Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Summary:

To do:
1. Party
2. Adventure
3. Face Dragon
4. Save Thorin & Lads
5. Destroy Ring

Or:

Bilbo accepts what he thinks is an offer to reunite with his friends in the afterlife. Apparently, he’s taken on a bit more than that.

Notes:

This type of concept has been executed very brilliantly many, many times before, but I wanted to try my hand at it either way. There will be angst ahead, but hopefully some fluff as well; this first chapter is mostly just cryptic visions and miscommunication. Enjoy!

Chapter 1: By the Sea

Chapter Text

Far away to the East, beneath the Lonely Mountain, King Thorin II, son of Thrain, son of Thror, rests with Orcrist at his side and the Arkenstone upon his breast. Some believe that he has returned to the stone whence he was hewn, melting into the very flesh of Erebor, becoming one with the Mountain that he sacrificed so much to reclaim. His people know that he dwells now in the halls of Mahal, waiting upon the Maker as all their departed have done since death took the very first of their race. For decades, now, he has been at peace, undisturbed by the cares that dogged him in life, and thus he shall remain until the end of time.

...

The gentle sound of waves against the shore resounds through the Grey Havens. The air carries the scent of salt, and strange birds which do not come to the Shire call to one another as they fly overhead. The old Hobbit follows his four companions out of the carriage, matching their expressions of wonder as his eyes devour his surroundings. As he has been all his life, Bilbo Baggins is ravenous, though at his advanced age, he has rather lost his appetite for hearty food and gripping books. His zest for adventure, however, remains as strong as it has been since the morning he abandoned his home to reclaim a stolen mountain with a group of total strangers and not so much as a handkerchief in his pocket.This place is much closer to their home than Erebor, Mordor, Rohan, or Gondor, and yet none of these well-traveled Hobbits have ever before laid eyes upon it.  

Bilbo steadies himself on his cane and pauses, inhaling the salty air. He closes his eyes, awash per usual with over a century’s worth of cluttered memories and no more able to parse them than he was when he left the Shire twenty years ago. Bilbo has outlived every Hobbit he has ever known; the past two decades have battered him about, restoring him at a breakneck pace to a physical and mental state appropriate to a Hobbit of his age. When he carried the ring, of course, things were much different. Bilbo misses the old thing dearly, but there is nothing for it. That useful little trinket has been lost somehow on one of Frodo’s adventures. A pity, but not worth half as much as his nephew’s life. 

Why is Bilbo here, in this strange and beautiful place? He considers asking Frodo, but the poor boy has already set him straight three times since their departure from the Shire. It was odd to see Bag End again, as though Bilbo were staring back into his past. That’s a location where he prefers not to dwell, now that he has seen his nephew to adulthood and finished his book. What Bilbo can remember makes his guts churn almost as much as the knowledge that many of his once-cherished memories have slipped from his mind like a little golden bauble from a pocket with a hidden hole. But Bilbo could live a thousand years, forget everything he’s ever known, and still retain his taste for novelty. 

“Pippin wants to see the waves,” Frodo announces. Bilbo must have drifted out of focus again, because he has no recollection of any comment to this effect from his young cousin. Nor, for that matter, did he notice his nephew’s approach. “Will you come with us, Uncle?” 

Bilbo waves him off. “You lads don’t need me slowing you down. I’ll be seeing the waves soon enough in my own time. You run along with Pippin and keep him out of trouble.” 

Frodo offers a rare smile, but there is a shadow behind it, as though he is only playing the part of the happy-go-lucky young master of Bag End.This act might fool his cousins, and it might even fool his dear Samwise, but it does not fool Bilbo. The shadow has been present since Frodo returned from his journey, waxing and waning with his moods but never retreating far enough away to leave the boy in peace. 

“If you say so.” Frodo rejoins the other young Hobbits, and they rush off at an enviable pace, as though they believe that the waves may notbe waiting for them if they tarry here a moment longer. 

But this way of thinking is typical among young folk. How old is Frodo, again? He must be out of his tweens by now, but compared to Bilbo, he will always be a child. Too young for all that has happened to him as a result of his uncle’s negligence. Far, far too young to be here in the Grey Havens, preparing to accompany Bilbo and the Elves on a journey from which none of them will return. Because that, Bilbo now recalls, is where they are going. He sighs. It is a bittersweet thing to remember, but at least he remembered it on his own. 

