Chapter Text
“No.”
“My dear boy. You must reconsider—”
“Gandalf, no.” His hushed voice trembled with tightly tamped down fury. Bilbo had thought his kitchen a safe enough spot to hide from a troop of noisy rude dwarves who were busy in the dining room eating the entire contents of his pantry. Pity it was not enough to hide him from wizards.
The wizard was nothing but persistent. “Their quest will not succeed without your intervention.”
Bilbo cried out, “My intervention is worthless! I am not my mother. She had compassion for any pitiable creature suffering outside of the Shire, but I am not her!”
He furiously chopped carrots and onions and firmly ignored the pleading eyes of the wizard sitting at his scrubbed kitchen worktable.
The hobbit’s thinned lips turned down slightly in genuine regret. In a more measured tone he said, “It’s not that I haven’t any pity. I simply do not believe I have enough.”
His knife stilled. He met Gandalf’s troubled gaze. “You understand, don’t you? I can’t help them. I’m not sure there’s anyone in the Shire capable of being the kind of safeguard those dwarves will need.”
He huffed and turned back to his vegetables with a mutter, “I mean, dragons! They’ll all be roasted! They need common sense more than they need a hobbit.”
After a silence, Gandalf said, “I have known hobbits for a great many years.”
Bilbo could sense a speech swelling in the old wizard’s voice. He stifled a sigh and said agreeably, “My mother often spoke fondly of her journeys with you.”
“She was a kind companion. She was the most compassionate being I have ever met in all my days.”
“I agree with you, obviously.” Eyes narrowing, he gestured with his kitchen knife, “But you can’t think flattering the memory of my mother is enough to convince me, do you?”
“The men and elves of the west protect the Shire, and have done so for generations, and will continue to do so in gratitude for the wonders of hobbits worked in an earlier age.” Gandalf’s voice grew firm, “But I wonder if they have done their duty too well, since hobbits in this age hoard their gift as jealously as a dragon does its gold!”
His shoulders crept up to his ears. He silently consoled himself that the guilt of the Shire’s collective dereliction was surely not his responsibility alone?
Gandalf filched a bit of carrot and munched thoughtfully. “It’s gossiped that adventure is what drew Belladonna Took from the Shire again and again. But you and I know adventure was the furthest thing from her mind whenever she ventured out.”
Bilbo had not missed his mother so intensely in a long time. The hobbit sniffled and huffed and decided to blame the onions. He could not meet Gandalf’s eyes.
“I am not my mother. Truly, I’m sorry I am not.”
But what Bilbo Baggins did not know then as he bustled about and fed hungry dwarves and worried about the eventual disposition of his grand aunt’s West Farthing china and silently fumed over a rude dwarven king, was what miracles would be eventually caused by the great upwelling of pity in the depths of his heart as he sat in darkness and listened to the dratted dwarves sing. That longing for home seeping from their heartbreaking song into his own soft heart, that was enough. That convinced him. Adventure didn’t make Bilbo rush out his door in the morning with a pack in hand and in such a hurry he forgot his handkerchief. He hadn’t a name for it yet, but it wasn’t adventure.
All through the troll incident, Bilbo held in his mind’s eye horrid visions of spitted, roasted, and ultimately partially digested dwarves. He vaguely wondered if his mother ever encountered anything of the like and had merely redacted such gruesome details from his bedtime stories. To his revulsion, he silently calculated and anticipated exactly what he should do first if any of his companions were to be eaten. To his relief, Gandalf arrived before the question shifted from academic to practical, and the trolls became stone without ever eating anybody.
Gandalf privately reassured the Company’s shivering hobbit, “You would have had everything well in hand, I’m sure.”
“Now I know you’re a liar!” he retorted in a sharp whisper. “Not even the most benevolent hobbit in all ages of the world could have had that in hand!”
“Nonsense. You are here for such an eventuality, and I am glad that in the end your intervention was not necessary.”
With head in hands, Bilbo wilted upon a stone with an inarticulate groan.
Rivendell was beautiful. The resplendent gardens wore their finest June herbage and blossoms nestled against graceful elven architecture. The dwarves muttered spitefully about hay fever and flimsy engineering. Nor was the prevailing dwarven opinion lightened any when impassive Lord Elrond’s expression finally broke into a smile to be introduced to the final member of their Company, Bilbo Baggins.
“I am deeply honored to meet your acquaintance, Master Baggins,” he said with a sweeping bow as graceful as a dancer’s. He bowed to a hobbit when the dwarven king merited but a polite incline of his head. (Thorin was hardly polite himself, so perhaps the slight was deserved.) “We have a place for you here if you should ever wish to follow after your mother’s ways.”
