Actions

Work Header

Sang The Sun In Flight

Chapter 20: Snow After Fire

Summary:

The aftermath of the battle raises as many questions as it answers.

Chapter Text

Bilbo had rarely dwelt on what afterlife might await a creature of the Enemy. Secretly, he had hoped that several millennia spent as a Hobbit would send him on their unknown paths. He had not expected this. He had not expected agony. Death was pain: pain to devour all reason; pain to flense away everything but his own regret, self-hatred, and shame; pain without the surcease of sorrow.

The revelation that he had not, in fact, died was an unwelcome one.

“Oh, Bilbo,” Gandalf murmured. “Oh, my poor, dear fellow.”

Bilbo coiled tighter, attempting to compress himself into nothing. Gandalf sighed. Wood creaked to Bilbo’s left, followed by the familiar rustle of pipeweed tamped into a pipe. Gandalf muttered something under his breath. Old Toby tickled Bilbo’s nostrils, so familiar and homey that Bilbo wept.

Other sounds were filtering in now: muffled conversations, interspersed with quickly passing footsteps and the lowing of livestock.

“The battle is over,” Gandalf said. “We have won. Azog is dead. Erebor remains in the Dwarves’ hands. There is a King Under the Mountain again.”

Bilbo wrung some consolation from that. He knew before Gandalf had spoken that his Dwarves had survived with minor injuries, except for Bifur, over a week dead, and Kíli—

A scalding tear rolled down Bilbo’s cheek.

Gandalf sighed. “The Eagles found you in the Celduin and flew you here. You are currently a guest of Thranduil.”

Both of Bilbo’s eyelids flew open, his pupils contracting painfully as he looked directly into the Sun. A perfect rectangle had been cut out of the fluttering wool, permitting light to bathe his scales. He surged upright and found himself inside a spacious tent, lying atop a bed of smooth river stones warmed by a Dwarvish woodstove. Gandalf was perched on a stool, obscured by his broad-brimmed hat and a cloud of pipeweed. Thranduil’s foul accouterments were arrayed behind him: a carafe of red wine, a maple table with matching chairs, an armor stand, weavings from Doriath.

“You are his guest, Bilbo,” Gandalf said. “I would not let him hold you captive.”

The chill crept in again. Gandalf tucked a blanket over Bilbo’s shoulders and he transformed into a Hobbit.

“How—how long?” Bilbo rasped. “How long since the … the…?”

When Bilbo could not continue, Gandalf said, “It has been two days since you killed Azog.”

Bilbo plopped onto the hot stones, his hairy feet stuck out in front of him.

“The company has been visiting you,” Gandalf said. “I could scarcely light my pipe without igniting a beard.” His voice softened. “They do not blame you, Bilbo. No one does.”

Bilbo’s throat worked soundlessly. “If I hadn’t—if I wasn’t—”

“If you had not risen to the occasion, many more would have died,” Gandalf said. “You saved the lives of thousands—the innocents of Laketown, Dáin and his army, Thranduil and his host, Thorin and his company.”

“But—”

“They are calling it the Battle of the Five Armies,” Gandalf said, “for the Men, Elves, Dwarves, Eagles, and Dragon who shattered the host of Dol Guldur.”

Bilbo’s eyes grew hot and itchy. “I’m no hero, Gandalf.”

“Heroism is an honor bestowed, not a title pursued,” Gandalf said, exhaling another cloud. “You fought to defend what you loved most in this world. So did Kíli and Bifur.”

Bilbo shuddered at their names.

“Honor the love for which they gave their lives,” Gandalf said. “Only by living can we celebrate their victory.”

Bilbo drew the blanket closer. “It … it’s different. They…”

“They are your hoard,” Gandalf said. When Bilbo looked up, Gandalf added, “I guessed as much when we parted in Mirkwood, but if you had not come to the same conclusion, I did not want to frighten you.”

“You knew this would happen?” Bilbo demanded, shooting to his feet.

“I did not know you would claim the company as your hoard,” Gandalf said. “Wizards are not in the business of knowing: we merely have hunches that often turn out to be right!”

Bilbo struggled to hold the high ground. “Well, your hunch certainly benefited you.”

Gandalf puffed irritably at his pipe. “When I asked you to come on this quest, I had merely hoped you would finally leave your dusty burrow, and that Thorin and his company had met their equal in stubbornness and more than their match in reason. If you spent the whole of the quest as a Hobbit, I would have said nothing of it.”

Bilbo’s fury spluttered out. He sat back down.

