Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Chapter 9: A Tentative Truce

Chapter Text

NINE:  A tentative truce

 

He slept in the parlour, curled up on the couch because Thorin was sleeping deeply in his bed and as he seemed to be resting quietly, Bilbo was restless but somehow, he felt safer now he had half of the Company here with him, as well as Tauriel and Bombur’s family. The parlour was cool but wrapped in a fluffy blanket and lying in front of the banked fire, Bilbo allowed himself to listen for various snores and snuffles. Kili and Tauriel had been given Bifur’s room-the dwarf had insisted-and he was now sharing with his cousin, Bofur. Dwalin and Ori had settled in the far parlour and bedded down, just glad to be safely in the Shire. The door was bolted and the night was dark, though the bluish reflections of the moon off the remaining patches of snow lit the room eerily. But soothed by the snoring of his dwarves, Bilbo slept.

 

He woke to the sound of footsteps and as he started up, he saw a tallish shape stumble towards the kitchen. Instantly, the Hobbit was up because he recognised that shape and he intercepted Thorin as he reached the kitchen. Gently, he rested a hand on the dwarf King’s arm.

 

“Thorin-what are you doing up?” he asked and the dwarf swayed but steadied himself.

 

“I was thirsty,” he murmured, “and I was hoping not to disturb you, Master Baggins…”

 

“Bilbo,” the Hobbit sighed. “I thought we had got past this Master Baggins nonsense. I did, after all, announce to Gardenia Proudfoot that you were my husband.” But instead of looking pleased, there was hurt in Thorin’s eyes.

 

“Now you toy with my affections and my name, Bilbo,” he said quietly. Bilbo wheeled away and paced across the passage, then back. 

 

“There is nothing further from the truth,” Bilbo said in exasperation. “I was absolutely furious how she and the rest of them were gossiping about you. And then she came up here and started insulting me and insulting you and calling you a nasty dwarf and a monster and I was not having that! Because I know, despite how stubborn and rash you are, that you are kind and determined and brave and heroic and terribly selfless and ridiculously dramatic and would give everything up for someone you loved. I wasn’t going to let her badmouth you any more. So I claimed you as my husband…which is true.”

 

Thorin stared at him, his back resting against the wall and arms folded across his chest-though the gesture looked very defensive.

 

“But you handed back my bead…” he murmured. He frowned and gave a wince, his hand rotating to press against his chest, causing Bilbo to look closer.

 

“Thorin-I cannot pretend not to be hurt by that the fact that you clearly did not trust me and believed the lies of Lords who had been trying to undermine me since Erebor was reclaimed,” he said calmly. “But I do care for you and I want to see if there is anything we can do to regain what we had. I-I just don’t know how…” 

 

“Neither do I…” Thorin muttered, his tone wretched. Bilbo sighed and beckoned and they headed into the kitchen. The fire in the range was giving a reddish light and Bilbo swiftly lit a couple of candles. Blinking away any residual sleep, Bilbo made the dwarf a cup of tea and himself one as well and then he stared at the shape sitting opposite. This was it: just the two of them in the quiet smial an hour before the late winter dawn, the only sounds the crackle of the fire and the snores of the others. 

 

Thorin sipped his tea, coughing slightly. He looked dishevelled and weary still, his face gaunt and eyes haunted but he was breathing more easily and it was clear that his fever had finally broken. And he was still looking desolate and wary. 

 

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo said honestly, his eyes never straying from the dwarf. “I didn’t know about the Rejection thing because you never told me. You never asked me about Hobbit courting.” Thorin bowed his head.

 

“I was so grateful for your forgiveness, that you would ever want to be near anywhere close to someone who tried to kill you…I did not want to offend you,” the King said wretchedly. “All I wanted was for you to be happy. Because I knew that Erebor was not the Shire, was not full of green, growing things and gardens and your family so I wanted to enjoy your presence as long as I could. But when Sulgan spoke, I felt such…jealousy. And part of me was screaming because I know you…but the rest was acting like a wounded boar.” He sighed. “And so I knew I could not stay there.”