“Likewise, I am honored!” Bilbo replied with a polite bow because his mother raised him with proper manners. “But, er, I’m afraid I can’t stay long. I have a contract with these gentledwarves.”
“A contract?” An elegant eyebrow arched upwards. “Is that enough to hold the regard of a hobbit?”
His gaze wavered towards a cool bearded glare belonging to a dwarven king before meeting their elven host’s eyes. He smiled politely. “They insisted.”
Despite dwarvish scowls, the elf shook his head slightly as if to yet again wonder at the incomprehensible nature of Aulë’s children. “Then a contract will have to do. I pray it is enough.”
During their long stay at the elven lord’s house waiting for midsummer moonrunes to show themselves, Bilbo defied the grumbling of one dwarven royal by his frequent morning strolls with their host.
Elrond did not natter on like a hobbit, but talk flowed easily and Bilbo felt deeply gratified by their varied and deeply interesting conversations. Happy memories of his mother was a frequently shared topic of theirs.
The hobbit breathed appreciably at the sweet scent of the season’s final apple blossoms as they walked past trees clouded with white. “Did my mother ever mention dealing with an unlucky sort who’d gotten themselves eaten?”
“If she ever did, she did not mention such an occurrence to me.”
“No. Me either. But I was wondering.”
Elrond raised one brow. “For both our sakes, I sincerely hope you will never come bearing such a tale to me.”
Bilbo huffed.
“The dwarves do not know of hobbits,” observed Elrond.
He held no censure in his tone, but Bilbo heard it plainly. The dwarven Company’s hobbit drew himself up and would have looked down his nose at him if the elf had not stood at such a lofty height.
“They most certainly do know of hobbits! They crossed the entire length of the Shire in my company, after all. I’ve been with them over six weeks!”
Elrond gave him an unimpressed look.
“No,” admitted Bilbo in quiet resignation. “They do not know of hobbits.”
“Do you wish me to tell them in your behalf? Should I speak to Thorin alone?”
“No,” he said quickly. “No, I’d rather you did not. I wish the dwarves to become my friends. If they knew… well, things won’t ever be the same.”
“Is it wise? I fear their ignorance will only cause a regrettable tragedy.”
“We were lucky against the trolls. And those wargs, too! Perhaps luck will be with us yet?”
“May the Valar be willing,” he conceded.
The flowers wafted a fine perfume, the breezes pleasantly shook green leaves hanging overhead, the stream chattered merrily, but for a time none of these beauties were comprehended by the hobbit shuffling at the elven lord’s side.
“Gandalf insists I will do the Company good. I… I don’t think he is right. I am not half the hobbit my mother was.” Careful to avoid meeting Elrond’s eyes, he scuffed his furry toes against the green grass. “Sorry to disappoint.”
They did not speak but tread among paths of mossy stone that wound through hillocks of flowers nodding on their stems.
“I understand the fear of following behind a greatly accomplished parent,” said Elrond suddenly when Bilbo had thought their conversation already finished. “I was quite grown before I came to accept that I am not my father, nor would he want me to be. I would be a fool to expect your accomplishments to perfectly match those of your mother. You will grow into yourself given time.”
“I hope you are right. I haven’t the confidence you or Gandalf put in me.”
“Mithrandir says you are enough. He is fond of saying that small hinges are always enough to open very great doors.”
He sighed. “I am a very, very small hinge, indeed.”
“Nevertheless, he believes you are enough,” Elrond retorted with a kind smile. “So do I.”
Bilbo would never admit it in a thousand years, but Gandalf was right: the Company absolutely required a hobbit’s intervention. He didn’t understand how right until the Company inadvertently camped out on the back porch of a goblin town.
Their unexpected fall was long and the ground unforgiving. Most were saved by the virtue of being asleep when it happened and falling atop their packs or bedrolls. But not Bofur.
There were groans and harsh exclamations of Khuzdul. The sound of Bombur’s cookpot falling down the rocks rang out like a gong.
“Quick!” came the order. “Gather your weapons! They are coming!”
Hobbit eyes were not made for the dark like dwarven eyes, so Bilbo did not see who was coming until fluttering goblin torchlight fell upon them. It was then he saw Bofur, his empty eyes staring upwards at nothing.
It was instinct. A reflex. At the same instant desperate dwarven blades clashed against goblin weaponry, Bilbo flung himself over the dead dwarf—his friend, perhaps his only friend among the dwarves.
