Chapter Text
When Bilbo awoke, he was lying on his side, one wing crumpled against his ribs and the other splayed across his outstretched limbs. His wings were tattered, patches of his scales were gone, his fangs were loose, and the tip of his tail was one stripe of agony. Worst of all, a great chasm had opened in his heart. Tears simply would not come.
A rough blanket descended over his flanks, then was just as quickly yanked off.
“He needs the sun, you wool-pated she-elf,” a Dwarf snarled.
Bilbo would know that voice at the end of the world. Both his eyelids slicked back. The sky was a featureless bank of clouds. A dark, half-bald silhouette loomed over him.
“Blink twice if you’re dead,” Dwalin said.
Bilbo blinked twice.
“He’s alive!” Kíli crowed. He hugged Bilbo’s snout, his cheek resting between Bilbo’s eyes. A moment later, Dwalin laid a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.
Bilbo raised his head off the gravel, twisting to find Thranduil’s red-haired captain clutching a blanket knitted with trout. Behind her, a small campfire licked at a pebbled perimeter. Smoke rose from the center of Long Lake. The air smelled of lake, smoke, Men, and the peculiar nothingness of Elves.
Bilbo extended his neck towards the Elf. Her hand flew to the bow strapped across her back, but Dwalin guessed his intent: he swiped her blanket and flicked it over Bilbo’s flanks. Bilbo shrank into a Hobbit and clutched the damp wool around his shoulders.
“Fine time for you to develop a sense of propriety,” Dwalin complained.
“Where’s Smaug?” Bilbo demanded.
“He is dead,” said the Elf.
The last of the tension fled Bilbo’s muscles. He exhaled, letting his shoulders sag. Kíli stacked his waterlogged coat atop the blanket.
“Captain Bard shot him with a black arrow,” the Elf continued. “His aim was true—and Smaug had been sore wounded.”
“The c-company did that, by the way,” Bilbo snapped, his anger undermined by his chattering teeth. “The same people your king t-tried to arrest.”
The Elf’s eyes narrowed. “You woke Smaug.”
“Trust me, he wasn’t sleeping quietly.” Bilbo shuddered. “Bifur is dead.”
“No!” Kíli cried. Dwalin inclined his head.
Bilbo did not hide his tears this time.
“We have to get back to Erebor,” Kíli said finally. “Thorin needs us.”
“Aye.” Dwalin glared at the Elf. “You won’t try to stop us.”
Her hazel eyes flickered from Dwalin to Kíli, to the mountain overhead, then back to Bilbo. Her bow hand was stiff at her side. “My king ordered me to kill you.” Her voice hardened. “I have never failed a charge.”
“Bilbo saved Laketown!” Kíli exclaimed.
“There are many who will not see it that way,” she said.
“And they’d be wrong,” Dwalin growled. “Smaug was already awake. Laketown’s destruction was only a matter of time.”
“I cannot levy judgment on Laketown’s behalf,” the Elf said. “However, your dragon tried to kill my king and my prince—and that I cannot forgive.”
“I v-very much did not,” Bilbo protested, drawing the wet blanket farther around his shoulders. It was Dwalin’s turn to add his coat. “I was p-p-perfectly content to bluff my way past the oaf. He ordered the first blow!”
“Tauriel,” Kíli said, “you were there.”
“His death is the will of my king,” Tauriel said, but her hand moved no closer to her bow.
“While we’re debating my death, c-can someone tell me what happened after I fell?” Bilbo asked. “I certainly remember Laketown still being there!”
“It was,” Tauriel said, “when you fell.”
She explained that she had been guarding the Laketown jail when the sky had reddened with dragon fire. Captain Bard had called for an evacuation and Tauriel had freed her charges: Bard had needed Dwarven help to bolt the city’s last windlance onto his barge. Bilbo and Smaug had fallen into the lake—both dead, it had seemed, until Smaug had surfaced in Laketown’s main canal, breathing fire and swearing vengeance. Bard, Dwalin, Kíli, and Tauriel had sailed through the wake of his destruction with the windlance and a single black arrow. With Kíli’s arrow—fletched with the feathers of Gwaihir the Windlord—Tauriel had blinded the dragon, giving Bard the shot that killed Smaug.
“Too quick,” Bilbo snarled. “Too quick by half.”
“He is dead,” Tauriel said flatly. “I thought you had met the same fate—”
“Hoped,” Dwalin muttered.