With a ghost of a smile, Gandalf said, “You have always been terribly self-centered.”

“I’ve changed in other ways.”

Gandalf leaned down to offer him the pipe. Bilbo shook his head.

“Thranduil travels with excellent vintages,” Gandalf said, “and you are his guest.”

Bilbo tottered to the carafe and poured a measure for himself and Gandalf. He handed a glass to the wizard, who clinked it against Bilbo’s.

“To treasures greater than gold,” Gandalf said.

Bilbo raised his glass, then sipped. The wine was a strong Elvish red: sour and dark.

“What do I do, Gandalf?” Bilbo asked miserably. “Three thousand years and I’m still as spry as a hatchling. The Dwarves…”

“They will age, while you do not,” Gandalf confirmed. Bilbo cringed. “Love is never wasted, Bilbo. Do not fear it.”

“I’m not some moonstruck Elf-maid. It’s—this … what I feel isn’t love.”

“That is the voice of the Enemy,” Gandalf said sternly. “If Smaug were in your position, he would have locked the company in Erebor until he lorded over their bones.”

“I didn’t want to let them leave,” Bilbo snarled. “They died in front of me.”

“Will you jail the company?”

“No!”

“And whyever not?”

“Because—because—!” Bilbo’s hands balled into fists. “Because that’s not what they want. That’s not—before they were my hoard, they were my friends, and that’s not what friends do.”

Gandalf smiled.

“Oh, alright, you rotten wizard.” Bilbo’s mirth dissipated swiftly after the talk of Smaug. He set down his half-full wine glass. “Smaug … he told me that the Enemy is back.”

Gandalf seemed to age a lifetime. Finally, he said, “I have long suspected as much. Erebor was the first of many tests—one that we passed, with your assistance.” He inclined his head. “The Enemy will have learned of your survival.”

“All the better to get far from Erebor.”

“Traveling, are we?”

Bilbo fiddled with his blanket. “I … I can’t do this eleven more times, Gandalf.” He knocked back the last of the wine. “Love or not, I’m not strong enough.”

“Do not make this decision rashly,” Gandalf said. “You are not the first to run afoul of immortality. Visit the lord Elrond: he possesses greater wisdom on the matter than I.”

“Elves!” Bilbo cried, just as his least favorite specimen ducked through the tent flaps. Bilbo had hoped to catch Thranduil in post-battle disarray, but he wore perfectly pressed scarlet robes and an expression of haughty surprise.

“Am I interrupting, Mithrandir?” Thranduil asked.

“Not at all,” Gandalf said. “I was merely entertaining your guest.”

“Ah, my guest.” Thranduil’s gaze dragged over to Bilbo, who bared his teeth. “Be welcome, Bilbo … or however you prefer to be addressed.”

“I prefer Master Baggins from acquaintances and foes alike,” Bilbo retorted.

“By Nienna’s tears, you are both over three thousand years old,” Gandalf snapped. “I have seen better hospitality from Tookish tweens!”

Bilbo settled back onto his hot stones, but only after helping himself to more wine under the watch of the Elvenking’s fish-belly eyes.

“Gandalf has vouched for your reformed character,” Thranduil said, “and it seems you lost a brother on the same day I lost a father.” He paused. “You also saved my son’s life, as well as many of my retinue. For that, I am willing to set aside my grudge.”

“Your sword doesn’t interest me,” Bilbo sniffed, “nor does your life’s blood.”

“Very good,” Gandalf said, before Thranduil could retort. “Very good!”

Bilbo and Thranduil both scowled.

“I will not have my guest reeking of orc,” Thranduil told Bilbo. “You must bathe.”

Bilbo dropped his blankets. “At your earliest convenience, Master Elf.”

Gandalf excused himself under the pretense of fetching the company as Thranduil orchestrated Bilbo’s bath. Several Elves hauled a copper tub into the tent, then filled it with lavender sachets and ewers of steaming saltwater. Bilbo climbed inside immediately, sighing as his muscles unspooled beneath his assumed skin.

The Elves kindled a fire beneath the bathtub and departed. Thranduil remained, lounging on a chair with a glass of wine and a book. To Bilbo’s unasked question, Thranduil said, “I would be a poor host if you drowned in my tent.”

“This is your chance,” Bilbo said, purposely slipping below the lip of the tub.

Thranduil studied him for a long moment. “I have seen your worth upon the field of battle. We would do well to join forces for the dark days ahead.”

Bilbo sat up. “You believe the Enemy is back.”