When he was a fauntling, his mother told him grief was love sung to a different tune. Love could be happy, or sad, or painful, or patient, or wide enough to fit all the flowers of spring. Love was always the same words, but could be sung to many different tunes. More tunes than you or I can ever name, my dearest, she told him when she tucked him in at night.
Bilbo had never done this sort of a thing in all his life, and being such an odd lonesome sort, he never anticipated he ever would, but he immediately recognized this thrill of shock and terrible throbbing in his heart he felt the moment he saw his friend dead—it was love. He held it. He made it bloom.
The wet-sounding crack of shattered vertebrae rejoining themselves was so loud Bilbo felt the noise of it in his chest pressed up against Bofur’s body, but the sound was lost in the noise of shouting and fighting. At the same moment, he felt a corresponding heat, a fire, in his own neck and back.
“Oh, Yavanna’s mercy!” sobbed Bilbo. His tears broke with a choke when a clawed hand hauled him up by the straps of his pack. Another goblin jerked Bofur’s coat lapels. The dwarf yowled and flailed up onto his feet. The entire Company was overwhelmed, snatched, shoved, howled at by an immense mob of ugly goblins who escorted them deeper into goblin town.
Being smaller than the dwarves and smaller than the goblins, it only took a little sidestep into the dark and a little dodge of grasping claws and Bilbo slipped behind them all. But not having eyes suited for living within a mountain, he misjudged his feet just as an unlucky goblin snatched at him, and they fell together down, down, down into the depths of the mountain.
On the backside of the mountain--after breaking his fall on the unfortunate goblin, after riddling with a monster, after sprinting for his life through the dark by sheer dumb and gutsy luck toward a sliver of daylight and discovering fresh air again—Bilbo rejoined the Company.
Even in the moment Thorin and the others voiced their doubts to his bravery, his suitability, Bilbo frankly agreed with them and felt his heart overfull. He wasn’t brave. He wasn’t suitable. But he promised these dwarves he would help them win their home back, and he told them so there in the midst of the pines on the backside of the Misty Mountains. He never felt more sincere in his life. The echo of feeling seemed reflected in the pleased expressions surrounding him. Perhaps he did have a place among them, no matter how much Thorin frowned. But even Thorin’s frown seemed more thoughtful now than hostile. Perhaps battling goblins, though brief, made brothers of them all. Bilbo had little time for self-reflection, however, because Gandalf hurried them along. They heard the howls of wargs.
Bilbo knew he had made a deadly mistake the moment Azog’s cruel eyes fixed upon him in the flickering shadows cast by the light of burning pines. He bravely held out his little sword, as if that could fell an orc-chief, and crouched between Thorin’s body and Azog.
The orc smiled. What slithering evil was in that slow smile!
“Perian.”
How an orc could make a fair elvish word sound so vile, he would never know.
Then Azog shouted aloud in Black Speech, and whatever it was he said, the orcs surrounding him grew frenzied. Bilbo didn’t think it was his imagination that their frenzy was particularly directed at reaching him and the fallen king. But the Company fought beside him with all their might and then the eagles came.
From the feathered shoulders of the eagle he rode upon, Bilbo worried and peered through moonlight at the limp figure of the dwarven king. He had been so rushed, he couldn’t do a proper job of it. It had been the slapdash work of a moment, and he prayed Yavanna it had been enough. For he knew as the minutes crept into an hour and beyond that there was no hope reviving Thorin now if his soul had slipped away to the Halls of Waiting during the fight.
At the Carrock, Gandalf finished what Bilbo began, and the hobbit’s legs felt weak with relief to watch Thorin stagger upright, in pain, but alive. To his shock, he was then embraced with words suffused with gratitude and apology.
Apologies were also tunes that sang of love, he thought with a happy smile, remembering his mother.
They were battered, with precious few supplies, and still far from the Lonely Mountain, but the Company were all alive. Bilbo felt content.
They had respite at Beorn’s.
When they arrived, the giant bear-man who grumbled at so many dwarves cluttering up his doorstep blinked at Bilbo and gasped in wonder, “Perian!”
And that was that. They were freely given shelter, supplies, new gear, and shared a generous table. The dwarves were so relieved to receive it, that they did not question Beorn’s hospitality.
“Master Baggins? Are you well?”
Bilbo sat in the dewy green cool of the morning in Beorn’s garden with his pipe between his teeth, although he had lost his bag of pipeweed somewhere beneath the Misty Mountains. He opened his eyes and watched Thorin ease himself down beside him to the fallen log that served as his bench.
