Chapter Text
The shadow climbs the walls to vaulted ceilings and splits into grey rays, translucent, projected down towards the tomb where Thorin lies, Bilbo still next to him. It’s like night falling, soft and mournful, yet peaceful all the same, the presence of this shadow he now begins to see.
His eyes look up to these strange counterparts of sunlight; he feels himself split likewise into parts. The parts align for battle against all enemies of reason, not buying this division of reality. Save for a lonely one, that has its doubts as well.
“You can’t be him.”
“Say it again,” he hears the voice. “Say what you want.”
The shadow lines are close together now, as if in waiting, there at his command.
“I want him to come back. To feel him close to me.”
The rays converge and form a whole, adjusting a few times, from vague to tall and slim, and then familiar. A contour and a stance that give Thorin away. The way he holds himself, that bearing no one in the world will have again.
A part of Bilbo wants to jump and run outside, to life. The other, barely lucid, approaches in a daze, his step a dizzy dance. The shadow moves with him and settles on the wall, and Bilbo tries to touch it in the highest place his hand can reach. But it’s just stone; he cannot feel a thing.
“The things you said...”
You as in him before he died.
“I have wondered if there was more.”
“Yes,” it whispers, coming through in waves, trickling as it saunters downwards, seeking.
“How can it be for us to not be parted?”
It hurts, it hurts that he can’t see its eyes. Whatever soul’s inhabiting this shadow, this can’t be easy. It’s full of reservations, made of caution.
“I’ve never asked if you could share my feelings. It was enough that you just... be.”
These words are so like Bilbo’s own; he must have conjured them.
“I thought we had time, too. After the battle. I was wrong.”
“Time. I would gladly give you all of mine, if you wanted it.” There is resentment in these words, that Bilbo cannot hide.
“It is what you want that matters.”
Isn’t this strange? He is alive, while Thorin is no more; yet this being acts as if it has all the time in the world, while he needs to buy time. Right there, that shows this isn’t real. It could be Thorin, yet still the fabrication of a dream. He decides.
“What I want... I suppose I want proof that this is real.”
“You will have it, very soon,” says the Thorin-like figure. And it flees.
* * *
It cannot wait.
How to make Bilbo listen not just to what he has to say, but also to what he keeps silent. How not to scare him, yet get those feelings out in the open, just enough for Bilbo to understand. How to reveal himself without reducing his love to a figment. Above all, not to force him; this Thorin will not stand for. The freedom to seek happiness in simple places, in cool rivers, sunny gardens, in tall trees, is Bilbo’s. It’s something Thorin loves in him, and will not take away.
This wish to find the balance now sends him flying to his family’s chambers, away from the tomb. He enters a dark, dusty room, carpets and curtains and an old, crippled closet, remnants of what used to be the royal bedroom.
In the closet there is a box no evil got to. In the box there are three rings. The one for him is blue, for Durin’s line, and big and Dwarvish, not made for hobbit fingers.
His hands open; he traces Bilbo’s hand in them, until he can see it, down to the last detail. He slides the ring onto one illusive finger, and the difference is made clear.
Sounds ring deep from the forge that evening, frightening to the ones who’d listen. Luckily everyone is upstairs, holding the feast of great remembrance. Bilbo is there, too, and Thorin yearns. The welding and the searing make longing all the deeper in this place.
He walks outside and scouts the Mountain top. It’s night. The stars are lit. He lifts his arms, ascends, until they reach the sky. He gathers seven stars around the ring, which form a circle, and draws a line from each. The lines converge from stars towards the ring, sending it light and matter. Now there are specks of stars in it, shining with the divine light of the world’s beginning, and Thorin pours his love into each one. This work feels like a bonding of their souls; no, the expression. That bond already exists. It must.
Back in the tomb, his form is shadow still, and one blue ring of light.
* * *
Once removed from the tomb, Bilbo resolved he imagined it all. There is only one reality. There is no Thorin anymore. It’s. Just. Him.
There is a feast. The Dwarves and Men are seated at the table. Gandalf is there too, scrutinizing him knowingly.
“The sooner, the better,” the wizard tries for a reminder. “To go home.”
He nods.
“It’s just what you need. A chance to think about all you’ve gone through during long hours. Each day a new beginning, bringing new sights, while you can witness a small change in you. It takes patience, and no ups and downs. In each stone, in every leaf and strand of grass, you will find strength, constancy; peace, ultimately. It’ll do you good.”
“Yes,” he whispers in agreement with this sensible reality. “It would.”
Would, not will. If. Yet the words linger; so easy it would be, if he could wash it all away.
Gandalf senses his hesitation. “Please humor me and get a good night’s sleep. You need it, Bilbo.”
He lies down on his bedroll. It is a matter of minutes before he hears the dwarves snoring in a familiar scene. All too familiar.
“Where are you going?” Bofur pierces him with his kind gaze.
I left something unfinished. He doesn’t want to lie. He wishes he could reconcile these two worlds, show his friends what he knows.
“To Thorin. I want to see him.”
“You don’t sound well, my friend.”
He and I are not finished. Bilbo thinks quickly. How best to put it without sounding mad, not just to Bofur; to himself as well.
“I’ll soon go home. And when I’m gone... I won’t get the chance again, you know. To be...”
