Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Chapter 15: The Price The Gods Decree

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

FIFTEEN: The Price The Gods Decree

 

 

Of course it wasn’t all plain sailing because Thorin had been fighting for days, his reserves depleted and he was very weak. But his fever had broken and his mind was clear. Even his sword wound appeared to be healing better than it had. The Princes were delighted and Oin was shocked at the proof of the power of the bond between Ones. Thorin still ate little and slept much of the time, marshalling and regaining his strength. But every day he was a little stronger and his wounds faded slowly. Oin had Dwalin and Balin help Thorin regain his strength and mobility, for with the best will in the world, Bilbo was not strong enough to really support the King as he took his first very shaky steps, though he stayed with his husband as Thorin began his recovery. And as he sat by his husband’s side, he wondered what he could say to try to explain why he had reacted how he had.

 

But he need not have worried. Thorin seemed determined to talk, to make up for all those desolate hours of silence and his words came from the heart. He apologised abjectly, begged forgiveness for his lack of faith, his pride and his jealousy. He also explained that when he was fading, he felt as if he could never hope for reconciliation until he honestly believed it was impossible. And while he savoured every moment with his beloved Hobbit, spending too much time only tormented him with what could not be.

 

Bilbo scolded him soundly for that, apologising for his own slowness in working through his own issues and recognising what his own heart had been trying to tell him. He confessed that he had clung to his anger and hurt and feelings of betrayal for far longer than he should and he guessed that there was still some residual anger at the scene on the ramparts feeding into that. Quietly, he admitted that he had completely forgiven Thorin for his actions, because he had been ill, but he still had occasional nightmares about that moment-and the Battle. Yet he was not afraid of Thorin and trusted him with his life. 

 

For his part, Thorin confessed that he had missed the Hobbit every second since he had left Erebor, feeling as if part of himself was missing. He apologised humbly for not asking enough about Hobbit relationships and made sure to check every detail of the way Heart-Mates related to one another and what he should and should not do. Then, he explained about Rejection and how he had no idea if it could be reversed-but it certainly felt as if he was stronger and less hopeless than he had been. As King, his upbringing had been very regimented, and had included a lot of lore and religion to ensure that he honoured his direct ancestor, Durin the Deathless, and Mahal, who had created their race. Bilbo confessed that he had been made aware that the StoneSeers would not have supported Thorin’s reign if he had broken dwarvish secrecy and explained what a normal dwarf would be told before marriage-which had prompted a wry smile from the King. He admitted that he had no idea what a normal couple would be told, for his own encounter with the StoneSeers had been a short lecture on how he was disgracing his people with his choice of Consort and how when he was rejected, it would be permanent. And he had not covered Rejection in anything he spoke to his husband about because…well, he was hoping that it would never come to that.

 

There had been happier talks as well, reminiscing about the Journey and life back in Erebor and the antics of the Princes. The Company had all spent time with Thorin and he had been touched by their care and attention-even moreso when the Ur family arrived, tipped off by the arrest of Lord Drooz in Ered Luin and the news of the deaths of those Lords exiled from Erebor who had made the attempt on the lives of King Thorin and his Consort. They had not expected to find nearly the entire Company there and there had been a lot of joyous reunions amid the more serious business. Finding that Thorin had been so close to death had been a shock to all and Bifur, Bofur and Bombur had not delayed in offering their wishes for their King’s speedy recovery. 

 

Time passed and as the daffodils withered, the later Spring flowers burst into life and the hedgerows filled with May and Elder flowers. Bluebells carpeted the woods and the entire Shire was green and full of life. Thorin grew stronger slowly while life adopted a new rhythm. Dwalin and the Princes worked the Forge, Dori took it upon himself to make new clothes fit for a King while Balin liaised with the Thain and did a little business in securing contracts with the Shire. Ravens kept coming from Erebor, filling the King and the Princes in with events back in the Mountain and there was an unspoken urgency that began to build in the Company. Everyone knew that they couldn’t remain in the Shire forever, that the Kingdom needed its rulers and the senior officers. Bilbo personally felt that if they never returned, Erebor was in excellent hands with Dis, though he knew as well that she would dispatch kidnappers or assassins if they failed to return-probably some of each, knowing the Princess.

