Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Chapter 7: A Few Truths

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

SEVEN: A Few Truths

 

He found Bofur in the kitchen, pouring himself an ale and Bilbo declined the offer in favour of a nice cup of tea. The miner was smiling but there was a vague shadow in his clear brown gaze and Bilbo found himself feeling guilty for bringing Thorin into Bag End…even though he had no options. Silently, he sat opposite his friend at the table and waited for Bofur to speak. He wasn’t usually shy in expressing his opinion but Bilbo knew he had been put in a very difficult position.

 

“I don’t blame you,” Bofur said at last, his tone thoughtful. “You couldn’t leave him to die any more than I could.” He sighed. 

 

“I know,” the Hobbit admitted. “I knew something was wrong-I could feel it.” He unconsciously laid his hand flat on his chest. “All through the blizzards, I knew I needed to get out there…” The dwarf inspected him slowly, his eyes sad.

 

“You still love him,” he realised. Bilbo sipped his tea.

 

“I think I have some oat and raisin biscuits in the pantry,” he said and made to rise. Bofur exhaled slowly and watched him. Bilbo was a brave and generous friend but sometimes, he was rather slow to acknowledge what was there. So he watched as the Hobbit carefully arranged biscuits on the plate and came back, resting it down on the table. Then he sat down again. Bofur sipped his ale and watched his friend. 

 

“I guess that means you’re not really ready to talk…” he commented. But Bilbo sighed.

 

“I was furious at Thorin…and I am still a bit annoyed, to be honest,” he admitted, taking a biscuit and neatly snapping it in half. “The problem was never that I did not love him.”

 

“He’s Thorin Oakenshield,” Bofur grumbled. “Despite his looks, he has charisma by the bucketload, he cannot stop being a King no matter what he does. No one could take our eyes off him even when he was suicidally running at Azog after the Goblin Caves. Even my Mam never gave me a second look but Thorin Bloody Oakenshield commands every room he walks into. How could you not still have feelings for him?”

 

Bilbo rolled his eyes, then refilled his cup from the pot, dropping a spot of milk in and stirring carefully. He dunked the next half of his biscuit.

 

“You and the rest of the dwarves forgot to ask me what Hobbits do when they are in love,” he said testily. “You are always so keen to hint about your Ones-without explaining everything that I need to know. But Hobbit courting and marriage customs never featured. Not even Thorin asked and I was married to him.”

 

“Was? Past tense?”

 

Bilbo gave a sad smile.

 

“I left my wedding ring and my marriage bead behind,” he said. “As far as I was concerned, publicly humiliating me and declaring that he did not trust me was a statement that our union was over. So I left the symbols of our marriage behind and had to close my heart to him. You said I rejected him but there was nothing else I could do.”

 

“Do you know what Rejection means?” Bofur asked.

 

“No!” Bilbo snapped. “No I don’t because of your blasted secrecy!” The dwarf gave a groan and drained his ale. 

 

“Alright,”  he sighed. “I’m only telling you this because you are married to a dwarf and because you are a One.” Bilbo folded his arms and glared. “Being a dwarf who finds his One isn’t a simple business, Bilbo,” Bofur sighed. “It is a wondrous gift from Mahal, the most precious of all things a dwarf can own. Mahal crafted our Ones specially for us, the perfect partner who completes our heart and soul. But that isn’t just words-when a couple recognise the bond, especially when it is accepted and formalised, there is a physical change in both dwarrow as well. Their wellbeing is tied to the other and they are stronger and healthier together.”

 

“You mean you have to stay close or you become unwell?” Bilbo asked with a frown, wishing he had been told this before he married. 

 

“Not usually,” his friend told him, a small smile lifting his lips. “Dwarrow travel and sometimes, you have to be many leagues from your One. Perhaps for many months. But that love, that connection keeps you warm and fills you with hope and certainty that your One will come back, that you will be reunited… There are tales of dwarrow who knew the instant their One fell, when that connection was severed, even though they never knew of it at the time.”

 

Bilbo frowned.

 

“You mean magic?” he asked suspiciously. But Bofur gave a shrug. 

 

“It is the way we were created,” he said. “Just as dwarrow love only once and will never love again if they are rejected.” Then he pressed his lips together and looked unhappy.

 

“There’s more,” Bilbo realised.

 

“Normally, no dwarf would reject his One,” Bofur admitted. “He could be angry, they could argue, they could even separate but they would never reject the other because they know what it would do.”

 

“What would it do?” Bilbo’s tone was exasperated. 

 

“Rejecting your One would sever the bond and leave the separated partners in trouble,” Bofur said.

 

“He means that each would feel constant, searing pain in their heart that worsens the further you are from your One,” Bombur said, walking in and refilling his brother’s flagon of ale. He poured himself one and sat by Bofur. “It is a discussion that we all have with the StoneSeers prior to marriage.”