“We found you in the lake,” Kíli said, “and hauled you back on Bard’s barge.”
“Bard left to rescue more of his people. We lit a fire and waited for you to awaken,” Tauriel concluded. She and Dwalin glared at each other. “They told me mere sunlight was the best medicine.”
“When there’s more of it,” Bilbo grumbled, shuffling his blanket and coats. “Well, many thanks for saving Dwalin and Kíli. I think you did the right thing.”
“The right thing would be to bring your head to Thranduil,” Tauriel said.
Kíli held Dwalin back and said, “You saved his life. Please let us go. Tell Thranduil we escaped.”
“I would never lie to my king, even if it would spare my life,” Tauriel said sharply. “Tell me your intentions towards the Woodland Realm.”
“None,” Bilbo said. “I have no intentions, good or bad, towards Thranduil. I only want to return to the company.”
“Us, too,” Kíli added. “We’re almost home.”
For some reason, this made Tauriel look away. “I have lived for many centuries and seen the true measure of evil.” To Bilbo, she said, “It is not here. My heart says I must let you go.”
“Thank you,” Kíli said, taking her hand. Tauriel stared at him in amazement. “Thank you, Tauriel.”
Dwalin rolled his eyes, but Bilbo was rather touched.
“I will tell Thranduil the truth.” A smile cracked Tauriel’s stern mask. “He knows two Dwarves and a dragon would be an easy quarry for his captain.”
“Lass, we’ve fought a balrog,” Dwalin bragged. “You’ll want to rethink that.”
Bilbo rose to his feet and returned his Dwarves’ coats. “Well, it’s a long hike up to Erebor. I’ll fly you both.”
“You’ll be seen,” Tauriel warned.
“Let them see!” Dwalin laughed. “Smaug’s reign is over. The King Under the Mountain has returned!”
Tauriel’s expression darkened, but she said nothing as Bilbo dropped his blanket and stretched extravagantly.
“Oh,” Bilbo said, “when we get back, tell Oin to cut off the end of my tail—all the bloody bits. I want it gone.”
“Will it grow back?” Kíli asked.
“Yes,” Bilbo lied.
He shed his skin and took full stock of his injuries. His hind legs were swollen, his back furrowed with Smaug’s claws, and the last foot of his tail still oozed blood.
Dwalin clambered onto Bilbo’s back behind Kíli. “Go slow. I don’t like—”
His jaw snapped shut as Bilbo leapt into the air, beating his abused wings until he and the two Dwarves ascended above the fog. Obscenities streamed from Dwalin’s mouth, then from Kíli’s when Dwalin gripped him too tightly.
As Bilbo rose, he caught sight of Laketown. Almost all the buildings were burnt or shattered, and a ghostly mist wended through the canals. Smoke choked the eastern shore, marking the survivors’ camp even before Bilbo noticed them washed up like so much flotsam. Bilbo was reminded of Dale, and shivered.
He snagged a wind blowing towards the Lonely Mountain, endeavoring to keep level as the desolation vanished under his claws. The Dwarves’ thighs tensed around Bilbo’s shoulders, and he thrummed with their anticipation.
Erebor’s ruined gates came into view at last. Five Dwarves were sorting the rubble, but looked up at the sound of Bilbo’s wingbeats and cheered his arrival. Bilbo folded his wings and sailed into Erebor’s front hall, landing gracelessly on three legs. Dwalin immediately tumbled from his back.
“We thought you’d died!” Glóin shouted, vaulting over the debris. Ori, Nori, Fíli, and Dori followed close behind. Kíli slid into Fíli’s arms, and the two brothers swung each other around in a motion that was both a heartfelt reunion and a celebratory jig.
“I saw you fall,” Ori told Bilbo, awestruck.
Bilbo shrugged.
“Killed Smaug all by yourself, didn’t you?” Nori said, slapping Bilbo’s foreleg.
“Bravo to our dragon!” seconded Dori.
“Where’s Balin?” Dwalin demanded.
“With Thorin,” Fíli said. He had Kíli pinned under his arm. “The others are looking for supplies. Bofur and Bombur are…” He hesitated. “We didn’t ask anything of them.”
“I’ll fetch them,” Ori said, but Nori stopped him.
“You’ll want to hear the story,” Nori said. “I’ll fetch them—and Bilbo’s clothes.”
