Actions

Work Header

One More Moment

Chapter Text

From her garden Yavanna watched the horizon stretching in yellow-pink hues like a veil. Quiet fingers grazed the trees as she took in the sweet scent of jasmine carried along by the wind on the path toward the garden’s center, where birds had flown to be near. Her singing was about to begin.

That is when the words came, lively and clear as if there, from a voice unknown. In a hole in the ground, there lived a hobbit. He thought he had it all, until a band of dwarves came to his house one night...

This would turn into a form of prayer, she knew. For Yavanna can feel hobbits’ stories unfold in real time, especially when they uncover a need beyond what their power can achieve.

She sat against a linden tree, her mind attentive to the breaking voice that poured desperate lines through emotion and restraint, an act of courage in every word. And the green lady was moved, and wanted to help.

Where are you? she called for Aulë in her mind.

Aulë’s voice echoed inside her head. He is in Middle Earth, above a place called Ravenhill.

She vanished, the hobbit’s words still ringing in her ears.

 

...From his seat in the clouds Mahal watched the dwarves, men and elves emerge victorious in the battle’s end. The sun began to descend; soon it would be time for his child to decide, ideally before Thorin’s Company find him relatively unharmed, locked in another’s arms in a surreal scene, suspiciously miracle-like.

“There you are.”

Aulë takes a moment to feel the change as Yavanna moves gracefully towards him: Ravenhill tower, the frozen waterfall against this luminous being made of kindness and hope; his equal, his partner in all things.

They have never met here before.

She relates details of a quest: dwarves, a lost kingdom, a hobbit in the midst of it all...

“Say no more. Take a look below.”

“Oh.” Yavanna spots the two figures on the ice. “I see. I take it the one with bronze curls, in the blue coat, is the hobbit in question?”

“Correct. And the other is the idiotic dwarf in question. The gist of it? The dwarf wants to live, because Baggins wants him to live. Wanted, to be exact. Because in the meantime Baggins changed his mind: he wants to die so that Thorin can die: which is what the dwarf wanted in the first place.”

“Oh, dear. We’d better get down there.”

As they descend, Thorin and Bilbo’s voices become clear. By the sound of it, they haven’t reached an agreement yet.

“Fine. We will go to the Halls. We haven’t even had one date, and you’re ready to join me in death.”

“Perfectly so.”

“What if a year from now you start missing your life?”

“We’ll deal with it then.”

“Yet that is not how your story ends,” Yavanna says as the two Valar reach the ground. “The hobbit asks a higher being to grant life to his friend. That is the last of what you said. If your wish has changed, your tale’s ending needs to change too.”

Bilbo and Thorin bow solemnly before her, lost for words; the urgency kicks in now.

“Y... you mean I can change it to anything I want?” Bilbo forgets himself, and Yavanna recognizes that shyness and determination, both present in this unlikely creature that manages to surprise. Mahal glances amusedly at her - Maybe you shouldn’t have told him that - and interjects with a stern voice.

“All right, lads. In her infinite grace, my wife grants you one more chance at formulating a request. But mind you, this is the last one. Speak, and be done with it.”

“I have the perfect ending,” says Bilbo, an idea striking him. “Here it goes: The dwarf king was content to die: for his fate was bound to that of his dead kin, the nephews whom he had raised as his own. The hobbit understood: Thorin would never be happy in life if Fíli and Kíli were dead. So Bilbo kneeled before Lord Mahal and Lady Yavanna, his lovely wife, and explained Fíli and Kíli both needed to live: one to rule in Thorin’s stead, the other to pursue romance with the elf. “Please,” he begged, “bring both back to life”.

“Fíli and Kíli have already reached my Halls,” Mahal says. “Bringing them back is not as simple as keeping Thorin alive. On the other hand, if you two accepted to take their place...”

“But I just said Thorin is bound to them! He wants to be near them, not switch places with them!”

“Yet you haven’t said anything about you two’s fate this time. And since you, Baggins, were content to follow Thorin to my Halls minutes ago - in fact, insisted upon it...”

“I... was hoping we could all live,” Bilbo says. “But you’re right, I am not asking for it. I place myself and Thorin at your mercy. Whatever you do, don’t tear us apart.”

