rested his temple against the bars of their cage. The cold metal did nothing for his growing headache. “In an earlier age, all the mighty kings of men and elves had a hobbit at their side.” He fidgeted uneasily. He hated this. He hated lying. “It’s old superstition. Hobbits are… um… lucky, I guess.”
“Lucky,” he repeated flatly.
Bilbo began to giggle, but it was filled with shattering nerves rather than any humor. “This has been an ill-omened venture from the start. I told Gandalf I wouldn’t be enough. I told him you lot needed so much more than I can give!”
He dug his knuckle against his temple, but still his pounding head had no relief. He didn’t dare look at the dwarven king and meet his gaze. If he did, he feared he would break.
“The wizard was strangely insistent we required a burglar,” said Thorin with low wondering words.
Bilbo snorted.
“But he instead wished us to have a hobbit’s luck?”
“Such as it is. If it wasn’t for me, I don’t doubt Thranduil wouldn’t have insulted you all a bit longer and then sent you on your way.”
“Your opinion of elves is too generous. He would have imprisoned us here regardless.” Thorin hesitantly patted the hobbit’s arm. The heavy warmth was a small comfort, but Bilbo felt steadier for it. “It was never a choice between your imprisonment and ours. The burden is not yours. We were all destined for these cells the moment the elves found us.”
They fell silent after that, and each kept his own thoughts.
Bilbo wasn’t sure at what point of the night sleeping shoulder to shoulder had turned into the hobbit burrowing into the fur of Thorin’s coat and a warm dwarven arm holding him close. Feeling a blush rise on his cheeks, he cleared his throat and gave his attention to their unexpected visitor. Not a guard. But formally attired. A steward of some sort, or a member of Thranduil’s household.
He was quite drunk.
“So this is a hobbit.”
“What do you want?” demanded Thorin.
“I’ve not seen a hobbit before. Not up close. No hobbit has stepped a single woolly foot on this side of Hithaeglir for half an age, at least.”
“Your curiosity has been satisfied. You’ve seen the hobbit. Now leave.”
He ignored Thorin. Bilbo wasn’t sure Thorin was much accustomed to being ignored.
The elf squinted at him. “You look young. Are you too young for it, yet? How old are you, hobbit?”
“I turn fifty next month.”
The elf was dismayed. “You are but a child!”
“I am middle aged,” Bilbo insisted with a frown.
“Hobbits live so little a time? I thought your spans of life comparable to dwarves, at least.”
“A hundred years is a full span of life for a hobbit. But rarely, there are some few who live considerably older. My mother saw two hundred before she passed.”
“Your mother!” The elf was overjoyed. “Nienna smiles upon me! Quickly, you will come with me—”
Bilbo took a step back from the cell door. “No, I don’t think I will.”
The elf looked shattered.
“You must know I cannot be forced.”
“What must I do?”
The hobbit folded his arms across his chest. “Convince me.”
The elf swallowed. He slumped down the wall and sat on the floor. They were closer to a height, now, though the elf was so unsteady on his legs Bilbo was sure he had not been thinking of that when he sat down.
“My name is Galion. I am the king’s butler. My wife sailed into the west years ago, but before she left me, she gave me a daughter. My child is young, but she is good and beautiful, better and more beautiful than either me or my wife. Despite her youth, she has a place in the king’s guard. But the spiders… They are very bad. They grow ever worse. Worse than the king will admit. They overwhelm our soldiers at times. And my daughter”—he hiccupped with a sob—”my daughter now lies overcome by their poison. There is nothing to be done. We wait for her to die.”
“I thought elves didn’t fear death. Not in the way the rest of Eru’s creation fears it. It’s said the Valar made a place for elves that is nothing but good and light and peace. The rest of us are not so certain if there is any place for us at all.”
He scowled. “It is true. Ilúvatar’s eldest children are promised such a place. We know it is true. But I am selfish. If she dies, I will be here and she will be there, and we will be divided until the world is remade. After all that time apart, we will be strangers when we reunite. I wish to keep my daughter just as she is because she is the daughter who loves me best. The daughter I raised from an infant.”
Frowning hard at the stone at his feet, Galion ruffled his long hair. It was a strange sight to see an elf with disheveled hair. “I sometimes wonder why us elves are not jealous of you all. Isn’t it a blessing to know when death parts you, the parting is not long? You will one day find your loved ones just as you remember them in the Halls of Waiting. It would be a comfort, I think.”
Bilbo’s fingers fiddled absently with one of the remaining buttons on his coat sleeve. “If I do this—and I cannot promise that I can—what will you give me?”
He looked appalled. “You sell yourself?”
“Of course not. But it is the only thing of value left to me and yet you ask me to give it to you when we are not friends. Under the circumstances…” He leaned against his cell door, his eyes roving suggestively about the narrow prison walls surrounding him.
“No. You speak truth.” He rubbed at his chin. He scrubbed at his bloodshot eyes. “Freedom. I give it to you in return.”
“Thranduil will be angry.”
The elf retorted sharply, “Thranduil does not understand the magics of hobbits any more than I do! He can be convinced that you freed yourself.” Then he softened and Bilbo spied a shine in his eyes. “Please, Master Hobbit. I beg you. Have mercy.”
Bilbo sighed. “I can only promise to try.”
“I can ask for no more.” Galion lurched to his feet. His hands shook on the key he set in its door. “Come with me.”
The tumblers screeched in their lock, and the moment the cell door opened, Thorin pounced. But the elf, even drunk, was quick and made the dwarf pull up short. A silver knife glinted in his fingers.
Bilbo felt Galion’s hand tighten around his bicep where he held him fast.
“I shout and a dozen guards will come with swords in hand. The halfling is worth much, no matter where he stands, but you are worth very little within a prison, dwarf.”
“Shut the door,” commanded Galion.
Bilbo shut the door. He tried hard not to meet Thorin’s eyes glaring from the other side.
“Lock it.”
He locked it.
“The key.”
Galion fumbled, but by the second try, he had the key plucked from Bilbo’s palm and stuffed in his pocket.
“Come, halfling,” he said lightly as if he was leading the way and not hauling him by his bruised arm, “I have need of you.”
Galion was a canny old elf. Bilbo didn’t wonder if he had planned this from the moment Bilbo stepped within Thranduil’s keep, and he drank his wine merely for courage. Because this seemed far too well orchestrated to be an idea born of sleepless drunkenness in the middle of the night.
It was much later when Bilbo woke with an aching head, nausea, and every muscle in his body ached with a dull burn. “Mmph,” he said.
“Bilbo?”
The rumbling voice was loud in his ear. It was then he realized he was reclining against a broad dwarven chest. He shivered. Why did he feel cold when it was so nice and warm here? Oh, thought Bilbo muzzily. Spiders. Yes, that would do it.
His mouth felt like cotton. “Elves are rather difficult to kill,” he rasped. An earthenware jug of water was held up to his lips and he drank. He felt steadier already. “That elf lady must’ve been bit by spiders a dozen times or more. Twice would be enough to kill you or me.”
“She is dead, then?”
“I don’t know. I fainted.”
“That damn elf Galion came slinking back here late in the afternoon after he took you. He had you tucked up inside an empty barrel carried in a handcart to keep you hidden. I believed he’d killed you and meant to leave your corpse with me.”
He smacked his lips with a grimace. “I thought I smelled apple brandy.”
“You’ve been unconscious nearly two days. What do you remember?”
“I remember enough to find our way out of the dungeons. But Galion’s quarters are inside the palace. I still don’t know a way out of the keep.”
Thorin seemed a little annoyed. Maybe that’s simply what he looked like close up.
Mortification slowly settled upon Bilbo. It finally occurred to his muddled brain that he was sitting on Thorin’s lap. His head was resting on Thorin’s shoulder. His knees were drawn up to his chin, and arms that did not belong to him were cradling him close within their cloaks. A warm dwarven hand was wrapped around his shoulders. Another hand was resting on his thigh.
“I mean,” Thorin repeated with an impatient note of insistence, “what did that damn elf do to you? What did he do that he carried you back half dead and feverish?”
“I really can’t say.” Woozily, he tried to scoot off Thorin’s lap.
“Can’t or won’t?” The dwarf tightened his hold.
Bilbo breathed. He felt dizzy. He turned his head and buried his face in Thorin’s chest. He smelled filthy and unwashed but not entirely unpleasant. He was reminded of an embrace on top of the Carrock and felt comforted.
“Bilbo.”
Resting his brow against a lovely collarbone, he said, “Did I tell you that generations ago, there were hobbits who belonged to the courts of elvish and mannish kings?”
“You mentioned it, yes.”
“It was not voluntary.”
Thorin surmised with slow unease, “Hobbits were captives.”
“Sometimes.”
The thump of Thorin’s heart in his ear steadied him. His quiet voice rumbled in his chest.
“Your people have a magic,” he murmured as if it was a secret shared between them two only. “You can do something no other can do.”
Bilbo remained silent.
“Dwarves have their secrets. I cannot begrudge hobbits their own.” He took a breath and Bilbo felt it swell in his breast beneath him. “Tell me this: did that elf deliberately hurt you? Him or his daughter?”
“No.”
“Alright then. Don’t do it again.”
“I’ll try.”
Despite his half-hearted promise, Bilbo broke it in less than three days.
Bilbo’s strange feverish chill broke within a few hours of waking. After he ate a little and slept a little, he felt well enough. Or at least that is what he told Thorin.
They passed the time almost pleasantly. They sat close together, side-by-side, and shared their cloaks. (After one had held the other curled up on his lap for two days to keep him warm through chills and fever, there was little propriety of distance left to maintain.) They talked. Very deliberately neither speculated on either hobbitish magic or their quest. They spoke of home, of the Company, favorite poems and stories they had read, their childhoods, and far-off places they had seen. Thorin even sang for him once. (Elven prisons had precious little to desire, but the small stone space had admittedly excellent acoustics.) Bilbo got him to laugh by telling his favorite tavern story of Gorhenbras Took and the Inexhaustible Barrel of Rum—and it was a great, gratifying dwarven belly laugh too.
Food and fresh water were brought. It was hardly enough.
Galion appeared the next night. He haunted the darkness outside their cell door and Thorin was instantly on his feet.
“You,” he hissed.
Impressively, the elf ignored the black stare boring into the side of his head. “Good. You are awake,” he said to Bilbo who rolled to his feet with a grunt. “We haven’t much time.”
“How is Tauriel?”
The elf’s expression brightened with quiet joy. “She lives. Health blooms in her cheeks. She grows stronger each day.” He bowed his head graciously, “And now I am here to give you your due.”
“Excuse me?”
“I promised your freedom, Master Hobbit, did I not?”
Bilbo’s brows drew together. “The Company,” he corrected pointedly. “The Company’s freedom.”
He clutched at his heart. “I promised no such thing! A life for a life is fair! A life for fourteen is impossibly exorbitant!”
“Then you shall keep your ‘payment’ and don’t bother asking for any favors again! I will not abandon my friends!”
Thorin demanded with as much iron in his spine as ever, “Bilbo Baggins, you will leave this place.”
“No.” Bilbo refused to argue. He refused to budge. Iron met stone and neither yielded.
But then Thorin’s voice gentled. “Then I will beg a favor—as your friend.” He pulled the ring from his finger and pressed it into Bilbo’s hands. A carved blood-red stone was inlaid in warm gold. “Go east. To the Iron Hills. My cousin Dain is lord there. He will plead our release from Thranduil. He will be a more convincing negotiator than I am since he has an army at his back.”
“I can’t.” The skin-warmed gold felt heavy in his hand. All that way? Alone?
“You must.”
Galion stared down the corridor at an imagined sound. Relieved there was nothing in it, he then tsked impatiently, “Hurry! The guards change shifts in an hour and there is a small gate left unattended for a few minutes only. We will miss our chance if you deliberate any longer.”
Bilbo looked at Thorin and saw in his eyes such sad hope, such conflict to risk him yet again, but such confidence that of all the Company, perhaps Bilbo could do the impossible. He threw his arms around his neck and felt strong arms encompass his shoulders. He didn’t allow himself to regret his impulsive gesture. It may be months before they saw one another, if ever again. He would have this to remember him by.
“When we meet again, I trust it will be under happier circumstances,” rumbled Thorin, his voice sounding rougher than usual.
“Yes,” said Bilbo. “Yes, I believe so.”
Their next meeting was indeed happier, and it came only an hour after Galion led Bilbo away into the darkness.
“Bilbo?” Thorin blinked like he meant to blink away false visions. “Kíli?”
“Hurry.” The door lock screeched. It was the last one.
They ran down the corridor, light-footed Kíli leading the way, his own short dwarven bow in his hands.
Breathless, the hobbit said to Thorin, “At night, the guards remain up on the walls only. There is no one at all down here in the dungeons. That is how Galion was able to escort me to his home so easily. He only had to hide me in a barrel for a little while.”
“But the gate? The small unguarded gate? It was left alone only for a few minutes. We are too late.”
“I’m small enough and quiet enough to get out through that gate without being spotted, but you lot are hopeless. We must go another way.”
They passed through a long corridor lined with prison cells that all stood open and empty. They wound down several flights of stairs and through twisting corridors.
Thorin wondered, “You have no stone sense. How on earth did you avoid getting lost down here?”
“Galion led me this way twice, now. He meant to stuff me into another empty brandy barrel again so to cart me upstairs, but I changed his mind for him.”
They pushed through a wide pair of doors where they were greeted by the entirety of the Company. They stood in the king’s wine cellar where Galion managed the stores of wine. Galion lay nearby, gagged and bound tight hand and foot with strips torn from his own cloak.
Thorin stared. Then he laughed, great happy full guffaws. He gently pounded Bilbo on the back and the hobbit felt it all the way down through his toes.
“I believe this belongs to you,” Bilbo said quietly as he slipped the heavy gold and jasper signet ring into his palm. If Bilbo’s fingers lingered perhaps a moment too long, Thorin didn’t say anything but instead beamed at him in silence.
Dwalin pressed Orcrist and Thorin’s own pack into his hands. “Lucky for us, Balin caught sight of our gear being stored away when they carried us down here.”
