Chapter Text
Bilbo did not care for the elven king’s calculating stare. Maybe it was the sensation of spider venom still roiling through his blood that made him shiver.
“A bargain, then,” offered Thranduil.
Thorin’s voice was terrifying for its calm. “For our freedom?”
He nodded once.
“What would you have of me?”
Bilbo wondered if Thranduil would ask for Erebor’s treasure room. He wondered if Thorin would give it. But he already knew in his gut what Thranduil would demand.
“The halfling. Leave him and you dwarves are free to go.”
It did warm Bilbo’s heart a little how openly staggered Thorin looked to hear the terms of the proposed bargain.
The dwarf composed himself quickly and his glower was truly thunderous. “No. He is not mine to give, nor for you to demand. He is a member of my Company. I will not abandon any one of them.”
Thranduil looked upon him unperturbed as if looking upon a small child throwing a tantrum for a ridiculous whim of fancy.
Before he could open his mouth to retort, Bilbo urged, “For pity’s sake, leave me here and go, Thorin! Don’t you see I am captive either way? I will bear my time here more easily if I know you’re all well and free.”
His glower turned on the hobbit. He snarled, “No!”
Thranduil looked bored. “Take the offer, dwarf. Take it and I promise the halfling will be kept well for all the days of his life. I will give him a comfortable room, plenty of amusements, food from my own table. You can leave him in good conscience.”
Equal parts incredulous and enraged, Thorin spat, “No!”
Thranduil’s eyes sparked. “So be it.”
He snapped his fingers. A guard stepped forward to hear his king’s command.
“To the dungeons. All of them.”
For many hours, hobbit and dwarf sat in their shared prison cell in mutual silence before Thorin spoke. “Master Baggins?”
“Yes?”
“Why do elves like you?”
Bilbo tsked. “I don’t think Thranduil ‘likes’ me.”
“Elrond was eager to make you welcome and invited you to remain in his halls. Thranduil has as good as stolen you. He wishes to possess you. I don’t understand.”
He rested his temple against the bars of their cage. The cold metal did nothing for his growing headache. “In an earlier age, all the mighty kings of men and elves had a hobbit at their side.” He fidgeted uneasily. He hated this. He hated lying. “It’s old superstition. Hobbits are… um… lucky, I guess.”
“Lucky,” he repeated flatly.
Bilbo began to giggle, but it was filled with shattering nerves rather than any humor. “This has been an ill-omened venture from the start. I told Gandalf I wouldn’t be enough. I told him you lot needed so much more than I can give!”
He dug his knuckle against his temple, but still his pounding head had no relief. He didn’t dare look at the dwarven king and meet his gaze. If he did, he feared he would break.
“The wizard was strangely insistent we required a burglar,” said Thorin with low wondering words.
Bilbo snorted.
“But he instead wished us to have a hobbit’s luck?”
“Such as it is. If it wasn’t for me, I don’t doubt Thranduil wouldn’t have insulted you all a bit longer and then sent you on your way.”
“Your opinion of elves is too generous. He would have imprisoned us here regardless.” Thorin hesitantly patted the hobbit’s arm. The heavy warmth was a small comfort, but Bilbo felt steadier for it. “It was never a choice between your imprisonment and ours. The burden is not yours. We were all destined for these cells the moment the elves found us.”
They fell silent after that, and each kept his own thoughts.
Bilbo wasn’t sure at what point of the night sleeping shoulder to shoulder had turned into the hobbit burrowing into the fur of Thorin’s coat and a warm dwarven arm holding him close. Feeling a blush rise on his cheeks, he cleared his throat and gave his attention to their unexpected visitor. Not a guard. But formally attired. A steward of some sort, or a member of Thranduil’s household.
He was quite drunk.
“So this is a hobbit.”
“What do you want?” demanded Thorin.
“I’ve not seen a hobbit before. Not up close. No hobbit has stepped a single woolly foot on this side of Hithaeglir for half an age, at least.”
“Your curiosity has been satisfied. You’ve seen the hobbit. Now leave.”
He ignored Thorin. Bilbo wasn’t sure Thorin was much accustomed to being ignored.
The elf squinted at him. “You look young. Are you too young for it, yet? How old are you, hobbit?”
“I turn fifty next month.”
The elf was dismayed. “You are but a child!”
“I am middle aged,” Bilbo insisted with a frown.
“Hobbits live so little a time? I thought your spans of life comparable to dwarves, at least.”
“A hundred years is a full span of life for a hobbit. But rarely, there are some few who live considerably older. My mother saw two hundred before she passed.”