 

“Kili told me you were alienating the people of Erebor by your actions,” Bilbo said.

 

“I didn’t care because they had cost me the only thing I cared about,” Thorin grumbled and slowly rotated the mug in his hands. “So leaving there under cover of darkness, travelling alone under an assumed name…it was no more than I deserved. And as I travelled further from Erebor and her tainted gold, my mind cleared and I could think straight again. And I wondered how I could possibly ever win back your trust.”

 

“You managed it before,” Bilbo reminded him. The King ghosted a smile, sipping his tea. It was strong and warm and eased the constant scratching of his throat. 

 

“You were receptive and had already formed friendships with the rest of the Company,” the King told him quietly. “You wanted to trust your travelling companions. But I did not. I saw you as weak and fussy and unsuited to the journey. I did not trust you-with anything. I always saw the worst of you. And I was harsh. Yet you did not give in and quit and instead, you stuck with us-even sneaking out of Rivendell, where I was certain you would stay.”

“I signed a contract,” Bilbo said automatically. 

 

“But you did not leave us in the Goblin Tunnels and then, when Azog attacked, you saved my life and I finally saw what lay beneath the Hobbit exterior: a heart of diamond, beautiful and strong and priceless. I knew I had misjudged you and I had to apologise…many of them have never seen me admit I was wrong…”

 

“Not a very good thing to admit,” Bilbo reminded him. Thorin gave that hint of a smile, his eyes thoughtful.

 

“The King is expected to be right and even if he is wrong, it is discreetly forgotten,” he reminded his friend.

 

“Except that is how dictators and tyrants rise, imagining they are always right and never listening,” the Hobbit retorted. The King’s shoulders slumped.

 

“Aye,” he conceded. “But once I started to trust you, I could not stop. And my heart ran away with me and decided you were my One…and once that determination is made, I was lost.” He bowed his head. “I could never win back your trust. Mahal knows how I ever managed to win it in the first place…”

 

“You know, you were determined and brave and no matter how desperate things were, you managed that little incline of the head you do so well and give a regal look and act the King,” Bilbo told him. “Even in Mirkwood, grubby and starved and covered in cobwebs, you still verbally tore Thranduil to shreds. You’re magnificent and it was then I realised that though he has thousands of years on you, Thranduil will never be a greater King than you.”

 

“You are biased,” Thorin told him.

 

“You were always royal and aloof but when we sat by the fire and chatted, you revealed who you were under all those trappings of history and duty…that was the dwarf I fell for,” Bilbo reminded him. “And after the Battle, I knew you had overcome the Dragon Sickness to come out and fight. I was so proud of you and so relieved that you survived that I was willing to give you a chance to be the King you were always meant to be…and if I ended at your side, well, my heart wasn’t averse the that…”

 

Thorin sipped his tea and then rested the mug down on the table.

 

“I wondered how I could win your trust back and eventually realised I could not,” he said. “I couldn’t even talk to you without us arguing. And the pain was worse whenever we did. I tried to tell you of my sorrow and abject humility in the face of your gift but I was not good enough at your language of flowers to speak clearly…”

 

“You did well,” Bilbo reassured him and patted his hand gently. “I just wasn’t ready to hear yet. I was still angry. Because I didn’t just lose you-I lost the Company, my friends and Erebor. I lost chats with Bofur, cooking with Bombur,  those afternoons reviewing stupid petitions with Balin, time with Ori in the Library, drinking tea with Dori…and I had to come back here, where they call me Mad Baggins because I ran away with dwarves.”

 

“I am sorry.” Thorin’s voice cracked with misery but Bilbo grabbed his hand. 

 

“You are my friend, Thorin,” he said seriously. “And I never wanted any ill to befall you. To learn I may have killed you and certainly caused you pain makes me feel sick. I am still not sure where our marriage is going…but I am willing to give you a chance to earn my trust back. And I am your friend. Will that ease your condition, at least a little…?”