Balin shook his whitened head. “‘Twas a torment knowing it all so close, being behind bars as we were. I consider it good luck, now.”
“Why, don’t you know?” grinned Thorin, his teeth a white line in his beard, “Hobbits are lucky. A bit of hobbit luck has rubbed off on you.”
“Then I hope there is yet a bit more luck to spare,” said Dwalin, hefting his war hammer. “We must fight our way through the guards before they all realize we are loose from our cages.”
The hobbit cleared his throat. The circle of dwarves looked at him, by now knowing hobbits well enough (or perhaps it was only Bilbo) to recognize the noise meant he wished to be heard. “I have a different route in mind,” he said.
Bilbo showed them the empty wine barrels and the trap door leading to the river and told them his plan.
“That,” said Glóin, “is a terrible plan.”
“I’m sure it will work, shouldn’t it?”
Fíli looked decidedly uneasy. “Although dwarves can swim, you do realize we don’t float? We sink, Bilbo. Like stone.”
“It’ll be a few hours at most. From what I’ve seen on maps, Long Lake isn’t far.”
They examined the barrels. They peeked through the trap door at the dark river’s current. They dithered and complained, but it was the distant sound of elves shouting an alarm in a far off corridor that made up their minds. They loaded themselves and their packs and weapons into their unlikely boats within minutes.
Their float down river took the rest of the night and most of the following day. Being the last who hammered the barrels shut and pulled the lever operating the trapdoor to the river, poor Bilbo clung the entire way to the outside of a barrel with a short, heavy prybar tied to his back.
The barrels finally washed up in the shallows where the river fed into the lake and grew so broad, the water rose no higher than Bilbo’s knees. The barrels full of dense dwarves sunk and the river’s current refused to carry them any farther.
Bilbo didn’t hear any noises. That scared him. He scurried from barrel to barrel, frantically prying them open. He sighed with relief when he was greeted by soggy dwarven cursing and frantically dove into the barrel when he was not.
When all were loosed and all were wringing out coats and beards, Bilbo counted thirteen wet dwarves, gave them an exhausted but satisfied nod, and then staggered onto shore and vomited into the bushes.
“My socks smell like elvish wine, but only two bottles broke!” announced Bofur as he triumphantly held up eight large green bottles he pulled up from the bottom of his barrel.
The dwarves cheered.
Looking worse for wear, Óin commandeered a bottle to help revive the most sodden of the Company. Bilbo declined a sip.
“Ugh. Please no.” He held his poor stomach and shivered. He felt slightly delirious. His head throbbed.
For a time, Dori was distraught by the amount of blood covering his little brother. He was not much mollified by various stories traded by the Company about past bumps, gashes, and scrapes that looked far worse than the reality.
Meanwhile, Ori sat calmly, scrubbing blood out of his favorite mittens while Óin tended to him. He called Dori over and showed him the small gash hidden in Ori’s hair.
“You see, Master Dori? ‘Tis a tiny wound—three stitches only. Head wounds are always terrible bleeders.”
The dwarves limped off to find a spot away from the river to camp for the night. They built a fire to dry off, roasted fish caught by Kíli and Fíli, liberally toasted their new-found freedom, and Bilbo developed a horrible wet cough in his lungs that lasted most of a week.
“Inhaled some river water,” concluded Óin, after listening to Bilbo’s chest. “Which is hardly a surprise. I drank a gallon of the stuff myself when we got tossed through those damn rapids!”
Men had short memories. Bilbo was glad none of the big people of Laketown took any notice of the smallest, slightly ill member of the Company. They remembered dwarves, but hobbits or halflings or perian were creatures of whom they had no recollection.
The men feted the dwarves and gave them an entire house for themselves to rest in, but tired and wary Bilbo remained at the edges, avoiding noise and people both. Somehow Thorin found him here alone on a balcony at the back of the house. Their faces were turned towards the Lonely Mountain although Bilbo couldn’t see it in this darkness. He wondered if dwarven eyes could see it.
“Durin’s Day is nearly upon us. We will be in the mountain soon,” said Thorin as stars glittered overhead.
“Soon,” agreed Bilbo.
He set a plate of food next to him with a clink. He slid it towards him.
“I see you know your way into a hobbit’s good graces. Thank you.”
Bilbo nibbled at the dainties and Thorin sipped at his ale.
“I cannot help but reflect on all of the very near misses the Company has enjoyed these past months. It is truly improbable—impossible—luck.”
“Truly,” said Bilbo, feeling an uncomfortable wariness building within him.
“Bilbo?” Thorin stared uncomfortably into the bottom of his ale. “Have we been… using you up?”
“Beg pardon?” He felt startled to see the strength of concern gleaming in the pair of blue eyes that met his gaze.
Thorin briefly raised his hand as if he meant to rest it on Bilbo’s arm or knee, but he instead settled his fingers on his own thigh where they drummed once, twice.
“You seem worn,” he said. “Thin. Stretched. I thought at first it was simply the softness of hobbits compared to the sturdiness of dwarves, but I know now that is false. You are as tired and dirty and hungry as the rest of us, but there is yet a greater travail that has sapped you of your vitality. Have we caused you this detriment?”
He sighed. “I’ll have you know a hobbit cannot be forced.”
“You say that, but I don’t believe it is true. Otherwise, the kings of old would have found it useless to hold your ancestors captive.”
He shook his head. “It is possible for one to be caught in a terrible bind and yet wish good fortune upon others.”
His face fell. “Then we have coerced you into it. Bullied you to it.”
Bilbo snatched up his hand with both his own. “No! You are my friends! I would give all, if necessary!”
“Oh, Bilbo.” His thumb brushed comfortingly against the back of his hand. “Please be a little selfish. We have no right to call ourselves your friends if we make you spend yourself so dearly for our sakes.”
“You don’t understand. I must intervene. I can’t bear the cost of standing idle and watching… tragedy, if I can prevent it. I am selfish, Thorin. So selfish. I am spending my strength, yes, but my heart would break completely should I ever allow my friends to come to a terrible end.”
“But a dragon.” His face turned back towards the shadow of the mountain looming to the north. “Oh, by Mahal, Bilbo. I haven’t any idea what I’m asking of you to keep us all alive against a dragon.”
Feeling brave, Bilbo drew their joined hands to set upon his knee. He rested his curls against Thorin’s broad shoulder and Thorin let him.
“Well. With any luck, perhaps the old thing has long since perished in its sleep?”
Chapter Text
Smaug was not dead.
All who witnessed the horror would relive it in their nightmares for the rest of their lives.
Smaug flung about the treasury, cascading mountains of gold coins and jewels as his long neck snapped after retreating dwarves. Smoke spilled from the dragon’s throat, showing promise of the fire slowly building within his gullet. The air surrounding the dragon’s chest shimmered with such heat, they all felt it like a burning smelter of iron.
The Company divided themselves into three, each group straining their agility to the limit as they struck and then retreated from the enraged dragon’s teeth to allow the others to strike in turn. A softer creature would have eventually succumbed. But dragon scales were like stone, like iron. The dwarves’ weapons could not draw blood. It was too much. Thorin shouted, and Bilbo did not know the Khuzdul word, but he recognized its meaning: retreat.
Smaug thrust his horned head among the scattering dwarves. Bombur made not a sound as teeth closed around his middle, but he gamely battered at the dragon’s snout as the beast raised his head higher than the trees. He tossed the dwarf into the air and snapped him down with a single gulp like a dog playing with its food.
In a move perhaps even more foolhardy than running towards Azog the Defiler himself, Bilbo ran at the dragon. With a wordless shriek of rage disproportionate to his size, he flung his hands onto the dragon’s scales.
Smaug flung his head back with a startled jerk. He shuddered. His great claws dug reflexively at the gold. Smoke then spilled out his nose, black and billowing. It clouded over all but his glowing amber eyes.
“What. What are you? You tricked me.”
What would have been a bellow was a gasp. Staggering, shuddering, the dragon collapsed atop glittering gold. His wings spasmed. Smaug rolled over in his death throe and went still.
There were no cheers. A few dwarven gasping coughs. The smoke pouring from the corpse’s snout was black and oily. They stared, their weapons slowly slacking in their upraised hands.
Bilbo alone was full of movement.
“Quick! Get him out! Bombur! Get him out!” He helplessly hacked at the dead dragon’s throat, his little sword throwing a few sparks, but unable to pierce dragon hide.
He didn’t see the dwarves watching him in shock.
Bilbo clambered over sliding piles of gold and braved the billowing smoke to crawl between open teeth longer than his entire body. He coughed and gagged, but boldly tread towards the back of the beast’s throat.
Bofur tossed aside his hat and ran after him. “Wait! Bilbo! You won’t reach by yourself! Let me grab hold of your feet!”
Bifur was shook and he huffed a few staggered words of Khuzdul and followed.
Glóin’s eyes bugged at the sight of living dwarves crawling into a dead dragon’s smoking mouth. “They’ve gone mad! They’re going to suffocate or burn!”
Clutching at his chest with horror in his eyes, Balin still managed to be the most logical head among them. He opened his mouth once, shut it, and then said slowly, “We must retrieve Bombur’s body for burial. I surely do not wish to do it now nor later, but it may be preferable now before it is digested by the beast’s stomach juices.”
Thorin held his head in his hand. He heaved a great breath and choked a little on the smoke. “Balin, Dwalin, see what can be done about the ventilation before we are all smothered. Glóin, Nori, go down to the forges and fetch fire suppressant. I fear that thing will burn its own flesh like a candle if we cannot put its fire out. Kíli, Fíli, go to our packs and fetch rope before Bilbo gets himself irrevocably stuck down its throat. Dori, Ori, we will take up our sharpest weapons that have any hope of splitting that wretched beast’s hide. Óin, advise us. Where is the most likely spot to begin a dissection?”
The entire operation lasted well into the night. Clever dwarven engineering throughout the mountain allowed various vents and shutters to be opened or closed to channel the smoke from the treasury and directly out into the open air.
The dragon’s scales could not be pierced, but they could be chiseled. They were much aided by Óin’s discovery of a chink in the scales of the corpse’s breast.
“Likely a wound gained when the foul beast took Erebor. To think, an arrow could have slipped through and stilled its heart! Would’ve saved us all a fair bit of trouble, but for an arrow.”
After hammering away a line of scales, they slit open the cavity that sat between neck and sternum, but it exposed to the air a thick oil that flickered into an unnaturally hot open flame. The prodigious heat drove them all out of the treasury and into the corridor. They had difficulty smothering it since every shovelful of sand and fire suppressant melted to glass at the first, but soon it was so buried, the flames finally smothered into a haze of smoke.
With the fire out, the corpse grew cool enough to hack into its stomach. Once the scales were pried or broken loose, the dragon’s hide cut like immensely thick leather.
Óin seemed the least bothered to cut through bloody muscle to uncover Smaug’s stomach, so the dwarves let him direct the final stage of recovering Bombur’s body.
“Curious fibers,” said Óin as he sawed through yet another thick cord as thick as his finger snaking through the dragon’s veins. “If I didn’t know better, I’d say a tree rooted itself in the damn dragon’s circulatory system while it slept! That is, of course, ridiculous. I suppose dragons simply must be built different than other creatures.”
Bilbo tried not to look like he knew anything was the matter. He ignored the dwarves’ side-eyed looks.
Óin said to nobody, or perhaps only to himself, “The beast must have been in a torpor for a century until we woke it. Its viscera haven’t any signs of digestion yet, thank Mahal.”
“Thank Mahal,” several in the Company echoed in grim mutters.
Bifur held Bofur tight to his breast so his cousin could not watch his brother’s body spill out onto the gold.
Reeking with dragon spit and blood and foul oily smoke, Bilbo slipped on bloody gold coins in his haste. He crawled across Bombur’s corpse and cradled his bearded face in his hands. He cried. He wrapped all the heavy emotion surrounding him into his fingers and forced together all the love and grief he possessed and could feel pressing against him from every side. He prayed Yavanna it was enough, it was not too late. He caught it all up in his hands and forced it to bloom into new life.
Bombur blinked. They all stared. He sat up. Bilbo groaned and fisted his hands against the knives of pain driving through his stomach. He slid a little way down a clinking mound of gold coins.
Bombur’s strangled voice was hard to hear, but they all heard it. “Bofur, Amad wanted me to tell you she thinks Galathâl daughter of Bakhâl would be a nice dwarrowdam to make your wife, but I told her that was a terrible idea.” He blinked again, the hoarseness of his voice now gone. “What’s the matter with Bilbo?”
Glóin cursed.
Slowly regarding the open dragon corpse above him, Bombur took a breath and held his blood-stained belly. “Did I get eaten?”
With a yelping sob, Bofur leapt upon his brother and then all was noise and commotion.
When Bilbo was next aware, he awoke to the disconcerting discovery that he was naked, freshly washed, and wrapped up in a terribly musty-smelling blanket. He was pillowed on a truly ancient eiderdown near a warm coal fire burning in a round iron stove.
“Are you awake?”
“Mmph,” said Bilbo.
“Fee! He’s awake!”
He felt strong hands hoist him to a sitting position and a mug of cool water was pressed to his lips. Under normal circumstances, he would protest such manhandling, but a great weariness leadened his limbs to the point that scratching his nose was a difficult endeavor.
“My clothes seem to be missing,” wheezed Bilbo.
Fíli’s sheepish smile lifted one side of his mustache. “We didn’t think you’d be too happy with us, but we were all so fouled by blood and gore and smoke—we couldn’t very well leave you in filth while we cleaned ourselves.”
“So we toted you down to the public baths with us and washed you along with our laundry!” said Kíli cheerfully.
Bilbo wasn’t sure how he felt about that. He shortly decided if he were to get upset, he would get upset later, because he hadn’t any strength to build up a decent head of steam right at the moment.
“Thorin said you were out for two days last time you did this.”
“How long?”
“Four days. You’ve really worried us, Bilbo. We could get you to drink a bit of broth or tea from time to time, but you’ve been completely out.”
“It was the size of that dragon, I think, and then Bombur, of course. Managing both so close together, well, it was a lot.”