 

It was only when he found Thorin standing in the back garden, slowly circling Orcrist in very basic exercises that Bilbo realised that his husband was progressing faster towards full health. His scars were an angry red but no longer needed dressing and the Hobbit was relieved that Thorin was looking and feeling more like himself. But not wholly, for he was quieter and more introspective than ever. Ever attentive to his husband, he was clearly making a great effort in asking if he did not understand anything and checking how his Hobbit was feeling. Bilbo would have found himself getting annoyed if he had not understood this was Thorin’s way of showing that he was trying to understand those things he had so woefully failed to learn. There were flashes of the King, of the regal facade and the practiced indifference when he was asked things in his capacity as King of Erebor but mostly, he was Thorin, Uncle and husband. 

 

Fortinbras visited on a sunny late Thrimidge day where the cuckoos were singing across the water in the woods and the breeze was warm and laden with the scents of the early roses. Half the Company were out practising weapons or shopping while Thorin-who had finished a strenuous weapons practice session with Dwalin half an hour before and was dozing in the parlour-and Bilbo, who was preparing lunch, were essentially alone in the smial.

 

The Hobbit had welcomed his cousin warmly and had shown him into the parlour while Thorin had woken abruptly and recreated his impassive facade even as he wondered why the ruler of the Shire was visiting. It was clearly not a social call, for Bilbo would have been forewarned and all of Thorin’s instincts were roused. But he watched as Bilbo played host and then ensured that his visitor had tea and snacks before sitting beside Thorin on the couch, offering his husband a wary glance.

 

“I’m sure you’re wondering why you’re here,” Fortinbras had said, his eyes sweeping over the couple. “I have several things I need to impart to you.”

 

Bilbo tensed and wondered if he was going to be exiled from the Shire. At least that would be a record, being thrown out of both lands where he had ever lived. He wondered if maybe he could apply to Lord Elrond to move to Rivendell…

 

“Your Highness, I am pleased to officially make you acquaintance,” the Thain said as Thorin stiffened then inclined his head.

 

“Sir, I travelled under an assumed name and had no expectations of any treatment other than that given to any traveller to the Shire,” he said honestly.

 

“Your family and friends seem happy to thrown your name around,” Fortinbras pointed out. Thorin grimaced.

 

“For that, you have my apologies, Thain Took,” he said gravely. “They were under orders to respect my anonymity, since I travelled here as the ‘fool of fools’ for my treatment of my beloved husband.”

 

“I may have been one of the offenders,” Bilbo admitted. “Kili certainly was. And Fili. We’re proud of you and everything you have achieved. You are only King of Erebor because you went on a crazy Quest no one would support you in, crossed Middle Earth, took back your home from a dragon and defended it against the armies of Orcs that Azog and Bolg brought to slay you and your line.”

 

“And yet, in the Shire I am Lulkhel, the dwarvish smith,” the King noted dryly. Fortinbras frowned and sipped his tea. 

 

“You mentioned you had mistreated your husband…Bilbo?” he asked, steel entering his voice. Bilbo grimaced: the accusation was a serious one in the Shire. To his credit, Thorin shook his head and looked utterly embarrassed. 

 

“I listened to rumours and lies-my own stupidity and jealous possessiveness would not allow me to act like a husband and instead, I confronted him and after he refused to answer my questions, I banished him,” he explained. “He, Bofur and Ori-the young dwarf with all the knitted clothes-had hatched a plan to locate and restore an ancient ancestor to Erebor, to be buried among his kin. They succeeded but accepted my anger and banishment in order to preserve the secret. I was thoroughly shamed and dishonoured when the remains arrived, laying bare the depths of my depravity in failing to trust my husband whose only thoughts were to grant me this gift and honour my Kingdom. After that, I could not stay in Erebor. I had to come to my One.”

 

“One?”

 

“The dwarf equivalent of a Heart-Mate,” Bilbo explained. Thorin nodded.