“Your mother!” The elf was overjoyed. “Nienna smiles upon me! Quickly, you will come with me—”
Bilbo took a step back from the cell door. “No, I don’t think I will.”
The elf looked shattered.
“You must know I cannot be forced.”
“What must I do?”
The hobbit folded his arms across his chest. “Convince me.”
The elf swallowed. He slumped down the wall and sat on the floor. They were closer to a height, now, though the elf was so unsteady on his legs Bilbo was sure he had not been thinking of that when he sat down.
“My name is Galion. I am the king’s butler. My wife sailed into the west years ago, but before she left me, she gave me a daughter. My child is young, but she is good and beautiful, better and more beautiful than either me or my wife. Despite her youth, she has a place in the king’s guard. But the spiders… They are very bad. They grow ever worse. Worse than the king will admit. They overwhelm our soldiers at times. And my daughter”—he hiccupped with a sob—”my daughter now lies overcome by their poison. There is nothing to be done. We wait for her to die.”
“I thought elves didn’t fear death. Not in the way the rest of Eru’s creation fears it. It’s said the Valar made a place for elves that is nothing but good and light and peace. The rest of us are not so certain if there is any place for us at all.”
He scowled. “It is true. Ilúvatar’s eldest children are promised such a place. We know it is true. But I am selfish. If she dies, I will be here and she will be there, and we will be divided until the world is remade. After all that time apart, we will be strangers when we reunite. I wish to keep my daughter just as she is because she is the daughter who loves me best. The daughter I raised from an infant.”
Frowning hard at the stone at his feet, Galion ruffled his long hair. It was a strange sight to see an elf with disheveled hair. “I sometimes wonder why us elves are not jealous of you all. Isn’t it a blessing to know when death parts you, the parting is not long? You will one day find your loved ones just as you remember them in the Halls of Waiting. It would be a comfort, I think.”
Bilbo’s fingers fiddled absently with one of the remaining buttons on his coat sleeve. “If I do this—and I cannot promise that I can—what will you give me?”
He looked appalled. “You sell yourself?”
“Of course not. But it is the only thing of value left to me and yet you ask me to give it to you when we are not friends. Under the circumstances…” He leaned against his cell door, his eyes roving suggestively about the narrow prison walls surrounding him.
“No. You speak truth.” He rubbed at his chin. He scrubbed at his bloodshot eyes. “Freedom. I give it to you in return.”
“Thranduil will be angry.”
The elf retorted sharply, “Thranduil does not understand the magics of hobbits any more than I do! He can be convinced that you freed yourself.” Then he softened and Bilbo spied a shine in his eyes. “Please, Master Hobbit. I beg you. Have mercy.”
Bilbo sighed. “I can only promise to try.”
“I can ask for no more.” Galion lurched to his feet. His hands shook on the key he set in its door. “Come with me.”
The tumblers screeched in their lock, and the moment the cell door opened, Thorin pounced. But the elf, even drunk, was quick and made the dwarf pull up short. A silver knife glinted in his fingers.
Bilbo felt Galion’s hand tighten around his bicep where he held him fast.
“I shout and a dozen guards will come with swords in hand. The halfling is worth much, no matter where he stands, but you are worth very little within a prison, dwarf.”
“Shut the door,” commanded Galion.
Bilbo shut the door. He tried hard not to meet Thorin’s eyes glaring from the other side.
“Lock it.”
He locked it.
“The key.”
Galion fumbled, but by the second try, he had the key plucked from Bilbo’s palm and stuffed in his pocket.
“Come, halfling,” he said lightly as if he was leading the way and not hauling him by his bruised arm, “I have need of you.”
Galion was a canny old elf. Bilbo didn’t wonder if he had planned this from the moment Bilbo stepped within Thranduil’s keep, and he drank his wine merely for courage. Because this seemed far too well orchestrated to be an idea born of sleepless drunkenness in the middle of the night.
It was much later when Bilbo woke with an aching head, nausea, and every muscle in his body ached with a dull burn. “Mmph,” he said.
“Bilbo?”
The rumbling voice was loud in his ear. It was then he realized he was reclining against a broad dwarven chest. He shivered. Why did he feel cold when it was so nice and warm here? Oh, thought Bilbo muzzily. Spiders. Yes, that would do it.
His mouth felt like cotton. “Elves are rather difficult to kill,” he rasped. An earthenware jug of water was held up to his lips and he drank. He felt steadier already. “That elf lady must’ve been bit by spiders a dozen times or more. Twice would be enough to kill you or me.”
“She is dead, then?”
“I don’t know. I fainted.”