Bilbo nodded. In truth, the idea of compressing his agony within a Hobbit skin was more than he could endure. He spread his wings beneath the rectangle of noon sun and laid down.
After Nori vanished, Glóin, Dori, Ori, and Fíli pressed Kíli and Dwalin for the details. News of Smaug’s death—suspected in Erebor, but unconfirmed—was especially welcome. Bilbo learned that the company had watched the battle from Ravenhill. The mist rising off the lake had hindered their sight and they had retreated after the last flames died. Bifur had been moved to the lower halls, and the search for both supplies and the Arkenstone had commenced.
“Don’t fret none about losing the Arkenstone, Mr. Baggins,” Dori told him. “Killing Smaug was a grand enough deed on its own.”
He dug his powerful fingers into Bilbo’s shoulder. Bilbo groaned in appreciation. The sun was not healing him as swiftly as he would have liked.
“Aye, we’re glad you returned at all,” Glóin said. “Thorin was fair beside himself.”
“What about me and Mr. Dwalin?” Kíli demanded.
“I wager he’ll be less enthused at two more troublemakers under the mountain.”
“Did Bifur have more family?” Fíli asked suddenly from his perch on Bilbo’s back. “I didn’t know him before the company.”
Dwalin shook his head. “Azanulbizar.”
The company fell silent.
The heavy tread of a Dwarven herd rumbled into the hall moments before the rest of the company. Bilbo, Dwalin, and Kíli were swarmed with questions and attention. Balin and Dwalin embraced in a ring of mail. Kíli all but leapt into his uncle’s arms. They pressed their foreheads together, then pulled Fíli in with them. The company celebrated Bilbo’s victory with affectionate—and painful—slaps to his mauled shoulders. Oin finally pushed them all away, even bashing Kíli over the head with his hearing trumpet.
“That’s enough of that!” Oin said. “The dragon’s injured! Get off him, you limpets! You’re blocking the sun!”
The Dwarves slid off Bilbo and moved a short distance away to hear Kíli and Dwalin recount their tale yet again. As Oin clucked over Bilbo’s wounds, Thorin approached.
“I thought you had died,” Thorin said, his voice breaking. He reached out, laying a hand on Bilbo’s neck, then gently guided Bilbo’s head down until he could rest his forehead against Bilbo’s. “I should never have doubted you.”
Bilbo hummed deep in his throat and closed his eyes. His company was here again, even if they had not survived Smaug unscathed. Most had burns and blisters; Nori—by far the worst—had lost all the hair on the right side of his head. And Bifur…
A jolt of agony unraveled his thoughts. He swiveled as Oin prepared to poke his tail a second time.
“A nasty break,” Oin announced. “I can’t even find bone.”
“He’ll heal,” Thorin said.
Dwalin stepped forward. “Cut it off.”
“Cut it off?” Oin demanded. “It’s in bad shape, but I think I can save it.”
“Bilbo said to cut off the bad bits,” Dwalin said. “It’ll regrow.”
“That seems unlikely,” Oin replied, clearly displeased at the upstaging. “Is that true, Bilbo?”
Bilbo nodded emphatically.
“There is no reason to amputate,” Oin said. “I know I can—”
“Do not remove his tail,” Thorin ordered.
“No, it’s alright,” Kíli said.
“It won’t make him lopsided?” Fíli asked.
“Good point,” said Kíli.
“Oh, by Durin’s reddest groin hair…” Dwalin yanked Glóin’s ax from his belt and brought it down on Bilbo’s tail. Bilbo yelped in pain and Thorin cursed as fresh blood spurted from the stump.
Everyone turned at the commotion, triggering a spirited argument between Dwalin and Oin, with the rest of the company taking sides. By the time Balin separated them, Bilbo was no longer bleeding and Nori had brought Bilbo’s pack. Bilbo returned to a shape with a mouth and hands, wordlessly donned his clothes—another child’s tunic, this one from Laketown—and belted Nagtelch at his hip.
Thus girded, Bilbo said, “Where is Bifur?”
Down, down, down the company walked, deep into the frigid heart of Erebor. Bofur, Bombur, Thorin, and Oin went first, bearing Bifur’s bier. The rest trailed after them in silence, their footfalls echoing until they sounded like an army.
