Actions

Work Header

Sang The Sun In Flight

Chapter 21: Concerning Dragons

Summary:

The fourteenth member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield chooses the manner of his death.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

If one endeavored to summarize Dáin Ironfoot in a word, they would eventually settle on loud. His presence expanded into any space he entered, from tents to battlefields. He was charming when he wanted to be and crass when he didn’t, but the combination of both was such that most found it easier to forgive him than fight. Anyone who did challenge the Lord of the Iron Hills would discover his armor turned all but a black arrow, and that his fighting prowess made short work of aggressors.

Dáin liked Bilbo immediately.

“There’s the wee dragon!” he roared as Bilbo arrived outside his tent. “Come here! I haven’t seen you this small!”

He beckoned Bilbo over to where he was playing cards with a dark-skinned Dwarf about Fíli’s age with a dramatic scar bisecting his eyebrow. The younger Dwarf appeared to be winning.

“Not as impressive as I thought you’d be,” Dáin told Bilbo. “Well, I heard all about how you defeated Thorin. Come to cross claws with the great Ironfoot?”

Bilbo smiled thinly. “Only if you would like to be known as Ironfeet.”

Dáin howled with laughter, then rocked to his feet and swept into a bow. “Dáin, Lord of the Iron Hills, at your service. This is my son, wee Thorin.”

Dáin’s solemn companion mimicked his father. “Thorin Stonehelm at your service, Master Hobbit—Baggins.”

“Bilbo Baggins, at yours,” Bilbo said, repeating the gesture. “Bilbo will do. I’ve heard of your bravery during the battle, Thorin. Ah—Stonehelm.”

Dáin guffawed as Thorin Stonehelm puffed with pride.

“And I have been assured that without you, King Thorin’s quest would have ended west of the Misty Mountains,” Stonehelm replied.

Were he not so heartsick, Bilbo would have preened. As it was, Stonehelm won Bilbo’s immediate respect. “You’re too kind. I’ve come because I haven’t had my fill of adventure, and I’d like to join you on your return to the Iron Hills.”

“Haven’t had your fill of Dwarves, you mean!” Dáin said. “Our home in the Iron Hills is second to none, and will be until Thorin gives us some competition!”

“Then I ought to visit now, during this fleeting window,” Bilbo said.

“Oho!” Dáin exclaimed, slapping his thighs. “So you spit fire in more ways than one, uslukhaluk!”

“We would be honored by your presence, Master Baggins,” said Stonehelm, “though I warn you that the journey will be neither comfortable nor quick.”

It was Bilbo’s turn to laugh. “I’ve grown quite accustomed to roughing it—a thousand leagues without a single handkerchief, tailored waistcoat, or spice stronger than salt!”

“I cannot promise the former two, but we season our food better than our western cousins,” Stonehelm said. “You will be our guest.”

“Really, I’m no stranger to hard work,” Bilbo said. “I’d be happy to help where I can.”

“Nonsense!” Dáin slapped Bilbo’s back with enough force to fell an ox—and wobble a Dragon. “We’ve already set aside your ram and tent. Cousin Thorin told us you were coming two days ago.”

Dáin’s caravan would depart the next day. Bilbo ached with things unfinished and words unsaid, but knew that lingering would corrode his resolve. Fortunately, he had little to gather: he had relinquished his fourteenth share—save for a small chest each of gold and silver to finance his travels—and planned to bring only the same leather pack he had taken from Bag End. The company lavished him with visits and gifts, the latter impractical more often than not, and the former as welcome as it was dangerous. Bilbo was forced to chase them out to secure his peace. Only Dori was admitted, later, as Bilbo could not begrudge him his fussing.

That evening was Bilbo’s final bask amongst his hoard. The bittersweet dregs of sorrow and victory mingled strangely, loosening tongues and tears alike.

And if Bilbo and Thorin avoided each other, no one mentioned it.


Autumn bared its first frosty fangs on the morning of Dáin’s leave-taking. Bilbo, the remaining company, and half of Dáin’s original party assembled outside Erebor’s gates. Bilbo had been given a goat and a place of honor beside Thorin Stonehelm, whose mount was a war pig named Sunshine. Sunshine despised Bilbo from the first—wise, he told her, as he could swallow her whole, with room for seconds—and he gladly rode with the company instead. They had somehow wrangled the Riddermark horses back from Thranduil, and made perfect asses of themselves by riding as poorly as when they had left the Field of Celebrant.

The company and the caravan parted ways on the eastern shore of Long Lake, where the sun had yet to reach and smoke from Laketown lingered in the hollows. The company halted their horses at the crossroads, waving furiously. Bilbo’s neck ached from how often he turned in the saddle, watching them grow small and smaller, until the caravan rounded a bend and his hoard was lost from sight.

