Chapter 1: Concerning Hobbits
Summary:
Bilbo proves his worth as a member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
In his exceptionally long life, Bilbo Baggins, Esq., had done battle with many fierce creatures, but none so terrifying as the stubby chestnut pony before him.
“Really, I can assure you that this is an awful idea,” Bilbo said.
The young Dwarf tightened the final strap tethering Bilbo’s belongings to the pony’s back and shook his head vigorously. “We’ll go faster if you ride with me, rather than try to—” He grinned “—hoof it.” A passing Dwarf—Bilbo couldn’t be bothered to remember his name—cuffed him on the head for that.
“I can keep up on foot. I’ve done my fair share of walking holidays, you know—even got as far as Frogmorton once,” Bilbo said. “I don’t mind walking.”
“Nonsense!” the Dwarf replied. “Hand me that sword. It’ll be easier to balance if you don’t have that thing on your back.”
Bilbo swatted his hand away from Orcrist. “I’ve consented to let the pony carry the rest of my things. Not this.”
“Have it your way, Master Bo—” He caught himself and corrected “—Master Baggins. Now, up you get.”
Bilbo glanced around, praying for someone to extricate him from this predicament. Instead, he found twelve sets of eyes watching him. The other Dwarves apparently had nothing better to do than witness his impending humiliation, even though half of their ponies were still unsaddled. It was a small mercy that they were some distance into the forest; at least he would not be seen by every farmer on their way into Hobbiton. “Oh, very well. Let’s get this folly over with so I can start walking.”
The Dwarf nodded, a quick jerk of his head that sent his hair tumbling into his face. He mounted his pony and waved Bilbo closer. As Bilbo approached, the animal’s nostrils flared and its eyes were ringed with white. Then Kíli—that was his name—lifted Bilbo by his armpits.
“You’re heavy! I’d say you’re nearly as heavy as Dwalin!” Kíli grunted, struggling as he sat Bilbo down on the saddle before him. Bilbo was not even given a chance to make himself comfortable: the pony reared and Kíli toppled from the saddle, dragging Bilbo with him.
The pony danced away until Thorin caught its bridle. He walked the beast over to where his nephew sat in the mud and pulled him up. He did not extend the same courtesy to Bilbo.
“We travel at haste, Master Hobbit,” Thorin said, passing the reins off to Kíli. “Don’t allow my sister-children to drag you into their games.” And then the damnable Dwarf was gone, off exchanging words with Gandalf and frowning at the cloudy sky.
Co-conspirator Kíli offered a hand, which Bilbo took gladly. It was only after yanking, though, that Kili was able to lift him from the ground.
“You’re heavy!” Kíli repeated dumbly, stroking the pony to soothe it. He looked Bilbo up and down, as if he thought to find hidden weights strapped to Bilbo’s ankles. “I don’t understand why.”
“Hobbits must be built of sterner stuff,” Bilbo replied, feigning confusion. “Can I walk now?”
“I don’t know. Can you?” Kíli asked. After a foul look from Bilbo, he added, “I suppose you’ll have to.” He pushed his hair out of his face with a dirty palm and looked at the pony glumly. “It’s odd, though. Minty is so mild-mannered.”
“Ah,” said another Dwarf, stumping past with his own saddle. “That’s the thing about these Shire-folk. All smiles and bows ’til you try to get them to do what they don’t want. Even the ponies. Is that right, Master Burglar?”
“Or near enough, Master ... Dwarf.”
“Bofur, if it pleases you, and none of that mister master business. Courtesy doesn’t matter much when you’re pissing together,” he said with a wry grin. “Ah, but look at the time. I best be getting my own pony ready. Wouldn’t want to hold us up, would I?”
Shortly before noon, Thorin led them onto the East-West Road towards Bree. Bilbo—who was accustomed to walking trips conducted in pensive silence—was disgusted by the Dwarves’ racket: their voices never fell lower than obnoxiously loud as they tossed jokes and jabs from pony to pony. All of it flew over Bilbo’s head, save for a few aborted attempts at pulling him into conversation. Being both sour about his current predicament and appalled by their behavior, Bilbo was as inclined to join them as he was to jump in a freezing lake.
Instead of walking with them, he trudged beside Gandalf’s horse, maintaining a respectful distance from the beast as he grouchily recalled the evening that had brought him to this point.
Bilbo knelt in the warm, wet earth, with the setting sun beating down on his back and a small pile of weeds to his right. Gandalf had convinced him to entertain some guests that evening and Bilbo wished to present an orderly garden. Generations of Hobbits had successfully inculcated him with that habit, along with many others—such as being punctual.
It was three full minutes past the half-hour when distant voices alerted him to Gandalf’s return. A quick glance over Bilbo’s shoulder showed that the wizard and his companions were still a good distance away, but his sharp hearing picked up their conversation with ease.
“Ah, and there it is! Bag End!” exclaimed Gandalf. “And if I’m not mistaken, I can see our host as well.”
“Up by that green door? Awfully … ordinary looking fellow,” said a Dwarf, his guttural accent full of sharp consonants and rolling vowels. “Much like all of these other halflings.”
Bilbo gritted his teeth and yanked on a dandelion stem, cursing when the root snapped.
“They prefer to be called Hobbits,” Gandalf corrected. “And you will find they are anything but ordinary, particularly this one. Remember your manners and take care not to offend him.”
“That is to be our burglar?” scoffed a second Dwarf. “Tharkȗn, is this a jest? He looks more like a grocer.”
“That is where you’re wrong, Thorin Oakenshield. He is often referred to as the Dragon of the Shire and there is no better creature in Middle Earth to aid you on your quest.”
Another dandelion met its untimely end as Bilbo tugged with all of his might. That was most certainly not how he was known.
“How did such a small fellow earn such a fierce name?” asked yet another Dwarf.
Bilbo stood just in time to see Gandalf, now much closer, bend to explain, quiet enough that Bilbo could not hear. The Dwarves all colored, snapping to look at him.
“Well!” Bilbo called, cupping his hands around his mouth. “You’re all a bit late, but I very well can’t turn you away now that you’ve arrived.”
Without waiting for so much as a nod, Bilbo retreated back into the smial. He fed the fire and put the kettle on, and was in the middle of putting out a plate of snacks when the doorbell rang.
He opened the door to five Dwarves and Gandalf, the latter of whom had to bend over to be seen.
“Bilbo, my dear boy,” he said. “It’s been far too long.”
“So it has, Gandalf,” Bilbo replied, smiling amiably. In small doses, the wizard was excellent company. “And these are the Dwarves?” They were a motley bunch, and all looked displeased by being made to wait on the doorstep.
“There will be more,” Gandalf said.
Bilbo’s smile dropped. “How many?”
“Not many.”
“And how many is that?”
The foremost of the Dwarves—a fearsome, noble-looking thing—spoke up. “We will be thirteen, when all of us arrive.”
By now, Bilbo sorely regretted allowing Gandalf to impose on his hospitality. “Oh, very well. I said I would hear you out, and so I shall. Bilbo Baggins, at your service,” he said, as that was a traditional greeting among Dwarves.
“Excellent!” exclaimed Gandalf, beaming. “Here we have Fíli, Kíli, Dwalin, Balin, and their leader, Thorin Oakenshield.”
“At your service,” they chorused, bowing and nodding.
“A pleasure, I suppose,” Bilbo said ungraciously. He turned into Bag End. “Come, come. Take those beastly boots off before you track mud all over the house, and put your swords in the umbrella stand. Tea will be ready soon.”
“A word, Bilbo?” Gandalf asked, nodding his head towards Bilbo’s sitting room.
The rain began as a soft, innocuous patter, but soon pounded upon the heads of Dwarves and ponies alike. Hoods were drawn up and cloaks were pulled tight around sodden shoulders. Bilbo shivered and followed suit, his cloak—borrowed from Dwalin—enveloping him to the ankles. The hems of his trousers were soaked through and he despaired of ever washing the mud out of his hairy feet. Orcrist weighed on his aching shoulders, but he didn’t dare shift it while walking.
So passed their first day together. The next was no better; it seemed as though they would all drown before even seeing the shadow of the Misty Mountains. Late into the second day, they passed over the Brandywine Bridge and the Shire’s easternmost border. Bilbo stared back mournfully at his fair country, its rolling hills and gentle fields now obscured behind curtains of rain. He was scarcely a hundred feet away and already yearned to return. He felt a momentary pang of empathy for Thorin’s company, then thought better of it.
The road wound a circuitous route between the narrow valleys hemming the Old Forest. The path thinned significantly, forcing Bilbo to evade the ponies’ teeth and hooves in tight quarters.
Thorin wheeled his pony around at the mouth of a rocky defile. “We’ll camp on the other side.”
The company sighed in relief and their ponies seemed to press forward with renewed energy. Bilbo wished he had the same strength.
The sun set as they passed, single-file, along the slim path. A steep wooded incline dropped away on their right and a line of boulders as high as Gandalf’s shoulder boxed them in on the left. The light was fading rapidly and Bilbo stumbled often, barely keeping his footing on the rough road. So distracted was he that he didn’t notice the hunters approaching until they were already among them.
With a cry, a group of Men, roughly dressed and roughly armed, leapt down from the rocks, waving their hands and yelling at the ponies until they spooked. Many of the Dwarves dismounted their frightened animals, grabbing their weapons and shouting Khuzdul battle cries as they dove at their attackers.
As Bilbo dodged churning hooves and swinging blades, he tried to count the Men in the raiding party, but he gave up after it was evident they were outnumbered and surrounded. The Dwarves were adept fighters—or made up for it in heart—and Bilbo hoped it would be enough to tip the scales in their favor.
Bilbo threw his hood back and pulled Orcrist free, only to drop its heavy and rain-slicked hilt. He ducked an over-enthusiastic blow from Bofur’s mattock and snatched Orcrist from the mud, sheathed it with great difficulty, and pulled out his dagger to reenter the fray.
The Men ignored him in favor of taller targets. This was their mistake, as Bilbo would dart behind them and slice their legs, cutting hamstrings and tendons. With a cry, the Men would fall, and Bilbo would leave them at the mercy of his companions.
As Bilbo slipped away from his most recent victim, he heard a growling streak of Khuzdul and the scream of a pony, and turned in time to see Thorin pulled bodily from his mount. He sprang up bare-handed in the midst of four men, his sword lost in the scuffle.
“This is the one?” one Man asked.
“Can’t really tell. They all look the same to—”
His words broke off as the tip of Bilbo’s shortsword forced its way through his chest. With a strangled shout, Bilbo pulled the blade free and pushed past the dying man. He threw Orcrist at Thorin, squaring up beside him without checking to see if he had caught it.
The three swords hung above the mantle, framed by the portraits of Belladonna and Bungo Baggins. The pictures and their frames had been fastidiously cleaned, but the swords bore a thin layer of dust.
“You still give them a place of honor,” Gandalf said, running his finger along one dirty hilt.
“They make good statement pieces, even without the complete set,” Bilbo said.
“And what sort of statement is that?”
“Well, it reminds Lobelia Sackville-Baggins just whose silver spoons she has in her pockets,” Bilbo replied, grinning puckishly.
Gandalf didn’t seem impressed. “And you’re sure that they no longer have any sway over you?”
“None whatsoever,” Bilbo said. “Simply nostalgia.” Gandalf frowned, and Bilbo was quick to correct himself. “Oh, it really was a pleasant feeling. You can’t fault me for missing it.” The damnable wizard still looked unconvinced. “Look, I haven’t dusted them for weeks! Sometimes I forget they’re up there.” He sighed. “You still don’t believe me.”
He dragged over a bench and stepped onto it to take down the longest sword. It had a solid weight: heavy steel made heavier by enchantment. When it had been used against Bilbo, it had glowed blue day and night, but it had lain dormant for years, and continued to do so as he offered it to Gandalf. “Take it.”
“You’re giving this to me?” the wizard asked. As Gandalf took the sword, he watched Bilbo’s face, as if seeking some radical change in expression or mood. Bilbo regretted that the sword’s absence left a dark patch on the faded wallpaper. Then again, he had planned to remodel...
“I would rather the old thing be put to use than sit here collecting dust,” Bilbo said, carefully climbing off the bench. “Its name is Glamdring. Use it well.” He flinched as something crashed in the kitchen, and fled to play host.
“What did I tell you?!” Gandalf exclaimed. “Fierce as a dragon in a pinch.”
Bilbo groaned and resisted the urge to slam his head against a tree.
The company sat upon stumps and rocks as they licked their wounds. Some counted their losses: keepsakes and tokens squirreled away in the baggage lost with five of their ponies. Others, with the battle still coursing in their blood, paced in tight circles, reliving the skirmish over and over again.
They had won free after a short battle, leaving many of the Men dead or injured as the company retreated to the flatter country surrounding the bridge. Thorin and Balin were reluctant to try the road again, so they took conference with Gandalf on the other side of the clearing.
Shortly thereafter, Thorin announced they would be moving again. Since none of the company was seriously injured, they redistributed the packs among Dwarves and ponies alike. It was a subdued group that plodded away from the road, but they made camp within the hour, and Glóin was able to light a fire for the first time since they had set out. Thorin did not object to this overt sign of their presence, perhaps to raise morale, and Bilbo liked him all the better for it.
Chatter cropped up in fits and starts, and soon even Bilbo couldn’t be left alone. Bofur dropped down beside him, omnipresent grin in place.
“Never got the chance to thank you,” he said.
Bilbo blinked. “Whatever for?”
“Well, I daresay you saved my life back there, coming in with that little ankle-biter of yours.”
“Ankle biter?” Bilbo scoffed. “I’ll have you know that this dagger has seen hundreds of battles and slain warriors far greater than yourself. It was forged in Gondolin, before … oh, never mind. This is all lost on you, isn’t it?”
Bofur grinned sheepishly. “I’m no warrior, and can spit farther than I care about your Elves. But it sounds a mighty blade. What’s it called?”
“It … well.” Bilbo flipped the tiny blade in his hands. “I—huh. It doesn’t have a name, I suppose. Swords are supposed to be named for their great deeds in battle and mine hasn’t done anything. It’s rather small.”
“Well, on you it’s a proper sword, I think,” Bofur said, “and it deserves a name after today! Saving the life of Thorin Oakenshield! Beset by bounty hunters on the road and—”
“Wait a moment,” Bilbo interrupted. “Bounty hunters?”
“Well, yes,” said Bofur, faltering. “Didn’t you know? Thorin said so to Balin, and Balin told Dwalin, who told Ori, who told Kíli. And once Kíli knows something, everyone does.”
“I most certainly did not know,” Bilbo said.
“Now you do.”
“Now I do. So someone does not want this king of Dwarves reaching his mountain,” Bilbo mused.
“Perhaps, but it’d not be wise to discuss that now,” Bofur said. He jumped up, brushing down the front of his tunic. “That ‘king of Dwarves’, as you called him, is coming right this way, probably for a word with you.”
A glance over his shoulder confirmed it. “What could he want?” Bilbo muttered. He spared a quick half-smile for Bofur. Bofur saluted in return and made himself scarce.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin said.
“Master Dwarf,” Bilbo replied with forced civility. Gandalf would no doubt want him to be cordial, and, really, Thorin could be no worse than a Sackville-Baggins.
Thorin offered Orcrist to Bilbo hilt-first. “This is a fine blade. Thank you for permitting me to use it.”
“I couldn’t let our journey come to a grisly end so soon. Though you and I must discuss why you would ever be hunted at some point.”
“Kíli,” Thorin hissed under his breath. “Of course.”
“Anyway, I think it would be in all of our best interests if you kept the sword.”
“Keep it?” Thorin pulled the blade close, then paused, eyeing Bilbo warily. “Why?”
“Why not?” Bilbo demanded. “This an ancient Elvish blade, forged in Gondolin in the First Age. You couldn’t find a better sword in all of Arda!”
“It would not do for me to wield an Elf-forged blade,” Thorin said, though Bilbo could hear the reluctance in his voice.
“This sword is much better than that up-jumped fire poker,” said Bilbo with a disdainful sniff.
“My sister forged this sword for me and I named it Deathless when I slew the orc Azog the Defiler upon the threshold of … of Khazad-dûm.” Thorin turned away, half his face in shadow, and Bilbo blanched, realizing his mistake. “But I shall accept your sword for the gift it is.”
“Its name is Orcrist, the Goblin-Cleaver,” Bilbo said. Thorin was about to walk away when Bilbo added, “I apologize for speaking ill of Deathless.”
“Your gift and apology are accepted, Master Baggins,” said Thorin stiffly. “As you were.”
Bilbo met Gandalf’s eyes across the fire. If Bilbo could bear to pass the sword to a Dwarf he disliked, then surely he was free from its hold.
Bilbo returned to Bofur’s side and said, “You know, I think I’ve thought of a name for this sword.”
“Have you?”
“Yes, I think I’ll call it Nagtelch. That’s Sindarin. For ankle-biter, as you suggested. It’s an apt name.”
Bofur tossed his head back and laughed, clapping Bilbo on the back so hard that he stumbled. Yet Bilbo couldn’t find it in himself to be frustrated by the display. “An apt name indeed! Hopefully you won’t be using it again, though.”
“Hopefully,” Bilbo said, but if the attack was anything to go by, their journey would be anything but a pony ride in the May sunshine.
Notes:
There was a Naruto reference! If you got it you're a nerd!
Translator’s Note
M: Upon eight years of reflection, Nagtelch is not the most optimal translation of AU!Sting’s name. A better construction would likely be tallif (S. noun. ankle [lit. foot-link]) + nanc (S. noun. bite) + -on (occupational suffix) = Tallifnancon. A more elegant translation might be Talnancon, which glosses closer to foot biter (tâl meaning foot).
Chapter 2: The Barrowdowns
Summary:
A detour lands the company in dire straits. Bilbo makes an important decision.
Notes:
Merry Crispmas!
Chapter Text
As if in apology for their stolen ponies, the weather improved drastically. The rain-laden clouds passed to the west, and in their place came the bright afternoons of early May. The company made excellent time despite their predicament.
The Men had stolen five ponies, which meant five of the company had to walk, but, worse, those ponies had carried most of their food and Bombur’s cooking equipment. Bilbo had thought they would resupply in Bree, but Thorin left the road to avoid further attention. They followed the Brandywine River south on the Shire side of the banks, forging through the thick underbrush with only their axes and their stocky ponies to break a path. It was hot, tiresome, and thankless work, and their progress slowed to a crawl as roots tripped them and spiderwebs tangled in their hair.
Early in the afternoon of their ninth day out of the Shire, the company stopped at a bend in the Brandywine to water their ponies and stretch their legs. Although it was lunchtime, they had no meal, and the rumbling of fourteen empty stomachs nearly overpowered the chuckling stream. Having only one meal a day was especially galling to Bilbo, who had been accustomed to seven meals—and several courses therein—for two ages. Not even a pipe of Old Toby could soothe his aching belly.
His eyes wandered to the gold-edged grass crushed under one hairy foot and idly wondered if it was edible. That’s it.
“What’d you say lad?” Oin asked, and Bilbo realized he had spoken aloud. The entire company’s attention was now fixed on him.
He doubted they would care what he said, but he felt it had to be said anyway, so he cleared his throat and set his hands on his hips. “I am not moving an inch until we find more food.”
The Dwarves rolled their eyes and returned to honing their blades or smoking their pipes, with many a rude comment about Hobbits and their bottomless stomachs. Slowly, Ori set down his sketchbook and said, “I have to agree with Mister Baggins.” The company stared at him. “This is the only tunic I have and I don’t fancy walking naked across the mountains because I’m falling out of it.”
“Here, here,” Kíli cheered from his seat by the riverbank.
“What are we to do if those Men come back?” Nori asked. “Or orcs? Roll over and let them kill us because we’re too weak to fight them off?”
“The Men won’t return,” Dwalin said. “We made sure of that.”
Bilbo seized his chance to fan the flames. “I’m sure the way you let them take our ponies terrified them.”
“We have faced leaner times than this,” Balin said, holding out a placating hand.
“Not when we were expected to fight a dragon,” Bofur said.
“Months from now,” Balin said. “We will have resupplied before then.”
A few curious gazes drifted towards the company’s leader, but Thorin seemed content to smoke his pipe and stare into the Brandywine’s clear waters. Something about his stance told Bilbo he was keeping a close ear on the conversation.
“We have enough supplies to reach Rivendell on full rations,” Gandalf said.
Thorin cut short his brooding to favor the wizard with a glare. “Our quest is of utmost secrecy. I would reluctantly ask my own kin for aid, let alone an Elf.”
Bilbo had sudden memories of bright helms gleaming under the spewing lava, of swarms of well-aimed arrows, and of legions of orcs falling before a single warrior with a shining gem suspended upon his brow. For once, he and Thorin agreed: he had no desire to see Elves either, although their larders might change his mind.
“Someone already knows of your quest,” Gandalf said, “unless you still believe those bounty hunters found us by mere chance.”
“No,” Thorin said, a touch sulkily. “They knew my name.”
“What good will the Elves do?” Glóin groused. “Fill our heads with their insipid music and our packs with their vegetables, is what!”
“And insult us behind our backs in that chittery tongue of theirs,” Oin added.
“Lord Elrond is the most powerful being on this side of the Misty Mountains,” Gandalf argued. Bilbo was offended and wondered if Elrond would be willing to back up Gandalf’s claim. “He may be able to find something yet unseen on your map, not to mention grant you food and a safe place to rest. A generous friend is just what we need at times like these.”
“In return for what?” Thorin asked bitterly. “I know well the avarice of Elves. A generous friend he may be, until he decides we would be more useful in his debt.”
“We could rob Rivendell,” Kíli suggested as he tore at the grass around his crossed legs.
Dwalin pointed to him. “I like his plan.”
Bilbo liked it, too. It had been too long since he had terrorized Elves, and they always had excellent treasuries. He refrained from commenting; as far as the Dwarves were concerned, he had only ever struck fear into the hearts of fauntlings running amok in his garden. Perhaps the Dwarves would like him better if he seconded Kíli’s plan, though.
“We will continue east,” Balin said. “Some of us are too well-known in these parts, but we could find a town in Eregion.”
“A month from now!” Dori groaned.
Bilbo’s stomach twisted at the thought. He could reach Rivendell within the week if he flew...
Thorin gestured them all into silence and let it stretch for a moment. At long last, he said, “Balin and a few others will go into Bree, while the rest of us wait by the Brandywine.”
“This is folly,” huffed Gandalf. “The lord Elrond would never extort you, unlike Bree-folk! I thought you had had enough of their ‘diplomacy’.”
Thorin twitched as if slapped. “Men may be dishonest, but at least I know the root of their lies is pure greed.”
Gandalf scowled, chomping fiercely on his pipe and muttering about the stubbornness of Dwarves. No one paid him any heed—not even when blue flames shot a foot out of the bowl.
“Me?” Balin asked. “All of Bree knows me by reputation, if not name.”
“We usually pass through Bree in the spring,” Thorin said. “As long as you leave your armor here, no one will be the wiser.”
The company resumed their trek moments later and spent the rest of the afternoon finding a safe crossing. It was not made without a great deal of splashing, both from Dwalin—who could not swim—and the more excitable ponies. For Bilbo, every step against the current felt like moving through molasses. Halfway across, his foot caught on an unseen rock and he pitched into the frigid water. He would have been content to lie there and drown, but he was hauled back up.
“Steady there, Mister Baggins,” Fíli said. “The sun will set in three hours. We’re almost done.”
“Can’t,” Bilbo mumbled, morosely spitting out a mouthful of water. He, the greatest blight of his age, had been undone by an empty stomach. There were worse ways to die.
Another set of hands grabbed Bilbo by the belt and shoulder and tossed him over the back of Fíli’s pony like a sack of potatoes. The pony spooked at the sudden weight, but to Bilbo’s immense gratitude, it did not throw him.
“You had best keep up,” Thorin said. “You’re too heavy to carry.”
Bilbo was too cold, exhausted, and hungry to reply.
On the other side of the Brandywine, Balin, Glóin, Oin, Bombur, and Nori took three of the remaining ponies and made plans to rejoin Thorin in the South Downs in five days. Once more, Gandalf exhorted Thorin to go to Rivendell, but he would not be swayed.
After parting ways, the remaining company rode until sundown, when they made camp in the shadow of the Old Forest. The company drew lots for watch—Bilbo was overlooked yet again, despite his vastly superior vision and hearing—and settled around the campfire. Fíli and Kíli stoked an enormous blaze and the sparks drifted skyward, where the Valacirca swung high in its nightly waltz. Crickets chirped sweetly in the underbrush and the air was redolent with the scent of honeysuckle and smoke. If Bilbo had ignored his twisting stomach—and he could not—it would have been a pleasant evening.
Bilbo knew better than to forage in the Old Forest, so instead of sneaking off, he inched towards the fire while maintaining a safe distance from the company. He was not frightened of them; he had faced many foes more fearsome than eight hungry Dwarves, and not the eight brightest or strongest, at that. He simply felt unwelcome. The Dwarves were a unit; outsiders like Gandalf and Bilbo fell beyond their purview.
He refused to let his isolation affect him. He had lived alone for thousands of years and, in retrospect, a few lean and lonely days would seem shorter than a heartbeat. Yet, his eye often strayed to Dwalin helping Fíli braid his hair, or to Bofur inspecting something Bifur had carved, or Dori holding Ori’s ink as he scribbled in his dog-eared book. Even Thorin quietly watching all of them with Orcrist naked across his lap affected Bilbo more than he’d like.
He ascribed it to the absence of the swords. They had been the center of his life for centuries, until Belladonna and Bungo had helped him let them go. Nothing had appeared to fill their void, so he had tried to lessen its edge by taking up hobby after hobby. Perhaps that was the real reason he had joined this madcap quest: few things kept him busier than wondering when his next meal would be.
And, if that failed, a one-fourteenth share of the greatest treasure in Arda awaited. If that much wealth couldn’t fill this hole, nothing could.
As the evening wore on, Bilbo’s unease grew until he could not put it down to mere exclusion or melancholy. In fact, it felt as if someone were watching him. When he voiced his concerns to Gandalf, the wizard merely smiled.
“You can sense them?” Gandalf asked.
“Sense who?” Bilbo asked irritably. “I’d rather not fight the Old Forest again.”
Gandalf’s bushy brows disappeared under the brim of his hat. “Again? I don’t think you’ve shared the story of the first time and I will be glad to hear it, at a later date. As for our watchers, I doubt they bear us any ill will. We will find out in a moment.”
Bilbo glanced around, one hand wrapped around Nagtelch’s hilt. Across the fire, Thorin jumped to his feet, searching the dark trees for danger.
A small host of Men melted from the gloom, bows drawn. The startled company reached for their weapons and Bilbo felt his other self reflexively coil within him, ready to strike despite Gandalf’s warning. Then, Fíli shoved him down, interposing himself between Bilbo and the nearest Man, with Kíli guarding their right, Ori and Dori their left, and the fire at their backs. Bilbo appreciated the gesture, even if his sore shoulder did not.
“Who goes there?” barked a Man, his face shrouded beneath a hood.
“Who disturbs peaceful travelers after sundown?” Thorin retorted, pointing Orcrist’s keen edge at his interlocutor.
“Ones who would see this land safe, no matter the disturbance it may bring to … peaceful travelers.”
“Oh, enough of this,” Gandalf snapped, taking up his staff. “I am Gandalf the Grey, and it is by my grace that they are traveling these lands. Their business is none of yours, if you know what’s good for you.”
The Man brushed back his hood, revealing a face of middling years crowned with greying black hair. “Mithrandir?” The other Men lowered their weapons upon seeing the wizard, but the Dwarves did not reciprocate. “I did not look to find you in such company.”
“You are in the presence of Thorin Oakenshield, Heir of Durin,” Dwalin snarled, hefting his axes, “and some respect would be in order.”
“Who are you?” Thorin demanded.
The Man gave him a curt bow. “We are the Dúnedain, scions of Elendil and guardians of the lost kingdom of Arnor.”
“Who?” Kíli whispered to Fíli.
“No idea,” Fíli whispered back.
Bilbo had heard of the Dúnedain, but he had arrived in Eriador during the apogee of Arnor’s power. By the time these rough folk had risen out of its ashes, he had established himself in the Shire, tucked away from their usual paths. He was grateful for that: he had heard their arrows could strike a blueberry at a thousand paces, that they could track a ptarmigan through a snowstorm, and that they were as tireless as hounds on the scent.
“A load of pretty titles, but I don’t think you’ve introduced yourself yet,” Bofur pointed out.
“Dírhael is my name, and Ivorwen is that of my captain and wife,” the ranger said, gesturing to the hard-bitten woman to his left. “We mean you no harm.” He stuck his arrow in the loam.
Thorin and Dwalin exchanged looks and sheathed their weapons. The company followed suit. Bifur was last of all, growling under his breath until Bofur put a hand on his shoulder.
“We were attacked by bandits last week,” Thorin told Dírhael. “You can understand our unease.”
“Where?” Ivorwen asked.
“On the very borders of the Shire,” Gandalf snapped. “Where were your rangers?”
“Tracking,” Dírhael said. “The ground aches and moans as if a great evil has passed through, and we have been trying in vain to find its source.”
Thorin looked up swiftly.
“This is most troubling,” Gandalf said. “When did you first sense it?”
“A week ago,” Dírhael said. He eyed the Dwarves warily before stepping around Dori to sit at Gandalf’s side by the fire. The company glared at the remaining Men, daring them to test their mettle. “We had assembled near Weathertop to share tidings from the far parts of Arnor when we all felt the earth convulse, rebelling beneath the feet of a fell creature.” Dírhael’s mouth was set in a grim line. “I have never felt its like this close to the Shire, and that worries me… But it is easy to trace, for this land is unaccustomed to great evils.”
Bilbo’s stomach churned. He was rather proud that he could frighten rangers dozens of leagues away, but on the whole he preferred to lie unobtrusively atop the leaf litter than subject his delicate wings to their arrows.
“Using what?” Dwalin asked derisively. “A twitch in your ear?”
“The blood of Elves and Maiar yet runs in our veins,” Ivorwen snapped, one hand slipping down to caress her sword. “We sense what many cannot.”
“There’s not a Man alive who can feel something through the earth that Dwarves can’t,” Dwalin said, and the rangers and the company seemed ready to fight once more, until Gandalf spoke.
“Do you know what it is?”
“Wargs,” Ivorwen said immediately. “We’ve seen signs of their passage from Rhudaur to the edges of Ered Luin, then east again through the old lands of Arnor.”
“Are they nearby?” Thorin demanded.
“Within ten leagues, I would say,” Dírhael said, passing a hand through his lank hair. “The evil is different, and closer, maybe even within one—”
“We must get to Bree,” Dori said. “We must warn them!”
“Warn them, aye, but going there together is too dangerous,” Dwalin said. “Thorin and I would be recognized.”
“I’ll go,” Kíli announced. “I’m the fastest and I’m used to traveling unseen.”
“No,” Thorin said. “I’ll not risk you going alone—or with your brother, for that matter. Your place is with the company.”
Where I can keep an eye on you, went unspoken.
Bilbo stood up, beating the dirt from his trousers. “I’ll go.”
“What is a Hobbit doing here?” Ivorwen asked incredulously.
“We can return you to the Shire’s borders, if you would like,” another ranger offered.
Dírhael asked, “Mithrandir, is this your doing?”
“It is of my own doing, thank you,” Bilbo said before someone threw him over their shoulder and carried him to Bag End. While the last week had been far from ideal, he had decided to go on this quest, and would not be dissuaded by bad weather and a few ill-tempered bandits.
“We will pass through Bree by tomorrow morning,” Ivorwen said, “and we will find your companions, if you wish.”
When the Dwarves did not respond, Gandalf muttered, “You can trust the Dúnedain.”
“Find Balin, son of Fundin,” Thorin said at last. “He is well-known within Bree.”
Ivorwen inclined her head in acknowledgement.
Dírhael stood, plucking his arrow from the ground. “Keep a heavier watch than your wont, and make no fire after dark.”
“We know,” snapped Dwalin.
“Mithrandir,” Dírhael said, bowing to the wizard. The Dúnedain withdrew into the forest, as swiftly and silently as they had first appeared.
“We are in dark times indeed when the first thing a ranger thinks when he sees a company of Dwarves is that they must be the great evil,” Thorin said. “It was not Dwarves who failed to destroy the One Ring.”
“No,” Gandalf said irritably, “but perhaps in Dwarvish hands it would have come to a more terrible end.”
Thorin ignored him.
They broke camp immediately, heading east until the Old Forest’s branches closed over their heads. The crickets and the creak of old wood were replaced by silence, and a blanket of low-lying clouds smothered all moonlight. The ponies shuffled along with their tails jammed between their legs and their eyes rimmed with white, and, before long, they refused to go any farther. The Dwarves dismounted and dragged the ponies along by their bridles.
For once, Bilbo heeded the ponies’ instincts. He, too, could not shake the sense of utter wrongness congealing in his breast.
For a brief, heart-stopping second, he saw someone drifting behind them—a tall, dark figure with eyes that burned with cold flame. He opened his mouth to shout a warning and the shape vanished into mist Bilbo could have sworn had not been there moments ago.
“Stay together,” Thorin called, his voice flat in the still air.
“We should go back,” Gandalf muttered. The tip of his staff glowed in the darkness; his grey cloak and hat made the rest of him invisible.
“Into the jaws of an orc pack?” Thorin demanded.
“Worse than orcs will find us if we don’t turn around.”
Behind Bilbo, Kíli pulled an arrow from his quiver. “We’ll be ready for it.” He glanced to his left. “Right Bifur?”
Bifur stamped his spear into the ground and nodded.
“You’ll be perfectly safe with us, Master Baggins,” Kíli said. He shook his shoulders as if to loosen up and climbed onto his pony’s back. “There isn’t an orc alive that could kill Uncle—and Fí and I are, of course, great warriors.”
Bilbo had to smile at his bravado. “I’ll try not to accidentally stab someone,” he said, patting Nagtelch. He missed Orcrist: there was something reassuring about wielding an enormous sword, even without the skill to use it.
At the front of the column, Thorin and Gandalf seemed to have reached an agreement, as the Dwarves were trying to turn their ponies. The animals reared, tossing their heads and whinnying shrilly.
Bilbo pulled Nagtelch from its sheath. The blade was still dull grey.
“It’s not orcs,” he said, his voice heavy with dread.
“Form a circle!” Thorin barked, yanking his pony back and drawing Orcrist. “Put Master Baggins in the middle.”
“Now just a m—”
Dark forms burst from the fog with piercing screeches, their long, dead fingers grasping at the Dwarves. The Dwarves released their ponies and the frightened animals plunged down the forest path, towards Bilbo and Bifur. Without thinking, Bilbo grabbed Bifur’s arm and pulled the old Dwarf out of harm’s way. Kíli loosened an arrow at the nearest wight and it struck the figure between the eyes. It staggered on as if nothing had happened.
“Burn them!” Gandalf boomed as he shot a bolt of fire into their ranks.
The front of the train erupted into chaos, garishly lit by the harsh flames. At the sight, Kíli’s pony bolted, taking Kíli with it.
“Kíli!” Fíli screamed, sprinting after the runaway pony.
“Stay together!” Gandalf ordered.
Thorin lopped off a wight’s head and ran after his nephews, the company following.
Bilbo watched the battle from the bushes. Two wights had trapped Bifur, Dori, and Ori. Dori crushed a wight with his hammer, but the second laid its hand upon his head and he went limp, his eyes fluttering shut. Bifur stabbed it through the chest, using the spear’s lug to hold it in place as Ori stuffed a burning patch of grass in its face with his bare hands. The wight howled, its head aflame, and stumbled back into the mist.
“Dori,” Ori said, pulling his brother up by his armpits. “Dori!”
He would not wake.
“His skin’s gone cold!” Ori shouted to Bifur, his voice strained with panic.
Bifur threw one of Dori’s arms around his neck, with Ori taking the other. Together, they dragged the older Dwarf in the direction of the company’s flight. Bilbo let them fade into the fog, then listened until all sounds of their passage vanished.
Bilbo stood up and stretched his arms behind his back, then scratched behind his ear as he oriented himself. By his reckoning, he would be back in Bag End by the end of the week. The company had greater things to worry about, and Gandalf would know where he had gone.
Bilbo had scarcely taken five steps before the night closed around him again, even more unpleasantly than before. Last fall’s leaves fluttered from withered branches, and Bilbo jumped, fearing more wights. He snuck from bush to tree, relying on the rough terrain for shelter.
Rather suddenly, the humus under his toes gave way to brittle brown grass. A shape loomed out of the darkness: a stone monolith, jutting upward like a fang out of green gums. Something foul pulsed from its center, something that intimated slow decay and hopelessness.
A baleful yellow eye seared his mind, and Bilbo leapt back.
”No!” he shouted. He thought of sunlight, of flowers blooming in the window boxes of Bag End, of the Party Tree’s spreading branches, of laughter and songs and fireworks and good food and dozens of other tiny things the Hobbits had taught him to love. Last of all, Bilbo conjured images of the company around the fire. The vile presence withdrew with a sharp snap and the pervading sense of rot lightened. Bilbo knew that if he passed the monolith, he would soon be out of these dreary hills.
Then, from behind, he heard the faint clash of weaponry. It was unmistakably the company, still at the mercy of the wights. Even if they prevailed, they would need to challenge the stone, and Bilbo was unsure if the Dwarves would survive until the morning sun dispelled the worst of the enchantment.
Quite against his will, Bilbo’s feet turned from the open fields and back towards the forest. He soon stood atop a steep hill, looking down on the beleaguered company. They were on foot and drawn in a tight circle with two dozen wights surrounding them. Gandalf was laying into the dead with Glamdring and Thorin was at his side with Orcrist. Of the others still on their feet, Dwalin relied on the inertia of his mighty swings to keep himself upright, and Bifur and Kíli seemed on the verge of collapse. The rest of the company was piled behind them, pale and unmoving.
Bilbo’s sensitive hearing detected even more wights crawling from their crypts, drawn by the noise and the promise of blood. He knew what he could do and shrank back, waggling a finger at himself. He had not assumed his true form in millennium—not since Hobbits had first appeared in Eriador. He was not sure he even remembered how, and even if he did, he would be saving the Dwarves only to die at their hand.
As he dithered, a wight slipped under Bifur’s spear and traced one hand down Kíli’s face. His eyes rolled back into his head and his blade fell from nerveless hands.
“Kíli!” Thorin shouted, chopping a wight in half to reach his nephew’s side, only for that wight to be replaced with two more.
Bilbo made his choice.
No one deserved to die in this awful place.
His soft Hobbit flesh melted away, his hair morphing into hard scales and his dirty nails curling into vicious claws. His flabby, suntanned arms stretched into powerful limbs and his face elongated into a muzzle filled with sharp teeth. His wings erupted from his armored back and, for the first time in thousands of years, Bilbo was himself.
He unfurled his wings with a sharp crack and coasted down the hill, claws out to catch the first wight. He sunk his teeth into its torso and tore it in half, gagging at the sour taste. His tail took out four more wights, and he battered another with his wing. He leapt over Gandalf, flared his wings to shield the unconscious company, and inhaled, drawing all the warmth in his body to the space just within his throat, letting it wax until the heat was too fierce for him to bear. Then he exhaled, releasing a searing column of air at the wights. The grass burst into flame; the mist burned off in a line of steam. The wights howled—a high, piercing sound that cut into his ears—and clutched their burning bodies as they dissolved into ash.
Bilbo twisted to confront any surviving wights, only to find a strangely triumphant Gandalf and three stunned Dwarves. Bilbo arched his neck proudly.
Thorin was the first to recover. He pointed Orcrist at Bilbo and said, “Kill it.”
Chapter 3: The House of Tom Bombadil
Summary:
The company has a short respite in the home of an unlikely ally.
Notes:
V: Happy New Year, kids! This was fun because mudkippy absolutely hates Tom Bombadil. We bartered for plot points and I got this one.
M: Tolkien himself didn't know who or what Tom Bombadil was! Just saying...
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
“Kill it,” said Thorin.
Bifur and Dwalin squared up beside him, weapons ready.
A feral hiss issued from Bilbo’s throat and his back arched. He did not wish to fight the Dwarves; battling the wights had tired him and, despite everything, the Dwarves had grown on him—but if they threatened his life, he would have no choice.
His vision took on a dark, nebulous edge, and he shivered, leaning into the hillside as he watched the cautiously advancing Dwarves. His thoughts, which had been crystal clear only moments before, turned viscous. His gaze met Thorin’s and found only fear and revulsion. If only Bilbo could beguile with merely a glance, like the firedrakes of old! He raised a wing to knock Thorin’s feet out from under him, but the moment it left his side, his hide contracted in the frigid air. He was so cold…
Bilbo feebly gathered heat in his throat, only to find that there was none to be had. Gandalf was shouting, but Bilbo could not find it in himself to care. He laid down and shrank, his scales receding to give way to skin, and his true self hidden once more.
Through heavy eyes, he saw Thorin pause mid-swing. “You ask me to spare this … this monster?” Thorin spat.
Bilbo frowned, pushing past the haze of exhaustion, but his teeth chattered too hard to speak, even if he could remember how to string words together.
“Bilbo Baggins is no monster,” Gandalf said. “If you will not have my burglar, I will have him returned unharmed, and not without your thanks. He did, after all, just save us from a very certain and very awful death.”
Bifur muttered something under his breath.
“I would rather face dragonfire than a wight in its crypt,” Gandalf snapped.
Thorin’s face twisted as he thought, until he finally doffed his coat and threw it on the ground. “Cover yourself,” he ordered, purposefully avoiding looking at Bilbo.
Bilbo, naked as the day he was hatched, grasped the coat and stood on trembling legs. “What?” he asked, a hand on his hip. “Does something bother you, Master Dwarf?”
Dwalin brandished his axes. “Not a step closer, dragon.”
It was difficult to tell in the dim light, but it looked as though Thorin’s ears had turned red.
“Bilbo, stop antagonizing Thorin,” Gandalf said. “We must move the company before more wights find us.”
The Dwarves glowered at Bilbo for a moment longer before stalking off to revive their companions. The sleeping Dwarves were shouted at and shaken, but not a single one stirred to wakefulness. Bilbo, who had a fair bit of experience with such sorcery, attempted to approach Bofur, but Bifur hefted his spear threateningly.
“My apologies, Master Bifur,” said Bilbo. He stepped away and contented himself with shivering uncontrollably. No matter how much he hopped up and down and rubbed his arms, he could not banish the creeping chill. He thought he might faint for want of sunlight, and how embarrassing that would be!
“Hullo!” a clear voice called out.
Thorin drew Orcrist and shouted, “Who goes there?”
A stout figure appeared from the darkness, neither Man nor Dwarf nor Hobbit. He had a wide grin that disappeared beneath a thick beard and a tanned face creased with laugh lines. There was something about that him that made the hair stand up on Bilbo’s neck. He was not evil, certainly, but Bilbo would not be surprised to find he was made of similar stuff as Gandalf.
“A host of little travelers, I see!” the figure exclaimed. He dipped his head towards Gandalf, then Bilbo. “And some who are not so small, as well! And not strangers, either. I am Tom Bombadil, and I have come just in time.” He bobbed his head and looked at the sleeping Dwarves. “You have found trouble with the wights.”
Bilbo scowled at Tom while Gandalf said, “That we have. We would very much appreciate it if you helped us wake them… Isn’t that right, Bilbo?”
“Yes,” Bilbo mumbled. So long as I don’t need to help. He was just beginning to warm.
Tom knelt down beside him, that disgusting cheer still planted on his weathered features. “Terrible things, aren’t they? But no match for you, Krul.”
Bilbo cringed. “Bilbo,” he hissed.
“A much better name,” Tom said approvingly. Then he clapped his hands together. “Now! I can have your lazy Dwarves up and about in no time, and won’t they be disappointed to rise from their naps?”
He ordered Thorin, Bifur, and Dwalin to lay the other Dwarves out in a line, side by side. They seemed dubious, but a few stern looks from Gandalf got them moving. Once the sleeping Dwarves were dragged and rolled into an uneven order, Tom stood before them and raised his hand.
Wake now, my merry lads! Wake and hear me calling!
Warm now be heart and limb! The cold stone is fallen;
Dark door is standing wide; dead hand is broken.
Night under Night is flown, and the Gate is open!
All at once, the Dwarves jolted awake with shouts and grunts. “I was having the worst dream,” Ori said, but when anyone asked for details, he shuddered and refused to elaborate.
“Who is this?” asked Bofur, stretching and yawning. “What did we miss?”
“And why is Bilbo naked?” said Kíli.
“I am Tom Bombadil, Master of Wood, Water, and Hill,” Bombadil explained. Then he gestured to Bilbo, hunkered down beneath Thorin’s furs. “And I would know this fellow anywhere, even if he wore the guise of the comeliest creature in Arda: he is a skin-changer of Sauron’s army.”
Bilbo groaned and fantasized about literally melting the smile off Bombadil’s face. “Formerly. Formerly.”
Those who had seen him grimaced, but those who had not began to laugh.
“A skin-changer?” Dori asked. “Am I meant to believe this?”
Fíli assumed a tone of polite doubt. “So, Mister Baggins, what is it that you, um, skin-change into?”
“A dragon,” said Bilbo with a haughty sniff.
“Usluk?” Kíli exclaimed. “You? That can’t be true!”
“It is,” growled Thorin, and Bifur nodded.
“This monster deceived us every step of this journey,” Dwalin said. “We should kill it.”
“Not here,” Gandalf said hurriedly. “A dragon’s worth of blood would only attract more wights.”
Bilbo glared at him. “This isn’t helping!”
Gandalf gave one of his nearly imperceptible shrugs.
“Then we’ll kill him on the other side of the Barrowdowns,” Dwalin said. “How far is that?”
“Far and far and far,” Bombadil sang, twirling around on his heel. “Let us go there! This is no place to discuss such dark things.”
“Agreed!” Bilbo squeaked through chattering teeth. After he was properly warm again, he would burn everything and everyone within ten miles out of pure spite before returning to his retirement, where he belonged.
They walked single file, so as not to lose each other in the mist. Bombadil headed the column, followed by Gandalf. Bilbo lagged behind: the cold had settled into his bones and he had no desire to speak to the Dwarves—or Bombadil. He would invariably bring up the Old Forest Incident and Bilbo hated discussing it.
Before long, Thorin was snapping at him to move faster.
“’adadith,” Kíli whispered. The Dwarves were still were not aware of Bilbo’s keen hearing, and he planned to keep it that way. “I don’t think he’s well. He looks pale.”
“I do not care how he looks,” Thorin replied.
“But if we slowed down…”
“I will not accommodate that beast.”
Bofur, who must have overheard, said, “He’s still Bilbo, just—”
“Dragons are selfish, manipulative monsters, with no love for anything but their own hides,” said Thorin. As he spoke, he clenched and unclenched his fist as though he wished for nothing more than to reach for Orcrist. “I will not abide such a creature being a part of the company.”
Their conversation tapered off after that. Though not one, but two Dwarves had vouched for Bilbo, the exchange left a foul taste in his mouth. He tensed when he felt the borders of the Barrowdowns pass behind them, expecting a Dwarven ax to split his skull, but, fortunately, it seemed the Dwarves were not as sensitive.
By mid-morning, they had departed the bleak fells and entered a land of soft, dewy hills. Skylarks warbled overhead and the breeze blowing through the grass with rich with wildflowers. A great, ash-crested berm rose above the lesser mounds: this seemed to be Bombadil’s destination.
As they approached, Bilbo realized the hill was actually a house, in the manner of a Hobbit’s smial, but there the similarities ended: there was no garden—although the berm was buttered with yellow trefoil—the door was rectangular, and the windows set higher than a Hobbit’s wont. A song of mesmeric beauty flowed from within, nestling in Bilbo’s heart. His spirits lifted, and the darkness he had carried since the monolith was banished.
Bombadil opened the door and ushered them inside. “And here is fair Goldberry, daughter of the river.”
She was lovely, arrayed in blue and green fabric that fell from her shoulders and cascaded to the floor like a coursing waterfall. Her skin was brown, like good earth, and her hair was bound in green and gold. She leapt up to greet them with the voice of the singer that Bilbo had heard earlier.
“Hello, good guests,” she said. “I am Goldberry. You look weary.” She took Kíli’s hands and smiled, and he looked so shocked that he might fall over. “Follow me. We shall refresh you and feed you, and then there is much for you to discuss, is there not?”
“It seems fairly straightforward to me,” Dwalin grumbled. “Let’s kill the beast and be done with it.”
“Peace, O Dwarves!” Goldberry chided. “Let the dragon speak before you levy judgement upon him. And let us fill your bellies, too, for many rash decisions have been made on empty stomachs.”
After Bilbo was clean and dressed, he returned to the main hall. There was no sign of Tom, Goldberry, or Gandalf, but a fire crackled in the hearth and—more importantly—a sumptuous feast had been laid on the table.
Bilbo grabbed a stack of blankets sitting on a chair and wrapped himself in all of them before shoveling food onto his plate and hunching beside the fire with his bounty. The Dwarves began trickling in soon afterward. They were always loud at mealtimes, and no less boisterous after their brush with death. In fact, the danger seemed to redouble their merrymaking. All the while, Bilbo silently picked his plate clean—bones and all—and wondered how long it would take him to walk back to Bag End. That he would be going home on the morrow was certain.
And if there was a small part of him that rebelled against going back to staid Hobbiton, who needed to know?
Bilbo was just contemplating searching for a cup of tea to chase the cold out of his lungs when Fíli and Kíli left the table and pulled chairs up in front of Bilbo. “Hello,” he said uncomfortably.
“Is it true?” Kíli asked, hovering at the edge of his seat.
“The dragon bit, he means,” Fíli clarified. “And also the Sauron bit.”
Bilbo sniffed. “Of course it is.”
“Well, tell us!” Kíli commanded.
If there was anything Bilbo loved more than gardening, it was storytelling, and he had never had the chance to recite this one before. The first words were on the tip of his tongue, but he bit down on them. His story would not endear him to anyone, not even two young Dwarves that—Bilbo assumed—had grown up on all sorts of grisly tales. Then again, he had nothing to lose if he were leaving tomorrow. The least he could do was entertain a willing and excitable audience.
“Only if I have some tea,” Bilbo said.
Minutes later, the most hastily made cup of tea in all of Arda was steeping in his hands. Just holding it did wonders.
“Firstly,” Bilbo began, “I should warn you that some of this is guesswork: mine or Gandalf’s or our fine host’s. Who my ancestors were is entirely speculation, and a long and boring story no matter what, so we’ll begin where I came in.”
“Good,” said Kíli, grinning. “I like when stories start at the good bit.”
Bilbo gave him a quelling glance. Interruptions would not be tolerated. “I was born in the fires of Orodruin surrounded by the stink of smoke and sulfur. The smell was unbelievable; it was a good four centuries before I rid myself of it entirely. For many days I thought I was alone, until I was reunited with my five brothers and sisters.”
A creak from Kíli’s chair caught Bilbo’s attention. Bofur leaned against it, chomping on his pipe. “Did you hatch out of an egg?” he asked.
“Probably,” Bilbo said. “Can I continue?”
“Aye, don’t mind me,” Bofur said as he sat on the floor.
“Sauron desired dragons for his army, but he had unreliable control over the firedrakes and colddrakes of the north,” Bilbo said. “It caused him no end of frustration, so instead, he worked his magics on my poor ancestors until they became me.
“We were weaker and smaller than he had hoped, and drab green instead of a fierce black or fiery red—oh, he was very displeased about that—but we were the only clutch to survive to adulthood. We would have to suffice: war would soon be upon him. He taught us to be fierce, angry, and dumb. And for a time we were.”
Bilbo waited for the leading question, which Fíli thankfully supplied within seconds. “Until what?”
“We began to change our skins. We didn’t know what we were doing. It just was a game to mock our handlers, where we made clumsy attempts at taking their shapes and voices to fool them. Word reached Sauron, as it always does, so he sent us human children and told us to assume their shapes. We ate them, mostly. The screaming was annoying.” Bilbo grinned toothily, enjoying the ill-masked horror and fascination on their faces.
As Bilbo took in their dismay, Bifur shuffled over, with Oin not a moment behind. “I was just telling these three my story,” Bilbo said pleasantly. “Would you like to join us?” After a moment of hesitation, Bifur sat while Oin dragged a chair over. “It would be remiss of me to simply throw you in the deep end of this sorry tale. Kíli, would you mind catching our newcomers up?”
“Of course,” Kíli said. Bilbo could not tell if he was excited or nervous. “He was telling us that he was born in Mordor—one of six dragons—and that his nadadan and amadan and him started learning to skin-change.”
“Brevity is the soul of wit, I suppose,” Bilbo muttered, bemoaning the butchery of a delicately spun tale. He yawned. “But Kíli is correct. We were given more children and told to learn all that they could teach us, including their forms. As young dragons, this was a tall order. I ate the first child they gave me, and the next after that. The third one made it as long as a week before I got frustrated and killed her. The fourth I grew fond of, and it was his form I learned to take.”
