Chapter Text
The vale of Erebor was disturbingly tranquil. No birds sang, no smoke rose from distant fires, no boulders tumbled down from the heights, and no rain fell. Clouds smothered the mountain like hot, wet blankets both day and night.
Bilbo, from his position atop Ravenhill, saw all, but what he saw was nothing. He had expected Tauriel to appraise the gates, Bard to seek shelter, or Thranduil to kill him, but it seemed like the wider world had forgotten the Lonely Mountain.
Bilbo rolled onto his back and wriggled, his scales rasping against the weathered stones of the old courtyard at just the right angle to slake his abominable itch. His scales were nearly regrown, but they would not fade to their usual oak green for a month.
His needs met, he curled up again, facing south towards Long Lake. Black and silver flickered across his vision and Bilbo looked up eagerly, his mind’s eye already filling in Bifur’s grizzled hair and beard. A raven settled onto a crumbled column and shuffled its feathers, head cocked. Bilbo considered roasting it out of spite, but he was on Ravenhill. The raven had likely been here first.
Suddenly heartsick, Bilbo leapt from the courtyard and soared into Erebor, managing the journey with only one flap of his wings.
“Anything?” Dwalin asked as Bilbo dressed.
“Nothing.” Bilbo glanced up to where the Dwarf stood guard. The armory had been emptied and the familiar curve of Dwalin’s tattooed scalp had been replaced by hard steel and gems. “Oh, I, ah, saw a raven.”
“Did it say anything?”
“Uh. No?” Bilbo pulled his Laketown jumper over his head. “Should it have?”
“Some can carry messages,” Dwalin said. “Thorin sent one to Dáin yesterday.”
“Who’s that?”
“Our cousin, Lord of the Iron Hills.” Dwalin leaned on his ax. “He’ll be here by week’s end with more than enough soldiers to keep Thranduil off our mountain.”
Bilbo crossed his arms. “You really think it’ll come to that?”
“You heard him.”
A week ago, Bilbo would have welcomed a rematch with Thranduil. Now, he only wanted peace. “Maybe we can negotiate with him. We have the mountain and his gems.”
“You did your part with Smaug,” Dwalin said. “We’ll deal with Thranduil. Thorin wants you in the treasury.”
Bilbo sighed as the usual state of affairs reasserted itself. “I’m sure he does.” He glanced up at Dwalin. “Has Thorin been … odd to you, lately?”
Dwalin did not answer immediately. “We haven’t been home in a long time.”
Bilbo did not press him for more. He picked up his cane and racked his brain for the proper Khuzdul farewell. “Galkhismêr.”
“Bifur taught you well,” Dwalin said quietly.
Bilbo’s stride hitched. The halls refracted the slip with cold mockery.
The Dwarves had rigged mirrors and lanterns across the treasury’s vastness, illuminating it for the first time in centuries. The company picked their way along like crabs, dark spots in the golden sea. No one looked up when Bilbo entered.
“Bilbo!” Thorin called from a higher platform. “Up here!”
Bilbo slung his cane over his back to free his hands as he fought for purchase on the treacherous coins. He was panting by the time he reached solid ground. He bent double, feeling the weight of Thorin’s gaze but no urgency to meet it. Finally, he brushed diamond dust from his threadbare jumper and straightened up.
As in Khazad-dûm, the Dwarves had assumed a more regal—and more arrogant, in Bilbo’s opinion—bearing. The Raven Crown had elevated Thorin to new heights, and he had traded his traveling clothes for ermine and silk, and his steel beads for gold. Bilbo was underwhelmed: his Arkenstone needed no framing.
“What passes beyond my domain?” Thorin asked.
“Nothing,” Bilbo panted. “I’ve seen neither hide nor hair of anything for days.”
“They will come.” Thorin’s lip curled. “Men. Elves. Maybe even wizards. All of them crave our kingdom.”
“Might welcome the wizard,” Bilbo admitted. “He might be rude and nosy, but he’s helped.”
“I have seen the tower of Orthanc and heard tell of the treasures within. Wizards are not immune to greed.” Thorin put a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “But let us speak of better things. How is your leg?”