“That damn elf Galion came slinking back here late in the afternoon after he took you. He had you tucked up inside an empty barrel carried in a handcart to keep you hidden. I believed he’d killed you and meant to leave your corpse with me.”
He smacked his lips with a grimace. “I thought I smelled apple brandy.”
“You’ve been unconscious nearly two days. What do you remember?”
“I remember enough to find our way out of the dungeons. But Galion’s quarters are inside the palace. I still don’t know a way out of the keep.”
Thorin seemed a little annoyed. Maybe that’s simply what he looked like close up.
Mortification slowly settled upon Bilbo. It finally occurred to his muddled brain that he was sitting on Thorin’s lap. His head was resting on Thorin’s shoulder. His knees were drawn up to his chin, and arms that did not belong to him were cradling him close within their cloaks. A warm dwarven hand was wrapped around his shoulders. Another hand was resting on his thigh.
“I mean,” Thorin repeated with an impatient note of insistence, “what did that damn elf do to you? What did he do that he carried you back half dead and feverish?”
“I really can’t say.” Woozily, he tried to scoot off Thorin’s lap.
“Can’t or won’t?” The dwarf tightened his hold.
Bilbo breathed. He felt dizzy. He turned his head and buried his face in Thorin’s chest. He smelled filthy and unwashed but not entirely unpleasant. He was reminded of an embrace on top of the Carrock and felt comforted.
“Bilbo.”
Resting his brow against a lovely collarbone, he said, “Did I tell you that generations ago, there were hobbits who belonged to the courts of elvish and mannish kings?”
“You mentioned it, yes.”
“It was not voluntary.”
Thorin surmised with slow unease, “Hobbits were captives.”
“Sometimes.”
The thump of Thorin’s heart in his ear steadied him. His quiet voice rumbled in his chest.
“Your people have a magic,” he murmured as if it was a secret shared between them two only. “You can do something no other can do.”
Bilbo remained silent.
“Dwarves have their secrets. I cannot begrudge hobbits their own.” He took a breath and Bilbo felt it swell in his breast beneath him. “Tell me this: did that elf deliberately hurt you? Him or his daughter?”
“No.”
“Alright then. Don’t do it again.”
“I’ll try.”
Despite his half-hearted promise, Bilbo broke it in less than three days.
Bilbo’s strange feverish chill broke within a few hours of waking. After he ate a little and slept a little, he felt well enough. Or at least that is what he told Thorin.
They passed the time almost pleasantly. They sat close together, side-by-side, and shared their cloaks. (After one had held the other curled up on his lap for two days to keep him warm through chills and fever, there was little propriety of distance left to maintain.) They talked. Very deliberately neither speculated on either hobbitish magic or their quest. They spoke of home, of the Company, favorite poems and stories they had read, their childhoods, and far-off places they had seen. Thorin even sang for him once. (Elven prisons had precious little to desire, but the small stone space had admittedly excellent acoustics.) Bilbo got him to laugh by telling his favorite tavern story of Gorhenbras Took and the Inexhaustible Barrel of Rum—and it was a great, gratifying dwarven belly laugh too.
Food and fresh water were brought. It was hardly enough.
Galion appeared the next night. He haunted the darkness outside their cell door and Thorin was instantly on his feet.
“You,” he hissed.
Impressively, the elf ignored the black stare boring into the side of his head. “Good. You are awake,” he said to Bilbo who rolled to his feet with a grunt. “We haven’t much time.”
“How is Tauriel?”
The elf’s expression brightened with quiet joy. “She lives. Health blooms in her cheeks. She grows stronger each day.” He bowed his head graciously, “And now I am here to give you your due.”
“Excuse me?”
“I promised your freedom, Master Hobbit, did I not?”
Bilbo’s brows drew together. “The Company,” he corrected pointedly. “The Company’s freedom.”
He clutched at his heart. “I promised no such thing! A life for a life is fair! A life for fourteen is impossibly exorbitant!”
“Then you shall keep your ‘payment’ and don’t bother asking for any favors again! I will not abandon my friends!”
Thorin demanded with as much iron in his spine as ever, “Bilbo Baggins, you will leave this place.”
“No.” Bilbo refused to argue. He refused to budge. Iron met stone and neither yielded.
But then Thorin’s voice gentled. “Then I will beg a favor—as your friend.” He pulled the ring from his finger and pressed it into Bilbo’s hands. A carved blood-red stone was inlaid in warm gold. “Go east. To the Iron Hills. My cousin Dain is lord there. He will plead our release from Thranduil. He will be a more convincing negotiator than I am since he has an army at his back.”