 

“Then why didn’t I get it?” Bilbo asked, feeling angry, hurt and bewildered. He had travelled halfway across the world, lived through every possible danger, almost got killed countless times, been cold, hungry and miserable, faced a dragon and fought a battle with his dwarves…but they still treated him as an outsider. Even when he married their King.

 

“Your face says you know why,” Bofur said in an apologetic voice. “StoneSeers will never even acknowledge an outsider. They are the most devout of Mahal's followers and interpreters of His Will.”

 

“And no one thought that quietly filling me in would be helpful. Maybe?” Bilbo asked sarcastically. 

 

“Maybe everyone else thought someone had done it,” Bombur offered.

 

“Certainly Thorin should have told you,” Bofur added shortly. Bilbo snorted.

 

“Not the best at explaining anything,” the Hobbit commented. “So being apart from Thorin after rejecting him causes him pain?” There was concern in his voice and the dwarven brothers shared a look.

 

“Not exactly,” Bofur said.

 

“Yes,” Bombur put in, elbowing him. “But more than that. A searing constant pain in the chest that is worse and worse the longer he is from the One he loved…and the further he is from him.” He shrugged. “I am astonished he lasted as long as he did.” Bilbo’s eyes widened.

 

“What does that mean?” he demanded. “And no more prevaricating. I’ve had it up to here with you clot-headed secretive mealy-mouthed dwarves! Explain it all. Clearly. Now!”

 

“When a dwarf is Rejected by his love, the bond with his One is cut,” Bofur explained. “You remember I said that dwarrow are stronger and healthier when they are with their Ones? The opposite is true. If a dwarf if rejected by his One, especially after he is married and their bond is formalised, then he suffers. There is the constant searing pain in the chest. There is the feeling of distress, loneliness and shame. Sleep becomes less restful and eventually the dwarf will be almost unable to get any rest. There will be nightmares and moodswings…” 

 

“Not that anyone could tell with certain dwarf Kings…” Bilbo muttered. Bombur gave him a severe look that caused him to snap his mouth shut and feel a little ashamed. Bombur was a quiet dwarf and was generally jolly as well-but he was also thoughtful and as a dwarf married for several decades with his beloved dwarflings, this was no joking matter to him. 

 

“And as time passes, the dwarf will weaken,” he continued, taking over from his brother. “In terms of strength but also in terms of will to live. He will become susceptible to illness and vulnerable to bandits and any of the normal dangers of life. His stamina will diminish and he will be unable to work. And finally, he will sicken and die.”

 

“WHAT?” Bilbo felt the world tilt around him.

 

“A young dwarf may be able to resist Rejection for many decades, though he would always bear the pain of rejection and, of course, he would never love again,” Bofur said. “But he could dedicate himself to his craft and for many, that would be enough to overcome the fading from rejection. They are always a little…odd…but some of the finest and most dedicated crafters in history have been rejected and choose to fill the gap with creating.”

 

“But an older dwarf like Thorin-especially one who has lived such a hard life-could never hope to survive Rejection,” Bombur added. “He would have known that, the moment you removed your Marriage Bead.”

 

“Then why did he banish me if he knew it would cause him so much pain?” Bilbo asked, his voice distressed.

 

“Because he is Thorin Oakenshield,” Bofur said. “The King.”

 

“And his damnable pride overrides everything that is of value in his life,” Bilbo said bitterly. “Our love, our marriage, the fact I would never knowingly hurt him…and yet, I end up doing it. The Crown meant more to him than his husband. The fact that people were laughing at him over a lie was more important than finding out the truth and caring for the one he loved. I bet he never even thought I would walk away, just sit there are take it like the lesser being I am…”

 

“Never…lesser…” Everyone looked up to see the sagging shape of Thorin leaning against the arch of the doorway into the kitchen. Bilbo started and stared at him, seeing the King’s face twisted with effort. Then he was up and at his dwarf’s side, helping Thorin into the chair he had just vacated.

 

“You should be in bed,” he told the ailing dwarf. 

 

“I think…this is more important,” Thorin said wearily. He still looked exhausted and gaunt, the shadows under his eyes dark like bruises. “Carry on. I think…I need to hear this…” Pulling up another chair, Bilbo perched on the cushion and exhaled in exasperation. “But the truth is, I never thought. I was angry and hurt…and foolish. Balin and the boys tried to stop me…but all I could see was the people of Erebor-and those Lords-laughing at me.”

 

“You know it was a lie, just malicious gossip…” Bilbo told him sharply. The King nodded, resting his hands flat on the table to steady himself.

