Chapter Text
I love you.
Just minutes ago Thorin waited for the end, pondering his wrongs, unsure if he could ever amend them.
Bilbo said he would follow him. And Thorin said, Tell me what happens next; for something else is present between them, has been from the moment Bilbo found him.
“In an ideal world,” Bilbo continues, “what happens next is the hobbit asks a higher being to grant life to his friend. Because the king deserves to live, and this being has the power to fulfill it.” Bilbo’s voice falters, perhaps afraid this is too direct considering Mahal can hear him, or scared that Thorin will reject his request.
“Bilbo...” Thorin gestures weakly, trying to lift himself up to Bilbo’s level. He cannot. “Come here.” Bilbo lies down on the ice next to him, his eyes searching for what Thorin will accept, things kept hidden in the solitude and secrecy of his heart.
“I have loved you since the first time you saved my life. And if Mahal granted me life today, it would be yours.”
There is regret and sorrow in these words; the finality of one who has no hope. Thorin’s hand reaches out to stroke Bilbo’s hair with endless adoration; Bilbo covers it with his own, and in his touch there is longing and relief. It is surreal, those eyes moments ago filled with pain now smile in blissful surprise, even as Thorin has not said yes to his happy ending.
“Do you wish it, son of Thráin? Do you want to live?” the voice of earlier speaks from above.
Bilbo changes instantly; rushes to adjust his position, fix his messy hair and beat-up clothes, but Thorin will not release him. He pulls Bilbo closer and envelops him in his arms. “I love you,” Thorin says as his arms close around the smaller figure, his strength now returned. “You’re all I ever wanted, all I want in the world.” And when he feels Bilbo surrender in his arms, then Thorin looks up to the sky, ready to face Mahal.
“I know you’ve been concerned about your kin,” his Maker presses on. “I can provide you with news of them.”
“Yes, Father. Please,” Thorin voices, and here he leaves Bilbo some room to breathe so as to shield him from incoming pain. “I do wish to know my nephews’ fate.”
“They both passed. A feast is being planned as we speak, to welcome them to my Halls.”
Thorin is silent; Bilbo can hear the unspoken I failed them, and the more worrisome My place is with them. He watches in horror how Thorin’s wound reopens, or is this an illusion, is it only his heart, so close to Bilbo’s that they feel as one, a heart that rages against the unfairness of it all; so close Bilbo can almost feel Azog’s blade in him, and still know to Thorin that was nothing compared to Mahal’s words just now.
Of which there are more. “By the way, your youngest nephew is in love with an elf. Focus on the positive, I told him. You saved her life, that’s something to be proud of. Instead he’s bummed he’ll never see her again.”
Kíli, love, young, youngest... Thorin’s mind wanders helplessly. If Bilbo’s wish is granted, maybe Thorin can switch places with Kíli; maybe Kíli can live instead. This is wrong, too, so many wrongs he cannot see the right thing.
Yet Bilbo’s hand rests on his heart reassuringly, keeping him on the ground and the clouds at bay.
“It would also interest you to know your father is dead,” Mahal delivers, really on a roll. “He came to the Halls a few days ago. On Durin’s Day, if I’m not mistaken.”
Thorin’s voice is a shadow in the dark. “How?”
“He was taken prisoner in Dol Guldur, and tortured for many years. The wizard Gandalf tried to rescue him, but underestimated the dark one’s power.”
Thorin. Thorin... Bilbo is with him, was with him until Thorin drifted, still dimly aware of surroundings, his spirit carried away by the wind. He could still feel Bilbo’s presence, light, graceful and heaven-like in the air around him... Yet Bilbo rests on the ground, wrapped in the arms of a figure fading, not for lack of strength but for lack of will.
“I thought it fit to give you the facts first,” says Mahal. “Now that all that is out of the way, shall we move on to happier things? I would let you live again, if you wish.”
“Thank you.”
The present approach lacks a measure of tact, Bilbo thinks. Perhaps Mahal forgets Thorin is not used to thinking about himself, let alone in this overflow of guilt that’s about to fracture the ice beneath them. He may be able to take in the heartbreak, but not the hope for repair at the same time. If Thorin’s heart can ever be repaired.
Memories float before Thorin’s mind, a feeble attempt to narrow down what he amounts to. Thráin was never far from his restless thoughts. In vain he struggled and searched; now it seems he didn’t search well enough. Fíli and Kíli needed a father figure, the dwarves of Erebor needed a place to live, his grandfather’s legacy remained his to protect. As for who Thorin was? Someone who would one day rule their reclaimed home, with Fíli and Kíli by his side.