While he spoke, Ori and Dori had carried two cushions over and sat behind Bofur. Bilbo smiled welcomingly. He knew that he had a captive audience in these Dwarves as he had seen Ori scribbling in his worn, leather-bound book.
“Don’t you go one step closer to him,” Dori hissed. “It isn’t natural! None of it!”
“You worry too much,” Ori returned. “Master Baggins won’t hurt us, else we’d already be dead.”
“Correct,” said Bilbo. “Your brother is in good hands, Master Dori.” Dori huffed and went back to speaking with Dwalin, who was still at the table, his head tilted slightly towards the fire. Thorin was nowhere to be seen.
Rather than trust the task to Kíli again, Bilbo began from the beginning. His tale was interspersed with a yawn or two, but he was sure the tea would do a wonderful job of waking him back up.
Soon he reached the point where he had stopped before and continued, “The day that he and I were separated, I was introduced to my hoard. Three fine swords and a dagger, all forged in Gondolin. Some spell lay over them, or me, and before long—I don’t know how—I held them dearer than anything else in the world, even my kin. And myself.” Bilbo shuddered, more for effect than in actual horror. The swords still gleamed bright in his mind, beautiful even after their hold over him had faded. “Every night, Sauron’s minions would take the swords from me and scatter them on the battlefield. And every day, I would fight as if Morgoth possessed me to get them back. Nothing could stand between me and my hoard. With my sisters I would tear soldiers limb from limb. With my brothers I would cook them in their own armor.” He laughed, suddenly feeling very ferocious despite the fact that he was a small Hobbit beneath a large pile of blankets. He yawned again. “I laid low warriors ... of old. I slew kings ... wiped out armies ... and any who dared to stand before me … knew my … my wrath.”
Bilbo gave one more mighty yawn before his head slipped to his shoulder and he fell asleep.
Bilbo woke to Goldberry’s high, clear voice ringing out from the garden. He sat up abruptly, searching for signs of his hosts, Gandalf, or the company, but the hall was empty, save for the bright noon sun slanting in through the windows. Someone had moved him to the floor and placed a pillow under his head, and there was a plate of food just out of reach. Bilbo was too sore to stand, so he wriggled towards it and wolfed it down.
As he licked the last of the currant jam off his fingers, he contemplated his future. The company had seemed interested in his story last night, but he could not take that as a sign of acceptance. He didn’t really want to go home—especially now that he had been properly fed and had a chance to wash—but if staying with the company meant constantly looking over his shoulder, he would leave without hesitation.
He struggled to his feet and shuffled to the door. Beneath Goldberry’s song, he heard Dwarvish shouting and splashing, likely coming from the pool Bilbo had seen earlier. Well, no matter where he went, he wanted to bathe while he had the chance.
The Dwarves were, for lack of a better word, playing. The stream wending across Bombadil’s yard fed into a wide pool that came up just above Dwalin’s waist. As Bilbo emerged, Dwalin was in the midst of pushing Kíli under the water, laughing all the while, as Fíli sat and braided Thorin’s hair while Dori did the same for Ori.
The water looked enticingly cool and none of the Dwarves’ weapons—or their clothes, for that matter—were within sight. It didn’t seem like going for a swim would kill him.
Bilbo sprinted towards the stream’s rocky shore, casting off the blanket he’d used to cover himself, then casting off his Hobbit form altogether. He covered the last few yards in an enormous leap, landing belly-first and diving as deep as he could go. He heard the muffled sounds of the Dwarves scrambling out of the water, but paid them no heed. He surfaced and submerged a few more times, undulating jerkily around the deepest parts until he was satisfied. Then he dragged himself halfway onto land, rested his head upon the grass, and spread his wings to capture the sun’s warmth. His eyes drifted shut as the heat flooded his veins.
His peace did not last long. Even when stealthy, Dwarves walked like a herd of cows.
“Is he asleep?” Kíli whispered. Bilbo turned his head, cracking open an eye. Fíli, Kíli, and Ori stood a few feet away, staring down at him.
“You woke him, Kí,” said Fíli. “Sorry, Master Baggins! We’ll be going.”
“Can I come closer?” Ori blurted.
Bilbo snorted, turning to lay on his stomach. Then he nodded, and the three Dwarves scrambled down the rocky bank, nearly tripping over themselves in their eagerness. Kíli and Fíli struck him with a barrage of questions before Ori asked, “Can you talk?”
Bilbo shook his head.
“Yes or no questions it is,” Ori said, settling himself more comfortably on his boulder. For the next few minutes, Bilbo and Ori went back and forth, Bilbo answering with a shake of his head, a nod, or a shrug.
“Can I touch your scales?” Kíli interrupted.
Bilbo shrugged. Kíli dove forward to run a hand down Bilbo’s shoulder. He laughed at the feeling of it. “It feels strange!” he exclaimed. “But not bad. Like a snake.” He rapped his knuckles against a scale. “Though your scales really are like armor.”
Fíli and Ori came forward, too. Fíli patted Bilbo’s neck carefully while Ori gave the base of his wing an experimental tap.
A deep rumbling brewed in Bilbo’s chest. Both sets of eyelids slid shut.
The three Dwarves leapt back. “Are you purring? ” Ori asked.
Bilbo nodded.
An hour later, Ori had moved on to questions about Bilbo’s physiology, which Bilbo found challenging: he had no way of knowing how many livers he possessed. Fíli was leaning against Bilbo’s neck, while Kíli stretched out between Bilbo’s wings. If the other Dwarves had any complaints, they did not voice them.
“You keep moving,” Ori complained. “It’s difficult to draw you if you’re moving.”
Bilbo huffed, stirring the pages of Ori’s sketchbook, and rested his head upon his foot.
A distant yelp of surprise rang over the valley. “By Durin, what is that?”
Bilbo lifted his head to stare at the newcomers. Nori stood at the crest of a hill hedging in the pool, with Balin puffing up behind him.
“Ori! Fíli! Kíli!” Balin shouted, drawing his sword. “Get away from there!”
“It’s a dragon!” Glóin exclaimed.
“Dragon?” Oin said from behind him. “My hearing has gone! Dragons don’t live— Mahal!”
Bombur brought up the rear, guiding a brace of ponies laden with baggage. He stopped so abruptly that the lead pony collided with his back.
“Balin,” Fíli complained. “It’s perfectly safe. It’s just Mister Baggins.”
Neither Fíli nor Kíli seemed inclined to move, but Ori dropped his things and tore off to greet his brother. Bilbo reached around, took Kíli’s shirt collar between his teeth, and dragged him off his back. The Dwarves sprinted down the hill, weapons half-drawn, but Kíli landed in the grass with little more than a loud complaint. Bilbo favored Kíli’s would-be rescuers with a gimlet eye, then shook off his dragon form.
“Well, I’m glad to see you that haven’t stabbed my friend,” Gandalf called down from the hilltop. “It seems that some of you have listened to me at last!”
“Quite hasty folk they are,” Bombadil agreed from out of sight.
“Well I’ll be,” Balin muttered as Bilbo skinned back into his clothes. “So Gandalf told it true?”
“Gandalf is a great many things,” Bilbo said, lacing his breeches and buttoned his shirt, “but a liar is not one of them. And isn’t it good to see you! Have you only just come?”
None of the Dwarves seemed to know what to make of him, which suited him just fine. He was, after all, unlike anything in Middle Earth, and expected to be treated as such. Bombur coughed nervously. Balin broke the awkward silence.
“That we did,” he said politely. “Our … host met us on the road and we joined Gandalf not long after.”
“Aye,” Oin said. “And Bombadil found the ponies you lost!”
Bilbo found that disappointing. He had no love for ponies.
“The halfling is a dragon!” Glóin blurted. “Are we nae going to discuss that?”
“Gandalf said he isn’t the evil kind,” Nori said. “Could be useful to have a big fire-breather in our company.”
“Thorin?” Balin asked, and all heads turned to their leader.
“He has only acted in our best interests,” Thorin said. The company—and Bilbo—eagerly waited for more, but it seemed Thorin had said all that he wanted on the matter. “Gandalf will have word of the road ahead. Come, Master Baggins. Make yourself decent.”
With thirteen Dwarves, a Hobbit, a wizard, and the master of the house crowded into Bombadil’s hall, Bilbo found himself firmly wedged between Bifur and Bofur with an inch to spare. That inch was caused by Bifur leaning almost across Dori so he did not touch Bilbo.
The news that Gandalf brought was not as well received as the results of Bombadil’s errand. While their host had returned with their companions and the ponies that had run off in the Barrowdowns, Gandalf reported that the Last Bridge, their original path, was being watched by orcs.
“Dírhael and his rangers will try to open the road for us, but they will need time that we cannot give,” Gandalf said.
“Has anyone seen the orcs and lived to tell the tale?” Thorin asked.
“No,” Gandalf said. “The rangers guess there are about thirty of them, all mounted on wargs.” He glared at Thorin. “Who did you tell of your quest?”
“No one beyond my close kin,” Thorin said.
“Well, I have no doubt that these wargs meant to stop you from reaching Erebor,” Gandalf said.
“Are you calling Mum a traitor?” Fíli asked, his fingers casually hooking under the lining of his jacket, where Bilbo knew he hid at least two knives.
“Not at all,” Gandalf said hurriedly. “I suspect someone has been monitoring your movements for some time. We have regained the element of surprise due to our gracious host, but it will not last if we continue on our current route. Now, we must make for the Gap of Rohan. It is less direct, I must admit, but it is safer. We will have friends from Rohan to Erebor to aid us.”
“You will have friends,” Thorin replied. “What makes you so sure that these friends will aid us? I propose a different route.” He pulled the map away from Bilbo and stabbed his finger on three tall peaks drawn halfway down the Misty Mountains. “We make for Khazad-dûm. The halls of our fathers will conceal our errand.”
The arguing began anew. As discreetly as he could, Bilbo slipped off of the bench and crept outside. He laid on the grass and enjoyed a pipe, sending up smoke rings to dance over the roof of the house. Bilbo was watching his latest creation vanish into the winds when he heard the door open, then shut. The footsteps were distinctly Dwarvish, but Bilbo was upwind and could not scent which one it was.
Thorin settled beside him with a heavy sigh and removed his pipe from his pocket. “May I join you, Master Baggins?”
“Very well,” Bilbo said warily, “but I’m not sharing.”
“Dragons are dragons.” Thorin fished out his own pipeweed. “I thought that if I was seen with you, Gandalf would not try to carry on with his tired arguments.”
“He does want us to get along,” Bilbo pointed out.
Thorin puffed on his pipe and gazed across the valley. He seemed to be brooding, which looked to require a good deal of focus, so Bilbo let him be.
Eventually, Thorin spoke. “What reason could you possibly have for going on this quest?”
It was Bilbo’s turn to frown and take a deep tug of pipeweed. “I’m not sure. I’d love to try my strength against a firedrake of the north—no true dragon, mind you. But I don’t have a hoard of my own and a fourteenth share of yours would do nicely.” The thought of restoring that bond filled Bilbo’s chest with a familiar warmth, like tea poured into a favorite mug.
“Is it so important to you? This hoard?”
“I would kill for my hoard, and have done so before. That should be answer enough,” Bilbo said, a little waspishly. The youngest Dwarves had asked him a great many similar questions before.
“What is it like?” Thorin pressed.
The question gave him pause. “It’s much like being in love, I suppose. A hollow, empty sort of love, but love all the same. The hoard was meant to bring us peace, to lull us into submission, and that it did well.” Bilbo laughed bitterly. “Even though it was wielded against me, I long for it still. But maybe that’s what love is, in the end.”
Thorin had no answer for that.
Notes:
Khuzdul Translations
’adadith—uncle
Amadan—brothers
Nadadan—sisters
Usluk—dragonBlack Speech Translation
Krul—four; word invented by authors, as Sauron referred to his dragons by hatch orderBilbo's ancient relatives were small, lizards that gradually evolved to larger sizes and flying squirrel-like wings for gliding. They had a symbiotic relationship with photosynthetic microorganisms and needed sun, heat, food, and water to survive, as does Bilbo. His breath weapon is pure body heat (he runs very, very hot lmao). Under Sauron's influence, his ancestors grew larger and capable of self-propelled flight. Bilbo is about fifty feet long, mostly neck and tail. Here is the inspiration for the wing physiology, an animation by Todd Lockwood. Mudkippy and I are bio majors so we live for this shit, so I'd be happy to go into intimate detail (I spent like an hour figuring out scale material, breath temp., and body temp. we're serious about this shit).
Ok so someone asked and mudkippy and I both responded with the different info we dug up so I'll post that here.
V: A lot of this is in comparison to Smaug because it was a good starting point since he's our canon dragon. So for Smaug I determined that his fire is about 950F (510C) and his scales are a biological equivalent of kevlar (super durable but has a relatively low (about 1,000F/540C depending on how good it is) melting point). Bilbo's scales are a biological equivalent of calcium silicate, which has a high melting point but is more brittle. His breath thing clocks in around an average of 2,000F (1,093C) but can go as high as 2,600F (1,427C) with minimal stress. Bilbo's got a snake scale sort of thing going, and does need to shed every thousand years or so. He's mostly green, about 50% shades of green, 40% greys/browns, and 10% reds. He sort of looks like a seventh grade science project of what would happen if you glue wings to a ferret, he's got relatively short legs and corners terribly. Is also super wriggly. If I remember more or find my notes I'll add more!
M: While Bilbo gets calcium from eating bones (which he can do, as long as he doesn't try swallowing them whole), when he sheds, he needs to consume silica to grow the replacement scales. You could say he even ... craves that mineral.
Bilbo also corners terribly because his ancestors had considerably smaller wings (again, only useful for gliding) and the first thing Sauron did was make them bigger. With bigger wings come bigger muscles, so the joints in Bilbo's front legs are effectively constrained by the mass of muscle surrounding his wing joint. He can move his legs back and forth with ease, but splaying them out wide is difficult and painful. Hence, he has to kind of hop around corners unless he wants to fall over. (His back legs have no such problems.) And Bilbo's ancestors had wide-set legs like you might find on a lizard, but, again, Sauron put them under his body because aesthetic, which only exacerbated the problem. He can run 20-25 mph and looks like an especially bouncy ferret when he does it.
Bilbo is roughly 50 ft. long. Of that, 17 ft. is body and 33 ft. is tail, for balance. Between his scales and wings, he's top heavy, so he has to have all that extra weight in the back to prevent himself from falling over. About half the tail is bone-stiff and acts as a rudder when he's flying or swimming. The end is more flexible, but not prehensile or whiplike.
Chapter 4: Reciprocity
Summary:
The company leaves the safety of Tom Bombadil's home and ventures into the world of Men
Notes:
V: mudkippy and I went back and forth making this chapter more gay and then less gay. Our motto is to start a chapter at maximum homosexuality. It's far easier to tone it down than to make it gayer (or so mudkippy says. She doubts me too much.)
M: If I didn't doubt you we would end up with 10k chapters full of sentences like, "Here he was, kissing a man, touching his butt."
oh my god that was one time
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
They waited a week at Bombadil’s for tidings of the orc pack. Bilbo wasted his days swimming, sleeping, and pocketing interesting trinkets that Bombadil had left lying about and wouldn’t miss. The Dwarves chafed at the delay and their pacing began to wear paths in Bombadil’s floor. Finally, Gandalf admitted that Thorin should delay no longer, and the company prepared to leave.
The youngest three were ecstatic when they saw Bilbo packing; others spared him a nod or a smile. A week of polite meals and afternoons spent splashing around the pool had convinced the majority of his companions that he was no threat. He knew even the kindest Dwarves would still behead him at Thorin’s behest, but he felt in no imminent danger, and he still wanted his fourteenth share and a good story, if he could get it.
Bilbo sensed Bombadil, on the other hand, was quite ready to conclude his part in their tale, and to be rid of the “young and hasty folk”, as he referred to them.
“May the wending roads bring you back to my door!” Bombadil called from the threshold of his hall. “Or, perhaps, to some better fortune.”
The Dwarves waved in return before turning south. Balin had purchased three more ponies in Bree, but they were still two ponies short and, burdened as they were, riding double would have overtaxed them. Balin had asked Bilbo if he could carry the excess as a dragon, to which Bilbo had disdainfully replied, “I am a Servant of Evil, not your pack animal” and that had put an end to that. It was well worth Gandalf’s blistering lecture for openly using that label.
So instead of overloading the animals, Bilbo and two other Dwarves walked, while the rest rode. The pace was grueling, but Balin’s back and Oin’s leg kept it manageable for Bilbo.
The green hills of Bombadil’s demesne vanished quickly, giving way to lands that had once been the Kingdom of Cardolan. Bilbo remembered its rise and fall well; even the peaceful Shire had not been sheltered from the wars that had torn the three daughters of Arnor asunder. The last that Bilbo had heard of Cardolan—more than a thousand years ago—it had been unfit to support even a mouse. While Bilbo saw smoke rising from distant chimneys, he found little else to disprove the report. Nothing grew except grey grass and black trees twisted by the winds gusting up towards the Misty Mountains. There was something about this blighted place that eroded all hope.
Gandalf hoped the orcs would feel the same way, yet the company still took precautions: they traveled at night and kept a heavy watch during the day. The flat terrain meant they would see the pack from miles away, but also that they would have no hope of outrunning them.
Despite everyone’s fears, they saw neither hide nor hair of anything larger than a vole and the company began to relax once more. Bilbo did his part to lighten the mood by acquiescing to Ori and Kíli’s demands for stories.
“Did you know Durin?” asked Kíli.
Bilbo sighed. “No. I did not know Durin.”
“Durin II?” Fíli put in.
“I knew none of the Durins. And may I be lucky enough to never know the next, or the one after that,” Bilbo snapped. “It’s not natural, this Durin the Deathless.”
“But you like the story of Glorfindel,” Ori pointed out.
“It’s a masterpiece!”
“Only because he’s an Elf,” Kíli muttered.
“It’s a far better story than any I’ve heard from the Dwarves,” Gandalf said.
“When was the last time you listened to a Dwarf story?” Glóin demanded.
“Well, I would not be opposed to one right now. It seems Bilbo has been doing most of the talking and he ought to be getting thirsty.”
“Don’t tell him anything,” Oin cautioned. “He’ll turn around and tell the Elves!”
Gandalf blustered and cajoled, but the Dwarves were stubborn, and perhaps a little vindictive: Gandalf’s horse carried nothing more than the wizard himself.
“Bilbo, tell us about the war,” Ori insisted. “You never even told us how you became free, or a Hobbit.”
“Fine, fine,” Bilbo said, waving a flippant hand. Inwardly, he was pleased at the opportunity to have more of his story recorded. “Ever aware of our failings, Sauron refused to send us forth unless the Black Gates were directly threatened. We did not want to fight for him, of course; we would have been just as happy killing orcs as Men or Elves.” Or Dwarves. “Then Sauron put the Last Alliance between us and our hoards—my swords, if you remember—and we had no choice.”
All the Dwarves were listening closely, even if it appeared that they weren’t. The wastes of Minhiriath offered no other entertainment.
“My siblings and I harassed the army for days as they made camp on the plains of Dagorlad, burning their food, driving their mounts mad, and killing anyone who wandered out of bowshot. It was a proper battle, make no mistake! Everyone wanted to be known as a dragonslayer and every time we appeared, a passel of fools would sprint out of their tents, ready to make a name for themselves.” Bilbo snorted. “We ate them by the dozens.”
He let his words settle over them. That would certainly forestall any attempts to murder him. Not that he thought that anyone would, although he was still leery around Bifur.
“On the first proper day of battle,” Bilbo said, “the Elves under Oropher, King of the Woodland Realm, broke from Gil-galad and made a futile assault against the gate. Sauron loosed my brother and me to halt him, and it was a matter of minutes before we had turned the tide against the Elves. Just at our moment of victory, my brother fell, slain by Oropher. When I saw Oropher’s blade—my blade, Orcrist—wet with his blood, I fell into a rage, killing Oropher and his household guard without thought. I reclaimed Orcrist, but Oropher’s vile son escaped with another piece of my hoard.
“My handlers called me back, but I refused. They threatened to destroy Orcrist, which would just as surely destroy me, and my battle rage returned. I used every bit of cruelty Sauron had taught me against his lackeys. And when they were all dead and in several pieces, I gathered up what remained of my hoard and fled. From there, my story only becomes more interesting. I met Gandalf—” The wizard nodded “—and he introduced me to Hobbits, who taught me the pleasures of gardening. If they weren’t so short-lived, I would gladly take my prize-winning tomato seeds as my hoard! Much more useful than some moldering old swords.”
Ori nodded vigorously. “Yes, I’ve already made extensive notes on your tomatoes.”
“Good. They deserve to be remembered,” Bilbo said. “This will be the first year in thousands that they haven’t competed in Hobbiton’s annual fair. That imbecile Otho Sackville-Baggins might win at last.”
“And your family?” Thorin asked. “What of them?”
Bilbo was so surprised that Thorin cared that he nearly forgot himself. “That is my only regret—not learning what happened to them.”
The company reached Tharbad as the swollen sun lazed atop the horizon. Bilbo barely noticed the town at all: they had been riding beside half-submerged ruins for some time and Tharbad’s earthworks—such as they were—were just as decrepit. It was only when Bilbo saw the green wood gate and guards that he realized the city still housed the living.
Bilbo eagerly awaited more food and another bath, but the guards instantly distrusted the Dwarves and appeared to recognize Thorin and Balin. Then, the Men sighted Bilbo and were presented with a new quandary: whether to let the “goblin-child” enter the city. Before Bilbo could incinerate the lot of them, Gandalf informed them that Bilbo was a Dwarf child and flipped each guard a gold coin. The Men verified the metal with their remaining teeth and decided that was sufficient to waive their doubts.
Tharbad was, beyond a doubt, the meanest town that Bilbo had ever seen. It was scarcely more than a glorified hamlet clinging to the rump of a once-great city, with perhaps fifty buildings of mud brick and stone. Their upper stories drooped over the streets as if they were melting, crowding out the light like choking weeds. The Men illuminated the alleys with tallow candles that stank horrendously when burned, clashing with the reek of the middens and of unwashed Men and animals. Feral dogs and pigs outnumbered people, and the rats outstripped all of them.
As for Tharbad’s denizens, it seemed as though they were made of congealed cruelty and anguish. Bilbo did not see one face without pox scars, and most had filthy, tangled hair and arms stained to the elbow with blood, dirt, or both. Men lounged in packs outside taverns, glaring at any passers-by with hungry, red-rimmed eyes. The women were little better: Bilbo watched one set her mastiff on a boy who stole bread from her stall. His screams faded into the cacophony of torment.
“When do we leave?” Bilbo asked in an undertone.
“We’ll ford the Greyflood in the morning,” Balin said, his mouth set in a grim line. “It’s too dangerous to attempt by night.”
Balin found lodging in a seedy inn squatting on the riverside. The Yellow Wineskin it was called, though Bilbo was disappointed to find that they had no wine. “The Yellow Pisspot, more like,” he heard Dwalin grumble as they pushed their way up the stairs. Balin had only been able to secure two rooms for them, and each at an exorbitant price. Gandalf had begged off staying with him, claiming he had business. The company suspected that “business” was finding a nicer establishment.
“I don’t understand this price,” Bilbo said as he glanced about the cramped room. There were two narrow cots unevenly set in the packed dirt floor. The roof sagged and Bilbo did not like the look the puddles half-concealed under the sparsely scattered rushes. For one thing, they had not been supplied with a chamber pot.
“You get used to it,” Nori said bitterly. “We’re Dwarves, after all. Hidden gold sewn into the linings of our cloaks.”
“If only it were true,” said Ori. “Imagine the colors of ink I could get with a coat’s worth of gold.”
“I claim the bed!” shouted Bofur, crashing onto one of the cots. It cracked alarmingly, but remained standing despite its shoddy construction. Bifur took the other with much more caution, going so far as to lick the wood.
“You’re welcome to it,” Dori said, coming up behind his brothers. “There are enough lice in that mattress to suck a Dwarf dry.”
Bilbo shuddered.
“We’ll see if they can bite through my skin first,” Bofur said. He hung his hat from the rafters, safely out of reach of anything with six legs. The others inched into the room; between them and their belongings, it was a tight fit indeed. Their packs covered the entire floor—but at least Bilbo would have something to sleep on. “I thought the innkeeper gave us a fair price, considering.”
“Considering what?” Bilbo asked.
“Considering,” Nori said, tapping the side of his nose and winking conspiratorially.
The Dwarves were out of the room in a trice, leaving Bilbo alone with Bifur.
“Do you know what this is about?” Bilbo asked him.
Bifur did not deign to answer, instead pulling out his squirrel toy and beginning to carve. Bifur had made the burled wood look like fur and its eyes had been polished so they shone like a living creature. If not for the unfinished paws, Bilbo would have thought it was real.
“That’s beautiful,” Bilbo said, meaning it.
Bifur shook his head and bent to his task. Bilbo headed back to the tavern, where he would no doubt find his compatriots and a healthy dose of trouble.
The room was packed to the rafters with rowdy Big Folk. Bilbo gagged; between the stench of their bodies and the smoky fires, he could scarcely breathe. He tried to listen for the company, but that was impossible. In one corner, a pair of Men deep in their cups bawled a lewd drinking song, to general applause. Even another Man emptying his tankard over their heads did not stop them.
There was really only one way to cope with all this: Bilbo was going to get well and properly drunk.
That would be a mighty undertaking. Dragons held their ale better than Hobbits, and Bilbo emptied five pints in five minutes. He felt slightly dizzy only after Kíli challenged him to a drinking contest, which Bilbo won handily after quaffing twenty-seven ales.
While Kíli drooled on the floor, Bilbo volunteered to buy a round for the company, which he suspected did more to win their favor than all his stories. He elbowed, shoved, and crawled his way across the common room, only to realize he was too short to see over the bar. He clambered onto the stool and had a moment to savor his victory before it splintered beneath him.
“It seems the fierce Bilbo Baggins has met his match at last,” Thorin said dryly, appearing from between two Men.
“What’s it to you?” Bilbo demanded, standing.
Thorin crossed his arms. “You promised the whole company a round. I thought you might want help carrying it.”
“I’ll balance it on my tail or something.”
“The first thing you need to do is order,” Thorin said. “If you can see over the counter.”
“I could see over your head if I chose, Master—hic!—Dwarf, and swallow you from braids to boots without any indigestion,” Bilbo retorted. The loud hiccup ruined any pretense of a threat; Thorin seemed to find it amusing.
“Order your ales, Master Baggins.”
“You order them,” Bilbo said mulishly. “I’m too short, as you so generously pointed out.”
Thorin glanced around for listeners. “Not unless you want the mugs spat in.”
“Because you did something to the people of Tharbad,” Bilbo said. Thorin scowled. “Oh, stop dancing around the issue! No one likes you here, which is unsurprising considering your disposition, but they seem to have a grudge of some kind. In fact, the two Men in the far corner haven’t taken their eyes off you since you came over.”
“I know.” Thorin shifted so that he had them in his periphery and the bar to his back. “We should not have stayed here.”
Bilbo stepped between Thorin and escape. “What did you do?”
Thorin looked longingly towards the company, somewhere over Bilbo’s shoulder. “If you can gleefully confess of the murder of thousands, I suppose I can tell you this: our exile pushed us to a place so dark we had scarcely conceived it before Erebor’s destruction. I did things I am not proud of, but I would not see my people reduced like the Dúnedain. They are the scions of Elendil and Isildur! Theirs was the land from Mithlond to Harad, but now they are a shadow of a shadow of their ancestors’ glory.” Thorin’s eyes glowed like embers. “That will never happen to the Line of Durin.”
Bilbo shivered in the heat of his fervor. “I see.”
“Tharbad asked for swords of fine Dwarven make and promised us less than a quarter of their value,” Thorin continued. “We delivered swords strong enough to survive until their first battle, then not long after. I left as soon as I was paid, and I suspect the people of Tharbad have since learned they were cheated.”
“I understand,” Bilbo said. A subtle tension bled from Thorin’s brow. “It would not be fair of me to judge when, as you said, I wear the blood of thousands. I only hope your business won’t inconvenience us too badly.”
“I doubt it, so long as we are vigilant,” Thorin said. “Order your ale. Dwalin has been known to rip arms of their sockets if too much time passes between his drinks.”
“You should get back to the company,” Bilbo said, pushing him gently. It was still enough to rock Thorin back on his heels. “More vigilance and all that. I’ll be fine.”
“You shouldn’t be alone either.”
Bilbo examined his nails. “I wouldn’t mind a brawl. After all, it seems your reputations can’t be made any worse.”
Thorin smiled. “Don’t take too long.”
Bilbo hauled himself onto a sturdier stool and carefully watched the Men around him as he waited for the barkeeper.
“You. Boy,” said a voice. Bilbo looked up to see that he was surrounded by three Men. So much for caution.
“Can I help you?” Bilbo asked sweetly, trying to emulate the innocence of childhood.
The youngest of the three was a weedy youth with the wispy beginnings of a beard. He spoke next. “Perhaps,” said Beard. He clapped Bilbo on the shoulder as he sat in the adjacent seat and waved down the barkeeper. “An ale for the Dwarf lad!”
Beard’s companions were tall and short. The taller was a barrel of a man with thick arms, the shorter a pile of skin and bones. Bilbo named them Barrel and Stick, respectively. They seemed to defer to Beard.
“What’s your name?” asked Beard.
“My name?” Bilbo squeaked. Desperate for a pseudonym, he looked to the company. Nori and Thorin were the first two he laid eyes on. “Norin.”
“Norin!” roared Barrel as he shoved the tankard into Bilbo’s hands. “A name to drink to. To Norin!”
Ale sloshed onto Bilbo’s hands as he crashed his tankard against Stick’s.
“Where are your parents, lad?” Barrel asked.
Bilbo could not recall if Gandalf had specified back at the gate. The potential for mischief was too great to pass. He pointed to where Dwalin and a resuscitated Kíli were singing about a Dwarf woman who did phenomenal things with her beard. “Over there.”
The Men conferred for a moment. “Which one’s your father?”
Bilbo pointed to Kíli just as the Dwarf spun away and tripped over a chair.
“So the big one, the one with the tattoos…?”
“My mother.”
“So that’s a Dwarf lass,” said Barrel. Dwalin had hauled Kíli up and slung him over his shoulder.
The others guffawed. “Still want to take a tumble with her?”
“I’d like to see you try,” Bilbo muttered.
Barrel squinted. “What was that, boy?”
“Nothing! Only that my mama’s more likely to feed you your cock than let it anywhere near her,” Bilbo replied. He’d sickened of their questions and lying for Gandalf was nowhere near as fun as Bilbo had expected. Not to mention their complete lack of respect for his Dwarves.
“What was that?” asked Barrel. As the rest of his companions laughed, Barrel reddened, both in anger and embarrassment, and Bilbo’s Hobbitish side screamed for him to teach them all some manners. His dragon side told him how.
“I doubt you’d need to worry, you probably wouldn’t even—oh, hullo Mother!”
Despite being a foot shorter, Dwalin still managed to loom over the Men. He showed no sign of having heard his new title, but also showed no sign of having not heard it.
“Come, lad,” Dwalin rumbled. He slung a protective—no, matronly—arm over Bilbo’s shoulder and led him back towards the company. As they walked, he leaned over and said, “Mother?”
“I wasn’t given much time to think on it,” Bilbo explained. “I hope you’re not too offended.”
“Offended?” Dwalin said. When Bilbo looked up, he saw that Dwalin looked … touched? “Never! To be thought fit for motherhood is a great compliment among Dwarves. I never knew you thought so highly of me.”
“Ah,” Bilbo said, searching for a way to respond. “But of course!”
For that, he received a hearty slap on the back. “I misjudged you, Master Baggins. Forgive me.”
“Naturally,” Bilbo replied, confused.
After Dwalin explained why Bilbo had returned empty-handed, the entire company—bless their thirsty hearts—escorted “our wee lad Norin” back to the bar for promised round. They also attempted to draw him into another drinking contest, but the danger seemed too great.
When the company began filtering towards the stairs, Bilbo led the charge. With great, leaping bounds he sped up down the hall, eager to escape the tavern. He heaved a great sigh of relief when he came to the door and pushed it open.
The first thing Bilbo saw was a Dwarf rummaging around the bags. Specifically, Bilbo’s bag. Something ferocious and possessive overtook him, only to be quelled by the familiarity of the silhouette.
“Nori,” Bilbo said amiably, “is there something you need?”
“Ah, Bilbo,” Nori said, straightening up with a guilty expression on his face. “No, no, I need nothing.”
“Are you sure? Because that’s my bag,” he said through clenched teeth. As he spoke, he blocked Nori’s path to the door. Nori sheepishly held out his hands, in which sat a pouch of Bilbo’s best pipeweed and two of his loveliest pipes.
“Now, I wanted to apologize, but couldn’t find a good way to do that,” said Nori. “I’d snatched them back in your hole—and a very nice hole, it was. Only, now I can’t find it in me to keep them. So I thought I’d return them. Make it right.”
Bilbo strode forward to take the pipes and the pouch. He looked between them and Nori, then handed a pipe back to him. “Well, it seems that I have come into an unexpected wealth of pipeweed. Perhaps you could be convinced to share it with me?”
“If I must,” said Nori, grinning. Bilbo sat at the edge of the bed and packed his pipe before handing the pouch over to his companion.
“Let me give something back,” Nori said. He pulled a knife from his coat, flipped it so that he held the blade, and offered the handle to Bilbo. “I don’t care where you came from or what you’ve done. It’s simple: you look out for me and my brothers, and I’ll look out for you.”
Bilbo cautiously took it. “Sounds like a fair deal.”
Nori snorted. “I expect you’ll be holding up your end before the quest’s over. And keep the knife. If I didn’t know you were a dragon I’d have your purse faster than you could blink… Say, Bilbo. Have your eyes always been blue?”
“Blue? No, no, they were green last I checked,” Bilbo said. He was paying more attention to lighting his pipe.
“You may want to check again, then.”
Bilbo hopped from the bed and went to his things, pulling Nagtelch from his bedroll. The scant light from the candles glinted off of the blade as Bilbo angled it until he could see his reflection. Nothing had changed but the color of his eyes, once green and now a very familiar blue.
Notes:
V: >:3c We have an au of our au in which dragon!Bilbo is about the size of a Maine Coon cat.
Chapter 5: Hunted
Summary:
The company flies from danger to danger as they travel to Khazad-dûm.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Sleep was impossible in their squalid room. The Dwarves’ snoring was bad enough, but Bilbo also heard the rats gnawing at the walls, the bats chittering in the attic, and the cockroaches scuttling on the floor—and sometimes on him. Lice crawled through his hair and into his clothing; he rubbed his skin raw to deter their bites.
All in all, it was probably the worst night—to date—of Bilbo’s entire life. The only thing that could possibly make it worse was, perhaps, being robbed.
Footsteps pattered down the hallway and stopped at the threshold of Bilbo’s room. Bilbo reached for Nagtelch, expecting the worst until he heard a knock, then Fíli’s muffled voice. “Get up. We’re leaving.”
Bilbo sprang to his feet and opened the door.
“Awake already, Mister Baggins?” Fíli asked. “Help me with the others—no, let me wake Nori. He has his other hand on a knife.”
The others were quick to rise and it was not long before they were silently filing downstairs to the stables, where the other half of their company waited with their readied ponies. There was a conspicuous absence.
“Where is Gandalf?” Bilbo asked.
“We couldn’t find him,” said Thorin, “and we cannot stay here.”
“What he doesn’t know won’t hurt him,” Fíli echoed loyally. “We’re going to Khazad-dûm, with or without him.”
“Why would we need a wizard?” Kíli asked, grinning. “We have a dragon!”
“But…” Bilbo ground his teeth, caught between his pride and admitting he could not protect them as well as Gandalf. He did not like the sound of this Khazad-dûm place, but he supposed he could manage against a few goblins and their ilk. “Oh, very well.”
It was barely light when they reached the streets. At Thorin’s behest, they wore their hoods far over their faces, but the only attention they attracted was from a few hungry dogs. Still, no one breathed easily until the entire Greyflood separated them from Tharbad.
They rode through breakfast and into lunch, determined to put the wretched city behind them. The ground turned into marshland, and their steady ride became a hopeless slog, forcing them to dismount. Flies the size of hummingbirds whined around their heads, biting any exposed skin; the company alternated holding their hands out for balance and wiping sheets of flies off their miserable ponies. Worse, the sedge did not take a spark and they could not dry their clothes.
“Is there no road?” Dori demanded as he hauled Ori out of the mud.
“Not one that we want to follow,” Dwalin said. “No one will find us in here.”
“I thought that was the point of going through Khazad-dûm,” Bofur said.
“Never hurts to be careful,” Balin said evenly, hacking at a marsh plant standing in their path.
“It hurts to be chewed on by these suckers,” Nori said.
Bilbo squashed a gnat in his fist and uncurled his sticky fingers to reveal a blood-smeared palm.
“Two more days, two more days,” Ori repeated. It had become his mantra of late.
“It might as well be two years,” Oin said. “There’s no end to this!”
Fíli sloshed up to them, putting one hand on Oin’s shoulder and one on Ori’s. “Uncle wouldn’t lead us through Swanfleet unless he has good reason. We must trust him.”
They all looked to Thorin’s unbending back. He seemed to be the only one unaffected by their surroundings. He burned with restless energy, pausing only to encourage a floundering Dwarf or pull a recalcitrant pony from the muck. Even during breaks, he paced as if he would not stop until he reached Erebor.
They escaped Swanfleet after four harrowing days and made camp immediately upon reaching solid ground. By now, everyone’s chores were a matter of routine. Fíli and Kíli watched the ponies, Bombur cooked, and Glóin minded the fire. The others first set up camp, then began the eternal tasks of mending clothing, weapons, packs, themselves, and anything else that had become damaged during the day. Bilbo and Balin usually fetched the water; today, it was drawn from the meandering river that dribbled into Swanfleet a mile downstream.
“That’s the Zudkhân, or Glanduin,” Balin said as they hauled their buckets up the riverbank. “We’ll follow it all the way to the doorstep of Khazad-dûm.”
“How many leagues is that?” Bilbo panted.
“Forty leagues, as the raven flies, but I expect it’ll be closer to forty-five after we wind our way through the foothills.”
They set the water near Bombur and sat around the fire to catch their breath.
“I don’t suppose there are any nice inns along the way,” Bilbo said.
“Few live in these parts,” Bofur said. “Or so I’ve been told.” He spat out the grass stem he had been chewing. “Bifur, you’ve been through here before.”
Bifur looked up from his latest woodcarving project just long enough to glare at Bilbo. The Dwarves probably thought he was a pampered brat, and they were right. There was no reason adventures had to be so unpleasant.
“I’ve been through too, but I’m not keen to repeat it,” Dori grumbled. “Elvish magics give me a tremendous itch.”
“There are Elves in these parts?" Bilbo asked nervously.
“Not anymore,” Balin said.
“We’ll be getting back into the mountains soon.” Glóin raked the coals with his bare hand until they glowed. “I hate traveling through the lowlands. I never feel like we’re actually moving.”
“Oh, I agree,” Bofur said, kicking off his soggy boots. “But mountains means goblins, and goblins means there won’t be any game for miles.”
“There will be towns on the other side of the Misty Mountains,” Balin reassured them. “We can trade there.”
Kíli gave a shout of alarm and pointed to the northern horizon. Their heads whipped around in time to catch several wargs disappearing behind distant rocks.
“They’ve found us,” Thorin said, picking up his saddle. “Come! We will not rest until nightfall.”
His urgency was infectious, and, by sunset, they had traveled twice the distance they had the day previously. Their necks became sore from constantly looking over their shoulders. The night was rent with howls, such that Bilbo had not heard since the Fell Winter.
“How far away are they?” Ori asked.
“Hour, at least,” Dwalin said. “The echoes make them sound closer.”
“They have the scent,” Balin said grimly. “It will be a hard ride to Khazad-dûm.”
“Do they know where we’re going?” Bilbo asked. “It doesn’t seem like there are many other ways to cross the Misty Mountains hereabouts.”
“They might suspect we’re making for the Redhorn Pass,” said Oin.
“The trailhead less than five leagues from Khazad-dûm,” Dwalin said. “Even if they think we’ll try Barazinbar, they’ll be too close for my comfort.”
“We did not go on this quest for comfort,” Thorin reminded him, somewhat dryly.
“Where there are wargs, there are orcs,” Bofur said. “And orcs love gossip more than Hobbits.”
“Pardon me!” Bilbo exclaimed.
“There are unfriendly eyes all over Tharbad,” Balin added. “Before long, the band from the Last Bridge will come south.”
“Let them,” was Thorin’s only response.
The company spent the next few days attempting to rid themselves of the wargs. They forded the Glanduin four times and led their ponies backward to point their tracks the wrong way, and Bombur laid his precious spices over their trail in the hopes of ruining the wargs’ noses. Fíli and Kíli took special delight in these deceptions as, they explained, they had used similar tactics to prevent Balin from hunting them down for their studies.
Their path became steadily steeper as they ascended into the foothills. The smooth plains of Swanfleet dipped and folded like crumpled paper, forcing the company to climb one hill only to descend it a mile later. The land was no longer featureless: spurs of lichen-coated rock punched up from the golden grass and rattling stands of aspen dotted the brooksides. Once or twice, Bilbo thought that some of the rocks had been carved, or the trees deliberately planted, but he saw no sign of habitation larger than a badger den.
The nights were silent, but worryingly so: no one knew if they had successfully lost the wargs or if the wargs had become stealthier.
Finally, Thorin voiced everyone’s thoughts as they stopped to refill their waterskins by a brook. “We need someone to scout ahead.”
“I’ll do it!” Kíli said immediately.
“Someone who can travel at speed and remain undetected.”
Kíli jumped in front of him. “Uncle! I’ll do it!”
Thorin’s eye remained fixed on Bilbo.
“Absolutely not,” Bilbo declared. He had managed a controlled glide in the Barrow Downs, but he feared anything more elaborate would end with his snout buried in the dirt and the company’s ridicule. “No. It will be very difficult, what with the … the wind shears coming off the mountains…” He gestured east, into some depressingly stagnant air.
“You need only to find the wargs,” Thorin said. “They should not be far behind.”
The company’s extremity bent Bilbo’s resolve. He was the only one who could do this task in relative safety and, at the very least, he would avoid another day of marching.
“Oh, very well,” Bilbo huffed. He stood up and began to strip.
“What are you doing?” Thorin asked.
Bilbo shoved his waistcoat under Thorin’s nose. “This is tailored, Master Dwarf. I won’t find its like again—not in this neck of the woods—so I can’t rip through my clothes off every time I transform.” He folded his clothes neatly and dropped them into Thorin’s arms. “Take care they aren’t wrinkled.”
Bilbo stretched his hands and watched them melt into claws as the transformation took hold of his body. Then, he crawled onto a tall rock and leapt off, his wings pumping as he struggled to gain altitude. He had scarcely climbed two hundred yards when he felt the strain, but a gust of wind caught his wings and he remembered how to soar.
Bilbo followed the thermal in a loose loop around the company before finding another one to blow him west. He looked down for a brief second and was stricken with vertigo. He shook his head to rid himself of the thought—a dizzy dragon!—and forced himself to search the ground beneath, immediately spotting a few deer camouflaged beneath the stubby trees. Bilbo’s stomach rumbled and he folded his wings into a dive. The wind roared in his ears and buffeted his body, and he closed both his eyelids and enjoyed the sensation.
His eyes snapped open, fractions of a second too late. He flared his wings, struggling to slow his descent, but he plowed feet-first into the grass, rolling until he fetched up against a pile of rocks as the deer pranced away. His wings ached and his chest felt as if Bofur had staved it in with his mattock. He dragged himself atop the rocks, twisting this way and that to taste the breeze. It was heavy with the taste of the deer, damp vegetation, and rocks. There was a hint of something else, too: something musty and rank.
A rock shifted behind him and Bilbo turned as an orc rose from the boulders and shot an arrow just past his head. Bilbo clenched his legs, preparing to take flight, but a warg barreled into his side, snapping at his wings. Bilbo twisted so his armored side bore the brunt of the attack and tucked his wings, tumbling down the rocks. He knew he ought to bite the warg, but the hobbitish part of him rebelled at the thought. He paid for his squeamishness: the warg sank its teeth into the lightly armored flesh on the inside of his leg. Bilbo hissed in rage and ripped out the warg’s throat in a black spray.
He spit out the warg’s corpse—which tasted just as awful as he had imagined—and rounded on its rider. The orc dropped its bow and lifted a horn to its lips, releasing one deafening blast before Bilbo crushed it in his claws. Distant barks and horns immediately answered the dead orc. Bilbo fled for the clouds. He reached a safe altitude, then watched as dozens of wargs galloped towards their summons.
Bilbo found the company and landed in their midst, ignoring the spooked ponies. Ori lobbed his clothes at him and Bilbo recounted his findings as he dressed.
“The wargs aren’t far behind,” he said. “Ten, maybe twelve leagues. They have orcs with them. I counted at least thirty wargs, maybe half as many orcs.”
“Thirty?” Nori demanded. “How is thirteen supposed to go against thirty?”
“With a better attitude than yours,” Glóin retorted.
“Thirty will be nothing to warriors like us,” Kíli declared, twirling his shortsword.
“We’re still five leagues from the gate,” Balin said. “We’ll have to make better time.”
Thorin turned to Bilbo. “Did anyone see you?”
“No one still alive,” Bilbo bragged, hooking his thumbs under his suspenders.
“Then it seems we have a use for you after all,” Thorin said. He must have realized how harsh that sounded, especially after the incident in the Barrowdowns, as he added, “You did well. Can you keep an eye on them?”
“Not now,” Oin said. “He’s injured.”
Bilbo barely noticed his warg bite or the ache of his now-hidden wings anymore, and an hour in the sunlight would mend him entirely. Nevertheless, he wanted to milk his injuries for all they were worth. The company owed it to him after he had rescued them from the wights. But he grudgingly admitted that he had not saved their necks only to let them die now, which was exactly what would happen if he begged off. He cursed his own selflessness.
“It’s nothing,” Bilbo said. “It’s already stopped bleeding.”
“I should have a look at it,” Oin said.
“Never had an infection,” Bilbo said, which was the truth. “You should get moving before more wargs show up.”
“He’s right,” Balin said. “We must be at Khazad-dûm’s gates by tomorrow.”
Kíli rode as close to Bilbo as his pony permitted. “You’re taking me with you next time.”
“You wouldn’t be able to stay on when I dive,” Bilbo said.
“I’ll figure something out,” Kíli said. “Usually do—oh, and don’t tell Fíli. I want to be the first Dwarf to ride a dragon. And don’t tell Uncle, either. He’d try to stop me. Or Mister Dwalin. Or Balin. Actually, keep it between us.”
“I haven’t agreed to take you!”
“But you might.”
Bilbo recalled his unfortunate acquaintance with the ground earlier that day and decided that an excitable Dwarf on top of everything else would be too much. But, as Kíli had said, his mind might change.
Bilbo watched the wargs from afar as they tracked the company’s trail. His estimate of their numbers settled around thirty-three, but their coats were too similar for complete certainty. Every hour, he flew off to locate the company and, each time, he felt the gap between the hunters and hunted contracting.
By the time the company made camp, Bilbo was nearly falling out of the sky with exhaustion. He landed in an undignified tangle of wings and tail, changed back into a Hobbit, snuggled deep into his bedroll, and fell asleep with a, “They’re four leagues behind. Expect an attack later tonight” for the company to mull over.
He woke in utter darkness. It appeared the Dwarves had made no fire, and the stars and moon were concealed behind mountains and clouds. Bilbo’s stomach grumbled and he sat up, rooting through his pack for something to eat—bread and dried venison, and a few early raspberries he had found the day before.
As he ate, he was aware of Thorin’s gaze.
“I’m not what you should be watching for,” Bilbo said.
“I’m not on watch,” Thorin said.
Bilbo searched until he found Bifur and Nori, craftily concealed in two nearby trees. “From what Balin said, you have another twenty miles to travel. You should rest.”
“I cannot sleep when there are wargs nearby, nor when we are so close to Khazad-dûm.”
“Gandalf made it sound dangerous.”
“To the unwary, as many things are,” Thorin said. “I have never had the pleasure of looking within, although I have often seen its three peaks. They stand high in the dreams of every Dwarf.”
Bilbo thought one mountain looked much the same as another, but he did not have the energy to fight a Dwarf about rocks. “Do they have names?”
“Zirakzigil the Silver, Bundushathur the Cloudy, and Barazinbar the Red—or the Cruel. The Elves have other names for them, no doubt, but since this is Dwarf land, it is proper to call them by their Khuzdul names.”
“I didn’t see any Dwarves when I was flying,” Bilbo said.
Thorin picked at the bark on his wood shield. “Did you see a white warg?”
“No.” Bilbo furrowed his brow as he thought. “No, don’t think so. It would have stood out.”
“It is imperative that you tell me if you do,” Thorin said. “Please.”
That decided it for Bilbo. Politeness always impressed him. “Of course.”
“Thank…” Thorin trailed off, then sprang to his feet, Orcrist drawn. Bilbo noticed a faint blue light trapped within Nagtelch’s sheath.
“Rukhskanâd!” shouted Bifur, leaping from cover. “Rukhskanâd!”
The whole company was awake by the time the wargs charged into their camp. Bilbo ducked out of the confusing press of bodies and hair and weapons, carefully removed his clothes, and then leapt over a rock with an angry hiss, his wings unfurled. The wargs hesitated for a split second, and that was all the time Kíli needed to shoot the largest one in the eye.
Chaos erupted anew, and now Bilbo was in the thick of it. He stomped and slashed, snapping their necks with one shake of his head and breaking their legs with powerful swipes of his tail. He counted on the company to move before he injured them, too, and they were more than up to the task. More than once, he felt a Dwarf passing under his belly or using him as cover, and Kíli soon clambered onto his back, firing arrows with deadly precision.
When all was quiet again, ten dead wargs lay in the midst of their camp and the company had assorted cuts and scrapes to show for it.
“Did any escape?” Dwalin asked.
“No,” Kíli said as he pulled an arrow from a dead warg’s neck. “Would’ve seen it.”
“The orcs will notice the wargs are gone by sunrise, if not sooner,” Balin said. “We should march through the night. Where are the ponies?”
“Bolted,” Ori said glumly.
“We don’t have time to look for them,” Thorin said. “Take what you can carry and give the rest to the dragon. Everyone must pull their weight.”
Bilbo took the hint and consented to being laden with their baggage. The Dwarves buried or burned their surplus supplies—including, to Bilbo’s alarm, some food—and, ultimately, Bilbo carried only half again as much as he usually would.
Balin led them out of the wilds and onto an ancient road running parallel to a dry streambed. Its paving stones were cracked or even gone altogether, but uniform enough to help instead of hinder. The company resolutely trudged up the mountain’s shoulder as the sun reached its apex. It had disappeared behind the western peaks when the road transformed into a switchback climbing a near-vertical slope. The oldest Dwarves began to stumble, but Thorin would not check their grueling pace. Bilbo flew over the worst obstacles, tail swishing impatiently as he waited for the Dwarves to ascend. The valley below rang with howls.
Most of a day’s strenuous marching brought them to the top of the ridge. A deep trough delved through the mountain; the missing river had been dammed within, filling the valley with black water untroubled by wind or reflection. Its opposite shore was bounded by a sheer cliff.
“It’s a dead end,” Bilbo whispered.
“No it’s not,” Bofur said, clapping him on the back. “That’s the gate.”
Bilbo jabbed a finger at the rock. “Into the mountain?”
“Well, of course,” Bofur said, sounding confused. “You’ve never heard of Khazad-dûm? Or Moria?”
“Mor-Moria?” Bilbo spluttered, backpedaling on instinct—right into Nori. “We’re going into Moria? ”
“Don’t be so scared,” Nori said, shoving Bilbo forward. “There’s nothing in there anymore. Hasn’t been since the war.”
“It’s perfectly safe, as long as you know where you’re going,” Kíli added.
“And all of us do,” Oin said, tapping his skull.
Bilbo fervently tried to expel the memory of Oin being convinced he had lost his stitching kit when it had been in his hand the whole time.
“What’s the holdup?” Dwalin asked.
“Targhu jalatatani,” Bifur said.
“We don’t have time for that,” Dwalin said. “Where’s the path? I don’t like the look of this water.”
Ori located a narrow strip of gravel rimming the northern circumference of the lake. The company walked single-file for a quarter mile until they reached a beach barely wide enough for three Dwarves to stand abreast. The shore terminated fifty yards distant between two gnarled holly trees framing bare rock. The Misty Mountains still towered overhead, as high as Bilbo could see.
“I can’t carry us over this,” Bilbo said, leaning back to take a full accounting of it.
“Have faith, Master Baggins,” Thorin said. “You stand at the gate of the greatest Dwarf kingdom of Middle Earth.” He caressed the rock lovingly, before rapping it with his knuckles. “If we can find it.”