“You killed the dragon. That’s astonishing. But then you—you—” He searched for the proper word and came up empty.
“You unkilled Bombur,” said Kíli. “That’s impossible.”
“Yeah,” agreed Fíli. “Impossible.”
He shrugged, and the movement did not come easily. “It’s what hobbits do.”
They fed him a few mouthfuls of bread and stew and Bilbo slept.
The next he awoke, Bombur was hovering nearby. He tried to ignore the brown bloodstains and recently mended tears bisecting the dwarf’s wool tunic.
Bilbo felt stronger. He was able to sit up under his own strength with only a bit of a wobble. Quiet and efficient, Bombur carefully propped him up with Bifur’s pack and his own bedroll. He fetched water to drink and Bilbo’s clothes, now clean and mended tidily with tiny dwarven stitches. After he allowed him some privacy to dress himself, Bombur tucked him right back under the blankets and set Bilbo up with some cold roasted meat and potatoes.
Roast rabbit and fried potatoes was likely the finest dish Bilbo had ever tasted in his life, and likely it was the tastiest he would ever eat, since he had no intention of ever again going four or five days without a proper meal and thus season his meat with hunger.
Bombur fussed over the food supplies, and then began to tidy up this chamber the Company had obviously taken for their new camp. He again fussed over the food, and then gave it up for a half-hearted attempt at sweeping the stone floor.
“Bilbo,” he finally rasped, his voice heavy with emotion. “I do not know how to speak. Because of you, my children are not fatherless. I am forever in your debt—”
“No—no, none of that, if you please,” interrupted Bilbo. “Not that I don’t value your thanks, because I do, and you are indeed very welcome. With all my heart, you’re welcome! But I am spared too much thanks for doing what any one of the Company would be perfectly willing to do, if only he could. You owe me no debt for a gift freely given to my friend.”
Bombur held the handle of his broom, his knuckles white, and shifted uneasily on his feet.
The hobbit shook his head and insisted kindly, “It is my gift to you. Not a miracle. Not dark magic. A gift.”
A slow, shy smile bloomed across the dwarf’s whiskers.
“He is awake?” Thorin stood in the arched doorway. A dwarven king standing within his ancestral halls, Thorin never looked more properly in place than in this moment, no matter that he was crownless and dressed in his travel-worn leathers and fur.
Bilbo looked away quickly and pretended he was much interested in the ceiling. He noticed for the first time the stone surrounding him was expertly carved in beautiful geometric lines crossing the arched ceiling and running along every straight line of the architecture. At every intersection of lines, little crossed battle axes or swords decorated the stones. He wondered if all dwarven motifs were so martial or if this large room had been allotted to soldiers for some purpose. Flecks of quartz (Bilbo knew it was quartz only because Bofur had repeatedly described to him the look of it in finished rock) shone in the firelight like sunlight glinting off a distant, wind-touched lake. Bofur was right—it was very pretty.
“He woke not long ago,” replied Bombur. “He has a good appetite and says he feels well.”
Bilbo gave a little wave. “I am right here, y’know.”
“You are awake,” wondered Thorin, coming closer as if to see for himself.
“Bombur just said that.”
“In Thranduil’s dungeon, I thought you had awoken several times and I was mistaken several times.”
“Oh. I feel quite well, thank you.”
Bombur bobbed a little on his toes. “Shall I go tell the others?”
Thorin gave a curt nod.
He set aside his broom and happily bustled toward the door.
“Bombur?”
He halted in the doorway and looked back.
Thorin stared steadily at the hobbit. “There is no need to hurry.”
Bombur looked from Thorin to Bilbo and back again. He fought against a knowing smile and bobbed his head in a nod. He left.
Bilbo could not withstand his stare. He wandered over to the table set near the iron stove that apparently now served as their kitchen. He vaguely thought to himself how something as simple as a flat piece of wood elevated campfire cooking into something resembling cooking in an actual kitchen.
“Hobbits are not lucky,” said Thorin.
Bilbo’s fingers skirted about the Company’s collection of battered tin cups, straightening their already tidy, straight lines. “I don’t think so, no.”
“You lied to me.”
“I am sorry for that. I should have told you the truth when we first met and then asked for a promise of secrecy in return, but I did not like the prospect of it.”
Thorin frowned and although no words accompanied it, Bilbo understood it to mean, Why not?
“I did not wish to become the Company’s hobbit. I wished to be your friend. How could I ever be certain if any of you liked me rather than merely valued what I could do for you?” He shook his head with a mutter to himself, “Not that I had any confidence I could do enough for you all.”
Thorin was standing very close now. Bilbo turned and felt his back pressing into the table. He swallowed and bravely met the dwarf’s eyes.
“I am foolish,” said Bilbo. “I knew this whole endeavor was dangerous, ill-fated, and had a dragon at its end, and yet I still underestimated how frequently death would dog our heels. I hoped perhaps I wouldn’t need to intervene at all. But then the first few—they happened while we were chased by goblins or orcs or by spiders... well, there was hardly time to have a proper sit and explain it all.”
“You could have told me in Thranduil’s dungeon. We spoke a great deal about many things.”
“I fought so hard to win your regard, I didn’t wish you obliged to me.”
“I already knew you saved my life from the white orc.”
Bilbo scoffed. “Even I understand there is a difference between saving a life and resurrecting a dead dwarf. I didn’t want you to fear me.”
Thorin gaze suddenly faltered. He stepped back unconsciously and shifted on his feet uneasily, as if the reality of his death had not until that moment occurred to him.
The hobbit’s smile was sad. “See? It is too late. All is changed between us. It is always so between hobbits and other peoples.”
His heart was breaking even as he tried to offer a friendly smile, perhaps one of his last to offer. The dragon was dead, his contract fulfilled. Gandalf would arrive at any day now and would surely be willing to escort him back to the west and the Shire.
“I am very sorry, Thorin.”
He turned away, his sight trembling with tears standing in his eyes. Bilbo felt fingers catch his arm and he was helpless to resist surrendering to a pair of strong hands holding him close against a warm dwarven chest.
Thorin’s voice was low and carried a slight shake that was not usually present in his measured words. “I ardently wish for all to be changed between us, but not like this—not you turning away, not this ache in me.”
“How… how do you wish things to be changed, then?”
A kiss pressed against Bilbo’s lips. It was soft, tentative.
When he looked into Thorin’s eyes, he saw fear there—but not fear of Bilbo or his awful magic that straddled the divide between life and death and called for souls to stand forth. The dwarf feared his going away. He feared Bilbo would reject him.
Bilbo felt a tremendous upwelling of love that had nowhere to go. There was no life to revive, no flowerbed to make bloom, just a swelling of love for Thorin who stole his breath away.
He rose on his toes, threaded his fingers between locks of dark hair and gave proof that Thorin had nothing to fear. Their kiss was passionate, long reserved by them both since neither believed until this moment their growing emotions were mirrored in the other.
Bilbo felt a thrill of pleasure to feel large warm hands move across his back and hold him close. He felt the heat of Thorin’s body. He felt the thrilling press and movement of warm lips across his own. It was obvious neither of them had much practice in such arts, but they made up for their mutual lack with a great deal of enthusiasm. Bilbo felt shivers to hear the quiet little moan overwhelmed by bliss torn from Thorin’s throat. He gasped for air as they broke their kiss and Thorin pressed a row of small, breathy kisses along the side of Bilbo’s neck. He gently kissed away the tracks of his tears until they were no more.
They held each other for a long while, panting and allowing their racing hearts to slow, and basking in one another’s warmth.
“Does this mean you forgive me for lying to you?”
“I do not wholly understand your reasoning, but I understand it was not born from malice. I forgive you. Let us have no more secrets between us.”
“No,” agreed Bilbo, “no more secrets.”
They smiled at one another.
Then Thorin’s eyes fell downward to the stone beneath them. “Is… is that normal for hobbits?”
A large bursting halo of lichens had bloomed around Bilbo’s feet, a pretty mottle of faint greens and white and orange. It quite encompassed half the room.
He laughed in delight. “Normal, but uncommon. I was feeling a great deal of sunflowers just now, but they couldn’t possibly grow on bare stone, so it all came out as lichens instead.” With a grin, he pressed a tiny kiss to his mouth and murmured, “Next time, kiss me outside at the foot of the mountain and I will give you an entire field of tulips!”
Thorin gazed at him in adoring wonder.
They heard Bofur chortle from down the corridor, “Ooh, is our little sleeping laze-abed awake?”
Thorin and Bilbo quickly turned away from each other, but not without a shared look of happy conspiracy. This was theirs, their secret, their pleasure. They would tell the others in time, but for now, this new fragile bloom held between them would be theirs and theirs alone while it branched and grew roots.
Like a faunt unwilling to be caught being naughty, Bilbo hopped onto his bed. He felt a little glad for the opportunity to sit down. Bofur, Bifur, Nori, Balin, Dwalin, and all the rest piled into the chamber, alerted by Bombur their burglar had finally awoke. They greeted him with happy and dwarvishly loud exclamations.
Bofur wagged a finger at him, “Lad, what would your mother say if she knew you were lazing the sunshine away here in your bed?”
He grinned at him around a mouthful of dried apple, “My mother would be quite pleased with me, under the circumstances.”
“I’m so relieved,” said Bofur with a suddenly strangled voice, and then the hobbit found himself half smothered by a fierce dwarven embrace. But Bilbo did not mind because he was accustomed to dwarvish embraces by now and he much preferred it to affectionate head butts.
Bombur then scolded his brother for handling Bilbo too roughly while the poor hobbit was just trying to eat his dinner.
Still kneeling beside Bilbo’s makeshift bed, he swept off his hat, took the hobbit’s hand and set it on his head. Every dwarf grew still and silent.
Bilbo had no hope of understanding the fervent Khuzdul tumbling from Bofur’s lips, but he understood enough. He snatched his hand away.
“No!” he said quickly. “No, thank you, all the same.”
Thorin, who had been haunting the periphery of the crowded chamber, rumbled quietly, “Hobbits do not accept life debts. It is an insult to them to do so.”
Bombur added, “Because hobbits don’t think them debts. They’re gifts.”
“Just so,” nodded Bilbo. “I expect no payment for a gift. Otherwise, it’s not a gift!”
“A life… gift?” said Bofur slowly.
He took a steadying breath. There was no use pretending anymore. They all saw Bombur swallowed by a dragon. There was no excusing that as a mere brush with calamity, which good luck had turned into an escape. Bilbo twisted a corner of his blanket in his trembling hands.
“Yes. We call it Yavanna’s Gift or the Gift of the Green Lady.”
“Can other hobbits do what you did for Bombur?”
“Of course! It’s common to all hobbits.”
Looking overwhelmed, Bofur sat on the floor. Bilbo patted his broad shoulder with an uneasy smile. He did not like the way Bofur stared. His friend was frightened.
Nori now understood what Bofur had just now realized for himself. He held himself very, very still, his gaze fixed upon Bilbo. “Bofur fell at the goblin’s back porch. I saw him. I thought I saw wrong, but I didn’t. He broke his neck.” Nori gave him a calculating, uncertain look. A little piece of Bilbo’s heart broke to feel that look upon him. “And you did something. You brought him back.”
All smiles faded. Bilbo nodded.
“Oh, by Mahal’s grace,” gasped Dori. “Bombur was not the first and Bofur was not the only other!”
Bilbo nodded again, feeling tension creeping into his spine and making his hands feel jittery. He twisted his blankets in his fingers and felt a few ancient threads snap.
“I was too late to reach you, Dori. With the spiders, I mean. I apologize. I tried, I really did, but there were just too many.”
Nori made a little choked noise in his throat. Bilbo ignored it and his eyes swept across the rest of the Company who were peculiarly solemn.
“The barrels? You were right. It was an awful idea. Terrible. I should’ve tried a different way. Balin, Ori, and Óin were all knocked about by the rapids and drowned.”
Bofur fiddled with his battered hat in his big hands. “Is that why when we reached the shore of Long Lake, you were staggering ‘round and vomiting like you’d been too hard at the cider?”
“It’s not easily done, so many in a row. I’m honestly not certain I could’ve managed a fourth.”
“You’ve no hobbit remedy for orcish poison?” asked Kíli plaintively. Fíli clutched at his arm.
“Well, yes, I do. But it’s not an herb. It’s me. The tea I gave you alleviates nausea.”
“By the very beard of Mahal!” exclaimed Óin. “How many of us didn’t die?”
Bilbo frowned, and his eyes flicked across the Company who looked as grim faced as he’d ever seen them. He willed his voice to be brave. He replied quietly, “Bifur, Dwalin, Glóin, Nori, Fíli—and me, of course.”
He could not understand the burst of low mutters in Khuzdul, but he recognized distress, astonishment, fear in the voices of his once friends who obviously could not hold him in friendship anymore. He wore the face of a harmless little hobbit, and it was a deception to them, now. His magic was too foreign, too unknown, too frightening.
“Harkulul!” Thorin’s sharp word of retort immediately silenced them. “The wizard insisted our fourteenth—our lucky member—should be a hobbit. I disagreed. But I now freely admit my error in judgment. We needed a hobbit. Our need is as obvious as the fact we live and Smaug is dead. Bilbo’s presence is a blessing of Mahal. You are fools if you do not see a truth so plain.”
They stood in tense silence and Bilbo felt their stares upon him. He kept his eyes fixed on the stones at his feet. The flecks of lichen there looked out of place. Lichen never grew on stones inside mountains away from the sun, he thought. Nothing grew there.
The eldest dwarf prince was first to break their silence.
“You killed the dragon, Bilbo,” said Fíli plainly. “There’s no use pretending he up and keeled over on his own. His lungs, his veins, his heart—they’re all full of some kind of vine!”
“Yes, well. I didn’t know I could do that. I’ve never heard of a hobbit doing such a thing in a living body rather than a good bit of dirt, but it just felt right in the moment.” He shrugged. “I might have panicked. Just a bit.”
“How is it possible?” wondered Ori.