“Almost healed,” Bilbo said, mirroring Thorin’s cheer. His ill mood would pass; it always did. “Nothing the sun can’t fix.”
“And what of your heart?”
“…Pardon?”
“We lost Bifur,” Thorin said. “You lost a piece of your hoard.”
Thorin was correct, but hearing Bifur referred to as a piece of Bilbo’s hoard seemed terribly crass. “I … I can’t talk about it. I’m sorry.”
Old anger tinted Thorin’s eyes. “The dragon took much from us both.”
The skeletons from the front halls had been moved to the catacombs, but the company found more dead in every corridor. Worse were the disembodied limbs or heads, or the Dwarves that Smaug had simply swallowed whole. Worse still was the empty space in the company’s bedrolls, and the too-tall spear that Bombur now carried.
Thorin suddenly bristled like an angry warg. “Glóin!”
From across the chamber, the red-haired Dwarf dropped the goblet he had been holding.
“We must find the Arkenstone,” Thorin told him. “We have no time to delay.”
“Aye, Thorin!” Glóin shouted back, and began sifting through the gold again.
“The work would go faster if they were not led so easily astray by cheap trinkets,” Thorin told Bilbo.
“They’re tired,” Bilbo said, which was the truth: the company’s exhaustion was his, too. “Or bored. They could be doing other tasks like fortifying the gates or hunting game. I saw a raven on Ravenhill. Dwalin said—”
Thorin’s hand closed painfully on his shoulder. “No task,” he whispered, “is more important than finding the King’s Jewel. Without it, I have no armies, no power. The title of King Under the Mountain is as empty for me as it was for Smaug.” Hot, covetous desire sparked his eyes. “I need it.”
Bilbo recoiled in disgust.
“What is it?” Thorin asked, his brows drawing close.
“Leg’s a little wobbly, is all,” Bilbo lied. “Lost my balance.”
“May I?” With Bilbo’s permission, Thorin took his cane from his hands. “I can find you others, made of steel and black iron. Such was the mastery of my forebears that their canes could support a cave troll, while remaining as light as a feather.”
Bilbo swiped his cane back. “Only poor gardeners blame their trowels.” Thorin’s unexpected tenderness had not quelled his unease—but neither did his anxiety stifle the pathetic fluttering in his heart. “I … I’ll be on Ravenhill.”
Thorin inclined his head. Bilbo took it as permission to leave. He had gotten a few yards when Thorin called after him.
“Have your plans regarding Erebor changed since Smaug’s death?”
Bilbo turned. “What do you mean?”
“You said you would travel,” Thorin said, the threads of some strange anxiety strangling his voice.
“I suppose I did.”
“Stay, Bilbo,” Thorin commanded. “Stay and see my kingdom restored to such great heights that even Khazad-dûm cannot compare.” Before Bilbo could respond, Thorin pulled a shimmering shirt from his robes. “Have this as a token of my regard.”
The corselet in Thorin’s hands would have fit a Hobbit perfectly, but that was not its most remarkable attribute: it was pure mithril. Bilbo almost tasted its worth, through both his draconic instincts and Thorin’s reverent presentation.
“You don’t need to buy my loyalty,” Bilbo said.
Thorin studied him through the pale rings. “Call it insurance.”
“No treasure has a greater hold on me than my hoard,” Bilbo reminded him.
“Then you will have no issue accepting.”
Long had Bilbo chased Thorin’s approval, only to be offered a mithril corselet and a place at his side in the same breath—and yet.
“I will stay in Erebor,” Bilbo promised, “as long as the company does.”
Hope broke across Thorin’s face like the dawn, but doubt shadowed his voice. “As long as the company does.”
Bilbo heard Thorin’s unasked question, but for all his bravado, he was not ready to answer. He reached out with grubby hands, unsure if he wanted to take the mithril or the Dwarf king behind it. “Thorin, I—” His head snapped up at the surge of irritation coming from Dwalin. “Something’s at the gate.”