“Brilliant!” Bilbo snapped, unable to contain his fear and exasperation. “Out of the fire and into the frying pan, I’d say! Escaping the wargs just to be butchered by—”
“Look!” Ori exclaimed, pointing to the cliff. The faint silver outline of a door hovered before them, about twenty feet high and ten feet across. Its sides were bracketed by two trees wrapped around pillars, over which arced lines of Fëanorian characters. Below the words were seven stars over a helm, and a hammer and anvil. It was, Bilbo had to admit, beautiful.
“True Dwarf doors only open when you speak the password,” Balin said, setting his hands on his hips. “We need only guess the password before the wargs arrive.”
“What does it say?” Ori asked.
“I … I don’t know,” Thorin said.
The company shuffled their feet awkwardly and Bilbo realized they couldn’t read the Elvish writing either.
Out of the frying pan indeed!
“How many Dwarves can guess the password at once?” Nori asked.
“You’d best start,” Balin said, and shouted, “Ijnidî! Abâd! M’imnu Durin! Khatdel!”
The other Dwarves started hollering incoherently in Khuzdul.
“Quiet!” Bilbo snapped, rubbing his temples.
“And I suppose a dragon has a better idea of how to get into a Dwarf kingdom,” Glóin said sarcastically.
“I know the characters, and if you would just give me a moment, I’ll remember how to read them,” Bilbo retorted, and the company fell silent.
“How came you to know Elvish characters?” Glóin asked.
“By watching over Fëanor’s shoulder as he devised them,” Bilbo retorted.
“Is he serious?” Kíli whispered to Fíli.
“I think so,” Fíli whispered back.
“The Doors of Durin, Lord of Moria, ” Bilbo translated. “Speak, friend, and enter. I, Narvi, made them. Celebrimbor of Hollin drew these signs. ”
“That was useless,” Oin said. “We are friends and we have spoken.”
“I’m not going to sit around while the wargs tear us to shreds,” Dwalin said, setting his ax against the rock. Dori, Ori, Glóin, and Kíli sprang to his aid, while Nori felt along the rock for the jamb.
“The answer is probably a simple one, knowing Elves,” Bilbo said to himself.
“Hardly,” Thorin scoffed. “They would never make simple what they could make hard, and they delight in…” The shadow seemed to lift from his face “…in riddles.”
“What is it, Uncle?” Fíli asked.
“It’s a riddle,” Thorin whispered. “Is it in the makers’ names? The name of Durin? Master Baggins, is aught amiss with the wording?”
“No,” Bilbo said slowly, reading through it again, “and I know Sindarin as well as Westron.”
A howl rose from the opposite side of the lake. Dark-furred wargs swarmed the far edge of the valley, their snouts down as they sniffed for the path. Dwalin, Balin, Glóin, Bombur, Nori, and Bifur stoppered the narrow beach, their weapons ready.
“You’d best be getting that door open!” Glóin shouted. “There are too many of them!”
“Think harder, Master Baggins,” Thorin said.
“Is there a letter missing?” Fíli guessed.
Bilbo growled in frustration, his fingers twisted in his hair. He read the lines again, and then again.
“Dragon!” Thorin barked.
“Friends,” Bilbo blurted, his hands falling weightlessly from his head. “What’s the Khuzdul word for friend? ”
“Bahâ! ” shouted the entire company.
The doors did not open. The foremost warg’s head lifted and it barked excitedly, then sped along the newfound path, its packmates in pursuit. Fragmented Black Speech floated up from the lower slopes.
“We’re doomed!” cried Dori.
“The door’s in Sindarin!” Kíli yelled. “What’s Sindarin for friend? ”
“Mellon,” Bilbo said, and after the most agonizing four seconds of his life, he heard a subterranean rumble and the doors began to pivot open with ponderous grace.
“Inside!” Thorin bellowed, standing to one side as the company sprinted past. He met Bilbo’s eye and made a sharp nod of approval.
The wargs howled at the sight of their escaping prey and forsook the path to cut across the water. Something rippled below the surface and a luminous green tentacle shot out of the pool, wrapping itself around the nearest warg and dragging it into the depths.
Dwalin had enough time to say, “What by Durin’s shortest groin hairs?” before the lake came alive. Tentacles shot towards orcs and Dwarves in equal measure. Thorin hewed many with Orcrist and Bilbo even stabbed one with Nagtelch before the company rallied to their defense.
“To the city!” Balin shouted as he cut a tentacle from Dori’s ankle. “We must shut the gates!”
The company turned to run when Ori screamed, scrabbling for purchase amidst the gravel as he was hauled towards the pool. Bilbo tossed aside Nagtelch, shed his Hobbit form, and took flight as a hideous shape reared out of the depths: a monstrous face framed by dozens of writhing tentacles—one of which suspended Ori high above the creature’s gaping mouth.
Bilbo swooped down, his claws extended, but the creature jerked Ori from Bilbo’s reach. Bilbo swerved to evade a grasping tentacle and made a second pass. He dug his talons into the tentacle, forcing it over the beach. Ori wriggled free and fell into the shallows, then sprinted for the gates. Bilbo spat out a mouthful of slimy flesh and barreled after him. Ori shouted a warning, pointing over Bilbo’s wings. Five thick tentacles were creeping over the threshold, groping for Bilbo legs.
Bilbo turned around, pushed the company behind him with his wings, and unleashed a scorching blast. The creature moaned, its scalded tentacles curling and writhing as it retreated to the depths. Dwalin and Dori sprang for the gates.
The last thing Bilbo saw before the doors closed was a white orc astride a white warg studying him coldly from across the water.
Notes:
Translations
Abâd — I am here
Bahâ — friend
Ijnidî — open
Khatdel — carrot of all carrots
M’imnu Durin — By Durin’s name
Rukhskanâd — wargs
Targhu jalatatani — he is afraid; literally, his beard withered
Chapter 6: The Empty Kingdom
Summary:
The company passes through Khazad-dûm and attempt to evade the perils lying in wait.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Bilbo woke up under a gargantuan pile of blankets, coats, cloaks, backpacks, and socks, with Bofur’s hat fitted snugly around his temples and the company clustered around him. As he opened his eyes, they set up a great hurrah. The distant ceiling distorted their joy into something empty and pathetic.
Bilbo sat up, gathering everything about him like a cocoon. “Where’s Ori?”
“Over here, Master Baggins,” the young scribe said, raising a gloved hand. “Still have all my important parts attached.”
Before Bilbo had the chance to respond, he was seized from behind and crushed in a powerful embrace.
“Thank you,” Dori sobbed into his ear. “I take back anything I said about your kind, even if you are slimy layabouts.”
“Th-thanks,” Bilbo said. It was nice to be vindicated.
“Can you walk?” Thorin asked when Dori had released Bilbo.
“In a moment. Where’s my pack?”
Kíli tossed it over and Bilbo dressed in his third-best set of clothing. He mourned his plum waistcoat, torn to shreds when he rescued Ori, and wondered what had possessed him to prioritize the company’s lives over his wardrobe. He must have been going soft in his dotage.
The company stepped back, allowing Bilbo to see his surroundings. He sat on an enormous threshold, with the closed gate on one side and crumbling stone steps descending into the blackness on the other. Beautifully carved pillars reached towards a ceiling so high up that Bilbo would have felt comfortable flying.
“Welcome to Khazad-dûm, greatest of the Dwarf Kingdoms,” Thorin said.
“You mean Moria,” Bilbo muttered. He was still sour at being deceived, and frightened now that he was within. He had heard nothing pleasant about this particular pit; he had not even known it was a Dwarvish settlement. He had been under the illusion that goblins had carved it out.
“You don’t have anything to worry about,” Bofur said, as if he had read Bilbo’s mind. “There aren’t many goblins left in the Misty Mountains.”
Bilbo wished Bofur would whisper; there was something about Moria that set his teeth on edge. “Are you going to g-guarantee that?”
“I will,” Thorin said, and there was an unspoken bitterness in his voice.
Now Bilbo could hear faint crashes and yelps coming from the other side of the door. “The w-wargs are still out th-there?”
“Aye and unless they guess the password, that’s where they’ll stay,” Dwalin said. “Dwarf doors can’t be breached.”
“Smaug did a f-fair job on y-yours.”
“Erebor’s gates were not made in the manner of Khazad-dûm’s,” Balin said.
“The only other way into Khazad-dûm is the Eastern Gate,” Thorin said. “They will have a hard ride over Barazinbar’s shoulder before they reach it.”
“It will take them five days at the earliest,” Balin clarified. “That is how long we have to reach the Gate.”
“If no one’s been here in a thousand years, how does anyone know the way?” Bilbo asked.
Oin looked at him incredulously. “All Dwarves know Khazad-dûm.”
“If we get lost, we can always follow the trail of corpses leading out,” Bofur said cheerfully, tapping a pillar with his finger.
Bilbo swallowed. “Corpses?”
“Few of Khazad-dûm’s last inhabitants escaped alive.”
Brilliant.
Thorin climbed a fallen pillar and looked down on them. “Listen, all of you: speak no more than necessary and muffle your weapons. We will not make any fire. There are worse than goblins in these halls.”
“I estimate it at four days’ walk to the Eastern Gate,” Balin added. “If we hurry, we might cut it to three.”
“Oin, keep the time,” Thorin ordered.
Oin pulled a tiny hourglass from his pocket and turned it over. Sand slowly began to trickle into the bottom half.
“We have ten turns to get out,” Balin explained to Bilbo. “Or else we’ll wish the watcher had eaten us instead.”
Time passed strangely in the halls of Moria. The sand in Oin’s hourglass said nothing of night or day, so they walked until they were tired, ate when they were hungry, and rested fitfully until they could go on. Despite Thorin’s warning, they came across nothing, living or dead. Bilbo could not rid himself of the feeling of being followed, and, worse, he found nothing to disprove his paranoia. For every junction they took, four or five others spiraled into the darkness. They passed through halls that would rival those of the Valar in their size and splendor, and skirted gaping pits descending to unguessable depths. The Dwarves kept a steady pace, but paused frequently to stare up in awe or lay a hand upon the stone until they were in danger of being left behind. Fíli, Kíli, and Ori walked about with their mouths agape.
“They have never strayed far from Eriador,” Thorin explained to Bilbo while they stood watch. “Our dwellings in Ered Luin are modest compared to Erebor, let alone Khazad-dûm.”
“Is its name Khazad-dûm or Moria?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin scraped a fingernail against his shield. Softly, he began to sing.
The world is grey, the mountains old,
The forge’s fire is ashen-cold;
No harp is wrung, no hammer falls;
The darkness dwells in Durin’s halls;
The shadow lies upon his tomb
In Moria, in Khazad-dûm.
Immediately, as if to banish the memory of his voice, Thorin added, “Moria means black pit. It is nothing more than Elvish slander.”
With Thorin’s baritone still thrumming in his ears, Bilbo was compelled to look upon the room in which they rested with new eyes. He saw the vestiges of its beauty in the weathered frieze wrapping around the walls, the white plinth rising elegantly from the center of the floor, and the sturdy pillars that protected it. The room must have been a broom closet by Dwarvish standards, but Bilbo would have found it cozy had it not fallen into disrepair. Half the pillars had collapsed and the plinth had been defaced with phrases so awful in quality and content that Bilbo wished he could not understand the Black Speech. The faint stench of goblin permeated everything, as did—oddly—that of brimstone.
“This rock has not known the laughter of its people for a thousand years,” Thorin whispered. “I fear the same fate will befall Erebor, should our quest fail.”
“There’s only one dragon sleeping in there,” Bilbo reassured him, “not a pack of goblins running around and scrawling what they’d like to stick up Durin’s arse on your walls, among other things. We dragons are very low-impact nesters. Smaug might even love Erebor, in his own way.”
“It is not him to love, only possess and covet,” Thorin spat. “You said so yourself.”
“Our desire to protect our hoard is something like love,” said Bilbo. “Love itself is not beyond us. I love the Shire. I love Hobbits. I love my home under Bag End. I do not covet them.” He glared at Thorin until the Dwarf looked away. “Perhaps Smaug does not know the difference. We are not the same kind of dragon, after all.”
“And for that, I am grateful,” Thorin said. “Thirteen is an unlucky number to our people and I would hate to add to our misfortune by ridding myself of you.”
Bilbo, who was accustomed to Hobbit wordplay, could not tell if Thorin had complimented or insulted him—or both. “If I had more energy, my pride would compel me to challenge you to a duel.” He yawned. “You’re lucky I’m such a merciful wyrm.”
“That we are,” Thorin said. “I can take this watch on my own. Sleep, Master Baggins. You’ll need it.”
“The sun,” Bilbo whispered through chapped lips. “The sun … we found the sun.”
He was half-convinced the golden shaft of light was an mirage, a cruel trick played by the foul caves. He had not seen anything of the sky for four turns of the hourglass—days, although he did not know how many.
He tugged on weakly at Bofur’s shoulder. “Is that the sun?”
“So it is.” Bofur cocked his head. “What’s she doing down here?”
Bilbo was already stumbling towards the light’s terminus.
“Where are you going?” Balin asked.
Bilbo waved vaguely ahead. “The sun.” He didn’t know how to express his deep desire to seek its warmth after so long underground. “I need … I need to see it.”
“We only have two days left,” Dwalin said.
“If I am not mistaken, this is the Chamber of Mazarbul,” Thorin said. “An easy day’s trek will bring us to Azanulbizar. We can rest here until Master Baggins feels well enough to continue.”
Relief blossomed in Bilbo’s chest. He sprinted into the Chamber of Mazarbul and threw himself under the rectangle of light with a satisfied sigh.
“What is this place?” he heard Fíli ask as the company entered.
“The chamber of records,” Balin said heavily. “Once a place of great light and learning.”
“We should search it,” Kíli said. “Maybe something is written here about Erebor or ways to enter it, since we couldn’t go to Rivendell.”
“Erebor was a mining colony when Khazad-dûm fell,” Glóin said. “There’s nothing to find, even if we did have the time to look.”
“It was a good idea,” Bofur said to the crestfallen young Dwarf.
They passed around what food they had—moldy cram from Tharbad, mostly—and sat in the sun. As much as the Dwarves blustered about thriving in darkness, Bilbo knew the light heartened them, too.
“How does it work?” Fíli asked, shielding his eyes as he looked up.
“Mirrors,” Oin said. “Erebor used to have their like.”
Bifur sat on the fringes, wringing his hands. It seemed like a nervous gesture and Bilbo wondered why he had never seen him do that.
The wood, he remembered. Bifur had almost always been carving. He must have recently finished his squirrel.
Bilbo walked over to the Dwarf and Bifur rushed to his feet, grabbing his spear and pointing it at Bilbo.
“No, wait,” Bilbo said, holding out his hands. “Wait!” From his pack, he drew out a piece of wood. “For you.”
Bifur regarded him suspiciously.
“I found it at Bombadil’s,” Bilbo said. He had intended it as a keepsake, to remind himself that the strange days after the Barrowdowns had actually happened, but Bifur needed it more. “I don’t know how well it’ll carve but it’s better than nothing, right? Here, I’m giving it to you.”
The Dwarf cocked his head, then slammed the butt of his spear into the ground and made a few sharp, violent gestures. “Akminruki astû. ”
“Akminruki astû,” Bilbo repeated, unsure of what else to say.
Bifur shook his head and pointed to him. “Y’amul.”
“Does that mean you’re welcome? ”
Bifur nodded.
“Y’amul,” Bilbo said.
Bifur snatched the branch from his hand and began examining it with a critical eye.
“There are some who might object to an outsider learning Khuzdul,” Glóin observed.
“None here, I assume,” Thorin said. His voice carried a warning undertone.
“None at all,” Glóin replied.
Bilbo was unexpectedly pleased at this implicit acceptance. Perhaps sticking with this ragtag group of stunted halfwits hadn’t been such a bad idea after all.
“None from me, neither,” Bofur said. “Even if he is a dragon-hobbit—a dragobbit.”
Fíli shook his head. “Dragit.”
“Hobbon,” Kíli said.
Dori suggested, “Hob-drag-it.”
“Pain in the ass,” Dwalin muttered.
“Drobbit!” Ori shouted from across the room.
There was a loud clang from behind them and everyone turned to see the source. Oin was backing away from a helmet he had evidently dropped, axe drawn.
“What’s wrong with it?” Oin demanded, pointing to the helmet.
“There’s nothing wrong with it!” Glóin snapped. “Why did you drop it?”
“Ori said to drop it!”
“I said drobbit, like dragon-hobbit! ” Ori said.
“Well it isn’t my fault I’m deaf!”
Balin frantically waved them into silence. The company froze, straining to hear anything beyond the Chamber of Mazarbul. Bilbo felt it first: a darkness so thick and cloying it blotted out the shadows like oil over onyx. The pillars at the far end of the hall lightened. Something snarled in tongues of flame.
“Abzâg Durinul,” Bifur whimpered.
It was the first time Bilbo had ever seen him—any of the Dwarves—truly afraid.
Kíli strode forth. “We’ll make a stand.” He held his sword aloft. “Du bekâr! ”
“Don’t be a fool,” Thorin said, pushing Kíli’s arm down. “Durin IV will be the last of our line to die here. We make for the gates.”
Up and down stairs and halls they ran, pursued by the growing light and scent of brimstone. They sprinted over the spindly Bridge of Khazad-dûm and Bilbo sensed they were approaching the surface, as it was considerably warmer here than it had been in the Chamber.
Suddenly, a gout of flame shot from the upper level on the opposite side of the bridge.
“What was that?” Bilbo said.
“Durin’s Bane,” Oin whispered. “May Mahal save us all.”
“Keep running!” Dwalin barked. “The Eastern Gate can’t be far.”
The company scrambled up the stairs, Dwalin all but carrying Ori when he fell behind. A scant hundred feet below, an enormous figure wreathed in flame stepped onto the bridge. In one hand it held a fiery scourge, and in the other, a molten sword.
“A balrog?” Bilbo squeaked, head spinning. “We woke a balrog?”
Two flaming wings sprouted from its back and it launched itself into the air, landing in front of the company with stone-shattering impact. The heat of its body was welcome to Bilbo, but forced the Dwarves back down the stairs.
“Fight me, you twisted creature of Morgoth!” Ori yelled as Dori pulled him back.
The balrog exhaled a scorching column and began to advance. Thorin broke from the company, sprinting for the balrog’s flank. It turned towards him and readied its whip.
“Get them to Kheled-zâram,” Thorin ordered. “I’ll join you there. Fíli, Kíli—listen to Balin.”
Fíli charged after Thorin, but Dwalin wrapped him in a headlock and wrestled him towards the Eastern Gate, with the rest of the company reluctantly following.
Thorin watched his nephews retreat, then faced the balrog. “I am Thorin Oakenshield!” he shouted, brandishing Orcrist. “Son of Thráin, Son of Thrór, Heir of Durin!”
Thorin had always stood tall in Bilbo’s mind, but he was diminished by the flames: a tiny Dwarf against a literal force of nature. The balrog lashed out with its whip. Thorin evaded it handily, then leaned back to avoid its sword. He dodged another attack, but now his back was to a wall: if the balrog’s whip did not kill him, its fire certainly would.
“He won’t make it,” Bilbo muttered, throwing his pack into Bofur’s arms. “Don’t wait for me.”
Bilbo assumed his dragon form mid-stride, shivering gratefully as hard scales closed over his vulnerable neck and back. He dove at the balrog; it cracked its whip threateningly. Thorin darted forth and stabbed the balrog’s foot, throwing himself prone as the whip passed over his head. Bilbo released a gout of his hottest breath upon the balrog. The flames on its back flared, but the balrog seemed uninjured.
The cold crept into Bilbo’s wings and he passed low to capitalize on the balrog’s searing aura. A flame curled around his back leg and the balrog pulled him from the air, slamming him onto the scorched flagstones. Bilbo’s claws squealed against the soot-stained rock as the balrog reeled him in.
Thorin reared up behind the creature and thrust Orcrist between its shoulders. The balrog shrieked in pain, its wings shooting out to throw Thorin against the far wall, where he did not stir.
Bilbo snapped the whip with one bite and rushed to Thorin’s side. The balrog’s sword barred his path. Undaunted, Bilbo feinted left and darted right, sweeping the balrog’s legs out with his tail. He tried, once more, to reach Thorin, but the balrog seized his paw. Bilbo writhed like an earthworm, but it held him fast as it prized Orcrist from its back and casually tossed the cherry-red sword towards Thorin.
It was then that Bilbo realized how close they were to the lip of the chasm. He wriggled towards the edge, forcing the balrog to step forward and readjust its slackening grip. Bilbo ripped his leg free, then surged forward and sank his claws into the balrog’s fiery hide, pumping his wings to push the creature towards the abyss. The balrog tipped over the edge, but Bilbo did not watch: he grabbed Orcrist in one paw and clumsily slung Thorin over his back. Thorin climbed into a better position; Bilbo took it as a hopeful sign.
He flew in the only direction he could fathom: away. But Thorin was heavy and Bilbo began to tire. The balrog’s ominous glow grew behind them, throwing their shadows far ahead. A sliver of sunlight appeared in the distance and Bilbo gathered his flagging strength for one final push.
“We must collapse the hall behind us,” Thorin said wearily. “It must not escape.”
Bilbo desperately circled the enormous hall, looking for any way to trap a balrog.
“Melt through that pillar,” Thorin said, pointing. “It will bring down the whole roof.”
All the other columns had fallen, but this one alone—reinforced by the orcs’ crude metals—had stood the test of time. Bilbo had neither the time nor the strength to ram it; he scorched it until pig iron and stone trickled down to its base, and the pillar began to groan.
Behind them, the balrog screeched in dismay, but Bilbo was already gone, slipping through the Eastern Gate with Thorin as the great Dwarf city crumbled behind them.
Notes:
After the War of Dwarves and Orcs (the conclusion of which was Azanulbizar), the Misty Mountains were all but cleared of Orcs, since the Dwarves had massacred the shit out of them in a series of enormous underground battles. It'll be another forty years before the Orcs have sufficient numbers to threaten travelers again, so the balrog can live in relative peace - meddlesome dragons aside.
....And I think we'll call that battle a draw.
Translations
Abzâg Durinul — Durin’s Bane
Akminruki astû — Thank you
Du bekâr—to arms
Y’amul — You’re welcome
Chapter 7: Reflection
Summary:
The company regains their strength on the edge of Kheled-zâram.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
The mountain’s weight disappeared off Bilbo’s back as the sky opened above. He tilted his wings upward, catching a gust off the peaks as he glided downslope in search of the company. He had only minutes before the cold crippled him. So great was his worry that he almost forgot about Thorin until he dove again and felt the Dwarf’s arms constrict around his throat.
Bilbo spotted the company moving under the larch woods filling the valley’s arms. Bilbo landed at the forest’s edge, barely breaking his stride to let Thorin dismount before sprinting after the company. The Dwarves halted at the sight of Thorin and Bilbo, a shout rising from their ranks, but Thorin wordlessly urged them onward.
The company kept east until the forest opened up to a leaf-shaped lake dotted with a stone pillar. The late hour glazed everything gold—except the water. It remained as smooth and unruffled as midnight silk.
“Where do we go from here?” Nori asked after they had stopped.
Bilbo turned back into a Hobbit and dressed as Thorin used his finger to sketch three peaks in the dirt, then drew a thin line to represent the water running between them. He pointed to the start of the river on his map. “We are here, at the source of Kibil-nâla, a tributary of the Anduin.” He scored a deep line for the Anduin, then drew hash marks to its right, with a small triangle atop that. “This is Erebor. We will pass under Mirkwood’s southern borders and then again up its eastern side.”
“With a host of wargs chasing us?” Dori asked. “That’s suicide!”
“Why not go north?” Kíli asked. “That’s where Erebor is.”
“We can’t outrun the orcs on open ground,” Dwalin said. “The lead we have won’t last more than a week.”
“That is why we are going south,” Thorin said. “The lands of Fantkitindilkhîn belong to Rohan. We can buy mounts and food there.”
“And Rohan guards the Anduin at all the crossings,” Fíli said. “They will not let orcs cross their borders uncontested.”
Balin frowned. “Should we trust the Rohirrim to guard our backs?”
“No,” said Thorin, “but we can trust them to kill the orcs.”
Balin rose to his feet. “We must keep moving. The Rohirrim are not as far north as they used to be. It might be a fortnight before we find one of their towns.”
Bilbo raised a hand. “Excuse me, but where is Rohan, exactly?”
Fíli paused just before he swept Thorin’s map from the dirt. He pointed to the area south of the Silverlode. “Over here.”
“Isn’t that Calenardhon?”
“What’s that?”
“Never mind,” Bilbo muttered. Not for the first time, he lamented the years lost in the Shire. He would not have lived elsewhere for all the world, but he should have listened harder for news from beyond its borders.
“We can afford a few hours’ rest,” Thorin said. Bilbo felt an immense swell of gratitude for the Dwarf. “We’ll get little of it in the coming days.”
Bilbo and the rest of the company fanned out along the rocky shore, speaking quietly amidst the oncoming twilight. Bilbo noticed no one approached the lake; the Dwarves refilled their waterskins from a spring nearly twenty yards downhill.
The flight from Khazad-dûm had kept the cold at bay, but, at last, it soaked through Bilbo’s clothes. He wrapped himself in the cloak he had never returned to Dwalin and flopped onto a dark rock, trying to ignore the headache bubbling behind his left eye.
Then Oin found him.
“Up you get, Master Baggins,” Oin said. “There’s no way you escaped a balrog of Morgoth with nothing to show for it.”
Bilbo shrugged, his clothing dragging viciously over the scorched skin beneath. He felt like a chicken left on the coals, but he would heal swiftly under tomorrow’s sun and could tolerate the pain in the meantime. “I’m fine.”
Oin’s hand shot out, grabbing Bilbo’s wrist. The old Dwarf pored over the cracked skin with an expert eye. “You have a fine crop of burns, Master Hobbit. We might need to carry you.”
“Certainly not! And I doubt you could, even if you wanted to.”
“We must move quickly.”
“And I will,” he said, taking a step forward. The blistered soles of his feet lit up with pain, but he managed to hide it under a grimace.
“I’m not leaving until we get your arm tended to, at least.”
Bilbo took the out and sat patiently as Oin dabbed a nasty-smelling ointment on the worst of his burns.
“You make a better patient than any Dwarf,” Oin said. “I have to sit on Nori.”
“I’ve resigned myself to my fate,” Bilbo said dryly.
“Smart of you.”
Bilbo lowered his voice. “Is Thorin alright?”
Oin moved his ear trumpet closer to Bilbo’s mouth. “Eh?”
Bilbo did not wish half the company to know he cared about Thorin’s wellbeing, so he said, “Why is everyone so quiet?”
“Ah.” Oin tied off the bandage before saying, “This is the Vale of Kibil-nâla—the Dimrill Dale, to Men, and Nanduhirion, to Elves. But to us it is Azanulbizar and we remembered it as fondly as Hollin, until we fought a great battle here, many years ago.” He sighed heavily. “I cannot describe the carnage. Thousands of corpses filled the valley from end to end: mostly orcs, but too many Dwarves to count. It was here that we lost five of royal blood: my cousin, Náin; my uncle, Fundin; Thorin’s younger brother, Frerin; and also our crown prince, Thráin, and our king, Thrór. It is not a battle any Dwarf would sing of, except in mourning.”
Bilbo felt a pang of empathy for the Dwarves. The Hobbits’ mortality had been a nasty surprise; their impending deaths had always overshadowed Bilbo’s friendships, even though he had known they wouldn’t die for years. But to lose all of one’s family in one day … Bilbo could not imagine.
“That’s horrible,” he managed.
“It was Thorin who turned the tide,” Oin said. “He stood against Azog, the Pale Orc, who had murdered his grandfather and brother before his eyes. His shield was lost, so he took a fallen oak branch from the ground to defend himself. Then he cut off that monster’s arm and the orcs fell into a rout. Too late, too late…”
“Not the same branch he carries around?” Bilbo asked.
“Indeed. I think he likes the reminder.”
That seemed rather morbid, but Bilbo could not judge: he had kept the sword that had slain his brother for thousands of years. He could only repeat, “How horrible.”
Oin nodded, his eyes distant. “Aye. It was.”
Bilbo cleared his throat. “Is that what the pillar near the lake is for? As a memorial?”
“Of a different kind, aye.”
Bilbo decided to let the Dwarves keep their secrets. After all, even after Khazad-dûm, he would not tell them the Baggins’ roast duck recipe.
“You know, I usually save the worst patients for last,” Oin said in a cheerier tone.
“Am I the last?”
“Kíli.” His name was spoken like a curse. “He twisted his ankle on the way out. I should look at it—if I can find the weasel.”
“He’s up in the trees about twelve yards that way,” Bilbo said, pointing behind them.
“The magic of dragons must be mighty indeed,” Oin said, slowly getting to his feet. “You don’t know where my hearing went, do you?”
Bilbo smiled. “No, sorry.”
As Oin left, Bilbo put his knowledge down to intuition—Kíli often took to the trees, the taller the better, when he was on lookout—but there was another explanation that he was loath to consider.
He was surprised when Glóin sat beside him. Of all the Dwarves in the company, Glóin had shown Bilbo the greatest animosity, and Bilbo initially thought someone else had forced him over here. But Glóin displayed no reluctance as he pulled a locket from inside his coat.
“Have I told you about my family?” Glóin asked.
“No, I don’t believe you have.” In truth, Bilbo often forgot the Dwarves had relations outside the company. They rarely spoke of them, at least to him. It was strange to a dragon that had spent the last few thousand years with Hobbits who couldn’t pass teatime without discussing relations down to their aunt’s third cousin’s grandfather.
Glóin opened the locket to reveal sketches of two Dwarves who looked remarkably similar, although Bilbo suspected the older one was female and the younger one her child.
“That’s my wife, Sólrun,” Glóin said, pointing to the left picture. “Ah, Durin smiled on me the day that she agreed to marry me. There was more than one Dwarf green about the gills at our wedding, and Oin was one of them—ha! And this is my child, Gimli, my zantbarakâl. They’re not much more than sixty and already a better axe-wielder than half of Ered Luin. Thorin wouldn’t let them come because they were too young.” Glóin smiled fondly at the locket. “They have a few decades until they can have adventures of their own, although they’ve managed to give their mother and me a run around the mountains…”
Bilbo was accustomed to the topic of families and knew exactly when to nod or make approving noises. Glóin rambled long into sunset, and it was not until darkness had fallen that Bofur rescued him.
“Need to find something to season our dinner,” Bofur said, clapping Bilbo on the back. “You know your plants. You can probably find something, or at least quicker than we could.”
“Of course,” Bilbo said. He took his leave of Glóin and headed into the woods with Bofur.
“You’re a true part of the company now,” Bofur said. “Everyone’s been cornered by him at some point. To have him tell it, his wife is the most beautiful Dwarf in all of Arda—which she is—and his child is the greatest axe-wielder since Dwalin—which they are.”
“Then he has much to be proud of,” Bilbo said. “I found it touching.”
“Then, from now on, it’ll be your job to keep him occupied,” Bofur said. “And if Bombur ever wants to talk about his children, you’d best listen.”
“Do many of you have children?”
“Bombur and Glóin, and I think Nori has a few,” Bofur said. “Dwarves aren’t like Hobbits. I suspect most of us will die as alone as we were born.”
Bilbo winced.
“It’s not awful if it’s what you want,” Bofur pointed out. “Anyway, I think Glóin’s bought the lie. We can return to camp, and not a moment too soon.” He rubbed his forehead, just beneath his hat. “My headache is killing me.”
As Bofur departed, Bilbo touched his brow, where a headache of his own was brewing. Perhaps it was sympathetic pain.
Bilbo walked away from Bofur, treading gingerly on his burned feet. Soon, he could neither see nor hear the company behind the larches. He had expected to welcome his respite. Instead, he felt as though he had stepped out without smothering his fire: his Dwarves would not be safe for long.
He had resolved to turn back when he noticed the pillar he had seen earlier. He crept out of the woods to investigate. It was about twenty feet high and adorned with nothing but moss. If it had not been hewn from razor-edged obsidian, Bilbo would have assumed it was natural. Thorin stood on the grass beneath the pillar. He had cast off his coat—it had probably been too damaged to save—and the bandages around his hands attested the fact that, despite Bilbo’s efforts, he had not escaped unscathed.
“So …” Bilbo said. “Are we leaving soon?”
“Soon,” Thorin said. He clasped his hands behind his back and gazed out over the still waters. “It was here in Kheled-zâram that my forebear, Durin the Deathless, saw his reflection crowned in seven stars and knew it was his fate to build Khazad-dûm and rule the seven families of the Dwarves.”
“Well, that’s ridiculous,” Bilbo said, stepping to the pool’s edge. “Anyone can see their … oh.” Even when he leaned over the water, he saw nothing, save the stars twinkling above. He briefly thought of wading in, but instinct warned him against it.
“Vainly, I sought my own reflection,” Thorin said. “I thought it would be different from last I looked.”
“At Azanulbizar?” Bilbo guessed.
Thorin flinched. “We passed Kheled-zâram on our way back to Dunland. The entire camp encouraged me to look. After the slaying of a single orc, they seemed to think me worthy of Durin’s crown, even after I had lost more than half of my command.”
“Thorin, there is something I should tell you.” Thorin half-turned in his direction. “I saw him. Azog. Just before Durin’s Doors closed, I saw a white orc on a white warg.”
Thorin closed his eyes. “As did I.” He was as still and remote as the monument itself. “Do you know how I earned the name Oakenshield?”
“Yes.”
In one smooth motion, Thorin unsheathed Orcrist and clove the wood shield in two. “It seems I no longer deserve the name.” He viciously kicked both halves across the grass. “I should have killed that filth when I had the chance.”
“It was the heat of battle—”
“Azog has sworn to wipe out the Line of Durin,” Thorin said. “Fíli and Kíli are in danger and it is my fault.”
Impulsively, Bilbo said, “I won’t let anything happen to them.”
“I know,” Thorin said, “and for that, and your actions in Khazad-dûm, I thank you. I had my doubts about you, Master Dragon, but you have since proved yourself an equal member of the company.”
Bilbo spluttered out some half-baked excuses about saving his own skin to disguise his pleasure. Suddenly, his wounds seemed inconsequential and all tiredness vanished from his bones. He could fly all the way to Erebor if need be, carrying the entire company and their supplies. He could slay Smaug alone, and then drag his corpse out of the mountain and burn it to ashes. He was an equal.
Thorin said, “We should return to camp before Balin sends a search party.”
“Would you prefer to fly?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin immediately paled. “Dwarves were meant to go under the ground, not above it.”
“Suit yourself.”
And, bickering good-naturedly, they rejoined the company to plan the next stage of their journey.
Notes:
Translations
Fantkitindilkhîn—Field of Celebrant
Zantbarakâl—child that shows great promise in wielding an axe
Chapter 8: Holbytla
Summary:
The company enters the realm of Rohan and meets her people.
Notes:
V: The editing on this is a little rushed because mudkippy and I both got sick and had a huge exam this week, forgive us for that!
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
By Balin’s reckoning, the company traveled nearly two hundred miles in five days, skirting Lórien’s southern borders and traveling deep into the Field of Celebrant. The terrain transformed from sharp shale headland to rolling hillocks, and it was here that they made the best time. Bilbo often flew ahead to patrol for orcs, of which there was no sign. The most dangerous thing he encountered was the eldritch aura emanating from Lothlórien; he gave it a wide berth.
Bilbo could never quite shake the fear that disaster would strike the moment he flew off, so he stayed within sight of the company—to him, at least. Having such tiny, dark-loving eyes, he doubted the Dwarves noticed him. All their focus was bent on putting one foot before the other, to cresting the next hill, to keeping pace with the others. Bilbo knew this because he could feel it, as if he were running in their midst. Even in the clouds, he could not escape their heartbeats pounding through his ears.
Bilbo’s awareness did not, unfortunately, extend to other creatures. Otherwise, he would have warned the poor Edain girl before she was forever scarred by the sight of the company bathing in the Limlight. Bilbo had to admit the sight of five naked Dwarves still off-putting for him, let alone the uninitiated. The girl shrieked in surprise—or disgust—and hopped onto her mount, galloping south.
“Should we have shot her?” Nori asked.
“Absolutely not,” Balin scolded, wringing out his shirt. “She’ll be back within the hour with more Men to question us, and then they will take us to their village.”
“She looked like a normal Man!” Kíli exclaimed.
“What were you expecting?” Glóin asked.
“They couple with their horses, don’t they?” He sounded almost disappointed. “I expected, you know…” He curled his hands as a demonstration “…hooves.”
Fíli shoved him back into the water.
“Don’t mention that in front of the Rohirrim,” Balin cautioned. “They’re as proud as any Dwarf and just as quick to anger.”
“Don’t we know,” Glóin groused as he set his socks out to dry. “I cannae tell you how many times I’ve had to remake horseshoes for these nomads because it’s not beautiful enough for the horse.”
“Damn them and their horses!” Dwalin exclaimed. “If I have to make one more copper pony brooch, I’ll eat my boots.”
“Or illustrate one more book on horse genealogy!” Ori added.
Bilbo drew himself onto the shore and basked in the midsummer sun, trying to ignore their increasingly derogative diatribe against the Rohirrim. All this talk of horses made him hungry.
Two hours later, a host of Men rode up from the south. They wore simple leather armor and emerald cloaks, and their helmets were forged of steel and mounted with flowing horsehair crests. They circled the company in a bristling ring of spears, but the horses gave Bilbo a wide berth.
“Who trespasses into the Riddermark?” the foremost of their riders asked. He rode the tallest horse and held himself proudly. “Speak, and swiftly, ere we judge you as foes!”
“I am Balin, son of Fundin, leading this company to seek our kin in the Iron Hills,” Balin said. “We mean no harm to you and yours.”
“Dwarves do not pass through our lands here,” the Man said. “You would have followed the Anduin north if you took the High Pass and we would have looked for your coming near Edoras if you had taken the Gap.”
“We went through Khazad-dûm,” Balin said.
The Men stirred and spoke amongst themselves in their own tongue. The company seemed irritated at the exclusion and Bilbo could not help but think it served them right.
“How do we know you’re not orc spies or Dunlendings in disguise?” the leader asked, pointing his spear at Thorin’s heart.
“Do we look like Men?” Kíli demanded.
Dwalin shoved the spearpoint aside and said, “We don’t act like them, or else we would have attacked you lot already for that insult.”
Bilbo walked between the Dwarves and Men, and stuck out his hairy feet. “Men don’t have these, and neither do orc spies. My name is Bilbo Baggins and I am a Hobbit, from west of the Misty Mountains. I have no care for your petty quarrels, only a place by the fire for myself and my companions.”
The head rider removed his helmet, revealing ruddy features and a thatch of long, blond hair. “Are you a … a holbytla?” he asked, sounding almost awed.
“Hobbit,” Bilbo corrected. “If it’s all the same to you.”
“We have stories of your folk from our first days in the Wold,” the man said. “It is said you are a benevolent people—” His expression turned wary “—but prone to disappearing at will and playing pranks upon the unwise.”
“That sounds like Bilbo,” Fíli muttered.
“I would never prank someone who might provide me with the first roof over my head for weeks,” Bilbo said. “We Hobbits think with our stomachs and there isn’t an ounce of mischief in us if food is in the offing. And if I disappeared, you would have one less problem on your hands.”
Their leader tapped his lower lip, then shrugged, his smile already returning. “Very well. I, Deorwine, son of Galwine, henceforth make you a guest of my hall. We shall share food and fire, and the great tales of our people.”
Bilbo’s heart leapt at the sound of halls and food. “What about my companions?”
“We will deal with them in town,” Deorwine said, putting on his helmet.
“They’re all the reputable sort. Very reasonable. You won’t find a fiercer or more loyal company on this side of the Misty Mountains.”
“That remains to be seen,” Deorwine said. He hoisted Bilbo into the saddle. “You are heavier than you appear, Master Holbytla, but you will be no burden to Leofa, whose dam was Gytha and whose sire was Earic of the thundering hooves.”
The Rohirrim circled the company and drove them forward, their spears never far from the Dwarves’ necks. Balin cast Bilbo a pleading look.
“Really, they mean no harm to you,” Bilbo said to Deorwine. “Surely they don’t need to be prodded along like a bunch of sheep.”
“We are not accustomed to Dwarves in these parts,” said Deorwine. “It is as much to ease the minds of my people as it is to restrain the Dwarves until we know their intentions. I sense a deeper truth at hand. But come! Tell me of your people, for we had long feared them dead.”
“There is little to say,” Bilbo admitted, but described the settlements in Eriador, from farms to great houses, such as they were. He could not see Deorwine’s face, but the Man never asked him to stop, only to clarify certain points as to their agricultural systems and accountings of lineage. But when Bilbo came to recounting the great Took breweries and the Hobbits’ love of drink, Deorwine laughed.
“I am gladdened to hear the holbytla have such festivities,” he said, “but I do not find your boasts of Hobbit fortitude to ring true, for you are small, and any brew made for your people would be lighter than any made for Men.”
“I’ve seen it knock Dwarves back onto their heels,” Bilbo boasted. “Men fall over in minutes. I can hold my liquor rather well, I’ll have you know.”
“I shall not call my guest a liar!” Deorwine said. “But I admit, I would like to see a holbytla face down some of our fiercest ale.”
An idea—a horrible one, admittedly—popped into Bilbo’s mind. “Then I have a proposition: you and I will have a drinking contest. If I win—”
Anything else Bilbo had wanted to say was cut off by Deorwine’s laughter. “A drinking contest? Against such a small creature? That would hardly be fair!”
“If I win,” Bilbo continued, “you’ll set the Dwarves free. If I lose, you can—” He waved his hand vaguely “—do what you want with them. They’re very skilled at making horseshoes.”
A wave of complaints rolled up from behind them. Bilbo twisted around and shot the Dwarves a quelling glare. In response, the Dwarves signed many rude things in Inglishmêk. Bilbo, who had since learned some profanities from Bifur, signed back.
Still chuckling, Deorwine said, “I acquiesce, Master Baggins! This shall be embarrassing or legendary, to be sure!”
It was unclear when the competition had ended and the party began. Bilbo had been winning, by the look of Deorwine’s increasingly reddening complexion, when several other Rohirrim decided they wanted to match tankards with the holbytla. A few turned to several, and the competition spread to most of the Men in Deorwine’s village. Bilbo even saw one of the company’s guards offering a tankard to Dwalin.
“All hail the Hobbits, halest of all races!” one of the Rohirrim cried, raising his mug. “Truly, this is a legend fit for the annals!”
Bilbo inclined his head graciously. Inside, he was preening. He was a legend!
“Don’t let it go to your head,” Dori warned, correctly reading the glint in Bilbo’s eye.
“Oh, don’t be jealous, Dori!” Kíli exclaimed, throwing his arms around the both of them. “We’ll all be famous after we reclaim Erebor!”
“Not here,” Fíli warned. “And Uncle doesn’t want us to drink too much. As nice as these Men are—”
Kíli stuck out his tongue. “Have it your way, brother. I’m getting myself another drink.”
Another drink turned into two, then three, and even Bilbo—who had drunk his weight earlier that afternoon—found he had space for more. He and the company were eventually invited to Deorwine’s hall, where they were, at last, fed. Bilbo surreptitiously devoured three whole chickens, a basket of fried flatbread, cold cherry soup, and some sweet, white rectangles that turned out to be dried curd. Only manners prevented him from further gluttony.
The provender and the lateness of a hot, sticky evening took their toll on Men and Dwarves alike: talk slowed and pipes emerged. It was swiftly rediscovered that the Rohirrim shared the Hobbits’ love of storytelling. Bilbo spent hours swapping tales with Deorwine’s half-sister, Thengara. Much of their audience was lulled to sleep, but Bilbo found Thengara as fascinating a raconteur as she found him.
“There is much and more that we could teach each other, holbytla, if only I were not so tired,” Thengara said, covering her mouth as she yawned. “I will tell one more tale.”
With an impish grin, Kili said, “Let’s have a dragon story!”
“We have only one,” Thengara said. “The tale of Scatha, Terror of the North.”
The Men hummed in agreement and drew closer each other.
“Scatha was the last and greatest of the Long-wyrms, a race of flightless dragons who once populated the North,” Thengara continued. “He was a beast of Morgoth, scion of the wyrms of old, and there was naught in his black heart but greed and malice. In the Third Age, he ventured south, terrorizing the Men and Dwarves of the Wilderland for many years, amassing a vast store of treasure—even greater than that which now sits beneath the claws of Smaug in Éorclanburg. It seemed none could stop his rampage. Then he attacked the village of Men that our forbear, Fram, called home, slaying many of his friends and family. Fram swore a vow of enmity against the vile beast and tirelessly tracked it on foot for twelve nights and twelve days. On the thirteenth morning, he surprised Scatha while he bathed in the morning light and slew him with his father’s sword.”
Bilbo had not expected a cheerier ending to the story, so he nodded appreciatively.
“Were that were the end of this sorry tale,” Thengara said. “But woe! The treasures of Scatha were now Fram’s by right, but the avaricious Dwarves—”
“But the Northmen, in their greed, refused to return the sacred treasures Scatha had looted from our dwellings,” Balin interrupted. “And—”
“The Dwarves demanded more than their fair share under the pretense of rebuilding their lands,” Thengara said. “They tried to turn their failure to defeat the dragon into a font of pity. It—”
“Fram claimed Scatha’s treasure as wergild for his dead companions,” Thorin rebutted. “Yet the Dwarves had lost countless scores of—”
“Oh, stop it!” Bilbo snapped, sitting forward. “Scatha’s shade would writhe in pleasure to see such strife. Let’s agree that bygones are bygones, and that all dragons are naught but evil.”
“Here, here,” said Deorwine, and the Dwarves and Men toasted to that. It was not long before pleasant conversation reigned again: specifically, the best way to gut an orc.
Bilbo was too well-bred—in a manner of speaking—to have such gory discussions around the dinner table. He stumbled outside and laid in the clover-starred grass. It was a lovely June evening, with nightjars churring in the eaves and luminous stands of wild carrot nodding in wake of passing owls. The heavens were more star than sky tonight, and Bilbo named constellations until his eyes drifted shut.
“Hey,” Kíli, dropping down next to him.
Bilbo opened one eye—both eyelids, he had to remind himself. “What a lovely night.”
“Oh.” Kíli fidgeted, perhaps settling into a more comfortable position. “There’s so much of Middle Earth, isn’t there?”
“And to think, I wasted so many years sitting under a hill in Hobbiton,” Bilbo said. “I should have been out here—” He suppressed a burp “—adventuring with the likes of you.”
Kíli sobered. “I wish it was just an adventure.”
“Reclaiming Erebor is the most important part,” Bilbo said. “I know what it’s like to find one’s home.”
“D’you …?” The Dwarf trailed off, tugging at the grass. “D’you think I’ll be a good prince?”
“I don’t know if you should be asking me,” Bilbo said. “The only standard for leadership I have is the Dark Lord Sauron.”
“I didn’t mean to make you remember—”
“No, no.” Bilbo shook his head ponderously. “Poor joke. I have lived under my fair share of Thains and Mayors in the Shire, not to mention those boisterous Tooks who think they own everything. There are many ways to be a good leader, and not all of them are being a stuffed shirt like your uncle Thorin.”
“He’s a good leader!”
“I agree,” Bilbo said, “but there are times when he ought to loosen up! Leaders need to be quick-witted and kind and endearing and swift to forgive, no matter what the other Dwarves would have you think. And you have those qualities in abun…” Bilbo frowned as he struggled to remember the word. “Ah, abundance.”
“And I’ll always have Fíli to balance me,” Kíli said.
“As he’ll always have you.”
Kíli mulled this over for a moment. “Thanks, Uncle Bilbo.”
Bilbo—who had no living kin—had been someone’s Uncle Bilbo for nearly as long as he had been a Hobbit. Dwarves were not so keen on adoption, Bilbo suspected, and so he was deeply honored to hear the title from Kíli’s mouth. “You’re welcome. Was there something else you wanted?”
“Oh, yeah.” Kíli leaned over him with a wicked grin. “Can I fly with you?”
After several more excursions, Bilbo knew he could carry at least one Dwarf, especially one as light as Kíli. Whether he would feel comfortable doing so was a different matter entirely—where would Kíli sit? Thorin had merely hung off the side, seconds from falling. “Ask your uncle.”
“Is that a yes?”
Bilbo sighed. “It’s not a no.”
Kíli sprang to his feet. “You won’t regret this, Uncle Bilbo—I promise. I’ll have the answer to you in no time!”
Bilbo watched him go, then laid back down to watch the stars. He would have liked to go flying if the Rohirrim were not so close.
Tentatively, he stretched his awareness towards the village. He sensed every member of the company: not merely hearing them or smelling them, but knowing that they were all content and safe. Some of them were still recovering from wounds sustained in Khazad-dûm, but, for the first time in days, the undercurrent of stress had dissipated.
Everything would be alright.
Notes:
Translations
Éorclanburg—Rohirric word for Erebor; invented by mudkippy as a contraction of eorclanstán (the Old English word for precious/holy stone, and etymological origin of Arkenstone) and burg (Old English word for city)
(Éorclanstánburg felt unwieldy so it shrunk to Éorclanburg)V: At some point in this, Bilbo mentions opening both of his eyelids. He's got two sets, the normal eyelids and a second set that keeps his eyes from drying out/getting junk in them and stuff. Also, in an earlier draft of this chapter the Rohirrim wanted to hunt the dwarves down for sport, but mudkippy and I decided to make the Rohirrim less extra.
M: Durin the Deathless = Dwarf Chuck Norris. To whit:Once an Orc stabbed Durin with a Morgul blade. After ten excruciating days, the Morgul blade dissolved into nothing.
Durin I didn’t have an army. He had himself.
Morgoth feeds off pure hate and fear. Durin I feeds off Morgoth.
The only reason Morgoth fought the Elves was because he knew he couldn’t take on Durin I.
Durin I is never late. Time slows down for him.
Mahal didn’t make Durin I. Durin I made Mahal.
Durin I doesn’t exhale. The air flees from his lungs.
Durin the Deathless doesn’t retreat. He charges backward.
Chapter 9: A Wizard is Late
Summary:
With heavy hearts and heavier hangovers, the Company leaves the village in Rohan. Now mounted on sturdy steeds of the finest horseflesh in Arda, they make their way to the Southern edge of Mirkwood.
Notes:
So! Apologies for that wait. Mudkippy got a boyfriend and I found out that I'm going to Antarctica for an extended period of time and had to prepare. Not to mention schoolwork. That also happened. But we're back with a fresh new chapter. This time with horses.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Morning saw the company nursing fierce headaches as they staggered from their beds. Bilbo sincerely wished he had the wherewithal to bid his hosts a proper farewell, but it was all he could do to hold his vomit when Deorwine, then Thengara, spun him around in an embrace.
“Should you ever pass this way again, you will be welcomed at my hall,” Deorwine said.
“And to mine, if you visit fair Edoras,” Thengara added.
“It was an honor to have stayed here,” Bilbo managed. He should have been immune to his current affliction, but the compounded pain of thirteen hangovers was more than he could bear. “I will return, one day.”
“Then I shall hold you to your word, Master Hobbit,” Deorwine said. “Farewell! And do not allow those Dwarves to order you about!”
Dwalin very deliberately rolled his eyes.
“Not to worry,” Bilbo said, tapping Nagtelch’s scabbard. “I manage them well enough.”
“A stout heart may serve you where might cannot,” Thengara said sagely. She handed Bilbo his pack, now stuffed with food and a few sets of children’s clothing. “May your steeds be hard of hoof and brave of heart, and may they bear you to great fortune in the Iron Hills, or wherever else your road bends.”
She glanced behind him, then laughed until Bilbo turned to look.
The Rohirrim had been kind enough—with ample monetary persuasion—to part with ten of their horses. At the time, some of the company had complained about the size of their mounts, and Bilbo saw why as he studied the bizarre scene unfolding in front of him. Bifur hopped around in a circle with his foot caught in the stirrup as Bofur tried to reach for him without falling out of the saddle. Bombur and his horse were glaring at each other. Glóin was attempting to give Oin a leg up, but his horse shied and Oin caught only the saddle horn, which he clung to doggedly. Several of the Dwarves—the tallest, Bilbo noted—had mounted, with mixed success. Thorin and his bay gelding both seemed nobly resigned to their fate, but Fíli and Kíli had unsurprisingly chosen the most spirited horse of the lot, and they fought for control as it threatened to dump them into the grass.
“We could throw you into the saddles,” Thengara called, flexing her bare—and very powerful—arms.
“No one tosses a Dwarf!” Nori hissed from where he was draped over his saddle. This only triggered more laughter from the watching Rohirrim. Bilbo swallowed his pride and asked Thengara to lift him behind Balin.
Although Bilbo had no love of horses, he had to ride out of the Deorwine’s village to avoid alarming the Rohirrim. On the road, though, Bilbo would fly and—Thorin had decided—Kíli would join him. Bilbo awaited that moment with equal parts fear and excitement, but for the nonce he was joined to a wretched beast with more stink than sense. The placid grey seemed unbothered by his presence, which infuriated him: he wanted his hatred to be justified. Just to make it clear, he said, “I hate riding.”