His heart, impossibly, broke just a little more.


Bilbo’s new travel companions were a different troupe: they sang different songs, wore different clothes, and even smelled very un-Dwarvish, to Bilbo’s nose—and, indeed, seasoned their food more generously than Bilbo had come to expect. Dáin and Stonehelm were perfect hosts, in their own way, but they were not Bilbo’s Dwarves. Every evening, Bilbo satisfied his requirements as a guest before retiring early to turn Bifur’s toy over in his hands, thinking of everything and nothing. Every morning, Bilbo would wake up facing west, towards the solitary peak dwindling into the distance.

Halfway to the Iron Hills, Bilbo penned a letter to Dáin and Thorin Stonehelm to announce his unforeseen departure and gift them his chests to repay their hospitality. Then, he evaded the keen-eyed watch and, once a goodly stretch from camp, bundled his clothes into his pack, tethered it to his ankle, and changed his skin for the first time in weeks.

Bilbo followed the waxing tang of salt and rotting seaweed, landing only when his wings could no longer keep him aloft. The winds grew warmer and the land drier, until plains gave way to forest, which petered out into scraggly brown scrub. On the third day after Bilbo’s parting from Dáin, a pearlescent smudge appeared at the bottom of his vision. Bilbo blinked, attempting to dispel the phantoms of his exhaustion, but the blur sharpened into an unbroken expanse of chicory-blue water.

Bilbo floated lower, wheeling amongst the gulls as the winds tipped him this way and that, until he landed on a blindingly white sandbar. The fine sand engulfed his claws and cut into his eyes. He wrinkled his nose, then transformed into a Hobbit and savored a lunch of dried fish and peppered waybread. He would need to hunt soon—and, indeed, for the foreseeable future, if this was to be his new home.

He wiped his mouth daintily, then knelt over the sea to wash himself. His reflection peered back at him: curls the color of old straw twisting around stolen eyes in a sunken face.

Bilbo dashed himself away, turned into a dragon, and strode into the Sea of Rhûn. The tepid water washed over his claws, then his feet, his legs, his chest. Bilbo waded into darker water. The sea suddenly rolled beneath his wings, lifting him up and back. The waves closed overhead, crushing him against the sand. Bilbo’s claws sluiced futilely through the brine and he could not pull his wings from the seabed. Another wave rolled by. Saltwater poured down his throat like fire. He forced his wings shut and kicked off the sand. With two powerful undulations, he beached himself, coughing and cursing his idiocy as the waves licked his tail.

Fuming, Bilbo crawled above the tideline and laid out for a nap. Even with the sun above and the hot sand below, sleep still did not come. Crabs scuttled over his paws and gulls perched on his spines to cry like lost souls. The sand beneath his belly cooled and the scarlet warmth beating against Bilbo’s eyelids faded with the light. With nightfall came a battalion of gnats whining in his ears and clustering around his eyes. He shook his head in a rattle of scales, then took to the sky. He soared aimlessly, admiring the stars and their rippled reflections. The scent of the sea faded and Bilbo realized, too late, that he had oriented himself towards his hoard.

He angled his wings until his heading shifted from night-blued plains to black water. The southern horizon seethed scarlet behind Ered Lithui. Bilbo had heard the mountains had fallen dormant after the Enemy’s defeat, but a red glow—too sullen for sunset—flamed beyond their peaks.

Unsettled, Bilbo swiftly returned to his sandbar. Crabs fled for their burrows, vanishing moments before the insects returned. Somewhere out in the reeds, an animal made a musty groan resembling Dwalin’s snores. The hushed waves came and went like Smaug’s breathing. Ered Lithui’s eruptions throbbed in the corner of his eye.

The next decades unfurled before him like an ill-starred tapestry. The Enemy would return, as Smaug foretold, and the good and green things of Middle Earth would wither beneath his onslaught. Bilbo thought of Hobbits fleeing from cruel orcish blades. He thought of Gandalf beset, of Beorn and Radagast and Thranduil scotched from their forest, of balrogs sweeping across the fields of the Rohirrim, of Dale’s bells silenced. Lastly, his fears turned to the Dwarves. Where would Bilbo be when the first of his hoard fell in defense of their hard-won home? The second? Bilbo’s master had preferred to enslave than kill, to languish weeks of attention on the strongest spirits until they shattered; Bilbo’s hoard would give him great sport. The thought of what Sauron might do to him paled in comparison to the agony of watching his hoard die.