Leaving feels right, and so Bilbo shall leave. He would prefer it if Frodo could stay, if he could be happy in the Shire with his maps and his friends, but Bilbo is not naive. Frodo has changed. He cannot enjoy life as he once did, cannot find meaning in cooking or cartography or anything else that Hobbiton has to offer. Whatever the ring did to Bilbo, stowed away in his pocket in the Shire, it did to Frodo tenfold in the far-away land of Mordor, and much more quickly, too. Ah, if only Lord Elrond had agreed to let Bilbo bear the ring on its final journey. Then he could have saved his nephew all of that pain and torment, could have kept him from this fate.

Bilbo should have been permitted to take responsibility for his own errors, to shelter Frodo from the evils of the world. But he would not have made it to Mordor, Bilbo knows. He would not have been so strong as his nephew, would not have been able to carry the ring all that way without putting it on and making himself known to the enemy. He would not have been able to resist after so many long years with the ring, all stretched out and twisted up in its destiny as he had become. Once, such a journey may have been possible, but by the time of Elrond’s Council, Bilbo was far too old to undertake the trip, and in no state of mind to do battle with such a powerful force of evil. It had to be Frodo, but it should have been Bilbo.

There is nothing for it now, of course. There are things that Bilbo has carried long and far, burdens far heavier than the one ring. There is much that Bilbo would have done differently, had he been given the chance. Many changes he would make for Frodo’s sake. And there were others as well, for whom Bilbo would have made any sacrifice required, had he known the outcome of events. They flit around like ghosts at the corners of his mind, familiar but unknown to him as he struggles to remember the names and faces of those he has lost. Bilbo forces himself to focus on the beautiful stone work in front of him instead, contemplating the craftsmanship required to create the sculpture toward which he has directed his blank stare. 

It once was some sort of fountain, Bilbo thinks, but it is ancient now, the carved stone playing host to moss in a shade of green as rich as any emerald. The stonework consists of intricate curled carvings that must have required time and patience create. Considering that it was made by Elves, in all likelihood, the crafter could very well still be alive, and no doubt unchanged by the millennia that have passed since they put down the chisel and stepped away from this now-crumbling work of art. The piece is fascinating, with boughs coming over a bowl in the center, each one hewn with equal care.Bilbo finds himself captivated by its beauty, its longevity, and all the careful work that must have gone into its production.

Someone Bilbo knew once was fond of such things. He had an eye for good craftsmanship, though he never would have admitted to finding it in anything made by an Elf. He’d have complained about this place to no end, Bilbo is certain. He’d have invented issues with the breeze, the salt-smell, and the bird calls, would have taken the opportunity to describe the superior stonework in the Dwarven Halls of Erebor and Khazad-Dûm. And Bilbo would have been very polite and not mentioned that his friend, whose name escapes him now, never set eyes on the halls of Khazad-Dûm. No point rubbing salt in that terrible wound. Despite the way his friend had treated him at first, Bilbo, even in his darkest moments, could never be so very cruel. Instead, he’d have said something funny, to elicit laughter. To coax out that smile from a face so accustomed to frowning. 

What was he called, again? Bilbo finds, to his horror, that he can’t remember. More slips away from him each day. He loses time, he loses focus, and he loses memories. The longer he stares at the sculpture, trying in vain to puzzle out what, exactly, it is meant to depict, the more he struggles to recall where he is and what is going on. Did he come here with Primula? She was always the adventurous sort. Bilbo’s favorite cousin, really, though he would never admit it to poor Drogo. They were married, weren’t they? And they had a son. What was the little lad’s name? 

A hand comes down on Bilbo’s shoulder, soft, gentle, and large. Not broad and calloused, not armored with a gauntlet, not the hand he has been dreaming of. This, instead, is a soft and slender hand, graceful and cool. Instantly, clarity washes over Bilbo in time with the waves that lap the shore in the middle distance. It is as though he has awoken from a very long dream, as though somehow his mind, once spread impossibly thin, has returned to the state that it was in fifty years ago. “What?” Bilbo asks. “Where is Frodo?” 

