Chapter Text
Bard did not return. The company welcomed the respite, but their king perceived a more sinister motive.
“The Elves are training the Dalefolk to march against us,” Thorin declared as he paced before the throne. His eyes darted to the cracked stone where the Arkenstone had rested. “And the King’s Jewel is still not found.” He turned with a rustle of copper silk. “We have been searching for twelve days. Where is it?”
“The treasury is enormous, my king,” Balin said, inclining his head. “As it is, we haven’t slept properly in days and our food is running low.”
“You can sleep when you’re dead,” Thorin snapped, “as we soon will be if I do not have the Arkenstone before Dáin arrives. I expect several thousand of his finest by the week’s end.”
“I could look for Dáin,” Bilbo suggested, “or bring news.”
“You are not to leave Erebor.”
Bilbo had not left the mountain since Bard’s visit; Thorin had insisted on keeping him close. Even in the throne hall, Bilbo had been stationed beside him, and Balin—Thorin’s own blood—stood below the dais like a supplicant.
“We will find the Arkenstone,” Balin promised.
“If anyone has found it and is withholding it from me…” Thorin descended from the throne, each footfall lending minatory weight to his words. “I shall be avenged.”
Balin did not meet Thorin’s eye. Bilbo’s heart ached for the old Dwarf.
“Thorin,” Bilbo said. Thorin’s head jerked sideways as his name died in echoes. “They won’t search well without sleep. Vision blurs, your hands shake, you forget things—all sorts of nasty stuff.”
“I have felt no such affliction,” Thorin said.
“They clearly lack your iron will.” He licked his lips. “Please, Thorin. I’m sure they’ll look twice as hard after a rest.”
The tension bled from Thorin’s shoulders. “They may sleep for an hour, if they must. Bilbo, with me.”
Bilbo scampered after Thorin’s long strides, smiling apologetically as he passed Balin and receiving only pain in return.
“You no longer use the cane,” Thorin observed as they walked—inevitably—towards the treasury. Balin trailed a few yards behind.
“A few days of basking and my leg’s as right as rain,” Bilbo said.
“And your tail?”
“I lied,” Bilbo admitted. “It’s not growing back.”
Thorin halted. “Never?”
“It was just a few inches,” Bilbo said dismissively. “I’m glad to be rid of it. Would’ve healed crooked anyway—and I’m told battle scars are quite impressive.”
“You do not require them,” Thorin said. “Thranduil and Bard have no doubt kept their distance because of your presence.”
Bilbo was too frazzled to preen. “Thank you.” He hiked a thumb over his shoulder. “Speaking of, I should return to the wall. I don’t fancy—”
“Stay,” Thorin said. He did not speak with the callous authority he had lately wielded. His voice was soft, almost doubtful.
“Of course,” he said. “As—as long as someone sufficiently frightening is standing watch. Dwalin, maybe, or Bifur, even though—” Grief sheared away the thought. “Never mind.”
Their silence was an unwelcome third as they entered the treasury.
“You have one hour of rest,” Thorin declared. “Dwalin, Kíli—guard the gates.”
“Where’s Bilbo?” Kíli asked, peering out from behind a column with his brother.
“He has other duties.” Thorin’s tone brooked no argument.
“Nothing’s wrong,” Bilbo reassured them. “Just a little cold and stiff. A stone wall isn’t the most pleasant place to spend a week.”
Fíli met Bilbo’s eye and shook his head. No improvement.
Bilbo reluctantly nodded.
Thorin scrutinized each of the returning Dwarves as if his red-rimmed glare could sear the Arkenstone from their pockets. He never answered their greetings, although few still solicited them. Most wordlessly collapsed atop the ledge they had camped on. Bilbo’s gaze lingered on the emptiness between Bofur and Bombur. He tucked another blanket around Bombur and hurried off.
He found Thorin along the western slope of the treasury, picking through coins as if they were as fragile as glass.
“I think the company searched here yesterday,” Bilbo said.
“They likely overlooked something in their carelessness,” Thorin said.
“You should sleep, too.”
“I am no stranger to exhaustion,” Thorin said, “nor hunger, nor thirst. I endured worse in exile.”
“You’re not in exile anymore. You’re home—you’re the King Under the Mountain.”