Thorin’s hand flew to Orcrist. To the other Dwarves, he shouted, “To the gate!” As they scrambled for their weapons, he said to Bilbo, “I require your other talents.”
Bilbo stuffed the mithril unceremoniously into his pack and skidded down the gold, throwing his clothes atop the corselet. Finally, he took flight with his pack clasped in his back feet. He overshot Dwalin—who had been coming to warn them—and then Erebor’s gate.
The cause of Dwalin’s concern was apparent: Bard was riding towards Erebor. Something flashed below and Bilbo dipped below the clouds to investigate. The ruins of Dale had been flooded overnight by Laketown’s survivors, and the few possessions and livestock they had saved from Smaug. Mingling amongst them were Elves clad in the russet armor of the Woodland Realm.
Thranduil had come.
Bilbo returned to the battlements and alighted beside Thorin, his teeth bared.
“What is it?” Thorin asked.
Bilbo raised a talon and put it near his ear.
“Elves?”
Bilbo nodded.
“The Elves and Men have allied against us, as they always do,” Thorin said. “Let Bard see you. He should know what he stands against, ere he takes the mountain.”
“There’s no chance of that,” Kíli declared.
“Do not doubt the craftiness of Men,” Thorin snapped. “Make ready!”
The armed and armored company marched onto the battlements. Their burnished armor gleamed: a sampling of the treasury secreted below. Bilbo stretched to cover the rest of the walkway and rested his chin on the wall to peer over the makeshift crenellations.
“That’s Ginny,” Fíli muttered, and Bilbo realized that Bard’s mount was indeed the golden mare that Fíli had bought in Rohan and lost in their confrontation with Thranduil.
“She must be their bargaining chip,” Kíli joked.
“Or their weapon,” Fíli said.
“Quiet,” Thorin commanded.
Whether through acclimation or sheer dumb bravery, Ginny brought Bard right up to the wall. The former captain of the guards had swapped his threadbare red tabard for an equally ragged brown tunic, and added a sword to his longbow.
“Who are you that come armed for war to the gates of Thorin son of Thráin, King Under the Mountain?” Thorin demanded.
Bard dropped Ginny’s reins and opened his hands in a gesture of conciliation—or supplication. “Hail, King Thorin. I did not think to find you alive after Smaug’s awakening, but I am glad to see I was wrong, so that we might parlay.”
“Name your errand,” Thorin called down.
“I am here on the matter of fair settlement,” Bard said. “Smaug destroyed Laketown and, with it, our homes and livelihoods. More bodies wash ashore every day. Hundreds are wounded, sleeping under the sky with nothing more than the clothes on their backs. I have come to collect our share of Erebor’s treasure in our hour of need. We aided and sheltered you, and have reaped nothing but sorrow and ruin, though unintended.”
If Bilbo had been a Hobbit, he would have shuffled his feet sheepishly. There was justice in Bard’s speech, even if his words were rather insolent.
“By what right do you speak for them?” Thorin sneered.
Bard sighed. “King Girion was my ancestor. For that, and for slaying Smaug, the people of Laketown have chosen me to lead following the Master’s death.”
From his shadowed eyes and patchwork beard, it seemed royalty did not agree with the former guard. Bilbo’s king cut a much more impressive figure: terrible and noble as he glared down at Bard, poised to dispense mercy—and gold—to the suffering Men as if he were tossing scraps to a cur.
“You will not have it,” Thorin declared.
Bilbo exchanged looks with the company, as stunned as Bard.
“Dale and Erebor lived in harmony during Thrór’s reign,” Bard said. “Gold flowed freely between the mountain and the city. I would have those days return, but we cannot help you if we are scrounging for food!”
“The treasure belongs to Dwarves of Erebor, not to Smaug, and I will not parcel out the wealth of my people to pay for the dragon’s misdeeds.”
“Smaug ransacked Dale and the surrounding towns as well,” Bard objected. “Dale’s wealth is mixed among your own. Give us that much, so that we might feed and shelter ourselves before winter comes.”
Balin leaned towards Thorin, but Thorin waved him away.
“So long as an armed host sits on our threshold, I will accord you as foes and thieves,” Thorin said.