Bofur nods, understanding catching up with him, or something like. “Yes. Yes. Of course.”
He finds the tomb again through hallways dark and grim, guarded with torches still; the shadow on the wall, waiting for him. It comes down, kneeling, no time to waste, and Bilbo sees the ring.
“It cannot be.”
“It is.”
“Why? What is this for?”
He feels Thorin hesitate. (Thorin? He must be mad.) Thorin wants something so much, right now, and is fighting it.
“Because you asked me how, and asked for proof. This is both.”
“This is so that we won’t be parted?”
“It’s what is needed, yes. You and me, joined in eternity.”
Bilbo’s legs melt. He reaches out instinctively, his hand moving through the immateriality of the figure before him and hitting the wall harshly.
“If... if you want.”
Maybe reality can change. Molded in ways I never knew I wished for.
“I will love you forever. No matter what. You need not feel... Being together... it’s in your hands.” And the ring is now in Bilbo’s hands, pushed by an invisible force, or maybe just the words alone.
“Thorin, this is. I...”
Lost. Lost in confusion, there’s no center, no logic there to guide him. The ring alone could steady him, the only thing that’s real. How does it feel, to hold this ring? It feels as if the ring lies at the bottom of a deep, deep sea, with green and red and blue mingled in myriads of combinations, and the clear yellow sand beneath. To grasp the ring would mean to drown in this sea, and he is lost.
Does he really know me? Do I really know him... The latter matters more.
“Take the night. And the day. To think about it.”
“Where will you be?”
“Here. I will be waiting for you.”
“Is there any way we can talk?”
“Of course.”
Because I don’t know if I love you and I don’t know how to figure it out and I thought you were dead this is nice of course it is having you here talking to you but it’s
Unreal, returns the answer. This is unreal.
Yet the ring’s there, pressed in his hands, glittering with the otherworldly beauty of the stars, a microcosm beckoning at him, take me, take me and shape this world anew.
“Do you want... to remember?” asks Thorin suddenly. Bilbo fears. It feels as if the shadow guessed his thoughts.
“What?”
“At the Hidden Door. When the sun and the moon were in the sky together. The way you looked at me. I thought...”
Bilbo kneels by the shadow. He leans his head forward and wishes to be held, for this is him; no one else can know this.
“I thought I saw something. The light in your eyes. I wondered then if you could love me.”
He breathes. He does. Remember. “I... yes. You see, what I felt then... I didn’t know who it was coming from, if it was you or me. I sensed love’s presence, and I knew we would... I mean, I thought we could...”
A rustling, like relief, like a breath long held, he hears, feels on his neck. He is close now.
“Yet we never did so much as hold hands.” He gives a wistful smile. “So this is... it’s just. A bit much, right now.”
The shadow breathes again, a powerless admission.
“I wish we had more time. To go through all the stages, you know. First this, first that.”
“I know,” the voice returns with sadness, yet Bilbo feels its hope. How he wishes he could see Thorin now; so he could read this hope upon his face, that they can do it now, all of this they can still do.
“Is there no more time? At least for me to think about it more?”
Yet Thorin sensed his wish before he spoke.
“All the time in the world, my love.”
He knows it can’t be true. If it were, Thorin would take his time. The words restore calm still, save for the tremble in his arms at the last two; he almost drops the ring.
“Please, tell me what you want.”
Who said this? Both spoke at the same time.
Now Thorin takes the lead. “Whatever you decide... follow your heart. Your happiness matters the most to me.”
This is what Thorin says; yet Bilbo knows there’s more, a wish that’s left unspoken.
“Your turn,” the shadow calls. And Bilbo knows it now, for it is his wish too.
“I want to stay here, with you, tonight.”
He places the ring at the shadow’s face, illumining it slightly, and he can see the blue in Thorin’s eyes. Then Bilbo moves the ring where Thorin’s lips would be. He presses with his fingertip gently inside the ring, and feels Thorin’s lips through, just barely there. And suddenly he sees how he could know him more. The more he never knew.
He pushes slowly through the air, hands open, until they reach the wall. He tests the ring against the stone. The form and color of Thorin’s lips are in the stone now, and Bilbo feels.
He wishes. To see more of you. To hold you.
A breeze, a breath upon the ring turns it face up. The shadow lifts its arms and points upward, and seven holes open up in the ceiling. Thin rays like lines precipitate out of these holes, proceeding from the stars above, shooting into the ring a glowing, fearful light. Something now pulls the lines, stretching the ring, while Bilbo’s hands adjust to try to hold it as it changes, moved by a higher force. Light immaterial, Thorin alone can touch.
“The power is yours, while we’re here. Anything you want is yours, my love.”
Bilbo shivers at the last two words, escaped again before Thorin could catch them. Or perhaps said knowingly this time; he cannot tell.
“Is this what you wanted? Do you like it?”
The ring is stretched as wide as Bilbo’s arms can spread.
“It is. I do.”
Thorin closes the holes above, and light diminishes, yet still remains in seven places of the ring. Bilbo guides the ring down, leaning it against the wall, and now he can see Thorin facing him. The inside of the ring, that empty space, is filled with him.
“I’m wrong,” he whispers to this dream, so limitless and free. “This is more than anything I could have ever wanted.”
And Thorin drinks the sight of him, his loving gaze infused with light of stars.