Thorin turned with the same ponderous menace he had displayed in the throne room. Any dragon could read him: this was a cornered predator.
“I cannot call myself that,” he snarled, “so long as I lack the Arkenstone.”
“You’re already a king to me,” Bilbo said, “and the rest of the company.”
“Do not speak to me of the company.” He lurched closer. “One of them has found the Arkenstone. One of them keeps it from me. One of them is false.”
“One of whom, Thorin?” Bilbo demanded. “One of your friends, your family? We’ve all risked our lives for you—Bifur died for you.”
“It was a mercy that he died before the rest embroiled him in their scheme.”
Bilbo suppressed the visceral urge to slap Thorin. He’s sick. He doesn’t mean it. “You should rest: the only dragon for leagues is me and I’m certainly not going to take anything.”
“That is why you have my utmost trust, Bilbo,” Thorin said hoarsely. “You alone of all the company.”
Bilbo propped his hands on his hips. “Now that is absolutely ridiculous. After all—”
Thorin approached with such rapidity that Bilbo’s skin erupted in scales, but Thorin only laid his ring-laden hands on Bilbo’s shoulders. “No earthly treasure can sway your loyalty. You alone still honor the friendship we forged.”
“What—?”
“Your bond causes you to think the best of them,” Thorin said with a king’s indulgence, “but my vision is unfettered: in their greed, they have forsaken our quest, and us, by denying me the Arkenstone.”
“Can’t we sort that out later?” Bilbo asked. “The people of Laketown—they’re starving and autumn’s coming, and you gave them your word. I gave them my word, on your behalf! Fine, yes, we can continue looking for the Arkenstone, but—”
“This gold is ours,” Thorin whispered, his eyes as lightless as Mirkwood, “and I will not part with even a single piece.”
“I want to part with it,” Bilbo insisted. “I want the Men to have their share—my share, if I must! I want to see the Erebor—and the Dale—you’ve been telling me about.” He felt on the verge of tears as he cupped Thorin’s face. “Please, Thorin.”
Thorin’s smile bloomed with the same cautious beauty as a morning glory greeting the sunrise. Once, Bilbo had ached to capture that beneath his lips—but that had been before Erebor, before Smaug, before Bifur’s funeral. Now, that same smile only deepened his dread.
“You have a tender heart, Master Baggins,” Thorin said. “You will see, in time, that all my actions were to protect it.”
Bilbo was so stunned that words quite failed him. If Thorin would not hear the truth, only lies remained. “I … no. It’s my duty to protect you and … and I need you to trust me now: you need rest.”
Thorin frowned. “I must keep searching.”
“I’ll do it.” Bilbo laid his hands over Thorin’s and pressed down, lowering them both onto the gold. “I’m a dragon. I’ll know the Arkenstone before I see it.”
They were kneeling across from each other now. Thorin half-heartedly sifted through the nearest gems, then jolted upright. “I cannot sleep. Not while these traitors—”
“I’ll be right here,” Bilbo soothed. “I won’t let anything happen to you.”
Thorin listed, his eyelids drooping even before his head hit Bilbo’s lap. The Raven Crown’s prongs stabbed Bilbo’s thighs as he combed his fingers through Thorin’s silvered hair.
“Stay,” Thorin whispered. His fear remained even as sleep took him. “Stay.”
Thorin’s scalp was feverish and his hair was slick with grease, but Bilbo could not stop touching him, could not stop soothing both Thorin and himself with the repetition. Bilbo would have taken this moment as his fourteenth share. He would have taken this moment every morning for the rest of their shared lives. Thorin did not need to ask: more than anything, despite everything, Bilbo wanted to stay.
Too short a time later, Kíli’s voice rang through the treasury. “Bard and Thranduil are back!”
Thorin leapt to his feet, swaying as he regained his balance. “Arm yourselves! They will not take Erebor without a fight.” To Bilbo, he said, “Do as you wish. You carry a king’s trust.”