 

Thorin nodded. He looked up, his eyes shockingly clear and honest.

 

“I will gratefully take whatever scraps you can spare me, Bilbo,” he said hoarsely. “When I came here, I never expected to even spend time like this with you again. As time passed, I knew I had lost you and resigned myself to perishing here. For you to save me and allow me this time…” Bilbo sighed.

 

“Over-dramatic dwarf,” he complained. “You should have come to me when you were freezing. When they turned you away…” But Thorin gave a smile of such sadness it broke his heart.

 

“I could not,” he said. “You had the others here and I would not impose my unwanted presence upon you…”

 

“Oh Thorin…” the Hobbit sighed and took his hand. “I would never turn you away in need. You know that.”

 

“That is why I could not come,” Thorin murmured. Bilbo squeezed his hand. 

 

“Stubborn rock-headed dwarf,” he complained. Thorin chuckled.

 

“I met my match in you,” he admitted as the Hobbit allowed himself a smile.

 

“Must be why I get on so well with all you dwarves,” he commented. “Oh Yavanna. Gardenia Proudfoot is going to make my life here a nightmare…”

 

“I could always go slay her?” Thorin suggested, a hopeful note entering his voice. “A Quest to reclaim your Honour and slay a dragoness…”

 

“Thorin Oakenshield…you are not slaying Gardenia Proudfoot!” Bilbo told him sternly.

 

“I could also throw in that cousin of yours…Lobelia Sackford-Baggins?” Thorin added enticingly.

 

“Sackville-Baggins and tempting though that is, the answer is still no,” the Hobbit repeated firmly. “You are just going to have to win me back the old fashioned way.”

 

“Flowers?” Thorin asked warily. The Hobbit cast his glance at the metal flowers Thorin had given him for Yule, outlined by the finest of pink lights from the impending dawn as they sat in a crystal vase on the windowsill.

 

“You know, you are really going to have to learn about Hobbit Courtship habits,” Bilbo told him smugly. “But those are utterly beautiful. And Bofur told me they are the work of a Master?” Thorin nodded.

 

“I earned my Mastery many decades ago,” he admitted. “And then spent my skills making nails and repairing kettles and plough-shares. I was ashamed to admit to anyone in any Guild because I had fallen so low, paid a pittance and sneered at by Men who possessed a tiny fraction of my skill. Yet I do not regret a moment that I spent working in such mean circumstances because that put clothes on the boy’s bodies and food in their bellies. My humiliation was nothing compared to their lives.”

 

“Oh Thorin, you are such a mass of contradictions,” Bilbo sighed. “You let your pride rip our marriage apart but you gave it up willingly to save your family.” Wearily, the King bowed his head.

 

“I had no choice-and I never regretted what I did for them…” he murmured. “Maybe…Tharkûn was right. About my pride…” Bilbo stared at him and found a small smile on his lips.

 

“And maybe there is hope for you yet,” he murmured, then glanced at the window. The trickle of watery pinkish golden light was spilling in as the hesitant winter dawn broke. “Now how about some breakfast?”

 

-o0o-

 

Dwalin had set out after second breakfast to check over the Forge in Bywater and keep it working while Thorin recovered. The King had offered to accompany him but Bilbo, Tauriel, Kili and Dwalin himself had offered to sit on the King until he saw sense. It was the first day his fever had broken and his lungs were still recovering and though the snow had mostly melted, the air was very cold and damp so even standing at the door had Thorin doubling up with a fit of coughing that had him gasping for breath. So Dwalin had tramped out alone, wrapped up in his cloak and headed for the Forge, ignoring the curious look of the Hobbits and determinedly not scowling fiercely at them. Thorin had worked hard for his tentative acceptance and Dwalin would not jeopardise it, no matter how angry he was at the Hobbits who had left his friend to die.