Yet that was Bilbo’s doom, one way or another, if he returned to Erebor. Losing two of his hoard—Kíli, Bifur—had nearly undone him. To watch the rest leave as he lived on was as terrible a fate as any dragon could dream. If madness did not take him, he would diminish until death seemed a mercy.

But without his Dwarves, was he living at all?


Five days later, Bilbo landed on a tor jutting from Erebor’s southern slope. He dressed, rubbed his growling stomach, and then picked his way down the ridge to join the Dwarf road leading to Dale.

The people of Laketown had moved into their ruins: the towers were clad in scaffolding, and the smell of cookfires and Men wafted far downhill. Spindly lifts waded between the buildings like herons, occasionally dipping to receive their bounty of bricks. A half-mile distant, a crew of Dwarves swarmed Erebor’s entrance. A new gate of iron-banded wood had already been erected. If Bilbo knew Dwarves half as well as he thought, timber would be replaced with stunning stonework in short order.

The gate guards admitted him immediately, even though it was nearly dark, and charged their youngest—a beautiful young Dwarf with fiery hair—to escort Bilbo to the throne room.

“Gimli, son of Glóin, at your service,” they said, bowing until their beard brushed the ground. “It is my honor to accompany you.”

Bilbo knew much about Gimli already: he happily questioned them about their apprenticeship and their journey from the Iron Hills. Gimli had inherited Glóin’s wagging tongue and occupied their walk with his answers.

Bilbo had thought Erebor’s throne room was rather gloomy, but with its braziers lit and mirrors gleaming, he realized it had been constructed to funnel all glory onto the throne. And there, beneath the niche that had once held the Arkenstone, was Dwalin, the Raven Crown girding his head and his mouth graven with displeasure.

“Step forth to receive your judgment,” Dwalin rumbled, his voice echoing magnificently.

Bilbo hurried forth. “Oh, come off it. We—”

Dwalin held up a hand. Bilbo stumbled to a halt. “For the crime of abandoning Erebor and its princes, I levy upon you the sentence of…” Dwalin paused dramatically “...death.”

Gimli and another guard seized Bilbo’s shoulders. Bilbo stared up at his old companion, bewildered.

“No, no, don’t actually kill him,” Dwalin told the guards. He removed his crown to dig his thumbs into his temples. “I always forget the word of the bloody king is bloody absolute.”

The guards released Bilbo, but he remained where he was, rooted with worry. “Is Thorin alright? And Fíli? And Balin?”

He frantically reached through their bond, touching each of them in turn.

“Thorin and Fíli are fine,” Dwalin said, “but Balin thought they needed time. Balin himself’s too busy to actually sit the throne and Dáin left, so here I am: King Under the Bloody Mountain.”

“Long may you reign,” Bilbo teased, bowing.

Dwalin barked with laughter. “If my reign lasts another week, I’ll foist the crown onto Glóin.”

“He has a worthy heir,” Bilbo pointed out. Behind him, Gimli made a choked noise that could have been a laugh or forestalled argument.

“More than most can say,” Dwalin said. “Mahal, maybe we should crown Bombur. With his brood, he’ll have as secure a line as any Dwarf could boast, and we’d feast like kings every night.” They chuckled at that. Then, Dwalin said, with a hint of regal menace, “You’ll be coming with me now.”

Bilbo was too thrilled to question him and, within minutes, he and Dwalin were standing outside a door. Or, at least, what Dwalin said was a door: much like the catacombs, the wall seemed unremarkable until Dwalin spoke the password and set his shoulder against the rock. The sounds of the quarreling company flooded into the hallway and Bilbo’s breath caught as his heart filled anew.

“King Dwalin brings gifts!” Dwalin bellowed. Bilbo followed him inside and found himself in a sitting room packed with Dwarves. Here they were: his whole hoard, gathered on armchairs and couches and glowing in the firelight, their mouths hanging open at the sight of him. Mouse-nibbled maps of the Iron Hills, the Sea of Rhûn, and the Withered Heath papered every surface, pinned to walls and flattened on tabletops with half-empty steins. Eleven travel packs sat against one wall, each one as familiar as their owners.

“Looks like you’re off on another quest,” Bilbo said at last.

“Of course we are!” Bofur exclaimed, standing atop his chair. “We thought we’d lost the fourteenth member of our company!”

“That, uh. That sounds rather serious.” Bilbo swallowed. Thorin—sitting beside Fíli on a dingy couch with a scroll in hand—was staring at Bilbo as if they were the only two people in the world. “You might need a dragon’s help fetching him back.”

“We’ve had enough trouble with dragons!” fumed Glóin. “And you’re the worst of the lot!”