This has become his chief concern: his charge, his ward, his nephew. Frodo. For years, Bilbo could think about his adventure only in terms of the story it made for him to tell to young Hobbits. None of the nasty bits, none of the terror, none of the fear. For his nephew’s sake, Bilbo could gloss over the moments when his heart nearly stopped, reducing his adventure to prose and verse all woven together between the covers of a red leather book. He busied himself with child-minding, and then with child-rearing, forcing anything else upon which he might dwell out of his mind. When he is startled, nervous, or confused, he finds it is best to focus on Frodo. Though now that Frodo bears the scars of his own adventure, Bilbo finds that even this line of thinking leads him down avenues he’d rather not travel. 

“He has gone ahead to look at the waves with his friends,” Lady Galadriel tells Bilbo. There is no mockery in her gentle smile. It is plain that she does not begrudge Bilbo his age, that she understands, perhaps better than others of her folk, the toll that time can take on those with mortal bodies. “I thought I might speak to you for a moment.”

He has seen her before, of course, once or twice, in passing.But they have never had a real conversation. She has always seemed remote to Bilbo, distant and strange. Not like the elves of Rivendell, who once delighted in hearing Bilbo’s poems, nor the elves of Mirkwood, who seem to take joy in causing as much trouble as possible for everyone that they encounter. The Lady’s hair is long and fair, her eyes as clear and sharp as dyed glass. Bilbo’s gaze is drawn, just for a moment, to the ring on her finger, the dazzling stone set in a silver band. Perhaps because of the burden that Bilbo once carried, he is able to discern that Lady Galadriel stands in a similar position. But even without the ring, this elf would be powerful. Bilbo can feel it coming off of her in waves, especially now that she has granted him such clarity.

“Ah, yes, of course, of course.” Bilbo will not be rude to one so ancient, noble, and wise. If she would like to speak to him, then he will not deny her the chance, baffled though he is by her desire to do so. Anything one might gain from a conversation with Bilbo could be found in his book, though he will admit to embellishing certain events and omitting others in his retelling. “What would you like to speak about, then, my Lady?”

“You would go West with us now, to the Undying Lands.” It is difficult to tell how the Elf feels about this. Galadriel is an ancient creature, powerful beyond Bilbo’s comprehension. She has seen many things in all three ages. The brief life of a Hobbit, even a long-lived Hobbit, must seem only a blink of an eye by her reckoning, no matter how sympathetic she might be to Bilbo’s relative age. But clearly, in all her many years, Galadriel has learned how to conceal her emotions. 

“Yes, I am going, my Lady. Frodo and I are coming with you,” Bilbo explains, smiling up at her.  “One last adventure, and I must say that I’m looking forward to it.” Who would not be excited about seeing the Undying Lands? Bilbo and Frodo will be the first Hobbits ever to do so. That almost compensates for the fact that so many of his closest friends have gone where Bilbo cannot follow. 

Galadriel returns his smile, though it does not reach her eyes. Through the cut glass exterior, he sees the light of stars, full of thoughts and magics which Bilbo cannot fathom. Though Bilbo is wrinkled enough to be her great-grandfather, the Elf’s ancient wisdom is unmistakable when he stares into those eyes. “I thought I might offer you an alternative, though of course, you are welcome to sail on should you so choose. Frodo has done his task and born his burden well. I can sense a peace returning to this land, though I sense also that the age of Elves has at long last come to an end. It is time even for those of us who have lingered to depart from Middle Earth.” 

“Yes, Frodo has done very well,” Bilbo agrees, ignoring the bit about the age of Elves. That  conversation seems like one which will take up time that Bilbo does not have. “I’m quite proud of him. But I don’t know what you mean about… an alternative, My Lady. You’ll have to speak plainly to an old Hobbit like me, I’m afraid.” 

“You have traveled far, Bilbo Baggins,” Galadriel replies. “And you will travel far once more, no matter what you choose.” 

Bilbo is dimly aware that this is not an answer to his request, though he doesn’t know why he’s surprised. Has he not learned his lesson, after so many years of taking counsel from Elves? Not only do they answer both yes and no, but they do so in the most ridiculous and confusing terms imaginable! Bilbo wonders, for a moment, why he has elected to spend his last days amongst such folk. With his mind restored, he finds he longs for loud, boisterous parties, with food and ale and friends who dance on tables, kings who hide their smiles in their mugs and tap their feet to bawdy tunes. 