 

His anger redoubled when he reached the Forge, for the door swung open and it was clear someone had been rooting around inside. Bilbo had made sure that all of Thorin’s possessions and his money had come back with the ailing dwarf but the thought someone had rifled through the Forge in search of some leverage against the King made his fists itch. So he pushed the hatch open and allowed the watery winter light to flood the space, then looked around. He smiled and walked to the tools, laid out neatly exactly as Thorin did in every forge he worked in. Dwalin had travelled and worked with his King for many seasons, for Dis and the Princes were his cousins as much as Thorin was, and he was very familiar with Thorin’s way of doing things. And he had seen his friend work late to finish an order that the Man who owned the forge had taken, hoping for the dwarves to fail and have their wages reduced for the failure. Or seen him swallow his pride as he was taunted and humiliated by creatures without a fraction of Thorin’s skill. The constant drizzle of name-calling and sneers was enough to make a dwarf want to kill something but Thorin-never the most temperate of dwarrow-had clung onto his temper and bowed his head, storing every insult for the day when he would need to determination to drive him on to his impossible goal of reclaiming Erebor.

 

“I say! You! Dwarf there! What are you doing in the Forge?”

 

Dwalin looked up to see a middle-aged Hobbit in a fancy red brocade waistcoat, a warm dark blue coat and the strange cut-off trousers the Hobbits wore, standing at the hatch and peering challengingly at him. The creature was short, plump and had a reasonable set of mutton-chop sideburns, the nearest to facial hair that Dwalin could recall seeing. 

 

“Tidying up,” the warrior said disinterestedly and glanced around. He could see that the little pail of nails had been tipped over. Who stole nails?

 

“And why are you here? Isn’t that other fellow…Lalkhen or something…supposed to be here?” The Hobbit’s voice was affected and rather entitled but his dark eyes were narrow and mean.

 

“Master Lulkhel is ill,” Dwalin drawled, hanging his cloak from the hook and looking around for fuel for the forge. As he expected, there was none, for Thorin would have burnt all the fuel he had to stay alive. “Some selfish bastard halflings wouldn’t allow him floor room in the inn during the blizzards and he almost froze to death. Fortunately, he has friends who found him before it was too late.” The Hobbit looked offended and planted his fists on his hips.

 

“I hardly see there is any need for such language!” he blustered.

 

“He almost died,” Dwalin growled. “Every need, I think.” He turned and walked towards the Hobbit who retreated a step, even though he was the other side of the counter. “It’s easy to be offended and pompous when you’re sitting in your home with a full larder and a good fire. But you should be offended that a guest in your land was turned away from an inn in the blizzard where he sought shelter. He offered to pay for a chair or a spot on the floor…but he was turned out into the blizzard to freeze. His nearest family was a thousand miles away! I thought you Hobbits were supposed to be good hosts and hospitable. Bunch of mealy-mouthed hypocrites, if you ask me.”

 

“I…do you know who I am?” the Hobbit blurted.

 

“No,” Dwalin said easily. “Now I won’t be doing any commissions yet but I’ll take orders while I tidy up and order more fuel. You got anything you want doing?”

 

The Hobbit gaped like a fish and then turned and stomped away. Dwalin chuckled. He was going to enjoy this.

 

He had tidied the place up and checked which orders were outstanding (none-Thorin had finished everything in an attempt to keep warm) and then had ordered fuel and iron urgently from the Bree merchant. As he watched the Raven flap away, he had bolted and locked the Forge and then headed back up to Bag End, stopping at the market to pick up some biscuits (his weakness) and some honey and treats for the others. Half a pig completed his purchases as he stomped back up the Hill with his goods. 

 

The others had chopped enough wood for half the Hill and were distributing it to the other Hobbit holes without hesitation as the afternoon grew grey. The chimney in Bag End was smoking nicely and warm light spilled through the windows. Kili gaped as he saw the half pig but Dwalin didn’t mind: he fancied some nice pork and crackling and knew that Thorin was partial as well. He imagined the Hobbit was pretty handy with a roast and would be able to do justice. But he didn’t expect to find Bilbo explaining to Thorin precisely how to peel an apple properly to get the peel off in one piece for some childish game. 