“I don’t see why you like flying, then,” Bofur said apprehensively. “Ten feet, ten miles—what’s the difference? Dwarves weren’t meant to leave the ground.”
Bilbo scowled. “Then how do you explain all those holes in Khazad-dûm? I couldn’t see the bottom, but your ancestors thought it was perfectly fine to build over them without so much as a guard rope.”
“That’s different,” Oin objected. “The chasms are already underground.”
“What if someone falls in?”
“That just means a lighter coffin,” Bofur said, eyes twinkling.
“Are you ready to leave?” Thorin asked, wheeling his bay towards them. Bilbo was displeased that although Thorin didn’t seem quite at ease on horseback, he looked every bit magnificent mounted as he did on the ground.
“Does Erebor have railings?” Bilbo asked him.
Thorin’s brow furrowed. “That would be a waste of stone.”
“We’re ready,” Bofur said, just as Bilbo was about to begin voicing his concerns.
With a parting wave to their hosts, the Dwarves spurred their horses eastward. The Rohirrim had not exaggerated their horses’ speed: the village of Men soon vanished from sight and the company covered nearly three leagues before they stopped for lunch.
Bilbo slid off Balin’s horse on stiff legs and gladly transformed into a dragon. Kíli clambered onto Bilbo’s back, sitting in front of his wings with his legs dangling over either side of his neck.
“It will be cold,” Thorin warned Kíli, who wore only a light tunic.
“I won’t notice, ’adad,” Kíli said, rolling his eyes.
“Be safe, then,” Thorin said, with some reluctance. “Take care of him, Bilbo.”
Bilbo made the softest, most comforting hiss he could manage. Then he sprinted into the open fields, beating his wings until the ground fell away beneath his claws. Kíli whooped in excitement and leaned against Bilbo’s scales.
The winds closest to the ground were always the fiercest, but Bilbo rose above them and tacked westward on a gentle current. Within minutes, he passed over Deorwine’s village, but he was so high in the sky that any onlookers would have mistaken him for a hawk.
Kíli was silent. He no longer held Bilbo’s neck and it felt as if he were sitting upright. Bilbo wished he could chat to pass the time, but his vocabulary as a dragon was severely limited.
A few hours drifted by and the fields began to fold like mussed sheets, with sweeping grass giving way to rocky headland. The Misty Mountains loomed in the distance, cloaked in their usual cloudy vestments. The air was cooler here, and the wind stronger, threatening to sweep Bilbo back into Rohan. Still, his vigilance did not falter and he saw no sign of Azog, nor that of any wargs.
So keen was his concentration on the ground that he failed to notice they had company in the skies.
“Look out!” Kíli yelled.
Bilbo twisted just in time to see two enormous yellow feet descending towards his face. He slammed his wings to his sides and clumsily dove backwards. Another eagle was waiting below, its talons already stretched wide.
Bilbo snarled a warning to Kíli before flaring his wings, stalling them in midair. The second eagle’s claws missed Bilbo’s flank by inches. The first eagle’s cry warned Bilbo of its return; he narrowly avoided a collision. As he turned east, he counted five eagles circling above. Bilbo was dangerously outmatched. He had the advantages of neither height nor cloud cover, and incinerating even one eagle would leave him and Kíli vulnerable.
Bilbo raced for the craggy foothills. The eagles easily kept pace a mile or two overhead. Bilbo banked around a cliff, then another as he scanned the rocks for somewhere to hide.
“They’re diving!” Kíli shouted, and Bilbo landed awkwardly atop a rocky spire to watch them descend, their chestnut feathers gleaming dully beneath the cloudy sky. When they could not divert from their course, Bilbo pushed backward off the rock, falling into the deep valley below. He righted himself immediately and flew close to the valley’s arms to prevent the eagles from flanking him. A massive rush of wind told him that the eagles had passed, and Bilbo turned his snout towards the sky, eager to gain altitude over Manwë’s hunters.
“They’re behind us!” Kíli said.
Let’s hope they stay that way, Bilbo thought grimly. Evading the eagles would take time and the company would worry at their absence. The mere thought of a prolonged separation tied Bilbo’s stomach into knots.
An eagle struck him hard, its talons constricting his neck and belly. Kíli’s grip loosened and Bilbo leveled out to prevent him from slipping. The eagle seized its chance to shift its claws from Bilbo’s neck to his wing, forcing it down, and they began to spiral in a mess of feathers, scales, and claws. The eagle pecked at Bilbo’s eyes. Bilbo sacrificed his crest, then tore out mouthfuls of the eagle’s wing feathers and scoured its breast until hot blood ran down his belly. Still the eagle clung to his wing with grim determination.
He heard a soft twang from behind him and an arrow pierced the eagle’s shoulder. The eagle screeched and dropped Bilbo, pummeling them with the downdraft from its wings. Bilbo arrested their fall—too sharply. Kíli was torn from his back.
“Bilbo!” Kíli cried.
Bilbo dove for Kíli, who was tumbling uncontrollably through the air, his arms wrapped around his quiver. The ground was perhaps five or six seconds away, and he had—
One of the eagles came up from under him, catching Kíli easily before darting away.
Bilbo’s vision went red. These rotten featherballs had no business with his Dwarves, his hoard. He bore down on the bird, sharply inhaling as he prepared to roast the feathery beast to its bones.
Stop!
Gandalf’s voice echoed through Bilbo’s head. An eagle swooped past, bearing a grey-robed figured on its back. The wizard shook his staff at Bilbo.
The eagles of Manwë mean you no harm, Gandalf continued. They mistook you for the firedrakes of old and thought you would visit evil upon this land.
No further harm, you mean! Bilbo fumed. I’ll be recovering for a week!
And you injured Gwaihir, their lord. You cannot play the innocent here.
Bilbo ground his teeth. Five eagles against one dragon hardly seemed fair. At least make them return Kíli.
He will be safe with Landroval, Gandalf said.
Bilbo reserved his doubts to avoid chastisement.
Now lead me back to the company, Gandalf continued. I have been away for far too long … and tell me what has passed since Tharbad. You need not say it, only think it.
Bilbo angled eastward, flapping steadily as he recalled being chased through Hollin and their time in Khazad-dûm. He felt Gandalf flinch when he reached the part about the balrog, but Bilbo pressed on, now eliding almost all of his conversations with the Dwarves. He finished up with their time in Rohan, ending with an image of the company riding far below.
It seems you have been busy, Gandalf said at last.
Bilbo said nothing as he began a slow descent on strained wings. He landed a quarter mile ahead of the company on the highest rock he could find, forcing the eagles—and Gandalf—to perch beneath him. A smaller eagle attempted landing beside Bilbo and Bilbo took great delight in muscling him out.
Kíli slid off his mount and went over to the eagle with an arrow protruding from its bloodied chest.
“My sincerest apologies, Master Eagle,” Kíli said, bowing hastily. “I didn’t want you to kill my friend.”
To Bilbo’s surprise, Gwaihir spoke in Westron. “Do not apologize. It was a fine shot.” He yanked the arrow and several feathers from his shoulder and spat them at Kíli’s feet. “Take them as a reminder of the time you wounded Gwaihir the Windlord. May your aim always be as true, young prince.”
Kíli snatched up the arrow and feathers, awestruck. Bilbo shattered the rocks beneath his paws to mask his jealousy.
“Our time together has come to an end, Mithrandir,” Gwaihir said. “Farewell wherever you fare, till your eyries receive you at the journey’s end.”
“May the wind under your wings bear you where the sun sails and the moon walks,” Gandalf said, bowing to him. Bilbo sincerely hoped he wasn’t expected to genuflect for one of Manwë’s pigeons. Gandalf glared at him as if he had read Bilbo’s thoughts. “If my friend should pass this way again, might I suggest not attacking him? Although he is a dragon, through great effort of his own, he overthrew Sauron’s hold on him and is now … ah, entirely benevolent.”
The grip of Gwaihir’s eyes was even more powerful than his claws. Bilbo resisted the urge to squirm away. “I still sense a darkness in this creature … but there is good, as well.” He inclined his head. “You have my word, from one lord of the sky to another, that me and mine shall never attack you again.”
Bilbo, for his part, could only purr. Lord of the Sky was a noble—and appropriate—epithet.
The eagles took off as the company rounded the top of the hill, pulling their mounts just short of the rocks.
“Mister Gandalf?” Dori asked.
Gandalf smiled. “Yes, it is I, rejoining you at last, albeit briefly.”
“Briefly?” Ori asked. “But we’re not even halfway to Erebor!”
“Peace, Master Dwarf,” Gandalf said. “I will explain.” He peered at the western horizon. The sunset seeped into the crags on his face. “Yes, this is a good time and place for you to stop for the evening.”
“It’s scarcely nightfall,” Thorin said.
“And your foes are many leagues behind you,” Gandalf said. “I spotted them when I flew over the mountains—looking for you, at first, but finding only Azog. Crossing over the Redhorn Pass halved his numbers and they lick their wounds in the Dimrill Dale, chasing a trail that is over a week old. Even Gundabad wargs will have difficulty with that!”
“I thought Azog was dead,” Ori said. “He was slain at Azanulbizar.”
The company looked to Thorin. With great difficulty, he said, “It seems that he survived. Master Baggins saw him before the Watcher collapsed Durin’s Gate.”
Dwalin put a hand on Thorin’s shoulder. “A trick of the light.”
“I had hoped,” Thorin said gravely, “but Master Baggins has keener eyes than we do and now Gandalf has confirmed it. It seems that that foul orc survived after all.”
“We should keep moving,” Balin said, an undercurrent of fear coloring his voice. His gaze darted to Fíli and Kíli. “Many of us spring from the Line of Durin.”
Gandalf’s eyes twinkled as he leaned on his staff. “May I also add that the eagles took great umbrage to the passage of orcs under their eyries.”
“Is he dead?” Dwalin asked.
“Azog is far too crafty for them,” Gandalf said, “but all his wargs are dead and reinforcements are far afield. You are safe, for now.”
The company set about their evening tasks: Ori, Nori, and Fíli picketed the horses; Dori, Balin, Dwalin, Bifur, and Bofur searched for firewood; Bombur and Oin fussed over dinner; and Glóin bent over the tinder, coaxing a flame from the small pile. Kíli was ostensibly brushing the horses, but he was so excited to recount his adventure that he hindered everyone’s productivity. Bilbo, who was dressing behind a nearby rock, had the misfortune to hear his actions retold in grisly detail.
“And then I was falling—but I wasn’t scared,” Kíli was saying to his brother. “The whole world stretched under me like a bed of emeralds. It was beautiful.” He sighed. “You should come with me next time, if Uncle Bilbo will let you.”
Fíli sniggered. “Are you going to keep calling him that?”
Bilbo paused with his shirt halfway over his head.
“He likes it.”
“But does he know why you’re using it?”
“Of course not!”
“Master Baggins,” Thorin said, interrupting his eavesdropping.
Bilbo hastily pulled his shirt down and looped his suspenders over his shoulders. “Sorry, did I miss something?”
“Dinner, almost,” Thorin said. “I heard my nephew had some excitement today.”
“It was all within my control,” Bilbo assured him. “It was fun having someone up there with me.”
Thorin quirked an eyebrow. “And to have someone to shoot eagles off your back.”
“He made it sound worse than it was,” Bilbo said.
“I can’t imagine how he could make flying sound worse.”
He spoke with such distaste that Bilbo laughed. “I thought it was everyone’s dream to fly.”
“Elves and Men, perhaps,” Thorin said. “They have always looked to the sky for the rhythms of their lives. But Khazâd were made from different stock and it is our maker’s earth and stone that we long to explore.”
“Would I be more interesting to cay-zud if I were a giant mole, then?”
Thorin grinned. “Ah! Imagine following you to the depths of the world, deeper than even we have delved. Imagine what veins we would find so far down. Rivers of mithril, galaxies of rubies, shimmering seas of opal—”
Bilbo stalked past him and teased, “I think I would like my fill of hot stew instead of Dwarvish lies.”
“Ah!” Gandalf said when they came into sight. “So nice of you to join us. Bombur was just about to take your share.”
Bombur shook his head insistently.
“Ah, we would have blamed the wizard first,” Bofur told him.
“To no avail,” Bilbo said, sitting at Gandalf’s side. “He exists on nothing but the finest Old Toby.” He inhaled deeply. “In fact, you have some with you right now.”
“To think I could have deceived a dragon,” Gandalf grumbled as he handed his pouch to Bilbo. “I went through a great deal of trouble convincing Lord Elrond to part with it, so don’t smoke it all. I should like something to soften my throat before I begin to tell you of what has transpired in your absence.”
“You haven’t even heard what we’ve been up to!” Fíli said.
“Bilbo already told me everything.”
Fíli’s face fell. Bilbo discreetly kicked the wizard.
“But I should very much like to hear it again,” Gandalf added. “It might be that Bilbo left out something important.”
“That’s likely,” Ori said. “He spent weeks telling me about Shire history, but he doesn’t know anything about any of the Durins.”
“Proof that I only remember things that matter,” Bilbo sniffed, to general derision.
The company took turns telling the story, often out-shouting one another when someone thought they could tell the tale better. Kíli and Fíli leapt to their feet during the battles, pulling whoever was nearest to join their reenactments. Bifur, enthusiastically serving as the balrog, almost pushed Dori into the fire.
Bilbo noted that while the company was particularly long-winded about the battles, they often omitted their thoughts and feelings, especially about Bilbo, the Rohirrim, and Khazad-dûm. Their rest in Azanulbizar was glossed over in a sentence. Knowing what actually transpired gave Bilbo a sense of privilege and belonging, and he felt rather smug as he sat beside Gandalf and smoked more pipeweed than polite.
“My part is considerably less exciting, but more fraught with worry,” Gandalf said, “beginning when I went to your inn in Tharbad less than a day after we parted and found you six hours gone!”
Bilbo coughed. Thorin set his jaw stubbornly.
“I found some Dunlendings who told me of Dwarves traveling east and I thought to myself, Well, if they want to risk the road without a wizard’s guidance, so be it!” Gandalf glared at them. “You are very lucky to have all escaped Moria in one piece. It is a feat you should be proud of—but in no hurry to repeat! I hope your time in the shadow of Durin’s Bane has shown you that retaking the city is still impossible.”
“We need no further lecture,” Thorin snapped.
Bilbo realized he was perilously wedged between Thorin and Gandalf. On the whole, he thought, he would have preferred a rematch with the balrog.
“Instead of following you,” Gandalf said, “I rode to Rivendell and passed some time there with Lord Elrond before making for the eagles’ eyries near the High Pass. If you were still alive at that point, I knew to look for you on the eastern slopes. Instead, I found Azog, and then shortly thereafter Bilbo and Kíli.”
“You ordered the eagles to attack my kin?” Thorin asked.
“Five of their youngest eagles were in the vanguard,” Gandalf said. “They became … excited, much as your nephews can be—and before you take umbrage, remember that they are the Eagles of Manwë; you would do well not to rouse their wrath.”
Thorin scowled.
“Now,” Gandalf said, “I assume you are heading south under Mirkwood and then north along its eastern border. I will travel with you for a time and lead you to a safe place where you might rest before completing the last leg of your journey.”
“For a time?” Dori asked, his voice heavy with dismay. “What other business do you have?”
“There have been reports of a necromancer who has taken up refuge in Dol Guldur, an old fortress in the south of Mirkwood,” Gandalf said. “It is my duty to investigate these rumors and put them to rest, if possible. I will rejoin you before you enter Erebor. In fact, I don’t want you to enter that mountain at all unless I am with you.”
“We will wait,” Balin said. “For a time.”
“What is this safe place you intend to take us to?” Thorin asked.
“Another member of my order, Radagast the Brown, keeps his home even farther south than Dol Guldur,” Gandalf said. “No creature of evil will be able to pass by his dwelling and, if they try, Radagast will take them off your scent.”
“There wouldn’t be any Elves in that part of the woods, would there?” Glóin asked.
“Not for many an age,” Gandalf said. “Thranduil’s domain—since it is him you fear—”
“Fear?” Dwalin demanded. “If I ever saw that liar, I’d behead him with a blunt knife!”
“It’s us he should be fearing!” Fíli cried bravely.
As the Dwarves made threats of ever-increasing violence, Bilbo wondered if Thranduil still had his old sword or if he remembered Bilbo had torn Oropher’s head from his body. Bilbo hoped for the former: he wanted it back.
“I would never take you to the Elvenking’s halls,” Gandalf was saying. “I know of the animosity that lies between you.”
“He left us to starve,” Thorin hissed. “That oathbreaker knows nothing of loyalty or kindness, and I would never treat him other than how he deserves.”
“Then it’s a good thing you are not going anywhere near him,” Gandalf said, exasperated. “Now, we should all rest. We still have far to travel.”
Since Gandalf did not have a mount, their travel arrangements changed. The wizard received his own horse and most of the company still rode, but Bilbo had to serve as their pack mule. He spent his days ferrying Ori, Fíli, Kíli, and Bifur—the lightest three, and someone to watch over them—from the previous night’s camp to where he thought the company would stop that evening. Flying with Kíli was no trouble, but Ori clung to his neck until Bilbo nearly suffocated; Bifur insisted on flying so low that Bilbo’s claws grazed the grass; and Fíli tried to emulate Kíli’s bravado, but always vomited upon returning to solid ground.
By the end of the week, they had reached Mirkwood’s border. A hard line of mature trees demarcated its boundary with Rohan as surely as a castle wall. Bilbo felt that they were diving into the sea, not walking into a wood.
“Dismount your horses,” Gandalf ordered as he slid off his. “We can’t risk them carrying you away. If you disappear, you may never be found again.”
“Some safe house this must be,” Dori complained.
“The best safe houses have something to ward off whoever’s looking for you,” Nori pointed out.
“This isn’t a ward,” Glóin said. “It’s all a trap.”
“Do not speak unkindly of the wood,” Gandalf warned. “You never know who may be listening.”
As if in response, a stiff wind rushed past, causing the trees to creak and nod. Bilbo shivered. There was something unsettlingly familiar about the forest—and when Bilbo found familiarity in the unpleasant, it usually meant Sauron’s hands had tainted it.
“Our quest will not be stopped by some wind and wizard’s words,” Thorin said. He took his horse’s bridle and led it into the forest, Orcrist held before him. Dwalin followed, then Gandalf, then the rest of the company. Bilbo glanced west, longing for the Shire’s sun-dappled forests. By now, the Party Tree would have all its leaves, and the apple trees would be heavy with ripening fruit. It was the season for long walks and picnics by chuckling streams. Bilbo did not want to think about what might be in the water here.
The sun vanished soon after they plunged into Mirkwood. The mossy branches twined overhead like fingers, choking all light and air long before it reached the company. Trees and shrubs grew into each other, creating a solid wall that confined them to the game trails wending through the eternal twilight. Without Gandalf’s leadership, Bilbo knew they would have gotten hopelessly lost within hours. The horses walked only where led, their ears back and their heads low, and even the Dwarves—who spent much of their lives in tunnels—were dismayed. Needless to say, Bilbo was as miserable as he had been in Khazad-dûm, but not even the abandoned city had not felt so overtly hostile.
“Do you sense something?” Bofur asked after Bilbo looked over his shoulder for the hundredth time that hour.
“Sickness,” Bilbo said firmly. “This place is sick. But I don’t see anything.”
“Neither do I,” said Bofur. “That’s what’s worry me. Aren’t there supposed to be birds and animals? Haven’t heard so much as a cricket.”
Bofur turned back around, humming quietly, but the unsettling silence gnawed at Bilbo’s patience. The company’s every sound burst across the forest like a thundercrack, advertising their presence to every unfriendly ear for miles in every direction.
On the third night, Bilbo was sitting on the edge of camp, gnawing a strip of venison as he kept watch. They had given up on lighting fires after being accosted by moths and the night was so dark that even Bilbo had trouble seeing. Behind him, the horses stamped uneasily and the company was resting as best they could. Bilbo knew none of them had slept well since entering Mirkwood; their exhaustion weighed on him.
Bilbo’s eyelids were beginning to droop when he heard a song fluttering just below his hearing. He tried to focus, scowling when the melody slipped from his grasp. He stood up. It was his business to guard the company and music amidst an eerily silent forest demanded his attention. Bilbo paused only as he remembered Gandalf’s warning: Mirkwood could turn him around for years, until he forgot about his Dwarves and the quest altogether.
The song grew louder, more insistent. Bilbo dug in his heels. What would the company think if he shirked his duties? Besides, he was as much a Hobbit as a dragon, and that meant he was sensible. Taking off after a pretty tune seemed the exact opposite of rational, even if it was nearby…
Bilbo took a step forward. Yes, it was not far; he could be there and back before anyone noticed he was gone. And he had found the company before: he was drawn to them as a moth to a flame.
He felt Thorin approaching and hastily sat back down, all thought of departure gone, but Thorin passed without speaking.
“Thorin!” Bilbo hissed. “Thorin! Where are you going?”
Thorin turned to him. All light had fled from his eyes. “There is … something I must find.”
“It’s a trick,” Bilbo said, standing. “The forest is playing with us.”
“I must go … my father’s ring … Erebor … the Arkenstone…”
Bilbo shook him. “Thorin! It’s not real.”
Thorin blinked, and the pallor receded from his cheeks. “Bilbo? What is it?”
“The voice,” Bilbo said. “You were going to follow it.”
“What…?” Thorin trailed off and lowered his head. “You can hear it, too?”
“Yes. It’s doing an awful job of convincing me, though,” Bilbo said. “As if I would leave the company for a song.”
“It promises me my father’s ring,” Thorin said. “The Dwarves were given seven rings of power, one for each clan. My father’s was the last, and he vanished with it.” He peered into the forest. “I don’t like that the trees know that.”
“I don’t think it’s the trees,” Bilbo muttered, half to himself. His master had spent many hours gloating about his rings of power, and how they had turned Men to his service and Dwarves to greed.
“It’s a good thing we have you to turn us from these dark paths,” Thorin said, smiling.
Bilbo felt unaccountably flustered. “It’s no great feat. I wouldn’t expect anything different from this company.”
“How odd you are,” Thorin said, “bragging to no end of your gardening but refusing to accept praise for saving me from Mirkwood.” He put a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “We should ensure no one else has—”
“They’re all here,” Bilbo said immediately. He had quite liked how Thorin had said we.
Thorin turned around, his lips moving soundlessly as he counted, sighing when he reached twelve. “So they are. Remember to wake Oin for the watch.”
Bilbo watched Thorin return to his bedroll, then lie awake for the rest of the night. The song played on and on, and neither of them slept.
The voice continued to nag at Bilbo on the following day. He made a game out of how long he could forget about it, as he might ignore a fly bite to avoid scratching, and Thorin seemed tired, but in no danger of wandering off again. If the other Dwarves heard the song, they gave no sign.
Fortunately, the voice tapered off late in the afternoon of the next day as a remarkable change overtook Mirkwood. Just as Bilbo had sensed decay when he had entered, now he felt welcome. The trees were handsome and well-spaced, and fingers of golden light stroked the emerald leaves. Birdsong had returned to the canopy.
“We are close,” Gandalf said. “Do not harm any animal and tread lightly. I expect to receive enough grief for even showing you this house.”
The company eyed the moss and their own heavy boots apprehensively. Bilbo rapidly hopped between piles of leaf litter to temper his tread. He had had no dealings wizards other than Gandalf and he did not wish to learn that this Radagast was the most powerful after he had accidentally crushed a flower.
The company entered a wide glade. It initially seemed empty, but at the far end, built around several beech trees, was a hut woven from sticks and mud daub, and roofed with mossy shingles and bird nests. Although the meadow was clearly wild, Bilbo sensed a greater pattern amidst the flowers nodding gently in the breeze.
“Let your horses loose,” Gandalf said. “They will not wander. I believe Radagast is out. We should wait here for his return.”
Bilbo immediately laid down amidst the milk vetch, watching the bees float between the lavender. He was looking forward to some much-deserved rest.
“Something’s coming,” Kíli warned, and Bilbo jumped up just as an enormous black bear burst from the trees, heading straight for him.
Notes:
Translation
’adad—dad
Khazâd—DwarvesWe'll see you guys (probably) next week B)
Chapter 10: Guts
Summary:
The company finds an unlikely haven in the forbidding Mirkwood.
Notes:
We are slowly but surely getting all of the chapters cleaned up, but we still can't promise regular updates. However! The whole thing is written, we're not gonna leave ya'll hanging.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
The attack was so swift that Bilbo had no time to react. Between one heartbeat and the next, the bear knocked him to the ground and pinned him beneath one huge paw. It leveled its yellowed fangs with Bilbo’s face, washing him in the moist, withering breath of a predator.
Bilbo felt the Dwarves’ heavy footfalls shake the ground as they rushed to his defense. The bear turned and Bilbo squirmed free, then interposed himself between the bear and the company, his skin already half-scaled. The bear was as tall as Dwalin at the shoulder, with a humped back and sickle claws dug into the soft loam. Still, the canopy was just high enough for Bilbo to fly—
“Stop!”
Gandalf’s command rattled the meadow with terrifying force. The bear flinched and stepped back, licking its lips.
Thorin broke the ensuing silence. “Is this our host?” he demanded.
“No,” Gandalf said. “His name is Beorn and he is a skin-changer.”
“Friend or foe?” Dwalin asked.
After a moment’s hesitation, Gandalf said, “Neither.”
Beorn snapped at Bilbo again before transforming into an equally tall and hirsute Man. His glare held the same ferocity as his teeth.
“Since when did Gandalf the Grey keep company with a servant of the Enemy?” Beorn growled.
“Bilbo Baggins is in my company,” Thorin snapped.
Bilbo puffed his fans with unexpected pride.
“If you want to fight him, you’ll have to fight all of us!” Ori exclaimed, and the Dwarves all roared in agreement.
“There will be no fighting in my home!” a quavering voice said. Everyone turned to see a small, bearded Man shuffling towards them, leaning on a gnarled staff. It was difficult to tell where his brown skin ended and his robes began. Nonetheless, there was a tired power to him, the same ragged wisdom that Gandalf carried.
A wizard, Bilbo realized.
“Gandalf? You’re late! And with company—who are they?” The wizard’s nose wrinkled. “You’ve brought Dwarves to my woods. I’m not overly fond of Dwarves.”
“Nor am I,” Beorn rumbled.
“I apologize for the inconvenience, Radagast,” Gandalf said to the smaller wizard, “but my companions are hunted by Azog the Defiler. They require food and shelter if they are to complete their quest.”
“And what quest is that?” Beorn asked.
“No concern of yours,” Thorin said.
“Something that will be instrumental in ours,” Gandalf told Beorn. “Will that suffice?”
The wizard—Radagast—caught sight of Bilbo and paled. “It’s — it’s one of them!” He fell back, eyes crossing in agitation. “Gandalf, it’s a kulkodar!”
Bilbo cringed at the word and Beorn dropped to all fours again, his fur already thickening.
“A friendly one,” Kíli objected.
“Fear not, my friend,” Gandalf told Radagast. “Master Baggins is an entirely agreeable being, whether he is Hobbit or dragon, and I have counted him as my friend for centuries. Look at him, Radagast.”
Radagast’s eyes slid back into focus and he peered at Bilbo with such intensity that Bilbo almost shrank away. “I see you, dragon.”
“And that he means no harm to you or yours, I should hope,” Dwalin said, his voice tinted with impatience.
“Yes, I…” Radagast’s vision clouded over again. “He may stay.”
“I trust your judgment, old friend,” Beorn said, “but even you can be deceived.”
“Peace, Beorn,” Gandalf said. “I’m sure you and Bilbo will get along splendidly, once you’ve worked out your differences.”
Beorn crossed his arms.
“Radagast, I think your guests are hungry,” Gandalf prompted.
“Oh, yes,” Radagast said. He clapped his hands together and whistled like a bird. The forest rustled vigorously for several minutes, and then the procession began. Robins and tits darted from the canopy, bearing green shoots and insects in their beaks, joined by squirrels and finches carrying the previous harvest’s nuts. The grass flooded with mice pinching sheaves of wild grains between their teeth. A badger trotted by with a honeycomb still trailing bees. Moles carrying mushrooms followed beavers with aquatic tubers, and, finally, a herd of white deer picked their way from the dappled shade, bearing dewy red fruits.
The animals deposited their offerings on the slab of rock in the center of the meadow, where hedgehogs rearranged the vegetation into a rather attractive design. Then, just as soon as they had appeared, the animals vanished; the sparrows alone remained to forage beside the grazing horses.
Bilbo was careful to keep Beorn in his periphery as he scrutinized the food. He recognized maybe half of it and he was leery about sampling anything from Mirkwood. The Dwarves exhibited no such restraint as they dove for the fungi. Bilbo watched them eat, then heeded the exhortations of his rumbling stomach and popped a raspberry in his mouth. The berry burst between his molars like a firecracker, exploding in a starry confection of tart and sweet. Unable to stop himself, he poured a handful down his throat, then palmed the rest and consumed them in contemplative silence like a pipe he was trying to ration.
The company had plopped down around the rock, helping themselves to anything familiar that could be eaten raw and regarding the rest with suspicion. The wizards and Beorn took their own council a fair distance away. For once, Bilbo was not offended at the exclusion.
“We should make a sign for Bilbo,” Fíli suggested. “Nice dragon.”
“Would save us a lot of time,” Bofur said, “since everyone seems to know who he is.”
“Nearly as bad as Thorin,” Glóin said.
“We could try blessing him,” Oin suggested. “Mahal has forgiven many Dwarves for sins worse than his.”
Bilbo sighed. “I am truly sorry for all the fuss.”
“I’ll take the cost of your being a dragon out of your fourteenth share,” Balin said, nodding. Bilbo was unsure if he was serious.
“How far are we from Erebor?” Kíli asked.
Balin pondered this as he nibbled on a morel. “I cannot tell our position in this forest, but I think about a month’s travel should bring us to Esgaroth.”
“A month,” Ori echoed, his gaze fixed on some faraway point.
Privately, Bilbo thought they could scarcely walk for another minute. Their beards and hair were tangled with twigs and moss, and their clothes were deplorable. Yet at the mention of Erebor, their postures straightened and a fire kindled within them, and Bilbo knew they would drag themselves home on bloody hands and knees if needed. It touched him so deeply that he had to look away.
“I say we eat and leave,” Dwalin said. “I don’t trust this skin-changer or the wizard.”
“It’s not natural,” Dori agreed.
“I reckon we’d last about … oh, five minutes alone in Mirkwood before something found us.” Bofur spat out a sunflower husk. “And it wouldn’t be a wizard. Might even be an Elf.”
Bifur spoke and Bofur translated, “He says he’ll go if Radagast intends for us to live on vegetables.”
“Seconded,” Kíli muttered, poking at a blueberry with one of his arrows.
“Wizards may be mysterious and unreliable, but at the end of the day, they’re good folk,” Fíli argued. “A few days of fruit are worth Radagast’s protection.”
“Fíli is right,” Thorin said, putting a hand on his proud heir’s shoulder. “Mirkwood is no place to wander friendless.”
“How many more must know of our quest?” Balin leaned in and the company crowded closer. “Trusting Gandalf was enough of a gamble. This Radagast seems even less reputable and we know nothing of Beorn.”
“The wizards and their companion have business of their own,” Thorin said. “I suspect that their necromancer issue will keep them from prying into ours.”
Bilbo wiggled free of the Dwarves to ensure no one had eavesdropped. The wizards were on the other side of the meadow, and Beorn had left them to their wizarding business in favor of brushing down Nori’s horse. Bilbo was certain Beorn could have heard a mouse sneeze in Pelargir, but the skin-changer was at least polite enough to pretend the horse occupied all of his attention.
Then, Bilbo heard a loud rustling from the forest. Under the cacophony of snapping branches and torn leaves was something even more insidious: the anticipatory hiss of a voracious predator.
“Dwarves,” they cried in the Black Speech. “Feast!”
“Something’s coming!” Bilbo shouted as he stripped down. He transformed the moment he was free, shivering as skin became scales and teeth became fangs.
The meadow boiled with activity as creatures of all shapes and sizes fled the forest for the safety of Radagast’s hut. A cloud of birds and bats filled the air, and Bilbo took care not to squash the multitude of dormice, hedgehogs, ermine, rabbits, and moles passing underfoot.
“Steady!” shouted Dwalin, and Bilbo felt the Dwarves closing ranks around him. He hummed in satisfaction, crouching low as he prepared to leap at anything that came through the trees.
The first spiders to approach Bilbo were cooked so swiftly that they died before their legs curled. The spiders in the second wave scarcely shied before redoubling their assault. Bilbo lashed out with tooth and claw, darting into the sun when he could to regain heat.
There were twenty or thirty spiders: counting was impossible with the speed at which they scuttled. Beorn tore into them with unmatched ferocity, often killing them with one swipe of his mighty claws. The spiders swarmed him briefly, but Gandalf and Glamdring came to his rescue, while Radagast beat them away from his hut with his staff.
The Dwarves were barely tall enough to look a spider in the eye. They hacked at limbs and heads, ducking under their abdomens to stab their softer underbellies. They were vocal fighters, often shouting warnings or insults, or curses when something went awry. Thorin alone did not participate in the company’s games. He sliced through the spiders with grim precision, until Orcrist was black with their foul blood. Bilbo sensed nothing from him—no joy, no relief, not even concern.
Bilbo knew each of the injuries the company sustained with unsettling detail. Fíli received a bite to the leg that Bilbo felt so viscerally he had to check to see if he had received a bite of his own. Nori twisted his ankle and Bilbo was afraid, for a moment, to put weight on his own. But the Dwarves’ banter reassured him that their wounds were minor, and Bilbo kept fighting.
Before long, the clearing was strewn with twitching spider carcasses. From what Bilbo could feel, none of the company was seriously injured. Fíli’s leg would heal and Nori’s method of “walking it off, thank you, Dori” seemed to be working.
At Gandalf’s behest, the Dwarves hauled the spiders’ bodies into the woods. Bifur wanted to burn them, and he and Radagast—with an exasperated Ori translating—were in the midst of a heated argument as to why that was not a smart idea.
Bilbo helped the Dwarves clear out the closest section of the meadow, then bounded over to where Thorin and Gandalf were examining another pile of spiders.
“You have a strange notion of sanctuary,” Thorin told Gandalf. “First our host insults a member of my company. Then we fight off dozens of Bubnudush’s spawn. What should we expect next?”
Gandalf poked the corpse with his staff, his craggy brow knit with concern. “I have never known Mirkwood’s spiders to be so bold. Trust me, Thorin, I did not foresee this.”
“Is it this Necromancer?”
“Perhaps,” Gandalf said, “but that is a task for Beorn, Radagast, and myself. Erebor is enough of a challenge for the company.”
“I was not offering,” Thorin said coldly. “Our errand is more important than putting down a gimcrack conjurer.”
“While I agree in pure fact, I would welcome a little more understanding from you, Thorin Oakenshield!” Gandalf snapped. “The spiders’ presence, Azog’s return, the Necromancer’s rise—it’s all connected. Evil is waking in the North!”
“Evil has roosted in the North for centuries,” Thorin said, unrepentant. “It’s past time you started to care.”
A great hand landed on Bilbo’s shoulder and he nearly leapt out of his skin.
“You did well,” Beorn rumbled from behind him.
Bilbo stepped away from the larger skin-changer and turned into a Hobbit, reluctantly abandoning Gandalf and Thorin’s escalating argument. “Well, I’ve defeated wights, watchers, and even a balrog. Spiders are no match for the likes of me.”
“What about a skin-changer?”
“Sorry, what?”
“We should spar, you and I,” Beorn said. “Even skilled warriors need practice.”
Bilbo’s desire for redemption won out over self-preservation. “I believe I shall take you up on that.”
Beorn nodded. “Good. You’re a fierce creature to behold, little ferret.”
Bilbo accepted the praise bitterly. “Ferrets don’t fly. And if they did, I doubt they would look as splendid.”
“I will take your word on that,” Beorn said. “Come. We must help Radagast.”
Bilbo turned back into a dragon and was in the midst of dragging an especially juicy spider when fatigue overcame him at last. He sagged to the ground, tearing off a leg to gnaw as he regained his strength.
“You look happy,” Nori said as he passed by.
Bilbo snapped off a joint and nodded towards where the rest of the company had gathered around the spider corpses, laughing at some previous joke. Ori chose that moment to belch thunderously, causing Fíli and Kíli to fall over with laughter.
Nori laughed. “I’m afraid we’ve tainted your good taste then, my friend.” He slipped a knife from some concealed pocket and began flipping it deftly. Bilbo watched the blade, admiring Nori’s evident talent.
That’s strange, Bilbo thought. From time to time he’d been impressed with the talent of a particularly adept tailor or baker in the Shire, but never had he taken pride in the skills of another.
Then Dori stormed over, shouting, “What do you think you’re doing? Spit that out! It’s not healthy.”
Bilbo considered Dori for a moment: red-faced from exertion, his hands on his hips, his meticulously braided hair askew. Overwhelmed with affection, Bilbo dropped the spider leg and edged it away with a claw.
“Make yourself useful, brother,” Dori said, dropping the saliva-coated leg into Nori’s arms. Nori rolled his eyes, but put his knife away and brought the leg to the pile all the same.
Bilbo turned into a Hobbit and quested about for his clothes. He found them shoved under a rock, safe—but not safe enough. He gave a great cry at the palm-sized blotch of spider blood on the center of his shirt. A waistcoat would have covered the blemish entirely, but he no longer had a waistcoat. None of his waistcoats in Bag End would fit him, anyway: he had lost too much weight. Perhaps this was a chance to refresh his wardrobe.
He heard Thorin approaching, but he was too engrossed in bemoaning the sartorial consequences of adventure to care.
“You fought well,” Thorin said.
And how could Bilbo have missed Thorin fighting? Laying about with Orcrist, his hair flying and beads flashing in the sun, as sure and grim as a Dwarf lord of legend? One day, he would sit on the throne of Erebor with the same surety and grimness, and all would bow before him as he scripted his own legend. There would be seven Durins. There would be only one Thorin Oakenshield.
Held captive by the vivacity of his own imagination, Bilbo answered late. “As—as did you. You’ve put Orcrist to good use.”
Thorin nodded stiffly. Bilbo had forgotten how poorly he accepted compliments, which only made him eager to pay another.
“Much better use than I ever did,” Bilbo continued. “Orcrist deserves a proper dance with a handsome partner.”
This time, Thorin flushed. “Have Oin take a look at you.”
“Actually, I thought I’d go for a flight.”
“Flying alone is too dangerous,” Thorin said. “Flying over Mirkwood doubly so.”
“I’ve stood up to worse,” Bilbo scoffed. “Besides, I won’t heal properly without it.”
“Stay near the house,” Thorin said. “I suspect worse than the Necromancer dwells here.”
Bilbo offered him a lazy salute. “I’ll be back before nightfall.”
He burst into his dragon shape and leapt into the air. Bilbo broke free of the canopy in four wingbeats. He rose higher and higher, extending his wings to their full length to reciprocate the sun’s embrace. He stopped only when the air grew cold and his breath short. For a moment, he was suspended at the border between earth and the heavens. Then, he tipped back, falling towards Mirkwood once more. The wind rushed up to meet him, whistling in his ears and along his fans until they flared to their full size. He cast out his wings, arresting his descent, and flipped into a steady glide.
For a time, he admired his shadow cast upon the clouds, mesmerized as each wingbeat rolled down his membranes and terminated at his tail. But not even his own considerable majesty could distract him from his Dwarves. Bilbo still felt the bite Fíli had sustained. His ankle still ached where Nori had twisted his ankle. The dull throb of Bifur’s head wound was like a second heartbeat. When in Rohan, he had felt the company’s hangovers as if they were his own, and, even now, he knew all their dispositions and locations. A dragon knew its hoard intimately: every blemish was keenly felt.
Mortals! Bilbo could protect his Dwarves against injury, but not against time. How long did Dwarves live? Two centuries? Three? That may have been a lengthy accounting by the standards of Hobbits or Men, but to Bilbo, it would be faster than drawing a breath. Was the satisfaction and comfort of a hoard worth the inevitable pain?
He neither knew the answer nor had the freedom to seek it. Breaking away from his swords had taken centuries and the love of two very patient Hobbits. Besides, the swords had been unwelcome relics from a time that Bilbo strove to abandon. The company was not lost in the past, but striving towards their future: living, breathing, changing Dwarves more precious to him than any Elvish trinkets.
He immediately sensed the borders of Radagast’s domain: the world seemed to desaturate, and his aches and pains—as well as those of the company—redoubled. Bilbo banked hard over the treetops, snapping and shattering branches in his wake. Overhead, the sun glided behind the Misty Mountains and night overflew the forest on frigid, velvet wings; constellations formed dot by dot. Bilbo suddenly wished to sit inside with a fire and hearty companionship. The thought turned him south, towards his Dwarves. Towards home. Towards Thorin.
In much the same way that one realizes they have left the kettle on, Bilbo realized that he was in love with Thorin. He cupped that feeling as he might a firefly, letting its gentle light play about his hands, then crushed it. A Dwarf prince! A fine object of his affections he’d chosen—not just any Dwarf prince, but one who had been beggared by a firedrake. Thorin might accept Bilbo as a friend, but Bilbo was not foolish enough to think Thorin would ever return his affections.
Troubled as he was, Bilbo’s return flight took longer than he had anticipated. He homed in on the lights of Radagast’s home as much as the company’s pull, circling at long last around the clearing before landing near the horses. The hut’s door flung open and a cluster of Dwarves spilled into the night. When Thorin recognized Bilbo, his hand dropped from Orcrist’s grip and he gave the all-clear. Dori pushed forward, the bundle of Bilbo’s clothes in his arms.
“Do you have any idea how worried we have been?” he said sternly, shoving Bilbo’s clothes at him. “You said you would be back by sunset, yet here you are well after nightfall! And this after ignoring Mister Gandalf’s warnings about flying over this accursed forest.”
Bilbo turned back into a Hobbit to accept his clothes. “I was perfectly safe! I’m bigger than almost anything under these leaves and none of them can breathe fire.”
“Regardless,” Thorin said, “take care not to trouble us in the future.”
“There’s food inside,” Ori said, wrinkling his nose. “All sorts of green things. You might like them.”
“Any break from salted pork and hard bread is most welcome,” Bilbo said. “Does Radagast have a pot? Perhaps I could cook…” His hands twitched giddily at the thought.
“Peach pie!” shouted Kíli.
“Roast capon!” suggested Glóin, and soon all the Dwarves were voicing their favorite dishes—many of which, as Bilbo remembered (since dragons never forgave a slight), had been “served” at their first meeting.
“Hold on,” Bilbo groused, waving them into silence. “Let’s see if wizards keep flour first…”
And he let himself be drawn inside by his hoard, the ugly emotions roiling in his chest momentarily silenced.
Notes:
Khuzdul Translation
Bubnudush—Ungoliant; lit. spider of darknessBlack Speech Translation
Kulkodar—dragonV: LOOK AT THAT! Bilbo has a crush.
Thorin has been SO GAY for Bilbo for SO LONG already. I mean who wouldn't be. Bakes? Kills Balrogs? Find a man that can do both. Also I've been terrible about replying to comments and that's usually my job so I'll be getting on those old-ass comments soon, promise <3
Chapter 11: Journey’s End
Summary:
The final leg of the quest commences.
Notes:
Backstreet’s back, ALRIGHT!
Chapter Text
Bilbo padded silently through the ferns, ears pricked and nostrils flared. The gnarly hazel wood rustled and sang with its usual inhabitants; their ruckus obscured Bilbo’s hearing just as the willow thickets blocked his sight. Bilbo’s heart pounded as he took a tentative step forward, then another. A twig snapped underfoot and Bilbo’s lips peeled back from his fangs: his position had been betrayed.
A branch cracked downwind and Bilbo pounced, his narrow body sluicing through the brambles. Too late, he recognized Oin. Bilbo barked in surprise, twisting away as Oin ducked. Bilbo landed off-kilter, scarcely regaining his feet before a dark, shaggy shape struck his side. Beorn’s momentum carried them downhill, flattening bushes and felling saplings as they wrestled. By the time they reached the bottom, Beorn had Bilbo thoroughly pinned. Bilbo put up a token struggle—Oin was watching and he did not wish to disappoint—before conceding the match by slipping out of his skin.
“Very well, Master Beorn,” Bilbo said, grinning. “I accept that you are the better hunter on the ground alone.”
The bear coughed, which deepened into a hearty chuckle as Beorn assumed his Mannish form. “Your shape works against you, little ferret.”
Bilbo strolled over to the log where he had left his clothes. “Here, maybe, but you would be no match for me in the sky.”
“Then let us be thankful your wings are clipped,” Beorn rumbled.
Bilbo muttered about which parts he would clip off Beorn as he stepped into his pants.
“Done laying into each other?” Oin called from the top of the hill.
“It is perfectly safe,” Beorn said. “You were in no danger.”
“Oh, I know,” Oin said. “Just want to know if a Dwarf can take a leak in peace, is all.”
“We will halt, for a time,” Beorn said. “I hear Bilbo’s stomach growling.”
“This is the first time I’ve had full meals since Hobbiton,” Bilbo said. He patted his shrunken belly. “It will be a cold winter indeed without my usual padding.”
Today, though, the sky was blue, the sun shone, and Bilbo knew the exact location of his lunch. Radagast’s animal helpers kept the meadow stone stocked with fruits, nuts, tubers, and roots. The Dwarves decried this spread as “rabbit food”, but never strayed far from its largesse. Bilbo inhaled two acorn griddlecakes and a stack of honey walnut cookies—Bombur’s best efforts given his restrictive pantry—then scooped up a handful of strawberries and perched on a rock, drinking in the sight of his hoard. Most dozed in the grass with the horses or occupied themselves with small tasks. Bombur was making a mushroom stew. Ori sketched a family of sociable hedgehogs. Fíli and Kíli were sitting bareback on Fíli’s golden horse, flicking knives at arbitrary targets as the horse grazed.
Then Bilbo saw Thorin marching over and the warmth in his chest fanned into a pleasant flame.
“This is twice now that Beorn has bested you, Master Dragon,” Thorin said.
“I didn’t change my skin the first time. It doesn’t count.” Their arrival at Radagast’s house was still a sore topic.
“Fierce in a pinch—is that not what Gandalf said?”
“I’m holding back,” Bilbo sniffed. “It would be poor manners to charbroil our ally.”
“Worse manners than tarnishing my company’s reputation?”
“I fought a balrog, thank you v—” Bilbo’s eyes narrowed. “You’re teasing me.”
Thorin’s eyes glittered with mischief. “Never, O Ironfang, O Gemscale.”
The epithets, disingenuous though they may have been, went straight to his head. “Truly, O Raven Prince, what chance does a bear have against a dragon?” Bilbo answered for him. “None. Absolutely none.”
“And what of a company of thirteen Dwarves?” Thorin asked, tilting his head towards a patch of trampled grass.
In addition to their usual tasks, the Dwarves had been drilling with Dwalin every day. Bilbo—who had been eagerly awaiting these summons—chose to allay Thorin’s fear instead of indulging his own ego. “Normally, I would eat thirteen Dwarves like finger sandwiches and wash them down with viola tea.” He slid off his rock and straightened his trousers. “But this company might stand a chance.”
“Do not show us mercy,” Thorin warned. “Smaug certainly won’t.”
Bilbo could not have harmed his hoard more than he could have snuffed out the sun, but he stridently trumpeted his ferocity as Dwalin secured the horses and rallied the insultingly eager company. Bilbo retaliated by waiting to strip until all thirteen Dwarves had assembled in front of him.
“Was that necessary?” Dwalin said, shielding Fíli and Kíli’s eyes.
“I put,” Bilbo huffed, “a century into developing a body this perfect—the very pinnacle of beauty. Why, I know of ten respectable gentlehobbits at this very moment who would scratch your eyes out for beholding—”
“I think your form is rather splendid, Master Baggins,” Dori said, to Bilbo’s delight, then added, “for your kind. It has much to be desired, to a Dwarf’s discerning eye.”
“You’re missing most of your hair,” Glóin said.
Bombur nodded, patting his own magnificent beard.
“Practically bald,” Oin agreed.
“Flabby arms,” Dwalin grunted.
“And you’re quite a—” Bofur’s gaze darted down “—small fellow, aren’t you?”
Bilbo’s mood blackened as they critiqued his sparse eyebrows and big ears and frangible fingers until he turned into a dragon, rose to his full height, and flared his crest. The Dwarves were distressingly unaffected by this display, but left off abusing him to absorb Balin’s substantial knowledge of dragon weaknesses. Balin pointed to Bilbo as he spoke, who lifted legs or wings on cue with long-suffering patience.
The Dwarves circled for their final war council and Bilbo crouched, tail twitching in anticipation. After minutes of muttering in Khuzdul, the Dwarves broke their huddle and split into two groups: one charged Bilbo from the front while the other circled around him. Bilbo had dealt with these tenderfoot tactics at the Black Gate. He reared on his hind legs, stopping the attackers in their tracks, then swept the ambushers off their feet with his tail. Fíli alone jumped over Bilbo’s fans and clambered onto his back, his boots rattling Bilbo’s spine. Bilbo ripped Dori’s habergeon from his hands and snapped out a wing to redirect Dwalin’s charge, then folded his crest and rolled, crushing Fíli beneath him. Thorin darted forward, but Bilbo seized Thorin’s coat in his teeth and tossed him into Oin. Then, Bilbo kicked Dori in the stomach and leapt into the air. The downdraft felled Nori and Ori; Balin and Glóin stabbed their weapons into the ground as anchors.
A blunted arrow struck Bilbo under the cheek. He snarled and folded his wings, and pounced on Kíli. Bombur, Dwalin, and Dori struck like charging rams, flipping Bilbo onto his belly. Bifur planted himself atop Bilbo’s chest, the tip of his spear poking Bilbo’s throat. Bilbo bared his teeth, but obediently “died” as the company congratulated their first dragonslayer.
Fíli walked up to Bilbo and stuck out his hand. Bilbo extended a single claw and let Fíli hold it as Bilbo pushed himself upright.
“You’re a challenge to fight,” Fíli admitted.
Bilbo extricated his claw from Fíli’s grasp and purred in acknowledgement.
Fíli hesitated, then asked, “Did you learn all of this … in Mordor?”
Bilbo nodded.
“And then you forgot it all to be a gardener.”
His crests rose in mortal offense.
“No, no, Mister Baggins,” Fíli said. “I meant…” He glanced around guiltily. “You were made to fight. And you chose a different path.”
Bilbo cocked his head, then rubbed his cheek against Fíli’s in silent understanding.
“Fíli, come here,” Dwalin said. “We’ve got to discuss your situational awareness.”
Fíli punched Bilbo’s wing in parting. “My situational awareness? Bilbo got you twice. Your eyesight’s going, Mister Dwalin!”
“That’s enough disrespect from you, laddie,” Dwalin growled, cuffing Fíli affectionately. “And you—” This was to Bilbo “—put your back into it.”
Bilbo snorted a disdainful jet of steam and rolled onto the grass, basking as the Dwarves reviewed strategy. The next time his Dwarves struck, they approached in a single formation. Bilbo hit them with a wave of heat—just enough to curl their beards—to demonstrate they would have died if Bilbo had been attacking in earnest. On and on it went, until the sun dipped below the trees, Bilbo’s scales were cold, and the Dwarves were shiny with sweat. When they broke for the last time, Beorn and Gandalf clapped from the sidelines. Radagast and several hedgehogs joined in.
Radagast was an eccentric but accommodating host. Bilbo liked him because he congratulated Bilbo at least twice a day for winning free of Sauron. Thorin liked him because he never meddled in the company’s affairs, although Bilbo suspected Beorn and Gandalf had already told Radagast everything. The three Big Folk had taken to conspiring in Radagast’s hut long into the night. Neither Thorin nor Balin—nor Nori, who had tried to eavesdrop on the wizards and spent the next day with morels for ears—knew more than that Gandalf planned to remain in Mirkwood to deal with the Necromancer.
Their leave-taking came fifteen days after their arrival. The Dwarves rose early, as always, and by unseen accord, began to prepare for a long ride. The fiery Riddermark horses pranced and snorted, vexing their riders until Radagast shuffled over to whisper in their ears. The horses nodded solemnly, then stood for the company to mount.
“Good fortune to you all,” Radagast said to no one in particular, his reedy voice carrying across the glade. “I will hear of your success from the beaks of ravens and thrushes.”
Balin and Glóin exchanged a look, then inclined their heads deeply to the wizard. Radagast returned to the woods without a backwards glance. Bilbo was sorry to see him go: he had liked Radagast, especially since his simple nature meant Gandalf could no longer claim reticence was a wizard’s prerogative.
Gandalf and Beorn stowed their pipes and descended from Radagast’s porch for their own goodbyes.
“Remember,” Gandalf said, “do not enter Erebor without me. I will await your coming on the Overlook outside of Dale.”
The Dwarves grumbled and rolled their eyes.