Bilbo forced a smile and sprinted for the gate with Thorin. They arrived well ahead of the still-waking company, and stood with Dwalin to watch the host of the Woodland Realm march on the Lonely Mountain. Each Elf was armored and armed with a bow, spear, and shield. Thranduil—once again atop his elk—rode at their fore, dressed in burnished steel and an ostentatious crimson cloak. Beside him, Bard was even dowdier and grimmer than usual. The Men behind him carried weapons requisitioned from their trades: gaff hooks, smithing hammers, oars.
Bilbo looked to the east, to the rocky shoulder that Dáin would surmount, but the ridge was empty; vultures wheeled overhead. To the west, towering storm clouds marched on the mountain. Lightning flashed in their depths like sun off glass.
The company arrived at the gate and arrayed themselves around Thorin, who glared down with regal disdain as Thranduil halted his army a hundred yards from the Erebor. He and Bard rode up alone. Bard, Bilbo was amused to see, had retained golden Ginny, who sported a bandaged flank.
“Hail to the King Under the Mountain,” Thranduil said, his words dripping with contempt. “When Bard told me you had survived, I could scarce believe it. I had to see with my own eyes.”
Thorin gestured impatiently for Kíli’s bow. Kíli handed it over and Thorin nocked an arrow, aiming at Thranduil.
Bard began to back his horse, but Thranduil motioned for him to wait. He said, “Assuming you can count, you will see you are outnumbered by several thousand to … twelve, it seems.”
“Thirteen!” Bilbo yelled, sticking his head over the battlements.
Thranduil flinched. “I had not thought a dragon would keep company with Dwarves. How much as Thorin promised you? I guarantee he will not let you keep it.”
“Fancy words for someone who came for the Gems of Lasgalen,” Thorin retorted. “Withdraw your armies or I will have the Gems destroyed before your very eyes!”
“You’re outnumbered, Thorin,” Bard called. “Just give the people of Laketown what we are owed!”
Bilbo knew Bard’s mistake moments before Thorin stiffened, his fur collar rising like a wolf’s hackles. “The people of Laketown,” Thorin spat. “You are nothing more than a front for the pointy-eared snake at your side. Thranduil’s promises are as empty as his heart.”
“King Thranduil brought us food and offered us protection,” Bard said. “See reason, Thorin! That is all we require.”
“I am seeing,” Thorin said. His arms shook under the strain of the bowstring. “I am seeing more clearly than I have in days. My promise to you was made under duress. Men have ever been the cronies of Elves: they must kill or possess anything they cannot make themselves. My oath to you holds no more weight than the one Girion made Thrór!”
The company remained stony-faced at Thorin’s pronouncement, letting their silence stand as tacit support. Beneath their helmets, they found their unease mirrored in a dozen other faces. Bilbo was too far away to see Fíli.
“We are not here to revisit the sins of our fathers!” Bard shouted.
“Indeed,” Thranduil said, “else we would be here for many generations.”
“Aye, and most of that accounting would be yours, you faithless sprite!” Dwalin bellowed. The Dwarves roared in approval.
“But if we were,” Bard said, “Smaug’s first victims were not Dwarves, but the Men of Dale. Smaug lies dead in Long Lake. We held up our end. Now I ask that you hold up yours.”
“You claim you do not wish to revisit the past, yet stake your claim on the same foundation of sand,” Thorin said. The wavering arrowhead shifted to Bard. “I will not surrender even a single coin: not to you, not to Esgaroth.”
Bard spread his hands. “I have three children: Bain, Sigrid, and Tilda. They’re going hungry. Please, Thorin.”
Thorin’s head half-turned to the east as the rain began. “Your pleas do not stir me. I will not parlay with robbers!”
“Pengryn,” Thranduil commanded. Rows of Elves nocked arrows in one synchronous click. The company—Bilbo included—ducked, but Thorin remained standing, his eyes blazing with the madness of a snared fox. Bilbo signaled Fíli. Fíli shook his head frantically.
A rumble deeper than thunder juddered the very stones of Erebor. Pebbles tumbled from the heights, forcing the company to shield themselves. Bilbo peeked over the wall just as three gargantuan worms retracted into the holes they had bored in the eastern cliffs. Seconds later, hundreds of wargs poured forth in a vile flood, coursing towards the Lonely Mountain. Thranduil rode before his army, shouting orders over the thunder and war drums. The Elves swiftly arrayed themselves to face the threat. Bard led the Men back to undefended Dale. Both armies seemed pitifully few against the orcs.