The company rushed forward, wrapping him in a many-armed embrace as they cursed the curly heads of Hobbits and the sly scales of Dragons in turn.

“Haring off without so much as a by-your-leave!” wailed Dori. “Master Baggins, we thought better of you!”

“I left a proper letter,” Bilbo objected. He could not hear himself speak, nor did he want to. He was part of a whole: a member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield, as they were all parts of his hoard. They would be the death of him, Bilbo knew, but when that time came, no dragon would have been so happy to meet his end.

Finally, Bilbo yelled, “I have an announcement! I have an announcement to make!”

The other Dwarves kept chastising him until Dwalin abused his new rank to silence them. Not all Dwarves wished to heed his command; Bilbo used the distraction to scarf down two unattended fennel biscuits and half of Dori’s wine. He had not quite finished when Fíli and Glóin hoisted him onto their shoulders.

“Well!” Bilbo began from his new throne. “I shan’t keep you long, because I have a very clear purpose. Two purposes, in fact, neither of which are more important than the other, although I suppose, you may later decide that one is vastly—”

“By Durin, will ye hurry it up already?” demanded Glóin, his voice strained.

“No, I won’t,” Bilbo said, twisting to look down at him. “I scarcely felt I’ve gotten a word in edgewise during this entire quest and it’s finally my turn to speak.”

Dwalin rolled his eyes. “You talked plenty.”

“Enough to fill two full notebooks!” Ori said, brandishing his latest record.

“If we hear another speech about tomatoes, I’ll eat my hat,” Bofur said.

“Peaches?” Oin asked. “No, they won’t grow in this soil.”

“Your throne or your speech,” Fíli grunted, his arms quivering. “Your choice.”

Bilbo saw Balin and Dwalin exchange grins and said, grumpily, “Speech.”

With much extraneous cursing, Bilbo was lowered to the floor. Now, he had no choice but to continue.

“I came back,” Bilbo said, “because I missed all of you dearly. You are my dearest friends, but you are also—you have become—my hoard.” Some of the company looked puzzled, but no one spoke. “All of you, including … including Kíli and Bifur.” He took a fortifying breath. “Now, I would understand if a dragon’s hoard implied possession, but that is not true. I am not—I will never be like Smaug: your lives are your own. Just know that they are—that you are—incalculably precious to me, and my only wish is to stay at Erebor, always, so that we might share them.” Hastily, he added, “If that’s alright.”

Silence reigned. Bilbo desperately met Thorin’s eye and received a single, supportive nod.

Ori raised a gloved hand.

“Yes, Ori,” Bilbo said.

“You’re not going to sit on us, are you?” Ori asked. “I don’t think Dori’s ribs can stand the strain.”

“What?” Bilbo demanded, as if he had never had that thought. “No! No, utterly rid—”

“And you’ll be letting other Dwarves into Erebor?” Glóin asked.

“Why wouldn’t I?”

“Will you kill Thranduil for us?” asked Nori.

“He and I have an agreement,” Bilbo said, not without regret.

“Is there a contract we might sign to define the terms?” Dori asked.

Bilbo scratched his head and glanced at Balin, who tapped his temple, his eyes gleaming with anticipation. “Oh, um, apparently Balin can—”

“Can we leave the mountain?” Oin asked.

“Yes!” Bilbo exclaimed. “Great Yavanna, did you not hear what I said?”

Thorin’s voice carried easily over the company. “Will you stay?”

“Yes,” Bilbo said. “Yes, I’ll stay.”

Thorin’s rare, beautiful smile bloomed at last.

“Then, essentially,” Bofur said, “you want our lovely companionship, augmented by a couple centuries of free food and a warm place to hang your hat.”

That was as succinct a summary as Bilbo could want. He threw up his hands. “Exactly.”

The company glanced amongst themselves, collectively shrugged, and began inviting him to their homes, or to meet this or that Dwarf newly arrived at the mountain, or to see their restored workshops. Even a gentlehobbit of Bilbo’s towering punctiliousness was flustered by the array of directions and dates, only for his planning to be interrupted by a fulminous snarl. The Dwarves laughed when they pinpointed the source as Bilbo’s empty stomach.

“Well, now we know what called you back!” Fíli exclaimed.

Bombur sighed and rolled ponderously to his feet, but Dwalin pushed him down.

“Thorin,” Balin said, “why don’t you find some food for our guest?”

Thorin looked like a hare caught out on a cart-road.

“I’d be honored,” Bofur said, then backtracked after Fíli surreptitiously kicked him. “But Thorin would be a better choice. He hasn’t done much of late, anyhow.”

“No respect for your king,” Glóin muttered.