“I can’t.” The skin-warmed gold felt heavy in his hand. All that way? Alone?
“You must.”
Galion stared down the corridor at an imagined sound. Relieved there was nothing in it, he then tsked impatiently, “Hurry! The guards change shifts in an hour and there is a small gate left unattended for a few minutes only. We will miss our chance if you deliberate any longer.”
Bilbo looked at Thorin and saw in his eyes such sad hope, such conflict to risk him yet again, but such confidence that of all the Company, perhaps Bilbo could do the impossible. He threw his arms around his neck and felt strong arms encompass his shoulders. He didn’t allow himself to regret his impulsive gesture. It may be months before they saw one another, if ever again. He would have this to remember him by.
“When we meet again, I trust it will be under happier circumstances,” rumbled Thorin, his voice sounding rougher than usual.
“Yes,” said Bilbo. “Yes, I believe so.”
Their next meeting was indeed happier, and it came only an hour after Galion led Bilbo away into the darkness.
“Bilbo?” Thorin blinked like he meant to blink away false visions. “Kíli?”
“Hurry.” The door lock screeched. It was the last one.
They ran down the corridor, light-footed Kíli leading the way, his own short dwarven bow in his hands.
Breathless, the hobbit said to Thorin, “At night, the guards remain up on the walls only. There is no one at all down here in the dungeons. That is how Galion was able to escort me to his home so easily. He only had to hide me in a barrel for a little while.”
“But the gate? The small unguarded gate? It was left alone only for a few minutes. We are too late.”
“I’m small enough and quiet enough to get out through that gate without being spotted, but you lot are hopeless. We must go another way.”
They passed through a long corridor lined with prison cells that all stood open and empty. They wound down several flights of stairs and through twisting corridors.
Thorin wondered, “You have no stone sense. How on earth did you avoid getting lost down here?”
“Galion led me this way twice, now. He meant to stuff me into another empty brandy barrel again so to cart me upstairs, but I changed his mind for him.”
They pushed through a wide pair of doors where they were greeted by the entirety of the Company. They stood in the king’s wine cellar where Galion managed the stores of wine. Galion lay nearby, gagged and bound tight hand and foot with strips torn from his own cloak.
Thorin stared. Then he laughed, great happy full guffaws. He gently pounded Bilbo on the back and the hobbit felt it all the way down through his toes.
“I believe this belongs to you,” Bilbo said quietly as he slipped the heavy gold and jasper signet ring into his palm. If Bilbo’s fingers lingered perhaps a moment too long, Thorin didn’t say anything but instead beamed at him in silence.
Dwalin pressed Orcrist and Thorin’s own pack into his hands. “Lucky for us, Balin caught sight of our gear being stored away when they carried us down here.”
Balin shook his whitened head. “‘Twas a torment knowing it all so close, being behind bars as we were. I consider it good luck, now.”
“Why, don’t you know?” grinned Thorin, his teeth a white line in his beard, “Hobbits are lucky. A bit of hobbit luck has rubbed off on you.”
“Then I hope there is yet a bit more luck to spare,” said Dwalin, hefting his war hammer. “We must fight our way through the guards before they all realize we are loose from our cages.”
The hobbit cleared his throat. The circle of dwarves looked at him, by now knowing hobbits well enough (or perhaps it was only Bilbo) to recognize the noise meant he wished to be heard. “I have a different route in mind,” he said.
Bilbo showed them the empty wine barrels and the trap door leading to the river and told them his plan.
“That,” said Glóin, “is a terrible plan.”
“I’m sure it will work, shouldn’t it?”
Fíli looked decidedly uneasy. “Although dwarves can swim, you do realize we don’t float? We sink, Bilbo. Like stone.”
“It’ll be a few hours at most. From what I’ve seen on maps, Long Lake isn’t far.”
They examined the barrels. They peeked through the trap door at the dark river’s current. They dithered and complained, but it was the distant sound of elves shouting an alarm in a far off corridor that made up their minds. They loaded themselves and their packs and weapons into their unlikely boats within minutes.
Their float down river took the rest of the night and most of the following day. Being the last who hammered the barrels shut and pulled the lever operating the trapdoor to the river, poor Bilbo clung the entire way to the outside of a barrel with a short, heavy prybar tied to his back.
The barrels finally washed up in the shallows where the river fed into the lake and grew so broad, the water rose no higher than Bilbo’s knees. The barrels full of dense dwarves sunk and the river’s current refused to carry them any farther.
Bilbo didn’t hear any noises. That scared him. He scurried from barrel to barrel, frantically prying them open. He sighed with relief when he was greeted by soggy dwarven cursing and frantically dove into the barrel when he was not.