 

“The perfect mate crafted for us by Mahal-the husband of your creator, Yavanna, who I guess was involved in our unique tale,” he explained slowly, clearly struggling with explaining secrets of his race to an outsider. “Bilbo broke our marriage when he left, removing his marriage bead and ring, rejecting me. I suffered as I deserved from his rejection, isolated and alone. And I endured the gossip and lies that led me to be ostracised and my character assassinated. It was an eloquent way for Mahal to repay me for my crimes. And all the time, I could not work out how to even apologise. Every encounter with Bilbo just angered him.”

 

“I had to close my heart to save myself, Forti,” Bilbo sighed. “It was only when I got close to losing him that I understood what was happening-and it took a lot of introspection and some scolding by the others to get me to re-evaluate what i was doing.”

 

“I had given up and was awaiting my end,” Thorin continued. “Except that some enemies came to kill both me and Bilbo. And the Company arrived just in time to save us…but I was injured. I was just content that Bilbo was safe.”

 

“I wanted him back desperately and accepted him back,” Bilbo admitted. “It’s been a long road getting him back to health.”

 

“Yet in our reckoning, you are no longer married,” the Thain reminded him. “I would recommend getting that regularised in the near future.” Then he looked at the pair. “Unless you are returning to Erebor…” Bilbo looked up and nodded.

 

“I think…the Kingdom will be relieved to have you back,” he said, glancing at the King. “And the Shire will be relieved to have no resident dwarves.”

 

“Young Mistress Mimosa Grainfellow has relocated to Bree after having to renounce her allegations that Lulkhel was engaged to her,” Fortinbras revealed. “And Gardenia Proudfoot has been told that she will be ostracised from the entire Proudfoot clan if she persists with her persecution of Lulkhel. But there is definite disquiet at having so many dwarves suddenly living in Hobbiton…” Bilbo looked outraged.

 

“Surely you can’t be serious and condone…” he began but the Thain sighed and shook his head.

 

“Our people dislike change and are wary of outsiders,” he reminded his cousin. “And while you and your friends are always welcome in the Shire, sometimes, it is better for people to be back where they belong…” Thorin lifted his chin and nodded.

 

“Of course,” he said evenly. “My people would never outstay their welcome…” But Bilbo was almost vibrating with anger.

 

“You know that when they lost the mountain, Thorin’s people were driven across Middle Earth, always ostracised and run out of towns and villages. You could at least try to make it sound like you would prefer we all left!” His voice had risen and Thorin quietly rested his large hand on Bilbo’s.

 

“I understand his meaning,” he reassured his husband. “He is correct: we should return. And if it keeps the peace with his people, I take no offence.” But there was a shadow in his eyes that had Bilbo promising silently that he would need another talk with his husband. The Thain, however, seemed satisfied.

 

“And are you planning to return there?” he checked. Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Balin has been planning it for the last couple of weeks, securing supplies and planning when we can leave. We can’t delay too long if we are to return to Erebor before the snows arrive…” he explained. “It will be good to go back, to be honest. I’m not sure I fit the Shire any more…” Fortinbras shook his head.

 

“Your home is always here-and I will resist all attempts to steal it from you,” he promised. Then he reached for another biscuit. “Now I have some family gossip to fill you in on…”

 

-o0o-

 

Things seemed to move in a blur after that. The weather remained good and Bilbo pottered in his garden, recalling his mother’s devotion and determined not to neglect it, even though his heart was turning back to Erebor once more. Thorin remained a constant, seeming desperate to spend time with his Hobbit and willingly assisting with unskilled jobs in the garden, though Bilbo knew his interest and abilities in the pastime were both limited. The Company trained and prepared with a good heart and better humour, making all meals raucous, hilarious homely affairs that made Bilbo smile for all the appalling manners on display. 