“I believe it is a possibility worth accounting for,” said Thranduil. “Mithrandir is over-free with his counsel, but rarely gives warning without cause.” He cocked his head, his silver hair shimmering. “He says your master has no hold over you.”

“Not since we parted at Dagorlad,” Bilbo said. “I have a new hoard now.”

Thranduil’s eyes narrowed. “What an … interesting choice.”

“Oh, insult me already,” Bilbo snapped. “I won’t tattle to Gandalf.”

“Your choice is, at best, questionable, and, at worst, execrable.”

“Fair enough,” Bilbo admitted, swishing his hands idly, “but I’ve been craving a good bath since … well, since Tom Bombadil’s, really. And your vintages are quite good.”

“I imagine comfort has been sorely lacking amidst your recent company.”

“Unbelievably so.” He glanced at Thranduil as the Elvenking picked up his book. “There was a captain of your guard—Tauriel. Is she…?”

“I banished her for disobeying my orders,” Thranduil said, turning a page. “Conveniently, this freed her to become my liaison to Erebor—a post she requested before news of her banishment arrived.”

Bilbo tried to puzzle that out, then surrendered to the bath’s warm embrace and sought the company through their bond. Their grief and lingering pain became his own, and his despair found fresh soil.

“Your Dwarves approach,” Thranduil announced, as if Bilbo had not already known, “and I would rather not hold my breath for their visit.”

So saying, he relocated himself, his chair, his book, and his wine to the far side of the tent. Moments later, Nori and Bofur threw aside the tent flaps and stopped at the scene before them.

“Hullo,” Bilbo said, as though he wasn’t stewing over a fire. “Thranduil believes that by eating me, he will absorb my power.”

“Lies,” Thranduil muttered from his perch.

“Bilbo!” Bofur yelled. He leaned over the tub’s scalding rim and hugged Bilbo. Bilbo yelped in pain, then again as Nori crushed both of them to his chest.

“Long Lake’s got it out for you,” Bofur said when Nori released them. “You can’t keep falling in there.”

Bilbo shook his head. “Where is everyone? Are they alright?”

Bofur’s smile faded, but Nori said, “Busier than us. Everyone wanted to come, but duties pulled them away until only the miner and the thief could make it.” He dragged a chair over and propped his boots on the tub. “Cozy in there?”

Bilbo couched his head on his arms. “Like a flea in Dwarven drawers.” Nori snorted. “The water is a bit filthy, though. I’m marinating in all sorts of blood.”

Bofur peered into the mix of blood, water, and dirt. “Thorin wanted Dwarf healers, but Gandalf said Thranduil was best.” He leaned in. “Has he been treating you right?”

“If Thranduil wanted to kill me, he would’ve already,” Bilbo said, then lowered his voice conspiratorially. “He respects me now.”

“Grudging respect is not a victory,” Thranduil drawled. “You have ten minutes before your Dwarves must depart.”

“We’ll take him with us, then,” Nori said.

“I care not what you do with the dragon,” Thranduil said, “but steal my tub and you will answer for it.”

“Erebor,” Bilbo prompted the Dwarves. “What happened?”

Bofur and Nori caught him up on the company’s wellbeing, skating around the raw edges of Kíli and Bifur’s losses. After Nori finished a detailed recounting of the clerical nightmares of maintaining an encampment this large, Thranduil’s book snapped shut.

“That’s enough,” Thranduil said. When Nori began complaining, he raised a hand. “The sooner Mr. Baggins rests, the sooner I can examine him. The sooner I examine him, the sooner I am rid of him and he is restored to you. Find some better occupation before I set you to boiling a dragon’s worth of bandages.”

With the threat of conscription and Bilbo’s own encouragement, the Dwarves said their goodbyes, mixed with imprecations for Thranduil’s bedside manner.

On their way out, Thranduil said, “My possessions, Master Nori.”

Without breaking stride, Nori turned out his pockets. Handfuls of silverware, tiny bottles, an enamel pipe, and a candlestick tumbled to the ground. Bilbo did not hide his smile.


Kíli entered Erebor’s catacombs three days after the Battle of the Five Armies. Hundreds of Dwarves had died during the battle: they were returned to the stone beside their young prince and old toymaker in a single, solemn rite. Fíli, Thorin, Dwalin, and Balin carried Kíli, and Kíli carried both the Arkenstone and the stone bearing his unfulfilled promise to his mother.