“Gracious, Thorin, shouldn’t I be asking you that?”
Ignoring his question, he insisted, “Were you injured any in the mountain? By those orcs?”
“No worse than anyone else. We all got our share of scrapes and bruises—and poor Kíli with that arrow, too.”
“You move but slowly. Carefully. Are you sure you are not injured? I will go fetch Óin—”
Bilbo caught at his sleeve and the dwarf slumped back down to the log.
“You are one to talk. You move like a little old man,” he tutted. “Three days ago and I wouldn’t have been able to manhandle you like I did just now.”
Thorin glared at him. But it was a mild glare, so Bilbo did not feel at all discomfited by it.
“I cannot have a member of this Company hiding his injuries from me.”
“I’ve some bruises. They are tender, but that is all,” he admitted. He peered curiously at the other. “What about you? Was Gandalf able to mend your wounds? I don’t think any of the others were close enough to see how very bad off you were. It was a close thing.”
“I… I am well.”
Bilbo turned a skeptically arched eyebrow upon him.
“I blacked out,” he amended. He rubbed at his beard while staring at his boots. He admitted quietly, “I felt your hand on my side. I saw you stand before Azog. I saw him smile. But I’m afraid I don’t recall…”
“No matter,” said Bilbo quickly. “The eagles came about then.”
“I am well enough,” said Thorin. His hand rested warm and heavy on Bilbo’s shoulder.
Some of the dwarves were generous with their touches and embraces, but not Thorin. His physical gestures of comradery were limited to Balin, Dwalin, and his sister-sons. And now Bilbo was included among the number. Something warm and pleasant swelled within his chest.
“I live and breathe because of you, Bilbo Baggins. I will not forget my debt.”
“No!” he said sharply, and Thorin was startled by his vehemence.
“No,” Bilbo repeated more temperately. “There is no debt. Hobbits never mark matters of life and death as something to be bought or sold. It is always a gift given. It is an insult to tally it up like a debt in a ledger.”
Thorin was silent for a moment before he rumbled quietly, “I thank you for the gift.”
Bilbo smiled at him. “You’re welcome.”
The dwarf’s small smile in return warmed Bilbo more than sunshine.
During their stay with Beorn, the hobbit gladly ate his fill at the bear-man’s generous table with the rest. He felt inexpressibly glad to scrub the grime of travel from his body and his clothes, too. The entire Company was in good spirits now that they were clean (or as clean as one got in one’s travel clothes) and with full bellies.
They had all worried for several days over Kíli who suffered after Azog’s attack from an orc arrow in his thigh. They wished hopelessly for Gandalf’s magic, but the wizard had left them for business in the south before they realized that Kíli’s wound was so grave. He grew worse and worse until Bilbo told them that he suddenly recalled an old hobbit remedy. He administered his remedy to the poor boy as a strong tea spooned between ashen lips. Kíli grew worser still in the night.
A great deal of excitement interrupted the Company’s tense midnight vigil when Beorn called them out to drive off an unexpected incursion of orc scouts.
“The Little Bunny must stay here,” he insisted with a growl, and his eyes lingered on the hobbit. “He is useless against orcs, but well-suited to tend to your young one in his sickbed.”
By sunrise when the Company all limped back, footsore and having seen few signs of orcs or wargs at all, Kíli was as well as if nothing at all had been the matter (although he complained of being desperately hungry), and even his inflamed wound was nearly healed over into a new scar.
Óin was especially interested to learn of this wonderful hobbitish remedy until Bilbo pulled him aside and whispered that dwarves were not the only race with secrets. It was a hobbit remedy that required a hobbit, and so the tea was quite useless in the hands of a dwarf, no matter how skilled. Óin frowned at that, but pestered Bilbo no more.
“You ought to drink some of your miracle tea yourself,” urged Kíli as he tucked into a hearty bowl of stewed beans and vegetables and thick brown bread spread with honeybutter. “You look pale, Bilbo.”
“Oh, I’m fine, Kíli. Don’t you worry about me.”
“I bet your tea tastes really disgusting, doesn’t it? Not even hobbits like to drink it!” he laughed.
Bilbo felt a happy warmth to hear that laugh again.
“I don’t remember it,” said Kíli around a mouthful of bread, “but I’m told it made all the difference in the end.”
“Lucky for us Beorn grows herbs in his garden, then, eh?” smiled Bilbo even though he felt a bit weak and feverish that morning.