“I deserve to die,” says Thorin quietly. “I would be happy to switch places with them.”

“Oh, stop it, you infuriating dwarf. You’re not helping.”

“I’m going to steal your... friend for a few minutes,” Yavanna addresses the hobbit while extending her hand to the king. Wordlessly, Thorin follows her. On the steps of Ravenhill tower they sit, a place Thorin would run from if not for the grace and purity bestowed by this warm, forgiving presence next to him. And suddenly the ice disappears. He stands on a golden shore, still caught in the flow of time, while infinite waves break below.

There is no right choice. The answer is in the sea, if the waves could wash away his guilt and carry him to another shore.

“Child of my husband, what are you afraid of?”

Thorin is not afraid: except of being stripped down to his very soul, or of the tears that start rolling by, unable to be controlled anymore.

“Your own heart, I think. You are used to doing your duty; yet that is not what is asked of you today.”

“It is not duty. None of what I feel is.”

“No. It is not. It is love: for your family, as well as your One. Taking Kíli’s place... you would do in a heartbeat, would you not?”

“Yes. I would.”

“And would you take Bilbo Baggins with you?”

Thorin shakes his head. “I would have him live, if I knew I would see him again one day.”

“Correct me if I’m wrong, but even if you weren’t thus assured, I believe you would have him live.”

“You are not wrong.”

“He wants to come with you. Why won’t you have him? It would bring both of your nephews back.”

“Because he doesn’t deserve to die. He joined me in this cursed quest thinking it would be the adventure of his life. For what? Only to die because I was stupid enough to die? I would have Bilbo enjoy life: he has not had enough.”

“And if his will is different from yours?”

“Then may his will be done. I love him too much to refuse him anything.”

The sea beckons to him. Eternity... He will endure, live on the certainty of Bilbo’s love alone. And they will meet again.

The green lady watches him carefully. “Incidentally, I agree with you.”

“On what?”

“That Bilbo should live.”

 

Back on the ice, the hobbit has not changed his mind: he will follow where Thorin goes. As Yavanna and Thorin return, Mahal lifts his hands to the sky and calls upon two children in the Halls, not just summoning, but materializing them.

Fíli and Kíli appear, happy, ready to launch the fiercest group hug, oblivious to the inevitable farewell.

“Wait a minute.” Kíli looks around. “How is it possible that we’re here? We were to attend a feast in Mahal’s Halls. Has it been cancelled?”

“No one told us,” Fíli says.

“Nothing’s been cancelled,” Mahal replies. “These two here have agreed to take your place. I should point out, your uncle was going anyway, as he was offed by Azog. But this other one” - he points to Bilbo - “comes of his own will.”

Fíli and Kíli demand answers, outraged. Yavanna whispers something in Fíli’s ear.

“Bilbo,” he says alarmedly, “you are the last person on our quest whom I would allow to die. I don’t want you to take my place. My Lord,” he kneels before Mahal, “this is out of the question. I demand to be taken back, now.”

“Very well. Then you will go back. Your brother will remain here, to enjoy life with the elf. And you, Baggins, will live too: if for nothing else, because it is my wife’s wish.”

“By the way, Uncle, your father sends his love,” Kíli says. “He is very proud of you.”

“Aye,” Fíli confirms. “Thráin is happy and at peace in the Halls. He doesn’t want you to worry about him. His wish is that you live a long, happy life.”

“Well, that’s not happening,” says Mahal. “So. Fíli and Kíli, say your goodbyes. And you too, Baggins and son of Thráin. I’ll be out of your hair while you do. Come, my love, let’s give them some time,” he says to his wife, undoubtedly meaning Let’s get out of here before anyone can change their mind.

“You are right, my dear,” Yavanna says as they drift away, out of sight. “They need time.”

 

...The waves crash at Thorin’s feet again. It is close, now. Not perfectly right, but perhaps it’s as right as it can be, to go to the Halls without his One and have one nephew live, be happy, and love. Half of his guilt will be washed away. It is fitting to endure the other half: he couldn’t buy both of their lives with his own.

It is close, now. Eternity, and the hope he will see Bilbo again. Yet much closer is the present moment, when they are still here, not ready to say goodbye.