“Yes,” Bilbo agrees, “I suppose it is quite the journey to the Undying Lands. But I’ll have you know that I’m more than up for it, My Lady.” 

He does hope she doesn’t try to persuade him to return to Rivendell, or, worse, to join young Aragorn in Gondor. Bilbo knows that to sit beside any throne would only make him long for the impossible presence of a different king. Though, perhaps when Galadriel leaves him, Bilbo will forget once more about Thorin Oakenshield. He sincerely hopes so. This remembered pain feels as fresh as it did when he first took the wound, and, ancient coward that he is, Bilbo would rather lose the ability to feel it than carry the hurt any further. Is that not why he has chosen to sail West now, before age takes him? Was that not his primary reason for his first great westward journey, many years ago? 

He could have stayed in Erebor if he had wished, Bilbo reminds himself. It was his decision to return to the Shire, and against the counsel of his friends, too. If he’d wanted, he could’ve styled himself a Lord of the Lonely Mountain and been hailed as a hero for the rest of his days, but that was not the path he took. He has no business longing for things that he turned down of his own volition, does he?

“And is that what you would do, if given the choice?” Galadriel searches Bilbo’s eyes for the answer. She seems to find it, after a moment, because she smiles, nods, and hums as though he’s just said something very clever. Bilbo, for his part, still has no clue what is going on or what the Lady wants from him. She means to offer something, but what it is, he cannot say.

“Forgive me, Lady,” Bilbo replies, throwing caution to the wind. He’s never been the type to walk on eggshells, anyway, and as he nears the end of his life, he finds his patience is running rather thin. “I am old now, and not as sharp as I once was. I do not know what you’re implying, though I should like to, if you’d be so kind as to explain.” There. That’s plenty polite. His father would be very proud, though Bungo Baggins would no doubt be turning in his grave at the sight of Bilbo now, about to step onto a boat, of all things, with Elves, of all people. 

Galadriel’s soft smile widens, sending a ripple as far as her cool blue eyes. It is like staring into the sea and watching the tide rise. Bilbo has no right to draw such a comparison, having never seen the sea before, but he has read enough about it to understand the general concept. Is this what it will be like, sailing West? Will the same enchantment shimmer over the Undying Lands? Bilbo thinks that he should like to see that if he can. He should like for Frodo to see it, too. Yavanna knows it will be better than what the lad has put up with over the course of the past few years. “Perhaps I should show you,” she breathes. 

“Of course,” Bilbo agrees, “Please show me.” Galadriel’s ability to grant vivid visions is not news to him, after all. 

Maybe this will be better. She seems to have trouble articulating whatever it is she wants to say in a manner that an old Hobbit can understand, but it would be difficult even for Bilbo to fumble the interpretation of clear images. 

Galadriel reaches out, cupping his cheek in her long, graceful hand. Her skin is cool and vibrant, youthful in its smoothness and ancient in its surety. Bilbo feels unsettled by this even before the barrage of images begins. 

 

He cannot make sense of them all as they bombard him from every direction. He catches snatches of familiar faces: Bofur, grinning broadly by the light of a fire. Dwalin, hefting an axe in battle, killing an orc in one fell swoop. Gandalf on horseback, riding through the rain. Beorn the bear-man in his verdant garden, tending to a swarm of giant bees. It is too much; the images swirl too quickly for Bilbo to pick out more than a few specific scenes. It feels as though he is experiencing them all at once, and he cannot decide whether seconds or decades are passing around him as he does so. 

And then time slows down again, and he is in a large, ornately decorated stone chamber. There is something familiar about it, and it takes a moment for him to realize that he is in the Throne Room of Erebor. It is not decorated as it was when he last visited. The golden lamps that lined the walls have been replaced with silver ones, and beside the stone throne upon which Dáin might sit is a slightly smaller chair designed in similar fashion. Thick tapestries line the walls, and Bilbo recognizes his own likeness amidst those of his one-time travel companions. He can see the reclamation of Erebor, stitched with painstaking care by a very talented artisan. Against his will, Bilbo is whirled around, faster than he has been able to move in decades, to face a troika of ghosts. 

