Chapter Text
Some believe that, during our earthly life, the body is a cage that keeps the soul imprisoned, hindering its progress, its ascension to the Good, the Truth. For some, when the soul exits the body, only then, it is released. It moves on towards knowledge, freedom, closer to perfection.
Bilbo does not believe these things. He may have, once, though in his case the comforts of the body, like good food, were nothing but conducive to reading, learning, reaching a higher plane. Yet he may have readily agreed that the soul, in the end, is all that matters, while humbly conceding that detachment from the body is an achievement reserved for a more elevated race, like Elves, and not for simple Hobbits like himself.
Yet upon meeting - seeing - Thorin, Bilbo saw a harmony of soul and body he’d never entertained before. For the first time, he wondered if by chance the soul and body are made to be together, and what one could do in one's life to blend them.
After meeting Thorin, certainly as of late, he may have also thought that at least in this case, when the soul departs, it is deprived.
That thought still lingers now, the second morning after that senseless, inconceivable event of death. It lingers now, when Thorin is, and yet is incomplete. His soul is within reach, transparent, like a glass window open before Bilbo. But Thorin’s body is not all that it could be. His body is light, ethereal, like a soft garment that is clothing Thorin’s soul, matching it, complimenting it... yet lacking.
It’s not important, though. It’s him, if in a new way, and what matters is to keep him there. That Thorin should not dis...
The thought tries to insert itself, and Bilbo fights to keep it out. He imagines this thought turn into smoke and float into the air, until it disappears.
After their brief night in the Shire, they rest side by side, in silent contemplation. Now and then Bilbo dozes off, then wakes up to see if Thorin is still there. There is no real rest here though, not when he knows they have to part again.
Bilbo watches him. Thorin looks a lot like he did that first night, when he stood by the fireplace and sang in Bilbo’s house, turning its mood from light-hearted to solemn. Thorin’s dark coat, colored in black and blue, his eyes, his hair... they paint a picture. The handsome, loving prince who walked straight from a dream like he was made to answer Bilbo’s wishes. He was like that before; but he was also more. Is it that now the pipe is missing in his hand, or that the sword is missing at his side?
Come to think of it, I can’t imagine this new Thorin even wielding a sword. He’s way too peaceful in this body.
Perhaps in this new body the warrior is gone. The one who can be blunt, not great with words, clumsy at times, but also fiercely passionate and fearless. It’s that component that made Thorin feel more real than anyone Bilbo has ever met.
Then this half-body, ethereal and imperfect, starts talking, and Bilbo leaves his musings.
“Bilbo, listen to me. You’ll need your strength today. Get some rest while it’s still morning. But don’t rest for too long. You’ll need to focus.”
“Focus,” repeats Bilbo. “On...”
“On our connection. All we’ve created these two nights together, and before. The way it seems we’re destined for each other. Think of me. Keep my memory with you, and don’t let go.”
This sounds as if you’re dead and you’ll stay dead, thinks Bilbo bitterly. As if I need to keep some sort of vigil.
“I am dead,” Thorin offers calmly. “It is thanks to you, in part, that I came back. Your wish to stay with me. Your active mind, your thoughts converging towards me. All of this helps to keep me here.”
Bilbo blinks in surprise. Is that all? Then if I lose my focus you may disappear. What if I can’t focus hard enough?
“Your faith in me. In us,” finishes Thorin, decisiveness in this statement. “It is important that you believe in what’s to come.”
He rises. It is time.
“Don’t go,” Bilbo breathes.
“Don’t be afraid. I will come back. I will.”
“I love you.”
Thorin gazes at him, intensity unspoken. His eyes are just the same as always, the light of stars in them shining with brightness, that part of him is unchanged and unmistakably alive, even more alive now, when Bilbo pushes him to the wall, the same wall where Thorin’s shadow first descended days ago. Thorin attempts to hold him, but Bilbo pins his arms onto the wall and kisses him, his heart burning to clarify something he cannot say. He’s not used to imposing reality on anyone, much less that anyone should be real for his sake. Yet what he can’t express in words he wants to with this kiss, to seal Thorin’s reality for good, to own it.
“There are things you’re not telling me.”
There's more Bilbo would want to say. Do you really believe that this can be, or can we say you don’t know, you just hope? He’d want to punish Thorin somehow, for not being real, no, for not reassuring him enough that he is. For being too cold and mysterious and calm.
“There are things I don’t know,” Thorin replies. “But as for you and I... It will happen. Tonight. You need not doubt it.”
Bilbo kisses him one more time, then puts his palms over his face, his fingers pushing against Thorin’s forehead, his cheeks, down to his neck, as to assert a claim. And as his fingers feel the soft materialness of this skin, Bilbo feels dreams must be different; this is not a dream. Thorin has kept his promises, there’s nothing left to do but follow through, follow this magic thread to its conclusion, and believe.
“Go now,” says Bilbo, his tone resigned. “I’ll wait for you tonight.” Go while I still believe enough to let you go.