Gandalf glared at them. “Bilbo may be swift and strong—” Bilbo preened “—but he is no match for a firedrake. Despite your wagging tongues, you were lucky to escape the balrog alive. Smaug will be just as difficult, if not more. His cunning and malice are rivaled perhaps only by the Enemy.” Gandalf met Bilbo’s eye. Take care of them, Bilbo. I fear their desire to return home will cloud their judgment.
That’s why you hauled me from my comfortable retirement, isn’t it? Bilbo asked wryly.
Gandalf chuckled and turned to the company. “We will meet again. May the Valar watch over your travels.”
Bilbo turned to Beorn and grimaced in embarrassment, his hands shoved in his pockets. “You know, we never fought a fair fight.”
Beorn’s laughter was felt rather than heard. “Little ferret, there is no need to say goodbye yet. Many foul things creep under the trees and you will need a guide.”
“We can handle Thranduil’s folk.”
“I do not speak of Elves,” Beorn said. “There are things older than them, and far crueler. I doubt they would challenge you, but I cannot guarantee the company’s safety.”
Bilbo’s skin tautened: the Dwarves were his to protect. The moment passed quickly and Bilbo smiled up at Beorn, happy to have more eyes in the accursed forest. “I’d be delighted.”
“Then let us be off!” Thorin said, who had apparently been listening. “Summer is flowing through our hands.”
Mirkwood’s eastern border was significantly more pleasant than the west. Bilbo heard no eerie songs, nor did he feel as though they were being stalked. If not for the occasional unearthly screech, he would have thought himself in the forests of Buckland. For all their love of caves, the Dwarves carped about the shadowy path and overhanging trees whenever they thought Beorn was out of earshot. The moment they saw the forest’s edge, they set their heels to their horses and galloped forward. Their ebullience threatened to speed Bilbo’s steps, too, but he stayed with Beorn and followed at a more sedate pace.
The maple canopy rose like a portcullis and Bilbo inhaled as he had not in many days, filling his lungs with hot, gritty air. He squinted until his eyes remembered the sky, then stared out at the leagues guarding the last stretch of their journey. The land was brown and flat in all directions save the one they had come from. The sun blazed overhead and heat rose from the cracked earth in shimmering waves. There was no shelter; the only plants were head-high bristles of grass.
“Do not camp in one place for more than a day,” Beorn said, shielding his eyes. “You will run out of forage otherwise.”
“Where’s the water?” Bilbo asked.
“I have never traveled this way before,” Beorn said. “I suspect you will need to search from the sky.”
“The Men who live here have hidden wells,” Thorin said, reining his horse alongside Bilbo. “We will be safe until we reach the River Running.”
“It is here that I leave you,” Beorn said, inclining his great head. “Radagast’s friends tracked Azog to Mirkwood. He will be at least a week behind you.”
“Is there no way to kill him?” Glóin asked gloomily.
“Be wary if you should meet him again,” Beorn warned. “He went into the old fortress, Dol Guldur; nothing good issues from there.”
The company bid farewell to the skin-changer. Bilbo received a bone-crushing hug. He would have reciprocated if his Hobbit arms were long enough to encircle Beorn’s hips.
“It is good that neither of us is alone anymore,” Beorn told him. “To be the last is … painful.”
Bilbo shivered, thinking of the Dwarves’ mortality. “Oh, yes. Well, I was glad to have a sparring partner my own size.” He pointed at Beorn. “Don’t go thinking you deserved to win every time.”
“We should have a rematch,” Beorn said. “My home is on the western edge of Mirkwood, where there are few trees. I would be honored to host a dragon—and to fight him on fair ground.”
“Master Baggins!” Thorin called. “We must be going.”
His summons hooked Bilbo’s very soul, but Bilbo lingered a moment beside Beorn to say, “I’ll visit. I promise.”
The cloudless sky and empty plain blended into a dull week. As Bilbo and Kíli soared, the rest of the company crawled along like snails, with no landmarks to aim for and no hoofprints to mark their progress. The horses were miserable. Bilbo had expected the same from the Dwarves, then was astonished as they laughed off thirst, saddle sores, and the omnipresent heat as mere trials of the quest.
Perhaps Bilbo was a jealous wyrm, but Erebor’s allure lessened with each paeon. Nothing wholesome could have such a grip on his hoard. Regardless, their joy was his, and he scarcely had to feign interest when he was regaled with yet another story of King Bladorthin’s thrice-forged spears or the tenth pillar in the ninth hall.
As the days inched by, the sandy wastes blossomed into wildflower-choked meadows bordered by copses of aspen and alder. A fortnight out from Radagast’s house, they reached the Celduin: a swift, narrow river rattling over a pebbly course. After Bilbo failed to locate a ford, he and Kíli transported everyone’s packs—and Dwalin—across the river, then spent a lazy hour picking blueberries as the others swam their panicking horses.
Their break was short-lived: there were horses to hobble, fires to light, and food to cook. Bilbo dried his Dwarves with his breath, then ignited Bombur’s coals and assisted him with dinner. A generous helping of moorcock stew—courtesy of Kíli’s bow—heartened even the grumpiest Dwarves. As night fell, as always, their talk turned to the mountain.
“So how are we planning to enter Erebor?” Fíli asked.
“The front gate is blocked,” Dwalin said. “Smaug destroyed it when he invaded. We’ll have to look for another way.”
“What about the key that Gandalf gave you?” Bilbo asked Thorin.
“Dwarf doors are invisible when closed,” Thorin said, “and, unless we know the keyhole’s location, impossible to open. We will clear a hole in the gate large enough for you to slip through and steal the Arkenstone.”
A collective shiver rippled around the Dwarves sitting shoulder-to-shoulder around the campfire.
“What is it, exactly?” Bilbo asked. “The Arkenstone.”
“A great, white gem found early in Thrór’s reign,” Balin said. “Proof that Mahal favored his right to rule.” He leaned back, his eyes misty. “Although it has been centuries, I will never forget the sight of it. It’s called the King’s Jewel for a reason: you will know it when you see it.”
“The Arkenstone!” Thorin murmured, almost to himself. “It shines like silver in the firelight, like water in the sun, like snow under the stars, like rain upon the Moon.”
Bilbo was so enthralled by Thorin’s poetry that he nearly forgot his chief concern. “And … and what about Smaug?”
Kíli wiggled an arrow freshly fletched with Gwaihir’s feathers. “His armor might be tougher than steel, but not his eye.”
Fíli added, “A javelin through the skull will kill him just as well as a black arrow.”
“Well,” Bilbo pressed, “what does he look like?”
Balin, Dwalin, and Thorin exchanged an uneasy look.
“Truth be told,” Balin said, “we, ah … well, no one who got a good look at him lived to tell the tale. Between the smoke, the fire, and the haze of memory, none of us can tell you much other than that he is extremely large, he can fly, and his flames can kill a Dwarf.”
Smaug’s breath must have been hot indeed: the Dwarves tended campfires barehanded and Thorin had survived a balrog.
“Is Smaug larger than me?” Bilbo asked.
“I ... would say so,” Balin hedged. “He filled the entirety of the treasure room. That was the last place I saw him, rolling in the riches of our forebears.”
Thorin looked away. A loon cried mournfully in the distance.
“Ah, the treasure,” Nori said. “One-fourteenth share to do with as I please.”
“Squander it, most likely,” Dwalin muttered.
“He’ll have a respectable occupation,” Dori said, patting Nori’s back, “especially after I start my weaving business.”
Nori scowled. “My fingers are quick around pockets, not on the loom.”
“If Ori’s not going to help, I expect you to pitch in,” Dori said.
“Where’s Ori going off to?” Kíli asked, alarmed.
“Two hundred years of mice will have ruined the library,” Ori said. “Someone needs to restore it.” He glanced at Thorin. “If that’s a priority.”
“I would not have that knowledge lost,” Thorin said magnanimously.
“You’re too young to be down there, inhaling naught but dust,” Dori said. “I expect you to be at my shop for at least half the day.”
“Time wasted!” Ori complained.
“My kin and I, for one, are starting a toy shop,” Bofur said. “Erebor used to be known for them, and I’ve done my time in the mines.”
Bifur nodded without looking up from his latest project. Bilbo caught a glimpse of a long body before Bifur shifted it from view.
“And Bombur has twelve children and a wife to feed, so I doubt the gold will last him long,” Bofur added.
Bombur ducked his head as the rest of the company resoundingly toasted his success, fecundity, and happiness.
“Your Gimli could join the royal guards,” Oin said, elbowing his brother. “That would be a fitting position for a Dwarf of their skill.”
“Maybe in a few years,” Glóin said. “They’re just a wee thing.”
“Aye, but they’re already apprenticed in the Iron Hills!” Oin exclaimed. “Adventure runs in that dwarfling’s veins as sure as gold runs in yours!”
“I’d keep an eye on the lad,” Dwalin offered, clapping Glóin on the back.
“That’s what I’m worried about!” Glóin exclaimed.
“And we—” Kíli leapt to his feet, an arrow held aloft “—will be princes!”
“And all of you will bow to us,” Fíli said. He then demonstrated exactly how low he expected everyone to genuflect.
“I changed your nappies,” Dwalin growled. “You’re not getting any Your Highnesses from me.”
“Not from you, Mister Dwalin,” Fíli said, “but the rest of our subjects—”
He was drowned out in a wave of friendly insults. Bifur punched Fíli’s thigh and the would-be prince collapsed into the dirt, laughing with the rest of the company.
“I don’t expect any of you to stand on ceremony,” Thorin said suddenly. “Among all my kin, you were the only ones brave—”
“Or foolish,” Bofur said.
“Or foolish,” Thorin acknowledged, “enough to join me. For that, we will be friends. I hope you will continue speaking as freely around me as you had during the quest.”
Bilbo had felt this whole conversation was an exercise in counting one’s chickens, but Thorin spoke with such gravity and affection that it was as if Smaug was already dead and their troubles were far behind them.
Shortly thereafter, it began to rain and the company turned in. Bilbo and Thorin drew first watch and sat beside the dying fire, facing opposite directions. The trees protected them from the drizzle, but the coals sizzled occasionally as drops found their way in.
“You said nothing of your plans after Erebor, Master Baggins,” Thorin said quietly. “Do you plan to return to the Shire?”
“I’m, uh, going traveling,” Bilbo said, waving his hand. He had purposely not been thinking about the end of the quest: the Dwarves would be disgusted if they knew about his new hoard. “Haven’t been anywhere other than the Shire and Mordor, you know. There’s a whole world out there.”
Thorin did not speak for a moment. “Should you go east, I will send word to the clans there. Anyone with the esteem of Erebor’s king will be waited on hand and foot.”
“As a dragon should be,” Bilbo declared, knowing Thorin would recognize the jest. “I appreciate it, Thorin.”
“It is the least I could do.” He chuckled. “I would not have believed even my own sister if she told me that I would welcome a dragon’s companionship.”
“And if someone had told me three months ago that my dearest friends would be Dwarves, I’d have laughed and slammed my door in their face.” Bilbo shrugged, feigning nonchalance. “I wouldn’t trade anything for having gone on this quest—and any quest that makes a dragon forsake his lair is an urgent and noble quest indeed.”
The rain intensified and Bilbo and Thorin donned their hoods. Bilbo could not see Thorin’s face when he said, “I thought your purpose for joining us was your fourteenth share. That will be difficult to carry.”
“Well,” Bilbo spluttered, buying time to fabricate a lie, “I won’t ask you to trade one dragon for another. The hoard can wait.”
“You said your hoard was more important than life itself.”
“There are other things I value now.”
“We could guard your share for you,” Thorin said, “at Erebor.”
“Really, Thorin,” Bilbo scolded, “if you want me to stay, you should just ask.”
The silence stretched uncomfortably, broken only by the pattering rain and Bilbo’s accelerating heartbeat.
“Is … is that what you’re asking?” Bilbo asked, his throat tight. He was grateful Thorin could not see the tenuous hope in his expression.
“You are free to do as you wish,” Thorin said. “But—” Bilbo’s heart leapt “—should you wish, you will always have a place in my kingdom.”
Bilbo could not continue their conversation: it was too tender a topic. “I suppose a Dwarf mountain is just one big Hobbit burrow. It wouldn’t be so hairy of a transition.”
“The halls of my grandfather are not to be compared to a hole,” Thorin scoffed, breaking the strange spell lying over them both.
That was close, Bilbo thought. No more noble declarations of sentiment, you silly worm! You are far too old for flights of fancy.
“That hole has been there longer than Erebor,” Bilbo said. “When was Erebor dug? Nine hundred years ago?”
“Nine hundred fifty,” Thorin said.
“Ha!” Bilbo said. “I saw Bag End dug nearly two thousand years ago.”
They spent the rest of their watch quibbling, Thorin blissfully ignorant of how close he had struck to Bilbo’s heart.
Chapter 12: Diplomacy
Summary:
The Elvenking waylays old enemies—some known, some not—passing through his lands.
Chapter Text
The departing rain graced them with a welcome chill. Bilbo stayed on the ground with the company, humming a walking song as the mud squished pleasantly between his toes. The alder-bordered meadows from the day before had expanded into a proper forest. Willow and birch marched along the brooks, and much of the riverside path was shaded by old pines. The Dwarves were in high spirits: they had settled onto their favorite topic—memories of Erebor—to which Bilbo listened with half an ear, the other being bent to Dori and Balin, who were explaining Khuzdul cases.
Now and then—well, often—Bilbo selfishly nurtured his own dreams of Erebor, but ripped them out by the roots before they could blossom. The company still had far to go and, anyway, he could not possibly cart all of Belladonna’s crockery across the Misty Mountains; a single chipped plate would shatter his peace for good and all.
Kíli prevailed upon Bilbo for an afternoon flight. As usual, they saw only the few Men eking out an existence in the wilderness. When they returned to the company, Bilbo passed low enough to spook the horses and for Kíli to lean down and smack Dwalin’s head. As Dwalin’s outrage faded into the distance, they turned north to scout ahead. Bilbo traced the Celduin’s shining course until the river and the trees dwindled, giving way to maroon sedge. Round tarns glowed on the heath like spilt sapphires.
Bilbo dipped into a shallow dive. Starling-thick herds of reindeer fled before his shadow, but his eye was not on them today: he skimmed his jaw over the Celduin’s surface for a drink.
“Watch this!” Kíli said, and slid off Bilbo’s back, his arms wrapped around Bilbo’s neck. Bilbo stalled, but Kíli said, “Go lower!” and Bilbo obeyed. Kíli pretended to walk along the water’s surface, his boots kicking up huge sprays that doused Bilbo’s chest. Damselflies and swifts scattered in their wake, their wings glittering in the sun, and a startled moose lifted his velvety head from the reeds. Ahead, the river frothed with rapids. Bilbo propped his foreleg under Kíli’s boots and pushed the Dwarf onto his back as he ascended.
“We have to do that again!” Kíli exclaimed. “I’ll learn how to shoot my bow at the same time!”
Bilbo raised his crest in amusement and a purr rumbled his ribs.
“Have some faith!” Kíli said. His weight shifted. “Look! To the north!”
There, on the horizon, a single, snow-topped mountain sliced the sky like a crooked knife. The forests ringing its feet were mere smudges, the lake at its feet little more than a puddle. Even Mount Doom’s most savage eruption would scarcely have melted Erebor’s ice, but Bilbo would not be cowed. He bared his fangs. So this was his rival!
“That’s Erebor!” Kíli said. “Has to be!” He laughed. “Look, Mister Baggins! We’re almost home!”
Home. The Dwarves’ home, certainly; Bilbo’s only in his dreams. Chastened, his lips slid back over his teeth.
“Turn around! We’ve got to tell Uncle!”
Bilbo caught a thermal and banked south, but a shard of alarm raised his hackles. Bilbo swerved west, nearly jostling Kíli from his back.
“What is it?” Kíli cried, but Bilbo could only snarl. Whosoever dared to frighten his hoard would pay tenfold in blood. He redoubled his speed, battling the headwind. The company’s fear was fading into hatred. Had they been captured? By whom?
He dove through the canopy, heedless of the branches.
“Wait!” Kíli said, pulling on his fans. “Slow down!”
Bilbo’s plunge was suddenly arrested. Vines and boughs had knotted around his wings and legs, immobilizing him far above the forest floor. He could not transform into a Hobbit: the drop would break his legs.
“Stop moving!” Kíli hissed. “You’ll throw us both!”
Bilbo reluctantly stilled. He felt Kíli walk down his back, then begin sawing through the plants. The sound of his knife was quickly swamped by the clamor of a dozen arguing Dwarves.
“—east bank of the River Running is beyond your borders,” Balin was saying. “Let us pass in peace. We wish no harm to you or your king.”
“The entire Greenwood is my king’s demesne,” an Elf replied. “You are trespassing, Dwarf.”
The rowan branch encircling Bilbo’s head sprang back, giving Bilbo a view of his hoard. The company had been forced to dismount; Bilbo saw only Balin, Fíli, and Oin between the foliage and swishing tails. Fíli and Oin held their weapons at their sides. Balin’s hands were spread in supplication towards the redheaded Elf facing him. She had an arrow trained on Balin’s chest. If not for the vines, Bilbo would have torn her limb from limb.
“We are merely passing through to visit our kin in the Iron Hills,” Balin said, with a glance over his shoulder, where Thorin no doubt lurked.
“You are far from the Forest Road,” another Elf remarked, this one blond and vaguely familiar, “and your tracks indicate you are heading north.”
“Well, this country was just so pleasant,” Balin said, faltering a little. “With the … the trees.”
“Do not dissemble before the king,” said a new speaker, his voice sliding like oil over the rustling leaves. “I know your names and your quest, Thorin, son of Thráin, Exile Under the Mountain.”
Bilbo would know that voice anywhere. He next wanted to hear its owner gurgling his own blood. The leaves near his snout browned and curled from the heat of his rage.
“You may have but one eye, Thranduil,” Thorin snarled, “but it works well.”
“Exile has not improved your manners,” Thranduil said. “Such is the fate of those who linger in the world of Men.”
“Allow us to pass freely through your lands,” Balin said. “We wish only to continue north.”
“To return home?” Thranduil sneered.
“To the Iron Hills.”
“Come now, you need not lie,” Thranduil said. “You seek to slay the dragon lying upon the bones of your kin and the gold of your crown, and reclaim that which belongs to you.”
“What I seek is not your business,” said Thorin. Bilbo imagined him, fists clenched, drawn to his full size.
“Oh, it is,” said Thranduil. “All of the North shared in the wealth of the mountain. I would have those days return.”
His tone suggested that his assistance would not come cheaply. Bilbo gathered himself for the short and murderous glide to Thranduil’s unseen position.
“Almost through,” Kíli whispered. “Almost—”
A branch snapped and Bilbo fell, Kíli with him. Bilbo turned into a Hobbit, grasping anything in reach. Leaves slipped through his fingers as the ground rushed up with terrifying speed. Suddenly, he jerked to a halt. Kíli had seized his wrist in one hand and grabbed a branch in the other; Bilbo felt Kíli’s shoulders screaming under the weight.
“What was that?” an Elf asked.
“Quite a few moose in these woods, aren’t there?” Balin asked.
“Feren,” Thranduil said. “Find this … moose.”
“I’ll swing you over,” Kíli whispered. “Then you free the company.”
Bilbo twisted back to the clearing. Through immense force of will, he said, “This situation does not call for a Dragon of Sauron. I must be Mr. Bilbo Baggins of Bag End. If the Elvenking wants to talk to someone with manners, then ha! He doesn’t know by what name he conjures!”
Kíli goggled at him.
Bilbo glanced queasily at the ground. “Now, Kíli, how might we dismount this tree in a somewhat dignified manner?”
Bilbo had just finished dressing when three Elves emerged from the forest, their arrows aimed at his head. Bilbo raised his hands. The Elves regarded him curiously and began to whisper in Sindarin.
“Terribly sorry for the fuss,” Bilbo said, “and the noise. If you could just reunite me with my Dwarves, we can get this sorted immediately.”
The Elves glanced at Nagtelch, but gestured for him to walk ahead.
Bits of conversation floated through the forest. After further posturing, Thranduil had ordered the Dwarves searched as he made lofty quips about their poverty.
Suddenly, Thranduil’s voice sliced through the trees. “Bring me that sword.”
Bilbo froze.
“Where did you get this blade?” Thranduil whispered.
“It was a gift,” Thorin gloated, “freely given.”
“From whom?” Thranduil asked. “Tell me, Oakenshield.”
Bilbo’s guard pushed him into the clearing. Thranduil’s escort numbered about twenty, half of whom surrounded the company, and the rest of whom were mounted on horses beside an Elf riding an elk. Millennia had passed since Bilbo had last seen Thranduil, but time touched neither of them: Thranduil was just as odiously pallid as Bilbo remembered. His arachnid fingers were wrapped around Orcrist and the faint stirrings of panic enlivened his cadaverous eyes.
Before the guards could explain Bilbo, he inflated with the petty indignation ubiquitous to a certain strain of gentlehobbits. “Would one of you, ah, Elves like to explain why you’ve detained my guards and, most importantly, all of my things?”
Thranduil gawped and lowered Orcrist. “I did not expect to see a creature of the kindly West so far from home with so uncouth a guard.”
“Hobbit, if you please,” Bilbo said, “and this lot was the best I could find on short notice.”
The Dwarves stared at him as if he had sprouted new heads. Not fit for the meanest stage, were the proud sons of Durin.
“We found you!” Nori shouted, catching on first.
“That’s right!” Fíli said.
“You begged us to come along!” Dwalin said.
Bilbo restrained himself from cheering or rolling his eyes as the company chimed in with similar thinly-veiled insults against his august person.
“Your guards are trespassing upon my realm,” Thranduil said to Bilbo.
“Well, begging your pardon, I had not the foggiest idea,” Bilbo said blithely. “I’m on a walking holiday—traveling east to the Sea of Rhûn. I’ve heard saltwater is wonderfully therapeutic. I hired these Dwarves to take me as far as the Iron Hills. I have that in triplicate, if you can believe.”
Bilbo’s tone insinuated that Thranduil was an utter tosser if he didn’t.
“Your proof is unnecessary,” Thranduil said. “I have already—”
“Really, where are my manners?” Bilbo said. “My name is Bilbo Baggins, of Bag End.”
“A pleasure to meet your acquaintance, Master Baggins,” Thranduil said, inclining his head gracefully. “I am Thranduil Oropherion, King of the Woodland Realm.”
His elk sank to its knees, mirroring its master’s bow. The movement shifted Thranduil’s silver robe, exposing the hilt of an intimately familiar sword. Rage boiled under Bilbo’s skin: a visceral memory of volcanoes and battlefields, of Elf princes mourning their fathers and fleeing with stolen swords.
Saliva flooded Bilbo’s mouth as steeled himself against the inevitable call of his unrelinquished treasure, but he heard … nothing. The sword in Thranduil’s scabbard was no more impressive than Orcrist or Nagtelch or any of the Dwarves’ weapons—perhaps less so. Bilbo certainly felt—he felt the aftershocks of Dagorlad as if it had been yesterday—but the blade no longer held mastery over him.
“It is a lovely sword, is it not?” asked Thranduil.
Bilbo’s gaze snapped to his, but detected only Thranduil’s remote curiosity. “I’m no judge of weapons, as any of my companions could tell you.” He laughed, feeling oddly giddy. “Can’t tell a hoe from a halberd!”
Thranduil lifted Orcrist for Bilbo’s inspection. “Surely this stood out to you.” After Bilbo shook his head, Thranduil added, “This is Orcrist, the Goblin-cleaver; it was forged in Gondolin to eradicate a great evil. It is not of Dwarf make, yet one of your company wields it.” Thranduil’s eyes narrowed. “How did he get it?”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo said, praying the company would not contradict him. “He had it when we met.”
“Think, Master Baggins! This is a matter of utmost importance.”
“The matter of utmost importance,” Bilbo insisted, “is that these Dwarves are transporting my baggage and protecting my person. I think, for all of our sakes, you should let us be on our way.”
“I must retain one of your guards,” Thranduil said. “He must be questioned further on this sword and he owes me a great debt. I cannot recommend him or his kin as business—”
“No, I will have all of them.” Bilbo circled his finger to indicate the Dwarves, except Kíli, who he had left in the trees as insurance. “All of us are leaving here together or I’m afraid you’ll have meddled most severely with my holiday.”
“My condolences for your holiday,” Thranduil said, “but Thorin Oakenshield will be returning with me.”
That claim was more than Bilbo could bear. Scales shivered down his arms and the guttural hiss of the Black Speech infiltrated his voice. “Return my Dwarves or see your forest burn.”
Thranduil jerked back, dropping Orcrist. His elk snorted and the horses tugged at their reins. Every Elven arrow aligned with Bilbo’s heart.
Thranduil regained control of his elk and halted ten feet back from his previous position. He held up a hand. “Hold. I want these Dwarves to see the monster for what he is.” To the company, he said, “I regret to inform you that you have been hoodwinked by a shapeshifting dragon. No doubt he intended to use you to enter the Lonely Mountain and claim Smaug’s riches as his own—or to join him. All wyrms writhe in the same filth.”
Thorin pulled the Dwarves into a huddle and they conferred for several minutes. Finally, they came to a decision and elected Bofur to present it by pushing him to the fore.
“Well, you see, O Pointy-Eared One,” Bofur said, grinning, “the thing is, we already knew. Great fellow, our dragon. Fights our battles, carries our bags, and everything—makes a splendid jam tart, too, if I do say so myself.” He hooked his fingers in his belt loops and turned to Bilbo. “Was that an egg wash on top?”
Bombur shook his head before Bilbo said, “Cream.”
Bofur turned back to Thranduil. “Well, there you have it.”
The Elvenking’s brow furrowed as he looked from Bilbo to the Dwarves. “You knew? But he—” Thranduil struggled for words as the Dwarves roared with laughter. They raised their weapons, slotting against Bilbo’s side with practiced ease.
Thranduil drew his stolen sword and pointed it at Bilbo. “Kill him, and I will set you free and aid your quest, all debts forgotten.”
Doubt scarcely had time to manifest in Bilbo’s mind before Thorin spoke.
“Members of my company are not pieces to bargain away,” he said. “You will let all of us leave, or you will face the wrath of Dwarves and dragons.”
“If you want our dragon, come take him!” Ori cried, to raucous agreement.
Thranduil stilled with deadly anticipation. “If that is your wish.”
Bilbo let his true shape take his body like a wildfire to kindling. The horses bolted away with or without their riders. Arrows leapt from a dozen Elven bows. Bilbo bounded in front of the company as they retreated, catching the arrows in his wings and armor, but his protective instincts sang louder than the pain.
Thranduil’s elk bellowed, its rider shouting orders in Sindarin as he interposed himself between Bilbo and the pale-haired Elf who so closely resembled him. Bilbo’s haunches tightened as he prepared to end the line of Oropher.
A solitary arrow whistled out of the forest, burying itself in the flank of Thranduil’s elk. The elk reared, throwing its rider, and Kíli abandoned his perch to join the fleeing company. Bilbo ensured all of them had gone, then nabbed Orcrist from the leaf litter—narrowly avoiding an arrow through the eye from Thranduil’s spawn—and followed his Dwarves.
He returned Orcrist to Thorin at his earliest convenience, then undressed and took to the sky on healing wings. The forest abated to the heath he and Kíli had spotted earlier and the company redoubled their pace on open ground, their running shadows rippling like a centipede.
The company did not stop until long after dark. The willows ringing their camp concealed them well, but not from a dragon returning to his hoard. Bilbo landed in their midst and became a Hobbit, then bent double as he caught his breath. Someone offered him a bag of clothes—the last from the Rohirrim—and Bilbo gasped his thanks as he pulled the wool tunic overhead.
“Are we being followed?” Dwalin asked.
“Not that I can tell,” Bilbo said. “They might be using the forest, but that’ll slow their horses.” He stuffed his feet into the leggings. “Saw lots of fires to the north, though.”
“That must be Laketown!” Bofur exclaimed.
“It’s properly called Esgaroth upon the Long Lake,” Ori said.
“A village of Men,” Thorin said dismissively. “We will resupply there and reach Erebor before Thranduil.”
That sounded like a wonderful plan, to Bilbo. He wanted to be well-rested before he took on Thranduil again.
“If we keep this pace, we’ll arrive by tomorrow evening,” Dwalin said. When a chorus of groans rose from the fallen Dwarves, he added, “Any stragglers will be sent up with Bilbo.”
Insects and bats rose to fill the Dwarves’ silence.
“That’s what I thought,” Dwalin said. “To bed, the lot of you.”
For all of his gruffness, Bilbo knew that Dwalin would take the first watch and special care to check on Bombur, Oin, and Ori before they fell asleep.
Bilbo scarfed down an acorn cake—noting with exhausted pride that Bombur’s recipe was improving—then unfurled his sleeping roll. Within seconds, he had Bofur, Kíli, and Ori strewn atop him like cats on a hearth. Ori had pulled him close, his head pillowed on Bilbo’s stomach, while Kíli claimed his left thigh. He was too grateful for the companionship to wriggle away—or, indeed, to incinerate Bofur’s positively ripe hat. He listened for the gentle rasp of Thorin’s sleeping breath and closed his eyes.
At the knife-edge of sleep, Bilbo coddled two words in the jealous depths of his heart.
Our dragon, they had called him. Our dragon.
Chapter 13: Thrice Welcome
Summary:
Esgaroth’s gates are thrown open, but kings never forget a slight.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
The company scented Esgaroth before they saw it: a low-riding reek of rotten fish, tar, lakewater, and sewers.
“Mahal!” cried Oin. “I wish my sense of smell had gone instead of my hearing.”
“Stinks worse than you, brother,” Balin chuckled, elbowing Dwalin.
“Aye, and looks sturdier than you,” Dwalin shot back. Even from a mile away, everyone could see that the town perched on crooked stilts.
“How will we get to Esgaroth?” Bilbo asked Balin. “We have no boats, and I do not think the Men would take kindly to a dragon flying his Dwarves to and fro.”
“There’s a bridge,” Balin said. “It’s there, sure as steel.”
Bilbo was in no hurry for it to come into view. He and Glóin were having a riveting exchange about Dwarvish and Hobbit bartering. Dwarves kept too many ledgers for Bilbo’s taste and Glóin distrusted committing so many transactions to memory.
The fog burned away as the sun reached its zenith, revealing the long bridge stretching out to Esgaroth. A lichen-encrusted gatehouse sagged over the entrance, guarded by three Men playing cards on an upturned crate. Another Man stood a short distance away, watching the road. He spotted the Dwarves moments after Bilbo saw him and hissed a command as he strung his longbow. The guards jumped to their feet, their hands forgotten—but for one, who took the opportunity to peek at the others’ cards.
The bowman strode forth to meet the company. Balin lengthened his strides and Bilbo hurried behind him. He wanted to be present if this meeting ended poorly.
“Hail, Dwarves,” called the Man. His stern gaze and dark hair reminded Bilbo of the Dúnedain. “I am Bard, Captain of the Laketown Guard.”
“Balin, at your service,” said Balin, bowing. “We seek to spend the night and resupply.”
“How many do you number?”
“We are fourteen, including Master Baggins here,” Balin said, pushing Bilbo forward like a shield. Bilbo, for his part, tried to look innocent.
“We received word that King Thranduil had fought a band of thirteen Dwarves within his borders,” Bard said. “Thirteen Dwarves—” His gaze dropped to Bilbo “—and a dragon.”
Bilbo forced a laugh. “Dragon? No, no, I’m a drogon. It’s a Shire title. You see—” It did not seem like Bard saw “—I oversee elections in North Farthing, but only when they take place in the months of Forelithe to Foreyule, but not Mersdays. Mersdays are market days for me, as that’s when old Mrs. Proudfoot sells her excellent preserves. It’s a terribly important role: the last five mayors of Michel Delving were all drogons before being elected. Now, where were we? Oh, yes. Thirteen Dwarves and one Hobbit, all present and accounted for.”
“We’re no criminals,” Balin said, diverting Bard’s attention from Bilbo. “We may have taken a wrong turn or two, but we meant no harm to the Elvenking.”
As Balin continued his litany of reassurances, Glóin sidled up to Bilbo.
“You’ve nae mentioned this drogon position before,” Glóin accused, “nor that you’d ever held it.”
“That’s because I made it up,” Bilbo whispered back. “Now shh! The Man is saying something.”
“No one enters Laketown but by leave of the Master,” Bard proclaimed, “and I enforce the Master’s laws.” His mouth twisted as if he had tasted something sour. “There is neither food nor shelter here if you have indeed broken King Thranduil’s peace.”
Dwalin stepped forward, pulling a disgruntled Thorin with him. “Do you not know who you turn away? This is Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thráin, son of Thrór, rightful King Under the Mountain.”
The other three guards exchanged a quick, eager glance at Thorin’s introduction, but Bard’s scowl deepened as he inclined his head. “My apologies, my lord, but I have my orders.”
“Who are you to stand against our quest?” Dwalin demanded.
Balin sighed as Bard and Bilbo prickled.
“What he means to say,” Balin explained, “is that we would like to speak with the Master. Would he be averse to meeting with such … illustrious company?”
“No,” Bard said heavily. “I suppose he would not.”
The Master did not object. Instead, he threw a party.
Why would he not celebrate the return of the Mountain King, he who would make the rivers run with gold and silver? As Thorin had said in his appeal to the Master, all would share in the wealth of the mountain—and that was but a small part of his grand speech.
Afterward, the Master had ushered them into a mean timber hall reeking of pigs and fish, and presented a feast featuring both animals stewed, salted, roasted, and baked seven ways to Highday. Pig’s feet aspic jiggled beside piles of steamed mussels, platters of lamprey, and bowls of poached trout slathered in verdant mint sauce. The high table—of which Bilbo was naturally a part—feasted on roast wigeons and tenderloin; the centerpiece was a heron cooked in its plumage swimming on a lake of pease pottage. Their tankards overflowed with ale and a white wine so bitter that Bilbo, Nori, and Dori surreptitiously poured it onto the dogs lurking beneath the table.
The Dwarves drank and ate and danced with reckless abandon. Bilbo had his fill of fish—their tiny bones especially—but avoided the funny aspics and abstained from drink after the disappointing wine. By the time the sweetmeats were served, the company was too drunk to entertain him, and neither the Men nor dogs of Laketown paid him much heed. Bilbo cast a fond glance at his carousing hoard, then smuggled half a gooseberry pie away from the festivities.
Compared to the feverish feast hall, the corridor was appallingly cold. Bilbo drew his new cloak around his shoulders and nearly stamped his numb feet on the planks when he noticed the lake glinting between the misaligned boards. Bilbo sheepishly tip-toed to the side of the passageway, tucked a napkin into his shirtfront, and produced a proper fork and knife.
He had taken one bite of pie before he heard the rasp of a knife on wood.
“Oh, Bifur,” Bilbo said. “I hadn’t seen you there.”
The Dwarf was wedged in the shadow pooling beneath one of the windows. A mound of wood shavings curled at his boots, indicating he had been there for some time.
“Did you want any pie?” Bilbo asked. “It’s not awful, but Bombur’s arrowroot cakes are better—and you know how those turned out.”
Bifur tucked away his project—a fish, by the look of it—and squatted in front of Bilbo, the tip of his embedded ax inches away from Bilbo’s forehead. From his coat, he withdrew something folded in green wool and passed it to Bilbo.
“Hullo!” Bilbo said, rather flattered. He unwrapped a long, thin shape. “What do we have…?”
Bilbo immediately recognized the wood as the strange branch he had stolen from Bombadil’s house. Bifur had carved its twists into the likeness of a dragon—of Bilbo, his wings tucked against his sides.
“Oh, Bifur,” Bilbo murmured, signing, “This is beautiful.”
Bifur wiggled the tail, displaying its subtle segmentation, then pushed a button cunningly hidden near the toy’s left foreleg. Bilbo’s fans popped out of his spine, so finely shaved that they were nearly translucent.
“For you,” Bifur said in Khuzdul.
“I can’t,” Bilbo said automatically, rotating his miniaturized body. He could not decide if he loved more the design or the skill of Bifur’s hands. “This…”
Bifur pulled him forward and gently tapped his temple to Bilbo’s, then rejoined the feast. Bilbo sniffed hard—no Dragon of Mordor would be seen weeping alone over his dessert!—and rewrapped the toy before slipping it into his coat. He consumed his feelings along with half a middling gooseberry pie, then decided he ought to put the toy in his pack, and quickly: he would never forgive himself if he lost it.
Bilbo passed a branching corridor and paused. Thorin was nursing a tankard in front of a window facing the Lonely Mountain.
“Party’s that way,” Bilbo called, jerking a thumb over his shoulder.
Thorin glanced at him, then went back to staring at the Erebor as if he could pull it through the glass. “I am not a fit companion for a feast tonight.”
“No one’s going to be fitting anything after tenth helpings of lamprey pie,” Bilbo joked, evincing a small smile from his friend. “Do you want me to…?”
“Abide here awhile, Master Baggins,” Thorin said.
Bilbo tried not to look too eager as he settled beside Thorin. His head felt light and heavy at the same time—not altogether unpleasantly, but Thorin’s presence demanded full command of his senses. Bilbo wiggled open the window. Fresh air tumbled in, tasting of rain.
Thorin did not speak or lift his tankard to his lips. His gaze was fixed on the mountain, as surely as Bilbo’s was fixed on him. He loved studying his Dwarf as a jeweler loved studying a diamond, evincing novel facets from the same depths. Thorin finally turned to him and Bilbo hurriedly switched his attention to the Lonely Mountain.
“You look unwell,” Thorin said. “Have you eaten well? If you are to face Smaug—”
“May I tell you something?” Bilbo blurted. “It must remain between you and I.”
Thorin immediately placed his tankard on the windowsill. “Anything you tell me will be in strictest confidence.”
“You recall the … ah. The hoarding instinct?”
Thorin nodded.
“Yes.” Bilbo fidgeted, unable to meet Thorin’s eye. “I don’t think I properly… I haven’t told you how it’s formed.” He stopped and started twice before he found his voice. “It’s much like…” He spread his hands uselessly. “It’s like—”
“Love,” Thorin interrupted.
Bilbo choked mid-sentence, feeling quite poleaxed. “Pardon?!”
Thorin hesitated, then said, “At the house of Tom Bombadil, when first we spoke of your hoard, you said it was much like—” His gaze flickered “—love.”
Bilbo pursed his lips. “I certainly did.”
Oh, he had been so wonderfully flippant and smart, hadn’t he? He fumed at his past self and groped for a more neutral metaphor through the haze of the company’s intoxication.
“A hollow, empty love.” Thorin half-turned towards Erebor. “As much a punishment as a reward.”
“Yes, yes,” Bilbo said, flapping his hands as if he could slap his words back into the past. “And I was wrong. Well, I was right. The hoard bond is love. It’s not—”
“If Thranduil’s sword is what you desire, we will fetch it back. This is but the smallest favor I would do for you.”
Bilbo nearly shrieked. “Now, listen here, Thorin—”
“Your … instinct did not endanger the fate of the quest, Master Baggins. In fact, I suspect Thranduil is much less eager to give chase now.”
“It’s not the swords, Thorin! They don’t call to me anymore, because—” Bilbo exhaled sharply. “Oh, confusticate everything. Because you are my hoard.”
Whatever direction Thorin had anticipated this conversation was going, Bilbo had clearly veered it into the mulch. Thorin rocked back on his heels, surprise overtaking his features. Bilbo shriveled at the distance newly opened between them.
Finally, Thorin said, “Me?”
“All of the company. All thirteen of you.” Thorin no longer met his eye and Bilbo twisted with the agony of rejection. “It’s not evil. Not like that. You’re—you’re not things. I don’t think of you that way. You … you aren’t molded, like poured gold. You haven’t been beaten into shape, like steel. You live, you breathe. You make mistakes. You’re valiant, and kind, and brave. You change and for that, I…”
Bilbo fumbled for an appropriate end to his tirade, but everything he came up with was so pathetic that he kept his mouth shut. He could not say, for that, I love you—not to Thorin, whom Bilbo cherished most of all, for he was so unlike anyone he had ever met. Thorin led with his heart in word and deed, and, for that, he owned Bilbo’s.
The crown jewel of Bilbo’s hoard peered into his eyes with irises of the exact same shade, a smile kindling beneath his beard. “Spoken like a true Dwarf, Master Baggins. We are just as fortunate to count you as one of ours.”
Bilbo’s heart swelled perilously. “Thank you, Thorin.” Thorin was still looking at him. “What?”
“Will this hoard bond … change anything?” Thorin asked.
“No,” Bilbo said. “No. Everything between you and me, and the company and me—it remains the same.” He scratched his ear as he debated his next words. “Well, ah. It changes me. My … loyalty, I suppose, belongs—truly belongs—to the company. Gold, personal safety, friendship, home—none of that matters to me anymore. My hoard is my life.”
Bilbo swayed on his toes, then glanced at Thorin to gauge his reaction. He seemed to take this revelation with suitable gravity.
“What of your fourteenth share?” Thorin asked.
“It’s yours, and Fíli’s, and Kíli’s. I don’t need it.”
“I would insist,” Thorin said, his chin lowering. “I would not ask you to risk so much for so little.”
“Thorin, my hoard is everything.” Bilbo smiled and tapped his chest. “I have what I want right here.”
Thorin’s fingers closed over his, pressing their joined hands against Bilbo’s galloping pulse. “If all we have is your heart, Master Baggins, then we are blessed indeed.”
Bilbo wrenched his hand away and set it on his hip, away from further temptations, thank you! “Just, ah, don’t tell the others.”
“I swore not to.”
“I will tell them, in time,” Bilbo said. “I just need to find the words when I’m sober.” He cleared his throat. “Well, I’m not drinking, but everyone else is.”
Thorin suspiciously eyed his tankard.
“I only feel extremes,” Bilbo clarified. “It’s rather inconvenient, actually, given how often you injure yourselves. Ori is too clumsy by half.”
Thorin chuckled. “I see your point.”
Thorin was warm, even to Bilbo, like a banked hearth on a frosty day. Bilbo did not lean into it—not to an extent he thought Thorin would notice, anyway.
“Some legends claim dragons have a jewel they covet above the rest,” Thorin said suddenly.
Bilbo fervently hoped his blush would be bleached away by moonlight. “How ridiculous! You can’t believe every tale you hear about dragons, Master Dwarf. Why, I’ve put about half of them myself for little more than a lark!”
Thorin’s reply vanished when the Master’s front door opened beneath them, pouring torchlight onto the docks. Bilbo looked down as Bard stepped out with four guards. One pair held Kíli. The other pair—and three Elves, including Thranduil’s redheaded captain—tussled with Dwalin.
“Dwalin! Kíli!” Bilbo gasped, darting to the sill.
Dwalin glanced up. He and Thorin nodded to each other before he and Kíli were hauled away.
Bilbo gripped the window frame. The damp wood splintered beneath his growing claws, but Thorin held him back.
“Not here,” Thorin said. “We must make for the mountain.”
Bilbo was aghast. “But Dwalin—”
“Dwalin understands the stakes,” Thorin interrupted, “and he will keep Kíli safe.”
He turned away, but Bilbo lingered, a snarl bubbling in his chest.
“We should help them,” Bilbo said.
“There’s nothing we can do,” Thorin called. “Thranduil already knows we’re here and we cannot destroy a town of Men and a host of Elves by ourselves.”
Bilbo ground his teeth, despair and helplessness twisting his gut.
“We will have the upper hand at the bargaining table after we take the mountain,” Thorin said. “Neither the Master nor Thranduil would dare harm my kin. Your hoard will be safe. They have withstood far worse than the Laketown jail.”
Bilbo reluctantly followed Thorin, his heart tearing as the Elves took Kíli and Dwalin farther from his side.
Weeks on the road and an anticipated early departure meant the company was already packed. Bilbo helped Thorin steal the last few items—food, waterskins, torches, and rope—then snuck into the banquet hall to fetch the Dwarves. The drunk Men lay insensate, the dogs had climbed onto the tables to lap up the leftovers, and the company was holding fast to each other as they bellowed a Khuzdul drinking song. A veritable Lonely Mountain of mugs attested to their consumption. Bilbo and Thorin bundled them out in twos and threes. Most sobered quickly when told of the arrests. Thorin and Balin had to sit with Fíli to prevent him from charging after his brother. Bilbo was left to wrestle Bombur on his lonesome.
As the smallest and sharpest, Bilbo was elected as scout. For a tense half hour, he snuck around corners, beckoning the company behind him, until they reached the Master’s dock. Balin and Nori picked a suitably large vessel and began loading the company’s supplies. Selecting rowers was difficult: half were leery of boats, half were too inebriated to hold an oar, and Bilbo was too small. Finally, Dori, Bifur, Oin, and Thorin sat beside the oarlocks and began to row.
Bilbo did not know how they made it out of Laketown undetected. Dori and Thorin’s stronger strokes sent the boat into unseen obstacles, and none of the Dwarves were watermen: their oars slapped the water and rocked the boat. Eventually, they cleared the city and slipped onto the glassy lake.
The Lonely Mountain loomed overhead, remote and beautiful.
Notes:
A lot of work went into describing the Master’s feast. I based the area around Laketown on the Scottish Highlands, and the dishes on those served during the High Middle Ages (AD 1000-1300). I built a calendar for the entire fic and transposed Shire Reckoning to the Gregorian Calendar using Psarando. I determined that the company arrives in Laketown on July 25 (Shire Reckoning)/July 17 (Gregorian Calendar). I researched mid-July birding and wildlife guides for Cairngorms National Park, mindful that global warming has altered avian migration dates and that many native species were hunted to extinction in past centuries. This research allowed me to place two items—wigeon (Anas penelope; a small duck) and heron (Ardea cinerea)—on the menu. The gooseberry pie that Bilbo later eats was also chosen for seasonality.
I also researched aquatic offerings. Britain is home to the brook lamprey (Lampetra planeri), which is a non-parasitic species that dwells exclusively in freshwater. I went through bills of fare and accounts of feasts for the trout (Salmo trutta) and freshwater mussel (Margaritifera margaritifera) recipes, as well as the presentation of the heron. Pigs have been omnipresent in human settlements since domestication and Bofur notably steals a pig’s dinner during Desolation of Smaug. The pig’s feet aspic is a bit of an anachronism, but too funny to pass up.
Ale was a common drink during the Middle Ages, as barley grows throughout the British Isles. England has its own wineries, but the best vintages came from warmer climates with sweeter grapes. Earlier drafts of this chapter also featured an even longer description of food—notably, the bread and sweetmeats—but that level of detail became unwieldy.
As a final note, with the calendar established, I tried to use seasonally and environmentally appropriate wildflowers when named. Any errors are my own.
Chapter 14: The Curses of Diamonds and Rings
Summary:
Two dragons meet at last.
Chapter Text
Their boat fetched against Long Lake’s northern shore just before dawn. Bilbo had fallen asleep hours before, lulled by the waves and rhythmic splash of the oars. The Dwarves’ jerky movements as they pulled the boat ashore told him that they had not slept at all.
A steady, soaking rain misted down from the heights as they stumbled over the brilliant heathers belting the lakeside. At an invisible line, the plants suddenly ended: nothing grew amidst the jagged tors and burnt stumps.
There were no birds.
Their path was an old Dwarf road zig-zagging up Erebor’s southern slope. Signs of life decayed quietly on the wayside: steel axles, the wood wheels moldered; pins and jewels and buckles, scattered like seeds; the orphaned blade of a halberd; discarded pots rouged with rust. Fear and reverence flowed between the Dwarves as they inhaled the ash of sorrow and history, seeing in every glorious ruin the grief of their past and the promise of an age to come.
Bilbo’s thoughts lingered on Dwalin and Kíli. He felt their absence as surely as if he had been caught in the rain without an umbrella: he was acutely aware of where they were, but there was little he could do except press on. He suspected Thorin would regret leaving them behind. Dwalin was a doughty fighter and Kíli could kill from a greater distance than anyone in the company.
They came upon the ruins of Dale near sunset. The rain had vanished, but the air was cool. While the Dwarves debated where to camp, Bilbo toddled to the edge of the ridge. The ruined city was cupped inside the valley like a bird in hand, its red roofs fallen after centuries of winters. Dale was a handsome town—grander, even in destruction, than Tharbad or Laketown—but Men’s achievements withered beside the stonework sunk into Erebor’s slopes. Two imposing Dwarf statues—each fifty feet tall and carved with lifelike detail—crouched on either side of the entrance. The gate reared another two hundred feet higher. Its lower half was buried in rubble, but its upper reaches were a mastery of sculpture, with pillars and tiered balconies seamlessly and symmetrically wrought.
Bilbo heard the crunch of boots behind him and asked, “Is this the overlook?”
“Aye, it is,” Balin said. “In kinder days, we would fly kites here.”
“Gandalf told us to wait for him,” Bilbo said.
There was an awkward pause. Dori cleared his throat.
“We’ll enter the mountain tomorrow,” Thorin announced.
Bilbo turned around. “The last time we didn’t wait for Gandalf, we went to Moria.”
“I doubt we’ll be welcomed back into Laketown for our weekend shopping,” Thorin said, his jaw tight. Either to reassure Bilbo or the Dwarves serried behind him, Thorin added, “Smaug has not been seen in seventy years. If he is dead, time wasted on the doorstep is time for Thranduil to find us and for our stores to dwindle. If Smaug lives, there is little a wizard can accomplish that you cannot.”
Thrilled by the compliment, Bilbo said, “Better to work on a full stomach, as we Hobbits say.”
“A blessing on the curly heads of all Hobbits, the wisest creatures in Arda,” Thorin said, his strained expression easing. “We press on.”
The company staggered up the steep stretch between Dale and the gates of Erebor in tense silence. The River Running foamed and splashed to their left, and its course swiftly glutted by springs gushing down from the western and southern arms of the Lonely Mountain. Yet, for all the water, not even the thinnest cape of moss covered the damp stone. Balin turned them from the river before reaching the gates, directing the company instead to an old archery range a quarter mile west. Two targets remained at the leeward end, still peppered with arrows. Fíli glumly remarked that Kíli would have laughed at the sight. No one responded.
Dinner was plentiful, but dull: twice-baked Man bread, salted trout, dried blueberries, and hard cheese. Bilbo scratched mold off the cheese and ate in desultory silence. There was no singing, no dancing, no acknowledgement that they had reached the end of their journey. The looming threat of Smaug, Dwalin and Kíli’s absences, and the company’s residual hangovers quashed the mood entirely.
The company disappeared into their bedrolls soon after. Dori drew first watch and settled down with a weary sigh, his back against the mountain.
The Dwarves’ visions of an Erebor renewed reverberated through their bond. Fat, happy Dwarf children tumbled into Bilbo’s dreams, gamboling beneath marbles depicting the great deeds of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield. Thorin was King Under the Mountain, seated above his heir, Prince Fíli, on a throne set with a wagon-sized diamond. Erebor’s mines were productive, its toy shops and scriptoriums and kitchens blazing with activity, its forges ringing with the fall of a thousand hammers. The company’s lives were industrious, but untroubled. Threaded into their midst was Bilbo, grown plump on the mountain’s bounty, soaring through Erebor’s halls or reclining on treasure or carrying a fresh sheet of oatmeal cookies—that had to be Dwalin’s dream—or barded in Erebor’s arms as the king’s emissary.
Sleep came easily that night.
Although Bilbo had volunteered for a watch, he was the last to wake on a grey, shadowy morning. Breakfast was as disappointing as dinner, but yesterday’s gloom had been suborned to pragmatism: everyone ate heartily.
Bilbo reviewed his dragonslaying experience as he choked down his waybread. He had never killed another dragon, but he and his siblings had often played at hunting within Orodruin’s lava tubes, and Bilbo had battled a balrog, a watcher, and the Eagles of Manwë, and so was rather confident. The Dwarves were optimistic about their own chances against Smaug, except for Fíli, who said, “We should’ve rescued Kíli. Fighting Smaug will be impossible at close range.”
Thorin shot him a quelling look, which Fíli sullenly reciprocated.
“Well, that’s not the plan,” Bilbo said. “I’m going to steal the Arkenstone, then go back for Smaug.”
“And we’ll come with you,” Bofur said, to which the rest of the company agreed. Bifur smacked his vambraces together.
“It would be a perfect waste for you to come all this way only to get squashed underfoot,” Bilbo snapped.
The company protested, mixing boasts of Dwarven durability and battle prowess, barbs directed at Bilbo’s competency, and, most reasonably, a recounting of the risks they had already undertaken. Bilbo waited for Thorin to weigh in, but he did not speak until the debate had almost escalated to violence.
“If the dragon wakes, we would not have you face him alone,” Thorin said. “The company shares the burdens of the quest—its dangers and rewards alike.”
“We haven’t come all this way to wait while the battle is fought!” Glóin added.
“Very well,” Bilbo said, “but you will wait here until I return!”
“Not here,” Bifur signed. “We will go with you to the gates.”