Thorin looks well. Healthier than Bilbo remembers him, his dark hair neatly brushed and freshly braided, his fur-trimmed coat in pristine condition. He wears a silver crown upon his head, more understated than the Raven Crown that Bilbo knew him to wear in his final days. His air of authority comes from the set of his shoulders, instead, and there is no mistaking that Thorin is a great and mighty king. He is smiling. It would, perhaps, be a bit of a stretch to describe him as carefree, but he is clearly not burdened as he was when Bilbo knew him. He is flanked on either side by his nephews: Fíli, in dark blue, and Kíli, wearing green. All of their beards are longer than Bilbo remembers. They look very pleased to see Bilbo, indeed. He opens his mouth to speak, but no sound comes out.

Once again, he is swept up into a sea of images which crash against him with battering force. He is pulled under the memory of a moment shared with Bifur, watching his friend whittle while they shared a watch in the moonlight. Time spits Bilbo back up again, and he watches as Óin’s careful hands prod at his midsection, conducting an exam, no doubt, after some skirmish or another. When did this happen? More images slam against Bilbo; he tries to close his eyes against them but finds, to his horror, that it is not possible. He is forced to watch but can do nothing to sway the passage of events. This is becoming a bit of a theme for him. 

And then Bilbo is in a different room, one he has never seen before, a bed chamber, dimly lit. He is laying on a bed he cannot feel, with black silken sheets that he is certain would be pleasantly cool to the touch, smooth and comfortable. It is opulent beyond his wildest dreams, the blue curtains on the four-poster bed embroidered with glimmering silver thread, the pillows perfectly fluffed, and a heavy grey fur thrown over the sheets to top it all off. And there is someone in the bed beside Bilbo, a dark-haired someone, laying on his side. The figure’s broad back is crossed with battle scars, some familiar, some that Bilbo has not seen. He stares in awe for a moment at this sight which is beyond even the wildest fantasies that he entertained during his quest.Bilbo cannot help himself from reaching out, extending a shimmering hand, but before he can touch Thorin, the horrible flurry of memories takes him again. 

He watches, upside down, as Fíli walks across the table in the dining room of Bag End. Then, Bilbo is jerked to the side, where he sees three trolls, poised to eat him for dinner. He watches Elrond studying a familiar broken sword. Bilbo is dragged beneath the surface of a pond, it seems, and there he is treated to the full force of a thunder battle, witnessed once and never forgotten. Spiders. Goblins. Wargs. A ball of pure light flying through the air. For a moment, Bilbo is sure that he is back at Ravenhill, that terrible, cursed place. Or else he is in the dungeons of the Woodland realm, but something is wrong, because he spent weeks there, and he is fairly certain that even in his sleep-deprived and hungry stupor, he’d have remembered any time passed inside a cell. 

Bilbo’s world resolves itself again and he stands in a library, jam-packed with ancient tomes and fresh volumes, scrolls and maps and papers to rival even the collection in Rivendell. Ori is there, his face buried in a book, and Balin watches fondly, the way a father might, his arms full of scrolls. Óin is present, too, carrying a heavy stack of medical tomes, with Glóin beside him, elbowing his brother in the side with little care for the fate of the books in his hands. The room is crowded, but Bilbo catches sight of Dori and Nori, Bofur, Bifur, and Bombur, all huddled around a table, engaged in the sort of conversation that any good librarian would frown upon. Even Dwalin isstanding sentinel at the door. It has been a long time since he’s seen all his friends together in one place. Not since he left Erebor after that horrible funeral.

This time, Bilbo is expecting it, and he steels himself against the breaking wave of memory. These images are not fair. He has spent decades trying to forget about Thorin Oakenshield and that smile of his, the way his eyes lit up on the Carrock. Bilbo should not have to be subjected to the sight of his long-dead beloved, grinning amidst a field of flowers, should not have to see him leaning against the kitchen counter in Bag End, a mug of tea in his hand, as he never could have done in life. But it is even worse to see Thorin laying on the ground, his blood staining the teeth of the warg that looms over him. Fire. So much fire. A snarling dragon. A stone precipice. The feathers of an Eagle surrounding Bilbo as he travels through the air on the great bird’s back. Thorin’s arms around him. A rising tide of liquid flame.