Thorin nods in agreement, and exits fast, the shadow sinking to the floor, going far once again, while Bilbo’s arm remains outstretched, his hand extended toward where it touched him, longing, unfulfilled.
The day begins.
* * *
...Bilbo is dreaming.
In his dream, Thorin does not come back. Bilbo waits, midnight comes and goes, and nothing. Many days pass by. He remains stuck in this one place, the Mountain, where he can hope to see Thorin again, for fear that leaving would diminish any hope of his return. Gandalf soon departs. The dwarves, Bilbo’s friends, do not begin to understand; they simply carry on. A statue he becomes, almost, like long-gone kings of Erebor, lost in his mind, spinning in circles, demanding what he missed. Until one day Thorin appears again, pale like a ghost, and Bilbo cannot speak. His face unfazed, no longer moved... he is not sure.
Then Thorin speaks. He’s come just to say that all he wanted was for Bilbo never to forget him. That is why he appeared to him shortly after his death: to strengthen their connection, to ensure it endured.
“I knew, at the time of my death, that you weren’t in love with me. Perhaps you were close; I do not know. I wanted you to love me. I would have done anything to make you love me. So I pleaded to be allowed a little more time, just so I could leave a proper imprint in your soul. When you finally said those words to me, that night in the Shire, I knew my wish was realized, and I could rest in peace.”
Bilbo finds his words at last. “You said you would marry me.”
He knows he sounds absurd. This is absurd.
Thorin is silent. Bilbo thinks he understands. It was part of leaving an imprint, to get him to imagine, to wish for such a thing. It was part of making him fall irreversibly in love. A wedding... Not actually attainable, just a practical means to an end. Makes sense.
“I would have,” Thorin speaks eventually, and as he does, his figure starts to fade. “Unfortunately there was no more time.”
And just like that, he’s gone, and Bilbo’s mind freezes in shock. Then he feels something changing, as if with Thorin’s ghost part of the world has gone; the dream disintegrates.
“You didn’t have to go to all those lengths to “make me love you”!” he screams to no one. “I would have loved you anyway! I did so before all this - it would just have taken me longer to realize it! You didn’t have to deceive me like this!”
“Bilbo,” a no-nonsense voice rises from somewhere around the tomb, that’s where he is, right, he’s at the tomb again talking to an illusion that he couldn’t hold on to.
“Bilbo, you were dreaming. Of nothing good, I venture to presume.”
It's not Thorin; still, there is hope.
“You’ll only exhaust yourself more this way.”
Gandalf beholds him with that annoying look that says I know everything and more that you don’t know. Bilbo hates that. I get it, you can read my mind, but could you just use words already and tell me what you know
It appears Gandalf heeds, for once.
“Bilbo... I can’t begin to imagine what you must be feeling right now,” he says in a grave, sympathetic tone. “You know... Some believe that after death a person’s soul lingers on earth for a short while, and that only on the third day it truly leaves this world. There are accounts of people who were able to see one’s soul shortly after one’s death; when this occurs, it gives us time to transition to being without those who left. It gives us time to say goodbye.”
Outside his control, Bilbo’s hands move up, suddenly on a mission to reach his ears.
“So understandably since the third day has arrived for... for Thorin, this must be incredibly difficult for you.”
They have reached his ears, and covered them, and Bilbo can’t hear anymore.
But he’d like to know more. Has anyone ever come back. Not for a day or two, but more. For a life. He doesn’t ask; he fears Gandalf’s answer.
“So, stay here if you wish, for the rest of the day. But know that it’s the last. If he has shown himself to you in any way, it is to ease your shock, give you a bit more time, but also to say the last goodbye. You need to let him go, Bilbo.”
He nods. He’s good at lying. All the same, Gandalf may know, may be able to see through it, that Bilbo not only doesn’t believe this is the end, but also dares to hope for something greater.
“I’ll come to check on you again after midnight.”
“That won’t be necessary. I’m perfectly fine. Good day to you,” Bilbo says sharply. And just as Bilbo did so, he thought he saw a raised eyebrow, a slight surprise on the wizard’s face.
The rest of the day is spent as Thorin guided, in a sort of focused meditation, where memories of them brush against the forefront of his mind in an austere, non-romantic way. Two silhouettes at first, later two dots that represent their souls connected, always close to each other, are all they are in his mind's exercise, which, he tries to remember, is what’s needed now. Thorin said Bilbo’s wish to never part is a factor in this strange, would-be miracle. A foreign thought, and quite a leap for Bilbo, the one not used to viewing himself as a cause; anyone but him.
He struggles in the evening. He forgot about breakfast, lunch or dinner, and now hunger is coming back to him. He’s feeling weak. He could go upstairs and ask for food, yet fears the distraction of other people will break his concentration. So he remains there, in the dark, silent tomb, soon to drift toward sleep again, at the foot of the stone where Thorin’s body lies.
...The dream he had continues with him in the Shire, all alone. Thorin is gone forever, and Bilbo is sentenced to continue living.