“Mahal has his children. Yavanna has hers. We’re a less ancient and less storied people, but we were given her gift to use.” He gestured vaguely, “Hobbits make things live and grow. I made things live and grow.”
“Inside the damn dragon’s inner organs?” exclaimed Glóin.
The corner of his poor blanket was coming apart at the seams by his nervous fiddling. He shrugged again. “It seems so. If you plant what’s left of him before the ground freezes, you may have a very nice blackberry bramble next autumn.”
At his side, Bofur blinked in astonishment. “Blackberries… Smaug was killed with a blackberry bush?”
The dwarves looked at one another with incredulous stares.
“Blackberries?” echoed Glóin.
The entire Company bubbled into giggles and then howls of laughter.
Above them all, Bofur crowed, “Lad, your battle standard will bear the mighty blackberry! For what other shrub has ever downed so terrible a beast as the last great fire drake of our age!”
That shattered the tension. To Bilbo’s profound relief, things went back to normal after that, more or less. He was once more the Company’s burglar, and once more they were at ease in his presence. All his doubts vanished like smoke on the breeze.
Thorin, however, made them each swear by their beards they would hold hobbit secrets as carefully as they did dwarvish ones. He explained the Shirefolk would be in danger should any one of them speak carelessly, and what poor recompense would it be if the Company should bring danger upon Bilbo’s kinsmen since he had carried them out of danger himself so many times? Without hesitation, they all made their oaths.
Bilbo might have shed a few tears to be given their trust so freely.
Now that they had all their number back, they made a celebration of what remained of the day. During the past four days, in between their bloody task of cutting the dragon’s corpse to pieces and hauling the carrion outside for the ravens to eat, as well as searching the treasury, someone had explored Erebor’s cellars and found wine and brandy that had not gone to vinegar. They found fine instruments in the treasury, too, so they had wine and music and dancing and what passed as a feast for travelers accustomed to road rations.
Kíli was the first to notice, and he didn’t notice until late in the night. “Say, was the floor in here always speckled like that?” He took a pull of his tankard, “Strange how it’s so round! It’s pretty. Like a starburst!”
Bilbo caught Thorin’s glance from across the room. They shared a secret smile that the rest of the Company would tell them in later years was not half as subtle as they thought it was even if they were all mostly drunk.
The next morning, Bilbo went into the treasury and found the Arkenstone. ‘Til the end of his life, Bilbo could never decide if his discovery of the unnaturally beautiful gem was done by either luck or the dragon’s lingering curse.
Notes:
Khuzdul is borrowed from the always fantastic Dwarrow Scholar.
Harkulul! Enough!
Chapter 4
Notes:
With the time jump here, it kinda looks like I forgot to post a chapter. I decided the story didn’t need a whole chapter on the gold-sickness/Arkenstone betrayal since I decided not to vary much from the events in canon. These final two chapters allude enough to those events that I’m confident y’all will be able to pick up on the bits of narrative that did vary from canon without it being narrated.
One difference I don’t explicitly explain anywhere last chapter (I don’t know where that info could naturally fit) is that Thorin is still himself four days after Smaug’s death, but in canon, he’s affected by dragon sickness almost immediately upon entering the Mountain. I figure he was so focused on/worried about Bilbo’s well-being, he was able to unconsciously resist the gold without any trouble, but the moment everything seemed OK, he let his guard down and got himself sucked into the gold lust and didn’t surface again until the Battle of Five Armies already started.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
It wasn’t many days after everything fell apart when Bilbo held his hand tight across Fíli’s mouth and called him back. He felt the heat, the burning sensation of ruptured organs, pierced flesh, shattered bones all rejoining themselves to be whole. Fíli’s body jolted in his arms, and he felt a sudden surge of panic when the dwarf instinctively gasped for breath and found he could not.
“Shh, Fíli, quiet!” he murmured in his ear, unable to keep his voice from shaking. “Please for the love of Eru, keep quiet!”
Fíli’s head bobbed up and down in a shaky nod. Bilbo lowered his hand. The young dwarf breathed heavily, silent tears striping the grime on his cheeks.
From the all-too-shallow hollow in the rock and screened by low scrubby trees naked of autumn leaves, Bilbo and Fíli sat and watched the orcs. There were dozens upon dozens of them milling about the watchtower ruin on Ravenhill.
Fíli clung closer and Bilbo didn’t begrudge him. Others in the Company had thought themselves merely lucky. They believed they had a near-miss, a brief black out, and some lingering aches. But Fíli knew—he felt the blade run him through, he felt the ground rush towards him when Azog dropped him from the top of the watchtower—he knew what it meant to wake in Bilbo’s arms. He held the trauma of dying in his hands. Of course, the young dwarf would quake and tears roll down his face to disappear into his beard.
“Easy there, Fíli.” Something was drawing the orcs away. The closest of them were now too far away to hear the murmur of a frightened hobbit. “Azog didn’t see me. He thinks you are dead. He won’t come back here to capture you again.”
“Bilbo… how could you?”
Feeling bewildered and a little dismayed, he pulled back to look Fíli in the face.
“We cast you out,” frowned Fíli. There was blood in his beard. “We banished you. We let Thorin descend into the worst of the dragon sickness and did nothing to protect you from him. We were jealous of our gold, and some wretched corner of our hearts were glad he did it. I… I do not deserve your friendship. How could you come here into danger to rescue me?”
Bilbo clucked his tongue like a mother chiding her child. “Of all the ridiculous—! I am angry. Upset. Hurt. But what makes you think I would ever abandon you? Of course, I would come!”
A cautious joy lit his eyes. “It is a battle. You are not a warrior.”
“Lucky for us, I am not,” he sniffed. “You didn’t need a warrior just now.”
They both shrank down into the meager shadows. A pair of shambling orcs passed far too close, but by a miracle, Bilbo and Fíli remained unseen or were perhaps mistaken as a pair of corpses tangled up in the embrace of their death throes.
Grimed fingers explored the bent armor where Azog’s blade had pierced him through. “Is… is that what it was like for the others?” Fíli asked in a small voice.
“What was?”
“Dying.”
“You’ll have to ask them. I’ve never died before.”
“Really?”
“Is that so hard to believe?”
A wry smile lifted a corner of his mustache, “The way you hobbits can simply unkill a fellow! Well, if I’d been born a hobbit, me and Kíli would’ve died a half dozen times each before arriving at our majority.”
He scoffed with a little shake of his head. “Calling someone back… it does not come so easily.”
“You are too modest. You unkilled over half the Company! Other than Bombur, it’s not been any great hardship for you.”
The look Bilbo gave him was so exasperated and cross that Fíli instantly understood he had said something at best ignorant, and at worst cruel.
“I don’t know what it’s like to die, but I know what it is to call the dead back to life. It hurts, Fíli. Life is not cheap.”
“I’m sorry.”
He sighed and scruffed a hand through his sweaty curls. “You didn’t know any better. I’m sorry I snapped. It’s been a tiring day.”
He fixed Fíli with a considering look. Fíli patiently returned his gaze without saying anything.
“In the Shire, we have death. But if circumstances are right and the right hobbit is found in good time, well, we have a little less death.” He shook his head, “You don’t understand how extraordinarily lucky you’ve all been! By rights, I shouldn’t have been able to do it at all.”
“Why not?”
“It’s just not done. It’s not able to be done. It—it belongs within family, you see. With kin.” He felt a blush creeping up his neck.
It wasn’t hard. After seven months together, they were all his dwarves. He’d shivered, starved, complained, fought, sung, teased, and worried with the whole Company. He dared to hope that, by now, he was their hobbit, because they were certainly all his dwarves. It was easy to love them.
He cleared his throat and said, “One must have… a certain regard for the other, otherwise they won’t hear you call.”
By the warm grin slowly dawning on Fíli’s face, he obviously understood more than he let on. He teased, “Maybe dwarves are simply very good listeners.”
Bilbo grumbled, “Dwarves are not very good listeners in life. What makes you think death would ever change that?”
His smile vanished. Bilbo sensed the shift, too.
Fíli tilted his head. “I think they’ve gone.”
“I don’t hear anyone, either.”
They crawled to the edge of their hiding spot. Not a single bat flew in the sky. Emboldened by the distinct lack of orc in what was once Azog’s center of command, they rose to their feet. Fíli staggered. Bilbo wordlessly served as his crutch. Treading through footprints left by orcs not even an hour past felt eerie, dangerous, like walking across cursed ground. They left the ruins behind.
There they spotted Dwalin below on the ancient stairs. Warhammer in hand, he gave chase to a pair of clearly demoralized orcs, and he disappeared behind a turn in the stones. Further below the ridge in the opposite direction, on the flat of a small frozen lake, Thorin fought Azog. Thorin was flagging. The way he limped, he was badly injured. Even from here they could see the spread of blood on the white ice.
“Thorin!”
Bilbo stopped him. “No. Fíli, no.”
“But Thorin—”
“Fíli, you shattered both legs, a hip, and part of your spine. You’re going to be wobbling around like a newborn calf for a time. It’s not a matter of desire or will—you were wounded and cannot fight anymore,” Bilbo fingers curled around the edge of Fíli’s breastplate, and he gave him an emphatic little shake. His stern words quelled the rebellious look that flashed in Fíli’s eyes. “I gave you a good gift. Don’t be ungrateful. Don’t throw it away as worth nothing.”
He breathed hard for a long moment and then the tense line of his shoulders relaxed. Humbled, Fíli asked, “What should I do? I will not hide while I’ve been given strength and breath.”
“Go to Dwalin. Maybe find Kíli while you’re at it. Get to where it’s safe. Go help Óin with the wounded—you’ll be useful there. They will need every willing hand to save the lives of the wounded.”
“Wait, aren’t you coming with me?”
“I’ll help your uncle.”
He hissed, “Azog will kill you!”
“I’m not stupid. I won’t let him touch me. I’ll—I’ll chuck a rock at his head!”
Fíli frowned at such a shallow and problematic battle plan as chucking rocks and hoping for the best.
“I’ll be careful and quick! Go on!”
Bilbo turned away, but a hand caught over his bicep and tugged him back. Fíli gently bumped his brow against his. He echoed softly, “Be careful, Bilbo. Be quick.”
“I will,” he smiled reassuringly. It was the first he had smiled in days, and it felt like a white lie.
The rock was a stupid idea. Bilbo’s aim was spot on. The first rock made an impressive thunk of stone on flesh and bone noise, but the second aimed at his skull was batted away by Azog’s bladed arm as easily as if he was swatting away a gnat.
“Perian,” he laughed, and the black words he then snarled made no sense to Bilbo, but they enraged Thorin.
Wounded, his strength spent, Thorin threw himself at the orc with abandon, screaming aloud in Khuzdul that needed no translation. Azog countered and he was brutal.
It was over so, so quickly.
The stink entered his awareness first. Then a throbbing headache. Then stiff aching muscles that did not want to move. Finally Bilbo’s eyes opened and clouded yellowed eyeballs stared back.
He jolted with a gasp. He scrambled backwards, away from the dead orc, but a rough living hand tipped with claws closed around his arm.
The orc eyed him closely. Dark shadows surrounded them, but the light from a nearby campfire was enough to illuminate his ragged features. The orc was very large and wore a small hoop of carved bone in his lip. The guttural words upon the large orc’s lips made no sense to Bilbo, but then he supposed it didn’t matter because the words were obviously not directed to him.
At his captor’s call, a few other orcs approached. One wearing a black-bloodied bandage over one eye looked very closely at Bilbo and he roughly seized his jaw so to slowly wag his head back and forth as he examined him. The one-eyed orc with no sense of personal space then said something—maybe he was merely clearing his throat? Whatever it was he said was apparently satisfactory because Bilbo’s captor hauled him up over his shoulder like a sack of potatoes.
A little startled gasp burst past his lips, but Bilbo strangled back any other sounds.
From his distressing vantage point on the large orc’s shoulder, he could see he was somewhere away from the battlefield, away from Ravenhill, away from the Lonely Mountain. He hadn’t any idea if it was just after sunset or the wee hours of the morning. It was difficult to tell the exact hour by the grey pall covering over both moon and stars. The only reason he could see anything at all was because there were bonfires scattered among the orcs and his sharp eyes could see shadows and the glint of firelight on pale stone and snow. It was rocky here, with great snowy pines pointing upwards, and by the size of the stone cliffs on either side, Bilbo understood they were in a canyon. He heard more than saw a narrow swift stream limned with ice hugging the canyon wall. A shelf of stone and frozen earth rose above it, and strung along that narrow shelf, lay the orc camp.
Orcs were everywhere. Bilbo had been plucked up from what he supposed served as an orcish healing camp, though it looked more like a convenient out-of-the-way spot designated for orcs to either die or lick their wounds for a while. Curious eyes rested upon him as they crossed through a hundred or more orcs resting among ratty tents and wagons and traveling weapons forges and cookfires. He saw no proper shelters, very few blankets. They built their fires high because that was all the warmth and shelter afforded them on a frozen night. Nearly all bore wounds. All stared at him with hate and some bit of curiosity.
Love was important for a hobbit’s survival, and the sensation of such bare hate roiling about him like a terrible flood nearly suffocated him. He trembled.
He was carried up a dark incline to a large sturdy tent. The large orc barked a word of command. A skinny little orc holding a lantern pulled back the tent flap, stared up at them, and disappeared back into the tent with a flick of canvas.
A brief moment later, the skinny orc reappeared and held open the tent flap. Bilbo was hauled inside and immediately dropped to the dirt. It was warm here. Warmth tingled painfully in his fingers and ears. Flames flickered in a rough round stove set in one corner. Bilbo slowly picked himself up. A wild inclination to run like hell nearly overtook him, but he knew it useless. There was no escape for Bilbo Baggins—not in the midst of an orc camp, not when he could hear a very large orc breathing nearby.
Bolg loomed over him. His smile had no joy in it, only satisfaction.
“Perian,” he said, and Bilbo felt he just might vomit. “You will revive him.”
Bilbo’s gaze followed Bolg’s outstretched claw to the massive pale bloodied corpse of Azog the Defiler laid out on the floor of the tent.