Exasperated and secretly flattered, Bilbo conceded. The company packed up camp, then picked their way down from the ridge. Thorin led them up the vale of Erebor, unerring and swift as an arrow. They rejoined the Celduin, but the river’s course veered west to where its headwaters cascaded from snowbound slopes. The company’s progress was slowed as they were forced to skirt ever-larger chunks torn from the gate. As Dwalin had reported, Smaug had crashed through the upper stonework, piling the lower reaches in fallen rock. A cart-sized chunk of granite lay before the doors, but the ruins above proved more amenable and the Dwarves set about clearing enough space for a stout Hobbit.
As they worked, Bofur pulled Bilbo aside. There was no privacy before the gates, but the urgency of their task and the grumble of shifting rock gave them some cover.
“You know you don’t need to do this,” Bofur told him.
“It took us all morning to agree to this plan,” Bilbo said, smiling ruefully. “No sense wasting the afternoon coming up with a new one.”
“You don’t need to do it alone.”
“But I haven’t been alone,” Bilbo told him. “You’ve gotten me this far—no, you have. I haven’t gone past Bree in an Age and here I am, on the other side of the world.” Bilbo tapped his chest. “And I always have you. In here.”
“Well, we’d rather have your back,” Bofur said, “in there, if it’s all the same to you.”
A block of masonry clunked at Bilbo’s feet. He and Bofur looked up to where Balin, Bifur, Dori, and Glóin stood atop their pile of rubble.
“That should be sufficient,” Dori announced, dusting off his broad hands.
The company scrambled for their first glimpse into Erebor. Bilbo began undressing. The chill stung his skin and he hopped from foot to foot as he stuffed his clothes inside his pack. The Dwarves parted as Bilbo approached the opening, shivering as the wind sucked him inward.
He handed his pack and Nagtelch to Dori, then said, “Now, remember that you promised to stay until I return with the Arkenstone! With any luck, I expect to see you soon.”
“I will keep them safe,” Thorin said.
Loath as Bilbo was to entrust his hoard to someone else, he cherished the sincerity of Thorin’s offer. “I can think of no one better.”
A gust of wind pinked Thorin’s cheeks. “They are as much my responsibility as yours.”
“Then I expect you to knock some sense into their rocky skulls if they get delusions of heroism!” Bilbo said.
The Dwarves chuckled.
“Be safe, Master Baggins,” Balin said. “Go with all the blessings Dwarves can offer.”
A chorus of whispered goodbyes and well-wishes followed the second dragon in as many centuries into Erebor. The meager sunlight had dazzled him; he screwed his eyes shut, then opened them to take in an entry hall built on the scale of dragons—or Dwarves. The walls were scarred with claw and scorch marks, and dust lay thick as Midwinter snow.
Bilbo changed his skin, then drew his wings close and padded deeper into the mountain. He—a creature of fire and air—felt the Lonely Mountain as millions of tons of rock pressing exactly on the nape of his neck. Such was his distraction that he initially sidestepped the misshapen lumps without a second thought. Upon closer inspection, though, he discovered that they were Dwarves, their burnt armor housing only ash.
He shrank back against the wall, his fans flared and his throat sizzling. He turned back in the direction of his Dwarves, suddenly wishing to gather them up and take them far away from this accursed place—even Khazad-dûm, if they wanted it.
His promise to Thorin stayed his flight. Thorin’s determination thrummed like a chord in the night, holding the rest of the company on the same note. Thorin believed they would finish their quest, that Erebor would never share Khazad-dûm’s fate.
Bilbo cast a final, sad glance at the dead Dwarves, and pressed on.
Words failed to describe Erebor’s enormity. The click of Bilbo’s claws was utterly lost in the vaulted ceilings and cavernous corridors. He passed through hall after scarred hall, each representing what seemed like a lifetime of work. Each corpse and carving marked a legacy passed, a time gone by. Smaug had methodically defaced the statuary and fine carvings—pettiness, Bilbo thought, before he noticed slivers of gold and silver shimmering in the deepest crevices. Smaug had gouged every trace of precious metal out of his kingdom.
Since the previous morning, Bilbo had sensed an insistent tug directing him towards Erebor, much like the smell of supper might drag fauntlings from play. Bilbo supposed in this analogy that he was already full, but he could still trace the treasure’s pull down a central road diving into the heart of the mountain. He took care to memorize landmarks: he would only have the similarly directionless presence of his own hoard to return by.
The musk of dragon gradually replaced stone and dust. Bilbo trotted onward, lured by both a growing warmth and the cresting scent of treasure. The road shot between two doors hanging on their hinges, framing what looked to be a large chamber beyond. Bilbo slipped between the doors and then froze, unable to comprehend the sight before him.
He had expected Thrór’s treasure-hoard to be the size of a Laketown warehouse, but he had vastly underestimated Erebor’s wealth. The undulating piles of treasure sloped up and away; the far walls were unseen in the distance. The buttressed ceiling was a smudgy suggestion supported by evenly-spaced columns thicker than the Party Tree. Gold lay so thickly that the floor had vanished, save in a rare few places where a suggestion of balcony peeked through. Bilbo had no scale for its depth: the gold could have been five fathoms deep or a hundred.
There was also no sign of its master, but Bilbo scented him close at hand.
Stifling a sneeze, Bilbo crept down the stairwell to where the great golden sea lapped at the steps. Cautiously, he set his forepaw onto the hoard. A sickening ooze crawled up his leg: the living force of Smaug’s avarice. Bilbo steeled himself and put down another paw, then both of his back feet. The gold slipped under him, but walking was not unlike navigating the sandy banks of the Brandywine. He stiffened his tail to keep it from dragging and continued into the treasury.
Smaug was an indiscriminate hoarder. Everything of worth had ended up here: coins, mostly, but also statues, tableware, tapestries, jewelry, urns, furniture, bricks, weapons, ornamented chests, toys, armor, portraits, bottles, and unusually shiny forge tools. Bilbo wondered how many years Smaug had spent amassing his hoard. Even a creature twice Bilbo’s size would need decades to ferret out every last bauble.
Inexplicably, he thought of Lobelia Sackville-Baggins and his own unattended delving at Bag End. He had left without a goodbye; surely she was circling like a vulture, ready to descend the moment that the consensus in Hobbiton was that old Mr. Baggins had shuffled off. Well! Mr. Baggins planned to return, and with as much righteous fury as his Dwarves returning to Erebor if he found Lobelia and her execrable husband snuggled in Belladonna and Bungo’s burrow! The idea of Nori sneaking into Bag End to seize the deed while Lobelia slept was so absurd that Bilbo hissed with laughter.
Sss-sss-sss.
Bilbo froze until the echoes died, then took his next steps gingerly.
He had hoped that Smaug had placed the Arkenstone in a place of honor, perhaps arranged on a mantlepiece or framed between dried flowers. He had no such luck, but that irresistible pull now gained form and direction amidst the gold dunes. Instinct pointed him at a pile climbing the back wall. He stuck his head and neck into the coins, triggering a lavish landslide around his shoulders. Something lodged in his teeth; he jerked free and spat out a mithril crown.
The coins continued sliding downslope, chiming as they struck columns and balconies. Bilbo glanced back, exasperated, and had nearly turned away when the coins suddenly heaved, then fell: the breath of an enormous beast. The gold on the distant side of the hall began to shift, triggering an avalanche down a scaly cliff newly exposed by Smaug’s movement.
Bilbo bounded towards what he thought was Smaug’s head. Smaug would be drowsy after such a long slumber: Bilbo would tear out his throat before he awoke.
A geyser of gold and smoke blasted towards the ceiling, followed by the thunderous roar of an inhalation. Coins began to fall away as a horned head, then a scaled neck, then a wing rose above the hoard. Priceless treasures pelted Bilbo like hail, turning his charge. He could only look on as Smaug, Chiefest and Greatest of Calamities, was revealed in the fullness of his might.
Bilbo rolled behind a pillar. Smaug had to be four, five, six times longer than Bilbo, and a great deal heavier. Furthermore, Bilbo had traveled farther into the treasury than he realized: his escape would not be swift on dragon wings or Hobbit feet.
“Welcome, thief,” Smaug said, his voice as soft and scarlet as fox fur. The ground quaked as he stepped forward. “You cannot hide from me.” His tongue slithered over his fangs. “I smell you. I feel your air. Come, meet your doom, trespasser.”
Bilbo took a fortifying breath, then stepped around the column and said, in the Black Speech, “I am no trespasser! I simply came to behold your majesty.”
He swept into a winged approximation of a bow as Smaug surged forward, heat presaging his presence like smoke before fire. The larger dragon halted within a handbreadth of Bilbo.
“Some thief you are, to reveal yourself so quickly,” Smaug declared. He, too, used the Black Speech, a language better suited to fanged mouths and sibilant snarls.
“O Smaug,” Bilbo said, “I wished to see if the tales of your malevolence were true. They have fallen utterly short: never has so powerful a dragon dwelt upon this Middle Earth.”
“Your manners please me.” Smaug’s nostrils flared. “You seem to know my name, yet I have neither seen nor smelled your kind before. Where have you come from, little lizard?”
Bilbo’s indignation overrode reason: he met Smaug’s blistering gaze. “I come from under the hill, and under the hill and over the hill my paths have led. I have walked with two legs and four. I was shaped by fire and chosen by earth. I am he whose flame burns unseen.”
Smaug cocked his head. “That cannot be your true name.”
“I am the bane of eagles, the friend of bears, the counselor of princes.”
“Lovely titles,” Smaug drawled.
“I have done battle with fire and shadow. Kings kneel before me in fear or in friendship.”
“Not I,” Smaug purred, ruffling his wings coyly.
“I would never presume, Your Radiance,” Bilbo said, warming to his riddles. “I am Deathslayer and Skinchanger, who brooks no master on the ground or the sky. I willingly surrendered three of the greatest treasures in Arda to gain thirteen of greater value still!”
“I possess the mightiest treasure in Arda,” Smaug interjected.
“Of course, Your Magnificence,” Bilbo said hastily. “Forgive my hyperboles. I merely wished to prove myself worthy of your presence.”
“Then I shall introduce myself in kind.” Smaug reared to display a dazzling waistcoat of gems. His wings stretched halfway across the chamber and his throat glowed like coals. “I am a scion of Glaurung, Father of Dragons, from whom sprang Ancalagon the Black, who broke the Host of Valinor. I am the great firedrake who swept south like a hurricane to roust Durin’s people from their halls. My armor is like tenfold shields, my teeth are swords, my claws are spears, and my breath is death!”
Smaug crashed back to all fours in a tsunami of gold, then tucked his paws and slithered closer like a water snake. Bilbo slipped as he spun to keep Smaug in sight.
“Truly,” Bilbo called, “you are the worthy inheritor of such a lineage, for no dragon could be your equal, O Smaug, and no living master could trammel you.”
“None indeed!” Smaug boomed.
He circled Bilbo in a spray of coins, sending Bilbo rolling down a dune of riches. By the time Bilbo righted himself, Smaug had fully encircled him, his snout resting atop his tail. Only now could Bilbo fathom Smaug’s true size. Bilbo was a fearsome creature, but only a shadow of the terrible red dragon. Nights spent at the Dwarves’ fireside bragging of Smaug’s death seemed very far away.
“I have riddled you out, Eaglebane,” Smaug murmured. “Such a small thing you are—a student aping his master’s work.”
“Well, see here,” Bilbo huffed, then remembered his predicament. “It is true that I can no longer consider myself a dragon when faced with such a specimen, Smaug the Malevolent. My maker would rise from his grave to agree.”
Smaug rumbled deep in his chest. “So you think him dead?” He tilted to regard Bilbo with a red-rimmed eye. “He has returned.”
Bilbo stiffened, the black memories of Mordor briefly overpowering the comforting weight of his hoard.
“This news troubles you.”
Bilbo struggled to recover his wits, ultimately defaulting on centuries of Hobbit courtesy. “Thank you for these glad tidings, Master of Erebor! I was unaware of his return.”
“He has not declared himself openly,” Smaug said, “but even in slumber, my hearing reaches far … to the very steps of Dol Guldur.”
Bilbo remembered the name from Gandalf’s warnings. A shiver ran down his spine. The wizard had been very late. Mostly to himself, Bilbo said, “This is dire news indeed.”
“Perhaps to a lesser wyrm.” Smaug grandly swept a wing (which Bilbo ducked) above the gold. “Let Men and Elves and Dwarves break themselves against the tide of darkness. After they perish, I will plunder their cities and amass a greater hoard than has ever been seen. Here I will remain, as King Under the Mountain! I am not a dog to be called by the shadow of Morgoth’s malice.” One baleful eye regarded Bilbo. “You may tell him as much when you crawl back.”
It was Bilbo’s turn to swell with pride. He mounted a platform protruding from the hoard and flexed his wings. “I am no longer bound to him.”
Smaug lowered his head and asked, softly, “And how did you accomplish this?”
“I severed myself from my hoard.”
“Faugh!” Smaug reared back, his muzzle wrinkling. “What is a dragon without his hoard?”
“Free, O King,” Bilbo said. He would not address this creature as the King Under the Mountain. That title was Thorin’s.
“You take pains to call yourself that, yet we both know you lie,” Smaug said.
Bilbo tilted his head. “Forgive me, but I am too dull-witted to grasp your—”
“In return for your riddling and your manners,” Smaug interrupted, “I shall grant you one piece of advice, from one dragon to another: cease your dealings with Dwarves.”
“Dwarves?” Bilbo asked, feigning surprise. “Duh-warves?”
“Do not lie to me,” Smaug hissed. “I know the smell and taste of Dwarf—no better!—and you reek of them.”
“I, too, know the taste of Dwarf,” Bilbo lied. Any hope of escaping the treasury—with or without the Arkenstone—was quickly fading, but Bilbo had no chance if Smaug attacked. “Washed them down with lakewater when I found them creeping up to your kingdom!”
Smaug inhaled sharply. “As if I did not know this day would come! The day when a pack of thieving, filthy Dwarves snuck into my hall!”
Bilbo edged towards an exit, but Smaug circled him, ramming his shoulders into the columns.
“And you!” Smaug cried. “You call yourself a dragon and ally yourself with rats!”
Bilbo abandoned his perch for cover.
“I see you now, O Hoardless One,” Smaug seethed. The sounds of his rampage stopped and a knowing voice skulked over the gold. “Do you truly believe that Dwarves would let you keep even a single coin? After all they believe they have suffered, do you think they will surrender their ancestors’ gold to a dragon? It is a mercy that you came to me: I shall kill you quickly, before Dwarves or Men fall over themselves to wear your hide or steal my gold!”
Bilbo peeked out from behind his column. Smaug was nearly twenty yards distant, a ruby glowing on a golden bed. “Gold, Smaug the Heedless? The Dwarves come for revenge.”
“Revenge!” Smaug snorted. “The King Under the Mountain fled and Girion perished between my teeth. I ate their peoples like a wolf among sheep and scattered their kin to their putrid byres! The warriors of yore are gone; none shall rise to take their place as I grow ever older, ever stronger, ever more cunning.”
“You see only the evil in the world,” Bilbo declared. “But there is much that is good and fair, and just.”
“Is that what you think, little lizard?” Smaug mocked.
Bilbo’s heart stirred: his hoard was approaching. Both the main exit and the Arkenstone were still behind Smaug.
“Yes,” Bilbo said. “That is what I believe.”
Smaug’s throat smoldered ominously. “Then you will die for it.”
Chapter 15: Fire and Stone
Summary:
The company battles Smaug beneath Erebor.
Chapter Text
Bilbo braced for fire, but Smaug’s tail swung with shocking speed. Bilbo flinched at the last moment, deflecting a killing blow into a rib-cracking one. He collapsed onto the gold and hobbled farther into the treasury, emphasizing his limp to encourage Smaug to follow.
Smaug needed no baiting: he leapt forward immediately. Bilbo twisted around, his chest blazing, but Smaug reared up and beat his wings, banishing the heat in a terrible gale. Bilbo’s own wings caught the wind and flew open, flinging him backward. He leapt to his feet, slipping on the gold as Smaug’s jaws closed inches from his leg. Bilbo inhaled again, but Smaug’s wing dealt him a fierce uppercut, snapping his mouth shut and knocking him over. He rolled under Smaug and came up beside the larger dragon’s hamstring. His fangs screeched across Smaug’s armor without leaving a single mark.
Bilbo’s hoard-bond waxed; he and Smaug whipped around to see a third of the company skidding to a stop on the balcony where Bilbo had first arrived. Their battle cries died in their throat as they beheld the sheer scale of the treasure, then the two dragons circling below.
Smaug’s crest rose as he beheld this new threat. “There you are! Less cowardly than I supposed, but—”
Bilbo latched onto the delicate skin of Smaug’s wing. His mouth flooded with searing blood. Smaug plunged in a flash of teeth and heat. Bilbo threw himself onto the treasure, letting the cascading gold carry him out of Smaug’s grasp. He righted himself, then leapt into the air, flying away from the Dwarves.
A growl of primal fury ripped from Smaug’s chest, followed by the thunderous crack of expanding leather.
“What deal did you make, wretch?” Smaug hissed, his voice hitching as he flew after Bilbo. “Kill me and claim your share of my treasure?”
Bilbo chanced a glance back, then hissed in alarm and flicked his tail out of Smaug’s jaws as they closed with a resounding clop. The motion that saved his tail snagged his wingtip on a column; Bilbo fetched up against a wall, then whirled to face Smaug. Smaug flared his wings, stopping himself short, his throat glowing. Behind him, the Dwarves were shouting in Khuzdul over an awful ratcheting noise. Bilbo would satisfy his curiosity if he lived through the next three seconds.
“And now, Skinchanger, you will die,” Smaug snarled.
Bilbo braced himself as the furnace in Smaug’s throat roared to life. His claws sank into the melting gold, but the flames licking his scales were less dangerous than his hearth in Bag End. Fire could not harm a creature of Mordor.
Smaug closed his jaws, his cruel satisfaction transforming into confusion when he saw Bilbo was unharmed.
“Your breath really is death, O Hurricane.” Bilbo lifted a paw to his snout. “Good heavens, when was the last time you brushed?”
Smaug lunged forward, flames streaming from his jaws. Bilbo leapt off the wall, passing through Smaug’s flames to fall on the other dragon. He bit down on the base of Smaug’s neck, drew his fire into his mouth, and exhaled. Smaug made a horrible, metallic squeal and rolled sideways. Bilbo smacked hard against the gold with Smaug’s half-melted scales glued to his teeth. Bilbo spat out the sizzling sludge as Smaug’s snout plowed into the treasure an arm’s length from Bilbo’s forepaws. Bilbo sprinted under the cascading coins, wings tucked tight, evading the larger dragon as Smaug snapped blindly.
Suddenly, a huge ruby sailed out of the darkness, striking Smaug on the shoulder.
“Slug!” Thorin shouted. “Layabout Under the Mountain!”
Bilbo and Smaug both turned, one with fear and the other in rage. Thorin stood atop a balcony with Balin and Ori. All three Dwarves held crossbows; something hunched beneath a tarp behind them.
Smaug inhaled and Bilbo pounced, releasing another inferno onto Smaug’s shoulder. Smaug shied; the shimmering waves blistered Smaug’s forelimb and the treasure beneath. As gold melted into thick runnels, so did Smaug’s scales, revealing angry pink skin.
“Your strength has clearly been overestimated!” Thorin gloated. “Braggart! Errand-boy of Morgoth!”
A jewel-encrusted goblet hit Smaug’s neck.
“Your mother was my left sock and your father was a peat-fire!” Glóin bellowed.
Bilbo whipped around, knowing before seeing that Glóin, Bifur, Fíli, and Nori were on the opposite side of the treasury. Oin, Bofur, Bombur, and Dori occupied another ledge a hundred yards distant, shouting insults of their own. Smaug paid them no heed: he stalked towards Bilbo, murder in his scarlet eyes. Bilbo backed up, preparing to take flight.
“Now!” Thorin shouted.
The Dwarves whipped the tarps off their contraptions, revealing three dusty ballistae loaded with javelins thicker than a Dwarf’s arm. The chamber echoed with hollow thuds. The bowstring of Glóin’s ballista snapped, nearly lashing him. One javelin sparked harmlessly against Smaug’s scales. The third—still trailing cobwebs—punched through the melted patch on Smaug’s forelimb.
The Dwarves’ cheers were drowned out by Smaug’s roar. His head snapped around, spraying fire across the upper chamber. The Dwarves scrambled for cover. Bilbo leapt onto Smaug’s back. Smaug bucked, his throat incandescent with the promise of retribution. Bilbo pressed his belly to Smaug’s back, soaking in his warmth, and exhaled a rippling blast. Scarlet rivulets ran down Smaug’s limbs. Another javelin stabbed through the exposed base of his wing.
Smaug smashed his cheek against Bilbo like a battering ram. Bilbo went flying, catching himself on bruised wings. Two more javelins buzzed through the stale air as Bilbo tilted his wings towards Smaug, who was lumbering towards Oin’s ballista. Smaug whipped his tail back as Bilbo approached. Bilbo dove low, his claws skimming the gold. Thorin’s ballista fired again. A black spike protruded from the freshly-melted patch on Smaug’s back. Bilbo targeted Smaug’s flank and belly, breathing until steaming scales plopped onto the floor.
The Dwarves on Glóin’s balcony unshouldered their crossbows—no doubt plundered from the dust-choked armories Bilbo had passed earlier—and took aim. Their quarrels found the raw skin newly opened along Smaug’s body. As Smaug writhed, Bilbo pitched under his neck and repeated his attack.
Bilbo could have laughed at his hoard’s ingenuity. With several avenues of attack, Smaug could not target any of them—and the more fire Smaug used, the warmer Bilbo remained.
“You will burn!” Smaug bellowed.
He smashed Oin’s ballista under his paw, then ignited the terrace. The Dwarves sprinted for cover. A tiny figure plummeted from the balcony: Dori, his coat aflame. He hit the gold and did not move.
Bilbo skidded to a halt beside the Dwarf and nosed him over, smothering his burning coat.
Dori groaned, then sat up, rubbing his head. “Did I leave the forge on?”
Bilbo dug his snout under Dori’s rear and flung the Dwarf upright, then looked behind him. Smaug had ceased pursuing the Dwarves and circled back to Bilbo. Crossbow bolts and javelins flew, but Smaug ignored the distraction and dove.
Bilbo pushed Dori, then slid between Dori and Smaug. Dori wailed as rolled down the steep pile of treasure. Fire bloomed from Smaug’s throat; Bilbo raised his wing as a rudimentary shield. The flames curled across Bilbo’s scales, leaving Dori untouched and Bilbo pleasantly warm. At the bottom, Dori stumbled drunkenly to his feet, swaying to face Smaug with nothing but his fists. Bilbo surged in front of Dori, baring his teeth and splaying his fans.
With a cavalcade of battle cries, the company poured down either side of the treasury, shooting their crossbows with deadly precision. Another javelin pierced Smaug’s wing, sending him off-balance. Thorin, Balin, Glóin, and Bifur ducked as Smaug careened over their heads, crashing through two pillars before toppling onto the treasure.
“He’s down!” Nori cried, charging forward.
“No,” Balin said. “Not here!”
“We need cover,” Thorin agreed. “Bilbo—”
Bilbo did not hear what Thorin meant to tell him. As Smaug heaved himself to his feet, Bilbo landed atop him, his talons carving bloody channels.
“Take the hoard!” Thorin shouted from behind him. “Take the gold and run! Into Erebor!”
The rill of gathered coins echoed around the treasury. Smaug twisted—oh, how Bilbo knew the agony of his hoard separated—and snarled as he witnessed the theft. Smaug aimed a kick at Bilbo, then turned to chase the Dwarves. Down the hallways they went, the Dwarves dodging gouts of flame by diving into doorways and behind columns, their pockets jingling with stolen treasure. Smaug howled and burned. With every step, more jewels slipped from his belly and more scales tumbled from his chest. The Dwarves found this as hilarious as it was terrifying: for the first time in over one hundred years, the halls of Erebor rang with laughter.
Bilbo hobbled after them. A dangerous chill numbed his toes and the tip of his tail; he dared not use his breath outside the unnaturally warm confines of the treasury. With great effort, Bilbo unfurled his wings and flew after Smaug. He rose above the larger dragon, then struck Smaug’s unprotected spine like a falcon. Bilbo’s talons grated against bone as he dug into Smaug’s flesh, but Smaug snaked around and seized Bilbo’s neck. The pain was everywhere—a seething collar ringing Bilbo’s throat. He curled up, his claws scratching Smaug’s lower jaw as he bathed Smaug’s snout in heat fit to boil Mount Doom. Even as scales ran like water down Bilbo’s back, Smaug did not release him.
A javelin flew out of the shadows, striking Smaug just under the eye, pinning lid to iris. Smaug dropped Bilbo, the reek of cooking meat lying heavily in the air. Bilbo struggled to his feet. Atop the nearest walkway was Bombur, looking faintly surprised at the empty ballista he had hauled out by himself. He was exposed on both sides. Bilbo’s heart dropped.
“Come on, Bombur!” Bofur shouted from the end of the walkway. “Time to go!”
Bombur took off, but Smaug had seen him. Behind Bombur pelted Bifur, ax-bladed head down as he sprinted. Bombur looked back, eyes wide. Bifur leapt forward, shoving his nephew into the safety of the column and Bofur’s waiting arms.
Bifur disappeared into the flames.
When something is taken, a raw emptiness is left behind: a wound so wide it will never heal, a void so deep it can never be filled. That void opened instantaneously for Bilbo. He seized in midair, tumbling to the ground. His talons hooked the edge of a corridor and he hauled himself up with the last of his strength.
Smaug whipped around, his eyes aglow with malice. Bofur and Bombur sought better shelter, their heads down to hide their tears. “You seem unwell, Skinchanger.”
“Where’s Bifur?” Thorin called.
“Bifur!” Balin shouted.
Bilbo’s knees were weak, his head light. “Spare the Dwarves. Let them escape to spread the story of your … your malevolence.”
“Only one need survive, then,” Smaug rumbled.
“You monster!” cried Dori. His quarrel ripped through Smaug’s wing.
Bilbo threw himself onto Smaug’s neck and bit down, his teeth grinding against the unmelted scales.
“You little rat,” snarled Smaug as he clawed Bilbo off. “You would protect—” Smaug laughed horribly. “They are your hoard, aren’t they?” He pinned Bilbo under his foot. “These Dwarves are yours.”
Bilbo squirmed between the black talons bracketing his throat.
“Then you will die last, after I have devoured them one by one,” Smaug declared. “There is no better punishment for a thief, a liar, and a traitor.”
“Now!” Fíli cried.
Bilbo looked up just as Fíli and Balin loosed the chains of a drawbridge suspended from the level above. The bridge cracked over Smaug’s head. He roared in agony, rocking back from the impact. Bilbo squirmed free and coiled himself around the larger dragon, raking his claws against Smaug’s stomach. Smaug buffeted him with his wings, throwing him into the far reaches of the hall. Bilbo caught himself on the wing, letting the updrafts from the bottomless expanse carry him. Quarrels whistled through the air from the scattered Dwarves, striking as often as not. The scales on Smaug’s spine, neck, and belly were largely gone; his wings were tattered; his snout had been roasted to bone; and his punctured eye dripped hot gobs of blood. Bilbo did not think about his own condition. Physical pain was nothing compared to that of Bifur’s loss.
“You fool,” Smaug snarled. “Your mortals will die and you will endure—alone, as you have always been, as you always will be.”
Bilbo aimed for Smaug’s eyes. Smaug snapped as he passed, catching his tail with enough force to shatter bone. Bilbo found Smaug’s throat and bit down, fracturing his superheated scales as Smaug rent Bilbo’s back and haunches.
They separated again. Smaug’s heat-shriveled lips peeled back in a permanent snarl. “Maybe I should let them live. They have seen my gold; it will drive them mad and you will go mad with them … but I am not so patient. They will die screaming.”
They collided in an exhausted tangle of limbs and scales. Smaug’s tail knocked a column onto Bilbo’s back leg. The breath left his lungs in a pained rush. Smaug limped a short distance away, his ribs hitching shallowly.
“I can count as well as any,” Smaug gloated. “There were eleven Dwarves, including your dead friend. Where have you stashed the other two?”
Bilbo leaned against the column.
“You wouldn’t have let them go far,” Smaug said. “They must be close, and safe … in Laketown.”
Bilbo looked up, his body tremoring with cold and fear.
“Laketown,” Smaug repeated, savoring the word. “Farewell, rat.”
Smaug took flight, dripping gold and scales. Bilbo rolled the column away, but his vision blurred and his legs refused to work.
“Bilbo!” Bofur cried, skidding to a stop beside him. “Are you alright? Oh, you’re in a bind, aren’t you?”
Bilbo took one step, then collapsed just as Fíli rounded the corner.
“Dori’s never here when you need him,” Fíli said. He and Bofur set their shoulders into Bilbo’s back and began to push. “Come on, Uncle Bilbo!”
The halls flared ahead, followed by Nori’s pained scream. Bilbo groaned. Neither grief nor terror could bestir his limbs.
“We need to leave,” Fíli blurted. “Thorin thinks we can leave by the East Gate.”
“We can’t,” Bofur said. “Not after … after everything.”
The note of desolation broke Bilbo’s heart.
“We lost Bifur,” Fíli said, his voice wobbling. “Bilbo’s injured. He needs the sun, and we need Kíli and Mister Dwalin.”
“There’s no sun down here!” Bofur said. “And if you have a way to summon Kíli and Dwalin, I’d rather you share it.”
Bilbo could barely see, but he knew Ori was the third Dwarf to join them.
“Well,” Ori said, “I don’t have the sun, but I have this…”
“How does that help?” Fíli demanded. “We can’t paint our way out of this!”
Something splashed on Bilbo’s shoulder. Flint and steel clicked together, and a yellow flame crackled to life. Bilbo’s eyes snapped open as the fire’s warmth trickled down his scales.
“It’s working!” Bofur shouted. “More paint! More oil!”
Bofur and Fíli dumped bottles of linseed oil, and Ori added more of his paints as the fire roared hotter and higher. Bilbo staggered to his feet, still aflame, and galloped on his three good legs until he gained enough momentum for takeoff. Smaug had used fire to trap Thorin, Glóin, Balin, and Bombur in an adjacent hall. Oin and Nori sheltered nearby. Nori had one hand clapped over his forearm and half his beard was missing.
Bilbo dealt Smaug a glancing blow and landed on the nearest column, his injured leg dangling. He bounded back for a second attack. Smaug abandoned the Dwarves, striking Bilbo with teeth and claws and fire, then continued towards the front hall. Bilbo followed, and so they came to the entrance, where the stones of the toppled gate were strewn like toys. Smaug shouldered through the rubble, flooding the hall with the humid summer air, and took flight with Bilbo in pursuit. The sun had set, leaving only flaming lashes against the purpling sky, and no memory of its heat. Flames leaked from Smaug’s jaws and ruined throat, but he did not waste his fire: they exchanged blows, lost altitude, then broke apart and soared higher again.
They were above the lake now, with Esgaroth a tiny point beneath them. Bilbo and Smaug locked claws with undimmed ferocity. Bilbo’s claws pierced the thin skin of Smaug’s left wing, tearing a line down its length as he flew by. Smaug’s leg shot out and seized Bilbo’s wing. They fell in tandem. The black waters of the lake rushed up towards them.
Two dragons fell into Long Lake.
Only one emerged.
Chapter 16: For Better or For Worse
Summary:
The company measures their grief against gold.
Chapter Text
When Bilbo awoke, he was lying on his side, one wing crumpled against his ribs and the other splayed across his outstretched limbs. His wings were tattered, patches of his scales were gone, his fangs were loose, and the tip of his tail was one stripe of agony. Worst of all, a great chasm had opened in his heart. Tears simply would not come.
A rough blanket descended over his flanks, then was just as quickly yanked off.
“He needs the sun, you wool-pated she-elf,” a Dwarf snarled.
Bilbo would know that voice at the end of the world. Both his eyelids slicked back. The sky was a featureless bank of clouds. A dark, half-bald silhouette loomed over him.
“Blink twice if you’re dead,” Dwalin said.
Bilbo blinked twice.
“He’s alive!” Kíli crowed. He hugged Bilbo’s snout, his cheek resting between Bilbo’s eyes. A moment later, Dwalin laid a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder.
Bilbo raised his head off the gravel, twisting to find Thranduil’s red-haired captain clutching a blanket knitted with trout. Behind her, a small campfire licked at a pebbled perimeter. Smoke rose from the center of Long Lake. The air smelled of lake, smoke, Men, and the peculiar nothingness of Elves.
Bilbo extended his neck towards the Elf. Her hand flew to the bow strapped across her back, but Dwalin guessed his intent: he swiped her blanket and flicked it over Bilbo’s flanks. Bilbo shrank into a Hobbit and clutched the damp wool around his shoulders.
“Fine time for you to develop a sense of propriety,” Dwalin complained.
“Where’s Smaug?” Bilbo demanded.
“He is dead,” said the Elf.
The last of the tension fled Bilbo’s muscles. He exhaled, letting his shoulders sag. Kíli stacked his waterlogged coat atop the blanket.
“Captain Bard shot him with a black arrow,” the Elf continued. “His aim was true—and Smaug had been sore wounded.”
“The c-company did that, by the way,” Bilbo snapped, his anger undermined by his chattering teeth. “The same people your king t-tried to arrest.”
The Elf’s eyes narrowed. “You woke Smaug.”
“Trust me, he wasn’t sleeping quietly.” Bilbo shuddered. “Bifur is dead.”
“No!” Kíli cried. Dwalin inclined his head.
Bilbo did not hide his tears this time.
“We have to get back to Erebor,” Kíli said finally. “Thorin needs us.”
“Aye.” Dwalin glared at the Elf. “You won’t try to stop us.”
Her hazel eyes flickered from Dwalin to Kíli, to the mountain overhead, then back to Bilbo. Her bow hand was stiff at her side. “My king ordered me to kill you.” Her voice hardened. “I have never failed a charge.”
“Bilbo saved Laketown!” Kíli exclaimed.
“There are many who will not see it that way,” she said.
“And they’d be wrong,” Dwalin growled. “Smaug was already awake. Laketown’s destruction was only a matter of time.”
“I cannot levy judgment on Laketown’s behalf,” the Elf said. “However, your dragon tried to kill my king and my prince—and that I cannot forgive.”
“I v-very much did not,” Bilbo protested, drawing the wet blanket farther around his shoulders. It was Dwalin’s turn to add his coat. “I was p-p-perfectly content to bluff my way past the oaf. He ordered the first blow!”
“Tauriel,” Kíli said, “you were there.”
“His death is the will of my king,” Tauriel said, but her hand moved no closer to her bow.
“While we’re debating my death, c-can someone tell me what happened after I fell?” Bilbo asked. “I certainly remember Laketown still being there!”
“It was,” Tauriel said, “when you fell.”
She explained that she had been guarding the Laketown jail when the sky had reddened with dragon fire. Captain Bard had called for an evacuation and Tauriel had freed her charges: Bard had needed Dwarven help to bolt the city’s last windlance onto his barge. Bilbo and Smaug had fallen into the lake—both dead, it had seemed, until Smaug had surfaced in Laketown’s main canal, breathing fire and swearing vengeance. Bard, Dwalin, Kíli, and Tauriel had sailed through the wake of his destruction with the windlance and a single black arrow. With Kíli’s arrow—fletched with the feathers of Gwaihir the Windlord—Tauriel had blinded the dragon, giving Bard the shot that killed Smaug.
“Too quick,” Bilbo snarled. “Too quick by half.”
“He is dead,” Tauriel said flatly. “I thought you had met the same fate—”
“Hoped,” Dwalin muttered.
“We found you in the lake,” Kíli said, “and hauled you back on Bard’s barge.”
“Bard left to rescue more of his people. We lit a fire and waited for you to awaken,” Tauriel concluded. She and Dwalin glared at each other. “They told me mere sunlight was the best medicine.”
“When there’s more of it,” Bilbo grumbled, shuffling his blanket and coats. “Well, many thanks for saving Dwalin and Kíli. I think you did the right thing.”
“The right thing would be to bring your head to Thranduil,” Tauriel said.
Kíli held Dwalin back and said, “You saved his life. Please let us go. Tell Thranduil we escaped.”
“I would never lie to my king, even if it would spare my life,” Tauriel said sharply. “Tell me your intentions towards the Woodland Realm.”
“None,” Bilbo said. “I have no intentions, good or bad, towards Thranduil. I only want to return to the company.”
“Us, too,” Kíli added. “We’re almost home.”
For some reason, this made Tauriel look away. “I have lived for many centuries and seen the true measure of evil.” To Bilbo, she said, “It is not here. My heart says I must let you go.”
“Thank you,” Kíli said, taking her hand. Tauriel stared at him in amazement. “Thank you, Tauriel.”
Dwalin rolled his eyes, but Bilbo was rather touched.
“I will tell Thranduil the truth.” A smile cracked Tauriel’s stern mask. “He knows two Dwarves and a dragon would be an easy quarry for his captain.”
“Lass, we’ve fought a balrog,” Dwalin bragged. “You’ll want to rethink that.”
Bilbo rose to his feet and returned his Dwarves’ coats. “Well, it’s a long hike up to Erebor. I’ll fly you both.”
“You’ll be seen,” Tauriel warned.
“Let them see!” Dwalin laughed. “Smaug’s reign is over. The King Under the Mountain has returned!”
Tauriel’s expression darkened, but she said nothing as Bilbo dropped his blanket and stretched extravagantly.
“Oh,” Bilbo said, “when we get back, tell Oin to cut off the end of my tail—all the bloody bits. I want it gone.”
“Will it grow back?” Kíli asked.
“Yes,” Bilbo lied.
He shed his skin and took full stock of his injuries. His hind legs were swollen, his back furrowed with Smaug’s claws, and the last foot of his tail still oozed blood.
Dwalin clambered onto Bilbo’s back behind Kíli. “Go slow. I don’t like—”
His jaw snapped shut as Bilbo leapt into the air, beating his abused wings until he and the two Dwarves ascended above the fog. Obscenities streamed from Dwalin’s mouth, then from Kíli’s when Dwalin gripped him too tightly.
As Bilbo rose, he caught sight of Laketown. Almost all the buildings were burnt or shattered, and a ghostly mist wended through the canals. Smoke choked the eastern shore, marking the survivors’ camp even before Bilbo noticed them washed up like so much flotsam. Bilbo was reminded of Dale, and shivered.
He snagged a wind blowing towards the Lonely Mountain, endeavoring to keep level as the desolation vanished under his claws. The Dwarves’ thighs tensed around Bilbo’s shoulders, and he thrummed with their anticipation.
Erebor’s ruined gates came into view at last. Five Dwarves were sorting the rubble, but looked up at the sound of Bilbo’s wingbeats and cheered his arrival. Bilbo folded his wings and sailed into Erebor’s front hall, landing gracelessly on three legs. Dwalin immediately tumbled from his back.
“We thought you’d died!” Glóin shouted, vaulting over the debris. Ori, Nori, Fíli, and Dori followed close behind. Kíli slid into Fíli’s arms, and the two brothers swung each other around in a motion that was both a heartfelt reunion and a celebratory jig.
“I saw you fall,” Ori told Bilbo, awestruck.
Bilbo shrugged.
“Killed Smaug all by yourself, didn’t you?” Nori said, slapping Bilbo’s foreleg.
“Bravo to our dragon!” seconded Dori.
“Where’s Balin?” Dwalin demanded.
“With Thorin,” Fíli said. He had Kíli pinned under his arm. “The others are looking for supplies. Bofur and Bombur are…” He hesitated. “We didn’t ask anything of them.”
“I’ll fetch them,” Ori said, but Nori stopped him.
“You’ll want to hear the story,” Nori said. “I’ll fetch them—and Bilbo’s clothes.”
Bilbo nodded. In truth, the idea of compressing his agony within a Hobbit skin was more than he could endure. He spread his wings beneath the rectangle of noon sun and laid down.
After Nori vanished, Glóin, Dori, Ori, and Fíli pressed Kíli and Dwalin for the details. News of Smaug’s death—suspected in Erebor, but unconfirmed—was especially welcome. Bilbo learned that the company had watched the battle from Ravenhill. The mist rising off the lake had hindered their sight and they had retreated after the last flames died. Bifur had been moved to the lower halls, and the search for both supplies and the Arkenstone had commenced.
“Don’t fret none about losing the Arkenstone, Mr. Baggins,” Dori told him. “Killing Smaug was a grand enough deed on its own.”
He dug his powerful fingers into Bilbo’s shoulder. Bilbo groaned in appreciation. The sun was not healing him as swiftly as he would have liked.
“Aye, we’re glad you returned at all,” Glóin said. “Thorin was fair beside himself.”
“What about me and Mr. Dwalin?” Kíli demanded.
“I wager he’ll be less enthused at two more troublemakers under the mountain.”
“Did Bifur have more family?” Fíli asked suddenly from his perch on Bilbo’s back. “I didn’t know him before the company.”
Dwalin shook his head. “Azanulbizar.”
The company fell silent.
The heavy tread of a Dwarven herd rumbled into the hall moments before the rest of the company. Bilbo, Dwalin, and Kíli were swarmed with questions and attention. Balin and Dwalin embraced in a ring of mail. Kíli all but leapt into his uncle’s arms. They pressed their foreheads together, then pulled Fíli in with them. The company celebrated Bilbo’s victory with affectionate—and painful—slaps to his mauled shoulders. Oin finally pushed them all away, even bashing Kíli over the head with his hearing trumpet.
“That’s enough of that!” Oin said. “The dragon’s injured! Get off him, you limpets! You’re blocking the sun!”
The Dwarves slid off Bilbo and moved a short distance away to hear Kíli and Dwalin recount their tale yet again. As Oin clucked over Bilbo’s wounds, Thorin approached.
“I thought you had died,” Thorin said, his voice breaking. He reached out, laying a hand on Bilbo’s neck, then gently guided Bilbo’s head down until he could rest his forehead against Bilbo’s. “I should never have doubted you.”
Bilbo hummed deep in his throat and closed his eyes. His company was here again, even if they had not survived Smaug unscathed. Most had burns and blisters; Nori—by far the worst—had lost all the hair on the right side of his head. And Bifur…
A jolt of agony unraveled his thoughts. He swiveled as Oin prepared to poke his tail a second time.
“A nasty break,” Oin announced. “I can’t even find bone.”
“He’ll heal,” Thorin said.
Dwalin stepped forward. “Cut it off.”
“Cut it off?” Oin demanded. “It’s in bad shape, but I think I can save it.”
“Bilbo said to cut off the bad bits,” Dwalin said. “It’ll regrow.”
“That seems unlikely,” Oin replied, clearly displeased at the upstaging. “Is that true, Bilbo?”
Bilbo nodded emphatically.
“There is no reason to amputate,” Oin said. “I know I can—”
“Do not remove his tail,” Thorin ordered.
“No, it’s alright,” Kíli said.
“It won’t make him lopsided?” Fíli asked.
“Good point,” said Kíli.
“Oh, by Durin’s reddest groin hair…” Dwalin yanked Glóin’s ax from his belt and brought it down on Bilbo’s tail. Bilbo yelped in pain and Thorin cursed as fresh blood spurted from the stump.
Everyone turned at the commotion, triggering a spirited argument between Dwalin and Oin, with the rest of the company taking sides. By the time Balin separated them, Bilbo was no longer bleeding and Nori had brought Bilbo’s pack. Bilbo returned to a shape with a mouth and hands, wordlessly donned his clothes—another child’s tunic, this one from Laketown—and belted Nagtelch at his hip.
Thus girded, Bilbo said, “Where is Bifur?”
Down, down, down the company walked, deep into the frigid heart of Erebor. Bofur, Bombur, Thorin, and Oin went first, bearing Bifur’s bier. The rest trailed after them in silence, their footfalls echoing until they sounded like an army.
Their tiny procession terminated at a blank wall. Balin hurried forward and muttered something inaudible into the rock. Thin seams suddenly lined the granite and the doors swung open, wafting a deathly cold over the diminished company. The Dwarves marched into the catacombs without hesitation, but Bilbo hung back. He knew that even the smattering of Khuzdul he had learned was an immense show of trust. Seeing their funeral rites was more than he wanted to presume.
Balin alone noticed Bilbo’s reluctance.
“Aye, this is no place for outsiders,” Balin agreed, his voice little more than a whisper. “Not even our most trusted friends have witnessed a Dwarf funeral. It’s no mark against you, Bilbo.”
“I understand,” Bilbo said.
Balin’s eyes crinkled sympathetically. “We’ll be up shortly. Don’t you worry about us.”
“I’ll, um.” Bilbo swallowed, his eyes hot. “I’ll look for the … the Arkenstone.”
Balin clapped him on the shoulder and hurried after the procession.
Bilbo climbed until he could no longer see the catacomb doors before stripping, stuffing his clothes into his bag, and winging up to the treasury. A sea of gold undulated before him, its buttery warmth tempered by the cold cost of victory. Its call was nothing to Bilbo now. Gold had no wishes, no needs; it did not speak or fight or crack tasteless jokes over dinner. Gold could not assuage a loss that dimmed the very colors of the world.
His hoard staggered into the treasury in ones and twos, rarely making it past the door before falling to their knees. A few scooped up coins and let them trickle through their hands. Others looked about vacantly. Bilbo could not watch. He slid away, then ducked out of the treasury altogether.
The sun had quit its noon perch, skewing a spear of pale light across the eastern end of the entrance hall. Bilbo settled atop the Dwarves’ half-finished wall and pulled his pack into his lap. He stared at it for several minutes, then withdrew the toy Bifur had given him just the day before yesterday. Bilbo probed Bifur’s loss like a missing tooth, worrying at the ragged edges until his mouth flooded with iron and salt.
Bilbo sniffed, then twitched his nose. He sniffed again, but the breath caught in his throat and a high, keening whine emerged, thick with tears. He curled forward over the toy, rocking on his heels, letting his grief flow freely and privately.
The sun set over Erebor’s western shoulder, plunging the vale into darkness. Bilbo heard Fíli’s steady clomp and hastily wiped his face. In that moment, he would have traded his fourteenth share for a single clean handkerchief.
“Bilbo,” Fíli called. “Uncle wants you in the treasury.”
Bilbo tucked the toy into his pack and started down the steps. “I assume you haven’t found the Arkenstone.”
“You’ll hear it from Minas Tirith when we do,” Fíli said.
They stopped on the stairwell: Bilbo descending and Fíli ascending. They searched each other for a long moment, then continued in opposite directions, brushing shoulders in silent camaraderie.
Bilbo descended into Erebor on Hobbit feet. From afar, he heard a gorgeous harp rippling up from the depths. Fearing enchantment, he hurried, but the scene greeting him was unlike the one he had left. The Dwarves were rolling in the gold, and tossing priceless gems back and forth like potatoes. Ori and Oin had found crowns of silver and mithril, and wore three apiece, along with so many necklaces they could barely turn their heads. Dwalin staggered under gilded armor and Dori laid on his back, waving his arms and legs like a fauntling in fresh snow. Nori sledded down the coins on a silver platter, crashing through a stack of cups that Bofur had erected to cheers from Glóin and Bombur. Kíli sat with a golden harp in his lap, richly embellishing a song they bawled like drunkards.
The sword is sharp, the spear is long
The arrow swift, the Gate is strong
The heart is bold that looks on gold
The Dwarves no more shall suffer wrong
Now we call over mountains cold
“Come back unto the caverns old!”
Here at the Gates the king awaits
His hands are rich with gems and gold
It was a martial reflection of the wistful melody they had sung under Bag End so many months ago. Bilbo’s heart fell.
“Here, dragon!” Thorin exclaimed from behind him.
As Bilbo turned, a necklace of luminous diamonds descended over his curls.
“The Gems of Lasgalen,” Thorin announced. “Thranduil will come for these.” He patted the center gem lying atop Bilbo’s sternum. “He will not have them.”
Bilbo met Thorin’s delirious, tear-clouded eyes for just a moment. Then Thorin was gone, weaving amidst the gold, spurning cheer and companionship as the rest of the company rapturously explored their spoils.
There was no place for grief in the Kingdom Under the Mountain.
Chapter 17: For Richer and For Poorer
Summary:
A storm brews outside Erebor.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
The vale of Erebor was disturbingly tranquil. No birds sang, no smoke rose from distant fires, no boulders tumbled down from the heights, and no rain fell. Clouds smothered the mountain like hot, wet blankets both day and night.
Bilbo, from his position atop Ravenhill, saw all, but what he saw was nothing. He had expected Tauriel to appraise the gates, Bard to seek shelter, or Thranduil to kill him, but it seemed like the wider world had forgotten the Lonely Mountain.
Bilbo rolled onto his back and wriggled, his scales rasping against the weathered stones of the old courtyard at just the right angle to slake his abominable itch. His scales were nearly regrown, but they would not fade to their usual oak green for a month.
His needs met, he curled up again, facing south towards Long Lake. Black and silver flickered across his vision and Bilbo looked up eagerly, his mind’s eye already filling in Bifur’s grizzled hair and beard. A raven settled onto a crumbled column and shuffled its feathers, head cocked. Bilbo considered roasting it out of spite, but he was on Ravenhill. The raven had likely been here first.
Suddenly heartsick, Bilbo leapt from the courtyard and soared into Erebor, managing the journey with only one flap of his wings.
“Anything?” Dwalin asked as Bilbo dressed.
“Nothing.” Bilbo glanced up to where the Dwarf stood guard. The armory had been emptied and the familiar curve of Dwalin’s tattooed scalp had been replaced by hard steel and gems. “Oh, I, ah, saw a raven.”
“Did it say anything?”
“Uh. No?” Bilbo pulled his Laketown jumper over his head. “Should it have?”
“Some can carry messages,” Dwalin said. “Thorin sent one to Dáin yesterday.”
“Who’s that?”
“Our cousin, Lord of the Iron Hills.” Dwalin leaned on his ax. “He’ll be here by week’s end with more than enough soldiers to keep Thranduil off our mountain.”
Bilbo crossed his arms. “You really think it’ll come to that?”
“You heard him.”
A week ago, Bilbo would have welcomed a rematch with Thranduil. Now, he only wanted peace. “Maybe we can negotiate with him. We have the mountain and his gems.”
“You did your part with Smaug,” Dwalin said. “We’ll deal with Thranduil. Thorin wants you in the treasury.”
Bilbo sighed as the usual state of affairs reasserted itself. “I’m sure he does.” He glanced up at Dwalin. “Has Thorin been … odd to you, lately?”
Dwalin did not answer immediately. “We haven’t been home in a long time.”
Bilbo did not press him for more. He picked up his cane and racked his brain for the proper Khuzdul farewell. “Galkhismêr.”
“Bifur taught you well,” Dwalin said quietly.
Bilbo’s stride hitched. The halls refracted the slip with cold mockery.
The Dwarves had rigged mirrors and lanterns across the treasury’s vastness, illuminating it for the first time in centuries. The company picked their way along like crabs, dark spots in the golden sea. No one looked up when Bilbo entered.
“Bilbo!” Thorin called from a higher platform. “Up here!”
Bilbo slung his cane over his back to free his hands as he fought for purchase on the treacherous coins. He was panting by the time he reached solid ground. He bent double, feeling the weight of Thorin’s gaze but no urgency to meet it. Finally, he brushed diamond dust from his threadbare jumper and straightened up.
As in Khazad-dûm, the Dwarves had assumed a more regal—and more arrogant, in Bilbo’s opinion—bearing. The Raven Crown had elevated Thorin to new heights, and he had traded his traveling clothes for ermine and silk, and his steel beads for gold. Bilbo was underwhelmed: his Arkenstone needed no framing.
“What passes beyond my domain?” Thorin asked.
“Nothing,” Bilbo panted. “I’ve seen neither hide nor hair of anything for days.”
“They will come.” Thorin’s lip curled. “Men. Elves. Maybe even wizards. All of them crave our kingdom.”
“Might welcome the wizard,” Bilbo admitted. “He might be rude and nosy, but he’s helped.”
“I have seen the tower of Orthanc and heard tell of the treasures within. Wizards are not immune to greed.” Thorin put a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “But let us speak of better things. How is your leg?”
“Almost healed,” Bilbo said, mirroring Thorin’s cheer. His ill mood would pass; it always did. “Nothing the sun can’t fix.”
“And what of your heart?”
“…Pardon?”
“We lost Bifur,” Thorin said. “You lost a piece of your hoard.”
Thorin was correct, but hearing Bifur referred to as a piece of Bilbo’s hoard seemed terribly crass. “I … I can’t talk about it. I’m sorry.”
Old anger tinted Thorin’s eyes. “The dragon took much from us both.”
The skeletons from the front halls had been moved to the catacombs, but the company found more dead in every corridor. Worse were the disembodied limbs or heads, or the Dwarves that Smaug had simply swallowed whole. Worse still was the empty space in the company’s bedrolls, and the too-tall spear that Bombur now carried.
Thorin suddenly bristled like an angry warg. “Glóin!”
From across the chamber, the red-haired Dwarf dropped the goblet he had been holding.
“We must find the Arkenstone,” Thorin told him. “We have no time to delay.”
“Aye, Thorin!” Glóin shouted back, and began sifting through the gold again.