 

Bilbo had started to pack, looking round the smial and deciding to take some things that he wanted to have with him, for he had not returned to Bag End at all since he ran out on the Quest. This time, he was determined to take some books, maps, more proper Hobbit clothes, some good quality wine, a few decent mathoms, a whole barrel of decent Old Toby pipeweed… Yes, when he returned, he would have enough Hobbitish things to keep him going if he never returned to the Shire. He had offered to buy his own additional pack horse but Balin had explained, looking around the sheepish faces of the Company, that everyone had been shopping and that the Company as a whole would be bringing half a dozen pack horses for all the extra luggage they would be returning with. And, of course, Bombur’s family and their cart of belongings would be accompanying the group. 

 

Rumours started, that the dwarves would finally be leaving the Shire and there was a general sense of relief among the Hobbits-at least some of them. In the Green Dragon, old Tolman Youngwhistle, the landlord, was bemoaning his profits when his dwarvish customers left, for the dwarves were good drinkers and always blended in the local drinkers with good cheer and excellent humour. Most of the traders in Bywater Market likewise were sad to see the dwarves going and a group made their way to Bag End to say farewell in person to ‘Master Lulkhel’ and wish him a safe journey. Thorin had been honestly touched by the kindness and had acted as an imperfect but genuine host-assisted by Bilbo-so they left filled with tea, scones and cakes and determined to ensure that the dwarves’ reputations were talked up and they were remembered kindly and generously for all they had contributed.

 

There was sadness as well for Bilbo found himself having to reassure a number of his cousins and neighbours that they would not be forgotten and that he would return one day. His younger Took cousins were especially upset, for they had determinedly kept him company after his return and had grown close to their adventurous and kind cousin. Hamfast and Belle were very saddened as well and Bilbo had baked up a storm for them, showing his affections and gratitude for all they had done in true Hobbitish fashion. Hamfast had promised to look after Bilbo’s garden as if it was his own and especially his prize-winning tomatoes. Thorin had picked up the cues from his husband and had presented Hamfast with a whole new set of gardening tools and Belle with new pots and pans for her kitchen, which the couple had been honestly touched at receiving. 

 

Forelithe was almost spent and the Midsummer celebrations were close when the Company had finished their preparations and were ready to depart. Their goodbye feast had been an especially memorable affair reminiscent of the Unexpected Party over six years earlier, eating out Bilbo’s pantry and drinking deeply of his cellar. Cousins, friends and family were all invited and when the Hobbit had rolled into bed beside his husband, he had been tired, happy and every-so-slightly drunk. He had mumbled a goodnight and curled against Thorin before he dropped asleep.

 

He woke alone, eyes snapping open and hand patting the empty and cold space where the solid warm shape of his husband should be. Guessing that Thorin may just have stepped out for a glass of water, Bilbo waited, wanting to snuggle up to him again, for all it was a warm night, but after a few minutes there was no sign and Bilbo, slightly cross, found himself awake in the bluish moonlight spilling between the curtains. With an exasperated sigh, he sat up and padded to the door, listening for any sounds of movement-but all he heard were the cacophony of snores that marked the presence of the Company. So he pushed the door open and padded silently through his home, his eyes straying to the gaps where things he had packed were missing. The place still seemed homely, even though he was about to leave because it was his home: he just had a better, truer home to go to with his dwarves back in Erebor. But Bag End would always be waiting for him.

 

After a few minutes, he was staring to feel worried, for he couldn’t locate Thorin. He was nowhere in the smial and peering through the window into he garden failed to reveal any hide nor hair of the dwarf King. Finally, he walked to the front door and found it unlatched, so he pulled on his dressing gown and emerged into his front garden, his eyes sweeping over the moonlit space and finding a shape sitting slumped on the bench. Bilbo paused, for Thorin was bowed forward, his hands clasped and hair covering his face. His entire posture looked completely defeated and Bilbo wondered what was wrong. Quietly and very cautiously, he walked down the steps towards his husband.

 

“Thorin?” he asked softly. “Are you alright?”

 

The dwarf didn’t move and Bilbo’s sense of foreboding worsened. He rested a hand on his heart and concentrated but didn’t feel anything coming over his Heart-Bond-not always a reliable indicator but he had analysed their previous interactions and had realised that he had felt various unpleasant sensations when Thorin was unwell. 