“I did not know what to expect when I approached,” Bard said, his gaze drifting to Bilbo.
“I am also of a mind to ask what share of the inheritance you would pay to our heirs and kindred had you found us dead—or undefended.”
“A fair question,” Bard said impatiently, “but a cruel one, and unnecessary, as we are not robbers and you are not dead.”
“And how you and Thranduil weep to see it,” Thorin snarled. “I will not negotiate with Elf-friends and their ilk. If that is all you came to say, begone! The wealth of Erebor belongs only to its king.”
Balin turned aside. Bilbo sensed a half-forgotten ache settling into the old Dwarf’s bones.
“If we do not reach an agreement, Thranduil will march against you,” Bard said.
“You forget,” Thorin said, “that we have a dragon.”
On cue, Bilbo yawned, letting the morning light play on his fangs. The company cheered and hollered insults as Bilbo’s gaze rolled over to Bard. He fixed the Man with what he hoped was an intimidating stare.
“Peace, Master Baggins!” Bard said, shielding himself from Bilbo’s sight. “Captain Tauriel tells me that you opened Smaug’s hide for the black arrow. For that, you have my gratitude. You vouched for Thorin in Laketown! I know his character, and yours. Do not let him use you.”
“Neither dragons nor kings need listen to Men,” Thorin said, to another round of cheers from the company.
Bard seized his horse’s reins, his shoulders tightening. “You gave us your word, Thorin! Your oath that you would give us what we were owed—”
“You are owed nothing!” Thorin roared. “While the Dwarves of Erebor labored and starved in exile, where were the Men of Dale? Rebuilding in the shadow of Thranduil’s hall, growing fat off your fisheries and trade! Get thee gone, whelp of Girion! There is no succor for you here!”
Bard cursed in frustration and wheeled Fíli’s horse back to Dale.
“Kíli,” Thorin said. The young Dwarf ripped his eyes from Bard. “Shoot the horse.” He turned to Bilbo. “Do not leave Erebor.” Thorin looked to the rest of the company. “Back to the treasure room. The Arkenstone is still missing.”
Half the company—Bilbo included—remained on the battlements after Thorin departed to share a silence punctuated by the retreating clop of Ginny’s hooves. Kíli inhaled sharply, drew an arrow, and shot it over the wall. A pained whinny sounded a moment later, followed by a thud and a curse.
“Nicked her flank,” Kíli explained to a horrified Fíli. “She threw Bard.”
Fíli nodded, mollified. “That’s my Siginmazn.”
“You disobeyed your king,” Oin told Kíli.
Kíli shrugged, then impatiently brushed his hair aside. “Fear not, Oin. I interpreted.”
Bilbo ensured the remounted Bard was far away before he shifted into his Hobbit form.
“Something’s not right here,” Bilbo said, stepping into his trousers. “Thorin would never go back on his word like that!”
“Tharbad,” Nori supplied, and was met with Dwalin’s fiercest scowl. “What?”
“Those Men cheated us, just as Bard cheated us,” Dwalin growled.
“And arrested us!” added Kíli.
“Bard is one Man,” Bilbo said. “There are hundreds on our doorstep, most having just lost the one place they call home to dragonfire. Who cares about rights when there’s … well, what’s right?”
“Nothing more than that Man deserves for allying himself with tree-shaggers,” Glóin declared, to general agreement.
“Thorin will negotiate,” Dwalin said, “after Thranduil is gone.”
“He’ll right himself when he has the Arkenstone,” Dori added.
“The people of Laketown can’t wait,” Bilbo said. “They have nothing.”
Fíli crossed his arms. “It does get cold up here.”
“And we did wake Smaug!” Bilbo said. “If you want to point fingers, I woke Smaug. And—”
“Sounds like he was a bit of a light sleeper,” Bofur said. “You shouldn’t blame yourself.”
“Come!” Thorin bellowed from within Erebor.
The remaining company obediently departed, save for Balin and Bilbo. Balin’s eyes shone with unshed tears.