“The work would go faster if they were not led so easily astray by cheap trinkets,” Thorin told Bilbo.
“They’re tired,” Bilbo said, which was the truth: the company’s exhaustion was his, too. “Or bored. They could be doing other tasks like fortifying the gates or hunting game. I saw a raven on Ravenhill. Dwalin said—”
Thorin’s hand closed painfully on his shoulder. “No task,” he whispered, “is more important than finding the King’s Jewel. Without it, I have no armies, no power. The title of King Under the Mountain is as empty for me as it was for Smaug.” Hot, covetous desire sparked his eyes. “I need it.”
Bilbo recoiled in disgust.
“What is it?” Thorin asked, his brows drawing close.
“Leg’s a little wobbly, is all,” Bilbo lied. “Lost my balance.”
“May I?” With Bilbo’s permission, Thorin took his cane from his hands. “I can find you others, made of steel and black iron. Such was the mastery of my forebears that their canes could support a cave troll, while remaining as light as a feather.”
Bilbo swiped his cane back. “Only poor gardeners blame their trowels.” Thorin’s unexpected tenderness had not quelled his unease—but neither did his anxiety stifle the pathetic fluttering in his heart. “I … I’ll be on Ravenhill.”
Thorin inclined his head. Bilbo took it as permission to leave. He had gotten a few yards when Thorin called after him.
“Have your plans regarding Erebor changed since Smaug’s death?”
Bilbo turned. “What do you mean?”
“You said you would travel,” Thorin said, the threads of some strange anxiety strangling his voice.
“I suppose I did.”
“Stay, Bilbo,” Thorin commanded. “Stay and see my kingdom restored to such great heights that even Khazad-dûm cannot compare.” Before Bilbo could respond, Thorin pulled a shimmering shirt from his robes. “Have this as a token of my regard.”
The corselet in Thorin’s hands would have fit a Hobbit perfectly, but that was not its most remarkable attribute: it was pure mithril. Bilbo almost tasted its worth, through both his draconic instincts and Thorin’s reverent presentation.
“You don’t need to buy my loyalty,” Bilbo said.
Thorin studied him through the pale rings. “Call it insurance.”
“No treasure has a greater hold on me than my hoard,” Bilbo reminded him.
“Then you will have no issue accepting.”
Long had Bilbo chased Thorin’s approval, only to be offered a mithril corselet and a place at his side in the same breath—and yet.
“I will stay in Erebor,” Bilbo promised, “as long as the company does.”
Hope broke across Thorin’s face like the dawn, but doubt shadowed his voice. “As long as the company does.”
Bilbo heard Thorin’s unasked question, but for all his bravado, he was not ready to answer. He reached out with grubby hands, unsure if he wanted to take the mithril or the Dwarf king behind it. “Thorin, I—” His head snapped up at the surge of irritation coming from Dwalin. “Something’s at the gate.”
Thorin’s hand flew to Orcrist. To the other Dwarves, he shouted, “To the gate!” As they scrambled for their weapons, he said to Bilbo, “I require your other talents.”
Bilbo stuffed the mithril unceremoniously into his pack and skidded down the gold, throwing his clothes atop the corselet. Finally, he took flight with his pack clasped in his back feet. He overshot Dwalin—who had been coming to warn them—and then Erebor’s gate.
The cause of Dwalin’s concern was apparent: Bard was riding towards Erebor. Something flashed below and Bilbo dipped below the clouds to investigate. The ruins of Dale had been flooded overnight by Laketown’s survivors, and the few possessions and livestock they had saved from Smaug. Mingling amongst them were Elves clad in the russet armor of the Woodland Realm.
Thranduil had come.
Bilbo returned to the battlements and alighted beside Thorin, his teeth bared.
“What is it?” Thorin asked.
Bilbo raised a talon and put it near his ear.
“Elves?”
Bilbo nodded.
“The Elves and Men have allied against us, as they always do,” Thorin said. “Let Bard see you. He should know what he stands against, ere he takes the mountain.”
“There’s no chance of that,” Kíli declared.
“Do not doubt the craftiness of Men,” Thorin snapped. “Make ready!”
The armed and armored company marched onto the battlements. Their burnished armor gleamed: a sampling of the treasury secreted below. Bilbo stretched to cover the rest of the walkway and rested his chin on the wall to peer over the makeshift crenellations.
“That’s Ginny,” Fíli muttered, and Bilbo realized that Bard’s mount was indeed the golden mare that Fíli had bought in Rohan and lost in their confrontation with Thranduil.
“She must be their bargaining chip,” Kíli joked.
“Or their weapon,” Fíli said.
“Quiet,” Thorin commanded.
Whether through acclimation or sheer dumb bravery, Ginny brought Bard right up to the wall. The former captain of the guards had swapped his threadbare red tabard for an equally ragged brown tunic, and added a sword to his longbow.
“Who are you that come armed for war to the gates of Thorin son of Thráin, King Under the Mountain?” Thorin demanded.
Bard dropped Ginny’s reins and opened his hands in a gesture of conciliation—or supplication. “Hail, King Thorin. I did not think to find you alive after Smaug’s awakening, but I am glad to see I was wrong, so that we might parlay.”
“Name your errand,” Thorin called down.
“I am here on the matter of fair settlement,” Bard said. “Smaug destroyed Laketown and, with it, our homes and livelihoods. More bodies wash ashore every day. Hundreds are wounded, sleeping under the sky with nothing more than the clothes on their backs. I have come to collect our share of Erebor’s treasure in our hour of need. We aided and sheltered you, and have reaped nothing but sorrow and ruin, though unintended.”
If Bilbo had been a Hobbit, he would have shuffled his feet sheepishly. There was justice in Bard’s speech, even if his words were rather insolent.
“By what right do you speak for them?” Thorin sneered.
Bard sighed. “King Girion was my ancestor. For that, and for slaying Smaug, the people of Laketown have chosen me to lead following the Master’s death.”
From his shadowed eyes and patchwork beard, it seemed royalty did not agree with the former guard. Bilbo’s king cut a much more impressive figure: terrible and noble as he glared down at Bard, poised to dispense mercy—and gold—to the suffering Men as if he were tossing scraps to a cur.
“You will not have it,” Thorin declared.
Bilbo exchanged looks with the company, as stunned as Bard.
“Dale and Erebor lived in harmony during Thrór’s reign,” Bard said. “Gold flowed freely between the mountain and the city. I would have those days return, but we cannot help you if we are scrounging for food!”
“The treasure belongs to Dwarves of Erebor, not to Smaug, and I will not parcel out the wealth of my people to pay for the dragon’s misdeeds.”
“Smaug ransacked Dale and the surrounding towns as well,” Bard objected. “Dale’s wealth is mixed among your own. Give us that much, so that we might feed and shelter ourselves before winter comes.”
Balin leaned towards Thorin, but Thorin waved him away.
“So long as an armed host sits on our threshold, I will accord you as foes and thieves,” Thorin said.
“I did not know what to expect when I approached,” Bard said, his gaze drifting to Bilbo.
“I am also of a mind to ask what share of the inheritance you would pay to our heirs and kindred had you found us dead—or undefended.”
“A fair question,” Bard said impatiently, “but a cruel one, and unnecessary, as we are not robbers and you are not dead.”
“And how you and Thranduil weep to see it,” Thorin snarled. “I will not negotiate with Elf-friends and their ilk. If that is all you came to say, begone! The wealth of Erebor belongs only to its king.”
Balin turned aside. Bilbo sensed a half-forgotten ache settling into the old Dwarf’s bones.
“If we do not reach an agreement, Thranduil will march against you,” Bard said.
“You forget,” Thorin said, “that we have a dragon.”
On cue, Bilbo yawned, letting the morning light play on his fangs. The company cheered and hollered insults as Bilbo’s gaze rolled over to Bard. He fixed the Man with what he hoped was an intimidating stare.
“Peace, Master Baggins!” Bard said, shielding himself from Bilbo’s sight. “Captain Tauriel tells me that you opened Smaug’s hide for the black arrow. For that, you have my gratitude. You vouched for Thorin in Laketown! I know his character, and yours. Do not let him use you.”
“Neither dragons nor kings need listen to Men,” Thorin said, to another round of cheers from the company.
Bard seized his horse’s reins, his shoulders tightening. “You gave us your word, Thorin! Your oath that you would give us what we were owed—”
“You are owed nothing!” Thorin roared. “While the Dwarves of Erebor labored and starved in exile, where were the Men of Dale? Rebuilding in the shadow of Thranduil’s hall, growing fat off your fisheries and trade! Get thee gone, whelp of Girion! There is no succor for you here!”
Bard cursed in frustration and wheeled Fíli’s horse back to Dale.
“Kíli,” Thorin said. The young Dwarf ripped his eyes from Bard. “Shoot the horse.” He turned to Bilbo. “Do not leave Erebor.” Thorin looked to the rest of the company. “Back to the treasure room. The Arkenstone is still missing.”
Half the company—Bilbo included—remained on the battlements after Thorin departed to share a silence punctuated by the retreating clop of Ginny’s hooves. Kíli inhaled sharply, drew an arrow, and shot it over the wall. A pained whinny sounded a moment later, followed by a thud and a curse.
“Nicked her flank,” Kíli explained to a horrified Fíli. “She threw Bard.”
Fíli nodded, mollified. “That’s my Siginmazn.”
“You disobeyed your king,” Oin told Kíli.
Kíli shrugged, then impatiently brushed his hair aside. “Fear not, Oin. I interpreted.”
Bilbo ensured the remounted Bard was far away before he shifted into his Hobbit form.
“Something’s not right here,” Bilbo said, stepping into his trousers. “Thorin would never go back on his word like that!”
“Tharbad,” Nori supplied, and was met with Dwalin’s fiercest scowl. “What?”
“Those Men cheated us, just as Bard cheated us,” Dwalin growled.
“And arrested us!” added Kíli.
“Bard is one Man,” Bilbo said. “There are hundreds on our doorstep, most having just lost the one place they call home to dragonfire. Who cares about rights when there’s … well, what’s right?”
“Nothing more than that Man deserves for allying himself with tree-shaggers,” Glóin declared, to general agreement.
“Thorin will negotiate,” Dwalin said, “after Thranduil is gone.”
“He’ll right himself when he has the Arkenstone,” Dori added.
“The people of Laketown can’t wait,” Bilbo said. “They have nothing.”
Fíli crossed his arms. “It does get cold up here.”
“And we did wake Smaug!” Bilbo said. “If you want to point fingers, I woke Smaug. And—”
“Sounds like he was a bit of a light sleeper,” Bofur said. “You shouldn’t blame yourself.”
“Come!” Thorin bellowed from within Erebor.
The remaining company obediently departed, save for Balin and Bilbo. Balin’s eyes shone with unshed tears.
“You’re right, Bilbo,” Balin said. “Thorin is not himself. There is a sickness on this gold and he has fallen ill.”
Bilbo frowned. “What do you mean, ill?”
“There is a curse on the Line of Durin,” Balin said. “Dragonsickness, we call it: an obsession with gold that consumes the mind.”
“No,” Bilbo said. “No, not Thorin. He’s just tired. We all are.”
“You saw how he spoke to Bard. I have heard those words before, from Thorin’s grandfather, Thrór. He had it, and we watched it destroy him. It was he who ordered us to retake Khazad-dûm at any cost…” Balin pressed a hand to his mouth. “I fear that Thorin would die before parting with a single piece of treasure.”
“No, he just did,” Bilbo insisted. “Look. He gave me—” Bilbo shoved the mithril shirt under Balin’s nose. “Trust me, if he was feeling particularly dragon-ish, he would not have done this. I can still reason with him.”
“I hope you can, lad,” Balin said. He wiped his eyes. “Or else there’s no hope for us.”
Bilbo watched him go, then shivered with a chill that had nothing to do with the temperature and everything to do with the wretched mountain. Smaug had dwelt here too long, fermenting in his malice and cupidity until it seeped into the very stones.
They have seen my gold; it will drive them mad and you will go mad with them.
If Balin and Smaug spoke true, threats against Erebor’s gold would only exacerbate Thorin’s belligerence. Bilbo had needed the deaths of two very dear friends and thousands of years to relinquish his hoard—but time was the one luxury the company did not have.
Bilbo took up his cane and limped straight for the treasury. The racket the Dwarves made while picking, kicking, and sifting through the coins concealed his passage. Working on a well-informed gut feeling, he climbed up to Smaug’s bed and burrowed into the gold. His fingers closed around something smooth and a shock sizzled all the way to his toes, like touching a doorknob in winter. He wormed his way free with his prize.
The Arkenstone was scarcely larger than his palm and heavy for its size. As Bilbo lifted the great jewel, its facets transformed the torchlight into a rainbow as dazzling as trapped moonlight. After hearing the Dwarves wax poetic for months, though, Bilbo was underwhelmed. He rolled the Arkenstone into his mithril corselet and tossed it into his pack before returning to the battlements.
There he stayed, even after the last rays of sunlight disappeared behind Erebor’s shoulder. He watched the fires ignite within Dale’s ruins—bonfires for burning Eru knew what, cookfires, and torches bobbing along the walls like fireflies. He watched, and saw nothing, for his mind was bent towards the company, obsessively counting and recounting them, poring over any emotion he gleaned from their minds. He felt grief, especially from the Ur brothers. He felt determination. He felt a spiky morass of exhaustion, fear, and anxiety. The hope they had kindled for Erebor’s future had been snuffed out.
The Dwarves periodically checked on him, but Bilbo remained a dragon until the evening deepened and Fíli finally approached. Bilbo took care to transform and dress before the prince arrived.
“Bombur’s fixing dinner,” Fíli said as he climbed. “Salted herring soup again. Don’t save me a bowl.”
“Do we still have biscuits?” Bilbo asked.
Fíli crested the top of the stairs. “Bofur ate the last one. Take it up with him; he’s coming to stand watch with me. And no Arkenstone, of course, but Uncle’s sure we’ll find it.” He glanced at the corselet bundled in Bilbo’s arms. “Is that mithril?”
“Fíli—”
“Hey there!” Bofur shouted up to them. “Does your arse ache yet, Bilbo? You’ve been on that wall all day!”
“The stone’s still warm,” Bilbo said, his hands reflexively tightening around the corselet.
Bofur stomped up the steps and leaned against the crenelations. Thus supported, he pulled out his pipe. Bilbo and Fíli both tensed in anticipation.
“Easy, lads,” Bofur said, laughing. “It’s empty.” He champed at the end. “Doesn’t mean I can’t pretend. I’ve had a lot of practice.”
“Share your secret,” Fíli all but moaned.
“The trick is imagination,” Bofur said, “but I doubt princes get much practice at that.” He shifted into a more comfortable position. “Did I interrupt you, Bilbo?”
Bilbo had wanted privacy, but wasn’t sure he would have another chance. He unwrapped the mithril. Fíli uttered a startled oath. Bofur’s unlit pipe dropped from his lips.
“You may have trouble sorting through all that treasure,” Bilbo said, “but you forgot you have a creature designed to root out anything of value.”
“Bilbo,” Fíli breathed. “Is that…?”
“The Arkenstone, or as near as I can figure,” Bilbo said grimly, rocking back on his heels. “You did a terrible job describing it.”
“No, that’s it.” Fíli reached for it. “It has to be.”
“What are you going to do with it?” Bofur asked.
“I’m giving it to Fíli,” Bilbo said, meeting the young prince’s eyes.
“I’ll give it to Uncle,” Fíli said. “He’ll be glad you found it.”
“No, Fíli,” Bilbo said. “Thorin is not himself. You know that—and Bofur knows it.”
Fíli snatched his hand back. “Keep it from him? But that’s … that’s treason.”
Bofur, too, had turned ashen. “To turn against one’s king is worse than kinslaying. Thorin would be in his rights to assume the worst of you.”
Fíli looked at Bilbo, his fright eerily underlit by the Arkenstone. “If I took it, I would be declaring myself King Under the Mountain. I’d never betray him like that.”
Bilbo appealed to Bofur. “You know Thorin isn’t in his right mind. If he gets worse, it could cost his life—all of our lives.” The Dwarves glared at him until he added, “I know you’d jump off a cliff if Thorin asked. I would, too. He’s more than earned my—our—respect and loyalty and … and love.” Bilbo took a deep breath. “But we can’t let him destroy everything we have traveled so far and given up so much to achieve. We can’t let him shatter his own dream—the very thing everyone has been working towards for nearly two hundred years!”
“With the Arkenstone, Thorin would unite the armies of the Dwarves,” Fíli said, his voice strained but proud. “We would chase Bard and Thranduil—”
“Bard does not have an army,” Bilbo interrupted. “He and his people are hungry—destitute, I might add, thanks to us. Thranduil is old and rich, and he has his allies. If you attack him, there will be retaliation, and if he attacks you, Dáin will kill him. And after Dwarves and Men and Elves shatter the North, orcs and wargs will feast on your bones.”
Bilbo tried for indignation, but Khazad-dûm’s fate imposed on Erebor too terrible to stoke his rage.
“Fíli,” Bilbo said, “I wouldn’t ask this of you if there was another way. I’m not saying you have to keep the Arkenstone forever. You don’t even have to tell him you have it. This … Thorin’s sickness … I might have a cure, but I need time.”
“You have a cure?” Bofur asked.
Bilbo spread his hands. “I know it can be overcome.”
Bofur recovered his pipe, then jabbed it at the Arkenstone. “Well, I’ll be honest, I can’t say Thorin speaks for me or Bombur when it comes to Laketown—or what’s left of it. Fíli, you’re my crown prince. I’ll follow you.”
“I’m barely an adult,” Fíli whispered. “I’ve never fought any battles or led our people.”
“You’ve a good head on your shoulders,” Bofur said. “I’ve seen that clear as crystal.”
“You don’t need to be Thorin to be a good king,” Bilbo said.
Fíli cautiously extended his hand and Bilbo gave him the Arkenstone. The King Under the Mountain trembled at its touch.
“Tell no one,” Bilbo warned. “Not even Kíli.”
Fíli hesitated, then nodded. “I promise.” He tucked the Arkenstone into his tunic. “I hope it never comes to this.”
“Nor do I,” Bofur said. “But if it does—” He bowed deeply “—you have my ax.”
“And whatever I can offer,” Bilbo said.
Fíli’s lips twitched. “I should’ve known you were serious the moment I realized you’d turned against Uncle.”
“Yes, well.” Bilbo rubbed his neck. “I should be getting inside. Let’s hope for tomorrow.”
“Night,” Bofur and Fíli chorused.
Bilbo descended the stairs, the hot weight of treachery burning in his breast.
Notes:
Translations
Galkhismêr — good guarding
Siginmazn — catapult
Chapter 18: In Sickness and in Health
Summary:
Thorin slips deeper into madness as both sides seek a resolution.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Bard did not return. The company welcomed the respite, but their king perceived a more sinister motive.
“The Elves are training the Dalefolk to march against us,” Thorin declared as he paced before the throne. His eyes darted to the cracked stone where the Arkenstone had rested. “And the King’s Jewel is still not found.” He turned with a rustle of copper silk. “We have been searching for twelve days. Where is it?”
“The treasury is enormous, my king,” Balin said, inclining his head. “As it is, we haven’t slept properly in days and our food is running low.”
“You can sleep when you’re dead,” Thorin snapped, “as we soon will be if I do not have the Arkenstone before Dáin arrives. I expect several thousand of his finest by the week’s end.”
“I could look for Dáin,” Bilbo suggested, “or bring news.”
“You are not to leave Erebor.”
Bilbo had not left the mountain since Bard’s visit; Thorin had insisted on keeping him close. Even in the throne hall, Bilbo had been stationed beside him, and Balin—Thorin’s own blood—stood below the dais like a supplicant.
“We will find the Arkenstone,” Balin promised.
“If anyone has found it and is withholding it from me…” Thorin descended from the throne, each footfall lending minatory weight to his words. “I shall be avenged.”
Balin did not meet Thorin’s eye. Bilbo’s heart ached for the old Dwarf.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said. Thorin’s head jerked sideways as his name died in echoes. “They won’t search well without sleep. Vision blurs, your hands shake, you forget things—all sorts of nasty stuff.”
“I have felt no such affliction,” Thorin said.
“They clearly lack your iron will.” He licked his lips. “Please, Thorin. I’m sure they’ll look twice as hard after a rest.”
The tension bled from Thorin’s shoulders. “They may sleep for an hour, if they must. Bilbo, with me.”
Bilbo scampered after Thorin’s long strides, smiling apologetically as he passed Balin and receiving only pain in return.
“You no longer use the cane,” Thorin observed as they walked—inevitably—towards the treasury. Balin trailed a few yards behind.
“A few days of basking and my leg’s as right as rain,” Bilbo said.
“And your tail?”
“I lied,” Bilbo admitted. “It’s not growing back.”
Thorin halted. “Never?”
“It was just a few inches,” Bilbo said dismissively. “I’m glad to be rid of it. Would’ve healed crooked anyway—and I’m told battle scars are quite impressive.”
“You do not require them,” Thorin said. “Thranduil and Bard have no doubt kept their distance because of your presence.”
Bilbo was too frazzled to preen. “Thank you.” He hiked a thumb over his shoulder. “Speaking of, I should return to the wall. I don’t fancy—”
“Stay,” Thorin said. He did not speak with the callous authority he had lately wielded. His voice was soft, almost doubtful.
“Of course,” he said. “As—as long as someone sufficiently frightening is standing watch. Dwalin, maybe, or Bifur, even though—” Grief sheared away the thought. “Never mind.”
Their silence was an unwelcome third as they entered the treasury.
“You have one hour of rest,” Thorin declared. “Dwalin, Kíli—guard the gates.”
“Where’s Bilbo?” Kíli asked, peering out from behind a column with his brother.
“He has other duties.” Thorin’s tone brooked no argument.
“Nothing’s wrong,” Bilbo reassured them. “Just a little cold and stiff. A stone wall isn’t the most pleasant place to spend a week.”
Fíli met Bilbo’s eye and shook his head. No improvement.
Bilbo reluctantly nodded.
Thorin scrutinized each of the returning Dwarves as if his red-rimmed glare could sear the Arkenstone from their pockets. He never answered their greetings, although few still solicited them. Most wordlessly collapsed atop the ledge they had camped on. Bilbo’s gaze lingered on the emptiness between Bofur and Bombur. He tucked another blanket around Bombur and hurried off.
He found Thorin along the western slope of the treasury, picking through coins as if they were as fragile as glass.
“I think the company searched here yesterday,” Bilbo said.
“They likely overlooked something in their carelessness,” Thorin said.
“You should sleep, too.”
“I am no stranger to exhaustion,” Thorin said, “nor hunger, nor thirst. I endured worse in exile.”
“You’re not in exile anymore. You’re home—you’re the King Under the Mountain.”
Thorin turned with the same ponderous menace he had displayed in the throne room. Any dragon could read him: this was a cornered predator.
“I cannot call myself that,” he snarled, “so long as I lack the Arkenstone.”
“You’re already a king to me,” Bilbo said, “and the rest of the company.”
“Do not speak to me of the company.” He lurched closer. “One of them has found the Arkenstone. One of them keeps it from me. One of them is false.”
“One of whom, Thorin?” Bilbo demanded. “One of your friends, your family? We’ve all risked our lives for you—Bifur died for you.”
“It was a mercy that he died before the rest embroiled him in their scheme.”
Bilbo suppressed the visceral urge to slap Thorin. He’s sick. He doesn’t mean it. “You should rest: the only dragon for leagues is me and I’m certainly not going to take anything.”
“That is why you have my utmost trust, Bilbo,” Thorin said hoarsely. “You alone of all the company.”
Bilbo propped his hands on his hips. “Now that is absolutely ridiculous. After all—”
Thorin approached with such rapidity that Bilbo’s skin erupted in scales, but Thorin only laid his ring-laden hands on Bilbo’s shoulders. “No earthly treasure can sway your loyalty. You alone still honor the friendship we forged.”
“What—?”
“Your bond causes you to think the best of them,” Thorin said with a king’s indulgence, “but my vision is unfettered: in their greed, they have forsaken our quest, and us, by denying me the Arkenstone.”
“Can’t we sort that out later?” Bilbo asked. “The people of Laketown—they’re starving and autumn’s coming, and you gave them your word. I gave them my word, on your behalf! Fine, yes, we can continue looking for the Arkenstone, but—”
“This gold is ours,” Thorin whispered, his eyes as lightless as Mirkwood, “and I will not part with even a single piece.”
“I want to part with it,” Bilbo insisted. “I want the Men to have their share—my share, if I must! I want to see the Erebor—and the Dale—you’ve been telling me about.” He felt on the verge of tears as he cupped Thorin’s face. “Please, Thorin.”
Thorin’s smile bloomed with the same cautious beauty as a morning glory greeting the sunrise. Once, Bilbo had ached to capture that beneath his lips—but that had been before Erebor, before Smaug, before Bifur’s funeral. Now, that same smile only deepened his dread.
“You have a tender heart, Master Baggins,” Thorin said. “You will see, in time, that all my actions were to protect it.”
Bilbo was so stunned that words quite failed him. If Thorin would not hear the truth, only lies remained. “I … no. It’s my duty to protect you and … and I need you to trust me now: you need rest.”
Thorin frowned. “I must keep searching.”
“I’ll do it.” Bilbo laid his hands over Thorin’s and pressed down, lowering them both onto the gold. “I’m a dragon. I’ll know the Arkenstone before I see it.”
They were kneeling across from each other now. Thorin half-heartedly sifted through the nearest gems, then jolted upright. “I cannot sleep. Not while these traitors—”
“I’ll be right here,” Bilbo soothed. “I won’t let anything happen to you.”
Thorin listed, his eyelids drooping even before his head hit Bilbo’s lap. The Raven Crown’s prongs stabbed Bilbo’s thighs as he combed his fingers through Thorin’s silvered hair.
“Stay,” Thorin whispered. His fear remained even as sleep took him. “Stay.”
Thorin’s scalp was feverish and his hair was slick with grease, but Bilbo could not stop touching him, could not stop soothing both Thorin and himself with the repetition. Bilbo would have taken this moment as his fourteenth share. He would have taken this moment every morning for the rest of their shared lives. Thorin did not need to ask: more than anything, despite everything, Bilbo wanted to stay.
Too short a time later, Kíli’s voice rang through the treasury. “Bard and Thranduil are back!”
Thorin leapt to his feet, swaying as he regained his balance. “Arm yourselves! They will not take Erebor without a fight.” To Bilbo, he said, “Do as you wish. You carry a king’s trust.”
Bilbo forced a smile and sprinted for the gate with Thorin. They arrived well ahead of the still-waking company, and stood with Dwalin to watch the host of the Woodland Realm march on the Lonely Mountain. Each Elf was armored and armed with a bow, spear, and shield. Thranduil—once again atop his elk—rode at their fore, dressed in burnished steel and an ostentatious crimson cloak. Beside him, Bard was even dowdier and grimmer than usual. The Men behind him carried weapons requisitioned from their trades: gaff hooks, smithing hammers, oars.
Bilbo looked to the east, to the rocky shoulder that Dáin would surmount, but the ridge was empty; vultures wheeled overhead. To the west, towering storm clouds marched on the mountain. Lightning flashed in their depths like sun off glass.
The company arrived at the gate and arrayed themselves around Thorin, who glared down with regal disdain as Thranduil halted his army a hundred yards from the Erebor. He and Bard rode up alone. Bard, Bilbo was amused to see, had retained golden Ginny, who sported a bandaged flank.
“Hail to the King Under the Mountain,” Thranduil said, his words dripping with contempt. “When Bard told me you had survived, I could scarce believe it. I had to see with my own eyes.”
Thorin gestured impatiently for Kíli’s bow. Kíli handed it over and Thorin nocked an arrow, aiming at Thranduil.
Bard began to back his horse, but Thranduil motioned for him to wait. He said, “Assuming you can count, you will see you are outnumbered by several thousand to … twelve, it seems.”
“Thirteen!” Bilbo yelled, sticking his head over the battlements.
Thranduil flinched. “I had not thought a dragon would keep company with Dwarves. How much as Thorin promised you? I guarantee he will not let you keep it.”
“Fancy words for someone who came for the Gems of Lasgalen,” Thorin retorted. “Withdraw your armies or I will have the Gems destroyed before your very eyes!”
“You’re outnumbered, Thorin,” Bard called. “Just give the people of Laketown what we are owed!”
Bilbo knew Bard’s mistake moments before Thorin stiffened, his fur collar rising like a wolf’s hackles. “The people of Laketown,” Thorin spat. “You are nothing more than a front for the pointy-eared snake at your side. Thranduil’s promises are as empty as his heart.”
“King Thranduil brought us food and offered us protection,” Bard said. “See reason, Thorin! That is all we require.”
“I am seeing,” Thorin said. His arms shook under the strain of the bowstring. “I am seeing more clearly than I have in days. My promise to you was made under duress. Men have ever been the cronies of Elves: they must kill or possess anything they cannot make themselves. My oath to you holds no more weight than the one Girion made Thrór!”
The company remained stony-faced at Thorin’s pronouncement, letting their silence stand as tacit support. Beneath their helmets, they found their unease mirrored in a dozen other faces. Bilbo was too far away to see Fíli.
“We are not here to revisit the sins of our fathers!” Bard shouted.
“Indeed,” Thranduil said, “else we would be here for many generations.”
“Aye, and most of that accounting would be yours, you faithless sprite!” Dwalin bellowed. The Dwarves roared in approval.
“But if we were,” Bard said, “Smaug’s first victims were not Dwarves, but the Men of Dale. Smaug lies dead in Long Lake. We held up our end. Now I ask that you hold up yours.”
“You claim you do not wish to revisit the past, yet stake your claim on the same foundation of sand,” Thorin said. The wavering arrowhead shifted to Bard. “I will not surrender even a single coin: not to you, not to Esgaroth.”
Bard spread his hands. “I have three children: Bain, Sigrid, and Tilda. They’re going hungry. Please, Thorin.”
Thorin’s head half-turned to the east as the rain began. “Your pleas do not stir me. I will not parlay with robbers!”
“Pengryn,” Thranduil commanded. Rows of Elves nocked arrows in one synchronous click. The company—Bilbo included—ducked, but Thorin remained standing, his eyes blazing with the madness of a snared fox. Bilbo signaled Fíli. Fíli shook his head frantically.
A rumble deeper than thunder juddered the very stones of Erebor. Pebbles tumbled from the heights, forcing the company to shield themselves. Bilbo peeked over the wall just as three gargantuan worms retracted into the holes they had bored in the eastern cliffs. Seconds later, hundreds of wargs poured forth in a vile flood, coursing towards the Lonely Mountain. Thranduil rode before his army, shouting orders over the thunder and war drums. The Elves swiftly arrayed themselves to face the threat. Bard led the Men back to undefended Dale. Both armies seemed pitifully few against the orcs.
Thorin thrust both bow and arrow back at Kíli, aglow with vindictive satisfaction.
“Come,” Thorin commanded, turning back to Erebor. “Let the scavengers scrap on our doorstep. Should they gain entry, every hall will be bought with blood.”
Bilbo did not ask whose blood; he traded a look with Bombur that suggested he was equally uncertain.
The company straggled after Thorin, casting nervous glances at their abandoned wall. Fíli and Bofur whispered with each other until Dwalin chivvied them along. Bilbo saw Balin eye the pair speculatively.
Bilbo jogged up to Thorin and caught him by the arm. “Thorin, this is madness. People are dying out there.”
“Thirteen cannot change the tide of battle,” Thorin said, unperturbed, “but we can hold these halls as well as a hundred.”
“Imagine what Thranduil and Bard’s armies could do from a defensible position,” Fíli said. “You must let them into Erebor.”
“Think, Fíli! The Elves and Men will seize our gold.”
The company muttered fitfully, their voices overlapping and blurring into disconnected syllables. From without, they heard the clarion call of the Elvish warhorns and the bells of Dale, and precious little else. Bilbo’s imagination supplied the screams of imminent battle, the rain pounding the heath, and the clash of weaponry.
“We need Dáin,” Balin said. “If we knew where his army is—”
Bilbo raised his hand. “I could go. If he isn’t far—”
“No,” Thorin said. He leaned into Bilbo. “I have need of you here.”
Bilbo shivered at the closeness of his mouth, but a metallic bugle cut through his complacency. The sound wrenched him back to the plains of Dagorlad, to tides of orcs streaming out beneath him in response to that same sound.
“The Men of Laketown are out there, too!” Bofur cried.
“We cannae sit on our hands,” Glóin agreed, hefting his war hammer.
“Let Bilbo find Dáin,” Dwalin urged Thorin. “He can’t be far.”
“Why must you doubt me?!” Thorin roared. “I am your king!”
“No, Uncle,” Fíli said. All eyes snapped to him as he pulled the Arkenstone from his surcoat. “I, Fíli, son of Dís, am King Under the Mountain.”
The terrified tremble of Fíli’s armor was the only sound in the sudden hush. His face had gone as pale as his hair, but the Arkenstone burned ethereal in his eyes. Opposite him was Thorin: dark and utterly still, swallowed like a pebble in a well by Thrór’s crown and robes and armor.
“It can’t be,” Thorin said at last. “This is a trick. Or a lie. You … you would not betray me.”
Thorin looked wildly to Balin for confirmation.
“Fíli holds the Arkenstone,” Balin said heavily. “Of that, there is no mistaking.”
“You,” Thorin breathed, his eyes shining with tears. “You would dare… After all I have done for you…”
“I love you, ’adadith,” Fíli said, his voice cracking, “and I would follow you even to my own death, but you are not yourself!”
“Give it here,” Thorin ordered, “ere I cut it from your hand.”
Fíli clutched the Arkenstone to his chest. Any chance of a peaceful resolution evaporated before Bilbo’s eyes as Thorin drew Orcrist. The company shrank back, but Fíli did not relinquish the Arkenstone or defend himself. One of Kíli’s hands hovered on his bow, the other over Fíli’s shoulder, his expression wretched with indecision.
“Fíli,” Dwalin said softly. “Give it to Thorin, lad. There’s time to fix this.”
“Thorin is not himself,” Fíli told him. “Can’t you see that?”
“He is our king,” Dwalin said, but doubt colored his voice and he withdrew, frowning.
“I see a grasping parasite, eager for glory and wealth beyond his station,” Thorin hissed. “You are no heir of mine. Kíli, take it from him!”
Kíli positioned himself between Thorin and his brother. “Fíli’s right. This is not you.”
Thorin drew up short, but did not sheathe Orcrist. “Anyone?!” He spun wildly towards the terrified company. His gaze fell on Bilbo. Even now, vulnerability lingered in his eyes. “Not even you?”
Bilbo’s every instinct exhorted him to defend, to tear throats and rend limbs, but he was powerless when his hoard had turned against itself.
“I know what the Arkenstone is doing to you,” Bilbo said. “I know it calls to you.”
“Thorin,” Balin said. “Do not follow your grandfather.”
The pain in Thorin’s eyes mutated into hatred. Thorin had never looked at Bilbo like that, not even on the Barrowdowns.
“It’s not right,” Glóin said to no one. “We can’t have two kings.”
“There is only one king,” Thorin growled, “and he will have his due.”
A scuffle erupted behind Bilbo as Oin attempted to wrest the Arkenstone from Fíli. Kíli wrestled the old Dwarf aside with Bofur’s help, and then Dwalin plowed into the fray—on whose side, Bilbo could not say. Glóin sprang to his brother’s defense, only to be halted by Bombur, who held Bifur’s spear to his throat. Ori tackled Glóin. Balin dithered. Dori hauled Nori away from the confrontation by the arm, then reached for Ori. Bilbo dodged a stray punch and positioned himself between Thorin and his company.
“You’re tearing the company apart!” Bilbo told Thorin.
“There is no company,” Thorin snarled, grabbing the front of Bilbo’s shirt. “Only a band of brigands and thieves—and you. As if I could forget that we traveled with a dragon! I scarcely slept as I anticipated you murdering us all, kulkodar.”
The solution appeared with utter clarity. “Then kill me.” Grief had sundered Bilbo’s first hoard-bond; he could only hope that Thorin would mourn a dragon as acutely as Bilbo had mourned the Bagginses. “If I’m a monster, then kill me.”
“I won’t let you,” Balin said from behind Bilbo. “Thorin, this is not you.”
Dwalin—pinned between Kíli and Oin—made an inarticulate noise of fury. “Don’t you dare kill him! He isn’t our enemy!”
Thorin jerked back. The sounds of the fighting company died away. Bilbo felt Fíli trying to push him aside, but Bilbo held his ground.
“You are not Thrór,” Balin said. “You are our king.”
Thorin was blinking fast, his armor clanging with each heaving breath.
“I gave the Arkenstone to Fíli,” Bilbo declared. “It was me, Thorin: I caused this.”
Thorin leveled Orcrist with Bilbo’s heart. Were this truly a battle, Bilbo knew he could defeat Thorin, but his bloody days on Dagorlad had passed. The hunger clawing at his chest was no longer Orcrist’s loss, but Thorin’s presence: the knowledge that his own love would be the death of him.
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin snarled. “I will kill you, dragon, and be avenged.”
“Bilbo is not Smaug,” Bofur said. “We aren’t your enemies!”
“Uncle,” Fíli whispered. “Don’t do this.”
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin repeated, softer this time. Orcrist wobbled in his grip.
“You’re our uncle,” Kíli added. “Thorin, please. We need you.”
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin repeated a third time, the embers of madness banked with growing dread. Bilbo captured his gaze and refused to look away, silently willing Thorin to do the same.
Dwalin carefully stepped around Bilbo and uncurled Thorin’s fingers from Orcrist. The Elven sword clanged to the ground. Everyone flinched. Thorin’s white-rimmed eyes shot from Bilbo to Dwalin.
Dwalin jerked his chin to the battlements. “Look.”
Thorin went, his movements slow and dreamy, with Dwalin a step behind. Bilbo picked up Orcrist and followed them, and the company trailed after. Only Dwalin and Bilbo mounted the battlements, where Thorin gripped the slick stone as he bore witness to the scene beyond.
The battle had scarcely begun: a vanguard of warg riders lay dead or dying on the eastern slopes, pierced with Elvish arrows. The main army was now marching from the heights. Thranduil’s archers took aim, barely thinning the ranks before the orcs slammed into the Elves’ pikes like a fist. Through the rain, something moved atop Ravenhill: a twisted weathervane hung with flags that were little more than blurs. A second host rushed from the burrows, outflanking the Elves towards Dale.
Thorin’s fingers curled around the Raven Crown. Bilbo, Dwalin, and the company watching below held their breath. Then, suddenly, he tore the crown from his head and hurled it off the battlements.
“Thorin?” Dwalin asked.
Thorin turned from the battle breaking outside his gates to his stricken company, lingering on his nephews.
“What have I done?” Thorin whispered.
Notes:
Khuzdul Translation
‘adadith—uncleSindarin Translation
Pengryn—archers; singular, pengron
From Sindarin peng (bow for shooting; Tolkien’s Etymologies pp. 366) and -on (occupational suffix). Invented by mudkippy. Note an “R” was added to improve phonetic consistency with known Sindarin words.
Chapter 19: ’Til Death Do Us Part
Summary:
The Battle of the Five Armies is fought.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Thorin looked down on the company with newfound horror and uncertainty, and they regarded him with equal wariness.
“Fíli,” Thorin croaked.
Neither Fíli nor Kíli moved or speak, even when Balin nudged them. Thorin swept down from the battlements, nearly tripping over his robes in his haste. Bilbo and Dwalin gave chase, and Balin half-drew his sword, but Thorin only knelt before Fíli and said, “The Arkenstone belongs to you, my king.”
Fíli immediately pressed the jewel into Thorin’s hand. “Uncle, no. I didn’t—I’m not ready—”
Thorin folded Fíli’s fingers over the Arkenstone. “You have proven your wisdom.”
Fíli’s tears fell freely. “I can’t be king yet.”
“If that is your wish,” Thorin said. “But I knew it before and I know it now.” He looked between his nephews. “You will be great kings.”
Kíli threw himself into Thorin’s arms, Fíli following a moment later.
“Not yet,” Fíli sobbed, his words muffled by Thorin’s shoulder.
“You’re back,” Kíli said.
“I’m sorry,” Thorin whispered. “I have not been myself.” He raised his head to address the company. “The gold has crept into my mind, poisoning me against those I hold dearest. No longer will I cower behind these walls while others die for our mountain. Du bekâr, sons of Durin!”
The company answered with a resounding roar and immediately began shucking their heaviest armor and reorganizing weaponry. Kíli squirmed as Fíli pulled the mithril shirt over his head. Dwalin helped Thorin exchange Thrór’s gilded armor for a mail hauberk. Bilbo and Nori were recruited to unbuckle Oin’s extraneous plates. Oin only knew half the Westron words for armor and Bilbo knew none at all.
Oin left to swap axes with Glóin and Nori to fix Dori’s braids, abandoning Bilbo with an armful of cuisses, poleyns, kannbundshumâr, and Mahal knew what else. Thorin stopped beside him, his features awash with the unsaid.
“Not now,” Bilbo said. “We have a battle to win.”
Thorin inclined his head. “Ori! Kíli! Tell me what you see of the battle.”
The young Dwarves bounded up the battlements. A moment later, Kíli said, “Thranduil and Bard have pulled back to Dale. The orcs have them trapped!”
“Any sign of Dáin?”
“None,” they chorused.
“What of Azog?”
“No sign,” Ori said a moment later. “He knows we’d run him through the moment he showed his ugly face!”
“No, he’s smarter than that,” Dwalin said.
The metallic horn that they had heard earlier overwhelmed the rain again. Oin pointedly removed his hearing trumpet.
“Where is the awful ruckus coming from?” Dori demanded.
“Ravenhill,” said Kíli.
“There’s some kind of contraption on the ridge,” Ori added. “I can’t quite make it out…”
“You’ve done enough,” Dori said. “Get down from there!”
“Azog must be on Ravenhill,” Thorin said. A mad light glinted in his eye. “I will end that filth myself.”
“Not alone, you won’t,” Dwalin said.
“I would not ask—”
“We know,” Balin said. “That’s why we’re going with you.”
“What about Dáin?” Nori asked. “We’ll need more than thirteen axes to defeat an army.”
Bilbo noisily dropped Oin’s armor. When he had the company’s attention, he stretched dramatically, cracking his neck both ways.
“Twelve axes, and a dragon,” Bofur corrected.
“About time you remembered me,” Bilbo groused. “I’d very nearly decided to nip back to Hobbiton.”
“You wouldn’t miss a fight like this!” Kíli exclaimed, hopping down from the parapet.
Bilbo grinned with teeth sharper than any Hobbit.
“If Dáin is coming, he should be close,” Balin said. “Very close, I wager.”
“Then he’ll either appear in time to save our skins or too late to make a difference,” Dwalin said. “I’m not waiting to find out.”
Bilbo climbed the wall to stand between Ori and Thorin. Dale was visible only as a hazy, red-roofed mass surrounded by brambles of black armor. The crude sigil on Ravenhill—and Ravenhill itself—had vanished into the storm. Insubstantial sounds penetrated the rain: howls, clashing metal, and thrumming bowstrings.
Scales overtook Bilbo’s skin and he fell to all fours, his clothes splitting as wing membranes rippled down his sides. He had not taken the field in millennia, but he would make his second outing no less memorable than his first.
He glided down from the battlements and waited before the makeshift wall until the Dwarves rappelled after him. Rain trickled down his scales and pinged off the Dwarves’ armor as they assembled from the charge. No one spoke; there was nothing to say. At last, Thorin strode forward. The company matched his quickening pace. Kíli swung onto Bilbo’s back mid-stride and they took flight as the Dwarves below gained speed and momentum, their line sharpening into a chevron with their king at its apex.
The company plowed through Azog’s first four lines like an avalanche. Bilbo extended his front claws and mowed down the surprised orcs as Kíli’s arrows threaded his wingbeats. Bilbo seized several orcs and ascended, dropping his captives at a deadly height. Lightning flared as he dove towards the orc line, shielded by his speed and the rain. The orcs scattered, their heads angled skyward even as the company hewed them down.
Bilbo followed the direction of the charge towards Dale. Trolls rampaged through the lower level and the Elves and Men was losing the heights to orcs.
“There!” Kíli exclaimed. He shifted on Bilbo’s back. “It’s Tauriel!”
Bilbo spotted a rusty flash on the outer ring of the city. Tauriel and Thranduil’s son fought back-to-back, dead orcs heaped at their feet and still more piling onto the parapet. Kíli’s arrow slayed the orc dueling Tauriel and she looked up, her eyes shining.
Bilbo cleared the orcs from the battlements. Something seized Bilbo’s tail and he landed atop the dead orcs, nearly crushing Thranduil’s son. Bilbo twisted, claws out, as arrows whizzed past his shoulder. The grip on his tail released and a runty troll that had been clinging to the wall below fell with one of Tauriel’s arrows in each eye. Bilbo looked back at her, only to find an Elven arrowhead inches from his snout.
“Hold, Legolas!” Tauriel ordered from behind him. “He is not our—”
An orc tackled her off the parapet. Tauriel arrested her fall with one hand, desperately clinging to the rain-slicked stone.
“Tauriel!” Kíli shouted, jumping from Bilbo’s back.
Bilbo scrabbled along the exterior wall, around Legolas and Kíli, and swung onto the walkway in front of Tauriel. He turned into the oncoming orcs, weaving around halberds to maul their holders. Two boots alighted on Bilbo’s back and Elvish arrows flew until the battlement was empty.
Legolas hopped from Bilbo’s back to join Tauriel, who had since recovered her footing. Kíli fussed over her abraded palms.
“You fight with us, then?” Legolas asked Kíli.
Bilbo hummed and Kíli said, “We’re all on the same side now. We’re going to Ravenhill to kill Azog. Please, help us if you can.”
“Where should we go?” Tauriel asked.
A cry rose from the beleaguered city: “The Dwarves! The Dwarves are coming!”
“The front gate,” Kíli said, scrambling onto Bilbo. “Thank you!”
Bilbo took flight, eager to rejoin the company. Orders trumpeted from Ravenhill and trolls thundered out of the ruins to block the bridge. Bilbo veered into the outermost troll, planted his claws in its side, and tore out its throat in a fountain of black blood. Elvish arrows whistled from the heights and the trolls shielded their eyes, blinding them to Bilbo’s attacks. He caught three more trolls unawares before coming against one wearing plate armor. His claws found no purchase on its wet backplate and he was forced to roll back as the troll swiped at him with steel claws welded to its knuckles. Bilbo felt Kíli stand on his back, his weight tipping forward as he thrust an orc halberd into the troll’s eye.
The orcs sprinted forward to fill the gaps between the dead trolls. This time, no archers came to Bilbo’s rescue: the orcs closed until Bilbo’s nostrils curled with their stink and Kíli was forced to draw his sword to fight them off. Bilbo raised a wing to shield him from arrows, then swung around, his tail snapping a forest of shins. The orcs trampled their dead and injured, their yellow teeth bared as they grabbed Bilbo’s wings. Some pulled themselves onto his back and he bucked, desperate to shed their weight.
The orcs’ jeers were suddenly drowned by Khuzdul battle cries. Dwarvish boots thudded up Bilbo’s spine, then pressed down for a final leap as Thorin soared into the orc lines, Orcrist flashing in the lightning. Fíli followed his uncle exactly; Kíli abandoned his seat to defend Fíli’s left. Ori rushed under Bilbo’s belly, then barreled into the orcs, warded by Nori and Dori. Dwalin headbutted an orc jabbing at Bilbo’s wing and hurried on, granting Balin the killing blow. Bilbo surged after them, feeling the rest of the company follow. Bilbo defended them where he could, but more often than not, they were protecting him: killing archers, deflecting pikes, turning blades.
The Dwarves chased the routed orcs into Dale, with nearly two hundred Elves and Men rescued from the battlefield hurrying on their heels. Bilbo saw Kíli watch the company go, then fight through the crush to remount Bilbo. Bilbo waited until the Men had passed, then took flight.
“Let’s not do that again!” Kíli declared. Bilbo’s body ached in agreement. They were not foot soldiers.
They swept Dale ahead of Thorin, targeting archers and trolls. The trolls were easy to find, and oblivious to their impending death until Bilbo and Kíli were on them. The orcs, on the other hand, quickly learned the dragon was not their ally: they hid in buildings and down alleys too narrow for his wings, emerging only to pepper him with arrows.
Even amidst his frustration, Bilbo noticed the battle was turning—and not for the better. There was an unseasonable bite in the air as the rain continued to roar down. Children scurried underfoot, shepherded around the battlefield by fear-blind minders. Orcs, Men, and Elves alike slipped in the blood, water, and guts. Arrows fell haphazardly as wet sinews released too early or too late, and stones hurled from the war machines crushed indiscriminately.
Bilbo finished his pass and soared high to monitor Ravenhill. Kíli, ever restless, began yanking arrows from Bilbo’s scales. He was removing a particularly fiddly shaft when Gandalf’s voice boomed in Bilbo’s head.
There you are!
Bilbo nearly fell out of the sky in shock. Kíli yelped as he lost his seat; Bilbo tilted sideways to save him. Here I am?! Where have you been?! Tardier than a Brandybuck, as usual!
Gandalf did not rise to the bait. Is Thorin with you?
He’s in Dale with the company, Bilbo said. He’s trying to get to Ravenhill to kill Azog, but…
Bilbo trailed off as a boulder sailed into a tower sheltering several of Bard’s archers. They screamed, their deaths lost in the rain and collapsing stone.
So he plans to finish what he started all those years ago, Gandalf said.
If he can get there! Bilbo snapped. Dale is a death trap.
It is, Gandalf said. That confirmation chilled Bilbo to the bone. But if we are smart and careful, and in no little part lucky, it might be Azog’s. Do not despair! Destroy the siege engines. I will do what I can for Thorin.
If Gandalf was indeed nearby, Bilbo trusted the wizard to honor his promise. He winged past Dale’s walls, where teams of trolls strained to free the siege machines bogged down beside the overflowing Celduin. The battering rams and siege towers were harmless at a distance, but the catapults and ballistae were still within range.
Bilbo tucked into a dive, plowing through the orcs surrounding the least-guarded catapult. The surviving orcs held him at bay with their spears, jabbing his sensitive wings. Kíli dismounted and slashed at their legs, and Bilbo picked off the wounded.
As Kíli slaughtered the remaining orcs, Bilbo set his shoulder against the catapult, slipping and straining until he heard a glutinous pop as the wheel came free of the muck. The catapult overbalanced and fell, crushing a troll beneath it. Kíli hopped into the catapult, slicing any rope in sight, then scrambled back onto Bilbo to repeat the process.
Bilbo had just finished dismantling their fourth catapult when Kíli turned to him with a frown.
“Are they out of Dale yet?” he asked. “Is Fíli alright?”
Bilbo shook his head, then nodded.
Kíli wiped his sword on a dead orc’s tunic. “It’s taking too long.”
Bilbo nodded.
“What if we went up to Ravenhill right now?” Kíli asked. Bilbo shook his head. “Come off it! Between you and me, Azog wouldn’t stand a chance!”
There was no eloquent way to convey that Bilbo knew an orc captain would never travel alone, so he merely hissed.
Kíli scowled. “Then let’s—” His eyes suddenly widened as he looked past Bilbo. “Look out!”
Bilbo turned to see a company of goblins sprinting towards him, bolos whirling above their heads. He instinctively leapt back, slipping on the mud. The foremost goblins released their bolos. One set tangled his forelimbs; another wrapped around his left wing, bruising the membrane. Bilbo grabbed Kíli’s shoulder with his back leg and took flight. The goblins sprang after him; several seized his tail fans. Bilbo felt them climbing up his spines and flicked his tail, to no effect: they scuttled up his back and began hacking at his wings.
“Drop me!” Kíli yelled. “Drop me, Bilbo! You’ll catch me! I know it!”
Bilbo flew higher and released Kíli, then immediately dove under the falling Dwarf. Kíli latched onto Bilbo’s neck, then sprang off Bilbo’s leg-up and onto his back. Bilbo heard Kíli draw his sword, then the crunch of metal through bone. Goblins screamed and fell, until Kíli stood unchallenged. Bilbo leveled out to let Kíli slice the bolo off his wing.
From above, the battle looked even more dire: orcs were pouring into Dale faster than Thorin was advancing. Worse, Bilbo noticed a new host marching down Erebor’s eastern shoulder. They marched in orderly lines, their legions demarcated by scarlet banners. Behind the heavily-armored foot were cavalry; even from a distance, Bilbo knew they were not on horses.
“That’s Dáin!” Kíli exclaimed. “And the host of the Iron Hills!”
Bilbo stiffened his wings, the winds holding him aloft as they watched Dáin’s cavalry mop up the orcs scattered between Dale and Erebor. The foot continued towards Dale, their singing audible above the rain.
“We have to tell Thorin!” Kíli said.
Bilbo winged towards the battle. I hope you’re listening, you damnable wizard, because Dáin is on his way to Dale with half the Iron Hills.