Bilbo stood with the guests of honor. The newly-crowned King Bard was at his side with his eldest daughter, and Thranduil was accompanied by Legolas and Tauriel. Gandalf was present, as he always was for momentous happenings. The Eagles alone of the Five Armies had not lingered, but Gwaihir had ripped down from his own breast to line Kíli’s bier.

The procession occupied a stretch of time that Bilbo, in his grief, would be hard-pressed to estimate. Finally, the doors swung shut behind the last bier and the guests departed. Bilbo said goodbye to Gandalf—who was being called away yet again—and to Bard, murmured condolences to Tauriel, and even nodded cordially to Thranduil before returning to Erebor’s upper levels. Fíli had organized a second funeral for Bilbo to attend. Another day, another death, Bilbo would have been flattered, but he followed Fíli’s instructions mindlessly until he opened the door to a room devoid of everything except furniture and the fast-fading scent of his hoard. Bilbo stared into his future and sobbed once, miserably, before clamping his hand to his mouth.

Bilbo retreated, sniffed left and right to orient himself, and set off for the kitchen. Erebor’s cooks were all Dáin’s; they gave him a wide berth as he fetched flour, butter, sugar, cinnamon, pickled peaches, and cream. Routine took him from there. When he finished baking, he wrapped the pies in towels and brought them to the room, then stoked the fire, folded his clothes, and turned into a dragon, curled up around the miniature wood version of himself.

The Dwarves returned shortly thereafter. They rushed in after the first whiff of pastry, their minds—however briefly—fixed on food.

“’s good,” Dwalin declared, spraying crumbs from a full mouth.

“Hurry it up!” Dori cried when Bofur took too long filling his plate. “Ori’s a growing Dwarf still.”

After they doled out the peach pies, they returned to Bilbo: Nori, Ori, and Bofur sat on his back; Dori and Dwalin against his right side; Balin, leaning on his shoulder; Fíli propped against his neck; Bombur and Oin sitting against his legs; and Glóin’s thigh brushing his tail. Thorin alone kept his distance. The Dwarves did not press Bilbo for speech or deed, and he was content to observe. Here, Dwalin and Balin toasting Kíli. There, Oin and Bombur trading stories about Bifur. Crown Prince Fíli was silent, but Bilbo sensed his bottled emotions as surely as he could have sensed a nick on his hoarded blades.

Fíli sat cross-legged by Bilbo’s head, picking at his bloody nailbeds. He said, very quietly, “I’m sorry that you lost your siblings.”

Bilbo voiced reassurances—they are long gone, this is not your burden—with his fangs and inflexible tongue, but all that emerged was a soft growl.

“Every morning I wake up thinking he’s alive,” Fíli continued. “And every morning I—” He frowned. “I don’t know if I’ll ever … or if I want to ever...”

Bilbo dropped his head onto Fíli’s lap. Fíli left off his own hands to scratch Bilbo’s jaw.

“Guess I’ll have to live enough for both of us,” Fíli whispered.

Bilbo closed his eyes.

“I’m not getting on your back, though,” Fíli added, lighter this time. “You’ll have to find a braver Dwarf.”

Bilbo snorted, accidentally crisping Oin’s pants. In the ensuing uproar, Thorin slipped out unseen—mostly.

Bilbo met Balin’s eye and clicked softly.

“Off him, lads,” Balin commanded. “Our dragon has somewhere to be.”

The Dwarves dismounted, thanking Bilbo for the pies with florid compliments and bows. Bilbo nuzzled each of them, then traded their companionship for Erebor’s cold halls.

The moment he was alone, Bilbo transformed and dressed, then set off down unfamiliar paths, around blind turns, and up steps hewn into the living rock. Bilbo knew he could follow Thorin anywhere—after all, he’d already followed him halfway across Middle Earth. Fortunately, this trek turned out to be a fair sight shorter. Thorin had stopped at the top of a curving staircase overlooking some grand hall whose purpose Bilbo could not divine through the dust. It was dark; torches twinkled in the distance like stars.

Bilbo cleared his throat when he drew level and Thorin turned. Bilbo wondered what he saw—nothing new, surely, unlike what he saw in Thorin. The king had cast aside his crown and silks, and now wore Dáin’s spare tunic and Mannish trousers neatly cuffed over his travel boots. Orcrist’s battered sheath hung empty on his back. Grief had dug graves under his eyes.

“I owe you so many apologies I do not know where to begin,” Thorin said finally.