 

“Gotcher some food,” the warrior grunted as the dropped the half-pig on the table and was rewarded by Bilbo squeaking in indignation. Thorin jumped and severed his peel and glared at his friend causing Dwalin to burst out laughing. Bilbo sighed.

 

“We’ll try another day and at least we can use the apples for apples sauce for the roast,” the Hobbit said. “You couldn’t find a ready-butchered one, could you?” Dwalin chuckled.

 

“I’m sure Bombur would do it for you,” he offered. 

 

“I can butcher a pig-it just makes a mess and I was rather hoping to get some laundry done today,” Bilbo protested. Dwalin clapped him on the back.

 

“I’ll ask Bombur to sort this, you do your laundry and I’ll have a word with this lunkhead here,” the warrior said. Bilbo glanced up to see Thorin square his shoulders, as if preparing himself for an unpleasant duty.

 

“We can try this another day,” he conceded. “But you are not to harangue him, Dwalin. He’s only just recovering and he needs his rest and no stress…” There was that fiercely protective note to his voice once more. The warrior nodded curtly.

 

“Promise not to break him,” he said and grabbed Thorin’s arm, yelling a request for Bombur in Khuzdul. He hauled the dwarf King all the way to Bilbo’s room and shoved him in, then slammed the door. Thorin backed up a couple of paces and folded his arms across his chest, inspecting his friend. The bed was rumpled and the room smelled stale with sweat and illness, adding weight to Bilbo’s desire to do some laundry. 

 

“Say what you will,” Thorin said reluctantly. Dwalin gave a shrug.

 

“I’ve been to the Forge,” he said. “Someone had broken it. A bucket of nails was knocked over.”

 

Thorin frowned and then his face fell. 

 

“Bilbo’s ring,” he murmured. “I left it under there when I…well, I don’t recall what I was doing. I had run out of fuel by then, I was so feverish I almost couldn’t think and I guess I thought it was safe. I have his bead…I’ve been holding it ever since I arrived back here but the ring…”

 

“I didn’t see it,” Dwalin told him. “Someone stole his ring.” Thorin sighed and turned away.

 

“How can I hope to win him back if I have lost his ring?” he sighed. “It’s hopeless…”

 

“You never said that when our people were scattered, marginalised and hopeless,” Dwalin told him. “You were always sure that you would lead us back to Erebor. No matter the distance, the dragon, the orcs and goblins and the fact no one would support us, you knew it would happen. And you succeeded. Why is winning back the trust and love of the One you love harder than that?”

 

“Because this time, I lost it,” Thorin said. “Now I lose his Ring. Maybe Mahal is telling me that I am a foolish old dwarf who has thrown away his one chance.”

 

“I heard that yer head is now clear, since you’re so far away from the Treasury,” Dwalin said and his friend nodded reluctantly. “So why are you still saying such stupid things? If Dis was here, she’s punch you in the gut.”

 

“Thank Mahal for small mercies,” Thorin muttered but eyed his friend carefully.

 

“Oh, I’m not about to hurt you when you’re still so weak,” Dwalin sneered, watching Thorin merely bow his head in acquiescence. And he hated that his friend accepted the taunt: the Thorin he had known all his life would have responded with an equally barbed comment but this one facing him was much more…defeated. “And yer s’posed to tell me I’m an orc’s backside for even thinking such a thing.”

 

“You are right though,” the King murmured. “I should have told him. I should have trusted him. I should have told the StoneSeers to go to Mandos’ Halls and made sure my One knew what any dwarf would have been told. Perhaps then he would understand…”

 

“You both would,” Dwalin muttered and looked at his friend. “I’ll help you in the Forge when yer up on yer feet again while you work out how to properly court your Hobbit.” Thorin groaned.