Ironfoot, Gandalf said, sounding both irritated and relieved. Stay out of his sight. We may win this yet.
At the cry of the war-horn, orcs streamed out of Dale to oppose Dáin.
“That’s not good,” Kíli said.
Despite the warning Bilbo had just received, he hummed in agreement. He dropped from the clouds and raked the orcs’ rear lines. The orcs hollered in surprise, twisting to take shots as Bilbo retreated. Several arrows found their marks, but Bilbo circled back for another pass.
The rain rattled with a deep thunk and the biggest javelin Bilbo had ever seen hurtled towards him from Dáin’s line. Bilbo swooped low over the orcs, then twisted—Kíli’s arms tight around his neck—as two more javelins punched past. He beat his wings aggressively, clearing Dale’s wall and using its towers as cover until he reached a safe altitude.
Bilbo’s efforts had not been for naught: Dáin took the bridge with little resistance from the disorganized orcs. Bilbo flew over Dale, homing in on his hoard. He sighted scarlet: Thranduil and five Elves were holding the street against forty orcs. Bilbo swooped—barely missing Thranduil’s scalp—and bowled over the orcs before continuing.
The company was on the second level, their chevron shattered as they fought hand-to-hand with wargs as large as Bilbo. Beside them were Laketown’s fisherfolk, scrapping with the untrained ferocity of bagged cats. Kíli targeted two wargs that had pinned Bombur against a wall. Bilbo dropped onto another, puncturing its skull with his claws. Kíli rolled off his back and drew his sword, leaping to the company’s defense. Bilbo brawled with the wargs, severing hamstrings and tearing throats until he and the company won their peace.
“Dáin’s here!” Kíli blurted. “Uncle, Dáin is inside the city.”
“Some good news at last,” Thorin rasped as the company cheered.
“Who is Dáin?” Bard demanded. Bilbo had not recognized him: like everyone else, he was soaked with rain and blood. His sword was badly notched.
“My cousin,” Thorin said. “He has come to lift the siege on Erebor.”
Bard scowled. “Not the siege he expected, I’m sure.”
“We’re glad to see him all the same,” Balin said smoothly. “Tell your people—and Gandalf, if he doesn’t know already.”
As Bard began to leave, Thorin called him back and held out Deathless, his first sword. “Take this. It will serve you better than anything crafted in the forges of Men.”
Bard exchanged his nicked blade for Deathless, nodded once, and took off with the other Men.
“Gandalf is here?” Kíli asked.
“He thought we needed help from some untrained Men,” Dwalin growled. Using much the same tone as Gandalf had for Dáin, he added, “That old meddler.”
By some miracle, the company was all on their feet. Most sported minor injuries, but Oin’s limp had worsened and both Balin and Bofur held arms at awkward angles. Ori was vacantly patting Bilbo’s shoulder, his eyes bigger than saucers. Fíli’s jaw was clenched so tightly that Bilbo’s own teeth ached.
“Have you seen Azog?” Balin asked Kíli.
Kíli shook his head. “Haven’t.”
Thorin glanced at Bilbo. “How many can you carry to Ravenhill?”
Bilbo whimpered as Oin ripped an arrow from his flank, then tapped his claw four times.
“Dwalin, Fíli, Glóin,” Thorin said.
“I’m coming, too,” Kíli said, stepping in front of his uncle.
“It’s too dangerous,” Thorin snapped. “Azog had sworn to wipe out the Line of Durin.”
“You’re leaving Balin and Oin behind!”
“You should stay,” Fíli seconded.
“My place is with my family,” Kíli said, “and you’ll need my arrows.”
Bilbo cocked his head. Reluctantly, he tapped his claw five times.
“You and your brother will only scout,” Thorin told him, to which Fíli and Kíli enthusiastically agreed. Kíli relayed Dáin and Thranduil’s positions, and Thorin told the injured Balin to fetch war rams from Dáin to follow him to Ravenhill. Bilbo paid little attention to the specifics. He nuzzled each of his hoard in turn, counting their injuries and reveling in their survival.
The company broke and Bilbo crouched to let Kíli, Fíli, Dwalin, Thorin, and Glóin climb aboard.
“Try to catch up with us!” Kíli called down. “We’ll have a head start!”
“Not for long!” Bofur retorted. “You’ll run out of arrows, but my ma forged this mattock herself. It’ll keep until Durin’s reborn!”
“Eh, don’t fall off,” Oin told Glóin. “I won’t have time to set your leg.”
“You’re not touching my legs!” Glóin snapped. “My left arm’s still crooked!”
“Fly well,” Balin told Bilbo, “and come back if you don’t find him.” He leaned close and whispered, “Look after them, Bilbo.”
Months of flying had strengthened Bilbo’s wings, but five Dwarves in battle array taxed him greatly. He fought for every inch of sky, his perforated wings pumping as he warred with gravity and wind. He climbed the southern spur and circled laboriously, too laden to soar. The Celduin tributary bisecting Ravenhill had burst its banks, inundating the ruins. Perhaps that was why the outpost was curiously—suspiciously—devoid of orcs.
“Set us down in that courtyard,” Thorin said, and Bilbo let himself fall into a circle of cracked tiles and fallen pillars. The Dwarves dismounted swiftly—Kíli, last of all.
“Try not to die without me,” Kíli told Bilbo, then raced after his brother.
Thorin, Dwalin, and Glóin took a different route than the younger Dwarves. Bilbo waited until they had disappeared into the rain, then took flight. He inscribed anxious loops over the floodwaters, darting this way and that when he heard the clash of steel, but encountering no orcs except ones the company had already defeated. Muffled shouts cut through the rain—some orc, some Dwarf—and then a spike of terror rammed through his gut: Kíli was in danger.
Bilbo raced towards him, his heart thundering louder than the storm. Battling figures wavered behind curtains of rain, then resolved into a terrifying tableau: Kíli was dueling a pale orc, alone, on the quayside walkway. Kíli slogged through the shin-deep water; Azog—twice Kíli’s height and with twice his reach—pressed him mercilessly with both flail and a blade embedded in the stump of his severed hand. As Bilbo watched, Azog shouldered Kíli, pointed his blade at Bilbo, and shouted, “Catch the dragon alive!”
A swarm of red-eyed bats the size of dogs exploded from the ruins, striking Bilbo like a solid mass. They nipped Bilbo’s fans and crest, and pummeled his delicate wings. Bilbo’s fangs ran black with the blood of Mordor. They could not hurt him when his Dwarf was threatened.
He broke free of the swarm just as Kíli’s sword tangled in the chain of Azog’s flail. The Dwarf was wrenched sideways. Azog buried his blade in Kíli’s stomach. Bilbo screamed as he, too, felt the blow, but Kíli bobbed upright, grinning wildly as he hacked off Azog’s missing arm above the elbow.
The mithril! Bilbo remembered.
“Kíli!” Thorin bellowed from the other side of the river. He surged into the water, heedless of his armor, with Fíli a few steps behind. Fíli hefted a knife and flung it at Azog. The pale orc snarled as the blade sank into his shoulder, but the injury only seemed to galvanize him. Kíli was now losing ground.
Bilbo tore through the remaining bats and dove, claws out. Kíli looked up and frantically waved him away even as he fended off Azog. Nets sprang up between the ruins; Bilbo flew directly into them. He crashed through an arch and landed on his back, his left wing snapping on impact and his limbs hopelessly tangled.
Azog knocked Kíli’s sword away and seized him by the throat.
No! Bilbo cried. No, no, no, no, no—!
“Kíli!” Fíli screamed. His second thrown dagger pierced Azog’s stomach.
Thorin waded up to his chest, struggling against the powerful current.
“So ends your filthy line, Oakenshield!” Azog gloated, and plunged Kíli headfirst into the water.
Orcs scuttled from their bolt holes to seize Bilbo’s trailing nets. He flailed, yanking the orcs off their feet and snaring himself further in the barbed hemp. He transformed into a Hobbit, freeing his muzzle and tail. The orcs rushed forward and clubbed Bilbo’s tiny body, breaking skin and bone with the force of their blows. Bilbo’s chest hitched. He couldn’t breathe.
A third knife whistled across the river, carving a bloody furrow in Azog’s upper arm. Only the top of Thorin’s head was visible under the water. Kíli’s struggles were slowing.
Bilbo transformed into a dragon and poured every thimble of heat in his body through his jaws. The air blurred as the rope steamed, then burnt to ash. The orcs nearest shrieked and died, their skin shriveled. The survivors threw another net, but Bilbo twisted, catching it on his broken wing. He charged Azog on numb legs, his nets dragging and his sight darkening.
Thorin burst from the river, Orcrist in hand. The current had pulled him ten yards from Kíli and Azog. Bilbo was farther away, but seconds could be hours on the battlefield—and seconds became an eternity the very moment Bilbo felt Kíli’s life slip away.
In the end, he was still the same beast that had crushed the Alliance at Dagorlad. And now, as then, when his hoard was harmed—killed; Kíli had been killed—the only recourse was violence.
Azog dropped Kíli’s body, laughing even as he bled from a dozen wounds. Bilbo and Thorin moved as one: Thorin swept under Azog’s flail and Bilbo pounced. Thorin plunged Orcrist into Azog’s chest as Bilbo’s claws closed around his shoulders. He tore off Azog’s head with a vicious twist.
The momentum of his leap swung the weighted nets into the river. They snagged in the swift current, dragging Bilbo away from what was left of Azog. Bilbo sank gratefully into the murky, frigid waters, his last sight the silhouette of Thorin reaching down and the eagles circling above.
Notes:
Translations
Du bekâr—to arms
Kannbundshumâr—tassets
Chapter 20: Snow After Fire
Summary:
The aftermath of the battle raises as many questions as it answers.
Chapter Text
Bilbo had rarely dwelt on what afterlife might await a creature of the Enemy. Secretly, he had hoped that several millennia spent as a Hobbit would send him on their unknown paths. He had not expected this. He had not expected agony. Death was pain: pain to devour all reason; pain to flense away everything but his own regret, self-hatred, and shame; pain without the surcease of sorrow.
The revelation that he had not, in fact, died was an unwelcome one.
“Oh, Bilbo,” Gandalf murmured. “Oh, my poor, dear fellow.”
Bilbo coiled tighter, attempting to compress himself into nothing. Gandalf sighed. Wood creaked to Bilbo’s left, followed by the familiar rustle of pipeweed tamped into a pipe. Gandalf muttered something under his breath. Old Toby tickled Bilbo’s nostrils, so familiar and homey that Bilbo wept.
Other sounds were filtering in now: muffled conversations, interspersed with quickly passing footsteps and the lowing of livestock.
“The battle is over,” Gandalf said. “We have won. Azog is dead. Erebor remains in the Dwarves’ hands. There is a King Under the Mountain again.”
Bilbo wrung some consolation from that. He knew before Gandalf had spoken that his Dwarves had survived with minor injuries, except for Bifur, over a week dead, and Kíli—
A scalding tear rolled down Bilbo’s cheek.
Gandalf sighed. “The Eagles found you in the Celduin and flew you here. You are currently a guest of Thranduil.”
Both of Bilbo’s eyelids flew open, his pupils contracting painfully as he looked directly into the Sun. A perfect rectangle had been cut out of the fluttering wool, permitting light to bathe his scales. He surged upright and found himself inside a spacious tent, lying atop a bed of smooth river stones warmed by a Dwarvish woodstove. Gandalf was perched on a stool, obscured by his broad-brimmed hat and a cloud of pipeweed. Thranduil’s foul accouterments were arrayed behind him: a carafe of red wine, a maple table with matching chairs, an armor stand, weavings from Doriath.
“You are his guest, Bilbo,” Gandalf said. “I would not let him hold you captive.”
The chill crept in again. Gandalf tucked a blanket over Bilbo’s shoulders and he transformed into a Hobbit.
“How—how long?” Bilbo rasped. “How long since the … the…?”
When Bilbo could not continue, Gandalf said, “It has been two days since you killed Azog.”
Bilbo plopped onto the hot stones, his hairy feet stuck out in front of him.
“The company has been visiting you,” Gandalf said. “I could scarcely light my pipe without igniting a beard.” His voice softened. “They do not blame you, Bilbo. No one does.”
Bilbo’s throat worked soundlessly. “If I hadn’t—if I wasn’t—”
“If you had not risen to the occasion, many more would have died,” Gandalf said. “You saved the lives of thousands—the innocents of Laketown, Dáin and his army, Thranduil and his host, Thorin and his company.”
“But—”
“They are calling it the Battle of the Five Armies,” Gandalf said, “for the Men, Elves, Dwarves, Eagles, and Dragon who shattered the host of Dol Guldur.”
Bilbo’s eyes grew hot and itchy. “I’m no hero, Gandalf.”
“Heroism is an honor bestowed, not a title pursued,” Gandalf said, exhaling another cloud. “You fought to defend what you loved most in this world. So did Kíli and Bifur.”
Bilbo shuddered at their names.
“Honor the love for which they gave their lives,” Gandalf said. “Only by living can we celebrate their victory.”
Bilbo drew the blanket closer. “It … it’s different. They…”
“They are your hoard,” Gandalf said. When Bilbo looked up, Gandalf added, “I guessed as much when we parted in Mirkwood, but if you had not come to the same conclusion, I did not want to frighten you.”
“You knew this would happen?” Bilbo demanded, shooting to his feet.
“I did not know you would claim the company as your hoard,” Gandalf said. “Wizards are not in the business of knowing: we merely have hunches that often turn out to be right!”
Bilbo struggled to hold the high ground. “Well, your hunch certainly benefited you.”
Gandalf puffed irritably at his pipe. “When I asked you to come on this quest, I had merely hoped you would finally leave your dusty burrow, and that Thorin and his company had met their equal in stubbornness and more than their match in reason. If you spent the whole of the quest as a Hobbit, I would have said nothing of it.”
Bilbo’s fury spluttered out. He sat back down.
With a ghost of a smile, Gandalf said, “You have always been terribly self-centered.”
“I’ve changed in other ways.”
Gandalf leaned down to offer him the pipe. Bilbo shook his head.
“Thranduil travels with excellent vintages,” Gandalf said, “and you are his guest.”
Bilbo tottered to the carafe and poured a measure for himself and Gandalf. He handed a glass to the wizard, who clinked it against Bilbo’s.
“To treasures greater than gold,” Gandalf said.
Bilbo raised his glass, then sipped. The wine was a strong Elvish red: sour and dark.
“What do I do, Gandalf?” Bilbo asked miserably. “Three thousand years and I’m still as spry as a hatchling. The Dwarves…”
“They will age, while you do not,” Gandalf confirmed. Bilbo cringed. “Love is never wasted, Bilbo. Do not fear it.”
“I’m not some moonstruck Elf-maid. It’s—this … what I feel isn’t love.”
“That is the voice of the Enemy,” Gandalf said sternly. “If Smaug were in your position, he would have locked the company in Erebor until he lorded over their bones.”
“I didn’t want to let them leave,” Bilbo snarled. “They died in front of me.”
“Will you jail the company?”
“No!”
“And whyever not?”
“Because—because—!” Bilbo’s hands balled into fists. “Because that’s not what they want. That’s not—before they were my hoard, they were my friends, and that’s not what friends do.”
Gandalf smiled.
“Oh, alright, you rotten wizard.” Bilbo’s mirth dissipated swiftly after the talk of Smaug. He set down his half-full wine glass. “Smaug … he told me that the Enemy is back.”
Gandalf seemed to age a lifetime. Finally, he said, “I have long suspected as much. Erebor was the first of many tests—one that we passed, with your assistance.” He inclined his head. “The Enemy will have learned of your survival.”
“All the better to get far from Erebor.”
“Traveling, are we?”
Bilbo fiddled with his blanket. “I … I can’t do this eleven more times, Gandalf.” He knocked back the last of the wine. “Love or not, I’m not strong enough.”
“Do not make this decision rashly,” Gandalf said. “You are not the first to run afoul of immortality. Visit the lord Elrond: he possesses greater wisdom on the matter than I.”
“Elves!” Bilbo cried, just as his least favorite specimen ducked through the tent flaps. Bilbo had hoped to catch Thranduil in post-battle disarray, but he wore perfectly pressed scarlet robes and an expression of haughty surprise.
“Am I interrupting, Mithrandir?” Thranduil asked.
“Not at all,” Gandalf said. “I was merely entertaining your guest.”
“Ah, my guest.” Thranduil’s gaze dragged over to Bilbo, who bared his teeth. “Be welcome, Bilbo … or however you prefer to be addressed.”
“I prefer Master Baggins from acquaintances and foes alike,” Bilbo retorted.
“By Nienna’s tears, you are both over three thousand years old,” Gandalf snapped. “I have seen better hospitality from Tookish tweens!”
Bilbo settled back onto his hot stones, but only after helping himself to more wine under the watch of the Elvenking’s fish-belly eyes.
“Gandalf has vouched for your reformed character,” Thranduil said, “and it seems you lost a brother on the same day I lost a father.” He paused. “You also saved my son’s life, as well as many of my retinue. For that, I am willing to set aside my grudge.”
“Your sword doesn’t interest me,” Bilbo sniffed, “nor does your life’s blood.”
“Very good,” Gandalf said, before Thranduil could retort. “Very good!”
Bilbo and Thranduil both scowled.
“I will not have my guest reeking of orc,” Thranduil told Bilbo. “You must bathe.”
Bilbo dropped his blankets. “At your earliest convenience, Master Elf.”
Gandalf excused himself under the pretense of fetching the company as Thranduil orchestrated Bilbo’s bath. Several Elves hauled a copper tub into the tent, then filled it with lavender sachets and ewers of steaming saltwater. Bilbo climbed inside immediately, sighing as his muscles unspooled beneath his assumed skin.
The Elves kindled a fire beneath the bathtub and departed. Thranduil remained, lounging on a chair with a glass of wine and a book. To Bilbo’s unasked question, Thranduil said, “I would be a poor host if you drowned in my tent.”
“This is your chance,” Bilbo said, purposely slipping below the lip of the tub.
Thranduil studied him for a long moment. “I have seen your worth upon the field of battle. We would do well to join forces for the dark days ahead.”
Bilbo sat up. “You believe the Enemy is back.”
“I believe it is a possibility worth accounting for,” said Thranduil. “Mithrandir is over-free with his counsel, but rarely gives warning without cause.” He cocked his head, his silver hair shimmering. “He says your master has no hold over you.”
“Not since we parted at Dagorlad,” Bilbo said. “I have a new hoard now.”
Thranduil’s eyes narrowed. “What an … interesting choice.”
“Oh, insult me already,” Bilbo snapped. “I won’t tattle to Gandalf.”
“Your choice is, at best, questionable, and, at worst, execrable.”
“Fair enough,” Bilbo admitted, swishing his hands idly, “but I’ve been craving a good bath since … well, since Tom Bombadil’s, really. And your vintages are quite good.”
“I imagine comfort has been sorely lacking amidst your recent company.”
“Unbelievably so.” He glanced at Thranduil as the Elvenking picked up his book. “There was a captain of your guard—Tauriel. Is she…?”
“I banished her for disobeying my orders,” Thranduil said, turning a page. “Conveniently, this freed her to become my liaison to Erebor—a post she requested before news of her banishment arrived.”
Bilbo tried to puzzle that out, then surrendered to the bath’s warm embrace and sought the company through their bond. Their grief and lingering pain became his own, and his despair found fresh soil.
“Your Dwarves approach,” Thranduil announced, as if Bilbo had not already known, “and I would rather not hold my breath for their visit.”
So saying, he relocated himself, his chair, his book, and his wine to the far side of the tent. Moments later, Nori and Bofur threw aside the tent flaps and stopped at the scene before them.
“Hullo,” Bilbo said, as though he wasn’t stewing over a fire. “Thranduil believes that by eating me, he will absorb my power.”
“Lies,” Thranduil muttered from his perch.
“Bilbo!” Bofur yelled. He leaned over the tub’s scalding rim and hugged Bilbo. Bilbo yelped in pain, then again as Nori crushed both of them to his chest.
“Long Lake’s got it out for you,” Bofur said when Nori released them. “You can’t keep falling in there.”
Bilbo shook his head. “Where is everyone? Are they alright?”
Bofur’s smile faded, but Nori said, “Busier than us. Everyone wanted to come, but duties pulled them away until only the miner and the thief could make it.” He dragged a chair over and propped his boots on the tub. “Cozy in there?”
Bilbo couched his head on his arms. “Like a flea in Dwarven drawers.” Nori snorted. “The water is a bit filthy, though. I’m marinating in all sorts of blood.”
Bofur peered into the mix of blood, water, and dirt. “Thorin wanted Dwarf healers, but Gandalf said Thranduil was best.” He leaned in. “Has he been treating you right?”
“If Thranduil wanted to kill me, he would’ve already,” Bilbo said, then lowered his voice conspiratorially. “He respects me now.”
“Grudging respect is not a victory,” Thranduil drawled. “You have ten minutes before your Dwarves must depart.”
“We’ll take him with us, then,” Nori said.
“I care not what you do with the dragon,” Thranduil said, “but steal my tub and you will answer for it.”
“Erebor,” Bilbo prompted the Dwarves. “What happened?”
Bofur and Nori caught him up on the company’s wellbeing, skating around the raw edges of Kíli and Bifur’s losses. After Nori finished a detailed recounting of the clerical nightmares of maintaining an encampment this large, Thranduil’s book snapped shut.
“That’s enough,” Thranduil said. When Nori began complaining, he raised a hand. “The sooner Mr. Baggins rests, the sooner I can examine him. The sooner I examine him, the sooner I am rid of him and he is restored to you. Find some better occupation before I set you to boiling a dragon’s worth of bandages.”
With the threat of conscription and Bilbo’s own encouragement, the Dwarves said their goodbyes, mixed with imprecations for Thranduil’s bedside manner.
On their way out, Thranduil said, “My possessions, Master Nori.”
Without breaking stride, Nori turned out his pockets. Handfuls of silverware, tiny bottles, an enamel pipe, and a candlestick tumbled to the ground. Bilbo did not hide his smile.
Kíli entered Erebor’s catacombs three days after the Battle of the Five Armies. Hundreds of Dwarves had died during the battle: they were returned to the stone beside their young prince and old toymaker in a single, solemn rite. Fíli, Thorin, Dwalin, and Balin carried Kíli, and Kíli carried both the Arkenstone and the stone bearing his unfulfilled promise to his mother.
Bilbo stood with the guests of honor. The newly-crowned King Bard was at his side with his eldest daughter, and Thranduil was accompanied by Legolas and Tauriel. Gandalf was present, as he always was for momentous happenings. The Eagles alone of the Five Armies had not lingered, but Gwaihir had ripped down from his own breast to line Kíli’s bier.
The procession occupied a stretch of time that Bilbo, in his grief, would be hard-pressed to estimate. Finally, the doors swung shut behind the last bier and the guests departed. Bilbo said goodbye to Gandalf—who was being called away yet again—and to Bard, murmured condolences to Tauriel, and even nodded cordially to Thranduil before returning to Erebor’s upper levels. Fíli had organized a second funeral for Bilbo to attend. Another day, another death, Bilbo would have been flattered, but he followed Fíli’s instructions mindlessly until he opened the door to a room devoid of everything except furniture and the fast-fading scent of his hoard. Bilbo stared into his future and sobbed once, miserably, before clamping his hand to his mouth.
Bilbo retreated, sniffed left and right to orient himself, and set off for the kitchen. Erebor’s cooks were all Dáin’s; they gave him a wide berth as he fetched flour, butter, sugar, cinnamon, pickled peaches, and cream. Routine took him from there. When he finished baking, he wrapped the pies in towels and brought them to the room, then stoked the fire, folded his clothes, and turned into a dragon, curled up around the miniature wood version of himself.
The Dwarves returned shortly thereafter. They rushed in after the first whiff of pastry, their minds—however briefly—fixed on food.
“’s good,” Dwalin declared, spraying crumbs from a full mouth.
“Hurry it up!” Dori cried when Bofur took too long filling his plate. “Ori’s a growing Dwarf still.”
After they doled out the peach pies, they returned to Bilbo: Nori, Ori, and Bofur sat on his back; Dori and Dwalin against his right side; Balin, leaning on his shoulder; Fíli propped against his neck; Bombur and Oin sitting against his legs; and Glóin’s thigh brushing his tail. Thorin alone kept his distance. The Dwarves did not press Bilbo for speech or deed, and he was content to observe. Here, Dwalin and Balin toasting Kíli. There, Oin and Bombur trading stories about Bifur. Crown Prince Fíli was silent, but Bilbo sensed his bottled emotions as surely as he could have sensed a nick on his hoarded blades.
Fíli sat cross-legged by Bilbo’s head, picking at his bloody nailbeds. He said, very quietly, “I’m sorry that you lost your siblings.”
Bilbo voiced reassurances—they are long gone, this is not your burden—with his fangs and inflexible tongue, but all that emerged was a soft growl.
“Every morning I wake up thinking he’s alive,” Fíli continued. “And every morning I—” He frowned. “I don’t know if I’ll ever … or if I want to ever...”
Bilbo dropped his head onto Fíli’s lap. Fíli left off his own hands to scratch Bilbo’s jaw.
“Guess I’ll have to live enough for both of us,” Fíli whispered.
Bilbo closed his eyes.
“I’m not getting on your back, though,” Fíli added, lighter this time. “You’ll have to find a braver Dwarf.”
Bilbo snorted, accidentally crisping Oin’s pants. In the ensuing uproar, Thorin slipped out unseen—mostly.
Bilbo met Balin’s eye and clicked softly.
“Off him, lads,” Balin commanded. “Our dragon has somewhere to be.”
The Dwarves dismounted, thanking Bilbo for the pies with florid compliments and bows. Bilbo nuzzled each of them, then traded their companionship for Erebor’s cold halls.
The moment he was alone, Bilbo transformed and dressed, then set off down unfamiliar paths, around blind turns, and up steps hewn into the living rock. Bilbo knew he could follow Thorin anywhere—after all, he’d already followed him halfway across Middle Earth. Fortunately, this trek turned out to be a fair sight shorter. Thorin had stopped at the top of a curving staircase overlooking some grand hall whose purpose Bilbo could not divine through the dust. It was dark; torches twinkled in the distance like stars.
Bilbo cleared his throat when he drew level and Thorin turned. Bilbo wondered what he saw—nothing new, surely, unlike what he saw in Thorin. The king had cast aside his crown and silks, and now wore Dáin’s spare tunic and Mannish trousers neatly cuffed over his travel boots. Orcrist’s battered sheath hung empty on his back. Grief had dug graves under his eyes.
“I owe you so many apologies I do not know where to begin,” Thorin said finally.
“Then we don’t have to,” Bilbo said. “Do that, I mean. Apologize.” He fidgeted. Thorin’s gaze held a hunger that Bilbo was unready to sate. “We’d be here for hours, each apologizing to the other, each thinking the other could’ve stopped ages ago. I’ve had my fill of them. So, please, let’s not.”
“Then where do we begin?”
“Sharing good company?” Bilbo suggested. “You don’t have to talk. I probably won’t.” He shrugged. “Doesn’t mean I want to be alone.”
Thorin tentatively offered his arm. Bilbo took it, his heart too heavy to thrill at the gesture. For a long time, they said and saw nothing, and heard nothing but their own footsteps. Slowly, the light grew and, with it, the frenetic energy of a mountain reignited. Restoration had already started in the vital areas: forges, homes, kitchens, armories, and record houses. They bustled with Dwarves from the Iron Hills, and Bilbo and Thorin avoided them as naturally as they avoided the treasury.
Thorin eventually took the lead, transforming an aimless walk into a proper tour. They spoke of reconstruction, of farming, of guilds and politics. They did not speak of Kíli or Bifur, or the thousands slain in the vale. They did not speak of gold except of what it could buy: food, raw materials, caravans to fetch the exiled Longbeards.
By the time Thorin led Bilbo outside, the sun was several hours gone and a rime of frost crusted the old archery targets. The hollow where the company had camped before entering Erebor now overlooked the even lines of Dáin’s encampment and, beyond that, Dale’s watchfires and the circular tents of Thranduil’s host. Bilbo accepted Thorin’s coat, then settled on a boulder and held up a packet of tobacco.
They were at the bottom of their bowls when Thorin asked the question they had evaded for hours. “Where will you go now?” When Bilbo did not answer—how he had dreaded this!—Thorin said, “You saved my kingdom, my people, and my kin. There will always be a place for you in Erebor.”
Oh, Thorin. Bilbo’s heart was so overburdened with emotions that he could not name them all. “I don’t know where I’ll go. But, please, Thorin…” Bilbo took Thorin’s hand. “Don’t ask me to stay.”
Thorin’s hand was as familiar as his face: square, trimmed nails; broad fingers rough with the calluses of a smith and a warrior; a dusting of dark hairs along the knuckles and backs; the struts of his bones; the blue rivers of his veins. Would that Bilbo could slip inside and lose himself at their confluence with no thought of return, like an eel swimming out to sea or an Elf sailing to Valinor.
“I swear never to ask anything of you again,” Thorin said. “You have shown the quality of dragons, Master Baggins—and of friends.”
Bilbo closed his eyes, whetting his other senses. Thorin’s muscles contracted beneath his borrowed clothes. His breath ruffled Bilbo’s curls; his beard scratched his forehead and his silvery hair tickled Bilbo’s cheek. An unseasonable thrush sang from the heather.
“I only request,” Thorin continued, “that you remember my offer always stands.”
“Will you stay?” Bilbo asked.
“I owe my people a great debt,” Thorin said. “I swore to the living and the dead to return Erebor to its former glory.”
Bilbo’s heart broke afresh. He knew as surely as Thorin could not leave, Bilbo could not remain. The Lonely Mountain would always be a monument to his failures, and the sorrow that he and Thorin shared.
But one day, under the same beloved hand twisted through Bilbo’s fingers, Erebor would prosper again, and here the company would grow old in safety, surrounded by each other and the realm they had renewed.
That hope lifted Bilbo enough to smile. “This won’t be the last time we see each other.”
Bilbo felt Thorin’s answering smile against his forehead. “All other kingdoms will pale in comparison by the time you return.”
“Well!” Bilbo laughed. “It sounds like we both have work to do! I’ll leave you to it.”
They embraced—a poor decision on Bilbo’s part, one that would worsen their parting, but he could not stop himself. They held each other for some time, until, at last, piece by piece, they separated. Last were their hands. Bilbo stared at his fingers, still enmeshed in Thorin’s, as the weight of Thorin’s gaze fell to the same point. Thorin pulled Bilbo a half-step forward and raised Bilbo’s left hand with his joined right, pressing Bilbo’s knuckles against his beard. Bilbo stood on his toes and leaned forward, angling Thorin’s hand until his mouth closed on Thorin’s knuckle. Their foreheads touched. Their breath mingled, acrid from pipe-smoke, and their lips were separated only by the pale hillocks of their knuckles.
When the moment grew unbearable, Bilbo said, “Watch over them for me, Thorin.”
“Always,” Thorin whispered.
The impending winter crept in around them as Bilbo left to prepare for his departure.
Chapter 21: Concerning Dragons
Summary:
The fourteenth member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield chooses the manner of his death.
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
If one endeavored to summarize Dáin Ironfoot in a word, they would eventually settle on loud. His presence expanded into any space he entered, from tents to battlefields. He was charming when he wanted to be and crass when he didn’t, but the combination of both was such that most found it easier to forgive him than fight. Anyone who did challenge the Lord of the Iron Hills would discover his armor turned all but a black arrow, and that his fighting prowess made short work of aggressors.
Dáin liked Bilbo immediately.
“There’s the wee dragon!” he roared as Bilbo arrived outside his tent. “Come here! I haven’t seen you this small!”
He beckoned Bilbo over to where he was playing cards with a dark-skinned Dwarf about Fíli’s age with a dramatic scar bisecting his eyebrow. The younger Dwarf appeared to be winning.
“Not as impressive as I thought you’d be,” Dáin told Bilbo. “Well, I heard all about how you defeated Thorin. Come to cross claws with the great Ironfoot?”
Bilbo smiled thinly. “Only if you would like to be known as Ironfeet.”
Dáin howled with laughter, then rocked to his feet and swept into a bow. “Dáin, Lord of the Iron Hills, at your service. This is my son, wee Thorin.”
Dáin’s solemn companion mimicked his father. “Thorin Stonehelm at your service, Master Hobbit—Baggins.”
“Bilbo Baggins, at yours,” Bilbo said, repeating the gesture. “Bilbo will do. I’ve heard of your bravery during the battle, Thorin. Ah—Stonehelm.”
Dáin guffawed as Thorin Stonehelm puffed with pride.
“And I have been assured that without you, King Thorin’s quest would have ended west of the Misty Mountains,” Stonehelm replied.
Were he not so heartsick, Bilbo would have preened. As it was, Stonehelm won Bilbo’s immediate respect. “You’re too kind. I’ve come because I haven’t had my fill of adventure, and I’d like to join you on your return to the Iron Hills.”
“Haven’t had your fill of Dwarves, you mean!” Dáin said. “Our home in the Iron Hills is second to none, and will be until Thorin gives us some competition!”
“Then I ought to visit now, during this fleeting window,” Bilbo said.
“Oho!” Dáin exclaimed, slapping his thighs. “So you spit fire in more ways than one, uslukhaluk!”
“We would be honored by your presence, Master Baggins,” said Stonehelm, “though I warn you that the journey will be neither comfortable nor quick.”
It was Bilbo’s turn to laugh. “I’ve grown quite accustomed to roughing it—a thousand leagues without a single handkerchief, tailored waistcoat, or spice stronger than salt!”
“I cannot promise the former two, but we season our food better than our western cousins,” Stonehelm said. “You will be our guest.”
“Really, I’m no stranger to hard work,” Bilbo said. “I’d be happy to help where I can.”
“Nonsense!” Dáin slapped Bilbo’s back with enough force to fell an ox—and wobble a Dragon. “We’ve already set aside your ram and tent. Cousin Thorin told us you were coming two days ago.”
Dáin’s caravan would depart the next day. Bilbo ached with things unfinished and words unsaid, but knew that lingering would corrode his resolve. Fortunately, he had little to gather: he had relinquished his fourteenth share—save for a small chest each of gold and silver to finance his travels—and planned to bring only the same leather pack he had taken from Bag End. The company lavished him with visits and gifts, the latter impractical more often than not, and the former as welcome as it was dangerous. Bilbo was forced to chase them out to secure his peace. Only Dori was admitted, later, as Bilbo could not begrudge him his fussing.
That evening was Bilbo’s final bask amongst his hoard. The bittersweet dregs of sorrow and victory mingled strangely, loosening tongues and tears alike.
And if Bilbo and Thorin avoided each other, no one mentioned it.
Autumn bared its first frosty fangs on the morning of Dáin’s leave-taking. Bilbo, the remaining company, and half of Dáin’s original party assembled outside Erebor’s gates. Bilbo had been given a goat and a place of honor beside Thorin Stonehelm, whose mount was a war pig named Sunshine. Sunshine despised Bilbo from the first—wise, he told her, as he could swallow her whole, with room for seconds—and he gladly rode with the company instead. They had somehow wrangled the Riddermark horses back from Thranduil, and made perfect asses of themselves by riding as poorly as when they had left the Field of Celebrant.
The company and the caravan parted ways on the eastern shore of Long Lake, where the sun had yet to reach and smoke from Laketown lingered in the hollows. The company halted their horses at the crossroads, waving furiously. Bilbo’s neck ached from how often he turned in the saddle, watching them grow small and smaller, until the caravan rounded a bend and his hoard was lost from sight.
His heart, impossibly, broke just a little more.
Bilbo’s new travel companions were a different troupe: they sang different songs, wore different clothes, and even smelled very un-Dwarvish, to Bilbo’s nose—and, indeed, seasoned their food more generously than Bilbo had come to expect. Dáin and Stonehelm were perfect hosts, in their own way, but they were not Bilbo’s Dwarves. Every evening, Bilbo satisfied his requirements as a guest before retiring early to turn Bifur’s toy over in his hands, thinking of everything and nothing. Every morning, Bilbo would wake up facing west, towards the solitary peak dwindling into the distance.
Halfway to the Iron Hills, Bilbo penned a letter to Dáin and Thorin Stonehelm to announce his unforeseen departure and gift them his chests to repay their hospitality. Then, he evaded the keen-eyed watch and, once a goodly stretch from camp, bundled his clothes into his pack, tethered it to his ankle, and changed his skin for the first time in weeks.
Bilbo followed the waxing tang of salt and rotting seaweed, landing only when his wings could no longer keep him aloft. The winds grew warmer and the land drier, until plains gave way to forest, which petered out into scraggly brown scrub. On the third day after Bilbo’s parting from Dáin, a pearlescent smudge appeared at the bottom of his vision. Bilbo blinked, attempting to dispel the phantoms of his exhaustion, but the blur sharpened into an unbroken expanse of chicory-blue water.
Bilbo floated lower, wheeling amongst the gulls as the winds tipped him this way and that, until he landed on a blindingly white sandbar. The fine sand engulfed his claws and cut into his eyes. He wrinkled his nose, then transformed into a Hobbit and savored a lunch of dried fish and peppered waybread. He would need to hunt soon—and, indeed, for the foreseeable future, if this was to be his new home.
He wiped his mouth daintily, then knelt over the sea to wash himself. His reflection peered back at him: curls the color of old straw twisting around stolen eyes in a sunken face.
Bilbo dashed himself away, turned into a dragon, and strode into the Sea of Rhûn. The tepid water washed over his claws, then his feet, his legs, his chest. Bilbo waded into darker water. The sea suddenly rolled beneath his wings, lifting him up and back. The waves closed overhead, crushing him against the sand. Bilbo’s claws sluiced futilely through the brine and he could not pull his wings from the seabed. Another wave rolled by. Saltwater poured down his throat like fire. He forced his wings shut and kicked off the sand. With two powerful undulations, he beached himself, coughing and cursing his idiocy as the waves licked his tail.
Fuming, Bilbo crawled above the tideline and laid out for a nap. Even with the sun above and the hot sand below, sleep still did not come. Crabs scuttled over his paws and gulls perched on his spines to cry like lost souls. The sand beneath his belly cooled and the scarlet warmth beating against Bilbo’s eyelids faded with the light. With nightfall came a battalion of gnats whining in his ears and clustering around his eyes. He shook his head in a rattle of scales, then took to the sky. He soared aimlessly, admiring the stars and their rippled reflections. The scent of the sea faded and Bilbo realized, too late, that he had oriented himself towards his hoard.
He angled his wings until his heading shifted from night-blued plains to black water. The southern horizon seethed scarlet behind Ered Lithui. Bilbo had heard the mountains had fallen dormant after the Enemy’s defeat, but a red glow—too sullen for sunset—flamed beyond their peaks.
Unsettled, Bilbo swiftly returned to his sandbar. Crabs fled for their burrows, vanishing moments before the insects returned. Somewhere out in the reeds, an animal made a musty groan resembling Dwalin’s snores. The hushed waves came and went like Smaug’s breathing. Ered Lithui’s eruptions throbbed in the corner of his eye.
The next decades unfurled before him like an ill-starred tapestry. The Enemy would return, as Smaug foretold, and the good and green things of Middle Earth would wither beneath his onslaught. Bilbo thought of Hobbits fleeing from cruel orcish blades. He thought of Gandalf beset, of Beorn and Radagast and Thranduil scotched from their forest, of balrogs sweeping across the fields of the Rohirrim, of Dale’s bells silenced. Lastly, his fears turned to the Dwarves. Where would Bilbo be when the first of his hoard fell in defense of their hard-won home? The second? Bilbo’s master had preferred to enslave than kill, to languish weeks of attention on the strongest spirits until they shattered; Bilbo’s hoard would give him great sport. The thought of what Sauron might do to him paled in comparison to the agony of watching his hoard die.
Yet that was Bilbo’s doom, one way or another, if he returned to Erebor. Losing two of his hoard—Kíli, Bifur—had nearly undone him. To watch the rest leave as he lived on was as terrible a fate as any dragon could dream. If madness did not take him, he would diminish until death seemed a mercy.
But without his Dwarves, was he living at all?
Five days later, Bilbo landed on a tor jutting from Erebor’s southern slope. He dressed, rubbed his growling stomach, and then picked his way down the ridge to join the Dwarf road leading to Dale.
The people of Laketown had moved into their ruins: the towers were clad in scaffolding, and the smell of cookfires and Men wafted far downhill. Spindly lifts waded between the buildings like herons, occasionally dipping to receive their bounty of bricks. A half-mile distant, a crew of Dwarves swarmed Erebor’s entrance. A new gate of iron-banded wood had already been erected. If Bilbo knew Dwarves half as well as he thought, timber would be replaced with stunning stonework in short order.
The gate guards admitted him immediately, even though it was nearly dark, and charged their youngest—a beautiful young Dwarf with fiery hair—to escort Bilbo to the throne room.
“Gimli, son of Glóin, at your service,” they said, bowing until their beard brushed the ground. “It is my honor to accompany you.”
Bilbo knew much about Gimli already: he happily questioned them about their apprenticeship and their journey from the Iron Hills. Gimli had inherited Glóin’s wagging tongue and occupied their walk with his answers.
Bilbo had thought Erebor’s throne room was rather gloomy, but with its braziers lit and mirrors gleaming, he realized it had been constructed to funnel all glory onto the throne. And there, beneath the niche that had once held the Arkenstone, was Dwalin, the Raven Crown girding his head and his mouth graven with displeasure.
“Step forth to receive your judgment,” Dwalin rumbled, his voice echoing magnificently.
Bilbo hurried forth. “Oh, come off it. We—”
Dwalin held up a hand. Bilbo stumbled to a halt. “For the crime of abandoning Erebor and its princes, I levy upon you the sentence of…” Dwalin paused dramatically “...death.”
Gimli and another guard seized Bilbo’s shoulders. Bilbo stared up at his old companion, bewildered.
“No, no, don’t actually kill him,” Dwalin told the guards. He removed his crown to dig his thumbs into his temples. “I always forget the word of the bloody king is bloody absolute.”
The guards released Bilbo, but he remained where he was, rooted with worry. “Is Thorin alright? And Fíli? And Balin?”
He frantically reached through their bond, touching each of them in turn.
“Thorin and Fíli are fine,” Dwalin said, “but Balin thought they needed time. Balin himself’s too busy to actually sit the throne and Dáin left, so here I am: King Under the Bloody Mountain.”
“Long may you reign,” Bilbo teased, bowing.
Dwalin barked with laughter. “If my reign lasts another week, I’ll foist the crown onto Glóin.”
“He has a worthy heir,” Bilbo pointed out. Behind him, Gimli made a choked noise that could have been a laugh or forestalled argument.
“More than most can say,” Dwalin said. “Mahal, maybe we should crown Bombur. With his brood, he’ll have as secure a line as any Dwarf could boast, and we’d feast like kings every night.” They chuckled at that. Then, Dwalin said, with a hint of regal menace, “You’ll be coming with me now.”
Bilbo was too thrilled to question him and, within minutes, he and Dwalin were standing outside a door. Or, at least, what Dwalin said was a door: much like the catacombs, the wall seemed unremarkable until Dwalin spoke the password and set his shoulder against the rock. The sounds of the quarreling company flooded into the hallway and Bilbo’s breath caught as his heart filled anew.
“King Dwalin brings gifts!” Dwalin bellowed. Bilbo followed him inside and found himself in a sitting room packed with Dwarves. Here they were: his whole hoard, gathered on armchairs and couches and glowing in the firelight, their mouths hanging open at the sight of him. Mouse-nibbled maps of the Iron Hills, the Sea of Rhûn, and the Withered Heath papered every surface, pinned to walls and flattened on tabletops with half-empty steins. Eleven travel packs sat against one wall, each one as familiar as their owners.
“Looks like you’re off on another quest,” Bilbo said at last.
“Of course we are!” Bofur exclaimed, standing atop his chair. “We thought we’d lost the fourteenth member of our company!”
“That, uh. That sounds rather serious.” Bilbo swallowed. Thorin—sitting beside Fíli on a dingy couch with a scroll in hand—was staring at Bilbo as if they were the only two people in the world. “You might need a dragon’s help fetching him back.”
“We’ve had enough trouble with dragons!” fumed Glóin. “And you’re the worst of the lot!”
The company rushed forward, wrapping him in a many-armed embrace as they cursed the curly heads of Hobbits and the sly scales of Dragons in turn.
“Haring off without so much as a by-your-leave!” wailed Dori. “Master Baggins, we thought better of you!”
“I left a proper letter,” Bilbo objected. He could not hear himself speak, nor did he want to. He was part of a whole: a member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield, as they were all parts of his hoard. They would be the death of him, Bilbo knew, but when that time came, no dragon would have been so happy to meet his end.
Finally, Bilbo yelled, “I have an announcement! I have an announcement to make!”
The other Dwarves kept chastising him until Dwalin abused his new rank to silence them. Not all Dwarves wished to heed his command; Bilbo used the distraction to scarf down two unattended fennel biscuits and half of Dori’s wine. He had not quite finished when Fíli and Glóin hoisted him onto their shoulders.
“Well!” Bilbo began from his new throne. “I shan’t keep you long, because I have a very clear purpose. Two purposes, in fact, neither of which are more important than the other, although I suppose, you may later decide that one is vastly—”
“By Durin, will ye hurry it up already?” demanded Glóin, his voice strained.
“No, I won’t,” Bilbo said, twisting to look down at him. “I scarcely felt I’ve gotten a word in edgewise during this entire quest and it’s finally my turn to speak.”
Dwalin rolled his eyes. “You talked plenty.”
“Enough to fill two full notebooks!” Ori said, brandishing his latest record.
“If we hear another speech about tomatoes, I’ll eat my hat,” Bofur said.
“Peaches?” Oin asked. “No, they won’t grow in this soil.”
“Your throne or your speech,” Fíli grunted, his arms quivering. “Your choice.”
Bilbo saw Balin and Dwalin exchange grins and said, grumpily, “Speech.”
With much extraneous cursing, Bilbo was lowered to the floor. Now, he had no choice but to continue.
“I came back,” Bilbo said, “because I missed all of you dearly. You are my dearest friends, but you are also—you have become—my hoard.” Some of the company looked puzzled, but no one spoke. “All of you, including … including Kíli and Bifur.” He took a fortifying breath. “Now, I would understand if a dragon’s hoard implied possession, but that is not true. I am not—I will never be like Smaug: your lives are your own. Just know that they are—that you are—incalculably precious to me, and my only wish is to stay at Erebor, always, so that we might share them.” Hastily, he added, “If that’s alright.”
Silence reigned. Bilbo desperately met Thorin’s eye and received a single, supportive nod.
Ori raised a gloved hand.
“Yes, Ori,” Bilbo said.
“You’re not going to sit on us, are you?” Ori asked. “I don’t think Dori’s ribs can stand the strain.”
“What?” Bilbo demanded, as if he had never had that thought. “No! No, utterly rid—”
“And you’ll be letting other Dwarves into Erebor?” Glóin asked.
“Why wouldn’t I?”
“Will you kill Thranduil for us?” asked Nori.
“He and I have an agreement,” Bilbo said, not without regret.
“Is there a contract we might sign to define the terms?” Dori asked.
Bilbo scratched his head and glanced at Balin, who tapped his temple, his eyes gleaming with anticipation. “Oh, um, apparently Balin can—”
“Can we leave the mountain?” Oin asked.
“Yes!” Bilbo exclaimed. “Great Yavanna, did you not hear what I said?”
Thorin’s voice carried easily over the company. “Will you stay?”
“Yes,” Bilbo said. “Yes, I’ll stay.”
Thorin’s rare, beautiful smile bloomed at last.
“Then, essentially,” Bofur said, “you want our lovely companionship, augmented by a couple centuries of free food and a warm place to hang your hat.”
That was as succinct a summary as Bilbo could want. He threw up his hands. “Exactly.”
The company glanced amongst themselves, collectively shrugged, and began inviting him to their homes, or to meet this or that Dwarf newly arrived at the mountain, or to see their restored workshops. Even a gentlehobbit of Bilbo’s towering punctiliousness was flustered by the array of directions and dates, only for his planning to be interrupted by a fulminous snarl. The Dwarves laughed when they pinpointed the source as Bilbo’s empty stomach.
“Well, now we know what called you back!” Fíli exclaimed.
Bombur sighed and rolled ponderously to his feet, but Dwalin pushed him down.
“Thorin,” Balin said, “why don’t you find some food for our guest?”
Thorin looked like a hare caught out on a cart-road.
“I’d be honored,” Bofur said, then backtracked after Fíli surreptitiously kicked him. “But Thorin would be a better choice. He hasn’t done much of late, anyhow.”
“No respect for your king,” Glóin muttered.
Bofur grinned. “Oh, I respect Dwalin plenty.”
Thorin seemed to force a smile at the following laughter, then walked into the hall with Bilbo bobbing in his wake. Unable to stop himself, Bilbo glanced back at his hoard. Some merely waved. Others—Bofur, Dwalin, Oin—made suggestive hand gestures. Bilbo responded with Bifur’s favorite invectives, then hurried after Thorin.
Bilbo had been gone scarcely a fortnight, but Erebor had transformed in his absence. The passageways had been swept and dusted, and much of Smaug’s marks had been mortared over or chiseled away. The air smelled of woodsmoke and smelted metal and Dwarves and other goodly things, and vibrated with the faint cacophony of industry.
“You frightened Dáin,” Thorin said when Bilbo caught up. “He sent a raven with a copy of your farewell letter and a missive begging my forgiveness.”
“Don’t chide me,” Bilbo scolded. “I’m five thousand years old.”
“You said three last time, O Agèd Wyrm,” Thorin said. Bilbo scowled. “Where did you go?”
“The Sea of Rhûn.” He shuddered. “Awful place. Too much sand, too many bugs—and the water tastes terrible.”
Thorin snorted.
“Have I missed much?” Bilbo asked. “Other than King Dwalin’s coronation, of course.”
“Long may he reign,” Thorin echoed.
“Did you renounce the throne?”
Thorin stopped and turned to face Bilbo. “Kíli is dead. I—I failed. I am unworthy to call myself king.”
His voice broke on his denied title.
“You are the king the company followed,” Bilbo said. “The king that I followed.” He added, somewhat drily, “Which should mean a great deal more to you than the endorsement of the other twelve.”
Thorin did not look up.
“You were sick, Thorin,” Bilbo added. “The sickness passed, and you are stronger for it.”
“Kíli—”
“We both failed him.” A tear darkened Bilbo’s tunic. He lifted Thorin’s chin. “But we must keep going. Together, if you’ll have me.”
Thorin hesitantly took his hand, the ball of his thumb working across Bilbo’s palm. “I will have you as a Dragon or Hobbit or any other form you choose, for all your days.”
“You ought to know I have many days ahead of me.” He laid his hand over Thorin’s. “Hobbits require a lot of provender—Hobbits who are Dragons doubly so.”
“You will be here to watch the mountain farms remade,” Thorin said. “In the days of my grandfather, we never wanted for food—although I suspect they would flourish all the more under a skilled gardener.”
“That may be a job worthy of my time,” Bilbo allowed, “but dragons are arrogant, and greedy, and vain. I will always demand more.”
“And I will grant it.”
“Then would you give me the rest of your life?”
“Yes,” Thorin said immediately.
“And if, Master Dwarf, I should ask for a kiss?”
Thorin’s lips parted, his ears flaring red. “Then, Master Dragon, I would kiss you.”
“Well,” Bilbo said, bouncing on his toes, “I am asking.”
Thorin smiled and leaned forward, until all Bilbo knew was the heat of Thorin’s mouth, and the sharp line of his teeth, and the caress of his hand. If this was not love, Bilbo did not want it. And if Thorin was his death, he was as welcome as springtime and glad tidings and hot meals on cold nights.
Bilbo pulled away first, but Thorin still leaned into him, his hair mussed and his cheeks aglow.
“I swore never to ask anything more of you,” Thorin murmured, his voice rough, “but might I kiss you this once?”
“I daresay you may kiss me as many times as you wish,” Bilbo said.
A sudden curse made them both turn, just as Ori was yanked behind the corner of the nearby passageway.
Bilbo sighed fondly as Thorin reddened. “Out with it!”
The company tumbled into view, their faces alight with glee. Dori was dabbing at tears with his handkerchief. Fíli met Bilbo’s eye and winked.
“Is a king to have no privacy in his own realm?” Thorin demanded, more amused than angry.
“Go on!” Bofur said. “Give him a kiss, why don’t you? I didn’t see the first one over Dwalin’s fat head.”
As Dwalin protested, Bilbo pulled Thorin close and pressed his mouth to his, tangling his fingers in his hair. Thorin pushed by their joined lips until Bilbo leaned back, with only Thorin’s hand between his shoulders keeping him upright as the company cheered.
When Thorin permitted Bilbo to stand again, Bilbo gave him a peck on the cheek and said, “That is quite enough showboating for today, Master Dwarf! We have a kingdom to rebuild.”
And, with that, they returned to the company.
Notes:
Translations
Uslukhaluk—tiny dragon (affectionate)For Shep, who kept the fire burning, and vilelithe, who holds the tinder.