“You’re right, Bilbo,” Balin said. “Thorin is not himself. There is a sickness on this gold and he has fallen ill.”
Bilbo frowned. “What do you mean, ill?”
“There is a curse on the Line of Durin,” Balin said. “Dragonsickness, we call it: an obsession with gold that consumes the mind.”
“No,” Bilbo said. “No, not Thorin. He’s just tired. We all are.”
“You saw how he spoke to Bard. I have heard those words before, from Thorin’s grandfather, Thrór. He had it, and we watched it destroy him. It was he who ordered us to retake Khazad-dûm at any cost…” Balin pressed a hand to his mouth. “I fear that Thorin would die before parting with a single piece of treasure.”
“No, he just did,” Bilbo insisted. “Look. He gave me—” Bilbo shoved the mithril shirt under Balin’s nose. “Trust me, if he was feeling particularly dragon-ish, he would not have done this. I can still reason with him.”
“I hope you can, lad,” Balin said. He wiped his eyes. “Or else there’s no hope for us.”
Bilbo watched him go, then shivered with a chill that had nothing to do with the temperature and everything to do with the wretched mountain. Smaug had dwelt here too long, fermenting in his malice and cupidity until it seeped into the very stones.
They have seen my gold; it will drive them mad and you will go mad with them.
If Balin and Smaug spoke true, threats against Erebor’s gold would only exacerbate Thorin’s belligerence. Bilbo had needed the deaths of two very dear friends and thousands of years to relinquish his hoard—but time was the one luxury the company did not have.
Bilbo took up his cane and limped straight for the treasury. The racket the Dwarves made while picking, kicking, and sifting through the coins concealed his passage. Working on a well-informed gut feeling, he climbed up to Smaug’s bed and burrowed into the gold. His fingers closed around something smooth and a shock sizzled all the way to his toes, like touching a doorknob in winter. He wormed his way free with his prize.
The Arkenstone was scarcely larger than his palm and heavy for its size. As Bilbo lifted the great jewel, its facets transformed the torchlight into a rainbow as dazzling as trapped moonlight. After hearing the Dwarves wax poetic for months, though, Bilbo was underwhelmed. He rolled the Arkenstone into his mithril corselet and tossed it into his pack before returning to the battlements.
There he stayed, even after the last rays of sunlight disappeared behind Erebor’s shoulder. He watched the fires ignite within Dale’s ruins—bonfires for burning Eru knew what, cookfires, and torches bobbing along the walls like fireflies. He watched, and saw nothing, for his mind was bent towards the company, obsessively counting and recounting them, poring over any emotion he gleaned from their minds. He felt grief, especially from the Ur brothers. He felt determination. He felt a spiky morass of exhaustion, fear, and anxiety. The hope they had kindled for Erebor’s future had been snuffed out.
The Dwarves periodically checked on him, but Bilbo remained a dragon until the evening deepened and Fíli finally approached. Bilbo took care to transform and dress before the prince arrived.
“Bombur’s fixing dinner,” Fíli said as he climbed. “Salted herring soup again. Don’t save me a bowl.”
“Do we still have biscuits?” Bilbo asked.
Fíli crested the top of the stairs. “Bofur ate the last one. Take it up with him; he’s coming to stand watch with me. And no Arkenstone, of course, but Uncle’s sure we’ll find it.” He glanced at the corselet bundled in Bilbo’s arms. “Is that mithril?”
“Fíli—”
“Hey there!” Bofur shouted up to them. “Does your arse ache yet, Bilbo? You’ve been on that wall all day!”
“The stone’s still warm,” Bilbo said, his hands reflexively tightening around the corselet.
Bofur stomped up the steps and leaned against the crenelations. Thus supported, he pulled out his pipe. Bilbo and Fíli both tensed in anticipation.
“Easy, lads,” Bofur said, laughing. “It’s empty.” He champed at the end. “Doesn’t mean I can’t pretend. I’ve had a lot of practice.”
“Share your secret,” Fíli all but moaned.
“The trick is imagination,” Bofur said, “but I doubt princes get much practice at that.” He shifted into a more comfortable position. “Did I interrupt you, Bilbo?”