Then Bilbo is in a garden, though it is not like any that he’s ever encountered before. This garden is indoors, with walls and a ceiling made of glass, and it is full of plants of all kinds. Some, he knows from the Shire. Some, he has never seen before. Even knowing that he cannot interact with the contents of this vision, Bilbo feels compelled to get his hands dirty tending to this miraculous treasure-trove. And Frodo is there, looking young and free and happy, with dirt under his fingernails and a freshly-harvested beet in his small hands. The shadows are gone from under his eyes, and he carries some healthy weight around his middle. This is not the thin, troubled waif who returned to Bilbo after so long on the road but a gleeful Hobbit in his prime, pleased to be among his plants. Though the dagger strapped to Frodo’s belt and the Elven brooch pinned to his lapel are more than enough to set the lad apart from any respectable Hobbit. Good. Bilbo should not like to think that he raised his nephew to be entirely respectable. 

 

And then Bilbo is back in the Grey Havens with Lady Galadriel. He wheezes for breath, taking slow notice of her trembling fingers centimeters from his flushed face. She draws back, and the beads of sweat that dot her forehead are not lost on Bilbo. In showing him all of this without the aid of her mirror, the Lady has exerted herself. So, too, has the Hobbit. “One moment, please,” says Bilbo, adjusting once more to his creaky limbs and aching muscles. He quite appreciated being outside of his body for a few moments, and he is not particularly pleased to have been returned to it. 

“Of course.” It is difficult to tell whether Galadriel is amused or impatient, but she does not seem angry, at the very least.

Once he has his bearings, Bilbo is prepared to wrestle with the sequence of images that he has just been shown. Most of them moved too quickly for him to make much sense of them; already, he is beginning to forget the contents of his vision. But he will never forget the sight of the throne room and what he saw there. His friends. His dead friends. All three sons of Durin:  Fíli, run through with a sword and thrown from a prodigious height, his life snuffed out as a threat to his uncle. Kíli, taken in battle, the circumstances murky because the only witness was beyond speech when Bilbo found her, sobbing over the prince’s lifeless body. And Thorin, dear Thorin, who died in Bilbo’s arms. Thorin, who would not heed Bilbo’s pleas to hold on, who slipped away from him, who would not stay no matter how Bilbo begged. Thorin, who ruined any thought of future romance for Bilbo, made the idea of courtship with a nice Hobbit lady from a good family seem cheap and flimsy by comparison to what the pair of them had endured side-by-side. 

To see all his friends together again was overwhelming enough for Bilbo. But to see himself so clearly sharing a bed with Thorin, an unfair glimpse at something that could never have come to pass, borders on the painful. Even if Thorin had lived, he would not have wanted Bilbo that way. They were close friends, and there was, at one point, a chance for more. There were glances shared, words heavy with meaning, gestures lost on Bilbo at the time which made more sense to him later on, as he learned more about Dwarven culture. But Bilbo betrayed Thorin, and the king sought revenge, nearly killing Bilbo over the stolen Arkenstone. Things were made complicated, irrevocably damaged by Bilbo’s folly. Oh, there was a time when Bilbo might have dreamed of a position by Thorin’s side, serving as his advisor, or something to that effect. But to think that they could sleep side-by-side in such a marvelous place, where there would be plenty of other beds to spare? That they might choose to share such intimacy when other options were available? The thought would never have crossed Bilbo’s mind, had Galadriel not planted it there. 

And, then, of course, there was the vision of the rest of the company, gathered together in the library. Bilbo knows that Balin died as Lord of Moria. He knows that Oin was killed there as well, though nobody has told him precisely how. Frodo and his fellows did not exactly have time to identify bodies while they traveled through the ruins of Moria, though they did manage to find where Ori had been slain. With a pen and one hand and a book of records in the other, the lad had died the way he lived. Though by then, he was no longer the shy young scholar that Bilbo had befriended on their quest but a master scribe of Erebor and Moria with decades of experience behind him.

When Bilbo last visited the Lonely Mountain, most of his friends were in fine health. Bifur complained of more frequent headaches, but that was only to be expected, what with the damage from the axe. Bombur was not well, suffering from limited mobility in his old age after a long life of many pleasures, exacerbating issues which had plagued him even in his poverty, but Dáin had accommodated him when a team of attendants to carry him from place to place. Although, that was before the War of the Ring, and who knows what kinds of troubles came to Erebor at the hands of the enemy? Is it possible that all of Bilbo’s friends could have been slain? That is the only way that he could imagine them all in the same location as Ori, Balin, and Óin, who are now beyond the reach of the living. 