 

“My heart knew that but my pride and honour…and all those worthless virtues…shouted louder,” he said miserably. “And my mind, clouded as it was…with residual Dragon Sickness, listened. My heart knew that my One-my fierce, sarcastic, brilliant, generous, kind, brave One-would never suffer such an insult without reacting…and I think I knew I would lose you. But it is what I have always deserved, since I held you over that drop and felt the overwhelming urge to kill you.” He lifted his chin. “You should never have forgiven me, Ghivashel. I never deserved it. And when we married, I always guessed…that I would do something heinous enough…to drive you away. I just hoped…that you would not suffer…as a dwarf would suffer from such a rejection.”

 

“You dwarves still know nothing about Hobbits,” Bilbo told him irritably. “All I’ve heard is about your Ones and how you manage to mess things up and have gotten yourself in such a pickle you are probably going to die from being Rejected. But no one has asked if I am alright or what happens with Hobbits. Because if you had, none of this would have happened at all!” The three dwarves frowned.

 

“What…do you mean?” Thorin asked hesitantly. He was trembling slightly and Bilbo had to stop himself from gasping his hand and giving a reassuring squeeze as his heart was telling him to.

 

“Hobbits are created by Yavanna, creatures of green growing fields and plants and earth and life,” he said. “They are not too different from you dwarves-who were created by Yavanna’s husband, Aüle-who you know as Mahal. We like food and family and good cheer. We value home and security. But you are creatures of stone and metal while we are softer. But another way we are similar is in that though we may have dalliances and fun when we are younger, we also only love once. And the one we love is called our Heart-Mate. No Hobbit could ever betray their Heart-Mate for another, no matter what inducements were offered. It doesn’t mean we don’t have close friends-Hobbits have huge extended families and very wide circles of friends and confidantes which is different to you secretive dwarves-but it does mean we would no more consider committing adultery than you would consider propositioning Thranduil.”

 

All three dwarves pulled a face that eloquently expressed their distaste of the very idea.

 

“You say it is very rare for a dwarf to be Rejected by his One,” Bilbo continued, now looking into Thorin’s eyes. “It is even rarer for a Hobbit. When a Hobbit loses his Heart-Mate, he fades. I watched it happen to my mother when my father died. She barely lasted a season, no longer wanting to go on without the other part of her Heart-and not even her son was enough to make her stay.” He paused and swallowed in grief at the words, then composed himself again. “And the only-the only way a Hobbit can stand a chance of avoiding that fate is to reject the bond and close their heart to the one they lost, almost as if they had never existed and certainly as if the relationship never was. And I did not want to fade, to die because of the stupidity and mistrust you showed me when I was innocent of everything you accused me of. So I rejected the bond, closed my heart to you and decided to survive, to go home and try to forget that I ever married the King of Erebor. But then, after not even communicating or offering any sort of apology, you just turned up here. Of course you never came to see me-I had to find out on my own. And I found you in the Shire, acting as if nothing had happened between us and playing at being a blacksmith.”

 

“I am a blacksmith,” Thorin said quietly.

 

“You are the King of Erebor!” Bilbo told him bluntly. “The Heir to the Line of Durin, leader of the Company, King Under The Mountain.”

 

“And for many years, I travelled and worked in the towns of men as a blacksmith to earn to support Dis and the boys,” the King said quietly. 

 

“Longer than I have been alive,” Bilbo grumbled and then stared as Thorin made no reply until a vicious bout of coughing had him doubled up and gasping for breath. He nodded slightly. 

 

“I spent many decades travelling, working and being alone among others,” he said haltingly, struggling to breathe. “I was isolated and abused and treated like nothing. But I knew why I did it: back in Ered Luin, Dis was waiting with my sister-sons, needing my help. And no matter how alone and desolate I feel I knew they were waiting. That I could endure what I was suffering because I had my family waiting for me at home.”

 

“And now…” Bilbo murmured.

 

“I wait for the end because I have lost the only gift Mahal ever gave me,” the King murmured. “I am Rejected. And I could no longer rule Erebor because I was no longer fit to rule. My family remain because they are who I risked it all for. Because they must rule the Kingdom for me.” Bilbo sighed.

 

“You are the King,” he murmured. “But I hurt you.” Thorin shook his head.

 

“Master Baggins, the fault is mine. The penance is mine-and it is justly deserved. There is no fault on your part…”

 

“Firstly, what is this ‘Master Baggins’ nonsense? It’s Bilbo, you rock-headed dwarf!” the Hobbit snapped. “And secondly, I never realised that by protecting myself from losing my Heart-Mate at the end of our marriage, I was hurting you. That I was killing you.”

 

Thorin gave a grim smile. 