Thorin thrust both bow and arrow back at Kíli, aglow with vindictive satisfaction.
“Come,” Thorin commanded, turning back to Erebor. “Let the scavengers scrap on our doorstep. Should they gain entry, every hall will be bought with blood.”
Bilbo did not ask whose blood; he traded a look with Bombur that suggested he was equally uncertain.
The company straggled after Thorin, casting nervous glances at their abandoned wall. Fíli and Bofur whispered with each other until Dwalin chivvied them along. Bilbo saw Balin eye the pair speculatively.
Bilbo jogged up to Thorin and caught him by the arm. “Thorin, this is madness. People are dying out there.”
“Thirteen cannot change the tide of battle,” Thorin said, unperturbed, “but we can hold these halls as well as a hundred.”
“Imagine what Thranduil and Bard’s armies could do from a defensible position,” Fíli said. “You must let them into Erebor.”
“Think, Fíli! The Elves and Men will seize our gold.”
The company muttered fitfully, their voices overlapping and blurring into disconnected syllables. From without, they heard the clarion call of the Elvish warhorns and the bells of Dale, and precious little else. Bilbo’s imagination supplied the screams of imminent battle, the rain pounding the heath, and the clash of weaponry.
“We need Dáin,” Balin said. “If we knew where his army is—”
Bilbo raised his hand. “I could go. If he isn’t far—”
“No,” Thorin said. He leaned into Bilbo. “I have need of you here.”
Bilbo shivered at the closeness of his mouth, but a metallic bugle cut through his complacency. The sound wrenched him back to the plains of Dagorlad, to tides of orcs streaming out beneath him in response to that same sound.
“The Men of Laketown are out there, too!” Bofur cried.
“We cannae sit on our hands,” Glóin agreed, hefting his war hammer.
“Let Bilbo find Dáin,” Dwalin urged Thorin. “He can’t be far.”
“Why must you doubt me?!” Thorin roared. “I am your king!”
“No, Uncle,” Fíli said. All eyes snapped to him as he pulled the Arkenstone from his surcoat. “I, Fíli, son of Dís, am King Under the Mountain.”
The terrified tremble of Fíli’s armor was the only sound in the sudden hush. His face had gone as pale as his hair, but the Arkenstone burned ethereal in his eyes. Opposite him was Thorin: dark and utterly still, swallowed like a pebble in a well by Thrór’s crown and robes and armor.
“It can’t be,” Thorin said at last. “This is a trick. Or a lie. You … you would not betray me.”
Thorin looked wildly to Balin for confirmation.
“Fíli holds the Arkenstone,” Balin said heavily. “Of that, there is no mistaking.”
“You,” Thorin breathed, his eyes shining with tears. “You would dare… After all I have done for you…”
“I love you, ’adadith,” Fíli said, his voice cracking, “and I would follow you even to my own death, but you are not yourself!”
“Give it here,” Thorin ordered, “ere I cut it from your hand.”
Fíli clutched the Arkenstone to his chest. Any chance of a peaceful resolution evaporated before Bilbo’s eyes as Thorin drew Orcrist. The company shrank back, but Fíli did not relinquish the Arkenstone or defend himself. One of Kíli’s hands hovered on his bow, the other over Fíli’s shoulder, his expression wretched with indecision.
“Fíli,” Dwalin said softly. “Give it to Thorin, lad. There’s time to fix this.”
“Thorin is not himself,” Fíli told him. “Can’t you see that?”
“He is our king,” Dwalin said, but doubt colored his voice and he withdrew, frowning.
“I see a grasping parasite, eager for glory and wealth beyond his station,” Thorin hissed. “You are no heir of mine. Kíli, take it from him!”
Kíli positioned himself between Thorin and his brother. “Fíli’s right. This is not you.”
Thorin drew up short, but did not sheathe Orcrist. “Anyone?!” He spun wildly towards the terrified company. His gaze fell on Bilbo. Even now, vulnerability lingered in his eyes. “Not even you?”
Bilbo’s every instinct exhorted him to defend, to tear throats and rend limbs, but he was powerless when his hoard had turned against itself.
“I know what the Arkenstone is doing to you,” Bilbo said. “I know it calls to you.”