 

“Thorin?” he repeated. Finally the dwarf looked up and Bilbo recoiled, shocked at the expression on the King’s face. He had seen Thorin regal, proud, angry, bitter, resigned, jealous, paranoid, hurt, happy, affectionate, determined, shocked, distraught, relaxed, peaceful and triumphant but never ever as utterly defeated as he saw him now. He looked as if he hadn’t slept at all, the shadows under his eyes like deep bruises and his eyes looked as desperate as they had when the couple were sundered and he was experiencing Rejection. Anxiety settled on him. “What’s wrong?”

 

The King took a shuddering breath and Bilbo realised with terrible foreboding that the King had been weeping silently. He scurried forward and knelt before Thorin, taking his hands and staring into the familiar proud face. 

 

“I…can’t…” Thorin murmured thickly. Bilbo sighed, almost feeling impatience but reminded himself that this was Thorin Oakenshield, a dwarf who had lived his life apart from his people because that was expected and who had really never learned to confide in anyone because that was how he had been brought up. He had been trying really hard because Bilbo had insisted, in one of their long and frank talks about what they needed to do in order to move forward and try again in their marriage. Nodding wordlessly, Thorin had promised to try, reminding the Hobbit that if he was slipping, to remind him not only of the talk but of the consequences. The humility and almost desperation had made Bilbo uncomfortable but he had agreed to the terms.

 

“Can’t what, Amrâlimê?” he asked gently, deliberately using the dwarvish term. Thorin had always been very free in his use of dwarvish terms of endearment and secretly Bilbo had loved the attention. He tended to use Shire terms of affection but sometimes, when he used dwarvish terms and gestures, he could see the delight and deep affection in Thorin’s expressive eyes. The dwarf took a shuddering breath and looked up.

 

“I cannot return,” he explained. Bilbo frowned.

 

“Return? You mean to Erebor?” he checked. Thorin nodded, the experienced mask settling on his features in a way that Bilbo hated, for he knew that the King was trying to conceal his true feelings. “But you are the King. You have to return!” Thorin flinched as if he had been struck, turning away slightly and closing his eyes.

 

“Erebor will have a new King, one who is better suited to rule her,” he said evenly.

 

“Fili? He’s only young and has a lot more to learn…”

 

“He has had three years of watching me rule and learning how the Mountain works,” Thorin said. “He will have Dis and Balin to advise him-and the rest of the Company. He has been trained from his youth and he is a fine and decisive leader. He will make a good King.”

 

“But you reclaimed Erebor! That was the point of the Quest…”

 

“And it was a success-thanks in no part to you, Ghivashel,” Thorin told him honestly. “Erebor was reclaimed. My people have their ancestral home once more. The Mountain is rebuilt and repopulated. Life is settled and good for all. I am not needed.”

 

Bilbo felt irritation explode in his throat, trying to remind himself there was something going on that Thorin hadn’t explained. Getting angry wouldn’t persuade Thorin to open up any quicker.

 

“But you are wanted, Thorin,” he said with forced patience. “You are the King. Their hero! So many look up to you, respect you, trust you. Leaving the throne to Fili would weaken Erebor-no slight on him, of course-because he does not command the same respect as Thorin Oakenshield, hero of Azanulbizar, ruler in Ered Luin, King of Erebor, son of Thrain, grandson of Thror. You are the King they want!”

 

“But not the King they need,” Thorin said quietly, his voice deeply shamed. “After you… ‘left’ Erebor, I behaved appallingly. I no longer cared because the Kingdom had cost me the only person I truly cared for. And yes, I know it was my own actions and failings that actually did the damage-Mahal, I know!-but it was the manipulations of my Lords and the gossip of my people against me and my Consort that harmed you and allowed me to react so badly.”

 

Bilbo stared into the familiar face. Thorin was forging ahead with his confession with the expression of one who was walking to his execution. He gave Thorin’s hands a squeeze.

 

“There were rumours and discontent in the Mountain at my performance, that I had gone mad-again-and that I should be removed. Balin and Fili explained that the agents of Sulgan and Prandil were spreading rumours that I was unfit to rule and should be removed from the throne, in favour of Fili. And though I ruled better after I realised what a Lalkhûn I was, I knew I was not giving them my attention and heart-because it belonged to another who was far away.”