He feels the loneliness, the emptiness of this dream. Nothing happens in it; it’s mainly just a feeling that stays with Bilbo, seeping into his core. A feeling of emptiness perpetually reflected by the world around. The houses, trees and flowers are lonely, colorless, devoid of life. In this desolate place Bilbo is doomed to exist, dimmed by the absence of a person that took the world with him.
The dream feels so real that when Bilbo wakes up, this feeling is in him. Thorin will not come back. He is convinced now. The dream is a foreshadowing of his life that starts tomorrow. Today, even. There will be no change. His time with Thorin was real, and rather wonderful, but it’s probably all they could have. Thorin gave him hope, something to hold on to, but ultimately, this has to be the end, as Gandalf said.
Focus, he thinks. Thorin told me to focus. I’m pretty sure this doesn’t count.
It’s hard to focus, the memories of him and Thorin marred by the greyness he has witnessed in his dream, internalized, now. Bilbo needs something else, a new device that can cut through this fog. Something that Thorin said...
Only I can bring him back. No, that’s not quite what he said. I don’t know if he can come back or not. But if he were to come back, it would be for me.
It’s not enough.
What Gandalf said... Is it time? Maybe Thorin will come for a brief moment, for a last goodbye? Or maybe they already had it? No. Neither. Nothing in what transpired between him and Thorin was, or will be goodbye. Gandalf must be wrong.
He takes out Thorin’s ring to look at it. The ring... All day Bilbo struggled, wanting this ring on his finger, to show it off and say to everyone, Look! Does any of you know what this means? Tonight I will marry your king!
He did put it on a few times. The next moment he was drenched in doubt; took off and hid the ring. Then on again, then off, a few more times. For who could validate such a statement? They would just think him mad. Yet he needs validation: the weakness in his body becomes weakness of the mind, a mind that can no longer rely on itself.
This must be an ongoing test; the ring can help, perhaps. The ring has mass, weight, color. It has been constant, always present. Thorin presented it as proof that this is real.
“Thorin,” he calls softly, almost like calling his own mind, to bring it back along with Thorin’s name.
“I don’t want to live in a world that you’re not in.”
The ring is lifeless, though. It has no power. It can’t help beyond providing a reminder of their brief time together.
“Yet in my dream, I was. And it was not unbearable. It was just... nothing.”
In my dream, I knew you wouldn’t return. But that was not the worst. The worst was that I was not allowed to delude myself. I couldn’t hope.
“If for whatever reason you don’t come... I want to at least be able to hope. And to remember. To live as if you were...”
Live like a madman? He frowns; pushes the thought away.
I will spend the rest of my life thinking of you. Hoping to see you again one day, even if I were to know that that can’t be.
I will spend the rest of my life waiting for you, even if I have no reason left to believe you will come.
Nothing is unbearable - well, except for this thing itself, that nothing is unbearable.
For all that he's tried for encouragement, this last thought is the most hopeless he's had. But this was not what Thorin told him to do, was it? No, he was supposed to believe. Not to plan for insurance in case Thorin didn’t come back. He sees it now: his mind has given up believing. His back-up plan has undermined his trust.
You asked me to believe. I did, for what, like an hour? If that.
What is it, to believe? How does one do it? Can one choose to believe, or is it something that just happens?
Either way, it has to be genuine. And I don’t genuinely believe this right now, when I myself feel I will disappear.
“Thorin...” he says, defeated, looking down in half-shame. “I do believe. I've always believed in you. But I also doubt. It’s both of them at once. I want to believe more fully. But for that... to be ready to be with you in the way that you promised... to believe completely in what's to come... I need your help. Help me.”
He sighs, relieved. That was the truth. He lets the seconds pass, then rises from the floor, leaning his back against the tomb. He should go, soon.
“You’re ready now.”
He turns and sees. Thorin stands behind him, on the other side.
A revelation. For both, not just for Bilbo. Thorin seems equally amazed.
“You love me.”
Bilbo smiles. That took a while. “You think?”
“I didn’t know it fully until now.”
“So... it sounds like I passed whatever test this was? Yet I can’t fathom how.”
“Faith is not perfect. But love can be. What you lost through lack of faith you made up with your love. It was enough.”
“Are you saying you watched me?”
“No,” says Thorin. “I felt you.”
He takes Bilbo’s hand in his, and Bilbo feels his hurry, that he doesn’t want to linger for too long. They take just one moment, for Bilbo to perceive Thorin dressed in dark, regal clothes, holding a white robe and two crowns in his hands.
“So, we’re really going to do this?”
“Yes, we will. Come with me. It is time.”
...And they begin to walk towards the hallway, leaving the empty tomb. And in this hand he holds Bilbo can feel Thorin's body and soul pulsing together, two in one. The Thorin, the way he knew him always, has come back to the real world, for real is the way Thorin has revealed himself. Bilbo could not have dreamed him in this way. In this hand that he holds, he feels the life returned to Thorin fully, the life that vibrates through his body now, the same body that was alive before, then died... Life flowing out of him, reaching into his One, giving itself so Bilbo can live, too.