 

“Mahal does not forgive,” he murmured. “Justice for my attack on you on the ramparts…”

 

“Enough!” Bilbo said shortly. “Enough of that nonsense! Thorin-I forgave you. Without hesitation and with understanding because you were ill. I fell in love with you during the Quest and I was prepared to give you another chance. I knew what you are like. You are moody and broody and have a temper and that damned pride and all that dwarvish secrecy…but you are also kind and tender and loving and thoughtful and when you were being my husband, you were perfect for me. You were my friend as well as my lover and I never regretted that. But you betrayed my trust by how you reacted. Maybe I over-reacted. But you never asked questions about my customs either…”

 

“I assumed…your kind were as secretive as my own,” Thorin murmured shamefacedly.

 

“You should have asked,” Bilbo scolded him. “Hobbits talk. We discuss things. We don’t confront first and last.” Thorin hung his head.

 

“I am sorry,” he murmured, then doubled up again in another paroxysm of coughing. He looked grey and ashen after it died down. Then he looked up. “Bofur, Bombur-the exile of your family has been rescinded. I should never have blamed you for my own stupidity. You have my humble apologies.”

 

Bilbo rolled his eyes at the stilted, formal language but Bofur looked thoughtful.

 

“You know, you didn’t apologise for being stark raving mad with Dragon Sickness on the ramparts-you just asked us to follow you ‘one last time’,” he said dryly. “You admitted you were wrong when you underestimated our Bilbo on the Carrock. But I think this is the first time I have ever heard of you uttering an actual apology.” 

 

Thorin stared flatly at him, the effect ruined by another bout of coughing.

 

“Kings don’t apologise…much,” Bilbo guessed as Thorin managed a weak nod. That last bout had drained all his air and he was shivering. Quietly, the Hobbit rose and found the rug he usually kept in a box in the parlour for cold evenings and wrapped it around the dwarf King’s shoulders. “You are impossible, Thorin. Stubborn as a rock and proud as…as…I don’t even know anything that is as proud as you! And you have a terrible temper and tend not to listen…but you would do anything for your people and you are stupidly brave and honourable even to your own detriment. You are an idiot…but you are still my idiot. I don’t want anything to happen to you…”

 

Still struggling to breathe, Thorin nodded.

 

“What was that name you use here?” Bilbo asked him thoughtfully, seeing him lean back in the chair. He was clearly exhausted and he wasn’t sure where Bofur stood on this but he now understood why Thorin was in the Shire. He just hoped the dwarf would understand why Bilbo had done what he had done.

 

“Lulkhel,” he managed to rasp. Bofur snorted and Bombur burst out laughing. Bilbo frowned, once again excluded from the joke.

 

“What? You said it was the name Dis gave you…” he said irritably. Bifur entered, laughing hard and made a comment in Khuzdul. Even though the axe had been removed from his head after the Battle, he still could not recall how to speak Westron. And though Bilbo had picked up a few words of the secret language, he still didn’t speak enough to understand the rapid words. “WHAT?”

 

“It means Idiot of Idiots,” Thorin muttered, his head bowed. His voice was still rough and he sounded exhausted. It shocked the Hobbit how little stamina he had, that a few minutes of admittedly emotionally-charged conversation had worn him out. “My sister’s idea of a joke. I agree that my name should remain in Erebor.”

 

“So the Hobbits have been calling you…basically the Biggest Idiot in Existence…since you arrived here?” Bilbo asked, his voice breaking slightly. Thorin nodded. “Oh Yavanna…” he whimpered and began laughing as well. And then he grasped Thorin’s shoulder. “You really set out to humiliate and humble yourself, didn’t you?” Another nod. “Oh Thorin…” There was sympathy in his tone and the King gave a sigh.

 

“Your people were as insular and xenophobic as my own,” Thorin rasped. “I was slandered, gossiped about and ostracised because I did not understand the ways of Hobbit courting.” He looked up. “But I should have. You have shown how inadequate and how selfish and foolish I have been. I never deserved you and all that befalls me is only justice from Mahal.” Bilbo took his hand then, squeezing it and feeling Thorin squeeze back. The skin was still abnormally warm, even for a dwarf, and another coffin cough had the Hobbit wincing. 

 

“I am so sorry,” Bilbo said gently. “You did not deserve that. Let’s get you to bed to rest and when you are feeling a little stronger, maybe we can have a longer talk.” Bifur helped him up with a reassuring murmur of Khuzdul which Thorin absently replied to and then he was helped back to Bilbo’s room. the Hobbit stared after him.

 

“You still love him,” Bofur said and there was a warmth in his voice which was more like the Bofur of old. “And he loves you. Bless me but he does seem to be trying to change. Maybe there is some hope for him.”

 

The Hobbit sighed.

 

“Somehow, he has to find a way to make me trust him,” he said and blinked. “That will be the key.”

 

“If he survives this, I am sure he will succeed,” Bofur grinned. “An apology from a King. That is something that Milania won’t believe!”

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Ghivashel - treasure of treasures
Lulkhel - idiot of idiots