 

“Well, I will be back now, Ghivashel,” Bilbo told him. “All will be well.”

 

“No, it won’t,” Thorin sighed and bowed his head. There was a look of utter defeat there.

 

“Thorin?”

 

“If I go back there, I will have to fight it again-every moment of every day,” he said softly. “I will have to resist with all my strength lest I slip and once more lose you by my actions. And I cannot…I cannot risk that.” Bilbo felt his heart shudder in sorrow, starting to understand.

 

“You mean the Dragon Sickness?” he asked. Thorin nodded ashamedly.

 

“My mind is clear here and I am myself once more…but I know when I return, when I reach Esgaroth or at least Dale, the pressure will return, the whispers and the sensations and the desire. Oh, the desire to go to the Treasury and lose myself in that magnificent treasure, to look at the gold and marvel and let the rest of the world fall away, for nothing else matters but the gold. And it will take every ounce of my strength to fight for every second of every day to resist it until the day I die. And if I slip…” He looked up, his eyes filled with a fear that Bilbo had never seen before. “If I slip, I may harm you. I nearly did once, the most shameful and dishonourable action of my life. I still cannot believe that I was forgiven by your for my actions on the ramparts…or that you are willing to consider me your husband once more. But if I go back…I know I will slip one day. And I will lose everything.”

 

“Oh Thorin,” Bilbo said, his heart shuddering with pity. “You should have said.”

 

“How could I?” the King asked softly. “How can I look the coward before you, flinching at the duty to return to my home? I know you have missed your friends in Erebor for so long, that you feel dislocated here and long for the Lonely Mountain. I cannot deny you that. But perhaps, I should stay here and you should go. I can…caretake your Halls and…” His voice trailed off. “And live and die alone where there is a memory of you.”

 

Bilbo’s eyes burned with tears at the words and he launched himself forward, wrapping Thorin in a tight hug. The King wrapped his arms around the Hobbit, his powerful arms holding him close and burying his head in Bilbo’s neck.

 

“You ridiculously over-dramatic dwarf,” Bilbo murmured, his own eyes shimmering with tears. “Why do you have to decide to do things the worst possible way?”

 

“For me, here is no choice,” the King mumbled. “I fell further than I thought was possible. I thought I had conquered it and earned my redemption in the Battle. If I had died on Ravenhill, then my life would have been complete-but I lived and I had to deal with the consequences of my actions, to work at earning redemption for threats of war and broken oaths and attempts to kill my own One. I am a disgrace as a dwarf! And I found that the gold was still talking to me, every minute of every day. And it was easy, when my guard was down, to dwell on the hoard and feel the pull of the treasure, to feel the apathy and madness start to overwhelm me. So I fought a silent battle every moment to remain…me. And I didn’t always succeed but I always had to fight. And I realised that I had won Erebor but my penance, my sentence from the Gods was that it was not for me. I found my people their home but sacrificed my right to live there.”

 

“But you have me there,” Bilbo murmured.

 

“Amrâlimê, my greatest fear is that I will hurt you if I fall,” Thorin said and then he seemed to shrink into himself. “When I fall. I have proven I cannot resist. I have proven I am as weak as my father and grandfather. Please don’t make me go back. Please don’t make me fear every day for what I could do to you.”

 

“Thorin, you’re not dangerous,” Bilbo tried to explain, pulling back and little to look into the King’s face. “In Erebor, you trusted me above all others and only turned on me when I stole the Arkenstone and was stupid enough to return and try to explain my reasoning to a mentally-ill dwarf. You were absolutely not in your right mind and that you can be so afraid of returning tells me that you are thinking absolutely clearly now.”

 

“But I won’t be if I return,” Thorin said in a defeated voice. The Hobbit pulled back and sat next to him on the bench, his hand wound with the King’s. Thorin absently raised his hand and kissed Bilbo’s knuckles. “I cannot ask you to give up your dream of returning, of being with your friends once more. I will stay here and you go home.”