Their tiny procession terminated at a blank wall. Balin hurried forward and muttered something inaudible into the rock. Thin seams suddenly lined the granite and the doors swung open, wafting a deathly cold over the diminished company. The Dwarves marched into the catacombs without hesitation, but Bilbo hung back. He knew that even the smattering of Khuzdul he had learned was an immense show of trust. Seeing their funeral rites was more than he wanted to presume.
Balin alone noticed Bilbo’s reluctance.
“Aye, this is no place for outsiders,” Balin agreed, his voice little more than a whisper. “Not even our most trusted friends have witnessed a Dwarf funeral. It’s no mark against you, Bilbo.”
“I understand,” Bilbo said.
Balin’s eyes crinkled sympathetically. “We’ll be up shortly. Don’t you worry about us.”
“I’ll, um.” Bilbo swallowed, his eyes hot. “I’ll look for the … the Arkenstone.”
Balin clapped him on the shoulder and hurried after the procession.
Bilbo climbed until he could no longer see the catacomb doors before stripping, stuffing his clothes into his bag, and winging up to the treasury. A sea of gold undulated before him, its buttery warmth tempered by the cold cost of victory. Its call was nothing to Bilbo now. Gold had no wishes, no needs; it did not speak or fight or crack tasteless jokes over dinner. Gold could not assuage a loss that dimmed the very colors of the world.
His hoard staggered into the treasury in ones and twos, rarely making it past the door before falling to their knees. A few scooped up coins and let them trickle through their hands. Others looked about vacantly. Bilbo could not watch. He slid away, then ducked out of the treasury altogether.
The sun had quit its noon perch, skewing a spear of pale light across the eastern end of the entrance hall. Bilbo settled atop the Dwarves’ half-finished wall and pulled his pack into his lap. He stared at it for several minutes, then withdrew the toy Bifur had given him just the day before yesterday. Bilbo probed Bifur’s loss like a missing tooth, worrying at the ragged edges until his mouth flooded with iron and salt.
Bilbo sniffed, then twitched his nose. He sniffed again, but the breath caught in his throat and a high, keening whine emerged, thick with tears. He curled forward over the toy, rocking on his heels, letting his grief flow freely and privately.
The sun set over Erebor’s western shoulder, plunging the vale into darkness. Bilbo heard Fíli’s steady clomp and hastily wiped his face. In that moment, he would have traded his fourteenth share for a single clean handkerchief.
“Bilbo,” Fíli called. “Uncle wants you in the treasury.”
Bilbo tucked the toy into his pack and started down the steps. “I assume you haven’t found the Arkenstone.”
“You’ll hear it from Minas Tirith when we do,” Fíli said.
They stopped on the stairwell: Bilbo descending and Fíli ascending. They searched each other for a long moment, then continued in opposite directions, brushing shoulders in silent camaraderie.
Bilbo descended into Erebor on Hobbit feet. From afar, he heard a gorgeous harp rippling up from the depths. Fearing enchantment, he hurried, but the scene greeting him was unlike the one he had left. The Dwarves were rolling in the gold, and tossing priceless gems back and forth like potatoes. Ori and Oin had found crowns of silver and mithril, and wore three apiece, along with so many necklaces they could barely turn their heads. Dwalin staggered under gilded armor and Dori laid on his back, waving his arms and legs like a fauntling in fresh snow. Nori sledded down the coins on a silver platter, crashing through a stack of cups that Bofur had erected to cheers from Glóin and Bombur. Kíli sat with a golden harp in his lap, richly embellishing a song they bawled like drunkards.
The sword is sharp, the spear is long
The arrow swift, the Gate is strong
The heart is bold that looks on gold
The Dwarves no more shall suffer wrong
Now we call over mountains cold
“Come back unto the caverns old!”
Here at the Gates the king awaits
His hands are rich with gems and gold
It was a martial reflection of the wistful melody they had sung under Bag End so many months ago. Bilbo’s heart fell.
“Here, dragon!” Thorin exclaimed from behind him.
As Bilbo turned, a necklace of luminous diamonds descended over his curls.
“The Gems of Lasgalen,” Thorin announced. “Thranduil will come for these.” He patted the center gem lying atop Bilbo’s sternum. “He will not have them.”
Bilbo met Thorin’s delirious, tear-clouded eyes for just a moment. Then Thorin was gone, weaving amidst the gold, spurning cheer and companionship as the rest of the company rapturously explored their spoils.
There was no place for grief in the Kingdom Under the Mountain.