“Thorin,” Balin said. “Do not follow your grandfather.”
The pain in Thorin’s eyes mutated into hatred. Thorin had never looked at Bilbo like that, not even on the Barrowdowns.
“It’s not right,” Glóin said to no one. “We can’t have two kings.”
“There is only one king,” Thorin growled, “and he will have his due.”
A scuffle erupted behind Bilbo as Oin attempted to wrest the Arkenstone from Fíli. Kíli wrestled the old Dwarf aside with Bofur’s help, and then Dwalin plowed into the fray—on whose side, Bilbo could not say. Glóin sprang to his brother’s defense, only to be halted by Bombur, who held Bifur’s spear to his throat. Ori tackled Glóin. Balin dithered. Dori hauled Nori away from the confrontation by the arm, then reached for Ori. Bilbo dodged a stray punch and positioned himself between Thorin and his company.
“You’re tearing the company apart!” Bilbo told Thorin.
“There is no company,” Thorin snarled, grabbing the front of Bilbo’s shirt. “Only a band of brigands and thieves—and you. As if I could forget that we traveled with a dragon! I scarcely slept as I anticipated you murdering us all, kulkodar.”
The solution appeared with utter clarity. “Then kill me.” Grief had sundered Bilbo’s first hoard-bond; he could only hope that Thorin would mourn a dragon as acutely as Bilbo had mourned the Bagginses. “If I’m a monster, then kill me.”
“I won’t let you,” Balin said from behind Bilbo. “Thorin, this is not you.”
Dwalin—pinned between Kíli and Oin—made an inarticulate noise of fury. “Don’t you dare kill him! He isn’t our enemy!”
Thorin jerked back. The sounds of the fighting company died away. Bilbo felt Fíli trying to push him aside, but Bilbo held his ground.
“You are not Thrór,” Balin said. “You are our king.”
Thorin was blinking fast, his armor clanging with each heaving breath.
“I gave the Arkenstone to Fíli,” Bilbo declared. “It was me, Thorin: I caused this.”
Thorin leveled Orcrist with Bilbo’s heart. Were this truly a battle, Bilbo knew he could defeat Thorin, but his bloody days on Dagorlad had passed. The hunger clawing at his chest was no longer Orcrist’s loss, but Thorin’s presence: the knowledge that his own love would be the death of him.
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin snarled. “I will kill you, dragon, and be avenged.”
“Bilbo is not Smaug,” Bofur said. “We aren’t your enemies!”
“Uncle,” Fíli whispered. “Don’t do this.”
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin repeated, softer this time. Orcrist wobbled in his grip.
“You’re our uncle,” Kíli added. “Thorin, please. We need you.”
“I am not my grandfather,” Thorin repeated a third time, the embers of madness banked with growing dread. Bilbo captured his gaze and refused to look away, silently willing Thorin to do the same.
Dwalin carefully stepped around Bilbo and uncurled Thorin’s fingers from Orcrist. The Elven sword clanged to the ground. Everyone flinched. Thorin’s white-rimmed eyes shot from Bilbo to Dwalin.
Dwalin jerked his chin to the battlements. “Look.”
Thorin went, his movements slow and dreamy, with Dwalin a step behind. Bilbo picked up Orcrist and followed them, and the company trailed after. Only Dwalin and Bilbo mounted the battlements, where Thorin gripped the slick stone as he bore witness to the scene beyond.
The battle had scarcely begun: a vanguard of warg riders lay dead or dying on the eastern slopes, pierced with Elvish arrows. The main army was now marching from the heights. Thranduil’s archers took aim, barely thinning the ranks before the orcs slammed into the Elves’ pikes like a fist. Through the rain, something moved atop Ravenhill: a twisted weathervane hung with flags that were little more than blurs. A second host rushed from the burrows, outflanking the Elves towards Dale.
Thorin’s fingers curled around the Raven Crown. Bilbo, Dwalin, and the company watching below held their breath. Then, suddenly, he tore the crown from his head and hurled it off the battlements.
“Thorin?” Dwalin asked.
Thorin turned from the battle breaking outside his gates to his stricken company, lingering on his nephews.
“What have I done?” Thorin whispered.