 

Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Thorin-what would the distance do to you after all that Rejection experience?” he asked carefully. “I know you suffered with the distance between us after I left.”

 

“It is unknown,” the King said softly. “No one has ever survived such a long and severe period of Rejection.” He stared at the ground and scuffed it with his boots. 

 

“But…” Bilbo prompted him, feeling him trembling through their grasp.

 

“Oin warned me that I am likely to be more vulnerable to the adverse effects of the Bond,” Thorin admitted with reluctance. “Separation may be more problematic.”

 

“No more trips away without me then,” Bilbo murmured and then looked at his dwarf, seeing the shame in his eyes. “Oh…”

 

“I will not take Erebor from you,” Thorin said quietly. “But I cannot return. You have earned your place with them, Bilbo. There would be no mountain without you. My pride and stupidity, my rashness and weakness would have led us to failure many times over. If anyone deserves their place in the Mountain, it’s you.” 

 

“But it is your home, your Kingdom,” Bilbo said, the sense of foreboding finally tightening around his stomach. 

 

“I reclaimed Erebor…but not, it seems, for me,” the King said with infinite sadness. “My own weakness has earned me the anger of Mahal and my penance is the Price the Gods decree. I will not return to my home and I will spend my remaining days in the Shire.”

 

Bilbo stared at him and almost wanted to shout at him. It was clear that Thorin had been struggling with this for days and weeks, wracked by misery and impossible choices that would harm one of them, no matter which way they chose. And the King had decided that he could not ruin this husband’s dreams of returning to Erebor, no matter how much the cost was for Thorin. And it seemed, the cost Thorin had decided he had to pay was exile and a lonely death.

 

But did he truly understand the depths of Thorin’s despair and sacrifice? Over the years, Thorin had confided that he had dreamed of returning home to the Lonely Mountain for the entire one hundred and seventy years of the occupation by the dragon. Not one day had passed without him feeling the longing to stand once more in the Halls of his people, surrounded by the stone of Erebor. Yet Erebor was tainted for Thorin by the legacy of the dragon, with the madness to which his line was exquisitely susceptible and which had turned the noble and proud King into a monster. Reclaiming his home had transformed from his dream to his worst nightmare and his actions-dishonourable, violent, paranoid-haunted his nightmares ever since. The aftermath still cast a long shadow in his relationships with his friends, his family and the Company…but especially with his husband. Thorin had been fighting a silent, secret battle for three years until he had lost spectacularly and lost the thing he cared for most. Was it any surprise that he did not want to risk another slip? That he did not want to lose his mind once more and risk committing some heinous crime that would end it for him, losing his honour, his love and his life?

 

But what Thorin implied was grave. He could not even approach Erebor for fear of falling once more-and if he refused the journey, Bilbo’s absence would probably end his life, finishing off the Fading that he had endured for far too long. Maybe he could travel to the East but remain beyond the reach of the cursed gold…but where would that be? The ruins of Laketown, itself a testament to the consequences of the Quest and reminder of Thorin’s dishonour in reneging on his word to the displaced people? In Mirkwood with Thranduil who would torment his guest constantly with reminders of his failure and weakness? In a hut in the wilds, staring in the direction of his husband who lived in luxury in Erebor? He could not go to the Iron Hills, for that would raise too many questions and some there would not welcome his presence. And otherwise…everywhere else was too far.

 

So what was Bilbo to do? If he left without Thorin, the dwarf would probably die alone in the Shire. If he travelled and left Thorin along the way, how would the King cope, alone in the wilds, waiting for his husband who was living in peace and luxury in the Mountain.