For all that he never would have dared to dream about Frodo’s healing anywhere but in the Undying Lands, for as implausible as it might seem for Bilbo to be allowed to visit his dead friends, these, at least, seem possible through the intervention of the Valar. Bilbo does not struggle in the slightest to believe that Yavanna and Aulë might be able to restore the dead to life, or, more likely, send Bilbo to his death and place him in an afterlife more to his liking than the one typically reserved for Hobbits. 

“This is… the alternative?” Bilbo asks, tentative. 

“Yes.” Galadriel does not expand upon this sentiment. 

Bilbo considers it. Obviously, if he accepts Galadriel’s offer, he will get to see his departed friends. And Frodo will be there. Perhaps Galadriel has already made him the same offer, and he has already accepted it. Or perhaps if Bilbo accepts, Frodo will follow, eager for another adventure. Because there is only one possible explanation: Bilbo and Frodo are being offered passage to the Dwarven afterlife. That is the only place where he might see Thorin and the others again, unless some other arrangement has been made. Perhaps the Valar have constructed a new afterlife for Bilbo and Thorin and their kin, in payment for the service that they have done for Middle Earth. Without Bilbo and Frodo, the enemy might be in possession of his ring, after all. And without Thorin and his irresponsible gift of mithril armor, Frodo would not have survived his journey to Mount Doom. 

Bilbo does not question Galadriel’s authority to make this offer. After all, if anyone could carry off such a thing, surely it’d be her. Unless, of course, Galadriel is merely a conduit for the will of the Valar. He will not pretend to understand or care how these things work. 

“I would see them all again, then?” Bilbo asks, his voice thin. It is not possible. It is far too good to be true, to think that he could be granted such a privilege. This is a boon beyond anything that Bilbo deserves, surely.

“Yes,” says Galadriel again. “You would.”

“And Frodo.” Bilbo will not get his hopes up just yet. He has not only himself to think of but his nephew as well, and in Frodo’s delicate condition, even the smallest matters have taken on a great importance. “He’ll still get to make his own decision? I’m not choosing for him, am I?”

“No.” Galadriel laughs, and it is a beautiful sound. “Frodo will travel his own path regardless of any choice that you might make.”

But he will choose to join Bilbo. Of course he will. They have always spoken about going on an adventure together, and this is the perfect opportunity. It may be a bit strange, meeting Thorin again after so long, but Bilbo will manage. He had long since given up on his old friend. On all of them, in fact. He would be over the moon, now, to be able to meet with any one of his onetime companions. But to have the entire company, together, once more, in the same place? 

And to think that he might lay in bed beside Thorin, as anything more than friend, companion, and advisor? To think that, once they talk things through and sort things out, once Bilbo makes it clear that he has long since forgiven Thorin, and, presumably, Thorin says his piece about the Arkenstone, they could be together? To think that Thorin would want to be with Bilbo in any capacity, even as ghosts, after everything that has happened? Galadriel, Gandalf, and all the Valar combined could not make it so. But it has been shown to Bilbo alongside the other things, as though it is equally possible. None could change Thorin’s will. If he will see Bilbo, and if he will have him as depicted in the vision, then perhaps their relationship was not so damaged as Bilbo once thought. 

That decides it, then. Thinking of Thorin, waiting for him in the afterlife all this time, and Bilbo, puttering around for decades longer than expected? He’s going to get a talking-to for that, he knows, but it will be more than worth it. He and Thorin could watch Frodo heal together, in this strange place. Or maybe Frodo will not come to them for some time. Maybe he will sail to the Undying Lands as intended, and reunite with Bilbo in many years. Will it matter, when Bilbo no longer needs to worry about the condition of his aging body, no longer needs to linger on the constraints of time?

“I accept,” he tells Galadriel. “Of course I accept.”

“That is wise,” she replies. Well, of course she would think that; it was her idea. Once again, Bilbo questions the wisdom of taking counsel from Elves. But it is too late now. He has already agreed to go through with the Lady’s scheme, for better or for worse. 

Galadriel reaches out again to cup Bilbo’s face, and this time, he accepts the touch without hesitation. He closes his eyes, unsure of what to expect, and the world around him dissolves in a blinding flash of white light.