Bofur grinned. “Oh, I respect Dwalin plenty.”

Thorin seemed to force a smile at the following laughter, then walked into the hall with Bilbo bobbing in his wake. Unable to stop himself, Bilbo glanced back at his hoard. Some merely waved. Others—Bofur, Dwalin, Oin—made suggestive hand gestures. Bilbo responded with Bifur’s favorite invectives, then hurried after Thorin.

Bilbo had been gone scarcely a fortnight, but Erebor had transformed in his absence. The passageways had been swept and dusted, and much of Smaug’s marks had been mortared over or chiseled away. The air smelled of woodsmoke and smelted metal and Dwarves and other goodly things, and vibrated with the faint cacophony of industry.

“You frightened Dáin,” Thorin said when Bilbo caught up. “He sent a raven with a copy of your farewell letter and a missive begging my forgiveness.”

“Don’t chide me,” Bilbo scolded. “I’m five thousand years old.”

“You said three last time, O Agèd Wyrm,” Thorin said. Bilbo scowled. “Where did you go?”

“The Sea of Rhûn.” He shuddered. “Awful place. Too much sand, too many bugs—and the water tastes terrible.”

Thorin snorted.

“Have I missed much?” Bilbo asked. “Other than King Dwalin’s coronation, of course.”

“Long may he reign,” Thorin echoed.

“Did you renounce the throne?”

Thorin stopped and turned to face Bilbo. “Kíli is dead. I—I failed. I am unworthy to call myself king.”

His voice broke on his denied title.

“You are the king the company followed,” Bilbo said. “The king that I followed.” He added, somewhat drily, “Which should mean a great deal more to you than the endorsement of the other twelve.”

Thorin did not look up.

“You were sick, Thorin,” Bilbo added. “The sickness passed, and you are stronger for it.”

“Kíli—”

“We both failed him.” A tear darkened Bilbo’s tunic. He lifted Thorin’s chin. “But we must keep going. Together, if you’ll have me.”

Thorin hesitantly took his hand, the ball of his thumb working across Bilbo’s palm. “I will have you as a Dragon or Hobbit or any other form you choose, for all your days.”

“You ought to know I have many days ahead of me.” He laid his hand over Thorin’s. “Hobbits require a lot of provender—Hobbits who are Dragons doubly so.”

“You will be here to watch the mountain farms remade,” Thorin said. “In the days of my grandfather, we never wanted for food—although I suspect they would flourish all the more under a skilled gardener.”

“That may be a job worthy of my time,” Bilbo allowed, “but dragons are arrogant, and greedy, and vain. I will always demand more.”

“And I will grant it.”

“Then would you give me the rest of your life?”

“Yes,” Thorin said immediately.

“And if, Master Dwarf, I should ask for a kiss?”

Thorin’s lips parted, his ears flaring red. “Then, Master Dragon, I would kiss you.”

“Well,” Bilbo said, bouncing on his toes, “I am asking.”

Thorin smiled and leaned forward, until all Bilbo knew was the heat of Thorin’s mouth, and the sharp line of his teeth, and the caress of his hand. If this was not love, Bilbo did not want it. And if Thorin was his death, he was as welcome as springtime and glad tidings and hot meals on cold nights.

Bilbo pulled away first, but Thorin still leaned into him, his hair mussed and his cheeks aglow.

“I swore never to ask anything more of you,” Thorin murmured, his voice rough, “but might I kiss you this once?”

“I daresay you may kiss me as many times as you wish,” Bilbo said.

A sudden curse made them both turn, just as Ori was yanked behind the corner of the nearby passageway.

Bilbo sighed fondly as Thorin reddened. “Out with it!”

The company tumbled into view, their faces alight with glee. Dori was dabbing at tears with his handkerchief. Fíli met Bilbo’s eye and winked.

“Is a king to have no privacy in his own realm?” Thorin demanded, more amused than angry.

“Go on!” Bofur said. “Give him a kiss, why don’t you? I didn’t see the first one over Dwalin’s fat head.”

As Dwalin protested, Bilbo pulled Thorin close and pressed his mouth to his, tangling his fingers in his hair. Thorin pushed by their joined lips until Bilbo leaned back, with only Thorin’s hand between his shoulders keeping him upright as the company cheered.

When Thorin permitted Bilbo to stand again, Bilbo gave him a peck on the cheek and said, “That is quite enough showboating for today, Master Dwarf! We have a kingdom to rebuild.”

And, with that, they returned to the company.

Notes:

Translations
Uslukhaluk—tiny dragon (affectionate)


For Shep, who kept the fire burning, and vilelithe, who holds the tinder.