He stared at the corpse. He dared to meet Bolg’s gaze. “I do beg your pardon?”
“Revive him. My own father watched you revive that wretched dwarf king months ago, so I know the stories are true. It can be done. You will do this now.”
Bilbo’s legs shook with a refreshed desire to flee.
“I don’t know what stories you’ve been told, but it doesn’t work that way. I, uh, I can’t revive just anybody. If the deceased has been, well, dead too long, they won’t listen when I call. They’re simply too far away to hear me.”
He twisted his bloodied dirt-worn cuff. “And, er, the body needs to be whole. I can’t very well grow somebody a new head, now can I?”
He cleared his throat, feeling stares as sharp as blades. He felt himself blush and felt furious at himself that he could possibly feel embarrassed in front of an orc as if he cared what such slime thought of him. “And perhaps most important, most difficult of all, I must feel… a certain regard for the deceased.”
“You must love the dead one,” said Bolg.
“Well, yes.”
“Have you no love for my father?”
The hobbit’s curled lip to survey the pale body lying between them was reply enough.
Bolg laughed. It was a terrifying sound. “I hold no love for my father, either, but I wish him alive. We have stories, perian. I know these things.”
He barked a word of command in black speech. The large orc left, but almost immediately returned with another dragging a dead body between them.
“Kíli,” gasped Bilbo.
Bolg’s blade swung to halt between his eyes. Bilbo’s outstretched hands dropped to his sides. He shut his eyes tight in self-recrimination.
The orc chuckled like a man winning an uncertain gamble at cards.
An indescribable dread curled in Bilbo’s stomach. Bolg hadn’t known. Bolg hadn’t known for certain until this moment that Kíli meant anything to him.
It was just like the stories of the last age, the dreadful stories of kings of old who kept hobbits as their pets—their slaves. The old selfish kings, as well as this blasted orc, knew exactly how their unloved dead could be revived by a hobbit’s love. They knew how that bloom of life could be stolen. Bilbo’s breath shuddered in his lungs. This was why hobbits stayed in the Shire. He dearly wished he had stayed, too.
The orcs dumped Kíli’s corpse next to Azog’s dead body. They looked like a bloody parody of bedmates curled into one another in repose.
“Our stories say you can do this. Let it be done, perian.”
His heart beating in his ears, Bilbo looked at one body and then the other and stubbornly thought this was a horrific scenario he could not have possibly anticipated when he signed his contract back at Bag End, though perhaps he should have known it was inevitable. And how many hours had it been since their lives had fled? Had it been over a day? How long had he laid unconscious?
Bolg’s small scoff was impatient. “If you are useless to me—”
“No. No, I understand,” Bilbo said quickly. “Just. I need a moment to gather myself.”
Warily eyeing the orc’s outstretched blade still rusted with red blood, he circled round the corpses and fell to his knees next to the mortal remains of Kíli.
He would try.
Kíli did not look well in death. There was no peace in his face, just unnatural slackness covered with dried blood and grime. He gently straightened his limbs. They felt so heavy without any life in them. His muscles were stiff. Dried blood flaked onto Bilbo’s pale hands. He stretched himself across the dwarf. He had been dead so long, no warmth remained in his chest. He shut his eyes.
He flailed with a squawk when a strong hand plucked him up by the back of his coat and dumped him sprawling on top both dwarf and orc.
“No trickery. I will kill the dwarf again and again until you get it right.”
Bilbo raised his head and stared at Azog’s clouded eye. His stomach recoiled to be so close, his imagination expecting fetid breath and a snarling curse between sharpened teeth. Bilbo lay so close, his breath melted frost from its eyelashes. He hadn’t any idea orcs had eyelashes.
Trembling, he wriggled until he rested one hand on the orc’s bare neck, and he turned away and pillowed his head on Kíli’s empty chest. That apparently satisfied Bolg since he did not rearrange them again.
Bilbo wasn’t sure he could do it. He desperately wanted Kíli alive, but he didn’t want Azog to be dragged alongside to share this breath, this life, with him. Kíli would surely hate him. He would likely rather stay dead if it meant the cursed creature who murdered his uncle, his grandfather, his great-grandfather remained dead in whatever pit of hell orcs were resigned to in the hereafter.
Tears sprung to Bilbo’s eyes. He let Thorin die. He couldn’t bring him back. He tried. He failed. His hurt was too much, too big, too impossible for love to dissolve and allow life to return. Kíli will be so sad to live without his uncle who had been to him as a father. Bilbo’s regret and shame felt like blades.
“I’m sorry,” he whispered into Kíli’s tunic. “I’m sorry I’m not enough.”
He seized this emotion muddled with grief and shame and made it grow. He heard a cold heart thud beneath his pointed ear. Beside him, new black blood swelled in a sword-pierced heart. Flesh knit under his fingers. Lungs rose and fell under him.
Then a roar.
His sight briefly blacked out, but he held onto enough of his consciousness to be aware of being thrown aside and hearing the clash of weaponry. He woozily opened his eyes. He felt nearly crushed. A strong arm held him tight. He was shaking—no, the arm holding him was shaking. Kíli held him and the dwarf’s muscles shook and shuddered. His other hand was upraised with a blood-blackened stone in his fist.
Bilbo peeked above the dwarf’s shoulder since Kíli had him shuffled almost completely behind himself. Azog, that hateful thing, was alive.
Bolg was laughing, his sword held between Kíli and Azog.
The orc’s father sneered, a new trickle of blood running down his temple. He growled something in hoarse black speech.
Bolg’s reply was a rough purr. But the longer he regarded his father, the darker grew his frown. His sword swung towards them.
Kíli’s grip grew firmer.
“I warned you against trickery, perian. Did you not believe me?”
“He’s been dead!” snapped Bilbo. “He’s cold! His muscles are shaking off their death stiffness! Put him to bed like a reasonable creature. If you remain unsatisfied in the morning, then you can go ahead and kill me.”
“You will not die,” said Bolg. His head inclined towards the dwarf. “He will.”
A bark of command and orcs swooped upon them. Bilbo swallowed back a choke of fear. Harsh claws attempted to separate them, but after an ineffectual fight while dwarven limbs wrapped around him so tight Bilbo swore his ribs creaked, the orc kicked Kíli in the side with a curse. They were dragged off together.
Far on the other side of camp, away from the firelights, they were flung into a narrow space within five iron grates padlocked together like a triangular coffin.
With a guttural curse and gesture of good riddance, their orc jailors disappeared into the darkness.
On his knees, Kíli rattled the grates. They were rusted, but they held.
“I’m no lockpick and neither are you,” said Bilbo with a weary sigh. “Come here. Let me warm you—best I can, anyhow.” He could not see his expression in the dark, but after a pause, he heard him crawl over the metal grates.
Bilbo tutted as he laid down and pulled a shivering dwarf to rest his head on his chest and his frozen hands in his coat. “After what you’ve been through, you should be put to a soft bed warmed with hot flannel-wrapped bricks, at least two cups of tea poured down your throat, and allowed to sleep for a week!”
“You s-smell like h-hobbit,” Kíli mumbled into his breast.
“Well, you smell of unwashed dwarf, yourself, but somehow I was polite enough not to mention it.”
A small laugh shook his shoulders, but it bubbled into sobs.
He was reminded how very young Kíli was. By rights he should not be in battles with orcs before his beard had even come in.
He murmured into his hair, “Oh, my dear. My poor lamb. I am so sorry.”
Remembering the nights in Mirkwood when he’d spied Fíli soothing his younger brother, he gently combed his fingers through his hair and rubbed at his shoulders wider than any hobbit’s until, finally exhausted, Kíli cried himself to sleep. Bilbo kept awake the long night through and watched for orcs.
Bilbo kept his arms and his coat wrapped around the young dwarf, but he knew poor Kíli could hardly feel rested sleeping here in the frozen air and the cold terror of being caged at the edge of an orc camp. A thin line of grey dawn brightened the tooth-edged top of the canyon walls. All was in shadow, but day was coming.
Kíli rubbed at his eye and with his mussed hair, Bilbo thought he must have a good idea what he looked like as a small child waking from a nap.
“How do you feel?”
“Sore. Thirsty,” he grunted.
“That’s to be expected.”
Kíli stayed reclined on Bilbo’s chest. It was warmer for them both and the confines of the cage would force him to stoop slightly if he sat up fully.
“Bilbo?”
“Hm?”
“I didn’t see anybody the first time.”
“I called for you right away the first time,” said Bilbo. He didn’t need Kíli to clarify what he meant. He stroked his hair gently and thought he felt his shoulders relax. “I watched you very closely at Beorn’s. I didn’t let you linger for fear you would be frightened. You saw someone this time, then?”
“My uncle Frerin. I didn’t realize I was dead at first, and I thought to myself, ‘just who is this dwarf hanging on me and crying?’ He died long before I was born.”
“That’s a rare thing. If anyone greets you, it’s nearly always someone you know.”
“Frerin told me Thorin was an idiot—well, it doesn’t translate right. The Khuzdul word he used is a touch crass, but he meant ‘idiot.’ And he hadn’t any idea what my mother was thinking by letting me follow him.” He breathed a great gusting sigh that momentarily warmed Bilbo’s skin. “I didn’t see any Halls,” said Kíli into his chest. “Are they real?”
His fingers combed through long dark hair and worked down his spine. “I don’t know,” he replied quietly. “If there are Halls of Waiting, by the time a soul reaches them, they are too far to hear a hobbit call them back. All we have are glimpses. Small snatches of conversation with loved ones now dead.”
Then he sounded sadly resigned. “I’m surprised Uncle Frerin was there at all. I rather expected Fíli.”
“Oh! Fíli’s not there!”
The young dwarf looked at him. Hope lit his expression with the strength of a bonfire.
“I sent him limping after Dwalin toward the Mountain.”
Delighted, Kíli laughed, “Oh, Bilbo, I could kiss you right now!”
Aware that he was essentially pinned beneath a dwarf who outweighed him, as well as caged so neither could so much as stand, Bilbo sighed, “Please don’t.”
He did it anyway. It was a happy loud smack of scruffy lips on his cheek and Bilbo thought his ribs might give out by the way Kíli embraced him.
“Oof, yes, that’s quite enough!”
Kíli grinned, “I know you don’t like the idea of life debts—”
“A life debt is an insult to both me and the Green Lady.”
“—but you do realize you are as good as family, now! Right, Uncle Bilbo?”
All good humor instantly crumbled like burnt ash. “Please don’t call me that.”
“What’s the matter?”
Bilbo’s face crumpled. “Kíli… I couldn’t… I tried, but I couldn’t… Thorin…”
“Uncle Thorin is dead?”
He felt wretched. “I’m sorry.”
Kíli settled his head back on Bilbo’s chest. He didn’t speak for a long while.
“He treated you very badly, didn’t he,” Kíli said in a voice made hoarse with emotion. “We all did by letting him do it. It all went bad so fast.”
“All standing up for me would have accomplished is two being banished from the Mountain instead of one. No, I don’t blame any in the Company one bit. Not you. None of them. I’m sorry.”
“He shook it off, did you know?” He raised his head to look Bilbo in the eye with the most heartbreakingly earnest expression. “If he had lived, all would be made right between you, I’m sure of it! He was his old self again once he realized what he’d done to you and then that an army of orcs had arrived. The shock of it all put him back in his place. It was like watching machinery gone out of calibration, and after a good whack of a mallet, the pieces all reseated themselves back into their fittings!”
Bilbo did not understand the metaphor, but he understood enough.
“We did speak.”
“You did?”
“He was dying. He’d killed Azog, but not before he was struck through with his blade.”
Poor Kíli breathed, “Oh, Uncle!”
“He wished to take back his words and deeds at the gate. He told me he would part from me in friendship. He asked for my forgiveness.”
“Did he have it?”
Bilbo nodded, the tears welling in his eyes finally spilling over and wetting his cheeks. “He bid me farewell and said if more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merry place.”
“You made Uncle happy, Bilbo. Fee said so at Laketown.”
He sniffled and wiped his cheek against his shrugged shoulder. His father would have been appalled. “At Laketown?”
“There was always a restlessness in Thorin—just underneath, y’know? But for the first time, at Laketown, he was content. I thought it was because we were almost to the Mountain. But Fee spotted it: he was happy because he was with you.”
“I tried. I am so sorry, Kíli. I will regret it for all my life.”
As he lay dying, Thorin, that stubborn dwarf, told Bilbo he was unworthy of his gifts. With his dying breaths, he insisted if Bilbo called for his soul to return, he would refuse. Bilbo would never repeat those final words aloud—it is better Kíli believe a hobbit’s hurt to blame and not his uncle’s own self-recrimination. Desperate and grieving, Bilbo called for Thorin again and again, and then all was oblivion after a thrown stone struck him in the head. The next Bilbo knew, he was held prisoner by Bolg’s orcs.
With a sickening turn of his stomach, he wondered if the orcs had left Thorin’s body. If the corpse remained intact, even though it had now been a day, maybe two… he choked back a sob in his throat. It was too late. Too late.
“I’m sorry,” murmured Bilbo into Kíli’s hair. “I’m so sorry.” He did not know if he was apologizing to Kíli or to Thorin who was now where he could not hear.
Again, Kíli was quiet for a long while.
“I don’t blame you, Bilbo. Not one bit.”
The young dwarf was so sincere, it was all Bilbo could do to hold him and weep.
Notes:
Everything is made all better in the next chapter—I promise!
Chapter Text
Sunrise barely illuminated the winter sky to a light wash of blue when the orc came. He carried a tin pan holding stew of questionable provenance. The slop looked grey to Bilbo, and he strenuously questioned the orc’s source of fresh meat so soon after a battle, but it steamed in the air, so perhaps the pan could warm frozen fingers since its contents were obviously inedible—
“Ready?” said Kíli under his breath so quietly Bilbo wasn’t sure if he was talking to himself or not.
The orc unlocked a pair of padlocks and lifted a grate.
He wanted to ask, Ready for what? but instead he yelped in horror when Kíli tackled the orc.