 

But the other alternative was…not to go. Never to return to Erebor, never to walk through the mountain, browse the amazing markets, stop to chat with the shopkeepers, spend time cooking with Bombur in the kitchens. Never to return to the Library and continue his researches into ancient dwarvish history and see if he could find any mention of his own people in other races’ records. Never to sit chatting with Ori about his latest knitting. Never to practice again with Dwalin. Never to wake again with the boys burrowing into the bed. Never to spend time with Dis discussing family…

 

He looked over at Thorin, who looked sunken in despair. His hand was still trembling and he looked almost broken. The King had made his choice, choosing to give up his life to allow Bilbo to do what his heart most desired and return to Erebor, leaving his husband behind to his fate. He had not even told Bilbo because he wanted his husband to have the choice to do what he wanted, when he had seemed so excited at the prospect of finally travelling again. If Bilbo insisted, Thorin may travel-but he would be condemning his husband to utter misery and fear, fear that he would slip once more, fear that he would fail his people and fear that he would harm his home and his husband.

 

Bilbo couldn't do that.

 

Thorin had given up almost everything for his people and had been willing to sacrifice his life-had almost sacrificed his life-to save the Mountain. He had asked for only one thing: his choice of husband and had faced down every opposing voice to proceed with his marriage. The loss of his husband had clearly hit Thorin hard if the reports Dwalin, Balin, Dis and Fili were correct and his appalling behaviour had spoken of a broken heart. Moving to the Shire had been his only option and he had suffered there, fading and behaving with ridiculous determination not to reconcile if it compromised Bilbo’s freedom. Bilbo’s own stubbornness hadn’t helped and it had only been crises that had brought them together. And now, reconciled and finally looking content with his lot, he was willing to throw it all away to allow his husband his desires.

 

But a marriage was a partnership, a dance of give and take. And Bilbo had seen his friends, spent time with them staying at his home for many happy weeks. And maybe the entire Company was not there but it was very close. And out of Bilbo’s desires, Thorin was at the top of the list and his safety and happiness were Bilbo’s primary concerns. He could not force Thorin to return and live in fear for the rest of his days. For Thorin to admit to fear must mean the agony he was facing at the choice was…intolerable. He had friends in the Shire, he had a comfortable home and plenty to occupy him. And he could still travel, with his husband, to visit new places. Maybe not Erebor but he had options. And crucially, his husband was still at his side. 

 

He stretched up and pressed a kiss on Thorin’s cheek, feeling the bristle of his beard under his lips and catching the salty edge of tears. How bitter and desolate must his husband have felt to weep? Thorin had endured the worst of times and he had faced them with stoicism and courage. He must have truly believed that this was the end and that he would finally and irrevocably lose his husband.

 

But he had finally told Bilbo, trusting his Hobbit with the simple truth and fearing the response.

 

“You silly dwarf,” he said softly. “Did you believe that I would leave you?”

 

“I cost you Erebor when I banished you,” Thorin managed gruffly. “I could not ask you to give her up forever.”

 

“You never needed to ask,” Bilbo said, feeling the disappointment evaporate even as he spoke the words. “I choose you the moment I agreed to marry you. I opened my heart to you. If I lose you, I would not last, I think. Erebor is a place where our friends and family live, but they can visit. Your health and safety and happiness is everything to me, Thorin. I would never ask you to return if you did not want to and I could never leave you. You are exasperating and idiotic if you thought I would ever leave you and make any choice other than you.” He turned Thorin’s face to look at him, staring into the shocked eyes. “I love you. I’m not sure you understand exactly what that means.”

 

Thorin laid his hand on Bilbo’s cheek and leaned in for a soft kiss. 

 

“My Sanâzyung,” he whispered. “I…have no words for your actions. I am not worthy of you…” Bilbo gave a small smile.

 

“Mahal made you for me as Yavanna made me for you,” he reminded the dwarf. “So now we have to decide what we do about this.”

 

Thorin nuzzled his hair.

 

“What do you suggest?” he asked gruffly.

 

“Get dressed,” Bilbo said. It was still dark but the short summer night was coming towards its end and the eastern sky was already warming a faint yellow with the approaching dawn. “I think that neither of us will sleep again tonight. So we can get up, I’ll make some tea and a light First Breakfast and then, before the others stir, we need to head for Tuckborough. I need to speak to my cousin.”

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Lalkhûn -idiot
Lulkhel- idiot of all idiots
Sanâzyung - perfect (true) love
Amrâlimê - my love
Ghivashel - treasure of all treasures