When all were loosed and all were wringing out coats and beards, Bilbo counted thirteen wet dwarves, gave them an exhausted but satisfied nod, and then staggered onto shore and vomited into the bushes.
“My socks smell like elvish wine, but only two bottles broke!” announced Bofur as he triumphantly held up eight large green bottles he pulled up from the bottom of his barrel.
The dwarves cheered.
Looking worse for wear, Óin commandeered a bottle to help revive the most sodden of the Company. Bilbo declined a sip.
“Ugh. Please no.” He held his poor stomach and shivered. He felt slightly delirious. His head throbbed.
For a time, Dori was distraught by the amount of blood covering his little brother. He was not much mollified by various stories traded by the Company about past bumps, gashes, and scrapes that looked far worse than the reality.
Meanwhile, Ori sat calmly, scrubbing blood out of his favorite mittens while Óin tended to him. He called Dori over and showed him the small gash hidden in Ori’s hair.
“You see, Master Dori? ‘Tis a tiny wound—three stitches only. Head wounds are always terrible bleeders.”
The dwarves limped off to find a spot away from the river to camp for the night. They built a fire to dry off, roasted fish caught by Kíli and Fíli, liberally toasted their new-found freedom, and Bilbo developed a horrible wet cough in his lungs that lasted most of a week.
“Inhaled some river water,” concluded Óin, after listening to Bilbo’s chest. “Which is hardly a surprise. I drank a gallon of the stuff myself when we got tossed through those damn rapids!”
Men had short memories. Bilbo was glad none of the big people of Laketown took any notice of the smallest, slightly ill member of the Company. They remembered dwarves, but hobbits or halflings or perian were creatures of whom they had no recollection.
The men feted the dwarves and gave them an entire house for themselves to rest in, but tired and wary Bilbo remained at the edges, avoiding noise and people both. Somehow Thorin found him here alone on a balcony at the back of the house. Their faces were turned towards the Lonely Mountain although Bilbo couldn’t see it in this darkness. He wondered if dwarven eyes could see it.
“Durin’s Day is nearly upon us. We will be in the mountain soon,” said Thorin as stars glittered overhead.
“Soon,” agreed Bilbo.
He set a plate of food next to him with a clink. He slid it towards him.
“I see you know your way into a hobbit’s good graces. Thank you.”
Bilbo nibbled at the dainties and Thorin sipped at his ale.
“I cannot help but reflect on all of the very near misses the Company has enjoyed these past months. It is truly improbable—impossible—luck.”
“Truly,” said Bilbo, feeling an uncomfortable wariness building within him.
“Bilbo?” Thorin stared uncomfortably into the bottom of his ale. “Have we been… using you up?”
“Beg pardon?” He felt startled to see the strength of concern gleaming in the pair of blue eyes that met his gaze.
Thorin briefly raised his hand as if he meant to rest it on Bilbo’s arm or knee, but he instead settled his fingers on his own thigh where they drummed once, twice.
“You seem worn,” he said. “Thin. Stretched. I thought at first it was simply the softness of hobbits compared to the sturdiness of dwarves, but I know now that is false. You are as tired and dirty and hungry as the rest of us, but there is yet a greater travail that has sapped you of your vitality. Have we caused you this detriment?”
He sighed. “I’ll have you know a hobbit cannot be forced.”
“You say that, but I don’t believe it is true. Otherwise, the kings of old would have found it useless to hold your ancestors captive.”
He shook his head. “It is possible for one to be caught in a terrible bind and yet wish good fortune upon others.”
His face fell. “Then we have coerced you into it. Bullied you to it.”
Bilbo snatched up his hand with both his own. “No! You are my friends! I would give all, if necessary!”
“Oh, Bilbo.” His thumb brushed comfortingly against the back of his hand. “Please be a little selfish. We have no right to call ourselves your friends if we make you spend yourself so dearly for our sakes.”
“You don’t understand. I must intervene. I can’t bear the cost of standing idle and watching… tragedy, if I can prevent it. I am selfish, Thorin. So selfish. I am spending my strength, yes, but my heart would break completely should I ever allow my friends to come to a terrible end.”
“But a dragon.” His face turned back towards the shadow of the mountain looming to the north. “Oh, by Mahal, Bilbo. I haven’t any idea what I’m asking of you to keep us all alive against a dragon.”
Feeling brave, Bilbo drew their joined hands to set upon his knee. He rested his curls against Thorin’s broad shoulder and Thorin let him.
“Well. With any luck, perhaps the old thing has long since perished in its sleep?”