Heedless of blade, heedless of danger, he wrestled the orc to the ground. The orc struck back with a squeal. The strength in Kíli’s limbs shuddered and failed. He gasped, unable to draw breath. With a rictus of fear spasming across his face, Kíli reflexively pawed at the blade in his ribcage and died.
Bilbo shot outside the cage. He brained the orc with a stone. Hampered by a dead dwarf and a corner of the rusted grate, the orc could neither loose his dagger from its fleshy sheath nor his tangled feet. He mercifully fell limp by the fourth blow.
Quivering, Bilbo focused on his anger. Because anger was what he felt most strongly right now. The feel of hot black orc blood on his skin nauseated him. He heaved Kíli’s body off the dead orc. He abhorred the sensation of hauling backwards with all his weight to pull out the bent orc blade stuck between sturdy dwarven ribs.
“Next time dwarves swarm my doorstep, I will shut the door. No contract, no adventure,” muttered Bilbo.
He dropped the loosened dagger.
“I’ll feed them, that’s fine, of course, but I will stay home!”
He clutched at Kíli’s body. He felt new warm blood seep into the thigh of his trousers.
“You stupid dwarf,” he said as his friend heaved a pained breath. “What if I couldn’t call you back again? What if his knife had broken off in your gut? What if you had hours of agony before dying? What if he’d killed us both?”
For a gasping moment or two, Kíli closed his eyes and shivered. But then he looked at Bilbo and a wan smile lit up his features.
“I knew you could do it. And if not”—his attempt at a shrug looked labored—”I already had a second and a third chance to live. I’d be greedy to expect a fourth just for the asking.”
“And yet you asked for a fourth!”
Bilbo wrapped his arms around his ribs and wheezed a little. His heart muscle hurt.
“I’ve never heard of anyone being called back so many times, not even in old winter’s tales! Don’t you dare go for a fifth. I expect you to live to be old and grey, understand me? You must live long enough to get your beard in!”
“I will try.”
He sat back on the stones with a sigh, catching his breath as he rubbed at his chest. Kíli looked deeply grateful to sit for a few moments, too.
“Anyone there this time?” wondered Bilbo.
“Adad. He said he didn’t expect to see me so soon.”
“No, I rather think not.”
“He hadn’t time for any more than that and a kiss I am to share with Amad and Fíli.” He gave a shy smile. “It was nice. He died when I was so small, I barely remember him. But now I have a face and a voice to think of when I think of him.”
“Thorin wasn’t…?”
His smile vanished. He shook his head. “I wasn’t gone long.”
“No. No, I suppose not. Can you stand?”
Kíli could stand, but he was hobbling.
Bilbo himself felt like crumpled wet paper that’d been stomped on a few times. Every bit of him ached and felt sore and moved so slowly, never mind the lingering pain of Fíli’s death, Thorin’s death, and both of Kíli’s deaths. He felt run through more times than a pin cushion. The bones of his right hip he knew were not feeling right. He blamed it on Fíli and hoped it would not slow them much. He took as deep a breath as he dared and tried to work out the new hitch in his ribs.
Kíli regarded the canyon walls deepening with shadows as the morning sun strengthened. “We’re boxed in.”
“Are you sure we can’t go that way? Away from the orc camp?”
“It’s impassable up canyon,” he scoffed, as if it were as obvious as painted words on a signpost. One brow rose and he favored his Uncle Thorin when he did so. “Unless you happen to be able to scale a sheer rock face?”
Bilbo sighed.
“We’ll just have to sneak through camp,” concluded Kíli with a note of optimism that sounded a little forced. “Hobbits are good at sneaking. Tharkûn said so.”
“I think Gandalf was marketing my services as a burglar. Hobbits are quiet only because we don’t wear noisy shoes.”
But Kíli thought Bilbo modest. He told him so later when they were resting. Kíli claimed he must be better than Nori at sneaking by the way he knew that bandy-legged orc was coming and yanked them both under the cover of some low scrub oak before they were spotted.
“Hobbits have good hearing. Orcs have bad eyesight. That’s all,” muttered Bilbo.
They managed to dodge the orc passing their way, and he did not know if they would be lucky enough to dodge a second, when they saw two, three, six scattered orcs appear, shouting at one another and clearly upset as they hurried past.
He whispered, “Is the camp being attacked?”
Kíli stared after the retreating orcs in the golden morning light. “No… Azog’s dead. He just pitched over dead into his plate of venison.”
Bilbo blinked at him.
“I can’t speak Black Speech, but Balin made sure me and Fíli can understand it. Is it a coup, you think?”
He lifted a hand to his lips in sudden realization. “Oh!”
Kíli frowned at him.
“When… you died—again—it snuffed out Azog, too. Another day or two, perhaps, and it wouldn’t have happened.”
Now it was Kíli’s time to stare.
Bilbo shrugged. “Life, especially new life, is fragile.”
Kíli giggled, clutching at his pained ribs, and it was a strangled noise.
“You scolded me when I deserved your praise! ‘Slayer of Azog,’ that is what I am!”
“Does the title count if you didn’t mean to do it? Everyone will think it was rotten venison what did him in.”
He nodded a head in the direction the orcs had gone. “That lot thinks Azog’s been murdered. Or the fates wished him to stay dead. Or that ‘Perian’ fellow did it. Perian—who is that? Do you know that name?”
“No, it’s Sindarin. It means ‘hobbit.’”
“Uh, oh.”
They both realized at the same instant that those orcs were sent to check on their prisoners locked up beyond the far edge of camp.
“We need to run,” said Bilbo.
“I don’t know that I can run,” grimaced Kíli.
“We need to move as fast as possible, then.”
They hobbled. Quickly.
Following the edge of the boot-stamped path southwestward through the orc camp, they stumbled from scrubby tree to tattered tent to the cover of a wagon. The wagon was filled with armor.
Even Bilbo, who was unaccustomed to war, contemplated the assemblage for only a scant moment before realizing the broken and bloodied armor had been stripped from the dead. Most was orcish. A hollowness sat uncomfortably in his gut to spot man-sized leather helms and good dwarvish iron and deceptively delicate plate armor belonging to elves.
Kíli had the clever idea of wearing a pair of orc helms and tattered wool gambesons as a disguise.
They stank. Horrifically.
But, as the old hobbits say, hungry faunts don’t get to choose the menu.
Kíli attempted to don a coat of orcish plate to complete the effect, but Bilbo convinced him the unnecessary weight would not do them any favors. The helms would have to do.
They skirted the dead and dying gathered in the orcish healing ward. Bilbo held Kíli close and shrank back in the shadows as two arguing orcs stumbled past them, one still struggling to put on a rusted chainmail shirt. The camp’s collective inattentiveness preserved a really rather obvious dwarf and hobbit unheard and unseen.
Bilbo’s hip and ribs were screaming for relief. The rock to the head he sustained yesterday wasn’t kind to him, either. Kíli clutched at his chest and constantly wheezed like he could not get enough air. They leaned against one another acting as a mutual crutch as they stumbled toward the mouth of the canyon, toward safety.
A great gong sounded. It rang out as melodious as a spoon struck against the bottom of a cookpot. Everywhere, orcs halted, raised their heads, and looked towards the center of camp. An orc bellowed a command in black speech, and the words were echoed and repeated by every orc from one end of camp to the other until all heard the command.
Bilbo didn’t understand the muttered words that fell from Kíli’s lips, either, but figured he well enough knew the meaning of Khuzdul expletives without asking for translation.
Orcs streamed to the center of camp. Hobbit and dwarf both kept their covered heads down. As one little orc strode past, he smacked Kíli on the helm with a sneering word.
Bilbo murmured, “Did he just say, ‘You’re going the wrong way, dummy?’”
“Ori said you had an ear for languages!” wheezed Kíli.
Arms linked, they fell into a hobbling rhythm forward as they held each other upright.
“How long do you suppose before they notice us?”
“Not long.”
Bilbo dared a glance backwards over his shoulder. In the distance, he spied Bolg’s distinctive profile standing at the head of a great many orcs.
The ground inclined downwards. The canyon opened out into dragon-ravaged flatlands. The narrow canyon river gurgled onward through the snows. There in the distance they spied the snowy Lonely Mountain, and beyond it to the south, a thin edge of Long Lake glittered in the sunshine.
“We can’t outrun them. We’ll be out in the open.”
“Thank Mahal orcs haven’t any archers,” grunted Kíli as he lurched forward.
Their lumbering crawl across the blackened snow-drifted grassland was hardly speedy.
“Wait! Wait.”
“We can’t rest, Bilbo!”
He tore the helm from his head and flung it away, sucking in a grateful breath of clean cold air.
“Oh, thank Mahal,” said Kíli, discarding his own helm.
Bilbo helped tug the oversized gambeson from his shoulders.
“I swear that thing gave me lice!”
“C’mon, hurry!”
They moved a little faster being less encumbered.
Bilbo Baggins had faced wargs, goblins, untrustworthy elves, and stared a dragon in the eye. But his fear then did not compare to the shudder of fear trembling down his spine when a hundred orcs shrieked their battle cry behind him like a many-throated demon.
They hurried between a jagged slope of stones, and his stomach somersaulted with hope and relief, because he saw another armed force running towards them.
“Bilbo!” A thin cry hailed them with vigor. “Kíli!”
He felt nearly deafened by the strength of Kíli’s returning bellow, “Fíli!”
With swords, axes, spears all raised, the dwarves, men, and elves swept past Bilbo and Kíli. In the same moment, the orcs behind surged forward. Erebor and orcs clashed together in a wavering line like two opposing waves crashing in the sea. Bilbo felt caught in a maelstrom of war. The shouts and clatter of iron arms rang painfully in his ears.
Their would-be saviors were not many, some few dozen able-bodied soldiers who could be spared to rescue one pitiful hobbit. They couldn’t have possibly known about Kíli. It was far more than Bilbo could have ever hoped for.
The orcs were in poor shape—wounded, exhausted, demoralized—but they were vicious, and they heavily outnumbered their rescuers.
A dwarf fell with a strange high-pitched cry. An elf collapsed to his knees as an orcish blade pierced him through a flaw in broken armor. A man at the fallen elf’s side summarily beheaded an orc with a single mighty swing, but in the downstroke, another orc buried an evil-looking ax into the man’s back.
There he recognized Bard struggling with a nasty orc, and there he finally spotted a few of his own helmed dwarves in the fray: Fíli, Glóin, and Nori and Ori. Glóin fell. Then Nori. Ori screamed and flung himself at a knot of orcs, his war hammer flashing.
His heart pounding in his ears, Bilbo shook his head, feeling dazed. He could not reach them. They were too many. They would all die here. All would bleed and die in these barren frozen fields. Kíli had one hand knotted in the lapel of Bilbo’s coat as if scared they would be parted. Perhaps he wished to shield him again with dwarven flesh should it prove necessary. Wheezing, Kíli swung a stolen bloodied orc blade in his other hand to defend them both.
No, thought Bilbo, and the thought reverberated in his mind like a song. No more. No more blood will be spilled here. His poor hobbit heart would not permit it.
With all the righteous fury that drove him to recklessly lay his hands on a dragon’s burning scales or charge at Azog the Defiler, he dropped to his knees and plunged his fingers into the half-frozen dirt. He screamed out to all who could hear and spent himself to the very last farthing.
That was the last he remembered for a great long while.
All was light.
“Bilbo? Wake up, my sweet pea.”
“Ma?”
The scent of green growing things was in his nose. An unseen summer sun warmed the air and the cool relief of a shady spot of grass cushioned his weary soul. Bilbo’s mother sat beside his head as if he had merely awoken from a nap after a picnic.
“Oh.”
He sat up.
“It is you!”
They embraced. He felt home and comfort and security, and an old, old aching loss was finally healed by his return to his mother’s arms.
She looked the same as he remembered from boyhood: dark curls, laughing eyes, and pretty dimples in round cheeks. No age shriveled her face into leanness and spotted her thinning skin. He saw not a single hair of the white and grey that overtook her curls in the years after his father died. Her prodigious age finally came upon her after her heart broke at his departure.
“You’ve found Dad again, I see.”
“Yes, love,” she smiled at him, petting his curls. “I am very happy. We both are.”
He sighed happily. “I’ll be glad to see him.”
“It’ll be a few years yet for that, dearest.”
Bilbo frowned at his mother, “But I’m dead.”
She hummed, “Yes, but no.”
He rested an uneasy hand on his sternum. His ribs didn’t hurt anymore. He felt tired.
“But I used myself all up… Didn’t I?”
“Is that what you think? Us hobbits have a currency to spend, and when it is all gone, there isn’t any left?”
“Well… it feels like it…”
She clucked at him in sad sympathy. “You’ve been under tremendous strain, poor lamb. You’ve exerted yourself a great deal in very little time.”
“I’ve had a tough go, lately.”
“Shall I tell you a secret?”
Her cheeks dimpled and her eyes smiled like shining half moons. He fiddled with a long bit of grass at his knee.
“Dwarves have a great many secrets,” said Bilbo.
“So I’ve heard,” replied his mother.
“What is it, then? Your secret you mean to tell?”
She announced impressively, “Your soul… is a garden.”
He squinted at her. “Alright?”
“You think your soul is a little pot growing a lovely vine of tomatoes, but it isn’t. It is a whole garden! You begin with a tiny little garden plot, but you dig and dig about the edges and give yourself more and more room to grow not only tomatoes, but carrots, and melons, and chard, and radishes, and potatoes, and even corn!”
He breathed a laugh at her enthusiasm.
“Alright, so my soul is larger than I’ve been led to believe.”
“Yes. With every soul you love well enough to save, your capacity to love only grows larger. And for every part of your soul you tie to another, means there is another soul tied to you, too.”
She smiled at him and tucked his curls far longer than she’d ever seen in life behind his pointed ear.
“All your beloved dwarves, that little girl—”
“Bard’s daughter Tilda,” he interrupted. “We thought it safe in the ruins of Dale, but there wasn’t anywhere safe, in the end. She was so young! I couldn’t leave her there without intervening.”
“Compassion would allow no less,” agreed his mother.
“No.”