And it’s selfish and strange, but he thinks part of him cannot bear to live and be happy with his One while those he should have protected died in a blaze of shattered dreams. Yet this gift... life, unexpected and undeserved, is the fruit of love, Bilbo’s love, impossible to earn in the afterlife: to live is to cherish this gift.
Maybe Thorin can have it.
“Don’t tell me that you want to go with them,” says Bilbo, who guessed both halves of his mind.
“It is not a question of want. I should.”
“Then I will go with you. That is, if...” Bilbo looks uncertainly around him, but Mahal’s presence is above, where he can’t see, yet maybe can still ask.
But Thorin does not wait for any answer. Because he is, once more, alive and solid on the frozen water, and there is no other way to say this except to claim Bilbo’s mouth in a kiss dark as the night and fragile as the air, warm as ice melting in a dying fire. Night is now falling yet a new day begins, and the colors have fled from this world leaving a blur of white and grey where nothing grows, there is no life anywhere but between them. Bilbo gives in to Thorin’s hold, absolute and complete; no longer belongs to himself. He is Thorin’s, even as he takes his lips reluctantly, cautiously, for this is highly improper and would work so much better as a private moment, assuming - no, praying - Mahal is still watching. Yet the longer and more passionate the kiss the more Bilbo welcomes it: it’s Thorin’s way of showing him how much this means, that Bilbo truly is willing to go in the afterlife with him. No, Thorin will not allow it; but it means everything.
“...if Lord Mahal will allow it,” Bilbo barely finishes his sentence, suddenly overcome with the wish to be so small he could hide in Thorin’s hair, or even better, disappear completely. Instead he pulls himself out of Thorin’s arms and kneels on the ice, positively embarrassed, while Thorin follows, proud and unashamed.
“I will allow it,” Mahal echoes from above.
“You will allow me to join Thorin in your Halls?”
“Yes. Of course, there is zero precedent for this, so don’t expect any hobbits there. But we do have the best drinks and entertainment. Plenty of interesting people, and the finest architecture,” completes Mahal proudly.
“What about trees and flowers?” Thorin asks. Bilbo likes nature, green, growing things. Somehow he doubts they’d be present in dwarven afterlife.
“Nope. That’s more my wife’s department. Sorry.”
Thorin turns toward Bilbo; they are now kneeling before each other. “Bilbo... Lord Mahal said he would let me live. I know very well how much you have missed your home. Let me take this chance and go to the Shire with you. I will spend the rest of my life loving you.”
And Bilbo thinks, that is all well and good, except Thorin’s conscience, his heart will not rest until he can be with his departed kin. Not to mention sitting around in the Shire with nothing to do is probably not what suits Thorin best. Well. Come to think of it, brooding in Mahal’s Halls forever does not suit him either, with or without his kin. Thorin was made to lead, to give of himself with purpose, to have others look up to him.
“What about staying in Erebor as its king? Can Thorin live and do that instead?” Bilbo risks, knowing he’s pushing it, but it’s what his love deserves.
“I’m afraid not. My child,” Mahal addresses Thorin, “you have made mistakes that cost others their lives: I am disappointed. I believe Dáin will make a better king. The chance I’m giving you is to live for love, nothing more.”
“Then it is settled. I’m going with you,” Bilbo repeats, more determined than ever.
“And leave everything? Bag End, your books and your garden? Is that what you want?”
“I love you,” Bilbo answers unrepentantly. “And I think you would be happier in the Halls, in your family’s company.”
“And I love you. Enough to be concerned you won’t be happy in a place with no soil, no growing things. Please, Bilbo. I would defer to you in anything but this. Let me go with you.”
“I told you I would follow you before any offer was made.”
“Yet you wanted me to live: that is what you asked for. That is how your story ends, is it not?”
They see what’s going on here: perhaps they’re a little too invested in each other’s happiness. Also, this is a big decision; it’s unclear how to proceed.
Unbelievable, Mahal thinks from his seat in the clouds. It’s possible he didn’t anticipate an innocent love confession to turn into an argument so soon, or that this unpredictable Baggins would be just as stubborn as his child.
Either way, they should get a move on: he doesn’t have all day.
“I have an idea. How about I just let you die, son of Thráin, and you can join us at the feast tonight, never to see this hobbit again. And you, Mister Bilbo “I-can’t-decide-what-I-want” Baggins, can sod off to your Shire with a nice tale to tell.”
“NO!! Please, Lord Mahal, give us a little more time! We’re going to figure this out!”
Mahal sighs, audibly annoyed. “Fine.”
He eyes the distant sun. Time is wasting; it’s already noon. And as Mahal watches the two powerless beings below, he meditates in silence. These two souls are just beginning to know love, and already their efforts to embrace it are way over the top; or maybe there is such a thing as loving too much. All the same, what they feel for each other is real and powerful: it would be a shame for them to part.