 

“I need to tell him,” he murmured and nodded. “Now.”

 

Dwalin watched as he walked to the door and went off in search of his estranged husband…and then he followed, meeting Ori on the way. The Scribe looked up at his husband and frowned.

 

“What have I missed now?” he asked. Dwalin grunted.

 

“Our gracious King, Lulkhel the Broody, has managed to lose his husband’s wedding ring,” he said. “Or more correctly, it was stolen from the Forge.” Ori frowned and then glanced in the direction that Thorin had walked. 

 

“I’m not even going to ask all the obvious questions,” he said and hurried after to find Thorin hanging back as Bilbo harangued Bombur about the mess he had made chopping up the half-pig. In fact, he had only taken off the legs and had trussed it to spit roast over a fire his brother and cousin were building in the garden. Then the Hobbit looked up and saw the King, the expression making his heart flutter with anxiety. 

 

“Thorin?” he asked as the King sighed.

 

“I have a confession to make to you-because I do not wish you to think I am holding any more secrets or withholding vital information from you, Bilbo,” the King said warily. Bilbo glanced over at Bombur, who was finishing trussing the pig and then grabbed Thorin and led him to the parlour. He suspected various dwarves were listening but then, his romance had always been public with the entire Company invested in their relationship. Bilbo took his seat and Thorin sank onto the couch, his back straight and chin lifted, looking like the King he was.

 

“Thorin, you are worrying me,” the Hobbit said as the dwarf closed his eyes for a moment.

 

“I am sorry,” the King said. “I should have told you about the way my people love. I should have explained everything you did not know because you aren’t a dwarf. The StoneSeers, the guardians of the most precious secrets of our race, forbad me to share with you, under threat of not recognising my right to rule. That could have been problematic while we were rebuilding…but less so now I’ve banished the three most didactic and traditional StoneSeers and ensured that Kili and Tauriel have been accepted by them. I should have told them to go to Morgoth when they tried to stop our marriage.”

 

Bilbo stared at him. He had known there had been opposition from the more traditional elements in their people but that they had threatened to try to take the throne from Thorin for loving him… Thorin misinterpreted his silence.

 

“I know I was wrong to keep that from you,” he sighed. “And I know you must be angry…" Then he squared his shoulders once more. “When I came to the Shire, I brought your bead and your ring, because I could not bear to be without them. The bead is always with me and usually the ring…but in my fevered state, I hid it in the forge, under the bucket of nails.” Bilbo frowned. “When Dwalin checked the forge, it was gone. It may just be a petty thief or someone with a more serious agenda. But I do not want you think that I would ever give away or relinquish anything of yours without a fight to the death…” The Hobbit looked at the intensity in Thorin’s eyes and the determination in his voice.

 

“Even when you were delirious, you tried to hide it,” he realised as Thorin hung his head. “You think someone is trying to cause trouble?”

 

“There are those who do not want me to remain here and would do anything to turn against me someone who has shown kindness to me,” the dwarf said. “I am certain of it.” He blinked. “But I will accept whatever you decree…” Bilbo stared at him.

 

“What would I decree?” he asked stubbornly. “You were ill and had every right to believe that something you left concealed in a locked up forge would be safe. This is the Shire, not one of the Man realms! But someone broke in. I will have to report it.” Thorin opened his mouth but the Hobbit was looking especially annoyed. “Dwalin-you come with me. Thorin-you will stay here because I am not having you suffer a relapse just because you want to be a hero.” Then he paused and rested his hand on Thorin’s. “And in case you worried, I am touched that you keep my ring and bead. And I am mad someone stole the ring you kept. It is not your fault.” He smiled and then rose. “Come on, Dwalin. I’ll take you to the Shirriffs. Whoever planned this probably won’t expect it.”

 

Then Thorin watched them leave and groaned. He was still none the wiser what he could do to win back his husband. But at least Bilbo hadn’t told him to leave or yelled at him and for Thorin and his battered heart, that could only be a positive.