“You’ve many threads, my dear. An entire pretty lacework of souls are all joined through you! Your dwarves, little Tilda, the elf Tauriel, and even the grand old yew tree in the dying Greenwood—all are threads tied to your soul’s garden.”
“Ma, you’re mixing metaphors.”
“Only because they are both true. Don’t be pedantic,” she chided without any heat.
“Sorry, Ma.”
His mother kissed his curls in prompt forgiveness.
“It’s not right that the old folks in the Shire miser their love for their own close kin alone. A hobbit’s heart can fit the whole world in it, if only they try. It’s in the attempt, you see. It’s enough.”
Bilbo sat with her words for an introspective moment before wondering, “Is that how you lived to two hundred and twelve?”
She nodded.
“And that is my secret.” Her bright smile wilted into a sad gaze. “I only regret leaving you behind, sweet pea. But look at how you’ve grown!—at all you’ve done! I am so very proud of you, my Bilbo.”
He basked in the warmth of his mother’s love, and she held him for what felt to be a long, long time.
“I’m very tired, Ma.”
“I know you are, my lamb.”
“It’s very awful there,” he said.
“It’s dreadful,” she agreed with a sympathetic squeeze of his hand.
“I’ve friends. They need me.”
“I know.”
“Can I go back?”
She tsked. “Sweet pea, you’ve been of age for eighteen years, now. You needn’t ask my permission.”
Bilbo amended, “How can I go back? Is it possible?”
She withdrew her arms from around him and looked at him, “What do you think?”
“I’ve threads? In the soul of my garden?” He frowned. “No, wait. They must follow a thread back to me when I call, so why couldn’t I follow a thread back to any one of them?”
Her eyes glittered. “It couldn’t hurt to try.”
He stood and felt grass beneath his feet, although strangely he saw none. He felt as if he was simultaneously occupying space in a great deal of formless nothing, but felt conscious of the comfort of sunshine and sweet breezes and cool grass surrounding him.
“Is this real?”
“Of course, it’s real! Just because it isn’t physically real, doesn’t mean it is not real.”
“Right.” He took a steadying breath. “Threads. To my dwarves. And my little girl and my elf and—perhaps not my yew tree.”
“You’re overthinking it, my dear.”
He looked helplessly at her.
“Haven’t I told you love is like a song sung to many tunes? Your love is what ties you to them.”
“You rely on entirely too many metaphors, Ma.”
She laughed.
He took another breath. He shut his eyes. He settled into the emotions that swirled and overwhelmed him every time he held a broken body in his arms and made life bloom. He thought on Kíli and Fíli’s vibrancy of youth and hope for Bard’s little girl. He thought of Bombur’s fierce love for his children and of Bofur freely offering his friendship. He thought of Tauriel and her desperate fight to live. He recalled each of his dwarves and his devotion to each of them, and he thought with pain in his heart of Thorin. They were all different emotions, but all were interwoven with his love.
A pulsing warmth split his chest open. It was a bizarre sensation. He dared to open his eyes. Feeling very surreal, he saw golden threads shimmering with unearthly light. The threads sunk through shirt and waistcoat and were knotted deep into his heart. They spun out into the distance beyond sight as if they were strung out into forever.
“Ma?”
She looked up at him.
“Yes, dearest?”
“Did you ever call back somebody who got himself eaten?”
She laughed, and the noise of it was a cheerful heartwarming sound.
“Goodbye, my Bilbo.”
“You’ll give my love to Dad?”
“I will.”
He took another careful breath to steady himself for this uncertain plunge.
“Ma? Which one? I don’t know which thread to follow?”
He looked and she wasn’t there. He felt a small thrill of fear to be all alone in this strange place.
“This one here,” said a dwarf who Bilbo did not know.
Startled, he turned on his heel to face him. He stood very close, just at Bilbo’s elbow. The dwarf had dark hair, dark eyes, and a long beard neatly woven with braids. He gently rested a finger upon one of the golden threads strung through Bilbo’s heart. It thrummed in his chest like a plucked harp string.
He repeated kindly, “This one.”
Bilbo looked down at the dwarf’s hand hovering over his heart to examine the shimmering gold thread his finger rested upon.
“Oh. Thank you, Mister Dwarf.”
He looked up again and met his friendly gaze. The dwarf smiled widely.
Bilbo quite lost himself, then. It was very disorienting. He wasn’t sure if he hadn’t dreamed the whole thing, except the memory of the conversation with his mother and the dwarf had a clarity and coherence that did not belong to dreams. He felt cool grass beneath him again, and for a moment he wondered if he hadn’t gone right back to his spot beside his mother’s knee.
He felt extraordinarily muzzy. He fought lethargy and pain and blinked open his eyes. He did not see his mother. The warm arms holding him were not his mother’s. He looked up into the startled face of a familiar dwarf.
“Kíli?” he croaked.
“Bilbo!”
He was sobbing.
Bilbo frowned at him, struggling against blackness crowding the edges of his sight.
He lisped faintly, “Did you know you have your father’s eyes?”
He did not hear Kíli’s reply.
Notes:
Thank you for your patience waiting for that last chapter! I decided what I had wasn’t right, so I pretty much rewrote it from scratch, and it more than doubled in size. So, you get 2 chapters! Actual last chapter coming soon...
Chapter Text
Bilbo slept for two weeks. His dwarves poured broth down his throat at intervals, Gandalf’s magic supported him, and permission was grudgingly given to the elves to assist. But Bilbo did not know that until later.
He knew he woke in darkness. He felt warm. His nose was buried in the folds of what smelled like his musty eiderdown. Since orcs did not have eiderdowns, and the men’s homes along with their beds had all burned, and he could not imagine elves allowing their bed linens to ever become musty, he deduced he must be at Erebor. He was resting in a proper bed. He saw the low glow of fire coals in a hearth. Feeling leadened aching muscles, he struggled and failed to shift himself upright.
A noise. Bilbo was not alone.
“Kíli?” he rasped.
“No. Not Kíli.”
His heart lurched. For a time, his breath did not come easily. He desperately struggled to release his weakened arms from beneath his bedding because everything within him yearned to embrace his dwarf.
Thorin gently wrapped a strong arm around his shoulders and lifted him. It was not an embrace. It was careful steadying of a weakened body as he raised water to sickbed-parched lips.
Bilbo drank deeply, and his relief was immense even though swallowing felt uncomfortable. He stared at him above the rim of his cup, and Thorin resolutely refused to return his gaze. He stared at him gently tucking the blankets around him. He stared after him when he left.
Bilbo must be dead. He concluded he must be dead (escape from a battle so far outnumbered by orcs was impossible), but he could not account for the presence of a hobbit in the dwarves’ Halls of Waiting, because this stone chamber certainly did not belong to Yavanna’s Gardens. Perhaps Yavanna and her husband recognized he would never be happy there.
Thorin returned with warm broth slightly thickened with something vegetable and tasting medicinal. Again securely tucking his arm beneath Bilbo, he helped him slowly drink.
Between swallows, Bilbo severely revised his assumptions and observed, “You are alive.”
Thorin finally met his eyes. “I am.”
“How?”
“You understand how far better than I do.”
“Out on the ice, I kept calling for you and calling for you, but you never came.”
He looked a little guilty. “My brother, Frerin, punched me in the nose. He told me to make amends and not excuses.”
A slow smile lifted the corners of Bilbo’s lips. “I like your brother. He’s sensible.”
He scoffed incredulously, but the noise was fond.
Bilbo swallowed the last of his broth. Thorin set the cup aside and made to reposition him upon the bed to rest alone, but Bilbo did not fight this hard only to relinquish all so easily. He weakly knotted his hand in Thorin’s tunic and clung to his ribs.
With a wary look, Thorin silently capitulated. He settled himself upon the bed with Bilbo reclining in his arms.
“In that matter, I agree Frerin was the sensible one.”
Thorin’s voice rumbled in his chest where Bilbo had pressed his ear.
“He made me return at your call. By the time I regained my wits, you were gone, and I felt so weak I could barely crawl. Beorn found me. He carried me to the Mountain.”
He lifted his head. “Kíli? Fíli? I saw Glóin, and Nori and Ori—?”
“All live. The Company are all well.”
A great tension seizing Bilbo’s shoulders for all this time finally relaxed. His relief was so sudden, he practically felt woozy. He pillowed his curls against Thorin’s chest again and greedily drew comfort from the steady hammer of his heartbeat and the slow bellows of his lungs.
“Every one of the Company acquitted himself well. Fíli, in fact, earned his battle name.”
“He did?”
Bilbo rattled his memory for what grand thing Fíli had done to earn such an accolade, knowing dwarves never awarded the honor frivolously. Granted, he hadn’t a view of every part of the battlefield, but he didn’t know of any mighty struggle Fíli had opportunity to fight.
Thorin must have recognized his puzzlement, because he said, “It happened after—after you parted ways.”
Affronted, Bilbo exclaimed, “I sent him after Dwalin!”
“He went to Dwalin,” replied Thorin calmly.
“And?”
“And he saw the battle faring poorly. He made Dwalin catch a battle ram that lost its rider. He tied himself into the saddle.”
“Oh, that blasted dwarf!”
“Dáin had been struck down—he yet lives and will recover—but he was struck down. The orcs pressed the advantage. But Fíli arrived and rallied both dwarves and men. He inspired them to stand, and he fought as boldly as Durin himself.”
His voice warmed, and Bilbo thought to himself how it was very like Thorin to boast of his nephew’s deeds, but not so much as mention his own battle that slew Azog.
“I’m told it was as if the orcs were dashing themselves against a wall. Fíli did not yield. He would not move.”
“Let’s have it then. What is he now called? His ‘battle name’?”
“Fíli the Well-Seated.”
Gobsmacked, Bilbo stared. “Fíli the Well-Seated?”
“It sounds more grand in Khuzdul.”
“We’ll have to work on that Westron, then.” He suggested, “Fíli the Unmoved?”
Thorin winced. “Mm, it sounds very bad in Khuzdul.”
“Hm. I’ll think on it.”
(Invented by clever Ori some days later, the prince’s battle name he wore all his life was Fíli Holdfast.)
“I owe both the lives of my sister-sons to you,” said Thorin quietly.
Bilbo narrowed his eyes.
“Beg pardon.” He revised, “You gifted us the lives of my sister-sons… several times.”
“They’re young. They deserve good gifts.”
His voice grew rough. “I am inexpressibly grateful for such gifts. I treasure your gifts beyond all others.”
“You’re welcome, Thorin. I’m happy to give.”
Thorin’s face darkened. “I am ashamed. I am the burglar. I stole that which is most precious when it was not freely given.”
“What in all Arda are you talking about?”
“I threatened you. I raised my hand to you. I cursed your name and banished you. How could you then possibly grant my life as a gift?” He shook his head, guilt clouding his features. “I coerced you, just like one of the old kings of an earlier age. In my madness, I told you I would, and I did.”
The memory of it was a cold flutter in Bilbo’s gut, but it passed as a shiver and was gone.
Bilbo said slowly, “I confess, hearing you talk to the others about ‘the halfling’ like I was your possession you intended to keep!—well, it hurt me a great deal. It was then I understood you were wholly lost to gold-sickness.”
Thorin’s voice was hushed and ashamed. “That night in the treasury when you begged me to abandon my search for the Arkenstone and find rest, I stole kisses that were never mine.”
Bilbo turned his head away. “I didn’t like that much, either.”
He could hear Thorin’s heart beating as if he were sprinting for his life and not lying quietly on a bed with his words trembling in his throat.
“I used you most terribly. I do not deserve your friendship, your regard, or your forgiveness. I am not worthy of any of them. I ask you for none of them. But I offer my apologies, and I beg you will accept them.
“Thorin—”
“I pledge no gold, no lifeless gem shall ever rise in my regard above my family, my friends, my people. The cost is too dear, and too late I’ve learned the love of hoarded gold is a cheat that will rob me of my greatest treasures.”
“Oh, Thorin,” sighed Bilbo.
He took no pleasure in the misery clouding Thorin’s eyes. But something in it felt to him like the relief of cool water after a long terrible journey beneath an unrelenting sun. Bilbo then thought of his mother and recalled coming to her once as a fauntling in guilt and apology, and she told him, There, there, my dear lamb, dry your tears. Don’t you know forgiveness is the tune of love with the most beautiful melody of all?
“I forgive you,” said Bilbo. “I accept your apology. Can we be friends again?”
Thorin blinked owlishly at him as if unable to comprehend such frank, plain words. But hardly stupid, he replied huskily, “I would like that.”
Bilbo settled his head more comfortably upon his chest. Now it felt less like he had pillowed himself upon an unwilling dwarf and more like sharing a comforting embrace with Thorin. The heart he heard in his pointed ear steadied into calm, but he could not help but notice the tension in his dwarf’s body refused to be eased into softness. Tentative fingers gently touched his curls.
“That’s nice,” murmured Bilbo.
Encouraged by his words, Thorin slowly carded his fingers through Bilbo’s hair.
“Thorin?”
“Mm?”
“I do wish you would kiss me. I’m a bit too tired to kiss you properly, myself.”
Bilbo felt slow movement beneath him. He felt whiskered lips pressed fervently to his brow. A shaky huff of breath stirred his curls.
He started to move away, but Bilbo’s words stopped him.
“That is a gift I wish none other to give me. I treasure each one.”
“The gift of a kiss is a poor recompense for a gift of life.”
With a sigh, Bilbo raised his head tiredly to meet his gaze. “You insist we are to do this the dwarvish way, then? Fine. Your life in exchange for your kiss. All’s settled now. The debt is absolved.”
“That’s hardly fair.”
“I’m satisfied I am paid in full, because your love for me is not so small, is it?”
Thorin stared at him.
Bilbo did not know exactly what realization Thorin arrived at, but he saw the moment it finally burst upon him like sunlight breaking through the clouds. His expression crumpled and he pressed another shaky kiss to Bilbo’s brow. Bearded kisses rained upon his cheeks, his nose, his lips, his chin, his neck, his eyes. Thorin’s shoulders shook and he wept even as he pressed fervent kisses to his precious hobbit cradled in his arms.