“Very lucky!”
On the afternoon of their final day at Beorn’s, they were lazing about a summer meadow thick with wildflowers and fat bumblebees. Bilbo knew dwarves usually lived inside mountains away from the sun, but every dwarf he saw stretched happily in the warm sunshine like they had all turned into hobbits. He did not mind it one bit. They smoked the last of their pipeweed and passed around pipes to those who had none.
Their easy talk then took an unpleasant turn to their recent passage under the mountains. Bilbo felt his shoulders grow tense.
“I was clocked out cold, there in the bottom of that goblin cave,” Bofur said with a slightly unsettled look that he was attempting to cover over with a smile. He shook his head, “The strangest thing of it—I thought I saw me amad!”
“In a goblin cave?” wondered Fíli.
“No…somewhere else.”
Bombur leaned forward, longing in his earnest face. “Did Amad say anything to you?”
“She kissed me, and told me I was too skinny and why don’t I find me a nice dam like you did?”
The dwarves laughed. Bilbo did not laugh. Neither did Thorin. Kíli was busy slipping flowers and tall grasses into Fíli’s hair when he wasn’t looking.
Bofur’s smile that was always so easy, did not reach his eyes. “Then she scolded me for dawdling when clearly my hobbit ‘twere asking me to go back so urgently!” He puffed nervously on his borrowed pipe. “Wasn’t that the strangest thing?”
Mirkwood smelled of death. It was an old permeating smell that settled in every murky hollow dip of the earth, in every boggy bit of ground. The entire forest, Bilbo decided, was sick and dying. From his childhood, he heard winter tales of hobbits reviving blighted lands and poisoned wells. But a forest as large as this! Bilbo wagered it would take every hobbit in the Shire to bring it back to life. But he tried. In his foolishness, he tried.
One night, the Company camped beneath a tall spreading tree that should have been a proud monarch of the forest, but now had bits of slime mold oozing from knotholes and craggy bits of bark, and its wood felt peculiarly spongy in some places. Bilbo felt such pity, he rested his hands on its gnarled roots and tried.
He barely stumbled out of camp to vomit up what little he had eaten for supper. He felt dizzy and foul and overwhelmed by nausea. He quite lost his senses for a moment.
“Bilbo! Are you alright?”
When he next was aware, he felt a steadying embrace surrounding him and in the gloom he saw Bofur’s concerned face very near his own.
“Yes,” he croaked. “I think so.”
“You were a bit out of your head, I think. You were asking for your ma.”
“Oh.”
“I mean, I’m hardly a substitute for anybody’s amad, but can I help?”
“You are helping.”
“Then I’ll just stand here for a bit?” His strong dwarven arms held him a little more securely.
“At least until the trees stop spinning, if you would be so kind.”
Bofur stood as steady as a rock and with just as much patience as he waited for Bilbo to gather himself.
After Bofur dragged him back into camp, Bilbo endured Óin’s manhandling and patiently insisted more than once that, no, he did not eat anything growing off the ground. He did not drink the oily looking water. He was not stupid, thank you very much.
Óin finally declared that walking through this foul forest to a hobbit must be like tunneling through weak loess to a dwarf. Bilbo didn’t quite understand what he meant by that, but the rest of the Company apparently did and gave him sympathetic pats on the shoulder. Óin gave him a bit of dried spicy root to chew that settled his stomach. Thorin pressed his waterskin into his hands without saying anything at all.
“Why, there are mushrooms on this tree!” said Ori pointing to a large patch of yellow fungi creeping up the gnarled trunk of their tree. He tilted his head to one side. “I swear they weren’t there, earlier.”
They were all terribly conscious of their dwindling food stores. Dori wondered, “Can we eat them? Bilbo, come see—you’ve the best eye for mushrooms in the Company.”
He barely cast a glance at them. “No. Those are not good to eat.”
“That’s a shame,” said Ori.
“Unfortunate,” frowned Dori. “It would’ve been a welcome spot of luck to have them.”
“No one is to eat anything foraged in these woods,” growled Thorin. “We cannot be slowed by illness.”
Bilbo appreciated how Bofur spread the hobbit’s bedroll between his own and Bifur’s.
“Stay away from Bombur,” he whispered. “He kicks in his sleep like a bad-tempered ram.” He tried to look very wise as if a sleep-twitching Bombur was the worst peril to be found in these woods.
For the rest of their journey through Mirkwood, once named Greenwood, Bilbo tried not to touch anything at all there that was either living or dying.