“Then we don’t have to,” Bilbo said. “Do that, I mean. Apologize.” He fidgeted. Thorin’s gaze held a hunger that Bilbo was unready to sate. “We’d be here for hours, each apologizing to the other, each thinking the other could’ve stopped ages ago. I’ve had my fill of them. So, please, let’s not.”

“Then where do we begin?”

“Sharing good company?” Bilbo suggested. “You don’t have to talk. I probably won’t.” He shrugged. “Doesn’t mean I want to be alone.”

Thorin tentatively offered his arm. Bilbo took it, his heart too heavy to thrill at the gesture. For a long time, they said and saw nothing, and heard nothing but their own footsteps. Slowly, the light grew and, with it, the frenetic energy of a mountain reignited. Restoration had already started in the vital areas: forges, homes, kitchens, armories, and record houses. They bustled with Dwarves from the Iron Hills, and Bilbo and Thorin avoided them as naturally as they avoided the treasury.

Thorin eventually took the lead, transforming an aimless walk into a proper tour. They spoke of reconstruction, of farming, of guilds and politics. They did not speak of Kíli or Bifur, or the thousands slain in the vale. They did not speak of gold except of what it could buy: food, raw materials, caravans to fetch the exiled Longbeards.

By the time Thorin led Bilbo outside, the sun was several hours gone and a rime of frost crusted the old archery targets. The hollow where the company had camped before entering Erebor now overlooked the even lines of Dáin’s encampment and, beyond that, Dale’s watchfires and the circular tents of Thranduil’s host. Bilbo accepted Thorin’s coat, then settled on a boulder and held up a packet of tobacco.

They were at the bottom of their bowls when Thorin asked the question they had evaded for hours. “Where will you go now?” When Bilbo did not answer—how he had dreaded this!—Thorin said, “You saved my kingdom, my people, and my kin. There will always be a place for you in Erebor.”

Oh, Thorin. Bilbo’s heart was so overburdened with emotions that he could not name them all. “I don’t know where I’ll go. But, please, Thorin…” Bilbo took Thorin’s hand. “Don’t ask me to stay.”

Thorin’s hand was as familiar as his face: square, trimmed nails; broad fingers rough with the calluses of a smith and a warrior; a dusting of dark hairs along the knuckles and backs; the struts of his bones; the blue rivers of his veins. Would that Bilbo could slip inside and lose himself at their confluence with no thought of return, like an eel swimming out to sea or an Elf sailing to Valinor.

“I swear never to ask anything of you again,” Thorin said. “You have shown the quality of dragons, Master Baggins—and of friends.”

Bilbo closed his eyes, whetting his other senses. Thorin’s muscles contracted beneath his borrowed clothes. His breath ruffled Bilbo’s curls; his beard scratched his forehead and his silvery hair tickled Bilbo’s cheek. An unseasonable thrush sang from the heather.

“I only request,” Thorin continued, “that you remember my offer always stands.”

“Will you stay?” Bilbo asked.

“I owe my people a great debt,” Thorin said. “I swore to the living and the dead to return Erebor to its former glory.”

Bilbo’s heart broke afresh. He knew as surely as Thorin could not leave, Bilbo could not remain. The Lonely Mountain would always be a monument to his failures, and the sorrow that he and Thorin shared.

But one day, under the same beloved hand twisted through Bilbo’s fingers, Erebor would prosper again, and here the company would grow old in safety, surrounded by each other and the realm they had renewed.

That hope lifted Bilbo enough to smile. “This won’t be the last time we see each other.”

Bilbo felt Thorin’s answering smile against his forehead. “All other kingdoms will pale in comparison by the time you return.”

“Well!” Bilbo laughed. “It sounds like we both have work to do! I’ll leave you to it.”

They embraced—a poor decision on Bilbo’s part, one that would worsen their parting, but he could not stop himself. They held each other for some time, until, at last, piece by piece, they separated. Last were their hands. Bilbo stared at his fingers, still enmeshed in Thorin’s, as the weight of Thorin’s gaze fell to the same point. Thorin pulled Bilbo a half-step forward and raised Bilbo’s left hand with his joined right, pressing Bilbo’s knuckles against his beard. Bilbo stood on his toes and leaned forward, angling Thorin’s hand until his mouth closed on Thorin’s knuckle. Their foreheads touched. Their breath mingled, acrid from pipe-smoke, and their lips were separated only by the pale hillocks of their knuckles.

When the moment grew unbearable, Bilbo said, “Watch over them for me, Thorin.”

“Always,” Thorin whispered.

The impending winter crept in around them as Bilbo left to prepare for his departure.