In return, Bilbo was a constant prattle of loving bromides and soft reassurances, and he wished he had strength to raise his arms and pet his hair, but Thorin did not seem to mind the lack. There in the dark and quiet, Bilbo basked in the warmth of Thorin’s love and felt like the richest creature in all the Lonely Mountain.
The following day after Bilbo had slept, bathed, eaten a meal that involved chewing, and tottered about his sickroom just to prove he could do it, the Company invaded his room. Thorin made Bilbo remain in his bed, even though he complained strenuously that it was unseemly to receive visitors while in bed! Dwarves simply didn’t understand these things. But despite Bilbo’s lack of manners, it was a loud, happy reunion. Most of the Company bore injuries from the battle, but none grievous, and he saw for himself both princes were as well as they had ever been.
He did allow himself a moment to yell at Fíli.
Hardly cowed, Fíli protested, “My legs were shaky, but my arms were not!”
After he exhausted his ire, Bilbo leaned his brow against his in the dwarven manner of affection, told him he was glad he was safe and well, and congratulated him on his new battle name. Fíli looked proud.
Late to the gathering, Gandalf joined them. They welcomed him, no matter Bilbo’s little sickroom was already overcrowded with fourteen.
Then Bilbo could not bear his ignorance one moment more. He asked the Company what happened to the orcs.
They quieted and looked to Kíli to answer first, because he had been the closest to everything. Kíli fidgeted with his gloves.
“You screamed,” he said. “I thought you’d gotten stabbed behind my back and fell, but when I looked, there wasn’t any orc there.”
“Then those strange bushy things appeared,” said Ori.
Ori’s arm was in a sling, and three of his fingers splinted, but he had told Bilbo that Óin said with a few more weeks of healing, he would write again without difficulty. Dwarves, apparently, healed faster than hobbits.
“They sprouted up, quick as a wink! I’d never seen a natural plant move like that before,” added Bofur. His head was bandaged and he had actually foregone his hat today because of it. “Where every orc stood, one of ‘em grew up at his feet and curled like a vine, all ‘round his legs, his arms, up over his head—! Never been terrified of a bush, in my life. But those were terrifying.”
The members of the Company who witnessed it muttered in agreement.
“They were not blackberry bushes,” said Fíli, looking grim. “Shiny dark green leaves with thorns—long, thick curved thorns longer than a man’s hand.”
With a shiver, Ori murmured, “It was one big scream, then nothing.”
Bilbo felt stunned. He’d killed Bolg’s orcs? Him, who caught spiders in his smial and released them into the garden? Him, who bought his chickens from market rather than raise them himself despite the price because he didn’t like the thought of wringing their necks? He’d killed the orc who stabbed Kíli, and he’d killed Smaug, too, but that felt different. They killed his friends first, and would have done it again if they weren’t stopped. But that didn’t mean Bilbo didn’t feel dreadful to think on it.
“It was more merciful than what the orcs intended for you all,” said Gandalf quietly, as if he knew Bilbo’s thoughts. “Who knows what mischief they designed. They were not many, but enough to have been a deadly trouble in these lands for many years.”
“Yes. Yes, I suppose so,” said Bilbo, knotting his fingers into his bedclothes. His eyes darted to meet the gazes of Ori, Fíli, Bofur, and the rest ringed about the room. “I’m sorry to have frightened you. That wasn’t my intention.”
“I didn’t notice it,” said Kíli.
His brother scoffed, “I don’t see how you couldn’t notice.”
“Because Uncle Bilbo died!” Kíli blindly reached out for Bilbo and caught onto his sleeve like a child seeking reassurance from a parent. “You didn’t see how he went so pale and limp and just stared.”
“I’m alright now, Kíli,” said Bilbo quietly, patting his hand.
Kíli relaxed.
“Did you mean to do it? With the thorn bushes?”
“I… no. Yes? Perhaps? I wanted to protect you all. Hobbits make things grow, but, um… but not like that.”
Gandalf observed wisely, “Hobbits are not warriors, but there are none fiercer in all Arda when it comes to defending their loved ones.”
“I don’t know about that…” frowned Bilbo.
“Your people have forgotten the deeds of their ancestors in the last age. They once changed the fates of entire kingdoms! And here, a hobbit has done so again.”
Gandalf looked a little smug. Bilbo felt a little nettled.
At Gandalf’s words, the Company all looked solemn and Bilbo’s thrill of irritation shrank into a troubled somersault in his stomach. But then the flutter of his doubts was wholly quelled when Thorin caught his eye. Thorin looked quietly adoring.
“Well, perhaps,” Bilbo conceded grudgingly. “But I doubt I could do anything like that again, even if I tried!”
Said Ori, “We forgot to mention the other plants.”
Bilbo looked at him blankly. “Other plants? What plants?”
“After the orcs,” said Bofur.
Fíli disagreed, “No, it was before. I’m certain it must’ve been just before.”
“It was all at once, wasn’t it?” said Ori with a considering frown. “It seemed all at once. There was so much, it was difficult to tell.”
“What did happen, then?” wondered Bilbo.
Fíli replied, “You yelled, the bushes sprang up, and maybe just before, maybe just after, this massive burst of greenery grew up through the snows!”
“More thorn bushes?” asked Bilbo, feeling even worse.
They shook their heads.
“They were knee-high weeds all filled with little white flowers. What did that lady elf call it?” wondered Bofur aloud to Nori before recalling the name, “Athelas! Kingsfoil.”
“An entire field of flowers,” said Nori.
Óin added, “‘Tis used for healing. ‘Tis mighty useful to have a plentiful supply so late in the season.” He said to Bilbo, “You saved more lives than you know to give us a whole field of fresh kingsfoil.”
“Smelled nice, too,” said Bofur. “Like spring.”
Fíli said, “You and Kíli were sat in the very center. It spread out all around you, like an enormous starburst.”
“And… everyone saw?” said Bilbo hesitantly.
He was glad of the good it had done, certainly glad, but in saving those thirty-odd dwarves, elves, and men, did he just condemn the Shire to an inadvertent evil? He was a hobbit. He understood how gossip spread. He knew his dwarves could be trusted, and he believed he could convince Bard to mind his tongue—Tauriel, too. (He was certain he spied her distinct red hair in the furor.) But all those others—he didn’t know them all by sight, let alone by name.
“They saw me?”
“I don’t know anyone saw you then,” said Glóin quickly, seeing his distress. “You’re just a little fellow, after all.”
“It was all crying and shouting and a lot of happy tears,” said Bofur with a reassuring grin.
Nori said, “The men wondered if the elves did it, and the dwarves thought maybe Tharkûn saved us.”
“But we didn’t say anything,” assured Kíli. “We just carried you along with the wounded. We said you’d gotten hit in the head.”
Bilbo twisted at the hems of his bedclothes. “I just don’t know how you all can be certain I wasn’t seen! Someone must have noticed. They will talk.”
“Everyone was well distracted,” said Glóin. “They all had plenty to catch their attention rather than one little sleeping hobbit.”
“But how many survived? Fifteen? Twenty? You cannot tell me not one of them isn’t going to think on the peculiarities of that morning and not realize—!”
Fíli huffed with a quiet laugh, being the first to understand. “Bilbo, there was far too much chaos for anyone to realize it was all because of you, because you didn’t just kill the orcs—you unkilled everybody else too!”
“Everybody?”
“Everybody,” smiled Fíli. “You saved us. Your secret’s safe.”
In later years, locals called the thorned bushes, “Baggins Rose.” By way of a curiosity, Bilbo sent starts of the eponymous bushes by raven to the best gardeners he knew—Lord Elrond and old Holman Greenhand—but neither could get the unusual plant to take root at all. There were only one hundred and thirty-eight known bushes in all the world, although there were rumors of many more growing further up the canyon.
Baggins Rose bore late-blooming blood-red flowers that adorned the ceilings and walls in great garlands at any proper Ereborian Durin’s Day celebration. It was also tradition in Erebor to give pride of place on their feasting tables to dishes and desserts incorporating blackberries. Blackberry wine, in particular, was always used to toast the king and his brave Company. No one understood why blackberries were so favored, but supposed it was simply the king’s favorite fruit in season because he insisted on it being served every year. The large blackberry brambles at the foot of the mountain were so lush and full at that time of year, it would be a shame to allow them all to go to the ravens.
Menfolk and elves, who did not recognize the day as marking the new year like dwarves did, were always invited to the celebrations to commemorate the death of the dragon, to remember their dead lost in the great subsequent battle, and to reaffirm their mutual peace and good will.
The last great dwarven caravan from the Blue Mountains plodded up the green grassy incline of the Misty Mountain foothills. The caravan of dwarves returning to their ancestral home was not only notable for being the last after five years of hard work and much effort, but because it was accompanied by a small contingent of elves from Rivendell.
“Did you enjoy your visit to the Shire?” asked Elrond sociably as he walked beside Bilbo’s pony, leading his horse behind him.
Bilbo hadn’t any idea how elves made hiking uphill on an over-warm spring morning look graceful, but Elrond did so easily.
“I did,” he said. “Very much so! But it’s changed. Perhaps I changed. I suppose it’s no matter. The Shire doesn’t have the hold over me as it once did.”
Elrond inclined his head that he understood.
“I felt very glad to visit. I think I surprised half of my relations by merely being alive.”
His eyes fixed on a pony wagon up ahead driven by a hobbit. The young hobbit stood on the swaying wagon, all the reins gathered up in his hands, and he expertly guided the ponies around a large stone in his path. He sat and his wife proudly rubbed at his shoulders.
“I still don’t think Prim and Drogo quite know what they’re doing bringing such a young faunt on this journey,” said Bilbo, “but Prim’s the daughter of a Took same as I am, and the temptation for an adventure was simply too much to resist! On the other hand, Drogo thought it a proper thing to do, to come visit for Thorin’s coronation. It’s only polite. After all, it isn’t everyone who can say they’ve a king in the family. But I do fear for little Frodo!”
“Infant dwarves made this journey many times without hazard these past five years,” assured Elrond.
In an exaggerated show of regret, Bilbo shook his head sadly. “I greatly fear Frodo will be terribly spoiled by all his adoptive dwarven uncles.”
They watched one of Elrond’s sons approach the hobbits’ wagon, and the faunt’s mother gladly allowed the elf to abscond with her child on his horse, and little Frodo squealed with laughter as they galloped away.
“Only if his adoptive elven uncles don’t spoil him, first,” smiled Elrond.
Bilbo huffed with a pleased look.
“You will keep them safe on your return journey after the coronation, will you?”
“Of course, Bilbo. Such pleasant companions will make the journey home enjoyable indeed.”
Elrond did not call him Master Baggins, and Bilbo felt glad. It took a good deal of cajoling to convince Elrond they were friends enough to dispense with formality. Elrond was friends with his mother for many years; Bilbo insisted her son was no less fond of him.
Bilbo caught sight of a particularly handsome dwarf in worn travel leathers and furs astride a passing pony. With a caravan of this size, Thorin never felt comfortable if he did not periodically circle up and down the length of it to ensure none strayed or were overlooked. Their gazes met and they exchanged small happy smiles. That smile belonged to Bilbo only, and it never failed to bloom a spot of warmth in his chest whenever he saw it upon his husband’s face.
Thorin glanced at Elrond and gave him a gracious nod before urging his pony onward. Funny how Thorin was far more polite to elves when he felt he approached them as equals and not as a desperate beggar with hat in hand.
“You have gained for yourself a reputation,” Elrond said to Bilbo.
Bilbo shrugged. “My relatives and neighbors don’t exactly understand what could ever compel a hobbit to leave the Shire.” (Though he had a pair of Took cousins take one long, lingering look at Thorin and then mutter that everything finally made sense.)
“I mean I have heard tell of you from rumors spread among menfolk in the kingdoms of the south,” said Elrond.
“Oh? I’ve not traveled much ‘til now. Too busy, no time at home, you see. Are you certain they were talking about me, of all people?”
“They say a great healer has taken residence among the dwarves of Erebor.”
Bilbo grumbled, “I never claimed to be a healer.”
“It’s said he allows hope for the hopeless.”
“I cannot save everybody,” he sighed.
Elrond sadly empathized with an understanding glance.
“We have death at Erebor, same as anywhere else,” said Bilbo. “But I do what I can so we have a little less death, a little less grief, a little less mourning.”
“It must be difficult to offer love to strangers.”
“I try. That’s usually enough.”
Bilbo incorrectly assumed they reached the end of that thread of conversation.
He watched the dwarves prodding big ox-drawn wagons forward, or riding on ponies, or steadily trodding forward on their own iron-booted feet. Some sang as they traveled, singing old hopeful songs of home.
Said Elrond after a long contemplative silence, “You have your mother’s gift.”
Bilbo looked at him, and from his spot in his pony’s saddle, he easily met Elrond’s eyes without either of them needing to look up or down.
“My ability is common to all hobbits, you know that.”
“She loved willingly. That is not common at all, not among any people. I believe she must be exceptionally proud of her son.”
“That is kind of you to say so, Elrond.”
Bilbo knew every hobbit of the Shire pitied him—at least a little bit. His self-imposed exile away from the secure greenery of home must be miserable, they said to one another. But Bilbo felt satisfied. He felt lucky. He had friends and family surrounding him, and although he left dear friends and much-loved family behind, he felt himself flourish like he never had before in new promising fields where he could lay down roots.
“Bilbo?”
“Mm?”
The green mountain slopes were covered in great swathes of flowers of yellow, white, and lavender. It was enough to gladden any hobbit heart.
“It is a mere curiosity, no more,” said Elrond.
“It’s a long way to Erebor. I’ve time to entertain many curiosities.”
“Tell me: did you ever encounter an unfortunate one who found himself eaten?”
Bilbo laughed.
Notes:
Thank you the kudos and comments! And thanks again for your patience while I finished up this fic with an unexpected rewrite.
And not to sound too full of myself, but if anyone wants to write in this AU, you’re welcome to it without asking permission. There’s plenty of room for other kids to play on my playground! If you do, I’d appreciate it if you would click the “inspired by another work” checkbox when you post it.
Thanks for reading!