Bilbo had wanted privacy, but wasn’t sure he would have another chance. He unwrapped the mithril. Fíli uttered a startled oath. Bofur’s unlit pipe dropped from his lips.
“You may have trouble sorting through all that treasure,” Bilbo said, “but you forgot you have a creature designed to root out anything of value.”
“Bilbo,” Fíli breathed. “Is that…?”
“The Arkenstone, or as near as I can figure,” Bilbo said grimly, rocking back on his heels. “You did a terrible job describing it.”
“No, that’s it.” Fíli reached for it. “It has to be.”
“What are you going to do with it?” Bofur asked.
“I’m giving it to Fíli,” Bilbo said, meeting the young prince’s eyes.
“I’ll give it to Uncle,” Fíli said. “He’ll be glad you found it.”
“No, Fíli,” Bilbo said. “Thorin is not himself. You know that—and Bofur knows it.”
Fíli snatched his hand back. “Keep it from him? But that’s … that’s treason.”
Bofur, too, had turned ashen. “To turn against one’s king is worse than kinslaying. Thorin would be in his rights to assume the worst of you.”
Fíli looked at Bilbo, his fright eerily underlit by the Arkenstone. “If I took it, I would be declaring myself King Under the Mountain. I’d never betray him like that.”
Bilbo appealed to Bofur. “You know Thorin isn’t in his right mind. If he gets worse, it could cost his life—all of our lives.” The Dwarves glared at him until he added, “I know you’d jump off a cliff if Thorin asked. I would, too. He’s more than earned my—our—respect and loyalty and … and love.” Bilbo took a deep breath. “But we can’t let him destroy everything we have traveled so far and given up so much to achieve. We can’t let him shatter his own dream—the very thing everyone has been working towards for nearly two hundred years!”
“With the Arkenstone, Thorin would unite the armies of the Dwarves,” Fíli said, his voice strained but proud. “We would chase Bard and Thranduil—”
“Bard does not have an army,” Bilbo interrupted. “He and his people are hungry—destitute, I might add, thanks to us. Thranduil is old and rich, and he has his allies. If you attack him, there will be retaliation, and if he attacks you, Dáin will kill him. And after Dwarves and Men and Elves shatter the North, orcs and wargs will feast on your bones.”
Bilbo tried for indignation, but Khazad-dûm’s fate imposed on Erebor too terrible to stoke his rage.
“Fíli,” Bilbo said, “I wouldn’t ask this of you if there was another way. I’m not saying you have to keep the Arkenstone forever. You don’t even have to tell him you have it. This … Thorin’s sickness … I might have a cure, but I need time.”
“You have a cure?” Bofur asked.
Bilbo spread his hands. “I know it can be overcome.”
Bofur recovered his pipe, then jabbed it at the Arkenstone. “Well, I’ll be honest, I can’t say Thorin speaks for me or Bombur when it comes to Laketown—or what’s left of it. Fíli, you’re my crown prince. I’ll follow you.”
“I’m barely an adult,” Fíli whispered. “I’ve never fought any battles or led our people.”
“You’ve a good head on your shoulders,” Bofur said. “I’ve seen that clear as crystal.”
“You don’t need to be Thorin to be a good king,” Bilbo said.
Fíli cautiously extended his hand and Bilbo gave him the Arkenstone. The King Under the Mountain trembled at its touch.
“Tell no one,” Bilbo warned. “Not even Kíli.”
Fíli hesitated, then nodded. “I promise.” He tucked the Arkenstone into his tunic. “I hope it never comes to this.”
“Nor do I,” Bofur said. “But if it does—” He bowed deeply “—you have my ax.”
“And whatever I can offer,” Bilbo said.
Fíli’s lips twitched. “I should’ve known you were serious the moment I realized you’d turned against Uncle.”
“Yes, well.” Bilbo rubbed his neck. “I should be getting inside. Let’s hope for tomorrow.”
“Night,” Bofur and Fíli chorused.
Bilbo descended the stairs, the hot weight of treachery burning in his breast.
